<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Rami Zahra on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Rami Zahra on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@rami_zahra?source=rss-5d95452aa4e4------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Thu, 19 Nov 2026 23:24:43 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@rami_zahra/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Bleeding Levant: The Continuous Demographic Purge of Eastern Christians]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@rami_zahra/the-bleeding-levant-the-ottoman-architecture-of-eradication-and-the-demographic-uprooting-of-551d8e178b36?source=rss-5d95452aa4e4------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/551d8e178b36</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[christianity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[eastern-christianity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[demographic-uprooting]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ottoman-empire]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[massacre]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Rami Zahra]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 16 Oct 2026 22:38:59 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-10-24T18:13:25.152Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Before the desert swallowed their names, imperial decree erased their geography — an unsparing record of a century and a half of Eastern Christian erasure.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*6oaFG1odkW_uFH54IpiF-w.jpeg" /></figure><p>On the seventeenth of October, marking the 176th anniversary of the 1850 Aleppo Riot <strong>(<em>Qawmat Halab قومة حلب</em>)</strong>, we are not merely commemorating a static date on a calendar or an isolated civil disturbance lost to archival dust. We are confronting the defining turning point that inaugurated an explicit, systematic programme of persecution against the Christians of the East under Ottoman rule. <br>Aleppo served as the grim harbinger of what would become of empty imperial promises of citizenship and civic equality, unleashing a century and a half of calculated demographic engineering and the tearing of indigenous communities from their ancestral soil.</p><p>The collapse of the Christian presence across the Levant — specifically in Syria, Iraq, and Lebanon — was never an accidental by-product of regional instability, nor was it an abrupt calamity born solely out of the extremist surges of the past decade. <br>An unsparing, forensic reading of this protracted tragedy reveals that the current demographic draining of the region is the organic culmination of a deliberate Ottoman policy of demographic eradication, later inherited and reproduced by successor regimes and non-state actors alike. <br>The Sublime Porte did not merely enforce military subjugation and punitive taxation; it operated an administrative and ideological apparatus of attrition that progressed from regional intimidation campaigns into state-sponsored massacres and genocidal sweeps.</p><h3>The Mirage of the Tanzimat and the Bloodstained Promise of Equality (1850–1860)</h3><p>In the mid-nineteenth century, a fracturing Ottoman Empire enacted the <em>Tanzimat تنظيمات </em>reforms to project an image of modern statehood to the Western powers. <br>On paper, these imperial edicts abolished the centuries-old <em>dhimmi</em> caste, replacing discriminatory tax codes and civil restrictions with theoretical legal equality under a unified Ottoman identity. In practice, the reforms proved fatal. <br>The commercial vitality, educational institutions, and <a href="https://www.cambridge.org/gb/universitypress/subjects/history/middle-east-history/ottoman-city-between-east-and-west-aleppo-izmir-and-istanbul"><strong>economic ascent of Levantine Christians</strong></a> — bolstered by maritime trade links with Europe — shattered the traditional supremacist social hierarchy, igniting deep-seated resentment among reactionary local elites and impoverished urban factions.</p><p>The reaction was swift, visceral, and inscribed in blood. <br>On 17 October 1850, mob violence erupted in Aleppo. <br>The historic Christian quarters of Al-Saliba and Al-Judaideh were ransacked; hundreds of Christian civilians were slaughtered, and six historic churches were desecrated and plundered. <br>In his scholarship published by <a href="https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/international-journal-of-middle-east-studies/article/abs/1850-events-in-aleppo-an-aftershock-of-syrias-incorporation-into-the-capitalist-world-system/0FCBB3EB63BF7A8213BE1B68797B92D4"><strong>Cambridge University Press</strong></a>, historian Bruce Masters documents how the local Ottoman governor, Mustafa Zarif Pasha, retreated behind the fortified walls of his barracks, refusing to intervene and deliberately abandoning the Christian quarters to the looters. The massacre triggered the first modern exodus of Christian merchants and intellectuals from Aleppo toward Beirut, Smyrna, and Alexandria, dealing a structural blow to the city’s pluralistic fabric.</p><p>Aleppo was merely the dress rehearsal. A decade later, in July 1860, sectarian conflict spilling over from Mount Lebanon and Zahlé culminated in the catastrophic massacre of Damascus, remembered locally as <a href="https://www.majalla.com/node/160186/%D8%AB%D9%82%D8%A7%D9%81%D8%A9%D9%85%D8%A4%D8%B1%D8%AE-%D8%B3%D9%88%D8%B1%D9%8A-%D9%8A%D8%B3%D8%AA%D8%B9%D9%8A%D8%AF-%D8%A3%D8%AD%D8%AF%D8%A7%D8%AB-%C2%AB%D9%86%D9%83%D8%A8%D8%A9-%D9%86%D8%B5%D8%A7%D8%B1%D9%89-%D8%A7%D9%84%D8%B4%D8%A7%D9%85%C2%BB-%D9%84%D8%B9%D9%84%D9%91-%D8%A7%D9%84%D8%B0%D9%83%D8%B1%D9%89-%D8%AA%D9%86%D9%81%D8%B9"><strong><em>Tawshat al-Sham طوشة الشام</em></strong></a>. <br>Ottoman complicity was absolute: imperial garrison commanders, led by Governor Ahmed Pasha, actively disarmed Christian residents or withdrew protective cordons, while irregular troops (<em>Bashi-bazouks باشبوزق</em>) joined the rioters. Over seven days of slaughter, the Bab Touma quarter was reduced to ash; nearly 5,000 Christians out of an urban population of 22,000 were murdered. <br>Damascus demonstrated that within the Ottoman orbit, any departure from codified subservience would be met with collective destruction.</p><h3>Centralising Violence: The Hamidian Massacres (1894–1896)</h3><p>By the close of the nineteenth century, violence shifted from state-tolerated municipal pogroms to centrally orchestrated extermination. <br>Confronting territorial erosion and rising Armenian demands for civil rights, Sultan Abdul Hamid II institutionalised state-sponsored militias: the Hamidiye light cavalry (<a href="https://www.cambridge.org/core/books/cambridge-history-of-christianity/89BE54EDC94C83AB6260024F86AB6757"><strong><em>Hamidiye Alayları</em></strong></a><strong><em> أفواج الحميدية</em></strong>).</p><p>Between 1894 and 1896, these units, supported by regular troops and incited tribes, swept across the eastern provinces. <br>The Hamidian Massacres claimed between 80,000 and 300,000 Armenian and Syriac lives, leaving upwards of 50,000 orphans and reducing hundreds of monasteries and churches to ruins or converting them by force into mosques. The violence was not confined to Armenians; during the 1895 massacres in the Diyarbekir Vilayet, as many as 25,000 Syriac Christians were slaughtered, establishing a precedent for total territorial cleansing.</p><h3>Adana 1909: Constitutional Camouflage, Unaltered Doctrine</h3><p>The vital historical link bridging the Hamidian atrocities to the total genocide of 1915 occurred in the Adana Vilayet in April 1909. <br>Following the 1908 Young Turk Revolution and the restoration of the Ottoman constitution, the Committee of Union and Progress (CUP) promised liberty, justice, and fraternity. <br>Yet when political crisis struck, the machinery of slaughter re-emerged with terrifying speed.</p><p><a href="https://www.cambridge.org/core/books/abs/cambridge-world-history-of-genocide/ottoman-massacres-of-armenians-18941896-and-1909/81A9DF0AD37185DBCB8BB02DDC44D10C"><strong>Academic studies</strong></a> published in <em>The Cambridge World History of Genocide</em> record that over 20,000 Armenians were murdered across Adana and Cilicia within weeks. <br>The Adana massacres shattered the illusion that constitutional governance had altered imperial instincts; the preservation of the imperial core was irrevocably tied to the physical reduction of its Christian populations.</p><h3>1915: The Zenith of Eradication and the Erasing of Geography</h3><p>Under the fog of the First World War, the CUP triumvirate implemented what was, in effect, a comprehensive final settlement of the Christian question. <br>Initiated on 24 April 1915 with the targeted arrest and execution of Armenian community leaders in Constantinople, the state deployed the Special Organisation (<em>Teşkilât-ı Mahsusa</em>) alongside imperial armies to execute mass deportations and executions. <br>Over 1.5 million Armenians perished through forced death marches into the Syrian desert, starvation, and direct executions.</p><p>Simultaneously, the genocide consumed the Syriac, Assyrian, and Chaldean peoples of northern Mesopotamia through the <a href="https://cap-press.com/books/isbn/9781594604362/Genocide-in-the-Middle-East"><strong><em>Sayfo</em> مذابح السيفو (“The Sword”)</strong></a>. <br>Historian Hannibal Travis documents that between 250,000 and 500,000 Syriac and Assyrian Christians were systematically eliminated. <br>Ancient cultural heartlands — Tur Abdin, Hakkari, Mardin, and Urmia — were emptied of their indigenous inhabitants through massacres, systemic rapes, and the wholesale confiscation of properties.</p><p>As Benny Morris and Dror Ze’evi <a href="https://www.hup.harvard.edu/books/9780674916456"><strong>demonstrate in <em>The Thirty-Year Genocide</em> (Harvard University Press, 2019)</strong></a>, the atrocities committed between 1894 and 1924 were not disjointed wartime excesses, but a sustained, state-driven thirty-year campaign designed to homogenise the realm by destroying its Christian foundations.</p><h3>The Unbroken Continuum (1918–1923)</h3><p>The signing of the 1918 Armistice did not halt the violence. <br>As documented in <a href="https://www.jstor.org/stable/j.ctvw04g61"><strong><em>Genocide in the Ottoman Empire: Armenians, Assyrians, and Greeks, 1913–1923</em>,</strong></a> the interwar period and the rise of the Turkish nationalist movement saw the continuation of expulsions, forced requisitions, and ethnic cleansing against remaining Greek Orthodox, Pontic, Armenian, and Assyrian survivors. <br>The <a href="https://www.hup.harvard.edu/books/9780674916456"><strong>new regional</strong></a> order was built atop the expropriated estates, businesses, and cultural heritage of wiped-out Christian communities.</p><h3>Simele 1933: The Post-Imperial Inheritance</h3><p>The destruction of the Eastern Christian fabric survived the fall of the Ottoman Sultanate. <br>In August 1933, the newly established Royal Iraqi Army carried out the <a href="https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/international-journal-of-middle-east-studies/article/abs/assyrian-affair-of-1933-i/A5D82B8880D796563782E73D85FACC6C"><strong>Simele Massacre</strong></a><strong> مجزرة سُميل</strong>, killing thousands of unarmed Assyrian men, women, and children and destroying dozens of villages. <br>Simele demonstrated that the post-Ottoman nation-states had inherited the foundational premise of their imperial predecessor: <a href="https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/international-journal-of-middle-east-studies/article/abs/assyrian-affair-of-1933-ii/C9BD52BD15F4A4F20CAFE5503D63A47D"><strong>that non-Muslim indigenous communities</strong></a> represented internal security threats to be managed through force and territorial uprooting.</p><h3>Contemporary Iraq: The Draining of Nineveh</h3><p>In modern history, the erasure of Iraq’s Christian population was methodical long before the territorial rise of Islamic State. Following the 2003 invasion, systematic kidnappings, bombings of churches, and targeted assassinations forced thousands into exile. In October 2008, the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) <a href="https://www.unhcr.org/uk/news/briefing-notes/unhcr-aiding-uprooted-iraqi-christians"><strong>documented</strong></a> the mass flight of thousands of Christians from Mosul following coordinated intimidation campaigns.</p><p>When ISIS seized Mosul and the Nineveh Plains in the <a href="https://iraq.un.org/en/278773-unitad-shares-detailed-findings-international-crimes-committed-against-christians-isil-da"><strong>summer of 2014</strong></a>, it executed the final phase of this historic uprooting. Homes were marked with the Arabic letter <em>N</em> ن (<em>Nasrani نصراني</em>), bank accounts were confiscated, and entire populations were expelled on pain of death. <br>In September 2024, the United Nations Investigative Team to Promote Accountability for Crimes Committed by Da’esh/ISIL (UNITAD) delivered its definitive findings, confirming that ISIS committed international crimes against Iraqi Christians, including crimes against humanity and war crimes encompassing forcible deportation, enslavement, torture, and cultural destruction.</p><h3>Syria: The Demographic Collapse</h3><p>Across the border in Syria, the modern conflict has accelerated a quiet, devastating collapse. According to a country-focus <a href="https://www.euaa.europa.eu/coi/syria/2025/country-focus/24-ethno-religious-minorities/245-christians"><strong>report released by the European Union Agency for Asylum (EUAA) in July 2025</strong></a>, the Christian demographic weight has experienced an alarming contraction. <br>Prior to the 2011 uprising, Christians comprised approximately 10% of Syria’s total population; current assessments estimate that this share has plummeted to around 2% — scarcely 300,000 individuals — with historic quarters in Aleppo, Homs, and the Khabur River basin largely abandoned.</p><p>To the Western Christian conscience, which observes its faith from the stable sanctuary of historic capitals, a stark, uncomfortable truth must be confronted: the Christians of the Levant are not a marginal, exotic minority seeking Western pity, but the living root of the global Christian body. They are the custodians of the very soil where the faith was first articulated, where early liturgy took form, and where apostolic communities took root.</p><p>When the West treats this protracted uprooting as a mere humanitarian refugee file, it participates in the active amnesia of its own foundations. The bells of Western cathedrals ring hollow if the historical churches of Nineveh, Aleppo, and Tur Abdin are systematically silenced. A Middle East stripped of its indigenous Christians leaves the West reading its own scripture as an extinct myth devoid of living witnesses.</p><p>Defending the Christian presence in the East demands rigorous historical accountability. One cannot ensure the survival, dignity, and right of return for these communities without explicitly confronting the structural legacy of Ottoman eradication and dismantling the supremacist ideologies that continue to finish its work today.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=551d8e178b36" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[“Never Will the Jews or the Christians Be Pleased with You”: The Hypocrisy Manifesto of a System…]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@rami_zahra/never-will-the-jews-or-the-christians-be-pleased-with-you-the-hypocrisy-manifesto-of-a-system-c0340703a631?source=rss-5d95452aa4e4------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c0340703a631</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[islam]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[taqiyya]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[jews]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[hypocrisy-manifesto]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[christian]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Rami Zahra]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 15 Oct 2026 10:20:06 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-10-19T06:17:31.797Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>“Never Will the Jews or the Christians Be Pleased with You”: The Hypocrisy Manifesto of a System that Rejects Coexistence yet Complains of Rejection</h3><blockquote><em>Unravelling the victim complex of a system that shelters beneath the safety nets of the free world, only to reduce the concept of citizenship to institutionalised hypocrisy and theological paranoia.</em></blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*kH4P1lZ-cTXbz73_4ePQeg.jpeg" /></figure><p>When entire societies are held captive by a text born out of a tribal conflict fourteen centuries ago, adopting it as the sole lens through which to view the contemporary world, we are no longer witnessing a state of faith, but rather a pathological condition of intellectual alienation and existential paranoia. The verse, <strong>“</strong><a href="https://legacy.quran.com/2/120"><strong>And never will the Jews or the Christians be pleased with you until you follow their religion, </strong></a><a href="https://legacy.quran.com/2/120"><strong>Quran 2:120</strong></a><a href="https://legacy.quran.com/2/120"><strong>”</strong></a> is no longer a mere historical document. In the collective consciousness, it has transformed into an isolation wall — a psychological and security veto that paralyses the potential for any social contract. It produces a discourse that lives as a parasite on the democracies of secular states, only to stab them in the back with the blade of the text.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*92KetKSFx21dk7LU1Kz8Vw.png" /></figure><p><strong>The Geography of the Text and the Illusion of Forced Assimilation</strong></p><p>To understand this predicament, the text must be placed under the scalpel of historical investigation, stripping it of its cosmic aura of sanctity and reducing it to its true size: a “cover-up” for a dismal political failure. Muhammad arrived in Yathrib clearly wagering on legitimising his message by winning over the Jews of Medina and the Christians of Najran. He faced their Qibla (Jerusalem) for sixteen months, fasted on Ashura, and drew inspiration from their biblical narratives as bridges of connection. When this gamble crashed against the rock of decisive theological rejection, and the Qibla was diverted to Mecca signalling a definitive rupture, this verse arrived to slam the door shut. <br>It is not a divine revelation of the nature of nations, but rather a defensive formulation for a failed gamble on integration, which the system later weaponised into an eternal decree of hostility to justify its early inability to extract recognition from the ‘other’.</p><p>In its attempt to invent a fictitious enemy front, this text committed a glaring historical and theological fallacy by lumping “Jews and Christians” into a single basket, portraying them as an identical bloc striving for one goal: to convert Muslims to their faith. <br>This discourse is astonishingly ignorant of the fact that Judaism is an ethno-national, closed, and inherently non-proselytising religion; the biblical Jew does not seek to invite anyone and places insurmountable conditions before those seeking to convert. Accusing the Jews that they will not be pleased until their religion is followed is a blatant fabrication of the opponent’s motives to invent an illusory desire for assimilation.</p><p>The social philosopher Eric Hoffer captured this pathological necessity perfectly when he noted that mass movements can rise and spread without belief in a God, but never without belief in a devil. <br>This verse was not merely a reaction; it was a psychological imperative to invent an eternal ‘devil’ to ensure the cohesion of the followers. <br>The opponent did not reject Muhammad out of a desire to assimilate him, but rather in rejection of claims that abrogated their covenant. <br>Had this text emanated from an all-encompassing, cosmic God, how did major religions like Hinduism and Buddhism — which embraced hundreds of millions — slip His awareness? <br>Reducing the theological challenge solely to the geographical perimeter navigated by the caravans of Quraysh is the damning fingerprint of a limited horizon.</p><p><strong>Inverted Mirrors and the Guillotine of Freedom of Conscience</strong></p><p>The flaw does not stop at the borders of geography and history; it plunges into the deepest states of psychological projection. <br>The system that faults the ‘other’ for not being pleased until their religion is followed is the very same system that rejects any egalitarian existence of the other, dogmatically declaring that <strong>“the [true] religion with Allah is Islam”</strong> and no other shall be accepted. <br>It did not stop at the dogmatic aspect; it codified military subjugation and imposed a tax of humiliation through the legislation of the <a href="https://medium.com/@rami_zahra/the-anatomy-of-dhimmitude-demystifying-modern-apologetics-surrounding-jizyah-7ca87d6fcc6c"><strong>Jizya</strong></a>,<strong> “willingly while they are humbled.”</strong> <br>How can a system that legalises the confiscation of others’ sovereignty and their humiliation cry foul and complain that they would prefer it if their religion were followed?</p><p>This discourse perfectly embodies what the French thinker Pascal Bruckner termed the “tyranny of guilt” and the monopolisation of victimhood. <br>A system that institutionalises the subjugation of minorities and the execution of apostates, whilst simultaneously weeping over its own marginalisation, practices the worst form of the ‘temptation of innocence’. It wears the mask of the eternal victim to grant itself a moral immunity, justifying its totalitarianism and its erasure of the ‘other’ without a shred of remorse.</p><p>The ultimate moral scandal manifests in the double standard towards freedom of conscience. The discourse screams warnings of conspiracies to strip the Muslim of his identity, whilst the system itself legalises the “summary execution” of anyone who exercises their basic human right to change their belief. <br>The apostate in Islamic jurisprudence is not offered the option of the Jizya; rather, their blood is voided by categorical consensus, founded upon the absolute foundational text: <strong>“Whoever changes his religion, kill him,” </strong>and affirmed by the consensus of the companions and jurists documented by Ibn Qudamah in the encyclopaedia <em>Al-Mughni</em>. <br>A system that trembles with ecstasy, mobilises the media, and allocates budgets for a naive celebration of a Westerner converting to Islam — merely to soothe a civilisational inferiority complex — whilst gripping a sword to sever the neck of anyone who leaves it, is a system that has forfeited any moral right to speak on freedom of belief or complain about the proselytisation of others.</p><p><strong>Manufacturing a Fifth Column and the Academic Institutionalisation of Paranoia</strong></p><p>Upon the collision of this terrifying heritage with contemporary reality, the system does not take a step back. Instead, it surges forward to institutionalise this paranoia using all its populist and academic tools, in a spectacle that barricades any genuine attempt at integration. <br>Firstly, the comical scene of cheap anachronism emerges, where populist preachers deliberately cram concepts of the modern state into a medieval text. <br>One such figure, <a href="https://x.com/Dr_Farhan_Obaid/status/1365756784200318978"><strong><em>“Dr Farhan Obaid”</em></strong></a>, declares that the verse is a warning against abolishing Sharia, <strong><em>changing school curricula, normalising diplomatic ties, women walking without headscarves, and selling alcohol. </em></strong><br>This delirium ignores that alcohol was brewed and consumed in the heart of Yathrib for many years. <br>It conveniently forgets that the hijab in early Islam was a class-based attire meant to distinguish free women from slave girls — with Umar ibn al-Khattab famously striking veiled slave girls lest they resemble free women. It was never a theological symbol upon which the pleasure of rabbis hinged.</p><p>Lest one think this deployment is merely a populist slip, the official academic establishment intervenes to lock the door of independent reasoning (Ijtihad) firmly. Whilst some might hope for a historical reading that confines the verse to the era of the Prophet, academics and former Awqaf ministers, such as <a href="https://x.com/Dralajmey/status/1078600204897652737"><strong><em>“Dr Nayef Al-Ajmi”</em></strong></a>, emerge to declare that deeming the verse exclusive to the Messenger of Allah and inapplicable to the wider Ummah is a “false statement”. <br>Relying on the absolute jurisprudential rule that consideration is given to the generality of the wording, Al-Ajmi invokes other verses to affirm that the hostility towards Jews and Christians is a continuous and enduring legislation. <br>This academic institutionalisation of paranoia represents the coup de grâce to any attempt at taming the text. <br>The official establishment fiercely refuses to live in the present, insisting that a Muslim child in the West carries the exact same tribal complex that prevailed in the seventh century.</p><p>However, the most dangerous and malicious version of this institutionalisation is <a href="https://x.com/ArabicBest/status/909672466393518080"><strong>what was formulated</strong></a> by the icon of popular exegesis, Sheikh <em>“Muhammad Metwally El-Shaarawy”</em>, when he emptied the concept of “coexistence” of any moral or human content, reducing it to a mere political tactic and a state of <a href="https://medium.com/@rami_zahra/al-taqiyya-the-terrorist-art-of-deception-548ce3514369">“<strong>Taqiyya</strong>” (dissimulation)</a> during periods of weakness. <br>El-Shaarawy does not present coexistence as a virtue. <br>Instead, he coldly explains that the era of Muhammad’s initial treaties with the Jews of Yathrib was merely a forced “coexistence”, interpreting it as tolerating the outward shell of actions <strong>without any “love in the heart”</strong>, because Muhammad was never going to do what pleased them anyway. When he acquired power and the balance of power shifted with the reversal of the Qibla, the verse descended to shatter the illusion of pleasure and end the charade of appeasement. <br>El-Shaarawy boastfully concludes: if this was the strict cautionary discourse directed at the Prophet himself, what then of the ordinary Muslim?</p><p>With this reference-level interpretation, the mainstream discourse confesses that what it markets today to the free world under the guise of “integrative coexistence” is nothing but an explicit religious institutionalisation of <a href="https://medium.com/@rami_zahra/al-taqiyya-the-terrorist-art-of-deception-548ce3514369"><strong>Taqiyya</strong></a>, a divine mandate for equivocation, and societal hypocrisy permitted in times of necessity. <br>The discourse here does not build a citizen; rather, it manufactures a fifth column adept at flashing a feigned smile in the face of its neighbour, exploiting the benefits and laws of its host country with extreme opportunism until the balance of power shifts. This alienation reaches its zenith when El-Shaarawy concludes with his catastrophic rule:<strong> “If the Jews are pleased with someone, let him be judged as having departed from the religion of Allah.”</strong> <br>This programming transforms your humanity, and your dedication to your profession as a doctor, lawyer, or journalist earning the trust and respect of your Western surroundings, into an “indicator of apostasy” from the religion! <br>It is a system built on a jurisprudence of <em>halal and haram</em>, dealing with the world with the supremacy of an executioner who feigns weakness until empowered, turning emotional isolation and civic <a href="https://medium.com/@rami_zahra/al-taqiyya-the-terrorist-art-of-deception-548ce3514369"><strong>hypocrisy into a divine obligation.</strong></a></p><p>The surrealism is completed in that scandalous scene that has become all too familiar every Friday: a cleric or an activist, having fled the hell of oppression, poverty, economic collapse, and Sharia laws in his home country, seeking refuge in the nations of the free world. <br>He stands in the heart of London or Paris, his dignity guaranteed, protected by a law that does not discriminate on the basis of race or religion. He relies on social safety nets funded by the very taxpayer he excommunicates, holding a Western passport that preserves his humanity in every airport across the globe.</p><p>This paradox brings to mind the philosopher Karl Popper’s famous warning regarding the ‘paradox of tolerance’ — the assertion that unlimited tolerance must lead to the disappearance of tolerance itself. If a society extends unlimited tolerance to those who are fundamentally intolerant, the tolerant will be destroyed, and tolerance with them. This fundamentalist discourse tests Popper’s prophecy every single day.</p><p>Then, with sheer audacity, this cleric grips the microphone to scream at immigrants with feigned reverence: “Beware… And never will the Jews or the Christians be pleased with you until you follow their religion!” He lives as a parasite upon their lack of pleasure, basking in the bounties of their democracy and secular civil rights, only to pelt them with medieval paranoia from a pulpit protected by their own laws. It is a vulgar display of double standards, slaughtering the values of Western citizenship with the very knife of freedom.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c0340703a631" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Dissecting the Illusion of Secession: The Geopolitical and Monetary Fault Lines Dismantling the…]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@rami_zahra/dissecting-the-illusion-of-secession-the-geopolitical-and-monetary-fault-lines-dismantling-the-8261514ed273?source=rss-5d95452aa4e4------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8261514ed273</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[brexit]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[geopolitics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[scottish-independence]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[uk]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[british-politics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Rami Zahra]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 14 Sep 2026 18:43:28 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-09-14T18:43:28.501Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Dissecting the Illusion of Secession: The Geopolitical and Monetary Fault Lines Dismantling the Break-up of the United Kingdom</h3><p>Secession does not reclaim sovereignty; it merely trades London’s safety net for Brussels’ mandates.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*viyfD6X2tLDE0QT2NxGdeQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>Prevailing political and media commentary routinely treats the “break-up of the United Kingdom” as a classic contest between the right to self-determination and the lingering imperial impulses of London. This ideological oversimplification grants the nationalist parties on the periphery — the Scottish National Party (SNP), Sinn Féin in Northern Ireland, and Plaid Cymru in Wales — an enduring platform to peddle a narrative of historic grievance that is emotionally seductive and electorally lucrative.</p><p>Yet dismantling the British state’s institutional infrastructure and moving the issue from rhetorical posturing to the cold slab of political dissection exposes a web of structural dependencies, legal quagmires, and geopolitical dead ends. The leaders of these independence movements possess not a single coherent answer to these realities; instead, they evade them entirely to prevent an immediate confrontation with the operational complexities that inevitably arise once political rhetoric gives way to governance.</p><p><strong>1, The Trap of “Sterlingisation” and the Absence of a Lender of Last Resort: How Independence Surrenders Monetary Sovereignty</strong></p><p>The currency question remains the primary strategic pillar of any secessionist project, particularly in the Scottish case. Nationalist leaders advocate for “sterlingisation” — the informal, unilateral use of the British pound sterling following secession, ostensibly as a transitional measure prior to launching an independent currency or adopting the euro. This proposal conceals a fundamental economic contradiction:</p><p><strong>. The Loss of an Unlimited Lender of Last Resort:</strong> If an emerging state utilises another country’s currency without a formal currency union, its putative central bank lacks the authority wielded by the Bank of England to create sterling and inject emergency liquidity on an unlimited scale. Preserving banking stability would therefore depend far more precariously on liquid reserves, bespoke financial stability arrangements, and untested bilateral accords. In an economy where the banking and financial sector represents a substantial proportion of gross domestic product, any banking distress would become an existential challenge for the nascent state.</p><p><strong>. Subjugation to English Monetary Policy:</strong> Interest rates and monetary conditions would remain exclusively determined by the decisions of the Bank of England’s Monetary Policy Committee, without the independent Scottish state holding membership within the governing body that sets those policies. This constitutes a de facto surrender of a core pillar of monetary sovereignty to an institution calibrated primarily to the requirements of the United Kingdom as a whole, without possessing the domestic central bank levers required to offset its domestic repercussions.</p><p><strong>. The Necessity of Independent Reserves and Fiscal Mechanisms: </strong>Transitioning to an independent state using sterling requires building an entirely new fiscal and banking framework, including liquidity arrangements, financial stability mechanisms, deposit protection schemes, and an adequate buffer to absorb external shocks. Establishing such an infrastructure is rendered extraordinarily formidable given that Scottish public finances run a severe structural deficit, as demonstrated by the official Government Expenditure and Revenue Scotland (GERS) accounts.</p><p><strong>2, The Trident Dilemma: The Blackmail Strategy That Burns Its Authors</strong></p><p>The military deployment of the United Kingdom’s strategic nuclear deterrent, Trident, at Faslane and Coulport on Scotland’s western coast represents one of the most sensitive, off-limits geopolitical files in nationalist circles. The SNP maintains a moralising platform demanding the immediate expulsion of nuclear weapons from Scottish waters upon independence. Yet this demand collides head-on with profound geopolitical and military realities:</p><p><strong>. The Faslane and Coulport Naval Bases:</strong> Replicating this nuclear infrastructure away from Scotland at an alternative location would be an exceptionally complex engineering and strategic undertaking, requiring decades of work and tens of billions in capital expenditure, coupled with rigorous hydrographic, geographic, and security constraints that make identifying a viable replacement exceptionally difficult.</p><p><strong>. NATO Accession:</strong> Nationalists envision rapid accession to NATO as an independent, non-nuclear state; yet this posture would plunge Scotland into protracted negotiations over its defence doctrine and its posture towards the alliance’s nuclear umbrella. Given that NATO is an alliance founded fundamentally upon nuclear deterrence, an independent Scottish state would be compelled to reconcile its unilateral ambition to decommission Trident with the strict conditions and strategic expectations of the alliance it seeks to join.</p><p><strong>. The Continuing British Military Footprint:</strong> Throughout any transitional phase, the status of nuclear bases and sovereign facilities would trigger rigorous and contentious negotiations between the newly independent state and the remainder of the United Kingdom concerning property rights, sovereignty, operational access, security regimes, and the prolonged timeline required to decommission or relocate installations. Independence would decidedly not mean the physical disappearance of this military architecture on the morning following separation.</p><p><strong>3, The Barnett Formula Lifeline: The Fiction of “Stolen Wealth” and the Reality of GERS</strong></p><p>Nationalist propaganda relies on the historical trope that London extracts peripheral wealth while withholding the revenues of North Sea hydrocarbons and renewable energy. Yet the Scottish Government’s own official statistics, published in the annual GERS reports, demonstrate a fiscal reality that confronts this grievance narrative with severe economic hurdles:</p><p><strong>. The Public Spending Differential:</strong> Public expenditure per head in Scotland, Wales, and Northern Ireland consistently outpaces the English equivalent by notable margins, sustained by the UK-wide fiscal transfer framework, principally the Barnett Formula funded through the general revenues of the United Kingdom.</p><p><strong>. Structural Fiscal Deficits:</strong> Scotland’s estimated net fiscal deficit stood at 10.9% of GDP for 2025–26, compared to 4.2% for the United Kingdom as a whole. This metric does not merely reflect the accounts of the devolved Scottish Government, but the structural difference between total public revenues raised in Scotland and total public spending undertaken for its benefit. Stripped of the United Kingdom’s overarching pooling and sharing mechanism, the emerging state would have to finance this shortfall through an aggressive combination of sovereign debt issuance, tax rises, public spending reductions, and long-term economic growth, with an independent issuer facing significantly higher borrowing costs than those secured under the UK sovereign umbrella.</p><p><strong>. The Illusion of Energy Windfalls:</strong> North Sea oil and gas revenues remain acutely vulnerable to international price volatility and the statutory trajectory of the green energy transition, rendering unilateral reliance on these volatile receipts as a fiscal backstop an extraordinarily hazardous gamble, even if they remain an important stream for the Scottish Exchequer.</p><p><strong>4, The Border Conundrum: Multiplying the Disruptions of Brexit</strong></p><p>While peripheral nationalist movements denounce Brexit as an act of economic self-harm, they champion a constitutional rupture that compounds its damage several times over:</p><p><strong>. Depth of Trade Integration:</strong> The rest of the United Kingdom, and England in particular, constitutes by far the most significant trading partner for the Scottish economy, with internal UK trade volumes vastly exceeding Scottish commerce with any single external international market.</p><p><strong>. The Inevitability of Trade and Legal Boundaries:</strong> An independent state cannot enter the European Union’s Single Market and Customs Union without having its commercial relations with third parties outside those frameworks governed by distinct regulatory and border regimes. Were Scotland to pursue EU accession, the land border with the rest of the United Kingdom would inevitably become subject to mandatory negotiations over customs, regulatory inspections, and sanitary and phytosanitary controls, depending on the terms of the eventual bilateral accords.</p><p><strong>. The Supply Chain Dilemma</strong>: How can nationalist administrations convince domestic industry, hauliers, and manufacturers to accept the systemic reorganisation and disruption of their primary domestic supply chains, at the very moment the new state is working to align its regulatory and commercial laws with Brussels? This contradiction represents one of the most punishing and complex costs of secession for the Scottish economy.</p><p><strong>5, Fractures in the Nationalist Front: Divergent Agendas Masked by False Solidarity</strong></p><p>The occasional joint appearances and shared memoranda between the three devolved administrations amount to little more than a tactical public relations exercise concealing irreconcilable constitutional objectives:</p><p><strong>. Northern Ireland Is Not a Project for Statehood:</strong> Sinn Féin’s constitutional goal is not the creation of a sovereign seat at the United Nations, but the alteration of Northern Ireland’s constitutional status through unification with the Republic of Ireland. This trajectory is circumscribed by delicate political, social, and security balances, and by a profoundly divided population regarding the territory’s constitutional allegiance.</p><p><strong>. Wales: An Economy Integrated into the English Core:</strong> Plaid Cymru is fully aware that electoral support for outright independence in Wales remains strictly limited, with the bulk of the population and economic activity concentrated in the south and east — regions deeply integrated into the neighbouring cities, industrial networks, and supply chains of England. This structural cohesion makes full constitutional separation an excruciatingly difficult economic proposition.</p><p><strong>. Conflicting Objectives in Brussels: </strong>Were these territories ever to negotiate terms with the European Union independently, they would inevitably enter distinct negotiations with divergent interests across structural funding, fisheries allocations, energy regulation, and market access, shattering any superficial alliance as soon as concrete economic interests collide.</p><p><strong>6, The English Centre of Gravity: Liberation of the Core, Not Its Isolation</strong></p><p>Superficial commentary regularly portrays England as the inevitable casualty of constitutional dissolution, isolated on the international stage. This reading completely ignores the fundamentals of international political economy:</p><p><strong>. Reallocation of Fiscal Resources:</strong> The termination of existing fiscal transfers across the Union would redraw the financial relationship between England and the newly separated states. While this could allow the British Treasury to retain resources previously redirected elsewhere, the net dividend would not be automatic, as the continuing state would also shoulder its share of inherited national liabilities, debt service, and shared international obligations, all of which would require extensive bilateral negotiation.</p><p><strong>. The Inescapable Transit Axis:</strong> By land, sea, and airspace, England remains the central logistical axis in the transport, power, and commercial networks connecting Scotland and Wales to Europe and the wider world. Consequently, the erection of international borders would hardly isolate England; rather, it would compel the newly established states to renegotiate transit, transit rights, energy corridors, and cross-border transport with their dominant neighbour.</p><p><strong>. The “Continuator State” and Diplomatic Weight:</strong> Under established principles of international law, the remainder of the United Kingdom would almost certainly be recognised as the continuator state across international organisations, preserving its permanent seat on the United Nations Security Council, its core treaty protections, and its sovereign standing. In contrast, an independent Scottish state would be tasked with negotiating its entry into international bodies from scratch and settling complex matters of state succession — a prolonged process requiring extensive political, legal, and institutional accommodations.</p><p><strong>The Functional Rhetoric of the Unachievable</strong></p><p>When subjected to rigorous economic, military, and geographical scrutiny, the independence project reveals itself not as a straightforward blueprint for viable statehood, but as a complex political manoeuvre that conceals fundamental, unresolved structural questions behind the banner of sovereignty. Flying the flag of secession remains an effective electoral instrument for nationalist parties to mobilise bases and leverage Westminster for expanded powers, but it fails to provide credible answers on how to fund a state, stabilise a currency, insulate a financial system, protect supply chains, or secure national territory.</p><p>Political leaders in Edinburgh, Cardiff, and Belfast are well aware that dismantling Britain is not a benign matter of hoisting different flags over regional parliaments. It is a systemic rupture that would dismantle existing fiscal solidarity, monetary certainty, and collective defence, casting emerging states into protracted, zero-sum negotiations with London, Brussels, and international allies. It is precisely for this reason that the rhetoric of independence will remain central to party conferences and media headlines, while the transition from manifesto to reality remains checked by budgetary arithmetic and the strategic interests of the British state.</p><p>In the specific context of Northern Ireland, nationalist reliance on external pressure collides with the binding constitutional framework established by the 1998 Belfast (Good Friday) Agreement under the auspices of the Clinton administration: the Principle of Consent. Neither London, nor Dublin, nor Washington possesses the legal authority to impose constitutional change on Northern Ireland; that choice rests strictly on the democratic consent of a majority within the jurisdiction via the statutory mechanisms established in the treaty. Within this framework, the historic institutional role of the United States remains that of an impartial guarantor committed to conflict resolution, rather than an arbiter of democratic self-determination. Passing political rhetoric cannot supersede the statutory safeguards of the Agreement.</p><p>Electorates drawn to nationalist slogans routinely overlook a glaring structural paradox: how can accession to the European Union or unification within the Republic of Ireland be framed as imperative for “unity, integration, and prosperity”, whilst simultaneously demanding the dismantlement of the United Kingdom — the very union that represents the most coherent, integrated, and historically durable internal market? The European Union is an evolving supranational project enforcing stringent budgetary parameters, common customs, and an eventual single currency. In contrast, the nations of Britain already inhabit a fully integrated monetary, fiscal, and legal framework, shaped collaboratively across centuries of representative parliamentary democracy.</p><p>Remaining within this historic Union serves the material interests of these populations far more effectively than constitutional upheaval. Improving public sector efficiency, refining fiscal accountability, and expanding local decision-making within the existing British constitutional architecture offers a far more viable and productive pathway than dissolving the state itself. The decisive vote of the Scottish electorate to remain within the United Kingdom in the 2014 referendum stands as compelling historical evidence that a substantial portion of Scottish voters actively preferred stability and established political and economic ties over the hazards of secession.</p><p>This contradiction becomes inescapable when one interrogates the nationalist narrative using its own primary weapon. If the contemporary separatist movement built its momentum by exploiting the dislocations of Brexit and feeding on public buyer’s remorse over departing the European bloc, should the electorate not ask itself — by parity of reasoning — what scale of historical remorse would accompany the break-up of the United Kingdom? Severing an organic union of more than three centuries would rapidly expose the acute costs and complexities of abstract promises of sovereignty, demonstrating that replacing an established state with unproven entities is not a routine constitutional exercise, but an arduous, high-risk reconstruction of currency, public finances, trade relations, defence capabilities, institutions, and international standing.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8261514ed273" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Myth That Islam Honoured Women..]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@rami_zahra/the-myth-that-islam-honoured-women-63e08519ac58?source=rss-5d95452aa4e4------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/63e08519ac58</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[honoured-women]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[myths-and-legends]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[left-wing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[islam]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[insulting-women]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Rami Zahra]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 24 Jul 2026 23:55:51 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-09-03T12:13:38.701Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>The Myth That Islam Honoured Women.. Deconstructing the System that Transforms Women from Human Beings into Public Property</h3><p>A critical deconstruction of the theological apparatus that systematically strips women of human agency under the guise of divine honouring. Exposing the shared hypocrisy of traditional jurisprudence, “Islamic feminism”, and Western multiculturalism.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*dcHt4oSrhZ95pCklW5O7CA.jpeg" /></figure><p>For decades, apologetics and sanitised theological discourses have echoed a persistent and demonstrably false mantra: <em>“Islam honoured women and granted them supreme status fifteen centuries ago.”</em> <br>This narrative is promoted not only by traditional clerics and religious institutions, but is also eagerly swallowed by naive Western “progressives” operating under the banners of “multiculturalism” and “anti-Islamophobia”.</p><p>However, once this cosmetic veneer manufactured for Western consumption is stripped away, one collides with a cold, indisputable reality: <strong>a comprehensive theological, jurisprudential, and cultural apparatus designed to strip women of their human agency, replacing it with a subservient status from their very first breath until they are buried in the earth</strong>.</p><p>This article does not seek to engage in pedantic, circular theological debates over minor procedural details that clerics have failed to agree upon for 1,400 years. <br>The core issue is not that women occasionally suffer from isolated acts of discrimination; rather, the system itself denies women full agency over their bodies, decisions, relationships, and lives — and then demands that they view this subjugation as an act of “honour”!</p><p><strong>The problem is not merely that women suffer injustice despite the existence of this framework; rather, the injustice itself has been systematically redefined as obedience, guardianship as protection, and servitude as honour.</strong></p><p>We are here to apply the scalpel directly to the wound — to confront live scriptural texts, Hadiths, contemporary fatwas, and social realities that shackle the lives of millions of women, stripping them of their basic human rights in the name of the “sacred”.</p><h3>1. Structural Discrimination: Lower Value from Birth</h3><p>The systemic devaluation of female existence is not an accidental social nuance; it is an <strong>entrenched theological foundation established at birth</strong>.</p><p>In the ritual of <em>Aqiqa</em> (the birth sacrifice), religious doctrine mandates the sacrifice of two sheep for a male infant, but only one for a female. This is not merely a financial distinction; it is a <strong>devastating symbolic decree establishing from day one that a female’s life is inherently valued at half that of a male</strong>. From this initial premise flows a continuous chain of discriminatory laws and doctrines:</p><ul><li><strong>Half a Witness:</strong> Regardless of a woman’s intellectual capacity, scientific achievements, or legal expertise, her court testimony is <a href="https://youtu.be/CngpEfZiOYc?si=Wjr0eODdOkdvQ2DC"><strong>quantified as half that of a man</strong></a>, explicitly stated in the Quran: <em>“And bring to witness two witnesses from among your men. And if there are not two men, then a man and two women from those whom you accept as witnesses — so that if one of the women errs, the other can remind her”</em> (Surah Al-Baqarah 2:282).</li><li><strong>Half Inheritance and Half Blood Money:</strong> In inheritance law, a daughter receives strictly half the share of her brother (Surah An-Nisa 4:11). In classical consensus jurisprudence (<em>Fiqh فقه</em>), the <em>Diyyah ديّة </em>(financial compensation paid for murder or bodily injury) for a female victim is explicitly fixed at half that of a male.</li><li><strong>Child Marriage:</strong> Traditional jurisprudence permits a father to contract a marriage for his underage daughter while she is still in the cradle or before reaching puberty (Surah At-Talaq 65:4). <br>The male guardian (<em>Wali ولي</em>) holds absolute authority to dispose of her life without her informed consent, limiting classical debates merely to determining the “age of consummation” (<em>al-bina’ البناء</em>), reducing a child’s bodily autonomy to zero.</li></ul><h3>2. Institutionalised Domestic Violence: Discipline and Nushuz</h3><p>Under the guise of marital “discipline” (<em>Ta’dib التأديب</em>), traditional jurisprudence explicitly legalises domestic violence against women.</p><p>Surah An-Nisa (4:34) establishes a rigid hierarchy, permitting the husband to discipline a rebellious wife (<em>Nushuz نشوز</em>) through a sequence of admonition, desertion in bed, and ultimately physical beating (<em>Wa-dhribuhunn واضربوهنّ</em>). <br>Clerics and traditional scholars <a href="https://youtu.be/8o-cBkvU5g4?si=gQ-KPmaoxfWcxjcp"><strong>attempt to soften this reality before Western audiences</strong></a> by claiming the beating must be “light” or symbolic (using a toothbrush or <em>Siwak سِواك</em>).</p><p>However, the legal principle remains intact and horrific: <strong>a man possesses a legitimate, religiously sanctioned right to inflict physical violence upon an adult woman to enforce her submission and obedience</strong>.</p><h3>3. From Father to Husband: The Stripping of Guardianship and Agency</h3><p>The problem extends far beyond a woman being “less free”; the legal structure enforces a <strong>systematic transfer of decision-making authority over her life from one male to another</strong>.</p><p>This structure relies on the distinction between <strong>“Agency”</strong> (<em>Wakalah وكالة</em>) and <strong>“Guardianship”</strong> (<em>Wilayah ولاية</em>). An agent acts on behalf of a fully competent individual with their consent, whereas a “Guardian” steps in because the woman, under this framework, is deemed permanently incompetent to make fundamental life choices.</p><p>The man is treated as the primary bearer of agency, whereas the female is the object of guardianship. Decision-making authority over her transfers from her father to her husband upon marriage, and back to a male relative or legal guardian during disputes. <br>In many <a href="https://www.hrw.org/reports/2008/saudiarabia0408/4.htm"><strong>legal environments</strong></a>, she cannot marry, obtain state documents, travel, or choose her residence without the permission of this male guardian, reducing her to a legal and social minor in perpetuity.</p><h3>4. Marriage as an Unequal Institution</h3><p>Even when a marriage ends, the myth of partnership is exposed; the two parties do not possess equal authority to dissolve the relationship:</p><ul><li><strong>Divorce (<em>Talaq طلاق</em>):</strong> An absolute right and unilateral male prerogative, exercised verbally and instantly without the need to prove grounds or seek judicial approval.</li><li><strong>Dissolution (<em>Khul’</em> <em>الخلع</em> and <em>Faskh الفسخ</em>):</strong> If a woman wishes to separate, she is forced to navigate arduous judicial hurdles, often required to surrender her financial rights and assets to buy back her freedom.</li><li><strong>Revocation (<em>Raj’ah الرجعة</em>) and Waiting Period (<em>‘Iddah العدة</em>):</strong> A man can unilaterally revoke a revocable divorce during the waiting period (<em>‘Iddah</em>) without a new contract or her consent. Meanwhile, the mandatory waiting period is imposed on the woman as a strict constraint restricting her movement and ability to start anew, while the man can remarry one hour after the divorce!</li></ul><h3>5. The Privilege of Desire and the Erasure of Sexual Agency</h3><p>Under this framework, the male is the <strong>subject of desire</strong>, while the female is the <strong>object of desire</strong>; the man seeks, the woman is sought; the man marries, the woman is married off.</p><ul><li><strong>Polygamy:</strong> A man is granted the privilege of legitimising his sexual desire through polygamy, marrying up to four women simultaneously (Surah An-Nisa 4:3), alongside concubines historically. Conversely, a woman’s sexual agency is confined to a single man, with any desire outside this boundary strictly criminalised under penalty of execution.</li><li><strong>Marital Sexual Coercion:</strong> Traditional texts erase mutual sexual consent, transforming male desire into a religious mandate that must be fulfilled immediately under threat of divine curse: <em>“If a man calls his wife to his bed and she refuses, and he spends the night angry with her, the angels will curse her until morning”</em> (Sahih al-Bukhari 3237, Sahih Muslim 1436). Scriptural traditions explicitly mandate her compliance regardless of her preoccupation: <em>“Even if he demands her while she is riding on the back of a camel saddle, she must not refuse”</em> (Musnad Ahmad, Sunan Ibn Majah 1853).</li><li><strong>Jealousy and Passivity:</strong> Male jealousy is weaponised into a legal right to conceal the woman and restrict her movement, whereas a woman is instructed to suppress her jealousy and accept co-wives as a sacred duty to be endured passively.</li></ul><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FTZvXJpL-kDQ%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DTZvXJpL-kDQ&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FTZvXJpL-kDQ%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="640" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/07aef4f0eda11866d4555ced221832cc/href">https://medium.com/media/07aef4f0eda11866d4555ced221832cc/href</a></iframe><h3>6. Micro-policing the Female Body: The Criminalisation of Perfume, Voice, and Movement</h3><p>The framework does not stop at structural laws governing inheritance and guardianship; it descends into a <strong>relentless legalistic micro-policing of a woman’s daily existence, aesthetics, and bodily autonomy</strong>:</p><ul><li><strong>The Criminalisation of Perfume:</strong> A woman is strictly forbidden from wearing fragrance outside her home. <br>Canonised scriptural texts explicitly brand a woman as a “fornicator” (<em>Zina زنى</em>) simply for wearing perfume: <em>“</em><a href="https://www.instagram.com/reels/DWZbNxBj0Q3/"><strong><em>Any woman who puts on perfume and passes by people so that they can smell her fragrance is a fornicator</em></strong></a><em>”</em> (Musnad Ahmad 19578, Sunan an-Nasa’i 5126).</li><li><strong>The Prohibition of Heels, Colours, and Strides:</strong> Clerics mandate strict bans on high-heeled shoes and vivid colours, deriving prohibitions from scriptural decrees against revealing hidden adornments through footsteps: <em>“And let them not strike their feet to make known what they conceal of their adornment”</em> (Surah An-Nur 24:31), transforming her physical presence and gait into a potential moral violation.</li><li><strong>The Erasure of the Female Voice:</strong> In extensive legal traditions, a woman’s voice itself is classified as <em>‘Awrah عورة</em> — an inherent source of temptation — restricting her ability to speak publicly, recite, or articulate her thoughts in the public sphere without divine censure.</li><li><strong>Restricted Mobility (Travel without a Male Guardian):</strong> A woman is legally prohibited from travelling or navigating distances independently without an escorting male relative (<em>Mahram مُحرم</em>): <em>“A woman shall not travel except with a Mahram”</em> (Sahih al-Bukhari 1862). This restriction treats an adult woman as a legal minor incapable of self-determination.</li></ul><h3>7. Manufacturing the “Pious Woman”</h3><p>The moral archetype of the ideal woman in traditional discourse is constructed exclusively around metrics of subservience: obedient, veiled, non-confrontational, quiet, sexually compliant, and economically and emotionally dependent.</p><p>The system poses a quiet question: Why are a woman’s ethics defined primarily through her <strong>obedience and compliance</strong>, whereas a man’s ethics are measured by his <strong>actions, achievements, and strength</strong>? Reducing female moral integrity to simple non-resistance and obedience is the ultimate mechanism to prevent her from demanding human agency.</p><h3>8. The Language of Shame and Psychological Subjugation: Omens, Deficiencies, and Devils</h3><p>When the erasure of agency is legalised, it is packaged in psychological and scriptural terms that instil a sense of inherent inferiority:</p><ul><li><strong>Branded as Deficient and Impure:</strong> Authentic canonical texts describe women as <em>“deficient in intelligence and religion”</em> (Sahih al-Bukhari 304), asserting that they constitute the <em>“majority of the inhabitants of Hell”</em>. Furthermore, a man’s ritual prayer is severed if a woman passes in front of him, grouped alongside a donkey and a black dog: <em>“The prayer is severed by a woman, a donkey, and a black dog”</em> (Sahih Muslim 510)!</li><li><strong>Women as Bad Omens and Devils:</strong> Scriptural traditions decree that bad omens reside in three things: <em>“Bad luck is in three: the horse, the woman, and the house”</em> (Sahih al-Bukhari 2858, Sahih Muslim 2225), asserting that her presence carries demonic temptation: <em>“A woman approaches in the shape of a devil and departs in the shape of a devil”</em> (Sahih Muslim 1403).</li><li><strong>The Honor Complex and Fragile Masculinity:</strong> Ethics and dignity are reduced entirely to a woman’s body and sexual conduct. A man’s honour is not anchored in his integrity, honesty, or societal contributions, but depends completely on governing the body and sexual behaviour of his sister, wife, or daughter.</li></ul><h3>9. The Female Body Before Criminal Law</h3><p>Religious texts do not generate every social behaviour automatically; rather, <strong>they provide social structures with legitimate language, legal frameworks, and moral concepts that sustain and justify them</strong>.</p><p>In conservative societies, a woman is not viewed as a person who owns her body, but as a public legal and moral space: the family monitors it, the husband claims it, society judges it, the state legislates for it, and religion dictates its visibility.</p><p>This framework directly legitimises “<a href="https://medium.com/@rami_zahra/when-will-we-stop-using-the-term-honour-to-justify-the-murder-of-women-886fb3a1c17a"><strong>Honour Killings</strong></a>” and provides male perpetrators with judicial leniency and reduced sentences in penal codes (such as Article 237 of the Egyptian Penal Code and Article 340 of the Jordanian Penal Code) if a man murders his wife or sister over alleged adultery, while denying women the same defense. It is a clear reality where a woman’s body is treated legally as a “potential crime” and her blood as inherently cheaper.</p><h3>10. Women Who Reject the Sacred: The True Test of Freedom</h3><p>Many in traditional societies accept a conditional “freedom” for women: provided she remains veiled, married, observant, uncritical of religion, and compliant with family structures.</p><p>However, the true test of liberty occurs when a woman declares: <strong>I do not want the Hijab, I do not want marriage, I do not want children, I want a divorce, I want complete independence, or I want to live my life according to my own values!</strong></p><p>At this moment, the mask of “honour” falls away. Departure from this system is met not with respect, but with a campaign of social terror: accusations of apostasy and shame, digital harassment, ostracisation, and in many conservative environments, the cost of departure can be exile, violence, or murder.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2F4VUZUCBYpoo%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3D4VUZUCBYpoo&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2F4VUZUCBYpoo%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/a6b297687095a8d0231c8788c842e736/href">https://medium.com/media/a6b297687095a8d0231c8788c842e736/href</a></iframe><h3>11. “Islamic Feminism” and the Manipulation of Language</h3><p>While women in the East fight perilous battles for liberation, a linguistic and intellectual farce has emerged in Western capitals under the label <strong>“Islamic Feminism”</strong>.</p><p>The core issue here is not to deny that religious women can hold feminist views; rather, the fundamental question is: <strong>Why is “Islam” presented as a necessary and distinct framework to define an independent category of feminism, while terms like “Christian Feminism”, “Orthodox Jewish Feminism”, or “Buddhist Feminism” are not routinely used as parallel global ideological projects?</strong></p><p>The problem starts with the name itself. <br>Why do we need “Islamic Feminism”? Does “Islamic Democracy” exist as an independent religious alternative to democracy? “Islamic Human Rights” as an alternative system? Or “Islamic Freedom” as a separate definition of liberty?</p><p>What is occurring here is an ongoing appropriation to rename the products of political and intellectual modernity after subjecting them to religious authority: <strong>The system was not democratised; rather, democracy was Islamised. Jurisprudence was not liberated; rather, the language of liberation was rewritten to serve it. Women are no longer asking for rights outside the system; instead, they are required first to prove that their rights do not conflict with it!</strong></p><p>In this sense, “Islamic Feminism” is not a natural extension of global feminism, but a project to redefine feminism so that it never exceeds the boundaries set by medieval jurisprudence and tradition. It does not ask: <em>“What do women want?”</em>; instead, it asks: <em>“What can women want without conflicting with the system?”</em></p><p>The issue is transforming a religious symbol born within a patriarchal structure into a universal benchmark of empowerment, and then demanding that Western societies protect this symbol from criticism. If the Hijab is truly a “personal choice” and an “autonomous decision free from male guardianship”, we pose this challenge to any woman defending it:</p><blockquote><strong><em>Can you remove your Hijab for just one single minute in a public space, walk freely before your family and community, and then put it back on purely by choice — without facing psychological terror, accusations of apostasy, social ostracisation, or threats of violence?</em></strong></blockquote><p>The undeniable answer is: <strong>No, you cannot!</strong></p><p>Therefore, it is not a free choice; it is the product of accumulated social and religious coercion. <br>Framing it as “freedom” is nothing more than repackaging bondage. The exact same logic applies to the “<a href="https://medium.com/@rami_zahra/banning-handshakes-between-genders-a-primitive-behaviour-and-an-intellectual-stigma-in-a-civilised-dfb86cef5308?sharedUserId=rami_zahra"><strong>refusal to shake hands</strong></a>”; where refraining from a polite greeting is marketed as “purity”, while in reality it sends a deeply insulting message treating the other person as an uncontrolled animal incapable of governing his desires upon a simple human gesture.</p><h3>12. The Betrayal of the Regressive Left</h3><p>In this ongoing tragedy, the <strong>Western Progressive Left</strong> bears a profound historical and moral culpability.</p><p>For short-term electoral gains and under the banner of “multiculturalism”, the Western left has forged an unholy alliance with conservative Islamist organisations across enclaves in European cities. They have abandoned vulnerable reformists, secularists, and ex-Muslim women, surrendering immigrant communities to self-appointed Sharia councils and community patriarchs!</p><p>The Western left exhibits the most grotesque double standard imaginable: they fiercely combat domestic patriarchy and male privilege when practiced by Western men, yet eagerly defend and celebrate the exact same patriarchal abuses when practiced by Eastern men under the guise of “protecting cultural identity”! It is a patronising attitude that quietly assumes Eastern women do not deserve the same universal human rights, bodily autonomy, and freedom enjoyed by Western women.</p><h3>The Fallacy of Apologetics: Sentimental Motherhood and the Eroticised Paradise</h3><p>Whenever the apologetic machine faces the unyielding legalism of traditional jurisprudence, it routinely retreats behind two cosmetic diversions engineered for gullible Western consumption: <strong>the facade of financial autonomy</strong>, and <strong>the sentimental weaponisation of motherhood</strong>.</p><p>Apologists triumphantly repeat the superficial trope: <em>“A woman’s wealth is entirely her own, while her husband’s income belongs to the household.”</em> Yet, classical jurisprudence strips away this romantic illusion: the second a wife declines sexual access or dares to step outside her home without her husband’s prior sanction, her financial maintenance (<em>Nafaqah</em>) is instantly extinguished under the charge of <em>Nushuz</em> (rebellion). In the raw, transactional taxonomy of Islamic law, maintenance is neither a gift of honour nor an egalitarian partnership; <strong>it is the contractual rent paid for physical confinement and absolute sexual availability</strong>. It is not economic empowerment; it is the price tag of domestic captivity.</p><p>When theological arguments hit a dead end, apologists stage their final moral retreat by exploiting maternal emotion, parroting the ubiquitous slogan: <em>“Paradise lies beneath the feet of mothers.”</em> This phrase is neither a Quranic verse nor an authentic Hadith; it is a fabricated cultural platitude falsely elevated to sacred dogma (categorically dismissed as baseless by classical Hadith authorities such as Al-Uqayli and Ibn Adi). Even if one humours this pious fiction, the logic immediately disintegrates:</p><ul><li><strong>Did theology discover maternal reverence?</strong> The veneration of mothers is a primal human instinct, enshrined in civic laws, ancient literature, and moral philosophy thousands of years before scriptural monotheism emerged. Were the mothers of human civilisation despised and subhuman until a 7th-century desert text arrived to teach humanity how to love them?</li><li><strong>More critically: What kind of “Paradise” lies beneath these feet?</strong> Is it the very afterlife designed as a crude, male-centric erotic playground, where female entities exist purely as sexual quarry? In decoding the canonical verse — <em>“Indeed, the companions of Paradise that Day will be amused in joyful occupation”</em> (Surah Ya-Sin 36:55) — the premier commentators and companions of Muhammad, led by Abdullah ibn Abbas (“The Scholar of the Nation”) and Abdullah ibn Mas’ud (“The Jurist of the Nation”), stated without ambiguity that this celestial “occupation” is: <strong>“The deflowering of virgin maidens”</strong> (<em>Iftidad al-Abkar</em>, Tafsir al-Tabari 20/531, Tafsir Ibn Kathir 6/580).</li></ul><p>What grotesque moral logic commands an earthly woman to kneel before a theological system that promises men an eternity of voracious sexual indulgence with genetically manufactured, eternally deflowered virgins (<em>Houri</em>), whilst reducing her own earthly worth to that of an unpaid domestic servant or an incubator?</p><h3>The Glaring Paradox: Dignity Conditional Upon the Womb</h3><p>The most damning indictment of this apologetic rhetoric lies in the question it desperately seeks to evade: <strong>If a woman’s claim to dignity is entirely contingent upon becoming a “mother”, what becomes of the woman who bears no children, who consciously rejects motherhood, the infertile, or the single woman? Does her human value evaporate the moment she has no womb to offer?</strong></p><p>Restricting honour to “motherhood” is not an affirmation of the female as an autonomous human being; it is the commodification of a biological function. The moment a woman is stripped of her status as an active incubator, she instantly reverts within this theological framework to what she was always codified to be: an inherently deficient minor, an object of sexual gratification, and a public contagion (<em>‘Awrah</em>) whose very presence must be erased from view.</p><h3>Conclusion: Human Dignity Above Sacred Dogma</h3><p>It is time to call things by their true names.</p><p>Human rights are not relative; human dignity cannot be compartmentalised. Any religious or legal framework that treats a woman as half a human being, strips her of human agency over her body and choices, and defines societal honour through the control of her body and behaviour, is a system that must be ruthlessly exposed and dismantled without fear or reverence for the “sacred”.</p><p>True liberation will not come from apologetics or reformist patching that attempts to make ancient chains feel comfortable; liberation begins when society finds the courage to demolish the sanctity of dogmas and elevate universal human agency and individual liberty. <br><strong>An individual who lacks the right to question the text governing their life, reject the custom demanding their submission, or own their body and decisions, does not live freely — regardless of the name given to their chains. <br>A chain does not become freedom because a cleric redefined it, nor does guardianship become honour because a woman was asked to thank the person exercising it over her.</strong></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=63e08519ac58" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Anatomy of Dhimmitude: Demystifying Modern Apologetics Surrounding Jizyah]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@rami_zahra/the-anatomy-of-dhimmitude-demystifying-modern-apologetics-surrounding-jizyah-7ca87d6fcc6c?source=rss-5d95452aa4e4------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/7ca87d6fcc6c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[dhimmi]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[jihad]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[supremacy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[jizyah]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[islam]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Rami Zahra]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 03 Jul 2026 01:26:22 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-07-08T22:54:05.472Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>The Architecture of Supremacy: Dissecting the systemic implementation of Jizyah as a mechanism of socio-political containment.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*qasDWOtG3PfeKBOp3y1viA.jpeg" /></figure><p>In the year 2026, the discussion regarding <em>Dhimmitude</em> (الذمة) is often relegated to the dusty shelves of medieval history. Yet, to treat it as a relic is to fundamentally misunderstand the architecture of contemporary political Islam. The persistent attempts to repackage, sanitize, and modernize the classical legal concepts of <em>Jizyah</em> (الجزية) are not merely academic exercises; they are calculated maneuvers. We are not witnessing the emergence of genuine historical revisionism, but rather a sophisticated, and at times brazen, project of apologetic maintenance.</p><p>Modern discourse, both from within certain theological circles and its echoes in Western academic spheres, routinely employs a strategy of systematic distortion. They describe <em>Jizyah</em> (الجزية) as a “benign civil tax,” a “voluntary contribution,” or a “pre-modern iteration of citizenship.” This is not an honest engagement with the texts of the architects of this system; it is <em>Taqiyya</em> (التقية) in its most potent, modern iteration. It is the art of misrepresenting the core tenets of an imperial system to make it palatable to the modern rule of law, while leaving the underlying mechanics of supremacy untouched in the original manuals.</p><p>This study does not aim to offer a Western critique of an Eastern system. It is, instead, an interrogation of the legacy texts themselves. It is a forensic examination of the classical lexicons, the authoritative <em>Tafsir</em> (تفسير), the exhaustive <em>Fiqh</em> (فقه) manuals, and the imperial registers of the Umayyad, Abbasid, and Ottoman eras. These sources do not speak of “equality” or “citizenship.” They speak of <em>Saghar</em> (صغار) — the institutionalized humiliation of the subjugated — as a permanent feature of a hierarchy designed to govern the non-Muslim population.</p><p>The hazard of the prevailing revisionist narrative lies in its disregard for the internal mechanics of classical jurisprudence. The <em>Jizyah</em> (الجزية) was never an isolated fiscal measure. It was the institutional anchor of a comprehensive framework of social and political dominance. It governed the lives of millions — including the indigenous Christian and Jewish communities whose rich cultural heritages were gradually dismantled by these very structures. To understand why this debate remains so volatile today, one must confront the reality that the framework of <em>Dhimmitude</em> was not a historical anomaly; it was a codified, deliberate policy of containment.</p><p>The question is no longer whether <em>Jizyah</em> (الجزية) existed, but why its memory is being so aggressively managed. By stripping away the layers of modern misrepresentation, this analysis seeks to uncover the structural reality of the system as it was codified by its architects and experienced by its subjects for centuries. We are not rewriting the past; we are demanding that the past be read without the distorting lens of modern “apologetic” convenience.</p><h3>Chapter I: The Verdict of Classical Lexicons</h3><p>The Apologetic Claim: “<em>Jizyah</em> (الجزية) is a citizenship tax, and subjugation (<em>Saghar</em>) merely implies compliance with the public order.”</p><p>To evaluate this assertion, one must return to the precise linguistic foundations of the Arabic language in which the Quranic text was delivered. Classical Arabic lexicons leave little room for semantic maneuvering regarding the vocabulary governing the <em>Dhimmi</em> contract.</p><ul><li><strong>Jizyah (الجزية):</strong> Ibn Manzur notes in <em>Lisan al-Arab</em> that <em>Jizyah</em> (الجزية) derives from the root <em>J-Z-Y</em> (ج — ز — ى) [1], functioning as a financial expiation for remaining in a state of disbelief. Linguistically, it does not represent a communal contribution to the state, but rather a financial consideration paid to secure the preservation of life while retaining a non-Islamic faith.</li><li><strong>Saghar (صغار):</strong> In <em>Taj al-Arus</em>, <em>Saghar</em> is defined as absolute lowliness, humiliation, and subjugation [2]. Similarly, both Al-Khalil in <em>Kitab al-Ayn</em> and Al-Raghib al-Isfahani in <em>Mufradat</em> establish that the term denotes an explicit acceptance of an inferior social status [2, 4]. Linguistically, a <em>Saghir</em> is not a citizen complying with the law, but an individual deliberately assigned a degraded social standing.</li><li><strong>An Yadin (عن يد):</strong> Classical philology demonstrates that this phrase indicates a direct, manual delivery of the tax, signifying submission and an acknowledgment of the recipient’s supremacy [3]. It implies that the tax must be paid in person, without proxy, reinforcing the payer’s vulnerable position before the collector.</li></ul><p><strong>The Historical Reality Check:</strong> <br>The apologetic narrative often attempts to divorce the linguistic roots of <em>Jizyah</em> (الجزية) from its geopolitical application. However, history provides the ultimate commentary on these terms. The early American experience with the Barbary States — where the young United States was compelled to pay what was effectively a <em>Jizyah</em> (الجزية) to North African regencies — strips away the mask of “civilized tax.” The diplomatic correspondence of the era confirms that this was not a reciprocal contract of citizenship, but a demand for tribute under threat of violence. The American envoy’s own accounts reveal the arrogance of the collectors, who demanded payment not as partners in a civilized state, but as masters dealing with a vulnerable, inferior entity. This incident serves as a historical bridge, proving that the terminology used in classical manuals was not metaphorical; it described a real, tangible power dynamic where the payer was, by definition, the <em>Saghir</em> (صغير) — the subjugated.</p><ul><li><strong>Dhimmah (ذمة):</strong> While the term denotes a covenant or safeguard, its linguistic application in classical manuals remains tied to a conditional guarantee [4]. The protection terminates upon any breach of the financial or behavioral obligations imposed, reverting the relationship to its baseline: combat.</li></ul><h3>Chapter II: Was Subjugation Merely Respect for the Law?</h3><p>The Apologetic Claim: “Interpreting the Quranic text as an endorsement of humiliation is a subjective view popularized by Ibn Kathir, and it reflects a specific historical context, not a universal doctrine.”</p><p>Moving from philology to exegesis (<em>Tafsir</em>), one finds that the most authoritative classical commentators — representing diverse historical eras and jurisprudential schools — demonstrate a striking, chilling consistency regarding the practical meaning of Surah At-Tawbah (9:29). They do not treat <em>Saghar</em> (صغار) as a social nicety or a misunderstood term; they treat it as an institutional imperative.</p><ul><li><strong>Imam al-Tabari (d. 310 AH):</strong> In his monumental <em>Jami al-Bayan</em>, Al-Tabari interprets the command to fight the People of the Book as a permanent mandate. He explicitly states that warfare must persist until they pay the <em>Jizyah</em> (الجزية) while they are “humbled and subdued” (صاغرون). For Al-Tabari, the payment is not merely a fiscal act; it is the manifestation of defeat [5]. It is the visible sign that the Islamic state has successfully asserted its political and religious sovereignty over the recipient.</li><li><strong>Imam al-Qurtubi (d. 671 AH):</strong> In <em>Al-Jami li-Ahkam al-Quran</em>, the analysis moves from the theological to the bureaucratic. Al-Qurtubi details the institutional protocols of collection with a level of precision that renders modern claims of “equality” absurd. He explains that the <em>Dhimmi</em> (ذمي) must approach the collector on foot, not mounted. The collector remains seated, while the <em>Dhimmi</em> (ذمي) stands in a state of visible deference [6]. This was a choreographed ritual of power, explicitly designed to deny the taxpayer any semblance of social parity or prestige. Al-Qurtubi’s interpretation reminds us that the state did not just want the money; it wanted the psychological submission that accompanied the handover.</li><li><strong>Hafiz Ibn Kathir (d. 774 AH):</strong> Modern revisionists often blame Ibn Kathir for “inventing” the harshness of the <em>Jizyah</em> (الجزية) interpretation. Yet, a reading of <em>Tafsir al-Quran al-Azim</em> reveals that he is merely the synthesizer of an established consensus [7]. He notes clearly that those under this covenant are not to be honored, nor elevated above the believers, but must remain in an inferior socio-political status that reflects their submission. His commentary is not a departure from his predecessors; it is a restatement of a codified legislative standard.</li></ul><p><strong>The Critique of Modern Revisionism:</strong> <br>The effort to frame <em>Saghar</em> (صغار) as a “respect for public order” is a contemporary invention that collapses under the weight of these primary sources. These commentators did not speak of “citizenship” or “taxation in exchange for military exemption.” They spoke of <em>Dhimmitude</em> (الذمة) as a system of religious and political containment. To claim that these interpretations are “subjective” is to ignore the rigorous, centuries-long consensus that defined the relationship between the Islamic state and the non-Muslim population as one of defined hierarchy.</p><p>The historical and methodological continuity across these centuries demonstrates that <em>Saghar</em> (صغار) was not a marginal or novel interpretation; it was the legislative heartbeat of the imperial expansion.</p><h3>Chapter III: In the Crucible of Tradition (Texts of Confrontation)</h3><p>There is no need for deduction when jurists and historical architects speak with explicit, clinical clarity. The apologetic discourse often attempts to shroud the reality of the <em>Jizyah</em> (الجزية) in the language of “mutual social contract.” However, when we open the practical manuals of jurisprudence (<em>Fiqh</em> فقه), we find a different reality: a structured, cold, and deliberate mechanism of subordination.</p><ul><li><strong>The Hanafi Perspective:</strong> Imam Al-Kasani, in his seminal work <em>Bada’i al-Sana’i</em>, offers perhaps the most damning refutation of the “tax for protection” myth. He defines the rationale behind the <em>Jizyah</em> (الجزية) with legalistic precision: “Because the <em>Jizyah</em> (الجزية) is a penalty for his disbelief… and whoever pays it while humbled (<em>Saghar</em>) has paid his punishment” [8]. Here, the mask of the “civic tax” falls completely. Al-Kasani identifies the tax as a <em>Jaza’</em> (جزاء) — a penalty or recompense — for the act of remaining outside the fold of Islam. It is not an economic transaction; it is a punitive measure designed to make the status of the non-Muslim uncomfortable, thereby encouraging conversion to escape the financial and psychological weight of the levy.</li><li><strong>The Logic of Utility (The Amr ibn al-As Doctrine):</strong> Historical accounts of the early conquests often bypass the harshness of the administrative directives. The instruction of Amr ibn al-As to the newly conquered populations of Egypt — recorded in <em>Futuh Misr</em> — is stark: “You are nothing but <em>Kharaj</em> (tribute) to us” [17]. This is not the language of a governor speaking to citizens; it is the language of a master defining the utility of an asset. The subjugated population was viewed as an “economic resource,” a permanent engine of wealth extraction that was to be maintained in a state of productive weakness.</li><li><strong>The Constitution of Humiliation:</strong> The <em>Pact of Umar</em> (<em>Al-Shurut al-Umariyya</em>) remains the most complete legislative blueprint for <em>Dhimmitude</em> (الذمة). As preserved in Ibn Qayyim al-Jawziyya’s <em>Ahkam Ahl al-Dhimmah</em>, these regulations were far more than security protocols; they were measures of demographic and spiritual containment [13]. The mandates — prohibiting the construction of new churches, barring the restoration of existing ones, and enforcing humiliating dress codes — were intended to prevent the non-Muslim community from ever achieving a sense of social or spiritual permanence.</li></ul><p><strong>The Price of Silence vs. The Price of Protection:</strong> The modern assertion that <em>Jizyah</em> (الجزية) was a “price of protection” from external military threats is historically inverted. The legislative reality proves that the <em>Jizyah</em> (الجزية) was, in effect, the “price of silence.” It was a fee paid to purchase the temporary forbearance of the state. If the payment yielded civic equality, as modern apologists claim, one would expect the records to show a steady rise in the social standing of the <em>Dhimmi</em> (ذمي) commensurate with their financial contributions. Instead, we see the opposite: the more the system was enforced, the more marginalized the non-Muslim populations became, until they were eventually absorbed or assimilated through the persistent, systematic weight of the <em>Saghar</em> (صغار).</p><p>This was not a social contract; it was a state-sponsored paradigm of religious and political exclusion, meticulously maintained by the jurists and enforced by the provincial governors.</p><h3>Chapter IV: The Dialectic of Taqiyya and Beautifying Reality</h3><p>Contemporary apologetic literature utilizes <em>Taqiyya</em> (التقية) as a fundamental tool of strategic communication. When contemporary clergy, intellectual gatekeepers, and state-sponsored academics appear on international platforms to declare that <em>Jizyah</em> (الجزية) was merely a “standard protection tax,” they are not engaging in historical inquiry; they are practicing overt, structured <em>Taqiyya</em> (التقية).</p><p>They operate on a dual-track strategy: a “public-facing” discourse tailored for the sensibilities of the modern Western world, and an “internal-facing” adherence to the rigid, exclusionary frameworks codified in the manuals of the four Sunni schools of jurisprudence.</p><ul><li><strong>The Anatomy of the Deception:</strong> The modern apologetic claim relies on a complete historical erasure. By stripping the <em>Jizyah</em> (الجزية) of its inherent connection to <em>Saghar</em> (صغار), they transform a mechanism of humiliation into a benign fiscal policy. When a modern defender of this legacy claims, “We protected the non-Muslims in exchange for this tax,” they intentionally omit the legislative reality: that this “protection” was conditional upon a state of permanent civic paralysis. They are aware that the rulings of the Hanafi, Shafi’i, Maliki, and Hanbali schools — which mandate specific physical and social protocols to reinforce the hierarchy — remain alive and un-abrogated in the libraries of their own institutions [8, 9, 10, 11, 12].</li><li><strong>The Contradiction as Strategy:</strong> This contradiction between what is preached to the West and what is preserved in the <em>Fiqh</em> (فقه) books is not a mistake; it is the essence of strategic deception. By defining the <em>Jizyah</em> (الجزية) as “citizenship tax” (a concept alien to the classical <em>Dhimma</em> contract), they attempt to retrospectively inject modern egalitarian values into an ancient system of conquest. This is a form of intellectual gaslighting. They are asking the world to believe that the jurists of the third and fourth centuries AH were, in fact, proto-liberal social reformers, even though those same jurists meticulously detailed the “humiliation” required to keep the <em>Dhimmi</em>(ذمي) population in its proper, subservient place.</li><li><strong>The Silence of the Ulema:</strong> Perhaps the most telling indicator of this <em>Taqiyya</em> (التقية) is the silence of the established religious authorities on the <em>Shurut al-Umariyya</em> (الشروط العمرية). While they are quick to defend the “tolerance” of the Islamic state in media interviews, one rarely hears a high-ranking cleric declare the <em>Pact of Umar</em> as obsolete or contrary to universal human dignity. They prefer to let these texts reside in a “grey zone” — denied when criticized by the West, yet revered as part of the immutable, “sacred” legacy when debated internally.</li></ul><p><strong>The Strategic Consequence:</strong> This revisionist smoothing has a clear, long-term political goal: to shield the classical Islamic political framework from legitimate scrutiny. By modernizing the nomenclature of the <em>Jizyah</em> (الجزية), they prevent the modern reader from asking the most dangerous question of all: <em>If the system was so benign, why was it built upon such rigid, asymmetric, and humiliating foundations?</em></p><p>The revisionists are not merely protecting the reputation of the past; they are protecting the possibility of a political future where such structures can be revisited. This is why the deconstruction of this narrative is not an academic luxury; it is a political necessity for any society that claims to be founded upon the principle of absolute, universal citizenship.</p><h3>Chapter V: The Illusion of Jurisprudential Evolution</h3><p>The apologetic narrative often attempts to paint the abolition of <em>Jizyah</em> (الجزية) as the crowning achievement of an internal, enlightened evolution of Islamic jurisprudence. We are told, with a flourish of academic arrogance, that as the “Islamic spirit” matured and encountered the modern era, the scholars — in their infinite wisdom — realized that <em>Jizyah</em>(الجزية) was an archaic burden that had outlived its purpose. This is a fairy tale for the gullible.</p><p>The historical record tells a far more brutal, yet pragmatic story: the cessation of the <em>Jizyah</em> (الجزية) did not come as a result of intellectual awakening, nor a change of heart in the seminaries of the <em>Ulema</em>. It was the direct, involuntary result of the collapse of military power and the desperate need to survive in an international system that no longer tolerated the archaic logic of conquest.</p><ul><li><strong>The Myth of Enlightened Reform:</strong> If we search the annals of nineteenth-century Islamic thought for a <em>Fatwa</em>declaring the <em>Jizyah</em> (الجزية) “un-Islamic” or “unsuited for human dignity,” we find nothing but silence. The scholars of the time were not debating the morality of the tax; they were debating how to maintain the hegemony of the state while the geopolitical floor was collapsing beneath them.</li><li><strong>Abolition Under Duress (The 1856 Imperial Rescript):</strong> The <em>Hatt-ı Hümayun</em> of 1856 is frequently cited by modern apologists as the moment the Ottoman Empire “voluntarily” embraced equality. The truth is far darker. The decree was not a gift from the Sublime Porte to its subjects; it was a ransom paid to the Great Powers — Britain, France, and Austria — to secure their military intervention against the Russian threat during the Crimean War. The Ottoman state was forced to dismantle the traditional framework of <em>Dhimmitude</em> (الذمة) precisely because it could no longer afford the political cost of maintaining an exclusionary system while begging for Western protection. It was a pragmatic concession enacted by a panicked government to prevent absolute geopolitical collapse.</li><li><strong>The Absence of a Theological Pivot:</strong> It is critical to note that the termination of the <em>Jizyah</em> (الجزية) never involved a re-reading of Surah At-Tawbah (9:29). There was no “Reformation.” The tax simply became unenforceable as the coercive apparatus of the state withered. The state did not renounce the <em>Jizyah</em> (الجزية) because it suddenly discovered universal human rights; it abandoned it because the cost of enforcement — in the face of European diplomatic pressure and internal military decline — finally outweighed the revenue it provided.</li></ul><p><strong>The Historical Verdict:</strong> This is the inconvenient truth that revisionists cannot afford to admit: the system did not die because it was judged morally wrong by the believers; it died because it was made obsolete by the reality of military and economic weakness. To credit “theological evolution” for this change is to insult history. The <em>Jizyah</em> (الجزية) was not reformed out of existence by the <em>Ulema</em>; it was coerced out of existence by the reality of power.</p><p>This proves that the system was never truly a “theological ideal” that changed over time; it was a mechanism of statecraft that functioned only as long as the state possessed the power to make its subjects feel the <em>Saghar</em> (صغار). When that power vanished, the system didn’t evolve — it simply disintegrated.</p><h3>Chapter VI: Conclusion — The Modern Dilemma of Revisionism</h3><p>The ongoing effort within apologetic discourse to modernize, sanitize, and reinterpret the institution of <em>Jizyah</em> (الجزية) faces an insurmountable friction: the relentless clarity of the classical text and the unforgiving record of history. Across lexicons, exegeses, juristic manuals, and imperial registers, the evidence stands as a monolith. The <em>Jizyah</em> (الجزية) was never a neutral economic instrument, nor a byproduct of a rudimentary administrative system. It was, from its inception, a deliberate mechanism of socio-political containment, explicitly structured to maintain a permanent hierarchy between the dominant faith and its tolerated subjects.</p><p><strong>The Failure of “Sanitized” Pluralism:</strong> A coherent modern critique cannot be achieved by rewriting the past or by projecting modern egalitarian values onto ancient imperial structures. The classical <em>Dhimmi</em> (ذمي) system was a product of its era — a framework constructed by expansionist empires operating on the logic of conquest, religious supremacy, and asymmetric legal authority. To pretend that this system was “inclusive” is not just a historical error; it is an act of intellectual bad faith.</p><p>The central dilemma of our time is that the intellectual descendants of these systems are attempting to integrate them into a modern global order that is predicated on the exact opposite of <em>Dhimmitude</em> (الذمة): the principle of absolute, universal citizenship. One cannot simultaneously claim to be a proponent of modern human rights while holding the classical framework of religious subjugation as a “divinely inspired” historical ideal. This is the structural tension that keeps the debate alive and volatile.</p><p><strong>The Question of Sovereignty:</strong> Ultimately, this is a question of sovereignty. The <em>Dhimmitude</em> (الذمة) system was built on the premise that political legitimacy belongs solely to the dominant faith. Any modern state that adopts this logic — or even attempts to integrate it into its legislative discourse — must inevitably reject the concept of the modern nation-state, which treats all citizens as equal before the law, regardless of their conscience or creed.</p><p>The classical <em>Dhimmi</em> (ذمي) system did not “evolve” into modern citizenship; it collapsed under the weight of its own contradiction. The modern societies we aspire to build require a clean break from such frameworks. True pluralism cannot coexist with the institutionalized <em>Saghar</em> (صغار) of the past.</p><p><strong>The Path Forward:</strong> The resilience of these ideas in the contemporary discourse is a reminder that the past is never truly buried as long as we refuse to confront its mechanics. If we are to understand the challenges of our present, we must stop “smoothing” the history of our predecessors and start looking at it with the cold, clear eyes of the researcher. We must recognize that the classical paradigms of conditional toleration — while historically significant — are fundamentally incompatible with the concept of an equal, free, and dignified society.</p><p>The future does not belong to those who can best disguise the past, but to those who have the courage to acknowledge that the age of <em>Dhimmitude</em> (الذمة) was an age of containment, and that the age of universal equality is an entirely different, and far more demanding, project.</p><blockquote><strong>References and Endnotes</strong></blockquote><blockquote>[1] Ibn Manzur, <em>Lisan al-Arab</em>, Vol. 14, Dar Sadir edition, root (J-Z-Y), p. 142.</blockquote><blockquote>[2] Al-Zabidi, <em>Taj al-Arus min Jawahir al-Qamus</em>, Vol. 12, Dar al-Hidayah edition, root (S-Gh-R), pp. 288–290.</blockquote><blockquote>[3] Ibn Faris, <em>Ma’jam Maqayis al-Lughah</em>, Vol. 6, Dar al-Jil edition, root (Y-D), p. 154.</blockquote><blockquote>[4] Al-Raghib al-Isfahani, <em>Mufradat Alfadh al-Quran</em>, Vol. 1, Dar al-Qalam edition, root (Dh-M-M), p. 331; Al-Khalil bin Ahmad, <em>Kitab al-Ayn</em>, Vol. 4, Dar al-Hilal edition, root (S-Gh-R), p. 381.</blockquote><blockquote>[5] Al-Tabari, <em>Jami al-Bayan an Ta’wil Ay al-Quran</em>, Vol. 14, Dar Hajar edition, commentary on Surah At-Tawbah (9:29), pp. 208–212.</blockquote><blockquote>[6] Al-Qurtubi, <em>Al-Jami li-Ahkam al-Quran</em>, Vol. 8, Dar al-Fikr edition, commentary on Surah At-Tawbah (9:29), pp. 114–117.</blockquote><blockquote>[7] Ibn Kathir, <em>Tafsir al-Quran al-Azim</em>, Vol. 4, Dar Taybah edition, p. 115.</blockquote><blockquote>[8] Al-Kasani, <em>Bada’i al-Sana’i fi Tartib al-Sharai’</em>, Vol. 7, Dar al-Kutub al-Ilmiyyah edition, Book of Siyar, Chapter on Jizyah, p. 115.</blockquote><blockquote>[9] Ibn Rushd (the Elder), <em>Al-Muqaddimat al-Mumahhadat</em>, Vol. 1, Dar al-Gharb al-Islami edition, Book of Jihad, Rulings of the Dhimmah Contract, pp. 384–386.</blockquote><blockquote>[10] Al-Nawawi, <em>Minhaj al-Talibin wa Umdat al-Muftin</em>, Vol. 1, Dar al-Kutub al-Ilmiyyah edition, Book of Siyar, Section on Rulings of Dhimmah, pp. 312–315.</blockquote><blockquote>[11] Al-Shirbini al-Khatib, <em>Mughni al-Muhtaj ila Ma’rifat Ma’ani Alfadh al-Minhaj</em>, Vol. 4, Dar al-Ma’rifah edition, Book of Siyar, Section on Jizyah, pp. 248–251.</blockquote><blockquote>[12] Ibn Qudamah, <em>Al-Mughni</em>, Vol. 9, Dar Alam al-Kutub edition, Book of Siyar, Chapter on the Dhimmah Contract and Subjugation, pp. 280–284.</blockquote><blockquote>[13] Ibn Qayyim al-Jawziyya, <em>Ahkam Ahl al-Dhimmah</em>, Vol. 1, Ramadi for Publishing edition (1997), Chapter on the Pact of Umar and Rulings of Churches, pp. 165–178.</blockquote><blockquote>[17] Ibn Abd al-Hakam, <em>Futuh Misr wa Akhbaruha</em>, Vol. 1, Dar al-Fikr edition, Accounts of Egyptian Taxes and Letters of Umar bin Abd al-Aziz, pp. 156–160.</blockquote><blockquote>[21] Ottoman State Archives, <em>Hatt-ı Hümayun Registers (Hatt-ı Hümayun Tasnifi)</em>, Prime Ministry Ottoman Archives (Istanbul), Imperial Rescript Decrees of 1856 and the Ottoman Tanzimat Reforms, Register №12, Document 45.</blockquote><blockquote>[26] Ottoman State Archives, <em>Hatt-ı Hümayun Registers</em>, Document 12/45 (1856).</blockquote><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=7ca87d6fcc6c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Borrowed Indulgences: Why Do We Hide on Jeffrey Epstein’s Island?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@rami_zahra/borrowed-indulgences-why-do-we-hide-on-jeffrey-epsteins-island-a7b8b2dbac85?source=rss-5d95452aa4e4------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a7b8b2dbac85</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[culture]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[religion]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[human-rights]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[middle-east]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[jeffrey-epstein]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Rami Zahra]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 01 Jul 2026 23:53:29 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-07-01T23:53:29.937Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>The law is an accomplice, the pulpit is a shield. We are not facing an isolated island; we are drowning in an ocean of legalised.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*9aibrDKsdHKjLcw-AGAJUw.jpeg" /></figure><p>Every time a dungeon is opened in our midst, a young girl violated under the guise of ‘discretion’, or a woman dragged through the dirt in the name of ‘honour’, our collective psyche triggers a flawless defense mechanism. We eagerly seize upon a comfortable sedative: <strong>“But what about Jeffrey Epstein?”</strong></p><p>The public imagination weaponises his monstrosity. We transform a billionaire predator — exposed and condemned by his own society’s press and judiciary — into a convenient moral sanctuary. A graveyard to bury our domestic rot. It is a deeply cynical psychological evasion. The corruption of the Western ‘Other’ becomes a sovereign licence to practice our own local degeneracy. The victims of the Caribbean are conscripted as human shields to protect the predators in our own backyards.</p><p>This hysterical invocation is not born out of solidarity with victims of Western oligarchs. It is ethical whitewashing, pure and simple. It is a pathetic plea to declare that as long as the outside world is a sewer, we are under no obligation to clean the latrines in our own homes.</p><p>Let us end this moral charlatanism. The difference between our societies and theirs is not the volume of human malice; evil is distributed with egalitarian precision across humanity. The difference lies in how we handle the pus. <br>In the West, Epstein became a naked national scandal. Documentaries stripped the elite bare. Investigative journalism rattled thrones and brought down politicians. Prosecutions pursued accomplices even after the mastermind died in his cell. There, society tore down the velvet curtain and chose a sickening, public confrontation over a comfortable silence.</p><p>Here, Epstein is weaponised to nationalise crime and grant it immunity. He is invoked to blackmail the human conscience, to trivialise the agony of our own casualties. The unwritten social contract tells the local victim: <em>Hush, the West has Epstein.</em> It demands that the trauma of a child in our streets be postponed, if not entirely cancelled, until the Western hemisphere purges itself of all sin. This is not cultural pride; it is structural complicity. It is a moral degradation that conditions the justice of a local victim upon the total purity of the entire planet.</p><p>The naked truth we mask by pointing across the Atlantic is that we are not dealing with an isolated island. We are drowning in vast, bottomless oceans of institutional violations. In our world, these atrocities are not accidental tears in the fabric of an otherwise functioning system. They are the fabric itself. It is a fabric woven by <em>fatwas</em>, enforced by the clan, and guarded by the silence of the elites and the crushing weight of social conformity.</p><p>Look at the child. The weakest, most vulnerable link in our social order. Childhood is systematically slaughtered in our villages and alleys under a revisionist cover that sanctifies statutory rape as ‘child marriage’, packaging it neatly in divine decrees and tribal complicity. This is no collection of ‘isolated cases’. The regional data published by UNICEF in its definitive analytical report, <em>Is an End to Child Marriage within Reach?</em>, paints a picture of a silent, systemic catastrophe. <br>The Middle East and North Africa region traps nearly 700,000 girls annually in forced marriages before they even reach their eighteenth year. Yemen and Sudan drive these harrowing metrics, forcing one in every three girls into wedlock. We have transformed the beds of children into legalised slaughterhouses, insulated by domestic statutes and an inherited jurisprudential legacy that dogmatically refuses to establish a minimum age for marriage.</p><p>In another corner of this broken geography, the pen is stripped from a boy’s hand and replaced with an assault rifle. The apologist will shrug this off as the tragic, temporary byproduct of war. International documentation strips away that excuse, exposing a calculated, structural horror. The <em>Report of the United Nations Secretary-General on Children and Armed Conflict (A/78/842–S/2024/384)</em> verifies the widespread recruitment of thousands of children used as raw cannon fodder by armed groups and factions across Yemen, Syria, and Libya. These children are systematically brainwashed in training camps, their innocence hollowed out to manufacture unthinking instruments of slaughter. It is a grotesque, modern reincarnation of the Janissary system, abducting the young to serve as human shields for warlords operating under the banner of religious fanaticism.</p><p>Where is the fierce outrage we reserved for Epstein when a twelve-year-old girl is led to the bed of an old man with the explicit blessing of the state, the tribe, and the mosque? How does our moral indignation evaporate when assault rifles are handed out to toddlers in ideological boot camps, while we scream for victims across the seas?</p><p>If you believe the cruelty stops at decimated childhoods, look at the annihilation of the Yazidi women. This was no collateral damage of a chaotic civil war. It was the deliberate, theological resurrection of the slave trade, justified by explicit scriptural interpretations found in classical books of jurisprudence that our institutions refuse to purge. The United Nations Investigative Team (UNITAD), in its briefing to the Security Council <em>(S/PV.8771)</em>, delivered clear and convincing evidence that ISIS executed a textbook genocide against the Yazidis. Their judicial records itemise the murder and abduction of 10,000 human beings, alongside the enslavement and trafficking of over 10,800 Yazidi women and girls. They were bartered in the slave markets of Mosul and Raqqa as sexual concubines, governed by jurisprudential manuals distributed to fighters that relied entirely on classical rulings of ‘right-hand possession’ (<em>milk al-yamin ملك اليمين</em>).</p><p>Step away from the frontlines, look behind the gleaming glass skyscrapers of our modern metropolises, and you find millions of domestic workers trapped in the vice of the <em>Kafala</em> sponsorship system. The International Labour Organization (ILO), in its global report <em>Global Estimates of Modern Slavery</em>, classifies this system as a contemporary blueprint for bondage. Passports are confiscated as a matter of routine, bodies are broken by ceaseless labour, and human beings are reduced to private property through legal contracts that penalise escape. The violation is institutionalised by local law.</p><p>Where is your human rage when Yazidi women are sold like livestock under heritage texts that no mainstream institution dares to repudiate? How can human beings be enslaved under the <em>Kafala</em> system right before the eyes of the very elites who fill the digital airwaves with righteous anger over the Caribbean?</p><p>The same architecture of cruelty operates behind the silent walls of state security apparatuses. Authoritarian regimes construct industrial slaughterhouses far from cameras and international scrutiny. Torture in our region is not an isolated transgression by a rogue officer. It is a systematic political science, a state culture engineered to shatter human dignity and liquidate consciousness. <br>The UN Independent International Commission of Inquiry exposed this terrifying machinery in its report, <em>‘Web of Agony: Arbitrary Detention, Torture, and Ill-Treatment’</em>. <br>Across thousands of testimonies, the Commission documented how enforced disappearance operates as a deliberate state strategy to erase bodies and souls. It details the routine application of electric shocks to genitalia, the ripping out of fingernails, and calculated sexual humiliation designed to extract signed confessions under the warden’s whip. <br>These findings are corroborated by intersecting, relentless investigations from Amnesty International and Human Rights Watch, confirming that detention centers throughout the region operate entirely outside the perimeter of humanitarian law, snuffing out lives and rendering corpses into anonymous numbers dumped in secret mass graves.</p><p>How can you scream at the judicial corruption of America over Epstein while you whisper in fear or deliberately ignore the agonizing screams of the tortured in prisons just a few miles from your front door? When will we admit that our state dungeons conceal oceans of structural violations?</p><p>Step out of the cells and into the daylight, and you encounter the woman, cursed to live in perpetual terror of her own family’s genes. Honour killings are not anomalous family tragedies; they are a collective culture of execution deeply embedded in the public psyche and protected by penal codes. Women are slaughtered in cold blood on mere rumor, or for daring to reject domestic servitude, while the killer emerges into the street as a cultural hero, shielded by ‘mitigating circumstances’. <br>The United Nations Population Fund (UNFPA) reports on gender-based violence expose a damning legislative reality. <br>Statutes like Article 548 of the Syrian Penal Code — prior to its superficial, glacial adjustments via Legislative Decree №2 of 2020 — and identical clauses across the region, historically granted an honour killer a reduced sentence or a suspended execution under the legal fiction of a ‘fit of fury’. This is state-sponsored, judicial complicity. The law itself underwrites the annihilation of women, ensuring a safe exit for the killer amid the applause of a society that puts the victim on trial even in her grave.</p><p>Where is the outrage when a woman’s blood is spilled on her own doorstep, and the murderer washes his hands with the water of tribal custom, cheered on by neighbours who suddenly morph into puritanical moralists when decrying Epstein’s crimes?</p><p>In this dark tunnel, ethnic and religious minorities face a similar ultimatum: assimilation, exile, or death. The nation is enforced as a single, rigid identity. Anyone who deviates in faith, sect, or thought is treated as historical surplus or a deferred corpse. Churches are bombed, ancient temples demolished, and entire communities hunted down. The apologist who attempts to dismiss this text as biased must first confront the UN Human Rights Council report <em>(A/HRC/52/38)</em> by the Special Rapporteur on freedom of religion or belief, Nazila Ghanea. These documents chart a suffocating apartheid of discrimination surrounding millions of Christians, Yazidis, Baha’is, and unrecognized sects. They face the systematic denial of basic citizenship and forced displacement, proving once again that we are swimming atop oceans of theological exclusion, validated by both official and popular <em>fatwas فتاوى</em>.</p><p>This machinery of persecution is driven by an intellectual framework that converts the sacred into a weapon of mass destruction. Terrorism in our societies is not a stray bullet or an accidental suicide vest. It is an integrated ecosystem nourished by explicit <em>fatwas</em> and mainstream institutions that are complicit through their silence or their absolute cowardice to mount a radical intellectual confrontation. When apologists claim that terrorism ‘does not represent religion’, they run headfirst into the historical quagmire documented by major religious institutions. Consider the Al-Azhar Observatory and the Grand Imam’s documented declarations at Cairo University. <br>Al-Azhar decisively and repeatedly refused to excommunicate (<em>takfir تكفير</em>) the butchers of ISIS. The most prestigious religious institution in the region blinked, evading its duty of absolute theological condemnation by hiding behind a cold jurisprudential maxim: <em>‘</em><strong><em>A Muslim cannot be excommunicated, regardless of their sins, so long as they pronounce the testimonies and pray towards the Qibla.’</em></strong></p><p>This cold-blooded theological complicity constructs an intellectual sanctuary for butchers. It threw an umbrella of protection over an organisation while the rest of the world watched its official broadcasts, like the 2015 video <em>‘Healing of the Chests’</em>, which documented the burning alive of a captured Jordanian pilot in an iron cage. That execution relied explicitly on mainstream heritage <em>fatwas</em> concerning the permissibility of immolation and the mutilation of enemies. This theology did not stop at cinematic executions; it infected the curriculum of ISIS’s Diwan of Education and the broadcasts of the ‘Cubs of the Caliphate’, where children were trained to cut the throats of hostages and booby-trap their own fragile bodies.</p><p>The defect does not lie in individual deviants; it lies in the intellectual operating system that our religious institutions refuse to dismantle. By contenting themselves with viewing mass murderers as ‘corruptors upon the earth rather than infidels’, they prove that we float on vast oceans of jurisprudential legitimisation built entirely on hypocrisy and semantic evasion. <br>How do you find the audacity to fill the digital sphere with screams demanding the destruction of Epstein’s network, while your highest religious authorities fail to cast out child-slaughterers and those who burn the living from the fold of the faith, simply because they utter the testimony before driving the knife home? Where is your moral zeal when preachers are dissecting the vices of the West while remaining silent about the monsters who crawled out from the cloak of our own schools and pulpits?</p><p>Why does this pattern persist? The answer lies in a sinister strategy perfected by the local criminal, the authoritarian regime, and the religious establishment alike: the nationalisation of identity. <br>The moment a predator is cornered by his crime — whether he is a rapist cleric, a torturing general, or an honour killer — he wraps himself in the flag and screams for help. He mutters about identity, mutating his filthy personal depravity into an ‘existential war’ against foreign conspiracies and Western cultural invasion. The criminal is instantly re-branded as the ‘son of the culture’ under siege by the brutal West. The moment society swallows this ruse, the victim is erased from the equation. Defending the executioner becomes a sacred, patriotic duty to protect the walls of the nation from fracturing. This is the absolute immunity we hand our monsters the moment they hoist our slogans and claim enmity with the West.</p><p>The supreme sin in our collective consciousness is never the commission of the crime; it is its exposure. We are societies pathologically obsessed with ‘discretion’ (<em>al-sitr الستر</em>) to the point of sanctifying the rot and criminalising the cleanliness. When a victim steps forward to scream, or a researcher writes to document, society mobilises its entire arsenal — not against the perpetrator, but against this ‘nuisance’ who dared to shake the velvet curtain. The writer is branded a traitor infected with self-loathing; the victim is accused of debauchery and airing dirty laundry. We prosecute the one holding the mirror, not the one who disfigured the face. This structural moral inversion is what renders reform impossible. The criminal in our environment is completely secure, knowing that the public will gladly undertake the stoning and ostracisation of any voice attempting to expose him, invoking ‘Epstein’ as a gatekeeper to ban any brave domestic debate.</p><p>Let us put an end to equivocations. The casualties in our societies — that young girl led to the theological guillotine, that woman slaughtered on her doorstep, and that tortured soul behind the silent walls of our dungeons — do not possess the luxury of waiting for the world to become pure. They do not care if Jeffrey Epstein is languishing in his hell or if New York is drowning in its vices. They want justice here, and now, in the very streets where they are bleeding, from the law and the conscience that is supposed to protect them.</p><p>When you use the atrocity of a criminal across the seas to justify your silence over a monster here, you are not practicing geopolitics, nor are you defending a civilisation. You are simply placing your hand in the hand of the local killer, handing him another bullet to fire at the next victim. Moral condemnation cannot be partitioned. A violation is a violation, even if it issues from ourselves or is heavily armed by our own texts.</p><p><strong>The words have ended.</strong> You may now return to social media, writing with furious rage about ‘Epstein’s island’ to experience some cheap, manufactured moral comfort, all while you trample over the corpses of victims in your own society without batting an eye. <br>Sleep soundly, for the West is filthy… and our home is nothing but a graveyard covered in fine Persian rugs, floating atop bottomless oceans of institutionalised violations.</p><h3>References &amp; Official Documents</h3><blockquote><strong>1. Child Protection, Child Marriage, and Child Soldiering</strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong>UNICEF.</strong> (2023). <em>Is an End to Child Marriage within Reach? Latest Trends and Future Prospects.</em> New York: United Nations Children’s Fund.</blockquote><blockquote><strong>United Nations Security Council.</strong> (2024). <em>Children and Armed Conflict: Report of the Secretary-General.</em> UN Document A/78/842–S/2024/384. New York: United Nations.</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Office of the Special Representative of the Secretary-General for Children and Armed Conflict.</strong> <em>Annual Reports Hub.</em> United Nations Official Repository.</blockquote><blockquote><strong>2. The Yazidi Genocide, Human Trafficking, and Modern Slavery</strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong>UNITAD.</strong> (2021). <em>Clear and Convincing Evidence of ISIL Genocide Against the Yazidis: Briefing of the Special Adviser and Head of UNITAD to the United Nations Security Council.</em> UN Security Council Meeting Record S/PV.8771.</blockquote><blockquote><strong>International Labour Organization, Walk Free, &amp; International Organisation for Migration.</strong> (2022). <em>Global Estimates of Modern Slavery: Forced Labour and Forced Marriage.</em> Geneva: ILO.</blockquote><blockquote><strong>3. Torture and Enforced Disappearance</strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong>UN Human Rights Council.</strong> (2025). <em>“Web of Agony”: Arbitrary Detention, Torture, and Ill-Treatment by Former Government Forces in the Syrian Arab Republic.</em> Companion Report to A/HRC/46/55. Geneva: Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights (OHCHR).</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Amnesty International.</strong> (2024). <em>Amnesty International Report 2023/24: The State of the World’s Human Rights.</em>London.</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Human Rights Watch.</strong> (2024). <em>World Report 2024: Events of 2023.</em> New York.</blockquote><blockquote><strong>4. Honour Crimes and Legislative Discrimination</strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong>Syrian Judiciary.</strong> <em>Legislative Decree №2 of 2020 amending Article 548 of the Syrian Penal Code.</em> Official Gazette.</blockquote><blockquote><strong>UNFPA.</strong> (2021). <em>International Standards and MENA Penal Codes: A Regional Assessment of Legal Loopholes in Gender-Based Violence and Criminal Mitigating Factors.</em> Cairo: United Nations Population Fund.</blockquote><blockquote><strong>5. Freedom of Belief and Persecution of Minorities</strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong>United Nations Human Rights Council.</strong> (2023). <em>Report of the Special Rapporteur on Freedom of Religion or Belief.</em> Nazila Ghanea. UN Document A/HRC/52/38. Geneva.</blockquote><blockquote><strong>6. Terrorism and the Exploitation of Religion</strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong>Al-Azhar Observatory.</strong> (2014–2015). <em>Official Statements and Communiqués Issued During the International Conference on Countering Extremism / “Al-Azhar Rejects Takfir… Won’t You Understand?”</em> Cairo: Al-Azhar Official English Repository.</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Institute for Economics &amp; Peace.</strong> (2024). <em>Global Terrorism Index 2024: Measuring the Impact of Terrorism.</em>Sydney: IEP (Based on the Global Terrorism Database).</blockquote><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a7b8b2dbac85" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Open Mosque Day: Why Is It Held, and Which Islam Is Presented to Visitors?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@rami_zahra/open-mosque-day-why-is-it-held-and-which-islam-is-presented-to-visitors-bb7d5fad1947?source=rss-5d95452aa4e4------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/bb7d5fad1947</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[hypocrisy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[taqiyya]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[religious-dissimulation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[islam]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[open-mosque-day]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Rami Zahra]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 17 Jun 2026 23:13:07 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-06-21T16:43:51.560Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>A critical examination of whether open mosque events offer a complete picture of Islam — or a carefully curated version designed for public consumption.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*aD9iz4kR9-Vo0dXnDlgdGQ.png" /></figure><p>What interests me less is what is said to visitors during an “Open Mosque Day” than the assumption upon which the event itself is built.</p><p>Everything about it begins with a single idea: that people do not know enough about Islam.</p><p>And whenever controversy grows, the same answer is offered: more explanation, more education, more dialogue.</p><p>But what about those who already know Islam?</p><p>Not from books, pamphlets, or guided tours, but from life itself.</p><p>Millions of people knew Islam long before they ever attended an open day or heard slogans about dialogue and understanding. They knew it in homes, schools, streets, and everyday relationships. They knew it when religion was not merely a belief held in the heart, but a social authority that followed every detail of life.</p><p>They knew it when some people knew you had missed the dawn prayer before they knew you were ill.</p><p>They knew it when a person’s religious reputation preceded them into employment, marriage, and social relationships.</p><p>They knew it when it was enough for someone to notice your absence from the mosque for a few weeks for the questions, whispers, and interpretations to begin.</p><p>They knew it when some people measured a person’s virtue by the number of prayers they had seen them perform rather than by the number of good deeds they had done.</p><p>They knew it when a <a href="https://medium.com/@rami_zahra/what-are-the-rights-of-women-in-islam-ea7365e987d1"><strong>woman</strong></a> hid her food during <em>Ramadan</em>, not because she “feared Allah”, but because she <a href="https://medium.com/@rami_zahra/wife-punishment-in-islam-1da15e5deb69"><strong>feared people</strong></a> — feared the looks, the comments, and the ready-made judgements, even though everyone knew she had a “legitimate religious excuse”.</p><p>They knew it when a young man sometimes pretended to believe things he did not truly believe, because honesty with society carried a higher cost than silence.</p><p>They knew it when some people concealed their true opinions for many years, not out of fear of prison, but out of fear of social rejection.</p><p>They knew it when relationships between people were not always built on morality, knowledge, or humanity, but on other questions: Does he pray? Does he fast? Is he observant? Is it permissible to sit with him? Is he suitable for marriage into our family? Can we eat at his house? Can we pray behind him?</p><p>They also knew it through the constant presence of <a href="https://medium.com/@rami_zahra/the-people-of-double-standards-between-haram-and-halal-e38153e09bdf"><strong><em>halal and haram</em></strong></a> in the smallest details of life — in food, clothing, relationships, friendships, music, books, celebrations, words, and even the thoughts that pass through a person’s mind.</p><p>This is the experience that does not appear in group photographs.</p><p>This is the life that cannot be reduced to an elegant pamphlet placed on a table at the entrance of a mosque.</p><p>And so I find myself pausing at an idea that is constantly repeated: that people’s problem with Islam is that they do not know enough about it.</p><p>Many people do not look at Islam through the glass of an exhibition hall.</p><p>They look at it through a very long memory.</p><p>A memory filled with social surveillance, ready-made judgements, and the fear of departing from the group.</p><p>And perhaps here I arrive at what I consider the most sensitive question in this entire subject.</p><p>When a visitor is invited into a mosque under banners of coexistence, openness, and mutual respect, it is naturally assumed that these values are the organic extension of what this religion believes and what its history has produced.</p><p>Yet the moment one begins to look a little deeper, a far more complex reality emerges.</p><p>Much of the debate surrounding Islam in the modern era does not stem from a simple misunderstanding or an unfair stereotype, but from genuine discussions about texts, traditions, and rulings that still exist in books, references, and fatwas, and which millions of Muslims continue to regard as part of the religion itself.</p><p>This is where the gap emerges.</p><p>The issue is not about isolated mistakes or individual behaviour. One only has to browse some <a href="https://medium.com/@rami_zahra/slavery-and-servitude-in-islam-from-the-middle-ages-to-isis-386b39913ae0"><strong>classical and contemporary works of Islamic</strong></a> jurisprudence to find lengthy discussions on how <a href="https://medium.com/@rami_zahra/muslims-view-of-non-muslims-5b0b0651125c"><strong>non-Muslims</strong></a> should be distinguished <a href="https://medium.com/@rami_zahra/non-muslims-clothing-yellow-for-jews-and-black-for-christians-f739f82cb62b"><strong>from Muslims in dress</strong></a>, appearance, and <a href="https://medium.com/@rami_zahra/first-we-take-care-of-saturday-then-we-take-care-of-sunday-2ed6025075c4"><strong>public life</strong></a>. One only has to listen to the debates taking place within Muslim societies themselves to see how takfir and accusations regarding a person’s faith are used as weapons against dissenters, thinkers, and those with unconventional views.</p><p>And one only has to look at the degree of fear that drives many people to conceal their true opinions or personal practices to realise that the debate is not always about stereotypes invented by others, but about realities and experiences people have lived through themselves.</p><p>For this reason, I do not believe the problem lies in the existence of these questions. The problem lies in acting, at times, as though they do not exist at all.</p><p>This is why I find it difficult to view an “Open Mosque Day” as merely an educational excursion.</p><p>Because the question that always accompanies me is not: Why do people not know Islam?</p><p>Rather: Why do we assume that everyone who criticises it, or has reservations about it, simply does not know it yet?</p><p>Some people do not speak from the position of a visitor, but from the position of a witness. And the difference between the two is enormous.</p><p>And if, for a moment, we move beyond the question of who knows Islam and who does not, another issue appears before us that is no less important:</p><p>Which Islam is being presented during an “Open Mosque Day”?</p><p>Every presentation, no matter how neutral it claims to be, is built on selection. And every selection necessarily involves exclusion.</p><p>For this reason, no event can be evaluated solely by what it chooses to display, but also by what it chooses not to display.</p><p>This is where the real questions begin.</p><p>Not at the tables where the pamphlets are laid out, but in the empty spaces between them.</p><p>Why, for example, are there no displays at the entrance entitled “The Difficult Questions”?</p><p>Why are there no sessions dedicated to discussing the most controversial issues?</p><p>Why is the visitor not told from the outset: Ask about everything. Ask about apostasy, about non-Muslims, about the boundaries between believer and unbeliever, about interfaith marriage, about the relationship between Sharia and civil law, about everything you hear in the media and everything that concerns or troubles you.</p><p>When a visitor enters a mosque on an open day, they are presented with a carefully arranged version of Islam. Everything appears considered: the selected verses, the selected stories, the selected topics, and even the questions people are encouraged to ask.</p><p>The organisers speak about mercy, charity, family, neighbours, tolerance, and shared values. But the problem does not lie in what is said. The problem lies in the fact that the picture appears complete when it is not.</p><p>When the Qur’an is displayed open to Surah Maryam at the entrance, that choice is not accidental.</p><p>It is a visual message before it is a religious one.</p><p>A message that says to the Christian visitor: Look, we too believe in Mary.</p><p>But does the visitor know that the same chapter presents Mary in a manner fundamentally different from Christian doctrine? Do they know that it presents Jesus Christ as a prophet and nothing more? Do they know that it denies His divine sonship and rejects the doctrine of the Trinity, the very foundation of Christian belief? Do they know that it does not merely differ <a href="https://medium.com/@rami_zahra/paid-ignorance-as-cultural-dialogue-how-celebrities-sell-simplistic-myths-and-call-it-interfaith-b08c39c21c96"><strong>from Christian doctrine</strong></a>, but rejects it altogether?</p><p>This is not about Surah Maryam alone. It is a broader pattern.<br><strong>Read </strong><a href="https://medium.com/@rami_zahra/paid-ignorance-as-cultural-dialogue-how-celebrities-sell-simplistic-myths-and-call-it-interfaith-b08c39c21c96"><strong>Here</strong></a><strong> &amp; </strong><a href="https://medium.com/@rami_zahra/is-mary-a-bridge-between-islam-and-christianity-7033526883f3"><strong>Here</strong></a><strong>.</strong></p><p>The points that create an immediate sense of familiarity are displayed, while the points that raise difficult questions are postponed. The common ground is highlighted, while the disputed ground is pushed into the background. Any person, institution, or ideology can appear attractive if it possesses the power to choose what it will display and what it will conceal.</p><p>Instead, most tours revolve around Islamic architecture, Arabic calligraphy, the pillars of Islam, the daily lives of Muslims, and a handful of <a href="https://medium.com/@rami_zahra/wishful-thinking-7d3d1714b566"><strong>emotionally engaging human stories.</strong></a></p><p>In some of these events, Islam is not merely explained; visitors are invited to experience part of it. Some children are encouraged to wear the hijab, others try standing in prayer rows, and visitors learn something about ablution. They may also be invited to participate in activities connected to religious rituals and symbols.</p><p>If the objective is purely educational, then why does the process move beyond information? Why does it move from explanation to experience, from knowledge to feeling, from presenting an idea to creating a psychological connection with it?</p><p>There is a significant difference between explaining what you believe and inviting me to taste the experience itself. There is an even greater difference between education and dialogue on the one hand, and the cultivation of emotional impressions on the other.</p><p>Is the visitor truly getting to know Islam? Or are they getting to know the <a href="https://medium.com/@rami_zahra/muslims-do-not-just-live-contradictions-they-master-them-ee7fc8d52ca9"><strong>version that the organisers</strong></a> have decided is appropriate to present?</p><p>One of the hardest things to ignore is that most of these initiatives flourish only in countries that Islamists criticise day and night.</p><p>“Open Mosque Day” was not born in Kabul, Tehran, Riyadh, or Idlib, nor in any environment where religious authorities or Islamists exercise broad influence over public life.</p><p>It was born in London, Manchester, Birmingham, Amsterdam, Berlin, Stockholm, and across Canada, Australia, and New Zealand.</p><p>It was born in places that allow people to disagree, criticise, object, mock, leave religion if they wish, and challenge an imam without fearing a visit from a religious police force, a morality committee, or the anger of family and tribe.</p><p>This day was born in a place where a mosque can open its doors to the public, distribute literature, organise events, host politicians and journalists, hold interfaith dialogue sessions, raise funds, establish associations, protest in the streets, challenge the government, and even accuse it of racism or Islamophobia, without fearing closure, prohibition, or persecution.</p><p>Indeed, the irony becomes sharper when we remember that these very events could not exist without the Western freedoms that are so often condemned as immoral, godless, and socially corrupt.</p><p>In many places outside this sphere, the question is not: How shall we organise an open day?</p><p>The question asked quietly is: Would we even be allowed to organise one?</p><p>We cannot ignore a simple irony: the societies that opened their doors to these initiatives are often the same societies portrayed in Islamic discourse as moral, civilisational, or spiritual crises.</p><p>Yet the freedom that allows a mosque to explain itself to others today is not a product of Islamic jurisprudence, Sharia, or Islamist movements. It is a product of the Western liberal model that granted everyone the right to speak, organise, advocate, and object in the first place.</p><p>The legitimate question here is this: if these values are so important when Muslims need their protection, why do they appear less important when non-Muslims, dissenters, or critics need them within Muslim societies?</p><p>What draws my attention most in photographs from “Open Mosque Day” is not who attended, but who did not.</p><p>After many years of these initiatives, the same images appear again and again: smiling faces, curious visitors, retirees, students, interfaith activists, people interested in different cultures, and individuals who entered the venue because they were already inclined to do so.</p><p>Yet the very people these initiatives supposedly exist to reach are scarcely visible.</p><p>You do not see the man who lost trust in this discourse years ago.</p><p>You do not see the woman carrying a painful experience from a conservative religious environment.</p><p>You do not see those who look at Islam with suspicion because of what they have lived through, witnessed, or read.</p><p>Nor do you see those around whom all these campaigns supposedly revolve.</p><p>The scene resembles a doctor standing in a public square to treat the sick, only to discover that those gathered before him are not the sick at all, but healthy people attending a lecture on health.</p><p>This is where the real question begins — not: How many people attended?</p><p>But: Where are the people we were told these initiatives were created to reach?</p><p>It may be easy to explain yourself to those who were already willing to listen.</p><p>It may be easy to speak about dialogue with those who came looking for dialogue in the first place.</p><p>But the real challenge begins with those who never enter the room at all.</p><p>Those who do not wish to attend.</p><p>Those who see no benefit in attending.</p><p>Or those who believe that nothing they hear there will be different from what they have heard before.</p><p>These, more than anyone else, are the great absentees from every group photograph taken at the end of the day.</p><p>Whenever I read about an “Open Mosque Day” or watch its reports and photographs, the same question returns to my mind:</p><p>Why did all of this emerge at that particular moment?</p><p>Not because Islam was unknown beforehand. Not because mosques did not exist. Not because people suddenly discovered that they had Muslim neighbours. All of that already existed.</p><p>But something else was happening in the background.</p><p>During those years, Islam was not present in public debate merely as a religion of prayer and fasting. It was present in news bulletins, political debates, and discussions about integration, extremism, terrorism, identity, and immigration. It was being questioned in a way it had not been questioned before.</p><p>It was at precisely that moment that doors began opening on a large scale, guided tours began appearing, national campaigns emerged, and open days multiplied.</p><p>When any individual, group, or institution feels that its image has come under scrutiny or doubt, it is only natural that it should seek to explain itself, defend itself, and present its own account of events.</p><p>Perhaps that is precisely why I cannot view these open days as merely an innocent invitation to a cup of tea and a tour of a mosque.</p><p>People do not arrive in these halls carrying blank notebooks. They arrive carrying memories, experiences, and impressions formed over many years. Some carry questions that have never been answered. Some carry old wounds. Some carry convictions that have settled in their minds long ago.</p><p>For this reason, it seems to me that the debate surrounding Islam in the West is far deeper than a misunderstanding that merely requires correction, or a stereotype that simply needs softening.</p><p>And so perhaps the most important question is not how we introduce people to Islam.</p><p>But which Islam we mean when we tell them: this is Islam. <a href="https://medium.com/@rami_zahra/al-taqiyya-the-terrorist-art-of-deception-548ce3514369"><strong>read more here</strong></a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=bb7d5fad1947" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Stop Romanticising It, Mamdani: This Was Power, Not Migration]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@rami_zahra/stop-romanticising-it-mamdani-this-was-power-not-migration-00d7e7fe9a9a?source=rss-5d95452aa4e4------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/00d7e7fe9a9a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[political-islam]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[religion-and-politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[democracy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[migration]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[zohran-mamdani]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Rami Zahra]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 18 Mar 2026 00:30:46 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-03-18T00:51:25.770Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>This was never a story about refuge, coexistence, or the search for a better life. It was a calculated political transformation — one that replaced a marginal religious movement with a governing authority. Presenting it today as a “beautiful example of migration” is not just misleading. It is a deliberate distortion of history. <br>When Zohran Mamdani invokes this example, he is not quoting history — he is rewriting it to fit a modern political narrative. The migration he refers to did not lead to integration into an existing society. It led to the creation of a new political order. That difference is not minor. It changes everything.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*FP11c3DW86xizUu7zakuXg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Source: Wikimedia Commons — public domain / open license image</figcaption></figure><p>A few days ago, Zohran Mamdani, the new mayor of New York City and its first Muslim mayor, spoke about protecting migrants in the city. In the course of his remarks, he cited the migration of the Prophet Muhammad from Mecca to Medina as “a beautiful example of migration,” presenting it as a positive model.</p><p>He said that Muhammad had been vulnerable and a stranger, and that he found in Medina a new homeland whose people welcomed him, and that this was a blessing for everyone. He also cited a verse from the Qur’an, from Surah An-Nahl: <em>“And those who emigrated for the cause of God after they had been wronged — We will surely settle them in this world in a good place; but the reward of the Hereafter is greater, if only they knew.”</em></p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?type=text%2Fhtml&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;schema=twitter&amp;url=https%3A//x.com/aa_arabic/status/2020131683568349626&amp;image=" width="500" height="281" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/c21d49edb5f9a8bad9b544de6a301ee4/href">https://medium.com/media/c21d49edb5f9a8bad9b544de6a301ee4/href</a></iframe><p>At first glance, this sounds rhetorically attractive. The story is familiar and is associated in the public imagination with persecution, refuge, and the search for safety. But the problem is not compassion for migrants, nor defending migration as a human phenomenon. The problem is the way religious history is used inside a modern political debate.</p><p>When a historical event with a specific religious and legal context is used to justify migration policies in a modern civil state, the question is direct: is this history being used as a complete intellectual framework, or as a selective metaphor from which only what serves a political message is taken?<br>The answer is clear: Mamdani chose the wrong example.</p><p>This is said from the position of someone who is himself a migrant, who supports tolerance toward migrants and rejects racism and marginalisation. These are basic matters that should not need to be repeated.</p><p>Mamdani is not an Islamist in the strict ideological sense, but he represents a familiar type: a “<strong><em>romantic Muslim,</em></strong>” shaped by <strong><em>Western left-wing </em></strong>education, <strong><em>post-colonial</em></strong> theory, and political correctness. A product of a Western left that treated migration as a simple moral issue before discovering its political consequences when the right and far right began to rise.</p><p>Defending migration does not mean opening borders without control, nor banning migration entirely. Migration is a complex issue that requires management, law, and policy. The real question is not whether migration is good or bad, but how it is managed, how integration is enforced, and how the law is applied.<br>But Mamdani’s example collapses when examined.</p><p>The migration of Muhammad was not an individual migration for work, education, or a better life. It was a collective migration with a clear political objective: establishing a new political and religious authority in Medina. It was not integration into a system — it was the creation of a new one.</p><p>It was also not a movement between different civilisations. Muhammad moved from one Arab society to another. Projecting this onto modern migration between fundamentally different societies is false.</p><p>If Muslims today migrate to Europe or America, they enter existing systems, laws, and institutions. They do not migrate to replace them. The Muhammadan migration, by contrast, led to the establishment of authority.</p><p>And the historical record itself is clear about what followed.</p><p>The consolidation of power in Medina was accompanied by the expulsion of Jewish tribes and the imposition of harsh measures. This is not external criticism. It is part of Islamic sources themselves.</p><p>More importantly, the Qur’anic text itself establishes clear rules.</p><p>In Surah At-Tawbah, one of the last chapters revealed, the text states directly:</p><p><em>“O you who believe, indeed the polytheists are unclean, so let them not approach the Sacred Mosque after this year…”</em>(9:28)</p><p>This is not interpretation. This is a direct command.<br>And this is not confined to text or historical interpretation. It is enforced in present-day reality.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Y_nbySNSR3xQWtmq4Jx6DQ.png" /><figcaption>Road signs in Saudi Arabia explicitly separating routes for Muslims and non-Muslims.<br>Not theory. Not history. A present-day application of religious restriction.</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/695/1*Fyvi74tc4abcBoMyQ0LELA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Road signs in Saudi Arabia explicitly separating routes for Muslims and non-Muslims.<br>Not theory. Not history. A present-day application of religious restriction.</figcaption></figure><p>It is still applied in reality today, where non-Muslims are prevented from entering <strong>Mecca and Medina</strong>, with separate roads designated accordingly.<br>This is the same framework being selectively invoked — but never fully acknowledged.</p><p>The same chapter continues:</p><p><em>“Fight those who do not believe in Allah or in the Last Day… among the People of the Book, until they give the jizya willingly while they are subdued.”</em> (9:29)<br><em>“The Jews say ‘Ezra is the son of God,’ and the Christians say ‘The Messiah is the son of God’… may Allah destroy them; how are they deluded?”</em> (9:30)<br><em>“They have taken their rabbis and monks as lords besides Allah…”</em> (9:31)</p><p>These are not marginal texts. They are central, explicit, and binding within the framework of the religion itself.</p><p>If this is the reference being used, then it must be used — not partially.</p><p>The same applies to the hadith Mamdani indirectly relies on:<br><strong><em>“Islam began as something strange and will return to being strange as it began.”<br></em></strong>But this is not the only statement.<br>There is also the explicit statement attributed to Muhammad:<br><strong><em>“I am free from any Muslim who resides among the polytheists.”</em></strong></p><p>This directly contradicts the modern framing of migration as coexistence and integration.<br>At the same time, <strong>jihad</strong> is not presented in classical Islamic sources as merely defensive. It is presented as an obligation tied to expansion and enforcement. <strong>The idea that migration is simply for safety or economic opportunity ignores the broader doctrinal framework.</strong></p><p>The texts are clear. The reinterpretations come later.</p><p>This makes Mamdani’s use of the example not only inaccurate, but misleading.</p><p>The contradiction is direct: a model built on establishing authority is being presented as a model of coexistence.</p><p>The problem does not stop at history.</p><p>Today, large Muslim communities live in Western societies that provide freedoms unavailable in many Muslim-majority countries: freedom of organisation, political participation, and expression.<br>For many, this is an opportunity for a better life.<br>For ideological movements, it is something else: an opportunity for expansion.</p><p>Here lies the core issue: <strong>the Islamisation of democracy, not the democratisation of Islam.<br></strong>Democracy becomes a tool, not a value.</p><p>This is reinforced by demographic realities. Muslim families in many Western countries have higher birth rates than average. The result is visible. In schools across Western cities, names like <strong><em>Mohammed, Ahmed, Aisha, Fatima, Khadija and Omar</em></strong> are widespread among younger generations.</p><p>The issue is not the presence of Muslims. The issue is how this presence is used.<br>The mechanism is clear.<br>Certain groups actively work to turn these communities into political bases. They use conflicts in the Middle East to create tension. They present Muslims as alien, marginalised, and in opposition to the societies they live in.<br>In addition to this, the real difficulties migrants face — language barriers, discrimination, are not treated as problems to be solved. They are treated as weaknesses to be exploited.<br>They are used to influence, mobilise, and recruit.<br>Peaceful individuals are pushed toward confrontation.</p><p>Even more striking, parts of the Western left contribute to this. By portraying Western societies as corrupt, colonial, and illegitimate, they reinforce the same narrative.</p><p>The result is a convergence:<br><strong>An Islamist narrative that separates Muslims from society.<br>And a left-wing narrative that undermines that society.</strong></p><p>Between them, integration becomes harder.</p><p>Within this environment, the statement:<br><em>“Islam began as something strange and will return to being strange as it began” </em>takes on a different meaning.<br>It becomes a political signal. A signal that influence can be rebuilt from the West, using its freedoms, its democracy, and its openness as a foundation.</p><p>This is exactly what Mamdani ignores.</p><p>And this is exactly why his example is not just wrong — it is dangerous.</p><p>Modern politics does not need selective metaphors. It needs clarity.</p><p>History, if it is used, must be used in full — not partially.</p><p>Anything else is not analysis.</p><p>It is manipulation.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=00d7e7fe9a9a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Inheritance of 1979]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@rami_zahra/the-inheritance-of-1979-b134ba7fa2f5?source=rss-5d95452aa4e4------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b134ba7fa2f5</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[oppression]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[iran]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[terrorism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[authoritarianism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[islam]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Rami Zahra]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 04 Mar 2026 00:29:37 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-03-04T00:29:37.830Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>The Iranian Islamic Revolution did not end with the fall of a monarchy.<br>It began a chain of wars, ideologies and interventions whose consequences still shape the region today.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*yxHB21t8ZpWcWudhI3wifw.png" /></figure><p>Since the Iranian Islamic Revolution of 1979, the political and strategic contours of the Middle East have been fundamentally reshaped. Its impact did not remain confined to Iran’s internal transformation; it evolved into a sustained trajectory that altered the region politically, strategically and intellectually. More than four decades later, the consequences continue to reverberate far beyond Iran’s borders.</p><p>What began as a domestic upheaval quickly evolved into a project with regional and global consequences. Because of the Iranian Islamic Revolution, a transnational project took root, grounded in the export of religious ideology and the fusion of politics with doctrine. The principle of “exporting the revolution” was transformed from a rhetorical slogan into operational policy, and the region was ignited by successive conflicts.</p><p>Because of the Iranian Islamic Revolution, the consolidation of clerical power did not end with the overthrow of the Shah; it extended to the systematic dismantling of former allies who had helped bring the revolution to power. Secular activists, Marxists, nationalists and leftist movements that initially stood alongside the religious leadership against the monarchy were progressively marginalised, outlawed, imprisoned and, in many cases, executed. The revolution did not merely replace one ruling order with another — it narrowed the political sphere until only ideological conformity remained. By the early 1980s, parties such as the Tudeh Party were crushed, opposition newspapers were shut down, and revolutionary pluralism gave way to clerical monopoly. The mass executions of political prisoners in 1988, which included members and supporters of the Mujahedin-e Khalq Organisation alongside leftist detainees, marked one of the most severe purges in modern Iranian history. In this sense, the revolution did not simply confront external adversaries; it consumed segments of its own coalition, establishing from its formative years a pattern of ideological exclusivity enforced through repression and fear.</p><p>Because of the Iranian Islamic Revolution, armed Sunni extremism emerged in reaction, and jihadist movements formed that perceived themselves to be confronting an opposing sectarian project. Political and financial backing intertwined with religious mobilisation during what became known as the “Islamic Awakening الصحوة الإسلامية”, merging ideological radicalism with geopolitical rivalry and unleashing a cycle of violence whose consequences endure.</p><p>Because of the Iranian Islamic Revolution, the eight-year war between Iran and Iraq (1980–1988) erupted — one of the longest conventional wars of the twentieth century — leaving hundreds of thousands dead and wounded, exhausting the economies of both states, and plunging the region into a vast arms race whose repercussions remain.</p><p>Because of the Iranian Islamic Revolution, the concept of the state in parts of the region shifted from a nation-state with defined borders to a sphere of cross-border influence. Major decisions came to be driven by ideological imperatives rather than national interest alone. Militias aligned doctrinally with Tehran multiplied, and weapons outside the framework of regular armed forces became a permanent element of political power.</p><p>The model of the “state within a state” was not merely tolerated — it was deliberately exported across multiple arenas. Because of the Iranian Islamic Revolution, support for militias ceased to be a temporary tactic and became a permanent model for expanding influence. Armed organisations evolved into parallel authorities capable of overruling or overshadowing official institutions. Sovereignty eroded, legitimacy became distorted, and irregular arms were transformed from instruments of combat into instruments of governance.</p><p>Because of the Iranian Islamic Revolution, political conflict was elevated from negotiable dispute to sacred religious struggle. When confrontation is framed as a doctrinal obligation that does not admit compromise, retreat becomes betrayal and settlement becomes weakness. Wars lengthen, and the human cost deepens without a visible ceiling.</p><p>Within the system created by the Iranian Islamic Revolution, society itself was gradually militarised, not as a temporary necessity but as a permanent political culture. The influence of the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps and the Basij expanded; ideological mobilisation intensified; education and media were reshaped into platforms reinforcing the narrative of perpetual struggle and the glorification of martyrdom. The logic of mobilisation prevailed over the logic of civil statehood.</p><p>Because of the Iranian Islamic Revolution, religious rituals were politicised and converted into transnational platforms of mobilisation. Observance became intertwined with political allegiance, and sacred symbols were employed to entrench division, moving beyond spiritual meaning to serve as instruments of polarisation and confrontation.</p><p>Because of the Iranian Islamic Revolution, Iran experienced extensive waves of emigration, including scientists, doctors, academics and entrepreneurs. Intellectual capital was drained, human resources weakened, and significant diaspora communities formed across Europe and North America as citizens sought escape from political and economic constraints.</p><p>Because of the Iranian Islamic Revolution, a shadow economy tied to powerful institutions expanded, particularly networks associated with the Revolutionary Guard in sectors such as oil, construction and telecommunications. A parallel economic structure emerged, less transparent and less competitive, where power and wealth became intertwined in ways that weakened governance and accountability.</p><p>Because of the Iranian Islamic Revolution, the detention of dual nationals and foreign citizens evolved into a recurring bargaining instrument. Arrests under broad security charges turned individual lives into negotiating files within exchanges and diplomatic pressure campaigns — a pattern that persists to this day and has directly shaped Iran’s relations with multiple states.</p><p>Because of the Iranian Islamic Revolution, the concept of citizenship eroded in favour of ideological loyalty. Allegiance to doctrine superseded allegiance to the nation in multiple contexts, weakening the modern principle of equal citizenship under the law and deepening internal fragmentation.</p><p>Because of the Iranian Islamic Revolution, influence extended into African states through religious, cultural and security activities within a broader cross-border network of engagement, adding new arenas of competition and projection beyond the traditional regional theatre.</p><p>Because of the Iranian Islamic Revolution, sanctions — precipitated by the policies of a small circle of clerics and security officials — were incorporated into the internal political equation. Rather than serving as impetus for reform, they were utilised as instruments of mobilisation and perpetual justification for economic hardship. Society bore the cost of decisions it did not make, and daily life grew heavier under accumulated burdens.</p><p>Because of the Iranian Islamic Revolution, Iran, Iraq, Syria, Yemen and Lebanon were transformed into theatres of direct or indirect confrontation. The Gulf region endured continuous security tension and threats to navigation and energy infrastructure. Borders closed, airspace was restricted, schools and public institutions halted during escalations, and entire economies deteriorated within an environment defined by prolonged instability.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FJmIJffNsWrA%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DJmIJffNsWrA&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FJmIJffNsWrA%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/ad91091ccedb8ffcf3b94bbb3a5f7c67/href">https://medium.com/media/ad91091ccedb8ffcf3b94bbb3a5f7c67/href</a></iframe><p>Because of the Iranian Islamic Revolution, the Strait of Hormuz became a permanent global flashpoint. Escalation there reverberates immediately through global energy markets, generating repeated oil price shocks that directly affect food and commodity costs worldwide and increase economic fragility across the region.</p><p>Because of the Iranian Islamic Revolution, Iran’s nuclear programme expanded, triggering sweeping international sanctions across oil, banking and trade sectors. Relations with the West deteriorated from the outset, beginning with the 1979 hostage crisis at the United States Embassy in Tehran. A sustained cycle of sanctions, pressure and retaliation followed, rendering tension a near-permanent condition rather than an exception.</p><p>Because of the Iranian Islamic Revolution, armed proxies outside the framework of the nation-state were consolidated, most prominently Hezbollah in Lebanon. The organisation evolved beyond a domestic political actor into a component of a regional project linked to Tehran, its influence exceeding the limits of Lebanese state institutions. <a href="https://english.alarabiya.net/News/middle-east/2013/05/27/Old-video-comes-back-to-haunt-Hezbollah-chief-Nasrallah"><strong>Its Secretary-General publicly affirmed that his ideological and political allegiance is bound to Iran and its Supreme Leader</strong></a>, underscoring the structural alignment between the movement and the Iranian project beyond national sovereignty.</p><p>Because of the Iranian Islamic Revolution, the project extended beyond political and military influence into transnational illicit financial networks. Through its proxies, it became associated with drug trafficking and money laundering operations across multiple continents.</p><p>Because of the Iranian Islamic Revolution, Hezbollah developed into a regional arm with global reach, accused in American, European and Latin American security reports of involvement in cocaine trafficking networks from South America to Africa and Europe, using proceeds to finance military operations.</p><p>Because of the Iranian Islamic Revolution, networks emerged in Venezuela, Brazil and Paraguay within the so-called Tri-Border Area, where activities linked to individuals associated with Hezbollah were documented in money laundering and drug trafficking cases through repeated indictments and sanctions.</p><p>Because of the Iranian Islamic Revolution, the Gulf became a recurring destination for large-scale drug shipments. Hundreds of millions of Captagon tablets and tonnes of hashish were seized at ports and border crossings. Certain networks were linked to actors aligned with Tehran’s axis, transforming narcotics into instruments of financing and leverage that undermine societies from within, drain their youth and exert sustained security and economic pressure.</p><p>Because of the Iranian Islamic Revolution, harm extended directly into Western states through proxy-linked trafficking networks as well as security operations, bombings and assassinations attributed to affiliated actors over past decades in Europe and Latin America.</p><p>Because of the Iranian Islamic Revolution, the then Supreme Leader <em>Ruhollah Mousavi Khomeini</em> issued a fatwa in 1989 calling for the killing of the British writer Salman Rushdie over “The Satanic Verses”. <br>The decree — فتوى was never formally withdrawn, and its substance was reaffirmed by Iranian religious authorities. Incitement and religious rulings were also directed against Western cartoonists and writers over satirical depictions, transforming intellectual dispute into direct threat.</p><p>Because of the Iranian Islamic Revolution, gallows were erected in public squares and extensive executions carried out. Kurdish regions experienced violent repression; thousands of dissidents were executed over decades. Women faced strict restrictions; girls were killed or detained over alleged hijab violations, embedding a climate of social fear.</p><p>Because of the Iranian Islamic Revolution, executions extended beyond a single ethnicity and became a political and security instrument applied across society. Iran consequently ranks among the highest countries globally in annual execution rates.</p><p>Because of the Iranian Islamic Revolution, tens of thousands of Afghans were recruited into formations such as the Fatemiyoun Brigade, and Iraqis into multiple armed factions, deployed beyond their own borders, particularly in Syria. Vast numbers were killed or wounded in conflicts driven by a transnational military project.</p><p>Because of the Iranian Islamic Revolution, the cost was not merely maps of influence, speeches and militias; the cost was homes broken one by one. In Yemen, in Syria, in Iraq, in Lebanon and across the Gulf, families lost sons and daughters. Children endured hunger, disease and fear. Women were widowed; children orphaned; permanent disabilities became the fate of bodies that chose nothing. This is not a footnote to geopolitics. It is the lived reality of millions whose lives were reshaped by the conflicts that followed.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2F0JgblBcw6Uc%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3D0JgblBcw6Uc&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2F0JgblBcw6Uc%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/ad42671b89966180d58268ddb2ca3aee/href">https://medium.com/media/ad42671b89966180d58268ddb2ca3aee/href</a></iframe><p>The intellectual double standard displayed by segments of the Western left has reached a striking level. We are expected to remain silent about everything that has occurred — and continues to occur — in both the Middle East and beyond, simply because the United States and Israel oppose Iran politically or militarily. As though geopolitical rivalry with Washington or Tel Aviv were sufficient to grant Tehran moral absolution, erasing decades of intervention, repression and ideological incitement, along with their visible and invisible consequences for millions of people.</p><p>This selective blindness ignores the exclusionary character of the Iranian Islamic regime, which has constructed its legitimacy on dividing the world into believers and adversaries, denouncing opponents as illegitimate, and escalating confrontational rhetoric toward the West in general and toward Israel and Jews in particular. Slogans of elimination, erasure and existential struggle have been amplified over decades, accompanied by political narratives that frame conflict not as policy disagreement but as sacred confrontation.</p><p>At the same time, terminology such as “<strong><em>Islamophobia</em></strong>” has frequently been deployed in political debate in ways that blur the distinction between legitimate criticism of a ruling system and hostility toward a religion or its adherents. The result has often been the insulation of state policy from scrutiny by conflating political accountability with religious prejudice.<br>One cannot ignore the rhetorical universe that accompanied the Iranian Islamic Revolution and spread through its ideological messaging over the decades. Alongside narratives framed around “Islamophobia”, the language of confrontation was amplified through slogans that became widely recognisable across the region and beyond — calls to “<strong><em>wipe Israel off the map</em></strong>” and chants about “<strong><em>throwing the Jews into the sea</em></strong>” circulated within the broader climate of revolutionary mobilisation. Such rhetoric helped transform political conflict into an existential struggle framed in religious and ideological terms, reinforcing a worldview in which compromise was portrayed as surrender and confrontation as historical duty.</p><p>Meanwhile, the reality of Hezbollah in Lebanon is frequently overlooked. An ideologically closed organisation that recruits exclusively from within the Shi’a community while presenting itself as a “Lebanese national resistance,” it is structurally and doctrinally aligned with Iran’s leadership. Its former Secretary-General repeatedly articulated a political vision tied to an Islamic project extending beyond Lebanese sovereignty and oriented toward the authority of Iran’s Supreme Leader. Yet its flags are displayed in Western cities, and it finds vocal supporters abroad — despite its role in political paralysis, armed intervention and the deepening suffering experienced by millions in Lebanon, Syria and Iraq.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FcuNSGuhOMbk%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DcuNSGuhOMbk&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FcuNSGuhOMbk%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="640" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/97cdde2a493eb1aa23e208d20dfbd1b8/href">https://medium.com/media/97cdde2a493eb1aa23e208d20dfbd1b8/href</a></iframe><p>The issue is not whether American or Israeli policies should be criticised. The issue is the transformation of that criticism into a shield that obscures another record of repression, intervention and incitement. Moral consistency demands that no state or movement be exempt from scrutiny merely because it stands in opposition to a shared adversary. The suffering of millions across the region cannot be dismissed as collateral to ideological alignment.</p><p>And yet behind the language of austerity and resistance stood a far harsher reality.</p><p><strong>Did Ali Khamenei live modestly?</strong><br>Yes — a few.. dollars in his personal account, while millions across Iran, Syria, Iraq, Yemen and Lebanon paid the price of the system he helped build.<br><strong>Did he reject luxury?</strong><br>Yes — the simplicity of the ruler who sat above a vast landscape of broken cities, shattered families and unmarked graves stretching from Tehran to Taiz.<br><strong>Was he steadfast under pressure?</strong><br>Yes — he remained in place through every crisis, every sanction, every war, leaving behind generations condemned to live under the shadow of conflicts that consumed lands and lives alike.<br>History will record the image often repeated by his admirers: a leader who claimed austerity. But history will also record the other ledger — the lives spent, the homes destroyed and the region left to carry the weight of that legacy.</p><p>We are not finished — and we will not be finished. The generations that come after us will remember this, and they will feel, sadly, the consequences of the Islamic Revolution in Iran as we have felt them, perhaps even more intensely.</p><p>We have not yet spoken about the deep psychological scars left by years of repression, wars and chronic fear; about societies raised under the shadow of permanent threat, and about children who grew up knowing nothing but the language of emergency, incitement and division. We have not addressed the social repercussions that tore families apart, the homes divided between exile, prison and grave, nor the destinies of millions that shifted abruptly from stability to an uncertain future.</p><p>We have not spoken of the humiliation of forced displacement, the bitterness of exile, or the suffering of those compelled to flee Iran or the countries set ablaze by its interventions. We have not described the ordeals of long journeys across deserts, forests and seas; the fragile boats, the sealed borders, the degrading wait in temporary camps in search of a place of safety.</p><p>These are not marginal details. They are the human faces of a much larger story. And the consequences of 1979 remain unfinished — written not only in the politics of states, but in the lives of millions who continue to live with its aftermath.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b134ba7fa2f5" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Absurdity of Algerian Reparation Claims.. from Enslavers to Victims!]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@rami_zahra/the-absurdity-of-algerian-reparation-claims-from-enslavers-to-victims-288476fd82a2?source=rss-5d95452aa4e4------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/288476fd82a2</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[france]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[enslavement]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[algeria]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[selective-reparations]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[algerian-myths]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Rami Zahra]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 06 Feb 2026 01:00:25 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-02-06T01:00:25.502Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>“Slavery in North Africa was not peripheral; it was systemic, public, and economically central.” — Robert C. Davis.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/570/1*xmL96b5d9CQhokUONQd8EQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>An eighteenth-century European engraving depicting the march of European captives into slavery in Algiers after their disembarkation from ships, providing visual documentation of the stage preceding sale or forced labour. Jan Luyken — Rijksmuseum — Amsterdam. Rijksmuseum — Amsterdam</figcaption></figure><p>On 24 December 2025, the Algerian parliament unanimously approved a law declaring France’s colonisation of Algeria, which lasted 132 years, a crime. The Algerian state also demands a formal apology and reparations from France. More alarmingly, the same law stipulates prison sentences for any Algerian who speaks positively about the French colonial period or makes any “statements with colonial connotations.” We are thus confronted with a blatant model of selective outrage: the legal condemnation of history, the criminalisation of opinion, and a coercive attempt to shut down any discussion that does not serve the official narrative.</p><p>Yes, France colonised Algeria for more than a century, but it is impossible to ignore that it introduced what did not previously exist: state administration, infrastructure, institutions, technology, medicine, and, in a single word, modernisation. This is precisely why the new law criminalises any positive discussion of that period, as many Algerians — especially among older generations — still acknowledge these realities. In addition, France granted its former colony priority in migration, allowing millions of Algerians to move there and pursue a better life, as a form of tangible, practical redress rather than rhetorical posturing.</p><p>By contrast, a question emerges that the official Algerian discourse deliberately avoids: what has Algeria done to atone for centuries of crimes committed on its territory against Europeans, including the French?<br> For more than three hundred years, from the sixteenth century until the early nineteenth century, North Africa thrived on the enslavement of Europeans. According to the conservative estimate provided by the <a href="https://www.bbc.co.uk/history/british/empire_seapower/white_slaves_01.shtml"><strong>American historian Robert Davis</strong></a>, between 1530 and 1780 approximately one million — and possibly as many as one and a quarter million — white European Christians were enslaved by the Barbary Coast pirates.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1014/1*iSVjUUHaqyWd9CkjHT_V-A.png" /></figure><p>No part of Europe’s coastline was truly safe from these raids. Between 1627 and 1633, pirates occupied Lundy Island off the west coast of Britain, from which they raided England at will. In 1627, they attacked Denmark and even distant Iceland, abducting around 800 people. <br>In 1631, the fishing village of Baltimore in Ireland was raided, and according to an early source, “237 persons, men, women, and children, even infants in the cradle,” were captured and transported to the miserable slave markets of North Africa, the most notorious and largest of which — ironically — was centred in Algiers itself.</p><p>Read more:</p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@rami_zahra/slavery-and-servitude-in-islam-from-the-middle-ages-to-isis-386b39913ae0">“Slavery and servitude in Islam: From the Middle Ages to ‘ISIS.’”</a></p><p>What these captives endured defies description: forced labour in quarries with severe shortages of food and water, chains on the oars of Ottoman galleys, beatings until exhaustion and death. Women and girls were sold into concubinage and subjected to sexual exploitation, as were not a few boys and even men. With vast numbers of European women sold for paltry sums, European observers in the late eighteenth century remarked that “the inhabitants of Algiers have a rather noticeably white complexion.” Those who resisted or dared to criticise Islam or Muslims — especially Muhammad — were punished by impalement or being roasted alive, or thrown from city walls onto sharp iron hooks to die. These were not rare exceptions, but a documented and recurring pattern in contemporary accounts.</p><p>The United States did not escape either. <br>In 1785, Algerian pirates captured two American vessels. Given the torture, religious coercion, and sexual abuse inflicted upon Christian slaves, Captain O’Brian was not exaggerating when he later wrote to Thomas Jefferson that their suffering was beyond expression. Jefferson himself reported, in a letter to Congress in 1786 after meeting with John Adams and an Algerian envoy, that the justification for these wars and enslavement was presented as a religious duty written in the Qur’an, rather than a response to any aggression.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*3qN9Ss9c7HnAz7IC44GbsA.png" /></figure><p>Nor was piracy launched from Algiers confined to coastal villages. Throughout the seventeenth century it systematically targeted European merchant shipping, particularly Dutch and English vessels. Hundreds of ships belonging to major trading companies were intercepted in the Mediterranean and even the Atlantic, their crews enslaved, cargoes seized, and exorbitant ransoms demanded from governments or families. Port records and maritime insurance archives in Amsterdam and London show that Algerian piracy was not random banditry but a structured economy built on human abduction and state-level extortion, to the extent that some trade routes had to be altered or permanently escorted by armed convoys. The sailors targeted were civilians and merchants, not soldiers, which fatally undermines any later attempt to portray these acts as “resistance” or “responses to aggression.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*9oTAOftEjqIUQusS_-uNKw.jpeg" /><figcaption>A British print from 1816 titled <em>“Christian Slavery at Algiers”</em>, depicting Captain Croker’s visit to a hospital in Algiers with testimonies of years of enslavement, alongside a scene of chained Christian captives driven home after forced labour and flogged — providing direct visual documentation of the contemporary slave system.© The Trustees of the British Museum.</figcaption></figure><p>When examining the geography of Mediterranean slave trading, it becomes clear that Algiers was not merely one node in a broader network but its most active and central hub, far surpassing Tripoli and Tunis. While all three ports participated in raids and enslavement, Algiers distinguished itself by the scale of its market, the number of captives, the regularity of operations, and its direct integration into Ottoman administration. Thousands of European captives passed through Algiers each year, redistributed into forced labour, galley service, construction, internal sale, or export. Tripoli and Tunis, by contrast, remained less intensive in both volume and organisation. This is precisely why Algiers appears most frequently in European diplomatic correspondence concerning ransoms, maritime threats, and navigation security, reflecting its true position at the centre of this system rather than on its margins.</p><p>Faced with this reality, Europe did not treat Algerian piracy as a series of isolated incidents but as a persistent threat requiring legal, political, and military responses. Dozens of bilateral treaties were concluded with Algiers, involving annual tributes, official gifts, or mass ransom payments in exchange for the release of captives. When these measures failed, several states resorted to force, including Britain, the Netherlands, Spain, and eventually the United States during the Barbary Wars. These episodes demonstrate that even as Europe later achieved naval superiority, it was for decades compelled to buy peace with money — an implicit acknowledgement that these raids constituted organised extortion rather than a symmetrical conflict.</p><p>Despite all this, Algeria today positions itself as a moral lecturer to Western societies, branding France a “criminal” coloniser and demanding “reparations,” while overlooking the fact that France originally invaded Algeria, in a striking historical irony, to put an end to the slave markets that had flourished there for centuries. Indeed, Algiers was arguably the worst of all Muslim centres of European enslavement, holding tens of thousands of slaves at any given time and leaving devastation across the coasts of France, Italy, and Spain.</p><p>This argument does not stem from a defence of France nor from an absolution of its colonial past, but from a categorical rejection of falsehood, historical distortion, and moral selectivity. Genuine demands for apology or compensation rest on non-negotiable foundations: fixed figures, documented records, named victims, graves, archives, and clearly attributable historical responsibility. These are the standards invoked globally when discussing recognition or redress. In the Algerian case, however, we encounter a political discourse built on fluctuating and inflated numbers, without official registers, lists of names, burial sites, or a single verifiable document, combined with a crude selectivity that targets one historical actor while deliberately erasing the rest.</p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@rami_zahra/how-the-lie-of-algerian-martyrs-snowballed-from-one-million-to-five-million-as-counted-by-the-8dab62dd16e5">How the Lie of “Algerian Martyrs” Snowballed from One Million to Five Million as Counted by the…</a></p><p>By the same logic Algeria now invokes, it should — if sincere in its reparations discourse — open the entire historical file without selectivity. Algeria was under Ottoman rule for nearly four centuries, a period that was neither “protection” nor “partnership” but full political, military, and economic subjugation. Tens of thousands of Algerians were forcibly conscripted into Ottoman wars in the Balkans, Europe, and the Mediterranean; the country’s human and economic resources were drained for Istanbul’s benefit; and Algeria was used as a naval base in conflicts that produced killing, captivity, and widespread destruction. The unavoidable question is therefore: why does Algeria not demand compensation for those centuries and those lives? And why is there no call today directed at Turkey, as the political and legal successor to the Ottoman Empire, for apology, compensation, or even historical acknowledgement?</p><p>Instead, demands are directed exclusively at France, despite the fact that — unlike the Ottomans — it left behind a modern state structure, institutions, infrastructure, administration, education, and healthcare, and opened its doors to millions of Algerians who today constitute its largest foreign community, enjoying rights of residence, employment, and citizenship, while France continues to bear economic and social burdens directly linked to this shared history. Turkey, by contrast, does not receive Algerians as “victims of Ottoman occupation,” offers no preferential policies, no compensation, and no official debate on that period, which is instead presented in official discourse as a “caliphate” or “protection,” not an occupation.</p><p>Here the double standard is exposed without disguise: occupation is condemned when European and excused or beautified when Islamic. Accordingly, the reparations discourse in this form represents neither a moral stance nor a serious historical reading, but a selectively deployed political instrument aimed at one party while deliberately discarding the rest of the historical record. If Algeria demands reparations from France in the name of history, then history itself — taken seriously — demands that it first ask: where are the Ottoman reparations, and where is the apology from their heirs?</p><p>Finally, on the subject of reparations, between 1795 and 1800 the United States was forced to spend 16% of its entire annual federal budget on ransom payments to Algiers to secure the release of American sailors and purchase a few years of peace, before Algerian demands escalated again and the First Barbary War broke out. By Algeria’s own logic, should it not therefore be paying reparations to the United States?</p><blockquote>-Algerian parliamentary discourse and the December 2025 law (official texts and associated statements).<br>-Robert C. Davis, Christian Slaves, Muslim Masters: White Slavery in the Mediterranean, the Barbary Coast, and Italy, 1500–1800, Palgrave Macmillan, 2003.<br>-Des Ekin, The Stolen Village: Baltimore and the Barbary Pirates, O’Brien Press, 2006.<br>-Contemporary European testimonies compiled in multiple historical works on the treatment of captives in Ottoman Algiers.<br>-Thomas Jefferson and John Adams, letter to John Jay, 28 March 1786, U.S. National Archives (Founders Online).<br>-British Library archival records on the occupation of Lundy Island, 1627–1633.<br>-Port and maritime insurance records from Amsterdam and London, seventeenth century.<br>-Comparative studies on Algiers, Tripoli, and Tunis within Mediterranean slave trading networks.<br>-INSEE (France), demographic data on Algerian migration to France.<br>-U.S. Department of State, records on the Barbary Wars and federal expenditures, 1795–1800.<br>-Ottoman archival studies on North Africa, 1518–1830.<br>-French archival records on the invasion of Algiers, 1830.</blockquote><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=288476fd82a2" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>