<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Justus Baird on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Justus Baird on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@rabbijustus?source=rss-d5a78496c308------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sun, 22 Nov 2026 04:35:05 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@rabbijustus/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Judaism Begins at Home]]></title>
            <link>https://rabbijustus.medium.com/judaism-begins-at-home-693c094180aa?source=rss-d5a78496c308------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/693c094180aa</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[russia]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[judaism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[home]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Justus Baird]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 04 Oct 2026 19:46:20 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-10-04T19:47:27.208Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/908/1*rGWCeLdChtqHl3NsXNN42A.png" /></figure><p>Sometime in my twenties — probably when I was in rabbinical school — I came across the phrase “be a man in the street, and a Jew at home.” Not long after, when I began wearing a kippah in public, the phrase came to mind. I had interpreted the words to mean: you can be fully Jewish at home, but be careful about projecting your Jewishness when you go out in public. For most of my life, though, I practiced the opposite; I wore a kippah in public as an act of Jewish identity, and at home I often took my kippah off because there was no one I needed to show it off to, and because, well, to be perfectly honest, there was no easy way to attach even the best-shaped kippah to my shiny, tonsured head.</p><p>As it turns out, the phrase ‘be a man in the street and a Jew at home’ has a long and important reception history, which includes frequent misinterpretations of the phrase’s original meaning by <em>schlemiels</em> like me.</p><p>The dictum’s actual history and original meaning are worth recovering. ‘Be a man in the street and a Jew at home’ was penned in 1863, in Russia, by the Jewish poet Yehuda Leib Gordon.[i] The phrase, which was part of a much longer poem, was five words in Hebrew: הֱיֵה אָדָם בְּצֵאתְךָ וִיהוּדִי בְּאָהֳלֶךָ<strong>, </strong>which I would translate as “Be a person (man, Hebrew <em>adam</em>) when you go out, and a Jew when you are in your tent (<em>ohalekha</em>), a biblical metaphor for home.[ii]</p><p>It is no stretch to claim that Gordon’s dictum, if you’ll permit an anachronism, went viral. Millions of Russian Jews knew ‘be a man in the street, a Jew at home.’ But, as so often happens when ideas go viral, his words were misinterpreted. Most thought (as I later would) that Gordon meant that Jews should bifurcate their Jewish identity. Jewish life should focus on home, synagogue, the private sphere, and in public, we should suppress our Jewishness.</p><p>But this is definitely not what Gordon’s poem was about, and certainly not what Gordon’s life and oeuvre were about. The poem, entitled “Awake, My People,” was a rallying cry for Russian Jews to “partake of the shared culture of civilized Europeans” while “remaining vibrantly attached” to Jewish tradition.[iii] ‘Be a man in the street and a Jew at home’ was not a call for Jews to bifurcate Jewish identity, it was a cry to integrate Jewish particularity with the outside world.</p><p>Understanding Gordon’s intense passion about this integration becomes much easier if you take a moment to imagine Russian Jewish life in the 1860s. Russian Jews at that time were unwilling to explore, let alone participate in, European culture. They spoke no Russian, only Yiddish and Hebrew, and could therefore not converse with their non-Jewish neighbors. Gordon challenged his Jewish comrades to wake up to the wider world, but, as they did so, to hold tight to Jewish wisdom and practice. His call for integration was notable because all the Jewish voices around him were advocating something different: on one side, Jewish traditionalists forbid engagement with Russian society and European enlightenment; on the other side, leaders of the <em>haskalah</em> called on Jews to abandon Jewish tradition, which they perceived as backwards and unredeemable.</p><p>How dramatically the tables have turned in the 160 years since Gordon wrote his poem! In contemporary America, Jews have joined the ranks of the elite in countless fields: doctors and nurses, lawyers and judges, scholars and scientists, educators and engineers, financiers and business leaders.</p><p>But as Jews achieved this arguably unparalleled success (compared to any other diaspora period or setting) of being a man in the street — joining the larger society — we Jews seemed to have lost some elements of our commitment to the other half of Gordon’s dictum — <em>v’yehudi b’ohalekha</em> — be a Jew at home.</p><p>Let me pinpoint the concern. The concern is not assimilation, that American Jews have abandoned our Jewish identities in order to become part of the larger society, though stories of people who have done exactly that abound. The concern is that Jews are losing our commitment to enacting Judaism in our <em>actual homes</em>. And losing that commitment will end tragically.</p><p>One of the most enduring issues for the American Jewish community, other than antisemitism, is our anxiety about continuity. We are constantly counting Jews, asking, what will ensure our kids and grandkids will be Jewish? We all want to know: what is the thing that will turn today’s Jewish kids into tomorrow’s proud Jewish adults?</p><p>Is it day school? Jewish summer camp? Jewish pre-K? Maybe the secret is reading Jewish books at bedtime? Or giving our kids a great bar or bat mitzvah. Maybe the answer is youth groups? Or Jewish studies courses in college. Perhaps a trip to Israel is the silver bullet?</p><p>One might assume, correctly it turns out, that someone would have done a study to answer this question already. In 2025, the British Jewish community published a study[iv] examining the question of what exactly will most likely turn Jewish kids into adults with strong Jewish identities. The study used data from a recent population survey of British Jews, which asked many questions that American Jewish surveys don’t ask. (If you had been one of the 5,000 participants, you would have had to answer over a hundred questions about every aspect of your Jewish life. Do you believe the Torah is the word of God, or more of an ancient book of moral precepts written by humans? What aspects of Jewish identity are most important to you: combating antisemitism? Remembering the Holocaust? Supporting social justice causes? Supporting Israel? What do you do in your home on Shabbat? How often you go to shul? Of course they also asked about the laundry list of key Jewish experiences mentioned above.)</p><p>So what did the data show? Before answering, I should note that as a rabbi, I normally don’t put too much stock into sociological studies. The tool of my trade is Jewish tradition: faith, ethics, practice. But in this case, the sociological data really supports the claim I want to make. And maybe, my thinking went, some readers will be more convinced by demographic data than by the Jewish texts I’m going to mention below.</p><p>Here’s what the data showed. The most important predictor of Jewish identity later in life is Jewish <strong>upbringing</strong>. In other words, what happens at home. Lighting candles. Keeping some form of kashrut. Friday night dinners. Observing Shabbat. Hosting guests. Doing Jewish holidays at home, like a Passover Seder, building a sukkah, and lighting Hanukah candles. The impact of these experiences at home, of <em>upbringing</em>, have much stronger correlation with future Jewish identity than attending a Jewish summer camp, a Jewish day school, coming to shul regularly, or having a bar or bat mitzvah.</p><p>I would summarize the study’s findings this way: the biggest shaper of Jewish identity is not shul, not school, not camp, but our homelife.</p><p>Here in the US, about 40% of American Jews do anything for Shabbat, even sometimes. The same number — 40% — read Jewish books, watch Jewish-themed TV, or listen to Jewish music. Only about 20% keep kosher at home in any way. Based on these figures,[v] the big picture doesn’t look good: less than half of American Jews are doing any basic Jewish practice at home. There is one bright spot in the data, though, something that three-fourths of American Jews do in a home: participate in a Passover seder. If the same percentage of Jews who join a seder were doing other home-base Jewish practices, the Jewish future would be completely transformed.</p><p>For those like me who make up the roughly 25% of American Jews who come to shul at least once a month, synagogue is where we enact Jewish community. But the commitment to enact our Jewishness in larger community cannot replace how we build a Jewish home. Synagogue should be the secondary, not the primary, address for our Jewish lives. What message will our kids and grandkids take if they see parents or grandparents shlep to shul a dozen times a year but rarely enact Jewishness at home?</p><p>That’s the sociological data suggesting that the Jewish home is the critical site for instilling Jewish identity. But that idea is also rooted in core Jewish teachings. I’ll mention two, starting with the Shema.</p><p>וְשִׁנַּנְתָּ֣ם לְבָנֶ֔יךָ ‘impress them upon your children’: the Shema teaches us to impress the basic ideas of Judaism on our children. How?</p><p>וְדִבַּרְתָּ֖ בָּ֑ם בְּשִׁבְתְּךָ֤ בְּבֵיתֶ֙ךָ֙ — וּבְלֶכְתְּךָ֣ בַדֶּ֔רֶךְ — וּֽבְשׇׁכְבְּךָ֖ וּבְקוּמֶֽךָ Speak of these ideas when you are coming home, and when you are going away, when you lie down and when you rise up.</p><p>Take note: the Shema does not say, ‘send children on an expensive Jewish journey’ or ‘find them a fancy teacher.’ It says: talk about Jewish ideas with kids. The watchword of our tradition, the Shema, reminds us that the foundation stone of Jewish identity are the words spoken by the people raising a child: parents, grandparents, aunts and uncles, and family friends.</p><p>Beyond the Shema, a remarkable teaching emphasizes the centrality of the home in our tradition. When the Temple in Jerusalem was destroyed a second time, in the first century CE, the rabbis struggled mightily with what to do. The Temple was THE place where Jews gathered, THE place where God listened to our requests and concerns, THE place where we found atonement for our sins. If the Temple doesn’t exist, where would all of these things happen?</p><p>Three rabbis, Rabbi Yochanan, Rabbi Elazar and Resh Lakish, drew upon a verse in Ezekiel that begins with the word <em>mizbeach</em> — altar — and then refers to it as a <em>shulchan — </em>table.[vi] Interpreting this verse, they taught:</p><p>בִּזְמַן שֶׁבֵּית הַמִּקְדָּשׁ קַיָּים — מִזְבֵּחַ מְכַפֵּר עַל אָדָם<br>in a time when the Temple exists, the Altar atones for our transgressions.<br>וְעַכְשָׁיו שֶׁאֵין בֵּית הַמִּקְדָּשׁ קַיָּים — שׁוּלְחָנוֹ שֶׁל אָדָם מְכַפֵּר עָלָיו<br>But now, when the Temple is not standing, a person’s table effects atonement.</p><p>These three rabbis taught that our homes — specifically our kitchen tables — have replaced some of the core functions of the Holy Temple. Ever wondered where the idea that your home is a Temple comes from? This is a key source. To be clear: the ancient rabbis were not suggesting that we all acquire a goat, slaughter it, and then sprinkle its blood and burn the entrails on our dining room tables — though if you were to do so it would certainly be memorable. The idea is that our dining tables are a spiritually powerful object like the altar in the Temple. This is why, according the Shulkhan Arukh (O.C. 167), we salt the challah at the Shabbat table: the Temple offerings were made with salt, so we sprinkle our bread with salt. Rabbeynu Bahya ben Asher wrote an entire treatise about the dining table and eating practices as a replacement for the Temple called <em>Shulkhan shel Arba</em>, the Table of Four. Among the many teachings it contains,[vii] he argued that the blessings we say at our dining tables correspond to the spices and incense that were used in the Temple: instead of cinnamon and cassia, frankincense and myrrh, we now have washing of the hands, blessings over bread and wine, the blessings of <em>birkat hamazon</em>.</p><p>Picture, for a moment, your favorite table to share a meal at. A table in a kitchen, or a dining room, perhaps. Maybe a table you grew up with, maybe a table in your home now. Picture that table in your mind’s eye. Now imagine it as a holy object, a holy site. A warm place where blessings, like fragrances, permeate the home; a spiritual place where transformative things can happen; a communal place where you connect with others and with the divine.</p><p>Seeing our home as a temple, our table as an altar, has implications for what we do and how we behave. There are many ways to put this idea into practice. But there are also many barriers to doing so, and it is worth acknowledging them. Many Jews feel that they don’t know enough to engage in certain practices or to lead them for their family. Too many of us are over-worked and have little energy or time for yet another demand. Many live in nuclear families and are not surrounded by multiple generations of family and friends who can offer support. Some live alone. These are challenging, legitimate barriers. And yet, the work of transmitting Jewish tradition <em>l’dor va-dor,</em> from generation to generation, through our Jewish homes is decidedly within reach.</p><p>Here are seven straightforward ways to get started:</p><p>1. Make Shabbat. Light candles Friday nights. Sit for Shabbat dinner, with blessings for kiddush and motzi and birkat hamazon;</p><p>2. Practice kashrut, at any level: buy kosher meat, separate milk and meat, keep <em>treyf</em> out of the house. Maybe even don’t eat <em>treyf</em>;</p><p>3. Acquire Jewish books, books appropriate for whatever ages of people live in your house;</p><p>4. Study Jewish stuff, especially with a friend, in a book club or a hevruta, or if you prefer, stream Jewish content;</p><p>5. Invite guests into your home: practice hospitality, from simple drinks to an elaborate meal;</p><p>6. Make the holidays: a seder on Pesach, a sukkah on Sukkot, mishloach manot on Purim, candles on Hanukah, there are so many holiday traditions to choose from; and</p><p>7. Engage in <em>chesed</em> and <em>tzedaka</em>, acts of loving kindness: visit the sick, join a shiva minyan, bring food or clothes to those in need.</p><p>If reading this list makes you feel smug — “rabbi, I do all of those things already!” — then please: forward this essay to Shlomo and Rivka and brag about it. Or, maybe, choose one of the items from the list that you want to make extra nice this year, <em>hiddur</em>-mitzvah style, and take it to the next level.</p><p>But, if there are any items on that list that don’t happen in your Jewish home yet, put them on your “home improvement” to-do list. You won’t find the items you need at Home Depot or Lowes — except for your sukkah of course — but you will be able to find all the support you need from a friend or your neighborhood rabbi. I can promise you that some of the sweetest words a rabbi will ever hear are, “Rabbi, I’ve been thinking about starting a Jewish practice in my home and I wonder if you could help me out.”</p><p>In an attempt to further prove the point that the Jewish home, the daily life we live in our homes, is the foundation of Jewishness, I combed through the list of all 613 mitzvot. Except for the mitzvot that require the Temple for sacrifice, and a few related to farming in the land of Israel, there is not one mitzvah on the list of 613 commandments that cannot be fulfilled at home or in daily life.</p><p>On this the sociologists and the rabbis agree: what Jews do Jewishly at home is the most important way to live out Jewish tradition. It is also the key to ensuring our Jewish future. Our homes are a temple; our tables the altar. Judaism begins at home.</p><p>[i] Michael Stanislawki, <em>For Whom Do I Toil?</em> (Oxford 1988) is an unparalleled biography of Yehuda Leib Gordon. He directly addresses the historical context and reception history of the phrase in question on pp49–52.</p><p>[ii] The phrase is an allusion to Deuteronomy 33:18: וְלִזְבוּלֻ֣ן אָמַ֔ר שְׂמַ֥ח זְבוּלֻ֖ן בְּצֵאתֶ֑ךָ וְיִשָּׂשכָ֖ר בְּאֹהָלֶֽיךָ׃ And of Zebulun he said: Rejoice, O Zebulun, on your journeys, and Issachar, in your tents.</p><p>[iii] Stanislawski, 51.</p><p>[iv] Institute for Jewish Policy Research, “<a href="https://www.jpr.org.uk/reports/what-works-jewish-programmes-jewish-identity">What Works? The impact of Jewish programmes and experiences on Jewish identity outcomes in the UK</a>” (2025).</p><p>[v] See Pew Research Center, “<a href="https://www.pewresearch.org/religion/2021/05/11/jewish-americans-in-2020/">Jewish Americans in 2020</a>”</p><p>[vi] Ezekiel 41:22. The text appears both at BT Menachot 97a and BT Berakhot 55a.</p><p>[vii] Rabbeinu Bahya ben Asher, <em>Shulkhan shel Arba</em>, Sha’ar 1. Jonathan Brumberg-Kraus has made a <a href="https://jkraus.webspace.wheatoncollege.edu/shulhan-shel-arba-table-of-contents/translation-of-shulhan-shel-arba-the-four-legged-table/">translation</a> available.</p><p><em>A version of this essay was delivered as a Yom Kippur sermon, September 2026 (Tishrei 5787) at Congregation Shomrei Emunah in Montclair, NJ.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=693c094180aa" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Loving Critic]]></title>
            <link>https://rabbijustus.medium.com/the-loving-critic-f48b0a2527e8?source=rss-d5a78496c308------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f48b0a2527e8</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[social-critique]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[judaism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cultural-critique]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[social-criticism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Justus Baird]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 16 Oct 2025 20:59:22 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-10-16T20:59:22.168Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>[Originally delivered as a Yom Kippur sermon, September 2025, at Shomrei Emunah Synagogue in Montclair, NJ]</em></p><p>In November 1905, 120 years ago, Rabbi Stephen Wise received an invitation he had been anticipating for many years: the chance to become senior rabbi of Temple Emanu-El in New York, arguably the premier synagogue in America at the time.[1] Rabbi Wise, who was 31 at the time, had already developed a well-known reputation as a great orator, an outspoken voice for justice, and an ardent Zionist, even though that view was then very unpopular in the Reform movement that he belonged to.</p><p>Rabbi Wise travelled to NYC all the way from Oregon to meet with the Emanu-El trustees and discuss their invitation. When he sat down for the interview, Rabbi Wise made seven requests:</p><p>(1) His election must be unanimous by the trustees and the congregation, for a term of three to five years; and if things went well, he would stay indefinitely</p><p>(2) He would preach three times a month, addressing his messages both to Jews and to non-Jews;</p><p>(3) He would invite guest preachers — not limited to other rabbis;</p><p>(4) He would participate in prayer services, not leaving that ritual task only to a reader;</p><p>(5) He would require a secretary</p><p>(6) At some point in the future, he would launch a downtown satellite of the synagogue to serve the needs of the immigrant Jewish masses there;</p><p>Although a few trustees raised their eyebrows at some of these requests, they all agreed. Then came Rabbi Wise’ seventh request:</p><p>(7) “the pulpit must be free while I preach therein”</p><p>Immediately Louis Marshall objected. (Louis Marshall was a prominent lawyer who would later become a director of the NAACP and part of the legal team that represented Leo Frank.) Marshall said: “Dr. Wise, I must say to you at once that such a condition cannot be complied with; the pulpit of Emanu-El has always been and is subject to and under the control of the board of trustees.”</p><p>“If that be true, gentlemen,” Rabbi Wise shot back, “there is nothing more to say.”</p><p>The trustees conferred, and then pushed Rabbi Wise to explain what he meant by a “free pulpit.” Here is what Stephen Wise told them:</p><p>“Mr. Moses, if it be true, as I have heard it rumored, that your nephew, Mr. Herman, is to be a Tammany Hall candidate for a Supreme Court judgeship, I would, if I were Emanu-El’s rabbi, oppose his candidacy in and out of my pulpit. Mr. Guggenheim, as a member of the Child Labor Commission of the State of Oregon, I must say to you that if it ever came to be known that children were being employed in your mines, I would cry out against such wrong. Mr. Marshall, the press stated that you and your firm are to be counsel for Mr. Hyde of the Equitable Life Assurance Society. That may or may not be true, but knowing that Charles Evans Hughes’s investigation of insurance companies in New York has been a very great service, I would in and out of my pulpit speak in condemnation of the crimes committed by the insurance thieves.”</p><p>To Rabbi Stephen Wise, a “free pulpit” meant that the rabbi was free to call out moral concerns wherever he saw them, <em>especially</em> when they emerged from his own community.</p><p>Stephen Wise turned down the invitation to become senior rabbi of Emanu-El. He was so committed to the idea of a free pulpit that, a couple years later, he founded what he called the Free Synagogue in NYC, now called Stephen Wise Free Synagogue.</p><p>The story of his interview is a useful introduction to the idea of critiquing in public, more specifically, the role of a social critic.</p><p>During the high holy days, and especially YK, we often reflect on our <em>personal</em> wrongdoings. What do I want to improve on next year? Who do I need to apologize to? Which of my relationships need extra attention?</p><p>But the focus of Yom Kippur is at least as much on our <em>collective</em> behavior, as it is about our individual behavior. Consider the <em>ashamnu</em>, a collective confession. We don’t say, <em>ashamti, bagadti</em>, I am culpable, I have been unfaithful. We say <em>ashamNU</em>, <em>bagadNU</em>, <em>we</em> are culpable, <em>we</em> have been unfaithful. Or consider the Avodah service later this afternoon, which begins with the high priest acknowledging his personal failures, then the failures of his household, and climaxes with the High Priest asking forgiveness of the collective, the people Israel.</p><p>The high holy days are prime time for reflecting on our collective behavior, and how we can improve as a society. But how, exactly, do we improve as a society?</p><p>Surely one key ingredient in any process of improving our society is social criticism. We need people who reflect on how we’re doing at the societal level, who point out when we are collectively falling short. The voice of the social critic can take many forms: clergy, artists, musicians, writers, social activists.</p><p>But if we’re honest with ourselves, I think almost all of us imagine ourselves as a social critic. We look around, at our town and our state, the Jewish community, our country, at other countries, especially Israel, and we judge. We critique. We ask incredulously, did you see the news? Can you believe what is going on? Most of us don’t broadcast our critique beyond our coffee chats, kiddush conversations, or social media feeds. But I would argue that even those semi-private conversations matter — they are the places we test out our thinking, the places we begin to form collective opinions.</p><p>Let me try to persuade you that the stakes of social critique are very high.</p><p>In the Talmud, Tractate Shabbat,[2] Rav Amram taught: Jerusalem was destroyed only because the people did not criticize one another. In his explanation, commenting on a verse from Lamentations,[3] he suggested that the Jews of that generation were like deer whose heads faced each others’ tails, a generation did not criticize one another.</p><p>One could be forgiven for thinking that Rav Amram is crazy. Could there ever been a generation of Jews who did not criticize each other? But let’s focus on his core message: Jewish society fails when Jews do not take responsibility for critiquing each other.</p><p>In another rabbinic passage,[4] the rabbis struggle with the practice of rebuke, <em>tochecha</em>. What happens, they say, if someone rebukes someone else four, maybe five times and that person doesn’t change? Faced with the reality that people don’t always respond to rebuke, Rabbi Tarfon said, “In this generation there is no one capable of rebuking.” Rabbi Elazar ben Azariah said: “In this generation there is no one capable of <em>receiving</em> rebuke.” Rabbi Akiva said: “In this generation there is no one who knows how rebuke ought to be worded.”</p><p>I hear in these words a frustrated lament: we know we’re supposed to rebuke and critique, but our rebukes aren’t working! We don’t seem to know how to critique effectively!</p><p>In our generation, we also have a problem with critique. The phrase “everyone’s a critic” provides a good summary. Consider movie critics: readers who grew up in the 1980s and 1990s probably remember Siskel and Ebert, who famously used their thumbs to sum up their opinion about a film. But today, all we have is Rotten Tomatoes and IMDB. Each review we post of a movie or restaurant or product or news headline: we have indeed, all become critics.</p><p>Nevertheless, with all this critique, society does not seem to be responding. The rabbi’s claim that “there is no one who understands how rebuke and critique ought to be worded” rings true for our generation too.</p><p>As a possible way out of this sad state of affairs, I want to offer a model of a more productive approach. The model comes from Jewish political philosopher Michael Walzer.</p><p>Over the course of many publications and decades, Walzer developed and committed himself to a version of the social critic he called the <strong>connected critic</strong>.</p><p>The basic idea of the connected critic is quite simple. It starts with the insight that an enemy cannot be a social critic, because an enemy lacks standing. Of course our enemies will critique us, but we will never listen to them. But some argued that an ideal social critic should be neutral, or have some distance, from the society he or she was critiquing.</p><p>Walzer pushed back on that belief. He taught that the first key element of a successful social critic is that they have standing, membership he calls it, in the collective. The social critic must be part of the group they critique.</p><p>Secondly, Walzer taught, the social critic should appeal to shared values. When a society’s behavior is not living up to its own values, then the social critic can point out the gap. The form of such a critique would be: “You say you believe in this principle, but you are not following your own values!”</p><p>Walzer explored the work of many contemporary social critics, but his favorite exemplars were the Hebrew prophets. On Yom Kippur, we read two great examples of social critique from the prophets in the day’s Haftarot passages: one who fits the connected critic model, Isaiah, and one who does not: Jonah.</p><p>Let’s start with Isaiah. Isaiah’s famous lines, is <em>this the fast, starving your bodies</em>…<em>no, this is the fast I desire: to unlock the fetters of wickedness…</em>these verses are surrounded by detailed descriptions of the principles and values that the Israelites know they should be upholding. Isaiah says to his people: “they are eager to learn God’s ways…eager for the nearness of God…if you banish…evil speech…and offer your compassion to the hungry — then your light will shine in the darkness.” Isaiah can say all these things — that the Israelites want to be near to God and to be compassionate to the hungry because Isaiah is part of Israelite society and knows the moral teachings of the group he is critiquing. Isaiah’s critique resonates because it appeals to the best selves of the Israelites, because he is one of them.</p><p>Compare this to the afternoon Haftarah, the book of Jonah. God sends Jonah to Nineveh, a completely different mission than Isaiah’s words to the House of Jacob. Ninevites are Assyrians, not Israelites. Jonah is an Israelite prophet, and he has absolutely no standing in Nineveh. Perhaps this is why Jonah resists the mission so absolutely — why in the world would the Assyrian people of Nineveh listen to a Hebrew prophet? Jonah’s prophecy, unlike Isaiah’s, has no content. The only thing Jonah says to the people of Nineveh is “40 days and Nineveh will be overturned.” Because Jonah, Walzer argues, is not a member of Nineveh’s society, he has no idea what shared values Ninevans espouse. He can’t appeal to their higher moral values. All he can do is be a mouthpiece for God.</p><p>The lesson of these prophets is that effective social critics focus on the fate of their own community. Social critique is ultimately an act of solidarity, an act of loyalty, an act of love for the collectives we are members of.</p><p>So what would it look like to embrace the model of the connected critic in our own lives? I think it boils down to this: if you don’t consider yourself a committed member of the group you are concerned about, lower your volume — maybe even turn it off. Armchair social criticism of groups we are not connected to may be entertaining, but it is little more than noise.</p><p>But we are all members of collectives: our local community, our Jewish community, American society, political movements, nonprofits, school communities…For these groups, how can we be effective social critics? The basic approach is this: appeal to the group’s own values, and point out behavior that isn’t living up to those values. And then, offer to help.</p><p>It is no revelation to point out that people who chose to take on communal leadership don’t like to be criticized. But when someone comes along and reminds a leader of the group’s shared values, and points out a discrepancy, it makes it much easier for that leader to hear the critique.</p><p>I have come to see social critique as a form of collective self-correction, maybe even a form of social healing. Like a living body that sends signals when something isn’t going right — thirst, exhaustion, a fever — the social critic sends signals to the collective when all is not well.</p><p>Rabbi Yosi ben Chanina taught:[5] “A love without reproof is no love.” Social critique is ultimately an act of solidarity, loyalty and love.</p><p>James Baldwin put it this way:[6] I love America more than any other country in the world. And exactly for this reason, I insist on the right to criticize her perpetually.</p><p>But Rabbi David Hartman had, perhaps, the best line. He used to say: critique me like my mother, not like my mother-in-law.</p><p>When Rabbi Stephen Wise met with the trustees of Emanu-El to interview for the senior rabbi position, he modeled what it means to be a connected critic. Instead of spouting a list of complicated social issues he could not control, he presented instead a list of concerning behaviors by people he was connected to, and, I’d like to think, people he loved.</p><p>The next time you find yourself fed up with some<em>one</em> or some issue, see if you can employ the model of the connected critic for good use.</p><p>[1] The details of this story can be found in Melvin Urofsky’s biography of Stephen Wise, <em>A Voice that Spoke for Justice: the Life and Times of Stephen S. Wise</em>, pp 52–54.</p><p>[2] BT Shabbat 119b</p><p>[3] Lamentations 1:6</p><p>[4] Sifra 89a-89b</p><p>[5] Bereshit Rabbah 54:3</p><p>[6] 1955, <em>Notes of a Native Son</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f48b0a2527e8" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Rabbinic Installation]]></title>
            <link>https://rabbijustus.medium.com/rabbinic-installation-3c75e98da15a?source=rss-d5a78496c308------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/3c75e98da15a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[synagogue]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ritual]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[installation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[rabbi]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Justus Baird]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 07 Feb 2025 01:12:30 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-02-07T01:13:48.190Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Or how to install a rabbi</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*9WJrlnHmPTtQ8F11u2wj5w.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>A brief reflection on the ritual, and a proposed liturgy</em></p><p>In 2023, my wife asked me to lead her rabbinic installation service. I was not her first choice. Her first choice, as for most rabbis I think, was one of her mentors from rabbinical school. For various reasons, each of them was unavailable. No other better option being found, she turned to me, her husband, who is also a rabbi.</p><p>I haven’t done the research to explore the origins of rabbinic installation. I can only assume that the practice emerged in America under the influence of <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Installation_(Christianity)">Christian clergy installation</a> practices.</p><p>Despite the unfortunate name, a synagogue’s wish to install their rabbi is a powerful opportunity to create a bond between clergy and community, to set the tone and direction of a rabbi’s leadership, and to create a lifecycle-like moment for the rabbi to remind everyone that serving a community as a rabbi is (much) more than a job.</p><p>When my wife asked me to install her, after pausing a beat to imagine the jokes I could tell about installing my wife, I immediately started looking around for help. Where is the installation handbook? Who has the instructions? What exactly, does one do for an installation? I watched a few recordings, read a few reflections, and asked around. I quickly learned there is little support for the would-be installing rabbi. This post is for all those who come after me who are similarly looking for help.</p><p>There were many aspects to the event; this post focuses solely on the role of the “installing rabbi.” (There were also tributes, music, remarks by the rabbi, and other things I can’t recall. Lay leaders planned the run of show, in cooperation with the rabbi.)</p><p>Here’s what I did.</p><ol><li><strong>Direct words to the rabbi</strong>: nice words that reinforce why s/he is/will become such a great rabbi.</li><li><strong>Direct words to the congregation</strong>: what the community needs to know about their rabbi, and how you expect them to treat their rabbi</li><li><strong>A very brief d’var Torah </strong>that connects the prior remarks to the liturgical act that will follow</li><li><strong>Liturgy of installation</strong>: I created a liturgy by listening to the words of others and borrowing from the wedding liturgy, which seemed to me the best analogue for the moment. I offer it here for any to use without attribution. I can’t remember if I borrowed specifically from others when I created it.</li></ol><p>INSTALLATION RITUAL</p><p><strong>The moment of Installation has come.</strong></p><p><em>Do you, Rabbi Ploni, agree to faithfully serve this community as its rabbi, to listen to its needs, and to lead in ways that will strengthen the Jewish people?</em></p><p>[Rabbi responds]</p><p><em>Do you, members of the community of [Synagogue Name], agree to abide by the leadership of Rabbi Ploni?</em></p><p>[WAIT FOR RESPONSE]</p><p><strong>We pray for God’s help in this transition:</strong></p><p><em>Eloheinu v’elohei avoteynu</em>: Our God and God of our ancestors, with mercy accept this prayer on behalf of our rabbi and our community.</p><p>As members of this congregation, help us to fulfill our responsibility:</p><p>When this community needs our help, open our hearts toward generosity, like the Israelites who built the Mishkan, to offer our time, our expertise, and our resources</p><p>When our rabbi asks something of us, help us respond to her/his invitation</p><p>And when we ourselves need to connect to the rabbi or to the community, support us to reach out, and ASK for help</p><p>We pray, O Lord, that Your spirit be awakened within Rabbi Ploni</p><p>Grant her/him the <strong>wisdom</strong> to know when to comfort the afflicted among us, and when to afflict the comfortable among us.</p><p>Grant her/him the <strong>understanding</strong> to know when to be patient-and-wait for the ripeness of a moment, and when to be impatient and lead with fiery vision.</p><p>Grant her/him the <strong>insight</strong> to know how to prioritize among the endless list of duties that s/he will be faced with</p><p>And when s/he faces <strong>doubt</strong> about how s/he is leading, God, comfort her/him, whisper to her/him, show her/him that you are with her/him.</p><p>May it be Your will that this community be a blessing for all who are part of it.</p><p>[TURN TO RABBI PLONI ASK HER/HIM TO LIFT UP TALLIT ONTO HER/HIS HEAD] [GET KIDDUSH CUP]</p><p>It is time to consecrate the relationship between this community and this rabbi. <strong>PLEASE RISE.</strong></p><p>הרי אתם מקודשים זה לזה, רב לקהילה</p><p>Behold you are consecrated to each other, as rabbi and congregation</p><p>בָּרוּךְ אַתָּה יְיָ אֱלֹהֵֽינוּ מֶֽלֶךְ הָעוֹלָם אֲשֶׁר בָּרָא <strong>שָׂשׂוֹן וְשִׂמְחָה</strong>.</p><p>גִּילָה רִנָּה דִּיצָה וְחֶדְוָה אַהֲבָה וְאַחֲוָה וְשָׁלוֹם וְרֵעוּת.</p><p>מְהֵרָה יְיָ אֱלֹהֵֽינוּ יִשָּׁמַע בְּחֻצוֹת <strong>[TOWNNAME]</strong>,</p><p>קוֹל שָׂשׂוֹן וְקוֹל שִׂמְחָה <strong>קוֹל הרב וְקוֹל קהילה</strong>.</p><p>בָּרוּךְ אַתָּה יְיָ מְשַׂמֵּֽחַ <strong>הרב עִם הַקהילה</strong></p><p>Blessed are you, Lord our God, Ruler of the Universe, who creates happiness and joy, exultation, delight, amusement, and pleasure, love and brotherhood, peace and friendship. Soon, Lord our God, may the sound of happiness and the sound of joy, and the voice of the rabbi and the voice of the congregation be heard throughout the streets of [OUR TOWN].</p><p>Blessed are you Lord who makes the Community and Rabbi rejoice together.</p><p>[Give rabbi a drink from the cup]</p><p>[PRIESTLY BLESSING: WE HAD A CANTOR LEAD IT. MAYBE INCLUDE RABBI’S KIDS/FAMILY]</p><p>[SING SHECHEYANU]</p><p>[PLEASE BE SEATED]</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=3c75e98da15a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Curating a Memory Display Case for Our Loved Ones]]></title>
            <link>https://rabbijustus.medium.com/curating-a-memory-display-case-for-our-loved-ones-35d834f1b6c4?source=rss-d5a78496c308------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/35d834f1b6c4</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[yizkor]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[memories]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[loved-ones]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[curation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[remembering]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Justus Baird]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 11 Jan 2022 13:47:23 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-10-14T12:39:23.416Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/372/1*YNZhGOJOa78qkPBpuV5FxQ.png" /><figcaption>Selecting a few items, and memories, from the complex life of a loved one is the best way to keep them from being forgotten.</figcaption></figure><p><em>This yizkor sermon was delivered at Congregation Shomrei Emunah in Montclair, NJ on Yom Kippur 5785. An earlier version was given at the Jewish Center of Princeton on Yom Kippur 5775.</em></p><p>41 years ago, in 1983, a book of photographs was published. The title of the book was <em>A Vanished World, </em>and the name of the photographer was Roman Vishniac. The book features hundreds of images of prewar Eastern European Jewish life: two young boys in black hats in <em>cheder</em>, sitting side by side and studying a page of rabbinic commentary; a sad shopkeeper with nothing to sell; a grandmother and her granddaughter, smiling slightly, standing in a small room that functions as both a kitchen and bedroom.</p><p>Roman Vishniac, born in Russia, took the photographs between 1935 and 1938 in the Pale of Settlement. His images evoke what many of us imagine when we think of Jewish life in the <em>shtetl</em>. His photographs were featured in books by Isaac Bashevis Singer and Irving Howe. They served as a guiding force for the cinematography of <em>Shindler’s List</em>. Vishiac had become, in the words of one art critic, “the official mortuary photographer of Eastern European Jewry.”[1]</p><p>Seventeen years after the book was published, in the year 2000, a graduate student in art history and museum education at Harvard was assigned to research a book of photography. Her name was Maya Benton. She remembered a coffee table book of Vishniac’s photographs from her grandmother’s house and chose it for the assignment. She dug into Vishniac’s work and became both fascinated, and troubled. Benton discovered that Vishniac had actually accumulated a much wider collection of photographs than the ones that he published — including many images that were of higher artistic quality, but that did not fit the narrative of impoverished Jewish life. She also found that Vishniac had a tendency to add captions to images that were imaginative, or more precisely, fictional. For instance, one pair of photographs put together a middle age man and a young boy. The caption reads, “The father is hiding from members of the National Democratic Party. His son signals him that they are approaching. Warsaw, 1938.” But the two images were taken from different rolls of film, and probably even different cities.</p><p>As she continued her research, Benton found a note from the sales executive who worked on Vishniac’s book, <em>A Vanished World.</em> The note described the publication as “an illustrated book of social history that would also appeal to a popular Jewish nostalgia market.” Benton talked to the editor of the book, who said that at one point he realized that Vishniac “had become a mythmaker of his past — telling stories that were better than what really happened.” Referring to Vishniac’s creative captions, the editor said that he saw it as his job to keep some of the quote “baloney away from the pictures.” Benton, the curator, put it this way: “It’s as if we took pictures of homeless people in New York and then the city fell into the sea, and 50 years from now people looked at those photos and thought, That’s what New York was.”</p><p>Eventually Benton discovered that Vishniac’s trip to the Pale of Settlement in the mid 1930’s was actually a paid assignment from the Joint Distribution Committee. He had been commissioned to document the poor and the Orthodox among Europe’s Jews so that the images could be used in fundraising work.</p><p>Vishniac’s powerful and memorable photographs turned out to be absolutely perfect for that assignment. With his camera, and his captions, Vishniac crafted a powerful story.</p><p>Perhaps most importantly, Vishniac was a master <strong>curator</strong>. He carefully selected only certain images and cropped each image in particular ways to tell a singular story of impoverished Jews.</p><p>* * *</p><p>My father died twelve years ago. His death introduced me to becoming a mourner. My father’s belongings occupied their own section of our basement, and it took me many years to sift through them. Like many before me, I started by going through the process of curating memories. I asked questions like, Which parts of his life do I want to remember? Which parts do I want to forget? Which parts do I want to tell my kids about?</p><p>I started to wonder: when we lose a loved one, should we aspire to be an historian, who pursues truth by representing the nuance and complexity of their life? Or, should we aspire to be like the photographer Vishniac, spinning a powerful story of their life, even at the cost of ignoring or misrepresenting other parts?</p><p>As I explored these questions, I came across a book by my friend and teacher Yehuda Kurtzer, president of the Shalom Hartman Institute. His book <em>Shuva</em> is about the roles of history and memory in forming and sustaining the Jewish people.</p><p>Kurtzer discusses “memory season” on the Jewish calendar. Each spring, we experience a series of holidays related to memory and history. First come two traditional holidays, Purim and Passover. They are followed by two modern holidays, Yom Hashoah and Yom HaZikaron.</p><p>Purim and Passover ritualize the past as acts of memory. Purim is the template for celebrating any moment when we emerge unscathed from a dangerous situation — like a communal benching of the <em>gomel</em> prayer. The tried to kill us, we survived, let’s eat! And on Pesach, Kurtzer notes, we “mostly tell stories about how people have told stories”[2] of what happened on Passover. On Pesach there are no harrowing testimonies of survivors. Instead, we get swept up in the “ongoing relevance of the message of liberation” that the holiday has come to represent. Purim and Pesach are exemplary holidays of Jewish <em>memory</em> in action.</p><p>But Yom HaShoah and Yom HaZikaron do not look anything like the templates of Purim and Pesach. Instead, they strive to be Jewish <em>history</em>. “On Passover,” Kurtzer writes, “we insert ourselves into a narrative, we become the oppressed and the liberated; [whereas] on Yom HaShoah…we become passive listeners to a survivor or eyewitness.” Yom HaShoah and Yom HaZikaron privilege historical accuracy. Purim and Pesach privilege collective memory and meaning making.</p><p>Over the last three years, we have witnessed Yom HaShoah begin to transition from ritual of history… to ritual of <em>memory</em>. Until very recently, almost all commemorations of Yom HaShoah featured the testimony of a survivor. Because that practice has become increasingly difficult, and because in a few years there will be no living survivors to turn to, the way we commemorate Yom HaShoah is starting to change. A new ritual was recently developed in Israel and has started to make its way to American Jewish communities. This new ritual, called <a href="https://www.hartman.org.il/program/yom-hashoah-hitkansut/#watch_a_hitkansut_gathering"><em>Hitkansut</em></a>, weaves together texts, testimonies, discussion, prayer, silence, and the voices of participants, not unlike the Haggadah of Passover. Before our very eyes, Yom HaShoah is starting to evolve to focus less on history, and more on memory and meaning making, earning its long-term place on Jewish memory season calendar.</p><p>And five days ago, on the first anniversary of October 7, we experienced an even more recent version of this process. Perhaps because the ongoing trauma that was triggered by that day is far from over, it felt — to me, at least — too early to make choices between history and memory.</p><p>Purim, Pesach, Yom HaShoah, Yom HaZikaron: these holidays embody the difference between memory and history. They contain wisdom that we could encapsulate as follows:</p><p>Jewish memory is not a photographic, comprehensive catalog. Jewish memory challenges us to create narratives of past events that lead to meaning, commitment and obligations.</p><p>The best way to think about this idea is with a metaphor, and the best metaphor I have found is an <strong>exhibition case</strong>.</p><p>When we try to preserve the totality of history — like preserving a whole library — without curating an exhibition case, we fail to transmit meaning. A vast but unused library may be more historically accurate, but it also gets very dusty. The Jewish way to remember is to curate an exhibition case with a handful of precious items and then tell stories about them, even if that means that the meaning of those memories evolves over time.</p><p>* * *</p><p>My father suffered from an un-named condition that causes hoarding. He was, in a phrase, a pack rat. A very successful pack rat, I might add. Throughout his life, he was surrounded by tall piles of stuff: in every room of every house he lived in, on every flat surface in each of those rooms, in every car he owned, in every bag he carried, there was lots and lots and lots of stuff. He was psychologically incapable of throwing things away.</p><p>In the backbreaking work of sorting through and getting rid of all that stuff after he died, I learned a simple truth: when you keep everything, you have kept nothing.</p><p>This is true for our physical material lives, and it is true for our digital lives: Only when you take the time, and spend the energy, to <strong>curate</strong> something have you created value and meaning. Only when you have abandoned completeness and accuracy in pursuit of a simple story that offers meaning — only then can you hold on to something for a long time.</p><p>This is the irony of Jewish memory: curating a few precious memories — and letting go of everything else — is the ultimate act of preservation. Placing a few memories, imbued with meaning, in a display case gives our loved ones a chance at being remembered.</p><p>So what do I put in the metaphorical display case of my father’s life? In my father’s display case, there are three things:</p><p>First: a few of his landscape photographs. I selected them from the literally thousands that he took in his life. These images remind me of how much he loved to be behind the viewfinder, of how much he longed to be outdoors, of the wonder he felt when he approached the natural world. These few images hang throughout our home.</p><p>Second: the display case contains a copy of my parents’ divorce court proceedings. I was 6 years old when they divorced, and I discovered these court proceedings as a teenager. The moment I read through them, I took a large step toward young adulthood. The divorce proceedings remind me of the pain of infidelity, the infinite complexity of parenting, and the amount of sacrifice required for a marriage to last.</p><p>Third: in the display case there is a piece of scrap paper with notes Dad jotted down during a phone call with me when I was 20 years old, living abroad in Jerusalem. I discovered the note in one of the hundreds of tall piles of his stuff. That note reminds me that he cared about what I was doing. And it reminds me that he really did keep everything.</p><p>Our relationships with our loved ones are complex, layered, containing multitudes. When our loved ones die, the memories we choose to display can be positive or negative. Romanticizing the past may not help. We make meaning from painful memories just as easily as we do from joyful memories — certainly we have learned <em>that</em> lesson from the Jews who came before us.</p><p>The display cases of memory that we construct may not be historically accurate. They will, by necessity, leave out many things. Kurtzer warns us not to “mistake accuracy for truth,” because approaching the past like an historian does not necessarily lead us to truth. We should have an historical consciousness, he argues, but not at the expense of creating “sacred myth” and meaning.</p><p>This is the genius behind the work of photographer Roman Vishniac. Did he realize that only by carefully selecting a few photos, and crafting a narrative around them, he would preserve the memory of Jewish life in the Pale of Settlement for generations to come?</p><p>No matter how many museums or centers for Jewish history we build, the future of the Jewish people cannot be built on archives. The only way to ensure the future of our people is to find the humanity in the stories of our loved ones and our communities — the stories that echo in our souls.[3]</p><p>One of my favorite Bible verses is from Psalms, one that we sing in Hallel: <em>lo hametim yehallelu yah — </em>those who are dead, cannot praise God. A companion verse might be: It is the job of the living to curate the memories of our deceased loved ones. Our deceased loved ones cannot do it for us. It is we who are living who have the responsibility to choose what we carry forward, to put those precious items into a display case, and to tell those stories to everyone who walks by.</p><p>Yizkor is our communal ritual for individual remembering. For a few precious moments we select a few precious memories to place in the display cases of the lives of those who made us who we are. Rediscover a memory. Add a memory. Maybe even exchange a memory. Yizkor is our designated time to build and refresh the display cases of memory of those we have loved and lost.</p><p>That is how our loved ones, and our people, will live into the future, safeguarded against being forgotten.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref1">[1]</a> Alana Newhouse, <a href="http://www.nytimes.com/2010/04/04/magazine/04shtetl-t.html?_r=0&amp;pagewanted=print">NYT</a>. 2nd quote by Leon Wieseltier, quoted in same article.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref2">[2]</a> Kurtzer, <em>Shuva</em>, p5</p><p><a href="#_ftnref3">[3]</a> Paraphrased from Kurtzer, 142.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=35d834f1b6c4" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Residue Is Carried, Not Forgiven]]></title>
            <link>https://rabbijustus.medium.com/residue-is-carried-not-forgiven-99649d8ef706?source=rss-d5a78496c308------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/99649d8ef706</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[residue]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[yom-kippur]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[forgiveness]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[police]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Justus Baird]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 22 Sep 2021 16:32:11 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-09-23T22:58:54.838Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>Originally delivered on Yom Kippur 5782 at the Princeton Jewish Center</em></p><p>Five years ago, in 2016, the CBS Evening News ran a <a href="https://www.cbsnews.com/video/crooked-cop-paired-up-with-man-he-framed/#x">heartwarming story about forgiveness</a>. Their reporter traveled to southwest Michigan, to a small town called Benton Harbor on the shore of Lake Michigan.</p><p>Jameel McGee told the reporter that he was minding his own business the day that a police officer came up to him, accused him of dealing drugs, and then arrested him. “The cop made it all up,” Jameel said.</p><p>It turns out that the cop <em>had</em> made it all up. The cop in question was Andrew Collins. Andrew says he was determined to make an arrest that day, even if it meant putting an innocent man in jail.</p><p>Jameel served four years of prison time for this crime he did not commit, while Andrew, the crooked cop, was eventually caught and sent to jail too — for a year and a half — for falsifying documents, planting drugs, and stealing.</p><p>A while after they were both released, Jameel and Andrew wound up together again, unexpectedly, working at Café Mosaic, a small coffee shop in town. Because of the tight quarters, they were forced to talk about what had happened between them, and they ended up becoming friends — close friends. In part because of their Christian faith, Andrew apologized and Jameel forgave him. Jameel forgave the man who intentionally put him in prison for four years for a crime he did not commit.</p><p>It’s not hard to see how this story of a wrongly accused man and a bad cop making amends could become a story worthy of national attention. Because Jameel is Black and Andrew is white, the story had overtones of racial reconciliation as well. News outlets flocked to cover the story — the Steve Harvey show, Megyn Kelly on NBC, Mike Huckabee on Fox. Jameel and Andrew went on the speaking circuit, giving talks about forgiveness at many churches. They even published a <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Convicted-Innocent-Unlikely-Forgiveness-Friendship/dp/0735290725">book</a> about their story.</p><p>But to Lilly Sullivan, a journalist and producer at This American Life, something didn’t seem right about the story. A friend had sent her one of the news reports, and Lilly did some digging. It turns out that Andrew — the bad cop — had falsified so many police reports and warrants, and had lied on the stand so frequently, that because of him 61 other cases were either overturned or thrown out. The town had to pay out 5 and a half million dollars to settle civil right violations. Andrew had intentionally framed dozens of innocent people so he could rise up the ranks of the police department. As Lilly put it, “And then he gets to go on TV and tell his story over and over, because annoyingly, America seems to love this kind of story of forgiveness.”</p><p>Lilly decided she wanted to find other victims and hear what they thought about Andrew [and you can listen to the <a href="https://www.thisamericanlife.org/650/transcript">resulting podcast</a> she produced]. She found Rob Walker, who told her — and I’m going to paraphrase here and change some of the words because we’re in synagogue, “How come you didn’t invite me on the Steve Harvey show? Because I woulda told you the damn truth. You’re hyping up this big thing about one person forgiving you. That ain’t the only person that he screwed over…what about everybody else that he done in?”</p><p>Rob told Lilly that Andrew was such a crooked cop that people would do crazy things to stay out of his way. For a while, one of the local radio stations warned people when Andrew was on duty. Rob told a story about how one time he was getting pulled over by a cop, and when he saw it was Andrew, instead of pulling his car to the side of the road, he drove directly to the police station, because that was the only place he could think of that he might be safe. Rob quickly got out of his car and asked the other cops to watch Andrew while he searched his car to make sure he didn’t plant something. Rob wasn’t interested in talking to Andrew, let alone forgiving him. There are dozens of these stories.</p><p><strong>* * * *</strong></p><p>During the ten days of repentance we think about, talk about, and pray for forgiveness. The rabbis talked about the different paths to forgiveness for sins between humans and God, and for sins <em>bein adam l’chavero — </em>between two people. But this Yom Kippur I want to look at one of the more difficult aspects of forgiveness.</p><p>As children we learn that once something has been done, “you can’t take it back.” Any wrongdoing leaves things in its wake, some form of damage, what we might call residue. That residue could be financial, physical, emotional, or relational. Forgiving someone does not remove this reside that is left behind.</p><p>When we forgive someone, we are saying: I have decided that the threat has passed, and I am going to find a way to bear the burden of this injury. Pamela Hieronymi is a philosopher who specializes in moral psychology at UCLA. She studied here at Princeton as an undergrad in the early 1990’s. <a href="http://hieronymi.bol.ucla.edu/Publications_files/Hieronymi%20Articulating%20Forgiveness%20pre-print.pdf">She writes</a> that when someone who has been wronged decides to forgive, they are choosing “to bear in [their] own person the cost of the wrongdoing and to incorporate the injury into [their] own life without further protest and without demand for retribution.” She says in some cases, this means “creatively incorporating the scars that bear the fingerprints” of what happened into the permanent fabric of our life.</p><p>Yotam Benziman, a professor at the Hebrew University in Jerusalem, takes this idea further. He teaches that when we forgive, we are embarking on a long, dialogical journey together with those who wronged us. The wrongdoer and the forgiver, he writes, will “walk together while they reexamine their relationship, the nature of the wrong, and the reasons why it occurred. The forgiver might become angry again, and the wrongdoer will apologize again.”</p><p>Benziman sees in the word “apology” a hint of this journey. The original Greek word <em>apologas</em>means “story.” The wrongdoer and the forgiver each tell their side of the story, reacting to the other. These stories are bound up in the identities and the biographies of the wrongdoer and the forgiver. These stories become part of who they are.</p><p>Seen in this light, the process of forgiveness, the process of being forgiven, requires us to carry the burden, deal with the residue, tell the stories of what we did and what happened to us, and to integrate them into our lives.</p><p>Our liturgy actually has language for this. The 13 attributes of God, which we recited at the beginning of the Torah service and will repeat later at the end of the Avodah service — <em>Adonai, Adonai, El Rachum v’Chanun</em> — words taken from Exodus 34, include the phrase <em>noseh avon</em> — which we usually translate as forgiving iniquity, but the words <em>noseh avon</em> more literally mean “<em>carry</em> the sin.”</p><p>In 1969, the Beatles recorded a mini-song for their Abbey Road album, “Boy, you’re gonna carry that weight.” But thousands of years before that, our Jewish ancestors understood that forgiveness involves carrying a burden and dealing with residue. Forgiving someone means saying, as my teacher Elana Stein Hain has taught: “I am willing to bear the scars of what you did to me, knowing that I will see you around.” I know that these scars, this residue, cannot be washed away. We are going to bear these scars and carry this residue together.</p><p>Lilly, the journalist who went in search of the bad cop’s other victims, eventually went to talk with the bad cop himself, Andrew. Andrew admitted that the news story was always framed as a story about two individuals — he and Jameel — and not about the community. He said no reporter had ever asked him to meet with one of his victims who still hated him. Lilly said she was happy to be the reporter to introduce him to victims who still hated him. She introduced Andrew to Quacy, another innocent person Andrew had framed, and who was still deeply resentful at Andrew for what he did. They talked for a while. Andrew apologized. Quacy said that Andrew got off way too easy, spending just a year and a half in jail for his crimes.</p><p>But then Quacy and Andrew started talking about how bad the policing still is in Benton Springs. They started having an insider conversation about other cops, judges and prosecutors they both believe are crooked. Lilly said they actually started to bond. Perhaps, this bond would later allow them to explore how they could carry the burden of the wrongdoing that Andrew committed, and the damage it did to Quacy, together.</p><p>I don’t know any story of deep hurt and wrong that isn’t complicated. The wrongs we have done, or that have been done to us, the ones that affect us most deeply, cannot be resolved with a simple process of forgiveness. When damage has been done, no amount of forgiveness can erase it. Showing up on Yom Kippur, striking our hearts, admitting to something we have done, this is not going to move things forward.</p><p>But there is a way we can take part in meaningful forgiveness. Meaningful forgiveness is to carry that burden, <em>noseh avon</em>, bear the scar, deal with the residue. It is messy. But it is real. And it can be done.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=99649d8ef706" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Your Personal Replay Center]]></title>
            <link>https://rabbijustus.medium.com/your-personal-replay-center-b8354f0ac2c2?source=rss-d5a78496c308------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b8354f0ac2c2</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[teshuva]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[rosh-hashanah]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[repentance]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[replay]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[basketball]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Justus Baird]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 22 Sep 2021 16:23:17 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-09-22T16:23:17.758Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>Originally delivered on Rosh Hashana 5782 at the Princeton Jewish Center.</em></p><p>In Secaucus, NJ there is a nondescript four story building full of large TV screens. The number of screens in the building keeps growing; currently there are more than 110 of them. Outside of the building are 29 fiber optics cables that snake across the United States to 29 special locations.</p><p>At the other end of each one of those 29 fiber optics cables is another special building, an NBA Basketball arena. All 29 basketball arenas are connected to the building in Secaucus with all the screens — making that building, of course, the <a href="https://official.nba.com/replay/">NBA Replay Center</a>.</p><p>The NBA Replay Center is just 7 years old. Every night there is an NBA game anywhere in America, there are referees inside glued to the screens, waiting for one of their referee colleagues to make the replay signal. Because of all the technology, it takes the replay center, on average, under 30 seconds to get the footage that the ref in the arena needs to review the call.</p><p>Working the replay center can be intense. Sometimes there are as many as 10 games happening simultaneously. Most replay requests come toward the end of the game, when every second and every point seems to matter more. One common replay request is whether a shot counts as 2 or 3 points. Another is whether a shot got off before the buzzer. The job of the replay center is to provide the ref on the floor with additional views of what happened, and the ref in the arena makes the ultimate call.</p><p>The NBA Replay Center was built to help out the referees, whose jobs are extremely stressful. Whatever call a referee makes, half of the fans-players and coaches are going to love it, and the other half are going to hate it. It’s not unusual for an entire stadium of fans to start chanting in unison, “<a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eqsioiQ5vkc">Ref you suck! Ref you suck</a>!” Increasingly, NBA players, especially the star players, have attacked refs by headbutting them, throwing their mouthguards at them, and by using all manner of foul language. Steve Kerr, head coach of the Golden State Warriors, admitted to a journalist that he sometimes snaps at a ref. “The things I say to referees I would never say to a normal person, Kerr said. I’ve been caught on camera calling refs bad names. It’s a sense of right or wrong, like a personal offense, a feeling that something unfair is happening.”</p><p>If you think about it, the NBA Replay Center is very unique. Other than elite professional sports, and perhaps the tables of a casino, I can’t think of another sector of society that we review what happened so closely. Can you imagine if there were replay centers for surgeons, covering each surgery in the operating room from multiple angles, scrutinizing every move the surgeons and nurses make? Or a replay center for stock traders, calculating the real-time financial consequences of every trade?</p><p>Although we are increasingly putting body cameras on police, it is nothing like the NBA Replay Center. It says something about our society that we invest millions of dollars in a replay facility to check whether a basketball player’s foot was over the 3-point line, but nothing comparable for life and death situations like judges and police.</p><p>* * *</p><p>One of the most important names for Rosh Hashana is Yom HaDin — the day of <em>din</em>, the day of judgment. Our high holidays are sometimes likened to a court trial, with Rosh Hashana as our first day in court. The <em>unetaneh tokef</em> prayer that we will recite during Musaf is very explicit:</p><blockquote>Your throne, from which You rule in truth, is established with love. Truly, You are Judge and Prosecutor, Expert, and Witness, completing the indictment, bringing the case, and enumerating the counts. You recall all that is forgotten, and will open the book of remembrance, which speaks for itself, for our own hands have signed the page.</blockquote><p>The author of the <em>unetaneh tokef </em>paints a powerful image of what happens on Rosh Hashana: a divine court assembles, with God playing all of the key roles as our lives are judged. Nothing that we have done is forgotten by God — everything is written in the book of remembrance.</p><p>Of course, the judgment we receive on Rosh Hashanah is not final. To use a phrase I learned from Rabbi Dov Linzer, of Yeshivat Chovevei Torah, Rosh Hashana is the day that our judgment is “penciled in” — written with pencil, but not sealed. That means Rosh Hashana is not the end of the judgment; it is, rather, the beginning of our <em>teshuvah</em>. Our <em>g’zerah</em> — the decree that results from how we have been judged — can be altered by <em>teshuvah, t’filah </em>and <em>tzedakah</em>.</p><p>For most of my life I have paid attention to certain elements of the <em>unetaneh tokef </em>prayer. I focused on the dread and terror of having my fate determined: will I live or die? What will my life be like this coming year, and how will my death come? I also focused on those three behaviors that can alter the decree, the three T’s: <em>teshuvah, t’filah </em>and <em>tzedakah</em>. Am I practicing enough repentance, prayer and charity?</p><p>But this year I was drawn to a different element of the prayer: the court scene in which God plays judge and jury and prosecutor. A court in which all of the evidence of our lives is on display, and nothing that we did during the year is forgotten because it is all recorded in the book of remembrance.</p><p>I hope this metaphor will not be a bridge too far for anyone who does not pay attention to professional sports — and I count myself as such a person — but I’d like to think of the divine court scene from <em>unetaneh tokef </em>as a Replay Center. Thinking of the divine court as a replay center makes possible a new understanding of what Rosh Hashana means.</p><p>The servers and screens in the NBA Replay Center are a modern version of the Book of Remembrance, except that they record only the events of basketball games. Every single thing that happens on the floor of that basketball court is recorded — from multiple angles — and available for replay. Players, fans, coaches and even referees each have their own perspective of what happened, but the replay center has captured it from every angle.</p><p>In today’s world, with multiple cameras and cheap storage, we actually have the technology to create <em>Sefer HaZichronot</em>, a Book of Remembrance, to capture everything that happens in a specific arena. In such an environment, there is no hiding. Like basketball players and referees, we are on the court, living out our lives. I think this is one aspect of what the author of the <em>unetaneh tokef</em> prayer was trying to communicate: the Book of Remembrance is God’s impartial record of everything we have done.</p><p>The Replay Center, more than a court room, helps us visualize what it might be like to review our behavior over the course of the year. By replacing the judge’s gavel and the witness box with a bank of TV screens, we can shift the question from “will I be judged guilty?” to “what can I learn by looking back over the past year?” and “How might I incorporate that new perspective into the choices I make this coming year?”</p><p>Imagine walking into a room with a dozen screens, each one playing scenes from your life over the past year from different angles. At that level of examination and detail, what might we learn about ourselves? How might we see our behavior differently from the camera angle of the people in our family? Or the camera angle of the people we never pay attention to? Or the camera angle of those whose lives we touched but never followed up to see the results?</p><p>There is a movie with a version of this plot that was released 30 years ago called “<a href="https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0101698/">Defending Your Life</a>.” It was written and directed by Albert Brooks, and co-starred a young Meryl Streep. The film depicts what happens immediately after we die. We spend a few days in Judgment City in a small court room, each of us being called to account by reviewing a handful of scenes from our lives. A defender and prosecutor make a case to the judges about whether or not our soul is enlightened enough to “move on.”</p><p>Unlike this Hollywood version, however, Rosh Hashana challenges us not to wait until we die to take serious stock of our lives. Instead, we engage in the look back each and every year.</p><p>There is one other prayer in today’s liturgy that highlights the theme of <em>Yom HaDin</em>. It is a piyyut we recited during the Shacharit Amidah, <em>l’el orekh din</em>. The piyyut bounces between the phrases “<em>b’yom din</em>” — on the Day of Judgment — and “<em>ba-din</em>” — in judgment or, as our Mahzor translates, “in justice.” Here are two lines from the prayer:</p><p><em>God is the one who knows our thoughts, </em><strong><em>b’yom din</em></strong><em>, on the Day of Judgment, and overcomes anger </em><strong><em>ba-din</em></strong><em>, with justice.</em></p><p><em>God is the One who responds to those who cry out, </em><strong><em>b’yom din</em></strong><em>, on the Day of Judgment, and demonstrates mercy</em><strong><em> ba-din</em></strong><em>, in justice.</em></p><p>Unlike the <em>Unetaneh Tokef</em>, this piyyut highlights the <strong>relational</strong> context of our judgment. Between God and the person being judged there is love and intimacy, understanding and forgiveness.</p><p>Over the next ten days of repentance, and the weeks that follow, we have an opportunity to sit in our own replay center. The room will be filled with love, intimacy, understanding and forgiveness. In my own version of the image, I imagine God saying to me, “I want to show you a clip of this event from a new angle.” After watching, I will say, “I never considered how my behavior might affect that person in that way.” After replaying many scenes from my life over the year, I will feel humbled but also energized by the challenge of improving how I live.</p><p>There are many ways to sit in our metaphorical replay centers. Write in a journal. Meditate. Talk with people you trust. Review your calendar over the past year. Watch the images of recent events in your minds eye. However you reflect best, this is the time of year our tradition gives us to do it.</p><p>Although we don’t have access to an actual video recording of our lives, we DO have access to multiple camera angles, so to speak. The people we live our lives with have recorded a version of our life over the past year. Our loved ones, our friends, our colleagues, our neighbors. They have seen us in ways we cannot see ourselves. They have access to understanding of our behavior that we do not have access to. If there is a scene you want to review from this year, think about asking someone else to give you a new camera angle on the event in question.</p><p>We know from the experience of sports referees that it is stressful to know that everyone is watching what you are doing, to watch a replay of your actions on screen. The referees weren’t excited about the replay center at first, because it seemed to threaten their authority. But over time, they welcomed the replay center as a powerful tool to do their jobs better. We can learn from these referees: every minute we spend in our own replay center will help us become better people.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b8354f0ac2c2" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Tefillin: Souvenirs from the Exodus]]></title>
            <link>https://rabbijustus.medium.com/tefillin-souvenirs-from-the-exodus-3004a6beda19?source=rss-d5a78496c308------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/3004a6beda19</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[judaism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[souvenir]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[tefillin]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[exodus]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Justus Baird]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 09 Feb 2021 22:38:25 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-02-09T22:38:25.487Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>Originally written for Parashat Bo 5779 (January 2019)</em></p><p>The story of the ten plagues in the book of Exodus follow a reasonable narrative arc, until the story breaks down after the tenth plague — the death of the first born. Right after that plague is carried out, in the middle of that night, Pharaoh gathers his courtiers, calls for Moses and Aaron, and tells them to “be gone.”</p><p>But then the story pauses, and the biblical text turns to a set of instructions about how to commemorate the Exodus. We start reading passages that are not connected to the <em>story</em>, but instead focus on how to <em>remember</em> the story.</p><p>This year, I’ve been reading to my daughter the story of Little Red Riding Hood in Hebrew — in that version she is called <em>Kipah Adumah. </em>Imagine reading that Little Red Riding Hood has entered her grandmother’s house and just realized that the body in the bed is not actually her grandmother, but is a hungry wolf — and then stopping the story for a set of meta-instructions about not talking to strangers. That was this interruption of the Exodus story is like.</p><p>What exactly is so important to tell the reader that it is worth pausing one of the greatest stories known to humanity — the story of the Exodus — right as the Israelites are about to escape?</p><p>The pause in the narrative contains three instructions, each one instructing us in a way of remembering the Exodus.</p><p>First, we are commanded to sacrifice a lamb and have a big meal. Why? So that when our children ask us about it, we will tell them, “It is the Passover sacrifice to God, because God passed over the houses of the Israelites in Egypt when God smote the Egyptians, but saved our houses” (Exodus 12:26–27).</p><p>Second, we are commanded to eat unleavened bread for seven days. Why? So that when our children ask us about it, we will tell them, “It is because of what God did for me when I went free from Egypt” (13:8).</p><p>Third, we are commanded to sacrifice or redeem every first-born living thing from an Israelite womb. Why? So that when our children ask us about it, we will tell them, “When Pharaoh stubbornly refused to let us go, God slew every first born in the land of Egypt, the first-born of both man and beast. Therefore I sacrifice to God every first male issue of the womb, but redeem every first born among my sons” (13:15).</p><p>But the text adds one more instruction and repeats it twice. This one does not follow the educational Q&amp;A format with children.</p><blockquote>13:9: “And this shall serve you as a sign on your hand as a reminder on your forehead — in order that the Teaching of God may be in your mouth — that with a mighty hand God freed you from Egypt.”</blockquote><blockquote>13:16: “And so it shall be as a sign upon your hand and as a symbol on your forehead that with a mighty hand God freed us from Egypt.”</blockquote><p>In these instructions we are commanded to do two things: first, put an <em>ot</em> on our arm. “<em>Ot</em>” is probably best understood as a sign of some sort. Second, put something between our eyes — in one verse it is called a <em>zikaron</em> and in the other it is called a <em>totafot</em>. <em>Zikaron</em> clearly means reminder, but <em>totafot</em> is anyone’s guess — it is often translated as symbol.</p><p>Many are familiar with the fact that these two verses — along with verses in Deuteronomy 6 and 11 — have been interpreted over the millennia in physical form, the ritual objects that we know today as <em>tefillin</em>.</p><p>I married a girl (now Rabbi) from Cleveland, and early in our marriage I learned from her that winter doesn’t work for her if we don’t take a break and go somewhere warm for a week. This winter, our wandering to a warmer climate took us to the Yucatan peninsula of Mexico. One of the many amazing aspects of the Yucatan are the extraordinary Mayan ruins, the most famous of which is Chichen Itza, one of the “new” seven wonders of the world.</p><p>We arrived at Chichen Itza early in the morning — just as the gates were opening — to avoid the crowds. As we walked around the vast complex, imagining what life was like for the Mayan people 1,000 years ago, we witnessed hundreds of local Mexican and Mayan vendors setting up their wares, or what we called <em>tchotchkes</em>. Every inch of every walkway of the entire compound was lined with sellers of souvenirs.</p><p>My children, of course, were quite interested in all of these tchotchkes. They struggled to choose something worthy of spending their allowance. They also struggled with the art of haggling. But they each got something. One bought a small chess set with a Mayan calendar inscribed on it. One bought a colorful pyramid. And one bought an elephant, because, well, he likes elephants.</p><p>As I studied the Exodus text again this year, I realized that there are many similarities between the souvenirs of Chichen Itza and <em>tefillin</em>. As I reconsidered the verses that instruct us to put an sign on our arm and a symbol between our eyes to remind us that God freed us from Egypt with a mighty hand — I came to see <em>tefillin</em> as a souvenir from the Exodus.</p><p>Inside these <em>tefillin</em> are four passages from Torah, three of which explicitly connect the instruction to put a sign on our arm and a symbol between our eyes to the Exodus. Unlike the three sacred rituals I mentioned earlier, the Passover meal, the eating of matzah, and the redemption of the first-born, <em>tefillin</em> — like a souvenir — are physical, tangible. They are a thing we can pick up, and take with us wherever we go — and each time we touch them and put them on and reflect on the sacred words that are carefully placed inside of them, we remember what God did for us by bringing us out of Egypt. We feel the harsh conditions of slavery as well as the exultation of having our cries heard by God.</p><p>I happened to have done a deep dive into studying <em>tefillin</em>. My hevruta partner and I took it upon ourselves to study every rabbinic text that mention <em>tefillin</em>. It took us five years, studying three times a month, to do it. We worked our way through every mention of <em>tefillin</em> in the Mishnah, the Talmud, and the ancient and medieval midrashim. During our years of studying texts related to <em>tefillin</em>, my respect for these objects deepened tremendously. I also discovered some fun facts that I never learned in rabbinical school.</p><p>I learned, for instance, that some rabbis recited a blessing not only when they put on <em>tefillin</em>, but also when they removed <em>tefillin</em>: (<em>v’tzivanu lishmor hukav</em>), though it seems that this blessing never entered the canon (Pesikta Rabbati 22). And I learned that when the Messiah comes, <em>tefillin</em> are among just a half dozen mitzvot that God will bring to all the nations (R. Tanhuman, Midrash Tehilim 21:1).</p><p>I also learned a midrash from our study that I’d like to share, one that connects <em>tefillin </em>to the moment when the Israelites crossed through the sea. When the sea parted, the water formed into a wall, a <em>homah</em>, on either side of the Israelites as they walked on dry land. This surprised the ministering angels. They said to God: “Why are you rescuing these humans who engaged in idol worship?” The rabbis explain that we know the angels were angry by reading the word for wall — <em>homah</em> — as <em>hamah</em> — anger. And then the rabbis debate what these walls of water were that protected the Israelites as they crossed the sea. One rabbi said that the wall on one side was the Torah and the wall on the other side was prayer. Another rabbi said, the wall on one side is the <em>mezuzah</em>, and on the other side <em>tefillin</em>. This is a powerful image: that the <em>mezuzah</em> and <em>tefillin</em> in our homes represent the two sides of the sea that protected the Israelites as they escaped slavery.</p><p><em>Tefillin</em> are our souvenir from the Exodus. By wearing them we are reminded of how God rescued us from Egypt with a mighty hand. And perhaps, depending on your theology, they are not only a reminder, but a form of spiritual protection as well.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=3004a6beda19" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Wave and the Cry: A Jewish Tale of Crisis and Response]]></title>
            <link>https://rabbijustus.medium.com/the-wave-and-the-cry-a-jewish-tale-of-crisis-and-response-b7f3aff93624?source=rss-d5a78496c308------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b7f3aff93624</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[crisis]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[judaism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[jonah]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[tales]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[birth]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Justus Baird]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 29 Sep 2020 20:17:12 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-09-29T20:17:12.057Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>Inspired by, and dedicated to, my teacher </em><a href="https://www.hartman.org.il/person/melila-hellner-eshed/"><em>Dr. Melila Hellner-Eshed</em></a><em>. See her teaching, Spiritual Sustenance in a Time of Crisis, </em><a href="https://summer.hartman.org.il/agenda/session/275528"><em>here</em></a><em>.</em></p><p>It was a glorious day on the water. The sea was filled with sailboats and kayaks and motorboats. People swimming at the beach. A child shuttled back and forth from his sandcastle to the water’s edge with a toy boat.</p><p>An elderly woman was taking a walk along the shore. She lifted her gaze to the horizon, but something didn’t look right. The edge of the sea looked as if it was curling up.</p><p>A mile offshore, the captain of a fishing vessel also saw it. It looked like white fire was burning on the edge of the sea.<a href="#_ftn1">[1]</a> By the time he realized that a giant wave was coming, it was too late. He put out a mayday call. And then the sailor’s ship was engulfed.</p><p>The wave was so high that everyone disagreed about how tall it was. Some said 100 feet, others said 100 stories. It was impossible to tell. Everyone who saw the wave believed in their heart they were about to die.</p><p>In the shadow of the giant wave, parents grabbed their children. Lovers clung to each other. Sailors and kayakers prepared to be tossed into the sea.</p><p>The wave was quick. It swallowed everything in its path. Under the water, the child with the toy boat felt weeds tangling around his head,<a href="#_ftn2">[2]</a> like they were trying to choke him. Under the water, the elderly woman was tossed about, over and over, like clothes in a washing machine.</p><p>Somehow, there were survivors. One by one, they broke through to the surface, gasping for air. Rori, the elderly woman, was coughing up water. Someone was yelling at her. Rori thought to herself, ‘How am I alive? I can’t even swim!’</p><p>The voice came again. “Lean back!” Rori leaned back and looked up. A man was trying to buckle a lifejacket around her. He clipped the strap. Rori bobbed in the water. “I’ll come back later to check on you!” the man called out as he sailed away.</p><p>Rori looked around. She saw a kayak full of water. Over there was an ice chest. A few yards away was a wooden plank, probably from a boat, and she decided to make her way toward it.</p><p>An hour later, the sailor came back. It was a small boat with a single sail, but the sight of it was exhilarating. He had a child with him. The sailor placed the child in the submerged kayak. “Stay in this kayak, and stay with this woman,” he instructed.</p><p>Rori saw the fear in the child’s eyes. So she mustered some courage. “I’m Rori. It looks like this nice man has saved both of us.” The child looked at her and cried.</p><p>The sailor looked at Rori. “There are two hours left before sunset. I promise I will return by then.” Then he sailed away, a second time.</p><p>Rori and the child, now alone together, distracted themselves with a game of searching for floating objects. ‘What do you think that one is?’ Rori would ask. The child would guess, then Rori would guess. And they would make their way over to the object to see what it was.</p><p>As Rori floated on the plank, and the child rested in the kayak, she remembered a story she had learned when she was a child. “There was an ancient rabbi whose ship wrecked on the open sea. I think it was Rabbi Akiva. He was tossed into the open sea, but he survived.”</p><p>The child asked, “How did he survive?”</p><p>“A plank from the boat floated by. He grabbed it, and to every wave that approached, he nodded his head. Eventually, he washed up on shore.’”<a href="#_ftn3">[3]</a></p><p>The child said, “so then I will hang on to my wet kayak and I will nod to every wave.”</p><p>The Sailor returned as he had promised, this time with a third survivor. Tied to the back of the boat was a floating junkyard.</p><p>Rori looked at the survivor and saw that she was pregnant. Probably in her third trimester. When the boat was close enough, she called out, “I’m Rori. And this is Jonah.”</p><p>The pregnant survivor called out, “Hi…I’m Hannah. We found a toy boat for the child.”</p><p>Together, the four of them, the elderly Rori wearing her lifejacket, the young Jonah, pregnant Hannah and the Sailor, assembled a makeshift raft.</p><p>When the sun started to set, Hannah asked the Sailor, “Which way is the shore? How far did we get pushed out?”</p><p>The Sailor was quiet for a moment. Then he said, “Based on the sunset, the shore should be in that direction. But I haven’t seen any sign of land since the wave came.”</p><p>The first night was interminable. Jonah was afraid of monsters in the sea. Rori and Hannah were worried about rolling off the raft while they slept. But there was one part of that night they would never forget. The stars. Other than the Sailor, they had never in their life seen so many stars. As she tried to make sense of what had happened, Rori thought, “Why did it take a tragedy like this for me to notice the beauty of these stars?”<a href="#_ftn4">[4]</a></p><p>Early the next morning, Jonah saw a blinking light in the distance. After a short discussion, they decided to investigate it. Using the sailboat as a tugboat to carry their raft, they headed toward the blinking light. Then the Sailor noticed something odd. The light wasn’t bobbing up and down like it should if it were on a floating buoy. When they arrived at the blinking light, they found a thin metal tower, bent and leaning, with the light on top.</p><p>The Sailor’s eyes followed the line of the tower down into the deep. “Oh God,” the Sailor whispered to himself. He suddenly realized why they couldn’t see the shore.</p><p>“What?!” Hannah asked.</p><p>“That’s an aviation warning light. It’s a blinking light they put on towers to keep airplanes from hitting very tall objects. Yesterday, that tower was on dry land. The reason we can’t see the shore…is because there is no shore anymore. Somehow all of the dry land is now hundreds of feet directly below us.”</p><p>As Hannah, Rori, Jonah and the Sailor peered down into the depths of the sea, their spirits sank.</p><p>After a week, a rhythm emerged. They learned to catch fish for food and found vessels to collect rainwater to drink. They built up their raft.</p><p>Early one morning, Jonah awoke just before dawn. Something deep in the water was glowing. He felt a sense of wonder, and a sense of dread, as he stared at the light. Actually, he noticed, there were two lights close together. He tried to show Rori, but by the time she woke up, the lights were gone.</p><p>Later that afternoon, the sailor went on his daily search for survivors and floating resources. When he returned, his boat was moving faster than usual. Jonah noticed the sailor was holding his fishing rod tightly. The boat was being pulled by something massive on the end of the fishing line.</p><p>Suddenly the surface of the water was very turbulent and two giant cones pierced the water’s surface. When the cones were twenty feet high, a mass the size of a small house emerged.</p><p>Rori grabbed Jonah’s hand. Jonah yelled out, with a voice of awe and wonder, it’s…a giant sea monster!</p><p>The sea monster spoke. “I am not a sea monster. I am a sea-goat. My name is Ilyam. We provide food for the Leviathan.”<a href="#_ftn5">[5]</a></p><p>Jonah started at the sea-goat. “Your eyes — those were your eyes I saw glowing in the deep this morning. Are you going to eat us?”</p><p>The sea-goat shook its giant head.</p><p>“That’s good. They why are you here?” Jonah asked.</p><p>The sea-goat spoke again. “I have always been here. Your maps will not work here. You will need new wisdom and new directions. Come, read my horns.”</p><p>The sea goat lowered its head and came close to the raft. Jonah sensed that Ilyam wanted him to jump onto his head, so he jumped. The sea-goat raised his head out of the water, with Jonah on top.</p><p>Jonah said, “There is something engraved on the horns. He brushed off the seaweed and some barnacles. This one says, <em>The cry that protects</em>.” Jonah carefully made his way over to the other horn. “And this one says, <em>Cracks are openings.</em>”</p><p>Ilyam the sea-goat lowered his head so that Jonah could return to the raft. Hannah turned to Rori. “What does that mean? The cry that protects….Cracks are openings?”</p><p>Rori watched the turbulent water turn calm again as the sea-goat descended into the deep.</p><p>A month went by. It was a quiet morning on the raft. Hannah spoke. “I think I’m going crazy.”</p><p>The Sailor replied, “We’re all going crazy.”</p><p>Hannah continued. “I’m angry. I’m sad. I’m exhausted. I feel trapped. And I’m scared.”</p><p>The Sailor thought he could listen for a while, so he decided to start with the first one, “What are you angry about?”</p><p>“I’m angry that my whole life is gone. I’m angry that all those people died.”</p><p>“What are you sad about?” inquired the Sailor.</p><p>“I miss my friends. I miss…the little things. I miss taking a walk in the morning. I miss walking! There’s no place to walk on this raft! The only thing we can do to move around is swim! I used to love swimming, but now…I’m not a fish!”</p><p>The Sailor thought to himself, ‘We’ve eaten so much fish that we might actually be becoming fish.’ But he decided to keep the comment to himself.</p><p>“What are you scared about?” he asked Hannah.</p><p>Hannah went quiet for a moment. “I’m scared about how I am going to care for this baby on this ramshackle raft. And I’m scared about…what will happen if, if… I can’t breastfeed?” Tears started running down Hannah’s face. “Do you see a hospital? There’s no doctors here. I’m scared that something bad is going to happen during delivery and there will be no one who knows what to do.”</p><p>Rori sat down next to Hannah. “Hannah.” she said softly. “<em>Ki chayot henah</em>.” It’s one of my favorite verses in the bible. It’s from the Exodus story. Pharoah told the midwives to kill all the boys delivered to Hebrew women. But the midwives couldn’t do it. They let the babies live. When Pharoah realized what was happening, he summoned the midwives and accused them: ‘Why are you letting the boys live?’ Those midwives were smart. They told him: ‘<em>ki chayot henah</em>’ — the Hebrew mothers are vigorous. They give birth to their babies before we can even arrive.’<a href="#_ftn6">[6]</a> Hannah, you are like those vigorous Hebrew mothers. Young mothers have been giving birth to their babies for thousands of years without doctors or hospitals.”</p><p>Hannah turned to Rori. “Yes, but many of those babies and their mothers died.”</p><p>Rori looked into Hannah’s eyes. “That’ true, but it wasn’t just the Hebrew mothers who were vigorous. Those midwives were vigorous too, for standing up to Pharoah. We will all be your midwives. Me, the Sailor, and Jonah. We will be ready to help you deliver your baby.”</p><p>Two months later, the time came for Hannah’s baby to be born. Rori, Jonah, and the Sailor were by her side. They had done everything they could to prepare. But there was one thing they were not prepared for, and that was Hannah’s cry. As she labored, Hannah’s cry went out like the sound of the shofar. Her cry vibrated across the surface of the sea in every direction. Her cry rose to the heavens. Her cry sunk to the deep. And just when she had nothing left to give, a smaller cry was heard, emerging from her exhausted womb. Rori caught the tiny bundle of new life. The Sailor massaged his aching hand, bruised from Hannah’s grip. When he looked out at the horizon, he saw dry land.</p><p><em>Originally told to the community gathered for Kol Nidre at the Jewish Center of Princeton, September 28, 2020.</em></p><p><a href="#_ftnref1">[1]</a> Rabbah bar Bar Hanah: Seafarers told me, the wave capable of sinking a ship looks as though a white fringe of fire is at its crest. B. Bava Batra 73a</p><p><a href="#_ftnref2">[2]</a> Jonah 2:4</p><p><a href="#_ftnref3">[3]</a> B. Yevamot 121a.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref4">[4]</a> I fell to my knees to gather / shards of a horizon shattered to bits. / Only then did I lift my head / to inhale into the depths of my heart / the entire canopy of the stars. Yehezkel Rahamim, “What Might Come After Storm and Dissolution”.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref5">[5]</a> BB 74a: R. Safra taught: Once, while traveling on a ship, we saw a fish that raised its head out of the sea. It had horns on which was engraved: “I, one of the lesser creatures of the sea, am 300 parasangs long, and yet I can fit into the Levithan’s mouth.” R. Ashi said: this fish was a sea-goat. Ilyam = (איל-ים)</p><p><a href="#_ftnref6">[6]</a> Exodus 1:19. For an example of how distress is described as not having enough strength to make it through the moment of childbirth, see Isaiah 37:7.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b7f3aff93624" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[John Witherspoon and the Book of Life]]></title>
            <link>https://rabbijustus.medium.com/john-witherspoon-and-the-book-of-life-856181f82155?source=rss-d5a78496c308------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/856181f82155</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[book-of-life]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[slavery]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[john-witherspoon]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[statue]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Justus Baird]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 21 Sep 2020 13:20:38 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-09-21T13:20:38.033Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>Originally delivered on Rosh Hashana 5781 at the Jewish Center in Princeton, NJ.</em></p><p>This summer I started taking my three kids on an afternoon Shabbat walk. We weren’t walking to shul anymore, and we needed a reason to stretch our legs. Their favorite destination became Carnegie Lake, where we discovered a couple hidden treehouses overlooking the water.</p><p>One Shabbat, I decided to take them on a more unusual walk. The idea for the walk occurred to me a few weeks prior, while we were watching Hamilton on Disney. I wanted to make the story of the founding of the United States come alive, so I decided to bring them on a short adventure to…the <a href="https://nassauchurch.org/about/princetoncemetery/">cemetery</a>. You can probably guess why. Just a few hundred yards from where we live, lies one of the key characters of Hamilton, one of our country’s founding fathers, Aaron Burr.</p><p>As a parenting intervention, the walk was basically a bust. Here’s one direct quote overheard at the cemetery gate: “Really, Aba? You dragged us on an adventure to the cemetery? Can we go home now?”</p><p>The stories of Alexander Hamilton and Aaron Burr and the other personalities that made it into the musical are part of a much larger reckoning that we are going through as an American society. One of those personalities whose life and legacy resonates deeply for our own town of Princeton is John Witherspoon.</p><p>John Witherspoon was the sixth president of Princeton University and a Founding Father of the United States. He has been lying in his grave for 226 years, just a few yards away from Aaron Burr. But this summer he was the talk of the town and of the talk of the university.</p><p>Professor Martha Sandweiss launched the <a href="https://slavery.princeton.edu/">Princeton and Slavery project</a>. For the past few years, I had the privilege of sharing a pre-fast meal on Erev Yom Kippur with Professor Sandweiss at the home of a mutual friend. Each year she would recount with excitement the findings of their research. One of the personalities her team researched closely was John Witherspoon.</p><p>Witherspoon’s leadership is certainly notable. He took over the College of New Jersey, later to be called Princeton University, when it was a small school focused on training minsters. The college was saddled with debt, and was known for its weak instruction and tiny library. Witherspoon transformed the college into a leadership academy for a new country. The roster of students he taught is almost mind-boggling: they include James Madison, Aaron Burr, three Supreme Court Justices, 10 cabinet officers, 12 members of the Continental Congress, 28 US senators, and 49 Congressmen.</p><p>But on the issue of slavery, an accounting of Witherspoon’s life comes up decidedly mixed.</p><p>On the side of the ledger that we would celebrate would be written:</p><p>· When Witherspoon was a pastor in Scotland, he gave religious instruction to a slave named James Montgomery and baptized him.</p><p>· While he was president of the college, he privately tutored two free African men, and late in his life took on a third.</p><p>· He was the only clergyman and college president to sign the Declaration of Independence, which declared that all men are created equal.</p><p>But on the other side of the ledger would be written:</p><p>· Witherspoon helped draft and signed the Articles of Confederation, which codified slavery as a national institution.</p><p>· He chaired a committee for the State of New Jersey to consider abolition, and voted against it, arguing that slavery was already dying out, and thus paving the way for slavery to be practiced in NJ for 75 more years until the end of the Civil War.</p><p>· Late in life he built a country home on Cherry Hill Road, called Tusculum. To help manage his property and farm, he purchased two slaves.<a href="#_ftn1">[1]</a></p><p>As part of the Princeton and Slavery project, a playwright named <a href="https://www.nathanalandavis.com/">Nathan Alan Davis</a> wrote a<a href="https://slavery.princeton.edu/multimedia/videos/symposium/the-princeton-slavery-plays-part-ii-the-torch"> short play about Witherspoon and slavery</a>. In his play, a freshmen student at the University decides to remove the statue of John Witherspoon that stands in the large open square near Firestone Library. The play imagines a heated conversation between Jasmine, the student, and Witherspoon, the statue.</p><p>As she takes out a blowtorch, the student, Jasmine, challenges Witherspoon to recall the names of his two slaves. Witherspoon wants to talk about how he did more “than most men for the upliftment” of blacks. But Jasmine wants to know if Witherspoon can even recall the names of the two people who served him: they are “Not details. People. People who lived with you. Who served you. For decades,” she yells at Witherspoon.</p><p>The playwright gives John Witherspoon the last line. As Witherspoon’s statue lays on the ground, having been toppled by Jasmine’s blowtorch, he says, “There are so many things I would change if I could. Once you’ve died: It’s too late. You just witness the effects. Of all you’ve done. And left undone. It’s wonderful and terrible. The worst, though. The worst are the compromises. The white lies you told yourself, so you could keep living your life. All those white lies.”</p><p>This is the legacy that leaders across Princeton have been wrestling with this summer. In town, the school board was wrestling with a request to change the name of Witherspoon Middle School. And on campus, students and faculty were wrestling with a request to relocate Witherspoon’s statue.</p><p>This is the time of year that we Jews consider our deeds. During the Ten Days of Repentance, and the month of Elul leading up to it, we look back. We reflect. We consider how others, and how God, will judge our past actions.</p><p>Soon we will recite the <em>Unetaneh Tokef</em> prayer as an introduction to the <em>kedusha </em>of <em>musaf</em>. The central idea of <em>Unetaneh Tokef</em> is the notion that God records our deeds in some type of written account. This idea goes all the way back to the book of Exodus. After the episode of the Golden Calf [Ex32], Moses pleads with God to forgive the sin of idolatry of the Israelites. Please forgive them, Moses says, and if you won’t, “then erase me from the record that you have written!”</p><p>The <em>sefer hayim</em>, the Book of Life, shows up in the Book of Psalms (69:29) and the New Testament. It also makes an appearance in the Mishna. In Pirkei Avot (2:1), Rabbi Judah Hanasi teaches that in order to avoid sin, we should be mindful of <em>three things above us</em>: an eye that sees, an ear that hears, and all our deeds are written in a scroll.</p><p>This idea that appears in the Bible and Mishnah that “someone is watching and recording us” made its way into the Talmud and eventually into our liturgy in the form of <em>Unetaneh Tokef</em>. The Book of Life is being recorded: on Rosh Hashanah it is written, on Yom Kippur it is sealed.</p><p>The idea reminds me of a lyric from the Violent Femmes — and perhaps the few of you who grew up in the 1970s and 1980s like I did, will remember it: “<a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=05k90ts2biw">this will go down on your permanent record!</a>”</p><p>For many years I have struggled with this theology. Perhaps God is watching us. Perhaps, as Rabbi Judah Hanasi taught, there <em>is</em> an eye and ear above. I will admit that each morning, when I put a kippah on my head, I think to myself, someone will be watching what I do today. But I’m not so sure about the idea that there is a scroll with our name, written for life or death in the next year.</p><p>This summer, after the University voted to change the name of the Woodrow Wilson school, an alum of Princeton High School named Geoffrey Allen decided to see if the time was right to change the name of John Witherspoon Middle School, the school where my two sons have just started seventh grade. More than 1,500 people signed his <a href="https://www.change.org/p/princeton-public-school-renaming-john-witherspoon-ms-and-reforming-racial-education-in-princeton-public-schools">petition</a>, most of them alumni. Perhaps the most compelling line in the petition was, “This change is imperative, as the school’s name and Witherspoon’s legacy creates a hostile environment for both the middle school and district’s racially diverse student body.”</p><p>One parent from the school, Princeton Art Professor Rachael DeLue, <a href="https://www.dailyprincetonian.com/article/2020/08/princeton-john-witherspoon-name-change">said </a>that changing the name will make the school more inclusive. She added that the name of her middle school when she grew up was Harriet Tubman Middle School, and that name “shaped how she saw the world.”</p><p>The school board agreed. After two meetings to discuss the request, they voted to change the name of the school.</p><p>I don’t know whether I believe that God is keeping a record of our deeds. What I <em>do</em> believe is that as a society, we, collectively, are keeping a written records of our deeds. Whether or not a Book of Life exists in the heavens, it sure exists here on earth. The decisions we make in life will be reviewed and judged by those who know us, by those who love us, and by those who come after us. And the scales of justice that they will use to measure our lives are not calibrated to the societal norms of our own day. The scales of justice they will use will be calibrated to the societal norms of the future.</p><p>Like John Witherspoon, we will all be judged. History, and the future, has their eyes on us.</p><p>Whether you are motivated more by the idea that God is keeping a ledger of your life, or by the idea that future generations will carefully review your actions, one idea rings true and runs throughout the liturgy of our high holy days: <em>the choices we make, right now, they matter</em>. The actions we take or don’t take, the words we say or withhold, the words we write or leave unwritten, the people we help or don’t help, the relationships we nurture or ignore, the way we respond to this pandemic.</p><p>I wish for each one of you a meaningful period of reflection these <em>yamim noraim</em>. One way to reflect this year is to take a few moments before Yom Kippur to ask yourself, “how might someone three generations from now judge my life?”</p><p><a href="#_ftnref1">[1]</a> For details of Witherspoon’s relationship to slavery, see <a href="https://slavery.princeton.edu/stories/john-witherspoon.">https://slavery.princeton.edu/stories/john-witherspoon.</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=856181f82155" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Ger Tzedek: The Righteous Convert]]></title>
            <link>https://rabbijustus.medium.com/ger-tzedek-the-righteous-convert-956edd4ab7?source=rss-d5a78496c308------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/956edd4ab7</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[jewish]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ger]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[conversion]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Justus Baird]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 26 May 2020 14:04:00 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-05-26T14:17:02.748Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/303/0*_gP1bEHlJwapOEtT.jpg" /></figure><p><strong>Ger Tzedek: The Righteous Convert</strong></p><p>The life of Count Valentin Potocki (who was called the Ger Tzedek after his death) was a remarkable break in the “monotonous course of the Jews’ economic struggle in Vilna” in the mid-18th century.<a href="https://mail.google.com/mail/u/1/#m_1688307838045126722__ftn1">[1]</a> As a young man, Potocki left Poland to study in Paris with his friend Zaremba. There they befriended an old Jew who studied Hebrew books in his wine shop. The stories of the Jewish wine merchant interested Potocki and Zaremba so much that they persuaded him to teach them Hebrew. He taught them about Judaism as well, and they were so impressed that they vowed to relinquish their Roman Catholic religion and one day convert to Judaism.</p><p>From Paris, Zaremba returned to Poland and married the daughter of a rich nobleman. Count Potocki moved to Rome, where his resolve to convert only strengthened. A few years later they decided to follow through on their promise to the Jewish wine shop merchant. Zaremba and his wife met Potocki in Amsterdam and all three were accepted into the Jewish faith. Potocki took on the name Abraham ben Abraham.</p><p>Potocki returned to Poland and wandered from place to place until his identity was discovered, almost by accident, in a townlet some miles from Vilna (Ilye). While studying in a <em>Beit Midrash</em>, Potocki was disturbed by a noisy little boy who refused to leave or be quiet. Potocki took the boy by the ear and put him outside. He remarked that such a misbehaved boy could not be a real Jewish child and would probably be baptized. The boy ran to his father, a tailor, and told him what had happened. The tailor, outraged by Potocki’s jab at his own religious fidelity, went to the local squire and betrayed Potocki’s identity as a proselyte.</p><p>Potocki fled to a village inn a few miles away. The innkeeper, afraid of harboring a wanted man, gave Potocki up to the squire’s servants. Potocki was put in shackles and taken to Vilna, where he was tortured in the hope that he would return to Christianity. Neither entreaties by friends and family nor a long imprisonment could persuade Potocki to recant. Legend relates that Potocki’s mother was able to acquire a pardon for him, but by the time she brought it to the jail, it was too late. Potocki was burned alive on the second day of Pentecost, May 24, 1749. The Jewish community remained indoors during the event to avoid community persecution. One exception was Leiser Zhiskes (a Jew) who, in an effort to obtain the martyr’s ashes, shaved his beard, dressed as a Christian, and bribed the executioner.</p><p>Although Potocki died at the stake, the story of the Ger Tzedek did not. Legend relates that as Potocki was being arrested, he uttered a curse that the tattle-tale tailor and his descendants for ten generations should not be spared some affliction. A visitor to the tailor’s townlet (Ilye) in 1930 reported that “all the descendants of the tailor had some physical defect: they were either deaf, dumb or lame, although the duration of the curse had about expired.”<a href="https://mail.google.com/mail/u/1/#m_1688307838045126722__ftn2">[2]</a> It is also told that from the place where the Count’s ashes were buried grew “a vigorous tree almost in the form of a man, with outstretched branches resembling hands and feet, which drew vast pilgrimages of Jews.”<a href="https://mail.google.com/mail/u/1/#m_1688307838045126722__ftn3">[3]</a> Later the Jewish authorities erected an iron shed over the grave and added a Hebrew inscription, but the grave has been repeatedly vandalized throughout history. Today the Ger Tzedek lies in the old cemetery in Vilna, not far from the tomb of the Gaon Elijah.</p><p>The life of the Ger Tzedek has been remembered in many ways. One author in 1992 recalls “my father telling me of going to the grave of the Ger Zedek on the Count’s yarhzeit and saying kaddish with a large group of Vilna’s Jews who came yearly to honor his memory.”<a href="https://mail.google.com/mail/u/1/#m_1688307838045126722__ftn4">[4]</a> Another describes how the rabbi of the main synagogue in Vilna memorialized the Ger Tzedek, whose yartzeit falls during Shavuot. “Rabbi Hirsh Levinson would interrupt the rejoicing on Shavuot to relate how Abraham ben Abraham Potocki became a Jew and how he died for the sanctification of His name on the day of the giving of the Torah.”<a href="https://mail.google.com/mail/u/1/#m_1688307838045126722__ftn5">[5]</a> The story of the Ger Tzedek has been recorded in books<a href="https://mail.google.com/mail/u/1/#m_1688307838045126722__ftn6">[6]</a> and even a play that was performed in Warsaw and America in the 1920s.<a href="https://mail.google.com/mail/u/1/#m_1688307838045126722__ftn7">[7]</a> But perhaps the best way to remember the Ger Tzedek is by one of his teachings. He is reported to have taught:</p><blockquote>…when God offered the Torah to the nations of the world and they refused to accept it, there were individuals among them who were prepared to receive the Law; from them descended converts whose souls were present at Mount Sinai.<a href="https://mail.google.com/mail/u/1/#m_1688307838045126722__ftn8">[8]</a></blockquote><p>(<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abraham_ben_Abraham">Additional details at Wikipedia</a>. Here is an <a href="http://strangeside.com/convert-avraham-the-convert-of-vilna/">additional version of his story.</a>)</p><p><a href="https://mail.google.com/mail/u/1/#m_1688307838045126722__ftnref1">[1]</a> The life and legends of the Ger Tzedek are told in part in Cohen, Israel, Vilna. (1992). This quotation is on p.73. Various parts of the story are related on pp.73–4, 416, and 484–6. The Ger Tzedek story related here is taken from Cohen’s work except as noted otherwise.</p><p><a href="https://mail.google.com/mail/u/1/#m_1688307838045126722__ftnref2">[2]</a> Cohen’s Vilna, p.485, attributed to A. Litvin in Jeshurin, E., Zammelbuch pp.841–7.</p><p><a href="https://mail.google.com/mail/u/1/#m_1688307838045126722__ftnref3">[3]</a> Cohen’s Vilna, p.74.</p><p><a href="https://mail.google.com/mail/u/1/#m_1688307838045126722__ftnref4">[4]</a> Hautzig, Ester, in introduction to Cohen’s Vilna, p. xxiii.</p><p><a href="https://mail.google.com/mail/u/1/#m_1688307838045126722__ftnref5">[5]</a> Goodman, Phillip, The Shavuot Anthology. p.237.</p><p><a href="https://mail.google.com/mail/u/1/#m_1688307838045126722__ftnref6">[6]</a> Cohen writes in Vilna p.486 that the text of the legend was printed in Prussia in 1862, and a Polish translation exists from 20 years earlier. The Ger Tzedek story was also discovered by pupils of Abraham Goldfaden (1840–1908) in the search for Jewish heroes (see From Mesopotamia to Modernity, p.251).</p><p><a href="https://mail.google.com/mail/u/1/#m_1688307838045126722__ftnref7">[7]</a> The play, <em>Der Dukus</em> was written by Alter Kacizne and performed in Warsaw in 1925 and afterwards in America. Shipley, Joseph, Encyclopedia of Literature. (1946) p.1043 and Cohen’s Vilna p.486.</p><p><a href="https://mail.google.com/mail/u/1/#m_1688307838045126722__ftnref8">[8]</a> Shavuot Anthology, p.237.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=956edd4ab7" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>