<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Rajat Sethi on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Rajat Sethi on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@rajatsethi?source=rss-7720a3058401------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sat, 21 Nov 2026 05:03:05 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@rajatsethi/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[SHARING ECONOMY: A Case for Creative Destruction]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@rajatsethi/sharing-economy-a-case-for-creative-destruction-2641af58a514?source=rss-7720a3058401------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2641af58a514</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Rajat Sethi]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 11 Nov 2014 00:13:53 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2014-11-11T00:16:11.478Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/780/1*5BPrCFYSW_MDjQFVIW7oyw.jpeg" /></figure><h3>Sharing Economy: A Case for Creative Destruction</h3><p>Intergenerational exchange demands a balance between conflicting theories of why and how to do business and how to reap benefits sustainably. None other than Millennials stand closer to striking this balance. The first big assault by Millennials lies on the ‘must-have’ and ‘must-buy’ type of market economy — its ubiquitous paraphernalia and the classes of haves and have-nots they have created.</p><p>In this new era, Millennials have forced the markets to make way for social networks building a steady replacement of ownership by access. The result is known variously as “collaborative consumption”, “asset-light lifestyle”, “peer economy”, “access economy” or “sharing economy”.</p><p>The beginning looks promising. However, what remains to be seen is, how sustained the impact will be, how new institutions will emerge to support it, what are the necessary ingredients for a society to leapfrog in shared economy and what are the immediate threats to it? This paper addresses some of these questions.</p><p><strong>PHILOSOPHY OF OWNERSHIP VERSUS ACCESS</strong></p><p>The desire and drive to own property is the fundamental need for individual identity. To own, possess, control, master, acquire and utilize comprise our basic motivations. We are taught that acquiring and accumulating property are integral parts of our earthly sojourn and who we are is partly a reflection of what we own.</p><p>Man’s yearning to possess property has been considered an undesirable trait that superior men could and would sublimate. Property relationships are considered crass and materialistic. Plato and the Stoics carried forward the idea that virtue was somehow related to propertyless-ness; the poor were in a more favored position because they were not burdened with possessions.</p><p>Sharing has been as basic a value as ownership. Having secured some property of our own, we wish others to experience the joys of our own attainment. It is this joy and satisfaction that fuels shared economy.</p><p>The relationship between physical products, individual ownership and self-identity is undergoing a profound evolution. Prof MacPherson argues that property is “a right to <em>immaterial </em>revenue” which can be enjoyed “in a satisfying set of social relations”. This idea emanates from a society that has conquered material scarcity, where immaterial values take precedence and quest for self-actualization and self-transcendence becomes the goal. Access, as a cherished socio-economic virtue, blossoms here.</p><p><strong>IN THE AGE OF ACCESS</strong></p><p>The dizzying speed of technological innovation and economic activity often make the notion of ownership problematic. In a world of customized production, continuous innovation and upgrades and ever narrowing product life-cycles, everything becomes obsolete almost immediately. Therefore, in the age of access, suppliers lease, rent or charge an admission, subscription, or membership fee for short-term use of property and capital.</p><p>The new “asset-light” generation does not want material stuff but craves for the needs it fulfills. We have constructed a large part of our freedom around our “right to own” and our self-identity around what we do. But for digital millennials, actual ownership of physical objects becomes less important than demonstrating use or use by association on online platforms like Twitter, Facebook or LinkedIn. Thus, our possessions de-materialize into intangibles — creating dotted lines between who owns what.</p><p>In the age of access, collaboration has become the new buzzword — sharing, bartering, lending or swapping. The old stigmatized concepts of cooperatives, collectives and communes are being refreshed and reinvented into appealing and valuable forms of collaboration and community.</p><p>This collaboration has brought a renewed hope to narrow the ever perpetuating gap between haves and have-nots. This new age comes with mobile technologies that connect people in need for goods or services who had so far been left behind by ‘propertied market’. In this quest, several institutions that were created to support market economy — property agreements, tax commissioners and legal system — will have to undergo a transformation.</p><p><strong>THE NEW ECONOMICS — AGENTS, RESOURCES &amp; MARKETS</strong></p><p>Shared Economy consists of its own set of producers, consumers, platform for exchange of goods, capital, market systems and total factor productivity like any other economy.</p><p><strong>a) Agents:</strong></p><p>Agents of shared economy — producers and consumers — are tech savvy and asset light Millennials who are hooked onto their PCs and smartphones. These new economic communities have sprung up around shared convictions, activities or interests. For them, “sharing is clean, crisp, urbane, postmodern; ownership is dull, selfish, timid and backward”, in the words of Mark Levine.</p><p>The early adopters jumped to the opportunity brought up by access based economy. They demonstrated proof of concepts with a critical mass of goods around their localities and generated support from others who thought alike. Within no time, these concepts grew into profitable companies like Netflix, Airbnb, Zipcar, Relayrides, Lyft, Uber, Zopa, Prosper, TaskRabbit, Parking Panda, SnapGoods and Massive Open Online Courses (MOOCs). These <em>Davids </em>of shared economy are now strong enough to challenge and disrupt the <em>Goliaths </em>of market economy centered on exclusive ownership.</p><p><strong>b) Segments:</strong></p><p>According to Botsman et al., there are three prominent market segments that are central to Shared Economy — ‘product service systems’, ‘redistribution markets’ and ‘collaborative lifestyles’. Each of these systems range in scale, maturity and purpose, yet they share similar underlying principles — critical mass, idling capacity, belief in commons, and trust between strangers.</p><p>Products which qualify as having ‘high idling capacity’ (cars, bikes, tools), potential for obsolescence (gadgets, fashion items), high initial capital costs (heavy industrial vehicles) or high extended life (electronic goods, furniture) are good fit for product service system based market segment.</p><p>Redistribution markets imply distribution of pre-owned goods from places of obsolescence to places of potential usage. Several goods like toys, clothes, books, DVDs can we swapped for something useful. This helps increase the overall life cycle of products.</p><p>Collaborative lifestyle involves people sharing and exchanging intangibles like skills, time, space, funds and experiences.</p><p>The concept of sharing has created such market segments out of non-monetizable micro-assets using the efforts of micro-entrepreneurs.</p><p><strong>c) Platforms:</strong></p><p>The rapid emergence of social networks has helped nurture an economy based on sharing, openness and cooperation. This economy is rooted in technologies and behavior of online social networks: Facebook, Twitter, Wikipedia, Flickr, Digg, and Youtube. They modestly began online by posting comments, sharing files, codes, photos, videos and knowledge but grew into a widely acceptable platform for exchange of goods and services. These platforms are destigmatizing the notion of sharing. They are creating service brands with a promise of safety, smartness, choice and attractiveness necessary to bring all types of actors on board.</p><p><strong>d) Trust Capital:</strong></p><p>Trust among peers is increasingly becoming a currency that facilitates transactions in shared economy. Whatever mark an individual leaves in form of comments on websites, photographs on photo-sharing sites, updates on twitter-handle, videos on youtube etc add up to his or her trust capital. Botsman et al. compare the function of this “reputation capital” with one’s credit score. On a cumulative scale, it measures if the individual is trustworthy enough for an economic engagement. All the collaborative services rely on ratings and reciprocal reviews to build trust among their users. Staying in a stranger’s apartment in another city seems much less daunting when you read testimonials from previous guests.</p><p><strong>e) Social Capital as Total Factor Productivity:</strong></p><p>Social capital is the expected economic benefit derived from cooperation between individuals and groups within a society. <em>Do unto others as they do unto you — </em>this rule of reciprocation allows one individual to give something to another with confidence and expectation that he will be equally rewarded. This sense of comfort makes the development of relationships, transactions and exchanges possible which, in turn, benefits society. Online relationships and social connectivity becomes pivotal to dictate this exchange. By analogy, it has been referred to as total factor productivity as it explains the reasons as to why some societies can effectively leapfrog in this collaborative setting while others cannot in spite of similarities in social media access and necessary demand-supply dynamics.</p><p>Social capital and collaborative economy thrive in a symbiotic relationship. The benefit of collaborative consumption turns out to be social. In an era when families are scattered and we may not know the people down the street, sharing things — even with strangers we’ve just met online — allows us to make meaningful connections. Peer-to-peer sharing “involves the re-emergence of community.”</p><p><strong>f) Demand and Supply:</strong></p><p>Users of every demography are flocking to services like Airbnb, Zipcar, Taskrabbit for one dominant reason: renting and sharing goods allow them to choose from a wide field without exorbitant expenditure. Clearly, cost savings justify the huge demand-pull. The continuous supply from users putting up houses for rent, allowing others to ride their cars or use their lawns for gardening suggest that hosts are quite satisfied with their experiences. Also, significant numbers of hosts are repeat hosts who have successfully leveraged trust to profitably participate on the supply side of the sharing economy. This interplay between demand and supply rests heavily on foundations of social capital and trust capital as elucidated above.</p><p><strong>SHARED ECONOMY: A CASE FOR CREATIVE DESTRUCTION</strong></p><p>A cardinal principle of economics is that efficiency focused innovations drive away all inefficiencies from the system. The ripple effects of shared economy could also be catastrophic for status quoist and ownership driven industries. Adjusting to a consumer who does not necessarily buy, but rather rents, would necessitate a shift in production, sales, and even employment structures. Everything interesting in economics happens at the margin, so if the nth consumer chooses to rent an apartment instead of buying a house or making do with a car-share program instead of purchasing a new vehicle, then demand for new houses and cars drop.</p><p>This has scared the industry consultants into believing that the crisis-sparked renting and sharing economy could morph the consumer psyche as during the Depression. They also believe that the recent recession could foster a generation of ‘renters’ and ‘sharers’ (as opposed to ‘savers’) who are wary of potentially risky investment in vehicles or financial instruments.</p><p><strong>COLLABORATIVE CONSUMPTION: ECONOMIC REACTION OR SOCIAL PARADIGM SHIFT?</strong></p><p>In the aftermath of the global financial crisis, several peer-to-peer rental firms emerged between 2008 and 2010. Some believe that this trend of collaborative consumption is out of economic necessity — as post-crisis antidote to hyper-consumption, which will naturally slow down once the economy revives.</p><blockquote>“As it stands, the rental economy will probably prosper for a bit longer as this cohort pays back student loans and finds higher-paying jobs,” say the ConvergEx strategists and envision that many will appreciate the “value of owning”.</blockquote><p>Others see collaborative consumption not as something much deeper and pervasive than a reactionary blip to 2008 crisis. They believe that consumer motivations extend deeper than cost savings. Economic necessity has made people more open to new ways of accessing what they truly need and how to go about getting it.</p><p>Shared economy is indeed a real trend. People are looking at this for economic, environmental and lifestyle reasons. Moreover, we yearn to trust and be trusted. That’s the beauty of a sharing society and the reason it might prove more lasting than one built on ownership.</p><p><strong>EARLY CRITICISMS</strong></p><p>As the idea of shared economy is still taking roots, questions are being raised on its altruistic and inclusive motives. If the new wealth depends on leasing, renting and charging for access, does this not simply reinforce the division between haves and have-nots: those who possess physical resources and those who are dependent on them? And what becomes of those parts of the global society that do not and cannot have “access”? Won’t the digital divide further exacerbate the economic divide?</p><p>The new model runs the risk of being mixed into existing models and embraced by incumbents. The threat of <em>tragedy of commons </em>looms large in shared economy. How will the economic players collectively solve the problem of individuals misusing resources? For the most part, this self-policing approach works well. However, shared economy will have to develop institutions to ensure its longevity.</p><p><strong>CONCLUSION</strong></p><p>The shift from geography to cyberspace, industrial to cultural capitalism, and ownership to access are going to force a wholesale rethinking of the social contract. While important, these issues are symptomatic of more fundamental concerns — concerns that go to the very heart of the kind of civilization we wish to create for ourselves. A portion of humanity has already embarked on this new journey where material dematerializes and commodifying time becomes more important than expropriating space. Access is the single most powerful metaphor in the coming age. It is becoming a conceptual tool of reformulating our worldview and economy.</p><p>What does it mean to live in a wired world where holding property is less important than having access and more and more of our economic and social life lives in cyberspace? Shared Economy brings deeper philosophical issues around purpose of property and its role in defining the essential nature of human beings and society. In near future, new communication technologies and networks will emerge as gateways and portals to new ways of re-envisioning human journey. Defining the sociological nature and political import of access-based relations remains the unfinished business at hand.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2641af58a514" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>