<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Johannes C. van Nieuwkerk on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Johannes C. van Nieuwkerk on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@refival?source=rss-f51763a22342------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Wed, 18 Nov 2026 03:58:59 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@refival/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Introduction to the Dialog.Builders Project and Ecosystem on Linkedin]]></title>
            <link>https://refival.medium.com/introduction-to-the-dialog-builders-project-and-ecosystem-on-linkedin-0776de7f2204?source=rss-f51763a22342------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/0776de7f2204</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[dialogue]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[peace]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[interfaith-dialogue]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[social-media]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[convergence]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Johannes C. van Nieuwkerk]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 22 Feb 2026 10:47:54 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-02-26T15:11:17.192Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/900/1*pWTi9elLmgf7-V-LAixYPg.jpeg" /></figure><p>A Very Warm Welcome!</p><p>The <a href="https://refival.medium.com/dialog-builders-manifesto-version-18-01-26-c7b94937e922">Dialog.Builders</a> project is targeting to achieve rebalancing of one’s screen-time, face-time and reflection; goal being to escape our current restrictive social bubbles. From this isolated starting point a main hurdle to take is to get in touch with “strangers” and to listen to their opinions; submerging oneself in the thoughts or positions of the other, developing empathy.</p><p>The present lack of contact with the unknown is, in my opinion, a main cause of humanity drifting apart; (re)connecting will bring mankind closer together or create <a href="https://refival.medium.com/make-earth-great-again-theoretical-background-long-read-37f18c72bcb2">convergence</a> as I name it.</p><p>The targeted communication, either being on-line or in person, has three envisioned degrees of depth:</p><p>The first (“local”) level is a fact-finding level where one can ask “someone local” questions as a more direct alternative source of one’s information, circumventing the added political narratives of today’s mass media.</p><p>The second (“fellow”) level is about establishing a connection between people; it targets to establish more durable personal relationships between “equals”.</p><p>The third (“guide”) level goes a step further and tries to establish a relationship between teachers and students. It tries to facilitate access to mentors or guides both on a worldly as well as on a spiritual excellence level. It explores unknown territory with the target to reflect and create meaning this way.</p><p>To achieve the above goals, <a href="https://refival.medium.com/dialog-builders-manifesto-version-18-01-26-c7b94937e922">Dialog.Builders</a>’ ecosystem consists of seven communities and it uses Linkedin groups’ infrastructure as a carrier.</p><p>The first community is an overarching Linkedin group under the name <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/groups/11806115/">dialog.builders</a>. Here anyone can exchange information. The other six Linkedin groups are meant as platforms for active participants and to facilitate the exchange between them.</p><p>“Ask” means primarily virtual contact in this context, whereas “Borrow” follows the logic of borrowing a human, similar to borrowing a book from a library; it is meant to enable more in-depth face-to-face encounters.</p><p>The six parallel active participant’s Linkedin sub-groups are named: <a href="http://www.askalocal.earth/">www.askalocal.earth</a>, <a href="http://www.borrowalocal.earth/">www.borrowalocal.earth</a>, <a href="http://www.askafellow.earth/">www.askafellow.earth</a>, <a href="http://www.borrowafellow.earth/">www.borrowafellow.earth</a>, <a href="http://www.askaguide.earth/">www.askaguide.earth</a> and <a href="http://www.borrowaguide.earth/">www.borrowaguide.earth</a>.</p><p>The communities’ basis is reciprocity; only group members can be contacted and can contact others in the group. The Ask-a-Guide and Borrow-a-Guide sub-communities differ slightly in their approach. Not everyone will be able to fulfill the role of a mentor. Still, membership of the latter two sub-communities assumes, whenever possible, allowing others to access one’s own area of excellence. Many people possess such virtuousness-based personal qualities and can share them.<br> <br>The <a href="https://refival.medium.com/introduction-to-the-dialog-builders-project-and-ecosystem-on-linkedin-0776de7f2204">Dialog.Builders</a> ecosystem entirely follows a non-commercial path; it is meant to be freely accessible for everyone on Linkedin. Still, it is exclusively the group member’s decision to enter into dialog with anyone requesting this.</p><p>My hope is that you will join Dialog.Builders and one or more of the Linkedin six sub-communities and through interaction with strangers contribute to a world growing together instead of drifting apart.</p><p>Warm Regards,</p><p>Johannes Cornelis (Hans) van Nieuwkerk</p><p><strong>A list of some further readings about the project’s background:</strong><br>Make Earth Great Again, Introduction: <a href="http://www.m-e-g-a.life/">www.m-e-g-a.life</a><br>Make Earth Great Again, Background: <a href="https://background.m-e-g-a.life/">https://background.m-e-g-a.life</a><br>Dialog Builders, Background: <a href="https://background.dialog.builders/">https://background.dialog.builders</a><br>End of Year Reflection 2024 on Dialog Builders: <a href="https://reflection2024.dialog.builders/">https://reflection2024.dialog.builders</a><br>One Pager Introduction to Dialog Builders’ Structure: <a href="https://onepager.dialog.builders/">https://onepager.dialog.builders</a><br>The Convergence Fundament (Older Article): <a href="http://www.convergence.ngo/">www.convergence.ngo</a><br>The Religious Concepts Component: <a href="http://www.samadeus.org/">www.samadeus.org</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=0776de7f2204" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Dialog.Builders Manifesto (Version 18/01/26)]]></title>
            <link>https://refival.medium.com/dialog-builders-manifesto-version-18-01-26-c7b94937e922?source=rss-f51763a22342------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c7b94937e922</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[interfaith-dialogue]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[convergence]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[peace]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[dialogue]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Johannes C. van Nieuwkerk]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 18 Jan 2026 10:05:02 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-03-05T22:04:49.942Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/700/0*oG_iPWCEpkvaLIih.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>Manifesto</strong></p><p>Humanity is in an existential crisis; people are growing apart and are becoming more and more polarized or “divergent” as I name it. Whereas mankind meanwhile possesses all tools and technologies needed to realize a dignified life for all human beings, we instead increasingly face conflict, inequality, forced migration and (mankind induced) climate change. This indicates that we, as humanity, are failing and are using our capabilities wrongly.</p><p>Some of us are maximizing their individual growth and footprint at the cost of others, often without realizing it. They do this instead of respecting personal boundaries and achieving sustainable growth for all of us. How to change the above behavior is the topic of this manifesto and its background. People will need to grow more together if we want to succeed in addressing the problems that impact all of us.</p><p>My counter movement proposition is quite straightforward; we need to enter into dialog with strangers and learn to encounter the unknown more often in order to get closer to each other. This can, as such, be relatively easily stimulated by wearing a Dialog.Builders symbol/button/badge, which invites strangers to address someone wherever he or she encounters a participant. However, the target is not to just establish a non-committing, small-talk type of conversation, but to contribute to convergence.</p><p>(The artwork required to locally produce/order the Dialog.Builders button can be found <a href="https://refival.wordpress.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/07/dialog_builders_jelveny_.pdf">here</a> (commercial exploitation of the logo is not allowed). Please contact us at <a href="/service/mailto:jcn@dialog.builders">jcn@dialog.builders</a> in case you need any further assistance. Since it will take time to reach a critical mass in which people will recognize each other in daily life on the street, virtual communities are used as catalysts to bring like-minded people together. To “join” the informal Linkedin Dialog.Builders <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/groups/11806115/">community</a> and its six sub- communities: <a href="http://www.askalocal.earth/">Ask-a-Local</a>, <a href="http://www.borrowalocal.earth/">Borrow-a-Local</a>, <a href="http://www.askafellow.earth/">Ask-a-Fellow</a>, <a href="http://www.borrowafellow.earth/">Borrow-a-Fellow</a>, <a href="http://www.askaguide.earth/">Ask-a-Guide</a> and <a href="http://www.borrowaguide.earth/">Borrow-a-Guide</a>, see: <a href="https://community.dialog.builders/">https://community.dialog.builders</a> and <a href="https://onepager.dialog.builders/">https://onepager.dialog.builders</a>)</p><p>Wearing the initiative’s button represents an open invitation to others to establish contact and to start talking to the person showing the Dialog.Builders button; establishing a “listening to each other” focused dialog. The approach is fully concentrated on learning from and about the other, clearly not on teaching one’s points of view or telling people to be right or wrong. The objective is to reflect on the faced and absorbed unknown. Its ultimate purpose is to internalize the encounter and make it one’s own by processing it. Nevertheless, normally, reciprocity will also be the result of a conversation and people will thus, additionally, automatically learn from and about each other’s views.</p><p>At first, the above idea seems pretty simple. However, listening to the unknown is actually very difficult and has to be learned. Further, what to learn strongly depends on one’s cultural context. There are fortunately many listening and reflection techniques available that can be learned. Which ones to select is beyond the scope of this manifesto. However, there is some guidance in the goals of the initiative being to meet the other with eight convergent attitudes: resemblance, affection, mindfulness, kindness, virtuousness, clear-sightedness, meekness and tenderness.</p><p>The above manifesto itself is short. However, the theoretical background of these processes and of the initiative is more extensive and will now be elaborated upon into more detail.</p><p><strong>Background: how did we stop listening to each other and ourselves?</strong> <strong>Root causes: media use</strong></p><p>Whereas radio and television were, in the beginning, a catalyst for starting a conversation between people — everyone listening to or watching the same channel, absorbing the same content, broadcast media actually became the start for more individualization or belonging to smaller, more specialized, groups of interest. With more choice, less people watched or listened to the same program and people started to become more selective, this automatically affected their human discussions which also became narrower and more selective.</p><p>From a, meanwhile mostly commercial, broadcaster’s point of view, the question became how to profit-wise optimize their audience. Two aspects are important here. First, broadcasters tried to find a common denominator, meaning that the popularity of the program became key. However, it also meant that large audience content became shallower. Second, because of the rise of zapping behavior, broadcasters needed to optimize the direct impact of their content, making it overall faster and more pronounced in order to attract immediate attention at any point in time to be selected between the many alternatives. As an overall effect, the continuous, optimized, call for attention has led to a general increase of media based screen time versus face time.</p><p>The next step beyond radio and TV is social media. Zapping has meanwhile been replaced by swiping. Posts must now attract our immediate attention to be liked and shared, and are thus optimized to strongly distract us from our daily routine (they become our daily routine) and to keep us busy.</p><p>Furthermore, friends force us via social pressure to participate and share our lives, often resulting in showing the outside world an avatar of ourselves, someone we would maybe like to be, but who we in reality are not. Notwithstanding, this effectively increases our screen time at the cost of face time even further.</p><p>Due to the uninterrupted stream of messages we now receive, our attention span is also becoming shorter, meaning that messages must be very brief and striking to be read and that more complex or longer messages are skipped or ignored. The end-result of these developments is that people started to live in a private bubble; a virtual life which is continuously requiring their attention, without much time left to physically <a href="https://www.derekthompson.org/p/the-death-of-partying-in-the-usaand">socialize</a> or reflect.</p><p>The next, AI assisted, step seems to go even further. AI starts to prevent material it considers non-relevant from reaching us. If one now searches with Google or opens a PDF, AI offers a summary to the user. For many people, this summary likely will be enough in the dense and overloaded information world we are meanwhile living in, and will read no further. What we tend to forget is that it are often the more random, less directly related, less precise, search results, which bring us our creative ideas and solutions because they stimulate us to think out of the box.</p><p>Following the filtering of information, limiting our view, AI powered LLMs like ChatGPT are <a href="https://refival.medium.com/cultural-divergence-as-a-result-of-using-artificial-intelligence-a-human-convergence-defff3600e83">mimicking human communication</a> in order to personally assist us. This indirectly reduces the need to seek true human dialog and <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GfeQXYFMuz0">reinforces the “acceptability”</a> of one’s growing actual personal isolation.</p><p>For now, the main problem caused by the above trends is that adopting this new virtual lifestyle leads to a strong reduction of real world human exposure outside of one’s core social bubble. We less and less meet and communicate with strangers coincidentally. Nevertheless, randomly encountering people in daily life remains the main contact with the unknown and an essential source of food for thought. Without such exposure there is less empathy and understanding developed; there is less convergence built. Encountering strangers is not about having the same opinion or agreeing or disagreeing with them; it is all about listening to and understanding the other’s, often different, views and to reflect on them. Such reflection does not require agreement.</p><p><strong>Background: how to counter divergence?</strong></p><p>Dialog.Builders’ goal is to increase the convergence between people. This means primarily to open up to listening. Of course this will also lead to talking and reciprocal dialog but Dialog.Builders’ mission is not to convince others, there are no rights or wrongs, there is no authority; there are only different opinions.</p><p>Wearing the initiative’s symbol/button/badge represents an open invitation to others to establish contact and to start talking in order to establish the above type of a listening-focused dialog. Although mostly very different in its purpose, there are similarities with the logic of confessing to a priest, one can out oneself here. The initiative’s approach is fully concentrated on learning from and about the other, clearly not on teaching one’s points of view. Nevertheless, normally, reciprocity will be the end result, and people will also learn from each other’s opinions.</p><p>There is always a relationship between talking and listening. However, teaching very often increases the distance between people because some participants will possess more knowledge than others about a subject. This is something that can easily create a position of authority and make people feel superior, creating divergence. But, as such, knowledge inequality does not have to cause such an issue as long as there is fundamental equality instead of dominance between people. For Dialog.Builders, every human being is considered different but equally valuable. Unfortunately, this is far from obvious in today’s reality.</p><p>On the other, listening, side, learning from/about the other brings people closer and leads mostly to convergence. The main purpose of the Dialog.Builders initiative is not to try to reach agreement or consensus with each other but to improve one’s understanding of a possibly different point of view, increasing tolerance; this will ultimately create more unity.</p><p>There is a fine balance between talking and listening, between teaching and learning. The first two of the pairs are needed as the stimulus or impulse for human growth, development and expansion, whereas the second pair is also there to realize or discover one’s boundaries and to prevent people from crossing the line: “learning” to respect others and nature/our environment over or in relation to a limitless desire for human growth and human control.</p><p>The problem is that currently there is a structural divergent unbalance found and that humanity (growing towards its death) urgently needs to undo this and rebalance itself by creating an increase in convergence. This is needed in order to address the issues we commonly or collectively face as humanity, such as conflict, climate change, inequality and forced migration. In our current largely individualistic world, there are, as we will see, five elements to address. For most people it will mean to focus less on their virtual avatar and be more authentic, but there are four more attitudes which determine our relationship with others and with the outside world. Dialog.Builders wants to promote the use of this convergent side of humanity more.</p><p>Which attitude is most relevant, depends actually on the cultural context one lives in. Explaining one’s cultural positioning is beyond the scope of this article. However, a detailed description of all detailed processes can be found in two previous publications: “<a href="https://refival.medium.com/the-parable-of-religious-convergence-3-the-path-of-non-violent-resistance-e2037892d6e2">The Parable of Religious Convergence, The Path of Non-Violent Resistance</a>” and “<a href="https://refival.medium.com/end-of-year-reflection-about-dialog-a0f2a7b8543f">About Dialog</a>”.</p><p>As said before, the initiative’s goal is to create a movement that stimulates people to establish communication with others on the basis of convergent principles; adjusting the globally divergent, currently unbalanced and dominant, elements with their convergent counterparts this way. Over the years I intensively observed people “culturally communicating” with each other, and developed a personal theory about the <a href="https://refival.medium.com/end-of-year-reflection-about-dialog-a0f2a7b8543f">ways</a> they use to do so. The corresponding cultural elements of my communication theory and their connections or attitudes will therefore be discussed into more detail now.</p><p><strong>Background: ten cultural elements; sixteen relationships between them</strong></p><p>Regardless of whether a cultural element in itself is individual or collective in nature, there are always two perspectives to be found. One perspective looks at the relational aspects from the “collective environment” point of view downwards, and represents the society’s dynamics towards its participants (top-down). The other perspective looks from the individual towards their surroundings and represents the upward individual-driven input or attitude to such a society’s framework (bottom-up). To analyze dialog, the second perspective is more useful, it directly shows how an individual can communicatively contribute to a society. This means that, other than in most of my previous publications, this bottom-up view from the individual upward towards their surroundings is used here.</p><p>In total there are ten cultural elements and sixteen relationships found between them, half of these are divergent and will mostly be used as a comparison or contrast to understand the other — convergent — half better. The outcome is that only the following five — bottom-up — cultural elements are the most relevant to detail, being the ones considered contributing to convergence according to my models: Genuineness, Adhesion, Hospitality, Entrustment and Compassion. These five elements and the eight relationships between them (four rational, two emotional and two spiritual), or to say it differently, their connecting convergent attitudes, will be elaborated on.</p><p><strong>-1- Rational dominance: Genuineness</strong></p><p>In the context of relating from Individual Identity (II) to others in the Emotional or Spiritual domain, there are four rational balances between divergence [d] and convergence [c] found, being: -a- Otherness [d] versus Resemblance [c], -b- Almsgiving [d] versus Mindfulness [c], -c- Mastery [d] versus Virtuousness [c] and -d- Disentitlement [d] versus Meekness [c].</p><p>Looking at the four above rational processes, which all point away from individual identity towards emotional or spiritual cultural elements, we can observe that the ones which have conditions imposed on or attached to participants and differentiate between people on the basis of such criteria are the divergent ones. Related to becoming involved, one has to show candidacy to become part. There is an argument ongoing about who can participate and who cannot. People with an outward looking attitude are thus forced to show their eligibility by presenting themselves, talking, rationally expressing themselves to be in favor of the demands. Often “candidates” will have to adapt to fulfill the external criteria, losing their genuineness. This process leads to artificiality, separation and a growing apart, as I name it divergence.</p><p>At the other, inward oriented side, this is not the case; people are primarily listening and asking themselves what or how they can take part in or contribute to the society, exploring their authenticity or genuineness. In principle, everyone capable can unconditionally participate in this case; this brings people closer to each other and makes them thus convergent. Each of the four processes will be described now.</p><p><em>-a- Otherness [d] versus Resemblance [c]</em></p><p>The first process links the individual with a small core group of others (Emotional Identity, EI), a group which gives a feeling of belonging to its members; there is a world of insiders and one of outsiders created. It frequently means to develop criteria for who can join and become a member; people who do not match these criteria or in a different way “express/show” otherness from the group are excluded, which is divergent. One often must adjust to the group identity and share a collective group conviction in order to join, trading one’s genuineness. The convergent alternative is to, in principle, allow everyone who identifies with the group to become its member and base the group on resemblance. This means to let people indiscriminately participate and let them explore their level of true commonality instead of primarily focusing on the differences between them.</p><p><em>-b- Almsgiving [d] versus Mindfulness [c]</em></p><p>The second process links the individual with the society as an overarching emotional entity (Emotional Unity, EU). Also, here two types of engagement can be found. One can see one’s engagement as an “obligation” and fulfill one’s duties or imposed expectations on the basis of who one considers oneself to be (expression). In practice, this means paying an obligatory contribution like taxes or an almsgiving type of donation to support the poor or deprived. However, this does not imply any deeper involvement beyond. Exclusivity is preserved, and the outward looking almsgiving approach mostly remains divergent by effectively separating the benefactor from the beneficiaries. The alternative, inward looking, approach is to listen and observe others and to ask oneself what one can contribute to the society as a whole. This mindfulness approach is convergent and brings people more intensively together.</p><p><em>-c- Mastery [d] versus Virtuousness [c]</em></p><p>The third process links the individual with governance (Spiritual Identity, SI). Entitlement to govern can be based on two principles in this case. The first one is formal education or other qualifications, in which people have to show their knowledge or potential influence in order to express their suitability to be in power. This mastery approach generates a classification and is thus divergent. The alternative, second, approach is based on people’s personal qualities or virtuousness; the most suitable people will govern, not based on individual power but on their capacity to listen to what is needed and prioritize the measures required. This is the convergent way.</p><p><em>-d- Disentitlement [d] versus Meekness [c]</em></p><p>The last, fourth individual process links the individual with regard for others or the universe (Spiritual Unity, SU). In this situation, there is an argument about the entitlement to participate, which can easily lead to dispossession of rights or property by those expressing to be entitled to more at the cost of those proclaimed to take no part in the system. This outward looking “apartheid” approach is separating people into entitled and disentitled and is thus divergent. The convergent alternative is to observe or listen to, for example nature and to develop meekness toward forces beyond human control and to submit oneself to acceptance of the unknown instead of trying to control it, this is a first stage of <a href="http://www.samadeus.org/">what religion is about</a>.</p><p>All four previously described personal balances are the start of a relationship between the individual and the outside world. These processes are dominantly rational. However, if one continues on the four (eight) paths opening up, one enters into the dominantly emotional or dominantly spiritual domain. It means that there are four (balanced) complements found, which are not rationally dominant but, which dominantly represent emotionality or spirituality. Their following order of use in practice depends on the culture one lives in. These, four, non-rational, cultural processes will be described now.</p><p><strong>-2- Emotional dominance: Adhesion &amp; Hospitality</strong></p><p><em>-a- Kinship [d] versus Affection [c]</em></p><p>Collectively, the members of a limited group (EI) have two choices: they can focus on “us” or they can focus on “them”. A focus on “them” leads to enforcement of strict kinship rules or to an expectation of strong loyalty to the group. This way the group’s identity is protected (conditional approach). This often causes tension between those members closely following the core conviction of the group and those who are more loosely attached or further away in their identification and are thus at risk to be expelled and become outsiders. Since there mostly is animosity between insiders and outsiders of the group, the approach is divergent. The convergent alternative is to focus on “us” and to make the group adhesive, welcoming everyone who feels at home in the group and let them explore their level of affection or commonality in following the group’s collective ideals (unconditional approach).</p><p><em>-b- Malleability [d] versus Kindness [c]</em></p><p>The second example of a relationship between rationality and emotionality is based on the treatment of strangers or outliers in a collective society (EU). Peoples’ behavior is based on their participation or engagement rather than on individual independence. The polarization is found in whether the society is principally warm or cold towards outsiders.</p><p>From a personal communication perspective, there is either hospitality or exclusivity/reservedness encountered. The “exclusive” nationalistic outward looking polarity leads to an expectation of compliance or malleability of the other to the group’s principles (assimilation). This is a continuation of the almsgiving approach which does not require real or close emotional involvement. Although people are more collectively involved at this stage, it is on the basis of a commonly or nationalistically sharing norms for being “proud of the society they are part of” and not on any sympathy for each other. This is mostly also expressed in their treatment of strangers as being unwelcome intruders instead of being welcome guests. Outliers are fenced-off from a patriotic environment. This is divergent behavior.</p><p>The alternative convergent polarity is to be hospitable and to treat strangers with kindness. Such society is open for change and absorption; it is based on what people have to collectively offer to others. There is convergent, solidarity-based behavior, to be found.</p><p><strong>-3- Spiritual dominance: Entrustment &amp; Compassion</strong></p><p><em>-a- Dictatorship [d] versus Clear-Sightedness [c]</em></p><p>The first spiritual balance is about governance or having control over all people in the entire ecosystem (SI). It is the leadership that rules over the spiritual domain here. Such a spiritual arrangement can be based on Entrustment, where everyone is positioned by voluntarily optimizing their fitting or matching capabilities to the entirety or, alternatively, it can be founded on a hierarchy, enforcing people how and where to fit in.</p><p>Enforcement means human control and to create a hierarchy of giving and taking autocratic orders in order to manage the entirety. Such a hierarchy is divergent in its character because it ranks people on the basis of formal appearances rather than their capabilities. At its top-end one finds an autocratic dictator ruling over all.</p><p>At the other side of the spectrum one finds Entrustment: here people contribute to the entirety on the basis of their capabilities and are empowered to do so by the leadership. This type of leadership is based on clear-sightedness, wisdom and mentorship. The “<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Primus_inter_pares">primus inter pares</a>” type leader does in this case not control people but instead stimulates or enables them to maximally contribute to the ecosystem; people are looking inward and behave convergently.</p><p><em>-b- Dehumanization [d] versus Tenderness [c]</em></p><p>The second and last spiritual balance is about the footprint of people as part of the entire ecosystem or universe (SU). It is about controlling the human impact and to address the eventual disharmony of negatively being out of balance by reducing this human footprint. The first, convergent, way is to look inward and to, through the development of (spiritual) compassion with all others, learning to realize that death is inevitable if it comes, and to learn to accept this. The second way is an outward looking divergent one, it enforces full subservience to the system and makes people silent from reacting at (human) measures or on (human) events which kill “other” people and actually could kill them in the end as well.</p><p>The above is not about the leadership guiding this process here (like in the first spiritual balance), but about the way mankind as a collective of individuals does not oppose it. This, subservience-based, process leads to human controlled spirituality, where humans decide (or allow their leaders to decide) how to reduce the human footprint by defining who gets the space and thus by destroying or killing all others who are no longer considered to be human, but vermin to be killed.</p><p>People dehumanize part of the population as being disentitled to occupy space and live in that space. The process starts with dispossession and ends with genocide and is clearly divergent. After Nazism, with its “<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Untermensch">Untermensch</a>” classification, it is what is currently happening in Gaza. The treatment of the Palestinians in Gaza is a clear example of this process. All Gazans are considered to be the vermin of Hamas, including babies, and can be killed without giving it any second thought.</p><p>The alternative to reduce the footprint is to look inward and to, out of compassion, share the surplus one may have with all others in order to reduce the total space mankind occupies and thus to maximize the space for the entire population. This spiritual tenderness approach is clearly convergent.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*79KNt24C1J35lgPIGI2oKQ.gif" /><figcaption>Diagram 1: Bottom-up World Map of Personal Cultural Involvement</figcaption></figure><p><strong>To do: start wearing the Dialog.Builders symbol and behave more convergently!</strong></p><p>Dialog.Builders is about escaping one’s virtual bubble with its related screen time, and to generate more face-time plus time for, inward looking, reflection. Starting point is to put one’s mobile phone away whilst travelling or when one is in other public spaces with people around. This allows strangers (or even friends or acquaintances these days) to initiate a face-to-face conversation by reaching out to the ones wearing a Dialog.Builders button. Wearing the badge symbolizes openness to get into dialog. (Also at home dialog is important but this subject is beyond the scope here). If no-one is around or no-one seeks connection, one should start reflecting rather than becoming hooked to the distraction of portable media again. In my opinion, people should clearly start to organize their balance between screen-time, face-time, and reflection.</p><p>The first step is to connect; the badge or button possibly being a catalyst. The next step is how to channel one’s thoughts and let them become proper input of the inwardly directed reflection processes in order to learn about the other, the unknown and about oneself. The target is not to immediately answer the questions or to react to the feelings one may have or that may be raised. The focus is primarily on listening and showing understanding, much less on someone’s own existing position. The goal is to absorb the raised questions, feelings and “awareness of existence” and process them until, for example via contemplation, an attitude out of one’s authenticity or genuineness appears. At that moment, a person gains clarity about where they stand and becomes generally able to respond more meaningfully. Their perspective now arises from a place of inner coherence and authenticity. The result of contemplating is not any concrete answer, but dissolving the question itself.</p><p>There are five reflection processes to be found here; associated with the five elements. Related to genuineness there is contemplation or realization, related to adhesion there is “emphatization”, related to hospitality there is “sympathization”, related to entrustment there is “empowerization”, and finally related to compassion there is invocation, prayer or meditation. To discuss them in detail is unfortunately beyond the limits of this article. However, the eight convergent attitudes are the outcome of these five reflection techniques.</p><p>The manifesto tries to generate a basic framework to process the encountered “food for reflection”. It tries to stimulate some attitudes whereas it tries to diminish others. However, every individual will have to independently explore what he or she relates to.</p><p>If humanity wants to grow together, it means to start avoiding the eight divergent attitudes and to stimulate using their complementing opposite convergent counterparts instead.</p><p><strong>Conclusion</strong></p><p>The world is rapidly falling apart. Institutions like the UN and its related international courts have the world’s mandate to prevent this. Unfortunately, this structure is currently failing on humanity because its members are becoming increasingly polarized and structurally disagree on the necessary measures to be taken. The UN therefore needs urgent <a href="http://www.unv2.org/">modernization</a> to fulfill our mandate again to safeguard peace and to contribute to issues like reducing forced migration, climate change and inequality, which impact all of us.</p><p>Besides this top-down approach, there is another vision, one of a bottom-up contribution of all individuals towards a better understanding of each other. Sadly, the opposite personal development is going on. Individuals are getting more and more isolated by the virtual media bubble they create and live in. There is less and less communication or contact with the unknown outside of their bubble.</p><p>This manifesto proposes a solution here. It targets to create a dialog between strangers and their related unknown by creating an opportunity to connect. Practically, it is simple — if those willing to allow connection start wearing a visible Dialog.Builders symbol/badge/button they cast an open invitation to talk to them. The goal is to improve the understanding of each other and to become more tolerant for differences by exchanging experiences.</p><p>However, such a result is not automatically achieved and needs guidance. First, the focus of the initiated dialog must be on listening to and learning from each other, rather than on talking or teaching the other one’s “right” opinion. Second, the impulses received as food for thought from the outside world, must be processed properly and internalized. The targeted result must not be a change of opinion about the single individual one has met, but a change in attitude. This is done by reflection on experiences by realization, “empathization”, “symphatization”, “empowerization” or invocation.</p><p>Finally, Dialog.Builders offers a theoretical model framework to achieve these convergent results above. It proposes to replace divergent by convergent attitudes:</p><p>-otherness by resemblance</p><p>-kinship by affection</p><p>-almsgiving by mindfulness</p><p>-malleability by kindness</p><p>-mastery by virtuousness</p><p>-dictatorship by clear-sightedness</p><p>-disentitlement by meekness</p><p>-dehumanization by tenderness</p><p>Internalizing these eight target processes will lead to a bottom-up growing together, correcting the current dominantly divergent tendency and form a counter movement. Hopefully, it will make the world a better place to live for all of us.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c7b94937e922" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Make-Earth-Great-Again (Persoonlijke Eindejaarsreflectie)]]></title>
            <link>https://refival.medium.com/make-earth-great-again-persoonlijke-eindejaarsreflectie-e858c5c4861e?source=rss-f51763a22342------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e858c5c4861e</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[maga]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[communicatie]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[vrede]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[filosofie]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mega]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Johannes C. van Nieuwkerk]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 17 Dec 2025 09:36:46 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-12-17T09:40:18.409Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/900/1*fSHbMxcs7BdjlZQfgSeQ-w.jpeg" /></figure><p>(Een lang achtergrondartikel over de basis van M-E-G-A is <a href="https://refival.medium.com/make-earth-great-again-theoretical-background-long-read-37f18c72bcb2">hier</a> te vinden)</p><p>Terugkijkend op 2025 staat de wereld in brand; de mensheid drijft uiteen in eindeloze conflicten over de hele wereld. Bovendien raakt de mensheid steeds meer gepolariseerd in M-A-G-A-achtige, egocentrische politieke kampen, die onze verschillen versterken in plaats van onze gelijkenis te benadrukken.</p><p>In juli 2025 startte ik mijn initiatief <a href="https://medium.com/www.dialog.builders">www.dialog.builders</a>, een actie om contact tussen vreemden te stimuleren als brug naar dialoog en om dichter bij elkaar te komen. Echter, na een week en zonder enige mogelijkheid om bezwaar aan te tekenen, werd mijn tien jaar oude persoonlijke Facebook-account verwijderd en alle inhoud van de betreffende groep vernietigd.</p><p>Toch zijn de uitdagingen niet verdwenen. Als mensen de problemen van onze tijd, zoals conflicten, ongelijkheid, gedwongen migratie en klimaatverandering, aan willen pakken, dan zullen ze dichter bij elkaar moeten komen en moeten samenwerken. Dat is waar M-E-G-A om draait. Het vertegenwoordigt een overkoepelend raamwerk om elk type persoonlijke applicatie voor het naar elkaar toegroeien of <a href="https://refival.medium.com/global-cultural-adaptation-convergence-versus-divergence-a3780482cbcc">convergentie</a>, zoals ik het noem, te bouwen.</p><p>Ondertussen voelen veel mensen zich verloren. Er zijn twee aspecten aan deze ontwikkeling. Mensen voelen zich niet gehoord en overstemd in situaties waarin ze duidelijk protesteren. Ten tweede, doordat ze steeds meer in veilige geïsoleerde sociale zeepbellen leven, zwijgen veel mensen of zijn ze zich inmiddels niet meer bewust van de onrechtvaardigheden die buiten hun beperkte wereldbeeld vallen.</p><p>Het eerste aspect weerspiegelt dat onze politieke (lokale en) internationale structuren, zoals de VN en haar op internationaal recht gebaseerde rechtbanken, ons in de steek laten en dringend aan een grondige <a href="http://www.unv2.org/">herziening</a> toe zijn. Als dit niet snel gebeurt, zullen de structuren voor mondiaal bestuur die we vandaag de dag meer dan ooit nodig hebben, verouderd en in de vergetelheid raken.</p><p>Het tweede aspect weerspiegelt een algemene persoonlijke verschuiving in de loop der tijd van “Wat kan ik bijdragen aan mijn omgeving?”, geworteld in (wederzijdse) afhankelijkheid, naar “Wat levert het mij op?”, als gevolg van onze toenemende materiële onafhankelijkheid. Menselijke cohesie raakt vaak verminderd of wordt genegeerd in onze op technologische vooruitgang gerichte samenleving; een trend die moet worden gecompenseerd of omgedraaid.</p><p>Kijkend naar de problemen waarmee de mensheid momenteel wordt geconfronteerd, komen die voornamelijk voort uit een gebrek aan zelfregulatie. Onze ongecontroleerde en onbegrensde (‘the sky is the limit’-type) groei van de individuele invloed veroorzaakt spanningen binnen de mensheid, wat weer leidt tot geweld en oorlogen. Bovendien veroorzaakt het, externe, onomkeerbare milieuschade, wat leidt tot klimaatrampen.</p><p>Het doel van <a href="http://www.m-e-g-a.life/">M-E-G-A</a> is dan ook om (opnieuw) de focus te leggen op de individuele bijdrage aan iemands sociale of maatschappelijke omgeving. Door mensen vrijwillig hun individuele ruimte in te laten perken kunnen de bovengenoemde spanningen verminderd worden. Deze aanpak is gebaseerd op mijn informatiefilosofie en culturele communicatiemodellen.</p><p>Welke persoonlijke bijdrage individuen kunnen leveren, hangt sterk af van de culturele context van de deelnemers. Voor degenen onder u die meer willen weten hierover, is het uitgebreide engelstalige overzichtsartikel over de fundamentele achtergrond van M-E-G-A.life <a href="http://www.background.m-e-g-a.life/">hier</a> te vinden.</p><p>Tenslotte volgt M-E-G-A een volledig bottom-up benadering; Het betekent dat ieder individu kan bijdragen aan verandering, en dat er geen excuus is om dat niet te doen. Als genoeg mensen meedoen, creëren we samen een betere toekomst voor de mensheid en maken we de aarde weer gezond.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e858c5c4861e" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Make — Earth — Great — Again (Personal End of Year Reflection 2025)]]></title>
            <link>https://refival.medium.com/make-earth-great-again-personal-end-of-year-reflection-2025-1634204ba782?source=rss-f51763a22342------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/1634204ba782</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[mega]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[world-peace]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[maga]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cultural-communication]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Johannes C. van Nieuwkerk]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 16 Dec 2025 12:15:15 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-12-16T16:50:12.156Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/900/1*fSHbMxcs7BdjlZQfgSeQ-w.jpeg" /></figure><h3><strong>Make — Earth — Great — Again (Personal End of Year Reflection)</strong></h3><p>(A long read about M-E-G-A’s background framework can be found <a href="https://refival.medium.com/make-earth-great-again-theoretical-background-long-read-37f18c72bcb2">here</a>)</p><p>Looking back at 2025, the world is on fire; humanity is drifting apart in endless wars and conflicts all around the globe. Furthermore, mankind is becoming increasingly polarized in M-A-G-A type of self-centered political camps, amplifying human otherness instead of resemblance.</p><p>In July 2025 I started my initiative <a href="http://www.dialog.builders/">www.dialog.builders</a>, an action to stimulate contact between strangers as a bridge towards dialog and getting closer to each other. However, after a week and without any possibility to appeal, my decade old personal Facebook account got deleted and all content of the related group destroyed.</p><p>Still, the challenges did not disappear. If people want to address the issues of our time like conflicts, inequality, forced migration and climate-change, they will need to get closer and cooperate. This is what M-E-G-A is all about. It represents the overarching framework needed to build any type of personal application for growing together or <a href="https://refival.medium.com/global-cultural-adaptation-convergence-versus-divergence-a3780482cbcc">convergence</a>.</p><p>Meanwhile, many individuals feel lost. There are two aspects here. People feel not listened to and overruled in situations where they clearly protest. Secondly, increasingly living in safe isolated social bubbles, people are becoming silent or ignorant to the injustices outside of their reduced worldview.</p><p>The first aspect reflects that our political (local and) international structures like the UN and its international law based courts are failing on us and are urgently in need of a thorough <a href="http://www.unv2.org/">overhaul</a>. If this does not happen soon, the world governance structures we actually need more than ever today will become obsolete and enter into oblivion.</p><p>The second aspect reflects a general personal attitude shift over time from “What can I contribute to my environment?”, rooted in (inter)dependence, to “What is in it for me?”, as a result of our growing material independence. Human cohesion is often reduced or ignored in our technological-progress-oriented modern societies; a trend that has to be balanced or reversed.</p><p>Looking at the type of problems mankind presently faces, all issues dominantly originate from a lack of self-regulation. Our uncontrolled and unlimited (“the sky is the limit” type of) individual-human-footprint growth causes tension within humanity, leading to violence and wars. On top, it invokes external irreversible environmental damage, which leads to climate catastrophes.</p><p><a href="http://www.background.m-e-g-a.life/">M-E-G-A</a>’s target is therefore to (re-)enable a focus on individual contribution to one’s social or societal environments, voluntarily restraining one’s individual space in order to reduce the above tensions. This approach is based on my information philosophy cultural communication models.</p><p>Which type of personal contribution individuals can make strongly depends on people’s cultural context. For those of you interested in more detail, the long-read overview article about M-E-G-A’s fundamental background can be found <a href="http://www.background.m-e-g-a.life/">here</a>.</p><p>Finally, M-E-G-A fully follows a bottom-up approach; it means that every individual can contribute to change, and that there is no excuse not to do so. If enough people participate, we will create a better future world for humanity together and make-earth-great-again.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=1634204ba782" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Make — Earth — Great — Again: Theoretical Background (Long Read)]]></title>
            <link>https://refival.medium.com/make-earth-great-again-theoretical-background-long-read-37f18c72bcb2?source=rss-f51763a22342------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/37f18c72bcb2</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[earth]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[world-peace]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[maga]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cultural-communication]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Johannes C. van Nieuwkerk]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 07 Dec 2025 09:20:08 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-12-16T16:51:40.677Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/900/1*fSHbMxcs7BdjlZQfgSeQ-w.jpeg" /></figure><h3><strong>Make — Earth — Great — Again: Theoretical Background (Long Read)</strong></h3><p>(A short reflection and introduction can be found <a href="https://refival.medium.com/make-earth-great-again-personal-end-of-year-reflection-2025-1634204ba782">here</a>)</p><p><strong>Intro</strong></p><p>“Make — Earth — Great — Again” is a call for people to rebalance their path towards the future — not only technologically and economically, but primarily socially and spiritually.</p><p>Looking at the types of current problems mankind faces, they mainly originate from a lack of self-regulation. Our uncontrolled and unlimited (“the sky is the limit” type of) individual-human-footprint growth causes tension within humanity leading to violence and wars, and invokes external irreversible environmental damage which leads to climate catastrophes.</p><p>Notwithstanding, to drift apart or to expand also has the important function to innovate, to think out of the box, to be different, to attempt to find solutions or ways to survive with more people than the ecosystem naturally may allow us; to achieve “progress” for humanity and avoid stagnation.</p><p>Although innovation is driven by individuals, addressing the collective negative effects of our combined impact may nevertheless require birth control or other self-imposed reductions of our influence. Innovation-derived life-expectance increase, may well force us to reduce our individual space allocation or our collective population growth.</p><p>Alternatively, there also may be technological options discovered to harmoniously and sustainably reduce mankind’s negative effects on its environment. This would allow more people to coexist within the same shared ecosystem and would optimize the available space for humans. It could change our “survival of the fittest” evolutionary selection by an approach of voluntary self-control.</p><p>However, in order to arrive at this stage of development, we will first have to be aware of our limits and educate ourselves on restraint. This implies to become competent to grow together or contract when the challenges we face surpass our capabilities and our initiated developments get out of hand; “when the side effects of the medicines we develop are or become worse than the disease”.</p><p>Reviewing today’s polarized situation, where the focus increasingly seems to be on fighting instead of cooperating with each other, we first will need to learn to talk with and respect each other again; without doing so we are out of control and doomed.</p><p>This long read is about balancing our “drifting apart” and “growing together” and what an individual can contribute to finding equilibrium between the two. It is meant as a thought framework for building personal applications to achieve this goal rather than for describing the applications themselves. Nevertheless, the article describes fundamental options to be explored by anyone.</p><p><strong>Individualization</strong></p><p>The world’s current polarization, inequality, forced migration, and environmental destruction all stem from the same structural imbalance between humanity <em>drifting apart</em> (the collective result of our expanding individual footprints) and <em>growing together </em>(requiring the shrinking of the sum of our individual footprints)<em>.</em></p><p>Technological progress as such is not enough to address this. Only the human management of the advancement can create the required sustainability. Without awareness and oversight, change can easily turn itself against us or ruin us. In times of weapons of mass destruction, nuclear threats and <a href="https://thefutureoftrust.org/">AI</a>, we can also easily initiate our self-destruction. This is why we as humanity will very frequently need to evaluate and pause or rebalance the systemic, evolution-related, expansion of our footprint.</p><p>Compared to 100 years ago, many people have become wealthy. Mankind meanwhile created a world of mass production and consumption. This has led to more individual options to select from and increased independence — but — it has also led to more personal competition and elevated gaps between rich and poor. Unfortunately, extreme poverty still keeps millions of people caught in a situation of powerlessness and forced interdependency. Notwithstanding, from a macro-level perspective, societies became more fragmented by people obtaining more freedom of choice and, as a result, the division of communities into smaller interest groups and greater individualization.</p><p>Related to the above, also the type of personal identity has changed. Connected to our dependence levels and assuming a situation of free will rather than of people being caught in forced discipline, our personal identity largely used to be more inward-looking. Our view used to be based on an integrity-and-authenticity-derived “being an integral part of one’s environment”<strong> </strong>approach. The result was a primarily solidarity-and-respect-founded attitude of <strong>“what can I contribute to my surroundings”</strong>. Meanwhile, to a great extend, this turned into an outward-looking, comparison-based, individuality and “freedom of expression” associated positioning of people, who now prioritize <strong>“what is in it for me”</strong>. More recently, social media developments have substantially <a href="http://www.dialog.builders/">contributed</a> to and accelerated this process.</p><p>The difference between the two shows a growing-together outcome for the first “contribution-based” attitude, while the second positioning of discriminating oneself from others is causing people to drift apart. Often this also results in presenting oneself as “who one would like to be”, rather than “who one actually is”, including deviation of the truth in order to achieve one’s personal or interest group’s goals. The use of <a href="https://thefutureoftrust.org/">AI</a> to manipulate people may strongly reinforce this “fake fictional truth” process from now on.</p><p>A related result is growing <a href="https://inequalitylab.world/en/">inequality</a>. Whereas a focus on contributing to one’s environment clearly has a leveling effect, in the “what is in it for me” situation, everyone has different access to resources and opportunities, leading to uneven outcomes.</p><p>Looking at the present-day imbalance between the two forces and in order to start addressing our common problems collectively, people will have to start prioritizing reconnecting with each other and with the ecosystems that sustain our life over maximizing their personal space. This requires a rethinking or re-shift from “what is in it for me” towards a more honest authenticity-based primary attitude of “what can I contribute to my surroundings”. For the time being, in order to address the above, the latter will have to become our personal guide towards the relationships with our context.</p><p>To conclude, the above two types of individual behavior both determine how we emotionally function in groups and how we position ourselves towards others and nature from a totality perspective. Growing together is the result of having one’s surroundings as its focal point and to look inside, whereas drifting apart is mainly caused by being self-centered and to look outside for reference. Both perspectives are directly connecting the individual with its societal environment.</p><p><strong>The Societal Environment</strong></p><p>The M-E-G-A model starts non-polarized with <strong>independence</strong> representing the core individual. From here the individual is surrounded by two collective social grouping concepts: <strong>belonging</strong> for one’s inner circle and <strong>engagement</strong> for the outer, wider, social participation. Furthermore, the individual is part of an organizational society structure, also here two concepts can be found: <strong>governance</strong> for the top-down and <strong>regard</strong> for the bottom-up view on one’s position.</p><p>Applying the previously described drifting apart versus growing together logic, the above five concepts become polarized in an outward-looking (drifting apart, inequality generating (-)) and an inward-looking (growing together, equality generating (+)) outlook on the world.</p><p>-a- <strong>Independence</strong> becomes polarized in <strong>(-) individuality</strong> (the more distinguishable a person is from others, the more independent the individual becomes) and <strong>(+) authenticity</strong> (the result of inward-looking self-discovery, one’s independence is derived from observed and lived inner values).</p><p>-b- <strong>Belonging</strong> becomes polarized in <strong>(-) rivalry</strong> (a result of comparing oneself to and discriminating oneself from others in a group) and <strong>(+) empathy</strong> (a result of looking for similarity by imagining oneself to be in the position of the others in the group).</p><p>-c- <strong>Engagement </strong>becomes polarized in <strong>(-) patriotism</strong> (seeing oneself as different from other societies and the urge to maintain this difference) and <strong>(+) solidarity</strong> (seeing oneself as having the same human value as others, leading to an urge to support others who face a deprived situation in societies).</p><p>-d- <strong>Governance</strong> becomes polarized in <strong>(-) superiority</strong> (decision making and control based on power dynamics) and <strong>(+) excellence</strong> (decision making and control based on supposed wisdom of the ruler).</p><p>-e- <strong>Regard</strong> becomes polarized in <strong>(-) discipline</strong> (forced regard for the power of others) and <strong>(+) respect</strong> (voluntary observing rules out of regard for the wisdom of the ruler and the related society structure).</p><p>The result is that there are eight paths connecting an individual to its societal environment. These paths and their implications will now be elaborated upon into more detail.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Xdjnc4pzJyuecg13sZZZdw.gif" /><figcaption>Diagram 1: eight (polarized) paths between independence and belonging, engagement, governance, and regard</figcaption></figure><p><strong>Two Cold versus Two Warm Social Paths</strong></p><p>There are in principle two social positions we have to choose from: “Cold” versus “Warm”, which implies to either socially, primarily, focus on “What separates people?” or on “What people have in common?”. The first approach assumes people to be different from each other, whereas the second one assumes people to be socially fundamentally equal.</p><p>On the four resulting social paths, which connect individual independence to <strong>belonging</strong> and <strong>engagement,</strong> there are two stages: a first step away from independence where the individual position is still dominant and a second step where the collective identity becomes more important than the individual one.</p><p>The first set of two paths has <strong>belonging</strong> as its goal. It means to connect to a social group and to identify with it. There are two approaches here: as said before, a cold and a warm one.</p><p>The first option means to base one’s belonging on “what is in it for me”. It leads to exclusively cluster with objectively, criteria-wise, selected people in order to reinforce one’s own position or interests and to shut-out everyone else. There is a world of “us and them” created. Belonging becomes polarized, exclusive, and competition-based. The group’s focus is on barring those considered to be different, being them, in order to maximize the interests of us. Its basis is <strong>otherness</strong>, which leads to <strong>kinship</strong> as a second stage. This path causes banning, rivalry, and potentially jealousy, which all feed “hatred” in those who are excluded; it causes the path to be cold.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*V_-T42fIOAOyhwZP7TvPBQ.gif" /><figcaption>Diagram 2: Path 1, individuality to rivalry; an inequality-based path between independence and belonging</figcaption></figure><p>The second option is to base belonging on “what I can contribute to my surroundings”. This integrity- or authenticity-driven path to one’s belonging, primary looks at what people have in common (the us component in us and them); it looks for <strong>resemblance</strong> as its first stage, which leads to empathy-based <strong>affection </strong>as a second stage. Also in this case, belonging becomes polarized; belonging turns inclusive and based on empathy. This path leads to affection, fondness and “love”, openly welcoming like-minded or socially resembling people, making it a warm path.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*v3dEAUJmtJEUNE3dwB7HwA.gif" /><figcaption>Diagram 3: Path 2, authenticity to empathy; an equality-based path between independence and belonging</figcaption></figure><p>The second set of two paths has <strong>engagement</strong> as its target. It means to become a member of a wider society beyond the more “specific belonging to a social group” level. Also here there are two options; a cold and a warm one.</p><p>The first option means to base one’s engagement on “what is in it for me”. It leads to seeing the society as a transactional system where paying taxes (<strong>almsgiving</strong>) and what people get for their contribution are weighted against each other. Supporting less fortunate others is dominantly considered to be an obligation rather than that the disadvantaged are being seen as (to be supported) full members of society. In the second stage of the path, one is supposed to be a good citizen who fully assimilates and perfectly fits-in (<strong>malleability</strong>) within the common societal denominator. This type of engagement in society is based on patriotism and much less on real individual personal involvement. The path leads to inequality; disadvantaged members and culturally different outsiders are socially ignored. This causes the path to be cold.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*LDi0wWJkR2fXFrYm2dG6LA.gif" /><figcaption>Diagram 4: Path 3, individuality to patriotism; an inequality-based path between independence and engagement</figcaption></figure><p>The second option is to base one’s engagement on “what I can contribute to my surroundings”. Less fortunate or disadvantaged members of the community are taken care of by the privileged ones. Its basis is <strong>mindfulness</strong>, people are socially involved and consciously aware of each other, this awareness turns into <strong>kindness</strong> in the second stage where solidarity starts to dominate as the polarized form of engagement. Besides inclusion, the path also leads to hospitality towards outsiders; culturally different people are welcomed. This leads to the path being warm.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*aW2rEPkUvW4FGoMexBQQcA.gif" /><figcaption>Diagram 5: Path 4, authenticity to solidarity; an equality-based path between independence and engagement</figcaption></figure><p><strong>Two Control- versus Two Non-Control-based Organizational Paths</strong></p><p>Also organizationally there are in principle two positions we have to choose from: a control- versus a non-control-based one. Also here the first approach is based on assumed differences whereas the second assumes equal fundamental rights. It means to either base the societal order on “division” or on “likeness”.</p><p>On the four organizational paths from independence to <strong>governance</strong> and <strong>regard</strong> there are (like before) two stages: a first step away from independence where the individual position is still dominant, and a second step where being part of the organizational structure or ecosystem becomes more important than a person’s individual purpose.</p><p>The first set of two paths has <strong>governance</strong> as its goal. It means to organizationally structure the society and to divide the tasks necessary to rule or manage it. There are two options here; a control and a non-control-based one.</p><p>The first option means to base governance on “what is in it for me”. It means to maximize one’s personal span of control, power or status. This leads to a hierarchy of competences and a struggle for power. Justification of the hierarchy is a supposed superiority of some over others. There is a world of top-down layers created with the focus on influence over those below. Its basis is qualification or <strong>mastery</strong>, which leads to <strong>autocracy</strong> or dictatorship as a second stage. Governance becomes polarized and based on the concept of superiority in this case. Since the hierarchy is involuntary imposed on people, enforcement is mostly needed to remain in control of the mechanism. The path leads to division and fundamental inequality between people.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*g00J8V5sqluPISlMEVW2jw.gif" /><figcaption>Diagram 6: Path 5, individuality to superiority; an inequality-based path between independence and governance</figcaption></figure><p>The second option is to base governance on “what I can contribute to my surroundings”. This integrity- or authenticity-driven path to bottom-up governance primary looks at qualities of people, it looks for <strong>virtuousness</strong> as its first stage, which leads to wisdom or <strong>clear-sightedness</strong>-driven governance as a second stage. This governance or polarized leadership-type is, excellence-driven, mentoring the others. Leaders are no autocrats but chosen to represent their population. The structure is based on entrustment and likeness or fundamental equality between people. Individuals are mentored to maximally contribute to their society structure by optimizing the use of the qualities they possess within an organizational context.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*mtuPByuMvZRPtvFj-Ku3iA.gif" /><figcaption>Diagram 7: Path 6, authenticity to excellence; an equality-based path between independence and governance</figcaption></figure><p>The second set of two paths has <strong>regard</strong> as its target. It means that resources are considered limited and compromises must be made on how to share or divide them. The result is limitation, which needs to be complied to. Also here there are two options; a control- and a non-control-based one.</p><p>The first option means to base the expected regard on “what is in it for me”. It leads to seeing oneself as entitled to resources whereas others are not. As an outcome, subservience or discipline is expected from the deprived individuals. In the second stage of the path, the disentitlement goes a step further and becomes absolute; totally disqualifying people from accessing the resources by declaring them to be non-human. This process leads to genocide. The related society type is one of Nazism; its foundation is <strong>disentitlement</strong>, which turns into <strong>dehumanization</strong> as a second stage. This, outward-oriented, polarized, and forced regard-founded path, fundamentally presumes inequality.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ZdSxRuSjOnv4NJ_UeZmGJg.gif" /><figcaption>Diagram 8: Path 7, individuality to discipline; an inequality-based path between independence and regard</figcaption></figure><p>The second option is to base one’s regard on “what I can contribute to my surroundings”. On this path, people are aware of the overarching omnipresent forces beyond their control and realize that these surpass their human influence or capacity. Its foundation is inward-oriented spiritual humbleness or <strong>meekness</strong>. Mankind realizes that we are no more than an integral part of nature or the ecosystem where we belong to, and that the system does not discriminate between individuals. This awareness of synthesis turns into spiritual-compassion-based <strong>tenderness</strong> or oneness in the second stage of the path, where spiritual unity dominates. Regard becomes polarized into voluntary respect here. This, inward looking, acceptance of our human limitations is based on presumed fundamental human equality in relation to the universe; none of us has achieved to escape death and to live forever yet.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*vspr5GIbZYmGC_dnxPVENQ.gif" /><figcaption>Diagram 9: Path 8, authenticity to respect; an equality-based path between independence and regard</figcaption></figure><p><strong>The Foundation for Change</strong></p><p>As we can see from the above explanation, change starts with the rebalancing of our concept of personal identity between “what is in it for me” versus “what I can contribute to my surroundings”. Taking less and giving more is most likely the only self-imposed path to bring people closer together. Doing so, its consequence is to try to rebalance cold versus warm, and control versus non-control. Only that way, we can address the encountered challenges when our initiated “progress” surpasses our capabilities to sustainably manage it. The next question is how to fill this in as an individual.</p><p><strong>-1- Otherness versus Resemblance</strong></p><p>Otherness is easy to assume, one does not even have to be in touch with the other, and outwardly one can often see it from far. This is where for many people the challenge starts to adjust their balance. Due to social media use, we more and more live in our safe social bubbles and avoid any contact with strangers. Without meeting them, there is no way to discover and reflect on the resemblance between people and to grow together. Resemblance is often hidden behind a veil of differences and needs introspection on what really matters. This is the topic <a href="http://www.dialog.builders/">www.dialog.builders</a> addresses. It proposes to rebalance screen-time, face-time and reflection, and to cross the bridges with the unknown in order to discover resemblance and as a next step reinforce empathy.</p><p><strong>-2- Kinship versus Affection</strong></p><p>After replacing otherness by resemblance, the following effort is to rebalance one’s attitude towards group membership. In order to grow together one needs to reduce one’s fear or defense against the outside world and to discover or replace it by trust. When non-violent interaction with strangers is created, automatically, mutual empathy will grow; meaning that it will become lighter to build group cohesion based on understanding and open affection instead of to isolate oneself in a fortress of fear- driven kinship and rivalry. However, the rising use of AI may frustrate the required trust-building process (also see: <a href="http://www.thefutureoftrust.org)./">www.thefutureoftrust.org).</a></p><p><strong>-3- Almsgiving versus Mindfulness</strong></p><p>In order to grow together, participation in society should not be exclusively based on abstract and cold financial (almsgiving type of) contribution. To socially engage means to be aware of the needs of the others one shares the collective space with. It results in mindfulness and warmth, bridges gaps and fills in needs, bringing people closer to each other.</p><p><strong>-4- Malleability versus Kindness</strong></p><p>Being aware or mindful, the next question is what to expect from society. Is it a structure asking for compliance, malleability and assimilation to the common denominator based social norms in order to be able to be proud on its created social identity? or is it a security- or solidarity-based system grounded in the kindness of its participants? The first approach excludes those who will or cannot assimilate to the applied set of limited and strict norms, whereas the second path is hospitable and warm to all sharing the same living space, bringing everyone together and culturally integrating them this way. This second approach can also be used for the reinclusion of forcibly displaced people, a group which worldwide meanwhile surpasses 100 million people (also see: <a href="http://www.reinclusion.org)./">www.reinclusion.org).</a></p><p><strong>-5- Mastery versus Virtuousness</strong></p><p>Currently, many people are educated to fulfill or master a position in an interrelated network of tasks or jobs representing the organizational structure of a society. This reward focused and inequality-based approach leads often to being under- or overqualified to perform the role one possesses or obtains. A related aspect is that, this way, Artificial Intelligence can easily take over many of the well specified job descriptions or tasks. At the other side of the spectrum one can find an alternative approach to maximize people’s potential contribution to a society’s “governance” by fully exploiting their qualities, potential or virtuousness. In this case, people are not qualifying for well-paid positions but are equally using their potential or authentic qualities to optimally contribute to the society’s structure. In order to move the balance between the two, one could for example introduce <a href="http://www.universalbasicemployment.org/">Universal Basic Employment</a> (UBE) and alternative education structures which enable more freedom for self-realization and let people grow together this way (also see: <a href="http://www.iknal.org)./">www.iknal.org).</a></p><p><strong>-6- Autocracy versus Clear-sightedness</strong></p><p>Autocratic leadership, as a position, is an outcome of the previously discussed power-, status- and reward-founded organizational system based on mastery. It leads to a top of a pyramid shaped structure which handles mostly fully autonomous without any longer being accountable to the bottom and is thus clearly inequality-based. The equality-based counterpart is a “first among equals”-like type of leader who is one and equal with all participants of a society. Wisdom, leadership qualities, and clear-sightedness rule here and lead to guiding or mentoring all others towards an optimal (managerial or organizational) structure and its related output of accomplishing progress towards the common societal goals. The balance between the two is determined by the degree of real democratic representation and the ability to select wise instead of primarily powerful leadership candidates. The approach can also be used for conflict resolution or peace-building between culturally incompatible parties (also see: <a href="http://www.canaan.community)./">www.canaan.community).</a> Unfortunately, most current politicians primarily posses the self-centered target of staying in power and to divide and rule instead of to focus on a population’s common interest of growing together.</p><p><strong>-7- Disentitlement versus Meekness</strong></p><p>In times of shortage or imagined lack of space, there are two paths to share the resulting limitations or suffering. The first path is one of inequality; it selects segments of the population in order to disentitle them from accessing the scarce resources, it means that the limitations become unequally divided. The second, equality-based, path is based on acceptance of the fact that mankind is not in control of the situation. The scarcity and its resulting suffering are equally borne by all, and there is humbleness or meekness towards one’s environment developed. Mankind is in this concept ruled by or subordinated to omnipresent forces which are beyond its capabilities to understand. The first (human) approach divides the society in those who will survive or thrive and those who will suffer, whereas the second leaves this decision to God. The latter lets people grow together and unite.</p><p><strong>-8- Dehumanization versus Tenderness</strong></p><p>In a continuation of the previous balance, addressing shortage or imagined lack of space can surpass the level of disentitlement or expropriation. At this stage, and in a situation of inequality, people will start to dehumanize others in order to “morally” defend killing them like vermin or pests. At this level, genocide is executed by those declaring themselves to be superior. The ideology of doing so is Nazism. On a different level, in respect to nature in general, a comparable process declares humans to be an entitled dominant species and exploit other species. The alternative, equality-based, approach of continuation of meekness is to bring all people together via uniting them with the omnipresent force ruling over them, and as a result to show spiritual compassion or spiritual tenderness towards each other and our ecosystem as a sign of the ultimate oneness with God (also see: <a href="http://www.samadeus.org)./">www.samadeus.org).</a> In order for humanity to grow together we will need less dehumanization and more religious consciousness and respect for nature to address the above situation.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*3NG78psX6IV9QbI-za2ogA.gif" /><figcaption>Diagram 10: four inequality-based paths between independence (individuality) and the society</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*JKLI39VBPF_PrtlHrZprNA.gif" /><figcaption>Diagram 11: four equality-based paths between independence (authenticity) and the society</figcaption></figure><p><strong>Implementing the Eight Personal Balance Shifts</strong></p><p>The above eight balances show a guide to shift one’s attitudes and rebalance humanity. If people need to grow together in order to be able to more collectively manage mankind’s progress by self-regulation, they will have to become warmer, less controlled and more focused on equality. Every individual can translate the required shift from “what is in it for me” to “what I can contribute to my surroundings” into forms of personal action. Indirectly, this will also lead to more appreciation for the society structure and the ecosystem one is an integral part of.</p><p>The steps to be taken to realize a particular contribution strongly depend on an individual’s cultural context. One of the eight balances will turn out to be the central or <a href="http://www.convergence.builders/">dominant</a> one in any specific culture. However, which one will differ between societies. Still, all other forces will also be present to a lesser extent, and can be addressed.</p><p><strong>Collective Effects</strong></p><p>All forces in a society are interrelated. Shifting the individual balances does not only have personal effects, it indirectly changes the society’s dynamics and also influences the “collective” forces a society possesses. Besides of the eight direct relationships between individual independence and the outside world, there are four more indirect “collective” relationships that will shift or be influenced as a result of a change of personal attitudes.</p><p>From the five basic (non-polarized) concepts being independence, belonging, engagement, governance and regard, only two (belonging and engagement) are truly collective in nature because of their dependence on joint interaction. Belonging and engagement are an indirect mutuality-based attitude or behavioral outcome which cannot be directly influenced externally; both empathy and solidarity cannot be enforced. Governance and regard are different in this respect. They also cause collective results but through individual action, the collective outcome here is the sum of all individual changes and not of mutuality. This means that simultaneously addressing all individuals in relation to governance and regard results in collective change. The implication is that in a relationship between the latter concepts (governance and regard), these organizational approaches will dominate the two mutuality-based ones. In this essay’s context it means that the balancing forces where mutuality would influence the outcome are omitted. It is important to realize this approach when one looks at the dynamics of the indirect “collective” relationships below.</p><p><em>The Relationship between Governance and Belonging</em></p><p>The combination between governance and belonging shows two polarities. On one side, when superiority and rivalry come together, authority-based leadership of a clan or inner circle will be established, the result is <strong>patriarchy</strong>. The stronger or more dominant the superiority component is in this balance, the more patriarchic a society will become. The second, opposite, process is when excellence and empathy meet. In this case the result will be <strong>communion</strong>:<strong> </strong>people unite under the influence of a conflict-dissolving and tension-avoiding clear-sighted leader. The level of communion will vary in accordance with the experienced level of excellence-based governance.</p><p><em>The Relationship between Governance and Engagement</em></p><p>The intersection between governance and engagement is very important in most societies. When the negative polarities (superiority and patriotism) meet, the result will be supposed <strong>supremacy</strong> of one society model over another (for example with colonialism as a result). The supremacy level depends hereby on the level of the superiority component in the balance between the two. However, when the positive polarities (excellence and solidarity) encounter each other, the derived result will be <strong>harmony</strong>. When solidarity becomes stimulated by a clear-sighted leader who wants to reduce tension in society, unity will increase. The realized outcome level of achieved harmony will vary, mostly depending on the impact level of leadership excellence in the balance.</p><p><em>The Relationship between Regard and Belonging</em></p><p>When belonging and regard meet each other there are two possible outcomes. The first one being <strong>subjugation</strong> as a result of the two negatives rivalry and discipline. One group of people becomes (involuntary) fully docile to the will of another one. The more disciplined people are in this balance, the stronger their subjugation is. The second, positive, result is natural <strong>blending</strong> of people’s spheres as a result of a combining empathy with respect. People become intertwined because of their respectful interaction which stimulates the development of empathy. The outcome level is determined by the respect level for each other; the latter determines the level of openness for blending.</p><p><em>The Relationship between Regard and Engagement</em></p><p>Last but not least, when regard and engagement meet, this has a direct effect on people’s fragmentation. If the relationship is forced (discipline meets patriotism), the outcome will be coerced, discipline-driven, <strong>deference</strong>. However, if the relationship is voluntary (respect meets solidarity), the outcome will be a <strong>pacification </strong>tendency, resolving all tensions and conflicts between society models and their participants. The level of respect for each other determines the strength of the pacification outcome here.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*pz4A4_Mb7ZhKKbeWLwxFFg.gif" /><figcaption>Diagram 12: collective relations between belonging, engagement, governance and regard</figcaption></figure><p><strong>Conclusion</strong></p><p>“Make — Earth — Great — Again” is a call for people to rebalance their path towards the future — not only technologically and economically, but primarily socially and spiritually.</p><p>The world’s current polarization, inequality, forced migration, and environmental destruction all stem from the same structural disparity between humanity <em>drifting apart</em> (the collective result of our expanding individual footprints) and <em>growing together </em>(requiring the shrinking of the sum of our individual footprints)<em>.</em></p><p>Technological progress as such is not enough to address this imbalance. Only the human management of the advancement can create the required sustainability. Without awareness and oversight, change can easily turn itself against us or ruin us. This is why we very frequently will need to evaluate and pause or halt the systemic, evolution-related, expansion of our footprint.</p><p>People will (in the current out-of-balance stage) have to start prioritizing reconnecting with each other and with the ecosystems that sustain our life over maximizing their personal space. This requires a re-shift from a “what is in it for me” attitude towards a more honest authenticity-based attitude of “what I can contribute to my surroundings”.</p><p>It means a required direct personal change of one’s focus from:</p><p>-Otherness towards -Resemblance</p><p>-Kinship towards -Affection</p><p>-Almsgiving towards -Mindfulness</p><p>-Malleability towards -Kindness</p><p>-Mastery towards -Virtuousness</p><p>-Autocracy towards -Clear-sightedness</p><p>-Disentitlement towards -Meekness</p><p>-Dehumanization towards -Tenderness</p><p>The individual steps to be taken will strongly depend on one’s personal cultural context. Out of the eight balances, a single one will turn out to be the central or <a href="http://www.convergence.builders/">dominant</a> shift required in any specific culture. Still, all other forces will also be present to a lesser extent, and can be addressed.</p><p>Doing so, will (on top) indirectly cause amplifying collective-growing-together effects, namely from:</p><p>-Patriarchy towards -Communion</p><p>-Supremacy towards -Harmony</p><p>-Subjugation towards -Blending</p><p>-Deference towards -Pacification</p><p>The above twelve outcomes will bring people closer to each other and improve their mutuality levels. This will open the opportunity to establish the required awareness of our human limits and self-control. Following the above steps, the medicines we develop may turn out to be able to cure our current and future diseases.</p><p>(The complete interactive “Information philosophy” cultural communication model, on which this article is based, and a short introduction to it can be found <a href="https://refival.medium.com/the-interactive-information-philosophy-model-0a16064a2a94">here</a>)</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*_5rmaqYScFX2teB3u-qawA.gif" /><figcaption>Diagram 13: total map of inequality-based cultural processes</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*--s2lts00y81bGsOibJl1w.gif" /><figcaption>Diagram 14: total map of equality-based cultural processes</figcaption></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=37f18c72bcb2" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Interactive “Information Philosophy” Model]]></title>
            <link>https://refival.medium.com/the-interactive-information-philosophy-model-0a16064a2a94?source=rss-f51763a22342------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/0a16064a2a94</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[cultural-communication]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[culture]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[interfaith]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[model]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Johannes C. van Nieuwkerk]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 07 Dec 2025 08:31:35 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-08-18T05:30:11.092Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/900/1*KW2VUZE7Gavj7cc3rncAxA.jpeg" /></figure><p>The development of the “Information Philosophy” cultural communication model started back in 1990 after a two-year world trip by car and has been continued ever since for more than 35 years. The current model possesses a -draft- status and is meant for personal use only, it can contain errors, please report these when you find them at <a href="/service/mailto:jcn@crp.foundation">jcn@crp.foundation</a>, this is very much appreciated!</p><p>The assumption behind the model is that humans have three tools to communicate namely -1- rational argumentation, -2- emotional storytelling and -3- spiritual contemplation/meditation/prayer and that the difference in use/balance between these three dimensions largely explains the cultural differences between people around the world.</p><p>By now, the model is fully interactive and can be navigated by clicking the buttons. Due to technical limitations it is in some cases necessary to switch between two different parts of the model (Pe and Po toggle switch).</p><p>In principle is the model self-explanatory. But in order to have a better understanding, it is advisable or necessary to read three articles about it:</p><p>-1- A general introduction: <a href="https://refival.medium.com/global-cultural-adaptation-convergence-versus-divergence-a3780482cbcc">www.convergence.builders</a></p><p>-2- A more detailed explanation of the Spiritual component: <a href="https://refival.medium.com/the-parable-of-religious-convergence-7a7bcfa8b1c0">www.samadeus.org</a></p><p>-3- A more detailed explanation of the bottom-up Individual component: <a href="https://refival.medium.com/dialog-builders-manifesto-a0f9aede3eb6">www.dialog.builders</a></p><p>A book about the model is work in progress, but unfortunately still a few years away…..</p><p>The actual model is available for personal use only in two formats, as an interactive <a href="https://refival.wordpress.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/12/personal-use-only-draft-worldmap-interactive-010925.pdf">PDF</a> or as a <a href="https://refival.wordpress.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/12/personal-use-only-draft-worldmap-interactive-010925.ppsx">PowerPoint</a> ppsx file. In case you want to compare cultural maps, please just open the files twice. (See P.S. at the bottom).</p><p>Finally, a brief description of the buttons used in the model:</p><p>Direction = Switch between towards and away from a dimension</p><p>Dominance = Switch between the dominance between two dimensions</p><p>Rotation = Navigation aid for quick navigation between dimensions</p><p>Polarity = Switch between Convergent, Divergent, and Non-Polarized map polarity perspectives</p><p>Perspective = Switch between the available detailed perspectives: Personal, Institutional, Stereotype</p><p>C = (Spiritual complement, under development)</p><p>B = Switch to Bottom-up Personal Perspective (All Other Perspectives are assumed Top-Down)</p><p>T = Switch to Top-Down Personal Perspective (Only the Individual components change!)</p><p>Pe = Access to three perspectives, Personal, Institutional and Stereotype (Top-Down)</p><p>Po = Switch to Personal perspective only, access to Top-down and Bottom-up personal perspectives</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*4kFyNDvLLbaD2Mt8QfV7rQ.gif" /><figcaption>Diagram 1: Total World map of non-polarized forces (Institutional View)</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*qIjsCloQ22ab3sd16GxERQ.gif" /><figcaption>Diagram 2: Total World map of divergent forces (Institutional View)</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*4y65KzzjRQ1A5z9QyPILxQ.gif" /><figcaption>Diagram 3: Total World map of convergent forces (Institutional View)</figcaption></figure><p>(Press enter or click on the images to view the images in full size)</p><p>(P.S. At the beginning of 2026 the term Integrity has been replaced by the more precise term Authenticity. In older materials (including the interactive model files) this change is not reflected yet and Integrity is still listed/used as the term for +II)</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=0a16064a2a94" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Dialog.Builders Manifesto (Version 14/07/25)]]></title>
            <link>https://refival.medium.com/dialog-builders-manifesto-a0f9aede3eb6?source=rss-f51763a22342------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a0f9aede3eb6</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[peace]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[dialogue]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[social-media]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[convergence]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[dialogbuilders]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Johannes C. van Nieuwkerk]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 14 Jul 2025 07:09:11 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-01-18T10:11:44.759Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/900/1*TXUDXAz-dOQGZeTZ9Ewm7Q.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>(An updated 18/01/26 version can be found </strong><a href="https://refival.medium.com/dialog-builders-manifesto-version-18-01-26-c7b94937e922"><strong>here</strong></a><strong>)</strong></p><p><strong>Manifesto</strong></p><p>Humanity is in an existential crisis; people are growing apart and are becoming more and more polarized or “divergent” as I name it. Whereas mankind meanwhile possesses all tools and technologies needed to realize a dignified life for all human beings, we instead increasingly face conflict, inequality, forced migration and (mankind induced) climate change. This indicates that we, as humanity, are failing and are using our capabilities wrongly.</p><p>Some of us are maximizing their individual growth and footprint at the cost of others, often without realizing it. They do this instead of respecting personal boundaries and achieving sustainable growth for all of us. How to change the above behavior is the topic of this manifesto and its background. People will need to grow more together if we want to succeed in addressing the problems that impact all of us.</p><p>My counter movement proposition is quite straightforward; we need to enter into dialog with strangers and learn to encounter the unknown more often in order to get closer to each other. This can, as such, be relatively easily stimulated by wearing a Dialog.Builders symbol/button/badge, which invites strangers to address someone wherever he or she encounters a participant. However, the target is not to just establish a non-committing, small-talk type of conversation, but to contribute to convergence.</p><p>(The artwork required to locally produce/order the Dialog.Builders button can be found <a href="https://refival.wordpress.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/07/dialog_builders_jelveny_.pdf">here</a> (commercial exploitation of the logo is not allowed). Please contact us at <a href="/service/mailto:jcn@dialog.builders">jcn@dialog.builders</a> in case you need any assistance. To “join” the informal Dialog.Builders community, see: <a href="https://community.dialog.builders/">https://community.dialog.builders</a>)</p><p>Wearing the initiative’s button represents an open invitation to others to establish contact and to start talking to the person showing the Dialog.Builders button; establishing a “listening to each other” focused dialog. The approach is fully concentrated on learning from and about the other, clearly not on teaching one’s points of view or telling people to be right or wrong. The objective is to reflect on the faced and absorbed unknown. Its ultimate purpose is to internalize the encounter and make it one’s own by processing it. Nevertheless, normally, reciprocity will also be the result of a conversation and people will thus, additionally, automatically learn from and about each other’s views.</p><p>At first, the above idea seems pretty simple. However, listening to the unknown is actually very difficult and has to be learned. Further, what to learn strongly depends on one’s cultural context. There are fortunately many listening and reflection techniques available that can be learned. Which ones to select is beyond the scope of this manifesto. However, there is some guidance in the goals of the initiative being to meet the other with eight convergent attitudes: resemblance, affection, mindfulness, kindness, virtuousness, clear-sightedness, meekness and tenderness.</p><p>The above manifesto itself is short. However, the theoretical background of these processes and of the initiative is more extensive and will now be elaborated upon into more detail.</p><p><strong>Background: how did we stop listening to each other and ourselves?</strong> <strong>Root causes: media use</strong></p><p>Whereas radio and television were, in the beginning, a catalyst for starting a conversation between people — everyone listening to or watching the same channel, absorbing the same content, broadcast media actually became the start for more individualization or belonging to smaller, more specialized, groups of interest. With more choice, less people watched or listened to the same program and people started to become more selective, this automatically affected their human discussions which also became narrower and more selective.</p><p>From a, meanwhile mostly commercial, broadcaster’s point of view, the question became how to profit-wise optimize their audience. Two aspects are important here. First, broadcasters tried to find a common denominator, meaning that the popularity of the program became key. However, it also meant that large audience content became shallower. Second, because of the rise of zapping behavior, broadcasters needed to optimize the direct impact of their content, making it overall faster and more pronounced in order to attract immediate attention at any point in time to be selected between the many alternatives. As an overall effect, the continuous, optimized, call for attention has led to a general increase of media based screen time versus face time.</p><p>The next step beyond radio and TV is social media. Zapping has meanwhile been replaced by swiping. Posts must now attract our immediate attention to be liked and shared, and are thus optimized to strongly distract us from our daily routine (they become our daily routine) and to keep us busy.</p><p>Furthermore, friends force us via social pressure to participate and share our lives, often resulting in showing the outside world an avatar of ourselves, someone we would maybe like to be, but who we in reality are not. Notwithstanding, this effectively increases our screen time at the cost of face time even further.</p><p>Due to the uninterrupted stream of messages we now receive, our attention span is also becoming shorter, meaning that messages must be very brief and striking to be read and that more complex or longer messages are skipped or ignored. The end-result of these developments is that people started to live in a private bubble; a virtual life which is continuously requiring their attention, without much time left to physically <a href="https://www.derekthompson.org/p/the-death-of-partying-in-the-usaand">socialize</a> or reflect.</p><p>The next, AI assisted, step seems to go even further. AI starts to prevent material it considers non-relevant from reaching us. If one now searches with Google or opens a PDF, AI offers a summary to the user. For many people, this summary likely will be enough in the dense and overloaded information world we are meanwhile living in, and will read no further. What we tend to forget is that it are often the more random, less directly related, less precise, search results, which bring us our creative ideas and solutions because they stimulate us to think out of the box.</p><p>Following the filtering of information, limiting our view, AI powered LLMs like ChatGPT are <a href="https://refival.medium.com/cultural-divergence-as-a-result-of-using-artificial-intelligence-a-human-convergence-defff3600e83">mimicking human communication</a> in order to personally assist us. This indirectly reduces the need to seek true human dialog and <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GfeQXYFMuz0">reinforces the “acceptability”</a> of one’s growing actual personal isolation.</p><p>For now, the main problem caused by the above trends is that adopting this new virtual lifestyle leads to a strong reduction of real world human exposure outside of one’s core social bubble. We less and less meet and communicate with strangers coincidentally. Nevertheless, randomly encountering people in daily life remains the main contact with the unknown and an essential source of food for thought. Without such exposure there is less empathy and understanding developed; there is less convergence built. Encountering strangers is not about having the same opinion or agreeing or disagreeing with them; it is all about listening to and understanding the other’s, often different, views and to reflect on them. Such reflection does not require agreement.</p><p><strong>Background: how to counter divergence?</strong></p><p>Dialog.Builders’ goal is to increase the convergence between people. This means primarily to open up to listening. Of course this will also lead to talking and reciprocal dialog but Dialog.Builders’ mission is not to convince others, there are no rights or wrongs, there is no authority; there are only different opinions.</p><p>Wearing the initiative’s symbol/button/badge represents an open invitation to others to establish contact and to start talking in order to establish the above type of a listening-focused dialog. Although mostly very different in its purpose, there are similarities with the logic of confessing to a priest, one can out oneself here. The initiative’s approach is fully concentrated on learning from and about the other, clearly not on teaching one’s points of view. Nevertheless, normally, reciprocity will be the end result, and people will also learn from each other’s opinions.</p><p>There is always a relationship between talking and listening. However, teaching very often increases the distance between people because some participants will possess more knowledge than others about a subject. This is something that can easily create a position of authority and make people feel superior, creating divergence. But, as such, knowledge inequality does not have to cause such an issue as long as there is fundamental equality instead of dominance between people. For Dialog.Builders, every human being is considered different but equally valuable. Unfortunately, this is far from obvious in today’s reality.</p><p>On the other, listening, side, learning from/about the other brings people closer and leads mostly to convergence. The main purpose of the Dialog.Builders initiative is not to try to reach agreement or consensus with each other but to improve one’s understanding of a possibly different point of view, increasing tolerance; this will ultimately create more unity.</p><p>There is a fine balance between talking and listening, between teaching and learning. The first two of the pairs are needed as the stimulus or impulse for human growth, development and expansion, whereas the second pair is also there to realize or discover one’s boundaries and to prevent people from crossing the line: “learning” to respect others and nature/our environment over or in relation to a limitless desire for human growth and human control.</p><p>The problem is that currently there is a structural divergent unbalance found and that humanity (growing towards its death) urgently needs to undo this and rebalance itself by creating an increase in convergence. This is needed in order to address the issues we commonly or collectively face as humanity, such as conflict, climate change, inequality and forced migration. In our current largely individualistic world, there are, as we will see, five elements to address. For most people it will mean to focus less on their virtual avatar and be more authentic, but there are four more attitudes which determine our relationship with others and with the outside world. Dialog.Builders wants to promote the use of this convergent side of humanity more.</p><p>Which attitude is most relevant, depends actually on the cultural context one lives in. Explaining one’s cultural positioning is beyond the scope of this article. However, a detailed description of all detailed processes can be found in two previous publications: “<a href="https://refival.medium.com/the-parable-of-religious-convergence-3-the-path-of-non-violent-resistance-e2037892d6e2">The Parable of Religious Convergence, The Path of Non-Violent Resistance</a>” and “<a href="https://refival.medium.com/end-of-year-reflection-about-dialog-a0f2a7b8543f">About Dialog</a>”.</p><p>As said before, the initiative’s goal is to create a movement that stimulates people to establish communication with others on the basis of convergent principles; adjusting the globally divergent, currently unbalanced and dominant, elements with their convergent counterparts this way. Over the years I intensively observed people “culturally communicating” with each other, and developed a personal theory about the <a href="https://refival.medium.com/end-of-year-reflection-about-dialog-a0f2a7b8543f">ways</a> they use to do so. The corresponding cultural elements of my communication theory and their connections or attitudes will therefore be discussed into more detail now.</p><p><strong>Background: ten cultural elements; sixteen relationships between them</strong></p><p>Regardless of whether a cultural element in itself is individual or collective in nature, there are always two perspectives to be found. One perspective looks at the relational aspects from the “collective environment” point of view downwards, and represents the society’s dynamics towards its participants (top-down). The other perspective looks from the individual towards their surroundings and represents the upward individual-driven input or attitude to such a society’s framework (bottom-up). To analyze dialog, the second perspective is more useful, it directly shows how an individual can communicatively contribute to a society. This means that, other than in most of my previous publications, this bottom-up view from the individual upward towards their surroundings is used here.</p><p>In total there are ten cultural elements and sixteen relationships found between them, half of these are divergent and will mostly be used as a comparison or contrast to understand the other — convergent — half better. The outcome is that only the following five — bottom-up — cultural elements are the most relevant to detail, being the ones considered contributing to convergence according to my models: Authenticity, Adhesion, Hospitality, Entrustment and Compassion. These five elements and the eight relationships between them (four rational, two emotional and two spiritual), or to say it differently, their connecting convergent attitudes, will be elaborated on.</p><p><strong>-1- Rational dominance: Authenticity</strong></p><p>In the context of relating from Individual Identity (II) to others in the Emotional or Spiritual domain, there are four rational balances between divergence [d] and convergence [c] found, being: -a- Otherness [d] versus Resemblance [c], -b- Almsgiving [d] versus Mindfulness [c], -c- Mastery [d] versus Virtuousness [c] and -d- Disentitlement [d] versus Meekness [c].</p><p>Looking at the four above rational processes, which all point away from individual identity towards emotional or spiritual cultural elements, we can observe that the ones which have conditions imposed on or attached to participants and differentiate between people on the basis of such criteria are the divergent ones. Related to becoming involved, one has to show candidacy to become part. There is an argument ongoing about who can participate and who cannot. People with an outward looking attitude are thus forced to show their eligibility by presenting themselves, talking, rationally expressing themselves to be in favor of the demands. Often “candidates” will have to adapt to fulfill the external criteria, losing their authenticity. This process leads to artificiality, separation and a growing apart, as I name it divergence.</p><p>At the other, inward oriented side, this is not the case; people are primarily listening and asking themselves what or how they can take part in or contribute to the society, exploring their authenticity. In principle, everyone capable can unconditionally participate in this case; this brings people closer to each other and makes them thus convergent. Each of the four processes will be described now.</p><p><em>-a- Otherness [d] versus Resemblance [c]</em></p><p>The first process links the individual with a small core group of others (Emotional Identity, EI), a group which gives a feeling of belonging to its members; there is a world of insiders and one of outsiders created. It frequently means to develop criteria for who can join and become a member; people who do not match these criteria or in a different way “express/show” otherness from the group are excluded, which is divergent. One often must adjust to the group identity and share a collective group conviction in order to join, trading one’s authenticity. The convergent alternative is to, in principle, allow everyone who identifies with the group to become its member and base the group on resemblance. This means to let people indiscriminately participate and let them explore their level of true commonality instead of primarily focusing on the differences between them.</p><p><em>-b- Almsgiving [d] versus Mindfulness [c]</em></p><p>The second process links the individual with the society as an overarching emotional entity (Emotional Unity, EU). Also, here two types of engagement can be found. One can see one’s engagement as an “obligation” and fulfill one’s duties or imposed expectations on the basis of who one considers oneself to be (expression). In practice, this means paying an obligatory contribution like taxes or an almsgiving type of donation to support the poor or deprived. However, this does not imply any deeper involvement beyond. Exclusivity is preserved, and the outward looking almsgiving approach mostly remains divergent by effectively separating the benefactor from the beneficiaries. The alternative, inward looking, approach is to listen and observe others and to ask oneself what one can contribute to the society as a whole. This mindfulness approach is convergent and brings people more intensively together.</p><p><em>-c- Mastery [d] versus Virtuousness [c]</em></p><p>The third process links the individual with governance (Spiritual Identity, SI). Entitlement to govern can be based on two principles in this case. The first one is formal education or other qualifications, in which people have to show their knowledge or potential influence in order to express their suitability to be in power. This mastery approach generates a classification and is thus divergent. The alternative, second, approach is based on people’s personal qualities or virtuousness; the most suitable people will govern, not based on individual power but on their capacity to listen to what is needed and prioritize the measures required. This is the convergent way.</p><p><em>-d- Disentitlement [d] versus Meekness [c]</em></p><p>The last, fourth individual process links the individual with regard for others or the universe (Spiritual Unity, SU). In this situation, there is an argument about the entitlement to participate, which can easily lead to dispossession of rights or property by those expressing to be entitled to more at the cost of those proclaimed to take no part in the system. This outward looking “apartheid” approach is separating people into entitled and disentitled and is thus divergent. The convergent alternative is to observe or listen to, for example nature and to develop meekness toward forces beyond human control and to submit oneself to acceptance of the unknown instead of trying to control it, this is a first stage of <a href="http://www.samadeus.org/">what religion is about</a>.</p><p>All four previously described personal balances are the start of a relationship between the individual and the outside world. These processes are dominantly rational. However, if one continues on the four (eight) paths opening up, one enters into the dominantly emotional or dominantly spiritual domain. It means that there are four (balanced) complements found, which are not rationally dominant but, which dominantly represent emotionality or spirituality. Their following order of use in practice depends on the culture one lives in. These, four, non-rational, cultural processes will be described now.</p><p><strong>-2- Emotional dominance: Adhesion &amp; Hospitality</strong></p><p><em>-a- Kinship [d] versus Affection [c]</em></p><p>Collectively, the members of a limited group (EI) have two choices: they can focus on “us” or they can focus on “them”. A focus on “them” leads to enforcement of strict kinship rules or to an expectation of strong loyalty to the group. This way the group’s identity is protected (conditional approach). This often causes tension between those members closely following the core conviction of the group and those who are more loosely attached or further away in their identification and are thus at risk to be expelled and become outsiders. Since there mostly is animosity between insiders and outsiders of the group, the approach is divergent. The convergent alternative is to focus on “us” and to make the group adhesive, welcoming everyone who feels at home in the group and let them explore their level of affection or commonality in following the group’s collective ideals (unconditional approach).</p><p><em>-b- Malleability [d] versus Kindness [c]</em></p><p>The second example of a relationship between rationality and emotionality is based on the treatment of strangers or outliers in a collective society (EU). Peoples’ behavior is based on their participation or engagement rather than on individual independence. The polarization is found in whether the society is principally warm or cold towards outsiders.</p><p>From a personal communication perspective, there is either hospitality or exclusivity/reservedness encountered. The “exclusive” nationalistic outward looking polarity leads to an expectation of compliance or malleability of the other to the group’s principles (assimilation). This is a continuation of the almsgiving approach which does not require real or close emotional involvement. Although people are more collectively involved at this stage, it is on the basis of a commonly or nationalistically sharing norms for being “proud of the society they are part of” and not on any sympathy for each other. This is mostly also expressed in their treatment of strangers as being unwelcome intruders instead of being welcome guests. Outliers are fenced-off from a patriotic environment. This is divergent behavior.</p><p>The alternative convergent polarity is to be hospitable and to treat strangers with kindness. Such society is open for change and absorption; it is based on what people have to collectively offer to others. There is convergent, solidarity-based behavior, to be found.</p><p><strong>-3- Spiritual dominance: Entrustment &amp; Compassion</strong></p><p><em>-a- Dictatorship [d] versus Clear-Sightedness [c]</em></p><p>The first spiritual balance is about governance or having control over all people in the entire ecosystem (SI). It is the leadership that rules over the spiritual domain here. Such a spiritual arrangement can be based on Entrustment, where everyone is positioned by voluntarily optimizing their fitting or matching capabilities to the entirety or, alternatively, it can be founded on a hierarchy, enforcing people how and where to fit in.</p><p>Enforcement means human control and to create a hierarchy of giving and taking autocratic orders in order to manage the entirety. Such a hierarchy is divergent in its character because it ranks people on the basis of formal appearances rather than their capabilities. At its top-end one finds an autocratic dictator ruling over all.</p><p>At the other side of the spectrum one finds Entrustment: here people contribute to the entirety on the basis of their capabilities and are empowered to do so by the leadership. This type of leadership is based on clear-sightedness, wisdom and mentorship. The “<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Primus_inter_pares">primus inter pares</a>” type leader does in this case not control people but instead stimulates or enables them to maximally contribute to the ecosystem; people are looking inward and behave convergently.</p><p><em>-b- Dehumanization [d] versus Tenderness [c]</em></p><p>The second and last spiritual balance is about the footprint of people as part of the entire ecosystem or universe (SU). It is about controlling the human impact and to address the eventual disharmony of negatively being out of balance by reducing this human footprint. The first, convergent, way is to look inward and to, through the development of (spiritual) compassion with all others, learning to realize that death is inevitable if it comes, and to learn to accept this. The second way is an outward looking divergent one, it enforces full subservience to the system and makes people silent from reacting at (human) measures or on (human) events which kill “other” people and actually could kill them in the end as well.</p><p>The above is not about the leadership guiding this process here (like in the first spiritual balance), but about the way mankind as a collective of individuals does not oppose it. This, subservience-based, process leads to human controlled spirituality, where humans decide (or allow their leaders to decide) how to reduce the human footprint by defining who gets the space and thus by destroying or killing all others who are no longer considered to be human, but vermin to be killed.</p><p>People dehumanize part of the population as being disentitled to occupy space and live in that space. The process starts with dispossession and ends with genocide and is clearly divergent. After Nazism, with its “<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Untermensch">Untermensch</a>” classification, it is what is currently happening in Gaza. The treatment of the Palestinians in Gaza is a clear example of this process. All Gazans are considered to be the vermin of Hamas, including babies, and can be killed without giving it any second thought.</p><p>The alternative to reduce the footprint is to look inward and to, out of compassion, share the surplus one may have with all others in order to reduce the total space mankind occupies and thus to maximize the space for the entire population. This spiritual tenderness approach is clearly convergent.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*hJw1pnwHyxTwsyjkyL-roQ.gif" /><figcaption>Diagram 1: Bottom-up World Map of Personal Cultural Involvement</figcaption></figure><p><strong>To do: start wearing the Dialog.Builders symbol and behave more convergently!</strong></p><p>Dialog.Builders is about escaping one’s virtual bubble with its related screen time, and to generate more face-time plus time for, inward looking, reflection. Starting point is to put one’s mobile phone away whilst travelling or when one is in other public spaces with people around. This allows strangers (or even friends or acquaintances these days) to initiate a face-to-face conversation by reaching out to the ones wearing a Dialog.Builders button. Wearing the badge symbolizes openness to get into dialog. (Also at home dialog is important but this subject is beyond the scope here). If no-one is around or no-one seeks connection, one should start reflecting rather than becoming hooked to the distraction of portable media again. In my opinion, people should clearly start to organize their balance between screen-time, face-time, and reflection.</p><p>The first step is to connect; the badge or button possibly being a catalyst. The next step is how to channel one’s thoughts and let them become proper input of the inwardly directed reflection processes in order to learn about the other, the unknown and about oneself. The target is not to immediately answer the questions or to react to the feelings one may have or that may be raised. The focus is primarily on listening and showing understanding, much less on someone’s own existing position. The goal is to absorb the raised questions, feelings and “awareness of existence” and process them until, for example via contemplation, an attitude out of one’s authenticity appears. At that moment, a person gains clarity about where they stand and becomes generally able to respond more meaningfully. Their perspective now arises from a place of inner coherence and authenticity. The result of contemplating is not any concrete answer, but dissolving the question itself.</p><p>There are five reflection processes to be found here; associated with the five elements. Related to authenticity there is contemplation or realization, related to adhesion there is “emphatization”, related to hospitality there is “sympathization”, related to entrustment there is “empowerization”, and finally related to compassion there is invocation, prayer or meditation. To discuss them in detail is unfortunately beyond the limits of this article. However, the eight convergent attitudes are the outcome of these five reflection techniques.</p><p>The manifesto tries to generate a basic framework to process the encountered “food for reflection”. It tries to stimulate some attitudes whereas it tries to diminish others. However, every individual will have to independently explore what he or she relates to.</p><p>If humanity wants to grow together, it means to start avoiding the eight divergent attitudes and to stimulate using their complementing opposite convergent counterparts instead.</p><p><strong>Conclusion</strong></p><p>The world is rapidly falling apart. Institutions like the UN and its related international courts have the world’s mandate to prevent this. Unfortunately, this structure is currently failing on humanity because its members are becoming increasingly polarized and structurally disagree on the necessary measures to be taken. The UN therefore needs urgent <a href="http://www.unv2.org/">modernization</a> to fulfill our mandate again to safeguard peace and to contribute to issues like reducing forced migration, climate change and inequality, which impact all of us.</p><p>Besides this top-down approach, there is another vision, one of a bottom-up contribution of all individuals towards a better understanding of each other. Sadly, the opposite personal development is going on. Individuals are getting more and more isolated by the virtual media bubble they create and live in. There is less and less communication or contact with the unknown outside of their bubble.</p><p>This manifesto proposes a solution here. It targets to create a dialog between strangers and their related unknown by creating an opportunity to connect. Practically, it is simple — if those willing to allow connection start wearing a visible Dialog.Builders symbol/badge/button they cast an open invitation to talk to them. The goal is to improve the understanding of each other and to become more tolerant for differences by exchanging experiences.</p><p>However, such a result is not automatically achieved and needs guidance. First, the focus of the initiated dialog must be on listening to and learning from each other, rather than on talking or teaching the other one’s “right” opinion. Second, the impulses received as food for thought from the outside world, must be processed properly and internalized. The targeted result must not be a change of opinion about the single individual one has met, but a change in attitude. This is done by reflection on experiences by realization, “empathization”, “symphatization”, “empowerization” or invocation.</p><p>Finally, Dialog.Builders offers a theoretical model framework to achieve these convergent results above. It proposes to replace divergent by convergent attitudes:</p><p>-otherness by resemblance</p><p>-kinship by affection</p><p>-almsgiving by mindfulness</p><p>-malleability by kindness</p><p>-mastery by virtuousness</p><p>-dictatorship by clear-sightedness</p><p>-disentitlement by meekness</p><p>-dehumanization by tenderness</p><p>Internalizing these eight target processes will lead to a bottom-up growing together, correcting the current dominantly divergent tendency and form a counter movement. Hopefully, it will make the world a better place to live for all of us.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a0f9aede3eb6" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[United Nations V2.0]]></title>
            <link>https://refival.medium.com/united-nations-v2-0-8b24fe095d54?source=rss-f51763a22342------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8b24fe095d54</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[united-nations]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[peacebuilding]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[consensus]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[peace]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[convergence]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Johannes C. van Nieuwkerk]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 11 Mar 2025 08:59:07 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-03-11T08:59:07.220Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/900/1*ovqj1itVzKl3h_5izaQl4g.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>Intro</strong></p><p>This brief essay is about a view on the future of the world order; a vision on the mission of the United Nations (UN), which was and should be there to maintain peace for, and <a href="http://www.pax.ngo/">convergence</a> within mankind. Looking at the currently raging wars, the UN is clearly failing in its responsibility, whereas a <a href="https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2024/12/12/un-demands-permanent-ceasefire-in-gaza-how-did-your-country-vote">vast majority</a> of its members still support its mission.</p><p>Disclaimer: I am no expert on this matter, just a very worried citizen who wonders what can be done to cause a renewal or regeneration of the, obviously, currently no longer functional international structures and to prevent them from effectively becoming fully obsolete.</p><p><strong>Rusty</strong></p><p>Although still possessing very useful elements in diplomatic exchange, the current UN structures strongly reflect the power dynamics of 80 years ago at the end of WWII. In practice, the United Nations General Assembly (UNGA) fundamentally hands over to or lets pre-filter almost all of its decisions by the United Nations Security Council (UNSC), of which the five permanent members, by voting negatively on substantive matters, each possess an individual “veto” to block any decision.</p><p>As such is this veto mechanism only to be used as a last resort if no unanimity in the UNSC can be reached; the P5 members of the UNSC should thus <a href="https://docs.un.org/en/A/RES/377%20(V)">exercise restraint</a> in the use of their veto power. Unfortunately, self-control has been lacking and the P5 powers have controlled or dominated the world’s geopolitics since 1945 partially by “misusing” their UNSC veto power. Unwilling to change their behavior, they currently block any UN self-renewal and modernization.</p><p>The use of a veto power mechanism is in principle a very useful instrument. It prevents that temporary political (majority) coalitions can take over the governance of the world and permanently establish their structural dominance over a minority point of view. Being able to block this is essential for a democracy and stimulates to use unanimity or consensus as the primary “controlling or governing mechanism” instead of dominance. Therefore, all substantial representations of humanity (for example, geographical/cultural/religious blocks or zones) should possess a “veto” option and not only the five permanent members of the UNSC.</p><p>However, there are limits. If parties start using vetoes to protect their national geopolitical stakes or for unjustified or unbalanced interests of their close allies, this easily results in the mechanism becoming politically dysfunctional from a diplomatic perspective. As a result, it hinders or destroys the originally intended peace-building mission and leads to a stalemate, preventing people from getting any nearer to each other.</p><p>If there are no rules and/or mechanisms to overrule the UNSC’s non-UN-mission-statement-aligned vetoes, the stimulus to use unanimity as the primary mechanism is also minimized. This process is unfortunately ongoing and turns the UN, its bodies and courts into much less effective instruments than humanity currently requires.</p><p>Lacking an effective and respected international channel of <a href="http://www.convergence.ngo/">convergence</a> increases tension between member countries and strongly distracts from the urgent collective issues mankind faces, such as climate-change, inequality and forced migration. We are often externally forced to cooperate. If we want to protect ourselves or achieve any positive change and get closer to each other, none of us can do this alone.</p><p><strong>The Willing versus the Unwilling</strong></p><p>The UN charter is meanwhile 80 years old and, in that period, there have been strong shifts in geographic and/or economic development. There are by now many new or rising important global players. However, the UN has evolved much less and the five main UNSC powers are still mostly dominating the organization. Unfortunately, a voluntary reduction of this dominance, which would be the appropriate solution in order to adapt to new realities, seems to be very far away. In an increasingly polarizing multi-polar world, the opposite is actually happening; mankind is rapidly drifting apart. From this starting point, there are two possible outcomes.</p><p>The first one is one of a status-quo of a dysfunctional UN or, to say it differently, a “continuation of the dominance of the unwillingness to adapt to change”. This drifting apart will most likely, over time, slowly lead to WWIII. Then, in its aftermath, and if mankind does not become extinct, a new peace charter can be developed, like this has occurred before, after each previous WW.</p><p>The second scenario is one of immediate change where such a new charter is developed right now and where those open or willing to grow together start acting as one coalition in order to prevent WWIII by <a href="http://www.dialog.builders/">dialog</a> and mutual understanding, thus focusing on what people have in common instead on of what makes us different from each other.</p><p>The question is how to facilitate such self-renewal mechanism and its regeneration outcome, how to motivate the few unwilling “status-quo” parties — who no longer reflect today’s world but the past — to voluntarily give up their dominance.</p><p><strong>Abolishing UN V1.0</strong></p><p>A serious obstacle is that the UN neither possesses procedures for withdrawal of member states nor for any process of regeneration, dissolution or disbandment. This means that it will be extremely hard to get the topic of modernization and adaptation to the current world situation on the agenda of the <a href="https://www.securitycouncilreport.org/atf/cf/%7B65BFCF9B-6D27-4E9C-8CD3-CF6E4FF96FF9%7D/the-un-security-council-handbook-by-scr-1.pdf">UNSC</a>. The five permanent members can easily control this by vetoing it. However, it is nevertheless not fully impossible to invoke such a dialogue. Since dissolution has a substantial <a href="https://www.securitycouncilreport.org/un-security-council-working-methods/procedural-vote.php">procedural</a> component, an UNGA majority can, in principle, initiate a discussion on this topic. This requires an UNGA two-thirds majority, followed by a 9 out of the 15 UNSC votes to put the topic on the UNSC agenda, whereas the five permanent members’ possible negative votes in this case would not have any veto power status.</p><p>Once on the UNSC agenda and with the permanent five having veto power over the <a href="https://main.un.org/securitycouncil/en/content/repertoire/provisional-rules-procedure#:~:text=In%20particular%2C%20according%20to%20Articles,of%20permanent%20members%E2%80%9D%20provided%20that%2C">substantive</a> elements of change, there is another option to stimulate those unwilling to adapt. There is precedence to be found in the past use of the “<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_Nations_General_Assembly_Resolution_377_(V)">Uniting for Peace</a>” resolution (<a href="https://docs.un.org/en/A/RES/377%20(V)">UNGA Res. 377A(V)</a>)<strong> </strong>which was originally designed to allow<strong> </strong>the<strong> </strong>General Assembly to act when the UNSC is blocked by a veto<strong> </strong>on urgent matters of<strong> </strong>international peace and security<strong>. </strong>Theoretically, this resolution could be applied if the UNSC turns out not to be open for the necessary voluntary change. The current UN dysfunction is clearly a matter which very urgently needs to be addressed from an international peace and security perspective.</p><p>The result of the above process can either be positive change, or a falling apart of the UN V1.0 as we know it today.</p><p><strong>Creating UN V2.0</strong></p><p>In case insufficient regenerative force is encountered, the UN in its current form will either dissolve or become irrelevant over time; the question is: What is next?</p><p>To, as mankind, address topics like conflict, climate change, inequality and forced migration collectively, we need international cooperation and coordination. The current UN charter is a good basis for this, but it should be formally broadened beyond peace and international cooperation as its primary scope.</p><p>A further main change which is required is to develop self-renewal or automatic regeneration mechanisms in order to keep the relevance of the UN as a stable factor on the international stage and to automatically adapt to a changing environment.</p><p>In such surroundings there is still space for using a veto mechanism to protect minority interests, but not for any misuse. A major change should thus be to define strict rules for the use of one’s veto in line with the UN charter’s mission statement.</p><p>The above can lead to disputes and therefore a court must be able to overrule possible misaligned vetoes and have the final judgment. Within the current setup this could probably be a new task for the ICJ. Still, the real challenge is to encourage positive unanimity-based decisions, instead of negative veto-based protective ones.</p><p><strong>Membership and Subscription to a UN Charter V2.0</strong></p><p>Still founded on principal equality and equal human rights, a new UN charter should be developed on the basis of consensus between an as large as possible majority of the current UN member states. Nevertheless, it will most likely imply that some of the current members will drop out.</p><p>Of course, one wants to maximize member country participation in the UN, but not at any price. If the result is stagnation, like right now, it is most probably a better approach to accept some countries’ refusal to join a UN V2.0.</p><p>Notwithstanding, it must remain attractive to be a member of the world community and to participate in optimizing global prosperity and convergence.</p><p><strong>Consequences of Non-Membership</strong></p><p>If a vast majority of countries joins UN V2.0, it would mean that the non-members isolate themselves from what “the world” wants. In the current globalized world this would likely have a strong negative effect on the non-participating minority.</p><p>In case a non-member’s behavior reaches the level of defined crimes against humanity, there are ample existing sanction mechanisms available which would discipline such party. As a last resort, collective military action could even be taken, although almost always more peaceful diplomatic alternatives are to be preferred.</p><p><strong>Looking forward</strong></p><p>Time is running out fast for the UN in its current form. The UNGA and UNSC must therefore act now. They have the world’s mandate to do so and to use all the instruments they possess to stop the current wars.</p><p>There is no single excuse left for any permanent UNSC member to use a “joker escape veto out of individual geopolitical interest”. Sanctions are urgently needed to secure peace.</p><p>Without doing so, the risk is very substantial that the UN becomes superfluous, and that the world is left without any structure to address common problems.</p><p>However, it is not primarily the UN’s fault that nothing happens, pointing at the UN as an organization is like shooting the messenger.</p><p>Mankind meanwhile created a world that is growing/falling apart, in which the UN just reflects our divergence and has become dysfunctional because of a lack of universal support. People will have to learn to focus on what they have in common instead of the differences between them to change this. To support this, we need a renewed UN as well.</p><p>If the current P5 members of the UNSC do not voluntarily abolish their dominance via a procedural UNSC discussion, a more convergent UN V2.0 must be created. If the above UNSC discussion fails, a second step is to use the precedent of the “<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_Nations_General_Assembly_Resolution_377_(V)">Uniting for Peace</a>” resolution by the UNGA to take over from the UNSC and to dissolve UN 1.0.</p><p>From here we can make a new start with charter UN V2.0 and to try to consensually unite as many as possible current UN member states in a broader and more modern organization. The other side of this coin is that some countries will not join the new 2.0 organization. Still, this is to be preferred over the current stagnation and dysfunction of the UN.</p><p>Humanity has to urgently grow together as equals in order to address the problems all of us face, such as conflict, climate change, inequality and forced migration; ”Collectively in Solidarity”.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8b24fe095d54" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[About Dialog]]></title>
            <link>https://refival.medium.com/end-of-year-reflection-about-dialog-a0f2a7b8543f?source=rss-f51763a22342------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a0f2a7b8543f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[convergence]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[divergence]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[peace]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[dialog]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[war]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Johannes C. van Nieuwkerk]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 30 Dec 2024 12:29:38 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-01-18T10:20:26.573Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/900/1*pWTi9elLmgf7-V-LAixYPg.jpeg" /></figure><p>(The term authenticity has been replaced by genuineness in later articles)</p><p><strong>Introduction</strong></p><p>The world order is rapidly collapsing and the global instruments (UN) we possess are clearly failing on humanity. Although vetoes can be extremely useful to protect the interests of minorities, they are currently continuously misused by the UN Security Council members to achieve their own geopolitical goals in order to stay in power. This behavior is reflecting the past power dynamics of the outcome of a second world war. But, looking at global economical changes, it is by now excluding many important new voices and lacking any future; this is destabilizing the entire world. Furthermore, with the ICJ and ICC court’s judgments meanwhile being widely disrespected, there are voices rising to dismantle the only global legal system mankind possesses, adding further fuel to the disruption.</p><p>The above situation is as such not unusual, there is an ongoing transition and there are global shifts. If one lifts one billion people out of extreme poverty, like it happened over the last four <a href="https://www.worldbank.org/en/news/opinion/2023/10/17/ending-poverty-is-our-first-global-goal-and-we-are-off-track">decades</a>, they will require a larger footprint than before. This causes friction and a demand for global repositioning. To settle this tension, it principally requires a giving up of some dominance by the old and a proper representation of the new forces. There are two ways to achieve this, a violent one through wars and a non-violent one through improved dialog and cooperation. Since the violent path seems to lead us to world war III and, as currently being clearly illustrated in Gaza with new AI supported weapons very capable of universally destroying everything, the question becomes how to realize the non-violent alternative. This is what this article is about or what it wants to contribute to.</p><p>The essay is based on self-developed cultural communication models. The result is six different balances between growing apart or divergence and growing together or convergence (also see <a href="http://www.convergence.ngo/">www.convergence.ngo</a>). Furthermore, as will be explained later, every culture uses only two out of the six balances as their main cultural communication components. The assumption is thus that cultures differ and that their individual potential contribution to a cooperative world varies. The underlying mechanisms will be elaborated further in this article.</p><p><strong>Three Main Cultural Dimensions, Split into Six Elements, Polarization</strong></p><p>Extensive travelling and working internationally have led to the observation and insight that (cultural) communication consists of three main factors: rational, emotional and spiritual communication. These three main cultural components, horizons or dimensions represent arranging the relationship with oneself (= rational), with everyone one knows or (who) is part of one’s known world (= emotional) and finally with the unknown or Omni-present (= spiritual). The corresponding communication mechanisms are argumentation (rational), association (emotional) and reflection/contemplation (spiritual).</p><p>However, there is a split of these three dimensions into six cultural elements found, depending on the level of identity a person or group acquires. There are two poles for the three cultural dimensions here, one where the collectivity stands central and one where the more personal or limited group identity is the core.</p><p>The above leads to a split of rationality into rational<strong><em> interdependence</em></strong> (model of the poor, Individual Unity (<strong>IU</strong>)) or rational <strong><em>independenc</em></strong><em>e</em> (model of the rich, Individual Identity (<strong>II</strong>)). It leads to a split of emotionality into emotional <strong><em>engagement</em></strong> (wider community, Emotional Unity (<strong>EU</strong>)) or emotional <strong><em>belonging</em></strong> (close relationship group, Emotional Identity (<strong>EI</strong>)). Finally it leads to a split into spiritual “<strong><em>regard</em></strong> for” (submission to, Spiritual Unity (<strong>SU</strong>)) or <strong><em>governance</em></strong> (leadership, Spiritual Identity (<strong>SI</strong>)).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*59X_kerU4wvKEkii_aGPWA.gif" /><figcaption>Diagram 1: Base cultural communication view</figcaption></figure><p><strong>Six Types of Fear, Six Types of Trust, an Outward versus an Inward Orientation, Balances</strong></p><p>Yet, the above six cultural elements are in practice further polarized and can either be fear- or trust-driven. Fear causes an outward orientation in order to protect one’s position; leading to divergence. Trust results in an inward orientation; leading to convergence. My experience is that divergent practices become a source of conflict, whereas the convergent ones do not. Dialog, convergence and trust are intertwined here. If people create a convergent attitude/goal, they will, as soon as they encounter reciprocity, enter into dialog with others and realize actual convergence, increasing their trust levels this way. Establishing a convergent attitude is thus the precondition for any dialog and will therefore be taken as the basis for this essay.</p><p>The outward and inward directed forces do not come alone but in pairs: they balance each other. This means that both forces are present at the same time. Cultural positioning is the result of these balances and immediate cultural change is the accumulated result of them varying over time. This, shorter-term, perceived equilibrium is actually a result of friction, only in “paradise/heaven” everything would be perfectly smooth and there would be the perfect trust needed to dissolve the balances and to become fully one or united. A good way to symbolize our human daily life situation is that mankind tries to expand its footprint until natural or other (human created, like wars) boundaries are encountered. Such limits force people to reflect whether the path they are on is the right one. Longer-term, there is another, different, mechanism for cultural change to be found, namely that of a change of the weighing of the three cultural dimensions themselves. However, this longer-term type of change mechanism of culture is beyond the scope of this article.</p><p>Regardless of whether a cultural element in itself is individual or collective in nature, there are finally always two perspectives to be found. One perspective looks at the relational aspects from the “collective environment” point of view downwards, and represents the society’s dynamics towards its participants (top-down). The other perspective looks from the individual towards their surroundings and represents the upward individual-driven input to such a society’s framework (bottom-up). To analyze dialog, the second perspective is more useful, it directly shows how an individual can communicatively contribute to a society. This means that, other than in most of my previous publications, this bottom-up view from the individual upward towards their surroundings is used here.</p><p>As can be seen in the final diagram below, the end result of a further fear/trust polarization is the determination of twelve polarized cultural elements, which come in six balances. The aim of this article is to determine the potential practical balance shifts between these elements that would contribute to convergence. These twelve cultural elements and their six balances will therefore be elaborated now. Some further explanations can also be found in my <a href="https://medium.com/@refival/global-cultural-adaptation-convergence-versus-divergence-a3780482cbcc">other</a> <a href="http://www.samadeus.org/">publications</a>.</p><p><strong><em>-1- More Equity, Less Liberation</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>Interdependence</em></strong> (IU) becomes split in<strong> Equity</strong> (inward orientation = convergent = +IU) and <strong>Liberation</strong> (outward orientation = divergence = -IU).</p><p>This balance takes place in an environment of (extreme) poverty where people are fully dependent on each other. People use a trial and error model similar to that of ants in order to survive. The convergent side of the balance is based on correcting/controlling the error (focusing on one’s boundaries) and has as its outcome to share any surplus, individuals may have, with others in order to maximize the efficient use of the community’s limited resources and to reduce “waste” by distributing those resources to where they are most needed. This way, the <strong>equity</strong> of the weaker participants is increased and their chances of survival optimized.</p><p>Sharing one’s surplus (rational, it is a mutual safety net approach) leads to a “live and let live” growing together and interdependence becomes convergent. The other, divergent (-), side of the balance is based on struggle and follows the rule of the jungle where only the “fittest will survive”. An example of this side is the violent gangs in ghettos. It means that some try to aggregate a disproportionate share of the limited resources and try to <strong>liberate</strong> themselves from poverty this way. People take their chance (the focus is on the trial aspect of trial and error) to escape misery. However, as we talk about a closed eco-system from a resource perspective here, this type of escape is realized at the cost of the poorer or weaker, who will receive even less. Liberation of some will mostly threaten the existence of others.</p><p>To conclude: people can, in an interdependence context, individually contribute to convergence by sharing the surplus they may have, and to transfer it to those who are most in need. They thus increase equity and optimize the survival of all, instead of to divergently aggregate (unneeded for their own survival) resources in the hands of a fittest few.</p><p>(Remark: the lifting out of poverty we have experienced due to globalization is an incomparable process and is not related to the above type of liberation. There is a win situation in this case, where, other than in the above situation, an absolute increase of resources for mankind is achieved. This leads to a revolution from a general interdependence to a general independence for many people.)</p><p><strong><em>-2- More Authenticity, Less Expression</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>Independence</em></strong> (II) becomes split in<strong> Authenticity</strong> (inward orientation = convergent = +II) and <strong>Expression</strong> (outward orientation = divergence = -II).</p><p>This balance takes place in an environment of independence of individuals. People possess sufficient resources to independently “materialistically” survive alone. The result is that communication with others becomes more or less voluntary; one can very often choose or decide with whom to interact.</p><p>The rational polarization is found in whether one focuses on listening to the other and as a result on learning to distinguish between what is real or important for oneself as part of a person’s <strong>authenticity</strong> and what is <strong>fake or a distraction</strong>. This also relates to listening to the interests of others (convergent) versus a focus on talking and on building an image or persona towards others by <strong>expressing</strong> one’s arguments or opinion (divergent).</p><p>Using an expression-based outward orientation, mostly means to consider everything as an (to be protected/defended) exclusive private possession and to base one’s individuality or personality on a comparison with the outside world. In our current “virtual social media world” this has led to the creation of individual avatars, which very often largely express what we would like to be, instead of who we are.</p><p>Where in the past there was a clear balance between physically talking and listening, this is meanwhile in today’s social media environment much less the case. Whereas radio and television in the beginning were a catalyst for conversation and discussion (because everyone watched or listened to the same program) this has, due to the increase of the number of available media channels to watch and select from, meanwhile fundamentally changed. Currently, each individual watches a more or less personalized social media stream. Since these streams are commercially optimized to maximize their achieved screen time with their customers/users, they try to keep people busy with steady (mostly shallow and brief) impulses. The effect is that most people have replaced face time by screen time.</p><p>The resulting shallowness has several aspects; it starts with reducing the required attention span by enabling to zap channels or swipe messages. This reduction also rewards shortening or compressing messages to their core content, mostly reducing them to moments instead of stories. A further point is that other simultaneous non-verbal expressions like body language and intonation etc., are missing, which is one of the causes for the information exchange to become superficial.</p><p>Participation in this “virtual” communication system generally means to continuously share each other’s life events. However, this sharing must match the superficial reception process, making it predominantly based on which mark or impression of oneself one wants to leave to be optimally accepted within one’s social bubble.</p><p>An example of how our communication behavior has changed over time. When people were travelling alone by train in the past, many of them looked into the train compartments in order (besides a place to sit) to select people to have a potential chat or dialog with upon sitting down. Currently, most people try to move as far away as possible from each other, maximizing their personal space and physical distance to others in order not to be disturbed in enjoying their virtual world. This is a clear example of increased growing apart or divergence.</p><p>The overall result of this balance shift on a practical activity level is an increased focus on expression at the price of a neglect of one’s ability to distinguish and develop authenticity. If this trend continues, many people will be kept pleasantly occupied or entertained by AI in future. They will namely lose their ability to be human and to distinguish between what counts for developing one’s human authenticity and what is just keeping people busy or distracted. Another important effect of this communication shallowness is loneliness, if people are not truly embedded socially and nobody trustfully listens anymore, people will be completely lost. To only meet people talking small talk instead of truly listening isolates. AI can become a <a href="https://medium.com/@refival/cultural-divergence-as-a-result-of-using-artificial-intelligence-a-human-convergence-defff3600e83">strong enabler</a> for a loss of trust here.</p><p>To conclude: individuals can, in an independence context, contribute to convergence by investing in exploring their authenticity, which is mostly a listening process. In order to do so, people will need to free-up screen time or shallow type of expression time and replace it by more in-depth face time again, thus limiting being one’s avatar instead of a human being. This is in principle a personal decision open to anyone.</p><p><strong><em>-3- More Hospitality, Less Exclusivity</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>Engagement</em></strong> (EU) becomes split in <strong>hospitality</strong> (inward orientation = convergent = +EU) and <strong>exclusivity</strong> (outward orientation = divergent = -EU).</p><p>Other than in the first two examples, this balance takes place in a collective emotionality-based society where the role of the individual is determined by their social environment. Peoples’ behavior is based on their participation or engagement rather than on individual interdependence or independence. The polarization is found in whether one is principally warm or cold towards outsiders. From a personal communication perspective, there is either hospitality or exclusivity.</p><p>Being open or convergent in one’s engagement means to possess a welcoming attitude towards outsiders; this position is internalized and leads to <strong>hospitality</strong> in relation to strangers. The other pole is to look outwards and considers oneself to be <strong>exclusive</strong> in the engagement with the society. This leads to the treatment of others as unwelcome intruders instead of being welcome guests.</p><p>To conclude: individuals can, in a society engagement context, independently contribute to convergence by developing a hospitable attitude towards outsiders. They thus increase the closeness to others instead of fencing them off by being patriotic and to exclude outsiders from participation.</p><p><strong><em>-4- More Adhesion, Less Animosity</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>Belonging</em></strong> (EI) becomes polarized in either building an “us” type of <strong>adhesive</strong> group with others (inward orientation = convergence =+EI) or a focus-on-“them”-based <strong>animosity</strong> (outward orientation = divergence =-EI).</p><p>Like in the previous example, this balance takes place in a collective society environment. However, the society is more fragmented in smaller groups like families or clans here. Peoples’ belonging is based on their social emotional behavior in their direct surroundings rather than on their more general engagement in the collective society as a whole. Polarization is found in the treatment of perceived insiders or outsiders of the group people think to belong to. There is reciprocal adhesion between insiders and as a complement, animosity between the group’s identity and outsiders.</p><p><strong>Adhesion</strong> means to look inwards in relation to the group one belongs to, and to focus on what one has in common with the others in the group. It means embracing the other and to laugh and cry together. This commonality is the basis of the group identity and for developing closeness between its members. The other perspective is one of looking to the outer world from the perspective of protecting the group identity, here one focuses on the differences between the in- and outsiders. The latter will lead to <strong>animosity</strong> towards others. It in this context means to reject the other(s) and to keep one’s distance, for example, by bullying or ignoring them.</p><p>To conclude: individuals can, in a context of belonging, independently contribute to convergence by focusing on what one has in common with each other instead of to focus on what makes one different from the other (and as a result separates social groups). The above behavior increases adhesion between people and reduces the animosity between them.</p><p><strong><em>-5- More Compassion, Less Subservience</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>Regard</em></strong> (SU) becomes split in <strong>compassion </strong>(inward orientation = convergent = +SU) and <strong>subservience</strong> (outward orientation = divergence = -SU).</p><p>This balance is about the positioning of people as part of the entire ecosystem rather than on any rational individual or emotional social view. The entirety rules the spiritual domain; individuals are just atoms in the wholeness and thus neither individually nor socially separated. They have no other choice than to dissolve their “identity” by voluntarily showing open mutual confidence toward the entirety and to contribute to consensus this way, or to be involuntary forced to show subservience, becoming disciplined by the entirety.</p><p><strong>Compassion</strong> means to look inward and as a reaction to focus on one’s own contribution to be made towards the absolute consensus of the entirety, people become united or one this way. This approach often uses or makes use of a concept of an omnipresent higher force to voluntarily respect, which is the <a href="http://www.samadeus.org/">core</a> of most religions. The opposite polarity is that of a superior worldly leader who requires discipline from the entirety, this means being forced to live according to rules from above and to show one’s <strong>subservience</strong> in relation to the power-based worldly leadership in control.</p><p>To conclude: individuals can, in the context of regard, independently contribute to convergence by evaluating what their role can be in achieving consensus. They thus can increase their spiritual compassion levels towards others instead of to follow a discipline-based imposed subservience approach in which they subordinate themselves to the rules of an autocratic leader and become obedient.</p><p><strong><em>-6- More Empowerment, Less Enforcement</em></strong></p><p>Finally, <strong>g<em>overnance</em></strong> (SI) becomes polarized in <strong>empowerment</strong> (inward orientation = convergence = +SI) and <strong>enforcement</strong> (outward orientation = divergence = -SI).</p><p>This last balance is the complement of the previous one and about control over people as part of the entire ecosystem. The entirety rules the spiritual domain here. However, to implement such an arrangement, one often needs guidance or leadership. Such a spiritual arrangement can be based on empowerment where everyone is positioned by optimizing their fitting or matching capabilities to the entirety or, alternatively, it can be founded on a hierarchy, enforcing people to fit.</p><p><strong>Empowerment</strong> is based on optimizing the use of everyone’s capabilities as mentioned above and gives people the freedom to apply their skills in the service of the goals of the entirety. <strong>Enforcement </strong>as its complement means human control and to create a hierarchy of giving and taking orders in order to manage the entirety.</p><p>To conclude: individuals can, in a governance context, independently contribute to convergence by using empowerment as their internal model of governance and to thus avoid or reject being ruled by enforcement when and wherever possible.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*3Y08J521vHEj74sK1A5YSA.gif" /><figcaption>Diagram 2: Six individual responsibility based dialog balances</figcaption></figure><p><strong>Six Balances — the Three Dimensions in Daily Practice, Two out of Six</strong></p><p>The three dimensions are not static, their application and balance can substantially change over time. However, in order to establish an exchange between people, one of these dimensions, in any culture, at any time, is always used as a clear starting point for any communication and is therefore dominant. Each of the above three dimensions can be this first normative mechanism though, and thus become the dominant communication method in a community, resulting in cultural differences between societies worldwide.</p><p>In the event that the first chosen method of finding a common frequency is unable to realize proper information exchange, establishing communication between people is too important to just fail. Instead, there now starts a second attempt to set-up a connection. An alternative method, a secondary dimension or new perspective is chosen. It is used to substitute the old, non-functioning, first communication method, and comes in as a new optional point of view. The chosen secondary dimension thus serves as a kind of pre-agreed “emergency” attempt to connect. An approach that is quite similar to using a pre-defined fallback frequency in order to improve the safety of technical communication.</p><p>My observation is that the choice of this second dimension is, like the first one, strongly coded and rigid in a community at any point in time. This leads to the phenomenon that there is in general no room for a third communication option to be used. Simultaneously using a third dimension would mainly generate confusion or noise. It would, namely, become necessary to choose which of the two remaining dimensions (after attempting to use the dominant first one) should be activated as one’s “emergency” secondary dimension.</p><p>This aspect in turn leads to the remaining third communication dimension becoming disabled or disconnected. As a result, humans use a two-dimensional information exchange whereas we possess a three-dimensional communication potential. All people worldwide use in practice a distinctive balance between their two chosen dimensions instead of their more extensive capability. This has strong impact and makes us culturally “different” from each other. Thus, while everyone possesses a fully universal three-dimensional human communication potential, we tend to simplify this more complex reality via our two-dimensional reduction approach. (A more detailed explanation can be found <a href="https://refival.medium.com/global-cultural-adaptation-convergence-versus-divergence-a3780482cbcc">here</a>).</p><p>The above mechanism takes place at the top level of the three dimensions. However, this indirectly impacts any further polarization, a dimension which is absent will also be absent in its polarized form. The result is that only two out of the six personal balances (from different dimensions) are momentary used in a culture, one being dominant, and one activated at the moment the first one fails. This implies that there are different contributions from different cultures to be expected if one seeks for a convergent path and a non-violent cultural contribution.</p><p>(Disclaimer: analyzing a by definition common denominator — communication, my theory and models strongly stereotype people. Yet, all people differ and possess their own personal cultural identity. This implies that an individual has and uses the freedom to behave differently from a general cultural norm or expectation. But, there is a trade-off in doing so; people pay “a price” for this freedom or deviant behavior in a community, and will have to accept the noise or misunderstandings their communication behavior causes. Not respecting norms can eventually mean that they become an outcast or a member of a subculture and no longer belong to the mainstream of a society.)</p><p><strong>About Dialog; How to Contribute to a World Growing Together: Less Divergence, More Convergence</strong></p><p>When enough members of a society change their personal behavior, the society changes with them. This has for example been a <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Opposition_to_United_States_involvement_in_the_Vietnam_War">factor</a> in the ending of the Vietnam War in the 1970s. As we can see above, all individuals have two direct handles for change, being their two current cultural balances. They have a direct influence on the balance between the convergent and divergent polarities of these two elements and can thus bottom-up change their society from within. Furthermore, they also have longer-term leverage on cultural change by altering the balance between the two cultural dimensions they use and by modifying the balance with their third, disconnected, cultural dimension. However, this longer-term process topic is beyond the scope of this article.</p><p>The shorter-term key is to reduce the use of the divergent polarity and to improve or to stimulate the use of the convergent side of the two balances one possesses. Every individual can personally do this and in the end, a society is no more than the sum of its members, regardless of its current structure.</p><p>However, there are limitations. One needs a critical mass to have impact. If one would be the sole individual changing, the only effect would be that one places oneself outside of the society. In practice, this limits the speed of change because one has to establish a movement of equals to be effective. The second factor is that sometimes divergent decisions have to be reversed and that only the current power or enforcement-based leadership is able to do so. In order to end a war, one first needs to negotiate truce and only after this, a peace-building process within a population can start: replacing fear and hatred by trust and empathy. Still, public opinion is an extremely powerful force and in most situations relatively influential.</p><p><strong>Conclusion</strong></p><p>It is important to realize that, unlike what many people perceive, there is the possibility for any human being to individually contribute bottom-up to a change of society. People are not dependent on waiting for top-down changes but are actually in control and are the ones who mostly induce such changes by forming a “critical-mass bottom-up movement” within a society.</p><p>The six balances described in this article are the universal tools to be used and every individual has the potential to independently contribute to a growing together of mankind (or as I name it convergence). By emphasizing any of the convergent elements, regardless of whether one lives in a dominant or subordinated culture, people can improve their attitude towards others. This is the precondition for enabling dialog and to realize actual convergence; resulting in increased levels of trust.</p><p>In practice, there are limitations found. One namely needs a critical mass of individuals behaving in the same manner and direction in order to create the necessary movement for cultural change from within a society or between societies. As explained in the article, a further limitation is that every culture only possesses two main cultural handles to connect to in this respect.</p><p>Personal contribution to shorter-term convergence is thus, because of the required scale, mostly related to one’s existing cultural environment. The creation of a successful movement in a society is in the end predominantly determined by which two cultural handles are available. A more detailed explanation of which two handles any distinct culture exactly possesses can be found <a href="https://refival.medium.com/global-cultural-adaptation-convergence-versus-divergence-a3780482cbcc">here</a>. Notwithstanding the above, everyone can contribute in their own manner; there are no exceptions on people’s ability to do so.</p><p>The main shift is to develop more internalized (convergent) references and to depend less on being driven by outward oriented (divergent) external stimuli. In order to do so, people have to develop their personality primarily on processing one’s environment instead of being controlled by it.</p><p>The six individual convergent keys for this are: <strong>Equity, Authenticity, Hospitality, Adhesion, Compassion</strong> and <strong>Empowerment</strong>. By creating more emphasis on these six keys in daily life, there will be a shift in the balance generated with their divergent counterparts, being: <strong>Liberation, Expression, Exclusivity, Animosity, Subservience</strong> and <strong>Enforcement</strong>.</p><p>By collectively changing these balances towards convergence, mankind can start growing together again and will over time become able to address the problems which impact all of us, like conflict, climate change, inequality and forced migration together.</p><p>Although it is late and the world is already fully on fire, it is hopefully not too late to extinguish the current wars and to replace them with their convergent alternative paths of dialog and cooperation. Contributing to these paths is the responsibility of every single person, and there is no excuse for non-participation; we may all be culturally different but we share this planet as equally valuable human beings.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a0f2a7b8543f" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Union of Canaan: Two Nations, One Country]]></title>
            <link>https://refival.medium.com/the-union-of-canaan-two-nations-one-country-443e80f36037?source=rss-f51763a22342------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/443e80f36037</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[israel-palestine-conflict]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[convergence]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[peace]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[canaan]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[gaza]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Johannes C. van Nieuwkerk]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 07 Jun 2024 19:41:55 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-06-08T06:03:34.545Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/900/1*LTZoXijteHDSwOaM8yQzcw.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>Introduction</strong></p><p>I have an almost unimaginable mission, one of sustainable peace in the Middle East, a new union of nations; I call it the “Union of Canaan”. Humanity urgently has to find ways out of growing apart by conflict, instead, we need to fully focus on addressing the issues that impact us all, such as climate-change, inequality and forced migration. For this we need to grow together or establish <a href="http://www.convergence.ngo/">convergence</a> as I name it.</p><p>Since last October I have written daily about the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. Over time, my views have evolved, shaped by the situation on the ground. Initially, I hoped for de-escalation through temporary safe zones in Gaza, and dismantling Hamas’s military infrastructure. When this proved impossible, I suggested safe zones in Israel as a starting point for coexistence.</p><p>In January, I introduced the <a href="https://refival.medium.com/the-union-of-canaan-3db0df11785f">first concept</a> of the Union of Canaan, a one-state peace solution based on local democratic governance where all local cultural communities would become equal members in a confederation.</p><p>This essay, influenced by Palestine’s growing international recognition, presents an alternative “two nations, one country” approach of cooperation between two confederations of such local autonomous cultural communities. It merges elements of both two-state and one-state solutions.</p><p><strong>Disclaimer</strong></p><p>I am not a historian or political scientist. My background is concept- and strategy development for innovation in the private sector, which requires out of the box thinking and a strongly looking forward attitude. Since my experience is international, I often had to bridge cultures and developed my own cultural communication models to do so. These are the basis of suggesting potential solutions in this case.</p><p>Finally, I have no real involvement in either side; I am neither Israeli nor Palestinian, neither Jewish nor Muslim. I am just deeply touched by the inhumanities happening at both sides and therefore strongly longing for peace and harmony. My vision should not be seen as an external proposition. It is food for thought, intended for those more directly involved.</p><p><strong>Peace Building</strong></p><p>Politicians start and end wars, but ordinary civilians must build peace through non-violent interaction. Only by communicating with each other as equals, mutual understanding and reciprocal empathy develops. This empathy is the sole basis for replacing fear and hatred by trust and solidarity and for solving conflicts forever.</p><p><strong>One State or Two States?</strong></p><p>Coexistence relies on non-violent interaction, not on governance. If a two-state solution implies erecting walls between them, there is no communication possible and hatred is preserved. Although one can live in sustainable truce for a long time, there is no true peace generated and a conflict can flame-up at any time.</p><p>While my concepts may seem far-fetched with the current level of hatred seeded at both sides, every road to peace will be tough and painful. At the moment, all pacification propositions seem unrealistic. In the beginning people will indeed likely require separation, hopefully, over time, this requirement will disappear.</p><p>Regardless of the difficulties, Palestinians and Israelis must coexist as equals, both are there to stay and no one outside is waiting for a new exodus of any of the two.</p><p><strong>Two States or Nations?</strong></p><p>The concepts of a state or a country both mostly relate to the governance or administration aspect of a territory, whereas a nation primarily refers to a cultural identity. In my opinion there are, in this specific Israeli Palestinian context, two nations sharing one common territory or country.</p><p>Using this vision, one will, on one side, try to safeguard a culture (such as for example the Jewish identity/”state”) from becoming diluted as a cultural minority, whilst, on the other side, one will try to govern the country jointly (as the union of two nations).</p><p>The above also implies that each of the two nations can independently represent itself by membership of international bodies, whereas simultaneously the territory can be governed on the basis of a union.</p><p><strong>Autonomous Local Cultural Communities</strong></p><p>How does this concept work in practice? If one wants the flexibility to share and split a territory on the basis of practicalities and a future outlook, instead of on history and returning to a certain point in time, one will have to establish what I call democratic autonomous local cultural “communities”.</p><p>It means to bring most governance to the local level, so that the “community” becomes the core of democracy and as autonomous as possible. Each “community” turns into a separated canton or “mini-nation” and is responsible for its own social and economic cohesion. Of course there remain many aspects that require coordination on a higher level, which implies the need for intense cooperation in an overarching structure; a nation.</p><p>However, the “communities” themselves are independent and culturally “homogeneous” which means being Jewish, Arabic or “of mixed coexistence” as an identity. This way, peaceful cells can be created, whereas at the same time the chosen identity is protected by local autonomy, regardless of the “community’s” size and its number of inhabitants.</p><p>Of course do these communities need a certain scale or critical mass in order to realize proper governance, and the cells are thus rather meant to be “clusters of homogeneity” than small scale units and represent “peaceful territories” or cantons instead of classical villages or small city structures. However, this is something to be determined by negotiation and political positioning.</p><p><strong>Aggregation into Two Confederations and One Union</strong></p><p>Next step is that administrative aggregation of all homogeneous, culturally identical communities is used to form a nation; in this instance two (or more) nations. Each nation has its own parliament and sets its own internal rules as long as these do not conflict with those of the others. Finally, the two nations together constitute a union in order to “govern” the country as a whole on the basis of equal rights.</p><p>The result is that the communities can be spread over the entire territory or country and do not necessarily have to follow the classical division of bordered grouped partitions. Instead, the communities are in constant dialog with all their neighbors, regardless of the nation they belong to.</p><p>In this case, the approach leads to two confederations of communities, the confederation of Israel and the confederation of Palestine. These two confederations are, regardless of their population size, fully independent of each other and possess a strict Jewish or Arab cultural identity. People can coexist without threatening each other’s culture this way. On a union level, one can then use a proportionality principle in order to guarantee equality. This is the heart of what I name “the Union of Canaan”.</p><p><strong>Three Obstacles</strong></p><p>There are a number of obstacles to establish such a union. First issue is that politicians must find a way to divide the current territory. Second, the security of the communities must be warranted, which can be challenging in an environment of hatred, and when the communities are potentially located as enclaves in “hostile” areas. Third, there must be a solution found for the currently displaced people and for people that will need to move in order to establish the two nations. This, last, relocation aspect of both Jews in illegal settlements and displaced Palestinians, separates the “Union of Canaan” approach from a pure one-state solution, where people are free to settle and mix wherever they want.</p><p><strong>Why Canaan?</strong></p><p>I have opted to use the name “Union of Canaan”, since the name goes back to the earliest times and antedates both Israel and Palestine as a name for the region. Its use in this context does thus neither refer to the biblical narrative, nor to the later, more limited, area covered by <a href="https://edisciplinas.usp.br/pluginfile.php/7572850/mod_resource/content/1/Concept%20of%20Palestine%20%5BNur%20M%5D.pdf">Canaan</a>. Key is that in the <a href="https://www.worldhistory.org/canaan/">earliest times</a>, various cultures and religions peacefully seem to have coexisted in the area.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/798/1*YfbDNyJo_t6ViMPoZnjQmw.jpeg" /><figcaption>See: <a href="https://www.worldhistory.org/canaan/">https://www.worldhistory.org/canaan/</a></figcaption></figure><p><strong>Politics Blocking the Way to Peace</strong></p><p>There is no future for Israel and Palestine based on the narrative of its radicals. Anyone who wants to claim the entire territory exclusively for themselves will only find eternal war, violence and further destruction, whereas the moderates at both sides hold the key to peace by entering into non-violent interaction and dialog as equals with each other.</p><p>The problem is that currently the politics, at both sides, are dominated by radicals who seek war and that, during a stage of conflict escalation, it is impossible to reliably measure the real opinion of a population. Anyone having a deviant opinion from the main “war narrative” is considered to be a traitor. This, clearly and predictably, leads to unrealistic, high, support percentages for the war at both sides. To have a more reliable indication of radicalism, it is better to look back before October 7th in analyzing the opinions about Hamas and the radical Israeli government and its settler policies.</p><p>Further, in such an escalated radicalized environment, parties must often externally be forced to a truce, after which the situation can de-escalate and a process of reflection and introspection can take place. After such “normalization” and realizing what happened, people may find an incentive to change their opinion and, after elections, a majority of moderates may return and be reinstated as a government at both sides.</p><p>Without such a development occurring and as long as the radicals, who are insisting on claiming the total territory, are in charge, there is no chance on true peace-building whatsoever. There first must be general willingness or consensus at both sides to coexist, this in order to be able to then share or divide the territory and other resources.</p><p>Looking at Hamas, <a href="https://www.arabbarometer.org/wp-content/uploads/what-palestinians-really-think-of-hamas-2023-10-26-08-4941.pdf">its support in Gaza</a> was relatively low on October 6th and represented a clear minority. Further, in my observations, Hamas has two components, a Jihad and an Intifada one. For their terror-based religious extremist Jihad component there is just no place in the current world order; it is an <a href="https://medium.com/@rami_zahra/islamisation-of-democracy-not-democratisation-of-islam-3c0045db6e95">incompatible</a> concept unless one wants to strive to return to the Caliphate. Hamas’ Intifada, liberation, component is another story; that one also comes with terror, but after achieving its goals, Hamas could, in principle, become a normal political force in the spectrum (analogue to the IRA). In my opinion, although intertwined, the Intifada component far outweighs the Jihad one in this case. Finally, there are more political forces in Palestine along with Hamas, especially if one looks at the other Palestinian areas besides Gaza. Altogether, if the Palestinian independent state rights are internationally recognized and general elections held, the outcome would most probably generate a basis for peaceful coexistence with Israel as two separated states or two separated nations.</p><p>Looking at the Netanyahu Israeli government, one can see that it has already been <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Opinion_polling_for_the_next_Israeli_legislative_election">unpopular</a> for a long time. Its war narrative can nevertheless count on a <a href="https://theconversation.com/most-israelis-dislike-netanyahu-but-support-the-war-in-gaza-an-israeli-scholar-explains-whats-driving-public-opinion-230046">majority support</a> of the population. However, there is another issue found here; even if there is a stage of de-radicalization and a new Israeli government is elected; one important problem would likely remain unsolved. For a long time there is a relatively high level (50%) of <a href="https://www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/israeli-opinion-on-settlements-and-outposts-2009-present">support for the settlement policies</a> of the Netanyahu administration, meaning that the expansionist Israeli settlers (who claim the entire territory for themselves) possess a reasonable level of backing from the Jewish Israeli population (not from the 20% Arab part). Still, internationally, the situation is clear and none of the Israeli settlements built after 1967 in the occupied Palestinian territories are internationally recognized and they are thus considered to be illegal. This issue will need to be solved by political negotiation, international mediation, and recognition of rights. First then, when there is a solution for this issue, there can be proper territory sharing and coexistence effectuated. A big plus here is that a confederation of communities model allows a certain flexibility in the territory division, there can be enclaves created when suitable and wished for; it is thus less rigid than drawing straight lines.</p><p><strong>Securing Communities</strong></p><p>The flexibility of the spreading of culturally homogeneous communities in order to prevent cultural dilution, which most probably would lead to a loss of cultural identity over time, has it limits though. If there is sustainable peace, the flexibility would be unlimited; unfortunately, in times of hatred and erupting violence, much less so. In order to secure the communities, especially in the beginning of establishing non-violent interaction, separation will still be needed, which may require the involvement of UN-Blue-Helmets peacekeepers.</p><p>The above practically limits the fragmentation of the shared territory and will likely force parties to use the borders of 1967 as a starting point, but with the option of making exceptions. Longer term, and based on migration, new settlement or new community development may be required, which should by then be possible to handle more flexibly, border- or separation-wise.</p><p><strong>Migration and New Settlements; Return of the Previously Displaced</strong></p><p>A last obstacle is the huge number of displaced or to be displaced people in the combined territory of the two nations.</p><p>Israel has currently a <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_Israel">population</a> of 10 million inhabitants of which 7 million are Jews and 2 million are (Palestinian) Arabs. Palestine has a <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Palestinians">population</a> of 5 million inhabitants and a refugee Diaspora in Jordan, Lebanon and Syria of another 3 million people. <a href="https://www.plands.org/en/articles-speeches/speeches/2023/return-plan-2023">If everyone returns</a>, the Union of Canaan would have 18 million inhabitants, 7 million Jews and 10 million Palestinians (other cultures are not taken into account in the scope of this article, also mixed communities are omitted; these two categories can constitute a further independent confederation of communities and join the union).</p><p>From the 10 million Palestinians, 5 million are currently displaced and in need for resettlement. From the 7 million Jews, at least 10% are currently living in illegal settlements and are thus also in need of relocation.</p><p>The above implies a strong need for (re)developing new settlements both in Gaza and in the other parts of the territory, mainly in what is now called Israel because of the current disproportionate allocation of resources by the Jewish part of the population.</p><p>Although an enormous challenge, it is <a href="https://www.plands.org/en/articles-speeches/speeches/2023/return-plan-2023">not undoable</a> and the potential is in principle there. Next step is to develop the will to enter such a road to common prosperity.</p><p><strong>Conclusion</strong></p><p>Coexistence relies on non-violent interaction, not on governance. If a two-state solution implies erecting walls between them, there is no communication possible and hatred is preserved; peace-building does not take place in that case.</p><p>Both Palestinians and Israelis are there to stay and must find a solution to live together. If one wants the flexibility to share and split the territory on the basis of practicalities, one will have to establish democratic autonomous local cultural communities (rather meant to be “clusters of homogeneity” or cantons than small scale units). The aggregation of all homogeneous cultural communities is then used to form two nations; these nations together constitute a union in order to govern the country as a whole. This way there is no conflict between a minority and a majority.</p><p>If the Palestinian independent nation rights are internationally recognized and elections held, the outcome would most probably generate a basis for peaceful coexistence with Israel as two separated nations.</p><p>However, even if there is a stage of de-radicalization and a new Israeli government elected; one important Israeli problem would likely remain unsolved. For a long time there is a relatively high level (50%) of support for the settlement policies of the Israeli administration. Still, internationally, the situation is clear and none of the Israeli settlements built after 1967 in the occupied Palestinian territories are internationally recognized and they are thus considered to be illegal. This issue needs to be mediated and solved.</p><p>In order to secure the communities, especially in the beginning, separation will still be needed. This may require the involvement of UN-Blue-Helmets peacekeepers.</p><p>A last obstacle is the huge number of displaced or to be displaced people in the combined territory of the two nations. From the 10 million Palestinians, 5 million are currently displaced and in need for resettlement. From the 7 million Jews, at least 10% are currently living in illegal settlements and are thus also in need of relocation.</p><p>The above implies a strong need for new settlements both in Gaza and in the other parts of the territory. Although an enormous challenge, it is not undoable and the potential is in principle there. Next step is to develop the will to enter such a common road to prosperity as a Union of Canaan.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=443e80f36037" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>