<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by RB on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by RB on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@raghu.bhaskaran?source=rss-f6d757e3687b------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sat, 21 Nov 2026 19:00:32 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@raghu.bhaskaran/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Hudaybiyyah — Published Pragyata]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@raghu.bhaskaran/hudaybiyyah-published-pragyata-bbbb1d242d1a?source=rss-f6d757e3687b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/bbbb1d242d1a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[islam]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[RB]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 29 Aug 2018 22:44:04 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-08-29T22:52:11.383Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><a href="http://www.pragyata.com/mag/the-treaty-of-hudaybiyyah-571">The Treaty of Hudaybiyyah</a></p><p>They were a rich and prosperous people, proud of their ways. They worshipped many gods, many people came to their places, bringing ideas and trading wealth.</p><p>One of them, took some of these ideas and set himself up as a Godman, but his ideas required abuse, insult, denial and violence upon other ideas and gods.</p><p>So the people of his city, threw him and his followers out, for they were strong at that point. Then they made a mistake, they made a treaty with him, for a peace lasting 10 years. And went back to their lives, meanwhile the Godman became a Warlord and gathered strength.<br>Under the protection of the treaty, he and his followers even went back and made a dashing pilgrimage, among the people of his enemies.</p><p>Then a private fracas between his allied tribe and tribe associated with his enemies, gave him a pretext — a technicality, to break the treaty and invade. The enemies fell.</p><p>And the god of this warlord, gave him a revelation called “The Victory”, after this treaty. It is aptly named, for when the people of diversity, plurality make a treaty with the intolerant, the intransigent, the fanatic — it is indeed a victory for the fanatic.</p><p>The Treaty of Hudaybiyyah.</p><p>And this event has been the basis of Islamic treaty making throughout history. All treaties, ceasefires, truces signed by an Islamic party on one side and non-Islamic party on another, is a victory for Islam.</p><p>For all it means is the non-Islamic side does not have the grit to fight, they are not willing to die, to kill for their cause and in the name of peace, are willing to yield to Islam. <br>Which is but a step to eventual Islamic take over. <br>And Allah is ok with this, making a treaty which Islam intends to break at the first convenient moment, irrespective of the treaty terms. Because Allah has given them victory over all polytheists and disbelievers, honest intentions are not required while making such treaties.</p><p>There are breaches of trusts, treaties, in the histories of other cultures as well. The British were particularly adept in using technicalities and earned the reputation of ‘Perfidious Albion’. But such is never set as an ideal. However in Islam, the life of Muhammed is the ideal to follow. That makes all the difference.</p><p>* Did Rani Meenakshi know about this story, when she believed Chanda Sahib, as he swore on the Quran to keep the peace? <br><a href="https://www.facebook.com/photo.php?fbid=10155424010771697&amp;set=a.10152861119466697&amp;type=3&amp;fref=mentions&amp;__xts__%5B0%5D=68.ARB7d4yljP88X6FSCvwm5L4MFIWKznlZuiotDjqOsjrP40sFOqs7Kw7IdYnF9HL5u5LZE3XvmIGv_af0jVAmANJx18Kq1Sq-169DrWCbMFH8CkauTJJjUr4t7xXlmepOfSPURAA&amp;__tn__=K-R">https://www.facebook.com/photo.php?fbid=10155424010771697&amp;set=a.10152861119466697.1073741826.617091696&amp;type=3&amp;theater</a></p><p>* Did PrithviRaj Chauhan know about this story, after he defeated Muhammad Ghori and let him go?</p><p>* Did Aliya Rama Raya know about this story, when he adopted Ali Adil Shah as his foster son?</p><p>* Did Indira Gandhi know about Hudaybiyyah, when she let 90000 prisoners of war go, without settling the borders once and for all?</p><p>* Does Duterte know about such treaties, when he agrees to a Muslim Autonomous Region in Southern Philippines?</p><p>Supposedly after Arafat signed the Oslo accords, unhappy Muslims were angry with him and in a press conference, he just said ‘Hudaybiyyah’ and the protests died down. For the entire Muslim world immediately realized that he was not planning to honour the accords, but simply was waiting to breach them to his advantage. Yet the western world had no idea of what it meant.</p><p>I don’t blame Muslims for being treaty breakers. Because they have always made their intentions clear.</p><p>It is the others who refuse to hear the Muslims, who keep thinking that making such accommodations will bring peace, that such treaties will be honoured.</p><p>From Quran to the local Mullah, they keep saying their intention is to make everyone dhimmi or dead.</p><p>As I wrote as an introduction to this post, <a href="https://l.facebook.com/l.php?u=https%3A%2F%2Fmedium.com%2F%40raghu.bhaskaran%2Fthe-intransigent-and-the-indians-10f13fe9afc7&amp;h=AT3X_uQ7hUVoExTc3WuIBd7BSB7ptq85e4xQsz80o28L5uD9_79gx8D_s-o-e43OWq_9MDIJCEGq39ttFUyXpVNTLB1qjTsVzsf7mLfAr6oTzm2nuZXaNm7HS_-IsIirESty1o7LbMQhoFB-VD1qHu-QqakmyWyMjZhZvcCKADbwG8a17J-EBr41j1rbYcAuykL_st1jYYt_uH3kLLbowJBSzDkOuum_Affocny-7Zt_B_5e9OZf2pLG2D9_imhdjVha3uHDhgLB982UiuKm4KLhLncDZP_1BvAgNtmBDGjB9jQf8KtKJR9Z_S6NcuPmMFV5VhNo0GUO8G52LMz90Vxkp5g">https://medium.com/…/the-intransigent-and-the-indians-10f13…</a><br>// For with Communism, Islam and Christianity — there is no compromise with the “other”, the end game is total and universal monopoly of thought. Across centuries -the occasional truce, peacetime or even push-backs are just temporary, in their march towards the Armageddon, the Apocalypse, the Al-Qayamat or the blood on the streets revolution. Witting, unwitting, active, passive, dormant, dogmatic — does not matter, the dogma corrodes civilization, cultures and humanity. //</p><p>Yet we refuse to listen, we think they also just care for a decent life, we think they can be bought, negotiated or reasoned with. But to paraphrase, ‘Some ideologies just want the world to burn’. <br>We rest on temporary victories, ignore to secure our borders, We think they will be grateful to join our prosperous societies, We think they won’t harm us because we share an ancestry.</p><p>Under the name of ‘humanity’, host the enemies of humanity<br>Under the name of ‘tolerance’, welcome the intolerant<br>Calling ourselves ‘inclusive’, include the ‘exclusive’</p><p>No it was not Muhammed or Islam to blame, but the Quraysh of Mecca. And like Quraysh we will fall, if we don’t listen to Muslims.</p><p>Funny thing, Fiberals Seculars keep crying that Muslims don’t have a voice, but it is them who are incapable of hearing what Islam preaches.</p><p>Does Rajiv Malhotra know about Hudaybiyyah?</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=bbbb1d242d1a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Barbarika blocked — Published Indiafacts]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@raghu.bhaskaran/barbarika-should-not-fight-indiafacts-pending-1e9892ff4913?source=rss-f6d757e3687b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/1e9892ff4913</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[left-wing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[naxalism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[RB]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 29 Aug 2018 21:38:34 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-08-30T21:04:40.552Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><a href="http://indiafacts.org/barbarika-should-never-be-allowed-to-fight/">Barbarika should never be allowed to fight | IndiaFacts</a></p><p>Recently a naxal sympathizer tweeted, in the context of raids and arrests of Urban Naxals.</p><p>“ Naxal movements have used <strong>violence</strong> — this is undeniable. But what is often lost in the analysis is this — the <strong>violence</strong> of the powerful cannot be equated to the <strong>violence</strong> of the <strong>powerless</strong>.”</p><p>Now power comes in many forms.</p><p>An ordinary citizen with a car, home and dreams for his children, would not be considered powerful, when compared against a landless, poor naxal who is willing to die or kill in the aforesaid citizen. The naxal can threaten and extort monies from that citizen.</p><p>Who is powerful and who is powerless in this context?</p><p>It is a great power, to be uncaring of social contracts and civil discourse, to act without considering repercussions of one’s actions, without considering the impact upon others.</p><p>If the abject personal circumstances is an excuse to visit violence upon others, then the constant churn in that circumstances means there would be no end to such violence.</p><p>A future tyranny of today’s dispossessed will be no less a burden, than the current tyranny of today’s privileged.</p><p>So then will the naxal sympathizers, fight for the newly dispossessed. Is there an end to that back and forth, except with the destruction of everyone?</p><p>Which brings us to Barbarika.</p><p>Barbarika was the grandson of Bhima, the son of Ghatothkacha. Upon the advent of the battle at Kurukshetra, he wants to fight alongside his father and grandfather, and his mother is unwilling. So to mollify her, he makes a commitment that if he fights, he would fight with the underdog, the disadvantaged side of the battle.</p><p>Barbarika like our Naxal sympathizers made the commitment based on the poor understanding of the dynamics of power, instead of making the commitment based on the righteousness of the cause — dharma.</p><p>So for Dharma came Krishna, <em>Yatho dharmaha:thatha Krishna</em></p><p>Krishna tested the powers of Barbarika and his infallible baan and was impressed, then asks whom Barbarika would favour in the war. Barbarika reveals that he intends to fight for the side whichever is weak. As the Pandavas have only seven Akshauhinis armies compared to the eleven of the Kauravas, he would fight for the Pandavas.</p><p>Krishna then reveals the actual consequences of his commitment,</p><p>Whichever side Barbarika supports, will end up making the other side weaker. Hence, as he will be forced switch sides to support the other side that has become weaker. So, he will keep oscillating between two sides, thereby destroying the entire army of both sides and eventually only he would remain.</p><p>Which serves no purpose and is a fool’s pursuit.</p><p>Barbarika understands the paradox he is caught in and agrees to sacrifice himself to neutralize his commitment to fight for the disadvantaged. And remains a mere witness to the Dharmayuddha.</p><p>It is natural for any of us to feel sympathy with the poor, the dispossessed and the disadvantaged, but that should not be confused with doing what is dharma. Advantages and disadvantages are relative, will keep changing. They are not consistent either, one person with advantage in one aspect of life, will be disadvantaged in another.</p><p>If confused people justify that adharma and violence are ok, if exercised on behalf of the contextually powerless, and seek to damage the society with that excuse, they should indeed be neutralized.</p><p>There were feminists who claimed that, if some innocent men are ruined by the #MeToo movement, then that is an acceptable collateral damage. They are no less criminals than actual rapists. And it is dharma to neutralize them.</p><p>And in this case, there are Naxalites, who may not directly perpetrate violence, but enable it - excuse it by claiming, that violence by the powerless (in a sense), is somehow less of an issue, than the violence by the powerful (in a sense). But would that matter to the victim of the violence?</p><p>The same narrative has been used by the Colonial apologists, that colonization by Britain was not as bad as say colonization by Belgium in Congo. Maybe, but would that matter to the dead in Jalianwala Bagh or the occupants of Kalapani?</p><p>Reductionists narratives like, the rich can do no good, all men are rapists, all women are victims, the poor can do no wrong — are like the commitment made by Barbarika.</p><p>While in Mahabharatha, Barbarika had the good sense to realize his mistake and sacrifice himself. In the present day, such Urban Naxals and Naxal apologists have grown so strong and headstrong, that they have to be forcibly neutralized.</p><p>This does not mean that there is not sympathy for the state of the poor and dispossessed, but to address that is to fight poverty and enable opportunity (not equality).</p><p>Barbarikas should not be allowed to fight.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=1e9892ff4913" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Dharma of diet — Published Pragyata]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@raghu.bhaskaran/dharma-of-diet-pragyata-published-3b523e950554?source=rss-f6d757e3687b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/3b523e950554</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[vegetarian]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[dharma]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[vegan]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[RB]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 29 Aug 2018 21:32:06 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-08-30T21:05:12.699Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><a href="http://www.pragyata.com/mag/dharma-of-diet-576">Dharma of Diet</a></p><h3>Dharma and Mamsa</h3><ul><li>Many Hindus eat meat, yet ahimsa and vegetarianism are considered as noble ideals.</li><li>Hindus have practiced polygamy, child marriage etc., but always consider monogamous commitment to a spouse with swatantra, as the ideal state.</li><li>Hindus have mistreated womenfolk and happening still, but to treat them well, is always considered a virtue.</li><li>Hindus have discriminated against people from different strata of the society, but to raise beyond the duality of worldly affairs and realize the essential Brahman pervading/permeating us all, is considered Jnana</li></ul><p>And many more such cases.</p><p>To the liberal intellectuals who selectively smear only Hinduism, these are all signs of hypocrisy.</p><p>But it is hardly so, the theme of Dharma is about ‘aspiration’, to set the goals for people to evolve towards.</p><p>For example:<br>A meat eater is recommended to avoid it, initially on one day of the week, then have it only once a week , over time entirely avoid and so on.</p><p>Similarly for different activities for different contexts.</p><p>The Shastras do not compromise on the virtues or ideals — end goals, but give flexibility in how each person evolves towards it.</p><p>A very apt quote of Vinoba in this context “ There can be a gap between desired goal and reality, but there should not be a contradiction between a goal and one’s acts.”</p><p>Ravana for all his greatness is still considered morally wrong and evil, for the choices he made.</p><p>But there are ideologies which impose a different set of end goals for different groups of peoples.Believers vs. non-believers primarily.</p><p>Rape and murder, are always crimes, even if the doer was Indra himself. They do not become non-crimes, if the victims were non-believers.</p><p>Punishments can be contextual, that is another complaint. Even if the crime is the same, it is foolish to apply the same punishment to all. A homeless vagrant in harsh weather, would be happy to be housed in a jail. A rich guy would be happy to pay fixed fines for breaking traffic rules.</p><p>Hindus have many flaws, but Hindu Dharma does not, I claim this not because it is a divine revelation, but because it is ever contextual, while divinely essential.<br>In fact static divine revelations not contextual to evolving social contexts, is the cause of much agony to the world.</p><p>Nothing expresses this better than two acts of Krishna.</p><ul><li><strong>Sambhavaami Yugeyuge:</strong> He knew that divine would have to revisit us again and again, in different avatars and makes that promise. Contrast this with “I am/this is the final, full and perfect revelation and anyone claiming divinity/Prophethood henceforth, is a charlatan. If you all don’t obey, then I will destroy the world.”</li><li><strong>Yatha Icchasi Thatha Kuru:</strong> That he ends Bhagavad Gita 18.63, asking Arjuna and therefore us, to consider all he has revealed and do as we see fit. Leaving the choice to us, instead of commandments or literal word, which can’t even be interpreted.</li></ul><p>This open framework has its risks, but it also prevents dogmatic zealotry.</p><p><strong>The importance of context and definition.</strong><br>Presstitutes claiming India is non-vegetarian based on statistics.</p><p>Example the Quint:<br>“Over 70% Indians Are Non-Vegetarian, Most Meat Eaters in Kerala”</p><p>So let’s look at definition first, Wiki for example says<br>“Non-vegetarian is an Indian English word that is used to refer to a person who is not a vegetarian i.e. someone who consumes meat, especially as a major source of protein”</p><p>Now look at the statistics,<br>“However, around 80 percent of Indian men and 70 percent of women consume eggs, fish, chicken or meat <strong>‘occasionally, if not weekly’, </strong>according to an IndiaSpend analysis of national health data. But their <strong>‘daily diet’</strong> tends to be vegetarian, consisting of milk or curd, pulses or beans and dark green and leafy vegetables,<br>Overall, 42.8 percent Indian women and 48.9 percent men consumed fish, chicken or meat weekly, according to the National Family Health Survey, 2015–16 (NFHS-4).</p><p>So now is meat/seafood, the major source of protein for Indians, if 70–80% of them consume it occasionally and weekly?</p><p>Per these statistics,<br>- 80% of the people consume meat only 2% of the time:<br>- 80% of the people consume vegetarian food 98% of the time;<br>- 20% of the people consume vegetarian food 100% of the time;</p><p>Yet the media calls India as a non-vegetarian nation.</p><p>If I were to apply this impressive lack of statistical analysis to other things,<br>- India is a Christian nation.<br>- India is a Communist nation<br>- India is ruled by Congress.<br>and so forth.</p><p>So if someone claims that India is a ‘non-vegetarian’ nation based on such numbers, then they can also be considered ‘non-idiotic’ people, for even they would have one bright idea, every other year.</p><p>But then this is the same thing media does with rapes and crimes against woman. Exaggerates and misrepresents statistics, hides the analysis behind emotional appeals and outrageous claims.</p><p>At an individual level, if a person consumes meat even occasionally, he/she can indeed claim to be non-vegetarian.</p><p>But the context matters, when looking at statistical numbers to categorize the society, it is nonsensical to use the far lesser number, to broad brush an entire nation.</p><p>And the reason they do this, is to protest BJP government’s efforts to promote vegetarianism. The argument is that India is highly non-vegetarian and the government is imposing ideology upon the people.</p><p>But as the statistics they quote themselves prove, the government is actually more in tune with the people, than the media.</p><p>Besides, irrespective of the current numbers, the government should nudge the people towards the future and that future should be determined by the ideology of the party elected — economic, cultural and social ideologies.</p><p>In that sense, the move towards vegetarianism makes eminent sense, giving the environmental challenges due to livestock breeding and industrial meat farming.</p><p>I hope India never gets to be like the US, which in the past 50 years has gone from having meat once a week, to having meat in every meal, causing massive damage to the ecology, health and lifestyle.</p><p>The values of Hindu Dharma, inculcated to inspire people to incrementally reduce their consumption of meat — barring one day of the week, only once a week, only on special occasions, less as you age, never bovines, only eggs, only seafood etc., is perfectly aligned to the future we must seek for the health of the environment.</p><p>The government should indeed nudge and encourage such maturity in diet.</p><p><strong>Rama did, so I will</strong></p><p>Rama, Durga, Shiva are all said to be meat eaters in Puranas and Itihaasaas, so why can’t we? I suppose, we should be glad that people are reading these literature at least to scrounge such justifications. But the problem is we are not Rama, Durga or Shiva. Shiva would even quaff the Halaahalaa poisons and remain unaffected, any volunteers to emulate that?. It is not the exact dietary customs we should imbibe from these legends, but values of dharma.</p><p>And that was my response to this question,</p><p><strong><em>When Ram and Krishna being a Kshatriya ate animals, &amp; hunted them in forest for training, why their followers are instructed to be a Veggie?</em></strong></p><p><strong>Answer:</strong><br>There are no instructions, but only recommendations. And if at all there is an instruction, then it is “know and follow your dharma”.</p><p>Our heritage never imposes a “set in stone” rule, that everyone should follow in all times. That is Christianity and Islam. Dharma is highly contextual, it depends on the “Kala, Desa, Varna, ashrama etc”</p><p>So what is right for Rama, may not be right for Krishna and what is wrong for me, may be right for you.</p><p>A good example is Dharmavyadha, a butcher was held a BrahmaGyani. Because he had achieved the state of Brahman, the karma of this world did not affect him — there was no “him”.</p><p>So unless I have achieved such a state, I don’t want vasanas tainting and adding to my karma. Today, I do not need to kill/cause animals to be killed, to sustain myself or do my duty. But if tomorrow, I am in a situation, where animal protein is the only option for me to meet my dietary needs to perform my worldly duty. I will eat meat, to do so is my Dharma.</p><p>But until then, for me to eat meat when alternatives are available, merely for indulging in my sense of taste, is adharmic.</p><p>Some families traditionally had professions, which required consuming animal protein. So that might have become a lifestyle. But they also should reassess their needs and evolve out of the habit slowly.</p><p>Until we evolve to photosynthesize, we have to kill something or other — plants, to survive. But while doing so, we should try to obtain nutrition in the with ‘ least impact’ to the world.</p><p>It could be fruit instead of seed, seed instead of plant, plant instead of fish, fish instead of mammals, other mammals instead of bovines, other bovines instead of cows and so on.</p><p>Impact is determined by many factors.</p><ul><li>If a being is endangered-scarce in numbers, then NO, even if it is plant.</li><li>If a being can’t reproduce/regenerate easily, then NO. If a being can feed more of us, then better than one that can’t.</li></ul><p>Eggs are better than the hen, itself and so on. To understand these factors, is to know Dharma. Don’t read it as though I am recommending to eat eggs :(.</p><p>No, the recommendation is to understand your needs, the availability and picking the optimum solution.</p><p>We do not know what was the optimum solution for Rama and Krishna, but given the honour accorded to them, we can assume that they picked whatever was the most optimum — Dharmic solution available to them at any point.</p><p>That is what we should be followers of and not the specific diet or other stuff.</p><p>We can’t and shouldn’t follow them literally, without applying our own contexts to it. For example, for a diabetic, eating sweetmeats would be adharmic.</p><p>So mimicking Rama is ok, if mimicked in all his acts. If I try even an ordinary bow and arrow, forget Shiva Dhanus or Kodanda, I probably would end up shooting myself in the foot.</p><p>Besides, dismissing Ramayana as fiction, for issues like Ayodhya JanmaSthan and then use it as justification to stuff oneself with beef, that is just hypocrisy.</p><p>If the arguments of meat-lovers are thus wobbly, there are the fanatic vegans at the other end of the spectrum. They would interpret everything in Hindu legendarium as ‘Vegetarian’, they make Tofurkey out of all the meat.</p><p>Not just vegetarianism, but veganism is a required in the present day context, but that is not to be achieved by means of dishonesty and misinterpreting the legends.</p><p>When it comes to lifestyle and dietary consumption, the ‘truth’ to be learnt from Itihaasaas and puranas, is not that ‘Rama or other avatars, did or did not eat meat’, but that they consumed what is optimal to their contexts.</p><p>They consumed it with a sense of trusteeship, for they were the upholders of a worldview which sees this world, the nature — prakriti, as Chaitanya, the divine permeating it all and considers ourselves as trustees. Hence the tree, the river, the stone and the animals, are all worshiped and treated with care, even as their products are used to better our lives.</p><p>And then there are other worldviews, where the divine is a remote Sky Daddy, laying out ultimatums and demanding total allegiances, in it the world and its creatures are meant for the man to exploit, animals are merely food.</p><p>So when we indulge in meat, diary or anything, what is the attitude we take towards it, that of Rama, Shiva or that of the desert cults?</p><p>Today, most of our lifestyles, make it unnecessary and even dangerous to indulge in meat or diary products. There are cases like soldiers, sportsmen, hard labourers, specific sadhanas which would need the use of mamsa, but otherwise, it is an indulgence.<br>Both to personal health and to the health of the environment. The diary and meat farming industry, is disastrous to the ecology. And our consumption keeps making it worse.</p><p>So it is dharmic for us, to reduce our intake slowly and for that the Shastras show the way. Make meat a dish for special occasions, ensure you buy the meat from native breeds and farms, instead of mass produced poultry or meat. Avoid the cruelty of Halal meat.Milk products as well, the value of calcium goes down beyond an age, so can be reduced.</p><p>Dharma would be know all these and to follow what is optimal to our contexts.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=3b523e950554" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Heena and the Hijab — Published Pragyata]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@raghu.bhaskaran/heena-and-the-hijab-pragyata-published-fc77e6a99268?source=rss-f6d757e3687b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/fc77e6a99268</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[hinduism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[christianity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cultural-appropriation]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[RB]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 29 Aug 2018 21:26:53 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-08-30T21:05:48.317Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><a href="http://www.pragyata.com/mag/heena-and-the-hijab-572">Heena and the Hijab</a></p><p>Recently, a program called “The Musical Confluence of Jesus” was being advertised, where the Carnatic Vidwan O.S. Arun was supposed to perform Carnatic Krithis (Compositions) in praise of Jesus. This triggered protests, on and off the social media, from the fan base of Carnatic music and others. Subsequently, O.S. Arun backed out for the program citing ‘personal commitments’. This brought to light many earlier cases, where popular Carnatic musicians including O.S. Arun, Nithyashree, Aruna Sairam had performed for Christian Albums.</p><p>The Wire published <a href="https://thewire.in/communalism/in-tamil-nadu-non-hindu-carnatic-musicians-are-being-othered">an article</a> alleging communalism and intolerance, as expected of its bias and inclinations, with some Brahmin Bashing thrown in. I had anticipated many of the allegations and arguments made by ‘The Wire’ and had addressed them in the past weeks. This commentary consolidates those perspectives.</p><p>To summarize, it is the question of <strong>‘Heena and the Hijab’,</strong></p><p><em>How much of your own identity, would you compromise to perform for an ideology, which seeks the destruction of your heritage?</em></p><p>The shooter Heena Sidhu <a href="https://www.indiatoday.in/sports/other-sports/story/heena-sidhu-asian-airgun-championship-iran-shooting-349165-2016-10-29">refused to wear a Hijab</a>, required by Iran, which she felt as compromising her identity and was admired for her stand. But O.S. Arun wore a crucifix, wiped off his usual Bhasma, Tilaka and performed Carnatic Krithis praising Christ. (<a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IMHHxYoM8kE">Video</a>). Other singers have acted in a similar manner and also performed plagiarized versions of classical <em>krithis</em>, where the themes and terms used to adore Rama or Shiva, have been replaced with Jesus. So we must consider what is an appropriate adoption and what is cultural appropriation, or rather in the context of Christianity, — inculturation.</p><p>Wikipedia defines inculturation as follows:</p><blockquote><em>In Christianity, inculturation is the adaptation of the way Church teachings are presented to non-Christian cultures and, in turn, the influence of those cultures on the evolution of these teachings. This is a term that is generally used by Roman Catholics, the World Council of Churches and some Protestants, other Protestants prefer to use the term “contextual theology”.</em></blockquote><p>From the Hindu perspective, this is cultural appropriation, that is taking of things that are holistically and intrinsically part of the Hindu worldview, culture and using them to propagate Christianity, leading to the eventual proselytization.</p><p>Temple architecture — Dwajastambas, Gopuras, Samskaras like Vidyarambham, Annapraasanas, wearing of saffron robes, <em>rudrakshas</em>, arts like Bharathanatya, literature like Sahasranama, Calling bible as Veda, church as Devalaya, Jesus as Devan etc. many aspects of Hindu dharma have been appropriated by the Christians as a part of this inculturation mission. There have been attempts to even digest the Devatas and Shastras, like presenting Prajapati’s <em>yagna</em>, as the metaphor for the Christ’s sacrifice or depicting he author of a Shastra like Thirukkural, ThiruValluva Naayanaar, as a disciple of Thomas.</p><p>So is such dishonest portrayal objectionable or not?</p><p>It can be seen as an attempt to Indianize Christianity and integrate. In fact, Indian Islam is often accused of not doing that and instead, of trying to Arabize itself. Indonesian Islam, which has retained its Hindu cultural indicators, is held up as an example worthy of emulation.</p><p>It is true that most Indian Christians are Hindu in their origins and hence it can be argued that, they only rejected the Devata, Shashtras, and Dharma of Hinduism and not the cultural expressions. It can also be argued that Sanskrit is a language, Carnatic a musical style, why can’t they be used to describe another subject? Another deity? I think these are valid points to consider. There is indeed nothing objectionable in using these external expressions towards another faith, another god.</p><p>But the key word here is ‘ANOTHER’.</p><p>What if these things are done by those, who don’t accept that they are just ‘ANOTHER’, but insists that they are the ‘ONLY’? Let us look at a relatable analogy. When young kids play cricket, each brings different pieces of equipment and pool it. Bats, some balls, stumps, pads etc. Everyone freely uses the equipment irrespective of who spent the money to purchase it. Each kid follows favorite teams, sports stars etc., collect equipment developed for the star, branded or signed by the star etc. All good. Then there are one or two kids, who keep claiming that others are wrong in how they play, deny the legitimacy of their favorite sports stars like Tendulkar and constantly disparage team affiliations etc. Yet these kids use such branded equipment, even as they refuse to acknowledge the ownership, association or origin of the equipment. And in the past they are known to have invaded other pitches and forced others to play by their rules, destroying the diversity of fan groups and even entire sports. Should such bullies, be trusted with the equipment of our heritage? What if the referees, umpires, and commentators i.e. Secular state, the left-liberal media etc., ignore such behaviors and insist that others give in to every demand of these perpetual ideological bullies? Would it be objectionable or not?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/900/0*QOIDLjJWH-UmmNjX.jpg" /></figure><p>[An advertisement for O.S. Arun’s “Christian” Concert]</p><p>I wonder if regional products can protect their products with GI tag — Geographic Indicators, Individuals/firms with Intellectual Property rights, Creators with Copyrights, Companies with Trademarks, why can’t cultures and religions be protected against inculturation or appropriation? And then there are the false claims. This advertisement for O.S. Arun concert claims that ‘Christian Keerthanas are many centuries old and indestructible in time’. Though there is a continuum to Indian classical music from Sama Veda, Bharata Shastra, and Sharngadeva, as a genre, Carnatic music is considered to have formulated from Purandaradasa in the 15th century. The Wire refers to Abrahama Pandithar (another semantic appropriation of the word Pandita) and he lived from 1859–1919. So how is it possible that Christian Keerthanas are claimed to be many centuries old? Perhaps they will go on to make the claim that Sharngadeva was a student of Simon and Purandaradasa of Peter. That is what they did with Thiruvalluvar, when they claimed him as a disciple of Thomas. Classic inculturation was at play.</p><p>It is not objectionable for artists to perform in praise of Jesus, it is only when they start compromising on their own beliefs, like removing tilaka and wearing the cross etc. that things become problematic. An actor could do that for playing the part of a devout Christian, but why would a musician compromise thus? What do we think of politicians who pander to the minority vote-banks by wearing skull caps or attending masses?</p><p>Of course, we know this is a one-way street. Christians and Muslims don’t usually compromise on their identities in such a way. It is only expected of Hindus because secularism is solely their responsibility and requires them to efface their identity, wipe the <em>tilakas</em> off their forehead, lest they offend the minorities.</p><p>Another example, in professional networking events in the west, often the only vegetarian food served is a salad and bread. Other attendees could look at you weirdly for refusing meat or alcohol. That’s an instance where one could compromise on one’s own identity and values, to fit in or for the sake of one’s career. But it is never considered ideal and for people like O.S. Arun to do so, in a native context is actually despicable. Unless he has converted, and if he has, then for him to sport a tilaka in his <em>kutcheris </em>is simply dishonest.</p><p>Dharma is nurtured only by our choices during conflicting priorities. From the days when composers like Swami Haridas and Thyagaraja refused even oblige great kings, citing that having sung for Devatas, they could not sing for <em>Manavas</em> (humans), the standards of integrity have indeed plummeted. Tansen was extremely talented but his integrity was compromised, for he compromised on his identity for professional fame. No surprise that he could never be what his Guru, Swami Haridas was, and it is believed that he himself acknowledged this fact.</p><p>Another aspect to this subject are people like Yesudas, Sheikh Chinna Moulana, Ustad Bismillah Khan etc., who perform for Hindu Devatas. But it is a false equivalence to compare them with what O.S Arun did, it is as false as comparing Hindu Dharma to Christianity or Islam. As earlier mentioned, unlike Christianity and Islam, which deny the ‘other’, Hindu dharma accepts the ‘other’. So they are not comparable. The exclusive nature of Christianity and Islam means that just the act of praising Jesus or Allah implies that you are denying, or even denigrating, other gods. Even if you do not explicitly do so, you are supporting activities which further this alienation. But for that exclusivity, God is just yet another god and Christianity yet another faith. And singing of Jesus is no different from singing to Rama or Shiva.</p><p>Hinduism is not based on a dogma that parts of it — Yoga, Ayurveda, Shilpa, Natya, Sangeetha — can be separated, secularized and sold as modular furniture. It is an interconnected whole. Secularism and inculturation are agendas, which seek to loot all the body parts of the culture, but will deny the living force itself and thus destroy it.</p><p>When I experience sublime art, I wonder at the divine that inspired such beauty even when I myself am unable to be inspired by it. This I do even with carols and qawwalis. But what to say of people who take the forms and expressions of such art, but deny the inspiration behind it, with visceral hatred? G.H.Hardy did not subscribe to Ramanujam’s belief that Namagiri Devi was the inspiration for his genius. But there is no record of him coercing Ramanujam to ‘change’ his inspiration to Jesus or claiming so after Ramanujam’s death. Ramanujam tried his best not to compromise on his identity or expressions, under very difficult circumstances. And that makes him even more admirable. But then G.H.Hardy was not a Christian.</p><p>For what Islam does by conflict, Christianity achieves by corruption. There are other ways to respect other traditions, without compromising on your own. Sri. Vittaldas Maharaj rendered ‘Iravinidam Kaiyendungal..’ a song popularly rendered by Nagore Hanifa praying to Allah, in his Bhajan program. It did not jar much because, in his repertoire of bhajans for Hari and many such devatas, this was one more song. He sang it wearing all the symbols of a devout Vaishnava, then it can be seen as invoking the universal divinity across forms and names. Though Islamists might feel affronted for including Allah along with other gods but they are not famous for their aesthetic admiration, are they? That performance was not an appropriation, inculturation or digestion. He <a href="https://youtu.be/RE9XTaWr7A8">sang</a> as a Vittal Bhaktha.</p><p>But if you wear a crucifix and participate in a program which is entirely about Jesus, though your heritage is seeing the divine in many forms and names, then you are furthering their agenda of exclusivity, letting them appropriate you and your culture for proselytizing. Hence The Wire makes a false equivalence between Vittaldas Maharaj and O.S. Arun.</p><p>Further, there is the economic argument that Carnatic music is a dwindling genre, so it is ok to dilute its essence to sell it to others. This is like saying adulterating food is okay to sell to a larger market. Will the Wire Columnist pitch that as well? Yes, Carnatic music, like any classical art form, is a niche field. It has thrived not because of market volume but because of a committed core fan base. Now it seems that folks like T.M. Krishna and O.S. Arun want to expand their base, even if it means compromising on the essential nature of the art and ignoring the Rasikas, who have fostered it for decades.</p><p>Political parties are known to adopt such market capturing strategies. The BJP, for example, has ignored its core Hindutva base for long, and chases other vote banks. Congress, after all, debased secularism into minority appeasement and pandering for decades and now half-heartedly pushes soft Hindutva through miserable attempts by the likes of Shashi Tharoor. This is similar to how commercial entities offer discounts and perks to new customers and ignore the loyalists. The calculation is that the rate of intake of new customers will be more than the loss of the old ones. So while that dynamic is inevitable, the question again is how much of your own essential identity are you willing to dilute, in return for success, before it turns out that you no longer have anything of value to offer?</p><p>The article in The Wire, while ranting against Right Wing (as though all Hindus are automatically Free market capitalists) intolerance, makes no mention of aspects like inculturation. So, when artists whose career was built by singing the compositions of great Bhakthi Saints like Thyagaraja, offer to sing for those people who abuse Rama and deny the divinity of Krishna, it is morally incumbent on the aware and alert Hindus to register their protests.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=fc77e6a99268" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Lost Child — Published MyIndMakers]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@raghu.bhaskaran/the-lost-child-published-myindmakers-81d1667abdbb?source=rss-f6d757e3687b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/81d1667abdbb</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[cultural-appropriation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[christianity]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[RB]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 29 Aug 2018 21:24:17 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-08-29T21:24:17.694Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><a href="https://www.myind.net/Home/viewArticle/some-civilizations-died-with-great-clamour-some-died-with-a-whimper-but-hindus-will-we-die-in-the-self-effacing-silence-of-secularism">Some civilizations died with great clamour, some died with a whimper, but Hindus - Will we die in the self-effacing silence of secularism?</a></p><p>One of my favorite short stories is Mulk Raj Anand’s ‘The Lost Child’</p><p>A little child who hankers for various things at a fair, but when it gets lost wants nothing but its parents.</p><p>Read the story here <a href="https://archive.org/stream/TheLostChild-English-MulkRajAnand/lostchild_djvu.txt">https://archive.org/stream/TheLostChild-English-MulkRajAnand/lostchild_djvu.txt</a></p><p>The imagery stayed with me and was meaningful in many ways.</p><p>For example, answering to the questions, <br>If God exists, and he has created this universe and life on Earth, what is his objective? What does he want with us (are we not his playthings then, created to amuse him)?</p><p>I referenced this story and answered,</p><p><em>Think of the game played by mothers with toddlers. The mother, she would hide her face with her hands and call out for the child. The child in a play room full of distractions will ignore her and be playing with other things, but will eventually seek her, search, hear her voice and signs, tumble and fumble it’s way, grab and pull apart her hands to reveal her face, the sheer joy both of them enjoy at that point is immeasurable. The divine peekaboo.</em></p><p><em>Now why should the mother do that — why hide, why play — she could always hold the child tightly in her embrace. Or rather why even have a child and all the trouble?</em></p><p><em>Simply because the mother too wants to experience the joy of this sport — the ‘leela’. And we, though we are a part of the mother, also play and get to experience the joy.</em></p><p><em>The mother is an analogy for Ishwara, who himself experiences this joy in all the roles. Of course it is for amusement, but there is no he and we, except due to our own ignorance. This Prakriti and Samsara — the world is the playroom.</em></p><p><em>And when people start asking ‘Why’, that is the start of the journey, where the child stops playing and starts seeking the mother, slowly it will cease to care about all the temptations and distractions, and will cry only for its parents.</em></p><p><em>Like the child in Mulk Raj Anand’s story.</em></p><p><em>The analogy can be extended further, though this leela is the same. The mothers, the playrooms, the children are a multitude.</em></p><p><em>The children rush into play, they create things, compete with each other, cooperate and play too. Sometimes they stumble and get hurt, or hurt each other, they cry in pain. Then the mothers soothe them, sometimes take them out of the play and put them back.</em></p><p><em>When some children get tired of the play and seeks its mother, who is hidden behind all the things which once were attractions, but are now distractions. Then also children also cry in frustration, but few remain steadfast in seeking the mother until they find her.</em></p><p><em>The times we cry out, are the times of our suffering, out of ignorance and frustration. The times we are taken out of play and put back, is Mrityu and Punarjanma. When we finally recognize and rush into the embrace, that is Moksha. And Ishwara craves our Moksha as a mother craving her child’s embrace, yet like any good parent, he lets us children go forth and adventure.</em></p><p><em>There would be no such joy if the child is never allowed to venture.</em></p><p>Yet it is very important for parents to equip the children with things they will need to find their way home. That is what culture, religion, philosophies are about. They equip us for our seeking.</p><p>A Christian told me that Hinduism is like huge shopping store and the children are being left unguided in the store, and hence they are confused lot. That is why she thinks the Abrahamic religions with their single choice is better.</p><p>And I said, well it entirely depends on the capacity of the child and intentions of the parents. I believe it is better for children to explore, face challenges and then seek out their way, rather than limiting them to a life limited to one dogma. It is possible that many children lose their way, yet the risk must be taken. Even when the child does not like it and cries, it is required of parents to prod it forth to explore.</p><p>Abrahamic religions can be considered as leashes which ensure that the children never get to explore beyond the limits of the dogma. The leash also expects all the children, should be tied to the single form of the mother.</p><p>That is a kind of parenting as well and we would not interfere, unless there is evident abuse.</p><p>So the leash — exclusivity by itself is not the problem. But when it combines with the insistence that every child should be thus leashed irrespective of the parenting, then it becomes a problem.</p><p>Supposing in the Mulk Raj Anand’s story, we introduce another character, a Missionary. And the Missionary follows the family as they go to the fair.</p><p>He hears the mother teaching the child, ‘Child, in the fair, you be distracted by many things and will get lost, playing with your friends, when you are tired and ready to be back, look for these signs and others who follow those signs, you will find your home then’</p><p>Know them by the music they make — Carnatic, Hindustani and such.</p><p>Know them by the dances — Bharathanatya, Kuchipudi, Kathak and such.</p><p>Know them by the philosophies — Various Darsanas like Vedanta.</p><p>Know them by the literature — Vedas, Puranas, Itihaasas, Smritis, Agamas etc.</p><p>Know them by the Bhakhti of the saints — Azhwars, Nayanmaars, Tulsidas, Jnaneshwar, Chaitanya, SankaraDeva, Narsi and Tukaram etc. and their compositions</p><p>Know them by the Samskaras — like Vidyarambha, Vivaha etc.</p><p>Know them by the temples built in different styles— of Dravida, Nagari, Hemadpanti and such.</p><p>And many more such things.</p><p>But above all know them by the gods — Hari, Shiva, Shakthi, Ganapathi, Skanda and many others. You will know them by their celebration of their Gods. Even those who are Advaita Vedantins, seeking the Nirguna Brahman, will not deny the devatas and their upasana. None will deny how the other worships or the gods worshiped — Nahi Ninda Nyaya.</p><p>Once you know them, you join them in the journey, pass on those cultural signs, create new ones for others to find.</p><p>That will enable the seeking in you, beyond wealth or success.</p><p>And the missionary was listening to all these conversations.</p><p>The child ventures forth and plays, and eventually realizes that he is missing his parents, and he looks for his people, as was taught to him.</p><p>And instead of the kind hearted man in the Mulk Raj Anand’s story, it is the Missionary who has prepared some traps for the child.</p><p>The child hears the familiar strains of Venkatesa Suprabatha. But as he listens he is confused, the words are strange and sound forced. He asks whether it is another version for another god?, They say, ‘No child this the Suprabatha for the only true god — Jesus!’</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FTisrJta2YkY%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DTisrJta2YkY&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FTisrJta2YkY%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="640" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/38764277eae35354f2a8e75e471350d9/href">https://medium.com/media/38764277eae35354f2a8e75e471350d9/href</a></iframe><p>He sees some people wearing the Saffron. They must be my people, he thinks and asks of them, for which god are you making this padyatra. They say, ‘Jesus’. He asks, is his like Rama or Shiva? They say, ‘No, those are all false gods, Jesus alone is the true son of God’.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/602/0*iBGrFZb-Wl8bgZ2V" /></figure><p>He then sees a Dwajastambha, before a building. He goes in and asks, they say ‘Here we pray to Jesus’, He says,’Like to Krishna?’, They respond, ‘Krishna is actually Christ, the Brahmins corrupted the name’.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*06wcFS2EjNHn3QxB.jpg" /></figure><p>Then he sees a temple in the style his parents had told him about. He asks, ‘Trinity — is it Brahma, Vishnu, Shiva?, but they say, ‘Those are demons, do not take their name in the house of the lord’.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/949/1*XxS8nek8b6gWqEMpTYC7Fw.png" /></figure><p>He sees another temple with Shivalinga, But the saffron clad priest tells him, ‘Shiva is actually only Jesus, but the Aryans corrupted the worship.’</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/523/1*axxsBft81aXCZbZB1bFWEA.png" /></figure><p>He hears the strains of a Carnatic Krithi, he follows the sound and hears the lyrics. It thoroughly confused him, a song declaring that there is no one equal to Jesus, he wondered if that is in the subjective context, similar to Thiyagaraja’s Krithi on Rama or Gopalakrishna Bharathi’s Krithi on Shiva Sabapathy. But no, they say, ‘Jesus alone is God with his father — absolutely and objectively.’</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2Fcsz-G8Y6Gk4%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3Dcsz-G8Y6Gk4&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2Fcsz-G8Y6Gk4%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/43f8dc49734ffbb809740e5858cdd9e1/href">https://medium.com/media/43f8dc49734ffbb809740e5858cdd9e1/href</a></iframe><p>He sees a familiar face in a video, a carnatic artist who sang on many stages, songs in devotion to Shiva, Shakthi and others. But now he was wearing a crucifix and singing of Jesus. He thinks, ‘Isn’t it only actors who wear costumes, according to the performance?’.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FIMHHxYoM8kE%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DIMHHxYoM8kE&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FIMHHxYoM8kE%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="640" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/e8b8da2f3425360863f1e11b7760f2e8/href">https://medium.com/media/e8b8da2f3425360863f1e11b7760f2e8/href</a></iframe><p>He sees a garden and people praying to a vigraha, and yet again it was Jesus. They call him a ‘Sinner’ and say that Jesus is the original Yogi.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/436/1*MWx1korlKkcfAm4swLEcFw.png" /></figure><p>He sees an announcement for a Upanishad Upanyasa and went in. But the lecturer is expounding upon Jesus as the true god of Upanishads, and that Aryans cheated people by misinterpreting them</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/620/1*ligYnQ_3gIAnEviTk3t-4Q.png" /></figure><p>And in another corner, they are chanting yet another familiar sounding Sthothra, but it is again.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/226/1*j6S3pgE0UKln065_QfmhRg.png" /></figure><p>Would he ever find his path to the mother? What would happen to such a child? Wouldn’t it be alienated from its own parents and fostered by the impostors?</p><p>In countries with child care subsidy, there is a scam where foster parents seek to take up more and more number of children, so that they can claim more and more benefits. In such large foster families, would children have the freedom to explore their paths or will they be leashed to a strict routine, brainwashed and crushed. All they know would be to perpetuate the same scam when they grow up, a global Ponzi scheme.</p><p>Then supposing he meets the fellow seekers and they ask him of his journey.</p><p>And he says, ‘I found them, my people, those of my heritage. Indeed they are as told to me. The temples, the music, the arts, the philosophies, the literature are all as described. But you are all wrong about the most important thing, the life-force of the civilization you had described.</p><p>‘How so?’, they ask aghast. ‘Did you get confused by the name or the form, for they are innumerable?’</p><p>‘I did find them by all those names and forms, yet you are wrong’</p><p>‘What did we get wrong, do tell us?’</p><p>‘That there are gods like Rama, Shiva etc, that is all wrong. Jesus alone is the true name and the crucifix alone the true form.’</p><p>‘Child, Jesus is considered God by many, but those are not the people of your civilization, but another. Respect them and their beliefs, but do not deny others or ours, that is not the way of your forefathers. Seek for the truth’</p><p>‘There is nothing to be sought. Everything there is, is in Bible, the true Veda, rest is all the corruption by the Aryans and Brahmins.’</p><p>Shocked they cry, ‘You have your father, but don’t you know that there are other fathers for other children. Would you go and tell them that only your father is true and others’ are false? And even if many men resemble your father in features, wouldn’t you know who is yours, won’t you recognize him by a lifetime of love, care and affection?</p><p>Similarly, wouldn’t you thus recognize what your Samskriti is, from the millennia of wisdom and values?</p><p>How can you make such two mistakes each contradicting the other? Fatherhood is the same, but fathers are various. If someone seeks to impersonate your father in features alone and further insists that he alone is the father and others as false, couldn’t you recognize him as an impostor?</p><p>He responds, ‘Why are you shocked? I only followed the instructions given to me. But saw many others of the same features, then how do I know which is the truth and which is the fraud? The Christians explained that such confusions are caused only by Satan, hence Jesus alone is the true god and others as false. You are all possessed by the Satan. I am a Christian now, hear my witness and accept Jesus alone, else you are damned. My forefathers are burning in hell and you will burn too. Repent and convert!’</p><p>The child in Mulk Raj Anand’s story, what if when it was lost, a person appears to it, with exactly the same features as its father, an impostor who seeks to kidnap the child and restrict it to the leash of doctrinal mono-vision.</p><p>Would it not have been the failure of the parents, not to have taught the child to search beyond mere features?</p><p>Would it not have been the failure of the parents, to ignore the declared intentions of the ‘kidnapper’, allow him to borrow their clothes, impersonate their features and do nothing about it?</p><p>That would be similar to the failure of Hindu society, when we don’t assert ourselves against the cultural appropriation by exclusivist religions, seeking to convert people.</p><p>The markers of culture are like the signboards, left by our ancestors in the search of the mother, Ishwara. They leveraged every aspect of human endeavour towards the seeking of that prime state.</p><p>To allow those markers, to be hijacked by people who seek to kidnap our children, we are failing ourselves and will wander ever lost.</p><p>The Vedantic excuse, that since all these still happen within the Leela of Ishwara, so we need do nothing, that is not acceptable. Because by doing nothing, we delay the moment we all reach the embrace of the mother.</p><p>Even as culture is appropriated, even when the churches declare ‘inculturation’ as a policy, even when they declare the death of theo-diversity as the goal, to be mute in ‘Secular Silence’…</p><p>Well, some civilizations died with great clamour, some died with a whimper, but Hindus, will we die in the self-effacing silence of secularism?</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=81d1667abdbb" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Carnatic music and cultural appropriation- Collection]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@raghu.bhaskaran/carnatic-music-and-cultural-appropriation-cc5bf8d37184?source=rss-f6d757e3687b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/cc5bf8d37184</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[hinduism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[christian-inculturation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cultural-appropriation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[carnatic-music]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[india]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[RB]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 21 Aug 2018 18:16:54 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-10-15T03:46:57.278Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>A collection of articles and posts regarding the Christian appropriation of Carnatic music, abetted by some artists.</p><p>8th August:</p><p>http://www.pragyata.com/mag/heena-and-the-hijab-572</p><p>9th August:</p><p>Saw some statements released by Carnatic music Vidwans and Vidushis, a telephonic response from O.S.Arun, that the intention was to promote communal harmony.<br>That Sanatana Dharma teaches to be inclusive etc.</p><p>Excellent. I completely agree with the intention.</p><p>So how come they did not start with a invocation to Ganesha, say with ‘Mahaganapathim..’, and then end with a Mangalam to Rama, I love Badrachala Ramdasa’s, ‘Ramachandraya ..’.</p><p>Songs about Mahavira, Odin, Buddha, Allah should be included as well.</p><p>So what it is conducted by Christians, they also want communal harmony, don’t they?</p><p>But if you sing solely about Jesus in the program and claim communal harmony, sounds suspicious.</p><p>~~~~~</p><p>It is same one-sided love nonsense. Even temples and ashrams do that. Putting Jesus along with Devata, dressing up Ganesha in a Santa Suit.</p><p>Without valuing the Adhyatmika bhava, mere optics.</p><p>Proselytizers appropriating culture is plagiarism.<br>But Hindus indulging in such antics is prostitution.</p><p>9th August:</p><p>A consultant for the Indian army, an expert appreciated by all in the field, he is furthering the research done by many greats inspired entirely by their love for the country.</p><p>Then Pakistan invites him under ‘Aman Ki Asha’, to visit and teach at one of their defense labs</p><p>Should he go? After all science doesn’t have any nationality. Science has no boundaries.</p><p>Pakistan also has scientific establishments.</p><p>It is his personal liberty. <br>Or is it such liberties limited to artists alone?</p><p>~~~~~~~~~~~</p><p>There is a successful horticulturalist family, who grows varieties of flora, with traditional and organic methods.</p><p>Next door is a commercial entity is setting up a plantation of an invasive allelopathic species like Eucalyptus, the firm has already enroached upon his land. It is with great difficulty have the family of horticulturalists preserved the diversity of their garden.</p><p>Now the firm is inviting one them, as friendly neighbours, to display his talents with the Eucalyptus.</p><p>Should the invitation be accepted?</p><p>Being neighbourly is a virtue and knowledge should have no boundaries.</p><p>~~~~~~<br>Every person has liberties, yet those liberties — even artistic liberties are not isolated from the society.<br>They should be tempered with the context.<br>Morality, integrity, legality, security all matters.</p><p>To not be aware that Pakistan is an political enemy seeking the destruction of India, is not acceptable.</p><p>To be unaware that Christianity and Islam are exclusive and proselytizing religions which do not accept the diversity of other beliefs and seek the destruction, is not acceptable.</p><p>You may not war on them, or hate them. But do not betray your country or dharma to them.</p><p>We can suffer Ghaznis, not Jaichands.</p><p>Communal harmony is not a one way street or anecdotal. It is ideological.</p><p>(1) Sing of Jesus or Allah among a Hindu audience in a concert, among other songs. We will accept as Rasikas.</p><p>(2) Then sing of Siva and Vishnu as well, to a Christian audience, if they accept then it is communal harmony.</p><p>If you do the first and not the second. You are hypocrite, an axe handle to your own heritage</p><p>May all the Devas, Rishis, Pitrus desert you.<br>May your vidya cause you nothing but pain.</p><p>10th August:</p><p>A superb take on the sordid selling-out by the Karnatik singers, by Sri. <a href="https://www.facebook.com/bsandeep?fref=mentions&amp;__xts__%5B0%5D=68.ARByplxFK7O1PZdaODfBT_cU1-EV6Gasq4n9WUFQhns7IdxNoW48eVjcJyuDV_UvGWCMbZXNG3m-MvWNZYGkQzBDa2eIj9TfqioE7kXsvccDwPYSWadn4vuyHmKQInOZ8rW5T6LsyqUf&amp;__tn__=K-R">Sandeep Balakrishna</a>.</p><p><a href="https://medium.com/the-deep-chronicles/christianising-carnatic-classical-music-the-madras-enablers-of-cultural-appropriation-b26190679379">https://medium.com/…/christianising-carnatic-classical-musi…</a></p><p>~~~~~~~~<br>I had a fb conversation with a singer whose rendering of Muthuswamy Dikishitar’s ‘Ranga Puravihara’ was popular on youtube few months ago.</p><p>And asked him if he would sing ‘Bethlehem Puravihara’ or ‘Mecca Puravihara’, in the same Brindavana-Saranga Raaga.<br>He said he would, for in his understanding, music has no ‘boundaries’.</p><p>Well though he is an amazing singer, I realised the difference.<br>He aptly has ‘Agam-bhava’ (Ahambhava). While Dikshithar’s bhava was — let’s listen to a person of Jewish origins expound on it <br><a href="https://youtu.be/yjbAbMu8mzY">https://youtu.be/yjbAbMu8mzY</a></p><p>Dikshithar was doing a ‘Sangeetha Pratishta’ of the devata, when he composed and sang. That was his bhava, he was establishing Devi NeelothpalaAmba with his Krithis, as a Shilpi would do a Prana Pratishta.</p><p>But will there be a ‘Pratishta Bhava’ towards Jesus, if you sing “Bethlehem Pura Vihara”?</p><p>How different is that from removing Ranganatha Swami, from the Sri Rangam temple and installing the Crucifix in the Garbhagriha?</p><p>Architecture has no religion, right?</p><p>Yet what is evident to David Shulman, is not evident to Karnatik artists who were supposedly trained in the sampradayas.</p><p>That ‘Prana Pratishta’ is the life force of Samskruti. And these axe-handles, are cutting off body parts, claiming that the flesh has no religion, while denying the damage they are doing to the Prana.</p><p>~~~~~~~~~~~~<br>तत् कर्म यत् न बन्दया सा विद्या या विमुक्तये<br>यस्य अपरं कर्म विद्या अन्या शिल्पनैपुणम् — विष्णु पुराणम्</p><p>“tatkarma yan na bandhāya sā vidyā yā vimuktaye |<br>āyāsāyāparaṃ karma vidyānyā śilpanaipuṇam ||<br>- VishnuPurana_1,19.41 ||”</p><p>That which uplifts the soul to liberation, is the true Vidya. Other learnings are merely a matter of artistic skill.</p><p>Dikshitar’s vidya was to elevate the consciousness — vimukthi. These people, merely śilpanaipuṇam</p><p>~~~~~~~~~~~~~~</p><p>I do not object to Raagas and Talas being used by anyone. Sounds, tunes, beats are universal. Even using the terms of the system — Melakarta, is somewhat ok.</p><p>But do not debase the intrinsic, the intangible that is invoked.</p><p>But because Muthuswami Dikshithar or Marimuthaa Pillai is not around to object, does not mean their work should be thus defiled. <br>The intent and integrity of the composer should be respected, even if there are no copyrights protecting them.</p><p>But I guess this is the Niyathi — entropy. <br>Once Devadasis, were truly the dasis of devas alone, with Natya as their sadhana. But overtime they degraded to prostitution, for many reasons, particularly economic.</p><p>Now it is the turn of Karnatik Singers, I suppose.<br>Yet what reason do they have, but avidya and agamkara.</p><p>10th August:</p><p>//Nithyasree Mahadevan also said she was against religious conversion of any kind and wouldn’t engage in any act that would endorse or propagate such things.//</p><p>Alcohol advertisements are banned in India, so the brands use a subterfuge, they sell club soda under the same name and get celebrities to endorse the name.</p><p>‘Communal Harmony’, is the Club Soda sold by companies, whose true product is the ‘Conversion Wine and Whiskey’</p><p>Nithyasree would not be endorsing or propagating alcohol consumption if she sang a jingle in Shankarabaranam for the club soda, would she?</p><p>12th August:</p><p><a href="http://www.tamilhindu.com/2018/08/%E0%AE%95%E0%AE%BF%E0%AE%B1%E0%AE%BF%E0%AE%B8%E0%AF%8D%E0%AE%A4%E0%AE%B5%E0%AE%A4%E0%AF%8D%E0%AE%A4%E0%AE%BF%E0%AE%A9%E0%AF%8D-%E0%AE%95%E0%AE%B2%E0%AE%BE%E0%AE%9A%E0%AE%BE%E0%AE%B0%E0%AE%A4%E0%AF%8D/">http://www.tamilhindu.com/2018/08/%E0%AE%95%E0%AE%BF%E0%AE%B1%E0%AE%BF%E0%AE%B8%E0%AF%8D%E0%AE%A4%E0%AE%B5%E0%AE%A4%E0%AF%8D%E0%AE%A4%E0%AE%BF%E0%AE%A9%E0%AF%8D-%E0%AE%95%E0%AE%B2%E0%AE%BE%E0%AE%9A%E0%AE%BE%E0%AE%B0%E0%AE%A4%E0%AF%8D/</a></p><p>12th August:</p><p>முருகனுக்கே இணையானவன்.. என்று<br>நித்யஸ்ரீயா பிரபாகரனை பாடுகிறார்?</p><p>அதே வாய் அருணகிரிநாதரின் திருப்புகழும் பாடும்.</p><p>பாடுவதின் அர்த்தம் புரிந்து பாடவேண்டாமா?<br>சேராத இடத்தில் சேர்ந்து நன்றாக செய்தாலும், அது கொடுஞ்செயலே.</p><p>நான் இரும்புகொல்லன் என் தொழில் கருவி செய்வதே ஆக நான் தெரிந்த கொலைகாரன் ஆயினும் ஆயுதம் செய்துதருவது என் கடமை என்று பேசுவது மடமை</p><p>சரி அரசியல் ரீதியாக விடுதலை புலிகளை ஆதரித்து இருக்கலாம் ஆனால் இப்படி முருகனோடு ஒப்பீடு தேவையா.</p><p>முருகனை ஏற்கனவே வெறும் முப்பாட்டன் என்று குறைத்து கூறும் ஒரு கூட்டம்.</p><p>பின்புலம் இருந்து இயக்கும் இயந்திரம்,<br>இயேசு மட்டுமே தெய்வம் என்னும் அடிப்படைவாதம் கொண்டது</p><p>இதெல்லாம் புரியாமல் கலையில் வல்லமை கொண்டு என்ன பயன்.</p><p>நீர் நதியிலும் ஓடும், சாக்கடையிலும் ஓடும்.<br>ஆனால் நதிகளையே சாக்கடையாக்கி விட்டோம்.<br>கழிவுநீரை கலைஞர் என்றும் ஏற்றுவிட்டோம்<br>பிறகு மற்ற கலைஞரும் அப்படித்தான் என்று அறிந்து வருத்தப்பட்டு என்ன பயன்.</p><p>18th August:</p><p>All great artists get associated with some specific pieces.</p><p>For example, ‘Maithreem Bhajata..’ and ‘Kurai ondrum illai..’ and M.S.Subbulakshmi.</p><p>I wonder what would be such songs for NithyaShree.</p><p>Would it be,</p><p>“Samanulevaru Prabhu’ — No one else is equal to Jesus.</p><p>And</p><p>‘Anthe Muruganukke ivan Niharaanavan’ — That LTTE Prabhakaran is equal to Muruga himself.</p><p>What a sham?</p><p>So Jesus is incomparable, while terrorists are comparable to Muruga.</p><p>TM Krishna will now take up the challenge and sing Kasab is like Krishna, all in the name of secularism and artistic freedom.</p><p>If Seeman is to be prosecuted for supporting secessionists and terrorists, then Nithyashree should also be.</p><p>In fact her case is worse, that Seeman is such a vermin is known to all, but her’s was far greater a betrayal.</p><p>20th August:</p><p>There are three popular signifiers of the Tamil-Brahmin culture. Kaapi (Filter Coffee), Karnataka Sangeetham (Carnatic Music) and Bharathanatyam.</p><p>The funny thing is, if you study the history of all the three, the association of TamBrahms with them, is only 2–4 centuries old.</p><p>The southern classical music and dance forms, was originally associated with other communities — the Paanars, the Devadasis and the Isai Vellalars.</p><p>But it was never limited to any specific community, for example, Purandaradasa considered the Pitamaha of Carnatic Music, would be a Vaishya.<br>Brahmins definitely contributed to the nadhopasana and natyopasana, but among many others.</p><p>Then the social churn happened, Islamic invasions and later British colonization, the traditional ownership of these art forms degraded. It is at that point, Brahmins took up the patronage of these arts in a big way. When the patronage from the royalty died away, when the temples could no more support the art, the sabha system of public performances kept it alive.</p><p>How does an art form or anything get associated with a specific community?</p><p>For example, how is the deep borewell drilling industry associated with the Gounders of Tiruchengode in the recent years?</p><p>It can’t be easily answered, but eventually it is noticed that the community builds an tradition of investment in that activity, builds institutions and that eco-system throws up innovators and achievers in the field and over time, that activity becomes a cultural identifier of the community.</p><p>Similarly with Carnatic music, the adoption by the Brahmins achieved traction and then came the amazing achievers like Thiagaraja, Dikshithar, Shyama Shastri and then many Guru-Shishya paramparas of amazing artists.</p><p>So the significance of Brahmin presence in the field increased, yet there were always others who were stalwarts in the field. It was not a system closed to outsiders, by a dogma.</p><p>There are many examples, including Maestro Ilayaraja who learnt Carnatic music from such gurus.</p><p>Carnatic music is still a niche art and it is not sustained by mass volume of audience, but by a small, loyal and informed fan base. I was told of this dynamic, ‘In the tiny sabhas tucked in the corners of old Madras, aspiring amateur artists will perform to empty halls in late afternoon concerts, in Chennai heat. Yet there will be few people who will come into the concert, nod their heads and listen. Then they will openly critique the artists, ‘there was a flaw in that spot’, ‘You should be from X school, I could recognize the Bhaani (style)’ etc. These rasikas with immense knowledge are the people who keep the art form alive.</p><p>Yet it is not a closed system.</p><p>~~~~~~~~~~~~<br>So what exactly did the Brahmins do wrong in this history of the art, that the libigots (liberal bigots) today assail them of elitism?</p><p>It is not for claiming exclusive ownership of the art, are the rasikas- Brahmin or not, protesting today. But against the acts of appropriation by the exclusivists of the Christian religion.<br>And particularly when it is enabled by the artists who unlike their predecessors, are willing to prostitute what was nadhopasana, for pieces of silver.</p><p>Who is going to object, if anyone comes with the shraddha towards the art and the spirituality that animates it and build a reputation and tradition of excellence in it?</p><p>~~~~~~~~~~~~~</p><p>Thiagaraja, arguably the greatest of Carnatic Vaggeyakaras sang, that nadha is a veritably “SadaaShiva” itself, arising from the Omkara, the raagaas will give the result equal to Yagna, Yoga and Tyaga.</p><p>//rAga sudhArasa pAnamu jEsi rAjillavE manasA<br>yAga yOga tyAga bhOga phala mosangE<br>sadAshiva mayamagu nAdOnkAra svara vidulu jIvan muktulani tyAgarAju teliyu//</p><p>Harikeshavanallur Muthiah Bhagavathar, sang of Vijayambike- Gauri as the ‘Sangeetha Rupini’ adorned with Srutis, Swaras, Gramas etc</p><p>//shruti svara grAma mUrcanAlankAra nAda janita rAga rasa bharita sangIta rUpiNi gaurI..//</p><p>And yet these artists think this music is merely tunes and beats, that it can be used to glorify the very dogma which clamours that Shiva is the demon and Shakthi a witch?<br>Will Jesus be thus intrinsic to Raagaas?</p><p>If they know not the difference between lust and love, why should they be allowed to love our gods any more?</p><p>~~~~~~<br>Edit: This post on the appropriation of Carnatic music has been shared and yet I see comments from the clueless claiming art has no religion, caste etc.</p><p>I had used history, logic, aesthetic and spirituality, perhaps that was my mistake.</p><p>So let me try melodrama, Indians have a reputation for being suckers for emotion, so let me try that.</p><p>* It is indeed art to make gold jewellery.<br>* People can make jewellery for their wives <br>* People can make jewellery for their mistresses, who wish that the wife be deserted and family broken up.</p><p>But what kind of a person will steal the mangalsutra of the wife, melt it to make a golden trinket for the mistresses?</p><p>That is what people like TM Krishna are doing with carnatic music.</p><p>Yes, carnatic music is just an art.</p><p>21st August:</p><p>If you can understand the distress of the lady here and what is disgusting in this act.</p><p>They you should be able to understand the distress and the immorality, when Hindu Devata are replaced by Jesus, in the cultural expressions.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/720/0*FEGYCyc8t_Nf9FHX" /></figure><p>21st August:</p><p>There is nothing wrong in singing that there is ‘nobody equal to Jesus’, in the raga which was meant to adorn Shiva ‘Shankarabharanam’, — NithyaShree Mahadevan.</p><p><a href="https://swarajyamag.com/ideas/the-carnatic-christian-conundrum-its-an-alarming-case-of-cultural-appropriation">https://swarajyamag.com/…/the-carnatic-christian-conundrum-…</a></p><p>//This time, however, the album at the centre of controversy contains songs that have blatantly plagiarised Tyagaraja, one of the trinities of Carnatic music. Jesus has been substituted for Rama in the kriti “Rama nee samanamevaru (Who is equal to you, oh Rama)” which has been sung as “Prabhu nee samanulevaru (Lord, who are your equals)”. Note the use of the plural “equals”, implying the plurality of Hindu gods including Rama.</p><p>In the face of Mahadevan maintaining that the songs are similar but not the same and that Rama’s name has not been replaced with another, the same can be said of all the songs plagiarised by the Bollywood musical industry. By changing bits here and there, one cannot claim to have created something new. A detailed analysis of the similarities and differences are beyond the scope of this article and users can listen and validate for themselves; however, this writer would like to draw attention to the fact that they did not even change the raga family. All it takes to shift from kharaharapriya, the raga of the original, to shankarabharanam, the raga of the Christian version, is a single grahabheda (tonic shift).//</p><p>~~~~~~~~~</p><p>Did somebody notice the travesty in using the raga called “Shankara-bharanam” i.e. the ornament of Shankara, to sing that “nobody is equal to Jesus”</p><p>If the shameless wonders have any integrity or ingenuity, who is stopping them from creating a new raga (and not a Janya raga), call it RagsOfJesus and singing about him. Heck they can sell the secular soda of communal harmony, but singing of Shankara with there new creation as well.</p><p>But to use a raga explicitly codified in Melakarta as ‘Shankarabharana’ to sing for a dogma which thinks Shankara as demonic and false god.<br>I can’t claim any skills in music and barely any technical knowledge, but I assumed a feted artist like Nithyashree Mahadevan knows what the Raga means and what it stands far. But apparently I was wrong.</p><p>Such things have become mere words and sounds, not meaning and sentiment.</p><p>Shankarabharanam can be used to sing any other god or sentiment, which does not explicitly deny the divinity of Shiva, no issues. But Christianity is a doctrine of exclusivity, it denies all other gods and beliefs.</p><p>August 24th 2018:</p><p>It seems I am stuck on this subject, earlier analogies and reasoning do not seem to have made a dent. But I still persist, because it might help others with their arguments.</p><p>There are at least four parts to a performance,<br>1. The artists<br>2. The content – composer, subject<br>3. The audience<br>4. The setting/medium – genre, raga, style, location</p><p>* Artists born in Christian creed, performing songs about Hindu Devatas, to any audience <br>e.g. Yesudas singing of Shasta. <br>Not an issue, but has that been ever done in a Christian organized program with predominantly Christian audience?</p><p>* Artists from Hindu tradition, performing songs about Jesus to any audience <br>e.g. Bethlehem Kuravanji performed by Sikkil Gurucharan or Iravindam Kaiyendungal on Allah by Vittaldas Maharaj, to a predominantly Hindu audience. <br>Not an issue, as long as it one song among many presented.</p><p>* Artists from Hindu tradition, performing songs about Jesus, in a highly imitational manner, or wearing Christian garb.<br>Performing specifically Hindu content<br>e.g. Nithyasree singing Shankarabaranam which proclaims the exclusivity of Jesus or O.S.Arun wearing a crucifix and singing of Jesus</p><p>Now those are objectionable.</p><p>That there were Christian converts who were contemporaries of Thyagaraja himself, who wrote songs in Carnatic style, is no excuse, because Christian inculturation and cultural appropriation is as old as Jesus. <br>That is like claiming there have been cultural thieves since ancient times, or that we have been abetting such thieves even in the past, so why object only today? <br>I would seriously recommend the thieves of wealth, use that argument when they are finally caught.<br>&#39;Your honour, I have been cheating and stealing for many years now, why is the police objecting now or the public protesting?&#39;</p><p>But let me ask people using this argument, <br>* Why have there been no attempts by artists to sing a Psalm for Parvathy or Carol for Krishna? <br>* Why has there never been any concert with predominantly Christian or Islamic audience, where songs have been performed on Shiva or Vishnu?<br>* Why has there been no traffic the other way?<br>* Why this one-sided generosity which is never reciprocated?<br>* Why the one-side love affair?</p><p>Have they ever asked such questions?<br>Are they aware of the words &#39;Inculturation&#39;, &#39;Cultural digestion&#39; etc. ?<br>Do they know the history of the cultures erased by Christianity?</p><p>Again ragas, talas are generic – they can been used by anyone in any way. They are like the vocabulary and grammar of a language. So are the musical instruments, notes etc (Nottu-Swara is such an adaptation from western music).<br>But the content, that is associated with a certain tradition, a culture – which has accrued that over generations of investment and fostering the art form.</p><p>Such content has to be handled with sensitivity and empathy to the owners and not prostituted out to those who seek the death of that culture and who don’t reciprocate the sharing.</p><p>Those are like the idioms of a language, which are specific to the culture and can&#39;t be used wantonly under the name of artistic freedom.<br>That is like feeding the Prasad to pigs. You can sure feed the pigs, keep them as pets or be a pet to them, but if you mess with the prasad, then protest we will.</p><p>If you can’t or won’t sing of Shiva to a Christian audience, then you have no business singing of Jesus to them. If you do, then we will sing a different tune to you.</p><p>Keep claiming that we are but fringe, but then Carnatic music itself is only a fringe art form, <br>~~~~~~~~~~<br>* Secularism is the surrogate Soda, advertised by Abrahamic Alcohol companies, to push addiction by deception. Don&#39;t sing jingles for them.<br>* What Islam seeks to achieve by conflict, Christianity seeks to achieve by corruption.<br>* All religions are not equal, if you can&#39;t or won&#39;t sing of Shiva to a Christian or Muslim audience, but can sing of Jesus and Allah to Hindus.<br>* Don&#39;t feed the Prasada to Pigs. Feed the pigs all you want, but not with the Neivedhya.<br>* Don&#39;t melt the wife&#39;s Mangalsutra to make jewellery for your mistress. That the wife put up with your philandering in the past, is no reason that she should shut up now.</p><p>---------------<br>A Chronicle of Collaboration, writes Sriram V. a historian of Carnatic music and Madras, the Secretary of the Music Academy, Chennai.</p><p>Collaborators is the right term, but the context here is more like VIchy France, Norway&#39;s Quisling, Collaborators with Nazi Germany, seeking the destruction of independent France and Norway<br>Collaboration is good, if it is a two way street, not when one side is exclusive and does not reciprocate,</p><p>https://www.thehindu.com/opinion/op-ed/a-chronicle-of-collaboration/article24732325.ece</p><p>The frogs of Hitopadesh would have thought it was only &#39;collaboration&#39; they had with the Snake Mandavishya. <br>The citizens of Ekachakrapura would have thought they were collaborating with Bakasura.</p><p>But unlike the physical deaths which are very noticeable, the slow strangling of the culture and its digestion, can be noticed only by the alert. <br>Alertness is not something associated with soporific secularism.</p><p>August 25th</p><p>ThoMa Khristna in this wire article, is comparing something like scientists building up from works of predecessors and being influenced by contemporaries, with the pilfering done by A.Q Khan.</p><p>Of course artists take inspiration from predecessors and others, but abetting the exclusivists are a different matter, that is like nuclear profileration to a terrorist state.</p><p>Seems he is arguing that such the carnatic greats were imitators of others and not inspired by others. So he it and others are justified in profilerating to the terrorists state equivalent among religions.</p><p>Do these soda-sellers, think there would have been this reaction if they had collaborated with say, Buddhists?</p><p>Dikshithar &#39;supposedly&#39; sang to Jesus, maybe so, but that is still like saying since our grandfathers worked for the colonial administration, today I will spy for the British government against India.</p><p>The Vedanta vada is nonsense as well, this is in the world of vyavaharika and not Paramatmika. And do Christians agree to the concept of Parabrahman which is the only reality? <br>If you are that much an Advaitin, sure go and sing that everything is Maya, there is no son, no holy ghost, it is all only God. And see how they react.</p><p>The contexts have changed since Dikshithar&#39;s day, colonialism of politics have ended and today we are fighting to end the colonialism of minds and appropriation of culture by the exclusivists.</p><p><a href="https://thewire.in/the-arts/carnatic-music-plagiarism-tradition">https://thewire.in/the-arts/carnatic-music-plagiarism-tradition</a></p><p>August 26 2018:</p><p>ThoMa(s) Khristna argues that those who don’t know Carnatic Music, are agitating and interfering with artistic freedom (to abet misappropriation by Convertors).</p><p>True, for example, I would not know a ‘Gamakam’ if it came and knocked me on my head.</p><p>But when Thoma Khris, protests and criticizes the Modi government, does he have degrees in political science, years of public administration, passed UPSC, won elections, ran ministries or at least municipalities?</p><p>All those lack, did not stop him from dissing Make In India and other policies, did it?</p><p>Typical liberal hypocrisy.</p><p>I do not need technical expertise in Shastriya Sangeetha, to criticize his intentions and actions, his choice of application and appropriation. The ‘context’ of his performance, which impacts my cultural world.</p><p>It is needed only to assess the quality of his performance.</p><p>When he throws ‘Prasada to Pigs’, I don’t need to be a expert Chef to criticize the action</p><p>Aug 27 2018:</p><p>//Violin is a gift from Christianity to Carnatic Music//<br><a href="https://www.facebook.com/thenewindianxpress/?fref=mentions&amp;__xts__%5B0%5D=68.ARAbfk-sJ5N5X-dT1CkNyg19FZI6eP8BEiIOpY1nqpBBPGztzx6CgaR_pNfxebCkzuhDq6DSdBNDI4kPMc7zAcBMtmIi_wkTiHmYLsCf-TLYSmkmk5DBLyDvCSFiSfENJb2163c&amp;__tn__=K-R">The New Indian Express</a></p><p>Oh really, so anything that came out of medieval Europe, is then a Christian gift, is it?</p><p>Would that include burning disbelievers alive with fire. Imprisoning aged scientists like Galileo because they said the planetary system is Helio-centric?</p><p>Oh wait, how about let us see — COLONIALISM?,<br>Which killed and enslaved millions, destroyed cultures and economies?</p><p>That’s a gift of Christianity, as well?</p><p>Just did a basic check on the evolution of violin, goes back to pre-Christian Greek Lyra which is very similar to the Yazh-harp of the Tamils, and given the trade between Greco-Romans and Tamil kingdoms, well…</p><p>Moronic claim.</p><p>Arts, science, language etc are always accumulated achievements, spanning multiple civilizations and long periods of history. But content is not.</p><p>I recollect the movie ‘Flash of genius’, about the inventor of intermittent windshield wipers. The car companies will try to swindle him saying he did nothing new but rearrange existing components in a new manner to achieve the result.<br>Then Robert Kearns the inventor will ask the defending lawyer to read from the Tale of Two Cities, “It-was-the-best-of-times,-it-was-the-worst-of-times.”<br>All these words pre-existed Dickens, yet it was his genius which could put it a certain pattern, to evocate a certain feeling in the readers, it is unique.</p><p>Similarly instruments, words, tunes, beats are universal, or have very short copy right period. But what they evocate as creations are unique.</p><p>The problem is less about imitation, plagiarism, appropriation etc.<br>The problem is with the intention of who is doing it.</p><p>Would anybody care, if it was for the Buddhists or Bollywood, these witless artists sang Shashtriya Sangeetha?</p><p>No, the issue is the intentions of Christianity. Like a key maker displaying his skills to a robber.</p><p>Christianity uses such things to claim ownership. Thiruvallur was a Christian, Upanishads are about Jesus etc. and then doesn’t respect other cultures and alienates people from their cultures, that’s the issue.</p><p>How many people today know the origins of the celebration that happens in the last week of December? Romans celebrated it for Sol Invictus, their sun god, Mithra was venerated in Anatolia, and many other cultures celebrated the Sun on Winter Solstice.</p><p>But today it has been entirely swallowed by Christmas. A day there is no evidence that Jesus was born on.</p><p>So whose gift was Christmas to a Christianity?</p><p>That’s the problem.</p><p>Did Mozart, Bach or Beethoven, credit and dedicate their genius to Jesus, and then if some Indian musician imitated their creation to sing of Shiva or Vishnu, then the zombies can complain.</p><p>They did not, while all the composers of Shastriya Sangeetha, entirely ascribed their art to Hindu Devatas. Their compositions were predominantly only about Hindu Devatas</p><p><a href="http://www.newindianexpress.com/cities/chennai/2018/aug/27/violin-a-gift-from-christianity-to-carnatic-music-1863305.html">http://www.newindianexpress.com/…/violin-a-gift-from-christ…</a></p><p>August 27, 2018:</p><p>Is music divine?</p><p>If yes, what is the divinity?</p><p>Is it only one specific God, <br>or could it be any God, <br>or multiple gods <br>or is it that divinity beyond names and forms which permeates everything?</p><p>If it is not limited to one specific God, then can the people who limit themselves to one form, one name, and further aggressively deny all other forms, names, conceptions — capable of divine music?</p><p>Wouldn’t that not be like making music, insisting that there is only one note ‘Swara’, and that the rest are false and must be denied?</p><p>How can music be universal, in the hands of such people or divine, in their minds?</p><p>Even if they make wonderful music, this dichotomy of exclusivity, means it will never be perfection, that overflowing of emotion, that sadhana towards something beyond time and existence.<br>It will be mere mechanical skill.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=cc5bf8d37184" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Ahalya — A Critique]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@raghu.bhaskaran/ahalya-a-critique-8aa582e1951?source=rss-f6d757e3687b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8aa582e1951</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[feminism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mahabharata]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[RB]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 15 Jun 2018 20:57:43 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-06-16T10:54:17.005Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Eklavya, Karna are misappropriated by Dalitists and leftists, as archetypical victims of Brahmanical oppressions and I have responded to that piece of nonsense already. See link.</p><p><a href="https://www.facebook.com/raghu.bhaskaran.9/posts/10154702354291697">https://www.facebook.com/raghu.bhaskaran.9/posts/10154702354291697</a></p><p>And recently I was asked to critique a post showing Ahalya, as an archetypical victim of Brahmanical Patriarchy and that is this post. This should endear me to the feminists. :)</p><p><strong>Ah Su Ra — Part 1</strong></p><p>I recently watched a dance performance by Anita Ratnam, Sharmila Biswas &amp; Geetha Chandran titled — Ah Su Ra. The performance tried to put forth retelling of some stories of Ramayana by the characters — Ahalya, S(h)urpanakha &amp; Raavana in their perspective.</p><p><strong>Ahalya — Her story as I know</strong> : Her story has many versions. The version that I have heard the most is as follows:</p><p>One day Indra visits Brahma and they get talking… After some time they begin chiding each other. Indra taunts Brahma that His best days are behind Him.. He has created the best possible woman already — Urvashi, who is with Indra… This irks Brahma and He makes “Ahalya”. Hala means flaw — Ahalya is the one with no flaw… She is beauty personified…</p><p>When Indra lays his eyes on Ahalya (as a child), he can already see the beauty she will grow up to be. He assumes that like other celestial beauties (Ramba, Menaka, Urvashi &amp; Thilothama), Ahalya will also be his. When Brahma decides to let Gauthama bring her up, Indra is only too happy (assuming she will grow up into a woman with no greed). Gauthama Rishi brings her up as Rishi Kanya. He happily returns Ahalya to Brahma when Ahalya grows up to be a young woman.</p><p>Seeing that Gauthama was not attracted to her and assuming that His creation will “intact” &amp; also to teach Indra a lesson, Brahma gets her married off to Gauthama. Gauthama takes her back as a Rishi Patni to his hermitage. He calls as “Ahalya — the one who cannot be ploughed” (Infertile). She stays as a lonely woman serving the needs of her husband.</p><blockquote><strong><em>******[Raghu Bhaskaran]</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>I do not know the specifics of the story, but how did the meaning change from ‘flawless’ to ‘infertile’, seems an inconsistency?</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>It appears intentional, to show Ahalya in favorable light — the meaning is taken as ‘flawless’ and to show Gautama in unfavorable light, it is presented as “infertile”.</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>*********</em></strong></blockquote><p>Indra starts spying their life… He notices her devotion to her husband.. but also her loneliness!! He sees her wake up before him, bathe and get his clothes ready… He sees her get flowers for his pooja and his food ready.. He sees her slog through her domestic chores… He decides to take advantage of the situation.</p><blockquote><strong><em>******[Raghu Bhaskaran]</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>Why are domestic chores considered a slog? Professional chores can also be. It depends on the person and context. 90% of 90% people’s life, in all times of history, in all societies and professions, are made up of such chores.</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>The attitude of the person towards any task, is what makes them a slog or not. Gautama could have as well complained about some components of Tapas or Samskaras, as slogging, or maybe the Grihasta duties?</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote>***********</blockquote><p>One morning, Indra takes the form of a rooster to wake up Gauthama earlier than his usual. As he goes for his morning rituals, Indra takes Gauthama’s form and enters the hermit. Ahalya is shocked to see Gauthama come back so soon. Indra praises her beauty (calls her a slim-waisted one) and approaches her. Ahalya is surprised and more importantly thrilled. They enjoy togetherness and just before he ejaculates, Ahalya sees a look of satisfaction on his face. She recognizes that it is not Gauthama, but it is probably too late. She asks Indra to leave immediately. But too late it is by then!! Gauthama is back dripping wet and one look at them both, he realizes what has happened. He curses Indra that he would lose his testicles and that what he longed for the most would cover his body (Indra’s body is covered with a 1000 vulva). He asks Ahalya if she knew that she had not slept with her husband. Ahalya is now in a dilema.. She initially did not know it was Indra.. But towards the end, she knows it was not Gauthama. She decides that truth is nothing but complete in itself. She says “Yes” and Gauthama curses her that she be reduced to a state where she can only breathe, eat air.. and that she should continue her penance in such a state until a point where every other man on earth feels like a son or brother to her.</p><p>Thus Ahalya is reduced to almost a state of stone. About a 1000 years later, Rama comes about that way. He is lead by Vishwamithra and accompanied by His brother Lakshmana. They are travelling towards Mithila. Vishwamithra is Kshathriya by birth and training. He walks so fast without halting and Rama and Lakshmana silently follow. At one point Vishwamithra is unable to see the shadow of Rama and when he turns, he notices that the boys are tired. So they decide to halt at Gauthama rishi’s hermit. Rama stamps a stone in the hermitage and realizes it is not a mere stone — it is moving slightly.. He touches it with empathy. His eyes well up with tears assuming it is a live creature that he stamped and almost crushed. Ahalya feels maternal love for this adolescent child who feels compassion towards all living creatures… At this point she takes up her form again and is free from her curse. Later she re-unites with Gauthama</p><p><strong>Ahalya’s life interpretation — as I see it :</strong></p><p>I find that so many men have played with Ahalya’s life right from her birth.</p><ul><li>She was created because Brahma was challenged by Indra. Brahma did not create her with the love He created other beings with. In that process — He must only have made her the most beautiful creature.. He wouldn’t have bothered about other aspects of her… Physical beauty was His utmost priority to show Himself off to Indra.</li></ul><blockquote><strong><em>******[Raghu Bhaskaran]</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>Taking this interpretation, how is Brahma any different from millions of other parents, who do want their children live up to their dreams, who expect their children to excel and show them off — from talent shows to visiting neighbours. After all that is the purpose of any creation, from parents to artists to gods — challenged by themselves or by others, to actualize their visions and see them grow to the potential envisaged.</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>And I assume her beauty was mentioned in the epic, but was it mentioned that she was lacking in other aspects? Then she would not have been ‘flawless’, would she? This makes her sound like the ancient version of a stereotyped — empty headed bimbo. Seems incongruous.</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>************</em></strong></blockquote><ul><li>Gauthama brought her up. Ahalya was not brought up by the man who made her. She wasn’t with the father — but with an adopted ‘father’. She looked upon Gauthama as a ‘father’ &amp; probably ‘teacher’. She must have respected him a lot to follow his footsteps.</li></ul><blockquote><strong><em>******[Raghu Bhaskaran]</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>This is not unusual in the context. Pati was indeed considered the guru and therefore a father in a sense. Yagnavalkya and Maitreyi is another example. Women were married young, given the mortality rates during childbirths. While older men also married, considering the constant chances of death.</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>Reading itihaasas and puranas, they lived in violent times. We definitely live in more secure times. So to keep the tribe/kula propagating was highly prioritized, such would have been the context. Lopamudra and Agastya were another example.</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>What is left unstated is, whether Ahalya was the only such person in Gautama’s ashrama. Ashramas were often refuge for many, like a boarding school. Ahalya could have been one among many who were fostered by Gautama, so is there anything in the epic to assume they had an exclusive father-daughter relationship?</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>***********</em></strong></blockquote><ul><li>Brahma again played with her life. He got her married off to the man who brought her up. There is another version of story to this — Brahma wants His best creation married off to a man worthy of her. So He announces that the man who goes around the world (all 3 lokas) thrice and comes to Brahma first will win her hand. Indra takes up the challenge and goes around the world thrice. Not knowing of this competition but seeing a cow (Surabhi) give birth to a calf, Gauthama is overwhelmed. He appreciates the effort taken by the mother cow. He is able to feel the pain the cow undergoes to give birth to a calf. That makes him respect the mother cow more and as a way of showing respect, he goes around the cow thrice. Brahma takes this equivalent of going around the world and gets Ahalya married off to Gauthama before Indra returns</li></ul><blockquote><strong><em>******[Raghu Bhaskaran]</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>If Gautama indeed brought her up as a father, why was he not consulted? And again if he felt like a father, would he have accepted to marry a girl he considered as a daughter.</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>Occam’s razor — simplest explanation seems that neither Gautama nor Ahalya, considered their relationship as one of father-daughter. Unless the bias is that all men lose their sense of morality/propriety when presented with a women — a typical 3rd wave feminist attitude “all men are potential rapists”.</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>*************</em></strong></blockquote><ul><li>Here again — no one asks Ahalya what she wants. As a young lady, she must have had some dreams about her marriage.. She must have had some expectations out of her future husband. Just because a man was not attracted to her (Version of story mentioned initially as I had heard) or just because a man went around the world thrice — probably showing off his speed or in this case his intelligence/compassion (Version of story mentioned just above), one can’t marry a girl off to him!! Probably she wasn’t looking for such a good man at all!!</li></ul><blockquote><strong><em>******[Raghu Bhaskaran]</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>Speculative. That is a game anyone can play. Rishis were way more powerful than Indra, legend after legend show him coming up short against Rishis. So who is to say that Ahalya was against the alliance. Again it can be speculated any way one wishes. In such cases, I prefer not to read between the lines of the authors.</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>*****************</em></strong></blockquote><ul><li>Irrespective of what the man’s qualities were, that man (Gauthama) was almost like a dad to her till that point in her life. How could she look upon him as a husband?! Probably she might have remained ‘safe and secured’ with Gauthama. But for that purpose a bodyguard would suffice!! One doesn’t need a husband for just feeling safe!!</li></ul><blockquote><strong><em>******[Raghu Bhaskaran]</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>Again, there is nothing to confirm that Gauthama was like a dad. Assuming “safety” indeed was the reason, then when Indra is known to desire her, would anyone else other than a Rishi provide her security? Can ordinary mortals resist the king of Devas?</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>And safety is not just physical safety — that a bodyguard would suffice, unless one is potent enough to ensure their own safety, she had to depend on another. Besides who pays the “bodyguard” — Gauthama or Brahma? It was not a modern day economy to have such professions. Husbands were needed not just for intimacy, but for education and safety as well — depends on the context.</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>***************</em></strong></blockquote><ul><li>Indra comes to her seeking sex from her. Probably for the first time in her life, she spread her wings.</li></ul><blockquote><strong><em>******[Raghu Bhaskaran] First time, is that mentioned or another assumption?</em></strong></blockquote><ul><li>I’d like to assume she consented for the sex.</li></ul><blockquote><strong><em>******[Raghu Bhaskaran] If she has the agency to do so, then why would you assume such a woman, consent to a marriage she did not want?</em></strong></blockquote><p>Even if one needs to accept that sex has to be mutually exclusive within the couple after marriage,</p><blockquote><strong><em>******[Raghu Bhaskaran]</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>They need to, otherwise it is a breach of trust. If they feel that marriage is not satisfactory, they should walk out of it and then do whatever. If giving into random impulses is ok, then there is no point in any social relationship. One could even argue that even incest is ok. If marital commitment can be discarded, why should biological relationships be honoured?Are genes that important then?</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>And besides Gautama did not even have that biological relationship with Ahalya. Seems a contradiction to the earlier point.</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>*************</em></strong></blockquote><p>it has to happen even when the woman longs for it. Gauthama called her the “un-ploughable”. He called her infertile. He kept verbally abusing his wife all through her life. How could she have lived happily with him?</p><blockquote><strong><em>******[Raghu Bhaskaran]</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>Is that stated in the epic? Verbal abuse, unhappiness etc.? Often a word is misread. Flawless became infertile — also it could have meant simply that she had not yet reached maturity.</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>‘It has to happen when the woman longs for it’ — does it mean that ‘it also has to happen whenever the man longs for it’ — then how would you reconcile that with marital rape? And what if the man or the woman does not long for it and the other person does?. There are many aspects to the dynamic.</em></strong></blockquote><ul><li>According to me, even if Gauthama felt he was wronged, he had the right to walk out of the relationship.</li></ul><blockquote><strong><em>******[Raghu Bhaskaran]</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>So could have Ahalya, why did she stay in a relationship if she was unhappy, she could have walked out and hired a bodyguard for security or gotten Indra to provide it, as well as intimacy. If she did not walk out due to social pressure, then why did she breach the social mores when it can to the encounter with Indra.</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>**********</em></strong></blockquote><p>He had no business cursing either of them just because he could!!. Who is he to harass them both with such a curse??!!</p><blockquote><strong><em>******[Raghu Bhaskaran] He can and should, for it was a breach of trust. He was the affected party and capable of levying punishment, so he did.</em></strong></blockquote><p>Imagine a man with a 1000 vagina. Surely he would only get disgusted looking at any woman’s vagina.</p><blockquote><strong><em>******[Raghu Bhaskaran] That would have been the purpose of the punishment. To wean Indra off such philandering. Like the cigars in the movie Padaiyappa. A surfeit of things would cause, the person to lose the taste for it.</em></strong></blockquote><p>Imagine the plight of Indra’s wives after that!! Hasn’t Gauthama been unreasonable to them all as well??</p><blockquote><strong><em>******[Raghu Bhaskaran] Not at all, this is like argument against criminalizing Triple Talaq. Every criminal would have a family, who would suffer if the criminal was punished. But that is no excuse not to punish a crime, else many more families will suffer.</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>Indira’s wives were involved for they had a relationship where the husband was philander. Besides who is to say, that they weren’t relieved to have their husband punished and reformed. Maybe they too were in an unhappy marriage. If we are speculating, that also is possible.</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>*********</em></strong></blockquote><p>Even assuming he had the right to, he curse Ahalya to become almost like a stone!! If he was such a great rishi, should he first not have asked if she wanted to even continue living the life as his wife? She might have preferred being the lover of Indra and not being respected in the society rather than being Gauthama’s respectable wife!! Was her choice ever considered by anybody at all??!!</p><blockquote><strong><em>******[Raghu Bhaskaran]</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>Nobody is under any obligation to consider another’s choice. If we are talking about independent agency for women, the accountability and responsibility lies with the individual. Male or female, they have to act and speak and not wait around for being asked. That is not independence.</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>Beside, was Gautama ever asked in the epic, whether he wants to marry Ahalya, what was his preference, was his choice ever considered, what if he wanted to be the lover of some apsara? His greatness perhaps lies in the fact, he did not commit any breach of trust.</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>And if Ahalya wanted to be Indira’s lover, wasn’t she being inconsiderate of Gautama and Indira’s wives?</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>**************</em></strong></blockquote><ul><li>I have heard a variation in the version of the story — Gauthama returns and by then Indra has fled from the house. Gauthama sees Indra outside the house and curses him. This part of it is unknown to Ahlaya. When Gauthama returns home and asks whether someone came home in his absence, she tells “Majjara” implying a cat. One can also do a Sandhi Viched and look at it as “Ma Jara” implying my lover. This version of the story shows how intelligent and quick-witted she was. Was her intelligence ever appreciated as much as her beauty even by Indra himself??</li></ul><blockquote><strong><em>******[Raghu Bhaskaran]</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>Didn’t you speculate that Brahma gave her only beauty and not other aspects, now she is quick-witted and intelligend?.</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>But anyway, dissembling with word play is not held to be virtue. Yudhistra tried that with “Aswatthama hatha,naro va kunjaro va” — still his fame and chariot came down, for it was held he swerved from the truth, when he let Drona believe his son died.</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>**********</em></strong></blockquote><ul><li>There’s another way of looking at the irony of her life. As long as she was married to Gauthama, she actually lead the life of a stone. She had to curtail all her wishes — but she could physically move around. But after the curse, she was physically still but her heart had the freedom to fly and think anything it wanted. Such is the irony of a woman’s life!!</li></ul><blockquote><strong><em>******[Raghu Bhaskaran]</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>Exaggerated, every person in life is bound by different ties and bonds, many inherited, many chosen of volition. Gautama’s curses were perfect if seen as reformatory, the philanderer suffered a surfeit to cure him. Ahalya who gave in into Indriya-Sukha, had to live immobile as stone — indirya-nigraha, until she could conquer it, perhaps that is what Gautama meant, that she still had “halyas”, until she preserved and truly became Ahalya — his curse became a medium for her to live up to her name.</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>Typically the curses of the Sages, indirectly make the individual and the world better. I would be more worried about the boons of the Devata, mostly inflames asura prakriti.</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>************</em></strong></blockquote><p>There are still a million women on earth who lead Ahalya’s life. They are constrained in a love-less marriage. And one moment of “weakness” or wanting to enjoy their life, they are branded so badly. Isn’t it the responsibility of both husband and wife to keep the marriage an enjoyable bond? A mangalsuthra or a ring does not define a relationship. It is the feeling of togetherness, companionship that defines the relationship.</p><blockquote><strong><em>******[Raghu Bhaskaran] Sure, that is a perspective. But are all men happy with their marriages? Are they all excused for their weakness. Gender is only one of many factors. Such tribulations affects us all.</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>Yes, mangalsutra or rings don’t define a relationship. But they symbolize it. Valuing them is an external expression of the internal meaning.</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>Wearing them alone does not mean the relationship is healthy, neither would discarding them mean that it is healthy.</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote>**********</blockquote><p>I see Ahalya as an intelligent, independent woman with a modern outlook who chose her path of freedom and love rather than living a repressed life. I see her as a courageous woman and hence I bow to her. I accept her as a “Pancha Kanya” who chose to fight for themselves (not because of their chastity) and set an example!! Hats off to you Ahalya!!</p><blockquote><strong><em>******[Raghu Bhaskaran]</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>I respect her as a person who overcame an exceptional situation. I respect a culture which could worship such a person, as a Devi. In any other culture her legacy would have been just that of an adulteress.</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>The Pancha Kanya were all exceptional cases — adultery, polyandry, niyoga-vidhva, levirate etc. Each of them took on extraordinary trials in life and at the end shined by their virtuousness. One would not wish the challenges they faced on any women, they can’t be role models to be literally emulated, but still teach us valuable lessons of life.</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>Though I gave counter points to every interpretation in this post, I am not insisting that points are correct and the interpretation is incorrect. But just proving that multiple conclusions can be arrived at from the same text, depending on one’s own biases.</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>And we should always be aware of that. Applying current day causes and morality to legendary tales, is just a ploy to appropriate archetypes. I would rather apply the learnings from the legends to better my life and society.</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>Dharma is eternal, change is eternal, so the forms of dharm will be ever changing, so it has to be rediscovered for every new context of Kala, Desha, Varna and Ashrama. And these legends are amazing resources which prepare us to do that.</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>ahalyā draupadī kunti tārā mandodarī tathā ।<br>pañcakanyāḥ smarennityaṃ mahāpātakanāśinīḥ ॥</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>Ahalya, Draupadi, Kunti, Tara and Mandodari<br>One should forever remember the panchakanya who are the destroyers of great sins</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>**************</em></strong></blockquote><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8aa582e1951" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Me, Mongoose and Made Snana]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@raghu.bhaskaran/me-mongoose-and-made-snana-30ff0f0ba0cd?source=rss-f6d757e3687b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/30ff0f0ba0cd</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[mahabharata]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[RB]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 04 Jun 2018 21:15:09 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-06-04T21:15:09.093Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>In recent months, some friends and followers, have reached out saying that I should write more, blog and even contribute to magazines.<br>I am bit flattered and also apprehensive.</p><p>Even friends who know my not-so-reputable youth, are of this opinion. Allegations like “storehouse of the knowledge” are being leveled. I will not refute it entirely though, I have had enough peeks into such storehouses, through the windows.</p><p>But to best describe my state, is the verse from Kenopanishad,</p><p>nAham manyE suvEdEti no na vEdEti vEda cha |<br>yo nastadvEda tadvEda no na vEdEti vEda cha ||</p><p>I do not think that I know well, nor do I think I don’t know, but I know. <br>He amongst us that understands — “Neither do I know, nor don’t I know” — really knows.</p><p>I know this piece from Kenopanishad, but do not know Kenopanishad itself. This is the case with most of my knowledge.</p><p>Many people take Arjuna, Krishna, Karna etc. as their favorite characters and role models from the itihaasaas. But I choose to liken myself to the mongoose, from Ashwamedha Parva of Mahabharatha. <br><a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ashvamedhika_Parva#The_fable_of_mongoose:_animal_sacrifice_or_compassion">https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ashvamedhika_Parva…</a></p><p><a href="http://www.sacred-texts.com/hin/m14/m14090.htm">http://www.sacred-texts.com/hin/m14/m14090.htm</a></p><p>Serendipity has lead me to some yagna-salas, the works/company of some wonderful people — from heritage, family, friends, teachers and even on social media.</p><p>I roll around in the crumbs of their work and some stick to me. So whatever shine I have, it is only in parts and is borrowed from such accomplished people.</p><p>Still I will confess to an inquisitive mind, a modicum of self-skepticism and respect for the contexts of other people.</p><p>My claim is not to knowledge, but to discernment.</p><p>All the rolling around, has given me a reliable nose, for what is gold and what is not.</p><p>*********<br>Recently I had an interaction with a person whose profile and self-proclamations glittered, but a particular viewpoint was not gold. He was disparaging of the Made Made Snana, recently in the news. (Links below, please do read the one from Indiafacts)</p><p>Initially I posited that such a ritual is not for me, though I would defend the rights of those who wished to.<br>Then considering the supercilious judgement exhibited by the person, I realized that if I ever was thus judgemental, such a snana would be the perfect purification for my mistake.</p><p>After all the Mongoose of Mahabharatha, did a “Made Snana” in a sense and achieved its golden coat.</p><p>Now the argument is that Made Snana would work, only if rolled/bathed on the leftovers of true rishis and brahmanas (not just of birth). But the problem is how do we know them. Unlike my interlocutor today, they are not going to self-certify themselves. <br>Even if per Sturgeon’s law, “90% of anything is a waste, but the remnant is worth the trouble for its own sake”<br>So like the mongoose, we can’t pre-judge the nature of the yagna or the worthiness of those who perform it. We can only roll and then find out.</p><p>Of course, I am talking about the Made Snana in multiple aspects. But in our tradition, the external expressions complement the internal evolution.</p><p><a href="http://www.thenewsminute.com/article/made-snana-ban-proposal-tribe-dakshin-kannada-threatens-boycott-festival-70254">http://www.thenewsminute.com/…/made-snana-ban-proposal-trib…</a></p><p><a href="http://indiafacts.org/made-snana-another-case-dismantling-hindu-practices/">http://indiafacts.org/made-snana-another-case-dismantling-…/</a></p><p>My gratitude to the wise- yajamanas and panditas, in whose crumbs I roll and shine; And apologies for any presumptions of knowledge.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=30ff0f0ba0cd" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>