<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Peter Carey on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Peter Carey on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@ptcarey?source=rss-90dcd2f3ae02------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 23:40:52 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@ptcarey/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[You’re not doing it right!! 
International Currency Transactions]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@ptcarey/youre-not-doing-it-right-international-currency-transactions-779368a398a5?source=rss-90dcd2f3ae02------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/779368a398a5</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Peter Carey]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 13 Sep 2014 12:02:52 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2014-09-13T12:02:52.030Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<blockquote><strong><em>You’re not doing it right!!<br>International Currency Transactions</em></strong></blockquote><p>Travelled overseas, travelling overseas, buying online internationally??<br>My guess is <strong>95% to 99% </strong>of international transactions are not being done efficiently or doing it right!!<br>(NB: Large International Money Transfers is a whole other topic!)</p><p>It is costing most people, the average traveller or international purchaser, somewhere between <strong>3% to 8% MORE THAN IT NEEDS TO – </strong>and in some cases, more than 10%. Hence <strong>“You’re not doing it right” – </strong>let me explain.</p><p>Friends, colleagues and other travellers always try to tell me how great a deal they are getting on the conversion of Australia dollars into foreign currency – Travel money cards, credit cards, cash exchanges are the most common. Almost every time I hear or see these 4 common phrases, I cringe;</p><p>1. “But, they gave me <strong>no exchange fees</strong>”<br>2. “I was offered <strong>free currency loading</strong>”<br>3. “I did my research and it is <strong>only a 2% international transaction fee</strong>”<br>4. And, at the checkout counter: “do you want to <strong>transact in local currency, or your home currency?</strong>”</p><p>This is only half the story being told. Here is the other half (in a very generalised response):</p><p><em>1. “But the exchange rate they have provided has about a 5% margin already built into it – so thank you for not charging an extra 1% or $8 into an already crappy offering”<br>2. “the exchange rate is terrible, of course they are going to give you “free loading”<br>3. “2% international fee, </em><strong><em>plus </em></strong><em>a cash advance fee, </em><strong><em>plus </em></strong><em>a foreign ATM fee, </em><strong><em>plus, plus</em></strong><em>…., my head hurts adding all these numbers up”<br>4. </em>This should read: “<em>do you want to transact in the local currency or, rather than just being done over by your own bank, the store’s bank also wants a piece of the action in ripping off the international customer as well”</em></p><p>So, how do you know what a good deal is? Are you going to believe the product providers’ marketing and actually think you are not being charged anything (or not much) to do business with them?<br>Credit cards, travel money cards or cash exchange (there are others, but let’s focus on these common ones) – which one? You have to read my story – and do your own homework.</p><p><strong>A “numbers nerd” with the “man flu”</strong><br>A few months ago I got the dreaded “man flu” in Paris. So there I was, lying in bed whilst my wife went shopping, I thought to myself, “how much is my 36 hour man flu really going to cost me” not just the shopping bill by my wife, but on the fees our bank are going to charge us as well. So I took my thought process one step further and expanded on my previous foreign currency transaction methods research. Out came my inner nerd (and the trusty Excel Spreadsheet) and away I went, researching the most popular foreign currency transaction methods from Australia, with different providers and of course, a collection of my own existing providers – about 20 different assessments. A small assessment when compared to the whole market, but a good cross-section of big players, specialist players and heavily marketed players.</p><p><strong>Based on a 400€ transaction — the results are….</strong></p><p><strong>The BEST DEAL: Credit Card (which only costs me 0.19% — </strong><em>see below)</em></p><p>But it has to be a very specific type of card with a very specific provider/s (sorry, no product recommendation, but I can tell you it’s not from the “Big 4&quot; &amp; they’re not a minnow either)</p><p><strong>The WORST DEAL: </strong>Also the Credit Card (<strong>costing roughly 3% to &gt;8%)</strong><br>And also those horribly expensive “instant money transfer providers” (<strong>as bad as 17.1%) – </strong>but does anyone really use these except for emergencies or being scammed by some New York apartment sub-let craiglist scam??</p><p>Why do I think 95% to 99% of people are doing it wrong – <strong>they’re using the wrong credit card (</strong>or wrong travel money card or wrong cash exchange method/provider) – I challenge you to tell me your story of why you think your method is better!!</p><p>And why do I think you are paying between 3% to &gt;8% more than you should be?? That is the total difference between the <a href="http://finance.yahoo.com/q?s=AUDEUR=X">“spot exchange rate”</a> on the day and what you are ultimately paying for your transaction via your chosen currency provider <strong><em>after </em></strong>all fees and the “provided exchange rate” (the rate your provider uses, includes their margin) is taken into account.</p><p>Unless you are spending millions, you are not going to get even close to the Spot Rate (unless you have a good Foreign Transactions Manager working with you). As “Joe Average”, you have to do your homework and understand what the real costs are.</p><p>Here are the 4 main costs to transacting internationally;</p><p><strong>1. Exchange rate used: </strong>product providers often create their own “provided exchange rate” – this is the rate your transaction will be charged – this can vary a lot (and I mean a lot) from provider to provider – do your homework here – on all providers &amp; all products (eg Credit Cards, Travel Money Cards and Cash Exchanges).<br>How to compare the Exchange Used? Obtain the “Provided Exchange Rate” from your provider on a Sunday (they’ll use the COB Friday/Saturday rate) – and compare that rate against the Saturday’s “Spot Exchange Rate” (<em>markets close Saturday afternoon, so Sunday is a great day to do a fair comparison). </em>This gives you a great base to compare the different providers on the same day – without the excuse of “the exchange rate fluctuates daily”.</p><p><strong>2. Fees (as a percentage): </strong>The 2 common ones are “International transaction fee” – typically 1.1% to 2.2% <strong>AND </strong>“Cash advance fee” (for credit cards for ATM withdrawals in foreign countries) – again typically 1.1% to 2.2%. <strong><em>Side note: </em></strong>A tricky fee here is also the <strong><em>“home currency transaction, but transaction supplied by an international merchant” </em>fee</strong> – some banks will even charge you a 2% fee for selecting “home currency” at the checkout terminal. You think you are saving money by transacting in your home currency – WRONG – the foreign merchant you just used in the store just gave you a bad exchange rate, then your own bank charged you a further 2% fee for using a foreign merchant, even though the transaction was done in your home currency…. Arhhh, when does the pain stop?</p><p>3<strong>. Fees (flat dollar): </strong>A few fees may apply here. ATM withdrawal fee (typically $3 to $5 per transaction), foreign ATM fee (your local bank may charge this as well if not with a “foreign partner”, but also, the foreign ATM may also charge it for themselves) typically up to $4 per transaction. These “little fees” can add up big time for smaller withdrawals.<br>4<strong>. Loading Fee for Travel Money Cards: </strong>To give some “security” or “comfort” that you have locked in a fixed rate (usually by sacrificing some of the current Spot Exchange Rate), providers were charging “loading fees” – many have moved away from this type of fee – but some are still charging, so be careful. So if you are convinced you need a Travel Money Card – check these 3 things;</p><p><strong>a. </strong>The exchange rate they are offering you (<em>see point 1)</em>;<br><strong>b. </strong>The loading fee (<em>should be 0% &amp; $0 all the time – so check it)</em>;<br><strong>c. </strong>All the other fees for using the card (<em>and there can be a few fees involved).</em></p><p>One other thing – if you are using a Travel Money Card to lock in an exchange rate because of fear the exchange value might go down, think about this – what if you have locked in the exchange rate in <strong>AND THE RATE IMPROVES IN VALUE? </strong>You have just missed out on this increase as well! There are always 3 directions an exchange rate can move. Up, Down &amp; Flat. Do your homework on how volatile the market is.</p><p>On a side note, the method I use for <strong>foreign international purchases only costs me 0.19% </strong>and for <strong>foreign cash/withdrawals, it only costs 0.7%, </strong>based on a 400€ (Euro) transaction. The most common forms of transaction methods are costing most people between 3% &amp; &gt;8%. So in real terms, <strong>it only costs me 0€76 to 2€80 for a 400€ transaction – </strong>but for the average international consumer, it is costing <strong>7€ to 28€ per 400€ transaction. </strong>Selecting a bad method can add up very quickly.</p><p>So, <strong>be prepared to do your research</strong>, I have done mine, I am keen to hear what methods you use and how much you think it is costing you to transact for your International Transactions. Can you really beat a “real cost” of 0€76 for a 400€ purchase transaction? or 2€80 for a 400€ cash transaction??</p><p>My suggestion to my fellow consumers, please, please do not rely on the marketing efforts of the foreign currency companies, learn what the fees are, how they calculate the “provided exchange rates and then determine what card / product you should be using – there are not many sensational offers out there, but there are a few, you just have to go digging for them.</p><p>The really cool thing is that this research also impacts small to medium businesses – Do you import products? Or pay for services in foreign currency? Imagine spending $100,000 on products &amp; services over 12 months and being able to save 3% to 8% — that is a lot of money in your back pocket!!</p><p>Also, the end result of the cost of my 36 hour man flu?? Thanks to my lovely wife’s restraint, it only cost us $30 AUD (around 20 Euro) – she bought us both soup and coffee each. No shoes, no handbags, no dresses – what a superstar!!</p><p>Peter Carey (currently a tourist in France)<br><a href="http://linkedin.com/in/ptcarey">linkedin.com/in/ptcarey</a><br><a href="http://twitter.com/ptcarey78">twitter.com/ptcarey78</a></p><p><strong>Key Words:<br></strong>International Currency Transactions: <em>spending or receiving money in another currency<br></em>Spot Exchange Rate: <em>The interbank exchange rate – typically what you see at the end of the news on TV each night (but way more technical than that)<br></em>Provided Exchange Rate: <em>What your bank/travel money card or exchange office offers to the consumer – with their margin built into the rate<br></em>Home Currency: <em>The currency in your own country (for me, it’s the Australian Dollar)<br></em>Local Currency:<em> The overseas currency you are transacting in (for me, typically the Euro, the British Pound and sometimes the US Dollar — depending on where I am or if shopping online)</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=779368a398a5" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>