<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by PV Bailey on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by PV Bailey on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@pvincentbailey?source=rss-fd5ee0e29696------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Wed, 18 Nov 2026 06:36:57 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@pvincentbailey/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Nothing is Inevitable]]></title>
            <link>https://pvincentbailey.medium.com/nothing-is-inevitable-2b17e6a783f6?source=rss-fd5ee0e29696------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2b17e6a783f6</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[history]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[PV Bailey]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 04 Aug 2024 03:43:24 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-08-04T04:02:26.410Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Stop dehumanizing history.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/330/1*An6WyiYm0TC13nYimdpGtw.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/330/1*bpQ-OqjofHpdg3pmS_pCLw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Gavrilo Princip and Archduke Franz-Ferdinand. (Source Wikipedia)</figcaption></figure><p>Recently, I came across a description for <em>The Guns of August</em> by Barbara Tuchmann that drove me nearly insane with its inaccuracies. The description claimed that Tuchmann argues that the war was inevitable. It laid a great deal of emphasis on the idea the Great War was inevitable. Tuchmann did NOT, however, argue any such thing in <em>The Guns of August </em>because her book was not about the causes of the war but how it was conducted during the first month and how battle plans went awry. Even in <em>The Proud Tower</em>, Tuchmann’s sweeping cultural and political history of the twenty-five years leading up to the war, she doesn’t argue the war was inevitable. She explores certain trends that made a war in Europe more likely but she also deals with countervailing trends as well. In neither book does she argue it was inevitable nor does she directly deal with the events of the summer of 1914 that led to the war.</p><p>But it wasn’t just a bad bookseller’s description that drove me crazy. It was the idea that historical events are inevitable — that anything in the course of human events is inevitable. There has been, over the last months and years, a lot of people spinning the idea that events are inevitable. I will grant you that events can reach a point of no return but to accept events as inevitable is a clockwork view of history that denies human beings of any control of or responsibility for what happens.</p><p>What happened during the summer of 1914 haunts my imagination because it is a master study in how human beings, acting on ideas, cultural attitudes, and imperfect information, make decisions. It is also a study in how happenstance, contingency, and seemingly minor things, can have a major impact on the course of history. And, this is what is so haunting about it, there are so many points during that summer when the people involved could have taken a step back and prevented one of the most devastating wars in history.</p><p>It all began because of a bad map, a bad driver, and a café on an unfortunate corner where a Bosnian student hopped up on nationalist fervor had gone for a drink. The events of the 28th of June 1914 began with an act of arrogance. The day was the Serbian National Day in neighboring Serbia, something akin to the Fourth of July for ethnic Serbs especially those that had dreams of either a greater Serbia or freedom for all Yugoslavs, southern Slavs. Ethnic nationalism had been a rising force in European politics for a while. This was the day that Archduke Franz Ferdinand, crown prince of the Hapsburg Empire — a country that was seen as the great oppressor of the Serbs — decided to visit the largely Serbian city of Sarajevo in full military regalia. For Serbs, it was the equivalent of showing up at a Juneteenth celebration dressed as Robert E. Lee.</p><p>There was also in Sarajevo a group of idealistic students who, with some backing from Serbia, decided to strike a blow against Hapsburg oppression by killing the Archduke. Hopped up on ideas about identity, nationalism and Serbian folklore, they called themselves the Black Hand. But like most idealistic young people who decide to go down the path of political violence, they were idealists first and terrorists second; they were amateurs. What followed that day would have been a comedy of errors had the results not been so devastating. The Black Hand had spread themselves all along the motorcade route. Their first attempt had one of them rush forward only to lose his nerve at the last second. The second threw a bomb that bounced off the Archduke’s car and blew up the car behind him. After that the motorcade broke up and his driver, using an out-of-date street map, turned into a blind alley. While trying to turn around, he stalled the car and couldn’t get it started again. Inside a café on that corner, Gavrilo Princip was drowning his sorrows at their failure and dreaming of a greater Serbia. He had been placed last because, according to a least one account, he was the worst shot. He saw the stalled car, rushed out, and killed the Archduke and his wife. You don’t need to be a very good shot at point blank range.</p><p>Thirty-seven days later Europe was at war.</p><p>During those thirty-seven days, the leaders of Great Powers of Europe engaged in a series of missteps, misunderstandings, miscalculations and miscommunications that ended in the first general European war since Napolean. A war on an industrial scale.</p><p>What is so infuriating about the summer of 1914 is that there are so many points where it is easy to imagine a different outcome had European leaders acted a little differently. Had the Archduke not gone to Sarajevo; had Princip gone to a different café; had Hapsburg Emperor Franz-Joseph accepted the Serbian response to his ultimatum; had that phone call between British Foreign Minister Edward Grey and the German ambassador been clearer; had Kaiser Wilhem II not reacted so angrily when the British tried to clarify; had Tsar Nicolas II not ordered a full mobilization; had, well, so many seemingly minor choices been replaced with other choices and our world today would be a very different place.</p><p>I think about that every time there is an international crisis. What miscalculations are being made because of misperceptions and misunderstandings that may lead us into catastrophe? The danger almost always resides in the response than in the actual start of a crisis.</p><p>The other striking thing about it all is just how similar and interconnected the European powers, and their leaders, were. Unlike the Second World War, there were no totalizing ideologies splitting the countries of Europe apart in 1914. The King of Britian, German Kaiser, and Russian Tsar were cousins. They were major trading partners — so connected by trade many called it interdependence and many posited that the deep trade connections would prevent any future wars between them. (This is why I was always so dubious toward the claims that globalized free trade would bring nothing but peace put forth by people like Thomas Friedman and the other neoliberal boosters.)</p><p>Culturally, the countries of Europe were remarkable for just how much they agreed on things. They read the same books, saw the same plays and operas, and wore similar fashions. I remember reading one time that Russian composers complained bitterly about how popular Gilbert and Sullivan were in St. Petersburg. They shared similar preoccupations about honor and duty. But most importantly, they all seemed to believe in Progress. And it was a particularly liberal, bourgeois version of Progress where life would continue to get better and better at a steady, stable pace until everyone could live a comfortably middle-class life. They honestly believed they had put the past of constant war in Europe, revolutions (and the need for them), and civil unrest generally behind them and that they were on the cusp of solving many of their social problems like poverty.</p><p>Yes, it was a collective delusion but a beautiful one. It is also a completely understandable one. If you had been alive in 1815, your life would have more in common Chaucer’s pilgrims — in how you lived and materially — than anything like today. It was still a world lit by fire. During the 19th century technological improvements radically changed human life. Public health measures like sewer systems, water systems along with advances in medicine had made life cleaner, healthier and longer; industrialization had made life much more abundant; education and literacy had become much more widespread through compulsory education laws and child labor laws; travel became easier with trains, steamboats, automobiles, and, even, airplanes. By 1910, it was a world lit by electricity. It was, mostly, the modern world we live in today.</p><p>Politically, Europe as a whole was moving in a more politically liberal direction as well. France had reestablished their republic; Britian throughout the 19th century moved steadily from its aristocratic system towards the much more democratic one they have today with universal manhood suffrage, limiting the power of the House of Lords, and more equal districts. Even the three large absolutist monarchies — Germany, the Hapsburg Empire, and Russia — were moving, albeit tentatively and slowly, towards constitutional monarchy. The last year of revolutionary fervor to grip Europe was in 1848. The last war to be fought in the heart of Europe was the Franco-Prussian war of 1870 which lasted only six weeks. The last general European war ended with Waterloo in 1815. All other conflicts between the powers of Europe were small and fought on the periphery of the continent, the Balkans or Crimea. Or they were fought out in the colonial empires far from home.</p><p>But there were other things, more troubling things, that Europeans agreed about as well; things that ultimately undermined their liberal, bourgeois beliefs and their faith in Progress. Imperialism and colonialism were viewed positively as a way to spread “blessings of industrial civilization” to underdeveloped parts of the world. Nationalism, the idea that your country or ethnic group is somehow better than others, was on the rise and generally viewed as a good thing.</p><p>Underpinning both of those, however, was something else that led them all to exaggerate their relatively minor differences in world view and make them blind to how similar they were. In the 19th and early 20th century, the mentality that inspired Linnean Taxonomy dominated academic thinking. The idea that everything — birds, plants, fish, languages, animals, rocks — could, based on certain characteristics, be put into a category as a way to understand the world. Even the Romantics reflected this categorizing impulse. Melville included a chapter in <em>Moby Dick </em>where he puts whales into categories based, primarily, on size.<a href="#_edn1">[i]</a></p><p>But what is useful for understanding plants or animals doesn’t work quite so well for understanding human beings. What began as a linguistic study of similar languages quickly morphed into an exercise in a misapplication of ideas about evolution and ethnic groups. This is especially true after Charles Darwin published <em>The Descent of Man</em> in 1871. Often mistaking culturally-learned behaviors and attitudes for effects of evolutionary biology, they divvied up humanity into various ethnic and racial groups. Inclusion in one or the other of the ethnic groups became determinate for understanding each other. To put it another way, intellectuals were terribly concerned about why some apes evolved into English middle-class gentlemen or Prussian aristocrats while others into Bedouin tribesmen or the Bushman of the Kalahari. This way of thinking became, in the twenty-five or so years before the Great War, ubiquitous. It was in everything from adventure stories like <em>Tarzan of the Apes</em> to children’s history textbooks. Princip said in his confession that he wanted justice for the Southern Slavs, Yugoslavs. Russia intervened on behalf of Serbia because of ideas about Pan-Slavic identity. Germany was motivated in part because of a Pan-Germanic movement. The Hapsburg Empire, a large, multiethnic state, had been fraying because of the various ethnic/nationalist movements within its borders.</p><p>This way of thinking helped erase all the things Europeans had in common while emphasizing differences.</p><p>They called it “race science.” It bears more than a passing resemblance to our politics of identity. It reached its ultimate expression long after the events of the 1914 in a small Polish town called Auschwitz.</p><p>And that leads me to the other thing that haunts me about 1914: all the things that happened or didn’t happen because the crisis was not averted like a number of crises in the years prior. Had the war not happened there would have been no rise of fascism, the right-wing populism that grew out of the collapse of the Hapsburg Empire and the disruptions in Italy and Germany following the war. That totalizing ideology is why there was a second world war that was even more destructive, materially, than the first one.</p><p>And without World War II, there would have been no Manhattan Project that gave the world the ability to destroy itself with nuclear weapons.</p><p>And there would have been no Soviet Union. Russia may have been ripe for revolution or reform for years but the success of the October 1917 revolution depended on German support. They spirited Lenin back into Russia and helped fund the Bolsheviks because Lenin promised to pull Russia out of the war. Think of it. No Soviet Union, no Iron Curtain, no Cold War, no People’s Republic of China, no wars in Korea or Viet Nam.</p><p>The collapse of the Ottoman Empire, and David Lloyd George and Georges Clemenceau drawing lines on a map during the negotiations for the Treaty of Versailles, gave us the shape of the modern Middle East, all those countries that have created so many problems in recent decades. While not exactly a model of modern, effective governance, the Ottomans had created a system where Muslim, Christian and Jew could live and work together in peace as peoples of the book. Granted, it was not on exactly equal terms but they had been able to do it for about 400 hundred years. It is worthy of our consideration given the recent events in Gaza. Or, indeed, so many events in recent decades.</p><p>Cities like Beirut, Aleppo, Baghdad were likened to Paris for their culture and openness.</p><p>The First World War laid the foundations for almost everything that followed. Was a war likely in Europe then? Perhaps. Perhaps not. For all the tensions between the great powers there were countervailing forces as well. That’s the rub about inevitability arguments: inevitability only works in hindsight and only if you elide a great deal about what was happening. And it only works if you reject the idea of human agency.</p><h3><strong>Inevitability as Absolution or To Induce Passivity?</strong></h3><p>That last part is what really bothers me the most. Why do people do it? Why do they want to remove the human element from human history?</p><p>With the Great War, the first writers to claim the war was inevitable seem to have been assuaging their own guilt. It is much easier to claim being at the mercy of inexorable forces than to admit that you were part of the few dozen people who made mistakes, acted stupidly, and failed to understand what was happening. Such arguments usually are easy to dispatch because whenever anyone says they had no choice they are always lying. It’s just that some of the possible choices are ones they find unpalatable or, possibly, merely embarrassing.</p><p>But the inevitability arguments that are harder to deal with come the type of historians and social theorists I like to call the systematizers. These are the historians and theorists who believe once certain conditions are met, then certain events must happen regardless of any actual human thought or ideas or actions. The most prominent are the Marxists who posit that once socioeconomic conditions meet a certain point an inevitable change must occur that is but a step on the road to the great communist state. Or to put it another way, economic conditions determine everything. There is no policy, human action, or idea that can alter it. Just be passive and accept it.</p><p>But the Marxists aren’t the only ones. Of late, I have been hearing a great deal about how democracies can only last a certain number of years before they lapse into some manner of tyranny. The latest iteration of this is the so-called late republic theory. The “Thucydides Trap” posits that whenever there is a rising power and a mature power they must go to war. This alleged inevitability is often brought up in discussions of Sino-US relations. I also remember thirty years ago when the “end of history” theorists were so prominent. These posited that all ideological conflicts in the world would ultimately be resolved in favor of democracy and a particular version of neoliberal capitalism. It was nothing more than Western, and neoconservative, triumphalism. And then there were…the list is really quite long and there is little point in continuing with it.</p><p>They all share similar traits regardless of their political leanings or whatever narrow aspect of human activity they focus on. They are long on theory but tend to be very minimalist when it comes to actual facts about their various examples. Call it a zooming effect. They pull their lens so far back that things that have, at best, a passing resemblance, until they look exactly the same. History doesn’t repeat but it does rhyme; we humans have a great capacity to make similar mistakes but they are never exactly the same. They also tend to be wildly anachronistic by projecting backward in time ideas and concerns that played no role in their examples. Such things often tell us more about the historians’ time than they do about the period being written about. The corollary to this is that they often discount or try to discredit as disingenuous the motivations expressed by the people involved in their examples. Most of the time, they reduce every motivation to a narrow, and base, form of self-interest. It is as if they do not believe human beings might act on ideas about justice, humanity, the nature of the divine, morality, honor, dignity, equality, or any other belief not based on avarice; that we all are motivated exclusively by a personal desire for money and power and everything else is just subterfuge.</p><p>That is if they consider motivations for human activity at all. Indeed, the systematizers often utterly ignore human beings altogether. I have read countless articles, essays, and even books that purport to be about history that didn’t mention a single human being or, if they did, only in passing. I remember one very popular book that supposedly dealt with the period before the Great War which didn’t mention a single British Prime Minister, or Kaiser, or Tsar, or French President. It did mention Franz Ferdinand in the last chapter. What it did discuss was things like relative amounts of the production of pig iron and arable land in colonial empires (but never dealing with why nineteenth century powers thought having colonies was a good idea). All accompanied by endless charts of statistics. Systematizers love statistics; they seem to believe that nothing is true unless you can attach big numbers to it.</p><p>Apparently, according to that book, the main reason for the Great War was the relative parity of iron and wheat production between Britian and Germany.</p><p>But none of the systematizers seem to understand that history, properly understood, is the story of human action based on human ideas. Remove humans from history, there is no such thing as history. But in many ways, this is what the systematizers want; inevitability negates human action. Nor, do they seem to understand why studying history is important. We study history to understand not only the present and how we got here but also to recognize when things in the present are going awry. History rhymes but if we can realize we are heading for a disaster like the Great War we can better prevent it from happening again. But we can’t do that if we accept that the future is inevitable. It is only so if we allow it to be so. That is what we must remember always whenever there is a crisis. Or an election. Or any movement — cultural or political — that wants to bend the arc of history in inhumane ways.</p><p>The future is not yet written; <strong><em>we</em></strong> are its authors.</p><p><a href="#_ednref1">[i]</a> Melville’s chapter, “Cetology”, tedious to many modern readers, is perhaps one of the best examples of the Linnean mindset that informed the culture of the time. Horizontal tails, blowholes, and blubber were his criteria for what is a whale and he then classifies them all by size. Ironically, however, he got it wrong by putting whales in the fish family rather than mammals.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2b17e6a783f6" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Two Plus Two Make Four]]></title>
            <link>https://pvincentbailey.medium.com/two-plus-two-make-four-1078166baac4?source=rss-fd5ee0e29696------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/1078166baac4</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[crisis]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[doomerism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[books]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[PV Bailey]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 28 Jul 2023 06:40:27 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-07-28T06:40:27.191Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>If you’re feeling doomed, it’s time for a little Antifa math</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/330/1*bG1T6-yTwbHGXdElCXfjow.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/255/1*W5fKn0cEOAf1DBlL88g8pA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Albert Camus and George Orwell. Source Wikipedia</figcaption></figure><p>We are living in a world where lies, politely called misinformation, have seemingly taken over our discourse, where false definitions of our basic principles are gaining currency, where the forces of authoritarianism seem to be marching all over the face of the land enforcing their will with threats and violence, and where civilization itself seems to be ready to collapse into ash and rubble. The response by many of those who are opposed to all this is equally troubling. I have read so many commentaries that have adopted the idea that there is almost nothing that can change the course of events, that we must just accept the idea that everything is collapsing and prepare to live in some sort of <em>Mad Max</em>-style post-apocalyptic world.</p><p>“We’re screwed” sums most of it up.</p><p>Such defeatism is a self-fulfilling prophecy. And there are other ways to look at our current moment and to view our prospects.</p><p>It’s time for a little Antifa math. Some original Antifa math.</p><p>In the middle of the last century two men, George Orwell and Albert Camus, happened upon a simple formula for freedom and resistance to the forces of oppression and destruction. Both men were original antifas. Orwell fought against the fascists in Spain and, despite his increasingly bad health, threw himself into the war effort with work for the BBC and participating in the Home Guard; Camus had been rejected, because of his health, by the Republicans in Spain but during the occupation of France participated in the resistance to the Nazi occupation primarily by editing the resistance newspaper <em>Combat</em>. Both men had seen much of their world reduced to actual ash and rubble.</p><p>Both men happened upon the same formula for understanding freedom and resistance: two plus two make four.</p><p>Although they were contemporaries, the two men never actually met although they were supposed in May 1945 but Camus had begged off because of exhaustion and tuberculous. Camus did read Orwell, he noted in his journal he had read <em>1984</em> and a few other of Orwell’s books, but it had to have been after he wrote <em>The Plague.</em> Orwell probably never read Camus. At least there is no evidence that he had.</p><p><em>“Freedom is the freedom to say two plus two make four. If that is granted, all else follows.”</em></p><p>Winston Smith, the main character in <em>1984,</em> writes that in his journal at the end of chapter seven in the first part of the novel. He had been musing about all the different ways the Party uses misinformation, constantly rewrites history, and, more generally, lies about everything. Earlier in the chapter Smith had written that he understood how it was done but not why. Smith is part of the apparatus of misinformation. We, of course, understand or come to understand, that it is just one of the ways the Party maintains itself in power along with fear, keeping everyone distracted and busy, constant surveillance, intimidation, purges, scapegoating — whatever enemy they are at war with, Goldstein, Jews. We also come to understand that the Party does all of it to maintain power, that there is no other goal or vision for it.</p><p>I think about this every time I hear the right down-playing the events of January 6th, or talking about “election integrity”, or their furor over how history is taught, or when they are using threats of violence to intimidate, or indeed, just about everything they say or do. That is the opposite of what Orwell wanted for his novel — a cautionary tale, and not, as the right seems to be using it, as a handbook for political power.</p><p>But there is another angle to look at Orwell’s equation for freedom that is often overlooked. He, and many of us today are focused on the negative interpretation — the denial of the ability to say two plus two make four. That is the focus of <em>1984.</em> It can also be seen as an affirmation. For freedom to exist, truth has to be the basis of discussion. And by truth I mean based on facts — provable facts. Those stubborn things, as John Adams called them. When any discussion is not based on provable facts, there can be no freedom, only manipulation. Manipulation through falsity and lies can only lead to the dystopian future Orwell tried to warn us about — it is basis for totalitarian and autocratic regimes where any sort of political discussion devolves into nothing more than shouting slogans, intimidation, scapegoating, and violence. And that is exactly where the right in our country is now.</p><p>It has become increasingly clear that the disinformation and misinformation currently being spread by the right is causing great harm to our country, democracy and individuals. And the purpose seems to be similar: the pursuit of raw power.</p><p>But, if freedom requires the ability to say two plus make four, it also requires that those, like O’Brien, face some consequences for trying to force people to say two plus two make five. It used to be accepted that a freedom or a right existed for an individual up to the point where it infringed on the freedoms and rights of others. The adage form of it was about your right to swing your fists ends with someone else’s nose. This idea has gone by many names over the centuries: ordered liberty and rule of law are the most common. Freedom needs parameters or it simply devolves into anarchy, or into might making right. This has always been a corollary to ideas about freedom. When it comes to things like misinformation, however, there are those that howl that applying parameters to freedom of speech is an attack on the very idea of freedom. But freedom of speech and press is not now, nor ever was, an absolute right. Defamation, libel and slander have long been civilly actionable, as Alex Jones, that raucous purveyor of disinformation, discovered. Inciting people to violence, giving false testimony under oath, and fomenting sedition are criminal acts, as the absurdly-named Oath Keepers discovered. Commercial speech has long been regulated. At the very least, I think some regulation of social media may be called for to ensure that misinformation and disinformation don’t rise to the top because of algorithms.</p><p>Orwell did not, in <em>1984</em> at least, delve into the issue of what are the edges of freedom because he was writing about a society where any independent thought or freedom had already been extinguished.</p><p>Camus, on the other hand, found that two plus two making four is not just a statement of truth but also of the logic of resistance.</p><p>But before we get into the logic of resistance, there are a couple of things in <em>The Plague</em> that accurately echo our own situation. Eerily so in places.</p><p>At the very beginning, Camus gives us an intriguing portrait of the town. Oran is an ugly place, striking for its ordinariness. “The truth is that everyone is bored, and devotes himself to cultivating habits. Our citizens work hard, but solely with the object of getting rich. Their chief interest is in commerce and their aim in life is…’doing business.’” As long as you cultivate habits, you can live quite comfortably with the banality of life. But to live by cultivating habits means you don’t really think about, well, anything. In short, the people of Oran lived rather thoughtlessly filling their days with work and family and reading the papers<a href="#_ftn1">[1]</a> and doing all the expected things of normal, modern life.</p><p>Then the rats start dying.</p><p>At first, no one is really sure what is happening so most people ignore the situation or just find it annoying, or, like some of the newspapers, use it as a chance to criticize the local government for not dealing with the dead rats better, like it was just another mundane bit of politics. When the plague starts to infect people, however, almost no one wants to admit it; there is even a reluctance to even say the word plague. Even in discussions among doctors. And there is a lot of denialism — “It can’t happen here” sort of response along with a healthy dose of “Even if it does, it won’t be that bad” sort of minimalism.</p><p>Honestly, I can think of no other work of literature that better captures not only how most of us were living before our myriad problems came to a head or how we reacted to the first signs of those problems. Most of us, until relatively recently, lived by habit — commute, work, commute, dinner, and then an evening of TV or surfing the web, repeat tomorrow. We never gave much thought to any of it; we just cultivated the habits. And we were encouraged in all this by the entire “self-help” industry. Books like Stephen R. Covey’s <em>Seven Habits of Highly Effective People, </em>James Clear’s <em>Atomic Habits, </em>and Jordan Peterson’s <em>Twelve Rules</em> (because what is following a bunch of simplistic rules than the cultivation of habits) all reinforced the idea that if we all had the right habits we would all be healthy, wealthy, and, if not exactly wise, then happy. We were also, like the people of Oran, focused on making money — working. In fact, the idea of work had become a nearly all-consuming obsession, either through necessity or habit.</p><p>Like the people of Oran ignoring the dying rats, we mostly ignored all the early signs of our various plagues. The growing sentiment on the right that undermines our democracy in favor of an autocratic form of minority rule have been around for almost as long I can remember. It became noticeable with Ronald Reagan proclaiming that government was not the solution to our problems but was the problem. Think about that for a moment. It was not an attack on any particular policy. It was, rather, an attack on the very idea of democratic governance, on the idea that the people, through their elected representatives, are capable of effectively governing themselves. That has been the justification for every system of autocratic government in the world from monarchy to fascism to communism. There are a couple of through lines that developed from that idea. The first is the erstwhile Republican Party’s continued attempts to obstruct and delegitimize any and all actions by the Democratic Party. Indeed, they want to obstruct and delegitimize any government action of any kind. Everything from the impeachment of Bill Clinton by Newt Gingrich’s House to Carl Rove’s nattering on about a “permanent majority” by Gerrymandering to the constant filibustering of Obama years to the plan to overturn the election on January 6th. The other through line is the rise of the so-called militia movement of the 1990s to the falsely named “Patriots” of the early 2000s to the Proud Boys and Oath Keepers who led the storming of the Capitol.</p><p>We did the same with climate change — deny and minimize. I remember first hearing about climate change, then called global warming, and how it was caused by releasing a lot of CO2 into atmosphere by burning fossil fuels back in high school. Understand this: I’m old. I graduated high school in 1985. Just imagine what the world might be like today had we started to shift to renewable energy back then. And my memories of renewable energy are even older — solar, wind, and hydroelectric energy were hot topics when I was in elementary school primarily because of the Arab oil embargo. And we did the same with our economic problems especially rising inequality, wage stagnation, concentration of wealth into ever fewer hands, and corporate consolidation. We ignored all those trend lines that really do go back at least forty years. Worse than that even. Many of us believed the Hayek-inspired economists when they said all those negative trends were actually good things.</p><p>But, like the people of Oran, we have reached the point when we can no longer ignore our plagues — our gates have been closed as they were in Camus’ novel. Once the gates close at the end of part one, the people of Oran fall into a few main categories. Many people simply try to continue their lives as normally as possible. There are those that flourished with the closing of the gates. Garcia and other smugglers do a brisk trade. Cottard, who is saved from arrest by the closed gates, even feels liberated in the enclosed, plague-infested city. Then there are those, like Rambert, who seek to escape. There are also those, like the priest Paneloux, who think everyone should just accept the situation and bow down to the inevitable.</p><p>And then there are the resisters. They resist the plague because two plus two make four; the plague is here, we must fight it. Or to put it another way, the truth must be acted upon. “There is nothing admirable in this attitude; it is merely logical,” Dr. Rieux, the narrator and Camus stand-in, observes in Part II. For Orwell, merely proclaiming two plus two make four was an act of heroic defiance. For Camus, however, it isn’t that; it isn’t even particularly praiseworthy. Afterall, as Camus points out, we do not praise a teacher for saying it, even though there are points in history where saying it may well lead to a person’s death. Nor does Rieux find praising those who take action based on the reality that two plus two make four to be a good idea because to do so would give into the idea that callousness and apathy are how most people are. Rieux, and thus Camus, rejects that idea. The real issue is whether you can make the calculation at all.</p><p>Once you make the calculation that two plus two equal four, then you must act. Camus connects this idea with the idea that most people are relatively decent and that what is not decent in us has more to do with ignorance. But, of course, the question then becomes how are we to act? For that, Camus gives us the example of Grand.</p><p>Grand fascinates me. He is an older white guy whose career never advanced beyond the position he took back in his twenties, his wife left him years ago — something he still grieves, and he basically lives in poverty in ill-health. He has, also, spent years working on the first sentence of a novel. He relentless revises that one sentence because he wants it to be perfect, instantly recognizable as a work of literary genius. There is never any indication of what he has planned for after that sentence or even what kind of novel it is to be. Grand is, in short, the type of person we would normally associate with the burn-it-all-down attitude of the MAGA-verse — marginalized, isolated, and lied to by a system that is willing to use him without any concern for his well-being.</p><p>Except he isn’t.</p><p>Too poor to give up his day job and in not in any condition to do heavy lifting, Grand keeps the records of the sanitary squads so everything can run smoothly. Every evening after work he goes to Rieux’s office to compile his statistics, make graphs, and mark his maps. He does this without hesitation. “Plague is here and we’ve got to make a stand, that’s obvious. Ah, I only wish everything were as simple!” he said when he was thanked for it. In short, he does his bit. He is under no delusion that his recording keeping is going to stop the plague. No one involved in fighting the plague seems to be under the delusion that they, alone, can stop the plague. But, as more and more people start doing their bit, the plague is dealt with until eventually the gates reopen. It is not, however, without setbacks and losses along the way. Even after the gates open, there is the recognition that the plague can come back.</p><p>Do what you can; do your bit. Be like Grand.</p><p>And that brings me back to the “we’re screwed; we’re doomed” crowd. I know most of them would argue they are merely pointing out the problems we face. That is valuable work. But when every set-back is treated as an irretrievable calamity, every problem as an insurmountable challenge, and the opposition to any sort of change as intractable and impossibly powerful — in short to adopt the attitude that we’re doomed — then a bigger danger will raise its head. That danger is fatalism — the idea that we shouldn’t even try to do anything because, well, we’re doomed.</p><p>Fatalism is the opposite of hope — the belief that the future will be worth living in. Give up on hope and we really will be doomed. Both Orwell and Camus were confronted with a world that had been, quite literally, reduced to ash and rubble. But neither man ever gave up on the idea of hope.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref1">[1]</a> Interestingly, both Camus and Orwell took a dim view of newspapers. Orwell, in <em>1984</em> and elsewhere, and Camus in both <em>The Plague</em> and <em>The Fall</em>, suggest that the newspapers of the period were what we would call infotainment, a midcentury version of surfing the net.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=1078166baac4" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[On Inspiration and the “Ages of Man”]]></title>
            <link>https://pvincentbailey.medium.com/on-inspiration-and-the-ages-of-man-ab2e94f092e8?source=rss-fd5ee0e29696------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ab2e94f092e8</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[false-inspiration]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[culture]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[shakespeare]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[humanism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[toxic-positivity]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[PV Bailey]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 28 Apr 2023 11:22:05 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-04-28T11:22:05.386Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>A meditation on Shakespeare and the modern inspirational claptrap.</p><p><a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UG3f3Nab1DA">“Seven Ages of Man — All the World’s a Stage” by William Shakespeare (read by Tom O’Bedlam) — YouTube</a></p><p>A while ago I saw a poster I am certain was meant to be inspirational. Normally I avoid such things as vapid, platitudinous claptrap designed to create an attitude of cheerful productivity with tired old saws that are more often than not untrue. But this one brought me up short. I forget the image but the text was from Shakespeare: “All the world’s a stage,/And all the men and women merely players.” It’s the opening line of the melancholy Jaques’ Ages of Man speech from Act II Scene VII of <em>As You Like It.</em></p><p>I was completely flummoxed by this. Either the poster maker pulled the quote from a list of quotes by Shakespeare with absolutely no context, or he or she believed everything by Shakespeare must be inspirational, or he or she had the reading comprehension of a garden slug, I thought. But some time later, I was discussing Jaques’ speech in one of my classes. Most of my students thought it was a wonderful, inspirational statement of life’s possibilities.</p><p>WTF? Did they read the same speech I had or had they gotten hold of some twisted version of the Cliff Notes? Has our cultural obsession with positivity so blinded them that they have become grotesque Pollyannas? Or, in the name of modern efficiency, are they all speed readers who skip over adjectives and modifiers to such an extent that all real meaning is lost?</p><p>There are many things you can say about this speech but inspirational is not one them. But, I think, coming to an understanding of this particular speech, both in its original context and in the seemingly ubiquitous modern misinterpretation of it, may just help us find some balance in an age of extremes.</p><p>“The Ages of Man” in the Context of the Renaissance and Humanism</p><p>My students tend to not like the Renaissance. Usually, they begin with the fairy tale version of it where it was the “rebirth of art and literature”; where everything was an advancement of scientific knowledge to a “true picture” of the universe; where humanism was an always positive expression of human potential and “perfectibility” (a lot more on that below). And they usually begin with a catalogue of the period’s greatest achievements like Michelangelo’s <em>David, </em>or Da Vinci’s <em>Mona Lisa</em>, or Copernicus’s and Galileo’s heliocentric universe, or Florence’s architecture, or Shakespeare’s plays. The image my students usually start with is one of a peaceful, harmonious picture of artists and writers sitting around discussing what is beautiful and how wonderful the world could be if humans were allowed to fulfill their true potential. They also find such a portrait of the age to be incredibly tedious. People sitting around essentially singing Kumbaya always is.</p><p>Granted, there was some of that but it is, at best, a woefully incomplete picture of the period that laid the groundwork for the modern age. It was also a period of nearly constant conflict and war, religious dissention, deep contradictions, reason and belief in witchcraft and alchemy, and hope and despair. Erasmus wrote that it was a degenerate age full of naked ambition, raw power-seeking, greed, impiety, and treachery. He also wrote that Europe was on the cusp of a golden age. It was an age when Thomas More would dream of an ideal society in <em>Utopia</em> before having his head lopped off by Henry VIII. It contained both Galileo’s telescope and the Spanish Inquisition. It was an age that put a great deal of emphasis on human agency, human reason, and trying to understand what it really meant to be human only to rip itself apart over religion.</p><p>Part of the problem is the nature of Renaissance humanism. So much dross and nonsense has grown up around the word <em>humanism</em> that it is hard to convey what it actually meant. It was never about rejecting religion or about how human beings can be perfect or, indeed, anything coherent. Students hate that last bit. They like words that end in -ism to be summarized with “principal beliefs” in neat little bullet points, preferably five to ten, on a power point slide. But Renaissance humanism doesn’t work that way because it is not a coherent intellectual movement.</p><p>What it was a curriculum based on Classical learning called the liberal arts. Beyond that, it really is a series of themes about human nature, human potential, nature, and how humans should relate to God. Humanism was essentially an intellectual stance that sought explanations of human events in human actions and ideas. It was like a great dialogue about these things that never really reached any conclusions. Indeed, dialogues and letters, along with essays, were the period’s principle forms of writing. While they marveled at the potential of human beings, how “like a god in reason” they could be, they were also remarkably clear-eyed about human flaws and short-comings. Machiavelli was a humanist.</p><p>But many of them also believed that they could bring about a golden age, if they could find just the right mix of Classical learning, aesthetic sensibility, and Christian piety. Of course they never could agree on what that mix was or how it would work or, even, if it were possible given how wanting human nature could be.</p><p>Shakespeare is at the top of the English Renaissance because his plays, at least those we still read and care about, capture that great debate about what it means to be human. And very much like the rest of the age, they don’t offer any conclusions, or pat answers, to the question. Indeed, whenever a dialogue or soliloquy or speech seems to be on the cusp of reaching a conclusion it is interrupted. Ophelia’s entrance ends Hamlet’s soliloquy; her funeral’s arrival ends his meditation on Yorick’s skull.</p><p><em>As You Like It</em> is rather strange play. It is almost plotless. There nothing in it that could be considered action except for the wrestling match between Orlando and Charles. Indeed, anything that could be considered an action sequence — the overthrow of Duke Senior by his younger brother, Oliver’s burning of Orlando’s stable, even the killing of a deer — happen off-stage. Most of the play is set in the Forest of Arden, an idyllic, pastoral, Classically-inspired golden world where the characters “fleet the time carelessly”, engage in conversation, fall in love, and talk about what it all means.</p><p>The melancholy Jaques occupies that part of humanism that finds human nature wanting. To be anachronistic about it, he is a rather Proustian character like the narrator of <em>In Search of Lost Time</em>. He has been many things in his search for meaning — a libertine, a traveler, a courtier. All of his experience to that point has made him melancholy but not quite a nihilist. He is not a nihilist because he keeps up his search for meaning. He reacts to things with “a thousand similes”. Even at the end of the play, he seeks meaning by seeking out Duke Frederick who has adopted a religious life.</p><p>The Ages of Man speech describes the life of a fairly well-educated, well-respected, and well-off Elizabethan country gentleman. Probably not someone at court but rather out in the shires, among the landed gentry or perhaps a minor lord of some sort, Jaques’ player does all the things expected of him by society. This is a moderately successful life by the worldly standards of wealth and position. The ages are infant, schoolboy, lover, soldier, and justice. The last two describe the physical and mental decline leading to a death from old age.</p><h3>Jaques is very much like the medieval danse macabre figure put in medieval art to remind us we are mortal.</h3><p>But it also describes a life without volition, without thought, and ultimately without meaning. The good country gentlemen is merely a player on a stage. Players do not determine much of anything about their roles. Every action they take and everything they say is determined by either the playwright or the director. The suggestion is that our roles in life are determined for us, not by us. This was actually a hot topic during the Renaissance: just how much free will do really we have and how much our lives are determined by society or birth or God. This question, especially after Martin Luther and John Calvin adopted the idea of predestination, also fueled aspects of the Reformation.</p><p>Ironically, in the play, many of the characters are busy exercising free will by subverting social conventions especially around marriage, parental authority, and inheritance.</p><p>As for the seven ages themselves, they come across as unsatisfying, unproductive, thoughtless, and, in the end, utterly futile. The infant does nothing but mewl and puke. The schoolboy only whines while going unwillingly to school. The lover writes “woeful ballads to his mistress’ eyebrow” which is a wonderful way to say trivial and bad poetry. Interestingly, Shakespeare gives us a prime example of woeful ballads in Orlando’s poetry to Rosalind that everyone mocks including Rosalind herself. Well, she mocks it until she finds out who wrote it. As a soldier, the player can achieve nothing but “bubble reputation” for all his valor. The problem with bubbles is that they are short lived and pop easily. How many people remember Capt. A. Roy Brown of the RCAF?<a href="#_ftn1">[1]</a> The justice doesn’t advance the law or much of anything. He merely applies old ideas, saws, to modern situations. The last two ages are the long slide to oblivion.</p><p>Jaques has given us a well-respected life that is lived by societal expectations. It is also a life of futile striving. It reminds me of an old bumper sticker I saw: “Eat Right, Exercise, Die Anyway.” But what it is decidedly not is an inspirational life. It is, rather, an ordinary life with nothing in particular to either defame or recommend it. It slouches toward nihilism. Ironically, Jaques delivers it in a place that everyone else considers a golden world. He is immediately answered by Amiens who sings about life being “most jolly”. Indeed, the whole rest of the play is weighted against him.</p><p>Jaques is very much like the medieval danse macabre figure put in medieval art to remind us we are mortal.</p><p>And that brings me back to where I began: WTF. How could anyone take Ages of Man to be inspirational?</p><p>I have to admit the idea stumped me for a while. But I think I have discerned a few reasons why such misreadings seem to be happening with such frustrating frequency.</p><p>Part of it may have to do with the idea that Elizabethan English is difficult. But the Ages of Man is closer to modern English, in usage and grammar than many other passages in Shakespeare. Another part is that Shakespeare is so venerated as a writer that people just assume everything he wrote must be inspirational. I shudder to think what students would think if I confront them with <em>King Lear</em> or <em>Macbeth.</em></p><p>But a bigger part of it is that the quality of our reading has fallen. We are all expected to read too much, for work, to keep up with the absolute deluge of news, social media, and that endless stream of emails. The quantity of our reading, however, has diminished its quality. We don’t really read so much as skim and scan it all. We want to be fast and efficient with it. And we read primarily for information. Indeed, most speed-reading techniques teach that you can elide things like adjectives, articles, and, even, prepositions. It is in these clarifying and functional parts of a sentence where the subtly of meaning resides.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/255/1*ewYbd-Ji_hBau5kFXhrYSg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Title page of the <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_Folio"><em>First Folio</em></a>, 1623. Copper engraving of Shakespeare by <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Martin_Droeshout">Martin Droeshout</a>. From Wikipedia</figcaption></figure><h3>No, there is something else, something worse, for our culture at play here: toxic positivity.</h3><p>But a lack of comprehension and contemplation cannot explain why my students and that poster designer thought the Ages of Man was meant to be inspirational. No, there is something else, something worse, for our culture at play here: toxic positivity.</p><p>There is nothing wrong with having a generally positive outlook on life or, even, finding a few glimmers of hope in the darkest night of the soul. But when everything is viewed as exclusively positive, no matter how debilitating or destructive or miserable, is toxic. To focus exclusively on the negative parts of life, to see nothing but doom in everything, is as toxic but that is a topic for another day.</p><p>We all have seen movies or read essays touting toxic positivity. They tend to speak of a “wonderful gift” that usually is a cancer diagnosis or a death or a child born with birth defects or a debilitating accident resulting in paralysis or some other equally horrible event. Granted, horrible events can lead to a positive insight on what it means to be human. But to speak of cancer or birth defects as “the best thing that ever happened” is nonsense. The pressure to view every horrible event as something positive just adds another layer of rage-inducing stress. Bad things happen to good people without rhyme or reason or good results. To think otherwise is the stuff of Voltaire’s Pangloss.</p><p>The other main form of toxic positivity is the idea every life must be, in some way, extraordinary. For life to have any meaning it must be full of struggle, overcoming great obstacles, constant striving, competition, ambition, advancement, innovation, entrepreneurial zeal, and success. That we should strive to be mini versions of Bill Gates or Steve Jobs or Jeff Bezos.</p><p>But even worse than that is the impulse to force every life, except the most despicable, into the inspirational narrative of heroic striving. The idea of an ordinary life — one where you get a good job with an adequate but moderate income to support your family, do your job but go home at the end of the day, have a few hobbies that are not “side hustles”, live decently, be moderately active in your community through civic organizations or coaching youth sports, never causing harm to others even if you don’t necessarily achieve any great good — seems to no longer be good enough.</p><p>To be an ordinary, decent, middle-class person, like Jaques’ Player, may have never been particularly inspiring but it was the goal for most of us. And it was the policy goal for most of our history to foster it. Everything from the Homestead Act and land-grant colleges to Theodore Roosevelt’s Square Deal and Franklin Roosevelt’s New Deal to the GI Bill was about creating the conditions so that people could live that ordinary life. The idea infused much of our culture starting with Hector St. John de Crevecoeur’s “What is an American”, to Louisa May Alcott’s <em>Little Women </em>and Laura Ingalls Wilder’s <em>Little House on the Prairie, </em>through writers like John Cheever and Sinclair Lewis, to TV shows like <em>Leave it to Beaver. </em>Whatever we may think of these things, there are reasons why they were popular.</p><p>Don’t get me wrong, I am a big fan of living an ordinary life.</p><p>But I am opposed to the idea that ordinariness should, somehow, be forced into the realm of the inspirational, the exceptional, the extraordinary. There are two problems with this line of thinking. The first is that most of us know, at our core, we are not exceptional. The reality is that most of our struggles, obstacles, failures and achievements are relatively common, often minor, and never really affect the course of history. All this forcing what is generally ordinary into the realm of the extraordinary really does is create another layer of unrealistic expectations and, perhaps more perniciously, a sense of failure among people who would have been considered just a few decades ago to be decent, and valuable, members of their communities.</p><p>And people wonder why mental health issues, especially depression, have become so prominent in recent years.</p><p>The most toxic thing about forcing the ordinary into the extraordinary is its underlying assumption that for anything to be inspirational it must involve constant striving, overcoming, and winning. And the true and only measure of success, what we should aspire to, is wealth and fame, to be the supposedly self-made man like Bezos, Gates and Jobs. Any suggestion to the contrary is often discounted as impractical and foolish. The Henry David Thoreaus and Dorothy Days of the modern world need not apply. But to view life that way is, at bottom, to view human beings as essentially competitive. It is to subscribe to the myths of the rugged individual and the self-made man.</p><p>Except we are not and those myths are just that — myths. Human beings are by nature cooperative; we live in and build communities. Although dime novels and, later, movies made much of the lone drifter with his Winchester rifle and six-gun, the West was not “won” by the type of character played by John Wayne. The true symbol of the West was the wagon train filled with families, along with their cook pots and other household goods, who would, once they found a spot they liked, worked together to build towns and homesteads. Not exactly the stuff of an exciting movie plot but life is not meant to be a movie. The self-made man is equally mythic. No business can operate without workers, suppliers, bankers, and, indeed, the entire structure of society.</p><p>An individual alone can accomplish nothing, build nothing, be nothing. The whole sweep of human history is the story of cooperation on an ever greater scale. Ordinary people, working together, can do extraordinary things. But being ordinary is not inspirational. And the idea that everything, everyone, everywhere all at once must be inspiring is absurd. The hypercompetitive, extreme form of individualism that calls on us all to be extraordinary is false and basing our views on such falsehoods is by its very nature toxic.</p><p>Jaques’ Ages of Man speech is not and was not intended to be inspirational. It is an exploration of being ordinary, average and mundane. In that, it is a speech about being human because the vast majority of us are ordinary, average and mundane. And that is perfectly fine.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref1">[1]</a> He is the WWI fighter pilot credited with shooting down the Red Baron, Manfred Albrecht Freiherr von Richthofen, who is primarily remember because he associated with the imagination of a cartoon dog.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ab2e94f092e8" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[On Democracy and Its Perils]]></title>
            <link>https://pvincentbailey.medium.com/on-democracy-and-its-perils-a303e2b1d95b?source=rss-fd5ee0e29696------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a303e2b1d95b</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[democracy-in-america]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[PV Bailey]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 28 Jul 2022 06:27:47 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-08-01T03:36:37.127Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>What is democracy for and how we can save it</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/970/1*PJQpOyzoidtgGn_mVC-d8w.jpeg" /><figcaption>The true face of the Reactionary Party.</figcaption></figure><p><em>It has been said that democracy is the worst form of government except all the others. — Winston Churchill.</em></p><p>Undeniably, our democracy is in peril. Our unalienable human rights are being threatened or abrogated as we speak. In this, the oldest extant democracy in the world, some thirty to forty percent are seeking to impose a theocratic system of minority rule the likes of which haven’t been seen since the Puritan Commonwealth in England in the 17th century. At least that is what Mr. Justice Samuel Alito indicated with his opinion destroying our unalienable right to bodily autonomy in the <em>Dobbs</em> case as I wrote <a href="https://medium.com/@pvincentbailey/a-thank-you-note-to-justice-alito-762788854370">here</a>. What the Reactionary Party is trying to do and what their aims are should be abundantly clear to everyone by now.</p><p>And every day, we hear people talking about our democracy being in peril and asking why someone — Attorney General Merrick Garland, President Joe Biden, the members of the January 6th committee, the Democrats in Congress — doesn’t do something to save our democracy. But no one individual or small group is going to save us because democracy doesn’t work that way. Another problem is what isn’t being discussed — why should we try to save our democracy and what we need to do to save it. We need to examine democracy’s premises, ideals, and obligations in order to really understand why it is worth the fight and to fully understand how to save it. We need to fully understand why a democracy is a more human system than all the others.</p><p>For much of human history, most people have lived under some sort of minority rule. Today, there are billions of people who live under some form of minority rule. It doesn’t matter what kind of minority rule — kings, priestly classes, aristocracy, ideological parties (like fascism and communism), or just your garden variety oligarchies and dictators — they all share some basic features. The first thing they all require is obedience, not to the law but to the minority and its interests. The demand for obedience is always backed by force. Opposing the ruling minority never comes to a good end. Punishment can range from a loss of employment, to constant harassment by agents of the state to imprisonment and death. Vaclav Havel, the Czechoslovakian dissent that led the movement to bring down the communist government there in 1989 and was the first democratically elected president, wrote often about how he suffered all of that except death. The list of people executed for opposing such regimes is long and illustrious.</p><p>All of them rely on some form of censorship. Book burning, book banning, not allowing the publication of certain writers, controlling school curriculums are common because nothing can be discussed that dares to challenge the omnipotence or omniscience of the minority. Granted, there have been times and places where this aspect of minority rule has been lighter and other times and places where it was heavier but it was and is always part of it. We are seeing it now with all the pearl-clutching hysteria about what is taught in schools and on library shelves in places like Tennessee and Florida and Texas. It seems that this is always connected with the beginnings of minority rule.</p><p>Another common feature is the complete absence of the rule of law — that fundamental idea that the law should apply to everyone equally and everyone should follow the laws because of that. Any administration of justice is arbitrary and most people will do what they want if they think they can get away with it or have the right connections.</p><p>All of this is rooted in the basic premise of minority rule: the people exist to serve the state and its interests as defined by the ruling minority.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/960/1*lRjH33dDUtfpQ9uK8SKGvQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>The Unite the Right rally in Charlottesville.</figcaption></figure><p>But a democracy inverts that basic premise. The state exists to serve the people by creating the conditions so that we can live the life we want. It does this by allowing all citizens to participate in their own governance and in the governance of the state. And that means that all citizens, because they are equal participants in government, must be treated equally under the law. (Okay, all you commenters wanting to write that this has never actually been the case, understand I am talking about the ideals of democracy now. Reality always falls short of the ideal. But if we give up on the ideal because humans are not perfect and don’t live up to the ideal all time, then all the people throughout history and today who wanted and want to destroy democracy have already won.)</p><p>These are not exactly new ideas. They come from Aristotle and Pericles.</p><p>The Ancient Greeks also came up with some else. The idea that there is something called natural rights. Much later another idea grew out that: the idea of unalienable, now generally called human, rights. These ideas became inseparably linked to the idea of democracy. But there was the understanding that any exercise of your rights ends when it infringes on the rights of others; no right can ever be considered absolute. Your right to swing your arms ended at some else’s nose was how we traditionally explained it.</p><p>Countries ruled by minorities don’t care about human rights. Vladimir Putin doesn’t care about human rights; the Chinese Communist Party doesn’t care about human rights; the Puritan Commonwealth, so beloved by our rogue Supreme Court, didn’t care about human rights.</p><p>The idea of unalienable human rights of citizens became so important that protecting them became the primary purpose of democratic governance. Perhaps the most powerful and influential expression of this newer idea of democracy is from the Declaration of Independence. <em>We hold these Truths to be self-evident, that all Men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty, and the Pursuit of Happiness — -That to secure these Rights, Governments are instituted among Men, deriving their just Powers from the Consent of the Governed, that whenever any Form of Government becomes destructive of these Ends, it is the Right of the People to alter or to abolish it, and to institute new Government, laying its Foundation on such Principles, and organizing its Powers in such Form, as to them shall seem most likely to effect their Safety and Happiness.</em></p><p>This concise statement of the democratic social contract was written by Thomas Jefferson, an enslaver known for serially raping at least one of his enslaved people, and edited by Benjamin Franklin, who had been president of one of the first anti-slavery organizations in North America even though he had once enslaved at least three people. The path to democracy is littered with irony and imperfect people who applied their ideas in imperfect ways. But it became the basis for the Declaration of the Rights of Man and Citizen during the French Revolution, the Abolitionist movement, universal adult suffrage which wasn’t achieved until the 20th century, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, the Civil Rights movement, and, well, any movement for equality and human rights.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*zwDQOlZtkoixMEWlVDUmZg.jpeg" /><figcaption>American opponents of democracy tend to be remarkably consistent.</figcaption></figure><p>Our democracy is in peril. Democracy is always in peril. Democracy has always been a fragile system. It’s very nature makes it fragile. It can be undermined easily by demagogues. That is why Plato and Socrates opposed democracy. It is a short step from demagoguery to tyranny. Democracy is always a fight between those who believe in it and its premises and purposes and those who don’t. And those that don’t really believe in democracy have, historically, been very good at hiding their true aims until they feel comfortable enough in their position of power to openly impose their will on everyone else. That seems to be the point we are in now.</p><p>Until that point they are excellent at manipulating the language of democracy to achieve their ends.</p><p>Any system of minority rule requires only one thing from the people: obedience. A democracy makes demands on its citizens. Demands that are sometimes difficult and uncomfortable. When people stop fulfilling those demands, the antidemocratic forces begin to take over. This is what makes democracy so fragile.</p><p>The first demand is that you believe in democratic governance; you believe that government is how the people come together, either directly or through elected representatives, to solve problems. You have to believe that it can be effective. But far too many of us simply stopped believing in this basic idea. Ronald Reagan claimed, despite all the evidence to the contrary, that democratic governance was the biggest problem in society. Those aren’t his exact words but that was really what he meant — government is ineffective and incapable of doing anything well so we should just stop trying.</p><p>He won reelection by carrying 49 states.</p><p>After that, it seemed that no one was willing to stand up for democratic governance or willing to stand against the equally false premises of economic anarchy, so-called neoliberal economics, would solve all our problems. Even Bill Clinton and Barak Obama bought into those judging by whom they appointed to their economic teams. The most false, and pernicious to democracy, of those false premises is that people are inherently selfish and competitive.</p><p>That leads us to the idea that citizens need to think about more than just yourself. Some people, on both sides of the aisle seem to find this demand to be very difficult. The question should never be “Are you better off than you were four years ago?” as Reagan, steeped in that neoliberal thinking, had it. The question should always be “Is the country better off?” The fundamental democratic principle is the idea that the healthier your community, the better off you and everyone will be even if any given policy adversely affects you personally. This is what Adam Smith meant when he wrote about enlightened self-interest. This is what the founders meant when they talked about the need to be disinterested. Disinterested meant that you should look reasonably at any given political idea without regard to your own narrow, selfish interests.</p><p>The next demand that democracy places on its citizens is reasonableness. This does not necessarily mean every political discussion needs to be a strictly logical, Socratic dialogue. But it does require certain habits of mind that seem to have been ignored in recent decades. The first thing necessary for reasonable political debate is a respect for and acceptance of facts. It is reasonable to dispute what facts mean but to trade in lies is inherently destructive. It is equally destructive to deny basic facts as well. You have to bargain in good faith. And you have to accept the idea that you may lose, either in an election or on an issue. If you lose, you accept that the other side will govern, at least until the next election. The next level of reasonableness is to respect your opponents as being fellow citizens who hold different ideas. In normal times, to vilify the opposition as inherently immoral, unpatriotic, evil, and the like is destructive.</p><p>These are not normal times. The reactionary right hasn’t engaged in reasonable politics since the 1990s. While the Democratic Party has had a few instances of being unreasonable on some issues, there has been nothing to compare with what the reactionaries have been doing. The Reactionary Party has also been very successful in rigging the game, through things like Gerrymandering and the like, to ensure their power. The Reactionary Party controls state legislatures in places where their party’s voter registration has them in the minority and in places where they receive fewer votes then their opposition.</p><p>That reality brings me to the most important obligation that a democracy puts on its citizens; the one that if we don’t fulfil it, puts democracy most at peril. That obligation, that duty, is participation. The duty to be politically engaged. Democracy depends on us showing up and taking part in it, at all levels. When we don’t we open the door to the end of democracy. This is not a new idea. It is included in the oldest defense of democracy, Pericles’ “Funeral Oration” in 431 BCE.</p><p>But to be a reasonable citizen in a democracy, you must first be informed, to know what is going on at the local, state and federal level. Too many of us simply aren’t aware. Our local papers are folding all over the country. While most of us know who the president is, do we know who are your senators are? Or representatives in the House? How about your state representative or senator? City or town councilor? School board member? The people on your local zoning commission?</p><p>Yes, I know that most state and local issues are often tedious. Reading a local paper is less enjoyable than keeping up with the Kardashians. Going to candidate nights or a school board meeting can be difficult, boring, and, well, the last thing anyone wants to do after a hard day’s work. But this is the true meaning of the expression “freedom isn’t free.”</p><p>The most basic form of participation in a representative democracy is voting. Most of us will turn out once every four years for presidential elections. But even then, voter turnout is only around 60 percent. Think about it a moment. A president has to appeal only to about a third of eligible voters to be elected. And people wonder why politicians don’t seem to care about what a majority of Americans want. They don’t need to. Voting is how we hold them to the mark</p><p>But a president isn’t a king with absolute power, despite what people like Bill Barr may think. He or she needs the support of a majority of both houses in Congress to get anything done. But in midterm elections sixty percent of us can’t be bothered to turn out to vote. Turnouts in midterms hover around forty percent. It’s even worse at the state and local level, especially in those states that have off-year elections or hold them on different days. There turnout seems to hover around twenty percent.</p><p>Lower voter turnout translates into more power for the most motivated political faction. The Reactionary Party is a zealous, religiously-inspired movement that is seeking to impose minority rule. They are highly motivated. And they represent roughly thirty percent of Americans.</p><p>This is why so many state legislatures are dominated by the Reactionary Party and why they have been able to Gerrymander so many states, especially in places that are more evenly split like Wisconsin, Michigan, and the rest of the so-called swing states. They can do it because the rest of us don’t bother to show up. A common theme in the discussions of all the voter suppression laws being proposed based on the lie of election fraud is that anytime an eligible voter is denied a ballot, our democracy is diminished. That is true. But it is also true that when eligible voters don’t vote our democracy is diminished.</p><p>The Reactionary Party is made up of zealots who always show up. Always remember that.</p><p>But voting alone is merely the baseline of democratic involvement. We also need to be activists. We need to volunteer for campaigns we support, door-knocking and such like. And, most importantly, we need to find people to run for office at all levels or do it ourselves. Those seeking to impose minority rule on the rest of us seemingly have figured out that if you want to rig the system you need to be active at the local and state levels. That means that if we want to unrig the system, so do we. But we really aren’t doing that. In 2020, 27 percent of state legislative races and 40 percent of local races were unopposed. State legislatures are the bodies responsible for Gerrymandering districts and local town councils and school boards are where books are banned.</p><p>Our democracy is <strong><em>NOT</em></strong> going to be saved by President Biden, or the January 6th Committee, or, even, the brave souls like Cassidy Hutchinson. Democracy will not be saved by any single savior. Want Joe Biden to protect our unalienable, human rights then work to get him the majorities he needs. Want to make Joe Manchin, who seems to want to frustrate progress on just about every issue, irrelevant than elect more senators who agree with you. Don’t want books banned in your local schools and libraries, elect local leaders who agree with you.</p><p>Democracy depends on all of us doing our part; holding our leaders to mark by showing up and participating. That is really what democracy is. Rule of the <em>demos</em>, the people, only works if the people, all the people, show up. When we don’t, like in 2010 or 2016, those who oppose democracy win. In 2010, many of us were disappointed that President Obama hadn’t completely fixed the economy or didn’t go far enough with the Affordable Care Act or thought it went too far or wasn’t hard enough on Wall Street. Whatever the reason people stayed home that year, what we got was the red wave, Gerrymandered states, the Tea Party pushing the Reactionary Party further to the right, and governors like Scott Walker. In 2016, the <a href="https://edition.cnn.com/2016/11/11/politics/popular-vote-turnout-2016/index.html">lowest voter turnout this century</a> for a presidential election, people stayed home because they didn’t like Hillary Clinton or were disappointed that other candidates didn’t win in the primaries. The result was nothing but violence, chaos and insurrection.</p><p>Nor will democracy be saved by institutions and processes. As the rogue Supreme Court seems absolutely hell-bent on proving, institutions are only as good as the people in them. Any institution or process can be subverted. The Reactionary Party is running candidates for county clerk and secretaries of state so they can toss out votes if they don’t like the outcome.</p><p>If we want to save our democracy, no other issue matters right now. Not inflation, not gas prices, not our disappointment over this or that policy failure. Besides, the Reactionary Party never offers any solutions to our myriad problems anyway. They only point them out to blame others and distract us. They want to overthrow democracy — rule by the people — in favor of creating a theocratic, fascist state where we will all be forced to live what they consider a “godly life.”</p><p>They may seek to destroy democracy but it is most imperiled by <strong><em>our</em></strong> apathy.</p><p>If we want to save democracy, we must get out to vote, get everyone we know out to vote. And we must vote for people who will defend our democracy and our unalienable rights. If we don’t show up, they win.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a303e2b1d95b" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A Thank You Note to Justice Alito]]></title>
            <link>https://pvincentbailey.medium.com/a-thank-you-note-to-justice-alito-762788854370?source=rss-fd5ee0e29696------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/762788854370</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[PV Bailey]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 06 Jun 2022 03:23:00 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-07-28T15:26:57.206Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>You have made it abundantly clear what the goal of the last forty years of reactionary politics is really all about.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*9ELagkpdAg4rXAFPu1_IYw.jpeg" /></figure><p>Mr. Justice Samuel Alito,</p><p>I want to thank you for confirming everything I have ever said about the reactionary movement in America and the party of reaction, the so-called Republican Party. I really cannot call you or the rest of your movement conservative because you really aren’t; you all haven’t been since Ronald Reagan was in the White House. A basic principle of being conservative had been, before that, was that once a right or privilege was established it should never be repealed. That is not my interpretation; it is almost a direct quote from Edmund Burke’s <em>Reflections on the Revolution in France</em>. You should know that book; it was the basis of conservative thinking from 1790 until you reactionaries took over the discussion and falsely called yourselves conservative. Burke was almost as upset by the idea of revoking rights and privileges as he was horrified of the idea of revolution. Oh, traditional conservatives were always willing to violate people’s rights in order to achieve their primary goal of protecting the status quo but they never really advocated repealing them. That is how we got Jim Crow laws and yellow-dog contracts and redlining and blacklisting, voter suppression, and Gerrymandering, and, well, every repressive bit of legal gymnastics and legislation to keep our fellow citizens in their place. To actively repeal rights was never conservative; it is reactionary. And it is direct contradiction to the social contract laid out in our founding documents.</p><p>And for the last forty years, implicitly and explicitly, your party has proven time and again that they are not republican in the sense of our constitutional, democratic republic so I will no longer use the term Republican Party. It is only republican in the sense of a government without a monarch more akin to the Islamic <strong><em>Republic</em></strong> of Iran or the People’s <strong><em>Republic </em></strong>of China. That is what Reagan really meant when he said that government was the problem — he meant the idea of a democratic republic. That is why he so often spoke about doing an “end-run” around Congress, the elected representatives of the people charged with making laws. That is what former Attorney General William Barr meant when he spoke of a unitary executive, a theory first proposed by Thomas Hobbes to justify the absolutist power of a monarch. Such examples of your movement’s indicating their disdain for a democratic republic is almost endless.</p><h3><strong>The leaked draft opinion overturning <em>Roe V. Wade</em> was the most revealing thing I have ever read about your and your movement’s reactionary principles and just how far you all will go to fulfil them.</strong></h3><p>But what you, Mr. Alito, wrote in that leaked draft opinion overturning <em>Roe V. Wade</em> was the most revealing thing I have ever read about your and your movement’s reactionary principles and just how far you all will go to fulfil them. Not that there was much left to reveal about your false “originalist” ideas of the law except to make just how false they were apparent. We already knew that reactionary politicians like yourself (for you have shown us you are just another partisan like Sen. Mitch McConnell and the former president and insurrectionist Donald Trump) would lie, cheat and steal to achieve your ideological objectives. You lied, as did your four fellow partisans on the court, about respect for precedent to get your position. Mr. Justice Neil Gorsuch was even willing to benefit from McConnell’s theft of his seat on the court. You could have done what reactionaries have always done with the rights of the people you don’t like: restrict them to such an extent that exercising them becomes impossible. That’s what Mr. Chief Justice John Roberts wanted on family planning rights. That’s the tactics used by the architects of Jim Crow.</p><p>But, no, Mr. Alito, you came up with a specious argument to do what no so-called conservative ever tried before: to eliminate long standing rights of the people simply because you don’t like them. No one has ever gone that far. As I am trained in the study of history, I will assail your arguments from that grounds.</p><p>Your supposed doctrine of “Originalism”, the idea that the Constitution must be read only using the intentions and understanding of the Founding Fathers, is the foundation of your draft opinion. And that “system of interpretation” led you to conclude that only rights enumerated in the Constitution or “of long standing tradition” can be considered valid.</p><p>But the Founders did NOT believe that natural, sometimes referred to as unalienable and now generally called human, rights had to be enumerated. Seventeenth and Eighteenth Century natural rights theorists always qualified their ideas suggesting there were others NOT enumerated. That is why the Declaration of Independence reads, “We hold these truths to be self-evident…that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that <strong><em>among</em></strong> these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness. — That to secure these rights, Governments are instituted among Men….” And that is why James Madison proposed the Ninth Amendment to the Constitution which clearly states, “The enumeration in the Constitution, of certain rights, shall not be construed to deny or disparage others retained by the people.”</p><p>The idea of unalienable, natural rights included, going all the way back to John Locke, was that if you could reasonably assert that a right was essential to being human then it could be claimed and upheld. It is highly probable that the Founding Fathers would be shocked and dismayed that, as you claim, there is no unalienable right to privacy especially around family planning.</p><p>So much for your false originalism.</p><p>Historically speaking, your second test — long standing tradition — also seems to be flawed. Clearly, a half century and the support of a supermajority of Americans does not seem to fit your ideas of established tradition. Even though most Americans alive today never knew a time without this right. Perhaps it needs to be longer than your lifetime. Well, two years before you were born the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, drafted by a committee headed by Eleanor Roosevelt, was passed by the United Nations and signed by the United States. It included a clause about a human, unalienable right to plan your own families. Nearly eighty years apparently isn‘t long enough. No, you reached back to Matthew Hale of the Seventeenth Century to talk about “long standing tradition.” So long standing tradition must be more than a century before American Independence.</p><p>And the Founders, as active participants in the Enlightenment, thought any appeal to tradition to be at best a weak argument and at worst the epitome of unreasonableness.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/275/1*5DO6WiA9dNO7O3Qy3p3Vkw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Sir Matthew Hale</figcaption></figure><p>But your inclusion, Mr. Justice Alito, of Hale is more telling than you realize. It reveals everything that you and your fellow partisans really want for America in the Twenty-First Century. And no, I am not speaking about Hale’s support of witch trials, or his belief that a wife was essentially the property of her husband, or, even, his belief that it was a crime to abort a <strong><em>quick</em></strong> baby and that any prosecution for an unquick baby should only be allowed is extraordinary circumstances. A quick baby, for those not well versed in archaic English, is one that has started to move. No, it is not Hale’s horrid views about women that is most telling for what you want, Mr. Justice Alito.</p><p>In 1649, Matthew Hale swore an oath of fidelity to the new English Commonwealth. That is the thing that is most telling about your choice of sources. The Commonwealth was an attempt by the Puritans, a zealous religious minority, to force the entire nation to live what they considered a “Godly life.” A little later, Oliver Cromwell, another Puritan zealot, became Lord Protector of England; this is the man who made Hale a judge. Cromwell was a essentially a military dictator known for his ruthlessness. He ruled England with an iron fist inside of a steel gauntlet; he often used brute force to enforce Puritanical strictures on everyone else. It is considered by every English historian I have read as the most repressive time in English history.</p><p>And that, Mr. Justice Alito is what you and your fellow reactionary partisans really want, isn’t it? A zealous religious minority ruling over everyone else, where human rights that do not fit with your minoritarian views will not only be violated but repealed, where no one except those who agree with you can ever feel secure in their liberty, rights, or safety.</p><p>We have gotten used to you and your fellow partisans lying, cheating, obstructing, and generally undermining every institution, tradition and principle of our democracy. We, who oppose you, had been complaisant, however, because we never imagined that you had so much disregard for the fundamental principles and ideals of our republic. Nor did most of us realize just what you and your fellow partisans had in mind as an objective. Most of us just thought you all were merely power-hungry folks interested in nothing more than greed and “owning the libs.”</p><p>So thank you, Mr. Justice Alito for revealing what the right truly wants: a 17th Century theocracy. We are fully awake to you and your fellow partisans and your goals now.</p><p>A Citizen.</p><p>Coda: One thing I wish people, on all sides of the destruction of our unalienable, human right to family planning, would stop saying is that this issue only affects women. It does not. Every pregnancy involves men as well. When my wife was pregnant with our daughter, things got very complicated medically. My daughter ended up being delivered a month early by emergency c-section. We were told that having another child would be highly risky, if not fatal. Contraceptives are not 100 percent effective, as we unfortunately discovered despite all our care. So when my wife became pregnant again, we terminated the pregnancy. My wife is alive today because of that. Had Mr. Justice Alito had his way earlier, she would be dead and my world would be a dark, grief-filled place.</p><p>So, the one question I have for Mr. Justice Alito is this: Why do you want my wife to be dead?</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=762788854370" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Reagan Wasn’t Conservative]]></title>
            <link>https://pvincentbailey.medium.com/can-you-please-stop-talking-about-the-principled-conservativism-of-reagan-376bc7a6a299?source=rss-fd5ee0e29696------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/376bc7a6a299</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[trump]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[conservatives]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[reagan]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[history-of-ideas]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[neoconservatism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[PV Bailey]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 15 Sep 2021 05:00:17 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-09-28T01:51:46.595Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>He Created the Conditions That Led to Trump</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/330/1*Cb1LVaJKirF7u2YsfEWb7Q.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/330/1*5SXrTbJHSUDqMm_Hyf5j5w.jpeg" /><figcaption>Thomas Hobbes and Edmund Burke: the Original Traditional Conservatives</figcaption></figure><p>The Origins of Conservativism</p><p>The never Trumpers love to pine away for the “true conservativism of Reagan.” The problem is that Reagan was not a conservative. He was, rather, a right-wing revolutionary and an economic anarchist. But the likes of Joe Scarborough, Charlie Sykes, and Bill Krystol, along with others, natter on about the need for the so-called Republican Party to set aside the politics of obstruction, culture wars, and antidemocratic Trumpism. They want to return what they call the “principled, small-government conservatism of Reagan”.</p><p>“If we could just go back to what Reagan stood for,” the thinking seems to go, “then things could return to ‘normal’ and sweetness and light would once again reign throughout the land.”</p><p>What a load of nonsense, absolutely steaming nonsense. Reagan, by the standard of traditional conservative thinking, the intellectual political frame that held from Edmund Burke to William F. Buckley, was not a conservative. Moreover, there is a direct line of thinking that stretches from Reagan to Trump. (I’ll get back to that later.)</p><p>But even traditional conservative thinking, if you drill down to its core, always had obstructionist, culture warrior, and antidemocratic foundations.</p><p>When traditional conservatives point to the foundations of their ideas, they tend to point to Burke so we’ll start there. Burke wrote his seminal work, <em>Reflections on the Revolution in France</em>, in 1790 in reaction<a href="#_ftn1">[1]</a> to a speech by Richard Price. Price had hailed the French Revolution as the spreading of the Empire of Reason that included Britain after the Glorious Revolution, the Unites States after its revolution, and then France. Price’s thesis was that these revolutions created governments based on Enlightenment ideas rather than tradition. Burke started his rebuttal with what we would call cancel culture. He tried to paint Price as a fringe figure. He then launches on an attack on other English writers on religious tolerance claiming no one bothered with such ideas anymore. He posits the Glorious Revolution was about merely (his word) fixing a problem in the secession of the British Monarchy. According to Burke, it would violate traditional norms to have a Catholic monarch rule over a Protestant nation. He conveniently ignores the English Bill of Rights and the Act of Toleration, which were part and parcel of it and made Parliament the primary organ of government. He also ignored the fact that Catholic Ireland was also part of Britain. Such omissions tend to be common throughout conservative thinking. For Burke, any government based on anything other than inherited tradition was bound to be flawed and unstable. This was especially true of governments based on things like the idea that a person was “endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable rights” to use another writer’s phrase for it. Any rights that you may have had to be inherited. No rights were inherent. Burke used <em>rights</em> and <em>privileges</em> more or less interchangeably.</p><p>He then launches on a long riff about his absolute horror at the arrest of the queen of France. How horrible to have a filthy rabble come into her chamber to arrest her. He constantly uses adjectives like sweet, tender, innocent to describe her while those who arrest her are dirty, riotous, disorderly, barbaric. It is a long riff; so long that I wanted to throw the book against the wall and shout “we get it already.”</p><p>The Queen of France was Marie Antionette.</p><p>Only after wading through all this culture war stuff about the Enlightenment and horror at the idea of any kind of revolution, does Burke actually get down to what he thinks governing should be. It should be about maintaining the existing institutions, social order, and traditions. This entire section could be boiled down to four words: protect the status quo. Defend our way of life is a more popular way conservatives have said it in US history. But the result is that conservatives always resisted change.</p><p>Now to be absolutely fair to Burke and his intellectual followers, theirs was not an absolutist, obstruct everything stance. He does acknowledge that, as things change in society, occasional reform is necessary. But it should always be done prudently, slowly, incrementally, and not alter the existing order too much. And if those reforms include extending rights and privileges to new groups, they should wait until those new groups were deemed “ready” and “deserving.” Burke, in the context of 18th century Britain, was thinking about class. In the American context, such concerns inevitably were connected with race. William F. Buckley’s essential argument when he debated James Baldwin at the Oxford Union about civil rights was about waiting until African-Americans were ready for fuller participation in American political life. Indeed, Burke, like Buckley, believed that any change should be resisted until agitation for change became so great as to threaten order.</p><p>For Burke, governments were instituted among men to ensure order. That is the foundational social contract<a href="#_ftn2">[2]</a> for conservatives. For Burke, and almost all conservative thinkers until Buckley, the best way to maintain order was to protect the status quo. But Burke did not originate that particular version of the social contract. Thomas Hobbes did.</p><p>Hobbes was a straight up monarchist. The more absolute the better. A supporter of Charles I, he fled England during the English Civil War and remained abroad until the monarchy was restored. The great irony of Hobbes is that he is the progenitor social contract theory that did so much to undermine absolute monarchy by overthrowing the idea of divine-right kingship.</p><p>Hobbes laid down what he thought about “good governance” in his 1651 treatise, <em>Leviathan</em>. The best form of government is when all power is invested in as few hands as possible, preferably only one set of hands: an all-powerful executive. And by all powerful he meant just that: legislative, executive, ecclesiastical, economic, artistic, educational, judicial, or anything else that might influence the hearts and minds of the people. He called it the unitary executive. (Yes, I did a head snap when former Attorney General William Barr talked about the presidency as a unitary executive.) Hobbes believed that people needed this because human beings are so self-interested that they will behave like brutes engaged in a “war of all against all.” He called that the state of nature. The unitary executive’s primary job was to maintain order so people would not revert to being violent brutes. Too much personal autonomy was a bad thing for people, Hobbes thought. And he didn’t necessarily care about methods of maintaining order.</p><p>Almost all traditional conservatives believed that acting on narrow, base self-interest needed to be restrained.</p><p>Hobbes and Burke laid down the basic themes of traditional conservative thinking. Conservative thinking has, baked into its origins, autocratic tendencies. But, for Burke and most traditional conservatives who followed him, protecting the status quo meant just that. Once a right or privilege, or a norm developed, or, an entitlement became established, it became part of the status quo, no matter how vigorously conservatives opposed it in the past, and thus was to be defended. That is why President Dwight Eisenhower said that no conservative would propose getting rid of Social Security. They may not expand any program or extend rights and privileges any further but they wouldn’t roll them back either. For a Burkean conservative, the idea of stripping 50-year-old constitutional rights from women or suppressing the right to vote would have been anathema.</p><p>The other thing, going all the way back to Hobbes, was the idea that government had to be effective — had to perform the tasks set to it well. The single greatest fear among traditional conservatives was an enfeebled government that could not act effectively. While traditional conservatives might argue that certain parts of life and society should fall outside of government action, as do liberals, the size of government was never an issue. Too small of a government, one so small that as to be ineffective, able to drown it in a bath tub, was a bad idea. It would result in disaffection; disaffection leads to disorder. It is the reason Hobbes named his treatise for the largest and most powerful creature on earth, the leviathan — whale.</p><p>Born out of an absolute horror of the idea of revolution, protective of the status quo, obsessed with order, conservative thinking remained remarkably consistent until the late 1970s. How did this set of political ideas morph into what we have now. What changes led conservatives down the path to believing all government was ineffective, in economic anarchy, in reactionary social policies, and being supportive of insurrectionists? How did conservatives go from Edmund Burke to Donald Trump?</p><h3><strong>Enter the Neocons</strong></h3><p>Well, what happened was that three sets of ideas came together to help create the so-called Reagan Revolution. This in turn was reinforced by the “conservative” media bubble. The problem with all of these ideas is that they were, at least in part, repudiations of traditional conservative thinking but were close enough so that the Bill Buckleys of the world were willing to go along with them. At least until they were hunted out of the Republican Party as RINOS.</p><p>The first group were the right-wing culture warriors. The most predominate of these were evangelical Christians. They were largely motivated by a reaction to the removal of prayer from public schools and Roe v. Wade. They predominated because they were the most organized of the culture warriors under the banner of the Moral Majority, a political action group headed by the Rev. Jerry Falwell. They seemed to believe that the US was in moral decline because of the tumult of the sixties and seventies, especially on sexual matters and the “traditional” family. But they were not alone. RWCWs also included white supremacists and racists who were upset over the advancement of civil rights. Gun enthusiasts wanted to return to an imaginary time when people could carry weapons whenever, wherever they wanted. And then there were all those that felt like the America they knew, their way of life, was slipping away for whatever reason.</p><p>What they all shared was a sense of grievance over the idea that the liberalism of the 1960s and 1970s had gone too far, that the old verities of the past had been overthrown, and that this threatened their core values. And there was a belief that a gain by someone else represented a loss for them. There was also a belief that America was in a state of decline, losing its position in the world morally, economically and politically.</p><p>The other thing they shared was an absolute certainty that they were right.</p><p>What they wanted was a return to the past, to a status quo ante. At least they all wanted to return to an idealized, nostalgic, sepia-toned, selective memory version of the status quo ante. Mostly it was the 1950s that they took as a model. Of course, they weren’t really thinking about the real 1950s of Cold War paranoia, McCarthyism, Jim Crow (although some were probably thinking about that), women so depressed that tranquilizers were invented. No, they were thinking of returning to the <em>Leave it to Beaver</em> version of the 1950s.</p><p>None of this was in the conservative tradition of Burke and Eisenhower. This politics of grievance, decline, and nostalgia was straight up reactionary politics. They didn’t want to defend the status quo, the fundamental principle of traditional conservatism. They want to destroy the status quo. They wanted what traditional conservatives always feared. They wanted a revolution. That’s what Reagan promised. The Reagan Revolution.</p><p>Reagan legitimized part of these reactionary forces, especially the religious right on the issue of abortion. For the ones who wanted to turn back civil rights, gay rights, and other rights for women, Reagan dog-whistled them. The biggest dog whistle, of course, was when he gave his first speech after his nomination in Philadelphia, Mississippi, whose only claim to fame had been the murder of three civil rights workers by the Ku Klux Klan in the early 1960s.</p><p>All Trump really did was turn Reagan’s dog-whistle into a megaphone of reactionary grievance.</p><p>But, while he dog whistled and legitimized these forces of social reaction, Reagan seems to have focused much more on the two other parts of his revolution, both of which would exacerbate the grievances of the RWCWs. But these aggrieved ones would turn out to be the hard core of Trump’s base. These are also the ones Trump played to the most.</p><p>The second part of Reagan’s revolution were the right libertarians. Right libertarians have a minimalist view of government that posits government’s role should be, as Robert Nozick puts it in his 1973 <em>Anarchy, State and Utopia,</em> “limited to the narrow functions of protection against force, theft, fraud, enforcement of contracts, and so on.” Anything beyond the most basic functions necessarily entails infringement upon individual rights. Indeed, they have redefined liberty to mean that you have the right to do whatever you want, however you want. They also tend to have an absolutist view of individual rights, meaning rights without limits. Especially property rights. Additionally, because of their absolutist views on rights, they have a rather extreme view of the importance of the individual — that the individual is paramount to the point that they reject the idea of a common good. In that regard, libertarianism is a direct assault on the basic premise of democracy — the idea that people come together, through elections and representation, to try to solve society’s problems for the common good. It is a rejection of the principles laid down in the preamble to the Constitution.</p><p>Right-libertarianism is a fundamental rejection of the idea of a social contract.</p><p>Indeed, as we have seen from the anti-mask, antivaccine crowd in recent months, any appeal to the idea of the common good is seen as an attack not only on liberty but the beginning of tyranny that will lead straight to a soviet-style totalitarian state where any dissent will be crushed mercilessly. It is, of course, an either/or fallacy: absolute liberty, as they define it, or a completely collectivist society that crushes all individual autonomy.</p><p>Right-libertarians get that last idea from Ayn Rand. Right libertarians mostly to point Rand as the source of many of their ideas. Rand had been traumatized as a young girl by her family’s experiences during the Bolshevik Revolution. There is much to decry in Rand — her belief selfishness is a virtue, her false version of what objective means, her tedious writing just to name a few. But it is this either/or fallacy that informs everything she wrote, that is the core of everything she believed. It is the source of all the blathering today about personal freedom, even freedom to endanger others. It is best incapsulated by <em>Anthem</em>, the novella she wrote in 1937.</p><p><em>Anthem </em>is a dystopian novella about a collectivist future where the idea of individuality has been completely eliminated. Everything is planned by councils (the Russian word for council is soviet) and no independent thought is allowed. Equality 7–2521 wants to be a scholar but he is assigned to be a street sweeper. He also falls in love with Liberty 5–3000 in contradiction to the mating rules of the ultra-collectivist society. Equality rediscovers electricity and presents it to a council who are horrified he did unapproved research. They threaten to punish him so he runs away from the city to the forest where he finds a house from “the old times” which apparently has a lot of books. Liberty 5–3000 follows him. They settle down and start living lives as individuals. It ends with them rediscovering the word “I”.</p><p>The message is clear: if you want to live a fully human life, then you have to get away from any sort of society or collective. If you want to live a fully human life, no one should be able to tell you what to do. Only an absolutist version of personal autonomy allows for a fully human life; any appeal to the good of others is tantamount to life in a gulag where any individuality is erased.</p><p>What did Hobbes say about too much personal autonomy again?</p><p>But the real core of the Reagan Revolution was not culture wars or libertarianism. It was economics. These ideas initially went by many different names: Reaganomics, Supply-side Economics, the Austrian School, the University of Chicago School. Today they are called Neoliberalism. The godfather of Neoliberalism is Friedrich August Von Hayek. His ideas and premises informed much of Reagan’s economic platform and small-government conservativism.</p><p>Hayek’s family of minor Hapsburg noblemen and scholars had been severely impacted by the hyperinflation following the collapse of the Empire at the end of World War I. He formulated his ideas at the London School of Economics, largely in opposition to the ideas developed at the same time by John Maynard Keynes at the University of Cambridge. Keynesian economics would dominate economic policy from the 1930s until, really, the elections of Reagan and Margaret Thatcher — the other great proponent of supply-side economics. Hayek began by redefining liberty as not being about rights to participate in governance, or a commitment to human rights, or, indeed, any of the principles long associated with the term. For Hayek, liberty meant a “policy that deliberately adopts competition, markets and pricing as its ordering principles.” His basic premise is society has become so complicated that any sort of economic planning would always be a bad decision that would introduce inefficiency and negative outcomes. The only way to have an efficient, productive economy is to allow self-interested people participate in unregulated markets. Hayek uses the terms “freedom” and “liberty” interchangeably. All that is from his 1943 <em>The Road to Serfdom.</em> The title makes it clear, Hayek’s is a slippery slope argument. Any government action to regulate markets will ultimately lead to an unfree, soviet-style socialist society. Indeed, according to Hayek, the only economic policy that doesn’t lead to dystopia is controlling the money supply by keeping interest rates and inflation low. That’s the <em>supply </em>in supply-side economics. It never had anything to do with the production of goods and services. It had everything to do with stock markets and investment banking. Fiscal policy, things like spending on infrastructure, education, social programs, and basic science, took a back seat to deregulating markets, tax cuts, keeping interest rates low, and controlling inflation. Indeed, except for defense spending, Reagan decried all other fiscal policy as big government spending.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/330/1*o768Msd-wa7svAB_0oSKtw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Ronald Reagan the Revolutionary</figcaption></figure><p>Had Hayek stopped there, it would have been bad enough but he wasn’t quite finished yet. In 1960, he published <em>The Constitution of Liberty, </em>the book Margaret Thatcher liked to wave around proclaiming, “This is what we believe.” In it he wrote about how “liberty” had to be balanced with “personal responsibility.” But, if you remember how Hayek defines liberty as the right to be selfishly self-interested in a completely unregulated market, it becomes clear that personal responsibility means you are responsible for your <em>economic</em> situation and should solve your economic problems by yourself. Pull yourself up by your bootstraps. Don’t expect anyone, especially government, to help you. Further, he argues that the coercive power of government should only be used to restrain those that would restrict other people’s liberty in that free market — like unions, consumer rights groups, environmental groups and the like. State power should only be used against those who would restrict the free market.</p><p>There we have it, the three strands of neoconservative thinking: a religion-infused reactionary view of the social order, an extreme version of individual autonomy based on selfishness that includes, at its bottom, a denial of the idea of a social contract, and a belief in essentially economic anarchy, as Keynes viewed Hayek’s main ideas, that posited hypercompetitive self-interest operating in an unregulated marketplace was liberty. The last two, as they broke down local economies and a sense of community, fed the first by creating ever more people who felt aggrieved. But all three strands were able to couch their rhetoric in terms of liberty and freedom although all three were defining those terms in ways alien to any traditional meaning of the terms. And all of them are inherently absolutist in their thinking. And all of it was a far cry from traditionally conservative views rooted in ideas about the status quo, respecting institutions, effective governance, and absolute horror at revolution put forth by Burke and the like.</p><h3>History Aids the Neocons in Driving Out Traditional Conservatives</h3><p>So the question really becomes how did these ideas come to displace the traditional, conservative thinking that held sway from the 1790s until the 1980s? How did these absolutist, reactionary, and, arguably, anarchic ideas become the dominate version of “conservative” thinking?</p><p>Three historical events played a large hand in the ascendency of the three strands of neoconservative ideas.</p><p>The first was the oil glut of the 1980s. Much of the stagnation and inflation of the 1970s had been caused by the oil shocks beginning in the early seventies when oil prices soared. The oil shocks were caused by geopolitics — Arab nations, especially Saudi Arabia, withheld oil production as political leverage because of the Arab-Israeli conflict. Gas prices soared; if you’re old enough you should remember the gas lines, the restrictions based license plate numbers, and no gas signs at gas stations. It was the primary cause of inflation and cuts in industrial production leading to unemployment. This was called stagflation. The dirty secret of industrial economies is that they depend on cheap energy. But oil prices collapsed to $10 a barrel in the mid-eighties. Low oil prices meant low inflation and the economy picked up again. Reagan claimed that it was his Hayek-based, free-market policies had caused the return of prosperity. The tactic worked so well that in the 1988 Democratic presidential primaries only one candidate, Richard Gephardt, questioned whether free trade/free markets was a good idea. He lost.</p><p>The true results of the economic policies of Reagan and his followers would not be really felt until decades later.</p><p>Then came 1989.</p><p>There are times when I feel like no one remembers 1989 and the great hope that was in the air. Beginning on April 15th Chinese students began a protest in Tiananmen Square. While the protests were still on-going, Soviet Premier Mikhail Gorbachev arrived for a summit with Chinese leaders. That lead to the arrival of the international press corps who, in addition to covering the summit, also covered the protest. After Gorbachev left, the Chinese shut down the international press in Beijing and violently cleared the square on June 4th. But not before the students’ message reached the wider world. They were protesting for “democracy, freedom, and human rights.”</p><p>Those Chinese students sparked protests throughout the Soviet bloc, in Berlin and Prague, in Budapest and Sofia, in every capital behind the Iron Curtain. Gorbachev, unlike previous Soviet leaders, did NOT send the Red Army with its tanks to suppress the protests. One by one, communist governments fell until by New Year’s Eve 1989 only the Soviet Union remained. The Soviet Union itself would collapse a little more than a year later in 1991.</p><p>And the protesters all said they were doing it for democracy, freedom, and human rights.</p><p>But leaders in the West, especially Republican President George H.W. Bush and Conservative Prime Minister Thatcher, called it a great victory for….wait for it, <strong><em>capitalism</em></strong>. And by capitalism, they meant free market, Hayek-inspired capitalism. So rather than sending people knowledgeable about things like how to run elections, or jurists to help set up independent judiciaries, or people knowledgeable about how legislatures work, Bush sent a lot of advisors reengineer economies and privatize industries and create free markets.</p><p>Especially in America, free-market, neoliberal capitalism was triumphant. And Reagan was credited with bringing down the Soviet Union. But the real result of Reaganomics, the inequality, stagnation, shrinking of the middle class, the obscene concentrations of wealth, would not really be felt for another couple of decades. Not really felt until 2008 and the financial crisis.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*BazJXfm1zOJj5n8AICtXLQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Rush Limbaugh</figcaption></figure><p>The last event was barely noticed at the time but would have a major role in helping creating the conditions that Trump so easily exploited. Reagan often spoke of “liberal bias” in the media whenever coverage went against him. Not really that far from Trump’s calling the nonconservative press “fake news” which is not that far from calling the press the “enemy of the people”. In 1987, Reagan succeeded in eliminating the fairness doctrine that required broadcasters to present both sides of a political issue. He often said it was his proudest achievement.</p><p>One of the first results of this was a rather bizarre radio syndication deal for a radio personality from an obscure station in California named Rush Limbaugh. It was bizarre in that radio stations didn’t have to pay for his show except for allowing the syndicator to sell four minutes of advertising for each hour. Limbaugh then took the idea of “liberal bias” and applied to not only the press, but also universities, government, and, well, experts of any kind including scientists. By the middle of the 1990s, this was taken up by Fox News and other outlets. And it worked, people on the right began to believe that only Rush, Fox and similar outlets were credible sources of news.</p><p>It was, and still is, insidious. Rush and Fox convinced people to trust them not because they had better information or better arguments but because they taught their listeners to not trust anyone else. Not to trust people who actually know or study things.</p><p>When they weren’t doing that, they were feeding the aggrieved a never-ending supply of scapegoats, conspiracy theories, and fallacious arguments. It’s the Clintons, feminists, gays, government, African-Americans, immigrants (especially those not from Europe), Democrats, and liberals — always those evil liberals — who are coming to destroy your way of life and were responsible for every bad thing in America. When they weren’t doing that, they were busy hunting RINOs — what they called traditional, Burkean conservatives — out of the Republican party.</p><p>Meanwhile, the results of that Hayek-based neoliberal economic system was blasting the economies of small towns throughout the country and Rand-based libertarianism was shredding their sense of community. Both of them, also, made it harder to deal with the increasing number of social problems they created.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/474/1*F1kn9hcwqa3ULPvU1D7tJw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Donald Trump fulfilled the Reagan Revolution</figcaption></figure><p>This just created more aggrieved RWCWs because they were already in a neoconservative media bubble.</p><p>By the mid-1990s that bubble was already in place. I lived in Missouri then. If you traveled around the Midwest and parts of the South in those years you saw lots small towns with dying business districts. But if you went into a restaurant or a bar that had a TV, it was always on Fox. Most people had their car radios preset to Rush. The right-wing echo chamber was merely reinforced by the internet and social media. It existed long before most people even knew what the internet was.</p><p>In the end, Trump did NOT create the current mindset of the erstwhile Republican Party of radical social reaction, extreme individualism, antidemocratic tendencies, and selfishness. He was just was better at exploiting it. What Trump and Trumpism really are is both the symptom and culmination of the Reagan Revolution.</p><p>And so I would like to tell Messrs. Scarborough, Sykes, and Kristol, along with all the others who want to return to the good old days of Reagan, to stop it. Because all you are really doing is advocating for the very things that made Trump possible. Reagan wasn’t conservative; Trump isn’t either. They are two sides of the same coin.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref1">[1]</a> Just an interesting side note, Thomas Paine wrote <em>The Rights of Man</em> in reaction to Burke’s reaction to Price. If you ever get a chance to read about the Enlightenment, a good way to view it is as a grand dialogue about what it means to be human and an individual in society. Everyone seemed to be writing in response to someone else.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref2">[2]</a> Here I want to define my terms. At its most basic, social contract theory is the idea that governments are created by human beings to serve particular purposes. It was in many ways a rejection of divine-right monarchy. Supernatural, or indeed any nonhuman force like Marx’s material dialectic, explanations need not apply. One of the reasons why there is such confusion about the idea of the social contract is that the writers and thinkers about it don’t agree on what those purposes are or what obligations and rights individuals have to the larger society.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=376bc7a6a299" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Howard University Just Stabbed Me in the Back, A Defense of the Liberal Arts: Part Three, How we…]]></title>
            <link>https://pvincentbailey.medium.com/howard-university-just-stabbed-me-in-the-back-a-defense-of-the-liberal-arts-part-three-how-we-a736617e1b36?source=rss-fd5ee0e29696------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a736617e1b36</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[society]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[education]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[howard-university]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[PV Bailey]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 27 Jul 2021 10:02:58 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-07-27T10:02:58.855Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>Howard University Just Stabbed Me in the Back, A Defense of the Liberal Arts: Part Three, How we got here and what we need to decide.</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*hegOzzNjU_gPVKSFg69PkA.jpeg" /></figure><p>So, how did we get here? How did we go from viewing Classics-based liberal arts as essential to workings of a democratic society, the fount of innovation, and, as W. E. B. DuBois called it, an education for the whole person to viewing it as useless, elitist, impractical, and unnecessary?</p><p>There seems to be a confluence of shifts in policy and culture that landed us here.</p><p>The first was President Reagan’s education dismantlement reform effort. In 1980, he set up a presidential commission because there was a lot of concern that American students were falling behind the rest of the world and that our schools were failing to help create a “competitive” workforce. The commission had twelve school administrators on it but only one classroom teacher. What they produced was <em>A Nation at Risk</em>. Not surprisingly, much of it was dedicated to the idea that students were lazy and teachers were unaccountable. Reagan and his followers used this as the basis of their “reform” effort of Back to Basics.<a href="#_ftn1">[1]</a> “‘Tell them you want the basics in your school and parents back in charge,’ Reagan said. ‘Tell them education must never become a political football because your children come first, and they must come first.’” (Sandler) Most of the controversy was over reforms affecting teachers and his attempts to weaken teachers’ unions. And the rest of the controversy was around Reagan’s attempt to cut education funding. It was about this time you start hearing the now very worn argument that “it’s never been proven that money will solve our education problems.” But that emphasis on “the basics in your school” did not generate much controversy but gained traction.</p><p>But what did “basics” actually translate to? Skills over content. The treating of things like comprehension, grammar, and critical thinking as discrete skills. At the same time, it also meant less substantive content — the very thing that those skills were honed on historically. And if you remove that substantive content, skills like critical thinking become abstracted, disconnected to things, and brittle.</p><p>And then George W. Bush came along with his No Child Left Behind Act with its emphasis on high-stakes standardized tests. If you believe education should be about teaching young people how to think for themselves, or how to question the nature of things, or how to engage in civic affairs reasonably, or inspiring a certain level of curiosity about the world, or how to make connections between different types of information, or inculcating a sense of beauty then there is nothing more pernicious than high-stakes standardized testing. I have taught at universities in east Asia where high-stakes standardized tests are the norm. Here is what happens in such systems: the curriculum narrows to only to what is on the test, rote memorization replaces interpretation and analysis, writing is diminished, and context, connections between subject areas, and discussion and argumentation are all either seriously downplayed or lost altogether. What students learn in such systems is to never question anything, there is only one right answer to every question, don’t be curious, learning is nothing more than memorizing information, and, lastly, don’t be different. All very negative lessons. Since school funding was tied to the tests, this particular emphasis had a much greater impact on poorer schools.</p><p>And it is in elementary and high school where the initial broad outlines and the basics of the habits of mind are laid down.</p><p>But the biggest change to how people view education, to the detriment of the humanities and any larger, societal purposes of education was best encapsulated by Barak Obama. In 2014, he said “…[F]olks can make a lot more, potentially, with skilled manufacturing or the trades than they can with an art history degree.” Yes, I know he went to say that he enjoyed art history, whatever that may mean, and that some art historians can go on to have “good careers,” whatever that may mean. And he did later apologize.</p><p>But the underlying assumption that Obama was espousing was that education, first and foremost, is about personal economic gain. Indeed, personal economic gain is the goal whenever I have read about education policy in recent years, decades, the language is decidedly the language of commerce. Young people attending school, and their parents, are no longer students and parents but <em>education consumers</em>, educational outcomes are spoken of as <em>returns on investment</em>. Any time a larger aim for education is mentioned, it, too, is thought of in strictly economic terms. Reagan’s commission was charged with coming up with proposals for <em>a competitive workforce.</em> Indeed, education policy makers often speak of workforce development, competing globally, winning the future, meeting the demands of tomorrow’s workforce.</p><p>The message is clear: education is about economics. That’s it, take it or leave it. No other purpose need apply. It is all a far cry from President Kennedy who said that art was a root of civilization, poetry was a cure for arrogance, and education was the way to advance knowledge and spread truth.</p><p>But this shift in how education was viewed did not happen in a vacuum. It was part of a cultural shift where <em>everything</em> began to be viewed in personal economic terms and wealth became the only barometer of success. It began in the eighties with the rise of neoliberal economy theory. The thing about neoliberal economic theories, as horrible as they turned out to be, is that they rested on certain cultural attitudes that became apparent in the eighties that I would argue are just as pernicious as its economic outcomes. And those attitudes were best presented by a movie of the eighties that was both a critical and box office success.</p><p>No, I am not referring to <em>Wall Street</em> with Michael Douglas’ infamous “Greed is Good” speech. In that movie there are still countervailing forces to the neoliberal thinking. After all, Gordon Gekko is carted off to jail for his sins in the end. No, the true neoliberal movie is <em>Risky Business, </em>Tom Cruise’s breakout movie from four years before <em>Wall Street. </em>Set in an extremely wealthy suburb of Chicago, the movie opens with Joel Goodson, Cruise’s character, and his friends being hypercompetitive about their SAT scores while discussing the purpose of going to college. Their purpose in education is to make a lot of money. No one, at any point, suggests any other reason. Then Joel’s parents leave town on a trip so he can live without restraint/regulation. During that time he hooks up with a prostitute name Lana, played by Rebecca De Mornay, who steals his mother’s valuable Steuben Glass egg, and he wrecks his father’s Porsche. To get out of the hole he has dug himself, he opens a one-night brothel in his family’s home, makes a ton of cash, and is interviewed for Princeton while the brothel is operating. In the end, Joel gets everything back; his parents never find out about anything; he is accepted into Princeton; he even wins his Junior Achievement-type contest by earning the most for his student “business” — trading in human pleasure. At no point during the film does anyone suggest what Joel is doing is wrong like happens in <em>Wall Street</em>. At no point does Joel suffer any real consequences for his behavior. And in the end he is rewarded with an Ivy League education in business.</p><p>Most people think <em>Risky Business</em> is just another ’80s teen sex comedy but it really is the perfect reflection of the culture created by neoliberal thinking. Everyone acts from a position of narrow, selfish, self-interest, believes that if you are entrepreneurial enough you will succeed, markets will solve all your problems, unrestrained/unregulated activity will lead to successful economic activity, and everything is transactional. No one ever shows any concern for anyone else.</p><p>These attitudes have seeped into every aspect of our lives. We use the language of commerce, markets, to describe everything. We are no longer patients — sick or injured people seeking treatment and comfort — but health care consumers. Young people are no longer students — people seeking knowledge and wisdom — but education consumers. We are no longer citizens but taxpayers or consumers. Everything is a market; everyone and everything is either a consumer or a commodity. Everything is evaluated based on personal economic gain; there is no other standard. This is what we have become. We are a society of Joel Goodsons.</p><p>We are constantly bombarded with the message that we are at an inflection point — on race, on democracy, on the purpose of government, on our economic system and inequality. Howard University, and the right’s hysteria about critical race theory, has revealed that we need to be at an inflection point on education as well. Do we want to return to the that humanist idea that education is, in part at least, about figuring out what it means to be human, to developing the wisdom and knowledge necessary to engage in civic affairs, to educating the whole person, as DuBois advocated, to be about sustaining a civilized society, and as an antidote to irrationality, selfishness and falsehood of the kind we saw on January 6th? Or do we want to continue down the path of education being about learning skills to be an economic cog, where critical thinking is downplayed, where the only standards that matter are money and personal gain, the more immediate the better?</p><p>Do we want, as Cornel West calls it, to break the tyranny of money and mediocrity or not?</p><p>Education shapes what type of society we live in. Asking what kind of society we want to live in depends on what kind of education we want to teach and learn. The time to choose is now.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref1">[1]</a> Interestingly, an emphasis on teaching basic skills was NOT part of the recommendations of the report. For high schools they did recommend “’…(a)4 years of English; (b) 3 years of mathematics; © 3 years of science; (d) 3 years of social studies; and (e) one-half year of computer science’ for high school students. The commission also recommended that students work toward proficiency in a foreign language starting in the elementary grades.” (Wikipedia) They also recommended longer school days and years, more standardized testing, competitive salaries for teachers (whatever that might mean), merit pay and a few other bits. (Wikipedia)</p><p>Series Works Cited</p><p>Sandler, Norman D., “President Reagan outlined his back To basics view of education reform” Universal Press International, June 15, 1983. UPI Archives accessed 20 July 2021</p><p>Wikipedia, <em>A Nation at Risk, </em>accessed 20 July 2021.</p><p>Comments from Cornel West, Eddie Glaude, Jr., and Wayne A. I. Frederick come from segments on MSNBC’s <em>Morning Joe.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a736617e1b36" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Howard University Just Stabbed Me in the Back, A Defense of the Liberal Arts: Part Two, How a…]]></title>
            <link>https://pvincentbailey.medium.com/howard-university-just-stabbed-me-in-the-back-a-defense-of-the-liberal-arts-part-two-how-a-85d6aa461397?source=rss-fd5ee0e29696------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/85d6aa461397</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[classics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[education]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[howard-university]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[PV Bailey]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 27 Jul 2021 09:44:25 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-07-27T09:44:25.909Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4><strong>Howard University Just Stabbed Me in the Back, A Defense of the Liberal Arts: Part Two, How a liberal education makes people reasonable.</strong></h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*gN9BMW3fG4oyLenAQcgtYg.jpeg" /></figure><p>So how do the liberal arts do all the things claimed for them? That is not the easiest question. Looked at from a certain angle, the humanities are the study of what it means to be human. Art and literature is the study of human imagination; history the study of human action; philosophy and intellectual history is the study of human thought. Seen from another angle, they are the study of people questioning what went before — every historical, artistic and philosophical movement begins with the questioning the validity of ideas that went before it. It means you are developing the habits of mind to question the nature of things, weigh their validity, and then create something new. Or not, if you find the existing ideas valid. You develop habits of mind that involve trying to understand what others think. That means you have to take into account meaning and context — nuance.</p><p>Understanding nuance leads to, perhaps, one of the more controversial aspects of what a liberal education: the idea that there is NOT one right answer to a question. I say controversial because whenever I have suggested this idea I have received some of the strongest negative reactions. I remember one discussion — I’ll be polite and call it a discussion — with an engineer I knew. He literally screamed in my face about flow ratios in water systems and how a wrong answer could destroy the entire system. And in cases like that, I usually agree with them and walk away. If they are calmer, I point out that much of life is not an engineering problem. The most fundamental questions, like what is a just society, what is democracy, what does equality mean, how does one “pursue happiness”, what is happiness, what is freedom, what is a good life, are all matters of discussion. But without any foundations or forms, without the habits of mind taught by a liberal education, such discussions devolve into opinionated shouting matches where the loudest voices are the only ones that matter. Recently, we have had too much of that.</p><p>The main way a liberal education trains the mind is through its principle form: the academic essay. This is not like a personal essay, rooted in an individual’s experience, or creative nonfiction, where the goal seems to be to tell a story, or a political polemic/persuasive essay like most op-eds, where the goal is get people to support, or oppose, some political or social idea. In all of these, artfulness is determinant to the quality of the writing. Academic essays are a very different animal where artfulness is helpful — everyone wants to write in the most effective way — but it is not determinant.</p><p>An academic essay is a form of writing where you try to prove a point with evidence and reasoning from that evidence. That is what every essay, term paper, and essay question on an exam you ever wrote in school was really all about — the evidence you marshalled to support your point (thesis). The first writing tip I give students is never write a first draft of anything until you have done the research. I, also, tell students you do not have a right to your opinion in my composition classes; you only have a right to an opinion you can support. Any opinion exists on a spectrum of validity from valid, meaning well-supported, to utterly invalid, meaning there is no evidence to support it. Then, I talk about is how to spot the difference between a statement of opinion and a statement of fact. “The United States is a great country” is a statement of opinion. “The United States has the world largest economy by GDP” is a statement of fact. That sort of thing.</p><p>Since the emphasis is on your evidence, you learn how to evaluate evidence. Is the source credible? Is the evidence complete? Is the evidence accurate? Is the evidence strong (meaning actually representative of the topic, factually based, credible sources) or weak (meaning not representative, an anecdote or outlier, not factually based, dubious source)? Does the evidence actually support my thesis? Is the evidence presented relevant to the topic or a deflection? What kind of evidence is it? Is the evidence true? Do this often enough and it almost becomes second nature.</p><p>The next big thing studying the humanities and writing essays teaches is how is that evidence dealt with. Is the evidence fairly stated? Or, to put it more simply, how to spot logical fallacies. It would be a waste of time and space to go into all the logical fallacies one encounters these days. Everything from the ad hominem attack to what aboutism to the slippery slope. But the process of writing academic essays does help in not only spotting them but rejecting them. Many years ago, I former student came up to me to accuse me of ruining Fox News for him because he said his favorite host, Bill O’Reilly, used too many fallacies in his commentaries. My student said he couldn’t do it anymore; he could no longer accept false arguments even if he agreed with their conclusion. (I took that as a win.)</p><p>And I took that conversation, anecdotal as it is, as evidence of the power of a liberal education to foster reasonableness, particularly in politics. He had learned to be able to disagree without being disagreeable.</p><p>But another thing a Classics-based liberal education does, if done right, acquaints you with the broad sweep of human experience. That helps you put things into context, have an understanding of how things have developed, and understand the difference between what is important and what is not. And it helps you figure out what is true and false. If ever there was a period where we needed thoughtful citizens to discern the difference between truth and lies, what is important, and an understanding of things, it is now.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=85d6aa461397" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Howard University Just Stabbed Me in the Back, A Defense of the Liberal Arts: Part One, What are…]]></title>
            <link>https://pvincentbailey.medium.com/howard-university-just-stabbed-me-in-the-back-a-defense-of-the-liberal-arts-part-one-what-are-a1a1575fda93?source=rss-fd5ee0e29696------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a1a1575fda93</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[PV Bailey]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 27 Jul 2021 08:17:34 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-07-27T08:17:34.997Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3><strong>Howard University Just Stabbed Me in the Back, A Defense of the Liberal Arts: Part One, What are the Liberal Arts and why are they important.</strong></h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*BOacBpZt7DTMyJbkNjL_YQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>From My Bookshelf. Photo by Author</figcaption></figure><p>Howard University, one of the most prominent universities in the country, is closing out its classics department. Cornel West of Harvard has referred to this as a spiritual catastrophe that undercuts the idea of a true education. Edie Glaude of Princeton has put the decision in the context of the larger assault on the humanities in favor of a narrower, utilitarian view of education. These pillars of African-American Studies at Ivy League universities seemed to alternate between outrage and sadness over Howard’s decision. They also operate in a rarified, stratospheric level of the academy that is a world away from my experience of teaching composition at state universities, continuing education programs, and community colleges. Down here in the trenches, these decisions seem more personal. It’s like an intellectual equivalent of Dunkirk where we may escape in the dingy of adjuncting but are stripped of the equipment needed to defend what we do or why we do it. No, it is worse than that. It’s more like we are trying to defend a fortress while our supposed leaders are ripping out its foundations and dismantling our ramparts to sell them to hostile enemies. Unfortunately, we are used to it.</p><p>Howard is not the first, nor will it, unfortunately, be the last to undermine us. The idea of a liberal education — one rooted in the liberal arts with the classics as both a foundation and inspiration — has been under assault for a while now. Wayne A. I. Frederick, the president of Howard, said that closing out the Classics Department was about “the need to provide a more contemporary education.” It sounds good. The arguments against the liberal arts always sound good. Until, that is, you realize what they are really up to. The attacks are always couched in terms like that: contemporary education, competitiveness, to meet the demands of tomorrow, better prepare students for (fill-in-the-blank word for either work or the future).</p><p>But I want to argue that not only is this the worst time to abandon the Classics and the idea of a liberal education, it is, perhaps, one of the few things that may offer a way out of many of our contemporary problems — from the tyranny of markets to social inequalities to our divorced-from-reality politics of division.</p><p>Resistance to the idea of a liberal education is common, unfortunately.</p><p>Whenever I engage students about why they are going to college, I often find myself the only one in the room defending the broader purposes of education that grew out of the humanities. Whenever I ask why are they there, a handful of perhaps more honest ones will say their parents made them go. But the vast majority usually talk about getting a better job or making lots of money. And when I hear political leaders and so-called education reformers speak about their vision, seems rooted in more macroeconomic terms rather than students’ decidedly microeconomic concerns. They use phrases like “meeting the demands of tomorrow’s workforce” or “winning the future” or, more simply, “the jobs of tomorrow”. Parents, my own included, tend to be more blunt when I recommend the humanities. “What are you going to <em>do</em> with <em>that?</em>” they ask. Education, for the last few decades at least, has been viewed in strictly, and narrow, utilitarian ways with a decidedly economic emphasis.<a href="#_ftn1">[1]</a> Indeed, in most of the discussions I have heard recently about education reform tend to use the phrase <em>education consumer</em> rather than <em>student</em> to discuss young people attending school.</p><p>But whenever I suggest to students there are other, less tangible, purposes to education, I am usually met with blank stares or suggestions that I am some sort of atavistic specimen of an intellectual Jurassic period unfit for the modern world. Parents have tended slightly stronger reactions to these ideas. Once, when I was talking to the parent of a teenager just about to go to college, I suggested that a good education should include some study of the old humanist idea of what it means to be human, how societies and cultures develop, and what it means to be an active citizen. He accused me of wanting to indoctrinate his daughter so she would become a “clove-smoking, beret-wearing socialist who spent all her time sitting around in cafes contemplating the meaning of her latte rather than doing something productive with her life.” Parents have always fretted about their children’s futures. Even Stephan Longfellow, Henry Wadsworth Longfellow’s father, worried how his son would pay his bills as a poet. But the concern for your child’s well-being, economic or otherwise, did not historically lead most people to reject the liberal arts.</p><p>But what is new is the idea that a liberal education, rooted in the humanities and classics, is a useless, irrelevant, and unproductive exercise. And that there are so few who are willing to defend it. By new, I mean within the last forty or fifty years or so. But such an attitude doesn’t reflect what the study of the humanities actually has been about and such an attitude closes off the perhaps the best path out of our many crises today.</p><p>To fully understand what I mean, we need to go back to the origins of this discussion. We need to go back to the Renaissance. The Renaissance is perhaps the most misunderstood period of Western Civilization. Most people think it was the rebirth of art and literature obsessed with ideas of beauty in art and architecture. It was and it wasn’t. The common textbook definition I just gave misses the point. To accept that definition is to deny the culture of Medieval period; ever hear of Geoffrey Chaucer? But when we think of the Renaissance, most people tend to think of the beautiful art and architecture of Italy or the soaring poetry of Shakespeare. What we tend to think less about are the ideas that guided and animated all that art and poetry. We also ignore what it was in reaction to, namely Medieval Scholasticism.</p><p>Medieval Scholasticism — the dominate intellectual framework for at least five hundred years — posited one explanation for just about everything: the will of God. The purpose of a human life, the idea went, was to get into heaven. When Classical texts were studied, one wouldn’t read them directly. Rather one would read the latest, church-approved commentary on, say, Aristotle. Indeed, Aristotle, for reasons I have never fully understood, was very important to the Medieval church. But by the 14th and 15th centuries, Scholasticism had reached an intellectual dead-end, became obsessed with arcane matters, and had devolved into irrelevance. And the Medieval culture that had supported it was waning.</p><p>About this time, that first generation of scholars we now refer to as Humanists, rediscovered, in dusty corners of libraries, original versions of ancient Greek and Roman writers. Among the first things they noticed was that these writers — Aristotle, Plato, Cicero, Lucretius — were nothing like those church-approved commentaries and they offered a very different way of looking at the universe and man’s place in it. It must have been so incredibly exciting and refreshing. The Humanists then set about setting up a course of study based on classical literature that they called the New Learning. This was original Liberal Arts.</p><p>But we need to understand what this Humanism was and, perhaps more importantly, what it wasn’t to fully grasp how much of an intellectual earthquake this new course of learning was. But first, we need to dispense with some of the nonsense that has come to surround the word Humanism. It was not about the idea that human beings can be perfect, whatever that might mean. It was not a rejection of religion or religious belief. Granted, the later version of it, called the Enlightenment, sought to de-emphasize religion as an organizing principle for human society and make religious tolerance a fundamental principle. Indeed, Humanism cannot even be called a coherent philosophy. Machiavelli, Thomas More, Shakespeare, Francis Bacon, Erasmus, and, arguably, Martin Luther were all humanists.</p><p>Humanism can best be understood as a philosophical stance that seeks human explanations and meaning as opposed to divine, supernatural, or, arguably, any nonhuman ones for human events. There was also a desire to understand nature as it actually is. But to be a humanist meant, first and foremost, studying the Classics-based liberal arts. Everything else they did — all that art, poetry, architecture, science, philosophy, innovation — grew out of that study, that curriculum. And that everything else had a private goal — worldly success, to be seen as excellent, and achieve wealth and fame<a href="#_ftn2">[2]</a>. A liberal education, well into the 20th century, was seen as a primary path to both social and economic advancement. It has a hard practical edge that would enable to person to skillfully navigate the world.</p><p>And that everything else had a public goal: to elevate people’s minds so that they could engage in public affairs is a reasonable way. The liberal tradition was about instilling people with the “wisdom and judgement” and “sustaining and renewing a civilized society”. That language is NOT from Lorenzo de’ Medici who patronized and guided the Florentine Renaissance for more than forty years. It is from the 1965 act the established the national endowments of the arts and humanities. Both the NEA and NEH were the brainchild of President Kennedy who said that art was a root of civilization, poetry was a cure for arrogance, and education was the way to advance knowledge and spread truth. He also said, when, in reaction to Sputnik and the then need to “win the future” by overemphasizing STEM, “…[W]e still need the men and women educated in the liberal tradition, willing to take the long look, undisturbed by prejudices and slogans of the moment, who attempt to make an honest judgment on difficult events.”</p><p>If there ever was a time when reasonableness is needed in our public life, then it is now when lies, conspiracy theories, and just downright craziness seem to be dominate. When fanaticism rooted in falsity becomes normalized, the result is chaos, the type of chaos we all witnessed on January 6th. Indeed, what have been the last several years but the triumph of irrationality, selfishness, and falsity?</p><p>But, before we discuss how a return to the classics-based liberal arts can be an antidote to unreason, I want to talk about what a liberal education does not necessarily do. It does not necessarily make someone politically liberal despite what so-called conservatives would have you believe. Studying the Classics and humanities may turn you into a revolutionary as it did Jefferson, Adams, and Madison; it may help you be a traditional conservative as it did Edmund Burke and William F. Buckley; it may turn you into a liberal like it did Franklin D. Roosevelt and Kennedy. It used to be a truism that as someone became more educated in the liberal tradition, the more likely they were to be politically conservative. That was until about forty or fifty years ago. All the hysterical blathering on the right about a liberal education as indoctrination to and the gateway for some fantasy socialist agenda merely tells us just how extreme they have become. And how they have twisted the word <em>conservative</em> beyond any traditionally recognizable definition.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref1">[1]</a> A quick internet search will quickly back this up. When I Googled “purpose of education”, I found a number of polls, particularly from Gallup, over the last few years that showed 85 percent of respondents typically said the purpose of an education was to earn more money or get a better job. Reasons such as critical thinking, learning about the world, fostering citizenship, or becoming a well-rounded person all consistently scored in the single digits. Mostly tellingly, Gallup and the other polling organizations all used the term education consumers rather than students.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref2">[2]</a> Fame is a troubling word today because we live in a world of celebrity culture. For the Renaissance Humanists you had to accomplish something that was either excellent, exceptional, or heroic. You had to do something: paint, write, build, create. Today all you have to do is post nonsense on social media to be famous.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a1a1575fda93" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[On Race and Grammar]]></title>
            <link>https://pvincentbailey.medium.com/on-race-and-grammar-aabb27ef573c?source=rss-fd5ee0e29696------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/aabb27ef573c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[race]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[grammar]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[PV Bailey]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 01 Mar 2021 05:22:18 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-05-07T00:23:55.314Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>“I was called a [n-word].” That is the opening sentence of an essay I received as a teaching assistant more than twenty-five years ago. To be accurate, it is the essence of it in meaning and structure; she used the actual word and, if I remember correctly, included a time and place. She then constructed a very persuasive argument about all the things that Black people can and should do to combat racism in America. It was a powerful essay that received a high grade. That I still remember it all these years later speaks to its power.</p><p>But something about that essay troubled me on an intuitive level. Something about her use of language seemed deeply flawed. And thus her essay was also flawed at a fundamental level. I did not, however, discuss this with my student; I lacked the experience to translate my intuition into anything approaching an articulate analysis. I was also reluctant to bring it up because I was a young white man uncomfortable telling a slightly younger Black women that there was a problem with how she wrote about her experience of racism. But that intuited something about her essay bubbled in the back of mind ever since. Now, since the police killing of George Floyd, the subsequent protests, and especially the insurrection of January 6 when the Confederate flag was paraded around the U. S. Capitol, translating that intuition into a more concrete analysis has taken on a new urgency. For the past several months I have been reading many articles, essays and blog posts about race in America that have reiterated the very problem I intuited all those years ago. It has to do with grammar. I think we need a new grammar on race and discrimination.</p><p>We use language to construct meaning, to understand reality. But language can also be used to obscure, misdirect and misinform. To use the wrong word to describe something alters how we understand whatever it is we are looking at or experiencing. This is George Orwell’s central point in “Politics and the English Language”. He focused on the intentional use of language to make horrible things sound like something positive or at least make them palatable. The modern example I like use in class is <em>collateral damage.</em> Collateral damage means a military unit missed its intended target and destroyed a hospital, a school full of children, a marketplace or somebody’s wedding party instead. Or, as is also the case, mistook one of those things for a military target. Most people tend to focus on such intentional and deceptive use of language. But there is also the use of vocabulary that is unintentionally inappropriate can also distort our understanding of things. This seems to fall into two categories: carelessness or because better terms simply don’t exist yet. For the former, misnomers happen, like all mistakes. The latter usually gets dropped when something accurate gains currency and the inappropriate. Once upon a time people now referred to as <em>transexual</em> were referred to as <em>transvestites</em>. The older term implied choice and fetish interest in cross-dressing while the newer term’s implications have to do with the intrinsic nature of a human being. (Recently, when it comes to sexuality this process is moving so quickly that I am constantly looking up the new vocabulary; the last one was demisexual.)</p><p>This has always been a concern. Twenty-six centuries ago, Confucius wrote about the need rectify vocabulary. Many of Plato’s dialogues are rooted in questioning the meaning of certain terms. Vaclav Havel referred to using the wrong terms as part of the evasive thinking inherent in communist totalitarianism. Indeed, most philosophy, political theory and social analysis can be seen as a discussion of what terms to use or what those term actually mean. This is not an esoteric concern. An inappropriate term leads to a misperception of reality which results in erroneous thinking. All this leads to ill-conceived action or inaction.</p><p>In the months since the police killing of Mr. Floyd, there has been a great deal of discussion of racism embedded in American society and the English language. Almost all of the latter has been on the level of vocabulary — the words we use to refer to people and things. But it was a discussion involving the use of <em>enslaved person </em>rather than <em>slave</em> that helped clarify what I intuited about my student’s essay. Harvard historian Annette Gordon-Reed explained that she preferred the use of the term <em>enslaved person </em>to <em>slav</em>e because referring to people historically held in bondage as an enslaved person restored their basic humanity while slave is inherently objectifying.<a href="#_ftn1">[1]</a> Ensuring that we do not objectify our fellow human beings is perhaps the primary reason we should care about how we say things.</p><p>But none of this gets at the grammar problem. Objectification, designating something or someone as an object, is a principle concern of grammar, not usage or vocabulary. Grammar is not, however, something people understand well, not really. When I tell people I’m an English teacher, they often respond by saying they had better watch their grammar as if I am just waiting to correct them. This is the wrong attitude. Grammar is not and should not be seen as a set of rigid rules used by people like me to correct them. Nor, if understood well, is it a means to oppress and exclude — as implied by a few commentaries that implied paying attention to grammar is somehow “talking white”. Granted, some may use the idea of grammar to exclude people or show an imagined superiority but to do so merely shows that those people do not really understand what grammar is or its function.</p><p>Words are the building blocks of meaning but grammar is the structure of meaning. When that structure is flawed, our understanding and our focus will be flawed. We all learned, way, way back in the first grade, the basic structure of an English declarative sentence is subject-verb-object(s). The subject is the actor; the verb is the action; objects are the acted upon (yes, there are other functions for objects but this is how they are first introduced and the most germane function here). This is drilled into our brains so early and often that for most of us it becomes an empty truism — something we accept without really thinking about it. But if you stop and think about it, that basic structure carries with it a profound signification. To be the actor is to be the active moral agent, the person or thing responsible, the person or thing the sentence is really about. To be the acted upon, however, is be on the receiving end of the action, the done to, the target of an action. Subjects are active and responsible; objects are passive.</p><p>Everyone has had an English teacher rail against using passive voice. I know I have and I have done so myself. We do this so regularly and, often, so badly that many people, including English teachers, have come to view it as merely a convention or a style choice to avoid being boring. Or we discuss how it can be used mendaciously as in “Mistakes were made.” Style guides and grammar help books reinforce these views with their examples and explanations. They usually begin with an anodyne example like: “The star was seen by the astronomers.” This is followed by a somewhat confusing discussion of the idea of a true subject, meaning who or what is preforming the action of the sentence, versus the grammatical subject, meaning who or what is being acted upon but is in the place of subject in the sentence. Thus, <em>astronomers</em> is the true subject because they are performing the action of <em>seeing</em> while the <em>star</em> is the grammatical subject because it is where the subject normally is even though it is the object of the action. Honestly, I can’t think of a worse way to discuss what the deeper problems of passive voice are. Such anodyne examples are just that: anodyne. They are meaningless, divorced from reality, and ultimately forgettable. Most passive voice sentences, moreover, rarely include that convenient prepositional phrase, like <em>by the astronomers,</em> that reveal the true subject.</p><p>But most importantly, such examples and explanations downplay the terribly important nature of the subject and how passive voice shifts the focus away from the idea of active, moral responsibility. In recent years I have used a different type of example to get students to think about the nature of subject.</p><p>“The student was hit in the head with a bottle,” I say. I follow it with a quick throwing motion with a water bottle in my hand. Notice there is no indication of the true subject other than my hand gesture. Then I ask the class what they would want to know if they were the student bopped on the head or saw it happen. Most of the time, many, if not most, want to know who hit the student — who is the true subject of the sentence. But there is always a sizable minority, and occasionally a majority, who want to know what the student was doing to get hit in the head. To that second group, I usually ask what possible behavior could justify such a violent reaction. These responses demonstrate the insidious nature of what the passive voice does to our understanding of things. It inverts the relationship between objects and subjects. It shifts the focus from the actor to the acted upon. That shift in focus leads us to put the moral responsibility for the action on the object rather than on who or what is actually responsible for it. And that makes us think more about what the object of an attack should have done differently so they would not have been attacked.</p><p>This brings me back to my student’s essay from all those years ago and to many of the things I have been reading about the Black experience since the summer protests began. Before I go on, I want to say I get it; I understand the purpose is to convey what it feels like to be a victim of racism and to discuss all the things people of color go through to mitigate or deal with racism. This is a very important perspective that far too many people need to understand. But much of it has read like my student’s essay from all those years ago beginning with “I was called…” or “I have been followed…” or “I have had my knowledge and skills ignored….” That grammar, that passive voice, still troubles me. My concern is that by inverting the relationship between the subject and object — that subtle shift in focus to acted upon and way from the actor — shifts the focus, and responsibility, away from the racist and onto the victims of a racist incident. And by doing so the question becomes, like my students in the example above, what was the person attacked doing to be so attacked. Any quick read of the comments section of any news article about a racist incident bears this out. They are filled with comments about not resisting the police or questions about the victims’ actions or dark suggestions about their past. All of it amounts to blaming the victim. All of it is absurd.</p><p>George Floyd was sitting in his car; Trayvon Martin was walking home after going to the corner store; Eric Garland was selling loose cigarettes; Ahmaud Arbery was out for a jog; Breana Taylor was asleep in her own bed at home. The question should not be what were the victims doing but what the police or armed vigilantes were thinking and doing that led them to kill. What lack of humanity led Dereck Chauven to drive his knee into Mr. Floyd’s neck for nearly nine minutes. The question for the rest of us should be do we really want to live in a world where police and armed vigilantes can summarily execute people for, at most, minor offenses or even mere suspicion with impunity?</p><p>Let’s be clear, racism is a problem FOR Black people but it is NOT a Black person’s problem. Racism is a racist’s problem. The responsibility for it lies solely with the racist and not with its victims. No amount of action taken by the victims of racism is going to change anything. They are not the ones who need to change their behavior or thinking. But if we really want to assign the responsibility for racialized actions, to hold people accountable for their racism we need to use a grammar that reflects that; the way we structure meaning, grammar, has to reflect our underlying moral understanding of race by making the racist the subject of the discussion. We need to stop using the passive voice. My hope is that by doing so, by that subtle shift in grammar and thus focus, will shift the discussion onto why racists act and think the way they do. That is where conversation should always have been.</p><p>And to my student all those years ago, I would have liked to say that it would have been more accurate to say someone, however she chose to characterize them, called her the N-word. Then the focus would have been on them and not her. And I would also like to apologize for my inexperience and lack of understanding.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref1">[1]</a> This was during an interview, along with her co-author John Meacham, about their new book, <em>In the Hands of the People: Thomas Jefferson on Equality, Faith, Freedom, Compromise, and the Art of Citizenship</em> on PBS’ Amanpour &amp; Company, originally aired on 26 June 2020. I stumbled across the clip in YouTube recently. I haven’t read their book yet but it is on my reading list.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=aabb27ef573c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>