<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Ramdas S on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Ramdas S on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@ramdaz?source=rss-950a15d41a34------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Mon, 16 Nov 2026 17:31:52 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@ramdaz/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Why AAP lost?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@ramdaz/why-aap-lost-7413bdc50037?source=rss-950a15d41a34------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/7413bdc50037</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ramdas S]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 17 May 2014 05:59:14 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2014-05-17T06:58:37.918Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>There are 11 reasons why AAP could not make the cut in this Lok Sabha elections …</h4><p>AAP’s journey to winning state elections in Delhi was incredible. While there were several AAP supporters who criticized AAP’s decision to take support from Congress, it was the best decision AAP could have taken at that time. Arvind Kejriwal had a dream start, except for excessive media attention. The kind of attention literally no other political greenhorn has ever managed. Except for some minor flaws, the first 3 weeks of the AAP Delhi government was pitch perfect.</p><p>1)The first mistake was to support the law minister Somnath Bharti. Whether Bharti was innocent or not was never the matter, good politics would have been zero tolerance once a serious allegation is levied, and AK should have asked law minister to quit and stay away till he is proven not guilty, instead of blindly supporting him. I am not even talking about his mid-night adventures in Kalkaji Extension. There was a serious allegation against Bharti being a spammer, and also one involving his role where he was warned by the court for trying to influence a witness a few days before the Kalkaji episode.</p><p>Such a move would have got respect from public and media, and would have put AAP on a higher moral ground.</p><p>Also party leadership or internal committees should never be used to pass judgements when party members have taken the role of public servants such as ministers of MLAs.</p><p>2) The <em>dharna</em> in Delhi just turned out to be a damp squib, and was perceived to be mere theatricals by public. It sent several wrong signals to the middle class and upper middle class voters who were banking on AAP as an alternative to BJP and Congress. Personally it reminded me of the good old communist party which used to call a Bandh or Hartal on the drop of a hat. For a CM in power sitting on<em> a Dharna</em> was never good <em>Dharma</em>. The <em>Dharna</em> alienated intellectuals, middle class voters and vast secti0n of media which painted AAP as a party which is not ready for governance. Moreover with no real action against the police officers. It ended up being an exercise to cover up for Bharti’s alleged misdeeds.</p><p>3) Quitting Delhi for not being able to pass a trivial bill (at least for the common man) was the biggest mistake. Lokpal Bill is perhaps central to AAP’s existence, and the leadership’s biggest dream. It’s probably the reason for AAP’s genesis. But the public gives a damn for the bill. For the voting public what mattered was a political party willing to resolve their issues, and AAP was doing just that even if the results were far from satisfactory. No one outside the BJP and Congress supporters questioned the party’s earnestness and willingness. AAP lost that goodwill overnight in Delhi.</p><p>AAP could have chosen 100 better routes to an honourable exit. The best would have been to force Congress to withdraw support by going after all the corruption cases of the previous governments. Public would have seen AAP as a real crusader against corruption, and the martyr status of being pulled down would have helped, instead of stepping down. Instead today the perception is that AAP has let Sheila Dikshit get away.</p><p>In addition, quitting gave an impression that Kejriwal was too eager to become the PM, and was greedy for power. People love ambitious politicians, but not greedy ones.</p><p>4) Filing of FIR against Ambani might have been a master-stroke if it were handled correctly. AAP could have initiated a larger debate, and several actions in a more matured fashion. However it is today seen more as a political gimmick. Tomorrow if and when Modi government agrees to hike Gas prices, Kejriwal can claim a moral victory. But it would have come too late. Also despite all the riches Ambani was envied, but not hated. You cannot simply start a new war front, and draw others into it, and that too without ample proof that can be accepted by our law system. People hated Congress and it’s leadership. In politics, if you do not tap into existing negativity to draw out the positives, you are a fool.</p><p>5) Immediately after quitting Kejriwal went after Modi. Modi had virtually disappeared from media during the 49 days of Delhi Government. The public anger was never against Modi, and was always channelized against Congress. Instead of being the strong ship in that channel, Kejriwal took on Modi, and in that process made Modi the only champion against the corrupt UPA-II. Worse, instead of tapping into the anti-incumbency vote bank, AAP became a part of the so-called pseudo-secular parties which had lost its charm in front of a Modi, who simply stuck to his development agenda.</p><p>Unlike in past elections, when communalism was a major issue, this year it was never a concern for most of India including a cross section of Indian minorities. Kejriwal’s fixation on Modi backfired completely.</p><p>6)By putting up candidates in 446 seats, the party spread itself too thin. With the lack of resources, manpower, leadership and capital, most of the candidates have ended up losing their deposits.</p><p>You need at least Rs 2 crore (or Rs 15 per voter) and about 12,000 volunteers to reach every voter directly or indirectly at least once in the six weeks run up to an election in a Lok Sabha constituency. For 446 constituencies, AAP would have needed a fund of minimum Rs 892 crore. AAP finally raised about 4 percent of that figure. It was just not enough.</p><p>I remember Yogendra Yadav saying that this was just an attempt to get a feel of what is AAP’s strength across the country and not to disappoint supporters outside Delhi. That explanation is fine, and I agree if AAP had limited themselves to say 50 seats, at least couple of the Punjab seats might have missed out.</p><p>7) Candidate selection and ticket distribution were totally flawed. AAP called in for nominations from just about anyone from anywhere. Problem was that political aspirants were huge in number, and many managed to get 100 to 1000 supporters from their constituency and filed in their applications for a party ticket. Obviously only one can get through and there was no transparency in the procedures around the final selection of a candidate. A friend of mine who was aspiring for a ticket from a UP constituency said that there were 30 candidates each with nearly 1,000 supporters who were vying for a party ticket for his constituency. Then someone unknown to most party supporters was chosen. This alienated everyone else who were rooting for the party and also their supporters. And AAP polled less than 4000 votes, when there were 30 candidates with 1000 supporters each in the first place. So essentially AAP alienated 29 of them and their supporters.</p><p>All bright ideas around having primaries just disappeared into thin air, perhaps due to lack of time.</p><p>Para-dropping of candidates work, if there are candidates who are really popular and you have a volunteer base which can work for them. AAP has just one star which is AK, and AK might have pulled off from any place if the opponent was not someone as popular as Modi.</p><p>8) AAP took on media, while Modi ignored every media entity for most of the elections until he was absolutely sure that the tide was clearly in his favour. Except AK, Yogendra Yadav and Ashish Khaitan, very few of the AAP spokespersons knew how to engage with an aggressive media anchor baying for their blood.</p><p>And you had motormouths who spoke their mind, and not the party’s, or at least what the party needs to especially during the election time. Prashant Bhushan is an example of someone who embarrassed the party and the leadership, with several politically incorrect statements, and then retracting them.</p><p>Your crusade against corruption gets diluted, when you include everyone in your list of corrupt. Media did not take it very kindly.</p><p>9) There were no clarity on the AAP’s larger agenda other than fight against corruption. Nothing concrete on foreign policy, or economic agenda except some specific plans on reviving SME and manufacturing, and a few other broad goals. Even BJP did not have any path breaking agenda, except broad plans and statements. However, BJP was harping about development from day one, and was showcasing the Gujarat model, which was marketed brilliantly. Narendra Modi had the clear backing of industrialists, pro-capitalists and the larger business community which controls the media. Modi except in select places like Varanasi stayed away from Hindutva and other touchy subjects, which could have potentially alienated thinking classes from the BJP.</p><p>The biggest challenge was AAP being perceived left of center(which it really is), and the image of being the New age Communist party. India can digest socialism, but communism is taboo everywhere except the three states of Kerala, West Bengal and Tripura. And these states would rather prefer original communists to a left of center non cadre based party without a specific ideology.</p><p>10) There were several blatant lies and half truths that were spread by BJP and it’s large social media army. Funding details around the various NGOs run by AAP leaders, AAP’s soft corner for separatists, Naxalites, Maoists and terrorists, and alleged connections with every anti-national group. AAP leadership either ignored such propaganda or were ignorant about such propaganda.</p><p>AAP’s failure to answer allegations by former party men and the likes further painted a wrong picture. In politics when you set high moral grounds, people expect you to follow that.</p><p>I guess millions switched over and started believing the BJP propaganda as AAP leadership could not successfully tackle them, however absurd the allegations were.</p><p>A few examples….</p><p>a) AAP is the Congress B Team and is a tool to stop Narendra Modi becoming PM.<br>b) AAP stayed in power so that Sheila Dikshit gets enough time to cover up and then disappear from the scene to be governor of Kerala.<br>c) AAP is a party full of Naxalites and anti-national elements, and their agenda is to destabilize India and hand over Kashmir to Pakistan. And AAP offices are safe heaven for Naxalites and anti-nationals.<br>d) AAP is a party of quitters.</p><p>The list is endless. But the BJP have been relentless, and I saw several AAP followers and supporters quitting under the attack. Clear written explanations and communications could have helped AAP.</p><p>11) Arvind Kejriwal. AK was AAP’s biggest strength and weakness. He was the face of the party. In him people saw a bright, honest, educated and progressive leader in December 2013. However AK kept taking U-turns, and several decisions by him turned millions of voters away from AAP. This lead to an image of him being indecisive, a trait which Indians also identifies with Dr Manmohan Singh, the outgoing PM.</p><p>Modi on the other hand was seen as a decisive leader. Throughout the campaign, Modi made very few mistakes, and never really changed his agenda. Under extensive media glare, every action and inaction of AK was interpreted or misinterpreted. From a corruption crusader, he was made to look like a bumbling, incompetent, and almost unstable person. This cost the party badly. In fact his actions have caused irreparable damage to his credibility as a leader amongst fence sitters who voted for BJP and not for AAP in these elections.</p><p>And AK must own complete responsibility of the election debacle.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=7413bdc50037" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Why am I still backing AAP?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@ramdaz/why-am-i-still-backing-aap-e8f1cc79c038?source=rss-950a15d41a34------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e8f1cc79c038</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ramdas S]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 14 Apr 2014 21:07:00 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2014-04-15T06:26:23.304Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>When others I started off with are abandoning the party, I am still standing behind it. Even more firmly, today!</h4><p>Sometime in the month of November 2013, I started taking notice of the phenomenon called Aam Aadmi Party. Their victory in Delhi elections inspired several of us friends, to back the fledgeling party, because of the freshness it brought to Indian political scenario. I met several of the state leaders, and then decided to join the party after listening to Yogendra Yadav at Bangalore, where he spelled out the difference which it can bring to the country.</p><p>At that AAP meeting, I met people with very disparate backgrounds backing AAP. Some tired of corruption and very narrow views within RSS, some folks belonging to the minorities wary of being treated as vote bank by Congress etc, youth looking for an alternative, and even CEOs and top executives of companies fed up of the ‘system’. AAP certainly had the momentum and the promise of alternative politics to inspire several of us, seeking change.</p><p>What followed in the next few months were a mix of euphoria and sheer frustration. The biggest frustration is that when you back a political thought process, you obviously have the responsibility of defending what you believe.</p><p>Perhaps the first 15 or 20 days of AAP rule in Delhi were too good to be true. However things started backfiring with Somnath Bharti’s nocturnal adventures, and AAP leadership backing him up. It became impossible to defend the indefensible with the dharna episode, and finally Arvind Kejriwal’s resignation on the 49th day of his government was nothing short of a political harakiri.</p><p>And then political activism took a back seat in my priorities. It was not because of my belief in alternative political thinking had come down, but just because I believe that this election time it is better to preserve my energies on other things, because AAP just lacks good political strategies and strategists.</p><p>I am not blaming Yogendra Yadav or Arvind Kejriwal here. When you are in middle of a political movement, where you will have a mix of sycophants and very few naysayers around you, you become myopic. You are unable to see, beyond your periphery, and that I believe is the issue which AAP is grappling with. Too many wrong decisions, and very few right messages that can inspire a nation which is swept over by what we call the Modi wave.</p><p>And I am still backing AAP, when it’s almost a certainty that NDA will be back to power, surfing on this Modi wave. And I am concerned.</p><p>My concerns about a Modi victory has nothing to do with the fact that Modi is communal. Yes, he is, and I have no doubt that his first victory in 2002 elections in Gujarat was a result of polarization of votes. But Modi could not have won the second and third time based on the polarization alone. However I sense that Modi is a smart man, and he will play up to the galleries, and build an image of being a more acceptable leader. He may even be tough on some right wing Hindu elements to spruce up that image of a moderate leader, even a secular one— that of another Vajpayee.</p><p>What I am bothered about is the amount of monies that are being spent to spruce up his image, the crores that are being spent to ferry across masses to attend his rallies, and the millions which are being spent on buying votes. My own conservative estimate is that BJP would be spending in excess of Rs 30,000 crores to win this elections.</p><p>It’s clear that this money is not contributed by the masses. Vast majority of Indians are poor, and are struggling to feed themselves. Hence the money comes from a certain business class which is clearly investing in Modi.</p><p>Now there are two kinds of Modi backers, and I will call them investors. One who is investing because they want to see a brighter future for themselves and the country. They are businessmen I know and salaried senior executives of MNCs who are voting for BJP and Modi, because they feel it’s better to back up a winner, rather than opt for a fragmented parliament, and another five years of policy paralysis. Many of them tell me that they would have backed Congress if they believed it had a chance.</p><p>However these friends of mine do not contribute to the BJP election funds, the only investments which they make is that of their vote.</p><p>What worries me is those investors who are pumping in big money, and mostly black. The kind of money that helps Modi hop across the country in a helicopter. The kind of money which is financing the liquor and cash to buy votes. The kind of money would have been used to perhaps ferry Sonia or Rahul Gandhi or another day, in another elections.</p><p>These are investments curried with risks.And bigger the risks, bigger are the returns.</p><p>Returns to the tune of at least five times of the investment. And these investors will ask for their pound of flesh once the party comes to power, and that’s essentially my friends is crony capitalism.</p><p>To me under a camouflage for development, what BJP and Modi are pimping is crony capitalism, and millions of voters are unknowingly going to back Modi on this. So let’s do some simple calculations. Rs 30,000 crores (or $5 billion) is the investment kitty. The returns expected are 5 times, and that would be Rs 150,000 crore ($25 billion). This is still a conservative estimate.</p><p>Where will these returns come from? It could be from anywhere. Favourable policies, fixing the budget, selling natural resources, and much more. And then there are kick backs at every stage. Local politicians, bureaucrats, opposition leaders and even NGOs will need to get bribed. So the cost over next five years, which the country need to pay could be anything from 500,000 to 1,000,000 crores. So what difference would be there from the current UPA government and a future NDA government?</p><p>The problem is that like corruption breeds corruption, crony capitalism opens up doors for more crony capitalism. But unfortunately our country does not have unlimited resources. And both the costs of getting elected, and the greed to rake in large returns would only grow exponentially in future.</p><p>Some of my friends in BJP claims that Modi is incorruptible, let’s assume for argument sake that he is indeed incorruptible. However, if BJP ends up getting 200 plus seats, remember at least 100 goons get elected who will look at recovering their money, and Modi will need to keep them happy. Then there’s the so called coalition dharma.</p><p>We need to put an end to all these, and the only way we can put an end is through alternate politics, where the gamble is much lesser, so that expectations on returns is even lesser.</p><p>Back in 50s and 60s, when politics meant social service, politicians only gained respect and no money. From the 70s you saw real career politicians across the country and it became a profession. Today from a profession, politics has become business, and we are entering very dangerous territories.</p><p>For all the riches the country has, we have one poor person out of every third living in this planet. Crony Capitalism will ensure that those below the poverty line will continue to be poor. The richest in the country will continue to get richer, and the poor-rich divide will grow to such proportions that we may need another bloody revolution to bridge that divide. This is very worrisome !</p><p>Friends question whether AAP has an economic policy, any vision or roadmap to take this country forward. If you are expecting a BJP like manifesto, then I am afraid the answer is No. AAP is definitely left of the center, without exhibiting the Hammer and Sickle flavour. Some of its founding members are fairly left leaning thinkers, and they are a burden for the party at this point of time and in future as they will alienate a huge chunk of middle class voters.</p><p>AAP’s economic agenda would be to stick to basics. Focus on ensuring the vast majority of this country get the absolute necessary—education, healthcare, food to eat and the likes. Yes, the fortunate amongst us who have all these taken care,and wanting more would label them Naxals when they talk of such basic necessities. But remember it’s a day-today struggle for 70 percent of our population on these counts.</p><p>However AAP offers you few things which no other party can. It can potentially get a couple of hundred candidates elected to the parliament with money contributed by the public— clean and white money. Such numbers perhaps are not going to happen this time, but the time will come.</p><p>And these candidates will have lesser reasons to get back their returns. They will not have to answer investors who waiting to exploit the natural resources of the country We need politicians who does not have the pressure to answer their political fundraisers. We need politicians who needs to only answer their real political masters— the voters of their constituency and the citizens of the country.</p><p>We want by next elections, lesser investors funding the liquor and money to buy, and fewer politicians ferrying the masses for rallies. We want politics to be a less of a business and more of a social service, and we want lesser number of career politicians.</p><p>Some may say that voting for AAP would be a waste, because they are not going to win this time. But remember every vote counts. The choice between NDA and UPA is not real, because they are both the same at the end of the day, just different symbols, and different vote banks. If there’s a possibility of politics with a difference, then it’s just through Aam Aadmi party.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e8f1cc79c038" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>