<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Bobby Schroeder on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Bobby Schroeder on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@ponett?source=rss-1885f92e94c5------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Mon, 16 Nov 2026 22:55:36 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@ponett/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Moving off of Medium]]></title>
            <link>https://ponett.medium.com/moving-off-of-medium-6d7c8e64301a?source=rss-1885f92e94c5------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6d7c8e64301a</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Bobby Schroeder]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 25 Sep 2024 10:16:10 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-09-25T10:16:10.031Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Hello to the small handful of people who follow me here, as well as anyone checking my profile in the future. Thanks for reading my writing on Medium. Moving forward, I won’t be posting here. I don’t currently plan on deleting my existing posts or anything like that, but <strong>they’re now mirrored on my new blog, the “</strong><a href="https://ponett.dog/blog/"><strong>Ponett Gazette</strong></a><strong>,”</strong> where I’ve also gathered other things I’ve written elsewhere. I’ve even made <a href="https://ponett.dog/blog/tags/originally-on-medium/">a tag for my posts that were originally on Medium</a>, so you can easily find them all in one place.</p><p>Why am I leaving Medium, though? Well, I was never particularly attached to this site in the first place. It was a means to an end, and that end was having a place to share my longform writing that was easier on the eyes than my Tumblr blog. Over time, though, Medium has made more and more changes that have annoyed me, universally altering the formatting of posts in ways I can’t control. I’ve also never liked the highlight system, which means anything I write that gets a decent amount of traction becomes permanently slathered in highlights I can’t easily turn off, particularly tiny accidental highlights that people forget to undo. This year Medium has also began mysteriously losing entire paragraphs of my posts! They’ll be there in the editor, and then sometime after I set them live they’ll disappear. This happened to one of my favorite paragraphs on my Hazbin Hotel review earlier this year, actually! I don’t like having to babysit my posts to keep them from getting fucked up like this.</p><p>Also this site is just full of tech bro hacks writing about crypto and AI and whatnot, and wannabe self-help gurus, and all sorts of other nonsense. It sucks here lol</p><p>And so I’ve finally just made my own damn blog, set up using the free software <a href="https://getpublii.com/">Publii</a> and hosted as part of the Neocities site I already had. I’ve also used it as an opportunity to gather some of my other writing from sites like Tumblr and Cohost, to save it all in one neatly organized place. (Cohost’s imminent demise and my need to archive some things I wrote there was, in fact, the main thing that finally pushed me to get this set up. RIP Cohost, you were too good for this world.) Moving forward, this new blog will be the central home for my more formal writing. And I’ve already got two new pieces going up in the near future! One’s about a bunch of comics I’ve been enjoying recently, and the other will be a ranking of my top 10 favorite games in the recently released UFO 50.</p><p>So, yes, if you’ve liked my writing here over the years, please consider reading it at its new home, the <a href="https://ponett.dog/blog/">Ponett Gazette</a>, at its very good URL <strong>ponett.dog/blog</strong>. Bookmark it! Save the RSS feed! Leave a comment! It has comments!</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=6d7c8e64301a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[My own personal Hell: Thoughts on Hazbin Hotel]]></title>
            <link>https://ponett.medium.com/my-own-personal-hell-thoughts-on-hazbin-hotel-1b226af317f5?source=rss-1885f92e94c5------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/1b226af317f5</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[hazbin-hotel]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[criticism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[animation]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Bobby Schroeder]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 08 Feb 2024 23:04:33 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-11-26T20:14:31.223Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*pGIhI4r8LYSPrM1i6N4qsw.jpeg" /></figure><p>(<strong>EDIT 9/25/2024: </strong>This piece is <a href="https://ponett.dog/blog/my-own-personal-hell-thoughts-on-hazbin-hotel">now mirrored on my new personal blog</a>! I’m no longer using Medium, and can’t guarantee that this site won’t mess with my formatting or randomly lose chunks of the article, as it’s done in the past.)</p><p>(<strong>EDIT 11/26/2025: </strong><a href="https://ponett.dog/blog/hazbin-hotel-season-2-and-helluva-boss-review">My followup review on season 2 (and <em>Helluva Boss</em>) is now available on my personal blog.</a>)</p><p>I never expected to watch <em>Hazbin Hotel, </em>the raunchy musical dramedy about demons created by Vivienne “VivziePop” Medrano. (No, not that one. The one with the wolf girl is <em>Helluva Boss. </em>This is the other one.) I just don’t vibe with the characters, the aesthetics, the sense of humor, any of it. I knew it wouldn’t be for me, and planned on staying far away from both the show and the drama constantly swirling around it like a hurricane. I know many of the people reading this feel the same way.</p><p>But then, the unthinkable happened: my boyfriend made me watch it with him. Anthony argued that we should at least give it a shot. It’s the big “indie animation” success story — the mega-popular pilot from YouTube that got picked up for a full series by beloved arthouse film distributor A24 and Amazon. Maybe it’d turn out better than we expected, or we’d be able to figure out what others see in it. And if we ended up hating it, we’d at least be able to give concrete reasons <em>why</em>, rather than just judging a book by its cover.</p><p>Having now watched the entire eight-episode first season (plus the pilot), I can safely say that, no, I didn’t like the show. But I’m a little bewildered by the specific ways in which it’s a mess.</p><p>The general vibe was about as grating as I expected, though the star-studded Broadway voice cast, expressive animation, and catchy songs do their damnedest to try and make it endearing. Very real effort was put into the presentation. More than anything, though, I was just blown away by the sloppy writing. And no, I don’t just mean the constant forced swearing and dick jokes. I’m talking big picture stuff. It really, truly feels like a first draft written with no oversight. Writing that’s always telling instead of showing. Constant diversions to introduce insufferable new characters and subplots, even though the main cast is so woefully underdeveloped. Big emotional crescendos that never feel earned. A central conflict that makes no goddamn sense if you stop and think about it even briefly.</p><p>I could go on and on. And I will!!</p><p>I didn’t think I was going to write this review, but there’s a dearth of genuine, thoughtful criticism of <em>Hazbin Hotel</em>. It’s feels like it’s either “Wow, those DeviantArt kids really went and made a whole cartoon! Bless their hearts,” or people combing through frame by frame looking for ammo for fandom bickering. I’m not here for any of that. I’m not here to write a callout post, or to get into behind-the-scenes drama. I just want to judge the final product on its own merits as a television show, offering praise where I feel it’s due while also explaining why it was one of the most frustrating things I’ve watched in a long time.</p><p><em>(This article will contain full spoilers for </em>Hazbin Hotel<em>, and will discuss heavy topics that come up in the show such as sexual abuse, abusive relationships, addiction, self-harm, queerphobia, genocide, racism, slavery, cannibalism, and honestly probably some other stuff I’m forgetting. It’s a long list. It’s a show about hell.)</em></p><p><em>(</em><strong><em>Edit September 2024: </em></strong><em>Adding a note here for context months later just to say that I did, in fact, end up catching up on sister series </em>Helluva Boss <em>later, and… I kinda enjoyed it? It shares some of </em>Hazbin’s <em>flaws, but it’s got better writing and pacing and characters and designs and is overall just way more solid as a TV show. It’s fine. Don’t expect a full review of that anytime soon, but believe me, I did give both of these shows a fair shot!)</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/1*gVJ6pZo0dJmMNH7MnazG1Q.jpeg" /></figure><h3>The pilot and the premise</h3><p>I didn’t actually watch the pilot at first. I figured I didn’t need to. It’s over four years old at this point, featuring an entirely different voice cast from the full series, and it isn’t even on Prime Video. If it was required viewing, it’d be on Amazon with the rest of the show, right? I mean, how many shows can you even think of that have required you to go seek out a separate pilot episode before watching the first season?</p><p>Well, turns out I was wrong. The pilot is very much still canon, and while the first Amazon episode makes <em>some </em>efforts to get new viewers up to speed, it’s pretty clear that the show expects you to have already seen the pilot, which sets up the character relationships and the founding of the titular hotel. This should be the first sign of one of my big problems with the show: it feels like it was written almost exclusively for people who are already obsessive fans of the characters and world, with very little effort to craft a coherent story that will draw in nonbelievers.</p><p>But I digress.</p><p>The pilot gives us our main characters and the basic premise. The series is set in a cartoonish version of Hell very loosely based on Christian mythology, which is less a place of eternal punishment and more a city of nonstop sin. Once a year, Hell is attacked by angels in order to curb “overpopulation” among the sinful human souls, with Exorcists randomly slaughtering them in the streets. This is obviously a bad thing. (Of course, citizens of Hell are already slaughtering each other all the time, but I think they, like… respawn, or something? And only angel weapons make them stay dead? I don’t know, the show doesn’t really explain this all that clearly.)</p><p>In steps Charlotte “Charlie” Morningstar, the plucky Princess of Hell and daughter of the realm’s absent ruler, Lucifer. Charlie has come up with an idea for how to deal with this annual genocide: <em>redemption!</em> Hell won’t be so full of sinners if Charlie can implement a system to teach some of them the error of their ways and send them off to Heaven. And she decides the perfect place to do this would be a hotel, the “Happy Hotel,” because a hotel is a place where you only stay temporarily before moving on. And so the pilot revolves around Charlie attempting to garner support for this hotel plan against the backdrop of the typical chaos of Hell. Eventually she does manage to find a benefactor, but only by making a deal with one of the most dangerous demons in Hell: Alastor the Radio Demon. He doesn’t actually believe in redemption, but he thinks the hotel thing sounds funny, deciding to rename it the “Hazbin Hotel.” And so the stage is set.</p><p>Now, if you’re like me and Anthony, this premise probably raises a million questions. We’ll get to those. Let’s just roll with it for now.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/1*tn7fZnW4aZVkXrAK4ZGbNg.png" /></figure><p>Believe it or not, for as much as I dislike the Amazon show, I can kind of see the appeal of the pilot. There’s something charming about it. It’s an artist’s sketchbook full of self-indulgent character designs come to life. The rough edges of the lively animation only add to this charm. The way some moments will be a little jankier, while others will put a little too much effort into lavishly animating the most inconsequential bits. It’s very visibly made by human beings who don’t entirely know what they’re doing, but they’re certainly giving it their all.</p><p>There are still some big problems with the writing, and I don’t <em>love</em> it, but I can see how it could have been refined into something solid. The genocide stuff and its ideas about what “redemption” means are, uh… well, we’ll get to that, but the contrast between our idealistic Disney Princess hero and the raunchy madness of Hell is an easy source of comedy. And the hotel angle, while kind of contrived, does make for a good setting. You can have all sorts of wacky one-off characters show up and stay in the hotel for an episode. I mean, look. Vivzie was only, what, 19 or 20 when she came up with a lot of these characters for her old webcomic, <em>Zoophobia</em>?<em> </em>She was far from a seasoned professional. But I can so easily envision a timeline where A24 got an experienced showrunner in as a supervisor to shepherd the project along, showing Vivzie the ropes and helping her bring out the potential of these ideas.</p><p>That isn’t the version of the show we got, though. Instead, all of the worst tendencies from the pilot were doubled down on while much of its potential went out the window. And it’s harder to give it the benefit of the doubt when it’s gone from being an indie passion project to being a major tentpole animation release for Amazon, with a star-studded red carpet premiere and billboards all over Times Square.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/1*XouCF1wzBibuUxY8RjQgww.jpeg" /></figure><h3>Yes there is in fact a lot of swearing in this</h3><p>I’ll get this out of the way briefly because it’s one of the main things people make fun of, although it’s far from one of the biggest issues I have. But yes, the characters swear a lot. Like, constantly.</p><p>It’s not the presence or quantity of swears that I find grating here. I swear all the time. I swear all over <em>this article</em>. I watch HBO shows where people say “fuck” every other sentence and it doesn’t faze me. But in those shows, it feels more natural. Like, that’s just the way those people talk. In <em>Hazbin Hotel, </em>it feels like the writers are a little too proud of the swearing. They’re too eager. They emphasize it too much. It’s juvenile. Too much of the time it feels like a character swearing is supposed to be a punchline in and of itself. Occasionally this works, like one instance where Charlie loses her composure and screams “shut the fuck up” at someone heckling her, but most of the time it just reminds me of dorky Tumblr and Twitter users who have to say shit like “Okay listen up chucklefucks, everyone buckle the FUCK up for this motherfucking thread!” Like, please, dial it back a notch.</p><p>You do get used to the constant swearing, though. It just becomes white noise. What I’m more interested in talking about is the other big thing people tend to mock: the way the show looks.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/1*ZOyghIRkZvbajN3L4uqaoQ.png" /></figure><h3>The character designs</h3><p>Watching the first episode of <em>Hazbin </em>was surreal for me. It feels like a show that shouldn’t exist. I don’t mean that there’s something <em>wrong </em>with it existing, that I don’t think it <em>deserves </em>to exist. But rather, the fact that it actually got made breaks some fundamental rule of how I thought the world worked. It feels like one of those things that would’ve been pitched via concept art on Tumblr back in the day, and people would’ve been like “OMG!! Everyone reblog this, we NEED to turn this into a real show!!!” And that would’ve been the end of it. Except they actually went and made the damn show. It evoked the feeling of, like, if the infamous <em>Miss Officer and Mr. Truffles </em>pitch had been picked up as a full TV series by Netflix, and I was sitting down and watching it.</p><p>A lot of this vibe comes down to the character designs, which strongly evoke visual traits that were popular on Tumblr and DeviantArt a decade ago that have always been like nails on a chalkboard to me. The big one is that almost every single male character seems to have been designed in a lab to be a “Tumblr Sexyman.” (The women, on the other hand, all look like Monster High dolls.) If you did a drinking game where you took a shot every time a new character was introduced who’s extremely thin with a top hat, bow tie, a big evil grin with sharp teeth, and Roaring Twenties overtones, you would die of alcohol poisoning halfway through the season. It’s Once-lers all the way down.</p><p>But, okay, that’s subjective. Maybe you want to jump the Once-ler’s bones. You’re allowed. Beyond the fact that they don’t jive with my personal tastes, I do think that the character designs genuinely hamper the show.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/700/1*HpCAzD0NbZba-DPAW8ksMQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>For one, many designs are overly detailed, which I can only imagine is a nightmare for the animators responsible for making them move frame by frame. And I generally do think those animators are doing good work with the hand they’ve been dealt. Everything is <em>drawn</em> very well. The characters are made of appealing shapes. Their faces are very expressive. They move in fun ways, squashing and stretching and snapping into dynamic poses. There’s clearly a solid grasp of the fundamentals here, and I can see why people like the animation. It’s just buried under so much nonsense.</p><p>Tons of characters have to be covered in random little spots and hearts and stripes. Things like this are common among younger artists within certain art communities online. With the furrier characters on the show, “sparkledogs” come to mind. And I get where the impulse to design characters like this comes from. You want your OCs to be unique, so you give them all sorts of identifying details, or come up with arbitrary little surface level quirks for your art style. When designing a ref sheet, maybe you fear blank space looking “boring” on a design. There’s perfectly good real estate on the back of that character’s head that could be used to add more little hearts and polka dots and whatnot! There’s no shame in any of this. We’ve all been there, and it can be just plain fun to draw. Sparkledogs are fun! They’re a totally harmless form of self-expression. But, again, when you’ve got an army of overworked animators who have to worry about making sure Husk has all the multicolored dots on his wings in every frame, it might be time to show some restraint.</p><p>As is often the case with younger artists who indulge in these sort of things, I feel like the excessive surface details are compensating for a lack of variety in other regards. Most notably, there’s a glaring lack of body diversity on the show, with almost every character being thin and lanky with a snatched waist. (In episode 5 I was so shocked when a short, fat woman burst into the scene and proved that this show was capable of depicting a character who isn’t skinny that it was practically a jumpscare.) Characters don’t tend to look their age, either — everyone just looks like they’re in their 20s. For another example, all but one of the main characters share similar red/white/black color schemes with minor yellow details, which tends to make group shots visually cluttered as hell. It can be hard to tell where one character ends and another begins when they’re close together, especially when the backgrounds are frequently dominated by the same colors. Take this group hug from the finale, for instance:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/1*K1BNDZkoLawOEonmNGrEXQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>At some point, though, sooner or later, the character designs will make you ask a question: “Why do people even look like this in Hell?”</p><p>The inhabitants of Hell are broadly categorized into two groups. There are, of course, natural Hellborn demons, who are exempt from the exterminations. Charlie, for example. But most of the characters are “sinner demons” — the reborn souls of humans who died and went to Hell for their sins. There’s no way to differentiate the two at a glance, because every character design is just kind of whatever Vivzie wanted them to look like. As far as I can remember, there’s no explanation given for why people turn into furries and monster people and Once-lers and object heads and all sorts of other things when they die and go to the Christian Hell in this universe. Some of them gain overt themes, like Alastor being “The Radio Demon,” but others don’t. They also gain random magic powers, with some of them being insanely powerful! As far as I can remember, there’s never any explanation for any of this. An offhand line about how peoples’ souls “take on their true forms” in the afterlife would have gone so far.</p><p>And yes, I’m sure Vivzie’s explained this somewhere, either on social media or in <em>Helluva Boss, </em>but I shouldn’t need external explanations for the basic logic of a show’s world to make sense. Again, it feels like this show makes very little effort to ingratiate itself to people who aren’t already obsessive fans of the characters and world.</p><p>And, okay, maybe you don’t think it’s that important to be able to tell Hellborn demons and “sinner demons” apart. Fine. But then you look at the Exorcist angels, who <em>also </em>just look like Hot Topic demons!!</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*flbDfmpQbbq8pQcSzfdBBw.png" /></figure><p>Now, I love fantasy and sci-fi series where it feels like anything goes, where character designs can just kinda be whatever the artists want because they can justify just about anything. In the realm of kids’ cartoons, <em>OK K.O.: Let’s Be Heroes </em>comes to mind, which depicts a world of heroes and villains where every single character was intentionally designed like they’re some kid’s OC based on their favorite Saturday morning cartoons, anime, and video games. That’s fun! But it works there because the broad cartoon logic of the world supports that ethos. In <em>Hazbin</em>, they don’t even really fit the theme of the Christian Heaven and Hell. If this was just a vague “underworld,” that would be one thing, but the very first scene in the Amazon show is about Adam and Lilith in the damn Garden of Eden! I never thought I’d find myself complaining about how a show didn’t have a good enough excuse to write in a giantess scene girl feathered dinosaur woman, but here we are.</p><p>The designs don’t even serve their individual characters because of their lack of variety and overabundance of details. A design is supposed to tell you a lot about the character at a glance, but the vast majority of characters here just recycle Vivzie’s favorite visual details over and over again — bow ties, top hats, sharp teeth, big evil smiles, mismatched eyes, pinstriped suits — to the point that it becomes impossible for any of these things to be seen as meaningful character choices. The main cast members all allegedly have animal themes that are supposed to have some sort of relevance to their personalities, but some of them are so diluted or so crammed full of other details that it’s impossible to tell what any of it means.</p><p>When Lucifer finally shows up halfway through the show, it lands with a complete thud. There’s nothing to make him stand out visually as the ruler of Hell and <em>the literal fucking Christian Devil, </em>because he just looks like every other Once-ler-ass side character on this goddamn show. He doesn’t even look or sound old enough to be Charlie’s dad!!!</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/1*QZeWesAnaooezWj4SFhRqg.jpeg" /></figure><p>But, okay. I’ve broadly talked about how the designs for long enough. Let’s properly introduce all of the main characters, each of whom will be a window into a different problem with the show.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/700/1*ynnljIRMbhjvDHExn-o0DQ.jpeg" /></figure><h3>Charlie</h3><p>Like I said, Charlie is very much a Disney Princess. Played by Broadway star Erika Henningsen (perhaps known as the original lead in the <em>Mean Girls</em> musical), Charlie is an upbeat, idealistic young woman with absent parents who sings about wanting to follow her dreams. She even has an animal companion in the form of KeeKee, a cute little cyclops cat thing that turns into a giant hotel key, though confusingly I’m not sure it ever actually does anything in the story, and its presence is rarely even acknowledged in the dialogue.</p><p>I’d also compare Charlie to the archetypical modern kids’ cartoon protagonist. She’s an optimistic and compassionate hero who wants to see the best in everyone, to give people the chance to redeem themselves, and for everyone to get along, and she’ll happily break out into songs about these things. Think Steven Universe, Star Butterfly, or Kipo Oak. <em>Hazbin Hotel </em>very comfortably slots in with those sorts of shows in terms of its general storytelling aspirations, regardless of how adult its content may be.</p><p>Charlie has one of the most straightforward designs on the main cast, and I generally find her cute, though learning that she’s apparently supposed to evoke a satyr is a little bewildering. She has an animal nose and fangs, and from the side you can tell that she has a bit of a snout, but that’s it for visible nonhuman features. She supposedly has satyr legs with hooves, according to Vivzie, but this is just demonstrably not true.</p><p>Charlie’s fine. I don’t really have a problem with Charlie as a character, more the story around her. One nitpick I’ll point to right now is that the show — and, in particular, the musical numbers — do way less with the tonal dissonance between its protagonist and its world than you’d think.</p><p>Like, knowing the basics of the show, you’d expect the songs to be funny, right? You’d expect them to go for kind of an <em>Avenue Q </em>type thing, where they’re parodying kids’ media by doing upbeat music numbers about really adult subjects. Charlie seems tailor made to be a character who tries to sing her Disney musical songs, but then all the other characters and the world around her make it more adult, and maybe she either bristles against this or she’s just blissfully unaware of it. The trailer for the season implies this sort of tone to me — it’s built all around the mismatch between the upbeat Broadway songs and all the gore and perversion in Hell.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*uCPAivQw3CcGrUGvjqojqg.png" /></figure><p>Charlie does, in fact, get a couple comedic musical numbers like this. There’s “Happy Day in Hell” towards the start of the first episode, a throwback to the opening number from <em>Beauty and the Beast — </em>except, you know, set in Hell instead of a small provincial town. So Charlie is running around singing about her dreams and how much she loves where she lives, but the dark world around her completely clashes with her optimism. (The song does, in fact, contain the phrase “demon bukkake shows.”) There’s also “Ready For This” in episode 7, where Charlie sings an inspirational song to try and get a bunch of cannibals to help her fight the angels, and the cannibals just keep interjecting to sing about, well, murder and wanting to eat the angels, and she just has to roll with it because at least they’re getting motivated by <em>something</em>.</p><p>But the vast majority of the rest of the songs are much more standard musical fare. Big emotional numbers, villain songs, clashes between two characters performed as duets. They aren’t really funny at all, nor are they particularly trying to be, although I guess the writers might think that the characters swearing in some of these songs is inherently funny. I’m not saying I love those two comedy songs — again, “demon bukkake shows” — but they at least feel like they’re doing something with the premise. With the rest, it’s easy to forget I’m not just watching a kids’ show. The whole point of Charlie being such an out of place character in Hell gets muddled when damn near <em>every</em> character is playing their Disney-style musical numbers completely straight.</p><p>Instead of leaning into this comedic dissonance, Charlie mostly just spends her time fretting about how the hotel plan isn’t really working out, due to the threat posed by the season’s overarching antagonist.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/854/1*sblzZTgHvra95PPqoiujMw.jpeg" /></figure><h3>Adam</h3><p>Yes, Adam! The first man! From the Bible! Played by Alex Brightman, star of the <em>School of Rock</em> and <em>Beetlejuice</em> musicals, Adam serves as the leader of the Exorcists and our main liaison with Heaven. Between the news that a demon had managed to kill an Exorcist for the first time ever in the latest extermination and Charlie’s proposal to start redeeming sinners, Adam decides to move up the date of the next extermination. This gives Charlie a hard six month deadline to try and prove her sinner redemption plan can work.</p><p>As the time limit implies, the first eight-episode season takes place over the span of six months. Characters will act like they’ve been through so much together and they’ve done a ton of off-screen bonding and really grown as people, but watching the show it’ll feel like it’s just been two weeks, because very little actually happens. Part of this is definitely a sign that the writers struggled with the short season and wished they’d gotten more episodes to work with, though I’m hesitant to claim that giving the team more episodes to space out those major developments would have solved many of the show’s storytelling problems. A lot of the ideas here are just not very good.</p><p>Take Adam, for example. For some reason, Adam’s whole thing is that he’s a horrible dudebro misogynist who’s constantly talking about sex.</p><figure><img alt="Adam smugly pointing to his crotch while saying “I’m fuckin’ Adam. I’m the original dick!”" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*-REOhSfcemrb5HHJXDdmCQ.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="Charlie looking on in boredom as Adam says “All dicks descend from me.”" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*VTpMQ6xCTtI6abl3IFsPOQ.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="Charlie growing more frustrated as Adam says “I’m the dick-fuckin’ master!”" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*yU1fUS_mG7AwCVvghrOhrQ.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="Adam eating ribs while saying “So Anyway, then we fucked, and it was awesome.”" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*jBUCNztn8ulFac8IOoAeWw.png" /></figure><p>Charlie’s face really captures how the dialogue in this show makes me feel.</p><p>The whole time, I was just asking myself “Why is Adam, the main angel in a show about angels and sinners, like this?” The fandom’s favorite little excuse that the characters <em>have</em> to talk like this because they’re sinners in Hell falls apart when even our lead angel acts exactly the same. Between this and his design that’s honestly just a <em>Helluva Boss</em> imp with a robe and a halo, I wondered if there was going to be some twist about Adam actually being a sinner demon under his mask. (Yes, that’s a mask.) But no, in the finale we see that he looks like a regular human under there, which I suppose is fitting for the first man, and his status as an angel is never questioned.</p><p>This leaves us with a story about privilege and double standards, where the sinners in Hell are deemed worthy of death for their misdeeds, while Adam can do whatever he wants and get away with it because he’s already in Heaven. And I <em>guess </em>there’s kinda something there, but man, the way this show talks about (and doesn’t talk about) conservative Christian morals and puritanism and the idea of redemption is such a fucking mess. We’ll get to that.</p><p>In the meantime, let’s talk about Charlie’s girlfriend.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/1*PMI6CN7gN8aUdhYXR2N5IA.png" /></figure><h3>Vaggie</h3><p>Yes. Charlie’s girlfriend, the only lesbian on the main cast, is named Vaggie.</p><p>One of the fun things about coming to this show blind is learning about years of inane fandom drama that I missed. Vaggie’s name was naturally the subject of many such arguments. Obviously, the name is very stupid, but the defense was always that it was supposedly short for “Vagatha.” Of <em>course </em>her name isn’t “Vagina!” It’s pronounced with a hard G! Get real!</p><p>And then the season comes out and episode 6 reveals that it is, in fact, short for Vagina. Adam named her after his favorite thing.</p><p>It’s supposed to be a shocking, emotional moment when this is revealed.</p><p>In practice, though, my main issue with Vaggie’s name isn’t even what it’s short for. It’s that Charlie’s voice actress doesn’t always pronounce her V’s the most clearly, so half the time it sounds like she’s calling her girlfriend “faggy.” Which had Anthony and me in stitches multiple times throughout the show.</p><p>Honestly, her stupid name is probably more fun to talk about than the actual character, who I feel is the most bland member of the main cast. In the pilot, Vaggie kind of came off as a stereotypical Angry Lesbian, a pessimistic and frequently offended little ball of rage to balance out Charlie’s boundless optimism. I have to wonder if Vivzie received some criticism about this, because Vaggie’s anger feels toned down in the final show, leaving her the empty shell of a character. She’s still the more pessimistic, snarky, bossy one as a foil to Charlie, but she doesn’t have much of a life of her own. For much of the season, she seems to only exist to support Charlie and her dreams. She’s Charlie’s bodyguard, I guess, but it’s not like there’s any serious fighting in this show prior to the finale.</p><p>It doesn’t help that she has what feels to me like the most underwhelming and monotone vocal performance of an otherwise strong cast, provided by Stephanie Beatriz of <em>Encanto</em> and <em>Brooklyn Nine-Nine </em>fame. In an early episode she briefly puts on a drill sergeant act, and it’s so forced and half-hearted that I questioned if we were genuinely supposed to believe that Vaggie has some sort of military background.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/1*rKyhObZXjWzuECEEme28oA.png" /></figure><p>As we learn in episode 6, though, it turns out she<em> does</em> have a military background. In a shocking twist, it’s revealed that Vaggie was formerly an Exorcist, one of Heaven’s soldiers sent to exterminate sinners in Hell. This was visually foreshadowed by the fact that Vaggie has an X over one eye, similar to the emotive masks that the Exorcists wear. I didn’t particularly take this as foreshadowing because I couldn’t tell how much the X eye thing was a specific lore thing and how much it was just another one of Vivzie’s little pet design quirks from when she was a teenager, like how other characters will randomly have little hearts all over them without it necessarily meaning anything. It would’ve perhaps been more obvious that Vaggie’s moth wing motif is actually an angel wing motif if we had seen any of the angels who look anything like Vaggie prior to the episode with the reveal. Again, the character designs are so all over the place and so prone to including random details for the hell of it that it’s difficult for the show to use character design as a storytelling tool.</p><p>While the show briefly tries to use Vaggie hiding the secret of her past as a demon-killer as a source of drama, Charlie ends up learning the truth within the same episode, and then everything is easily resolved in the one after that. It’s a little confusing that whether or not Charlie will forgive Vaggie is even treated as a question, since Charlie’s whole life revolves around wanting to give second chances to murderous demons and send them to Heaven. It’s not like Vaggie betrays Charlie or anything — she’s already disavowed Heaven and completed her own redemption arc long before the show started.</p><p>In general, I’d point to Charlie and Vaggie’s relationship as one of the weakest character dynamics on the show. I don’t doubt that these two are very personal characters for Vivzie, but it’s weird to me that these two have such a chaste and understated romance in a series so full of extremely explicit sexual humor. They occasionally reference the fact that they’re dating in an offhand way, they sleep in the same bed, and the season finale has a brief romantic duet where they finally kiss — which happens to be tied for the title of the shortest song in the show, at only a minute in length. But other than that, basically nothing would change if Vaggie was just Charlie’s supportive best friend instead of her girlfriend. There’s very little intimacy between them, or any flirting, or really much chemistry at all. I’ve seen children’s cartoons with more intimate lesbian couples. They’re boring. Vaggie is boring.</p><p>Speaking of explicit sexual humor!</p><figure><img alt="Angel Dust posing seductively on a couch with a bottle of beer in hand, saying “This body was made to be exploited.”" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*jOnEMOdZy3PNbb709QKJdg.png" /></figure><h3>Angel Dust</h3><p>Angel, the hotel’s main guest, is… a lot. Played by Blake Roman with a thick New York accent that honestly just makes me think of Rattrap from <em>Beast Wars, </em>Angel Dust is the most famous gay porn star and male escort in Hell, and he won’t let you forget it.</p><p>Almost every line that comes out of his mouth is about his sexual prowess, or about wanting to fuck every other male character he meets, or about his gag reflex, or about how he wants somebody to fill his holes, or about how something another character said could be interpreted in a sexual way, or about how his chest fluff looks kinda like a pair of tits and his partners love that, or about how he thinks the gang should resolve their current problem by letting him film a porno. He drags Charlie and co. into sexual situations that make them uncomfortable for laughs, whether it’s taking them to a BDSM club or making them watch some of his porn as a group. This shtick gets old immediately. It’s as if every scene has an invisible timer ticking away, and when it goes off that’s Angel’s cue to randomly interject with something like “Hey, did you guys know I love suckin’ dick?” And if he’s <em>not </em>talking about sex, chances are he’s talking about how much he loves drugs. His name is “Angel Dust,” after all.</p><p>So, with all that in mind, I was in shock when Angel Dust ended up being the character with the most potential on the show. If I had to pick a favorite, I guess it’d be him.</p><p>He’s still extremely grating and one-note at times, particularly in episodes focusing on other characters where he’s just there as the comic relief gay guy who interjects with sex jokes. But in the two episodes that shine the spotlight on him and his tragic, fucked up life, Angel is the only character that actually made me feel something. He’s capable of some surprising depth and nuance, and I found myself genuinely sympathizing with him. We’ll talk much more about all that later.</p><p>Also, Angel Dust’s real name is revealed to be Anthony. Which my boyfriend naturally hates.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/700/1*GP6MUj-cxaPggre8A3H3Nw.jpeg" /></figure><h3>Husk</h3><p>The hotel’s bartender. He has one of my least favorite designs. I don’t know why the gruff, shit-talking old bartender who calls ’em like he sees ’em is, like… a skinny little owl catboy twink thing who’s covered in spots and hearts and stripes, with a bow tie and top hat? How do these things relate? Husk also has a history with gambling, and I can <em>kind</em> <em>of</em> see the theming there, but again, the design has so many individual details that any motif gets lost in the clutter. And I don’t know why he needs the wings, or why they always have to be visible instead of getting tucked away. Their high contrast clusters of multicolored spots add so much unnecessary visual clutter to any group shot he’s in. Look at this:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/854/1*tWujR5VhYUucIeMhKF4gWw.jpeg" /></figure><p>Actually, researching this a little further, I found out that this is <em>already</em> the simplified version of Husk’s design. All those little spots all over his wings were supposed to be different card suit symbols. It could have been even worse.</p><p>Husk mostly exists to be shipped with Angel Dust, with the two hating each other at first and getting along better over time. He also gets one of my favorite examples of <em>Hazbin</em>’s “tell, don’t show” writing in episode 4, where he just starts listing off everyone else’s character flaws to show how perceptive and blunt he is. The only thing giving this character any charm whatsoever and elevating him above being a Karkat Vantas wannabe is the fact that he’s played by Keith David. Yes, <em>that </em>Keith David. That deep voice with all that gravitas and charisma is coming out of this overdesigned twink catboy. It’s wild. The first time he opened his mouth I was like “<em>That’s </em>the character they got Keith David to play?!”</p><p>Oh, and there’s one more thing worth mentioning with Husk, regarding his relationship with another character. Let’s put a pin in that for a moment.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/700/1*bq6MOMlHqaMEp84NHTRwtQ.png" /></figure><h3>Niffty</h3><p>The hotel’s manic maid played Kimiko Glenn, who you may know as Brook in <em>Orange is the New Black</em>, Horse in <em>Centaurworld</em>, Izzy Moonbow in <em>My Little Pony: A New Generation</em>, or Peni Parker in the <em>Spider-Verse</em> movies, among many other roles. Niffty exists to be the obligatory “gremlin” archetype character, because fandoms eat that kind of thing up. She’s small, cute, mischievous, and hyperactive, but ALSO she loves murder. There’s very little to her because she’s a pure comic relief character. Maybe I’d find her more charming in another show, one where fewer characters feel like they were created in a lab to hit on specific tropes that are like catnip to fandoms in the most mercenary way possible.</p><p>Niffty is at least responsible for one of the few jokes in the series that made me laugh. She excitedly volunteers to participate in a commercial for the hotel, but then every time they start filming she just completely blanks out like this:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/1*OthPZcn_7IQqZEdeGwacaw.jpeg" /></figure><p>For a while we weren’t sure whether or not Niffty is supposed to be a child. She’s the size of a child, and half the time she’s written like a child that’s had too much sugar, such as when the gang is hanging out at a bar and Niffty doesn’t seem to understand what people <em>do</em> in bars. But in one episode when Angel Dust brings the gang to a BDSM club she puts on a black latex dominatrix outfit, so uh… I guess she’s an adult.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/1*G1d04Y5PzoEz1Ko8PGTtXA.jpeg" /></figure><h3>Sir Pentious</h3><p>Also played by Alex Brightman, Sir Pentious is the second guest who stays in the hotel. He’s not the worst, I guess. I tend to like the whole “pompous, scheming supervillain who comically fails at everything” thing, and he’s not a terrible version of that. He has his moments. He’s also the only member of the gang with a slightly different color scheme, so I’ll give him that.</p><p>It’s a little baffling that the show thinks I’ll care about his growth as a person when he’s such a joke of a character, though. They try <em>really</em> hard to push him as the “looks like he could kill you, but is actually a cinnamon roll” character with what little screentime he gets, revealing that he’s a total dork beneath his villainous exterior. It’s super forced, especially him suddenly falling in love with his female rival, Cherri Bomb. The scene where he asks if she would like to “do a sex” with him is perhaps one of the most painful scenes I have ever had to watch in my life.</p><p>Last but certainly not least…</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/700/1*WY0Yb1Rz7W-wCOmCX_BJlg.jpeg" /></figure><h3>Alastor, and his inescapable gravity</h3><p>Alastor the Radio Demon is apparently the most popular character on the show. Seemingly by a pretty wide margin.</p><p>I hate him.</p><p>Every single aspect of this character is agonizing to me. I hate the way he looks, I hate the way he talks, I hate the way he acts, I hate the way the show is so completely in love with him, I hate his very existence. There is no character who drags down this show as much as Alastor. My rating of this show would jump up a point or two if you just deleted Alastor.</p><p>The first thing wrong with this guy is that he’s just got way too fucking much going on. Let’s list some of his character traits here:</p><ul><li>He’s the “Radio Demon.” This means he has a microphone-shaped* staff and talks like an over-the-top old-timey radio host at all times, complete with a radio filter effect over his voice. The voice is already grating enough for me to dislike him based on that alone. His eyes also sometimes transform into radio dials. Again, it’s not entirely clear why a small handful of the demons like Alastor embody different concepts like they’re <em>Chainsaw Man </em>devils when most of the others don’t, or why a human soul would even become the embodiment of a concept after death in the Christian Hell.</li><li>* When the microphone part of the staff is facing away from the camera, as in the screenshot above, it just looks like a butt plug. Believe it or not, I don’t think this was intentional.</li><li>Despite having nothing to do with the radio theme, he’s also a deer boy, because he was originally conceived as a deer demon in <em>Zoophobia. </em>You might not notice this at first. I thought his two-tone hair was supposed to be shaped like fox ears or something until I eventually noticed his teeny tiny little black antlers.</li><li>He’s a sadistic cannibal with razor sharp teeth.</li><li>In his life as a human, he was a serial killer.</li><li>He is literally always smiling menacingly and is insufferably smug.</li><li>He dresses like the Once-ler and wears a monocle. (At least he doesn’t have a top hat.)</li><li>Despite being radio-themed, he can make <em>video</em> glitch effects appear around him and distort the screen.</li><li>On some occasions he gains glowing green stitching over his mouth, like this:</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/1*98WYM9mtdvDp2bu477qLmw.jpeg" /></figure><ul><li>These stitches may or may not be a “voodoo thing.” The word of god excuse for this is that he’s supposedly half Creole. (On the other hand, his voice actor, Amir Talai, is of Iranian descent.)</li><li>Sorry let’s just really let the Creole thing sink in for a second</li><li>He makes shady “deal with the Devil” type soul contracts with characters as part of his vague schemes, seemingly wanting to play all sides at all times. Lucifer, <em>the literal Devil, </em>does not do this in this show, but Alastor does.</li><li>Despite being a sinner who previously lived a normal life as a human, he somehow seems to be the most powerful entity in Hell by a wide margin, even rivaling Lucifer. Both the pilot and the full series recount how he just showed up one day and started wiping out Overlords of Hell and claiming their territory. Alastor immediately stomps just about any threat to the hotel — that is, until the finale, where he needs to randomly lose against Adam and slink away into the shadows for a bit so that the actual protagonist of the show and her dad can beat the villain.</li><li>And, to top it all off, he can transform into a giant and even more edgy eldritch tentacle monster form where he’s even more powerful. Again, no idea what this has to do with the radio theme!</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*0qAgf1_jXlky2T4Tjqj7RQ.png" /></figure><p>It’s just too much. I rankle at media criticism that calls characters “Mary Sues” or “Gary Stus,” so I won’t take that route here, but I just find Alastor plain annoying. He has quirk after quirk after quirk piled on top despite having an extremely one-note personality. He’s trying entirely too hard and he’s just fucking lame. I am allergic to everything this character represents. If you locked some animators in a room for a year with nothing for entertainment but a bunch of horny humanized Bill Cipher fanart from 2014 and some electro swing playlists, Alastor would be the character they’d make. Again, absolutely not for me.</p><p>The thing is, for as much as Alastor has going on, for the first few episodes we were often left asking a question: “Why is Alastor even here?” We’d initially skipped the pilot that sets Alastor up as the shady benefactor of the hotel (and, honestly, makes him look like the main antagonist of the show), and the Amazon show didn’t convey his role particularly clearly at first. So he was just, like. This annoying Tumblr Sexyman who hangs around the hotel and has a grating, gimmicky voice and is like “heehee I’m so evil.”</p><p>Despite seemingly contributing so little, though, Alastor is constantly derailing the main story so that we can follow him around and meet characters he knows. Of the eight 22-minute episodes comprising this season of television, <em>four </em>feature lengthy tangents about new characters spurred on by Alastor. This is what elevates him above being simply an amalgamation of a bunch of tropes I find annoying and turns him into a true menace to this show’s writing. When I say that the scripts feel like a first draft, that they don’t properly know how to spend their time, and that they place emotional beats in the wrong order, so much of that comes down to these Alastor-related subplots.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/1*sD5a2UABX3ejQR5zdFq2HA.jpeg" /></figure><p>Episode two is the one where Sir Pentious becomes the second guest at the hotel and Charlie starts to work on redeeming him. However, much of its runtime focuses instead on introducing Alastor’s rivalry with Vox, a demon with a TV for a head (who of course needs a pinstripe suit, bow tie, top hat, sharp teeth, and mismatched eyes etc. etc.) who runs a TV empire in Hell that rivals Alastor’s radio empire. This, in turn, means we have to spend a bunch of time with Vox, and meet characters <em>he </em>interacts with, as if I give even a single shit about this old vs. new, radio vs. TV thing they have going on, or Vox as a villain. (It seems like he’s being set up as the villain for season 2. Yaaaaayyy.) We literally just established in the first episode that the clock’s ticking for the next round of genocide, and that we need Charlie’s hotel plan to work if there’s gonna be any hope of stopping it, but it feels like the show is already losing interest in that.</p><p>The A- and B-plots here are at least <em>somewhat </em>connected, with Vox getting Sir Pentious to spy on the hotel for him, but I don’t think that means we needed a whole three-minute musical number about Alastor and Vox’s rivalry, especially considering Vox doesn’t do anything for the rest of the season. The balance is completely off. But even though the stuff with Sir Pentious himself feels like such a footnote, with even Angel Dust getting more depth in the episode, it still ends with the song “It Starts With Sorry,” in which Charlie convinces Pentious to tearfully apologize for his misdeeds and take the first step towards true redemption. In the moment it’s so fucking funny that Pentious apologizing is treated as such a big emotional crescendo worthy of a song when the episode wanted to focus on anyone other than him.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*obBWmDGkoD4o8sCNQQcHnA.jpeg" /></figure><p>(There’s that giantess scene girl feathered dinosaur woman I was talking about. I wish she was in a better show.)</p><p>Episode three <em>also </em>has us getting sidetracked to learn about Alastor’s life and even more new characters outside of the hotel, following him to a meeting with the other Overlords of Hell. There, the question of who exactly killed an Exorcist is raised. Now, you might think this would linger as a central mystery of the season. Maybe we’d have different suspects and wonder who did it. At least one or two of Charlie’s friends should be implicated, right? That’s a good hook for ongoing drama! Maybe Alastor did it as some kind of 4D chess move. If we’re gonna focus so much on Alastor, can we at least, like, have him <em>do </em>something?</p><p>You might think these things. But you’d be wrong.</p><p>As Alastor learns, the one who killed the Exorcist is Carmilla Carmine, one of the Overlords. We only meet her in episode 3, and she admits she did it in her second scene. Why’d she do it? Why, to protect her family! And we only learn she has a family in the scene where she confesses, because… well, her two daughters are standing there in the scene. The daughters get a total of four lines across the whole episode. Even still, Carmine launches into a big emotional ballad about the hard choices she’s had to make to protect her family and about how her actions have now put her family in danger, as if these aren’t all characters we just met. (Carmilla gets the spotlight in both of the songs in episode 3 because they need to develop her as a character ASAP, and also because she’s played by one of the original stars of <em>Rent</em>.) This song also tries to depict some kind of parallel between Carmilla and Vaggie, who’s barely had any character development by this point, so it just falls flat. They don’t even show a flashback to the damn murder until episode 7, the only other episode Carmilla is in! This could have been such a good source of drama for the main cast, but instead it’s handed off to some other random character in Alastor’s orbit.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/1*2iT1EcOO9BabU-k_t-J_YA.jpeg" /></figure><p>Perhaps the worst of all these episodes that get derailed by Alastor-related subplots is episode 5, “Dad Beat Dad.” At this point, even though it feels like no time has passed and no progress has been made, it’s apparently already been <em>four months, </em>with only two months remaining until the next extermination. Charlie generally hates using her position of power as the Princess of Hell to support the hotel, even though you’d think she’d pull out all the stops to try and end the genocide, but here she finally caves and decides to get help from her dad.</p><p>Despite being set up as a mysteriously absent figure by the first episode’s opening lore, Lucifer has just been… depressed over the fact that he signed off on the exterminations, and hiding in his house to ignore his problems. The show doesn’t seem particularly interested in addressing the fact that Lucifer is partially responsible for the ongoing genocide. Instead it’s like, look, he has a rubber duck obsession! Lol so random!!!!</p><p>Anyway, so Lucifer comes to the hotel, and he has to go around meeting all the other characters. And then he meets Alastor. And suddenly, the show decides that they’re rivals.</p><p>Because, apparently, we were supposed to see Alastor as a father figure to Charlie this entire time.</p><p>This is maybe the most insane story beat in the entire show to me. When I say the writing has a “tell, don’t show” problem, this right here is exhibit A. I got <em>zero </em>indication that Alastor is supposed to be like a father to Charlie. I didn’t even realize he was supposed to be that much older than her! Shit, they’ve barely even had any meaningful interactions! The only episode in this season that’s really about Alastor helping Charlie out is two episodes <em>after</em> this one, when he takes her to Cannibal Town to rally the troops there. But suddenly the show makes this nonexistent dynamic a big thing and does a whole musical number, “Hell’s Greatest Dad,” where Alastor and Lucifer argue over who’s the better dad for Charlie.</p><p>(Apparently in some interview Vivzie explained that Alastor is bullshitting here and lying about his relationship with Charlie just to get under Lucifer’s skin, in which case, great! Instead of focusing on a character dynamic that didn’t feel properly established, that would just make this subplot a complete fucking waste of time. Great. These plot cul-de-sacs are one of many things I’d like to think a more experienced producer might have advised against.)</p><p>And THEN this fuckin’ shortstack flapper woman bursts into the hotel and interrupts Alastor and Lucifer’s song???</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*VUFJHN3cje7JfdXJo2tp7g.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*fCRxkbi8p5OLVO9Kqp8NAg.png" /></figure><p>Yeah, so here’s that sudden “Vivzie can design a fat character?!” jumpscare. We were stupefied at this point.</p><p>This character is Mimzy, who Hazbin fans have been arguing over because they can’t decide whether or not she’s a Jewish stereotype and — look, I’m getting off track. What matters is that Mimzy is another character who knows Alastor, and she’s here to derail this episode that’s supposed to be about Charlie and her relationship with her dad so that it can instead be about Mimzy explaining how Alastor is the most twisted fucking cycle path in the history of Hell. And once again, the climax of the episode is an emotional musical number that feels completely unearned — this time, a duet between Charlie and Lucifer capping off an episode where they barely interacted because of all the focus on Alastor.</p><p>…Oh, and there’s one more thing this episode draws attention to regarding Alastor.</p><p>So, you remember when I said Husk had a relationship with another character? What I meant is that he has a history with Alastor. Back when he was a gambler (and an Overlord, apparently), Husk made a bet with Alastor and lost, meaning that Alastor now owns Husk’s soul.</p><p>Yes. Alastor, the writers’ pet Tumblr Sexyman character, owns Husk, the only Black-coded character on the main cast, as a slave.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*YGdM4CTRw00NmUexemE41g.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*y1W5cmp8jYKTJYERp90mNw.png" /></figure><p>Did you know that the slave owner who chains up the only Black-coded character on the main cast and threatens to torture and kill him is also supposed to be the token aromantic asexual representation on the main cast? And also don’t forget that he’s apparently half Creole, so it’s totally not problematic!!! Anyway I hate this fucking show so goddamn much</p><p>It’s wild to see the mental gymnastics <em>Hazbin </em>fans pull to try and woobify Alastor in spite of this. I’ve seen people say shit like “Well, Alastor only threatens Husk when he talks back, so he’s really not <em>that </em>bad!” or “Well, at least Alastor doesn’t hit Husk!” I also see the “Alastor is a villain, of course he does bad things” card used a lot. And like, in many other instances, I agree with that logic. But I’m not so sure the writers of this show agree that Alastor is the bad guy! The show is completely enamored with him, and it flip flops between treating him like a genuine menace, acting like he’s becoming friends with the rest of the gang, and hinting that poor widdle Alastor is actually just being used by someone else. (Probably Lilith, Charlie’s absent mother, whose involvement is teased at the end of the finale.) They could take him in any direction they wanted.</p><p>Really, though, where the show lands on Alastor’s morality is a moot point. Either way, it won’t fix the complete tonal whiplash of the show being like “oh yeah btw Alastor owns Husk as a slave and threatens to tear him apart if he acts up” and then expecting you to still care about whether or not he’ll help Charlie teach Sir Pentious how to say thank you or what the fuck ever. <em>That </em>is the problem.</p><p>Again, I think the show would be moderately improved just by removing Alastor from the story, or at least drastically reducing his screentime. They could’ve used the time spent on him and his related subplots to expand on things like, oh, I don’t know…</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/1*vAjm8FPUZx-lBQtyMtAQOg.png" /></figure><h3><strong>The titular Hazbin Hotel</strong></h3><p>Remember when I was talking about the potential of the pilot? Had I watched the pilot in 2019, I would have expected the hotel to be the show’s story engine. Various characters show up as guests to the hotel, and that drives the stories. It’s so obvious! It writes itself.</p><p>You wanna know how many new guests stay at the hotel over the course of the season?</p><p>One.</p><p>It’s Sir Pentious. Sir Pentious and Angel Dust are the only guests at the hotel. Both characters introduced in the pilot. Nobody else stays at the hotel. Despite damn near every new episode introducing new characters, <em>none of them stay at the hotel</em>.</p><p>After a while, I started asking another one of my little questions: “Why is this show even set in a hotel?” It’s so thoroughly uninterested in doing things with the hotel as a setting. We barely even see rooms other than the lobby. They don’t get guests. They barely have any staff, and without guests they rarely have to do their jobs. But even still, we have to get endless scenes about the <em>idea </em>of the hotel, with Charlie bemoaning that the hotel isn’t as successful as she’d hoped and that they really need to figure out something to make it more of a success before time runs out.</p><p>Now, as with many other problems with the show’s pacing and structure, it’s easy to see the short episode order as the problem here. And, sure. Maybe if we’d gotten 13 or more episodes this season, they could’ve done some one-off episodes about new hotel guests. But you know what? I kinda doubt it. Because everyone I know who’s seen <em>Helluva Boss </em>says that show <em>also</em> largely gives up on its premise after a few episodes, shifting much of its focus away from its demon hitman agency in favor of the cast’s personal lives. So I kinda think this is just a thing with Spindlehorse shows in general.</p><p>(Also, I have a hard time believing they could’ve pulled off a longer season at all, given it took them like three or four years just to make eight episodes. A 26-episode season would’ve taken them a decade, or otherwise would’ve required them to stop making <em>Helluva Boss </em>alongside <em>Hazbin</em>, and I know <em>that </em>would’ve pissed people off.)</p><p>Really, it feels like the hotel was only chosen as a setting because Vivzie likes using an ornate early 20th century hotel with its fancy wallpaper as a backdrop as part of her fixation on Roaring Twenties aesthetics. And I guess she also thought of a catchy title with the word “hotel” in it. It’s not even really a hotel at all. Charlie’s trying to use it as a rehab center. It’s a halfway house.</p><p>And at long last, that finally leads us back to the central theme of the show.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/1*kTpwLIAujPHY8_YaN_9fpQ.png" /></figure><h3>“Sin” and “redemption”</h3><p>To me, <em>Hazbin Hotel</em>’s greatest failing isn’t any single character or episode. It’s the entire premise at its very core. The story about Charlie wanting to redeem sinners.</p><p>Let’s set aside the afterlife stuff for a second and look at it from a different perspective. Heaven and Hell basically function as two nations, with one having control over the other — almost as a colonial power, though that analogy doesn’t 100% fit. Regardless, Heaven fears Hell growing too powerful via “overpopulation,” and so a scheme has been arranged to prevent all-out war: Heaven gets to do just a <em>little </em>genocide to their rival nation every year, killing a few hundred random civilians just to keep them in their place. In the face of this genocide, our protagonist’s brilliant plan is to, uh… have some of the people of her nation prove that they’re worthy of not being murdered by cleaning up and learning good Christian morals. (Mostly just by having them do trust falls, and singing <em>My Little Pony</em>-ass songs about how you should say sorry, and that sort of thing.) And then she’ll ship her best and brightest out to live in the nation responsible for the genocide, as if they’ll just be accepted with open arms.</p><p>By the end of the first season, it’s not entirely clear whether or not the show understands the problems with Charlie’s plan, or its rather conservative undertones.</p><p>To me, the big problem with the pilot was that, when you really get down to it, the emotional core of <em>Hazbin Hotel </em>is about a rich girl from the upper echelons of society — a <em>princess</em>, even! — picking a crack-snorting gay sex worker up off the street and trying to turn him into a “proper” member of society. The villains of the series, the angels, hold the conservative Christian stance that Angel Dust died a sinner, and that he deserves to spend eternity in Hell because of that. Instead of arguing that maybe it’s fucked up to say someone deserves eternal torment for doing sex work and recreationally using drugs, Charlie’s best defense is “But I can fix him.”</p><p>Despite being a raunchy adult comedy on the surface, <em>Hazbin</em> has some kinda backwards ideas about sex. Sex is used in very specific ways on this show. It can be used for provocative shock value humor, as set dressing to illustrate the senseless debauchery of Hell. It can be something for the chauvinistic Adam to brag about, making the women around him uncomfortable. And it can be a form of abuse or exploitation, as it is to Angel Dust. But there are never any positive sexual relationships. Sex is never a good thing. It’s a sin. I think this is where the extremely chaste relationship between Charlie and Vaggie really starts to rub me the wrong way. Charlie is the show’s moral compass, and she’s depicted as “pure” and “innocent” and completely sexless. Charlie and Vaggie barely even hug or cuddle. I think they kiss <em>once, </em>in the finale. And like, obviously I’m not saying every romantic relationship needs to be sexual — ace people exist. But when you’re telling a story about a slutty gay guy who’s ruining his life by having too much sex, and how he’s being “saved” by a wholesome woman who never has impure thoughts, that… kinda sucks?</p><p>It didn’t always have to be this way. Let’s finally circle back around to why I said Angel Dust was the character with the most potential. (This is also where we get into some very heavy subject matter, as signaled by the content warning at the start of this piece.)</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/1*2eUNOZ_P_8Mo5YWIwt3f9Q.png" /></figure><p>Episode 4 is when we really learn about Angel Dust’s life in the porn industry, and his abusive relationship with his manager, Valentino, one of the other Overlords of Hell. Because of their contract, Val owns Angel’s soul and thinks he can do whatever he wants to his “favorite toy.” He’s physically abusive towards him, giving Angel a black eye when Angel “acts out,” and it’s implied there’s a history of sexual abuse as well. Honestly, it’s pretty hard to watch, and there’s a huge difference in tone between this and the rest of the show around it. (The preceding scene before Val hits Angel had Charlie barging in on the porn set and getting into slapstick shenanigans, ending with her starting a fire on the set. Other episodes also can’t help but give Angel dark jokes about his abuse, such as an offhand line about how Val’s been waterboarding him lately. “I don’t know, it’s a kink,” he shrugs.) But setting the rest of the show aside, this episode is the first and only time it really made me feel for one of the characters. They were almost on to something here.</p><p>The main reason for that is the nuance of Angel’s feelings about this abusive relationship. I’ve complained before that many depictions of abuse in fiction are way too simplified — just a big, angry guy who hits his partner, and a victim who should know better than to stay. But this depicts an actual cycle of psychological abuse. Valentino breaks Angel down emotionally. He makes Angel think it’s his own fault that he’s in this situation. Angel, in turn, self-harms through his drug addiction and letting people do whatever they want with his body. “If I can ruin myself enough in the process… if I end up broken, I won’t be his favorite toy anymore.” This reinforces Angel’s negative self-image, which makes him feel like he doesn’t deserve better than Val, the only person who really makes him feel anything. And so the loop continues. Angel hides his true feelings and pushes others away by leaning into the hypersexual porn star persona who doesn’t give a shit about anything. It’s all a vicious cycle that Val keeps Angel in to exploit him.</p><p>Much of this is detailed in the episode’s first big musical number and one of the lead singles off the soundtrack, “Poison.” I won’t say this song handles these heavy topics delicately— the controversial visuals depicting Angel at work are extremely sexually charged, and people absolutely have every right to find it uncomfortable— but the lyrics about Angel’s hopelessness make it the only song in the entire show that I find even remotely emotionally affecting. There is, at the very least, the seed of a compelling story here.</p><p>Unfortunately, I already knew the show wouldn’t be able to stick the landing.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/1*kIJ0_y2LAWTcljl8fqdU5Q.jpeg" /></figure><p>Things start to falter with the resolution of this episode. The whole time, Husk’s been noticing how bad Angel’s been doing beneath his carefree persona. Charlie’s corny positivity hasn’t been helping Angel at all. She just doesn’t get it. But the world-weary Husk thinks getting real with Angel might be what he needs.</p><p>And so we get the episode’s second song: “Loser, Baby.”</p><blockquote><strong>Husk:</strong> So things look bad, and your back’s against the wall<br>Your whole existence seems fuckin’ hopeless<br>You’re feelin’ filthy as a dive bar bathroom stall<br>Can’t face the world sober and dopeless<br>You’ve lost your way, you think your life is wrecked<br>Well, let me just say you’re correct</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Angel Dust:</strong> Wait, what?</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Husk:</strong> You’re a loser, baby<br>A loser, goddamn baby<br>You’re a fucked up little whiny bitch</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Angel Dust: </strong>Hey!</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Husk: </strong>You’re a loser, just like me</blockquote><p>Look. I get what they’re going for. Husk gives him some tough love as a shock to the system, and then explains how his life sucks, too, so he can sympathize. But like… man, Angel Dust is practically a fucking sex slave who’s trying to slowly kill himself. Horrendous porn industry abuse is maybe <em>a little much </em>for this “life sucks, but what can you do?” mentality. (The Amazon show also hadn’t properly conveyed that Alastor <em>owns</em> Husk at this point, so when he’s recounting a story about how he used to be a gambler who lost his title of Overlord in a bet with Alastor it feels like a complete mismatch with what Angel is going through.)</p><p>I don’t know. The real glimmer of hope in this ending, to me, is right before the song, when Angel says “I didn’t ask for Charlie to save me.” Maybe, just maybe, this could be a sign that Charlie’s redemption plan is flawed, that she doesn’t really get people, and that in the end it’ll be more about self-improvement for the sake of self-improvement, rather than self-improvement so that you can stop being “a sinner” and get into Heaven. Angel seems to accept himself a little better at the end of “Loser, Baby,” after all.</p><p>And then, we get episode 6. The Heaven episode, where Charlie has to try and prove to the angels that redemption is possible. And of course, the one being judged is Angel Dust.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*JEkde76Db6MAEkJ9VRJr8Q.png" /></figure><p>Perhaps the most shocking part of this episode, way more shocking than the <em>big twist </em>about Vaggie being an angel, is the realization that the angels don’t actually have a list of criteria for who does and doesn’t get into heaven. Yes, this show riffing on the Christian afterlife and sins and redemption does not actually have a list of what it considers a sin. They don’t even use the Ten Commandments. For that matter, God isn’t a factor at all, even though you think he’d be the guy deciding all this stuff. Adam ends up making a short list of criteria to judge Angel Dust by on the spot: “Act selfless, don’t steal, stick it to the man.”</p><p>Everyone in the courtroom in Heaven spies on Angel Dust as he hangs out at a bar with the rest of the gang, with invisible little moral tests along the way to see if he’s changed. Charlie at least argues that whether or not Angel decides to drink shouldn’t be treated as a sign of his moral character. What really bothers me is when Angel stands up for himself against Valentino at the bar, saying he can do what he wants outside of the studio, which Charlie treats as the example of Angel “sticking it to the man” that Adam wanted. And I just… yes, this moment is a win for Angel Dust against his abuser, but it’s gross to me to treat it as a <em>moral </em>win, y’know? To act like standing up against his abuser is what makes Angel Dust a good person deserving of a spot in Heaven? Come on.</p><p>This episode is also the only time the show actually does anything with the angels as homophobic puritans. This bit in the song “You Didn’t Know” is worded in such a vulgar way and is such a sudden shift in tone that it’s mostly just shocking in the moment:</p><blockquote><strong>Lute:</strong> What are we even talkin’ about?<br> Some crack-whore who fucked up already?<br> He blew his shot, like the cocks in his mouth<br> This discussion is senseless and petty</blockquote><p>Again, we’re supposed to want Angel Dust to clean up his act so he can go up and live with people like this in heaven? Really??</p><p>But, okay. This is the point where Charlie realizes she’s never going to sway Adam, Heaven is built on double standards, and they’re just gonna have to fight back against the Exorcists the next time they show up. Which is what the last two episodes are about. Surely <em>now, </em>after all this, the show realizes the flaws in Charlie’s redemption plan, right? Surely they’re going for a “fuck it, we don’t need Heaven’s approval” message now that they’re literally battling Heaven, <em>right?</em></p><p>I have no fucking idea!</p><p>In the end, the hotel is destroyed, but they just rebuild it and open it right back up to get right back to the redemption thing. And Sir Pentious dies a comically anticlimactic death in the final battle, but because he made a heroic sacrifice and has apparently grown <em>so much </em>over the course of this season, he’s rewarded… by becoming an angel. He just respawns in heaven with a new design, a thing that was never presented as a possibility. So I guess redemption and becoming an angel is still supposed to be desirable? After all that???</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/1*XyIWoLkXyEhaJM_xi80qgA.jpeg" /></figure><p>Ah, but of course we also learned that, other than the lead seraphim, Sera, and the Exorcists themselves… nobody in Heaven even knows about the genocide! It was a <em>secret</em> the whole time! And right now, that feels like a move designed to make sure as few characters in Heaven as possible are culpable for the genocide, so that “reforming sinners” and sending them to Heaven can still be seen as a desirable and noble goal.</p><p>No matter how subversive <em>Hazbin Hotel </em>thinks it is with its foul-mouthed queer demon protagonists pitted against an army of angels, the series has been unable to actually say anything critical of conservative Christian values and the idea of sin. At best, season one gives us a message about double standards and forgiving people for past sins, saying that if people can change their ways later in life then they should be able to get into Heaven after all, regardless of their past mistakes. Which, uh. Is already a thing most Christians believe? Like, hello?? Charlie wanting to “save” sinners and get them into Heaven is almost indistinguishable from the behavior of many real life Christians, who want to convert “sinful” nonbelievers so they can atone for their actions and Jesus can “save their souls.” Which makes it kind of hilarious when fundamentalists hear about the show and go “Oh my God, this Amazon show is promoting devil worship!” Half the time Charlie just feels like a fucking youth pastor.</p><p>Look, I could keep going in circles about this stuff forever. It is a complete and total mess. Maybe they’ll go somewhere more thematically satisfying with the next season. Forgive me if I’m doubtful.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/854/1*uA-tg7FKGseQ0IBpLpmMlw.jpeg" /></figure><h3>Stray observations</h3><ul><li>I could’ve done a whole long section about how poorly paced the musical numbers are. Almost every single one starts at a weird time, either coming in at the end of a very long dialogue scene where we already get the point of what’s going on or serving as the climax of an emotional arc that had been barely touched upon. “Happy Day in Hell” is a throwback to classic Disney opening songs introducing the hero, her dreams, and the setting, but it only starts after almost nine minutes of exposition and dialogue scenes.</li><li>Vox, Valentino, and another character whose name starts with V are watching the events of the final battle on TV the whole time and just constantly reacting to events how the writers expect the audience to react, and it’s the most annoying thing.</li><li>Episode 7 is all about getting help from the cannibals in Cannibal Town and then they’re barely even a factor in the finale. They’re usually just shown as a featureless crowd of silhouettes in the background.</li><li>There’s exactly one angel who takes Charlie’s side in episode 6 but then she just doesn’t help at all in the finale.</li><li>Both Vaggie and Charlie try to do some kind of “be the bigger person” moment where they spare the lead Exorcists, even though everyone was just going around decapitating the nameless ones without a second thought just a minute before. Then Niffty just stabs Adam to death.</li><li>I called Sir Pentious dying in the finale from a mile away because he was so obviously the most disposable one lmao. I am a little annoyed they removed the only character with a somewhat different color scheme from the hotel, though.</li><li>Did you know this show currently sits at an 86% positive rating on Rotten Tomatoes?</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/1*bYMzHh2VTrp_RRC3E_kInw.png" /></figure><h3>Closing thoughts</h3><p>So, uh. I didn’t like this show very much.</p><p><em>Hazbin Hotel</em> is a weird, weird show. Again, it had a ton of effort put into it. I don’t want to shit on the voice cast or the animators, who did good work with the material they were given. I don’t wish any harm towards the people who made it, or fans of the show. No, not even Vivzie. But I thought the show was a mess.</p><p>I was often left thinking about how cynical it all feels. It’s like a show designed to hit a bare minimum number of bullet points required to create a rabid fandom.</p><p>Instead of giving us time to get to know the characters and their relationships, we’re just flat out told how we’re supposed to see them. We get the Wikipedia synopsis of every character arc, and then at the end they act like they’ve all grown and changed so much. It reminds me of those TikTokers who write romance novels and try to sell them to you by just listing all the tropes they contain. <em>Hazbin Hotel</em> informs you of the presence of some tropes that fandoms love — the found family, the dapper demonic villain, the enemies to lovers ships, the gremlin, the heckin’ cinnamon roll redeemed villain, the animal mascot companion — and tells you to fill in the rest yourself. It’s written for an audience who have, in fact, <em>already </em>been filling in the rest for years, based on a pilot episode and years of social media posts from the creator. It’s designed to give people who already love the cast little moments to go “wow, I’m shook” or “OMG they confirmed that theory!” But if you aren’t already in love with these characters, the show they made probably won’t sway you.</p><p>Many will pin this rushed storytelling on how short the season was, and believe me, I am definitely a critic of how short TV seasons have become in the streaming era. It’s extremely limiting, particularly for shows built for a more episodic structure as opposed to the “it’s like one big movie” approach. The eight-episode season didn’t help, but I also don’t think squeezing in more episodes would have fixed this show. Many of its biggest issues seem like unforced errors to me.</p><p>But I’m also left wondering if this is just the natural end result of the current crowdfunded indie animation model. Yeah, that’s right, I found a way to blame capitalism!!!</p><p><em>Hazbin Hotel </em>and<em> Helluva Boss</em> are the poster children for a model that requires small teams of up-and-coming animators, usually in their 20s, to put out a polished pilot that blows up as a viral hit and generates a huge, dedicated fandom<em> immediately</em>. Funding (which you need <em>a lot of</em> for TV-quality animation) is secured not just through Patreon or Kickstarter donations, but through mountains and mountains of merch that has to start coming out alongside the pilot. And then <em>maybe</em>, if you’re lucky, you get picked up by a distributor, after you’ve already become a massive success on your own. Of course that model is going to reward shows that hit on easy, marketable, fandom-friendly tropes. But it also means you can’t drastically change things from the pilot, because you might alienate the fandom that’s already there. The concept can’t grow and mature over time. You’re locked in from the start. Who knows if she’d ever even consider this, but imagine how Vivzie’s rabid fandom would have responded if she’d totally reworked the plot from the pilot to remove the genocide stuff. Imagine if the characters had been changed more drastically between the pilot and the full show, after all those shirts and pins and prints had already been sold. Imagine if she’d made the pilot non-canon after years of fanfics building off of it. If you piss off enough fans, there goes your funding.</p><p>I’m not saying the fandom <em>made</em> the Spindlehorse crew make any of the decisions they did, nor do I think that having to pitch to executives is a better system than this. I don’t want the David Zaslavs of the world to be the sole arbiters of what shows get made. But I don’t think this “democratized” crowdfunding model is as freeing as some make it out to be. It’s just a different ball and chain.</p><p>I don’t really have a solution to this. I’m not even an animator. I’m a game dev, and lord knows how bad our industry is doing right now. I just hope that, someday, there are more avenues for success than the ones animators currently have. VivziePop got to make her weird little self-indulgent show about demons — two of them, even! — and I may not like it, but I’d love for more industry outsiders to get their shot like she did. And maybe those other people could make shows with better dialogue.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=1b226af317f5" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Final Fantasy XVI: The one that can say “fuck”]]></title>
            <link>https://ponett.medium.com/final-fantasy-xvi-the-one-that-can-say-fuck-720077d99ec3?source=rss-1885f92e94c5------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/720077d99ec3</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[final-fantasy-xvi]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[final-fantasy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[criticism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[videogames]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Bobby Schroeder]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 13 Jul 2023 22:42:27 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-09-25T21:46:35.668Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*-8XUMMNNTVl_TP7xtpqs6w.jpeg" /></figure><p>(<strong>EDIT 9/25/2024: </strong>This piece is <a href="https://ponett.dog/blog/final-fantasy-xvi-the-one-that-can-say-fuck">now mirrored on my new personal blog</a>! I’m no longer using Medium, and can’t guarantee that this site won’t mess with my formatting or randomly lose chunks of the article, as it’s done in the past.)</p><p><strong><em>Content warning:</em></strong> <em>This article will mention misogynist violence, sexual assault, and incest. These aren’t a huge part of the game, but they come up. Oh, and, you know, </em><strong><em>I’m going to spoil the entire game.</em></strong></p><p><em>Final Fantasy XVI </em>is an easy game to make assumptions about. From the moment it was unveiled, many worried that it would be overly bleak and nihilistic in a series that’s usually anything but. That it would use its newfound ability to more directly depict sex, violence, and sexual violence primarily as a cheap means of shocking the audience and generating buzz, taking the worst possible lessons from one of its primary inspirations, <em>Game of Thrones</em>. Between its shifts in aesthetic, tone, and gameplay, it seemed a little too eager to prove that it wasn’t your dad’s <em>Final Fantasy</em>. All the trailers about the grim protagonist making angry <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z9dg8PI2sEg">chin down, eyes up</a> faces and thinking about revenge certainly don’t help. They wanted you to think that was the whole game!</p><p>Anyway, it turns out that, in the sequences that really matter, <em>Final Fantasy XVI</em> wants to be a shounen battle anime.</p><p>This is theoretically great news for me, someone who loves a good shounen battle anime and finds much of <em>Game of Thrones </em>unwatchable<em>. FF16 </em>does, in fact, have many completely bonkers multi-phase boss fights where two overwhelmingly powerful characters trade blows, transform into more powerful forms, and loudly state their ideals. This is a game where people scream while boosting their energy exactly like <em>Dragon Ball</em> characters. This is a game with beam struggles. This is a game where your dog can do a Sonic homing attack. I can’t help but like those parts.</p><p>It’s less good news for anyone who was earnestly interested in this being “the mature <em>Final Fantasy</em> for adults.” Its shallow, cliché writing and underdeveloped characters are almost completely unable to cash that check. At times, I wondered why they even went for an M rating in the first place, if<em> this </em>was the story they wanted to tell.</p><p>Part of me was relieved, knowing how poor of a track record mass market AAA action games have with “difficult subjects” — and also knowing how inconsistent the narrative arcs have been throughout <em>Final Fantasy XIV’</em>s expansions<em>, </em>which many of <em>FF16&#39;</em>s core creatives previously oversaw. But part of me was also open to the thought of <em>FF </em>telling a story in the vein of something like <em>Berserk </em>or <em>Chainsaw Man, </em>two stories I deeply love. Stories that balance awe-inspiring spectacle, violent action, and horrific trauma with moments of genuine peace and reflection and intimacy. Compassionate stories about broken, fucked up people trying to make it in a complicated world that feels like it’s out to hurt them. Stories that wouldn’t resonate the same way if all the graphic violence and sex were scrubbed out. And <em>FF16 </em>just doesn’t hit like that. But when you announce to the world that you’re exploring more dark, adult, messy, nuanced subject matter, only to completely hedge your bets on it? It just makes me judge the entire game under a different lens, one that the writing doesn’t benefit from in the slightest.</p><p>My opinions on <em>Final Fantasy XVI</em> constantly flip-flopped based on what was currently happening on the screen. It’s a game of extreme highs and lows. But without a doubt… it’s very <em>Final Fantasy.</em></p><p><strong><em>DISCLAIMER:</em></strong><em> Rather than playing through </em>FF16<em> myself, I watched my boyfriend play through it while discussing it with him thoroughly, then dabbled with the combat a little on my own. He also proofread this piece. Feel free to take my thoughts with a grain of salt, since I know the fun of the combat carries the game for a lot of people. But I’ll mostly be focusing on the story, and I doubt my opinions on it would’ve changed much if Anthony had handed me the controller.</em></p><h4>The world</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*oObNP6Ma46PZ99bO5rx46Q.png" /></figure><p><em>Final Fantasy XVI</em> is set in the land of Valisthea. I knew from the start that enjoying this world would be an uphill battle for me. It isn’t going for <em>D&amp;D</em>-style medieval fantasy, like the first five games would more or less do (before introducing some sort of ancient sci-fi technology later in each game, at least),<em> </em>but rather trying harder than ever to just depict a fictionalized version of the real medieval world— or at least, modern pop culture’s image of it. And boy is that not what I want out of this series.</p><p>Gone is most of the whimsy. You’ll never fly an airship. You won’t encounter any funny little guys like Vivi or Red XIII or Papalymo. You won’t find a town full of wizards, or dwarves who say “Lali-ho!”, or anything of the sort. There’s one single Moogle, who exists only to manage the Hunt Board in your base. Every other character you’ll speak to is a human. There is a dog. The dog cannot talk. There are Chocobos, but no Chocobo Theme. While the game’s next gen graphics are certainly extremely pretty, you’ll rarely encounter any scenery as imaginative as <em>FF9</em>’s Iifa Tree, the interiors of <em>FF13</em>’s Cocoon, or <em>FF10’s </em>aquatic Blitzball arenas, nor does it even have the fun juxtaposition of seeing a bunch of <em>FF </em>characters walk into a regular-ass gas station like in <em>FF15.</em></p><p>It’s mostly just dingy old medieval Europe, populated by all the tired innkeepers, blacksmiths, town guards, and prostitutes you would expect, just with a higher rate of feathered bangs per square mile. And it doesn’t help that most areas have such dull, washed out color palettes that I had to check and see if our TV had its HDR settings configured wrong. There will thankfully be exceptions, but this is the image of the world presented up front.</p><p>Valisthea is threatened by the encroaching “Blight,” which turns the land lifeless and grey. More and more of the realm’s outskirts are dying, pushing the nations to feud over the remaining green pastures. Intriguingly, modern Valisthea is so cut off from the rest of the world that it’s implied it may just be the last small landmass on a planet otherwise consumed by the Blight, although this is never confirmed or denied. The game will suddenly decide that the Blight is important later, but for the early hours it’ll be commented on surprisingly little.</p><p>What’s really important to know up front is that there are three different, seemingly unrelated sources of magic that vie for the story’s attention.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*F74qsLrrnaqWBcyniLyvDw.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>ONE: </strong>Scattered across Valisthea are five mountain-sized Mothercrystals, the exteriors and interiors of which generally deliver the most striking and fantastical sights in the game. Most of the major powers of the world have built their capital cities next to them for the sake of mining them, as crystals are the most accessible form of magic and this is a society wholly reliant on magic for day-to-day life. At least, they tell you it is. A few times you’ll see characters use small fire crystals to light pipes or boil water. Things like that. It can be hard to remember how magic-reliant this world apparently is when everything mostly just looks like medieval Europe, a world that did not need magic to exist. Either way, we’ll have more to say about crystals later.</p><p><strong>TWO: </strong>Unrelated to the Mothercrystals (I think?), some people are randomly born with the ability to do magic — although if they do TOO MUCH magic their bodies begin to petrify, and they eventually die. Which is probably why you never see them do magic, despite that being their defining thing. These people are known as “Bearers” and are almost universally enslaved their whole lives, typically marked with a cursed face tattoo that earns them the label “Branded.” I don’t know whether or not this is supposed to be a slur, but non-Bearer NPCs sure say it like it is.</p><p>Yes, this game is, in fact, doing a big story about slavery in a world consisting almost entirely of white British people — for “historical accuracy,” of course, because the average AAA game producer continues to believe that everyone in medieval Europe was white. Even the blatantly Middle East/North Africa-inspired desert nation of Dhalmekia on the southern side of the map seems to mostly be inhabited by British people with tans, <em>Lawrence of Arabia</em> style. At best, maybe two noteworthy characters are “racially ambiguous.” For that matter, it’s also doing yet another oppression allegory where the oppressors are given a legitimate reason to fear the minority — <em>they can literally kill you with fucking magic</em>.</p><p>This is as bad as it sounds. Or at least, it is until the game decides to stop caring about slavery as a major driving force in the plot. We’ll get to this.</p><p><strong>THREE:</strong> Last but certainly not least, the Dominants, people who can channel the powers of godlike entities known as “Eikons” and even fully transform into them. (Think the jinchūriki from <em>Naruto</em>, sort of.) Like Bearers, Dominants can only use their magic so much before it exacts a fatal toll on their bodies, but the limits seem to be whatever the story needs on a case by case basis. Dominants can also grant other people the ability to use some of their elemental magic, but this rarely comes up. Those granted magic in this manner are generally not treated like Bearers, except for when they are.</p><p>Supposedly, the different cultures of Valisthea all treat their Dominants differently, but only the weirdo religious extremists in the small Iron Kingdom off the west coast really seem to subjugate their Dominants. The rest of the major kingdoms put them in some sort of position of power, or even base their royal families around Dominant bloodlines. Despite this, the game will still feel the need to give its protagonist a line where he points out the irony of the term “Dominants” out loud.</p><p>The Eikons are, of course, based on classic <em>Final Fantasy</em> summons, because the creatives behind <em>FF14: A Realm Reborn </em>seem to have a particular fixation on the classic summons. There are eight Dominants for eight elements: Phoenix (fire bird), Shiva (ice lady), Ramuh (electricity wizard), Titan (earth giant), Garuda (wind harpy), Bahamut (light dragon), and Odin (dark knight guy on horse), plus the long-lost Leviathan (water serpent), who’s mentioned in passing but otherwise absent for reasons the game doesn’t explain. Most fans seem to assume it’ll be DLC.</p><p>Naturally, the Dominants comprise most of the game’s main cast.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Rq--tXabEKfClR6KUFRmmw.jpeg" /></figure><h4>“Yeah, that’s me. My name’s Clive. I’m just your average kid!”</h4><p>The star of the show is Clive Rosfield. We briefly meet him as an adult in an opening action sequence that’s really just a movement tutorial, then flash back to his youth for a couple slow, cutscene-heavy hours.</p><p>Clive is the eldest son of the Archduke of the humble Rosaria. In theory, Clive should have been the Phoenix Dominant, and therefore his father’s heir, but instead it skipped him and went to his younger brother Joshua. In the prologue, the meek Joshua (10) is being prepared for his future on the throne, while Clive (15) trains as Joshua’s primary bodyguard using some fire magic granted by the Phoenix. Their brotherly bond is sweet. Also, their friend Jill is there, and she is a girl.</p><p>It’s here that we finally get our first taste of combat. Yes, <em>Final Fantasy XVI </em>has, in fact, fully embraced real time action. It’s fast and responsive with the expected mix of sword slashes, ranged magic, dodges, a gap closing move, and flashy special attacks that are on cooldowns, with no use of menus whatsoever. Enemies have stagger meters a la <em>FF13</em> and <em>FF7 Remake</em>, which deplete as you do damage and leave them vulnerable for a short period when empty. This leads to a rhythm where you slowly chip away at an enemy until they’re staggered, at which point you go all out with your strongest moves and try to do as much damage as you can. You can also map items such as potions to the D-pad and use them mid-combat, sort of like Estus Flasks. The early game keeps things simple, but I’ll have much more to say about the gameplay later.</p><p>By the end of this prologue, Clive’s life goes to hell. His mother, Annabella, is a selfish bloodline purist who’s always viewed him as a failure for not being born the Phoenix. Hoping to take her precious Dominant baby Joshua with her and fuck off to greener pastures, she stages a violent coup against the Archduke so that she can run off with the Emperor of the vaguely French-flavored Holy Empire of Sanbreque. However, this plan backfires. In the ensuing massacre, an unheard of <em>second</em> Eikon of Fire — the demonic Ifrit — appears, goes on a rampage, and kills Joshua. (After a lengthy <em>Panzer Dragoon</em>-esque rail shooter boss fight where you control Joshua as the Phoenix, that is.) A distraught Clive is one of the few who survive the night, but Annabella gives him to the Empire as a slave before having her onlooking handmaidens executed, because she has no character traits beyond “evil bitch.”</p><p>Spoiler: it’s immediately obvious that Ifrit here is actually Clive, having awoken unknown Dominant powers and gone out of control, but the game’s going to spend a good few hours pretending you didn’t figure this out watching the trailers. The game will spend even longer pretending you don’t know what phoenixes are famous for doing. I’ll be generous and call this “dramatic irony.”</p><p>Back in the present day, Clive is now 28, having spent the last 13 years as a Branded slave in the Sanbreque army. We rejoin him behind enemy lines during a clash between Titan, serving the vaguely Arabian Dhalmekian Republic, and Shiva, serving the aforementioned religious extremists in the small Iron Kingdom, with his squad intending to kill Shiva. Clive realizes that Shiva is really none other than his childhood friend Jill, having apparently awoken Dominant powers since they last saw each other, and he betrays his commanding officer to save her. Conveniently, the two newfound fugitives are immediately taken to safety by this game’s Cid, who coincidentally happens to be there at the time. Even <em>more </em>coincidentally, Cid is even accompanied by Clive and Jill’s old puppy, Torgal, who is now a full grown wolf. His name is fun to say. Torgal.<em> Torgal.</em></p><p>And so the game can finally properly get going.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*6lZZjeZDL5b7i_5nG8BvRw.jpeg" /></figure><h4>Hide away, folk family, or else someone’s gonna get ya…</h4><p>Cid, as it turns out, basically runs the underground railroad for Bearers, based out of a hideaway called… well, The Hideaway. (He’s also soon revealed to be Ramuh’s Dominant.) The Hideaway serves as your main “town,” being the place you’ll return to between most story missions.</p><p>I had mixed feelings about Cid and the Hideaway, mostly because they didn’t jive with the type of Dark Fantasy story I thought I was getting into. The Hideaway offers a reprieve from the horrors of the rest of the world basically as soon as you exit the prologue. There’s no real time spent exploring Clive’s time as a slave, or even as a runaway, before reaching the one place on the planet where everyone is nice and has all the answers. There’s no time to sit with that discomfort. To go back to the <em>Berserk </em>comparison, it’d be like if Guts reached the safe haven of Elfhelm the very next chapter after the idea was suggested.</p><p>The Hideaway always has food and a warm bed available for whoever needs it. Hours before the Blight becomes relevant in the story, we have a gardener at the Hideaway excited to reassure us that Blighted land can still be made to grow plants again. Within minutes of learning that Clive has become Branded, we’re introduced to the one person in the world capable of removing the Brand. (Frustratingly, though, Clive won’t actually take up this offer to get the cursed face tattoo marking him as a slave removed for another ten hours. That chunk of the game has to largely revolve around teaching you and Clive just how bad the slavery situation is to get him to care about Cid’s cause. You know, as if Clive didn’t just spend 13 entire years of his life enslaved to the Empire.)</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*0hCRCe2SXj5Laz1xBj3xgQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>Similarly, upon his introduction Cid felt like way too clear-cut of a hero for the type of story I thought I was getting into. He’s just purely, unambiguously good, and he has all the answers. He’s an archetype played straight. It feels too easy for this type of story. Not just because Cid’s a good guy, but because he doesn’t have to do any work to get to that goodness, nor is he ever really faced with anything that challenges it. He’s got everything figured out and knows exactly what to do. He never has to discuss politics or strategy with other people at the Hideaway, nor does he seem to be building off of the work and ideas of previous revolutionaries. He doesn’t even ever sit down and talk with Bearers to figure out their needs and how he can help them. Everyone is just following “Cid’s dream,” as they call it, which I guess came to him fully-formed one day. He’s a downright messianic figure. I’d call him a white savior, but, again, they made a game about slavery where everyone is white.</p><p>(Specifically, Cid’s dream is stated to be to create “a place where people can die on their own terms.” A few hours later Clive will go “but what about a place where people can LIVE on their own terms?” as if this doesn’t basically mean the same thing, and the game will treat this like the most profound line ever written. These are thereafter combined into “creating a world where people can live AND die on their own terms.” That’s dialectics, I guess? Thesis, antithesis, synthesis. Hegel would be so proud.)</p><p>Now, I love plenty of mass market pop culture about heroic rebels fighting the big evil empire, including several previous <em>Final Fantasies</em>. But when you’re repeatedly citing George R.R. Martin as an inspiration, and giving me a world with politics so complex that you need to create an entire NPC who exists just to keep me updated on the movements of the various factions? My expectations are different than when I’m watching <em>Star Wars. </em>Actually, in the early hours, I was constantly thinking back to how much more nuanced and fascinating <em>Andor’s </em>takes on the Rebels, the Empire, and the systems surrounding them were compared to what’s being done here. If only Cid had an ounce of Luthen’s complexity...</p><p>That being said, knowing the much more shounen action direction the story would actually go in, I’m willing to look back on Cid and his Hideaway more fondly. While he felt like a square peg in a round hole to me at first based on how the game was pitched, he fits better in the lighter, more morally straightforward story we actually got by the end. He’s a likeable character, particularly thanks to the memorable performance by the gravelly-voiced Ralph Ineson. He’s charismatic and witty. He’s world-weary and feeling his age, but he still just wants to do good in spite of that. I get why he’s proving to be the breakout star of the game, aside from Clive himself.</p><p>I will also admit that not “both sides”-ing a fight to end slavery puts the writing in this game above a good number of beloved western RPGs. But a lot of western RPGs are just written by libertarians, so that’s not exactly a high bar to clear.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*8eiPB24TrY4U4LUO7SUb8A.jpeg" /></figure><h4><strong>Clive and Cid’s Big Adventure</strong></h4><p>Anyway! While Cid presumably has more important things to be doing as the head of The Underground Railroad For Wizards, he decides to help Clive follow a lead on an alleged second Dominant of Fire, as the only thing Clive wants in life right now is to avenge Joshua. Said Dominant is apparently already being scouted out by Benedikta, the Dominant of Garuda, who works for the evil Kingdom of Waloed (pronounced wuh-LOOD). This will position her as the villain of the game’s first proper story arc.</p><p>Again, it was safe to assume from the start that Clive is Ifrit, which in turn narrows down who this other Dominant of Fire Clive’s tracking down actually is. It drove me insane that no one ever goes “Hey wait, aren’t phoenixes immortal?” We can’t hint that Joshua is alive, though, because he’s got to spend this part of the game running around in an ominous hooded robe exactly like the main antagonist’s as a red herring.</p><p>Clive and Cid’s journey will take you through a string of linear stages designed to always funnel you towards the next boss or story scene, with only a few glowing blue item pickups off to the side as distractions. The first six or so hours of the game are very linear like this, which led me to make a few posts early on saying that the game was only interested in being a character action game a la <em>Devil May Cry, </em>with minimal “RPG elements.” This disappointed me at first, but the extreme padding in the back half of the game would make me come to truly miss these few briskly paced, action-packed hours. I can’t believe I came away wishing a <em>Final Fantasy </em>game was <em>less </em>of an RPG, but here we are.</p><p>While I feel the pre-release hot takes about how “the story is so convoluted that even the devs couldn’t figure it out!” were overblown — at its heart this is the most straighforward <em>FF</em> story in decades — this was the point in the story where Anthony and I felt the need to consult the lore entries. Mainly, the game kept using the term “Royalists” to describe an enemy faction, and we had no clue who this was referring to. It turns out it was the guys from Waloed, while we thought it was Sanbreque. While I initially liked that the game had jumped right into some action, comparing it favorably against the slow walls of text about the warring nations of Ivalice that <em>Final Fantasy XII </em>is front-loaded with, by this point I kind of wished we’d gotten a straightforward rundown of who’s fighting who early on. You don’t actually get this until like a dozen hours in, when the war map and relationship chart unlock. And while the “Active Time Lore” system is nice, we never wanted to pause a cutscene to check the in-game wiki.</p><p>Eventually, after fighting a whole lot of her dudes, we catch up with Benedikta for the first true major boss battle of the game.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*uBY_2sbkicLYnEmBjCYOJA.jpeg" /></figure><h4>Evil harpy woman</h4><p>I feel like there are two alternate versions of Benedikta who would have worked better. Option one: the version whose inner life and complexities the story is more interested in, which we might have gotten if the game had learned more valuable lessons from George R.R. Martin. Option two: the version who isn’t trying to be particularly deep and instead is just a cool sexy evil witch lady who serves as a fun villain for a while, which we might have gotten if the game just embraced being a shounen action romp. Unfortunately, writer Kazutoyo Maehiro is too bad at writing women for us to get the former, and the game tries too hard to be taken seriously to get the latter. So we get an uncomfortable middle ground.</p><p>Benedikta is very overtly sexual as a character. Even beyond her low-cut top, sultry voice, and the exaggerated way she sways her hips any time she walks, she’s by far the most sexually active character of any relevance. Shortly after we meet her in the game’s opening, Benedikta will pounce on Hugo Kupka, Titan’s Dominant, and practically start dry humping him in a hallway. Later, she’s also shown to be sleeping with her boss, King Barnabas — Odin’s Dominant — via a scene where they’re both in the nude but the camera keeps doing cinematography gymnastics to avoid ever showing her nipples. (This is very funny to me.) And, of course, she’s also Cid’s toxic ex.</p><p>I don’t have a problem when Benedikta being a sultry femme fatale type. I am a known stan of Rouge the Bat, and I have the <em>Bayonetta</em> OST in my iTunes library. And I think Benedikta has a cool design! I also don’t have a problem with her sleeping around. But it feels very telling that the most sexually active character in the game is a female villain who’s using her promiscuity to get ahead in the world — as if she wasn’t already born one of the most magically powerful beings in existence. Compare this to the extremely chaste romance between Clive and Jill. When put next to Clive’s evil mother Annabella, there’s a recurring theme here of evil blonde women who just want to fuck the men in power to further their personal agendas.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*cPvVy4LvKlC2nlFfG1pulQ.png" /></figure><p>Anyway, because she has the “second” Dominant of Fire that Clive’s looking for captive, you fight her. It’s a multi-phase fight where she uses more and more Garuda powers. Eventually she’ll start grabbing and throwing entire castle towers at Clive. It’s cool. The boss fights in this game are cool. These are the parts that I like. And then afterwards Clive steals her Garuda powers — a thing he’s only just now realizing he can do — to unlock the next branch on his skill tree.</p><p>After her lifelong connection to Garuda is severed, Benedikta starts having a mental breakdown, and some of her grunts pull her away as the off-screen Dominant of Fire starts to destroy her fortress. They drag her off into the nearby woods where her grunts are murdered by three random bandits, who I guess just spawn out of thin air in this kind of story. No prize for guessing what a gang of random, nameless bandits in a medieval fantasy story written by hacks want to do to a defenseless woman in the middle of nowhere after walking up to her and saying “What do we ‘ave ‘ere?” Yes, the fact that this happens the second Benedikta loses her Garuda powers fucking sucks. Before they can really do anything to her, Benedikta spirals even further into despair, wonders if this is her karmic punishment for not siding with Cid, and decides the whole world deserves to be destroyed, causing the last remnants of her connection to Garuda to take over. She now takes on her full Garuda form, but she’s no longer in control of her own actions.</p><p>In other words, Benedikta randomly almost gets raped and turned into a sex slave and it makes her go crazy and turn into a big monster that you have to put down.</p><p>Yeah, it’s, uh. Not great!</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*yQJmmZAG29yL9P2_Bmxo-g.jpeg" /><figcaption>That winning smile… god I wish I could like this part</figcaption></figure><p>The fight against the gigantic Garuda is certainly fun, and she’s got a cool design. The second phase will drive Clive to finally transform into Ifrit, confirming what we all knew and giving us our first proper Eikon vs. Eikon fight. These bombastic kaiju battles will generally be my highlights of the entire game, but it was impossible for me to really get into this first one because of the overwhelmingly nasty taste Benedikta’s storyline was leaving in my mouth. Again, it just feels like lashing out over her trauma turned her into a monster and now you have to put her down.</p><p>And so Benedikta dies, with Cid mourning her after the battle. The two have a history together, and Benedikta is vaguely shown to have been saved from an impoverished background by Cid as an attempt to give her some depth beyond Sexy Evil Woman, but we never get the full details. Other villains will later call her a whore, but it’s hard to tell if they’re talking about her past or just being misogynists.</p><p>It can still get worse, though!</p><p>Later, Benedikta’s severed head is sent to Hugo Kupka in a box.</p><p>We never actually see inside the box, and it takes hours for anyone to actually say that’s what it is, but yep. That’s what it is. Either Barnabas or one of his minions must have found Benedikta’s corpse sometime after her and Clive’s battle, cut off her head, and sent it to Kupka, blaming Cid for the deed so that Kupka will start attacking Cid’s rebels.</p><p>Yes, the ultimate fate of this vaguely sexually traumatized seductress is for her decapitated head to be used as a chess piece in a feud between three of her former lovers<em>. </em>We never learn more about her as a character. Her death is merely fuel for Kupka’s rage so that he can be the next Dominant you have to fight.</p><p>Yeah, I, uh. I hate this. That sure is the <em>Game of Thrones </em>influence coming through in the worst possible way. None of Martin’s knack for political intrigue or nuanced characters, just the gratuitous violence against women. This is exactly what I was worried the game would be full of. To its credit, this is the most egregious instance in <em>FF16</em>, and nothing this nasty will happen again. It could’ve been much worse. But it also could’ve done anything other than this.</p><p>We’re never truly invited to see Benedikta’s perspective. We get so little of her inner life. We get hints, but she mainly exists in relation to the men she slept with. We see her through their eyes, not hers. She exists to further their stories, not her own. By the time we finally start to deal directly with Barnabas and reach Waloed, she may as well have never existed at all with how little lasting impact she has. And this will become a recurring problem with the game’s handling of its female cast — and, hell, the male villains don’t fare much better, either, when it comes to having any real depth.</p><p>…But, uh… at least the combat’s fun, right?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*zmg6j9F5jmI1subWSVF0pQ.jpeg" /></figure><h4><strong>The section where I finally talk about the combat</strong></h4><p>With multiple Eikon movesets at our disposal, it’s finally time to dig into everyone’s favorite part of the game: the combat. I do like the combat overall, but I also think there’s massive room to improve here, should they iterate on this format in the future.</p><p>The gameplay systems of <em>Final Fantasy XVI </em>where largely designed to evoke the job system of <em>Final Fantasy V — </em>one of my personal favorites — which grants the player an ever-expanding roster of classes to apply to their party however they see fit, as well as the ability to mix and match abilities. And the influence is certainly there.</p><p>Over the course of the game you’ll unlock seven different sets of Eikon abilities, three of which you can equip at a time to swap between freely. Each Eikon comes with its own innate perks — Garuda has a grapple, Shiva lets you skate around and freeze enemies, Ramuh has a spell that’s literally just the Shotlock mechanic from <em>Kingdom Hearts: Birth by Sleep</em>, etc. — as well as four special moves that operate on cooldowns, of which you can equip two at at time. As a lifelong fan of games like <em>Mega Man </em>or <em>Kirby</em> where you have a lot of different powers to choose from<em>, </em>the variety here naturally appeals to me. It is, in fact, a lot of fun every time you unlock the flashy skills of another <em>FF </em>summon.</p><p>Similar to <em>FF5, </em>you can “master” Eikon spells so that you can equip them to other Eikon sets. Rather than needing to grind out a specific Eikon, this is done by simply investing enough points in the skill you want to master. And, conveniently, you’re free to refund the points spent on a given skill at any time, or even reset your entire skill tree, then put those points back into something else. This encourages you to experiment and try out new things, as you’re never locked into any one build for Clive.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*3eBcFtzaY7FmuClzNpwWrw.jpeg" /></figure><p>In theory, this means that there’s tons of room to customize Clive and strategize your builds. This is true to some extent. In practice, the encounter design in this game means you’ll rarely have any reason to do so.</p><p>The one that most people notice is the complete lack of elemental weaknesses and resistances among enemies, which stands out in a game themed around elemental powers. A common refrain is that it’s weird that the Bomb enemies, which are made of fire and thus normally immune to the element, can be killed with fire spells. As such, there will rarely be a scenario where any one set of Eikon skills will feel more useful than the others.</p><p>This also feels like the team’s MMO experience seeping through. Enemies in MMORPGs generally lack weaknesses and resistances so that all players, regardless of class, can do the same content. MMOs in the vein of <em>World of Warcraft</em> are decidedly <em>not </em>about stopping to rethink your strategy or coming up with your own build, instead generally focusing on doing your class’s optimal skill rotation. And, in practice, that’s kind of what <em>FF16</em> devolves into as well. You’ll rarely need to think about what skills to use where, you just pop whatever’s off cooldown at the moment.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*GeKuTOfRoNr6qe_zZX2c1A.jpeg" /></figure><p>This is exacerbated by the fact that standard enemies are kind of a joke. In the early game, before you’ve maxed out any Eikons, many of them will feel like damage sponges with way too much health, but they rarely put up much of a fight. It was extremely rare for Anthony to need to heal against normal mobs, and he’ll readily admit he isn’t even that good at the game.</p><p>Setting aside the lack of elemental weaknesses, enemies (and encounters as a whole) aren’t designed to mix up your use of your basic skills, unlike the enemies in many pure action games. You’ll never really encounter a heavily armored enemy you need to hit with heavy attacks, or a high-flying enemy that needs to be knocked down with your ranged magic before you can hit it with other attacks, or an enemy that requires you to use the funny Goomba stomp move Clive has for some reason, or anything like that. Like an MMO, you just keep doing your rotation. While there’s tons of potential to strategize your build for Clive, when you’re actually in the heat of battle, I would argue that there’s less strategic thought required here than in proper character action games like <em>Devil May Cry, Bayonetta, </em>or <em>Hi-Fi Rush.</em></p><p>By the late game, Anthony had unlocked Bahamut’s skill tree, and with it a flamethrower skill that magnetically pulls enemies towards its cone of effect, and even drags them along with you if you move. It felt like a flamethrower version of the Poltergust from <em>Luigi’s Mansion</em>. It was so effective that Anthony got into a habit of walking up to groups of five or so enemies at a time, popping this skill, and then literally putting the controller down in his lap for about ten seconds as he waited for them to die. At one point he said he was just playing as a <a href="https://wiki.teamfortress.com/wiki/Glossary_of_player_terms#W.2BM1">W+M1 Pyro</a>. Was this funny? Yes. But I don’t know if it’s particularly engaging gameplay.</p><p>Shockingly, the build guides I’ve found don’t even recommend using this skill, instead telling you to master Bahamut’s big fuck off laser attack and put it on another Eikon. This isn’t even a min-maxed build. It’s just a random build, and it eviscerated the game.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*XwNVUASgTpLhz4drBNUO_w.jpeg" /><figcaption>The W+M1 Pyro gameplay in question.</figcaption></figure><p>“But Bobby!” I hear some of you interjecting. “This is only normal mode! What about the harder ‘Final Fantasy’ difficulty?” Well, dear reader: you need to beat the game to unlock it, and we’re not playing through a 50-hour game twice in a row. Hardly anyone who plays the game is going to do that. It really, really should have been an option from the start.</p><p>To be clear: I don’t necessarily mind when an RPG is a little easy, or when you end up finding a dominant strategy that wipes the floor with most enemies. You can say the same thing about many classic <em>Final Fantasy </em>games. But, for one, the fun there is that you chose how to build your party to get to that strategy in the first place. It’s the payoff for the thought you’ve put into your party. Like I’ve been saying, it doesn’t feel like <em>FF16</em>’s default difficulty ever really makes you think about your build or what moves you’re using. And in an action game, I’m gonna want the action to be more engaging.</p><p>The other part, of course, is that I don’t mind an easy RPG if the story is carrying it for me. And I don’t like the writing in <em>FF16.</em></p><p>When you start to think about it, there really are a lot of basic gameplay elements missing that could have helped add a little more depth. There are no status ailments or buffs. The only combo you have is a basic four-hit combo. There are no alternate weapon types, just a long string of reskins for Clive’s sword with a linear progression of strength upgrades. And, of course, there’s no customizing equipment, skills, or behavior on your “party members” whatsoever.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*zJQSNwNfdLHL8-YYEmYFCw.jpeg" /></figure><p>At the end of the day, for all my complaints, the combat is still pretty fun. The boss fights in particular are so chock full of spectacle that you don’t really think about things like a lack of elemental weaknesses or the fact that Clive can’t equip a heavier sword or whatever.</p><p>But on a personal level, it bothers me the way people act like this gameplay is an objective upgrade. It bothers me that people talk about the turn-based systems of previous <em>FF</em>s like they’re a relic of the past, an evolutionary stepping stone on the way to this, Square’s ultimate vision: a watered down version of a Platinum game. As if the mechanical history of the series doesn’t really matter so much as its aesthetics and vibe. As if turn-based combat is purely a compromise, and not an interesting avenue of design and play in and of itself.</p><p>I’ve already seen people retroactively declare the menuing of <em>FF7 Remake </em>to be an evolutionary half-step towards this, when I find the combat, encounter design, controllable party members, and character building options in <em>Remake </em>vastly more interesting. Yes, even the menus! I like the menus! I like stopping to think about my options. I like going into slow-mo and scrambling to get my Phoenix Downs out of my inventory with my last standing party member. I liked having a few boss fights that genuinely made me rethink my Materia loadouts. There is no part of me that considers that to be “lesser” to <em>FF16</em>’s fully real-time combat. They didn’t leave in the menus in <em>Remake</em> because they didn’t know how else to design combat, <strong><em>they put them there on purpose.</em></strong></p><p>I’m not opposed to <em>FF </em>doing full real time combat, and I think <em>FF16</em> is a decent attempt at this, but I’m still interested in what a game with this budget and graphical fidelity could do with an updated take on turn-based combat. But even mild preference for the turn-based systems of old is always met with the response of “What about <em>Bravely Default </em>and <em>Octopath Traveler</em>?” Well, you see, those games suck ass. I would like Square to make more new turn-based RPGs that don’t suck ass. But for all my complaints, I guess I’ll still take <em>FF16</em> over the mind-numbing <em>Bravely </em>and <em>Octopath</em> games any day.</p><p>Anyway, speaking of things that suck ass, let’s get back to how this game treats its female cast.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*leUOZkbFti2MItSFsLcmyA.jpeg" /></figure><h4>Jill is also a character in this game</h4><p>After Benedikta’s defeat, the game decides it’s finally ready for its female lead to wake up from her very long nap back at the Hideaway, and Jill joins the party.</p><p>I wish I liked Jill more. I really do. But it doesn’t feel like the game actually gives that much of a shit about her. Compared to Clive, who grows a ton and reveals new layers over time, Jill feels very thinly sketched as a character.</p><p>Jill Warrick was an orphan from a region consumed by the Blight. She ended up in the care of the Archduke of Rosaria, who “raised her like a daughter” without outright adopting her. In other words, yes, Jill is kinda sorta Clive’s step sister. And also his girlfriend.</p><p>Fun!</p><p>I’m gonna be honest, this is brought up so little that I forgot about it until fact checking to write this article. I remembered her as being just a vague family friend. But nope! She was “raised like a sister to Clive and Joshua.” So it’s not TECHNICALLY step sibling incest, but it’s juuuuuuuust close enough that it gets weird when you think about it. I’m not going to dwell on this any longer, but, again, make of this what you will.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*4yMqYIG54qffSkeBNw2kvQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>After the fall of Rosaria in the prologue, Jill and many other women were taken as slaves by the religious zealots in the neighboring Iron Kingdom. Lord knows what horrors she saw others experience, but she herself narrowly avoided being raped and murdered. In her own words: “I thought they meant to have their fun with me before the end… but the end never came. My powers awoke, and everything changed.” Those powers being Jill’s Shiva powers. The Ironbloods forced her to become their walking superweapon and commit mass murder for them on the battlefield as Shiva, using threats against children as leverage.</p><p>The game spends basically no time exploring this further in Jill and Clive’s reunion scene, as Jill immediately shifts the subject to Clive and his problems, resolving to accompany him on a journey back to Phoenix Gate to try and find clues about what really happened. This sums up her entire character. Jill’s trauma exists so that she can say she went through some stuff sort of like what Clive went through. They were both enslaved by evil empires for those 13 years, they both killed a lot of people with their Dominant powers and regret it. She has very little going on beyond being the person who tells Clive he should look after himself. She only ever wants what Clive wants.</p><p>If you held a gun to my head, I could not name a single personality trait of Jill’s that doesn’t come back to either her trauma or her relationship with Clive. (“Having cool ice powers” does not count as a deep personality trait.) I guess I would describe her as “nice.” If you catch me in a bad mood I might describe her as “the Family Dollar version of Ysayle from <em>Heavensward,” </em>even if that’s not fair.</p><p>Jill gets the most prominence in a story arc somewhere around halfway through the game. By now, Clive’s already come to terms with his past and the fact that he’s Ifrit’s Dominant, having set aside his revenge plot since he can’t really get revenge against himself. So at one point in their travels, Jill stops to all but say “Hey, you got your big revenge arc where you got to deal with your traumatic backstory. Now it’s my turn.” It’s an errand Jill needs to get out of the way before she can continue being Clive’s sidekick. And so they go do that. Because they were already heading for the hideout of the Ironbloods anyway.</p><p>It’s stunning how this subplot plays out. Jill wants to murder the High Priest of the Iron Kingdom — a character we barely see — for, well, everything. And so you go to their seat of power, and after the obligatory boss fight for Clive, Jill gets her big girlboss moment where she gets her revenge, and then that’s it. No further introspection needed. She’s sufficiently dealt with her trauma by getting her revenge. It never meaningfully comes up again. In a game that otherwise spends such a huge amount of its runtime contemplating the pointlessness of revenge, it’s such a thematic cop out. They don’t even free the captive Rosarian women they run into on the way in — as far as I remember, they’re last seen being boated out with the evacuating Ironblood soldiers.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*L8KUUlxTD-lcYHTxOS4w4g.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*fm8ZMnUBZPPrWqtTbkG0mA.png" /></figure><p>Jill’s characterization certainly isn’t helped by the general lack of a real party in <em>FF16. </em>While there are a handful of different companions who will shuffle in and out of your entourage over the course of your adventure, it’s usually just Clive and one other character (plus Torgal, who you can issue basic commands to via the D-pad). Jill rarely has anyone to bounce off of other than Clive because she gets benched whenever it’s time for Clive to hang out with anyone else. And, sure, Jill is probably the party member you’ll have at your side the most throughout the game, but it sure is easy to forget this when your companions always vanish for the many, many hours of side quest cutscenes.</p><p>Despite being the romantic leads in the <em>Final Fantasy </em>game where characters fuck, there’s extremely little physical intimacy of any kind between Clive and Jill. (Again, I’m trying to ignore the fact that they’re pseudo-step-siblings because the game sure does brush that idea under the rug.) In any other game in the series I would have no issue with this. But when the evil Benedikta is defined by her promiscuity, as are the many down-on-their-luck sex workers that populate the game’s various medieval towns, the fact that the heroic Clive and Jill’s love has to remain chaste and pure and largely implied despite both of them being grown adults in their 30s really sends a message.</p><p>They do get <em>one </em>major scene of physical intimacy, though.</p><p>Much later in the game, Jill will take one for the team, going Shiva mode to stall Odin’s Dominant, Barnabas. She’s defeated easily, and for a brief period she becomes his prisoner who Clive needs to rescue. (This makes her two for two when it comes to being captured by the male Dominants who serve as major arc villains, as earlier in the game she was captured by Kupka.) You chase down Barnabas’ ship and rescue Jill, Barnabas does a big Odin slash to part the sea, you lose a fight to him, and Jill helps you escape the dry sea floor before it becomes a wet sea floor again by making a big tunnel of ice. Okay, that part is cool, I will admit.</p><p>Washing up on the coast, we rejoin Clive and Jill that night as they have a heart to heart on the beach. In the nude. Because their clothes are wet. They have an emotional conversation that’s really all about Clive and how Jill worries about Clive, because that’s 90% of her character. After embracing him from behind in the nude, and finally sharing a kiss with him… she decides to share her Shiva powers with Clive so that he can unlock another branch on his skill tree.</p><p>Would it shock you to hear that, after sharing her powers, Jill is sidelined for the entire rest of the story?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*PcpAjK4YoLksPbJvoKApeQ.png" /></figure><h4>The Crystals and Cid’s big plan</h4><p>I jumped ahead to summarize what happens with Jill, but now let’s return to the ongoing story. After Jill awakens, they take a detour over to Phoenix Gate so that Clive can accept in his heart that he’s Ifrit and unlock his Limit Break meter. Along the way they run into a bunch of shit that reminds them how bad slavery is and Clive has no meaningful reactions to any of it blah blah blah moving on</p><p>When they get back to the Hideaway, Cid reveals that he’s come up with a big plan to save the world, which will become the heroes’ main goal throughout the rest of the game.</p><p>We have to destroy all the Mothercrystals.</p><p>Yes, Cid has just suddenly figured everything out. The Mothercrystals, and all of the smaller crystals mined from them, are sucking the Aether out of the planet, and that’s what’s causing the Blight. There’s no meaningful buildup to this discovery. It’s a hilariously sharp pivot in the plot. Cid lampshades this by saying that other people had probably figured this out before him, but that it was perhaps considered an inconvenient truth. Subtle!!</p><p>How will this actually help the Bearers? Who fucking knows.</p><p>This is where the main plot stops really caring about the stuff with the Bearers, and where that whole element of the story completely falls apart. For one, as far as I can find, the powers of the Bearers don’t appear to be connected to the Mothercrystals at all, as they’re separate sources of magic granted to the humans of Valisthea by the gods. So it’s not like destroying the crystals will rid the world of all magic. If anything, you would think that, in a society supposedly reliant on magic like how we’re reliant on electricity, destroying one major source of magic would only put more pressure on the others that remain. It would only make people abuse the Bearers and their powers MORE, right? Maybe even triggering conflicts where nations fight to capture each others’ Bearers? And, sure enough, Cid admits that things will probably get worse for Bearers before they get better. I’m glad he at least understands this, but he really has no long-term plan. The game is just shifting into themes of environmentalism now and you have to roll with it. We’re doing Avalanche blowing up the Mako Reactors again.</p><p>While there have been many arguments over whether or not <em>FF16 </em>is “real <em>Final Fantasy,” </em>this really does solidify the feeling that much of its story is just a fairly generic greatest hits album of the series. We’ve got the crystals<em>, </em>heroic rebels, evil empires, a Cid, a pair of supporting characters who may as well be named Biggs and Wedge, the focus on the classic summons as godlike entities like in <em>FF14, </em>the main character redemption arc of <em>FF4, </em>gameplay inspired by the job system of <em>FF5</em>, a whole lot of allusions to Ivalice stuff, and now even the environmental conflict of <em>FF7. </em>While this has always been a series that riffed on recurring images and ideas, it’s hard to point to many things that are unique to <em>FF16, </em>aside from the Dominants and, like… an obsession with slavery?</p><p>As the story continues, the question of whether or not destroying the crystals is actually helping anything never goes away. Annabella, now the Empress of Sanbreque, will retaliate after Sanbreque’s crystal is destroyed by committing genocide on the Bearers across Rosaria. (Don’t bother trying to make sense of her logic there, because the game sure as fuck didn’t.) If anything, every destroyed Mothercrystal only seems to make the state of the world WORSE. It starts to feel like a story where a bunch of ecoterrorists are going around causing massive oil spoils. Sure enough, in the end the main villain will reveal that he created the Mothercrystals to stockpile Aether, and that destroying them was a necessary step in his grand plan to use said magic, for… some reason? But don’t worry, this doesn’t actually matter, because a last second deus ex machina will fix everything for everyone.</p><p>Yes, this is what the day one reviews meant when they said all the fantasy politics mean jack shit by the end because it just turns into a big save-the-world plot.</p><p>Speaking of said villain…</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*B5sYK82TBbP9zG5pK1Arbw.jpeg" /></figure><h4><strong>The Big Bad</strong></h4><p>When Cid, Clive, and Jill (and Torgal) arrive at the heart of Sanbreque’s Mothercrystal, the first Mothercrystal they intend to destroy, they have a surprise encounter with the entity who will become the true villain of the game: Ultima. You know, in case you couldn’t tell the devs really, really like <em>Final Fantasy Tactics.</em></p><p>A lot of this info will be conveyed over the course of the three dozen hours or so that remain in the game, but for the sake of brevity, I’m just gonna summarize Ultima’s deal here.</p><p>While the stereotype is that every Japanese RPG ends up being about killing god, <em>Final Fantasy </em>tends to prefer having you fight someone who’s trying to <em>become </em>a god. Ultima, on the other hand, is the literal god of this world. At least, he’s the last of a group of immortal, immensely powerful beings (possibly aliens) who created humanity as his servants. Mankind had forgotten about him, with the only real clues to his existence lying in ancient “Magitek” structures underground (finally! the sci-fi shit everyone said TOTALLY wouldn’t be in the game!) that only the Dominants seem able to access. Now he’s back to collect on mankind’s tab.</p><p>Look. Is this cliche? Yes. Is this a total departure from the grounded tale of warring medieval nations that everyone thought they were getting into? Also yes. Is Ultima even that good of an <em>FF</em> villain? No. Do the specifics of his plan make any sense? Nope! But this is the part where I actually start to kind of like the main story. These RPG tropes became tropes for a reason: they’re fun! Maybe I’m just biased towards stories where characters are like “fuck your God, I’m choosing my own destiny” as a trans woman who grew up in Florida, surrounded by evangelicals. I won’t deny that factor.</p><p>Clive’s powers, as it turns out, are Ultima’s doing. He’s referred to as “Mythos,” who will become the perfect vessel for Ultima once he’s absorbed the powers of all the other Eikons. And so we have a central conflict for Clive: he needs to grow more powerful to continue defeating those who threaten his loved ones, but in doing so he’s potentially giving Ultima more power as well. Aside from the obvious <em>FF Tactics</em> allusions, I’m realizing now how similar this is to the plot of <em>Jujutsu Kaisen</em>. It’s very shounen. And you know what? All of my favorite parts of the game are the parts where it drops the half-baked politics and just goes full shounen. So I kinda have to like this, even if Ultima doesn’t have much going on as a character.</p><p>It probably helps that this sequence where Ultima is properly set up is so cool. First, after the crystal is destroyed, a portal suddenly opens and out crawls… this.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*loxcxesGF0MFG9m3dT-W7Q.png" /></figure><p>Then you get an sick boss fight between Clive in Ifrit mode and Ultima’s current vessel, Typhon, in some kind of surreal mindscape, with Typhon evoking the image of the crucified Lilith in <em>Evangelion. </em>An unspoiled first time player will have NO idea what’s going on.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*_8qmsgcBsDP6y_noEEM2-g.png" /></figure><p>Like! After hours of dull talk about fantasy slavery, this REALLY shook me awake!</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*777E53jgxxTZ_KAYLq0rhg.png" /></figure><p>Fuck everything else, give me more of this!!!</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/640/1*PrYjlpH98w4Z99lsByqcCw.gif" /></figure><p>Yes, I had to make my own gif to convey how goddamn cool this part is. No, I do not give a fuck that it’s just a string of quick time events. The QTEs in this game rule.</p><p>Anyway, uh, after all this Cid dies, succumbing to wounds he’d suffered from Typhon. It’s sad. I don’t have much more to say about that. Ultima tries to take an unconscious Clive as his vessel, but the all-grown-up Joshua finally steps out of the shadows and swoops in to save the day, sealing (a part of?) Ultima within himself instead. The Mothercrystal evaporates. Kupka’s forces attack the Hideaway. And we flash forward…</p><p>…another five whole years.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Dp5PkgeKeco8pZMqVD7EVg.jpeg" /></figure><h4>The timeskip, and the shape of the rest of the game</h4><p>Riding high following the sheer fun of the Typhon fight, we rejoin Clive five years later, now having taken on Cid’s role as the leader of the relocated Hideaway. To the rest of the world, Clive is known simply as Cid the Outlaw.</p><p>This timeskip is maybe one of the smartest story decisions in the game, as it allows Clive to become a different, better character. Once a lone swordsman who only cared about revenge, Clive is now a rebel leader with strong convictions. He becomes a much warmer, more compassionate character who’s looking out for the people in his care at the Hideaway, and who fights for a just cause regardless of what the rest of the world thinks of him. He’s still kind of gruff, but he’s also earnest and a bit of a doofus in an endearing way. It’s not at all the character I expected him to be going into this game, but I welcome this change nonetheless.</p><p>Also, he finally got rid of the damn Brand on his face, so every random NPC can stop demeaning him! Hooray!</p><p>The rest of the game will see him on a quest to destroy the four remaining Mothercrystals one by one, and along the way he’ll inevitably have to fight the remaining Dominants — Titan, Bahamut, and eventually Odin — for one reason or another. While this all happens, Ultima continues to watch as his scheme comes closer to fruition.</p><p>After a long string of events, the next major boss will be Kupka, Titan’s Dominant, since he now has it out for “Cid” after the death of Benedikta. It’s personal for Clive, too, since Kupka destroyed the previous Hideaway before the timeskip, forcing them to relocate. (Not that any named characters seem to have died in the massacre.) While Kupka seemed to be a bit more intelligent than his role as the big meathead would necessitate, he unfortunately becomes kind of a rageaholic here and flattens as a character. He often reminds me of Tuco from <em>Breaking Bad. </em>I don’t know if that was intentional.</p><p>Regardless of his character, the important thing is that you eventually get to fight his Titan form. And afterwards, when you think he’s defeated, he instead decides to absorb the nearby Mothercrystal core, a thing you didn’t know Dominants could do, to become an even more titanic Titan.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*xls_ZDZeHtleIxZ9S7O-uw.jpeg" /></figure><p>This part OWNS, with my favorite part being when the mountain-sized Lost Titan shoots out mile-long tendrils of earth that Ifrit chases him along while dodging incoming attacks. But this is only one small part of a knock down drag out multi-phase fight that’s full of great set pieces.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/640/1*MXpPZXqxvN1OeQuJF_6Gvw.gif" /></figure><p>While looking at this, be sure to remember that Ifrit is <em>kaiju-sized.</em></p><p>With every new Ifrit fight I was becoming more and more fond of the main story. Does the writing about the more Serious parts get that much better here? No, not really. That shit I talked about with Jill is spread throughout the rest of the game, for instance, as is the confirmation that the box Kupka was crying over contained Benedikta’s severed head. But by this point I’d seen enough fun parts that I was willing to just kind of roll my eyes at the lame stuff while going along for the ride. I had given up on this story being good Dark Fantasy and was now judging it as lighter fare.</p><p>But like I said up top, this is a game of extreme highs and lows. And unfortunately, this is where the game dramatically ramps up the frequency and density of its absolutely awful side quests.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*VjYjLLATtcD_cNSlNnPL1g.png" /></figure><h4><strong>I think someone needs to go to jail for cramming this game so full of shit ass side quests and no Yuji Naka cannot be the scapegoat</strong></h4><p>The line that’s being repeated ad nauseam about the side quests by the game’s biggest fans is that you should do them because they “help flesh out the worldbuilding and lore.”</p><p>Sure, some of the quests might flesh out the folks around the Hideaway, who I like decently enough, or they might give you a little tidbit of info about the region you’re in. I will admit that I found a few of them mildly interesting, particularly some of the ones at the very end of the game.</p><p>But most of the time the world of Valisthea, when divorced from the heightened theatrics and big battles of the main story, is so agonizingly boring that there’s barely anything there to flesh out in the first place. It’s one of the dullest medieval fantasy settings I’ve seen in years. None of the towns are particularly imaginative, and the townsfolk that populate them feel completely stock. You’re perpetually stuck in the world’s most boring and least colorful renaissance faire. This isn’t particularly GOOD worldbuilding, it’s just a LOT of worldbuilding, and those are not the same thing. Most new things I learned about the setting made me want to hear less about it.</p><p>Even when there was interesting info buried in these quests, I found myself wishing they would have just delivered some of this info via one-off dialogue scenes, rather than turning every single thing into a fucking fetch quest sandwiched between multiple slow, boringly staged, wordy cutscenes that all had to be fully voiced. It all just blurs together into miserable Cockney sludge.</p><p>At their worst, some quests feel actively harmful to my enjoyment of the world. Take, for example, a quest involving goblins in Dhalmekia. A guard reveals that he’s protecting a group of goblins that had stolen some food, as they don’t mean any harm. They aren’t native to the desert and are struggling just to survive in the unfamiliar environment, just like everyone else. Clive, who’s been slaughtering goblins without a care in the world throughout the game because they’re “beastmen” who can’t speak any discernible language, is surprised to learn that they can be communicated with. He agrees to leave them be. Quest complete!</p><p>Twenty feet away, you’ll run into some more goblins you need to kill for another quest.</p><p>The vast majority of side quests boil down to “go there, pick up an item, come back” or “go there, fight this group of enemies, come back” with no interesting twists along the way. You’ll find so many people you need to save from random bandits. Oh no, the hot spring is too hot! You go to the source of the water and there are Bombs. You kill them and go back to town, problem solved. <em>Yakuza-</em>tier side quests, these are not. Later in the game, as the state of the world worsens for plot reasons, many quests just send you to different locations that have been flooded with Aether, causing any non-magic user in the area to become “Akashic” — mindless thralls of Ultima — that need to be slain. I damn near lost it when one quest involved killing not just bandits or Akashic, but <em>Akashic bandits.</em></p><p>The counter-argument to all this, of course, is that there are plenty of other games I like with simple side quests that aren’t particularly thrilling, yet I don’t feel the need to go on a lengthy rant about those. The differences to me, when looking at something like <em>Tears of the Kingdom </em>or the original <em>Xenoblade Chronicles, </em>are in the world and objective design.</p><p>In those games, the side quests are often just excuses to get you back out into the world, where you’re likely to find many other things of interest along the way. <em>FF16’s </em>barren maps<em> </em>give you no reasons to explore and nothing else to do other than your current objectives or fighting trash mobs, so it becomes a rote process of fast traveling to the spot marked on your map, grabbing what you need, then returning, with no interesting distractions along the way. You’ll never stumble upon any treasure of particular interest or any fun secrets. You’ll never randomly stumble upon a new side quest, either, because the game directs you to every quest giver via green icons on your map. <em>FF16</em> also generally only spawns quest objectives upon accepting a quest, meaning you’ll never already have the items you need, nor will you be asked to get an item that’s available from multiple sources and allowed to acquire it how you see fit. It’s always a specific, boring errand.</p><p>Yes, these are, in fact, MMO-style quests. Even the main story constantly breaks up its major events with padding like this. I tolerate it in an MMO, where I’m really just judging it against <em>World of Warcraft</em>, but in a singleplayer game I’m gonna have higher standards. And even <em>FF14 </em>had more enjoyable quest lines than these, like the better Job storylines or Hildibrand’s detective hijinks. These just made me desperately want to get back to the parts where Ifrit does a Hadoken, or perhaps a Spirit Bomb.</p><p>Tons of <em>FF16</em> side quests also just exist to remind you of the poorly written slavery stuff, particularly now that the main story has completely stopped giving a shit about the Bearers.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*l7L_GO_Z33q-PiRTdZTu4w.png" /></figure><p>The second part of the “Rekindling the Flame” quest line takes you back to the small Rosarian village of Eastpool, which was full of bigots earlier in the game before everyone was slaughtered by… I wanna say Sanbreque? It was one of the evil empires, it doesn’t fucking matter. Anyway, later, the abandoned village is given to a group of freed slaves who need somewhere to stay.</p><p>When you return for this particular quest, your local allies bemoan the fact that the freed Bearers don’t know how to take care of themselves after a lifetime of servitude and have no motivation to do basic chores, and as such the town is beginning to fall back into ruin. Anyone who knows even a little about American history should probably be extremely uncomfortable reading that sentence, because it kinda, you know, mirrors actual arguments that were made against the abolition of slavery? In real life? It’s literally a myth slave owners made up to justify continuing to own other people as property.</p><p>Soon, Akashic threaten the village, the freed Bearers refuse to help because they think they’ll just be used as meat shields (wonder why they might assume that?), and they have to be angrily lectured at to join the fight. Afterwards, they all apologize for not taking good enough care of their new home and not having enough work ethic and promise to redouble their efforts to fix the town.</p><p>It suuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuucks</p><p>I could have written an entire lengthy article about shitty side quests in <em>FF16</em> that highlight how badly it handles its slavery plot. How about the one that reveals that some of Clive’s allies in the desert are just going to slave auctions and buying individual slaves to free them instead of, you know, fighting the system itself? Killing the slave auctioneers? Helping Bearers fight their masters? Anything! How about the quest line where a beloved pillar of the community in the main desert town is revealed to have secretly been a Bearer all along, and they turn on him so suddenly and dramatically that they start stoning him and trying to run him out of town? But then the day is saved when a couple precocious kids give a rousing speech about how he’s a model minority who’s actually really useful to have around because of all the work he does for the town. How about the quests revealing that Clive’s dad was SUCH a good guy because he wrote a letter saying he wanted to free his slaves, but the time was just never right to do so, so he didn’t. But he REALLY wanted to, you guys, honest! He was one of the good ones just like Clive, which is why Clive’s main outfit for most of the game is his dad’s old armor. How about the one where Clive’s uncle assures another noble trader that Clive’s rebel outlaws aren’t actually interested in changing any of the systems of power around Valisthea or overthrowing anyone?</p><p>I could go on and on and on about this sort of thing. I’ll spare you.</p><p>When it’s not doing shit like that, I often find that the side quests let down the dark fantasy tone of the game by being completely unwilling to end on a low emotional note. Take, for example, a quest where minor recurring ally Quinten decides to finally get together a mob to go kill the Sanbreque justice who murdered his family — and who also hunts Bearers for sport. Clive isn’t invited for no particular reason, so when it turns out the justice has a monster guarding his front door, Quinten ends up getting dozens of people killed. He gets his revenge, “cutting the man from ear to ear,” but feels empty. All those people died for nothing. And to make matters worse, while he was away, his whole town was Aether flooded and everyone turned Akashic.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*uiYtFm1gFhDhINILobwpiA.png" /></figure><p>How does this extremely dark quest end? Oh, with a handful of survivors from the town giving Quinten a pat on the back and a hokey little speech about how they’re a family, and they’re gonna build a new Lostwing somewhere else that’s gonna be even BETTER than the old Lostwing! And of COURSE Quinten still gets to be in charge even after getting all those people killed due to a lack of foresight! Quest Complete, here’s your EXP and gil!</p><p>Oh, and this quest line is named “For Great Justice.” Just to cap it all off with an All Your Base joke.</p><p>Even the backdrops to these quests do them no favors. While <em>FF16</em> is capable of being absolutely beautiful with some of the prettiest forests I’ve ever seen in a game, they decided the worsening state of the world in the back half of the game needed to be accompanied by a permanent weather change: the whole sky above every map turns an unnatural pinkish, purplish, grayish overcast. Everything will also occasionally undulate into and out of slightly more intense pink lighting as the clouds move past the sun. While this is striking at first, and it would have been acceptable as an endgame world state, it gets VERY old over the dozens of hours of fetch quests that are constantly unlocking throughout the back half of the story.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*6zh7Tj6PXkQKibGmOOGseA.png" /><figcaption>One of multiple weather conditions seen in the early game (left), vs. the only weather in the late game (right)</figcaption></figure><p>Speaking of which: the pacing at which quests unlock is horrendous. In the long portion of the story slowly building towards the confrontation with Barnabas, which takes place after this weather change, it feels like you can’t do ten minutes of the main story without unlocking another wave of side quests that will take an hour or two to complete. It’s maddening. I wanted Anthony to start skipping these so bad, but it felt like such a crapshoot whether or not anything important might happen in them that he felt he couldn’t risk skipping them.</p><p>Sure enough, when you reach the point in the main story where you can go fight Ultima, several <em>hours </em>of fetch quests unlock all at once, because the conclusions to most characters arcs’ were shoved into side quests instead of being woven into the main story.</p><p>Dear reader, I am giving you permission now: you don’t have to do all the side quests. If it’s for a character you like? Sure, do it. And similar to in <em>XIV, </em>if a quest is marked with a plus sign, that means it unlocks something. Do those. Skip the rest if you value your time, or if you don’t want to completely ruin the pacing of the main story.</p><p>The hunts are fine, though.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*QgJf574QfDr1bUz8ZJYmDQ.jpeg" /></figure><h4>The music</h4><p>This might actually be my most controversial take here. I like the soundtrack. It’s great. It’s Soken, so of course it’s great.</p><p>…But as a whole, is it his best work? I would say it isn’t.</p><p>Now, don’t get me wrong. There’s a lot to like here, from more laid back area tunes to the bombastic orchestral battle themes. In particular, the theme that plays for the Eikon battles stands out as a favorite, as does the final boss theme, which of course has to go hard as hell. I’m praying that these make it into <em>Theatrhythm</em> as DLC. But I think a lot of it feels kind of…safe? It leans VERY heavily into that “epic orchestral score” sound with blaring brass and awe-inspiring choirs and all that. The expected sound of high fantasy. And Soken’s great at that stuff! But while it all fits in the moment, very little of what’s here stands out in my memory, and I haven’t had the urge to listen to much of it outside the context of the game. Mostly, I’m left wishing this soundtrack had more stylistic variety.</p><p>I also just wish it had more rock. I’ll admit that’s extremely subjective, but well, that’s music taste for you. I usually enjoy it the most when RPG battle themes (particularly boss themes) go for orchestral rock, or full blown metal or prog or whatever, over a pure orchestral sound. I’m a sucker for tracks like <em>Xenoblade</em>’s “<a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a_YyP_zQQJs">Mechanical Rhythm</a>” or the<em> </em><a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6wWHZE14hP8"><em>Lufia 2</em> boss theme</a>. I hated <em>Octopath Traveler,</em> but I will rock the fuck out to “<a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4aKFdpJ4_bo">Decisive Battle II</a>” ALL DAY. Give me those guitars! And I don’t want to reduce this to an Uematsu comparison as if every <em>FF </em>soundtrack needs to copy him, but like, if you give enough of a shit to be reading this article at all then you’ve probably got at least half a dozen iconic, proggy boss themes by Uematsu memorized. If the soundtrack had gone in a totally different, more creative direction in terms of style, I probably wouldn’t be here complaining about a lack of electric guitars — but it didn’t, so I am.</p><p>Soken does, in fact, mix it up on a few tracks that evoke the types of sounds he’s famous for thanks to the <em>FF14 </em>Primal boss themes. The surreal fight against Typhon is set to an <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5R4EhATbCTQ">electronic track</a> that makes it feel truly otherworldly after 12 hours of orchestral music. This is not a place you’re supposed to be, or a layer of reality you’re supposed to see, and the music drives that home. Later, Titan gets a new set of <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7L_6atLQouc">industrial rock themes</a> with heavily filtered vocals that make his boss fight truly spectacular. These are moments that made me sit up, and I suspect that the intentional genre shifts were chosen to try and accomplish that. These are characters so powerful, so full of magic, that they completely break the genre of the soundtrack. I get that approach. It’s cool! But if that’s the case, I wish he would’ve done that a few more times for later, even more powerful bosses, instead of only doing it twice.</p><p>I just feel like Soken’s work on <em>FF14 </em>has way more variety. There’s nothing like “<a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ExXhr8ch8Mk">Ink Long Dry</a>” or “<a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NBIRYjP1NNM">A Long Fall</a>” or “<a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-3JbbFL-aks">What Angel Wakes Me</a>” on this soundtrack. And I think that lack of variety means that a lot of the strong orchestral work on this soundtrack doesn’t stand out as much as it should. I’d be curious to know whose choice it was to have Soken hold back like this.</p><p>The one thing that does seem to be a common critique of the soundtrack, though, is its overuse of classic <em>FF </em>motifs. Fans of <em>FF14 </em>will no doubt be used to hearing reinterpretations of The Prelude or the <em>Final Fantasy </em>main theme, but I find them a bit overused here, particularly when the emotional farewell before the final boss is set to the series’ main theme as a nostalgia play instead of any tune more directly tied to these characters. What <em>really</em> bothered me is that the main theme for Ultima is just a slowed down, minor key version of the <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EgW7cT77xUQ"><em>Final Fantasy I</em> overworld theme</a> sung by a choir. It plays any time Ultima shows up or characters start talk about ancient lore regarding gods. I give this stuff a pass in <em>FF14 </em>because the whole point of that game is for it to be a pastiche of the series in MMO form, but here it always took me out of the scene.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*lk7GzFxVNC-pEqnqR5hTmQ.jpeg" /></figure><h3>Let’s just wrap this up okay</h3><p>Sorry, but I won’t be going into nearly as much detail about the rest of the game. This is already WAAAAYYYY too long, and there’s a lot of story left, and my brain is melting. You should get the broad strokes of what I liked and didn’t like by now. Most of this shit ain’t gonna matter by the time you fight Ultima.</p><p>But, anyway… what else happens after we fight Kupka?</p><h4><strong>Chaos in Sanbreque!</strong></h4><p>We meet Prince Dion, AKA Bahamut’s Dominant, who’s the leader of Sanbreque’s dragoons. He’s cool! He’s sympathetic to Clive’s cause! He becomes allies with Joshua, who’s still off doing his own mysterious stuff because he knows things about the plot and Ultima that we don’t.</p><p>Dion is also gay. He’s in love with one of his knights, Terence.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*XmnQJIEqe0wpkR3QkERCow.png" /></figure><p>It’s cool, but Dion is woefully underused as a character in this game, and his romance even moreso. They get like two scenes together, I think? It’s very “Disney’s first ever gay character.” Similar to Clive and Jill, their love has to be chaste and understated while the bad guys are out there fuckin’ like rabbits. Maybe I should just be thankful this game didn’t try to tackle medieval homophobia with the same grace with which it tackles slavery.</p><p>Dion is suspicious because his dad, who used to be cool I guess, is now conquering the neighboring lands (despite it always, you know, being the Holy <em>Empire</em> of Sanbreque), with their capital being moved to the formerly neutral Crystalline Dominion after the destruction of their original capital’s Mothercrystal. His dad’s also had a creepy child with Annabella, who’s been busy genociding the Bearers in Rosaria for no particular reason. He even steps down and names the creepy kid the new Emperor, and that REALLY pisses Dion off. Dion gives a rousing speech in the throne room and realizes that the kid is really just another vessel for Ultima, or something, and tries to murder the kid, but his dad steps in front of the spear.</p><p>Overwhelmed by rage and grief, Dion transforms into Bahamut and starts going on a rampage. Clive finally properly reunites with Joshua and the two go Eikon mode to stop Dion, fighting tag team — until they realize they can FUSE!!!</p><p>This is the coolest boss fight in the entire game.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/639/1*D9waNybgQKL7vhSgpJ2GKA.gif" /></figure><p>Yes, that is a dragon doing an Itano Circus. Yes, they are fighting <strong>in outer space. </strong>Somehow there are still two more major bosses left in the game after this.</p><p>After the fight, Dion successfully kills his little brother, who dissolves into blue particle effects because I guess he really was just Ultima in disguise for… some reason? Okay. Annabella starts weeping over the fact that her plan to fuck royalty and have a child of the noblest possible bloodline has been thwarted twice over. Joshua, who she’d thought was dead for the last 18 years, is standing right there, but she never really seems to process this. She thinks this is all just a bad dream, and slits her own throat to end it.</p><p>If you were waiting for any more insight into the character who arguably sets the entire story in motion, hoping she would have more depth than just “selfish evil bitch mother”: nope! That’s it.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*fwqz9VJOIICdaHktiXpyaQ.jpeg" /></figure><h4>Barnabas!</h4><p>One Mothercrystal now remains, and in its way stands Barnabas. Warrior King of Waloed! Odin’s Dominant! Benedikta’s boss! And, apparently, faithful servant to Ultima?</p><p>I’m not going to waste much breath on Barnabas as a character, because there isn’t much there. All his scheming throughout the game is revealed to be the bidding of Ultima, as Barnabas is an accelerationist who wants Ultima to create a new world and turn everyone into Akashic thralls — or rather, turn everyone <em>back </em>into Akashic, as this was apparently humanity’s original nature before they unexpectedly developed free will. Clive LOVES free will and Barnabas HATES it! He also has an Oedipus complex? I don’t fucking know. He’s evil, he has a big fight with Clive to test him, he forces you to take the last Eikon skill tree and become Ultima’s perfect vessel.</p><p>With Barnabas’ story as a widely beloved mythical warrior king who betrayed his people to create an army of monsters with the help of an evil god as part of a grand scheme to create his perfect world, I do wonder if they’re trying to channel Griffith here. If that’s what they’re going for, they weren’t very good at it.</p><p>The main story has given up on politics and shifted fully into scenery-chewing villains who ponder the nature of consciousness. It’s not particularly great by<em> FF</em> standards, but I’ll take it over the bad politics.</p><h4>The grand finale!</h4><p>After doing like six more hours of side quests, we finally come to the climax! Clive, Joshua, and Dion set off to stop Ultima. Jill isn’t allowed to come. She has to wait back at home and pray for Clive’s safety, as she does for most of the last quarter of the story. It sucks. Regardless, the buildup to this is rather emotional, with everyone understanding there’s a good chance they aren’t going to come back from this mission.</p><p>This assumption is correct, as in the initial phases of their assault on Ultima’s giant floating crystal fortress Dion and Joshua both go down. And so we’re left with a grieving Clive filled with righteous fury.</p><p>It’s time to kill god.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*w1XpC1Hw4vDMbBdXmh2AwA.jpeg" /></figure><p>I do have to once again admit that I kinda like this stuff. The fight is cool, the music is cool, and there’s something cathartic to me about Clive defying the wishes of his creator and going “Fuck you, we’re choosing our own path.” If this was all the game had ever aspired to be, this big battle where the voices of all of Clive’s loved ones go “You can do it, Clive!” would be a fun finale. But, of course, in the back of my head I know how much of the preceding story has fallen to the wayside.</p><p>Clive attempts to give the game some kind of thesis by saying that Ultima actually isn’t any different from humans because he’s driven by fear. He’d escaped from his home after it was consumed by the Blight, fled to a new realm of his own design, and populated it with mindless peons to worship him as a god. He now wishes to regain control of his creations because he fears what they’re capable of with free will. A parallel is drawn with the story of the Bearers, who became oppressed when the non-magic users grew to fear them. Clive, on the other hand, no longer fears the future, or the harm mankind is capable of via free will. He readily admits that even if he stops Ultima’s plan to take away everyone’s consciousness, there will still be pain and suffering in the world, and everything won’t be magically fixed. But that’s just life.</p><p>This is quickly undermined by the ending where Clive magically fixes everything by beating Ultima, absorbing his power, and using the last of his energy to will all magic out of existence. It’s a fine moment in a bubble, and Clive’s apparent death and Jill’s tearful realization of his fate back at the Hideaway moved me at the time, but it’s a big wet fart of a resolution to the stories of the nations of Valisthea. None of that stuff mattered. All that mattered is Clive bravely declaring that having free will is Good, Actually. In the end, this is a story about slavery and about questioning the nature of power in which the solution is to just have the main character become so powerful that he can Thanos snap slavery out of existence.</p><p>But at the same time, Clive quite literally finishes the fight by punching god directly in the face as hard as he can via a button mashing QTE, so who’s to say if this is good or bad?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ArcxeiElolUt_NbPyyzJEw.png" /></figure><p>The ending also contains not one but TWO hamfisted title drops attempting to give meaning to the phrase “Final Fantasy,” as if we’ve all been waiting on pins and needles to learn what the title REALLY means for decades. First, towards the end of the battle, Ultima says “The world you seek is but a fantasy!” to which Clive retorts “The only <strong>fantasy </strong>here is yours. And we shall be its <strong>final</strong> witness!” Then, in the post-credits scene set in the far future (which still looks like medieval Europe), the story of the game has been immortalized in the form of a book literally titled <em>Final Fantasy</em>, which is now viewed as a mere fairy tale in this peaceful world without magic. It’s a game of pretend to be played by two brothers, who are probably supposed to be the reincarnations of Clive and Joshua, or at least their successors in spirit.</p><p>Said book is attributed to Joshua, who we thought died — although, again. Phoenix. There’s apparently some hints in some side quests that this might actually be Clive’s doing, which has sparked tons of heated debate over whether or not Clive survived, especially since a LOT of people seem very mad over both the ambiguity of the ending and the thought of an ending where the hero dies. Personally, I find a bittersweet ending where Clive chooses to sacrifice himself to rid the world of the curse of magic, living and dying on his own terms like he’s repeatedly said throughout the game, to be much more satisfying than one where you have to dig through a bunch of shitty optional side quests for clues that maybe Clive survived off-screen after his emotional death scene.</p><p>Either way: it’s over.</p><h4>Final takeaways</h4><p>In conclusion, Valisthea is a land of contrasts.</p><p>This game has massive, glaring flaws. The writing is frequently terrible. The gameplay is fun, but undercooked. Its handling of its female cast is about as bad as I expected. It’s paced horribly, with an absurd amount of filler. But I went into <em>Final Fantasy XVI </em>with negative hype, and came out with <em>some</em> hype, so I guess that’s a partial win?</p><p>I expected a game that was just dour and self-serious all the way through, and that’s certainly part of it, but it’s also a game full of lavishly produced action sequences that are just dumb fun, and moments of genuine warmth between the characters that are sold by the all-around excellent voice performances. Clive is not my favorite <em>FF </em>protagonist, but I came away liking him and some of his supporting cast more than I thought I would. So I can’t quite say I totally hated it, even if I hated many parts of it. Like I’ve been saying: extreme highs and lows.</p><p>If I had to go back in time and “fix” this game, I would mainly want to see two big changes:</p><ol><li>Remove the concept of the Bearers from the story wholesale. It’s unnecessary to the overarching narrative and drags everything down with how poorly it’s handled.</li><li>Cut at least half of the side quests.</li></ol><p>I do think there’s potential in this action-based style of <em>Final Fantasy</em>. There’s something here. But this first attempt is far from a home run, and far from my favorite game in the series.</p><p>I guess that’s <em>Final Fantasy </em>for you. As everyone will tell you, it’s a series that’s been many things for many people over the years. Every <em>FF</em> is someone’s favorite and someone else’s least favorite. I just hope that the next wholly new take on the series might be a bit more for me, and that I don’t have to wait until next decade to get it. In the meantime, I’ve got <em>Rebirth</em> to look forward to.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=720077d99ec3" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[We’re Always Connected: An ode to Mega Man Battle Network]]></title>
            <link>https://ponett.medium.com/were-always-connected-an-ode-to-mega-man-battle-network-66a738b99d47?source=rss-1885f92e94c5------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/66a738b99d47</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[gaming]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mega-man-battle-network]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[videogames]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[megaman]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Bobby Schroeder]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 05 May 2023 22:28:43 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-09-25T21:47:20.836Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*871tYz3lwzucAU0qKfcnGA.png" /></figure><p>(<strong>EDIT 9/25/2024: </strong>This piece is <a href="https://ponett.dog/blog/were-always-connected-an-ode-to-mega-man-battle-network.html">now mirrored on my new personal blog</a>! I’m no longer using Medium, and can’t guarantee that this site won’t mess with my formatting or randomly lose chunks of the article, as it’s done in the past.)</p><p>If you paid attention to video game discourse in the ’00s, you may remember a common narrative about <em>Mega Man.</em></p><p>The early sidescrollers had been rightfully enshrined as all-time classics, but there was also this weird reboot they did on the Game Boy Advance called <em>Mega Man Battle Network, </em>designed to cash in on the popularity of series like <em>Pokémon</em>, <em>Yu-Gi-Oh!, </em>and<em> Digimon</em> among kids<em>. </em>Apparently it was popular in Japan for a while, so they flooded the market with sequels and spinoffs. But to the rest of the world that trash just couldn’t hold a candle to the original series, which lacked a new mainline entry in the 12-year gap between 1996&#39;s <em>Mega Man 8</em> and 2008 retro throwback <em>Mega Man</em> <em>9</em>. I mean, in <em>Battle Network</em> you have to play as some stupid kid who has to go to SCHOOL?! No thank you!</p><p>Fast forward to 2023. The newly released <em>Mega Man Battle Network Legacy Collection </em>is the fastest selling <em>Mega Man</em> game in history, selling a million copies in its first two weeks. In a few more, it could be the best selling <em>Mega Man</em> game ever. Why? How? Well, the kids who grew up playing it are all like 30 years old now, so we’re able to explain it more eloquently: <em>Mega Man Battle Network </em>fucking whips ass. It’s whipped ass this whole time. We’ve been trying to tell you.</p><p>Minor annoyances aside, these games have aged remarkably well as action RPGs, and their kitschy Y2K era take on the internet only gets more and more charming with age. There’s still nothing quite like it. But in the current media landscape, it’s also left me thinking about how fascinating <em>Battle Network </em>has become as a reboot — one that lovingly homages preceding games while also throwing out tons of their core elements, favoring interesting new ideas over pure nostalgia. For both fans and nonbelievers, I’d like to try and convey what makes these games so special to me.</p><p><em>(New players: This article will spoil the twist ending of </em>Mega Man Battle Network 1. <em>Every fan of the series will tell you to skip to 2 or 3 anyway.)</em></p><h3>Why are we Battling on this Network?</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/1*Paw2PQqz5qAEc5s5UFwscg.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>Mega Man Battle Network </em>(or <em>Battle Network Rockman.EXE</em> in Japan) is an isometric action RPG released by Capcom in 2001 as part of the GBA’s Japanese launch lineup, with five sequels released in the following years. It loosely reinterpreted the original <em>Mega Man </em>series for a new generation, although it was never intended to replace it — at least one <em>Mega Man</em> sidescroller of some kind was still coming out every year at the time. For fans of the classic games, <em>Battle Network</em> imagines an alternate universe where Mega Man’s creator Dr. Thomas Light — renamed Dr. Tadashi Hikari here to fit the Japan-inspired setting— was a pioneer in cyberspace technology, rather than making sentient robots and being surprised when the guy named Bomb Man was used for more than just land development. (Overused joke, I know.)</p><p>In the far-off year of <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WppzVTcSRjA">200X</a>, <strong>everything</strong> is connected to the internet, which in this universe is a whole virtual world of its own. Everyone carries around a cell phone-like device invented by Dr. Hikari called a Personal Terminal, or PET, which houses an AI companion called a Net Navigator. Using your PET, you can “jack in” to various devices and have your NetNavi explore cyberspace. While most NPCs will have generic NetNavis, important characters have custom ones, most of which just so happen to be based on classic <em>Mega Man </em>robots. These battle-ready BonziBuddies are particularly useful due to the fact that the internet is crawling with monstrous computer viruses that can only be deleted via Net Battles.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/960/1*sgTv3IQmcUUn6LKdiuo_Kg.png" /><figcaption>Despite what this line may imply, don’t worry. MegaMan.EXE doesn’t talk like his Captain N counterpart.</figcaption></figure><p>Players take control of an 11- or 12-year-old Net Battler named Lan Hikari, grandson of Tadashi Hikari, and his NetNavi MegaMan.EXE, who was given to Lan by his super-scientist father. The two have a sort of odd couple dynamic going on. Lan is very much your average kid — he likes soccer, he puts off doing his homework, he seems to wake up late every day of his life, he can have a bit of an ego, and he leaps before he looks. (He also wears rollerblades everywhere he goes.) He’s a good kid, but he’s got a lot of growing up to do. MegaMan, on the other hand, is the more polite, responsible, and intelligent one who tries to keep Lan in line, being the angel on his shoulder. However, like his namesake, MegaMan also has a tendency to push himself extremely hard when others are in peril, disregarding his own well-being in the process and leaving Lan to watch out for him.</p><p>Despite exchanging ribbing jokes at each other’s expense, the two have an unbreakable bond that makes them sync up incredibly well in Net Battles. And, as revealed at the end of the first game, this brotherly bond runs deeper than they realize — MegaMan was really created by Lan’s father as the digital revival of Lan’s late twin brother, Hub, who died as an infant due to a rare heart condition. You would perhaps be surprised how rarely this life-changing reveal is referenced in most of the sequels.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/960/1*2b0vQ2hUAu_1UJ3DPjEBww.png" /></figure><p>Lan and Hub’s otherwise normal life is frequently interrupted by the efforts of the criminal organization World Three (or WWW for short), led by none other than the villainous Dr. Wily. True to his namesake, Wily wants revenge against the world for ignoring his research in the field of robotics in favor of his former colleague Tadashi Hikari’s work on the internet and Navis. Various colorful characters working for Wily (or other villains) will use their Navis to hack different systems connected to the internet and wreak havoc on the world, ranging in seriousness from “Lan’s house could burn down” to “Skynet is about to launch the nukes.” Lan and his friends inevitably always end up being the ones who have to stop them, because this is a game for children and it wouldn’t be as fun if they let the adults handle it.</p><p>Is the writing <em>amazing?</em> Is it even the best writing about the internet I’ve seen in a game? No. It’s no <em>Hypnospace Outlaw</em>. But the characters and world are fun and often funny, and there are strong emotional moments here and there (particularly in the back half of 3). The character writing has more substance than most generations of <em>Pokémon</em>, at the very least, and it should entertain anyone with a soft spot for similar “hobbyani” properties like <em>Yu-Gi-Oh!</em> where the fate of the world revolves around everyone playing a children’s game.</p><h3>Life on the net</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/960/1*JYwssWQWmHKem9J1TT_oSA.png" /></figure><p>In an era where we’re all chained to a small handful of corporate-owned social media sites, there really is something extremely charming about <em>MMBN’s </em>retro-futuristic vision for the internet.</p><p>Every area has an appropriately themed Geocities-ass animated gif background — an aquarium’s control systems will have rotating fish, a power plant will have crackling electricity. Real world landmarks may be represented as holograms in some towns’ corners of the internet. Your neighborhood message board is a literal notice board placed in a town square where Navis congregate. To shop online you have to find a shopkeeper Navi standing behind a retail counter. Shortcut links on your friends’ homepages function as teleporters, which means it’s sometimes quicker to get to certain parts of the net if you log in through your friend’s desktop. And if that’s not enough, you may have to take a little digital tram to get from one town’s network to another’s. Truly, I think we would be happier if we had to make our little guys ride a little virtual train to get from Twitter to YouTube instead of just refreshing the same three sites in a loop.</p><p>This charm is perhaps best illustrated by the unsung hero of the series: Mr. Prog. Mr. Progs can be found all over the internet in every game, acting as personifications of simpler programs and usually giving you an excited line or two about their given functions. They are all very stupid and I love them with all my heart.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/960/1*E4oS96g_hcELQEsdznWuFw.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/960/1*OcLXzbuk8f0DpXL6T6V1ag.png" /></figure><p>(That one screenshot you may have seen of a Mr. Prog saying “ALL VISITORS, JACK OFF IMMEDIATELY! RUN AWAAAY!” is fake, though. He says “jack <em>out.</em>” I’m sorry to be the bearer of bad news.)</p><p>There’s also one aspect of this quaint Y2K-era vision for the internet that’s aged like a fine wine. The idea that every appliance in your home would one day be connected to the internet seemed farcical in 2001, but in the Internet of Things era that’s now a reality for many. If it weren’t for its overall optimistic bent, <em>Battle Network </em>and its constant crises involving wi-fi enabled ovens and self-driving vehicles would almost come off as prescient satire of the era where smart fridges are bugging out and Teslas are constantly self-immolating in peoples’ driveways.</p><p>Truly, we live in the lamest version of the near future <em>Battle Network </em>foresaw. I mean, we don’t even have Net Battles.</p><h3>I love this battle system so goddamn much</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*I4_knSHs8Y4W48znM7ChcA.png" /></figure><p>The main draw of Battle Network is its unique combat system that blends real time action with deck building. Years before <em>Slay the Spire</em>, and even before <em>Kingdom Hearts: Chain of Memories</em> and <em>Metal Gear Acid</em>, it was <em>Battle Network</em> that was innovating in the realm of genre-mixing deck builder gameplay.</p><p>All battles take place on a 6x3 grid divided into red panels (your side) and blue panels (the enemies’ side). The speed at which MegaMan and his opponents can warp between panels means that combat can become lightning fast by the end of the story— but even as things speed up, it never becomes a game about pure reflexes. This is an action <em>RPG </em>after all. Strategy is key.</p><p>At the start of each battle, the player is presented with five random Battle Chips from their chip folder — basically a deck of 30 trading cards. Each chip comes with a letter code (A through Z), and in a given turn you can either select multiple of the same chip, or you can select different chips with the same code. <em>Battle Network 2 </em>also introduced wildcard chips marked with an asterisk code, which can be used with other types of chips, as well as the ability to mark one chip as your “regular” chip that you always draw first. (These small changes make the sequels infinitely more enjoyable than the first game.) You then enter real time combat, able to use the chips you selected in sequence while dodging enemy attacks. After about ten seconds, your custom gauge at the top of the screen will fill up and allow you to pause the action and select more chips. If necessary, you also have your chargeable Mega Buster to do some damage, but chips are the real star of the show.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/960/1*O1mzt0QHFVXEPc0q6t3m4w.png" /></figure><p>There are hundreds of different Battle Chips in each game. Some are straightforward projectile attacks. Some hit a specific pattern of panels. Some are melee weapons with varying ranges. Some will be boomerangs that circle the battlefield, bombs that are lobbed three panels ahead, or homing projectiles. Some will heal you. Some are shields that deflect enemy attacks. Some can steal enemy panels so that you can move in closer or restrict their movement. Some alter the types of panels on the field. There are shockwaves, yo-yos, time bombs, giant fans, geysers, charging sheep, cactus balls, chess piece minions, corn grenades… I could go on and on. There are even secret chip combos called Program Advances that give you various super attacks. There are seemingly endless possibilities to customize your loadout to your liking.</p><p>This freedom also means these games are begging for you to break them in fun ways. Many bosses can be totally cheesed with the right strategy. In my recent playthrough of <em>Battle Network 3, </em>the semi-randomized Style Change system granted my MegaMan a fire-themed form that made his charged shot a flamethrower and made him immune to damage from lava panels. Naturally, I paired this with a rare Battle Chip that turned the whole battlefield into lava. When it came time to fight PlantMan, who’s weak to fire damage, I simply watched as he helplessly jumped from lava panel to lava panel, losing 10% of his health and getting stunned each time, and then used my charged shot to finish him off. I barely saw any of his abilities. I used one Battle Chip. <a href="https://twitter.com/ponettplus/status/1649608392049328132">It ruled.</a></p><p>In practice, Net Battles become a delicious cycle of planning and execution. You look over the chips drawn from your carefully constructed folder, anticipate your enemies’ moves, and then try your best to execute on that plan. At the end of each battle you’re ranked based on your speed and efficiency, and when you get good at fighting and building the right folders the actual combat can end in the blink of an eye — it’s common to see groups of viruses go down in under a second or two of combat.</p><p>(The speed of battles, as well as the randomness of your Battle Chip selection, helps make the constant random encounters in these games less annoying than they would otherwise be, although there are still items and upgrades that can disable encounters as needed. Starting in 2, you can also flee from any random encounter with no penalty.)</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/960/1*9zz-JCt1x8xj071oOT4Oug.png" /></figure><p>As the series progressed, more toys were added to play around with —a Navi Customizer to tweak MegaMan’s attributes, a counter system, various transformations that change MegaMan’s Buster shot and elemental affinity, opportunities to play as other Navis, etc. This culminated in the beautiful chaos of <em>Battle Network 6</em>, in which MegaMan can turn into a <a href="https://www.mobygames.com/game/23373/mega-man-battle-network-6-cybeast-gregar/promo/group-92853/image-735298/">demonic train furry</a>. But the core of the combat remained the same throughout. For reviewers at the time, these similar annual releases led to series fatigue and ever-decreasing review scores. It’s understandable. But as a fan, it’s hard to complain about having six whole games in that style to go back to when there’s nothing else quite like it, even in this era where we’re starting to see indie spiritual successors like <em>One Step From Eden, EndCycle VS,</em> and <em>Hero.EXE.</em></p><p>While I’ve never really touched this aspect of the series, the combat also shines in multiplayer, with two players being able to pit their MegaMen against each other. Capcom used to hold official tournaments when the series was new, but in the years since there’s remained a passionate grassroots competitive scene around the world. Multiplayer should appeal to fans of fighting games who enjoy mind games and trying to read your opponent’s next three moves. With the release of the <em>Legacy Collection </em>and the addition of online play, I’m sure that scene is only going to grow bigger and bigger. (If you’re interested in the competitive scene, I would recommend <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JtWeNgtpDBo">this video by Akshon Esports</a> about its history.)</p><p>Truly, at the very least, <em>Battle Network </em>deserves respect for creating such a unique and engaging battle system. It would’ve been so easy for them to just make <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robopon_Sun,_Star,_and_Moon_Versions">a <em>Pokémon</em> clone with robots</a> and call it a day, but instead they used the trends of the time as inspiration for something not quite like anything else. It’s in conversation with those trends, rather than just copying them.</p><p>It might play nothing like the <em>Mega Man </em>you grew up with, but that doesn’t mean it isn’t one hell of a game in its own right.</p><h3><strong>Building off of the past without just rebuilding it</strong></h3><p>In the current media landscape, a reimagining as creative as <em>Battle Network </em>is rare — and successful ones are even rarer.</p><p>You just can’t change the fundamentals of a beloved series without causing widespread fandom outrage. Some will recall the exaggerated response to the blue arms and sports tape in <em>Sonic Boom, </em>a reboot that otherwise stuck much closer to its roots than <em>MMBN </em>did, and things haven’t gotten any better in the decade since. Today, right wing grifters on YouTube make bank screaming that their childhood has been ruined anytime a popular franchise makes even the slightest changes. Corporations, too, are primarily concerned with sticking with what works about their big name IPs and appealing to nostalgia, rather than taking risks on too many new ideas — even new ideas attached to established names. We’re in the age where most AAA games are getting more and more samey, and Disney is pumping out multiple near shot-for-shot live action remakes a year and making billions in the process. Familiarity is king.</p><p>As this article proves, I am not immune to nostalgia. But when pure, unfiltered nostalgia is increasingly the only thing that’s allowed to have a budget, you don’t get interesting new takes like <em>Battle Network. </em>At most, you might get an adaptation into a new medium that takes some liberties… like, say, the most recent attempt to reboot classic <em>Mega Man </em>for a new generation of kids: the 2018 animated series <em>Mega Man: Fully Charged.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Ni2qZzZEst-B-PqYhP9R8Q.jpeg" /><figcaption>I’m willing to bet most of you either forgot this existed or had never heard of it in the first place.</figcaption></figure><p>While it took some liberties with the source material, <em>Fully Charged </em>was still a show about a super advanced robot boy created by a scientist named Dr. Light who dons a blue suit of armor to become Mega Man. The surface details of his design have changed to be more “modern” (he glows like a gamer keyboard so you know it’s The Future), but his silhouette is identical. He fights rogue Robot Masters like Guts Man and Wood Man with his Mega Buster, copying their abilities along the way. He also has a sister, a dog named Rush who can transform into vehicles for him to ride around on, and a long lost brother who’s been coerced into being his rival by the main villain.</p><p>Even though it was aimed squarely at kids with no attachment to <em>Mega Man </em>beyond maybe recognizing him from <em>Smash Bros.</em>, the creators were constantly reassuring adult fans that it would mostly be the same <em>Mega Man</em> they knew and loved, just with a new coat of paint. Because that’s pretty much what you have to do these days, lest you face the wrath of your loyal fans. Trying to do something new and different is a very hard sell.</p><p>Anyway, you’ll never guess what show still faced the wrath of the loyal fans.</p><p>For the older fans they tried to court, it wasn’t the 100% faithful <em>Mega Man </em>cartoon they wanted. Many wrote it off from the start simply because the character designs were tweaked. For the Gen Alpha target audience, it was a generic kids’ superhero show that aired at like 6 a.m., designed to sell them on 8-bit platformers from when their parents were kids. (<em>Fully Charged</em> didn’t have a game — it was ostensibly advertising the <em>Legacy Collections</em>.) Aside from a few interesting story ideas that were later expanded upon in a surprisingly cool 2019 comic miniseries, the ways in which it differed from the source material were mostly just efforts to copy the formula of previous Man of Action productions like <em>Ben 10</em>. It had its moments, but any true creativity was heavily watered down in the single season we got before the show was canceled.</p><p><em>Battle Network </em>was a very different beast. Rather than merely aping as many of the nostalgic surface level elements of <em>Mega Man</em> as possible while shifting some details around, <em>Battle Network </em>broke the original <em>Mega Man</em> down to the bare essentials, then built something new from those pieces. Something that was unafraid to drastically change the premise, characters, aesthetics, and gameplay, but retained the essential spirit of the series.</p><p>Let’s identify some of those core elements that comprise that spirit.</p><h3>Remixing the spirit of Mega Man</h3><ol><li><strong>Anime and manga influence</strong></li></ol><p><em>Mega Man </em>has always drawn very liberally from its anime and manga inspirations. The classic series “borrowed” much of its identity from <em>Astro Boy, </em>as well as other series like<em> Cyborg 009</em>. For my money, <em>Mega Man X’</em>s somewhat darker storytelling learned some lessons from <em>Gundam </em>(one of the games literally revolves around a colony drop), but a <a href="https://twitter.com/Richmond_Lee/status/1551434406610366465?lang=en">certain Twitter thread</a> also makes a compelling argument about there being a ton of <em>Samurai Pizza Cats </em>in there. <em>Battle Network</em>’s dev team reportedly watched Mamoru Hosoda’s <em>Digimon Adventure: Our War Game! </em>as homework during the final months of development, and they also looked to the character design work of <em>Shaman King. </em>(Naturally, they watched <em>The Matrix, </em>too.)</p><p><strong>2. A futuristic setting</strong></p><p>As a sci-fi series, the story revolves around fictional technology. Instead of robots, this time it’s a more fantastical version of the internet, something that kids would find relatable. While misuse of this technology leads to conflict, at the end of the day this vision of the future is going to be more optimistic than pessimistic.</p><p><strong>3. Mega Man himself</strong></p><p>The hero still has to be a little blue guy with a Mega Buster and a vertical stripe on his helmet. He doesn’t have to be a robot, but the personality is important — the true Mega Man is fairly serious, helpful, and selfless to a fault, originally intended primarily as a helper before circumstances push him into becoming a hero. He’s a little bit of a dweeb, but putting that dweeb up against cooler, seemingly stronger characters and having him fight for what’s right makes him cool.</p><p>There’s also an underlying air of sadness to him in some way. Instead of being forced to fight his reprogrammed brethren and longing for a peaceful future like the original Mega Man, MegaMan.EXE has his backstory as Hub, and a sense of longing from the fact that these two brothers can’t exist in the same physical space.</p><p><strong>4. Simple but challenging gameplay</strong></p><p>The specific genre is less important here than this broad design ethos. The action-based gameplay is simple to learn but hard to master. The challenges the player is presented with can largely be overcome by learning to recognize boss patterns and figuring out the right tools for the job. This strategic element is given greater focus over pure reflexes in <em>Battle Network</em> in an attempt to appeal to a broader audience compared to the sidescrollers, which were growing more and more niche at the time.</p><p><strong>5. Mega Man gains stronger weapons from the opponents he defeats</strong></p><p>This concept is greatly expanded upon via Battle Chips. Common virus enemies can drop chips that let MegaMan replicate their attacks, while boss NetNavis drop chips that let you summon them for time-freezing super attacks. As in the original games, you generally have a lot of freedom in choosing what weapons to use where, but knowing the right weapons to use at the right time and taking advantage of rock-paper-scissors-style weaknesses is key.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/280/1*aFbvUJd73q4e0d5ay2edPg.png" /></figure><p><strong>6. Mets</strong></p><p>You gotta have some Mets. The Mettaur virus appears as the first enemy you learn how to fight in all six games. The rest of the viruses, however, all have totally new designs, unrelated to anything that came before.</p><p>And, of course…</p><p><strong>7. The music</strong></p><p>His name is <strong>Rock</strong>man, after all. The music has to rock. And while it would have been easy to remix all the iconic tunes of the past, the mainline <em>Battle Network </em>games instead feature wholly original soundtracks that can easily stand toe to toe with the rest of the franchise.</p><p>The music team consisted of Akari Kaida (<em>Mega Man &amp; Bass, Breath of Fire III, Okami</em>) on 1 and 5; Yoshino Aoki <em>(Breath of Fire III </em>and<em> IV, Final Fantasy XV) </em>on 2, 3, and 6; and recurring <em>Mega Man </em>contributor Toshihiko Horiyama (<em>Apollo Justice: Ace Attorney</em>) filling in on 4. Rather than fight with the infamous GBA sound chip by trying to make something that sounded like a live band (or, god forbid, a whole orchestra), Kaida embraced her limitations and established a more chiptune-led sound with sampled harmonies, percussion, and orchestra hits as supporting elements. This played much nicer with the tinny hardware without feeling too compromised in audio quality, and it fit the digital setting like a glove.</p><p>I’ll let a few of my favorite tracks speak for themselves:</p><p><strong>“Fire Field” — </strong>FireMan’s stage, <em>Battle Network 1</em></p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FcplRj1b2b9c%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DcplRj1b2b9c&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FcplRj1b2b9c%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/9bfeed44dc22523c088d227d464f01c8/href">https://medium.com/media/9bfeed44dc22523c088d227d464f01c8/href</a></iframe><p><strong>“Shooting Enemy” — </strong>Battle theme, <em>Battle Network 3</em></p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2F3b9D5YWqtFM%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3D3b9D5YWqtFM&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2F3b9D5YWqtFM%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/bc040fca46b208a1cacf743325c1351f/href">https://medium.com/media/bc040fca46b208a1cacf743325c1351f/href</a></iframe><p><strong>“Navi Customizer” — </strong>Navi Customizer, <em>Battle Network 5</em></p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FIj-KxIsxkdM%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DIj-KxIsxkdM&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FIj-KxIsxkdM%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/5d0b92e1bf0cc64061c58221adbb0d32/href">https://medium.com/media/5d0b92e1bf0cc64061c58221adbb0d32/href</a></iframe><p>Again, the first game was a <em>launch title </em>for the GBA, which only makes Kaida’s immediate home run even more impressive.</p><p>Many other elements that you might expect to see in a <em>Mega Man</em> game were liberally cut. A stage select with eight bosses to choose from? Out. People had been getting tired of that formula. Does Mega Man have his faithful canine companion, Rush? A version of him does technically exist… but it’s really just a random dog-themed virus. What about E-Tanks, Sniper Joes, and disappearing block puzzles? Nope. Not all of the old iconography needed to return. There needed to be ample room for new ideas, and to riff on the old material instead of just repeating it. The entire point was for the series to evolve.</p><h3>The missing link</h3><p>There <em>is </em>an extremely important missing evolutionary link between <em>Mega Man</em> and <em>Battle Network</em>, though: the cult classic 3D action adventure game <em>Mega Man Legends, </em>which had previously expanded the definition of what <em>“</em>Mega Man” could mean.</p><p>The <em>Battle Network </em>team grew out of the <em>Legends </em>team at Capcom Production Studios 2. Initial key members were fresh off work on 1999 spinoff <em>The Misadventures of Tron Bonne</em>, while others joined later after completing <em>Legends 2 </em>in 2000. To this day, the public face of the dev team is series writer Masakazu Eguchi, who got his start as the script writer for <em>Legends 2.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*MMy1FYsDlBRsy2Yj1u-wEA.png" /></figure><p>When you know about this connection, a lot of things in <em>Battle Network </em>start to make more sense. The art direction, the shift towards RPG elements, the way the Mega Buster now has multiple different attributes that can be upgraded. They even share Zenny as a currency. To me, the divide between the real world and the cyber world in <em>Battle Network</em> evokes the way the human-populated surface world of Kattelox Island contains scattered entrances to the maze-like network of underground ruins where most of the action takes place in <em>Legends 1</em>. While it’s rarely framed as such, <em>Battle Network </em>is very much an evolution of <em>Legends.</em></p><p>As a nod to their previous work, the first few <em>Battle Network </em>games are filled with overt references to <em>Legends.</em> One of Lan’s best friends, the genius rich girl Yai who skipped two grades, is an expy of a minor NPC in <em>Legends 2 </em>— and her Navi, Glyde, is based loosely on the character of the same name introduced in <em>The Misadventures of Tron Bonne</em>. Various real world locations will also feature posters and toys of <em>Legends </em>characters like the Servbots and Data (and sometimes classic <em>Mega Man</em> and <em>Mega Man X </em>characters), with the implication being that they exist as works of fiction in this universe.</p><p>Of course, the English translators didn’t always get the memo that these were references.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/959/1*nBklOwbFlNT2Tuo-G3CTZw.png" /></figure><p>And like <em>Legends, Battle Network </em>also has some really sick character designs.</p><h3>NetNavis rule</h3><p>As mentioned, a majority of Navis are based on existing <em>Mega Man </em>characters, although the character design vocabulary here is much broader than what was allowed in classic <em>Mega Man. </em>Not every character has to have the same big, stompy boots and metal undies — but at the same time, not every character has to have the streamlined bodysuit look of MegaMan.EXE, either.</p><p>Some Navis hew very close to their original series counterparts with relatively minor changes, like CutMan, AirMan, and QuickMan. The proportions may be adjusted to create a more unique silhouette, like with SkullMan, but the important details are mostly the same. Because this isn’t a hard rule, it feels like an intentional choice when it happens, usually to retain the look of a particularly iconic Robot Master.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*gGSxnsNSODr6zIkkIvqXrg.png" /></figure><p>Like, no disrespect towards the classic designs. I love ‘em. There’s an undeniable appeal to their uniform aesthetic. But I love how much the varied Navi designs are able to bring out everyone’s personality at a glance. You get them immediately. QuickMan LOOKS fast now. SkullMan LOOKS skeletal and scary. CutMan LOOKS like a cute little guy.</p><p>Then there are Navis who are recognizable without sticking quite so close to their original designs. This includes much of the main cast.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*fPpcGiH5T0Hlsk7MKAWkbQ.png" /></figure><p>ProtoMan.EXE has the color scheme and shades of his predecessor, but he looks much sleeker, and he also borrows a long ponytail and laser sword from <em>Mega Man X’s </em>Zero (who he’s arguably closer to in terms of personality). Bass.EXE has the trademark helmet fins, but his role as a wandering rogue Navi with no human operator means his bulkier armor is traded for a scarred chest and a tattered cloak. Why would a digital NetNavi need a cloak? Who cares. Rule of cool. Importantly, both retain proportions close to MegaMan’s, letting them remain something of a trio, design-wise.</p><p>A good deal of boss Navis get this treatment as well. HeatMan retains his signature yellow Zippo lighter body, but he’s given more of a crazed pyromanic look with flaming eyes and hands, and he hovers instead of having legs. PlantMan retains the general idea of his original design with a flower-shaped head and dangling vines coming off his back, but he has a more graceful design inspired by a morning glory rather than a Rafflesia. I also just love the leek-inspired gradient of stripes going down his legs.</p><p>And then there are the redesigns that take the core theme and go in a totally different direction with it.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*lQLPzNRO7zBjArhk__KHKw.png" /></figure><p>Where the original Stone Man just looked like a Guts Man reskin, StoneMan.EXE gets to be a gigantic, blocky stone golem. ToadMan goes from being a big, round bruiser to a cute little mascot character belonging to a peppy young news reporter named Ribitta. GyroMan takes a green helicopter-themed robot and turns him into a straight up Transformer with a lively yellow color scheme. And one of my personal favorites: ChargeMan takes a train-themed humanoid robot and makes him… a train.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*j8eAEsftulw7pc-sjTaNXw.png" /></figure><p>Of course, there are also a lot of Navis that have no prior counterparts whatsoever, like canonical nonbinary icon Serenade, beloved turbo nerd NumberMan, battle nurse Meddy, or the spherical PlanetMan. But none of them can compare to the sheer audacity of BowlMan, a bowling-themed samurai with arms made of bowling balls and a giant pin-shaped cannon. Like many of the classic Robot Masters, he was the result of a boss design contest, and he is truly one of the greatest character designs ever made.</p><p>To prevent this article from getting even longer, I won’t be devoting nine more paragraphs to the designs of the Navis’ human operators, but the way Navis and their human counterparts play off of each other is another fun part of the series. They might be extremely alike in demeanor and aesthetic, they might form a logical duo like a princess and her knight, or they might be total opposites. One of the simple joys of the series is encountering a supposedly innocuous NPC with a unique design and trying to guess what their Navi will be like once they’re inevitably revealed to be a Net Battler.</p><h3>Smart design choices</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/960/1*fidug5QLIaHfXazqcnYZxQ.png" /></figure><p>Amidst all this glowing praise for the series, I will admit that these games are far from perfect. Aside from the inherent repetition of six games that mostly play the same, there tends to be padding in the form of forced backtracking, the random encounters can get tiring, internet areas can get a little too maze-like in design, story objectives can sometimes be unclear, and the English scripts can be a little messy (particularly 4’s, which is riddled with constant typos and errors). But these are mostly problems that any fan of old JRPGs should be used to.</p><p>In spite of all this, I genuinely do believe that these are well-made games, particularly for their time. I’d like to highlight some random design choices that I liked upon returning to the series. While a lot of this will sound really basic to players used to the countless quality of life features seen in modern RPGs<em>, </em>for a handheld RPG from the ’00s these are a godsend:</p><ul><li>Damn near every unique object in the real world seems to have bespoke flavor text attached to it. Given some of these objects will secretly contain internet ports, this helps encourage the player to inspect everything.</li><li>Nearly every NPC in the world also gets new dialogue after every major story beat to reflect current events.</li><li>Your PET has an email inbox, which sort of serves as a clever in-universe justification for a quest log. Characters will occasionally tell you what you need to do next via email. Even more useful: pressing L at <em>any point </em>outside of battle will give you a hint about what you’re supposed to be doing.</li><li>(Later games also offer a “Humor” program that makes MegaMan crack jokes when you press L instead of giving hints.)</li><li>You can save anywhere outside of battle. That might sound like nothing, but tons of big name GBA games used save points and made up for it with some sort of “sleep mode” that turned off the screen and speakers.</li><li>There’s no need for inns or Pokémon Centers. On top of healing items and chips, MegaMan is automatically healed when you exit the internet. The ability to jack out also means that there’s no need for escape ropes or similar items — you can just press R to leave a dungeon.</li><li>Instead of treasure chests, the internet is littered with gem-shaped Mystery Data. Blue ones and locked purple ones give specific one-time rewards, but green ones spawn in random spots and give random loot anytime you return to an area. This makes both backtracking and grinding for money a bit less painful.</li></ul><p>Again, while many perceived these games as cheap, low-effort cash grabs, this couldn’t be further from the truth. Yes, they iterate on the same gameplay ideas over and over, and many art assets are recycled across the series. But so much thought and care was put into making them genuinely good action RPGs. Coming back as an adult with greater perspective on game design has only made me appreciate them in new ways.</p><h3>Growing up in the Mega Man bubble</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/713/1*yI6m0C41yRpepUU3-w1E9A.jpeg" /></figure><p>When people claim that <em>Battle Network </em>flopped in the west, it makes me feel like I grew up in an alternate universe. <em>Battle Network </em>was <strong>everywhere</strong> at the time.</p><p>Sure, it never reached <em>Pokémon</em> levels of market saturation, but is that really a fair comparison for anything? We had the games. We had like 100 episodes of the anime airing Saturday mornings on Kids WB, right after Yu-Gi-Oh! You could go into any Waldenbooks and pick up the manga at a time when manga based on video games being released in English was NOT a guarantee. There was, predictably, a trading card game. Just about every store that sold toys had a shelf full of Mattel’s action figures and roleplay weapons based on the anime. There were Hot Wheels with the characters printed on them. And, of course, we got the Tamagotchi-like physical version of the PET and its dozens and dozens of plastic Battle Chips. (I could never really get mine to work right, but it’s a cherished item in my collection nonetheless.) With such a huge marketing push, it’s no wonder it was the thing that got kids in the ’00s to pay attention to <em>Mega Man.</em></p><p>My first <em>Mega Man</em> game was <em>Mega Man Battle Network 3: White</em>. I still remember picking it up with my allowance at the Sam’s Club in my hometown of Gainesville, Florida 20 years ago. I don’t remember what exactly spurred me to buy it — living out in rural Florida, our only option for TV was a satellite package that didn’t have the major networks, so it’s not like I was watching the anime. If I had to guess, it might have been that commercial for the franchise’s 15th anniversary where the kid says “he’s the Blue Bomber, he’s the best.” (I cannot for the life of me find an upload of this.)</p><p>Regardless of what inspired me to buy it, I was instantly enthralled by this world where kids could lead double lives fighting evil on the internet, as well as the unique battle system. For a while I’d just run through ACDC Town’s internet and fight the first three virus types over and over. Maybe I’d feel spicy and start a new file from scratch. Eventually I figured out how to move new Battle Chips into my folder, as well as how to actually progress the story through the FlashMan scenario, although I never beat it — or even got close. This didn’t lessen my love for it. The thought of how much more Game there was in that cartridge—the rest of the story, a way to unlock those pesky WWW gates and get the treasure behind them, the spooky Undernet — gave it this air of mystique. It was a game that kept on giving.</p><p>Over the next few years I would scoop up every piece of <em>Mega Man</em>-related media I could get my hands on. My first classic series game was the unpopular GBA port of <em>Mega Man &amp; Bass. </em>I didn’t know how to beat any of the first set of Robot Masters, so I just replayed the first set of stages over and over on car rides. I still prefer the “lesser” GBA version of the soundtrack because of this. For Christmas in 2004, I got a PlayStation 2, and with it <em>Mega Man Anniversary Collection</em>. I started with <em>Mega Man 1</em>, because it was the first one. I chose Guts Man’s stage because I recognized him as MegaMan’s friend from <em>Battle Network.</em></p><p>It went like this:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*umgPmyj7dPFju1rAHf74rA.png" /><figcaption>(dramatic reenactment)</figcaption></figure><p>I traded the game in the next day.</p><p>In the summer of 2005, I would get into sprite comics like <em>Bob and George</em> and its many contemporaries, which got me more into the world of the classic games — although it did lead me to believe in the Cataclysm Theory, and that Ran Cossack must have been a canon <em>Mega Man </em>character. (I won’t go on these tangents.) This would get me to start editing <em>Mega Man </em>sprites, which got me into pixel art, which was my first step down the path of game development. It also got me to buy another copy of <em>Anniversary Collection. Mega Man </em>became such an object of worship to me that I came to school dressed up as Proto Man for Halloween in 6th grade, complete with a cylindrical homemade Proto Buster my mom helped me make, although I had to make due with no helmet and a blue scarf due to a lack of materials.</p><p>Then, in the fall of 2006, a few months into 7th grade, my paternal grandmother died. I had never met this woman due to the fact that she hated my mother, and everything I’d ever heard about her was bad. Suddenly, her death changed everything for my family, and we had to move from my lifelong home in rural Florida to her house in Greenwich, Connecticut to take care of affairs for a year. It was a hard year for me. I had to leave behind my friends — friends who I had bonded with in part over our shared love of <em>Mega Man</em> and <em>Sonic, </em>who I’d inserted into my sprite comics via edited <em>Mega Man</em> sprites<em>. </em>I would still talk to my best friend over the phone, but making new ones was hard for a kid as shy as me. For Christmas that year, I received a copy of <em>Battle Network 6, </em>the final game in the series. In it, Lan, too, had to move away from his hometown, now distant from the friends he had known for five games, and start going to a new school where everything worked a little differently. It resonated. It felt like the stars had aligned.</p><p>MegaMan’s arc in 6 was also relatable, as that’s the one where the internet makes something awaken inside him and he becomes a furry.</p><p>The ’00s were a magical time to become a <em>Mega Man</em> fan. We had multiple series continuing at the same time — alongside <em>Battle Network</em> and its spinoffs, we had the final few entries of <em>Mega Man X, </em>its sequel series <em>Mega Man Zero, </em>all sorts of ports and remakes, and eventually a pair of tokusatsu-flavored DS era successors: the MetroidVania-ish <em>Mega Man ZX, </em>following up on <em>Zero</em>, and the space-themed <em>Mega Man Star Force,</em> set in <em>Battle Network’</em>s future. As a fan, it was a dream come true. You were never more than a few months away from a new Mega Man game in some form or antother, and most (if not all) of them were good. Truly, we didn’t know how lucky we were.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/910/1*YosI76TOcNIOpVLXI9GFVg.png" /><figcaption>Most (but not all) of the Mega Man games released between 2000 and 2009.</figcaption></figure><p>But… it’s understandable why things dried up as we closed out that decade. While I love and cherish a majority of the dozens of games that were released for the franchise in the ’00s, the market was flooded with <em>Mega Man. </em>Overwhelmed outsiders took one look and assumed that Capcom was just shoveling out crap, coasting off of the fame of the brand from the 8- and 16-bit eras. The GBA section of any game store was invariably filled with like 20 different <em>Mega Man</em> games, most of them baring the <em>Battle Network</em> name. I mean, critics and casual audiences were already growing tired of the iterative classic and <em>X </em>series games in the ’90s, which was why <em>Battle Network </em>was created to freshen things up for a new generation in the first place, and now the fresh revival also had its own mountain of games. For many, it was easier to simply ignore all of it instead of trying to figure out how much of it was any good.</p><p>I’ll admit: I didn’t return to <em>Battle Network</em> for years, despite my love of the series. I continued to revisit most of the other <em>Mega Man </em>games on and off, but not <em>Battle Network — </em>or its successor <em>Star Force</em>, for that matter, which lasted into high school for me. Unlike most of the sidescrollers, I can’t beat a <em>Battle Network </em>game in an afternoon, so that probably didn’t help. But I guess on some level I’d also just had my fill after nine games based around the same format. And so had the rest of the world, it seemed. Declining sales led to the cancellation of <em>Star Force 4,</em> robbing the world of its <a href="https://antifandom.com/megaman/wiki/Mega_Man_Star_Force_4">sick as hell premise</a>. The final release— a mildly enhanced DS port of <em>Battle Network 1 </em>with some <em>Star Force </em>content added — never officially left Japan, cementing the image of a failed experiment in the eyes of many onlookers.</p><p>But now, here we are, over two decades after the series began. The <em>Legacy Collection </em>is out. It’s breaking sales records for <em>Mega Man</em> as a whole. We’re seeing an outpouring of love for the series around the world. We even got a heartwarming new <a href="https://www.capcom-games.com/megaman/exe/en-us/comics/takamisaki-new/">epilogue chapter</a> for the manga, showing us how Lan and friends are doing as adults. After years of uncertainty, the EXE Sweep is here. And with it, I’ve finally made time to play my first Mega Man game —<em> Mega Man Battle Network 3</em> — through to the end.</p><p>Absence really does make the heart grow fonder.</p><p>…Now let’s get those <em>Legends</em> and <em>Star Force</em> collections.</p><h3>Epilogue: So… which one should you start with?</h3><p>If you’ve somehow made it to the end of this long article as a series newcomer and wanna know where to start, what’s the verdict? And which versions should you play?</p><ul><li><strong><em>Battle Network 1?</em> </strong>Nope. While it laid the groundwork for the series, the first one’s super clunky in ways that its sequels ironed out.</li><li><strong><em>Battle Network 2?</em> </strong>Maybe the easiest place to start, with big improvements over 1. The biggest caveat here is just that 2<em> </em>and its insane script are probably the main reason why the <em>Legacy Collection </em>opens with a disclaimer about cultural insensitivity. Just… brace yourself for a few parts of the story.</li><li><strong><em>Battle Network 3? </em></strong>One of my favorites, but it was also meant to be the end of the series, which is reflected by both its story and its difficulty spikes. Some annoying sections could deter first time players, but it’s well worth playing. (Recommended version: <em>Blue</em>.)</li><li><strong><em>Battle Network 4?</em> </strong>No. Despite being the best seller, <em>BN4</em> is the low point of the series. It’s bad. Skip it. (If you HAVE to play it? <em>Red Sun, I guess.)</em></li><li><strong><em>Battle Network 5?</em> </strong>A good one, but also a departure in terms of gameplay, with difficult tactical missions where you take control of an area using multiple Navis. Probably not a good place to start. (<em>Team Colonel </em>is considered “more canon” for focusing on new characters who are important in 6, but I like the Navis in <em>Team ProtoMan </em>better. Maybe look up the version exclusives yourself.)</li><li><strong><em>Battle Network 6?</em> </strong>Possibly the most fun, with tons of freedom to mess around with its cool transformations. But it’s also the finale, wrapping up the story while also having Lan move to a new town for a change of pace. If you really only have time to play one of these games, or if you mainly want to check out the multiplayer, 6 might be the one. Otherwise, I think you’ll get more out of it if you play some of the others first. (I like <em>Cybeast Gregar, </em>but like with 5, you might wanna look up the version exclusive transformations and Navis to see which version’s you like better.)</li></ul><p>Happy virus busting.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/959/1*xkAUdW6cgc3lzeIp5kO4mw.png" /></figure><p><em>Thank you for reading another lengthy, meandering article about a piece of children’s media from me. We are now entering the shameless plug zone, where I say that if you like my thoughts on game design and want to play an RPG of my own, you can now buy </em><strong>Super Lesbian Animal RPG</strong><em> for Windows PCs on </em><a href="https://store.steampowered.com/app/2124380/Super_Lesbian_Animal_RPG/"><em>Steam</em></a><em> or </em><a href="https://ponett.itch.io/slarpg"><em>itch.io</em></a><em>. One of the main characters is, in fact, named after a supporting character from </em>Battle Network.<em> If that doesn’t prove my love for the series then I don’t know what will.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=66a738b99d47" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Sonic Frontiers: Sonic’s back, baby!!!]]></title>
            <link>https://ponett.medium.com/sonic-frontiers-sonics-back-baby-f0b7121d0f69?source=rss-1885f92e94c5------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f0b7121d0f69</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[videogames]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[criticism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[sonic-frontiers]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[sonic-the-hedgehog]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Bobby Schroeder]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 30 Nov 2022 22:51:31 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-09-25T21:47:52.836Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/1*3SgfKAtgjvJMpxrklUwpuw.png" /></figure><p>(<strong>EDIT 9/25/2024: </strong>This piece is <a href="https://ponett.dog/blog/sonic-frontiers-sonics-back-baby.html">now mirrored on my new personal blog</a>! I’m no longer using Medium, and can’t guarantee that this site won’t mess with my formatting or randomly lose chunks of the article, as it’s done in the past.)</p><p>It‘s a miracle that <em>Sonic Frontiers </em>is as good as it is.</p><p>I don’t mean that I’m shocked a 3D <em>Sonic</em> game is fun. I like 3D <em>Sonic</em> games. As readers of my blog <a href="https://thankskenpenders.tumblr.com/">Thanks Ken Penders</a> know, I’m a huge fan of the franchise, even if I’m not blind to its many flaws.</p><p>No, the miracle here is that this open world<em> Sonic</em> game could have so easily been the most cynical thing they’ve ever made. An attempt to strip<em> Sonic</em> of its identity in favor of making another bland, trend-chasing, design by committee AAA game after a decade with no clear direction. I get that the generic aesthetics of the open world seem to signal this. In June, my best case scenario was that the game would be boring, but that it might at least have some good dialogue thanks to longtime <em>Sonic</em> comic writer Ian Flynn, who I was ecstatic to see writing a mainline game.</p><p>Instead, <em>Frontiers</em> has more heart than any 3D <em>Sonic</em> game in years, embracing so much of what makes the series fun and amping it up to new levels. It’s absolutely not without its flaws, but as a lifelong fan of the series I’ve never been more excited about its future than I am now.</p><p>Sonic’s back. He’s really, really back.</p><p><em>(Note: I played </em>Sonic Frontiers <em>on PC. Experiences with other versions may differ. Also, this article will contain </em><strong><em>full spoilers.</em></strong><em> I’ll give a warning before discussing the big ones.)</em></p><h3>Sonic’s back, but give him a minute to warm up first</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*EJOgqKYiTmbI7StngXDZWw.jpeg" /></figure><p>As with the marketing campaign, <em>Sonic Frontiers </em>doesn’t make the strongest first impressions. After a couple cutscenes, the game drops you into the first Cyber Space level (yet another version of Green Hill), where the only really <em>new</em> thing is Sonic’s tweaked control physics.</p><p>Jump and homing attack are separate buttons again. The boost’s speed is nerfed a bit, and it no longer damages enemies — no more “boost to win” here. But Sonic also feels like he stops on a dime more easily than you’d expect. In my 20 hours with the game, I never did quite figure out what determined whether or not Sonic would stop dead in his tracks if I let go of the stick while boosting. This stopping power makes more sense when something catches your eye in the open world, but while trying to maintain flow in a linear stage it can feel weird. Once I got used to the changes, though, controlling Sonic felt natural to me, and I never encountered any major bugs.</p><p>I’ve never been one to get so granular about the movement physics in 3D <em>Sonic</em>, so I can’t speak for people who think <em>Frontiers </em>feels bad to play. I think this is just one of many areas where what’s “right” for <em>Sonic</em> will be different for everyone. Apparently Sonic Team feels the same, because this time they let players decide how Sonic controls through a bunch of sliders in the options menu (and two presets up front). This was a great idea. Some have been enjoying the game more after cranking everything to the max, but I personally thought Sonic felt less slippery if I turned his starting speed <em>down, </em>making him briefly build up to a run sort of like in the Genesis games. This made the occasional bits of more precise platforming a breeze for me.</p><p>After finishing the level, you’re taken to the tutorial area of the first island, where you’re bombarded with blunt tutorial popups that seem like they were added in response to confused focus testers. With these initial hurdles out of the way, though, the real fun can begin.</p><h3><strong>The joys of the Open Zone</strong></h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*gh7TYrxFRBhqdLfwZJ6B6g.jpeg" /></figure><p>I think I deserve a medal for going this long before namedropping <em>Breath of the Wild.</em></p><p>I know people are getting sick of every open world game getting compared to <em>BotW</em>, but like, come on. This is a game where the hero is dropped into a natural landscape dotted with the mysterious ruins of a long-dead kingdom as moody piano music plays in the background. You solve puzzles. You climb towers. You fight four colossal mechanical bosses. You collect funny little guys who are hiding all over the map and give them back to their elder to increase your carrying capacity. Come <em>on.</em></p><p>That being said, while <em>Frontiers </em>is clearly aping the vibes of <em>BotW, </em>it isn’t mimicking the gameplay or structure. It can be hard to understand until you’ve played it. If you’ve seen one big ol’ map littered with icons, you’ve seem them all, right? But no. <em>Frontiers </em>is very much an action-platformer through and through, and it’s a delight to play because of it.</p><p>Each of the “five” (really four) islands Sonic explores is a big, open-ended playground of smaller platforming challenges to complete. Upon getting to the mainland of the first island, I quickly fell into a rhythm where I’d gleefully zip around the map from one small objective to another. People made fun of all the rails in the sky and how poorly they seem to be integrated into the world, which is fair, but they sure do catch your eye. You’ll spot a collectible at the end of a series of floating rails and set off to figure out how to get up there. You’ll uncover a hidden spring which launches you towards a set of platforms you couldn’t previously reach, and after getting through those a boost pad will point you in the direction of three more mini-challenges. I was in a constant loop of “ooh, what’s that over there?” because you’re never more than a few seconds away from more fun. And Sonic’s natural speed without the need for a car or a horse or whatever makes it a joy to traverse the map looking for these little challenges.</p><p>Even the obligatory Ubisoft tower climbs ended up being more fun than I expected because there were multiple ways to tackle them. For more observant players there are always some balloons to homing attack or rails to boost up just off the beaten path, and the new wall climbing sections can be done significantly faster if you boost into the wall instead of grabbing on normally.</p><p>I had my doubts, but this experiment worked. It’s pretty much free of the usual open world filler. You aren’t grinding for crafting materials, raiding copy and pasted enemy bases to slowly claim territory on the map, doing tailing missions, or being asked to defeat 20 of a specific enemy for an NPC. Even the generic <em>Zelda </em>puzzles you do to fill out the map (which I’ve made fun of previously) don’t feel like too much of a chore, being a short breather before you zip off towards more action. It’s just a Big Sonic Game where you do Cool Sonic Shit for 20 hours. As you read my nitpicks below, just know that none of it drowned out that core fun.</p><h3><strong>The Economy (of collectibles)</strong></h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*DjMZiuRsf0WplrKAZqG0eA.jpeg" /></figure><p>So yeah, it’s a good thing I found the core gameplay so innately pleasing, because the structure around it could use some work.</p><p><em>Sonic Frontiers</em> incentivizes exploration via collectibles. The game thankfully knows you’re going to be running around at Sonic speeds and accommodates this, placing common items out in the open for you to grab without stopping and bluntly signposting other points of interest instead of making you methodically comb the map.</p><p>The thing is, the game doesn’t require (or even <em>reward</em>) completionism, as there are multiple ways to get just about every type of item, and many,<em> many</em> more than you’ll need of everything. On the one hand, this means you’re largely free to run around and do what you want, safe in knowing that you’ll have the items needed to progress before long if you just keep doing Sonic Shit. On the other… well, there’s nothing to do with the extra items that continue to litter the UI even after their purpose has been fulfilled.</p><p>The worst offender is the leveling system. Sonic gains “skill pieces” (EXP) from defeating enemies and doing midair tricks, which can be used to unlock moves on a skill tree. I’m fine with this, as it allows the game to slowly expand the combat rather than overwhelming you up front, and it lacks typical filler unlocks like +5% damage to one specific attack or whatever. The problem is that I maxed out the skill tree about halfway through the game, and after that kept racking up over 150 levels that couldn’t be spent on anything. Why do you even keep gaining EXP at that point? Who knows!</p><p>Sonic also has four attributes to level up. Ring capacity and max speed can be increased for every 20 Koco you find, but each upgrade is so negligible (+6 max rings per rank!) and it takes so long to redeem them one at a time with the Elder Koco that I quickly gave up. You also get a free speed boost at max rings, so raising the cap beyond 400 seems counterproductive. The Hermit Koco, meanwhile, redeems the items that bolster your attack and defense. Again, about halfway through the game my attack was at level 67 of 99 and I already felt overpowered, so I just stopped upgrading it and never looked back. I probably had more fun than the people who maxed out their stats and accidentally Saitama’d the penultimate boss.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*gHnv-5BGZJjR_LiTj5bMvA.jpeg" /></figure><p>Then there’s also Big’s fishing minigame (side note: god bless), in which you can earn basically every type of collectible — as well as audio logs from Eggman, for some reason. It’s almost comical how easy it becomes to circumvent the loop of fighting minibosses to get Portal Gears, using Portal Gears to unlock Cyber Space levels, completing Cyber Space level challenges to earn Vault Keys, and using Vault Keys to claim Chaos Emeralds, all by just… fishing. Especially since you’ll have hundreds upon hundreds of the purple coins needed to go fishing after just a couple of those meteor shower events. The speedrun community is going to need a “no fishing” category.</p><p>But, again, I’m glad that the game let me play the way I wanted to play, rather than forcing me to grind for collectibles. I did all the Cyber Space levels not because I needed to, but because I thought they were fun. I just wish there was <em>anything </em>you could do with all those excess items. Even a simple shop where you could unlock more shoes or concept art or something would go a long way. (Or, you know… a Chao Garden, which served this purpose in the <em>Adventure</em> games.) Or maybe they’ll be useful when those newly announced free DLCs adding <a href="https://twitter.com/sonic_hedgehog/status/1598000246772023296">a bunch of new content</a> drop.</p><h3><strong>Sights and sounds</strong></h3><p>While <em>Frontiers</em> manages to translate many aspects of the Sonic series into this new format wonderfully, the main letdown for me is the visuals.</p><p>Now, that’s not to say the game isn’t pretty. Because it absolutely is. The game is lit beautifully, and certain biomes and vistas within each island can be particularly impressive. There were a few points where I had to just stop and take a screenshot:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Vte2SM8y-GsEPG8vv6Eiow.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*B0mt_YwLw7KjJ3yJWjEgXw.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Le6D29W94ATXp9q4eOtplg.jpeg" /></figure><p>It’s just, you know… for the most part, it looks like dozens of other open world games. You’ve seen grassy plains and deserts and mountains like this before. You’ve seen these mysterious ruins. There’s nothing wrong with this look, but there’s nothing distinctly <em>Sonic</em> about any of it, either.</p><p>And sure, what “feels like <em>Sonic</em>” is another one of those things that fans will never universally agree on. I’m admittedly biased, because the hyper-stylized technicolor scenery of games like <em>Kirby</em> and 2D <em>Sonic </em>are some of my main artistic influences. I like when things are the wrong colors and when there’s shapes everywhere. They could’ve at least slapped some geometric patterns on that dirt or something. But it’s not even that the game shouldn’t have a “realistic” art style, because <em>Sonic</em> has pulled that off before! Previous entries would at least incorporate loops and corkscrews into the terrain. They’d also feature bustling cities, sprawling Eggman fortresses, and other environments that have been present in the series since the start. These open zones use just three nature biomes littered with abandoned ruins in the same art style for 20 hours, with only the Cyber Space levels to mix it up.</p><p>(For the record, I also completely, wholeheartedly reject the notion that the art direction needed to ditch the stylized environments and bright colors just because the story is more serious. That’s not how visual storytelling mediums work.)</p><p>But the real killer, if you ask me, is just how often it’s overcast or rainy. Worst off is the third island, Chaos Island, which is set atop a volcanic mountain range above the clouds. With a clear sky and a good view, this can be pretty striking! The way that white sea of clouds contrasts against the deep blue sky and the volcanic sands…</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*w2FoRtRNQ6VhZVanmksCQw.jpeg" /></figure><p>But most of the time it’s foggy, and with surprisingly little lava around it just becomes the fucking grey level.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*-Ab3Sk3g84YiiroPKav9bQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>This and the frequency of forced 2D sections on this island made it the weakest of the bunch for me. This foggy greyscale look could be an interesting tone setter for a little while, but for four or five hours? Nah. It gets boring.</p><p>I could also say a lot of the same things about the music for the open zones. One of the main complaints about <em>Breath of the Wild</em> was its sparse use of music compared to past <em>Zelda</em> games, and I think that <em>Frontiers</em> proves pretty clearly why Nintendo did it that way. It’s because constant moody, subdued piano and strings gets fuckin’ old after a while. These parts of the soundtrack are competently made, and they fit the tone of the story and setting, sure. But they lack personality, and even the wise decision to update each area theme as you progress through the story only does so much to keep it from all blending together. <em>BotW</em>, on the other hand, uses its often minimalist music to highlight specific moments. It feels special when that lowkey piano rendition of the main <em>Zelda</em> theme starts up as you’re galloping across Hyrule at night. That still sticks with me almost six years later, as do decade-old memories of C418&#39;s music starting up at <em>just</em> the right moment in <em>Minecraft</em>. But I couldn’t for the life of me tell you what any variation of the Chaos Island theme sounds like after having literally booted the game up to take the above screenshots half an hour before writing this sentence.</p><p>There are certainly areas where the music shines, though. For instance…</p><h3><strong>Cyber Space</strong></h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*i-jLhpteSUvOSnndpXaVdw.jpeg" /></figure><p>Everything about the Cyber Space levels in Frontiers screams “backup plan.” Ironically, they’re actually the weaker part of the game.</p><p>I can see the gears turning in the devs’ heads. They weren’t sure if people would like the open zones, so they threw in some regular levels and cautiously framed the open zones as simply big level select hubs. But they also couldn’t divert too much effort away from those massive open areas, so they decided to recycle level layouts from <em>Unleashed, Generations, </em>and<em> Adventure 2 </em>with glitched-out <em>Generations </em>visuals and frame it as a jumbled-up version of Sonic’s memories. This wouldn’t sting so bad if the preceding game hadn’t already reused half of these themes<em>, </em>or if <em>Frontiers </em>at least used more than the same four level themes throughout the game. You’ve seen every theme by the end of the first island. The glitch aesthetic can be cool, particularly the impossible freeways that stretch out in every direction in the city-themed levels, but why not take it further? Why not at least mash the assets from different levels together? Or recolor them? Anything!</p><p>Recycling aside, though, the Cyber Space stuff is mostly pretty decent. My main complaint with <em>Forces, </em>aside from the story being, in a word, bad, was that every level ended just as you were starting to have fun. The Cyber Space levels are still short here, but the framing as a side activity on top of the bountiful open world makes me enjoy them way more. The most obvious comparison here is the shrines in <em>Breath of the Wild, </em>but I would also compare them to the linear sub-areas you visit via pipe in <em>Super Mario Odyssey. </em>(In general, <em>Odyssey’</em>s kingdoms are a much better point of comparison for the structure of the Starfall Islands than any true open world.)</p><p>The gentle nudge towards trying to S-rank every Cyber Space level also makes them way more fun. Aside from the already infamous 1–2, the time attack limits are generally doable, and the levels are so short that they’re relatively painless to restart. I enjoyed figuring out which paths to take and how best to chain together my boosts, homing attacks, double jumps, air boosts, stomps, and more to maintain my flow. I didn’t do it for <em>every </em>level, but the fact that I went out of my way to get any of them here despite not usually caring about S-ranks says something.</p><p>Replaying the levels also gives you the chance to appreciate the music. While the visuals and stage layouts are recycled, Tomoya Ohtani and co. used the digital setting as an excuse to try out a wide variety of electronic music. Ohtani’s always loved his Amen breaks, so perhaps this was inevitable. Everything from EDM to drum &amp; bass to techno to future bass to dubstep to trance is here (there’s a LOT of trance actually lol) and it’s all so, so good. Not only that, but <em>every single level</em> has its own bespoke track. They did NOT need to do that! Like, just. <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TL80HDK3DjY">Listen to this</a>. It speaks for itself. I love it. Where the orchestral open zone themes didn’t quite hit for me, the Cyber Space themes prove that any genre can be “<em>Sonic </em>music” so long as it has the right energy.</p><p>But, okay! Enough beating around the bush. I know what a lot of you really came here for. In <em>Sonic</em> circles I’m known primarily for writing about the American comics ad nauseam, and guess what? They finally got that one guy who writes for those to write a Sonic game. How’d he do?</p><h3><strong>The story!!! (spoilers start here)</strong></h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*moi993BmjjGZYifTS8mH6w.jpeg" /></figure><p>Prior to release, there were many debates about how much impact Ian Flynn would actually have on the story. His work as both lead writer on Archie <em>Sonic</em> throughout its final decade and the original writer of IDW’s successor series is widely beloved, but in the game industry how much input a script writer actually has varies wildly. I can now confidently say that, while Sonic Team may have provided the broad strokes for Ian, his creative voice is absolutely there, clear as day. And thanks to him this is the best <em>Sonic</em> story we’ve had in like 20 fucking years.</p><p>Depending on who you ask, that’s either a bold claim or damning <em>Frontiers </em>with faint praise. But to me this script’s a breath of fresh air. To be back to this mode of storytelling where the characters can sincerely engage with the story they’re in, where there can be mysteries with interesting payoffs, where there can be humor without constant terrible zingers and low-tier Canadian cartoon level jokes. I am so happy to be here. And to be here with an English script that sounds natural, with voice actors who are allowed to display some emotional range without odd timing issues. I know the bar is low, but this has been a struggle for years!</p><p>And the characters! Oh my god! The characterization feels spot on for the first time in years. When I saw Sonic and Knuckles’ first scene together, with Sonic being all smug about Knuckles needing to be rescued and Knuckles begrudgingly thanking him while also trying to puff himself up, I was ecstatic. Ian just gets these characters, and he’s eager to do them justice.</p><p>I was also pleasantly surprised by how <em>much </em>story there is in Frontiers. With talk of Sonic’s friends being trapped in Cyber Space and needing their memories restored, I was worried that Amy, Knuckles, and Tails would barely get to do anything. But while you do collect “Memory Tokens,” nobody has amnesia, and the first thing you do on an island is rescue the friend stuck there. After that they’re still stuck as holograms, but they’re able to freely roam the islands and participate in the story.</p><p>Personally, with Ian writing, I would’ve liked to see a few more characters show up outside of these “safe” ones. But the tight focus means that each island gets to showcase one ally’s story, and it’s kind of shocking what Ian got to do here: Sonic’s friends call back to past events in an attempt to reframe them as key points in cohesive character arcs.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/755/1*RZlu9rSAesFHp2WsSWeR1w.jpeg" /></figure><p>For example, in perhaps the most meta moment of the story, Tails discusses his past triumphs and failures and his nature as the sidekick with Sonic — the time he saved Station Square in <em>Sonic Adventure, </em>the time he saved Sonic from the Deadly Six in <em>Lost World, </em>and, of course, the time he completely shut down when confronted by Chaos 0 in <em>Forces, </em>a moment that’s never sat right with fans. “I’m wildly inconsistent,” Tails surmises at his lowest point here. This might be on-the nose, and it ALMOST crossed the line of being too much of a canonical <em>Forces</em> fix-it fic for me, but it’s saved by Sonic’s thesis for Tails as a character: that these highs and lows, these moments of bravery and moments where he’s overwhelmed and needs help from his friends, are all just part of growing up. And that even if he’s not perfect, Tails has come a long way in the time they’ve known each other, and Sonic’s proud of his little bro.</p><p>This. This is why people wanted Ian to write a <em>Sonic </em>game.</p><p>Interestingly, the use of continuity in <em>Frontiers </em>feels like how continuity tends to be treated in long-running comic books — and I don’t just mean because we’ve got a new writer coming in to fix shit the previous ones fucked up, like Ian did at Archie. I mean it’s written to theoretically be digestible for a newcomer (“every issue is someone’s first”), but it still references past events heavily. For returning fans, this adds extra layers to the story. For newcomers, hopefully they can use context clues to figure out the important stuff. And if they can’t, well… there’s a wiki? It’s a risky move for a game aiming for a broad audience like this, but if there’s one game series known for having an obsessive fanbase that already has all the old games memorized, it’s <em>Sonic.</em></p><p>Beyond just touching on the past, Frontiers also treads new ground by looking to the future for each of these characters. Amy wants to see more of the world and share her belief in the power of love, even if it means being away from Sonic. Knuckles wants to get off of Angel Island more instead of accepting his lonely fate as the last echidna. And Tails wants to continue to grow more independent from Sonic. It feels like they’re setting up future stories here, if not in the games then at least in the IDW comics, and I’m super curious to see what comes of this.</p><p>Many will probably look at these stories and laugh, wondering why <em>Sonic </em>should have any drama at all. As someone who grew up with the <em>Adventure</em> games and the Archie comics, the reason is simple: the drama’s part of the charm. It can be taken too far (sorry zoomers, I am not about to defend the writing in <em>Sonic ‘06</em>), but I think the fact that there <em>is </em>something to latch onto on a dramatic level with the <em>Sonic </em>cast is one of the main things that separates the series from, say, <em>Mario. </em>The fact that they can have feelings and internal conflicts, that they can have stories where they learn and grow, where they can go through real hardships and come out the other side. That they can be more than sterile corporate mascot characters, even if that’s what they’re often treated as. Kids want to take the stories they love seriously, to get emotionally invested, and <em>Sonic</em> is a franchise that often rewards that desire instead of holding you at arm’s length. There’s a whole generation that still has a strong emotional attachment to Shadow because of his arc in <em>Adventure 2, </em>even if conventional wisdom might call the black and red Sonic lookalike with a complicated tragic backstory “tryhard” or “cringe.” It’s over-the-top, yes, but it’s <em>earnest. </em>And now that earnestness is finally back in full force.</p><p>Really, the only character in the group who feels a little weaker here is Amy, but I’d personally suspect that has more to do with Sega not knowing what to do with the character than Ian’s writing. Where Knuckles feels like a return to form after like 20 years of being such a nothing character in the mainline games, Amy’s depiction here seems to be an attempt to make sense of the character in this age where Sega wants her crush on Sonic to be downplayed.</p><p>There’s absolutely a lot of good here. This might be Cindy Robinson’s best performance as Amy, even if she’s never gonna sound like a 12-year-old. There are shades of <em>Boom</em>, but the <em>Adventure </em>influence is also strong, with Amy returning to her role as the kindhearted girl who always wants to look out for the little guys (the Flickies in <em>Adventure</em>, the Koco here) even when it’s not the most important thing to be prioritizing. But the fiery side of her personality is more tempered here than I’d like, especially with her being unable to smash robots with a mallet in hologram form. Toning down her one-sided obsession with Sonic is a move I like, but she can still get riled up or be quirky or even be a little abrasive. People love abrasive girls these days. Just look at Power. But, again, it’s hard to say how much of this is Sonic Team meddling, or how much her manic energy just couldn’t come out given the chiller tone they wanted for the whole story.</p><p>Sonic himself is great, though, with a solid performance as usual from Roger Craig Smith (even if the deeper tone of voice he slips into sometimes takes some getting used to). Like everyone else, he’s written much more earnestly, but he still has his moments of impatience and smartassery. If I have one small complaint here, it’s just that “amateur anthropologist” isn’t necessarily my favorite mode for Sonic to be in for 90% of a game. It’s wonderful to see him engaging with the story instead of just quipping, for sure, but many dialogue scenes are dedicated to deciphering the mysteries of the Ancients and wondering what different areas of the ruins were originally supposed to be. Which is, y’know. Probably a direct result of the homogeneous setting. I like that so much thought was put into the ruins as a place with a history and not just as a series of video game levels, but it’s another reason why I wouldn’t mind a little more variety for the next game, especially given how incredibly strong the character work is here.</p><p>On the subject of Sonic, though, he’s very much in line with his portrayal in the IDW comics, which is just a treat as a big fan of that series. His gradually worsening corruption from his journeys into Cyber Space contrasting with his determination to smile through the pain and save his friends evokes the Metal Virus saga. Given Iizuka has said they gave Ian the job after being impressed with the IDW comics, I have a feeling they outright asked him to channel that energy here. But where it really becomes clear that this is the same take on the character seen in the IDW comics is in his interactions with a new character: Sage.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*FM_dsx1lZ6AL4fo4KTnPPA.png" /></figure><h3><strong>Sage</strong></h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/1*1LUfoz8CPJX2kHJWtvHOmA.png" /></figure><p>Great news for everyone who drew fanart of “Eggette”: Eggman has made himself an AI daughter, and she’s adorable.</p><p>I actually didn’t expect Sage to be that, since trailers always associated her with the ruins, not with Eggman. Really, she was just pitched as “mysterious, spooky little anime girl,” which didn’t grab me. But before long the game reveals that she is, in fact, the advanced AI Eggman designed to take over the Starfall Islands’ Cyber Space network. When Eggman is trapped in Cyber Space, it becomes her job to protect him.</p><p>Sage is cagey, at first a very cold character with machine-like logic, and her interactions with Sonic for the first few hours of the game mostly consist of her telling him to fuck off. She won’t elaborate because he’s Eggman’s arch nemesis, but she knows that Sonic is at risk of making a bad situation worse through his actions on the Starfall Islands. Sonic, on the other hand, refuses to see Sage as an enemy — he has no idea what her deal is and no real reason to fight her. Sure, he has to defeat a bunch of giant robots she points in his direction, but that’s business as usual for him. All he knows is that Sage is the only person who has any idea what’s actually going on, and therefore his only hope of saving his friends from being trapped in Cyber Space forever. It very much evokes the version of Sonic seen in the IDW comics who can and will kick ass, but who’s not eager to get into fights that could be avoided by simply talking things out. He’ll tell Sage to buzz off if she’s just being annoyingly cryptic again, sure, but all he really wants is info that can help safe his friends.</p><p>Over time, though, Sage sees how much Sonic loves his friends and the lengths he’ll go to to save them, even as she keeps telling him that it’s hopeless, and it awakens something in her: a desire to be loved like Sonic loves his friends — particularly the found family dynamic he has with Tails, which Ian highlights in the script.</p><p>Meanwhile, Eggman is extremely proud of his new AI. Part of this is that he’s really happy to see one of his creations be competent for a change. Part of it is that the eager-to-please Sage likes to deliver play-by-play mission reports of Sonic getting beaten up by robots, which Eggman eats right up. But like with Sage, there’s something more human being unearthed within Eggman here.</p><p>Eggman begins to view Sage as family.</p><p>He certainly fights it, trying to view Sage as just another machine, but it doesn’t take long for him to cave and refer to her as his daughter. He tries to write it off as pride over the fact that he’s created life (“And if I did create life, she would be brilliant and loyal and perfectly effective! And you know why? Because her dad is a genius, that’s why!”), but the most fascinating hint at what’s really going through his head comes from this memo:</p><blockquote>“I never really knew my cousin, Maria. Everyone spoke of her like she was very special. All that love for someone who was gone when I was! Right! There! But I have to wonder. Back then, was she anything like Sage is now?”</blockquote><p>It’s subtle, but you can read SO much into this. Again, it’s amazing that Ian was allowed to touch something like this <em>at all</em> with Eggman. Nobody in production told him to knock it off because people would call it cringe. They didn’t turn it into a joke. At worst we get an exchange where Sage goes “You… think he cares about me?” and Sonic goes “Sure! (In his… own way…)” and the line from Roger makes it genuinely hilarious.</p><p>Sage’s story arc may not be the most original thing in the world, and it can get cheesy, but by god, it has heart in a way that no <em>Sonic </em>game has had in years. It reminds me in some ways of Archie <em>Sonic</em>’s Nicole, Sally’s AI companion who slowly develops a desire to be “alive” and experience love, which has always been one of my favorite parts of that series. She also has some real shades of Rei Ayanami — and, wouldn’t you know it? The two share voice actresses in both English AND Japanese. Juxtaposing those vibes with her role as Eggman’s new sidekick makes her really, really fun, and I sincerely hope we see more of her.</p><p>Also just… look at how much I can write about Sage as a character. I could NOT do that with Infinite or Zavok. <em>Sonic</em> has ACTUAL WRITING again, y’all!</p><h3><strong>The Titans (and other enemies)</strong></h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*xAKtSMv0mqycsfcztanwxw.jpeg" /></figure><p>People often wonder why <em>Sonic</em> has to be so weird, based on assumptions of what a scrimblo bimblo platformer series is allowed to do. Why couldn’t he just be like that nice Italian boy Mario down the street? Sometimes these criticisms were absolutely fair and were echoed within the fandom itself. Other times it comes off more as people being unwilling to engage with <em>Sonic</em> in good faith, or simply a failure to understand what kind of story <em>Sonic</em> actually wants to be. Despite his design influences, <em>Sonic</em> has never 100% wanted to be a classic rubber hose cartoon. <em>Sonic</em> wants to be some flavor of shounen anime. He literally goes Super Saiyan in the second game. But after a decade of mixed reception in the ‘00s, Sega shied away from much of this, wanting to make <em>Sonic</em> more like <em>Mario</em>. This was most evident in <em>Colors</em> and <em>Lost World</em>. And I like both of those games! They were the games <em>Sonic</em> needed at that time. But it would have been such a shame if they stuck with that tone forever.</p><p>Thankfully, they didn’t. Because now the biggest <em>Sonic</em> game ever made also has boss fights where Super Sonic does shounen anime finisher moves on gigantic robot kaiju as metalcore music plays.</p><p>This was the moment when I knew for certain. <em>Sonic</em> is cool again.</p><p>Let’s back up a bit. The Titan boss fights build upon the new combat. Past <em>Sonic </em>games have tried to incorporate more combat into the series for the sake of variety (and padding) to mixed results. Giving enemies health bars often just meant mashing A to homing attack repeatedly. The Werehog gameplay was <em>fine, </em>but it distracted from the things you actually wanted to be doing (breaking the sound barrier in Rooftop Run). This time, they finally figured out how to put melee combat in <em>Sonic</em>. The answer is to not make it another mode of gameplay at all. Just give it to Sonic.</p><p>The effect here is that enemies and bosses are more fun to fight than they’ve ever been, turning into a light character action game complete with special attacks, dodges, and the world’s most generous parry. The earliest footage made fights look slow and laborious, but it’s just a matter of learning the strategies. I found it super satisfying to tear down enemies that had previously given me trouble in seconds after learning their weaknesses. Is it as deep as a Platinum game? No. But it doesn’t need to be, since most of the game is still a platformer.</p><p>In general the new enemies have a ton of variety in how they make you utilize Sonic’s moveset, with many even creating small platforming challenges. Some minibosses like the Squid will create roads in the sky that you have to chase them down. Some have shields that you can quickly use the Cyloop to destroy. One enemy traps Sonic inside itself, forcing you to stomp your way out. They’re honestly all great, but perhaps my favorite of the regulars is the massive “Fortress” miniboss that you have to chase through the sky via rails it emits in its wake, just for the sheer spectacle of it.</p><p>But without a doubt, the absolute pinnacle of the game is the climactic fights against the Titans.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*vMfD0Wl_vmaX6KX1gbYIaA.jpeg" /></figure><p>That new combat of Sonic’s pays off in spades when he transforms into Super Sonic for these fights, as his powered up form cranks all of his regular moves up to 11. Finally, Super Sonic is actually fun to play as! All of the anime influences are fully indulged in here, with beam struggle quick time events and Super Sonic creating shadow clones and more. And the designs of the Titans themselves rule, including a first Titan that has major <em>Eva</em> vibes and cool details like cascading rows of teeth that open up one by one when it fires a beam out of its mouth. And all the cinematic moments that play up the scale of it all and the absurd power of Super Sonic, such as when he steals the third titan’s mile-long sword to deal the finishing blow. And the music, oh my GOD the music. This is peak <em>Sonic</em>. Period.</p><p>You know how much fun I had with these boss fights? I died like ten times on the first one, and I didn’t even care. I went in with low rings, and with no way to pick up more rings in that fight (that I could see, anyway) I was on a strict 100 second time limit as Super Sonic’s ring counter slowly drained. I struggled to figure out how to optimize my attacks to deal enough damage to the boss within the time limit. It’s not actually <em>that</em> hard, but I didn’t realize that you can just hold down the buttons to parry instead of trying to time it precisely until I was several tries deep. But even with all those restarts, I was still having a blast. It gave me more time to savor the spectacle, to see more of Super Sonic’s powered up finishers, and most importantly, to listen to that high-energy vocal theme.</p><p>And I think those vocal themes, which I’ve absolutely been listening to on loop, are a perfect encapsulation of how the series has found its confidence again with <em>Frontiers. </em>A decade ago they never would’ve humored the idea of effectively writing a metalcore EP for this game. They would’ve been worried about people making fun of it, of the game “taking itself too seriously,” of it “clashing” with the protagonist being a blue cartoon hedgehog. They’d be worried about the vocals being written off as “screamo” that general audiences might find abrasive. Now they don’t give a shit about any of that, because actually? <strong>It’s fucking cool.</strong> Screw the haters.</p><p>Cringe is dead. Sonic is forever.</p><h3>The Ancients</h3><p>So here’s where this game really started making my eyes bulge out of my skull. By the end of the first island, you’ve caught a brief glimpse of what the Ancients looked like.</p><p>They look like this.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/911/1*q-R-VW8DhkdnwaTV1X1maQ.png" /></figure><p>That’s… that’s Chaos.</p><p>Oh shit.</p><p>The excellent animated prologue starring Knuckles hinted that Frontiers would have ties to the lore of Angel Island and perhaps even the Chaos Emeralds themselves, but I didn’t expect them to delve <em>this deep </em>into the foundational lore of the franchise. I had always assumed that these were questions designed to never be answered, but boy have I been proven wrong. We now know the origins of the Chaos Emeralds.</p><p>The Chaos Emeralds are from <strong><em>SPACE!!!</em></strong></p><p>That’s right, Archie readers! The weird lore about the Emeralds coming from space in Mobius’s ancient past is canon now! Well, not quite. Where Archie depicted tons of Emeralds in seven different colors raining down upon seven different planets from an unknown origin in space, <em>Frontiers </em>depicts them as a power source from the home planet of the Ancients, which they fled after it was destroyed by the true antagonist of <em>Frontiers</em>. As they traveled through space, Earth’s Master Emerald resonated with their seven Chaos Emeralds and forced them to land.</p><p>I’ll avoid recapping the entire story of the Ancients here, but there’s actually a decent amount of room for interpretation, which I personally find really cool. Obviously, the thing that sticks out is that they all look like Chaos, and an Egg Memo confirms they’re related. But some obscure lore already said that Chaos was a mutated Chao. Did they retcon this? Well, maybe, but Eggman <em>also </em>says that “After countless years, [the Ancients’] DNA corroded to the point they were completely transformed into a new species. Some kind of radiation affected them for eons, making them unrecognizable — except to a genius like me.” So maybe it’s the other way around. Chaos isn’t a mutated Chao… Chao are mutated Ancients, affected by some kind of radiation on Earth. And maybe the original backstory is still true! Maybe Chaos <em>was </em>a normal Chao, and the Master Emerald simply made him devolve into an Ancient. One way or another, Chaos seems to be an alien now. He did always kinda look like one.</p><p>This is just my read on it, and I’m sure there are other theories. But it’s just so fun that there’s so much to chew on here—and that I actually care to theorize about the story at all after having finished the game. What a change of pace. It’s no wonder Sega has a dedicated Sonic Lore Team now.</p><h3><strong>The End</strong></h3><p>With the truth of the Ancients revealed, so too is the true villain: The End, the source of the mysterious voice that goaded Sonic into defeating the Ancients’ Titans in the first place. Over the course of the final island, Sonic teams up with Sage and Eggman to gather the Emeralds one last time and save Earth from the cosmic scourge that destroyed the Ancients’ home planet. While standoffish around Sonic, Sage has been hoping he would work with Eggman basically the whole game, as it’s Eggman’s only chance for survival here. She’s the logical one, after all, and she’s run the numbers based on all those past games where the two teamed up to stop a bigger threat. And so Eggman begrudgingly inducts Sonic into the Eggman Empire — on a temporary basis, of course.</p><p>(Side note: the final island disappointingly uses a very similar biome to the first. It also has the problem that many open world games have these days where it doesn’t feel like there’s a true “final level” to build up hype for the finale, instead leaving you to just kind of go kill the final boss and roll the credits when there’s nothing else to do.)</p><p>After a final Titan battle that’s fine, if not the most flashy of the four (again, I stopped leveling up hours ago, so it put up more of a fight), things will diverge based on whether or not you’re playing hard mode. It’s weird. The only meaningful difference, aside from changing the second song in the credits, is that the battle with The End is skipped over altogether if you aren’t playing on hard, leaving it to be defeated purely via cutscene for one of the biggest anticlimaxes in the history of the medium. After all those insane Super Sonic fights, that’s it? Really? But I suspect focus testers had trouble with that fight, which has you controlling the final Titan as Sage using the <em>Ikaruga-</em>inspired bullet hell gameplay seen previously in a few hacking minigames. (I got through on my first try, and I attribute this purely to me getting into <em>Touhou </em>last year.)</p><p>The End also has a very unique design for a <em>Sonic </em>villain, and by that I mean it’s the Black Moon from <em>Evangelion. </em>I’m noticing a pattern…</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*kLf7ml8IRDOQebgDang6eA.png" /></figure><p>Folks seem divided on this. I like <em>Eva</em>, and <em>Kirby </em>has conditioned me to love unknowable cosmic horrors that take the form of evil space orbs (as well as genre-shifting final boss battles that turn into shmups), so I’d say I like it. But a second form of some kind with more of an actual Design that you fight as Super Sonic and one last vocal theme surely couldn’t have hurt.</p><p>The End comes dangerously close to being a JRPG final boss monster that shows up at the last second without ever being mentioned previously, but I think on a story level it works for me. For one, it was foreshadowed the whole game. But I also think the final boss monologue Ian wrote for it (which, again, you only get on hard mode) helps tie a nice bow on the themes of the story and the central tenets of Sonic as a character.</p><p><em>Sonic Frontiers</em> is, in many ways, about moving on — a fitting theme for what the game represents for the series as a whole. Not running from the past and its sorrows, but accepting it, learning from it, and knowing that you still have to move forward anyway. Sonic and friends help the lingering spirits of the Ancients trapped within the Koco move on. Sonic’s friends, too, grapple with their own prior shortcomings and decide they need to move on with their lives, even if the past is filled with regrets and the future is uncertain. Sage wonders how Sonic can keep moving forward the way he does, fighting on as he grows more and more corrupted, even though she’s run the numbers and believes his fate is already sealed.</p><p>The End is the epitome of this. It’s the embodiment of entropy. It’s the void. The destroyer of countless other worlds. It’s the antithesis to the “teeming chaos of creation.” It’s the nothingness at the end of everything. How do you keep pushing forward when you know The End is coming? “What can one mote of golden light illuminate within the abyss?” But Sonic isn’t a mere mortal. He’s an ideal. He’s a force of nature. He’s the unwavering determination to keep going no matter what, to fight for your friends with everything you’ve got, because that’s love.</p><p>Is that cheesy as hell? Yes. It’s the time-honored message that the powers of love and friendship can never be defeated. And I wouldn’t have it any other way. Because that’s Sonic.</p><p>Sonic’s back, baby.</p><blockquote>I’m here<br>Reaching far across these new frontiers<br>With my life I fight this fear<br>In my hands I hold the ones I love<br>Walk forward through the cold dawn<br>Always to new horizons</blockquote><h3><strong>Epilogue: My wish list for next time</strong></h3><p>Iizuka has already outright stated that Sega views <em>Frontiers </em>as the basis for future games, like <em>Sonic Adventure </em>before it.<em> </em>In that regard, I think that <em>Frontiers</em> is a fantastic foundation to expand upon next time. So here’s what I’d like to see tweaked. Even a few of these would go a long way:</p><ul><li>Bring back Sage!!! She’s great. I want to see her be Eggman’s second in command more. I saw that damn post-credits scene, I know she survived her heroic sacrifice against The End. Please don’t let her be one of those characters that Sonic Team keeps in the toy box.</li><li>Make the art direction of the open zones look less like an Unreal tech demo, and give the linear stages new themes. Ideally I would love it if they were set in “real” locations rather than being abstract challenges.</li><li>Give the extra collectibles a purpose. Anything.</li><li>Secrets! I was shocked to realize there are no interesting secrets on the Starfall Islands<em>, </em>just more collectibles. That’s one of the main points of even doing an open world to me.</li><li>More NPCs — particularly, more of Sonic’s friends! My main wish was for them to include some fun side content with the supporting cast, and they didn’t do this. It would also be nice to have some kind of town or city for NPCs to inhabit instead of just ruins.</li><li>Also, let the supporting cast interact with each other more in the story. It would’ve been nice to see Tails, Knuckles, and Amy play off of each other more.</li><li>Tangle and Whisper get married — wait did I really go the whole article without mentioning that a comic-original character (Tangle) got a namedrop in a mainline game for the first time ever oh my god</li></ul><p><em>Shameless plug zone! Thanks for reading this. If you enjoyed it, you may also enjoy my Tumblr blog </em><a href="https://thankskenpenders.tumblr.com/"><em>Thanks Ken Penders</em></a><em> where I discuss the American </em>Sonic<em> comics. It’ll be coming back from hiatus in 2023 since I’m finally releasing my game, </em><a href="https://slarpg.com/"><em>Super Lesbian Animal RPG</em></a><em>, in the next few weeks. Also go </em><a href="https://store.steampowered.com/app/2124380/Super_Lesbian_Animal_RPG"><em>wishlist that on Steam</em></a><em> thanks</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f0b7121d0f69" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Pony Get iPad: Checking in on My Little Pony’s 5th generation]]></title>
            <link>https://ponett.medium.com/pony-get-ipad-checking-in-on-my-little-ponys-5th-generation-6ad4bc69b65e?source=rss-1885f92e94c5------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6ad4bc69b65e</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[my-little-pony]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[animation]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Bobby Schroeder]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 09 Oct 2022 23:02:15 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-09-25T21:48:16.773Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*GuLzCxamMy7dsPoEvAN5ww.png" /></figure><p>(<strong>EDIT 9/25/2024: </strong>This piece is <a href="https://ponett.dog/blog/pony-get-ipad-checking-in-on-my-little-ponys-5th-generation.html">now mirrored on my new personal blog</a>! I’m no longer using Medium, and can’t guarantee that this site won’t mess with my formatting or randomly lose chunks of the article, as it’s done in the past.)</p><p>I’ve been asked a few times about my thoughts on the new My Little Pony series on Netflix, <em>Make Your Mark</em> — the flagship series for Generation 5. I previously shared<a href="https://ponett.tumblr.com/post/663421723138473985/hi-i-watched-the-new-my-little-pony-movie-and-it"> more casual thoughts on the preceding movie, <em>My Little Pony: A New Generation</em></a>, which I thought was cute but bogged down by having the entire story revolve around a very trite and overly simplistic political allegory. I said at the time that I did like the new characters, though, and that they had potential.</p><p>Well now <em>Make Your Mark</em> is here, it gives the cast more to talk about than Horse Racism, and it’s… all right! Hit or miss. Sometimes fun, sometimes really bland. It’s slowly improving, but the ways in which it stumbles over itself are interesting to me. So here I am, once again writing too many words about a cartoon and also the ways in which adults online talk about cartoons for kids.</p><h3>But first, context</h3><p>Part of me feels kind of bad for complaining that a show for little kids doesn’t totally speak to me. Like. I’m 28. It’s not made for me. But I don’t expect it to be! Much of the initial charm of <em>Friendship is Magic</em> is that it was so unapologetically a cute and nice show for little girls at a time when cartoons about girls were harder to get off the ground. But because the target audience is so young, it’s easy to fall into the critical pitfall where you’re one step removed from going “Why isn’t the writing in <em>Peppa Pig</em> cathartic for me, an adult?” or “Why am I still hungry after eating this Kid Cuisine?” It’s not immune to criticism, but it’s important not to lose sight of what reading level it’s aiming for.</p><p>(Side note: I’ve seen claims that <em>Make Your Mark</em> is a preschool show, which <em>FiM</em> wasn’t, but I don’t buy it. Its style feels in the same ballpark as <em>FiM</em>’s, and both shows’ movies are rated PG, not G. I’ll touch on this more later.)</p><p>I also know I’m extremely biased because <em>Friendship is Magic</em> was my fucking LIFE. I met a lot of close friends through that fandom, and even my boyfriend of eight years. My drive to make MLP fanart as a teen was what pushed me to start posting art online and improving my skills after years of insecurity. And, yes, I am one of countless trans women online who started to figure some shit out because of this cartoon about how there’s no single right or wrong way to be a girl. (The girls in question just happen to be horses.)</p><p>At the same time, I don’t think every new generation of My Little Pony now needs to emulate Generation 4 directly. The entire point of a reboot is to do something new. But <em>FiM</em> was also never a perfect show.</p><p>The most common critique is the increase in pandering to bronies over time. And, yes, episode 100 being 22 minutes of “do you recognize this background pony meme?” was torture; Discord’s “redemption arc,” where he went from showstopping villain to insufferable backstabbing “friend” so fan favorite <em>Star Trek</em> actor John de Lancie could become a series regular, sucked ass; and the fifth season finale in which Twilight was thrust into various grimdark bad timelines, including a war-torn Equestria in which a battle-scarred Rainbow Dash <a href="https://i.imgur.com/Mf30IYO.png">seemed to be dressed like a <em>Fallout </em>character</a>, was bizarre. The shift was an issue. But I also think lapsed fans tended to latch onto random things like a nameless extra wearing a fedora (as a resident of a pony city modeled after early 20th century New York) as “proof” that the show had abandoned little girls altogether and shifted its focus <em>exclusively</em> to the most toxic and entitled parts of the brony fandom, which was never quite true, even at its worst.</p><p>No, there was always more to critique than that. There were some bad episodes in every season, even before creator Lauren Faust left, thanks in part to the way characters’ personalities and relationships could fluctuate wildly based on the writer and whose turn it was to learn a lesson on not being an asshole that week. After<em> </em>Faust left, seasonal arcs and the big Event Episodes became a mixed bag, based largely on needing to make up more macguffins and conflicts (and toys) to keep the show going every year they got renewed. And attempts at depicting other cultures through the non-pony races like the zebras, the buffalo, and the yaks often devolved into crude stereotypes, with WAY too many storylines about the ponies needing to introduce these <em>primitive cultures</em> to the concept of friendship. There’s always been tons of room to improve on <em>FiM</em>.</p><p>But in spite of all that, it’s still one of my favorite things ever, and a show that continues to be very dear to me. Yes, even the later seasons. (They have Starlight and Trixie.) So it makes me a little sad that this new show is having trouble either recapturing that magic or making a compelling argument for itself as a proper new take on the franchise.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*MQ3jBIe2u4I0MSBZGt-RUA.png" /><figcaption>yes I chose a screenshot that looks gay on purpose</figcaption></figure><h3>Okay let’s actually talk about Make Your Mark now</h3><p>The first thing everyone notices is the new 3D art style. Opinions have been mixed, but I think it looks good by TV standards. The 44-minute premiere felt rougher, with characters seeming like they’d been chroma keyed in over the environments at times, but newer episodes feel more polished. The new pony models with their Disney-like faces and finely groomed eyebrows might be a hard sell for some, but I got used to it quickly, and I like new details like the visibly separate hooves, additional accessories, and multicolored wings.</p><p>The shift to 3D clearly has its limitations, though, and I think it’s one of the main things that hurts the show. For one, the over-the-top cartoony expressiveness that gave <em>FiM</em> so much of its charm is basically impossible to recreate here. You can push 3D animation super far into exaggerated cartoon territory when your assets are being built for that (see: <em>The Bad Guys </em>and <em>The Mitchells vs. the Machines, </em>but I also can’t resist a chance to plug <em>Battle Kitty</em>), but that wasn’t the goal here. This alone isn’t a dealbreaker to me, though. Also not a dealbreaker, but something I keep noticing: they constantly use the animation cheat of just having the ponies magnetically pick up props with their hooves. <em>FiM </em>tried to avoid this, and it looks even weirder in high-fidelity 3D. (Their phone cases are all designed to slot over their hooves, though, and I think that’s a cute touch.)</p><p>What’s worse is that the fantasy adventure elements that defined G1 and G4 are now almost entirely gone, at least in these episodes, and I personally suspect the shift to 3D is the culprit here as well.</p><p><em>FiM</em> would frequently insert fantasy monsters into even its slice of life comedy episodes, or have the gang explore different parts of Equestria. The crew just had to draw the new creatures and backgrounds, which is the kind of thing built into the expected workload of a 2D cartoon. But now we have stricter 3D modeling budgets and asset pipelines to worry about, which here means the cast can rarely leave a very small set of locations within Maretime Bay (they don’t even visit the other locations from the movie) and all of the non-pony species have been removed from the series, with the sole exceptions of the obligatory baby dragon and a few critters. Having more foreign, non-equine characters (hippogryphs, dragons, changelings, griffons, etc.) join the cast was also a focal point of <em>FiM’</em>s last few seasons, so their exclusion in the new show that’s all about embracing diversity really stands out. You could argue that this is intentionally a back-to-basics reboot, which is probably true to some extent, but removing the other fantasy creatures that have been an element since 1986 makes the world feel so small and empty. Ironic, since this is probably the most expensive MLP show ever made.</p><p>I feel like these restrictions on character animation, locations, and creature variety are why so many are interpreting <em>Make Your Mark</em> as more of a low-key preschool show. Which would be fine, but given the Lore and Plot stuff, I don’t necessarily think they’re trying to make <em>Bluey</em>. (We’ll get to the Lore, believe me.) Maybe that vibe will make it speak more to fans of things like <em>My Little Pony Tales </em>and G3, though? If that applies to you, fan complaints that this show is “more girly” instead of being “serious fantasy” might be a sign that the pool’s open again. Why yes I did make the mistake of looking at the MLP subreddit why do you ask</p><p>Regardless, this is a character-driven show. Nothing else matters if they can carry it. So, how are the characters?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*axv4lbHgsCiiiNPyeosFQA.png" /></figure><h3>The Mane Five</h3><p>I’ll admit that I have yet to start watching <em>Tell Your Tale</em>, the series of 2D shorts on YouTube, because the animation looks… well, bad. But I hear it’s cute. I also haven’t been keeping up with the comics, or played the video game. It’s possible that those use the cast better, but I don’t think it should be necessary to do homework to watch a cartoon for kids. So I’m judging this as its own thing.</p><p>Unfortunately, it’s hard to judge the characters in <em>Make Your Mark </em>as their own characters, because they so frequently feel like watered down versions of <em>FiM’</em>s Mane Six.</p><p>I’ve tried so very hard to not just view them as that. That criticism can be such a cheap dig. And even if the Mane Six are some of my favorite fictional characters ever, after nine seasons of them it was clear that the franchise was ready for something new. I was excited to give this new cast a chance! But it’s so hard to not see the gears turning in the writers’ heads. It all maps too directly.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*5zh4LD_q7KRuWWAN0v4xiw.png" /></figure><h4><strong>Izzy</strong></h4><p>Let’s take Izzy as an example, because I thought for sure she was gonna be my favorite. And I do <em>like </em>her, but in <em>Make Your Mark</em> Izzy Moonbow is Pinkie Pie if she was a unicorn who was into crafts instead of an Earth pony who was into baking and parties. Moment to moment they‘re identical. Cheerful, easily excitable, superstitious, seemingly airheaded because they operate on logic no one else fully understands. The thing is, Pinkie had more to her than that! She wanted to make everyone happy and for everyone to like her, and conflicts arose from her tying her self-worth to that. She would sometimes struggle with feeling replaceable to her friends, thinking she was only worth having around if she could entertain them. She was often reduced to just a zany goofball as a supporting player, sure, but those extra layers were there when they zoomed in. Izzy just doesn’t have that yet. She’s <em>just </em>a goofball. (But without Pinkie’s cartoony visual gags, because, again, animation limitations.) Like most of the cast, she might be rendered in three dimensions, but she tends to be written in one, and it makes the whole show more boring to follow.</p><p>See, <em>FiM </em>was a great example of one of my favorite character writing tools, which is giving them apparent “contradictions.” Pinkie was an upbeat goober, BUT there was also this inner layer of sadness and self-doubt to her sometimes. This doesn’t just include flaws and insecurities, though — take, for example, the fact that Pinkie was the party animal of the group, but she actually grew up with a very dour Amish family (who she still loves). She’s not just one thing or the other all the time, and these contrasting sides of her character make her more interesting. For something more comedic, see how the normally wise and regal Princess Celestia also liked to be a prankster sometimes, such as when she revealed she invited the Mane Six to the gala because she thought it’d be more fun if they trashed the party. This is character writing 101 stuff, but the cast of <em>FiM</em> felt more engaging on both a dramatic and a comedic level because of these added wrinkles beyond their moment to moment personality archetypes. It’s why people still love them so damn much.</p><h4><strong>Zipp and Pipp</strong></h4><p>Zipp Storm and Pipp Petals are also great examples of how much flatter the characters tend to be. Zipp is very clearly the new Rainbow Dash, the cool and confident tomboy pegasus with a multicolored mane and a lightning bolt cutie mark who’s great at flying. The problem is that Zipp is rarely anything <em>but </em>“the cool one.” She’s just kind of confident and chill. Meanwhile, Rainbow Dash had a lot of traits that contradicted her “cool” image. She was a total fangirl with her idols like the Wonderbolts, and she tended to judge herself extremely harshly in comparison to them despite seemingly having such a massive ego. Her selfish and competitive tendencies could make her kind of an insensitive jerk at times, but this was balanced out with plenty of sweet moments where she’s supportive of her friends. Zipp doesn’t really have many wrinkles like that. And it’s clear that the writers knew they needed to give her something else, because <em>Make Your Mark </em>also decides that she’s a detective. Her natural inquisitiveness is something, I guess, but in practice it usually means she’s the character who mutters to herself about plot clues while everyone else is distracted by the episode’s main problems.</p><p>Pipp, meanwhile, is the new fashionable girly girl to replace Rarity. But Rarity bucked (ha ha) the tropes that would have made her the generic snob in so many other shows by also being a passionate, workaholic fashion designer who was generous to a fault and wanted to help bring out the beauty in everyone, AND being confident enough to stand up to all sorts of monsters. Pipp, meanwhile… is a vain valley girl pop star princess (who seemingly only has three fans in town?) obsessed with her phone and social media. She’s mostly presented as a stock character in ways that Rarity never was.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Im_NyRMjcm22748vgw789A.png" /></figure><p>On the subject of Pipp and Zipp, though, the first episode that really stood out to me as a sign that the writers <em>could </em>do more with this cast was “Portrait of a Princess,” which focuses on them. As we learn in this episode, they were extremely close as kids, but as they’ve grown up their differing personalities have led to them bickering more and growing apart. They reach a breaking point when Zipp reveals that the events of the episode were just her trying to get out of their family portrait day, and the normally upbeat and vain Pipp is left heartbroken by her sister seemingly not wanting to be around her anymore. It’s a brief, quiet scene, but Zipp realizing how much she’s hurt her sister is moving, as is the heartfelt duet she initiates to apologize and make it clear that she does still love her. It’s not revolutionary, but it’s an effective little bit of storytelling that made me feel more emotion than the three preceding episodes combined.</p><p>And as the season progressed? Pipp unexpectedly became my favorite. She’s absolutely still a stock character, but her lively performance and solid comedic timing made a lot of the jokes about her being vain and obsessed with her online popularity land better for me than other jokes, which tended to whiff in that trademark mid-tier Canadian cartoon fashion. This performance also made her moments of genuine kindness work better for me, perhaps because they’re contrasted against that comical vanity. And I think it’s cute that they made the fashionable popular girl the short and stocky one.</p><p>I’ll also admit that it’s still early in <em>Make Your Mark</em>, with only nine of the currently planned 27 episodes released. It’s not really fair to judge that against characters who had over 200 episodes to make themselves interesting. But by this point in its run <em>FiM </em>had already given us some all-timer character spotlight episodes like “Applebuck Season” and “Dragonshy,” and 1-on-1 dynamics within the group were starting to develop with episodes like “Griffon the Brush-Off” and “Look Before You Sleep.” My hope is that <em>Make Your Mark </em>is just off to a slow start, and that we’ll get more standout moments like that scene with Zipp and Pipp in future episodes. But they aren’t giving me much to latch onto.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ho9bOomGvl0iCT6unyD7vQ.png" /><figcaption>Seriously though they hold props like this all the time. Although I guess it wouldn’t exactly be practical for Sunny to hold a microphone in her mouth</figcaption></figure><h4>Sunny</h4><p>I have yet to mention the actual main character, Sunny Starscout, and that’s because I find her so… bland. In press releases her core personality trait has been identified as “activist,” apparently in an effort to appeal to the “higher emotional intelligence of Generation Alpha.” With the only major societal problem in her world (Horse Racism) basically solved by the end of the movie, Sunny’s no longer portrayed as the last sane person fighting for justice in a dystopian world, currently leaving her the most boring character in the show. She’s just kind of broadly preachy about how everyone else should live their lives, but not to the extent that it’s funny or a character flaw, because she’s also pretty much always right, and the things she’s right about aren’t particularly high stakes. (There is at least a good joke where the villain does a double take at Sunny’s loftiest goal, the one she would achieve if given unlimited power, being to open up a small community garden so everyone can eat less junk food.) Beyond that, her role is often just to serenely place a hoof on her friend’s shoulder whenever they’re having a problem and tell them that everything’s gonna be okay.</p><p>In other words, yes, Sunny tends to feel almost identical to late era Twilight. The version of Twilight whose rough edges were all sanded away in an effort to make her THE<em> </em>expert on friendship — her know-it-all attitude, her poor social skills, her extreme bookishness, her tendency to solve problems with magic even when it’s a bad idea, her obsessive nature, her ability to just get fed up with all the nonsense going on around her and explode. The most boring version of Twilight that downplayed all those quirks that made her fun and relatable in the first couple seasons. She’s back, and she’s orange now.</p><h4>Hitch</h4><p>Hitch is also there. It’s admittedly not a great look to define the protagonist primarily as a social justice activist and have her lifelong best friend be the town cop, but aside from that he’s fine. He’s roughly the equivalent of Applejack, and he has the least traits in common with his predecessor because AJ was always the least popular. (He does wear a cowboy hat in one episode, though.) He becomes the adopted father to a horrible little dragon baby he dubs Sparky Sparkeroni that feels like it was inserted to make the show more marketable to the kids addicted to Cocomelon, or perhaps to give the show its own Baby Yoda copycat, or both. Vile beast.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*i_Vx-k04tZJCca26jzIvjw.png" /><figcaption>Ugh, the beast is demonic in nature. Very icky, no good</figcaption></figure><p>(I did think the instructional video Hitch made for babysitting Sparky was funny, though. A parent definitely wrote that.)</p><h3>New ideas</h3><p>A lot of this sounds like it could just be a new season of <em>FiM </em>with new characters, but <em>Make Your Mark </em>does introduce some new ideas of its own here and there.</p><p>The big one is that Earth ponies develop their own form of magic dubbed “Flora Magic,” or the ability to make plants grow at their hooves. This and Hitch’s newfound ability to understand animals (which, yes, is lifted wholesale from Fluttershy) show that they’re trying to more clearly emphasize Earth ponies tending to the land.</p><p>I’m of two minds about this. I do think it makes a lot of sense to try and “spice up” Earth ponies, given all the claims that nobody would want to be an Earth pony because they’re “boring.” It’s also a genuine new idea, which I like! But Earth pony culture was always about doing things the old-fashioned way, working with their hands — sorry, hooves, instead of relying on magic, perhaps illustrated best in “Winter Wrap-Up.” Being able to stomp their hooves a few times and grow a giant tomato is the exact opposite of that ethos. BUT it’s at least a type of magic that otherwise fits, and it’s specific and limited enough that it doesn’t feel like they’re suddenly “overpowered.” As the seasons went on the Apple Family’s episodes about doing manual labor down on the farm also tended to land with a thud, so I can’t really blame them for removing full-blown farming from the show in favor of magic community gardens.</p><p>The other big new idea I’d draw attention to is really just a structural change. I’ve wondered many times what <em>FiM </em>would’ve been like if its first season had been structured like more recent fantasy adventure cartoons. You know, slowly building towards Nightmare Moon and the Elements of Harmony through an overarching narrative, rather than covering it in the first two episodes. Well, now <em>Make Your Mark </em>is doing pretty much exactly that, with every episode touching on the looming threat of the mysterious Queen Opaline and the questions surrounding her past.</p><p>Let’s talk about her!</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*yCkTzfjWhoGnrYGuM7iB-Q.png" /></figure><h3>Alicorns</h3><p>One of my criticisms of the movie was that Sunny being karmically rewarded with the ability to manifest wings and a horn felt weird in a movie where the Earth ponies, pegasi, and unicorns were distinct cultures in a blunt racism allegory. I was also just excited to see a humble Earth pony protagonist after six seasons of Princess Twilight, and I was disappointed they made her an alicorn in under 90 minutes. This is thankfully downplayed a bit in the show — Sunny’s usually in Earth pony mode — but they also try to do something interesting with it through Opaline.</p><p>Queen Opaline is, herself, a powerful and power-hungry alicorn who believes that being an alicorn automatically puts her in a position of power over every other pony. (She also claims at one point that alicorns are immortal, something I’m pretty sure they’ve dodged confirming before? If she’s telling the truth… where are all the princesses?) A few episodes in we get a story where Opaline tries to manipulate Sunny into believing this ideology herself, saying that she’s uniquely special and important now that she’s an alicorn and that everyone else should be serving her. Sunny rejects this because she doesn’t think she’s better than anyone else just for being an alicorn. In a bubble, this is an interesting dynamic for the main hero and villain to have, and the most interesting thing to happen with Sunny so far.</p><p>The problem, of course, is that according to the rules of the world established in <em>Friendship is Magic</em>, Opaline’s claims are all basically true.</p><p>Alicorns ARE inherently special! They ARE more magical than everyone else! They DO get to call all the shots! On paper, yes, having your hero fight against the idea that you’re better than everyone else for any innate reason is a great message, but it’s undermined by the worldbuilding established from the very first scene of the previous show. Opaline is a hateful extremist, but she’s also a product of her environment. If this was some kind of deconstruction of <em>FiM </em>trying to say that hey, maybe it <em>is</em> a little fucked up that there’s a special type of pony that automatically gets treated like gods by all the others, that might be an interesting story. One questioning the fact that a show about the power of friendship and working together still ends up rewarding Twilight above her friends, because Celestia has deemed her worthy of some special destiny. It’s hard to say where exactly this storyline is going, but I don’t think this show has a nuanced criticism of Celestia and Twilight and the pony monarchy up its sleeve given how much it, like Sunny herself, worships the ground <em>FiM </em>walked on.</p><p>And really, it’s those attempts to tie it all back to <em>Friendship is Magic </em>that might perplex me the most.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*SoD4Bm7yQLR6AgbKYyM5mA.png" /></figure><h3>They put Lore in this</h3><p>Early on, Twilight makes a cameo in hologram form to begin to explain how events in her era led to current events, a question that’s been on every returning fan’s mind. But this connection highlights one of the central hurdles “next generation” sequels face, which is that they often disrupt the “happily ever after” endings of their predecessors. For there to be more story after the ending, you probably need more conflict, and for characters to make more mistakes and deal with the repercussions. Fandoms tend to hate this on principle, but it isn’t an inherently bad thing. I’m a known <em>The Last Jedi</em> liker in part because I think saying that Luke continued to struggle with balancing his light and dark sides and that rebuilding the Jedi Order meant repeating many of their mistakes, causing him to question the whole system, is way more interesting than saying that he was just the bestest Jedi ever and nothing bad happened. And sometimes really leaning into that darker “everything’s gone to shit since you last saw these characters” angle gets you a hit like <em>Logan</em>.</p><p>The problem is that we’re talking about <em>My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic</em>, an extremely schmaltzy cartoon where the power of friendship is the ultimate magical force in the universe that can solve any problem (and also lets you shoot rainbow beams). That’s the appeal! The ending to <em>FiM</em> was bittersweet, with Twilight tearfully moving back to Canterlot so she can rule as Celestia’s heir, but the feel-good flash forward shows that the Mane Six are all still best friends who make time to hang out as a group as often as they can, even years later. The villains have been defeated, peace reigns, and everyone’s greatest dreams have come true. The book from the first episode closes to bring it all full circle. The end.</p><p>…EXCEPT according to this show after that Opaline showed up and started making ponies racist against each other as part of some grand scheme to steal their magic and a unicorn hurt an Earth pony so Twilight decided she had to take away her whole species’ magic by sealing it in the three Unity Crystals so they couldn’t use it against each other and then she also put all of Equestria in an “invisibubble” that somehow obscures the locations of the three crystals from Opaline. The entire country was put in time out, and they weren’t allowed to have magic again unless they played nice. The comics make it sound like this plan restored normalcy for a while before ponykind started fighting again at an unknown point (perhaps after Twilight’s era), but in the show Sunny frames Twilight creating the Unity Crystals and taking everyone’s magic as the last straw before the ponies fully segregated themselves. Ultimately Twilight’s reign ends like this, with everyone isolated, hateful, and without magic, and the world remains this way for centuries. That’s the Mane Six’s legacy now according to the new incarnation of the franchise. That’s their fate. Bleak.</p><p>I’m not gonna say that this “ruins <em>FiM</em>” or whatever. It’s its own story, and this is a new one. You can always ignore parts of a franchise you don’t like. (Lord knows there are some episodes of <em>FiM</em> that I pretend didn’t happen — looking at you, “Brotherhooves Social.”) It’s fiction, not a literal window into the history of a real parallel universe with immutable events. It’s just… this is a huge downer ending to establish for the heroes of your sappy power-of-friendship cartoon within the lore of your next sappy power-of-friendship cartoon. And it really sticks out when the new show generally has even lower stakes and less danger, to the point that people are wondering if it’s supposed to be a preschool show. It’s not like it’s even led to any interesting character work for Twilight either, like how cranky old man Luke was fun. Because she’s not a character in this! So far she’s just a hologram here to exposit lore.</p><p>It feels like connecting this new series to <em>FiM</em> was a move to appease and intrigue older fans, seeing as how the target audience of this show wasn’t alive when <em>FiM</em> premiered in 2010. A four-year-old whose first introduction to MLP is G5 won’t really know who Twilight Sparkle is. And as<em> </em>one of those returning fans I’m just getting caught up on how fucked up everything apparently went for Twilight and co. as soon as the cameras stopped rolling, instead of enjoying this cute little cartoon. If this was an unrelated show then this backstory would be totally fine in the allegorical mode G5 is operating in. Everyone started fighting each other and their ruler put them in time out on a grand scale! Sure! That works for a show for little kids. But tying these events so explicitly to the characters of <em>FiM</em> and their fates just gives it all this unnecessary baggage.</p><p>You know what the real kicker is, though?</p><p><strong><em>They already did this story!!!</em></strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*vGmVDsq1M5WahN17l8Zjlg.png" /></figure><p>Twilight and friends already stopped the three main pony races from being manipulated into turning on each other in “The Ending of the End.” It’s literally the last threat the Mane Six stopped in the whole show! The grand finale! They had everyone see through the deception and the entire extended cast of the show came together to defeat Chrysalis, Tirek, and Darla Dimple — sorry,<em> Cozy Glow</em> for good. The allegory wasn’t great then either, but Twilight’s final test as a hero was overcoming her feelings of powerlessness in the face of this very problem with the help of her friends! And then years later a new villain just… tried it again! But it actually worked that time, and Twilight couldn’t fix it, so she took away everyone’s magic and pony segregation happened.</p><p>I can’t even really argue all this benefits the themes, because the movie’s story about overcoming prejudice becomes even more shallow when it’s revealed that the problem was all just the result of one Rita Repulsa-ass villain manipulating everyone into deciding they don’t like each other anymore after one inciting incident so she could get more magic. Yeah, there are countless power-hungry people who incite bigotry as a tool for their own personal gain in real life. They’re called conservatives. But Donald Trump did not invent racism, and you can’t end it instantly with magic macguffins. I know the truth about these issues is complicated, and I know the writers’ hearts were in the right place, but I think we do kids a disservice when we water it down this much. Kids can handle a lot more nuance than adults give them credit for, and they latch onto the stories that don’t speak down to them. Just look at how many of my peers grew up religiously reading <em>Animorphs</em>.</p><p>Do I think that My Little Pony should be telling a morally complex and grounded story about systemic issues? Not really, no. I think they should’ve looked in the mirror and realized that maybe the cartoon that said the cowboys and the Native Americans should’ve just learned to share wasn’t equipped for this.</p><p>So wait if all this “Equestria suddenly becomes Divided and we must learn to come together again” shit is very obviously inspired by Trump era America then does that mean they see Twilight as pony Obama</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ro0HT0TYpUQ9LFGeNrlaNQ.png" /></figure><h3>Misty</h3><p><em>Make Your Mark </em>does have a secret weapon, though. Something that feels genuinely new while also building on <em>FiM</em>’s ideas, that makes great use of the serialized format to create an actual arc. And her name is Misty.</p><p>Misty is introduced as Opaline’s underling. This poor little ball of anxiety in the shape of a unicorn is constantly belittled and berated in an effort to keep her under control. Any brief moment of happiness is immediately squashed to keep her focused on serving her Queen. But Opaline strings Misty along through lies (Opaline naturally paints Twilight as the villain of the story) and by claiming that regaining her magic will let her give Misty a cutie mark, which she lacks even as an adult.</p><p>After a few episodes, Misty starts getting sent out to Maretime Bay to spy on the Mane Five. This escalates to the point where Misty is actively infiltrating the group to try to steal a macguffin. But then…</p><p>She actually starts to make friends with them.</p><p>The main cast is genuinely nice to Misty in a way she’s never experienced, and she has the time of her life at a sleepover Izzy throws for her. She’s actually… happy. But then she inevitably has to report back to Opaline, who wants her to just focus on the mission and continues to dangle the promise of a cutie mark (and, by extension, a purpose in life) over her head.</p><p>Misty actually makes the fact that the cast consists of obvious <em>FiM </em>stand-ins slightly more interesting, because once you see her start to hang out with the group, you realize she’s the missing member. She’s the Fluttershy. It’s like she was cosmically destined to be a part of this friend group by this universe’s rule of six, but all the lies and manipulation from Opaline have done a number on her, so she’s torn between the two sides. She longs for friendship, but she squashes that part of her and redoubles her efforts to be a villain and serve Opaline… which only gets her more verbal abuse back at the lair when she inevitably makes mistakes. It doesn’t take a rocket scientist to figure out that in a show like this, Misty’s gonna eventually stand up for herself against Opaline and become one of the good guys. But I want to see that happen! Wanting to see how Misty’s story plays out is maybe the main thing that has me looking forward to more of this show.</p><p>But it’s still not quite there yet. Misty’s role as a spy leads to an episode that I <em>thought </em>was shaping up to be my favorite… until they flubbed it. Episode 8, “Hoof Done It?”, has Zipp investigating the disappearance of a macguffin after Misty tries and fails to steal it from the Brighthouse. (Hey, something interesting with the detective angle!) What ensues seems to be a comedy of errors where the main cast are all getting in each others’ way and making the hunt for the macguffin more complicated than it needs to be, beginning with Pipp finding it almost immediately and deciding to hide it better so as to not spoil her sister’s fun playing detective. But then, as Zipp has Misty cornered, having suspected her all along… Pipp confesses and gives Zipp the macguffin. With like eight minutes left in the episode. What happens next is some of the most bizarre episode pacing I’ve ever seen, with multiple things happening<em> after</em> the resolution of the plot that clearly should have been part of the escalating action. First we get a (really good!!) song from Pipp about Zipp’s investigation, which, instead of playing as part of a montage of Zipp on the case, is just shown to us as a music video on Pipp’s phone? After the mystery is already solved??? Then they run into Sunny and Hitch, who had been starting to work on their own search for the macguffin, but because the plot is over Zipp and Pipp just tell them that they can abort that subplot before they actually do anything. I have no idea why they did it like this.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*O-H03Z-RKgnovmhZYKrF5w.png" /></figure><h3>Closing thoughts</h3><p>That episode is really a great encapsulation of where the show’s at right now. After a rough start they’re so, so close to having something good on their hands, and it really seemed like they’d finally figured it out, but they just keep tripping over themselves in odd ways — usually on a very basic writing level.</p><p>I don’t envy the crew behind Generation 5. The brony fandom has perhaps deified those first two seasons and Lauren Faust’s original vision to an unreasonable degree, but despite its flaws <em>Friendship is Magic </em>really was a cultural phenomenon. It took the foundation laid by the first three generations of the franchise and ran with it, recontextualizing established elements like the different kinds of pony and the little symbols on their rumps into an imaginative new fairy tale world with its own mythos and culture and endless opportunities for adventure. More importantly, though, it was made out of a drive to give young girls a cartoon with a highly varied and multifaceted cast of female characters, ones who defied common stereotypes without feeling the need to go all “not like other girls” mode, ones who were flawed and sympathetic and funny and heroic, and it focused squarely on the ups and downs of the heartfelt friendships between them. For all its many flaws as a series, it resonated, and continues to resonate, because of that.</p><p><em>Make Your Mark, </em>as it currently stands<em>… </em>is more My Little Pony.</p><p>It has yet to escape the shadow of its predecessor, but it also seems too comfortable living there. Its characters frequently struggle to be more than slight remixes of Faust’s. Its world is a smaller, less interesting version of Faust’s. Its central conflict is largely a retread of the final season of Faust’s. Its protagonist openly idolizes Faust’s protagonist, who keeps coming up in fanservicey lore dumps for better or worse. It’s scared to venture out from that shadow, seemingly worried it’ll be unloved if it tries to truly be its own thing, like how Misty is scared she wouldn’t be able to make it on her own if she stopped unquestioningly mimicking Queen Opaline’s villainous ways. But I’m rooting for both Misty and <em>Make Your Mark</em> to find their own voices<em>. </em>I’ve more or less enjoyed my time with it so far, and there are glimpses of a better series peeking through the cracks more and more with each passing episode. A joke that actually makes me laugh, a catchy song, hints at storylines that are slowly coming together, small moments that make me really like some of these characters.</p><p>But hey, even if this is as good as it gets? There are worse things for a cartoon to be than just more My Little Pony, I suppose. It’s still decently cute and fun. And I hope it resonates with its actual target audience, and that in 15 years those Generation Alpha kids with their higher emotional intelligence will be all grown up and writing their own overly-wordy articles about how actually <em>Make Your Mark </em>was the best one.</p><p>Pippchamp</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1015/1*SX1cEAUayAV0myhdTj6Uzw.png" /></figure><p><em>Hi, thanks for reading this! You’re now in the shameless plug zone. As of writing, I’ve got a video game coming out in December (Super Lesbian Animal RPG), which you can go wishlist </em><a href="https://store.steampowered.com/app/2124380/Super_Lesbian_Animal_RPG"><em>on Steam</em></a><em> right now. Right now!</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=6ad4bc69b65e" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Thoughts on Star]]></title>
            <link>https://ponett.medium.com/thoughts-on-star-fe9a7a96dc4a?source=rss-1885f92e94c5------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/fe9a7a96dc4a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[svtfoe]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[animation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[criticism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Bobby Schroeder]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 01 Aug 2021 21:05:43 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-09-25T21:49:05.511Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/1*w4nG_ubSFJE74cAbtGSb-w.png" /></figure><p>(<strong>EDIT 9/25/2024: </strong>This piece is <a href="https://ponett.dog/blog/thoughts-on-star-vs-the-forces-of-evil.html">now mirrored on my new personal blog</a>! I’m no longer using Medium, and can’t guarantee that this site won’t mess with my formatting or randomly lose chunks of the article, as it’s done in the past.)</p><p>I have a confession: I took entirely too long to watch Star vs. the Forces of Evil, and I put it off for petty reasons. For one, I thought the show gave off what I’d call “Parry Gripp energy.” Between things like Star’s signature move being a “narwhal blast” and, well, the multiple scenes where they literally play “Space Unicorn,” the show gave off this overly-wacky, perhaps semi-ironic lolrandom vibe. Fun for the kids in the target audience, but not necessarily for me.</p><p>It turns out I was dead wrong, and I was missing out! I mean, that Parry Gripp vibe is still kind of there, sure. But within minutes I was totally won over by the show’s rebellious attitude, wildly expressive animation, snappy humor, and instantly lovable characters. It has elements seen in other cartoons about young heroes balancing school life with magical adventures, but it executes those elements in a way that gives the series an identity all its own.</p><p>But the thing is, the first and last episodes of Star Vs. might as well be completely different shows. And not in a good way. I don’t <em>hate </em>the show it became — no series is flawless, and when it’s good, Star Vs. is phenomenal. But its failures are interesting. Unfortunately, a lot of the criticism from fans focuses too much on oversimplified complaints like “Toffee didn’t come back” or “the monster arm never came up again” or “the ship I like didn’t become canon.” So instead of skimming the surface, let’s dip down.</p><p><em>Writer’s note: I worry sometimes that being posted to Medium gives posts like this an air of legitimacy to folks who don’t know that Medium is literally just a blogging platform. Medium articles don’t have to be vetted by anyone, and I am not writing this professionally. I also don’t want this to get shared around as some kind of epic dunk on the show or its creators. I mostly liked the show! The people who made it should be proud! I am just one random woman sharing lukewarm takes on a children’s cartoon, and I’m only doing it here rather than on Tumblr because it’s easier on the eyes.</em></p><p><em>Here’s an unrelated Hotel Mario gif to further undermine this post’s legitimacy.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/540/1*mANX2QCj2w-AEOYBebUq3w.gif" /></figure><p>Now, the first two seasons are mostly episodic, so the easiest way to talk about what I love there is to talk about the characters.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/1*l0kuMX4lFaJ0CQksTuNaTQ.png" /></figure><h3>Star</h3><p>Star, as she’s introduced in season 1, is not just <em>a </em>manic pixie dream girl. She is <em>the </em>manic pixie dream girl. And she rules. She could have easily come off as annoying, but between the writing, animation, and Eden Sher’s performance, I loved her instantly.</p><p>Star is a loving embodiment of the hyperactive weird girl in school, except she is also literally a magic princess from another dimension. In this type of cartoon, you would probably expect this to be a secret, right? Star probably lives a double life and has to balance school with her magic adventures, and both comedy and drama spring up from her trying to keep them separate. Right? Nope! The show plays fast and loose with its fantasy elements, with Star hiding nothing from the people she meets on Earth, and that’s what makes the first two seasons so fun. Everyone knows Star’s whole deal from the start. She carries her wand with her everywhere she goes and fires off spells on a whim. In an early episode she turns her teacher into a troll, and she just… stays that way for the rest of the series? In one episode Star gets bored on a field trip and decides to take her whole class to another dimension where they all nearly die.</p><p>With so much chaos, you might think that Star might get in trouble with the Diaz parents, who she’s staying with as a foreign exchange student. Right? Wrong again! Marco’s parents love Star and her antics. They think it’s great when she transforms their living room with magic. They love the puppies she made that shoot lasers out of their eyes. (The unexpected dynamics with the parents extend to Star’s parents too, which I also liked a lot. While they seem like stern disciplinarians at first, King River actually has the boisterous personality of your typical fantasy dwarf, and he only gets more feral as the show progresses. Because of his informality, he has a very casual dynamic with Marco, to the point that they’re on a first name basis.)</p><p>Another thing I love about Star in these early seasons is that she doesn’t have to be a role model. It was apparently a conscious decision to not really portray Star as a superhero, and I love that. It fits the oddball tone of the show perfectly. In her time on Earth, Star doesn’t go out of her way to save people, and she only really fights villains when they come after her. Half the time she’s cleaning up her own messes. In school, she’s kind of a delinquent. She’s allowed to be weird and flawed and go on all these adventures with Marco without there always needing to be a tidy lesson for kids at the end of the episode. It doesn’t feel like they had an executive breathing down their necks going “what if Star is a bad influence,” and that makes her feel so refreshing.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/1*5SmZzte3u2Mygw76yAQTsw.png" /></figure><h3>Marco</h3><p>I wasn’t sure how I’d feel about Marco. Next to all the other characters, Marco is just kind of… a guy in a hoodie? He seemed boring. But I ended up liking him a lot. He’s the straight man to Star’s antics, and he feels integral to the show’s formula, to the point that the stretches where he isn’t interacting with Star much felt like some of the weakest parts of the show to me.</p><p>Marco isn’t <em>just </em>the straight man, though. He has his own eccentricities. He’ll gladly rush into battle alongside Star, and they explain his fighting skills by saying that… he’s a green belt in karate. Sure! It fits the tone of these early seasons. (Series creator Daron Nefcy has also cited Scott Pilgrim as one source of inspiration for the show’s style, and you can definitely see that with Marco’s whole deal as a dork who can inexplicably do crazy martial arts moves.) He could have been a total wet blanket, but nah. Marco’s fun.</p><p>Of course, for anyone who was on Tumblr in this show’s heyday, there’s an elephant in the room. And as a trans woman I know everyone is expecting me to address…</p><p>The trans Marco headcanons.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/1*cOc0PLY92_0Akss6D71C-Q.png" /></figure><p>Now, here’s the thing. I get it. I absolutely do.</p><p>There are so many little moments that you can point to as giving off trans vibes. Even aside from the princess disguise that he’s consistently totally casual about, there’s little stuff like comments about him being uncomfortable with his body, the way he covers his chest with a towel after showering, or all the stuff about being your true self. Believe me when I say I have come up with headcanons for much, much less, including reasons like “I like this character.” So I don’t begrudge anyone who supported this reading back during the show’s run, or who speculated about it on Tumblr, or who said they would have been happy if Marco was a trans girl. I would have been ecstatic myself!</p><p>It was just so hard to watch people getting into all these heated arguments on Tumblr about Marco’s gender and how revolutionary it makes the show and analyzing every little comment from the crew in the hopes that it would happen, when... it’s <em>Disney. </em>I don’t wanna rub salt in the wound — again, it would’ve ruled if they did this, and folks were eager for it because there’s so little good trans representation out there. But it was so obvious that Disney would never approve of it, no matter what the crew wanted. And the crew meant for these little moments to be jokes. Not necessarily jokes at Marco’s expense, but jokes nonetheless. (I mean, his princess alias is literally “Princess Turdina.”) It’s not the first time a cartoon for girls has had jokes about the male lead being kind of girly by association.</p><p>Constant fandom discourse was, in fact, the other big reason I put off watching Star Vs. for so long. All I ever saw was fans bickering about stuff like this. But, again, I’m glad that I finally got around to watching it now.</p><p>There’s much more to say involving both Star and Marco, but for now let’s skim over some other characters.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/1*3QmJhYhQ0P0PqR9OexrAqg.png" /></figure><h4>Ludo</h4><p>Ludo is ostensibly the main antagonist for the first two seasons of the show. He’s fun as far as your typical megalomaniacal villains with delusions of grandeur go, and Alan Tudyk puts in a great performance here. However, the show basically forgets Ludo exists in the last season, so there really isn’t much to say about him.</p><h4>Toffee</h4><p>Speaking of villains, sorry to disappoint, but I have little to say about Toffee. He’s lizard Magneto. He’s cool. He isn’t actually in the show much. I don’t really care that he stayed dead because he still gets the last laugh. Moving on.</p><h4>Pony Head</h4><p>I’d never really seen people talk about Pony Head, so I had no idea what she was actually like. I just knew she was a wacky magic flying unicorn head.</p><p>It turns out Pony Head is one of my favorite characters.</p><p>I expected her to kind of be like, I don’t know… a generic My Little Pony parody, maybe? Sickeningly cutesy in an ironic way? Instead she’s Jenny Slate being a horrible toxic party girl, and that performance makes her one of the funniest characters in the show. A lot of fans seem to hate her because she’s narcissistic, possessive, mean, and, well, crazy, but I just love her for that. She’s horrible and it’s funny that she’s horrible.</p><p>I think she only starts to feel out of place to some people because she never grows or learns her lesson, even as the show gets more serious and other characters like Star become more heroic and responsible. But like, to me, that’s just Pony Head keeping the original madcap spirit of the show alive.</p><p>The crew also clearly had a lot of fun drawing her and I appreciate that. This is truly peak character design:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/1*pa133mv0sQ6_w-LenHjcjg.png" /></figure><h4>Tom</h4><p>Ignoring the romantic drama for now, I ended up liking Tom, Star’s on-again-off-again half-demon boyfriend. In the early seasons I thought it was really funny that they kept playing up Tom as this bad boy toxic ex of Star’s when they must have broken up when they were like… 13? So I’m glad he got to have an arc where he worked through his teenage anger issues.</p><h4>Janna</h4><p>Since the first two seasons have Star and Marco going to school, they need a lot of classmates. Most of them are stock teens — the popular girl, the nerds, the cool girl Marco has a crush on, etc. (One of Marco’s dorky friends, Alfonzo, is very clearly voiced by Homestar Runner co-creator Matt Chapman. I like him because of this.) A lot of them start to disappear in season 2 because the writers just had nothing to do with them.</p><p>The odd one out is Janna, who goes from a minor extra to a main character. She loves dark magic, and there are tons of increasingly absurd jokes about her invading Marco’s privacy off-screen, which escalate from her stealing his stuff to her apparently hypnotizing him so she can make him fall asleep on command. When the show shifts its focus from Earth to Mewni, Janna inexplicably starts showing up there too. In a show full of oddball characters, it makes sense that Janna would be the one classmate who stuck around.</p><h4>Kelly</h4><p>Kelly’s okay. She ends up being a surprisingly prominent character, but I also… don’t really get what her role is supposed to be? What’s her deal? It feels like she ends up mostly existing to be another point on the shipping web in seasons 3 and 4. I dunno. She’s fine. Kelly’s fine.</p><h4>Oskar</h4><p>I’m going to single out Oskar as another one of Star’s classmates who I liked. He’s fun as the weird kid with inexplicable vampire fangs who makes indie music and lives in his car, and Jon Heder is great in the role. I wish we saw more of him, but I’m glad they at least remembered he existed in the last few episodes on Earth.</p><p>More characters will come up organically as we talk about the story. Speaking of which…</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/1*jLzoAnUxu8Yyy3FCR-kOTw.png" /></figure><h3>Things start to change</h3><p>The season 1 finale, where Star has her first dramatic confrontation with Toffee, is the first time the show really gets serious. This leads to multiple shifts in style, including a complete overhaul of the animation style. This made me a little sad at first.</p><p>The first few episodes were animated by Mercury Filmworks, known for their work from Wander Over Yonder and the recent Mickey Mouse shorts, among many other shows. Despite effectively being a Flash cartoon they managed to capture this hand drawn energy that almost makes it look like a cool indie graphic novel come to life. It’s perfect for this show. Characters are all bouncy and fun, snapping between all sorts of dynamic poses to suit the comedy and the action as needed. In a lot of shows like this the fight scenes can feel more like an obligation than a selling point, but it’s just so fun to watch Star and Marco do their thing because of the way they move. That fight scene in the convenience store parking lot at the end of the first episode is what had me totally hooked on the show.</p><p>After a transitional period in late season 1, season 2 gives the show a more typical hand drawn style. And it still looks good for sure! But it looks like your typical 2010s cartoon, and the lack of that dynamic motion changes the vibe of the show.</p><p>Still, once I got used to it, the second season was also a lot of fun. The show was clearly starting to become more serious with an overarching serialized story, big mysteries, and more focus on romance (again, we’ll get to that), but this was all balanced out with plenty of one-off adventures like those seen in the first season.</p><h3>Nitpicks with seasons 1 and 2</h3><p>It’s easy to oversimplify things say that the first two seasons were perfect and they ruined it later on, so in fairness here are some things I liked less in the first half of the show.</p><p>One thing that struck me is that the show doesn’t tend to treat its fat characters all that great. Most of the heroes are super thin, while the minor fat characters like Miss Skullnick and Marco’s friend Ferguson are generally supposed to be gross and obnoxious, with ill-fitting clothes and exaggerated pudge always spilling out over their waistlines. It’s not the end of the world I guess (lots of cartoons have this problem), but it’s not great either.</p><p>There’s also Marco’s crush on Jackie. Knowing that Marco was gonna end up with Star anyway didn’t help, but the fact that so much time is spent on Marco’s crush on a girl who he’s never actually spoken to, is just… so tiring. I never like these kinds of stories where a character has a crush on someone they don’t even know, and it didn’t help that Jackie only started to be fleshed out as a character <em>after </em>she started dating Marco, at which point they were already teasing Starco.</p><p>(Way later, towards the end of the show, Jackie comes back after a long absence and we find out she has a girlfriend. Well, okay, they don’t say it, because Disney, but it’s <em>implied</em>. It’s a nice little gesture, I suppose. I’m sure the writers fought for that one, and I’m sure they would’ve done more if they could. But we only really see Jackie’s implied girlfriend for one scene, and Jackie herself already felt like an underdeveloped character, so it didn’t exactly blow me away.)</p><p>Season 2 also introduces a recurring subplot where we see Marco as a rugged adult hero due to him spending nearly 20 years fighting in another dimension where time works differently. While he always changes back when he returns home, this recurring subplot is <em>deeply weird </em>to me because they keep having him remind everyone that he remembers everything and that he’s actually in his 30s now. I’m not gonna make any hyperbolic accusations about this being unforgivably problematic or whatever, but like… it is <em>weird.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/1*Q2bKJL0cdKt53zmenVPzcQ.jpeg" /></figure><h3><strong>A very finite multiverse</strong></h3><p>I will reiterate that I don’t <em>hate </em>seasons 3 and 4 as a whole, but things start to feel off with season 3, when the show leaves Earth.</p><p>One of the best things about the early seasons is that you never know where Star and Marco will go next, with them bouncing between Earth, Mewni, and a seemingly endless list of other colorful worlds. Season 3 throws that out. Most of the rest of the show takes place exclusively on Star’s home planet of Mewni. The scope of the series starts to feel claustrophobic. Star and Marco rarely visit other worlds. Most of the Earth cast is rarely seen again. The intro and outro are updated to remove the Earth stuff. (The second ending theme does go hard, though.) Even characters who you would assume must be from other zany worlds, like Pony Head or Tom, are revealed to actually be from other kingdoms on Mewni. Almost every episode has to exist to serve the ongoing main plot on Mewni.</p><p>And like, I get why they would do this. Look at how people (especially adults) talk about cartoons online. Any time a new episode doesn’t advance the main plot, fans will immediately bemoan it as filler. People want the stakes to constantly be raised, the drama to get ratcheted up, the big mysteries to be unraveled. That’s what gets all the praise, not slice of life comedies or monster-of-the-week shows.</p><p>So I get the rationale. But in some ways this show ends up feeling like a cautionary tale about how not every cartoon can pull off that shift. We have a real plot now, but again, the world feels like it’s shrunk. Everything revolves around a few characters on Mewni— mainly the Butterfly family, the Magic High Commission, and Glossaryck. And it all comes back to…</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/1*bbuqB_7B5T0mH63sFh4IsQ.png" /></figure><h3>Monster racism</h3><p>All of the major conflicts in Star Vs. lead back to one thing: the centuries-long divide between Star’s people, the Mewmans, and the monsters.</p><p>I can’t say this wasn’t telegraphed early on. Season 1 had “Lobster Claws,” which first introduced the idea that Ludo’s monster goons could change, and “Mewnipendance Day,” which… well, made it blatantly clear that the Mewmans are violent colonizers. Season 2 takes this further, painting more of the monsters like Buff Frog as sympathetic and showing what the inequality on Mewni looks like from their perspective. But in seasons 3 and 4, this becomes the main focus.</p><p>Now I think people can sometimes be unfair in media criticism when they confuse allegory for applicability. Every story has many potential readings, and you can always find unintended parallels, but that doesn’t necessarily mean it needs to be judged as an explicit allegory for one specific thing. With this, though, there are so many direct allusions to real world racism and colonialism (including both America’s history <em>and </em>modern day issues) that it’s hard to read this as anything but a direct allegory. In the final story arc the villain even proclaims “this kingdom used to be great, but not anymore”, and a Mewman village has erected a wall to keep monsters out. It is <em>not </em>subtle.</p><p>Despite these being huge, systemic problems that no one person can fix, Star keeps coming up with ideas for special events that she thinks will bring peace between the two groups. The first time it happened, I was like, okay. This is a kids’ show. Star is 14. She’s naïve. Maybe she’ll learn a lesson here. But… she keeps doing it? She thinks a petition will fix racism. A party will fix racism. A live TV special will fix racism. An “integrated” sporting event will fix racism. When the show does finally try to be a little more nuanced in one such episode, the message is that the adults are probably too far gone, but the next generation will be better. In other words, it’s the tired argument that we just have to “wait for the old bigots to die.”</p><p>Much has already been written about the ways in which fantasy racism allegories fail to reflect real life. But for a while I thought that, for as trite as all this is, maybe Star Vs. would at least avoid the common pitfall of giving a rational historical reason for why the oppressed group is hated. And then, sure enough, the reveal: the one monster king in the history of Star’s kingdom ate a guy. The truth is more complicated than that (the guy who got ate deserved it), but the show doesn’t really get into that, leaving the Mewmans with an excuse for their bigotry. They’re still painted as being in the wrong, of course, but it’s still so disappointing for the show to go there at all.</p><p>The fact that the monsters have become sympathetic also means that the show massively cuts down on the number of fight scenes in the back half with few real villains around to fill in for Ludo’s gang. In a lot of cartoons I wouldn’t mind this, but the fights were always so fun and energetic in the first season that this is one of those rare instances where it does feel like a loss.</p><p>I did say that I didn’t entirely hate seasons 3 and 4 though. There are still some good one-off episodes in there, and within the main story there’s one new character who really shines.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/1*EmD0omSDLUjwKXnwbpU3zw.png" /></figure><h3>Eclipsa</h3><p>It’s a good thing I like Eclipsa, because boy does this series turn into The Eclipsa Show a lot!</p><p>Eclipsa was a queen from 300 years ago who experimented with “dark magic” and ran off with a monster husband. Her reign is generally treated as the darkest period in the Butterfly family’s history, and her section in Star’s spellbook is initially locked away for being too dangerous. But as it turns out, Eclipsa has been trapped in a crystal this whole time, meaning she’s still alive. And when she’s eventually freed… she’s totally chill.</p><p>The show keeps the audience guessing about her true motives for a while, but ultimately Eclipsa doesn’t have a single evil bone in her body. She’s actually one of the kindest and most affable characters in the whole show. She just doesn’t care about society’s definitions of “good” and “evil,” and also she’s goth, and kind of a rock star to boot. (Eclipsa being both goth and a walking ray of sunshine makes her an accurate representation of a bunch of goth people I’ve known in my life.) And all this while being not a rebellious teen going through a phase, but a grown woman who’s married with a kid.</p><p>So yes, for all its flaws, I’m happy that I stuck with this show to the end, and Eclipsa is a big part of why. She’s just so much fun. Unfortunately, while I would have loved to see Eclipsa go on adventures or be a cool leader or just be herself, she has little time to do this.</p><p>Eclipsa spends much of season 3 under house arrest in the castle while Star’s mom and the Magic High Commission debate over her fate. When it’s discovered that the queen who succeeded Eclipsa wasn’t her real daughter (because her real daughter was half-monster) and that Star and Moon aren’t real descendants of the royal family, Star gives the throne back to Eclipsa.</p><p>(Even ignoring Eclipsa’s arc, so much of the back half of Star Vs. revolves around the politics of the royal family. I’ll admit I have a lower tolerance for this kind of thing than a lot of people, but it felt like such a massive step down from the goofball adventures of the first two seasons. Like, just because you said Star is a princess doesn’t mean we have to devote so many episodes to the inner workings of the monarchy, especially if it’s going to be this dry.)</p><p>Throughout season 4, Eclipsa is in charge, but she’s unable to really do anything because she has no public support. A central part of the conflict here is that Eclipsa’s monster husband, Globgor, is <em>also </em>trapped in a crystal like Eclipsa was. (Globgor is also a total sweetheart, might I add? Eclipsa’s lucky.) However, she can’t free him because the racist Mewmans are still afraid of him and it will hurt her already dismal approval ratings. So we get multiple episodes where Eclipsa tries some sneaky method of freeing her wrongfully imprisoned husband, only for Star to get mad and scold her for not doing things “the right way.”</p><p>Yes, Star, the girl who once filled a high school football field with death traps because she took a comment about her school’s team getting “slaughtered” too literally, is now a huge nark who cares about doing things by the book. I get that she’s got this typical arc where a young hero becomes more responsible over time, and I get that Eclipsa’s chaotic good nature is supposed to make her a foil to showcase how far Star’s come. But it’s still so disappointing to see Star lose her rebellious charm. She thinks that Eclipsa’s life needs to be structured entirely around what will or won’t piss off the bigots who already hate her. Even if she and Globgor did nothing wrong, even if it’s clear that the Magic High Commission completely fucked them and their daughter over, she still has to do everything through the proper channels so that she looks respectable. Man, fuck that! Just go free your husband!!</p><p>This whole arc comes to a head with “Cornonation,” when Globgor is freed during Eclipsa’s official coronation and all hell breaks loose. Star gets mad at Eclipsa because she thinks she did it, but it turns out a member of the Magic High Commission did it in order to frame Eclipsa and try to take the throne from her. This all backfires when the crowd at the coronation sees the gentle way Globgor treats his and Eclipsa’s baby daughter, Meteora, and they all realize that he’s just a normal dad like any other.</p><p>Yes, after multiple episodes about how Star can’t end racism with a single event… Globgor being a chill dad at the coronation was what did it. They like him and Eclipsa now! At this point I was so tired of this arc that I just accepted it. Eclipsa can just be a cool leader now, right? WRONG! Because with only a few episodes left, THIS is the point where the show finally decides to return to Earth. But it’s okay. Racism on Mewni is over!! Or IS IT??? But hold on, before we get to the final battle, it’s time for everyone’s favorite part of the show…</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/1*h4XYhBzL5kw6UNH-rynkAw.png" /></figure><h3>SHIPPING!!!</h3><p>At first, Star had a crush on Oskar, but then she started crushing on Marco. But oh no, Marco has always had a crush on Jackie, and now they’re dating!! Star tries to rekindle her feelings for Oskar, but it’s too late! She likes Marco more! Marco finds out Star has a crush on him, and he starts to like her back! So he breaks up with Jackie so he can go be with Star on Mewni, but <em>uh oh</em>! During that time Star got back with her ex, Tom! But oh snap, now Star and Marco are alone together and due to extraneous circumstances they have to KISS! But Star is still dating Tom, and now it’s even more awkward! And now Marco is kind of ambiguously maybe going out with Kelly as a rebound? But not really I guess, they’re just “breakup buddies.” But oh, it turns out Star and Marco have just been cursed this whole time! They don’t actually love each other! They’re just friends. Phew! Let’s spend an entire 22-minute episode breaking the curse. Okay, great. Everything’s settled now. It’s OVER. Oh, whoops, it’s NOT over, they still like each other!!! And Tom can tell! So now Tom’s breaking up with Star, and THAT sure is awkward, but Marco’s afraid to make a move! But finally, with less than an hour left in the series, they have a moment together in the final arc to confess that they’re still in love with each other, at which point they kiss again and start dating.</p><p>Now imagine that, stretched over 77 episodes.</p><p>Like, look. I have no horse in this race when it comes to Star Vs. shipping. If they wanted to pair Star and Marco up, that’s fine. They clearly have chemistry, and it was hinted at from the first season. They’re cute together! And you know, there’s something powerful about Star, the Quirky Weird Girl, finding love without having to change anything about herself. This is also far from the worst love triangle nonsense I’ve ever seen. Everyone’s respectful the whole time, and Marco and Tom get along great instead of bickering over Star. (Which just made me think they should be poly, but, again, Disney.) And to be fair, sometimes it’s good to explore other romantic options for your lead characters just so you can prove that the endgame pairing really is The One, and that they aren’t just settling or being forced together.</p><p>But the show wastes so much time on this will they/won’t they nonsense that even after years of slow burn Starco pining it somehow STILL feels rushed in the end. They wait so long to actually resolve it that there’s no time left to explore what their relationship looks like now. When Star calls Marco her boyfriend in the finale I was like, wait, what? They’re going steady?</p><p>What kills me is that, if they wanted a source of juicy relationship drama other than love triangles? They had an alternative. “The Knight Shift” reveals that Marco doesn’t plan on staying on Mewni forever, because at some point he’ll want to have a normal life on Earth and go to college and whatnot. Now he and Star start to worry that growing up will lead them down different paths in life. If they had already been dating at this point then the question of whether or not this teenage romance will last would be a perfect source of tension! (And this is EXACTLY what they do in the finale. But by then it was too late.)</p><p>But like, this is it? Star and Marco can visit any dimension on a whim and go on whatever adventures they want, and what we’re focusing on most of the time is this merry-go-round of teen romance, a tired fantasy racism allegory, and royal family drama? It’s not <em>just </em>that there was a shift in tone. Tons of shows pull that off. It’s that the things they chose to focus on are boring.</p><h3>Praise for seasons 3 and 4</h3><p>I swear I still like this show overall, so let’s balance this out a little with some random things I liked in the last two seasons:</p><ul><li>The episodes about Star’s spells. (Yes, I’ll get to them.)</li><li>The Pony Head episodes. Yes, even the ones where she’s at her worst! ESPECIALLY those episodes!! She’s FUNNY I love her</li><li>Any time they went back to Earth. That last stretch of episodes back on Earth was particularly nice and felt like a return to form in some ways</li><li>The episode where we finally find out how Janna got to Mewni off-screen</li><li>The joke with Marco’s old friends about how actually DnD is cool with a diverse audience now</li><li>Some folks seem to dislike the final arc of season 3 with Meteora as a villain, but I dunno. I thought it worked. It felt like they struck the right balance between drama, action, and comedy</li><li>The start of season 4 where Star and Marco got to go on adventures to new locations with Star’s dad. River is fun, even if the subplot of Moon losing her memory was resolved super quickly</li><li>Nachos the dragon-cycle is cute. I want to pet her</li><li>The episode where we finally see Globgor interacting with Eclipsa is ADORABLE. She’s living the dream</li></ul><p>Okay, enough beating around the bush.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/1*R7vLwO9uSOTAZSP0tB0tAA.png" /></figure><h3>The final arc</h3><p>(Quick side note: despite rumors that the ending was rushed due to a sudden cancelation mid-production, series creator Daron Nefcy said in an AMA that season 4 was always written to be the end.)</p><p>The final villain is none other than Mina Loveberry, the deranged magical warrior first introduced in season 2 who has more than a passing resemblance to Sailor Moon and the voice of Princess Carolyn. A lot of fans were apparently disappointed that the final villain was her and not Toffee, the show’s Magneto. But eh. It made sense to me. Mina is the embodiment of all the skeletons in the Butterfly family closet, being the last in a line of super soldiers made to oppress monster kind. With the show being all about that conflict in its later years, it made sense for the last threat to be a Mewman who hates monsters and wants to take the throne back from Eclipsa and Globgor, and Mina fits the bill there.</p><p>Of course, Mina isn’t alone. We soon find out that Mina has been taking orders from Star’s mother, (former) Queen Moon, who thinks that she needs to take the throne back for the good of her people.</p><p>While the show had its ups and downs, this is the exact point where the final arc starts to completely fall apart for me. Moon had her problems with Eclipsa, sure, and there have been times when she butted heads with Star. And I was also starting to worry about her during the subplot about her becoming the leader of a makeshift village of displaced Mewmans who were bitter that Eclipsa gave the monsters their land back. But she was also portrayed throughout the show as a rational individual and responsible to a fault, and she had worked with Eclipsa in the past. So to say that Moon was behind the attempts to dethrone Eclipsa, and that she’s behind Mina and her new army of monster hating super soldiers, and that she thought someone as crazy and bigoted as Mina would just… stop when commanded? That Mina wouldn’t take things too far? I mean, come on.</p><p>Things manage to get worse, though, because this isn’t really a twist where Moon ends up being the villain! After she’s like “oh no, I didn’t think Mina would go this far, I just wanted Eclipsa to surrender the throne,” she has to work with Star and co. for the rest of the arc, helping them pull off the plan that ultimately saves the day. And in the end… Star readily forgives her mother. Like it was nothing! Like Moon didn’t literally threaten a race war to take back the throne! She isn’t even really sorry, but Star says “I want to be the kind of family where Moms mess up and we figure it out.” I was in awe that after getting so deep into the politics for so long they would try to walk it back to be a simple family dispute.</p><p>What’s this big plan to stop Mina and her army though? Well, Star comes up with one last plan to end racism:</p><p>To destroy all magic.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/1*etf0IUmE4Qt9pNNcfWy2_Q.png" /></figure><h3>The problem with magic</h3><p>It’s easy to find tons of armchair critics online who will tell you that the most important thing for a story with magic is for the magic to have clearly defined rules. And honestly, that’s bullshit. Twin Peaks is full of surreal, unexplainable magic that works off of vague dream logic, but that’s half of the appeal. What’s really important is for the presence of magic in a story to support the intended narrative. A more interesting question than “how does the magic work” is “what does magic mean to this world,” and that’s a question that Star Vs. ends up asking with its finale.</p><p>Unfortunately, the answer they landed on seems to have pleased no one.</p><p>In defense of this decision, the idea that magic is a tool of oppression in this story doesn’t come out of nowhere. Toffee hated the Butterfly family’s use of magic against monster kind the whole time, the Magic High Commission are clearly corrupt, and when the wand was created it was given to the first Mewman settlers (who were actually lost humans from Earth who had crossed over through the Realm of Magic, as we learn later) to use in their colonization of Mewni. There are also plenty of times where the magic in the show is supposed to be dark and ominous, or just flat out a stupid thing for Star to be messing with.</p><p>This is absolutely <em>not</em> a consistent theme, though. The biggest counter-example is Star’s spells. Her narwhal blasts and her warnicorn stampedes have been summoning sentient creatures with free will, as it turn out, and they all live in a palace inside her wand and hang out together. Even the non-animal based spells are anthropomorphized in there and turned into sympathetic characters with their own little stories. And when Star destroys all magic, they all just… die off-screen. Fans tend to throw around “Star committed genocide” when talking about this ending, and I don’t think that’s really fair. Everyone who died was like, a magical construct, and aside from her spells we only know four characters who die. But it’s like… she’s still <em>killing </em>them. It’s still wild that the show doesn’t even acknowledge this.</p><p>The Magic High Commission also dies with the destruction of all magic, but they suck, so eh. Fuck ’em. I know fans love Hekapoo for being cute, but it’s still… weird to me? That Marco is buddies with her even though she’s complicit in all the horrible things done to Eclipsa and her family? They make a point to depict Hekapoo as the least bad of the group, but she was still a part of that, and she still had it out for Eclipsa. My opinion of her aside, though, it’s very bizarre that Star is so casual about sacrificing Hekapoo.</p><p>There’s one more character who dies with the destruction of magic, though, and that’s Glossaryck. I’ve mostly avoided talking about him until this point, but he’s one of the most important characters in the entire show, and also kind of the poster child for the unsatisfying direction the story went in.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/1*bvleoQUbN5HSc8GN-p2arw.png" /></figure><p>Glossaryck (whose voice suddenly changes from Jeffrey Tambor to Keith David because… well, you know) is introduced in season 1 as the funny little wizard who lives in Star’s spellbook. He’s basically Clippy, except fully self-aware and even less helpful. He is but one of many fun, eccentric characters for Star and Marco to interact with in this multiverse. By the end of the series, Glossaryck has been revealed as a Dr. Manhattan-style neutral character who knows everything that’s going to happen, the creator of the Magic High Commission, and basically the embodiment of all magic in the universe<em>. </em>(A tie-in book apparently reveals that he was “created by the universe as a means of understanding all of the magic that flows within it.”)</p><p>Through time travel Glossaryck created the wand and gave it to the first settlers of Mewni to oppress the native monsters, and he also stoked Toffee’s hatred of magic on the monster side. Again, like Dr. Manhattan, he knows everything that’s going to happen and doesn’t really care about any of it. He just does what’s needed for the timeline. It was Star’s destiny to destroy all magic, and he ensured that this happened by… creating the centuries-long conflict that made magic a tool of oppression in the first place?</p><p>I don’t fucking know, man.</p><p>So yes, magic did create this whole conflict. But destroying magic and ending the monarchy doesn’t actually fix it at this point. Taking away Mina’s magic ends the current threat, but as she points out, the bigotry that she embodies isn’t just going to go away. That history isn’t undone. And, in fact, I can only assume that things will get worse with what happens in the last scene of the show. To ensure that Star and Marco can stay together, Mewni and Earth are merged into a single world. On the surface it’s supposed to be touching, and it <em>kind of</em> is, but I just can’t help but wonder about all the new conflicts that will arise from this. The show went to great lengths to show all the problems that arose from Mewmans coming to Mewni, and now we have to throw modern Earth humans into the mix too?</p><p>But even with this new fantastical fused world to explore, the universe of the show is left feeling small and sad. The magic is gone. While it was framed as a tool of oppression by the end, it was also the thing that gave the show its entire identity! Star being the rebellious princess who used magic however she wanted! On Earth, magic was what made Star different from everyone else. It was counterculture. But instead of making her an outcast, she was surrounded by people who loved and supported her eccentricities. And she used that magic to travel to different worlds and make likeminded friends! But that’s just gone now. Some characters who should theoretically be magical beings like Pony Head and Tom are allowed to live, so they’re still around, but the full extent of magic’s role in this world outside of the Butterfly family is unclear. One thing that IS explicit, though, is that the dimensional portals are all gone. Anyone from a world other than Earth or Mewni? Goodbye! They’ll never ever see Kelly again because they can’t make portals anymore. No more adventures in other dimensions ever again.</p><p>I want to like this ending so bad! I really do! On paper I think it rules that Star’s ultimate decision is to give up her own power and end the monarchy for the greater good. I love stories where people realize that the system is broken beyond repair and decide to burn it all down. But the way she accomplishes this raises so many more questions and leaves the universe of the show in a less interesting state. They barely even spend any time debating this decision to rid the entire multiverse of magic before they go through with this plan. They never wonder if magic could be used as a tool for good instead of just oppression. I could see some of the groundwork for this decision, sure, but if they wanted to end on that shocking note then they should’ve spent more time having Star question whether or not magic is a good thing instead of going in circles with love triangles and attempts to end racism through respectability politics.</p><p>So, where does that leave us? Well, even after all that… I still liked the show.</p><p>I know, I know. The ending sucked. The romance sucked. So much of the main plot was lame. But no show is perfect, and there was still so much I fell in love with in there. The characters, the humor, the art, the action, the world. Even with all my complaints, there’s a lot here that the folks who worked on this show should be super proud of. I’ll be thinking back fondly on this cast for years to come, and I’m glad that a show this fun and unique exists — not just for adults like me, but for kids lucky enough to grow up with it.</p><p>I wouldn’t go back and stop myself from watching this show, even if I did just write thousands of words about how the ending stinks. I’d even still recommend it! (Just… maybe stop after Eclipsa’s coronation and pretend that’s the happy ending. Or maybe you’ll like the ending better than I did! I don’t know you.) Because sometimes what matters is the friends made along the way. Friends like my new beloved toxic fave, Flying Princess Pony Head.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/1*7AMS8LfOdhjy0x7sbv5LuA.png" /></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=fe9a7a96dc4a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Thoughts on Aggretsuko Season 3]]></title>
            <link>https://ponett.medium.com/thoughts-on-aggretsuko-season-3-e223d95f9578?source=rss-1885f92e94c5------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e223d95f9578</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[aggretsuko]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[criticism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Bobby Schroeder]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 30 Aug 2020 19:41:15 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-09-25T21:49:49.060Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>(<strong>EDIT 9/25/2024: </strong>This piece is <a href="https://ponett.dog/blog/thoughts-on-aggretsuko-season-3.html">now mirrored on my new personal blog</a>! I’m no longer using Medium, and can’t guarantee that this site won’t mess with my formatting or randomly lose chunks of the article, as it’s done in the past.)</p><p><em>Note: This isn’t a comprehensive review. This is just one blogger’s spoiler-filled thoughts that were too wordy for Twitter.</em></p><p><em>Content warning for descriptions of misogynistic harassment and violence, stalking, and that sort of thing. No pictures, though.</em></p><p>Two years after its strong premiere season, <em>Aggretsuko</em> has become one of the most frustrating shows I follow. It still has tons of fun moments, but it’s also the kind of story that chickens out every time it’s close to an epiphany about its characters and themes.</p><p>Each season of <em>Aggretsuko</em> follows a cyclical pattern. It starts with Retsuko dealing with the hardships of life as an average millennial with a shitty office job. She wants a better life, but she doesn’t know what that means for her. She feels trapped. She’s relatable and easy to sympathize with. At some point she’ll latch onto some fairy tale fantasy that she thinks will save her. Things seem perfect to her for a while, but the cracks start to show. In the climax of the season she realizes it won’t work, and then things return to the status quo.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*04cc9FSFUFULuuvp5CmFuQ.png" /></figure><p>In season 1, Retsuko’s fantasy was getting married, having kids, and becoming a housewife so that she could quit her job. She tried to force herself into a relationship with Resasuke out of convenience, but this was doomed to fail. In season 2, she started dating the dreamy tech entrepreneur Tadano, only to realize that her own needs weren’t being fulfilled. The finale hinged upon Retsuko standing up for her own dreams instead of just accepting Tadano’s. I love this in theory, but the problem was that the only dreams the show could come up with for her were, again, marriage, kids, and her crappy office job. Obviously there’s nothing wrong with wanting those things, but she didn’t have a life or any aspirations outside of society’s default expectations for her, even though the show had previously painted other characters like Retsuko’s mother putting these expectations on her as a bad thing.</p><p>So I was pleasantly surprised when the poster for season 3 dropped, and it seemed like Retsuko would be joining a band inspired by Babymetal. I knew it would likely be another fantasy that fell apart, but it also seemed like a fun curveball that might help Retsuko learn more about herself. She’d finally have a life outside of work, dating, and venting about work and dating at karaoke.</p><p>And that’s… <em>sort of </em>what we got? But it’s more complicated than that.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*xuTWAL0saq_QouxJWpI-cg.png" /></figure><h3>So this time Retsuko becomes an idol</h3><p>Through a silly series of events involving a parking lot fender bender with a manager, Retsuko eventually joins an idol group. Not a band. An idol group. That might not seem like an important distinction, but it is. Instead of her new music career being a creative outlet for her, Retsuko is roped into an extremely toxic industry that revolves more around encouraging an obsessive fandom culture to make a record label lots of money. (If this description is somehow news to you, Googling “idol industry” brings up endless articles recounting horror stories about current and former idols. Take your pick.)</p><p>While I won’t say this arc is all bad, I have… mixed feelings. It’s frustrating considering how close the show came to a big epiphany early on. Pushed to the limit by her debts, in one of her death metal interludes Retsuko literally screams “Screw you, capitalism!” and starts to rant about being stuck in the rat race. And yeah, I don’t expect a show made by Sanrio to go full anti-capitalist or anything. But for a little bit, Retsuko understands the real root of her problems. Instead of dwelling on that, the show just gives her a new side gig that placates her.</p><p>In this portion of the arc, it sort of feels like the show is devolving into some meaningless platitude like “if you enjoy your job, you’ll never have to work a day in your life.” Yeah, Retsuko is still working her ass off for a job where her coworkers talk shit on her (on top of still having her 9 to 5 office job). And yeah, she was basically forced into this. And yeah, she’s being paid next to nothing for it. But she’s kind of enjoying the hustle now, so it’s okay! Right?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*YmWFzE-bBGAWGNHh1rl2Wg.png" /></figure><p>Still, while I have reservations, I <em>mostly</em> enjoyed Retsuko’s arc in the first half of the season. After seeing her at her lowest, she suddenly had a job she was passionate about! She was utilizing her talents! She was getting more confident! Her growing friendship with the rest of the group is cute, and I like these new characters! There was finally more to her life than office work and wanting a husband! Even if it was never going to last, it felt like a step in the right direction for her.</p><p>Some fans will be disappointed that she didn’t remain an idol at the end of the season, saying she “gave up her dream,” but it was never really <em>her</em> dream to begin with. It wasn’t even her idea, and she had to be forced every step of the way to get there. It was this season’s pipe dream, like her past relationships with Resasuke and Tadano. My hope was that she’d realize that the idol industry wasn’t her perfect escapist fantasy, but maybe still get something out of the experience. Maybe she’ll hold onto that newfound confidence and start some dinky little garage band with some friends. Or maybe she’ll just be less shy about inviting people to karaoke. Who knows.</p><p>The show <em>did </em>end up grappling with how toxic idol culture can get before she quit, though. It went further than I ever imagined. But first, we need to talk about the elephant in the room — or I guess, rather, the hyena.</p><h3>Haida</h3><p>The show clearly expects me to find Haida’s crush on Retsuko cute, but at this point I just want to slap him, and I know I’m not alone.</p><p>Three seasons in, Haida still isn’t over Retsuko rejecting him, and he’s only gotten worse. Yeah, everyone feels like shit after getting rejected, but Haida’s way beyond that. It’s been two years. His crush has developed into this complex over a girl from his work. As several characters point out, he barely even knows her, and yet almost every single second of screentime he gets is spent thinking about Retsuko. Fenneko says he’s had his heart set on dating Retsuko for <em>five years. </em>And he only gets worse and worse.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/905/1*D8WGIFIX4qbxNcMawiQiVw.png" /></figure><p>Midway through season 3, Haida grows suspicious of Retsuko’s personal life, and decides to start following her. He spies on her leaving her apartment, follows her to the airport, <em>buys a plane ticket to follow her across the country, </em>follows her onto a train (staring at her from the next car over), and then follows her to a gig with her idol group. (Gori is also there because she’s nosy, but even she knows better than to get on the plane.) And yeah, they play it off as Haida thinking Retsuko might be in trouble, but come the fuck on. It’s obvious she’s fine at the airport.</p><p>In other words, Haida has become a stalker. I know some of you are rolling your eyes at that sentence, but put aside your opinion of Haida and just think about his actions in this season. The thought of a coworker acting like this, <em>especially </em>after getting shot down, is a nightmare to most women. (Haida also outright says that he and Gori are acting like stalkers at the beginning of the scene. If you’re mad at me for not criticizing Gori more: yeah, Gori is also behaving inappropriately, but Haida takes things way further and is ultimately rewarded for it.)</p><p>Put yourself in Retsuko’s shoes. This coworker she politely turned down two seasons ago still thinks about her every waking moment of the day, even though they barely talk. What she sees as a casual but supportive friendship is actually something completely different to him. He won’t explicitly ask her out again, but every single nice gesture from Haida comes burdened with the expectation that she’ll eventually reciprocate his feelings. Every day she doesn’t, he gets more upset. What if Retsuko turns him down again? Will he take “no” for an answer this time? If he just keeps bugging her, Retsuko can’t exactly avoid him— they sit next to each other at work. And Fenneko, Washimi, and Gori aren’t helping, flip-flopping back and forth between calling Haida an idiot and egging him on.</p><p>What makes this even more frustrating is that Haida is given the perfect way out on a silver platter. This season introduces a new character from another department at Retsuko and Haida’s work, a dog girl named Inui. She’s sweet, she’s cute, she shares Haida’s passion for old school rock, she’s a great cook, and, most importantly, <em>she likes him</em>. It’s almost absurd how perfect Inui is for Haida, and her only duty in the narrative is to try and date him. But after spending a good chunk of the season building their relationship … Inui gives up because Haida can’t stop obsessing over Retsuko.</p><p>Still, as agonizing as Haida was to watch, the season didn’t feel like a total wash. But then Retsuko and Haida’s storylines came crashing together.</p><h3>What the fuck was up with those last two episodes</h3><p><em>Again, </em><strong><em>major</em></strong><em> content warning for discussions of misogynistic harassment and violence, stalking, physical assault, and that sort of thing.</em></p><p>Throughout the season there are hints that the idol group has a stalker, but Retsuko tries to brush it off as a harmless fan. And then, in episode 9, the guy shows up at a handshaking event looking like a <em>My Hero Academia</em> villain and goes off the deep end. While keeping a vice grip on Retsuko’s hands, he goes into this lengthy incel rant for what feels like an eternity. Even for a show with as much swearing as Aggretsuko, I was <em>stunned </em>at how vulgar this guy got, insulting Retsuko’s singing, calling her a cock tease (his words, not mine), and saying many other misogynist things I’d rather not repeat. But because he has a bundle of handshake tickets, Retsuko has to just sit there and take it as everyone watches in horror. Nobody stops the guy. This is just part of the job.</p><p>This is already enough to leave Retsuko clearly traumatized in the following scenes, but it doesn’t stop there. The guy keeps stalking Retsuko and posting photos of her. Her manager tries to protect her, but Retsuko tries to pretend everything’s okay. The stalker buys a box cutter. And one day after work, he walks up behind Retsuko and tries to stab her.</p><p>I was in shock watching this scene, which is <em>agonizingly long</em>. I couldn’t believe my eyes. I couldn’t believe that this was where the cartoonish storyline about a parking lot fender bender leading to Retsuko becoming an idol ended up going. I couldn’t believe that this workplace dramedy series had turned into this. There’s even a bit where the show tries to psych you out and think Retsuko <em>died</em>!</p><p>It gets even worse. Haida swoops in and saves the day, pinning the deranged fan to the ground (and getting cut in the process). Suddenly this incredibly traumatizing event for Retsuko becomes all about Haida. Again, <strong><em>Haida was also stalking Retsuko just a few episodes ago. </em></strong>But the narrative rewards Haida for being so obsessive! The way it’s been written, his obsession is the only reason Retsuko doesn’t get stabbed. If Haida hadn’t been keeping an eye on Retsuko after work, <strong><em>she would have been killed by her other stalker!</em></strong></p><p>While it was important to address the toxic fandom inherent to idol culture in some capacity, this grueling sequence in which Retsuko nearly got assaulted just felt like cheap shock value drama that didn’t fit the established tone of the series. Suddenly this office comedy wants to be <em>Perfect Blue. </em>And it wasn’t even for her own arc. Not really. She gets knocked to the ground and is unconscious for most of the attack scene. It was all to set up a heroic moment for Haida. Inui even shows up right after the attack (while Haida is bleeding, Retsuko is unconscious, and some passers by are still pinning the attacker down in the background) to be like “wow, Haida, this really proves how much you love Retsuko.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*nGRu0P-XiiqS2mjHG7T1Ug.png" /></figure><p>After this sequence, things just go completely off the fucking rails. Retsuko stops coming to work and hides out at her parents’ house because she’s obviously traumatized by nearly getting <em>murdered</em>. She’s having nightmares about crowds filled with her stalker, all armed with box cutters. But Haida marches in and drags her to karaoke. In a climactic death metal battle, the two vent their feelings. Haida… chews out Retsuko for being traumatized? Here, this is the direct quote from Haida. (Yes, I’m sure the original Japanese dialogue is slightly different, but that’s not the version most people will get.)</p><blockquote><em>That’s the trouble of having feelings… they get out. You want me to just bottle them up forever? <br></em>Squash your feelings — what the hell?<br>Playing the doormat is so neat<br>You too scared to meet the gaze<br>Of strangers you see on the street?<br>Walking on eggshells, that’s your plan?<br>All on account of some messed up man<br>Who gave you a scare, and yeah we all care<br>But now you’re a shut-in, and letting him win<br>Sounds chicken to me (x4)<br>So what the hell do you wanna do?<br>Figure that out and crawl outta your cave already</blockquote><p>I get that he’s trying to jolt her out of her sadness, but repeatedly screaming at this girl who, again, <em>nearly got murdered a few days ago</em>, and calling her chicken for having PTSD, specifically over another guy who chewed her out… what the fuck? Then, of course, Haida once again confesses his love. Because, as he shows Retsuko, Gori’s work-in-progress dating app said they were a 100% match. He says that if he can’t restore her faith in the world then she should at least put her faith in him. So, basically, he chews her out for being traumatized, then says he’s the solution for her trauma. This scene is supposed to be showing how supportive Haida is of Retsuko and how much he wants to help her deal with her trauma, but he just spends the whole scene either yelling at her or making everything about his own feelings.</p><p>I’m not sure how intentional the parallels between the incel fanboy’s unhinged rant in the previous episode and Haida’s rant here are, but they’re there.</p><p>Against all odds, there was one last ray of hope. Retsuko gets her own verse jabbing back at Haida, and everything she says about him is spot on:</p><blockquote><em>Grow up already, Haida. Your feelings aren’t my responsibility. You barged into my bedroom without a second thought. Where do you get off telling me how to live? How dare you. Because no matter what I decide, it’s not your decision, Haida — it’s mine!<br></em>Crisis averted, Haida’s here to save the day!<br>Trust in you, huh? It doesn’t work that way<br>You think that crap is helpful, but you couldn’t be more wrong<br>Idiot, idiot, idiot, idiot, idiot!<br>Stop!!<br>Leave me, leave me, leave me, leave me alone<br>I didn’t ask for any of this<br>It’s me against the whole damn world<br>And they punched first</blockquote><p>But then Retsuko is cut off as Haida grabs her hand. He says “Then let’s go punch ’em back!”</p><p>And that’s where the scene ends! No, for real! Hard cut to Retsuko happily headlining her final concert as an idol, followed by the closing montage. Retsuko and Haida are back at work now and they’re making goo goo eyes at each other. Seems like Netflix is gonna keep stringing fans along for another season with this cliffhanger ending, but the implication is clearly that Retsuko and Haida are destined for each other.</p><p>Haida did it! Retsuko nearly got assaulted just so that he could save her and prove his devotion! And then he fixed her trauma in one scene! It was all for Haida’s personal arc! Her agency and her feelings don’t matter! He’s earned enough good boy points to redeem them for a relationship with Retsuko!</p><p>God, this sucks.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*NMrszHPePzlZwbjX4jW2cw.png" /></figure><p>I don’t want all this to come off as me complaining about characters behaving in unhealthy ways, or cartoons getting into traumatic content. Believe me, I love heavier shows like <em>BoJack Horseman</em> and <em>Tuca &amp; Bertie </em>just as much as everyone else. But those series have things to say about those heavy elements. They treat them with more care, and build to those moments more naturally. They’re thoughtful.</p><p>And I guess <em>Aggretsuko </em>also has some thoughts — just no good conclusions. Retsuko realizes capitalism sucks, but then she decides she just needs to find the right hustle for her. The show realizes that Haida‘s obsession is unhealthy, and has half the supporting cast call him an idiot over it, but then…implies that they’re gonna end up together anyway. There was a lot I enjoyed in this season, and I don’t begrudge others for feeling more positive about it. But in the end it feels like it was all in service of this tasteless ending with Retsuko and Haida, where Retsuko only makes it out alive because Haida doesn’t know how to take “no” for an answer. It feels like a waste.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e223d95f9578" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[10 weird and wonderful Archie Sonic stories that hold up today]]></title>
            <link>https://ponett.medium.com/10-weird-and-wonderful-archie-sonic-stories-that-hold-up-today-44df6d3a2fcb?source=rss-1885f92e94c5------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/44df6d3a2fcb</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[videogames]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[sonic-the-hedgehog]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[archie-comics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[comics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Bobby Schroeder]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 15 Nov 2019 01:06:22 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-09-25T21:50:22.446Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/658/1*7yT2tuzw-d9VhLjl0ZbYqQ.png" /></figure><p>(<strong>EDIT 9/25/2024: </strong>This piece is <a href="https://ponett.dog/blog/10-weird-and-wonderful-archie-sonic-stories-that-hold-up-today.html">now mirrored on my new personal blog</a>! I’m no longer using Medium, and can’t guarantee that this site won’t mess with my formatting or randomly lose chunks of the article, as it’s done in the past.)</p><p>In my recent <a href="https://medium.com/@ponett/i-read-every-sonic-comic-by-ken-penders-and-theyre-wilder-than-you-could-ever-imagine-1f9dd05ae433">retrospective on Ken Penders’ run on Archie’s <em>Sonic the Hedgehog </em>and its spinoffs</a>, I was very negative, because reading his comics is often a nightmare. But Ken wasn’t the only writer, and focusing exclusively on him doesn’t paint a full picture of the series.</p><p>In this shorter followup, I’d like to highlight ten stories that stood out to me in the much-maligned first thirteen years of the series. Most readers will tell you to skip to <em>Sonic </em>#160, when the reigns were handed to the ever-popular creative duo of Ian Flynn and Tracy Yardley (who are still doing phenomenal <em>Sonic </em>work at IDW today). But thanks to stories like these, I’m glad I gave the earlier issues a fair shake.</p><h3>1. Mecha Madness</h3><p><em>Sonic #39 and Sonic &amp; Knuckles: Mecha Madness Special. Writer: Michael Gallagher, Penciler: Pat Spaziante</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*D344kjJgsUxMD7Md5EWstQ.png" /></figure><p>If there’s one story arc everyone remembers as being cool as hell from early Archie <em>Sonic, </em>it’s “Mecha Madness.”</p><p>The story goes like this: A couple issues prior, the Freedom Fighters had invented a gizmo that could allow a Mobian to retain their free will when roboticized. Thus, Sonic had an idea: why not stick one of these gadgets on his person, let Robotnik turn him into a robot, and then use his new super-strong robot powers to finally beat Robotnik once and for all?</p><p>This plan gets shot down for being too dangerous. But then Sonic gets captured and roboticized anyway, and all hell breaks loose. What proceeds is basically an excuse for beloved cover artist Pat Spaziante to draw cool robot fights, with many one-liners of varying quality along the way.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*U_ncJYWYTiG8dOoOKqf3Rg.png" /></figure><p>This one isn’t gonna win any awards for its writing. It’s loud and stupid. But it’s exactly what most kids in the ’90s wanted out of a <em>Sonic</em> comic.</p><p>Of course, the flashy action of “Mecha Madness” isn’t particularly representative of the earliest comics. Let’s look at a more typical example.</p><h3>2. Sonic’s Christmas Carol</h3><p><em>Sonic #6. Writer: Angelo DeCesare, Penciler: Dave Manak</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/758/1*FMNnzAYO7croXVFx86WJjA.png" /></figure><p>Yes, this is literally just an adaptation of <em>A Christmas Carol</em> with <em>Sonic </em>characters.</p><p>I know that including this nonsense has ruined the credibility of this list, and I don’t care. The sheer absurdity of this one has always made it stand out to me as a highlight of the comic’s earliest days. It’s deeply silly and it knows it. I can’t not love it.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/608/1*85tJnAZXyJkYpA0eu7-7vQ.png" /></figure><p>It also gave me one of my favorite out-of-context <em>Sonic </em>panels of all time.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/210/1*nIGJ4VZOG8ss22DWPjoqQw.png" /></figure><h3>3. Sonic Under Glass</h3><p><em>Sonic #16. Writer: Ken Penders, Penciler: Dave Manak</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/613/1*IEOt_mBdlqK-g_tTg5OvUA.png" /></figure><p>Yes, even Ken had a couple stories I liked. His early work from before he started indulging in his worst tendencies hold up pretty decently, to be honest. One of my favorite stories of his is a rather unassuming one in a random early issue. In it, we open with the revelation that the Freedom Fighters have apparently beaten Robotnik off-screen. Peace has been restored to Mobius. Sonic and Sally are even getting married.</p><p>Then, of course, comes the twist: none of this is real. Robotnik has captured the Freedom Fighters. However, he decided that simply roboticizing them or killing them wouldn’t be satisfying enough after their years of meddling with his schemes. So instead, he hooks them up to a virtual reality simulation where all their dreams come true. On top of getting the satisfaction of knowing that their happiness is based on a big fat lie, he’ll now be free to go on a global rampage and the Freedom Fighters will be none the wiser.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/628/1*ETEGkzjzx8VXSq4SZqFoFw.png" /></figure><p>In earlier issues, Robotnik was a joke. He once literally screwed up building a robot so badly that he somehow accidentally created <a href="https://thankskenpenders.tumblr.com/post/104120195350/you-know-i-probably-shouldve-seen-this-coming">a robotic version of Steve Urkel</a>. (Yes, the irony of Jaleel White’s other most famous character appearing alongside Sonic is not lost on me.) While this is still a very silly story, the diabolical nature of this scheme has always made it stand out to me.</p><h3>4. Bunnie’s Worst Nightmare</h3><p><em>Sonic #37. Writer and penciler: Rich Koslowski</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/610/1*wnPagBEjNbMlIgGKVFJloQ.png" /></figure><p>In my Penders piece, I mentioned that my favorite character in the series was Bunnie Rabbot. There are many reasons for this, from her upbeat attitude, to her ability to kick robot ass, to the fact that cyborgs are just plain cool. But this story from when the comics were slowly starting to get serious really solidified her as my favorite.</p><p>In it, Bunnie realizes that her roboticized parts are slowly starting to take over the rest of her body. Robotnik is finally finishing what he started, and the super-strong robot parts that allow Bunnie to protect her friends are now making her a threat to them. Distraught, Bunnie decides to leave Knothole so that she won’t hurt anyone. Even with the simple, kid-friendly framing of this story, it’s pretty tragic.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/604/1*-ZBSZRkjKNGEei3pBNzjeg.png" /></figure><p>And then… Bunnie wakes up. It was all a bad dream. (Maybe the title should’ve clued my stupid ass in.) In many cases, this would feel like a cop out. But here, I’d argue that framing it as a dream makes it <em>more </em>interesting. Now, this nightmare is framed not as a random bad thing that happens one day, but as something Bunnie apparently worries about <em>all the time. </em>The ending makes it clear that this nightmare scenario is gonna be in the back of her mind for a long time. And yet, in spite of this, Bunnie still puts on a brave face every day for the sake of her friends, being one of the most upbeat and positive members of the team.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/610/1*h14bqR0GipsJeksbWpBpAw.png" /></figure><p>Honestly, if there’s one element I wish the early comics explored more, it’s the cyberpunk-y transhumanist-y themes inherent to the whole roboticization thing. And really, Bunnie was the perfect character to explore these themes with, as a character who’s half organic and half roboticized. (Because of this, in my extremely biased opinion, I honestly think Bunnie could’ve made a better lead protagonist for this incarnation of the series than Sonic himself.) Between both the early Archie comics and <em>SatAM</em>, both of which criminally underutilized Bunnie, this story stands out as an instance where her potential finally started to come to the surface, if only for a few pages.</p><h3>5. Icon</h3><p><em>Sonic #62-#63. Writer: Karl Bollers, Penciler: Steven Butler</em></p><p>I feel sorry for Karl Bollers. While he wrote his fair share of stories I didn’t care for, he also wrote a lot of my favorites (as the rest of this list goes to show). But he’s almost as widely disliked as Penders in the fandom. This is primarily due to the messy romantic drama he wrote. But to be fair, the dreadful Mina Mongoose love triangle was mandated by editor Justin Gabrie. And I‘d argue “the Slap” only became infamous because he quit before he could resolve the tension between Sonic and Sally, leaving them in a worse place than when he started.</p><p>Bollers really is a talented guy, though! And his earliest stories as the new lead writer on the main series proved it. They were consistently fun and adventurous, they played around with Sonic’s super speed, and when paired with artist Steven Butler, his stories tended to make creative use of comics as a medium.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/609/1*CuN8TDC6PhS6V0ZZqavlig.png" /></figure><p>One such story was at the very start of his tenure as lead writer — “Icon.” This was part of what’s been dubbed the “World Tour” arc, in which Sonic and Tails left Knothole for nearly a year of comics in search of one of the major villains. One of the most memorable stops along their globetrotting adventure was in Sand-Blast City, a very <em>Mad Max </em>inspired safe haven in a robot-infested desert. The problem? Since he’s the guy who defeated Robotnik, the Sand-Blasters worship Sonic as their hero, the greatest Freedom Fighter of all time, and their new personal savior… and they won’t let him leave.</p><p>The Sand-Blasters wait on Sonic hand and foot, but when he and Tails try to leave, they aren’t afraid to use force. Ultimately, in order to escape and get back to his important mission to find Ixis Naugus, Sonic destroys their force field (and, in a very symbolic gesture, their statue of him) and leaves the fanatical Sand-Blasters to fend for themselves against the robot horde. It was probably the right call, but it was a surprisingly dark note to end the story on. Sonic would regret his actions here for many issues to come. One story even showed that he had recurring nightmares about it.</p><p>While this story is going on, Bollers also keeps cutting over to parallel events happening closer to Knothole. See, Robotnik’s cowardly nephew Snively has been in jail since shortly after Robotnik’s defeat in issue #50, along with a bunch of the miscellaneous C-list villains — most of whom are incredibly jacked furry dudes. When the locks on their cells are mysteriously opened by a shadowy figure, Snively gets all the credit, and they immediately make him their new leader. All the while, Snively is <em>terrified. </em>But he pretends to be their new fearless leader anyway, knowing that it’s probably his one ticket out.</p><p>Here’s the kicker that allows this parallel between Sonic and Snively to make sense: back in issue #50, when Robotnik was defeated? Sonic wasn’t actually the one who did Robotnik in. He was there when it happened, sure, but Robotnik was killed by his own Ultimate Annihilator. But everyone, including the Sand-Blasters, gives him the credit for it. Not unlike how Snively takes credit for the jailbreak. But while Snively gets a happy ending in this story, Sonic’s is more bittersweet.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/613/1*KrBlyfrfqrlS7NVETY5-DA.png" /></figure><p>In a series where the morality is normally so black and white, it’s interesting to see a story end on a dark note like this, with Sonic being forced to do something cruel that he would regret for many issues to come. He couldn’t stay in Sand-Blast city, of course, and later stories would reveal that they survived (although they’re not exactly fans of Sonic anymore), so it’s not like he <em>killed </em>them. But to see direct parallels drawn between the main hero and the most cowardly villain in a series like this is kind of fascinating.</p><h3>6. The Sonic Adventure 2 tie-in</h3><p><em>Sonic #98. Writer: Karl Bollers, Penciler: Pat Spaziante</em></p><p>This is a pretty straightforward story that basically just summarizes the premise of <em>Sonic Adventure 2, </em>and then tells you to go buy the game. Archie had to do this occasionally, with mixed results.</p><p>I love this one for one reason: we got to see Pat Spaziante draw City Escape.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/649/1*oTXWKI6igEXSbdi_DowCRQ.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/635/1*MuBM4dUzAXV8j3eYvqw2aw.png" /><figcaption>(slap bass begins to play)</figcaption></figure><h3>7. Reunion</h3><p><em>Sonic #100. Writer: Karl Bollers, Penciler: Ron Lim</em></p><p>This one’s a bit harder to appreciate unless you’re familiar with the overarching story of Archie <em>Sonic </em>and know where the story was at around issue #100. But when I was neck deep in the series, this felt like a breath of fresh air. After so many stories from multiple different writers in which Sally felt like a supporting character who never got to do anything, Bollers let her do something cool. Something VERY cool. He gave her a magic sword and had her restore the free will of the Robians.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*vWINhxJ80s4qV0kbkFHFHw.png" /></figure><p>Hell yeah!! Not even Ron Lim’s wonky Sonic art can ruin this one for me.</p><p>Actually, as an aside, this almost played into a really cool subplot that sadly never made it into the series. If you’ve read my blog or the Penders retrospective, you may remember me discussing “the Sally Dip Story,” in which Sally nearly bonded with the omniscient “Source of All” that her family worships. Well, the Sword of Acorns that Sally uses in this story is made of Source goop, and it starts talking to her (and <em>through </em>her). See, Bollers actually knew how absurdly creepy the Source concept was, and wanted to run with that. He planned on revealing that the Source wasn’t a benevolent deity, but more of an eldritch one that wanted to corrupt Sally’s family.</p><p>It’s too bad he never got to do this. But he did at least blow up the Source of All. So there’s that.</p><h3>8. Sonic Adventure 2.5</h3><p><em>Sonic #124-#125. Writer: Karl Bollers, Pencilers: Dave Manak, Art Mawhinney, Ron Lim, Dawn Best, Stephen Butler, J. Axer</em></p><p>This was my favorite arc in the comics as a child, and I was pleasantly surprised to see that it’s still a fun read today.</p><p>This arc marked the 10th anniversary of the series, and was also the climax of the first ten years of comics. It was a big deal. And what did Bollers do with this momentus issue?</p><p>He had an alien menace show up on Mobius to reveal a long-foreshadowed truth: that Mobius is a post-apocalyptic Earth.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/658/1*6rhT-NeC8XDzVkHBFdMKLQ.png" /></figure><p>Yes, this cartoon wonderland full of different fantasy and sci-fi elements is actually a post-apocalyptic Earth in the distant future. Humanity has been nearly wiped out, and colorful creatures of all kinds now roam the lands. In other words: Archie <em>Sonic </em>did <em>Adventure Time</em>’s big twist years earlier.</p><p>Bollers had been foreshadowing this twist since basically day one of his run, and it always seemed like he had a lot of fun with it. From the aforementioned <em>Mad Max</em>-themed story, to mentions of an apocalyptic “Day of Fury” in the distant past, to Station Square being a giant underground human city built to ride out the apocalypse, to “Old Megaopolis” very clearly being the ruins of New York, the writing had been on the wall for ages.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/620/1*dHxBDdfRg9Ct8H9ODZqw9g.png" /><figcaption>(from Sonic #116)</figcaption></figure><p><em>This</em> is the kind of weird that I love in the Archie comics. Not Penders’ hangups with gender roles and dads. Not the agonizing love triangles. Just some good clean fun with a story about how all the furries in Sonic are actually post-apocalyptic mutants.</p><p>Anyway, so once these aliens figure out that they didn’t successfully wipe out all life on Earth, they come back to finish the job. And so in <em>Sonic </em>#125, just about every character in the series teams up to stop them.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/650/1*6UvSCuPlM1rFVv2AiArshA.png" /></figure><p>They make a valiant effort (and there’s also a cool part where Sonic and Sally pilot a mech built by Eggman), but this isn’t enough. In the end, only Sonic is fast enough to stop the doomsday device. After a tearful goodbye with Sally, he sacrifices his own life to save the planet.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/655/1*HzyLh3lCEYysVvZKhZf_PA.png" /></figure><p>Yes, this is all melodramatic. But if you’re not reading these comics for the juicy melodrama, then I don’t know what to tell you.</p><p>Of course, Sonic isn’t really dead. They still did like 170 more issues after this. But he WAS transported to the other side of the galaxy when he destroyed the doomsday device. This lead directly into the “Tossed in Space” arc, which was also pretty fun!</p><h3>9. Return to Angel Island</h3><p><em>Sonic #138-#141. Writer: Karl Bollers, Penciler: Jon Gray</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/656/1*URQJJPerbuDLGWoLYIVhCw.png" /></figure><p>I already gushed about this arc in the Penders retrospective, so I’ll try to avoid repeating myself too much. But this truly is a wonderful story arc, one that brought out the potential I always knew Archie <em>Sonic </em>had.</p><p>In this arc, the conflict on Angel Island is completely reinvented, with Eggman’s forces having taken over and Knuckles and the other echidnas now being the underdogs. Every single character involved feels more interesting and believable than they ever did in Ken’s comics. The focus isn’t on Knuckles’ racist grandpas and how cool Ken thinks they are, but rather on <em>everyone else. </em>It manages to tell a more satisfying arc in four issues than Penders was able to tell over the course of a decade.</p><p>With the change in writers, Knuckles’ world also suddenly has <em>way</em> more elements from the games. This includes big changes, like most of the locations visited being taken directly from <em>Sonic 3 &amp; Knuckles </em>(Marble Garden, Lava Reef, Hidden Palace), as well as more subtle touches, like Knuckles compensating for his current lack of superpowers with his upgrades from <em>Sonic Adventure 2.</em></p><p>On top of all this, it also introduces a new echidna character: the Dark Legion scientist Dr. Finitevus. While just about every panel with the guy radiates evil energy, he also feels like he believes what he’s doing is right — something that Ken’s <em>Knuckles </em>comics always struggled with. The other echidnas have turned to spirituality, relying on their faith in the prophecy surrounding Knuckles, even when the Legion is right there with the resources to solve their problems with science. Yeah, the Legion has ulterior motives, and they want control over Angel Island for their own purposes, but they really are trying to help everyone. It’s understandable that Finitevus would be pissed about the way everyone worships Knuckles.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/658/1*OeWLbjt0Ge486aOxvrAKrQ.png" /></figure><p>This was the only arc Bollers got to write with Dr. Finitevus before he left, but Ian Flynn would do <em>a lot </em>with the character in the following years, firmly cementing him as a fan favorite.</p><p>In a way, this whole arc feels like a meta commentary on Ken’s work. The echidnas literally worship Knuckles as their savior because a prophecy told them to, even when he has no powers. He’s not sure if the prophecy is true, or if he can even do anything to help. But ultimately, it’s not his dad or the prophecy or any of that that allows Knuckles to win. It’s the fact that he never gives up, even when the odds are stacked against him. Here he comes, rougher than the rest of them.The best of them. Tougher than leather. You can call him Knuckles</p><p>While the arc is pretty serious, it also has many genuinely funny moments, thanks in part to the outstandingly energetic art by Jon Gray. I already shared this part in the Penders article, but I’d be remiss to leave out the introductory scene for Knuckles’ baby brother:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/658/1*ymHfi7UEx0E7ojS9teLynA.png" /></figure><p>And the other best part about this arc? In the climax, when Knuckles transforms into his super form? Jon did <a href="https://thankskenpenders.tumblr.com/post/187830621905/a-few-people-have-pointed-out-something-amazing">a shot for shot recreation of Elpizo’s final boss transformation from <em>Mega Man Zero 2</em></a><em>.</em></p><p>Honestly, if there’s one story arc you should track down and read from the first 13 years of Archie <em>Sonic, </em>it’s absolutely this. This was the last Arc of this scope that Bollers wrote for the series before his departure, but man, did he go out with a bang.</p><h3>10. Stargazing</h3><p><em>Sonic #151. Writer and penciler: Tania del Rio</em></p><p>Let’s end on a high note with hands down my favorite backup story: “Stargazing,” written and drawn by Tania del Rio of <em>Sabrina the Teenage Witch </em>fame. This is an <em>immensely</em> important little story for Archie <em>Sonic. </em>In it, Sally is awoken one night by a strange figure seen leaving her bedroom. When she follows it outside, she finds something she didn’t expect: her AI assistant Nicole has given herself a simulated organic form.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/658/1*jPyEIRAQwcCxTUAvnEPutQ.png" /></figure><p>In a series that’s normally very bombastic and absurd, this is a very gentle, emotional story. Nicole is just happy to be experiencing life as an organic being, if only for a brief moment. While she’d been in the comics for over a decade, it feels like Sally and Nicole are only truly meeting for the first time here. The shoujo manga look is a departure from the usual designs, but del Rio’s expressions really sell the subtle emotions of this scene.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/652/1*2Glw38v2a4ZVWJ_xTLAfQg.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/658/1*wKKBRJ-jDBqdwJVQ7262Gg.png" /></figure><p>Despite Sally’s protests, Nicole can’t stay in this form forever. It takes a lot of power to maintain a solid hologram like this, and her data is much easier to hack in this form.</p><p>The two decide to simply watch the stars together as Nicole fades away and returns to her computer form.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/658/1*8sAe8DHVTm9idNnxJzR5qQ.png" /></figure><p>As I said, this short story was hugely influential. It introduced Nicole’s holo-lynx form, which reinvented the character and allowed her to become a major player in the Archieverse. (Going back to the <em>Adventure Time</em> comparisons, I’d compare Nicole’s arc to how BMO went from being Finn and Jake’s talking Game Boy to being one of the most beloved main characters.)</p><p>The other obvious impact of this story was that folks started shipping Sally and Nicole. <em>A lot. </em>I mean, it’s no wonder why. Whether or not the romantic subtext was intentional, it’s there. I’d almost say these two have a more sincere emotional connection in this scene than Sonic and Sally ever did. It’s a quiet, tender moment that makes me <em>feel things.</em></p><p>The pairing would become so popular that, actually, after the 2013 reboot? Ian Flynn and co. would start sneaking in hints that Sally and Nicole actually <em>were </em>in love. Discussing their relationship, he once said “I would dare say that if you go through the book since the reboot, you could probably make a case for it.” And after the Archie comics were suddenly canceled and they no longer had corporate breathing down their necks, the creative team came forward and said that yes, Sally and Nicole were a couple.</p><p>Sallicole for life babey</p><p>And so, those are a few of my favorite Archie <em>Sonic </em>stories from before the Ian Flynn era. This isn’t <em>every</em> story I like from back then, of course. There were a handful of other Bollers stories I considered including, and a Robin Hood inspired arc from Penders ended up being much more entertaining than I expected. There’s also Joe Edkin’s early issues on <em>Sonic X, </em>which are extremely entertaining and criminally underrated.</p><p>If you found this more positive look at the comics entertaining, be sure to check out my blog <a href="https://thankskenpenders.tumblr.com/">Thanks Ken Penders</a> later this month! I’ll finally be starting the Ian Flynn era, which I’m very excited about. I hope to see you then!</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=44df6d3a2fcb" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[I read every Sonic comic by Ken Penders, and they’re wilder than you could ever imagine]]></title>
            <link>https://ponett.medium.com/i-read-every-sonic-comic-by-ken-penders-and-theyre-wilder-than-you-could-ever-imagine-1f9dd05ae433?source=rss-1885f92e94c5------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/1f9dd05ae433</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[comics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[sonic-the-hedgehog]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[criticism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[videogames]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[archie-comics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Bobby Schroeder]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 14 Nov 2019 01:18:23 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-09-25T21:50:53.606Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/640/1*M6AH6Dgu0giWYUNed7r0Sg.png" /></figure><p>(<strong>EDIT 9/25/2024: </strong>This piece is <a href="https://ponett.dog/blog/i-read-every-sonic-comic-by-ken-penders-and-theyre-wilder-than-you-could-ever-imagine.html">now mirrored on my new personal blog</a>! I’m no longer using Medium, and can’t guarantee that this site won’t mess with my formatting or randomly lose chunks of the article, as it’s done in the past.)</p><p>For years now, former Archie <em>Sonic</em> writer Ken Penders has been most well known for his legal battles with Archie and Sega in which he acquired the rights to his characters and stories. Among dedicated Sonic fans, he’s also known for his bad tweets and strange art style.</p><p>You know what doesn’t come up as often?<strong> The actual content of his stories.</strong></p><p>Sure, everyone vaguely knows the Archie comics are weird, and it’s easy to find goofy out-of-context panels. But that’s only skimming the surface. What’s up with the bizarre recurring themes in his stories? The obsession with asshole dads? The weird attempts at mature themes? Dingo firing squads executing civilians? A cartoon bee dying from eating an LSD-laced chili dog? Distasteful allusions to the Holocaust? Implications that teenage <em>Sonic</em> characters were having sex off-screen? <em>Why did any of this happen?</em></p><p>Few can answer this, because few want to analyze over 100 issues of mediocre furry soap opera comics with bad politics. I mean, there’s no shortage of good <em>Sonic </em>comics you could read instead. Who would be stupid enough to do that?</p><p>Me. My name is Bobby Schroeder, and I’m stupid enough.</p><p>Five years ago, I started a blog to archive my journey through Archie <em>Sonic</em>. I jokingly gave it the name “<a href="https://thankskenpenders.tumblr.com/">Thanks, Ken Penders</a>.” Now, in 2019, I’ve finally finished reading every issue the man ever wrote for <em>Sonic the Hedgehog </em>and its spinoffs. To close out this first leg of my journey, I’d like to take some time to summarize what the fuck is up with Ken Penders’ bizarre <em>Sonic</em> comics.</p><p>I expected them to be weird. I did not expect them to be <em>this </em>weird.</p><p>So… compared to the other writers on the series, what did Penders actually bring to the table with Archie <em>Sonic</em>?</p><h3>Continuity and lore</h3><p>The earliest Archie <em>Sonic</em> issues were written primarily by Michael Gallagher (who also did a lot of weird and distasteful shit, but that’s another post), and they focused almost exclusively on gags, puns, and fourth wall breaks. Due to the themes of the source material, the comics also occasionally had <a href="https://thankskenpenders.tumblr.com/post/183388813135/i-was-graciously-linked-to-the-gag-pages-the">a <em>slight </em>satirical edge</a> when it came to environmental issues.</p><p>It was entertaining enough, and a lot of fans look back on those comics fondly. But there wasn’t much to sink your teeth into if you preferred the more serious tone of the Saturday morning <em>Sonic </em>cartoon (<em>SatAM</em>)<em> </em>that inspired the comics in the first place. I mean, this was a story about an evil dictator (Robotnik) taking over the world and turning the populace into robot slaves, leaving a small band of teenage rebels (Sonic, Princess Sally, and the other Freedom Fighters) to stop him. But most of the early comics were like this:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/599/1*XTdr55XVn_g-qDPB2tXl5w.png" /><figcaption>would you be surprised if I told you Sonugh the Boghog never comes back</figcaption></figure><p>This all started to change with 1994&#39;s <em>Sonic </em>#11, when writer (and sometimes penciler, inker, colorist, letterer, etc.) Ken Penders came on board with temporary creative partner Mike Kanterovich. While they tried to tell sillier Gallagher-style stories at first with <a href="https://thankskenpenders.tumblr.com/post/104209350147/what-the-fuck-am-i-looking-at">mixed results</a> (they actually <a href="https://imgur.com/a/XKBMnh8">almost did a Mario parody</a>), it didn’t take long for Penders to push for a more serious, serialized structure as he became one of the most influential contributors on the series.</p><p>(I should make it clear up front, however, that Penders was never the <em>only </em>writer on the series. For much of his run in the late ’90s and early ’00s he was relegated to writing short backup stories while Karl Bollers handled the main story in each <em>Sonic </em>issue, and that’s not even mentioning the decade of mostly very good comics written after he quit. The idea that Penders wrote the entire series, or even a majority of it, is a common misconception, and by zeroing in on his work in this article I’m only looking at a fraction of the overall series.)</p><p>Ken’s serialized style was most clearly on display in the 32-issue <em>Knuckles the Echidna</em> series, which ran from 1997 to 1999 and was written exclusively by him with art primarily by Manny Galan. The <em>Knuckles</em> comics were very much one long story broken up into smaller three-issue arcs. In a time when <em>Sonic</em> was handled by many different writers and artists (and therefore varied wildly in quality and style), <em>Knuckles</em> was incredibly consistent. If you liked the series, you knew what you were getting into every month, and it was all apparently building towards… <em>something.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/540/0*FS8ARRXeTXExapgm.png" /></figure><p>Premonitions of a troubled future promised readers that Knuckles and co. were destined to save the world from a major threat in their adult years, and that the audience’s patience and dedication would be rewarded. Many readers stuck with it month after month, wanting to see what Ken had been building towards. But in hindsight, many of his most hyped ideas (the Chaos Knuckles arc, “Mobius: 25 Years Later”) ended up being total duds that massively disappointed a lot of longtime readers.</p><p>These days, most fans don’t seem to think Penders’ eventual payoff, whatever he had in mind, would’ve been worth it. In retrospect, most of his stories feel more like teases for future issues than engaging narratives in their own right. But he still has a small but loyal following of people who are dying to see him finish his take on the story. Penders is more than happy to egg them on, saying that he considers all of his successor Ian Flynn’s stories non-canon and that the <em>real </em>ending will come in the form of <em>The Lara-Su Chronicles</em>… you know, if that’s ever released.</p><h3>Countless original characters</h3><p>“Who the hell is Lara-Su?” you may be asking. Penders is known for introducing a great many new characters to the comics. This is either a good thing or a bad thing, depending on who you ask.</p><p>While many of the characters added in licensed <em>Sonic </em>media are fan favorites (the Freedom Fighters, Cosmo, Tangle, Whisper, etc.), Penders’ additions to the Archie cast were a mixed bag. Some of them, like Knuckles’ love interest Julie-Su or Sally’s brother Elias, showed a lot of potential, and still have a lot of fans to this day. But it always felt like Penders mistook quantity for quality.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/540/0*nQMnBKu5l-eaxzV5.png" /><figcaption>Pictured: Sally, and six characters whose names you probably don’t know.</figcaption></figure><p>The Sonic wiki lists nearly <strong>200 characters </strong>introduced by Ken, and a lot of them aren’t names you would recognize. You have your forgettable but inoffensive characters like <a href="https://archiesonic.fandom.com/wiki/Penelope_Platypus">Penelope Platypus</a> or <a href="https://archiesonic.fandom.com/wiki/Valdez_the_Chameleon">Valdez the Chameleon</a> (who is <em>not</em> Espio in a hat). Then you have <a href="https://archiesonic.fandom.com/wiki/Category:Echidnas">about 7.5 trillion echidnas</a>, most of whom look extremely similar to Knuckles. And then you’ve got the downright bizarre characters, like Charmy’s butler <a href="https://archiesonic.fandom.com/wiki/Jeepers">Jeepers the bee</a>, who looks like an absolutely wasted John Adams cosplayer. (Side note: Penders made Charmy a prince.) Oh, and who could forget the traitorous <a href="https://archiesonic.fandom.com/wiki/Sleuth_%22Doggy%22_Dawg">Sleuth “Doggy” Dawg</a>? Or how about a human poacher very blatantly inspired by “The Most Dangerous Game,” who was named… <a href="https://archiesonic.fandom.com/wiki/Hunter">Hunter</a>?</p><p>Again, the key word is “potential.” Penders is a writer who has okay ideas, but tends to stumble on the execution. In the hands of other writers, his characters can turn into something really special. The “<a href="https://thankskenpenders.tumblr.com/tagged/RTAI%20arc/chrono">Return to Angel Island” arc</a> (#138 — #141) was basically just writer Karl Bollers giving us a fresh take on the <em>Knuckles </em>comics, and it was fantastic. And prior to the 2013 continuity reboot (which was sparked by Archie losing their lawsuit against Ken), many of Ian Flynn’s comics revolved around breathing new life into Ken’s old ideas.</p><p>Of course, Ken’s vision for Sonic is… <em>unique.</em></p><h3>A general lack of interest in Sonic</h3><p>Almost everyone who works on the <em>Sonic</em> comics these days grew up as a fan. These folks really care about these characters (even the “uncool” ones like Cream the Rabbit or Silver the Hedgehog), and it’s clearly a labor of love. For a troubled franchise like <em>Sonic,</em> this is something truly special.</p><p>But this obviously wasn’t possible in 1993, when the kids who grew up with the Genesis were still… you know, kids. So instead, they got a ragtag group of creatives who were available at the time, such as Michael Gallagher and Dave Manak, the creative duo behind Marvel’s <em>Alf </em>comics. Why not? Sonic and Alf are basically the same character, right?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/607/1*uRoPmnCWiqr-TckVGdJ07A.png" /></figure><p>Penders ended up working on <em>Sonic</em> by mere happenstance. It was a gig that was hiring, and he happened to know a guy. But because Penders was the first writer at Archie to really give a shit about lore, he got to steer things in a direction he personally preferred. Now, there’s nothing wrong with bringing in outside influences (as I write this, IDW‘s Sonic is trying to stop a zombie apocalypse), but Ken’s tastes are very… <em>narrow. Star Trek</em>, the works of Jack Kirby, <em>Dungeons &amp; Dragons-</em>style fantasy. That sort of thing. He’s very much your typical nerdy baby boomer. So in the ’90s and early 2000s, you had this hip and trendy video game franchise for kids known for its use of pop, rock, and rap music, and the comic adaptation read like a bizarre Silver Age comic or a <em>D&amp;D </em>campaign. (For a fun bit of tonal dissonance, try listening to <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hCvg0_h3a-k">this classic <em>Sonic CD</em> track</a> while reading those panels with the sword horse.)</p><p>The perfect example of how odd Ken’s vision was for <em>Sonic</em>? He wanted to make Sonic’s birth name <strong>Olgilvie Maurice Hedgehog.</strong></p><p>Why not stick closer to the content of the games? Well, in the ’90s, there were only a handful of <em>Sonic </em>games, and they didn’t exactly have a ton of story content to build off of. But Penders also didn’t really play the <em>Sonic</em> games. He saw Sonic as a comic (and cartoon) character first and foremost, with the games as simply a starting point. To survive in the long run, he argued, the comics needed to expand past the confines of the games. To forge their own path. And this is true to a certain extent, but as time went on Ken’s vision only veered further and further from the things people liked about Sonic in the first place. And when Sega’s vision clashed with his own, he tended to ignore it the best he could. You might get a story here or there directly tying in to a new game, and new game characters would join the cast, but it’d usually be right back to business as usual afterwards. (For that matter, he also didn’t read the other writers’ stories.)</p><p>One of the most infamous displays of this disconnect with the games is seen in the “Sonic Live” special. In it, Ken’s <em>actual son and niece</em> are sucked into the TV to go on an adventure with Sonic. (They don’t really end up helping, and Sonic almost gets them killed along the way.) In the live action opening, which was shot by Ken himself, they’re supposed to be playing an unspecified <em>Sonic</em> game… except instead, his son is just holding a TV remote sideways while staring at a blank screen.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/345/0*UuG7EnHyMkK6_fiO.png" /><figcaption>I’m pretty sure he just hit the power button</figcaption></figure><p>In an effort to move the comics into new territory, Penders also tried to kill off Robotnik. Multiple times! He wanted to replace him with his own original villains like the Dark Legion and Dr. Droid (who… basically served the same purpose), but this never worked out for obvious reasons.</p><p>The thing is, he actually <em>did </em>kill Robotnik! This happened in 1997&#39;s <em>Sonic</em> #50, at the climax of the “Endgame” arc. This was envisioned as potentially being the series finale, so Robotnik dying would’ve made sense… but then the comics kept going. Ken argued that Robotnik should stay dead — comic book heroes almost never fought the same villain every issue, and he thought Sonic needed new foes. Robotnik remained out of the series until <em>Sonic</em> #75 (shortly before the adaptation of <em>Sonic Adventure, </em>which necessitated having Robotnik around), in which writer Karl Bollers brought in an alternate universe counterpart (”Robo-Robotnik”) who Penders had previously introduced. (The fandom has always speculated that Robotnik was revived in this way to avoid pissing off Ken.) This incarnation ended up sticking around for the rest of the series, while the Robotnik of the first 50 issues (mostly) stayed dead. Because of this, the classic Robotnik and the modern Eggman are technically two separate characters in the Archie comics.</p><p>(Side note: That new villain Penders wanted to introduce, Dr. Ian Droid? He was introduced in a crossover between <em>Sonic </em>and several extremely adult-oriented Image Comics properties like <em>Spawn </em>and <em>Savage Dragon. </em>Penders also used this special as a backdoor pilot for his own Image series, <em>The Lost Ones</em>, which lasted one issue.)</p><p>You know what he seemed to dislike more than writing Robotnik, though? Writing teenagers! Which is kind of a problem in a series about teenagers. We had story after story about how Sonic and co. should just listen to their elders, and how they’ll grow up someday to be just like their parents and have naïve, rebellious kids of their own who they won’t understand. We had characters talking down to Sonic for being a teenager, even though the games and most other <em>Sonic</em> media tended not to draw much attention to his age. The writing for the teenage cast frequently devolved into trite, out of touch soap opera drama about those crazy teens and their hormones. The adults in their lives, meanwhile, could practically do no wrong. Most of Ken’s pet characters were adults. Knuckles’ dad. Sally’s dad. Geoffrey St. John. Hershey the Cat. Dr. Quack. Harry the cab driver. The preference was obvious.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/540/0*3JpxJZt2VYt39CjQ.png" /></figure><p>There was one major exception, though. Knuckles.</p><p>As time went on, Penders made Knuckles more and more important. Knuckles became the hero of his own stories, and then a chosen one of prophecy, destined to save the world<em>. </em>Knuckles wasn’t just Sonic’s friendly rival and the guy who guarded the Master Emerald, he was Mobius’s greatest hero. Knuckles slowly unlocked more and more Chaos Emerald powers over Ken’s run, culminating in 2000 with his green Chaos Knuckles form in which he literally had the power of a god. He could reshape reality at his whims, control peoples’ minds, travel to any point in time and alter history, create matter out of thin air, and generally do anything he could think of, and he stayed in this form for over <em>two years. </em>(Not that Knuckles accomplished much of anything in this time except, uh… die. But it’s a comic book, so he got better.)</p><p>As the ultimate statement of Knuckles’ importance over everyone else, when Penders explained how Robotnik had finally been defeated in “Mobius: 25 Years Later”… Knuckles was the one who had killed him.</p><p>So what was up with this guy’s fascination with Knuckles?</p><h3>Echidnas, echidnas, echidnas</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/540/0*8B8-7hH63pzJD8pn.png" /></figure><p>There are a few factors that led to the proliferation of echidnas in Ken’s comics, but it’s mostly a matter of coincidence. For one, Knuckles instantly became a fan favorite, so Archie naturally wanted more stories about him. Ken’s desire to make his mark on the lore of Angel Island and the echidna race meant that it didn’t take long for Archie to give him near complete control over the character in their comics. Sega apparently also let him do basically whatever he wanted with Knuckles, whereas pitches for Sonic-centric stories faced much more scrutiny, so it didn’t take long for Ken to start dumping all of his ideas into Knuckles stories.</p><p>Really, with little established canon to worry about at the time, Angel Island was just this perfect little isolated part of the world where Penders could tell his own original story that, deep down, had little to do with the <em>Sonic</em> franchise.</p><p>To kick things off, Penders established that Knuckles was guarding Angel Island because he was the latest member of the Brotherhood of Guardians, a role passed down from father to son for generations. (Knuckles had exactly one female ancestor who served as Guardian, but we barely ever saw her, because of course we didn’t.)</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/540/0*Akr8QTXMtJKvDtBE.png" /><figcaption>Knuckles is the latest Knuckles in a long line of Knuckleses</figcaption></figure><p>Penders’ Knuckles is not the lovable blockhead with a quick temper from the games and other media. He’s more of a generic comic book leading man. He’s smart and uses lots of big words, but he’s not quite a genius. He has quips and one-liners, but he’s not really funny. When he got his own series, he briefly tried to use “It’s crunch time!” as a catchphrase. This didn’t catch on. Ultimately, he sounds like most other characters Ken writes. He has few defining traits, and the story just sort of happens around him.</p><p>After a string of stories where Knuckles wandered around Angel Island and talked to himself, and then two arcs about him actually fighting bad guys, Penders made another big reveal. The high-tech capital city of Echidnaopolis, which Knuckles believed had been destroyed hundreds of years ago, still existed. The city quickly became the new primary setting for the Knuckles solo series.</p><p>At this point, the floodgates were truly open</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/540/0*nTq2xS6Crv7Ckluk.png" /></figure><p>It took me a while to realize this, but Penders sort of turned the echidnas into Kryptonians. (In hindsight, the hyphenated female echidna names like Julie-Su and Lien-Da were dead giveaways.) Our superpowered hero, the son of an incredibly important scientist with a god complex, was originally thought to be the last survivor of this highly advanced race. But eventually, more survivors were found, and soon there were important echidnas all over the place. They’re even associated with magic green crystals! And to really drive this similarity home: for years, Penders wanted to tell a story where Mobius exploded and everyone fled to space.</p><p>Penders also had a tendency to treat echidnas as very special. When explaining Mobius’s prehistory, he established them as the first race to attain advanced technology after the apocalypse. (Oh yeah, have I mentioned that Mobius is a post-apocalyptic Earth in the Archie comics? That wasn’t Ken’s idea, though.) Because of this, the echidnas have always thought they were better than everyone else. They’re supposed to be key allies of Sally’s royal family, but they repeatedly refused to help in the war against Robotnik because they’re smug, isolationist assholes.</p><p>Knuckles’ ancestors were also horrible British colonizers — the echidna homeland is in Mobius’s version of England — who took land from the “less evolved” races (<strong>ugh</strong>). This includes the dingoes, natives of Downunda (Mobius’s Australia) whose land was stolen so that Echidnaopolis could be built. And when I say the land was “stolen,” I mean that quite literally — the echidnas eventually hoisted it into the sky to dodge a meteor, creating Angel Island as we know it. They basically Brexited their capital city into the goddamn sky. Needless to say, the dingoes were not pleased about being stuck on a big floating rock with their oppressors.</p><p>On that note, I should probably talk about the furry politics in these comics, huh</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/540/0*gYdFzbMh1gKllUvI.png" /></figure><h3>Immature attempts at maturity</h3><p>Many of the strangest things that occurred in Ken’s run were misguided attempts at making his stories come off as more “mature,” which catapulted the tone of the comics straight from the Silver Age into the Dark Age. This came in many different forms.</p><h4>1. Furry politics!</h4><p>Penders often injected allusions to real world politics into his comics. Now, to be clear: I am absolutely not a “keep your politics out of my comics” type. The problem is Ken isn’t self-aware enough to treat these topics with care.</p><p>There are too many examples to list all of them here. The brief attempt to write an oppression allegory around the roboticized Mobians. Rotor’s sudden staunch anti-gun stance and his claim that the Freedom Fighters had <em>never</em> used guns, even though Penders had given Rotor guns multiple times before. But probably the biggest example is the obsession with fascism in the <em>Knuckles</em> comics. Granted, Penders had nothing to <em>say </em>about fascism, other than “it’s bad.” But boy, for someone with nothing to say on this topic, Penders sure did say a lot.</p><p>The Dark Legion, the main bad guys of the Knuckles comics, are techno-fascist echidnas. The comics really beat you over the head with this fact. One <em>Knuckles </em>arc focused on them rigging an election, and it included an absolutely bewildering number of tasteless allusions to World War II and the Holocaust. This included <a href="https://thankskenpenders.tumblr.com/post/184092781835/unsurprisingly-the-brainwashed-high-councilor-has">echidnas doing “hail Hitler” salutes</a>, Legionnaires <a href="https://thankskenpenders.tumblr.com/post/184044908107/this-issue-is-too-goddamn-much">smashing windows to evoke Kristallnacht</a>, and most infamously of all… Penders rephrasing Martin Niemöller’s “First they came…” to be about echidnas and hedgehogs.</p><p>I wish I was kidding.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/339/0*4eDek6k_oCW4KtKA.png" /><figcaption>that isn’t even how it happened</figcaption></figure><p>So yes, the Dark Legion are a bunch of Nazis, and their leader Dimitri is Echidna Hitler. But Dimitri is also Knuckles’ great great great great (like fifteen more greats) uncle from the past. Eventually, in stories published after the end of his solo series, Knuckles teams up with Dimitri in order to save Echidnaopolis from… Dimitri? Yeah, it didn’t make a lot of sense. But then, after this point, Knuckles inexplicably started sticking up for Dimitri and the Dark Legion? And telling everyone to trust them?</p><p>Knuckles literally pretends to take a bullet to convince the other echidnas to trust the Legion, even though only a dozen or so issues prior Penders was writing them as in-your-face Nazi allegories.</p><p>To make matters worse, though, the Dark Legion aren’t the only <em>Knuckles</em> villains who were designed to evoke Nazi Germany. There’s also the dingoes! “Wait Bobby,” I can hear you saying. “You just said that the dingoes were a native race that the echidnas colonized and subjugated.” Uh huh! Are you seeing the problem here? On the one hand, the dingoes are a marginalized racial minority who got stuck on a floating island with their colonizers — they literally live in Echidnaopolis’s ghetto, and they’re shown protesting for equal rights a few times. At the same time, these same dingoes are <em>also </em>a bunch of Nazis with buzz cuts and jodhpurs and names like “Helmut von Stryker.” Ken wanted to have it both ways. Eventually, Knuckles starts to sympathize a bit with the dingoes, but their methods are always framed as too violent, and Ken avoided depicting any women or children among the dingoes so that they’d come off as less sympathetic.</p><p>Okay, let’s back up. Why are there techno-fascists? Well, one of the central storylines in <em>Knuckles </em>is an ideological battle over the use of technology.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/540/0*axprx89KNSyatshh.png" /></figure><p>Early stories repeatedly claimed that the technology-reliant echidnas of the past (in particular Dimitri, future Echidna Hitler) were punished for their hubris. To repent, they apparently abandoned their technology and <em>destroyed </em>the city of Echidnaopolis. As it turns out, that last part isn’t true in the slightest. The city and its tech still exist in Knuckles’ time. Okay, but surely they got rid of their weapons, right? Nope! They still have guns!! Hell, at a later point, Sally goes to the Brotherhood for help in the escalating fight against Robotnik, and they refuse because the Freedom Fighters won’t use their guns. They just love guns so goddamn much, you guys.</p><p>They also had nukes!</p><p>Confusingly, the Dark Legion (the bad guys in the Knuckles comics) started out as a faction that wanted to maintain the status quo and prevent the rest of Echidnaopolis from abandoning technology. But like I said: the good guys never abandoned their technology. The status quo never actually changed much. So what exactly did the Legion want? Who knows! They just arbitrarily turned into cyborg fascists and got exiled.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/412/0*IN26ak0MtggJA6AR.png" /></figure><p>This theme of an ideological battle over technology never really goes anywhere. For a time, it seems like the hypocrisy of the Brotherhood and the Echidnaopolis government is intentional. The High Councilor (basically the mayor) is really bougie, and attention is drawn to his personal limo. There are technological haves and have-nots in this society, and those in power get to decide who’s who. But this train of thought also fizzles out, as Knuckles’ family is just as rich and bougie as the High Councilor, and this is never painted as a bad thing. Later, Penders tries to reframe the whole conflict as one of religious fundamentalism vs. reckless technological progress (even though the radical pro-tech guys, the Dark Legion, initially only wanted to preserve the status quo). In this framing, Knuckles sort of represents a balance between the two sides as both God’s chosen one and a genetically engineered bioweapon.</p><p>Have I mentioned that Knuckles is a genetically engineered bioweapon?</p><h4>2. Drugs!</h4><p><em>Knuckles</em> #13 opens with Harry the dingo cab driver (the one dingo character who isn’t a Nazi) discovering Charmy Bee in an alley, with another bee we’ve never met before collapsed in his arms. Harry rushes Charmy and his apparent best friend Mello to the hospital. The doctors try their best, but they have to break the bad news to Charmy. Mello is dead.</p><p>How did Charmy’s best friend die? Oh, by accidentally eating a drug-laced chili dog and overdosing on LSD!</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/540/0*eeYykFeaKEE_d2zf.png" /></figure><p>See, the shady owner of the local carnival is secretly working with a drug lord. He’s lacing his carnival food with this substance called “Lemon Sundrop Dandelion” (very subtle, Ken) in an effort to get the locals hooked on it. And now kids are getting poisoned left and right, including Charmy’s friend. The Chaotix investigate, but they get hungry and idiotically decide to eat the carnival food, and well…</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/658/1*iOEvXWVbHSwti0tLHOTFag.png" /></figure><p>Then they get dragged to the hospital because they’re fucking tripping balls on acid. Shenanigans ensue</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/540/0*iAR2dYcB3Q6XGiiX.png" /></figure><p>Yes, this happened in an officially licensed <em>Sonic the Hedgehog</em> comic.</p><p>This is the only story about drugs in the series, but it’s so bizarre because it doesn’t focus on the usual Very Special Episode peer pressure narrative. The victims don’t even know they’re being drugged! It reminds me more of those nutty articles claiming people are giving away edibles to trick-or-treaters.</p><h4>3. Religious allegories!</h4><p>Since he made Knuckles a chosen one, Ken just couldn’t resist throwing in some Christ allusions. Early in his solo series, Knuckles is vaporized by Dimitri, then <a href="https://thankskenpenders.tumblr.com/post/109052462180/in-case-those-dramatic-beams-of-light-in-the">resurrected by the Ancient Walkers</a> (three of the deities of Mobius) to become the savior of echidna kind. Later, he makes a heroic sacrifice (this time to <em>save</em> Dimitri, the guy who killed him last time) and is resurrected by <em>another </em>deity. In one issue, Knuckles’ mom is <a href="https://thankskenpenders.tumblr.com/post/183614446137/this-issue-literally-opens-with-knuckles-mom">praying in an echidna church</a>, bathed in holy light, and then comes home to suddenly find Knuckles, seemingly answering her prayers. There’s the sudden Christlike forgiveness Knuckles shows towards the Dark Legion after attaining his nigh-omnipotent Chaos Knuckles form. And of course, the most classic example: a scene where Knuckles led a bunch of other echidnas to the promised land by literally walking on water.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/259/1*U91xW0LyIvUnokxZ1st7jw.png" /></figure><p>Of course, while Knuckles is Echidna Jesus, there’s also his father, a bearded man who watches over everything he does from afar and judges his every action. I was so mad when I figured this one out. But everything about Locke makes me mad, really.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/540/0*iWKQ7sLtHZOJ2wO4.png" /></figure><h3>Bad dads</h3><p>Penders had a love of introducing <em>secret family members</em>. Sally had a long lost brother, Prince Elias, who everyone had conveniently forgotten about. Sonic had his parents, Jules and Bernie (the latter of whom is named for Penders’ wife), who had gone missing during Robotnik’s takeover. But two family members have always loomed large over Penders’ stories. Those characters are Sally’s father, King Maximillian Acorn, and Knuckles’ father, Locke.</p><p>To explain Locke and his whole deal, I have to talk about the Brotherhood of Guardians. You know how I said that Knuckles was the descendant of the previous Guardians of Angel Island? You probably assumed that meant the previous Guardians were gone, right? Nope! Knuckles has grandpas who are still alive like eight generations back. Possibly more — most of them are interchangeable, so it’s easy to lose count. They refuse to die for hundreds of years because of Chaos Emerald magic. On the rare occasions one of Knuckles’ racist grandpas managed to actually kick the bucket, I was ecstatic.</p><p>This secret cabal of racist grandpas has almost complete control over Angel Island. They’re essentially royalty. They still let Echidnaopolis act like a democracy, but the Brotherhood rules from the shadows, operating above the law however they see fit with no one to hold them accountable. This is never presented as a bad thing. So yeah, all of the previous Guardians were assholes. But Locke is a very special breed of monster.</p><p>One night, before Knuckles was born, the echidna God showed Locke a vision of his adult son battling a giant robot. Locke was so spooked by this that he decided he had to perform dangerous genetic experiments on himself to turn his offspring into a mutant superweapon. After his wife, Lara-Le, laid Knuckles’ egg (they’re echidnas, remember), Locke took the egg and blasted his unhatched son with dangerous Chaos Emerald radiation in the hopes that it would give him superpowers.</p><p>This whole backstory is lovingly summarized by fans as “had a bad dream, better microwave the baby.” This story is also why Knuckles has mutant knuckles.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/540/0*hI9vpLBNJNniIrSE.png" /><figcaption>Pictured: Locke, microwaving the baby.</figcaption></figure><p>It gets worse, though! See, Locke did <em>all of this </em>without telling his wife. She was completely left out of this decision making process. Then, when Knuckles was an infant, Locke decided that he was going to take him to live in the wilderness and train to be the next Guardian. Again, Knuckles’ mother Lara-Le had no say in this, and was visibly distraught over having her infant son taken from her.</p><p>Out in the wilderness, Locke trained and home schooled Knuckles, but he also told his son all sorts of lies. He lied about Echidnaopolis being destroyed, and told Knuckles that the two of them were the last of their kind. He let him believe that his mother was dead. And then, at the age of 10, Locke abandoned Knuckles. He jumped into a wall of fire and convinced Knuckles that he had killed himself, leaving the 10-year-old Knuckles as the sole protector of Angel Island.</p><p>In reality, the fire was merely a hologram. Locke watched over Knuckles through his network of spy cameras and continued to control his life from the shadows, but his son believed he was alone. At one point, Locke and the Brotherhood also tried to murder another kid who was picking on Knuckles. They literally <a href="https://thankskenpenders.tumblr.com/post/184856745877/knuckles-dad-and-grandpas-randomly-chucking-grape">threw a gorilla off of Angel Island in the middle of the night.</a></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/540/0*UQFDKQ-0OfzTp8sU.png" /></figure><p>Fast forward to the early issues of <em>Knuckles, </em>and the titular hero has been monitored by his “dead” father nonstop for several years. Knuckles starts to meet other relatives he thought were dead, like his mom and a few of his racist grandpas (all of whom know that Locke is still alive), but Locke remains out of sight. Knuckles grows increasingly frustrated with his family’s secrecy and the pressure put on him, and it looks like his destiny might be to confront the Brotherhood and break from their horrible traditions.</p><p>If you’re unfamiliar with the series, you’re probably reading all this and thinking “so Locke is a villain, right?”</p><p>Nope!</p><p>We hit <em>Knuckles</em> #25, and Penders decides it’s time for Knuckles and Locke to reunite because it’s a milestone issue. How does this happen? Knuckles spots Locke in the city completely on accident, and Locke doesn’t manage to get away fast enough. So he just… <a href="https://thankskenpenders.tumblr.com/post/184233235998/so-after-so-many-issues-of-creepily-watching">gives up, and lets his son catch him</a>.</p><p>Does Knuckles confront his dad for all the lying and manipulating? Is he mad when he realizes his dad faked his own death? Does Locke apologize for anything? Nah!!! Knuckles is just happy to see him! Even after Locke explains that he used Knuckles as a guinea pig and forced him into the role of a savior from birth because he had a vision one time, Knuckles seems cool with it. He immediately forgives his dad for everything, starts pretending they have a normal father-son relationship, and never questions him again. Years in the future, Knuckles reflects on how good of a parent he thinks Locke was.</p><p>Locke never has to pay for what he did, nor do the characters really humor the thought that he should even be sorry. The fact that he meant well is good enough. We’re supposed to like him. Ken sure did! Hell, we’re even supposed to think he’s cool! Towards the end of his run, Ken did baffling things like having elderly scientist Locke <a href="https://thankskenpenders.tumblr.com/post/187988097962/so-whats-the-first-thing-penders-does-with">beat Shadow in a fight</a> and having him <a href="https://thankskenpenders.tumblr.com/post/188241335835/so-anti-sonic-still-pretending-to-be-the-real">get kissed by Rouge the Bat</a>. Rouge was just using him to get the Master Emerald, but she still seemed to genuinely think he was the hottest stud on Angel Island. (Penders allegedly did not know that Rouge was only 18 when he wrote this arc.)</p><p>Locke never apologizes to Knuckles, or his ex-wife for that matter. Oh, and speaking of her, there’s also this absolutely dreadful part where Locke forces a kiss on Lara-Le, even though they’ve been divorced for years and she’s engaged to someone else. This even immediately follows a flashback to Locke being horrible to Lara-Le in the past. It is <em>putrid.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/630/1*5iVt3koRK-eGTxKVUgy7Uw.png" /></figure><p>Locke wasn’t alone in this, either! Under Penders, Sally’s father, King Maximilian Acorn (who we’ll discuss in a moment), was just as bad. And in his final arc before quitting, he almost turned Sonic’s Uncle Chuck into another conflicted father figure who fucked up catastrophically but “meant well.”</p><p>I don’t personally like to psychoanalyze Penders through his stories — at the end of the day, I don’t know the man, no matter how many comics of his I’ve read — but with the topic of shitty dads, it’s hard not to.</p><p>See, Penders has been very open about the fact that Locke was based in part on his own father. As Ken has explained, he had a rough relationship with his dad, and only really made amends with him at the end of his life. A flash forward story about Knuckles mourning his father’s death (the cause of which was pancreatic cancer, a side effect of Locke’s experimentation on himself) was dedicated to Ken’s own father. And you know, on some level, I sympathize with the guy. Growing up with a shitty dad is tough, and leaves you with a lot of baggage and complex feelings after he’s gone. The kind of complex feelings that many, many, <em>many </em>artists explore through their work.</p><p>The problem is that the feelings characters like Knuckles and Sally have about their awful abusive dads <em>aren’t</em> complex. On the contrary, they’re incredibly black and white. They’re frustrated with their dads at first, but the dads always have “good reasons” (usually “God showed me the future”) for the horrible things they do. After the shitty dads explain their reasoning, their kids forgive them unconditionally. In their eyes, the behavior was justified by the fact that their dads “had their best interests in mind.” Father knows best, after all!</p><p>This recurring theme is honestly one of the most sickening parts of Ken’s body of work to me. The message it sends to kids is loud and clear: “you must love your parents unconditionally — they only hurt you because they love you.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/492/0*U5f1dvKMgvZywYKC.png" /></figure><h3>Sally had a bad dad, too</h3><p>The earliest comics did not treat Sally Acorn well. Where <em>SatAM</em>’s Sally was a bold, confident leader with a quick wit, writer Michael Gallagher’s Sally was Sonic’s nagging girlfriend who tended to either stay home or get kidnapped. Even in issues where she wasn’t kidnapped, they’d often depict her as a damsel on the covers. And where cartoon Sally downplayed her own status as royalty, comic Sally liked to sit on a big throne and boss everyone around.</p><p>Things actually started to improve with Ken’s early work. One of his first stories ca. 1994 was a patronizing but well-meaning “girls can do anything” story starring Sally and Bunnie Rabbot, and he quickly took an interest in fleshing out Sally’s backstory and using her as a point of view character. The first sign that this wouldn’t last, though, was 1995&#39;s three-issue <em>Princess Sally</em> miniseries. In it, Sally finally got to go on a big adventure of her own. Except… not really. Much of the spotlight was hogged by Ken’s new character, Geoffrey St. John (oh boy, we’ll get to him), and the Sally we followed for over half of the story? Was actually a robot doppelganger. Yes, for the sake of a twist, the <em>Princess Sally </em>miniseries did not actually star Princess Sally. Even ignoring this, Sally came off as flat. She was too perfect, with no real personality. Ken tried so hard to write a “strong female character” that he wrote one with no interesting traits whatsoever.</p><p>This miniseries sold poorly (it was mostly marketed towards boys, who were afraid to buy a “girly” comic). Ken took it as a sign that fans didn’t like Sally.</p><p>In 1996, the Freedom Fighters finally succeeded in their quest to save Sally’s father, King Maximilian Acorn, who had been missing for ten years in-fiction. This felt like a huge victory. The tide was beginning to turn in their favor. But to Penders and the other writers, the King being back meant the Princess was no longer needed. The writers didn’t really know what to do with her now that she had been outranked, and her romantic relationship with Sonic was heavily restricted by Sega mandates.</p><p>So what did Ken do? He killed Sally.</p><p>1997&#39;s “Endgame” arc (<em>Sonic</em> #47-#50) was written as a potential series finale — <em>SatAM </em>had been off the air for over two years at this point, and the team figured their days were numbered. So Ken wanted it to be as dramatic as possible. As previously mentioned, Robotnik was killed in the climax of this arc. But the inciting incident was the death of another main character: Sally. Did she at least have a heroic death? Did she sacrifice herself to save everyone? Nope! She fell about three or four stories during a random mission to Robotropolis and hit the ground too hard.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/611/1*1grLwj8eVUL99IopOJdvCg.png" /></figure><p>In Ken’s words… “Main reason I wanted to kill off Princess Sally back in the day: felt she made Sonic into a second banana and cramped his style.”</p><p>So you <em>killed her????</em></p><p>Due to immediate fan backlash (and possibly Sally’s role as one of the mascots for Sega World Sydney), Sega quickly demanded that Ken revive Sally. As such, the story was changed. In Ken’s original plans, the “Sally” who shows up alive at the end of <em>Sonic </em>#50 wasn’t the real Sally, but another robot doppelganger, as foreshadowed in the following issue. However, this whole subplot was scrapped, and the robot doppelganger was quietly retconned to be the real Sally after all. (This did still mean, though, that Sally, the leader of the Freedom Fighters, was in a coma throughout the climactic mission where Robotnik was finally defeated.)</p><p>Things didn’t get better after this point. Oh, no, no, no. We still had King Max to deal with.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/610/1*AAAkp3Es8rq4FXtOi5zQ7A.png" /></figure><p>In several stories written by Karl Bollers after Robotnik’s death, some of the civilians started to distrust the scores of freed “Robians” (roboticized Mobians who were formerly Robotnik’s mind controlled slaves, including Sonic’s family) as part of a short-lived oppression allegory. To escalate this conflict further, one of King Max’s first orders after returning to the throne was to have all of the Robians rounded up and executed. He called for genocide.</p><p>Bollers would soon reveal that Max was behaving this way because he was being manipulated by a major villain. Phew! But then Penders had Max scold Sally for not following these insane orders that he had literally given while being mind controlled by an evil wizard. Yes, even his order to <em>commit genocide.</em> “Ever since I ordered the dismantling of the Robians you’ve been questioning my judgment!” he says. Gee, I wonder why! (Even after admitting that he “wasn’t completely himself” at the time, he still feels the need to argue that the Robians don’t really count as people anyway, playing devil’s advocate for a call he had made under mind control.)</p><p>This tension between Sally and her father quickly became a running theme. Sally stomped around the castle complaining about how her dad never told her anything or let her make any decisions of her own, but the cool and rational Max simply told her that father knows best. He was incredibly controlling over her life, trying to force her into a loveless political marriage with Antoine at <em>two separate points</em>, and he eventually started forbidding her from even leaving the castle. For <em>years,</em> Sally was largely out of the action because her dad said she had to stay home and be the princess. Instead of rebelling, she simply gave up.</p><p>A year and a half’s worth of stories later, in <em>Knuckles </em>#29, Sally heads to Angel Island to ask the Brotherhood for help. Along the way, Penders squeezes in a scene where Sally decides to rationalize her father’s earlier call for robot genocide as “pragmatic,” and says that she should never have doubted him.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/658/1*3aNpVAY9sBmkez7FmLS2tQ.png" /></figure><p>Immediately after this, we got the lead story of 1999’s “Girls Rule” special, lovingly referred to by fans as “The Sally Dip Story.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/658/1*uuhZVAbHujAfaXJMCd1RYg.png" /></figure><p>This particular story is infamous for its uncomfortably nude art by Jim Valentino (reprints would later let Sally keep her vest on), but the story itself is just as nauseating. In it, Sally participates in an ancient (and extremely creepy) rite of passage that all heirs to her family’s throne go through. The ritual involves stripping down and wading into a golden pool of liquid (lovingly referred to by fans as “the pool of Tang”) so that she can bond with “the Source of All” — basically, God. Yes, the Acorn family has their own monotheistic God separate from the God the echidnas have. We don’t have time to get into that.</p><p>Once bonded with the Source, it begins to communicate with Sally telepathically, sending her a series of visions. And what’s the purpose of these visions? <strong><em>To tell her that her dad can literally see the goddamn future because of his connection to God, and that he is therefore always right.</em></strong></p><p>Yes, the asshole dad who constantly lies to her and manipulates her life is always right! His actions were justified all along! He never has to apologize for anything, because he “did everything out of love”! Again, between Locke and Max, this is a deeply concerning running theme in Ken’s work. The fathers are never wrong, and the hurt they cause their families are excused as acts of love.</p><p>Ultimately, this story about God making up excuses for Max’s behavior is framed as an empowering one, simply because Sally decided not to bond with the Source after all. This is framed as an act of agency for her, a symbolic act of defiance. But even after this, Sally has little agency or personality. Nor do most of the other female characters in Ken’s stories.</p><p>The rest of the “Girls Rule” special, Ken’s tribute to the female fans, doesn’t treat the other girls much better. Minor recurring character Lupe the Wolf gets a story where she’s roboticized and then seemingly sacrifices her life to save her family. The story literally ends on a shot of her grave. In Ken’s own words: “Frankly, I thought the Lupe story was important simply because it showed that even a female could make the ultimate sacrifice on behalf of those dear to her. More often than not, it’s the girls who are usually shown being rescued instead of heroic, and that’s why I felt that this was an opportunity to really make a statement with this character.”</p><p>Yeah, you sure did make a statement there, my guy.</p><h3>Furry racism</h3><p>I already covered the dingoes, but that actually wasn’t the only instance of echidna colonialism in the comics. When it came time to adapt <em>Sonic Adventure </em>in 2000<em>, </em>Ken decided to add an extra subplot. He said that the Mystic Ruins were located in “Mysterious Cat Country,” a nation in Mobius’s equivalent of South America that the Knuckles Clan colonized. The cats don’t trust the echidnas because of this.</p><p>But once again, the victims of the echidnas’ colonization are painted as evil. This time, instead of being Nazis, the cats are cannibalistic jungle dwellers who eat their young. They’re much larger and more bestial than the other Mobians, and most of them carry spears. They’re a cruel stereotype in every way possible.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/658/1*cSw1eWIHUCyRkl46bMzLwg.jpeg" /></figure><p>Anyway, so the jungle cats kidnap the Chaotix, and then Locke shows up to beat them up. This is framed as cool and heroic by Penders. This is, of course, an extremely ironic thing to include in what’s otherwise a straight adaptation of <em>Sonic Adventure, </em>a game about breaking cycles of violence through empathy. (<em>Sonic Adventure</em> may not have the deepest writing, but Sonic spells this theme out in the climax.)</p><p>Then you have the more… <em>“urban” </em>characters. In the <em>Knuckles </em>arc where the Chaotix accidentally got high on acid, the villainous drug lord is essentially a stereotypical pimp named <a href="https://archiesonic.fandom.com/wiki/Downtown_Ebony_Hare">Downtown Ebony Hare</a>. The character who took the cake, though, was Vector. In Ken’s stories, Vector was the jive-talking comic relief character. He was obnoxious, he was dim-witted, he was crude, he’d randomly bring up rap music. One time he started singing “Dem Bones” to himself while held captive by the Dark Legion. He was also <em>extremely </em>misogynistic (one arc literally went into great detail about how he viewed women as prizes to be won — ironic, given Ken’s treatment of Sally). He constantly said shit that got on the nerves of either Knuckles or Julie-Su, and then they would smack him around to shut him up. It often felt like Penders was turning Vector into Julie-Su’s personal punching bag, making her look “cooler” and “tougher” at Vector’s expense.</p><p>Anyway, here’s a panel in which I’m almost certain Penders made Vector say “bee-otch” before someone told him what that meant and it was censored:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/314/0*Gqnnjkv96qQvhKcD.png" /></figure><h3>Goddamn fucking love triangles</h3><p>Romance was always a big aspect of Archie <em>Sonic</em> due to the presence of Sally and the surprisingly large female audience. In most cases, Penders’ love stories could be summarized as “these two characters are in love because I said so.” We rarely saw why any of the couples <em>liked </em>each other. The plot simply dictated it.</p><p>The ultimate example of this is Knuckles’ relationship with Julie-Su. She defects from the Dark Legion, the evil fascist organization that had brainwashed her from birth, because she “soultouched” with Knuckles. This quite literally means that they’re soulmates from first sight, because this is apparently a function evolution has hard wired into every echidna. Really, Knuckles just needed a girlfriend so that he could have a kid to be his successor in “Mobius: 25 Years Later,” so Penders tossed in a new female character and said she was his soulmate.</p><p>The comics never really explain how this “soultouch” process can be so infallible if Locke and Lara-Le ended up getting divorced. There’s also this absurd part where Knuckles straight up asks if he can just be gay instead of dealing with his supposed soulmate, and Locke is like “now, now son, why don’t we go back to talking about your heterosexuality?”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/658/1*M6dmwDddq4iVLa5q_shsog.png" /></figure><p>(This issue where Knuckles gets “the talk” immediately follows the one where they reunite after years apart and Locke tells him he’s a mutant bioweapon.)</p><p>There’s also the love triangles. In his first few years on <em>Sonic</em>, Penders focused on one main love triangle between Sonic, Sally, and a new character of his own creation — Geoffrey St. John. Geoffrey is one of Ken’s most enduring creations, a skunk with an attitude comparable to James Bond and an inconsistent accent. (For years, readers have called Geoffrey his self-insert, but this is a reach. He’s just a Bond expy.)</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/540/0*vjmG8iJlzmyiJMEi.png" /></figure><p>Throughout this era of the comics, Sally would regularly make out with Geoffrey, the older, more suave Freedom Fighter, and Sonic would get angry about this. “Older?” I can already hear you asking, worried about what that might mean. “How much older was Geoffrey?” Well, Penders imagined Geoffrey as vaguely “college aged,” and he was definitely <em>at least</em> 20 or 21 when he was making out with Sally, who at the time was… 15 years old.</p><p><strong><em>Woof.</em></strong></p><p>If that’s not bad enough, Penders got himself into some hot water earlier this year when he ran his mouth on Twitter and declared that during this period of the story, Geoffrey had apparently taken Sally’s virginity off-screen. In his exact words:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/575/1*kG-Mg2Eya-vK8KfZ_FxHYQ.png" /></figure><p>Words cannot do justice to how vile this is. Not only because Sally is <em>a minor</em>, but also because of how illuminating it is. It puts that whole arc into perspective. Sally was not an active participant in that love triangle — she was a prize to be fought over between Sonic and Geoffrey. She had no say, she merely responded to the competing boys’ advances to indicate who was currently “winning.” And by being “faster on the draw,” Geoffrey “tainted” Sally for Sonic, like how one might lick someone else’s food to keep them from eating it.</p><p>(After this initial tweet blew up, Ken dug himself into a very deep hole. His arguments ranged from “the age of consent on Mobius is actually 16” (Sally wasn’t 16!) to a claim that if Geoffrey hadn’t slept with the underage princess, he would’ve had to turn to “the kingdom’s red light district.” Apparently he just HAS to fuck.)</p><p>But the thing is, that’s only what he <em>thought </em>about doing. No matter what Ken claims, it didn’t make it into the book. But once, in one of the final arcs he wrote… a reference to characters having sex actually made it to print. Under-the-radar adult jokes and implications in children’s media are nothing new, of course, but the subtext here is especially nasty.</p><p>2005’s <em>Sonic</em> #150 and #151 revolve around Sonic’s evil doppelganger from another universe, Anti-Sonic, posing as the real Sonic and hitting on just about every girl he knows. For the most part, these characters all managed to come out of this relatively unscathed, but one didn’t. And that would just so happen to be my favorite character: poor, poor Bunnie Rabbot.</p><p>Tails finds Anti-Sonic making out with Bunnie in the bushes. Now, Bunnie isn’t with her usual boyfriend Antoine at this point, because Antoine had <em>also </em>been replaced with an evil doppelganger at that point, and the evil Antoine broke up with her. But she still had feelings for Antoine, and wanted to win him back. Bunnie is also Sally’s best friend, and she absolutely knew that Sally still had feelings for Sonic at that point. And yet, in spite of this, Bunnie is apparently <em>so desperate </em>to be shown affection that she gladly starts rolling in the hay with “Sonic.”</p><p>After the scene with Tails, we immediately cut to this:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/638/1*fUQr3FyYe5H1AFFmIGIAAA.png" /></figure><p>If it’s not obvious, the implication here is that Anti-Sonic tricked Bunnie into having sex with him.</p><p>Everything about this is just disgusting, <em>especially </em>Anti-Sonic’s smug wink at the camera. But also, look closer at that dialogue. The lines about a “nap”? They’re in a different font. They aren’t hand lettered. This is a telltale sign that the text was altered late in production. I shudder to think what it originally said. And the icing on the cake? Penders considers this not a story about Bunnie being victimized, but rather a story about her betraying Antoine’s trust by sleeping with another guy.</p><p>After this, the real Sonic quickly returns to his rightful place and kicks Anti-Sonic out. Except, he didn’t bother to set the record straight about what happened. In the following issue, Bunnie still had feelings for Sonic, thinking that they had been together. And immediately following this, Sonic inexplicably started dating Fiona Fox as a rebound girlfriend, somehow playing into Ken’s master plan to get Sonic and Sally back together over the next… oh, 50 issues.</p><h3>Fighting with the other writers over continuity</h3><p>Thankfully, later writers would fix many of Penders’ worst mistakes, including much of the love triangle garbage. In the early 2000s, Karl Bollers completely abandoned Geoffrey’s feelings for Sally and had him marry a woman his age. Much of the first year of Ian Flynn’s run in 2006–2007 was also dedicated to fixing the quagmire of love triangles that Penders had ended his run on.</p><p>Penders was never happy about other writers touching his things, though.</p><p>Earlier, I mentioned the “Return to Angel Island” arc by Karl Bollers. It’s by far my favorite arc in the first 13 years of the series. Released in 2004 shortly after the comics’ big one-year timeskip, the arc has Sonic, Knuckles, Julie-Su, and the Chaotix infiltrating an Eggman-occupied Angel Island to liberate the echidnas.</p><p>You see, Echidnaopolis has been reduced to rubble (for real this time), the Brotherhood is missing, and the echidnas are desperate. They no longer have their big fancy city, and they now resemble the Knuckles Tribe from <em>Sonic Adventure. </em>They’ve put all their faith in the Chosen One prophecy surrounding Knuckles, believing that he’ll be the one to save them. Except… Knuckles lost his powers a year ago, and he has no idea if he’s capable of helping. Meanwhile, the “reformed” Dark Legion is trying to use their advanced technology to fight Eggman and rescue as many people as they can. They really are genuinely helping here… but it’s also clear that they have ulterior motives. Needless to say, the Dark Legion isn’t happy when a powerless Knuckles returns and is immediately hailed as a savior. Knuckles, on the other hand, considers all of this his cosmic punishment for rejecting his ascent to godhood at the end of the Chaos Knuckles arc so that he could instead save his loved ones back on Mobius.</p><p>Everyone just feels <em>right. </em>Knuckles is finally an underdog, and his fiery personality is on display at long last. The Dark Legion are sinister jerks, but for once their actions make logical sense, and it feels like they actually believe in what they’re doing (even if they’re doing so for the wrong reasons). Knuckles’ friends and the Legion butt heads throughout the arc as Knuckles questions what kind of hero he is — if he can still consider himself one at all.</p><p>Oh, and this arc also introduced Knuckles’ baby brother… who Bollers decided to name Kneecaps. Beautiful.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/658/1*ymHfi7UEx0E7ojS9teLynA.png" /></figure><p>Penders hated this arc, though.</p><p>Ken liked to maintain a very specific status quo on Angel Island, and was <em>livid </em>when Karl shook things up. Ken referred to the arc as a “hissy fit” written to undermine his work. When Karl moved on to other projects and Ken regained control of Angel Island, the echidnas rapidly rebuilt their city, and Locke immediately began searching for the missing Brotherhood. He was determined to erase Karl’s story from relevance and return everything to the way it used to be.</p><p>Penders wanted full control over the lore. He was the first writer who gave a shit about the lore in the comics, so in his eyes, his take on the franchise is one of the most important. He sees himself as Sonic’s Jack Kirby — a visionary creator who was treated unfairly by his employers and not given his due credit. He rants about how Sega and IDW should hire him back so he can completely throw out all of the stories written by Ian Flynn since his departure and get back to what the fans <em>really </em>want.</p><p>After all, it was all going somewhere, right?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/646/1*beP5_uIfdzYsZ-euK9d6wg.png" /></figure><h3>“Mobius: 25 Years Later” — a story about nothing</h3><p>The story he was building to — one of his proudest creative achievements, the story he came back to write after nearly quitting the series with <em>Sonic </em>#125 — was “Mobius: 25 Years Later.” It was published from 2003 to 2004 in <em>Sonic </em>#131 through #144, primarily as shorter backup stories, although it got top billing a few times. This is basically the <em>Boruto </em>or <em>Harry Potter </em>epilogue<em> </em>of Archie <em>Sonic. </em>It’s the future, and all the characters have been arbitrarily paired off into loveless straight marriages so that they can all have boring kids. Knuckles and Julie-Su are married with a daughter, Lara-Su. King Sonic and Queen Sally have kids that look just like them. Everyone’s married with kids. Knuckles now sits in a cave all day and monitors Angel Island via his spy cameras, like Locke, because everyone has to turn into their shitty parents. It’s all depressing.</p><p>While Archie naturally said that M25YL was only one possible future timeline, Ken always intended for it to be <em>the </em>canonical future for these characters, the one he had been foreshadowing from the start. He always hated it when anyone contradicted him on this, too — legend has it that he banned Karl Bollers from his personal forum over one such argument. He also took any stories that seemingly contradicted the future depicted in M25YL as attempts to undermine him.</p><p>What‘s the actual plot of this arc, though? Well, towards the beginning, Sonic’s scientist pal Rotor Walrus, core member of the Freedom Fighters since <em>SatAM, </em>discovers that Mobius is going to explode. Sonic apparently messed up the timespace continuum something fierce when they were teenagers, and now they’re boned. <strong>“If only we could travel back in time,” </strong>Rotor says. But apparently, that’s impossible.<em> I want you to remember that for later.</em></p><p>After this, the story shifts focus almost exclusively to domestic life. They talk about how Lara-Su (the alleged protagonist of the arc) is doing in school, and she begs her dad to make her the next Guardian. They sit around their big fucking mansion, and talk to their creepy looking and vaguely racist koala maid about what they’re going to have for dinner. They have a dinner party. They have a pool party. They have a slumber party. They gossip about the kids’ love lives. Julie-Su has a casual Skype video call with Lien-Da, her fascist half-sister who murdered her parents and spent years brainwashing her. For years, Ken assured fans that the rough-and-tumble Julie-Su would not be forced into the role of Knuckles’ traditional housewife. But that’s exactly what we got. Even Sonic is boring now. He’s given in to the mundane life of a king, no longer going on adventures. He doesn’t even talk to Tails anymore.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/658/1*28UWE_RH5EOezPvws1leBg.png" /></figure><p>This lasts for<em> </em><strong><em>fifteen issues.</em></strong></p><p>Oh, and then there’s Rotor. Rotor is hanging around this old echidna scientist named Cobar now. He’s just another character to have around so that Rotor isn’t talking to himself when he gives exposition. Nothing really special. No real obvious connection there.</p><p>According to Penders, this is Rotor’s husband.</p><p>Now, if there’s one thing anyone knows about me, it’s that I am an extremely bisexual woman, and I want every cartoon in the universe to be the gayest and transest shit imaginable. The Sonic comics are no exception. Sally and Nicole for life, babey. But Ken’s attempt at writing Rotor as gay could not have been weaker. It’s all the mildest subtext possible, with no real passion. Sure, gay narratives are often censored, and you can only get away with so much. But Rotor and Cobar barely even seem to be <em>friends. </em>And yet Ken expects to be heaped with praise for doing the bare minimum. He has literally claimed that his mild hinting at Rotor’s sexuality “paved the way for Kevin Keller,” <em>Archie</em>’s first openly gay character.</p><p>Do you wanna know why we even know about this gay subtext in the first place? Because when Ian Flynn later killed off Cobar, thinking that he was a redundant character who added nothing to the story, Ken decided to make a big stink online about how Ian had apparently killed off Rotor’s husband. No one at Archie knew that this was his intention. He never told them.</p><p>Upon closer inspection, fans also found one more hint at Penders’ plans for Rotor’s sexuality. In a throwaway scene in 2005&#39;s <em>Sonic </em>#157, Eggman calls Rotor “our dear Rotor.” Sonic interprets this as meaning that Eggman knows something secret about Rotor. Apparently, this was foreshadowing the fact that Eggman was later going to out Rotor, or just straight up blackmail him.</p><p>Gay rights!</p><p>“Mobius: 25 Years Later,” while not the final arc Penders wrote for the series, was very clearly the final arc he gave a shit about. And it’s really the perfect encapsulation of his work on the series. It’s got it all! Boring echidna politics, cliffhangers that go nowhere, Knuckles threatening to spank his teenage daughter, everyone inexplicably being chill with the fascist Dark Legion for no reason, Knuckles being the most important person in the world, and female characters getting the shaft.</p><p>After over a dozen issues in which nothing happens, Ken decides to wrap things up. Sonic and Knuckles suddenly start talking about how they oughtta stop the planet from exploding. (Sally isn’t involved with this plan, in spite of being the queen of the most powerful nation in the world, because she’s a woman, and Penders is a misogynist.) So they go talk to Rotor, who suddenly has a brilliant idea…</p><p><strong>“What if we went back in time?”</strong></p><p>And so, the arc ends on a cliffhanger. Ken had several more years of M25YL stories planned, but he never got to write them himself, as he quit the series in 2006 after <em>Sonic </em>#159.</p><p>Thanks to Archie losing their copyright lawsuit against Ken, though, he’s now the proud owner of all of the stories and characters he wrote for Archie. Julie-Su, Geoffrey St. John, Sleuth Doggy Dawg, all his. They’d lost his contract, you see, and therefore the rights defaulted back to him. For the better part of a decade now, Ken has been talking about how he’s finally going to conclude the story of both “Mobius: 25 Years Later” and the whole <em>Knuckles </em>saga in the form of his new graphic novel series, <em>The Lara-Su Chronicles.</em></p><p>The art looks like this.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*08KLithPOW1cfmZk9hz9hA.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>Thank you for reading this incredibly long piece that got way out of hand! If you’re new to </em><a href="https://thankskenpenders.tumblr.com/"><em>Thanks Ken Penders</em></a><em> and you enjoyed it, maybe give the Tumblr a follow to see my future coverage of Ian Flynn’s run at Archie Sonic. You could also throw me a couple bucks on </em><a href="https://ko-fi.com/ponett"><em>Ko-Fi</em></a><em>, or check out the demo for my upcoming video game, </em><a href="https://ponett.itch.io/slarpgdemo"><em>Super Lesbian Animal RPG</em></a><em>. Wait, is it considered uncouth to plug yourself at the end of a Medium article? I don’t fuckin’ know.</em></p><p><strong><em>EDIT: </em></strong><em>If you would like to read something more positive about Archie Sonic, you can read </em><a href="https://medium.com/@ponett/10-weird-and-wonderful-archie-sonic-stories-that-hold-up-today-44df6d3a2fcb"><em>a quick followup article</em></a><em> about 10 stories I actually liked (mostly from the other writers). I was also invited by New York Magazine to write an article detailing Ken’s copyright battles and their impact on the Sonic franchise, </em><a href="https://nymag.com/intelligencer/2020/02/the-lawsuit-that-reshaped-sonic-the-hedgehog-comics.html"><em>which you can read here</em></a><em>.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=1f9dd05ae433" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>