<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Renato Henrique de Gaspi on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Renato Henrique de Gaspi on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@renatohdegaspi?source=rss-d26c0424e0f9------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Mon, 16 Nov 2026 04:51:07 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@renatohdegaspi/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Resurging social democracy, dying social democrats]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@renatohdegaspi/resurging-social-democracy-dying-social-democrats-670666de6ace?source=rss-d26c0424e0f9------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/670666de6ace</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[political-economy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[social-democracy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[european-union]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[latin-america]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Renato Henrique de Gaspi]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 15 Jun 2018 11:15:33 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-06-15T14:59:53.459Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Google is ruthless. By banging away sets of three or four words you can find almostanything you like. Want to validate your amateur medical opinion? Go on, just type something like: ‘mole back cancer’… or what is more, want to find people who think like you in your apparently cornered political opinion? Just type ‘trump why good’ and you will find plenty of people like you and motives to believe even more firmly. However, that is not always the case and, if Google is at all right, social democracy is dying all around us, the victim of its own failures and of careerist politicians that would sell their positions for a couple more votes. Well, that may be right, however, I tend to disagree.</p><p>In my last text, I advocated that we are in a crucial and wide-open moment. Some could take me for an optimist, others for a prophet of disaster, but in the end, this position is as neutral as one could be in social science (not much, that is…). What I mean is that we might be heading towards the abyss of right-wing extremism, tense borders, rampant oppositional nationalism, muffling of dissidents and so on… but we also could envision a future of less consumerism, more recognizable universal social and individual rights and so on. My thesis in this text is that social democracy, or at least a version of it, is not dying, in fact, it could be on an interesting way towards a resurgence after its obvious defeat in the 1980s and 90s (oh, Latin America and Southeast Asia, always a decade late on your trends, good thing there is the internet now and we can catch-up more quickly with what is in vogue), however, social-democrats are, in fact, dying, and not just electorally, but <em>actually</em> dying… they are old, sluggish, hard pressed to catch onto new trends.</p><p>Well, what does this mean then? This means that, perhaps, we are witnessing a revamping of social-democracy, and today I will try to talk a little bit about what this means in practical and broad terms. Anyway, let’s start from the beggining.</p><p>Social-democracy has its roots on the first and second international, two moments when Marxism was on the rise. However, these (mostly) men at the time thought that a peaceful and evolutionary transition into socialism was, in fact possible, contradicting the mainstream trend in orthodox Marxism. Well, as far as left-wing division goes, the Second International was perhaps the Pandora’s Box, giving rise to many divisions and sub-divisions later resulting in the Rose-and-Fist organization <em>Socialist International</em>, a body with 153 members ranging from the Brazilian Democratic Labour Party (PDT) to the British Labour Party and to the Venezuelan centre-right, believe it or not…</p><p>Anyway, this is a tired and old institution for, largely, tired and old parties, especially where the ones in Europe are concerned… so, why are we talking about all of this?</p><p>Well, because this is the past of social-democracy, and this was an incredibly important movement in the centre and periphery alike. In Latin America, figures like Leonel Brizola, Carlos Andres Perez and Raúl Alfonsín shaped debates in their respective countries Brazil, Venezuela and Argentina. In Europe, even more success awaited for the social-democrats, as the Labour Party of Clement Attlee and the SPD of Willy Brandt created systems of social protection in England and Germany, not to mention the cliché examples of Nordic social-democracy.</p><p>However, looking at these parties today may be a bit glum. The PDT was, for years, converted into a mere electoral ‘rent-party’ without much of an ideology until 2016, and is now poised to try and make some noise at the 2018 general elections in Brazil (with a small chance of winning the presidential election, and a slim-to-none chance of winning any majority in the chamber of deputies). Its Venezuelan and Argentinian counterparts look even more fragile and closer to disappearance. In Europe, the SPD took a beating in the last German election (with the worst party result since 1945), and, even so, is repeating once again a ‘grand coalition’ with the party with whom they should be ideological rivals, and even Nordic social-democracy is looking a bit more exclusive with the new wave of immigrants.</p><p>As you will notice, I skipped the United Kingdom… I also have not talked about the US, and I didn&#39;t even come close to the European periphery. Why is that?</p><p>Well, there is where I think Social-Democracy has been in revival, but the multifaceted character of this revamp is making it hard to trace. Plus, many of the main actors of this revival are not claiming to be social democrats, although their projects look a bit like an <em>actual </em>modernization of social democracy (unlike the one done by the so-called ‘Third Way’, which was more like neoliberalism with a human face)… let us start to look at that by the case that looks more hopeless: the USA.</p><p><em>Bernie would have won</em>. That phrase has become almost a mantra for left-wing Americans, and that should mean something. Apparently, the country that managed to go through the thirty glorious without mentioning the <em>“S” </em>word are now falling for an old man who claims to be a democratic socialist (honestly, inverting the terms does not a new ideology make). The electorate is young, the phenomenon is new, but the ideology is just plain, good old social democracy. A universal health system, offsetting of debts for the countries’ most vulnerable (and, unless you have been living in a cave you should know that recent college graduates are among this number), and universities with virtually no tuition are observable traits of countries that have a strong social democratic background. In the US, however, it took almost thirty years since the falling of the wall, and a generation laden with the worse of the US’s system (I am talking about millennials here) for people to realize that “hey, maybe state intervention is not so bad after all”. To be sure, Bernie <em>would</em> have won, and I believe he might if the Democrats stop their whining and outright sabotage of his candidacy.</p><p>In the UK, Jeremy Corbyn seems to have captured the spirit of Old Labour. New Labour was a sham… Tony Blair’s leaflet with the writing ‘social-ism’ and the fear of invoking the term was a trend of the time, but it is no less ridiculous. Basically, what the ‘Third Way’ did has run to its outermost limits. Who would have known that changing the structure of debt from governmental to familial debt could go so wrong? Well, it seems the 2008 crisis has finished with this possibility once and for all. What are we to do? Well, let’s give social democracy a go once again.</p><p>Outright, but undeclared, social democratic candidates have been gaining some success. Portugal’s ‘geringonça’ coalition managed quite the feat in recovering some of the Portuguese economy’s dynamism, and all over the globe, it seems social-democracy may make a comeback.</p><p>However, why did I say, then, in the title, that social democrats are dying. The answer is quite simple. European Social Democracy has accrued a bad rep. More and more, we will see social democratic ideals are not going to be defended by the same parties they did in the past, or by the same actors anyway. In more rigid party structures, like the UK and the US, ‘Corbyn candidates’ or ‘Bernie candidates’ will grow inside mainstream parties, but always in a strenuous battle against the old establishment… they will either change their party for good, or their party will break them and discard them on the political trash bin.</p><p>In other countries, with more possibilities for the creation of new parties, these are going to take the wheel, even if they are on the minority. Portugal has a coalition of left wing parties, ranging from the old Social Democratic and third way adherent Socialist Party (PS), but is pulled more to the left by the more identitarian Left Block and the more orthodox Marxist Communist Party. Of course this is not the whole story, many other countries are going on the opposite direction and electing officials from the other end of the spectrum.</p><p>However, what is most curious is that many of these new parties that are now labelled as radicals or revolutionary are nothing of the sort. Most of them just want to go back to the social democratic practices that marked the 20th century in the centre. Social democracy seems to be again on the rise, and, however we want to label it, is one of the possibilities for our future, it is one of the ideas in our newly-started battle.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*OsUXfL844_e_1OzDhitUlg.png" /><figcaption>A revamped social democracy? Democratic Socialism? SD21? 21st century Socialism? It doesn’t matter…</figcaption></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=670666de6ace" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A world wide-open: Polanyi and the reasons for political action]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@renatohdegaspi/a-world-wide-open-polanyi-and-the-reasons-for-political-action-76b6c549600b?source=rss-d26c0424e0f9------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/76b6c549600b</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[political-economy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[economics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[crisis]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[institutions]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Renato Henrique de Gaspi]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 23 May 2018 22:13:34 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-06-16T07:31:17.244Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>It could not be much different. My first text written at Medium had to be riddled with quotes from Polanyi, generalizations about the global political scenario and some exercises in cautious futurology. Although I try to keep these trends of mine under control throughout my academic writings, I wanted to try Medium exactly so that I don’t have to do so… or at least not all the time.</p><p>As I believe writings cannot be separated from its author’s background, and since this is my first text here, I will start by briefly introducing myself as a “erratic political economist”… I should explain:</p><p>My BA in International Relations in Brazil was quite unorthodox. Joining together all my credits I guess a more suitable title would be a BA in International Political Economy. As it turns out, the subject ended up being my actual field of study and the theme of my Master’s thesis. Two years in China gave me a privileged perspective on some of the key happenings of our day. I was far from the field of play for most of it, but the distance helped me see things from a global point of view. Instead of focusing in my own country, I could actually appreciate the fact that <em>the world</em>, and not Brazil or Latin America, was going through bad bits. From the Middle Kingdom I watched, in this order, Brexit, Dilma Rousseff’s impeachment in Brazil, the election of Donald Trump and the ultimate change in Chinese rhetoric as a response to such a period of instability characteristic of what Gramsci called the <em>interregnum: </em>a point in time where “the old is dying, but the new has not yet come”.</p><p>In due time, I will write about all of those themes and more, but today, I wanted to make some broad considerations that will set the tone to my future writings. So without further ado, I will try to show why political economist Karl Polanyi (Vienna, 1886) gives us reason to believe in political action however tired our age may be.</p><p>My first consideration is purely theoretical and it comes from Karl Polanyi’s <em>The Great Transformation </em>(from here on GT, 1944 [2001]). In his book, as pointed out more craftily by Fred Block and Margaret Somers (2014), Polanyi uses three levels of analysis to make sense of the world. These are the global level, the national level and the sphere of local societal groups (if you are in IR, you will notice a striking similarity with Wallerstein’s three levels of analysis). The great strength of Polanyi’s book resides in its capacity to use these levels almost simultaneously without collapsing one over the other in the process and its focus on the institutions that kept the system of the time in place. Here is an example of that, and pay attention, for we will come back to this later: <em>“Nineteenth-century civilization rested on four institutions. The first was the balance-of-power system (…) [t]he second was the international </em><strong><em>gold standard </em></strong><em>which symbolized a unique organization of world economy. The third was the self-regulating market which produced an unheard-of material welfare. The fourth was the liberal state (…) </em>(2001, p.3).</p><p>He was also quick to point out the primacy of the social sphere for the shaping and contesting of these institutions, also denouncing the so-called <em>economistic fallacy </em>that plagued both orthodox political economists and Marxism, and <em>highlighting the role of ideas</em> in keeping these institutions standing with some degree of legitimacy. In a way, for all Political Theory nerds out there, Polanyi was the precursor of the more modern Constructivist Institutionalism (CI), a strand in political science and political economy espoused by names like Mark Blyth and Colin Hay. In their thinking, institutions are born out of ideational paradigms and can therefore be modified by different sets of ideas over time. In Colin Hay’s words: “Institutions [are] codified systems of ideas and the practices they sustain” (Hay, 2006, p. 58).</p><p>So why is Polanyi in fashion, and why should Constructivist Institutionalism be in vogue too? First and more obviously because they are quite complementary. In one of the most influential works in CI, Mark Blyth draws on Polanyi even for his title in <em>Great Transformations: economic ideas and institutional change in the twentieth century (2002)</em>. If Polanyi is in fact making a comeback, Constructivist Institutionalism must also get some of the attention. The second and more important reason is because Polanyi’s framework and Constructivist Institutionalism is all about the role of ideas in either preventing rupture and legitimizing the status quo, or reconstructing institutions after a major change. The main feature of these approaches is their assertion that <em>nothing</em> about society is actually natural and therefore <em>all</em> can be changed. Every institution of the social order was borne out of an idea, is kept by the permanence of an idea and it is changed only when an idea constructs a new institutional paradigm.</p><p>So it seems that these theoretical frameworks are tailor-made for the current state of affairs… although we are not sure exactly as to how and what are the consequences, change is indeed happening. Be the diagnosis* the end of times, the end of capitalism or both, the fact is that uncertainty has seldom been higher in recent history, and this is showing in scholarly productions across disciplinary fields.</p><p>Faced with such loose ends, it is only human to seek for examples from history to elucidate us, to offer us some way forward, or at least some sense that what is taking place is not only our problem, that it has happened similarly somehow, somewhere.</p><p>It is not a coincidence, then, that we have been drawing examples from the world and times of Karl Polanyi. After the election of Donald Trump, comparing our decade to the 1930s has become very much the go-to headline. However tired the comparison might be, we would be foolish not to hear the echoes not of Adolf Hitler (which I think we are still far away from seeing resurrected), but perhaps of Mr. Churchill in our very own unimaginative political representatives. This is not a frontal attack on Churchill’s political prowess or capacity, or a comparison of his dignified figure to Mr. Trump, but a mere comment on his known insistence, during the interwar years, on the return to the <strong>Gold Standard </strong>(told you). In fact, John Maynard Keynes wrote a tirade against these ideas in 1925, and “The Economic Consequences of Mr. Churchill” turned out to be a quite prescient collection of articles. This insistence led to a fatal stalemate to the institutions appointed by Polanyi as the ones keeping the 1870–1914 system in place. For starters, the Gold Standard had a thoroughly deflationary bias, was quite inflexible when it came to policy making, and was thus quite harsh on the working classes in times of trade deficits. However, that same working class was no longer willing to take things lying down. A war had been fought, mostly by them, and they were not about to go back to terrible working conditions and wages that responded to the quantity of gold amassed by their homeland in the last trade cycle.</p><p>With all these differences, what is the similitude to our times? Well, as it turns out, quite a lot. Right after the 2008 crisis we engaged in a short-lived and misused Keynesianism that, according to Lord Skidelsky averted a 1930s-style collapse. What happened afterwards, however, shows that we keep on being stubborn. At this point in time, ten years after the biggest crisis of capitalism since 1929, we are hard-pressed and failing to find an alternative, and the problem, although not the same as the 1930s, bears striking similarity with it: we have a deeply entrenched economic system, with a very coherent (although slightly variable) and dominant set of ideas that guides economic decision making on the global level, influences politicians on the national level, and shapes imaginaries on the societal level, sounds familiar? Some of the same frailties that made the Gold Standard absolutely impracticable in times of crisis are now afflicting neoliberal capitalism to the point of deeply influencing our politics in much the same way as the 1930s. Attempting to resolve crises with inadequate economic ideas leads to material and social hardship, leading to a profound and worrisome discredit of politics.</p><p>Thus, there is a reason why people are tired of politics and politicking at present. For many years now (since, about, the 1980s), there has been really only one game in town (you can call it whatever you want, but I will use neoliberalism). Shades of neoliberal politics were put to the choice of electors left and right. Sure, ‘New Labour’ invested a lot more in education, for example, than their Conservative counterparts in Britain, but there was not much ‘Third Way’ politicians could offer in times such as ours. The consequence is seen across the globe as the most traditional parties and the most ‘presentable’ politicians amass, at best, mediocre results. Conciliatory politics is the first casualty in times of crisis. People, common people, are looking for solutions to their very real problems and it is high time we understand that when a human being is faced with poverty, hunger, homelessness and cultural and social disenfranchisement, no option is off the table.</p><p>We are faced with the political consequences of a very serious economic crisis, and every specialist claiming recovery will have a very hard time in selling that to an unemployed middle-aged woman with two kids. Although some data may point to some kind of recovery, the objective reality of most nations at present is one of high un or underemployment, falling wage masses and deep income concentration. Polanyi was clear, fascism was<em> “(…)made practically unavoidable by the liberals’ obstruction of any reform involving planning, regulation, or control. (GT, p. 265)”, </em>and we seem to be incurring not on the same mistakes, but on the same stubbornness in failing to reform the system that actually legated us our <em>current crisis.</em></p><p>Let me be clear, Polanyi was not exactly a revolutionary who believed that the state was a mere managerial bureaucracy to serve the interests of the bourgeoisie. Taking his advice would not mean an entire overhaul of the political system, much the opposite. Polanyi believed a world without power struggles and politics to be a stark and cruel utopia. But he trusted that the shape and function of the state was to be shaped by a constant battle of ideas. This is why he was so concerned with <em>“[t]he stubbornness with which economic liberals, for a critical decade, had, in the service of deflationary policies, supported authoritarian interventionism, merely [resulting] in a decisive weakening of the democratic forces which might otherwise have averted the fascist catastrophe (p. 242)”.</em> They shaped the action of the state in a certain fashion, and that culminated on the rise of fascism. We should understand how similar this sounds to our present reality of technocrats and enforced ‘expansionary austerity’</p><p>This text, however, is not about predicting a terrible future for mankind, or a return of the fascist threat, our objective here is much more humble. I merely am pointing out that, in essence, we have been sowing this same stubbornness and reaping governments and strong political actors that are dangerously close to an outright authoritarianism especially on those countries that were most affected by the crisis and failed to provide some kind of credible alternative. It is not a coincidence that Portugal (perhaps the only country in Europe who managed to find a way to circumvent austerity), has escaped a rise in Right-Wing Populism, but more on that in another text…</p><p>However gloomy this picture might be, this is not the end of the story. Democracy and capitalism (especially neoliberal capitalism), this strange and contentious marriage, might be on the ropes and perhaps on its last days, but that does not mean humanity is also on the brink of doom. With the risk of incurring in a placid platitude, if we can recognize that our current order is disintegrating, the future will depend on what we make of it. We, the collective of mankind, can choose to revamp democracy, take away the burden of conditioning human physical life and social existence to work, redraw our ethical boundaries and rethink the role of the state. Alternatively, we can gradually hand over the control of our societies to opportunistic politicians with easy solutions to complicated problems resulting in a future with stricter borders and soaring xenophobic nationalism. A new order will emerge, and it will have bits and pieces of our current one, but its shape and colour are yet to be defined by our political action today. To end our text in a better note than I could ever write:</p><blockquote>Uncomplaining acceptance of the reality of society gives man indomitable courage and strength to remove all removable injustices and unfreedom. As long as he is true to his task of creating more abundant freedom for all, he need not fear that either power or planning will turn against him and destroy the freedom he is building by their instrumentality (Polanyi, 1944 [2001], p. 268).</blockquote><ul><li>(I will talk about some of these diagnoses in future texts as well).</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*e8UFOBr7ZOJLUMVsyHjTaw.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*qsQ7yoXPPi9Oaj3gbX7Gsw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Image from the website from the University of Vienna: <a href="https://www.google.com/url?sa=i&amp;source=images&amp;cd=&amp;cad=rja&amp;uact=8&amp;ved=2ahUKEwiVkNeCsI3bAhVHOZAKHTbHBNwQjhx6BAgBEAM&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.wu.ac.at%2Fmlgd%2Fnews-mlgd-special-pages%2Fnews-details%2Fdetail%2Finternational-karl-polanyi-society%2F&amp;psig=AOvVaw1jLXyH67ltZBTIsUVuHf6D&amp;ust=1526667959587126">https://www.google.com/url?sa=i&amp;source=images&amp;cd=&amp;cad=rja&amp;uact=8&amp;ved=2ahUKEwiVkNeCsI3bAhVHOZAKHTbHBNwQjhx6BAgBEAM&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.wu.ac.at%2Fmlgd%2Fnews-mlgd-special-pages%2Fnews-details%2Fdetail%2Finternational-karl-polanyi-society%2F&amp;psig=AOvVaw1jLXyH67ltZBTIsUVuHf6D&amp;ust=1526667959587126</a></figcaption></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=76b6c549600b" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>