<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Priyankar Bhunia on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Priyankar Bhunia on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@priyankarbhunia?source=rss-86d08e491c9------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Fri, 20 Nov 2026 01:54:15 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@priyankarbhunia/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Diary 2016 (July 29th)- Borrowed words]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@priyankarbhunia/diary-2016-july-27th-borrowed-words-c777fde2c7a6?source=rss-86d08e491c9------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c777fde2c7a6</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[violence]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[history]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[poetry]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[humanity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[terrorism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Priyankar Bhunia]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 31 Jul 2016 11:05:30 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-08-08T19:35:13.122Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>The morning after the coup attempt in Turkey the news was shared on one of my Whatssap groups. The outcome was not yet clear. One member of the group suggested that a successful coup might not be a bad thing. The army in Turkey is considered to the upholder of Ataturk’s liberal, secular legacy. Whereas Erdogan is an increasingly autocratic. megalomaniac ruler with alarming Islamist tendencies. At this stage, Fetullah Gulen’s name was not all over global headlines.</p><p>I replied that I detest Erdogan based on what I know. But he is a democratically elected leader with genuine popularity. How would his supporters react if he is removed through a coup and the army’s version of secularism is enforced? From a liberal perspective how is army rule preferable in any way? That would be replacing an elected president with authoritarian tendencies with autocratic enforcement of the views which happen to align with mine. The means do matter.</p><p>The scale might be different, but if Turkish liberals prefer this, then how are they any different from the <a href="http://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2016/05/30/the-new-activism-of-liberal-arts-colleges">micro-aggressions crowd</a> in American college campuses. Stifle voices which don’t match yours?</p><p>Another pointed out that liberalism and democracy do not necessarily coincide. Democracy might not always be the preferred environment for liberalism to thrive. He was right.</p><p>The (expected) aftermath of the coup in Turkey, the purge, the blatant human right abuses make the waters murkier. If you call yourself a liberal, where should you stand? Liberalism in my view is ultimately about individual freedom. But which bits of whose freedom do you choose, since you can’t have it all. Do we make a timetable like the Communists or do we cut pieces out of a pie like nationalists?Should we try to optimise the net freedom? What do the words liberal and freedom mean now?</p><p>In China, a liberal is essentially a right-winger, while a conservative would be a leftist. You have social and economic liberalism. The meaning of the word has <a href="https://aeon.co/essays/everyone-was-a-liberal-now-no-one-wants-to-be">changed with time and place</a>. While people of all stripes and shades <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JAUH6xyuEVQ">could agree on the details of right and wrong</a> I suspect, if they could bother to listen to each other, that is</p><p>I have been trying to write this for a month now. I have been unable to make much headway. I wanted to write about being a liberal. I was going to write about ideology as compromise, ideology as a take it or leave it package, ideology as a a thinking-substitute.</p><p>Every time there is a terrorist attack, every time another demagogue tells the ‘difficult truth’, every time humanism is denigrated in the name of realism, I try. I find that I have nothing to contribute other than my doubt.</p><p>In the midst of tumult, when I try to sort my thoughts, threads are left dangling. Questions remain unanswered. I am not even certain what the right questions are. I am only certain of my doubt.</p><p>In lieu of the 3000 word post I had in mind, I am going to borrow words. I will share two English poems by Auden and one in Hindi by Ramdhari Singh ‘Dinkar’.</p><p>I think they point to where we travelled and where we are headed. They remind us of what we have forgotten, of what we always forget.</p><p>They might seem didactic, they might appear naive, they might teeter on the edge of being too obvious. But only if we could grasp them.</p><p><a href="https://www.poets.org/poetsorg/poem/september-1-1939">September 1, 1939 Poems</a></p><p>Excerpt:</p><blockquote>Accurate scholarship can <br>Unearth the whole offence<br>From Luther until now<br>That has driven a culture mad,<br>Find what occurred at Linz,<br>What huge imago made<br>A psychopathic god:<br>I and the public know<br>What all schoolchildren learn,<br>Those to whom evil is done<br>Do evil in return.</blockquote><blockquote>Exiled Thucydides knew<br>All that a speech can say<br>About Democracy,<br>And what dictators do,<br>The elderly rubbish they talk<br>To an apathetic grave;<br>Analysed all in his book,<br>The enlightenment driven away,<br>The habit-forming pain,<br>Mismanagement and grief:<br>We must suffer them all again.</blockquote><blockquote>……….</blockquote><blockquote>Faces along the bar<br>Cling to their average day:<br>The lights must never go out,<br>The music must always play,<br>All the conventions conspire <br>To make this fort assume<br>The furniture of home;<br>Lest we should see where we are,<br>Lost in a haunted wood,<br>Children afraid of the night<br>Who have never been happy or good.</blockquote><blockquote>The windiest militant trash<br>Important Persons shout<br>Is not so crude as our wish:<br>What mad Nijinsky wrote<br>About Diaghilev<br>Is true of the normal heart;<br>For the error bred in the bone<br>Of each woman and each man<br>Craves what it cannot have,<br>Not universal love<br>But to be loved alone.</blockquote><p><a href="https://www.poets.org/poetsorg/poem/shield-achilles">The Shield of Achilles</a></p><p>Excerpt:</p><blockquote>The mass and majesty of this world, all<br> That carries weight and always weighs the same<br>Lay in the hands of others; they were small<br> And could not hope for help and no help came:<br> What their foes like to do was done, their shame<br>Was all the worst could wish; they lost their pride<br>And died as men before their bodies died.</blockquote><blockquote>……</blockquote><blockquote>A ragged urchin, aimless and alone, <br> Loitered about that vacancy; a bird<br>Flew up to safety from his well-aimed stone:<br> That girls are raped, that two boys knife a third,<br> Were axioms to him, who’d never heard<br>Of any world where promises were kept,<br>Or one could weep because another wept.</blockquote><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FiKzEr5itBPc%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DiKzEr5itBPc&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FiKzEr5itBPc%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=d04bfffea46d4aeda930ec88cc64b87c&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/850eb482847707f9a6ef965ac561af77/href">https://medium.com/media/850eb482847707f9a6ef965ac561af77/href</a></iframe><p>Interestingly, another poem by Dinkar extolling the necessity of war is oft-quoted and very popular. I remember complete passages from school. I discovered this one only last week. This one is about the aftermath of that necessary war.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c777fde2c7a6" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Diary 2016 (June 14th)- Reading, forgetting]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@priyankarbhunia/diary-2016-june-14th-reading-forgetting-b042176aa0ca?source=rss-86d08e491c9------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b042176aa0ca</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[reading]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[remembering]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[forgetting]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[books]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Priyankar Bhunia]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 17 Jun 2016 12:37:50 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-04-11T13:04:49.284Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*48PmbQWwhhE4JrVvz_VK4Q.jpeg" /><figcaption>A section of one of my bo0kshelves</figcaption></figure><p>A few days back a friend was rewatching The English Patient. He could hardly remember anything of the plot. He could only recall certain scenes, how he had felt during them. I had also seen the movie, a long time, 8–9 years, ago. I had read the book and I remembered liking it a lot. However hard I tried I could not recall any details of the story. Thinking of the movie and the book evoked a very specific mood, one of languid romance, of suffocating intensity, and of the weight of inexorable tragedy. In my memory it was a book to be read on hot, humid, lazy afternoons.</p><p>It got me thinking about other books I have read and forgotten. My wife was on a Maugham binge around then. I loved Of human bondage in high school. But I have not retained anything from it. How many more are there? Would it be most of what I have read? How many books have I read? How much do I remember? Does it all pass through my sieve-like mind leaving trace remnants sticking in lost corners? Then why do I read?</p><p>Absolute numbers don’t mean much. Still I will start with them because I do stack up totals. I take a snobbish pride, I would rarely admit to, in the quantity as well as quality of what I read.</p><p>Late last year, I started religiously updating my reading on Goodreads. I also meticulously went through my book purchases and library borrowing history to update all the books from 2015. It added up to 73 books, 26938 pages. I think it was a slightly better year than usual. Also, there was a drastic reduction in the number of movies I watched compared to prior years. Meaning more time for reading. Since the age of around 12, in an average year I guess I would be reading 50–60 books. I am 31 now. I arrive at a rounded cumulative figure of 1000.</p><p>It is depressing how small a speck it is in comparison to the cosmos of books worth reading. Even if I live for 40 more years and continue apace, I would have barely made a dent in my aspirational to-read list.</p><p>Then there are the big, fat classics. ‘Finishing’ one gives the satisfaction of conquering a formidable peak. Abandoning one midway feels like a shameful secret. It has happened more times than I can count, with authors from Dostoevsky to David Foster Wallace. In conversations, I have pretended to have read books I ditched. There are books I might have convinced myself that I have actually read, whereas I am familiar with the plot because it is embedded into the web of popular literary references. It is kind of the opposite of forgetting books I have actually read.</p><p>All this together with the low retention paints a bleak picture. But when I imagine life without books, I see a nightmare. I have always been unable to step outside the house without a book. I panic when I am halfway through a book, that it will be over and I will be alone somewhere, with nothing to do and nothing to read. So, I start carrying one more book, sometimes two because I haven’t yet decided what I am going to read next. I keep a Kindle for reading emergencies though I prefer reading on paper. It could be like any other addiction. Have I been after an ephemeral high for so long? The answer would be a qualified yes. For me nothing matches the rush of a startling image, an exquisitely crafted sentence (though I can never recall them to quote) or a subtle gut punch. They might not be the crucial pivots in the story but there was an inexplicable connection with them.</p><p>There has to be something more. I might be unable to provide a summary of books I read just a year ago. Yet they have left behind something more substantial than incidental dregs. Reading defines me, for good or bad. As much as my parents, my education, my experiences. The books interacted with who I was at that point. They fed from it, fed into it.</p><p>I read Revolutionary Road, while I was on my first job, well-paying, mind-numbing. The first stone had been laid on the path. The stones further ahead would be a house, a car, a wife, children. I would have a few night-outs with old buddies to relive past glories, to relieve the monotony. I had been listening to Mistaken for strangers by The National on loop. I had an inkling of what I didn’t want, no idea of what I wanted. Maybe I would write a book, maybe make films some day. Maybe, maybe. Then this book landed like an asteroid. It made me see the ‘hopeless emptiness’, scared the hell out of me. I ran. Not that I managed to escape it. I failed in a prosaic fashion compared to the understated grandeur of Yates’characters. The same theme of yearning for meaning dominates Richard Yates’ dark oeuvre. I read other books by him, though Revolutionary Road was the collision which changed everything.</p><p>Going back a few years, I find the great literary love affair of my youth, Haruki Murakami. I discovered and devoured his works when I was 17–18. I was going through a delayed adolescence, like many Indian kids I suspect. Murakami spoke to my dreamy unfocused angst. He gave wing to the unexpressed romance. His protagonists were shy, sensitive, earnest young men, with their noses buried in books, with their heads lost in the clouds. The women were intensely desirable and mysterious. They led the boys down unexpected rabbit holes. Murakami provided hope for salvation. He continued to be one of my fallback authors when I didn’t know what to read for the next 6–7 years. But gradually I started finding them a tad flimsy. His last few books seemed much weaker. Then the realization dawned that I was getting older. Still at that age, for a certain kind of personality, Murakami is the perfect author.</p><p>A few days back, a friend gave a relatively lowly 3 stars to a collection of short stories by Flannery O’Connor on Goodreads. I had read a complete collection of her short stories a long time ago. I remembered liking a lot the ones I liked. That frequently happens. I remember liking or not liking a book. When the same friend was reading a Susan Sontag book, I could remember feeling underwhelmed by it though the contents were missing from my memory.</p><p>Here too, I could not remember most of the stories. Her best known story, A good man is hard to find, was the exception. That left a deep imprint. It was the first time I encountered utterly meaningless violence in literature. Its meaning lay in its meaninglessness. I was slowly adjusting to the randomness of the real world. At some level I still wanted to believe that good and bad things happened for a reason. This story shook me up.</p><p>The full frontal assault came soon in the form of Eichmann at Jerusalem. A Couchsurfing guest had left behind a copy. The subheading of the book, ‘A report on the banality of evil’ succinctly summarizes the subject matter of the book. It forced me to face what I had subconsciously known for a while. Arendt was accused of victim-blaming, of trivializing one of the greatest human tragedies. I came to know of all that after I read the book. Even after a lot more reading, a lot more watching (the only other similarly transformative experience was sitting through the 9 hour documentary Shoah), I believe Arendt captured an essential and difficult truth. That any of us is capable of the most heinous of actions, given the right motivation or circumstances.</p><p>Around that time, I also read Hubert Selby Jr’s Last exit to Brooklyn. It battered my psyche almost to the edge. I felt I had witnessed truth. Recently I heard a song called Fitzpleasure with a repeated refrain, Tralala, and curious lyrics. Turns out it was inspired by a chapter from the aforementioned book. It was probably the darkest chapter in a dark book set among the dregs of society. I could recollect exactly how the book made me feel. But I had totally forgotten that chapter as well as the rest of the chapters.</p><p>Just when my worldview was turning unremittingly sour, I came upon Marilyn Robinson’s luminescent Gilead. Robinson also spoke the truth. It was a spiritual experience in the most un-religious sense of the word. It was probably the most deeply humane work I had read. I would never avert my eyes from the pervasive ugliness in the world. Nor would I lose sight of the tiny but important potential for good in man.</p><p>Then I discovered Alice Munro. She showed me the beautiful mundaneness of uneventful lives. Love, loneliness, joy, sorrow coursed through the veins of her stories of Candaian small town life. I had stories happening all around me. I just didn’t know how to look.</p><p>I had been reading and loving Philip K. Dick for a while. His works demonstrated what science fiction could be. He picked up a concept and forced his way to its logical implications. In terms of asking the questions, Kazuo Ishiguro’s Never let me go set new bars for me. It is a bit difficult to explain why it affected me so much. A partial explanation would be the heartbreaking sequence where they learn that making creative paintings is not enough to escape the claws of predestined fate.</p><p>Never let me go made me think what it means to be human, to be conscious, to be aware of my own mortality. I have always been a bit flummoxed by how little people think about death. I am not talking about staring down death and conquering your fears. I am talking about being aware that your time is limited. As a child, when I first learnt about death, it paralyzed me. I could not comprehend my consciousness not existing after a certain inevitable point. I was haunted by the idea. It could strike me any time, while taking a bath, during class. The fear (fear is a grossly inadequate word) persists but I have learnt to control it better.</p><p>There was a time when I read only fiction.The moment you put pen to paper or finger to keyboard, you put yourself into whatever you write. I saw the requirement of adhering strictly to facts as an encumbrance. I continue to believe that. But I trust my judgment more now. Reading the first couple of chapters of a non-fiction book, I think I can tell if it was written with a pre-conceived agenda. If a book passes the open exploration test, I continue with it. Now I read nearly as many non-fiction accounts as novels and short story collections.</p><p>During 2015, my non-fiction reading was focused on World War 2 and its aftermath. The one which left the deepest impression fell into a twilight zone between fiction and non-fiction. I hadn’t read anything remotely like it. In The skin, Curzio Malaparte combines journalistic reportage from postwar Sicily, with surreal flights of fantasy. You cannot tell which parts were real and which are products of his twisted imagination. You never know when to laugh, when to be disgusted, when to feel horrified. In some odd way, it presents a more revealing picture of man and society in extremis than many straightforward accounts.</p><p>During the last week of 2015, I devoured Elena Ferrante’s Neapolitan tetralogy in a week. They are packed with life, almost to the point of exploding.</p><p>I have always loved good, old-fashioned sprawling storytelling, epic in breadth and depth. Every once in a while I get tired of experimental writing, post-modern flourishes (I am not even sure what post-modern or similar terms mean) and crave for a directly narrated, impeccably detailed literary world where I can lose myself. Here the intense reality is shot through with a raw honesty I have rarely encountered.</p><p>I haven’t yet untangled my knotted reaction to the books and some of the details of the intricate storylines are already dissolving. But I am sure I am not the same person I was before I read them.</p><p>There are a few of the books which augmented my identity and altered it. I cannot explain why I read although I cannot imagine living without reading. When I pass my eyes over my bookshelves, I see a lot I haven’t read. But it might be time to look back on the ones I have read, to renew my acquaintance with the ones which stayed.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b042176aa0ca" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Diary 2016 (May 25th)- Notes on recent reading- The rim of morning]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@priyankarbhunia/diary-2016-may-25th-notes-on-recent-reading-the-rim-of-morning-c3d90b11aa3b?source=rss-86d08e491c9------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c3d90b11aa3b</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[science-fiction]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[horror]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[books]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Priyankar Bhunia]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 27 May 2016 04:24:32 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-05-27T04:38:21.907Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>This note includes spoilers.</strong></p><p>According to the uncanny valley theory, as the resemblance of an object to humans increases, our ability to relate to it, to empathize with it increases. But at a certain point, when its features and behavior are close to a human but not exactly there, we are repulsed by it. We might not be able to put our finger on it. But it creeps us out. In the first novel, To walk the night, Sloane explores that primal mystery. The horror evoked by something or someone, who is almost human but is not human.</p><p>Bark Jones is visiting the father of his friend, Jerry Lister. He’s there to hand over the ashes of Jerry Lister to Dr. Lister and to tell the father why and how the son died. Jerry had fallen in love with and married Selena, the widow of his reclusive and brilliant astronomy professor.</p><p>The bizarre and horrific death of the professor crosses the paths of Jerry and Bark with Selena. The two accidentally discover the dead professor’s body during a visit to their alma mater. In her first mention, Selena is described by a character as possibly the most beautiful woman in the world. The encounter itself leaves a bad taste in Bark’s mouth. The cause eludes him for a while. Then he decides it was her intelligence, her ‘merciless’ intelligence.</p><p>Selena moves to New York, is brought out into society, has a whirlwind romance and marries Jerry. The perspective is entirely Bark’s. We get barely a peek into Jerry’s mind. While narrating the story to Dr. Lister, Bark dredges up a plethora of small incidents and details adding up to a discomfiting picture. As the pieces fall into place, he is still unwilling to look at the completed image. But there is nowhere to hide after a certain point.</p><p>The revelation itself won’t be shocking to contemporary readers. The author, William Sloane, scatters enough clues for anyone with even a remote familiarity with horror and sci-fi tropes to guess where the story is going. But Sloane accomplishes what good speculative fiction should do. That is to explore the implications of the speculation, to use it to raise difficult questions.</p><p>It is clear that Selena and Bark loved each other, if love is the right word. But their love was not enough. Sloane implies that Jerry was unable to accept the absence of a past for Selena. Even an absent past casts long shadows. But Sloane stops short of giving a full answer. Why should Jerry have been so horrified on figuring what Selena is. Maybe he couldn’t live with the lie underlying their love. Possibly there cannot be an adequate answer.</p><p>The second novel, The edge of running water, is better written (though I found the ideas in the first one more intriguing). Electrophysicist, Julian Blair, broken by grief at the sudden death of his wife embarks on a dangerous venture. He moves to a remote one horse town in Maine and sets out to find what happens after death. In the process, he opens up doors to dark places.</p><p>There is a whodunit in the mix, the answer to which is obvious. But I believe the enjoyment of these two novels is in anyway dependent on the plot or its twists. In fact, the author, William Sloane, scatters big breadcrumbs, enough for anyone with even a remote familiarity with horror, detective and sci-fi tropes to guess where the story is going. The pleasure is derived instead from the precisely constructed atmosphere.</p><p>The tension is ratcheted up at a deliberate pace. In the second novel, much of the disquiet arises from aural cues. The description of the unearthly sound created by Blair’s device, ‘single and yet as multiple as the noise of a tempest or the roar of a rock slide, builds up the dread beautifully. When we and the narrator get our first glimpse of the machine, the stage is perfectly set. Similarly, in the first novel, there is a spine-tingling account of a ‘mentally retarded’ girl vanishing as if into thin air.</p><p>The cover of the book describes these two remarkable horror stories as ‘Tales of cosmic horror’. That’s a term I would associate with Lovecraft. Sloane is much more restrained. But he does understand very well that fear is strongest, when we don’t even know what we are afraid of. He does justice to the term in his invoking of fears far beyond the pale of standard experience, experiences that are “doomed for a certain term to walk the night before the mind of man either recognizes them for what they are or dismisses them as fantasy.”</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c3d90b11aa3b" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Dairy 2016 (May 21st)- Mint tea]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@priyankarbhunia/diary-2016-may-9th-mint-tea-c85e6720cf25?source=rss-86d08e491c9------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c85e6720cf25</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[travel]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[trip]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[morocco]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Priyankar Bhunia]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 21 May 2016 12:27:08 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-08-12T04:41:58.622Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*_2S-Q9zGTKNRI_WTV9ULWQ.jpeg" /></figure><h3>Diary 2016 (May 21st)- Mint tea</h3><p><strong>Remembrances of things past</strong></p><p>We had been walking for an hour and a half. We had done two rounds of the Kasbah (fortified precinct within the Medina, the old city). We were trying to locate 1001 nights, a legendary cafe established by <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brion_Gysin">Brion Gysin </a>in 1954. The Beat Generation, Rolling Stones and other illustrious and notorious names from the era were associated with the place. Like every second bar, cafe and hotel in Tangier.</p><p>For me and K, it was the cafe where <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FCvNiwv1AGY">Yasmine Hamdan sang </a>in Only Lovers Left Alive. I was seduced by the allure of a Tangier long gone, as I watched a pale as pale can be Tom Hiddleston and Tilda Swinton walk the dark, mysterious streets of Tangier, as we listened Hamdan croon in her smoky, sensuous voice. A few months later when I suggested to K that it’s high time for a trip, he proposed Morocco. I instantly replied ‘great idea’. Without knowing anything about the country, other than the name Casablanca from the eponymous Hollywood classic and being obliquely acquainted with the aura of 1950s Tangier through books.</p><p>We knew the cafe had been shut for renovation for years.We wanted a glimpse of the closed doors. We took a different route each time. Old, decrepit houses crowded into the narrow alleys. Bursts of bright colors suddenly appeared on doors and windows. Every corner was a tantalizing photo opportunity. K frequently stopped for taking advantage. My attempts with my Canon 500D were desultory. Like many other things, I had lost interest in learning photography soon after purchasing the camera.</p><p>We finally found the correct street and soon reached a small square with a shuttered building. An old man approached telling us that it was being converted into a museum or an orphanage. From whatever we could recall of the movie scene, it looked like the best possibility for being 1001 nights. We told ourselves so and moved on.</p><p>By this time, the old man was following us. He had placed us as Indians and chosen broken English as his language of exhortation. Throughout Morocco, locals always correctly recognized us as Indians/Pakistanis. Despite the miniscule number of Indian tourists. It could be attributed to the astounding popularity of Bollywood in Morocco. Superstar Shahrukh Khan is literally a household name. That’s the second word most locals uttered after ‘Namaste’. The kind of Indian movies I despise appear to be popular in many parts of world, precisely for the reasons I am unable to stand them, their melodrama, over-the-top stories, random intrusions of songs and dance. But those are comfort food for millions around the globe.</p><p>The old man wanted to help us, to guide us through the medina. He said he wasn’t after money. By then, we had encountered the pervasiveness of unwanted free help in Morocco’s medinas, free except for a small tip. We were on a budget. As we would do a few more times in the trip, we kept walking purposefully and entered into a cafe to escape. Both of us were addicted to the mint tea by then. We were having an average of 5–6 cups a day.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Ws6DKvYuWkyK8jJ0uGTZeg.jpeg" /></figure><p>Generous sprigs of mint submerged in steaming, sweet tea and served in tall glasses, it is the de facto national beverage of Morocco and drinking it in cafes a national pastime. These institutions are present on every street corner. The atmosphere varies from comfortably relaxed to seedy. Men, young and old (rarely women), sit with a glass of tea or a cup of Cafe noir. The chairs are always arranged facing outwards, towards the street. Sometimes, you might see animated conversations. More often, two people would be sitting side by side, staring out or maybe staring in, with nary a word uttered for hours. A single cup of tea or coffee would be drunk languorously. The only thing changed frequently were the ashtrays. The waiters seemed to consider it indecorous if they let an ashtray remain on a table with more than one butt. (Morocco is hell for non-smokers. People smoke everywhere, from all restaurants and shops to train stations and platforms.)</p><p>Opposite the cafe, called Cafe Colon, there was an small, run down theater called Cine Alcazar. We speculated that it must have some story behind it. Turns out, the cafe and Cine Alcazar both appeared in Bertolucci’s 1990 adaptation of Paul Bowles’ The sheltering sky. Earlier that day we lost our way and saw a building on an obscure road, with an opulent art-deco facade and fading lettering spelling out Gran Teatro Cervantes. It was one of the most famous performance venues in north Africa. History can sneak up on you from any corner, though the city has been sanitized during the last 15 years following 40 years of post-independence neglect.</p><p>We had already done a tour of the main sights. Like in most of the cities we visited, the sights were not the point. There was an interesting church, which was presented a confluence of different religions. The touted American Legation Museum was an admirable effort but not very impressive. Here again, the history was more fascinating than what you would see as a tourist.</p><p>The Sultan of Morocco was among the first government leaders in the world to recognize the nascent American state after the declaration of independence. The Legation building was the first piece of overseas real estate acquired by the American government. It housed a center for American intelligence agents during WW2. Now, diplomatic documents are displayed. Some are hilarious like an American consul seeking advice on dealing with the gift of a tiger from the Sultan. Others are tragicomic and reflect the ignorant hubris and tragedy of the colonial era.</p><p>We weren’t done with mint tea for the day. We figured out the directions using Cafe Colon’s wifi and strolled to Cafe Hafa. Its location is extraordinary. It is basically a series of platforms rolling down a hillside overlooking the Mediterranean. William Buroughs, Paul Bowles, Tennessee Williams and others stopped by Café Hafa regularly to imbibe tea and stronger mind-altering substances, with the wind blowing in their faces. The slow service is a bonus. It let us just sit there and take in the astounding view, trying to imprint it on our minds.</p><p>We had to do a brief stopover at Librarie des Colonnes. I successfully resisted buying a book. Another legendary institution, it used to a regular haunt for Bowles, Beckett, Genet et al. At the moment it feels like a regular bookstore, though it still hosts events with famous authors. Just the weekend before we came Tahar Ben Jelloun had graced the store. It was a similar story with the fabled Tanger Inn, one of Tangier’s oldest pubs, situated next to the hotel where Burroughs wrote Naked Lunch. Now, it could be any hip drinking destination with quotes from Kerouac, Ginsberg and Burroughs on the walls. The latest renovation seems to have obliterated whatever little atmosphere might have persisted from the Interzone days.</p><p>We stopped by a pub to knock down a few beers. With the first round, we were served a small portion bread and chicken curry. Next it was two whole fried fish. Then it was a plate of lamb livers. Alarmed, we tried to confirm if we were going to be charged for it. It was free tapas. The Spanish influence. The excellent food continued to arrive as the night passed and the conversation improved, reached a peak and then went downhill, as we went from a good high to inebriated. Live music started playing from a synthesizer stationed just in front of the restroom.</p><p>As I pushed open the toilet door, I stepped back alarmed, when I saw a lady in janitor’s scrubs sitting inside on a toilet seat in the dark. She was stationed there to hand toilet paper after the facilities had been used. Soon K had the same shock. We joked that the Dardenne brothers should make a movie with the toilet paper lady and the singer/musician playing in front of the toilet, as the central characters.</p><p>We had come as pilgrims to Tangier, to partake of the stories, the legends. There was hardly anything left. I had read that the city is very different now. The romance was gone. The degraded seediness, the crime was also disappearing. Though I felt a tad disappointed at the time, the ghosts of what we had come seeking seem to be more than enough in retrospect. The idea of Tangier I had in my head added to the experience, though it has passed with the times or maybe because it has passed.</p><p><strong>A sleepy town</strong></p><p>We had started our trip in Casablanca. It is the commercial capital of the country. It might be an interesting place to live in. But it had little to offer to tourists. That first evening itself, we left for El Jadida, a tiny coastal town, once a Portuguese fortress. We had selected it over more popular destinations, such as Essaouira and Agadir.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*dDCwrAJzTDjSIC7Fd1TX4Q.jpeg" /></figure><p>El Jadida is the very definition of a sleepy town. After checking into the cosy hotel, we went out for a night time tour of the Portuguese ‘city’. It must have been barely 1 sq km in length or breadth.</p><p>It was the perfect first night. No tourists in sight. Children playing soccer in the streets under the ramparts. Women gossiping in doorways. Cats sauntering along regally. Morocco has the highest cat density of all places I have been to. The Koran abounds with stories about the Prophet’s love for cats. On the other hand, dogs are considered clean. You don’t see any on the streets.</p><p>The next day we left the walled city and had our first proper cups of mint tea, along with croissants for breakfast. We went for a long walk along the streets of the main town. Most shops were still in the process of opening at around 11. This won’t be mentioned in any tourist guidebook. But it was one of the best walks of the trip. Laidback-ness vibe was literally dripping from every part of the town. As a bonus, you could easily shoot a ‘Humans of El Jadida feature’. It was probably the closest we came to see Moroccans going about their daily lives, without caring or worrying about tourists. Locals didn’t pay us any attention. In El Jadida, it was limited within the walls also, but here it was totally absent.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*C0VKEXGLgqyjIkM5-yW9VQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>On a tour of the ramparts where K clicked some fantastic photographs. We had a long, leisurely lunch of amazing fish tagine and chicken at a nondescript hole in the wall in the middle of the vegetable market. After soaking up every bit of deliciousness with Khobz, the big round disks of bread served with every meal in Morocco, we headed to a promontory jutting out into the sea.</p><p>We settled down on the rocks, before the point where local crowds were converging. We watched an old man make preparations to fish. We waited for him to cast the rod. We kept waiting. Steps included separating the bones and the flesh, mashing the bones and the flesh separately with a rock, mixing the mash with some kind of a crumb, pouring oil and finally making tiny balls. Sorting of the rods followed. After almost an hour and a half, we made our way to the railway station to catch the train for Tangier.</p><p><strong>Searching for blue</strong></p><p>A Google search of Chefchaouen brings up images of breathtaking blue. The blue-swept Chefchaouen medina is probably the prettiest in Morocco.</p><p>Getting off the bus after a 3 hour journey from Tangier along beautiful green vistas, we stopped by a cafe, for a breakfast of tea and Msemen, a flaky, square, fried pancake. It is a cousin of the Indian Paratha or the Malay/ Arab Murtabak. Sitting there, we saw yet another another young man with crutches. It seemed to both me and K, that we were coming across a disproportionately high number of young men walking around with crutches. We came up with a theory that it might be polio. But it seems Morocco had eradicated polio by 1988. The mystery remains.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*QN_RbenIjwgWTcBjpAkWfg.jpeg" /></figure><p>Discovered and patronized by hippies for decades, for the easy availability of kif (a cannabis product), tourism here has boomed in recent years. The medina is packed with hotels, restaurants, cafes and shops selling carpets. Those carpets and assorted tourist souvenirs cover most of the walls. Now you have to go to the edges of the medina to find the unblemished blue you see in the photographs. Not that you would be able to tell from the pictures we clicked.</p><p><strong>From empires to ruins</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*gr8txEsL8Q6MXjzO6Gc6DA.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*MxfCvX3S-uDyR9jkXYJoNg.jpeg" /></figure><p>Moulay Idriss is the holiest destination in Morocco. Six pilgrimages to Moulay Idriss are considered to be equivalent to one trip to Mecca. The eponymous Moulay Idriss, a grandson of the Prophet Mohammad brought Islam to Morocco and established the Idrissid dynasty. Moulay Idriss and his son were also responsible for the establishment of Fes. The mausoleum itself is off-limits to non-Muslims. Most of the mosques and madrassas (Islamic schools) have limited access for non-Muslims. Most of the time, you end up glancing inside through gates and barriers. Without understanding of architecture, all the filigree begins to look the same.</p><p>The hotel manager or owner (not sure if he was either or both) drew us a rough map to Volubilis, a site of ancient Roman ruins, on an A3 size parchment. We decided to take the longer scenic route. When we left, it was sunny and hot. But the views were amazing. The route goes around a hillside, with expansive scenes of verdant slopes and the town of Moulay Idriss looming in the distance. Brilliant red and purple flowers dotted the hills. There were a certain kind of trees all over the hillsides all the way, which we later learnt were olive trees. Olives, fresh or pickled, are served with every meal and drink in Morocco.</p><p>Coming down the slope, we glimpsed the ruins in the distance. Volubilis was a distant outpost of the Roman empire at its height. Its prosperity was driven by olives. Only about half the site has been excavated revealing impressively intact mosaics. I don’t know enough of Roman history or mythology to appreciate the mosaics or the stories told in them, the twelve labors of Hercules or Orpheus playing the lyre.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*G14i-6-P-kODctkqjR6eFw.jpeg" /></figure><p>It was the setting was affected me. Located on a hillock in the midst of rolling green countryside, the ruins were preserved just well enough to convey the past grandeur. They were decayed just to the right extent to remind of the inescapable claws of time. Important sections were roped off. Colorful wild flowers grew all over the ruins. Tourists clambered over the barriers to get good shots of the mosaics and to get selfies. Loud tour groups chatted in a Babel of tongues.</p><p>What would the Romans have made of it? They must have believed their empire was eternal, that it would survive and thrive for millenia. The very existence of a remote outpost like Volubilis was testament to the extent of their power. Most modern nation states have been in existence for barely a couple of hundred years. For post colonial nations, the duration is even shorter. The all-encompassing theories which are supposed to save humanity, the 50 year long-term examples which are supposed to provide proof for the boundless efficacy of ideologies and frameworks, are meaningless. Of course, they do make a difference in terms of immediate impact during our lifetimes. But maybe it is randomness, with the patterns neatly sorted in hindsight.</p><p><strong>Imperial cities</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ZoYTtxqPmP5IO0AIutQ4kA.jpeg" /></figure><p>Of the two imperial cities we had managed to fit into our itinerary, we savored Meknes more. Though in Meknes, the taxi dropped us off at the wrong end of the medina, a young man took 30 Dirhams to take us to our hotel, the waiter in a restaurant charged us 20% extra in the name of service fee. It didn’t matter. Again we wandered past the tourist sights and a huge open air market where everything imaginable was on sale into what was most probably the old Mellah or Jewish town. Most Moroccan cities had a Medina for the Muslim majority, a Mellah for the Jews and a Ville Nouvelle built by the French or Spanish for their administrators and armies. In medieval times, the Muslim world was a safer bet for the Jews, compared to Europe. These days, there are hardly any Jews left in the Mellahs. In Fes, we visited an old synagogue dating to the 1700s with an ancient Muslim caretaker. He couldn’t speak much English. But his enthusiasm made up for it. He informed us that there are 56 Jewish families in Fes now and all have moved out to apartments in the Ville Nouvelle. Most have immigrated to Israel.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*8i_U4NsTEez_ofI3XsFYkw.jpeg" /></figure><p>We had the best tea drinking experience of the trip in Meknes. We chanced upon a small cafe with chairs laid out on sides of the narrow street. There were old Arabic songs playing inside. The music sounded very Indian, almost like the background score of melodramatic Bengali movies from the 1950s and 60s. We asked the name of the singer. I came across his name, Mohammed Abdel Wahab, in the Gate of the sun by Elias Khoury in another manifestation of the Baader Meinhof phenomenon. This instance also explains it. I am sure the name wouldn’t have registered if I hadn’t encountered it just a few days prior. I read up about him later. A famous Egyptian singer, he also composed the national anthems of Libya, Tunisia and UAE.</p><p>It was the perfect place for watching life go by. Kids playing, teasing old ladies, getting scolded by the old men sitting in chairs across from us. One man seemed to be a figure of some importance in the community. Everyone passing by greeted him. A few stopped to have conversations in hushed tones.</p><p>We spent nearly two hours sitting on those chairs. We exchanged barely ten sentences. We knew that we were going through an intense experience which shouldn’t be spoiled with words.</p><p>I tried to remember the setting of that cafe, so that I could describe it with vivid details. I tried to recall what kind of chairs we sat on. What were the tables like, what was the colour of the wall opposite. I couldn’t remember. I felt anguished over my memory and lack of observational skills. But photographs came to the rescue. The gentlemen in the cafe had graciously agreed to be photographed. I could log on to Facebook and look up the photos uploaded by K.</p><p>Both of us don’t like clicking photos of ourselves or each other, let alone selfies. But during this trip, I had been wondering about why we take photos. Is it to to preserve an artistic impression of the place, something that might have value beyond the personal? In Thinking, fast and slow I remember reading about studies which show that we react to pain not based on the actual experience but on the memory of the pain. A longer, more intense pain experience is preferred to one with lower peaks and total duration, as long as the former ends at a lower point. The experiencing self is very different from the remembering self. If it is the same for pleasure, then it is a difficult choice. Focusing too much on taking photographs, especially of yourself, would interfere with experiencing the ‘now’. But it might not be irrational if it would enhance memories and add to cumulative pleasure over the long term.</p><p>Maybe, the old cliche, moderation is the best option. Selfies were still a bit too much. But K and I agreed to click a few photos of each other. By the end of the trip, both of us had around ten photos ourselves in the other’s camera. To prove to ourselves and others that we had indeed traveled to Morocco in the month of April in the year 2016.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*lF8FLMcxiqjmcayM0k0nfw.jpeg" /></figure><p>The hotel in Meknes was a Riad, a Moroccan house with a courtyard or garden. The word comes from the Arabic word for garden and the architecture inspired by the Romans. The Riad had a fantastic terrace and we wanted to make full use of it. We walked to the Ville Nouvelle to get a bottle of local wine. Meknes is the wine producing center of Morocco. But you cannot get alcohol inside the Medina in any of the Moroccan cities. We spent the night sipping wine on the hotel rooftop, watching the lights go off one by one and the green mosque minarets gleaming in the dark.</p><p>Fes was our last stop before going back to Casblanca. If it had been our first destination, we might have spent more time exploring the Medina. As it happened it was the last and the most crowded with tourists. If you stopped for a second to consult the Lonely Planet maps or look for direction markers, five people would converge, offering to give a guided tour. One common tactic is to shout out that whichever way you are going is closed. Many of the alleys are cul-de-sacs. But you can always find your way out, with a map and a sense of where the major landmarks are.</p><p>The medinas are what the tourists come to Morocco for. But the residents of the medina in cities like Fes are glad to sell their crumbling, anicent properties to outsiders/ foreigners and move to a comfortable apartment in the newer parts of town.</p><p>We got a good orientation of the place on the first day, walking along the Talia’a Kabira. We were confident that we would be able to find our way back to the hotel or to the largest of the gates, Bab Boujloud. Along the way we had a fantastic lunch of a massive Moroccan sandwich which would put any meat galore pizza to shame. Served in a shop having a few chairs and a massive 50 inch TV dominating the space and playing recitations from the Koran on Youtube. Containing 10 different varieties of meats and sausages in varying shades of read and brown, it was juicy, moist and maybe the best sandwich I have ever had.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*lmZHXZJo5sEtYWx4lZxTGg.jpeg" /></figure><p>A few sights would have been unreachable, like the synagogue mentioned earlier and the tanneries. The synagogue was located in a very dark corner of a very dark alley in the middle of a very long market street. We had given up after wandering around the area for half an hour. We were also looking for the entrance for the Jewish cemetery. This was following a long walk along a dusty boring main road we ended up walking on for over an hour. At times, efforts to travel away from the beaten paths can lead to really beaten paths. We were aware of the paradox in searching for non-touristy corners, despite being tourists. The mere fact of our being there was making it touristy. Still, we wanted to feel rare. We wanted not to be a part of the teeming tourist hordes. It was a uniqueness we borrowed from the exclusivity of our experiences. It is the impulse which makes some fiercely possessive of obscure bands or cult genre movies.</p><p>The individual whose help we accepted took us to a rooftop terrace for a view of the cemetery. It was closed for the day. The white graves spread out into the distance. Standing on the rooftop in the twilight, looking down on it was weirdly touching.</p><p>He also gave us the directions to the synagogue. We had to knock on the door and then another door opened upstairs and the charming caretaker appeared with the key. The chairs were arranged as if for a MBA group discussion. He encouraged us to take pictures with the Torah and the altar. He also didn’t mind appearing in the photographs. There were a somewhat macabre and poignant display of photos of Jewish cemeteries from cities across Morocco along the walls. The caretaker referred to himself as Moroccan, hastening to add Muslim, when we inquired about his religious affiliation.</p><p>The current Queen is from Fes and the royal family spends a lot of time in the city. Maybe that’s the reason Fes seems to favor the King’s family photographs. He appears much older than usual and his kids make an appearance frequently. His wife is the first Moroccan queen to make an appearance in public. The King’s image is ubiquitous across Morocco. But the King seems to enjoy genuine popularity. His father crushed opponents with the aid of a brutal secret police. Mohammad VI is viewed as more benevolent. After coming to the throne in 1999, he carried out constitutional reforms, devolving powers to the elected prime minister and promoting women’s rights. But youth employment hovers over 20% and h<a href="http://hdr.undp.org/sites/all/themes/hdr_theme/country-notes/MAR.pdf">uman development indicators remain firmly below average</a>. During the Arab Spring, there were protests in Morocco against government corruption but nary a slogan was raised against the king.</p><p>We ended up in a bar at the edge of the medina where the hip and happening of Fes congregate. There were girls smoking and drinking, young guys with ponytails and goatees playing Hotel California and Black magic woman, trying to impress the girls. Campus fashions and music are apparently the same across the world.</p><p>The hotel owner came over for a chat at night. He ran a tour guide business in addition to the Riad and rambled on about arrogant and condescending American guests, troublesome Indian tour groups demanding Indian food and of course Indian movies.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*AuHE1N0X7FjYS8nrVemN1A.jpeg" /></figure><p>The next day, we went to Cafe Clock, ranked as the top cafe/restaurant in Fes in most publications. It was a sophisticated version of the pub from the previous night. The pub was trying to attain nirvana. Cafe Clock had attained it. Packed with western tourists, advertising classes in cooking and calligraphy, music, soccer and film sessions and more, it was the epitome of coolness. Places like it stripped away everything genuinely interesting and presented an exotic yet safe facade for tourists.</p><p>The last evening in Fes was devoted to buying souvenirs. Both of us picked up copies of an ornately decorated, cool-looking item for our families from a rare shop where no-one was touting for customers. I discovered later that the item we picked up was a fire bellow. We came across a bookshop, where I made up for my self-control earlier and ended up buying three books. We had delicious snail soup from a street cart. Also a sticky pastry with rice filling. Followed by a long drinking session in a hotel with a run-down colonial feel. We sat in a courtyard next to the pool. We talked about our obsessions, movies, books, politics. That session might have happened anywhere.</p><p>That night on the way back to Casablanca, we barely slept. Our co-passengers in the compartment were a group of noisy college kids taking selfies throughout the night. The disease has spread everywhere. Bleary-eyed, bone tired, we arrived at the airport. The journey back home was over 20 hours.</p><p>For both me and K, if we had known all that would happen during the month after we booked tickets and hotels, most likely we wouldn’t have gone ahead. Life keeps preempting plans. It was an improbable trip, planned almost at a whim. That was the only way it could have been. But it was worth it all.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c85e6720cf25" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Diary 2016 (April 3rd)- What I didn’t know about following my heart]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@priyankarbhunia/diary-2016-april-3rd-what-i-didnt-know-about-following-my-heart-1ca08ba8433?source=rss-86d08e491c9------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/1ca08ba8433</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[follow-your-passion]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[entrepreneurship]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[self-help]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Priyankar Bhunia]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 06 May 2016 19:05:53 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-07-04T16:28:13.067Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>This was a difficult piece to write but I had to get it out of my system. I didn’t want to come cross as a self-pitying narcissist. I don’t know if I have been able to avoid that.</p><p>“Remember that wherever your heart is, there you will find your treasure.”</p><p>— The alchemist</p><p>This bromide is accepted as profound wisdom in today’s world, imparted by self help gurus, mythologized by entrepreneurs, eagerly lapped up by drones sitting in cubicles around the world. It has created a market worth billions of dollars. The remedy is snake oil. But the ailment is all too real . I did suffer from it. I did crave a cure. I did believe in following my heart. Follow I did. Turn your passion into a career. You only live once, it’s your life. Why care about what anyone thinks. So on and on.</p><p>The uplifting stories maybe make up 1% of the total. No one talks about the 99% failures. They are forgotten. Saw a stand-up comedian telling this joke on Comedy Central the other night, “If you follow your heart, everyone will still love you…if you succeed.”</p><p>What do you want to be when you grow up? When I was around 4 or 5, I wanted to be an astronaut. I was in awe of the scale of the universe and our insignificant place in it. I read about our solar system, about white dwarfs and black stars. I was a bit older, when I read a book with short, inspiring biographies of famous scientists, deciphering nature. I felt inspired. I wanted to be a scientist. When I read about the Indus Valley Civilization, about Egyptian heiroglyphics and the Rosetta stone, I wanted to be an archaeologist. These were all passing ill-defined fantasies. I kept devouring books, kept working hard at school.</p><p>For a long time I did everything I was supposed to. Then I quit the well-trodden path without a clear idea, about which less traveled road I wanted to take.</p><p>In India if you are in the top 30 or 40 percentile academically, you write the highly competitive entrance exams for engineering or medical colleges and become an engineer or a doctor. Total seats in the former far exceed the later. Hence the joke that Indians become engineers first and then decide what they want to be when they grow up. It was the same with me. I had no clue what engineering was all about. I studied for the Indian Institutes of Technology entrance, got through. What branch you selected was largely determined by demand/supply. In my time, the usual sequence in prospective students’ consideration was computer science, electrical/ electronics/ mechanical/ chemical/ civil. I am simplifying the process here but I can confidently say that actual interest would rank low in the list of criteria. The opposite of informed decision making is the norm.</p><p>By final year, I was just going through the motions. I was sure that I didn’t want to be a chemical engineer for the rest of my life. Remarkably few job placements, at best 20–25%, were in core industries. This from one of the best engineering colleges in the country. Software companies and random consultancies picked up most students. IITians are considered to be intelligent. After all, they survived possibly one of the toughest examinations in the world. I doubt if much value was attached to the education imparted during the 4 years it took to earn a degree.</p><p>In a burst of all too common inspiration, I wrote the entrance for the Indian Institutes of Management. Good thing was you didn’t have to prepare too much for it. I spent two more years completing MBA, majoring in finance. I got a job with JP Morgan and worked there for three years.</p><p>I was making good money, good salary plus decent bonuses, notwithstanding the effects of the 2008 meltdown. Mumbai was a vibrant, cosmopolitan city, with something always happening for those willing to explore. I hung out with other fresh MBAs, also on their first, well-paying jobs. Most were still free of the burdens of family life. We would go to the best pubs in town, eat out at the best restaurants. I had good company for exploring the arts scene. We frequently went for plays, attended film screenings.</p><p>We brushed up against filmmakers, actors, writers. We were not awed by the big Bollywood glamour but we were thrilled by the cerebral brilliance of the work of independent directors, the work of great actors performing 10 feet from you on the stage. I made a friend who had given up his career in a multinational corporation to write scripts. Once, he got me an invite to a BYOB party at Anurag Kashyap’s house. Drinking Old Monk, watching a screener DVD of Carlos sent to Kashyap by Oliver Assayas, surrounded by people passionate about cinema. And some wannabes. It was bliss. It magnified the emptiness of what I was doing.</p><p>I learned 80% of whatever was required for my job in finance during the first six months. After that work was mostly on autopilot. It was mind-numbing. From ‘a bit’ it crept up to nearly unbearable. Especially when a friend from engineering approached me to join his venture.</p><p>I was 26 when I quit my regular job. I was young and I felt the world was mine for the taking. Most of my acquaintances agreed. They said you are so young. This is the time to take risks. If it doesn’t work out, you can always go back to your career. It sounds intuitive but it is stupid.</p><p>Nearly five years later I am in a limbo. I do not have any marketable skill set. It would take 10–15 years for that. When you reach middle to senior management, you can always claim expertise in that area. And hopefully return to it, unless the economy is in the dumps.</p><p>Your compatriots keep climbing the ladder. Lateral entry doorways are rare and narrow. For people who have reached a certain level, it is essential to build up an aura, a mystique about their knowledge and skills, so that their compensations are justified. It makes it difficult to switch from even one division to another, within a field like finance.</p><p>Even if you are willing to take a knock in terms of level, companies would rather recruit youngsters fresh out of college and train them, rather than train a 30 year old. I can’t imagine what 50 year old lay offs go through.</p><p>Most of this is applicable for MBA type jobs, maybe not so much where your work is very specific and tangible, say programming or graphic design or plumbing.</p><p>Getting back to the tale, six months into the new venture I knew it was a mistake. I didn’t want to admit it. I didn’t want to admit that I hadn’t done any analysis of the business idea. Even the most cursory scrutiny would have laid bare the foolishness. My partner was dedicated. But neither of us had a clear idea of how to execute. We had bitten off far more than we could chew. It was Don Quixote running into the windmills. We finally stopped torturing ourselves after a year and a half and the venture was wound up.</p><p>After spending over a year twiddling my thumbs in Singapore, I landed a job as a production manager in a small media company. As mentioned previously, I had a vague conception of doing something related to cinema. The few months I spent in that role shattered the rose-tinted glasses.</p><p>I hoped for special respect due to my educational qualifications. But it was not forthcoming, as I was an utter novice. I put my head down and started working 15 hours a day, 7 days a week. Part of my role was to wield the whip for the master. I tried to be reasonable with everyone for a while, the editors, cameramen, clients, the owner. But I was playing the game the wrong way. Official policy was to wring every last penny’s worth from the employees. The employees slacked off whenever possible. The clients woke up on the last day (largely government employees prodded by their bosses on the day before the event)with seemingly impossible demands. It was difficult to tell who was exploiting whom. I joined in the circus.</p><p>I was picking up on the technical stuff as well as the somewhat sleazy modus operandi. We shot TV shows which were aired on prominent Indian TV channels (only overseas, though we took care not to highlight it to sponsors while pitching). These were not commissioned shows. The company would pay to have its show aired, get money from sponsors, promising them the moon, the show would be produced on a shoestring budget and the owner would pocket the margin. At least two of three segments in every episode of a variety show were crude product placements, quid pro quo publicity or hideous ego stroking of eminent personages. Most sponsors could be duped only once. Only the ones with special arrangements came back year after year. I was disturbed, though I knew that those were common practices. The owner was merely trying to get his small share of the pie. But that was not why I quit.</p><p>I had heard about the years of struggle, the luck factor. I had to admit that there was no hidden talent inside me, just waiting to be discovered and dazzle the world. Years of slogging for minimum and/or irregular pay in a sometimes exciting, often tedious job and then with a lot of luck, I could hope to get the chance to make something of my own. I was not sure if I was willing to devote years to it with the dim prospect of being an above average filmmaker, somewhere in the distant future, as a best case scenario.</p><p>If I was 20, I might still have done a course in cinematography or editing, one of the technical fields where you can make a living. But I was not prepared to commit myself to the field without any qualifications at the age of 30. I was not so passionate in my passion after all.</p><p>So I crawled back to the comforting world of IIT and IIM graduates. I joined my second start-up. It had enough space where I could let my creative juices flow! I was going to have my cake and eat it too.</p><p>There were serious limitations to the product quality. Not many in the company seemed concerned. There was strategic thinking (sometimes over-thinking) regarding operations, technology, marketing. Everything except the artwork. The approach towards it can only be described using the Hindi word ‘<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jugaad">Jugaad</a>’. Mutual backslapping was part of the issue but not the whole story. I was given free rein to change or improve anything I wanted to. There were a few constraints related to office dynamics but my own shortcomings were the bigger bottleneck.</p><p>It was to be expected. I hadn’t considered the danger of jumping into a field with no formal education in it. Any proper job in any field will demand qualifications and relevant experience. I was handling animations, books, publicity material, social media. I was recruited on the basis of my education and my expressed interest in it. But I can barely work on Photoshop or create a storyboard. No established firm is going to offer me a similar role. Unless you have mastered the art of selling yourself, sticking to your supposed competency is the astute option.</p><p>I witnessed the level of networking and deal-making required for getting a start-up off the ground. Beyond a certain stage it is no longer about the product or service. I had a wry laugh at the naivety of my 26-year old self embarking on my first venture. What were we thinking when we embarked on that misadventure.</p><p>There was a lot of travel, many meetings (not for me as I would have failed miserably at selling the story). Every month, the possibility of a new opening out of the dark tunnel materialized. I stopped being excited after a while. I was also discomfited by the attempts to ride on the coat-tails of certain dubious spiritual leaders. I felt that I would be betraying myself by being a part of that.</p><p>The world is not black and white. You can make your own principles and set firm boundaries for how far you are willing to go into the muck. Still a nagging, meaningless sense of morality, gets in the way at inopportune times. I might have been able to deal with it but the snag is I am not brilliant enough to forge my own path. I am not brave enough to take a radical stand with disregard for consequences. I am just aware enough that I am unable to close my eyes.</p><p>I am back to my first love, books. I am snobbish about what I read. I believe that I am able to judge the quality of writing. But I do not nurse any notion of being a good or a great author some day. I find most of my own pieces unreadable afterwards. At best, with regular practice and revisions for years, I might be able to write ‘not execrable’ short articles.</p><p>I think I can recognize great writing or good film-making. That puts my own shortcomings in harsh perspective. I started reading Thomas Bernhard’s The loser yesterday. Two students of a fictionalized version of piano virtuoso, Glenn Gould, feel compelled to abandon their pursuit of music in the face of genius. Though they are better than many, they see themselves as failures.</p><p>Most of us are destined to be painfully ordinary. We would like to think of ourselves as unique, but we are unique only to ourselves. As we get older and this realization dawns gradually, the drawn out process of dying starts. I wanted to make a difference in the world, to be remembered by at least a few, other than my family and friends. Those ideas had as much substance as a mirage within a dream.</p><p>I have wondered what happiness is. I think it exists in two forms. An ephemeral ecstasy or stable contentment. I saw contentment as catatonic. I fled from it. My first step into the unknown was guided by negatives, by what I didn’t want. What followed was determined by what was available. In the pursuit of more freedom, I was left with none at all.</p><p>My wife’s stance is that you do a job to earn money. It is a means to an end, the end being to savor the small pleasures of life and indulge in your interests. The job should pay well enough and leave you with enough time and resources to live your life. That’s the smart pragmatic approach.</p><p>But looking at the big picture, the progress of the human race depends on optimism. The stories of success are essential. They do change the world. Maybe it is better not to be aware of these things while dreaming dreams. Maybe it is better not to listen when someone warns you of the hazards. I am not sure I would have listened if I was told all this six years ago.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=1ca08ba8433" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Diary 2016 (April 1st)- Notes on recent reading: Embracing defeat]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@priyankarbhunia/diary-2016-april-1st-notes-on-recent-reading-embracing-defeat-227dd5cd41fb?source=rss-86d08e491c9------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/227dd5cd41fb</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[war]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[world-war-ii]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[japanese]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Priyankar Bhunia]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 03 Apr 2016 14:33:38 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-04-03T14:33:38.513Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>During the past 15 months I have been reading a little bit about World War 2. It is more like I have been reading around it. I am not interested in generals, army movements, brilliant strategies and stupid tactics, bout how the battles and wars were won and lost. I realized that I find books set in the immediate aftermath of a war more interesting than those set during the war itself.</p><p>Civilization shatters during wartime. But primal survival instinct, wrapped up in ideas such as nation and religion hold things together. The sound and the fury of war are terrible. Once they die down, when the dust starts settling, then only the full extent of damage is visible.</p><p>In The Skin, Malaparte succinctly summarizes the difference between wartime and its wake in the passage below:</p><blockquote>There is a profound difference between fighting to avoid death and fighting in order to live. Men who fight to avoid death preserve their dignity and one and all — men, women and children — defend it jealously, tenaciously, fiercely…When men fight to avoid death they cling with a tenacity born of desperation to all that constitutes the living and eternal part of human life, the essence, the noblest and purest element of life: dignity, pride, freedom of conscience. They fight to save their souls. But after the liberation men had to fight <em>in order to live</em>…It is a humiliating, horrible thing, a shameful necessity, a fight for life. Only for life. Only to save one’s skin.</blockquote><p>The famed Yamato spirit of the Japanese didn’t take long to devolve into dog eat dog after Emperor Hirohito’s surrender speech. There was widespread looting of army stocks. A vibrant black market blossomed. John Bower says that ‘For many Japanese, this was virtually <em>the</em> economy’.</p><p>Embracing defeat: Japan in the wake of World War II explores the history of Japan from 1945 till 1952, the end of the American occupation. The perspective is almost entirely Japanese.</p><p>It presents the portrait of a nation where 2.7 million servicemen and civilians died, millions more injured, sick or malnourished, one-quarter of the country’s wealth was destroyed and 40% of urban areas were destroyed, rendering 30% of their population homeless. Exhaustion and despair was so prevalent that the populace was said to have succumbed to something called the ‘kyodatsu’ condition. They had been primed for a total war, a war to glorious victory or total annihilation. The unconditional surrender left a number of people relieved yet devastated.</p><p>Bower spends a lot of pages trying to understand how and why Hirohito escaped being charged with any war crimes. There were many in the US armed forces and allied governments who would loved to line up a firing squad for him. According to Bower, majority of Japanese were also indifferent and at least wouldn’t have objected to his abdication and maybe even the abolition of monarchy. He gives the caveat though that historical speculation is always risky.</p><p>One reason seems to be General Mac Arthur and his staff’s fervent belief that the Japanese revered their emperor spiritually. Any attempt to remove him would lead to chaos and make the occupation much more difficult.</p><blockquote>“(MacArthur) warned that if he were indicted the nation would experience “a tremendous convulsion”, “disintegrate”, initiate a “vendetta for revenge…whose cycle may well not be complete for centuries if ever.” Government agencies would break down; “civilized practices will largely cease”; guerrilla warfare could be expected; all hopes of introducing modern democracy would disappear; and once the occupation forces left, “some form of intense regimentation probably along communistic line(s) would arise from the mutilated masses.”</blockquote><p>Bower judges this to be hyperbole on MacArthur’s part but the list of potential disasters seems to be eerily prescient and applicable to American interventions in the middle-east. It could have written for the Iraq war.</p><p>But insulating the Emperor from the trials had long-term repercussions. It compromised the Tokyo War Crimes Tribunal. The occupation bureaucracy and court officials worked behind the scenes not only to prevent Hirohito from being indicted, but also to slant the testimony of the defendants to ensure that no one implicated the emperor even by a slip of tongue. There were other serious problems with the trial which reduced their legitimacy in the eyes of not just the convicted and the Japanese populace but also among some of the judges and Allied army officials.</p><ol><li>The concept of ‘naked conspiracy’- The prosecution tried to prove an eighteen year long ‘common plan’ to wage aggressive war. There was no such provision in international law. Also, acts of omission along with commission were factored in the trial. The ex post facto indictments threatened a fundamental principle of law : Without a law there can be no crime, without a law there can be no punishment.</li><li>Capricious and arbitrary selection of individuals to try: Examples had to be made and a few convenient ones were chosen. But no heads of the Kempetai, leaders of the nationalistic secret societies or industrialists, who were more than supportive of the government’s path to war were tried. Scientists from the notorious Unit 731 in Manchuria were granted blanket amnesty in exchange for sharing their research. By the latter stages of the trial, fighting communism was rapidly precedence over punishing war crimes. The ruthless <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nobusuke_Kishi">economic head of the Manchurian government</a> and a <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yoshio_Kodama">powerful right wing mobster</a> were just two examples of individuals freed for they could be allies in fighting the menace of communism.</li><li>Nearly exclusive focus on war crimes committed against allied POWs: The mobilization of Koreans and Taiwanese (Formosans) for forced labor, comfort women, possible use of chemical warfare were all utterly ignored. The Japanese were even forbidden to refer to the Great Asia War and were required to use ‘Pacific war’. Bower describes as semantic imperialism, which gave primacy to the conflict between Japan and the US at the cost of their victims in Asia. It is pretty certain that the Americans did not think through the ramifications. It was not a conspiracy. But it wouldn’t have helped in remembering what the Asian countries suffered at the hands of Japan.</li><li>Hypocrisy about Western colonialism: Japan was accused of waging aggressive war. While the trial was going on, , Britain, France and Netherlands were actively and violently trying to re-establish control over their colonies. Justice Radhabinod Pal had a thing or two to say about the effusive rhetoric of freedom and democracy gushing from the American prosecutors. He mentioned how the Japanese ‘had followed the precedents of European imperialism, sometimes with “almost pedantic exactitude”’ and pointed out the similarities between Japan’s Amau doctrine and the US’ Monroe doctrine. It was no wonder that the Japanese took the accusations of crimes against peace and humanity with a pinch of salt.</li></ol><p>There were more technical and execution problems which turned the trials into little more than a farce. The initial euphoria of freedom of speech and suddenly created space for political activism was dying by the time the trial judgments were handed down. Left-leaning politicians and newspapers were feeling the pressure. The censorship machinery had hardened. Bower takes care to point out that it was still better than the war years but it was a far cry from the heady initial days.</p><p>The Japanese struggled on how to deal with their war dead. Bower writes with empathy about it in a chapter titled, ‘What do you tell the dead when you lose.’ In the initial months, they also learned about the rape of Nanjing and Manila and similar events. Many were horrified.</p><p>But within a few years the focus had shifted to explaining the defeat. The scapegoats ranged from backwardness in science to an evil cabal of ultra-nationalist leaders to demented cabal of mad and/or stupid military clique who had betrayed the emperor and the Meiji charter. Several collections of letters and writings by soldiers were published in the late 1940s. Combined with the undeniable suffering of the Japanese people, it produced an intense, inward-looking sense of victim-hood.</p><p>It created a miasma of selective forgetting, a widespread amnesia regarding the atrocities perpetrated by the Japanese army and the active or passive collusion of majority of Japanese. But in a true irony, it also planted a deep anti-war sentiment in the country. The roots struck seem to have been firm, firm enough that last year, when the Japanese parliament passed bills enabling the Japanese military to fight overseas and defend allies with limited conditions, <a href="http://edition.cnn.com/2015/09/16/asia/japan-military-constitution/">over 50% of respondents opposed and only 29% supported the bills</a>, according to polls. The bills were radical for Japan but tame by any other sovereign nation’s standards.</p><p>Japan’s post world war 2 history is interesting because of the questions it raises. Questions which are always more interesting than the answers. Questions about remembrance and forgetting, about guilt vs responsibility, about national character, top-down patently un-liberal imposition of liberal political systems.</p><p>It would be interesting to contrast Germany and Japan with regards to the culpability, repentance and atonement. Majority of populations in both countries supported the regimes. But after the war, it was hard to find Nazis in Germany or nationalists in Japan. Out of necessity, most of the middle level administration and bureaucracy in both countries had to be left in place by the victors to avoid total breakdown, though partial purges did happen if only for the sake of appearances. My reading on this is limited but in Germany, some amount of acceptance seems to have happened at the highest political levels and also among the public. It took time though. Apparently, when the American TV miniseries, The Holocaust, was aired in West Germany in 1979, <a href="https://books.google.com/books?id=zeWSAgAAQBAJ&amp;pg=PA91&amp;lpg=PA91&amp;dq=the+holocaust+tv+series+west+german+reaction&amp;source=bl&amp;ots=B0hs9cKtKU&amp;sig=fWCaXCj_FMOrESIANK69iE0c9Eg&amp;hl=en&amp;sa=X&amp;ved=0ahUKEwi09e_n3fDLAhXEB44KHRW-AFIQ6AEIUzAI#v=onepage&amp;q=the%20holocaust%20tv%20series%20west%20german%20reaction&amp;f=false">people were shocked</a>. The process was not easy.</p><blockquote><a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holocaust_(miniseries)#Critical_reception">The series which was watched by 20 million people or 50 percent West Germans first brought the matter of the genocide in World War II to widespread public attention in a way that it never been before. After each part of Holocaust was aired, there was a companion show where a panel of historians could answer questions from people phoning in. The historian’s panels were overwhelmed with thousands of phone calls from shocked and outraged Germans, a great many of whom stated that they were born after 1945 and that was the first time that they learned that their country had practiced genocide in World War II.</a></blockquote><p>In Japan, it was much worse. There was no forthright facing up to the complete history. In today’s geopolitical environment, chances of that happening are negligible. China wields it as yet another weapon in their armory for achieving their global and regional ambitions. Tensions have risen and there has been a political leadership move towards renewed militarism and nationalism in Japan.</p><p>For later generations, direct guilt is not applicable. But would there be a sense of responsibility, a need to remember so as to not repeat? It is difficult to be optimistic based on history.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=227dd5cd41fb" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Diary 2016 (March 28th)- Oscar Wilde’s sad fairy tales, Kafka’s Kafkaesque trial]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@priyankarbhunia/diary-2016-march-28th-oscar-wilde-s-sad-fairy-tales-kafka-s-kafkaesque-trial-605ade855934?source=rss-86d08e491c9------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/605ade855934</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[kafka]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[israel]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[oscar-wilde]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Priyankar Bhunia]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 30 Mar 2016 17:50:20 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-03-30T18:29:41.624Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>My wife has been in classics mode recently. She has decided not to read anything published post-1950 for the next few months. She believes that works have to stand the test of time to be certified classic and abhors the phrase ‘instant classic’.</p><p>After crawling her way through Anthony Trollope’s 800-page magnum opus, The way we live now, she was torn whether to read Dickens or Oscar Wilde next. She asked me to download Wilde’s collected plays and his fairy tales from Project Gutenberg. She wanted to read the fairy tales as a light diversion.</p><p>They didn’t make for amusing reading when I was a kid. Still I loved them. I must have read and re-read them at least once a year. I had a collected edition, which included The happy prince and other tales and House of pomegranates. Maybe they played a minor role in forming my gloomy disposition.</p><p>The happy prince is sad from seeing all the suffering in his city. Selfless sacrifices go in vain. A story of friendship is a tale of ruthless exploitation. A story of hard-earned redemption ends with the line: ‘<em>Yet ruled he not long, so great had been his suffering, and so bitter the fire of his testing, for after the space of three years he died. And he who came after him ruled evilly.’</em></p><p>Most of the stories are extraordinarily tragic. You could read morals in them. You could read support for socialism in them. But I am not equipped to do an academic analysis. In my eyes, the point Wilde seems to be making is that if you are bad, then you pay a heavy price for it. If you are good, you might end up paying an even higher price. Whatever goodness exists in the world is unappreciated and undervalued.</p><p>The Grimm brothers’ fairy tales in their original, unexpurgated, unmodified version (I got a translation of the first edition. It seems they themselves sanitized a few of them once they realized the market the potential of the market for childrens’ books) are absurd, gory and funny. They collected folk tales and there was a surprising absence of morality or desire to teach morals in them. Similarly, Hans Christian Andersen wrote some of the saddest stories ever written in the form of his fairy tales. If Disney had stuck to his version of The little mermaid, kids would have been crying their hearts out by the end of the movie. They would have been dismayed, shocked, traumatized but maybe wiser. I still remember the line about the mermaid feeling like walking on knives every time she took a step or danced.</p><p>Interestingly, the same story types occur across the world, across languages, nations, cultures. In fact, there are classification systems for folk tales and folk songs, based on motifs and themes, called <a href="http://www.mftd.org/index.php?action=atu">Aarne–Thompson classification </a>system and the <a href="http://www.vwml.org/search/search-roud-indexes">Roud Index</a> respectively.</p><p>The same day I searched for Kafka’s translated works on Gutenberg. Surprisingly, english translations of only Metamorphosis and The trial were available. More of his works were available in the original German. I checked for ‘Kafka copyright’ on Google. The translation thing turned out to be something stupid related to the translations being an independent work. But I came across the fascinating story below:</p><p><a href="http://www.nytimes.com/2010/09/26/magazine/26kafka-t.html?_r=0">Kafka&#39;s Last Trial</a></p><p>Kafka famously asked his friend, Max Brod to burn unread his ‘diaries, manuscripts, letters (my own and others’), sketches’. But Max didn’t follow his wishes, doing the world a great favor. Kafka is one of those authors everyone has heard of, few have read, but many refer to him. Similar to Orwellian , Kafkaesque is an adjective used to describe mind-numbing, senseless bureaucracy. The <a href="http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/Kafkaesque">Merriam-Webster dictionary defines it as</a> “ having a nightmarishly complex, bizarre, or illogical quality”. The adjective is used by people who might have not read a single word Kafka wrote. I myself have read Metamorphosis multiple times and read The Trial once in high school. I had his collected novels, comprising The trial, The castle and Amerika. I never read the latter two and only have a dim recollection of the first.</p><p>His unpublished works traveled a tortuous path, revealed by the graphic below from the article I referred to earlier.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/proxy/0*8fb1aAGql4FIfGu8.jpg" /></figure><p>Of course, no journalistic worth his/her salt can resist talking about the trail without resorting to the descriptive ‘Kafkaesque’.</p><blockquote>After Hoffe’s death in late 2007, at age 101, the National Library of Israel challenged the legality of her will, which bequeaths the materials to her two septuagenarian daughters, Eva Hoffe and Ruth Wiesler. The library is claiming a right to the papers under the terms of Brod’s will. The case has dragged on for more than two years. If the court finds in the sisters’ favor, they will be free to follow Eva’s stated plan to sell some or all of the papers to the German Literature Archive in Marbach. They will also be free to keep whatever they don’t sell in their multiple Swiss and Israeli bank vaults and in the Tel Aviv apartment that Eva shares with an untold number of cats.</blockquote><p>The case was finally decided in June 2015, when an Israeli court ruled that the papers belonged to the National Library of Israel. It also stated that, “It seems he(Kafka)would have rejected out of hand the possibility of his literary estate being transferred to an archive located in Germany”.</p><p>There was another essay which discussed some very interesting aspects of this trial:</p><p><a href="http://www.lrb.co.uk/v33/n05/judith-butler/who-owns-kafka">LRB · Judith Butler · Who Owns Kafka?</a></p><blockquote>In focusing on just how perfectly German his language is, the archive joins in a long and curious tradition of praise for Kafka’s ‘pure’ German.… So although Kafka was certainly Czech, it seems that fact is superseded by his written German, which is apparently the most pure — or, shall we say, purified? Given the history of the valuation of ‘purity’ within German nationalism, including National Socialism, it is curious that Kafka should be made to stand for this rigorous and exclusionary norm. In what ways must Kafka’s multilingualism and his Czech origins be ‘purified’ in order to have him stand for a pure German?</blockquote><p>At the same time, Kafka’s view on Zionism:</p><blockquote>I have not shown the faintest firmness of resolve in the conduct of my life. It was as if I, like everyone else, had been given a point from which to prolong the radius of a circle, and had then, like everyone else, to describe my perfect circle round this point. Instead, I was forever starting my radius only constantly to be forced at once to break it off. (Examples: piano, violin, languages, Germanics, anti-Zionism, Zionism, Hebrew, gardening, carpentering, writing, marriage attempts, an apartment of my own.)</blockquote><p>Of course, we cannot reach a conclusion on Kafka’s approach towards Zionism from this one fragment.</p><blockquote>He attended musical events at the Bar Kokhba Society, read portions of Kaballah and discussed them in his diaries, studied Moses Mendelssohn and Sholem Aleichem, read several Jewish magazines, attended lectures on Zionism and plays in Yiddish, and listened to Hebrew stories in translation.</blockquote><p>But it is hilarious how the Germans and Israelis stake their claim to Kafka. It is difficult to write about his works without resorting to hyperbole but the greatness of his works (in whatever I have read) lies in their universality, in their brilliant truth-telling about human nature and society. He had the ability to see beyond the cloaks we construct for ourselves, as individuals and as communities. I am sure he would have been able to get past his friend not adhering to his dying wishes and have a good laugh at these arguments to claim him as belonging to one nation or language.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=605ade855934" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Diary 2016 (March 29th)- Media apathy or our indifference?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@priyankarbhunia/diary-2016-march-29th-media-apathy-or-our-indifference-ab8372ab3821?source=rss-86d08e491c9------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ab8372ab3821</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[isis]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[paris]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[brussels]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Priyankar Bhunia]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 30 Mar 2016 17:50:15 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-07-15T09:34:24.889Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<blockquote>The bomb went off right where you come out of the overpass, by the flower stands, only a few yards away from where I used to take the dolmuş to ODTÜ, my alma mater…Crying for a bomb that takes out a familiar place and strange people is not like crying at a funeral, for a breakup, or a sad movie…I cried for the dead, for their youth, for their parents, for broken glass, for familiar cobblestone, but the whole time, I suspected that I was just crying for myself because someone bombed the backdrop of my life.</blockquote><p>This is a <a href="https://www.guernicamag.com/daily/selin-gokcesu-on-ankara/">Turkish expat living in Brooklyn reacting</a> to news of the <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/March_2016_Ankara_bombing">recent bombing in Ankara</a> on 13th March. The following week, on March 19th there was a bomb attack in central Istanbul. Three days after that the attacks in Brussels happened.</p><p>The last made headlines all over the world. The debates about Islamic extremism, ISIS, the new normal, which were already at fever pitch, reached a new level. The first two barely made a dent in public consciousness. Brussels continues to dominate news, as other attacks happened in Iraq and Pakistan.</p><p>A similar story played out last year after the Paris attacks. On social media, people questioned the ‘lack’ of coverage of terrorist attacks and similar tragedies in countries, not named USA or located in western Europe. Today I came across this blog post:</p><p><a href="https://medium.com/p/5a82bf1c8e6d">The difficulty of getting people to read about Lahore</a></p><blockquote>I was struck by the fact that despite leading the site with several stories about the Lahore attacks, it was not our most read story. Lahore didn’t even make the top five most read..at that point in time it was being out-performed by stories about a logic puzzle, the ruins of Palmyra, a woman having lots and lots of sex but being dissatisfied about it and John Kerry’s comments on the US Presidential race…on the day of the Brussels attacks, five of the top ten most read stories on the site that day were about Brussels, with the live blog having millions and millions of views.</blockquote><p>The blog says that it is difficult to empathize with people and places at a remove. The piece about the Ankara blast substantiates this. The author’s anguish arises from familiarity. But it is important to note that Paris might still evoke strong emotions in her. It did for me. It is a city which looms big in the common imagination. Even if you haven’t been there, you have been there. But I doubt Lahore would have the a similar effect.</p><p>It is unfortunate but unavoidable. It is difficult to care about tribals suffering (they make the news only when the Maoists kill paramilitary forces) in your own country’s hinterland, let alone a war-ravaged country in sub-Saharan Africa. The same people expressing outrage about no attention paid to terrorism in their countries would have no clue about a bloody civil war happening in South America or Africa.</p><p>Other than the obvious There is another reason for this indifference about say Iraq or Pakistan. When such things <a href="http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2016/03/28/world/asia/pakistan-terrorist-attacks-history.html?_r=0">happen on a painfully regular basis</a>, it will lead to a numbness. Another suicide bomber in Baghdad? Ahh….it’s an old story. They will keep on killing each other. Who cares?</p><p>PS: This is from a somewhat different content but I think is relevant. There was a tweet shared on of my messaging groups on 31st March. An industrialist tweeted: “ Coping with dual tragedies. First #KolkataFlyOver, then Mumbai #Wankhede.” The day before India had lost a cricket semi-final and a flyover had collapsed in the city of Kolkata killing around 30 people. But if you think about it, a lot more people would have been genuinely saddened by the sports loss, though few would be willing to admit it. Therein lies the problem with empathizing with a tragic incident where you are not affected. And regularity transforms them into ‘incidents’ which we accept as life.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ab8372ab3821" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Diary 2016 (March 13th)- Notes on recent reading: A Moroccan binge]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@priyankarbhunia/diary-2016-march-13th-notes-on-recent-reading-a-moroccan-binge-a906e9782e94?source=rss-86d08e491c9------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a906e9782e94</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[morocco]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[islam]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[books]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Priyankar Bhunia]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 13 Mar 2016 05:08:46 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-03-30T15:45:42.085Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>In anticipation of a trip to Morocco I borrowed a few books from the local library. This is something I intended to do before every trip but never ended up doing. Some books I wanted were not available. The ones I found included three novels by Paul Bowles, one by Tahar Ben Jelloun, Tahir Shah’s In Arabian nights, Edith Wharton’s On Morocco and a couple of guidebooks.</p><p>I have read the first four in the list till now. I probably liked ‘In Arabian nights’ the least of the lot. It’s not as if it doesn’t have its merits. Some of the details he provides about Moroccans and Moroccan culture are fascinating. But there is touch of exoticism to his writing.</p><p>Bored and tired of living in London, in search of excitement, Anglo-Afghan Indian author Tahir Shah moved to Morocco in 2003, along with his Indian wife Rachana and their two small children. They bought a crumbling mansion in Casablanca, located in the middle of a shantytown. The Caliph’s House was his account of the restoration of the house and their adaptation to life in Morocco. This is a sequel to that. Now Shah and his family have settled down into comfortable routines. But still there are some issues with Djinns haunting his house. He begins to seek the one story inside him, after he learns of this tradition. It is the thread connecting Shah’s episodic narrative. Though he can speak the language and should be able to blend in, his writing appears to be that of a wide-eyed observer, taking in the wonders, constantly getting surprised at every turn.</p><p>Tahir Shah’s father was the famous Idries Shah, who wrote the seminal work on Sufism, The Sufis. I also learned of Richard Burton from this book. That in itself should be worth the read. He was a ‘<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Richard_Francis_Burton">explorer, geographer, translator, writer, soldier, orientalist, cartographer, ethnologist, spy, linguist, poet, fencer, and diplomat</a>’. He had mastered around 25 languages, 40 if you include dialects. A partial list deserves to be presented here: English, French, Italian, Neapolitan, Latin, Greek, Hindustani, Urdu, Sindhi, Marathi, Arabic, Persian, Pushtu, Sanskrit, Portuguese, Spanish, German, Icelandic, Swahili, Amharic, Hebrew and Aramaic. He traveled to Mecca, disguised as a Muslim, when Europeans were forbidden access to the holy city on pain of death. He assumed multiple identities during the trip. He was part of the expedition which discovered the source of the Nile, heading back after serious illnesses.</p><p>He translated and was responsible for the publication of the first unexpurgated edition of The Thousand and one nights or The Arabian nights. He published a translation of the Kama Sutra (<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kama_Sutra">As Burton could not read classical Sanskrit, most of the translation was done by Bhagwan Lal Indraji, with the support of Forster Fitzgerald Arbuthnot and Shivaram Parshuram Bhide</a>). I am looking for a good biography. But it is not easy. With a resume like his, it is tough to separate the man from the myth.</p><p>Paul Bowles moved to Tangier in 1947 and lived there till his death in 1999. His house became the center of expat life. Visitors included Truman Capote, Tennessee Williams, Gore Vidal, Allen Ginsberg and William S. Burroughs. Most of his novels are set in north Africa. He translated Morrocan authors and transcribed story-tellers, recorded Moroccan music from ethnic groups around the country. If any outsider could be expected to understand Morocco, it would be him.</p><p>The two Bowles’ novels I read were The spider’s house and Let it come down. There are two central characters. The first, Amar descends from a long but impoverished line of Cherifs (descendants of Prophet Muhammad). He is illiterate but smart and ambitious. The second is an expat American novelist, Stenham, who has lived in Fez for many years and is proud of his understanding of the local culture.</p><p>There is not much of a plot. It is a time of great tumult with secular nationalists fighting for the country’s independence but relying on religious rhetoric also. It is rather about how the foreigners view the locals and vice versa, the variations within themselves also, what they think of the future of Morocco or whether that is of concern to them at all.</p><p>It is not for Amar’s father, who believes only in God’s word. For him, any talk of politics, whether that of the French or the indigenous revolutionaries is blasphemy. How can man change what’s written by God? I noticed this idea running through most of these books, this absolute submission to God’s will. (It raises the question of how free will is reconciled with an omnipotent, omniscient God and predetestination. It seems there are <a href="http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/freewill/#4">schools of philosophy and theology which argue for and against reconciliation</a>. In Islam, t<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Predestination_in_Islam">he debate revolves around the interpretation of ‘Qadr’</a>.)</p><p>Amar rebels against his father. But his worldview is totally shaped by Islam, the form of Islam which was an inseparable part of Moroccan society. His hatred of the French is also framed in those terms. It is a nuanced, complex and rigid view. It is regressive by any modern standards, yet it doesn’t bear much resemblance to the stereotypes of regressive Islam. I think the difference is that Bowles doesn’t judge at all and is able to put himself into the shoes of a devout intelligent Moroccan. I don’t think I have encountered any outsider authors who have presented such a clear-sighted view of a traditional Islamic society. It is very easy to think of those views as primitive and deranged. It is very difficult to show how they make perfect sense to the ones who hold those views.</p><p>There is a troubling question raised in the novel through conversations between Stenham and an American woman traveler. The latter would be categorized as a modern liberal. She believes that mankind is on a one-way escalator to democracy and liberty, equality and fraternity for all. There are only a few minor obstacles to be overcome. Her intentions are noble but she misinterprets the local’s actions time and again.</p><p>Her faith in enlightenment values mirrors the faith of Amar. Stenham, Bowles’ surrogate, feels that if the old ways are destroyed, they will be left with no anchor to their lives. He is also romantic in his fervent desire for everything to stay the same. This dialogue is as relevant today as it was then, with the efforts to export democracy to third world countries, with the tug-of-war between modernity/ liberalism and tradition/ religion. But today few even try to see through the ‘other’s’ eyes.</p><p>A larger part of the novel is narrated from Amar’s perspective. It is vivid and has the spark of a real life. Weirdly, the novel seems to loose some of its verve when it switches to the expats’ view. Maybe, Bowles was too put off by most expats and their behavior.</p><p>The other novel by Paul Bowles, Let it come down, tells the story of a freshly arrived American expat, Nelson Dyer. Trying to escape the hopeless emptiness of the life set out for him, he lands in the International Zone in Tangier, not knowing anything about the country or the Zone and clutching at the flimsiest of straws. For Nelson Dyer, it is a secretive, alien world, a morass stuck in purgatory. He is overcome by its dark, seductive charms. It is a hallucinatory nightmare.</p><p>Tahar Ben Jelloun is probably the most well-known of contemporary Moroccan authors. I was looking for Blinding absence of light or The sand child by. The only one I could find immediately was A palace in the old village. It is the story of a Moroccan immigrant in France at the end of his working life.</p><p>He is a good Muslim and a decent human being. For him, one cannot be without the other. He has spent more than half in life in France but is still not home. He sees through the radical imams. He does not understand why Muslim immigrants would burn his car in a riot. The hard-working, family man might have become a stereotype for politicians to exploit. It might be a cliche to say that they are the ones who pay the price. But they end up paying. Ben Jelloun’s achievement lies in presenting a believable, touching portrait of such a decent man.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a906e9782e94" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Diary 2016 (March 12th)- Straw men]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@priyankarbhunia/diary-2016-march-12th-straw-men-94b42509a2cd?source=rss-86d08e491c9------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/94b42509a2cd</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[india]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[fallacy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Priyankar Bhunia]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 12 Mar 2016 10:11:56 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-03-14T12:58:52.022Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<blockquote>“Anything that is Hindu, India, Bharatiya, you object… You went to an Afzal Guru and Yakub Memon concert and now you are objecting to a world cultural event”</blockquote><p>This was the <a href="http://www.ndtv.com/india-news/anything-that-is-hindu-india-bharatiya-you-object-venkaiah-naidu-backs-sri-sri-event-1285835?pfrom=home-india">response of Venkaih Naidu</a>, the Union Minister of Urban Development, Housing and Urban Poverty Alleviation and Parliamentary Affairs to allegations of environmental damage caused by Sri Sri Ravi Shankar’s World Cultural Festival. India’s environmental watchdog, the National Green Tribunal, has ordered Sri Sri’s Art of Living Foundation to deposit a fine of five-crores ahead of the event (which he has refused to pay). <a href="http://indianexpress.com/article/india/india-news-india/ngt-art-of-living-world-culture-festival-sri-sri-ravi-shankar-yamuna/">The organizers have been accused of altering the topography and the natural flow of the Yamuna through extensive construction of roads, ramps, pontoon bridges and accumulation of debris</a>. There were also questions raised regarding the deployment of the army at the event. I do not know if the army deployment is regular in events of this sort.</p><p>The current administration is adept at turning any criticism of the government into an insult to India and Indians. Many are falling for the ruse. Debates are continuously re-framed, to create straw men, which can be more easily tackled.</p><p>Based on two papers ( <a href="https://www.academia.edu/654363/Two_Forms_of_the_Straw_Man">Two Forms of the Straw Man</a> and <a href="https://www.academia.edu/2609857/Straw_Men_Weak_Men_and_Hollow_Men">Straw Men, Weak Men, and Hollow Men</a>) which expanded the scope of the straw man fallacy, I have tried to summarize the varieties of its manifestation. I could have done it in three sentences but I felt the formal representation was important.</p><blockquote>Straw man fallacy: A fallacy committed when a person misrepresents an argument, theory, or claim, and then, on the basis of that misrepresentation, claims to have refuted to position the person has misrepresented.</blockquote><blockquote>Traditional representational form: : Two speakers (A and B), B’s position (p) or argument (a), A’s misrepresentation of B’s position (p*) or argument (a*), and A’s argument that takes advantage of the misrepresentation (m)…A commits the straw man fallacy when she replaces p (or a) with p* (or a*), thereby erecting m, and then proceeds with m as if she were refuting p (or a).</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Selection form or weak man</strong>: An arguer A and an opponent B, a position p defended by B with arguments x, y, and z. A is guilty of the weak man when, in arguing against B’s position p, A selects the weakest of B’s arguments x, y, and z, refutes that argument, call it x, and claims to have defeated B’s overall case for p. OR A might select the weakest arguments from among arguments of several different arguers (B, C and D). In this case it’s not the weaker or weakest of on interlocutor’s, B’s, arguments, but the weaker or weakest of arguments against A’s views, which is a position which B holds (and which C and D hold as well)….B, perhaps, is sophisticated, and she holds that p on the basis of arguments x, y, and z…. C and D, however, though they get B’s arguments, when they try to give them, they muck them up. C holds that p on the basis of distorted and more criticizable arguments x*, y*, and z*. And D just holds p on the basis of x*. A does not need to distort standing arguments for p…all he needs to do is find and pick on the members of the opposition that are more mistake-prone or less careful.</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Hollow man:</strong> Fabricating an imaginary opponent with an imaginary and impossibly weak argument, and then defeating the argument. A may have his view that not-p and there may or may not be some B who criticizes A’s view. A invokes a class U, representative of the standing opposition. A attributes an exceedingly bad argument (w*) either directly to B or to U, responds to w*, and then claims to have defended his view. This strategy admits of some variation of attribution of w*, from a very specific B, to the vaguely defined class U. The employment of this version of the hollow man is signaled by extremely general descriptions of one’s opponents in U — they may be relatively specific by ‘‘Liberals,’’ or ‘‘Republicans’’, and they may be very general, such as with a ‘‘some say’’ or ‘‘you know someone out there thinks’’.</blockquote><blockquote>…straw man arguments have an ad hominem character to them, especially as they are deployed not just in the face of an opponent in an adversarial dialogue, but also in monological portrayals of adversaries.</blockquote><p>These days the quality of political discourse, whether in the US or in my country, India, has degenerated to such an extent that Hollow man is most commonly prevalent.</p><p>Here too, the government’s response falls within the Hollow man category. No one had raised objection to the Festival because it was organized by a Hindu religious leader or because it promotes Indian spirituality and culture. The questions raised were the environmental impact of the construction for the event. But since the opposition and the liberal intelligentsia has accused the government in the past of saffronizing Indian history and questioned the attitude of members of the government and the ruling party towards the minority Muslim community, here also the environmental objection must be a smoke-screen for the real reason for the protestations.</p><p>The government’s critics have also been guilty of this at times. I have previously made it clear where <a href="https://medium.com/@priyankarbhunia/diary-2016-feb-27th-why-even-lip-service-to-ideals-might-be-important-bb025fcc641a#.qo5etsnzs">I stand on the JNU fracas</a>. But the rhetoric emanating from the campus and many supporters has been disappointing. <a href="http://thewire.in/2016/03/04/english-translation-kanhaiya-kumars-electrifying-speech-at-jnu-23820/">In his speech</a>, Kanhaiya Kumar reported a conversation he had with a police man about the need for eliminating caste. The policeman apparently said there was nothing anti-national with what you just said. He talked about improving the lot of the farmers, about eliminating poverty, implying that the government is against those worthy objectives. Whatever the BJP’s faults, maliciously intending to keep the poor where they are is not one of them. It was mostly about constructing these straw men and then demolishing them. Intelligent, pointed criticism of specific government policies would have been another matter.</p><p>Then there were insinuations of planned conspiracy. I have too much faith in t human ineptitude and stupidity to believe in conspiracy theories. He resorted to repeated references to his underprivileged background. The government’s motives for the hard-handed crackdown might have been its antipathy to the left and tendency towards majoritarianism. But Kanhaiya’s arrest definitely had nothing to do with his poverty. This was not much better than the hard-selling of the chaiwallah (tea-seller) background of our honorable prime minister.</p><p>It was as irrelevant, as the government’s aggressive, jingoistic nationalism and the mentions of soldiers dying on the front or taxpayers’ money being wasted. If Hitler and Stalin are how the two sides address each other, then there’s not even a remote possibility of conversation.</p><p>In the two papers quoted above, the authors also discuss the conditions for straw men arguments to succeed.</p><blockquote>The representation form of the straw man argument depends on the audience not detecting the difference between B’s argument (a) or position (p) and A’s misrepresentation of them with a* or p*. The audience must be inattentive in the sense that any nuance of p does not register or is deemed inconsequential. In the selection form of the straw man, however, A’s argument depends on the audience being unaware of the variety and relative quality of opposition to A’s position.</blockquote><blockquote>…many straw man arguments are not made with unbiased or indifferent audiences in mind, but rather are made as theater for those with whom the speaker already agrees. The speaker and her implicit audience already share an understanding (or at least suspicion) of the vice and ineptitude of the opposition, and the act of responding to distorted, the weakest, or invented arguments of the other side is an act of pseudo-engagement. It is the illusion of having deliberated with those with whom they disagree, play-act at having done one’s homework. It is a false reminder of just how right they are and how benighted (or mendacious) the opposition must be to continue their resistance</blockquote><p>It reflects poorly on politicians when they use straw man arguments. When they do so successfully, it reflects poorly on us. In Two forms of the Straw man, the authors bemoan the political ignorance among the American population, notwithstanding improved access to information and proliferation of political analysts and commentators.</p><p>A similar story has been playing out in many countries, including India. Individuals feel they are more knowledgable, while swimming around in the echo chambers of like-minded people. The <a href="http://googleweblight.com/?lite_url=http://reports.weforum.org/global-risks-2013/risk-case-1/digital-wildfires-in-a-hyperconnected-world/&amp;ei=cFchrdos&amp;lc=en-IN&amp;s=1&amp;m=336&amp;host=www.google.co.in&amp;ts=1457417966&amp;sig=ALL1Aj4tgYu0xBEMjdPmAR83VccDI8DTEQ">nature of the internet and social media</a> algorithms have amplified the problem. Daily doses of validation dull the critical faculties. As commentators mushroom across mainstream and alternate media, few try to seek out primary sources to verify information. There is passion, emotion, anger, but thought and engagement are in short supply.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=94b42509a2cd" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>