<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Peter Sigrist on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Peter Sigrist on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@psigrist?source=rss-a7ac5bc97ebb------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 05:40:21 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@psigrist/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[How ZX-calculus reveals the logic and processes of quantum mechanics to everyone]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/quantinuum/how-zx-calculus-reveals-the-logic-and-processes-of-quantum-mechanics-to-everyone-944fc3bbbb2c?source=rss-a7ac5bc97ebb------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/944fc3bbbb2c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[science]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[technology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[quantum-computing]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Peter Sigrist]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 07 Feb 2023 14:00:13 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-02-17T10:03:14.346Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>By </em><a href="https://medium.com/u/28b0ccf7b735"><em>Ali Hussein</em></a><em>, </em><a href="https://medium.com/u/a7ac5bc97ebb"><em>Peter Sigrist</em></a><em>, Ilyas Khan</em></p><blockquote><strong>“To reject one paradigm without simultaneously substituting another is to reject science itself”</strong> (Thomas Kuhn, author of “The Structure of Scientific Revolutions” and the originator of the phrase “paradigm shift”)<em>¹</em></blockquote><p>Humans have been asking fundamental questions about the nature of reality for a very long time. From Democritus to Empedocles of Akragas, from Gallileo to Newton, from Kant to Wittgenstein, and from Einstein to Hawking.</p><p>Over a hundred years ago, a series of advances, in an extraordinarily short period of time that has been described as the most innovative period in human history², led to the discovery of quantum mechanics — the laws that govern the universe at the most fundamental level, and which are unchanging across the known universe.</p><p>Since its discovery, quantum mechanics has become the most proven scientific theory ever, allowing scientists to make predictions of unparalleled accuracy.³</p><p>However, despite the extent to which the “what” of quantum mechanics has been experimentally proven time and time again, we still do not understand the “why”. Although scientists have spent more than a century investigating the foundations of quantum physics, the “why” of quantum mechanics remains shrouded in mystery and largely inaccessible to anyone other than trained physicists and advanced mathematicians. Non-specialists, from artists to lawyers, from architects to engineers, from educators to the “person on the street”, have only been able to follow from afar.</p><p>Anyone who has tried to understand quantum mechanics without a formal training in physics, and more specifically without a strong foundation in mathematics, has struggled. Part of the difficulty lies in the fact that the vast majority of the literature that tries to explain quantum physics is written by mathematicians and physicists for their own peers.</p><p>However, an equally important part of the difficulty that we all face in really getting to grips with quantum mechanics stems from our habitually applying a classical lens to concepts such as <em>superposition</em> or <em>entanglement</em>, and painstakingly trying to pick our way through counterintuitive processes. This is inevitable. After all, the universe at the smallest scale works in ways that are at odds with our everyday experience. We inhabit a classical world, whereas quantum mechanics describes the rules of the world at the infinitesimal level of the atom and its constituent parts such as electrons and other impossibly small things such as photons. We humans are simply too big, and the world of quantum mechanics is not visible and its effects not obviously evident to us, in our day to day lives.</p><p>In this article, we focus on the “what” of quantum physics and hope to shed some light on the way that, no matter how counterintuitive quantum mechanics might seem, it may be possible to gain an understanding of it without being a scientist. We examine ZX-calculus, a relatively new innovation which helps to move us away from the classical paradigm, with a new approach to the mathematics of quantum mechanics that encapsulates it in comprehensible “game-like” rules. We consider the role of ZX-calculus in supporting the development of transformational technologies like quantum computing, and how ZX aids in satisfying the need for more people in a successful modern society to come to terms with the “what” of quantum mechanics. We also hope to inspire some readers to consider how it might lead them to engage more deeply with the “why”.</p><h4><strong>Closing a 100-year quantum knowledge gap</strong></h4><blockquote><strong>“The problem of getting the interpretation proved to be rather more difficult than just working out the equations”</strong>(Paul Dirac, one of the founding fathers of quantum mechanics)<em>⁴</em></blockquote><p>Quantum mechanics was discovered at the beginning of the twentieth century by a handful of scientists, some of whom have subsequently become household names. Scientists such as Einstein, Planck, Bohr, Schrödinger, Jordan, Dirac, Heisenberg and von Neumann, developed explanations to interpret, formalise and account for discrepancies that had been observed in nature at the very tiniest scale. These discrepancies often appeared to contradict the world as it could be normally observed at the “macro” or human level.</p><p>A systematic framework was devised and developed by these scientists and then supplemented throughout the twentieth century by others, to account for accurate observations of quantum phenomena arising from increasingly high-energy physics experiments, and using instrumentation with futuristic names such as “cyclotrons”, “betatrons”, “synchrotrons”, and “the Cosmotron”.⁵ Yet, while the “what” was consistently advancing, the “why” remained baffling even to the founders of quantum theory, who preferred to describe their perspectives on the experimental data as “interpretations”.</p><p>This lack of clarity was reflected in the very low level of understanding amongst the public at large. Aside from <em>Schrödinger’s Cat</em>, a well known thought experiment, there remains a very large gulf between the understanding of quantum mechanics by specialists in physics and mathematics on the one hand, and the general public on the other, with the theory often introduced as being so “hard” that it is not worth most people’s time. Descriptions such as “irrational”, “strange”⁶ and “spooky”⁷ have long been the norm, even among professional theoreticians.</p><h4><strong>A rigorous quantum mathematics</strong></h4><p>From the very earliest days there was growing confidence that the “what” of quantum theory, at least, was described correctly by the mathematics that formalised the theory. The most important mathematical treatment of quantum physics, which was celebrated for its rigour, was presented by the Hungarian-American mathematician John von Neumann in his 1932 book, <em>Mathematical Foundations of Quantum Mechanics (Mathematische Grundlagen der Quantenmechanik)</em>.⁸ This built on the innovations and breakthroughs of the founders of quantum mechanics and created a complete system. This work remains central to quantum mechanics, although ironically within three years of publishing his masterpiece, von Neumann was unhappy with it and expressed a desire for a new approach⁹.</p><p>Von Neumann believed that quantum physics was a theory not limited to describing the subatomic, but was “a theory of the whole world”¹⁰. This bold reflection was typical of physicists and mathematicians engaged in quantum physics at that time. Von Neumann’s contemporary, Erwin Schrödinger, who also became something of a “public intellectual”, wrote, “if you cannot — in the long run — tell everyone what you have been doing, your doing has been worthless.”¹¹</p><p>Von Neumann never finished working on the mathematical basis of quantum mechanics and, with the Second World War looming, practical applications of physics overtook concerns about what quantum mechanics was telling us about the fundamentals of the universe.¹²</p><h4><strong>A categorical approach to quantum mathematics</strong></h4><p>During the early and mid 1940’s, Saunders Mac Lane of the University of Chicago and Samuel Eilenberg of Columbia in New York City, produced a seminal paper¹³ laying the foundations of category theory, a field of mathematics that connects branches such as algebra — where mathematical symbols are manipulated as part of formulae, with topology — the study of continuous properties of spatial objects. From its inception, category theory, which places an emphasis on links between objects rather than the objects themselves, promised to reveal fresh insights about the way systems in the world relate to one another. In the past two or three decades category theory has started to deliver on that promise, and is being widely used, for example, by computer scientists.</p><p>Category theorists also work on better understanding and explaining challenging problems in physics, engineering, natural language processing and more, in addition to computer science. The movement has been advanced by mathematicians such as Jean Bénabou, Vladimir Voevodsky, John Baez, Emily Riehl, Joachim Lambek, and Alexander Grothendieck.</p><p>In 2004, Professor Samson Abramsky and Bob Coecke, from the Oxford University Computing Laboratory (now the Computer Science Department), applied category theory to quantum mechanics, to create the new field of <em>categorical quantum mechanics</em>. They explicitly set out to “recast” the mathematics of “quantum mechanics, due to von Neumann”,¹⁴ picking up the baton passed on, over 70 years earlier, when von Neumann expressed his dissatisfaction, particularly with Hilbert space formalism. Abramsky and Coecke’s new formalism, which is as rigorous as von Neumann’s standard system, was designed as a pictorial method for reasoning about quantum processes. This followed and built upon graphical notations used by Nobel Laureate physicist and mathematician Roger Penrose in the 1970s. In the years following the introduction of categorical quantum mechanics, Coecke worked with other collaborators to develop and refine the approach, for example in papers with Ross Duncan, <em>A Graphical Calculus for Quantum Observables</em>¹⁵ and with Eric Oliver Paquette and Dusko Pavlovic, <em>Classical and Quantum Structuralism</em>¹⁶, which introduced to the world new elements of graphical notation, including in a variety of instances, an element called a “spider”. As we shall see shortly, this would subsequently become a central character in the new ZX-calculus.</p><h4><strong>Picturing difficult concepts</strong></h4><p>There is a long tradition of using pictures to explain the complex. When the 17th century Bohemian theologian, Jan Amos Komenský — often called the father of modern education — wanted to grant knowledge to every child in the world, he chose pictures as the most natural, accessible, and immediate medium available. In Komenský’s view, the measure of an education lay not in its curriculum, but in its accessibility to all. “Not the children of the rich or the powerful only,” he wrote, “but of all alike, boys and girls, both noble and ignoble, rich and poor, in all cities and towns, villages and hamlets, should be sent to school.”¹⁷</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/156/1*1jScwZZPLME9MbrT5fPfsw.jpeg" /><figcaption>“Religion” in Orbis Sensualium Pictus,<br>English version, 1672</figcaption></figure><p>His book, <em>Orbis Sensualium Pictus</em> (<em>The Visible World in Pictures</em>, 1658), became the first widely printed resource for children, that explained concepts as diverse as bread making, shipbuilding, weather-forecasting, and caring for animals.</p><p>Komenský’s grand idea took more than two centuries to be widely adopted, but his instincts were as revolutionary as they were right.</p><p>In this regard, ZX-calculus follows a long tradition. A rapidly growing industrial and educational interest in ZX means pictures might again prove able to offer widespread access to previously closed-off and thereby restricted knowledge.</p><h4><strong>Quantum mechanics in pictures — a brief history and explanation of ZX-calculus</strong></h4><p>ZX-calculus was formally introduced in a 2009 paper¹⁸ by Coecke (now the Chief Scientist at Quantinuum, a world leader in quantum computing) and Dr Ross Duncan (now Head of Software at Quantinuum) as an intuitive and diagrammatical way of expressing the properties of quantum particles, based on the principles of categorical quantum mechanics and considered from the perspective of quantum information science, which, according to the authors, had “provided a breath of fresh air for quantum foundations research”. Following that introduction, and thanks to the work of a dedicated and growing group of scientists based all over the world, ZX has become increasingly influential and plays an important part in the enormous and continuing growth of interest in quantum computing, particularly in recent years, as working quantum processors have started to emerge.</p><p>Variously described as “a graphical language that goes beyond circuit diagrams….(and) ‘splits the atom’ of well known quantum logic gates”¹⁹ and “a rigorous graphical language for reasoning about linear maps between qubits”²⁰, ZX is most easily thought of as a form of mathematics that uses pictures and simple, game-like rules to represent the vital elements of quantum mechanics. It does this by representing the relationship between qubits, which are the basic form of information in quantum information theory and quantum computing. Think of the qubit as the quantum equivalent of a “bit” in classical computing.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/470/1*cSaXJ8WFt1VKT-hPX6lFLQ.png" /></figure><p>ZX allows anyone to “play” with quantum processes, (including those that take place when quantum logic gates are applied to qubits as part of a quantum circuit), using string diagrams, mostly made up of small, coloured, counter-like disks with wiry legs. These building blocks, string diagrams with “bodies” and “legs” are called <em>spiders</em>.</p><p>The link with games is important. In classical computing, some of the most impressive breakthroughs can be traced to events inspired by game-play, such as when IBM created a computer that could consistently beat human opponents at chess.²¹ More recently Google’s DeepMind group developed a programme that could play “Go”, a game that for a long time was assumed to be beyond the reach of AI.²² John von Neumann, who played such a central role in formalising quantum mechanics has also been described as “the father of game theory”²³, following the publication in 1928 of <em>On the theory of parlour games (Zur Theorie der Gesellschaftsspiele)</em>²⁴, and later, with Oskar Morgenstern the foundational work, <em>Theory of games and economic behavior</em>²⁵. Von Neumann was also one of the original architects of the classical computer, working alongside another founding father of classical computing, Alan Turing, who in turn used a game as his test for machine intelligence, the Turing Test.²⁶</p><p>Built into ZX are the necessary mathematical rules (the “calculus”) to handle quantum mechanics. “Doing” mathematics with ZX means using a method known as <em>picturalism</em>, which means playing with and manipulating spiders in diagrams. ZX has been proven mathematically to be <em>universal, sound </em>and<em> complete </em>— in other words, you can reason about and calculate quantum processes as effectively as if you had a university-level of prior mathematical training and were calculating solutions to complex quantum mechanical problems.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Iq4Ti8ZG06DXiKYgqF2Q3Q.png" /><figcaption>Example: an entangled system known as a Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger state shown as a quantum computing circuit, then as a ZX diagram, which can then easily be simplified using ZX rules</figcaption></figure><p>ZX diagrams are<strong> not at</strong> <strong>all</strong> trivial. The green and red (and very occasionally yellow) nodes that are referred to as spiders represent rigorously and accurately the linear maps that define a process that is applied in quantum computers when quantum circuits are implemented. By way of example, the small yellow box in the diagram above is the operator (or fundamental building block) in ZX-calculus that is critical in quantum computing circuits, known as the <em>Hadamard Gate</em>. In traditional mathematics it is represented as a linear map, which, depending on the state of the input qubit, can look like this:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/140/1*cdfF29-ibGStYJBf8CoD0g.png" /><figcaption>Traditional Representation²⁷</figcaption></figure><p>Working with this notation typically requires special mathematical training, however in ZX all there is to it is that:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/648/1*2eVAm0gI_fvZxiKf-IR0_g.png" /><figcaption>ZX-calculus Representation²⁸</figcaption></figure><p>In a breakthrough event in 2017, almost a decade after the formal introduction of ZX-calculus by Coecke and Duncan, the seminal ZX book, <em>Picturing Quantum Processes</em> by Coecke and Dr Aleks Kissinger, was published. <em>Picturing Quantum Processes</em> has become an essential resource for many university-based quantum computing research groups, doctoral and post-doctoral students of quantum information theory, as well as quantum computing professionals. ZX is rapidly being adopted and used for meaningful research to advance quantum computing, for example, in a recent paper²⁹ published by researchers at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology and Harvard University, including Peter W. Shor, a founding father of quantum computing. This paper describes ZX as being “of more interest than ever in fault-tolerant quantum computation and quantum compiler theory” because it can intuitively visualise “the properties of circuits and entanglement”.</p><p>Very recently, a new book, <em>Quantum in Pictures</em> by Coecke and Dr Stefano Gogioso (see below) has further distilled ZX into the 5 rules that open the door for almost anyone to get to grips with quantum mechanics and its most important principles. ZX-calculus allows topics such as <em>teleportation</em> and <em>non-locality</em> to become more accessible and easily understood, and even proven from scratch in a small number of “moves”.</p><h4><strong>Bringing quantum mechanics — and the technologies being built on it — to a global audience</strong></h4><p>Engineering advances in the past two decades mean that quantum computers — based on a computing paradigm that was conceived in the late 1970’s and early 1980’s — are now becoming a reality. Early stage proto-typical quantum computers now proliferate and there is an increasing amount of evidence that they will scale in size and capacity steadily in the next few years. Fault tolerant quantum computers change entirely the way that we approach and solve certain problems, which remain intractable for classical computers. Quantum computers take advantage of the properties and laws of quantum mechanics that are inaccessible to classical devices, and thus address problems in a way that is beyond the reach of classical computers.</p><p>It is for this reason that quantum computers and quantum technologies have been adopted as national strategic priorities by many countries around the world³⁰, and most credible estimates show that the annual expenditure by governments, large corporates and private capital has been many billions of dollars annually for the past few years.</p><p>The reason for this geo-political and investment interest is that quantum computing presents a huge economic and social opportunity. Quantum information technologies suggest we may discover promising new solutions to some of our planet’s most worrying problems and challenges, not only in the development of information technology, but much more widely across fields of chemistry, physics and beyond, leading to improvements in medicine and food production, and dealing with processes that affect climate change.³¹</p><p>In order to take full advantage of this opportunity, and more importantly, to ensure that the benefits of quantum technologies are democratised in the truest sense of the word, there must be a more consistent comprehension among the public of what quantum mechanics means. Technologies such as quantum computing can only benefit humanity as a whole when everyone “has a seat at the table”, and new tools and efforts to close the information gap are a necessity for this understanding to become universal.</p><p>ZX-calculus provides us with the first generation of such tools, combining comprehensive mathematical power with accessibility.</p><h4><strong>The power of accessibility</strong></h4><p>Observing the rapid growth of quantum picturalism, Professor Coecke has now taken on the mission to show how, using ZX, the most important and useful aspects of quantum mechanics can be understood by anyone with a basic level of mathematical education.</p><p>He and his collaborators believe that giving people direct access to quantum mechanics will have a profound and lasting impact on the way they see the world more generally. Coecke and one of the authors of this article, Ilyas Khan (Founder and CEO of Quantinuum), believe that access to quantum mechanics, and first-hand experience of quantum principles such as <em>uncertainty, entanglement </em>and<em> teleportation</em> could help redefine what is meant by “common sense”.</p><p>One thing has become obvious — by thinking very differently about the mathematics used to reason with quantum mechanics we can turn the most important explanatory theory of our age into an accessible and creative playground — using intuitive methodologies that are engaging and fun.</p><h4><strong>Sidebar: five rules that account for most of quantum mechanics</strong></h4><blockquote><strong>“Using pictures alone (we will) equip you with the tools you need to understand the quantum world” </strong>(Bob Coecke and Stefano Gogioso authors of “Quantum in Pictures”)</blockquote><p>In the book noted above, one of the founders of ZX-calculus, Coecke and his former doctoral student Dr Stefano Gogioso, introduce a game-like process using ZX-calculus. <em>Quantum in Pictures</em> provides anyone with a chance to learn about quantum mechanics, what it tells us about our universe and the nature of reality — and to start to understand how quantum computers work. This is all made possible through the simplicity and completeness of ZX-calculus.</p><h4><strong>The five ZX rules used in Quantum in Pictures</strong></h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*RMunf2V1yCbUASAYoFnA-w.png" /></figure><h4><strong>ZX in the present</strong></h4><p>ZX has proved its importance within many of the world’s leading quantum computing companies, being front and centre in different aspects of their research and experimentation with quantum circuits that are implemented on actual quantum computers. This includes early work in compiling and routing circuits for use in quantum chemistry, quantum computing enhanced cybersecurity, quantum machine learning and quantum natural language processing.</p><p>One of the most compelling examples of this practical application is that Quantinuum’s quantum software development kit <em>TKET</em>, which has been downloaded all over the world more than 900,000 times, and is growing rapidly, has ZX right at the heart of its powerful functionality. In other examples, computer scientists working at Google use ZX to deal with central challenges such as error correction, and companies such as PsiQuantum and Quandela are using it to research and develop optical measurement-based quantum computing. ZX continues to be actively adopted beyond these limited examples.</p><p>The adoption of ZX in research organisations is accelerating too, being substantially used in a growing number of PhD theses and post-doctoral research papers from universities such as Oxford University, the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Imperial College London, and Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität; as well as the Universities of Cambridge, Lorraine, Tokyo, and Marseille, and institutions such as NASA. A whole generation of quantum computing experts who are familiar with and proponents of ZX-calculus are coming to the fore, and the annual rate of papers published on the arXiv pre-print repository that cite ZX has doubled every single year for the past six years.³²</p><p>Quantum computing is yet to be given any serious consideration within high school education³³ but ZX could change that too, over time. Through educational books that utilise ZX it will be possible to broaden and deepen our understanding of quantum mechanics. Just as regular computer science is now studied by high school students, quantum mechanics and quantum computing might be taken up in the future.</p><p>In this respect, ZX offers us a helping hand in understanding aspects of quantum mechanics from quantum foundations all the way through to quantum computing.</p><h4><strong>What next?</strong></h4><p>The publication of <em>Quantum in Pictures</em> will accelerate public engagement with the most profound and important thoughts and ideas ever devised to describe the nature of the universe. Einstein, Bohr, Schrödinger, and Heisenberg did not agree on what quantum mechanics revealed to us about the universe³⁴, but they knew it challenged many beliefs that had been widely held and taught for thousands of years throughout human history.</p><p>A more recent public scientific intellectual, Carl Sagan, in a 1996 interview with American journalist Charlie Rose, said presciently, “We’ve arranged a society based on science and technology, in which nobody understands anything about science and technology.” He followed this with a challenge: “And this combustible mixture of ignorance and power, sooner or later, is going to blow up in our faces. Who is running the science and technology in a democracy if the people don’t know anything about it?”³⁵</p><p>ZX gives us access to the “what” of quantum mechanics and importantly, given the pace of technological development in the field, it offers the public the opportunity to consider the “what” of quantum computing too.</p><p>By engaging with these issues, through books such as <em>Quantum in Pictures</em>, ZX also offers all of us a chance to gain personal insight into the “why” of quantum mechanics, the question that continues to elude us. For those of us who are not trained scientists, it helps us to close the gap that has affected quantum physics for a century, and it can help in the bigger challenge to make sure that the progress and benefits of quantum computing will be available to everyone.</p><h4><strong>Conclusion</strong></h4><p>Thomas Kuhn, in <em>The Structure of Scientific Revolutions</em> sought to explain why human understanding, throughout history, progresses in fits and starts.³⁶ Rather than a smooth process of new ideas surpassing older ones in their explanatory power, there are linguistic and social forces at play, which first resist the necessity for a new system of understanding, and then produce Kuhn’s famous “paradigm shifts,” which are so rapid and so complete, that sometimes the preceding theories and the language they employed may be lost entirely.</p><p>The period between 1895 and 1945 represents a period of paradigm shifts across multiple scientific domains. Abraham Pais, in <em>Inward Bound</em>, a history of particle physics, recounts how it was not individual phenomena that required new explanations based on observations and experiments made during that period, but entire fields of science that required complete rewriting as theories and discoveries cascaded relentlessly, decade after decade:</p><blockquote>“Part I of this book begins in 1895, when none of the fundamental particles […] had yet been found, cosmic rays had not been discovered, the only accelerator in captivity was the cathode ray tube, and relativity theory and quantum theory were yet to come. It ends in 1945 when physicists had become familiar with the electron, the proton, the neutron, a neutrino, and a meson, when cosmic rays were ardently studied, when cyclotrons had produced particles with energies larger than 10 MeV, and when the first explorations of relativistic quantum field theories had yielded a puzzling mixture of success and failure.”<em>³⁷</em></blockquote><p>Paradigm shifts in the physical sciences continue to occur, with quantum mechanics being joined by theories of quantum fields, quantum chromodynamics and supersymmetry. But as Kuhn argues, one of the most important features of a paradigm shift is the change in language that accompanies it, and allows scientists — and, we would argue, society as a whole — to engage with the systems and theories of the new paradigm.</p><p>In this context, ZX-calculus is best thought of as a critical piece of a puzzle that was missing for over a century in the paradigm shift from classical to quantum explanations of the physical world. Up to now, without access to the language required to reason about quantum phenomena, non-scientists have been very largely excluded from the dialogue. The gap between understanding the science, and understanding how the resulting technologies might be applied, was simply too big.</p><p>One of the most important consequences of ZX-calculus therefore, is that quantum physics can be made far more accessible than it has been in the past. In turn, this increases the potential of quantum technologies such as quantum computing to be better appreciated by as many people as possible — and therein lies the key to unlocking the full potential of the revolutionary change in the computing and AI landscape that is unfolding before us.</p><p><strong>If you’d like to read more, the new book authored by Quantinuum’s Chief Scientist, Bob Coecke, and his colleague from Oxford University, Stefano Gogioso, Quantum in Pictures is available on Amazon and Kindle:</strong> <a href="https://amzn.eu/d/gGgyDLO">https://amzn.eu/d/gGgyDLO</a></p><p>¹ Kuhn, T. S. 1962. <em>The structure of scientific revolutions.</em> University of Chicago Press: Chicago.<br>² “The rapidity of advance during the years 1895–1915 has seldom, if ever, been equalled in the history of science”, Ernest Rutherford, quoted in Pais, A. 1986. <em>Inward Bound: Of Matter and Forces in the Physical World. </em>Clarendon Press ; Oxford University Press, Oxford New York<br>³ Mermin, D. 1989. <em>What’s wrong with this pillow? </em><a href="https://doi.org/10.1063/1.2810963">https://doi.org/10.1063/1.2810963</a><br>⁴ Dirac, P. A. M. 1977. Hungarian Ac. of Sc. Rep. KFK-62. (cited in Bes, D. 2012. <em>Quantum Mechanics</em>. Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg)<br>⁵ Pais, 1986<br>⁶ Mermin, 1989<br>⁷ Einstein, A., Born, M., &amp; Born, H. 1971. <em>The Born-Einstein letters: Correspondence between Albert Einstein and Max and Hedwig Born from 1916–1955, with commentaries by Max Born.</em> London: Macmillan.<br>⁸ Von Neumann, J. 1932. <em>Mathematische Grundlagen der Quantenmechanik.</em> Verlag Julius Springer, Berlin.<br>⁹ Rédei, M. 1997. <em>Why John von Neumann did not like the Hilbert space formalism of quantum mechanics (and what he liked instead).</em> Studies in History and Philosophy of Modern Physics 27, 493–510, cited in Coecke. B. 2005. Kindergarten Quantum Mechanics. <a href="https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.quant-ph/0510032">https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.quant-ph/0510032</a> <br>¹⁰ Becker, A. 2018. <em>What Is Real?: The Unfinished Quest for the Meaning of Quantum Physics.</em> London, UK: John Murray.<br>¹¹ Schrödinger, E. 1951. <em>Science and Humanism; Physics in Our Time.</em> Cambridge England: University Press.<br>¹² Kaiser, D. 2020. <em>Quantum Legacies: Dispatches from an Uncertain World. </em>Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.<br>¹³ Eilenberg, S. and MacLane, S. 1945. <em>General Theory of Natural Equivalences.</em> Transactions of the American Mathematical Society Vol. 58, №2, pp. 231–294 (64 pages) Published By: American Mathematical Society <a href="https://doi.org/10.2307/1990284">https://doi.org/10.2307/1990284</a> <br>¹⁴ Abramsky, S &amp; Coecke, B. 2004. <em>A categorical semantics of quantum protocols.</em> <a href="https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.quant-ph/0402130">https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.quant-ph/0402130</a><br>¹⁵ Duncan, R. &amp; Coecke, B. 2007. <em>A Graphical Calculus for Quantum Observables.</em> Unpublished extended abstract, available at: <a href="http://people.maths.ox.ac.uk/~hap/tancl07/tancl07-duncan.pdf">http://people.maths.ox.ac.uk/~hap/tancl07/tancl07-duncan.pdf</a> <br>¹⁶ Coecke, B., Paquette, E. O. &amp; Pavlovic, D. 2009. <em>Classical and quantum structuralism. </em><a href="https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.0904.1997">https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.0904.1997</a> <br>¹⁷ Komenský, J. A. 1658. <em>Orbis Sensualium Pictus. Hoc est, Omnium fundamentalium in Mundo Rerum &amp; in Vita Actionum Pictura &amp; Nomenclatura. </em>Noribergae [Nuremberg].<br>¹⁸ Coecke, B &amp; Duncan, R. 2009.<em> Interacting Quantum Observables: Categorical Algebra and Diagrammatics.</em> <a href="https://arxiv.org/abs/0906.4725">https://arxiv.org/abs/0906.4725</a> <br>¹⁹ <em>The ZX-calculus (website).</em> <a href="https://zxcalculus.com/">https://zxcalculus.com/</a> <br>²⁰<em> ZX calculus entry.</em> Wikipedia. <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ZX-calculus">https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ZX-calculus</a> <br>²¹ <em>IBM 100: Icons of progress (website) </em><a href="https://www.ibm.com/ibm/history/ibm100/us/en/icons/deepblue/">https://www.ibm.com/ibm/history/ibm100/us/en/icons/deepblue/</a> <br>²² Silver, D., Huang, A., Maddison, C. et al. 2016. <em>Mastering the game of Go with deep neural networks and tree search.</em> Nature 529, 484–489. <a href="https://doi.org/10.1038/nature16961">https://doi.org/10.1038/nature16961</a> <br>²³ Kuhn, H.W., Introduction to Von Neumann, J., &amp; Morgenstern, O. 2004. <em>Theory of games and economic behavior. (60th anniversary commemorative edition). </em>Princeton University Press.<br>²⁴ Von Neumann, J. 1928. <em>Zur Theorie der Gesellschaftsspiele.</em> Math. Ann. 100, 295–320. <a href="https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01448847">https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01448847</a> <br>²⁵ Von Neumann, J., &amp; Morgenstern, O. 1944. <em>Theory of games and economic behavior. </em>Princeton University Press.<br>²⁶ Turing, A M. 1950. <em>Computing Machinery and Intelligence.</em> Mind, Volume LIX, Issue 236. <a href="https://doi.org/10.1093/mind/LIX.236.433">https://doi.org/10.1093/mind/LIX.236.433</a> <br>²⁷ Ekert, A, Hayden, P. &amp; Inamori, H. 2008. <em>Basic concepts in quantum computation.</em> <a href="https://arxiv.org/pdf/quant-ph/0011013.pdf">https://arxiv.org/pdf/quant-ph/0011013.pdf</a> <br>²⁸ <em>The ZX calculus (website)</em> <a href="https://zxcalculus.com/intro">https://zxcalculus.com/intro</a> <br>²⁹ Khesin, A.B., Lu, J.Z. &amp; Shor, P.W. (2023) <em>Graphical quantum Clifford-encoder compilers from the ZX calculus </em><a href="https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2301.02356">https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2301.02356</a><br>³⁰ Candelon, F &amp; Bobier, J-F. 2022. <em>Can Europe Catch Up with the US (and China) in Quantum Computing?</em> Boston Consulting Group. <a href="https://www.bcg.com/publications/2022/can-europe-catch-up-in-quantum-computer-race">https://www.bcg.com/publications/2022/can-europe-catch-up-in-quantum-computer-race</a> <br>³¹ Biondi, M et al. 2021. <em>Quantum computing: An emerging ecosystem and industry use cases. </em>McKinsey &amp; Company <a href="https://www.mckinsey.com/~/media/mckinsey/business%20functions/mckinsey%20digital/our%20insights/quantum%20computing%20use%20cases%20are%20getting%20real%20what%20you%20need%20to%20know/quantum-computing-an-emerging-ecosystem.pdf">https://www.mckinsey.com/~/media/mckinsey/business%20functions/mckinsey%20digital/our%20insights/quantum%20computing%20use%20cases%20are%20getting%20real%20what%20you%20need%20to%20know/quantum-computing-an-emerging-ecosystem.pdf</a><br>³² arXiv search results for “ZX-calculus” <a href="https://arxiv.org/search/?query=%22ZX+calculus%22&amp;searchtype=all&amp;abstracts=show&amp;order=-announced_date_first&amp;size=50">https://arxiv.org/search/?query=%22ZX+calculus%22&amp;searchtype=all&amp;abstracts=show&amp;order=-announced_date_first&amp;size=50</a> <br>³³ Stadermann, H. K. E., van den Berg, E., &amp; Goedhart, M. J. 2019. <em>Analysis of secondary school quantum physics curricula of 15 different countries: Different perspectives on a challenging topic.</em> Physical Review Physics Education Research: <a href="https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevPhysEducRes.15.010130">https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevPhysEducRes.15.010130</a> <br>³⁴ Pais, 1986<br>³⁵ Kirshenbaum, S. 2011. <em>A day to remember Carl Sagan. </em>Wired, May 2011 <a href="https://www.wired.com/2011/05/a-day-to-remember-carl-sagan/">https://www.wired.com/2011/05/a-day-to-remember-carl-sagan/</a> <br>³⁶ Kuhn, 1962<br>³⁷ Pais, 1986</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=944fc3bbbb2c" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/quantinuum/how-zx-calculus-reveals-the-logic-and-processes-of-quantum-mechanics-to-everyone-944fc3bbbb2c">How ZX-calculus reveals the logic and processes of quantum mechanics to everyone</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/quantinuum">Quantinuum</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[IB or A Level?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@psigrist/ib-or-a-level-c0b82b4d5dd1?source=rss-a7ac5bc97ebb------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c0b82b4d5dd1</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Peter Sigrist]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 22 Aug 2014 11:45:48 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2014-08-22T11:45:48.375Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Sv5P252EzJwb_d3XLxIy2Q.jpeg" /><figcaption>To ponder: IB or A Level?</figcaption></figure><p><em>This blog post was written by the former head teacher at a school in the UK. The post is no longer available on its original website but I felt it was too good to lose forever. So I snatched it from the jaws of deletion. I would happily cite the author or take down the post if it offends anyone — but I can’t track him down and so thought I’d ask forgiveness rather than permission. These thoughts are too good not to be shared. Sorry.</em></p><p>To maintain anonymity, I’ve renamed the school <em>Madeup School</em>.</p><h2>IB or A Level?</h2><p>I don’t propose to describe the courses in detail. Most UK parents are familiar with A level (though it’s all about to change again: see below). Please click on <a href="http://www.ibo.org/school/">IB World School</a> to find out details about the International Baccalaureate.</p><p>In a nutshell:</p><ul><li>A level is three subjects studied in depth, IB is six. IB also includes a compulsory core programme comprising of Theory of Knowledge, an Extended Essay and an evaluation of a student’s CAS (Creativity, Action and Service). You have to “pass”” this core as well as secure good scores in your six subjects to get a Diploma.</li><li>A level courses are discrete, while the IB is holistic.</li><li>A level is a pragmatic test of academic ability. IB (while highly academic) is unashamedly idealistic in its philosophy.</li><li>A levels are graded by letters, with A* being the top grade, while IB uses a points system (the perfect score is 45 points), where 24 points and above secures an IB Diploma. The Diploma is, effectively, a worldwide qualification.</li></ul><p>I’ve taught A level and IB in top academic schools, and done a tour of duty as Head of <em>Another Madeup School</em>, so while I’m shooting from the hip in what I say below, the comments are based on experience as well as observation and research.</p><h4><strong>What’s wrong with A levels?</strong></h4><ul><li>The government’s new Education White Paper (November 2010) acknowledges A levels to be “educationally inappropriate” in part because of the modules and re-sits. So the government is abolishing (to a very great extent, and maybe entirely) the offending modules and re-sits. This is big news. However, the White Paper says that even after these dramatic changes to A level, the government will decide “whether these and other recent changes are sufficient to address the concerns with A levels.” At GCSE, for example, the government is now going to introduce an English Baccalaureate made up of a specified number of core GCSEs at high grades (the soft options won’t count). Don’t be surprised if something similar happens at A level.</li><li>Last year, <em>lots of </em>pupils in <em>Madeup School’s</em> Upper Sixth achieved three or more grade As at A level. When I was at School, three grade As got you a telegram from the Queen (or at least a picture in the local rag). Grade inflation is rampant, year on year. Top universities are now looking back at AS module and GCSE results to distinguish between the masses of straight A candidates. Originally, many universities said they would not countenance the new A* grades, but some changed their tune very quickly when confronted by a sea of straight A grades. A*s, however, are very difficult to achieve if you are bright but not necessarily exceptional in a particular subject. A*s demand still more specialisation at 16+.</li><li>Are three traditional, discrete old school subjects really appropriate for our children’s future? I was born into a world where Britain was the world’s second biggest car exporter and rice was in puddings rather than under a curry. Our children’s will be a world in which a President of the USA will probably have Spanish as a first language, where Brazil, India and Russia will be challenging China for economic supremacy and where empathetic, global cooperation will be prerequisites for any nation’s success. It’s not the jetpacks and Bacofoil space suits I was promised.</li></ul><h4><strong>How come every school isn’t doing IB if it’s so good?</strong></h4><ul><li>You can’t just start teaching IB: the IB organisation will only make you an IB World School if they think you are up to it. You have to become accredited and that means passing what is effectively an inspection. So, some schools have tried to introduce IB and failed at the first hurdle.</li><li>It can be expensive to introduce. You have to retrain teachers and – if you keep teaching A level – you actually need to increase the staff roll. Many schools simply cannot afford to do this.</li><li>It’s challenging and schools don’t want to be seen to fail. Unlike A level, there is no grade inflation so you can’t hide behind a wave of rising scores year on year. 40 points was a great IB score in 1970, and it’s a great IB score now. Tony Blair and Ed Balls had a long look at IB and the state sector. Cynics would say that they realised IB would simply increase the state/independent divide as many state schools simply could not deliver IB Diplomas. (Of course some top state schools teach the IB brilliantly).</li><li>It’s got the word “International” in it and, by Gad sir, we’re British. I merely remind British readers that, back in the year I was born, “Made in Japan” meant treat product with caution. We in Britain went cheerily on to build and buy Leyland cars. Quite. Now, of course, if something doesn’t have “Made in Japan” on it, we fear it may fail or fall apart. Took us a while to suss that one.</li></ul><h4><strong>Isn’t IB some new fangled craze?</strong></h4><p>It’s over forty years old. Close to one million students are studying on the programme in one hundred and thirty nine countries. Some of Britain’s greatest independent Schools are now wholly IB Schools. It’s merely new to <em>Madeup School</em>.</p><h4><strong>But in IB you have to do Maths and a Language. That’s a huge turn off for many British teenagers.</strong></h4><p>Indeed so. And that’s one of the reasons why Britain is in free fall in the world education tables. The nations of the earth are not cowering in terror as we plucky Brits prepare to unleash yet another cohort of innumerate, monolingual anachronisms (I am one). The point is, you don’t have to opt for an especially difficult maths or language course. Weaker GCSE mathematicians can and should choose Maths Studies which is the easiest of the three IB Maths options. It is designed to keep your long division ticking along while you are trying to get into a top university to read History or whatever. Students who struggled with a language at GCSE can actually start a new one at IB from scratch (ab initio Spanish for example). Obviously, students wishing to study a language at university will select a more challenging option in this area. Pick your level, says the IB, but don’t give up on these crucial skills when you are only 16 years old. An international future beckons and you need to be ready for a different world.</p><h4><strong>I’ve heard IB is for super intelligent pupils, while A level is for the rest.</strong></h4><p>Not true. This kind of comment is a huge insult to top A level pupils chasing the highest grades. And it’s a snobbishly demeaning slight to academically average, hardworking pupils who will do well at IB if they apply themselves. I’ve taught many such pupils. (Interestingly, this kind of comment has led to a rearguard action from some parents in the car park who defend their child’s choice of A level as the informed option for those not blinded by IB propaganda. Wow! “A level is the Saab to IB’s BMW. Discuss.” Now there’s an IB Extended Essay question….)</p><h4><strong>But IB does tend to attract bright pupils?</strong></h4><p>True when it’s optional. But see below.</p><h4><strong>IB is more work. Everybody knows that.</strong></h4><p>An A level candidate aiming for three A*s will work every bit as hard as a similar IB candidate looking to achieve over 40 points. But an A level candidate looking for an easy three C’s in soft subjects could work less hard than a similar candidate trying to get the minimum IB Diploma score (24 points).</p><h4><strong>But IB takes up far more School time than A level.</strong></h4><p>Now this is true and much mythmaking comes from this fact. This is why some pupils, boys especially, find the lure of free periods (staff call them study periods) too great to resist and so choose A level. It sounds and is a dumb reason for choosing one course above another, but peer pressure at 16+ can be immense. Some sixteen year olds will reason that you must be a geek to voluntarily replace “free” periods with taught lessons: hence the fairy tale that everybody doing IB is super bright.</p><h4><strong>Isn’t A level about depth while IB is concerned with breadth?</strong></h4><p>You’d think three subjects versus six subjects (plus the core) make this an easy one to answer. But such comparisons are simplistic, even, in some subjects, fatuous. Take my degree subject, for example. Here are two English past paper questions. The first is an A level question, the second from an IB exam. In A level you get a perfectly sensible question on your set book, whereas for the IB there is no set book: the student is being asked to do something very different.</p><ol><li>‘Heathcliff is more hero than villain.’ How far and in what ways do you agree with this view of Brontë’s presentation of Heathcliff in Wuthering Heights? (A level)</li><li>“Often enough the novelist favors certain characters, even waxing sentimental about them, and becomes annoyed with others, even feeling contemptuous of them: one way or another, the reader detects bias in the portrayal of the society. How far have you found your chosen novelists to be biased or unbiased in their presentation of their characters and what has been the resulting effect in each novel?” (IB)</li></ol><h4><strong>Why keep A levels at all?</strong></h4><ul><li>In my view, a bright pupil wanting, say, Maths, Further Maths and Physics is insufficiently well served by IB. You simply can’t do that much Maths in the IB programme, and I accept that some pupils are utterly set on a range of subjects such as this. So, this is a good example of why a bright pupil might still opt for the A level route. However, you have to be sure it’s what you want, because in making choices of this kind you are closing more doors than you open.</li><li>Academically weaker pupils can opt for only three AS levels in the Lower Sixth rather than the usual four and, in the Upper Sixth, two A2 levels and a further AS, say, rather than the usual three A2s. There is no such luxury at IB if you are doing the Diploma: an IB Diploma student can drop nothing over the two years. But again, the university choices afforded to an A level student with this profile will be limited.</li><li>Pupils with organisational issues certainly responded well to A level modules and resits but please note again that the argument everybody can do well at A level because you can resit modules to your heart’s content is about to be blown out of the water by the government. Only time will tell whether terminally examined A levels should be the preferred option for disorganised pupils.</li></ul><h4><strong>Conclusion – A personal view</strong></h4><p>The government knows A levels are an anachronism and is quite rightly changing what they are, so let’s keep a wary eye on what happens. For the moment, I think the examples I give above as to why pupils might want to opt for A level are valid and so we will continue to provide A levels at <em>Madeup School</em>.</p><p>But the default position of a typical <em>Madeup School</em> pupil should, increasingly, be the IB. The world has changed.</p><p><em>If you were the original author of this post, please let me know so I can cite you properly. If you’d like it taken down, just say.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c0b82b4d5dd1" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Wikipedia challenges us to adopt a pedagogy of questions]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@psigrist/wikipedia-challenges-us-to-adopt-a-pedagogy-of-questions-a6814ed25a76?source=rss-a7ac5bc97ebb------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a6814ed25a76</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Peter Sigrist]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 11 Aug 2014 00:55:21 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2014-08-11T00:58:04.316Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Notes from David White’s talk at Wikimania 2014</h4><p>David White wants to know: will you be staying here long, in the internet?</p><p>This is the question he posed back in 2008 when, as part of his <a href="http://journals.uic.edu/ojs/index.php/fm/article/viewArticle/3171/3049">research</a> at the University of Oxford, he attempted to articulate a better taxonomy of web users than the “digital native”/ “digital immigrant” distinction used so glibly and so often around that time. These terms referred to whether an individual had been of a certain age before the mid-1990s, when the web and mobile devices started taking off. The age has always been ill-defined, but it was trying to connect the general concept of “awareness of a world before the web, email, mobile phones etc.” and “comfort at using digital media and tools now”.</p><p>David concluded that to find a meaningful distinction, it was less useful to think in terms of ages and skills, more about attitudes. In particular, he identified a distinction between those who see the web as a place to “inhabit” and those who see it as just a bunch of tools. People would, by this interpretation, be either “residents” or “visitors” to the internet (or, of course, something in between).</p><p>(Incidentally, I see a parallel, if unrelated distinction play out frequently when it comes to people’s conceptions of social media — most see them as communication channels or perhaps a source of information — just a bunch of tools — whereas to me and a minority of others, their real strength lies in the connections you make, the information merely being the currency of the medium. Social media are, in other words, a place to inhabit.)</p><p>Today, I listened to David give a talk at <a href="http://wikimania2014.wikimedia.org/wiki/Programme">Wikimania 2014</a>. This eclectic event at The Barbican Centre in London revolves around Wikipedia and its role in society (or something like that, it’s a little imprecise). I’m particularly interested in the education streams as I began working for an <a href="http://www.skola.co.uk/">organisation</a> recently that runs a number of schools.</p><p>David’s talk focused on the broad issue of Wikipedia’s relevance to educational institutions such as schools and universities. It’s no secret that teachers and educationalists essentially see Wikipedia as somewhere between a joke and a threat. There have been many claims by institutions to be taking <a href="http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/education-12809944">a fresh approach</a>, but the gap persists between those who use Wikipedia (everyone, basically), those who admit it (geeks), those who love it (Wikipedia editors and a few others) and those in academia.</p><p>David wants us to accept three things:</p><ol><li>Students use Wikipedia anyway, so teachers need to accept that it exists and teach accordingly</li><li>Failure to disclose this use fosters a “learning black market”</li><li>Education as equipping students to find answers becomes redundant, while this black market exists</li></ol><p>His solution is twofold:</p><ol><li>Admit Wikipedia exists, is used, is excellent, and makes answer-seeking redundant</li><li>Recognise that education is about questions, not answers</li></ol><p>He also, in a nice addendum, suggested that creating, editing and improving Wikipedia pages would be a far better assignment for a student than tests or essays. There was a murmour of nervousness here in the hall as all the Wikipedia editors felt the fragile walls of their world bulge inwards momentarily. But then it was all OK again.</p><p>One addendum of my own: from what I heard today, the International Baccalaureate is on to something in its structure and direction regarding questions instead of answers. The key is putting the power of enquiry into the hands of students and helping them realise, through their units of enquiry, connections such as that between a question and the real world, the connection between a question and many possible answers, the connection between evidence and fact, the connection between truth and falsehood and all the other connections that arise when you start with thinking about what the question is in the first place. Incidentally, I’m not saying the English national curriculum is not on the same path — I don’t feel I fully understand this yet. With that in mind, <a href="http://www.bromsgrove-school.co.uk/ib-or-a-level/">here’s a great post</a> outlining some of the differences between the two by head of Bromsgrove School in the UK, Chris Edwards (hat tip to <a href="http://twitter.com/bentoettcher">Ben</a>, my boss, for spotting this).</p><p>Last point: When I shared the following notes with Ben, he found an interesting parallel between Wikipedia and academia on the one hand, and knowledge and understanding on the other. In his words, he speculated that perhaps “Wikipedia is about knowledge, education is about understanding”. He also made me see a distinction between the <em>emergent</em> motivations of Wikipedia and the commercially-motivated ones of academia (controversial, perhaps?). Finally, there may also be a nice parallel between the hyperlink structure of Wikipedia and the educational approach of the International Baccalaureate — start here, get there, but find your own path. Again, this may be true also of the English national curriculum, I’m not certain.</p><p>Anyway, here’s the notes I made during David’s talk — I hope they make sense.</p><h3>My notes on David’s talk, with some photos</h3><p><strong>3pm Saturday 9 August, 2014</strong><br>Why does the education sector laugh at Wikipedia? Why is it that if you mention Wikipedia in the classroom, you get laughed at?<br>Even when we all know that all students use Wikipedia. All the time.<br>The learning black market. Learners are not making it clear to their educational institutions that they are using Wikipedia and other non-traditional sources (for the reasons above). Educational establishments are not having a conversation about that.<br>In the drive to gather all the knowledge in Wikipedia, you have a huge impact on the education system, and on epistemological investigation. What makes someone an expert? In the education world, experts might be “anyone who’s paid by a university”. But the issue of credibility becomes far more complex if people are undertaking small amounts of niche but relevant research during their editing of Wikipedia.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*JZMMjlfSXUTWcBs93-zN7g.jpeg" /></figure><p>The system whereby universities and educational establishments reject Wikipedia because “anyone could write that” may have a point, but if so, it’s a tiny one. After all, the same argument can be levelled against any website, journal or other publication. The only thing that prevents “anyone” from writing in an academic a journal too often seems to boil down to the fact that the author is paid by a university. In fact, what we’re really trying to get to here is credibility.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*b6TKMZ1oDYXgV9_hCh8dbA.jpeg" /></figure><p>So why is Wikipedia not credible, and in particular, why is it not credible in the context of the university-academic system?</p><p>Are we facing a crisis of credibility, where it’s getting harder to say for sure that a source or piece of information is credible at all? (On a personal note, the social media information coming out of Ukraine earlier this year and Gaza in the more recent past have certainly stretched the definition of credibility. As governments, agencies and interested groups have slammed the social media sphere with information, there’s little time to understand the credibility-chains, or suchlike, that should be helped by things like validated accounts and the transparent retweet system. These systems fall down if it turns out credibility and objectivity are completely unrelated concepts, which in terms of geopolitics, they essentially are.)</p><h3>Why no-one loves Wikipedia</h3><p>So why is Wikipedia not considered to be a credible source by many of those people who spend time online and are otherwise digitally savvy? This is an interesting question, because you’d think that Wikipedia would have credibility with at least one of these two audiences.</p><p>One possible source of this twin lack of credibility ventured by David is that Wikipedia falls between the two ends of his visitor-resident model. In his model, the visitors drop in, read something, go away. Residents leave a social trace, engage, interact, build reputation over time, gain value and therefore have self-interested reasons to consider what they say/write.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*AjQ_3JAIF_OjpVizAko4eQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Look! It’s my model from 2008</figcaption></figure><p>Wikipedia does not fit with this model. It is less obvious who people are — trading in edits, rather than personal identifiers. Perhaps Wikipedia fails in the credibility game because it fits neither into the web culture or the education culture. As a matter of fact, the audience sniggered so loudly at this point that David elected to move quickly on!<br>Now looking at other possible sources for the lack of credibility. David cites a famous flow chart (see the picture below), much loved by Wikipedians, that helps you know when to follow the rules, break the rules, or break the rule that says you need to follow the rules.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*xl9uJE80Xnxo62bXU_w4MA.jpeg" /><figcaption>David White trying to choose whether to break the rules or not…</figcaption></figure><p>The argument he makes, I think, is that any system where rule-breaking is this overtly supported, must lack the kind of credibility required by academia. (Actually, I suspect strongly that this isn’t what David meant — I’d love to know what he was getting at here <strong>Update</strong>: see note on the right for David’s clarification). For me, at any rate, this is a non-sequitur. I see no reason that rule breaking should be inconsistent with credibility. In fact, the transparency involved here would surely be a credibility-enhancer?</p><p>Perhaps Wikipedia’s credibility issue stems from the dictum that “anyone can change Wikipedia”. No, argues David, this is a red herring. It’s actually not, in any really simple way, true that “anyone can change Wikipedia”, at least not unnoticed. There are plenty of checks and balances, watch lists and wary editors and it would be really hard mendaciously to edit something significant for any period of time and get away with it.</p><p>Finally, David reaches what he thinks is the real reason for the gap between the academic world and Wikipedia — and it turns out to be more about conceptions of education than of Wikipedia.</p><p>“We often ask our students, if you could have anything to help you in your education, what would it be?” says David. The most common answer is something like “perfect Google”. This would be Google, where you know that the top result is correct.</p><blockquote><em>Perfect Google: where you know the top answer is correct</em></blockquote><p>Think about “perfect Google” in the context of an academic approach to research. Academics, like David, would say research follows a path something like this:</p><ol><li>find multiple sources</li><li>analyse them critically</li><li>synthesise them into a cogent argument</li></ol><p>The “perfect Google” argument essentially says that students would prefer not to have to do this thinking.<br>And clearly, this is in opposition to the education culture.</p><h3>Learning as finding questions</h3><p>So finally, we get to a point where we can understand why academics don’t much like Wikipedia: it is, essentially, too good. It makes finding information too easy. It takes away a necessary skill. It is not to do with the chunks of information on the site: it is rather to do with the loss of ontology in the student’s enquiry entailed by Wikipedia. You no longer need to understand the system of knowledge in order to find the information you need, when you need it. The cartography required to build a map of understanding is lost. Remember: the nodes are not important; the connections are. In a world of “perfect Google” or — let’s say — Wikipedia, the nodes become all there is.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*KuLsQS3e4ZAOdzb3Z0XIfg.jpeg" /><figcaption>What’s the difference between learning and getting an answer?</figcaption></figure><p>Many students will find an answer on Wikipedia, but they won’t learn anything. Right? No, says David. We can reach a starkly different conclusion:</p><p>“If the answer to the homework you’ve set is a Wikipedia page then you need to change the way you teach,” he says. The part of this statement doing a lot of work is the word “answer”. Education is no longer concerned with answers.</p><p>Education is concerned with questions.</p><h3>What needs to happen next</h3><p>David proposed some of the things that could help to narrow the gap between the worlds of education and Wikipedia.</p><p>First, he argues, the education system has to admit the way Wikipedia exists, and engage with it — influence the way it works. (Personally, I think this is so true as to be mildly embarrassing to the teachers of the world — if you don’t think Wikipedia is very good, rewrite it, for goodness’ sake!)<br>Second, and most substantially, educationalists have to shift from a <em>pedagogy of answers</em> to a <em>pedagogy of questions</em>. There’s no point setting work to find answers, where the answer has already been written on Wikipedia. Education needs to be about the questions. This needs to become the way we educate 7–10 year olds, not wait until final undergraduate year.</p><blockquote>We have to move to a pedagogy of questions</blockquote><p>David proposes programmes to get students to improve Wikipedia pages as an assigned activity are of more value, potentially, than writing essays (some links relating to this at the bottom of this post). This type of assignment would challenge students to consider what constitutes a fact, how to verify facts, how to test theories uncovered by research. It pushes against the culture of “think less, find more”, or of the “perfect Google”.</p><p>Educators often think of the web as being like a huge, chaotic library. But it is not. Everyone can get involved. This is essential to Wikipedia, but has not been to education.<br>David’s conclusion was simple:</p><blockquote>Wikipedia is not a threat to the education system — it is a massive gift. It allows teachers to stop trying to cram answers into people’s heads, and instead to teach them to think.</blockquote><p>Talk by <a href="http://twitter.com/daveowhite">David White</a>, Head of Technology Enhanced Learning at UAL</p><p><em>If you were interested in David’s talk, recommend and share this post — I’ve no doubt both education and Wikipedia would benefit from a more honest, open relationship.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a6814ed25a76" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Teachers Against Technology in Education? No Way.]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@psigrist/teachers-against-technology-in-education-no-way-4b168e8702ab?source=rss-a7ac5bc97ebb------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4b168e8702ab</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Peter Sigrist]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 24 Jun 2014 15:00:35 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2014-06-24T15:43:19.749Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>When some teachers in schools are said to be against “technology”, it highlights the misuse of a word rather than a failing on the part of teachers</h4><p>In a recent blog post, <a href="https://twitter.com/terryheick">Terry Heick</a> pondered the fact that some teachers are <a href="http://www.teachthought.com/technology/why-some-teachers-are-against-technology-in-education/">against technology in education</a>. It’s an excellent, thoughtful post and I encourage you to read it. It attempts to balance arguments about education technology; that while it can be transformational, it can also be costly, awkward and manipulative.</p><p>Throughout his post, Heick repeatedly uses the word <em>“technology”</em> to mean electronic or computer-based technology. By doing so, he frames the debate about teachers and technology as one about teachers and electronic devices and services.</p><p>Is this fair or useful?</p><p>Technology is an incredible enabler of development, opportunity, productivity and — particularly in the context of the classroom — learning. Technology is one of the hallmarks of human progress, of civilization. It’s surely true that to take a stand against technology, <em>per se</em>, is a task as misguided as it is Sisyphean.</p><p><em>“Technology”</em>, on the other hand, is a word, a label that has taken on a meaning that has, lately, become narrower. <em>“Technology”</em> has become almost synonymous with “computer-based devices” or “web-based services”. Such a narrow definition intuitively seems to place technology in opposition to the analogue tools or artisanal methods of a bygone era.</p><p>When, as Terry Heick argues, some teachers are “against technology”, there’s a temptation to conclude that such teachers must be some kind of modern-day Luddite, to be against progress, and therefore to risk doing harm to the progress of the children in their care. Clearly, at this point it’s difficult any longer to have a sensible discussion, and people neatly divide along partisan lines, technophobes against the technophiles.</p><p>But it seems to me that this narrow definition of <em>“technology”</em> is actually holding back a more useful discussion about classroom culture and the role of teachers to inspire interest in their students. If we could expand our definition of technology, take it back to its original meaning, then we would not be inclined to see some teachers as being for technology, others against: we would recognize that all right-minded teachers are advocates of technology in the classroom, but that some prefer one set of technologies over another. And why not?</p><p>In order to get a sense of what I mean, it’s helpful to consider one of the greatest technologies ever to grace our culture: the humble book.</p><h3>Books: A Practical Application of Science</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*3YNw_Ac1-5bcGOh2Dy14qQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Hard-back edition of A Christmas Carol</figcaption></figure><p>A <a href="http://www.pinterest.com/pin/27654985181695267/">beautifully hard-bound book</a> contains more innovation — characterized by <em>generations </em>of hypothesizing, experimentation, application, testing, failure, improvement, marketing, consumption, competition, investment, loss, gain and, above all, patience — than a smartphone.</p><p>I know there will be many people who disagree with this, and point to the incredible sophistication of the technology inherent in a smartphone. It is true that smartphones are an archetypal state of the art, but to think that a book is not so is to see technology excessively through what I’d like to call the <em>lens of now</em>.</p><p>Right <em>now</em>, we’re impressed by the density of silicon squeezed around a state of the art lithium ion battery, perched behind toughened glass and a liquid crystal display constructed so you can’t even see the tiny dots of colored light that create the sensation of a moving image on the screen.</p><p>It is the very definition of magic, as <a href="http://blogs.wsj.com/digits/2011/08/24/steve-jobss-best-quotes/">once described by Steve Jobs</a>:</p><blockquote>It takes these very simple-minded instructions—‘Go fetch a number, add it to this number, put the result there, perceive if it’s greater than this other number’—but executes them at a rate of, let’s say, 1,000,000 per second. At 1,000,000 per second, the results appear to be magic.</blockquote><p>But what the lens of now conceals from us is that once upon a time, we were just as stirred by the tough, portable, innovative combination of print, paper and binding that <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gutenberg_Bible">put the Word into the hands of the People</a>.</p><h3>Technology Does Not Equal Computers</h3><p>Technology is not synonymous with electronics; even less, the <em>internet</em>. But we are routinely persuaded so by the narrow focus of much current discussion about technology.</p><p>In his blog post, Heick uses <em>“technology”</em> in a narrow way. He states, for example:</p><blockquote>that “technology” seems all lumped together, the iPads with YouTube with social media with mobile learning.</blockquote><p>Heick argues that debates over <em>“technology”</em> obscure other, more important pedagogical conversations:</p><blockquote>including the new learning models like blended learning, self-directed learning, flipped classrooms, mobile learning, and sync teaching that technology enables.</blockquote><p>Through it all, he intends by <em>“technology”</em> a certain very narrow subset of technology: iPads, social networks, mobile devices and interactive screens among other things. By their omission, there is a clear implication that tools like books and blackboards would not count. This act of definition may be accidental, but Heick seems to see later technologies as replacing earlier ones.</p><p>This version of technological progress is analogous to the form of scientific progress proposed by Thomas Kuhn in <a href="http://projektintegracija.pravo.hr/_download/repository/Kuhn_Structure_of_Scientific_Revolutions.pdf"><em>The Structure of Scientific Revolutions</em></a>. Prior to Kuhn, scientific progress was understood as “development by accumulation”. Kuhn proposed a more drastic theory, where the inevitable failure of successive theories leads scientists to question the underlying assumptions of the current paradigm. A new paradigm consequently emerges, resolving those issues that plagued the previous one. That technological progress can move forward in a similar manner was later proposed in the much-cited paper, <a href="https://faculty.fuqua.duke.edu/~charlesw/s591/Bocconi-Duke/Bocconi/s6_Demand_View/Dosi%201982.pdf"><em>Technological paradigms and technological trajectories</em></a>.</p><p>Under Kuhn’s model, earlier paradigms are rejected in favor of newer, more successful ones. This version of technological progress is one-directional, perpetual, ecdysial: books and chalk, inkwells and pinhole cameras, abacuses and slide rules are part of an earlier skin, since shed to reveal the glistening veins of silicon and copper that characterize technology <em>now.</em></p><p>But what if technology is not ecdysial, but accretive? Can’t we accept there are advantages to both books and iPads; that they can work alongside one another; that in a learning environment using both is in fact better than using just one? Isn&#39;t it possible that if one teacher prefers to bring together a set of older technologies, while another is an early adopter, this is in fact the optimum scenario for children, who learn from both teachers?</p><h3>Choosing is Not Rejecting</h3><p>The teacher who encourages her students to embrace technologies of a bygone age openly and honestly — whether alongside or in place of more recent inventions — is making a choice, not a rejection. The teacher who feels personally and strongly that books are better than iPads or vinyl is better than MP3 is not rejecting technology: she is merely expressing a preference for one technology over another in a specific context.</p><p>She may want to have some good reasons to back up her choice. She may be challenged by students, colleagues or parents: buy <em>why</em> did you think it would be better to learn like this? That’s just fine. This is exactly the kind of discussion that fosters clear thinking.</p><p>The teacher who instills in his charges a love of learning, as well as the fruits of study, through the consistent application of a set of technologies that work together well — such as pencils and paper, skipping ropes and Elastoplast, YouTube and GoPro, iPads and Dropbox — is changing the world, one child at a time, in the way only he knows how. This is how we should judge him.</p><p>I agree with Heick that technology should not obscure our view of what matters in education. His post is not a judgment, but an open-minded inquiry into the phenomenon of teachers rejecting technology in the classroom. Yet it’s hard to ignore that whenever he uses <em>“technology”</em> to mean apps and iPads and PowerPoint and things like that, he ignores the fact that trumpets and books and chalk and trainers are all types of technology that —I strongly suspect— those teachers he finds rejecting <em>“technology”</em> would be inclined to embrace.</p><p>If we can recognize that technological progress is not a one-way street, then we must be able to allow teachers who don’t use PowerPoint to remain — potentially at least — excellent teachers. There is room in modern education for digital evangelists as well as lovers of artisanal paint-making and bookbinding processes. Children will benefit from the breadth of an education shaped by teachers at each end of this spectrum, and all those in between.</p><p>We shouldn&#39;t force teachers on to the horns of a false dilemma: iPads or books, Playstations or footballs. We should put down the lens of now and recognize that technology is about choices, not rejection. Most of all, we should trust teachers to make their choices openly, shaping the learning experience of their students on the basis of their training, inspiration and passion.</p><p>Let’s judge teachers by their ability to inspire learning, not by the tools they choose to do it.</p><p><em>I’m not a teacher but my work focuses on technology adoption and behavioral characteristics of people working with technology, mainly of the electronic-computer-web kind. I have worked with a number of high profile education organisations, and am an inquisitive blogger. I’d welcome your comments on this post, if there are areas I&#39;ve failed to understand or get across.</em></p><p><em>And if you think it’s worth it, why not recommend it below?</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4b168e8702ab" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Speech notes: Digital Trends Report 2014]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@psigrist/speech-notes-digital-trends-report-2014-65c6ea8f8005?source=rss-a7ac5bc97ebb------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/65c6ea8f8005</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Peter Sigrist]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 06 Feb 2014 00:11:09 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2014-02-06T07:59:12.190Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>For the 33 Digital/Hotwire launch event at the ICA in London, 4 February 2014</h4><p>These are the notes I used to present the fifth annual Digital Trends Report at the ICA in London. The event has been a part of the 33 Digital calendar since 2010. This year we had our biggest turn out yet, with over 250 communication professionals signing up.</p><p>The speech covers eight of ten chapters covering our predictions of the major trends for 2014. It is designed to appeal to communications professionals who are facing a digital future. All mistakes here are mine alone, so please do point them out.</p><p>If you enjoy it, please feel free to download the whole report at <a href="http://digitaltrendsreport.com/">DigitalTrendsReport.com</a>.</p><p>And please annotate in the margin!</p><h3>Rise of the niche networks</h3><p>It’s 10 years since Facebook opened its doors and eight since Twitter reimagined the text message.</p><p>Today, Facebook has 1.2 billion users. That was the total human population in 1850.</p><p>Each month, we spend 700 billion minutes on Facebook. That’s the same as every adult on Earth dedicating 45 minutes a week. You might say this is reaching the scale of a religion.</p><p>But what happened a decade ago to spur this growth? It wasn’t a faddish new technology: it was a new freedom. Of connection without governance; of unedited expression.</p><p>It was easy, and it was profound.</p><p>How have things changed, now Facebook has grown up? As FB turns on the advertising tap, the draw of connection withers. And as Facebook becomes a social utility that everyone uses, self-expression dies.</p><p>But the demand remains and will spur new services.</p><p>Every generation of teens has clamoured for new ways to connect and build a self-image. The difference is that we’re now in a world where everyone was once a teenager.</p><p>The teen desire is now universal, and this is why we can expect to see, as the technological barriers decline, a repeated churn of social networks: Twitter takes over from Facebook; Tumblr takes over from Twitter; Snapchat takes over from Tumblr. Eventually, you turn to a new place that better suits your needs.</p><p>Already, Strava welcomes cyclists, StyledOn fashionistas, greens fix the world on Wiser and emos kill one another on Vampire FreaksThe tech barriers are down.</p><p>The only thing holding back most companies and brands from building their own community of fans is that they have not taken enough time to get to know them better.</p><blockquote>2014 is the year to get closer to your audience</blockquote><h3>Data for the moment</h3><p>When you start social media listening for the first time, it can be overwhelming. So much data, flowing past so fast. A typical organisation is simply not built to deal with a world at that pace.</p><p>This is what Douglas Rushkoff — who is @rushkoff on Twitter — called “Present Shock”. This describes the state of large organisations who are unable to handle the inputs from the last event to affect them, before they are being beset by the next one.</p><p>Think governments or crisis-hit companies trying to operate at the speed of Twitter.</p><p>But some organisations are managing to achieve this. What sets them apart? They have built flexibility in. Remember at the 2013 Superbowl where the lights went out? Oreo tweeted a picture, reminding their fans that it’s OK to dunk in the dark. They got the image designed, approved and published within 15 minutes. As a result, they captured the mood, the image went viral and they out-advertised the main Superbowl sponsors — for free.</p><p>Many brands are attempting this: they hire a social media manager, they ask them to be quirky, to “join the conversation”. And what happens? They all start posting “funny” images about major events such as the birth of King George last year.</p><p>The problem is nobody’s listening to them. As everyone follows everyone, the signal becomes noise. As a result, the value of differentiation grows exponentially.</p><p>The solution is give your social media manager the freedom and the tools to develop a real brand personality. If you haven’t noticed the rapid growth of Tesco Mobile, you haven’t enjoyed the banter, cutting remarks and humility offered by that brand on Twitter. They have maintained a good sense of humour, while surprising the public with their cheek.</p><p>The lesson is simple: this is the year of digital maturity. It’s no longer enough just to appoint a social media manager — hire someone with a gift for creative content, and see the difference it makes to your online community engagement and growth, as you become capable of capitalising on what’s happening right now.</p><h3>Pre-emptive computing</h3><p>Artificial intelligence, for most people, means robots or chess-playing computers. Some may think of the Turing Test, where computer scientists attempt to design a computer that is indistinguishable from a human in conversation.</p><p>Yet these are all one type of AI. Science fiction gave us another: the borg in Star Trek or Minds in the novels of Iain M Banks — you might call them both artificial intelligence in the cloud.</p><p>This sort of AI is with us already.</p><p>We’re calling it PRE-EMPTIVE COMPUTING — an application that attempts to figure out what you want based on a mathematical hunch. In your browser or using your mobile phone’s notification system, a pre-emptive computing system may advertise to you a product you like based on a site you visited previously, or suggest a place to go based on where you are now.</p><p>Foursquare no longer requires you to check in: it figures out where you are, how long you’ve been there, and what you or someone like you would typically do next — then suggests it.</p><p>Google Now does something similar, working out what information you might want based on the time of day or where you are. And Apple’s new iBeacon will help retailers to pinpoint your location, serving you offers that they guess will appeal, based on your precise location.</p><p>For companies with large volumes of customer or location data, such as retail, transport or public sector organisations, your data may add value to one of these services. Perhaps the opportunity is to launch a service of your own, based on your customers’ behaviour.</p><p>For every company and service, it opens up opportunities as your customers will quickly become comfortable with unplanned notification, if the timing is right. Your customers are going to expect to hear from you more, not less. But you have to make sure your communication is well-timed, otherwise it will feel like INTERRUPTIVE COMPUTING.</p><h3>Social media in school</h3><p>Depending on what you read, anywhere between 80% and 98% of teens use social media. Broadly a good thing, there is increasing evidence of poor behaviour on social media, such as bullying or threatening behaviour.</p><p>At least nine teen suicides from the past 18 months were blamed on social network Ask.FM. Childline reported an increase of online bullying cases to nearly 5K in 2013.</p><p>Yet social media has already entered the classroom, and is having a very positive impact. Specialist social network EDMODO is designed with classroom learning and assignments in mind, and is already widely used in schools.</p><p>In the latest poll by the CENTRE FOR LEARNING AND PERFORMANCE TECHNOLOGIES, Edmodo was voted the 29th most useful classroom tool for learning. TWITTER was number 1, YOUTUBE 3, WORDPRESS 8 and FACEBOOK 9.</p><p>We’re reaching the age of maturity in the way social media is used in schools, but there is a need to educate teens about using social networks properly, particularly outside the classroom. The two young adults recently convicted for abusing the journalist and activist Caroline Criado Perez on Twitter were clearly unaware of the seriousness of their tweets.</p><p>We expect to see the discussion around teens and social media to grow in 2014. For companies and brands wishing to target youth audiences, taking a position on educating young people on the need for safe use of social media may be a necessary defensive measure. It could also be a great PR opportunity.</p><h3>The rise of the digital artisans</h3><p>For every action there is an equal and opposite reaction. This is true of society, just as it is in physics.</p><p>And so, as the past few years have seen a dash for digital superiority, so we expect the counter-movement to be strong in 2014. Whether it is the continued growth of the vintage chic seen in the photo filters popularised by Instagram, or the invention of devices that help turn tablets into note and sketch pads, we think we’ll see the past creeping into the future more this year.</p><p>We think smart companies and brands will make an attempt better to meet people’s love of craftsmanship, whether in their products, or simply in the way they communicate the stories behind them.</p><p>The evidence of craft is all around, accelerated by the advent of online marketplaces. Take Etsy: whose chief executive Chad Dickerson states he wants to “humanise” commerce and work. According to a recent article in The Economist, Etsy is the heir of the 19th Century Arts and Crafts movement. The difference is that today’s army of craftspeople have embraced technology.</p><p>The internet has given craftspeople a route to market that didn’t exist before. These are promoted with their backstory front and centre, drawing on the human propensity or nostalgia. We’ll see companies make more of the stories and people behind their products and services.</p><p>For every company or brand, craft can be deployed in their own website, in creating a place where their customers can easily engage with their products or brands. Those who get it right will enjoy an advantage over those who see communicating with their customers as an assembly line process.</p><blockquote>This is the year of the beautifully-crafted message</blockquote><h3>From customers to community</h3><p>In our first digital trend report way back in 2010, we predicted the rise of the community manager. Today, some brands are really getting this right: KLM, Nike Running and O2 are examples of companies really engaging their customers via social media. Indeed, for them, Twitter and Facebook are legitimate customer service channels.</p><p>And why not?</p><p>Nestle, in France, has a team of 20 dedicated to delivering inspirational customer service online. Telstra in Australia operates a social customer command centre that responds to hundreds of thousands of posts on average within a minute.</p><p>Yet there is evidence all around of a disconnect between social media and customer service. In Italy, it was recently found that only 2% of companies have blended customer service and social media.</p><p>When the customer service and social media teams are working in silos, it is a risk. A few years ago, Eurostar found this out when it continued to tweet special offers while trains were stuck in the Channel Tunnel. Last year, just as the horsemeat scandal was taking off, Tesco tweeted it was “time to hit the hay”. That alone caused days’ worth of headlines.</p><p>The problem within companies is that social media and customer service teams are coming at the same problem from completely different backgrounds. Customer service is defensive in nature; fewer contacts with a customer count as a success. Community managers, on the other hand, are tasked with getting members of the public, as well as customers, engaging as often as possible.</p><p>These are two different worlds, and when one enters the other, it can go wrong. Look at the result of the British Gas customer service team turning to Twitter last year to engage with customers. During their #askBG twitter chat, the public turned on them about energy prices and the customer service team was incapable of changing the conversation.</p><p>Meanwhile, Tesco Mobile has shown how social media are a place where normal human language and tone of voice can work to a brand’s advantage.</p><p>The solution is to close the gap between customer service and social media teams. Each approach has its advantages, and by acting more closely together, companies should be able to better make use of their respective cultures and skills.</p><blockquote>The winners will be customers, who will gain confidence in their communication with companies and brands, no matter the channel</blockquote><h3>Big media is back</h3><p>The way the media interact with the public has changed. For years, the broadcast model allowed media companies to create a fixed schedule for content, and consumers would be happy enough to receive that content at a time dictated by the media company.</p><p>Today, schedules are becoming a thing of the past. William Eccleshare, the CEO of Clearchannel, recently said that 2014 will see the death of the TV advertising model. The good news is that media are discovering new ways to publish content that takes advantage of new consumer behaviours.</p><p>Social, rather than search, is the battleground for news organisations. The viral news model pioneered by Buzzfeed and Upworthy will become more widely adopted. Publishers are creating content that inspires people to share with their communities, based on an emotional connection.</p><p>The distinction between editorial and advertising is being continually eroded, with sponsored content becoming a bedrock of all media. Even the New York Times recently created a new design for native advertising.</p><p>Media are experimenting with immersive narratives such as Snowfall or Firestorm, by the New York Times and The Guardian respectively. These are designed to drive attention through social media sharing, being based on better use of media to create an emotional response with the reader.</p><p>These techniques are not limited to the media. This year, we have worked with Microsoft to create its own immersive narrative content on its website. Companies can and should pitch stories on their website that people want to share, using wit or emotion.</p><p>This idea, of “brand journalism” isn’t new. But perhaps the emphasis on journalism, and publishing news is now out of date. Brands need to see how news media is spreading its wings into new styles of storytelling, and follow that path.</p><blockquote>Crafting better content on a company website is a relatively small investment, but with a huge potential to reach new audiences and better connect with existing ones</blockquote><h3>But how much?</h3><p>Our final trend this year is measurement. Measurement in public relations is too often thought about the wrong way — either as a service to be delivered or as some form of magic, a black box run by geeks.</p><p>But measurement is a language, and the PR industry is realising that fluency is no longer optional.</p><p>Too many PR campaigns are conceived and launched without a clear view of the business value or efficacy of the campaign. Inputs are measured (number of press releases written); or outputs (number of stories secured). And meanwhile, the connection to business outcomes is often ignored completely.</p><p>I know that some people believe it is safer not to measure PR too closely, because it doesn’t compare favourably to advertising. For example, a well-placed story in the press doesn’t necessarily lead to a spike in sales, in the way that some advertising can deliver.</p><p>Well, this may or may not be true (there’s no evidence for it). But that stance leaves only two options: either there is no measurable business value, in which case we should all pack up and go home. Or there is a measurable business value, and we’re not looking in the right place.</p><p>For us at 33 Digital, the trick lies in integration. Whitehall Lane, a Napa Valley winery used tasting sessions as a sales avenue. When they began to use social media to complement this activity, they were able to increase sales by 39%. Social media was not the sales tool, but played a critical part in the sales journey — and measuring this was possible thanks to the open nature of social media.</p><p>This reveals the root of success in measuring PR: getting your hands on the right data. Many working in PR see toolkits such as Google Analytics, Radian6 or our own tool Listening Post as costs to be borne. However, they each provide critical elements in measuring the efficacy of a campaign — in this sense their cost is easily outweighed by the value they provide to a team willing to prove the value of their work.</p><p>Measuring the impact of traditional and digital PR is the key to securing a more lucrative future. The good thing is that few doubt the potential of PR to shift the needle for a company or brand — the pity is that few are able to show by how much.</p><p>If you want a place to start, I would recommend visiting the website of the International Association for the Measurement and Evaluation of Communication. <strong>Amecorg.com</strong> provides a measurement Framework, with an idea of the kind of metrics that can be used by PR people in building a picture of the value of their work.</p><h3>CONCLUSION</h3><p>Thanks once again for listening to our talk today. Thanks to …</p><p>We’ve been doing this for five years, and have talked about dozens of trends over those years.</p><p>But this year, we detect a larger shift, which we have characterised as digital maturity. We think the key to achieving success this year will be less about shiny new technologies, more about making use of those who have matured into the online tools and platforms that are available today.</p><blockquote>This year think about well-crafted content, data and measurement, and integration with other marketing and communication disciplines</blockquote><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=65c6ea8f8005" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Designing for an audio web]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/i-m-h-o/designing-for-an-audio-web-2669cd13b5a7?source=rss-a7ac5bc97ebb------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2669cd13b5a7</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Peter Sigrist]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 20 May 2013 09:22:09 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2014-05-23T07:44:08.632Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/700/0*UfY74nwxDA0jgr18.jpeg" /></figure><h4>Inventions like Siri, Evi and Indigo are beginning to give us a glimpse of what an audio web could be like, but we’re currently held back by the browser paradigm</h4><p>I’m walking to a mid-afternoon client meeting in North London and listening to music as I go. Thinking further ahead, I can’t recall whether my meeting after this one is at 3:30 p.m. or 4:00 p.m. I hold down the button on my earphones.</p><p>The music fades and a customary bleep followed by silence prompts me to ask out loud:</p><blockquote><em>when is my meeting, Team Catch Up?</em></blockquote><p>The robot voice responds:</p><blockquote>checking your calendar. Your meeting is at 4pm today.</blockquote><p>The music fades back in but I press the button again and after the fade out and the bleep, I ask:</p><blockquote><em>where is my meeting, Team Catch Up?</em> Checking your calendar. Your meeting is at Dose Espresso.</blockquote><p>I’ve arrived at my first meeting now and I head into my client’s airy hilltop offices. Through every four-metre window, from here I get a spine-tinglingly good view of London’s iconic skyline. Once we’re settled in, we discuss the way we’re employing a number of thoughtful design principles to make it more likely that people will spread the word about their next report. It’s our job to make it more likely that people who read the report will be inspired to share it with their friends.</p><blockquote>In locating these buttons, we’re attempting to predict where the reader’s eye will fall in 20 microseconds.</blockquote><p>This is it, our job. We persuade people to share our clients’ stories with the people they interact with. In the past, our tools were press releases and the people we tried to influence were journalists. Now, we are as likely to use interactive content painstakingly designed for a niche audience, embedded with snippets of code. In this case, we’re using code to zoom in, to draw a visitor’s attention to certain parts of the report. We represent these as expressive visualisations or quotes, and carefully locate sharing buttons next to them.</p><p>In locating these buttons, we’re attempting to predict where the reader’s eye will fall in the 20 microseconds it takes for the impact of a chart or a quote to hit. The button in effect says <em>tell everyone what you’re experiencing right now</em>. If we’ve done our job properly, the button invites an instant tap and immediately the reader will see — popped up and ready to send — almost exactly what they’re thinking in that moment. The message will be in short-form and contain within it something that may trigger someone reading it to tap on a link for more information, something like:</p><blockquote>It’s reassuring to see that our holiday choices remain one of the best <a href="http://gb.hotels.com/hotel-price-index/1-global-price-changes.html">indicators of wealth</a>, even after the financial crisis.</blockquote><p>Design in context like this plays into the immediacy of the internet, and the ability to share opinions and information with specific groups using social media. It plays into mobile access to information, which is quite literally at your fingertips, no matter where you are. Such design costs little and can have a profound effect on the way a story spreads.</p><p>Yet — strikingly — it has taken 20 years of the web and at least five years where share buttons have been commonplace, for this type of thinking to become normal. Until recently, the social web has been limited by the inexperience of those who know how to embed a share button but have never used one in anger. As my colleague <a href="http://twitter.com/lurkmoophy">Luke Murphy</a> recently <a href="http://www.lurkmoophy.com/2013/designing-to-share-putting-the-context-into-share-buttons/">put it so well</a>:</p><blockquote>On an article, having a ‘share this’ button at the top of your article isn’t conducive to the user journey. The user is most likely on that page to read the article, and by putting a call to action at the top of the article, you are asking them to disrupt their intended journey to do something else.</blockquote><p>Contextual social design — like the tweetable summaries used at the top of <a href="http://gigaom.com/2013/05/18/why-yahoo-acquiring-tumblr-for-1-billion-makes-a-certain-horrible-kind-of-sense/">Gigaom</a>’s articles — considers the frame of mind of the user at the point they encounter the button, and it appears only to have taken hold <a href="http://www.smashingmagazine.com/2012/06/04/social-media-is-a-part-of-the-user-experience/">within the past year</a>. Until now, it has been lurking, just out of sight. What other design paradigms are sitting out there waiting, waiting to take hold?</p><h4>Controlling a computer without looking</h4><p>So now my earphones are back in and I’m walking out through the revolving doors of my client’s offices, getting my bearings. Where on earth is Dose Espresso from here?</p><p>Hold. Fade. Bleep. I ask: “How do I get to Dose Espresso?” <em>Getting directions to Dose Espresso. Starting route to Dose Espresso. Head South on St John Street… </em>The music fades back in and I start walking. Occasionally, where I have to take a turn, the music fades out and I’m directed towards <a href="https://foursquare.com/v/dose-espresso/4ad7a8ddf964a520650d21e3">Dose Espresso</a>.</p><blockquote>Using my voice immediately makes my interfacing with a set of databases far more like dealing with a human or a pet.</blockquote><p>This is a relatively new experience, outside of <a href="http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HwBmPiOmEGQ"><em>2001</em></a> or, if you like, <a href="http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dcqmVws4nr4"><em>The Hitchhiker’s Guide To The Galaxy</em></a>. Using ears and my voice — instead of my fingers and eyes connected to a screen and keyboard — is different. Not just a little bit different, but really different. Using my ears is more intimate than staring at a screen. And using my voice immediately makes my interfacing with a set of databases far more like dealing with a human or a pet than anything else.</p><p>I’ve no doubt that researchers at <a href="http://research.microsoft.com/apps/video/dl.aspx?id=175450">Microsoft</a> (this is an amazing demo), Apple and Google are spending vast sums to unearth the ideal paradigm for audio web interface. Start-ups, such as <a href="http://www.kickstarter.com/projects/607691307/ubi-the-ubiquitous-computer-voice-activated-and-al-0/posts/303007">Ubi</a>, are vying for a place in the home. So it seems as though we’re close to reaching a point where voice activation might become a viable interface alternative to the screen and manual input that we’ve been used to in recent decades.</p><h4>Being productive with no hands</h4><p>As I pass Smithfield Market, approaching Dose Espresso for my team catch up, I suddenly realise I’ve not looked at the minutes from our last catch up. Now, where are they, I wonder? I hold down the button again.</p><p>Fade.</p><p>Bleep.</p><p>Silence…</p><p>Of course, there’s no immediate way for me to start accessing data in the cloud or surf websites using the audio controls that have helped me manage my day. As I think about it, with contextual social design still buzzing around my mind, I begin suddenly to see what’s going on behind the scenes in apps like Dropbox, Google Drive or even a vanilla web browser. The metatagging, alt text, tabular data, images, downloadable files, clickable links and the means of connecting instantly with people I know depending on their availability — in fact, everything that has emerged through the browser paradigm in the past 20 years — are all unavailable to someone controlling it through voice and ears.</p><p>The more I think about it, the more I realise the browser paradigm, with its <a href="http://www.slideshare.net/orangeup/fundamental-principles-of-usability-and-user-centred-design">emphasis on <em>graphical</em> user iterface</a> is just no good at all for what I’m trying to do here. Some things — like connecting with other people, and using search — are far closer to the natural process of audio control. Others — such as hierarchical file structures, quickly scanning detailed documents or browsing images — are alien to audio control. I worry that efforts to develop a standardised semantic web architecture will be tripped up if designers simply take what emerges and applies it to the spacial web we’re used to.</p><p>The language used by the W3C on its <a href="http://www.w3.org/2001/sw/">Semantic Web</a> project isn’t reassuring:</p><blockquote>but can I see my photos in a calendar to see what I was doing when I took them? Can I see bank statement lines in a calendar?</blockquote><p>It’s very visual. What about can I <em>voice-activatedly hear </em>a forecast of my bank balance at some future date while I’m using a project management app to plan my wedding? Can I <em>voice-activatedly search</em> for a venue, <em>check availability</em> on a certain date and <em>call </em>to book, without — literally — lifting a finger? Now that would be neat.</p><p>Has anyone yet mastered audio user interface design for more complex tasks than using urgent bleeps to help park a car? There are some <a href="http://uxdesign.smashingmagazine.com/2012/09/14/guidelines-designing-audio/">fantastic guides</a> to the design thinking in this area. There are also a number of intriguing experiments into the relationship between information and sound, such as <a href="https://twitter.com/petergregson">Peter Gregson</a> and Daniel Jones’ “<a href="http://thelisteningmachine.org/">The Listening Machine</a>,” or “<a href="http://cybraphon.com/about/">Cybraphon</a>” by <a href="https://twitter.com/surfacepressure">Tommy Perman</a>, <a href="https://twitter.com/SimonKirby">Simon Kirby</a> and Ziggy Campbell. Yet it looks like it could be decades before a useful, voice-driven AUI could become a genuine alternative to the GUI that we’ve become dependent on.</p><p>My only hope at this time is that it isn’t going to take 20 years before the design principles for an audio web are settled. Applying the learnings of all the web design <em>culs de sac</em> of the past should, I hope, allow designers to take shortcuts in the development of the ideal AUI.</p><p>But then, with hindsight, putting share buttons in the right place sounds pretty easy too and that simple thing took five years alone.</p><p>I use the older, more robust form of audio user interface to order a double espresso.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2669cd13b5a7" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/i-m-h-o/designing-for-an-audio-web-2669cd13b5a7">Designing for an audio web</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/i-m-h-o">I. M. H. O.</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>