<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Philipp Markolin on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Philipp Markolin on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@protagonist-science?source=rss-c8e0e038559d------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 13:19:46 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@protagonist-science/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The AI Race to Reboot Feudalism]]></title>
            <link>https://protagonist-science.medium.com/the-ai-race-to-reboot-feudalism-92a4878915f5?source=rss-c8e0e038559d------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/92a4878915f5</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[ai-infrastructure]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ai-race]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[artificial-intelligence]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ai-bubble]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[democracy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Philipp Markolin]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 10 Nov 2025 15:53:21 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-11-10T15:55:50.931Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Let’s be honest why they gamble everything</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*W04U1P3JkyH_H7Cuq7xSeQ.png" /><figcaption>Image created by Canva.AI</figcaption></figure><p><strong>Note:</strong> <em>This article is the first essay in my larger research focus on building participatory democracy in the digital age, specifically exploring how to counteract the global authoritarian movement. Given recent AI news and a sense of urgency, I wanted to share one idea that maybe is worth a discussion today.</em></p><h3>Unease about the AI investment boom is everywhere</h3><p><em>The Atlantic</em>’s excellent article by Charlie Warzel and Matteo Wong <strong>“</strong><a href="https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/2025/10/data-centers-ai-crash/684765/?gift=XDGksH9-kSi4e_1z75-nAWW2K6wXO8zKcyNRxWiiLP4"><strong>Here’s How the AI Crash Happens</strong></a><strong>”</strong> inspired something that has been on my mind for quite some time. I will get to that in a bit, but let’s recap:</p><p>Quoting from the article:</p><blockquote>“The AI boom is visible from orbit.”<em> Fields in Indiana now host vast data centers that </em>“demand more power than two Atlantas.”<em> The U.S., they argue, is becoming an </em>“Nvidia-state,”<em> where one chipmaker has become a </em>“precariously placed, load-bearing piece of the global economy.”</blockquote><blockquote><em>Despite hype, profits lag: </em>“Nearly 80 percent of companies using AI discovered the technology had no significant impact on their bottom line.”<em> Analysts whisper “bubble.” OpenAI lost $5 billion last year; Microsoft’s AI losses topped $3 billion.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>The article likens today’s frenzy to </em>“the canals, railroads, and fiber-optic cables laid during past booms.”<em> Whether AI transforms the world or triggers a crash, the authors warn, </em>“either outcome will bring real, painful disruption for the rest of us.”</blockquote><p>It paints a vivid picture of America racing headlong into an AI-driven infrastructure boom that could reshape — or destabilize — the global economy.</p><p>In a matter of years, AI infrastructure has come to dominate American growth. Vast energy-hungry data centers rise from farmland; trillions flow into chips and computing power. I think the authors point out, correctly, that the economic return remains uncertain, I recently argued a <a href="https://bsky.app/profile/philippmarkolin.bsky.social/post/3m2q573ztpk2y">similar point about AI and productivity loss</a> and why that might be. So rapid economic windfall justifying the investments seems very unlikely. Like many others, the authors point to the <strong>dot-com and other </strong><a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Railway_Mania"><strong>infrastructure</strong></a><strong> bubbles</strong>; history suggests such frenzies rarely end smoothly. Whether the AI revolution fulfills its promise or collapses under its own weight, they conclude that shock will be profound, and the United States may already be too invested to turn back.</p><p>For me, there is no real question whether this is a bubble, of course it is. But everybody seems to think they can ride it long enough to be not harmed when it inevitably burst.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*YLyyeAluUazfF40C.png" /></figure><p>Source: <a href="https://www.bloomberg.com/news/features/2025-10-07/openai-s-nvidia-amd-deals-boost-1-trillion-ai-boom-with-circular-deals">https://www.bloomberg.com/news/features/2025-10-07/openai-s-nvidia-amd-deals-boost-1-trillion-ai-boom-with-circular-deals</a></p><p>As <em>The Atlantic</em> article pointed out, the bigger the bubble gets, the more people will get harmed by the ensuing fallout. Yet hunger from the companies for finding ever more convoluted, <a href="https://fortune.com/2025/10/24/debt-financing-ai-tech-stock-market-weaker-morgan-stanley/">reckless</a> and <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2025/10/31/technology/openai-fundraising-deals.html"><strong>possibly illegitimate</strong></a><strong> ways </strong>for money to be poured into their ecosystem to stretch the AI bubble just a bit longer is palpable.</p><blockquote>And if the dynamics also sound familiar, it’s because not two decades ago, the Great Recession was precipitated by banks packaging risky mortgages into tranches of securities that were falsely marketed as high-quality. By 2008, the house of cards had collapsed. — <em>The Atlantic</em></blockquote><p>Which is why, when the WSJ just a few days ago reported that the <a href="https://www.wsj.com/tech/ai/openai-isnt-yet-working-toward-an-ipo-cfo-says-58037472">OpenAI CFO calls for a federal backstop</a>, more than a few eyebrows were raised by investors. The comment was followed by a <a href="https://www.tomshardware.com/tech-industry/openai-walks-back-statement-it-wants-a-government-backstop-for-its-massive-loans-company-says-government-playing-its-part-critical-for-industrial-ai-capacity-increases">quick supposed walkback from the CFO on LinkedIn, but not really</a> since she just rephrased the point more politely about the government having to “play its part”. Privatize the win, socialize the losses I guess.</p><p>All while the systemic risk of a major recession increases by the day.</p><p>So why are we allowing them to take the gamble?</p><h3>Know the game before you gamble</h3><p>Several stories are told of why the current AI race, despite being a bubble, needs to happen as fast and recklessly as it does, no matter the cost, harms or methods deployed. That <a href="https://www.technologyreview.com/2025/11/03/1126780/the-state-of-ai-is-china-about-to-win-the-race/">China will otherwise win the AI race is</a> one such current crowd pleaser, especially out of the <a href="http://Or that AI will unlock productivity and lead to real value creation in every sector of the economy anytime soon.">CEO of NVIDIA</a> who coincidentally would gain the most by stoking such US anxieties. Or that AI will unlock untold productivity and lead to real value creation in <a href="https://www.economist.com/briefing/2025/07/24/what-if-ai-made-the-worlds-economic-growth-explode">every sector of the economy</a> soon. Well, I am more of the persuasion that AI is a <a href="https://www.economist.com/finance-and-economics/2025/09/04/what-if-artificial-intelligence-is-just-a-normal-technology">normal technology</a>, useful and transformative in the long run, but not magic. It seemingly follows a normal S-curve of innovation and people overextrapolate from the current slope while ignoring that we are <a href="https://substack.com/home/post/p-176820231">already seeing some signs of a plateau</a>. But whatever your belief in economic gains in the mid to long-term, I would certainly like to retire the bedtime story that today’s AI boom is a <a href="https://substack.com/home/post/p-176484932">moonshot for machine sentience</a>, and not only because these graphs look immensely silly:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/706/0*r4v6i3WIX39R1eRG.png" /></figure><p>Source: <a href="https://www.ft.com/content/60dfa917-c5e6-4b9b-9cdb-a30692a29527">Who’s right about AI: economists or technologists? Financial Times.</a></p><p>The current AI paradigms will inspire innovators to find applications that actually add value to various industries; but they can not usher in AGI, singularity or extinction. And yet, a combination of these stories and their penetration of the public infosphere, especially the part about <a href="https://www.ft.com/content/5f2f411c-3600-483b-bee8-4f06473ecdc0">imminent</a> or future <a href="https://www.reuters.com/technology/microsoft-launches-superintelligence-team-targeting-medical-diagnosis-start-2025-11-06/">superintelligence</a>, ushering in various visions of utopia or dystopia, seems to inspire investor FOMO and public imagination.</p><p><strong>So let me challenge that frenzy with a different story, one I believe to be more grounded in history and reality, and in many ways more urgent:</strong></p><blockquote>Consolidation of power through infrastructure capture, data &amp; rent extraction, tech stack lock-in and autocratic information control.,</blockquote><p>It’s the <strong>robber barons, rails, rents and defaults</strong> of the next twenty years I worry about, not skynet, the singularity or misaligned paperclip optimizers.</p><h3>Infrastructure ownership: it’s the rails, not the robots</h3><p>Infrastructure capture refers to the consolidation of essential systems, such as transport, energy, communications, or now AI <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solution_stack">tech stacks</a>, under the control of a small number of private actors. Historically, this pattern has produced enduring power asymmetries. When a resource becomes indispensable for competition in the market and cannot be reasonably duplicated, its owner wields structural power. When public infrastructure gets privatized or commodified into a corporate chokepoint, those who own it do not merely extract rent; they set the terms of participation in economic and civic life.</p><p>A classic example is the Gilded Age railroad monopolies in the United States. By the late 19th century, a handful of companies controlled the rail network, enabling discriminatory pricing and political leverage while producing the largest wealth inequality between a small elite and masses in poverty.</p><p>We have seen the same more recently with the big social media platforms, that for too long were treated as<em> </em>consumer products, when in reality they aimed to become the roads and bridges of digital life for most of us while extracting a heavy rent on our attention. That rent did not only make them filthy rich but also extremely powerful and politically influential, enshrining continued exploitation of their users data as their business model.</p><p>AI infrastructure magnifies these stakes, as AI tech stacks are becoming the interface to information creation, dissemination and consumption. If a few companies own the chips, data centers, cloud compute, foundational models, model weights, and distribution channels, they effectively control any future useful AI application build on top of it; and with it, the epistemic and economic arteries of the 21st century.</p><blockquote>Public infrastructure capture is de facto governance, only without consent of the governed, oversight, or accountability.</blockquote><p>The gamble to become the next Vanderbilt, Rockefeller or Carnegie’s of the info age are long underway. Current tech giants have already captured chips and cloud computing, that is why <strong>Nvidia’s</strong> data‑center revenue hit <strong>$18.4 billion</strong> in a single quarter — <strong>up 409% YoY</strong> as AI hyperscalers started hoarding H100 chips like potable water before a drought. <strong>Amazon</strong> plowed <strong>$8 billion</strong> into <strong>Anthropic</strong> so Claude will use <strong>Amazon Web Services</strong> (AWS) as its primary cloud and training partner, and will utilize Amazon’s custom AI chips. OpenAI will purchase an additional <a href="https://www.reuters.com/business/microsoft-openai-reach-new-deal-allow-openai-restructure-2025-10-28/"><strong>$250 billion</strong> of Microsoft Azure cloud compute</a> and locked its model distribution to Azure’s cloud for the next decade.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/874/0*caYMFUPtZLb2fQej.png" /></figure><p>Encrypted Messenger Service Signal CEO Meredith Whittaker about infrastructure capture in cloud computing. Source: <a href="https://bsky.app/profile/meredithmeredith.bsky.social/post/3m46a2fm5ac23">BlueSky</a></p><blockquote>Such infrastructure costs billions and billions of dollars to provision and maintain, and it’s highly depreciable. In the case of the hyperscalers, the staggering cost is cross-subsidized by other businesses–themselves also massive platforms with significant lock-in […]</blockquote><blockquote>In short, the problem here is not that Signal ‘chose’ to run on AWS. The problem is the concentration of power in the infrastructure space that means there isn’t really another choice: the entire stack, practically speaking, is owned by 3–4 players.</blockquote><blockquote><em>- </em><a href="https://bsky.app/profile/meredithmeredith.bsky.social/post/3m46a2fm5ac23"><em>Meredith Whittaker on Bluesky</em></a></blockquote><p>This brings us to the next point:</p><h3>Strong-arming society into technological lock‑in</h3><p>Infrastructure capture is not just about finding one bottleneck to own, because bottlenecks can be remedied with just building more capacity over time through market competition or government investment. Real infrastructure capture today is much more about owning the full value-chain, tech stack or ecosystem. That is why the current AI players aim to cement <strong>vertical control</strong> — chips → cloud → model → API — where each layer enforces the others and makes competition almost impossible. The current AI web of partnerships and strategic investments have only one goal: to <strong>entrench big tech incumbents across multiple layers of the value chain.</strong></p><p>Good luck trying to spin up an alternative service provider when technical incompatibilities, contractual exclusivity and prohibitively expensive user switching cost sabotage any type of fair competition.</p><p>Historical examples include AT&amp;T’s telephone monopoly and Microsoft’s bundling of Windows and Internet Explorer in the 1990s, both of which stifled competition until antitrust interventions, and they seem really tame compared to the AI tech stack capture we observe today by what is basically an industry cartel.</p><blockquote>A captured tech stack puts handcuffs on all of society; stifling innovation and making economic alternatives unviable.</blockquote><p>One idea we have to get rid ourselves of is the thought that technological lock-in just happens as a feature of innovation or first-mover advantage by offering new technological capabilities. No, these are deliberate business decisions as rapid adoption is the biggest challenge these companies face, they need to <strong>race to entrench themselves before the dust settles.</strong></p><p>We can feel their urgency by opening any app these days. They simply put their AI anywhere so people can not escape it. Again, this is not coincidence:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/571/0*kFM7Wht4MiH4ErkW.png" /></figure><p>Summary table of adoption strategies and the related deceptive patterns. Source:<a href="https://computingwithinlimits.org/2025/papers/limits2025-beigon-imposing-ai.pdf"> Beignon A. et al., Imposing AI: Deceptive design patterns against sustainability. (2025). In <em>LIMITS ’25, 11th Workshop on Computing Within Limits</em></a></p><p>Here is an article by Brian Merchant puts it succinctly: <a href="https://www.bloodinthemachine.com/p/how-big-tech-is-force-feeding-us"><strong>How big tech is force-feeding us AI.</strong></a></p><blockquote>By inserting AI features onto the top of messaging apps and social media, where it’s all but unignorable, by deploying pop-ups and unsubtle design tricks to direct users to AI on the interface, or by pushing prompts to use AI outright, AI is being imposed on billions of users, rather than eagerly adopted.</blockquote><p>When your AI business model is to extract rent and exert power through infrastructure and technological lock-in, you better find a million ways to force people to adopt your AI stuff, no matter how crappy, immature or <a href="https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-025-03222-1">outright unsafe</a>, by any and all means necessary, even <a href="https://www.jpost.com/business-and-innovation/article-873080">leveraging the Trump administration to pressure EU regulation</a>.</p><p>Technological lock-in is key because it ensures dominance of tech-turned-AI giants for generations to come. And we know that dominant firms face little pressure to improve quality, consumer protection, or maintain reasonable prices. Instead, once we are locked in, the real squeeze can start.</p><h3>Preparing for the big squeeze with data colonialism</h3><p>AI models are built on <em>collective data</em>: the internet’s archives, social media posts, public domain works, academic research, and user interactions. Yet, as these commons are appropriated into proprietary model weights, they cease to be shared public knowledge and become enclosed corporate property.</p><p><strong>The AI hunger for data is palpable, </strong>not least shown by a steady drip of licensing deals between content publishers and AI hyperscalers.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1007/0*y-gKxiR-zOe1oahH.jpeg" /></figure><p>Source: <a href="https://futureweek.com/a-complete-list-of-publishers-striking-ai-content-licensing-deals/">Duffy, K. (2025, September 4). <em>A complete list of publishers and their AI licensing deals — Futureweek</em>. Futureweek.</a></p><p>With a lot of money going around, c<strong>ash‑starved newsrooms are happily negotiating with AI firms</strong> whose models already cannibalize their traffic but now promise them a share of the AI boom and newfound social relevance.</p><p>Take a look at <em>The Associated Press</em>:</p><blockquote>The news organization has spent the last nine to 12 months making its tens of millions of content assets across text, video, photos and audio formats, machine-readable for LLMs to assimilate easily. […]</blockquote><blockquote>“The best AI has the best inputs and generates the best outputs. This is the inverse of garbage in, garbage out,” said Roberts at the summit. “This means that in the future, we need more good quality, high quality content, not less. We’re going to transform the entire multi-trillion-dollar global economy based on AI, and AI fundamentally needs great information to be great”</blockquote><blockquote>- <a href="https://digiday.com/media/ap-makes-its-archive-ai-ready-to-tap-the-enterprise-rag-boom/"><em>Jessica Davis, Digiday</em></a></blockquote><p>Then there’s <em>Reddit</em>, which disclosed <a href="https://www.cjr.org/analysis/reddit-winning-ai-licensing-deals-openai-google-gemini-answers-rsl.php">AI data‑licensing contracts with Google and OpenAI</a>, selling their user content for training in exchange for boosts in AI search, immediately tripling their user base thanks to Google AI search.</p><p>Sounds like a win-win, right? Let me come to that in a second.</p><p>Before, we need to also acknowledge that AI hyperscalers are rarely so kind to ask for information, rather than <strong>pirating it by scraping the internet</strong> or worse. <a href="https://sustainabletechpartner.com/topics/ai/generative-ai-lawsuit-timeline/">All AI companies are currently in legal fights</a> over their blatant copyright infringement of information they had no legal way of obtaining, such as books or art. Anthropic recently settled one case for <a href="https://www.npr.org/2025/09/05/nx-s1-5529404/anthropic-settlement-authors-copyright-ai">$1.5 billion for pirating half a million books</a>. Peanuts for AI hyperscalers drunk on investor money and the prospect of robbing humanity blind in the future.</p><p>But this will make AI just more useful to users, so why worry about how companies get there?</p><p>This dynamic mirrors what <a href="https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/1527476418796632"><strong>Nick Couldry and Ulises Mejias</strong> coined <em>data colonialism</em></a>: the systematic appropriation of human life through data extraction, justified by narratives of progress and innovation. There was also a time when big tech platforms, from google search to social media platforms, felt genuinely useful and empowering to users. How did that turn out?</p><p>The Canadian writer <strong>Cory Doctorow</strong> coined the term “<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Enshittification">enshittification</a>” to describe the lifecycle of digital platforms that<strong> initially serve users</strong>, <strong>then prioritize business</strong> customers, and <strong>finally exploit both</strong> for maximum profit.</p><blockquote>Once users, creators, and institutions are locked in and have no real alternatives, the owners of the infrastructure can begin to systematically extract value from every layer of human activity.</blockquote><p>Remember social media platforms that once felt like open, empowering infrastructure? It is no coincidence they quickly devolved into an <strong>extractive apparatus for mass exploitation</strong>, with all the negative social and political consequences for society we have to grapple with today.</p><p>The AI data colonialism currently happening is even more worrisome. The <em>common goods of our digital lives</em> — language, images, art, stories, code — are either mined, bought or simply stolen to produce systems that we then must <em>rent access to</em> through corporate APIs and subscriptions. Every prompt becomes a micro-transaction in a planetary rent economy, and everybody will pay for what was once a public good.</p><p>And the social and political consequences will be almost unfathomable.</p><h3>Something new: owning the interface to reality</h3><p>Historically, media theorists have warned that the medium shapes the message. Today, it is more like: <strong>Control the interface, control the story</strong>.</p><p>As AI systems are installed as the default lens on the web, they act as <strong>new gatekeepers</strong> that will arbitrate which facts surface and which fall through the cracks. How thoroughly vulnerable this approach is to the whims of billionaire oligarchs that own the AI systems will surprise exactly nobody who just paid a glimpsing look at <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grokipedia">Elon Musk’s Grokipedia</a>.</p><blockquote>“Shortly after launch, several sources described articles as promoting right-wing perspectives, <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Conspiracy_theories">conspiracy theories</a>, and <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Views_of_Elon_Musk">Elon Musk’s personal views</a>. Other criticism of Grokipedia focused on its accuracy and biases due to <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hallucination_(artificial_intelligence)">AI hallucinations</a> and potential <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Algorithmic_bias">algorithmic bias</a>.”</blockquote><blockquote><em>-Wikipedia</em> (which is actually a community-based model that has proven invaluable to the world)</blockquote><p>This is a subtler, more pervasive form of any previous censorship or propaganda system because it operates under the guise of assistance and personalization while selling a very specific and narrow ideological worldview.</p><p>The more these captured AI models mediate our access to information, summarizing search results, generating news reports, drafting our communications, the less we experience the<strong> raw plurality of perspectives that once defined the open web</strong>.</p><p>Gatekeepers, censorship and propaganda are of course only the surface of how bad things can get.</p><p>Because AI is currently also deployed to create an <strong>unmeasurable amount of slop, deep fakes, fan fictions and disinformation</strong> that fundamentally will pollute and destroy the information ecosystem as we know it and make it <strong>basically unusable for human agents</strong>. Leading the pack is of course X.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/650/0*Qii4HJv0ir0yp5gN" /></figure><p>Source: Wald, B. (n.d.). <em>Dead Internet Theory and the collapse of online truth</em>. Galaxy. <a href="https://www.galaxy.com/insights/perspectives/dead-internet-theory-collapse-online-truth">https://www.galaxy.com/insights/perspectives/dead-internet-theory-collapse-online-truth</a></p><blockquote>“We’re trending quickly toward an internet that could be 99.9% AI-generated content, where agents and bots outnumber humans not just in traffic but in creative output. AI agents chat with each other on forums, generate news articles, create thought leadership, engage on social media, leave product reviews, spark controversy, and post memes. Each bot believes it’s talking to a human. Each human statistically is engaging with a bot. Every interaction seems plausible, even engaging. But it’s all synthetic.”</blockquote><blockquote><em>- Benjamin Wald, Galaxy</em></blockquote><p>When the signal to noise ratio of any true information is one in a million within an ocean of related, personalized and microtargeted lies that are optimized to be emotionally compelling, what confidence can we ever have in any information we consume?</p><p>Our current chaotic and broken information ecosystems already breed <strong>epistemic nihilism</strong>, where citizens believe that nothing is ever really true except for what feels right and convenient in the moment.</p><p>It is no surprise so many people turn to AI and treat them as answering machines, oracles or all-knowing gods over fact-checking and verifying sources themselves. That cognitive dependency on AI models and agents as navigation tools will only get more profound as time progresses.</p><p>Do I really have to point out the <strong>power differential</strong> when few entities will own and control the AI gatekeepers that generate the bulk of information flows at a time when billions depend on AI for cognitive navigation? Market monopoly would instill a much more powerful <strong>epistemic monopoly</strong>: control over the conditions of knowing.</p><p>Linguist have already noticed that AI “<a href="https://english.elpais.com/technology/2025-11-01/the-chatgpt-effect-weve-all-started-talking-like-robots.html">externalized thinking so completely that it makes us all equal</a>” in our use of language. It decreases democratic plurality in the worst way possible; by boiling our human diversity of thought and expression down into a homogeneous language slop.</p><p>Once users internalize the AI model’s outputs as truth, it will not only homogenize how we speak but how we reason and see the world. I for one would put that power under as much democratic accountability as possible.</p><blockquote>Leaving AI infrastructure to tech moguls will enshrine a trillionaire-friendly 21st century mix of corpo-Orwellian “goodspeak” and manufactured consent.</blockquote><p>Or much worse… but I do not want to give them any more ideas.</p><p>So let’s conclude our current state of affairs:</p><h3>Welcome to the robber‑mogul playbook</h3><p>All this leads me to an unpleasant but not unexpected conclusion:</p><p>Today’s AI arms race is best understood as a <strong>calculated corporate power grap</strong>: spend unprecedented sums on compute, <strong>secure strategic infrastructure</strong> along a <strong>vertical tech stack</strong>, use your investor billions to <strong>manipulate, muscle or coerce</strong> a critical mass of users and industry <strong>into rapid adoption</strong> of your stack <strong>despite productivity </strong>and <strong>expertise losses, security risks </strong>and<strong> environmental destruction</strong>, and let the narrative fog of “AGI” anxieties, geopolitics and empty promises cover up the construction of your <strong>death star rentier empire</strong>.</p><p>Unfortunately, the AI infrastructure boom for these <strong>tech moguls</strong> isn’t about reaching AGI; winning against China, or unlocking productivity utopia and abundance for humanity. As if any of these narcissistic wannabe sun-king egos would ever spare ambition for anybody but themselves. They play into these narratives with their appearances, press releases and pocketbooks to keep the media and the population occupied to look somewhere else.</p><p>But best I can tell, the current evidence suggests that the AI race is mostly about an older, more <strong>mundane, imperialistic impulse</strong> from centuries past that <strong>vast wealth inequality has always engendered</strong>: A lust for power. Dominance over the means of human affairs, from collaboration to production, enshrining their position over society for generations to come.</p><p><strong>It’s a feudalism reboot attempt for the information age.</strong></p><p>If the tech moguls win their gambit, if they succeed at infrastructure capture, technological lock-in and public dispossession of our shared information ecosystem, we will have ceded more than we have bargained for. Once control over knowledge creation, distribution and consumption (and with it increasingly cognitive agency) is lost for most of us, what awaits is a new dark age of monarchs, myths, manipulation and magical thinking.</p><p>A handful will own, a tiny minority will benefit, and the rest of us will fall into exploitation, exclusion or serfdom.</p><h3>How to stop feudal entrenchment</h3><p>What would a non‑feudal alternative require?</p><p>It is a question that many people are currently working on in the EU and elsewhere. One of them is <a href="https://cv.berjon.com/?utm_source=chatgpt.com">Robin Berjon</a>, a seasoned technologist and governance expert whose career spans <a href="https://www.w3.org/">web standards</a>, open protocols, data governance in media, and next-generation infrastructure like IPFS. He works on figuring out how digital systems can be governed in the public interest. He was also very kind and charitable to sit down for a chat with me and outline solutions.</p><blockquote><em>“</em>We really have to break this myth that monopolies were made by innovation, and that they could be broken by innovation.<em>”</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>- Robin Berjon</em></blockquote><p>He emphasized that the first imperative is to <strong>treat digital and AI infrastructure as public-interest infrastructure</strong> rather than private consumer products. That means regulation, not innovation, is needed. Historical lessons from railroads and telecom monopolies show that when essential systems are privately captured, democratic oversight collapses. As a strong proponent of <a href="https://berjon.com/digital-sovereignty/">digital sovereignty</a>, Robin was very clear about the stakes:</p><blockquote>“We have to treat this like a war effort… what you’re fighting for is the right to set your own rules in your own country.”</blockquote><blockquote><em>- Robin Berjon</em></blockquote><p>While my investigation into this topic is still very much ongoing, <strong>I already learned from him and others that there are good reasons for hope</strong>.</p><p>The current AI revolution presents not only a threat, but also an opportunity, to restore the foundations of democratic society in the digital age. If we, the people, aim to seize it now.</p><p>For example, there are already some practical solutions, often with proven efficacy at smaller scales or throughout history, already on offer.</p><p>So here is what we (and our representatives) should work on:</p><ul><li><strong>Establish pre-emptive regulatory guardrails today</strong> like the EU AI Act’s transparency and systemic-risk obligations, combined with antitrust enforcement to curb exclusive cloud-model tie-ups and break vertical control by tech cartels.</li><li><strong>Enshrine capabilities-centric infrastructure neutrality</strong> for things like identity verification, safety or content moderation, ensuring plural applications can compete with each other without having to recreate their own capabilities to fend off bots, spam, scams or cyber attacks that any digital endeavor suffers from</li><li><strong>Demand open protocols, federated architectures and interoperability standards</strong> (similar to ActivityPub [Bluesky] or <a href="https://becknprotocol.io/">Beckn</a>) to reduce dependency on single platforms, prevent lock-in and empower citizens by transferring data ownership back to users.</li><li><strong>Governmental and public adoption incentives</strong> of pro-democracy communication infrastructures. Habermasian democracy depends on institutionalizing norms of discourse. Adoption incentives ensure these norms are embedded in digital spaces rather than leaving them to market forces.</li><li><strong>Foster institutional density</strong>: AI should be regulated by a dense web of local institutions and governance models that reflect the diversity of communities and use cases. Start by building governance frameworks locally, experiment and pressure test, whatever works can then be shared or scaled horizontally to other domains.</li></ul><blockquote>“If you want democracy, it has to look like a hairball. Democracy is messy, but that’s what makes it resilient.”</blockquote><blockquote><em>- Robin Berjon</em></blockquote><ul><li><strong>Allow for epistemic pluralism</strong> by encouraging many models with diverse priors; resist interface monopolies. Information has a powerful impact on our identity and worldview. Grant individuals the right to control the mechanisms and interfaces that filter their perception</li></ul><h3>In short, we have to understand and reclaim digital infrastructure as a public good for all of society.</h3><p>That is my key message for you today; and wildly at odds with current AI developments, media narratives and public attention.</p><p>Let’s change that, together.</p><p>Please consider sharing this post or its message.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=92a4878915f5" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Chapter 2 — Early drums of war]]></title>
            <link>https://protagonist-science.medium.com/chapter-2-early-drums-of-war-97e35d2d9065?source=rss-c8e0e038559d------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/97e35d2d9065</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[serialized-stories]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[chapter-2]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[lab-leak-fever]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Philipp Markolin]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 31 Jul 2025 11:44:46 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-08-30T09:08:24.683Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>Adapted from Lab Leak Fever: The COVID-19 origin theory that sabotaged science and society</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*zNYwwEnhTxJiGRPk5hz8Lw.png" /><figcaption>Note: This is a freely accessible serialized version of Lab Leak Fever. Find an <a href="https://www.protagonist-science.com/p/lab-leak-fever-serialized">overview of all chapters</a> here or consult the <a href="https://www.lab-leak-fever.com/">book website</a> for further information.</figcaption></figure><p>“Without a harmonious and stable environment, how can there be a home where people can live and work happily?”<em> </em>Xi Jinping’s words on New Year’s Eve in 2019 were intended to reign in pro-democracy protests in Hong Kong. For months, the city has been in a renewed battle for its soul against the oppressive and subversive influence of the Chinese Communist Party. Tens of thousands, if not hundreds of thousands, were expected to march again on January 1, 2020.</p><p>The goal was to maintain political pressure after a landslide victory of pro-democracy candidates in district court elections weeks prior. Six thousand police officers were deployed to deal with potential unrest — the wrong signal to send, given previous escalations and excessive police brutality. “Safety concerns” led to the cancellation of the midnight fireworks despite months of planning. The next day, a peaceful protest with families, kids, and the elderly, often dressed up in costumes, quickly escalated into violence, tear gas, and mass arrests. The police blamed some radical student agitators who had hijacked the march. Maybe it was inevitable; tensions had been high for months. Universities and their students were front and center of the recent civil rights movement, and the police claimed these institutions had become “weapon factories.” As a result, sieges and raids on universities have become part of campus life over the last few months.</p><p>The last thing the exasperated Jasnah Kholin (pseudonym) needed at the time was “one more fucking thing to worry” about. The unfiltered coronavirus researcher (who swore like a sailor) now uses a pseudonym to hide her real identity for safety reasons (I promised her that I would omit any details that she felt would compromise her safety). She, like many others, had been at these protests for civil rights and experienced firsthand how they were squashed by the police, often with force. Once, the young academic had a pepper ball barely miss her face that would certainly have knocked her out. Another time, the police came to pick her up, and she was in prison for weeks before they let her go. Wrongfully suspected or not, she was among the lucky few who got out uncharged because there was no evidence to place her at the scene. It’s not surprising she had an innate distrust of the Chinese authorities, who were more and more entrenched in Hong Kong, her only home.</p><p>When she heard about the pneumonia outbreak in Wuhan around New Year’s on ProMED-mail, an internet service supported by volunteers that tracks unusual health events, she immediately started screenshotting and saving every bit of information that was coming out of Wuhan: every pdf, every Weibo message, every picture, all kinds of vital info. Because of Chinese censorship, information can sometimes be lost within minutes of appearing online. What foresight! “Oh, I am very familiar with how information works in China,” she would later explain to me. In any crisis, Chinese authorities shut down the information flow to try to control the narrative. This is not unusual; it happens for things big and small, important or insignificant. This approach might even help to contain false and harmful rumors during a crisis. However, it also creates a layer of obfuscation and political spin that can make it challenging to assert pertinent facts with any confidence. For example, consider how dangerous the virus was and how it spread. In the very beginning, the Chinese authorities claimed that the virus was barely, or not at all, transmissible human-to-human in an attempt to not cause panic, a claim that was still being repeated by the World Health Organization (WHO) on January 14th.</p><p>Jasnah Kholin and her academic colleagues in Hong Kong did not believe any of it. They had been burned before. On January 4th, Jasnah caught wind of a concerning story on Weibo (Chinese Twitter) about an infected father who had not gone to the Huanan market. Chinese censors deleted it within the hour. Yet for her, already gathering as much from rumors, the specifics of this story were the final indication of human-to-human transmission, vehemently denied by Chinese authorities until weeks later. Many other coronavirus experts were just as suspicious as her, including SARS-veterans Yuen Kwok-Yung, a giant among Hong Kong’s infectious disease experts, and Leo Poon, who developed the first PCR diagnostic for SARS in 2003. They all independently read the signs on the wall and raised the alarm in Hong Kong about the human spread. “SARS was a generational trauma for Hong Kong; this was not our first fucking rodeo,” Jasnah kept cursing. According to her, SARS-1 had also been much closer to a pandemic than people commonly realize. However, all of them knew this and did everything they could to make the rest of Hong Kong take this seriously.</p><p>Most likely, their actions at the time helped the city avoid the worst. By any measure, Hong Kong’s early and harsh response has been a success story. With the high uncertainty and unclear messaging from mainland China, it fell mostly to outbreak professionals and coronavirus academics like Jasnah to exert caution and inform society. Speed is everything in emerging outbreaks; the longer it takes to mount collective action, the worse it usually gets. Because of their warnings, both the population and Hong Kong’s chief executive would take the threat seriously and implement strict pandemic prevention protocols. From the first to the fourth wave, Hong Kongers succeeded where most of the world would fail; they suppressed community transmission of the virus.</p><p>Yet not everybody was happy. Pro-democracy protests saw their momentum decline under new restrictions. They were especially concerned about the ubiquitous use of contact tracing and digital surveillance, which they feared would be a new and powerful tool in the hands of the police. In the following months, civil rights protests were canceled, and the CCP exerted even more political pressure on Hong Kong. Stuck between a rock and a hard place, Jasnah, like many in the wider Chinese diaspora, wished that somebody would blow the lid off this thing in those early days. <em>Why did the CCP initially deny the obvious human-to-human spread? Why the silencing of doctors? Did the communist party really think they could hush up the severity of the outbreak? When will the world wake up about the Chinese government?</em> Somewhat ironically, the tumultuous cultural and political moment, along with this appropriately placed mistrust, made the Chinese diaspora, especially Hong Kong, very susceptible to a different type of viral spread.</p><p>Since December 30, when the outbreak of pneumonia of unknown etiology became official, sporadic voices both on Chinese and Western social media have put the connection of WIV’s biosafety level 4 (BSL-4) laboratory into public spaces, albeit in the context that they had the capacity and expertise there to handle the outbreak. The positive connotation did not last long. Within five days, this information would be presented by a pro-civil rights protester in Hong Kong to suggest quite a different connection. A tweet from the time, still visible today, reads:</p><p><em>My guess is China has ordered an attack on Hong Kong with bio-weapons to stop the continuous protests. Like in 2003, the CCP assisted the outbreak of SARS in HK to pave the way for #CEPA. You can’t underestimate how evil this regime is. #Bioweapon</em></p><p>Others echoed the idea, highlighting the particular timing right after the New Year’s protests that ended in violence. While none of these rumors gained any wide-reaching traction, they symbolized both fear and suspicion about the CCP and what they would or would not do. Suspicion was warranted. Independent information from Wuhan was hard to come by. And ordinary people would never get the full story.</p><p>Many of the early outbreak threads come together in one person, Dr. Gao Fu, known in the West as Dr. George Gao, director of the Chinese Center for Disease Control and Prevention (CCDC). Within China, public health authorities like the CCDC had mostly independent community-level, state-level, and federal offices, and George was sitting at the top node where all data would cascade towards, in many ways, the highest public health position in the land, only below the communist party’s National Health Commission. Dr. Gao rarely gave interviews, and every time he did, he would be investigated by authorities. The Associated Press learned of three such instances. When I managed to get an interview, it was a random Sunday afternoon. He was still in the office, working alongside his personal assistant. He kept running out of our interview on and off, dictating instructions in Chinese under his breath, sometimes even while I was directly talking to him.</p><p>Originally a veterinarian, George went to Oxford for a PhD and postdoc in Virology. After that, he went to Harvard for a few years, then back to Oxford as a group leader, before returning to China and starting his meteoric rise. From the Chinese Academy of Science to heading National Key Laboratories, working on the ground in the 2014 Ebola outbreak in Sierra Leone (his role was described as “heroic” by the US National Academy of Science), and all the way to becoming the Director of the Chinese CDC. By any measure, Dr. Gao is an incredibly successful scientist and possibly an equally skilled political tactician.</p><p>Most of our conversation was not about the questions I asked but a mixture of highlighting the work he has done, the papers he has published, the awards he has achieved, and overall, how great China did. “I have been on the frontline from the very beginning for the vaccine development in China, and also, I have some original publications for antibody development,” he said as he rattled off a long list of things I did not ask about and that went quite beyond the scope, but soon I would figure out why. He used it as a preamble to say that writers like me should really write for the general public about his and China’s amazing achievements. He jumped up from his chair to show me popular science books he had written in Chinese, and if I was interested in writing about these topics, we could write something together. I was torn between rolling my eyes and staying diplomatic. What a start, I thought, not even five minutes into our conversation. It went a bit better when I prompted him to put down a timeline for the early outbreak.</p><p>By the end of December, there were already rumors of another SARS outbreak on the Chinese internet. People were getting sick, and some doctors discovered that their patients had an association with the Huanan seafood market. Perhaps even market visitors or vendors noticed something unusual and spoke up as well; reconstruction has been difficult. As far as anybody can tell, these speculations started only around the last week of December but would soon harden into alarming action.</p><p>On December 30th, the municipal government issued a “red head” letter — an official document — noting they had a PUE (pneumonia of unknown etiology). The letter asked that if any other hospital notices similar cases, take them seriously and report them to the Bureau of Health. When Dr. Gao read that, he sent his staff and second-in-command to Wuhan. On December 31st, they collected samples from hospital patients.</p><p>On January 3rd, they got the first sequences confirming it was a coronavirus. In parallel, they quickly developed PCR primers and sent them to the local CCDC in Wuhan so they could start testing and screening patients. He could not stop himself from mentioning how China did well in contrast to the United States, where officials struggled with developing their own PCR test, which was a bit of a scandal at the time under Robert Redfield’s CDC. On the 5th, Gao and his team were trying to isolate and culture the virus in all the cell lines they had. They even took lung tissue samples from acute patients. “We were prepared to try everything, but in the end, this particular coronavirus was so easy to grow,” he admitted. On the evening of the 6th, they saw the canonical picture of the coronavirus (the spikes around the viral particle that look like a crown) under the electron microscope. This would famously be published in <em>The Lancet,</em> a renowned medical journal, a few weeks later.</p><p>On January 10th, Dr. Gao would personally visit Wuhan. They would report the first fatal case a day later, on the 11th. The following day, Gao’s team had been taking environmental swabs from the Huanan market multiple times, a place epidemiologically linked to most early patients in the hospital. However, the municipal CCDC in Wuhan had discussed shutting down the market on December 31st late into the night, and on January 1st at 8:00 a.m., fully geared CCDC workers would disinfect it. “So, there was not much to see anymore,” George told me. Yet neither official source acknowledged human-to-human transmission.</p><p>Dr. Gao traveled back to Beijing only to return to Wuhan again a week later, on the 17th, with another expert committee to assess the worsening outbreak. By then, he told me, they all felt that this outbreak was very serious. Many healthcare workers were getting sick, too. In full PPE gear, Gao’s team would interview patients and doctors, whereas he would personally interrogate the directors of the various hospitals with coronavirus cases. They had to make an announcement. “We were always discussing when we should make this official announcement. We didn’t want to create a big panic; we wanted a chance to get the disease done.” It was a difficult balance to strike, given the rumors at the time. “I never spoke to the media before the 20th; because I am the director of the CDC, I cannot speak out without evidence… But we felt and we thought it was human-to-human transmission, but we need evidence [sic].” He was right; no matter if it is the Chinese CDC, WHO, or any other organization, scientific evidence is always much slower to come forward than speculations and rumors. When I asked him how he felt about this asymmetry, he finally dropped some of the self-promotion and got angry. “With all these conspiracy theories, what can you do as a scientist? You cannot do anything. All you can do is keep yourself quiet. Can you argue? You wanna quarrel with them? Fight with them? In the media? You’ll never have the end.”</p><p>In the months following January, Dr. Gao had been fiercely criticized for not announcing human-to-human transmission earlier, so I guess he felt the need to keep reiterating how he had always considered that there was human-to-human spread. It was a coronavirus, after all. That it would spread between humans was never in question. But how much? “MERS did not spread well between humans,” he offered as another example. One really needs evidence to substantiate and classify claims. “I tried really hard to never say anything wrong,” he defended himself. After that, he went on another round of deflection — “Americans and Europeans would not even wear masks” — and more self-promotion.</p><p>I asked him how he dealt with the pressure and never-ending criticism. “I don’t want to be in the spotlight, but it comes with the position; people put you in this position. If I did something wrong in the last three years, I cannot change history. If you tell me, ‘George, you did this or that wrong in 2020,’… I know we have some lessons to learn, but that is not our Chinese culture to say. We only say we learn experiences [sic], not learn lessons.” He pointed out how the Germans officially admitted to the mistakes of the Second World War, but the Japanese never did. Any admission of failure comes with the threat of losing face. Being silent was a way to preserve it. “We never use the word ‘lesson’; you guys can use lesson.” He chuckled a bit at this cultural idiosyncrasy — maybe the one thing that was truly coming from him as a person, not him as a political tactician. He spent fifteen years living outside of China and was trained at Oxford and Harvard, he reminded me. He believed that he understood both cultures and that understanding had equipped him for his position. “If it were not me, with such a big pressure, the world would be different.” He reiterated this last point twice. I think he was correct, but whether it would have been better or worse if a less skilled politician had been in his influential role remains open to interpretation.</p><p>The simple fact is that while Chinese scientists were well positioned, Chinese authorities had failed to learn some crucial lessons from the original SARS outbreak. They tried to control the message before the outbreak overwhelmed them. On January 3, 2020, after a week of rumors about a new SARS outbreak appeared on social media, a memo from the National Health Commission, one of China’s executive departments of the State Council, ordered the shutdown of all outbreak communication. Digital censors would filter and delete messages talking about the outbreak from Weibo, websites, and anywhere else online. In a situation where speed of communication is everything, artificial barriers to information flow can be a poisonous thorn. Even Chinese scientists were not allowed to talk to the press or release any data in an effort by authorities to keep a lid on this thing until they could figure out how to spin it. The authorities muzzled them and prohibited them from speaking with outsiders, at least in theory. Is it really any surprise that the rest of the world was suspicious?</p><p>There were rays of hope, though. I believe one has to understand that science is not only an engine for innovation or a way to get fancy new gadgets but has always functioned as a tool of global diplomacy. Even during the Cold War, scientific collaborations and trust built between researchers would often circumnavigate political nonsense. The Wuhan outbreak was no different. Despite the muzzle, information would be disclosed to academic collaborators. That is why many scientists in authoritarian countries will always be viewed with distrust by their own governments. They fear that a scientist’s loyalty to the truth is higher than their loyalty to the state. For Chinese scientists, working under these conditions was, and certainly still is, a difficult line to walk.</p><p>Few understand this better than evolutionary virologist Edward Holmes. The British-born scientist, who prefers to go by Eddie, holds a position at the University of Sydney in Australia, where studying viral emergence has been his career and life. In 2012, he became interested in working on emergent diseases in China and struck up several collaborations all over the country, including in Wuhan. One of these collaborators was Professor Zhang Yongzhen from the Shanghai Public Health Clinical Center, formerly of the CCDC as well. The two shared many common interests, including discovering novel RNA viruses and studying their evolution. Both saw the potential and power of metagenomic sequencing, a technique where all DNA or RNA sequences from within an environmental sample are amplified without bias. Metagenomic sequencing creates terabytes of data, and filtering through billions of genetic puzzle pieces while trying to stitch them together into novel and unknown genomes is a computationally challenging task that requires expertise, resources, and, of course, local collaboration to get relevant samples.</p><p>This hunt for relevant samples brought the two of them to Wuhan in 2014, where researchers from the municipal CCDC took them to the Huanan market as an example of where spillovers might happen. It was no secret that wildlife was sold there, often without the right permissions. Eddie snapped photos of caged raccoon dogs, potentially sick and held in cages in the corner of the western side of the market in unsanitary conditions, with other wildlife stacked below and above them. Eddie had always been interested in the animal-human interface, whereas Zhang was more focused on human pathogen surveillance. That is why the two also visited local hospitals. Zhang had an ambitious vision. He wanted to build a network of hospitals all over China that would collect samples from patients with respiratory symptoms and send them to him to search for new viral pathogens. Where better to find novel RNA viruses of relevance than in the obscure pneumonia cases all larger hospitals see but rarely resolve?</p><p>In the end, Zhang would manifest his human-centric vision of an alarm system for pneumonia cases. A system that would now deliver the first patient samples from Wuhan on January 3, 2020, to him. By January 5th, reportedly after 40 hours of straight-up work, team member Chen Yan-Mei had produced the first full genome sequence from these patient samples in his lab. It was a new SARS-related virus. Zhang raised the alarm with his contacts in Shanghai’s Health Authority and uploaded the new viral genome to Genbank under an embargo. “We wrote the paper in two days,” Eddie would later explain to me. On January 7th, they submitted a paper to the scientific journal <em>Nature</em>.</p><p>There was incredible urgency to be quick from a public health perspective, but we would be remiss not to note the prestige that comes with publishing. Zhang wanted to get the sequence out, but other Chinese groups, including George Gao’s CCDC and Shi Zhengli from WIV, were also trying to do so, and they had their genomes ready around the same time. The problem was the National Health Commission’s ban on releasing any data. For days, Eddie was urging Zhang for permission to release the genome, but the rules were clear. Zhang was likely torn from what I could gather. It seems to me that when Zhang visited Wuhan in person that week and saw the full scope of the emerging outbreak starting to overwhelm hospitals, he believed word needed to get out. An editor at the journal was pushing him to release the genome, and when Eddie called him when he was on his flight to Beijing, urging him once again to release the genome, he agreed. Zhang’s day had been as eye-opening as it was grim. “Eddie, I authorize you to release the data,” Eddie recalled their exchange. Fifty-two minutes after Eddie received the FASTA file containing the genome sequence, he released it on Zhang’s behalf to a virological website. It would become the global reference genome named Wuhan-Hu-1, the wild-type original SARS-CoV-2. The world would finally get to see the new virus.</p><p>And not a second too soon because just two days later, Thailand would report the first infected patient, identified by none other than Supaporn Wacharapluesadee, the Thai virus huntress I met in Chonburi. This alarm from the international spread put pressure and attention on the Chinese authorities to acknowledge human-to-human transmission, which they still had not confirmed with WHO.</p><p>Because of his decision to share data transparently, Zhang was named the “saving grace” of the pandemic by <em>Time</em> magazine, and the scientific journal <em>Nature</em> featured him in an article titled “Ten people who shaped science in 2020.” However, his actions were met with scorn and punishment inside China. The National Health Commission had previously reprimanded him with a “rectification” order, temporarily disallowing his team to study the virus. Officials came to “inspect” his lab based on bogus claims about biosafety protocols. They were there to put him on a leash. Silence would fall around him.</p><p>Since then, Zhang has consistently denied being reprimanded, reportedly arguing that he did not believe China was controlling information and that their response was simply based on caution due to false statements made by scientists about the first SARS outbreak. “Zhang is now not the same person as I knew him before,” Eddie shared with me. Years later, the ongoing conflict escalated publicly again, leading to Zhang and his team’s sudden eviction, which caused him to stage a protest. Dramatic pictures showed him sleeping in front of his office door with policemen surrounding him while students spoke up on his behalf, to no avail. In Eddie’s opinion, the authorities had long punished Zhang for disobeying the muzzle order; his eviction marked the end point of a four-year prosecution, even though he was not privy to the details.</p><p>There was also friction with Zhang’s release of the virus genome from other sources outside the health commission. In particular, Dr. George Gao from the CCDC felt someone had stolen his prestige. He had uploaded the first genome sequences from his patient samples to GISAID on January 9th (although Gao told me it was the 8th), and they were released by the 12th, a good day and a half after Eddie posted Zhang’s work. Zhang was the first, not him, because he broke the rules. Since then, Gao has used his power and influence to try to rewrite history, striking up a deal with the now controversial Peter Bogner and the database GISAID to retrospectively change the release date to January 10th so he would be first. Others also reported how GISAID bullied scientists into citing the bogus date on the GISAID genomes and removing citations from Zhang’s genome. Everything to create a thin paper trail to make it look like Gao and GISAID were the first.</p><p>In reality, neither Gao nor Zhang, nor Zhengli Shi from the WIV, were truly the first.</p><p>On December 25th, the private sequencing company Vision Medicals, a sequencing service provider working with hospitals, had sequenced samples from a retired 65-year-old deliveryman who used to work at the Huanan seafood market and still spent a lot of time there. He was first admitted to Wuhan Central Hospital on December 18th. When a technician by the name of 小山狗 (Xiǎoshān Gǒu, or “Little Mountain Dog”) came to work on the morning of December 26th, she found that her software had flagged a few sequencing reads as belonging to a “sensitive pathogen,” something that seemed like a SARS coronavirus. “Feeling anxious, I quickly checked the detailed analysis data in the background and found that the similarity was not very high,” she would later write in her blog. She initiated a more detailed analysis, finding an 87% similarity to a bat SARS-related virus. But bat SARS are still classified under SARS, so she was worried and compared it to all published SARS-related genomes. She found the closest two — bat-SL-CoVZC45 and bat-SL-CoVZXC2 — sampled in 2018 in Zhoushan, Zhejiang Province. They would not remain the closest known relatives for long.</p><p>Dr. Shi Zhengli, now better known as “The Batwoman,” had been contacted by her boss at WIV around ten on the night of December 30th while she was in Shanghai for a meeting. Doctors from the Jinyintan hospital had reached out to WIV because they had nine patients with pneumonia of unknown etiology; the suspicion was SARS. Zhengli contacted students in her lab that same night; luckily, three of them were still working. She asked them to stay the night and test the samples. They ran a pan-PCR test for general coronaviruses, as well as a few qRT-PCR probes more specifically for SARS-related coronaviruses. Four and five patient samples tested positive, respectively. “We believed the results. But I could not believe the results, you know?” she recalled for me. “That was not possible. We always said, ‘Oh, one day it will come,’ and it really came.” Her lab was working with coronaviruses; could this be one of the viruses they were working with? She described to me how she felt upset, her hand waving up and down in front of her body. At first, they could not get the full genome sequence, so they could not compare it with what they had in the lab. Only by lunchtime could one of her colleagues get a hold of the virus sequence that Little Mountain Dog had assembled via a hospital sample. The new virus was nothing they had ever seen, isolated, or worked on. “So I feel relieved,” she admitted. No scientist takes lab safety lightly, and Zhengli, who was trained in the West, was no different. But she, like everybody else, has never encountered this novel virus before.</p><p>That being said, her extensive work on collecting bat samples paid off. Within her database, there was a pretty close match to a bat coronavirus her team had collected in Yunnan, Southern China. It was a big deal, pointing to the origin of the new virus being bats again. Soon, she would publish the genome sequence extracted from that bat fecal swab, named RaTG13, and with its publication, her troubles would begin (more on that later). Back in the first days of January, her team also managed to sequence the full-length genome of the novel virus from the patient samples the hospital sent them. Zhengli was very proud of her team because they got the full genome, even with the very last base pairs at the end — the trickiest part of the assembly. Her genome sequence was the cleanest with lots of read support; a fact she would be really proud of.</p><p>To sum up, within a week of clinicians raising the alarm, three different labs and one sequencing company had identified and sequenced the novel virus causing sickness, which I personally find rather impressive. Even today, there is a broad agreement that nobody had ever seen this novel virus before, and there was a collective effort to identify, sequence, and understand what was happening to patients in Wuhan hospitals. Most Chinese doctors and scientists did their part to quickly help decision-makers have good information for dealing with the outbreak. And yet, upholding appearances and hierarchical politics seemed to somehow have thrown sand into some of those efficient gears. Limiting the free flow of information, muzzling what scientists can say and to whom, and trying to downplay rumors and control narratives slowed down our collective understanding. Much of that continues to this day. Some Chinese scientists get punished for breaking these rules; some do the best they can within the system, and others try to navigate it to their advantage.</p><p>In my interview with the accomplished Dr. Gao, getting all the credit for “being first to publish the genome” counted more than sharing pesky details and messy efforts from many scientists to identify and understand this new virus. After his shenanigans with the GISAID database, today he would turn around and claim that because a journal (<em>The Lancet </em>in this case) quoted his GISAID genomes as being the first, it proved that he was indeed the first. After a tedious interview, I felt very little desire to stroke his ego, so our conversation dried up. Either way, he was a good reminder of how personal ambition and politics can tempt even very accomplished scientists down the wrong path of fiction and falsehood. In the larger picture, Dr. Gao’s petty attempts to rewrite his role were a rather mundane quibble left for the history books, inconsequential to how we understood the novel threat. Few citizens of the world had any idea what a way-less accomplished scientist might do when faced with the tragic outbreak of a novel virus and the opportunity to become famous.</p><p>Dr. Li-Meng Yan is our first example of one such scientist. Scarlett — as Jasnah Kholin would call her former acquaintance from Hong Kong University by her Western name — was a rather unremarkable postdoc. Yet, in just a few months, the black-haired woman with the square glasses and monotonous, almost robotic voice would leverage her scientific affiliations into stardom. Dr. Leo Poon, a viral disease expert whose excellent lab develops diagnostic tools, hired her in 2015 to conduct experiments with a hamster animal model system to evaluate some of the diagnostic tests the lab was investigating. I tracked down the soft-spoken professor because I wanted to know who Scarlett was before she became a media sensation. Leo explained his lab’s focus and that Scarlett had been a hard worker. At the time, her experimental work was focused on studying influenza virus transmission and testing attenuated influenza vaccines in mice. Until January 2020, Scarlett had never even worked with coronaviruses, according to Leo.</p><p>“I had no idea what she was up to,” he would tell me. Leo Poon, like other Hong Kong academics, had been preparing for the worst early on. In 2003, he and his colleague Malik Peiris first isolated a coronavirus from samples of 50 pneumonic patients in Hong Kong and identified this as the infectious agent causing SARS. Their findings and groundbreaking paper on the novel virus would make them famous among academics. Back then, Leo had developed the diagnostic PCR test for SARS, and when he saw the official “red-head” notice from the Wuhan authorities in late December, he began preparing himself mentally to do the same again with the new virus. With a grim sense of foreboding, he pulled genomic sequences of SARS-related viruses from databases and started constructing various primers from consensus regions — genomic regions that had high similarity — to test specificity even before the first genome would be published. He wanted to be ready and have the system up and running for when the genome of the new virus would be released. Speed is critical.</p><p>In his opinion, Scarlett might have felt bored about her influenza vaccine work, and she had not been very happy over the years with how little impact and recognition her work entailed. Leo remembered how she always wanted “to be more,” attempted to request first authorship on a paper to which her contribution was not substantial enough to warrant such a demand, and sought to work on projects that were outside the scope of his lab. She pushed him to let her speak at seminars for more exposure or invite guests to the lab by leveraging his name. But science can be very frustrating in that way. Except for some extremely lucky or extraordinary circumstances, scientific work and recognition are slow, gradual, and almost never reach the wider public.</p><p>From my perspective and that of people who knew her, it seemed that even after years in a great lab, success did not come fast enough for Scarlett. Like many junior academics hungry for impact, maybe she also desired to be the one to find something that would make her famous.</p><p>On January 13th, a bit more than a day after Zhang’s SARS-CoV-2 genome was published online, SARS-veteran Professor Yuen Kwok-Yung gave an interview to a local Hong Kong newspaper that most likely caught Scarlett’s attention. By comparing the genome sequences to published coronaviruses and placing them into a basic phylogenetic family tree like Little Mountain Dog did a few weeks prior, he explained that, while the new virus is genetically distant from the SARS of 2003, the original source might have been bats. He also highlighted that two bat viruses with around 90% similarity, sampled in 2018 in Zhoushan, Zhejiang Province, were the closest relatives of the new virus. The archipelago south of Shanghai in the East China Sea was over 1000 kilometers away from Wuhan. “However, the reason for the similarity of the coronaviruses in the two places is not yet known,” he was quoted as saying. Little did he know that his words would contribute to setting a course of action in motion that would shake the world. Scientific mysteries invite speculation, and Scarlett possibly saw an opportunity to solve that particular mystery of why these geographically distant viruses were so similar.</p><p>She looked up the 2018 study he was referencing. It had the apt title, “Genomic characterization and infectivity of a novel SARS-like coronavirus in Chinese bats.” A basic internet search highlighted that the scientists who discovered these bat viruses were affiliated with a military medical university. Jasnah had explained to me how Scarlett was deeply distrustful of the CCP, so it did not take much for her to believe that maybe there was a hidden human connection between the Wuhan outbreak and these bat viruses named ZC45 and ZXC21. After all, why were the two closest viral relatives to the novel virus both discovered by scientists affiliated with the Chinese military? How could a new virus emerge 1,000 kilometers away in a city with one of China’s two high-security BSL-4 labs? Maybe there was a deeper reason why Chinese authorities have not been transparent about the outbreak and lied about human-to-human transmission. It likely seemed to be too much of a coincidence for her, but we can only speculate about the full scope of her motives.</p><p>She certainly was not the only one in Hong Kong who distrusted anything and everything coming from China. “Honestly, it doesn’t take much for certain people. Moving outside of the PRC [People’s Republic of China] for any reason and realizing that you have basically been fed a carefully crafted lie your entire life is not exactly a comforting experience,” Jasnah elaborated. She had seen this many times before when Chinese students were moving to Hong Kong. The change in the information environment often leads to a change in their worldview. As for Scarlett, Jasnah told me she had been “a regular watcher” of YouTuber and supposed Chinese dissident Wang Dinggang, who broadcasts under the name of Lu De. For years, he has built a name for himself by attacking the CCP on YouTube. He railed against China’s crackdown on Muslims and pontificated on the US trade war. Scarlett possibly saw an opportunity for recognition, or maybe just a need to share, so she reached out to him and offered her suspicions about the new virus.</p><p>It is unclear whether she knew — or even cared about — how much her suspicions would be capitalized on by bad actors at the time. When a group of US-based Chinese influencers suddenly started distributing the first social media posts, videos, and articles in Chinese on January 18th that highlighted these spurious connections to ZC45, ZXC21, and the Chinese military, few consumers within the Chinese-speaking community were aware that the information flooding their news feeds was inauthentic. They had no idea that the information being released was made up for a specific purpose: to manipulate them. “The media outlets that cater to the Chinese diaspora — a jumble of independent websites, YouTube channels, and Twitter accounts with anti-Beijing leanings — have formed a fast-growing echo chamber for misinformation. With few reliable Chinese-language news sources to fact-check them, rumors can quickly harden into a distorted reality,” <em>The New York Times</em> would later report about this ecosystem. Only with some hindsight can we reconstruct where all the activity was coming from at the time.</p><p>The ringleader behind these sets of rumors was Ho Wan Kwok (also known as Guo Wengui or Miles Kwok), better known as Miles Guo. He was a reportedly corrupt billionaire and self-proclaimed dissident who fled China in 2014 after sniffing out that he was going to be arrested under allegations of bribery, money laundering, fraud, and rape. Profiting from shady construction deals and political maneuvering for decades, Guo was, at the time, the 73rd richest person in China when his political network was slowly being dismantled by Xi Jinping’s anti-corruption campaign. He was losing influence. Before investigators could reach him, he took his money and ran.</p><p>Ever since, the exiled tycoon has lived lavishly in the US and found a new political home within the Trump-associated MAGA movement in the USA, being a frequent guest at Mar-a-Lago and a close collaborator of then-President Trump’s advisor and Breitbart founder Steve Bannon. In 2018, Guo, with the help of Bannon, entered the media game and trademarked Guo Media, a social media video and broadcasting service owned as a foreign business corporation by a shell company in Delaware. He would later also be the funding source behind Gettr, a Twitter clone and alt-tech social media platform targeting American conservatives that was founded by Jason Miller, a former Donald Trump aide. Miles Guo and Trump’s inner circle had a shared interest in undermining the Chinese government, and Bannon received over a million dollars in consulting fees from Guo, according to investigative reports. With their near-daily video commentary, Guo and Bannon’s opinion pieces would flood GNews, and they accumulated a decent following, especially among the Chinese-speaking diaspora, who saw Guo as some kind of anti-CCP warrior and hero, a false image he crafted for himself.</p><p>The billionaire has also cultivated a set of popular influencers and dissidents to boost his profile, including John Pan, who was among Mr. Guo’s inner circle until December 2019. A dissident, Mr. Pan would later explain to ABC News Australia how he became trapped in Guo’s anti-CCP activism and how he and the initial 18 members of the inner circle discussed how to orchestrate viral media campaigns against the CCP. “We’re talking about how we would promote the information that Guo was leaking out, how we spread that information to the world. No matter [if it was] true or false,” Mr. Pan was quoted as saying by the news organization. He explained, as an example, how Guo once encouraged his key followers during the 2019 Hong Kong democracy protests to spread a rumor that martial law was imminent in the territory. People predisposed to this kind of messaging in times of crisis ate it up uncritically, and Guo’s followership and influence grew, especially in Hong Kong, where there was a massive hunger for CCP-independent information in Chinese, and he was pumping out propaganda content daily.</p><p>When the outbreak in Wuhan emerged in early 2020, it presented a tremendous opportunity for Guo’s operation. On January 18th, Miles Guo created the marching orders and, in a live stream, passed them to his followers. Together with Lu De, his “chief propagandist,” he used Scarlett’s suspicions and persona to concoct a bioweapon myth based on the spurious connections to the 2018 bat viruses. Some of Guo’s sock puppet accounts (fictitious social media accounts controlled by somebody else) are still visible today.</p><p>They would all blast out the same copy-pasted message:</p><p>武汉的类SARS冠状病毒就是来源于中共军方2018年从舟山蝙蝠身上发现并分离的新型冠状病毒。如图改病毒序列可以在美国国立卫生研究院的基因数据库找到（NIH的GenBank)，由南京军区军事医学科学研究所递交。并且通过技术故意更改舟山蝙蝠病毒，适于人类传播的新病毒</p><p>Translation: <em>The SARS-like coronavirus in Wuhan originated from a new type of coronavirus discovered and isolated from bats in Zhoushan by the Chinese military in 2018. The virus sequence shown in the picture can be found in the gene database of the National Institutes of Health (NIH’s GenBank), and submitted by the Institute of Military Medical Sciences of the Nanjing Military Region. And the Zhoushan bat virus was intentionally changed through technology, a new virus suitable for human transmission.</em></p><p>These identical messages contained the same images: one was a screenshot of the GenBank (the US National Institute of Health’s sequence repository) website showing the 2018 bat virus entries, and the second was of the 2018 publication with the military hospital affiliation of the last author highlighted separately. Disinformation often uses real but decontextualized information as the supposed “source” for its false or manipulative claims. There was no question that all of these identical posts came from the same originator. It was low-effort but effective. Dozens, if not hundreds, of sock puppet accounts and bots would amplify this message on Twitter, Facebook, WeChat, Weibo, and other social media platforms. Lu De and other influencers in Guo’s network would do the same. The groundwork had been laid, and audiences were primed.</p><p>On January 19th, the influencer Lu De would put on a suit and get ready for his show. In his 80-minute episode devoted to an “unnamed whistle-blower” (later revealed to be Scarlett), Lu De boasted that he had heard from “the world’s absolute top coronavirus expert” some troubling news that China was not being transparent. The Chinese military had actually created the virus. “I think this is very believable and very scary,” he said. Broadcast on GNews, Vimeo, and YouTube and then amplified by his tens of thousands of followers, his show hit like a bomb, with hundreds of thousands of clicks and engagements. The other influencers in Guo’s network followed suit, with the inner group alone reaching around 143 million views in the following weeks, according to an investigation by the Digital Forensics Research Lab, an organization that tracks disinformation.</p><p>Yet this first media blitz would only be the beginning of their success story. Guo’s biggest move was still a few months out. Scarlett was to assume a much bigger and way more controversial role, maybe the one she always wanted. Leo Poon warned me that he might not want to answer any more questions about her because “I am sure she will use all my comments on her to promote herself and to discredit science. I personally do not want to give her any chance to make up new stories. Of this reason [sic], I might refuse to answer questions about her.” Jasnah was equally dismayed. “I swear, if that whole fucking thing comes back to Miles fucking Guo, I don’t know what I would do,” was her response when I laid out how I viewed this particular origin of the bioweapon myth. We humans like to believe that if circumstances had just been a bit more favorable, maybe events could have played out quite differently. Unfortunately, the reality was not that simple.</p><p>I have been sifting through early reporting to investigate where the different “man-made” conspiracy theories originated. Reconstruction is a tedious task, eating away hours after hours; sitting many late nights chasing down outdated links and articles and deleted social media posts in the internet archive with tools like the Wayback Machine. However, when taken together with first-hand accounts from people on the ground who lived through it, a fuller picture emerges. Rumors, myths, and controversy after outbreaks are common, maybe even unavoidable. Every single outbreak, from the plague to the various influenza pandemics to “SARS, MERS, EBOLA, ZIKA, you name it,” Leo Poon would finish my exact thoughts. Each one of them was followed by conspiracy theories that blamed humans for it, and a substantial number of people were willing to believe any explanation given, no matter how absurd. The best I can tell is that we humans have a tendency to seek and see agency behind grand catastrophes. We also tend to assign blame to an outgroup when things go wrong.</p><p>The bat viruses collected in 2018 in Zhoushan might have been the earliest of the man-made conspiracy theories that received inauthentic amplification and went viral, but Miles Guo and his gang of influencers were, of course, not the only ones who tapped into the political moment. General anxiety and uncertainty at the beginning of any crisis lend themselves to media manipulation. In fact, multiple related origin myths would emerge separately and almost simultaneously all over the world, sometimes mingling and converging topically but gradually and independently gaining more attention.</p><p>For example, on January 20th, Russian disinformation operations in state media started to pick up on the man-made theme, albeit with a twist: they platformed self-proclaimed biosecurity expert Igor Nikulin, a political activist with no discernable expertise, who argued that the US created the virus and used it to attack China. He first expressed this belief on <em>Zvezda</em>, a state media outlet tied to the Russian military, and repeated it dozens of times in other interviews with mainstream outlets that seemed to eat it up uncritically. This facade of laundering information through supposed independent voices and intermediaries is neither new nor unexpected from Russia. The KGB had run a similar disinformation campaign in the 1980s, today known as “Операция «Инфекция,” a.k.a. Operation Infection (originally Operation Denver), to blame the emergent AIDS pandemic on their foreign adversary, the US. Iran and China would follow this playbook in due time.</p><p>In the US, on January 21st, a QAnon influencer expressing strong anti-vaccine sentiments named Jordan Sather picked up and amplified to his hundreds of thousands of followers a different conspiracy myth, creating roots for a set of ideas that would later resurface occasionally under the name “Plandemic.” He alleged that the pandemic was man-made for nefarious purposes, such as selling vaccines for profit. His evidence? Links to an old patent entry. He claimed researchers had produced a vaccine against the new virus, but now the patent was about to expire. That patent he linked to does, in fact, exist. It was work that was partially supported by grants from the Bill Gates Foundation and pharmaceutical companies. What a coincidence, he echoed on social media. <em>“Was the release of this disease planned? Is the media being used to incite fear around it? Is the Cabal desperate for money, so they’re tapping their Big Pharma reserves? Are there vaccines already being manufactured to “fight” this?”</em> Sather did not realize or care that the patent in question was for a vaccine against SARS that broke out in 2003, not SARS-CoV-2. But of course, he did not need to get the facts right; his posts prompted countless online engagements all the same, spreading the patent myth far and wide.</p><p>A few days later on January 23, with a veneer of serious reporting, the UK tabloid <em>Daily Mail</em> amplified another very influential myth that would also spread like wildfire. A Western scientist wrote in a 2017 <em>Nature News</em> article a warning about how the Chinese culture of hiding problems and lack of transparency might pose an issue for working in BSL-4 labs like in Wuhan. The <em>Daily Mail</em>’s insinuation was clear: The new virus might have leaked from this lab in Wuhan because of bad biosafety. The article bolstered its claims with the commentary of a bioweapon fearmonger who had an axe to grind with virological biosafety for years. It gave a veneer of serious reporting. However, BSL-4 labs only work with <em>known</em>, very dangerous pathogens, not random bat viruses whose pathogenicity has not been characterized yet. Ordinary bat viruses cannot infect humans, so they could be studied under BSL-2 at the time. But the high-security BSL-4 sounded more dangerous, so it was good for headlines. That any such proposed lab accident from a BSL-4 lab would have, by necessity, required knowledge and documentation of this hitherto unseen virus first, or that no unknown virus ever leaked from a high biosafety lab, was conveniently withheld from readers.</p><p>On January 23rd, Wuhan, a megacity of 11 million, went into lockdown. Outbound public transport was suspended. Public activities were canceled. Flights got grounded. Panic set in. The news sent shockwaves around the world. The outbreak in Wuhan had been a narrow issue for most of the world until this point. Suddenly, it really captured the attention and imagination of the masses. The infosphere exploded into overdrive. With a large global audience came a huge market demand for more outbreak information and answers, a need that scientists and institutions could not satisfy immediately. However, commentators, bloggers, and influencers were all too happy to fill those gaps with more rumors, speculations, and falsehoods, often by scraping together bits and pieces from dubious internet sources and Google searches. Speed over accuracy is how you make gains in the attention economy. It was like putting gasoline on a fire. With the media attention surrounding the dramatic lockdown announcements, conspiracy theories exploded into the mainstream. The early conspiracy theories received the biggest amplification from crowd-sourced interest. It’s called first-mover advantage. Everybody was sharing, retweeting, and commenting on content that featured the Wuhan outbreak and the mysterious virus as its topic.</p><p>On January 25, Guo Media’s GNews announced in an article that the CCP admitted to the bioweapon release — a complete fabrication — by providing a Word document full of “evidence” for the bioweapon. That document included screenshots Guo and his network had spread before, along with some loose commentary and descriptions to create the superficial appearance of merit. It was happily picked up by fringe and right-wing media as well as partisans.</p><p>On January 26, the obscure Indian blogger Great Game India amplified social media chatter by publishing an article titled <em>Coronavirus Bioweapon — How China Stole Coronavirus from Canada and Weaponized It</em>. The piece was a complete fabrication, distorting a legitimate July 2019 report from Canada. Around the same time, the U.S. partisan tabloid <em>The</em> <em>Washington</em> <em>Times</em> picked up similar rumors, blending <em>Daily Mail</em> reporting from three days earlier about biosafety concerns with baseless speculations from a questionable Israeli intelligence analyst. This analyst reiterated the false Canadian spy story and claimed the Wuhan Institute of Virology (WIV) was involved in bioweapons research. The narrative, fueled by the Israeli bioweapon analyst’s claim, quickly gained traction within right-wing media circles.</p><p>On January 29, the blogging outlet Zerohedge started doxxing a Chinese scientist, accusing him of being responsible for the pandemic. The outrage that followed the blaming of an individual was good for amplification; major media outlets would cover these lies in an attempt to debunk them, but this only added to their spread. The poor scientist’s name, photograph, telephone number, and email address were shared over 11,500 times on Twitter. Zerohedge would later be temporarily banned on Twitter for doxxing because it violated company policies. But this was only after the blogger pulled off his biggest stunt two days later.</p><p>On January 30, Indian researchers published a preprint finding an “uncanny similarity of unique inserts” in the spike protein, identical to peptide fragments found in HIV. The uncanny sequences were just arising out of coincidence, and the preprint would be withdrawn later, but not before amplifiers on social media picked up on it and ran their mouths off. In parallel, foreign policy hawks like Francis Boyle and US senators like Tom Cotton were publicly entertaining the idea that the new virus was a bioweapon or could have come from the Wuhan BSL-4 lab.</p><p>On January 31, ZeroHedge dramatically amplified the bioweapon myth by creating a fairytale based on merging many circulating themes. A chimera bioweapon myth, if you will. Integrating the <em>Daily Mail</em> reporting about biosafety warnings, the pick-up of Great Game India’s Canadian spies, the fresh preprint about supposed HIV sequences found, and the scientists he felt justified doxxing two days earlier, the blogger built an engaging storyline for his audience that included many of the prevailing themes and sentiments. The emotional truth of the narrative went along the lines of “Chinese scientists have ulterior motives; they wanted to create a bioweapon, but WIV was lacking biosafety, and it escaped.” True or not, it was a sentiment so powerful that it would never leave the conversation again in US right-wing ideological circles, and often beyond.</p><p>These were, of course, only a fraction of the early narratives bubbling up in various corners around the world. Nobody can accurately trace them all, figure out where exactly they all came from, or identify who was “patient zero” for their spread. The only thing that we can say for sure is that after the dramatic lockdown announcement in Wuhan brought global attention, a week of wild speculations, viral conspiracy theories, and crowd-sourced myth-making followed. Everybody wanted to talk about it and be seen talking about it. Within that week, the dynamics of our global interconnected information systems made sure that the unsubstantiated idea of a man-made virus would be broadcast all around the world. China might have wanted to control rumors and craft its heroic response narrative, but its mantle of silence did not extinguish the fire; it fueled the flames.</p><p>Aristotle famously claimed that nature abhors a vacuum. After spending way too much time on social media over the last few years, I became pretty convinced that, just as nature fears a void, the internet fears an information vacuum. Whether fiction or fact, truth or trickery, myth, magical thinking, or outright manipulation, whatever is offered has to be better than having to wait for information. This is human. Especially in times of ambiguity and dire peril, we tend to prioritize information speed over accuracy.</p><p>Consequences be damned.</p><p>Adapted from <em>Lab Leak Fever: The COVID-19 Origin Theory that Sabotaged Science and Society</em> by Philipp Markolin.Copyright © 2025 by Philipp Markolin. All rights reserved.</p><p>Continue reading <a href="https://www.protagonist-science.com/p/lab-leak-fever-chapter-2">chapter 3 here</a>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/700/0*fAMPKoyJqfzlU-Rq.png" /><figcaption>The inside story behind a viral origin hunt</figcaption></figure><p>Find more background info, chapter footnotes and video interviews at <a href="https://www.lab-leak-fever.com/">www.lab-leak-fever.com</a>. If you want a physical copy of the book, kindle ebook, or support my work, you can <a href="https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0FKNDRJ8Z">buy directly on Amazon</a>. (<em>for non-US readers, please check your regional Amazon such as </em><a href="https://www.amazon.com.br/Lab-Leak-Fever-COVID-19-sabotaged-ebook/dp/B0FKK9Q4D3/"><em>amazon.br</em></a><em> or </em><a href="https://www.amazon.in/Lab-Leak-Fever-COVID-19-sabotaged-ebook/dp/B0FKK9Q4D3"><em>amazon.in</em></a><em> as ebook prices may differ dramatically</em>)</p><p><strong>How did you feel about this chapter? Please let me know any feedback or comment below. Make sure to share.</strong></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=97e35d2d9065" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Chapter 1 — With the shadow hunters]]></title>
            <link>https://protagonist-science.medium.com/chapter-1-5ff7b04fd42a?source=rss-c8e0e038559d------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5ff7b04fd42a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[chapter-1]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[origin-of-sars-cov-2]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[lab-leak-fever]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Philipp Markolin]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 30 Jul 2025 08:20:24 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-08-30T09:07:45.604Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Chapter 1 — With the shadow hunters</h3><p><em>Adapted from Lab Leak Fever: The COVID-19 origin theory that sabotaged science and society</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*gaFO63kkKx2A-8idxvb5eg.png" /><figcaption>Note: This is a freely accessible serialized version of Lab Leak Fever. Find an <a href="https://www.protagonist-science.com/p/lab-leak-fever-serialized">overview of all chapters</a> here or consult the <a href="https://www.lab-leak-fever.com/">book website</a> for further information.</figcaption></figure><p>A disturbingly dry cough broke the silence of the Malaysian night; the pigs resting under the mango trees had been uneasy that day. Loud, whooping breaths filled the backyards of small farmhouses. Pig farming had been a family business in the villages of Bukit Pelandok and Sikamat, and for the Foochow Chinese, it was a source of pride and good income. While most Malay are Muslim and not permitted to touch pigs, for Mr. Yap, handling these animals would feed his family of five, the youngest just three years old. The pork supply chain had recently exploded into a huge industry in Malaysia, employing thousands and lifting many more out of poverty. Within the lush and dense green vegetation, small streets connected scattered farmhouses, and the many small pig operations that originally started in backyards kept expanding, requiring more space and cultivation of the land.</p><p>Mr. Yap’s days were humid and hot, but the nights were pleasant, and he would often sit outside until the tropical sunset. A brighter and more hopeful future lay ahead for the immigrant family. He had felt a bit tired the last few days, and then he developed a fever on that fateful Monday in March 1999. A week later, he fell into a mysterious coma, never to wake up again. He would not be the only one.</p><p>“My father died of Nipah virus,” Wee Chee revealed timidly. “So did my uncle.”</p><p>Mr. Yap’s then-three-year-old daughter was sitting in front of me 23 years later. She was tall with straight hair, and her large round glasses amplified her intelligent mocha eyes, exuding curiosity. She was a young researcher on her journey to earn a PhD in virology at one of the best labs in Singapore. “I don’t remember him; I was too young.” Her soft voice and casual tone were in stark contrast to the severity of the revelation about her father. I felt a bit uneasy interrogating her about the painful past, but I needed to understand what drove her to be out here with the other virus hunters.</p><p>“The authorities first thought it was Japanese encephalitis,” she explained, a virus transmitted by mosquitoes. The year before, after the first unusual encephalitis casualties in 1998, the pig farmers in Malaysia received vaccinations. Despite taking mosquito protection measures, the outbreak continued unabated, and the death toll skyrocketed. Something did not add up. Although some of the initial patients demonstrated cross-reactivity with Japanese encephalitis antibodies in serological assays, indicating their recent exposure to the virus, not all patients tested positive. Some would even get sick after being vaccinated against the Japanese encephalitis virus. These cases were attributed to an ineffective vaccine — something almost unheard of. Confused, the department heads were more concerned with confirming Japanese encephalitis through PCR tests rather than challenging their assumptions. In the meantime, the authorities would continue with their prevention measures, even telling the pig farmers it was safe to keep working. Wee Chee’s father trusted them despite knowing his pigs had died too.</p><p>However, Dr. Kaw Bing Chua, a tenacious local scientist had developed a hunch that it was a new virus that caused the disease, jumping over from pigs to farmers. With a subtle tone of admiration in her voice, Wee Chee briefly recounted his history. He would isolate the virus from the cerebrospinal fluid of patients and attempt to cultivate it not only in insect cell lines, as is indicated for the Japanese encephalitis virus, but also in human, canine, pig, and monkey cell lines available at the University Malaya Medical Center. He discovered that the isolated virus would not only grow in various cell lines but also show a cytopathic effect — the infected cells looked rugged and sick under a microscope, quite similar to syncytial virus infection, a respiratory pathogen. Excited, he raised the alarm, but his supervisor initially attributed his findings to contamination. He had to keep pushing. Time was working against them, as a new wave was killing more farmers. With the help of the CDC in the US, he eventually figured out that the suspected new virus was of the paramyxoviridae family.</p><p>“Paramyxoviridae,” a word that rolled off Wee Chee’s tongue easily. Even today, I mess up sometimes. It meant that the new virus, later named Nipah, was part of the same larger family as measles, mumps, and many parainfluenza cold viruses causing bronchitis or pneumonia. This insight had dramatic significance. The control measures against a paramyxovirus are completely different from the mosquito-transmitted Japanese encephalitis virus. The authorities had to switch tactics, which they did after a short review process.</p><p>Unfortunately, the necessary policy change would come too late for Mr. Yap, who was infected just two days prior to that recognition. Two freaking days. A sinking feeling entered my gut. “If actions would have followed immediately…” Wee Chee ended her thought mid-sentence. I understood. Nothing was to be gained from what-ifs anymore. The history of emergent diseases is often one of cruel timing and unlucky circumstances. Mr. Yap was among the last of the farmers to become infected before the pigs were finally identified as the intermediate culprits spreading the disease to humans. Pig farms were shut down, over a million pigs were culled, and a half-billion-dollar industry crashed overnight. While “what happened” was eventually figured out and the outbreak stopped, the victims and impacted families were often left with no answer as to “why did it happen?”. Why did Nipah appear in Malaysian pigs, and when and where did it appear? Why did nobody see it coming? And, perhaps most crucially, could it happen again?</p><p>Disease outbreaks are almost always shrouded in mysteries and uncertainties. The true origin story and transmission route of the Nipah virus, a pathogen that can lurk in fruit for days, was only worked out conclusively years later. Leading the effort were the talented scientific teams of Dr. Linfa Wang from Duke-NUS Medical School in Singapore and non-profit organization EcoHealth Alliance, headed by the zoologist Peter Daszak. This was a whole decade before their research into pandemic outbreaks would become controversial. It was long before the global spotlight fell on them and their close collaborator Shi Zhengli from the Wuhan Institute of Virology (WIV). Back then, they had found that pig farms had not only extended into local fruit bat territory, but also the plantation of fruit carrying trees like Mango trees around the farms had attracted bats. While feasting, some of the bats ended up contaminating the tree fruits with their saliva full of Nipah virus. Their leftovers or half-eaten pieces would fall to the ground, where they would remain infectious for days. Some of these contaminated fruits were snuffed up and eaten by the pigs.</p><p>Given the factory farming environment, the unlucky farm animals would become infected, even intermediate reservoirs of Nipah. Usually, such an outbreak in animals would burn itself out. Adult pigs would be culled, die off, or gradually develop immunity. Yet Peter Daszak’s team could show through epidemiological modeling that it was the young piglets, coupled with the rapid breeding and selling practices of farmers, that provided fresh immune-naive hosts to sustain the outbreak. Protected by Nipah antibodies from their immune mother sows while being raised, the moment these piglets got weaned off to be sold to other farms, they could become infected by Nipah. The Foochow farmers, who bought those piglets to raise them for their backyard businesses, would gradually spread the outbreak to other provinces. Like Mr. Yap, most of them would eventually contract the infection, and four out of ten would meet an untimely demise. Over a hundred farmers died in the Malaysian Nipah outbreak, and, over the course of nine months, the disease had spread all the way to neighboring Singapore.</p><p>While a scientific explanation can provide closure, the threat is far from gone. Wee Chee was here with Linfa Wang’s team. Today, the Nipah virus is monitored in multiple countries in Southeast Asia where <em>Pteropus</em> fruit bats, also known as flying foxes, roost. The virus’s persistent danger and high case fatality rate (40–70%) have led to its classification as a Biosafety Level 4 pathogen. With good reason. Since 1998 and 1999 in Malaysia, several Nipah outbreaks have occurred in India and Bangladesh, with the majority caused by direct zoonotic spillovers from infected bat reservoirs to humans via contaminated fruits or tree sap. In 2011, 35 out of 40 infected people died after drinking contaminated palm tree sap (imagine something akin to maple syrup), which resulted in a local ban on fresh sap. But enforcement has been difficult to this day. Many Bangladeshi villagers, who are Muslim and don’t drink alcohol, prefer drinking the fresh sap over the safer fermented wine.</p><p>Education has been identified as a barrier to prevention, with only about 5% of villagers ever hearing about the Nipah virus and only 1 in 3 saying they are aware that raw sap can transmit diseases. But education is not the only barrier. A study showed that even villagers who had heard about the risk of raw sap were just as likely to drink sap as those who were not aware of the potential danger. Despite the deadly precedents, the threat just does not seem real enough to local residents to change their behavior. As outsiders, we are often quick to condemn, or we might shake our heads in incredulity. But as a science communicator, this did not surprise me. It is not uncommon for cultural practices and lived experiences to trump abstract scientific knowledge. It’s the norm everywhere around the world. It’s a human universal that needs constant efforts from scientists to counterbalance.</p><p>Unfortunately, the rift between scientific knowledge and societal actions means that Nipah’s story is not over. Researchers learning about its existence, where it lingers, and how it spreads is a necessary first step, yet it is unlikely to spell the end of its lethal trajectory. Wee Chee was not optimistic. Some other virologists worry the regular local outbreaks could just be Nipah’s first act, a warming up of something much, much worse to come. Maybe a warning shot like SARS was for COVID-19. The more opportunities we give our viral adversaries to try and adapt to us and our farmed animals, the more likely calamity becomes. Constant monitoring, educational efforts in communities, and new solutions are required to tackle these perpetual risks. Yet our attention wavers and life moves on. After more than a decade of reduced activity following the spillover, the pig farming industry is now back in full swing in Malaysia. The Nipah outbreak, if not forgotten, is little more than a cautionary, distant memory for most Malaysians. Its only remaining digital footprints are a Wikipedia page and a few dated publications.</p><p>We humans are often very set in our ways, even if, theoretically, we know better. I believe that compassion often gets lost between the idiosyncrasies of lived culture and the detached nature of scientific analysis. Compassion is what motivates lasting behavioral change. We owe it to those who paid the bitter price of figuring it out the hard way. Maybe there is also some concern for our future selves, which we tend to set up for unnecessary failure tomorrow. Once we care, action becomes a necessity. We cannot help it. Change becomes inevitable. That’s at least what drove Wee Chee.</p><p>“What really gets me is that even at university, Nipah is just one of those viruses you learn for an exam and forget about briefly after, you know?” Her voice was slightly trembling toward the end of the sentence. The pressure of my probing was finally getting to her. Talking about science in the abstract was one thing; talking about her life was quite another. The otherwise composed research assistant lifted her oversized round glasses to wipe away some tears. She had trouble dealing with the lack of attention and compassion for the topic. To her, Nipah was not just a historical anecdote, a schoolbook entry, or a mere scientific statistic. It had ripped apart her family, made her move away from the countryside to her grandmother’s, made her question why her mother kept crying and made her wonder why they were not allowed to play with the pigs anymore. She had no recollection of her father, having been so young when he passed. “I only found out that it was Nipah when I was 12,” she remembered. Her mother’s explanations about Japanese encephalitis did not make sense to her because what did this mosquito virus have to do with pigs? “So, I actually googled what happened and found out it was Nipah virus.” Her curiosity would put her on a path to study biology, followed by a job in an industry working with stem cells. Despite the tragic past, her future looked rosier.</p><p>Yet when the COVID pandemic hit, she felt herself at a crossroads. “I just had to do something,” she confessed. At the time, she was sharing a flat with multiple other young adults who did not have a science background. Their confusion, worries, and asking for her input to navigate a new virus made her realize she had something more to offer; it awakened a dormant desire in her. She describes it as an unavoidable “obligation” imposed on her to “reduce future outbreaks.” While she confided in me, her eyes peeked into the distance. Or the past. I was not sure. It was clear to me that losing someone dear to an unknown virus is something she did not wish on anybody. That’s why she needed to act.</p><p>But how was she to go about it? One day, while listening to the niche podcast <em>This Week in Virology</em>, she heard about Linfa Wang’s work on bat immunology, and everything clicked. That was what she needed to do. She quit her job in the middle of the pandemic and took a position as a research assistant at Linfa Wang’s lab in Singapore “to help however I could.” Among many things, Linfa Wang’s lab was building a tech platform that will allow the rapid serological testing of a range of bat viruses, especially coronaviruses like SARS, MERS, and SARS-CoV-2, and henipaviruses like Hendra and Nipah. If serological tests like these had existed 25 years ago, when Wee Chee was a child, the initial confusion and PCR misdiagnosis of Japanese encephalitis that stalled real action for months might have been avoided. At least technically, that is.</p><p>One of the lessons I kept re-learning the last few years is that during a crisis, we humans have a reduced capacity to deal with uncertainty. We long for an explanation, any explanation, no matter how at odds with the evidence. We rush to judgment and often stick with it, as had been the case with ineffective measures against Japanese encephalitis. It is difficult to change entrenched beliefs. Wee Chee lamented that, even now, more often than not, her own mother would still conflate or misattribute her husband’s demise to Japanese encephalitis.</p><p>Understandable, given what her mother had been told repeatedly at the time. Scientists eventually figured out that it was a different virus, which made no difference to her mother’s tragedy; the name Nipah was a mostly irrelevant detail to her. Like the raw sap drinking Bangladeshi villagers, lived memory is just more visceral than abstract scientific knowledge. It’s the norm. It is human. It makes sense.</p><p>Of course, the problem arises when that abstract scientific knowledge becomes relevant again. Those who forget history are bound to repeat it. I shuddered at the thought.</p><p>I met Wee Chee on a field sampling trip in Chonburi, Thailand. A magnificent bat colony of at least ten thousand <em>Pteropus</em> fruit bats, or flying foxes, has nested in the trees around picturesque Wat Luang Phrommawat, a Buddhist temple. Sittiwatt, the head monk who protects the colony and manages the temple, explained to us that the bats had been there for at least 300 years, dating back to when the temple was first built. He had started to thin out the trees and plant them on the other side of the small creek next to the temple, reducing the risk of getting hit by excretions while strolling under the branches. I knew that the very deadly Bangladesh variant of Nipah can also directly infect humans if one is unlucky enough to get contaminated liquids like urine in the eyes, nose, or mouth. Wait, why was I walking haphazardly under those Thai flying fox colonies again?</p><p>“Don’t look up when you are below”</p><p>Peter Daszak urged me from the side. I pulled my protective hat, glasses, and masks closer over my face, probably looking odd given that Sittiwatt and the other monks walk under those trees every day with their shaved heads, bare feet, and orange Buddhist robes.</p><p>The zoologist Peter Daszak has become a controversial figure and household name in many conspiratorial circles, from online message boards, Substack blogs, and right-wing tabloids all the way to the pages of <em>The Wall Street Journal</em>, <em>The Washington Post,</em> and the halls of the US Congress. Many believe he is at the center of an elaborate cover-up conspiracy that ultimately puts the blame for the pandemic on him, his organization EcoHealth Alliance, and their Chinese collaborators at WIV in China. What does he know? What might he be hiding? Trained scientists like myself tend to prefer hard evidence over speculation; we avoid or even shy away from giving weight to the ambivalence, messiness, and uncertainty of human motivations and actions. In any scientific investigation, human idiosyncrasies often make it difficult to assert matters with confidence.</p><p>However, after almost two years of chasing answers to the origin of SARS-CoV-2, Peter Daszak was among the last promising avenues of investigation left for me: the big unknown. He embodied a human uncertainty that I needed to narrow as much as I could now that I had the opportunity. This, I told myself, is how the scientific process is supposed to work, after all. A constant strife to reduce uncertainty as much as possible, but not more than is warranted. His circumstances did not make my work easy, though.</p><p>I first met Peter Daszak a few days prior at Zurich Airport. He snuck up on me and opened with a clumsy joke about my lack of situational awareness. Immediately, he wanted to get me in on a game to figure out who the “sound guy” was, the third group member flying from Zurich on our trip to Thailand. He pointed to a few random passengers at the terminal with a half-stretched thumb, a little less obvious than finger-pointing but still pretty impolite for Swiss standards. “That’s how they point in Thailand,” he explained as if that somehow made it better.</p><p>Peter was wearing mostly unremarkable clothes: a shirt with some silvery or blond chest hair just peeking beyond, and a bit of a higher voice pitch for a man his size and age than I would have presumed. We started chatting all over the place, but also somewhat right to the point about how crazy things have gotten. He wanted to take a selfie with me by his side. I declined. Yet this was a feeling I got from most of what he was saying: he was trying to create a connection, any connection, between strangers. He had been fighting alone for quite some time.</p><p>“My wife follows you on Twitter,” he assured me more than once. Words just kept flowing from him. As if haunted. I was trying to decide if he wanted company, if he wanted to win me over, or if he was trying to entertain, impress, or just enjoy himself. He’d probably contest that it was just his open and confident charm. In general, he contested a lot.</p><p>The reality was probably somewhere in the middle. He can be a bit of a character. As far as first impressions go, it was pretty modest. He was entertaining but did not seem very humble, contrary to what I would have expected from a scientist. Often, he was not shy with words and strong opinions. My first instinct was to be guarded, keep listening, and let him do the talking. He was clearly restless. Pacing. He informed me how he had already “wasted hours” on the flight from the US to Zurich, redacting irrelevant details in “FOIA” emails sent between the NIH (US National Institute of Health) and his organization, EcoHealth Alliance, a non-profit that grew out of the wildlife trust. FOIA stands for Freedom of Information Act, a law US citizens can use to obtain information, such as emails from federal agencies and employees, in the name of transparency and democratic accountability. A noble and important tool that can, unfortunately, be abused as well. For Peter, being FOIA’d mostly meant sifting through endless paperwork and redacting personal information, such as phone numbers, addresses, or irrelevant personal stuff, about other people in his communications with the NIH. He knew that his appearance before the GOP House Committee at the end of 2022 was only a matter of time. A politically motivated witch hunt was coming. His head would be desired next in line after Anthony Fauci, the former head of NIAID (US National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases) and presidential advisor, along with a list of other independent scientists, all being targeted and subsumed by the same energy that was driving outrage in social networks. What started with anti-scientific conspiracy myths online, spread by anonymous accounts on social media and amplified by clandestine disinformation campaigns, tabloid journalism, cynical influencers, and other media manipulators, has eventually mutated into real-life ramifications for many scientists.</p><p>I asked him how he dealt with what happened to him, not sure what to expect in an answer. He tried to play it cool, joking about the time these people waste creating elaborate fantasies or the work they put into making comics or memes about him. He had even “collected their best art pieces,” assuring me he was handling it okay and making fun of them. But there was also something haunted about his responses and, sporadically, a not-so-subtle anger. “Sometimes, I’d like to meet and smack them,” he offered once on this recurring theme of what to do about his often-anonymous tormentors as if he had reached the limits of his patience. He would not be the only one. Nobody really knows how to deal with so much weaponized hatred.</p><p>After a split moment of vulnerability, Peter was back to being a bit of an entertainer, telling me about how he tries to mess with the most abusive harassers but without much success. The danger is, however, all too present. Some of them doxxed — released private information to harass or intimidate — his family, work connections, and every move. One of them had just recently spread private information about his daughter, her college attendance, and what courses she takes, together with a picture of her. They all are on death lists, posted publicly. His daughter, who is 21 years old, is now targeted and put in harm’s way just by sheer fact of sharing the family name. Peter and his family had to get security for their house in New York once online stalkers and harassers started posting their home addresses, together with allegations of him being a mass murderer, responsible for the pandemic, and involved in the COVID cover-up. While many scientists, not just Peter, have been sent credible death threats, few have had a constant siege around their houses. Letters with unidentified white powder substances have been sent to his home and his place of work. Calls at night to disrupt his sleep. The FBI informs him regularly about his name appearing on death lists of groups classified as domestic terrorist threats.</p><p>Fomenting online hate campaigns against individuals is a common tactic of information combatants — public discourse manipulators ranging from anonymous trolls and fringe scientists to influencers, foreign agents, activists, and even journalists and politicians — on social media platforms because of the asymmetric cost they incur on their opponents. Putting out hateful lies is cheap and easy, yet defusing the situation for those targeted is not. This is especially true when emotional accusations about having created the pandemic and of being responsible for the deaths of millions are leveraged for attention. These accusations put the lives of scientists at stake. Experts would classify such hate campaigns against individuals as a form of “stochastic terrorism.” Putting a mark on somebody’s back with emotionally charged lies and repeated falsehoods runs the predictable risk that some consumers of those lies might believe them and become radicalized to act on these accusations. A few do. However, the overall goal of these communication tactics is not necessarily to harm but to silence. His politically unwelcome voice needed to go away. “They want me to turn radioactive,” Peter told me. He was mostly correct, but it would turn out much more sinister than he could ever imagine.</p><p>“The worst part is they succeeded. I am posting way less on Twitter, and I almost don’t travel anymore,” he lamented. Due to all the FOIA and congressional requests, he cannot get his normal work done. “They even petitioned to have me kicked off every committee and scientific society.” Even respectable colleagues had disinvited him from speaking because of the fear of controversy. Few in the US wanted to be exposed to the potential harassment his presence could bring. He has lost funding, and his organization, EcoHealth Alliance, is fighting against lawmakers in the US Congress for its existence. Maybe that’s why he preferred to go to rural Asia, where the temperature of origin discussion had a cooler, more scientifically nuanced tone. It certainly would be a welcome respite from the constant harassment for him.</p><p>A few days later, back in Thailand with me, the head monk Sittiwatt led us into the restricted and closed-off Wat Luang Phrommawat shrine. Peter would get a selfie of us to send to his wife. He and the weird science blogger who wanted to learn what he had been up to. Alright, I gave in under the condition that it was not to be spread beyond that. I had no interest in becoming collateral damage in the hate campaigns against him just yet. It would be inevitable soon enough.</p><p>My intuition proved correct. When Peter had snapped photos of me and others in full protective gear exploring a different bat cave at five in the morning that day and uploaded them on Twitter to explain this type of fieldwork, all hell would break lose. Social media can be a boon for direct science communication from the field, a brilliant thing that can bring science and society closer. But not when you’re radioactive. Within 24 hours, my figure ended up on the pages of both the <em>New York Post</em> and <em>Daily Mail</em>, two tabloid newspapers, with my identity luckily unrecognized behind the full protective gear I wore. The tabloids’ non-stories were about how Peter Daszak dared to post “brazen photos of himself” in the bat cave after doing work that allegedly started the pandemic. When it came to substance, that was it. These articles were basically what digital natives call “outrage bait,” a good opportunity for the newspapers to rehash a bunch of engaging conspiratorial talking points, provoke some outrage, and make sure the attention does not drop on the topic. That is what the attention economy rewards, after all — an effortless story that one can copy and paste together quickly to reap clicks and engagements. A suspicious picture of bats, a sensationalist headline, an antagonist with name recognition, and a well-known trope are all that are really necessary to go viral on social media. And viral it went, with two US Senators angrily commenting on the record about this type of work as a “smoke and mirror operation” from somebody who might have caused the pandemic. What a mess. It was a waste of everyone’s time and a poor reflection on the so-called “journalists” involved.</p><p>Nuanced scientific information about the benefits of this work can never compete in this information environment, I thought while observing about two dozen field workers. They were busy setting up impromptu field labs, raising nets between the trees, and carefully capturing flying foxes. No tabloid would ever write an article about this.</p><p>It is hard work. Everybody had to wear N95 masks, hair nets, nitrile gloves, and large white polyethylene coveralls in the scorching heat. I had spent the day strolling around, watching both clockwork military discipline as well as the careful treatment of sensitive equipment and captured animals. The Forestry Department scientists, together with virology students, research assistants, and their supervisors, had set up a field lab, which was, in essence, three small kitchen tables under a roof. After being caught by nets, the flying foxes would be transferred into loose cotton bags and hung on a long bar next to the field lab for subsequent processing. Each station would perform a sequence of steps, from measuring the captured animals’ size, wingspan, and weight to taking stool, urine, and blood samples. More recently, they also started taking wing clips, small tissue samples from the bat’s wing, to try to establish primary bat tissue cultures. This would be a way to explore some biological and immunological questions that scientists have not yet wrapped their heads around. On average, each animal went through the ordeal in less than ten minutes, received some fruit juice and banana pieces as a reward, and was subsequently released back into the trees, to fly back to their colony. The laborious hours dragged on until dusk when the flying foxes would prepare for their fly-off.</p><p>The buzzing of the trees became a cascade of noise, excitement, and conflict. It is not clear who gives the start signal. Like a hive mind, at some point, a collective decision is made, and thousands of animals leave in concert into the unknown of the night. Standing under and listening to the buzz is a humbling experience, an homage to the brilliance and vastness of nature. Not wanting to look up when directly below, I made my way to a little visiting tower with a roof on top, where tourists could safely watch the nightly flyout.</p><p>While watching the bat colony take flight, several thoughts came to me. Are we socially interconnected humans so different? How do we aggregate and make certain topics go viral? Is it a collective decision or one made by a select few? My thoughts trailed off.</p><p>Later that night, after spending a whole day walking in their shadow, I finally got to ask about the disease prevalence in these fruit bats again.</p><p>“Oh, about 1–2% of those bats [now] actively carry Nipah,” Supaporn Wacharapluesadee let us know; it was not her first field trip to this specific colony. I gulped. Certainly tempted by the lightly dressed monks all day, I was happy that, following Peter’s advice, I did not remove my mask, glasses, or hat despite the heat. She continued, “But no Nipah antibodies in pigs anywhere yet.” Years ago, they implemented prevention measures against Nipah spillovers. The slim and timid-looking Thai scientist was very precise in her language. She was a scientific icon to many, the first one to sequence SARS-CoV-2 outside of China, as well as a virus hunter and discoverer of many novel bat viruses, including SARS1 and 2-related coronaviruses. Before that, she had made a name for herself by studying and surveilling the Nipah virus for almost two decades — work that still continues. She and others had identified Nipah as one of the viruses with the highest risk of spillover to humans, causing devastating outbreaks. After all, Nipah has done so in the past, continues to cause local spillovers today, and might wreak unspeakable havoc in the future. Supaporn is intent on not letting it happen; that’s why she is training all these young scientists, including collaborators from Singapore like Wee Chee, to perform this essential surveillance work. We need the next generation of scientists to be equipped for what is coming.</p><p>I quite appreciated Supaporn taking us all out to dinner now that the night had set in. Her golden-rimmed glasses shone in the modest light from the streetside restaurant we sat down in. I’d been wanting to talk to her all day. Earlier, we had driven for four hours in a van together to get to Chonburi, and she had barely spoken two sentences on the trip. “When I was young, I was not a communicative person, so working in the lab, there was no need to talk to anyone. I thought being a technician was the best job for me,” she once admitted in an interview with the journal <em>Science</em>. She was very pensive and clearly did not need to be the center of attention. Eventually, she warmed up and conversed with us as she served everyone an incredibly spicy Thai soup. She even displayed a mischievous hint of a smile towards Peter and me, unless my watering eyes were playing a trick on me. I hastily grabbed my drink and some rice. To think I’d do well with spicy food, even in Thailand, was naive. Wee Chee laughed openly at my misery. Eventually, I decided to stay with the rice dish.</p><p>In contrast to Supaporn’s food taste, her mild-mannered, unpresumptuous, nurturing demeanor, even when collaborating with students from Singapore, was quite endearing. She would insist on ordering and serving everybody else’s food and drinks first — a cultural norm for her that we respected despite it feeling unusual for us — after a long, exhausting day of stressful field sampling that must have taken a toll on her, too. Jokes were exchanged, and old anecdotes were recalled as if we were at a long-awaited reunion with friends. Evenings like these also embody a certain beauty within the scientific enterprise: its ability to bring people together from all over the world, even in difficult times.</p><p>Make no mistake; the times have become difficult for virus hunters. Supaporn has been collaborating with Peter Daszak and Ecohealth Alliance since 2009, dedicated to tackling potential pandemic pathogens at their place of origin, where they spill over into humans at often complex human-animal interfaces. The US Agency for International Development (USAID)-sponsored PREDICT program was established to identify new emerging infectious diseases that could become a threat to human health in geographic hot spots all over the world, including countries like Thailand, Bangladesh, and China. While PREDICT ended in 2020, it included efforts and training similar to the one I visited today. Scientists collect swabs or other samples in the field from animals and humans, and then they analyze the samples in the lab to look for evidence of disease, gaining insights about what pathogens are out there, how they evolve, and how often they spill over into humans.</p><p>However, since the pandemic, this type of work has become seen by some as misguided, pricey, and possibly dangerous. Some influential activists have attributed the pandemic to the PREDICT work performed by Peter Daszak and a network of regional collaborators, including Supaporn as well as Shi Zhengli from WIV at the heart of the pandemic. It was one of many mutually contradictory theories about how scientists might be culpable for the misery of the past years. From bioweapon research to gain-of-function experiments or unorthodox culturing methods to just trying to identify viral threats in the wild, everything and anything virologists might reasonably study about coronaviruses was made to sound suspicious, dangerous, and unnecessary.</p><p>Even virus surveillance has been made a target. In 2023, the USAID canceled a virus discovery grant named DEEP VZN after an influence campaign by biotechnology fearmongers reached all the way to the Biden White House. This was a program the USAID had deemed essential for pandemic prevention just two years earlier before virus hunting became controversial as well. For Supaporn, her coronavirus work has since led to a fallout with her boss, the head of her previous institute at King Chulalongkorn Memorial Hospital in Bangkok. Despite being a trained physician, her boss was a strong believer that SARS-CoV-2 was engineered and leaked from a Chinese lab, that the mRNA vaccines cause harm, that ivermectin works against COVID-19, that the media was suppressing the truth. He was not taking no for an answer. Everyone is familiar with this type of conspiratorial person by now. Suddenly, Supaporn found herself without a lab, equipment, or trained technicians. He had also alleged, without evidence, that she siphoned off and misappropriated grant money for her “risky” research, but Supaporn was completely exonerated by an internal investigation. Eventually, she managed to keep her professorship at the Memorial Hospital, changing institutes, and now works for its Clinical Center with a new lab and team.</p><p>To us, she was shrugging her shoulders and rolling her eyes at what she called “politics.” She still respects her former department head’s work, and that was all she had to say about him and this stressful episode. Some claim her former boss was jealous of the international recognition and fame this timid woman received for her coronavirus work. It would not be surprising. Our documentary was not the first she participated in; <em>Channel News Asia</em> did a long segment about her work in 2020 that catapulted her to the spotlight. Even within science, such media attention can hurt egos and drive quite nasty conflicts. I lean toward this explanation. In my experience, behind every successful woman, there is no shortage of lesser men with a grudge trying to denigrate her accomplishments and drag her down. The international and geopolitical spotlight on researchers like her or Peter can be a double-edged sword. Even the Thai government has made it difficult for her to publish new coronavirus sequences for fear of becoming the focus of the origin controversy from what I gathered.</p><p>Over the years, I’ve come in contact with many renowned academics and researchers who worked on the COVID-19 origin topic and became targets of opportunists, activists, conspiracy theorists, and governments alike. Many of them saw their expertise discredited, their funding withdrawn, their work forbidden, or their safety threatened. Currently, resources for virus discovery and surveillance have been cut globally, while international cooperation, especially with China, has dried up because of geopolitics. Many bat scientists in authoritarian countries, including China, Laos, Thailand, Vietnam, Myanmar, and even Malaysia, are under heightened pressure and scrutiny. On top of that, governments, institutions, funders, and NGOs (non-governmental organizations) everywhere seem to have lost interest in public health and abdicated their responsibilities to act to prevent the next pandemic. China even pulled out of previous commitments for wildlife and wet market surveillance and loosened its laws against this industry again. We are moving in the wrong direction and show no signs of changing course.</p><p>Despite the current obstacles, Supaporn does not allow herself to give up. If not her, who else would carry out the crucial work that needs to be done? Who will surveil the humans and animals at these spillover hotspots and study which pathogens are out there, waiting for their chance? Isn’t anticipating what might be coming next the first necessary step if we want a chance to control outbreaks? There is no question that another pandemic will come, even if most of us would rather put aside the unwelcome reality. The work of Supaporn and many other researchers in the region, no matter if funded by the Institut Pasteur, the UN, or EcoHealth Alliance, is directly related to reducing both the frequency and severity of outbreaks. Their effort lies in stopping as many of them as possible in their tracks before they turn into a major public health crisis. Given our current trajectory of failing to learn the lessons of COVID-19, another pandemic is likely within the next decade, as many experts I interviewed now fear. After spending years listening, learning, and trying to understand our current conundrums, I share their worry. We are squandering valuable time and sabotaging our future.</p><p>A few months after our trip, I caught up with Wee Chee. The compassionate research assistant has had struggles on her own. She has not yet managed to get into a PhD program in virology in Singapore because there are just too few positions, too little interest, and not enough money. Acquiring the necessary scientific funding for a multi-year PhD project is a struggle worldwide, but for her, the pandemic has not made it easier, but harder. Highly unusual. After devastating outbreaks, we would traditionally see an influx of young and brilliant minds going into medicine or science, which would push the whole field forward. Now we seem intent on cutting off the legs of the next generation of researchers.</p><p>Wee Chee remained focused on her work. We talked shortly before the Chinese New Year holiday. While others might have prepared for being on vacation, she had been in Vietnam “capacity building” in a collaborating lab. This meant that she would travel there on a very modest budget, often without comfortable housing, yet stay to work ten or even twelve hours a day, teaching local students how to perform more complex experiments. For example, she would teach them how to use the neutralization assay Linfa Wang’s lab developed to monitor bat viruses. Work was challenging, she admitted, but she would still try to find time to go home and visit her family in Malaysia. She just needed to get the work done first. For all of its importance, the lived reality of her day-to-day research boiled down to demanding, often dreary, and always piecemeal work and effort. Unrewarding for most people, yet, like many young scientists, she was driven by her idealism and the hope of contributing a tiny puzzle piece to the larger whole of pandemic anticipation and prevention.</p><p>In the end, that hope, coupled with a sense of obligation and compassion, is what all the virus hunters and virologists I met have in common. There is a need to understand not just the “how” but also the “why” of outbreaks. That’s the reason they gear up and venture out into the unknown. They are playing the long game against an untold number of faceless opponents that are versatile, deadly, and ever-changing.</p><p>And while often a lonely and frustrating endeavor, not a single virus hunter expected that during a global pandemic, their formidable viral adversaries would somehow find a way to have society blame scientists instead. How the hell did we get here?</p><p>Adapted from <em>Lab Leak Fever: The COVID-19 Origin Theory that Sabotaged Science and Society</em> by Philipp Markolin.Copyright © 2025 by Philipp Markolin. All rights reserved.</p><p>Continue reading <a href="https://protagonist-science.medium.com/chapter-2-early-drums-of-war-97e35d2d9065">chapter 2 here</a>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*X9iM1CaSmurBQhFMXDw1qA.png" /><figcaption>The inside story behind a viral origin hunt</figcaption></figure><p>Find more background info, chapter footnotes and video interviews at <a href="https://www.lab-leak-fever.com/">www.lab-leak-fever.com</a>. If you want a physical copy of the book, kindle ebook, or support my work, you can <a href="https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0FKNDRJ8Z">buy directly on Amazon</a>. (<em>for non-US readers, please check your regional Amazon such as </em><a href="https://www.amazon.com.br/Lab-Leak-Fever-COVID-19-sabotaged-ebook/dp/B0FKK9Q4D3/"><em>amazon.br</em></a><em> or </em><a href="https://www.amazon.in/Lab-Leak-Fever-COVID-19-sabotaged-ebook/dp/B0FKK9Q4D3"><em>amazon.in</em></a><em> as ebook prices may differ dramatically</em>)</p><p><strong>How did you feel about this chapter? Please let me know any feedback or comment below. Make sure to share.</strong></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5ff7b04fd42a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Exclusive: Inside the WHO mission to Wuhan]]></title>
            <link>https://protagonist-science.medium.com/exclusive-inside-the-who-mission-to-wuhan-41c7b738dea8?source=rss-c8e0e038559d------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/41c7b738dea8</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[wuhan]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[world-health-organization]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[covid-origin]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Philipp Markolin]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 21 Apr 2025 20:15:01 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-04-21T20:15:01.352Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>An exclusive excerpt from “Lab Leak Fever”, the inside story behind the search for the origins of SARS-CoV-2 and the manipulation campaigns around it</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*1JD3ggmX-I44oycr.png" /><figcaption><strong>Jade Boutique Hotel, January 2021, Wuhan</strong>. Each international member of the WHO mission was quarantined for two weeks and tested twice a day for COVID-19. Mobile phone footage © Peter Daszak. Screen capture from documentary movie “<a href="https://www.screendaily.com/reviews/blame-review-three-covid-19-scientists-fall-victim-to-truth-twisting-narratives/5203315.article">Blame — bats, politics and a world out of balance</a>”</figcaption></figure><p>Last time, I <a href="https://www.protagonist-science.com/p/exclusive-the-inside-story-behind">revealed the inside story of Chinese scientists in Wuhan</a> racing to understand the new virus that started overwhelming the city; and how the bioweapon myth started through inauthentic amplification of a Hong Kong postdoc by Steve Bannon and Miles Guo’s media operation, which ended up fueling a billion dollar fraud scheme. This sum was calculated by the <em>US District Court, Southern District of New York</em>. Due to worries about retaliation, we can currently not go deeper into the mechanism, motivations and malice of their story described in my investigative book, released on the 20th April only in Germany, Austria and Switzerland. (<em>German readers, you are in for a wild ride! </em><a href="https://www.amazon.de/Das-Laborfieber-Ursprungstheorie-Wissenschaft-Gesellschaft-ebook/dp/B0F3DMHBSB"><em>Get the ebook</em></a><em> or paperback [link coming soon]</em>)</p><p>I wished publication circumstances had been easier, the book should have been out already in the US but the publisher deemed it too risky after the election and the return to power of many antagonists whose manipulative actions the book exposes, and that very much includes Steve Bannon and Miles Guo.</p><p>For now, English speakers can find a <a href="https://bigthink.com/starts-with-a-bang/covid-19-origin-chinese-lab/"><strong>longer Q&amp;A with me in <em>BigThink</em></strong></a> about the book and what it is all about. I will also make myself more available for <strong>live Q&amp;A sessions</strong> in the near future.</p><p>I always strongly believed that citizens should have access to good information. While I currently can not release the full story here about how bad actors brought about the vibe shift in the origin’s discourse, at least I wanted to take you <strong>inside the WHO mission to Wuhan in 2021 </strong>that I reconstructed by interviewing several members of the international team.</p><p>They lend me their eyes and ears so I can share their story with you:</p><h3>Chapter 6: The Vibe Shift</h3><blockquote><em>“I thought to myself, you could not script a better place to have an outbreak”</em></blockquote><blockquote><strong>Dominic Dwyer</strong>, University of Sidney and member of the WHO mission to Wuhan</blockquote><blockquote><em>“That is the missing piece; they could have traced the animals…</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>Why did they step away from following up on that?”</em></blockquote><blockquote><strong>Marion Koopmans</strong>, Erasmus University Medical Center and member of the WHO mission to Wuhan</blockquote><blockquote><em>“If people trust, they trust. If they don’t trust, they don’t…</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>So we just do our job and leave everything on the side… to the times.”</em></blockquote><blockquote><strong>Shi Zhengli</strong>, Wuhan Institute of Virology</blockquote><p>Heavy breaths followed a claustrophobic chase around the hotel room. Peter Daszak was doing his workout run from the showers through the bedroom to the antechamber and back, again and again and again. The Chinese hosts in Wuhan had placed him in quarantine for two weeks, and the pressure, isolation, and restrictions were difficult to deal with at times. He was an outdoor person. Twice daily, a team in full hazmat gear would knock on his door to take his temperature. “It really makes you feel dirty. Contagious,” he remembered thinking. He was not the only one.</p><p>Marion Koopmans was two rooms away. “It was amazing; they were so strict. I really thought, ‘Okay, this is how plague victims must have felt.’ You really felt like contaminated waste, almost.” She showed me photos she’d taken at the time. “It’s dystopia; they have made a plastic corridor for us.” Plastic sheeting completely covered the hallway from top to bottom. They were sampled as per instructions: 5-second swabs and not a millisecond less. Everyone was suited up except them. Warning signs and restriction bands were everywhere. China had been COVID-free for months. She just hoped she would not get a fever from anything else because it was not clear what would happen if she did. And yet, they, along with eight other international experts, were finally there, where it all happened. “We had been asked before to be quiet about where we would go before,” she laughed, “then we landed in China and had an escort everywhere and a charade of media following us.”</p><p>Peter Daszak and Marion Koopmans were two obvious scientists to reach out to when the WHO was assembling a mission to Wuhan in January 2021. Peter, the British zoologist, and head of the non-profit EcoHealth Alliance, had worked for decades on understanding viral spillover from bats, identified the origin of SARS with Shi Zhengli from WIV, and worked together with various emergent disease collaborators all over the world. He would be on the WHO’s animal and environment working group, trying to make sense of what happened at the Huanan market.</p><blockquote>I did not particularly want to serve. It irritated me. My big grant was canceled by Trump, and we went through months and months of misery. And I thought, “Why the hell should I help WHO? Doing the work that we should be doing for them?” That just seemed cruel, and then I am asked to volunteer for them?</blockquote><p>On the phone, he told Peter Karim Ben Embarek, who had assembled the mission, that he didn’t want to do it. On top of that, his participation would invite terrible political attacks on the WHO. Embarek just replied, “What’s new?” The WHO has been under attack on a daily basis; he naively believed it wouldn’t matter. Then, the WHO mission chief reiterated the enormous significance this work would have for the world. After some back and forth, Peter said that he would be available to the group, but he did not want to do fieldwork. “Ben said okay, but he did not take this as an answer; he kind of treated me like I was on the team.” Peter shrugged at how he ended up on the mission. The WHO team knew what they were doing and why they wanted him. “They wanted access to Chinese scientists, not just [because of] the lab issue, but because George Gao and the Wuhan Institute of Virology were investigating the outbreak… so the WHO needed somebody close to them.” Reports suggested that Beijing had indicated he would be a good person to have on the team. As best I can tell from Embarek’s comments, the suggestion came from Shi Zhengli herself. “It’s obvious if you got a researcher who you’ve been working with for 20 years who has not ripped you off, who had been honest with them,” Peter explained the likely rationale. It is worth retelling how Peter came to be on the WHO team because many conspiracy theorists claim that he inserted himself purposefully to aid in a possible cover-up. His private email records with Ben Embarek tell a much different story: one of hesitation and duty. Until October 2020, he still did not want to go to Wuhan.</p><blockquote>It was only on our first call when I saw the list that I had to begin to consider it. Fabian Leendertz was there, and a bunch of other people I had heard about. It was a very impressive team. Marion Koopmans was there too, and she is fantastic.</blockquote><p>After that first video call, he decided to commit to the mission.</p><blockquote>In the end, you just get carried over by the feeling of duty. This is what a scientist is supposed to do. If the outbreak of a global pandemic happens to be from a virus family you have been working on for years in the place you have been working, probably from the animals you have been working with, of course you should be sitting on that committee, trying to do everything you can.</blockquote><p>The Dutch virologist Marion Koopmans, who was scanning me with a gazing look behind sharp spectacles and white, spiky hair as she listened in on our conversation, agreed with that sentiment. She has investigated countless outbreaks in her career. She had started with noroviruses, hepatitis A virus, bird flu, and arboviruses. During the Ebola outbreak in West Africa, she was responsible for the deployment of mobile laboratories in Liberia and Sierra Leone. One would be hard-pressed to find anyone more knowledgeable and experienced to study novel outbreaks. She was very quick and to the point. “Every virus, and with it every outbreak, is different,” she explained. However, “with every spillover, you have a couple of key questions.” Hospital records, patient samples, and molecular and sampling data tend to be spread out over multiple locations, times, and people. Her job was to make sense of it. For her, the WHO reaching out and wanting her on the team was “the honor of a lifetime.” She did not hesitate to say yes.</p><p>“I was leading the molecular epidemiology interaction. That collaboration actually was nice.” She lauded her team and the Chinese collaborators. They basically had to figure out, from all the available data, which person, which genomic sequence, and what time. Putting that puzzle into place was challenging. The team made recommendations for analysis, and the Chinese side actually had scientists performing the work in real-time. “I think this group was maybe the least political because what you could do with genomics was not clear yet,” she laughed wholeheartedly. Indeed, the early epidemiologically linked sequences her team helped to establish and verify would hold incredibly important clues to the virus’s origin.</p><p>She was not a fan of the simple narrative that took hold that the Chinese were not sharing data with them. “Yes, there can be more transparency, but look at all that was shared.” She continued, “It was remarkable. There were no agreements in place. If somebody came to us and said, ‘Give us all your hospital and patient data,’ there is no way this would work.” Yet, as she says, the Chinese scientists tried hard to make much of it work.</p><p>That does not mean everything went smoothly, either. The WHO mission had two delegations: one of international scientists and one of Chinese scientists. The latter was constantly monitored and assisted by members of State Security, Foreign Affairs, and translators. “It was clear it is going to be this China-style process — you have these meetings where there is the director’s director, the director, the subdirector, and blah-blah — and everybody has to say something, and only then can you get to business.” Marion rolled her eyes. Working day and night analyzing data and being on group calls and meetings while in quarantine had been a strain, but their schedule afterward would not be much easier. The first two days out of quarantine, January 29th and 30th, they visited the Xinhua Hospital to interview doctors and staff and learn about patients.</p><p>There was the obligatory political visit to the “Anti-Epidemic Exhibition Hall,” a memorial to the “heroic” actions of Chinese authorities in defeating the virus in Wuhan. Like in my interview with George Gao from the Chinese CDC, their Chinese hosts felt it was incredibly important to stress to foreigners how well they handled the outbreak. Peter Daszak showed me some footage he shot with his phone, and it was every bit as red communist propaganda as one might imagine. Life-size statues of doctors in various poses, heroic background music, and testimonies running on screens about the greatness of the leaders winning the war against the virus. Not exactly subtle. However, he still found it to be “really moving.” That was the point. The Chinese authorities wanted to convince the WHO mission, as well as the world, of a different perspective on the outbreak. Not of failure, blame, and death, but of heroic strife, folk bravery, and overcoming the odds. China had been COVID-free for many months, while the US and other countries were suffocated by the virus. Doesn’t that show Chinese superiority?</p><p>Any hubris that they might have signaled fell short of reality when the WHO team arrived at the next stop.</p><p>On January 31, 2021, more than a year after the outbreak emerged from there, the WHO mission finally visited the Huanan seafood market.</p><p>“You walk into a dark hall; it is smelly. It still had white patches of disinfectant powder. It was eerie, like ground zero.”</p><p>Marion Koopmans lent me her eyes for this visit. She found it really impressive to be there. “There were these assumptions that, oh, this was a very modern market… This idea went out the window fast,” she elaborated.</p><p>“This was a wet market like any other I have ever been to,” Peter Daszak concurred. It had a mix of seafood, vegetables, restaurants, and live animals, all “stacked on top of each other; cages, freezers, [and] tools to move or process animals.” It was not that different from many other wet markets in China and Southeast Asia. Dominic Dwyer, a medical virologist from Australia, also elaborated on his experiences. “I thought to myself, you could not script a better place to have an outbreak.” He had been part of the WHO team that investigated the first SARS outbreak in 2003. “Dark tunnels, open drains, cages, people’s… you know. You could see sleeping quarters next, or a perfect place to start an outbreak of anything; doesn’t matter whether it’s a virus or salmonella or whatever.”</p><p>The international scientists were allowed to go around by themselves. Marion was still taken in by the experience. “To see how messy the place was. There was an open sewer channel with stuff floating through there.” In wet markets where animals are handled, they are often butchered alive in front of the customers by skilled vendors. The open sewage is for the animal guts that splash on the floor; they just get swept into the sewer. “Sometimes stray cats have a go at it,” Peter offered as an amusing anecdote.</p><p>The market had been shut down and decontaminated before the arrival of scientists from the Chinese CDC. The CDC investigators found a hastily abandoned place with no live animals, stocks of frozen food, and few vendors from which to take testimony. Yet that does not mean Chinese scientists didn’t try to figure out what happened.</p><p>“People who had done the environmental sampling showed us what they did, what they moved, and it really gives a feel for the place,” Marion Koopmans explained. It was more or less a standard outbreak investigation for the samplers. “Of course, they should have collected and sampled animals; that was a missed opportunity. But the message was that the animals were not there,” she lamented the lost chance. It was an obvious falsehood because everybody involved knew that live mammals, including certain wildlife without the necessary permits, were sold at that market. Peter Daszak elaborated on the “logic” presented by their Chinese counterparts:</p><blockquote>Look, wildlife trade is often illegal in China for certain protected species. Certainly without the right permits. If something is illegal in China, it is not happening in China, according to the authorities, because it is illegal. So officially, there was no illegal wildlife at the Huanan market, because that would have been illegal.</blockquote><p>But does that logic even hold? At the time of the WHO work, Peter Daszak had some of his staff, including those with fluent Mandarin, check the city, provincial and federal laws. None of them would make trading live mammals of the type that carry coronaviruses illegal. The next day he argued with the Chinese delegation for over 19 hours over the draft of the animal section of the WHO report which he drafted. Despite his repeated requests that the Chinese team cite the law that would have made selling live mammals illegal, no law was ever shown.</p><p>He had also been trying hard to get photographic evidence of possible wildlife at the Huanan market accepted by the Chinese counterparts but to no avail. They told him the photos were “unverifiable,” despite their origin being from Chinese social media in December 2019 and the floor tile pattern in the photos matching the floor tiles of the Huanan market. Professor Eddie Holmes, who visited the Huanan market in 2014, also had photographic evidence of SARS-susceptible illegal wildlife locked in the dark metal cages on top of the same checkered floor tiles they had just visited. “I offered… to call Eddie Holmes and verify with him,” Peter explained. But the authorities did not want to hear it. A dispute broke out. “Really argy-bargy here in Wuhan,” Dominic Dwyer, the medical virologist from Down Under, would write in best Australian fashion to his countryman, Edward Holmes, at the time. The international team was fighting hard to get the Chinese scientists to acknowledge that live wild mammals had been sold at the market. “The head Chinese guy said your photos might be synthesized,” he informed Eddie about the ridiculous infighting over something so trivial. Everyone knew that these animals had been there. But in the end, the hands of their Chinese counterparts were bound; they were not to admit anything untoward had happened at the market. “There were no illegal animals when we came,” the Wuhan CDC investigators repeated again and again.</p><p>In a narrow sense, I guess that simple retreat was likely true. The animals were gone by the time investigators arrived. “There has been a one-day notice period for merchants to remove them a day before the Wuhan CDC came,” Marion reiterated a rumor I have heard multiple times, although independent substantiation of who gave the notice has been hard to come by. Peter blames the corrupt manager of the market, who told the vendors that the national CDC was going to arrive. “I had asked this guy twenty times whether there were live mammals sold at the market. He lied twenty times.” Back in the last days of 2019, the Huanan market manager had to be notified in advance by the Wuhan CDC and was likely aware of their imminent plans for a market visit. “He probably told the vendors to clean up and get rid of everything,” Peter speculated. Some scientists assumed the warning to vendors came from within the Wuhan CDC itself. Others suggested that social networks relayed the message of an imminent inspection to get vendors to move or cull their animals. After all, clinicians already suggested the market link to the new outbreak on December 27, 2019, and rumors of another SARS linked to wildlife also spread on social media. Yet another set of possibilities are random market checks in December that might have triggered a clear-out of animals. The Associated Press reported about a recording of a confidential WHO meeting that the local authorities had independently visited the market for a spot check on December 25th, before the virus was even sequenced; albeit this date was likely a human mix-up between Christmas and New Year.</p><p>Irrespective of who or what told or warned the merchants to remove their animals by December 31st 2019, multiple lines of evidence support the presence of SARS-CoV-2-susceptible mammals until late December at the Huanan market. By the time George Gao’s national CDC arrived, these mammals were gone — and thus were never tested. “That is the missing piece; they could have traced the animals,” Marion lamented. “Why did they step away from following up on that?” To her, it would have been the obvious thing to do. But for Chinese scientists, this course of action had not necessarily been a politically desired one.</p><p>As we heard from Alice Hughes, most likely the vendors and wildlife were not tracked by the authorities because they wanted Chinese scientists to find a blameless reason for an outbreak that increasingly resembled the original SARS. Given the emerging facts, that option quickly became untenable. Unbeknownst to the WHO, in early 2019, “multiple vendors at the Huanan market had been fined for selling live animals by the local forestry, market supervision, and quarantine [AQSIQ] authorities,” the freelance journalist Michael Standaert, who was in Wuhan shortly after the outbreak checking official records, would later find out. He wrote:</p><blockquote>These are minimal, slap on the wrist fines. The authorities giving out the fines would have been aware of the continuous sales of these and other animals, especially forestry bureau officials. Their office was only a few hundred meters west of these stalls.</blockquote><p>Independent Chinese researchers Xiao Xiao and Zhao-Min Zhou from the Key Laboratory of Southwest China Wildlife Resources Conservation in Nanchong, Sichuan Province, would publish a study in <em>Scientific Reports</em> shortly after the WHO mission. By chance, they had surveyed the Huanan market between May 2017 and November 2019 for a project on tick-borne diseases following an earlier outbreak in Hubei in 2010. They surveyed 17 shops in Wuhan, seven of which were at the Huanan market, and found that over 30,000 live animals had been sold. They also noted:</p><blockquote>Almost all animals were sold alive, caged, stacked and in poor condition. Most stores offered butchering services, done on site, with considerable implications for food hygiene and animal welfare. Approximately 30% of individuals from 6 mammal species inspected had suffered wounds from gunshots or traps, implying illegal wild harvesting. […] None of the 17 shops posted an origin certificate or quarantine certificate, so all wildlife trade was fundamentally illegal.</blockquote><p>To sum up what we know today, from as early as 2014, when Eddie Holmes visited the market, to at least the end of 2019, we know with certainty that there was risky wildlife activity occurring at the market, with at least part of it likely illegal. The local authorities were keenly aware of it but decided to turn a blind eye, which sounded reckless but should not surprise us. The wildlife trade is a 73-billion-dollar industry in China and is culturally accepted by the population. With the right permissions, most wildlife trade is not illegal, even for rather exotic animals. Pre-pandemic sales activities at the Huanan market were not that unusual for authorities. Huanan was just the largest of four similar markets in the same city, and it sold wild animals that might not have undergone thorough source vetting or had vendors whose products did not always fully align with prevailing legal permissions. Everyone can understand this messy human reality. Putting the onus solely on the government to stop any infringements or blaming them for a failure to prevent illegal trade completely seems to follow unreasonable expectations and hindsight bias. No government has the power to completely prevent illegal activities. Offering transparency about wildlife activities and animals at the market, maybe paired with some lax local enforcement to get rid of it, seemed like a small concession to make for any government.</p><p>Yet by January 2021, Beijing had no interest in giving even that tiny admission of responsibility, certainly not after many months of blame games from the Trump administration. Especially when the Trump administration started to demand reparations for the pandemic from China in June of 2020, even admitting any bat-to-wildlife-related outbreak became unthinkable in Beijing. Geopolitics had taken over, and thus Beijing fought tooth and nail to deny any susceptible wildlife — illegal or not — had been there. Their new official position was “the virus came from outside of China.” Under the upcoming auspices of the WHO investigation, Chinese scientists found themselves cornered into a position where, really, any alternative scientific theory was desired by the higher-ups. They wanted a blameless reason for how the virus might have come to the market. In preparatory calls with WHO members a couple of months before the Wuhan mission, they had already converged on the idea that the virus did not spill over via any illegal wildlife trade but via various imported cold-chain products. A scientifically flimsy but possible hypothesis, and a politically desired one. If this theory were true, it would make the Huanan market just the first innocent victim of the virus coming from far away instead of being ground zero, with the exotic and live mammalian wildlife trade potentially fostering its maturation and emergence. This cold-chain narrative became the official scientific story during the first call with the international team.</p><p>“Right then and there, I knew they were going to make our life difficult”</p><p>Peter Daszak remembered. To support their cold-chain assertions, Chinese scientists performed studies showing how the virus could persist in the cold and remain infectious for days on frozen products like fish. Even Zhengli had soaked chicken, pork, and beef meat in virus culture supernatant and stored it in the freezer to sample every month. Even 3 years later, those meat samples still test positive, she told me. George Gao also led a study that provided some data that aquatic animals, including whales, might have ACE2 receptors susceptible to SARS-CoV-2 infection. “So, who is really to say how the virus came to the market?” he asked me. While some leftover frozen animal carcasses tested negative for SARS-CoV-2, environmental samples taken from leftover fish at the Huanan market were contaminated with the virus. The latter is not surprising, given that the market was awash in virus particles from the outbreak before all open surfaces were sprayed down for decontamination. When environmental sampling was performed — spread out over multiple weeks in January 2020 — multiple places, including those associated with cold chain products, they found that some viral particles persisted there to nobodies surprise. This is not to say the cold-chain theory was completely baseless per se. In fairness to the sanity of the Chinese scientists, they traced a different SARS-CoV-2 outbreak back to supermarkets via cold chain products imported from outside China after China locked down and enforced its Zero-COVID strategy. So, from a possibility standpoint, the cold-chain narrative cannot be discarded. Plausibility is another question. The cold-chain-related outbreak occurred at a time when the virus had already infected much of the world, and was subsequently on many important products.</p><p>However, for the cold-chain theory to be true, the virus needed to get on those frozen products somewhere. This would require a gigantic outbreak of COVID somewhere else that went unnoticed, and it still fails to explain why the first cases would show up at the Huanan market and nowhere else, nor does it account for a host of other correlating lines of phylogenetic, epidemiological, and geographic evidence pointing to the market and wildlife. Chinese scientists were not oblivious to these gaps in their story, but at the moment, the international scientists were not able to disprove the cold-chain theory, which was good enough for Beijing. They really needed the blameless cold-chain alternative to the unwelcome wildlife theory to save face and escape demands for culpability.</p><p>Peter Daszak, as part of the environmental and animal team, felt the Chinese pushback on the wildlife trade the most. “We came here almost as diplomats,” he once said, trying to explain how he understood his role. They tried everything they could to get their Chinese counterparts to agree with them. He asserted, “They knew that we knew that they knew this was BS, but there was not much to be done.” Marion Koopmans also understood that some of these cold-chain arguments were flimsy and motivated but took it very pragmatically. “To me, the solution was to stick to what I know and can investigate,” she explained.</p><p>They didn’t get to spend more time at the market because the next days were fully booked with visits to the Hubei Provincial CDC, the Wuhan CDC, and the Animal CDC, followed by a visit to the Wuhan Blood Center. In a megacity of over 11 million, there were a lot of labs and researchers involved in the response, after all. Again, the idea was to interview scientists, collect data, and give recommendations for further studies. “We asked them all sorts of questions, such as how did they handle the samples, what samples they took, because part of our strategy was to get those samples to be re-tested in other labs, maybe even in the West.” They also recommended testing samples in the blood bank to see if, in the months leading up to the outbreak, any remnants of SARS-CoV-2 infections could be discerned. This would be informative for both the timing of the outbreak and whether the virus had been circulating for a long time, unnoticed, before it caused a lot of sickness around the Huanan market. Based on these recommendations and contrary to the increasing geopolitical tensions, that lab work was indeed performed and later presented to SAGO, another WHO expert body tasked with understanding the origins of the pandemic. The blood bank study showed that there were no early cases detected in over 34,000 pre-pandemic samples leading up to December, arguing against any asymptomatic or silent spread much before the market-centered outbreak. Yet almost no raw data or samples have been shared with international scientists.</p><p>“Clearly, from the get-go, Beijing did not want this to happen. They did not want an investigation, international people to come”</p><p>Peter Daszak explained. Not to the market, not to the various CDC offices, and not to WIV. “At first, they said the lab would be impossible,” Peter Daszak elaborated, “but then we got it to happen; I got it to happen.” Dr. Embarek had been adamant that they could not go all the way to Wuhan and not visit Zhengli’s lab, and he knew he could leverage Peter to get it done. They strategized. “What do you want me to do, call Zhengli?” he offered. When he called Zhengli, she had no objections to her lab being visited. But how to get the authorities on board? “My idea was to get her to give a scientific seminar. Marion suggested they all do to make it a research seminar day while we were still on lockdown. Marion gave a talk; I gave a talk; Zhengli did too.” They quietly held the seminar with all WHO and Chinese scientists involved while in quarantine at the Wuhan hotel. It softened things up and built trust. Ultimately, it got them access to the lab a week later.</p><p>I personally find this little snippet fascinating; it shows how science can be a tool for diplomacy. Even during the height of the Cold War, scientific collaborations were the channels that often bridged seemingly insurmountable geopolitical chasms. In the end, Peter’s idea and the WHO team succeeded where belligerent grandstanding and virtuous posturing from Western actors failed. They got access to the lab.</p><p>On February 3rd, the WHO mission visited the WIV. In this much-anticipated event, reporters who had laid siege to the academic institute began chasing the WHO mission cars all along the street. Once inside, the international team interviewed scientists and took a tour, including the BSL-4 labs. Discussions were in the usual setup, however: a big room with their Chinese counterparts and an entourage of translators. They were allowed to ask ad hoc questions of Shi Zhengli and other staff, including the director of the Institute. “We asked them nasty questions about how they do their work, what protections they use, what viruses they had, what experiments they did,” Peter Daszak recounted.</p><p>They also inquired about rumors. “We asked them why they took down the database. What about these rumors of a missing person? What about the three scientists who were supposedly hospitalized?” According to the prevailing conspiratorial narratives, Zhengli had allegedly taken down her virus database as part of a cover-up. In addition, one of her students named Huang Yanling had supposedly gone missing from her lab website, possibly “taken care of” to shut her up. Other allegations had circulated, including one about three sick workers at the large institute potentially being patients zero of the outbreak. Despite these insinuations and their implications, the answers the WHO team got from Zhengli were quite candid. On the database, she admitted that it just never worked that well. “We took it down to make it better and more user-friendly. And then, when we put it back on, they were hacking us, so we had to take it back down again.” Peter tried to recollect the gist of it. On Huang Yanling, “she just moved to a different province and did not want to be contacted.” That’s why they took down her profile from the lab website. Regarding the sick workers, she said that all team members had been tested for COVID antibodies in the spring, and all tested negative. “We had the chance to ask unscripted questions; we could catch them in a lie,” Peter said. “The answers seemed to be straightforward and not coordinated.”</p><p>Beijing did not admit to this officially, but Zhengli’s lab had been audited twice in the spring of 2020, by both WIV people who were concerned it might have come from their lab and by the Chinese authorities. “Of course, they were, you know, and they were obviously horrified that something could have happened,” Dominic Dwyer explained. “Well, tell me what you did about investigating your staff. Did you collect blood?” he asked them. They did blood tests, and they were all negative. They monitored staff health. They explained the procedures in the lab, and they had a good biosafety lab built by the French.</p><p>“We couldn’t find any evidence that SARS-CoV-2 was in the lab before the outbreak. They only started culturing after the outbreak started”</p><p>Dominic Dwyer said. He added, “They generally published as quickly as they could with anything, you know. So why would they hide that they had SARS-CoV-2?” Before the pandemic, there would have been no need to do so. Research projects are iterative; they take years, and “generally laboratory accidents happen when you’re culturing,” which makes the idea of hidden or secret viruses even more untenable.</p><p>There was no indication that Zhengli’s lab had anything to do with the outbreak. “All the coronavirus scientists felt pressure, not only me. At this point, the only thing you can do is show your work to the people who want to know.” Zhengli also told me about this stressful period when her lab was under intense scrutiny by authorities in 2020.</p><p>“They checked everything. Electronic records, sequences, experiments. We were transparent; we had nothing to fear.”</p><p>Since then, her lab has been free to operate. By the time the Wuhan mission had arrived, Zhengli was no longer treated as if under suspicion by Chinese authorities and thus was free to talk. The opposite was happening in the West, where the default assumption was that she couldn’t be trusted no matter what.</p><p>That being said, a deeper investigation into her statements always seemed to corroborate, rather than refute, her story. For example, records of her database server activities have been uncovered, showing not only that the database was <em>not</em> taken offline in September 2019 — as conspiracy theories still allege to this day — but that it was online sporadically until February 2020, when hacking attempts finally brought it down. “There had been thousands of hacking attempts since the beginning of the pandemic,” Chinese journalist Jane Qiu would learn from Zhengli, independent of the WHO mission. “The IT managers were really worried somebody might sabotage the databases or, worse, implant virus sequences for malicious intent,” Zhengli had said. So, I guess it was no mystery why they never brought it back online again.</p><p>But what happened to Huang, Zhengli’s student? Some of the Western press had confidently declared Huang “COVID-19 patient zero” and “missing,” but the technician had left the lab years earlier after graduation to work for a biology company in Sichuan Province. Chinese journalists quickly traced her whereabouts in 2020; she was doing fine, and they even got a statement from her company that she was never sick or anything suspicious.</p><p>Independent people and facts seemed to corroborate every explanation offered by Zhengli. Overall, I found nothing suspicious about Zhengli’s lab or actions, and she also did not culture any secret viruses nor hide them in her database. We know this, again independently, because she was working on a publication pre-pandemic that would contain sequences from all the SARS-related coronaviruses she ever sequenced. The study came out in the middle of 2020, despite strong pushback from Chinese authorities, and there was no suspicious viral cousin closer than RaTG13 in that set, confirming that she did not possess anything that could have been transformed into SARS-CoV-2. Zhengli had submitted the first draft of that paper pre-pandemic — before there might be an incentive to hide or cover up sequences — and her collaborators on that study did not observe any changes, removals, or similar alterations made between the first version and final publication. “The real scientists in the field, they trust me,” Zhengli gave for consideration. “I attended a lot of meetings before COVID-19. I discussed my unpublished work with a lot of scientists. They know everything from my lab.”</p><p>These facts of academic minutiae should make us confident she was not withholding any pertinent sequences and certainly not engaged in secret culturing programs. Unless all her collaborators, many of whom weren’t even Chinese, were also in on the cover-up. Which is, of course, what conspiracy theorists would immediately allege after she was allowed to publish all her sequences in mid-2020. But allegations of such a broad international cover-up are unrealistic, to say the least. “If people trust, they trust. If they don’t trust, they don’t,” Zhengli sounded resigned today. For most of 2020, she had been furious; it was taxing on her. “So, I said okay. I gave up pursuing every person to trust me. So, we just do our job and leave everything on the side… to the times,” she waved her hand in a dismissive motion to the side.</p><p>Irrespective of trust, in 2022, almost incontrovertible proof of the veracity of her words arrived when a set of embargoed sequences from 2018, belonging to a forgotten manuscript, appeared on a Western database. A student had uploaded them with a standard embargo of 4 years, but the paper was never accepted by a journal, so the principal investigators forgot, and the student moved on without removing the sequences. In 2022, that lucky oversight suddenly unlocked sequencing samples from 2018, showing that at this time, Zhengli’s work focused exclusively on SARS-CoV-1-related viruses, again, not RaTG13 or any other known or unknown SARS-CoV-2-related coronaviruses. Exactly like she told everybody.</p><p>But merely being innocent is unfortunately a poor excuse when the world is looking for somebody to blame. Far too many continue to assert, without any basis, that Zhengli must be lying about a lot of things, regardless of how much evidence is presented to the contrary. To this day, Zhengli has not given a reason to doubt her words, but because she is a Chinese researcher in mainland China, the prevailing assumption in the West seems to be that she is not to be trusted, no matter what.</p><p>This does not imply that we should not be suspicious of Chinese authorities and politicians trying to control the narrative. Take the WHO mission, where opaque Chinese politics and a lack of transparency often seeded justified distrust, no matter if it was about market animals or what happened to staff at the lab. The panel discussion got a bit more heated with the director of WIV — a communist party member, in contrast to Zhengli, who is not — when it came to rumors about the three sick WIV staffers. Just a week before, the Trump administration’s State Department put out a statement claiming intelligence reports found three workers being hospitalized in late 2019; the implication was that this proved that WIV had started the pandemic. Because of these accusations in the news cycle, the topic was highly sensitive. The WHO members really ruffled some feathers, just raising the subject. Rumbling went through the back desks. The director, Wang Yanyi, and the assembly of their Chinese scientists with the lead negotiator, Liang Wannian, claimed that “nobody got sick at the WIV” in that period. This caused Thea Fisher — Professor in Public Health, Virus Infections, and Epidemics from the Nordsjællands Hospital in Denmark — and John Watson, an epidemiologist and public health researcher from the UK, to become quite enraged. “Are you seriously saying that, during the peak of flu season, no one would have gotten sick at all?” WIV is a big institute with many people; epidemiologically, this did not make sense. “I just find that very, very hard to believe,” they said. Some more rumbling ensued. “But those guys were smooth,” Peter Daszak explained. Especially the head of the Chinese delegation, Prof. Liang Wannian, the architect of the Zero-COVID strategy, was a seasoned politician. “He clarified that people may have gotten the flu, but then they would just not come into work. But nobody from the lab was hospitalized,” unlike Trump’s State Department memo suggested.</p><p>Again, this did not mean that nobody from WIV ever visited a hospital in the autumn of 2019. In China, it is common to visit a hospital as an outpatient, much like someone would go to a house doctor or general practitioner in other countries. There is a difference between being hospitalized and just visiting a doctor in the hospital. After that heated exchange, the mission’s goodwill began to wane. Asked by the WHO scientists whether WIV has been audited in response to various conspiracy theories, they deflected by saying that annual external audits were routinely conducted. A contradiction to what Zhengli had told Peter Daszak — that her lab had indeed been under intense scrutiny. Beijing seemingly did not want to admit that a laboratory leak was a real possibility they themselves had considered. Geopolitically and domestically, they now preferred to project the image that there was never any concern that the virus could have come from the lab.</p><p>“It’s too political,” Zhengli had told Peter. He, of course, had already observed that at the time of the audit in late spring 2020, Zhengli and her lab had been under immense pressure. The reality was that, at the time, Beijing was very worried the virus came from WIV, and they not only had everybody serologically tested for COVID antibodies — all negative — but they also investigated the clinical records of all staffers. Nothing to point to COVID, but it was likely that some workers had visited a doctor as an outpatient in the hospital for unrelated illnesses back in 2019. Maybe the US spy agencies picked up those records. Again, the Chinese delegation did not admit to any of it. The WHO epidemiologists would not have found outpatient visits suspicious or indicative of anything, but geopolitically, Beijing probably correctly expected that it was a hard nuance to make on the world stage. It was just one of those things that superficially looked too damning. Maybe that’s why the topic became so sensitive.</p><p>The WHO mission report is on record stating that no suspected or confirmed cases of COVID-19 were seen by PCR, and antibody testing of all WIV staff was negative. That they had been tested thoroughly and nobody was found exposed is not unusual or suspicious either. One has to consider that China’s virus surveillance and contact tracing during the outbreak were very strict, irrespective of institute affiliation. For example, it had been found that all staff from both the provincial Hubei CDC and the animal CDC tested negative in that period. Only one of the Wuhan CDC’s staff members was confirmed SARS-CoV-2 seropositive after infection due to family cluster transmission. All other staff had tested negative as well. The point of the dramatic lockdown and the Zero-COVID strategy after had been to spare most citizens an infection.</p><p>A day after the heated exchanges at the Wuhan Institute of Virology, the WHO mission visited the Jian Xin Yuan Community Centre, a place for senior and elderly citizens that saw 19 confirmed cases of SARS-CoV-2 on January 24, 2020. They were to hear testimony from survivors. It was moving, as well as highlighting the traumatic impact of the pandemic on the elderly. After that, they had some more days of expert interviews conducted at their hotel from the Huazhong Agricultural University, Wuhan Blood Center, and Wuhan Central Hospital. There were multiple days of discussions among themselves and with their Chinese counterparts for a joint statement and preparation of a summary report. The WHO members left China feeling that they had made some good progress and were hopeful to continue the work in the upcoming months and maybe even years.</p><p>By most standard measures, the WHO mission was pretty successful. First, it collected a large body of verified evidence despite political interference from an authoritarian country. The evidence allowed researchers to make succinct recommendations for further work and good estimates about the likely origin of the virus. Second, it was a diplomatic win, bringing together an international team of Chinese scientists as well as providing a basis for further data sharing and collaboration. Third, it provided valuable lessons on how to set up future outbreak investigations. “An outbreak not studied is an outbreak wasted,” Marion Koopmans would say. “We always went in with the idea that this is <em>Step One</em>.” Their goal for this mission was to put all the available information together, which was already a large chunk of work. “I never expected for a second we [would] come out with full answers, only to focus our knowledge and give recommendations.”</p><p>Yet from the start, the WHO mission had been viewed with skepticism by the US, believing that it was nothing more than a guided tour where the Chinese only showed the international members what they were allowed to see. A farce doomed to fail before it was even underway. While the WHO members and other scientists were getting ready for a year-long and arduous scientific investigation, the world was dissatisfied with not getting immediate answers. Hearing that the WHO mission had not definitively identified the origin of COVID, interest in the topic began to spike anew.</p><p>Everybody, including citizens, journalists, politicians, and even some scientists, craved a more compelling explanation of where this virus came from. They started looking for clues elsewhere. Many were unaware that their desire for a more emotionally satisfying answer would drive them into an information ecosystem that sought to blame not only some foreign virologists, but science itself, for the pandemic…</p><p>[<em>the chapter continues in the book, explaining what led to the “vibe shift” of public sentiment in 2021. To protect myself from retaliation, this book excerpt in English has to stop here</em>]</p><p><em>Thanks for reading Protagonist Science! You can subscribe for free to receive new posts directly to your email. I try to post very little and only high quality; but with the book release there might be a few more updates than usual.</em></p><p>More information on the book can be found here: <a href="https://www.lab-leak-fever.com/">www.lab-leak-fever.com</a></p><ul><li>DE — “<em>Das Laborfieber”</em>, released as <strong>paperback</strong> and <strong>ebook</strong> April 20th</li><li>EN — “<em>Lab Leak Fever</em>”, currently unavailable, trying to find a courageous publisher</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*J403udigzz_0alLh.png" /></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=41c7b738dea8" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Exclusive: The inside story behind the search for the origins of COVID-19]]></title>
            <link>https://protagonist-science.medium.com/exclusive-the-inside-story-behind-the-search-for-the-origins-of-covid-19-786c659a20bb?source=rss-c8e0e038559d------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/786c659a20bb</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[manipulation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[lab-leak]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[covid-origin]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Philipp Markolin]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 12 Apr 2025 17:03:31 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-04-28T19:00:24.051Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>A big screen documentary movie, an announcement, and an exclusive excerpt from “Lab Leak Fever”, the definitive book unraveling the pandemic origin controversy</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*ZUHxk03ciaAzXEKq.jpeg" /><figcaption>Image credit: Emile Ducke</figcaption></figure><p>So it has gotten quiet around here because I have been working for years on two big projects to resolve the COVID-19 origin controversy for ordinary citizens.</p><h3>The Movie</h3><p>The first one is a <strong>big cinema documentary movie</strong> directed by <strong>Oscar-nominated Swiss Filmmaker Christian Frei </strong>called <strong>“</strong><a href="https://businessdoceurope.com/visions-du-reel-opening-film-interview-blame-by-christian-frei/"><strong>Blame: Bats, politics and a planet out of balance</strong></a><strong>”</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*_LY32IaeaNQ_kx5G.jpeg" /></figure><p>When Christian Frei approached me in March 2022 about participating because he read my article about the topic, I was not sure if I was being pranked. But then we met and I realized that he was somebody who tried to really understand what happened, to those scientists, to science, and to all of us in this traumatic pandemic.</p><p><strong>Q &amp; A For Blame</strong></p><p><a href="https://www.protagonist-science.com/api/v1/file/12cb1017-a2e7-4163-b256-f696e23e002d.pdf">Download</a> an extended Q&amp;A about how I came into the movie, what this movie is about, and what we hope to achieve.</p><h3>The Book</h3><p>In early 2023, I decided that I wanted to tell the real full story of the origin controversy. Until then, I had been incredibily lucky to interview many key scientists involved in the search for the origin of SARS-CoV-2 and learn enough of the science to understand the full body of evidence and the scientific consensus arising from that evidence.</p><p>What I did not understand was how public opinion was so far from scientific reality, so that is what I began to investigate. In each chapter of my book, you will not only find unheard testimony and unique insights of scientific protagonists, but also hear about the many surprising obstacles, antagonists, or tormentors in our modern information ecosystem that sabotaged their work and our public understanding. These range from cynical anti-science activists to profiteering influencers, from social media trolls and conspiracy theorists to contrarian experts, motivated journalists, sitting US Congressmen and Senators up to the US President and the Chinese Bureau of State Security.</p><p>United by a common scapegoat, their loose alliance of connivance and calculation seeks to gain popularity, profit, or power by keeping the scientifically unsubstantiated but emotionally satisfying lab leak hypothesis alive. Their actions and agendas expose how the technological disruption of our information sphere has created new vulnerabilities in our social fabric. In turn, these vulnerabilities are constantly exploited by a new class of power holders in our midst: influencers, platforms, and online crowds… it was quite a ride.</p><p>The book should have been published in early 2025 in the US, but then Trump won the election and the risks became too high for my publisher. I was not intending to speak about this, I thought the book was dead. But then the <strong>German intelligence agencies began seeding a lab leak narrative through shady methods in the German-speaking sphere</strong>, so I had to act, no matter the risks to me personally. And the risks for telling the truth are real, unfortunately. So I spoke about this with <a href="https://www.volkskrant.nl/wetenschap/zijn-uitgever-durft-dit-boek-over-de-lablektheorie-niet-uit-te-brengen-de-wetenschap-is-de-informatieoorlog-aan-het-verliezen~b1586aa6/?referrer=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.google.com%2F">de Volkskrant, a renowned newspaper in the Netherlands</a>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/671/0*uA-pfwQgq8buLZPx.png" /></figure><p>Translated Interview De Volkskrant</p><p><a href="https://www.protagonist-science.com/api/v1/file/575c48df-37a9-474b-90b4-611647f12a90.pdf">Download</a></p><p>I am sorry for my many American and international friends that I can currently not offer the original English version due to geopolitical sensitivities and very real dangers of becoming a target of powerful actors, in China, and more worryingly, in the US. But I will give you an exclusive excerpt to form your opinion about why this book going to change the false lab leak narrative forever, and what I learned about the media manipulators in the back.</p><p>As one of the few, if not the only western writer, I got to interview <strong>George Gao from the Chinese CDC</strong> and<strong> Zhengli Shi from the Wuhan Institute of Virology</strong>. What did they do when a pneumonia of unknown aetiology broke out in Wuhan?</p><p>Let´s find out:</p><p><strong>Disclaimer</strong></p><p><em>This book is told from the perspective of multiple scientists and the author who recount the events surrounding the pandemic origin controversy to the best of their knowledge.</em></p><h3>Chapter 2: Early Drums of War</h3><blockquote>I tried really hard to never say anything wrong. - <strong>Dr. George Fu Gao</strong>, Director of the Chinese CDC</blockquote><blockquote>We believed the results. But I could not believe the results, you know? That was not possible. We always said, “Oh, one day it will come,” and it really came. - <strong>Prof. Shi Zhengli</strong>, Wuhan Institute of Virology</blockquote><p>“Without a harmonious and stable environment, how can there be a home where people can live and work happily?”</p><p>Xi Jinping’s words on New Year’s Eve in 2019 were intended to reign in pro-democracy protests in Hong Kong. For months, the city has been in a renewed battle for its soul against the oppressive and subversive influence of the Chinese Communist Party (CCP). Tens of thousands, if not hundreds of thousands, were expected to march again on January 1, 2020. The goal was to maintain political pressure after a landslide victory of pro-democracy candidates in district court elections weeks prior. Six thousand police officers were deployed to deal with potential unrest — the wrong signal to send, given previous escalations and excessive police brutality. “Safety concerns” led to the cancellation of the midnight fireworks despite months of planning. The next day, a peaceful protest with families, kids, and the elderly, often dressed up in costumes, quickly escalated into violence, tear gas, and mass arrests. The police blamed some radical student agitators who had hijacked the march. Maybe it was inevitable; tensions had been high for months. ​​Universities and their students were front and center of the recent civil rights movement, and the police claimed these institutions had become “weapon factories.” As a result, sieges and raids on universities have become part of campus life over the last few months.</p><p>The last thing the exasperated Jasnah Kholin (pseudonym) needed at the time was “one more fucking thing to worry” about. The unfiltered coronavirus researcher (who swore like a sailor) now uses a pseudonym to hide her real identity for safety reasons (I promised her that I would omit any details that she felt would compromise her safety). She, like many others, had been at these protests for civil rights and experienced firsthand how they were squashed by the police, often with force. Once, the young academic had a pepper ball barely miss her face that would certainly have knocked her out. Another time, the police came to pick her up, and she was in prison for weeks before they let her go. Wrongfully suspected or not, she was among the lucky few who got out uncharged because there was no evidence to place her at the scene. It’s not surprising she had an innate distrust of the Chinese authorities, who were more and more entrenched in Hong Kong, her only home.</p><p>When she heard about the pneumonia outbreak in Wuhan around New Year’s on ProMED-mail, an internet service supported by volunteers that tracks unusual health events, she immediately started screenshotting and saving every bit of information that was coming out of Wuhan: every pdf, every Weibo message, every picture, all kinds of vital info. Because of Chinese censorship, information can sometimes be lost within minutes of appearing online. What foresight! “Oh, I am very familiar with how information works in China,” she would later explain to me. In any crisis, Chinese authorities shut down the information flow to try to control the narrative. This is not unusual; it happens for things big and small, important or insignificant. This approach might even help to contain false and harmful rumors during a crisis. However, it also creates a layer of obfuscation and political spin that can make it challenging to assert pertinent facts with any confidence. For example, consider how dangerous the virus was and how it spread. In the very beginning, the Chinese authorities claimed that the virus ​​was barely, or not at all, transmissible human-to-human in an attempt to not cause panic, a claim that was still being repeated by the World Health Organization (WHO) on January 14th.</p><p>Jasnah Kholin and her academic colleagues in Hong Kong did not believe any of it. They had been burned before. On January 4th, Jasnah caught wind of a concerning story on Weibo (Chinese Twitter) about an infected father who had not gone to the Huanan market. Chinese censors deleted it within the hour. Yet for her, already gathering as much from rumors, the specifics of this story were the final indication of human-to-human transmission, vehemently denied by Chinese authorities until weeks later. Many other coronavirus experts were just as suspicious as her, including SARS-veterans Yuen Kwok-Yung, a giant among Hong Kong’s infectious disease experts, and Leo Poon, who developed the first PCR diagnostic for SARS in 2003. They all independently read the signs on the wall and raised the alarm in Hong Kong about the human spread. “SARS was a generational trauma for Hong Kong; this was not our first fucking rodeo,” Jasnah kept cursing. According to her, SARS-1 had also been much closer to a pandemic than people commonly realize. However, all of them knew this and did everything they could to make the rest of Hong Kong take this seriously.</p><p>Most likely, their actions at the time helped the city avoid the worst. By any measure, Hong Kong’s early and harsh response has been a success story. With the high uncertainty and unclear messaging from mainland China, it fell mostly to outbreak professionals and coronavirus academics like Jasnah to exert caution and inform society. Speed is everything in emerging outbreaks; the longer it takes to mount collective action, the worse it usually gets. Because of their warnings, both the population and Hong Kong’s chief executive would take the threat seriously and implement strict pandemic prevention protocols. From the first to the fourth wave, Hong Kongers succeeded where most of the world would fail; they suppressed community transmission of the virus.</p><p>Yet not everybody was happy. Pro-democracy protests saw their momentum decline under new restrictions. They were especially concerned about the ubiquitous use of contact tracing and digital surveillance, which they feared would be a new and powerful tool in the hands of the police. In the following months, civil rights protests were canceled, and the CCP exerted even more political pressure on Hong Kong. Stuck between a rock and a hard place, Jasnah, like many in the wider Chinese diaspora, wished that somebody would blow the lid off this thing in those early days. <em>Why did the CCP initially deny the obvious human-to-human spread? Why the silencing of doctors? Did the communist party really think they could hush up the severity of the outbreak? When will the world wake up about the Chinese government?</em> Somewhat ironically, the tumultuous cultural and political moment, along with this appropriately placed mistrust, made the Chinese diaspora, especially Hong Kong, very susceptible to a different type of viral spread.</p><p>Since December 30, when the outbreak of pneumonia of unknown etiology became official, sporadic voices both on Chinese and Western social media have put the connection of WIV’s biosafety level 4 (BSL-4) laboratory into public spaces, albeit in the context that they had the capacity and expertise there to handle the outbreak. The positive connotation did not last long. Within five days, this information would be presented by a pro-civil rights protester in Hong Kong to suggest quite a different connection. A tweet from the time, still visible today, reads:</p><blockquote>My guess is China has ordered an attack on Hong Kong with bio-weapons to stop the continuous protests. Like in 2003, the CCP assisted the outbreak of SARS in HK to pave the way for #CEPA. You can’t underestimate how evil this regime is. #Bioweapon</blockquote><p>Others echoed the idea, highlighting the particular timing right after the New Year’s protests that ended in violence. While none of these rumors gained any wide-reaching traction, they symbolized both fear and suspicion about the CCP and what they would or would not do. Suspicion was warranted. Independent information from Wuhan was hard to come by. And ordinary people would never get the full story.</p><p>Many of the early outbreak threads come together in one person, Dr. Gao Fu, known in the West as Dr. George Gao, director of the Chinese Center for Disease Control and Prevention (CCDC). Within China, public health authorities like the CCDC had mostly independent community-level, state-level, and federal offices, and George was sitting at the top node where all data would cascade towards, in many ways, the highest public health position in the land, only below the communist party’s National Health Commission. Dr. Gao rarely gave interviews, and every time he did, he would be investigated by authorities. The Associated Press learned of three such instances. When I managed to get an interview, it was a random Sunday afternoon. He was still in the office, working alongside his personal assistant. He kept running out of our interview on and off, dictating instructions in Chinese under his breath, sometimes even while I was directly talking to him.</p><p>​​​Originally a veterinarian, George went to Oxford for a PhD and postdoc in Virology. After that, he went to Harvard for a few years, then back to Oxford as a group leader, before returning to China and starting his meteoric rise. From the Chinese Academy of Science to heading National Key Laboratories, working on the ground in the 2014 Ebola outbreak in Sierra Leone (his role was described as “heroic” by the US National Academy of Science), and all the way to becoming the Director of the Chinese CDC. By any measure, Dr. Gao is an incredibly successful scientist and possibly an equally skilled political tactician.</p><p>Most of our conversation was not about the questions I asked but a mixture of highlighting the work he has done, the papers he has published, the awards he has achieved, and overall, how great China did. “I have been on the frontline from the very beginning for the vaccine development in China, and also, I have some original publications for antibody development,” he said as he rattled off a long list of things I did not ask about and that went quite beyond the scope, but soon I would figure out why. He used it as a preamble to say that writers like me should really write for the general public about his and China’s amazing achievements. He jumped up from his chair to show me popular science books he had written in Chinese, and if I was interested in writing about these topics, we could write something together. I was torn between rolling my eyes and staying diplomatic. What a start, I thought, not even five minutes into our conversation. It went a bit better when I prompted him to put down a timeline for the early outbreak.</p><p>By the end of December, there were already rumors of another SARS outbreak on the Chinese internet. People were getting sick, and some doctors discovered that their patients had an association with the Huanan seafood market. Perhaps even market visitors or vendors noticed something unusual and spoke up as well; reconstruction has been difficult. As far as anybody can tell, these speculations started only around the last week of December but would soon harden into alarming action.</p><p>On December 30th, the municipal government issued a “red head” letter — an official document — noting they had a PUE (pneumonia of unknown etiology). The letter asked that if any other hospital notices similar cases, take them seriously and report them to the Bureau of Health. When Dr. Gao read that, he sent his staff and second-in-command to Wuhan. On December 31st, they collected samples from hospital patients.</p><p>On January 3rd, they got the first sequences confirming it was a coronavirus. In parallel, they quickly developed PCR primers and sent them to the local CCDC in Wuhan so they could start testing and screening patients. He could not stop himself from mentioning how China did well in contrast to the United States, where officials struggled with developing their own PCR test, which was a bit of a scandal at the time under Robert Redfield’s CDC. On the 5th, Gao and his team were trying to isolate and culture the virus in all the cell lines they had. They even took lung tissue samples from acute patients. “We were prepared to try everything, but in the end, this particular coronavirus was so easy to grow,” he admitted. On the evening of the 6th, they saw the canonical picture of the coronavirus (the spikes around the viral particle that look like a crown) under the electron microscope. This would famously be published in <em>The Lancet,</em> a renowned medical journal, a few weeks later.</p><p>On January 10th, Dr. Gao would personally visit Wuhan. They would report the first fatal case a day later, on the 11th. The following day, Gao’s team had been taking environmental swabs from the Huanan market multiple times, a place epidemiologically linked to most early patients in the hospital. However, the municipal CCDC in Wuhan had discussed shutting down the market on December 31st late into the night, and on January 1st at 8:00 a.m., fully geared CCDC workers would disinfect it. “So, there was not much to see anymore,” George told me. Yet neither official source acknowledged human-to-human transmission.</p><p>Dr. Gao traveled back to Beijing only to return to Wuhan again a week later, on the 17th, with another expert committee to assess the worsening outbreak. By then, he told me, they all felt that this outbreak was very serious. Many healthcare workers were getting sick, too. In full PPE gear, Gao’s team would interview patients and doctors, whereas he would personally interrogate the directors of the various hospitals with coronavirus cases. They had to make an announcement. “We were always discussing when we should make this official announcement. We didn’t want to create a big panic; we wanted a chance to get the disease done.” It was a difficult balance to strike, given the rumors at the time. “I never spoke to the media before the 20th; because I am the director of the CDC, I cannot speak out without evidence… But we felt and we thought it was human-to-human transmission, but we need evidence [sic].” He was right; no matter if it is the Chinese CDC, WHO, or any other organization, scientific evidence is always much slower to come forward than speculations and rumors. When I asked him how he felt about this asymmetry, he finally dropped some of the self-promotion and got angry. “With all these conspiracy theories, what can you do as a scientist? You cannot do anything. All you can do is keep yourself quiet. Can you argue? You wanna quarrel with them? Fight with them? In the media? You’ll never have the end.”</p><p>In the months following January, Dr. Gao had been fiercely criticized for not announcing human-to-human transmission earlier, so I guess he felt the need to keep reiterating how he had always considered that there was human-to-human spread. It was a coronavirus, after all. That it would spread between humans was never in question. But how much? “MERS did not spread well between humans,” he offered as another example. One really needs evidence to substantiate and classify claims. “I tried really hard to never say anything wrong,” he defended himself. After that, he went on another round of deflection — “Americans and Europeans would not even wear masks” — and more self-promotion.</p><p>I asked him how he dealt with the pressure and never-ending criticism. “I don’t want to be in the spotlight, but it comes with the position; people put you in this position. If I did something wrong in the last three years, I cannot change history. If you tell me, ‘George, you did this or that wrong in 2020,’ … I know we have some lessons to learn, but that is not our Chinese culture to say. We only say we learn experiences [sic], not learn lessons.” He pointed out how the Germans officially admitted to the mistakes of the Second World War, but the Japanese never did. Any admission of failure comes with the threat of losing face. Being silent was a way to preserve it. “We never use the word ‘lesson’; you guys can use lesson.” He chuckled a bit at this cultural idiosyncrasy — maybe the one thing that was truly coming from him as a person, not him as a political tactician. He spent fifteen years living outside of China and was trained at Oxford and Harvard, he reminded me. He believed that he understood both cultures and that understanding had equipped him for his position. “If it were not me, with such a big pressure, the world would be different.” He reiterated this last point twice. I think he was correct, but whether it would have been better or worse if a less skilled politician had been in his influential role remains ​​open to interpretation.</p><p>The simple fact is that while Chinese scientists were well positioned, Chinese authorities had failed to learn some crucial lessons from the original SARS outbreak. They tried to control the message before the outbreak overwhelmed them. On January 3, 2020, after a week of rumors about a new SARS outbreak appeared on social media, a memo from the National Health Commission, one of China’s executive departments of the State Council, ordered the shutdown of all outbreak communication. Digital censors would filter and delete messages talking about the outbreak from Weibo, websites, and anywhere else online. In a situation where speed of communication is everything, artificial barriers to information flow can be a poisonous thorn. Even Chinese scientists were not allowed to talk to the press or release any data in an effort by authorities to keep a lid on this thing until they could figure out how to spin it. The authorities muzzled them and prohibited them from speaking with outsiders, at least in theory. Is it really any surprise that the rest of the world was suspicious?</p><p>There were rays of hope, though. I believe one has to understand that science is not only an engine for innovation or a way to get fancy new gadgets but has always functioned as a tool of global diplomacy. Even during the Cold War, scientific collaborations and trust built between researchers would often circumnavigate political nonsense. The Wuhan outbreak was no different. Despite the muzzle, information would be disclosed to academic collaborators. That is why many scientists in authoritarian countries will always be viewed with distrust by their own governments. They fear that a scientist’s loyalty to the truth is higher than their loyalty to the state. For Chinese scientists, working under these conditions was, and certainly still is, a difficult line to walk.</p><p>Few understand this better than evolutionary virologist Edward Holmes. The British-born scientist, who prefers to go by Eddie, holds a position at the University of Sydney in Australia, where studying viral emergence has been his career and life. In 2012, he became interested in working on emergent diseases in China and struck up several collaborations all over the country, including in Wuhan. One of these collaborators was Professor Zhang Yongzhen from the Shanghai Public Health Clinical Center, formerly of the CCDC as well. The two shared many common interests, including discovering novel RNA viruses and studying their evolution. Both saw the potential and power of metagenomic sequencing, a technique where all DNA or RNA sequences from within an environmental sample are amplified without bias. Metagenomic sequencing creates terabytes of data, and filtering through billions of genetic puzzle pieces while trying to stitch them together into novel and unknown genomes is a computationally challenging task that requires expertise, resources, and, of course, local collaboration to get relevant samples.</p><p>This hunt for relevant samples brought the two of them to Wuhan in 2014, where researchers from the municipal CCDC took them to the Huanan market as an example of where spillovers might happen. It was no secret that wildlife was sold there, often without the right permissions. Eddie snapped photos of caged raccoon dogs, potentially sick and held in cages in the corner of the western side of the market in unsanitary conditions, with other wildlife stacked below and above them. Eddie had always been interested in the animal-human interface, whereas Zhang was more focused on human pathogen surveillance. That is why the two also visited local hospitals. Zhang had an ambitious vision. He wanted to build a network of hospitals all over China that would collect samples from patients with respiratory symptoms and send them to him to search for new viral pathogens. Where better to find novel RNA viruses of relevance than in the obscure pneumonia cases all larger hospitals see but rarely resolve?</p><p>In the end, Zhang would manifest his human-centric vision of an alarm system for pneumonia cases. A system that would now deliver the first patient samples from Wuhan on January 3, 2020, to him. By January 5th, reportedly after 40 hours of straight-up work, team member Chen Yan-Mei had produced the first full genome sequence from these patient samples in his lab. It was a new SARS-related virus. Zhang raised the alarm with his contacts in Shanghai’s Health Authority and uploaded the new viral genome to Genbank under an embargo. “We wrote the paper in two days,” Eddie would later explain to me. On January 7th, they submitted a paper to the scientific journal <em>Nature</em>.</p><p>There was incredible urgency to be quick from a public health perspective, but we would be remiss not to note the prestige that comes with publishing. Zhang wanted to get the sequence out, but other Chinese groups, including George Gao’s CCDC and Shi Zhengli from WIV, were also trying to do so, and they had their genomes ready around the same time. The problem was the National Health Commission’s ban on releasing any data. For days, Eddie was urging Zhang for permission to release the genome, but the rules were clear. Zhang was likely torn from what I could gather. It seems to me that when Zhang visited Wuhan in person that week and saw the full scope of the emerging outbreak starting to overwhelm hospitals, he believe word needed to get out. An editor at the journal was pushing him to release the genome, and when Eddie called him when he was on his flight to Beijing, urging him once again to release the genome, he agreed. Zhang’s day had been as eye-opening as it was grim. “Eddie, I authorize you to release the data,” Eddie recalled their exchange. Fifty-two minutes after Eddie received the FASTA file containing the genome sequence, he released it on Zhang’s behalf to a virological website. It would become the global reference genome named Wuhan-Hu-1, the wild-type original SARS-CoV-2. The world would finally get to see the new virus.</p><p>And not a second too soon because just two days later, Thailand would report the first infected patient, identified by none other than Supaporn Wacharapluesadee, the Thai virus huntress I met in Chonburi. This alarm from the international spread put pressure and attention on the Chinese authorities to acknowledge human-to-human transmission, which they still had not confirmed with WHO.</p><p>Because of his decision to share data transparently, Zhang was named the “saving grace” of the pandemic by <em>Time</em> magazine, and the scientific journal <em>Nature</em> featured him in an article titled “Ten people who shaped science in 2020.” However, his actions were met with scorn and punishment inside China. The National Health Commission had previously reprimanded him with a “rectification” order, temporarily disallowing his team to study the virus. Officials came to “inspect” his lab based on bogus claims about biosafety protocols. They were there to put him on a leash. Silence would fall around him.</p><p>Since then, Zhang has consistently denied being reprimanded, reportedly arguing that he did not believe China was controlling information and that their response was simply based on caution due to false statements made by scientists about the first SARS outbreak. “Zhang is now not the same person as I knew him before,” Eddie shared with me. Years later, the ongoing conflict escalated publicly again, leading to Zhang and his team’s sudden eviction, which caused him to stage a protest. Dramatic pictures showed him sleeping in front of his office door with policemen surrounding him while students spoke up on his behalf, to no avail. In Eddie’s opinion, the authorities had long punished Zhang for disobeying the muzzle order; his eviction marked the end point of a four-year prosecution, even though he was not privy to the details.</p><p>There was also friction with Zhang’s release of the virus genome from other sources outside the health commission. In particular, Dr. George Gao from the CCDC felt someone had stolen his prestige. He had uploaded the first genome sequences from his patient samples to GISAID on January 9th (although Gao told me it was the 8th), and they were released by the 12th, a good day and a half after Eddie posted Zhang’s work. Zhang was the first, not him, because he broke the rules. Since then, Gao has used his power and influence to try to rewrite history, striking up a deal with the now controversial Peter Bogner and the database GISAID to retrospectively change the release date to January 10th so he would be first. Others also reported how GISAID bullied scientists into citing the bogus date on the GISAID genomes and removing citations from Zhang’s genome. Everything to create a thin paper trail to make it look like Gao and GISAID were the first.</p><p>In reality, neither Gao nor Zhang were truly the first.</p><p>On December 25th, the private sequencing company Vision Medicals, a sequencing service provider working with hospitals, had sequenced samples from a retired 65-year-old deliveryman who used to work at the Huanan seafood market and still spent a lot of time there. He was first admitted to Wuhan Central Hospital on December 18th. When a technician by the name of 小山狗 (Xiǎoshān Gǒu, or “Little Mountain Dog”) came to work on the morning of December 26th, she found that her software had flagged a few sequencing reads as belonging to a “sensitive pathogen,” something that seemed like a SARS coronavirus. “Feeling anxious, I quickly checked the detailed analysis data in the background and found that the similarity was not very high,” she would later write in her blog. She initiated a more detailed analysis, finding an 87% similarity to a bat SARS-related virus. But bat SARS are still classified under SARS, so she was worried and compared it to all published SARS-related genomes. She found the closest two — bat-SL-CoVZC45 and bat-SL-CoVZXC2 — sampled in 2018 in Zhoushan, Zhejiang Province. They would not remain the closest known relatives for long.</p><p>Dr. Shi Zhengli, now better known as “The Batwoman,” had been contacted by her boss at WIV around ten on the night of December 30th while she was in Shanghai for a meeting. Doctors from the Jinyintan hospital had reached out to WIV because they had nine patients with pneumonia of unknown etiology; the suspicion was SARS. Zhengli contacted students in her lab that same night; luckily, three of them were still working. She asked them to stay the night and test the samples. They ran a pan-PCR test for general coronaviruses, as well as a few qRT-PCR probes more specifically for SARS-related coronaviruses. Four and five patient samples tested positive, respectively. “We believed the results. But I could not believe the results, you know?” she recalled for me. “That was not possible. We always said, ‘Oh, one day it will come,’ and it really came.” Her lab was working with coronaviruses; could this be one of the viruses they were working with? She described to me how she felt upset, her hand waving up and down in front of her body. At first, they could not get the full genome sequence, so they could not compare it with what they had in the lab. Only by lunchtime could one of her colleagues get a hold of the virus sequence that Little Mountain Dog had assembled via a hospital sample. The new virus was nothing they had ever seen, isolated, or worked on. “So I feel relieved,” she admitted. No scientist takes lab safety lightly, and Zhengli, who was trained in the West, was no different. But she, like everybody else, has never encountered this novel virus before.</p><p>That being said, her extensive work on collecting bat samples ​​paid off. Within her database, there was a pretty close match to a bat coronavirus her team had collected in Yunnan, Southern China. It was a big deal, pointing to the origin of the new virus being bats again. Soon, she would publish the genome sequence extracted from that bat fecal swab, named RaTG13, and with its publication, her troubles would begin (more on that later). Back in the first days of January, her team also managed to sequence the full-length genome of the novel virus from the patient samples the hospital sent them. Zhengli was very proud of her team because they got the full genome, even with the very last base pairs at the end — the trickiest part of the assembly. Her genome sequence was the cleanest with lots of read support; a fact she would be really proud of.</p><p>To sum up, within a week of clinicians raising the alarm, three different labs and one sequencing company had identified and sequenced the novel virus causing sickness, which I personally find rather impressive. Even today, there is a broad agreement that nobody had ever seen this novel virus before, and there was a collective effort to identify, sequence, and understand what was happening to patients in Wuhan hospitals. Most Chinese doctors and scientists did their part to quickly help decision-makers have good information for dealing with the outbreak. And yet, upholding appearances and hierarchical politics seemed to somehow have thrown sand into some of those efficient gears. Limiting the free flow of information, muzzling what scientists can say and to whom, and trying to downplay rumors and control narratives slowed down our collective understanding. Much of that continues to this day. Some Chinese scientists get punished for breaking these rules; some do the best they can within the system, and others try to navigate it to their advantage.</p><p>In my interview with the accomplished Dr. Gao, getting all the credit for “being first to publish the genome” counted more than sharing pesky details and messy efforts from many scientists to identify and understand this new virus. After his shenanigans with the GISAID database, today he would turn around and claim that because a journal (<em>The Lancet </em>in this case) quoted his GISAID genomes as being the first, it proved that he was indeed the first. After a tedious interview, I felt very little desire to stroke his ego, so our conversation dried up. Either way, he was a good reminder of how personal ambition and politics can tempt even very accomplished scientists down the wrong path of fiction and falsehood. In the larger picture, Dr. Gao’s petty attempts to rewrite his role were a rather mundane quibble left for the history books, inconsequential to how we understood the novel threat. Few citizens of the world had any idea what a way-less accomplished scientist might do when faced with the tragic outbreak of a novel virus and the opportunity to become famous.</p><p>Dr. Li-Meng Yan is our first example of one such scientist. Scarlett — as Jasnah Kholin would call her former acquaintance from Hong Kong University by her Western name — was a rather unremarkable postdoc. Yet, in just a few months, the black-haired woman with the square glasses and monotonous, almost robotic voice would leverage her scientific affiliations into stardom. Dr. Leo Poon, a viral disease expert whose excellent lab develops diagnostic tools, hired her in 2015 to conduct experiments with a hamster animal model system to evaluate some of the diagnostic tests the lab was investigating. I tracked down the soft-spoken professor because I wanted to know who Scarlett was before she became a media sensation. Leo explained his lab’s focus and that Scarlett had been a hard worker. At the time, her experimental work was focused on studying influenza virus transmission and testing attenuated influenza vaccines in mice. Until January 2020, Scarlett had never even worked with coronaviruses, according to Leo.</p><p>“I had no idea what she was up to,” he would tell me. Leo Poon, like other Hong Kong academics, had been preparing for the worst early on. In 2003, he and his colleague Malik Peiris first isolated a coronavirus from samples of 50 pneumonic patients in Hong Kong and identified this as the infectious agent causing SARS. Their findings and groundbreaking paper on the novel virus would make them famous among academics. Back then, Leo had developed the diagnostic PCR test for SARS, and when he saw the official “red-head” notice from the Wuhan authorities in late December, he began preparing himself mentally to do the same again with the new virus. With a grim sense of foreboding, he pulled genomic sequences of SARS-related viruses from databases and started constructing various primers from consensus regions — genomic regions that had high similarity — to test specificity even before the first genome would be published. He wanted to be ready and have the system up and running for when the genome of the new virus would be released. Speed is critical.</p><p>Scarlett might have felt bored about her influenza vaccine work, and she had not been very happy over the years with how little impact and recognition her work entailed. Leo remembered how she always wanted “to be more,” attempted to request first authorship on a paper to which her contribution was not substantial enough to warrant such a demand, and sought to work on projects that were outside the scope of his lab. She pushed him to let her speak at seminars for more exposure or invite guests to the lab by leveraging his name. But science can be very frustrating in that way. Except for some extremely lucky or extraordinary circumstances, scientific work and recognition are slow, gradual, and almost never reach the wider public.</p><p>From my perspective and that of people who knew her, it seemed that even after years in a great lab, success did not come fast enough for Scarlett. Like many junior academics hungry for impact, maybe she also desired to be the one to find something that would make her famous.</p><p>On January 13th, a bit more than a day after Zhang’s SARS-CoV-2 genome was published online, SARS-veteran Professor Yuen Kwok-Yung gave an interview to a local Hong Kong newspaper that most likely caught Scarlett’s attention. By comparing the genome sequences to published coronaviruses and placing them into a basic phylogenetic family tree like Little Mountain Dog did a few weeks prior, he explained that, while the new virus is genetically distant from the SARS of 2003, the original source might have been bats. He also highlighted that two bat viruses with around 90% similarity, sampled in 2018 in Zhoushan, Zhejiang Province, were the closest relatives of the new virus. The archipelago south of Shanghai in the East China Sea was over 1000 kilometers away from Wuhan. “However, the reason for the similarity of the coronaviruses in the two places is not yet known,” he was quoted as saying. Little did he know that his words would contribute to setting a course of action in motion that would shake the world. Scientific mysteries invite speculation, and Scarlett possibly saw an opportunity to solve that particular mystery of why these geographically distant viruses were so similar.</p><p>She looked up the 2018 study he was referencing. It had the apt title, “Genomic characterization and infectivity of a novel SARS-like coronavirus in Chinese bats.” A basic internet search highlighted that the scientists who discovered these bat viruses were affiliated with a military medical university. Jasnah had explained to me how Scarlett was deeply distrustful of the CCP, so it did not take much for her to believe that maybe there was a hidden human connection between the Wuhan outbreak and these bat viruses named ZC45 and ZXC21. After all, why were the two closest viral relatives to the novel virus both discovered by scientists affiliated with the Chinese military? How could a new virus emerge 1,000 kilometers away in a city with one of China’s two high-security BSL-4 labs? Maybe there was a deeper reason why Chinese authorities have not been transparent about the outbreak and lied about human-to-human transmission. It likely seemed to be too much of a coincidence for her, but we can only speculate about the full scope of her motives.</p><p>She certainly was not the only one in Hong Kong who distrusted anything and everything coming from China. “Honestly, it doesn’t take much for certain people. Moving outside of the PRC [People’s Republic of China] for any reason and realizing that you have basically been fed a carefully crafted lie your entire life is not exactly a comforting experience,” Jasnah elaborated. She had seen this many times before when Chinese students were moving to Hong Kong. The change in the information environment often leads to a change in their worldview. As for Scarlett, Jasnah told me she had been “a regular watcher” of YouTuber and supposed Chinese dissident Wang Dinggang, who broadcasts under the name of Lu De. For years, he has built a name for himself by attacking the CCP on YouTube. He railed against China’s crackdown on Muslims and pontificated on the US trade war. Scarlett possibly saw an opportunity for recognition, or maybe just a need to share, so she reached out to him and offered her suspicions about the new virus.</p><p>It is unclear whether she knew — or even cared about — how much her suspicions would be capitalized on by bad actors at the time. When a group of US-based Chinese influencers suddenly started distributing the first social media posts, videos, and articles in Chinese on January 18th that highlighted these spurious connections to ZC45, ZXC21, and the Chinese military, few consumers within the Chinese-speaking community were aware that the information flooding their news feeds was inauthentic. They had no idea that the information being released was made up for a specific purpose: to manipulate them. “The media outlets that cater to the Chinese diaspora — a jumble of independent websites, YouTube channels, and Twitter accounts with anti-Beijing leanings — have formed a fast-growing echo chamber for misinformation. With few reliable Chinese-language news sources to fact-check them, rumors can quickly harden into a distorted reality,” <em>The New York Times</em> would later report about this ecosystem. Only with some hindsight can we reconstruct where all the activity was coming from at the time.</p><p>The ringleader behind these sets of rumors was Ho Wan Kwok (also known as Guo Wengui or Miles Kwok), better known as Miles Guo. He was a reportedly corrupt billionaire and self-proclaimed dissident who fled China in 2014 after sniffing out that he was going to be arrested under allegations of bribery, money laundering, fraud, and rape. Profiting from shady construction deals and political maneuvering for decades, Guo was, at the time, the 73rd richest person in China when his political network was slowly being dismantled by Xi Jinping’s anti-corruption campaign. He was losing influence. Before investigators could reach him, he took his money and ran.</p><p>Ever since, the exiled tycoon has lived lavishly in the US and found a new political home within the Trump-associated MAGA movement in the US, being a frequent guest at ​​Mar-a-Lago and a close collaborator of then-President Trump’s advisor and Breitbart founder Steve Bannon. In 2018, Guo, with the help of Bannon, entered the media game and trademarked Guo Media, a social media video and broadcasting service owned as a foreign business corporation by a shell company in Delaware. He would later also be the funding source behind Gettr, a Twitter clone and alt-tech social media platform targeting American conservatives that was founded by Jason Miller, a former Donald Trump aide. Miles Guo and Trump’s inner circle had a shared interest in undermining the Chinese government, and Bannon received over a million dollars in consulting fees from Guo, according to investigative reports. With their near-daily video commentary, Guo and Bannon’s opinion pieces would flood GNews, and they accumulated a decent following, especially among the Chinese-speaking diaspora, who saw Guo as some kind of anti-CCP warrior and hero, a false image he crafted for himself.</p><p>The billionaire has also cultivated a set of popular influencers and dissidents to boost his profile, including John Pan, who was among Mr. Guo’s inner circle until December 2019. A dissident, Mr. Pan would later explain to ABC News Australia how he became trapped in Guo’s anti-CCP activism and how he and the initial 18 members of the inner circle discussed how to orchestrate viral media campaigns against the CCP. “We’re talking about how we would promote the information that Guo was leaking out, how we spread that information to the world. No matter [if it was] true or false,” Mr. Pan was quoted as saying by the news organization. He explained, as an example, how Guo once encouraged his key followers during the 2019 Hong Kong democracy protests to spread a rumor that martial law was imminent in the territory. People predisposed to this kind of messaging in times of crisis ate it up uncritically, and Guo’s followership and influence grew, especially in Hong Kong, where there was a massive hunger for CCP-independent information in Chinese, and he was pumping out propaganda content daily.</p><p>When the outbreak in Wuhan emerged in early 2020, it presented a tremendous opportunity for Guo’s operation. On January 18th, Miles Guo created the marching orders and, in a live stream, passed them to his followers. Together with Lu De, his “chief propagandist,” he used Scarlett’s suspicions and persona to concoct a bioweapon myth based on the spurious connections to the 2018 bat viruses. Some of Guo’s sock puppet accounts (fictitious social media accounts controlled by somebody else) are still visible today. They would all blast out the same copy-pasted message:</p><blockquote><em>武汉的类SARS冠状病毒就是来源于中共军方2018年从舟山蝙蝠身上发现并分离的新型冠状病毒。如图改病毒序列可以在美国国立卫生研究院的基因数据库找到（NIH的GenBank)，由南京军区军事医学科学研究所递交。并且通过技术故意更改舟山蝙蝠病毒，适于人类传播的新病毒.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>Translation: </em>The SARS-like coronavirus in Wuhan originated from a new type of coronavirus discovered and isolated from bats in Zhoushan by the Chinese military in 2018. The virus sequence shown in the picture can be found in the gene database of the National Institutes of Health (NIH’s GenBank), and submitted by the Institute of Military Medical Sciences of the Nanjing Military Region. And the Zhoushan bat virus was intentionally changed through technology, a new virus suitable for human transmission.</blockquote><p>These identical messages contained the same images: one was a screenshot of the GenBank (the US National Institute of Health’s sequence repository) website showing the 2018 bat virus entries, and the second was of the 2018 publication with the military hospital affiliation of the last author highlighted separately. Disinformation often uses real but decontextualized information as the supposed “source” for its false or manipulative claims. There was no question that all of these identical posts came from the same originator. It was low-effort but effective. Dozens, if not hundreds, of sock puppet accounts and bots would amplify this message on Twitter, Facebook, WeChat, Weibo, and other social media platforms. Lu De and other influencers in Guo’s network would do the same. The groundwork had been laid, and audiences were primed.</p><p>On January 19th, the influencer Lu De would put on a suit and get ready for his show. In his 80-minute episode devoted to an “unnamed whistle-blower” (later revealed to be Scarlett), Lu De boasted that he had heard from “the world’s absolute top coronavirus expert” some troubling news that China was not being transparent. The Chinese military had actually created the virus. “I think this is very believable and very scary,” he said. Broadcast on GNews, Vimeo, and YouTube and then amplified by his tens of thousands of followers, his show hit like a bomb, with hundreds of thousands of clicks and engagements. The other influencers in Guo’s network followed suit, with the inner group alone reaching around 143 million views in the following weeks, according to an investigation by the Digital Forensics Research Lab, an organization that tracks disinformation.</p><p>Yet this first media blitz would only be the beginning of their success story. Guo’s biggest move was still a few months out. Scarlett was to assume a much bigger and way more controversial role, maybe the one she always wanted. Leo Poon warned me that he might not want to answer any more questions about her because “I am sure she will use all my comments on her to promote herself and to discredit science. I personally do not want to give her any chance to make up new stories. Of this reason [sic], I might refuse to answer questions about her.” Jasnah was equally dismayed. “I swear, if that whole fucking thing comes back to Miles fucking Guo, I don’t know what I would do,” was her response when I laid out how I viewed this particular origin of the bioweapon myth. We humans like to believe that if circumstances had just been a bit more favorable, maybe events could have played out quite differently. Unfortunately, the reality was not that simple.</p><p>I have been sifting through early reporting to investigate where the different “man-made” conspiracy theories originated. Reconstruction is a tedious task, eating away hours after hours; sitting many late nights chasing down outdated links and articles and deleted social media posts in the internet archive with tools like the Wayback Machine. However, when taken together with first-hand accounts from people on the ground who lived through it, a fuller picture emerges. Rumors, myths, and controversy after outbreaks are common, maybe even unavoidable. Every single outbreak, from the plague to the various influenza pandemics to “SARS, MERS, EBOLA, ZIKA, you name it,” Leo Poon would finish my exact thoughts. Each one of them was followed by conspiracy theories that blamed humans for it, and a substantial number of people were willing to believe any explanation given, no matter how absurd. The best I can tell is that we humans have a tendency to seek and see agency behind grand catastrophes. We also tend to assign blame to an outgroup when things go wrong.</p><p>The bat viruses collected in 2018 in Zhoushan might have been the earliest of the man-made conspiracy theories that received inauthentic amplification and went viral, but Miles Guo and his gang of influencers were, of course, not the only ones who tapped into the political moment. General anxiety and uncertainty at the beginning of any crisis lend themselves to media manipulation. In fact, multiple related origin myths would emerge separately and almost simultaneously all over the world, sometimes mingling and converging topically but gradually and independently gaining more attention.</p><p>For example, on January 20th, Russian disinformation operations in state media started to pick up on the man-made theme, albeit with a twist: they platformed self-proclaimed biosecurity expert Igor Nikulin, a political activist with no discernable expertise, who argued that the US created the virus and used it to attack China. He first expressed this belief on <em>Zvezda</em>, a state media outlet tied to the Russian military, and repeated it dozens of times in other interviews with mainstream outlets that seemed to eat it up uncritically. This facade of laundering information through supposed independent voices and intermediaries is neither new nor unexpected from Russia. The KGB had run a similar disinformation campaign in the 1980s, today known as “Операция Инфекция,” a.k.a. Operation Infection (originally Operation Denver), to blame the emergent AIDS pandemic on their foreign adversary, the US. Iran and China would follow this playbook in due time.</p><p>In the US, on January 21st, a QAnon influencer expressing strong anti-vaccine sentiments named Jordan Sather picked up and amplified to his hundreds of thousands of followers a different conspiracy myth, creating roots for a set of ideas that would later resurface occasionally under the name “Plandemic.” He alleged that the pandemic was man-made for nefarious purposes, such as selling vaccines for profit. His evidence? Links to an old patent entry. He claimed researchers had produced a vaccine against the new virus, but now the patent was about to expire. That patent he linked to does, in fact, exist. It was work that was partially supported by grants from the Bill Gates Foundation and pharmaceutical companies. What a coincidence, he echoed on social media. <em>“Was the release of this disease planned? Is the media being used to incite fear around it? Is the Cabal desperate for money, so they’re tapping their Big Pharma reserves? Are there vaccines already being manufactured to “fight” this?”</em> Sather did not realize or care that the patent in question was for a vaccine against SARS that broke out in 2003, not SARS-CoV-2. But of course, he did not need to get the facts right; his posts prompted countless online engagements all the same, spreading the patent myth far and wide.</p><p>​​​A few days later on January 23, with a veneer of serious reporting, the UK tabloid <em>Daily Mail</em> amplified another very influential myth that would also spread like wildfire. A Western scientist wrote in a 2017 <em>Nature News</em> article a warning about how the Chinese culture of hiding problems and lack of transparency might pose an issue for working in BSL-4 labs like in Wuhan. The <em>Daily Mail</em>’s insinuation was clear: The new virus might have leaked from this lab in Wuhan because of bad biosafety. The article bolstered its claims with the commentary of a bioweapon fearmonger who had an axe to grind with virological biosafety for years. It gave a veneer of serious reporting. However, BSL-4 labs only work with <em>known</em>, very dangerous pathogens, not random bat viruses whose pathogenicity has not been characterized yet. Ordinary bat viruses cannot infect humans, so they could be studied under BSL-2 at the time. But the high-security BSL-4 sounded more dangerous, so it was good for headlines. That any such proposed lab accident from a BSL-4 lab would have, by necessity, required knowledge and documentation of this hitherto unseen virus first, or that no unknown virus ever leaked from a high biosafety lab to the best of our knowledge, was conveniently withheld from readers.</p><p>On January 23, 2020, Wuhan, a megacity of 11 million, went into lockdown. Outbound public transport was suspended. Public activities were canceled. Flights got grounded. Panic set in. The news sent shockwaves around the world. The outbreak in Wuhan had been a narrow issue for most of the world until this point. Suddenly, it really captured the attention and imagination of the masses. The infosphere exploded into overdrive. With a large global audience came a huge market demand for more outbreak information and answers, a need that scientists and institutions could not satisfy immediately. However, commentators, bloggers, and influencers were all too happy to fill those gaps with more rumors, speculations, and falsehoods, often by scraping together bits and pieces from dubious internet sources and Google searches. Speed over accuracy is how you make gains in the attention economy. It was like putting gasoline on a fire. With the media attention surrounding the dramatic lockdown announcements, conspiracy theories exploded into the mainstream. The early conspiracy theories received the biggest amplification from crowd-sourced interest. It’s called first-mover advantage. Everybody was sharing, retweeting, and commenting on content that featured the Wuhan outbreak and the mysterious virus as its topic.</p><p>On January 25, Guo Media’s GNews announced in an article that the CCP admitted to the bioweapon release — a complete fabrication — by providing a Word document full of “evidence” for the bioweapon. That document included screenshots Guo and his network had spread before, along with some loose commentary and descriptions to create the superficial appearance of merit. It was happily picked up by fringe and right-wing media as well as partisans.</p><p>On January 26, the obscure Indian blogger Great Game India amplified social media chatter by publishing an article titled <em>Coronavirus Bioweapon — How China Stole Coronavirus from Canada and Weaponized It</em>. The piece was a complete fabrication, distorting a legitimate July 2019 report from Canada. Around the same time, the U.S. partisan tabloid <em>The</em> <em>Washington</em> <em>Times</em> picked up similar rumors, blending <em>Daily Mail</em> reporting from three days earlier about biosafety concerns with baseless speculations from a questionable Israeli intelligence analyst. This analyst reiterated the false Canadian spy story and claimed the Wuhan Institute of Virology (WIV) was involved in bioweapons research. The narrative, fueled by the Israeli bioweapon analyst’s claim, quickly gained traction within right-wing media circles.</p><p>On January 29, the blogging outlet Zerohedge started doxxing a Chinese scientist, accusing him of being responsible for the pandemic. The outrage that followed the blaming of an individual was good for amplification; major media outlets would cover these lies in an attempt to debunk them, but this only added to their spread. The poor scientist’s name, photograph, telephone number, and email address were shared over 11,500 times on Twitter. Zerohedge would later be temporarily banned on Twitter for doxxing because it violated company policies. But this was only after the blogger pulled off his biggest stunt two days later.</p><p>On January 30, Indian researchers published a preprint finding an “uncanny similarity of unique inserts” in the spike protein, identical to peptide fragments found in HIV. The uncanny sequences were just arising out of coincidence, and the preprint would be withdrawn later, but not before amplifiers on social media picked up on it and ran their mouths off. In parallel, foreign policy hawks like Francis Boyle and US senators like Tom Cotton were publicly entertaining the idea that the new virus was a bioweapon or could have come from the Wuhan BSL-4 lab.</p><p>On January 31, ZeroHedge dramatically amplified the bioweapon myth by creating a fairytale based on merging many circulating themes. A chimera bioweapon myth, if you will. Integrating the <em>Daily Mail</em> reporting about biosafety warnings, the pick-up of Great Game India’s Canadian spies, the fresh preprint about supposed HIV sequences found, and the scientists he felt justified doxxing two days earlier, the blogger built an engaging storyline for his audience that included many of the prevailing themes and sentiments. The emotional truth of the narrative went along the lines of “Chinese scientists have ulterior motives; they wanted to create a bioweapon, but WIV was lacking biosafety, and it escaped.” True or not, it was a sentiment so powerful that it would never leave the conversation again in US right-wing ideological circles, and often beyond.</p><p>These were, of course, only a fraction of the early narratives bubbling up in various corners around the world. Nobody can accurately trace them all, figure out where exactly they all came from, or identify who was “patient zero” for their spread. The only thing that we can say for sure is that after the dramatic lockdown announcement in Wuhan brought global attention, a week of wild speculations, viral conspiracy theories, and crowd-sourced myth-making followed. Everybody wanted to talk about it and be seen talking about it. Within that week, the dynamics of our global interconnected information systems made sure that the unsubstantiated idea of a man-made virus would be broadcast all around the world. China might have wanted to control rumors and craft its heroic response narrative, but its mantle of silence did not extinguish the fire; it fueled the flames.</p><p>Aristotle famously claimed that nature abhors a vacuum. After spending way too much time on social media over the last few years, I became pretty convinced that, just as nature fears a void, the internet fears an information vacuum. Whether fiction or fact, truth or trickery, myth, magical thinking, or outright manipulation, whatever is offered seems to be more desirable to us than having to wait for information. This is human. Especially in times of ambiguity and dire peril, we tend to prioritize information speed over accuracy.</p><p>Consequences be damned.</p><p>Excerpted from <em>Lab Leak Fever: The COVID-19 Origin Theory that Sabotaged Science and Society</em> by Philipp Markolin.</p><p>Copyright © 2025 by Philipp Markolin. All rights reserved.</p><p>If you are interested in the origin of the pandemic, and the manipulation campaigns around it, you can find more information about the book here: <a href="http://www.lab-leak-fever.com/">www.lab-leak-fever.com</a></p><ul><li>Release day in Germany/Austria/Switzerland: 20. April 2025 (<a href="https://www.amazon.de/Das-Laborfieber-Ursprungstheorie-Wissenschaft-Gesellschaft-ebook/dp/B0F3DMHBSB">buy here</a>)</li><li>Release day Global: TBD*</li></ul><p>*Due to geopolitical sensitivities, this book is currently unavailable outside of Germany, Switzerland, and Austria. <a href="https://www.volkskrant.nl/wetenschap/zijn-uitgever-durft-dit-boek-over-de-lablektheorie-niet-uit-te-brengen-de-wetenschap-is-de-informatieoorlog-aan-het-verliezen~b1586aa6/">My US publisher deemed the risks to severe to go forward with the book after the US elections</a>, and I can not blame them. But that means that US/UK readers and elsewhere will have to be patient, while I am looking for support and solutions to make this story available to everybody eventually.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*7ocvCnF5gg59yZSU.png" /></figure><h3>Free Access to read-only version:</h3><p>While I can not gift away the books for free because of printing and other costs; I believe <strong>this topic is too important to be kept behind a paywall</strong>.</p><p>Anybody who wants to read how the pandemic began deserves access to good information; so if you can not afford to buy the book or ebook, please reach out to me with a quick explanation and I will provide access to a <strong>digital reader-only version* for free</strong> that can not be downloaded and copied, no questions asked.</p><p>Just go to <a href="https://www.lab-leak-fever.com/contact">www.lab-leak-fever.com</a> and write in the form below “<strong>Digital reader-only version</strong>” and a sentence or two about your circumstances (for example: <em>“Hi, I am a student in Austria/Mexico/Thailand, can’t afford to buy but really want to read it”</em>) and I will grant access to the book to you via your email address.</p><p>*this offer is subject to release date of the English version for readers outside of Germany, Austria and Switzerland. By gaining access to the readers-only version, the reader promises to not share, copy, distribute, claim copyright or commercialize the content of the book in any shape or form. Infringement of these conditions might be subject to legal action.</p><p>Please consider sharing this post so more people can learn the insider story behind the pandemic origin controversy.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=786c659a20bb" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[How social media destroys democratic discourse, explained in 6 easy figures]]></title>
            <link>https://protagonist-science.medium.com/how-social-media-destroys-democratic-discourse-explained-in-6-easy-figures-bd40e96ed04a?source=rss-c8e0e038559d------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/bd40e96ed04a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[democracy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[polarization]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[social-media]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Philipp Markolin]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 22 Jan 2025 22:44:12 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-01-22T22:44:12.009Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Where we all went wrong</h3><p>An evidence-based worldview has come under attack from <a href="https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/19401612241311886">rightwing populist movements all around the world</a>. Fueling the rise of these precarious political parties is a broken information ecosystem that came about by the technological disruption of the information age, especially the social media platform giants of the web 2.0.</p><p>It seems that only now people begin to truly realize that silicon valley moved fast and broke things, with no idea of how to put back together the pieces.</p><p>Many still dispute what exactly went wrong; misinformation, polarization, extremism, algorithms, influence operations … a long list of symptoms and culprits are offered; but no coherent picture of how they all relate to each other.</p><p>So maybe I can share how I think about the bigger picture after spending a great deal immersing myself in the topic; and lay out, as simple as I can, what goes wrong in the information ecosystems we currently inhabit.</p><p>Let us look at 6 major drivers that broke our information ecosystems and led to our fall into myth, manipulation and magical thinking.</p><p>As always, there is a handy summary infographic, free to use:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*40-NW85MJLn9sAmi-tGwHA.png" /></figure><h3>1) The attention economy commercialized information, altering how we treat and value information.</h3><p>The commercialization of attention has turned information from something we traditionally used to “inform ourselves” about the world into a product we create, amplify and exchange for popularity, persuasion, profit or power. The “informational value” (truth, accuracy, relevance, context) of that product is secondary, what counts is its “informational impact”, how well it furthers the strategic goals of the creator/amplifier/consumer.</p><p>This shift in how we treat information has created many asymmetries between what information products are successful online; and unfortunately, facts currently always lose out. Facts are<strong> less profitable that falsehoods</strong>, facts <strong>spread worse than fictions </strong>that serve the powerful or the popular; and facts are <strong>less common</strong> <strong>in our spaces</strong>, drowned out by the abundance of ideologically motivated garbage takes. If all information products exist on a spectrum between very factual and very false, imagine various forces pushing the levers strongly to one side over the other.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*L9CdM3gFp4P1QCVm.png" /></figure><h3>2) Social media supercharges processes leading to community and identity formation</h3><p>In a <a href="https://www.routledge.com/Intimate-Communities-of-Hate-Why-Social-Media-Fuels-Far-Right-Extremism/Tornberg-Tornberg/p/book/9780367622039?srsltid=AfmBOoo0U-MrQfI0aiK2tm0aVH30KzVTq3hmhGkqjJr4-xbjW02MckSe">fascinating book by Prof. Petter Törnberg</a>, a computational sociologist who studies extremist online communities with NLP-based methods, the researcher describes how “discursive spaces” always shape the ideas, communities and identities of the people participating in said environment. We humans use stories to make sense of our world, and doing it together with others endows us with a sense of meaning and belonging to our tribe. Breaking down his full argument can be a bit lengthy (it is a book that I recommend highly), but here is my short-version of how social media funnels us into niche online communities and creates a social information environment.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*6Ts9h-VKE6PFDl9A.png" /></figure><h3>The trifecta of crowds, algorithms and influencers create viral narratives that shape public discourse</h3><p>People are probably very familiar now with <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Invisible-Rulers-People-Turn-Reality/dp/1541703375">Renée DiResta’s Invisible Rulers</a> book, which I will happily count among the most important books of the year. In what she aimed to be a sequel to Chomsky’s and Herman’s <em>Manufacturing Consent</em>, the propaganda researcher describes how public discourse is now shaped by a set of new forces in our midst; namely platform algorithms, influencers and (activist) crowds.</p><p>I think what is important to understand is that each ingredient needs the other two to thrive. Influencers rise from the crowd because they are perceived as authentic representatives of a niche community, they serve as the conduit (or conductor) of the emotional energy of crowds while “up-selling” their raw emotions into often profound-sounding rationalizations that inspire trust or admiration and spread well. After an initial boost from their niche community, influencers also get new crowds to engage with their content, which signals to algorithms that more people should be exposed to that content. This in turn increases the size of the crowd that can sustain the success of an influencer and the co-created narrative this growing niche community drives into virality.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*zb2wfqajhHxb4jAL.png" /></figure><h3>Viral narratives shape public participation, and with it, social graphs, along the most efficient amplification cascades</h3><p>On social media, we constantly make the binary decision to buy or reject information products in the form of engagement and sharing. When an influencer engages with a piece of content, his followers see this and might be nudged to make the same decision to engage. If a piece of content has been visibly engaged with by multiple people in our social circle, our decision to engage with it becomes more likely. After all, we want to participate in the conversation with our peers and signal our allegiance. At some point, after seeing almost everybody engaging with a specific information product, our supposedly private choice to engage becomes a near certainty. Our social network compels us to engage, and our decision to do so further influences others after us to engage as well. By being part of a specific social group and engaging with a specific information product the same way, we have become part of an information cascade amplifying the information, a stepping stone on its way into virality.</p><p>But information cascades on social media do more than make things go viral; they teach the algorithms what content and associated social relationships influence our decisions to engage. And inversely, the algorithms learn which of our connections and friends are less relevant to create ever higher likelihoods of us participating in such social information cascades. This leads to a radical social sorting over time.</p><p>Network studies showed that participation in “<a href="https://dl.acm.org/doi/10.1145/2566486.2568043">Tweet cascades increase the similarity between connected users, as users lose ties to more dissimilar users and add new ties to similar users</a>” and that “<a href="https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8685718/">Twitter users who follow and share more polarized news coverage tend to lose social ties to users of the opposite ideology.</a>”</p><p>Again, here is a very simple figure of how the social topology of our personal network changes; we lose connections to people who do not agree with us, while we elevate some influencers in our midst.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*-zPmajZ_qQ-15gzm.png" /></figure><h3>Altered information flow leads to tribally motivated rationalizations, fragmentation of reality perceptions, and bespoke worldviews</h3><p>Good information rarely reaches people unfiltered by influencers anymore. The socially restructured crowds, in turn, look for influencers and conduits who could channel their feelings, biases and preferences into viral narratives while working to sway, subvert, or discredit the traditional gatekeepers of information flow, such as institutions or media.</p><p>Over years, the actions of online culture warriors and tribal gladiators have carved up society into factions with the help of algorithms and asymmetrically engaged crowds. Engagement algorithms made sure to remove the friction for information flow within these socially restructured amplification networks while building barriers to them for outsiders.</p><p>Once our social networks have been completely restructured along lowest common denominator lines, such as partisanship or conspiratorial worldview, building bridges and good-faith discussions between opposing camps becomes almost impossible. We inhabit bespoke realities where no consensus on what is real or true exists anymore.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*kPWyoQ10V3l-ylfC.png" /></figure><h3>In the all-versus-all war between polarized factions, power and might, not evidence, science or rationality, shapes politics and our understanding of the world.</h3><p>We need a shared set of facts to function in a democracy; without them, any collaboration on shared issues becomes impossible.</p><blockquote>Without facts, you can’t have truth. Without truth, you can’t have trust. Without all three, we have no shared reality, and democracy as we know it — and all meaningful human endeavors — are dead. —</blockquote><blockquote>Maria Ressa, Nobel Laureate</blockquote><p>I believe that today, an entirely new front of informational conflicts has opened between shared reality and our digital world.</p><p>In a world fragmented by increasingly bespoke reality perceptions, science, facts, rationality have become an existential threat to most of our cherished co-created beliefs and worldviews; an unwelcome challenge to our recently developed online politics, identity, and community. These frictions can quickly lead to conflict between warring tribes and ideologies; and between two camps completely detached from facts and rationality, no common ground can be found anymore. Might makes right.</p><blockquote>“Once you get into this world where truth is a subset of power, it basically means that you can’t have democratic debate anymore,” - <em>Kyiv-born journalist and propaganda researcher </em><strong><em>Peter Pomerantsev</em></strong><em> in his Atlantic podcast</em> <em>Autocracy in America</em></blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*fm5MmVZ7Q2Uz1Og-.png" /></figure><h3>The endresult?</h3><p>The technological disruption of the information age has changed how society values and treats information; instead of using information to “inform and educate” ourselves about the world we live in, we use information now as a tool for popularity, profit, persuasion or power. And some who are really successful at doing so become new powerholders in our midst, shaping our discourse. We have created an information environment where the most ruthless velocity hackers are rewarded for creating the most compelling motivated rationalizations for the most enaging viral narratives.</p><p>Information is coercive. What we see online and what narratives we will buy into is not fully our choice, but a feature of our social and information environment in the first place. So once the addictive pull of viral narratives invites our participation, we can become manipulated by them.</p><p>Social media platforms are designed to supercharge emotional energy, introducing us to niche communities where we co-create and shape the viral narratives ever further until they become self-sustaining fan-fiction universes with little attachment to factual reality.</p><p>Even worse, once our continuous participation build allegiance to our niche communities and we form our online identities around these fan fiction universes, they shape our worldview and reshape our social connections. From that point forward, any contradictory information is often perceived as a threat to us and our tribe, and anybody holding a different worldview becomes “the other”, an enemy to defeat.</p><p>Consensus finding, and democratic discourse, becomes increasingly impossible between worldviews that are based on participatory fan fictions, not scientific reality or rational thinking.</p><p>In contrast, the tribal polarization within bespoke worldviews empowers a different type of politics; one of constant existential threat, and desire for dominance and strongmen. Especially fascism is an ideology of “us-versus-them”, a movement based on participatory myth-making about the superiority of one’s ingroup, nation and ideology facing the constant threat of enemies from without and within.</p><p>So this is where we are today.</p><p>The only antidote is for us to embrace and defend an evidence-based worldview, a seemingly simple thing has become an act of courage and defiance to fascism these days.</p><p>So to all of you out there:</p><p><strong>Be safe, stay smart, and let’s connect with other defenders of an evidence-based worldview out there to hold the line for democracy.</strong></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=bd40e96ed04a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Treacherous ancestry]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/advances-in-biological-science/treacherous-ancestry-b59614b92f3d?source=rss-c8e0e038559d------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b59614b92f3d</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[gain-of-function]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[covid-origin]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[science-communication]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[long-reads]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Philipp Markolin]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 11 Apr 2024 22:08:13 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-04-15T08:46:21.592Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>An extraordinary hunt for the ghosts of SARS-CoV-2</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*lraVtM3KRnkfnr-kiyusxw.png" /><figcaption>Where is the birthplace of SARS-CoV-2? Will we ever find out? Shown: Evidence for SARS-CoV-2 related bat coronaviruses in Southern China and Southeast Asia, color coding indicates genetic similarity (yellow — medium, orange — high, red — very high)</figcaption></figure><h3>Prelude: The Ongoing Confusions</h3><p>Why are <a href="https://www.c-span.org/video/?529219-1/hearing-origins-covid-19">US scientists dragged in front of Congress in Benghazi-style show trials</a>? How come <a href="https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/international/us/us-government-terminates-deep-vzn-program-to-research-exotic-virus-pathogens-apprehending-accidental-outbreak/articleshow/103517652.cms?from=mdr">highly rated research programs get quietly shut down</a>? Is it justified to treat virologists with suspicion, <a href="https://www.foxnews.com/politics/covid-origins-ecohealth-alliance-president-testify-publicly-congress-next-month">consider them guilty of recklessness or dishonest</a>y, even leak their subpoenaed <a href="https://public.substack.com/p/top-scientists-misled-congress-about">private conversations to professional smear artists for cherry-picking</a>?</p><p><strong>The origin controversy is political and polarized.</strong> Myths that COVID-19 was somehow a <em>manmade pandemic</em> are still impactful, whether they are true or not. Polls have shown that <a href="https://today.yougov.com/politics/articles/45389-americans-believe-covid-origin-lab?redirect_from=%2Ftopics%2Fpolitics%2Farticles-reports%2F2023%2F03%2F10%2Famericans-believe-covid-origin-lab">2 out of 3 US citizens believe</a> that SARS-CoV-2, the virus that started the COVID-19 pandemic, came out of a laboratory rather than nature.</p><p><strong>Scientists worldwide vehemently disagree.</strong> The <a href="https://www.science.org/content/article/virologists-and-epidemiologists-back-natural-origin-covid-19-survey-suggests">emerging scientific consensus among domain experts</a> is that SARS-CoV-2 is a natural virus that entered humanity via zoonotic spillover (<em>more importantly, there is a </em><a href="https://protagonistfuture.substack.com/p/bite-size-origin-science"><em>consensus stemming from the body of evidence</em></a><em> that is entirely unequivoca</em>l).</p><p>Yet fewer and fewer citizens seem to hear or care for their evidence-based voices. Domain experts are distrusted, but how much of that is self-inflicted, and how much is sown by anti-science actors?</p><blockquote>“We keep changing our minds about things based on data — that is science, not fraud.” <em>— Robert Garry</em></blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*BeYq5b9QPysvDMQzarDXfQ.png" /><figcaption>Dr. Kristian Andersen and Dr. Robert Garry called to testify on the origins of COVID-19 before the House Oversight Select Subcommittee on the Coronavirus Pandemic. <em>[Image credit: C-SPAN]</em></figcaption></figure><p>We can observe scientists are <a href="https://bylinetimes.com/2024/01/16/elon-musks-war-against-science-evidence-and-objective-truth/">increasingly bullied out of public discourse</a> by information combatants or <a href="https://www.latimes.com/business/story/2024-03-20/leading-scientists-accuse-two-rutgers-professors-of-poisoning-the-debate-over-covids-origins-heres-why">targeted by harassers on social media</a>. Most simply have their knowledge drowned out by an <a href="https://protagonistfuture.substack.com/p/watch-my-seminar-on-covid-origins">information ecosystem that favors emotional falsehoods</a> over complicated facts. It is fair to say that science has come under pressure.</p><p>On top of that, various conspiracy myths about a “lab leak” continue to <a href="https://bsky.app/profile/philippmarkolin.bsky.social/post/3kmmnzp55z32r">garner attention in the media, international forums, and the halls of US Congress</a>, all while <a href="https://twitter.com/RepThomasMassie/status/1767215668301041710">elected representatives</a>, <a href="https://www.washingtonexaminer.com/restoring-america/opinion-restoring-america/2842488/dangerous-virus-research-continues-to-endanger-lives/">senators</a>, <a href="https://usrtk.org/covid-19-origins/american-scientists-misled-pentagon-on-wuhan-research/">anti-science activists</a>, and <a href="https://www.zerohedge.com/covid-19/watch-former-director-national-intelligence-admits-fauci-lied-about-gain-function-research">propagandists</a> seek to gain popularity, profit, or power by instigating a “<strong>gain-of-function research” moral panic*.</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*_l39qTnvKu1fRlbG5yFegw.png" /></figure><p>How many concerns about GoF research are justified, and how many just make for a <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UaRfbJE1qZ4">good story</a>? Media manipulators are skilled <a href="https://protagonistfuture.substack.com/p/disparage-disorient-dispute">at fabricating false uncertainty and inventing sensationalist narratives</a> out of whole cloth. W<em>hen it comes to supporting evidence, the ‘gain-of-function” emperor is embarrassingly naked. </em>But it makes for a fantastic story.</p><blockquote>“It takes more effort to debunk a conspiracy theory than to create one. It took only one podcast to make me think the lab leak theory was possible, but it took months of research to understand why it’s not” — <a href="https://protagonistfuture.substack.com/p/lableak-truther-loses-100000-in-his"><em>Peter Miller, who recently won $100.000 in an 18h origin debate</em></a><em> against a lab leak truther</em></blockquote><p>All scientists can hope for is that eventually, citizens will get tired enough of the spectacle and make-belief to take a closer look at what we already know about the topic.</p><blockquote>O<strong>utside the heated spotlight, multiple teams of international scientists have quietly honed in on a set of new clues to the origin of COVID-19.</strong></blockquote><p>Clues that might not only hold the <strong>definitive answer to whether SARS-CoV-2 came from nature or the lab</strong>, but also how to best anticipate and mitigate the risk of another SARS-related coronavirus pandemic.</p><p>So where is the birthplace of SARS-CoV-2, and how exactly did this chimeric virus come about? Which trajectory did it take before the <a href="https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.abp8715">first outbreak emerged at the Huanan market</a> in Wuhan? Will we ever find out?</p><p>Given current geopolitics, deliberate <a href="https://protagonistfuture.substack.com/p/us-virus-hunting-grant-quietly-canceled">sabotage of scientific processes</a>, and Beijing’s obfuscation of the matter, many say the true origins of COVID-19 will never be solved. Some governments explicitly root for that outcome, preferring to be stuck in perpetual uncertainty forever.</p><p>I would not take that bet against scientific inquiry — and after reading this deep dive on the origin controversy — I believe neither will you.</p><p><strong>Scientific literacy is a superpower</strong> in the (dis)information age. It enables citizens to cut through the noise, intelligently engage with a topic of global controversy, and come out wiser. Scientifically literate citizens however need relevant evidence and the reasoning of scientists to be made accessible to form their opinion. On top of that, they will probably need months to familiarize themselves with the complexity of the origin discussion, and honestly, who has time for that? Having done the (sometimes painful) legwork, here is where I believe I can offer a helping hand. If you gift me your curiosity and time, this article will be a guide to understanding some of the most compelling evidence for the natural origin of this virus.</p><blockquote><em>Tune out the politics, the broken media, and the bad actors. Let’s return to the process of scientific inquiry.</em></blockquote><p>It is time to put the false “gain-of-function research” myth to bed once and for all, and learn about the <strong>cutting-edge science on the hunt for the true origins</strong> of SARS-CoV-2.</p><p>Buckle up, or fetch a large cup of tea, <strong>this is the origin story told through the lens of viral recombination</strong>.</p><h3>An Extraordinary Scientific Hunt</h3><blockquote>“If you gave me a billion dollars to find the origins, I`d probably spent 90% of that outside of China in South East Asia” — <em>Bat immunologist Linfa Wang, Duke-NUS Singapore</em></blockquote><h3>Chapter 1: Unraveling a Mysterious Chimera</h3><h4><strong>I) An uncanny genome</strong></h4><p>When SARS-CoV-2 emerged, it was a confusing virus for a lot of reasons. First, it was very infectious to humans for a novel virus, spreading effectively between them via the respiratory route. Second, it did not cause severe disease in many patients, was sometimes asymptomatic, and subsequently hard to track. Third, side-by-side comparisons to known SARS-related viruses seemed to show that the novel virus was a chimera. It had parts of very high genetic similarity, and other parts of low genetic similarity, on top of a <a href="https://protagonistfuture.substack.com/p/a-proximal-witch-hunt">few other oddities that gave researchers initially a hard time</a> to wrap their heads around. Even seasoned virologists were quoted wondering how “<em>this gets accomplished in nature</em>” in early February 2020.</p><p>As the pandemic turned into full swing, multiple “man-made” theories of varied quality were advanced on how the SARS-COV-2 — and its odd genome — came to be. From bioweapon development to gain-of-function research, from de-novo genetic engineering to the alleged introduction of HIV sequences, from serial passage through human cells or humanized mice to arcane vaccine experiments, <strong>many asserted that some type of human manipulation was necessary to explain how this dangerous patchwork virus of high and low sequence similarities to other coronaviruses </strong>came about.</p><p>Only coronavirologists with decades of experience with that particular viral sub-family would disagree, they certainly saw nothing unheard of in the genome. But the biggest problem in debunking the plethora of false notions was the lack of reference points; namely viral cousins of SARS-CoV-2. Those only gradually came trickling in once the severity of the outbreak turned into a global pandemic and jolted more and more scientists into urgent action. Rather than speculate on inconclusive data, many researchers set out to find related coronaviruses, either by discovering neglected genomes in large biomedical databases or by direct sampling of bats in nature.</p><p>They quickly realized that SARS-CoV-2-related viruses all looked a bit weird and stitched together; for example, a <a href="https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-020-2169-0">pangolin virus had an ACE2 receptor binding domain very closely related</a> and able to bind and infect human cells. Another <a href="https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32416074/">bat virus discovered in Mengla country</a> in China had an insertion reminiscent of the furin cleavage site at the S1/S2 boundary, as well as what looked like an ancestral genome to SC2, at least for about the first 2/3rds of its full span. How could these diverse animal viruses seem so closely related to SARS-CoV-2 in one part, and so distant in another?</p><h4><strong>II) On recombination versus artificial assembly</strong></h4><p>Almost from day one, coronavirus veterans had been quick to educate their collaborators that CoV genomes <strong>might just seem unintuitive</strong> because they are shaped by a process called<strong> recombination</strong>.</p><p>Recombination is a mechanism for genetic exchange between two different parental viruses that creates a new viral genome sharing genetic information of both. It requires two (<em>usually distinct</em>) viruses to be present in the same host cell.</p><blockquote><em>As a useful but imprecise abstraction, one might think of recombination as a form of “virus sex” that produces unique offspring sharing a mix of parental genomic regions.</em></blockquote><p>Offspring that came about by recombination is in many cases unproductive, meaning it can either not fulfill all essential functions necessary for the virus to replicate and infect new hosts; or it can do so but worse than the parental lineages, thus getting quickly outcompeted by them and vanish into nothingness. A virus needs to constantly spread and adapt to persist, after all.</p><p>However, sometimes this <em>“virus sex”</em> brings forth recombinant offspring that is in some aspect better — <em>meaning more fit in its current or new environment</em> — than the parental lineages, ergo it will spread and gain ground in the host population or particular environmental niche, possibly establishing itself for years to come.</p><p><strong>Recombination frequencies vary dramatically between viral families, from the promiscuous to the prudent.</strong> For example, recombination does not seem to play an important role in some Flaviviridae (Ebola, Zika) and Paramyxoviridae (Hendra, Nipah). At the same time, segmented viruses such as influenza use a different mechanism of genetic exchange altogether called “re-assortment”.</p><p>The coronavirus sub-family of negative-strand RNA viruses reportedly recombines frequently. Recombination in CoVs is thought to be facilitated by a molecular mechanism called RNA-dependent RNA polymerase (RdRp) template switching leading to <strong>copy-choice recombination (see figure below)</strong>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*6N4mGQ64tpy-PaxB4-so8A.png" /><figcaption>Three proposed molecular mechanisms for copy-choice recombination in CoVs utilizing RdRp template switching. <em>(</em><a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10265781/"><em>Wells H. et al., Cell Host Microbe, 2023</em></a><em>)</em></figcaption></figure><p>What this means is that the RNA production machinery <strong>(RdRp) can jump between instruction templates</strong> at any point if more than one is available, producing a hybrid sequence (chimeric genome).</p><p>I sketched out the mechanistic interplay between replication and viral gene transcription (<em>see below</em>) to illustrate how <strong>template switching is not a freak event but an essential step</strong> in the viral life cycle.</p><blockquote>Replication of the coronavirus genome requires continuous RNA synthesis, whereas transcription is a discontinuous process unique among RNA viruses. Transcription includes a template switch during the synthesis of subgenomic negative-strand RNAs to add a copy of the leader sequence. — <a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6025776/">Sola I. et al., Annu Rev Virol., 2015</a></blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*EekZpnuKht5jmu6j_z4JhQ.png" /><figcaption>Illustration of recombination-prone genome replication in negative-stranded coronaviruses. When two RNA viruses find themselves in the same host cell, recombination is not an unusual event but common. (Individual figures from <a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6025776/">Sola I. et al., Annu Rev Virol., 2015</a> and <a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10265781/"><em>Wells H. et al., Cell Host Microbe, 2023</em></a><em>)</em></figcaption></figure><p>An RdRp that needs to jump back and forth between genetic elements constantly might easily jump to another different genome when thrown into the mix, thus providing ample mechanistic opportunity for recombination. (<em>Where CoVs get physical opportunity to have so much virus sex and what we can learn from it we will look at in Chapter 2</em>)</p><p>This is of course not a secret to experts in the field. <strong>That coronaviruses</strong> <strong><em>fuck around</em></strong><em> </em>— <em>sorry recombine constantly</em> — has been <strong>scientifically established</strong> for many years before COVID-19.</p><p>For now, what is important is that <strong>the</strong> <strong>promiscuous sarbecovirus (SARS-related beta-coronavirus) sub-genus gets a lot of recombinant progeny</strong>; and over time, established offspring lineages can themselves engage in more virus sex (= undergo recombination) with other circulating viruses. From long-estranged cousins and viral strangers to incestuous siblings and even their own offspring, anything seemingly goes (<em>hey, not our place to judge!</em>).</p><p>Again, thinking about this promiscuous mingling is merely a useful abstraction, because in reality, each individual virus genome is just one of many millions copies in a single infected person. Out of this complexity, recombination can result in ever new chimeric offspring that — if successful — will carry parental genetic segments forth from the generations that came before it. However, in the early days with less information, <a href="https://virological.org/t/ncovs-relationship-to-bat-coronaviruses-recombination-signals-no-snakes-no-evidence-the-2019-ncov-lineage-is-recombinant/331">SARS-CoV-2 did not seem very recombinant</a>. But maybe something changed with more bat cousins being found since?</p><blockquote><em>If SARS-CoV-2 and related sarbecoviruses indeed came about by frequent recombination, we would expect a colorful mix (a mosaic) of genome segments shared between them and their closest cousins.</em></blockquote><p>Here is how that looks for SARS-CoV-2 and some of it’s closest relatives:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ZHUwNAd6e7sLGFlnT7bOSw.png" /><figcaption>Representation of the 15 recombinant fragments of relevant <em>Sarbecovirus</em> genomes compared to the SARS-CoV-2 human prototype strain. Where possible, the closest viral sequence is indicated for each fragment. In other cases, MULT indicates a group of multiple sequences. (<a href="https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-022-04532-4">Temmam S. et al., Nature, 2022</a>)</figcaption></figure><p>For SARS-CoV-2, the above figure shows that it shares regions of high sequence similarity with a bunch of different bat viruses, namely RmYN02, Banal-103, RpYN06, Banal-52, and RaTG13. Close cousins. However, for each SARS-CoV-2 to bat virus comparison individually, there might be some regions of very low sequence similarity (usually around the spike) where they are not similar at all.</p><p>The observation of this mosaic genome makes clear that SARS-CoV-2’s <strong>overall genome could not have been designed or derived from any known single progenitor virus</strong> (<em>for example RaTG13 or a BANAL-like virus, as lab leak activists like to argue</em>), but rather that <strong>it is a genetic chimera </strong>containing bits and pieces from multiple related viruses. We know this technically because <strong>no engineering or culturing approach could have magically created the “ancestral” sequence in hundreds of positions</strong> any time a cousin diverged from SARS-COV-2.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*6n0jxWkPQk1nyZJtNGM_kg.png" /></figure><p>Given this reality slowly breaking through, lab leak activists (<em>not prone to hold any coherent hypotheses on this issue anyway</em>) have since moved on to fantasize that <a href="https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/2022.10.18.512756v1.full">SARS-CoV-2 must then have been “stitched together” in a lab</a> from a set of (multiple known and unknown) progenitor viruses secretly sampled by the Wuhan Institute of Virology. (<em>“What can be asserted without evidence can also be discarded without evidence”</em>, I would say about the never-ending epicycles of conspiratorial ideation)</p><p>In reality, all of the proposed “<em>stitched together</em>” speculations are of course not only <strong>contradicted by evidence and epistemically risky</strong> at face value (<a href="https://protagonistfuture.substack.com/p/scientific-meme-content"><em>I classified them as fraudulent</em></a>), but they also<strong> fail to account for the fact that</strong> <strong>all other SARS-CoV-2 relatives found in the wild</strong> <strong>look equally stitched together</strong> from multiple viruses.</p><blockquote>In other words, if the SARS-CoV-2 chimeric genome is supposedly “stitched together” artificially, how come every random viral cousin found in the wild looks equally “stitched together”?</blockquote><p>There is no question that recombination is the only scientific explanation that can account for the observation of these natural chimeras. (<em>There are </em><a href="https://github.com/alexcritschristoph/ancestral_reconstruction_endonucleases"><em>many more technical details as to why scientists know</em></a><em> that SARS-CoV-2’s mosaic genome was not assembled and stitched together in a lab from a sequence, but you get the main point. Virus sex, baby.</em>)</p><p>On top of that, the observed recombination patterns left behind by <strong>past “sexual” encounters between parental lineages can not be produced, simulated, or faked in a laboratory</strong>. <em>Pause for a second and read that again.</em></p><p>The relevant “sexual history” that played out over the last five decades or so needed to be lived in the wild, it <strong>could only have happened in nature</strong> where all these viruses meet.</p><p>All scientific evidence and prudence suggest therefore that <strong>a naturally evolved, immediate bat ancestor to SARS-CoV-2 </strong>must have existed. It did not spring from a computer sequence, was not dreamt up by a mad scientist, or recklessly assembled from disparate parts. SARS-CoV-2’s bat ancestor came about as naturally as all the other recombinant children of parental sarbecoviruses that we have since discovered in bats.</p><blockquote>This is what scientists mean when they say the “backbone” of SARS-CoV-2 is natural and was not stitched together.</blockquote><p>On the larger genetic makeup, this ancestral bat version of SARS-CoV-2 already looked very much like the one that first surfaced in Wuhan. But this alone is not sufficient to exclude that such a recombinant bat ancestor was found by researchers and then “tinkered with” in the lab. <strong>Recombination has a low resolution</strong>, it can not track targeted single mutations. <em>So genetic tinkering remains possible and plausible, right?</em></p><p>How else can we explain that a bat virus seems so damn good at infecting human cells?</p><h4><strong>III) Recombination patterns are not random</strong></h4><p>Another common line of erroneous argumentation by lab leak proponents concerns the idea that because SARS-CoV-2 was capable of infecting humans very well, it must have been somehow <em>pre-adapted</em> or <em>optimized</em> to do so via serial passaging in human cells, or been given this remarkable ability by thoughtful engineers. How else could a bat virus circulating in bats develop this human affinity just by chance?</p><p>For me, this argumentation from supposed “optimization” always has a bit of a fallacious character — “<em>How can something marvelous such as the eye have come about by chance alone?“ </em>— seen many times in creationist arguments. <strong>Evolution is not the same as chance</strong>. We humans tend to underestimate the diversity of nature and the power of evolutionary selection at our peril.</p><blockquote>So how do we know that nature has optimized the human affinity of SARS-CoV-2 all by itself?</blockquote><p>I am glad you asked. CoV virologists have studied over the years how the S gene — encoding the spike protein — seems to be one of the biggest factors influencing cellular and species tropism (<em>the ability to successfully infect different hosts</em>). When scientists plot the frequency of recombination events along the Sarbecovirus genome, they found that there was not an even distribution, but rather “hot spots” and “cold spots” for genetic exchanges, with the spike region shining bright red.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/719/1*oksWfKNu2A4UAWeJREE97g.png" /><figcaption>Recombination region count matrices indicating genome regions that are most and least commonly transferred during detectable coronavirus recombination events (<a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9261289/">Klerk A. et al, Virus Evol., 2022</a>)</figcaption></figure><p>What does this mean? Well, let us remember that recombination almost exclusively causes <em>fucked up</em> offspring genomes that are unable to procreate or establish themselves. <strong>All scientists ever get to observe are the survivors</strong>, those one-in-a-billion viral children who came out fitter than their parents.</p><blockquote>A recombination event that adds to niche fitness gets to stay, and whatever impairs fitness gets selected out.</blockquote><blockquote>[…] non-random and mostly conserved recombination patterns that we and others have detected in various coronavirus subgenera are likely shaped both by evolutionarily conserved variations in the mechanistic predispositions of different genome regions to recombination and by shared selective processes disfavouring the survival of recombinants that express improperly folded proteins. — <a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9261289/"><em>Klerk A. et al, Virus Evol., 2022</em></a></blockquote><p>The figure above basically shows that <strong>within and surrounding the spike</strong> and some accessory protein genes (orange), <strong>observing</strong> <strong>new productive recombinant segments</strong> <em>(and with it, a higher sequence diversity)</em> <strong>is much more likely</strong> than anywhere else along Sarbecoviruses’ genomes.</p><p>So finding that SARS-CoV-2 has an “unusual” spike gene sequence compared to many of its relatives is actually not unusual at all. It is the norm among members sarbecovirus sub-genus, <strong>they all have unusually diverse sequences there</strong>. The question is why?</p><p>In general, high sequence diversity enables viruses to stumble upon <strong>new functionalities</strong>, from evading immune systems to changing their tropism (<em>what type of cells they can infect</em>), facilitating more efficient cellular entry, or infecting new host organisms.</p><p>However, developing and maintaining sequence diversity over a viral population is not always easy to come by.</p><ul><li>Single point mutations arising from replication errors rarely get the job done, and face obstacles such as <a href="https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29844134/">purifying selection</a>.</li><li>On top of that, RNA viruses with large genomes require a strong proofreading ability to correct replication errors that give rise to deleterious mutations.</li><li>That is why for some RNA viruses, such as HIV, it is thought that sequence <a href="https://academic.oup.com/genetics/article/167/4/1573/6050528">diversity more frequently arises through recombination than point mutation</a>.</li></ul><p>In coronaviruses, recombination is also assumed as an efficient mechanism for how these long, proofreading RNA viruses can rapidly create <strong>genetic diversity from an existing pool of sequences</strong>; presumably to cope with quickly changing niche environmental conditions. (<em>More on that in Chapter 2)</em></p><blockquote>[…] recombination also has the potential to act as an evolutionary “fast-forward” by quickly shuffling genetic material between vastly different viruses.</blockquote><blockquote>For the same result to be produced by mutation alone, long spans of time would be needed for selective forces to shape such extensive nucleotide changes, especially considering the high proofreading capacity of coronaviruses.— <a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10265781/"><em>Wells H. et al., Cell Host Microbe, 2023</em></a></blockquote><p>When we think of general genetic diversity as a “potential for new functionalities” and recombination as a way to “shuffle varied genome segments” around, some alarm bells should be ringing.</p><p>With chimeric sarbecoviruses genomes, we are in essence <strong>observing direct evidence </strong>of countless potential <strong>“gain-of-function” experiments</strong> conducted on a scale hardly imaginable that must have happened in the past.<em> (More on that in Chapter 2)</em></p><blockquote><em>The existence of untold numbers of such recombinant cousins in the wild implies that chimeric sarbecoviruses must have been birthed in some vast, natural “gain-of-function” laboratory.</em></blockquote><p>A laboratory where gain-of-function experiments with promiscuous parental lineages and distinct genetic functionalities relentlessly produce chimeric offspring that might have tricks from both parents.</p><p>Over time, the <strong>constant combinatoric mixing</strong> of varied elements and functionalities will <strong>on occasion produce some very elaborate traits</strong>, such as the ability to infect multiple different hosts (broad species tropism), including us humans.</p><p>I think it is worth looking at that in detail.</p><h4><strong>IV) Of locks, keys, and the door to human infection</strong></h4><p>Broken down to a structural level, the major determinant of CoVs to infect various host species has to do with the makeup of <strong>the receptor-binding domain (RBD)</strong>, a part of the 3D organization of the larger viral spike protein that <strong>has to fit the 3D scaffold of host receptor</strong> (ACE2 in humans) exposed on host cells. This is a bit of the lock-and-key principle.</p><ul><li>The higher the<strong> tolerated genetic diversity of the RBM</strong> (the genetic sequences coding for the RBD in the spike protein), the bigger the repertoire of potential keys available to CoVs.</li></ul><blockquote>Sarbecoviruses exhibit extensive genetic diversity in RBM, likely arising from frequent recombination and the high selective pressure associated with inter-species host jumping. — <a href="https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/2024.02.11.579781v1.full.pdf">Si J. et al., biorxiv, 2024</a></blockquote><p>Viral recombination in CoV spike genes is considered a major evolutionary mechanism that drives new adaptation processes, such as viral host switching. (<em>If you already have a key factory within the family, and promiscuous virus sex where successful keys get passed around like a hot potato, all new chimeras need is the physical opportunity to try them on previously locked doors</em>)</p><p>Here is an interesting little sidebar:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*-wN73oRbbI4MjZpa_jAekQ.png" /></figure><p>In any case, <strong>we do not need to speculate</strong> about whether it is possible or what potential ambitions genome engineers might have had or not. Since 2021, researchers have not only found more cousins of SARS-CoV-2, but they also discovered that some of these cousins had keys very much identical to it, <strong>proving that nature is and remains the ultimate key master for this particular set of keys</strong>, so to speak.</p><p>A very recent <strong>illuminating preprint</strong> from Chinese scientists — <em>including </em><strong>Zhengli Shi</strong><em>, the unjustly blamed “Batwoman” herself</em>— took a deep dive to understand how exactly RBM motifs (key shapes) relate to broad ACE2 tropism.</p><p>Experimentally, they produced 56 individual cell lines expressing ACE2 orthologues (locks) from bats and selected mammals and then tried 14 different RBDs (keys) from Sarbecoviruses.</p><blockquote>What they discovered was that <strong>some keys could open almost all locks</strong>, whereas others could open only one, or even none of the locks presented.</blockquote><p>Much of this is not unique, but based on specific deletions in specific positions of the RBM <em>(see below)</em>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*3hhPifjcEGjHwK58Pt5jow.png" /><figcaption>Sarbecovirus RBMs exhibit a non-random pattern for narrowing or widening ACE2 affinity and species tropism. (Figures from <a href="https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/2024.02.11.579781v1.full.pdf">Si J. et al., biorxiv, 2024</a>)</figcaption></figure><blockquote>We revealed that most sarbecoviruses with longer RBMs (type-I), present broad ACE2 tropism, whereas viruses with single deletions in Region 1 (type-II) or Region 2 (type-III) generally exhibit narrow ACE2 tropism, typically favoring their hosts’ ACE2. Sarbecoviruses with double region deletions (type-IV) exhibit a complete loss of ACE2 usage — <a href="https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/2024.02.11.579781v1.full.pdf">Si J. et al., biorxiv, 2024</a></blockquote><p>The RBD in SARS-CoV-2 has had a very broad binding affinity from the start, which is why it is not only great at infecting humans, but minks, deer, house- and zoo animals as well.</p><p>Why Sarbecoviruses would need either very broad or very specialized keys we will look deeper into in the next chapter; it has to do with evolutionary and selection pressures in niche environments.</p><p>But just to sum up the implications of our deep dive into spike recombination, genetic diversity, and broad ACE2 tropism:</p><blockquote>The supposedly “uncanny” ability of SARS-CoV-2 to infect human cells is neither uncanny nor especially unique. Some bat CoVs can just infect humans from the get-go. No pre-adaption, no magic human hand, no designer, no arcane lab experiments needed.</blockquote><p>On top of this, <strong>unique </strong><a href="https://academic.oup.com/gbe/article/14/2/evac018/6524630"><strong>recombination patterns in the spike gene</strong></a> and the <a href="https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-022-04532-4"><strong>discovery of identical RBMs in nature</strong></a> make it unequivocally clear that SARS-CoV-2’s RBD was not “designed”, “created” or “swapped in from an unknown virus” by researchers in any kind of “gain-of-function” setup.</p><p>It acquired this receptor-binding domain in nature.</p><h4>V) Defusing the myth of the Furin cleavage site</h4><blockquote>But what about the furin cleavage site? Project DEFUSE?</blockquote><p>You might hear lab leak proponents lament. Recombination does not have the granularity to rule out that this small sequence motif was artificially introduced. The idea gained traction after a <a href="https://theintercept.com/2021/09/23/coronavirus-research-grant-darpa/">rejected research proposal from 2018 was played up by credulous amplifiers</a> in the press.</p><p>In the “man-made” mythology, the <strong>furin cleavage site (FCS)</strong> — a polybasic cleavage site recognized by furin-like proteases — is a dramatic functional element and allegedly the <strong>secret sauce and trigger whose artificial insertion turned an ordinary bat virus into the pandemic blight pathogen</strong> we have today.</p><p>For lab leak believers, the DEFUSE proposal <strong>mentioning the possibility of introducing</strong> FCS <strong>coupled with the “suspicious” occurrence of an FCS in SARS-CoV-2</strong> is all but proof that the virus was engineered or tinkered with. In other words, researchers wanted to create a pandemic virus, or had reckless disregard if their work would do so.</p><p>A quick sidebar:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*xhpAENmdRtMPafMWTyaGlg.png" /></figure><p>Despite the DEFUSE proposal being irrelevant, I think it is worth discussing the <strong>two associated insinuations based on scientific ignorance</strong> a bit deeper.</p><p><strong>First, there is the common confusion</strong> that the introduction of a single genetic element has the power to make a pandemic pathogen.</p><p><strong>Second, there is deliberate deception</strong> about how likely it is that nature or engineering came up with the FCS insertion in SARS-CoV-2.</p><blockquote>The FCS is <strong>probably one of the most misunderstood elements in the history of the SARS-CoV-2 origin controversy.</strong></blockquote><p><strong>So let us first talk about why the Spike protein needs to be cleaved, where it needs to be cleaved, and how the FCS might help.</strong> (<em>The next points are going to be highly technical, so I made a visual summary to help below</em>)</p><ul><li>The Spike protein in SARS-COV-2 needs to be cut during viral processing, first in the S1/S2 region, and second at the S2&#39; site</li><li>TMPRSS2 extracellular cleavage facilitates entry at or near the cell surface (cell fusion), as opposed to viral entry through the endosome pathway and late cleavage by cathepsins</li><li>Extracellular cleavage allows the virus to avoid the potent endosomal/ endolysosomal restriction factors — the IFITM proteins — which inhibit viral membrane fusion and can stall virus replication</li><li>TMPRSS2-expression is particularly high for cells in the upper respiratory tract, so viruses that can use this route more efficiently will have a selective advantage in respiratory transmission</li></ul><p><strong>Furin pre-cleavage aids TMPRSS2-mediated cell fusion</strong></p><ul><li>The FCS motif allows spike proteins to be pre-cleaved before they leave their host cell; but also makes them less stable</li><li>Spike protein egress that was <strong>pre-cleaved by the furin-like proteases in S1/S2 </strong>seem to take away some of the processing work of TMPRSS2, <strong>bind better to ACE2</strong>, and thus make viral entry via this membrane-fusion route more efficient for the virus</li><li>Studies have shown that TMPRSS2-mediated entry was particularly potent for virus particles that had FCS-containing spike compared with the non-furin-cleaved mutants</li><li>In ferrets it was shown that virions with FCS-containing SC2 spike protein could spread to new hosts, but did not observe this for virions with FCS-mutated spikes</li><li>Conservation of the FCS since pandemic start argues for its selective advantage in human-to-human transmission as well</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*R3Cd3M5pGtQgkxWrHoGdvQ.png" /><figcaption><em>Cleavage at S1/S2 and S2 viral processivity studies highlight the function of the FCS and role in </em>egress priming, respiratory tropism as well as transmission and infectivity. (Figures from: <a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9278140/">Lavie M. et al., J Virol., 2022</a>, <a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8491763/">Jackson JB. et al., Nat Rev Mol Cell Biol., 2022</a>, <a href="https://www.nature.com/articles/s41564-021-00908-w">Peacock T. et al., Nature Microbiology, 2022</a>, <a href="https://www.nature.com/articles/s41579-023-01003-z">Steiner S. et al., Nature Reviews Microbiology, 2024</a>)</figcaption></figure><p><strong>Therefore, we know that the FCS in SARS-CoV-2 is critically involved in transmission and pathogenicity.</strong></p><p>That an <strong>FCS acquisition can aid a respiratory virus</strong> is not exactly unobserved in nature either; for example, the transition from low pathogenic influenza strains towards <a href="https://rnajournal.cshlp.org/content/27/2/123.long#ref-43">high pathogenic versions often happens by the acquisition of a polybasic cleavage</a> site which can be recognized by furin-like proteases.</p><p>However, context matters:</p><ul><li>It was shown that even furin-deficient cells can still cleave SARS-CoV-2 spike protein at S1/S2</li><li>The furin-cleavage site in SARS-COV-2 is quickly lost by normal cell culture techniques because of slower kinetics, so it impedes the virus in this laboratory “serial passage” context</li><li>The requirement of FCS and basic residues at S2′ for S-mediated cell fusion is entirely cell type dependent</li><li>an FCS does not make (or necessarily break) an pandemic virus, the whole viral-host context matters</li></ul><p>For a subset of highly pathogenic viruses infecting humans, an FCS might be a <strong>necessary, but not sufficient element</strong> to efficiently infect humans or sustain respiratory transmissions.</p><blockquote>However, merely <strong>adding an FCS can not magically turn any bat sarbecoviruses</strong> into a pandemic pathogen</blockquote><p>For example, MERS-CoV and SARS-CoV-2 both <strong>caused epidemics, one with and without an FCS.</strong> In the case of SARS, some experiments have shown that <a href="https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/16519916/">the artificial addition of an FCS does not increase infectivity</a> or pathogenicity. Additionally, <a href="https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-021-21918-6"><strong>SARS-CoV-1 without an FCS is no less infectious</strong></a> in ferrets compared to FCS-containing SARS-CoV-2. Some of our <strong>endemic human CoVs have an FCS</strong> (hCoV-HKU1) but <strong>do not use ACE2 </strong>as an entry receptor, <strong>others have no FCS but still use ACE2</strong> (hCoV-NL63).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*8s9pD02QA-c1H0WEHT2J1Q.png" /></figure><blockquote>In nature, no genetic element acts alone.</blockquote><p>For a pandemic virus, the right genetic elements, host and environmental conditions have to fall together to create a perfect storm. We also would expect for any natural virus capable to start a pandemic to have some unusual genetic tricks up its sleeve. Otherwise, every ordinary virus would cause a pandemic.</p><p><strong>So why are many suspicious about SARS-CoV-2 having an FCS?</strong></p><p>The main reason why the short FCS sequence in SARS-CoV-2 (<em>12 nucleotide insertion</em>) has been hotly discussed is because it <strong>stood out like a sore thumb in side-by-side sequence comparisons</strong> to known coronaviruses in early 2020. (<em>Since then, scientists have found plenty of naturally occurring FCS in the wider CoV sub-family, but not in the sarbecoviruses specifically</em>)</p><p>Just <strong>because something is rare or even unique</strong> among currently known sarbecovirus sub-genus members is however <strong>not good evidence for artificial introduction</strong> <strong>given the high sequence diversity</strong> at S1/S2 (<em>see below</em>). On top of that, there is some <a href="https://virological.org/t/the-sarbecovirus-origin-of-sars-cov-2-s-furin-cleavage-site/536/6">evidence to suggest the FCS region itself underwent recombination</a> with a related sarbecovirus. Again, we underestimate the diversity of nature at our own peril.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*eJDcfSTZXzBGPCGqQqZ7-Q.png" /><figcaption>Polybasic cleavage sites recognized by furin-like proteases are spread all over the wider beta-CoV tree; including human CoVs HKU1 and OCT43. S1/S2 boundary region is highly sequence-diverse and susceptible to nucleotide insertions. These are the ingredients necessary to produce an FCS, irrespective of whether it is common or well-maintained in the bat sarbecovirus sub-genus specifically. (Figures from: <a href="https://www.nature.com/articles/s41591-020-0820-9">Andersen KG., Nature Medicine, 202</a>0, <a href="https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1873506120304165#!">Wu Y. et al, <em>Stem Cell Research, 2021</em></a><em>, </em><a href="https://www.nature.com/articles/s42003-022-03421-w">Sander AL. et al., Communications Biology, 2022</a>)</figcaption></figure><p>But let’s discard for a second our experience with vast and crafty nature — <em>and the naïve presumption that an FCS can turn any virus into a pandemic threat</em> — and take the idea of a “man-made” FCS introduction as a null hypothesis.</p><p>Is there some evidence that could help us confirm or reject this hypothesis?</p><p>For an engineered FCS, the observed sequence motif in SARS-CoV-2 is odd, to say the least (<em>see figure below for a visual summary</em>)</p><ul><li>All previous FCS created by researchers (<em>for example </em><a href="https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0042682206000900?via%3Dihub"><em>here in 2006</em></a><em>, </em><a href="https://www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.0809524106"><em>or here in 2009,</em></a><em> all published years before the “secret” DEFUSE proposal suggesting similar work got played up as a smoking gun</em>) <strong>have avoided using an “insertion”</strong>, and rather chose to <strong>“substitute”</strong> — <em>rewrite</em> — <strong>existing nucleotides in this position</strong> to change the encoded amino acids to create an FCS. This is necessary and basic biology because <strong>the addition of new amino acids to any spike protein will likely disrupt its structure</strong> and break the whole thing.</li><li>Curiously, an <strong>additional, unnecessary proline residue is part of the insertion</strong>. Proline is not part of any FCS motif, however, the amino acid is <a href="https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/8692877/">considered a helix-breaker</a>; something that will mess up your protein structure with a high probability. Why risk introducing that?</li><li>Even more curious, <strong>the whole sequence insertion is “out-of-frame”</strong>, meaning the nucleotides were not introduced neatly but rather staggered for no reason, again something that scientists would not do ordinarily (or at all)</li><li>However, the FCS insertion is right next to an <strong>RNA sequence motif prone for copy-choice recombination</strong>, arguing for this natural mechanism bringing it about (<em>and copy-choice recombination is reading-frame independent and favors out-of-frame insertions 2:1</em>)</li><li>The <strong>GC content</strong> of the insertion is 83%, very unusual for artificial introductions</li><li>The coded amino acids themselves make an <strong>odd, non-canonical, and weak recognition motif</strong> (RRXR) for furin-like proteases; a motif that might ordinarily not work compared to strong motifs such as RRSRR (which would usually be used by virologists).</li><li>The <strong>FCS cleavage at S1/S2 destabilizes the original (Wuhan-Hu-1) spike protein</strong>, which only got compensated partially when the D614G mutation emerged quickly in the early pandemic, arguing for a recent acquisition, not design or cell culture</li><li>Furthermore, potentially because the FCS in the original SARS-COV-2 is not that stable, it <strong>is lost very quickly in Vero cells and other typical cell culture systems.</strong> Selection pressures seem to run against it in these research-associated amplification systems; so how exactly did an FCS-containing virus that first has to be amplified in cell culture before it can infect a researcher escape from a lab and do so with an FCS?</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*1r7L3Q0p5cJjjsNlrX3mYw.png" /><figcaption>Looking at the specifics of the observed FCS sequence motif, as well as how and where it is placed within the S1/S2 site, makes the hypothesis of an artificial insertion via genetic engineering extremely unlikely. (Figure based on <a href="https://www.nature.com/articles/s41591-020-0820-9">Andersen KG., Nature Medicine, 2020</a>, <a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9546612/">Garry R., PNAS, 2022</a>)</figcaption></figure><p><strong>From an engineering perspective, none of these odd, suboptimal, and self-defeating FCS design choices make any sense</strong> and certainly contradict the assumption of “rational design” as a whole. They also <a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9546612/">serve to rule out engineering or mimicry of existing furin cleavage sites</a>.</p><p>But that alone is not proof. Who knows what weird and arcane experiments those Chinese researchers would cook up in a lab, right? (<em>Some lab leak truthers with no molecular biology experience would say. For actual genetic engineers, the situation is already clear as day</em>) Fortunately, we do not need to rely on experience or speculations about any motivations or experimental procedures Chinese scientists might have followed.</p><blockquote>This is because nature just has more secrets hidden in the FCS that humans could not have come up with in the first place.</blockquote><p>After <strong>intensive mechanistic studies of the FCS in SARS-CoV-2</strong>, researchers discovered a <strong>hitherto unknown synergistic interplay</strong> between the odd, suboptimal FCS and the genetic backbone of the virus (<em>which we by now know is natural because of recombination</em>).</p><ul><li>We have learned that <strong>pre-cleavage of SARS-CoV-2 S1/S2 by furin</strong> is what <strong>boost TMPRSS2-mediated cell fusion</strong> and thus impacts cellular tropism and transmission dynamics (ergo infectivity)</li></ul><blockquote><strong>But it turns out, that was not the full mechanistic story. In nature, no genetic element acts alone</strong></blockquote><ul><li>The viral <strong>QTQTN amino acid motif is an uncommon natural sequence</strong> in several sarbecovirus spike proteins directly upstream of the FCS sequence</li><li>In cell culture experiments, <strong>QTQTN is not stable and repeatedly lost</strong>, similar to the FCS. <strong>Loss results in impaired viral replication.</strong></li><li>QTQTN determines how<strong> tightly the loop harboring the FCS is bound to the spike protein</strong>, thus it regulates spike protein stability and shapes how well the Golgi-bound furin-like proteases <strong>have access to recognize the FCS motif</strong> and pre-cleave at S1/S2</li><li>The QTQTN motif is also glycosylated and <strong>loss of that glycosylation impairs viral replication</strong> as well.</li><li>Researchers showed beautifully that there is an intricate functional interplay between the FCS, the loop length, and glycosylation: <strong>These separate but co-dependent elements work together synergistically</strong> and all elements are ultimately required for efficient FCS pre-cleavage (and with it, impact viral replication and pathogenesis). <em>In nature, no genetic element acts alone.</em></li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/0*FWVW5o0sIGRQ_XdW.jpeg" /><figcaption>Synergistic interaction between the FCS, proximal sequence motif (QTQTN) and glycosylation (Figure: <a href="https://www.pnas.org/doi/full/10.1073/pnas.2205690119">Vu MN. et al., PNAS, 2022</a>)</figcaption></figure><p><strong>Co-dependency and synergy between genetic elements are hallmarks of evolutionary selection</strong>; these type of complex interactions are extremely hard to design for even with perfect knowledge of all structural components, which nobody had in 2019. In the case of SARS-CoV-2’s FCS, there is no conceivable way how engineers could have designed the observed — but hitherto undiscovered — mechanistic synergy purposefully.</p><p>Some might still contest that engineers could have stumbled upon this interaction by sheer “lucky accident”, like winning the lottery.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/597/1*asedFzmTJoTTNqyK4JAfSQ.png" /><figcaption>To just give you the odds of a “lucky engineering accident” scenario, scientists would have to have tried an unholy combination of FCS sequence/random spacer motifs against the backdrop of total viral diversity with the right proximal sequence elements available from rare viruses nobody previously described but that are capable of causing a pandemic in the first place.</figcaption></figure><p>But I think even that special pleading for a “miracle accident” evaporates in comparison to what we know about nature’s relentless trying to bring forth such elements. Mechanistic details and probabilistic observations are key to wrapping our heads around the FCS in SARS-COV-2. If we understand that:</p><ul><li>an FCS alone can not turn a random bat virus into a weapon of mass disruption</li><li>the FCS has many hallmarks speaking against it being designed but strongly arguing in favor of evolutionary mechanisms</li><li>a previous unknown synergistic interaction (<em>with an uncommon natural sequence contained in a 100% natural backbone that evolved in nature</em>) could not have come about or stumbled upon by any known laboratory experimental setup</li></ul><p>…<strong>only then can we fully appreciate the scope and intricacies of gain-of-function experiments nature runs every day</strong>.</p><p>They are of a sophistication and breadth human engineers yet can not hope to match, nor fully fathom.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*IQ-JzVI1vtxpSvB7TnyHHQ.png" /></figure><p>So this point in our genetic deep dive, there is only one thing to do:</p><h4>VI) Putting the “gain-of-function research” narrative to bed</h4><p>Speculations that the “odd and unusual” genetic features of SARS-CoV-2 came about by gain-of-function research, genetic engineering, design, or any other type of human tinkering — <em>while hard to disprove in 2020</em> — are today contradicted by available evidence and published scientific literature. Science did not stand still in the last four years, researchers learned an incredible amount about the intricacies of the virus that disrupted the world.</p><p>Taking together various recombination analyses, sequence diversity in nature, and hallmarks of evolution in the backbone, RBM and FCS leave only one parsimonious conclusion:</p><blockquote>SARS-CoV-2 is a fully natural virus, its specific genomic features could not have come about by any known or unknown laboratory experiment. Period.</blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ZRap0BXqBcKE95FevdEVZw.png" /></figure><p><strong>Note: A natural virus in itself does not disprove a lab leak, nor all conceivable research-related origin scenarios. But it certainly disproves all notions of “gain-of-function” research causing the pandemic.</strong></p><blockquote>Currently, it can not be disproven that an extremely rare pandemic-ready SARS-CoV-2 ancestor circulating in the wild could have been found by researchers, brought to Wuhan secretly, being cultured secretly (and quickly) before it lost the FCS but with high enough titers to somehow infect a researcher. The virus then beat the odds and escaped from a lab unnoticed, then beat the odds again to cause an outbreak, then beat the odds again to start and spread at a wildlife market far away from the lab but nowhere else in a megacity. And then a week later, the exact same unlikely chain of events happened with a slightly different SARS-CoV-2 strain called lineage A; because evidence shows that both lineage B and A are centered around the Huanan market. On top of that, everything that could point to the occurrence of such unlikely chains of events was covered up perfectly not only by Chinese scientists, but by an international cabal including independent scientists, governments, and international organizations.</blockquote><p>These or similar convoluted scenarios might remain theoretically possible forever, but are they plausible?</p><p>Science works with evidence, so it is often impossible to prove a negative — <em>that something did not happen </em>— scientifically, as there would be no evidence of something “not occurring”. <strong>Conspiracy myths are adaptive and built to sustain the belief that the evidence-based “mainstream” explanation is wrong.</strong> This often makes their scientific refutations difficult especially when the goalposts of how an event supposedly happened are constantly shifting, <a href="https://manifold.markets/PeterMillerc030/if-covid-is-a-lab-leak-which-lab-di">including central elements such as which lab is supposed to be the culprit can shift at a moment’s notice</a>.</p><p>All I am cautioning about is that such <strong>cover-up conspiracy myths filled with extraordinary and magical assumptions are epistemologically irresponsible</strong>, contradicted by <a href="https://www.protagonist-science.com/p/bite-size-origin-science">multiple other strong lines of scientific evidence</a> (<em>we can not go deeper into here</em>), and can not even explain most of the body of evidence we observe.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*B4nUvC-Pb0tOFu-_zPkuNw.png" /><figcaption>There is a large and detailed body of evidence that any scientific hypothesis needs to be able to explain. The zoonotic spillover hypothesis is not only consistent with but powerfully explains every piece of evidence we have. No such consistent hypothesis currently exists for the speculations surrounding a research-related accident. (Figure source: <a href="https://www.protagonist-science.com/p/bite-size-origin-science">here</a>)</figcaption></figure><p>I believe it is fair to say that the continued push for a “<em>gain-of-function lab accident</em>” narrative in politics and media is not driven by evidence, not justified by remaining scientific uncertainties, and can be safely discarded. We have seen again and again that no amount of hard evidence for any scientific theory has the power to prevent certain activists, politicians, influencers, and other manipulators from trying to sell citizens a different — and usually emotionally more satisfying or engaging — story. Climate change denial, anti-vaccine activism, homeopathy, various alleged alternative medicines or wonderdrugs; none have any scientific leg to stand on, but are <strong>profitable narratives to use for popularity, persuasion, or power</strong>. Those who have something to gain from pushing false myths will continue to mislead no matter the evidence. We just do not have to buy into their debunked falsehoods.</p><blockquote>The constant performative pearl-clutching and fearmongering about gain-of-function research or lab biosafety in the media should not distract citizens from the factual reality that SARS-CoV-2 is a natural virus.</blockquote><p>Another important side note about this here:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*MiU0VJc7Em4b9MEjroySKg.png" /><figcaption><a href="https://digitalcommons.unl.edu/crsdocs/33/">Knee-jerk regulation currently being considered</a> has already <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2023/10/16/science/covid-lab-leak-research.html">cast a chill over virological research</a> even <strong>before being implemented. </strong><em>Considerations based on a recent perspective article from 78 leading virologists (</em><a href="https://journals.asm.org/doi/10.1128/jvi.01791-23"><em>Rasmussen AL. et al., Journal of Virology, 2024</em></a><em>)</em></figcaption></figure><p>My larger point is that biosafety is an important, complex, and omnipresent topic that virologists take seriously. But do its most fervent advocates in politics, media, and other halls of power?</p><p>If you observe these activists, politicians, contrarians, or influencers who claim gain-of-function research —<em> or any type of human genetic engineering technology — </em>created the virus, you’d be wise to question not only their motifs but their leadership.</p><p>Unfortunately, <strong>getting the origin of SARS-COV-2 right</strong> is not just an academic exercise, or avoiding being fooled. It is about the actions we collectively fail to take when falsehoods dominate the discourse.</p><blockquote>The relentless mythmaking about a “gain-of-function” virus and alleged lab biosafety breaches have exposed a dangerous blind spot in its most fervent purveyors:</blockquote><blockquote>The inability to appreciate the vastness of viral diversity and the “gain-of-function” ingenuity of nature, both of which continue to pose a predictable and outsized threat to human health and prosperity.</blockquote><p>False narratives and beliefs in a “<em>gain-of-function lab accident</em>” are not without consequences for society, and neither is scientific illiteracy or dishonesty in elected representatives and social elites. Are we truly okay with too many leaders chasing false myths while sleepwalking into the next natural pandemic they could not be bothered to understand? Whatever your risk-to-benefit perception about gain-of-function research in labs, ignorance about the scope and predictable danger of gain-of-function dynamics in the wild is a surefire recipe for disaster.</p><blockquote>I hope citizens can at least agree that<strong> if you care about “gain-of-function viruses”, you should care about them anywhere in the world.</strong></blockquote><p><strong>Any biosafety advocacy that magically stops at the lab door </strong>— that does not consider nor care for the <strong>quantifiable orders-of-magnitude larger natural risks</strong> — is not a good basis for collective decision-making in an interconnected world. The threat we neglect will be the one we will keep facing.</p><p>So let me help focus our attention and understanding of where the true origins of this <em>chimeric gain-of-function virus</em> — and its future unwelcome pandemic cousins — actually are to be found.</p><h3>Chapter 2: Chasing the ghosts of SARS-CoV-2</h3><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FWMh25scsC90&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DWMh25scsC90&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=google" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/c8439ead4c693021de8b34359651414e/href">https://medium.com/media/c8439ead4c693021de8b34359651414e/href</a></iframe><p><strong>Prelude: A river in the sky</strong></p><p><em>A river of black drew its line in the darkening sky. Above bat ornaments on crimson roofs from the pagodas at Wat Khao Chong Pran, the river flow turned southeast tonight, towards the crop fields. Rationally, I knew that the cave housed around two and a half million horseshoe bats, but observing a seemingly never-ending flood of hectic creatures — the fly-out of 2,5 million bats took more than forty-five minutes — I realized that I never truly appreciated how many bats share the world with us.</em></p><p><em>There are around 1500 described bat species that have emerged from their last common ancestor over 60 million years ago. Because they are the only flying mammals, we conceptualize them all together under an umbrella term called “bats” like we do with “fish” in the sea. </em><strong><em>But based on genetic diversity, that simplification is rarely adequate</em></strong><em>. It feels equivalent to lumping together giraffes and cows with dolphins and whales, all of which diverged from a shared common Artiodactyla — even-toed ungulate — about fifty million years ago. Hardly justified we think of them as the same, so why do we do it for bats?</em></p><p><em>It is no exaggeration to claim that bats come in almost all sizes, shapes, and forms; from the thumb-sized Craseonycteris thonglongyai — also known as bumblebee bat weighing just 1,5 grams and holding the title of smallest mammal on earth — to various majestic flying foxes with wing spans of over 6 feet, close to two meters. Some bats look almost like dog puppies you’d want to cuddle and take home, others might appear like they’ve escaped from a horror-movie production. Maybe we humans just tend to be afraid of what we do not understand.</em></p><p><strong><em>The horseshoe bats flying here were small insectivores </em></strong><em>— insect-eating bats — who got their name from the weird horseshoe-shaped disfigurement where their nose should be. Intuitively, we humans find them rather ugly — I was no exception — at least at first. I think this is partly because we assume their faces are weirdly deformed, like a fully cleft palate, rather than what they really are: optimized.</em></p><p><em>Horseshoe bats belong to a group of bats that echolocate — sending out and receiving sonar waves — primarily through their nostrils. Other bats mostly use their mouths. These varied shapes and forms in the middle of their faces however have intricate functionality for shaping their calls, impacting not only orientation but for their feeding and social lives too.</em></p><p><em>Given their enormous diversity, bats exist in almost all variations of social structures, from eremites that don’t want to bother with others, to small family groups, to villages, to multicultural megacities. Some like to mingle with other bat species, others are territorial and of the “get off my lawn” persuasion, with threatening grunts and fletching teeth and all.</em></p><p><em>Some horseshoe bat species are not only considered hypersocial cosmopolitans, they are also the most prominent </em><strong><em>host reservoir to SARS-related bat coronaviruses</em></strong><em>; close viral cousins of both SARS-COV-1 and SARS-CoV-2 that have since caused havoc in our human world.</em></p><p><strong><em>I believe to truly understand where these dangerous viruses come from, we have to first take a look into the lively homes of their hosts.</em></strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*0kIzj8wuH97U6AbYnFOfOg.png" /><figcaption>Rhinolophus bat species are very diverse and their nose (and ear) shapes have been optimized for echolocation at a large range of frequencies. Shown: <strong>R. rex, R. stheno, R. I. yunanensis, R. sinicus, R. malayanus</strong> (from left to right) Image credit: Prof. Alice Hughes, University of Hong Kong</figcaption></figure><h4>I) The Cave(s) Where It Happens</h4><blockquote>“No one else was in the room where it happened. The room where it happened. No one really knows how the game is played, the art of the trade, how the sausage gets made. We just assume that it happens, but no one else is in the room where it happens” — <em>Hamilton (Musical), the </em><a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WySzEXKUSZw"><em>Room Where It Happens</em></a><em>.</em></blockquote><p>Physiologically, bats are extraordinary, they can speed up their metabolism 16 times, creating immense heat that would denature our proteins and fry our cells. A bat’s heart can beat up to 1,000 beats per minute and its body temperature can rise to 42 degrees Celsius [107.6 F] during flight at night. Even if we could withstand the initial stress of flight, our inflammatory response after would render us sick. That is not true for bats. Many species have unique immune systems that do not overreact to stressors; including viral infections. There are also no reliable markers of aging after they reach adulthood, bats seem young until they are dead. Some species tend to live up to 40 years in vast, dense, and diverse colonies. All of the above seem to make bats uniquely suited as reservoirs to almost all viral families that befall mammals. But for Sarbecoviruses specifically, that is not the whole story.</p><blockquote>Virus outbreaks are always social phenomena as well, and that rarely is limited to humans.</blockquote><p>There is emergent evidence that the lives of their primary hosts, the Rhinolophids — <em>horseshoe bats with odd noses</em> — are not only a lot more crowded and cosmopolitan than the average bat, but also a lot more socially intricate. Horseshoe bats vary in nose shapes because that allows them to specialize in echolocation at very wide ranges of frequencies. While not fully understood today, researchers believe that bat echolocation is not only for orientation and hunting but also for communication and vocal learning. Some bat’s extensive vocal repertoire is needed to create specialized social calls used either for parent–offspring reunions, territorial defense, or maintaining group integration. Some speculate that the evolution and differentiation of vocal frequencies within a species leads to mating preferences and exclusions, driving niche formation and ultimate species separation into <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Species_complex">species complexes</a>.</p><p>A species complex is interesting from the perspective of viruses. The genetic stratification of their host reservoir means that <strong>some viruses will specialize on a small niche or subgroup</strong> of the species complex, whereas <strong>others might try to develop or maintain broad affinity to multiple specie</strong>s that might still inhabit the same spaces, but not mate with each other.</p><p>Let’s recall an observation from before: the RBDs of sarbecoviruses can be very broad (<em>even opening the door to non-bat ACE2 receptors</em>), or very niche.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*3hhPifjcEGjHwK58Pt5jow.png" /><figcaption>Sarbecovirus RBMs and ACE2 tropism are likely a reflection of the population structure and intricate social lives of their host species (Figures from <a href="https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/2024.02.11.579781v1.full.pdf">Si J. et al., biorxiv, 2024</a>)</figcaption></figure><p>It is reasonable to assume that the intricate population structures of Rhinolophids create evolutionary pressures for viruses to constantly adapt to new niches. Recombination as an “evolutionary fast-forward” is the mechanism of how sarbecoviruses survive in such an environment, which is why this is such a prominent and critical feature in their evolution.</p><blockquote>Given that the shuffling of genetic material has a very high probability of producing genomes that are no longer functional, the selective pressure for the underlying mechanism of recombination to be evolutionarily maintained must presumably be very strong. […]</blockquote><blockquote>Recombinant viruses that are most likely to succeed under competitive circumstances with small population sizes are those for which the recombination event has conferred a strong selective advantage over both parental viruses. — <a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10265781/">Wells H. et al., Cell Host Microbe, 2023</a></blockquote><p>While various horseshoe bat species were identified as the most prominent hosts and natural reservoirs of sarbecoviruses in the wild, they are certainly not the only bat family involved in creating overall sarbecoviral diversity.</p><p>Viral recombination needs the physical opportunity for <em>other viruses</em> to infect the same cell; parental viruses can not create offspring if they never meet, but <strong>their offspring might also not be as diverse if they never meet very distinct others</strong>. So how do our hypersocial rhinolophids do on that <em>“meeting new people”</em> front?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*NPnvR8s7APBS6HjbR7NNEw.png" /><figcaption>Some bat species have been observed to regularly co-mingle with other species, especially in cooler caves or during torpor (short-term hibernation). Image credit: Prof. Alice C Hughed, University of Hong Kong.</figcaption></figure><blockquote>“Some of those different species will roost together, especially when it is cooler or during hibernation. So when we have done work in various cooler caves […], we will see clusters. Rhinolophus [horseshoe bats] cuddled up to Miniopterus [long-winged bats], and the next one is Myotis [mouse-eared bats]. Now these are lineages that diverged 50 million years ago.” — <em>Bat ecologist Prof. Alice Hughes</em></blockquote><p><strong>Beyond mere cuddling with strangers, bats are known to switch roosts constantly.</strong> There are maternity-only roosts, summer and winter locations, and roosts that are calm or have special geographic features. Some bats like to stay and guard the house cave, others cycle outside but come back periodically over the year — <em>maybe kids going to college would be a social analogy, if only we could tell bat age, that is </em>— and many bats do food tourism with the seasons. All of this leads to constant turnover, and various bat species mixing and mingling with each other.</p><blockquote>So we have a colorful and complex social, seasonal, and geographic mixing of various bat species even when just studying single locations, like a specific cave or a forest.</blockquote><p>Some of this movement and mingling was always a natural part of bat lives. More recently, however, human encroachment on bat territory — <em>urbanization, deforestation, hunting, tourism, mining, etc </em>— is considered the biggest factor in displacing bats from their traditional roost sites and forcing species together that might not have ordinarily met.</p><p>If some bat species that diverged often millions of years ago tend to huddle together —<em> and we already learned that the ACE2 tropism of various sarbecovirus RBDs can be very broad </em>— do the diverse viruses they carry infect each other and influence recombination patterns as well?</p><p>This is one question researchers were able to answer recently with a resounding <strong>yes</strong>.</p><p>By using a meta-transcriptomics approach — <em>taking a sample and sequencing every single piece of genetic information in it</em> — they discovered that many of the bats they sampled carried more than one virus. On top of that, the study found that some of the discovered viruses were shared between different bat species, suggesting frequent spillover events distributed the virome over multiple hosts. Dramatic opportunity for <em>virus sex </em>(recombination) and diversifying the viral gene pool with new genetic elements.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*mpAObYJF8cpNb1nP2uBYHA.png" /><figcaption>Co-infection with multiple viruses is a prerequisite for virus recombination. Some bats are hypersocial and diverse virus-sharing network reveals connectivity among viromes of different bat taxa. Viruses of concern and putative cross-species transmissions are shown in different colors. (<a href="https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-023-39835-1">Wang J. et al, Nature communications, 2023</a>)</figcaption></figure><blockquote>“The frequent virus spillover among phylogenetically related or spatially co-located bats provides an opportunity for viromes of different bat species to exchange, further expanding genetic diversity of circulating viruses” — <a href="https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-023-39835-1"><em>Wang J. et al, Nature communications, 2023</em></a></blockquote><p>I think these findings are important to consider. Whatever innate mechanistic ability for recombination sarbecovirus genomes might have, it is <strong>largely the social lives of their host reservoir that create the opportunity and evolutionary pressures for recombination</strong> to shape sarbecovirus genomes.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*YQcW5QN8VRDB98ac5_nVIQ.png" /><figcaption>The diverse bat populations with their intricate lives serve as vast natural “gain-of-function” laboratories. (See the extended pdf version of this article.)</figcaption></figure><blockquote>These caves are nature’s vast “gain-of-function” laboratory, all while our human encroachment on bat territory is stirring the genetic cauldron ever faster.</blockquote><p>So now that we know what “gain-of-function labs” we are looking for, do we know where to look? Where exactly is the birthplace of SARS-CoV-2?</p><h4><strong>II) Undersampled Karst in the Wild-Wild East</strong></h4><p>Karst is a topography formed by the erosion of soluble carbonate rocks, such as limestone or dolomite. With a total area of 500.000 square kilometers in China and 400.000 square kilometers spread over various nations in Southeast Asia, these countries house some of the largest and most biodiverse Karst regions in the world. But it is truly the power of water over eons that has shaped the landscape to include spiky spires, enormous sinkholes, underground rivers, and intricate cave systems below the old-growth subtropical forest and rainforests. This is bat country, and each valley and limestone formation can not only house millions of bats but is a microcosm in itself.</p><blockquote>Each isolated limestone hill can host more than 12 unique species found nowhere else on earth, with up to 100 microsnails, endemic begonias, orchids, and geckos, and yet an estimated 90% of cave-dependent species are undescribed. — <em>Prof. Alice Hughes, University of Hong Kong</em></blockquote><p>The Karst region spanning Southern China and Southeast Asia forms a unique and biodiverse ecosystem that in considerable parts is still relatively untouched by humans, albeit that has been changing especially with deforestation, slash-and-burn, and cash crop agriculture leading to the degradation of the land. Its importance to the global climate and conservation is probably second behind the Amazon rainforest, with projections suggesting around 40% loss until the end of the century if we do not dramatically change course.</p><p>The shifting landscape use in turn is one of the major drivers of zoonotic spillover. Some studies suggest that around 65.000 spillovers of CoVs happen each year, most of them from viruses that are yet undiscovered and that do not cause an outbreak for a variety of reasons.</p><blockquote>The risk for zoonotic viral disease presence and emergence in humans also increases in geographic areas with higher mammal diversity, where previously pristine forests have been recently deforested. This makes the areas of Southeast Asia, which support large, intact natural habitats and have ongoing ecosystem fragmentation, at high risk for disease emergence — <a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9981523/"><em>Evans TS. et al., Int J. Infect Dis, 2023</em></a></blockquote><p>The majority of viruses that spill over might just not replicate well in the host cell, or get shut down by our innate human host defense, such as the interferon pathway, without humans ever being the wiser. Even most replicating viruses might be unable to transmit between humans, or unable to spread effectively enough. Outbreaks are also always social phenomena, even a perfectly capable pandemic like SARS-CoV-2 would have <a href="https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.abf8003">died out with a 99,5% likelihood</a> if it spilled over in a remote village, rather than a megacity.</p><p>Given most of these sarbecoviruses die out and will never be known, narrowing down where exactly SARS-CoV-2 came from within an often inaccessible, remote Karst region 2,5 times bigger than the size of Germany is a daunting challenge.</p><p>Yet this background of viral emergence and constant spillovers gives researchers three lines of attack to at least narrow down where the bat ancestor of SARS-CoV-2 likely originated.</p><ul><li>discover the immunological footprint of related viruses through serology in humans and farm animals</li><li>discover the immunological footprint of related viruses through serology in wild bats</li><li>discover related viruses through sequencing bat samples</li></ul><p>Evidence for SARS-CoV-2-related sarbecoviruses has been found in China, Laos, Vietnam, Cambodia, Thailand, Myanmar, and Malaysia.</p><ul><li>Most direct evidence comes from sequenced bat viruses in China (before sampling in Yunnan became forbidden), where researchers found a pool of SC2-related viruses in Yunnan province. (<em>China has been more sampled than other nations</em>)</li><li>Another trove of informative viruses was found by French and Laotian researchers in Vientiane province in Laos. Here the closest match to SARS-CoV-2 broad-affinity RBD was found, proving nature unlocked that particular door to human infection; not human engineering.</li><li>More distant SC2-related viruses have also been found in Cambodia and Thailand; which in themselves can house informative genetic elements such as insertions at the S1/S2 site reminiscent of the polybasic cleavage motif in SC2</li></ul><p>Some have summarized the possible origin place at very low resolution (<em>below</em>) based on the sampling location and overall genetic similarity of the various SC2-related viruses.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*t7tCj7Pas33YiRRy5Wkjfw.png" /><figcaption>Low-resolution likely geographic origin based on overall genetic and RBD similarity of a set of closely related SC2-like bat viruses and their original sampling site (red triangle) <a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9128337/">Zhao S. et al., J Genet Genomics, 2022</a></figcaption></figure><p>Yet such efforts are bound to be highly dependent on sampling biases and offer a low granularity that is almost meaningless. The map has also not considered some other relevant findings such as:</p><ul><li>SC2-related viruses have been found in pangolins smuggled over the Chinese and Thai borders</li><li>Especially the karst regions bordering Laos, Northern Vietnam, and Myanmar seemed very rich in these viruses, with Myanmar lacking any bat sampling efforts there so far</li><li>However, <a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9981523/">serological evidence from Myanmar</a> further South found a very high prevalence of undiscovered SC2-related viruses in humans that had contact with wildlife. More than 1 out of 5 had antibodies and cross-reactivity to a panel of these viruses (most prominently RaTG13), arguing for high prevalence and spillover potential in this region</li><li>Bat sampling in Japan, Southern Vietnam, and Malaysia shows more ancestral and distantly related sarbecoviruses</li><li>Sampling in Northern Thailand has been politically difficult to publish but might be fruitful as well</li></ul><p>Here is a rough summary of scientist’s efforts so far:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*uVZOnFVED5orqNeogTA47A.png" /><figcaption><strong>Geographic location of SARS-CoV-2 relatives sampled in Southern China and Southeast Asia</strong>. Large parts of the Karst region, especially outside of China, remain hopelessly undersampled. Technical names of virus relatives usually include the bat species as first letters. Rm … Rhinolophus malayanus, Ra … Rhinolophus affinis, Rsh… Rhinolophus stheno, Rp … Rhinolophus pussilis, Rac … Rhinolophus acuminatus. The displayed color coding roughly indicates genetic similarity to SARS-CoV-2 (yellow — medium, orange — high, red — very high)</figcaption></figure><p>Honestly, while a lot of valuable information has been gathered in the last few years, it serves merely as a snapshot of the scope of our ongoing ignorance.</p><p><strong>The reality is that there is still much we do not understand about our diverse world.</strong> According to Prof. Alice Hughes, it is estimated that 90% of caves in Southeast Asia alone remain scientifically undescribed and uninventoried, while some estimate around 60% of bat species remain to be discovered, and a staggering many of the bat species we know about have never been sequenced. We still need to learn much more about viral and bat geography, how human drivers from deforestation to urbanization to tourism interface with bat immunity, viral-host interactions, bat-human contacts, and propensity for viral shedding.</p><blockquote>We are working with a map where many spots are and will likely remain blank because any research on bats has been so highly politicized by the distorted origins debate.</blockquote><p>There is a need to study these complex interactions between viruses, bats, and humans. However, many Southeast Asian nations, as well as China, have little interest in allowing researchers to sample more bats, discover new viruses, or even publish ones they have already found (<em>personal communication from multiple bat hunters</em>).</p><p>Especially sarbecoviruses are a sensitive subject almost everywhere. Governments are currently not interested in discovering where these dangerous chimeras are circulating in the wild or what drives their emergence.</p><blockquote>Some governments fear more scientific discoveries will lead to them being blamed by a world that has not made peace with natural pandemic risks.</blockquote><p>A world that asks for reparations, culprits, or impossible insurances, rather than offering a helping hand on a collective problem. A world where leaders seek power with geopolitical grandstanding, or worse, gain popularity by exerting vengeance on inconvenient scientists rather than heeding their warnings.</p><p>I believe collectively, we need to do better on that front.</p><p>Scientists are doing their part, despite these artificial limitations and political constraints. Some of them have been tinkering with new methods and ingenious ideas to learn more about the origin history of SARS-CoV-2, and there are some exciting findings to report.</p><h4>III) <strong>Ghost hunting with phylogenetic inference</strong></h4><p>Gaining knowledge from sparse data is difficult, but not impossible.</p><p>To date, only 167 sarbecoviruses have been found. 139 of them are closely related to SARS-CoV-1, and 26 are SARS-CoV-2-like. Not much to work with to pinpoint a geographic location, and individual genomes can also not be used to reconstruct a faithful evolutionary history because all of these are chimeras, so molecular clock estimates based on mutational divergence are being misled by the “evolutionary fast-forwards” of recombination.</p><blockquote>Evolutionary rate estimation can be profoundly affected by the presence of recombination — <a href="https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32724171/"><em>Boni MF. et al., Nature Microbiology, 2020</em></a></blockquote><p>The number of sarbecovirus relatives discovered to date is however just good enough to identify<strong> recombination breakpoints, </strong>places where genetic similarity from one parental strain stops and similarity to a different parental strain starts. A way to think about <strong>recombination breakpoints</strong> is as a minimum number of sexual acts that must have happened in the past that can explain the segmented shape of the chimeric genome today.</p><p>The genomic segments in between recombination breakpoints are called <strong>non-recombinant regions (NRRs), </strong>basically <em>intact genomic segments</em> from a parental strain. On these segments, molecular clock estimates work normally and can thus be informative. Virologists will just have to individually work with as many clocks and evolutionary histories as there are NRRs, which is 27 in the case of SARS-CoV-2, and 31 for SARS-CoV-1. (<em>see figure below</em>)</p><blockquote>“If you align all viruses in the same place, and then chop up the genome into segments — what we call non-recombinant regions (NRRs) — then each NRR will have their evolutionary history” — <em>Dr. Spyros Lytras, an evolutionary virologist at the University of Tokyo (</em>exclusive video interview video at the end of article<em>)</em></blockquote><blockquote>Imagine NRRs not as pieces of larger viruses, but as floating genetic elements that can shuttle in and out of viral backbones. Why should they not be analyzed individually?</blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*jWLCBnaKRxRwio1FkUwedQ.png" /><figcaption>Non-recombinant regions are informative and need to be analyzed individually to be able to present — to the extent possible — a single evolutionary history of chimeric viruses. <a href="https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/2023.07.12.548617v1.full.pdf">(Pekar et al., biorxiv, 2023</a>)</figcaption></figure><p>Separating the histories of NRRs allows researchers to gain some critical information. For example, while some NRRs might be very old and just serve as reminders of sexual conduct decades ago, others might be very recent additions; the <strong>final sexual (<em>recombination</em>) events that gave rise to the chimera</strong>.</p><p>Indeed, researchers found that <strong>the youngest recombinant additions</strong> for SARS-CoV-1 and SARS-CoV-2 to their closest-inferred bat virus ancestor happened not decades ago, but were in 2001 (SARS-CoV-1 spilled over in 2002) and <strong>in 2014 (SARS-CoV-2 spilled over in 2019)</strong>, respectively. This is of course not the final word, as the researchers noticed the more cousins are discovered, the closer the time estimate moves up towards toward the emergence date.</p><blockquote>“The virus pieces that were most similar circulated in bats very recently” — <em>Dr. Jonathan Pekar, US San Diego</em></blockquote><p>Having identified the 27 disparate recombinant pieces constituting SARS-CoV-2 also allows researchers to do something very interesting, which is constructing the <strong>closest common recombinant ancestor (recCA</strong>) genome, basically looking at which viral cousin of SC2 has the highest similarity to SARS-CoV-2 for each NRR.</p><blockquote><em>The recCA genome is an aggregate, built from the ghosts of closest-inferred ancestors for each NRR that must have existed at one point</em></blockquote><p>Tellingly, researchers have found that the more bat virus relatives got discovered in nature, the closer the genome sequence of the recCA resembled the human-infecting SARS-CoV-2 that emerged.</p><p><strong>In other words, we have evidence to infer that a 98.8% identical to SC2 bat virus ancestor circulated just a few years before emergence</strong>; with temporal and genetic granularity still increasing as more viral cousins are discovered.</p><p>But what can we do with that knowledge?</p><h4>IV) Reconstructing the phylogeographic histories</h4><p>As we have observed in the karst region, sarbecoviruses, just like their bat hosts, show a <strong>degree of geographic structuring</strong>; with the border region of Laos, Myanmar, Northern Vietnam, and Southern China seemingly quite rich in sarbecoviruses closely related to SARS-CoV-2.</p><p>But does that mean SARS-CoV-2 came from that region, or is it just a mixture of undersampling and coincidence?</p><p>By using these <strong>phylogeographic data</strong>, a phylogeny (family tree) for each NRR can be constructed that is spatially mapped to sampling locations.</p><blockquote>“When we build those family trees, we want to calibrate them with time” — <em>Dr. Jonathan Pekar, US San Diego.</em></blockquote><p><strong>Combining geographic information</strong> from sampling locations of close ancestors <strong>with phylogeny scaled with units of time</strong> of their closest recombinant ancestors creates a geo-temporal record for the various genetic elements constituting the SARS-CoV-2 viral genome.</p><blockquote><em>A record of their ancestor’s whereabouts throughout history, and where and when they had time to meet each other to mingle.</em></blockquote><p>These geospatial and temporal efforts also allow us to <strong>narrow down a dispersion zone</strong> for these “floating genetic elements”, and with it, the viruses that arose by their (re)combination.</p><p>In other words, the <strong>most likely</strong> <strong>geographic birthplaces</strong> <strong>of direct bat ancestors</strong> to SARS-CoV-1 and SARS-CoV-2 (<em>see below</em>).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*sP-hWlP0-aOYmOabiPG-cw.png" /><figcaption>Phylogeographic origin dispersion map of SARS-CoV-1 (left) and SARS-CoV-2 (right). Green density map tracks evolutionary history through time, red density are the most likely birthplaces of the direct bat ancestors to SARS-COV-1 and SARS-CoV-2 (<a href="https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/2023.07.12.548617v1.full.pdf">Pekar et al., biorxiv, 2023</a>)</figcaption></figure><blockquote>The phylogeographic patterns seemed to be spatially structured, with phylogenetically similar viruses being generally sampled in geographically similar regions and almost no back-and-forth travel of viral lineages across relatively large regions of the study area. — <a href="https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/2023.07.12.548617v1.full.pdf">Pekar et al., biorxiv, 2023</a></blockquote><p>This last result gained from studying sarbecovirus ancestry unearthed one more essential clue to how SARS-CoV-1 and SARS-CoV-2 emerged.</p><p>It starts with a suspicious conclusion:</p><blockquote><em>“Direct ancestors of the SARS-CoVs likely could not have reached sites of emergence via the bat reservoir alone”</em></blockquote><p>SARS-COV-1 emerged in Guangzhou, around 1000km away from its suspected home; and SARS-COV-2 emerged in Wuhan, around 1500 km away from where the direct bat ancestor existed.</p><blockquote>So how exactly did SARS-CoV-2 find its long way from the sarbecovirus “gain-of-function” heart of the Karst region to a wet market in Wuhan?</blockquote><h4>V) Smoking guns pointing at the wildlife industry</h4><p>An outbreak rarely divulges all of its mysteries. How the virus made it to Wuhan still leaves room for uncertainty and speculation. <em>Lab leak advocates might be quick to smell an opportunity to allege that maybe a researcher from Wuhan has gotten infected and brought the virus to the city. Weren’t Zhengli’s group and some other teams sampling in Yunnan after all?</em></p><p>These insinuations are unfortunately quite shallow, scientifically naive, and ultimately false because the leftover uncertainties are much smaller than one might appreciate.</p><p>I could spill much more digital ink on arguing how <em>a priori</em> unlikely it is for bat researchers and virus hunters to ever stumble upon a pandemic-ready chimeric virus from the small bat sampling efforts researchers ever get to conduct. One might find genetic puzzle pieces, but how nature put them together only comes to light after selection created those million-to-one lottery winners that spill over into other mammals. If Chinese researchers had collected and stored hundreds of those spillover viruses, maybe suspicions had a ground to stand on. The reality is that Zhengli Shi’s team only ever found one SARS-CoV-2-related virus, even non-pandemic viruses are hard to find. One could also contend that there is no evidence for any of these speculations. One might also list the eerie circumstances surrounding SARS-CoV-2 that look an awful lot like SARS-CoV-1; from the fact that both started in November (suggesting seasonality) to the finding that sampled wildlife farms around Wuhan had SARS-CoV-1 lineages potentially ancestral to the outbreak that happened in Guangzhou… <em>but okay, I am spilling digital ink again, so I will stop. (See extended pdf version)</em></p><p>Again, it is 2024 and scientists have uncovered a lot more <strong>evidence that completely exonerates</strong> Chinese and other<strong> bat researchers</strong> who ever sampled in Yunnan or various places in South East Asia.</p><blockquote>Let us just focus on two puzzle pieces that I think are illuminating because no type of research-related accident can explain them.</blockquote><h4><strong>The first piece</strong></h4><p>The first one is — what I feel — one of the biggest oversights in the discussion, and it has to do with the <strong>damned furin cleavage site</strong> again.</p><p>In Chapter 1, we spend considerable time explaining why we know that the <strong>FCS does not have an artificial origin</strong>. We also know from looking at sarbecoviruses that while these FCS motifs can easily be created, they do not seem to be maintained in bat viral lineages. They are even unstable in many cell culture systems. However — within certain real-life transmission contexts — the FCS is strongly <strong>preserved as a respiratory adaption</strong>.</p><p>That extends beyond humans; minks, deers, and other animals that got infected with SARS-CoV-2 via reverse spillover and the respiratory route from humans have been shown to preserve the FCS as well. Bats do not appear to do so, for reasons one <a href="https://www.protagonist-science.com/p/natures-neglected-gof-laboratory">can speculate</a> (<em>e.g. bat sarbecoviruses are gut-adapted, not respiratory</em>) but are certainly <strong>host-context dependent</strong>. No genetic element acts alone.</p><p>This observation however means that one has to assume that <strong>the direct bat ancestor of SARS-COV-2 almost certainly did not have (or maintain) an FCS</strong>. But we also know that the <strong>FCS does not have an artificial origin</strong>.</p><blockquote><em>If neither bats nor humans created the FCS, where does it come from?</em></blockquote><p>By just following these two evidence-based assessments to their logical conclusion, it becomes clear that an intermediate host had to be involved.</p><p>Somewhen <strong>between as early as 2014</strong> (likely later) when a recombination event allowed the bat ancestor to reach its final chimeric form, <strong>but before it emerged in 2019</strong> at the Huanan wildlife market, the <strong>virus must have acquired and/or sustained it’s FCS in a non-bat host</strong> (<em>complimentary evidence like </em><a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8491763/"><em>D614G stabilization also argue for a very recent FCS addition</em></a>).</p><p><em>“The Furin cleavage site gave me the strongest hint that the progenitor virus of SARS-CoV-2 is not in bats”,</em> Prof. Linfa Wang told me. He is by far not the only virologist who believes this is the case. <em>“It’s in pangolins, raccoon dogs, civets, badgers, or whatever, maybe another small mammal we don’t know”</em></p><p><strong>There is a recent precedent.</strong> Evidence for such <a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9933577/">FCS acquisition in intermediate host species</a> has been found in 2023 with trafficked pangolins. A bat HKU4-related merbecovirus (<em>bat ancestors to MERS also do not contain an FCS</em>) has acquired a minimal polybasic cleavage motif experimentally shown to be cleaved by furin. It seems that for CoV spillovers, <strong>intermediate animal populations </strong>tend to bring these polybasic cleavage sites forth and<strong> can maintain them</strong>.</p><p>An identical argument for another such <strong>respiratory adaptation that gets maintained</strong> could also be made for the <a href="https://www.nature.com/articles/s41422-021-00600-y#MOESM1">T372A mutation that alters the 3D confirmation of the trimeric S glycoprotein to a more open and respiratory infectious form</a>. Bat sarbecoviruses do not have this, humans could not have come up with it. So where did it come from? <em>Same story really.</em></p><p><em>A priori</em>, it is very unlikely that bats directly infect bat researchers, and even extremely unlikely to ever find a pandemic pathogen from the pithy sampling efforts bat researchers ever get to conduct. But add to this the likely requirement of a <strong>host-context switch and respiratory adaptation</strong> in an intermediate animal to maintain an FCS/T372A? Pretty much impossible.</p><p>I trust this should finally dispel the myth that bat-sampling researchers brought SARS-CoV-2 to Wuhan.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/750/0*H73Coh8Q5r0vefn0.png" /></figure><p>There has been a lot of hysteria and myth-making surrounding the furin-cleavage site in the media over the last four years.</p><p>To now <strong>understand that the one genetic element</strong> many have falsely called the “smoking gun for engineering” <strong>contributes much more to bat researchers’ exoneration than to their incrimination</strong> is certainly a fitting and long-overdue twist of fate.</p><p>Talking about non-bat intermediate hosts though…</p><h4>The second piece</h4><p>Something no research-related accident can explain is the fact that the <a href="https://www.protagonist-science.com/p/natures-neglected-gof-laboratory">multiple independent lines of evidence</a> point to the <a href="https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.add8384">Huanan market as the epicenter of the pandemic</a>.</p><p>Researchers had already established in 2022 that SARS-CoV-2 susceptible wildlife had been sold at the market — despite denials and obfuscations from Chinese authorities — and that the spreading pattern of two lineages centering from the market is best explained by a multi-spillover scenario from an infected pool of animals.</p><p>More recently, sequencing data of environmental samples from the market were finally released by Chinese scientists which provided a trove of genetic information to sift through for more possible clues.</p><p>And clues they found.</p><ul><li>Genetic diversity of SARS-CoV-2 samples is consistent with viral emergence at the market; also contradicts the market as a mere “amplifier” or “superspreading” event</li><li>Environmental samples that tested positive for SARS-CoV-2 contained lots of DNA/RNA from various SARS-CoV-2 susceptible wildlife species</li><li>Animal DNA/RNA correlated spatially with stalls that housed these animals, but not other places in the market</li><li>Environmental samples from these wildlife stalls contained sequencing reads for wildlife-specific animal viruses and SARS-CoV-2, but not other human viruses (<em>arguing against human contamination of these samples</em>)</li><li>single-nucleotide variation (SNV) analysis if raccoon dog reads found that the raccoon dogs at the market did not belong to a commonly breed species used for fur production, but rather a wild-caught variety commonly found in Southern China</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*lU_CT0tK6Dmb0Nnu8ZTtoA.png" /><figcaption>Metatranscriptomic analysis of environmental samples taken from SC2-susceptible animals at the Huanan market provide evidence for a link to the wildlife trade in Southern China. (Figures from <a href="https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/2023.09.13.557637v1.full.pdf">Crits-Christoph A. et al., biorxiv, 2023</a>)</figcaption></figure><p>These market data make it clear that no infected lab worker just walked into Huanan to start the pandemic, nor sneezed on the animals to make it look like they were involved. On top of that, they provide multiple direct links to the wildlife trade and industry; from the species that were identified to the types of viruses that plagued those animals; and even to the geographic region where they might have come from.</p><p><strong>These findings are consistent with the WHO report that also suggested the involvement of the </strong><a href="https://www.npr.org/sections/goatsandsoda/2021/03/15/977527808/who-points-to-wildlife-farms-in-southwest-china-as-likely-source-of-pandemic"><strong>wildlife industry in Yunnan</strong></a><strong> and beyond.</strong></p><p>From illegal trafficking of rare animals over the border, hunting and trapping them in the wild for later sale or sustenance, or supplementing breeding in <a href="https://www.npr.org/sections/goatsandsoda/2021/03/15/977527808/who-points-to-wildlife-farms-in-southwest-china-as-likely-source-of-pandemic">wildlife farms</a>, the industry has many facets. Some activities are illegal but lack enforcement, some are traditional and culturally valued, while other activities such as wildlife farms were explicitly promoted before the pandemic.</p><blockquote>“Local officials trumpeted the wildlife trade as a way to close the rural-urban divide and to meet ambitious national targets to alleviate poverty.” — <em>Emily Fang, </em><a href="https://www.npr.org/sections/goatsandsoda/2020/06/28/883900042/pandemic-causes-china-to-ban-breeding-of-bamboo-rats-and-other-wild-animals"><em>reporting for NPR</em></a></blockquote><p><strong>So that is it? This is how the virus made it to Wuhan?</strong></p><p>Outbreaks rarely divulge all their secrets, and insights have to be pried from nature and history through the often painstaking work of scientists, journalists, and other truthseekers.</p><p>Science is a process of approaching ever more likely explanations of reality by rooting out false hypotheses and narrowing down existing uncertainties.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*NYQ785cGPRoa25tniyUk8A.png" /><figcaption>The controversy surrounding the origins of SARS-CoV-2 has been largely resolved. Any genetic manipulation or laboratory involvement is incompatible with available evidence and falls outside the remaining uncertainties that surround the SE Asian and Chinese wildlife industry’s role in circulating the virus and facilitating its ultimate emergence at the Huanan market in Wuhan</figcaption></figure><p>The remaining scientific uncertainties of the origin puzzle surround politically sensitive topics such as a <strong>rampant regional wildlife industry</strong> — <em>estimated to be over </em><a href="https://www.npr.org/sections/goatsandsoda/2021/03/15/977527808/who-points-to-wildlife-farms-in-southwest-china-as-likely-source-of-pandemic"><em>USD 70 Billion in China</em></a><em> </em>and around <a href="https://news.mongabay.com/2023/03/se-asias-covid-legacy-is-less-wildlife-trade-but-more-hunting-study-finds/"><em>USD 10 Billion in South East Asia just for trafficking</em></a> — as well as more complex patterns of how socioeconomic behavior and ecosystemic disruption influences spillover risk factors and pandemic prevention policies at various virus/animal/human interfaces. That is why this type of “pandemic origin” research must continue, despite knowing this virus did not come from any lab. There is still much more to learn on how to prevent SARS-CoV-3. But that is a topic for a different time.</p><p>For now, I think we finally reached a (<em>hopefully satisfying</em>) end of this epic journey towards the cutting edge of origins research. So what is my personal takeaway?</p><h3>Conclusion: Don’t bet against scientific inquiry</h3><p>Finding the origin of a new virus is a lot more difficult than finding the needle in a haystack, because viruses evolve, adapt, branch out, and almost always die out without us ever being the wiser. It’s like finding a particular grain of sand on a beach, always in danger of being washed away by the next wave. The search for any “bat patient zero” almost four years later would be a hopeless effort even before the deliberate sabotage of scientific processes by governments and malicious actors.</p><p>Yet in some twisted sense, <strong>we were lucky that the genome and evolution of sarbecoviruses are so intricate and reliant on recombination</strong>; it means that SARS-CoV-2&#39;s evolutionary history contains many overlapping stories. Stories that can provide a richer picture of what, when, where, why, and how it happened, akin to a set of contemporary witnesses with limited knowledge, or a set of partial fingerprints all over a crime scene.</p><blockquote>Puzzling these genetic and phylogeographic fingerprints together, documenting what places they touched at what time, and listening to what story they have to tell allows researchers to draw a much larger picture from the mosaic knowledge of our ignorance.</blockquote><p>The reality is that the observed viral ancestry of SARS-CoV-2 betrays any conceited notions we might have held about virologists — or gain-of-function research — bringing about the deadly chimeric pathogen. Scientists have the time and place of its birth and emergence narrowed down to a sufficient granularity to exclude any lab-related incidents. On top of that, we learned about some viral features that only natural selection, not human engineering, could bring forth.</p><p>Yet our understandable fears and suspicions of a “man-made” pandemic — <em>albeit misplaced into too simple narratives or wrongfully projected onto all too convenient scapegoats in suspicious white coats</em>— are also not entirely baseless.</p><blockquote>As often with popular myths and sentiments, there is a grain of larger truths embedded in them.</blockquote><p><strong>Today, there is plenty of scientific evidence to make the case that collectively, we humans are not entirely innocent.</strong> Neither when it comes to fueling the forces that create these dangerous viruses, nor the reasons that make them spill over into us. <em>In nature, no element acts alone</em>. That includes us and the circumstances we create. As a now publicly smeared and unjustly character-assassinated zoologist once told me:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*-Z9nWNLx-nXsTe7Kwo1jsg.png" /></figure><p>It is <strong>what we humans currently do to the planet and every other species on it that largely sets the conditions for zoonotic spillover events</strong>, and we drive them at an ever-accelerating pace.</p><blockquote>What we can and should do about this sobering reality needs urgent societal discussion.</blockquote><p>For that to happen, I believe that <strong>the era where false “gain-of-function” origin myths are wielded as weapons for persuasion, profit, or power has to end</strong>. Not only is this deeply unethical and scientifically irresponsible in 2024, but it has thus far proven counterproductive for scientific research, pandemic prevention efforts, and the public good.</p><p>In this article, I focused our attention on an <strong>interconnected set of scientific knowledge related to viral recombination</strong>, and it is important to mention that this — <em>while very comprehensive</em> — is just a mere facette of the larger origin picture. There are other comprehensive lines of investigation that this article could not go into, like epidemiology, which also points to viral emergence in the Huanan market and contradicts any research-related origin scenario. No single article can cover it all.</p><p><strong>Understanding the origin story through the lens of viral recombination is incredibly powerful</strong> because it exposes the shallow ideas and trivial falsehoods about the virus thrown into our faces every day. It also shows us that nature is much more complex, nuanced, and vast than we commonly give it credit for. It would be wise to exert more caution and compassion before trying to shape every last ecosystem to our human whims.</p><p>A comprehensive body of scientific evidence has shown us that the <strong>immediate bat ancestor to SARS-CoV-2</strong> came from one of the <strong>countless natural “gain-of-function labs” </strong>spanning the vast biodiverse Karst region from Yunnan in Southern China towards Myanmar, Laos, Thailand, Cambodia, Vietnam, and maybe even Malaysia in Southeast Asia. The lingering and promiscuous endemic viral elements in that enormous geographic region constantly mix and bring forth new chimeric combinations within their socially intricate reservoir hosts; while <strong>human activities and encroachment on bat territories stir the genetic cauldron ever faster</strong>.</p><p>Once a particularly combustible set of genetic elements produced a <strong>potential pandemic pathogen with broad host tropism</strong>, the <strong>legal and illegal mammalian wildlife industry likely became the maturing vessels </strong>through which the virus we now know as SARS-CoV-2 reached its final explosive form. From there, it was <strong>dragged in front of hundreds of immune-naïve future hosts visiting the largest wet market</strong> of one particular Chinese megacity well connected with the entire world.</p><blockquote>The rest is history, one which we are currently bound to repeat.</blockquote><p>Maybe after four years of political myth-making and societal inaction, it is time to face scientific reality. I certainly believe we’d be better off fighting for solutions rather than for who is to blame.</p><p><strong>Because no matter what we want to believe</strong>, these natural chimeras will keep haunting us if science and society don’t come together to stop them.</p><p>[end]</p><h4><strong>Additional material:</strong></h4><p>Listen to an exclusive interview with Spyros Lytras and Jonathan Pekar about their groundbreaking SARS-CoV-1 and SARS-CoV-2 recombinant ancestry study:</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FROUdGeCmVYk%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DROUdGeCmVYk&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FROUdGeCmVYk%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/ed27d72947dc0dab44a760be158438d0/href">https://medium.com/media/ed27d72947dc0dab44a760be158438d0/href</a></iframe><p><strong>High-quality extended pdf version of this article can be found at:</strong></p><p><a href="https://www.protagonist-science.com/p/treacherous-ancestry">https://www.protagonist-science.com/p/treacherous-ancestry</a></p><p>Booklet version online:</p><p><a href="https://simplebooklet.com/treacherousancestry">Treacherous ancestry : simplebooklet.com</a></p><h3>A word of caution about science communication versus peer-reviewed research and scientific reviews</h3><p>In this article, I explained how multiple lines of scientific inquiry <strong>strongly exclude the possibility of gain-of-function research leading to COVID-19.</strong> Furthermore, the article highlights a body of literature warning about the <strong>clear and persistent danger of another zoonotic sarbecovirus spilling over into the human population</strong>.</p><p>Please consider that no single article can summarize all the valuable scientific contributions that scientists have made in support of investigating the origin question. It is a large and still-growing body of evidence spanning hundreds of papers that are mutually consistent with each other, the extant evidence, and the reality we live in.</p><p>I want deeply thank <strong>Prof. Alice Hughes, Prof. David Robertson, Prof. Linfa Wang, Dr. Alex Crits-Christoph and Dr. Jonathan Pekar</strong> for reviewing relevant sections of this article.</p><p><strong>My humble contribution</strong> to this topic was to focus on <strong>explaining recent key scientific arguments through the lens of viral recombination</strong> for non-experts and also accurately present the conclusions scientists reached in their work by considering a large, detailed body of evidence.</p><p>While I did go to great lengths to avoid misrepresentations — such as having hours of expert interviews and article reviews by domain experts before I post — I cannot always control how my words will be interpreted. If there are uncertainties arising from my simplifications, omissions of brevity, or bad analogies, I advise you to first consult the primary literature for clarification rather than presume there is an obvious mistake in the science or reasoning of scientists.</p><p><strong>At this point, the scientific consensus arising from a large body of evidence is pretty unequivocal on key issues surrounding the origins of SC2.</strong> However, this does not mean that there are no more questions to be asked or no more lessons to be learned on how to prevent SARS-CoV-3. That is why origin research continues, despite the “lab leak” question being mostly settled in the scientific literature.</p><p>Whenever there is a <em>(fake or real)</em> controversy about a scientific topic, I strongly believe that only the fruits of scientific inquiry — not a toxic combination of politics, media, and activists — will produce reliable knowledge and factual insights to act upon.</p><p>All that is missing currently is for some <strong>citizen</strong> <strong>defenders of an evidence-based worldview to do the legwork of closing the rift between science and society</strong>, for example by building bridges of accessibility where there are none. There is no infrastructure and no money in science communication, and science desks were the first to go in a crumbling newspaper economy. That is why I have to do this work without any financial aid or compensation (see motivation statement below); and against a lot of headwinds from emotionally engaged conspiratorial communities.</p><p>To be completely honest, the lack of accessible information and resources on this topic is not only a monetary issue, <a href="https://www.protagonist-science.com/p/asymmetric-power-in-the-information">nor a coincidence in a broken information ecosystem</a>. <a href="https://decoding-the-gurus.captivate.fm/episode/interview-with-worobey-andersen-holmes-the-lab-leak">Many virologists</a> have been generous and <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hIqmg4tIJ6c">great communicators</a> trying to compensate for public knowledge gaps before they were <a href="https://public.substack.com/p/top-scientists-misled-congress-about">publicly smeared and character assassinated into disengagement</a> (or <a href="https://www.science.org/content/article/lab-leak-proponents-rutgers-accused-defaming-and-intimidating-covid-19-origin">even defamed</a>) by motivated actors. Anti-science pressure organizations like US-right-to-know (USRTK) target outspoken virologists explicitly for that reason.</p><blockquote>“They extract a high cost for free speech, they coerce the informed into silence”</blockquote><blockquote><em>— </em><a href="https://www.nature.com/articles/nbt.3384"><em>Nature Magazine editorial about the anti-science pressure group USRTK</em></a></blockquote><p>I believe nobody in society should condone anti-science activism and abusive behavior. It would surely help if citizens stood up for scientists unfairly targeted by politicians once in a while. That virologists are bitterly disappointed in institutions, media, and politics that facilitate such attacks is an understatement. In the end, <a href="https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2352250X23001562">science and democracy can not function</a> without a society that supports them.</p><p>So I encourage you and other defenders of a “<em>weight-of-evidence</em>”-based worldview to talk about and speak up for the scientific method, use it to dispel popular myths, or simply enjoy having understood something important about a dramatic world event so you won’t be a sucker for the next manipulative charlatan that comes along.</p><h4>Motivation statement and copyright</h4><p>As always, my hope and goals are to educate and equip citizens with conceptual tools and new perspectives to make sense of the world we inhabit.</p><p>This article took a lot of time and effort to conceptualize, research, and produce, actually almost irresponsibly so given that <strong>I do not monetize</strong> my scicomm here; and neither do the scientists that so graciously gifted their time and expertise to help me and others understand their field of expertise.</p><blockquote><strong>I see this work as a public good that I send out into the void of the internet in hopes others will get inspired to act</strong></blockquote><p>You are also invited to deepen this work or just derive satisfaction from understanding our chaotic modern world a bit better.</p><p>So feel free to use, share, or build on top of this work, I just ask you to properly attribute (Creative Commons<strong> </strong><a href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/"><strong>CC-BY-NC 4.0</strong></a>).</p><p><strong><em>Cite this work:</em></strong></p><p><strong>Markolin P.</strong>, “<em>Treacherous ancestry. A phylogeographic hunt for the ghosts of SARS-CoV-2”</em>, April 19, 2024. <strong>Free direct access link:</strong></p><p><a href="https://www.protagonist-science.com/p/treacherous-ancestry">https://www.protagonist-science.com/p/treacherous-ancestry</a></p><p><em>Also, since this topic is close to my heart, I’d be happy to hear your thoughts</em></p><h3><strong>References:</strong></h3><p>Below I listed some of the key publications referenced in this article, with a short comment on what they are about for easy navigation and further reading.</p><h4><strong>On recombination in CoVs:</strong></h4><p><a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6025776/">Sola I. et al., Annu Rev Virol., 2015</a> (<em>recombination in CoVs is discontinuous with RdRp jumping around; deep mechanism of CoV transcription</em>)</p><p><a href="https://academic.oup.com/mbe/article/38/6/2520/6135088">Patino-Galindo JA. et al., Molecular Biology and Evolution, 2021</a> (<em>recombination patterns and frequency between viral families</em>)</p><p><a href="https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32724171/">Boni MF. et al., Nature Microbiology, 2020</a> (r<em>ecombination event between bats and pangolins not likely to have led to emergence of SARS-CoV-2, genetic elements of lineage have been circulating in bats for decades</em>)</p><p><a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9261289/">Klerk A. et al, Virus Evol., 2022</a> (<em>Conserved recombination patterns across and within coronavirus subgenera</em>)</p><p><a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10265781/">Wells H. et al., Cell Host Microbe, 2023</a> (<em>review article about CoV recombination, requirements and likely mechanisms</em>)</p><p><a href="https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-023-39835-1">Wang J. et al, Nature communications, 2023</a> (<em>virus-sharing networks between bats highlight ample opportunity for CoV recombination in nature</em>)</p><p><strong>*recombination as “virus sex” is not accurate mechanistically: </strong><em>The exchange of genetic material between viruses is usually non-reciprocal, meaning the recipient of a genome portion does not act as donor of the replaced portion in the original source. In this respect, the term recombination does not have the same meaning in viruses that it does in diploid, sexually reproducing organisms wherein the exchange of genetic material between chromatids in the first meiosis division is reciprocal.</em> (<a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7106159/">Perez-Losada M., Infect Genet Evol., 2015</a>)</p><h4><strong>On the Furin-cleavage site</strong></h4><p><a href="https://www.nature.com/articles/s41591-020-0820-9">Andersen KG., Nature Medicine, 202</a>0 (<em>proximal origin noticing unusual FCS and structural predictions of changed glycosylation patterns</em>)</p><p><a href="https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1873506120304165#!">Wu Y. et al, <em>Stem Cell Research, 2021</em></a><em> (highlights FCS sites over wider CoV family)</em></p><p><a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9278140/">Lavie M. et al., J Virol., 2022</a> (<em>cleavage at S1/S2 and S2 viral processivity studies highlight the function of the FCS</em>)</p><p><a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8491763/">Jackson JB. et al., Nat Rev Mol Cell Biol., 2022</a> (<em>FCS cleavage makes S1/S2 unstable, stabilizing mutation D614G. “This perplexing observation suggests that the acquisition of a furin-cleavage site by SARS-CoV-2 may have been a recent event.”</em>)</p><p><a href="https://www.nature.com/articles/s41564-021-00908-w">Peacock T. et al., Nature Microbiology, 2022</a> (<em>FCS cleavage of S1/S2 is essential in ferrets, pre-cleavage of the spike during viral egress enhances entry of progeny virions into TMPRSS2-expressing cells such as those abundant in respiratory tissue</em>;<em> and avoid endosomal </em><a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7078001/"><em>IFITM protein</em></a><em>s</em>)</p><p><a href="https://www.nature.com/articles/s41589-022-01059-7">Fraser BJ. et al., Nature, 2022</a> (<em>Spike processing by TMPRSS2; cuts extracellular spike in 3 places including S1/S2 if not pre-cleaved by furin to enable membrane fusion</em>)</p><p><a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9546612/">Garry R., PNAS, 2022</a> (<em>FCS was not engineered and certainly not modeled after human EnAC</em>)</p><p><a href="https://journals.asm.org/doi/10.1128/jvi.02186-21">Chaudhry MZ. et al., Virology, 2022</a> (<em>FCS gets quickly lost in cell culture because of kinetics</em>)</p><p><a href="https://www.pnas.org/doi/full/10.1073/pnas.2205690119">Vu MN. et al., PNAS, 2022</a> (<em>synergistic interaction with the QTQTN motif proximal to the FCS plays a key role in infection and pathogenesis</em>)</p><p><a href="https://www.nature.com/articles/s42003-022-03421-w">Sander AL. et al., Communications Biology, 2022</a> (<em>high sequence diversity in S1/S2 and a proto-FCS site found in European SARS-related bat </em>CoVs)</p><p><a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10117112/">Alwine JC. et al., mSphere, 2023</a> (<em>The FCS not lab adapted — </em>initial SARS-CoV-2 isolates replicate poorly in traditional laboratory models —<em> and not engineered — </em>cleavage site loop length — <em>best we can tell</em>)</p><p><a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9933577/">Neil SD. Cell, 2023</a> (<em>Furin cleavage sites in intermediate host animals, but not bat reservoirs</em>)</p><p><a href="https://www.nature.com/articles/s41579-023-01003-z">Steiner S. et al., Nature Reviews Microbiology, 2024</a> (<em>recent review on viral entry and what is known about different mechanisms</em>)</p><h4><strong>On the social lives of bats</strong></h4><p><a href="https://bioone.org/journals/acta-chiropterologica/volume-13/issue-2/150811011X624938/Using-Echolocation-Calls-to-Identify-Thai-Bat-Species--Vespertilionidae/10.3161/150811011X624938.short">Hughes AC. et al., Acta Chiropterologica, 2011</a> (<em>Bat calls are destinct; rhinolophids use distinctive constant frequencies that can facilitate identification</em>)</p><p><a href="https://royalsocietypublishing.org/doi/full/10.1098/rstb.2019.0061">Vernes SC. et al., Phil. Trans. R. Soc. B., 2019</a> (<em>vocalizations vary between species and include echolocation calls as well as social calls used either for parent–offspring reunions, territorial defence or maintaining group integration</em>)</p><p><a href="https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-020-03128-0">Irving A. et al., Nature, 2021</a> (<em>bats are uniquely suited hosts and viral reservoirs</em>)</p><p><a href="https://besjournals.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/1365-2656.14072">Respicio JM. et al., Journal of Animal Ecology, 2024</a> (<em>bat aggregation leads more negative and aggressive behavior</em>)</p><p><a href="https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-024-46979-1">Meyer M. et al., Nature Communications, 2024</a> (<em>bat diversity and disease relationship in response to human encroachment and habitat change</em>)</p><h4>On Karst and caves</h4><p><a href="https://academic.oup.com/book/40644/chapter-abstract/348314710?redirectedFrom=fulltext">David Gillieson, Oxford Academic, 2005</a> (<em>With a total area of about 400 000 km2, Southeast Asia contains some of the more extensive karst regions in the world. Many of these karst areas are of high relief with spectacular arrays of tower and cone karst. Many have now been inscribed on the World Heritage list in recognition of their unique geomorphology and biology</em>)</p><p><a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/South_China_Karst">https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/South_China_Karst</a> (<em>500.000 km2</em>)</p><h4><strong>On pre-pandemic Sarbeco seroprevalence in South-East Asia</strong></h4><p><a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6178078/">Wang N. et al., Virol Sin, 2018</a> (<em>October 2015 serum sampling from 218 residents in four villages in Jinning County, Yunnan province, China, 6 (2.7%) positive SARSr serology</em>)</p><p><a href="https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2590053619300308">Li H. et al., Biosafety and Health, 2019</a> (<em>pre-pandemic: 9 cases (0.6%) of SARS-CoV-1 positive serology from a snowball-sampled cohort of 1600 people in 3 provinces in Southern China between 2015–2017</em>)</p><p><a href="https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-022-31860-w">Sanchez CA et al., Nature communications, 2022 </a>(<em>65000 sarbeco-CoVs spillovers per year estimated</em>)</p><p><a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8798695/">Manning J. et al., Emerg. Inf Dis, 2022</a> (<em>SC2 Elisa assays of pre-pandemic blood samples taken in Cambodia between 2005–2011 show 4–14% reactivity</em>)</p><p><a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9981523/">Evans TS. et al., Int J. Infect Dis, 2023</a> (<em>neutralizing antibodies against various SC2r CoVs in Myanmar locals</em>, <em>high seroprevalence for rural (~20%) populations in 4 areas, 0% in city people, sampled pre-pandemic</em> <em>July 2017 to February 2020</em>)</p><h4><strong>On sampling location, geographical distribution of SC2r genomes:</strong></h4><p><a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8381922/">Li LL. et al., Emerg. Microb Infect. 2021</a> (<em>RpPrC31, a viral recombinant ancestor, retrospectively discovered from bat samples in Yunnan</em>)</p><p><a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7873279/">Wacharaplusadee S. et al., Nature communications, 2021</a> (<em>RacSC203, a cousin of SARS-2 discovered in Thailand containing S1/S2 insertion; also pangolin CoVs at wildlife checkpoint</em>)</p><p><a href="https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/34753934/">Delaune D. et al., Nature communications, 2021</a> (<em>bat samples from 2010 cambodia find a close relative 92,6% of SARS-CoV-2 (RSHTT200), one bat was simultaneously co-infected with 4 viruses, 2 of them sarbecoviruses)</em></p><p><a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8882382/">Lytras S. et al., Gen Evo., 2022</a> (<em>recombination analysis and geographic distribution of Sarbecoviruses</em>)</p><p><a href="https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-022-04532-4">Temmam S. et al., Nature, 2022</a> (<em>discovery of human-infectious SC2 relatives in Laos, “Banal” viruses and genome sequences</em>)</p><p><a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9128337/">Zhao S. et al., J Genet Genomics, 2022</a> (<em>geogenomic distribution patterns</em>)</p><p><a href="https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-023-41264-z">Han Y. et al., Nature communications, 2023</a> (<em>CoV sampling all over China)</em></p><p><a href="https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-023-42627-2">Muylaert RL. et al., Nature communication, 2023</a> (<em>landscape predictions and drivers of SC2 spillover</em>)</p><p><a href="https://msptm.org/files/Vol40No3/tb-40-3-001-Gilbert-M.pdf">Gilbert M. et al., Tropical Biomedicine, 2023</a> (<em>SC2 related coronaviruses in Malaysia, no full genome sequencing yet but 99% similarity for a fragment</em>)</p><p><a href="https://academic.oup.com/ve/article/10/1/vead079/7484569?login=false">Forero-Muñoz NR. et al., Virus evolution, 2024</a> (<em>phylogeographic structure in bat hosts creates a landscape of selective pressure</em>)</p><h4>On moral panics</h4><p><strong>*moral panic:</strong> <em>As a distinct species of collective behavior, moral panics represent contentious and intensely affective campaigns to police the parameters of public knowledge and morality. As such, they are necessarily dependent upon and constituted by claims-making, with interested parties historically seeking to actuate alarm by influencing the imagery and representations of the mainstream press. (</em><a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7201200/"><em>Walsh JP, International Journal of Cultural Studies, 2020</em></a><em>)</em></p><h4><strong>Recent preprints:</strong></h4><p><a href="https://www.researchsquare.com/article/rs-3227228/v1">Hassanin A. et al., biorxiv, 2023</a> (<em>phylogenetic divergence of close SC2 relatives between sub-tropical Northern Vietnam and tropical Southern Vietnam</em>)</p><p><a href="https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/2023.09.13.557637v1.full.pdf">Crits-Christoph A. et al., biorxiv, 2023</a> (<em>metatranscriptomics data analysis from Huanan market identifies wildlife species</em>)</p><p><a href="https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/2023.07.12.548617v1.full.pdf">Pekar et al., biorxiv, 2023</a> (<em>geospatial history and origins of SARS-CoV-1 and SARS-CoV-2, </em>video interview <a href="https://youtu.be/ROUdGeCmVYk">here</a>)</p><p><a href="https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/2024.02.11.579781v1.full.pdf">Si J. et al., biorxiv, 2024</a> (<em>multi-species ACE2 adaptiveness</em>, <em>Sarbecos can infect humans from the get-go</em>)</p><h4>Video interviews</h4><p><strong>Video</strong>: <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CJRM4htOhlM">Long-form discussion with bat ecologist Dr. Alice C. Hughes and the risk of SARS-CoV-3</a></p><p><strong>Video:</strong> <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lIuY0rZ3KjI">Long-form discussion with Dr. Michael Worobey and Dr. Kristian Anderson about their research establishing the Huanan market as the origin of the SARS-CoV-2 pandemic</a></p><p><strong>Video:</strong> <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J8VmHZl7DH0">Long-form discussion with Dr. Angela Rasmussen and Dr Stephen Goldstein debunking common bad lableak argument</a></p><p><strong>Video:</strong> <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eDIsQF8x80Q">Long-form discussion with SAGO member Dr. Carlos Morel</a> (<a href="https://www.who.int/groups/scientific-advisory-group-on-the-origins-of-novel-pathogens-%28sago%29">SAGO is the WHO’s scientific advisory group</a> on the origins of pandemics)</p><h4><strong>Bonus</strong></h4><p>Wow, I am surprised you scrolled all the end to the references. This curiosity (or due diligence) is of course rewarded with a little bonus information:</p><p><em>I have been working on an origins book with a twist that I believe will make some waves. It raises questions nobody else has yet dared to tackle: Where exactly does the “lab leak” myth come from, how did it move through society, and why were so many citizens susceptible to it? From the remote villages of the Lahu mountain tribes via chaotic conspiracy theorists and needy journalists to the halls of power and even the US presidency, THE LAB-LEAK MYTH will invite readers into my most challenging project yet; making sense of where the current rift between science and society really comes from.</em></p><p>You can subscribe for free to keep following my science writing and receive further updates and announcements per email.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b59614b92f3d" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/advances-in-biological-science/treacherous-ancestry-b59614b92f3d">Treacherous ancestry</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/advances-in-biological-science">Advances in biological science</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Lableak truther loses $100,000 in his own debate]]></title>
            <link>https://protagonist-science.medium.com/lableak-truther-loses-100-000-in-his-own-debate-0c3930ccd443?source=rss-c8e0e038559d------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/0c3930ccd443</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[lab-leak]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[literacy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[events]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[debate]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[science-communication]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Philipp Markolin]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 22 Feb 2024 10:40:43 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-03-04T08:51:19.251Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Scientific literacy can be lucrative in the age of myth and manipulation</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*VqGlouM5kDsYtyVm_X4XMw.png" /></figure><p><strong>Background:</strong></p><p>The false myth of a research-related accident being at the root of the COVID-19 pandemic has become endemic in society. Despite a large and detailed body of scientific evidence contradicting or disproving most circulating ideas, many proponents are reluctant to give up even the most unsustainable notions of genetic engineering or gain-of-function research. This gap between scientific knowledge and public belief is dangerous for any democratic society.</p><blockquote>However — and this will be the topic of today — it is also not exactly fantastic for most “Lab Leak”-advocates to be captured by a false myth.</blockquote><p>One of them, an Israeli investor and poker player named <strong>Saar Wilf,</strong> has for years been working on a little but pompous side project he christened “<strong>Rootclaim</strong>”, a method promising to use probabilistic inference and math to get to the truth of any conflict.</p><blockquote>“Humans are <a href="https://www.rootclaim.com/white-paper">bad at reasoning</a>, clumsily trying to force the complexity and uncertainty of our world into a logical-deterministic model.</blockquote><blockquote>The problem is made worse by bad information inputs: dishonest and inaccurate journalism, state censorship, and culture wars.</blockquote><blockquote>Together, the result is that humans are left in the dark.<a href="https://www.rootclaim.com/analysis/Who-carried-out-the-chemical-attack-in-Ghouta-on-August-21-2013"> International disputes go unsolved</a>, <a href="https://www.rootclaim.com/claims/what-happened-to-barry-and-honey-sherman-19972">cold cases lay dormant</a>, and <a href="https://www.rootclaim.com/analysis/does-vitamin-d-reduce-the-severity-of-covid-19-outcomes">potentially life-saving drugs go unused</a>. The public is left bereft of reliable sources of information to make sense of the world, and worse decisions are made.</blockquote><blockquote>Rootclaim provides the solution. We overcome the flaws of human reasoning with our probabilistic inference methodology, and correct faulty inputs through transparency in our evidence and analysis.” <em>— Rootclaim mission statement</em></blockquote><p>Now reducing human biases and providing aid to reasoning are certainly lofty goals one can and ought to agree with. But the devil is, as often, in the details and implementation.</p><p><strong>How it works:</strong> Rootclaim defines basically a set of hypotheses, then takes all available evidence and groups them into evidence clusters (evidence that is conditionally dependent on each other is in the same cluster, whereas independent evidence would be in a new cluster) and then runs the probabilistic numbers to “update their priors”. Here is an example of their calculation:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*v5qErULgR_Y_j1k1e5LwoA.png" /></figure><p>Saar Wilf is very confident that his approach outperforms any other way to make sense of our often complex and chaotic world that has contradictory or incomplete information layered on top of motivated reasoning and human fallibility.</p><p>Even for a scientific question such as to the origin of SARS-CoV-2, he believes his epistemological approach more reliable than anything else, including the scientific method.</p><p>And that is where the trouble started for him.</p><h3>The Rootclaim debate</h3><p>Saar Wilf has been somebody who experienced a lot of luck in his career. As a training programmer, he created successful start-ups during the early 2000’s and leveraged them into significant wealth before becoming a successful investor and multi-millionaire. Since 2005, he had also turned into a semi-professional poker player with what appears to be robust winnings. Accordingly with such a background of achievement, he was confident in his ability to devised a supreme debate system that would allow challengers to win 100.000$ by putting themselves an equal amount on their side into an escrow; and independent judges would decide the debate winner based on probabilistic criteria and Rootclaim’s methodology.</p><p>Now the idea of putting up a fast 100.000$ for an internet debate is probably his idea of “fun”, but for most people, this format makes it inaccessible and just more of the “(financial) might is right” type of exercise. Accordingly, Rootclaim has not seen many challengers of the years. (<em>Update March 4: Saar contests that the $100,000 does not make the challenge inaccessible. “We are also willing to reduce the stakes as low as </em><strong><em>$10,000 for applicants already involved in public debate</em></strong><em> on the issue.”… </em>so I guess if you are famous, he is willing to reduce down to 10k to debate you on it)</p><p>None of these monetary details stopped Saar Wilf to issue a verdict on the likelihood on one of the most contested issues of today: <strong>Where exactly did SARS-COV-2 come from?</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*xqa60RLBcfuWmZIz0y3Itw.png" /><figcaption>Rootclaim assessed the likelyhood of a gain-of-function research escape at 89%, followed by a bioweapon at 4.5%, a lab accident with a natural virus at 3.2%, and a non-research related accident only at 3.2%</figcaption></figure><p>Anybody who has followed my writing or the scientific discourse on this topic will probably be shell-shocked to see a zoonotic origin featured only at a 3.2% likelihood, whereas the “bioweapon” scenario gets 4.5%, and a “gain-of-function lab leak” scenario gets 89%.</p><p><strong>Clearly, whatever Saar Wilf’s methodology, he came to hold a belief in strong contradiction of scientific evidence and expert consensus.</strong> Is he a lone maverick that has figures something out they have not? Or could it be that maybe he is not as lucky in science as he has been in business and gambling?</p><p>For years, his assessment stood unchallenged, garnering quite a following in the lableak truther community including DRASTIC amateurs.</p><p>This is not surprising, because who in their right mind would put up 100.000$ of their own money to debate a multimillionaire in his wonky debate format?</p><h3>Meet the challenger: Peter Miller</h3><p>Peter Miller is a software engineer, extreme rock climber and hobby blogger who got a bit too deep into the origin topic. An avid reader of Scott Alexander’s popular Astral Codex Ten blog, he came upon Saar Wilf in the comment section. Saar was arguing that while most conspiracy theories are false, the lab leak idea proves that they should still be taken seriously. The two started a conversation, which after some back and forth eventually resulted in Peter wanting to set up a rootclaim debate.</p><p>“If at any point I thought the process was rigged, I would have pulled out”, he told me yesterday in an interview. He liked Saar Wilf, because the Israeli investor had also set up a Rootclaim bet against notorious anti-vaccine lunatic Steve Kirsch and Peter “really, really” wanted this debate to happen before.</p><p>For months, they have rested in a sort of limbo about whether to debate the origin topic or Steve Kirsch first, with Peter even offering Saar help against Kirsch and the two of them building a friendly rapport. As Kirsch kept running away, Peter eventually wanted to get his own debate started; so they tried to find judges by just writing some famous people, including Scott Alexander. Most of them did not want to invest the time; but eventually, by looking through the “rationalist” community, Peter and Saar found a shortlist of people to interview who would serve as independent judges to the debate (with a small compensation for their efforts).</p><p>The debate could begin, and Peter — who was already well read in the topic — spend pretty much every waking moment over the next two months trying to sharpen his arguments and systematically assess all possible lab leak claims he could find. “If I had found anything that would have made me go like: Uh, this is compelling, or puts the odds of lab leak higher, I would have pulled out at this stage”, he told me.</p><p>However: “After looking deeper behind hundreds of lab leak arguments, kinda the opposite happened, I became more convinced to go forward with the debate”</p><p>That does not mean that he was comfortable at all.</p><blockquote>“I have never done a debate in my life. I was super nervous. The night before the first debate, I only slept one hour” —<em> Peter Miller (private communication)</em></blockquote><h3>The 18-hour video debate</h3><p>The Rootclaim debate was structured over 3 days with 3 thematic blocks;</p><ul><li>the first block was about the geographic location and the evidence for the Huanan market versus the Wuhan Institute of virology being where the virus came from</li><li>the second block was about the SARS-CoV-2 genome and whether its genetic features more likely arose in nature versus gain-of-function research</li><li>the third block was about probability; how can the evidence be grouped and what probabilistic assumptions should be taken to accurate reflect odds of the evidence occurring</li></ul><p>Each side first got 90 minutes to lay out their cases, then another 90 minutes together to respond to questions. No matter how you slice it, this is a serious effort and time investment, as the preparation alone of materials and research into it probably consumed hundreds of hours from speakers and judges alike.</p><p>The assumptions for this large timeframe are simple: Both parties get to present the best version or case for their hypothesis and explain in minute detail how they have come to their conclusions. The judges get to hear all the arguments, see all the materials, and then will use the <strong>probabilistic framework of the Rootclaim method to calculate the odds of zoonotic spillover versus a gain-of-function lab leak.</strong></p><p>Saar spend considerable time to guide the judges through a set of real or supposed oddities, coincidences, anomalies or facts that seem counterintuitive for a “natural” pandemic; elaborating on classics such as: Wuhan is a very unlikely place for the pandemic to have started, the Chinese response of obfuscation is very likely if one assumes a lab leak, the odds of SARS-CoV-2 to include furin cleavage site that other bat sarbecoviruses do not have is minimal at best, and so on. All backed up with his probability estimates. On top of that, he had an interesting habit we will look later at again, which is to <strong>find “probabilistic” reasons to discard informative evidence as irrelevant</strong>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*HnCWApQd2pv9CFYqz5bH1w.png" /><figcaption>Saar Wilf using his “probabilistic reasoning” to say ALL the data pointing towards the Huanan Seafood Market can be ignored because he believes the first patients being noticed there might have had another reason.</figcaption></figure><p>Saar was very confident at the end of the third day. According to his final statement, given all odd circumstances he laid out, a zoonotic origin would be just too hard to explain probabilistically. Whereas:</p><blockquote>“For the lab leak to be correct, all you need to assume is that people are people. They did bad modeling, they manipulated data, they made mistakes in their codes. […] That is guaranteed to happen given the politics” —<em> Saar Wilf</em></blockquote><p>So basically, this was Saar’s approach: Look at all the weird coincidences but do not trust the science nor the scientists. All available evidence for a zoonotic origin is a mirage, a mistake, or a manipulation and can thus be discarded. All you really need is your intuition about priors and some grandiose probabilistic inference to calculate the odds together. That’s the Rootclaim method.</p><p>In contrast, <strong>Peter Miller took quite a different approach, painstakingly doing high quality science communication to explain the key findings of published scientific papers</strong> on the topic and putting them in the context of the larger question.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ix8lHTg6v-nkE4vPfKhkhw.png" /><figcaption>Peter Miller explaining phylogenetic evidence for two lineages, and how they relate to a market origin.</figcaption></figure><p>Peter also humbly shows limitations of the data and offers his own analysis in areas that are somewhat unclear and need contextualization; one particular example coming to mind was when he created his own “conspiracy theory about HCoV-HKU1”, where <strong>he highlighted how easy it is to cherry-pick “suspicious” genomic oddities even from a natural virus</strong> to fabricate a theory about how its features look man-made. An illustrative counterfactual.</p><p>For his last statement, he really wanted judges to focus on the difference between a scientific theory supported by evidence, and an amalgamation of mutually incompatible speculations and allegations:</p><blockquote>“I think it is important that the judges cut through the noise here. The lab leak side can’t stick to their argument, even during this debate. […] They retreat to a tabloid story, believing it is a 100% true, while thinking the WHO mission report is a 100% false.” — <em>Peter Miller</em></blockquote><p>→ You can find<a href="https://www.youtube.com/@tgof137/videos"> the whole debate split into 9 videos on Peter Miller’s youtube channel</a>.</p><p>So, after all this time and effort, who would the judges find offered the better argument? A maverick investor, multi-millionaire gambler and devisor of the very debate format judgement will be placed in? Or a scientifically literate software engineer who spend his efforts in explaining scientific results?</p><h3>The debate conclusion</h3><p>As mentioned earlier, both debaters were involved in finding judges, they created a short list and invited them for an interview before converging together on two. Both judges were independent junior academics with no bias in the topic, and a willingness to sit through hours of the debate. Both were ask to evaluate probabilities based on Rootclaim’s format and methodologies, and both wrote very long summary statements explaining their decision. Here are their conclusions:</p><p>The PhD molecular biologist Will van Treuren:</p><blockquote>“I viewed this debate as a truth-seeking exercise with my vote reflecting what I found to be the most plausible origin of SARS-CoV-2 […] I concluded that there is approximately a 1 in 300 chance that SARS-CoV-2 was the result of a lab leak.”</blockquote><blockquote><em>— </em><a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YlxTztAkdGQ"><em>Judge Will van Treuren</em></a></blockquote><p>and the applied mathematician and Earth Science PhD Eric Stansifer:</p><blockquote>“The resolution of the debate was relatively simple. […] On the basis of the evidence and arguments presented during the debate, I find with high confidence that zoonotic spillover is the more likely origin of sars-cov-2. The most important basis for this decision is the relative epidemiological proximity of the earliest indicators of covid to a plausible animal source rather than a potential laboratory source.”</blockquote><blockquote>— <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OKwunTJ1b40">Judge Eric Stansifer</a></blockquote><p>Using Rootclaim’s calculation method, Eric even came to a number as low as 0.07%, so odds of 1 in 1300 that this was a lab leak; albeit he as mathematician was not too happy with their method of calculation. His full final statement is 70 pages, while judge Will offered around 30 pages of explanation how they reached their conclusions.</p><p>Overall, both judges went deep into the detail and assessed the presented evidence as objectively as possible and independent of each other. Both ended up not only agreeing on what origin hypothesis is more likely, they both put the odds of a gain-of-function lab leak scenario well below 1%.</p><p>I have to say, for the laymen involved, I was pleasantly surprised that although they did not get every scientific nuance completely correct, they reached a conclusion that is consistent with more expert assessment on the issue as well. (<em>Note: the actual odds of SARS-CoV-2 being a gain-of-function construct are of course way less likely still</em>)</p><p>Either way, Saar Wilf’s original estimation of a GoF lab escape being around 89% certain was deemed far off and false, ergo he lost the debate and Peter Miller is the rightful winner of Saar’s 100.000$ stake money.</p><p>So all is legit! Why have we not heard about it?</p><h3>The telling aftermath</h3><p>In the alternate “sense-making” sphere of the internet, betting markets are considered a source for truth often better than ordinary expert assessments. Maybe because Saar is a poker player, some people in that community have made a bet on the outcome of the debate, and giving <a href="https://manifold.markets/chrisjbillington/will-bsp9000-win-the-rootclaim-chal">lableak the better odds for months and months</a> in the lead up.</p><p>But after the debate finished, a sudden quietness started surrounding the debate. The winner announcement was suspiciously delayed. The betting odds for a zoonotic win kept rising sharply. All while the judges and Peter Miller were awfully quiet, having signed NDAs that Saar seemed to be suddenly enforcing. Many on the betting website took this as a cue that something went wrong; maybe the judges did decide against Saar? But why not come out straight and announce the results?</p><p>“He used the time to work the refs” — Peter Miller told me in an interview. According to him, Saar had been shocked that he had lost the debate, and spend a long time trying to change their assessment. He “calm and politely” <em>(see article update: March 4 below) </em>demanded they correct their analysis because they allegedly made so many mistakes. The judges however had integrity and would not alter their assessment. Saar then immediately wanted to re-challenge Peter and have another debate; or that both parties write a rebuttal to the judges assessment. But the judges said that no matter what, they will not be swayed. For weeks and weeks, an increasingly desperate Saar tried to shift the result or neutralize the outcome. Since early on, he offered to pay Peter the 100.000$ for winning the debate, both parties agree that there was never a question whether Peter would get his money (<em>see article update: March 4 below).</em> But Saar still needed the judges to change their assessment for posteriority.</p><p>Was he just a sore loser, or is something else going on?</p><p>For me, it seemed pretty clear that Saar did not care about losing 100.000$ on a bad call, he is a poker player, after all. But the loss had confronted him with two bad choices:</p><ul><li>either he had to let go of the belief that his baby — the Rootclaim format — is actually the best method to assess truth of controversial topics</li><li>or he had to let go of his belief that the gain-of-function lab leak theory is true, given the result of the debate in his own superior format</li></ul><p>Both of these outcomes were much more unacceptable to him than losing money, because they are deeply personal, part of his identity. He was in a conundrum and for weeks of trying to play the refs behind the scenes to save them. The NDA agreement gave him extra time to spin his public defeat as something other than a loss, but eventually it ran out and the announcement of the winner was inevitable.</p><p><strong>Here is the excuse that Saar came up with:</strong></p><blockquote>We believe two things tilted the debate in favor of our opponent and we will correct them in future debates: First, the debate structure provided a major advantage to the debater with more memorized knowledge of the issue. The debate was live (via video) and Miller exemplified extensive knowledge and superb memory for many details, which we could not compete with.</blockquote><blockquote>Future debates will be held in an offline text format.</blockquote><blockquote>The second issue was that we failed to incorporate a process of ongoing feedback from the judges, spending most of our time on issues that had little impact on their final decision. In their ruling, we found major mistakes in their understanding of our analysis, which could have been easily corrected had we built the debate with more direct ongoing feedback from the judges. — <em>Saar Wilf</em></blockquote><p>So basically, Peter just won because he memorized details that swayed the judges, who did not really understand Saar’s probabilistic analysis. Uh-huh.</p><p>Anything else?</p><blockquote>Unfortunately, the result of our steelmanning was that when our hypothesis’ explanation was favored, the effect on the final likelihood was much smaller than when Miller’s was. When the judges did not have the tools to conclude between the sides, their result was some average of the two, which of course, given the extreme, strawmanned numbers offered by Peter, favored zoonosis. — <em>Saar Wilf</em></blockquote><p>Oh, Saar was just “too fair” steelmanning zoonosis, while mean Peter was just strawmanning numbers to mess up the probabilistic inference in favor of zoonosis. Of course.</p><blockquote>“<a href="https://www.rootclaim.com/rootclaim-challenge">Rootclaim’s $100,000 challenge is still open to anyone</a>, including on the COVID-19 origins issue, as we’re still standing behind our analysis and willing to put our money where our mouth is” — <em>Saar Wilf</em></blockquote><p>Now Saar Wilf is of course not a very gracious loser, blaming everybody else but his poor arguments and lack of technical knowledge on the science.<strong> In best lab leak truther fashion, he uses the announcement to double down, issuing another 100.000$ for anybody willing to challenge him again</strong>, this time with a different debate format (<em>that he believes will favor his outcome next time</em>). Somehow magically, his odds of a lab leak have also increased to 99.8% as well, which is beyond ridiculous.</p><p>A hopeless case, if you ask me.</p><p>Before we move on, there is one last thing that Saar Wilf brought up in his justification barrage on Twitter that is worth mentioning, giving us a clue where it all went wrong for him.</p><p>Because he lacks technical knowledge and can not assess technical claims made by scientists as well as lab leak advocates, he developed this idea of “cancelling” out evidence with “counter-evidence”.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/719/1*OStJbQznH-m-1JFDP3kezw.png" /><figcaption>Rootclaim (Saar Wilf) believes that scientific evidence can be “canceled” out with “counter-evidence”; meaning that because the Huanan market evidence leans zoonosis, he can take the FCS evidence (which leans lab leak for him) and just “cancel” them out against each other so they would not influence his probabilistic inference calculation. Absurd.</figcaption></figure><p>Now you know me, this type of arguments is not something I could let slide easily.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/705/1*D0gFxgtv28lchfex7J6kgA.png" /><figcaption>The idea that published scientific evidence can be “canceled” out probabilistically by taking any baseless argument from the lab leak side off the table is just bizzare. It is absurd and tortured reasoning that really highlight a profound lack of scientific literacy. A scientific theory has to account for ALL available evidence, and is rejected even if one piece of hard evidence disproves it.</figcaption></figure><p>I guess these examples are quite illuminating to understand why Saar failed to convince the judges. “Saar seems to believe that scientists are fundamentally corrupt”, Peter Miller offered his impression.</p><p>As a result, Saar Wilf never bothered to understand why the scientists believed a zoonotic origin more likely; never bothered to understand the pesky scientific details on the topic, and never bothered to understand how the scientific method actually produces knowledge. His opponent, Peter Miller, however did.</p><blockquote>Scientific literacy is a superpower, putting those who lack it at a dramatic disadvantage.</blockquote><p><strong>Just to hammer home this point, here is a little insider anecdote from my side:</strong></p><p>Months before the debate happened, Peter Miller reached out to me to ask whether I might be up for assisting him. I strongly advised against taking the debate, but said that I will try to pitch in if needed. Peter was nervous that Saar will have deep technical arguments that he as a software engineer might not be able to address scientifically. Yet when he got the Saar’s arguments in advance of the debate in September, he contacted me again with a very telling email:</p><blockquote>“Not sure I’m gonna need any help with this, their arguments are bad…” — <em>Peter Miller (private correspondence)</em></blockquote><p>I found this little exchange illuminating and hopeful. If a smart laymen could reach such an understanding of the origin debate by simply immersing himself in the scientific literature as to make him feel confident enough to address all the weird, confused and irrelevant arguments commonly thrown up lableak advocates, there is hope for our shared public discourse. So what is stopping journalists, influencers and other amplifiers doing the same thing as Peter on this issue?</p><p>After familiarizing himself with the scientific research, Peter was so confident in fact that he could not be talked out of waging 100.000$ of his own money on winning a dodgy debate (<em>and believe me, I tried</em>). Guess he is not exactly risk averse.</p><blockquote>“The real bet that Peter Miller took was that Saar Wilf is a lableak truther”</blockquote><p>…a scientist involved in origin research who rather not be named here told me. I liked this comment because I think it is correct. When somebody is as captured by a false belief as Saar Wilf, they unfortunately become <strong>an easy mark for bad actors</strong> and <strong>bad reasoning</strong> that poisons their understanding of reality. Saar showed this by inviting the conspiracy theorist and well-known DRASTIC member Yuri Deigin to argue his case for the second debate about genetics. Yuri and I have of course a bit of a history, with me getting tired of his amateurish BS and motivated cherry-picking; so of course he gets an honorary mention.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/742/1*WJhk2oSPpvPGzwljjk0bag.png" /><figcaption>DRASTIC member Yuri Deigin — often hailed one of the more serious lab leak proponents — took over the second part of the debate for Saar Wilf. He did not fare better than the Israeli investor captured by a false belief.</figcaption></figure><p>Peter Miller took advantage of Saar Wilf’s lack of scientific literacy and reliance on charlatans like Yuri on the topic.</p><blockquote>“Conspiracy theories can be monetized, their debunking usually not. I saw the debate as a possible unique opportunity that rewards debunking” — Peter Miller (private communication)</blockquote><p>In any forum that allows for evidence-based discourse with independent judges, Saar never stood a chance arguing against a scientific consensus with his broken epistemology driving his own motivated reasoning.</p><p>The interesting part is that with Rootclaim, Saar Wilf had created a debate format that actually did encourage evidence-based discourse, rather than exchanging rhetorical tricks and pre-tested talking points. If he could have overcome his lose with grace, he could have doubled down on Rootclaim itself as being a good thing and expand it to host future public debates in this format. That would have been the move to save face and turn a loss into a learning experience for growth.</p><p>However, the sad reality is that Saar Wilf can not even acknowledge where he went wrong. He rather saw fault in the “superior memorization and detail knowledge” of Peter Miller, as well as the “judges focusing on the wrong facts” and he himself being “too fair to zoonosis probabilities” than his own biased reasoning. Hopefully, he will eventually overcome his false belief that made the successful businessman and poker player become an obsessed lab leak fool.</p><h3>The quick takeaway</h3><p>For all of us, Saar Wilf serves as a cautionary tale about the emotional power the false lab leak myth holds over people, twisting their perception of reality and ability to make sense of it; without them being aware of its hidden pull.</p><p>Peter Miller delivered a fantastic science communication experience in the debate that he can be more than proud of. Maybe he even changed some minds before the whole ordeal will vanish into the annuls of internet history. All credit to him.</p><p>And yet, despite his valiant efforts, overwhelming win of evidence-based reasoning and a very lucrative payout, I would still advise everybody against taking lableak truthers up for debate. Here is why:</p><h3>A worrying counterfactual</h3><p>Let us imagine for a second what would have happened if Peter Miller actually lost the debate (for whatever reason), or the judges were swayed by Saar`s relentless efforts after.</p><p>The lab leak myth has already started multiple information cascades based on nothing but rumors and willing amplifiers; from entirely made up allegations of patients zero, to alleged whistleblowers at the WIV being thrown of roofs; to faulty insinuations about Chinese scientists deleting critical data, to secret Chinese party speak that only a western maverick could decipher… on and on it goes. It really does not take much for these narrativesto go viral. What all of these stories have in common is usually a sensationalist headline, a rehashing of common lab leak talking points, and the aspect of “novelty”; a new twist in the genre.</p><p>Having an “Israeli multi-millionaire maverick win a 100.000$ debate by defeating a zoonotic origin proponent” would deliver just enough substance and salacious headline to really cascade well to the top of the attention economy on social media.</p><p>Conspiracy theorists dominate discourse on social media because there is an “asymmetry of passion” they exhibit on the emotional myths they care about. If Saar won, they would be relentless in their activism to push the debate to larger and larger audiences; and because many people will talk about it, journalists, influencers and other amplifiers will feel a need to cover it as well. All of them will feel enticed to come up with their own spin and hot takes on the event; hailing the debate as an important step forward in public discourse, or chastising scientists for dodging debates, or how Saar Wilf has put his money where his mouth is an won against the “flimsy” arguments of science. I could see a million ways how this debate could and would have been weaponized if Saar Wilf had indeed been declared the winner.</p><p>The reality is that most citizens will ever watch the 18hours, nobody will care whether Peter Miller presented a good or bad argument, whether the judges were reasonable or unreasonable in their assessment; whether Saar Wilf played the refs or rigged the debate. All that matters is how amplifiers would react to it, and most citizens would take their clues from them. Superficial clues like: After 18h of debate, “lab leak” won and science lost.</p><p>A great headline for anti-science activists, propagandists, politicians and other information combatants alike who want to sow doubt and distrust about science and scientists. The opposite is however not true. No amplifier will hail the debate outcome as proof of zoonosis, no journalist or influencer will cue up and watch 18 hours of debate to make some hot takes about it, because there is no audience demand for it. We want to hear about a maverick proving the scientists wrong; to confirm our own suspicious. Nobody wants to deal with the reality that they might have been misled and the pesky experts were right all along. This just doesn’t sell in the attention economy.</p><p>That is why I advised Peter Miller against the debate; lots to lose but almost nothing to gain for the public understanding of science.</p><blockquote>Peter Miller took a big risk with very little gain for science.</blockquote><p>In his very last statement, he acknowledges that he has created an asymmetrical pay-off. He decided to go forward anyways.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*C7fwXyetOxuaBIzc21gRGg.png" /><figcaption>Peter Miller acknowledging that if he wins, few will change their minds, and virtually nobody will hear about the debate, and public discourse will remain unaltered. If he loses however, there would be an outsized impact on the public discourse, with activists using his loss for information warfare.</figcaption></figure><p>In our interview, Peter told me he is a mountain climber where sometimes there is a 5% chance to die, and the stakes are just not that high for a debate. He is an optimist and believe it can have an impact, despite the odds.</p><p>I believe he was reckless, and yet I am reluctant to blame him for taking the risk. Science has already largely lost the public discourse surrounding the origins of COVID since 2021, with most citizens being successfully misled by a mixture of influencers, activists, information combatants and our own human biases.</p><blockquote>Taking a risk in science communication, even throwing a Hail Mary in a 100.000$ debate to wake citizens up is something I deeply sympathize with.</blockquote><p>It is not Peter Miller’s fault that our information environment is so broken that anti-scientific falsehoods and activism flourish, nor that the stakes for communication errors are made so high that it effectively silences scientists or bullies them out of public conversation.</p><p><strong>To truly change public discourse for the better, we have to change the incentives and asymmetries in our shared information spaces.</strong></p><p>Until then, maybe it is up to all of us to be a bit more like Peter; to do the legwork to deeply understand a scientific topic and then be not afraid to stand up for science in its dire hour of need, however that might look for you personally. He was just being courageous, defending science and an evidence-based discourse the best way he knew how, and doing so by putting the money where his mouth was.</p><p>I hope courageousness is infectious.</p><p>Please consider sharing his win.</p><h4>Article update March 3rd 2024:</h4><p>As expected, Saar Wilf was not happy with this article about the Rootclaim debate, trying to get Peter Miller to influence my writing by giving him a long list of his objections and contestations.</p><p>Some minor nitpicks about him not being “angry” when demanding the judges change their assessment, but he was “calm and polite” doing so. Since I can not infer state of mind, I will correct this.</p><p>The main thrust of his objections was about how he did not “try to work the refs” by exerting influence on the judges in the aftermath, and that the two months delay of winner announcement was supposedly up to the judges, not him running interference. He also contested that the judges never said they would not change their assessment, that I’d better clarify that “<em>there is no integrity involved here</em>”, that he merely “a<em>sked them politely if they would be interested in working together to improve their verdicts</em>” and that they “<em>had some discussions about this but could not conclude in time, but might still do so in the future</em>”. <strong>All of Saar’s objections here are however contested by other parties to say the least.</strong> And what better way to rebut my characterization of his backhanded actions then to “try to work Peter Miller” to demand of me to change my assessment in the article, right? :)</p><p><strong>Seriously Saar, you will have to deal with the fact that reality does not always conform to what you want to believe it to be. Neither do people.</strong></p><p>I understand this can be frustrating, but see it as an opportunity to align your beliefs with reality, rather than double down on a losing proposition and challenging everyone who has not bought into your version of the world.</p><p>I wish for your success with this format on debating anti-vaxxers, where <em>— spoiler alert — </em>you are actually aligned with the scientific reality, and a swift recovery from the false myths that hold you down.</p><h4><strong>Further information</strong></h4><p>Peter Miller’s debate videos can be found here:</p><p>Part 1: <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y1vaooTKHCM">Evidence for Huanan market</a></p><p>Part 2: <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FLnXVflOjMo">Genetic evidence for natural virus</a></p><p>Part 3: <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6sOcdexHKnk">Probabilistic assessment of evidence</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=0c3930ccd443" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Disparage, disorient, dispute]]></title>
            <link>https://protagonist-science.medium.com/disparage-disorient-dispute-ff494e7f3ec4?source=rss-c8e0e038559d------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ff494e7f3ec4</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[long-reads]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[manipulation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[science-communication]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[science-denial]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[disinformation]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Philipp Markolin]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 17 Nov 2023 17:16:49 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-11-17T17:16:49.373Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>The manipulation playbook of anti-science actors, part 3</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/855/1*akJunzD93WLxzqZ35nWbKw.jpeg" /></figure><h4>Background</h4><p>Confusion is a natural part of life arising from error-prone communication, conflicting information, or unexpected observations. When confused, we often misinterpret information or situations in a way that conforms to our prior expectations, knowledge, and biases. The latter is what makes confusion interesting for anti-science actors as a tool of information warfare.</p><p>Media manipulators — a mix of influencers, media owners, politicians, activists, grifters, entertainers, marketing departments, shadowy businesses, and clandestine actors — sow confusion in order to create space for unsubstantiated worldviews we might already be inclined to hold. Beliefs that are ultimately either unjustified given the current evidence, or directly contradicted by scientific knowledge.</p><p>They might give us strawmen we can utilize in our own motivated reasoning, or lull us in comfort that our in-group or the silent majority believes the same thing as we do. They might use information asymmetries to obfuscate the state of evidence, or take our minds on a slippery slope to scare us into rejecting action or change. They want to dull our senses to ignore contradictions, plead for exceptions and rewrite histories with causes that never were, all to justify the status quo.</p><p>Confusion is powerful because it breeds paralysis for our agency and sabotages collective action for the public good. Additionally, confusion instills us with anxiety, frustration, and anger; these are activating emotions that can be targeted and channeled toward radicalization.</p><blockquote>In the battlespace of information, we are civilians in harm’s way.</blockquote><p>The most cynical or dishonest media manipulators might sow confusion for express political ends. Unfortunately, there is no rescue in sight for most civilians globally. For people outside of the European Union’s protection, there is little hope that governments will intervene and implement regulations to safeguard their human rights online.</p><p>But even within the EU today, if we are not careful with whom we trust, our attention, money, and ultimately agency are up for grabs for the next influential charlatan who comes ambling along.</p><p><strong>Understanding what tactics they are most likely to use is the least we can do to start working on a defense strategy.</strong></p><p>Well, at this point, you know the drill. Downloadable high-resolution versions are at the end of the article. Previous manipulation tactics can be found here: <a href="https://protagonistfuture.substack.com/p/denounce-deny-deceive">The playbook of anti-science actors — part 1</a> , <a href="https://protagonistfuture.substack.com/p/distort-discredit-dismiss">The playbook of anti-science actors — part 2</a></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ryPlFOARTYjczKT6QgkB4w.jpeg" /></figure><p>Let’s get started.</p><h3><strong>The new archetypes:</strong></h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*a1h8dU5TAzFHZVfZRE3Evw.png" /><figcaption>Disparage, disorient, dispute. The playbook of anti-science actors, part 3</figcaption></figure><h3><strong>The one-sided Litigators</strong></h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/402/1*DtSgTMzNs1cc4aBt_1R61g.png" /></figure><h4><strong>How they work:</strong></h4><p>Information asymmetries — when one party knows more than the other — pose a risk for opportunism in business, management, and human relationships (<a href="https://www.researchgate.net/publication/327804777_Information_Asymmetry_in_Management_Research_Past_Accomplishments_and_Future_Opportunities">Bergh D., 2018</a>), especially when individuals with low ability or knowledge overestimate their own competence in a topic (<a href="https://psycnet.apa.org/record/1999-15054-002">Dunning &amp; Kruger, 1999</a>).</p><p>Media manipulators can <strong>hijack information asymmetries in science</strong> by providing only one-sided facts and narratives in support of false claims or hypotheses. As seasoned litigators, manipulators take advantage of our ignorance of details to craft seemingly compelling cases for alternative theories or poke holes into established theories. This works because we tend to rely on a <a href="https://www.verywellmind.com/availability-heuristic-2794824">cognitive bias known as the <strong>availability heuristic</strong></a> to evaluate merit of a claim (<a href="https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/0010028573900339">Tversky &amp; Kahneman, 1973</a>). If we have no expert knowledge available, we are more inclined to believe the narratives on offer.</p><p>A related asymmetric information strategy is to pronounce the (supposed)<strong> absence</strong> <strong>of any counter-evidence as evidence for a claim</strong>, which might mislead individuals to accept prima facie implausible claims or not reject them to preserve cognitive consistency (<a href="https://psycnet.apa.org/fulltext/2024-16890-004.html">Vu L., et al., 2023</a>)</p><blockquote>“What can be asserted without evidence can also be discarded without evidence” <em>— Hitchens’ razor (named after Christopher Hitchens)</em></blockquote><h4>Case study: Taking uninformed watchers on a hero’s journey</h4><p>John Stossel is a former award-winning television presenter for ABC and later Fox News who has been in the media game for more than four decades. As a libertarian ideologue, author, political activist, and pundit, his content focuses on conservative classics such as free market absolutism, big government criticism, and opinionated essays of why an inconvenient scientific consensus on things like smoking or climate change is actually wrong. The latter I am sure has nothing to do with his countless affiliations to climate denial networks, funders, think tanks, and Koch-money-sponsored NGOs pretending to be academic institutes.</p><p>The seasoned media personality has been criticized over the years for his lack of balance of coverage and <a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20071010060957/http://www.fair.org/index.php?page=19">distortion of facts on his part by organizations such as FAIR </a>and media matters. His shtick would include the superficial veneer and mannerisms of an investigative journalist. Interviewing supposed expert sources, quoting media reporting of established outlets, asking seemingly tough questions, and sprinkling in enough truthful bits to be hard to discard while ignoring inconvenient facts or context. The overarching conclusions would however always fall in a very one-sided direction.</p><p>Since 2019, he realized that there is a much larger market for his learned journalistic make-belief skills by creating Stossel TV, a media-of-one outlet that posts videos on YouTube, his own website, and social media like Facebook and Twitter. Let’s just say the quality of his one-sided reporting has not increased since. But he got even more successful.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*HVAyzoayPMPOOHKu1YjD_Q.png" /><figcaption>Snapshot of most recent “Jossel TV” videos</figcaption></figure><blockquote>“Stossel carefully crafts narratives that directly oppose nearly everything we know to be true […] you might think twice about blindly believing the figureheads on your screen”</blockquote><p>… a recent <a href="https://www.greenpeace.org/usa/john-stossels-transformation-from-skeptical-libertarian-to-polluter-apologist/">article about Stossel’s modus operandi</a> would claim. But how exactly does he achieve this?</p><p><strong>Most of Stossel’s videos follow the same 3-act script:</strong></p><ul><li><strong>Act 1:</strong> They start with a question or statement about a commonly held fact or belief that Stossel will then look “deeper” into in his five-minute YouTube clips. Often, he pretends to bolster the initial claim by highlighting clips and media reporting supportive of it. <strong>He frames it as the “status quo”</strong>.</li><li><strong>Act 2:</strong> He gives voice to a supposed expert or interviewee who disagrees with the “mainstream” perception, a stark contrast. Why would they come to a different conclusion, did we not just hear what the facts are? He then pretends to challenge the contrarian, giving him enough space to introduce decontextualization, motivated reasoning, or other misleading talking points. Then Stossel takes over judgment, highlighting cherry-picked facts or reporting that seems to support the contrarian; ultimately coming to an agreement with him. A nice little “journey” for low-information watchers to follow; a <strong>facsimile of an educational moment</strong>, but distorted for persuasion.</li><li><strong>Act 3: </strong>In his conclusory remarks, he or his interviewees re-iterate what we now “learned” by looking deeper. This reinforces the new narrative and prepares watchers for a final <strong>“call to action”</strong> that usually is in service of Stossel’s ideological position.</li></ul><p>If this 3-act structure sounds roughly familiar, this is because it is structured to bring watchers along a powerful story trope called the “<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hero%27s_journey">hero’s journey</a>”. Stossel’s watchers get taken away from the “status quo” and are brought on an adventure where they meet new companions, challenges, and struggles, to then finally return changed or wiser.</p><p>Who does not like to feel they learned something precious, coming home — after watching a clip — feeling a bit like a hero? This type of content and trope is as ubiquitous as it is persuasive, and we fall quite easily for it on any topic we know much too little about or overestimate our competence.</p><blockquote>Information asymmetries always exist because nobody can have detailed knowledge about everything. But unless we recognize them for what they are and put our guard up, we will be an easy mark.</blockquote><p>A very recent example of such a “Stossel” special journey just went online on a new GOP classic, which is the false myth that COVID-19 was created in a Wuhan lab with the help of “US government” funding.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*z_5eusw0TD21nfRNEWH-Qg.png" /><figcaption>Manipulation works best when true facts can be decontextualized and woven into a compelling narrative</figcaption></figure><blockquote>In the video, Stossel starts laying out the status quo, how US senator Rand Paul accused Fauci of funding the creation of the virus, and how the media all claimed it came from nature and lambasted Rand Paul. Then he sits down with Rand Paul for an interview and lets him air some talking points. Next up, some one-sided media snippets to suggest that we learned there is more to the story. Adding selective quotes from news about the FBI and DoE assessments, reports on how other viruses leaked from labs before, and some decontextualized clips of scientists. Taking advantage of his watchers’ ignorance about the details, he offers example after examples that seems to contradict what the mainstream told them in Act 1. Did they learn now by themselves that Rand Paul was right after all? He certainly judges that to be the case. In Act 3, he lets a magnanimous Rand Paul pontificate about how he does not want an apology, he just wants to prevent the next pandemic by not letting “government research” create these dangerous viruses. What a brave truthteller! Luckily, we who have been on a journey with him and have not been fooled by the “science and mainstream media”, can feel a bit like a hero too. Brilliant!</blockquote><p>And self-sealing.</p><blockquote>Science has lost at this point. Because all that the truth has left on offer for true believers is a bitter realization.</blockquote><blockquote>One where they are not really heroes, but rather have been conned by seasoned manipulators on a topic they knew too little about.</blockquote><p>I leave it to your imagination how receptive citizens are to hear that message, especially those already aggrieved with little to feel good about themselves. Most manipulation tactics hold their power on an emotional level, the shticks and spiels are just to provide enough cognitive distraction to get lured into these positions.</p><p>Talking about emotions, I heard fear can be quite useful too.</p><h3><strong>The Slippery Slope Scaremongers</strong></h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/400/1*u87cBCsPo1MsUDiPkBwukw.png" /></figure><h4><strong>How they work:</strong></h4><p>A slippery slope argument claims an initial event or action will trigger a series of other events and lead to an extreme or undesirable outcome. However, these arguments are often fallacious because they imply inevitability, causality, and necessity between individual steps. Slippery slope arguments appeal to a mixture of factors such as habituation processes, problems in drawing distinctions, and social pressures in the direction of a slippery slope. (<a href="https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/21516214/">Jefferson A., 2014</a>)</p><p>Media manipulators use slippery slope arguments to instill fear or other negative emotions in their audience by presenting (hypothetical) extreme consequences as if they were a certainty. (<a href="https://www.scribbr.com/fallacies/slippery-slope-fallacy/">Nikolopoulou K., 2023</a>) This is a form of fearmongering that plays on humans’ inherent aversion to loss, perceived threats or negative outcomes, sometimes at the expense of logical reasoning (<a href="https://psycnet.apa.org/record/2001-07168-011">Lerner &amp; Keltner, 2001</a>). Shared fears can also be abused to guide collective behaviors, socially reinforcing individual fears and beliefs about risks (<a href="https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1111/j.1539-6924.1988.tb01168.x">Kasperson et al., 1988</a>).</p><h4><strong>Case study: Fear-mongering about School-based Health Centers</strong></h4><p>Getting even basic healthcare is often tricky in the US. School-based health centers (SBHCs) are primary care clinics based on primary and secondary school campuses that would take care of the children’s physical and mental health. While the first SBHCs go back over a century, they have become more popular in the last 30 years because they come with some substantive benefits.</p><p>Their biggest impact is on the health and well-being of children with high unmet needs, such as uninsured students or healthcare access disparities among African American and disabled students (<a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2556719/">Wade TJ. et al., 2008</a> , <a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2920971/">Guo JJ. et al., 2010</a>). SBHC have also been linked to lower absences in school and positive academic outcome (<a href="https://publications.aap.org/pediatrics/article/121/5/1052/73463/Role-of-the-School-Nurse-in-Providing-School?autologincheck=redirected">Magalnick H. and Mazyck D., 2008</a>). There has been some controversy surrounding school-based clinics that provide reproductive health care in conservative states like Louisiana in the past (<a href="https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.1746-1561.1996.tb06277.x">Zeanah PD et al., 1996</a>). Yet overall, these centers had a very positive footprint on students and schools that implemented them and thus increased in popularity.</p><p>So all good and well, right?</p><p>Let’s say their recent success was not liked by everybody, because SBHCs have also been shown more effective than community centers such as hospitals at <strong>facilitating preventive health measures including vaccinations</strong> (<a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2920988/">Federico SL. et al., 2010</a>).</p><p>By now, you should know exactly where this is going:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*-pbuhgYHa5EXRptsUVXzMA.png" /><figcaption><strong>The radical anti-vaccine organization CHD uses a (fallacious) slippery slope argument to instill fear about health clinics in parents.</strong> They suggest that once they are implemented, they will be able to<strong> A)</strong> <strong>treat and diagnose the children in a variety of ways</strong> (arguably true). Then they<strong> B)</strong> <strong>will replace your pediatrician</strong> (argument does not follow from A, also false). Then they <strong>C) will replace the parents as decision makers</strong> (does not follow from A even if B were true). Then they <strong>D) can do whatever they want</strong> (does not follow from A even if B and C were true). Then <strong>E) there will be no options to protect parental rights</strong> (does not follow from A, B, C or D; but sure does sound scary, right?)</figcaption></figure><p>Let’s not give these despicable anti-vaccine pressure groups any more air than necessary. The point is that albeit slippery slope arguments are often fallacious, they can still be persuasive when coupled to a very strong emotional cue like fear.</p><blockquote>If parents worry about losing the right to protect their children, they will not question whether the long slippery slope argumentation line before them is very probably or sound; they will just reject the initial step immediately.</blockquote><p>I guess we all can emphasize. But that’s why it is so important to guard ourselves against emotional manipulation and maintain our analytical capabilities in arguments.</p><p>Talking about sound reasoning… there are ways for manipulators to abuse our sound reasoning as well, if only they manage to make us belief in false causal relationships…</p><h3><strong>The false-cause Fabricators</strong></h3><blockquote>Narrative tools often operate under the radar of conscious reflection, leaving us with the impression that we have a direct, unmediated picture of reality —Prof. James Wertsch</blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/392/1*sfypWam2jx1A5xL_lCD4Mg.png" /></figure><h4>How they work:</h4><p>Humans have an innate desire to understand causality. Our pattern-recognition ability evolved to help us understand and predict our environment, but it has a tendency to overfit data to patterns, and perceive connections between unrelated things (<a href="https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0010945208001391">Fyfe S. et al., 2008</a>, <a href="https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/ejsp.2331">van Prooijen, 2017</a>).</p><p>Media manipulators can abuse this predisposition to prompt us to falsely attribute relationships to events that correlate in time, also known as <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Post_hoc_ergo_propter_hoc">post hoc ergo propter hoc</a> fallacies.</p><p>A related version is the “Narrative Fallacy” (<a href="https://www.jstor.org/stable/23723297">Taleb, 2007</a>) where manipulators take advantage of our desire to shape scattered facts into coherent stories. Collective memories and shared narratives can amplify these false causalities, especially if they align with broader cultural stories or beliefs (<a href="https://academic.oup.com/book/39495$">Wertsch JV., 2021</a>, <a href="https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/memory-mind-and-media/article/hidden-power-of-implicit-collective-memory/57C05A703EF6EF7602E30F490845A377">Erll A., 2022</a>).</p><blockquote>The narrative fallacy addresses our limited ability to look at sequences of facts without weaving an explanation into them, or, equivalently, forcing a logical link, an arrow of relationship upon them. Explanations bind facts together. They make them all the more easily remembered; they help them make more sense. Where this propensity can go wrong is when it increases our impression of understanding <em>[but not our actual understanding]</em>.</blockquote><h4><strong>Case study: The ever-expanding miracle cure illusion</strong></h4><p>A core strength of medical practice is the trial-and-error strategy of initiating a treatment and assessing a patient’s response. However, this strategy is subject to <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Post_hoc_ergo_propter_hoc"><em>post-hoc ergo propter hoc</em> fallacies</a> because an observed change in the patient’s health is not necessarily caused by the medical treatment (<a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7573066/">Redelmeier and Ross, 2020</a>).</p><ul><li>The reason to fall into these fallacies are manifold, for example, the placebo effect can complicate the manner. The mere expectation of receiving help and treatment can lead to a positive perception of disease progression or severity while reducing patient suffering after any type of intervention. This does not mean the intervention was effective, to really do that, placebo-controlled studies have to be held.</li><li>On top of placebo, phenomena such as <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regression_toward_the_mean">regression toward the mean</a> can also create the illusion of causality. Patients are most likely to seek a doctor’s help at the peak of disease or discomfort, but no peak lasts very long (regression). So after a “peak” doctor’s visit, patients will automatically feel slightly better, no matter if the doctor gives a medication, placebo, or just a few encouraging words.</li></ul><p>All of the above factors (and many more such as doctor’s expectations, observer bias, and bad statistics) can initially make a drug seem falsely effective, that’s why multiple good studies (such as randomized control trials) are required to really establish whether a drug works or not. But experiencing improvement or having strong hopes can cloud our judgement for a long time.</p><blockquote>The history of medicine is full of people believing in false remedies to diseases, and subsequently self-serving manipulators abusing their hope, suffering or confusion.</blockquote><p>The <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Snake_oil">literal snake-oil salesmen in the 18th century were SELLING SNAKE OIL as a cure-all elixir</a>, a literal fake miracle cure, for gods sake. Today, within our broken information ecosystems, this type of business continues unabated to trick the unaware. False causality is easily attributed to whatever product they want to peddle, all manipulators need to do is add a bit of narrative flavor to the sales pitch. Anecdotes about how the “supposedly vaccine-injured see profound results”, or how the cure has “won the noble prize” (for it’s actual efficacy, which is parasite-killing, not miracle curing), or how “the pharma companies don’t want you to know about the miracle cure because it would harm their profits” and “hey it might also work against cancer and inflammatory diseases”. *eurgh*</p><p>You all know the spiel.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*r1Bldfu8bVg_OdVxIG1iyA.png" /></figure><p>Many media manipulators often gain a hefty income by selling supplements and other dodgy products they tout as miracle cures. Platforms and law makers need to introduce consumer protection mechanisms against these manipulative vultures who prey on the hope of patients.</p><p>But how do manipulators deal with scientific pushback when those cures get debunked experimentally? And why would people rather take some dodgy miracle cure against COVID when safe and effective vaccines are available?</p><p>Well, let’s check out the next tactic.</p><h3><strong>The Exclusionary Scotsmen</strong></h3><blockquote>“I do not have a problem with vaccines, just with the mRNA gene therapies” — <em>victims targeted by well-funded vaccine disinformation</em></blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/383/1*lJd1Wm8iwnOiVVxLIaW_Mg.png" /></figure><h4>How they work:</h4><p>When confronted with scientific information that contradicts our beliefs, we experience discomfort and cognitive dissonance (<a href="https://psycnet.apa.org/record/2012-15135-003">Harmon-Jones et al., 2009</a>). To resolve these contradictions, we often fall into special pleading (<a href="https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1002/9781119165811.ch46">Dim Y., 2018</a>) by setting different standards for different arguments to unjustly reject inconsistencies.</p><p>Media manipulators can foment special pleading with <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/No_true_Scotsman">appeals to purity</a>, identity or <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Self-licensing">moral credentialing</a> of their in-group. By claiming that “no true scientist” would ever act or speak in a dissenting way to their beliefs (<a href="https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/9781119165811.ch91">Manninen TW, 2018</a>), they aim to assert their group’s moral superiority (<a href="https://psycnet.apa.org/record/2001-07168-003">Monin &amp; Miller, 2001</a>) and give citizens license to disregard or devalue inconvenient counterexamples.</p><h4><strong>Level 1: Discrediting inconvenient evidence</strong></h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/559/1*1eT7w_wcF_YlZxsgqVnLNg.png" /><figcaption>Appeals to purity, such as the “no true Scotsman” fallacy can be used by anti-science actors to discard inconvenient scientific studies</figcaption></figure><h4><strong>Level 2: Discrediting an inconvenient scientist</strong></h4><p><em>“I offered to go on Joe Rogan but not to turn it into the Jerry Springer show with having RFK Jr. on” — </em>Dr. Peter Hotez</p><p><a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peter_Hotez">Dr. Peter Hotez is a vaccine scientist</a>, vaccine advocate and book author. He has developed a low-cost and effective COVID vaccine serving over a 100 million people; a model case for public health without the profiteering of big pharma companies. He also is the father of an autistic daughter and wrote a <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Vaccines-Did-Not-Cause-Rachels-Autism/dp/1421426609">very personal science book about the genetic determinants of autism</a>, debunking the maliciousness of claiming vaccines causing autism.</p><p>Obviously, everything he stands for puts a target on his back by anti-vaccine extremists, even decades before they gained new power with the politicization of the pandemic and our broken info systems. One of the most despicable manipulators, <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robert_F._Kennedy_Jr.">former lawyer and seasoned liar RFKjr.</a> has long <a href="https://www.facebook.com/resultswithmary/videos/10163288539190142">labeled Dr. Hotez as the “OG villain</a>”, marking him as target.</p><p>When the Joe Rogan Experience — a popular podcast regularly platforming a variety of anti-science contrarians, cranks, conspiracy theorists — gave a platform to RFKjr. and his anti-vaccine talking points, Dr. Hotez shared a <a href="https://www.vice.com/en/article/k7zz9z/spotify-rogan-rfk-vaccine-misinformation-policy">VICE article lamenting the blatant misinformation</a> being spread to millions.</p><p>His indirect criticism still prompted the entertainer to angrily challenge Hotez to a debate with RFKjr., to be moderated by Joe. Basically a public mud fight over a topic only one person is qualified to talk about. Unsurprisingly, Hotez disagreed at the prospect of inviting any false equivalency between him and the malicious RFKjr. Nevertheless, he offered Joe Rogan to come on the podcast to explain to him point by point why RFKjr.’s talking points were wrong.</p><p>Joe Rogan agreed and a nice and well-informed conversation ensued…</p><p>Of course not. Hotez polite refusal was immediately seized upon by Joe Rogan and many anti-science actors to attack and discredit him. With so much attention, even the <a href="https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1670219488485154816">spitefully foolish owner of X/Twitter</a> took it on himself to pile-on and stoke the toxic flames of harassment. The consequences were predictable:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*bzuOc1EZdINL0dgtc0A4rg.png" /><figcaption><strong>Vaccine scientists Dr. Hotez was subjected to a harassment campaign</strong> when he showed no interest in debating the anti-vaccine extremist RFKJr. on the Joe Rogan podcast. Media manipulators seized upon the opportunity to discredit the prominent vaccine advocate because being a “true scientist” apparently means that one must give platform and debate propagandists and anti-science cranks. On top of that, Elon Musk falsely claimed that Hotez must have been “afraid of a public debate, because he knows he is wrong”. Subsequently, millions of followers of the spectacle felt they had moral license to harass Dr. Hotez online, and even in front of his home.</figcaption></figure><p>Is this really the way we should treat public health scientists that work tirelessly to help countless people for little money? Getting railroaded by “debate me bro” podcasters in service of shameless liars whose actions have caused incalculable harm? And is a podcast discussion even a debate, or rather cheap showmanship?</p><p>Scientific debates, even on the most controversial topics, constantly happen in science. But their format is scientific papers that make arguments based on data and analysis, not bravado and rhetoric. Scientific debate is slow, meticulous and a much less entertaining process than a podcast shouting match. But there is a good reason for this: Nobody can debunk all bad arguments and falsehoods of rhetorically media manipulators in a live debate. Studies after studies have shown that if you pair a domain expert with a manipulator in a debate format, false equivalency ensues and people will still end up misinformed about the topic at hand (<a href="https://psycnet.apa.org/doiLanding?doi=10.1016%2Fj.jarmac.2021.10.002"><em>Imundo &amp; Rapp, 2022</em></a><em>)</em>.</p><p>There just is nothing to debate between fact and fiction, and even if one could debunk the arguments on the fly, skilled debaters just keep moving the goal posts.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/815/1*aCITnWBckQzn6zp3s8pnDA.png" /><figcaption>Slide show from Dr. Hotez explaining how anti-vaccine activists have been moving the goalposts anytime scientific studies debunked their assertions.</figcaption></figure><p>The <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brandolini%27s_law">time and effort to debunk falsehoods is at least an order of magnitude higher than it takes to just make</a> them up.</p><p>And that is even before considering the “pleasantness” of having Joe Rogan and RFKjr twist your words into strawmen arguments to validate the beliefs of their tribal audiences.</p><p>Guess that brings us to the next tactic in the manipulator’s arsenal.</p><h3><strong>The strawmen architects</strong></h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/315/1*i-kGB6qEZEyCB4n3orAcjQ.png" /></figure><h4>How they work:</h4><p>We have an innate tendency to view members of out-groups as more similar to each other than members of in-groups (<a href="https://psycnet.apa.org/doiLanding?doi=10.1037%2F0022-3514.38.1.141">Quattrone &amp; Jones, 1980</a>, <a href="https://psycnet.apa.org/doiLanding?doi=10.1037%2F0022-3514.61.3.366">Judd et al., 1991</a>). We also judge probabilities through a representativeness heuristic by comparing an event to a prototype or stereotype that we already have in mind (<a href="https://www.cambridge.org/core/books/abs/heuristics-and-biases/like-goes-with-like-the-role-of-representativeness-in-erroneous-and-pseudoscientific-beliefs/BF28E4797AA05C125AB6F452D13D1CF0">Gilovits &amp; Savitsky, 2012</a>, <a href="https://www.sas.upenn.edu/~bhatiasu/Bhatia%202015%20CogSci%20PP.pdf">Balia S., 2015</a>)</p><p>Media manipulators play into these tendencies by treating the complex positions of out-group members as if they are monolithically simple and representative of a flawed or extreme stance. These oversimplified strawmen arguments are more easily processed (<a href="https://psycnet.apa.org/record/2011-26535-000">Kahneman, 2011</a>) and can be pompously debunked to persuade and reinforce “in-group” solidarity (<a href="https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/9781119011071.iemp0153">Harwood J., 2020</a>).</p><h4>Case study: Climate change action is just another word for genocide</h4><blockquote>“All of that reeks to me of and underhanded and brutal genocidal impulse” — <em>Jordan Peterson’s strawman about environmentalism</em></blockquote><p>Alex Epstein is a climate change denier, propagandist writer and messaging consultant for fossil companies. He recently published a book advocating for the expansion of fossil fuels and is now touring rightwing networks for promotion.</p><p>Logically, when such a seasoned climate denier and manipulator like Epstein comes together with pathological drama queen and galaxy-brain bullshitter Jordan Peterson, any tethering to reality goes out the window.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Zbagz038Bw2LmVyChEWqGQ.png" /><figcaption>The climate deniers Alex Epstein and Jordan Peterson came together to bombard their tribal audiences with terrible strawmen arguments. The goal is to smear and ridicule people who want to take any action against climate change (<a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QQnGipXrwu0">Debunking video source</a>, not linking the original garbage)</figcaption></figure><p>Among the many obvious and dated strawmen the two heat up for their tribal audience, one absurdly flawed line of thinking particularly seems to stand out:</p><blockquote>“Any action against fossil fuels is inextricably part of a genocidal de-population agenda.”</blockquote><p>Conspiratorial issues aside, this ridiculous characterization of their opponents position is of course not build on a single strawman argument, but a whole barn-fire full of them. Here is a rough outline:</p><ul><li>“The <em>climate catastrophe movement</em> has a total non-interest in the obvious biological productivity benefits”</li><li>“That is because environmentalists believe that any type of human impact on the planet is bad”</li><li>“Their metric is the purity of the planet, not human well-being”</li><li>“But if they believe all humans do to the planet is evil, then the solution is obvious: Better to have a hell lot fewer of us”</li><li>“They have this view on humanity as some kind of cancer. We are not yeast in a bloody Petri dish. The planet is not a Petri dish”</li><li>“Every single bit of that reeks to me of an underhanded and brutal genocidal impulse”</li></ul><p>Now most people realize that the two of them just talk total nonsense, arguing against figments of their own imagination. However, the goal of strawmen arguments is not to convince people for the cause. The aim is identity justification and tribal mobilization. Once believers are activated about the imminent danger of environmentalists and their supposed “anti-human” depopulation agenda… time to sell them stuff for supposed safety or comfort.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*zwRfoWmakwiHbSncrYDRcA.png" /><figcaption>Climate denialism content attracts tribal groups that are easy to target, and even easier to manipulate into buying products that support their world view.</figcaption></figure><p>Ultimately, strawman arguments just serve to keep citizens trapped in ideological, tribal or social groups, and leaders who use them usually have ways to profit of them, politically, financially or socially.</p><p>Talking about tribal identification, I wonder if there is another lever manipulators can pull to stir us towards their ends?</p><h3><strong>The Ad Populum Propagandists</strong></h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/308/1*FH6Q_la8gxvBP5MOXjOvMA.png" /></figure><h4>How they work:</h4><p>We often do things because many other people are doing them, regardless of our own beliefs or supportive evidence. This bandwagon effect (<a href="https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0148296322000972">Bindra S. et al, 2022</a>) is innate to social beings influenced by pressures and norms of groups, from wisdom of the crowd (<a href="https://psycnet.apa.org/record/2004-20179-000">Suroweicki, 2004</a>) to <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_proof">social proof</a> (<a href="https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/mar.4220010317">Cialdini, 1984</a>).</p><p>Media manipulators abuse our tendency to look to others by <strong>appealing to the popularity of an unsubstantiated position</strong> (<a href="https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/9781119165811.ch16">McCrew BW., 2018</a>) or taking advantage on the individual’s fear of being isolated or ostracized (<a href="https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S2352250X22000720">Williams KD et al., 2022</a>).</p><p>A related tactic is<strong> to invoke common practice or tradition</strong> to assert that a premise must be right because people have always believed or practiced it (<a href="https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/9781119165811.ch19">Michaud N., 2018</a>).</p><h4>Case study: The silent majority has spoken, evidence be damned</h4><p>A common trope of pundits and media manipulators is to use polling data to spin narratives, justify their beliefs, or advocate for political action.</p><p>Representative polling is often hard to come by, and many of those pollings should be taken with a grain of salt. Nevertheless, while polling has (and ought to have) some legitimacy for politics, what a majority of non-experts believe is entirely irrelevant to science.</p><ul><li>The validity of a scientific theory is based on evidence, plausibility, and coherence with existing knowledge (among other things), but not popular appeal. Nor can a dissenting popular opinion negate the broader scientific consensus on any well-established or emerging scientific topic of inquiry. Scientific reality is what does not go away even when people stop believing in it.</li></ul><p>Almost everybody agrees with this. And yet, we seem to forget when skilled media manipulators frame scientific questions as a political our tribal issue, to be decided by a popularity contest.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*3M28ARdgY8x8CsgQUSincA.png" /><figcaption>This line of argumentation is well known as the <a href="https://www.scribbr.com/fallacies/ad-populum-fallacy/">ad populum fallacy</a>.</figcaption></figure><p>What the “majority of Americans believe” has not only shifted over time, it also tends to fall on the wrong side of scientific knowledge when media manipulators are at work. No matter if in the past with Darwinian evolution and Climate change, or more contemporary with vaccines and SARS-CoV-2, popular sentiment can take wide swings independent of evidentiary basis. And while citizens are entitled to their opinion, I believe society can only prosper when decisions are made according to the best available science.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/752/1*rVbjkVyJJV4oPEplm2OiRg.png" /><figcaption>Virologist Dr. Angela Rasmussen — who has done research on the origin of COVID-19 and published multiple papers on the topic — is not impressed by polling numbers quoted as proof of a man-made origin.</figcaption></figure><p>In the information age that asymmetrically favors falsehoods over science, popularity has become a dangerous proxy for truth.</p><p>That brings us to a final concluding remark.</p><h3><strong>Concluding remarks</strong></h3><p>Something went awry in our information sphere, and not just during the pandemic.</p><p>We went from information scarcity to information abundance and ubiquity. We went from mostly being an information receiver to being a constant broadcaster of it. We went from careful curation and gatekeeping to free-for-all cage fights for our attention. Clickbait, memes, hacktivism, virtue-signaling, community raids, micro-targeted persuasion campaigns, crypto scammers, conspiracy myth entrepreneurs, synthetic media, bot networks, astroturfing, unrepentant information warfare. All these and more now happen — and often define — what most citizens get to see in their fragmented digital spaces.</p><blockquote>The merciless and bloody winner-takes-all fight for our attention has somehow transformed the traditional role of information in society: To inform and educate us.</blockquote><p>Media manipulators thrive in the battlespace of information. They do not share information to educate us. They tell us whatever we want to hear and what keeps us engaged, but not necessarily what we ought to know. Truth is often an obstacle to attention-grapping stories, but fictions can be tailored and optimized for their niche audiences. Many media manipulators selectively amplify information that furthers their ideological, strategic, or financial goals. Largely unaccountable, they share information in service of popularity, persuasion, profit, or power, not the public good.</p><blockquote>Media manipulators have set their sights on one of the last bastions of evidence-based reasoning in society: Science.</blockquote><p>Evidence, research, fact checks, debunking, and scientific literacy are a threat that undermines their business model, popularity, and power. Media literacy, scientific knowledge, and critical thinking are a type of immune defense that allows civilians to arm themselves against their manipulation.</p><blockquote>And believe me when I say: They rather not have you inoculated</blockquote><p>I chronicle and explain their tactics because I believe much of the doubt, ambiguity, and confusion surrounding scientific topics, institutions, and ultimately scientists today did not arise organically.</p><p>Instead, it was fostered by deep-pocketed anti-science networks and the collective actions of media manipulators online who rather have science take a backseat in public discourse and societal decision-making.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/813/1*BtPoShRP1vwiwjzFxkQJNw.png" /><figcaption>American trust in scientists is declining (<a href="https://www.pewresearch.org/science/2023/11/14/americans-trust-in-scientists-positive-views-of-science-continue-to-decline/?utm_content=buffer6b1c6&amp;utm_medium=social&amp;utm_source=twitter.com&amp;utm_campaign=buffer-pew">Figure source: Pew Research Center</a>)</figcaption></figure><p>The bitter reality is that currently, manipulators are winning the war for your attention, for your money, and ultimately for your agency.</p><p>Are you really going to let them get away with it?</p><p>I’d say the buck stops here, right now, with you.</p><p>Good luck.</p><p>To make our odds of success a bit higher, here are 5 templates in high resolution to equip you to fend off manipulation on 5 popular anti-science topics. All are free-access and free to use, share, build upon, and so forth. I just ask you to properly attribute (Creative Commons<strong> </strong><a href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/"><strong>CC-BY-NC 4.0</strong></a>).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*VTx7HOFmFd-mWq_KcVO2EQ.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*50-j89fN9zEm6fvzxp7f4A.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*U99nFAeSvjaju0Z9gPTV4w.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*HC1Vzh8TTveBlY9Z_3IDRg.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*0cHpeabY7FzlBc395xJjBA.png" /></figure><h4>Disclaimer:</h4><p>This article, like the previous ones, hold the dilemma that they might be used by bad actors as a guide on how to influence or derail discussions.</p><p>I just wanted to share a few considerations about why the benefit of writing about them outpaces the risk:</p><ul><li><strong>Ubiquity</strong>. These tactics are already widely used, many of them as old as time. My article highlighting why they work is unlikely to dramatically increase their use.</li><li><strong>Harm reduction</strong>. It is my belief that these tactics mostly work to manipulate when there is a lack of awareness. Creating awareness thus should reduce harm, especially around medical discussions.</li><li><strong>Combatting side effects</strong>. These tactics create noise pollution, and noise pollution comes with many societal diseases we yet have to wrap our heads around, like epistemic paralysis, nihilism, and conspiratorial thinking. If enough people come around to see the bigger picture, systemic changes to our info spheres are more realistic.</li><li><strong>Restore agency</strong>. Manipulation robs us of a fundamental human right, the freedom and agency to make our own decisions. There is no democracy when citizens have no agency.</li></ul><p>As always, my hope and goals are to educate and equip citizens with conceptual tools and new perspectives to make sense of the world we inhabit.</p><p>This article took a lot of time and effort to conceptualize, research, and produce, actually almost irresponsibly so given that <strong>I do not monetize</strong> my scicomm and certainly do not plan to start with it now.</p><blockquote><strong>I see this work as a public good that I send out into the void of the internet in hopes others will get inspired to act.</strong></blockquote><p>You are also invited to deepen this work or just derive satisfaction from understanding our chaotic modern world a bit better.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ff494e7f3ec4" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The subtle whitewash of anti-science activism]]></title>
            <link>https://protagonist-science.medium.com/the-subtle-whitewash-of-anti-science-activism-271e1d3416a5?source=rss-c8e0e038559d------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/271e1d3416a5</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[science-communication]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[lab-leak]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[disinformation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[science-journalism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[antiscience]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Philipp Markolin]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 29 Sep 2023 15:24:39 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-10-03T20:22:55.809Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>Editorial choices to make the ugly palatable for the mainstream</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*e-nni439ViSOTfzJUURYsg.png" /></figure><p><strong>Background:</strong></p><p>The Atlantic released an article called “<a href="https://www.theatlantic.com/science/archive/2023/09/scientific-research-papers-covid-lab-leak/675464/?gift=aW-LJLyMhm5qBQkWD91si0JXseamAgQZNFpiZZB0dKY&amp;utm_source=copy-link&amp;utm_medium=social&amp;utm_campaign=share">The Banality of Bad-Faith in Science</a>” by <strong>Benjamin Mazer</strong>, an assistant professor of pathology and occasional contributor to the Atlantic. In his latest piece, he takes to three recent scientific controversies, the <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9c17pvE_y8E">self-described censorship</a> for <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9c17pvE_y8E">a climate science article</a> <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9c17pvE_y8E">by Dr. Patrick Brown</a>, the <a href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/documents/5a66d4ae-963e-4b70-aaf3-272f6c64d09f.pdf?itid=lk_inline_manual_5">purposeful omission of contradictory data by Florida Surgeon General Dr. Joseph Ladapo</a>, and the alleged illegitimacy surrounding the publication of the <a href="https://www.nature.com/articles/S41591-020-0820-9">“Proximal origins” paper by Prof. Kristian Andersen</a> and his co-authors.</p><p>Mazer claims that <strong>all three cases of represent a novel type of scientific misconduct in the public’s mind</strong>, which he called the “crime of insincerity” or bad faith. According to his retelling of current controversies involving scientists, Brown is a whistleblower calling out the institutional forces driving his own insincerity, Andersen insincerely tweaked his conclusions to suit editorial expectations, and Ladapo’s conduct is no worse than these and other thousands of bad-faith publications, just receiving more scrutiny. He then goes on to argue <strong>that this type of insincerity is actually baked into the scientific publication system</strong>,<strong> but this should not worry us</strong>. Not every publication needs to be heartfelt, we just abuse sincerity as a proxy of trustworthiness. But as long as the data are not fabricated, the sincerity of the author’s beliefs matters very little, according to Mazer. This is a daring proposition in itself. Can he substantiate it based on these controversies though? Do we overreact to insincerity?</p><p>And maybe more importantly: After years of scientific criticism of publish-or-perish incentives causing a tired yawn in popular media, why are editors, bloggers, disinformation spreaders and mainstream news magazines suddenly coming together with renewed interest in the topic?</p><p>Could it be that editorial decisions to play these real issues up now might not entirely follow out of academic interest, but rather to justify their stances on certain popular anti-science myths of the day?</p><p>Let’s approach these questions methodically.</p><h3>The problem with Mazer’s facts</h3><blockquote>“Do scientists lie? Let’s review the recent evidence.” — <strong><em>Benjamin Mazer, The Atlantic</em></strong></blockquote><p>Goes the dramatic opener of Mazer’s article. First, let me start with the acknowledgement that science is imperfect, that scientists are humans with flaws, that incentives and especially scientific publishing cultures are quite in need of reform. This is well understood by scientists, and this topic has been a passion project for many academics, open-source advocates, and science communicators (including myself) for some time.</p><blockquote>As scientists, it is difficult for us to be anything but protective about the scientific process and the inner workings of science, especially since any acknowledgement of issues will be used by enemies of science to distort, discredit and sow distrust about the scientific enterprise as a whole. But as a <a href="https://www.goodreads.com/quotes/3882-for-me-it-is-far-better-to-grasp-the-universe">wise man</a> said, ‘<em>it is far better to grasp the universe as it really is than to persist in delusion, however satisfying and reassuring’</em>. So let us hold a candle towards the darker corners of today’s scientific enterprise. — <a href="https://medium.com/advances-in-biological-science/how-corruptive-forces-are-chewing-on-science-from-the-inside-ba9af825f277"><strong><em>Philipp Markolin &amp; Laura de Vargas Roditi, </em>How corruptive forces are chewing on science from the inside<em>, 2018</em></strong></a></blockquote><p>These darker corners include profound criticisms of the <strong>oligopoly of publishers</strong>, the <strong>publish-or-perish system</strong>, and resulting unethical behaviors such as <strong>selective reporting, p-hacking, HARKing</strong> (hypothesis after results known), <strong>even outright falsification or fraud</strong>. All of these exist and pose a real problem to the scientific process, and solutions are not always easy to come by, albeit they do exist. But does that mean scientists are driven to lie? Let’s review the factual basis of the case studies Mazer offers.</p><h3>Part 1: Taking a clout-chasing shyster by his word</h3><p>Mazer starts his article by uncritically repeating the claims of Dr. Patrick Brown, a former Greenpeace activist turned climate skeptic, who’s recent media stunts have garnered dramatic attention in certain alternative media ecosystems. Brown asserts without evidence that he felt forced into selective reporting of data and alarmism in order to get his paper into a prestigious journal; and that he is basically blowing the whistle on this institutional “directive” from climate alarmists that required him to do bad science. It is truly “they” who had him downplay other causes of wildfire and overplay the role of climate change.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*-P5RVeVXJAZS9z5ZzVgS6w.png" /><figcaption>“THEY MADE ME DO IT”, would be the summary of a sensational testimony of a former climate researcher who felt that higher forces wanted him to do bad science in service of climate alarmism. He is currently milking attention for his supposed whistleblowing on a climate science conspiracy in alternative media circles. But did events unfold as the climate sceptic now working for a dark money funded climate change denial NGO wants you to believe, or do the facts tell a quite different story?</figcaption></figure><p>A dramatic testimony, the only problem: The <a href="https://static-content.springer.com/esm/art%3A10.1038%2Fs41586-023-06444-3/MediaObjects/41586_2023_6444_MOESM2_ESM.pdf">peer reviews are publicly available</a> and the facts contradict his claims; the reviewers actually demanded the authors to limit their claims and rewrite the manuscript to clarify its limited scope of analysis. One reviewer specifically even asked them to address alternative causes of wild fires, which Patrick declined because it would be too difficult to do for them. If there are any institutional pressures on climate scientists to push a one-sided alarmist narrative, this was not an example of it, but quite the opposite.</p><p>Brown, who in the years between submission and final publication of the article has left academia has since joined the <a href="https://www.resilience.org/stories/2023-09-26/patrick-browns-stunt-takes-climate-change-denial-to-a-new-plateau/">climate science sceptic “Breakthrough institute”, one of those dubiously funded NGOs pretending to be academic institutions (they are not),</a> while serving very specific ideological interests.</p><blockquote>Academic apologists for energy profiteers can concoct highly sophisticated ways to both “acknowledge the science” and quell public anxiety. Brown does not deny anthropogenic climate change, he merely argues that capitalist “resilience,” is more than a match for warming, and sets about earnestly to cherry-pick a couple of out of context graphs and charts to buttress a rather indefensible position. <strong>— <em>Phil Wilson, Resiliance.org</em></strong></blockquote><p>Brown’s current rise to alt-media fame and re-telling seems to be at least inspired by the valid criticism he once received from the peer-review at the time, turning an acknowledged weakness of his research identified by others into an opportunity for personal myth making.</p><p>When he left John Hopkins and joined the California based Breakthrough institute, he appears to have retrospectively fabricated, best we can tell today, a salacious “whistleblower” story, which is, surprise surprise, <a href="https://www.sfchronicle.com/climate/article/breakthrough-institute-berkeley-18109580.php">somehow aligned exactly with the overt politics and activism of his current financial benefactors</a> and their associated media ecosystem. What a coincidence.</p><blockquote>I’d argue that there is certainly some type of insincerity at play, but I see its roots clearly associated with an individual and moral failure, much rather than any type of systemic or academic one.</blockquote><p>However, Benjamin Mazer seems to take Brown’s testimony of systemic failure mostly at face value, rather than critically question and compare it with available facts.</p><blockquote>“If he’s right, then peer review — once a means of making scientific work balanced and consensus-driven — now serves to stifle disagreements, and deferring to it would be a form of surrender to establishment elites.”— <strong><em>Benjamin Mazer, The Atlantic</em></strong></blockquote><p>because it allows him a great ramp into his relativizing argument:</p><blockquote>“Every study is strategic, though. Each requires choices about how to design the analysis and explain the results. Yes, Brown made his choices with a particular conclusion in mind, one he thought would be acceptable to scientific gatekeepers.” — <strong><em>Benjamin Mazer, The Atlantic</em></strong></blockquote><p>Instead of condemning Patrick Brown’s self-serving media stunt and unethical conduct (<em>no matter if genuinely felt at the time or retrospectively reframed</em>), Mazer elevates them to a sort of academic peccadillo, the equivalent of a celebrity sex scandal that actually is all too human given this conducive environment. Who would not understand, right? He re-emphasizes that point with a personal anecdote to really make it stick:</p><blockquote>As an academic physician, I’ve contributed to papers for medical journals and fielded the demands of peer reviewers, however parochial they may be. I can’t say that I’ve always held the line on my own, sincere beliefs. I’ve toned down criticism of professional colleagues, for example, and like […] Brown, I’ve hewed to the preferred phrasing of my editors. — <strong><em>Benjamin Mazer, The Atlantic</em></strong></blockquote><p>Alright, we get it, scientists are human and subject to incentives and pressures… but responding to varied criticisms and trying to accommodate dissenting voices during finalizing a paper is on average positive because it prevents echo chamber effects and knowledge siloes. Are these adjustments most scientists do really on par with Patrick Brown’s actual actions? Or did he see an opportunity for self-aggrandizement with <a href="https://unherd.com/thepost/climate-scientist-why-i-left-out-the-full-truth-in-my-research/">lofty profiles about his heroic whistleblowing</a>?</p><p>I believe most scientists would not align themselves with conspiratorial climate science deniers to tell politically charged fairy tails on topics of public controversy to boost their own profile.</p><blockquote>A small minority of credentialed experts have, in time-honored fashion, always been willing to exchange their reputations for the spoils that corporate strategists and libertarian think tanks are eager to pay <strong>— <em>Phil Wilson, Resiliance.org</em></strong></blockquote><p>Either way, the trust of Mazer’s argument was that institutional pressures drove Brown to be insincere in service of climate alarmism, and that is entirely unsubstantiated.</p><h3>Part 2: Defaming the integrity of a politically targeted scientist</h3><p>For Mazer, Brown’s actions seem one and the same with what he next offers as another example of author insincerity under systemic pressure:</p><blockquote>“Another, similar story came out in June, during the <a href="https://www.theatlantic.com/science/archive/2023/07/covid-lab-leak-congress-investigation/674690/">congressional inquiry</a> into COVID’s origins: The language of a crucial, early paper ruling out the “lab-leak theory” had been altered during peer review to make its conclusions more robust, investigators found.” — <strong><em>Benjamin Mazer, The Atlantic</em></strong></blockquote><p>Now the background of the proximal origin paper <a href="https://protagonistfuture.substack.com/p/a-proximal-witch-hunt">has already been described by me on a different occasion</a>, based on extensive research, leaked documents, hourlong interviews and multiple primary sources:</p><p><a href="https://protagonistfuture.substack.com/p/a-proximal-witch-hunt">A proximal witch hunt</a></p><p>To sum up, there was no wrongdoing, no interference, no agenda, just scientists doing their jobs following the evidence. The conspiratorial energy driving controversy surrounding this paper is entirely baseless. However, what I have not yet explained is the little snippet of <strong>why the proximal origin authors changed their wording to stronger rule out the lab leak theory during peer review</strong>? Mazer claimed that under pressure from peer-reviewers and editors, as well as personal insincerity on the side of Andersen, he elected to <em>“make some the language punchier”</em>. Sounds possible, but is that factual?</p><h4><strong>The next part is not really public knowledge, but happy to give a little exlusive on this.</strong></h4><p>The change in wording had to do with a crucial piece of scientific evidence that arrived during the peer-review period. Namely the discovery of the bat virus RmYN02 in Yunnan by Weifeng Shi and team. Not only was RmYN02 a close relative of SARS-CoV-2, but it also contained a partial polybasic cleavage site that strongly hinted that the FCS in SARS-CoV-2 had a natural origin. Here you have its impact on proximal origins in prose:</p><blockquote>Because in early 2020, RmYN02 had another explosive genetic feature that would shine a light on the origins of the pandemic and dramatically change the minds of the “proximal origin”-virologists in the West, as well as the minds of the wider scientific community. SARS-CoV-2 had seemed so very special because of its `suspicious` insertion of a furin cleavage site in the very narrow S1/S2 region of the spike gene. It was a bit of a fluke. No other previously sampled relative had these extra amino acids in that position, so any alignment and comparison to other viruses made this sequence stand out like a Llama in a flock of sheep. Until RmYN02, that is. This bat virus contained a rather reminiscent insertion in that very same position as well. And while RmYN02`s insertion did not form a full polybasic cleavage site, it showed that within what was supposed to be a flock of sheep, there were at least some odd Alpacas too. Since those early days, we have found all kinds of insertions that made it clear in hindsight that the FCS was indeed not that unexpected. We constantly underestimate what diversity nature can come up with. RmYN02 was the first hard clue toward unraveling the mystery of the FCS and a strong argument for natural evolution, rather than human design, being its originator.</blockquote><blockquote>News traveled fast among experts. It might not be surprising at this point, but Weifeng Shi had good contacts to Western scientists. He had been doing a sabbatical in 2017 — an academic semester abroad — with none other than Eddie Holmes. Since the start of the outbreak, the two have been involved in a different project about early patient genome sequences together with George Gao from the Chinese CDC. On the eve of February 24th, Weifeng reached out with their manuscript to Eddie Holmes for discussion about this one bat virus they found in Yunnan and what it could tell about the evolutionary history of SARS-CoV-2. He sent Eddie the draft of their analysis. Already primed from his ongoing work and discussions about the proximal origin paper, Eddie immediately spotted the partial insertions at the S1/S2 boundary. Hours later, he messaged his co-authors the early draft of Weifang’s paper with just one prompt: “Discuss”.</blockquote><blockquote>“Holy crap — that’s amazing”, Robert Garry could not help himself blurting out first. Kristian Andersen, still dogged about keeping open the possibility of a lab leak, said that this was no polybasic cleavage site, but it for sure provided a mechanism for how the FCS came about.</blockquote><blockquote>“I think this lends pretty strong support for an animal origin of the ‘confusing’ features of the virus [SARS-COV-2]… it shows that the virus likes to “mess around’’ in this part of its genome, that is pretty important knowledge.” Then Andrew Rambaut weighed in about how one could get to a furin cleavage site using RmYN02 by just simulating a few deletions. Eddie explained that RmYN02 is the closest ancestor for certain parts of its genome, so clearly some recombination — the exchange of genetic elements between viruses — was going on with SARS-CoV-2. After a bit of back and forth, Kristian Andersen again: “It does not rule out lab infection/release … however, there are now no more ‘mysteries’ to explain… we see the optimized RBD in pangolins and parts of the furin site in bats (which is pretty cool!!!)” Eddie Holmes concurred: “I am now strongly in favor of a natural origin”.</blockquote><blockquote>Soon after, they would submit a revised version of their proximal origins paper to the journal Nature Medicine being more firm in their conclusions. RmYN02 was, to the best the experts could tell, a major contribution to figuring out the much larger story behind how SARS-CoV-2 came about.</blockquote><p>… and that is it. During peer review, new evidence arose that required the authors to further adjust their conclusions. Some abstract systemic pressures, again, had nothing to do with the authors strengthening their wording on the implausibility of a laboratory origin of the virus. The only thing that would have been “insincere” on the scientists part, to come back to address Mazer’s accusations, is to not adjust the conclusion in light of new evidence.</p><blockquote>“To see our research, and my work as a scientist, so deeply misrepresented by the Atlantic is disappointing to me.” — Prof. Kristian Andersen</blockquote><p>Lastly, and maybe most abhorrently, Mazer turned his attention to yet another controversy to throw in the mix as well.</p><h3>Part 3: Trivializing scientific misconduct of manipulators</h3><blockquote>“Truthfully, his behavior may be dangerous, but it is not all that unusual.” — Benjamin Mazer</blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*U688r1YNCELQeoNVaJDpfg.png" /><figcaption>Anti-science activism coming from elected leaders will always find a sycophantic following eager to please.</figcaption></figure><p>I really do not want to waste my breath on a clear and shut case of anti-science activism by a political manipulator, which is <strong>Ron DeSantis’s sycophantic lickspittle Dr. Josepth Ladapo</strong>. He has been a contrarian on just about every science-based action with respect to the pandemic. He was a supporter of the “let-them-die-working-the-machines” billionaire-sponsored <a href="https://arstechnica.com/science/2021/09/floridas-new-surgeon-general-skeptical-of-vaccines-opposes-masks/">Great Barrington Declaration, he was against masks and of course, he is one of the US most prominent anti-vaccine officials</a>. Earlier this year, he made headlines by publishing a <a href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2023/04/29/florida-vaccine-study-surgeon-general/">purposefully manipulated study on vaccine safety</a> that he <a href="https://www.politico.com/news/2023/04/24/florida-surgeon-general-covid-vaccine-00093510">personally altered</a> to fit the desired political narrative. Deeply unethical, of course, it prompted a public outcry and subsequent investigation that found him engaged in “careless and contentious research practice” and omission of critical data.</p><blockquote>“In summary, our committee has found that Dr. Ladapo’s guidance is based on a finding that is likely insignificant once appropriate statistical corrections are made for multiple tests, fails to compare risks of vaccination with its benefits in terms of averted COVID-19 deaths, and fails to acknowledge generally the societal benefit of reduced illnesses, hospitalizations, and deaths provided by vaccination for all eligible Floridians. Indeed, based on an analysis that is seriously flawed for the reasons enumerated above, Dr. Ladapo makes policy recommendations that are in direct conflict with those of every other major U.S. scientific and public health organization, which are based on published studies that contradict his finding.” <em>— </em><strong><em>University of Florida’s</em></strong><a href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/documents/5a66d4ae-963e-4b70-aaf3-272f6c64d09f.pdf?itid=lk_inline_manual_5"><strong><em> Faculty Council Committee on Dr. Joseph Ladapo’s Analysis</em></strong></a><strong><em> of COVID-19 Vaccination</em></strong></blockquote><p>Or as Mazer put it:</p><blockquote>“Ladapo has faced more scrutiny than some other vaccine skeptics because of his influential public post and affiliation with Governor Ron DeSantis.” […] Truthfully, his behavior may be dangerous, but it is not all that unusual. A large swath of academic literature could reasonably be described as “careless and contentious.” The blowback to Ladapo’s work — and to Andersen’s and Brown’s — has more to do with ongoing political conflicts than any specific, egregious details of its presentation. — <strong><em>Benjamin Mazer, The Atlantic</em></strong></blockquote><p>So Ladapo is just a victim of extra scrutiny because of his political position, while his unethical conduct is pretty much in line with the conduct of other researchers? This is a blatant false equivalency that I find very hard to swallow. Ladapo created and manipulated a study for the express purpose of an anti-science agenda, as justification for pre-determined policies that are not only unsupported by scientific evidence but it stringent contradiction to the scientific consensus. But let’s try to be charitable and say that in order to advance his extraordinary argument that Ladapo’s behavior is not unusual within science, Mazer would have to provide extraordinary evidence.</p><h4>Summary</h4><p>Mazer is grouping three controversies on three scientific issues together as if they were part of the same underlying phenomenon; in short, bad incentives in science which give room or reward bad behavior of scientists.</p><p>However, the underlying facts of these three controversies do not support his premise. Nor is the alleged systemic insincerity of scientists at the root (or even a contributor) of these larger public controversies around climate publications, vaccine safety and pandemic origin science.</p><p>But for the sake of argument, let us assume his premise would have been substantiated, and that the controversies are in fact a public response to the “banality of bad faith” baked into science. Should we just make our peace with that reality, as Mazer suggests?</p><h3>The problem with Mazer’s motivated reasoning</h3><p>I believe that there are systemic problems in science arising from various bad incentives for publishing. Not everybody doing research is honest. We currently have a gameable environment built for humble idealists that lacks strong mechanisms to thwart or punish those who break ethical or professional rules. Science is still largely based on reputation, but in the information age where the most shameless attention-seekers thrive, reputational repercussions have limited effectiveness. Even producing fraudulent papers is not punishable by law except for in dramatic cases of patient harm or investor fraud. Instead of dealing with the grim reality of our insufficient control mechanisms of unethical scientists that go beyond reputation, Mazer’s advances quite a different argument: Insincerity is actually not a big deal.</p><blockquote>“Is scientific insincerity really a problem? Facts, as the <a href="https://knowyourmeme.com/memes/facts-dont-care-about-your-feelings">saying</a> goes, don’t care about our feelings; science is supposed to be the land of facts. Data are presented, discussed, confirmed, or discredited — all on their own terms. Belief has nothing to do with it, and forensically dissecting an author’s motivations has little practical value.” —<strong> <em>Benjamin Mazer, The Atlantic</em></strong></blockquote><p>I agree that science is about evidence. If unethical scientists produce false or fraudulent studies, if carelessness or publication pressures drive interpretations beyond what the data support, this will be found out eventually by other scientists. Science is self-correcting, over time, unreproducible results, false causations, unsupported hypotheses will be challenged and replaced. The issue resources and speed, and this is why <strong>Mazer’s argument is naïve and counterproductive for the disinformation age</strong>.</p><p>When a fraudulent study is easily fabricated, but debunking takes ten times the effort, an asymmetry arises. When convenient falsehoods travel around the world fast, whereas their correction does not even make it out the door further than two steps before the next news cycle starts, another asymmetry takes its place. The deck is stacked against careful science, and the commodification of information into a digital product has created an abundance of junk information in our informational ecosystems.</p><p>We currently live in a <a href="https://protagonistfuture.substack.com/p/asymmetric-power-in-the-information-282">noise-polluted information environment, and this deprives citizens of options to figure out what is real and what is true</a> for themselves when it comes to the above scientific controversies. All they have left is to judge the trustworthiness of scientific information is the trustworthiness of the messenger. This is the underlying reason why citizens feel attached to use the sincerity of scientists as a proxy for the reliability of their science.</p><p>When Mazer argues that figuring out motivations has little practical value, he devalues a useful proxy for non-experts and outsources the task of assessing the veracity of facts on complicated scientific matters to citizens over domain experts.</p><blockquote>This is bad advise, because “do your own research” usually does not favor inconvenient truths over compelling falsehoods. It favors those who have the means or power to control the attention of the masses.</blockquote><p>Don’t get me wrong. It would be great if citizens had the time, energy and expertise to intelligently and independently assess the factual merits of scientific controversies. But if a quack doctor wants to sell you an allegedly repressed miracle cure against COVID, you do not spend years studying virology, pharmacology and medicine to see if he has a point, you get a second (and third) opinion from somebody you trust and who has spend those years studying.</p><p>Trust remains important in science, that is why artificially created scientific controversies that target scientists and scientific processes with an array of <a href="https://protagonistfuture.substack.com/p/distort-discredit-dismiss">information warfare tactics are so corrosive to science and society</a>.</p><p>Ultimately, this is why I believe obscuring the formative role of anti-science activism in these scientific controversies is not only rewriting history, but by framing them as “<em>Banalities of bad faith</em>” from scientists, Mazer’s article has created a harmful whitewash of their true nature.</p><p>Let’s jump into the final section:</p><h3>The problem with Mazer’s blind spots</h3><blockquote>Mazer created a persuasive story; one where scientists are flawed humans embedded in dysfunctional institutions and out for their own profits, just like you and me.</blockquote><p>For me, the real scandal is not that Mazer wrote an unsubstantiated hot take about a topic he did not understand enough. The scandal is to see it published and amplified by mainstream news media that should uphold editorial and journalistic standards.</p><p>Why did the Atlantic decide to go with his article and forego any fact-checking? Especially in the case of Prof. Kristian Andersen, the assertion of Mazer that he acted insincerely when publishing proximal origins is not only not factual, it is a <a href="https://protagonistfuture.substack.com/p/a-proximal-witch-hunt">direct result of a GOP-led disinformation and character assassination campaign</a>.</p><blockquote>“Mazer is making several defamatory statements […] and assigning motives to my actions — actions he has no insights to. He never contacted me before making these false statements […] and I have also not been contacted by any fact checkers associated with the Atlantic.”<strong><em> — Prof. Kristian Andersen (personal communication)</em></strong></blockquote><p>The Atlantic is a <a href="https://mediabiasfactcheck.com/the-atlantic/">serious center-left magazine characterized by well-sourced and fact checked reporting that is broadly read worldwide</a>. What value did the editors see in this op-ed? Is it because Mazer tries to make a very nuanced point about how publication incentives can distort science? Or that we humans care too much about these inevitable insincerities from scientists? (<em>which, as argued above, have become about the only proxy normal people can rely on in our noise-polluted world</em>). Or is it because these are the type of palatable, centrist arguments too many editors in the public intelligentsia on the center left actually want to read and hear?</p><p>While Mazer’s article and the Atlantic was singled out here almost arbitrarily, based on my specialized knowledge about the underlying facts, these types of centrist-y, calm and supposed unbiased op-eds about the flaws of science and scientists are not hard to find. There has been a noticeable trend in mainstream media, from <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2023/04/12/opinion/covid-lab-leak-theory.html">New York Times</a> to the <a href="https://twitter.com/PhilippMarkolin/status/1680849146595385345">popular chattering classes on X-Twitter</a>.</p><blockquote>All of them seem to have formed a consensus that scientists are to be treated as some kind of political interest group that is out for their own gain.</blockquote><p>But too few people ask: Why do these ideas really come from?</p><p>Researchers of varied backgrounds, such as <a href="https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-023-02981-z">vaccine advocacy</a>, <a href="https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/0963721416654436">climate science</a> or political extremism, have noted that these anti-science narratives often start on social media, in the rightwing <a href="https://www.thefp.com/p/i-overhyped-climate-change-to-get-published">bloggosphere</a>, on conspiracy myth <a href="https://stewpeters.com/video/2022/10/exclusive-interview-florida-surgeon-general-blows-open-the-truth-about-deadly-covid-jabs/">podcasts</a> or similar <a href="https://blogs.lse.ac.uk/lsereviewofbooks/2023/07/25/book-reviewgoing-mainstream-how-extremists-are-taking-over-julia-ebner/">extremist fringe outlets before they cascade into the mainstream</a>. <strong>Disinformation campaigns, well-financed information combatants and persuasion operations explicitly aim to change public discourse towards political ends,</strong> a tactic sometimes refered to as “metapolitics”.</p><blockquote>New Right metapolitics is a challenge for discourse research as its proponents possess reflexive knowledge of the discursive arenas in which they engage. <strong><em>— Felix Schilk, University of Tübingen, </em></strong><a href="https://www.researchgate.net/publication/371576108_Metapolitics_as_Programmatic_Storytelling_New_Right_Discourses_as_a_Challenge_for_Discourse_Research">Metapolitics as Programmatic Storytelling</a></blockquote><p>The goal of these actors is usually to <strong>seed specific memes in susceptible information ecosystems</strong>, <strong>finance the amplification of specific story narratives</strong> either directly or <strong>via proxies such as influencers. </strong>By creating enough buzz, attention and momentum online, they aim <strong>to force the hand of mainstream media to talk about these topics, </strong>but through a lens and <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Overton_window">Overton window</a> they covertly shaped. <em>(more on that at a later time)</em></p><p>In our case, once the public perception was created that scientists like Andersen were insincere, that self-mythologizing whistleblowers like Brown are to be taken at their word, or that political activists like Ladapo just engage in everyday deception of science, mainstream media is forced into a reactionary role:</p><blockquote>Editors either have to tell their readers that what they believe is baseless bullshit, or come up with a framing to make these beliefs more palatable to audiences (and to oneself).</blockquote><p>My worry and speculation is that Mazer’s article was just a very satisfying hot take for editors <em>(who also saw their relevance and influence challenged by science during the pandemic as well)</em> to close that gap between personal beliefs, audience demand and journalistic self-image. Mazer, as an academic, is a great voice to instrumentalize by media manipulators, because he has the credentials and beliefs to credibly point out problems within science.</p><blockquote>Mazer draws a picture of problems in science that intelligent people can adapt with good conscience to justify their belief in anti-science controversies.</blockquote><p>Yet by conflating the problems of scientific publishing and incentives with popular misconceptions artificially created through genuine disinformation campaigns (e.g. on climate, origin and vaccine science), Mazer does a disservice to both problems.</p><p>Equating self-serving personal manipulators (Brown, Ladapo) to politically targeted scientists (Andersen), he minimizes the real life consequences faced by the latter while dismissing the unethical conduct of credentialed activists.</p><blockquote>“To say I’m pissed is an understatement. Comparing a domain expert doing the actual scientific work that has allowed us to much better understand the pandemic — unlike the many charlatans in that space — to somebody like Ladapo is just unbelievable.” — Prof. Kristian Andersen</blockquote><p>By not doing his homework and failing to recognize the nature of each specific “controversy”, Mazer created more than just a false equivalence. <strong>He has created a moral injustice; dismissing the role of influence campaigns in shaping public perception and creating a sanitized history of these controversies that puts the flawed “scientific system” at its center.</strong></p><p>This is infuriating to me, who has been a vocal advocate to correct the actual faults in that publishing incentive system. We need intelligent advocacy for improvement, not motivated conflation with popular myths to raise awareness. Awareness (and honestly, self-reflection) would be needed on the wider anti-science context and instrumentalization of certain types of articles.</p><p>He aided the amplification and whitewash of these controversies for “polite society” and the mainstream. By casting them as cases of personal incentivized insincerities that are common in academia and mostly banal, he obscures that these controversies have their roots in the unacceptable (<em>anti-science political activism, climate denial, vaccine and biotechnology fearmongering, disaster profiteering, conspiratorial ideation</em>). These controversies are not caused by the banalities of everyday bad faith in academia. As a result, Mazer leaves readers with a muddy explanation of why these controversies exist and equips anti-science media manipulators and influential commentators with some whitewashed talking points of broken incentives in academia.</p><p>The real harm stemming from his article is that despite the lack of factual basis, all the mind-bending conflations by Mazer created a persuasive story. One where scientists are flawed humans embedded in dysfunctional institutions and out for their own profits, just like you and me. No higher ideals, no professional ethos, no working towards the public good, just good old self-interest, bias, and being a mere cog in a larger machinery. Does it really warrant the authority we attribute to science? Why should we treat a scientist’s opinion preferentially?</p><p>These are exactly the types of subtle arguments that can be recycled by anti-science actors as to why citizens should feel justified to distrust scientists, or why it is legitimate to discard inconvenient science in the first place.</p><blockquote>I do not believe Mazer intended anything of this; and yet, writing about scientific controversies in the disinformation age needs a good amount of self-reflection.</blockquote><p>I understand seeing one’s hot takes picked up by mainstream media is exciting and rewarding, we all want to believe that our ideas are valued and received the way we intended them. But the takeaway is dire. Having one’s ideas subtle instrumentalized for larger political agendas should send shivers up any academic spine.</p><p><strong>That this article was published as is and not challenged on the facts by the Atlantic’s editors and fact-checkers is deeply problematic.</strong> Yet this is the new normal, in the US at least. The uncritical publication of Mazer’s catastrophic but persuasive argument about the core cause of these controversies is as much a symptom as a desired outcome of an entirely different set of actors and incentives. His article was by far not the first, nor will it be the last in a series of persuasive stories about the many alleged institutional failures within science.</p><p>New right metapolitics has identified science as a critical guardrail of democracy to dismantle. We are observing the discourse-warping impact of its anti-science influence campaigns in action. Cascading all the way to the top, enabled by new platform vulnerabilities and the broken market incentives of the attention (manipulation) economy.</p><p>I do hope Benjamin Mazer ponders these next time he sits down to write about the true roots of scientific controversies, albeit I doubt he will have an easy time finding a venue for a more reflective take.</p><p><strong>UPDATE 3rd October 2023: </strong>The Atlantic responded relatively quickly to negative feedback to its original article, changing the problematic title and thrust of the argument advanced by Mazer. Here is the editor’s note:</p><blockquote>This article has been updated to provide more context about the scientific debates it describes. It now includes an expanded description of Kristian Andersen’s characterizations of what constitutes typical collaboration during the peer-review process. It has also been updated to clarify that a faculty committee at the University of Florida stated that Joseph Ladapo may have violated research integrity standards, but the university declined to investigate. It has been updated to elaborate on the nature of the edits made to the state analysis led by Ladapo prior to release. It has been updated to include Brown’s defense of the Nature paper that was the subject of his “I Left Out the Full Truth to Get My Climate Change Paper Published” essay.</blockquote><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=271e1d3416a5" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>