<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Peter Merritt on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Peter Merritt on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@psychoanalysisforartists?source=rss-d8e8331f118------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sun, 22 Nov 2026 09:02:43 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@psychoanalysisforartists/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Freud’s Theory of Dreams: A Psychoanalytic Tool to Investigate Consciousness]]></title>
            <link>https://psychoanalysisforartists.medium.com/freuds-theory-of-dreams-a-psychoanalytic-tool-to-investigate-consciousness-6b3d0aafbef?source=rss-d8e8331f118------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6b3d0aafbef</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[psychoanalysis]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cognitive-science]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[consciousness]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[dreams]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[freud]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Peter Merritt]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 24 Oct 2020 23:50:39 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-10-24T23:50:39.825Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>It is commonly regarded that Freud’s <em>Interpretation of Dreams </em>is his magnum opus, as he himself believed it to be. The contents of its more than 600 pages compromises what would establish the framework of psychoanalysis in far reaching scope, for not only did Freud lay out a comprehensive and erudite elucidation of the nature of dreams and how they can be of crucial importance in revealing unconscious desires of the individual who has them, he also went about constructing a comprehensive model of the mind as well a methodology of how to understand not only what he called the unconscious, but consciousness as such. <em>The Interpretation of Dreams </em>concerns far more than dreams.</p><p>It was the professional intention to cure neurotic symptoms that led Freud to explore the unconscious and the nature of dreams, but in the process of working on <em>The Interpretation of Dreams </em>he had constructed a brilliant and complex theory of mind and everyday psychology. He found listening to the dreams of his patients a profound tool to investigate the meaning and source of a</p><p>valuable was the way the symptoms of psychoneuroses provided a window to look at the nature and sense of dreams as such. Following this train of thought would provide the impetus for a radical exposition that a dream can mimic the symptoms of the neurotic, and that dreams were in fact blueprints to understand the functioning of normal conscious processes. In recognizing that dreams where sense making activities of the mind that underwent certain mental processes in order to be produced, he inferred that they correlated with the psychic activity of waking consciousness, and could thus provide a sturdy basis of examining much broader issues of human psychology and the mechanisms that enable it.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/433/1*SVlxIZ6Q17d_U7S9JGaDcA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Dreams allow you to see the same thing in a different language</figcaption></figure><p>In Freud’s earlier work, most prominently known by his 1895 <em>Studies on Hysteria </em>which he co-wrote with Joseph Breuer, he had been primarily concerned with the idea that neuroses and their manifestations where the result of early childhood traumas, predominantly of a sexual nature, that had been repressed and needed the work of the “talking cure” to uncover lost memories in order to relieve symptoms. However in 1896 he abandoned his “seduction theory”, and became preoccupied with finding a way to explain psychopathological phenomena via a neurophysiologic model of the mind. One year prior, the same year he had published his work on hysteria and simultaneously started distancing himself from Breuer, he sent an unfinished paper to his new confidant, Wilhelm Fliess, which would come to be known as the “Project for a Scientific Psychology”. In this audacious paper Freud hoped to work out how physiological processes of the brain correspond with psychological experience, especially how specific neuronal processes receive and regulate excitations of energy. His early work dedicated to psychopathology had, in essence, now given him the tools at his disposal to interrogate general psychology. However, his confidence in the theory of quantifying human psychology in this way quickly waned. Inferential deductions without empirical proof seemed futile, and so, although still devoted to finding material and scientific correlates to neurotic symptoms, he became more and more preoccupied with the investigation of non-localized, purely mental phenomena.</p><p>Around 1887, partially due to his continued correspondence with Fliess, Freud’s thought moved increasingly to the theory of mind. The ‘Project for a insufficient technology at the time. However scant in cohesive explanations of mental phenomena as the “project” had been, it would in fact be an establishing text whose preliminary and not fully worked out ideas would procure the majority of his future formulations concerning the psychological mechanisms and processes of the mind. In the course of the project, he had briefly outlined two foundational structures that govern consciousness and behavior in both the pathological and “normal” mind.</p><p>The ‘Project’ had postulated two operations that functioned as crucial foundations for the invention of psychoanalysis, the “constancy principle” and the “primary and secondary processes”. Throughout the corpus of Freud’s work, no two general concepts would be more important than the twin notions of the drive and the unconscious, and these were the seeds of these tremendous bodies of thought. The “constancy principle” has to do with the regulation of sexual drives, where pleasure derives from quiescence of an over abundance of ‘libido’, or energy that causes tension. The human organism attempts to regulate this balance. Freud’s formulations of this function is the basis on which the later formulations of the “pleasure principle” and the “reality principle” would derive, and would become instrumental in completing his “drive theory”.</p><p>Perhaps most importantly, the formulation of the primary processes and secondary processes threw light on the as of yet to be named mechanisms of the “id” and the “ego” and how their interaction formed the unconscious through mechanisms of repression and regulation. This would give Freud the working hypothesis onto which he could construct and substantiate his theories of dream formation. It is the inadequacies of the secondary process of Ego and its incapability to cope with the discharge or cathexis of libinal drives that make coping with everyday reality difficult. The reality principal of the secondary process is not always able to keep the drives of the pleasure principal of the primary process at bay, and neurotic symptoms, the parapraxes, jokes, and especially dreams, Freud found, were unconscious phenomena that exposed the primary process thoughts in the midst of the secondary process thoughts of everyday life.</p><p>Dreams were especially well suited to understanding the coping mechanisms between the innate instinctual urges of the primary process and of</p><p>the secondary processes which attempt to hold sway over them precisely because the secondary process, the one we contend with most directly in waking life, is thoroughly out of commission during sleep. Freud’s famous dictum that “The interpretation of dreams is the royal road to a knowledge of the unconscious activities of the mind” would forever be a guiding principal that he adhered to.</p><p>Freud’s most generalized and pervasive idea about dreams is that they are the disguised fulfillments of wishes, especially wishes that arise from the primary process but have been suppressed by the secondary process. That is, they are unfulfilled primary process wishes that stem from inner drives and are disguised via repression. Freud found that in listening to the dreams of his patients, and especially his own dreams, that it was clear that desires which would never be appropriate to think of, or indeed act upon during the day, were made expressly clear in the recitation of a dream. But dreams, as he was at pains to make clear the already obvious, are never coherent, and seem not to follow any logic we are accustomed to. That which presents itself in a dream, whether it be an image, a person or idea, is not necessarily the wish itself, even if it fulfills <em>a </em>wish by virtue of it appearing in the first place. To Freud however, this makes perfect sense, for if a wish was to appear exactly as it is perceived in the dream, then there would be no difference between dream thought and waking thought, or primary and secondary processes, if there were a one to one correlation. Anyone who has ever dreamt, and that is the whole of civilization, knows that dreams are at once both absurd, but also reflect pieces of what has once been experienced in ones waking life.</p><p>Besides wish fulfillment, the other most universal aspect of a dream is that it transforms a mere thought, or a collection of thoughts, into a hallucinated experience. Freud observed a dream of a man who saw his brother in a box, ‘Kasten’, and upon reciting the dream further associated the box as a cupboard ‘Schrank”. The dream content of “my brother was in a box” was transformed into the experience of the wish that his brother ‘ought to restrict himself’ fulfilled by the same object perceived in the dream. This is most clearly seen in dreams involving somatic needs imagined in dreams such as drinking water, for one may indeed be thirsty in one’s slumber. Or for that matter the nature of many dreams of children, such as the observation Freud made when his daughter Anna mumbled about “stwawbewwies”5 in her sleep after being deprived of them in the day preceding. Childhood and infantile dreams are often an ‘open to pass right through into the content of the dream, where the ‘repressed wish has shown itself stronger than the censorship’, they are ‘open fulfillment of a patient wakes from the terror that has not been sufficiently disguised. Still, usually, an unconscious wish, be it pleasurable or horrifying, is symbolized dramatically different in sleep and waking life.</p><p>The crucial point that effectively bridges the logical gap between that which is wished by the primary process, and that which is fulfilled by the dream is that, due to the wish being constitutive of the primary process, that of the innate and instinctual forces of the mind — the wish and its fulfillment are not two entities but in fact one during the dream, as is illustrated in the dream of the man’s brother in the box being equivalent to the desire for his brother to restrict himself. In a way, one can say the primary process, or the Id, is the stupid mental function, it makes no distinction between a desire and its satisfaction and does not understand that there is an inherent gap between wanting something and having it. For the primary process, the wish and it’s fulfillment are a uniform entity, they are glued together, and since during sleep there are no hurdles imposed by the logical, reality principal driven secondary process of the Ego, the imagined or hallucinatory fulfillment of the wish can take any form. The expression of the wish fulfillment in the dream is akin to the froth on the wave of the primary process wish, it goes along for the ride with nothing to say that its peculiar representation is incoherent or wrong, no matter how absurd its imagery may be to us upon waking. This is one reason why, upon returning to the logic of waking reality, not only are we often startled or amazed by our dreams, but also often repudiate them. ‘their fulfillment will give (the dreamer) no pleasure, but just the opposite; and experience shows that this opposite appears in the form of dreamer himself is not.</p><p>This raises the following queries; if our wish is disguised, how do we know it exists or is related to any wish in reality, and vice-versa, if we don’t have knowledge of the wish how is there anything to be disguised? Since it is not comprehensible to us in a normal conscious state, how is it of use to either the dreamer or the analyst? The discrepancies and incompatible nature of these premises understandably make objections raised both by the laymen and the psychology professional understandable, but, as is so admirable of Freud, he went through rigorous work to foresee objections, understand them, and if he saw his ideas accurate, defend against these objections with the most exhaustive of arguments. His painstaking work in overcoming this rugged theoretical terrain began by explicating how it was that primary process and secondary process thought came to coincide with each other and result in the dream. That is, in order to explain why truths about our innermost desires were expressed in dreams, he had to explain how the content of the dream came to be disguised in its particular fashion in the first place. In simpler terms, what is the content of the dream and how does it arise from us? This process of arising is what Freud calls “the dream work” for which he devotes the entire sixth chapter of <em>The Interpretation of Dreams.</em></p><p>The “dream work” is the process by which dreams come to be manifested in the experience of the dream itself through mechanisms of repression that transform and reconstruct past experiences that make sense to us in waking life into distorted dream forms that lack coherent sense or meaning. He contended that all dreams went through a process of being disguised and that it is the dream work that is responsible for this. He termed the content that the dreamer experiences during the dream, or more aptly the content that the subject remembers and dictates during analysis, as the “manifest content” or “dream content” and deemed the conscious thoughts, past experiences and concepts from which the manifest content of the dream derived the “latent content” or “dream thoughts”. He associates these two defined and distinct forms of content with the primary and secondary processes, respectively. The manifest content of the dream is not only a wish fulfillment, but an entire context made up of an amalgamation of real life events, identifications and ‘day’s residue’9 that constitute the latent dream thoughts. A repressed wish comes into contact in the preceding day with an associative thought or experience, but has not been worked through by the secondary process and so is revived in sleep as proxy of the wish via the primary process. Dream work is needed for the wish to find transformed into manifest dream content of a radically different nature, then it should logically follow that there should be findings for how, and through what particular method these transformations take place.</p><p>Freud contended that, since manifest dream content appeared in an entirely different logic than the dream thoughts they derive from, that is was less akin to the transformation that is indicative of language translation, where one word or idea attempts to represent a similar meaning or connotation in a different language or form, but that the transformation that takes place during the dream work is in fact an entire rearranging of the sense, or logic that an idea is originally perceived as in the latent dream thought. He contended that the relationship between the dream content and it’s thought was more akin to the nature of a rebus, wherein components of a word or phrase must be totally rearranged in order to understand the logic, or sense of the rebus. Dream formation is similar to the process of solving a rebus.</p><p>Freud defined four principal mechanisms of dream formation, or dream work. He termed them condensation, displacement, representation (That which appears in the dream content for which we can only infer its representation and which Ella Sharpe prefers to emphasize the distinct categories of dramatization and symbolization)and secondary revision (Or secondary elaboration).</p><p>It is impossible to make a one to one analogy between manifest content and its latent counterpart, and epitomizes the anti-logic that prevails in primary process thinking and makes it so alien to how we consciously perceive that which arises in secondary processes.</p><p>Condensation does exactly what its name implies. It condenses many different images, concepts, people, objects, identifications, or any other conscious thoughts into a single element (or at least smaller set of elements) of dream content. In one particularly curious vignette of a patients dream, especially for its linguistic usage, Freud describes an analysis he conducted in French where the dreamer had perceived Freud himself as an Elephant. Upon inquiring</p><p>Because <em>trompe </em>means trunk in French, the dreamer had interpreted his latent thought that Freud was a swindler or intentionally deceiving him into an image that A. melded “trunk” to “deception” as components of the word <em>trompez, </em>resulting in the image of an elephant, and B. utilized the common theme of an elephant being a representative of reliance, confidence and trust, as in the phrase “elephants never forget”. An additional property of condensation is that it becomes evident when we consider how manifest content has quantitatively less content than the multitudes of latent content it pulls and derives itself from.</p><p>Displacement in some ways epitomizes the disguising mechanism of the dream work. It is the substitute of one thought or emotion for a radically different one, where for example, in Freud’s case of ‘Little Hans’, the small boy’s fear of horses was interpreted as him being afraid of his father, or more specifically, the looming castration of his father. He had displaced his father for the figure of a horse. The substitution of one idea or image is made possible by a chain of associations, as can be seen when the elephant in the aforementioned dream stands in for Freud via association both figurative and literal. In so far as one idea or person can be substituted for another, displacement is very much akin to the phenomenon of transference in the clinical setting, where for instance, the analyst could represent one’s father, to use but one example.</p><p>Representation is the transformation of thoughts, which are invariably of many different mediums (things, words, feelings) to ocular imagery. The word “medium” is used here to invoke Freud’s own observation of the parallels made between classical aesthetics contention between poetry and visual art and the uncooperative and difficult procedure the dream work must contend with in the creation of representations. The visual arts are inherently limited in the scope of their conveyance, or representation of ideas since they do not have all the nuanced capabilities of poetry or prose. In his <em>Introductory Lectures on Psychoanalysis </em>Freud declares ‘It is clear that this achievement is not an easy one. To form some idea of its difficulties, let us suppose that you have undertaken the task of replacing a political leading article in a newspaper by a series of illustrations. You will thus have been thrown back from alphabetic writing to picture writing.’13 Dream representations are inherently abstract and ‘watered-down’14 versions of concrete ideas, to use Freud’s words. The analogy to art is an especially cogent one, especially when considering the numerous times Freud points out that dreams are predominantly visual experiences.</p><p>In so far as dreams are to a large extent visual and hallucinatory, the two variations of representation that Freud regards as ubiquitous, namely symbolism and dramatization, can be clearly understood through the elaborations of Ella Sharpe with her perceptive visual analogies. It should be noted that these two distinct elements of representation do not have the extraordinarily difficult dream work process of representation in general as elucidated above, the reasons for which will be made clear.</p><p>Symbolism is the expression of an idea or concept in a distinct, predominantly pictorial form. Where an object comes to stand for something else in a disguised form, similar to instances of displacement. The difference<br>however, is that symbolism tends to concern basic, primal or even ancient elements of human existence, such as life, death and sexual reproduction and urges. This is why symbols in dreams tend to be stable, or fixed visual imagery that reappear in dreams. Crucially, Freud contends that similar symbols appear universally in various people, if not everyone. This is because Freud believes they are manifestations of invariant human origins. These images are part of our shared ancestry, and so thus not only have a fixed meaning for one dreamer, but also have the same meaning among all dreamers. To use classical examples, a phallus is conveyed as an umbrella in all instances of an umbrella in dreams, or a room can represent motherly love. The exceptional implications of this theory is that not only does symbolism arise from latent dream thoughts and experience as do the other dream mechanisms, but on the contrary, symbolism arises innately from the unconscious, primordial Id, and proceeds from these inherited ideas to all the derivative ideas that can be constitutive of dream life and indeed waking life. This is but one way to see clearly how unconscious dream elements influence conscious experience, for which will be expanded upon later. Ella Sharpe takes a more extreme view than Freud. ‘Symbolism occurs in one direction only, namely, from the unconscious mind’ . This is intuitively at odds with Freud’s claim, for how could something like an umbrella originate anywhere else but the conscious, secondary process experience, since although it may be a universal symbol, the umbrella is a relatively recent invention that cannot be considered in light of ancient ancestry. Due to its generalized acceptance by both the primary and secondary processes, the labor of symbolism dream work is a considerably straightforward operation.</p><p>Dramatization is the ‘representation in the manifest dream of an action or a situation which the dream mechanisms evolve from the latent thoughts. A film of moving pictures is projected on the screen of our private inner cinema’ and is ‘done predominantly by visual images’</p><p>representation as such, with its difficulties’ dictating the concrete, Sharpe’s analogy to a film is insightful because films have the capacity to transpose literal descriptions and narrative more effectively than a still picture or image.</p><p>Secondary revision is the process in which the content of dreams organize themselves to form an explicit and intact whole.</p><p>Having established how dream formation takes place, how does the knowledge of this process facilitate an understanding of its correlation with unconscious truths about why we behave the way we do? Furthermore, what does it say about the nature of waking consciousness? In order to make sense of this gargantuan problem of consciousness let us first reflect on how these understandings concerning dream work factor into clinical psychoanalytic practice.</p><p>Psychoanalysis is first and foremost an act of speech on behalf of the analysand. A dream has to be formulated before it can be interpreted and chains of association connect dreams to unconscious wishes and desires. A working knowledge of the mechanisms of condensation and displacement in dreams can allow us to clinically understand how the symptoms of the analysand have come to be via the workings between the primary and secondary process, but how?</p><p>By looking at the primary and secondary processes as a two way street we can understand how dreams are a reflection of the same structure of a symptom. The secondary processes of conscious life and the symptoms manifested during it are attempts to regulate the primary processes. Freud contends that condensation and displacement are mechanisms of distortion that govern the conditions of consciousness and the problems one encounters in it. In his ‘Five Lectures’ he states ‘The dream-work is a special case of the effects produced by two different mental groupings on each other — that is, of the consequences of mental splitting; and it seems identical in all essentials with the process of distortion which transforms the repressed complexes<br>into symptoms where there is unsuccessful repression.’17</p><p>Some thoughts only come to us in our dreams, which would never arise in waking life. This is the reason why analysts must privilege dreams. One cannot, after explaining a dream, ask, “what was I doing in the dream?” The dream WAS the doing. A dream is, in this way, a pure symptom. It is an indisputable repressed desire that has only been allowed to express itself in the dream. Dreams reveal a truth by their very nature. Because the reciting of a dream is a reciting of a disguised wish, they are important tools that allow for a specific reading of symptoms.</p><p>Additionally, dreams provide evidence for the premise that our disguised wishes in dreams derive from unresolved issues because they have a tendency to repeat themselves. They reveal that which has come to affect the analysand historically. Often people have dreams that have appeared since child hood, and so it is important for dreams to come out because they may reveal constructions that shed light on the individuals entire course of existence that the talk concerning present day issues would never allow to be revealed. The crucial point is that upon noticing dreams that repeat themselves the analyst can see similarities to an individual’s life history and the repetitions of their symptoms.</p><p>In Freud’s famous “Theatre Dream” a women patient had been distraught over her friend Elise’s late engagement to a great man. In the patients dream she was at the theatre with her husband who informed her that Elise and her husband did not go as they could only purchase three bad seats for the two of them. Elise was three months her junior. The number of tickets directly correlated to her fear that she herself had married too early. The central dream thoughts of time and the regret that she had lived her life too hastily are obfuscated in the dream by major displacement. A marriage regretted is the number three regretted in the dream. The dream revealed a truth and a wish that she could never reveal to herself in waking life, that she regretted marrying so early.</p><p>We have seen how dreams can allow for reflection upon aspects of ones life that could otherwise never be unearthed, but are still left with a question. Does unconscious content only shine light on consciousness at the time of manifesting, as in dreams and parapraxes, or do dreams and the unconscious go along for the continual ride of consciousness itself? If mechanisms of dream work turn latent thought into unconscious manifest content, does it follow suit that it works in reverse? Do condensation and displacement turn the unconscious conscious? The feasibility of Freud’s dream work theory must in some way derive its substantiation from a conception of the mind and human consciousness that is more general. Its theory must be scrutinized in reverse. In order to take the primary process at face value, we must look at it through the only way we consciously can, the secondary process.</p><p>When considering this in light of the distinctions between manifest and latent content, it is possible to see how there is a two-way road that traverses between manifest content and dream thoughts.</p><p>In the “project for a scientific psychology” Freud put forth that the mental apparatus of the secondary process must submit to the primary process as a rule, but that during conscious experience our mind attempts to inhibit the primary processes in favor of the illusion of control allowed us by the secondary process and a good cathexis of the Ego.</p><p>Dream thoughts and the conscious ideas they derive from are not synonymous with conscious perception in waking life. Dreams are a hallucination of a wish, but waking existence is also a hallucination that constricts all of our mental faculties from revealing themselves. What we perceive is not all that we get.</p><p>Consciousness ‘requires a criterion from elsewhere (the primary process) in order to distinguish between <em>perception </em>and <em>idea</em>.’</p><p>‘<em>The information of the discharge from ω </em>(conscious perception<em>) is thus</em></p><p><em>the indication of quality or of reality for ψ </em>(Ego, or consciousness as</p><p>such).’</p><p>If the wished-for object is abundantly cathected, so that it is activated in a hallucinatory manner, the same indication of follows too as in the case of external of reality discharge or perception.’</p><p>So, although what we perceive as our conception of experience in everyday life has the feeling of primacy during wakefulness, it is in fact only a condition that is a portion of our overall mental life, which establishes itself only in so far as it has managed to limit our primary processes to a suitable level of constraint. Jacques Lacan, speaking about the anachronistic relationship between the latent content of consciousness in correlation to its subjugations of unconscious thought for which it derives and is always inundated, states that ‘When we speak of the unconscious processes coming into consciousness, we are indeed obliged to place consciousness at the exit, whereas perception, with which it is in fact closely bound up, is to be found at the entrance.’</p><p>That is to say that, for an object perceived in reality to become conscious, it first has to undergo the process by which the primary function allows it to emerge in the secondary process. Here we can see that the same mechanisms of the dream work are also with us in waking life. This statement holds profound connotations to how we should further consider human consciousness.</p><p>Bibliography</p><p>Freud, S. ‘</p><p>Works of Sigmund Freud, Volume I, Ed. J. Strachey, Vintage, London, 2001.</p><p>Freud, S. <em>The Interpretation of Dreams, </em>(1900), Standard Edition of the Complete Works of Sigmund Freud, Vol. IV, Ed. J. Strachey, Vintage, London, 2001.</p><p>Freud, S. <em>The Interpretation of Dreams, </em>(1900), Standard Edition of the Complete Works of Sigmund Freud, Vol. V, Ed. J. Strachey, Vintage, London, 2001.</p><p>Freud, S. ‘Five Lectures on Psycho-analysis,’ (1910), Standard Edition of the Complete Works of Sigmund Freud, Vol. XI, Ed. J. Strachey, Vintage, London, 2001.</p><p>Freud, S. <em>Introductory Lectures on Psycho-Analysis</em>, (1915–1916), Standard Edition of the Complete Works of Sigmund Freud, Vol. XV, Ed. J. Strachey, Vintage, London, 2001.</p><p>Lacan, J. Book II. <em>The Ego in Freud’s Theory and in the Technique of Psychoanalysis, </em>(1954–55), Ed. J.-A. Miller, Trans. S. Tomaselli, W.W. Norton &amp; Co., New York, 1988.</p><p>Sharpe, E. <em>Dream Analysis, </em>(1937), Hogarth Press Ltd, London, Reprinted Karnac, London, 1988.</p><p>Project for a Scientific Psychology,’ (1895), Standard Edition.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=6b3d0aafbef" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Feminine Jouissance does not exist.]]></title>
            <link>https://psychoanalysisforartists.medium.com/feminine-jouissance-does-not-exist-268845accea9?source=rss-d8e8331f118------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/268845accea9</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[lacanian-psychoanalysis]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[feminism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[female-empowerment]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[psychoanalysis]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[lacan]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Peter Merritt]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 24 Oct 2020 05:54:36 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-10-24T05:54:36.957Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>‘The unconscious is structured like a language.’</strong></p><p>There you have it ladies and gentleman, that’s what Lacan said, right there in his twentieth seminar. I could stop here but I believe there are some items to be clarified. Ill let Lacan go on: ‘On that basis, language is clarified…by being posited as the apparatus of jouissance.’[1]</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/627/1*KHLLckjlukGkMTL0JrX0qw@2x.jpeg" /></figure><p>What I am going to say is a bit provocative, that Lacan’s famous seminar on feminine sexuality has little to with the matter, and there is no such thing as “feminine jouissance”. Instead, there is knowledge; something feminine sexuality has a great deal to say about. Lacan is talking about knowledge in seminar XX, knowledge with a capital “NO”. In many places Lacan shows us that there is a failure in how language installs itself as knowledge, which is to say as jouissance.</p><p>Our placement in language is a fundamental trauma; so much so that I will argue it is THE form of castration, overriding the Oedipus Complex itself as the nucleus of psychosexual development. The trauma of language resides in-between the symbolic and the real, and seminar twenty is an audacious attempt to articulate how this trauma is synonymous with the arrival of sexuation that is nothing less than human consciousness itself, that which is predicated on the disjunction with the Other.</p><p>Knowledge does not properly satiate us. We need more pleasure still! Modes of jouissance are constructed to establish supplementary epistemophilia; we insist there must be more, out there, somewhere! God only knows where that is! This is why I believe Lacan states ‘The true aims at the real’[2]. This knowledge we so desperately seek in the form of truth guides us with an injunction: “it must exist!” Lacan makes this explicit: ‘Doesn’t this jouissance one experiences and yet knows nothing about put us on the path of ex-sistence?’[3]He demarcates our grandest questions about existence with a single dash — a tiny dash that gives us a great deal of worry, an epistemological gap that continues to cause us great distress.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/740/1*K2h3_z8qLTVPGuFHwwhk6Q.jpeg" /><figcaption>Playing for keeps</figcaption></figure><p>But Lacan insists that it is only in this failure of knowledge that anything meaningful can ever be expressed, and he will carry this idea with him throughout the whole of <em>Encore</em> to describe what speaking beings produce, namely desire by means of jouissance ‘that shouldn’t be/could never fail. That is the correlate of the fact that there’s no such thing as a sexual relationship, and it is the substantial aspect of the phallic function.’[4] For Lacan, the question of sexuation is a question of knowledge acquisition and its limits to approach truth– for even our first person knowledge, designated as <em>Connaissance, </em>that construction of knowledge par-excellence of the phallus, is always a <em>méconnaissance</em>, a misunderstanding of the foundations of ones own subjectivity that always runs the risk of falling off the precipice of a “no-ledge”.</p><p>We don’t want to fall off this ledge, so we make up nifty tricks to overcome it, the niftiest of solutions? It must come from the Other! There must be one who has this Other Jouissance that we know nothing about! You in this room know what I mean when I say the Other, but the miraculous thing is — so does everyone else, and they know where to find it! We see this all the time with religion, with science, you name it! As analysts, we most evidently see it in the clinic, albeit cloaked by repression and anxiety.</p><p>For Marie Cardinal, in her testimony of her analysis, <em>The Words to Say It</em>, she thought this knowledge was to be found in her mOther. Cardinal takes pains to describe her drawn-out bout with constant vaginal bleeding and the analysis that most miraculously allowed it to cease, and gives an example of the knowledge, that is to say the jouissance, that is specific to the feminine and it must be said, could fundamentally never have been written by a man. In analysis, she re-discovers the torturous relationship she had to her mother, whose abusive words left an impression so traumatic that it had to be painfully repressed. How was it repressed? Into the body, and it is predominantly out of the body that it would manifest itself again and again as a visible, unending conflict between the knowledge she holds within her, and that which can not be put to words. In fact, it is only upon putting it into words, transfiguring her jouissance into signifiers that aim at the Real, that the bleeding stops. This case is quite suitable to discuss the mechanisms of feminine knowledge, and the crux of the matter, that odd reading assignment we are given as analysts: jouissance itself, the text that lies between a subject’s truth, and their knowledge.</p><p>Lacan tells us this is our job, and there is a rare, almost mystifying passage in Freud’s 1924 essay “A supplement to the Theory of Sexuality” where he takes up Lacan’s advice if you will, he investigates knowledge in relation to sexuation: ‘for both sexes in childhood only one kind of genital organ comes into account — the male. The primacy reached is not therefore a primacy of the <em>genital</em>, but of the <em>phallus</em>.’ This is a rare occasion for Freud, for throughout his corpus, even when he used the adjective ‘phallic’, he still implied the genital organ. This sentence is immediately followed by one of Freud’s many disappointments: ‘Unfortunately we can describe this state of things only as it concerns the male child; the corresponding processes in the little girl are not sufficiently known to us.’ Curiously enough, this same paragraph includes Freud’s allusion to an ‘epistemological impulse’[5] on the behalf of the little boy to expect ‘the same thing in other people’. In these passages of Freud’s we find three key elements to the limits of his exposition on the topic of psychosexual development: the inability to conceptualize the abstract function of the phallus, (albeit with the suggestion that it may need to be), an extremely limited grasp on feminine desire, and the aspiration of, but failure to explore the ways in which sexual drives constitute the acquisition of knowledge. Lacan picks up where this paper left Freud on that Dark Continent he thought women inhabited. As to the first failure of Freud’s that he famously left to Princess Marie Bonaparte, ‘<em>Was will das Weib?</em>’[6], a question that suggests men know what they want, and indeed already have what troubles them. In Seminar XX, Lacan shifts this logic with a phenomenological spin, suggesting that sexuation is conferred on the basis of “having” or “being” the phallus. However, by “having” he does not mean “possessing” as Freud did with the literal Penis, and by being he does not mean “is”.</p><p>Instead, sexuation for Lacan, in so far as he capitulates to any actual conceptualization of it (which I argue he never really does), gets woven together by means of various philosophical principles in order to formulate an ontological schema that serves to correct Freudian drive theory by examining its epistemological tenets, in particular his views on female sexuality. To be frank, these needed some straightening out. In “Female Sexuality” Freud stated that bisexual dispositions manifest ‘much more plainly in the female than in the male.’[7]And then in 1933, with charming school boy wit, he exclaims to an audience all too keen to hear, that in keeping with their narcissistic investment, women prefer to be passively in the position of “being” loved rather than doing it, pardon my French. Putting aside that this would be followed up by a quaint fabrication of history, that the only thing women had contributed to society was knitting[8] to compensate for their un-decorative pubic hair — it would seem Lacan latched onto Freud’s tacit sexual phenomenology.</p><p>The “being” Freud described is a modality of knowledge for Lacan. To be precise, it is a ‘<em>Rapport objectal’</em><strong><em>[9]</em></strong> to a semblance of the phallus. The phallus, being a ‘pure signifier’[10] in the words of Paola Mieli, is something that no one, not even Freud’s little boy “has” as such. And if woman is indeed a confused and Dark Continent, it is because the conditions that womanliness is predicated on has less to do with a body of land (a piece of property for Freud to own it would seem) and more to do with a “body” of knowledge.</p><p>Referring to his 1972 lecture given in Milan, Lacan goes on to tell his audience that ‘the lady analysts’, ‘haven’t contributed one iota to the question of feminine sexuality. There must be an internal reason for that, related to the structure of the apparatus of jouissance.’[11]</p><p>What a preposterous statement for Lacan to make, and yes, the Italian ladies certainly took notice! But, let us remember that when a great thinker says something preposterous, there is probably good reason. This is because the only way to say anything about woman is to necessarily invoke phallic logic, which does nothing for feminine jouissance, since their “no-ledge” extends infinitely beyond the phallus. Lacan says you can only write “<em>le femme”</em>, ‘at the level at which woman is truth, why one can only half-speak of her.’[12] The literary provocation Lacan invents on the blackboard for which I have appropriated, “Woman”, is an epistemological exercise to help correct that other idea of Freud’s, that all the ladies are “more” bisexual than the lads.</p><p>Lacan says what everybody already knows: that women are better philosophers of desire, so much so that they “make [the Other] desire”[13], to quote Colette Soler, who, in her essay “What does the unconscious say about Women?” states ‘the unconscious does not know everything, but what it knows is sufficient for us to analyze women.’[14] For women, it turns out there’s a great deal the unconscious knows, it knows it is a “body” of knowledge, in fact, the Womanphilosophizes with every inch of this flexible “body”!</p><p>There is a crude and vulgar joke that a psychoanalytic colleague, a woman mind you, told me: “What bleeds for five days and doesn’t die?”</p><p>Marie Cardinal, after spending most of her life bleeding, both with blood and with repressed desire (no-ledge), went to an analyst who told her in no uncertain terms that he had no interest in her medical problems! She had to express her anguish somehow, and after a bit of psychoanalytic finagling, she finally chose words, after all what else could she choose? However, before she could make this conscious choice, the Real of the body did it for her!</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*f86y84lvZpXiUuX9ithRvg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Knowledge herself</figcaption></figure><p>Lacan says, ‘there is nothing more philosophical than materialism.’ [15] And what is the body other than material? In a word, women are the ultimate philosophers of the Real.</p><p>If I may, let me add an addendum to this brilliant statement, the best I have come across to explain the Real. The Real is that which we cannot see, hear, know, or speak but we all know it is out there, no matter what the scientists will have you believe, it ex-ists. The so-called “hard sciences” must wax over that which we cannot know with their own discursive, coercive mind you — theory, and in this way they are excellent philosophers, in so far as a philosophical theory (for example if it is poorly thought out), can be more <em>philosophical </em>than it is good. Scientists plaster on philosophy to explain away the Real, to sweep it aside.</p><p>If we can say one thing about the feminine and its corollary modes of jouissance, it is that the feminine is that which waxes philosophical over the Real with what? Knowledge. What differs this knowledge from the phallic logic of the “hard” scientists is that the multitudes of feminine jouissance do not have such an exigency for coherence, and take for granted the primacy of the not-all of knowledge. I venture Lacan agrees that we should be grateful for this. For the women ‘make the speaking being speak.’[16] In other words, femininity is the agent provocateur of the Real. If there were a feminine jouissance, which there is not, it would be called the “jouissance of the Real of the ‘body’ of knowledge”. Metaphysics, since the birth of the natural sciences, has tried to be a “science of being”. The best scientist of being it turns out, is woman.</p><p>Bibliography:</p><p>Cardinal, Marie., <em>The Words to Say It.,</em> (1983), Van Vactor &amp; Goodheart, Cambridge, Mass., 1983.</p><p>Freud, Sigmund., ‘The Infantile Genital Organization of the Libido: A Supplement to the Theory of Sexuality.’, <em>Int. J. Psycho-Anal.</em>, 5.,1924.</p><p>Freud, Sigmund., ‘Female Sexuality’. (1931), <em>Sexuality and the Psychology of Love</em>, Touchstone, New York, 1997.</p><p>Freud, Sigmund., ‘Femininity,’ (1933), Standard Edition of the Complete Works of Sigmund Freud, Vol. XXII, Ed. J. Strachey, Vintage, London, 2001.</p><p>Jones, Ernest., <em>Sigmund Freud:Life and Work</em>, (1955), Hogarth Press, London, Vol. 2.,1955.</p><p>Lacan, Jacques., Book 1. <em>On Feminine Sexuality, The Limits of Love and Knowledge, </em>(1972–1973),<em> </em>The Seminar of Jacques Lacan, Book XX, Encore, (Ed. Miller, J.-A.), Norton, London, 1998.</p><p>Mieli, Paola., ‘Femininity and the Limits of Theory’., <em>The Subject of Lacan: A Lacanian Reader for Psychologists., </em>Eds. K.R. Malone &amp; S. Friedlander, SUNY Press, 2000.</p><p>Soler, Colette., ‘What Does The Unconscious Know About Women?’, <em>Reading Seminar XX: Lacan’s Major Work on Love, Knowledge, and Feminine Sexuality”, </em>SUNY Press, Albany, 2002.</p><p>[1] J. Lacan, Book 1. <em>On Feminine Sexuality, The Limits of Love and Knowledge, </em>(1972–1973),<em> </em>The Seminar of Jacques Lacan, Book XX, Encore, (Ed. Miller, J.-A.), Norton, London, 1998, p.55.</p><p>[2] ibid. p. 91.</p><p>[3] Ibid. p. 77.</p><p>[4] ibid. p. 59.</p><p>[5] S. Freud, ‘The Infantile Genital Organization of the Libido: A Supplement to the Theory of Sexuality.’, <em>Int. J. Psycho-Anal.</em>, 5.,1924, 126–127</p><p>[6] E. Jones, <em>Sigmund Freud:Life and Work</em>, (1955), Hogarth Press, London, 1955, Vol. 2 ,p.468.</p><p>[7] S. Freud, ‘Female Sexuality’. (1931), <em>Sexuality and the Psychology of Love</em>, Touchstone, New York, 1997, p. 187.</p><p>[8] *It seems that women have made few contributions to the discoveries and inventions in the history of civilization; there is, however, one technique which they may have invented — that of plaiting and weaving. If that is so, we should be tempted to guess the unconscious motive for the achievement. Nature herself would seem to have given the model which this achievement imitates by causing the growth at maturity of the pubic hair that conceals the genitals. The step that remained to be taken lay in making the threads adhere to one another, while on the body they stick into the skin and are only matted together</p><p>S. Freud, ‘Femininity,’ (1933), Standard Edition of the Complete Works of Sigmund Freud, Vol. XXII, Ed. J. Strachey, Vintage, London, 2001, p. 132.</p><p>[9] J. Lacan, op. cit. p. 92.</p><p>[10] P. Mieli, ‘Femininity and the Limits of Theory’., <em>The Subject of Lacan: A Lacanian Reader for Psychologists., </em>Eds. K.R. Malone &amp; S. Friedlander, SUNY Press, 2000, p. 269.</p><p>[11] J. Lacan, op. cit. pp. 57–58.</p><p>[12] ibid. p. 103.</p><p>[13] C. Soler, ‘What Does The Unconscious Know About Women?’, <em>Reading Seminar XX: Lacan’s Major Work on Love, Knowledge, and Feminine Sexuality”, </em>SUNY Press, Albany, 2002, p. 103.</p><p>[14] J. Lacan, op. cit. p. 99.</p><p>[15] ibid. p. 68.</p><p>[16] Ibid. p. 99.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=268845accea9" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[PEDRO REYES for SFAQ]]></title>
            <link>https://psychoanalysisforartists.medium.com/pedro-reyes-for-sfaq-eeb36e0e3747?source=rss-d8e8331f118------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/eeb36e0e3747</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[art-market]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[psychology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[contemporary-art]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mexican-art]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[therapy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Peter Merritt]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 24 Oct 2020 05:43:36 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-10-24T05:43:36.504Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*2MyoCc6iIcNHfUOKdeK7ZQ.png" /><figcaption>Pedro Reyes, Selected portraits from Citizen-Delegates, 2013. Documentation from his exhibition The People’s United Nations (pUN), Queens Museum, New York City. Photographs courtesy of the artist.</figcaption></figure><p><strong>I first found out about Pedro Reyes’s project the <em>People’s United Nations (pUN) </em>while attending the 2013 Creative Time Summit in New York. There was a booth in the auditorium there for recruiting individuals from all over the world to represent their homeland as part of the exhibition at the Queens Museum, the site where the UN General Assembly met from 1946 through 1950. <em>The People’s United Nations </em>congregated its 150 citizen-delegates for two days in late November of last year.</strong></p><p><strong>Reyes’ contribution at the Creative Time Summit was the organization of conversations between himself and former Bogotá mayor Antanas Mockus Šivickas, who famously introduced mimes to curb traffic accidents in Bogotá, as well as numerous other political endeavors that took cues from art and creative impulses in general. The conversation was entitled “The Absurd and Urban Transformation,” and successfully brought genuine curiosity and playfulness to the very dry bureaucratic problem of tax collection. The conversation culminated with the two of them offering tokens of public resources in the form of sacramental bread to the mouths of audience members.</strong></p><blockquote><strong>Long an admirer of Pedro’s ethics in the form of art projects inspired by psychotherapy, I was now a follower of his aesthetics, which I perceived to be adorations to humanity and the complexities of human psychology and spirituality. The following freeform interview is an attempt to understand the mechanisms behind his therapeutic thought process.</strong></blockquote><p><strong>Can you tell us how you originally came up with the idea for <em>People’s United Nations</em>?</strong></p><p>The dream of making a parallel organization to the UN may be something that I thought since I was a child. I used to read <em>Mafalda</em>, which was a very influential cartoon for several generations in Latin America. Different from Charlie Brown (<em>Peanuts</em>), Mafalda was always commenting on the Vietnam War, the tensions between the Pentagon and the Kremlin, or the dictatorships in Latin America. Her dream was to grow up to become an interpreter at the UN to smooth the exchanges between countries. Many years later I got invited by Larissa Harris to present a project for the reopening of the Queens Museum. The building was the first home of the UN and where many historical events, such as the partitions of Palestine, and North and South Korea were discussed. Two other factors were crucial: the Queens Museum has a special vocation for social practice with a unique community outreach, and Queens is perhaps the most ethnically diverse place on Earth.</p><p><strong>Your work is political, in a direct sense, and yet it seems to work precisely because it is not overtly political. It is transformational rather than political. Can you say something about the positive outcome you hope for with much of your work, especially your project <em>People’s United Nations?</em></strong></p><p>We live in a world where different cultural environments overlap as in a kind of palimpsest. Each cultural environment has its own set of parameters to assign value. My work in general is very optimistic and Panglossian, as in the character from Voltaire’s <em>Candide</em>. It suggests optimism regardless of circumstances, and is very utopian. Dr. Pangloss is someone who speaks all languages with all species, the Latin <em>pan </em>for everything, all, and <em>glossa </em>for a list of words; glossary. <em>People’s United Nations </em>is a totally Panglossian project in the sense that it aims to bring everyone together — one representative from every country in the actual UN. Humor is a very important aspect of all of this. One of the main theses of my work has to do with humor and the way that jokes work. Most jokes have a setup and a punch line. The setup involves something that is wrong or is going in the wrong direction. To tell a joke is a process of things becoming an awkward situation, and the punch line is this shocking delivery far below your expectations. And when something is far below your expectations, when someone is in a ridiculous and embarrassing situation, the way one can best handle such shock and disappointment is with laughter. For instance there is a joke where a guy goes to a doctor and the doctor says to the patient, “Here is your analysis and it says that there is not much time left, only ten.” The patient replies anxiously, “Ten months? Ten weeks? Ten days?” And the doctor says, “No . . . 10, 9, 8, 7, 6, 5 . . .” — you know? You have to have a setup that is a kind of warning and a delivery that is between your expectations of reality and the realpolitik. The way that a joke allows one to deal with disappointment is through laughing. According to biologists, laughing is a kind of reaction where, say, you thought you were being attacked but you realized it was a false alarm, and then a scream is produced that is this kind of a spastic thing that we call laughter.</p><p>What I am trying to do with pieces like <em>p(UN) </em>is reverse the mechanisms of jokes. So you have an extremely optimistic punch line, something that is so far above your expectations that the shock value is a resolution that is extremely, hilariously optimistic. I do that because I believe that the shock value of optimistic projects is something that brings new ideas to life. It is a little bit messianic, but it is based in spontaneity.</p><p><strong>In his book on the psychology of jokes and laughter, Freud says that jokes produce revelations through their technique — creating something that makes sense via the mechanisms of the nonsensical, juxtaposing two conflicting ideas — and in this way jokes are akin to how our unconscious mechanisms make sense in dream displacement, allowing for new interpretations to arise. Can you say something about the thought process of conflict resolution in <em>p(UN)</em>? You say that diplomacy has proved not to work, so you want to try alternative play therapies<em>.</em></strong></p><p>For instance, one of the workshops <em>at p(UN</em>) consists of breaking down the participants in groups of five or six, and then for the first ten minutes everyone has to share the most embarrassing thing about their own country. Then the participants have a workshop where they envision an ideal world where, if they were to open the pages of a newspaper, they are to imagine the polarities were switched around from the worst to the best. For instance, people who were from the Philippines were angry that the Catholic Church had ruined the reproductive rights of women. So then they were able to imagine a joint venture between the Catholic Church and the State to open abortion clinics nationwide, and they expressed this idea though the workshops. Another example emerged when the people of Turkey were embarrassed that they had the highest number of journalists in prison. The reversal of that fact was that Turkish prisons could become journalistic meccas and that a newspaper called the <em>Turkish Prison Times </em>would sweep the Pulitzers. Because really it’s not that farfetched; it’s actually a completely plausible idea. Imagine that you create some kind of network inside a Turkish prison that becomes an online newspaper through which they smuggle their texts. It really could be!</p><p>What I’m trying to do comes from this basic thing that I believe in, that there are two ways to deal with reality. One is to focus on the problem, and the other is to focus on the solution. But the focus on the solution has to be something that is daring. And I do that in sculpture as well. With <em>Disarm </em>and <em>Imagine</em>, a continuation of my project <em>Palas por Pistolas</em>, I transformed seized guns into musical instruments. Turning a machine gun into an electric guitar is a successful, positive transformation. Many of the operations that are underlying my work are basically quite systematic in the sense of identifying an agent of suffering and death and destruction and making a change in polarity where these agents become something extremely positive. For instance, I may do a collage where I turn a tank into kind of a musical-mechanical orchestra on wheels, or I take a drone and I turn it into a dove, and it becomes a drone-dove. Visualizing something positive is a stepping-stone towards that reality. You have to have a vision.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*0z6f2013ysDOBFuOec2ZWg.png" /><figcaption><strong><em>Blueprint plans for Drone Dove, 2013. Courtesy of the artist.</em></strong></figcaption></figure><p><strong>It would seem to me that a concentration of yours is to play with the given polarities of a situation. With projects such as <em>Disarm </em>and</strong> <strong><em>Imagine</em></strong> <strong>you have made a pretty straightforward reversal of polarities, from this extremely negative force of the weapons to this very positive source of the musical instruments. However, it’s a great deal more nuanced with something like</strong> <strong><em>People’s United Nations</em>, where the act is not necessarily reversing or transforming a given situation, that of the UN, but rather presenting viable resolutions that could easily be implanted by the already existing state of affairs. Nonetheless, there is a visceral reaction to the solutions offered through</strong> <strong><em>p(UN), </em>such as the absurd and hilarious ones you have mentioned with the delegates of the Philippines or Turkey. Why do we have this internalized reaction to these great solutions that says, “that’s clever, but it’s totally crazy, too crazy to work”?</strong></p><p>I believe it is because the status quo is insane by nature, how things operate normally is often wrong from the very get-go. What we are used to accepting as normal is in fact insanity. It’s why R.D. Laing would say something along the lines of “perfectly normal people have killed two million people in the last century.” The idea is that you are never going to run out of incredibly wrong things in the world that need to be corrected. They’re everywhere, from energy for communication, or distribution of wealth, everything is wrong.</p><p>For instance, food, when I was doing the catering for <em>People’s United Nations</em>, I wanted to do a kind of prototype dish that could become the staple food for the future, and my rationale for doing this turned into the “GrassWhopper,” which is a hamburger of crickets, of grasshoppers, and if you stick to the most rational solution, this is it! The GrassWhopper is the most kosher thing to grow in this way, because insects such as crickets don’t need refrigeration, and they are pure protein, and no suffering is involved. If a cricket eats 100 grams of grass it becomes 100 grams of protein in its body so it’s a kind of 1:1 translation, whereas a cow has to eat the equivalent of hundreds of football fields to create a single pound of meat. There are so many aspects to illustrate how this food choice is in fact the most rational, economical choice of all. It may look exotic and strange, but that’s only because our regular world is wrong and completely upside down.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/1*wYID3OvT7hssWh-RHUFcgA.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong><em>Disarm, 2013. Instruments made from de-commissioned weapons, Lisson Gallery, London, 2013. Courtesy of the artist and Lisson Gallery, London.</em></strong></figcaption></figure><p><strong>Intuitively we laugh at the GrassWhopper and jump a bit because it sounds disgusting and absurd to our usual sensibilities. However, if you were a super-rigid bureaucrat crunching the data, it would be something where to see this on paper it would be the most pragmatic food solution.</strong></p><p>One of the things that art does best is to bring estrangement. You have to make the familiar strange in order to reveal the arbitrary standards that we live inside of. And you have to make the strange familiar to introduce something new. Monotony is gray. Art brings color, and when it punctures the monotony of the everyday, it creates estrangement. In order to do this you must make the strange familiar and the familiar strange.</p><p><strong>This idea of estrangement is really interesting in the context of <em>People’s United Nations </em>because it seems to be at odds with the espoused mission of the actual United Nations. What I imagine is that the United Nations seeks to be seen in the public imagination as bringing people together to create a common understanding and set of solutions, and in this way presents itself as diametrically opposed to estrangement. So then, the artistic component of <em>p(UN)</em> would seemingly go against that logical, rational, practical ideal of the actual United Nations. I’m trying to contextualize the idea of estrangement within the kind of cultural politics that play out at the UN that supposes a goal of “mutual understanding” and “democracy.”</strong></p><p>But what makes it work has to do with it being not only estrangement; it’s also role-play. Estrangement is one condition present but the reason these individuals felt like they needed to be there, the reason people were so committed to the project, was because of the aspect of role-play, and playing a part that is already inside of them. I was afraid the volunteers would not show up, because this was in New York where people’s time is very coveted, and especially since it was freezing and all the way up at the end of the 7 line in Queens. It was a big request for people to do this for free. But in the end they not only showed up for the first day but they came enthusiastically for the second because they were passionate about it. They really devoted two whole days to this, and these people were all very busy people, important people in their respective fields. I really believe that the reason why they committed was because of the aspect of role-play. The moment that they accepted their roles as delegates, they would fail their countries if they failed to be there. Their countries would not be represented. So they had an honor and a duty to…</p><p><strong>Their identity. Twice removed, and put back again.</strong></p><p>Yes, helped by the fact that they were wearing a badge. I believe a lot in the rich role of props. So they were asked to dress in business attire or their ethnic clothing, just as in the UN, and also they were wearing a badge with their flag and their name. If these same people were just at a party it would be different, but the fact that they became delegates created a kind of atmosphere of respect and admiration for each other, and it was all because of role-play. Estrangement is just a kind of substrata; it is this role-play that brings a certain cohesion to the psychodynamic.</p><p><strong>In some way this role-play becomes a dress-up game where someone becomes themselves again, albeit in the role of their entire country. But of course they were not alone. You have people in character talking to other people in character but the character is themselves.</strong></p><p>In New York everyone is from everywhere, but during <em>p(UN) </em>they were delegates and they were talking on behalf of their nations and their legacies and their cultures. They had to advertise and advocate for their countries. They took it very seriously because they were around others doing the same, which set up opposition that would not exist on the streets of NYC normally. As for coming together with the other delegates in new ways there was a therapist from the school of Milton Erickson doing couple’s therapy, and I had these people from different countries going to this couples therapy and really talking about their long-standing hatred between their two countries to this therapist. There were many other situations where there was socio-drama. I use a lot of psychology, mainly Milton Erickson and Jacob Levy Moreno, founder of psychodrama and socio-drama.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/553/1*DfWwcNnEaHHmy7COxsRTjA.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong><em>Citizen-delegates and other participants of The People’s United Nations (pUN), Drone Dove in foreground and official pUN flag with motto “Hands-on with a vision” in background. Queens Museum, New York City, 2013. Courtesy of the artist.</em></strong></figcaption></figure><p><strong>It seems that the most important thing is that you have made a space for various new psychological states to play out, in this case literally psychological “states”! What strikes me is how seriously the delegates took role-playing. Because in a way it was also a state of play, a universal country of ridiculousness. And it is within this very psychological playground of absurdity that all of this was taken very seriously.</strong></p><p>I believe that the mind loves cognitive dissonance. When you don’t know if it’s real or if it’s a joke, then you’re actually paying attention. And above all, the existence of the two possible interpretations, the coexistence of those two: Is this serious? Is this a joke? I’ve been talking with a neurologist, that I’ve had a long-standing conversation with, about how we get excited by cognitive dissonance. You are playing a role and you are aware that it’s a joke, and at the same time it’s serious. And that is exactly what provides you access. I have these opposing interpretations, that it all has to do with our own meta-theater. The mask frees you to perform roles that otherwise would be unbearable. Because if this were pretending to be serious it could be about worthiness or it could be patronizing, or it could be messianic, but you’re stating, you’re warning, that this is a joke and a game, so then people relax, and precisely because they are relaxed you can talk seriously. If you talk serious straight-talk to people you scare them off. You have to present it as a game for it to become serious; at least that was my framework for this project. In other scenarios there is a demand and a place for earnestness as well, and some aesthetic experiences demand this earnestness. For instance, in <em>Sanatorium </em>at documenta, I had different people coming in, but there always had to be a place for this ambiguity between play and earnestness; it was also a big role-play game. Suddenly I had some serious workshops that had to be conducted in full earnestness. I had a Protestant pastor at documenta who came to give a blessing workshop . . .</p><p><strong>[Laughs]</strong></p><p>Why do you laugh?</p><p><strong>I laugh because it could have only been a Protestant pastor doing such a thing — the Protestants who once swore off aestheticism, and yet he’s doing it in a place that is highly aestheticized. On one hand it’s this very aesthetic experience of the blessing, one probably most associated with the aesthetics of the Catholic Church, but this priest would be reprimanded immediately if he was Catholic. He has traded one aesthetic venue for another . . . for an ethics and aesthetics of earnestness.</strong></p><p>A blessing is something that has to be earnest. It consists of you saying something positive to someone and then complementing that with a physical gesture. Wishing someone good, it’s very powerful. Most importantly, it’s beautiful.</p><p><strong><em>I</em>t’s interesting though that you use a blessing as being exemplary of earnestness in the face of role-play and an open-ended play in general. Presenting serious matters as a game was at the heart of the conversation you had with Antanas Mockus Šivickas at the Creative Time Summit. Can you introduce our readers to this project of Antanas’s and the conversation you two had around it?</strong></p><p>Antanas Mockus is a mathematician, philosopher and used to be the mayor of Bogotá. I was interested in showing a very particular policy that he implemented that increased tax collection by 30% in Bogotá. He created something called “110% for Bogota,” where the citizens of Bogotá went to the tax service office to pay taxes and you could opt for paying 10% more and you could choose where that extra 10% would go. What was most exciting about the project was the idea of empowering people to take part in direct democracy. It was not something that you could do online — you had to go to an office to pay your taxes. He created a casino in these places.</p><p><strong>At the beginning of the talk you remarked that he had “turned the entire city of Bogotá into a game.”</strong></p><p>It was a very sophisticated and whacky game that worked. He has one of the wackiest minds I know. He created this pseudo-casino and people were using this kind of dreidel called a pirinola that you spin, which has six sides and it says things like put one, take one, take two, pass, etc. Every time you bet money you lose or you gain. Antanas is so sophisticated that he created a seven-side pirinola. So when you spin the pirinola, you will end with two faces up, so you have the freedom to choose whether to be selfish or altruistic, and that is how one decides how to spend this public money. The citizens became addicted to this democracy and were going back to the cashier to pay more taxes to get more points and bet more on which projects they wanted funded.</p><p><strong>A fantastic phrase, “addicted to democracy.”</strong></p><p>Yes! So tax collection was then able to be increased 30% because people were very excited to take part in this addictive and fun game to promote paying taxes. And if you paid 10% extra you were given these chips. For whatever you were paying you were given a stack of chips and then you could enter these tables where people were gambling for where the money should go, and you would bet on certain projects, which made the whole process very exciting. People would lose their money and then go pay more taxes to get more chips and get the projects they wanted funded. And these chips resembled and acted as the body of Christ, the <em>hostia</em>, and they said on them “Public Resources-Sacred Resources,” and the citizens were given a small piece of paper with which they had to classify where the resources would be put — social justice, roads, etc. — and he was trying to create a cultural change by saying that stealing public resources was a worse scene than stealing private money. He sees money given as a tax to be holy, and he was teaching people that the biggest proof of love for your country was to pay your taxes. That is how some of the pain of paying taxes could be relieved. You had to be extremely careful about how you handled your public resources. And so that’s why we ended the Creative Time talk by giving away these pieces that resembled the communion bread as if we were in mass. People made a line and we gave it to them in the mouth while saying “public resources, public resources” instead of “body of Christ.”</p><p><strong>This blessing gesture you surprised the audience with was a brilliant mix of play and earnestness. And I believe Antanas beautifully placed it into language when he said at the end that he was convinced that humanity cannot change many of its problems without taking a look at religious traditions. I believe a lot in the importance of religious mythologies, aesthetics, and ethics in art. I am Catholic in this sense.</strong></p><p>I am Catholic but I don’t know what I am now . . .</p><p><strong>But, I bring this up in light of the certain dichotomy and dialectic that was at play, if you will, with the presentation you and Antanas made by giving the body of Christ as if at mass, because this gesture is at once the most serious, and indeed earnest gestures imaginable if you are a believer, but the way it was presented was very playful and childlike, and outside of the usual context it’s given at the Church. It seems to be a fundamentally artistic gesture.</strong></p><p>Antanas would say so. One of his favorite quotes is, “When I don’t know what to do, I ask myself, what would an artist do?” And so now I ask myself, “What would Antanas do?” To me he’s a genuine genius.</p><p><strong>You have said that your artwork has an intention to heal. Can you speak a little bit about this?</strong></p><p>The idea is not creation for creation’s purpose; I believe that art has to have a purpose. At least for me. There is this story of Bashō, the Japanese poet, who is working with an apprentice, walking in a field where there are many dragonflies, and the apprentice says, “Master, I have a haiku,” and the master says, “Okay, tell me.” “A dragonfly takes out its wing and you have a pepper pod.” And the master says, “No, that’s not a good Haiku. You have to say, ‘take a piece of pepper, and add wings and it’s a dragonfly.’” So it has to be something that adds positively and that is a kind of healing process that reveals something beautiful and good, and I’m not afraid of having that ethos, that moral intention in itself. That’s why I insist on, you know, that the work is not completely open-ended, that the work has an intention to heal. It’s about healing.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/832/1*qMjLKOTmFJ6SU28SRJrv7w.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong><em>Drone Dove, 2013, artist rendering. Courtesy of the artist.</em></strong></figcaption></figure><p><strong>In this sense it’s an Aristotelian ethics, something which aims toward the good and the positive rather than inverting things.</strong></p><p>It’s a categorical imperative. And I acknowledge that this is strange within the art world, because in the art world there is a kind of parenthesis or exception where you don’t have to be ethical, you only have to be aesthetical. I don’t know why, but I believe that things have to make the world better. And I don’t believe that all art has to be like that. It’s only something that I ask for most of my own work.</p><p>When I create group activities I hope for collective creativity and spontaneity to produce a spectrum of different ideas. This is coming from Paulo Freire’s <em>Pedagogy of the Oppressed</em>. He is possibly the most important philosopher from Latin America in the 20th century. He states an obvious thing: there are the rich guys and the poor guys, and the rich guys think the poor guys are inferior. You cannot expect change to come from above — you have to teach yourself if you want liberation. One must take responsibility for one’s own liberation process, and when you have a problem you have to socialize the problem. Then I have to turn to Augusto Boal because he takes Freire’s <em>Pedagogy of the Oppressed </em>and he creates <em>Theatre of the Oppressed</em>, wherein what you do enunciate the problem with a one-act play, a short play, with a critical moment where the oppressed face all the oppression, and you don’t have a solution. Then you stop the play at that moment, and you invite the audience to contribute with solutions, but they cannot verbally say the solutions, they have to act them out. The people from the audience come on stage and decide which actor they want to replace and then you have different endings. You have a problem and you have the audience who become “spect-actors” through which you explore all the potential outcomes of the problem. You have a spectrum, a rainbow of solutions.</p><p>In the end it is about the difference between learning and teaching, learning and being taught. Augusto Boal says that the whole problem started with Aristotle because Aristotle was a hack for the government, you know? Aristotle, when he created the idea of tragedy, he was first of all saying, okay, drama is going to be a prescription where we’re going to show what those people should not do, because if they do that they will end up destroyed. So you should not sleep with your mother, etc. . . .</p><p><strong>Yes, of course. This is the double-edged sword of the Aristotelian ethics of the good, “You must do this.”</strong></p><p>Yes, Aristotle alienates the audience by creating the chorus. You don’t need to participate now that there’s a chorus that will sing for you, that will lament when there is disgrace, or will celebrate when there is victory. He alienates reactions from you. He basically separates the audience from the actors and he kills spontaneity and agency from the public. Augusto Boal and Jacob Levy Moreno, through psychodrama, group therapy, and the encounter movement, basically brought back theater to its primitive stage where the audience could participate and change the end of the play.</p><p><strong>One can change the trajectory of the story because they have their own understanding and not someone else’s.</strong></p><p>I believe that you have to create an idea that the audiences can experience and make as their own. If an idea is truly valuable everyone will understand it. The idea that an artist should not create small curtains — basically, I don’t want bullshit.</p><p><strong>I see a kind of curatorial dictation in art today that reminds me of this flaw of Aristotle’s — all too often the way an exhibit is organized and written about demands an art spectator to experience it with a strict, often oppressive pedagogy, where they tell you how to look at a piece of art. That seems like bullshit.</strong></p><p>Well, I like obscurity and I like art — I enjoy some art about art. But I don’t expect other artists to follow the same rules that I make for myself. I don’t think that it’s bad that there’s self-referential art. But I do believe that art should speak to most people, even though when I do this I put myself in a risky position because I know that in reaching out, your audience may have curators in it.</p><p><strong>But what I appreciate in much of your work and your thought process is what I see as creations of open spaces that let the viewer see for themselves, spaces that one can navigate on their own and decide between what is good and what is not, because the most basic and yet most profound thing one can understand is their own lived experience.</strong></p><p>I have a kind of a very personal dogma that my work has to be understood by everyone.</p><p><strong>Has to be or could be?</strong></p><p>Has to be. Yeah.</p><h3><a href="https://youtu.be/_BrVghNPDxs">https://youtu.be/_BrVghNPDxs</a></h3><p>Originally appeared in SFAQ on January 5 2015 <a href="https://www.sfaq.us/2015/01/pedro-reyes-in-conversation-with-peter-dobey/">https://www.sfaq.us/2015/01/pedro-reyes-in-conversation-with-peter-dobey/</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=eeb36e0e3747" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[On The Libidinal Economy of Artists]]></title>
            <link>https://psychoanalysisforartists.medium.com/on-the-libidinal-economy-of-artists-cba7bc5ecffb?source=rss-d8e8331f118------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/cba7bc5ecffb</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[lacan]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[therapy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[contemporary-art]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[lacanian-psychoanalysis]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[psychoanalysis]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Peter Merritt]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 24 Oct 2020 05:27:59 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-10-24T05:45:44.654Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Artists are both ruthlessly independent in one way, and rather dependent on another more ground level way, that is characterized in attachment styles that resemble the process that keeps them so involved in making their artwork in the first place.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*hKSHzYwK2EZJkMSshKzYVQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Painting by Romina Bassu</figcaption></figure><p>It is a paradox at the level of the Ego, to be so libidinally engaged with ones productions is a drive for independent creation, soul independence, but the attachment to the work is one of not letting go.</p><p>Also, artworks as such are not commercial until they enter a very rarified niche, this is the niche economy of the artworld, but even once their have to have a subjective, personal way of entering into circulation that is essentially at odds with trade their products existence, their artworks ontology, is bound up and embude with a narcissistic component of the individual, an individual not fully detached from early libidinal investments. Now this narcissistic component can also, and indeed is precisely what speaks to people, speaks to viewers at a universal level: this access to someone’s private world, that is how art can have some of the divine to it, because the particularity can effect the global and universal without leaving the specificity of the individuals vision. Art, if it’s good, really can connect disparate people, but it’s only because the art product itself is severely attached, to a primordial womb we could say.</p><p>Now there is plenty of art simply made for the art market, but those kind of people generally won’t come to me, and there are some psychoanalysts out there who will get the joke about what that says about them — that they are perverse because their art is not coming from a genuine place of the drives, but of one where they are crafting things into an asimilable form, a market form.</p><p>Authentic artworks are not readily absorbed into an economy, unless and until they are absorbed by the art world, which happens to be a very specific commercial economy that caters to their libidinal dependence while applauding their entrepreneurial independence, but not every artist figures out or falls into the specific symbolic register of the artworld, it’s institutional reality.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=cba7bc5ecffb" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>