<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by rain laniakea on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by rain laniakea on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@rainlaniakea?source=rss-a6ef9030c792------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 00:40:26 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@rainlaniakea/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Oh, Keberagaman Mental]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@rainlaniakea/oh-keberagaman-mental-944078d6ab4c?source=rss-a6ef9030c792------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/944078d6ab4c</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[rain laniakea]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 14 Jun 2026 12:32:15 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-06-14T12:36:50.230Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Racauan Semester Tua</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/500/1*JN0d3XAgg8FvMN75nWl_hg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Jangan Lupa Senyum :)</figcaption></figure><p>Belakangan ini, diriku mungil sering merasa ada yang tertinggal dari diskursus keseharian kampus. Aku pun ingat bagaimana unggahan BEM FIB UI mengenai Hari Kesadaran Autisme Sedunia memicu candaan mengenai autisme. <em>Kontol</em>, kata gue. Bukan karena gue adalah <em>si paling beda</em> yang gak ngatain temen gue pake kata <em>“autis”</em>, tetapi karena, sayangnya, perilaku seperti ini mencerminkan permasalahan lebih dalam mengenai keberagaman: pengucilan, mau kasar atau halus, terhadap mereka yang bertindak “tidak waras”.</p><p>Keberagaman mental ini emang fenomena yang gak gampang. <em>Conceptually speaking, </em>emang ia semacam turunan dari permasalahan “Gak ada yang pernah tau isi kepala orang lain”. Lo ngatain orang “boti” karena baju, gestur dan gaya ngomongnya gak sesuai iklan Gudang Garam. Lo ngatain orang “item” karena warna kulit, rambut dan logatnya gak sesuai iklan Pepsodent. Keberagaman mental, di sisi lain, <em>gak ada yang pernah tau. </em>Gue gak cuma ngomongin orang yang coli di tengah jalan ataupun tindakan-tindakan “ekstrem” lainnya. Itu jelas keliatan. Maksud gue jugalah orang-orang yang bisa lu ajak ngobrol biasa tapi kayak ada yang janggal. Mereka menggunakan kata-kata umum, berpakaian dan bergestur sebagaimana orang pada biasanya, namun sepertinya <em>tidak sefrekuensi.</em></p><p>Jujur aje, koleksi umpatan gue banyak dan beragam, tetapi bukan berarti gue sengaja nge-<em>judge</em>, ngejauhin ataupun nyakitin orang “aneh”, mau itu yang aneh dalam perbuatan, perkataan atau pikiran. Sebagai seseorang yang cukup cakap dalam menggunakan kekerasan verbal, <em>lo lo pada mending belajar jaga mulut lo dah. </em>Sesekali iseng boleh lah: kita semua <em>butuh hiburan.</em> Seneng juga ngetawain orang <em>gila, ya kan?</em> Cuma gak usah digebukin lah: Itu orang coli di KRL gak usah di-<em>ini-ini</em>-in banget lah. Ketawa boleh, cuma <em>mikir juga mas </em>kenapa dia ampe begitu. Bantu sebisanya. Kalo gak bisa, gak usah dibawa ke hati.</p><p>Gak usah juga lo sok temen-temenin banget si temen lo yang rada aneh itu. Kita adalah manusia yang terbatas, dengan kepedulian yang terbatas. Kalo lo emang seneng sama dia, <em>gas. </em>Kalo kagak, gak usah sibuk-sibuk ngatur dia. Biarin aja lah. Terserah lo mau anggep tu orang lagi <em>senewen, gila </em>ato<em> putus cinta. </em>Bisa kali belajar urus idup masing-masing. Dia yang tidak ataupun belum terdiagnosa bukan berarti dia <em>harus sama seperti dirimu</em>. Gak usah sebar-sebar urusan idup dia juga ke orang yang lo baru temuin di tongkrongan:<em> Ngentot, mereka sokap??? </em>Pun, mau seberapapun lo tolak, tidak menutup kemungkinan bahwa dirimu sendiri lah yang <em>aneh. Jangan-jangan ente yang caper </em>:)</p><p>Maaf, maaf. Kasian aja gue ama beberapa temen-temen gue. Udah kayak <em>public enemy no. </em>1 cuma karena mereka <em>rada-rada</em>. Masa jurusan yang belajar “kritis” segini doang “kritis-nya” <em>(oops)</em>— nyalahin individu daripada komunitas, institusi atau lingkungan sekitarnya? <em>Gak berani kah berhadapan dengan dosa-dosa diri sendiri?</em></p><p>Belom lagi yang kepikiran mulu apa kata orang lain. Padahal orang lain kagak ada tuh yang mikirin keluhan mereka. Ada sih. Gue. Hahaha<em>… Salam skizoanalisis. #peace</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=944078d6ab4c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Bantai Aje Orang Manado]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@rainlaniakea/bantai-aje-orang-manado-97b8987a886b?source=rss-a6ef9030c792------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/97b8987a886b</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[rain laniakea]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 23 May 2026 23:37:21 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-05-24T08:58:36.772Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Misanthropies #4</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*YVY2JDbhh8eQUDpd4QCYvQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>Hidup yang <em>“gini-gini aje” </em>sebagaimana kuceritakan ke kawan lama jumpa ketika bertanya <em>“how’ve you been doing lately?”</em> sebenarnya sedang dihantui pikiran-pikiran jahat akibat meninggalnya orang tua dua teman asal Jaktim. Diriku kecil ikut berduka tepat di malam-malam mereka pergi, ngeliat langsung sosok sang anak yang masih sempet-sempetnya <em>neken </em>biar kawan dan kerabat gak <em>sok iye sok sedih </em>pas di tempat. Yang satu di rumah, yang satu di Carolus; dua-duanya korban privatisasi kesehatan yang cuma nguntungin <em>Crazy Rich Asian </em>Lippo Group. Oh tenang, gue gak rasis. Cokin benteng disuapin <em>hustle culture </em>dari kecil tapi di umur 80 cuma bisa ngewarisin toko elektronik ke anaknya dan ngerasa gagal gak bisa bangun dinasti à la keluarga Hartono. <em>No War but Class War</em>.</p><p>Ya mungkin kecuali kepada orang Manado. Gue jadi sering ngebayang-bayangin skenario orang tua gue sendiri meninggal. Beda sama kawan-kawan Jakarte gue, Tangsel <em>geist </em>dalem gue pengennya sih nyayurin kerabat pake botol <em>Guinness </em>(<em>I love Guinness!</em>) kalo ada yang coba-coba bilang “yang sabar ya”. “<em>Get off my property!”</em> seperti <em>redneck </em>yang ngibarin bendera <em>confederate </em>depan rumah ketika ngeliat tukang pos kulit hitam naro surat 5 cm ngelewatin wilayah imajiner-paranoid mereka akibat negara yang makin hari makin mengabaikan epidemik <em>male loneliness </em>dalam nama DEI berlandasan nilai-nilai liberal dengan menggunakan interseksionalitas sebagai metrik <em>oppression olympics</em>.</p><p>Sana-sini <em>basodara </em>tapi giliran anak gak setuju malah ngutip ayat Alkitab. <em>Siapapun yang menampar pipi kananmu, berilah juga kepadanya tangan kananmu. </em>Ngapain gue sok ramah sama orang-orang yang melorotin nyokap-bokap gue, yang selama 21 tahun gue berkelana di muka Bumi ini, cuma nyamperin <em>either </em>karena BU, ngundang “acara”, ato ngurus warisan. Itu kakek gue udah kejang-kejang di kubur <em>gilak — </em>gitarnya dijual begitu aja. Ibarat kalo <em>dress </em>dan baju-baju gue yang “Ini kan baju cewek” dijokul biar gue bisa “fokus belajar” dan jadi laki yang “gak boleh nyakitin cewek”.</p><p>Makanya, kalo salah satu nyokap-bokap gue ada yang mati, gue angkat tangan bergembira joget ke <em>Ballad of Matt and Mica, </em>dan nyuruh keluarga buat “serah lo dah” dan <em>atur sebrengsek mungkin. </em>Gile aja nyokap gue nge-<em>call </em>gue terus walaupun gue gak pernah angkat <em>like can’t you take a hint?</em> Tiap kali ngobrol udah kayak ngobrol ama tembok, dan bukan <em>drywall </em>yang mana lu bisa denger tetangga ngedesah “enak banget, puji Tuhan Yesus Kristus Bapa Kami di Sorga”, tapi beton yang ngingetin “Kan gaada yang tau kapan Mami mati”. Sumpah kalo ni orang mati gue bakal seneng sekaligus menyayangkan bahwa beliau adalah korban <em>patriarchal conditioning </em>rezim jamannye (<em>Fuck</em> Orba dan Neo-Orba)<em>. </em>Iya, gue #DoItForHer, tapi dia <em>highkey gotta stop </em>sotoy kayak seniman cetakan Jakarta yang pake <em>buzzword </em>filsafat buat ngejual karya dan cabulin cewek <em>with even the slightest interest in art </em>(<em>Fuck </em>GM dan Sitok Sangenge).</p><p>Belom lagi bokap gue yang planga-plongo kagak hadir selama hidup gue (anjir gue berasa <em>cringe </em>udah kayak XXXTentacion). Doi yang “sibuk kerja” ternyateeeeee sibuk ngebayar silop yang ngeplorotin his <em>dumbass, FUCK N — CAN’T SAY IT — lil’ bro</em> karena kegep <em>make</em>. <em>SHIT, can’t use that word without a</em> Kurasu <em>matcha-sipping BITCH in my ear comparing me to 16-year-old, gentrified </em>sekolah intern Kanye <em>fans; telling me I need to educate myself</em>. Keluarga gue baru tobat dari <em>assault and battery </em>di generasi gue dan masih luput gelagat <em>BCIMFSS</em>. <em>Your bitch ass </em>nolak make <em>n-word</em> karena takut PR lo jelek (yahaa kena <em>white guilt </em>kan lo, <em>colonial fuck</em>), gue jarang make <em>n-word </em>karena gue sadar diri dan gak enak nge-<em>sok-iye-sok-deket </em>ama orang Afro-Amrik.</p><p>Tapi gue dah gak bisa boong lagi, emang bokap gue kayak <em>stereotypical</em> <em>black father </em>yang, walau mungkin cukup beruntung bisa bikin keluarganya tinggal di <em>suburb</em>, masih <em>absent </em>karena secara tidak sadar perlu bayar utang simbolik biar setara sama <em>the</em> <em>hwite man</em>. <em>We are not the same, </em>terutama ama skena Jaksel yang nganggep diri <em>underground </em>tapi dapet iklan sama Spotify, tapi <em>nge-strip black culture </em>dari <em>political significance</em>-nya — karena gue tau lo lo semua <em>privileged</em>, <em>just like me</em> (<em>Fuck </em>JXL dan WBJ). Mana mungkin punya <em>taste </em>akibat <em>internet access </em>itu kalo gak karena duit haram proyek pemerintah atau perusahaan tambang. <em>Bitch ass n — (still can’t say it), </em>padahal GUE yang punya darah VOC.</p><p>Lu kalo mau <em>psychoanalyze </em>gua, ya mending kagak usah sih. Gue sendiri udah <em>schizoanalyze this dividual multiplicity </em>dan mencapai sebuah <em>half-assed conclusion</em>: sentimen kritis gue terhadap <em>pemrentah </em>(ACAB) bersumber dari kekecewaan sedari fase Oedipal terhadap <em>any semblance of authority</em>. <em>I don’t buy </em>segala upaya “cara kekeluargaan” karena interaksi di keluarga Manado ekuivalen dengan <em>operation MKUltra </em>yang mana LSD digantikan dengan celetukan pasif-agresif “tamu harus dijamu”. Mending kalo mintanya Cap Tikus, ini mintanya kasih sayang seperti Yesus mengasihi keduabelas muridnya. Sini sepong <em>this tranny dick </em>dan inget bahwa <em>political correctness does not mean positionality and reflexivity. Count me out </em>dari rezim identitarian lo karena gimana gue mau ngurusin makam ortu kalo kangen aja kagak bisa. Peduli setan ngebuka aib keluarga <em>cuz ion need nobody’s spiritually Israeli cookie points</em>.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=97b8987a886b" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Please Leave Me Alone]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@rainlaniakea/please-leave-me-alone-2bd516623e66?source=rss-a6ef9030c792------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2bd516623e66</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[rain laniakea]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 24 Apr 2026 12:55:33 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-04-24T12:55:33.295Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Misanthropies #3</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/992/1*CB0ToTic9oUOEDOuiaM4Nw.jpeg" /><figcaption><em>Dead Mother, </em>Egon Schiele (1910)</figcaption></figure><p>Nothing strikes harder than realizing your fundamental inability to care. Gun to my head: “Name five people you’d die for!” I’d think for a bit, say a few names, stutter while saying them — precisely because I’m doubting my choice of names, end my list unsatisfied.</p><p>I’m never satisfied. Nobody’s told me that, so it’s not like it’s a trauma response that I think I’m never satisfied. In fact, people tell me I get satisfied too easily — when someone finally cares about me, I take it for granted. I take <em>people</em> for granted. I’ve always been afraid to admit it. But it’s definitely something I have to say out loud. I would be lying otherwise.</p><p>When I’m thinking of the list of names, I try to come up with reasons. “He’s been a good friend. Stayed by my side even though I act like shit sometimes.” “She raised me, always trying her best to bring food to the table.” I weigh them with each other to see who deserves a mention. In weighing them, I realize I’m reducing people to how I feel about them. The truth is that <em>it’s not the truth.</em> What if they hate being nice to me? Does my mother secretly want me dead? “No, you mean the world to me” is what she’d say. I don’t — rather <em>can’t — </em>trust those words. Not when she keeps reminding me that she’ll die any second and I have to learn how to live by myself.</p><p>I don’t wanna live by myself. I don’t wanna <em>not live for myself</em> either. I’ve learnt that two things can be true at once. But it takes so much energy. Or, maybe, I’m afraid that it’d take so much energy. I’ve lived my life spending so much energy. Saying a word takes so much energy. Smiling at my crush — whose mere presence, whose mere attention, is supposed to make me naturally happy — takes so much energy. Even, writing this takes so much energy. I’m sure keeping two things together true takes more energy.</p><p>And it’s not like I can’t imagine a hand holding me through my shot in the dark. <em>I can, </em>but, just as quickly as I imagine this hand, I’d hope whoever is the unlucky bearer of it dies. I hope everyone dies. I hope you all die, all those who tried caring even a splinter of me. This is what you get. Nobody’s asking you to care for me. I’m a narcissistic prick who can’t seem to care for anyone but themself.</p><p>But it takes even more energy to keep being so sure. The truth is a lie I have to keep investing in. It’s so much easier to spiral into madness. Or, more precisely, it’s so much easier being told I’m mad. People keep reminding me of how great I am. I’d like them to stop lying. You’ve seen how cruel I can be. Do you not remember that I left you hanging when you said you needed a friend? Do you not remember how I told you that you’re worrying too much? You people are so easy. You people forget so easily that I get to manipulate you. I’m making the truth up by virtue of your forgetting. I hurt you. Don’t forgive it so easily.</p><p>Never have I ever said sorry first. At least, that’s what I remember. I have never come up to a person I know I’ve hurt and said, “Hey, I realized how much my actions hurt you. Just wanted to say sorry.” I’m too much of a pussy to do that. It would ruin their day to be put on the spot like that. They’d have to forgive me or else they’ll suffer the guilt of being an unforgiving person.</p><p>So, please, leave me alone. Let me spiral into madness. I’m sure it’s what everyone else is doing — else they would be as much as a prick as I am.</p><p>Please just let me die. Just let me rot in silence and die in a ditch. Don’t ask questions. Don’t come to my funeral. Don’t even remember my name. I want attention and keep telling everyone how badly I wanna kill myself. But, more than that, I wish everyone I know would just hang themselves on a rope or shoot themselves in the head. Go kill yourself.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2bd516623e66" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Thank You, Chainsaw Man]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@rainlaniakea/thank-you-chainsaw-man-6808f1c6067a?source=rss-a6ef9030c792------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6808f1c6067a</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[rain laniakea]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 28 Mar 2026 01:29:52 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-03-28T01:39:41.539Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>I liked the ending, I liked the manga :) (spoilers)</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/746/1*rw_jWITlaoXA-VxBZuN4Vg.png" /></figure><p>Break week right after the penultimate chapter was definitely the <em>edge</em> of a lifetime. But, there I was on March 24th, around 9.30 p.m., waiting desperately for how Fujimoto will tie up the series. By the time 10 o’ clock hit, I was in the middle of a conversation with my friend. I checked my phone, saw it was 10, and told him I had to stop for a bit. I had to <em>lock in</em>: t’was the end of an era.</p><p>Two weeks prior, I’d tweeted (<em>X-ed?</em>) about <a href="https://x.com/rainlaniakea/status/2031598852932096274">my own little speculation for the ending</a>. So when the chapter came, I was sorta happy that I was sorta right. (I like being right, I am always correct). Read the first few pages with excitement, and I myself was content with the story ending on Denji dying. Yet, turns out the page count hadn’t even reached halfway. And, turns out, at the brink of Denji’s death, Fujimoto pulled a Goodnight Punpun-style “wake up!” by bringing Power into the scene. That got me <em>real </em>happy because I know what’s coming next: “This is the part where Fujimoto shows his hand for a full house.” Not the double aces kind. He’s been bluffing his way through the third act of Part Two. The all-too-extended fight with Yoru, the <em>death of Death — </em>all beginning with Nayuta’s head being served on a plate — convince you enough to keep betting that the story is going nowhere. Yet, “My role is to be a switch”, Aging Devil’s world, the heart-to-heart with Asa, and <em>Denji Man </em>get your doubts up. And you fold as soon as Denji loses to some random no-name devil that sprung out of nowhere. Everyone folds. We lose to a seven-deuce from someone who’s got a weird (albeit definitely my type) sense of humor.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*QGzrAyVPaerozZ5MU2wHeQ.png" /></figure><p><strong>The Fear of Living</strong></p><p>“Well, isn’t that just how life is?” is the sentiment a lot of people seem to have. It may not have been a good idea to scroll through Twitter (do I really have to call it X?) right after finishing the chapter. That’s a whole nother can of worms. Back on track, I’m not 16 anymore so I kinda find the sentiment corny. I, though, am 21, in the third year of my undergrad degree, with no sense of direction in my life.</p><p>So, you know what? <em>The ending hits, </em>with all its humor and absurdity. I became a subscriber to Dream Theory and Life Devil Theory because it’s what made sense to me as I try to make sense of the real world. <em>Chainsaw Man</em> has this way of playing with notions — as all pieces of art do, and, yes, <em>do look deep enough</em> — with its characters. Not saying that they’re not meant to be autonomous agents within their own rights, but look at it this way: when you meet someone, you get to know them, you interact with them — you inevitabily comprehend them through<em> your own eyes. </em>When your friend does nice things to you, you get the sense of what <em>niceness </em>is through your interactions with them. Of course, they’re not wholly nice; there’s so much to them that you don’t know, and that even if you <em>do </em>know the not-so-nice things they’ve done, you don’t <em>feel </em>that way<em>. </em>When you have a friend that’s controlling — always asking what you’re up to, always telling you who to be friends with and who not to, always being the one to punish you when you violate their terms, even if they make it seem like it’s fate asking you to pay up, they embody Control within your life.</p><p>Fujimoto has made it clear that the Devils represent fears. They canonically feed upon the fears of mankind to get stronger, so might as well make the equation. Yet it’s always been a question whether Pochita truly is the Chainsaw Devil or not. There’s the argument that chainsaws represent birth because they were used for childbirth. But there’s no need for this argument if we try to understand what Denji and Pochita’s contract really meant: an idea, a <em>fantasy</em>, of “life” made up in the head of a dying teenager to keep himself living. To battle against the very fear holding him down, he must make amends with it somehow — not being able to overcome it, he <em>gives in</em>, he shakes the Devil’s hand, he makes a <em>contract</em>. The trauma response, the coping mechanism. Following this line of thinking will also lead to the conclusion that, rather than being the Chainsaw Devil, Pochita was the <em>Chainsaw Man Devil</em>. “Chainsaw Man” is Denji’s idea of Life: Be the Hero, Get the Girl, Eat Good Food! <em>Yes, it’s a critique of the Hero’s Journey: A movie ends, life continues — it need not be like in the movies</em>.</p><p>And it’s not as if we, in the real world, don’t wear costumes everywhere. We walk around with much confidence in public despite how much a little comment — “You’re late again!” — makes us cry. And we tell ourselves that we shouldn’t cry over a simple comment, so we don’t cry. Yet, when it keeps happening, we burst out and blame everyone, even those closest to us. <em>Black Chainsaw Man</em>: we throw a tantrum and hide behind our idea of Life. We point at others and hold them accountable for not doing Life properly. Of course, we only think we’re “holding them accountable”; in truth, we are repeating the very same violence done to us; we are enforcing our idea of Life on them. We wish we had a magic dog to help us turn into the Hero of Hell, and <em>we do have that magic dog</em>. We love it, we keep it, it keeps the fears away, it <em>eats </em>them. But it keeps eating away that everything becomes beyond our control. We let our idea of Life comfort us so much that the basic function of fear — a survival instinct that, by showing how little agency we have, reminds us to manifest our little bit of agency within the world — disappears. It is a dream. We all live in our own dreams, our own version of reality. But how far will we let our dreams of living take over the life we live?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*BTRliGG-Lglc28p_eIrSCg.png" /></figure><p>Until we open ourselves up to make genuine connections with others. The idea of Life shatters with the reality of living: “I wouldn’t like that because they wouldn’t like that.” Denji’s Part 1 declaration that he “wants to be Chainsaw Man” was one step in the right direction, though not quite there yet. So, it may well seem at first that this is the Devil winning its side of the contract again; we see the consequences of “wanting to be Chainsaw Man” in Part 2. But, this time it’s not: “They’re OK with me disagreeing. They remind me that I can choose.” Fear turns into conscience, something malleable, no longer absolute. We were all too ready to compromise with our fears thinking that it’s compromising with other people. Yet, we forget to understand them in the first place: we forget to sort out who’s important to us and who’s not, which opinions we can agree on and which not. Power, Aki, Asa, even Makima. Tell you what, turns out Makima’s <em>just a kid who needed more love, more affirmation, in her life</em>. Nayuta still has her tendencies, but it’s more manageable now that Denji knows how she is and what she needs.</p><p>So, of course after having that whole mindscape heart-to-heart with Asa (Total AsaDen Victory By The Way) Pochita concedes. He’s back to his <em>near-death state</em>; Denji’s grown to understand Asa. Despite Yoru allowing him to have sex, despite Denji not visibily being able to distinguish between Asa and Yoru, his <em>chainsaw-dog-heart </em>knows. Denji’s soul won in the end. The idea of Life was there to keep him living, but it seems that, now, the lives (Life-s) of other people are in conflict with it, and with comprehensible cause instead of fatal mystery. He knows <em>how</em> to live now, instead of simply wanting to live in abstract rebellion against unmerciful fate. The idea of “Chainsaw Man” no longer needs to be the absolute guide to his life: he can ask his friends. It can be the heart that keeps beating in him, it can be <em>drive, </em>but it no longer needs to be All There Is To Life. The death of this idea, then, brings the death of the other fears so that they may be reinterpreted anew: Control (affirmation of the self), War (conflict with others), Famine (failure to survive), Death (the divine judgment that is the consequences of our actions), and such and such. We reset, we take a step back to really think about them. We let them go. We live again. We keep on dreaming, though quite a bit more freely this time.</p><p><strong>The Mirror, The Other</strong></p><p>“What about Asa?” Yeah, I was pretty disappointed there wasn’t a chapter or two to really get into Asa’s side. I felt seen by those early Part Two chapters that’d have Asa’s long in-her-head monologues, going back and forth in anxiety (she’s so me, you don’t get it). I wish we got to see how Asa grew from the third act, too.</p><p>Here’s my little take on Asa. It’s clear Asa fears life too. Of her biggest fears, it’s fearing the potential conflict that comes with interaction (War). Just look at how afraid she is to make friends. She even, at one point, said she didn’t need friends. Yet she’s so envious of the “normal life” her classmates live. She’s clearly been held back by this fear yet wants to overcome it so bad. So, at the critical moment, she makes amends in the style that Denji does: a <em>contract</em>. “You know what? Sure. I’ll go to War with people.” She lets the idea of War guide her life: It Is How People Work. People Fight. People Kill Each Other. Without truly understanding which wars are to be fought, when, where, why, how. Trauma response, coping mechanism. She asks the first guy to talk to her to become her boyfriend in an attempt to “be more selfish”. She lashes out against her abusers. And then, she goes on lashing out to the world. “I am you,” Yoru says. <em>They’ve always been the same person. Asa let herself be War.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*A0HZVucwaQ0RrL3W8AfPLA.png" /></figure><p>To add onto that, it makes sense that Yoru turns those she deems have lost to her into her “weapons”. Only through feeling superior can someone with Asa’s state of mind trust another person. But, it comes at a cost of silencing them. And this cost needs to be paid continuously: Keep thinking of them as your tools, keep being mean to them. Keep killing them so you don’t die yourself. It’s a fragile kind of “trust” that probably shouldn’t be called so. (I can’t think of a word for it at the moment). Kinda like toxic masculinity, huh.</p><p>So, I’m all for representation of female agency. Though, you know, <em>Denji does not strictly need to be interpreted as male. </em>Again, male-ness is an idea that each person born with a penis is forced to live up to. Which they can fight. I’m going on a tangent. Alright, I think that the ending reinforces Fujimoto’s statement that we are stuck to our own eyes and what we see of the world. It’s a way to hit the nail on the head: Everything is seen through the lens of the titular <em>Chainsaw Man</em>, of course. This is <em>his story</em>. Cannot be otherwise. You are back to your own vices. Your story. Asa isn’t suddenly reduced to the plot device that is the Love Interest, <em>there is no one that is not a plot device. </em>Even Denji is a plot device, that of a pilot seat. And through the meta-emphasis of this pilot seat, Fujimoto reminds us that we may never absolutely know, absolutely understand another person: we may have a sense of what they are, what’s best for them, but you have no right in making absolute judgment. You, reader, are, in the end, <em>another person</em>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*4h0YzrA4xfqkL-7xmo9Rcw.png" /></figure><p>But what can be is that <em>you see yourself in the other </em>and the <em>other within yourself</em>. This moment of double recognition opens us up to reflecting on what should be done within our life in consideration of other people. You don’t know their story, you haven’t lived it. You can, however, <em>listen</em> to it and get somewhat of a grasp. And you can continue to renew and adapt — rather than <em>linearly </em>improve, again, not to assume that there is a fixed destination, a complete version — that grasp the longer you choose to connect with that person. Of course, there’s always the risk of conflict: the disagreements and the disappointments that come after. Yet, paradoxically, that risk seems less scary the longer you connect. We find certain people that we’d rather not connect with, but that realization only comes <em>after the fact</em>.</p><p>We get smarter choosing who to spend our time and attention with by, well, trial and error. You’ve felt comfortable with certain people and uncomfortable with certain others. Having seen yourself in another person, you open up the possibilities that you’ve held yourself back from. “I don’t like this person, but they’re a good person. Well, at least, the evidence says so”. You’re willingly setting aside that conscience of yours because it’s in the way of Good Ol’ “Reality”. With the company of these “mirrors” of yourself, however, you start feeling sure of your conscience. “No, no. I still don’t like them, because my friend wouldn’t like them; <em>I</em> wouldn’t like them.” This notion is what Asa brings to the narrative, and it’s what made Denji realize that his life does not have to be that of Chainsaw Man. “<em>Fuck this or that, I — no, WE, can live how WE want.”</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*Z16ZvVRxZyOmiXy6qOdADw.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*oygM23NwPogeuONrVMNYDw.png" /><figcaption>He literally grows up 😭</figcaption></figure><h4>Closing Thoughts</h4><p>I realize how hard I’m projecting here. And the AsaDen cope is definitely playing a big part. But, all in all, I’m grateful that the ending got people talking about <em>le themes and such</em>. And all the fanart too! I do agree that Fujimoto rushed the ending in the sense that he felt pressured by deadlines. Even if he could take as many breaks as he wanted, I think that he also felt the pressure to not keep the fans hanging for too long. If I had that many people who read what I wrote, I would feel the same too. Though, nobody reads my stuff. Argh.</p><p>It’s — as many have said — bittersweet. Bitter as in one of my favorite series is ending. Sweet as in I’m happy with what we got. I do think that there might have been better ways to end it off, but, at the same time, I can’t imagine how. <em>Chainsaw Man </em>has helped me understand myself and the world around me a little better. Fujimoto’s poetic ambiguity tends to allow room for that. So many things unresolved but that’s really not a problem. It’s fun when authors let you speculate and draw your own conclusions. “Let the art speak for itself” is <em>cliché </em>but it’s not half-bad. I hope we get more of whatever this is in whatever he’s making next. I saw the vision in Fire Punch and I see it clearer after <em>Chainsaw Man</em> finished. I did see it too in his pre-CSM one-shots and <em>Look Back</em> (film). Though, I haven’t taken the time to read <em>Look Back</em> and <em>Goodbye, Eri</em>. Will get to that as soon as possible, especially the latter.</p><p>With that said, I do hope that it’s a female lead next time. Part of the reason people got disappointed was because of how well Asa was written as a protagonist in the first act of Part 2. Or, at least, that’s how I feel. I hope Fujimoto takes the risk; there’s definitely potential. Oh, especially if you saw or read Look Back. Or even the one-shot where a guy turns into a girl, or the one where it’s about two sisters. He definitely knows what he’s doing. Maybe, <em>he’s a she</em>. Who knows.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*-_WweHlFKOnsKkiRYVWxhA.png" /></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=6808f1c6067a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Ternyata Gue Orang Jakarta]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@rainlaniakea/ternyata-gue-orang-jakarta-2df4f6d7d24f?source=rss-a6ef9030c792------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2df4f6d7d24f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[jakarta]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[poetry]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[rain laniakea]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 15 Jan 2026 14:22:17 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-01-15T14:48:12.331Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Misanthropies #2</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*utVuidYCmKg5NUv0aLN2zQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>Beres balik dari Bandung rasanya hampa banget. Kayak, darah gue penuh tapi <em>mana</em> gue kosong. Lari ke Bandung pun malah akhirnya ketemu setan-setan Jakarta yang selama ini kagak gue anggep. Gue kira gue cuma Manado-Jawa. Zonk.</p><p>Maksud gue Jakarta pun bukan Jakarta Utara-ke-Selatan, Barat-ke-Timur doang. Wilayah apa pun yang dijangkau Commuterline™ udah kerasukan hantu Jecartah. Iya, bacanya harus Jecarta kayak Bule. Beda kayak Bule di Bali yang tinggal <em>di-viral-keun</em> biar diusir, Bule di Jecartah adalah para Jakartans itu sendiri.</p><p>Gue pas ke Bandung kagak ngerasain perbedaan apa pun dari Jakarta. Gue menolak kemakan romantisasi Bandung sebagaimana <em>disarankam di bandung </em>menceritakan (Tapi sejujurnya, ada sewaktu gue bengong di Taman Ganesha sambil baca buku). Awalnya sih ada sedikit rasa keseruan yang muncul. Udara baru <em>fren</em>. Tapi, hari makin hari, ya gitu-gitu aje. Bandung cuma Jakarta tapi lebih kecil. Kayaknya.</p><p>Tapi mungkin perbedaan yang paling mencolok dari nirperbedaan itu adalah tingkah laku temen-temen Dasun gue. Lebih waras sih, dibanding pas mereka di Jakarta. Lebih <em>guyub</em> tepatnya. Malesnya pun makin keliatan, iya, tapi di antara sekumpulan kami-kami, malah gue yang jadi paling males. Ibarat butuh <em>hahaneutan </em>mulu. Kalo gak, mesin gak sanap-sanap. Mana ada lagi nih satu kawan yang ngibrit ngeliat <em>awewe </em>FSRD. Gue juga sih. Kesepian gue.</p><p>Suatu ketika, di tengah suatu agenda <em>nggur </em>kami, tuh setan muncul depan muka gue. Kami lagi <em>having fun, </em>ngobrol-ngobrol goblok setelah puteran kedua, dan gue kerasukan rasa bingung. Kenapa ya, ketawa gue palsu (#fakesmile)? Kenapa ya, ketawa gue palsu <em>melulu? </em>Palsunya juga bukan KW premium tapi <em>knockoff </em>toko <em>“thrift” </em>yang<em> </em>sablonannya rusak beres dua kali cuci. Di tengah ramai sukaria ini, mengapa aku terus merasa sendirian?</p><p>Mak gue sering bilang, “lahir sendiri, mati sendiri” (atau semacamnya lah, gue aja lupa persisnya beliau ngeracau apa). Entah bagaimana, kayaknya alam fikir gue udah keracunan mantra begituan. Gue pun ngira itu cuma cara beliau menghibur gue yang harus besar di keadaan <em>broken home</em> ini. Tapi lama kelamaan, gue makin sadar Dosa Besar Jakarta yang merajalela. Ternyata, temen-temen perantau gue lama kelamaan ketularan Al-Gengsi. <em>The Jakartan Dream</em>. Lo bukan orang Jakarta kalo gengsi lo gak tinggi. Semakin deket Jakarta Pusat, semakin deres gengsi mengalir. Gengsi telah melahap banyak nyawa dan laparnya tak kenal henti. Kembang desa dari daerah ia tandai sebagai korban selanjutnya. Biasanya sih yang di bawah umur. Ati-ati ama vokalis yang suka ngasihanin dirinye.</p><p><em>Beuhhhh</em>, di UI kerasa banget. Ampe urusan OSIS-OSIS-an aja pake nodong beceng. Gak tau beneran apa kagak, cuma udah gak aneh aja pas lewat TL. Kolam besar butuh gigi besar bos. Tapi goblok juga ya jadi hiu di kolam. Kolam <em>still</em> kolam, mau lo isi air brapa banyak pun. Kolam darah ye apa lagi: Adu kontolnya kenceng banget. Cewe di Jakarta bahkan harus punya kontol gede. Kalo kontol lo gak gede, gimana mau jadi KOL? KOL-alias-<em>influencer-</em>alias-pedagang mimpi?</p><p>Usut punya usut, ternyata mata uang di Jakarta adalah mimpi. Tapi, gue cuma pengen mimpi basah, cuma pengen <em>ngaloco di dieu. </em>Gue cuma pengen coli sembarangan. Biarin dibilang gila, lo pada juga pengen coli, kan? Yahaa, gak bisa coli sembarangan. Al-Gengsi selalu memantau! “Masturbasi menurunkan tingkat testosteron dalam tubuhmu!” Inget, semakin rendahnya testosteron, semakin rendahnya kemungkinan naik jabatan. Padahal udah gak ketampung banget. Kayak Ken Arok pas ngeliat sekilas paha Ken Dedes. Cabul lo!</p><p>Wkwkwk. Sayangnya, Al-Gengsi masih sering ngebisikin kuping gue. Sayangnya, gue masih nengok dari Utara-ke-Selatan, Barat-ke-Timur: Sayangnya, gue masih mastiin bahwa gak ada yang mau nikam gue pas gue ejakulasi di kamar mandi gue sendiri.</p><p>Lahir sendiri, mati sendiri. Semoga, suatu hari, makan bergizi emang beneran gratis. Kalo gak, Jakarta tenggelem duluan ama gengsi. Stop lah bikin lapangan padel.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*S45GPa866HKFv_tk90fWbQ.jpeg" /></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2df4f6d7d24f" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Attention, and Why You Are (Not) A Victim]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@rainlaniakea/attention-and-why-you-are-not-a-victim-4afe6eb23fac?source=rss-a6ef9030c792------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4afe6eb23fac</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[culture]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[poetry]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[rain laniakea]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 11 Oct 2025 05:53:40 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-10-11T06:10:28.389Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Misanthropies #1</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/736/1*t2E4e1jZrdzR4HrOUpH36A.jpeg" /><figcaption>How did we get here?</figcaption></figure><p>Attention is nice. Some use it to get around, navigate through social spheres and benefit. Some are hooked to it; they get high when all eyes are on them. And to a certain some, it is the very life force that keeps them alive, it is <em>nourishment</em>. No need for food, or water, <em>“Mama, Papa, look at me!”</em> is the motto.</p><p>It’s <em>just a phase</em>™ for some and a lifetime subscription for others. I mean, <em>I</em> bought into it once (maybe even a little still today). But it’s a shady business: it rots you from the inside, makes you forget what’s important — food, water, and <em>friendship</em>. It’s like the creepy old guy peeking out his white van, saying, “Hey, kid, you want some of this?” It promises glory, wholeness; the bright garden of sunshine and sunflowers — the <em>happy ending</em>. And then it grabs you by the mouth, and you scream and think you need to scream even louder, but by the time you know you’re fucked, it’s too late. The chloroform’s taken in (do they still use that nowadays?) and there’s nothing you can do.</p><p>You wake up on a chair. There’s surgical equipment everywhere: syringes, scalpels, scissors. Then there’s the amateur doctor with his dead stare. He’s a machine you can’t negotiate with, completely soulless and just there for the job. He slices your arm a little and checks how you respond. You let out only a little “Ow!” which is enough for him. He continues the procedure and cuts you open. It hurts a lot this time, and <em>it’s big</em>. You scream. He keeps going. The cut gets deeper. You scream again, louder, but no one’s there to get you. Things fade to black, <em>you can still dream</em>, but you’re no longer really there. Something about the apparatus to your left, attached to your arm, is keeping you alive. Yet it’s pure delirium from here on out.</p><p>So you dream. Papa and Mama sit at the dinner table without screaming at each other. You won first place at that English competition back in third grade. Your crush sent a letter back, with little ribbons and all. You never took an interest in reading because everything <em>already made sense</em>. You got good at football (whichever one), and kept up with school. You got into that Ivy League University, into actuarial science, or business, or electrical engineering — something <em>useful.</em></p><p>“<em>Putain</em>, it’s beautiful!” (you’ve dreamt of France) you say to yourself. And I won’t disagree with that, neither the French nor the beauty. You wake up at the side of the road, and you start looking for this dream. You run around without realizing you’re hollow; your organs are all gone. You ask a man sitting beneath an electric pole. He says dreams are made up of “the good stuff,” as he takes another of I-don’t-know-what. He then says, “You’ve got the guts, kid!” You don’t get what he means and move on. You go to the convenience store and ask the cashier. “We don’t sell cigarettes here,” he says. You get angry as you forget whether you’re looking for the dream or for your organs, whether there’s a light at the end of the tunnel or the big bad wolf chasing you throughout — you never find out.</p><p>You’ve been dealt a bad hand. You should’ve gone with a strategy, instead of betting for the thrill of it. Or at least that’s what you keep telling yourself, even though deep down you want to say that you’re hurt. So many hours spent swimming in tears, yet you refuse to say that someone violated you. You were <em>fucked over</em> by someone who does the <em>fucking over</em>. No, you did not <em>fuck yourself over</em>. Someone runs the game, the dealer wanted to cheat you the whole time. And this being —<em> these beings</em> — who did the fucking over needs you to fuck it over.</p><p>You go around looking for Mama. “I’m hungry!” you say to everyone. No one responds, because <em>no one is Mama</em>. But you never look back at the times when Mama, your biological mother, or guardian or whoever plays the part, breaks her bones for you. You’ve gotten so high with delirium that you can’t even see the love right in front of you.</p><p>Oh, what an insult every time someone complains they’re depressed or suicidal or whatever. Just say you feel like shit because someone was being mean to you, or that you’re not used to working this much or SOMETHING. We have words for these things, and we have words for other things. Not everyone will understand, <em>but at least you know who cares and who doesn’t.</em> This misplacement of words is what makes psych-majors get into HR — and work for companies with questionable ethics — instead of clinical psychology and living their initial dream of “wanting to help people”. I’m sorry, <em>I would rather keep throwing shit at Oedipus than feed the very social structure that enforces it</em>. Even worse is when they act as if no one else is feeling like shit; or that only certain people can feel shit because “they’re just like me”. We <em>all </em>feel like shit sometimes, but we do have time for you. So just say what you need to say instead of jumbling it up with words because we simply don’t look like Mama: we can never be Mama (not even your biological mother can be!), Mama was just a pain-induced dream; Mama was the-man-in-the-white-van-plus-shady-doctor-plus-chloroform all along.</p><p>I do consciously think some people deserve to die, and it’s precisely this that keeps me away from having hateful obsessions. Some level of self-honesty is good. Going around strengthening the defenses of your words-fortress is missing the point; you should’ve stayed a trade village. Of course, there are bandits once in a while, but know who the thieves are, instead of worrying every time merchants come. Don’t become the Despot, don’t fall for the paranoia.</p><p>It’s not as if no one agrees on which things cross certain lines. At least those closest to you can agree when you’ve been fucked over, and that fucker-over deserves to be fucked over too; or, in <em>restorative </em>words, deserves whoever or whatever fucked them over to be fucked over too. I mean, again and again, it’s the dream of few that’s fucked over so many, and that very dream has ascended to become a boogeyman in the back of everyone’s head. There’ll be a lot of fucking over to do, because what we must fuck over is beyond a fucking over some <em>one</em>.</p><p>It’s this very dream that got you here. Everybody wants love. So, the boogeyman goes around saying, “You’ll be loved, if and only if …” He speaks his terms, and even though you know it’s a scam, you fall for it anyway. Because you want to <em>be something</em>; to be seen for once.</p><p>But to be seen by what? By who? And how are you so sure it is <em>you </em>doing the wanting? Did the boogeyman meet you by chance — the queue’s caught up to you — or did he plan this meeting all along? Are you sure the dealer and the boogeyman aren’t working together? Are you sure the bandits got in because you didn’t keep enough guards around, or that you didn’t scream loud enough for Mama? You know, for someone who’s lost all their organs, you seem to say “I” and “me” a lot. <em>What even are you without your organs, oh Narcissus?</em></p><p>It’s confusing, isn’t it? Are we victims or losers? When we get down, why is it that we always “hate the player”, but never the game? Oh, the boogeyman also tells everyone: “Life’s a game.” And we keep buying into it, don’t we? Is life, by its very nature, in its pure state, really analogous to a game? Or did someone <em>make it a game — </em>and we know that those behind the game are seeking to profit? Why don’t we ever question this? Why do we keep playing instead of getting together to finally say, “your rules are rigged”? Why do we instead blame the person sitting next to us for winning this round’s bet, when we know they’ll be fucked? And when they do lose the bet, they’ll either put in more money or get the offer to be a dealer (especially if they’re so deep into debt — and they have no choice).</p><p>Are we a victim of the people around us, or something deeply rotten about the world? Have we sought attention from the very thing that hollows our insides, instead of being honest to the few who care — those who nourish us? Are we living inside the dream-delirium of some evil men who’ve adorned themselves with the robes of gods, and, in our compliance with this <em>game</em>, we’ve continued to allow the hollowing with our very own little piece of dream-delirium? How deep does the rabbit hole go, and how latently immanent has it become?</p><p><em>“Beware of the Other’s dream.</em>”</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4afe6eb23fac" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[idup gue gini-gini aje di sini-sini aje]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@rainlaniakea/idup-gue-gini-gini-aje-di-sini-sini-aje-d17f2fd12a9c?source=rss-a6ef9030c792------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d17f2fd12a9c</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[rain laniakea]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 18 Sep 2025 17:35:11 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-09-18T17:35:11.832Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/736/1*PLo9ntVtRBuoitHeF0wAcg.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>*sebelumnya maaf nulis ginian dan secara sadar menentukan upload ke medium</em></p><p>capek cok. apa-apa asem lambung, belom lagi asem muka. ntar lama-lama asem urat. bangsattt</p><p>rasanyeee bentar lagi gue mati, hari-hari jadi binatang jalang di kebon binatang yang udah ga ada kandang. orang-orang belaga waras tapi disentil dikit ngambekan, kayak anjing gak dikasih makan — kayak <em>anjing</em> aja sih wkwkwkwk. suap-suap cuap-cuap ego yang sok dingin kayak es batu tapi suhu naik dikit mencair langsung, siap ndan!</p><p>seru ngetai-taiin orang tanpa sebut nama, soalnya jaman sekarang apa-apa UU ITE ato gak UU Perampasan Aset karena gue hari-hari ngerasa kayak aset yang dirampas. kayak tobrut lagi jalan di gang diliat-liatin sama preman yang sange, pengen ngegrepe tete gue. dikira gue pelacur? wkwkkw, pelacur juga punya harga diri, pren. satu ronde satu menit doang juga diketawain lo haha</p><p>gatau ye emang mungkin gue kalo ngomong insensitif dan tidak selayaknya mahasiswa di <em>world-class university </em>tapi emang gue sering ngerasa gue pengen ngelapor ke satgas karena gue udah diperkosa tiap hari. <em>fair-fair</em>-an aja, gue tau otak gue cakep tapi gausah tuh main asal pegang aja, dikit-dikit muji, main jilat-jilat aje. najis bego liur lo, jigong bau udah kayak tai kambing sebelom dikurban.</p><p>kapitalisme kapitalisme ini emang tai ye, dikira orang layak dikapitalisasi terus dibuang abis crot dalem. tai lah dikira perek ga punya martabat apa? semahal-mahal <em>rate card </em>orang juga bukan berarti dia milik siapa pun bos! ya kecuali <em>influencer </em>yang jual harga dirinya ke setan hahahahaha itu mah kembali ke masing-masing aje dah.</p><p>jujur pengen hidup tenang, banyak pikiran tapi mikirin yang penting-penting aje. dibenci banyak orang juga gapapa, <em>ga dianggep banyak karena ga banyak yang gue anggep. </em>apa gue bunuh diri aja ye? … ga ah, tunggu kelar bikin mahakarya dulu. ya lagipula, hidup aja udah cukup mahakarya.</p><p>umur ga ada yang pernah tau tapi yang gue tau adalah: sekarang gue dipandang sebelah mata, 10 tahun lagi <em>juga dipandang sebelah mata.</em> makasih ke orang baik yang ngingetin gue itu. semoga 10 tahun lagi PSK udah diregulasi biar pejabat ga main buang gue di lorong belakang klub lagi, biar Stadium gak kejadian lagi.</p><p>semangat all 🌻</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d17f2fd12a9c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Sandiwara Politik Kelas Menengah]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@rainlaniakea/sandiwara-politik-kelas-menengah-5e4fd5ae2805?source=rss-a6ef9030c792------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5e4fd5ae2805</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[indonesia]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[activism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[society]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[rain laniakea]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 30 Jul 2025 17:04:01 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-07-31T16:10:04.300Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Tirani Identitas dalam Mitos Gerakan Mahasiswa dan ‘Vanguardisme’ Influencer</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/975/1*MyKY71prVo-Whqp2fBXiGA.png" /><figcaption>Aksi #IndonesiaCemas BEM SI Rakyat Bangkit; Foto asli dari detik.com.</figcaption></figure><p><em>Untuk para korban kriminalisasi aksi Mayday kemarin.</em></p><p>“Gue di sini, gak ke mana-mana, kalian gak sendiri” ujar seorang <em>influencer</em> dengan lebih dari <strong>satu setengah juta</strong> pengikut di platform YouTube, pada aksi #TolakRUUTNI hari Kamis tanggal 20 Maret 2025 kemarin. <em>Bung Ferry</em> mengatakan ini melalui laman X/Twitter-nya, dan menghadapi dukungan maupun hujatan oleh warganet: Ferry dipuji karena rela meluangkan waktu dan mempertaruhkan karirnya — <em>nyawanya</em> — demi membantu massa di titik aksi; ia juga dianggap norak oleh beragam pengguna X, dari <em>haters</em>-nya hingga makhluk-makhluk kiri Twitter (karib dilabel ‘SJW’) — ataupun mereka yang keduanya. <strong><em>Ferry-lah sang sosok Eren Yeager yang menuntut Marley untuk menebus dosa-dosanya, dan kami para Yeagerist akan bertumpah darah membela mimpinya;</em></strong><em> </em>sang <strong>warga sipil</strong> ini yang merintis dari bawah untuk menantang yang di atas.</p><p>Tapi, seperti Eren Yeager, Ferry bukan asal rakyat jelata. Ferry ternyata memiliki kekuatan <em>Founding Titan</em>: retorika serta gunung rupiah di belakangnya yang mampu digunakan untuk merekayasa persepsi masyarakat, demi mengikuti kepentingan dirinya serta kroni-kroninya. <em>Founding Titan </em>pun diwariskan dari zaman ke zaman; pada tahun 1996,<strong> PRD, diketuai Budiman Sudjatmiko,</strong> mendeklarasikan bahwa <a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20150709025533/http://peace.home.xs4all.nl/pubind/p/280696.html">(Partai Rakyat Demokratik, 1996)</a>:</p><blockquote>… Berdirinya Partai Rakyat Demokratik (PRD) merupakan salah satu manifestasi dan jawaban untuk menjawab kebekuan dan kebuntuan dari alat-alat politik ekstra parlementer, serta meningkatakan kualitatif gerakan rakyat menuju suatu masyarakat demokratik multi partai kerakyatan yang damai, tanpa kekerasan.</blockquote><p>Mungkin gunung rupiah yang dimiliki PRD tidak setinggi milik Ferry; jangan lupa, Indonesia mengalami krisis moneter pada tahun 1998, sehingga kalau diuji <em>rupiah-for-rupiah</em>, pasti Ferry jauh lebih kaya. Kendati demikian, mari arahkan perhatian kepada pengaruh — kuasa — yang mereka sama-sama miliki terhadap masyarakat luas; <strong>suara khas <em>Bene Gesserit </em>yang dapat mematuh berbagai lapisan masyarakat untuk bersatu di bawah tujuan yang Sama.</strong></p><p>Peristiwa lucu lain di tahun ini adalah dualisme BEM Universitas Indonesia, sang <em>universitas terbaik di Indonesia</em>, yang menggaungkan ‘Tuhan telah mati!’ kepada abang-abang pergerakan Depok, khususnya yang di dalam <em>ormeque</em>; karena yang gak <em>ngolah </em>gak peduli, <em>wkwkwkwk</em>. Sebenarnya sih, Nietzsche tidak datang <em>ex nihilio </em>saat mengucapkan demikian, ada Schopenhauer sebelumnya yang bengis terhadap Hegel, sang <em>Pelindung dan Penyelamat Terakhir</em> BEM Kuning. Schopenhauer melihat pencerahan Jerman lahan-perlahan retak oleh karena jumlah korban yang ia lahap: <em>anti-Semitisme yang pada tahap akhirnya menjagal enam juta Yahudi</em>. Dualisme BEM Seluruh Indonesia sudah mewanti-wanti, <strong>namun sayang IKM UI tetap Idealis — Jerman.</strong> BEM Ungu tidak lain hanya rahasia Badan Eksekutif Mahasiswa yang selama ini disembunyikan: <em>kekopongan kontrak sosial antar mahasiswa yang akhirnya mengamuk dan meledak;</em> <strong>tumor ganas akibat terlalu banyak menghisap rokok di berbagai warkop Kukusan sembari <em>plotting-</em>an dan bagi-bagi jatah antara abang-abangan pergerakan.</strong> Aksi Indonesia Cemas kemarin pun BEM SI Rakyat Bangkit akhirnya berhenti malu-malu:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/975/1*XbZubX8ASdhnBBDocBriiw.png" /><figcaption>*Hiks*</figcaption></figure><p>Jadi, patut dicurigai, <em>apakah perwakilan perubahan ini sementara, disepakati dan membebaskan? Ataukah ia mengikat, meminggirkan dan membungkam? </em>Apakah Ferry, BEM dan berbagai ‘elemen oposisi’ lainnya mewakilkan kebutuhan dan keinginan masyarakat? Ataukah ia terlebih dahulu merancang tuntutan dan memerintahkan, “Ini yang kalian inginkan” — melarang permintaan-permintaan yang liyan, aneh dan <em>tidak waras</em>; pada akhirnya, mempertahankan struktur kekuasaan yang, depan orang banyak, ia akui sebagai lawannya?</p><h3>Mitos Gerakan Mahasiswa</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/975/1*COCwr5sJeu41AWDcJFbSYg.png" /><figcaption>Gedung DPR, 21 Mei 1998</figcaption></figure><blockquote>“Betapa sering mereka yang menyaksikan keindahan menyesal tidak memotretnya. Begitu berhasil sang kamera berperan dalam memperindah dunia sehingga foto, alih-alih dunia, menjadi standar keindahan.”</blockquote><blockquote>Susan Sontag, O<em>n Photography, </em>hal. 65</blockquote><p>Seperti potret mantan, potret aksi mahasiswa begitu indah dilihat. Ragam latar belakang bersatu untuk menghancurkan rezim Soeharto atas keresahan kolektif yang tidak lagi rela berkorban demi ‘pembangunan’-nya. Dan, tak hanya mahasiswa, berbagai kalangan kelas pekerja — buruh dan tani — berkumpul, berserikat dan mengeluarkan pendapat jujur mereka; mendukung gerakan terorganisir mereka demi menciptakan perubahan.</p><p>Namun, juga seperti potret mantan, manis senyumannya hanya sejengkal gambar dari kenyataan — toh ia sudahlah mantan, bukan? Di balik memori persatuan, ternyata segala sesuatu jauh lebih kompleks: <strong>mahasiswa dikedepankan oleh media sebagai aktor pergerakan, sedangkan kelas pekerja hanya sekadar <em>supporting character</em> atau bahkan <em>damsel-in-distress</em> yang perlu diselamatkan. </strong>Yang sekarang diingat dari PRD adalah peran mahasiswa dalam mengorganisirnya — betapa rapi, jelas dan berwibawa perlawanan mereka akibat mahasiswa yang <em>terdidik dan rasional</em>;<em> </em>bukan pengorbanan buruh dan tani yang mempertaruhkan kestabilan finansial keluarga mereka <em>yang bahkan sudah tidak stabil</em>. <strong>Dilupakan bahwa sebagian alasan dibentuknya PRD — yang merupakan <em>persatuan </em>sebelum ia <em>partai</em> — adalah atas kekecewaan terhadap gagalnya pergerakan mahasiswa di tahun 1978 dan kebuntuan pergerakan mahasiswa serta LSM di tahun 1980-an </strong>(Lane, 2008).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/975/1*XYKQDbln6UOKuJQFzglGrQ.png" /><figcaption>Partai Rakyat Demokratik</figcaption></figure><p>Sang mantan <em>toxic </em>ini pun terus menerus merayu: “Ingatkah betapa indahnya hubungan kita? Aku merasa bersalah akan <em>segalanya</em>…” <em>Yeeeeeilah… masa segalanya sih…</em> Minta maaf sana-sini udah kayak abang-abang pergerakan yang sekarang dapet kursi aja nih… Ntar, nganggep tiada sejarah antara kita lagiii… Ya kan, <em>Mas Fadli</em>?</p><p>Ternyata nge-<em>ghosting </em>mantan baik juga ya… Jadi kepikiran, <strong>ke mana wibawa dan organisasi dan rasionalitas itu pasca jatuhnya Soeharto? </strong>Kanan-kiri lahir partai politik rebutan kursi, di mana Partai <em>al Gaib </em>yang menyelamatkan kita semua? Ohhh… ternyata ketum sama sekjen masih di Cipinang <a href="https://www.historia.id/article/prd-dalam-pemilu-1999-Drg2b">(Matanasi, 2023)</a>… Kenapa? Salah <em>deal-deal</em>-an kah? Oke, udah lah, kasihan si Budiman. Bandel kena, gak bandel kena. Lagian ini udah masa lalu kok… Nanti gimana dia mau mengepalai Badan Percepatan Pengentasan Kemiskinan dengan tenang dan tentram?</p><p>Tapi memang pintar si Budiman ini. Kalau bandel, ia masuk penjara. Kalau tidak bandel, paling hanya kena kritik kolom opini media alternatif yang gampang diselimuti <em>brainrot </em>algoritma — tinggal bayar <em>buzzer</em> saja. Mungkin ia juga paham bahwa <strong><em>mitos gerakan mahasiswa </em>merupakan rawatan negara agar muncul sosok oposisi dalam masyarakat: “Demokrasi berjalan kok!” </strong>Namun, “jika kritik dan protes mahasiswa dipandang mengganggu tata tertib serta tatanan yang ada … maka represi dan koersi tak segan-segan digunakan”: <em>sebuah strategi ‘permen atau pentungan’, bila perlu dinamakan</em>. Mahasiswa lantas digambarkan bukan sebagai “kelompok politik yang berusaha mendapat kekuasaan, melainkan kekuatan moral (<em>moral force</em>) yang secara aktif ingin ikut berperan dalam mencapai cita-cita negara” (Radjab, 2023).</p><h3>‘Vanguardisme’ Influencer</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/975/1*DsepJP6smS0fHBeaQC8pJQ.png" /><figcaption>Lenin dan Revolusinya</figcaption></figure><p>Sudah tidak zaman lagi Partai <em>al Gaib</em>, sekarang waktunya <em>Lisan al Gaib. </em>Datanglah dari surga-surga sang Imam Mahdi yang siap membangun <em>kuliah baru </em>dan <em>revolusi intelektual</em> dalam upaya memimpin masyarakat awam ke masa depan yang cerdas dan sejahtera. Lenin toh bilang <a href="https://www.marxists.org/archive/lenin/works/1922/mar/12.htm">(Lenin, On the Significance of Militant Materialism, 2002)</a>:</p><blockquote>Salah satu kesalahan terbesar dan paling berbahaya yang dilakukan para Komunis … adalah gagasan bahwa suatu revolusi dapat diwujudkan hanya oleh revolusioner saja. Sebaliknya, agar berhasil, semua upaya revolusioner perlu menerjemahkan dan memahami gagasan bahwa para revolusioner mampu berperan hanya sebagai <em>pelopor (vanguard) </em>kelas yang tangguh dan maju menjadi tindakan nyata. <strong>Suatu pelopor berperan sebagai pelopor sejauh ia dapat menghindari keterasingan dari massa rakyat dan sesungguhnya mampu memimpin seluruh massa tersebut ke depan.</strong></blockquote><p>Entah bagaimana, mungkin pesan Lenin ini terlalu dihayati oleh <em>kamerad-kamerad </em>Malaka Project, sehingga mereka dengan gamblang menafsirkan <a href="https://www.marxists.org/indonesia/archive/lenin/1902/ApaYang/index.htm">(Lenin, Apa Yang Harus Dikerjakan?, 2014)</a>:</p><blockquote>… Tidaklah cukup menamakan diri kita sendiri ‘pelopor’, detasemen depan; kita harus bertindak sebagai itu; kita harus bertindak begitu rupa sehingga semua detasemen lainnya akan melihat kita, dan <strong>terpaksa mengakui bahwa kita berjalan di baris depan.</strong></blockquote><p><em>Bray</em>, itu makhluk kiri Twitter bukan sembarang makhluk. Mereka mendalami teks klasik dan riset kiri mentok, mau itu orientasinya komunis atau anarkis. Oh, ya jelas mereka gerakannya tidak kelihatan — <strong>lupa sama de-Soekarnoisasi yang membantai pembelajaran dan pergerakan kiri?</strong> Tidak tahu Soeharto mengirim <em>firemen </em>untuk membakar 2.000 buku yang membahas Marxisme-Leninisme, komunisme, sosialisme, Maoisme dan PKI? Lupa dengan genosida anggota maupun tertuduh anggota PKI serta organisasi terafiliasinya? (Hidayat, 2022, hal. 80).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/975/1*7Zg2JjedaIsCBIZS4m7grQ.png" /></figure><blockquote>“Gambar-gambar yang terasingkan dari segala segi kehidupan menyatu menjadi suatu aliran yang sepenuhnya menghilangkan kesatuan dari kehidupan tersebut. Pandangan yang terpecah belah mengenai kenyataan bersatu menjadi suatu kesatuan baru sebagai <em>dunia semu</em> yang hanya dapat dipandang.”</blockquote><blockquote>Guy Debord, S<em>ociety of the Spectacle, </em>hal. 7</blockquote><p>Apakah pergerakan penuh kehebohan dan gebrakan setiap harinya? Atau justru ia telah bersembunyi — tersembunyi— di zaman yang menyebarluaskan gambar, sensasi dan perhatian? <em>Influencer-influencer </em>yang keras menampilkan dirinya di mata publik, menokohkan dirinya sebagai <em>pelopor</em>, tentu membuat tontonan yang baik; <strong>satu setengah juta pengikut tidak datang dari kekosongan. </strong>Tapi mengapa mereka, apabila sejatinya mendorong perubahan radikal, belum dipentung? Dan maksud penulis dipentung bukan hanya didorong membuat video klarifikasi berlagak dalam bahaya… Saluran YouTube mereka masih ada. Dengan perhatian sebanyak itu, akun-akun sosial media mereka tetap masih ada, tanpa tantangan nyata dari negara untuk menghanguskan pengaruh mereka…</p><p>Dari notulensi teklap yang dijual hingga <em>influencer </em>yang sibuk berlagak juruselamat, pergerakan sudah lama dikomodifikasi. Gerakan seakan-akan sudah menjadi <em>life-style</em>: baca Tan Malaka dan rencanakan ‘revolusi’ di warkop terdekatmu! <strong>Ya, persetan revolusi yang dimaksud hanya mengubah dirimu dan sekelompok kawan-kawanmu menjadi pejabat. </strong>Gerakan adalah <em>mindset</em> — <em>grindset </em>bahkan, di sebelah Akademi Crypto dan Hustlers University.</p><blockquote>“… Ialah penganggukan maha hadir dari pilihan yang sudah dibuat dalam lingkup produksi serta konsumsi. Dalam keduanya bentuk dan isi, sang pertunjukan <em>(spectacle)</em> berperan sebagai pembenaran penuh terhadap kondisi dan tujuan sistem yang ada.”</blockquote><blockquote><em>Society of the Spectacle, </em>hal. 8</blockquote><p>Oh tenang, bukan <em>influencer </em>saja yang bersalah. Toh akhirnya, sandiwara memerlukan banyak pemain: rantai dan roda gigi dalam mesin yang terus menerus memproduksi narsisisme dan ketakutan akan penyimpangan — <em>perbedaan</em>. <strong><em>Bhineka Tunggal Ika tai anjing </em>ketika melihat orang memiliki kepercayaan non-monoteistik, atau mengaku identitas gender selain laki atau perempuan cis. </strong>Media tradisional, penulis hingga akun-akun media sosial ‘gerakan’ juga banyak yang melanggengkan kekerasan di balik romantisasi pergerakan: terlalu terjerumus ke dalam narsisisme mereka atau memang bermain hakim dalam mengecap apa yang ‘gerakan’ dan apa yang ‘marah-marah tidak jelas’.</p><p>Sebuah studi oleh Ralph Schroeder menelusuri bagaimana narasi sayap-kanan berhasil dijual di Amerika, India, Swedia dan Cina melalui media digital: Donald Trump dan Narendra Modi melalui Twitter, Demokrat Swedia melalui koran <em>online</em>, dan Cina dengan nasionalis-nasionalis <em>onlinenya</em>. Studi ini menyimpulkan bahwa gagasan-gagasan populis ‘menantang’ dan ‘melawan’ partai-partai yang sudah mapan, politikus-politikus partai tersebut dan media yang terafiliasi entah itu partai atau pemerintahan. “Semua jenis populisme bersifat anti-elit; di sini daya tariknya — <strong>pasukan moral melawan elit yang tidak responsif.</strong> Isi dari populisme mereka berbeda-beda, meskipun penguatan bangsa demi meningkatkan representasi tradisi khasnya dalam mewujudkan ‘rakyat’ umum bagi keempat kasus tersebut.” (Schroeder, 2018, hal. 78–79). <em>Sound familiar?</em></p><h3>Tirani Identitas</h3><p>Wahai mereka yang masih takut akan kerusuhan; menamakan segala unjuk rasa yang mengekspresikan kekecewaan dari hati sebagai ‘anarkis’, tanpa memahami apa artinya anarkisme terlebih dahulu. “Aksi tidak apa-apa, yang penting jangan anarkis!” dengan lekas mereka utarakan, <strong>lebih sigap membela aparat daripada rakyat.</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/730/1*9iRjNnhMw0WMzngg23qw8A.png" /></figure><blockquote><strong>“Hukum menentukan hanya kemiripan subjek-subjek yang dikuasainya, bersama kesamaan mereka dengan ketentuan yang ia tetapkan. Alih-alih melandaskan pengulangan <em>(repetition)</em>, hukum memperlihatkan, justru, bagaimana pengulangan akan terus mustahil untuk subjek murni hukum — para partikular.”</strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong>Gilles Deleuze, D<em>ifference and Repetition, </em>hal. 2</strong></blockquote><p>Perkenalkan, ini teman kita <em>Budi</em>. Semasa ia SD, guru PKn Budi sering mengingatkan bahwa Bung Karno, <em>Bapak kemerdekaan negara kita</em>, pernah mengatakan “Beri aku sepuluh pemuda, niscaya akan kuguncangkan dunia!” Di SMP, Budi belajar bahwa Soekarno memiliki sembilan istri, dan Budi sempat bertanya: “Pak Guru, bukannya seseorang hanya boleh memiliki satu istri? Mengapa Bung Karno memiliki sembilan istri? Apakah Bung Karno memiliki masalah berkomitmen?”. Pak Guru hanya menjawab, “Ya, namanya manusia, tidak ada yang sempurna. <strong>Yang penting kita ingat jasa dan pengorbanannya; buruk-buruknya jangan dicontoh.”</strong></p><p>Untuk masuk SMA, Budi pun bertumpah darah membujuk orang tuanya untuk tidak memasukkannya ke SMK. Budi memiliki peminatan terhadap sejarah: Budi ingin tahu berbagai kisah pahlawan bangsa Indonesia. <strong>Mungkin, suatu hari, Budi juga bisa jadi pahlawan. </strong>Namun, pekan ketiga semester pertama Kelas Satu Sekolah Menengah Atas, Budi terpaksa berhadapan dengan luka sejarah Indonesia yang mendalam: Gerakan 30 September. “Komunis bangsat!” pikir Budi, setelah gurunya menjelaskan gugurnya enam jenderal dan satu perwira.</p><p>Namun, beruntungnya, protagonis kita Budi lebih berhati-hati dari itu. <strong>Hatinya masih tergoyang saat mengingat bahwa Soekarno memiliki sembilan istri: tidak mungkin, tidak mungkin!</strong> Budi, yang sehari-hari gemar bermain <em>Mobile Legends</em>, kali ini mencoba menelusuri apa yang sebenarnya terjadi dibalik Gerakan 30 September di YouTube, alih-alih menonton <em>tutorial farming jungler terbaru. </em>Budi menemukan dua jenis video: yang pertama sama persis seperti ucapan gurunya — menggambarkan PKI sebagai bangsat masyarakat yang berhak dimusnahkan — dan yang kedua, walau tidak langsung menuduh, mempertanyakan keberadaan Jenderal Soeharto di malam pembunuhan.</p><p>Lompat ke kelas dua, semester satu, pekan empat, Budi telah melakukan riset pribadinya melalui YouTube. Ternyata memang banyak bukti yang mengarah pada keterlibatan Soeharto setidaknya dalam membenarkan pembunuhan PKI pasca-G30S. Sehingga, Budi menemukan tokoh baru, yang bukan Soeharto sang pembantai dan bukan Soekarno sang pemain: Tan Malaka, Bapak Republik Indonesia yang tersembunyi. <strong>“Ini baru pahlawanku, idolaku” dalam hati Budi. </strong>Mencari jejak-jejak Tan Malaka, Budi menyelam ke banyak lagi video YouTube serta — sebagai sumber baru, untuk memperluas risetnya — TikTok. Budi belajar bahwa kemunduran masyarakat Indonesia adalah karena <em>logika mistika</em>: cara berpikir kuno yang terlalu cepat menyimpulkan segala suatu hal. Setelah mencoba memahami penyakit <em>logika mistika </em>di iklim politik Indonesia, Budi pun menemukan ‘komunitas pergerakan’ yang ia incar untuk daftar sesaat ia masuk universitas: <strong>Organisasi Mahasiswa Eksternal yang merupakan ruang diskusi, bertukar pikiran dan merancang strategi untuk menuntut pemerintah yang selalu mengabaikan kepentingan masyarakat.</strong></p><p>Lantas, semasuk Perguruan Tinggi favorit (karena perlu diakui, Budi memang salah satu siswa paling pintar di angkatannya), Budi bergegas mencari komisariat terdekat dan bergaul dengan mahasiswa dalamnya. Budi menyukai lingkungannya: banyak kawan yang sependapat! Maka, Budi langsung mendaftarkan dirinya.</p><p>Semester tiga perkuliahan Budi mulai menyesal; ia telah berjabat tangan dengan orang-orang yang salah dan kehilangan banyak kesempatan. Sudah telat bagi Budi untuk keluar dari lingkungan sosial yang terus menekan dirinya: “Ingat ya, kami sudah memberimu ini dan itu! Kami mendidikmu dari awal dan kami memberikan rumah kepadamu!” Budi, yang tidak tahu lagi harus berbuat apa, berteguh hati dan terus mengatakan pada dirinya, <strong>“<em>Inilah pergerakan</em>, yang kelak membawa perubahan, dan setiap perubahan memerlukan pengorbanan.” </strong>Sayang sekali, Budi, padahal masih banyak ajang perubahan yang tidak sebegitu mengikat dan menyengsarakan.</p><blockquote>“Hukum mengutuk mereka untuk berubah. Sebagai bentuk perbedaan (<em>difference)</em> yang kopong, suatu bentuk keragaman yang tidak ragam, hukum memaksa subjeknya untuk menyerupainya dengan mengorbankan perubahan mereka sendiri.”</blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>Difference and Repetition, </em>hal. 2</strong></blockquote><p><strong><em>Oke, waktunya sedikit teoritis.</em></strong></p><p>Dalam <em>Anti-Oedipus</em>, Gilles Deleuze dan Félix Guattari merumuskan <em>tiga sintesis </em>dalam penandaan (<em>produksi hasrat</em>): <em>konektif, disjungtif dan konjungtif.</em> Sintesis konektif adalah penghubungan antara suatu hal dan dengan hal lain: “dan …” “dan juga …” Sintesis disjungtif adalah apa yang kita lazim paham sebagai <em>identifikasi</em>; hal-hal ditata dan dibedakan sebagaimana “antara … atau … atau …” Sintesis konektif adalah disambungkannya berbagai identitas menjadi suatu alur dan tujuan jelas: “ternyata mereka adalah …” (Deleuze &amp; Guattari, Anti-Oedipus, 2009, hal. 5, 12, 17). Alam bawah sadar mengarahkan <em>hasrat</em>-nya — keinginannya, tindakannya — sesuai hasil dari tiga sintesis ini: “Yang saya inginkan adalah X, Y, Z.”</p><p>Ketiga sintesis ini, namun, memiliki dua jenis masing-masing, berdasarkan penggunaan mereka: satu <em>eksklusif </em>dan satu lagi <em>inklusif</em>. Sintesis konektif antara antara global dan spesifik atau parsial dan non-spesifik; Sintesis disjungtif antara eksklusif dan restriktif atau inklusif dan non-restriktif; Sintesis konjungtif antara segregatif dan univokal atau nomaden dan polivokal (Deleuze &amp; Guattari, Anti-Oedipus, 2009, hal. 110). Jenis yang pertama menutup pemaknaan sedangkan yang kedua membebaskan pemaknaan. Deleuze dan Guattari mengingatkan kita untuk sekali-kali melihat dari sudut pandang yang kedua: <strong>kita perlu melepaskan identitas-identitas yang utuh, jelas dan satu, demi identitas yang terbuka, kabur dan ragam</strong> — <em>Bhineka </em>sebelum <em>Tunggal Ika</em>.</p><p>Kendati demikian, ada setan yang menghantui segala upaya kita untuk meragamkan dunia: <em>kuasa</em>. Pak Guru, Pak Dokter, Pak Polisi, bahkan Bapak sendiri semua mengatakan bahwa kebenaran adalah X. Sekalinya Budi menentang bapak-bapak ini, ia — mungkin tidak langsung dipentung — akan diingatkan bahwa ia ‘halu’ atau ‘terlalu imajinatif’ atau <em>“Ya, pokoknya begitu!”</em> Deleuze dan Guattari, dengan menulis Anti-Oedipus mengkitik posisi sang psikiater di ruang kliniknya: <strong>Apakah sang skizo <em>gila dari sananya </em>atau ia <em>dibuat</em> — <em>dianggap</em> — <em>gila</em> oleh sang psikiater?</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/975/1*qNS5cRmBVfYwe-iOepVvMA.png" /></figure><blockquote><strong>“Sang psikoanalis menjadi sutradara untuk teater pribadi, alih-alih insinyur atau mekanik yang merancang unit-unit produksi, dan bergulat dengan agen-agen kolektif produksi serta antiproduksi.”</strong></blockquote><blockquote>Deleuze dan Guattari, A<strong><em>nti-Oedipus, </em>hal. 5</strong></blockquote><p>Kelas menengah — yang selalu me-nengah, <em>selalu narsis</em> — adalah pusat dari masyarakat. Mereka adalah <em>representasi </em>atau <em>ide </em>dari suatu masyarakat: bukan pemerintah atau ‘penguasa’, namun juga bukan contoh-contoh yang bersimpang, seperti kriminal, atau <em>orang miskin</em>. Mereka adalah mayoritas yang, dalam pemikiran Deleuze dan Guattari, <strong>bukan sekadar <em>mayoritas secara kuantitatif, </em>melainkan suatu “konstan, ekspresi maupun isi, yang berperan sebagai tolak ukur [masyarakat]”</strong> (Deleuze &amp; Guattari, A Thousand Plateaus, 1987, hal. 105) — <em>mayoritas ontologis</em>. Dengan ‘mewakilkan’, mereka berkuasa dalam menentukan siapa yang patut disebut warga sipil baik dan benar dan siapa yang tidak: mereka punya sumber daya untuk bersandiwara di depan kelas pekerja, <em>sekaligus merekrut mereka perlahan-perlahan dengan janji manis kesejahteraan,</em> dan punya identitas nasional untuk mengganggu — setidaknya, <em>terlihat mengganggu</em> — pemerintah.</p><p>Maka, keberagaman hanya mampu wujud apabila kuasa berkehendak. <em>Namun, jangan lupa, sang skizo juga bisa marah-marah ke keluarganya yang terus memaksanya masuk RSJ.</em> <strong>Sang skizo, sebagai unsur sosial, juga memiliki kuasa. </strong>Persetan ia dibilang gila; ia ingin sesuatu dan ia akan mendapatkannya. Tidaklah mustahil mengumpulkan sejumlah besar skizo-skizo untuk marah kepada pemerintah; <strong>tidaklah mustahil membuat <em>gerakan skizo terorganisir </em>untuk menantang struktur kuasa yang berlaku.</strong></p><h3>Rimpang: Politik yang Terus Menerus Membunuh Dirinya</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/975/1*kX5ecCcImUHygbF4alrY8w.png" /></figure><blockquote><strong>“Suatu pertemuan, suatu penemuan, suatu gelombang besar mogok kerja, suatu gempa: segala peristiwa menghasilkan kebenaran dengan mengubah keberadaan kita di dunia. Sebaliknya, pengamatan apa pun yang tidak mengganggu kita, tidak memengaruhi kita, tidak menuntut kita kepada apa pun, tidak lagi berhak disebut kebenaran.”</strong></blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://theanarchistlibrary.org/library/comite-invisible-the-coming-insurrection">comité invisible, <em>The Coming Insurrection</em></a></blockquote><p>Membahas Deleuze dan Guattari rentan tenggelam dalam Efek Rumah Kaca dan taktik “menjadi batang ‘kan menjalar.” Apa yang dimaksud dengan rimpang?: <em>Apakah rimpang taktik gerakan atau kenyataan politik? </em><strong>Apakah rimpang dijadikan suatu gambar ideal pergerakan, ataukah ia relasi kuasa antar unsur yang perlu diperhitungkan? Apakah kita sudah menjalar sebelum perlu ‘menjadi batang’?</strong></p><p>Ya, tidaklah perlu menganggap segala bentuk organisasi sekadar <em>spook</em>: “Kerja sama hanyalah jebakan sosial, <em>arghhh…”</em> Jangan seperti <a href="https://indoprogress.com/2025/07/bahaya-laten-gerakan-rimpang/">Abdil Mughis Mudhoffir (2025)</a> yang menganggap “para advokat gerakan rimpang lebih suka menjadi simbol perlawanan yang populer.” Jangan juga seperti <a href="https://indoprogress.com/2025/06/apa-yang-bisa-kita-lakukan-sekarang/">Alvino Kusumabrata (2025)</a>, yang mengira pergerakan “fluktuatif, cair dan berstatus non-hierarkal” sudah cukup: <strong>iya, ia tahan melawan rezim, namun transformasi sosial hanya terjadi dengan sedikit, sejenak dan sendiri.</strong> <a href="https://indoprogress.com/2025/06/rizomatik-sebagai-taktik/">Fathimah Fildzah Izzati dan Rio Apinino (2025)</a>, serta <a href="https://indoprogress.com/2025/07/gerakan-rimpang-dan-rekoneksi-politik-kelas/">Dodi Faedlulloh (2025)</a> mengambil posisi yang lebih moderat: <strong>“Gerakan [rimpang] semestinya menjadi langkah atau taktik awal untuk kemudian didorong maju ke gerakan yang lebih terstruktur, terpimpin, dan terorganisir” dan “[Gerakan rimpang] tetap memiliki nilai sebagai pintu masuk bagi generasi baru untuk terlibat dalam aksi politik.”</strong></p><p>Akan tetapi, keempatnya sama-sama salah memahami rimpang, setidaknya rimpang menurut Deleuze dan Guattari, sebagai ‘taktik’. “Suatu rimpang (<em>rhizome</em>),” bagi D&amp;G, “tak henti membuat koneksi antara rantai semiotik, organisasi kekuasaan, dan keadaan yang relatif terhadap seni, ilmu pengetahuan, dan perjuangan sosial.” Namun yang terlewat adalah “Tumbuhan berakar atau berradikula mungkin rizomorfik dalam arti lain: <strong>pertanyaannya adalah apakah kehidupan tumbuhan secara khusus tidak sepenuhnya rizomatik. Bahkan beberapa hewan, sebagai kelompok, termasuk rizomatik.”</strong> (Deleuze &amp; Guattari, A Thousand Plateaus, 1987, hal. 7, 6). Bukan masalah pendefinisian sesuatu sebagai rimpang atau tidak: <em>apa pun bisa ‘rimpang’, tergantung cara melihatnya</em>. (<em>Apabila kita mengetatkan, memaksakan definisi ‘rimpang’ yang utuh, jelas dan satu, bukankah kita melakukan dosa yang sama dengan kelas menengah?)</em></p><p>Suatu hutan penuh dengan pohon-pohon lebat juga termasuk rimpang: dalamnya ada ekosistem kehidupan yang saling memberdayakan dan bertengkar. <strong>Masyarakat, dengan perusahaan, pemerintah, pekerja, pengemis, pendidikan, pelajar, penulis dan, jangan lupa, <em>orang gila</em>, di dalamnya, sudahlah suatu rimpang. </strong><em>Pertanyaannya adalah bagaimana mengatur dan menavigasi rimpang ini agar rata dalam memenuhi keinginan dan kebutuhan masing-masing unsurnya; bagaimana cara jadi nomaden </em>(Deleuze &amp; Guattari, A Thousand Plateaus, 1987, hal. 471)<em>:</em></p><blockquote>Masalahnya bukan sama sekali tentang anarki versus organisasi, ataupun tentang sentralisme versus desentralisasi, namun sebuah kalkulus atau konsepsi dari masalah-masalah himpunan tak terhingga, yang berlawanan dengan aksioma-aksioma himpunan terhingga. Kalkulus sedemikian mungkin memiliki komposisi, organisasi maupun sentralisasinya sendiri; namun, ia berjalan bukan melalui Negara atau proses aksiomatis melainkan sebuah<strong> kemenjadian murni minoritas.</strong></blockquote><p>Kita tidak akan pernah lepas dari gambar: <em>Kita perlu gambar untuk berkomunikasi. </em>Namun, di balik suatu lukisan ada seorang pelukis, dan terkadang pesan yang ingin disampaikan pelukis sudah tidak kita sepakati lagi. Apabila sang pelukis masih hidup, kita dapat sampaikan kritik kepada sang pelukis, dan mungkin, <em>mungkin saja</em>, pada lukisan selanjutnya, ia akan lebih prihatin terhadap pesan yang ia tanam dalam lukisannya — dampaknya pada masyarakat. Inilah <em>kemenjadian murni</em> atau <em>politik minoritarian</em>: <strong>terus menerus merangkul yang terpinggirkan dan terus mentransformasi pergerakan.</strong> Strategi Deleuze dan Guattari ini <em>cukup abstrak, betul,</em> namun, ia jelas bukan <em>influencer </em>atau <em>mitos</em> yang mendaur ulang gagasan lama, yang justru hanya mengandangi pergerakan. Ia menganjurkan kreativitas dalam bergerak, alih-alih tunduk pada identitas atau <em>gambar</em> ‘pergerakan’ itu sendiri. Oh, dan, ini juga berarti pergerakan tidak harus serta merta terlihat di mata publik, karena yang terlihat adalah <em>tontonan</em> — atau <em>identitas</em> , bukan <em>proses</em>. <strong>Sesuatu yang terus berproses akan terlihat kontradiktif, tetapi pergerakan sehat ialah pergerakan yang berkembang. Dan bukan berarti suatu organisasi tidak bisa berproses: Pergerakan rimpang, pada dasarnya, adalah tentang menyeimbangi keutuhan dan perubahan.</strong></p><p>Melihat dunia secara rimpang berarti memberanikan diri untuk menjadi pelukis dunia baru, menutup telinga terhadap hujatan kelas menengah sekaligus mereka yang masih di bawah ‘kesadaran palsu’. <strong>Berkaryalah seliar mungkin, manfaatkanlah beragam jalar-jalar — semua medan perang — yang kau miliki.</strong> Lahir ke dalam keluarga kelas menengah bukan berarti kau harus terjun bebas meng-<em>cosplay</em> gelandangan: manfaatkan harta warisan itu untuk belajar, bergaul dan berjaring dengan mereka yang terpinggirkan. <strong>Melawan sandiwara politik kelas menengah dimulai dari kejujuran dengan diri sendiri: bersorak melawan rezim identitas dan berjuang demi dunia yang lebih baik, <em>menurut suara hati terdalammu</em> — <em>di samping kawan-kawanmu.</em></strong></p><p><em>Selainnya, untuk organisasi pergerakan, jika sejatinya masih peduli terhadap gerakan:</em></p><p><em>1.</em> <strong>Berhenti memberi panggung bagi sandiwara kelas menengah</strong>, entah itu <em>influencer, abang-abangan pergerakan </em>atau <em>wacana </em>yang hanya mengalih perhatian.</p><p>2. <strong>Lepaskan ortodoksi ideologis</strong>: ia hanya sejumlah ide yang kapanpun bisa dibuang apabila praktik menentangnya; organisasi perlu menyerupai <em>para-</em>doks.</p><p>3. <strong>Berpikir secara terbuka dan libatkan kelompok-kelompok terpinggirkan</strong>, <em>karena justru mereka yang membawa perubahan; </em>meretakkan bingkai identitas dan merusak tiraninya.</p><p>4. <strong>Ingat bahwa pergerakan adalah proses kreatif yang tak henti namun tak <em>spektakular</em></strong><em>: </em>rehat yang cukup dan bantu sesama kawan — jangan lupakan keselamatan.</p><p>5. <strong>Tidak perlu mengunjuk rasa secara rasional dan komunikatif</strong>; logika identitas berperan mengucilkan keresahan-keresahan yang tidak bermain dengan aturannya.</p><p>6. <strong>Baca, baca, <em>BACA!</em></strong></p><h3>↙↙↙</h3><h3>Daftar Referensi</h3><p><em>Berbagai kutipan diterjemahkan secara amatir ke Bahasa Indonesia</em></p><p>comité invisible. (2007). <em>The Coming Insurrection.</em> Diambil kembali dari <a href="https://theanarchistlibrary.org/library/comite-invisible-the-coming-insurrection">https://theanarchistlibrary.org/library/comite-invisible-the-coming-insurrection</a></p><p>Debord, G. (2005). <em>Society of the Spectacle.</em> (K. Knabb, Penerj.) Rebel Press.</p><p>Deleuze, G. (1994). <em>Difference and Repetition.</em> (P. Patton, Penerj.) Columbia University Press.</p><p>Deleuze, G., &amp; Guattari, F. (1987). <em>A Thousand Plateaus.</em> (B. Massumi, Penerj.) Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.</p><p>Deleuze, G., &amp; Guattari, F. (2009). <em>Anti-Oedipus.</em> (R. Hurley, M. Seem, &amp; H. R. Lane, Penerj.) Penguin.</p><p>Faedlulloh, D. (2025, Juli 24). Gerakan Rimpang dan Rekoneksi Politik Kelas. <em>IndoProgress</em>. Diambil kembali dari <a href="https://indoprogress.com/2025/07/gerakan-rimpang-dan-rekoneksi-politik-kelas/">https://indoprogress.com/2025/07/gerakan-rimpang-dan-rekoneksi-politik-kelas/</a></p><p>Hidayat, F. (2022). Sketsa Sejarah Filsafat Indonesia. Tazakka Press.</p><p>Izzati, F. F., &amp; Apinino, R. (2025, Juni 14). Rizomatik sebagai Taktik? <em>IndoProgress</em>. Diambil kembali dari <a href="https://indoprogress.com/2025/06/rizomatik-sebagai-taktik/">https://indoprogress.com/2025/06/rizomatik-sebagai-taktik/</a></p><p>Kusumabrata, A. (2025, Juni 11). Apa yang Bisa Kita Lakukan Sekarang? <em>IndoProgress</em>. Diambil kembali dari <a href="https://indoprogress.com/2025/06/apa-yang-bisa-kita-lakukan-sekarang/">https://indoprogress.com/2025/06/apa-yang-bisa-kita-lakukan-sekarang/</a></p><p>Lane, M. (2008). Unfinished Nation: Indonesia Before and After Suharto. Verso.</p><p>Lenin, V. I. (2002). On the Significance of Militant Materialism. <em>Marxists Internet Archive</em>. (D. Skvirsky, &amp; G. Hanna, Penerj.) Diambil kembali dari Marxists Internet Archive: <a href="https://www.marxists.org/archive/lenin/works/1922/mar/12.htm">https://www.marxists.org/archive/lenin/works/1922/mar/12.htm</a></p><p>Lenin, V. I. (2014). Apa Yang Harus Dikerjakan? <em>Marxists Internet Archive</em>. (T. Sprague, Penerj.) Diambil kembali dari <a href="https://www.marxists.org/indonesia/archive/lenin/1902/ApaYang/index.htm">https://www.marxists.org/indonesia/archive/lenin/1902/ApaYang/index.htm</a></p><p>Matanasi, P. (2023, Agustus 21). PRD dalam Pemilu 1999. <em>Historia.id</em>. Diambil kembali dari <a href="https://www.historia.id/article/prd-dalam-pemilu-1999-Drg2b">https://www.historia.id/article/prd-dalam-pemilu-1999-Drg2b</a></p><p>Mudhoffir, A. M. (2025, Juli 6). Bahaya Laten Gerakan Rimpang. <em>IndoProgress</em>. Diambil kembali dari <a href="https://indoprogress.com/2025/07/bahaya-laten-gerakan-rimpang/">https://indoprogress.com/2025/07/bahaya-laten-gerakan-rimpang/</a></p><p>Partai Rakyat Demokratik. (1996, Juli 22). Manifesto Partai Rakyat Demokratik. Diambil kembali dari <a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20150709025533/http://peace.home.xs4all.nl/pubind/p/280696.html">https://web.archive.org/web/20150709025533/http://peace.home.xs4all.nl/pubind/p/280696.html</a></p><p>Radjab, S. A. (2023, Januari 4). Panggung-Panggung Mitologi dalam Hegemoni Negara: Gerakan Mahasiswa di Bawah Orde Baru. <em>BangsaMahardika</em>. Diambil kembali dari <a href="https://bangsamahardika.co/bangsa-mahasiswa/panggung-panggung-mitologi-dalam-hegemoni-negara-gerakan-mahasiswa-di-bawah-orde-baru/">https://bangsamahardika.co/bangsa-mahasiswa/panggung-panggung-mitologi-dalam-hegemoni-negara-gerakan-mahasiswa-di-bawah-orde-baru/</a></p><p>Schroeder, R. (2018). Digital media and the rise of right-wing populism. Dalam <em>Social Theory after the Internet: Media, Technology, and Globalization</em> (hal. 60–81). UCL Press.</p><p>Sontag, S. (2005). <em>On Photography.</em> RosettaBooks.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5e4fd5ae2805" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[On the Politics of Art in the 21st Century]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@rainlaniakea/on-the-politics-of-art-in-the-21st-century-04b17293c641?source=rss-a6ef9030c792------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/04b17293c641</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[art]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[rain laniakea]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 21 Jul 2025 12:58:56 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-07-22T12:13:03.878Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Short Reflection on The Work of Art in the Age of Mechanical Reproduction</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/733/1*MaawIclQ8xJwDtXFrQoIsg.png" /><figcaption>There’s this show about two, REALLY close, female friends</figcaption></figure><p>The talking point that “all art is political” has become quite common in public discourse — especially online. Most understand it to mean that art is <em>value-laden</em>: a work of art cannot be stripped from the social, cultural, and political context of its emergence, which, therefore, means that it says something about the world we live in. Though this is an apt interpretation in and of itself, there is a second, at the other end, that would complete the dialectic between art and society: <strong>a work of art, as an expression of human subjectivity, is an exercise of power.</strong> A work of art is not simply a recording of thought to be used as knowledge; its existence also generates response in society, whether it be personal reflection, academic critique, or even economic valuation.</p><p>In his essay, Walter Benjamin attempts to elaborate film’s place in the canon of art — what it is as a novel art form — and, by the very same analysis, offer an interpretation of how art operates through the implications film brought to society. This is of course done in the context of the early 20th century: film was the new kid on the block, following photography. Photography’s reproducability was, to Benjamin, fully manifested through film; its demystifying effects, or dissolvement of what Benjamin calls ‘aura’, was to a broader extent carried out by film, particularly the sound film. No longer did people have to pay a considerable fee, or be of a certain social status, and prepare themselves in a certain way — dressing, arriving and talking — to enjoy an opera, a factory worker could spend a small portion of their monthly earnings, in the small amount of free time that they had, to bring their family to the movies. Photography brought images to newspapers which were so immediately perceivable that they cease being labelled as ‘art’, <strong>though film successfully sparked the conversation by bringing close to home the established setting of perceiving art:</strong> the theater, namely. Sound film then introduces the auditory sense to this reproduction, completing the sensual standard of ‘art’, being that of audiovisual. Other forms, I would argue, were less established as painting, sculpture, literature, music, and theater were. They would either be thoroughly associated with their utility value, as is the case with culinary arts, or subsumed within the audiovisual, such as architecture, despite the object itself being mostly experienced as the need for shelter.</p><p>The wake of the 20th century brought with it even more massive reproductions of ‘art’, no matter its established form. Advancements in information technology brought with it an even more perceivable reflection that art was, at its core, a distraction rather than immersion, as Benjamin argues. The distinction between the two was a superficial one, for art merely offers, following Theodor Adorno’s understanding of art, alternative realities to its perceiver. ‘Immersion’ was simply the bourgeois mode of perceiving art, ignorant of its indulgent isolation from mass society: <strong>art’s mystique derives from its being exclusive. </strong>The investments for<strong> i</strong>mmersion and attention simply reflected the amount of free time and energy the ruling class had, which the working class — be it wage laborers of the industrial age, the slaves of ancient and medieval times, and serfs of the modern period — did not have much of, by virtue of the current economic structure, a society’s <em>division of labor</em>. Furthermore, <strong>objects considered art by the elites of society were not considered such if it were produced and distributed <em>en masse</em></strong><em> </em>(such is the distinction between <em>architecture</em> and <em>buildings </em>as well as <em>cuisine</em> and <em>food).</em></p><p>The installation of values, whether deemed artificial or real, is now a concern in the 21st century. Defenders of unique value, such as Jean Baudrillard, would consider reproduction as secondary to production; representation secondary to presentation. This comes from the threat that mass media embodies, which Benjamin hinted in the <em>Afterword</em>: a mass aesthetization of politics that would disguise its morally dubious, or even wrong, practices as social necessity — as social, unilateral progress. Fascism did not simply work by presenting one voice to the masses, it<strong> first induced paranoia so that they all could fall into that one voice.</strong> It may seem times have changed, yet we are not so unfamiliar with the feeling; so many alternative truths presented to us, at such a high frequency, that we so easily fall to conclusion rather than contemplation. There may be no one truth enforced, yet the confusion we feel guides us to rely on anything stable; and of course those who rule offer such stability, precisely by stripping political labels from it. It is the perceived stability that certain politicians or parties gain trust, not the ideology they claim to be: nationalist, democratic, socialist, liberal, environmentalist, or any of the sort become superficial once the people understand that they give them enough food, shelter, and jobs. Not that organization is necessarily a bad thing, though blindly following other people, as even ancient proverbs have warned, may lead to violations of human dignity unimaginable today.</p><p>Quite a blessing I had the chance to attend a discussion one of my lecturers had on Hannah Arendt. The acts that lead humans to conduct ‘evil’ (although I myself would criticize the epistemic standpoint) are <strong>caused by a lack of contemplative thinking — </strong>hence the ‘banality’ of evil. Jean-Paul Sartre offered a similar response to war: the soldier evades reflection on the critical moment of murder in fear of how his superiors, and thereby mass society — from his point of view, would treat him. He would be deemed a delinquent, lose respect as well as certain rights, and so he must follow orders. Although the swarm of information invading us today might appear to not be so authoritative as the sergeant, it is the same strand of paranoia, though in the form of confusion. And<strong> </strong>in this confusion we tend to fall into the opinions and values normally construed as solutions or, even more numbingly, those readily available — hence stable<strong>. “Thinking otherwise would not be thinking at all,” mass media tells us. </strong>It is not one voice that guides all, but rather a plurality of voices, opinions and values that all support one speaker as always being right and, retroactively, having always been right. Such confusion opens for the need of upholding universal values — a return to the past, mistaking the need for particular, critical evaluation for enforcement.</p><p>We are met today with an endless stream of values: “This film is <em>X</em> because it is <em>Y</em>”, then, another replies, “I think not, because in the film, <em>A</em> happens and therefore it deserves an <em>N</em> out of five stars.” You then head over to another site, it says: “Top five albums you must listen to if you liked Z.” Review platforms have even become mind-numbing with short reviews and instant ratings, telling you whether to <em>consume </em>this certain piece of media instead of giving a contemplative account that adds on to the experience. Then you get all the opinions floating everywhere about ‘modern art’ (<em>contemporary </em>art), claiming it to not be art because it ‘takes no effort’ and ‘says nothing’. The very same people would ironically denounce traditionally established forms of art — namely painting and music — as not worth mastering, for we have artificial intelligence now that can do that. <strong>We are constantly robbed of our agency to choose what we like and what we dislike. </strong>I would even opine that it is better for someone to contemplate AI art as a first step rather than go change their rating for a movie because people say it’s unfair to rate it at such low stars.</p><p>And not in an “it begins with TikTok, then the ballots” sort of rationale, the mass confusion experienced thereby silences one’s realization — both the consciousness and actualization — of one’s own power to value. This then reproduces the very power structure that democracy promises to destroy.<strong> </strong>Objects traditionally understood as art can be mass-produced by the ruling class either to sway opinions a certain way or create the aforementioned mass confusion. Yet, either way, <strong>might it not be wise to suspect that this is precisely in their interests to do so? </strong>We have been conditioned to enjoy others’ opinions rather than ours, so that, one day, one vision of the world may absorb All into One, because All is One and All has always been One; disguising itself first as All and never revealing its one-among-many-ness.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*lXja9Pd3LU-UZjsup7q6eQ.png" /><figcaption><em>‘Great guiding light’</em></figcaption></figure><p>Art’s role in politics is clear<strong>: a medium through which one experiences a version of reality, which may be circulated to enforce a certain version<em>. </em></strong>A seeming plurality of realities can suppress oneself from the consciousness of one’s own creative reality, that little part of the world we each call <em>our world </em>(though, arguably, is it not <em>the world?). </em><strong>And for this reason we have art criticism: which <em>realities </em>shall we best accept — <em>here and now</em>? </strong>Article by article, critics negate realities which are deemed to contribute to suffering: representations of the world that are inaccurate precisely because they lay too big of a claim to accuracy — they say that “this is the world <em>as is</em>”<em>, </em>implying <em>no other</em>, and serve to preserve the power structure instead of challenging it in hopes for better times, <em>even if they may not last forever. </em>By this negation, we find a better, for the time being, alternative reality, an <em>idea (and from it, ideals) </em>of how the world should be, as a world of many — of <em>others</em>.</p><p>So, express and contemplate: go write that poem or draw or sing or whatever; and take some time off social media to sit and think. No, you don’t have to think about the latest film that just came out, <em>maybe a small pebble in the park said more to you than Hollywood’s new blockbuster.</em> Though, even if you do end up watching said blockbuster, maybe instead watch it with a loved one, or with popcorn (sneaking in snacks as the working class alternative)— get comfy! <strong>It is, after all, a matter of ritualization that <em>distraction</em> becomes <em>immersion</em>. </strong>For those one hundred and twenty minutes, you are the ruling class — isolated from the world around, or <em>society’s world</em>, so act like it.</p><p>After thinking, talk to a friend; whether they agree or disagree, think again: “which of what they said shall I accept and which not?” Ready-made conclusions may tempt one since, today, the average person knows of how much is going on around the world — no time to think. Though, then again, <strong>the appearance of there being ‘so much going on around the world’ is being sold to us so that we fall into these opinion-traps rather than thinking about things that may be more relevant to us. We have been made to feel like we’ve missed out on the world, and we either fall into or abandon the world, failing to curate, by our own volition, which things we should care about and which not. </strong>Navigating the vast World Wide Web requires a venturer with a goal and a way to get there; jumping in with no light will just get you lost. The genocide of the Palestinian people gets mixed up with information on the up-and-coming sequel of a franchise that has long lost its charm, made to sell more toys and merchandise. Or, the opposite: that artist you listen to every day is coming on tour to your country — and it would really be nice for you, who gets yelled at by your boss every day, to finally watch first-hand the fuel that keeps you going; but you missed buying tickets because you were busy arguing with some shut-in on the internet who subscribes to a fringe, alt-right political philosophy.</p><p>Oh, last thing, and no, your post of that poem or drawing or cover or dance or recital does not have to get thousands of likes for it to be something. <strong>It<em> </em>already <em>is </em>something, someone already saw or heard or experienced it — <em>you, moved by yourself</em>.</strong></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=04b17293c641" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Forgetful Angel (Vergesslicher Engel)]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@rainlaniakea/forgetful-angel-vergesslicher-engel-fa7fe632aeba?source=rss-a6ef9030c792------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/fa7fe632aeba</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[poetry]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[history]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[rain laniakea]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 29 May 2025 22:53:09 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-05-29T22:54:57.445Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>History and Joy</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/600/1*EyXGx7gBovLrSXCh_thHLg.jpeg" /></figure><p>A Klee painting named <em>Vergesslicher Engel </em>shows an angel looking as though he has just let go of something he has long regretted. His eyes are grateful, his mouth is smiling, his wings are closed. This is how one pictures the angel of history. His face is turned inwards. Where we perceive one minor error, he sees a chain of catastrophes which never seem to get anything right and swallows it all into his heart. The angel would like to leave, run away from death, and smash all that keeps him prisoner. But the sun keeps shining; its light caught in his wings with such love that the angel has no need to open them. And this sun illuminates the past to which he faces within, while his heart continues aching. This sun is what we call purpose.</p><p>Amidst the growing anxiety from illness and Nazism was this painting born. The lack of color and symmetry call into question whether this work could even be called a painting — call it a sketch. Yet it remains so captivating and, at first view, one cannot help but feel welcome. It reminds me of childhood drawings; Klee’s known for that, but, here even more. Black and white being the only colors give a sense of serenity. The blissful ignorance in forgetting is a privilege one wishes to have. The storm called progress keeps blowing and demands one to remember. But I want to be a kid and forget.</p><p>Looking back is no easy process. There is anger and hatred at what one has done and what one could have done. There are lost presents and impossible futures scattered throughout. We can forgive but never can seem to forget, especially our past. The world wants to strive for a better future but can never let go of its past. The past defines the present, and the present defines the future. The imaginary worlds we made when we were little seem so far away now.</p><p>What goes on in the mind of the revolutionary? There’s something new every day, from someone, somewhere. Sometimes, this someone has a big something they want to make real. They then tell others about it. Other people agree, so they try to make it real — for the people. They proceed to delude themself that their imaginary world is the world of the people. They then fail. They are met with disappointment from the people. It turns out their little sketch is no painting. They look to the past. They regret.</p><p>Though, they do it again. Add a little this and a little that. They tell themself that the people do not yet get the picture, and that they must make it clearer. So they go on drawing, maybe this time with crayon. Pencil drawings are sometimes hard to see under bad lighting. Especially for those in the back, not lucky enough to pay for front-row seats. The victims of history can not see beyond history, and it is not for them to bear the blame.</p><p>Is history, then, a pile of dead bodies? Is history a list of sins? Will God punish us all in the end, because of our carelessness? Will the bedbugs bite in the middle of a beautiful dream? Will <em>arete </em>keep waiting for me? I do not belong here; I have nothing to give. Look at them, all so great, all so happy. History has desecrated their bodies, yet they sit and listen. Better off without me — look at me.</p><p>Historical materialism tends to strain the eye. Material conditions need to be met before change can be carried out, sure. But the existential singularity in which the revolutionary exists cannot be set aside in the analyses of change, social or scientific. Nothing surely follows something when it comes to people. Hume distrusts nature and I distrust people. Call it my problem or make it yours, I can not care less.</p><p>One has to choose whether to fall into the hellmouth of regret or laugh at it. One forgets things here and there, meets the judgment for not getting the bigger picture oneself — because of the inability to even make a picture. Too many holes and even those closest to one and one’s cause will surely disapprove. Nevertheless, one is an abyss and one must stare back. The whirlpool of history has one in its epicenter and one must bring joy, at least to oneself. One does not continue drawing because of the angst; one is caught up in one’s own ego. One knows one can go beyond. One can see the world for what it is and dream of what it could be. So one makes what the world could be into what it is.</p><p>Are those his hands, connected directly to his wings? I can barely make anything out of this angel. I can only know that his formlessness keeps him joyful; just look at his face. I still remember that one time I read Nāgārjuna: <em>nirvāṇa</em> and <em>saṃsāra</em> are one and the same. One cannot dispel the karma but one can let go of it — forget it. One will accumulate more and more karma even once one has forgotten it, but one will forget it once more. When the cause has reached effect, one can only laugh for one forgot the cause. Joy.</p><p>No need to spread any wings and fly. May the storm from Paradise strike; the burden of history will continue to pile up. The warmth of the sun keeps the angel sure and steady. Purpose, however messy and childish and imaginary a drawing it may be, lets the angel face the darkest corners of history and continue to smile. The angel keeps being nothing and along the way becomes something. Paul Klee simply wanted to draw something.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=fa7fe632aeba" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>