<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Ronnie Lingard on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Ronnie Lingard on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@r.lingard9?source=rss-66b3eef183eb------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Fri, 20 Nov 2026 23:12:28 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@r.lingard9/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Part 3 (episode 2): Facets of a More Comprehensive Cosmology (part I)]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@r.lingard9/part-3-episode-2-facets-of-a-more-comprehensive-cosmology-part-i-5a56d20826d6?source=rss-66b3eef183eb------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5a56d20826d6</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[light]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[spirit-potential]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cosmology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[time-management]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[worldview]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ronnie Lingard]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 10 Oct 2026 09:46:01 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-11-02T08:00:22.110Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/788/1*AVZfsxh_n1MhVj5NEi-glw.png" /></figure><p><strong><em>With the benefit of deep space telescopes such as Hubble and now the James Webb we can look at the Universe in ever finer resolution. We can appreciate and be drawn in by its beauty and mystery. We can wonder at its vastness and complexity. On the other hand we can also find the Universe cold, remote and impersonal…it’s just a machine for churning out stars irrespective of whether we exist or not. Outer space is, after all, inhospitable to Life.</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>It is this paradox that the Universe is both inhospitable to Life and yet hosts the conditions for its emergence so that we can now appreciate its beauty; the paradox that it doesn’t seem to care whether we live or die and yet provides a nursery within which Life can flourish; it is this paradox that would call for a more comprehensive cosmology beyond what instrumental data or our untrained senses may tell us.</em></strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/95/1*3WvWTdTNgt7w0JzsR0zWMw.png" /></figure><p>The paradox that the Universe both affirms Life and at the same time denies it is an invitation to explore the relationship between these two seemingly contradictory facts.</p><p>The previous episode ‘It’s just a Wonder’ was written with a touch of poetic license. But what it was suggesting is that there is more to the phenomenon of light than its being a neutral mediator by which we see the World. It was also suggesting that, in its triadic potential to be second and third-born in living structures, in the holding of light in the form of in-sight and self-illumination, the Universe-Life paradox is gradually being resolved -spiritually not just physically - through the evolution of interiority.</p><p>Whilst seeing, in-sight and self-illumination are being presented as a 3-fold potential that is consequential in how we see the World the triadic template would nevertheless claim that all (9) potentials contribute to the light-bearing formation that the Universe is and is yet to become.</p><p>As well as light, the nature of time is also implicated in how we see the World. Together, these three are facets of a more comprehensive cosmology and the commentary below will offer some opening statements about each in turn to be followed up in later episodes.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/55/1*KT7VrvbPjQCeiPUI6POk6w.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/163/1*dqi6kNpD4AKUctFwHzMTgg.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/292/1*778xHAhA6qeFOBKr88RnSw.png" /></figure><p>As part of our ordinary waking experience the phenomenon of light is as familiar to us as the air we breathe. But its deeper structure and its meaning are of equal importance to the scientific and spiritual practitioner alike.</p><p>Spiritual traditions have always associated consciousness with forms of light. And in science it was the study of the nature of light — its speed, inner structure and radiative properties — that led to the breakthrough moments of early 20th century physics, the outcome of which expanded the principle of relativity to its most general form as well as producing a conceptual revolution through quantum physics.</p><p>In outer space stars are host to nuclear structures that generate first-born light and it is the recapture of this light, organically in neural space, that we are able to see and then know the world.</p><p>Being neither star nor pure spirit, we develop our understanding of the World in a realm of light that is second-born; in a realm that is internally rather than externally sourced; conceptual rather than perceptual.</p><p>True to its name second-born light has a double meaning. It faces two ways; outward to a world born of the senses and inward to an abstracted world out from which we fashion our world-views.</p><p>The eye, the optic nerve and the visual cortex form a dedicated pathway by which we come to conceive of a World of distinct objects and this is confirmed by the other four senses. A particular type of apple has a unique taste, oil has a different feel to water, a rose has a particular fragrance, an orchestra is many but each instrument has a distinct sound we can identify. We recognise and familiarise ourselves with this world of distinction and reconfirm it every day.</p><p>But from the very beginning of the possibility of sensory awareness with the evolution of living organisms, a gradual transformation of has taken place in the realm of interiority. What began as rudimentary sight, captured as an awareness of light and dark, has gradually evolved to reveal a vision of the World in ever finer resolution.</p><p>All Life finds its place within an available organic or biospheric order that is self-regulating. But human life, having placed one foot outside a world where evolution is continually resolving itself in slow-time, has entered the time curve of exponential evolution. Human life has to find solutions and resolutions to questions of how to be that the biosphere never had to ask.</p><p>Global evolution has proceeded at different speeds in different places but it is in Europe that the exponential evolution of second-born light has had a particularly significant impact on the World.</p><p>The Age of Enlightenment was a broad spectrumed movement across disciplines ranging from science to philosophy to social concerns about governing structures. It was also referred to as the Age of Reason implying that reason brings light into our understanding. Yet, from the perspective of the triadic template, there is another vital step.</p><p>Enlightenment thinker and social philosopher Baron de Montesquieu coined the phrase ‘being in the spirit of the law’ and tried to answer an important question about individual liberty under a system of social laws. His insight revealed the importance of dividing governing structures into three departments as a check and balance system: legislative (makers of law), executive (enforcers of law), and judicial (interpreters of law).</p><p>The reasoning was intact and the structure is still operative but the key element that would guarantee the wholeness of that structural triad was the ingredient that formed the title of his principle work ‘The Spirit of Law’. Without this ingredient, an ingredient that requires personal integrity, however well policed it is, the system fails.</p><p>So why dwell on this particular point?</p><p>Science has discovered laws of nature but are we living within the ‘spirit’ of those laws?</p><p>Without an obvious law-maker the executors of natural law, which is to say those who profit most from their usage, have free reign. Executors make for bad judges especially for profiteers whose world-view cannot see or refuses to see consequences?</p><p>Third-born light would say that we may resolve the World conceptually but it remains incomplete unless we also resolve the World spiritually; consciously. Without this ingredient the fact of the Universe and the fact of human life will remain paradoxical.</p><p>We see by virtue of a biological optic but unless we also see by virtue of a ‘spiritual optic’ reason grows dim and eventually goes dark. Without the Presence of a spiritual optic, reason is not enough and the Age in which it had its zenith gave way to its post-modern deconstruction.</p><p>This is not a ‘Luddite’ argument against scientific progress. The scientific enterprise is first and foremost is a spiritual pursuit and is naturally present in a child as much as it was in early human life and some are beginning to ask questions about the nature of natural law and the nature of the observer. Instead, the argument here expresses the need to become better judges of how we govern ourselves in the face of ‘exponential tech’.</p><p>Natural law and social law are clearly two different sources of law. Yet these two forms of law are not independent of each other. They belong to a larger triadic framing that require of us to be in ‘The Spirit of Law’. Without this ingredient exponential time will peak and fall rather than provide a new form of enlightenment.</p><p>This series is an open exploration of how the constitution of the middle sphere in which our world-views are fashioned may support the realisation of spirit potentials and how then we may see the World with new eyes.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/12/1*KagpDzSldkIk8nUCbgf72Q.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/162/1*yYPu1WLWKhjk5kj4k12KNA.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/303/1*Kwb5zvZ3L03W_F-Tl5S6uw.png" /><figcaption><strong>Reproduced from Part 2 episode 4 ‘Time and all things Abstract’</strong></figcaption></figure><p>Just as our senses would show us a world of distinct objects it would also tell us that time moves on.</p><p>First there was the physical world, then the biological world and then human life as a branch of the tree of life that now, with aid of sophisticated instruments, looks back through time almost to the origin of the Universe, perhaps in an attempt to close that cosmological loop.</p><p>The potentiality of (3), however, is not time-sequenced in the way of past, present and future. For the triadic template beginnings do not live in the past now gone. The triad as a whole is a domain of resolutions and deep time (Part 2 episode 4) within that configuration is being conceived as a continuum of new beginnings present in all spaces; actual, neural and spiritual.</p><p>The 3-sphere is <strong><em>intra-causal</em></strong> meaning that each part of the triad — deep time, timeless and timelike — is in causal relation to the other two.</p><p>The triadic structure of time does not deny common sense its sequential, timelike story; it only suggests that it is incomplete. When viewed intra-causally, if the timelike and timeless drop out of the triadic arrangement they become a dualistic subset in which deep time or perhaps better — new time — is then obscured from consciousness. Trying to solve the duality of timeless and timelike, then leads to another paradox of ideal versus real.</p><p>Common sense says past/present/future. Yet buried within the triadic framing of timelike, timeless and deep time the question of time opens up many facets of a more comprehensive cosmology that from different perspectives spiritual traditions and scientific theories such as relativity and quantum physics show is possible but not achievable in a dualistic framing that tries to separate the fact of Life (observer) from the fact of the Universe (observed).</p><p>If the principles of relativity and quantum theories say anything about the Universe-Life paradox, and I believe they do, it’s that this paradox is far more complex than the simplistic solution of reducing Life to mechanism and relying upon bottom-up emergence to do all the work.</p><p>Restricting the 3-sphere to first-born light (perceptual) and second-born light (conceptual) the feeling of <em>to know </em>may seem to be direct knowledge of the external World. But the intimacy being spoken of in the evolution of interiority is that light of the third kind is the Universe beginning to realise the ‘I-self’ of ‘Itself ‘and not just the itself of Itself. <em>[See the previous episode ‘It’s just a Wonder’]</em></p><p>The 3-sphere would see this realisation of ‘Self-Life’ in and of the Universe as the evolution of centre — an evolution of deep time — rather than an accumulation of knowledge.</p><p>Even so scientific knowledge such as the theory of special relativity tells us something unusual about first-born light that eyes and telescopes are not built to directly reveal. It tells us that, unless impeded by contact with or proximity to a region of mass-energy, light travels through that now idealised vacuum state at the very edge of time. At the speed of light, time drops to ‘absolute zero’ and time freezes.</p><p>This dualistic framing of timeless/timelike then begs a paradoxical question: If time does in fact stop with light, does light actually go anywhere? But surely it must if astronomers are to receive light from the Universe’s very early era of its expansion.</p><p>The 3-way framing of time poses a different question. Is this state of temporal stillness of light indicated by the theory of special relativity not just a ‘physical’ theory but a 4-D framing that conceptually mirrors but does not actualise a potential state of consciousness as having a timeless quality? Is timeless then a conceptual threshold that, for an external observer, would freeze time as an abstraction rather than consciousness becoming a potential holding state of third-born light?</p><p>Whatever the case about these speculations what this wondering does say is that light and time are somehow bound together not only as indicated by special relativity but perhaps even more deeply bound within the inner sphere of spirit potentials.</p><p>If this is true then the bonding of time and light conditions not only how we see the World but also how see ourselves as agents of change.</p><p>And this conditioning of identity within the world of second-born light concerns the third facet of this 3-fold enquiry and will be opened up further in part II of ‘Facets of a more Comprehensive Cosmology’.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/12/1*KagpDzSldkIk8nUCbgf72Q.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/395/1*M94h1o7oG7bzaSe_00twUw.png" /></figure><p>Whilst spirit potential configured by (3) is not historically time-sequenced its possible realisations are nevertheless governed by the evolution of consciousness at any particular period of time.</p><p>In recent epochs (say the last 40,000+ years) the evolution of consciousness demonstrates three broad world-views as relatively distinct cosmologies each according to its particular human-World interface. If we take the timelike view and look back from now to earlier, these cosmologies can be described as:</p><p><strong>A) Auto-Reactive:</strong> The modern concept of a physio-mathematical universe governed by fixed automatic laws (instrumental-theoretic interface)</p><p><strong>B) Bio-Cosmic:</strong> the ancient concept of a living Kosmos as an ordered and harmonious entity (rational interface)</p><p><strong>C) Human (proto-Spiritual):</strong> the very early, minimally diagnostic perception of the World as an instinctive-spiritual encounter (mythical-magical interface)</p><p>If time moves on as common sense would have it, the modern concept of a mathematical universe confirmed by instrumental measurement would be seen to have superseded the rational Kosmos of the Pythagorean world-view, the rational, in turn, having superseded the proto-spiritual world of an earlier form of consciousness that we would judge as irrational.</p><p>Spirit potential (3) would say that these three cosmologies — the super-rational (mathematical), the rational (logos) and the irrational (mythos) — are 3 facets of one trans-rational cosmology yet to be realised.</p><p>So is the modern self-view of human life coming into a state of ‘enlightenment’ emerging in the early centuries of the scientific and social revolutions a title given all too previous when we have not yet defeated the irrational as the daily news proves?</p><p>The irrational, it seems, has not been superseded but has simply shifted its base of operations. No longer projected onto the external world, it now resides in the unconscious contents showing up as vestigial images of mythic nature-power through a modern veneer of rational behaviour and is still dangerously present in the human psyche.</p><p>Whilst the scientific project has continued to pursue the ‘super-rational’ with increasing mathematical and instrumental precision, the light of The Enlightenment has faded and any aspirations to rationality in human affairs deconstructed.</p><p>Rationality does not, of course, exhaust the human template of developing reason (see Part 2 episode 1). Trans-rational is not super-rational. The 3-sphere template would say that super-rational and consequently super-tech is a surrogate third-vector that cannot resolve the interior questions exponential evolution would ask. Instead it leaves us with splintered images of the World not unlike a hall of self reflecting mirrors.</p><p>The prefix trans- points not to the World but to how to be in the World. It is an ethical dimension of reason; the reason why we do what we do. It is the paradox of how to reason our reason.</p><p>In the face of a complex and challenging world we each struggle with the question of how to be. But the irrational acts that now dominate the world stage cannot be resolved by superior math, rational argument or the threat of superior mythic god-like power.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/12/1*KagpDzSldkIk8nUCbgf72Q.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/207/1*7DER6RcAPrtWjN68YeqZVQ.png" /></figure><p>The subject matter of all three enquiries and others will be explored throughout a range of episodes in Parts 4 to 7. They will be presented such that the numbering of each Part will try to bring to light facets of its corresponding spirit potential.</p><p>In all it is a vast territory and what follows has no pretense of a ‘theory of everything’. Instead, what it presents are cameos of personal research into the fields of (9) spirit potentials through the objective framing of their commensurate structural principles.</p><p>To make a start, part II of ‘Facets of a More Comprehensive Cosmology’ will offer some grounding through structural principles for the third of these enquiries which concerns the question with which this whole series began: ‘How do you see the World’.</p><p>The writer does however appreciate that this question is for each person to answer for themselves.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/95/1*3WvWTdTNgt7w0JzsR0zWMw.png" /></figure><p>Thank you for taking the time to read this episode.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5a56d20826d6" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Part 3: Living in a Self-Realising Universe (verse 1 and verse 2)]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@r.lingard9/part-3-living-in-a-self-realising-universe-verse-1-and-verse-2-aa3d4b56acb6?source=rss-66b3eef183eb------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/aa3d4b56acb6</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[self-illumination]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[universe]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[light]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[wonder]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[realisation]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ronnie Lingard]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 10 Oct 2026 09:43:39 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-10-10T09:43:39.249Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/732/1*g-qT9EwziC_lpENvsVbRDQ.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/312/1*LfjmHLQjV5nAvMXihGFx4Q.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/74/1*a1SMm7a0LxRcnMlmDnyXWQ.png" /></figure><p>To pick up a stone from the ground and wonder about its history, about how it came to be where it is and what it is, the term <strong><em>self-realising</em></strong> may not immediately come to mind.</p><p>After all the stone has no ‘self’ to realize in any sense that I might understand.</p><p>To realise has two meanings…</p><p>The first is to bring something into being from a state of potential; to make it real as an external fact.</p><p>(I want to build a house, I have it in mind but need the skill, materials and help from others to bring it into reality.)</p><p>The second meaning of realise relates to an internal process of understanding, often by the occurrence of a sudden insight.</p><p>The first is idea to its physical realisation as fact. But the second is a small growth of interiority.</p><p>The stone I hold in my hand is clearly a realization of the first kind brought into being from the potential in stars to generate the raw materials such that the stone can become a fact.</p><p>But can wondering about the stone lead to a realization of the second kind?</p><p>These two meanings of realization seem to be worlds apart; as different as what I see to be external, persistently present and confirmed by the fact I can now hold this stone in my hand. As against what, in wondering, I may feel to be internal and ephemeral, landing as a thought without obvious source or substance.</p><p>Yet, in the wondering, are these two meanings not brought closer together? Is there is more to realize about realization?</p><p>So, by my wondering, are seeing the stone as an external fact and any moment of insight I may now have about it, not then separate but two parts of a continuing arc of realization?</p><p>Is the reality of the stone the Universe showing me something about the ‘it-self’ of Its Self so that I, in my wondering, may see it as more than just a fact? Possibly then to cause me to wonder about the ‘I-self’ of my-self.</p><p>I can carry the stone with me and I could forget I am holding it, the fact of the stone having become mutual to my senses.</p><p>If I, just like the stone, am a realisation of the Universe as fact do I also become mutual to my senses? If I stop wondering do I forget the second meaning of realisation as an interior awareness?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/12/1*KagpDzSldkIk8nUCbgf72Q.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/77/1*qmOCcnnHPvHRG9EsvN3MEA.png" /></figure><p>Stars are not just the bearers of stones.</p><p>Foremost, they are bearers of the first light of the Universe. And by this light we are able to see things and know things like the stone as fact.</p><p>So, by wondering, am I not then the bearer of <strong><em>second-born</em></strong> light; the light of insight?</p><p>It takes thousands of years for light to emerge from its core to be released into space. Stars create light in perpetuity but science tells us that these lights will eventually go out.</p><p>And also, for us, the light of insight may only occur in moments that may later grow dim.</p><p>So does this transformation of <strong><em>first-born</em></strong> light to <strong><em>second-born</em></strong> light only show us the small beginnings of a slower generation of light through the evolution and enrichment of interiority?</p><p>As a continuing story from star to stone to self-realization could the slower, perhaps more certain, inner self-illumination then be called: <strong><em>third-born light</em></strong>?</p><p>On second thoughts, would this third light be better called: the evolution of a Self-Realizing Universe?</p><p>Where then is verse 3?</p><p>It’s just a wonder…</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/95/1*3WvWTdTNgt7w0JzsR0zWMw.png" /></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=aa3d4b56acb6" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Part 2 (episode 4): Deep Time and all things Abstract]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@r.lingard9/part-2-episode-4-deep-time-and-all-things-abstract-7b84b22a85da?source=rss-66b3eef183eb------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/7b84b22a85da</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[abstraction]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[deep-time]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[creativity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[spiritualisation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[belonging]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ronnie Lingard]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 30 Sep 2026 09:53:34 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-09-30T09:53:34.147Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/713/1*1ggjR6-SfOcESkCLUhyeqg.png" /><figcaption>Vesica Piscis, Chalice Well Symbol, Glastonbury, England</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/404/1*BRf1CIwfjldW4k34F9-2Yg.png" /></figure><p>Developed as a set of structural principles and referred to collectively as the universal infrastructure, the numbers (1) to (9) are fundamental to the living-spiritual diagnostics of this series.</p><p>Numbers are perhaps not an obvious starting point to speak about Life in a spiritually sympathetic sense for they do not live in the Universe in the same way that we live in the Universe. We live our lives in a world of process, of growing up, of passing on and passing away, and every thought or action has a time-like consequence. In contrast numbers are not subject to the enforcement of time. Nevertheless, we have given them life in our life; given them life, that is, in the abstract but no less consequential life of the mind.</p><p>If it’s true that numbers, conceived in the mind as pure timeless entities, and Life as an ever-becoming process constitute such different worlds how can we live in the one and yet claim to know the other? Are we ourselves also divided ‘mind’ to ‘body’ as some philosophers have imagined?</p><p>To separate mind from body or more generally Mind from Nature may seem advantageous to us. It has after all, by standing back from Nature, given us what appears to be an objective view of the World. With Nature as one world (out there) and Mind as another world (in here) the separation has appeared to give us more choice and more control of our future as a species.</p><p>Yet the consequence of any act of division is always double edged.</p><p>In taking advantage of the power latent within the mind to divide and then control, human life has incrementally loaded the balance of the Nature/Mind equation to a critical point and Nature is now flagging up the consequences with red warning signs flashing across multiple vectors.</p><p>Nature’s redressing of the balance is an old lesson we never seem to learn. It is what the ancient Greeks would call Justice. Personified by the goddess Themis who was known for her clear-sightedness she is symbolized by the form of a female figure holding a sword (the double edge) and a balance (the symbol of redress and recovery) and the image is still used today as an emblem of the Justice System.</p><p>We might think of the symbol of Justice as an aspect of the Earth; as Nature getting her own back in the face of human folly. But this would be a human projection for, in truth, Mother Nature is not so vindictive. Justice is blindfolded and she is not given to bias. She is working within deeper universal principles in order to preserve a greater purpose than nature’s utility value for human life.</p><p>Human life has taken full advantage of the power of abstraction but as already mentioned abstraction has a dual edge and therefore consequential, sometimes in unexpected ways.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/12/1*KagpDzSldkIk8nUCbgf72Q.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/404/1*-0yQZW4gZHNwWrVMhalgfA.png" /></figure><p>Abstraction is trans-spectral — beyond ordinary vision — a power to see what otherwise would remain hidden and it has a broad remit. It is as much a part of the creative arts as it is of the success of the sciences and the appeal of symbolic religion.</p><p>Myth, mathematics, metaphysical systems, symbolism, sacred geometry, archetypes, ideas, ideals and principles, in as much as they explore what is otherwise unseen, they also seek that which is beyond the consequences of time.</p><p>One side of this power is a kind of entrapment. It is what Owen Barfield, if I understand him correctly, would call idolatry; a worship of the abstract as the objective reality. The other side of this power is that it represents a gateway to creativity; signs of an unfulfilled potential that to a large extent has been captured as human property in our modern era. We no longer see creativity as participance.</p><p>Whether trap or gateway, abstraction is an artifact of the mind and with this mental power we are able to create conceptual worlds that are outside of time. And this creative power to generate worlds has left us with the question as to whether these otherwise unseen worlds have a reality over and above the fact of nature or whether they are, just that, artifact of the mind.</p><p>We live history as a timelike process with timelike consequences yet it is also an evolution in the abstract. It is the interface of a potential and its realisation in which the timeless worlds of the ideal object and the timelike world of living history mix in complex ways. It is with this mental power that human life distances itself from the billions of years of biology.</p><p>The biosphere evolves impersonally by a selection process that is in large part based on functional efficacy. But if history is also an evolution in the abstract, a power to create worlds over and above the one that we all share, abstraction becomes the raw material of a new selection principle.</p><p>Let’s put this dualism of worlds, mental and natural, in the form of the 3-sphere template used throughout this series as an aid to its ongoing diagnostics according to the content it is exploring. The 3-sphere is also an abstraction but takes time out of its dualistic framing by accommodating it as an active 3-fold process…</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/335/1*S_uGII1seKSD-ylnOnxUKg.png" /></figure><p>What the triadic template would claim is that the power of abstraction and its’ historical evolution is to some purpose and not just a search for timeless entities or unified theories as an end in itself. Principles are a bridge to spirit and its creative potential; a well of resource of deep time. The 3-sphere is still an abstraction but it points to creative energies that can reshape Life as a bio-spiritual organism.</p><p>We may search for deep time when we dig through the layers of history left behind by our ancestors, not only to find buildings and artifacts but also to discover conceptual schemes and language and story and other important narrative threads of history. We search for deep time when we look out into the universe and therefore back in time to its origin. We also search for deep time when we look back through our own genetic inheritance and the layers of geological time now coded in the nucleus of every human cell. We are, in a sense, made of deep time.</p><p>Deep time is neither timeless nor timelike. Instead it is the <strong><em>eternal re-greening of time</em></strong>.</p><p><strong>The worlds we create do not survive because they claim to be timeless. They survive because they serve to re-enliven the spiritual actuality of Life’s engagement with the Cosmos.</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/12/1*KagpDzSldkIk8nUCbgf72Q.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/385/1*1DMEkZoZzI025S98pcGT6Q.png" /></figure><p>To address spirit potential (8) at this point in the series is out of sequence. Whilst the 7 Parts are being written in an expected sequence 1-to-7, (8) as well as (9) are not sequential. It has been bought forward to set the tone for the following episodes.</p><p>All even numbered spirit potentials (2;4;6;8) have a dual expression and spirit potential (8) has something particular to say about the dualism of timeless and timelike.</p><p>In the language of structural principles the structure of a two-world dualism such as ‘nature’ and ‘mind’ is the inner configuration (4:4). It is one world (4) set against another world (4).</p><p>As a spirit potential (8) is not divided. Let’s discuss its geometric symbolism.</p><p>Like the two circles from which the symbolic figure of 8 is itself constructed and like the two overlapping circles of the Vesica Piscis symbol shown in the Chalice Well photograph above, (8) is the language of connective flow between worlds (the Vesica Piscis symbol was also known as the Mother of all Forms).</p><p>When (8) is divided (4:4) there is, as in the symbol for eight, only a single point of contact between two spheres or worlds; a connection to a trans-spectral potential that whilst touching in a moment of insight can then become frozen in time. But when time stops the flow stops and a two-world dualism becomes the resultant image left in the mind whereby one world (mind), would then seem logically permitted to acquire authority over another (nature).</p><p>The structural principle of (8) does not deny the philosophical insight of two worlds; two world-dualisms are the creative tension implicit in abstraction and this tension has served its time in the recent history.</p><p>Nature and mind are of course different. Whilst nature is bound within a preservation principle to act in reality if there is to be any world at all, mind has access to a power, the power of image, whose purpose is not yet clear. It can be a gate to deep time but if divided as two worlds the division sterilises the connection and can instead drain that potential of its spiritual value. <em>[Note: gates and pathways are synaptic and structure the language of the brain but the brain together with its CEO the ego loves to freeze thus possess reality.]</em></p><p>The deeper challenge that two-world dualisms present to the mind is not that the World is divided but that the mind has the freedom to make it so. The deeper challenge that the mind has to overcome is the mind itself or, rather, to free itself from the brain and then use the brain, rather than being trapped within it.</p><p>The inner configuration (4:4) is the balancing principle that holds the mind at the point of its own self-transcendence. It is a subtle equation but without taking the step into participation consciousness, two-world dualisms take us hostage leaving the mind with an enigma of its own making.</p><p>This double edge of being at the limit of one world looking at another is not so much the timeless world of abstraction making its judgement upon the timelike. It is really a mirror of self-reflection and it either forces the mind to face the consequences of its dualistic enclosures or places it in solitary confinement.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/12/1*KagpDzSldkIk8nUCbgf72Q.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/682/1*xsF1EMb4fRgdgs22bicQRA.png" /></figure><p>The phrase ‘spiritualization of infrastructure’ relates to pathways that transcend rather than solve questions surrounding two-world dualisms. It involves the pairing (8;9) and this will be explored in the episodes to come.</p><p>Pathways of resolution are not answers to abstract dualities faced with the question of real or not real, they represent new consciousness, embody new nerve structure and thus new ways of seeing. New ways of seeing are the creative energy of deep time. It is what abstraction truly seeks in its breaking of the spell of timeless realities.</p><p>Solving by abstraction, resolving by personal insight and absolving by recourse to deep time are the triadic arrangement of meaningful realisation in the outer sphere of the 3-sphere in which the whole becomes emanatory; an intimately felt quality.</p><p>Nature serves a purpose as agency function but human life has the potential to be conscious of itself as agency. Being conscious of consequences is a measure of the difference between use and abuse.</p><p>When we make the effort to really see clearly what nature is saying to us we do not then see it as being out there. More significantly we see it as a co-relation of worlds and feel it as a clearer sense of Belonging. The symbolic one-third overlap of two worlds in the Vesica Piscis intimates that Belonging.</p><p>In the opening remarks a distinction was made between a timelike world of process in which there is becoming and a timeless world which implies permanency of being and these two have become the basis of two contrasting philosophical positions; another two-world dualism. Without the co-relation that realizes itself through the principle of belonging, philosophies of nature powered by mental abstraction grow cold and remote.</p><p>The intimate cosmology which this series of essays has in its mind to seek would therefore see belonging as having a deeper ontological primacy for human life than the world <em>as</em> becoming or the world <em>as</em> being. An intimate cosmology needs a triadic and mindful arrangement in which Being, Becoming and Belonging are its ways to be.</p><p>When belonging drops out of the triadic equation, the co-relational insight implicit in two-world dualisms, such as Being/Becoming, Nature/Mind, Subject/Object, will be forgotten leaving us with two incompatible worlds.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/95/1*3WvWTdTNgt7w0JzsR0zWMw.png" /></figure><p>Thank you for reading please clap or comment, it helps…</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=7b84b22a85da" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Part 2 (episode 3): The Reason ‘Why?’]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@r.lingard9/part-2-episode-3-the-reason-why-41333b46a1e7?source=rss-66b3eef183eb------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/41333b46a1e7</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[absence]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[the-question-why]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[spiritual-logic]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[reason]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[abduction]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ronnie Lingard]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 26 Sep 2026 07:14:48 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-09-26T07:14:48.697Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/544/1*cITXlxR6f2Mm3EeuMFHLvw.png" /></figure><p>To ask the question ‘Why’ is as natural to us as breathing. Just as in breathing we do not have to ask why we breathe (although we could), we do not usually ask why we ask the question ‘Why’ (although we also could).</p><p>At a certain stage of growing up and without prompting a child will naturally ask ‘Why’ about everything. As adults we field these questions and try to give sensible answers to apparently simple questions. Until that is they go beyond the horizon of our understanding of why the child is asking or our available patience.</p><p>Is the child looking for answers? Did you, as a child, look for answers? Or, at least, did the answers received ever satisfy that need to ask ‘Why’, and thereby to ask it again and again? Or does the asking represent an instinctive search for an unknown centre; the child’s own nucleus of reason? <strong>[See Part 2 episode 1; ‘Finding Oneself in an Intelligent Universe’]</strong></p><p>Perhaps then, rather than answers, children are looking to us to hold them by the hand and show them around the unfamiliar place in which they are trying to find themselves before they get caught up in the tangled undergrowth of contradictory grown up answers.</p><p>Reason naturally begins with wondering ‘why’ but reason itself has two directives that behave like oil and water. Water is polar and oil is non-polar and they do not easily mix. Shake them up but eventually they settle into two zones, heavy below and light above. Yet there is a special combination of mixture whereby if the two are fine enough and gravity no longer an influence, they adopt a new state referred to as a colloid. Milk (fat and water) for example is such a colloidal state.</p><p>The structural principles that shape these two directives of reason are signified by (2) the principle of polarity and (3) the principle of non-polarity. Polar and non-polar are the basis of two logics.</p><p>As spirit potentials however they have a deeper function. If this doesn’t stretch the analogy too far it could be said that the spiritual directive (3:2) which combines polar and non-polar has the potential of a finer mixture of the two logics that is akin to a colloidal state; a state of reason that is <strong><em>held in suspension</em></strong>.</p><p>In the commentary ‘Intimacy as a Self-Persuasion Argument’ the triadic or non-polar principle, also called Presence, was explored through the three valued logic of the nuclear triad: Sameness, Difference and Greater.</p><p>Here, in Part 2, the commentary is going to look at the polar or two-valued logic also from a spiritual perspective; beyond its being a method of axiomatic deduction.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/12/1*KagpDzSldkIk8nUCbgf72Q.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/366/1*LYAYjgC_B7dLBdO-GyMG-g.png" /></figure><p>From a classical viewpoint 2-valued logic represents an ideal that reason should aspire to in the sense that it calls upon reason to show evidence of its’ self-consistency and completeness. For the Greek philosopher Aristotle, self-consistency is summed up by the 2nd law of logic; the law of non-contradiction whereas completeness is driven by the 3rd law of logic; the law of the excluded middle.</p><p>Self-consistency, or the exclusion of internal contradiction within a reasoned argument, and completeness, or the certainty of conclusion by excluding of any vague or middle way, is obviously reasons’ struggle with the nature of (2) as a polarising structure.</p><p>Reason tailored by 2-valued logic tries to banish the uncertain 3rd value for the sake of completeness. And yet, in truth, it can only put the non-polar triadic potential on hold or into a state of forgetfulness. For, if the triadic principle rings true for a person, it is not the final answer to a question so much as a step into an awakening state. And the child asks ‘why’ because they are seeking to wake up.</p><p>The argument of binary logic would seem to be that, if reason can demonstrate its completeness and non-contradiction under its super-vision, then subjecting reasoning to this more forensic form of a true/false diagnostic should provide a more certain knowledge about the World. At least this was the hope.</p><p>In a historical setting philosophy takes a back seat and to the extent that human history has been driven by those simply with the power to act, reason has not been well supervised. In the end logic seems not to have played much of a part in why those in power do what they do except by way of self-justification, for which there are plenty of examples in every age.</p><p>There is, however, an abductive component in 2-valued logic that over time shows itself as a self-conscious awareness in the process of history. The spiritual aspiration of 2-valued logic becomes evident in various shifts that have taken place in the perception of how we, as a collective species, have come to expose previously hidden self-contradictions between what we suppose we are (human) and what we actually are (persons) by what history in reality demonstrates.</p><p>We can look back upon what evidence we have about historical outcomes and make the analysis of good or bad. But will it not be the case that future generations will look back at our present situation and wonder at our own stupidity. If, that is, the human race has a future.</p><p>Tailored by 2-valued logic reason can become reductive upon how we see the World. But the spiritual aspiration within reason is to become reductive upon our own assumptions. In co-relation with 3-valued logic the reason why we do what we do can be placed on hold, standing back from the momentum of history in order to <strong><em>reason our reason</em></strong>.</p><p>Ever since the employment of some form of logical instrument the binary approach to reason has been sorely in need of spiritual grounding.</p><p>In the east there is the tetralemma, a logical instrument often used in Indian philosophy and Buddhist logic providing four possibilities and not just two (dilemma). In the west there is the Socratic Method or dialectic which holds back the tendency of an argument to its pre-emptive closure. More up to date there is Charles Sanders Pierce’s abduction which opens reason to the fields of open pre-spective intuition. This commentary would claim that all these instruments of reason are attempts at giving spiritual grounding to the binary potential without losing the power of critical thinking.</p><p>Spiritual grounding is a sensibility which seems to be specifically human, i.e. not biologically sourced (including the brain) and is driven by the need to be, and not just seen to be or heard to be, free of self-contradiction as a personal attribute. At points where self-contradiction seems to be retrospectively evident, these realizations are either points of admission to oneself or points where the logic of the whole situation becomes hidden from consciousness.</p><p>And that which was hidden was certainly a target for one of the earliest examples of the triadic persuasion within reasoned discourse. Using the awareness of contradiction as leverage to reveal hidden assumptions Socrates challenged inadequate answers to the questions he posed. From all accounts Socrates’ position in relation to his fellow Athenians was to point out the self-contradictions that reside in the politics of assumed authority.</p><p>For obvious reasons those who claimed to speak with such authority weren’t keen to have a mirror held up to them and, in the course of time, Socrates was condemned to death for the charge of ‘impiety’ and ‘corrupting the young’; charges something akin to questioning prevailing beliefs and encouraging others (the young) to do the same.</p><p>The famous story of the life and death of Socrates along with that of many other spiritually committed historical figures known and unknown is a powerful historical argument that consistency of reasoning in self about one’s self-action in the World has a spiritual motive. And that the internal logic of that self-diagnostic has to stand absolutely to the person alone. It is something for which Socrates was prepared to die rather than renounce.</p><p>The following statement in italics about this self-diagnostic challenge of spirit potential (2), something that we may personally understand as the inner freedom to decide <em>yes</em> or <em>no</em> about one’s own actions, even in the face of the most challenging and threatening environments such as ridicule, excommunication or even torture and death is an attempt to put this deeper need that goes beyond life into a language that is hand-in-hand with that of the persuasion argument of intimacy outlined in Part 1 episode 4.</p><p>Spirit potential (3) has within its configuration an implicit admission to the awareness of <strong><em>not-being-alone</em></strong> and thus respect, a spiritual persuasion of ‘other’ as Presence, and this was presented in Part 1 through the nuclear triad Sameness, Difference and Greater. But the binary potential as a self-deciding life is a ‘stand-alone’ logic self-to-self.</p><p>Both (3) and (2) call upon the same spiritual ground albeit from different perspectives. As a mutually implicated combination, the nucleus of reason (3) along with the diagnostic intelligence self-exclusion (2), together represent configurations that offer increasing refinement of the <strong><em>spiritual directive (3:2)</em></strong>. Such a spiritual directive, like a life-line weaving its way through the tribulations of history, is an evolving story of trial and error that has now reached a critical threshold.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/12/1*KagpDzSldkIk8nUCbgf72Q.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/443/1*uclv5I-GJh0BL-7T8_tzqw.png" /></figure><p><em>Since the birth of philosophy as a method of rational inquiry logic has been an instrument in which human reason has put its faith. Much as we would put our faith in a guide who knows a particular terrain to take us safely to the destination of a journey, reason has put its faith in logic to guide it through the gates of true and false.</em></p><p><em>But if you ask an ordinary person if they are willing to put their faith in logic they will probably have a reservation in them. Not only in terms of not fully trusting those who claim to be acting with the certainty of an absolutely worked-out rational argument but, deeper, there is an instinctive feeling that logic, in the sense of something being completely certain, ultimately reduces human possibility and somehow turns what we do into something mechanical; something that without due care and attention can override a deeper human capability to respond to a greater need that may, to ordinary eyes, seem unreasonable and illogical.</em></p><p><em>The caution that we ‘ordinary-folk’ perhaps feel is that too much certainty is a barrier against going beyond the accepted view of who we are and consequently takes away the freedom to choose by other means or sensibilities and thus ultimately negates the spirit as a deeper motivation that drives human will at times of almost impossible adversity. Too much certainty is even perhaps anti-human.</em></p><p><em>And further, that sometimes to act in the opposite way of the rational, such as to put oneself in personal danger to save a complete stranger or animal in distress, or to battle against impossible odds for a greater good, that such heroic acts summon from within us the very core of what it means to be human.</em></p><p><em>So what if binary logic is not just a set of rules for filtering out contradiction but a deep seated pre-potent, spiritual quality that drives human activity abductively (by Absence) and thus reaches beyond its self-limitations and, ultimately, something that is more powerful as a human directive than rationality alone…a directive not only to guide reason through the gates of true and false but also to act as a more primary directive to the whole of us?</em></p><p><em>Perhaps then, Logic, in this primary form of a powerful directive to the more of us (beyond our ordinary reasonability), rather than negating human will, as that power which finds a way in spite of overwhelming odds, may even be or become the very substance of will, if ‘substance’ is the correct word here. But will not as a personalized property, Will as a throughout or even collective property felt, perceived, understood as persuasive to the inner courts of what it means to be human.</em></p><p><em>The keyway that runs from spiritual logic…to a greater Will, would take a different path from the one it takes that leads to resultant</em><strong><em> </em></strong><em>knowledge. In the case of resultant knowledge logic may well be a determinant of reason as the one and only path that an argument can take (premise A to conclusion B via the logical instrument C) but, in the case of Will, logic can be the determinant of a pure act — </em><strong><em>the one and only path an action can take.</em></strong></p><p><em>Think of the example above of the heroic act, how could any person go beyond reasonability unless that act was felt at the time to be the only possible course of action. Perhaps then Logic in this greater sense of spiritual persuasion is not a separation from the World but a source of being in the World. A source acting as a higher human directive occurring as a determinant in the understanding, or the feeling, or the intuition, or the conscience, that motivates or liberates or even becomes Will as a necessary strength drawn from the Logic of the whole situation.</em></p><p><em>But understood or felt by what? Logic in the sense of having access to a deeper resource is certainly something very difficult to put into language and, yet, when witnessed in such acts of selfless bravery and direct action has the power to move us all deeply.</em></p><p><em>Is logic therefore not just an instrument of analytical reason but, deeper, something that sheds light on the inner life task of understanding the whole situation as a human historical as well as cosmological imperative?</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/12/1*KagpDzSldkIk8nUCbgf72Q.png" /></figure><p>The spirit in which this statement is written is not authoritative but stands to each person alone in the uniqueness of a person’s own living/spiritual diagnostic.</p><p>Using the example of the heroic act is a way of describing the extreme situation where, when the need is plain to see, all contradiction magically disappears without the need for analysis. In its place is the summoning of a greater inner resource to override the uncertainty of an understandable hesitation when committing to any heroic and possibly life-threatening act.</p><p>If the potency of such a resource is to be sustained, to grow and develop over time as an individual or even collective property, then perhaps it may persist through time in much the same way that evolution has been found to grow and develop through time, by the branching genealogies of a nucleated template.</p><p>Perhaps it may be possible then to speak of a ‘spiritual genetic’ as a template of coded values that holds to more than one centre; a collective multi-nucleated template of reason.</p><p>The brain, the mind and other mental structures may well be the functioning part of the diagnostic intelligence of such a nucleating power. But perhaps it is access to this spiritual resource that brings together <strong><em>person</em> <em>intelligence</em></strong> and <strong><em>design intelligence</em></strong> as a combined double helix of this proposed spiritual genetic.</p><p>If reason is blind when it finds itself in the unknown and its’ how-should-I-be language therefore not certain then perhaps it’s the presence of this spiritual resource which provides us with the eyes to see or a voice to speak.</p><p>The roots of the word logic can be found in the term <strong><em>logos</em></strong> which originally meant words spoken and the spoken word has certainly been a powerful tool in the hands of those who claim to lead the way. But if words are to be a measure then perhaps it is ‘what truly speaks’ or ‘what needs to be said’ rather than the logic of the argument that gives it spiritual power.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/95/1*3WvWTdTNgt7w0JzsR0zWMw.png" /></figure><p>Thank you for taking the time to read this episode, please comment if you are inclined to…</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=41333b46a1e7" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Part 2 (episode 2): The Intimate and Magical Life of Childhood]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@r.lingard9/part-2-episode-2-the-intimate-and-magical-life-of-childhood-34c614deb99c?source=rss-66b3eef183eb------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/34c614deb99c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[intelligence]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[spiritual-logic]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[magical]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[childhood]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[becoming-human]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ronnie Lingard]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 26 Sep 2026 05:57:00 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-09-26T05:57:00.953Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/695/1*95buHu0H6lfe08W8HfsXhA.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/126/1*q_X5M_4iPINLpCxHN7RJ9Q.png" /></figure><p>We can all observe, perhaps even personally remember, that children are insatiably inquisitive only stopping when the some inborn urge calls them to sleep. They are always doing things and experimenting with their surroundings to the point of self-danger and have to be constantly watched. They are highly motivated by absence of experience and absence of knowledge and therefore absence of predictive ability. As a consequence they are full of surprise and delight at what things can do.</p><p>A child is human by its designated template (model: genus homo-sapiens) and is not called <em>to be</em> anything other. For a child the leading edge of its template of developing reason is not therefore <em>to be</em> but the urgency <em>to know</em> by finding things out for themselves such as: that’s soft, that’s hard, that’s warm, that’s hot (!), that’s unusual (?), that’s interesting and the like.</p><p>The natural approach of a child is to experiment with the world to see what things do. All this enquiring activity then only later fostering the deeper question ‘Why’.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/278/1*WlpFzVikr9-L0rRtJNo4Rw.png" /></figure><p><strong>[See episode 1 ‘Finding oneself in and Intelligent Universe’ for the larger context to the template of developing reason]</strong></p><p>A child needs no training or reason for this kind of inquiring activity. Just like sleep it is in-born. It is design intelligence led from the start in which there is the instinctive urgency to do anything in order to know something and observing this activity from the outside is what grown-ups would call play.</p><p>A child is not yet familiar with the world and they examine everything but the existential question <em>to be</em> is not yet given to the task of reason. For a child,<em> to be</em> is simply to be able <em>to do</em> and thus to be able <em>to know</em>; to be able that is…to see, to hear, to feel, to pick up, to put down, to react, to try things out and eventually to question.</p><p>The activity of a child demonstrates that within the instinctive urgency to know the World there is a special kind of absence which generates a resolving sequence: <em>seeking</em>, <em>finding</em> and <em>holding</em>. We may characterize such a triadic sequence as <em>learning.</em> But because it is design intelligence led from the start it is not yet the kind of educated learning that is directly related to becoming a deciding person in an already grown-up world.</p><p>To try and give some sense of what is being suggested by this other kind of learning two examples are offered below. They are necessarily taken from the writers’ own childhood although the reader may recognise something in their own experience that may be similar but nevertheless unique to them.</p><p>These two examples will be referred to in the third person because ‘<em>the child</em>’ is not yet a substantial first person identity in the way that a person is going to have to become in the world and, therefore, the <strong><em>holding</em></strong> of what a child <strong><em>seeks</em></strong> and <strong><em>finds</em></strong> does not carry the same kind of personal investment that we do as adults in what we <em>hold </em>about what we feel we <em>know</em>.</p><p>What a child instinctively seeks is, in one respect, even more deeply personal and strangely magical.</p><p>Example 1) <em>A child may be at home one day in an ordinary family setting and for no reason that is obvious at the time, half-knowingly, begin to write their address…the living room, the house, the street, the town, the country, the earth, and then to something else that must be Greater for which the child may not have the word — say ‘Universe’ — but can somehow see or imagine that it must be there…but then, having been caused by this activity to occupy an ever expanding world to which the child feels itself to be the absolute centre, suddenly the expansion runs out of space and comes to a dead stop…and losing all sense of any familiarity with its immediate family surroundings to be held in a frozen moment of the wonder of not being able to go any further, and then, imagining a green door at the end of the universe that must lead somewhere go to open it only to find there is not ‘nothing’ exactly but something quite distinct — a profound sense of </em><strong><em>absence</em></strong> — <em>a perfect stillness that overwhelms the expectation that there must be something…to only then be brought back into a more familiar sense of home and the family living room the radio gently playing Sunday afternoon family favourites, leaving the question of absence (?) somehow held in suspension and without resolution.</em></p><p>Example 2) <em>Or, in another moment of similar play, to be alone rummaging around in a disused quarry and find a piece of old ceramic and suddenly come to a surprising realization and know for real that there were other people present at other times, not just characters in story books, that actually existed before the present moment; the present moment of the child being the confinement of time awareness that, until that moment of new awakening to the knowing of a past time, had pre-occupied the child at play.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/12/1*KagpDzSldkIk8nUCbgf72Q.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/377/1*6Ze262nqBvFXbNK7_cz82g.png" /></figure><p>Whilst perhaps not of obvious importance at the time these kinds of intimate experiences are moments of special consciousness for any child. They seem out of place because they are different to the accumulated expectation of a familiar world to which the child is being habituated; the world of story books and front room family favourites.</p><p>An adult person can look upon those early experiences and decide that the above two examples refer to childish assumptions about space and time for which science now gives a ‘grown-up’ answers.</p><p>Nevertheless they are waking moments for a child. We forget them of course, perhaps forever, but if they are later re-awakened and brought back into consciousness we may remember them in all there sensory detail and be caused to wonder at their essential nature. Why is it, for example, that the presence of such moments would have such fidelity of recall of the intimate feeling of the moment whilst other parts of childhood fade and become general?</p><p>As a child we naturally <strong><em>seek</em></strong> experience not yet knowing what we are looking for but when we <strong><em>find</em></strong> it in this awakening way, even if we forget and move on, the nature of the design intelligence of being human absorbs the potency of impression of that moment, <strong><em>holding</em></strong> it in a state where it might later be nurtured.</p><p>Having searched and found, the design intelligence holds it because these waking moments can indicate momentary glimpses of something of a significantly different nature than the commonly taught product knowledge of standard education, even perhaps more real, and yet unfinished. They are perhaps a clue, an access point or unique personal keyway into the third stratum shown in the diagram given in episode 1: the Creation Continuum, Yet-to-Be and the Unknown.</p><p>These glimpses activate and impress upon the imagination and cannot therefore be described in terms of an end-product system of knowledge by which we ordinarily navigate the world of adult experience. They are perhaps best described as <em>knowing</em> moments even though, as a child, we know very little. Knowing little, these kinds of knowing moments, special ‘luminosities’ they could be called, have to rely upon the innate holding power of the design intelligence for the sanctuary of their keeping.</p><p>As a child we may be held in such moments of play and these knowings can become <strong><em>axioms of</em> <em>spiritual logic</em></strong> in a questioning life, if this italicized phrase can be used without too much explanation at the moment.</p><p>As a person however we accumulate knowledge and the freedom to act upon that knowledge is what gives each one of us the power to be a deciding person in an adult world. With the power of decision making comes the possibility to then learn what it means to act within the limitations of the world as agency. What then do we become?</p><p>In the meantime, as we grow up, the ‘child within’ and the developing person come to occupy the same space. Almost before we realise it the design intelligence that gave guidance to the child is gradually lost to the person and at this point the questioning triad, the template of developing reason, begins to change its emphasis, the leading edge of need transposing from <em>knowing</em> to <em>being.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/592/1*Nbh2MFnekyVzwqPePrmqBA.png" /></figure><p>And it does need to change because whilst design intelligence is always active as a developing potential in <em>seeking,</em> <em>finding</em> and <em>holding</em>, the person, in one way or another, is faced with the task of choosing what they are going <em>to be </em>in the world.</p><p>The eternal question that parental guardians always ask of the child: What are you going <em>to be</em> when you grow up? Or worse, we have always wanted you to be a (?) just like your father.</p><p>But following on from the two examples of the child at play the argument being presented in these first two episodes is that design intelligence is not something confined just to a biological form whose intelligence has been fashioned over billions of years. The claim is that its roots lie deeper in which the intelligence of the Organic Order is a significant pointer, a bridge even, towards realising the unfinished business of a Cosmological Order.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/394/1*2mb-CCufQlGCAKoy4hE_Sg.png" /></figure><p>With the (9) spirit potentials being presented as a 3 x 3 matrix what is being proposed is that design intelligence, whilst being configured <strong><em>in domain</em></strong> within the context of a <strong><em>biological directive (4:1)</em></strong>, in the greater possibility of the nine potentials it is also being nurtured to fulfill a <strong><em>spiritual directive (3:2)</em></strong>.</p><p>These claims about specific inner configurations of spirit potential (5) expressed here as directives (4:1) and (3:2) will be explored at length in the coming commentaries. The immediate task in the rest of Part 2 and then in Part 3 is to explore further the co-relational potential of <strong><em>design intelligence</em></strong> and <strong><em>person intelligence</em></strong>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/12/1*KagpDzSldkIk8nUCbgf72Q.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/149/1*n3y0z7PCvHxzFJUNscBLFw.png" /></figure><p>To be human is to be born already equipped to engage with the world from our very first breath and yet absent of the reason why and therefore to be already natured by design intelligence but with the person intelligence yet to be nurtured.</p><p>Being two parts of the one life perhaps this co-dependent relation of design intelligence<em> </em>and<em> </em>person intelligence could be likened to two sides of the same coin; the former ancient and time-tested by the fact of its being developed over billions of years of evolution and the latter an unknown field of yet-to-be reasoned and yet-to-be realised space.</p><p>Or perhaps a more fitting image of this dual aspected intelligence is that of a double helix; as two strands of our being human that are bonded together and yet not bound by the same kinds of permissions and limitations.</p><p>There is, I believe, an innate intelligence within each child that is our duty to nurture and not indoctrinate. They are an open book but in the world as it is, this task is becoming more and more complex to manage not to say impossible to fulfill.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/95/1*3WvWTdTNgt7w0JzsR0zWMw.png" /></figure><p>Thank you for taking the time to read episode 2.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=34c614deb99c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Part 2 (episode 1): Finding oneself in an Intelligent Universe]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@r.lingard9/part-2-episode-1-finding-oneself-in-an-intelligent-universe-46aabb5350cb?source=rss-66b3eef183eb------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/46aabb5350cb</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[intelligence]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[existentual-question]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[observer-participance]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cosmology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[nucleus-of-reason]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ronnie Lingard]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 19 Sep 2026 09:41:55 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-09-19T09:41:55.638Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/868/1*m7UfQLCB-NSevvl9Z7y5Kw.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/121/1*9IgQAIjr-vzJxISxpv0KGw.png" /></figure><p>To ourselves we may freely grant the term intelligent, to other life less so but to the Universe, most likely, none at all. Whilst this statement may not strictly apply to any thinking person’s point of view it could, by default, stand as the summation of a Modernist attitude that has become implicit in the way we see and act in the World: the Natural World, be it here on Earth or in the greater Cosmos, is only there for the taking.</p><p>One of the reasons for this is that most would equate intelligence with mental or cognitive capacities such as skill in reasoning or logic or pattern recognition. Yet psychologists now recognise that intelligence can be applied to a range of types of human creative potential that is not just localised in the computing capacity of the brain.</p><p>Schemes vary from a simple triad such as analytical intelligence, creative intelligence and practical intelligence to more complex schemes such as Howard Gardner’s nine types of intelligence that include both body and mind:</p><ul><li>Logical-Mathematical Intelligence</li><li>Linguistic Intelligence</li><li>Interpersonal Intelligence</li><li>Intrapersonal Intelligence</li><li>Musical Intelligence</li><li>Visual-Spatial Intelligence</li><li>Bodily-Kinaesthetic Intelligence</li><li>Naturalist Intelligence</li><li>Existential Intelligence</li></ul><p>It’s clear from the list that a person may excel in one or different combinations of intelligence as well as the developmental level within a given type. But however predisposed a person may be to any one of the nine, these types of intelligence remain unfulfilled potentials.</p><p>How could it be said that as fields of creative intelligence the use of language or the gift of natural musical sensibility has been brought to completion such that no one needs to write or compose ever again? An individual innovator or even genius may enrich those fields of intelligence beyond measure in their own unique way and by doing so achieve a sense of completeness in their own life. And yet, however complete it may seem for that person, a reservation within that feeling of completeness is the knowing that human creative intelligence always strives to discover more.</p><p>Even logical-mathematical intelligence faces the question that any logical scheme can ever be complete. Logical-mathematical potential is unique amongst the range of human intelligence types proposed by Gardener in its being able to actually make statements about its own incompleteness.</p><p>According to 20th century logician Kurt Gödel a logical scheme that is complex or rich enough for the criteria to apply cannot demonstrate its own self-consistency. As a consequence there will always be propositions within the scheme that cannot themselves be proved. This open-ended nature of a logical scheme is not a failure of the scheme as a proving ground for propositions. Its incompleteness is built into its deep structure.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/12/1*KagpDzSldkIk8nUCbgf72Q.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/314/1*vix3yewEdq6lKckUWB5fig.png" /></figure><p>Over the course of recent centuries the logical-mathematical potential of human intelligence has discovered that the functional integrity of the Universe can be effectively described by a set of mathematical structures. However, if Gödel is correct in his logic, in as much as the Universe can be described by a self-consistent logical-mathematical scheme, it also demonstrates its incompleteness.</p><p>The leap of faith that the modern scientific project made four or five centuries ago was not to rely on logic alone but to embrace instrumental evidence as the proving ground of mathematical propositions about the Universe. The success in confirmation of theory by experiment is compelling evidence that the Universe is a deeply integrated structure. And yet, in expanding the logical scheme from unsubstantiated theories to instrumentally confirmed theories, the proposition that such evidence can be the proving ground of theory is an open question that cannot itself be proved. The open nature of scientific enquiry is both a strength and a weakness.</p><p>This commentary would therefore like to pursue a more radical scheme of questioning about intelligence: Is the gradual realization of Life as an evolving system of intelligence potentials (not just cognitive) a more comprehensive proving ground for the Universe than instrumental evidence? And, then, if so: What would ‘proving ground’ mean in this context?</p><p>Science tells us that the Universe has existed for 13.8 billion years and living systems for around 3.8 billion years. These figures are vastly beyond the time scale of a single human life or even hominid as a species and such time scales could be taken as demonstration of some order of existential intelligence fundamentally written into the fabric of both the Universe and Life, the nature of which is difficult to pin down.</p><p>If their intelligence does reside in the simple yet enigmatic fact of their <strong>being able to be and continue to be what they are</strong>, within the context of such throughout existential intelligence the Universe and Life do not seek proof. When it comes to human life however the fact that we exist has taken on new meaning. As if drawing on a new resource of potential beyond just the fact of being human as an living organism, we have come to ask the ethical question: <strong>How should I be?</strong></p><p>Instrumental evidence will prove an instrumental universe within the limits of its reach. But is this deeper existential question, having become conscious in human life, part of the greater proving ground of an evolving, universal intelligence? From a cosmological perspective was the ethical nature of the being question, in some sense, already set in motion waiting to be asked from the very moment of there being anything at all?</p><p>To pursue this scheme of questioning I am going to recast these questions in the context of a different set of 9 potentials in the fields of intelligence (also incomplete) other than those on Gardeners’ list. Not just Gardeners but different to the psycho-physiological approach to intelligence that casts intelligence in terms of human attributes of body and mind.</p><p>Returning to the title of this commentary ‘Finding Oneself in an Intelligent Universe’ the 9 potentials shown in the 3 x 3 matrix below re-contextualise intelligence around the central concept of design intelligence not as a pre-designed object but <strong><em>co-evolved in situ </em></strong>in which the co-evolution <strong><em>faces human life with an apparent duality.</em></strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/12/1*KagpDzSldkIk8nUCbgf72Q.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/504/1*Ru_uxnU8HfvrWfxNAPeCng.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/421/1*whH3ZB6mL7jW6VUYQHRKog.png" /></figure><p>What this diagram proposes is that: <strong><em>To be human is not to be singular as might be implied by a person saying ‘I am a human being’ — the ‘I am’ being taken as a singular pronouncement of self — but constitutes a dual arrangement between design intelligence and person intelligence.</em></strong></p><p>Whilst this proposal mentions the idea of a dual arrangement concerning human life it is <strong><em>not</em></strong> saying that to be human is to be divided. It is not proposing something resembling the mind/body dualism made famous over the last centuries for this would take the intended meaning of ‘dual arrangement’ out of context of the 3 x 3 matrix.</p><p>As the diagram suggests, design intelligence and person intelligence are unique intelligences but both are part of the same story as if constituting two strands of development, like a double helix bound together as a dual agency potential but different in their limitations and permissions.</p><p>As persons we have deciding agency or person intelligence and can, <em>within limits</em>, cause the ‘body’ to do what we will it to do. But the design intelligence of the body has functional agency and will do what is necessary to exist and continue to exist; for living organisms are still part of an existential continuum. There is, then, a complex relation between these two agential powers set within a greater cosmological context.</p><p>In simple terms what this particular 3 x 3 arrangement is trying to convey is what it means to be human, each person finding themselves within an already given state of both a Planetary Organic as well as a Greater Cosmic Order. Placing design intelligence in a central position within the (9) is suggesting that, being fashioned <em>in domain</em>, it functions as a point of first contact and thereby primary interface between the person to be and these time-established Orders; Planetary and Universal.</p><p>A<em> </em>person may come to know the world uniquely as measured against the value and significance of their own particular experience as it grows; learning quickly at first and then more slowly as what we come to know begins to define its own limitations. And yet, human life in general cannot know anything without the <em>design intelligence</em> of the outer sensory and inner sensing intelligence that has been both natured and nurtured over billions of years of organic refinement in tried and tested conditions.</p><p>As living organisms we are dependents within the Organic Order but as human beings we are also drawn to know the Cosmic Order whilst it yet remains largely unknown. The relation between the Organic and Cosmic is a central theme of this series ‘seeking objectivity within a more intimate cosmology’ and will be explored in detail especially in Parts 5 and 6.</p><p>This episode is simply setting the scene and part of the scenery is the part played by human reason.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/12/1*KagpDzSldkIk8nUCbgf72Q.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/559/1*lwAk3c3tjc7dNeYJD44YCg.png" /></figure><p>Whilst the 3 x 3 loom includes both the Cosmic, as a universal given, and the Organic, as our domestic given, an essential key to human context sensitive participance in either realm lies with the nuclear triad — the developing template of reason — as a refining and resolving power. It is illustrated in the diagram as the base tripod — <em>to be, to know, to do</em> — that gives grounding to each of the 3 columns situated directly above each apex.</p><p>In the diagram the triad has been taken out of context for the purposes of description but this triad is not truly outside the (9).</p><p>The triad <em>— to be, to know, to do</em> — is a three-fold presentation of a number of fundamental questions we can ask about being in the world which then challenge each person to make demand upon their own powers of reason in the individual choices they make; in trying to find ones way with such questions as…What governs my decisions? Why should <em>I do</em> one thing rather than another? And perhaps most important: How can <em>I know</em> that what I know is sufficient guidance in relation to those two questions?</p><p>The template of developing reason could be interpreted as a philosophical triad concerning questions of ontology, ethics and epistemology. However, professional philosopher or not, we are all observer-participants in this foundational tripod to some degree, uniquely expressed but nevertheless relevant to the bio-spiritual potential of the human story as a whole.</p><p>The phrase ‘nuclear triad’ draws on the analogy that, similar to the way that the nucleus of a cell contains the replicating power of DNA that is functionally tasked to hold to the integrity of its host organism, the nucleus of reason holds to the integrity of the person. It is what, in life, a person puts their name to and in that sense it is what a person is becoming because of the choices they make.</p><p>The backstop of Life is the biological order as a preservation principle manifesting as a basic instinct. But it is within the spiritualising potential of the (9) that design intelligence becomes pro-active in agency consciousness. Not however as a <strong><em>‘pre-designed object’</em></strong> which would deny the freedom to reason for oneself<em> </em><strong><em>‘but’</em></strong> as intelligent co-evolving participants and therefore<em> </em><strong><em>‘a reason to be discovered’</em></strong> and more importantly as <strong><em>‘an objectivity’ </em></strong>if it is, indeed, objectively grounded<strong><em> ‘through which we may eventually find ourselves’</em></strong>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/55/1*KT7VrvbPjQCeiPUI6POk6w.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/405/1*LNBh1zw4-yE0dEYnrZVOlQ.png" /></figure><p>Having brought up the issue of ‘design’ as a central issue in this episode I felt it important to add this postscript for the whole concept has been badly represented and overplayed.</p><p>In the latter decades of the 20th century science was faced with a new question concerning the origin of Life issuing from an unlikely source: theoretical physics. The mathematical laws discovered by science that were assumed to be present at the very beginning of the ‘big bang’ and fixed for all time were so finely tuned that it seems the Universe was designed for Life from its very first moment. After its demotion in the face of neo-Darwinian selection it seemed that a designer was finding its way back into the domain of biology through physics.</p><p>If this loading of the dice towards a bio-friendly outcome of a set of universal law is true, as it seems to be, the Universe and Life would be more directly connected to the very first moment, top down so to speak, rather than the gradual bottom up route from physics through chemistry to biology and thus living organisms. It is as if a strange loop had been discovered between Life and the Cosmos and science had to somehow deal with its teleological implications.</p><p>The first step was to propose a multi-verse theory together with anthropic selection. The simple reasoning of this theory is that with enough universes there is bound to be one that would ‘select’ for Life and hence no need for a Grand Designer.</p><p>The Darwinian style cosmology of a landscape of randomly generated universes from which a living universe could then be selected convinced some but not others. A major stumbling block was no access to other universes and this theory could not be directly tested. An alternative theory brought together some of the most advanced physics of the day including holographic theory, string theory and black hole singularity physics. It was put forward by Stephen Hawkins who, in partnership with Dutch cosmologist Thomas Hertog, took an unprecedented step of observer inclusion.</p><p>The standard instrumental-theoretic method of confirmation keeps the observer separate from the Universe by the interface of instrumental measurement and by doing so claims an external ‘Gods-eye’ view. Cosmology is about the whole Universe so in what sense could it be said that we stand outside the Universe as observers? Where would we stand?</p><p>In as much as I understand the general outline of the theory the Hawking-Hertog cosmology* it goes against the grain of drawing a hard line between the Universe and human observation by introducing into its theoretical structure a form of retroactive participant-observership as an essential part of the theory. Observership in this sense is not just human but how the Universe itself is an evolving self-observing and thus self-realising structure. The Darwinian tree of the Universe, like the evolution of life, has grown its branches from the very first moment by retrodiction of the necessary laws that will eventually produce Life.</p><p>*[See Thomas Hertog’s book ‘On the Origin of Time’ for a readable account of the background to his and Stephen Hawkins’ work seeking to give a scientific/naturalistic account of why the laws of the Universe seem to have been designed for Life.]</p><p>This cosmology assigns to the Universe and Life a combined role in observership in which both have been in some sense operating as a selection agency in the retroactive fashioning of laws to ‘create’ the bio-friendly conditions observed today. What the cosmology seems to be saying is that, with the aid of the no-boundary condition, Life was not so much intended from the beginning but because of participant observership the cosmological order has nevertheless said ‘yes’ to the question of an organic order as a new growth potential.</p><p>To truly deny a place for an external designer part of the theory is that this self-observing Universe has no beginning; no T = 0 moment. As a consequence there is no room for external designer — a classic God as law giver — dictating a regime of fixed law from which Life would later consequentially emerged. Instead laws are ‘tweaked’ from within many possible universe histories to influence the way that laws develop up to the present time. Where laws are concerned this cosmology takes evolution to a moment before time was fixed in a form that we experience it, i.e. as processes, and instead as a dimension of space, if the term space itself has a meaning in this pre-temporal regime.</p><p>The simple intuitive image it evokes is the Universe as a sphere of possible futures bounded by the uncertainty of quantum rules. The Universe says yes to many histories but we, as observer participants, have to ask the question to formulate or condense a chosen option.</p><p>[See a section of the paper by Hawkins and Hertog published in 2002 ‘Populating the Landscape: A Top Down Approach’ the link is included at the end of this episode.]</p><p>This is heady stuff and whether it can be proved on the grounds of instrumental evidence or presents science with a whole new meaning of ‘proof’ remains moot. Whatever the merits of this attempt at a naturalistic theory trying to overcome the embarrassment of a ‘Designer God’, it is another indicator that the instrumental-theoretic method is incomplete and needs the addition of observer-participance.</p><p>The design-without-designer paradox is a scientific problem and I would suggest one of its own making. It will have to deal with it in its own terms. What this commentary would say, however, is that, whilst participant-observership is a spiritual insight and not a classical religious dogma, its proving ground is not instrumental-theoretic. Participant-observership is a spiritual invitation to discover an inner objective within cosmology that is sympathetic to the greater cosmological scheme of a Bio-cosmos and its scope is beyond the reach of mathematical structures. From a spiritual perspective it is invitational to a new form of Presence within the context of Existential Fact as Presence.</p><p>The (9) spirit potentials would claim that ‘design’ is not a concept that can be reduced just to one side of the equation ‘designer’ versus ‘no designer’. The (9) spirit potential bend towards science as a cognitive framework as much as they do towards the heart of religious contemplation. But in as much as they diverge in the minds of their adherents (religious or scientific) is as much as they persuade towards making the reductive choice of one side or another. This may well be a time for exploring different options outside the hallowed halls of the inner temples of religion or the backroom think tanks of theoretical physics.</p><p>On a final note, whilst not ignoring the spiritual sentiment that resides in all true religions this series is mostly concerned with the science-spirituality side of the coin because the religious side remains a deeply personal issue whereas science lays claim to the objectivity. Except that this series needs a broader scope to that objectivity in which observer-participance at least opens a new door.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/95/1*3WvWTdTNgt7w0JzsR0zWMw.png" /></figure><p>Thank you for taking the time to read this opening episode of Part 2…</p><h3>*Postscript: Hawking Goes Anthropic</h3><p>Posted on <a href="https://www.math.columbia.edu/~woit/wordpress/?p=347">February 10, 2006</a> by <a href="https://www.math.columbia.edu/~woit/wordpress/?author=2">woit</a></p><p>Link: Stephen Hawking and Thomas Hertog have a new paper out, called <a href="http://www.arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/0602091">Populating the Landscape: A Top Down Approach</a>. It contains his version of the anthropic landscape idea, based on his “no-boundary” idea of quantum cosmology (sometimes also referred to as the “Hartle-Hawking wavefunction”), and he refers to it as “top-down cosmology”.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=46aabb5350cb" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Part 1 (episode 3): Intimacy as a Self-Persuasion Argument]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@r.lingard9/if-i-were-to-go-outside-on-a-clear-night-and-look-up-at-the-stars-i-might-be-caused-to-wonder-about-071bbce4aaa9?source=rss-66b3eef183eb------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/071bbce4aaa9</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[logic]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[spiritual-directive]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[nucleus-of-reason]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[intimacy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cosmology]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ronnie Lingard]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 16 Sep 2026 10:08:54 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-09-16T11:57:22.143Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*AMTyT-13Szs7wTWc75e5JA.png" /></figure><p><em>If I were to go outside on a clear night and look up at the stars I might be caused to wonder about the incomprehensible vastness of space and begin to realise how small i am and even the human race is in comparison to the Universe. It certainly brings a sobering perspective to any self-view I might have.</em></p><p><em>Having at the same time been brought close in by the wonder and the intimacy of that moment and yet left remote by its sheer scale, I am struck by the contradiction. Why should a small and transient organism born on a planet that itself is located in the middle of nowhere find itself thinking about such a vast and possibly infinite universe? Yet the evidence of a relationship between human beings and the stars goes back to the era of cave painting and if records of oral traditions are true even further back.</em></p><p><em>Oral traditions, stories from elders of how the stars came to be and what they mean would engender intimacy with the cosmos. Yet with the advent of early naturalistic cosmologies it could be said that such intimacy has been pushed back by human reason and with the advent of modern telescopes pushed back further still.</em></p><p><em>Or is it the case that in building a mathematical bridge to the Universe, as modern science has done, intimacy has taken a different form that is perhaps just as compelling as the stories of old?</em></p><p><em>So going back to the original contradiction between the smallness of myself and the incomprehensible vastness of the Universe I want to say something about this close-in, intimate aspect as the now neglected thread of this human-to-universe relationship.</em></p><p><em>Say more, that is, about the meaning of ‘Intimacy as a Self-Persuasion Argument’ and by consequence about the premise ‘finding objectivity in a more intimate cosmology’.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/55/1*KT7VrvbPjQCeiPUI6POk6w.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/398/1*HHZJIhzRnBVWxaSE32Wy_A.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/313/1*2xklgKzMpmPVZllSQLbY9A.png" /></figure><p>In seeking to understand intimacy as a self-persuasion argument, I would first have to admit that some <em>other</em> that is not me is present in its own right and is therefore independent of me and not just an image of other-in-me. And, if this independent <em>other</em> is true, it is something over which I have no right of control and therefore commands respect.</p><p>This is, perhaps, the most difficult part of the 3-way logic of self-other inclusion, too easy to dismiss in a world that dismisses virtually everything. But this step is an invisible gateway into the 3-way logic of the inner sphere of spirit potentials.</p><p>Another part of the logic is that, if I take this sense of <em>other</em> as a recognition of a true, unique and not superficial difference, when this is combined with the <em>not alone</em> feeling that is potentially the same for all, this co-relation of both <em>Difference</em> and <em>Sameness</em> is really showing me something <em>Greater</em>; something to which we cannot give possessive pronouns such as My God as against Your God, my theory against your theory. For this form of possession is simply about the image of you-in-me and me-in-you.</p><p>The proposition of a 3-way or 3-valued logic of — Difference, Sameness and Greater — is a description of spiritual objectivity in generic terms. But the inner formations of its realizations can be uniquely specific to each person.</p><p>Just as the biological template that sits within the nucleus of every human cell operates to faithfully replicate the form of the human organism as fundamentally the same for all; it also expresses unique and variant differences. Triadic logic is also generic nuclear the same and yet uniquely personal by difference.</p><p>Unlike 2-valued logic which is a standalone logic that manages our reason preventing inner contradiction, 3-valued logic is the logic of not alone.</p><p>I believe that each person knows the feeling of this tri-partite expression of ‘not alone’. It is first to be found in that period of time, which could be called the extended present moment of the child when, in all innocence, the child knows no other than to give total trust to the parental care within which it finds itself.</p><p>Yet the opportunity to realise the intimacy of not alone exists always. In the natural world we can, like the night sky, have contradictory reactions towards it; intimate and remote. In nature we can be attracted by its beauty or repelled by its aggression. We can even draw an imaginary circle around it and remove all feeling towards it, or, placing it in a different department in ourselves, think that nature is nothing other than an object for our own benefit.</p><p>Yet in the feeling of not alone the natural world may represent another possible relationship, a practical expression of our natural humanity or kindness towards a particular animal or to all animal life.</p><p>Or perhaps this kind of not alone feeling may happen in the Presence of some awe inspiring natural phenomenon that each of us in our own unique way has become particularly attracted to. Such as the vast continuum of the ocean, or the elemental power of lightning, or the intricate life of trees, or the extraordinary world of the cell, or the sound of bird song, the beauty of a condors’ flight, the awe inspiring nature of co-operational intelligence by which natural systems thrive…and so on.</p><p>So, personally speaking, even in spite of the fact that the ocean is a very different entity to me there can be this special and intimate feeling of Sameness.</p><p>In wondering about the ocean in this manner, the wonder can reveal into my personal awareness the quality of a timeless patience or it can reveal that power and danger in the depths and gentleness and playfulness in the shallows can live in the same thing without any contradiction.</p><p>Casting my mind back to the example of the starry night, it is the power of the Presence of the heavens, witnessed now and at every moment that human beings have been alive, that has instigated a search into the Greater to try to discover the meaning of Sameness. Not just same as in ‘made of the same material’ as would be proposed by a method of physical analysis but same in this more significant sense of a Greater relationship.</p><p>The idea that we can understand the Universe in quite specific and revealing ways for example is an extraordinary thing. It is not ordinary, although it is our common property if we wish to exercise it, to be able to know something about the nature of light. Not only in terms of the mathematical elegance revealed in the structure of light now made available through scientific acumen but also that such light connects me to the deep time of universal history; all time present on display in the night sky, all at once. It is always present even if at times I forget this because, as night turns into day, its starry Presence turns into Absence.</p><p>The self-persuasion argument of intimacy can begin to form up in consciousness the idea that this 3-vectored property, like a germinating seed in the process of its moving towards the light, is trying to grow itself in us. The Presence of <em>Other</em> is persuasive to this argument.</p><p>Because patience <strong>is not</strong> <strong>in</strong> <strong>the ocean as such</strong>; this is not presenting an animistic argument about nature. The reality of patience is liberated through the connective chain that brings the nature of water, a quality generated in the greater ocean-entity and the potential of human consciousness to witness such a moment, all together as a triad. It is not in any of the parts but in the inter-causal relation of all three.</p><p>And this summing into Greater accumulates from other chains of simple observation we can make such as <em>dog-waiting-food</em> or <em>mother-child-play</em> or some other chain in continuum, all unique but in simile to the persuasion argument of patience or care or understanding as many potential growth properties from which we make our connections to value.</p><p>The self-persuasion argument of intimacy may seem a long way from the power structures of human history that have come to dominate our field of vision. And it is a long way. But nevertheless it is always close by. For intimacy speaks to the natural genius of human life as an inner resource we may discover that is not, in itself, historical or even time-like. And, as adults, elders of the tribe if you like, it is the duty of each parent to nurture this natural genius in our off-spring</p><p>The three vectored logic of the <em>nucleus of reason</em>, as I choose to call it, is not so much a story but a realization; a reason that enters us as a persuasion through our ‘Being-with-Other’ experiences; a connecting up to the chains of participation, in which human consciousness is a unique and vital part of the chain.</p><p>And it is from such inner persuasions that we are then free to develop the inner qualities that persuade us to make necessary reformations in our personal, if not collective, human choices.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/55/1*KT7VrvbPjQCeiPUI6POk6w.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/623/1*iX_UYxm4Jw5wdSfHouRoBA.png" /></figure><p>In trying to make way for the more intimate perspective of inclusive logic, the self-persuasion argument touched on above is bound to come into conflict with the more impersonal nature of the modern scientific ways of knowing.</p><p>It is an old saying that nature loves to hide and ever since human beings have speculated about a hidden or deeper truth in nature beyond its surface appearance the argument between <em>objective</em> and <em>subjective</em> viewpoints has been a point of conflict; a conflict between the ‘mind’ and the ‘heart’, between science and religion, between the truth of an interior life that reveals nature in more experiential terms and a world ‘out there’ that can be measured.</p><p>But the middle argument, if it can be put that way, is to see the difference between these two arguments as no more than between two different but equally important ways of seeing the World.</p><p>There is obviously a difference between a way of coming to know the World that deliberately excludes the subject and a way that requires a subject as a necessary condition. That being so, the difference is put into perspective if the spirit potentials of (3) and (2) that shape these two arguments are seen in the context of a larger 9-fold infrastructure; a structure in which the terms inclusion and exclusion are not the basis of two apparently incompatible positions, only guiding principles in the kind of choices we make concerning our relationship to the World and to each other.</p><p>And yet, there is something deeper at work in the genius moments of the modern scientific revelation that has a bearing upon the relationship between these two ways of seeing the World. This resides in the fact that the mathematical structures that make science possible as a conceptual representation of nature are the very structures that allow a scientist to ‘see’ in the mind what seems otherwise hidden in nature.</p><p>If a scientist says they understand nature they are not referring to facts and figures or to the instrumental data upon which science relies for confirmation. They are referring to this deeper mathematical insight that reveals to the mind something that the Universe has already realised.</p><p>But why the World ‘out there’ and the mathematical concepts occurring in the abstract space of the human mind correspond in their deeper structures cannot be explained by the scientific argument itself. The Universe and the mathematical mind seem to correspond at depth but why this is the case still remains a mystery that lies beyond the scope of its method to explain. In the words of cosmologist Eugene Wigner: “the miracle of the appropriateness of the language of mathematics for the formulation of the laws of physics is a wonderful gift which we neither understand nor deserve”.</p><p>The mathematical basis of the modern scientific enterprise is sciences’ equivalent of the ‘Greater’ and scientists revere it as strongly as any adherent reveres their religion. And they should for in those moments of realisation when the Universe reveals itself to our human scientific acumen it brings the mind into a close and I would say intimate relation to the Universe which scientists pursue with passion.</p><p>To the extent that mathematical structures are the ‘Greater’ of the scientific argument and something that cannot itself be seen without a <em>subject</em> to see it, the scientific argument contains a hidden or unseen persuasion argument. It is a powerful argument backed by instrumental confirmation and carries a depth of personal conviction that scientific truth must, at bottom, be the Truth.</p><p>In moments of reflection it is probably the self-persuasive nature of the mathematical integrity of the universe, the inner experience that brings ‘subject’ and ‘object’ together in such an unexpected way, that makes some scientists temporarily evoke their own personal sense of ‘Other’; a feeling that they are looking at the ‘mind of God’ for example or that God must be a mathematician or that the mathematical equations are in some sense intelligent of themselves and are therefore showing us something beyond the laws they come to represent.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/12/1*KagpDzSldkIk8nUCbgf72Q.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/456/1*ShRYwrVwKmf1knUtVhwynQ.png" /></figure><p>The mathematical equations that the scientific mode of enquiry generates in relation to its observations of the natural world and formulates in terms of the principles and laws of physics, reside within the realms of human knowledge and it is easy to see why a scientist would tend to override those passing thoughts of something ‘Greater’.</p><p>And yet, what exists in the nature that we witness in front of our eyes <strong><em>is</em></strong> the realization of that intelligence by being the reality that the mathematical equations are trying to describe.</p><p>So, if the proposition that the Universe is, in some sense, intelligent, what kind of intelligence could its reality be? Is it the <em>same</em> or is it something <em>different</em> to human intelligence? Or does this strong coupling of universe and mind suggest a deeper set of principles at work in the Universe but which are able only to be partially realised within its demand for instrumental confirmation?</p><p>The kind of intelligence by which nature is able to be Present in front of our eyes as an enduring fact and not just present in the mind as mathematics is going to be referred to as <em>design intelligence</em> and Part 2 will be dedicated to the task of exploring this concept.</p><p>But like the proposal alone/not alone logics the design intelligence being explored here is not a binary choice between natural and super-natural agency. Instead, it takes into account a particular relation between all (9) spirit potentials being referred to as a nucleus of reason whilst yet being constrained by what any particular set of structural principles we fix upon in the middle sphere allow.</p><p>Conceived in this series, spirit potentials are no more abstract and no less real than gravity. Spirit potentials and gravity are palpable as well as highly abstract.</p><p>Through the creative moments of scientific acumen we have come to know design intelligence in the form of mathematical laws by using specifically tailored language such as force, power, energy, symmetry, plasma, magnetism, gravity, space, time and so on; through to biologically tailored language such as genetics, selection, replication, cell, gender, immunity, ecology, behaviour, nurture, nature and so on.</p><p>We also experience design intelligence, inclusively but not conclusively, through the evolution of such appreciations as sensory awareness, feeling, insight, consciousness, cognizance, logic and more that come to constitute our understanding of the World through the ongoing sequences of its realizations.</p><p>When the scientific argument explains to its audience that the Universe is expanding and we say ‘expanding into what?’ it tells us that we are naïve. There is no such thing as inside and outside of the Universe because these dualistic terms are transcended in the Greater mathematical scheme.</p><p>Similarly, by the same triadic principle, trying to understand the World by exclusive logic alone is also naïve. ‘Stand alone’ logic and ‘not alone’ logic are mutually implicated within the spiritual directive (2:3).</p><p>It is important to say, then, that <strong><em>design intelligence is not a pre-designed object but a reason to be discovered. It is the realization of an objectivity through which we may eventually find ourselves</em></strong>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/95/1*3WvWTdTNgt7w0JzsR0zWMw.png" /></figure><p>Thank you for taking the time to read this episode…</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=071bbce4aaa9" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Part 1 (episode 2): The Power to Choose]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@r.lingard9/part-1-episode-2-the-power-to-choose-ddd4e3b5b6e3?source=rss-66b3eef183eb------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ddd4e3b5b6e3</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[food]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[triadic-power-structure]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[free-will]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[choices]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cosmology]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ronnie Lingard]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 13 Sep 2026 11:10:49 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-09-13T11:10:49.811Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/709/1*wK4JVYI_IzjRivRuYmNimw.png" /></figure><h3><strong>Choice as a Triadic not Binary Power Structure</strong></h3><p>The everyday choices we make, however small, have their origins in reason even if the reason may sometimes be hidden or unclear or ‘unthought’, the reasons perhaps being already embedded in our everyday habits or in the historical patterns that have otherwise lost their meaning.</p><p>Even choosing to do something apparently for no reason, for the ‘hell of it’ so to speak, has its reasons such as trying to get away from those very same habitual requirements and loss of meaning that faces us every day. And yet, even being conditioned this way, internally by habit and externally by history, we may still feel we retain the power of personal choice. For the freedom to choose is not so much in the act of choosing but in the reason why.</p><p>Let’s take an apparently simple but fundamental example, food…</p><p>The reason to eat is a response to the automatic sensation of hunger which rises as an instigating enforcement in every living organism. In times where food maybe scarce this is the overriding reason to eat. We have no choice. But in times of plenty the reason to eat becomes overlaid by other reasons: an occasion, a community celebration, a first date, a reconciling gesture, to sell an idea to a prospective buyer, not to mention the simple fact of boredom and so on. The reason to eat can, in other words, become a shared even intimate pleasure or a small yet unsatisfying relief from loss of meaning.</p><p>If, however, a person chooses to go on hunger strike in defence of a deeply committed principle then, in order to sustain such an extreme and difficult to manage choice, the starting point of reason would have to come from a more powerful and consciously reasoned source.</p><p>To put this example in more general terms there are 3 levels:</p><p><strong>1.</strong> <strong>A <em>not chosen</em> level of reason</strong> concerning all that is automatically governing, instinctively enforcing or otherwise conditioned by the fact of carnality. Yet within this level of not chosen reason is a more subtle enforcement, psychological in its nature. We are born and familiarise ourselves with a world of existing culture that is particular to time and place. And unless we see otherwise this world already gives us the reason why we do what we do.</p><p><strong>2. A <em>chosen</em> level of reason</strong> in which we may find a range of options, some trivial (I choose this cereal instead of that) and some that fulfill a purpose beyond the fact of having to eat. This level is relational.</p><p><strong>3. </strong>A level of reason in which, in order for any committed principle to remain valid, the deciding person would have to <strong><em>choose to have no choice</em></strong>.</p><p>To choose to have no choice is obviously an extreme option. It is an action born on principle when all relational options have been exhausted. But there is another way to look at this triad which is not to do with running out of options.</p><p>The proposal that choice is a triadic power structure is claiming that these three levels, whilst distinct, are tightly bound as a <em>template of developing reason</em>. Or, as the 3-sphere would phrase it: <strong><em>intra-causal</em></strong>.</p><p><em>[The template of developing reason is a phrase that will be explored further in Part 2 of this series.]</em></p><p>To stand back and look upon choice as a triadic power and not a set of binary options is to see a very complex and facing set of questions which history shows us has no simple answer. For the systems of government that have been developed throughout human history from ‘might is right’ to liberality and its promises of false freedoms have failed on one thing: <strong><em>no governing system that remains just an external condition can ultimately succeed</em></strong>.</p><p>So, is there a way out that does just involve the principle of no option of choosing to have no choice?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/12/1*KagpDzSldkIk8nUCbgf72Q.png" /></figure><h3><strong>The Spectre of Free Will</strong></h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/295/1*-vR2N2FZjYICKc-e_88j2g.png" /></figure><p>The power to choose of course raises the spectre of free will which has been and is such a deep issue for us as individual human beings. Beyond the needs of living in a world that causes us to do what we do for reasons we did not choose, the wish to be free to choose one’s own way in life would probably be high on a person’s list of needs. At least, for those who have inherited the privilege of such a choice.</p><p>Broadening the argument what spirit potentials would say about the idea of ‘free will’ is that the will isn’t free until it has been ‘paid for’ and that payment is to realise the broader natural power structure within which every single person, rich or poor, privileged or not, is governed.</p><p>Global humanity has become a patchwork of competing systems of government. Yet governing all is a tangled web of economic enforcements that because of our collective choices is clearly in debt. World debt is counted in trillions of dollars and is a debt which we ultimately owe to its suppliers, the Earth and its energy provider the Sun. Free will is not then a personal question it is a cosmological question.</p><p>So, apart from a complex web of societal power structures created to provide governing conditions for the survival needs of human collectives, another side of this question of individual freedom concerns the natural power structures that automatically limit what we <strong><em>can do</em></strong> and applies to all human beings equally. <strong>In this context world debt is symptomatic of running out of options</strong>.</p><p>Putting economics to one side for the moment and going back to the food example: if by bad management and greed we undermine this cosmologically contexted Sun/Planet coupling as a pre-given power structure shared by all Life, the Earth will not be able to return enough food. At this point, the personal choice about food we may have enjoyed in times of plenty vanishes .</p><p>Whilst not always about food the lesson from history about the governing conditions of any social collective whatsoever (including global) is that, in spite of their apparent structural integrity, options wither and the structural integrity of the middle sphere of the 3-sphere collapses.</p><p>But we are clever are we not (?) and there are those who would say that human ingenuity will prevail because we can bend the rules of nature.</p><p>Well, maybe so, but whatever the case about human ingenuity the way forward cannot be to will the future by choosing to force nature too far from its own structural integrity. For this bending the rules creates another more insidious power in which the natural qualities that would ordinarily go with human to human relations such as trust and basic humanity are ultimately superseded by monetary concerns and diminishing resources.</p><p>And asking Chat GPT is not a solution it is an accelerant.</p><p>There is, in other words, a price to pay for choosing to keep just re-fixing nature to fit our existing requirements (choices). Especially if it requires such things as dumping toxic, forever chemicals that even now are building up in the food chain.</p><p>When monetary power becomes first principle and hence governing by default, the available choices can only become a process of diminishing return. And the middle level which should allow, within natural and humane limits, an open space for the freedom to develop our human choices in a more intelligent way starts to wither, as it is doing this very day as the world economy struggles to balance its books.</p><p>Money is symptomatic of a power that plays upon the human psyche by promising something that it cannot deliver. Money is the search for a false freedom and false choices and at this present time we are nearing bankruptcy and sorely in need of some of that human ingenuity but of the <em>self-facing</em> and <em>self-diagnostic</em><strong> </strong>kind.</p><p>The power to choose that we might recognise as ‘free will’ was never an argument between idealistic or ideological forms of social government, say, between a self-serving liberal democracy with too much choice of the trivial kind and more authoritarian regimes which control individual choice at all costs. It was always about overcoming the self-centredness of human greed and by definition this ignores any form of cosmological context.</p><p>But let’s look at this from a different perspective.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/55/1*KT7VrvbPjQCeiPUI6POk6w.png" /></figure><h3><strong>Three Forms of the Structural Principle of (3)</strong></h3><p>One of the recurring themes of this series is to explore diagnostics that can shed light on the human condition: its spiritual potential and the structural principles that serve its needs. For the integrity of the middle sphere is dependent upon its access to the inner sphere potential for its meaning.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/302/1*f2oXaLkI3aZiocKp1c-how.png" /></figure><p>From the perspective of structural principles looking more closely at the triadic potential in its hierarchical form, as 3 levels of choice, there are two other configurations of (3).</p><p>Whilst these two configurations are relatively independent they are also an integral part of the dynamical evolution of all hierarchies. These two other forms of (3) have, in fact, already been indicated by level 1 and level 3 in the food example above.</p><p>However, their independent power to act in ways that are decoupled from any human ‘leader-and-led’ hierarchical form of governance, comes from the fact that within the intra-causal integrity of the 3-sphere they do not operate from the principle of ‘high’ and ‘low’ but from a complementary principle — the principle of equivalence — but in very different ways.</p><p>Let’s look at the food example again…</p><p><strong>Level 1</strong>: equates by automatic enforcement and where governing criterion of food is concerned this is a simple equation all can appreciate. As the saying goes ‘<strong>everyone is equal under the Sun.’</strong></p><p><strong>Level 3</strong>: also operates from the criterion of equality but in a different way. In a spiritual context and not just a social one, level 3 equalizes the hierarchical power structure without destroying its efficacy by seeing that the deeper need of human life is not food or any other external requirement. It is a belonging need in which the principle of equivalence and all that goes to support it such as trust naturally becomes its central value in building of a spiritual and not just a societal infrastructure. Using the food analogy again a necessary principle in this stratum would see that all human beings have the right to food and other necessities rather than their being used as a weapon of control.</p><p>If level 3 is fulfilled the basic needs of level 1 is also satisfied and the hierarchical structure that organises the middle sphere simply becomes an operational or functional question and not a power seeking ideological one.</p><p>All human created power structures, even those that claim to uphold the freedom of choice, have within their configuration this double edge which plays out through the choices we make and the promises we break every day. This is the power of the middle level of personal choice, for as long as it remains open that is.</p><p>Global warming for example is a test case of our current choices and it demonstrates an alarming lack of action concerning what needs to be done in those who have the power to change it and have taken their eye of the ball being too engrossed in power struggles that nobody in their right mind wants.</p><p>A deeper and more vexing question, however, is: Does anyone have the power to change it? Have we not yet paid the price of glaring examples.</p><p>The climate debate is only one of a collection of world forums between Nations that promises much but being built on fragile relations and national constraints delivers little. Meanwhile the World is being split into two economic blocs.</p><p>But as already said before, this whole picture is a complex set of questions that faces each and every human being.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/95/1*3WvWTdTNgt7w0JzsR0zWMw.png" /></figure><p>Thank you for taking time to read this commentary. If it finds agreement with you please show it by using the hand icon…</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ddd4e3b5b6e3" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Part 1: Towards an Open Research into Science, Spirituality and Structural Principles]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@r.lingard9/part-1-towards-an-open-research-into-science-spirituality-and-structural-principles-c7c965af1078?source=rss-66b3eef183eb------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c7c965af1078</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[relationality]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[intra-causal]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[structural-principles]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[unity-spectra]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[triadic-template]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ronnie Lingard]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 10 Sep 2026 07:17:56 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-10-23T17:59:24.176Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/596/1*UvsDLY28OwVdAV3MkYwU1g.png" /></figure><p><strong><em>Structural principles and spirit potentials</em></strong><em>: Structural principles are the ways in which something bears the weights and pressures of the external and internal forces that act upon and within it. They are usually applied to such things as buildings and bridges. In relation to spirit potentials they carry the same function: How does a person, for example, bear the weights and pressures (internal and external) of their own self-realising potential?</em></p><p><em>This series is an open exploration into the relation between potentials and principles; between spirituality and the principle structures that best serve its realisations. It frames structural principles as a set of universal configurations structured by the numbers (1) to (9) and it is advised to read the introductory essay ‘Seeking Objectivity within a more Intimate Cosmology’ for this gives an outline of structural principles in this context.</em></p><p><em>The use of number as a set of universal configurations that serve both spirit potentials and their correspondent structural principles like-to-like do not, of course, refer to the concept of number as a process of unit counting or unit measurement.</em></p><p><em>So let’s start there…</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/12/1*KagpDzSldkIk8nUCbgf72Q.png" /></figure><p>Our earliest experience of numbers is their function as a system of unit counting such as 1 apple plus 1 apple equals 2 apples. This kind of counting by attachment to a common object is how we are first taught about numbers at school with pictures and signs. This picture method of teaching then allows a child to more readily accept on faith the abstract version situated in the rarified mental space of number theory beyond the reach of all objects and expressed by the simplest of equations 1 + 1 = 2.</p><p>Yet there is more in what is hidden in this equation than its apparent simplicity reveals.</p><p>The concept of 1 apple may be obvious to us because of the familiarity of handling things one at a time and this helps us in the everyday task of buying fruit. It makes for common sense and we no longer have to think about what unit counting means. However, when looked at from the perspective of structural principles the concept of ‘1 apple’ is itself an abstraction; something taken out of the World for our own convenience.</p><p>Reflecting on the apple equation as it is in the World and not in the rarified world of number theory the equation would not be 1 + 1 = 2. If there were to be such an equation it would have to read (1) + (1) = (3), for apples, if they are to be present in the World at all, cannot be separated from a whole system of co-relational exchange, (3) being the principle structure that upholds relationality.</p><p>If the equation (1) + (1) = (3) were to be put into axiomatic language, a way of saying the same thing is that (1) requires (3) as a minimum diagnostic from which comes the statement that <em>nothing can exist or be realised without three things being present</em> and a fuller meaning of this statement will be explored in Part 3.</p><p>Rather like the photograph shown above when we concentrate on the 1 of a single object, the falling leaf in this case, the background goes out of focus and the relationality that gives realisation to that particular leaf — where it came from and where it is going — is lost.</p><p>Everything — a leaf, a mountain, the sky, a human being — is on the move and the relational structure of the World is constantly changing and along with it its attendant forms. There is a balancing dynamic of exchange processes both within and between all things in such a way that something, like that single leaf, can continue to be what it is; at least, for as long as it is.</p><p>But the paradox of (1) in its relation to the complement of (9) structural principles is that it has no structure. Unlike the leaf, or a mountain, or the sky or a human being, (1) cannot be realised without losing its essential nature; without losing its unitary potential.</p><p>As a consequence, in order to include (1) as participant within the complement of (9) structural principles, (1) becomes the principle that seeks for structure and not a principle that provides it.</p><p>So how does the paradox of (1) play out in the way we see the World?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/12/1*KagpDzSldkIk8nUCbgf72Q.png" /></figure><h3><strong>Tensions within the Unitary Spectrum: Seen and Unseen</strong></h3><p>When the <em>Greek pre-Socratic philosopher</em> Thales of Miletus claimed that water was the source of all things he was obviously not referring to the substance made from molecular units signified by the chemical formula H2O. He was giving expression to what he saw as a unifying principle or <em>arche</em> intuited from his observations of the World.</p><p>We may take the modern version of water as collection of chemical units to be true of course and the ancient intuition to be false. However, what this contrast between Ancient and Modern shows is not so much an absolute distinction true as against false but opposing uses of (1) as a principle stretched across the poles of a unitary spectrum from units to unity in which there always seems to be an insufficiency of ground to bring the two poles into relation. In this case the structural principle of (3) remains unfulfilled.</p><p>Building the World bottom-up from smaller and smaller units in order to achieve unification as mainstream science has attempted to do, as against seeing the World through an overarching or unifying principle top-down to thereby explain ‘all things’ are two opposing metaphysical directives.</p><p>The contrast between the speculative philosophy of ancient metaphysics and modern science is clear to see. But the contrast between science and spirituality is more nuanced.</p><p>Due to scientific advancement in instrumental measurement of brain activity the contrast has also become more sharply defined. It has been brought into focus by empirical research into the phenomenon of consciousness and this has brought its traditional association with spirituality into question.</p><p>Spiritual and religious traditions both east and west have long since spoken of unification in states of consciousness; as a sense of Oneness whereby such states can even deny the ‘experiencer’. In fact would have to actively reject it as experiencer requires division.</p><p>But unification in science, if it is to retain the efficacy and universality of its explanatory method, would require that states of consciousness be ultimately reducible to some identifiable substrate such as the brain as an electro-chemical entity.</p><p>For spiritual traditions such methodological reduction would totally miss the point of the individual developmental journey to achieve such self-transcendent or transpersonal states.</p><p>The path of science and the path of spirituality seem to be intractably divergent. Even so, for both disciplines, the common ground is their denying or overcoming of the <strong><em>problematic subject</em></strong>. In the case of spirituality the method of contemplative meditation is letting go of a false sense of ‘self’. For science it is to deliberately circumvent the subject by denying it any access to the World at all by using the interface of instrumental measurement.</p><p>Whether about purity of consciousness or purity of objective knowledge, the tension between them as opposing poles on the unitary spectrum seems unavoidable. Yet, seen through the eyes of structural principles both disciplines, scientific and spiritual, have their own version of the unitary spectrum.</p><p>For spirituality the spectrum of consciousness may be said to stretch between True-Self and No-Self. It can also be said that the Truest Self is No-Self and there is no separation. But the tension within the unitary spectrum may then enter a secondary field of self-diagnostic questioning of how these states relate to the World.</p><p>Whether unitary consciousness is ultimately True-Self or No-Self, the question of relation to the World is present for both. Should attainment in such high states of consciousness take the form of teaching or a dedicated/intentional community that practices the necessary steps to purify Self. True Self may be inclined to this way of seeing the World. Or should it reject the World altogether as No-Self would be inclined to do, seeing that the ongoing business of human global commerce has little use of such exotic potential states that cannot be truly taught.</p><p>For science, however, relating to the World presents a problem already split into two parts; one external and one internal. The external problem concerns the piling up of ethical issues concerning the use of powerfully invasive high-tech in a very unstable world. Super-tech such as AGI does not come with an ethical manual. Such technology is scientifically high functioning but is ethically illiterate about its usage. It provides a red light warning but demands that each individual has to decide for themselves how best to address such ethical issues. The internal problem, however, relates to the scientific method itself. It is an instrumental interface problem.</p><p>The instrumental method of modern science was an attempt to cancel the effects of speculative metaphysics as a subjectively persuaded pursuit of knowledge. But keeping the subject out of its experimental investigations by the use of an instrumental interface was put to test by quantum systems. It seems that the subject (the experimenter) was, so to speak, being invited back into the experimental setup itself. The quantum principle questions the observer-world interface in its trying to draw a hard line between subject and object. The instrumental interface seems not as clean a separation as the scientific project first assumed or needed it to be.</p><p>The shear amount of industry that has been put into the observer/measurement question since the confirmation of quantum physics as a well established theory is testament to the depth of this as yet unresolved issue. There are plenty of candidates but for one reason or another they all fail on the unification issue without some kind of compromise or extreme condition.</p><p>Stepping back from the grand narratives of modern science and the spiritual/religious traditions that are now embedded in various cultures and looking at this in a social context, the unitary spectrum also manifests at a more personal scale through another form of polarity. The tension between individual freedom and collective cohesion is apparent in all socio-political structures of whatever persuasion: left, right or centre. In fact, it could be said that politics emerged so as to try and solve this very question of individual and collective relations without recourse to internal collapse and civil war.</p><p>With all this in mind an enquiring person might naturally ask the question: Are all these representations of the unitary spectrum related? Does the spiritual, scientific, social and cultural tendency to spectral spreading across dual horizons amount to an intractable problem that has a deeper meaning for us yet to decode?</p><p>In light of these preliminary considerations about the structural property of numbers as universal principles that have to bear the weight of internal and external pressures, sympathetically grounded like-to-like in spirit potentials, it is important to say that the aim of this series is not to solve apparent paradoxes surrounding the principle of (1) and its unitary spectrums but only to place them in a larger context.</p><p>It is for this reason that the first three Parts of this series will not focus directly on the nature of (1) as a spirit potential. Whilst exploring examples this series is not primarily taking the historical route as a main source of reference but drilling down, so to speak, into the bedrock of spirit potentials and their consequential principles.</p><p>Instead the first 3 parts of this series will first open up the language of the binary principle consequent within spirit potential (2) and the triadic principle consequent within the spirit potential (3) and in particular it will consider the many variations of their mutually co-dependent assembly (3:2).</p><p>But there is this to add…</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/12/1*KagpDzSldkIk8nUCbgf72Q.png" /></figure><h3><strong>The 3-sphere as a Universal Framework for all (9) Spirit Potentials</strong></h3><p>The use of frameworks in this series is to minimize the impact of premise-to-conclusion deductive logic and its tendency to pre-emptive closure of the unitary spectrum via one pole or the other.</p><p>A framework is a diagnostic window, simply that. They are abstractions through which we may look at the World and in that function they are part of a whole range of principle structures that occupy the middle sphere from sacred geometry and symbology to the conceptual language of the mathematical sciences.</p><p>Bearing this caution in mind if there were to be a framework as a guide to the whole of this series the 3 co-centric spheres first introduced in the opening commentary and shown below will prove to be extremely useful.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/299/1*o13mx01eHSD0sSs1BG74ug.png" /><figcaption><strong>3-Sphere Template</strong></figcaption></figure><h3><strong>Defining the Limits of Unity Spectra</strong></h3><p>As a structural principle, (3) is inter-relational and defines the limits of unity spectra. But as a spirit potential (3) is also intra-causal such that the three spheres, if co-centrically aligned, are <strong><em>in</em> <em>confluence</em></strong> with each other as a systemic evolution towards an attractor state constituted by all (9) spirit potentials. All three spheres are involved within the realisations of (9), for (3) evolves along the eigenvector* of the nested directive (3;6;9).</p><p>[*Note: The term ‘eigenvector’ is an unusual term to use in a spiritual context but it conveys the idea of a directive in the realisation of spirit potentials. An eigenvector is a special class of vectors that when transformed expand or contract the vector but do not change its direction (alignment). Something similar could be said about the alignment between spirit potentials and their corresponding structural principles. Principles expand the potential but do not change its essential directive. Thus structural principles may or may not be ‘spiritualised’.]</p><p>It is the decoding of the (9) potentials as an evolving system of living structures that this open research into science, spirituality and structural principles is attempting to explore.</p><p>It is being suggested then, that the 3-sphere is not just a framework but a multi-aspected, self-diagnostic template that offers objective guidance (directive) within this state of intra-causal triadic confluence of the 3-sphere.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/95/1*3WvWTdTNgt7w0JzsR0zWMw.png" /></figure><p>Thank you for taking the time to read the first episode of the first Part of this exploratory series.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c7c965af1078" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Seeking Objectivity within a more Intimate Cosmology:]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@r.lingard9/seeking-objectivity-within-a-more-intimate-cosmology-ee024d2a9032?source=rss-66b3eef183eb------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ee024d2a9032</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[esoteric]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[world]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[intimacy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cosmology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[spirit-potential]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ronnie Lingard]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 10 Sep 2026 06:47:07 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-10-31T08:39:41.248Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3><strong><em>Towards an Open Research into Science, Spirituality and Structural Principles</em></strong></h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*fRCGaxI83FtFnu90" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@nasa?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">NASA</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/288/1*h2t1iOpF43pX-HUhVFL5jw.png" /></figure><p>It is a truism to say that life is full of contradictions. Some examples are obvious hence the truism label. But obvious things eventually go unnoticed and we live side-by-side with contradiction because we have learnt to handle life with different departments in ourselves such as ‘head’ and ‘heart’.</p><p>To the head could be assigned an objective way of seeing the natural world and as a consequence use that world as a convenient resource without a second thought. And yet the heart may reveal another side to nature that evokes feelings of intimacy and beauty.</p><p>Head and heart have their ways and their reasons and we could accept these different ways of seeing the World and leave it at that. Except that in life we generally handle such things as difference and contradiction badly, irrationally, argumentatively, defensively, even aggressively and see the fact of difference as something to confront, eliminate or control.</p><p>We are clearly a product of nature, an organism like any other, except there is a deeper sense within human life that, whilst born of nature, we are not wholly bound to that world. Like the Janus god of Roman mythology holding a staff in one hand and a key in the other, we look two ways.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/345/1*aYUCDIFmwWLNkx_1b47GWQ.png" /><figcaption><strong>Janus: the god of beginnings, endings and transitions</strong></figcaption></figure><p>There seems to be an implicit ambiguity in being human, in being who we are, with one part firmly planted on Earth and the other perhaps now dreaming of going to the stars. This is a simple truth easy to see. It needs no metaphysical analysis. But it does require us to expand our vision of the World beyond arguing over who owns what.</p><p>What Janus represents is one aspect of a deeply rooted universal principle that is both easy to see and yet very difficult to fathom; a principle that is coded or structured by the number (2). It is one of 9 universal principles coded by number that inform the objectivity of this series of writings. This opening commentary will try to offer a simple and informative overview in order to start.</p><p>[Note: In the following explorations brackets e.g. (2) will be used to distinguish between structural principles configured by number and numbers as a system of unit counting.]</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/12/1*KagpDzSldkIk8nUCbgf72Q.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/558/1*dTUiNiuOfdjYjjpn903ACA.png" /></figure><p>The kind of objectivity to be explored in this series is not to do with objects or object measurement; things we can pick up, use and put down.</p><p>As with (2) the objectivity is based upon structural principles numerically configured across the whole range of natural numbers (1) to (9). The introductory comments above briefly focused on the structural principle of (2) simply because such phenomena as opposition, contradiction, difference, schism, resistance are ubiquitous in human behaviour; easily recognised but not easily dealt with. It is one of the ways we structure the World, extremely useful in context but at the same time deeply problematic.</p><p>Before broadening out this introduction I will briefly mention four historical figures that will help to place a few co-ordinates on what is a very large map that, in our modern object-centred world, has largely been dismissed as ‘esoteric’ as if this is an automatic death sentence. But the word stems from the Greek root <em>‘eso-’</em> and simply means <em>‘within</em>’. And this labeling ‘within’ highlights another problematic dualism that exposes an apparent opposite as it separates inner experience from outer observation; a distinction that keeps the terms ‘subject’ and ‘object’ in their separate boxes.</p><p>The four people chosen below have been selected on the basis that they each offer a reference location that gives to the role of numbers a status beyond their everyday meaning of counting and measuring.</p><p>· George Ivanovich Gurdjieff (1867–1949), an Armenian spiritual teacher, referred to natural laws by numbers such as the law of 3 and the law of 7 and by doing so opened the way to a unique developmental method said to have been bequeathed from ancient sources.</p><p>· John G Bennett (1897–1974) an English polymath and author of The Dramatic Universe, as well as being Gurdjieff’s one-time representative in England, offered a way of exploring numbers more generally as number-coded systems such as 2-term systems, 3-term systems and so on, referred to as systematics.</p><p>· At around the same time Carl Jung (1875–1961) a Swiss psychologist and explorer into the mysteries of the unconscious (his own included) added another dimension to numbers by calling them the most primitive archetypes of spirit.</p><p>· And taking a historical figure from the ancient world Pythagoras held that Nature or Kosmos is, in essence, number.</p><p>Modern science has a view of Nature that is also tightly bound to number; number in the sense of the counting of time and the measuring of distance. Yet in its use of pure mathematics as a source of principles used to describe to structure of matter, science could also be counted as esoteric and requires ‘initiation’ into the abstract spaces that theory demands.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/12/1*KagpDzSldkIk8nUCbgf72Q.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/352/1*IE2_k_9L0exfnIa3Axu3mg.png" /></figure><p>Alongside the structural principle of (2) the triadic principle (3) also has a central role in what is to follow. Presented in the form of 3 co-centric spheres (see below), the diagram is a concise graphic of a template that will occur repeatedly throughout this series with different examples according to context.</p><p>To make a fresh approach to this whole territory I want to map the ‘co-ordinates’ above onto this 3-sphere.</p><p>What Jung referred to as archetypal spiritual primitives, the inner sphere of the 3 spheres will refer to as spirit potentials. Primitive in the sense of prime but not yet developed and therefore still in potential. The inner sphere is host to all (9) spirit potentials.</p><p>What Gurdjieff called laws and Bennett called systems or laws of framework will be referred to in the middle sphere under the more general term of structural principles.</p><p>What then can be realised in the outer sphere is how the middle sphere serves the inner sphere and there will be many examples in the commentaries to follow according what spirit potentials are being explored.</p><p>The 3-sphere is also a map but nevertheless an extremely useful one…</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/289/1*ufmfCTHyYfWA9SYDIuRG_Q.png" /><figcaption><strong>The 3-Sphere as a Triadic Template</strong></figcaption></figure><p>Before getting too lost by using a map that has at the moment very few contours or landmarks let’s take an example…</p><p>If I say to another person ‘there is an oak tree in front of us’ they can readily agree that there is in fact 1 oak tree and not 2 or more oak trees. But object counting doesn’t really work in this instance. Taking time into account, there is actually a forest of oak trees standing before us in the potentiality of each acorn.</p><p>That (1) can become many (1)’s highlights the potentiality of the single oak tree but how that potential develops in actuality is the uncertainty of unrealized options. Standing between the potentiality of the acorn and the expanding forest are the governing dynamics of its immediate world.</p><p>Structural principles are similarly contextual as the interface that stands between spirit potentials and their realization.</p><p>How we form our own structural principles or self-law, knowingly or by default, is how we will come to see the World.</p><p>So, let’s look at (2) from a different perspective.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/12/1*KagpDzSldkIk8nUCbgf72Q.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/558/1*wtk1zXxdBOFhg_1PZoJElQ.png" /></figure><p>If a child goes to their mum with a cut finger she may dress the wound and this is an obvious solution to what is absent. But for the child, beyond the practicality of first aid, it is the presence of parental care, the ‘kissing it better’, that more deeply resolves the Absence. The bandage is an easily seen need but the quality of maternal care is the unseen need that heals another part of the child.</p><p>It is a more intimate part and yet still ‘primitive’ in the sense of a young life not yet developed to understand why the World can be painful. Pain is part of growing up of course but the maternal act helps protect against what may later become deeper occlusions in the spiritual growth and thus psychology of the child.</p><p>This example points not just to absence as a need but an instinctive (sometimes conscious) awareness of Absence as a spirit potential. Without Absence there is no growth or maturity for the child or, for that matter, no evolution for a species that cannot successfully negotiate its ecology.</p><p>That which is truly Absent is sometimes difficult to see for there is another end to the bar of Absence where structure crystallises into the hard position of a dualism; a separation framed by (2) but without apparent third principle.</p><p>As a structure (2) is easy to see by simply drawing up a list of apparent opposites; good and bad, within and without, mind and matter, child and adult, high and low, Fiat and Fact, time and eternity, everything and nothing…the list that could be named is in fact endless; Chinese philosopher Lao-Tsu’s 10,000 things. It is apparent everywhere and throughout everything from the microscopic to the macroscopic.</p><p>However, there are no opposites in Absence as a spirit potential that is still not yet structured; there is only growth. In the child example Absence naturally draws out from a caring mother maternal Presence. In the 3-sphere Absence (2) is intimately linked to Presence (3) as a co-dependent coupling.</p><p>The relationship between the caring mother and the child’s pain is not then fully reasoned; it is naturally abductive.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/12/1*KagpDzSldkIk8nUCbgf72Q.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/433/1*XT0GuH7dfe0DoYvTf1Wqug.png" /></figure><p>Expressed qualitatively as the Principle of Absence and the Principle of Presence, spirit potentials (2) and (3) may themselves seem opposite rather like the way that the two hemispheres of the brain may see the same World in contrasting ways.</p><p>When binary logic crystallises into an ‘us and them’ argument, the struggle to escape what become intransigent complex schisms within and between cultures to the point where access to any resolution seems impossible to reach, physical conflict becomes the default action.</p><p>And yet, in the courts of reconciliation in post-apartheid South Africa the perpetrators were able to admit and the victims forgive in the face of the pain and trauma of that ‘us and them’ division and its ensuing atrocities. Admission and forgiveness go beyond anything gained or lost by punishment or physical conflict. The court of reconciliation was for the benefit and healing of the whole culture, for the soul of that culture, to release it from spiritual deadlock and clear the way for a new start.</p><p>In a court of law if the facts are clear and unbiased the perpetrator is judged and punished. We need courts of law of course but the court of reconciliation appeals to a higher court — an inner spiritual court — where intimacy cannot be avoided for it serves a deeper human need which cannot be otherwise reconciled.</p><p>I have chosen the word <em>intimacy</em> in the title but this is a cover-all name for a whole microcosm of inner qualities human life has strived for and demonstrated throughout what has otherwise been a deeply troubled and sometimes unspeakable history in the process of human life forever locked into the power struggle of being at war with itself.</p><p>In spite of the atrocities recorded by history books and happening now, each and every day, this ‘inner microcosm’ of intimate qualities, to care about something beyond personal gain for example, has thankfully not been fully extinguished in ordinary discourse between human beings who are not entrenched in identity politics.</p><p>There is something in the human configuration that answers not just to the will of conquest or subjugation but to the will of a deeper need. The court of reconciliation in the aftermath of apartheid is an isolated example but the need for solutions, resolutions and even absolutions in this inner court sense is that which reconciles for the benefit of all.</p><p>As co-relation, both Absence (2) and Presence (3) are part of the bridge-building of reconciliation. But all nine potentials are needed to complete the bridge. As a whole, the structural principles (1)-to-(9) are going to be referred to as the <em>universal infrastructure</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/12/1*KagpDzSldkIk8nUCbgf72Q.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/299/1*oVMmcUzgyLKMxkd1MtsaqA.png" /></figure><p>Cosmology is about the ‘Big Picture’; the whole Universe: observable, unobservable and intangible. So, considering the unimaginable size of the Universe stretching beyond the horizon of the best telescopes ever invented the phrase ‘intimate cosmology’ is at the very least incongruous.</p><p>But this would be to underestimate the mutually implicated sense of why we, as transient beings, would seek for answers to questions on such a grand scale as the Universe.</p><p>Modern telescopes have expanded the human vision of how we see the World far into deep space and therefore into deep time. However, even in this expanded view it seems that the vast majority of what makes up the Universe remains dark to instrumental observation and cosmologists are searching to find the missing pieces of the puzzle; searching for what is theoretically and instrumentally Absent.</p><p>Something similar could be said of the microcosm of human qualities. Instruments can measure the sparking of brain activity in various states of consciousness and assign locations or regional effects as brain frequencies oscillate within and between zones. But instruments cannot find anything in this inner cosmos of bones, blood and brains as to what it means to be conscious; of what it means to care for a child.</p><p>In a way this is an obvious result. How can inner qualities like understanding and care and forgiveness be measured except by another human being who also understands and cares and can forgive? Giving them a Latin name ‘qualia’ does not help, for names hide as much as they reveal.</p><p>Any genuine exploration into the phrase ‘intimate cosmology’ would naturally ask the question: Are these two worlds, the inner microcosm of an intimate feeling life and the virtually infinite Universe we see as out there, somehow connected? Not just as material substance but in the sense of belonging.</p><p>The co-respondence between the infinite macrocosm and the intimate microcosm is of course an old idea. It was a central tenet of Hermetic philosophy that the inner cosmos and the outer cosmos were not only mutually implicated but also mirror each other. This sense of closeness to the Kosmos is no doubt something that the Pythagoreans understood in a way that we cannot perhaps imagine in our super-tech conquest of the natural world.</p><p>Separated by time it is difficult to see through ancient eyes, so what the Hermetic philosophers of old had in mind with this central tenet of co-respondence is not easy for the modern mind to take and therefore too easy to simply reject.</p><p>Modern science would of course claim any such esoteric view is naive and has been superseded by the explanatory power of mathematics and instrumental evidence. But, in the opinion of the writer, this instrumental-theoretic view is also naive. Without rejecting either view perhaps it needs a new start.</p><p>What follows in the commentaries to come is a personal project and is not trying to convince anyone of whether it is true or not. But for anyone reading this hopefully there is enough in it to match with your own search concerning the key question of ‘How do I/we see the World?’</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/95/1*3WvWTdTNgt7w0JzsR0zWMw.png" /></figure><p>Thank you for taking the time to read this introductory episode…</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ee024d2a9032" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>