<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Rachelle Martinez on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Rachelle Martinez on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@raaachelle?source=rss-9b509b93f729------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sun, 22 Nov 2026 23:34:56 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@raaachelle/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Making Higher Education More Cooperative: Lessons from the Mondragon Corporation]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@raaachelle/making-higher-education-more-cooperative-lessons-from-the-mondragon-corporation-1fa6a05832dd?source=rss-9b509b93f729------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/1fa6a05832dd</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[mondragon]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[higher-education]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cooperatives]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Rachelle Martinez]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 02 Aug 2024 04:18:59 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-08-22T22:39:46.041Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>“It is said that institutions which oppose change will, in the end, be destroyed by it.” — Dr. Alex Laidlaw</em></p><p>There remains an enduring tension between the values proclaimed by an institution of higher education and the ways in which the organizational culture is experienced by various campus stakeholders. Many colleges and universities continue to struggle with sustaining equitable and inclusive practices for the increasingly diverse communities they serve (Hurtado, 1992). While much progress has been made since the inception of higher education in the United States nearly four hundred years ago, much work still remains.</p><p>There are many areas of higher education that can be examined when it comes to the clash between espoused values and institutional culture. While students and faculty receive the lionshare of campus resources when it comes to support with inclusion and belonging, administrators and staff are given relatively less attention. In the years following the Covid-19 pandemic, there were higher rates of turnover as “The Great Resignation” made its impact on the higher education workforce (Ellis, 2021). This phenomenon was particularly acute in the realm of student affairs as budgets shrank, stress increased, and morale declined (NASPA, 2021).</p><p>After a recent visit to the Mondragon Corporation in the Basque Country of Spain, it got me thinking about how their cooperative model could inspire new approaches to improving the workplace for higher education administrators and staff. I entered the world of higher education as an undergraduate over fifteen years ago and have remained in this space as either a student or an employee ever since. I am currently pursuing my PhD in Leadership Studies at the University of San Diego (USD) in the School of Leadership and Education Sciences (SOLES), and my visit to Mondragon was in the context of a global study course on cooperative leadership. The central focus of my research is examining how individuals use power and resistance to cultivate belonging in the workplace irrespective of their place in the organizational hierarchy, and my dissertation focuses specifically on the experiences of women of color mid-level administrators.</p><p>In addition to being a doctoral student, I also serve SOLES as the director of student engagement. My prior work experience was primarily in undergraduate academic advising, so shifting to graduate student engagement has broadened my skills even further. SOLES comprises three academic departments: counseling and marital and family therapy, learning and teaching, and leadership studies. Across these departments are a variety of master’s and doctoral programs with a population of over 700 graduate students. In the four years that I have been in this role (initially as an assistant director then promoted to director last year), I have seen our fair share of comings and goings among our administrators and staff.</p><p>Now don’t get me wrong, SOLES conducts amazing and impactful work, and it has been the best professional environment of my career to date. At the same time, SOLES is still subject to the constraints that all institutions of higher education are currently facing. The Covid-19 pandemic led to enrollment challenges that trickle down to tighter budgets for many colleges and universities. This impacted not only the resources available to carry out the work but also the prospects of salary and promotion for employees. The pandemic also awakened many individuals to the joys of fully remote work, which inspired their departure as campuses mandated a return to in-office work. It is also important to note that the racial awakening in the summer of 2020 prompted an interrogation of diversity and equity practices on many campuses throughout the country. Inadequate support for addressing racism and conflicts between personal values and observed institutional values are potential contributors to student affairs professionals leaving the field (NASPA, 2021).</p><p>While I have witnessed firsthand the enormous efforts that take place to live out our mission and values, SOLES is no exception to the trappings of being part of a university in this day and age. This means there is always ample opportunity for improvement. As SOLES continues to realize our vision of creating a better world, the Mondragon Corporation’s cooperative model provides a framework with which new strategies can be developed. The principles that the corporation espouses “include open admission, democratic organization, the sovereignty of labor, the instrumental and subordinate nature of capital, participatory management, payment solidarity, inter-cooperation, social transformation, universality, and education” (Cheney et al., 2014).</p><h3>The Magic of Mondragon</h3><p>The Mondragon Corporation attributes its inception to José María Arizmendiarrieta, a Catholic priest whose vision for society centered human dignity and social justice through cooperation. The cooperative model is rooted in the Basque social tradition that values solidarity and hard work (MacLeod, 1997). To Arizmendiarrieta, work is seen as a collective endeavor. That is to say, no individual works alone, and all work is interdependent. As a foil to Western individualism where work supports personal consumption, Arizmendiarrieta viewed work as a means through which to accumulate wealth as a community. Furthermore, work is not a punishment to be evaded but a meaningful endeavor that bolsters personal development by contributing to the community (MacLeod, 1997).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*BvPgnnSgt6YcpAFk5-ZOEA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Otalora, Center for Management and Cooperative Development for the Mondragon Corporation</figcaption></figure><p>While Arizmendiarrieta had his disagreements with capitalism, he understood the necessity of capital in order to participate in modern society. However, while a traditional capitalist enterprise values capital, the cooperative prioritizes people. Furthermore, instead of decisions being made by shareholders, they are made by the workers who own a portion of capital within the cooperative. This creates an environment where worker-owners are invested in ensuring the growth of capital. They are members of the cooperative and each have a vote in the general assembly where major decisions are made (MacLeod, 1997). As members, their participation in decision making includes electing corporate representatives and committee members, developing their job descriptions, and profit-sharing (Hererra, 2004).</p><p>Participation in decision making is a key characteristic of the cooperative model. While the foundational values focus on centering humanity, the operations of the cooperative focus on the economy (MacLeod, 1997). In that sense, while members of the cooperative vote in the general assembly, day-to-day decisions are still made by managers who have been selected by the members. The organizational structure is not unlike that of a capitalist corporation in that there is a hierarchy with managers possessing a basic level of decisive authority. However, what does differentiate the cooperative is its moral foundation. Among managers, that manifests as an obligation to remain regularly trained, not only professionally but also personally. Arizmendiarrieta noted how critical management development was in the cooperative model. Managers must maintain open lines of communication as well as offer resources and support to the workers. An interesting part of this social commitment among managers is having the self-awareness to recognize when they are no longer equipped to keep up with the growth and choose to step down for the good of the cooperative.</p><p>While the cooperative is still hierarchical, the workers have the right to work, even if the economy changes. If the economy shifts and certain industries face a decline, workers from cooperatives that close are trained and placed in another (MacLeod, 1997). While a capitalist corporation would not hesitate to lay off workers to maximize revenue and minimize losses, cooperatives believe in an individual’s right to work as a form of human dignity, just as Arizmendiarrieta saw it. Additionally, cooperatives who experience losses within the Mondragon Corporation, which currently comprises 81 cooperatives, receive funds reallocated from cooperatives who made a profit. This is possible because the culture is rooted in trust and solidarity. The hierarchical structure is in place to streamline decision making, not to stratify individuals and their value based on rank.</p><p>Solidarity is what keeps the Mondragon Corporation together through times of prosperity and decline. Analogous to the human body, each cooperative within the corporation is essential to one another. “Each part has its own identity but yet can only function as part of a larger whole” (MacLeod, 1997, p. 89). Furthermore, members are not only obligated to look out for one another but also for the needs of society. Cooperatives must continuously be aware of the community and how to contribute to the common good through the creation of jobs and community development projects.</p><p>Another feature of the cooperatives is the solidarity through pay. The ratio of salary between top executives and those working in the factories or the field is limited (Herrera, 2004). These equitable ratios are currently 6:1, executive to field/factory worker, and these ratios are voted on by each member in the general assembly. “It is recognized that the work performed by all worker-owners is worthy of dignity, and they are all interdependent” (Herrera, 2004, p. 62). This is astounding when compared to traditional capitalist corporations that can be 400:1 or greater. While executives could certainly work outside of the cooperative to make a higher salary, they believe in economic justice over individual gain.</p><p>Now that I have discussed some of the context and key characteristics of the Mondragon Corporation, I will outline how this framework inspired three strategies that can be applied to higher education as a way to further invest in the experiences of administrators and staff, specifically through the lens of my experience at SOLES. In doing so, I will also provide additional details regarding the cooperative framework to help bridge worlds between the Mondragon Corporation and higher education in the United States. The strategies are as follows: 1) sub-unit onboarding, 2) financial competency, and 3) participation in decision making.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*NLKwEVrpvCcSrQUHn53-SA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Ander Etxeberria, director of cooperative dissemination for the Mondragon Corporation, and me</figcaption></figure><h3>Cooperative Strategies for Higher Education</h3><h3>Strategy 1: Sub-unit Onboarding</h3><p>While the University of San Diego provides a standard employee orientation for all newcomers, the onboarding process specifically at SOLES varies depending on the nature of your role and who you report to. In the absence of an official policy or process, the supervisor makes their own determinations about who the new employee should meet, how they will be welcomed, and what they must do in order to get familiar with the organizational culture and their place in it. This difference is stark in comparison to students and faculty.</p><p>As part of my role, I plan the new student orientation for our incoming graduate students so I know their onboarding process quite well. To support their sense of self-efficacy and belonging, I ensure that they are introduced to the abundance of resources available to them as well as given the opportunity to connect with their peers and professors. As for our new faculty members, they are invited to a new faculty orientation hosted by our associate dean. In this orientation, they are given an overview of SOLES and the key sources of support that they will need to be successful during their time here.</p><p>While one might argue that the employee orientation hosted by human resources for all new administrators and staff should suffice, that ignores the reality that there are subcultures within the various schools and departments on campus. Garcia (2016) referred to them as microclimates when she studied the experiences of student affairs professionals at Hispanic Serving Institutions. When considering the Mondragon Corporation and the importance of working as a collective, having a standard onboarding process and orientation for new administrators and staff at SOLES can provide a strong foundation rooted in mission and values.</p><p>This presents an opportunity to ensure that every new administrator and staff is given the same information about the school itself. This instills a sense of mission and creates a common understanding when information is shared in a consistent manner. It is also a chance for SOLES to share their origin story and vision as a way to contextualize the work that each newcomer will take part in. Each group of new hires can also form informal cohorts that can bond over their “newness” and provide mutual support as they acclimate. Currently, how one gets to know SOLES and their work depends on who they talk to and that can vary by department or team. Creating a formalized and centralized onboarding process at SOLES can support the development of their belonging at the outset.</p><h3>Strategy 2: Financial Competency</h3><p>The dean’s office at SOLES hosts a monthly all-hands meeting for administrators, faculty, students, and staff during the fall and spring semesters. This is where important announcements are made, and the various departments within SOLES share their updates. The introduction of this practice by our current dean was welcomed by many. Prior to this, there was no formal space where the whole SOLES community could come together to share information (at least in the four years that I have been there). There have been instances where SOLES finances have been discussed at an all hands meeting. Our assistant dean of finance and planning would provide an overview of our financial landscape and share various data points. I found this practice to be refreshing because financial transparency is not necessarily a priority in higher education. It was certainly a first for me in my career, and I definitely appreciated the information.</p><p>My suggestion builds on this practice by implementing training sessions to understand the financial operations of the school and in higher education in general. Doing so would allow administrators and staff to contextualize the financial data and develop a familiarity with what these numbers mean. For the worker-owners of the cooperatives in the Mondragon Corporation, part of their responsibility as owners is developing an understanding of the business. While converting the University of San Diego into an employee-owned entity reasonably sounds like a nonstarter (at least at this point in time), we could still invoke the cooperative principle of education within SOLES among administrators and staff as it relates to understanding the finances of higher education.</p><p>One arena in which this could be conducted is during the monthly staff and administrator meetings. These are thirty-minute virtual meetings where information relevant to this group are shared, typically in the form of announcements. It is not uncommon for the meeting to get canceled if it is a particularly busy season, such as the end of the year, or if there isn’t much information to share. To exercise the strategy of financial competency, the meeting could be extended to an hour, and the assistant dean of finance and planning could provide an overview of how funding is allocated at SOLES. From tuition and donations to paychecks and resources, demystifying the financial operations of SOLES can provide clarity for administrators and staff who are unfamiliar with these processes.</p><p>It may also prompt more understanding instead of resentment when promotions are delayed or salaries are frozen. Without this information, people are left to their own assumptions, and those may not always be the most generous of interpretations. According to MacLeod (1997), “the model must include education and development of the work force as well as effective means of communication between the associates” (p. 82). By providing administrators and staff with the opportunity to develop a working knowledge of how finances in higher education work, it can create a culture in which everyone feels a deeper sense of responsibility over the ways in which resources are spent.</p><h3>Strategy 3: Participation in Decision Making</h3><p>The hierarchical structure of higher education is also reflected in the decision making process. Major decisions are made at the top and are enforced on employees who had very little say in them. Given that SOLES is part of a university, that seems unlikely to change in the short term. However, it might be beneficial to have employees take part in some decision making, even if they are low risk ones to start with. Employee participation in any decision making would be novel for SOLES as there is currently no occasion during which administrators and staff vote on any sort of decision (at least not formally). And that’s not a knock on SOLES because it’s a common organizational norm. Herrera (2004) describes it as “the absence of participation by most managers and employees in practically any corresponding aspect in traditional organizations” (p. 60).</p><p>We recently had our annual administrator and staff retreat, and that seems like a great place to pilot employee participation in decision making. For example, the content addressed at the retreat is determined by the dean’s leadership team. It might be worthwhile to solicit input from the administrators and staff to understand what topics they would like to discuss. At the very least, it would provide insights on what administrators and staff are concerned about going into the next academic year, even if it cannot necessarily be covered during the retreat. Also, from our visit to Mondragon, we learned from a worker-owner, who served a prior term as elected president of her cooperative, that not all employees vote at the general assembly even if they have the right to. So if what I was describing about Mondragon sounded too much like a utopia, that example adds a dose of reality. Nonetheless, my sense is that it is not necessarily that every employee must provide input but that the organization is set up such that they could if they wanted to. It is that freedom of choice that humans love — a reminder of one’s agency.</p><p>Besides, if voting on agenda items feels like too much of a leap, then maybe they can vote on the type of swag item they are given that year. All to say, it is less about what the decision is and more about the practice of institutionalizing employee input as a mechanism through which they can feel heard. Feeling heard cultivates belonging, which can help mitigate “The Great Resignation” happening in student affairs.</p><h3>The Importance of Place</h3><p>It is essential to note the importance of place when it comes to the cooperative magic that takes place in Mondragon. The cooperatives’ collective goal of working toward the common good of society can be considered leadership. Sutherland and colleagues (2022) assert that “by considering ‘place’, we must recognise that leadership is inherently context-dependent and ultimately beyond the scope of any particular discipline or approach to fully explain” (p. 9). For the Mondragon Corporation, Arizmendiarrieta integrated Basque values and Catholic social thought in his vision for the cooperative. As Ander Etxeberria, director of cooperative dissemination for the Mondragon Corporation, explained during our visit, the values are turned into rules and are instilled into the structure of the cooperative.</p><p>For example, one of their values is solidarity, and this is very much reflected in “the no lay-off policy, the willingness to retrain and absorb displaced workers among cooperatives, and the limited pay ratios between top executives and factory/field workers” (Hererra, 2004, p. 64). Prioritizing people over capital is integrated into the organizational processes. And that is not to say that one is at the expense of the other. Putting people first is great for business. In recognizing the interdependence of the cooperatives, it is in their best interest to invest in each other’s longevity through profit-sharing. By having their values instilled into the organizational processes, the cooperative model “would not only compete, but do better than conventional business” (MacLeod, 1997, p. 85).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*90FRHb1N85tUQISFqIzAIQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Arizmendi Ikastola, a cooperative in the Mondragon Corporation</figcaption></figure><p>The importance of place means that the institutional values mirror that of the community. The Basque social tradition is instilled in their people from the outset. During our visit to the Arizmendi Ikastola at one of their elementary schools, we learned about the values that are at the foundation of the curriculum. One of these values is pride in being Euskaldun, which is Basque in the Basque language, or Euskara. While that may make it easier to socialize oneself into a cooperative, of which Arizmendi Ikastola is one, it does not mean it is impossible to achieve in another context. But it certainly suggests that the approach must differ to fit the context.</p><h3>Where Do We Go From Here?</h3><p>Of the many pieces of wisdom that Arizmendiarrieta offered through actualizing his vision for the cooperative, “he claimed that one could not know the real world in a laboratory; it can only be known in doing concrete actions” (MacLeod, 1997, p. 56). While it is very appropriate for higher education to develop scholarship on this very phenomenon, there is no greater potential for change than by taking action and learning from the experience. “Cooperative work requires mutual care and help, working closely and sharing with each other, participating, compromising, negotiating and often accepting decisions contrary to one’s wishes” (Herrera, 2004, p. 64). An entire organizational restructuring is not the only way to achieve this.</p><p>Besides, based on Herrera’s (2004) requirements for cooperative work, this can also be achieved through a shift in mindsets and behaviors. An individual must choose to approach their work in this way day in and day out. Developing a regular practice in which we are striving to embody cooperativism through mutual support, compromise, and negotiation can help to support the belonging of administrators and staff in higher education. Individual commitment can lead to collective change, which can facilitate organizational transformation. While it may seem impossible, as Arizmendiarreta is famously known to have said: “let us try and see.” (MacLeod, 1997, p. 55).</p><h3>References</h3><p>Cheney, G., Santa Cruz, I., Peredo, A. M., &amp; Nazareno, E. (2014). Worker cooperatives as an organizational alternative: Challenges, achievements and promise in business governance and ownership.<em> Organization, 21</em>(5), 591–603. <a href="https://doi.org/10.1177/1350508414539784">https://doi.org/10.1177/1350508414539784</a></p><p>Garcia, G. A. (2016). Exploring student affairs professionals’ experiences with the campus racial climate at a Hispanic Serving Institution (HSI). <em>Journal of Diversity in Higher Education, 9</em>(1), 20–33. <a href="https://doi.org/10.1037/a0039199">https://doi.org/10.1037/a0039199</a></p><p>Herrera, D. (2004). Mondragon: A for-profit organization that embodies catholic social thought. <em>Review of Business, 25</em>(1), 56–68.</p><p>Hurtado, S. (1992). The campus racial climate: Contexts of conflict. The <em>Journal of Higher Education, 63</em>(5), 539–569. <a href="https://www.jstor.org/stable/1982093">https://www.jstor.org/stable/1982093</a></p><p>MacLeod, G. (1997). <em>From Mondragon to America</em>. University College of Cape Breton Press.</p><p>Student Affairs Administrators in Higher Education (NASPA) (2021). <em>The compass report: Charting the future of student affairs.</em> <a href="https://naspa.org/about/future-of-student-affairsreport/the-compass-report-charting-the-future-of-student-affairs">https://naspa.org/about/future-of-student-affairsreport/the-compass-report-charting-the-future-of-student-affairs</a></p><p>Sutherland, N., Bolden, R., Edwards, G., &amp; Schedlitzki, D. (2022). Putting leadership in its place: Introduction to the special issue. <em>Leadership, 18</em>(1), 3–12. <a href="https://doi.org/10.1177/17427150221083498">https://doi.org/10.1177/17427150221083498</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=1fa6a05832dd" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Shift Your Language to Make Room for Nuance in a Dichotomous World]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@raaachelle/shift-your-language-to-make-room-for-nuance-in-a-dichotomous-world-17cd2d5af5f0?source=rss-9b509b93f729------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/17cd2d5af5f0</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[language]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ego]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Rachelle Martinez]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 15 Apr 2023 00:02:49 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-04-17T17:15:21.356Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Given the amount of information our brains are exposed to at any given moment, its efforts to simplify our world make sense. To be aware of every single detail in our day to day lives is impossible to manage. Our brains support our survival by focusing on what most requires our attention. For example, on an average commute to work, it is more important to be aware of the cars and pedestrians around you than the number of houses you drive past or the sensation of the clothes on your body. The challenge is how the efficiencies of our brain can turn into oversimplification. We see these tendencies addressed in efforts such as implicit bias training, where we confront subconscious associations based on these mental heuristics. In the current political climate in the United States, it is apparent in everyday conversations, media headlines, and popular culture that our perspectives have been reduced to either/or binaries. In glancing at the New York Times website, articles discuss blue or red states, the political left or right, and liberals or conservatives. To reduce ourselves to binary thinking is to lose out on subtleties that can create more understanding across these invisible lines. What might we do to move us in a direction that makes room for nuance?</p><p><strong>A Crash Course in Ego Development Theory</strong></p><p>An interesting theory to approach this is Susanne Cook-Greuter’s Ego Development Theory (EDT). Her theory outlines eight stages of development that are rooted in how an individual makes meaning of the world around them along behavioral, emotional and cognitive dimensions. In this theory, the ego plays a large role in how we navigate our world. “The ego is the meaning maker… it orchestrates, integrates, and metabolizes experience throughout life” (Cook-Greuter, 2013, p. 12). While the stages vacillate between differentiation and integration, the theory as a whole also illustrates a focus on differentiation in the first half and a focus on integration in the second half. In the first four stages of EDT, “development from birth to adulthood shows an overall trend of increasing differentiation towards an independent, well-defined, individual self-identity” (Cook-Greuter, 2013, p. 16). In these stages, we acquire knowledge to help us understand patterns and rules of our world. The second half of EDT is focused on integrating with others and having a greater awareness of a more inclusive reality. Instead of the acquisition of knowledge, the emphasis is on developing wisdom to have a broader understanding of our assumptions and seeing us all as parts of a whole system.</p><p>The unitive stage, which is the last of this theory’s stages, is when “individuals experience themselves and others as part of ongoing humanity… they can cherish the humanness in the seemingly most undifferentiated beings and feel at one with them” (Cook-Greuter, 2013, p. 87). It is important to note that there is no moral hierarchy among each of the stages. A higher stage is not better, just different. But for the purposes of inviting nuance into our thinking, the unitive stage provides an opportunity to think about how to combat the ego’s potential to deepen the binaries we are socialized in. “The ego maintains its stability, its identity, and its coherence by selectively gating out observations inconsistent with its current state” (Cook-Greuter, 2013, p. 12). The selective inattention of the ego protects us from the distress of grappling with contradictions. It is not until the unitive stage that an individual is able to witness their own ego and not create value judgments on the inconsistencies that are a natural part of our world. While the dichotomies we have created are a way to simplify our world, they are not mirrors of its reality.</p><p>In thinking about the common binaries of our society, our everyday language plays a role in continuing this line of thinking. By reducing phenomena to dichotomous labels, we reinforce the idea of us versus them, and this impedes on the potential for consensus, collaboration, or compromise. As a result, it becomes all the more difficult to address the problems of our world, whether that be climate change, reproductive justice, or gun violence. By opening ourselves to the nuance of seemingly opposing positions, we may discover that there is room for everyone and that together is the best way forward to solve these issues.</p><p><strong>Language Strategies from the Unitive Stage</strong></p><p>How we talk about our world creates the reality in which we live. In an effort to make room for more nuance and subtlety into our interactions with others, we can create room to understand how our lived experiences contribute to the perspectives we hold. Developing that understanding can then foster empathy and compassion to move us toward finding collective solutions that create our best chance at social change.</p><p><strong>Strategy 1: Not Debate, But Dialogue</strong></p><p>Framing something as a debate automatically brings forth the idea of opposing positions. Furthermore, it also means a debate can be won by poking holes in the arguments of your opponent and successfully defending your position. While this is a common exercise in classrooms as a way to learn how to make sound arguments, carrying this further into our everyday interactions creates oversimplifications of right and wrong. Yet even as a pedagogical exercise, debates in class can exacerbate the notion that there are only two positions on an issue and one can emerge victorious over another. This becomes part of our socialization when it becomes a commonly used learning technique.</p><p>While “the great debate” is an oft-used catchy rhyme, approaching issues as a dialogue can instead welcome conversation among many perspectives. People can be invited to speak directly from their own experience instead of having to take up a side. Making room for context and culture can provide insight on how individuals arrive at the conclusions that they do. This is not for the sake of convincing others but simply to expand our awareness of what realities can coexist. For individuals in the unitive stage of EDT, “inner conflicts and conflicting external demands simply are part of being and need not be resolved or denied, only witnessed” (Cook-Greuter, 2013, p. 88). There is so much more behind the positions that people hold, and using dialogue instead of debate can be an avenue to make room for this knowledge.</p><p><strong>Strategy 2: Employ Collective Language</strong></p><p>It is a common practice in my professional world of higher education and student affairs, as well as many other contexts, to use “I” statements in order to speak from one’s perspective. This is indeed a valuable practice in order not to speak in generalizations on behalf of others. Alongside this, the strategy of employing collective language asserts that in certain situations, using plural subject pronouns can help create an environment that reinforces how we are interconnected. “Though adults in the unitive stage are aware of themselves as separate and unique embodiments, they also identify with all other living beings” (Cook-Greuter, 2013, p. 16). The most salient application of this is considering how we can approach the issue of global warming. Instead of considering how others external to us are responsible for addressing this problem, such as the government or corporations, we can reframe it as caring for “our” planet to solve “our” problem. In thinking about the many contexts in which we are immediately aware of being in a collective, whether that is your family, your workplace, or your classroom, using language that calls upon the group as a whole can create a more collaborative culture.</p><p><strong>Strategy 3: Speak to the Part, Not the Whole</strong></p><p>In the last couple of decades, we have witnessed the rise of a phenomenon called “cancel culture.” While this concept certainly prompts discord among many (that desperately needs the first strategy discussed above to address!), it also serves as an example of throwing the baby out with the bathwater. While I by no means want to absolve any accountability regarding the harm that was caused by the actions of individuals, what is important to note about cancel culture is how a single misstep can lead to the denigration of the entire person. In doing so, the opportunity for understanding and repair is compromised. When a behavior causes harm, it is imperative to address the behavior, not the entirety of the person who enacted it. It is the difference between “what you said was awful” and “you’re an awful person for saying that.” From our inspiration in the unitive stage, individuals “care about the fundamental dilemma of the human condition. They work for justice, fairness, and benevolence towards all” (Cook-Greuter, 2013, p. 89). By centering this perspective, we can address each other’s actions in ways that can create understanding to bring us closer instead of drawing conclusions about an entire personhood to sow division that drives us farther apart.</p><p><strong>In Closing</strong></p><p>The ego is meant to keep us safe, and it does so by reinforcing the things we believe to be true. As we navigate our developmental journeys, it may be that you are seeing more contradictions in your positions that may be difficult to make sense of. Instead of calling upon selective inattention, I invite you to use that discomfort as a springboard toward opening your awareness to the coexistence of multiple perspectives. It is possible to see the world as “both/and” instead of “either/or.” One of the small but impactful ways of doing so is changing the way we talk to and talk about one another. There are many issues in our world that are in dire need of our attention and of collective solutions. By shifting our language, we might have a greater chance of addressing these issues, one conversation at a time.</p><p><strong>References</strong></p><p>Cook-Greuter, S. (1985). Ego development: Nine levels of increasing embrace. (Revised Dec. 2013). 1–97.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=17cd2d5af5f0" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[To Save the World, Stay Right Where You Are]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@raaachelle/to-save-the-world-stay-right-where-you-are-a6203c3a6833?source=rss-9b509b93f729------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a6203c3a6833</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[spiral-dynamics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Rachelle Martinez]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 14 Apr 2023 03:46:04 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-04-14T16:59:31.249Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Globalization has fundamentally changed the scope of our lives. We can interact with people on the other side of the world without leaving our physical location. We can access books, videos, photos, music, and all other forms of knowledge and media from anywhere. The entire expanse of the world wide web fits in the palms, pockets, and purses of many throughout our world. This rapid development of access to information is relatively recent in the history of humankind yet it has become a firmly established status quo. It seems to be the only way to participate in modern society. One humbling example of this is watching a TikTok of children interacting with a landline telephone. What was once the most advanced form of communication technology has become an ancient relic whose mechanism of contact is mysterious to our youth today.</p><p>What is clear about this introduction is that the offered perspective is decidedly Western with marked assumptions around class, education, and wealth. When leadership over technology and media are in the hands of the elite few, our access to information and our understanding of it is skewed. While globalization has provided many improvements to our modern world, it has not been without cost. Furthermore, these improvements are not universally experienced by all. Our current world finds itself with a host of long standing crises still desperate to be addressed. The saturation of headlines about climate change and threats to basic human rights is overwhelming. As Erikson (1950) suggests in his stages of development, when an individual does not work through a crisis in a healthy way, that issue will continue to arise throughout their lifetime. As we consider our collective lifetime as a species, these global crises have been present in our lives for some time, are desperate for our attention, and can no longer be ignored for the sake of our health as a society.</p><p>This essay is meant for those who are unsure of how to navigate our world as it is while trying to reconcile thoughts on how it should be. It is not a meta analysis of every possible angle to consider the issues put forth. It also does not serve as an arbiter of what should and should not be. It is simply an offering of consideration to guide our reflections on our place in this world at this moment in time.</p><p>A recent observation sparked the impetus for this essay topic. JetBlue was preparing to acquire Spirit Airlines, and the online buzz around this was the growing concern that this would cause a decline in the quality of air travel. With fewer competing airlines, costs were expected to increase significantly while travelers continue to deal with fewer complimentary amenities, understaffed flight crews, and flight cancellations and delays. While the status of the merger currently remains up in the air at the time of writing, the situation sparked a larger thought: why do we feel the need to travel the world?</p><p><strong>Spiral Dynamics Has Entered The Chat</strong></p><p>There are a number of perspectives from which to answer such a large and admittedly leading question. In considering a lens through which to take up our exploration, spiral dynamics can provide a developmental understanding of how we got here. It is a model that outlines the development of individuals as well as our society as a whole. Spiral dynamics organizes the model into eight memes, each one named after a color and marked by their respective characteristics of thought patterns, priorities, and perspectives. Memes are units of culture (not to be confused with its other definition of funny images recycled throughout the internet). For example, the first meme is beige, and this is characterized by the basic focus of subsistence. As an individual and collective model, the beige tier can be seen in the helplessness of an infant born yesterday as well as that of early hunter gatherers foraging for food thousands of years ago. Like any theory, it has its limitations, the scope of which will not be discussed in this essay for the sake of length. But overall, there is value in the perspectives it offers. To learn more, I recommend this <a href="https://www.corechange.nl/wp-content/uploads/spiraldynamics.pdf">interview with Don Beck</a>, one of the scholars behind spiral dynamics.</p><p>A key feature of this model is that there is no hierarchy between the memes. Though each meme increases in complexity, there is no value judgment for a meme being better or worse than another. Each is useful to us in their own way. As people navigate their own development, each prior meme remains a part of them and can be called upon based on changing life conditions. From a collective standpoint, the emergence of each meme can be marked throughout history, and at any given time, there is a wide distribution of the memes among people globally. For the remainder of this essay, the orange meme will take center stage. In exploring the idea that we prioritize advancement as a society, which is characteristic of the orange meme, we can gain a better understanding of the siren sound that air travel sings and renegotiate our relationship with progress.</p><p><strong>Orange You Glad For Spiral Dynamics?</strong></p><p>An obvious perspective on why we feel the need to travel the world is simply because we have the technology, the machinery, and the infrastructure to do so. In short: “why not?” The credit for this line of thinking goes to the orange meme, which emerged in society during the Enlightenment with its marked emphasis on “advancement, improvement, and progress” (Roemischer, 2002, p. 14). In today’s world, the orange meme makes its appearance in situations as large as space exploration, as local as neighborhood gentrification, and as common as the expected annual debut of the newest iPhone model. After all, according to the orange meme, “societies prosper through strategy, technology, and competitiveness” (Roemischer, 2002, pg. 7). From this perspective, it is unsurprising that JetBlue seeks growth in its acquisition of Spirit Airlines. Further, it is unsurprising that it is considered a wholly positive endeavor by some. Moving from societal to individual development, it is reasonable for a person to consider air travel their right as a participant of a society that is meant to continuously improve. Is there no greater improvement than for humans, as a bipedal species without wings, to take flight?</p><p>One important thing to note about the memes is that they can differentiate in how they are expressed. The spirit of the orange meme is simply making things better, and orange memes are within many of us. While it can explain the desire to fly to various parts of the world, it can also explain the writing of this essay and the hope of it prompting reflection to improve society regarding our relationship with air travel. That being said, is it an advancement of technology to fly at the expense of the health of our planet? This is less about measuring carbon emissions to confirm a yes or no answer using the scientific method and more of a conceptual question that examines the discourse to balance the benefits with the costs. There are greater implications to air travel than when a family decides to go on an annual vacation or when an immigrant like myself answers the call to return to the motherland. There are consumer goods that are regularly shipped by air. There are celebrities flying on private jets who sell movies, music, or products that are purchased by our dollars.</p><p><strong>Well, Now What?</strong></p><p>Globalization makes it feel as though flying is a firmly established right available to those who can afford it, but only if we continue to make it so. What would it look like to reframe popular notions of progress? What if advancement meant improving our stewardship over the local communities we are a part of? I pose these questions not with an expectation for the reader to generate the correct answer (as I don’t believe one exists) but to reflect on in order to be a more intentional traveler. It is heartening to see that <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2023/02/06/travel/travel-climate-no-fly-pledge.html">there are folks already moving in this direction</a>. In an overwhelmingly limitless world, your local community can be a site for real and visible change. This is not about reverting back to simpler times but moving forward with a renewed sense of what counts as progress. As we consider the state of our world, it will call for collective trust in stewardship over our planet wherever we may find ourselves.</p><p>I just flew back from a national conference in Boston where I presented my work on supporting incoming graduate students. This is not a confession of my own hypocrisy but instead an invitation to the complicated nuance of these issues. I am a participant in our world, and while I refuse to indulge in the false dichotomy of whether we should think of air travel as being good or bad, I know I am reflecting so much more about my movement on our planet. I hope you will do the same.</p><p>Erikson, E. H. (1950). Childhood and society. New York: Norton.</p><p>Roemischer, J. (2002). The never-ending upward quest. What is Enlightenment?, (22), 4–24.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a6203c3a6833" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>