<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Ransom H. Love on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Ransom H. Love on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@ransomhlove?source=rss-c44b575286b0------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sat, 21 Nov 2026 13:15:18 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@ransomhlove/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Love of Linux Chapter 15: Lessons Learned]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@ransomhlove/the-love-of-linux-chapter-15-lessons-learned-9d6281a1352b?source=rss-c44b575286b0------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9d6281a1352b</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[linux]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[entrepreneurship]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[tech]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ransom H. Love]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 24 Feb 2016 22:40:56 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-02-24T22:40:56.561Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>When we went on the MBA trip to the Orient, after visiting Korea, Japan, Hong Kong and mainland China, encountering many cultures, business’ and ways of doing business, our host professors got all of the students into a room and had us put all of our impressions and ideas from the trip on a couple of easels. The entitled the session “R”essons “R”earned. A common trait in all Asian cultures is that they have a hard time pronouncing “L”s in English. Instead of the “L” they would almost always say an “R”. Since we were there to observe such commonalities among cultures and businesses, our professors had captured a common speech trait in all the Asian cultures we had visited. I for one had learned more in that trip than the entire two years of schooling. Some may say that without the schooling, I would not have been perceptive enough to see and absorb as much. I do not doubt the truthfulness of that statement, but I learn from seeing and doing. This trip to the Orient made an important impression on me and the session we held did help to capture in my mind many of the items I had learned.</p><p>The eight years I was involved in the commercialization of Linux has had even more impact on my life. We were truly privileged to be in the middle of a truly disruptive technology that has and will change the industry and the world. We were privileged to see behind the corporate curtain and see the bowels of the Industry. We were in the board rooms and saw and heard much more than what was publically made available. Much of what we saw and experienced was incredibly negative. My attempt in including some of that information in this book was not to dwell on the negative but to shine a light on the learning which was priceless to obtain. The lessons learned were far more painful and yet at the same time more enjoyable and rich. As human beings, we unfortunately seem to learn more from negative experiences than from positive. We were incredibly privileged. So much happened in these years and Caldera was in a totally unique position in the formation of the industry. We were able to dance with the giants and see many of the forces at work. In addition, while many books have been written on some of the lessons that can be learned from Linux that I included in this book when I wrote the first draft nearly 10 years ago, the impact of Linux and Open Source have not fully reached their apex. The far reaching affects of free have not been fully felt by the economy or even in the digital market place. For example, the pressure to deliver products and services for free or next to free will continue for all things digital as Chris Anderson stated, but they will spread to non-dgitial industries because of increased globalization, innovation and competition. Similarly, the motivations of why people want to contribute to Linux have yet to be fully explored in a business setting as many of the principals can and should be applied in these highly competitive times. Developing people, platforms and partners may be the only effective way to compete long term.</p><p>Having been privileged to participate in the process of trying to making Linux a business success, I would like to reiterate and share some of Ressons Rearned in hopes that they might help others trying to navigate through the business world many call and we can personally attest is a vicious jungle.</p><p>We did not achieve what we set out to achieve, primarily because of lack of leadership at a critical time, but we did lay the foundations for the commercialization of Linux. We had helped create an industry and participated in something that is changing the world. However, the real benefits of Linux and Open-Source have yet to be realized. The real business benefits do not lie in the great operating system or Open Source Licenses. The real benefit lies in the Lessons that can be learned from Linux and Open-Source and how they can be applied to business. As I mentioned in the text, new books and studies have and will continue to come out proving that business has fundamentally changed as a result of the Internet and Open Source. Open source and the Internet are symbiotic. They fuel each other. The Internet provides the collaboration environment and the open source technology like Linux facilitates broader distribution of the Internet by making it economically feasible that in turns creates a broader community to collaborate. This symbiotic platform also breaks down traditional barriers in distribution that disrupts underlying businesses assumptions and paradigms. It also attacks businesses that do not evolve and embrace the new paradigm.</p><p>As well documented in the book “The Long Tail” and “Free: The Future of a Radical Price,” these technologies will fundamentally change the way we do business and interact with each other on a global basis. The real benefit, however, is not the technology or how it is developed, but the principles behind it. Open source, collaboration, the Internet and the constantly doubling of technology, frees the power of the individual. When only the few and the privileged could get published; now nearly every one can. When a company learns to truly unlock the full capacity and imagination of their people, enabling them to do the right thing at the right time for the right reason, they will allow them the freedom to pursue their dreams without forcing them up a corporate ladder. The company that achieves this will create a new paradigm and thrive in the brave new world. The lessons of Linux go far beyond how to develop great technology, they are lessons for how to survive and thrive in an entirely new world. Someday, the world will point back to this paradigm and recognize it as being a fundamental shift of similar significance as the Industrial revolution. Nearly all of us at Caldera believed that Linux was more than just a great technology. Those who worked to make that vision come true were for ever changed by the experience and we did indirectly have had a major influence on an industry and the world.</p><p><em>Follow Your Heart or Reach for the Unreachable Star</em></p><p>My father and I both loved the play Man of La Mancha. Don Quixote, though many thought was crazy, pursued a dream, he followed his heart. In the process, he changed lives, both his and others. The book Built To Last refers studies the businesses that have lasted over 100 years. Everyone of them was driven by a Big Harry Audacious Goal or BHAG, something that compelled and motivated everyone in the company. The BHAG in many ways defined the company and created the culture. I heard Dick Williams, former CEO of Digital Research and current CEO of Wily, say once that he tells his employees if they have a chance to change the world, they need to take it no matter what. He said he has had a couple of times where things he worked on have made a major impact on the world and it has made all the difference in his life. I could not agree with him more.</p><p>One of the pitfalls in pursuing a dream is to become fanatical. I believe that the essence and safety in life is containing in the principle no more and no less. Many people become fanatical around causes. They get caught up in the moment or the movement itself. They become infatuated with a certain idea or concept and exclude the whole. Soon the idea or concept becomes all consuming. Others do too little. They get caught in tradition and in the way things have always been. They find it very hard to change or except change. In fact, they often fight it because it seems to threaten them. The power of Linux and open source is not just about business, it is about change.</p><p>Nearly everyone who started out with Caldera in the beginning did so because they felt almost compelled to do so. Most of them were not fanatics, they just saw in Linux a chance to change the industry. They had seen how the industry had come under the strangle hold of a monopoly power. That power had misused the term business to be “the end justifies the means.” The sad thing that I have witnessed in “Business” is that most of the companies who criticize the “monopoly” are only jealous that it is not their company who has the industry paying tribute to them. They nearly all conduct their business in the same way, “the end justifies the means.” The other way to categorize this philosophy of business is win/loose. If you win, I loose because there are limited resources. Hence, I must do everything in my power to see that I win at any cost. The fallacy of this model is it is based on a fallacious premise that resources are limited. The reality is that the resources of the mind are infinite.</p><p>Many of those who rallied around Linux saw it as a way to fundamentally change the industry. Some have inaccurately felt that it was “business” that was the evil empire or that commerce is fundamentally bad. Because of the examples that are so rampant in industry, I hardly blame them for coming to that conclusion. However, it is a false one. Business and financial success can and does corrupt. The age old saying: “Power corrupts, and absolute power corrupts absolutely;” seems to be what most blindly pursue in business but not always. True business is captured in Charles Dickens “A Christmas Carol.” In the interview between Scrooge and his deceased business partner Jacob Marley. Scrooge tries to console Jacob by stating that he had been a very good businessman. Jacob Marley’s response I have found to be the truth about business “Mankind should have been my business.”</p><p>I have been criticized over the years by some who are more fanatical in their views as a parasite on open source, because I wanted to make Linux a successful business platform. Their criticism, I believe comes the fact that many businesses are not what true business should be. True business should be something in which all parties involved in a transaction are made better off. Some have called this win-win-win. There are many misconceptions that abound and are even taught in major business and legal schools and negotiation classes around the world that if someone wins, you loose. In a win/lose negotiation, everyone looses.</p><p>Those in the Open Source community, who feel that those who have tried to create successful business out of Linux and other open source initiatives are parasites, fail to understand that in order to have the freedom to continue to develop; you must have enough financial success to maintain your independence. Someone has to pay the bill. Collaborative work can produce technology, but producing and successfully marketing products and solutions takes some money. The beauty of capitalism is that it allows the individual to reap the rewards of his efforts and thus maintain self-respect and independence. Socialism is forced, legally enforced sharing. This breeds mediocrity and enslavement. If Linux cannot be self sustaining as an Industry, it will be dependent upon the products that do make money or it will become a niche solution. Nearly all of the Linux distribution companies have spent millions of dollars promoting Linux. I am not aware of any Linux company that is getting rich off of Linux, even Red Hat has made very little in comparison with other companies that have been market leaders in the past. Making money is not bad because it allows Linux to be self-sustaining and independent. Some feel that it is ok to make money on the services. The problem with services alone is that they do not scale. As the software industry moves towards online maintenance and subscription services, that look and feel a lot like products, then Linux and Open Source will have a sustainable business model. But just doing professional services and support will not be enough to fuel any kind of significant growth in the Linux Industry. The challenge for Linux may be that the larger players, IBM and Oracle, may not want a Linux company to become too successful because they fear having to deal with another Microsoft.</p><p>We had a dream to change the world to improve our industry and provide an alternative operating platform. We felt open source could play a vital role in that change. While Caldera, now SCO, changed its course and did not reach its potential, Caldera, the Linux developers and other Linux vendors did change the world. The vision for making Linux the predominate ISV platform in the industry that we had at Caldera is being realized. A recent Gartner report entitled “2006 Predictions: The Effects of Open-Source Software on the IT Software Industry” states:</p><ul><li>By 2010, 90 percent of Global 2000 organizations will have formal open-source acquisition and management strategies (0.8 probability).</li><li>By 2008, OSS solutions will directly compete with closed-source products in all software infrastructure markets (0.8 probability).</li><li>By 2010, open source will be included in mission-critical software portfolios within 75 percent of Global 2000 enterprises (0.7 probability).</li><li>By 2008, 70 percent of Unix ISVs will make Linux the first priority port (0.8 probability).</li></ul><p>We staged a major evolution. Caldera or SCO did not stick it out to reap the benefits of their labors, but the collective Open Source team made up of those very talented individuals at Caldera, other Linux providers and throughout the industry made a significant contribution that has yet been fully realized. We pursued a dream that has and will continue to change the world. I believe the principles Open-Source has and will teach the industry may cause change far more profound than even the software and open-source development techniques every will. When we can capture the true power of individuals by empowering them and enabling them to be the best they can, real business can and will take place. You have to follow your heart and allow others to do the same.</p><p><em>You sow what you reap</em></p><p>Business is and always will be about people, trust and the relationships formed in the course of doing business. Those who walk away from a win-loose negotiation temporarily on the win side may walk away with more money (sometimes millions of dollars) in the short term, but they will be the poorer in the end. They walk away having betrayed themselves and their own humanity. They fail to realize that there is another eternal, unbreakable truth called the law of the harvest. That law states that what you sow, you will eventually reap. I have tragically watched men sell their souls, or maybe more accurately, their humanity to the all mighty dollar. They violate friendship, trust, and integrity, simply to get more money or achieve their goal at all costs. Some think it weak to approach a business transaction, honestly. To sincerely try to negotiate a fair and equitable contract or business arrangement, will only result in someone taking advantage of you. Many misinformed and misguided businessman will take advantage, as Caldera was taken advantage of over the years. While it is a truly vanishing trait, may I simply state that it is not weakness but strength to be honest in all your dealings. I salute those who still can conduct their business affairs on a handshake because of their inner integrity. I have come in contact with a few of these men and women in business and they are like diamonds in a sea of coal. Rather than succumbing to the pressure of doing poor business, because everyone else is, they have let that pressure bring out the integrity of their soul.</p><p>The biggest mistake of business, whether as a buyer, seller or employer or employee, is that we like to create a separate standard. The phrase, “business is business” or “that’s business” as if business were a different standard, is a lie. Mankind is our business. Many in business want to treat partners, employees, and employers as something to satisfy their own selfish desires rather than as truly human beings. They do not allow the people around them to be human, only instruments to achieve a goal. Nowhere is this more dramatically displayed than in Scrooge’s treatment of Bob Crachet before and after his change in heart brought about by his interaction with the three spirits.</p><p>There are no short cuts. Some feel that business is business or what ever you do is ok as long as it is legal or you don’t get caught. What is morally correct or basically treating others, employees, customers or business relationships the way you would want to be treated is old fashion, naïve or out of date. Another way to put it is the end justifies the means. Another way to couch this philosophy is that there are no absolutes in life. I have listened to some of our top politicians stand up and ridicule anyone that believes in absolutes. Fortunately, history and science are proving the existence and importance of absolutes. The 10 commandments are not suggestions. They are the foundation of a happy productive life. The reality is that no matter how technology is changing our world and will yet change our world, we will always deal and interact with people. There is nothing out there worth losing your integrity to obtain. The industry and the economy are too small to burn bridges. Being able to sleep at nights is priceless. Knowing that while people may not like you or what you do, they know that you are doing the best you can with what information you have. As every parent will tell you, it is not about being liked by others, it is about maintaining their trust through your own integrity.</p><p>As I look back on the nine plus years I have been involved with Linux and Open Source, it is the people was privileged to know like Ray Noorda, Linus Torvalds, Jon “Maddog” Hall, Mark Bolzern, Ted Cook, Bob Frankenburg, Bob Young, and countless others that I have learned from and had the privilege to associate with. Even more it is the dear friends that I have worked with Ed Donakey, Dean Taylor, Nick Wells, Benoy Tamang, Kenneth Bergenthal, Bob Bench, Kathy Martens, Stefan Provast, Ralf Flaxa and all who participated in making the Caldera dream a reality. I cherish the memories and the friendships that were forged in pursuing the dream. At the end of the day, it is all about people and the relationships you form. Real wealth lies in the relationships and not the money. What you sow, you will reap.</p><p><em>The Negative Things in Life are Just a Nudge in the Right Direction</em></p><p>Often times it is from the negative things in life that we either learn the most, or it is only through them that certain positive things can happen to us. Caldera never would have become a company if Novell had completed the Corsair product. I would have never been the President and CEO of the company if the company had not split over economic pressures. I do not think that the Linux companies would have voluntarily come together to form UnitedLinux if the economy had not taken a turn for the worse. Sometimes the reason for the bumps that forces you to change direction in your life is not always apparent for many years to come, but I have come to realize that there is very little chance in life. Everything has a purpose. The real key is to have the right attitude so that you can see the purpose and stay the course.</p><p>Caldera put Red Hat on the map and yet Caldera would have never have gone public if Red Hat had not gone public first. Sometimes the reason behind the events is apparent almost immediately. Other times it takes more than a life time, but always they become apparent in time. Some may take this principle to an extreme and think that if something happens to either good or bad; it is a direct result of their actions. Sometimes things just happen. You really have so little control in life over what happens to you, but you have total control over how you will react. If you can look at set backs, not as obstacles or disappointments but as opportunities to adjust, or recommit, life and every dream you pursue becomes an adventure. The Mother Superior in Sound of Music states that whenever the Lord closes a door, He opens a window. The challenge in life and business is to keep looking for the window.</p><p><em>The industry has fundamentally changed</em></p><p>The book “Who Moved My Cheese” by Spencer Johnson is a great, thought provoking book. It points out that it is quite common to get accustomed to finding cheese in a certain place and ignore the fact that the supply of cheese is dwindling. Almost overnight, we wake up to find that the cheese is gone. There are many signs that go unnoticed that indicate the cheese is being depleted. I believe that Linux, Open Source and the Internet have fundamentally shifted where the cheese is. It is not evident to everyone, because they are still finding cheese in the traditional places, but the main supply is found somewhere else. Books like “The Long Tail” by Chris Anderson are starting to document the change in distribution methods, but more importantly, they are indicating the potential consequences of the physical changes. Our very culture is evolving quite rapidly. How we purchase, from where and what is available will shape the products and services of tomorrow. To quote Chris Anderson’s phrase, “the ants have megaphones.”</p><p>The ability to reach and understand the customer in new and profound ways is almost mind boggling but also life saving if you are a business who desires to survive and thrive. Thus, the ramifications of that change in what products and services must be produced in order to be successful are even more profound. How and what those products and services are or can become are also greatly enhanced because of Linux and Open Source. Linux and the commodity class PC have made the building blocks of technology affordable and flexible enough to greatly facilitate innovation and production. Chris in his book speaks of three major forces for change: 1) Democratization of production, 2) Democratization of distribution and 3) The ability find what you want. The democratization of production is simply anyone can now publish themselves without needing a publisher or label company. The democratization of distribution means anyone can be a supplier as long as they have a server or access to one. Linux and Open Source have played one of if not the most vital role in each of these major forces. Open Source has enabled very complex computer problems to become commoditized. The power of computing has been brought to the masses facilitating the spread of the Internet more broadly than thought possible. Linux and Apache are the very backbone and building blocks of the web. They have given voice and access to thousands because they have enabled inexpensive hardware to become the fabric of a global network. Without this infrastructure the democratization of production and distribution could not have taken place or continue to do so. This inexpensive extension of the Internet has allowed the masses to get on the net regardless of nationality or economic background and begin to express their views facilitating Chris’ third major force the ability to find what you want. Linux and Open Source are facilitating the development of the massive search engines that connect all the production to the micro cultures desiring specialization through this global network. These search engines are connecting what used to be totally disparate systems and data together and enabling the linking of separate data sources in the matter of seconds. This incredible freedom of expression and the fulfillment of individual, personal interests and needs are fundamentally changing our culture and how we interact with each other.</p><p>Communication systems like wireless and satellite are greatly reduced in costs because of Linux and Open Source enabling us to remain connected no matter where we are. I am sitting on a bus commuting to Salt Lake as I write this book. At the same time, I am doing my emails from work. Nearly 1/3 to ½ of my fellow passengers have laptops, Treos or some other device they are working on that are connected to the Internet. Linux and Open Source enable many of these devices or the servers they talk to. From somewhat small and seemingly insignificant things, great and almost unimaginable things are accomplished. The world has shrunk. We are all connected in ways we could have never imagined. Software and services are being developed using this infrastructure that will further break down cultural, geographic and even traditional economic barriers and social impediments. People are being empowered. The world is becoming of the people, for the people and by the people. This of course will scare many individuals and organizations who insist on control or believe that people are incapable of governing themselves. Linux and Open Source is the catalyst for this new age of expression for without them, the costs would be prohibitive. I cannot even begin to paint the picture of the extent of the change and forces Linux and Open Source have unleashed. They are like a genie that has been uncorked that is granting wishes all over the world. This is just what Linux has done for technology. The world has changed dramatically but the physical surroundings appear the same so few really see that things are totally different. The following quote from Tim O’Reilly underscores the subtlety of the evolution occurring on the web. A fundamental shift toward multimedia and interaction.</p><p>“This characterization of the current state of the Web is at times contended, and though the clear delineation between the first and second Webs is here admitted to be rather arbitrary, it still must be recognized that the Web is indeed evolving into a more interactive, multi-media driven technological space, and this understanding of the term is used in this paper. As <a href="http://www.webology.ir/2006/v3n2/a25.html#24#24">O’Reilly</a> (2005) observes in what is often cited as the seminal work on Web 2.0, personal web-pages are evolving into blogs, encyclopedias into <a href="http://www.webology.ir/2006/v3n2/a25.html#34#34">Wikipedia</a>, text-based tutorials into streaming media applications, taxonomies into “folksonomies,” and question-answer/email customer support infrastructures into instant messaging (IM) services.” O’Reilly, T. (2005). <a href="http://www.oreillynet.com/pub/a/oreilly/tim/news/2005/09/30/what-is-web-20.html#mememap"><em>What is web 2.0?</em></a> Retrieved May 18, 2006, from <a href="http://www.oreillynet.com/pub/a/oreilly/tim/news/2005/09/30/what-is-web-20.html#mememap">http://www.oreillynet.com/pub/a/oreilly/tim/news/2005/09/30/what-is-web-20.html#mememap</a></p><p>The world and even the web we know has and will continue to change at a very rapid pace. Much of that change has and will continue to be facilitated by Linux and Open Source and commodity hardware. By enabling broader participation and collaboration, these building blocks of innovation will continue to fuel an already hyper environment. Several books recently written help explain just how much has changed, “Wikinomics” and “The Starfish and the Spider.” However, Linux in many ways started it all. Remaining viable in such a competitive, constantly changing world will be increasingly difficult. The challenges will be almost overwhelming. How will companies succeed? Many of the key answers as I have described in this book, also lie with Linux.</p><p><em>The Love of Linux is a Lesson about What People Want and Need and What will make Businesses Successful in a new Business Paradigm</em></p><p>The real lessons from Linux are yet to be learned by the industry. The lesson is not about how to produce better, more timely software with less money. The lesson is about people and what they are expressing by their love or commitment to Linux. The love of Linux is really a vote for freedom and creative expression. The infatuation with Linux is a vote for the ability to develop something that either truly meets a customer’s needs or scratches a developer’s itch rather than the expedience of the all mighty dollar. Linux and the Internet allow for immediate customer feedback and interaction. I am a strong advocate of using good business practices to run a business, but so often decisions that dictate the feature of a product are more political than truly dictated by either business constraints or true customer value.</p><p>The love of Linux may be a vote for true leadership rather than management. I believe the key reason Linux, is the dominate alternative operating system on Intel not BSD is Linus. People have no real problem following a true leader, but they will fight tyranny to their last breath. Corporate management must stop looking for ways to justify control and restraint and learn to lead. The passion for Linux and the Internet and its openness may be a vote for the less control even in the face of major change and uncertainty. Government and corporate business seem to fear and fight change rather than embrace and evolve with it when appropriate. The real lesson for business that comes from Open Source and Linux I believe is about freedom and expression. Allowing people to capitalize on their strengths and stay in positions that allow them to utilize those strengths without jeopardizing the financial growth. In the book, “Now, Discover Your Strengths,” by Marcus Buckingham and Donald O. Clifton, Ph. D., they mention a study conducted by asking over 1.7 million employees in 101 companies from 63 countries if they felt that they had the opportunity to do what they do best every day or feel that their strengths are in play every day. The answer was only 20%. “Most bizarre of all, the longer an employee stays with an organization and the higher he climbs the traditional career ladder, the less likely he is to strongly agree that he is playing to his strengths” (pg. 6). As mentioned in an earlier chapter, councils, not committees, may be a great way to accomplish this empowerment. Enabling groups of key individuals regardless of where they sit on the corporate ladder to participate in key projects and even lead them without having to be a manager. If the company can designate a lead that can not only make recommendations but decisions, they could help flatten the traditional hierarchical organizational structures and facilitate responsiveness to the industry and capture the creativity of your employees. The companies who learn to take the risk and empower their people where they have strengths, they will be successful.</p><p><em>Strategy, Creating Real Customer Value and Leadership are How to sustain a Competitive Advantage</em></p><p>Strategy, Collaboration and Delivering Real Customer Value are the answer. Strategy Requires Leadership. Leadership can only flourish when there is freedom and ability to take risk. To have that freedom, you must protect the ownership of the company, ensure the proper constitution of the board, and have the CEO both retain enough ownership personally and function as the Chairman of the Board.</p><p>That said, the value in a company does not come from a single CEO paid multiple times more than those really making the business happen. The value in a company will occur when each individual in their respective roles are true leaders and then share in the benefits of their labors. When individuals can bloom, blossom and prosper without being forced to leave their role or the company in order to find fulfillment.</p><p>A company’s management team comprising the chairman of the board, the board and the corporate management team must be unified and supportive of the strategy or it cannot be effectively completed. Consequently, the constitution of a board and the role of a chairman are absolutely critical especially when things do not go quite as planned. Keeping the ownership structure with the employees and management rather than with investors is absolutely necessary. With the ownership, rogue investors can be kept in check and the strategy can be executed. If the board and management are unified, they can develop a successful strategy and then stay the course when the storms hit.</p><p>With the freedom and ability to take risk, the organization can determine a strategy. What customer are they going to serve and what unique value can they deliver to that customer? Is there a sustainable market? Who are the competitors? The more specific the company can get in answering these questions, they greater opportunity they will have for success. The more unique actions they can take to deliver true value to their customer, the less chance a competitor can imitate them or confuse the market. These unique actions or decisions make up a unique strategy that nearly becomes impossible to duplicate. If the company is delivering real value to its customers, they will likely not want or need to choose a different product or service. This sounds so easy. In many ways, it is but the challenge comes when other opportunities present themselves that are not in line with the chosen strategy. This is where leadership becomes critical at all levels. They must be willing to stay the course; to make the necessary trade offs to be true to the strategy. The must demonstrate true leadership.</p><p>This does not mean that a company cannot change products or even customers in time. How many successful companies have ended up being what they set out to become? A company often reinvents itself three to four times as it evolves. The market is constantly evolving and changing. The cheese is constantly on the move. The key lies in empowering the people to respond to the change within the confines of a vision and strategy. Council together, analyze the information, involve those who have the most knowledge regardless of where they are on the corporate ladder and then make a decision. As you move forward, constantly monitor the success of the decision and be willing to modify and improve as more data becomes available. Stay true to the over riding vision and strategy but constantly listen and adapt. These are lessons that Open Source and Linux can teach the industry. Lead, empower, stay true to vision and strategy but listen to the market and the customer, and adapt. Create in essence a living, breathing organism that has the power to think respond and act. There really is no greater thrill than to see others capture a vision and make it their own. They make it uniquely better than even the originator envisioned. As each member of the organization adds their unique contribution and is rewarded for it, the organization as a whole becomes unstoppable. From what I have read, Goggle may be such an environment.</p><p>Understanding the customer, creating real customer value through linked actions that form a compelling strategy and having the leadership and vision to follow through and stay the course is how to be successful in this new, constantly changing, and highly competitive world. Since Linux was born in this environment and has been the catalyst for the growth of this market, much can be learned by studying, not only the operating system and Open Source and their methodologies, but also understanding and applying the principles and key motivations that drive Linux and apply those to business. In many ways, the love of Linux is an innate, human desire in everyone to contribute to something that is worthwhile, to be able to express themselves and have the expression listened to, added upon and valued. The love of Linux is the desire to truly help someone and deliver something to them that they really appreciate. This love has been unleashed on the world and it has and will change the very fabric of society. The opportunity for business is to somehow harness that love, not to control it, but to provide direction and vision. To somehow learn and apply the principles that allow their people to unite in a common cause and freely give of themselves to something they believe in. To develop the mindset to trust in the community and in the basic goodness of others rather than close up and protect, will be the challenge of nearly all management teams. The principles utilized by Linux and Open Source can be applied to business and then that business will prosper in an ever changing environment. This is the love and lesson of Linux. Linux has changed my life and whether or not you are aware it is changing yours. The real opportunity for change lies in understanding the principles that have made Linux and Open Source successful and applying them in business.</p><p>�� k��</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9d6281a1352b" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Love of Linux Chapter 14: So What About the SCO Lawsuit?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@ransomhlove/the-love-of-linux-chapter-14-so-what-about-the-sco-lawsuit-7d4c9fba20c?source=rss-c44b575286b0------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/7d4c9fba20c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[linux]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[tech]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[entrepreneurship]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ransom H. Love]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 24 Feb 2016 22:30:30 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-02-24T22:30:30.853Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>I have been asked by many people what my opinion of what SCO did. I have not commented publicly about their actions, because it really requires more explanation than can be provided in a 30 second sound bite. First of all, I would like the record very clear that I do not stand to gain anything from what I am about to say as I sold all of my stock in SCO when they announced the suit with IBM. And the sale occurred long before the stock went to 8 dollars a share after the announcement that MicroSoft had made an investment or the subsequent spike to around $17 per share. I fundamentally did not believe in the suit, not because I do not think that elements of the suit against IBM are not justified (I think the suit against Linux is wrong), but because it had a strong chance of destroying SCO’s own business (which it has), hampering the success of Linux (very little) and seriously destroying UnitedLinux (which it did). It is not how I would have done it and that is obviously why I am not still there. Why are they doing this you might ask? To answer that will take some history.</p><p>One of the main reasons Caldera bought UNIX was to extend and enhance Linux. When we went to the main supporters of Linux, Intel and IBM, their responses were less than warm. Intel was almost rude. If anyone has dealt with Intel that is not that unusual J but their reaction was close to anger which did surprise us a little. We proposed that the UNIX kernel could be open sourced and used to supplement Linux and provide a very scale-up solution while the current Linux kernel was focused on providing a scale-out solution. We felt that we could create a common application and even installation environment that would be seamless. We were not only willing to Open Source much if not most of the technology but provide indemnification. They did not want to hear any of it. If I recall Will Swope’s comment was something to the effect, “We have tried UNIX on Intel and we are done with it.” I left the meeting, really questioning why Intel was even involved in Linux. Interestingly enough, Intel was a prominent sponsor of the Monterey project with SCO and IBM, whose stated purpose was to move UNIX on to the IA64 architecture. My questioning and suspicions of Intel’s motives continued when I encountered their resistance on almost every major initiative they sponsored publicly. They would organize industry wide imitative for Linux like OSDL, only to block any and all funding when it came to marketing and promoting Linux, they were supporting the technical advancement of Linux only. They insisted that they would not spend any of their money on marketing Linux. They clearly contributed technology and they were very vocal about wanting to use Linux to destroy any and all Intel UNIX. They seemed bent on using Linux against UNIX but not against MicroSoft. So why are they so much against UNIX when it actually could and should complement Linux? What we were proposing was an Operating System platform for Intel that could scale and possibly displace the majority of proprietary, high-end RISC hardware systems. Our strategy was borrowing from MicroSoft’s own. They had Windows running on top of a DOS operating system and NT, MicroSoft’s own multiuser operating system. Both MicroSoft kernels shared the same application environment so that ISV’s could develop a windows application and have it run seamlessly in both environments. Caldera would open source the UNIX kernel, utilize the Lunix application environment and allow our Replicated Site organizations and VARs develop applications that could either scale using a cluster of smaller servers or for some applications, the power of symmetrical multiprocessing on one server. The difference between what we would offer and what Microsoft could offer at the time, is our platform actually worked and scaled as promised. It could have taken Intel to a very different place much faster in the Enterprise. So why were they so against the concept?</p><p>The only obvious conclusion I could come to was they wanted to use Linux to hurt SUN Micro Systems. So why wouldn’t they embrace Intel UNIX to help Linux scale and truly compete with Sun on Intel hardware? The UnixWare kernel of UNIX could scale to 32 way clusters on Unisys Intel machines. All we were lacking was a stable, credible hardware platform that would scale. Obviously, if our UNIX kernel could be made to run on Intel, so could Sun’s, so Intel would be concerned. Intel felt that the commodity platform would eventually push the proprietary RISC processors out of the Enterprise because the processing power was doubling every 18 months. They knew they would be pushing Sun and its competitors out, so they just did not want to leave them any turf on their own platform to prosper.</p><p>Ironically, Sun actually did what Caldera proposed to Intel. They published the entire Solaris Operating System under an open source license, but it was a little too late for the company. Had Intel simply supported Caldera’s efforts, we would have been more of a deterrent against Sun as there would have been almost no interest in the open source community to support another Unix kernel on Intel and ISVs would not have tolerated yet another platform to certify and test. However, I think there was more to Intel’s reaction then just an attack on Sun.</p><p>It is interesting to note that Intel’s support of Linux began right about the time that Microsoft was in the government antitrust suit claiming that Linux was a major threat to them and their business. We had the biggest laugh when Microsoft actually used the Caldera desktop product in court showing how it was a competitive threat to Windows. This was the time when the infamous “Halloween” letters were leaked to the press. The Halloween documents were supposed internal memos that got published by accident. Many in the Linux community really believed the marketing hype that Microsoft was somehow threatened by them and the documents ran like wild fire through the open source community. I have always been skeptical. Microsoft never makes mistakes like that and Intel and Microsoft have an incredible working relationship. Some say it is a love, hate relationship, but I seriously wonder especially in something as critical as an investment in alternative, competing operating system platform.</p><p>As mentioned, it is interesting that Intel was a major sponsor of the Monterey project. To refresh the readers mind, the project was between SCO, prior to their purchase by Caldera, IBM, Intel and Compaq, prior to their purchase by Hewlet Packard. The intent was to move Intel Unix on to the IA64 processor. So why did their good intentions turn so dramatically against Intel UNIX even when it was offered as a way to enhance and move Linux forward?</p><p>Regardless of the motives of both IBM and Intel in regards to Intel UNIX, the Monterey Project, later called AIX 5L, was one of the major reasons Caldera purchased SCO. SCO had a very good agreement with IBM that would enable them to move their large customer’s like Nasdac to IA64 as they needed the capacity. IBM had spent considerable effort to ensure Caldera of their intent to continue to support Monterey when we announced the purchase agreement at the SCO Open World event in Santa Cruz. A team from IBM came to the event with a specific agenda to assure both the SCO and Caldera management of their ongoing commitment to Monterey. At the time, the move to IA64 was imminent. Intel was using its marketing muscle on its OEMS and the industry to get them all to embrace Itanium which was going to be their very next generation chip set. All of SCO’s large UNIX customers were concerned about an upgrade path. Most of SCO’s install base did not need IA64. The mainstream OpenServer customers did not need or want the large foot print or enterprise functionality of UnixWare. IA64 was additional cost and overhead the VAR channel and its customers were not interested in. However, what the OpenServer customers and the VARs that serviced them needed was hardware driver and application support. OpenServer was not staying up with the new hardware platforms and the application developers were more interested in the growing market share of Linux.</p><p>Caldera felt it could marry the two issues by making the UNIX kernel another kernel option for Linux. Placing the Linux application environment on UNIX would allow software developers and hardware OEMs the opportunity write one application and have it scale across multiple hardware platforms. Linux had won the battle for the developers but the UNIX kernel had a good chance to be a deployment option. Linux was ideally suited for the SCO OpenServer and VAR market if Caldera could get its version of Linux certified by all the Intel OEMs. When those VAR’s and customers needed more scalability, they would not have to change their application. This solution was also appealing to the distributed enterprise or replicated site customer. Marrying UNIX and Linux would enable applications developed for a small retail outlet of McDonalds or Kentucky Fried Chicken which were currently using and outdated UNIX to deploy very low cost software and hardware solutions at the retail outlet but interface with large back end UNIX needs at the corporate offices with a single application. The marriage of UNIX and Linux would enable software developer’s access to the most flexible, scalable, fastest growing Intel hardware platform in the Industry and fully utilize all of Intel’s capabilities and growing maturity. At the time, no one really took Intel serious in the enterprise. IA64 was going to change that. The marriage of UNIX and Linux on the Intel platform would have been unstoppable. The market projections and popularity of Linux on a mature, scalable kernel or on a distributed, low cost Linux kernel was ideal for Caldera’s mixed customer base and for the world at large. The key of course would be to have the UNIX kernel on Itanium, the latest Intel platform in order to have a complete story. Having UNIX on Itanium was more critical for Caldera’s Linux business than even its UNIX business.</p><p>Caldera needed the OEMS, ISVs and IHVs support. The popularity and growth of Linux, the UNIX technology Caldera could have provided to ensure compatibility of these applications on Linux along with the power of UNIX, placed Caldera at the center of an incredible industry opportunity. Apparently, the opportunity for Caldera really scared some of the major players like IBM and Intel, whose investment in Linux was not to create another Microsoft, but drive their own agendas. For Intel, while they would finally have a platform that would enable its hardware to be seriously considered in the enterprise, it would allow Sun a foothold on Intel as they could also create or license the Linux personality for Solaris and the married UNIX/Linux platform could really pose a threat to Microsoft. It would appear that all some in Intel wanted was to help produce enough of threat of competition to Microsoft to ease the government’s investigation of antitrust but not enable a true competitor to Microsoft that could erode current business. And as I mentioned, Intel also wanted to launch a Linux/Intel attack on Sun.</p><p>IBM’s concerns seemed much less founded. Caldera should have been the ideal Linux partner. IBM did not want to sell the Linux OS. They had stated that they wanted to enable Linux for the enterprise. How better than to utilize UNIX technology like the kernel and compatible libraries and utilities? They needed a Linux provider that could support the OS globally. Caldera had offices all over the world and a global reseller channel allowing global roll outs of products and services with a single Linux vendor. IBM was also very strong in the distributed enterprise or replicated site business market. They sold cash registers and software to the same VARs and retailers as Caldera did. We could not get IBM software or the retail group of IBM engaged for a long time. Steve Mills, who headed IBM software, refused to support Caldera until we had successful negotiated the UnitedLinux relationship. This really hurt Caldera. Without the support of the IBM and other major ISVs and IHVs (IBM was both in our major market) we were losing business to SuSe and RedHat even though we had long established relationships with the distributed enterprise customers. We lost the Target account to Red Hat primarily because Red Hat was supported by IBM.</p><p>So when IBM just chose not to continue the Monterey project on Intel, they really hurt our credibility. IBM continued what became to be known as AIX 5L on their RS6000 platforms but not on Intel. When we went back to talk with IBM’s legal department, they simply said we are not gong to deliver. When we asked for some compensation, the offers were absolutely ludicrous considering the economic cost to Caldera for not offering an IA64 UNIX offering to their existing customers. I believe they offered something like $50,000. We considered the matter unresolved, but we focused our attention on trying to collaborate with IBM on UnitedLinux and our joint, replicated site retail business. The lion share of Caldera’s business was in the distributed enterprise, replicated site or retail. SCO and IBM had a substantial amount of common retail business.</p><p>IBM was also not very receptive to our desires to merge UNIX with Linux. Early on, we approached IBM about an investment and they flatly turned us down. We had a terrible time getting the software division to continue to support even our Linux products until we were successful in creating UnitedLinux but by that time we were loosing very significant customers. All other Linux companies received major investments and assistance from IBM except Caldera even though it was primarily Caldera that was driving UnitedLinux. IBM needed UnitedLinux because they did not want a dominate Linux provider but they could not afford to test and support their software on too many independent Linux versions. IBM, because of their interest in UnitedLinux, was a major influence in helping to shape the UnitedLinux relationship. They were not helpful in assisting Caldera in being successful and in fact were a major impediment. There was substantial justification for a suit relating to the Monterey project, but we choose to focus on building a business.</p><p>I am not a conspiracy promoter, but we kept hearing rumors that Intel’s and IBM’s motives were not pure in relationship with Monterey or ultimately AIX 5L. They did not want UNIX to succeed on the Intel platform. I do believe IBM’s motives with Linux are business pure. In other words, they are making money on Linux so they genuinely want Linux to succeed. I believe that while they have a good relationship with Intel and Microsoft, they also would like nothing more than to see something at least threaten the dominance of Windows. What IBM did not want was another MicroSoft to deal with. The felt they could manage Linux if it remained even one or two small players. I honestly do not see that same motivation for Intel. What do they really stand to gain with Linux except as a weapon against Sun who remains their only real chip competitor? However, AMD has made some inroads. They had absolutely no desire to really help Linux except as a weapon against UNIX. Consequently, their motives with Linux did not appear altruistic or even pure business related.</p><p>So to summarize, while we had gotten Caldera to break even, the investment to get Tarantella off the board had completely drained the cash reserves. Darl needed an investment to provide a cushion and fund new business growth opportunities. He did not come through on his promise of his own investors. Bob Bench and I had been working to attract other investors and had developed a package that both Bob and I had begun to present to the investment community highlighting our strengths. Some of our efforts were beginning to bear fruit but we did not have any major success.</p><p>The board had seen the major set backs Caldera had suffered both at the hands of large corporate entities like Novell, Netscape, Corel, Star Division, IBM and Intel as well as the abuse of a well meaning but misinformed Linux community itself. Many of these companies had literally stolen millions of dollars from Caldera only to be held up as icons by the Linux and Open Source communities. Other companies, either intentionally or unintentionally really hurt Caldera by withholding their support both financially and or through supporting Caldera’s Linux version with their hardware and software products, making it extremely hard to meet customer demands. This lack of support was particularly puzzling given their public statements and Caldera’s excellent positioning to help and move Linux forward on a global basis in comparison to the other extremely regional players. The company had spent millions of dollars in supporting Linux only to be ridiculed, brow beaten and falsely accused by the community of trying to take advantage of the Linux developers when we were only trying to make a legitimate business while these other companies, who behind the scene, were stealing money by breaking contracts and at the very least, had very mixed motives for Linux, were heralded as almost heroes by the open source community.</p><p>The Taratella influence on the board in support of UNIX came at a critical time. With the economic down turn, it appeared that the Linux bubble could have burst along with the dot coms. At least, I think Alok and Doug Michaels must have felt that way. They had completely missed both the Internet and Linux opportunity and I think they were almost hoping it would fail just to vindicate their poor choices. Our board was somewhat receptive because of all that had transpired. I do not critize the board, but this was a critical time when real leadership was needed. Unfortunately, since I was not the chairman of the board, Canopy was running scared (concerned about minority share holder suits at a time when they were particular vulnerable), and the bottom was falling out of the market, there was no one to stay the course.</p><p>When Darl began to get enamored with the heritage of UNIX, he felt he had found something that glittered. He felt he might have something that could either bring IBM or Mircrosoft to the table for very different reasons. Apparently, the tactic worked short term as a major investor came to the table very shortly after the announcement of the suit. There were a number of very legitimate suits that could have been made because of the many injustices that were done, but the path they took was apparently determined by the investor that came to the table. Unfortunately, as is the case with these suits, those closely involved began to get caught up in the frenzy and publicity that occurs as a result of the public attention. They start to believe themselves.</p><p>When I heard about the suit against IBM and Linux I immediately sold my shares. When the investment came into Caldera from one of Microsoft’s investment companies and the stock price rose to $17 per share, I had long since cashed out without benefiting from the hype. I absolutely do not regret my decision because I had lived through a suit and knew what it could do to a company and had lost faith in the management’s ability to carry out our vision. Their decision had put a knife through our Linux vision and over 9 years of efforts when they were finally in a position to capitalize on the investment. The management team and board in my mind had gone for the quick pay off rather than opting to build the business. The board and management team literally gave all our Linux work to SuSE and then to Novell. The incredible ride was over but the vision of Caldera lives on in Novell’s core engineering team that was acquired by SuSE to complete United Linux.</p><p>F����</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=7d4c9fba20c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Love of Linux Chapter 13: The Attack of the “BORG/Board”]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@ransomhlove/the-love-of-linux-chapter-13-the-attack-of-the-borg-board-1cc2122bd6e?source=rss-c44b575286b0------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/1cc2122bd6e</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[entrepreneurship]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[tech]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[business-strategy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ransom H. Love]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 24 Feb 2016 22:28:11 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-02-24T22:28:11.563Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>You will be assimilated or destroyed. While digesting the elephant of the SCO, much of our attention was turned internally, partly because of the enormity of the task and partly because of the influence of Tarantella on our board. To purchase the asset, we had given up nearly a 1/3 of the company to Tarantella. That gave Tarantella the right to participate on the board with two seats. Tarantella saw Caldera an on going source of cash and thus the work to turn the company around was further complicated. Every change we made that would negatively impact the employees would make its way across the street in Santa Cruz to the Tarantella buildings from disgruntled employees. The irony of this situation was that the board, driven primarily by Tarantella interests, was actually putting the constraints on the Caldera management team to make some of the changes. However, this created a tension on the board which made it hard to function. We had hoped to avoid that situation, by recommending that Tarantella appoint Alok Mahon to the board rather than Doug Michaels to avoid the emotional tie. Doug and his father started the SCO business, and we felt that Doug would be emotionally tied and slow down some of the tougher decisions. The idea that Alok would be less hampered proved to be short sighted. Alok was controlled a lot more by Doug than we had at first anticipated. In hindsight, it may have been better to have Doug participate directly then he could have been part of the decisions.</p><p>It would have been a little more difficult to reach a decision, but it may have been more effective. My experience with SCO and their representatives on Caldera’s board is that they lost any ability to create value with the passing of Doug Michels’ father. Negotiating anything with them became a tar baby. The only thing they know is win/loose negotiation. The only time we were able to have a reasonable negotiation, was when they were desperate for cash. We successfully negotiated the pay off of the remaining 8 million dollar note for 5 million dollars cash. When we renegotiated the original deal, we paid out 25 million more in cash than we had wanted to. We also had a note for 8 million to be paid in installments of two million a quarter beginning 12 months from the close of the transaction. Having two members of our board from Tarantella proved to be a serious mistake. It enabled them to double team and wrestle control of the company away from the management and original investors by dominating the agenda and leveraging their ownership in Caldera. They took control of our board by threatening or casually referencing the majority share holders with minority share holder suits. Unfortunately, their only real interest in Caldera appeared to be to provide cash flow for the asset they did not sell to Caldera. They were so entrenched in the Innovator’s Dilemma mindset; they could not begin to understand the value of Linux and a completely different economic model that was emerging. My last official act as CEO and President of Caldera, which gave me great satisfaction, was to sign the agreement that repurchased the outstanding shares from Tarantella and removed their representatives from the board.</p><p>The challenge with a board of directors lies in the fact that they are there to protect the shareholders of the business. Because of all of the legal suites that occur, the board members take more seriously, however, their own legal liabilities and exposure. Therefore, men who understand how to push the right buttons, can manipulate others who are concerned about potential liability or rationalize that after all, they are their to protect the share holders and if the share holder represented on the board wants something, they should support them. Unfortunately, what an individual shareholder wants is very seldom in the best interest of the entire body of shareholders.</p><p>Back to the board, our board is composed of two representatives from Canopy, one from MTI, one from the company (me), two from Tarantella and three independents board seats. They are called independent because they were not investors. Unfortunately, we had only two. The challenge for the independents is that they are there to protect the shareholders interests, thus they look to the other shareholders on the board to take the lead. Canopy, the largest shareholder, felt the most vulnerable. By being the largest shareholder, they were at the greatest risk of being sued. I believe the minority shareholders who were astute investors and sat on other boards with them point out to them or maybe even threaten suit if they took the lead on several issues. Consequently, Canopy would sit back and let the discussion happen without giving it much guidance. If Ray Noorda had been able to participate in the board meetings, this would have never happened because he would have called their bluff.</p><p>The chairman of a board is vital. They should be independent in their thinking and should provide the necessary leadership. Most of the work of a board should be done outside the board meeting. The chairman should call all of the board members and brief them on the issues and get their open candid feedback before the meeting ever takes place. If this is not done, the different agendas of individual board members are facilitated because, in the public forum of the actual board meetings where notes are required, all that has to happen is for a minority shareholder to threaten some lack of fiduciary responsibility. Without a functioning chairman, the management team is put in direct conflict with the board members and a board ceases to be of much value.</p><p>In an environment of “fiduciary fear,” the board no longer seeks to understand truth. They would rather hide the truth and look for a scapegoat. Since they lack the knowledge of the business, (they very seldom if ever read the information provided them in the board packets) they are very busy in their day today businesses. Therefore, they kind of go with the flow, often offering “seat of the pants advice” or even worse, many have left active participation in the management of a business many years ago and they want to give advice about how they did it then.</p><p>My purpose is not to criticize. Steve Cakebread was a tremendous asset. Steve also headed up the Audit Committee and he did an absolutely wonderful job. Ed Iaccabucci has also been very valuable. Much of the problem with the independents are simply they must rely upon the input from the shareholders and if your shareholders will not give their input or their input does not even make sense, they can and will make poor judgments. Ideally, I believe your board should be made up of mainly independents if at all possible. What you would like on a board is independent, strong advice from people who have experience in the industry. When your board is made up of investors, they tend to give advice that helps their portfolio or the company that they have the biggest personal stake in rather than what is best for the company on whose board they sit. Worse still, they may manage for themselves personally rather than for the companies they should represent.</p><p>One of my main issues with our board was that when Alok Mahon came onto the board, he immediately pushed through a raise for the board. At a time when our management team was taking major cuts in salary and stock instead of cash bonuses, our board, under the influence of Alok gave themselves a big raise. When I tried to protest, I was immediately put in my place by the other Tarantella board member, Duff Thompson with the statement that the board has significantly more risk than the management team and therefore they should never be compared. The truth is that there is no one more at risk than the CEO and CFO of a corporation, but for our board there was a double standard. When Ray Noorda’s health would not allow him to actively participate on our board, I also tried in vain to reduce the board. Instead of having two representatives from Tarantella and two from Canopy, I suggested that each reduce by one. Canopy was very willing, but Alok insisted on having two members. Consequently, Darcy Mott was added to our board, bringing the number to 9.</p><p>The other area which I felt needed to be addressed was the office of chairman. When a board gets so large, and even on smaller boards, the chairman must spend quite a bit of time working with each member of the board outside the board meetings. Ralph Yarro was participating on so many boards, that it was difficult for him to spend the time on any one company. While I did not want the additional worry of being chairman, I felt that the company needed to have that added direction and influence of an active chairman. I suggested that to Ralph who was willing to move forward. However, there were others that did not want that to happen.</p><p>The biggest constraint to a successful board and in business in general, is self interest. Clearly, a free enterprise system is driven in a large part by ethical self interest but some people are so self consumed, they cannot and will not do what is fair and just, but rather justify their actions by creating attacking those they have abused or taken advantage of. Those who engage in politics to harm another, do so feeling totally justified in their actions because they have built an internal case against that person by not being true or honest with themselves. They may temporarily harm the person they attack with their politics, but they can never run away from themselves and eventually it will catch up with them.</p><p>Many have rumored that I had a falling out with the board. The reality was that I had more worn out the board. Over the four quarters that I was managing the greater Caldera/SCO union, the economy literally feel apart and the stock market went toppling. To keep my people engaged and invested in the business, I was constantly going back to the board for more options only to find that they were of little value within 6 months. This was no reflection on the management team or the board. They were unprecedented times that no one foresaw or had any experience at. In addition, we would make revenue forecasts that were based on the best information that we had. With the expert help of Bob Bench, our CFO and Ed Donakey, our Chief of Staff, we tenaciously met all of our expense cutting targets without fail, but we did not reach our revenues. Again, not trying to make any excesses but no one else was making their revenue targets either. The reality is that we were all living through some very difficult times. The team did an incredible job of managing the ship and frankly, I believe that the merger was a great success. The entire company was working together toward the common goal. However, these events are extremely stressful to a board that has a fiduciary responsibility. While they did not have any better ideas, some felt it their responsibility to criticize. It is amazing how easy it is to tear down and so hard to build something up, especially when it means that you might have to take some heat for it. Having two vocal board members whose entire mind set was to fight rather than support Linux, made it virtually impossible to move forward. When nothing else works, “let’s do something new,” becomes the path of least resistance so that at least we can represent to investors that we have tried.</p><p>Every board meeting became an absolute battle. We could not accomplish anything in the board meeting. Alok would attack everything that management wanted to accomplish and suggest to the board that all Caldera had going for it was UNIX. There was truth in what Alok said but it was very deceptive. As a management team and board, we had intentionally let our retail business die which is where we sold most of our Linux products in favor of the VAR channel. UnitedLinux would have opened up the application and hardware platform market to us as the ISVs and IHVs would rally and support just two Linux platforms. With the applications and support of the hardware OEMS, we could have pushed Linux back into the VAR channel where we felt it had the highest chance of success. Even though we were successful in managing costs, something Alok and the SCO management team could not do, and we successfully negotiated a relationship with four highly competitive Linux companies, it was apparent that I would have little more effect on the board to bring about the vision we had put in place.</p><p>Ralph Yarro, who was the Chairman of the board, refused to step in and control Alok and Duff Thompson. They apparently felt SCO would spear head a minority share holder suit if they support showed any support for the Linux strategy. Canopy was in a tenuous position. Ray Noorda had stepped out of the day to day business a year or two earlier. Ray had set up Canopy to be independent. He did not want his children to know or be involved in the management of the funds allocated to Canopy as I understand it. Ralph and Darcy Mott were making business decisions without any guidance from the Noordas. The Noorda family was growing increasingly uneasy. Also, Darcy had wanted to be appointed to the SCO board with Ray’s resignation. I had not wanted that to happen for two reasons: 1) we already had the necessary accounting experience on the board with Steve Cakebread. Darcy already attended all board meetings and had full input through Ralph. The Caldera board desperately needed more independent marketing and business expertise that another accountant who represented the principal investor. 2) Darcy and I had butted heads a few times. He viewed the world as a true accountant and struggled to see anything but numbers. With the contention already on the board with Alok, our management team could not afford to have yet another antagonist.</p><p>Because I apposed his appointment, which by the way, Alok had made quite lucrative, I believe Darcy wanted to get rid of me. I was quite naïve and was only focused on how to get our vision implemented. Our vision and commitment to Linux had seen the company through the dark days of the dissolution of Caldera Inc. and I was hoping that Ralph would stand up for their investment again. When Ralph did not step forward in defense of the Linux vision and management, I realized that I had absolutely no support from Canopy and thus the board. Consequently, I determined to do two things: 1) Find a replacement that could build on what we had started and 2) Do everything in my power to get the SCO board members off the Caldera board so the new CEO would be free from their influence and able to move forward on the vision.</p><p>I heard that Darl McBride was looking for a job. Darl had been instrumental years before in getting Caldera started inside Novell. When Bryan Sparks, Rob Hicks and I met to discuss the possibility of starting a company based on Linux. Rob Hicks had met with Darl who was a Vice President over Novell’s embedded technologies and told him of our efforts. Darl had mentioned our ideas to Ray Noorda. Ray called Rob Hicks in and started a skunk works project inside of Novell. Darl had since been involved with several channel companies and had even done a successful channel roll up, buying up of individual Value Added Resellers to form on large global business.</p><p>To get SCO off the board, we had to buy out Tarantella’s remaining interest in Caldera. To do so would use up the remaining cash reserves. Bob Bench and I had begun a program to reach out to new investors and position Caldera properly. We had stopped the hemorrhaging and were cash flow break even and were well positioned to get new capital. When I met with Darl, he felt he could bring a number of key investors to Caldera who had helped him in the past with his channel roll up. I spoke with the board and suggested that they consider Darl as a replacement. They were quite interested so Alok volunteered to interview him in California. It was arrange for Darl to fly out to Santa Cruz and meet with Alok.</p><p>I was not present at the interview, but Darl came back and began to grow very interested in the pedigree of UNIX. The board agreed to make Darl an offer. I was also successful at negotiating a buy out amount with Tarantella. Also, I was trying to work with the board to figure out an exit package for myself. I had requested that the board give me the shares in the company that I had to leave behind from Caldera, Inc. At the time Caldera Systems was formed, I could not afford to pay the taxes when Caldera Inc.’s Linux debt was converted to equity. The equity investment of 16 million, raised the value of Caldera System’s stock price. I had founder’s stock I had to let go because I could not afford to pay the taxes. Serendipitously, I found the agreement the officers of the company signed when we purchased SCO. It made reference to the fact that if a significant change in board structure occurred, it would trigger the severance package for the company officers. The resignation of Ray Noorda, Alok Mahon and Duff Thompson placed Caldera in that position. So when I pushed that point after signing Alok’s and Duff’s resignations, the Board quickly reinstated Duff to stay on the board as an independent. Duff was good friend with Darcy Mott and local to Utah and the board did not want to be in a position that the rest of my staff could claim a severance package.</p><p>I did not show up at the announcement of Darl’s appointment because the board would not respond to my request. Shortly after the announcement, I came into the office when the board finally agreed to a very reasonable but conservative package. I was going to stay on for a couple of months, months paid out of my severance package, and see if I could move over and help manage the UnitedLinux effort. During that time, Darl came into my office and asked me several questions relating to the UNIX source code. In one conversation, he asked about the IBCS II libraries that enabled some OpenLinux applications to run on Linux. He wondered if Caldera could sue the open source community on intellectual property infringement. I told him he was going down the wrong path. This was one area we had hoped to publish actual libraries and have them included in UnitedLinux but they were not that valuable because many ISVs were porting their applications directly to Linux and the libraries were becoming less important. On another occasion, Darl suggested that they could threaten suit to IBM and see who would come to the table first to invest, either Microsoft or IBM. He felt either IBM would invest or buy Caldera or Microsoft would support the effort against IBM. At that time, I suggested that if he wanted to use the legal route, he should sue IBM in regard to the Monterey project and their lack of support on the ISV and IHV front as that was clearly an area that IBM had misrepresented and hurt Caldera’s business.</p><p>Knowing that I would be stepping down as CEO, I approached members of the UnitedLinux consortium to see if they would like me to move that imitative forward. All the presidents of the companies seemed very supportive of the move, but the SuSE board came back and would not support my being appointed as the Presdient/CEO of UnitedLinux for fear that I would be bias toward Caldera’s interests. I stopped going into work at Caldera International since I was basically paying myself out of my severance.</p><p>Within months, they changed the name of Caldera to SCO. I remember distinctly a conversation with Doug Michaels on the Santa Cruz board walk when he asked me what I intended to do with the SCO name. I said we would probably try to have it coexist with Caldera until we could phase it out. He suggested that it was probably better known than Caldera in many parts of the world. I agreed with him but could not see where using the name would help convey the new Linux direction of Caldera. I would guess that when Darl went out to visit with Alok and very likely Doug Michaels, they suggested the SCO name change and UNIX focus since I had been battling them for months on the same issues.</p><p>There are several very critical lessons that I learned from my interaction with the board. First, to be a CEO without any real ownership or stake in the company makes it difficult to manage the politics of a board made up of investors. Letting go of ownership is a critical flaw if want to have the ability to successfully implement strategy. When we started Caldera, Inc., the Noorda Family Trust (NFT) which later became Canopy, demanded 80% of the company leaving only 20% to the founders. The absolute most we should have given up was 40%. Bryan Sparks came to me and told me he felt he needed to hold on to at least 10% as CEO. The rest of the founders took approximately 2%. At the time I questioned the need, but I believe Bryan was wise to hold onto a greater percentage. I watched as he was able to negotiate successfully with NFT/Canopy as his company evolved, primarily because he was a legitimate minority share holder. As things evolved, I ended up with no real ownership in Caldera, International, so when I began to lock horns with Alok, we had no leverage. Our critical flaw, and frankly the downfall of Caldera, was to give up so much ownership to NFT. Having Canopy own so much of the company was also somewhat difficult when we tried to take the company public. The investment bankers really wanted to see much more ownership by the employees and management.</p><p>To grow a company, you will likely have to bring on some investors. But to have the unity at the board level, the constitution of the board is a critical factor. A major challenge in the constitution of the board is the need to raise capital. In raising capital, it is critical not to loose control of the board. If a company can grow organically, it is by far the best but that is not always possible. Sometimes there are clear market windows and opportunities that will pass if you do not move forward and raise the necessary capital to do so. Getting the best set of advisors for the business should be the key objective. Ideally, it is best to have board members who have strengths in each of the key business disciplines like Sales/Marketing, Finance, etc. Also, depending on the nature of the business, it is helpful to have someone with channel experience or even a major customer to get the right perspective. The natural evolution of most boards however is to either have a lot of investors or board members with financial backgrounds. This is due in a large part because of needed capital. Also, a public company requires that a financial specialist to head up the audit committee. Investors and board members with financial backgrounds tend to be heavily adverse to risk and tend to lack understanding and patience when it comes to developing a business or following a strategy.</p><p>Having the CEO also act as the Chairman of the Board is also critical in many ways. Nearly all of the board members are very busy and have little time to review board materials. The business of a board should be nearly decided before the board meets in a one on one meeting between the Chairman and individual board members. The CEO is closest to the strategy and the company. Ensuring that the CEO has time to spend with the board outside of board meetings can be extremely beneficial to the company. When the Chairman is consumed with his own company or interests, he is not able to represent the interests of the management or company well. Hire a Chief Operating Officer to handle the operations of the company if necessary and allow the CEO to act as the Chairman of the Board and spend time working with board members if you want to be successful.</p><p>Going public is not the ideal way to either provide an incentive for employees or liquidity for the investors. Initial Public Offerings (IPOs) are not the answer for every company. In fact, if there is any other way to raise the capital without going public, I would recommend it. The cost, overhead and loss of flexibility are far more than you can comprehend. Liquidity for both the shareholders and employees can be achieved other ways that enable the company to successfully pursue a strategy and control its own destiny.</p><p>Public traded stock does provide a currency that can facilitate some strategic plans for growth and acquisitions, but you must be aware of the costs and where ever possible maintain control and constitution of the board to ensure ultimate success.</p><p>��F��</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=1cc2122bd6e" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Love of Linux Chapter 12: The Formation of Standards-UnitedLinux; a New Paradigm of…]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@ransomhlove/the-love-of-linux-chapter-12-the-formation-of-standards-unitedlinux-a-new-paradigm-of-ac30a5f5c3c4?source=rss-c44b575286b0------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ac30a5f5c3c4</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[linux]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[entrepreneurship]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[tech]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ransom H. Love]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 24 Feb 2016 22:25:16 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-02-24T22:25:16.698Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>The Love of Linux Chapter 12: The Formation of Standards-UnitedLinux; a New Paradigm of Collaboration</h3><p>One of the greatest principal to be learned from Linux and the formation of UnitedLinux is the power of a new type of collaboration even among competitors. Caldera was very instrumental in both the formation and the down fall of UnitedLinux but the principals behind the formation of UnitedLinux live on and can offer great advantages to companies who embrace them. To understand Caldera’s motivation for the encouraging UnitedLinux, one needs to understand the need to establish a platform supported by Independent Software Vendors (ISVs) and Independent Hardware Vendors (IHV).</p><p>Volume attracts developers and standards help to increase volume and to gain broad market acceptance of the ISVs and IHVs. If these developers know that the same interface or method of doing something is used not only by one company but all companies utilizing that technology, they can reach a far bigger market by developing to that interface or standard. Caldera, almost from its inception, has been very vocal and financially committed to the support for standards, recognizing that if Linux were fragmented ISVs and IHVs would have a very difficult time supporting Linux over time. It is important to understand a brief history of standards within the Linux movement. Caldera was committed and played a key role throughout this process because we understood the importance of the support of these ISVs and IHVs.</p><p>Shortly after the formation of Linux International, an influential developer in the Linux Community named Bruce Parens approached the Linux International board with the idea of beginning a standardization effort for Linux that included a reference port for Independent Software Vendors. Caldera was very vocal about the need to have a standard and a reference implementation. Bob Young of Redhat was supportive of a standard but did not want a reference port. After some rather contentious email discussions, Bruce Parens stepped out of the effort and the open source movement for a time.</p><p>Linus Torvalds intervened and almost self appointed a coworker Dan Quinlan to head up the effort. About this time, Redhat partnered with Debian to establish an independent standard, but after an outcry from the Linux community, RedHat and Debian conceded and agreed to support what had come to be known as the Linux Standard Base effort. Dan spent a great deal of time lobbying the different groups in garnering support for the standard. Caldera’s lead Linux engineering manager, Ralf Flax was nominated to head up the reference port implementation. Progress was slow and painful. Those who were often the most vocal on the email groups were interpreted as being supportive of the effort when in fact they appeared to be stalling the process.</p><p>The feeding frenzy that took place as several Linux companies went public greatly slowed the attention paid the standards efforts. The spotlight of the industry was on Linux and it seemed as though the Linux companies could do no wrong. Every leading OEM and ISV was jumping on the Linux bandwagon and wanted to be associated with Linux. Investments were being announced; marketing and support agreements were being signed. Geographic regions of market share were being carved out and everyone was racing to pull ahead of the others. Significant amounts of capital were being poured into the industry and duplicate infrastructures were being created. Each was trying to leverage their geographic leadership to gain global dominance. In this over heated environment, some in the community where not as motivated to come together and cooperate, because they all felt that they could be the number one. In addition, in fairness to all, resources were limited and the rapid release cycle the open source business model required, greatly constrained the amount of time and resource the Linux companies could allocate to a cooperative effort when they were racing to gain market share and presence. Many were claiming the ultimate victory of open source as the new way for software to be developed, marketed and sold. Linus and Dan’s company went public. Dan stepped down as the head of the LSB effort. The former President of SuSE in North America, Scott McNeal picked up the pieces and formed the Free Standards Group and brought the Internationalization standards and LSB under one umbrella. The specification LSB 1.0 and 1.1 was finally completed and released.</p><p>Then the financial market came crashing down and with it the reality that unless there was a business model to sustain the ongoing development and global infrastructure, Linux companies could not survive, let alone expand. As the investment dollars dried up, all the Linux companies began to shrink and return to their own areas geographic areas of strength. As the economy slows, the major players cannot continue to support multiple versions of Linux. As discussed previously, the costs of certification are not insignificant. The retail market followed the economic downturn as a result of the .com implosion and Caldera’s revenues were directly tied to retail sales. Caldera inherited two additional operating systems from SCO, OpenServer which was driving the majority of the revenue and UnixWare, a System 5 Release 4 version of UNIX on Intel. These operating systems both had significant, but unique challenges. While the OpenServer operating system had wonderful legacy application and hardware support in the retail market, it was very old and lacked the architecture and support of the new hardware platforms. New application developers were looking toward the Internet and windows to seek the elusive dollar. OpenServer had little or no Internet functionality and needed a significant overhaul to be able to compete in the new markets. Linux was an ideal substitute for OpenServer because it required very little hardware resources, it had all the needed Internet functionality; it was extremely stable and very low cost.</p><p>All Linux lacked was the legacy driver and application support of OpenServer to significantly penetrate the retail market. SCO’s management could have been the dominate leader in Linux if they had embraced it early on. However, they could not see a way of making money with Linux and feared that it would erode their revenue stream. Instead, they bought UnixWare from Novell. Unfortunately, UnixWare was very much overkill for the majority of SCO’s market. UnixWare required significantly larger servers with larger disks and memory, making the overall solution for the small business environments too expensive to deploy. Besides, Novell had already mined out the Value Added Resellers (VAR) that were willing to carry UnixWare. The VARs and distributed enterprise customers loyal to OpenServer could not afford to deploy UnixWare. I can only speculate why SCO management choose to purchase UnixWare rather than investing in Linux. 1) SCO management could not figure out how to make money on Linux. I had several conversations with Doug and Alok on this topic so I know that it eluded them. In their defense, the successful models described above were only visionary at the time and there were no one who had yet proved them 2) SCO Management wanted to play with the “big” boys because it appealed to their egos</p><p>Everyone wanted to be the “enterprise” player to be the next “Microsoft” rather than develop a strategy of their own. I watched Novell almost grow to disdain the very small business channel that made and kept them in business for so long. Novell loved the revenue generated by the cash cow “Netware” but almost resented the fact that it was “small” business that made the money. I believe that SCO suffered from this same desire to “arrive” in the big leagues. 3) SCO management believed the Intel marketing hype and thought the new generation of Intel platforms would actually allow them to play in the enterprise. In many ways, UnixWare was even overkill for the Intel architecture. Many of the enterprise features UnixWare contained could not be deployed on Intel hardware platforms and when they could, few if any major corporation seriously considered deploying Intel in the true enterprise. Intel Architecture (IA) 64 bit was going to change all of this. While “enterprise” feature rich, UnixWare never had enough volume to attract either hardware or software developers. It was the epitome of a wonderful technology waiting for a market. Unfortunately, although UnixWare was in fact mainstream UNIX functionality, it significantly lacked Internet performance and functionality. SCO was relatively a small company. They did not have the resources to maintain, let alone enhance, two Operating system platforms. Furthermore, they did not have the resources to try to “buy” the support of the OEMs, ISVs and IHVs for two platforms since they both lacked current market support.</p><p>The SCO management had literally painted themselves into a corner because the ignored the market and their customer. The SCO management had failed to upgrade OpenServer, ignored Linux and the Internet (textbook Innovator’s Dilemma) and purchased a product that was of relatively little value to their current customer base. From the long term (20 year) lease agreements we had to buy our way out of, I firmly believe they also completely misinterpreted the increase sells that occurred around the turn of the century. Many companies purchased new licenses to avoid the dreaded “Y2K” fears. The SCO Management probably interpreted the increase volume as market acceptance of their very poor choices and began to act like they were on top of the world only to watch the bottom fall out of their market and their stock price within the first few months of 2000.</p><p>While we had an idea of what we were getting into when we purchased SCO, we did not anticipate fully the predicament we now found ourselves in and the deteriorating economy amplified significantly. We had limited cash, an obsolete operating system (OpenServer) that was bringing in the cash, expenses that far exceeded revenues, and revenues that were shrinking monthly with the economy. We also had a “primer” Operating system (UnixWare) that needed applications, hardware and Internet support, and customers and a Linux operating system that lacked endorsement by the major ISVs and IHVs because of the increasing costs to certify. RedHat was quickly becoming the default certification platform for Linux. If the rest of the Linux companies could not provide a unified platform, the ISVs and IHVs would have just gone with RedHat.</p><p>As the market started to deteriorate, Caldera and several others began to have discussions on collaborating on an LSB reference platform. John Terperstra, a prominent contributor to the SAMBA development effort and well respected in the open source community, left Turbo Linux and joined Caldera. John began to have successful discussions with representatives of SuSE, Turbo and Conectiva. Now adverse economic conditions hampered the success. Development resource cycles were even scarcer. At Caldera’s Forum in August in 2000, I made a public plea that it was time to come together and form a Common Business Linux effort. Intel and HP began promoting Debian as a way to standardize around the LSB specification.</p><p>From August, Caldera began working to get traction with the major Linux providers. Turbo was highly supportive of the effort, but SuSE was distracted by interval restructuring efforts. Rick Becker, from Compaq arranged a meeting in Munich to begin the discussion in earnest. SuSE had an interactive management team, and discussions fell apart. Caldera then went to IBM and a meeting was set up in Barcelona, Spain. SuSE sent a team there under the direction of the interim management team. We nearly had to break of negotiations because we could not get past some very key points. We finally parted ways believing that we had an agreement in principle. Several weeks latter, Gerhard Bertcher was appointed CEO of SuSE. A team was sent to Utah and negotiations were begun again in earnest. The plan was to announce at Linux World. Unfortunately, some of the very same issues we had thought we had agreed upon in Spain resurfaced. Caldera finally terminated the discussion and sent the SuSE team home to think over the issues. Gerhard called and we were able to begin again, unfortunately, we could not make the Linux World meetings. I flew down to Houston and had a meeting with Rick Becker and was able to brief him on the discussions we were having. Compaq was very supportive of the idea. However, we did not make a lot of progress. We called Bob Butler of IBM to see if he could step in. IBM had actually invested in several of the other participants and had a little more influence. Bob helped coordinate a meeting in Atlanta. We made tremendous progress. All parties felt that we had created a bond of mutual respect. After the meeting, progress slowed. We called another face to face in New York. Again, we made tremendous progress and set the framework to move forward. To move progress along, Benoy Tamang from Caldera and Roland Dryfuss from SuSE took the lead in the negotiations. Turbo and Conectiva relegated the heavy lifting to Benoy and Roland. We had targeted the first of May to make the announcement.</p><p>The first of May came and went. We decided to call a negotiation meeting in Europe. Benoy and Harrison Colter, Caldera’s attorney flew to meet with Roland and SuSE’s attorney in London. They worked several days straight and were able to come up with the first draft of a solid complete draft of the document. We began to brief companies in earnest while we continued to work on the contract. In spite of relegating the negotiations to Caldera and SuSE, Turbo came back with a fairly large list of issues just several days before we were to sign. We wanted to have time to sign and then brief Redhat and Mandrake, but the negotiations went clear through the following week. Turbo wanted to work out the final details with SuSE on the non-Intel platforms. We had scheduled May 3 as the target date to announce. We blew past that date. We then set May 22. That day came and went so we set May 30 as the date. At the end of the week of May 22, we did not have sign able contracts, but we all felt that we would be there by the 30th. Finally, on Tuesday afternoon, all the companies had signed. As previously committed, I called Michael Evens at Redhat. I explained that we had taken longer than anticipated to form the union and we knew that they did not have enough time to consider and participate. I promised to follow up in a couple of weeks. On Wednesday morning, I followed up with Mandrake. They seem genuinely interested and we were to follow up. In some ways it did not matter that Redhat joined because both groups will be supporting the Linux Standard Base initiative. Hence, with the formation of UnitedLinux, the Linux community again showed an innovative way to come together. A well know figure in the Linux industry and good friend, Jon “Maddog” Hall put it the best.</p><p>“Open Source licensing leads to each vendor having the same functionality in the base system over time. This effort shows forethought in making that effort a planned, cooperative event. Rather than spend their money re-engineering the basic underlying functionalities of reliability, scalability and availability, these vendors will be able to build a common platform with which to innovate new features that their customer’s desire. I wish the old Unix vendors had learned that lesson.</p><p>For many years the analysts have been saying that the marketplace could not support so many distributions of Linux, hinting that only one or two might survive. Once again the Linux community has come back with a unique answer that may prove the analysts both right and wrong. This bold step should give a strong base distribution that will satisfy the needs of the software vendor for consistency and the hardware vendor for support, yet allow differentiation at the upper levels to meet the needs of diverse customers.”<br> — Jon “maddog” Hall, Executive Director of Linux International.</p><p>What Maddog points out is that Linux and in particular UnitedLinux facilitated a new dimension of collaboration even among competitors that previously has not existed broadly in the industry before. This level of collaboration and reliance and trust in a community effort for even competitors is an important mindset and principal that can benefit companies as they deal with the almost overwhelming competitive environment of a global economy, but it is important to understand the history first.</p><p>On Monday of announcement week, I flew to Europe. Tuesday, I spoke with Redhat. Wednesday morning I spoke with Mandrake. On Wednesday morning, we held a conference call with the industry analysts. The call went very well. On Thursday we made the announcement. The call and support was significant. The support for UnitedLinux was genuine and evident.</p><p>With the formation of United Linux Software, LLC, the Linux industry had reached another major step towards making Linux an industry alternative OS platform. UnitedLinux could have provided a true reference implementation of the LSB specification and a collaborative business model that can sustain ongoing investment in the development of a robust business offering. UnitedLinux could have also provided industry players a direct way of influencing the direction of the Linux technology.</p><p>For Caldera, UnitedLinux helped solve several very pressing concerns. We could now get ISV and IHV support for OpenLinux derived from the UnitedLinux base. We could focus our very scarce resources on optimizing that Linux for the retail and distributed enterprise market. We felt we could also infuse UNIX technologies into UnitedLinux to ensure broader acceptance by the UNIX ISV and IHV community including utilities, APIs, and libraries. The SCO management had begun to experiment with a Linux personality on the UNIX kernel and we felt Caldera could now focus on enhancing this layer. I had proposed to the management team that we should contribute the OpenUnix or UnixWare kernel to the open source community. Caldera’s management team felt that by contributing the Unix kernel to open source, we could also contribute significant technology back to the open source community. In turn, the community could help develop the Linux personality and common API layer. Caldera intended to use the kernel and other Unix technologies to enhance the UnitedLinux distribution and create a premiere version. By so doing, Caldera could facilitate a Linux platform for ISVs and IHVs that could literally scale from hundreds of clustered PCs with the Linux Kernel to 36 SMP processors on the OpenUnix kernel using the same Linux APIs. With a common API layer, these sister kernels could have enabled the Intel hardware platform to accomplish almost any application on high end hardware systems.</p><p>One of the key benefits of UnitedLinux however, was the precedent setting collaboration between key industry competitors. This mindset was very uncommon in the industry at the time. Some could say that UnitedLinux was unsuccessful as the lack of collaboration from SCO proved to be part of its undoing. However, these corporations did collaborate on a united platform that ISVs and IHVs choose to support. When Novell purchased SuSE Linux, they inherited the collaborative work of the four companies that were fierce competitors. The winner was that the software and hardware developers had just one platform to certify to rather than four. The irony of Caldera and then SCO being both the key catalyst and facilitator of both the creation and disillusionment of UnitedLinux should not go unnoticed.</p><p>Fortunately, the principals or mindset which created UnitedLinux have lived on and flourished in the industry. This mindset is almost incomprehensible for many who may read this book. Why would competitors share such intimate information or be dependent upon them for such key technology? A new book entitled “The Starfish and the Spider” details the formation of many leaderless organizations since the Internet and Linux. The book also points out how leaderless organizations cannot be defeated by centralized organizations easily. While doing so, however, it shines further light upon the benefit and power of the trusting previously unheard of intellectual property into the hands of the community and competitors to derive tremendous benefit. They include the story of a Gold Mining Company which was struggling to find new sources of ore on its property. The CEO decided to publish all the highly important and often thought key proprietary information to the community and potential competitors. Within weeks of publishing the information, creative ideas began to flood into the company. They were able to find new ore and within months became one of the most successful mining companies in the world. This new mindset of trust and openness is a vitally important principal for success in this new global and highly competitive world. At a time when most would want to close up and protect their intellectual property, those who will be the leaders and most successful in these changing times will be those who can embrace this mindset.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ac30a5f5c3c4" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Love of Linux Chapter 11: The Business Model]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@ransomhlove/the-love-of-linux-chapter-11-the-business-model-ed437cf4fc9c?source=rss-c44b575286b0------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ed437cf4fc9c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[startup]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[tech]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[entrepreneurship]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ransom H. Love]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 24 Feb 2016 22:21:58 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-02-24T22:21:58.897Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>How do you make money on something that is basically free? That is the question that I have been asked almost from the first day that I became involved with Linux over twelve years ago. I believe the answer is becoming more obvious, but it was not when we were involved in Linux. A recent book entitled “Free: The Future of a Radical Price” by Chris Anderson provides a much broader history of the use of free and its future. Chris points out that with processing power and storage more than doubling every 18 months and bandwidth even more rapidly, the pressure toward everything digital being made available for free will be significant. Chris lists numerous examples of products and services that are moving or started free such as the gaming industry. Games have been traditionally a product centric business but the new games are available for free online and Chris predicts that nearly all games will so follow. They are far more profitable than the traditional product business, because there is almost no cost to distribute, they get direct access to those who are their target market, and they can make updates and enhancements for very little cost. They sell advertising in incredibly creative ways. Billboards or posters on buildings, clothes or other product endorsements are being included in the game, etc. Chris also does a paper napkin approach to determine how much money is being made in and around free software and came up with a $360 Billion dollar industry. This and the fact that Chris makes the statement that all things digital will be under pressure to be free, a little more than 10 years after we started with open source and Linux is both almost unbelievable but also very vindicating.</p><p>When we first started Linux, we felt open, free access and price, was the wave of the future but at the time consumers were not paying more for bottled water than for soda at the store. Nor had Google become a global power providing a free service by selling advertising. For us, finding the answer to the question of making money on Linux was truly a journey in faith.</p><p>In the technology sector, Linux and Open Source really pushed the envelope of free and in many ways paved the way for Google’s success by fueling the Internet infrastructure in an economical way. There were many times I felt like the young man left in a room filled with horse manure. Several hours latter when they returned they found him still digging through the manure. When asked what he was doing, he said, “With all this horse manure, there has to be a pony in here somewhere.” In this chapter, I will try to reveal the pony or ‘show you the money.’ But maybe more importantly, I will share some conclusions that have far greater application then just to Linux or to even the emerging free digital economy described by Chris Anderson. In this new world of the Internet with so much information, nearly every industry is feeling like they cannot keep up on the ever increasing tread mill of innovation. If they invest time and money into producing a product, they often do not have the product cycle long enough to get a return before a competitor has produced something better, faster or cheaper. It is a proven fact that nearly every major invention made was made by more than one person independently in totally isolated parts of the world. With the abundance of information made available from the Internet, inventions will continue at a pace unparalleled in history. There is a principle called the 100th monkey principle derived from a study made on isolated troops of monkeys. These troops had no way to communicate with each other, but almost simultaneously, each troop developed new eating behaviors. Apparently, the monkeys would not sweat potatoes that fell to the ground and got dirty. They would just get themselves another sweat potato. Then, usually a young male monkey in each troop decided to take the sweat potatoes down to the river and wash it off and eat the rest of it. Soon it became an accepted practice in all the troops. Some have questioned the “rapid adoption by unrelated troops” as not being conclusive in the original studies, but similar phenomena has occurred in humans.</p><p>Traditionally, the method of protecting ideas, inventions or what is called Intellectual Property (IP) was to get a patent. Today, often patents are primarily there to protect the investors. Historically it was a race to get to the patent office first. Now that is complicated because it is a global economy and it is not sufficient to protect your product in one market, you must register it in all major markets. Also, with the level of innovation that is taking place around the world, how can the patent office keep straight what is a new invention or if it even qualifies for a patent? I read an article that the patent office was going to experiment with a Wiki model for registering patents. Clearly, something has to change because there are so many patents that should not qualify to be patents. Even with a patent, it does not guarantee that you can enforce it. I am not against patents, but they are becoming harder and harder to enforce and more and more expensive to protect. A company can choose to spend its life in a court room making attorneys rich or they can learn some principles from watching the open source model mature. Some can argue that no one is really making money on open source. Clearly there are some examples where open source companies are doing relatively well, but none of them are extremely successful financially. However, there are many like Google that are making billions on free. In some ways, the same forces that make it difficult to make money on open source apply to nearly every other product in today’s market as I mention. The affects of technology innovation and the Internets explosion of information are fueling innovation. So as open source matures and solves some of these concerns, there will be a lot to again learn from Linux, the new Internet economy and the emerging digitally free models. In many ways, the Internet and open source are not only causing significant change in how we do business, but it is like a magnifying glass, simply exposing things that have already changed but we have not been able to see the signs as clearly and as quickly as before. This free exchange and broad availability of data is allowing us to see change quicker. The phenomena of “Who Move the Cheese” is heightened. I am reminded of a statement that Ray Noorda was quite fond of saying. Ray said that a company can fight change and die, accept change and possibly survive, create change and thrive. No one has a monopoly on good ideas. And with free flow of information and the ability to collaborate on projects around the world, innovation is going to continue at an amazing pace. So how does one protect their investment and bring something to market that they can reap a return on?</p><p>Caldera experimented with how to make money from open source software from the day that we were incorporated. In some areas, we helped pioneer many of these models in the Linux space and as a result have taken a lot of heat from the community. These models include:</p><p>1) Sell services not software (We did not believe this model could sustain itself)</p><p>2) Add proprietary value above Linux or the sale of a related product (Give away the razor and sell the blades)</p><p>3) Technology innovation (Hold and then release) or hold some features to create a “premium edition” for fee but release openly over time</p><p>4) Collaborative cost sharing with specialization — Customer focused solutions</p><p>5) Certified platforms/Subscription services</p><p>Something can be learned from each of these models and several of them or their combinations have proven successful. Each of these concepts is worth discussing:</p><p><em>Sell Services Not Software</em></p><p>One could argue that the “distribution” business was nothing more than a “service” since none of the companies who offered Linux owned anything. They were just packaging the software. The service only model is most conducive to the open source mentality and has always be accepted and promoted by the Linux community and industry. Caldera was not a pioneer of this model. Frankly, Cygnus and later Red Hat were the companies that are held up as companies who have been successful at this model. It is interesting that Cygnus, even before being bought by Red Hat were experimenting with other ways to make money. I listened to the CTO of Red Hat when he worked for Cygnus give several presentations and sat on several panels with him in which he justified moving to proprietary software because they needed more revenue potential. Red Hat is currently experimenting with a combination of the methods I am discussing with their advanced service product. The advanced server is a combination of technology innovation and certified platforms which I will discuss later. The point is, a pure services model is difficult to build a long lasting, profitable business on. Caldera did not heavily pursue this method because there are two major challenges with this model. First, it is difficult to scale. Services require people to provide them. A person can only physically handle a certain number of accounts or projects at one time. Consequently, to grow the business requires the company to increase overhead. Clearly, there are very successful service companies, but they are not as profitable and consequently as attractive to investors. The margins are much lower. There is one notable exception to the services model that may very well scale, the subscription model which I will also discuss later. The other challenge with selling services only, is that it is much harder to differentiate yourself from your competitors.</p><p>Service is about being where your customer needs you to be. It is difficult to compete in services against an IBM Global services, for example, because they are every where the customer needs them to be. You can target services to companies that fall below IBM’s targeted customer size or other requirements, but that greatly reduces you market potential. The recent announcement by Oracle that they intend to provide better support for Red Hat than Red Hat can on its own product illustrates this challenge. The original “distribution service” that started Linux is a good example of the inability of this model to be self sustaining. Cygnus and Red Hat both began utilizing this model because it is highly compatible with the open source mentality and thereby helped them establish market share. Of course, in the beginning, I think Red Hat made a lot more money on selling hats, shirts and other trinkets then on pure services with the exception of the distribution itself. It is important to point out that both Cygnus and Red Hat are held up as icons of successful open source, service based software companies and yet both Cygnus before they were acquired and Red Hat now, are experimenting with other business models to continue their growth. Selling services are an important extension of a business, but they will not be the main source of the business model with the exception of a “subscription” based solution.</p><p><em>Sell Value add above Linux or a related product</em></p><p>Caldera was the first to try a value added concept. In other words, add something proprietary above the Linux kernel and associated packages that the customer was willing to pay for. The Caldera Network Desktop, our first product, introduced a fully graphical desktop to Linux derived from the proprietary Visix technology. As described previously, Caldera spent millions of dollars licensing technology to move Linux forward and provide a reason for buying Caldera’s offering. The only one that really benefited from this effort as also mentioned, were the companies like Netscape, Star Division, Corel and others who owned the technology. Caldera was constantly accused of trying to take something from Linux when in reality; we spent far more on marketing Linux and licensing these technologies and received relatively little return. The problem with adding proprietary elements to open source is that it then clouds the license usage issue. One of the reasons the customer wants to buy open source, is that it is “free.” They want to be able to copy the software onto other systems. Having a license that permits copying and redistribution of software for some pieces and restricts others, simple confuses the issue. Customers will simply choose the less confusing solution even if it may not be as good. It only has to be good enough just ask Microsoft. As complete solutions are created that target specific customer segments, this may become more acceptable. The value-add model is however, the model most large companies like Dell, Hewlett Packard, Oracle and IBM are using. They do not make money on Linux; they simple sell more hardware, software or support. This model works fine for companies who have an established market share in either hardware of software products that benefit from having Linux present. In fact, the Linux model is ideal for companies like IBM who sell a variety of hardware, software and services. The challenge for most Linux companies was they did not have other products that can be sold as a result a free operating system.</p><p>The challenge with the value added model is that eventually the concerns of the product making money will dictate the direction of the operating system that is free. A good example of this is the “Unbreakable Linux” offered by Oracle. They have modified Linux so that their particular software will run faster and scale. Red Hat and SuSE (Formerly UnitedLinux) have agreed to integrate the necessary changes back into their respective products. This offers Red Hat and SuSE a chance to have an additional value proposition, the technology innovation advantage, for a period of time, but the agenda is set by the Oracle database. I am not suggesting that this is necessary bad, but what about the needs of the other database vendors? Does that relegate Linux to being a niche, customizable operating system platform? The real benefactor of this approach is Oracle and Oracle’s customers who chose to deploy on Linux. As mentioned before in an article I wrote several years ago, eventually, Linux will be driven by the needs of the hardware and software products that are making money. Another way to explain why this is potentially harmful to the best interests of Linux is to look closely at how the companies like Intel, IBM and Hewlett Packard market and position their Linux products and offerings. They do not position them to go after any Microsoft customers. They are targeting UNIX customers. Customers they do not have on Intel platforms. The one exception to that is IBM, because I believe they are were still smarting from losing to Microsoft on OS2. IBM appeared to market Linux as an alternative to Microsoft in some areas. At least, some divisions were not afraid of talking about it. These examples point out that if Linux makes money, it can begins to write its own agenda and will have broader market acceptance. If the company who is selling Linux is making more money on Microsoft products, they will not promote Linux as an alternative to Microsoft because they do not want to loose the revenue or the potential relationship with Microsoft. (This is why Microsoft carries such a big stick and it is so hard to pin them down on misdeeds. Many companies exclude Microsoft’s competitor’s offerings just because they fear Microsoft retaliation.) As I said before, this is not just about Microsoft.</p><p>What brings in the money, will have the mindshare of all those who are part of the distribution system. Therefore, if Linux, or any open source product, wants to be something other than a niche product, it must find a way to be financially self supporting. What I mean by financially self supporting, is that it must be able to not only cover development costs which are lower on Linux because of the collaborative development model, but all the cost to promote and support the specific customer solutions provided by that technology which are as much or maybe even more than more conventional software products because they are so different. These marketing costs require hard dollars so Linux companies must make hard profits. Consequently, while the value added model works well for companies like Oracle, IBM, Hewlett Packard and others because they have proprietary products and services who make incremental sales through promoting Linux, it does not work for Linux itself of for companies providing Linux. As I mentioned, Caldera was the first to try the value added model and we continued to experiment with it up until I left with products like Volution, a comprehensive management system for Linux. The challenge for a start up company with scarce resources is that it becomes difficult to decide on where those resources go. When you must invest resources into developing the operating system or core business, it is difficult to invest in the value-added or new business opportunities. This is difficult for businesses in all stages if they do not have a clear strategy or have lost touch with their customers. Often in mature businesses with products that have become cash cows, management often struggle where to put scarce resources and invest properly. This was true of SCO before we purchased them and apparently true for SCO’s new management and board as they seem to have gone back to what they think will bring them the most money, choosing UNIX over Linux. The value-add or new business model is particularly hard in start up mode because there is no established revenue base and you are just trying to stay alive. Consequently, for most Linux companies, a value-add model was very difficult. Companies like HP, IBM and Oracle could easily play this game because they have the base.</p><p><em>Technology Innovation (Hold and then release) or create a “premier edition” for a fee or a “Freemium”</em></p><p>Caldera also tried technology innovation, the hold and release proposition. At one time, Caldera felt that it could innovate and on the first release hold the technology proprietary and then subsequently release it under a social contract. Caldera’s innovative graphical installer, Lizard was just one attempt at this business model. Other companies like SuSE also experimented with this model with the drivers. The Linux community was suspicious of the company’s intents and usually, all that resulted was to launch an all out effort by the competitors to develop the same functionality as you have. This resulted in multiple ways of doing the same thing, duplication of effort, and fragmenting rather than creating standards. If your competitor happened to open source the technology before you did, they were the “heroes” and you were the “heals” for trying to take something away from the community. Rather than defining you as the technological leader, you start a cat fight in a highly competitive market. However, developing new technology that is released first as a “premier business edition” for a fee and then allowing those features to make their way into the free and open solution has been further evolved and proven to be a valid model for free. RedHat’s Advanced Server was an attempt to be trying at least some aspects of this concept combined with the certification platform to be discussed later. SugarCRM is another success story relating to this model. They have a commercial version of their open source effort. The Sugar CRM “premier edition” seems to be working. At the time we were involved in Linux, there were very few enterprise customers. To bring the company the most value in recognition and market share, it was better to innovate on the technology and just release the code openly rather than use it to garner more revenue for an extended time. Today, things are different. Combing richer features with a subscription model for business works and is becoming more accepted. Technology innovation can result in a very positive revenue stream while allowing the generic product to be fully open. When we experimented with this model, using a pure technology innovation model was very difficult because a single company could not keep up with the innovation of an industry. At the time, the innovative idea did not bring the company a lot of revenue or even recognition; it just showed the competitors what they need to do in their next release. What we hoped to ultimately do was to open source the Unix kernel, create a complete Linux application environment around either the Unix or Linux kernel, and a build and development environment that would allow our Replicated Site customers to select which ever kernel met their application needs. Our intent was to merge this with the UnitedLinux base to enable a unique platform for business that would provide, ISVs, VARs and corporate developers with the single most scalable operating system platform on the Intel hardware. We knew this would still not be enough of to get us out of this dilemma was to specialize and truly focus on delivering a total value proposition to a customer in a given market segment. So we would then offer a premier package with additional richer utilities and services for our VARs and Replicated Site customers that would facilitate the installation and management of their unique services on top of Linux.</p><p><em>Collaborative Cost Sharing and Specialization</em></p><p>I include the concept of a collaborative cost sharing in this section, not because it is a standalone business model, but I honestly believe that the UnitedLinux collaborative cost sharing would have saved enough resources to facilitate the needed specialization to sustain a competitive business model. Clearly, by not spending time and energy duplicating our efforts on the same basic bits and bites, each partner in UnitedLinux could have focused on delivering real business solutions to specific customers that will drive further financial success. The other benefit of the UnitedLinux model is the ability to create a much better product then each of participating companies could individually. The down fall of this model was demonstrated by the actions of SCO. The collective success is also based on all participating parties continuing to support the founding principles. When one of the major players pulls out, for what ever reason, it weakens the collective whole. For this reason, many will choose to go it alone. Unfortunately, to remain competitive in today’s world will require interdependencies that most are uncomfortable with. Those who continue to experiment with and take the risks necessary to perfect this model will eventually win, though it may require some failures before it is mastered.</p><p>How then does one really compete and maintain a defensible position against competition? The answer lies in truly understanding the customer and all the activities needed to meet the target customers’ needs. Linking those activities together in a unique way becomes the key. This is not new. Other commodity based industries, like the airlines, have struggled with these problems for years. SouthWest Airlines has done a masterful job of identifying their customer and building unique linkages between their activities to make if very hard to compete with them in their segment of the market. Michael J. Lanning in his book Delivering Profitable Value refers to this as delivering a complete customer experience or set of experiences. He correctly explains that deciding what value proposition the company is going to deliver to its chosen customer is what should constitute the business of the company. SouthWest is a great example of this principle. They specifically chose the market segment they were after and understood completely what decisions would enable them to deliver the decided value or customer experience to that market segment. This discipline has enabled them to remain profitable in spite of major tragedies like September 11.</p><h3>Delta Airlines Offers:</h3><ul><li>“Major” airports only</li><li>First-class seating</li><li>Baggage transfer</li><li>Meals</li><li>Varied fleet of aircraft</li></ul><h3>Southwest Airlines Offers:</h3><ul><li>Avoids Major airports</li><li>No first-class seating</li><li>No baggage transfer</li><li>No meals</li><li>Entire fleet of only 737 aircraft</li></ul><p><strong>Bottom Line: Bottom Line:</strong></p><p><strong>Higher Value = Higher Pricing Lower Value = Lower Pricing</strong></p><p>The most often requested change SouthWest receives is to have assigned seating and food. They choose to ignore those requests because they greatly increases their costs and thus force them to raise their price and jeopardize their on time departures which are primary reasons people fly SouthWest. There is a significant difference between being “customer compelled” or “internally driven” and in understanding the complete experience the company intends to deliver to customer and still make money. Lanning does an excellent job explaining how to avoid so many pitfalls associated with trying to deliver a true customer value proposition. A “customer compelled” company does not have the vision or leadership that SouthWest has to say no to it customers who are asking for food service on the flight. An Internally driven company thinks it understands what a customer wants because after all it talks to them all the time and their product managers have been in the business for years but nearly 80% of the time they are wrong. Having said that, I would like to list several key pitfalls I have watched companies, including Caldera, fall into:</p><p>1. Companies want to imitate <em>everything</em> about their competitors — assuming rivals know something we don’t or they want to have an expert like an analyst tell them what they are doing is correct. Unfortunately, this is more common than many may at first admit. This behavior occurs when management lacks direction or the leadership necessary to make the hard choices. Companies get so caught up in what their competitors are doing that they ignore their business, the customer.</p><p>2. Companies substitute operational effectiveness for strategy because it is more concrete and actionable. In other words, companies do what is easy, they continue to look at ways to cut cost out of the system rather then take the necessary gamble to develop new products that deliver real value to new customers. They continue to milk the cash cow even at the expense of new product development. Frankly, I experienced these phenomena at Novell. There was a core group of engineers that felt all they needed to do was make NetWare faster and more efficient. Unfortunately, Novell was unable to put the resources on new opportunities. These companies will fall victim to the Innovator’s Dilemma described by Clayton Christensen in his books and writings.</p><p>3. Companies become technology driven rather than having a “customer focus.” This is an example of what Michael Lanning calls “Internally Driven.” My personal experience is that some companies get caught up on delivering the latest and greatest technology. The stuff that excites the engineers but the real paying customer does not see its value. This is so easy to do in the information technology space.</p><p>4. Companies who are still technology driven but want to give lip service to “customer focus” find a customer who will tell them what they want to hear. This group is obviously a variation on the number 3. What happens after delivering a technology searching for a solution, they begin to say the answer lies in delivering value to a customer. The pitfall is that the technologies in the company run out and find a customer who agrees with their approach. Rather than taking the time to really understand the customer’s need, they seek for a customer that agrees with their approach.</p><p>5. Companies mistake “customer focus” to mean they must listen to just what the customer says he or she needs only. This is logical step after steps 3 and 4 have failed. Again, this approach requires little or no risk or leadership on the part of the company. They simply go out and listen to a customer and try to deliver a product based solely on that input. The challenge lies in the fact that the market and technology is changing rapidly. Many customers do not have insight into the new developments and how they would or would not benefit their business. They are busy running their own enterprises. I recall one CEO stating that if he developed exactly what is customer wanted, he would simply deliver a solution that is what they wanted 6 months or a year ago. This solution is the “customer compelled” company described by Lanning.</p><p>6. Companies often make no choice to avoid risking blame for making a bad choice often the result of having to choose between not doing one of two things. This is just another option some companies choose because they do not have the leadership to take a risk so they make a decision to not make a decision or they continue to focus on the things they know how to do as outlined in number 2 above.</p><p>To deliver a complete customer focused experience requires true strategic leadership. Those who choose this model must have the discipline to say “no” even to a customer when it will destroy the primary reason the customer is buying your product initially.</p><p> The challenge of developing or reestablishing a customer focused experience is often primarily an organizational one and depends on leadership</p><p> In many companies leadership has degenerated into orchestrating operational improvements and making deals as previously mentioned</p><p> General management’s core should be delivering a customer focused solution:</p><p>– Defining and communicating the company’s unique position</p><p>– Making trade-offs, and</p><p>– Forging fit among activities</p><p> Managers at lower levels lack the perspective and the confidence to maintain a strategy resulting in constant pressures to compromise, relax trade-offs, and emulate rivals</p><p> The executives’ jobs are to teach others in the organization about strategy — and to say no</p><p> Strategy requires constant discipline and clear communication</p><p> One of the most important functions of explicit, communicated strategy is to guide employees in making choices that arise because of trade-offs in the individual activities and day-to-day decisions</p><p>The solution to this</p><p>· A day in the life of a customer</p><p>· Brainstorm and determine what questions must be answered to reach the target audience</p><p>· Create a minimal viable product or a product that can effectively test and answer your critical questions or premises</p><p>· Test and monitor the audience</p><p>· Analyze the data and determine new questions that must be tested, alter the minimal viable product and repeat</p><p>· Once there is success, evaluate options (What is available?) on how to effectively deliver the solution</p><p>Build, partner, buy or integrate</p><p>· Clearly communicate to the company the results of the tests and the rationale behind the tradeoffs so they can make the choices</p><p>Much of the process described above to develop a truly customer focused solution has been well documented by Eric Ries in his book “The Lean Startup.” However, the forces that first exposed the need for continuous innovation where first encountered in the open source world but now apply to nearly all markets because of hyper competition. The advantage to this methodology in a highly competitive environment is that as the selected customer experience is delivered and the company is able to determine the needed tradeoffs or strategy to deliver that solution, their competitors cannot imitate them without having to make the same difficult choices. Michael Dell from Dell Computers after giving a presentation on his very innovative process for building and delivering basically built to order systems to a broad industry gathering was asked if he was concerned about his competition imitating his actions. He responded that he had absolutely no concern about his competitors imitating him. By the time they could duplicated the system, the industry has moved on and it would require them to alienate their existing customers and their value propositions. Delivering a complete customer experience to a targeted segment requires a company to specialize. Other companies must make the same tradeoffs in order to effectively compete. However, being able to obtain a real understanding of the customer’s desired experience and then make those internal trade offs requires real leadership at all levels of management, ability for the company as a whole to take risk which are disciplines most companies will need to acquire. Linux can play an invaluable role in delivering a complete customer focused experience because of its flexibility. Caldera was working toward this objective when I left. Books like “The Long Tail” are validating the fact that the economy is moving from hits to niches. Delivering customized solutions to specific customers who need those solutions. The traditional “barriers to entry,” old models to ensure success are being replaced by strategy and evolution. Determining and targeting the customer the company is uniquely capable and interested in servicing (not being all things to all people), assessing their needs and the best way of servicing those needs, and then get in the market and evolve as needed. Evolution does not mean the company must listen to everything the customer says but rather truly understand what the customer needs and adapt. I believe the companies that apply this concept will be successful even in this highly competitive market.</p><p><em>Certified Platform and Subscription Service</em></p><p>For any operating system to be deployed extensively by a reseller channel to businesses or into the enterprise, it must have two very core things:</p><p>1) Broad hardware support</p><p>2) Broad application support</p><p><em>Broad Hardware Support</em></p><p>Every hardware component that makes up a computer system has a piece of software that enables its use by the system called a driver. A standard PC or server is made up of many other hardware components e.g. a hard disk, a CDROM, a monitor, etc. Not only does a driver have to exist for each of these components, but they must be tested and certified to work together in a particular configuration. Computer manufacturers must test and certify that their new computer systems function with all the drivers and possibly operating systems supported. Computer manufacturers release new systems every nine to 18 months. Supporting an operating system on all these new configurations is very expensive because of the required testing and certification. Manufactures have a very strong interest in not supporting multiple operating systems. They must be motivated by either very strong market demand or pretty secure new market expansion.</p><p>This testing and certification is particularly true if the operating system is focused on a particular market niche that requires specialized hardware components. The software drivers that enable use of the latest hardware systems and components must be available shortly after the system or component is made available on the market or the market will not materialize. The hardware market turns quickly because of ongoing rapid innovation.</p><p>Open source does facilitate the development of drivers because the source code to the other similar drivers is readily available and can be utilized to develop the new driver. However, open source does little to reduce the cost of testing and certification. In fact, some could argue that it may actually increase the cost because the opportunity for change is introduced by having the source code readily available and rapidly changing. A concern raised by some software providers was if they certified to a single product and the source code were freely distributed, it could introduce additional support obligations and liabilities they were not interested in incurring. The business customer also does not want to have a widely distributed source base.</p><p>Broad hardware support refers to not only having drivers available for new hardware but having companies who have tested and certified those drivers to work well with their computer systems or products. Without broad hardware support, many application developers cannot even begin to write or port (move) their applications to a new operating system.</p><p><em>Broad Application Support</em></p><p>Applications are produced by software companies, value added resellers servicing a unique market niche or by the enterprise for in house consumption. Each new computer system and/or hardware device must also be tested to work with their existing or new application. Most software companies design their software to run across multiple operating systems and hardware platforms. However, each operating system and hardware device must be tested and certified to work with any given configuration. Value added resellers and some enterprises will significantly limit their choices of operating systems and hardware configurations to reduce their costs of this required testing and the complexities of supporting the different choices. Like the computer manufactures, these entities must be compelled to embrace a new operating system by either broad market demand or perceived, but quire real market opportunity. The challenge is quite difficult because it is cyclical. You must have large market demand for the hardware developers to write drivers and for computer manufactures to be willing to test and certify. Without the applications, there is very little market demand. The applications need the new hardware to take advantage of the new features.</p><p>Since the market dictates that Microsoft operating systems be supported on nearly all Intel based computer systems, testing, certifying and supporting another operating system on the same architecture is costly and unwanted unless it can bring new market growth. Eroding existing market share on the same platform is not interesting or compelling because of these costs. For computer, hardware and software manufactures selling the same number of units while increasing their testing, certification and support costs is not at all an incentive. Linux was able to gain acceptance because it grew with introduction of an entirely new market niche, the Internet. However, different distributions of Linux function differently when it comes to both hardware and software drivers and applications. The computer manufactures, value added resellers, application developers and enterprise customers will not tolerate more than two major flavors of Linux. Many want more than one because they do not want to experience the pain of working with another Microsoft, but they do not want more than two. Even with two, they now have to test and certify three different operating systems on the Intel architecture. Being one of those two platforms means that you can charge more for the “distribution” because it is tested and certified to work with all the major hardware and software solutions and the market cannot afford a third competitor on the same operating system platform. Both RedHat and SuSE Linux are utilizing this approach to charge corporate customers for their distributions through the subscription model described below.</p><p><em>Subscription Services</em></p><p>Once a product has broad hardware and software support, an annual subscription service not unlike annual maintenance and support can be generated. Business customers are willing to pay an ongoing service fee to ensure that the “certified platform” is updated with the latest security fixes and software enhancements. The subscription services would ensure that the changes and enhancements do not cause existing applications or hardware drivers to malfunction and protect against security breaches. Caldera intended to include the Unix Kernel in the UnitedLinux offering so that while it would be open sourced and basically be a Linux application environment, it would provide developers, VARs and enterprise businesses with a uniquely scalable, certified hardware and software platform.</p><p>Several trends are occurring in the software industry that will support this subscription model. The traditional software cycle is to produce and release a new version every 18 months to two years. New versions are often full of bugs and have many features that most customers are not interested in. New versions require significant costs in training and require hardware upgrades to support the increase footprint. This cycle has fueled the software and commodity computer industry for years but many customers do not need this service for some of their server applications and will be free to load other non-certified versions of Linux. The movement to Software as a Service or SaaS, will also legitimize the concept of an annual subscription as your computing infrastructure is in the cloud and not on your physical premises.</p><p>Companies that deliver digital products will have to find a way to make money when their core service is offered for free just like Linux. However, these same lessons still apply for nearly all other businesses that will have to find a way to compete in an increasingly competitive market where margins will shrink and their need to make a profit on decreasing product life cycles. The principles gleaned from Linux can provide guidance on how to differentiate, specialize and continue to provide real value to their customers.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ed437cf4fc9c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Love of Linux Chapter 10: The Open Company — Using Councils to Manage]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@ransomhlove/the-love-of-linux-chapter-10-the-open-company-using-councils-to-manage-cb6fadeb5261?source=rss-c44b575286b0------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/cb6fadeb5261</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[tech]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[business-strategy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[entrepreneurship]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ransom H. Love]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 24 Feb 2016 22:10:16 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-02-24T22:10:16.880Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Partially because of all of the negative experiences I had had working for other companies and having suffered injustice at the hands of large companies without any moral conscience, my dream was to create not only a financially successful business, but also an environment that people with integrity would be proud to be a part of. I knew my limitations, but I also know that when a talented group of people come together, united in a common cause, they can overcome and do just about anything. As discussed in a previous chapter, the key to create such an environment is at least three things 1) a vision that motivates discussed in the last chapter “For the Love of Linux,” 2) a personal empowerment and responsibility, and 3) an organizational structure that facilitates collaborative thinking. As described in the chapter on The Love of Linux, open source and the Internet are showing the world how collaboration can motivate people to produce higher quality products. This chapter expands on the principals in open source work groups can help provide an organizational structure that remove important formal and informal obstacles.</p><p>A manager in the company does not have all the answers, sometimes just a broader view. There is a strong misconception that in order to have any influence in a company, you must be a manager. I find that my biggest management challenges have been trying to help people realize that they can have far more influence in a company and be far happier if they do not pursue a management position for which they are not yet suited but feel they must have to be successful. The following parable somewhat illustrates this misconception:</p><p>A crow was sitting on a tree, doing nothing all day. A small rabbit saw the crow, and asked him, “Can I also sit like you and do nothing all day long?” The crow answered: “Sure, why not.” So, the rabbit sat on the ground below the crow, and rested. All of a sudden, a fox appeared, jumped on the rabbit and ate it.</p><p>A Management Lesson: To be sitting and doing nothing, you must be sitting very, very high up.</p><p>When information was scarce, being in a position at the top did allow a broader perspective, but with the explosion of information everyone is empowered. So many employees find it easy to criticize upper management and often do not understand the decisions made. Consequently, they feel that management do very little or nothing. Clearly, some of that criticism is warranted, but there is a serious management dilemma with the current information overloaded environment we live in. Employees have many of the facts available to them, but no responsibility. They hear about all the mismanagement and assume the worst. They treat upper management like referees of a highly contested sports event. They can always see the play better then the ref and so they become increasingly skeptical. They honestly feel they can do a better job than their manager and some probably could. After all what does management really do? Today, the answers to problems can often be found with the person closest to the problem if they are empowered to make the decision. There is no question that sometimes the most valuable input is not from a VP but from the person answering the phone.</p><p>One of the most impressive speakers that came to our executive MBA program was a woman CEO. She was running one of the most successful divisions of Mack Truck in Salt Lake City. Her division built cement trucks. She knew nothing about building trucks when she started, so she would go out on the shop floor and ask questions. She noticed that the mechanic putting on the finder had to grind down the same edge every time he put it on. She asked why he did not submit a change order on the part. He said he had made several change orders but they had been ignored. When she investigated further, she found out that the engineers did not want to make the alteration because of the costly approval process. Needless to say, she made a few changes and the mechanics on the floor started getting parts that fit without modification. In a similar fashion, often those closest to the problem can solve some of the most costly issues. In traditional organizations that are hierarchical, those on the bottom of the ladder feel as though they have no ability to influence change.</p><p>Consequently, hierarchical management structures do not adapt well to change. A book entitled The Starfish and the Spider explores the reasons why this is true. The structure also seems to get in the way of communication because information must flow up and then back down the organization. Hierarchical structures also seem to support the Peter Principle where people will have often risen to the level of their own incompetence. They may have out lasted their predecessors, or they may be the best politicians or they have sought management only to increase their influence or compensation without the necessary qualifications, talents or interests. The following parable illustrates a very true principle in business:</p><p>A turkey was chatting with a bull. “I would love to be able to get to the top of that tree,” sighed the turkey, “but I haven’t got the energy.” “Well, why don’t you nibble on some of my droppings?” replied the bull. “They’re packed with nutrients.” The turkey pecked at a lump of dung and found that it actually gave him enough strength to reach the lowest branch of the tree. The next day, after eating some more dung, he reached the second branch. Finally after a fourth night, there he was proudly perched at the top of the tree. Soon a farmer, spotted the turkey in the top of the tree, promptly shot him.</p><p>A Management Lesson: Bull might get you to the top, but it won’t keep you there.</p><p>Following the lead of the open source working groups, to change the traditional hierarchical structure Caldera began to experiment with councils. A council form of management is based on more of a matrix style of organization with a slight twist. A council is not a committee. It is not a staff meeting. Councils can involve people regardless of reporting structure. Councils are not as free flowing or self selective as the leadership selection methodology of the open source model of development, though these clearly have their place. The self appointed leadership method of open source and the fact that there is no monetary reward for efforts in open source, does help reduce the politics traditionally associated with management appointments. But not having compensation as a way to motivate or encourage performance, does make it more difficult to be accountable to specific timelines. After all, those working in that environment are doing so without compensation or for the love of it. This creates a management dilemma for anyone depending on the open source community to meet a business schedule. Many would argue that is why they like contributing to open source. They do not have a boss “breathing down their neck to produce something for a deadline. Besides, deadlines only produce poor software because they force delivery of code that may or may not be ready.” There is some truth to the fact that software is done when it is done and deadlines may not have much impact. Also, there is truth to the fact that if software is an art, it can be created better when done in love and not when paid for it. However, this methodology does not facilitate schedules and it makes virtually impossible to partner with other entities. To be successful in business, there must be road maps and schedules and someone accountable for deliverables even when some of the work may be produced by volunteer labor. I believe there is a way to allow one to actually get compensated for doing something they love to do. To allow them to do what they do best and love to do while enabling them to participate in key decisions that they may have better insight into even though they are not in management. The key to making that happen is empowerment and lies in the concept of councils.</p><p>The concept of a council incorporates some of the principles of collaboration and participation of the open source leadership model. In an open source environment, there is no monetary reward which simplifies the implementation considerably. In a council within the business environment like an open source working group, there is a specific individual who makes the final decision. In business, the chairman of the council is responsible for the outcome. The council members provide the council chair the necessary input to make the best possible decision, but the decision is not made by a democratic vote. In exchange for the right to participate in the decision, it is imperative that the council members support the decision of the chair person. Members of a council are responsible to the chair for the performance of their duties even if they also have a direct line manager.</p><p>A principle of a council that is not utilized in an open source work group setting is the concept that each member of the council can put items on the agenda and then step into the leadership circle and make assignments and silicate input from all participants even the chairman. The chairman coordinates and manages the agenda of the meeting and has ultimate say on assignments, but each member can and should take a leadership role in the council setting. At Caldera, we were not able to move to this level of empowerment.</p><p>The biggest challenge to implementing councils is the entrenched management structure and methodology. Managers feel they have earned the right to be where they are one the ladder. They have spent their entire careers getting to that their status, their compensation and perks are based upon where they have managed to get on the corporate ladder. Consequently, they continue to support their own agenda rather than playing as a team. Clearly, there will always be some outliers. However, given enough time, some can become converts or the power of the culture will expel them as described in Jim Collin’s “Built To Last.”</p><p>Clayton Christensen, author of the best selling book Innovator’s Dilemma, presented his follow on research in a presentation entitled “Creating Growth through Disruptive Innovation.” This research shows clearly that how you structure the organization will determine the ability of that organization to innovate. Many who are organized along traditional functional lines completely miss disruptive technologies that come along that enter the market at the low end and being to address areas of non-consumption. These technologies are very low cost and lack many of the functions needed to appeal to the broad market. However, they are “good enough” to fill a market need that is currently not being met. The incumbent companies initially ignore the technology because it does not take any of its customers away and lacks the ability to do so because many of the features needed do not exist. This is exactly what happened to the Santa Cruz Operation when Linux was being developed. However, as the technology matures and more functionality is added, it begins to take away customers. The incumbent companies seem unable to react. According to Clayton Christensen’s research, the lack of ability to react and effectively compete is directly related to how an organization is structured. I have with his permission included a diagram from that presentation that I feel provides tremendous guidance on how to structure an organization to accomplish the desired change or needed innovation.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*KQRgBKucly41oSf83tebeg.jpeg" /></figure><p>As you can see from the chart, the desired change or needed innovation in product and process determines the empowerment of the team or council. The need for innovation or change literally determines the corresponding need for the autonomy of the council. If all that is wanted is to improve performance of each component of an existing product, the traditional functionally aligned organization will provide the best structure for incremental change. However, if the very architecture of the product must change, then a heavy weight team or council is needed. A heavy weight council is one where the direct reporting of the team members is to the team lead with only a dotted line to the functional teams. If the business model or entire value delivery system must change in order for the product to be competitive, then the council or team must become an independent business unit with no ties to the functional organization.</p><p>This diagram and the incredible research behind it explains so clearly what we were trying to do intuitively at Caldera and what Linux working groups almost spontaneously arrived at. There are companies experimenting with matrix organizations which have many characteristics similar to councils. They are using a matrix to become more competitive and empower their employees. There pluses and minus such as some additional overhead associated with councils or matrix organizations, but the outcome in unity, empowerment and management experience in most cases is well worth the overhead. Councils can allow individuals with expertise, knowledge or interest in a given topic to participate and contribute to significant efforts within the organization without having to climb the ladder of the organization. Their different views of the problem can contribute to a more complete picture of the solution and will likely be more accurate. The council can then test their ideas through the minimal viable product concept; they can learn and pivot as needed to arrive at comprehensive and effective needed change. If the team is able to make the necessary changes and when possible affect the bottom line, a portion of the savings or income resulting from their efforts could be used as compensation or bonuses for the team members. It would not take long for others to volunteer and seek to contribute their time, talents and interest to key projects. Furthermore, the pressure to climb the ladder simply to seek the financial rewards will be reduced and individuals could bloom where they were planted, contribute to the success of the organization in profound ways and be fairly compensated.</p><p>At Caldera, we began to implement councils but were consumed with cost cutting measures of getting the business profitable during an economic down turn and we were not able to fully break away from the traditional paradigm. We were also not able to experiment on how to compensate people based on their contribution rather than based on the position as we were not able to allow the council to function. Unfortunately, changing this paradigm throughout the business community may require a crisis. This concept is also confirmed in Dr. Christensen’s research. Strategy does not drive new product development or innovation but rather, crisis or opportunities that demand a response actually drive new products that result in strategy. The reason for this to a large degree lies in an organizations rigidity to change. Some how we are going to have to really look honestly at the hierarchical systems and process that we have been carrying more from tradition. The days of the all talented manager are really over. To remain competitive, we need the collective thinking and support of every member of the company. We need to empower people at all levels of the organization to do the Right Thing at the Right Time for the Right Reason. We must also learn to compensate, not base on a position on a corporate ladder, but on contribution. There is far more to learn from Linux than the code that is produced by the open source community. I think that councils, or the principles they represent as seen in Linux working teams, will play a role in this needed evolution.</p><p>K7S�� i��</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=cb6fadeb5261" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Love of Linux Chapter 9: The Love of Linux — A Lesson for Business]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@ransomhlove/the-love-of-linux-chapter-9-the-love-of-linux-a-lesson-for-business-8710b155d955?source=rss-c44b575286b0------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8710b155d955</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[tech]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[management]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[entrepreneurship]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ransom H. Love]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 24 Feb 2016 21:43:25 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-02-24T21:43:25.959Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Why have so many people invested so much for this thing called Linux? When you consider that Linux has been a volunteer effort for the most part, you really need to ask why so many would give so much to write and share their efforts with others or why companies like Caldera would put so much time and money into Linux. The question needs to be answer, not just to understand the motivations behind Linux, but to draw much broader conclusions to answers that are plaguing businesses in many different industries. I do not propose to know all of the motivations but I would like to explore just a few for the benefit of what can be learned from them:</p><p>1. To make a difference and change the world</p><p>2. Reaction to Microsoft</p><p>3. Just for the Love of it</p><p>4. To participate in a revolution</p><p>5. To make money</p><p><em>To make a difference</em></p><p>While I have tried to categorize some of these motives for the purpose of discussion, the truth is most people’s motivation is a combination of these and others. I listed “A chance to make a difference” as the first because fundamentally, I believe those who have been working with Linux even from the very beginning felt that Linux was different. The model of collaborative development was so compelling and liberating. Nearly everyone in the IT industry have worked with companies who made such major trade offs on quality to ship a product. Those developing these products have wanted to do more than their company’s permitted them to do. In some ways, the rigid, hierarchical management structures of business have stymied creativity and innovation. Many decisions are made strictly on dollars or for self serving motivations. Many good people want to do more. They recognized that there are so many needs in the world that can be fulfilled that are not because they do not have a specific profit motive or benefit. The open source model of Linux opens the door to creativity and empowerment without the political and financial constraints that keep good people from doing the “right thing.” I am not saying the business constraints are “bad,” they are not. However, so much that is done in business under the name of fiscal restraints are based on self serving motives or tradition. Consequently, many people would like a chance to do the “right thing, for the right reason at the right time.”</p><p>I remember sitting in the audience when the first President of the United States addressed Comdex, the largest IT trade show in the United States. Bill Clinton came to Comdex and spoke to the group about what he called the “digital divide.” I do not like a lot of what Bill Clinton did and stood for personally, but I really enjoyed what he had to say to this group. The “digital divide” is basically, that here in the United States and around the world within blocks of each other, there are students within one school who have all of the tools and equipment to participate in the “digital” world. And yet, sometimes within 8 to 10 blocks away, the students in another school have little or no opportunity to get the training. President Clinton was making a plea to the individuals to do what they could to help fill in the “digital divide.” I sat through the presentation and could hardly keep my seat. I was either sitting next to “Maddog” Hall or I ran into him right after the speech and we both agreed that the answer to the digital divide, in a large degree, was Linux. Linux can run on older hardware or on very inexpensive hand held devices. Linux had all of the features to get the under privileged kids or underdeveloped countries on the Internet for pennies on the dollar. Taking the new hand held computers; wireless and satellite technology, schools and countries can be online and participating with the rest of the world on the Internet for very little investment.</p><p>Linux has also helped educate students and enthusiasts on Linux and Internet services. While I cannot speak for Linus, I believe his primary interest in writing a terminal emulator to improve Minix but the terminal emulator “grew legs.” Since it evolved into more of an operating system, he wanted it POSIX compatible. Minix, and now Linux, because the source code was open, has helped computer students and enthusiasts learn not only Linux, but many different Internet protocols and services. Some of your best programmers are self taught and under 20 years old. I remember flying to Phoenix to speak to a group of businessmen. During the lunch I spoke with a man whose main programmer was a kid in high school who had taught himself Linux and Java. Linux has and will continue to make the world a much better place. I also believe that the principals unleashed by Linux and open source have and will yet significantly change the computer industry and the world. Center 7 another Canopy company with a very large data center was testing the 4th fastest computer in the world that was all based on Linux clusters, super computer capabilities on commodity hardware. Using wireless and satellite and commodity PCs or even the new hand held devices, Linux can help bring the world together, lower the barriers to participate and fill in the digital divide.</p><p>I have been to China several times and have been incredibly impressed with the people. They are extremely bright. I remember once I was asked to speak at a key note in Beijing. Before the talk, I met with a group of press and analyst. They had brought in a professional translator. After answering a few of their questions, I realized that none of them really needed the translator. They understood my English though they were a little embarrassed to speak it. More importantly, they asked more intelligent questions about what was happening in the United States IT market than some of the United States analysts had. Since then, I have investigated a little more. The Government has stressed learning English in all their schools and have brought in many English speaking teachers into their Universities to give them the opportunity to learn to hear it spoken. I believe there are more English literate people in China than in the United States; they just have not had the opportunity to speak it. When I went back to China recently to attend Oracle World, I met two college students on the Great Wall and had a wonderful conversation in English. On the Internet, using email, they will not need to speak English, just read and write it. Given how much Linux lowers the cost of computing, China will leap frog many other more developed nations tied to old infrastructure. What will that mean? What about Eastern Europe, Latin America and many other areas of the world? Language, religious, governmental barriers will come down as the Linux and the Internet facilitate communication and the principles of open source empower these individuals to really make a difference. What about the students down the street who now can afford to get on the Internet? The Internet and the up coming onslaught of web services have and will make location irrelevant. Companies and individuals will be able to offer their services from a shack in the middle of China. While this is a wonderful thing from a humanitarian perspective, it will also heighten competition and continue to cause change in the business environment. Linux has permeated nearly every educational institution around the world. When those students go to work, they will take Linux with them. It has and will change the world dramatically. Linux is about giving back, sharing with others who are less fortunate. It is about collaboration and innovation. It is about removing political and financial constraints and unleashing the power of the individual to do something or give something back to make the world a better place.</p><p>Obviously, Linux can solve many of the technology problems facing the world and it will be a solution to a great many problems, but the real power of Linux is in the model that unlocks the power of those who created Linux. This freedom and empowerment offered by open source, allows great minds to solve great problems in an environment of collaboration and in the absence or at least reduced greed and politics. This power is not in the open source license as some propose; it is in the principles that are partly incorporated in the license and in the methodology of Linux. If these principles were adopted in a business environment and a similar environment of empowerment could be created, that company would be both financially successful and make the world a much better place. The age old proverb that it is better to teach a man to fish than to give him a fish applies. Linux, the technology is like the fish. It will do a great deal to satisfy hunger, but the principles that made Linux successful are the most valuable to understand. Linux will make a significant difference as a technology, but the principles by which it was created could revolutionize business and the world if we have ears to hear and eyes to see.</p><p><em>Reaction to Microsoft</em></p><p>The second major reason for participating with Linux is a reaction to Microsoft. Many individuals and now companies see Linux as the only real alternative to Microsoft, however, Apple sure has made some inroads over the last few years. In many ways, Linux is the antitheses to Microsoft’s business model. I once gave a talk about how much Mircosoft had influenced the creation and continued to provide a major motivation for Linux. This is not a personal attack on Microsoft. Unfortunately, or fortunately, Microsoft is held up as the epitome of American business. In many ways they are the epitome of what some people hate about business and others covet. They practice the business doctrine of the end justifies the means and they have been incredibly successful. Those who criticize their tactics are accused of being jealous. Unfortunately, many of those who do criticize Microsoft are jealous. These competing businesses would do exactly what Microsoft has and continues to do if they were in Microsoft’s shoes. This is evidenced by the way they do business today in their respective businesses. Regardless, Microsoft is an American business icon and there are many good people who would really like to see a viable alternative to the way Microsoft does business.</p><p>I know that at Caldera, we were looking for a way to compete with Microsoft by changing all their rules. IBM had proven with OS2 that you cannot beat them at their own game, so change the game. Many programmers are also fed up with the junk that Microsoft released. Microsoft would always hype the market and then deliver something so inferior. It was just good enough to sell. They would finally get it right on the third or fourth release. The other complaint was that Microsoft would focus on the appearance and they would have little or no depth to their products. Developers, I had explained to me, enjoy depth. They like to buy something because it was really neat, but then weeks latter they love finding out what more it could do that they did not even realize it could do when they bought it. Microsoft’s products had a great appearance and gave you a great sense of expectation, but when you got under the covers, it was very superficial. Scott McNeally, of Sun Microsystems described Windows once as “dog manure with whipped cream on top.” For those who pride themselves on quality, they get a little frustrated that consumers would buy such poor quality products. Another anti-Microsoft reaction was the injustice of having to compete against them when they did not play fair. Not only were they the 500 pound gorilla, they played by the rule the “end justified the means.”</p><p>A common sentiment in the Industry was that Microsoft would first partner with you simple to find out how you did things then duplicate them and put you out of business. They were the bully. I recall Ray Noorda mentioning that Microsoft offered to buy Novell at least twice only to get access to their books and then call off the deal. They did things just because they could and then would merely laugh at the law and anyone who accused them of wrong doing. To this day, I still do not understand how some companies and individuals who has been convicted of breaking the laws of this land can walk away with little or no penalty. The truth is everyone has bullies like Microsoft in their lives. Unfortunately, many are encountered in business. Many managers, CEOs and others are almost narcissistic. There is a common criticism among journalists who are favorable to Microsoft that the competitors are just jealous of Microsoft’s success. In many cases, I would have to agree. In many of my experiences in the industry, if the tables were turned, Microsoft’s competitors would do exactly what Bill Gates had done. Linux was a chance to take on the bully and fight him on different terms and it continues to be a motivation for many who participate with Linux. Linux provides a since of justice that cannot be had in a court of law. It is justice in action and it gives the individual power to do something.</p><p><em>Just for the Love of it</em></p><p>Having worked with many computer programmers over the years, I believe they are in many ways frustrated artists or engineers. They feel very strongly about the work they do. It is more then code, it is art. They love to create, but a beautiful creation that no one sees looses a great deal of its value. A civil engineer or architect creates something on paper like a building or a bridge and then are able to point to the structure and say I did that. That’s why we have museums. To share the great art of the world so everyone can enjoy its beauty. Open source is the world’s museum for programmers. Traditionally, when we compiled source into binary code that the computer needs to function (the hardware only understands 1s and 0s, but programmers write in near English sentences. Compilers translate what is written into 1s and 0s. There is nothing pretty about 1s and 0s), we hid the work of programmers from the world. They could only talk about it at the water cooler, like the infamous fish stories of the one big one that got away. No one could appreciate the beauty of what they had accomplished except sometimes a peer who happened to work by them. Open source changed that for ever. However, it is not just publishing the source that makes it attractive to developers. There are many open source projects that have little or no support. Linux has gained International attention. Thus, if you can contribute to Linux and get your code accepted, it could literally be seen by hundreds and even thousands. The world can now appreciate the art. To programmers working on Linux, the proof was in the code. They did not have to win the argument in words that were spoken in meeting after meeting. They could just code it and prove that it could work. Consequently, Linux is honest, gets rid of the debate and provides for open expression and recognition.</p><p>At a time when world wide productivity is at an all time low, how do we motivate people to not just do what is required but to go the extra mile? Linux is a shinning example of people going the extra mile for something and therefore offers some strong lessons. Clearly, businesses must allow their people to feel like they are contributing to something bigger than themselves. “Built to Last” suggests that every company should have a Big Harry Audacious Goal or BHAG. Contribution to something that will make a difference is a tremendous motivation. The environment within the business must have a sense of fair play and justice. It must be a part of the culture so that it becomes self culling. Again, “Built to Last” suggests that culture plays a major role in the success of a company long term. Managers, employees, cannot be allowed to bully. Also, empowering them so that they can contribute without the red tape and layers of administration or approvals or feeling that they have to go into management in order to influence the direction of the company is a significant motivation. In the open source world, each programmer who contributes code participates in a group of contributors. Each is given an opportunity to critique the submission. The self appointed head of the group will listen to the discussion about the best approach and then make a decision. Everyone accepts the decision and the group moves on. This is basically a council process described above and can be implemented effectively in business to empower and engage the companies best thinking.</p><p>Like Linux work groups, in business, when a contribution is made, we must find a way to compensate, reward and recognize that contribution. That would do a great deal to motivate our employees. Finally, finding a way to enable all to participate and contribute even when their ideas are not exactly main stream empowers and motivates.</p><p>The love of Linux is not just fueled by self expression or participating in something bigger than you. It comes from an empowering leadership paradigm that begins with Linus Torvalds. People do not want to be managed, they want to be led. I believe that much of the success of Linux lies in the personality and leadership qualities of Linus Torvalds. Much of what Linus did for Linux seemed to come naturally to Linus. In some ways, his combination of personality and belief systems combined and did the right thing at the right time for the right reason. As I mentioned before when discussing how we got involved with Linux while at Novell, Linus’ approachable, open nature allowed for everyone to contribute their own ideas to him without fear of reprisal or ridicule. Linus would listen or read their inputs and respond in a way that everyone felt like at least he they had had a voice and input in the decision. No one went away feeling that he was arrogant and unwilling to listen. This is not to say that Linus did not have very strong opinion on some subjects. He did. He was not a spineless leader. Rather, he made everyone feel that they were his peer.</p><p>I never attended a key note or read an email from Linus where he was not gracious of the contributions that so many had made. In listening to him speak; everyone sensed a real humility, honesty and naturalness to Linus that inspired confidence and loyalty. Another key component of Linus’ successful leadership style was his willingness to not step into things that either did not interest him or he felt were none of his business. Linus did not pick sides in the distribution debates and seldom if ever commented, at least openly, on debates about whether or not things should be charged for. He did support commercialization efforts, and willing gave his interpretation of the license supporting a more liberal interpretation of the GNU Public license to support driver and other efforts. Linus showed very good judgment in his decisions which attracted eventually thousands of extremely talented people who graciously donate time, efforts, energy and real resources in a true effort of love. There were other “open source” alternatives in the market at the time that was far more advanced than Linux. One of the key reasons Linux was the choice of so many people, including Caldera, was Linus’ honest, open, humble, yet strong leadership.</p><p>This lesson is so critical in today’s business environment. Much of what is done in business today is done under the “do it because I told you to do it.” Linus shows a shinning example of how to lead, not manage, or coerce people to do great things. Joseph Smith, the first president of Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, was once asked how he could possibly govern the very fast growing population of the Church. He made a very profound statement, “I teach them correct principles and let them govern themselves.” It is not enough give lip service to the principles or guiding core values of a business, they must be practiced. I honestly believe that people are crying for leaders who they can follow. Many of the leaders in business lack integrity or are so self centered. Linus has demonstrated that type of integrity that inspires others to follow willingly.</p><p>In his pamphlet entitled “Good to Great and the Social Sectors,” published in 2005 as a supplement to his book “Good to Great,” Jim Collins comments on what it will take to be successful in management in today’s information rich environment. He states the following:</p><p>The complex governance and diffuse power structures common to non-business led me to hypothesize that there are two types of leadership skill: Executive and legislative. In executive leadership, the individual has enough concentrated power to simply make the right decisions. In legislative leadership, on the other hand, no individual leader — not even the nominal executive chief — has enough structural power to make the most important decisions by himself or herself. Legislative leadership relies more upon persuasion, political currency, and shared interests to create the right conditions for the right decisions to happen. And it is precisely this legislative dynamic that makes Level 5 Leadership particularly important to the social sectors.</p><p>Our good-to-great research uncovered that leadership capabilities follow a five-level hierarchy with level 5 at the top. Level 5 leaders differ from level 4 in that they are ambitious first and foremost for the cause, the movement, the mission, the work — not themselves — and they have the will to do whatever it takes (whatever it takes) to make good on that ambition…</p><p>The executive versus legislative distinction remains a working hypothesis, awaiting rigorous research. If empirical evidence validates the distinction, it is unlikely to be as simple as “business sector = executive” and “social sector = legislative.” More likely, there will be a spectrum, and the most effective leaders will show a blend of both executive and legislative skills. The best leaders of the future — in the social sectors and business — will not be purely executive or legislative; they will have a knack for knowing when to play their executive chips and when not to.</p><p>There is an irony in all this. Social organizations increasingly look to business for leadership models and talent, yet I suspect we will find more true leadership in the social sectors than the business sector. How can I say that? Because, as James MacGregor Burns taught in his classic 1978 text, Leadership, the practice of leadership is not the same as the exercise of power.(James MacGregor Burns, Leadership, (New York: Harper &amp; Row, 1978), pp 9–28.) If I put a loaded gun to your head, I can get you to do things you might not otherwise do, but I’ve not practiced leadership: I’ve exercised power. True leadership only exists if people follow when they have the freedom not to. If people follow you because they have no choice, they you are not leading. Today’s business leaders face highly mobile knowledge workers. The face Sarbanes-Oxley, environmental and consumer groups, and shareholder activists. In short, business executives don’t have the same concentration of power they once enjoyed. Level 5 leadership combined with legislative skill will become even more important to the next generation of business executives, and they would do well to learn from the social sectors. Indeed, perhaps tomorrow’s great business leaders will come from the social sectors, not the other way around. (Jim Collins, Good to Great and the Social Sectors, (Jim Collins, 2005) pp 11–13).</p><p>Linus is a prime example of a Level 5 leader. In fact, nearly all the development managers combine the legislative and executive leadership skills. All of the developers who manage the different components are self-appointed. They volunteer and remain the leader as long as they can effectively do the job. If the load gets to be too much, they step down and allow someone else to take over. Evaluation on how well they do is done entirely by their peers. The collective group solves the problem and the solution is also critiqued in a similar manner. If someone can improve on the work, they are free to do so and then contribute the solution back into the code base. This collaborative or legislative from of management is very close to the “chaos” theories of management that many feel are the utopia. Clearly, from one perspective they are utopia. Every thing is done without deadlines and expectations. It is done when it is done. Contributions are easy to make and ones contribution is easy to see in the code as it still contains your copyright.</p><p>The love of Linux and the leadership rather than management paradigm provides a powerful, compelling motivation to participate even without compensation. As Jim Collins suggests, the most successful leaders of the future in both the business and social sectors could learn something from the open source management example. Individuals, employees, communities, companies and nations are crying for true empowerment and leadership. What would be the potential of a company that could offer that environment to its employees?</p><p><em>To Join a Revolution</em></p><p>Finally, there are those frustrated souls who are not interested in change or evolution; they feel the only chance to save the world is revolution. They are not satisfied with making the world a better place through their contributions; they want to force the world to change. They are convinced that their way is the only way and they would do everything in their power to make sure everyone accepts their views. Unfortunately, there are many associated with Linux that have been caught up in the revolutionary cries of some of the more radical leaders of the movement. I do not mean to criticize the efforts or intentions of these individuals. Many of these well meaning individuals have contributed a great deal to making Linux a reality, and for that, I am personally grateful, but they often get in its way of reaching its potential. Revolution in all its forms throughout the ages strikes fear into hearts of the very organizations and businesses that can best benefit from the ideologies they profess. Often revolution results in the destruction of all that is good as well as all that is bad. I have always been a proponent of evolution rather than revolution. Evolution requires compromise. To some, compromise means defeat. I have found, more often than not, that compromise or better yet synergy can actually result in a better solution. Listening to another’s point of view or as Stephen Covey states “seeking to understand before being understood,” results in tremendous solutions. Once you better understand the problem, the two of you can then work together to solve the problem. Regardless, Linux does provide a peaceful way of expression for those whose ideas are better given an outlet.</p><p><em>To make money</em></p><p>The motivation of making money seems very hard for many in the open source developers to understand. Again, some who are involved with Linux are there to exploit it, or make as much as possible with as little as possible effort. Maximize your investment. Many in the Linux industry feel that this motivation is “evil” or that it is taking advantage of the volunteer efforts of others. It is not. Our entire economic system is based on the principles that we are all self motivated. I personally feel that money is a by product of good business and good business is about solving people’s needs and problems. Unfortunately, so many feel that money is the end and therefore all their actions to get money are justified. It is no wonder; the developer is weary of the businessmen. Because the developer has made a significant contribution, they feel they have if not “ownership,” a vested interest in the project. They should feel that they have ownership as it is a key motivator for participation. The misunderstanding occurs when the developer feels that once the code has been produced, that is all that is important. What they do not recognize is the cost of development of a product is often only 18 to 20% of the total cost to get a solution to market and into the hands of the customer who needs it. Open source has been a tremendous innovation on how to develop a technology in a collaborative manner. But, having the development work done primarily by the Internet community does not eliminate the cost of packaging and marketing Linux so that it can be made useful to a business.</p><p>No one buys technology. They buy a solution. To be a solution, it must have applications and be tailored to meet a specific solution or set of solutions. It must be delivered with support, documentation, and through a channel familiar or trusted by the business. The average business man must know of its benefits and they must know of others who have successfully implemented the solution. They must know that there is someone accountable, that they can call if there is a problem who is motivated to resolve his problem because his livelihood depends upon it. Shortly after the announcement of the SCO acquisition, Oracle called a meeting with us. They spent nearly the whole time expressing their frustration with dealing with the Linux community. They had spent much time and resources trying to get some of their changes into Linux in order to have Oracle function optimally. They needed someone to point to and say, we need this done will you do it. The same is true for regular businesses. They need accountability because they are accountable. It is very difficult to run a business not knowing when to expect a finish product and not knowing where the product is going. In reality, seldom do we produce something on time or does the road map we lay out end up being where we end up, but business does need more predictable outcomes.</p><p>All of this effort takes nearly 80% of the total cost to deliver the solution. The difficult thing is that this part of the equation can not be done through collaborative methods. Clearly, the word of mouth factor is amplified through the Internet and collaborative methodology of open source. Companies can literally watch and observe the development of the technology unfold. They can and do choose to participate when they feel the technology is ready to be deployed in there companies and then they contact the supplier. Companies, who deploy open source solutions, still want and need the complete product infrastructure. To pay for all of these items, requires money, real money. To illustrate, let me ask the question, why has Oracle announced its own support for the Red Hat distribution? Clearly, Oracle feels somewhat vulnerable without an operating system of its own in a highly competitive environment. Oracle’s original support of Linux was motivated by Microsoft. Oracle was concerned that while Microsoft had an inferior database, with the increasing power of the Intel platform, even an inferior product could be good enough and scale pushing Oracle higher and higher up the food chain. Microsoft’s recent announcement with Novell may have been a motivating factor in why Oracle announced support for Red Hat directly, but the reality is Red Hat as a company does not have a very robust infrastructure world wide to support their own product. This is one of the primary reasons, Caldera bought SCO. We needed a global infrastructure. Even today, Red Hat does not have the infrastructure world wide to provide a complete product solution to its customers or more importantly, to Oracle’s customers to develop that infrastructure is highly costly and the margins on Linux alone make it difficult to maintain, let alone develop, that infrastructure.</p><p>In the hay day of Linux, it seemed like money grew on trees. All you had to tell an investor was you were doing Linux and the money came. That was not what it was like early on and especially now. Linux has to be self reliant. The way to protect Linux from those who will exploit it, is for it to be financially self sufficient — that means not just covering the cost of developing the core technology. You have to be able to pay for all of these costs and there has to be enough return to appease the investors. How we make enough money to be self reliant is the next chapter. However, one of the key tensions between the open source developers and the distribution companies is that the developers perceive that someone has been making money at their expense. They do not recognize or appreciate the costs associated with delivering a solution. They are artists. Once they have finished the painting, they are done. They do not appreciated the other costs and contributions made. I do not know of one Linux distribution company that has not contributed far more back than they ever received from Linux. I believe that will change as the market matures, but I know that Caldera has spent millions and millions of dollars with very little return yet.</p><p>Some may ask: Why would IBM and Oracle support Linux? Linux is making them money. Linux enables them to either sell more hardware or software which is a legitimate way to utilize open source. Oracle has been trying for years to tell the world that the operating systems is irrelevant, because they do not own one and feel very vulnerable to Microsoft because they do not have one. They love an open source project that they can utilize without having to deal with the company that has provided it. IBM also loves Linux. It has sold many mainframes. The challenge for Linux is that if all the money is being generated from things other than Linux. These motivations are not bad. Linux would not be viable if it did not attract all these players. But, it is vital to understand that the things that generate the money will drive the agenda. If Linux itself is not self sufficient, it will be at the mercy of the things that do make money. I was asked to submit an article on my thoughts on Linux shortly after the bubble burst. I have included it in its entirety because it addresses this issue:</p><p><strong>Linux: The Dawn of a new day… Not the setting of the sun</strong></p><p>With the downturn in the economy, the drop in Linux companies’ share prices and recent announcements by nearly all Linux companies of layoffs, reduced revenues and management changes, many may think that the sun has set on Linux. They could not be further from the truth. The expectations by some in the industry for Linux are analogous to a parent expecting their teenager to successfully complete college before graduating from high school. Few, if any, have the maturity to make that jump.</p><p>To move from adolescence to adulthood one must uphold the law, utilize knowledge and experience outside the immediate family, seek specialized training to be able to provide for a family and seek companions that will help them mature faster. Maturation is often very painful because it requires self-discipline as well as accepting responsibility and accountability for one’s actions.</p><p>The successes and failures of teenagers as they strive to cross the chasm between adolescence and adulthood do not greatly concern us or diminish their potential in our eyes. In fact, we applaud and encourage them to continue to try because we know that those who are often the brightest, with the most potential will have as many or more failures before they reach their potential.</p><p>As a father of seven children, three of which are teenagers, and as a founder of Caldera, I know whereof I speak. The Linux industry is as complex to understand as a teenager. The challenges facing Linux have nothing to do with potential, or even past successes, but rather with maturity. To attain maturity, I suggest the following five things for the Linux industry.</p><p>Learn from and honestly evaluate successes and failures</p><p>Uphold standards</p><p>Develop and/or embrace mature business channels outside of retail</p><p>Specialize</p><p>Seek compatible companions that will help it mature faster</p><h3>Evaluate Successes and Failures</h3><p>The Linux industry and the Open Source development model have had tremendous successes that have changed the information technology landscape for good. The Open Source development model facilitates collaboration and innovation that has few parallels. Linux, as a technology, has matured much faster in its development than any other technology or operating system. However, Open Source still leaves something to be desired — even as a development model.</p><p>An Open Source model does not provide a complete road map of where the technology is going as the outcome and timing of Open Source development is even less predictable than traditional methods. Open Source is like the ideal sand box for a developer — lots of technology to play with and no one giving assignments or deadlines. This is great for development but not great for business.</p><p>Some are taking advantage of the Open Source model for marketing purposes. Companies have published old or obsolete technology under the guise of contributing back to the community or improving their standing within the community. Others hope to get free development. Some even market the collaborative model so that they can take credit for the work or innovation of others simply by association. Open Source is not a license to steal or borrow ideas from others and take credit for that development. Nor is it a free ride for development. Open Source is a way to collaboratively develop projects that lend themselves to a collaborative model of development.</p><p>Even so, Open Source has made a significant contribution to the way software is and will be developed. It has proven to be a method of development worthy of further review and refinement. We can mature the model by developing roadmaps and improving timelines and deliverables.</p><p>While the development model shows great potential, the business model for open software needs some additional work. If we want to support the development model of “free” software, we must come to realize that someone has to make money. If a Linux provider does not become profitable, the only companies who will continue to invest will be those who have a different agenda. The money they make will be from different sources and their primary allegiance and motivation will be other sources of revenue. If Linux becomes simply an enabling technology, its interests will be subservient to other industries.</p><p>IBM is a prime example. Linux is an enabling technology for IBM. Linux enables IBM to sell IBM’s own software, hardware or additional services. If Linux providers can achieve a successful business model, this is good because IBM provides valuable validation and is an invaluable partner. If IBM is left to provide Linux on their own, the interests of the groups within IBM making money will take precedence over what is good for Linux.</p><p>Linux providers must be free to experiment with business models that have a profit motive. The Linux industry is going to have to mature into a real industry or it will be relegated to a catalyst for existing industries like hardware or software. The Linux community must allow the Linux providers to make money or the rising sun will not be Linux. The industry as a whole needs healthy Linux providers or we will return to the fragmented days of UNIX with hardware driving the platform and differentiation.</p><h3>Uphold Standards</h3><p>So what is needed for Linux to mature and reach its potential as an alternative business platform? The answer is similar to the maturation of teenagers. They must first realize that laws or standards are for their benefit, not a hindrance or a restriction. Linux needs to have a standard reference platform and distribution that all developers can develop to and know with confidence that their applications will run everywhere.</p><p>The industry has talked about Linux Standard Base (LSB) but the early success of Linux has been an obstacle to adoption. Every Linux provider felt they could be the dominant platform and the tight development cycles needed to compete in the retail space consumed all available resources. The quick development cycles and the developer’s insatiable desire to have the latest and greatest technology fueled self-feeding retail frenzy.</p><p><strong>Develop and Embrace Mature Business Channels</strong></p><p>This leads to the next point. Just as a teenager must branch out beyond his parents in order to integrate the knowledge and experience of others, Linux must branch out from its retail roots and develop mature business channels. Mature business channels like Value Added Resellers (VARS), Consultants and Original Equipment Manufacturers (OEMs) are critical to the business customer. These specialists provide the total solution to their customers. No one buys an operating system — they buy a solution to their business need.</p><p>Because we live in a global economy, these channels and the company that supports them must be global. Having regional Linux companies is a major disincentive to business customers and major application and hardware providers. These application and solution providers cannot afford to support different relationships to cover their need for global marketing. While many large application and hardware providers are supporting multiple regional Linux providers, the majority of businesses cannot. Even the larger players are losing patience.</p><p>Consequently, a Linux provider must be able to offer a global infrastructure for support, marketing and sales. To build a global infrastructure requires tremendous resources, time and capital. With money tight, the current market is forcing the maturation and consolidation of suppliers.</p><p><strong>Specialize</strong></p><p>Just as a teenager must seek specialized training, the Linux providers must begin to focus and specialize. Rather than viewing each other as competition, we can partner rather than compete in key areas that would be beneficial to the industry at large. Since there is little or no money in a base distribution of Linux, we can all provide a Linux Standard Base compliant distribution. Specialization can then come from the markets we choose to support or the products areas above the operating system in which we develop intellectual property.</p><p><strong>Seek Compatible Companions</strong></p><p>Finally, when we are young, we feel that we do not need anyone or anything to accomplish our goals. We have no fear. We are invincible. When we get a little wiser, we realize that partnering with others provides tremendous growth, comfort and enjoyment.</p><p>Some in the Linux community have the attitude of doing it all themselves. We have borrowed from the rich UNIX heritage in the way we have designed the system; but we have done everything from scratch. With all of the investment that has gone into making Linux successful, there is tremendous pressure for Linux to mature much faster than may be realistic both as a technology and as a business.</p><p>Unifying UNIX with Linux is a way to achieve that maturity in the short term. UNIX as a technology has test suites, application programming interfaces, tools and infrastructure that would be very compatible and complementary to Linux. UNIX has established channels, applications and customers. Unifying UNIX with Linux will enable business application developers and business customers to more fully embrace and deploy Linux into the mainstream business back office. There is clearly a trend in the industry for UNIX providers to begin to integrate Linux. Rather than fight this trend, the Linux industry can embrace these groups.</p><p>There are things in the UNIX industry that need to change and there are things in the Linux industry that need to change. However, the marriage of the two could result in the most reliable, scalable, open and useful technology platform the industry has ever known.</p><p>My greatest joy as a father has come from watching my teenagers, in both their failures and triumphs, take on the additional challenges of adulthood. For those who conclude from my analogy that they should wait to embrace Linux until it matures, I issue this challenge. If you wait, you may be left behind. Linux has grown and matured faster than any other operating system platform in history. Many of the issues that I suggest for Linux to mature can and are happening with incredible speed.</p><p>Like youth itself, Linux is fresh. The development model is new and intriguing. The business model is not fully cooked, but this provides opportunity. Linux and Open Source is a “disruptive” technology; it has and will continue to change the information technology world. More importantly, like the Internet itself, Linux will change the way we do business, the way we develop and deploy technology, the way we package and deliver applications and business solutions.</p><p>Get to know this teenager called Linux and you will be richer and wiser, not only financially but also personally. Get to know Linux and see the new potential for change in our industry. Get to know Linux and have hope for a better, more cooperative industry. Linux is the smart alternative, the dawn of a new day.</p><p>There is no question that Linux and Open Source have changed the world but Linux and Open Source could do more if they continue to find a model to be financially self-reliant. Enough money must be generated from Linux or Open Source itself. I will talk more about this in the chapter on “The Business Model.” This lack of self-sufficiency is also one of the reasons for the dilemma that faced Linux with the SCO suit which I will address in the last chapter “Where do we go from here?”</p><p>The motivations I have tried to discuss 1) To make a difference and change the world 2) Reaction to Microsoft, 3) Just for the Love of it, 4) To participate in a revolution and 5) To make money are not an attempt to list all the reasons why people are willing to contribute or promote Linux. These motivations and leadership principles are not only important to understand some of the forces that have helped compel Linux to be a major alternative in the market, but more importantly, they may help provide the keys to unlocking the potential for businesses struggling to understand and adapt to rapidly changing electronic business environment. These principles empower and may help management move from being a top down hierarchical structure to empowered teams who can make decisions and commit resources.</p><p>S1wYXNzT��A�}</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8710b155d955" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Love of Linux Chapter 8: Empowerment, Lessons Learned from Open Source]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@ransomhlove/the-love-of-linux-chapter-8-empowerment-lessons-learned-from-open-source-a1cc2f007f28?source=rss-c44b575286b0------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a1cc2f007f28</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[management]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[empowerment]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[tech]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ransom H. Love]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 24 Feb 2016 21:40:58 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-02-24T21:40:58.227Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>As we began to understand the SCO business and take stock of the company, we felt that we had four things that even with all the problems and hassles made the transaction worth it: the loyal resellers around the world, some extremely scalable and robust technology, the install base of incredibly customers and the very talented group of employees. The employees, however, had been through some pretty rough times. Some of them had been sold four times in eight years. Others had come from being a leader in the industry to loosing money every quarter. We had had to make several cuts and they had lost good friends. They had watched previous management continue to be paid salaries even when the company was doing poorly. Some employees had grown cynical and yet, they wanted to do the right thing. They believed in the product and technologies and wanted the company to succeed. Not everyone, however, were in agreement on what the company should do. Early on, we began to hold company wide meetings and smaller site meetings with the employees. We also started a strategy process to get the company turned around and in unity going in the same direction.</p><p>Curt Porritt gave me a copy of Michael Porter’s paper “<em>What Is Strategy?”</em> I read the paper and immediately recognized how vital a strategy was in gaining unity and direction. We began a series of meetings in which we first educated the management team on what strategy really was. Much of what Porter said really resonated with my own experience and with what I had learned from Linux and in marketing products over the years. The key to strategy in this new world of instant information exchange is to understand who your customer is and what they need. You must then empower the organization to deliver the value or complete experience the customer is seeking or you have determined will result in the most valuable experience for the customer while allowing the company to make money. Before talking about each of the four components that empower an organization to deliver real value to its customers, it is very important to address a fundamental underlying philosophy of how management views its employees.</p><p>Simplistically, there are two basic philosophies of management control or empowerment. These two philosophies have been a war in the hearts and minds of people as long as their have been people. These conflicting and basic philosophies are riddled throughout management theory and managerial concepts and principles. They are almost unrecognizable for what they truly are having been cloaked with modern terms and acceptable, even true principles. Every manager must honesty answer what philosophy they subscribe to. Liz Wiseman and Greg Mckeown wrote a book entitled “Multipliers: How the Best Leaders Make Everyone Smarter” which addresses these two forms of management style. Liz and Greg have classified them as Multipliers and Diminishers. What is interesting about these two styles is that the actions of both a Multiplier and a Diminisher can be quite similar. They find the best people and they require a lot from their people but they do not see their people the same at all. A multiplier sees his people as smarter than they are with infinite potential to do more than could be conceived of originally while a diminisher will see his people as nothing more than pawns or a means to an end. The diminisher will feel that no one can understand the problem as well as they can or do the work better than they can. I had the experience of reading this book and sharing this with a collegue. At the time, we were working for an extremely bright manager. When my peer came back to me after reading the first several chapters and he could not wait to tell me that our manager was a diminisher. Interestingly, the book spread like wild fire around the management team. All those working for this individual arrived at the same conclusion. However, when this came to the attention of the manager, he invited Liz Wiseman to come and visit with our team. In that meeting, I watched this individual categorize himself as a multiplier in front of the whole team and the author. He could check all the boxes but everyone around the table who interacted with him, knew that in spite of his ability to check the boxes, to us, he was a diminisher. Interestingly, another book entitled “The Anatomy of Peace: Resolving the Heart of Conflict” by The Arbinger Institute may shed light on the difference between a multiplier and a diminisher. This book beautifully explains some of the core elements of human nature. It points out that when we see our fellow man as nothing more than objects, less than human or as a means to an end, we view them from within “a box.” The people they interact with automatically sense that they are being treated less than humanly and react usually confrontationally or in a passive aggressive way if they cannot react openly. Because the manager or individual is not true to his or her own original feelings or promptings, he or she begin to justify, rationalize and even amass others to think the way that we do and the conflict escalates. The primary difference between a diminisher and a multiplier is how they view their fellow man and their employees. If to the manager, the employees are competitors, pawns or objects, he or she will diminish those around them and no matter how smart or gifted they are, the people will sense their real feelings and motivations and not perform to the level they could. If they see the employees collectively more talented than themselves and with proper empowerment these employees can deliver beyond what they themselves could deliver, the employees will achieve multiplied results beyond what the manager may have imagined.</p><p>In order to determine what underlying philosophy a manager subscribes to, it might be helpful to discuss these philosophies a little more. Ray Noorda used to say to start a business you need an engineer, to grow it you need a marketer, to manage it you need an accountant. In today’s market, I agree with all but the accountant. Do not misunderstand; I believe accounting is a vital tool to help manage a business. Accounting as a method to keep track of assets and the incomes and outgoes of a business is absolutely necessary, but when accounting becomes the methodology for managing a business, it will squeeze it dry. Accounting by its very nature is dwelling on operational efficiency. When an accounting philosophy is used to manage the entire business, strategy can go out the window and the true part of business; the people can be reduced to numbers. This can be a company’s biggest mistake if it wants to remain competitive. Everything but people can be managed. To unlock their hearts and minds, people must be lead and the leader must believe that those who follow can achieve far more than what they can accomplish themselves or they will not be multipliers.</p><p>Unfortunately, the philosophy of control seems to permeate most business ventures and transactions. The concept of “win-loose” or “win at all costs”, “the end justifies the means” are also examples of control. Many text books teach that strategy is about creating and maintaining a sustainable competitive advantage. The solution to maintain above average returns lies in finding a lucrative market and then either creating or finding barriers to entry to prevent a potential competitor or even a customer from taking your share of the business. The philosophy is based on a zero sum game. All you have is all you can take from someone else and all they have is what they can take from you. Clearly, there is much the business world and even in this book that would support someone’s view that it is a dog eat dog world and you had better eat them before they eat you, but it is not the way it has to or should be. If you view business strictly from quarter to quarter as many publicly traded companies do, trying to maximize the short term stock price, you will easily be able to justify this position. So many things that are out of your control can have a devastating impact on revenues and the bottom line. And, there are way too many companies who do operate using these dog eat dog business practices. However, the win-loose business philosophies are short term and self destructive. With this view of the world, management does not trust anyone, not even their own employees. The number of companies run under the control philosophy is almost too many to name.</p><p>Fewer, but far more interesting and exciting are the examples that are emerging of empowerment based on an abundance mentality. These shining examples provide a much better way to operate a business that will actually do more to develop and maintain a competitive advantage in this new information age. There are some wonderful examples of companies who are not only surviving hard times, but thriving in them because they have focused on unlocking the potential of their people. Nucor Corp in the steel industry is a company that continues to thrive when nearly everyone else is complaining about dumping and external excuses. Nucor did not hire people who worked in the steel industry. The hired skilled people and then rewarded them for innovation and taking risks to improve the process. They do not spend any money on research and development but the probably lead the industry in innovation. They do not even mind having their competitors tour their facilities because they know the secret to their success is still in the minds of their workers. They have never lain off workers, but rather slow production in an economic downturn. This impacts management compensation more than the average worker. Southwest Airline industry is another shinning example in the airline industry. I just read that in the wake of September 11th, every airline except SouthWest is no longer profitable. Southwest was also the only airline to have cash reserves so that they did not lay off one person as a result of 9/11. Coincidence or people centered strategies? Continental Grain and Kimball are two others that I have personally seen wonderful results by making employees a key component of their strategy.</p><p>Those who view the world from the perspective that people must be managed or controlled, will have a hard time understanding Linux and open source. Those who are trying to manage Linux through traditional zero sum strategies, will only see Linux as a failure. How can you make money on Linux? Where is the sustainable competitive advantage? Where are the barriers to entry? How do you protect yourself from your competitors, customers and suppliers? Where is the intellectual property? For years we have been asking ourselves these questions and I will address them in a subsequent chapter, but before I try to answer them, I would first like to illustrate the reality of the new world market that I think is somewhat hidden to the casual observer or even participant.</p><p>One of the challenges of the new information age, is the rate of innovation is increasing at an almost unbelievable rate. The traditionally process to develop a proprietary product internally with innovative technology and possibly patent your efforts to protect the company from competitors is a slow and tedious process. By the time a product gets to market or before a company can show a return on the investment made in innovation, packaging and marketing, someone has created an alternative solution. Because of the global economy, it is not sufficient to protect Intellectual Property (IP) in one country; you must register the name and patents around the world. This is a time consuming and expensive proposition. Once the legal process is complete, a company could then spend tremendous time trying to protect its IP in a court of law by enforcing its patents, but the outcome of a court of law is totally unpredictable. It is a total gamble to go to court. Right does not always prevail. Even when “justice is done” often it is not administered, as in the case of Microsoft. Microsoft was finally convicted of antitrust violations but suffered little or not penalty.</p><p>Spending precious resources trying to protect obsolete patents and developing patentable IP is a time consuming and almost impossible task given the global economy. Unless you are a very large company with tremendous resources, the legal route becomes almost impossible to pursue successfully. Every country around the world has different patent laws. While information is accessible instantaneously, the processes to patent and protect information are virtually impossible to do. Just protecting a company name in all the major markets is very expensive and time consuming and the world continues to move at an unprecedented rate. Within months or weeks, the key features of the product you have developed has been introduced somewhere else so the traditional product life cycle is cut short and a return on investment cannot be achieved.</p><p>The Linux model of open source and free access and use of intellectual property removes many of the illusions of control that many still have. Some feel that this is Linux’s greatest weakness, that open sources licenses prevent any company from making money. Many are coming to realize that the Internet, with its ability to provide information instantaneously coupled with open source break down barriers that have artificially protected inefficient business models. This combination has in fact created a completely new business environment. This combination has created an environment that enables a company to truly focus on the important elements of business, innovation and meeting peoples needs, its employees and its customers. The Linux model allows you to focus on the part of strategy that is the most important, constant innovation that solves a customers needs, the way you motivate people to continue to innovate and contribute, and most importantly delivering real value to the customer. The only real sustainable competitive advantage any company has is its people and to deliver real value to their chosen customer. If companies can figure out a way to empower their people and encourage them to continually improve the processes and products of a company and understand the changing needs of their customers, the company will have a competitive strategy that will survive because it can evolve with the market and its customers. An example of this type of empowerment is Toyota. As I mentioned before, when we visited Toyota City, their managers mentioned that they had had over 2003 suggestions from their employees and had implemented all be three. Their competitors were trying a top down motivation strategy to try to compete with them and Toyota was using a bottom up strategy to remain number one. Also, Google has also proven this model in recent years which Chris Andreson covers well in his book “Free”. The empowerment provided by open source is an important model to discuss, so important that the title of this book and an entire chapter is dedicated to it, The Love of Linux. As mentioned, at the core of the conflict between control and empowerment is how one truly views people. Are people and their infinite ability to create the essence of the organization or just a needed expense, a means to the corporate end or the hands to implement the bright ideas of someone more talented then the average employee?</p><p>So one critical key is how to motivate and empower your employees. So how do you empower your organization? From Linux you learn that to truly empower the organization requires at least four things: 1) a compelling vision or strategy of who you are going to target and what experience you want to provide 2) an environment encourages personal empowerment and responsibility 3) an organizational structure that removes the informal and formal obstacles and barriers and rewards proper execution of the strategy; and 4) Innovative use of collaborative tools.</p><p><em>A Compelling Vision</em></p><p>The Bible states that without vision, the people perish. Without leadership, people become disenchanted, disgruntled, unmotivated and put their energy into things that will bring them satisfaction and fulfillment. Many argue that this is precisely why people must be controlled. People want leadership with empowerment to then accomplish the mission, strategy or objective. Linux provides a great example of a compelling vision which is discussed in the next chapter, The Love of Linux. The vision is so compelling that the people give their time, talents and energy to the effort without compensation. If every business could find such a vision, how could they be stopped? The core of a business strategy must be about delivering real value to a customer at a price that makes the company providing the value a profit. Providing something of real worth is highly motivating. The first question to answer is who is the customer the company chooses to service? It may not be the current customer base. At Caldera, we determined that the customer we going to target were the companies who managed replicated small businesses. These were the McDonalds, KFCs, CVS and KMarts of the world. They also included vertical application and value added resellers who sold their applications to and managed them for small businesses such as the dentist and doctor’s offices. SCO has one of the largest install bases of these customers. We were beginning to get more information about them and what they needed. Once you know who your customer is, you must truly learn all you can about them. Spend time understanding their business and listening to their issues. You can then determine the value you intend to deliver to them and if that experience will be compelling enough for them to modify their behavior and buy more products and services. The vision we had was to provide a platform for the replicated site providers and the value added resellers that supplied key applications and services to this customer a low cost alternative on Intel a turn-key solution for these business.</p><p>It is not about providing technology; it is about truly understanding a customer and their needs and then providing the experience they desire or will truly benefit them while delivering a profit for the business. I spend a little more time on this in the chapter on Business Models.</p><p><em>An Environment that Encourages Personal Empowerment and Responsibility</em></p><p>Once a vision or strategy is decided upon, you must begin to honestly look at the environment and determine if the culture is there to support the strategic direction. One lesson that I would often repeat at company meetings was just do the right thing at the right time for the right reason. Again, one might ask what is right for one may not be right for another. Unfortunately, many use that to justify situation ethics, in other words they believe that the end justifies the means. The right thing however, may change given the circumstances. Each person in the business must make decisions daily on how to treat customers, fellow employees and partners. How they conduct themselves will determine whether or not the company will be successful. There are two main things that can help each person be empowered to make this choice. First, every person must understand what the strategic goals of the organization are and then how what they do fits into the whole. The responsibility of management is to determine and communicate this vision but each individual has the responsibility to own that vision. Make it their own by seeking to understand it and give input to its evolution. The second thing that helps each person understand what is right is their own intuition. Each person does know instinctively what he or she should do in a given situation. However, if the individual acts on the original impressions at the time they are given, they will not only will the company be successful, but also they will be personally fulfilled. Hence they must do the right thing at the right time. The right time, is usually when the impression comes. The company with its formal and informal processes must not get in the way of the individual being able to make these important decisions. One of the key reasons that Linux is so successful at attracting and keeping very talented people who continue to put time in for free is that it empowers. The construct of business do not get in the way of people suggesting and implementing “the right thing at the right time.” I will address this more in the next chapter. The company must reward and not penalize the risk each individual may need to take. Sometimes, the right time may be to wait. Again, this principle can be used improperly. Following one’s conscience is the key. Waiting to do something out of fear or political gain will not result in the right thing happening. This leads to the next point.</p><p>The way you can determine if you are doing “the right thing at the right time” is if you are doing it for the “right reason.” If the individual or management is acting selfishly or for the wrong reasons, both they and the company will fail. So many decisions are made out of fear, or selfishness, rather than out of what is morally right. Some rationalize and say how can you know what is right? What is right for one is not right for another? I fundamentally disagree. Each human being is born with the ability to discern right from wrong. We are all given a light in our souls. When we are true or honest to the light or impressions that come to us, we remain true to ourselves and to humanity. When we fail to respond to those impressions, we begin to rationalize and horriblize the behavior of those we have been prompted to help simply to justify our lack of action. Most often they are the ones closest to us in business or our personal lives. Over time, we can become dark inside. The pursuit of the things of this world, money, power, and fame, are among the quickest ways to go dark because they allow us to be selfish and self serving. When we focus on ourselves, at the exclusion of others, we grow dark.</p><p><em>An Organizational Structure that Removes the Informal and Formal Obstacles and Barriers and Rewards Proper Execution of Strategy</em></p><p>When it comes to empowerment, there is much business can learn from Linux that it is not about IP and protecting that IP, it is about empowering their people and removing the obstacles that prevent them from being able to innovate and meet those customer needs. Every company has formal and informal systems that determine how decisions are made and how people interact with each other. But the formal and informal systems of the company may compel them to do something else. Again, it is the responsibility of management to understand when these informal and formal systems get in the way of people being able to make the right choices. The key for management is to remove the formal and informal obstacles that would influence individuals to not follow their intuition. A very wise leader stated:</p><p>“A prudent leader will not complain at the weakness or the inefficiency or the lack of interest of those with whom he works until he is certain that he has presented the program fully, concisely, thoroughly, and understandably, and that he has followed through to keep the matter fresh in their minds, being sure that they understand the program and go forward. He should evaluate his performance before he criticizes other in theirs. His success will be measured not by his brilliance, nor by how much he knows about the program, but by how well he can transmit the knowledge and enthusiasm to others. When one person speaks the people say, “How eloquent,” but when another finishes speaking, they say, “Come, let us march.” (Teachings of Spencer W. Kimball p. 486).</p><p>If management will follow this counsel, they will often find many of the both formal and informal obstacles that exist in every culture that will prevent full implementation of strategy. Some lessons we learned at Caldera were the formal hierarchical structure sometimes keeps some from reaching their true potential. The financial and power rewards for management force key contributors to seek management positions. No matter how high up in a company or organization a person climbs, the real truth is that you only really have control over one individual, yourself. Some feel that you must have a title to have the authority. There is no question that some people do respond to titles. But competence is true authority. Some feel that all you have to do is have a title and then you can tell people what to do. They are like the traditional sheepherder who, with a dog goes around yapping at the heels of their workers. This method is quick and does not require but little investment, but the results are temporary. To lead like a shepherd, requires the sheep to know and trust you. It is not that you are perfect, but they must believe in you. Thus, real control is self-control. Shakespeare states, “To thine own self be true and it follows thou cannot be false to another.”</p><p>Being true to oneself is being truly honest or doing things for the “right reason.” But being true to oneself also means not trying to be something you are not. I find that many people feel they must be something they are not in order to be successful. Our society and traditional business structure makes individuals feel they have to be in management or climb the corporate ladder to be successful. I have found that many individuals find out that they are very unhappy in positions they felt they wanted. They are like fish out of water. Those who know themselves and know what they are good at and are not good at and are truly honest can have far more influence in their respective positions then in management. The old saying “bloom where you are planted” has significance. This should not be used as an excuse to not improve our talents and strive to become the best we can. We must be true to ourselves by becoming the best selves we can, not be trying to be someone else nor doing something someone wants us to do. The organization, however, must not force people into positions just to reap financial rewards when it is to the organizations benefit to keep them right where they are. Similarly, systems of rewards must be developed that allow for key contributors to remain where they are in the organization while allowing them to have greater influence in the organization.</p><p>I have learned that there is a leadership dilemma at the executive level of a company that may the cause of some of the challenges facing business. Each individual career path that leads to an executive level rewards operational efficiencies. For example, a good VP of Finance is one who really understands how to budget and minimize risks. They must put constraints on how finances are to be conserved and waste eliminated in the organization. There is a huge gulf between the necessary personality traits needed in a good CFO and a good VP of Finance. A good CFO must be an entrepreneur. They must know how to spend money to make money and take good calculated risks. This is true about every major discipline. The transition from functional head to the executive level is a chasm. Their focus must be more toward the strategic than operational efficiencies. That is not to say they should neglect operational focus. But, strategy is the unknown, uncharted space that many highly efficient operational managers feel very uncomfortable in. Many, many individuals cannot jump that chasm. It is a similar chasm that exists between individual contributors and management. Some feel compelled to go into management to receive the benefits. They should stay on the functional or operational side rather than move across. The challenge from a management side is that our hierarchical management infrastructure does not reward key participants based on contribution, but where they are on the corporate ladder. This problem must be solved. People of at all levels in an organization, can give invaluable input to the strategy and operation of the company and important management training. This is particularly true of those who are closer to the customer. Good talent should be utilized where they can flourish and be given the opportunity to influence the company in their areas of greatest competency not be forced into management or to a level of management that they are not suited for and will be miserable in just to be compensated appropriately, either monetarily or by influence. This is one of the dynamics that must change in the new world of the Internet and information exchange.</p><p>An employee can be truer to him or herself and be of much greater service to the company and their coworkers if they learn to blossom where they are planted rather than always pursuing a higher management position. The challenge is that most company’s compensation and reward systems are base on hierarchy. This must change. The responsibility increases with some management positions and consequently the compensation should be commensurate with that additional responsibility and risks, but we must begin to explore other ways to enable people to influence the direction of the company without being in management and truly compensate them for their contribution. I have learned that there is a leadership dilemma at the executive level of a company that may the cause of some of the challenges facing business. Each individual career path that leads to an executive level rewards operational efficiencies. For example, a good VP of Finance is one who really understands how to budget and minimize risks. They must put constraints on how finances are to be conserved and waste eliminated in the organization. There is a huge gulf between the necessary personality traits needed in a good CFO and a good VP of Finance. A good CFO must be an entrepreneur. They must know how to spend money to make money and take good calculated risks. This is true about every major discipline. The transition from functional head to the executive level is a chasm. Their focus must be more toward the strategic than operational efficiencies. That is not to say they should neglect operational focus. But, strategy is the unknown, uncharted space that many highly efficient operational managers feel very uncomfortable in. Many, many individuals cannot jump that chasm. It is a similar chasm that exists between individual contributors and management. Some feel compelled to go into management to receive the benefits. They should stay on the functional or operational side rather than move across. The challenge from a management side is that our hierarchical management infrastructure does not reward key participants based on contribution, but where they are on the corporate ladder. This problem must be solved. People of at all levels in an organization, can give invaluable input to the strategy and operation of the company and important management training. This is particularly true of those who are closer to the customer. Good talent should be utilized where they can flourish and be given the opportunity to influence the company in their areas of greatest competency not be forced into management or to a level of management that they are not suited for and will be miserable in just to be compensated appropriately, either monetarily or by influence. This is one of the dynamics that must change in the new world of the Internet and information exchange.</p><p>Again, open source working group model provides a powerful tool to empower people to greatly contribute and unify people. This concept of working together in groups that are not committees, but have a designated or even self appointed leader is a way to engage peoples hearts and minds. It requires a very different management skill than what is taught in most management texts. And most importantly, it requires the heart of the manager. They must truly believe that working together as a group will result in a better solution than they could on their own. Clearly, the manager or council leader must always have the option to make a decision with or without discussion, but the preferred method would be to utilize a council. I will talk more about councils in the chapter on The Open Company — Using Councils to Manage, but it is important to note that it is a powerful tool for the organization to break down both formal and informal barriers.</p><p>In this rapidly changing, highly competitive world, they only way to succeed is to empower the individual and the organization. Management must provide the vision. That vision must come from understanding who their customer is and what that customer needs. Strategy and vision is not about coming up with the greatest technology and then trying to protect it legally. It is about understanding and satisfying customer needs and satisfying those needs by unlocking the innovative power of its employees. Management must provide develop and communicate that vision to its employees and management so that they can truly do the right thing, at the right time, for the right reason. Management must discover the obstacles both formal and informal and provide incentives based contributions and not position.</p><p><em>Innovative Use of Collaborative Tools</em></p><p>Since the early days of Linux, many new collaborative tools have been developed that have fostered collaboration throughout the industry. Wikis, blogs, and social networking software are enabling interaction around the world. The tools are classified as Web 2.0. Many of these tools are now being used within the organization. This effort has been called Enterprise 2.0. It is reported that Jonathan Schwartz the former CEO of Sun, was using blogs to communicate to employees. Jonathan can communicate to all employees and can clearly see the direction of where he wants to take the company and they in turn can communicate with him. Much can be done in this area to experiment with how these tools of can not only break down formal and informal barriers within the company, but also traditional walls between the company and its suppliers, partners, affiliates and consumers.</p><p>u��p�’</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a1cc2f007f28" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Love of Linux Chapter 7: The Python Swallowing the Elephant]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@ransomhlove/the-love-of-linux-chapter-7-the-python-swallowing-the-elephant-33c25b18ac52?source=rss-c44b575286b0------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/33c25b18ac52</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[investment]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[entrepreneurship]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[tech]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ransom H. Love]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 24 Feb 2016 20:55:52 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-02-24T21:38:30.425Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>I use the analogy of the python, because after a python has swallowed its meal, it maintains the shape of its victim until it has had time to digest it. Caldera had from its inception, being trying to develop a global reseller channel. We knew that we needed to provide business solutions to customers and the integrator/VAR was, and is, instrumental in providing the total solution to the business customer. These integrators also provided much needed business applications. To build a channel takes time and money. To build a channel from scratch is very expensive and time consuming. Caldera began this process early on. Long before the IPO, we had contracted with MindShare to recruit resellers and begin to build a reseller channel.</p><p>With the capital and currency from the IPO, we felt that the best thing to do was to buy the channel and then grow it. We also knew that Linux could make an ideal small business server platform because it was very stable. But, to get it accepted into small business, you needed the reseller and existing customer base. It is a known fact in the industry, that the local reseller does have tremendous influence on what the customer buys. At this time, approximately 75% of what a small business owner purchased was based on the recommendation of the value added reseller they work with.</p><p>Ralph Yarro, the president of Canopy and chairman of our board, suggested that I look at Santa Cruz Operations stock. Ralph owned just a few shares and had been tracking their price. Early on at Caldera, Bryan Sparks, Ralph and I had almost jokingly talked about buying SCO and UNIX if Caldera was ever successful in going public. Ralph and I looked at the stock and saw that they were trading a little less than half of our share price. SCO had one of the best reseller/integrator channels in the industry, not to mention an impressive list of business customers like, McDonalds, Kmart, Taco Bell, KFC, only to mention a few. I mentioned to Ralph that I had met Doug Michels a few months earlier when SCO launched Tarantella on Linux. SCO had invited Caldera to participate with several other Linux companies on a panel at their press briefing. After the panel, Doug Michels came up to me and introduced himself and thanked me for participating. I gave Doug a call and asked him if he had considered selling SCO. Doug mentioned that if I had not called him, he would have called us in a couple of weeks. We set up a meeting in Las Vegas and I flew down and met with Doug and a member of the SCO board.</p><p>Much of our initial discussions were how to structure a deal that would allow new growth business of UnixWare and Linux to be separate from the old declining revenues of OpenServer, the old UNIX product that was the back bone of SCO’s success. What resulted was a quite complex transaction that the SEC had a hard time digesting. The original agreement and frankly, nearly all negotiations with Tarantella were incredibly difficult. The Tarantella management truly subscribed to the win loose mentality on negotiations. If we won they lost and if they won we lost. The concept that they had a real stake in Caldera’s future, owning a substantial amount of stock in our company and would benefit from a win win proposition appeared totally alien to them. It appeared to us that all they could see was the short term and they wanted as much of our cash as they could get. There were several times when the negotiations were broken off because we had reached an impass. On one such occasion, I received a call from Maureen O’Gerra notorious for getting the scope on all the UNIX and Linux stories in the industry before they appeared any where else. I had always leveled with Maureen and I think she appreciated that. She asked me point blank if there was anything going on with the purchase of SCO and I honestly told her no. We had walked away from the deal. However, within days, SCO responded favorably and the negotiations continued. When we made the announcement a couple of weeks later that we intended on purchasing SCO, I do not think Maureen ever forgave me. SCO had broken up their company into three divisions, the server division, professional services, and Tarantella division. Caldera purchased two of the three divisions. After the purchase, the remaining Tarantella division changed the name of their company to Tarantella.</p><p>The transaction took almost nine months to get SEC approval and complete. In the original agreement, Caldera did not actually purchase the OpenServer business. Tarantella maintained ownership and Caldera became the exclusive distributor. We owned the distribution channel and they owned the OpenServer product. The deal was structured this way because Doug was convinced that if the Caldera was saddled with decreasing revenue stream of the old business, investment analysts would never give the company a good valuation. The logic seemed sound, but we also felt that Doug wanted to hang on to his baby or at least the revenue from it and the negotiation process was tedious at best. Regardless, the resulting deal was far too complex. After six months into the SEC review process and continued cash drain on Tarantella’s quickly depleting resources, Caldera renegotiated the deal with Tarantella and purchased the Open Server business as well. But it was not until the cash situation at Tarantella became almost desperate that we could negotiate a reasonable agreement.</p><p>To manage the company during the SEC review process, Caldera and Tarantella set up a way for Caldera to begin to influence the direction of the two SCO divisions we were acquiring. Caldera held management and strategy meetings with the existing SCO management of the two divisions and were able to choose what resources we were going to keep and what resources had to go. We would then meet with the Tarantella management to get their approvals and agreement in a meeting affectionately called Fortnight. However, since Caldera did not know the company or the employees well, we had to rely heavily on the advice and input of the SCO division management. Unfortunately, they were still being paid by Tarantella and the bonuses seemed to provide more direction than either Caldera or the remaining Tarantella management team. During the SEC approval time, the Tarantella team paid incredible sales bonuses to the existing management team to ensure that they would sell the old OpenServer products and minimize any and all marketing expenses on either OpenServer or UnixWare products. At the time, Tarantella was quickly running out of cash and was milking the SCO revenue stream to support investment in Tarantella. Consequently, to meet the expense targets and get the bonuses, nearly all marketing of the SCO products stopped in the Americas for 9 months. Tarantella also provided incentives to the sales force to sell the old UNIX product Open Server, because the original agreement allowed Tarantella to maintain ownership of this product. Under the original agreement, nearly all the proceeds of OpenServer would have stayed with Tarantella and Caldera would have been paid a royalty to market and sell it.</p><p>Originally, Caldera intended to keep as much of the old management team in place to ensure continuity. Honestly, I had never run a 600 person company before and did not have the confidence that I or the original Caldera management team knew enough about the SCO business. But it was very difficult to get a clear picture on the state of the business because the information was being filtered thorough the remaining SCO division management. The remaining SCO management of course, did not want to be the bearers of bad news to the new owners. Unfortunately, this filtering continued up until the last several weeks of the first quarter of doing business as Caldera International following the close of the transaction. For example, the old SCO management team represented that we were going to meet the sales projections. We soon found out that they were over 5 million dollars off. Upon investigation, the projections from the sales force were very accurate, but this same layer of management had made a management uplift to the numbers at the beginning of the quarter, probably anticipating renewed interest in the products after the close of the sale. But, they continued to represent that they would meet the unrealistic projections. Unfortunately, we had kept additional resources in place during that time anticipating better revenues. This misinformation created credibility problems with the board. Being the CEO, I had to represent and defend the numbers to the board given to me by the management team without having complete access to the information.</p><p>Realizing that we were paying a premium in many different ways to have an extra layer of management and we were not getting the information we needed to run the business, we decided to let nearly the entire middle management layer go and risk making a few mistakes ourselves. As a lesson learned, if I were to do a major accusation again, I would negotiate up front for the old management team to transition out immediately or in a staggered manner as each element of the business is effectively transferred. You can learn a business pretty quickly by taking to the customers and solid business principles apply to all size of businesses. At Caldera, the Executive team made a significant effort taking the time to develop a strategy with key managers from all over the company. We hired several consultants to assist in this process which was very helpful. The Executive team would purposely stop in and meet with employees all over the world when we would visit a customer or attend a trade show. We flew around the world meeting with customers, OEMs and ISVs so that within months, we had a very good handle on the business and where we needed to go. Each member of the team, Drew Spencer, Benoy Tamang, Ed Donakey, Bob Bench, Reg Broughton, Jeff Hunsaker and others played a great role in helping to ascertain the needed strategy and develop confidence with the employees and managers. So if I were to acquire a company again, my recommendation would be to let the existing managers know they will be transitioning and negotiate separation packages up front to provide them the incentive to assist in the transition. This method is far less costly than trying to keep them on and educate them on a completely new way of doing things or leaving them to guess about their future. In some cases, the managers can make the transition and may be a great asset, but only a little time will tell. A good transition package with give you that time and allow you the opportunity to see if the managers are willing to accept the new direction and play a vital role in achieving the new vision.</p><p>Caldera now had the infrastructure it needed to deliver high quality business solutions around the world and the management team had a common goal, build a world-class business in a new world economy and make a difference. It took us longer to digest the SCO acquisition than we have anticipated. After four quarters, we had finally gotten through the majority of the one time charges we needed to take to clean up many items like 20 year leases SCO had entered into. We had nearly twice as much office space as we needed worldwide. The number of employees was nearly 650 and we had to pair the back to 395. The revenues were declining at nearly 10% a quarter and we were able to slow that down and level it off. At the same time, the economy and the entire IT stock market dropped to record lows. The Dot Com bubble had burst and the economy suffered. During this time, Caldera cut out nearly 36% of its costs on a quarterly basis for five straight quarters. While some of those cuts were in laying off people, we went through great pain to minimize that option. Management took fairly significant cuts in pay as did some of the employees who had been with the company for some time. The management team and the employees did a fabulous job. They consistently met their budget targets every quarter without fail. The experience was like trying to pull the nose up of a 747 whose engines quit during flight.</p><p>����</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=33c25b18ac52" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Love of Linux Chapter 6: Taking the Company Public]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@ransomhlove/the-love-of-linux-chapter-6-taking-the-company-public-9d8a801acb30?source=rss-c44b575286b0------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9d8a801acb30</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[finance]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[stock-market]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ransom H. Love]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 24 Feb 2016 20:53:03 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-02-24T20:53:03.221Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Before Red Hat went public, we had spoken with several investment bankers to evaluate the interest. Our initial search led us to S. G. Cowen. We were impressed with the knowledge and maturity of the investment banker and even went so far as to sign a letter of intent. However, S.G. Cowen did not feel the company was quite ready. Taking a company public is a real balancing act. It appeared to us, that you have to go public when there is interest in the Industry you are in. In many ways, Caldera or any Linux company for that matter was not ready to go public. While revenues for Linux products were increasing, the sales were primarily based on retail. Retail sales were cyclical and based on constant turn and freshness. Linux companies were pulled into the rush of investment brought about by the dot com flurry but it was right at the end of the bubble. The window on the Linux industry was open and Caldera could not wait if we wanted to go public and pursue our strategy, especially when our competitors had already successfully completed their IPOs and were full of cash. This decision proved to be a company saving judgment call and one exciting, educational ride.</p><p>During the second round of financing, we interviewed several other investment banks to determine if there was a bank interested in taking the company public at that time. We were very pleased with the response. Robert and Stephens (known affectionately as Robbie) had the most credibility as the lead banker. The fierce competition among banks was unknown to me at first, but who you pick as a lead will determine so much of who the working group of banks, attorneys and accountants become. They also determine to a large degree how well your company will be represented to the investment community during the initial offering and, more importantly, after the IPO. Finding the banks to participate after selecting the lead bank is a unique dance. For those unfamiliar with the process of taking a company public, a representatives from three to four investment banks along with a leading accounting and legal firm forms a team called the working group” The objective of the working group is to produce a booklet called an S4. The S4 is submitted to the Securities Exchange Commission (SEC) for approval. When approved, the booklet gets printed and becomes the bible about your company to potential investors. Each of the investment banks that participate in this process and the distribution of the initial offering are listed “on the cover.” Investment bankers are very sensitive about whom they associate with and their positioning “on the cover” of the S4 as it contributes to their prestige in the investment community. Certain banks will not even be “on the cover” if they are not the lead. Others will be “on the cover” if they have only a certain percentage. I always thought that the IT industry was very competitive, until I began to interact with the investment banking industry. There is a definite, clear pecking order that appears to only change through acquisitions and mergers, one of the many reasons why the investment banks seem to change their name so frequently. Change is almost constant in the investment banking area. Consequently, my advice to anyone even considering taking a company public would be to talk to several companies that have gone through the process with the bank. Make sure that you interview companies that have just been through the process as well as those who have been public for several years and ask them how well the bank and its “analyst” represent the company in the beginning and on an on going basis. Each investment bank employs analysts who are considered experts on a given market. The analyst listen to the company earnings reports and recommend to investors whether to invest or not. They wield much power because companies in the past spoke through them to the investors to reduce risk. However, good analysts were hard to find and would often move to the highest bidder. Because of the fierce competition, the faces change rapidly and you want to be sure that the service does not change with the changing of the guard.</p><p>We asked the appropriate questions and Robbie assured us that, unlike their competing bankers, they would stick with us after the IPO. In other words, we were asking would their analyst continue to watch our company and make the necessary recommendations to investors. We did not interview companies they had taken public because we were very new to the investment game and a little naive. We were able to convince Bear Sterns, and an online banking upstart, WIT Capital to join Robbie on the cover. We took a chance on WIT because they had not done a lot of IPOs as a cover participant. They had mainly handled the “Friends and Family” or “Directed Shares” programs for other offerings. We wanted WIT involved because we knew our “Directed Share” program would be very complex because we wanted to involve many from the Linux community all around the world.</p><p>I should also explain the term “Friends and Family” or “Directed Share” program. When a company goes public, a small percentage of the stock is often reserved for the friends and family of the company or key customers and suppliers. Shares of the initial offering are set aside or directed to friends and family. Those who are identified on a list provided by the company going public are notified and are able to register and get a certain number of shares at the initial stock price the day the company goes public. The directed share program is a political hot potato. People are offended if you don’t offer them participation and people are offended if you offer them participation and they don’t make money. If the initial price goes up significantly, then those friends and family can sell the stock and make some pretty good money. If the stock goes down, after the initial offering, you will probable not have to many friends left. Family is stuck with you, but family gatherings can become more challenging. I would recommend that you investigate this option ahead of time and talk with companies who have and have not offered a directed share program and determine if it is right for your company and your employees.</p><p>In the Linux industry, we wanted to offer, not only our employees, but key players in the industry the opportunity to participate. Because of Linux’s open source collaborative model, many out side the company had contributed to our success. While we could not “reward” all those who had contributed to Linux, our Directed Share offering was much larger than most. What added to the complexity beyond the size of the Directed Share offering were many of the individuals we wanted to participate live outside the U.S. We had heard that Red Hat’s directed share program did not go as well as they had hoped, so we felt that WIT might be able to help us in this endeavor as they were a leader in online directed share programs. Again, we explained our desires upfront to Robbie and the other banks and they appeased us with telling us what we wanted to hear, but when it came time to administer the program we really ran into some problems. At first, Robbie did not want to let WIT handle the program and they were not accommodating at all. Robbie agreed to let WIT handle it, but the next problem we found was WIT could not offer any shares internationally. We were able to work something out with yet another bank to offer shares in Europe.</p><p>The youth of the employees of the larger investment banks was amazing. They had some very talented young people, but the average age at Robbie was probably lower to mid twenties. Most of the investment bankers we dealt with, even the VP of the group at Robbie were not much older than my oldest son. The investment banking industry takes some of the best young talent, works them very hard and pays them very little. The good ones would get some incredible experience in a short period of time and then often go to work for one of the companies they helped take public. I have often heard that the IT industry was full of young talent, but investment banking again had us beat. You may be able to tell just how competitive an industry is by average age of the employees of the companies that compete in the industry. With IT, the youthfulness is more a result of the love for technology. In the banking industry, it appears to be part of the business strategy.</p><p>Selecting the banks who will work together is only part of a very delicate dance you must do up front. Negotiating the percentage split between the banks was like negotiating for their first-born child. The SEC, I believe, sets the total percentage of the offering that can go to the investment banks, so that each percent that one firm wants has to come from one of the other participating banks. Each percentage change had to be negotiated back and forth between each of the other participating banks. Finally, after negotiating things down to what seemed like pennies on the dollar, everyone agreed, but that did not mean we were going public. That was only the beginning. Right before we filed, First Security Van Kasper now Wells Fargo approached us and said they were a local bank and would help us if we would just put them on the cover. We met with their team and were very impressed. We were able to renegotiate a small participation fee.</p><p>The lead bank also influences to a great deal the other players on the team, the banks, the attorneys and the accountants. We were very happy with a local attorney firm in Salt Lake who had taken several local companies public. Robbie would not hear of it. We had to select between several of the top three or four California based law firms. These firms charge a premium, because of their name and associations. The attorneys, banks and accountants have a network of companies they choose to work with. In their defense, they were doing so many IPOs and so rapidly, they could not afford to have one of the “working group” to not pull its weight. Fortunately, we were using Arthur Anderson as our accountants and that met Robbie’s criteria (obviously this was before the Enron scandal). We decided to use Brobeck as our attorneys because they had an office in Denver who had some cycles they could spare. Most of the attorneys with offices in California were so busy taking other companies public, they did not have time to assist us. Brobeck did a good job for us, but it would have been a little more convenient and less expensive to use a local firm.</p><p>Just a side note on Arthur Anderson, Arthur Anderson was destroyed because of the actions of just a few. It is an absolute tragedy and only the beginning of the fall out of Enron and other disasters of moral decay in business. Our Arthur Anderson team was great through the whole IPO process and continued to serve the company well after the IPO. The tragedy of moral decay is that so many innocent people are hurt from the actions of a few. The country was in an uproar as they should be over the events of September 11th. The nation in many ways has rallied around the heroes of that day and the subsequent weeks. And there has been a reawakening of religious devotion and service. The same thing that has helped heal the nation from a terrorist attack will also heal it from the erosion of business ethics that has economically devastated the lives of thousands. There is no quick fix to terrorism or unethical behavior in business and financially it is going to leave a wake of tragedy. Fixing terrorism and moral decay in business will require a painstaking, inside out approach to fix. Unfortunately, if we try the quick fix, to legislate morality, the result will be more economic lives lost as companies will not be able to survive the bureaucratic red tape. As a country, an industry, a company or individual, we must be willing to pay the price to really fix the problem.</p><p>Returning to the IPO process, even after putting all the time and money into drafting the S4, (we have been told that we have one of the best written “Risk” sections ever produced) there are absolutely no guarantees that the banks will take the company public. Just before we were scheduled for the “road show,” an intensive two weeks of traveling all over the country and sometimes to Europe to meet with investors, all of the banks went before their approval teams and got the green light, to take Caldera Systems public. It is not until each banker gets the approval from their respective approval boards, that a company can go public. By this time in the process, the company has spent thousands of dollars in legal and accounting fees which could be a total loss if these boards do not approve going forward and the company has no recourse. After preparation school (our bankers insisted that we take several lessons and prepping from a specialist who helped us refine our Road show presentation and presenting skills) Alan Hansen, our CFO at the time, and I began the two week road show. This process really does help polish the presentation and allow those who present a chance to say only the things of most importance in the 20 to 30 minutes that you are given in front of each investment firm.</p><p>The Robbie team kept telling us how important it was to keep up the intensity and sell these investors on our story, as they these investors will want to hold the stock. When we went public was a unique time so it may never be repeated, but we found that their claim of not selling or “flipping” the stock with in the first few days was a misrepresentation. Within two days of actually going public, I think nearly everyone who we had spoken with on the road show and had purchased shares from Robbie had “flipped” their stock. Either we were very poor salesman or there never was any intent, at least in our case, to hold and we were just characters on a stage that they had already seen which is exactly how you feel when you present to them. I do not think this is a complete representation of what happens when companies go public as our IPO was right at the tail end of what seemed to be an unstoppable flow of IPOs in the heart of the Dot com era, a unique occurrence in history that may never repeat itself.</p><p>During the two-week trip, we had three different investment bankers travel with us. The others were required to fly home to take out other companies on the road who were going public. I guess once they saw that our offering had acceptance, they wanted the more experienced team members to get the other companies started. However, because of these constant changes and misrepresentations, at the end of the whirlwind two weeks, we felt like we had gone through the meat packing plant.</p><p>Near the end of the road show, is the pricing call. Our board and the investment bank get on a phone call and determine the initial price of the shares to be offered. The price is a very political issue. The initial price is all the proceeds that the company gets from the offering. In other words, if the stock is priced at $10.00 per share, but on the first day of trading, the price goes up to $40.00 a share, the company only receives $10.00 share. The difference goes to the commercial investors who buy the stock at $10.00 and then sell it or “flip the stock” on the same day or shortly there after. What the banks will tell you is that their commercial investors want long term investments so they will hold the stock. The bank is interested in the lowest possible price so that their investors can benefit from the upside and the lower price is an easier sale. During the road show, the bank communicates with its commercial investors and monitors their commitments to buy the stock but that information is not shared directly with the company. During the road show a figure is floated but everyone knows it can go up or down depending on the “pricing” meeting. When we talked to people during the road show, we floated the price of $10.00. We were able to raise that to $12.00 per share in the pricing call. Apparently, the demand for our stock was pretty good. Although we had an incredible presentation, the interest in our stock apparently was not a reflection of their interest in our company but an interest in the hype of Linux and the hope of making a quick buck.</p><p>Just as a side note, VA Linux and Caldera did not do as well as Red Hat in being able to benefit from going public. That may sound funny to some, because VA Linux price raised so much on the first few days of trading. As mentioned above, the company does not benefit at all from the rise in price after the initial pricing of the stock. The company and its initial investors must sign a “lock up” agreement stating that they will not sell any stock for at least 6 months. The investment banks and their investors who are offered the stock are not under the same restrictions. The reason that Red Hat did so well, was that being first, Red Hat was doing a second round of financing while VA and Caldera were both just doing our first. On the second round, the company benefits much more because the market price is now established at a much higher price. Consequently, the selling price could be much higher but the percent of change in selling price is much lower. Consequently, the second round is less attractive to commercial investors that want to ride the stock price up and “flip,” so you get more serious investors as well. As a result, to do a second round, the market and interest in your stock must be very strong, or bankers will not even bother to take you on a second round tour.</p><p>At least when our company was going through the IPO, the investment interest depended a lot on the hype of the industry or company. The investment banks utilize the hype in the industry to get the average private investor to participate. They appeared interested in only taking a company public when the company is know in the industry or the industry itself has some buzz. The commercial investors know that it is hype, but the investing public do not. The commercial investors receive blocks of stock from the bank and then as the company goes public the commercial investors and the banks sell their stock quickly as the price goes up. To avoid competition from the company and its corporate investors, the banks have them all sign lock up agreements. This insures that their commercial investors can turn a quick profit. In the stock market, the average private investor is looking for the next Apple or Microsoft. To get maximum profits, these private investors feel they have to invest on the ground floor. If there is a buzz about a company or an industry, the public will invest. Commercial investors, if the hype exists, realize it may be risky to invest long term, but they do see an opportunity to make some quick money. However, this creates a timing issue for the company who wants to raise capital in the public markets. To catch a company or industry when it is buzzing may be too soon in the typical life cycle of the company under more conservative measurements or times. For those in the industry, this timing window may be your only chance to go public and raise additional capital needed to fund growth. My speculation on this comes from the fact that many of the Dot coms that went public, had good business concepts, but they lacked the business maturity to justify their valuations. The commercial investors we talked to seemed to be very savvy and were not as interested in the business details as they were about the position in the market the company had that would insure them a lucrative market to sell their stock. Obviously, not all investors are looking for a quick turn around. The business of investment banking is very high risk. There is no guarantee that the companies stock will go up after the initial pricing. The investment bankers provide an important service with high risk and high reward and many are very legitimate. But anywhere there is “quick” money to be made; there are those who conveniently subscribe to the “end justifies the means” business ethics so prominent in our society today.</p><p>The industry was in such an IPO feeding frenzy that everyone was processing them as fast as they could. The real disappointment for Caldera was after taking us public, only two of the four bank’s analysts ever even covered the company, Robbie and First Security now Wells Fargo. Having analyst covering the company really helped stabilize the stock price. The importance of “coverage” is that the average investor does not have the time to fully investigate every company individually. They learn to listen and trust certain analysts whose job it is to know the company and make investment recommendations that they follow. This is part of the service the investment bank should provide the companies they take public, part of the benefit of being on the cover and having the initial blocks of stocks to sell, but Bear Sterns and Wit could never come up with a convenient time to begin analyst coverage in spite of numerous calls and visits by the company. Robbie’s analyst quit shortly after our IPO and they were not able to replace him for several months. We met with the new analyst and he suggested we come back after the acquisition of SCO was complete. By the time the acquisition was complete, our stock had dropped below ten dollars, partly because we did not have coverage from the analysts and partly because of market conditions, and Robbie said, “don’t call us we will call you.” When the company could have greatly benefited from analyst coverage, all of our top banks who benefited from the IPO were no where to be seen. Only First Security Van Kasper or Wells Fargo, who benefited by far the least, continued to cover the company. Knowing what I know now about the industry, if I were a commercial investor, I would do the research myself. The analyst may provide some guidance, but they were way overvalued. With recent changes by the SEC, more and more companies will begin to make their own projections directly to the investors which will reduce the industry’s dependence on analysts and investment bankers after the IPO.</p><p>To anyone interested in taking a company public, of all the banks we participated with, First Security Van Kasper (Wells Fargo) provided the best services and stuck with us for some time. It may just be that regional banks still value a customer rather than seeing them as a cog in their machinery. I do not want to appear ungrateful, nor do I want to paint the whole investment industry as completely self serving, there are just some observations that will hopefully help others keep their eyes open. We had a very successful IPO and had raised a significant amount of money. But through the process, I had learned that the ones who really made the money were the banks, the commercial investors, the attorneys and accountants and we were just a very, very small dab of grease in a very large system of financial wheels. Caldera went public during a financial hay day for the information technology that may never occur again. Some of these experiences may not be as applicable now, but the experience was extremely eye opening. I have included a memo I sent out to the IPO working group shortly after completing the IPO in hopes that it would be some constructive criticism:</p><h3>Dear Working Group,</h3><p>I wanted to write and thank everyone on this list for a lot of very hard work. We greatly appreciate all the effort in getting our company public. We all sincerely thank you.</p><p>I also wanted to give you our perceptions of the process in hopes that it might be beneficial to everyone in the future. I thought I would do it bank by bank.</p><h3>First Security</h3><p>First Security came into the process quite late, but they were extremely helpful to us personally. With very little to gain financially, they put forth genuine efforts in answering questions, critiquing our presentation and providing assistance.</p><h3>WIT Soundview</h3><p>Like First Security, WIT was extremely helpful during all phases of the process. They would call and answer questions as well as educate us on the entire ordeal. They gave us a lot of time and access to their top people to ensure that the process went well for us.</p><p>On the Directed Share program, they bent over backwards to meet our requests. They went out of their way to bring in Montgomery to handle our International needs. We are extremely grateful for their efforts.</p><p>The actual process for Friends and Family needs a little work. The process is just too complex for people with limited and even a lot of experience on the Internet to follow. I completed the process for one of my friends and followed each step as outlined only to have Wit tell me that I did not complete the process right. There are just too many things that can go wrong. We recognize that what we asked for was unique, but there are some things that could have been done to avoid the problems that occurred. I offer some suggestions that might have helped.</p><p>After the registration deadline was past, a report could have been generated to indicate all of the participants who did not complete the process correctly. We could have compared lists and resolved many of the problems then. We would have had an exact numbers of participants and then allocated the shares appropriately. As it turned out, there were many people internationally that received far more shares then our domestic participants. No letter should have been sent out stating that a random number generator had kicked them out. We agreed at the beginning that everyone in the program should receive shares and we were going to allocate them across the board.</p><h3>Bear Sterns</h3><p>We appreciate Bear’s help during the financial due diligence, but in hindsight, we are left with the feeling that it was not to help our company as much as cover Bear’s exposure. We felt that there was little contribution made for the amount of the deal that Bear received. We spoke only one time with a senior Bear representative and that was to discuss the economics and Bears percentage of the IPO. We would have liked to offer more to WIT and First Security if we had it all to do over.</p><h3>Roberstson Stephens</h3><p>We appreciate the many hours put into our transaction by Robertson. There were many things done to help, like finding 4,500 shares to help with the problems that occurred with the directed share program. Clearly, with Robbie being the lead, the likelihood of finding more concerns is much higher as they have done more work. At the end of the process, we were left with many unanswered questions and were treated at different stages with almost contempt. For example, the directed share people were almost rude in there responses to our requests. There was no apparent attempt to even consider our needs even though they were explained in detail before Robbie was selected as the lead. The investment banking team on our deal was extremely helpful and professional, but they were very young and lacked considerable experience when compared to the representatives from even the co-managing banks.</p><p>Many things were not explained to us. We had never taken a company public and many things were left unsaid which could have been very helpful. For example, during the pricing meeting, we indicated that we would like to see 20% of the deal go to retail. We were told that including the directed share program, 20% of the deal was going to retail. I have been informed subsequently, that typical deals are 20% excluding directed shares. We were also led to believe that institutional investors were better because Robbie sales force would work with them to insure that they would hold the shares. With 90% of the deal going (excluding directed shares) to institutional investors, we should not have seen such high trading volumes if a significant amount of the investors did not flip.</p><p>The impression we are left with is that we were used to grease the hands of Robbie’s true clients, the institutional investors. The retail demand was very high, which would have increased the value of the stock if the institutional investors had not flipped in such quantities. We are very anxious to see your final report on who flipped and who held the stock.</p><p>During the road show, we did not have a constant representative with us. We kept changing people in and out. We recognize that this is a very busy time, but we could not help but come away from the entire process and feel somewhat used, like we were just a cog in Robbie’s IPO machine. We do not believe you intended for us to have that experience. Anna, Nimesh and Peter are terrific, they are just overworked. Our requests to stay in less expensive, yet quality hotels were ignored. The airlines we would have rather flown were not even considered. The schedule could have been better organized to prevent flying back and forth between cities in the same day. We did not need to drive in stretch limos. Most of these issues are a direct result of trying to make it as easy as possible on those doing the scheduling because of over scheduling. Again, the impression it leaves on the company is that it is just a cog in the wheel.</p><p>We offer these insights not to complain, but to provide feedback. Our IPO is over and it was a success. We did not want a repeat of VA because it leaves so many of the investors hanging, but the price could have been higher if there had not been so many shares sold. We can now get on to our business. However, you all must continue to provide these services to other companies. I just hope you do not forget that for many of them, there will never be another time and they are depending upon you to be the experts. This is one of the most important events in a company’s history and much of it is in your control. You have an obligation to represent all of the facts to ensure that the right decisions are made. We do not feel that we were intentionally mistreated. In many cases, you are clearly trying to do too much and thus your overall service is suffering. We hope this is helpful.</p><p>Please understand that we are very grateful for the long hours spent in our behalf. Our purpose in writing this is to provide you full and honest feedback in hopes that you can improve the service that you are providing other companies in this process. We are grateful for the success that we did achieve.</p><p>We would also be amiss if we did not thank Brobeck, Cooley and Arthur Andersen for many long hours. They did an outstanding job. We could not have done it without their efforts in our behalf. Thank you.</p><p>Respectfully,</p><p>Ransom</p><p>All of the feeding frenzy is gone in the public markets and it may never return, but my advice is to visit with the bank’s customers and find out if they are satisfied with the service or not. Do not take the banks word alone. Spend the time to meet with several recent and not so recent customers and have them evaluate the bank. This is particularly important of your lead bank, but has direct application for the other banks and even attorneys and accountants. The process is incredibly expensive. Make sure you get your money’s worth.</p><p>With the IPO completed, we knew that we would need to use our new currency and funds to expand our business through acquisition. We felt that we could not take the time to grow organically.</p><p>�3��ՙ�</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9d8a801acb30" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>