<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Richard Nephew on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Richard Nephew on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@rmnephew?source=rss-ec6ec9a4a26------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sat, 21 Nov 2026 03:48:58 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@rmnephew/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Debate or Desertion?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@rmnephew/debate-or-desertion-fd7bcc92910d?source=rss-ec6ec9a4a26------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/fd7bcc92910d</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Richard Nephew]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 09 Oct 2020 13:39:07 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-10-09T13:39:07.617Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>My decision to join in a debate organized by the German Marshall Fund and moderated by my friend Ariane Tabatabai with Mark Dubowitz of the Foundation for the Defense of Democracies has resulted in, shall we say, feedback. I have been reflecting on the reactions that have been given and wanted to offer a response in turn. I suspect that those prepared to label me a disgusting, criminal psychopath are less interested in a discussion of their views than perhaps I’d hope, but let this serve as my rejoinder.</p><p>First and foremost, let’s get out of the way what this debate is and what it is not. It is not a game. There are no points being awarded to the winner and, though the GMF has a polling mechanism in place to test how persuasive the arguments will be, its results will be a function of participation more than anything else. Neither Mark nor I have an incentive to land a “knock out” punch in service of a viewpoint that we do not actually hold. This is a competition that we’d rather lose than win.</p><p>But, of course, that’s why the “competition” is not the point: the process of examining the arguments in favor of a position we don’t hold is the point. I have spent some hours reading the documents prepared by Mark and his colleagues at FDD, as well as other JCPOA opponents. But, admittedly, in recent years, I’ve glossed more than read. I don’t agree with them on their fundamental premises, so why bother getting into the weeds? There is more than enough to read out there and I have three kids to handle.</p><p>That is a terrible way to proceed. It stunts my own intellectual development and growth, and it means that rather than debate fairly on the merits of the case I have read, I debate on what I “know” they think. I might even be correct in my assumptions, but that is still a disservice to my own position as well as to my field of study. I should be forced to deal with the views of people I disagree with and this is a mechanism to do that.</p><p>I will take this argument a step further: those who are clamoring against this debate are doing so — consciously or unconsciously — in support of a concept of policy debate that involves no listening, no examining, and no deliberating. It is the “Crossfire” of policy analysis, for those of you familiar with the old CNN show that <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aFQFB5YpDZE&amp;list=PL4XDKYYzjtt-HMQnDfxAg2kEevdjgFvNo&amp;index=25">Jon Stewart beautifully eviscerated</a>: if Mark’s for it, then I am against it. It may very well be the case that Mark and I disagree on 99.9% of all of the issues we may ever discuss. But, this should not be because he is Mark and I am Richard. I should be — and others should be — responsible to our own scholarship to read and understand the other side’s point of view.</p><p>This actually calls to mind a decision that I made — and which Mark has respected — back in 2015 to no longer engage in Twitter debates with him. For those who may remember, when I left government in early 2015, I took to twitter with trepidation, as I dislike all forms of social media. I find them reductionist and overly inclined to encourage “feel good” and knee-jerk reactions to news and commentary. We get likes from our followers when we spike the other side, which has positive psychological effects. We can get in the heads of our opponents and make them seethe. But, I was in a new job and asked to use twitter to support my work, so I did. And, I used the platform to debate Mark and others well into the night on the Iran negotiations underway and the JCPOA once announced.</p><p>But, I came to find that the highs of the debate were just as unsavory as I had always suspected. Increasingly, I found that I mostly wrote to encourage people with whom I already agreed. I described this in a conversation with Mark prior to our respective testimony in the House of Representatives in the following way: He and I are standing in opposite ends of a football stadium, screaming at one another. We can’t really hear what the other is saying, but our friends next to us can…and we played for those friends. I decided that was an exceedingly dull way to live and that it was not productive, and told him that I wouldn’t do it any more.</p><p>I agreed to do this debate because I think that the “crossfire-ing” and “twitter-ing” of policy debate in the United States and beyond is antithetical to reasoned discourse. It doesn’t mean that I won’t slip into the “twitter” approach from time to time, especially in the current political climate, but I don’t like it and don’t think anyone else should either. This debate is in part an attempt to claw back to a time where one could have a serious argument or — if cynics suggest no such time ever existed — to create one now.</p><p>This takes me to the format, as some have said “but couldn’t you do that with your same positions?” Of course we could have. And, 10 people would show up because they know our positions. We talk and write about them often enough. And those 10 people will already know what they think when they come into the (virtual) room. We may get those 10 people here too — or even more — but they will be forced to hear someone they may hate say something they like…and vice versa. That will be uncomfortable. GOOD! These are important, serious topics and people SHOULD be uncomfortable from time to time. If you come out on the other side still committed to your position, so be it (and if that position is the same as my true views, all the better!). But, the experience of the discomfort — in my opinion — has value.</p><p>The other problem that I have with the “crossfire-ing” of our debate is that it results in absolutist, yes/no, off/on policy recommendations. Such black and white approaches to analysis are facile and childish. Almost no policy issue can or should be assessed with such lenses (and I say “almost” to avoid some people helping to prove my ultimate point by bringing up the Holocaust). The truth is that I support the use of U.S. sanctions power in some circumstances, not in others, and with modifications in yet others. The truth is that I think that Iran holds some responsibility for its current predicament and that the Trump Administration — which has made a complete hash of Iran policy overall, in my view — has also taken some steps that are meritorious. The sanctions imposed on the judges who sentenced Navid Afkari to death are a recent, salient example. Can I — should I — condemn everything that the Trump Administration has done because they’ve done it or because they usually pursue policies with which I disagree?</p><p>Likewise, I am proud of the role that I played in securing the JCPOA. It was — and maybe still is, if it lasts — a good agreement. Its imperfections were marginal compared to its positives. I will defend it to the last. But, I have been attacked at times for talking it down by acknowledging its deficiencies. I have been accused of “letting down the side” by doing so. Some of the folks who have laid those charges upon me have noted that “the other side” doesn’t talk down their positions, so neither should we. My response: shame on us if we allow the narrow-minded, shallow, vapid approaches to analysis that others take dictate how we think through problems! In a practical world with practical problems to deal with, the tactics we all employ may occasionally require our own reductionism. But, those should be exceptions that we lament and not models for our own behavior.</p><p>Policy pronouncement without reflection is not analysis, it is religious devotion. That’s especially the case when moral arguments are brought into the equation. Even setting aside all sorts of interesting philosophical questions about morality and who gets to judge, the practical reality of invoking moral judgment in debate is to render the other side heretical and evil. It is a tactic, not an assessment. And it is done far, far too much in order to justify extreme positions.</p><p>Don’t think that we should talk with Iran? “It is because they are immoral terrorists, bent on our destruction!”</p><p>Don’t think that we should use sanctions to push Iran to make better policy choices? “It is because sanctions are an immoral instrument that hurt innocents.”</p><p>There are legitimate arguments in each of those positions and individual morality can play a part in a person’s deciding which argument to support, but the invocation of morality has — to me — always seemed like the invocation of “magic” when describing technology one doesn’t understand. Moreover, moral judgments have a funny way of looking crystal clear depending on how you frame them. Reasonable people might say that it is moral to use sanctions against Iran to prevent it from developing nuclear weapons because, if they acquire nuclear weapons, they might use them, killing people. Reasonable people might say that it is immoral to use sanctions against Iran because doing so causes harm now in hopes of avoiding future, theoretical harm. Reasonable people might say that those who violate human rights should be punished…but then flinch when those being punished happened to be on their side of another argument.</p><p>This also calls to mind one of the most persuasive presentations I’ve ever heard against the JCPOA. I was in the Middle East in early spring 2014, attending then Under Secretary Sherman on a visit to then Foreign Minister Saud. His health was flagging, but he was crystal clear cognitively. He delivered an eloquent, sober, and sensible indictment of U.S. policy. He used facts, figures, and arguments that did not appeal to our emotions, but our logic. It was polite, it was authoritative, and it was deeply impressive. It led me to think about our approach for literally days. In the end, I concluded that — for me — negotiating the JCPOA was still the right call. In my own head, I weighed his arguments, I set them against what I thought and understood, and I made a decision. But, I think about his arguments all the time and they are no more or less powerful for the passing of time. And, I should also note: I have also been challenged from the other direction in my discussions and participation in negotiations with Iranian Foreign Minister Zarif, his colleagues, and those more aligned internationally with the Iranian government point of view. It is good to be challenged. It is a privilege to be challenged. And, I now try to challenge myself on my own views when I write them or discuss them, including assessing how right or wrong I was in past calls.</p><p>This takes me to my last point, with apologies for carrying on so: if a university researcher cannot take the other side of an argument for a thirty minute debate to suss out the good points and bad points of the argument, then what hope is there for reasoned discourse in the future? So much of the debate that concerns international affairs has become locked into soundbites, twitter posts and memes that we are losing any ability to engage in nuance (and the less said about domestic political issues, the better). One thirty minute debate on a random Thursday in October will not fix this problem. But, I am perfectly pleased to stake out one tiny corner of the discourse and say “here, for this moment, we will try to discuss things like adults.” It is not just my right as an American to utilize my freedom of speech in this manner, it is my responsibility as a citizen, as a scholar, and as a policy advocate to take seriously the free exchange of ideas. I will not be bullied by arguments that “hardliners in Iran or the United States will spin what you say” or “you are giving a platform to ideas that you don’t like” or let these arguments sway me from the essential task of supporting reasoned argumentation on a subject I hold dear.</p><p>I also will not be told that my credibility or my reputation is at stake from this one discussion. I have earned whatever credibility and reputation I may have over years of study, research, and practice. Only I can relinquish my credibility and reputation, and part of that would come from refusing to take seriously points of view that are not my own.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=fd7bcc92910d" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>