<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Rodolfo C. Rivas on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Rodolfo C. Rivas on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@rivasrod?source=rss-c519b7f88399------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Wed, 18 Nov 2026 05:01:53 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@rivasrod/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[An Ode to Zenith and El Primero: The story of El Primero, the Chronomaster Revival Shadow and a…]]></title>
            <link>https://rivasrod.medium.com/an-ode-to-zenith-and-el-primero-the-story-of-el-primero-the-chronomaster-revival-shadow-and-a-3196f36a58f0?source=rss-c519b7f88399------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/3196f36a58f0</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[watches]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[culture]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[personal-essay]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[zenith]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[switzerland]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Rodolfo C. Rivas]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 13 Nov 2026 15:45:48 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-11-13T17:45:07.356Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>An Ode to Zenith and El Primero: <em>The story of El Primero, the Chronomaster Revival Shadow and a manufacture at a crossroads</em></h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ctNQJp-lYtoJ17viQUWdaQ.png" /></figure><p>By Rodolfo C. Rivas</p><p>The first time I heard the words <em>El Primero</em>, I thought, that’s pretty cool. A Swiss watch, from an industry that can seem determined to make everything sound as Swiss as possible, called <em>El Primero</em>. In Spanish. I remember thinking that one day I need to own one.</p><p>Zenith was not alone in giving Swiss watchmaking a little Spanish flavour. Mido takes its name from <em>yo mido</em>, “I measure”, which is almost absurdly appropriate, but also strange, for a watch company. I have a soft spot for these crossings. When I wrote “<a href="https://rivasrod.medium.com/hecho-en-mexico-the-authorized-anomaly-of-the-rolex-bracelet-016e72f2b916">Hecho en México / Swiss Made</a>” about the Rolex bracelets the Fleischer family made in Mexico City, I kept seeing Switzerland and Mexico meet on the wrist. Here Switzerland makes the watch, and Spanish gives it a name. It feels meant to be to me.</p><p>Then there is Zenith itself. A zenith is the highest point a celestial body reaches in the sky, and Georges Favre-Jacot, who founded the company in Le Locle in 1865 at the age of 22, was not thinking small. He wanted to bring the trades of watchmaking together under one roof, at a time when most Jura watches were assembled from parts made by artisans working in their own homes. The company became one of the great chronometry houses of Switzerland. By its own count, it holds 2,333 chronometry prizes, more than any other watchmaker.</p><p>The name says something about how the company saw itself. Many of the traditional houses put their founders on the dial: Vacheron Constantin, Patek Philippe, Audemars Piguet, Breguet. You buy the names of the men who made the thing. Omega and Zenith went another way and took the name of a movement. Omega was first a calibre, introduced in 1894, and only later the company. Favre-Jacot unveiled his flagship calibre, Zenith, in 1898, and the company adopted the name in 1911. I find that early twentieth-century confidence charming. The movement mattered more than the man.</p><p>Then, in 1969, Zenith gave us <em>El Primero</em>. The first.</p><p>The story starts earlier. In 1962 Zenith set out to build the first automatic chronograph, and the plan was to present it in 1965, the year of the centenary. One hundred years after Favre-Jacot opened his workshop, the house would show the most advanced chronograph movement ever made.</p><p>Then the brief kept growing. Automatic was not enough. The chronograph had to be integrated into the movement, and the movement had to beat fast enough to measure tenths of a second. The centenary came and went with no finished calibre. Most companies would have shipped what they had. But not Zenith. Zenith took four more years and announced <em>El Primero</em> on 10 January 1969, with watches reaching customers later that year.</p><p>I like that Zenith let the anniversary pass. In “<a href="https://rivasrod.medium.com/an-arbitrators-improbable-journey-or-how-learned-to-embrace-the-scenic-route-and-stopped-worrying-68c8fb57b78c">The Scenic Route</a>” I wrote about careers that take the long way and arrive later than planned. I have come to believe that arriving late with the right thing beats arriving on time with the wrong one. Zenith missed its own party and made history anyway.</p><p>The result was an integrated automatic chronograph beating at 36,000 vibrations per hour, or 5 Hz, which let it time intervals to a tenth of a second. The chronograph lived inside the architecture of the movement instead of sitting on top of it as a module. Zenith made the whole thing work at a frequency that is still high by today’s standards.</p><p>Zenith was not alone in the race. The Chrono-Matic consortium of Heuer, Breitling, Hamilton-Büren and Dubois Dépraz presented its Calibre 11 on 3 March 1969, and Seiko’s 6139 reached the market in May. I spent a good part of my Monaco essay with Calibre 11, the wristwatch with the crown on the left, and I have real affection for it. Zenith announced first. The others most likely reached a wrist first. Of the three automatic chronographs of 1969, only <em>El Primero</em> is still in production with basically the same movement.</p><p>The story has been told so often that it can sound too neat, but the facts hold up. Designed in the 1960s, launched in 1969, nearly killed by quartz, brought back. Through decades of improvements, its basic architecture has stayed the same. Most old movements disappear. Something thinner, more efficient, or simply newer replaces them, and the calibre that was revolutionary in 1969 ends up as horological archaeology. <em>El Primero</em> evolved, and its modern descendants are clearly related to the original. Zenith got a lot right the first time. That is a large claim in mechanical watchmaking, where generations of engineers have spent their careers trying to improve things that were already very good.</p><p>Then came quartz, and being very good at mechanical watchmaking stopped being a business plan.</p><p>This is where my childhood in Mexico enters the story. I knew Zenith first as the name on televisions and radios, an American electronics brand, and only later did I learn the connection. In 1971, the Zenith Radio Corporation of Chicago bought the Swiss company. The new owners believed in quartz, and mechanical chronographs looked like relics. In 1975, the order came to stop making mechanical movements, and the tooling for <em>El Primero</em> was to be sold off or scrapped.</p><p>Charles Vermot did not go along with it. He had worked on <em>El Primero</em> from the start, and he knew what was about to be lost. Evening after evening, without telling his colleagues or his family, he carried the plans, the cams, the small tools and about 150 presses up to an attic at the manufacture and walled them in. It sounds like watchmaking mythology, but it really happened. The owners were ready to throw the tooling away, and one employee kept it.</p><p>My essay on the Chief of Staff role, “<a href="https://rivasrod.medium.com/background-operator-fb315685ce4c">Background Operator</a>”, is about the people who keep an institution running from the edge of the frame. Vermot may be the purest case I know, even if he wasn’t technically a Chief of Staff, but then again, who really is? But just like many Chiefs of Staff, nobody gave him the authority. He saw what the house needed and did it quietly, at real personal risk. Loyalty to a house can, under certain circumstances, mean disobeying the people who run it.</p><p>Mechanical watches came back. El Primero went back into production in 1984, with Rolex among the first customers, and Ebel soon came to Le Locle. It needed an automatic chronograph movement for the Daytona and chose Zenith’s calibre. Because why not call the best? Rolex modified it extensively, lowering the frequency from 36,000 to 28,800 vibrations per hour, and removing the date, among other changes, and the Zenith-based Daytona (aka Zenith Daytona) was sold from 1988 to 2000.</p><p>The sequence has a certain symmetry. Zenith’s owners nearly destroyed the movement. As a response, one man hid the tools in an attic. As a consequence, the movement survived long enough for Rolex, the most powerful name in Swiss watchmaking, to want what Zenith had almost thrown away. After all my time researching the Joske’s bracelets, I enjoy the interconnectedness story in which Rolex depends on someone else’s expertise.</p><p>It is also why Jean-Claude Biver’s criticism of Zenith interests me. When he took charge of the brand in 2017, he saw <em>El Primero</em> as both its greatest asset and its trap. The line attributed to him goes roughly like this: “What was the last revolutionary innovation from Zenith? El Primero, 1969. And then? 1969. And then? 1969.” It works as criticism. It could also be taken as a compliment. Zenith made something revolutionary that has stood the test of time. If it is not broken, why fix it?</p><p>Plenty of watch brands become one-trick ponies, with one famous movement, one famous design, and a marketing operation devoted to reminding everyone about it. Zenith has <em>El Primero</em>, but it also has the Defy, the Pilot, the Elite, a chronometry record and a catalogue of eccentric watches. Favre-Jacot registered the trademark <em>Pilote</em>, later Pilot, in 1888, and Defi, the origin of Defy, in 1902. The company was doing interesting things long before 1969 and kept doing them afterwards.</p><p>That is part of why I have always found the brand appealing. It is not the obvious choice. You do not walk into a room and see a sea of Zeniths. With annual production in the thousands rather than the hundreds of thousands, you can go a long time without meeting one in the wild. When I do, I smile. There is a kinship in choosing something off the main road, particularly when you know the history behind it.</p><p>I gifted someone a vintage Zenith before I owned one myself. I think I was waiting for the right watch, not a Zenith for its own sake.</p><p>I considered the Lupin III editions. I love comics, and the watches look great, the Final Edition in particular. But I never really connected with that particular manga enough to justify it. I could admire the watch, and if I ever saw one, I would think great choice! But I never felt it was mine.</p><p>But that had settled it. I needed to look seriously at the A384.</p><p>The A384 is one of the original <em>El Primero</em> watches of 1969, alongside the A385 and the A386, and its case makes you wonder why designers spent so many decades afterwards making watches look like watches. At 37 millimetres it sounds small by current standards, but the <em>tonneau</em> shape, sharp facets and angular shoulders give it more presence than the number suggests. In the 1970’s thanks to Gérald Genta canon, we started to look differently at angular, sculpted steel cases, and it eventually became the language of the 1970s and dominated largely the current watch design era. But if you think about it, the A384 was speaking that language in 1969, being a sort of precursor three years before the Royal Oak.</p><p>Zenith called the A384 the first watch to house <em>El Primero</em>, as it was the model first appearing in an ad. Some collectors give that honour to the A386, which has become the face of the trio, and I will concede the point to the purists. Still, if <em>El Primero</em> means “the first”, and Zenith advertised the A384 first, then this means, in a slightly ridiculous bit of horological wordplay, the <em>El Primero El Primero</em>. A watch obsessive cannot resist that.</p><p>The modern Revival stays close to the original, which is what I want from a reissue like this. It does not try to make the A384 more contemporary than it needs to be. It keeps the angular case, the compact dimensions and the Gay Frères ladder bracelet.</p><p>A word on the bracelet. It is not perfect. By modern standards, it can be annoying: jangly, slightly loose, with an old-style clasp that lacks the silky precision and easy micro-adjustment we now expect. You could fit a modern clasp if you want, and there is nothing wrong with that. I don’t want to. The jangle is part of the charm. It makes the watch feel like a vintage piece that arrived in the present as new old stock. If I wanted modern convenience above everything else, I would buy a modern bracelet. With the Zenith, I want the history.</p><p>That applies even more to the Chronomaster Revival Shadow.</p><p>The Shadow is unusual even by Zenith standards. Zenith took the A384, put it in a dark microblasted titanium case, and a design from 1969 suddenly looks as if it belongs in a science fiction film. It is clearly the same watch with a completely different personality. Zenith says it was inspired by an obscure chronograph prototype from around 1970 with a black-coated case, so it is an interpretation and not a copy of a watch that was never sold, even if from time to time you can find them floating around.</p><p>The design is an acquired taste, and I am not sure I would have appreciated it when I first became interested in watches. Back then I would probably have found the case too strange, the bracelet too awkward and the whole thing too unconventional. I had the same experience with cocktails, which I wrote about at length in my essay on cocktail diplomacy. When I was younger, I wanted something immediately understandable: cold, sweet, colourful, perhaps with an umbrella. It took me years to appreciate a properly made Old Fashioned, where the ingredients have nowhere to hide. Whiskey, bitters, sugar, orange peel. Once you understand why the proportions work, you see how hard it is to get something so simple right.</p><p>The Shadow is a little like that. It does not announce its beauty. You have to spend some time with it, an acquired taste, just like me.</p><p>The first Shadow, on its strap, also felt incomplete to me. The case was there, the movement was there, the idea was there, and the titanium Gay Frères ladder bracelet was the missing word in the sentence. Once Zenith offered it, the watch looked finished.</p><p>On the wrist, I think it is fantastic. The 37-millimetre case wears larger than the number suggests without feeling oversized, and the titanium makes it extremely light. The black, almost brownish-grey tones give it a stealthy quality, and the grey subdials and <em>tachymeter</em> scale against the matte black dial give it just enough definition to keep it from going anonymous. The layout is very seventies, but the materials make it feel futuristic.</p><p>Then there is the movement, the part you cannot readily see and the part that gives the watch its meaning. On your wrist is a modern descendant of a calibre developed in the 1960s, a movement that was nearly destroyed, whose tooling survived because one man hid it in an attic, and which later became good enough for Rolex to build its automatic Daytona around it. It still beats at 36,000 vibrations per hour.</p><p>It has been improved, of course. Modern materials, better manufacturing, and steady refinements to reliability have been added over the decades. Production stopped between 1975 and 1984, but the design came through intact.</p><p>Zenith has also kept pushing the idea forward. The <em>El Primero</em> 21, introduced in 2017, took high frequency much further, with a dedicated chronograph mechanism running at 360,000 vibrations per hour and measuring to one hundredth of a second. Zenith is not simply polishing the 1969 movement. The original was good enough to serve as a platform for new ideas, and I suspect that is the best answer to Biver’s “And then?”</p><p>Zenith has collected an unusual group of admirers over the years, and some predate <em>El Primero</em> by decades. Mahatma Gandhi owned a silver Zenith alarm pocket watch that, according to Zenith, was a gift from Jawaharlal Nehru. Its alarm marked his prayer times, and it was one of the very few things he owned. It was stolen from him on a train journey to Kanpur in late May 1947, an episode he recorded in his own diary. According to Zenith, the thief returned it six months later and asked for his forgiveness. Although it was not a wristwatch, it was a Zenith. Fast forward and you find Carl Cox, Aaron Rodgers, Will Ferrell, Nicolas Cage and Russell Westbrook. Mahatma Gandhi, a DJ, actors, comedians and top athletes. Zenith is appreciated by different types and has never belonged to one tribe.</p><p>I write fiction around watches. In <a href="https://www.amazon.com.be/-/en/Just-Past-Midnight-Rodolfo-Rivas/dp/B0HH8L9TB9"><em>Just Past Midnight</em></a>, a Tudor Submariner 7928 carries the plot, because I have always believed a watch can hold a story. Zenith holds more stories than most. That is part of why I keep coming back to it. If you want the obvious Swiss watch, there are plenty. If you want something recognizable across a restaurant table, there are plenty of those too. Zenith sits on slightly different ground. You need to know what you are looking at, or at least be curious enough to ask. The Shadow rewards that curiosity.</p><p>It is not perfect. The bracelet rattles. The clasp feels old-fashioned. The design is strange. Because it is an interpretation and not a straight reissue, the story behind this version is less clean than the story of the original A384. Plenty of watches are easier to live with, and plenty are easier to explain. Very few pack this much history, engineering and eccentricity into just 37 millimetres.</p><p>I will not claim the decision was rational. You can spend hours comparing movements, dimensions, finishing, accuracy, power reserve and bracelet construction, and all of it matters. Then you put the watch on, look down and smile. The Shadow does that for me.</p><p>It reminds me of hearing <em>El Primero</em> for the first time and wondering why a Swiss company had chosen a Spanish name. Of Zenith televisions in Mexico. Of Charles Vermot carrying presses up the stairs at night. Of Rolex coming for the movement, and of Biver worrying that Zenith had become trapped by its own past. Of a mechanical calibre that survived when almost everything around it changed.</p><p>A word on timing.</p><p>I bought this watch before the news. A piece like this can easily read as a reaction to the headlines, but it is not, since my decision was long time in the making and happened before the news.</p><p>On 22 October 2026, Zenith confirmed that it had opened a staff consultation as part of what it called a strategic repositioning. According to news articles, about 100 of the 196 jobs at the Le Locle manufacture are affected, and roughly 100 more in the international sales network. Le Temps reported that Zenith would leave the CHF 8,000 to 15,000 territory that has been its core and move towards lower-volume, far more expensive watchmaking, with the shift completed by 2029. Some news outlets put the target at watches in the region of CHF 50,000. The consultation was closing as I finished this piece, and the union Unia had until 12 November to propose alternatives, so the numbers may still change.</p><p>Part of the logic is the G.F.J. Zenith launched it in 2025 for its 160th anniversary as a limited edition of 160 platinum pieces at CHF 48,900, built around a revived Calibre 135, and it won the Chronometry Prize at the Grand Prix d’Horlogerie de Genève that November. According to some news outlets, Benoît de Clerck, Zenith’s chief executive, has cited its success as a reason to move upmarket.</p><p>The news is sad. It could be worse, but it is also not a closure. The manufacture will continue making movements, including for other LVMH brands such as Hublot, and de Clerck has spoken of a full order book. The plan is to come out smaller and more expensive, but not everyone is convinced. Oliver Müller of LuxeConsult has pointed out that this would be Zenith’s sixth price positioning since LVMH bought it in 1999, and that what the brand has lacked is consistency. Zenith has been here before, at least in outline. It was once told to destroy the tools for the movement that defines it, and it survived because one man ignored the instruction.</p><p>This time the backdrop is different. The pandemic boom is over. The Swiss franc is strong. De Clerck has pointed to weaker demand in the Middle East and Asia, and to US tariffs. My day job is trade policy in Geneva, so I notice when a tariff shows up in watch prices. Washington’s 39 percent tariff on Swiss goods was cut to 15 percent in November 2025, but a brand cannot plan production around numbers that move like that.</p><p>Zenith is not alone in the room. In some less publicized news, Montblanc is closing its watch factory in Le Locle and spun off Minverva. Sowind, the group that has owned Girard-Perregaux and Ulysse Nardin since Kering sold them to management in 2022, put some staff on short-time work and cut jobs in 2025. Richemont sold Baume &amp; Mercier to Damiani, with the deal closing in July. Ebel is changing hands again: in October Movado agreed to sell 95 percent of it for USD 66.5 million to a group led by F.P. Journe’s company, with Chanel taking part. The cases differ, but side by side they look like an industry taking stock of itself.</p><p>None of this is the quartz crisis. Nothing has made the mechanical watch obsolete. The market is splitting, with strong demand at the very top and a squeezed middle, which is exactly where Zenith has lived. According to Morgan Stanley and LuxeConsult, watches above CHF 50,000 were only 1.4 percent of Swiss watch volumes in 2025, but about 37 percent of export value and 89 percent of the industry’s growth.</p><p>Then the numbers for Zenith. Morgan Stanley and LuxeConsult estimate that its output fell from roughly 13,000 watches in 2023 to about 8,500 in 2025, with sales dropping from around CHF 138 million to CHF 98 million. Zenith does not publish these figures, so treat them as estimates.</p><p>Even at its larger size, Zenith was small. The same report puts Rolex at around 1.15 million watches a year, Cartier at roughly 695,000 and Omega at about 460,000. Zenith’s whole annual output is less than one percent of Rolex’s. Rolex makes that many watches in under three days.</p><p>My decision came before any of this, and the news, if anything, confirms it. The Shadow sits inside the price range Zenith says it will leave, so I would not assume it stays in the catalogue. I still think it is one of the finest watches at its price.</p><p>It is a watch that should probably not exist in quite the form it does, which is another reason I like it. The safe choice would have been something else. So would the obvious one.</p><p>But if you want history, design, mechanical eccentricity, a bit of attitude, and the quiet pleasure of wearing something most people in the room will not recognize, then I would say the words that caught my attention all those years ago.</p><p><em>El Primero</em>. The first. And after all this time, I finally have one.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=3196f36a58f0" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Name on the Ticker]]></title>
            <link>https://rivasrod.medium.com/the-name-on-the-ticker-a5bb7a392ea1?source=rss-c519b7f88399------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a5bb7a392ea1</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[career-advice]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[jobs]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[job-hunting]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[careers]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[career-development]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Rodolfo C. Rivas]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 24 Oct 2026 17:05:40 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-10-24T17:05:40.479Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>On perceived potential, rejection and taking the scenic route</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*4r_bvKYKn7Wu_aKo64n_xA.png" /></figure><p>By Rodolfo C. Rivas</p><p>When the Denver Nuggets picked Nikola Jokić 41st in the 2014 NBA Draft, he was asleep at home in Sombor, Serbia. His brother called from New York with the news, and Jokić told him he was sleeping and hung up. Viewers didn’t see much more than that. ESPN was running a Taco Bell commercial, and his name crawled across the bottom of the screen. He went on to become the lowest-drafted player ever to win the MVP, won it three times, and in 2023 led Denver to its first championship.</p><p>I’ve thought about that Taco Bell commercial more than a grown man should. It’s funny, but mostly I recognize something in it. For a good part of my career I’ve been the name on the ticker while everyone was looking at something else. I don’t say that to complain. I’ve had opportunities I couldn’t have predicted when I started, and I’ve done work I’m proud of. I’ve also applied for jobs I thought I was qualified for and never made a shortlist. I’ve gone after a professional goal twice and been turned down twice. I’ve written things nobody wanted to publish.</p><p>I want to look at the distance between how potential reads on paper and what a person ends up doing with it. Basketball shows that distance more openly than most fields do; film shows it too, and my own career is a smaller and less glamorous example. Plenty of people never get discovered, so I won’t pretend this ends with everyone getting their due. I’m curious about what happens when the prediction turns out wrong, and the road you end up on is not the one you planned.</p><h3>Draft night</h3><p>Michael Jordan went third in 1984. Portland, which already had Clyde Drexler, took the center Sam Bowie second, which made sense on paper since the Trail Blazers needed size. Hakeem Olajuwon went first. Jordan went to Chicago and became Michael Jordan, and the draft board has looked a little silly ever since. In fairness to Portland, injuries shaped Bowie’s career, and nobody could have known how his body would hold up. Greg Oden went first in 2007, one pick ahead of Kevin Durant, and his knees gave out before he could deliver what the number promised.</p><p>Some of the busts had nothing to do with knees. Kwame Brown went first in 2001 and spent his career being compared to the number next to his name. Darko Milićić went second in 2003, ahead of Carmelo Anthony, Chris Bosh and Dwyane Wade. A first pick walks into the building already owing something, and every missed shot gets read against that number.</p><p>The sure things were sure for good reason. Magic Johnson went first in 1979 and, as a rookie, started at center in the clinching Finals game with Kareem hurt, and scored 42. LeBron James was on the cover of <em>Sports Illustrated</em> at seventeen under the words “The Chosen One”, and somehow lived up to the sentence. Luka Dončić went third in 2018 and was traded for Trae Young that night. Shai Gilgeous-Alexander went eleventh and was sent to the Clippers on draft night. Years later Luka landed with the Lakers, which I followed closely, and Shai was the league’s MVP in 2025.</p><p>The 1996 class shows how little draft order tells you. Allen Iverson went first and was spectacular. Kobe Bryant went thirteenth and Steve Nash fifteenth. Ben Wallace wasn’t drafted at all and went on to win Defensive Player of the Year four times.</p><p>And Jokić, whom scouts thought too slow and too heavy, has changed how the center position gets played.</p><p>A pick is a guess made by people who have watched a young player for a few hundred hours. It tells you something about the player, and a good deal about what the guessers value, what they’re afraid of, and what they haven’t learned yet.</p><h3>The work</h3><p>Kobe Bryant came straight out of high school, and Charlotte sent his rights to the Lakers for Vlade Divac. At eighteen, he shot four airballs in a single playoff game against Utah, with a full arena watching. What interests me more is what he did afterward. By every account I’ve read, he went back to work and kept at it for twenty years. He studied film, including tape of Jordan; he was first into the gym and last out of it, and he later wrote a book called <em>The Mamba Mentality</em>, which is mostly about preparation.</p><p>Five championships came out of that. The thirteenth pick doesn’t explain him, and neither do the airballs. He was a student of the game who had decided to outwork everyone in the building, and no draft room has a way to measure that.</p><h3>The long way to the league</h3><p>Manu Ginóbili was the second round 57th pick in 1999, but played his first NBA game years later. He stayed in Europe, didn’t reach the NBA until he was twenty-five, and then won four championships in San Antonio. Jeremy Lin went undrafted, after attending Harvard, got cut by two teams, and was reportedly sleeping on his brother’s couch when, for a few weeks in 2012, he became the most talked-about athlete in the world.</p><p>Then there is Jalen Brunson, whose story I’ve been able to follow in real time. He won two national championships at Villanova and was the college player of the year, and he still lasted until the 33rd pick in 2018, taken by Dallas. This year, when reporters asked him what the scouts had missed, he answered in one word: “Everything”. He left Dallas as a free agent in 2022 and signed with a Knicks team that had won a single playoff series in the previous two decades. Four years later, in June 2026, the Knicks beat the Spurs in five games for their first title since 1973. Brunson was the Finals MVP, and he scored 45 in the clincher.</p><p>And the argument isn’t over. In 2023, Becky Hammon told a television audience that the Knicks didn’t have a true number one guy, partly because Brunson is six-foot-two. After the title, she admitted her opinion was wrong, without apologizing for having held it. This fall, a preseason ranking still placed him outside the top five.</p><p>Fred VanVleet took a different fork. He was a six-foot-one point guard out of Wichita State, and in 2016 no team picked him. By his own account, he had turned down offers that would have kept him in the minor leagues for a couple of years on very little money. At the draft party his family and friends had organized, he took the microphone and told the room he’d bet on himself. He admitted he was disappointed. Then he said, “My story don’t end here”, and gave the reason: “It wouldn’t really make sense for my story if I did get picked”. He had been up against the odds his whole life, and a story like his was never going to start with a draft pick.</p><p>Toronto signed him as a free agent. He spent time in the G League, helped the Raptors win the 2019 championship, and later signed a four-year, $85 million contract, at the time the biggest ever for an undrafted player.</p><p>Even the greats had their own versions. At the height of his fame, Jordan left basketball to play minor league baseball. With the Double-A Birmingham Barons in 1994, he hit .202 with three home runs and struck out 114 times in 127 games. Then he came back and won three more championships. The numbers weren’t impressive, but I admire the decision to try something he wasn’t good at.</p><p>We tell these stories backward, from the championship, which makes every bad stretch look like a required chapter. Nobody living through those chapters knew that.</p><h3>Movie jail</h3><p>Directors live under a similar arithmetic, with louder consequences. Damien Chazelle won Best Director for <em>La La Land</em> at thirty-two, so everything after it was judged against that night. <em>First Man</em> underperformed, and <em>Babylon</em> lost a great deal of money. Hollywood has a name for where directors go after that. It’s called movie jail, and sentences vary. Before any of it, Chazelle got <em>Whiplash</em> made by first making it as an eighteen-minute short, to show financiers the feature could work.</p><p>Then there are the three Mexicans, Alfonso Cuarón, Guillermo del Toro and Alejandro González Iñárritu. They are friends, and they behave like friends. They read one another’s scripts, show up at one another’s premieres, and serve as one another’s first audience. Across six ceremonies, they collected five Best Director awards. From the outside, that looks like a streak. From the inside, I suspect, it looks more like a support system. None of them arrived by a straight line, either. Iñárritu was a radio DJ in Mexico City before he directed a feature, and del Toro came up through makeup effects and Mexican television before the difficult experience of making <em>Mimic</em> in Hollywood.</p><p><em>Digger</em>, Iñárritu’s satire starring Tom Cruise, opened to roughly $20 million worldwide against a reported budget well above $100 million, and the reviews split sharply. Del Toro publicly defended it and urged people to go see it. I believe <em>Digger</em> will be regarded as a masterpiece in ten or twenty years, and a film that expensive has real consequences now. What I notice is that the friends are still showing up.</p><p>The story I find most useful for my own purposes is Sylvester Stallone’s, which Peter Farrelly turns into a film this November called <em>I Play Rocky</em>. (It is good and inspiring!) In the mid-1970s Stallone was a struggling actor of twenty-nine, with a partly paralyzed face and a way of speaking that made producers wince. He wrote the script for <em>Rocky</em> in a matter of days. The studio wanted the script and didn’t want the man. They offered serious money, reportedly as much as $360,000, if he would let someone else play Rocky. He was broke, and he said no. He eventually got the film made for under a million dollars with himself in the lead, and it won Best Picture.</p><p>Most of us never get a $360,000 offer to turn down, but we get smaller versions of it all the time: the safer role, the cleaner résumé, the version of ourselves that fits somebody else’s drawer.</p><h3>The books</h3><p>Writers have been keeping this ledger for centuries, and the Mexican shelf is the one that comforts me most. Juan Rulfo wrote two slim books that Mexican literature still circles while selling tires and later working for a government agency. Gabriel García Márquez spent years in Mexico City writing journalism and film scripts before <em>One Hundred Years of Solitude</em> appeared when he was forty. Octavio Paz and Carlos Fuentes pursued diplomatic careers alongside their writing.</p><p>For a long time I told myself that dividing my life between law and writing meant spreading myself too thin. These people made that worry harder to keep. I doubt they ever resolved the tension. They lived with it.</p><h3>My own draft</h3><p>My career began in labour law. I was a trainee at a firm run by one of my law professors, who is still a good friend, and I split my days between class and the office. Eventually I found myself advising a local football team on labour matters.</p><p>Around the same time, I discovered the Court of Arbitration for Sport in Lausanne. That was when I knew what I wanted to do, even if I had no idea how to get there: international sports arbitration.</p><p>I asked the domestic arbitration institutions for guidance, and the advice was unanimous. I needed more experience and more specialization. So I went to Alicante and completed a master’s that also let me bring my love of film into a legal career. Whenever I was back in Mexico, I visited those institutions, and eventually the visits led to my first appointments as an arbitrator.</p><p>Then WIPO’s Arbitration and Mediation Centre recruited me. I worked on domain name disputes, a young and fast-growing area, and later served as a panelist for almost all the approved providers. At WIPO, I also got to watch international arbitrations up close, and I realized my civil law training wouldn’t be enough on its own. So I went to Stanford for an LL.M. in the common law tradition.</p><p>After that came what I thought would be a detour into trade law. I joined the WTO’s Appellate Body Secretariat, where I was part of the Secretariat that administered disputes, and later I joined the teams representing two different states in them. Those years are among the proudest of my professional career.</p><p>Since then, I’ve taught international dispute settlement, been included on the WTO’s roster of panelists, joined the CAS pro bono counsel list, and become a Fellow of the Chartered Institute of Arbitrators (FCIArb). I also completed an MBA somewhere along the way. I wrote about this road for <em>The Resolver</em>, the CIArb magazine. My <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/rivasrodolfo">LinkedIn profile</a> has the full list of roles and degrees. But there’s something that article couldn’t yet say.</p><p>The goal I started with, the one that began with a football team and a building in Lausanne, was to become a CAS arbitrator. When I wrote the piece, I had just submitted my application and was waiting for a decision. I have applied twice since then, and been turned down both times.</p><p>When the second rejection came, I was on my way to a meeting. It did not feel good, but I had to bring my A-game. The meeting went well, and I did not tell anyone about the rejection for weeks. Only those closest to me could tell something was wrong.</p><p>I had spent years building the experience I thought the role required, and I believed I had a credible case. Apparently that wasn’t enough.</p><p>But I suppose the third time is the charm. I’ll apply again.</p><p>Today I work as chief of staff for the mission of a country that isn’t my own, in the rooms where WTO disputes and negotiations take place. I host a podcast, <em>The Rodolfo Rivas Project</em>, now in its seventh season. One of my short films, <em>Driver</em>, won an audience award at a small festival in December 2025. I spend a fair amount of time thinking about watches, including how to set up the GMT and why the Monaco is a better watch than it has any right to be. I watch basketball with a seriousness my family and colleagues may find slightly alarming.</p><h3>The novelette</h3><p>I also write fiction, and so far the piece I’m proudest of is a novelette called <em>Just Past Midnight</em>.</p><p>I did what you’re supposed to do. I researched the conventional publishing routes, wrote the letters, sent the pages, and waited. There was very little interest. Nobody was hostile, which would at least have given me something to push against. The mailbox just stayed quiet.</p><p>Eventually I decided to publish it myself. That didn’t solve the problem of finding readers, but it got the story off my hard drive, and it has since grown into an expanded story. It never felt like a fallback to me. The work had to exist before anyone else could decide whether it was worth reading.</p><p>Chazelle’s <em>Whiplash</em> short was on my mind at the time. My situation was different, since I wasn’t trying to get a studio to finance a film, but I understood the impulse. I’ve started to think of the podcast, the films, the cases and the essays the same way, as proof of concept of what I can do, laid on a table for anyone willing to look.</p><h3>The shortlist</h3><p>I started my career inside WIPO, and later inside the WTO, so I know those corridors. Years afterward I applied for countless new positions at both, and at pretty much every international organization in Geneva. I have never once made a shortlist.</p><p>For a long time I took that as a verdict. I assumed there was some deficiency I couldn’t see, so I kept adding to the pile, hoping the next qualification would settle the argument.</p><p>Eventually I tried the other door. I spoke with headhunters about the private sector, and they were polite and direct. I had spent too many years in the public sector, which they regarded as inefficient, and the private sector wasn’t interested. That got to me. I talked about transferable skills, and about negotiating in complex settings with dozens of delegations around the table and no shared first language. I mentioned the writing, the films, the podcast, the habit of finishing things. None of it seemed to change their minds.</p><p>You can live with being rejected for something you lack. Being rejected for where you’ve been is stranger, because there’s nothing obvious to fix.</p><p>In time I started to suspect that the trouble had less to do with what I could do than with how hard it was to see where I fit. A lawyer who writes and hosts a podcast. A negotiator with a festival award. A Mexican in Geneva working for a foreign government, with a public-sector résumé the private sector has already decided to read as a flaw. People look at that combination and struggle to place it, and when a candidate with a tidier fit is available, the decision gets easy. A draft board works the same way: people pick the player whose position they can see.</p><p>WIPO and the WTO picked me early in my career, and yet that didn’t make anyone else pick me later.</p><h3>My batting average</h3><p>Baseball has a statistic I find unusually honest. A hitter who gets a hit three times out of ten is considered excellent, and one who fails seven times out of ten can still end up in the Hall of Fame. Ted Williams hit .406 in 1941, and nobody has reached .400 in the MLB since.</p><p>I’ve tried to work out my own average, counting everything: applications at international organizations, the CAS applications, pitches, business opportunities, ideas I pursued, offers I sent into the void, emails that began with hope and ended in silence. Some attempts were small, and some took years. Counted honestly, my success rate is below .100. In baseball terms, that sits well under the Mendoza Line, the unofficial threshold of .200, which is named after my fellow Mexican shortstop Mario Mendoza.</p><p>That coincidence appeals to me more than it probably should. Mendoza hit .215 over his major league career and became famous for an average that was poor by professional standards. But he stayed in the majors for years, largely because of his defense, and kept playing in Mexico afterward. In the Mexican League he hit .291 over seven seasons. They called him Manos de Seda, “Silk Hands,” and he was eventually inducted into the Mexican Baseball Hall of Fame. The man whose name became shorthand for failing at the plate had a long career and was remembered for a skill no single statistic captured. Jordan, arguably the best athlete in history, for what it’s worth, hit .202 in Birmingham, so he cleared that line by two points.</p><p>The comparison only goes so far, since Mendoza made it to the major leagues and I’m a lawyer who also writes and makes films. But it makes me ask what I’m counting. If I count only the applications that turned into the jobs I wanted, the number is bleak. If I count the work I was trusted with, the cases, the students, the films, the stories, it looks different.</p><p>Strikeouts don’t tell the whole story either. Reggie Jackson holds the major league record with 2,597, and Jim Thome is close behind him. Both are in the Hall of Fame. A long career means a lot of at-bats. I’m not going to claim every failure was secretly worth it. Some applications just fail, and some answers stay no.</p><h3>What people see</h3><p>I don’t know exactly how other people see my career. I can only go by what they tell me, from younger professionals and from people with considerably more experience. On the whole, they seem to regard it as a success.</p><p>Perhaps that’s partly because I’m loud on LinkedIn. I’ve learned to talk about what I do, to share work I’m proud of and make the occasional announcement. In the years when I didn’t, it didn’t help me, and I watched other people benefit from a habit I’d assumed was beneath me. I’m still not sure I’ve found the right balance. I don’t want to turn every part of my life into content or pretend every project matters more than it does. But if something feels meaningful and worth sharing, I share it, and if it doesn’t, I don’t.</p><p>The difficulty is that social media shows the results without the full record. People see the new role, the degree, the festival award, or the published essay. They don’t see the thousand, or perhaps ten thousand, things I’ve tried and failed at: the applications that disappeared, the pitches that went nowhere, the business ideas nobody wanted to buy. That isn’t dishonest, but it is selective. My résumé is selective, my profile is, and so is this essay.</p><p>Someone early in their career may look at my résumé, or at yours, and conclude that people like us were chosen, that the path was clear and the doors opened on schedule. They weren’t, and they didn’t.</p><h3>The doubt</h3><p>A piece like this can make me sound calmer than I am, so I should say that there has always been doubt. Maybe that isn’t true for everyone, and I envy those people a little, but it has been true for me. I’ve asked myself more than once whether I should have picked a lane, whether the films and the essays and the podcast were a way of avoiding a harder decision, whether the people who said I was spreading myself thin had a point.</p><p>After many years, and I can’t name the day it happened, the doubt has quieted. I trust the whole road more than I trust any single turn in it. I know where I’m headed. There will be detours on the way, some of them long, and a few I would have skipped if I could have seen them coming. But the direction hasn’t changed since a football team and a building in Lausanne.</p><h3>The hours</h3><p>People sometimes ask how I find the time to do everything: the arbitration work, the podcast, the writing, the films. I feel I waste a lot of it. I love watching films, I love reading, and I love watching the Lakers, and some evenings I wonder whether I should be doing something else with the hours. I’ve come to think those evenings are where the work comes from.</p><p>I have plenty of half-written pieces. When I hit a block, I move to the next one, and I return to each of them when I have something to say, or when a movie or a Lakers run gives me a reason. It doesn’t look efficient from the outside, but it works for me.</p><p>Running is the other thing I would have bet against. For more than forty years I wasn’t a runner. Then something switched, and now I am. It’s a small thing, but it taught me what no argument had managed to: you can change the path. It also made me a little less sure about some of the other things I had told myself over the years.</p><h3>Comparing</h3><p>For years I measured myself against the careers around me. In Geneva I watched people begin with brighter résumés than mine. Some were gone within a few years, pushed out by the same expectations that had helped them rise. Others began quietly and, ten years later, became the people everyone wanted in the room. I watched a few who seemed to have everything and didn’t seem to enjoy any of it.</p><p>I knew the titles and the promotions. I rarely knew what they had cost, which is the main reason comparing yourself to someone else’s career is such a miserable approach.</p><p>I spent a long time thinking I was supposed to follow a straight line to the top of the building. What I found along the way was work I actually wanted to do. The films, the writing, and the podcast were never consolation prizes. When *Drive* won that audience award, the feeling was nothing like what I had imagined a promotion letter would give me. It was good, of course, but the surprise was how little it resembled the feeling I had spent so long chasing, and how much more it meant to me in its own way.</p><p>The road has been slower than I expected, harder to explain at dinner, and sometimes lonely. It has also taken me places I might never have seen if I’d followed the plan.</p><p>I still want to become a CAS arbitrator, and I don’t think there’s anything noble about pretending otherwise. What I’ve stopped doing is treating that destination as the only thing that justifies the road.</p><p>Nobody can tell you how your career is going to go, and plenty of people will try. You have to live through it yourself.</p><p>I’ll keep applying, keep writing and keep making films, and I’ll keep sending things out, knowing some of them will go nowhere. I can’t promise persistence pays off, or that the next rejection will be easier than the last. I can only say that the work still interests me, and that I haven’t run out of things to try.</p><p>When Jokić won the championship, he said he wanted to go home to his horses. He has also said he has never eaten Taco Bell because of that draft night. For a man whose name once crawled across the bottom of the screen, he holds what resembles a grudge against exactly one thing, and I respect that.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a5bb7a392ea1" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Careful What You Wish For: What a World Without the WTO Would Actually Look Like]]></title>
            <link>https://rivasrod.medium.com/careful-what-you-wish-for-what-a-world-without-the-wto-would-actually-look-like-29bbfbee1291?source=rss-c519b7f88399------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/29bbfbee1291</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[international-relations]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[trade]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[international-development]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[international]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[wto]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Rodolfo C. Rivas]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 14 Oct 2026 05:00:14 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-10-14T05:00:14.181Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*XQbOzVIdC2emBXdJOTFawA.jpeg" /></figure><p>By Rodolfo C. Rivas</p><h3>I. A Building on the Lake, and the Story Told About It</h3><p>The Centre William Rappard sits in a park on the shore of Lake Geneva. Built in the 1920s for the International Labour Office (ILO), the GATT secretariat moved in during 1977. Outside, tourists photograph the lake, joggers use the waterfront and the buses carry people to work. Inside, a committee examines a notification, a delegate delivers a statement in a rush to beat the two-minute clock, and someone reads a schedule of concessions more carefully than its drafters ever expected.</p><p>I have spent enough time in that building to be wary of how it is described elsewhere. For years now the WTO has been presented in the press, and in a good part of the public conversation, as an institution in crisis: paralyzed, irrelevant, perhaps finished. Obituaries for the WTO have been in circulation at least since Seattle in 1999, and the patient keeps turning up to meetings. Some of this comes from people who want it reformed and some from people who would not mind seeing it go. Very little of it describes what the organization does on an ordinary working day, which is that its councils and committees meet, its members notify measures and question each other’s regulations, accession and reform work continues, and negotiators submit proposals that may end up in draft text.</p><p>Part of the criticism is fair. The Appellate Body has been unable to hear appeals since December 2019. The 14th Ministerial Conference, held in Yaoundé in March 2026, ended without agreement on extending the moratorium on customs duties on electronic transmissions, and the moratorium lapsed for the first time since 1998. The share of world merchandise trade on most-favoured-nation (MFN) terms has fallen. I do not intend to wave any of that away.</p><p>It helps to separate what the WTO does into four functions: negotiating, monitoring and transparency, the substantive rules and commitments, and dispute settlement and enforcement. The impairment of one does not show that the others have failed. By the same token, the fact that committees keep meeting does not show that the organization is delivering its full value. Activity is not the same thing as effectiveness.</p><p>But one strand of the commentary measures the WTO by whether it produces a new set of rules every few years. That is a standard the institution has never met and no multilateral body could meet. The Tokyo Round ran from 1973 to 1979. The Uruguay Round was launched in 1986 and concluded in 1993, with the agreements signed at Marrakesh in 1994. The Doha Round began in 2001. These were negotiations among governments with sharply different interests, and the WTO now has 166 members that decide by consensus. Even in favourable political conditions, which these are not, nobody serious expects comprehensive agreements every other year.</p><p>The record since 2013 is also less empty than the headlines suggest. Members concluded the Trade Facilitation Agreement in 2013, and it entered into force in 2017. At Nairobi in 2015 we agreed to eliminate agricultural export subsidies and expanded the Information Technology Agreement. In 2022 we adopted a ministerial decision on intellectual property and COVID-19 vaccines, and concluded the Agreement on Fisheries Subsidies, which entered into force on 15 September 2025 as the first WTO agreement with environmental sustainability at its core. Comoros and Timor-Leste completed their accessions in 2024. At Yaoundé, 66 members, accounting for roughly 70 percent of world trade, announced that they would move forward with the Agreement on Electronic Commerce through interim arrangements (the count has since risen to 67). The outcome of Yaoundé was disappointing on several fronts, but “nothing happens” is not an accurate description of it, to put it diplomatically.</p><p>The second observation concerns the United States. The rhetoric in Washington about the organization has been harsh at times, and the United States has not hidden its dissatisfaction with the Appellate Body, with special and differential treatment, with the way consensus operates, or, as recently as this month, with the unconditional application of the MFN principle. Yet it has not left. It sent a ministerial-level delegation to Yaoundé, it issued reform papers in December 2025 and March 2026, and it continues to take part in the work of the organization’s councils, committees and negotiating groups. I have written about this elsewhere, because it tends to get lost in the noise. A government that regards an institution as worthless does not spend this much diplomatic effort trying to change it. The United States stays because the system gives its exporters, its service providers, its farmers and its rights-holders something they cannot easily obtain elsewhere. The same logic applies to most other members.</p><p>This piece has been on my mind for a long time. It responds to that climate, and it is meant as a jolt to those working inside and around the WTO. It is a thought experiment of the monkey’s paw kind: suppose the wish of the WTO’s harshest critics were granted. What would the world look like on the morning after, and for how long afterwards? My answer, in short, is that trade would continue and most existing arrangements would survive the first morning. What would erode, gradually, is the predictability of what governments may do next.</p><h3>II. The Scenario, and Its Limits</h3><p>I want to be precise about what I am describing, because there are two quite different counterfactuals.</p><p>The first is a world in which the WTO was never created, and the GATT of 1947 simply carried on or collapsed. That is a legitimate question for historians, and the period from the 1970s to the early 1990s gives a partial answer. It is not the question here.</p><p>The second is the one I am examining: the WTO as we know it ceases to exist. Starting from the world of October 2026, the Marrakesh Agreement ceases to operate, its multilateral agreements stop functioning as a common framework among members, and the institution (its councils, committees, secretariat and dispute settlement) is gone. Everything else remains: national tariff laws, customs administrations, regulatory agencies, intellectual property statutes, procurement rules, more than 380 regional and preferential agreements notified to the WTO, bilateral investment treaties, and the standard-setting and technical bodies that work alongside the WTO without belonging to it. I assume that no successor institution appears in the first few years.</p><p>This is necessarily a stylized counterfactual. The disappearance of the WTO would not, by itself, settle what happened to every obligation in its agreements, or to provisions that other treaties incorporate by reference, and the answer would depend on the mechanism. An orderly dissolution agreed by the members, a wave of withdrawals and a collapse in which the treaties lapse by default would not have the same legal consequences. For the purposes of this exercise I assume that the WTO’s institutional functions and the multilateral disciplines cease to operate, while domestic laws and separate international agreements remain in force unless they are changed under their own terms. The distinction matters, because the consequences would depend not only on what disappeared but on what governments chose to preserve.</p><p>My aim is a realistic picture rather than an apocalyptic one. International trade would not stop, ships would still sail, and the 1930s would not simply repeat themselves. What changes is slower and more specific, and most of it concerns what each government can rely on from every other government once the common reference point is gone. I will try to say what would persist, what would erode, and roughly how fast. Where I am offering judgement rather than something that can be verified, I will say so.</p><h3>III. What the System Has Delivered</h3><p>It is worth stating plainly what would be lost, because the debate sometimes proceeds as if the organization had produced nothing.</p><p>The WTO’s Chief Economist has cited estimates that world merchandise trade volume has expanded nearly fifty-fold since the multilateral system began, and that GATT/WTO membership has raised trade among members by around 140 percent. These are three different propositions and should not be run together: that trade has grown enormously, that GATT/WTO membership accounts for part of that growth, and what would happen if the WTO were removed today. The first is a matter of record. The second is an econometric estimate, and a debated one. Trade growth has also reflected technological change, falling transport costs, economic growth, domestic reforms, regional agreements and the integration of large economies into global production networks, so the figures show that the multilateral system accompanied a transformation of the world economy; they do not show how much of it the WTO caused. Neither number answers the third question, which is why the rest of this essay works through mechanisms rather than extrapolating from statistics. Since 1995, the share of low- and middle-income economies in world merchandise trade rose from 23 percent to about 45 percent today. That is a change in who participates in the world economy, and it happened within a rules-based system rather than outside one.</p><p>The benefits are easier to see in particular cases than in aggregates.</p><p>· <strong>Predictability for exporters.</strong> A manufacturer in Monterrey, Penang or Nairobi can look up the bound tariff ceiling in a market it intends to enter and rely on it. For a company deciding whether to build a plant that will operate for fifteen or twenty years, that ceiling is information.</p><p>· <strong>Treatment that does not depend on size.</strong> Under MFN, a small member receives the tariff treatment that larger members negotiated among themselves, without having to buy it separately. This is a real advantage, and it is also what critics call free-riding. Both descriptions are accurate.</p><p>· <strong>Accession as a route into the system.</strong> More than thirty economies have joined since 1995, including China (2001), Saudi Arabia (2005), Vietnam (2007), Russia (2012), Liberia and Afghanistan (2016), and Comoros and Timor-Leste (2024). Nepal and Cambodia, both in 2004, were the first least-developed countries to complete the full accession process. Each of them accepted obligations in return for access and a seat at the table.</p><p>· <strong>Legal recourse.</strong> More than 600 disputes have been filed since 1995, and a notable number were brought by developing countries against much larger trading partners. I return to some of them below.</p><p>· <strong>Transparency.</strong> Trade Policy Reviews, notifications and the committee system give governments, and increasingly firms, a reasonably reliable picture of what other members are doing.</p><p>It is hard to find a member that has gained nothing from the system, though a member can benefit overall while particular sectors or groups lose. The United States is the world’s largest exporter of services, a leading exporter of agricultural products and aircraft, and the home of many of the world’s most valuable intellectual property portfolios, and all of those interests rely on commitments made by other members. The same applies to the European Union, China, India, Mexico and Brazil, and, in different ways, to the smallest economies.</p><p>I would not claim that the benefits have been evenly shared. They have not been. Developing countries have argued for decades that the Uruguay Round bargain reflected the priorities of the wealthiest members, that the agriculture rules left rich-country support largely intact, and that implementation costs for agreements such as TRIPS were high. Those arguments have substance. They are arguments about how the benefits are distributed, and about how the rules should be improved, which is a different matter from whether benefits exist.</p><h3>IV. What the Organization Does, and What It Does Not</h3><p>The WTO came into being on 1 January 1995, following the Uruguay Round. It has no army, no customs officers and no power to amend a national statute. It cannot order a government to lower a tariff because the tariff is unwise. Its authority rests on agreements that members negotiated, accepted and undertook to respect. Six elements carry most of the weight.</p><p>1. <strong>Most-favoured-nation treatment.</strong> Subject to exceptions, an advantage granted to one member must be extended to the others. Governments may still apply different tariffs to different products; what they cannot ordinarily do is pick one partner for better treatment without extending it to the rest.</p><p>2. <strong>Tariff bindings.</strong> Members’ schedules set maximum tariff rates. A government may apply a lower rate, but raising a rate above its binding generally requires renegotiation and, where appropriate, compensation under Article XXVIII of the GATT. I have spent enough time around Article XXVIII to know that it is not a provision most people meet voluntarily, but it is the mechanism that keeps concessions negotiated over decades from being withdrawn at will.</p><p>3. <strong>National treatment.</strong> Once imported goods have entered the market, they should not be treated less favourably than domestic goods through internal taxes or regulations.</p><p>4. <strong>Transparency.</strong> Members publish regulations, notify measures and submit to periodic Trade Policy Reviews. These are not examinations; they are structured occasions for governments to explain their policies and for others to ask questions.</p><p>5. <strong>Substantive agreements</strong> covering services, intellectual property, subsidies, technical regulations, sanitary and phytosanitary measures, trade facilitation, customs valuation and government procurement. Some bind the whole membership; others, such as the Government Procurement Agreement, bind only those that have accepted them.</p><p>6. <strong>Dispute settlement</strong>, the component most often associated with the organization, though only one part of its work, and currently an impaired one: panels still operate, but the Appellate Body has not heard an appeal since December 2019.</p><p>The WTO does not set national tariffs. Governments do. The distinction between an applied and a bound tariff illustrates the point. A government may charge 10 percent while having committed not to exceed 30. The gap is not an instruction to raise the tariff; it is room for manoeuvre the government has kept, and a ceiling its trading partners can rely upon. India, for example, has wide gaps between applied and bound rates in several agricultural categories. That is why abolishing bindings would not automatically raise tariffs everywhere. Some governments might lower them, others might raise them, and the uncertainty would be part of the cost.</p><p>The WTO’s latest analysis, with tariff measures taken into account up to the end of July 2026, estimates that about 72 percent of world merchandise trade still takes place on MFN terms, down from just over 80 percent at the start of 2025. The 72 percent is made up of roughly 47 percent on MFN duty-free terms, about 21 percent on dutiable MFN terms, and about 4 percent that was eligible for preferences but entered under MFN rates. The decline reflects the increase in tariff actions since 2025.</p><p>These figures need care. They describe how merchandise trade is currently treated for tariff purposes. They do not say that 72 percent of trade would disappear without the WTO, and they do not show that every MFN transaction depends solely on the organization. They do show how much of present-day trade still runs on the common framework.</p><h3>V. Two Historical Baselines</h3><p>Anyone writing on this subject is expected to mention the 1930s, and I will, though I think the more useful comparison is a different one.</p><p>The Smoot-Hawley Tariff Act of 1930 raised American duties across a wide range of products; trading partners retaliated, and world trade fell by roughly two-thirds in value between 1929 and 1934. Tariffs were one cause among several; deflation, the collapse of demand and the contraction of credit were operating at the same time, and economic historians still debate the weighting. What is less disputed is the political aftermath. Britain adopted imperial preference after the Ottawa Conference of 1932. Germany built bilateral clearing arrangements that tied partners, especially in southeastern Europe, into payment relationships on terms Berlin set. Currency blocs formed around sterling, the dollar and gold. Trade was organized around political alignment.</p><p>The United States began to reverse course with the Reciprocal Trade Agreements Act of 1934. Cordell Hull, the principal architect of that programme, believed that commercial discrimination contributed to international conflict, and that view influenced the officials who designed the postwar order, including the GATT and the unsuccessful International Trade Organization.</p><p>I would not expect a world without the WTO to replay the Depression. Production networks are far more integrated than in 1930, with components crossing borders several times before reaching a final product. The web of preferential agreements is also much denser. The more relevant comparison is the period from the 1970s to the early 1990s, when the GATT existed but its dispute settlement was weak enough that a party facing an adverse panel report could block its adoption, and major economies managed disagreements through negotiated restrictions. Japanese automobile exports to the United States were subject to voluntary export restraints in the 1980s. Steel trade was repeatedly managed through negotiated arrangements. The Multifibre Arrangement allocated much of the world’s textile and clothing trade through bilateral quotas, a system that outlived the Uruguay Round and ended only in 2005. That period was not an institutional vacuum: the GATT supplied a multilateral framework, tariff bindings and a standing forum throughout. What it lacked was enforcement strong enough to discipline the largest players. I do not suggest that a world without the WTO would recreate those particular instruments, since governments now have different tools and supply chains, services and digital trade have changed the context. The period is better read as an illustration of mechanisms than as a template.</p><p>Those arrangements were not irrational from the point of view of the governments that made them. They gave relief to politically influential industries and avoided broader retaliation. But they moved influence from general rules to the officials who negotiated the arrangements. A producer under a quota regime had to ask not only whether its product was competitive but whether it would be allowed to sell it, and the allocation of quota rights became an asset in its own right. The Uruguay Round was meant to move away from that model, with panel reports that are adopted unless there is a consensus to reject them, and with broader commitments from developing countries in return.</p><p>The lesson I take from both periods is a modest one. The absence of multilateral discipline does not end trade. It changes the terms on which market access is obtained, and it gives more weight to the relative bargaining power of the parties.</p><h3>VI. What Would Go, What Would Stay, and For How Long</h3><p>The first thing to say about the morning after is that very little would change on the surface. Customs declarations would still be filed under the Harmonized System, which is maintained by the World Customs Organization. Importers would still pay the applied tariffs written into national law. Regulators would still enforce the technical and sanitary rules already on their books. A government that wanted to raise a duty would still need a domestic legal basis for doing so, and legislatures, courts and administrative procedures would still operate. The lights would go out at the Rappard, not at the port of Rotterdam.</p><p>What disappears at once is the layer of obligations that governments owe one another under the Marrakesh Agreement: the bound ceilings, the MFN and national-treatment commitments, the right to challenge a measure in a panel, and the committees, notifications and Trade Policy Reviews through which members watch one another. What persists, at least initially, is everything that lives in domestic law or in bilateral and regional treaties.</p><p>The useful question is therefore how long the persistent layer would last once the multilateral layer above it was gone. The table below is my judgement, based on how these instruments work and on the GATT-era experience. It is not a forecast with a probability attached, and the time horizons are illustrative scenarios, not predicted deadlines. The rows also differ in kind: the day-one column follows almost mechanically from the scenario, whereas the later columns are judgements about political behaviour, and they would not move at the same speed in every sector.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/832/1*ieUt6Uo-eIwIphmwYOsYEQ.png" /></figure><h3>Sanitary, phytosanitary and technical standards</h3><p>The case of SPS and TBT measures deserves a closer look, because it shows how persistence and erosion can coexist.</p><p>What remains: the regulations themselves. A food-safety rule, a labelling requirement or a product standard is domestic law, and it stays in force until the domestic authority changes it. International standard-setters also remain. The Codex Alimentarius Commission, the International Plant Protection Convention, the World Organisation for Animal Health, the International Organization for Standardization and the International Electrotechnical Commission are separate bodies, and national regulators have good operational reasons to keep using their standards, because manufacturers do not want to produce a different product for every market. Many bilateral and regional agreements also contain their own SPS and TBT chapters, and mutual recognition and equivalence arrangements between regulators operate independently of the WTO.</p><p>What goes: the obligations. Under the SPS Agreement a member must base its measures on scientific evidence and risk assessment and may not use them as disguised restrictions on trade. Under the TBT Agreement a member must not discriminate and must not create unnecessary obstacles. Both agreements also require notification of draft measures, and the committees provide a place to raise “specific trade concerns” before a measure is finalized. Without the agreements, an exporter whose product was blocked by a new regulation would have no multilateral standard to invoke and no committee in which to raise it.</p><p>How long: for existing measures, essentially indefinitely, because nobody repeals a functioning regulation merely because the treaty obligation behind it lapsed. The erosion would show up in new measures. In the first year or two I would expect regulators to carry on out of habit, since their internal procedures, public consultations and relationships with foreign counterparts are domestic and take time to change. The first visible effects would come with the next significant food-safety scare, animal disease outbreak or labelling initiative, when a government would be free to respond without having to demonstrate to its trading partners that its response was scientifically justified or the least trade-restrictive option. Domestic law, regional agreements and the scrutiny of its own courts and legislature might still require something of the kind, and careful regulators would probably keep doing it, but the obligation would no longer be owed to anyone abroad. By year five, I would expect noticeable divergence in sectors with no applicable regional agreement, and gradual abandonment not through repeal but through failure to update: new rules would be written for the domestic market and its main partners, with less attention to alignment elsewhere. What would be lost first is transparency, since notifying a draft regulation is a courtesy once nothing requires it, and the loss of advance notice would hurt small exporters most.</p><p>There is a legal wrinkle that lawyers would spend years on. Many regional agreements incorporate WTO agreements by reference, for example by stating that the parties affirm their SPS rights and obligations under the SPS Agreement. Whether such a reference would be read as frozen at the date the WTO ended, as lapsing, or as continuing to bind the parties as a matter of the regional agreement’s own terms is a question the drafters did not expect to answer.</p><p>The same logic, with different timelines, applies elsewhere. Applied tariff rates would survive as national customs law, but the ceilings above them would no longer bind anyone. Anti-dumping, countervailing and safeguard statutes would remain on the books, and the WTO disciplines on how they are used would be gone. Patent terms, copyright rules and trademark protection are in domestic statutes and WIPO treaties and would not be repealed, but the multilateral link between intellectual property standards and trade access would break, and the flexibilities recognized in the 2001 Doha Declaration on TRIPS and public health, which are guidance on how to read an agreement that would no longer exist, would survive only as options in national law and in whatever terms bilateral partners agreed.</p><h3>VII. The First Year, and the Years After</h3><p>The first year would probably be remembered as an anticlimax. Shipping lines would honour their contracts. Container ships do not read treaties. Most tariffs would be what they were the day before.</p><p>The first real change would be in how businesses assess risk. A company deciding where to build a plant it expects to run for fifteen years is estimating the commercial conditions that will apply over the life of the investment, and a binding tariff ceiling reduces the range of outcomes it has to consider. Without it, the possibility that a government could raise tariffs substantially after the investment was made would have to be priced in. The effect would not show up first in trade statistics. It would show up in projects postponed, plans revised, and plants built elsewhere. This is a mechanism, not an automatic result. Businesses that depend on imported inputs would lobby against higher tariffs, domestic law and regional treaties would keep some commitments in place, and governments uneasy about the uncertainty might negotiate new agreements or simply keep their tariffs low. I would put more weight on the direction of the effect than on its size, and least of all on its timing.</p><p>The second change would concern retaliation. Under the WTO, a member that raises tariffs above its commitments may face a dispute, and although the system is imperfect, an agreed procedure exists for deciding whether a measure is consistent with the commitments. Without that procedure, the response would depend more directly on the parties’ respective leverage.</p><p>This is not wholly hypothetical. The Appellate Body has been unable to hear appeals since December 2019, and some members have used the Multi-Party Interim Appeal Arbitration Arrangement while others have appealed “into the void” or let disputes lapse. The organization has already lived through years in which dispute settlement did not work as designed.</p><p>It has also been a period in which the importance of domestic legal constraints has become clearer. On 20 February 2026, in <em>Learning Resources, Inc. v. Trump</em>, the U.S. Supreme Court held by a vote of six to three that the International Emergency Economic Powers Act does not authorize the President to impose tariffs. The ruling concerned one statutory basis and left other tariff authorities available, and the administration moved to rely on them. The case shows that national courts can and do limit trade measures. It also shows the limits of that check: a court asks whether the executive had the authority under domestic law, and it does not ask whether the resulting tariff is consistent with the country’s international commitments. In a world without the WTO the two questions would be fully separated, and a measure could be entirely lawful at home while imposing costs on trading partners who had no means of contesting it.</p><p>The third change would be in the vocabulary of negotiation. Today, governments that depart from the common framework are generally expected to explain the departure by reference to an exception or to another member’s alleged violation. Without that framework, every negotiation would begin with a more basic question: what, exactly, is the other side entitled to ask for?</p><h3>VIII. Power Without a Referee</h3><p>The history of the dispute settlement system shows what a legal entitlement can mean to a member without much economic weight.</p><p>In the <em>US — Underwear</em> case, Costa Rica challenged a transitional safeguard that the United States had imposed on cotton and man-made fibre underwear. Costa Rica filed in 1995, and the Appellate Body ruled in its favour in 1997. A small exporter had obtained a ruling against a measure of its largest market.</p><p>Brazil’s dispute with the United States over cotton subsidies ran for more than a decade. Brazil won on important points, obtained authorization to retaliate, and the dispute ended in a settlement in 2014. The long-running banana dispute, which involved several Latin American countries and the United States against the European Union’s import regime, was resolved through agreements concluded in Geneva in 2009.</p><p>Antigua and Barbuda prevailed against the United States on measures affecting cross-border gambling services and was authorized to suspend certain intellectual property obligations. The remedy was hard to use in practice, given the difference in scale between the parties. That case shows both the strength and the limit of the system: the WTO can establish an entitlement, but it cannot give a small economy the leverage of a large one. Even so, the entitlement mattered. It meant the question was not simply whether Washington was willing to accommodate a small Caribbean state. A ruling, an authorization to retaliate, implementation of the ruling and actual economic relief are four different outcomes, and the system delivers them unevenly. My claim is therefore not that the WTO equalizes power. It is that it reduces the extent to which outcomes depend on power alone.</p><p>Without the WTO, cases of this kind would be handled through diplomacy, domestic procedures and whatever bilateral arrangements existed. Some would be resolved amicably. Others would sit unresolved for years, and outcomes would depend more directly on the costs each side could impose on the other. Rick Blaine’s Café Américain in <em>Casablanca</em> is a place where people negotiate passage through a world in which permits and connections determine who may move. Trade restrictions can produce a version of that situation, in which the commercial value of a product depends partly on who controls access to the market and what is asked in return. A rule can be invoked by a government that has no special relationship with the one granting it, whereas a favour has to be requested.</p><h3>IX. Fragmentation, Hubs and Spokes</h3><p>The usual prediction is that the world would divide into three or four trading blocs. That seems to me too tidy.</p><p>Hundreds of preferential agreements are in force, among them the EU single market, the USMCA, the CPTPP, the RCEP, Mercosur and the African Continental Free Trade Area. These are separate legal instruments and would not terminate automatically. Their legal validity would not depend on the WTO, and many contain their own obligations and dispute settlement. But parts of their content do depend on it: their provisions often refer to WTO agreements, use WTO definitions, incorporate WTO obligations or rely on concepts developed through the multilateral system. A reference to a WTO agreement would not necessarily become ineffective because the institution disappeared; whether it was read as frozen, as lapsed or as continuing under the regional agreement’s own terms would have to be worked out. Agreements with independent obligations would continue with little disruption, while those that lean on WTO cross-references, definitions or institutions would need clarification, revision or renegotiation.</p><p>Without the MFN baseline, governments would have more freedom to give different partners different terms and less reason to preserve a common floor. The resulting structure might resemble hubs and spokes rather than coherent blocs. A large economy could negotiate separately with each of a series of smaller partners, with terms reflecting the value of access to its market, the importance of the partner’s exports, and whatever political or strategic considerations it chose to add. The hubs would generally have the larger markets, the greater fiscal capacity and more of the leverage, although a spoke that supplied a critical input, or whose exports a hub’s industries could not easily replace, would hold more than its size suggests. Most spokes would have fewer alternatives, particularly where their industries were integrated into one hub’s supply chains.</p><p>The coalitions that have formed inside the WTO, such as the G-33, the African Group, the G-90 and the Cairns Group, would lose their main arena. Their influence has never rested only on the combined economic weight of their members. It comes from being able to organize proposals, negotiate texts and participate in a forum where decisions require broad support. The groups could still meet, but they would have fewer opportunities to turn a common position into commitments from larger economies.</p><p>Mexico illustrates the position of a middle economy. It has an extensive network of trade agreements and a manufacturing sector deeply integrated into North American supply chains, and the USMCA, which has its own periodic joint review, would remain the central framework. Mexico would not be starting from zero. But its position would depend even more heavily on the stability of its relationship with the United States, because the WTO gives Mexico a second forum in which it can invoke rights that do not depend on the terms of any one bilateral negotiation. The loss would not necessarily appear in the first year’s trade volumes. It would appear in the options available to Mexico the next time there was a disagreement.</p><p>The largest economies would be affected differently. The United States would have substantial room to act, given its market size and the statutory authorities available to the executive, but its exporters benefit from other members’ bindings and non-discrimination obligations, and its partners would have stronger incentives to reduce their dependence on the American market. China would still have enormous manufacturing capacity and a large domestic market, but its exporters would face greater uncertainty in markets where their access rested on WTO commitments. The European Union would have considerable leverage through its market and its regulatory influence, but as a major exporter it depends on predictable foreign access and would have to handle more disputes bilaterally. India would gain policy space where its applied tariffs are well below its bindings, while its services exports would be exposed to the regulatory choices of its partners. For other economies such as Japan, Korea, Brazil, Turkey and Indonesia, the central question would be how to keep access to major markets without becoming dependent on any one of them, and maintaining several relationships at once takes considerable negotiating capacity.</p><h3>X. Sectors, Winners and Losers</h3><p><strong>Agriculture.</strong> The Agreement on Agriculture has been criticized for preserving the advantages of wealthy subsidizers, and the criticism is justified in important respects. Still, it provides disciplines on domestic support, export competition and market access, and it gives exporters a legal basis for challenging measures that exceed commitments. Without it, support for farmers would depend more heavily on fiscal capacity. The EU, the United States, China, India and Japan could continue to support their producers, and countries with smaller budgets could not match them. Efficient exporters such as Brazil, Argentina, Australia, Uruguay and Thailand would keep their production advantages but would have fewer grounds for challenging competitors’ support.</p><p><strong>Services and digital trade.</strong> The GATS was negotiated long before cloud computing, artificial intelligence, quantum computing and cross-border data flows. It nevertheless provides a framework of commitments in telecommunications, banking, transport and professional services. Without it, access to services markets would depend more heavily on regional and bilateral agreements and on domestic law. Digital trade already shows how fragmentation and cooperation can coexist. At Yaoundé, ministers could not agree to extend the e-commerce moratorium, which lapsed in late March 2026, and at the same time a group of 66 members (67 by June) adopted a pathway to bring the Agreement on Electronic Commerce into effect among themselves, including a commitment not to impose duties on electronic transmissions. The United States did not join that arrangement, but one account attributes this to a wish to preserve domestic regulatory freedom, and Washington has pursued a separate statement on the duty moratorium with a group of like-minded members. The lapse does not mean duties were immediately imposed on digital transmissions, and the interim agreement does not cover the whole membership. In a world without the WTO, there would be no common institution in which to reconcile the two.</p><p><strong>Intellectual property.</strong> The effects would be mixed. TRIPS is among the most contested WTO agreements, and some governments would welcome its disappearance. But countries seeking access to a large market might then be asked to accept obligations beyond TRIPS, negotiated from a weaker position. The agreement that critics said imposed excessive demands could be replaced by bilateral agreements that impose more.</p><p><strong>Government procurement.</strong> The Agreement on Government Procurement, which the WTO estimates opens procurement markets worth about $1.7 trillion annually to suppliers from the participating parties, is plurilateral and would not leave procurement markets closed. The parties could replicate it in a separate treaty, but that would require negotiating institutions, schedules and enforcement. Anyone who has worked on a procurement negotiation knows that the details (entities, thresholds, exceptions, offsets, procedures) are harder than the political announcement.</p><p><strong>Winners.</strong> Large economies with fiscal capacity and strategic leverage would gain freedom to use subsidies and industrial policy and to treat market access as a bargaining instrument. Freedom of action is not the same as net benefit: a large economy that subsidizes an industry or taxes imported inputs also charges its own consumers and the downstream firms that use those inputs. What the largest economies would gain is discretion and leverage. Whether that became an economic gain would depend on how they used it. Protected domestic industries would find it easier to obtain restrictions. Countries holding critical minerals or other hard-to-replace inputs could improve their bargaining positions, though this applies only to those with real chokepoints. Trade lawyers, consultants and customs specialists would have more work. For professionals like me that is a silver lining of sorts, but I record it without enthusiasm, since more legal work for the same transaction is not a sign of a healthier system.</p><p><strong>Losers.</strong> Small open economies such as Singapore, Switzerland, Ireland, Uruguay, Costa Rica and New Zealand have built their prosperity on reliable access to foreign markets and cannot offer the commercial inducements of a large economy. Least-developed countries would see changes in the framework behind non-reciprocal preferences. The Enabling Clause provides legal cover for preferential schemes, though schemes such as the EU’s Everything But Arms are autonomous instruments and would not lapse automatically. Governments could, however, review or recondition them. Bangladesh and Cambodia, whose garment industries developed within a system shaped by preferential access, would be especially exposed. Small and medium-sized enterprises would bear a disproportionate administrative burden: a large multinational has compliance departments and can reorganize supply chains, while a mid-sized exporter on narrow margins may find that new documentation requirements and clearance uncertainty decide whether an export is viable. Consumers would experience the effects gradually, through prices and reduced choice, and lower-income households, which spend more of their income on food, clothing and basic goods, would bear more of it.</p><p>The sustainability agenda would be affected too. The Agreement on Fisheries Subsidies, which entered into force in September 2025, would lose its institutional home, though its parties could try to preserve it elsewhere. More broadly, carbon border measures and green subsidies could become instruments of bilateral competition rather than subjects of coordinated negotiation, which might produce more regulation but with less coordination.</p><h3>XI. What Would Survive, and What Might Replace It</h3><p>The Harmonized System would continue to classify goods. ISO, IEC, Codex and the IPPC would continue to produce standards. The International Monetary Fund would continue to monitor exchange rates and balance-of-payments developments, bilateral investment treaties would stay in force according to their terms, and the International Chamber of Commerce would continue to maintain Incoterms and the rules for documentary credits. Regional institutions would continue to operate.</p><p>These institutions provide much of the technical infrastructure of trade. They do not reproduce the WTO’s tariff bindings, non-discrimination commitments, transparency obligations and dispute settlement. Knowing how to classify a product does not establish the maximum tariff that can be imposed on it, and knowing how to test it does not settle whether a technical regulation is consistent with a trade commitment.</p><p>A successor might well emerge in time, though not necessarily looking like the WTO. That is a conjecture, not a law of history, and the obvious question is why the largest economies would bother. The answer I find most plausible is that managing hundreds of bilateral relationships is costly for them too, and that exporters and investors would press for a common framework, as they did after the 1930s. But the political conflicts that ended the WTO would not disappear with it, and a successor could take a decade or more. Geneva has seen this film before: the League of Nations dissolved in 1946, and its Palais des Nations passed to the United Nations. The postwar trade precedent is instructive. The Havana Charter of 1948 would have created an International Trade Organization, but the United States did not pursue ratification, and the GATT, which was meant to be provisional, governed much of world trade for nearly half a century. A group of willing members could similarly build a smaller structure, perhaps covering goods, services and digital trade first and leaving the harder subjects for later. Its membership would depend on the major economies, and its rules would reflect the priorities of those who drafted them.</p><p>The harder thing to rebuild is institutional knowledge. The secretariat holds schedules, notifications, panel reports and negotiating records. Delegations carry practical knowledge of procedure, drafting conventions and the history of individual commitments. The comparison I find most apt is the kitchen brigade in <em>The Bear</em>: recipes can be written down, and a kitchen can be rebuilt, but the operation also depends on people who know how the stations fit together and can spot a problem before it reaches the pass. I have watched negotiations stall over procedural questions that looked minor to outsiders, and the way forward sometimes depended on a chair or an experienced delegate who knew the history of the issue. That knowledge would not vanish, as the people would still be working in governments and elsewhere, but the setting through which it is passed on would be disrupted.</p><h3>XII. The Strongest Argument on the Other Side</h3><p>There is a serious argument against the pessimistic reading, and it deserves a fair statement. Perhaps the disappearance of the WTO would produce a more flexible, and in some ways more cooperative, system.</p><p>The organization has struggled to conclude large multilateral negotiations. Members disagree about special and differential treatment, industrial subsidies, the role of consensus and the relationship between trade and national security. A new institution could avoid some of that. A smaller group could negotiate faster, agreements could be tailored to sectors, and members unwilling to accept particular obligations could stay out while the rest proceed. The interim e-commerce agreement shows that cooperation does not require every member to join every initiative. There is also a respectable view that some WTO rules limit choices governments should be entitled to make, on subsidies, on industrial policy, and on the relationship between intellectual property and public health.</p><p>The strongest version of the argument goes further. Predictability, it says, does not need a universal institution. Exporters would lobby against tariffs on their inputs, courts would constrain executives, the largest regional agreements carry their own dispute mechanisms, and governments that depend on one another’s markets would have reasons to keep their word. I think this is largely right as far as existing trade in well-organized sectors is concerned. It is much less reassuring for the new entrant, the exporter without a lobby or the investor looking fifteen years ahead, and it is weakest when a government’s priorities shift, toward economic security for instance, and the cost of keeping a commitment suddenly rises. These protections hold while interests align. A common framework matters most when they do not.</p><p>The difficulty is that flexibility is worth less to a government negotiating with a much larger economy than to one dealing with a partner of similar size. A small group can move faster partly because it excludes those who disagree, and a bilateral agreement can be more detailed because the parties exchange concessions, but neither feature guarantees balanced terms. The real question is whether a more flexible system would preserve meaningful rights for countries that lack the leverage to secure them individually. The WTO has not eliminated unequal bargaining power. It has given that power a setting in which it operates alongside agreed commitments and collective procedures.</p><p>The disappearance of the WTO might therefore not end multilateralism. It might begin a more selective form of it, whose benefits would depend on who was invited, which obligations were kept and what happened to those left outside.</p><h3>XIII. Conclusion</h3><p>The WTO was never meant to deliver free trade in an absolute sense. Its purpose is to give governments a framework in which they can make commitments, explain their policies and resolve disagreements without renegotiating the entire relationship each time a dispute arises. Its rules do not remove politics. They provide a setting in which political decisions can be measured against obligations that governments have accepted. The WTO is not necessary for any given transaction to take place. What it provides is a common framework that reduces the uncertainty surrounding what governments will do next.</p><p>If it ceased to exist, trade would continue, and most existing arrangements would persist for some time, because they sit in national law and in bilateral and regional treaties. The tariff schedules, customs codes, sanitary and technical regulations, intellectual property statutes and procurement rules would remain in force on the first day and for years afterwards. What would go is the shared set of commitments above them: the ceilings, the non-discrimination obligations, the disciplines on new measures, the transparency requirements and the forum for dispute settlement. The effects would accumulate slowly, through investment decisions, new regulations, disputes and the terms offered to countries seeking access to large markets. In effect, discretion and bargaining leverage would shift toward the largest economies, while small open economies, low-income exporters and smaller firms would carry much of the uncertainty. What that meant in practice would depend on how governments used the room they had gained.</p><p>None of this is a forecast, and I hope it will not be tested. The WTO today is neither fully functioning as designed nor irrelevant. Its dispute settlement is impaired, its negotiating function is slow, and its members, the United States among them, are open about wanting reform. But they are engaged in that reform; they continue to negotiate within the organization and among groups of members, and about 72 percent of world merchandise trade still takes place on MFN terms.</p><p>I return to the building on the lake. Its value does not depend on every decision made inside it being wise or fair. It provides a place where governments can negotiate the conditions of trade, examine one another’s policies and invoke commitments that go beyond any single bilateral relationship, and the criticism it receives is best answered by improving it. The next time a small country challenges a major trading partner, it will have somewhere to do it, and a world without the WTO would not.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=29bbfbee1291" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Digger: Twenty-five years of madness, ambition and mastery finally distilled into one film.]]></title>
            <link>https://rivasrod.medium.com/digger-twenty-five-years-of-madness-ambition-and-mastery-finally-distilled-into-one-film-ac7a3b35378a?source=rss-c519b7f88399------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ac7a3b35378a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[film-reviews]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[filmmaking]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[film]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Rodolfo C. Rivas]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 01 Oct 2026 16:46:56 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-10-03T10:43:03.932Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*uWJeTmuQiliVfTRgbDWFLA@2x.jpeg" /></figure><p>I think I just saw a masterpiece.</p><p>I should be careful, because I know how that sounds after a single viewing. But Iñárritu may finally have done what I assumed he never would: made a film that holds its own against <em>Amores Perros</em>.</p><p>I still remember coming out of <em>Amores Perros</em> asking where on earth this guy had come from (from Mexico!). It had the energy of a director who had arrived fully formed: raw, violent, funny, sad, chaotic and, under all that noise, very carefully built. Twenty-five years later, sitting through <em>Digger</em>, I had the odd sensation of looking at the other end of the same road.</p><p><em>Digger</em> feels like everything he has learned, and a few things that nearly sank him, thrown into one enormous and slightly deranged machine. The fractured lives of <em>Amores Perros</em>, <em>21 Grams</em> and <em>Babel</em> are there. So are the bleakness of <em>Biutiful</em>, the theatrical lunacy of <em>Birdman</em>, the physical stubbornness of <em>The Revenant</em> and the dream-inside-a-dream logic of <em>Bardo</em>. What has changed is that the ingredients finally work together.</p><p>Of the three amigos, Iñárritu has never been my favourite. There, I’ve said it. I lean more naturally towards del Toro and Cuarón. Iñárritu can be a demanding creator, and his films are not always pleasant to sit through. <em>Biutiful</em> drains you and goes straight for the stomach, and <em>Bardo</em> can feel like being locked inside someone else’s dream at three in the morning. But the talent is ridiculous, and here he seems to have stopped apologizing for any of it (eventhough I don’t think he was ever apologizing). This is a man enjoying himself, properly enjoying himself.</p><p>Tom Cruise is a large part of that. After so many years of watching him sprint across the world as Ethan Hunt, it is easy to forget there is a great actor underneath the movie star, and <em>Digger</em> reminds us. What he does here is bonkers, yet there is real precision under the madness. He is funny, grotesque, charismatic, pathetic, terrifying and, somehow, vulnerable. Just when you think you have worked out what he is up to, the film rearranges the furniture.</p><p>It isn’t only Cruise. The whole cast seems to have received the same note: go for it, but don’t lose the human being. John Goodman, Riz Ahmed, Sandra Hüller and Michael Stuhlbarg each play in a slightly different key, and Iñárritu conducts them without letting the thing collapse into noise.</p><p>Then there is the filmmaking. Chivo is back, and Lubezki seems to be having a mid-career crisis in the best possible sense. The photography is spectacular without shouting “look at me”, and there is so much happening inside the frame that I suspect I missed half of it. The music is wonderfully strange and the production design is insane. Costume, makeup, editing and framing all feel tactile and handmade, at a time when so much big-budget cinema feels assembled by committee.</p><p>But the screenplay is where I think <em>Digger</em> is its biggest gamble and its most succesful. It has layers, and more layers beneath those. You laugh at something and realize five minutes later that you probably weren’t meant to. A character seems to be one thing and turns out to be another. A scene that first looks absurd quietly takes on a different meaning. I already know I need to see it again, probably more than once, which is usually a good sign.</p><p>Some films you watch, enjoy and forget. Some you talk about all the way home. And a few are dangerous: they follow you around for days while you try to work out what the director was actually doing. <em>Digger</em> is one of those.</p><p>It will also divide people. I can already hear the words: excessive, pretentious, indulgent, too much. Fair enough, but I have a soft spot for films that are too much. <em>Babylon</em> is a recent example, a glorious excess that some people simply could not get into. <em>Eyes Wide Shut</em> was treated with suspicion for years. <em>The Shining</em> was not immediately embraced as the masterpiece we now take it for, and <em>2001: A Space Odyssey</em> did not arrive as a universally understood revelation. Sometimes a film has to find its audience, and sometimes the audience has to catch up.</p><p>I am not claiming <em>Digger</em> is <em>The Godfather</em> or <em>2001: A Space Odyssey</em>. That is not for me to say, and it is far too early. But I would not be surprised if, in ten or twenty years, people look back at this strange, extravagant, thoroughly crazy film and say: of course. Beneath the madness something remarkably coherent and thought-provoking is going on. It feels like a filmmaker taking twenty-five years of lessons, shrugging and putting every one of them in: the ambition of <em>Babel</em>, the darkness of <em>Biutiful</em>, the theatricality of <em>Birdman</em>, the physicality of <em>The Revenant</em>, the dream logic of <em>Bardo</em>, the raw nerve of <em>Amores Perros</em>. And then Tom Cruise, because why not.</p><p>I walked out with the slightly irritating feeling of having seen something I am not yet ready to explain, so I’ll stop there. Iñárritu may have made the film I never thought he would make, one that for me stands next to <em>Amores Perros</em> and perhaps even surpasses it.</p><p>A masterpiece. Now I need to watch it again.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ac7a3b35378a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Precise Miss Verhoeven]]></title>
            <link>https://rivasrod.medium.com/the-precise-miss-verhoeven-2475d2d0f943?source=rss-c519b7f88399------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2475d2d0f943</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[novel]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[creative-writing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[storytelling]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[profile]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[short-story]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Rodolfo C. Rivas]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 29 Sep 2026 13:29:05 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-09-29T14:09:51.348Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*fT3o0Bomnmyb7cBSau9m_w.png" /></figure><p><em>By Rodolfo C. Rivas</em></p><p>This piece was written to accompany <em>Just Past Midnight</em>, Rodolfo C. Rivas’s first novelette. It is not, strictly speaking, a character study of Mathilde Verhoeven. I have always had a weakness for written profiles of individuals who are interesting enough to warrant one, however, and Mathilde seemed a particularly good candidate. So, I decided to throw my hat over the wall and see what came back.</p><p>Readers of <em>Just Past Midnight</em> will recognize the watch, and perhaps a name or two. They may also notice that some of the people mentioned here seem to have a curious relationship with the people in the novelette. This is not an accident, although calling it an accident would probably make the paperwork considerably easier.</p><p>There is another small matter worth settling. Rodolfo and Diego are distinct characters. Entirely distinct. Any resemblance in their habits, opinions, or unfortunate proximity to the author is purely a matter of narrative convenience. If that sounds like a distinction that requires some explanation, then you have probably understood the point.</p><p>As for Mathilde, the simplest thing to say is that I found her fascinating and wanted to spend a little more time with her. Whether that means this is a profile, a prequel, an appendix, or merely an elaborate excuse to read or revisit <em>Just Past Midnight</em> is best left to the reader.</p><p>Until then, it can remain here as a companion to the story, and as evidence of what happened before Rivas thought to make any of it up.</p><p>Available here: https://amzn.eu/d/06VgumO5</p><p>—</p><p><em>On an inherited watch, a friendship nobody saw coming, and a woman who is very hard to lose track of.</em></p><p>The first thing I noticed about Mathilde Verhoeven was the watch.</p><p>This was not because I knew anything about watches at the time, beyond the vague understanding that some watches were expensive and some were not, and that the ones men became strangely emotional about tended to belong to the first category. Hers looked considerably too old and too masculine for the rest of her outfit: a heavy steel watch with the worn, slightly severe appearance of something that had been built for a purpose and had never quite recovered from taking that purpose seriously.</p><p>I did not ask her about it.</p><p>It would be months before I learned where it had come from, and considerably longer before I understood why I remembered it at all.</p><p>It was the ides of June, in the middle of one of those weeks that swallow a diplomat whole, all late nights and redrafted text and rooms that smell faintly of old coffee, that I had one of the only truly memorable evenings of that whole exhausting month. It had nothing whatsoever to do with any of it. It is said that once you have sat through enough weeks like that one, very little can surprise you anymore. Nevertheless, that particular week was different on several levels the Lord allowed. The most obvious difference was the stakes, which were as high as they get that season, and the whole world was watching, or at least those of us inside the Geneva bubble liked to imagine it was.</p><p>The other difference, considerably less important to the world but no less important to me, was a rare, unrelated conversation that had nothing to do with any of the craziness down the corridor: an evening with a recent acquaintance who moved in an entirely different Geneva, one built around a university rather than a conference room.</p><p>If this were a film, and it may very well become one someday, these two evenings would be woven together through parallel editing, à la the baptism scene in Francis Ford Coppola’s magnum opus <em>The Godfather</em> (1972), sharpening the contrast in tone even though both scenes carried a version of high stakes. Or maybe I have simply spent too many years mistaking my own life for a movie.</p><p>Looking back, many things about that week are a blur. I was at the tail end of a string of long working weeks, and although we both knew it did not come close to more essential work, like that of health professionals during the worst of the pandemic, at the time it felt as near to war as diplomats are ever meant to get. Perhaps it was simply a rite of passage, and in that sense a time many diplomats will remember for a long while yet.</p><p>But this is a different story.</p><p>It was that same week that Mathilde Verhoeven first ran me through one of her own questionnaires, the kind she officially disapproves of on professional grounds and privately cannot resist using on her friends.</p><p>“You test as someone who needs the story to make sense more than he needs the story to be true,” she told me, reading the result off her phone with the seriousness usually reserved for a coroner’s report, having built the whole thing herself as a joke that had gotten, by her own admission, out of hand over several years of tinkering. She then spent a further ten minutes explaining, unprompted, everything wrong with the entire field of personality typing, while still clearly enjoying every second of having just typed me.</p><p>Sometime in the year 2000, Victor Burgin, a British conceptual artist of some renown, delivered a lecture in which he mentioned, somewhat in passing, the concept of <em>après coup</em>: something that hits you hard, long after the event, something that did not mean very much at the time but later in retrospect becomes very influential.</p><p>The term carries a note of trauma in its Freudian sense that does not quite belong here. But there is little doubt in my mind that the story of a lost watch, told to me that same June, falls squarely within what Mr. Burgin described as <em>après coup</em>, inasmuch as it relates to a friendship I did not see coming.</p><p>How many new friends can you make as an adult? I have thought about this a lot lately. Of course, when you are young, you make new friends all the time, but as you get older this number starts to dwindle. Before then, I did not think about this much. I was content with my dwindling friendships. But an unexpected friendship flourished from precisely where I least expected it.</p><p>This is a version of that story.</p><p>But mainly, it is a version of Mathilde’s story.</p><p><strong>The person</strong></p><p>I met her only that same spring, a few months before that June, at one of the newer places at the forefront of what passes, in Geneva, for a food revolution, introduced by a mutual friend whose good taste in guests I am still trying to repay. Before then there were vanishingly few places in this city to have a decent meal, and we are still not spoiled for options now, a fact my friends abroad remind me of constantly, though it is at least possible to eat well at something like a reasonable price.</p><p>We talked about Salinger and Sally Rooney that night, mostly, since it turned out to be the one subject we both have a strong interest in. I remember very little else of that conversation.</p><p>What I remember clearly is that a couple of weeks later she insisted I try a bakery near Plainpalais that, by her account, made the only correct almond croissant left in this city, a claim delivered with the total seriousness of an academic defending a dissertation.</p><p>I told her that every bakery in this city makes exactly the same claim.</p><p>She told me, without a flicker of doubt, that the others were simply wrong, and ordered two for us before I had finished making my case.</p><p>What she liked about the place had little to do with sophistication and more to do with a grudge she had held for years against a different bakery two streets over that had, in her telling, once shortchanged her on a single croissant and never apologized. She is not, by inclination, much of a food lover, though she appreciates a good meal. She approaches most meals the way people approach a logistical problem rather than an experience, and I suspect she would be quietly appalled by anyone who described her otherwise.</p><p>She would later tell me that even with all the good bakeries Geneva has slowly acquired, she still walks the extra ten minutes for that particular one, because a good almond croissant is, in her words, an argument settled.</p><p>Her sensibilities, more generally, run closer to a certain Northern European melancholy than to anything fashionable: David Bowie’s Berlin years, an old Charles Trenet record drifting from somebody’s open window, a grandfather who insisted that everything worthwhile happens in cafés and could never be argued out of it.</p><p>I do not recall her drinking anything stronger than coffee the first weeks I knew her. These days, if we repeated that same outing, there is a decent chance we would end up next door afterward over a genever instead, in her grandfather’s honor, though she would deny the sentimentality of it immediately and completely.</p><p>Perhaps an <em>après coup</em> can be represented in various sequential events. If so, this is another one.</p><p>As we walked back from that first dinner, I asked Mathilde, entirely in jest, which of her namesake’s films she liked best.</p><p>Let me provide some context. Back then, I used to think that everybody ought to have opinions about the filmography of anyone who happened to share their surname, which is an unreasonable thing to expect of anyone, and an especially unreasonable thing to expect of a woman whose surname simply happened, by coincidence, to belong to a well-known Dutch director who had made a name for himself in 1990s Hollywood.</p><p>She likes films, more than most, and even had a favourite film, but she seemed wholly uninterested in discussing Paul Verhoeven’s filmography. She said she had seen exactly one of his films, by accident, on a plane, and had disliked it for reasons that had nothing to do with the film itself and everything to do with the seat in front of her failing to recline properly.</p><p>She appeared, in other words, not to care in the slightest.</p><p>I found this briefly disappointing.</p><p>I only later realized I had been premature in holding that particular blind spot against her. She may not care for her own namesake’s work, but she is far more genuinely curious about the world than that one indifferent answer suggested, and she proved it to me only a few weeks later, in a way I did not expect.</p><p>We had gone together to a colleague’s retirement lunch, more out of obligation than enthusiasm on either side, and somewhere in the middle of an interminable slideshow of photographs that had nothing whatsoever to do with either of us, I noticed she had gone quiet in a different way than her usual quiet.</p><p>She was crying, carefully, and blaming the room for being too warm, and I let her have the excuse, because it seemed like the least I could do, and because I had the distinct sense I was not meant to have noticed at all. There is a long thread tying everything together. After all, there is no great distance between an artist who reinvented himself every few years, out of what he later admitted was closer to terror than courage, and a woman who has rebuilt her own address book with something like the same regularity, without, as far as I can tell, ever quite losing herself in the process.</p><p>I am starting to believe that Mathilde is herself a study in reinvention that has, so far, managed to outrun her own research on the subject.</p><p>She is, professionally, a very good researcher working in a field that studies exactly the kind of certainty most people crave and cannot have, which is not how she defies convention, although there is an argument that this counts as one of the ways she does it. The truth is she defied it by choosing the one path in her family that came with no guarantees at all: an academic career assembled one grant at a time, in a field with a name vague enough that she jokes it exists mainly to make the funding applications easier, while people quieter than her settled into steadier things around her.</p><p>Staying safe would have been the easier road.</p><p>That was never going to be her way.</p><p>Let us get one thing out of the way. Mathilde has no real interest in being a style icon, and would find the label mildly insulting if I applied it to her directly, which is precisely why I am doing so here.</p><p>She wears the same long red coat through every season it can plausibly justify, carries running shoes in one hand rather than wearing them anywhere serious, on principle, and ties her hair back badly enough that you suspect, correctly, she has never once checked the result in a mirror. This is less a style than a policy, and like most of her policies it is enforced without negotiation.</p><p>She inherited some of it, I think, from a grandfather who judged furniture with the severity most people reserve for actual crimes, and once declared an entire armchair morally weak.</p><p>She calls high heels a device invented by men who have never had to run for a departing tram, and carries herself, in professional settings, with what I have privately started calling the posture of someone perpetually three minutes from an uncomfortable meeting: upright, slightly impatient, already halfway out the door before it has properly begun.</p><p>The one exception to all of this indifference sits on her wrist: a heavy steel watch, decades older than she is, that she has never once let a repairer’s hands anywhere near without standing over the workbench herself.</p><p>It has since become something of a running joke among her circle to thank her for making trainers acceptable footwear at academic conferences, a trend she insists she never meant to start and has done absolutely nothing to discourage.</p><p>A conversation with Mathilde can go anywhere, which is one of her many talents.</p><p>She loves music, books, and design, in roughly that order, though her favourite author remains, somewhat surprisingly for a woman who studies the architecture of human error for a living, Agatha Christie, the British queen of crime and arguably the first genuinely modern literary celebrity.</p><p>Once, while we were discussing the human capacity for cruelty, she brought up <em>Evil Under the Sun</em>, one of the many stories built around Christie’s detective Hercule Poirot.</p><p>What prompted this particular conversation was my asking her what she thought was the most evil thing happening in Geneva at that exact moment.</p><p>Her reply came without hesitation: some adult telling a child they are not good enough.</p><p>She followed this almost immediately with the more conventional suggestion that some terrorist was probably also, somewhere, building a bomb, as though unsure I would take the first answer seriously enough on its own.</p><p>I found the first answer far more interesting than the second and told her so. She looked pleased in that particular way she does when someone agrees with an answer she had been slightly worried about giving. Once I asked what she might want as a gift, she told me, quite decisively, that she wanted all of Christie’s books beautifully bound, nothing more complicated than that.</p><p>Mathilde can talk about nearly anything.</p><p>Once she began discussing Charles Dickens entirely unprompted, admitting she believed she had read all of his novels, though some she had not particularly enjoyed, even as she conceded, in retrospect, that she was better for having read them, <em>A Tale of Two Cities</em> among them.</p><p>The character she always thinks of, she told me, is also a law clerk: Uriah Heep, from <em>David Copperfield</em>, whom she considers straightforwardly evil, adding that what frightens her most is the thought of not recognizing someone like him coming.</p><p>And then, within the space of a single breath, the conversation turned to pineapple on pizza, which she declared the single craziest thing that could possibly enter her mind.</p><p>She also holds strong and entirely unmovable opinions about doughnuts, chiefly that they must be fried, and no amount of argument on my part about the merits of a good baked version, or the ethics of the cronut, has ever moved her an inch.</p><p>We have spent, cumulatively, an unreasonable number of hours arguing about which era of David Bowie represents his true peak, Berlin against Ziggy, an argument neither of us has any intention of settling and both of us privately hope never gets resolved, since the argument itself has become the point.</p><p>Mathilde is also funny, very funny, though I do not think she always intends to be, which is the only kind of funny I fully trust.</p><p>She once called a chocolate croissant vulgar, with no further explanation offered or apparently required.</p><p>I asked her once in what language she dreams, and she answered that her dreams transcend language entirely, delivered with such total conviction that I did not think to question it until much later.</p><p>She can spend a genuine ten minutes in a stationery shop deciding between two nearly identical notebooks, on the grounds that the wrong one would somehow curse whatever she meant to use it for, and once left a shop assistant visibly reconsidering his career while trying to help her choose.</p><p>At a dinner I hosted not long after we met, I introduced her to a colleague who spent several minutes narrating, entirely unprompted, the plot of a film he had once optioned and never made.</p><p>When he finally paused for breath, Mathilde said only that this was the first time she had truly understood why people invented the exit.</p><p>He laughed for several seconds before realizing, from her expression, that she had not been joking, at which point he laughed considerably less.</p><p>I was once recounting how I hoped this profile might reach some prestigious magazine, naming <em>Vanity Fair</em> and then, unwisely, <em>Playboy</em>, and instantly regretting the second one for making me sound uncouth.</p><p>Her response was immediate, disarming, and gold.</p><p>“They have the best writers,” she said. “Everyone knows that. Like the sun coming up in the East.”</p><p>If you listen to her speak, her French comes fast and precise, delivered like a small weapon she has decided, for now, not to turn on you, though she reserves the right to do so at any moment. Underneath it, there is a particular way she says certain words that comes from growing up in a household split between two languages, French for the world outside and Dutch for her grandfather, and she pronounces her own name slightly differently depending on which language she happens to be answering to to everyone she meets. She has a reputation, by her own cheerful admission, for being considerably harder on the people who work alongside her than you are close enough to hear the small verbal tells that give away where she actually comes from, you have usually already stopped keeping score of the best of them, which was a relief to discover, since I also swear more than I probably should. The first time I did it in front of her I apologized immediately, out of some old reflex, and she assured me there was nothing to apologize for, since she curses whenever the situation calls at that moment, a distinction almost nobody else notices and which she has long since stopped bothering to correct.</p><p>She is not, particularly, kind to everyone she meets. She has a reputation, by her own cheerful admission, for being considerably harder on the people who work alongside her than on total strangers, on the theory that a stranger has not yet earned the effort of her full attention.</p><p>But by the time you are close enough to hear the small verbal tells that give away where she actually comes from, you have usually already stopped keeping score of the sharper edges, because you have found other things about her to like more.</p><p>She also has a way with words, as many researchers of cognition do. She thinks about them carefully and deploys them precisely.</p><p>She once complained that an entire dinner party had been missing <em>gezelligheid</em>, a Dutch word she then spent ten minutes trying, and largely failing, to translate for me, since the closest English approximations all understate it somehow.</p><p>This is not a word that comes up often in daily conversation, but daily conversation with Mathilde rarely resembles daily conversation with anyone else.</p><p>She can curse like the best of them, which was a relief to discover, since I also swear more than I probably should. The first time I did it in front of her I apologized immediately, out of some old reflex, and she assured me there was nothing to apologize for, since she curses whenever the situation calls for it.</p><p>I once watched her curse a parking meter outside a café with real venom, feeding it coins it kept rejecting, before giving up entirely and leaving a handwritten apology under the windshield wiper instead, addressed, with total sincerity, to whichever meter maid found the car first.</p><p>She once described a colleague as acting like a little bitch, and in all fairness to her, the colleague truly was.</p><p>She is, physically, more disciplined than almost anyone I know.</p><p>She runs before six most mornings, in weather that would make reasonable people reconsider their commitments, and calls it the only hour the city belongs to no one, which sounds like wisdom until you notice it is also a fairly dignified way of running from something, a description she arrived at herself, with more honesty than most people manage about anyone.</p><p>Twenty kilometers before breakfast counts, for her, as an ordinary day.</p><p>She once told me she started running young, stopped for a stretch after leaving home, and started again once she noticed how much better she felt pushing herself past what any sensible trainer would allow, which is why, by her own telling, she is more or less permanently and slightly injured.</p><p>She has broken at least one door, out of frustration rather than any athletic intention, and it isn’t hard to imagine she could have been a serious athlete in another life.</p><p>It is almost as if she was built for something specific and handed an ordinary job instead.</p><p>She physically resembles a couple of film actresses and could plausibly have been mistaken for minor European royalty, although she insists she is as much a commoner as I am.</p><p>A colleague of hers once told me that he had been asked, entirely sincerely, for the name of the beautiful woman who worked down the corridor from him.</p><p>That woman, of course, was Mathilde.</p><p>At certain angles and in certain light, she resembles a young Famke Janssen; once, in a particularly moody combination of light and circumstance that neither of us could quite name at the time, she reminded me of Jessica Paré.</p><p>Mathilde is one hundred and seventy-six centimeters tall, by her own declaration. I would have guessed taller, and so, apparently, would most people who know her, including, by her own admission, Mathilde herself.</p><p>In photographs she does not stand out as dramatically taller than everyone else, and yet in the collective memory of the people who know her, she is always remembered as the tall one.</p><p>It is a small, private illusion she causes without apparently trying. I think it has less to do with the number itself than with the certainty with which she moves through any given room, which is a different thing entirely, and considerably harder to fake.</p><p><strong>The contradictions</strong></p><p>Professionally, Mathilde studies cognition at the university, and more specifically the gap between what people expect will make them happy and what actually does.</p><p>She once summarized her own field to me, dryly, as the business of confirming, with proper statistical rigor, that people are almost always wrong about themselves.</p><p>It is more than a little funny, I have pointed out to her more than once, that a woman this fluent in mapping other people’s mistaken feelings remains, by her own cheerful admission, entirely unable to predict a single one of her own.</p><p>She does not find this observation nearly as funny as I do.</p><p>Human beings are nothing if not contradictory, and by the time you have known her a season, you come to believe she sits comfortably at the farthest end of that particular spectrum, fully aware of it, and only occasionally embarrassed.</p><p>Her academic circle, from what I have gathered over a couple of dinners with them, is small, loyal, and thoroughly argumentative, the sort of people who spend an entire evening dismantling one another’s methodology and would still close ranks instantly if a stranger tried it.</p><p>She has lived so much, in relatively few years, that asking her for a straightforward chronology of events tends to produce something closer to a single long breath than a timeline.</p><p>My grandfather looked after me until secondary school, she recapped once, then Amsterdam for my degree, then Paris for a while, then a shorter and considerably messier stretch in Berlin I would rather not itemize, and now I am back in the same canton I started in, telling people why they cannot predict their own happiness.</p><p>She insists, and technically means it, that she has lived in this canton her whole life, a claim that only holds up if you are willing to subtract the year in Amsterdam, the half year in Paris, and the Berlin chapter she prefers to keep vague, which I have decided, on the whole, to allow her.</p><p>Her father is very much alive and difficult in an entirely different register: quieter, more Dutch about it, which in her family apparently means saying the true thing plainly and letting the silence around it do the remaining work.</p><p>“We communicate badly,” she told me once, which may be the single most diplomatic sentence she has ever produced in my presence.</p><p>He calls. She lets it ring, then calls him back, usually before the guilt has time to fully compound.</p><p>He believes she makes her own life harder than it needs to be. She agrees with him, mostly, while insisting it is never on purpose.</p><p>Her brother, without a word of commentary, once drove a van and a thermos the length of the country to help her move out of an apartment she had briefly and regrettably shared with a musician who described his own output as genreless and owned three synthesizers and no bedsheets.</p><p>He asked no questions about the musician.</p><p>He simply arrived and turned the whole miserable errand into something closer to a road trip, which is, I gather, her family’s preferred way of offering comfort.</p><p>Three of the people who matter most to her, she once told me, share birthdays that fall on consecutive days near the middle of December: her grandfather, her father, and her brother, clustered together in a way that seems statistically improbable and that she had, of course, long since worked out for herself before I ever pointed it out.</p><p>“I wholeheartedly believe in soulmates,” she said once, entirely unprompted. “People arrive in your life at a certain time to play a certain role.”</p><p>She is, as of this writing, seeing a man named Diego: quiet, watchful, the sort of person who notices the details most people walk straight past, which may explain why the two of them get along as well as they apparently do.</p><p>But that is something you will have to hear directly from her if you want to know more.</p><p><strong>The grandfather</strong></p><p>It is only here, having spent all this time describing Mathilde, that the watch makes sense.</p><p>Her grandfather, a Dutchman who repaired radios for a living and treated the replacement of any object as a small moral failure, raised her for the better part of most of her childhood, her parents having decided early and often that work came first.</p><p>He wore the same steel Tudor Submariner, reference 7928, every single day of his adult life: swimming in it, boxing in it, gardening in it, once repairing a sink while wearing it, on the theory that removing a watch to do plumbing amounted to a kind of surrender.</p><p>Up close it looks older than its years even allow. The acrylic crystal is scratched and translucent in more than one place, the bezel has faded unevenly from black to something closer to charcoal blue, one side noticeably paler than the other, and the crown is worn thin at the top edge in the particular way that only happens from winding a watch by hand every morning for decades.</p><p>He died wearing it, in the middle of a coffee, in a café, which he would have considered a fitting way to go, since he believed without qualification that everything good happened in cafés and refused to be argued out of it.</p><p>On the back of the case he had engraved, in Dutch:</p><p><em>Kom gauw terug.</em></p><p>Watches of that particular kind carry more history than most people realize. The Tudor Submariner, in one execution or another, spent much of the 1970s and 1980s strapped to the wrists of French Navy combat divers, chosen precisely because nobody expected it to be treated gently.</p><p>I have a professional interest in this, since I wear something like a distant cousin of it myself: an Omega Seamaster 300, reference 166.024, issued in roughly the same years, in a strikingly similar case, to divers in another navy altogether.</p><p>Mine reached me by considerably less romantic means: an eBay listing from a dealer in Berlin who described its condition, generously, as honest.</p><p>I like to think the two watches recognize something in each other on the rare occasions I set them side by side: a pair of tool watches built for men who were expected to forget they were wearing them, both eventually inherited, decades later, by people who never once let anyone forget it.</p><p>Mathilde finds the whole comparison faintly ridiculous, mostly, I suspect, because she is annoyed that she did not think of it herself first.</p><p>She has never once let anyone repair her watch without standing over the workbench herself.</p><p>I understand that now.</p><p><strong>The meaning</strong></p><p>The grandfather who repaired radios and refused to replace things seems, in retrospect, to have left her more than a watch.</p><p>He left her a way of understanding objects, people, and perhaps even departures: nothing should be discarded merely because it has become inconvenient, and returning is different from merely surviving.</p><p>That may be why the watch has always seemed less like jewelry than an instrument.</p><p>The luminous markers have long since faded from white to something closer to old cream, and it keeps, by any reasonable standard, better time than a watch that age has any right to.</p><p>I think, in the end, about the watch again: the one her grandfather wore into a sink and out of this world, the one she still checks the way other people check a pulse, without appearing to notice she is doing it.</p><p><em>Kom gauw terug.</em></p><p>Come back soon?</p><p>I did not know, that June, that I was hearing the opening chapter of a genuine friendship, or that I would spend the following months learning, slowly and mostly by accident, how much of what looks like restraint in her is really just precision wearing a plainer coat.</p><p>I did not know that the watch I noticed on the first night would eventually become the object through which so much else about her came into focus.</p><p>But <em>après coup</em> works exactly this way: the thing that did not mean very much at the time becomes, later, the thing you cannot stop thinking about.</p><p>Now I am one of those who knows more, and considerably more carefully, because of the precise Miss Verhoeven.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2475d2d0f943" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Hecho en Mexico: The Authorized Anomaly of the Rolex Bracelet]]></title>
            <link>https://rivasrod.medium.com/hecho-en-mexico-the-authorized-anomaly-of-the-rolex-bracelet-016e72f2b916?source=rss-c519b7f88399------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/016e72f2b916</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[history]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[storytelling]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[foreign-policy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[watches]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mexico]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Rodolfo C. Rivas]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 24 Aug 2026 07:57:11 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-08-24T07:57:11.570Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>On the Watches That Were Finished Where They Were Sold</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/816/1*9i2oBs887TMfOlxSbMcCiw.png" /></figure><h3>By Rodolfo C. Rivas<a href="http://#_ftn1">[1]</a></h3><p>There is a clasp.</p><p>It lives beneath the wrist, hidden from view. On a Rolex Datejust 1603 from the early 1970s, the clasp sits under the Jubilee bracelet like a second inscription — one public, one secret, both requiring close inspection.</p><p>With sufficient light, and the patience of someone who no longer entirely trusts appearances, the steel yields its sentence:</p><p><em>Joske’s — Hecho en Mexico</em>.</p><p>Made in Mexico.</p><p>Much of the surviving history surrounding Joske’s bracelets comes from collector research, oral testimony, dealer archives, and surviving examples.</p><p>It goes something like this, bridging history and perception.</p><p>Collectors call it a Frankenwatch, implying deception. But in this case, there was official authorization.</p><p>A Rolex<a href="http://#_ftn2">[2]</a>, intact in its being, yet finished on a different continent, as though geography had briefly negotiated with precision.</p><p>That stamping is what started this. A vintage listing, a loupe, a detail that would not resolve into the expected. It led me, an international trade lawyer by profession and a student of <em>horlogerie</em> by inclination, into a story that turns out to be about both.</p><p>Any watch enthusiast encountering these bracelets for the first time tends to react in one of two ways. The first is suspicion: something is wrong, the clasp looks different, and there might be deception in the chain of ownership. This leads to a search for an innocent explanation, dividing the collector internally.</p><p>One-half suspects fraud: luxury passes as purity, and purity is fragile. The other half, slower, perhaps more versed in system failures, suspects history. In the space between moral and archival suspicion, meaning circulates.</p><p>The clasp is not decoration. It is a document that forgot it was supposed to remain private.</p><p>— — —</p><p>To understand the origins of these bracelets, the story begins, as many Mexican economic stories do, with a state deciding its place in the world.</p><p>Manuel Ávila Camacho governed Mexico from 1940 to 1946. The country was still young, caught between importing ideas and creating its own, between admiration and rejection. He ruled as if modernity were something to be controlled before it could be freely embraced.</p><p>This era’s cornerstone policy was import substitution industrialization (ISI). The government established a complex framework of import licenses that prioritized domestic production. Manufacturers had to assemble products locally, leading to domestic content requirements. Economist Raúl Prebisch, through the CEPAL, gave ISI a theoretical framework. Mexico became a leading practitioner. Between 1940 and 1970, GDP and manufacturing soared, cities industrialized, and the middle class grew. The period became known as the “Mexican Miracle”.</p><p>The policies impact everything being produced and consumed in the country. Even luxury is not exempt.</p><p>Especially luxury.</p><p>There is something almost literary in the constraint that follows, as if the state had decided that objects, like migrants, must acquire local accents before they are permitted to remain.</p><p>Swiss watches could enter Mexico only incomplete. Regulations — part of broader ‘fabrication programs’ — mandated domestic assembly. The bracelet, which touches the body, had to be made locally.</p><p>Not replaced.</p><p>Translated.</p><p>The regulation is surgical in a way that many of the period’s industrial policies are not. It does not attempt to build a Mexican watch industry from scratch, which would have been enormously capital-intensive and almost certainly unsuccessful given the centuries of accumulated Swiss horological knowledge that all competitors have been attempting to replicate. It asks instead for one component. A specific, visible, technically demanding component that requires precision metalworking capability and quality control disciplines, but not the movement-making expertise that constitutes the real core of the Swiss competitive advantage. The import permit requirement, gradually extended through the 1950s and 1960s, eventually covered approximately two-thirds of all import value before the reforms of the 1980s began dismantling it.</p><p>At this regulatory crossroads, Grupo Joske’s Mexico S.A. enters the narrative, though it does not yet know it is part of one.</p><p>Its origins are not horological but commercial. Joske’s name in Mexico appears to derive from its connection to Joske’s of Texas, the department store chain founded by Julius Joske, a German Jewish immigrant who arrived in San Antonio in 1867 and opened his first store on Military Plaza. By the time of its eventual sale to Dillard’s in 1987, the Joske’s chain operated twenty-seven stores across Texas. At its peak, the largest department store in the state, and by some accounts, the largest south and west of the Mississippi.</p><p>The Mexican operation is a different entity. Grupo Joske’s Mexico is a jewelry manufacturer based in the State of Mexico. It has developed, through its jewelry work, precisely the kind of precision metalworking capability required for watch bracelets: the ability to cut, shape, finish, and assemble small metal components to tight tolerances with consistent surface quality. When Mexican regulations created a market for locally made watch bracelets, Joske’s was positioned to supply them.</p><p>According to later accounts associated with the Fleischer family, the partnership with Rolex was established when Alex Benuit, the director of Rolex Mexico, reached out to Don José Fleischer, the founder of Joske’s, to negotiate an arrangement. The negotiation must resolve two distinct problems simultaneously. Rolex faced legal obstacles to importing complete watches, in addition to regulations on precious metals, and was required to create local employment. The bracelet manufacturing arrangement addressed both: it provides local employment and local value addition, satisfying the regulatory requirement, while allowing the Swiss movement and case to enter the market at the tariff rates applicable to incomplete watches.</p><p>Accounts associated with the Fleischer family state that Joske’s used its own equipment and locally sourced steel rather than machinery or raw materials supplied by Rolex.</p><p>With their own special tools. Their own <em>troqueles</em>, as Bernardo Fleischer, Don José’s son, would later describe them: fifteen and twenty artisans or mechanics on the line, the number shifting with each authorized batch. A workshop staffed to the size of its obligation.</p><p>And Rolex is not the only client. For the same regulatory reasons, Joske’s supplies bracelets for Omega, Nivada, Tissot, and Citizen. The ISI requirement is universal: any watch brand selling in Mexico faces the same legal condition and must find a local answer. Joske’s is not a Rolex supplier but the supplier of Swiss watches in Mexico, with each brand requiring its own bracelet specifications, sample authorization, and production run. The workshop also produces cases and boxes — the small containers that hold the watch before it reaches the wrist. The geometry of Mexican compliance is wider than the clasp suggests.</p><p>In this environment, Joske’s workers are not making watches.</p><p>They are making permission — documenting how global brands negotiate local rules, and how authenticity is shaped as much by regulation as by origin. The Joske’s bracelet manifests Rolex’s compliance with, and adaptation to, Mexico’s economic vision.</p><p>This point deserves precision, because it is often misread. The arrangement appears to have involved both import restrictions and tariff classifications favoring incomplete assemblies. Contemporary import regulations and industrial policy requirements appear to have prevented the routine importation of complete watches with foreign-made bracelets, creating a practical requirement for local bracelet production.</p><p>The Swiss approval arrives in batches, like weather that has been negotiated in advance.</p><p>Each bracelet required a prototype. After rigorous quality control, Switzerland authorized production. Nothing moved without approval.</p><p>And so Mexico does not merely produce. Each bracelet is a record of how local industries responded to global demands, submitting prototypes of reality for foreign confirmation, not to fake, but to redefine what counts as genuine.</p><p>Quality control is not relaxed because the production is in Mexico. It is the same quality control as applied to any component bearing the Rolex name, administered by the same authority, with the same power to reject batches that do not meet standard. According to accounts associated with the workshop, samples were submitted to Switzerland for approval before production batches proceeded.</p><p>The Jubilee bracelet itself belongs to another genealogy, one that begins in Geneva but does not stay there.</p><p>Introduced by Rolex in 1945 to mark the brand’s fortieth anniversary, the Jubilee is a five-piece link construction with a characteristic elegance: a larger center link flanked by two smaller links on each side, the combination producing a suppleness and comfort on the wrist that the three-piece Oyster bracelet’s more robust construction does not always match. The design is created by Gay Frères, the Geneva bracelet manufacturer that has been supplying Rolex since the 1930s, and their relationship deepens over the following decades until Rolex purchases Gay Frères in 1998 as part of an ongoing effort to acquire its suppliers and vertically integrate all aspects of its production process.</p><p>In Mexico, this genealogy is interrupted by requirement.</p><p>Joske’s manufactures steel and steel-and-gold Jubilee model bracelets, as well as other types. Fully gold variants are handled by a separate manufacturer. Over roughly two decades, the State of Mexico workshop has produced authorized Jubilee bracelets that are, in the sense that matters most, faithful: faithful to the original specification, produced under authorization from the original designer, distinguishable by those who know what they are looking at but not inferior by any objective measure that the specification can capture.</p><p>The bracelets carry their own marks of origin. On a period-matched Swiss-made clasp, the Rolex coronet sits directly atop the latch. On Joske’s piece, the logo sits in the upper third rather than directly at the apex, and the solid outer links take an oval form that differs slightly from the Geneva production. These differences are identifiable. They are not deficiencies. They are the marks of a different manufacturing context producing a legitimate variant of the same authorized design.</p><p>There is a temptation, when encountering these objects, to treat them as anomalies.</p><p>They are symptoms of a broader arrangement in which the world briefly agreed that production should be geographically incomplete.</p><p>Omega participates in this geography of distributed manufacture, as does Tissot. Any Swiss watchmaker selling into the Mexican market faced the same regulatory framework and had to adopt similar solutions. The constraint was not brand-specific but structural. The Swiss watch, often imagined as a closed, fully integrated object arriving intact from a single origin, is in practice a negotiated assemblage shaped by trade rules and local production requirements.</p><p>For Omega in Mexico, relevant manufacturers include Holzer and J/M. Holzer is independently documented as a Mexican supplier operating within Omega’s distribution network. The J/M stamp found on the clasp components of Omega bracelets from this period has been widely discussed by collectors and researchers. The prevailing interpretation links J/M to Joske’s Mexico, suggesting a subcontracting arrangement in which bracelets or components were produced or finished locally and stamped differently depending on production and distribution channels. Documentary confirmation of this linkage remains limited, but these markings point to a broader industrial ecosystem during the import-substitution era, with multiple firms, overlapping subcontracting relationships, and varied stamping conventions, rather than a single standardized supply chain.</p><p>Tissot appears to have operated under similar conditions for watches sold in Mexico during the same period. The regulatory environment applied broadly and required Swiss manufacturers to adapt in comparable ways. These cases are less extensively documented than those associated with Omega and Rolex.</p><p>Comparable arrangements also appear in other markets, including C&amp;I and JB Champion in the United States, WAB in the United Kingdom, D’A in Venezuela, and other regional suppliers in Japan and elsewhere. Each reflects a local adaptation of the same underlying logic, in which precision watchmaking is distributed across borders rather than contained within them.</p><p>Collectors argue about these stamps as if they were encrypted messages.</p><p>In truth, they are simpler. They are receipts from a world that no longer organizes itself in quite the same way.</p><p>And then comes the misunderstanding, which is always the beginning of valuation.</p><p>The conventional wisdom, transmitted through forum threads and dealer commentary with the authority that repeated opinions tend to acquire, holds that the Mexican bracelets are inferior. The finishing is said to be slightly off. The clasp mechanism feels marginally different. The metal composition is thought to vary in ways that reveal themselves through decades of wear.</p><p>The conventional wisdom is partial.</p><p>What the physical evidence actually shows, and what the collector community has documented over the past decade through careful comparison with period-correct Swiss production, is that Joske’s bracelets range from competent to genuinely very good by the standards of the era. On well-preserved examples, the surface finishing is professional, the link articulation is correct, and the clasp mechanism functions exactly as it should. Where observable differences exist, they cluster around consistency across a production run rather than the quality of individual examples. Accounts describe an assembly line employing roughly fifteen to twenty workers, producing under Swiss-quality oversight, which is not the same as a major Swiss manufacturer’s bracelet facility operating at scale. The batch-to-batch variance is real and expected.</p><p>What was once deviation becomes variation.</p><p>What was once variation becomes rarity.</p><p>What was once a rarity becomes value.</p><p>Markets are archivists of desire. The same bracelets that once required explanation now require authentication. The narrative around them has. In certain well-preserved examples, rarity and provenance have begun to outweigh the mythology of “Swiss Made”.</p><p>Joske’s Jubilee bracelets, in particular, have become highly sought after by collectors around the world. The loupe has become an instrument of discovery: under the right light, a close inspection of the clasp can reveal details the market once overlooked, and uncover value that the old mythology failed to recognize.</p><p>The clasp remains unchanged throughout.</p><p>It is only interpretation that migrates.</p><p>In August 1986, the system dissolved quietly.</p><p>Mexico’s accession to the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade (GATT), signed July 25, 1986, ended the bracelet’s production. Import licenses replaced by tariffs. The regulatory necessity for local assembly vanishes. The workshop becomes obsolete. What preceded it: the collapse of oil prices in the early 1980s, a foreign exchange crisis in August 1982, López Portillo’s moratorium on external debt, and a recognition by the de la Madrid administration that protection had run its course. Import-substitution policies that had governed the economy since the 1940s are replaced by policies aimed at attracting foreign investment, lowering trade barriers, and positioning Mexico for export-led growth.</p><p>The logic that once required objects to be partially nationalized loses its administrative breath.</p><p>Watches arrive whole again. The bracelet returns to Switzerland, or to wherever efficiency has decided it should live.</p><p>The regulations that made the bracelet necessary have ceased to exist. Rolex can now import complete watches. The fifteen or twenty-person assembly line in the State of Mexico is no longer required by the law that had created it.</p><p>The workshop does not collapse. It simply becomes unnecessary.</p><p>And unrequired things have a particular kind of silence.</p><p>Don José Fleischer already knew this would come. He had told his son, Bernardo, for years: the moment Mexico opens its doors to imports, this business ends. Months after Mexico entered GATT in 1986, the instruction arrived: no further production.</p><p>— — —</p><p>Rolex has never publicly discussed its collaboration with Joske’s, unlike its relationship with Gay Frères, which it eventually acquired.</p><p>There is no acquisition. No acknowledgment. No public statement of thanks for more than two decades of partnership in which a Mexican jewelry manufacturer had held a Rolex standard on Swiss-approved production runs and put the result on the wrists of Mexican professionals who were buying luxury goods with the aspirational confidence of a growing middle class in a country trying, with genuine ambition and mixed results, to become something more than what it had been.</p><p>Bernardo Fleischer, speaking of this absence, is matter-of-fact. The recognition, he says, was the payment. That was what the relationship offered. It was sufficient.</p><p>The relationship ends the way many industrial arrangements end when the regulatory conditions that created them disappear: not with ceremony, but with the quiet administrative fact of no further orders.</p><p>Objects remember differently than policy.</p><p>A movement does not know trade agreements.</p><p>A clasp does not read legislation.</p><p>— — —</p><p>Seen from a distance, this resembles many other mid-century transformations: the disappearance of regulated hybridity in favor of global continuity.</p><p>But the broader context of Joske’s story is not only Mexican. The Mexican bracelet is a small data point in a larger story about what protectionism can and cannot build. Mexico’s ISI framework, which runs from the Ávila Camacho years through successive PRI governments, is one of the most sustained experiments in development-through-protection that the twentieth century produced. It transforms the country from an agrarian to an urban, semi-industrial society. It is, on the whole, a success.</p><p>And yet. The strategy contains the seeds of its own exhaustion. By the late 1970s, growth had lost momentum, slowed by difficulties in substituting imports of high-technology capital goods. Public expenditure becomes the engine, funded by oil revenues and external debt. The collapse of the international oil market in 1981, combined with rising US interest rates, triggered the crisis. By 1982, the expansion was over.</p><p>What the bracelet demonstrates, in its small and precise way, is that Mexican manufacturers can meet Swiss precision standards when the regulatory conditions create both the requirement and the market for them to do so. The assembly line workers in the State of Mexico produced, over roughly two decades, an object that Rolex certifies and consumers wear without knowing its origin.</p><p>The contemporary moment in trade and industrial policy has returned, with different instruments and different language but recognizable underlying intent, to the questions that Ávila Camacho was asking in 1940. The CHIPS and Science Act, the Inflation Reduction Act, and the European Union’s framework for Open Strategic Autonomy: these are governments deciding, after decades of faith in markets to allocate manufacturing activity without state intervention, that some industries are too strategically important to leave entirely to market allocation. Manufacturing activity creates technical capability. Capability supports industrial ecosystems. Ecosystems produce the kind of accumulated knowledge and supply chain resilience that are extremely difficult to rebuild once lost.</p><p>The instruments are different. The new industrial policy is more export-oriented and assumes deeply globalized supply chains rather than nationally closed production systems. But the underlying question remains the same: how does a country ensure that the value created by sophisticated manufacturing activity is captured domestically rather than accruing to other parts of the global chain? How does it move up the value chain into higher-value segments such as design, advanced manufacturing, and intellectual property?</p><p>The Joske’s bracelet is a small, specific, and now collectible answer to that question from a particular moment in the history of one country’s economic ambition. The answer lasted as long as the regulations did. When the regulations changed, the answer ended.</p><p>What remained was the object.</p><p>— — —</p><p>A successor jewelry business associated with the Joske’s name appears to continue operating today. The watch bracelet chapter of its history spans roughly from the late 1960s through 1986, approximately two decades of production runs approved by Switzerland, produced with Mexican steel on Joske’s own equipment by an assembly line of fifteen or twenty workers making something that will outlast the policy that required it.</p><p>Those workers are now in their seventies and eighties, if they are still living. They wound machines in a factory in the State of Mexico, made links, fitted clasps, sent samples to Switzerland, waited for authorization, and began the next batch. They did not know, because nobody does at the time, that they were making things that would eventually command higher prices than the Swiss-made equivalents at auction, that would generate collector forum threads of several hundred replies, that would be described on the websites of European watch dealers as rarities and time capsules and genuine anomalies.</p><p>They were doing a job to a standard for a wage in a country that had decided precision manufacturing was worth protecting.</p><p>They were right.</p><p>Don José Fleischer, who managed this entire relationship personally for more than two decades, never wore a Rolex. His son Bernardo did, a Rolex Oyster Perpetual, the smaller model. Until two robberies took it. After the second, he stopped wearing a watch altogether. The man who founded the company, who negotiated with Alex Benuit, who approved every sample and coordinated every batch, wore no watch. The makers of things are not always the keepers of them. The object moves outward. The maker stays behind.</p><p>The Mexican bracelets, once considered secondary, accumulate a kind of prestige precisely because they are legible. They carry history on their surface. Standardized objects do not. They are readable.</p><p>And readability, in the end, is what survives systems.</p><p>— — —</p><p>The bracelet on the Datejust in some European watch dealer’s display case is proof.</p><p>Open the clasp with a loupe in adequate light.</p><p>Read what it says.</p><p><em>Joske’s — Hecho en Mexico.</em></p><p>Four words and a brand name. The compressed record of a presidential economic conviction, a regulatory mechanism, a negotiation between Alex Benuit and Don José Fleischer, and fifteen or twenty workers on an assembly line, and Switzerland’s quality-control stamp on every batch before production began.</p><p>The movement inside the case does not know any of this.</p><p>It keeps time with the same precision it was built to keep. The mainspring uncoils. The escapement regulates. The hands move in their measured sweep across the dial.</p><p>But the bracelet knows.</p><p>Or rather: the bracelet carries.</p><p>Objects do not know their histories. They carry them, in the specific marks that the conditions of their production left in their surfaces, their structures, their stampings.</p><p>The history is there whether or not anyone reads it.</p><p>This one is worth reading.</p><p>It is rarer than it looks.</p><p>It is more valuable than the mythology suggests.</p><p>And it was made, with authorization and craft and fifteen or twenty people’s daily labor, in Mexico.</p><p><em>Hecho en Mexico.</em></p><p>Done correctly.</p><p>Done well.</p><p>Still here.</p><p><a href="http://#_ftnref1">[1]</a>Rodolfo C. Rivas is a Mexican-born horophile and international trade lawyer based in Geneva, where he has spent more than forty percent of his life. His writing explores the hidden histories of watches, trade, and cinema</p><p><a href="http://#_ftnref2">[2]</a> Rolex is a registered trademark of Rolex SA. This article is an independent historical commentary and is not affiliated with or endorsed by Rolex SA.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=016e72f2b916" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The City Ring Votes: How a watch complication quietly voted on the shape of the World]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/classroom/the-city-ring-votes-how-a-watch-complication-quietly-voted-on-the-shape-of-the-world-2c77ed6464d1?source=rss-c519b7f88399------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2c77ed6464d1</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[watches]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[world]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[economy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[international-relations]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Rodolfo C. Rivas]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 02 Aug 2026 18:32:20 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-08-03T08:19:10.909Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/768/1*H46Z9-_AXp5D_93MUIS0JQ@2x.jpeg" /></figure><p>By Rodolfo C. Rivas</p><p>Twenty-Four Cities</p><p>Why these cities and not others?</p><p>Some may consider it the least interesting question one can ask about a World Timer, yet it is one of the most important. Collectors speak of calibers, enamel dials, and precious metals. Historians of horology rightly celebrate Louis Cottier’s invention and the manufacturers who transformed it into one of watchmaking’s most enduring complications. Yet for nearly a century, remarkably little attention has gone to the twenty-four names engraved around the edge of the dial.</p><p>Why does Dhaka sit on the modern dial while Delhi rarely has on any modern Swiss ring? Why did Karachi outlast Bombay and Calcutta, cities it shared a ring with for over a decade before both disappeared and it alone remained? Why does South Georgia still hold seats while Vienna, home to Mozart and Freud has rarely been on the roster? Why has Hong Kong disappeared from some city rings while Beijing has taken its place? Why did Saigon belong among these cities while Istanbul, capital of three empires, appeared only on the largest vintage rosters and never made the modern cut? Why did Singapore move time itself to align with its principal trading partners? Why did a Soviet watchmaker once replace Tokyo with Vladivostok?</p><p>These questions interest me in equal measure to the watches themselves, and I say that as someone who has spent a professional lifetime in rooms where questions very much like them are argued out in earnest: which country chairs the committee or which capital hosts the diplomatic conference. The World Timer, it turns out, has been having that argument in miniature for nearly a century, on the inside of a wristwatch, without anyone much noticing.</p><p>There are many remarkable complications in horology. The perpetual calendar preserves our relationship with the heavens. The chronograph measures our relationship with movement. The minute repeater turns time into music. The World Timer does something different. It is the only great complication that periodically forces its maker to answer a deceptively simple question: which cities matter now? Its answers have never been merely geographical.</p><p>The World Timer rewards neither population nor beauty, and its memory is shorter than collectors like to admit. Florence gave civilization Michelangelo, Dante and Brunelleschi and remains conspicuously absent from most rings ever produced. Vienna gave us Mozart, Freud and Klimt and has similarly been largely absent. Lagos, one of the great urban centers of this century, has rarely appeared on the dial. Guadalajara, my own hometown, remains absent despite standing among Latin America’s great cultural capitals. Civilization, it would appear, is not always fair in distributing its honors, nor is it always consistent.</p><p>What the city ring rewards is movement, the same instinct that governs my own field, where a small alpine city with no army and no navy hosts conversations that shape how the rest of the world trades and disagrees. For nearly a century, the ring has documented where commerce flows, where diplomacy gathers, where humanity has decided it needs to convene. It has done this without any committee of historians or economists ever sitting down to decide the roster. Generation after generation, watchmakers have asked themselves the same question the delegates in Geneva ask every autumn: who needs to be in this room?</p><p>There is an irony worth sitting with here. We speak of World Timers as though they were principally concerned with time, when in truth they are concerned with geography, and, more precisely, with a geography of standing rather than a geography of coastlines. They are miniature atlases worn on the wrist, atlases that periodically revise themselves as our understanding of commerce, politics and civilization changes beneath them. The cities remain. Their meanings evolve. Or, more accurately: some cities remain.</p><p>London has endured. So have New York, Paris, Tokyo and Geneva. Others have disappeared into history. Saigon yielded to Ho Chi Minh City. Bombay became Mumbai. Moscow occasionally moves westward by legislative decree, an act of geography obeying politics rather than the reverse. Hong Kong cedes some modern World Timers to Beijing, despite remaining indispensable to international commerce. Noumea surrenders its place to Brisbane. The city ring evolves because the world evolves, and the closer one studies these changes, the harder it becomes to think of them as accidental.</p><p>Take Singapore, whose natural neighbors on any map are Bangkok and Kuala Lumpur, yet which sits in a time zone its longitude does not quite justify: it moved time itself, a decision I return to later in this essay, because it is one of the cleanest examples anywhere of economics overruling geography by legislative fiat.</p><p>Or take Geneva, whose case I know well after two decades walking past its lake to rooms where trade disputes get settled. On paper its continued presence on the dial may be hard to justify: modest population, no commercial weight to rival New York, no demographic scale to rival Tokyo. And yet it has remained indispensable for a century, for reasons I take up properly in the next chapter.</p><p>There is something genuinely optimistic in a complication that assumes twenty-four distant places belong to the same conversation. Long before economists began speaking of globalization and political scientists of interdependence, the World Timer had already imagined a connected world: twenty-four cities, separated by oceans and languages, moving together in perfect mechanical harmony. It remains an extraordinary proposition, and one I have come to believe describes my own life rather better than any passport stamp does.</p><p>International life teaches you that you accumulate cities slowly and almost by accident. They become chapters rather than destinations. Geneva becomes home while Guadalajara remains home as well; other places quietly occupy their own corners of memory. Airports stop being interruptions and become recurring chapters instead. You discover, eventually, that movement itself can become a curious kind of permanence, which is perhaps why I keep returning to the World Timer. It understands something about civilization that has nothing to do with watchmaking: that cities rise and decline, that commerce changes direction, that nations periodically reinvent themselves, and that every generation leaves behind its own answer, engraved on a city ring, to the question of where the center of the world now sits.</p><p>This piece, then, is not principally about watches. It is about those answers, about why humanity chose twenty-four cities to represent itself, and what those choices reveal about who we were, who we are, and who we may be becoming. For nearly a century, the World Timer has been keeping that conversation. We have simply forgotten to listen to what the cities have been saying.</p><p>Louis Cottier’s Global Mind</p><p>Every history of the World Timer begins with the same sentence: Louis Cottier invented it in 1931. Almost none of them ask what kind of mind produces an invention like that, at that particular moment, in that particular city. I want to spend this chapter on the question, because I think the answer explains everything that follows.</p><p>Great inventions rarely solve only the problem stated on the label. Gutenberg’s press was ostensibly a printing solution; it democratized argument itself. Brunelleschi’s dome was ostensibly an engineering problem; it changed what a city believed it could build over its own skyline. Harrison’s chronometer was ostensibly a timekeeping device; it redrew the boundaries of empire by letting ships fix their longitude at sea. Cottier’s invention belongs in that company, and for the same reason: its stated problem, how does one read the time in several cities from a single dial, was never really the problem he solved.</p><p>The genius of the Cottier system does not lie in the mechanism, elegant as it is. A rotating city ring geared to a twenty-four-hour track is, mechanically speaking, a modest achievement next to a minute repeater or a perpetual calendar. What Cottier actually did was recognize, a decade before anyone had a word for it, that the world had become a single conversation, and that a watch could be built to say so.</p><p>Picture Geneva around 1930, because it is worth picturing precisely: this is the terrain Cottier was standing on when he had his idea. The League of Nations had taken up residence a few years earlier, the first true experiment in a permanent, standing conversation among nations that did not depend on any single empire to convene it. The International Labour Organization had its offices nearby. Commercial aviation was still an adventure rather than a habit, but the habit was visibly forming. Imperial Airways and its rivals were stitching together routes that would, within a decade, make the idea of “elsewhere” considerably less remote. The telegraph and the wireless had already compressed news to something approaching simultaneity. International banking, insurance and reinsurance were consolidating themselves in a handful of cities, Geneva and Zurich prominent among them. Switzerland, in other words, was busy becoming one of the places where internationalism itself was being invented, tested, and occasionally embarrassed.</p><p>Cottier was not designing a complication in a vacuum. He was answering, in gold and enamel, a question his own city was asking out loud: if the world now negotiates as a single body, oughtn’t a watch be able to say what time it is for everyone in the room at once? That is a substantially more ambitious project than “world time,” and it explains why the invention feels, even a century later, less like an engineering solution and more like a small manifesto.</p><p>Vacheron Constantin, arguably the finest and oldest continuously operating watchmaker, was first to commission him, producing a pocket reference in 1932 that read, in effect, like a steamship timetable rendered in gold: Paris, London, New York, Bombay, Shanghai, Yokohama, Rio, and Cairo occupying the same ring, the same imperial trade routes that moved goods now moving hours. Patek Philippe followed in 1937 with the Ref. 96 HU and 515 HU, wrist worn rather than pocket carried, with Paris fixed at twelve o’clock, a choice that was, by literal design, Eurocentric, and one that tells you plainly which capital still believed itself the meridian of the civilized world in 1937. It would take until 1939, with the Ref. 1415, for the complication to reach series production at all; until then, every Cottier-based world timer had been effectively bespoke, a private conversation between a patron and his watchmaker about which twenty-four cities deserved to share a dial with him.</p><p>I find something quietly moving in the fact that the roster of those earliest watches is, without exception, a map of empire rather than of the world. London, Paris, Calcutta, Hong Kong, Shanghai, Bombay, Rio: these are not the twenty-four largest cities on earth in 1937, nor the twenty-four wealthiest, nor the twenty-four most beautiful. They are the twenty-four nodes of a colonial trading system that still believed, correctly for the moment, that it ran the planet’s clock. Cottier did not invent that map. He gave it a mechanism, which is precisely why the ring has had to keep revising itself ever since: the mechanism outlived the empire that first populated it, and every subsequent generation of watchmakers has had to decide, city by city, what ought to replace the assumptions Cottier inherited rather than chose.</p><p>This is also, I think, why the complication has proven so durable where so many of its contemporaries have not. A watch that flatters a single empire’s self-image becomes an antique the moment that empire recedes. A watch built on the underlying premise that the world is a single conversation and that a person of consequence ought to be able to track it survives the empire’s recession intact because the premise proves true regardless of who chairs the meeting. Cottier’s invention has needed new city names roughly once a generation. It has never needed a new idea.</p><p>One version of the story stops with the mechanism: dual crowns, then a single pusher, then a micro rotor, refinements that mattered enormously to the people making the watches and rather less to the idea itself. I will get to those refinements later because I, like collectors, am right to care about them. But the more interesting inheritance runs through the diplomats and negotiators who have, without ever knowing Cottier’s name, spent the intervening century building the very institution his watch anticipated: a world that despite all the recent developments increasingly seems more interconnected, for better and for worse. He got there first, and he got there quietly, on the inside of a dial nobody was watching closely enough.</p><p>The Immortals</p><p>Some cities arrive on the city ring triumphantly, only to disappear a generation later. Others endure. London has remained. So have New York, Paris, Tokyo and Geneva, their presence spanning wars, revolutions, technological upheaval and the most dramatic redistribution of economic power since the beginning of the modern age. They have survived the rise of Asia, the decline of empires, and the arrival of entirely new centers of commerce. What makes a city indispensable for nearly a century?</p><p>No single characteristic has ever been sufficient. Population is not enough on its own; Delhi has more people than most nations and has never held a seat on any Swiss or mainstream modern World Timer, even as Karachi and Dhaka, both younger capitals, hold two of the modern ring’s twenty-four seats today. This may owe something to India’s fixed half-hour offset, a complication most world timer mechanisms were never built to display. Delhi has appeared on a 1970 Soviet ring that replaced most of the Western roster outright, a curiosity I return to later. Wealth alone will not do. Beauty has almost nothing to do with it. The immortals possess something more elusive: they sit simultaneously at the intersection of commerce, culture, diplomacy, connectivity and imagination, and they are places through which humanity keeps choosing to conduct its most important conversations, generation after generation, regardless of who happens to be winning at any given moment.</p><p>London is at once the easiest of the five to understand and the hardest to explain. Its presence on the ring is oddly circular: the Prime Meridian passes through Greenwich not because geography demanded it but because an international conference in 1884 decided it should, and having established London as the point from which modern time itself is measured, watchmakers half a century later confirmed the arrangement by engraving its name. But London’s story is about considerably more than longitude. For two centuries it has remained one of the world’s indispensable financial centers. Empires departed; financial crises came and went; political influence waxed and waned. London remained, because it is Shakespeare and Churchill, James Bond and Harry Potter, the Bank of England and Lloyd’s, Heathrow and Canary Wharf, all at once, and because millions of decisions pass through it every year in a language international commerce still speaks fluently.</p><p>New York offers a similar case built on a different foundation. It is impossible to imagine globalization without it. Wall Street alone might justify its inclusion, but New York has always represented something larger than finance: an idea as much as a city, where international commerce is negotiated, culture is exported, immigration continuously reinvents the population, the United Nations gathers, the Knicks, Madison Square Garden, and Broadway remind everyone that civilization concerns itself with more than balance sheets. If London became the point from which we measure time, New York became one of the places where we increasingly measure influence.</p><p>Paris complicates the thesis rather than confirming it. If the ring rewards movement, commerce and connectivity, Paris insists that civilization occasionally rewards beauty as well. No serious account of humanity’s intellectual and artistic history can comfortably exclude it; Hemingway understood as much when he wrote that Paris accompanies you for the rest of your life, and entire generations of artists, writers and philosophers have found themselves unable to leave it entirely behind. Economists are considerably more comfortable discussing trade flows than imagination. Yet civilization requires both, and Paris remains on the dial because it has become simultaneously indispensable and aspirational, one of the few cities people continue to visit not merely because they must, but because they wish to. The ring occasionally rewards necessity. Sometimes it rewards desire.</p><p>Tokyo, arguably one of the greatest economic success stories preserved on any city ring anywhere. There was nothing inevitable about its rise; the devastation of WWII makes its contemporary prominence all the more extraordinary. Within a remarkably short span, Japan transformed itself into one of the world’s great economic powers while becoming an indispensable center of innovation and culture. Seiko’s decision to introduce its first World Timer alongside the Tokyo Olympics of 1964 could not have been better timed symbolically: Japan was not merely hosting an international event; it was reintroducing itself to the world, and the watch became an expression of belonging rather than a mere souvenir of the Games. Tokyo stopped being a Japanese city and became one of humanity’s cities. The complication understood this immediately.</p><p>And then there is Geneva, which fascinates me more than any other city on the ring, for reasons that have as much to do with where I have spent my career and where I learned to love watchmaking and watches. It could be argued it should not be there, and yet could scarcely be anywhere else. There are larger cities, wealthier cities, cities of greater cultural weight and far greater political heft. Geneva possesses none of these advantages in any obvious abundance; by any conventional measure its continued inclusion looks almost irrational. And yet civilization, and the watchmakers, keep choosing it as the place to conduct some of its most difficult conversations. The League of Nations came here, then the United Nations established one of its principal seats on the same shore. The World Health Organization, the International Labour Organization, the World Trade Organization and a dozen lesser known bodies found homes along the lake. Diplomats representing nearly every nation quietly conduct their daily work here; humanitarian organizations have shaped whole bodies of international law from these offices; scientific discovery emerges from CERN’s laboratories a short drive away; the watchmaking industry itself still treats the region as something close to a spiritual home.</p><p>Geneva is not principally a city of commerce or culture. It is a city of institutions, and institutions possess unusually long memories; they survive governments and occasionally outlive empires, preserving a society’s collective aspirations through periods of real uncertainty. Geneva’s presence on the ring is therefore not a recognition of demographic or economic power. It is an acknowledgment that civilization occasionally needs a place dedicated principally to conversation itself, and I have come, after years of walking to committee rooms along that lake, to think the ring understood this before I did.</p><p>There is a sixth immortal I nearly overlooked, since we seem to overlook what is right in front of our eyes. Mexico City has appeared on essentially every world timer of consequence made since Louis Cottier drew up his very first prototype in 1931, not merely the modern standard, but the 1932 Vacheron pocket piece, every wartime Patek reference, the Ref. 2523 in each of its Cold War iterations, the Seiko built for the 1964 Olympics, and every mechanical and quartz descendant produced since. Geneva, by contrast, even if it has appeared consistently, arrived in the ring around the mid 1950s. It has earned that permanence honestly: a metropolitan area larger than most nations, a financial and cultural capital for a hemisphere, and, not incidentally, one of Patek Philippe’s own priority markets, honored in 2019 with a limited edition marking twenty-five years of the house’s presence there. I mention this partly because I am from Mexico, and partly because it corrects an assumption I very nearly made myself while drafting this essay: that a city’s absence from memory is the same thing as its absence from the record. It rarely is.</p><p>Considered together, the immortals have remarkably little in common by traditional measures of power. London is not Tokyo. Geneva bears little resemblance to New York. Paris cannot comfortably be compared to any of them, and Mexico City’s tenure outlasts what seems like a permanent fixture in Geneva. What they share, I think, is that each has become indispensable in its own language: London speaks finance, New York speaks commerce and culture, Paris speaks beauty and ideas, Tokyo speaks innovation and resilience, Geneva speaks diplomacy, Mexico City speaks through centuries of heritage. Civilization has repeatedly decided that all six languages deserve a permanent seat at the table, and this may also explain why the immortals are so difficult to replace. Cities rarely leave the ring simply because a rival becomes wealthier or larger; they leave only when humanity collectively decides the conversation itself has changed. New York did not displace London. Tokyo did not displace Paris. Each became necessary in its own way, and civilization made room for all of them.</p><p>For every city that survives, though, there are others whose stories are more interesting still, cities that did not merely join the conversation but changed it, redirecting commerce and shifting the world’s center of gravity while the rest of us were looking elsewhere. Those are the cities to which I turn next.</p><p>Cities That Moved the World</p><p>If one compares a World Timer from 1937 with one produced in 2026, the differences reveal considerably more than a century of watchmaking. They tell the story of empires dissolving and economies emerging; they show a global economy whose center of gravity has steadily shifted eastward; they remind us that aviation has made neighbors of distant continents and that globalization periodically redraws its own maps. The city ring has been recording this transformation for nearly a hundred years. We have simply not been paying attention.</p><p>It helps, before getting to individual cities, to look at the roster in a few fixed snapshots, because the cumulative shift is easy to miss and startling once you see it laid out.</p><p>In 1950, the ring still belongs to the old order. London, New York and Paris anchor it as they always have; empire still matters more than trade statistics; commercial aviation exists but remains an adventure rather than a habit; containerization has not yet been invented, so the ports that move the world’s goods still look much as they did before the war. A watch from this year is, in effect, a photograph of a world still organized by the powers that had won it a few years earlier.</p><p>By 1975, the picture had already changed. Tokyo has risen from the wreckage of 1945 into one of the century’s genuine surprises. Hong Kong is becoming the conduit through which East meets West. Singapore, newly independent barely a decade earlier, is beginning the ascent that will make it one of the era’s defining economic stories. Jet travel has compressed the world in a way the ocean liner never did. A ring drawn up in this decade already looks toward Asia in a way its 1950 predecessor could not have anticipated.</p><p>By 2000, the vocabulary has changed entirely. Globalization has a name and an acronym. The World Trade Organization exists; I have spent most of my career inside the building where it conducts its business, and China’s accession the following year will reorganize global trade flows more thoroughly than any single event since the end of WWII. The container revolution, quietly underway since the 1960s, has by now completely restructured how goods move and, by extension, which ports and which cities matter. The internet has begun to compress information the way jet travel once compressed distance.</p><p>And today, the ring speaks a vocabulary its 1937 ancestor could not have imagined: Asia accounts for a majority of global economic growth. Dubai is a crossroads rather than an outpost. Financial centers have proliferated well beyond the old Atlantic axis. Digital commerce and, increasingly, questions about artificial intelligence and data flows sit alongside the older conversations about tariffs and shipping lanes. Watch this progression as a sequence of four photographs rather than a single static image, and the cities I am about to discuss stop looking like isolated curiosities and start looking like a pattern.</p><p>Singapore is perhaps the clearest example of a city refusing to accept the limits geography first assigned it. When it became independent in 1965, few would have predicted that a city state smaller than New York would become one of the world’s indispensable crossroads; geography suggested modest ambitions, and commerce had considerably grander ideas. From a developing economy with a per capita income measured in the hundreds of dollars, Singapore became one of the world’s wealthiest societies within a single working lifetime. More than a fifth of the world’s transshipment containers now pass through its ports; its financial institutions help underwrite commerce taking place thousands of miles beyond its shores; Changi Airport has repeatedly been ranked among the world’s finest and busiest. And in 1982, having concluded that geography had placed it in the wrong time zone for its own economic purposes, Singapore moved: it adopted UTC plus eight rather than the seven its longitude implied, aligning itself with the working hours of its principal trading partners rather than the position of the sun. The city ring did not create that decision. It only recognized, some years later, that the decision had already been made.</p><p>Hong Kong tells an adjacent but distinct story. Few cities have embodied globalization as completely over the past half century; its harbor became one of the great gateways between East and West, international finance flourished there, and entire generations of business were conducted from offices overlooking Victoria Harbour. It remains, by one measure, the world’s busiest cargo airport by tonnage, a fact worth holding next to the decision several manufacturers have since made to replace it on the ring with Beijing. There is no technically correct answer to the question of which city should speak for UTC+8. Economic weight points one way; political reality increasingly points another; and the ring, which is never as neutral as collectors like to imagine, has begun quietly voting, reference by reference, on a question the rest of us have generally preferred not to phrase so bluntly.</p><p>Dubai’s rise would have struck an earlier generation of collectors as implausible. More than ninety million passengers now pass through Dubai International Airport annually, making it one of the world’s genuine crossroads, a waiting room, in effect, for a considerable share of the planet’s business travel, with millions of journeys that begin elsewhere pausing briefly beneath its ceilings before continuing. Other cities in the region arguably carry considerably greater political weight within its own region, and other cities in the Gulf can claim longer histories. Yet Dubai prevailed on the modern ring because the complication has always rewarded movement over memory. Civilization occasionally chooses crossroads over capitals.</p><p>Shanghai makes a related point from a different direction. Dismissed for decades as a historical curiosity following its mid century decline, it has reemerged as one of the world’s indispensable centers of finance, shipping, and commerce; the Port of Shanghai is now the busiest container port on the planet, handling trade volumes that would have seemed incomprehensible a generation ago. The city ring understood what economists would eventually call the Asian century well before the phrase entered common use, and its choices, Tokyo indispensable, Singapore ascendant, Hong Kong globally essential, Shanghai returning, Beijing increasingly confident, Dubai transformed from regional outpost to international crossroads, tell that story with unusual economy.</p><p>And yet the ring remains conservative in other respects. London has not departed. Neither has Geneva. New York continues to speak fluently in the language of commerce while Paris remains equally eloquent in the language of civilization. This apparent contradiction reveals something important: the World Timer is not attempting merely to track economic change, or its roster would evolve considerably faster than it does. It is recording something more complicated: humanity’s understanding of influence in its broadest sense, in which commerce matters enormously but has never been sufficient on its own. Ideas matter. Institutions matter. Connectivity matters. History occasionally matters too.</p><p>The greatest changes on the ring have rarely been revolutionary. They have been evolutionary: cities do not suddenly arrive on the world stage so much as humanity gradually discovers it can no longer comfortably imagine the world without them. That, ultimately, is how a place stops being merely a location and becomes a conversation. Singapore became a conversation about economic possibility. Hong Kong became a conversation about globalization itself. Dubai became a conversation about movement. Shanghai became a conversation about return. The ring listened to each of them, and then, without any ceremony at all, engraved their names around the edge of a dial because humanity had quietly decided they had become indispensable.</p><p>Airports and Ports</p><p>Few, in my experience, write about World Timers and containers in the same sentence, which is a shame, because the ring cannot really be understood without both.</p><p>The complication was born maritime. Cottier’s earliest rosters read like a steamship company’s timetable: Bombay, Shanghai, Yokohama, Rio, Cairo, because in 1931 that is what the map of global connection actually looked like. Harbors, coaling stations, the handful of ports through which an empire’s cargo and correspondence had to pass. A city earned its place on that early ring the same way it earned its place on a shipping line’s schedule, by sitting at a useful distance from the last stop and the next one.</p><p>Two revolutions have since rewritten that logic almost completely, and it is worth naming them plainly, because collectors tend to discuss the watches while skipping the infrastructure that made the modern roster inevitable.</p><p>The first is containerization. It sounds like a dry engineering footnote and turns out to be one of the more consequential ideas of the twentieth century: standardize the box, and you standardize the port, the crane, the ship, and eventually the working day of everyone downstream of the cargo. Malacca, Suez and Panama had mattered as chokepoints for centuries; container shipping made a small number of ports, Singapore, Shanghai, Rotterdam, and more recently Dubai’s Jebel Ali, matter in an entirely different way, as the coordination points of a supply chain rather than merely the crossing points of a strait. Singapore’s decision to align its clock with UTC plus eight makes considerably more sense once you understand it this way: a port that handles a fifth of the world’s transshipment containers cannot afford to keep its own hours. Trade did not simply pass through Singapore. It reorganized Singapore’s relationship to time itself.</p><p>The second revolution is aviation, and it has done to the ring’s logic in the past sixty years roughly what containerization did to the ports. The World Timer originally reflected a maritime civilization; today it increasingly reflects an airborne one. Consider where the modern roster clusters: Dubai’s ninety million annual passengers, Changi’s perennial place among the world’s finest hubs, Heathrow’s enduring weight as a financial and logistical gateway at once, Narita and Haneda anchoring Tokyo’s claim, JFK doing the same for New York, Charles de Gaulle for Paris. Airports have become to the twenty-first century ring what harbors were to Cottier’s original one: the places where a city’s claim to indispensability gets tested daily, in passenger counts and cargo tonnage rather than tariff schedules.</p><p>This is also, I think, why certain cities keep their seats regardless of the political weather, Hong Kong’s case being one example already discussed. Geneva is a more interesting one, because it has no airport of any comparable scale, and no port at all, and yet it keeps its seat: the connectivity it offers is diplomatic rather than logistical. Planes and container ships move goods; Geneva moves agreements (from time to time), which turn out to be just as capable of reorganizing where cities sit on a ring.</p><p>One can read the whole roster, in fact, as a layered history of how goods and people have moved across a century: a maritime layer laid down by Cottier and inherited more or less intact by Vacheron and early Patek references, an aviation layer added as commercial flight matured through the 1960s and 1970s, and now something closer to a digital layer, in which a city’s claim rests as much on its role as a data or financial hub as on anything moving through its harbor or its arrivals hall. The three layers do not replace one another so much as accumulate, the way sediment does, and a careful reader of any given city ring can usually tell which layer a particular reference was engraved to reflect.</p><p>None of this makes the earlier, more romantic account of the World Timer wrong. It simply completes it. The ring has always been a map of where humanity chooses to gather; it happens that, for most of the century in question, the answer to “where do people gather” has been answerable in cargo manifests and flight schedules before it becomes answerable in the language of culture or diplomacy. Trade, in the plainest sense, has done a great deal of the work of choosing these twenty-four names. The rest of this piece is largely about what happens once trade has made its choice, and civilization has to decide whether to agree with it.</p><p>The City Ring Votes</p><p>No city ring is ever politically neutral. The proposition occasionally surprises collectors, perhaps because we like to imagine that time is somehow objective; it is not. Humanity negotiated time before it ever learned to wear it on the wrist. Time zones are diplomatic compromises masquerading as geographical inevitabilities, products of history, economics and occasionally plain stubbornness, and the World Timer inherited every one of those contradictions along with the mechanism.</p><p>Every generation asks it the same questions: which city speaks for UTC plus eight? Which civilization speaks through that city? Which understanding of the world do we wish to preserve? There are no technically correct answers to any of these, only choices, and the ring makes them quietly, every generation, in decisions that are rarely unanimous.</p><p>I have spent enough of my career sitting in negotiating rooms to have developed an occupational habit of reading cities the way a collector reads a dial, and I want to spend part of this chapter on that habit directly, because it is the one contribution to this subject that a watch journalist may not make. Cities possess personalities, and you learn this faster at the negotiating table than you do anywhere else. Geneva negotiates differently from New York, more patiently, more procedurally, with a preference for the quiet corridor conversation over the public statement. Brussels speaks in institutions, endlessly fluent in the grammar of directives and working groups. Singapore speaks in efficiency, arriving at meetings having already done the arithmetic everyone else is still doing in the room. Tokyo speaks in preparation, rarely improvising, never underprepared. Washington speaks in clarity, sometimes to a fault. Nairobi speaks in coalition, building numbers before building arguments. None of this is written down anywhere, and all of it is instantly recognizable to anyone who has sat across a table from delegations representing each of these places more than once. The city ring, I have come to think, was teaching me this lesson years before any actual negotiation confirmed it: a city’s name is shorthand for a way of doing business with the world, and the ring has always understood that, whether or not the watchmakers engraving it ever set foot in a single one of these rooms.</p><p>Perhaps nowhere on the ring is the underlying vote more visible than in the long argument over UTC plus eight. Should Beijing speak for it? Should Hong Kong? Should Singapore? Could Taipei make an equally compelling case? Geography settled the matter long ago; civilization continues to debate it. There was a time when Hong Kong’s place seemed almost inevitable; few cities better embodied globalization during the latter half of the twentieth century, with capital flowing through its institutions in astonishing volumes and East meeting West in both literal and figurative ways. Hong Kong did not simply become wealthy. It became connected, and connectivity has always been one of the ring’s preferred languages. But history is not static; political realities evolve, and the question of whether Hong Kong should remain because globalization still speaks fluently through it, or whether Beijing should now speak with the confidence of a different kind of influence, has no answer that satisfies everyone. Both positions are simultaneously correct and incomplete. At least one Swiss house has declined to choose: Tissot’s Heritage Navigator quietly uses Shanghai to speak for UTC plus eight, sidestepping the Hong Kong Beijing argument entirely by nominating a third candidate nobody at the negotiating table can object to on political grounds. The ring occasionally disagrees with economists; civilization occasionally disagrees with commerce; and that disagreement, uncomfortable as it is, tells you rather more about the present moment than either side’s preferred statistic does.</p><p>Moscow makes a related point from an older archive. Collectors have long understood that you can date a vintage World Timer without ever opening its case, simply by reading the cities engraved around it. Peking belongs to another age; so do Bombay and Saigon. Their continued existence on vintage dials preserves moments in history more faithfully than most textbooks manage. Moscow moved westward not because geography changed its mind but because legislators did, shifting the clock from UTC plus four to plus three between 2014 and 2016 in a decision explicitly framed as drawing Russia closer, at least on paper, to Western Europe. The World Timer records these decisions. It does not adjudicate them, though it cannot help but preserve them.</p><p>The most complete answer to the question of whether time zones are political rather than natural, though, comes from a watch that never much bothered with the Swiss consensus. In 1970, the Soviet manufacturer Raketa produced its own ‘Goroda’ (Cities, World Time), and its roster reads like a parallel planet. Moscow and Leningrad anchor it, predictably enough. Less predictably, Tokyo is gone; Vladivostok speaks for the Pacific instead, with Magadan and Anadyr, two Soviet cities deep in the Arctic Far East, filling zones a Western dial would have given to Honolulu or Anchorage. London and Paris survive, oddly, alongside a wall of Warsaw Pact capitals, Warsaw, Prague, Budapest, Bucharest, Sofia, plus Beirut, Tehran, Kabul and Tashkent standing in for Soviet interests along the southern border, and Delhi occupying the seat no Western watchmaker has ever given it. Raketa was not showing the world as it was. It was showing the world as Moscow needed its own citizens to see it: a geography organized entirely around Soviet reach, with New York, Tokyo and most of Western Europe simply absent from the conversation. A parallel line of Raketa twenty-four-hour ‘Polar’ dials, built through the 1970s for submariners and crews working through the Arctic’s months-long night, abandoned the city ring format altogether in favor of function, proof that even inside a single Soviet workshop, watchmakers occasionally decided that geography mattered less than survival. Nothing could make the case for the ring’s political nature more plainly than a second, entirely coherent map of the same planet, built by people who had decided that a different twenty-four cities deserved to matter.</p><p>Faith enters the conversation too, in a register the ring handles with unexpected elegance. Certain World Timers render Mecca in green, the color long associated with Islam. This choice looks at first like mere ornament and turns out to be considerably more interesting than that. Economics alone cannot explain humanity’s understanding of civilization, nor can politics or commerce; religion has shaped cities and collective imagination for millennia, and pilgrimage remains one of the oldest and most enduring forms of human movement, older by a wide margin than anything in the contemporary vocabulary of globalization. Patek’s Gulf market limited editions, with Mecca picked out in green against the standard roster, are as much a piece of religious diplomacy as they are a marketing decision, and the two motives are not, on reflection, easy to separate.</p><p>There are, of course, cities whose relationship with the ring is more complicated than simple exclusion, Istanbul, Florence, Delhi and Lagos among them. The ring is not always fair in distributing immortality, and its decisions are neither obvious nor necessarily permanent, a subject I take up properly in the next chapter, because the injustice of the roster turns out to be almost as revealing as its logic.</p><p>Permanence, in the end, is something of an illusion here. London has survived where empires have not; Tokyo endured past the point many observers once doubted; Geneva keeps speaking softly from its place on the shore, refusing to surrender the invitation. New cities will almost certainly join this conversation in the century ahead, and others will depart without ceremony, because the ring has always understood, better, frankly, than most of the institutions I have spent my career working alongside, that civilization remains unfinished. It votes quietly every generation. It always has. Very few of us have remembered to count the ballots.</p><p>Cities That Almost Made It</p><p>Civilization, it would appear, is occasionally unfair in distributing immortality, and nowhere is that unfairness more entertaining to sit with than in the roster of cities that have never once appeared on a ring.</p><p>In 2000, Patek’s Ref. 5110 consolidated the sprawling vintage rosters into a lean, modern twenty-four, and Vienna, along with Prague, Budapest, Warsaw, Stockholm, Oslo and Helsinki, an entire tier of European capitals that had shared the dial with it for decades, did not make the cut. The World Timer has never much cared what a city has given to the species; it cares what the species currently cannot do without, and it turns out to be entirely possible to imagine modern civilization without Vienna in a way that had become, by the late 1990s, considerably harder to imagine without Dubai or Hong Kong.</p><p>Florence presents an even starker version of the same injustice. Were beauty the qualification, the name would have gone on a dial before Cottier had finished his prototype. Florence gave humanity Michelangelo, Dante and Brunelleschi and remains difficult to imagine modern civilization without, yet remarkably easy to imagine modern globalization without, which is precisely the distinction the ring has been drawing, whether or not it ever announced it was doing so. It rewards indispensability rather than influence, and those are not, on inspection, the same question at all.</p><p>Istanbul’s case sits somewhere between Vienna’s and Florence’s. The city served as the capital of three separate empires and sits, quite literally, astride the boundary between two continents, a geography that ought to make it one of the more obvious candidates for a complication built entirely around the idea of connection. It did appear briefly on the largest vintage rosters: the sprawling forty-one-city pocket references of the 1930s and 1950s found room for it alongside Tehran and Karachi. It never survived the industry’s consolidation to twenty-four, and has not reappeared since, possibly for reasons closer to the ones that keep Taipei off most modern rosters entirely; a handful of Patek’s regional limited editions have quietly swapped in Doha, Bogotá or Taipei for a single market run and then just as quietly swapped them back out. Putting a name on a dial is itself a small diplomatic statement, and some names carry more complication than a watchmaker wants to engrave permanently.</p><p>India offers the starkest case of all, precisely because it is not a single city’s disappearance from the roster but an entire civilization’s. Bombay shared a dial with London and Paris on every roster from Cottier’s earliest prototypes through the mid 1940s; Calcutta outlasted it considerably, holding its seat all the way through the Ref. 2523’s final run in 1965. The Partition in 1947 complicated matters further, elevating Karachi as Pakistan’s new capital even as Calcutta held its own for nearly two more decades. Then, in 2000, the consolidation to a modern twenty-four, Karachi and Dhaka, Pakistan and Bangladesh, both younger states than India itself, dropped every Indian city entirely. The half-hour time zone could explain it, yet a country of more than a billion people, home to one of the world’s fastest-growing economies, has not held a single seat on a standard modern World Timer of consequence in over a quarter century. Population, again, turns out not to be the currency this complication trades in, a fact I find genuinely useful to sit with, given how much of my own professional life is spent negotiating around exactly that kind of statistic.</p><p>São Paulo speaks for a related absence, from the same hemisphere as Buenos Aires but without that city’s considerably longer history on the dial. Buenos Aires had, in fact, shared rings with Rio de Janeiro on and off since the 1930s; what changed in 2016 was that Patek’s Ref. 5230 replaced Rio outright, giving Buenos Aires sole custody of the region’s seat on the modern standard roster for the first time. São Paulo, despite being the region’s largest financial center by a wide margin, has rarely held that seat, which tells you something about how conservative the ring remains even as it rearranges itself elsewhere.</p><p>Lagos may become one of the great megacities of this century; it already represents one of Africa’s principal economic and cultural centers, and speaks increasingly confidently in the language of innovation and entrepreneurship. There was once a time when Singapore looked like an unlikely candidate for immortality too, and it is not difficult to imagine future collectors wondering how civilization failed to recognize Lagos’s significance sooner. Johannesburg makes a parallel case from the continent’s opposite coast, anchoring the region’s financial infrastructure in a way that has yet to translate into a seat at this particular table. Nairobi, meanwhile, has become one of the more interesting coalition builders in multilateral settings, a city whose diplomatic weight in African trade groupings considerably exceeds what its airport statistics alone would suggest, and which may, in time, make its case to the ring on institutional grounds rather than commercial ones, much as Geneva once did.</p><p>Seoul and Tel Aviv round out the list of conspicuous absences for reasons that have less to do with each other than with the specific blind spots of an aging roster. Seoul anchors one of the world’s genuinely significant technology economies and sits within one of the busiest air corridors on earth, yet has never displaced Tokyo’s claim to represent the region on a standard ring; Tel Aviv has built, in a single generation, one of the most consequential technology sectors per capita anywhere on the planet, a fact that has yet to register on any dial I have seen. Both cases suggest the ring’s economic instincts, while generally sound, lag the underlying data by longer than collectors like to admit.</p><p>There are more than ten thousand cities on earth and only twenty-four invitations to this particular table. Twenty-four is a remarkably small number, and the ring has always rewarded movement with a generosity it does not consistently extend to beauty, history, or population. The World Timer does not principally reward influence. It rewards indispensability, a word I have needed most of this essay to arrive at properly, though I suspect it has been waiting patiently since the first page. The ring asks every city the same question: has humanity decided it can no longer comfortably imagine itself without the conversation taking place there? If the answer is yes, the city survives. If the answer is no, it departs, however unfair that verdict may look from Florence’s side of the ledger.</p><p>I do not think this injustice undermines the complication. I think it is the most honest feature of the complication. A watch that tried to rank the greatest cities in human history would need to include Athens, Jerusalem, Florence and Vienna, and would need considerably more than twenty-four positions to do it. A watch that tried to preserve the world’s largest cities would need still more room and would, within a decade, look like a phone book rather than a dial. The World Timer has never attempted either project. What it attempts, imperfectly but with real elegance, is to preserve humanity’s changing understanding of where civilization presently resides, and that understanding, being a judgment rather than a census, will always leave someone out. Every city missing from the dial forces the question of why another remains, and that question, I have come to think, is more interesting than any answer this essay or any other could give it.</p><p>The Dial as a Map</p><p>The remarkable thing about a World Timer is not that it tells the time in twenty-four places at once. It is that it tells you what the world looked like when it was made, and if you are willing to sit with the watches themselves rather than the argument I have been making around them, the individual references make that case better than any essay can.</p><p>Start with the Ref. 1415. Collectors rarely single it out for beauty, and rightly so; earlier and later references are, on strictly aesthetic terms, more accomplished. Its importance is historical rather than decorative: it was the first Cottier-based world timer to reach series production in 1939, which sounds like a modest distinction until you consider what it actually meant. Every world timer before it had been a private commission, a conversation between one patron and one workshop about which twenty-four cities deserved a place on his particular wrist. The 1415 turned that private conversation into a standing offer. Anyone with sufficient means could now buy into Cottier’s premise rather than negotiate it from scratch. That shift, from bespoke philosophy to commercially available product, did more to secure the complication’s survival than any single mechanical refinement that followed. Watchmaking has always cared about firsts; this is the first that mattered.</p><p>The Ref. 2523, introduced in 1953 with a second crown that allowed the wearer to rotate the city ring independently of the movement, deserves its own subsection rather than a passing mention, because it is arguably the single most consequential reference in the complication’s history and the one that auction houses treat accordingly. Part of its appeal is mechanical: the dual-crown system it introduced became, in modified form, the basis of nearly every world timer that followed, including the Ref. 240 HU calibers still running in Patek’s current production. Part of its appeal is aesthetic: certain examples were produced with cloisonné enamel dials mapping all of Eurasia beneath the city ring, a level of decorative ambition that turned the watch into a genuine object of applied art rather than a mere instrument. And part of its appeal, frankly, is rarity; total production across the reference’s roughly decade-long run is estimated in the low hundreds, and surviving examples with their original enamel intact command some of the highest prices any wristwatch of the period has ever achieved. Every Ref. 2523 that survives preserves not merely a moment in horological history but a specific mid-century understanding of which twenty-four cities constituted the civilized world, Peiping rather than Beijing, Moscou rather than Moscow, spellings and choices that date the watch as precisely as a hallmark.</p><p>It is worth pausing here to compare two watches that collectors constantly reference yet rarely examine closely: the World Timer and the Rolex GMT Master. The two are frequently discussed in the same breath, and they could hardly be more different in what they were built to do. The GMT Master was born from a specific commercial partnership with Pan American Airways in the mid 1950s, designed to give pilots and crew flying the new transatlantic and transpacific routes a way to track two time zones at once, home and away, nothing more ambitious than that. It is a magnificent traveler’s watch, and it remains one, but it was never conceived to represent the world; it was conceived to represent a single flight crew’s practical problem. The World Timer emerged from a different set of instincts entirely, out of Geneva rather than an airline’s operations department, answering a question about civilization rather than jet lag. One watch reflects aviation. The other reflects a city that had, by the 1930s, begun to think of itself as the address of the international conversation itself. That is not a value judgment; the GMT Master’s practical genius is real, and I would not want to fly transpacific without one on a colleague’s wrist even now, but it is a distinction worth holding onto, because conflating the two complications’ philosophies is the single most common category error collectors make when discussing either.</p><p>Vacheron Constantin took Cottier’s premise in a more explicitly artistic direction almost from the start, and their modern references make the point most clearly. The Patrimony Traditionnelle World Time, introduced in 2011, was the first watch to display all thirty-seven of the world’s time zones rather than the traditional twenty-four whole-hour cities, adding Kathmandu, Tehran, Mumbai, and a handful of other half- and quarter-hour outliers in red against the standard cities in black. What that decision actually concedes: the twenty-four city convention Cottier established was always a simplification, smoothing over the roughly dozen zones on earth that run on fractional offsets, and Vacheron’s choice to show all thirty-seven rather than round them away is itself a small argument about honesty in cartography. Their Overseas World Time followed in 2016 with a sportier case and the same thirty-seven-zone logic, and the house’s most recent anniversary edition in 2025 treats the full thirty-seven-zone map as something close to a house signature. Where Patek has generally treated the complication as an institution, each successive reference reflecting continuity rather than rupture, Vacheron has treated it as a cartographer’s ongoing argument about what a map owes its reader.</p><p>Andersen Genève deserves more space in any serious account of this subject than it typically receives, and for a reason that has nothing to do with marketing: Svend Andersen, the house’s founder, worked at Patek Philippe during the era when the 1415 and 2523 were still current production, and later became one of the small handful of people anywhere who genuinely understood Cottier’s system from the inside rather than by reverse engineering an old reference. His own watches under the Andersen Genève name, the ultra-thin Mundus, at 4.2 millimeters still the thinnest world timer ever produced, or the 1992 Christophorus Columbus, which set the city ring over a map of the 1492 Atlantic crossing, read less like commercial products than like a private conversation continuing across sixty years with a mentor who happened to have died in 1966. That intellectual lineage, direct and personal rather than merely stylistic, is rare enough in watchmaking to merit a plain name: Andersen is not paying tribute to Cottier from a respectful distance. He is one of the last people who can claim to have actually worked alongside him.</p><p>The modern field has widened considerably beyond these three houses, and the widening tells its own story. Omega’s Seamaster Aquaterra Worldtimer, introduced in 2017 with a laser-etched map of the northern hemisphere, quietly includes Bienne, Omega’s own hometown, among its twenty-four cities, a small piece of house pride tucked into an otherwise standard roster. Montblanc’s 4810 Orbis Terrarum offers the complication at a considerably more accessible price point without disturbing the standard modern city list. Glashütte Original took the opposite approach entirely with its Senator Cosmopolite. Rather than named cities, it shows IATA airport codes across thirty-five to thirty-seven zones, engineering asserting itself over romance in a distinctly German register. Bulgari’s Octo Roma Worldtimer foregrounds Rome within an otherwise standard modern roster, an Italian house quietly asserting its own capital’s presence on a dial that has never given it top billing. Louis Vuitton’s Escale Worldtime abandons the named city ring altogether in favor of painted color coded flags, which collectors have variously described as heresy and as the logical next step once you accept that the ring was always more about identity than about literal cartography. And a wave of independent and mid-tier makers, Czapek, Frédérique Constant, the deliberately spare NOMOS approach that abandons city clutter almost entirely, Jack Mason’s quartz Pursuit Worldtimer with its unlikely Dallas code tucked into the American zone, show that the conversation Cottier started in 1931 has never stopped attracting new voices, some reverent, some skeptical of the entire premise. Even the quartz crisis, which very nearly ended mechanical watchmaking altogether, produced its own contribution: Citizen and Casio’s world time quartz lines of the 1980s reduced the whole complication to a ring of airport codes on a rubber strap, and did more than any Swiss house to put the idea of tracking twenty-four cities into ordinary pockets rather than vitrines.</p><p>Some of the most revealing cases, though, are not standard production at all but the one-off pieces and short-run editions that brands make for a single market, a single anniversary, or a single person, and these deserve their own accounting, because a limited edition is where a watchmaker’s usual discretion briefly slips and the politics of the dial become explicit rather than implied. Patek’s Ref. 5230G Manama, made in a run of fifty for Bahrain’s fiftieth anniversary in 2017, swapped Moscow for Manama outright on a flag red dial, proof that a seat on the standard ring is never quite as permanent as it looks, even for a matter of months, if the right anniversary and the right client happen to align. The house’s 2019 Ref. 5230G Mexico, discussed earlier, did something similar in spirit for a market rather than an anniversary. Its Ref. 5930G Singapore and Ref. 5230G New York, both limited to three hundred pieces around the same period, kept the standard roster intact but recolored a single city in red or added local skyline relief, flattery rather than substitution, and a considerably gentler diplomatic gesture than swapping Manama in for Moscow. A 2019 boutique edition made for an Italian retailer went further still, moving Rome into the twelve o’clock position Cottier had reserved for Paris since 1937, a small act of cartographic mutiny that Bulgari’s own Rome foregrounding Octo, discussed above, stops just short of committing. The 2011 series of Ref. 5130 country discs went furthest of all in this direction, quietly rotating in Doha, Bogotá or Taipei for a single regional run before rotating them back out again, treating the dial itself as a diplomatic credential extended and then withdrawn.</p><p>The strangest piece unique of all has nothing to do with statecraft. In 2022, Patek produced a single charity watch for the musician Ed Sheeran, in which London, a city that has anchored every serious World Timer since Cottier’s own prototype, was quietly replaced by Framingham, Sheeran’s own small hometown in Suffolk, on a pale blue dial. It is a joke, in a sense, and a rather good one: the same complication that has spent ninety years adjudicating which capitals matter to the whole of civilization can, for one collector with sufficient means and a charitable cause attached, decide that his own village matters more than London does. Nothing could demonstrate more clearly that the twenty-four names on any given ring were never natural law. They are a series of decisions, made by particular people for particular reasons. Every so often, Framingham standing in for London, Manama standing in for Moscow, Shanghai foregrounded in red on Patek’s 2020 market edition for mainland China, the watchmaker tells you so directly, rather than leaving you to work it out from the pattern of what changed and what didn’t. There is an older precedent for this kind of casual improvisation, in fact, dating to WWII itself: American market Cottier based watches of the early 1940s reportedly swapped Samoa for Midway at UTC minus eleven, not for any commercial reason but because Midway had just become famous for a naval battle and Samoa, for the moment, had not.</p><p>Look at a Ref. 2523 beside a contemporary Ref. 5330, and at first glance remarkably little appears to have changed: twenty-four cities still circle the dial, local time still sits at the center while the world patiently revolves around it, Cottier’s original insight remains as elegant now as when he first drew it up. Look a little longer, and the differences accumulate. Some names have vanished. Others have taken their place. Certain spellings have shifted; certain political identities have changed without the underlying geography moving an inch. These are not merely different watches. They are different maps, and every map embeds an editorial decision: what to include, what to omit, which city gets to stand in for an entire time zone, which name best captures an age. Cartographers have wrestled with exactly these questions for centuries. World Timer manufacturers continue to wrestle with them today. Their maps happen to fit on a wrist.</p><p>The Future City Ring</p><p>Every account of this complication eventually has to ask an uncomfortable question: if Louis Cottier were designing his invention today in Geneva, with the same instincts that produced the 1931 prototype, would he choose the same twenty-four cities the industry still largely defaults to?</p><p>I doubt it, and I think the doubt is worth taking seriously rather than treating as idle speculation. Cottier was not a nostalgic man; his entire achievement was to read his own moment accurately rather than to inherit someone else’s map unexamined. A Cottier working today would have to reckon with a set of facts his 1931 self could not have imagined, and I suspect several current fixtures of the standard roster would not survive the reckoning.</p><p>Would he still choose Hong Kong, given the argument already underway between its trade weight and its shifting political status? Possibly, on the strength of that cargo tonnage alone, the ring has kept cities on weaker grounds than a busiest in the world claim. Would he add Shenzhen, whose manufacturing and technology output now rivals cities several times its age and international profile, or would he judge it still too young, too recently built, to have earned the kind of institutional memory the ring seems to prize? Would India, absent from any standard roster for over a quarter century, finally be granted a seat, and if so, would it go to Delhi’s diplomatic weight, Mumbai’s financial one, or Bangalore’s claim as one of the world’s genuine technology capitals? Would Lagos, finally, arrive, and if it did, would it arrive on the strength of population, of its technology sector, or simply because enough time had passed that its absence became more conspicuous than its inclusion would be? Would São Paulo finally receive the invitation this essay’s previous chapter suggested it has long deserved?</p><p>There is a harder question underneath all of these, and I think it is the more interesting one: does the ring need to grow? Vacheron’s decision to show all thirty-seven zones rather than the traditional twenty-four already concedes that twenty-four was always a convenience rather than a natural number, smoothing away half-hour and quarter-hour offsets for the sake of a cleaner dial. If the future rewards precision over elegance, and digital displays, which can show any number of zones without running out of room, suggest it might, then the twenty-four-city format inherited from 1931 could eventually look as quaint as a fixed Paris-at-noon dial looks today. Or the opposite could happen: faced with genuinely too many claimants and a format that punishes crowding, the industry could retreat toward an even smaller, more curated number, on the theory that scarcity is precisely what makes the current twenty-four feel like an honor rather than a directory listing.</p><p>I do not know the answer, and I am suspicious of anyone who claims to. What I do think is that the question itself, is twenty-four sacred, or merely traditional, is a genuinely philosophical one dressed up as a design decision, and that Cottier, whatever he would have chosen, would have recognized it as the right question to be asking. He built a watch that assumed the world was a single conversation. The only honest way to honor that assumption is to keep asking, as the conversation keeps changing, who still belongs in the room.</p><p>A Movable Feast of Cities</p><p>Every collector develops a ritual eventually. Some admire the movement before fastening a watch to the wrist; others linger over the hands or the texture of the dial as it catches the morning light. Mine has always begun elsewhere. I read the cities. London. Geneva. Moscow. Dubai. Singapore. Tokyo. Each name calls up something beyond the place itself, a negotiation, a friendship, a dinner that ran longer than planned because the conversation proved too interesting to end, the particular satisfaction of recognizing a skyline before the aircraft has properly landed. A World Timer has never been merely a watch to me. It has always been closer to a passport.</p><p>For me, Geneva is no longer a location so much as a symbol of conversation itself, a case I have already made at length, and will not remake here.</p><p>And then there is Guadalajara, which has never appeared on a single ring and likely never will. I do not think its absence diminishes it; if anything, it reinforces the essay’s real argument: the twenty-four cities on any given dial were never the only cities that mattered. They are merely the twenty-four that a particular generation, working within the limits of a particular format, chose to represent itself. Every reader of this essay could add a city of their own, wherever they were born, wherever they fell in love, wherever they found their vocation, and the ring was never built to hold all of them. It was built to remind us that the world extends well beyond our own experience of it, which strikes me, nearly a century after Cottier first drew up the idea, as an unusually generous thing for a wristwatch to attempt.</p><p>I confess, I would like to own one of those blue-collar World Timers one day. Not a Patek, not a Vacheron, not something that requires a second mortgage. Something honest, something that proves the complication belongs to everyone who moves through the world, not merely to those who can afford an enamel dial. The kind of watch a diplomat might wear on a quiet weekend, or a pilot between flights, or a collector who has spent more years reading city rings than wearing them. I suspect I am not quite there yet, but the aspiration sits somewhere in the same part of me that keeps returning to these twenty-four names.</p><p>For now, I am happy with my Rado Captain Cook World Timer Over-Pole reference R32116158. It is not the thinnest, not the rarest, not the one auction houses fight over. But it tells the same twenty-four hours, the same cities, the same quiet argument about which places matter. It sits on the wrist the way a well-worn passport sits in a jacket pocket, unassuming, familiar, ready. And there is something I appreciate about that, about a watch that does not demand attention but still answers the question when you ask it.</p><p>That Rado has accompanied me on more trips than I can easily count, through terminals and time zones I would otherwise have blurred together. It has sat beside hotel room phones and boarding gate displays, silently registering each hour as I crossed it. Strangers have noticed it; more than once, a question about the dial has turned into a conversation, a shared drink, a brief acquaintance struck up in the liminal space between departures and arrivals. I have given longer explanations about the history of Cottier, the politics of UTC plus eight, and the injustice of Delhi’s absence from the standard roster than most of my interlocutors likely bargained for. They asked about the watch. I gave them the lecture they did not know they were requesting.</p><p>I have said, more than once, across the corridors of the WTO, and I have written about it as well, that the GMT is the most diplomatic of complications, the one that lets you know what time it is back home while you sit in a negotiating room arguing about tariffs. But the more I have lived with this Rado, watching those twenty-four names circle the dial, the more I suspect the World Timer may be the ultimate diplomatic complication. The GMT asks where you are from. The World Timer asks where the world is gathering. One is personal; the other is planetary. One tracks your anchor; the other tracks the conversation itself. And diplomacy, I have learned, is never about the single voice but about the room full of them, each speaking from a different hour, each waiting for the right moment to be heard. I have repeated that observation often enough that colleagues have begun to expect it, the way they expect Geneva to be cold in March or the coffee in the WTO cafeteria to be reliably terrible. The World Timer, I tell them, is the complication that understands what we do here. It just happens to do it in gold and steel rather than in legal texts.</p><p>And so, when I recall the mosaic of cities I have carried with me, it is not just the memory of the places themselves, but the small human connections forged around a rotating bezel and a disk of names. The watch has become a quiet accomplice in that work, a conversation starter that never intended to start one, a compass that points not north but toward the nearest gathering of people who, like me, have found themselves living between time zones.</p><p>Time, I have come to think, behaves the same way in memory as cities do. We carry a few of them permanently, others teach us something and let us go, and a handful quietly change how we understand the world’s shape. Cottier understood this before most of us did. He engraved twenty-four of them around the edge of a dial and left the rest of the invitation unwritten, for each owner to fill in on their own.</p><p>Every World Timer tells the time. The best ones also tell the story of civilization, not the whole of it, never the whole of it, only the twenty-four names a particular generation was willing to stand behind. That may be the most honest thing any watch has ever managed to do.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2c77ed6464d1" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/classroom/the-city-ring-votes-how-a-watch-complication-quietly-voted-on-the-shape-of-the-world-2c77ed6464d1">The City Ring Votes: How a watch complication quietly voted on the shape of the World</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/classroom">Classroom</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The World Cup’s Beautiful Truce]]></title>
            <link>https://rivasrod.medium.com/the-world-cups-beautiful-truce-857b8728c640?source=rss-c519b7f88399------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/857b8728c640</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[fifa]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[diplomacy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[world-cup]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[international-relations]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[football]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Rodolfo C. Rivas]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 02 Jul 2026 10:55:09 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-07-02T13:38:55.076Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/624/1*r-Ltz2Y6GK0LQa93yo3KpA.png" /></figure><p>Multilateralism is not a career I chose. It is closer to an inheritance. My chosen family comes from Kenya. I live in Switzerland. I work on behalf of Israel. I see many differences among us, but also countless similarities. Three continents sit inside a single household, and I did not have to travel far to learn that people from different worlds can share a table, a language, a purpose, without erasing what makes each of them distinct. Long before I sat across a negotiating table for a living, I sat across a dinner table that already looked like the United Nations. That is the lens I bring to everything, including a football match. It is why the World Cup does not strike me as an exception to how the world works. It strikes me as proof of it.</p><p>Geneva runs on treaties, even now. I spend my days inside rooms where nations argue over tariff schedules and procurement thresholds, where a single word in an annex can take eighteen months to settle. Consensus here is slow. It is earned sentence by sentence, and it rarely feels like triumph. It feels like relief, the kind that comes after holding your breath too long.</p><p>Then the World Cup starts, and for ninety minutes at a time, the planet agrees on something instantly. A ball crosses a line. Everyone in the stadium knows what just happened before the referee’s arm goes up. No committee convenes. No reservation is filed. No delegation asks for a footnote reflecting its objection. The goal simply is, and it belongs equally to the fan in Nairobi, the fan in Seoul, the fan in the bar three streets from my apartment who has never watched a full match in his life and is suddenly on his feet screaming at a television bolted to the wall.</p><p>This summer the tournament is being played across three countries at once. Mexico, the United States, Canada. I carry Mexico in me the way I carry Kenya and Switzerland, and I have watched what it means for three governments to build something at this scale together and hand it to the world without arguing over which flag flies highest above it. Stadiums shared. Logistics shared. A single tournament stitched across a continent, coordinated across time zones and customs regimes and immigration counters, and none of it makes the evening news the way a trade dispute does. That is multilateralism too, though nobody names it that on television. It is easier to notice cooperation when it fails than when it works.</p><p>And it is becoming the pattern rather than the exception. This edition is shared by three nations. The next, in 2030, will be organized jointly by Portugal, Spain and Morocco, a tournament that will stretch across the Strait of Gibraltar and connect Europe to Africa inside a single competition. In addition, in celebration of a century after football’s first global gathering, the game returns to its origins. Montevideo will host the centenary match and ceremony, honoring Uruguay, host and champion of 1930. Argentina will stage a commemorative fixture in tribute to its role as the inaugural finalist. Paraguay, home of CONMEBOL, the only confederation in existence at the dawn of the World Cup, will likewise welcome a match, completing a tribute to the lands where the story first began.</p><p>Some undertakings have simply grown too large for one nation to carry alone, and football’s governing bodies figured that out before most trade ministries did. A stadium grid spanning continents is now easier to organize than a customs union. I notice that as someone whose job is the second thing.</p><p>Football does not pretend to be gentle. It is built on conflict. Two sides want the same outcome and only one can have it, at least in the knockout stages. There is nothing diplomatic about a tackle, nothing consensus-based about a penalty shootout taken in front of eighty thousand people who have traveled continents to watch a young man’s leg decide the outcome. And yet the tournament produces the opposite of what its structure promises. Instead of division, it produces a kind of temporary citizenship. For a month, you belong to whichever flag you are standing under, and the person next to you belongs to another, and neither of you minds. You will trade jerseys with him afterward regardless of who won, and mean it.</p><p>History keeps handing us proof that this is not sentiment, it is mechanism. In 1969, El Salvador and Honduras went to actual war days after a qualifying match, though the tension between them long predated any ball being kicked, the sport only the spark that lit fuel already stacked. I mention that one first because honesty requires it. The ledger is not one sided, and anyone building a case for football’s power to unite owes the record a look at the moments when it did the opposite.</p><p>Cross the ledger the other way and the evidence is just as real, and there is more of it than a single case. In 2005, Ivory Coast’s national team qualified for its first World Cup in the middle of a civil war, and the players, live on national broadcast, knelt and asked their country’s factions to lay down arms. A ceasefire followed soon afterward, with many Ivorians crediting the team’s appeal for helping create the political space for it. Two years later, still divided between a government-held south and a rebel-held north, the same captain asked that an upcoming qualifier against Madagascar be moved out of the capital and played instead in Bouake, the northern city that had become the rebellion’s stronghold. Nobody in football administration is required to think about front lines when scheduling a friendly. He asked anyway, and the match was moved, and for one afternoon a stadium that had spent years on the wrong side of a checkpoint hosted its own national team instead.</p><p>In 1998, Iran and the United States were drawn into the same group in France, two governments that had not exchanged ambassadors in nearly two decades, each federation bracing for the match to become a referendum on everything except football. Instead the players from both sides posed together for a photograph before kickoff, Iranian players presenting the Americans with flowers, both teams walking onto the pitch as one unit rather than two. None of it changed a single line of policy in Washington or Tehran. What it did was give both publics a single image of the other side that had nothing to do with an embassy or a headline, at a moment when almost no other image was available to either.</p><p>Four years later, South Korea and Japan hosted the tournament together, the first World Cup shared by two nations and the first held in Asia. The two countries carry a colonial history neither side has fully settled, and the idea of them coordinating stadiums, logistics, and a shared trophy ceremony struck plenty of observers at the time as close to impossible. They did it anyway, each hosting matches on its own soil under a single tournament banner, and the cooperation required to pull it off, quiet, procedural, unglamorous, did more for the working relationship between the two federations than a decade of separate statements had managed. And in 1994, in the United States, a reunified Germany appeared at its second World Cup as a single nation, players from what had once been separate football systems wearing one shirt, only a few years after that would have been unthinkable. I do not offer any of this as proof that football ends wars or heals colonial wounds or reunifies nations on its own. It does none of those things by itself, and anyone who claims otherwise is selling something. I offer it as a pattern. Time and again, when the tournament arrives at a moment already carrying geopolitical weight, it becomes the occasion where something gets said, or shown, or shared, that the usual channels had not yet found a way to say.</p><p>I witnessed my first World Cup the second time Mexico hosted it, in 1986. I was too young to keep any of it. I have no memory of my own, only photographs and the stories my parents told me. What I do remember is growing up believing that a country only gets that privilege once, maybe twice if the century is generous, and that I would spend my life watching the tournament arrive somewhere else, on some other continent, on someone else’s television. Never in my wildest calculations did I think Mexico would host a third time inside my own lifetime, let alone that I would be fortunate enough to sit inside the stadium and watch it happen with my own eyes rather than read about it later.</p><p>What I saw there confirmed everything my strange, scattered upbringing had already taught me. I watched Mexicans, in Mexican stadiums, adopt the Korean team as their own for an afternoon, singing for players who share not one word of their language, simply because the football on display deserved it. I watched an entire stadium, Mexican flags everywhere, throw its full voice behind Morocco, a country most of the crowd could not have located on a map a decade earlier. Nobody organized that. No federation issued instructions on who to support once your own team was eliminated. It happened because people in a stadium recognize something in strangers that people at a negotiating table often forget to look for.</p><p>One of the finest players wearing Mexico’s colors this tournament was born in Colombia. He came to Mexico young enough that the country is not an adopted home to him so much as the only one he actually remembers building. He grew his game on Mexican fields, married into a Mexican family, and when he scores, someone in Bogota is proud and someone in Guadalajara is equally proud, and both are right to be. Stories like his are not incidental to the tournament. They are the tournament, quietly, underneath the scoreline. A man can become fully of a place without ceasing to be of the place he came from, and once every four years the whole world is handed dozens of proofs of that fact wearing shin guards.</p><p>I think about all of this because my own work is the slow version of the same instinct. Every negotiation I sit through starts from adversarial footing. Delegations want different things, sometimes irreconcilable things, and the room is built for disagreement in the way a football pitch is built for it, with sides and rules and a clock. But somewhere inside that structure, if the process holds, something gets built that neither side could have built alone. A schedule of concessions. A phrase both delegations can live inside. The World Cup compresses that same arc into ninety minutes and repeats it until we reach the final, and the compression makes the lesson easier to see, not harder. Structure does not have to be the enemy of unity. Sometimes it is the only thing that makes unity possible, because it gives both sides a shared set of rules to lose gracefully inside.</p><p>There is a particular kind of quiet that settles over a city during a match its team is playing. I have felt it in Geneva during matches that had nothing to do with Switzerland. Streets empty. Conversations pause mid-sentence. A stranger in a bar looks up at the same moment you do because the same commentator’s voice just changed pitch on every screen in the room. It is one of the only remaining experiences where a large fraction of humanity is looking at the exact same thing, at the exact same second, for the same reason. Not the news, not a market, not a crisis assembled differently by a different algorithm for every person watching it. A ball, a line, a whistle. In an era when two people standing three feet apart can be living in entirely different realities depending on which feed they scroll, that kind of shared second has become close to sacred.</p><p>That scarcity is worth naming honestly. Attention has become the most fragmented resource we have. Everyone is watching something different, believing something different, arguing from a different set of facts curated for them alone. The World Cup does not fix that. It does not solve anything the way a treaty solves something, with binding language and enforcement mechanisms and follow up sessions in Geneva five years later. What it does is simpler, and this year, rarer than it has ever been. It gives several billion people one shared afternoon, with no login required and no algorithm deciding who gets to see it.</p><p>I think of the players themselves, the ones testing the outer edge of what a human body can be asked to do. A striker holding a full sprint in the ninetieth minute of a match played in July heat that would send most of us looking for shade. A goalkeeper reading a ball’s spin in a fraction of a second that no training can fully replicate, only sharpen, guessing right or wrong in front of a stadium and a hundred million more watching from home. There is something honest about watching a body meet its limit in real time, in public, with no way to hide the outcome. Diplomacy hides its failures behind language that calls disagreement a frank exchange of views. Football has no such vocabulary available to it. The scoreboard says what happened, and everyone reads it the same way, in every language, at once.</p><p>What moves me most is not the goals themselves but what happens directly after them. A player from a small nation scores against a giant and the giant’s own fans, some of them, applaud. Commentators who spent a career being paid to be partisan go quiet for a second because the moment asks for silence rather than analysis. A child in a stadium ten thousand kilometers from home holds up a sign in a language the cameras cannot translate fast enough, and it does not matter, because everyone already understood the sign before it was translated. That instinct, to recognize excellence even when it defeats you, is not naive. It is one of the more sophisticated things people do, and we do it more freely at a football match than almost anywhere else in public life.</p><p>None of this erases what the news carries most days. Wars continue while the tournament plays. Negotiations I care about stall while a match somewhere reaches penalties. I am not asking anyone to look away from what is difficult, and I would distrust anyone who told me the tournament makes the difficult things disappear. I am only pointing at something that is, for once, easy, and asking that we let it be easy without apologizing for it. A month where the hardest disagreement most of us will have is over who deserved a red card. A month where three neighboring countries built something together and gave it away for free, to everyone, all at once, and asked for nothing back except that we show up and watch. A preview, in four years, of what Portugal, Spain and Morocco intend to do again across a different sea.</p><p>I will keep negotiating in rooms where the wins are small and the language is careful, where a good outcome is measured in what did not go wrong rather than in what triumphantly did. But I will watch the matches too, and for those ninety minutes I will let the whole complicated apparatus of my profession rest. I will think of my family in Mexico, of Switzerland that gave me a second home, and of the many nations reflected in the friendships I have built throughout my career, and I will recognize, in the stands, exactly what I grew up inside. The ball does not care about jurisdiction. It does not care which delegation walked out of which meeting last week. It only cares about the line, and for one month, so do the rest of us, together, on purpose, out loud.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=857b8728c640" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Background Operator: On Chiefs of Staff, Sydney Adamu, and the Invisible Work That Keeps Everything]]></title>
            <link>https://rivasrod.medium.com/background-operator-fb315685ce4c?source=rss-c519b7f88399------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/fb315685ce4c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[diplomacy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[tv-series]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[leadership]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[chief-of-staff]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[chefs]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Rodolfo C. Rivas]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 28 Jun 2026 20:40:26 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-08-05T07:13:26.788Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h2>Background Operator: On Chiefs of Staff, Sydney Adamu, and the Invisible Work That Keeps Everything Standing</h2><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/768/1*-8_uXBI3N5hVNKYJn6jA9g@2x.jpeg" /></figure><p>By Rodolfo C. Rivas</p><p>There is a thing that happens when you buy a new pair of shoes.</p><p>You walk out of the store in them and for the next three days the whole world appears to be wearing your shoes. The same model. The same color. On strangers on the street. On people at the café. On the feet of the man across the aisle from you who has no idea, and still has no idea, that he is wearing what you are wearing. The shoes were always there. You just were not looking.</p><p>That is what happened to me when I became a Chief of Staff.</p><p>It started with the Camper Peu Boots. Those rounded toes. That deliberate, slightly absurd refusal to look like anything else on the street. I bought them at an outlet store and for weeks afterward I could not walk anywhere in Geneva without seeing them on other people. Strangers had them. Then they started to trickle in to a few colleagues who either had them already or whose feet I had simply never noticed. A senior official at the WTO had them under the table in a room where serious discussions were taking place. I had unlocked something. Not the boots. The noticing. And then, as these things go, I migrated. The Campers gave way to Onitsuka Tigers, Mexico 66, the low profile with the stripe, cleaner, faster-looking, a different kind of statement. And the same thing happened again.</p><p>The point is the noticing. Once you own the thing, you see the thing everywhere. Before you own it, it is invisible.</p><p>That is also what happened with the role.</p><p>I became Chief of Staff of a Diplomatic Mission here in Geneva. And suddenly I saw Chiefs of Staff everywhere. In books I was rereading, in history I thought I already understood, in television I was watching with a glass of something good after the children were finally in bed. I saw the role in places I had not expected to see it, described by words that did not use the title but nonetheless named the function perfectly. I saw it in kitchens and in war rooms. In board meetings and in diplomatic negotiations. In the quiet competence of people who never quite got the credit and who, if they were good at the job, probably preferred it that way.</p><p>And then I got used to having the role. The way you get used to the shoes.</p><p>Last week I was at a reception. I got talking with someone about what I do. Not the organization, not the subject matter, not the technical work. The role. Chief of Staff. And I realized, standing there with a glass of Champagne, that I had not explained this in a while. That I had, in the way of all habituated things, stopped finding it remarkable.</p><p>The person I was talking to had questions. Sincere ones. What do you actually do? Is it like a deputy? Is it like an administrator? Is it political? Is it operational? Is it both?</p><p>I did not have a clean answer. I never do. That is also, I have come to understand, part of the job.</p><p><strong>The Bear, Season Five, Final Service</strong></p><p>I watched <em>The Bear</em> in a state of tension that does not fully resolve even after you pause it to get a glass of water, which you tell yourself you need but which is really just an excuse to breathe for thirty seconds in a kitchen that is not on fire. Christopher Storer’s show is the rare piece of television that makes the invisible visible. It shows you what it costs to make something beautiful. It shows you the infrastructure of excellence and the human wreckage that gets produced alongside it. And in doing so, it gave me, when I started watching it with the eyes of someone who had just become a Chief of Staff, one of the most precise portraits of the role I have ever encountered in any medium.</p><p>Her name is Sydney Adamu.</p><p>She is played by Ayo Edebiri, who has won everything there is to win for this performance and still somehow seems underpraised, because the nature of what she is doing is so embedded in the texture of the show that you can miss it if you are looking at the wrong thing. If you are looking at Carmy, at Jeremy Allen White and all his coiled genius and barely managed self-destruction, you will miss Sydney. That is the point. That is the job.</p><p>Sydney arrives at the Original Beef of Chicagoland as a formally trained chef, a Culinary Institute of America graduate coming off the failure of her own catering business, looking to get back on her feet by working alongside someone she considers the best in the room. She is, at the beginning, a subordinate. A very talented one who knows it. The kind of person who enters a chaotic system and immediately starts making a mental map of every broken thing in it, not because they were asked to, but because they cannot help it. Because that is how they see.</p><p>What she becomes across the seasons is something harder to name. Partner is the word the show eventually settles on. But before the word arrives, there is the function. And the function is Chief of Staff.</p><p>By the end of Season Four, Carmy tells Sydney that she is the Bear. He means it as the highest thing he can say. But that moment, that formal recognition, is almost beside the point. She had been the Bear, in every practical sense, for a long time before anyone said it out loud. The title caught up to the function. That is how it usually works.</p><p><strong>What a Chief of Staff Actually Does</strong></p><p>Let me try the clean answer I did not have at the reception.</p><p>A Chief of Staff is not a deputy. A deputy is a replacement: someone who steps in when the principal is absent and does what the principal would have done. A Chief of Staff is something different. A Chief of Staff is the person who makes the principal more capable of being the principal. They expand capacity. They multiply reach. They manage the things that would otherwise cost the principal too much time, too much attention, or too much of the wrong kind of political capital.</p><p>There are four things a Chief of Staff does. Sydney Adamu does all four of them, with varying degrees of visible credit.</p><p><strong>First: they hold the situational awareness.</strong></p><p>In any organization of meaningful complexity, there is always more happening than the principal can see. The Chief of Staff sees it. Not because they are omniscient, but because they have built the relationships at every level of the organization that allow information to flow to them. They are the person who knows what is actually going on in the kitchen before the morning briefing. They know which vendor relationship is fraying. They know which team member is two bad services away from quitting. They know the thing that no one has put in a memo yet because it has not become a crisis yet, but it will.</p><p>Sydney knows. In scene after scene, she is the person who has already read the room before Carmy walks into it. She knows that Marcus is struggling with something he has not named. She knows that Tina’s pride is being managed badly by the wrong kind of pressure. She knows that Richie’s bravado is structural, that if you remove it too quickly, the whole architecture of his self-regard comes down. She knows these things because she pays attention in a way that the genius at the center of the operation does not always have the bandwidth to.</p><p>In diplomatic work, this is called situational awareness, and it is perhaps the most undervalued intelligence in any mission. I have sat in rooms where a decision was being made in good faith but in near-total ignorance of what was happening three floors below, or in the corridor outside, or in the bilateral meeting that happened yesterday that no one thought to mention. The Chief of Staff is the person whose job it is to know. And to make sure the principal knows. And to know how to tell the principal, because information without timing and framing is just noise.</p><p><strong>Second: they do the invisible work.</strong></p><p>There is a concept in organizational theory called coordination costs. It refers to the effort required to align multiple people, functions, and timelines toward a single goal. In most organizations, these costs are enormous and almost entirely invisible. They are paid by someone, but that someone is rarely recognized for paying them. The Chief of Staff pays them.</p><p>In <em>The Bear</em>, Sydney is constantly paying coordination costs that no one will ever see on a menu. She bridges the gap between Carmy’s vision and the team’s capacity to execute it. She absorbs the shock of his bad days so that it does not crater the service. When the kitchen is in crisis, she works the problem at the level where the problem actually lives: not at the level of vision, but at the level of execution, of the next ten minutes, of how do we get through this service right now.</p><p>Over the course of Season One, when Sydney feels like a fish out of water with a crew that is older, lacking formal training, and bound by long-established loyalties, she wins them over not by asserting authority but by doing the work. By being undeniably competent in the place where competence is the only currency that counts. That is the Chief of Staff move. You do not take power by announcing you have it. You accumulate it by being indispensable. Power in these roles is always demonstrated, never declared.</p><p><strong>Third: they manage relationships at every level.</strong></p><p>The Chief of Staff is not just the principal’s relationship with the organization. They are the organization’s relationship with the principal. They translate upward and downward. They know when to hold information back and when to deliver it immediately. They know whose ego needs managing and whose needs ignoring. They know that the way you say something to the Director of Operations is not the way you say the same thing to the most junior member of the team, even if the information is identical.</p><p>Sydney does this constantly, and it is one of the things the show renders most precisely. The dynamic between Sydney and Richie, who spent much of Season One at each other’s throats to the point where she accidentally stabbed him, becomes over time one of the central emotional relationships of the show. She sees potential in him that he cannot see in himself. She is patient with his chaos in a way that is not sentimental but strategic. She understands that Richie’s energy, properly channeled, is an asset that Carmy cannot provide and Marcus cannot provide and no one else in the kitchen can provide. So she channels it. She manages the relationship not for its own sake but because the organization needs it managed.</p><p>That is what a Chief of Staff does with every relationship in the building. Not friendship for its own sake, though friendship sometimes happens. Management with genuine human warmth underneath it, which is actually harder than it sounds and much rarer than it should be.</p><p><strong>Fourth: they solve problems before they become crises.</strong></p><p>The best Chiefs of Staff are invisible precisely because their work succeeds. The crisis that does not happen. The miscommunication that gets caught before it becomes a rupture. The schedule conflict that gets resolved three days before it would have become a problem. None of this appears in any report. None of it gets celebrated. It is the work of prevention, which is always less dramatic than the work of rescue but infinitely more valuable.</p><p>Sydney, at her best, sees the shape of the disaster that is forming and redirects, absorbs, or defuses it before Carmy has to deal with it. Not because she is protecting his feelings. Because the organization cannot afford the cost of his attention being pulled toward a problem that someone else can handle. Every problem that reaches Carmy is a tax on the one thing the restaurant actually runs on: his cooking. Sydney is the person who keeps that tax as low as possible.</p><p><strong>The People Who Actually Ran the Room</strong></p><p>History is full of Chiefs of Staff who were more powerful than their titles suggested and less famous than the people they served.</p><p>H. R. Haldeman, Richard Nixon’s Chief of Staff, was described by <em>Newsweek</em> as “Richard Nixon’s son-of-a-bitch”, a characterization he reportedly embraced. He was a rigid gatekeeper who controlled access to the president with unusual severity, frequently managing administration officials himself and filtering information before it reached Nixon. This is the iron-hand version of the role. The version that treats the function as one of total control over access, information, and decision. Haldeman made the trains run on time by making absolutely clear what happened to trains that did not. He is remembered, too, as a cautionary figure: the Watergate scandal that destroyed Nixon’s presidency ran, in significant part, through the very command structure Haldeman had built.</p><p>James Baker is the more elegant example and perhaps the most admired White House Chief of Staff in modern American political history. He is the only person to hold the office twice, serving under two different presidents. Baker served Ronald Reagan as Chief of Staff from 1981 to 1985, before moving to the Treasury. Under George H. W. Bush, he served first as Secretary of State and then returned, in 1992, to the Chief of Staff role. The full arc of someone who understood the machinery of power from every angle. Baker grasped something that not all Chiefs of Staff understand: the role is not about accumulating power for oneself. It is about making the principal’s power more usable. He was the person who understood the full board well enough to move pieces on it without the king having to leave the throne. That is a specific and rare intelligence.</p><p>Denis McDonough managed a White House staff running into the thousands during Obama’s second term, Cabinet secretaries, agency leaders, strategic advisers, providing counsel on domestic policy, national security, and the daily management of the executive apparatus. What strikes me about McDonough is not the scale of the operation but the nature of it. He was described, consistently, by people who worked with him as a listener. Someone who knew what was happening in every room of the building not because he demanded reports but because people actually talked to him. That is the relationship infrastructure I mean when I talk about the third function of the role. It is built slowly, over time, through a thousand small conversations that do not look like anything until suddenly they are everything.</p><p>The average tenure for a White House Chief of Staff is just over eighteen months. That number tells you something important about the job. It is not because people are bad at it. It is because the job can eat at you. The coordination costs you pay on behalf of the principal are ultimately paid out of your own reserves. The invisible work is invisible to everyone except you. You know exactly how much it costs. And after a while, the account can run low.</p><p>The ones who last, Baker, McDonough, Andrew Card, who served George W. Bush for a full term and then some, are the ones who found a way to replenish the account. In my case I have managed to do the same, though my job is not the White House. Usually it happens by being genuinely, not performatively, committed to the mission. By believing in what you are doing. By caring about the organization the way you care about something you built yourself, even when you did not.</p><p>John Kelly, the retired Marine general who served Trump as Chief of Staff, offers the cautionary version. His structured, hierarchical approach never quite fit the particular character of the office he served, and the pairing struggled from the start. This is not a political observation. It is an organizational truth. The Chief of Staff role is relational at its core. It depends on a specific and quite particular trust between the principal and the chief, a trust that has to be earned, maintained, and renegotiated constantly as circumstances change. Without it, the role cannot function. With it, the role can function beautifully even in conditions that look from the outside like chaos. Trust is the infrastructure. Everything else runs on top of it.</p><p>The kitchen at <em>The Bear </em>looks like chaos from the outside. From the inside, from Sydney’s inside, it is a system. It is a system with problems and inefficiencies and people who are not always performing at their best and a central genius who is also a central liability. But it is a system. And Sydney understands it as a system, which means she can work on it at the level of the system rather than just reacting to each individual fire as it breaks out.</p><p>That is the difference.</p><p><strong>A Diplomatic Mission in Geneva</strong></p><p>I will not go into operational detail, because that is not what this is and also because I have colleagues who read what I write and some habits of discretion are worth keeping.</p><p>But I can tell you what the role looks like from the inside of a Diplomatic Mission, in a city that is itself a kind of coordination mechanism. A place built for the management of relationships at every level. A place where the invisible architecture of international order is maintained by thousands of people in buildings that tourists walk past without any particular curiosity.</p><p>Geneva is a city of Chiefs of Staff, and most do not use that title. The person who manages the Director-General’s staff at the World Trade Organization. The counsellor who knows which delegation is about to break from the consensus before the delegation itself has fully decided. The delegate who has been in post for four years and who is, in practical terms, the institutional memory of the entire operation. These people run the room. The room does not know this. The room is not supposed to know this.</p><p>When I stepped into this role, the first thing I noticed was that the information landscape was completely different from what it had been in any previous role I had held. As a negotiator, as someone who sits across the table and argues for a position, you see the information that is relevant to your position. You see what you need to see to do your job. As Chief of Staff, your view is broader. You see the position and the arguments behind the position and the relationship dynamics that are going to determine whether the position can actually be advanced and the internal tensions within your own delegation that might complicate the picture. You see a fuller board. It can be, at first, overwhelming. And then, gradually, it becomes the only way you can see. You stop being able to turn it off.</p><p>The second thing I noticed was the meetings before the meetings. This is something that never shows up in any formal account of how decisions get made, but it is where almost all decisions actually get made. The conversation in the corridor before the formal session. The bilateral over coffee that sets the parameters for the plenary. The quiet agreement between two chiefs of staff, even if only one of them has the formal title, that their principals will be positioned in a particular way before they walk into the room. This is where the work happens. And it is invisible by design. The formal session is the announcement of what was already decided in the hallway. The Chief of Staff is the person who was most likely in the hallway.</p><p>Sydney knows this too. The meals before the service. The conversations in the walk-in when no one else is there. The small adjustments to the plan that happen at the level of the kitchen and never make it onto any tasting menu. The real negotiation always happens before the room fills up.</p><p>The third thing, and this is the one I was not fully prepared for, is the loneliness of it. Not in any dramatic sense. Not the loneliness of isolation. The loneliness of being the person who holds a fuller picture in a room where almost no one else does. You cannot share what you know with everyone, because some of it is not yours to share. You cannot always explain your decisions, because the reasons would require more context than the moment allows. You operate with a certain amount of opacity that is not dishonesty but is a kind of discipline. And that discipline, over time, creates a particular kind of solitude.</p><p>I suspect Sydney feels this in every season of <em>The Bear</em>, though the show is too precise to name it. There is a shot, and there are many shots like it, where she is watching Carmy work, watching the team move around him, watching the service unfold, and her expression is unreadable in a way that is not blankness but fullness. She knows too much. She is holding too much. And she has learned to carry it without showing the weight.</p><p>That is the job.</p><p><strong>What Organizations Get Wrong About the Role</strong></p><p>Most organizations that have a Chief of Staff use the role wrong. They use it as a senior assistant. Or as a communications function. Or as a project manager with a better title. And those are all legitimate uses of someone’s time and talent, but they are not what the role is for.</p><p>The role is for organizational intelligence. For the kind of systemic awareness that allows a leader to operate at the level of vision and strategy without losing touch with the level of execution and culture. It is for the management of the gap between what the organization says it is doing and what it is actually doing. It is for the translation work between levels: between the executive suite and the operational floor, between the diplomatic mission and Capital, between Carmy’s impossible standards and the team’s very human limitations.</p><p>When the Chief of Staff is doing the job well, the principal’s reach extends further. Their decisions are better informed. Their relationships are better maintained. Their time is better spent. The organization moves faster and more coherently because there is someone whose specific job is to ensure that the principal’s attention is being used at the highest possible level.</p><p>When it goes badly, the Chief of Staff becomes a bottleneck. A gatekeeper in the worst sense: someone who controls access without understanding value. Someone whose presence in the organization creates friction rather than removing it. The difference, almost always, is the same difference that separates the good diplomats from the merely senior ones. Judgment. The judgment to know when to intervene and when to step back. When to hold information and when to surface it. When to protect the principal from the noise and when to make sure they hear exactly the note that is about to go wrong. Judgment cannot be taught directly. It is what you get when knowledge meets experience meets genuine care about the outcome.</p><p>Organizations also get the reporting line wrong. The Chief of Staff who reports to anyone other than the principal is not a Chief of Staff. They are something else, something that might be perfectly useful but is a different function. The authority of the role derives entirely from proximity to the principal and from the trust the principal has placed in that proximity. The moment that proximity is intermediated, the function collapses. This is why the role is so difficult to replicate or delegate. It is not a process. It is a relationship.</p><p><strong>Season Five, Final Service</strong></p><p>The fifth and final season of <em>The Bear </em>picks up the morning after Carmy announces he is leaving the restaurant, the same night the thirty-day financial timer, the last of Uncle Jimmy’s money keeping the lights on, runs out.</p><p>I have been watching carefully and trying not to get too far ahead of myself. But the question that has been sitting with me, the one I keep returning to, is not about Carmy. It is about Sydney.</p><p>She has, across the run of this show, mastered every culinary skill the kitchen demands. She has learned every person in it, their limits and their potential, their triggers and their loyalties. She has kept the whole system running in the gaps between the genius moments, which is to say, most of the time. She has been, in every practical sense, the operation. Now the question is whether she becomes the principal.</p><p>The transition from Chief of Staff into principal is not always easy. It requires a different kind of visibility, one that many people in the role actively resist. Because part of what makes someone good at being a Chief of Staff is a certain comfort with operating behind the line, with letting the credit flow upward, with finding satisfaction in the system working rather than in being seen to make it work. That disposition does not simply switch off when circumstances change. Some Chiefs of Staff, when offered the chair at the head of the table, discover they would rather stay standing near the door. I have seen this. I have felt versions of it myself.</p><p>Sydney has been preparing, in some sense, for the principal role all along. The tasting menus she develops alone, the conversations with investors, the moments when she steps into the gap not out of ambition but out of necessity: these are the rehearsals. But rehearsal and performance are different things. The spotlight changes what you are doing even when the steps are the same.</p><p>What the show has always understood is that the work is the thing. Not the title, not the recognition, not the moment of formal transfer. The work. Sydney’s arc across five seasons is not really about whether she gets the restaurant. It is about whether she trusts herself enough to want it. Whether she can make the move from indispensable second to accountable first. Whether the skills she built in the shadow of someone else’s vision can hold their shape when the shadow lifts.</p><p>I wrote this before watching the final episodes. I wanted to get it down while the question was still open. That felt right, somehow, for a piece about a role that is defined by what happens before the room fills up.</p><p><strong>A Note on Reading</strong></p><p>I should say, somewhere in here, that I also read <em>Leading with the Heart, </em>Coach K’s book on leadership and basketball. I came to it partly out of genuine interest in the sport, I follow basketball more than most people in Geneva expect a trade lawyer to, and partly because, at one point, I received a scholarship offer to Duke. Not for basketball, sadly. The thought that crossed my mind, seriously enough that I wrote it down somewhere, was that one of the draws would be the possibility of running into Coach Krzyzewski on campus and having, if I was lucky, a brief conversation. That is the kind of thing you think about at a certain age, when you are deciding where to go and what you want to become.</p><p>I did not end up at Duke. But I read the book. And what I found, under the basketball, was something I would have recognized even without the role I now hold: a sustained argument for what it means to build trust as the operating medium of a team. Coach K’s language is different from the language of diplomacy or of restaurant kitchens, but the structure is the same. You invest in relationships before you need them. You hold people accountable in ways that do not cost them their dignity. You make it safe to know things and to say them. You build the system around the best version of the people in it, not the worst version you are trying to protect against.</p><p>It is a leadership book, yes. But it also turns out to be, if you read it with the right eyes, a Chief of Staff book. Sydney would recognize it. So would James Baker.</p><p><strong>Why I Am Writing This</strong></p><p>I am writing this because of a conversation at a reception in Geneva, with a person who had sincere questions about what I do.</p><p>And because I have been in this role long enough that I forgot it was not as common as I think it should be. That most organizations do not have it, or have it in name only, or have it performed by someone whose actual function is something quite different. That the language and the function are not yet common enough to be legible without explanation. I had to explain it at a reception, to someone asking genuine questions, and I realized I had forgotten how.</p><p>And because the fifth and final season of <em>The Bear</em>, a show that has been across its entire run one of the most precise accounts of what it costs to build something beautiful, has just ended. Sydney Adamu, who never once had the title, never once demanded the credit, and never once stopped doing the work, deserved a proper send-off from someone who recognized what she was doing.</p><p>She was a Chief of Staff. One of the best I have seen rendered in any medium.</p><p>The Onitsuka Tigers Mexico 66 were always there. You just were not looking.</p><p>— -</p><p>Rodolfo C. Rivas is a Geneva-based international trade lawyer and negotiator. He serves as Chief of Staff of a Diplomatic Mission to the WTO in Geneva. He writes fiction and essays under the same name. He is currently wearing the Mexico 66 Onitsuka Tigers.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=fb315685ce4c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Liquid Diplomacy: A Short History of How the World Learned to Negotiate Over a Drink]]></title>
            <link>https://rivasrod.medium.com/by-rodolfo-c-rivas-a194049e94a2?source=rss-c519b7f88399------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a194049e94a2</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[cocktails]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[international-relations]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[diplomacy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[international]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[alcohol]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Rodolfo C. Rivas]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 02 Jun 2026 19:19:43 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-08-05T07:14:06.841Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*elHMzXNGOmCKsoD6qnYl3A.jpeg" /></figure><p>by <strong>Rodolfo C. Rivas</strong></p><p>A well-timed toast can loosen protocol, soften suspicion, and open a brief space for trust between people seated on opposite sides of a table. In the architecture of diplomacy, alcohol is often the unacknowledged mortar: the lubricant that permits movement in what might otherwise become a rigid grind of formal positions. Over centuries, across continents, from the royal courts in Europe to the corridors of the United Nations (UN) in Geneva and the World Trade Organization (WTO), from the quietly elegant diplomatic reception to the raucous bar hidden behind the <em>façade</em> of a summit, the sharing of a drink has often symbolized the transition from adversary to interlocutor.</p><p>There’s a particular sound that marks the true start of any diplomatic negotiation. It is not the shuffling of papers or the rustling of translation headsets. It is the sound of glass meeting glass. A toast signals that the sterile theatre of diplomacy has given way to the real negotiation, which will bring the agreement home. Or so I’m told; such moments tend to happen above my pay grade.</p><p>Still, I’ve heard the stories. A young ambassador in his first posting once confessed that what he really had to learn, more than anything else, was how to drink and hold his liquor. Public, open drinking may have faded from the heyday of diplomacy, or at least from how we like to remember early multilateral diplomacy through the haze of nostalgia, but it remains alive in the back rooms where relationships are forged, and the final details are hammered out. After all, alcohol is one of society’s great lubricants, and, by extension, one of diplomacy’s. That has held true even as public drinking has slowly retreated since the start of the twentieth century.</p><p>In Geneva, where I’ve spent most of my professional life (and more hours than I’ll ever admit trying to reconcile countries that can’t even agree on the definition of “consensus”), that moment is everywhere: in the carpeted bar of the Four Seasons Hotel des Bergues; at receptions in mission multipurpose rooms where the wine is questionable but the gossip tends to be the standout feature; or on the terrace of the Beau-Rivage, with its breathtaking mountain views, where a 25 CHF Boulevardier can sometimes create the atmosphere in which difficult conversations become possible. It is in such rooms that agreements like the WTO’s GPA, covering public procurement markets worth more than US$1.7 trillion annually, are quietly made imaginable.</p><p>I came late to the game myself and only a few years ago began to understand the quiet power that ritual holds over diplomacy, diplomats, and the societies they represent. The first time I attended a reception, I did not drink, thinking it was a matter of discipline rather than participation. But I later learned that the real dialogue often begins after most guests have left, when you find yourself lingering over a glass of whisky you did not expect to have, sometimes a fine Indian single malt whiskey, listening to the last exchanges of gossip, and forming connections that outlast postings, titles, and mandates.</p><p>The significance was never alcohol itself. States do not change their interests because someone uncorks a bottle. The ritual matters only insofar as it lowers friction long enough for negotiators to see what formal settings obscure.</p><p><strong>The Spiritual Infrastructure of Diplomacy</strong></p><p>Alcohol has long functioned as one of society’s social lubricants, and in diplomacy, that lubrication can shape outcomes. There are days when ambassadors are mere elaborate delivery systems for their country’s stubbornness. Then someone uncorks a bottle, and suddenly you catch a glimpse of the person behind the flag.</p><p>Every culture has known this. This is not a modern phenomenon. The ancient Persians are said to have debated each question twice, once drunk, and once sober, to ensure their decisions held up under both conditions<a href="#_ftn1">[1]</a>. Centuries later, the French turned it into an art: Charles Maurice de Talleyrand-Périgord<a href="#_ftn2">[2]</a> famously used lavish feasts and copious wine as tools of diplomacy, proving that it is indeed possible to conduct statecraft and a wine tasting at the same time. Even the notoriously ascetic British foreign officials have been known to indulge, every so often, in a dose of the old “medicinal claret”.</p><p>The same logic appears in less romanticized form in early modern accounts. Giles Fletcher, a British ambassador to Russia, in 1588 wrote that for early modern Russia “to drink drunk is an ordinary matter with them every day in the week”. He went on to describe with genuine discomfort that refusing to drink was regarded as a breach of hospitality, and thus of diplomacy. At least back in the day, at Moscow’s ambassadorial feasts, the guest would be toasted in bowls and required to drink, sometimes to near excess, and only then could the conversation proceed.</p><p>Today, the multilateral system runs as much on Chardonnay as on charter. There are official receptions, semi-official cocktails, unofficial after-parties, karaoke nights, and the most crucial category of all: “spontaneous informal (social) consultations”. That, of course, is diplomatic code for “we’re stuck, let’s drink about it”. This is not to suggest that it bridges all disagreements; if it did, we would have far more multilateral agreements in legal scrubbing than we currently do.</p><p>In more recent times, a commentator in Diplomat Magazine puts it thus: “The truth is that alcohol is a tool of much diplomacy. It oils the social interaction… When abused to excess, alcohol can be a cause of physical and professional ruin. But when exploited in moderation, it can further the national interest, glass by glass, sip by sip”.</p><p><strong>The Toast as Weapon, as Truce, as Theatre</strong></p><p>When Richard Nixon landed in Beijing in February 1972, the world watched him raise a small glass of fiery <em>mao-tai</em><a href="#_ftn3">[3]</a> to Premier Zhou Enlai. The symbolism was irresistible: the President of the United States, long identified with anti-Communism, sharing a toast with the leadership of the People’s Republic of China. The diplomatic breakthrough was not born from a single drink, but the toast became a visible marker of something more important: the willingness of two estranged powers to occupy the same political space. Diplomacy often works through such gestures. They do not resolve disputes, but they can signal that resolution is no longer impossible.</p><p>Alexander Haig, who would later become Secretary of State under Reagan, is said to have warned in a cable, “under no repeat no circumstances should the President actually drink from his glass in response to banquet toasts”. It has been said that Nixon was not a fan of the high-proof <em>Maotai </em>liquor. Henry Kissinger, ever the realist, is said to have whispered, “Swallow quickly”. But the photo mattered more than the flavor. Diplomacy is often like that, a bitter shot followed by a sweet headline.</p><p>Winston Churchill turned the toast into an art form, usually with whisky in hand. “I have taken more out of alcohol than alcohol has taken out of me,” he quipped, proving that charisma is an acceptable substitute for moderation. At Yalta, he toasted Stalin and Roosevelt with vintage Pol Roger<a href="#_ftn4">[4]</a>, because champagne, he said, was “the wine of civilization and the oil of government”. One imagines the Soviets politely yearning for vodka.</p><p>A senior Latin American official once told me of a meeting that had ground to a familiar diplomatic halt. As tempers frayed and positions hardened, he was politely but firmly asked to leave a room where two Ministers had decided to continue their discussion alone. “This is a matter for Ministers,” he recalled being told. Shortly thereafter, a bottle of tequila was brought in. The official waited outside. Time passed. Then the door opened. The Ministers emerged, all smiles, announcing that an agreement had been reached. Whether tequila contributed to the breakthrough is impossible to know. What is clear is that the shift from formal negotiation to private conversation altered the dynamics of the discussion. The bottle may have been incidental; the informal setting almost certainly was not.</p><p>Pop culture has long understood the choreography of drinking as diplomacy in disguise. In <em>Casablanca</em>, every alliance, betrayal, and heartbreak happens under the neon sign of “Rick’s Café Americain”. When he says, “Of all the gin joints in all the towns in all the world,” he’s really voicing every diplomat’s lament: fate is a drunk host with unpredictable guest lists. Popular culture exaggerates the role of the bar in diplomacy, but only slightly. Real-world diplomatic institutions have long developed their own informal drinking cultures, creating spaces where personal relationships can soften the rigidity of official positions. The setting may be less glamorous than Rick’s Café, but the underlying logic remains recognizable.</p><p><strong>Multilateral Happy Hour</strong></p><p>If alcohol serves a diplomatic purpose, it is the creation of temporary spaces in which people can speak outside the constraints of official positions. Modern multilateral diplomacy, despite its procedural formality, remains heavily dependent on such informal encounters.</p><p>Access to the WTO Green Room at crucial moments is above my pay grade, so I can’t say what happens behind those closed doors. But it has been reported that during the Uruguay Round, Director-General and Chairman Arthur Dunkel invited up to 24 chief negotiators, without their deputies, to private dinners at his home, in the hope of fostering <em>esprit de corps</em>. There is no record of the menu and drinks available, but one can imagine wine and a couple of digestifs were regularly available. WTO Directors-General continued using private discussions among key states in Geneva and during ministerial meetings to resolve deadlocks, but growing dissatisfaction culminated in widespread criticism during and after the turbulent Seattle conference in 1999.</p><p>At the United Nations in New York, at least until a few years ago, the atmosphere in the Delegates Lounge would change noticeably once evening settled in and the bars emerged from behind their discreetly closed doors. Unsurprisingly, it became a favored refuge for diplomats and staff alike. Its regulars even christened it the “Seventh Committee”, an affectionate nod to the United Nations’ six official committees and an acknowledgment that some of diplomacy’s most useful conversations occur beyond the formal agenda.</p><p>The bar, after all, is a great equalizer. On any given evening, one might find a Jamaican diplomat quoting Bob Marley, or a Brazilian colleague insisting, with impeccable logic, that a caipirinha should count as a serving of fruit. Hierarchies soften, talking points are set aside, and the rituals of diplomacy give way, if only briefly, to ordinary conversation.</p><p>I have it on good authority that on particularly good nights, even members of the Security Council speak to one another without preambles. And every mission has its own signature. The Russians pour vodka like ideology. The French arrive armed with Bordeaux. The Mexicans bring tequila or mezcal, and suggest not to shoot it or have a margarita; instead, they should sip it. The Americans bring craft beer and talking points. And the Swiss? They host graciously in Geneva and never seem to pay, or if you are lucky, you get the first round.</p><p><strong>When the Glass Betrays the Hand</strong></p><p>But alcohol, like diplomacy, insists on proportion. For every legend of <em>détente</em> sealed over cognac or martinis, there is another where judgment slips quietly out of the room and returns only after the damage has already been noted.</p><p>As recorded in the Foreign Affairs Oral History Program of the Association for Diplomatic Studies and Training (ADST), one junior Foreign Service officer, early in a posting in Beijing, attended a formal banquet hosted by the Chinese Mountaineering Association. The structure was familiar to anyone who has spent time in such rooms: assigned seating, ritual courtesy, and a sequence of increasingly insistent toasts anchored by <em>baijiu</em> and the expectation of <em>ganbei</em>, each glass emptied as proof of reciprocity rather than preference. As the evening progressed, the cadence of toasting tightened, shifting from ceremonial rhythm to continuous obligation. The hosts remained unfailingly polite; the effect, however, was a sustained act of consumption disguised as hospitality.</p><p>The officer later recalled that the evening became harder to reconstruct, though the atmosphere never broke its courteous surface. By the following day, the hosts had declared the event a success, as if coherence and recollection were not essential criteria. ADST oral histories preserve these episodes as early instruction: that diplomacy often operates through social forms in which participation itself becomes the test, and restraint is a private calculation conducted within a public ritual.</p><p>In that narrow space, outcomes depend on staying power, as one Security Council diplomat who has sat through many such sessions put it: “The last one standing is the winner. After three weeks together, twenty hours a day, people get comfortable. But if you are dumb enough to get so drunk you can’t negotiate, then you deserve [to get outplayed].” That logic, left unchecked, eventually drew rare public rebuke from the United States, when Ambassador Joseph Torsella urged colleagues to curb excessive drinking during the 2012 budget talks, reflecting frustration with what one diplomat described as a “circus” in the final stretch of negotiations.</p><p>Even at the highest levels, excess has a way of undoing intention. Stalin, according to numerous accounts, understood hospitality as a form of leverage, encouraging heavy drinking and observing what loosened under pressure. Roosevelt practiced a markedly different approach. He used conviviality to broaden participation rather than expose weakness, treating sociability as a means of relationship-building rather than extraction. The contrast illustrates a broader truth: alcohol can function either as a mechanism of trust-building or as an instrument of pressure, depending on the power dynamics surrounding the ritual.</p><p>Modern diplomacy has tried to formalize restraint. There are “no-alcohol” delegations, “one-glass” receptions, and even carefully curated mocktail circuits. But removing alcohol from diplomacy has always been less a policy change than an aspiration: like removing improvisation from jazz, leaving the music practically unrecognizable.</p><p><strong>A Cartography of Glasses</strong></p><p>Diplomatic drinking is never entirely about consumption. What goes in the glass is a kind of shorthand — for a country, a history, a way of carrying oneself. The bar is its own language, and most diplomats are at least bilingual in it.</p><p>Each drink, in this register, becomes a small map of its region’s politics, a distilled version of history that arrives in glassware. The French 75, built from champagne, gin, and lemon, takes its name from a World War I field gun, carrying an elegance that never fully hides its force. The first time I tried it, handed to me by a senior European diplomat, it took me by surprise, and after having two in quick succession, I learned that in long evenings you should pace yourself and keep hydrated.</p><p>The Latin American <em>El Presidente</em>, made from rum, vermouth, and curaçao, was mixed in Havana for Americans who came south to drink during Prohibition. It also brings me back to the endless rounds of negotiations on the Trade in Services Agreement (TiSA), when, after long hours at the table, we finally went for drinks and had the most delicious <em>El Presidente</em> con <em>Ron Abuelo</em>, the kind of drink that closes a chapter without fully ending it.</p><p>I discovered the Manhattan on my own, and since then, I have paid it forward by introducing younger diplomats to it. It resembles a diplomatic cable that has been overconcentrated: precise in structure, slightly softened in tone, and still capable of carrying impact well beyond its surface.</p><p><strong>The Perils of the Pour</strong></p><p>Still, it would be a mistake to romanticize it too far. Alcohol in diplomatic life often operates as a way to smooth over the fatigue of distance, repetition, and the strange permanence of temporary crises. In foreign postings, it also masks the quiet isolation: hotel rooms that repeat from capital to capital, conversations that recycle across different flags, and the gradual sense that most relationships are conditional on mandate, rotation, and geography. In that environment, stress rarely arrives as rupture. It accumulates as routine, and alcohol can convert that routine into something that feels manageable until, quietly, it does not. I have seen capable negotiators undone not by scandal, but by the incremental logic of too many “one for the roads”, until habit begins to negotiate on its own behalf.</p><p>The difficulty is that none of this is culturally neutral. In some diplomatic traditions, refusing a drink signals distrust or disrespect; in others, accepting one signals a lack of discipline or seriousness. A raised glass can read as courtesy, pressure, solidarity, or surrender, depending on who is watching and what history sits in the room. Even refusal has to be explained, and the explanation becomes part of the negotiation. The trick, never fully mastered, is to stay in the room without disappearing into it.</p><p>Yet institutions rarely preserve social rituals indefinitely. Practices that once appeared indispensable eventually confront changing norms, generational expectations, and new understandings of risk. Diplomacy is no exception.</p><p>And yet the broader context is shifting in ways that would have been difficult to imagine a generation ago. Across many Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) countries, alcohol consumption has been steadily declining, most notably among the young, for whom a sober evening is no longer something to explain. The drink that once held a reception together is now simply one option on the table.</p><p>Science has hardened alongside the habit. For years, the received wisdom held that a glass of red was good for the heart; the World Health Organization now says plainly that no amount of alcohol is safe. The convivial glass has been quietly reclassified, from social custom to health risk.</p><p>In diplomacy, these shifts register less as ruptures than as gradual adjustments. Formal receptions increasingly include non-alcoholic pairings that are treated with the same care as their alcoholic counterparts. “No alcohol” missions are no longer unusual, and “one-drink maximum” norms are quietly observed in some delegations without ever needing formal announcement. The old social infrastructure has not disappeared; it now coexists with alternatives that no longer require justification.</p><p>Still, adaptation is most visible at the individual level, in the small tactics of continuity inside changing expectations. One learns how to keep a glass full without finishing it, how to pace participation across an evening without signaling withdrawal, how to switch discreetly to soda water or tonic without turning it into a statement. The phrase “doctor’s orders” has become a kind of universal diplomatic instrument, vague enough to close inquiry and specific enough to avoid follow-up.</p><p>What is changing is not only behavior but expectation. The ritual is still there, but it no longer commands. You can still raise a glass, but no one assumes you will drain it, and no one reads abstention as a verdict. The performance continues; it has simply ceased to be compulsory.</p><p><strong>The Moral of the Bottle</strong></p><p>In the end, the bottle is not the story; it is only the accessory. The story is what gathers around it: the shifting geometry of attention, the carefully managed pauses, the way a room briefly agrees to believe in itself. Every toast is a small act of faith, not in the drink but in the possibility that conversation can still hold more weight than silence, and that sharing a glass can imply, however briefly and imperfectly, a shared frame of reference across disagreement, language, and interest.</p><p>There is a fragile choreography to it all. Glasses rise not only in celebration but in calibration, testing whether proximity can be mistaken for alignment, whether courtesy can survive contradiction. For a moment, hierarchy softens. Negotiators who have spent hours resisting each other’s language find themselves participating in the same gesture, if not the same meaning. The ritual does not resolve conflict, but it suspends it just long enough for something like continuity to appear.</p><p>That is the quiet logic beneath it. Diplomacy seeks arrangements that can survive disagreement without collapsing under it. In that sense, the shared drink is about endurance, a temporary structure built out of politeness and timing.</p><p>Alcohol, with all its distortions and excesses, becomes part of that architecture because it reveals something unguarded in the margins. It reminds participants, often unintentionally, that they are fragile, occasionally funny, and almost always improvising under pressure. The seriousness of the room is always interrupted by human variability.</p><p>And perhaps that is its final function. To return diplomacy to its most workable form: imperfect people attempting, with uneven clarity and intermittent grace, to build a shared order inside a world that refuses to stay still.</p><blockquote><em>For some time now, I have been quietly tinkering with recipes: reading, tasting, researching, adjusting, and trying to understand not only what makes a cocktail balanced, but what gives it character.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>After several attempts, I decided to throw my hat into the ring and develop a recipe that, at least to me, feels appropriate for a diplomat: measured, layered, slightly bold, and capable of bringing people into conversation.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>I could not come up with a better name for it than </em><strong><em>The Diplomat Boulevardier</em></strong><em>.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>And here it is.</em></blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*EhPd_ihmslifMa29otS9og.png" /></figure><p><strong>Last Call</strong></p><p>So here is to the spirits that once greased the system, and to the quieter ones now reshaping it. To Talleyrand’s brandy, Churchill’s whisky, Obama’s beer, and to the unnamed diplomats who spent long nights searching for common ground over whatever was at hand. And to those who abstain, with equal grace and purpose, diplomacy has made room for you as well. The ritual remains, but imitation is no longer required.</p><p>Because what endures is not the drink, but the gathering: the room, the pause before speech, the decision to stay at the table long enough for disagreement to become manageable.</p><p>Somewhere between the clink of glasses and the signing of <em>communiqués</em> lies the fragile arrangement through which civilization holds.</p><p>Later, after the speeches end and the glasses are cleared, the room empties in stages: a final handshake or a last exchange of cards. Outside, Geneva is quiet. The lake is still, the flags hang motionless, and the last <em>Les Mouettes Genevoises</em> ferry crosses the water.</p><p>A young diplomat walks home with a folded briefing note and the sense that the conversation was better than it had any right to be. Tomorrow, the disagreements will return. But for a few hours, those who arrived speaking past one another stayed in the same room long enough to listen. Each generation arrives believing it is inheriting the same arguments, and only slowly realizes they have already been reshaped in its hands.</p><p>The glasses are left behind. The conversation continues for now.</p><p>— -</p><p>Rodolfo C. Rivas is a trade diplomat with over 17 years of experience working in International Geneva.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref1">[1]</a> According to the Greek historian Herodotus, a decision would only be enacted if it was still approved after being re-evaluated in a sober state.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref2">[2]</a> Served as the French Diplomat in the Congress of Vienna.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref3">[3]</a> A type of baijiu, a popular sorghum-based spirit in China allegedly created 4,000 years ago by King Yi Di. It was promptly banned in fear future leaders would become alcoholics.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref4">[4]</a> Sir Winston Churchill and the Pol Roger Champagne House is one of the most legendary relationships in the history of wine, culminating in the creation of the prestigious Cuvée Sir Winston Churchill.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a194049e94a2" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>