<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Rob Knight on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Rob Knight on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@rob_knight?source=rss-69bb99cf537a------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 00:35:57 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@rob_knight/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[After the crash]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/humanizing-the-singularity/after-the-crash-350fd32bf3ed?source=rss-69bb99cf537a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/350fd32bf3ed</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[bitcoin]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[blockchain]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cryptocurrency]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ethereum]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mattereum]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Rob Knight]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 28 Nov 2018 22:10:07 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-11-28T22:10:07.897Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1010/1*BtE2s0qw4ltkIw8iwROCRA.jpeg" /></figure><p>The crypto crash is in full swing. Falls of 80–90% from the peak have already happened. What does this mean?</p><p>The economist Scott Sumner says “<a href="http://www.themoneyillusion.com/never-reason-from-a-price-change/">never reason from a price change</a>”. The fact that a price changed is unarguable, but we need to know <em>why</em> it changed in order to understand what to do about it. As Scott says:</p><blockquote>My suggestion is that people should never reason from a price change, but always start one step earlier — what caused the price to change. If oil prices fall because Saudi Arabia increases production, then that is bullish news. If oil prices fall because of falling AD in Europe, that might be expansionary for the US. But if oil prices are falling because the euro crisis is increasing the demand for dollars and lowering AD worldwide; confirmed by falls in commodity prices, US equity prices, and TIPS spreads, then that is bearish news.</blockquote><p>With this in mind, let’s ask: why are crypto prices falling?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/932/1*-yPMtUpAzBUcUTrZJQrVEw.png" /><figcaption>Technical Analysis — image from <a href="https://www.tradingview.com/ideas/btc-usd/">https://www.tradingview.com/ideas/btc-usd/</a></figcaption></figure><p>The answer is pretty simple: demand is lower than it was previously. We can draw up many complex charts, but they all tell the same story. Fewer people want to buy Bitcoin, Ether, or other cryptocurrencies and tokens, at their current prices. The fall may continue until an equilibrium is reached, and opinions differ on where that equilibrium point is. Prices are unlikely to rise until potential buyers are persuaded that a higher price is justifiable.</p><p>Of course, “lower than it was previously” means we’re making a comparison to the peak of the market. Prices could fall a lot further than still be higher than they were at, say, the beginning of 2017.</p><p>The bubble of late 2017/early 2018 represented an enormous infusion of capital into blockchain projects. We know that many of these projects were <a href="https://www.48days.com/in-a-tornado-even-a-turkey-can-fly/">turkeys in a tornado</a>, with not much value beyond having the words ‘block’, ‘chain’, or ‘blockchain’ somewhere in their names. Some were outright scams. Some raised funding illegally. A substantial fraction of the market is therefore dead, and ought to be assigned a value of near zero. People who bought these tokens in order to HODL them will lose, big-time.</p><p>What about the rest? Once we have discounted the scams, the pump-n-dumps, the over-hyped and under-designed, and those that assumed that blockchain was miracle potion for otherwise mediocre business ideas, we’re left with a few fundamental facts:</p><ul><li>There is some genuine technical innovation in applying cryptography to distributed databases; cryptography is generally under-applied in the real world and the potential value from applying it more broadly is real.</li><li>The major public blockchains have demonstrated stability and security despite using novel mechanisms for consensus and predictability.</li><li>The core application of managing scarce resources using distributed databases appears to work well for Bitcoin.</li><li>Managing a much larger fraction of the world’s scarce resources using current blockchain technology is not feasible without relaxing the requirement for true decentralisation.</li></ul><p>So, we have some genuine technical innovations, a reasonable belief that more such innovations can be found, and a decent grasp on the problems of scalability and cost. A global network of stateful, distributed and consensus-forming databases, capable of modelling scarce, long-lived resources and multi-party relationships to those resources sounds genuinely useful.</p><p>This sounds bullish. Why, then, is everyone depressed?</p><p>If you’re making a bear case for crypto <em>applications</em> based on the movements of Bitcoin, Ether, or token prices, then you’re probably making the mistake that Scott Sumner warned about: reasoning from a price change. Much of the “<a href="https://duckduckgo.com/?q=technical+analysis+bitcoin&amp;t=osx&amp;iax=images&amp;ia=images">technical analysis</a>” you see on Twitter is doing this too — attempting to understand the future by looking at a narrow measurement of the past.</p><p>This is important because demand for crypto tokens is not like demand for oil. Much of the money flowing into tokens over the last year was <em>investment</em>, not consumption. Investments are designed to produce long-term value, not short-term returns. Investments follow cycles, and down-cycles are inevitable for innovative products that take time to develop and mature.</p><p>A better model for understanding this is <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carlota_Perez">Carlota Perez</a>’s model of the interaction of finance and innovation:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/530/1*7H5BXaP7agM5nLx5BmLn_Q.png" /></figure><p>Put simply, innovations occur somewhat spontaneously and unpredictably. Some initial investment is made, and success follows (or doesn’t). After a while, the momentum becomes visible to the wider world. Suddenly, everyone wants a piece. A frenzy begins.</p><p>The <em>inevitable </em>consequence of the frenzy is the crash. <em>Inevitable</em>. The market cannot react fast enough to deliver enough investable opportunities to satisfy the frenzied demand. Once the good opportunities are taken, bad investments are made, and the quality of each new opportunity falls as all of the good opportunities are already well-capitalised. The only way to avoid further bad investments is for investment levels to fall.</p><p>Software engineers might recognise the “<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Mythical_Man-Month">mythical man-month</a>” problem here. Building useful infrastructure takes time, and having 10x as many people working on it doesn’t result in it getting done any faster. 10x more capital doesn’t help, either.</p><p>The crash, then, isn’t necessarily bullish or bearish as a long-term signal. It’s consistent with the view that crypto was over-hyped and will be remembered as an embarrassing fad. It’s also consistent with the view that investment takes time to yield returns, and the timescale from the peak to now (less than a year) is far too short to know what those returns will be.</p><p>Of course, this is no help to those who are holding falling tokens right now, any more than the eventual success of Amazon was a comfort to people who lost everything on WebVan in the dot com bubble. Investing is hard! In retrospect, it is obvious that the crypto markets couldn’t absorb hundreds of billions of dollars and allocate all of them to successful projects — the baseline for startups is a 90%+ failure rate, even in normal times. You can hope that one of your investments turns out to have long-term value after the crash, but most won’t.</p><p>In the interests of balance, let’s look at the <strong>bullish case for crypto</strong>.</p><p>The ICO scams were great for the total “crypto market cap” but bad for any long-term infrastructure or product development. The death of the scam market and the return to sane notions of risk and investment is a positive, not a negative.</p><p>Blockchains are great technology for managing scarce resources and their metadata, but plugging those resources into blockchain technology takes time. We’re starting to see projects like <a href="https://harbor.com/">Harbor</a> which are plugging scarce real-world assets in — and this makes a lot more sense than trying to manage the supply of some arbitrarily-defined “utility token” that has no natural need for scarcity beyond the ability to speculate on its price. (Disclosure: at <a href="https://www.mattereum.com/">Mattereum</a> we are also focusing on plugging the real world into the blockchain). If you want to see tokens that hold real value and move independently of the price of Bitcoin, this will be how it happens in the short-term.</p><p>Fundamental technical innovations are still coming — <a href="https://bitcoinmagazine.com/articles/ethereum-killer-ethereum-20-vitalik-buterins-roadmap/">Ethereum will get a substantial upgrade</a>, and rival technologies will compete. This simply wasn’t true even a year ago.</p><p>The great wave of investment has left us with a number of well-capitalised teams that will continue to innovate for years. As uncertainties around technology, scaling and legal issues subside, the focus on user experience will predominate and we will see products that look very different from today’s prototypes.</p><p>Perez’s model gives us some idea of what to look for after a crash — an adjustment in which the projects that find the best fit between the technology and the market succeed, and the rest disappear. In total size and scale, this phase is <em>bigger</em> than what came before it, but will also proceed more slowly and more carefully. Once the crash bottoms out, it may take years for the total valuation of blockchain projects to approach the peak again. Still, once we clear away the wreckage of the bubble, the real opportunities are still there.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=350fd32bf3ed" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/humanizing-the-singularity/after-the-crash-350fd32bf3ed">After the crash</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/humanizing-the-singularity">Mattereum - Humanizing the Singularity</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Announcing the Mattereum summary white paper]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/humanizing-the-singularity/announcing-the-mattereum-summary-white-paper-36cb2a817a3a?source=rss-69bb99cf537a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/36cb2a817a3a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[ethereum]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[smart-contracts]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[blockchain]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mattereum]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[crypto]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Rob Knight]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 02 Nov 2018 14:41:02 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-11-02T14:58:29.693Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*FH3H90xGPqdKRmnPQooDyw.png" /></figure><p><strong>This week, we released the </strong><a href="https://www.mattereum.com/lp"><strong>Mattereum summary white paper</strong></a><strong>.</strong> It is the result of a year’s work on the problems of smart contract enforcement and the transfer of property using smart contracts.</p><p>In it, we describe a system for managing contractual rights in assets of all kinds — including tokenization of those rights. That system is the <strong>Mattereum Smart Property Register</strong>, a blockchain-based register of contractual rights in assets. This is the system that will power blockchain-based trade, investment and real-world business deals.</p><p>It’s a brief document, so if you want to know what it says then I’d suggest just reading it! However, some brief highlights:</p><ul><li>We introduce the concept of the <em>automated custodian</em>, a software system with legal control over assets, driven entirely by code and smart contracts</li><li>We explain how a network of <em>registrars</em> — legal entities whose contracts are entirely specified on-chain — collaborate to create this system</li><li>We describe the <em>asset passport</em>, the identity record for assets which acts as the hub for provenance records, proofs of existence, ownership and insurance, and relationships to contracts and tokens</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*vC_oQL6fERTh1teNuswc8Q.png" /><figcaption>Mattereum Asset Passports</figcaption></figure><p>The paper also draws on our work with our partners and customers over the last year. We will be announcing further partnerships soon, and if you’re interested in using the Smart Property Register for your app or project, you should get in touch at <a href="/service/mailto:info@mattereum.com">info@mattereum.com</a>.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=36cb2a817a3a" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/humanizing-the-singularity/announcing-the-mattereum-summary-white-paper-36cb2a817a3a">Announcing the Mattereum summary white paper</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/humanizing-the-singularity">Mattereum - Humanizing the Singularity</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Internet of Agreements IV: Space]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/humanizing-the-singularity/internet-of-agreements-iv-space-75df2284a5f4?source=rss-69bb99cf537a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/75df2284a5f4</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[bitcoin]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[blockchain]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[space]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[internet-of-agreements]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ethereum]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Rob Knight]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 28 May 2018 09:07:11 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-05-31T16:15:48.916Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*wJibUxrZb_yHqHOaBbN09g.jpeg" /></figure><p>On June 21st, we will hold the fourth Internet of Agreements conference: “<a href="http://internetofagreements.com/space">Blockchains and Space</a>”. It will bring together blockchain developers, space entrepreneurs, and investors, with a focus on how the technology can be used to enhance, support, and finance space exploration and space-based products and services. If you want to understand how blockchains, smart contracts, and the Internet of Agreements will shape the future of space, this is the place to be. Building on our conferences on <a href="http://www.internetofagreements.com/law">Law</a>, <a href="http://www.internetofagreements.com/trade">Trade</a>, and <a href="http://www.internetofagreements.com/identity">Identity</a>, it’s going to be the best IOA yet.</p><p><strong><em>We have a limited number of sponsorship slots left — if you would like to sponsor the event, please get in touch with </em></strong><a href="/service/mailto:info@internetofagreements.com"><strong><em>info@internetofagreements.com</em></strong></a></p><p>Internet of Agreements IV: Blockchains and Space will take place on June 21st, at the Digital Catapult in London.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FYn5kjVYjYvI%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DYn5kjVYjYvI&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FYn5kjVYjYvI%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/aff0790eeefe3cdc0cf6d178651b49b7/href">https://medium.com/media/aff0790eeefe3cdc0cf6d178651b49b7/href</a></iframe><p>Our previous events have focused on <a href="http://internetofagreements.com/law">law and blockchains</a>, including smart contracts, law as a programming language, and arbitration; <a href="http://internetofagreements.com/trade">world trade</a>, including supply chain management and globalisation; and <a href="http://internetofagreements.com/identity">identity</a>, including self-sovereign identity and identity insurance.</p><p>You can browse our previous videos and transcripts at the <a href="http://www.internetofagreements.com/">Internet of Agreements</a> site.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=75df2284a5f4" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/humanizing-the-singularity/internet-of-agreements-iv-space-75df2284a5f4">Internet of Agreements IV: Space</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/humanizing-the-singularity">Mattereum - Humanizing the Singularity</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Mattereum panel at the Internet of Agreements conference.]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/humanizing-the-singularity/mattereum-panel-at-the-internet-of-agreements-conference-f732dc873b93?source=rss-69bb99cf537a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f732dc873b93</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Rob Knight]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 06 Apr 2018 18:34:06 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-05-22T15:54:55.341Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>On February 23rd, </em><a href="https://mattereum.com/"><em>Mattereum</em></a><em> hosted the second </em><a href="http://internetofagreements.com/"><em>Internet of Agreements</em></a>®<em>(IoA) conference at the UK Government’s Digital Catapult in London. IoA</em>®<em> is a vision for global supply chains and logistics, integrating national laws and regulation with international commerce through the application of technology such as blockchains and smart contracts.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*MJWpVzwKSlXX_N0ftnVnig.jpeg" /></figure><p>At the conference Mattereum held a panel discussing the legal enforceability of smart contracts and the work that we are doing to facilitate the adoption of of the blockchain technology by business. Below you can find the video and the transcript of this panel.</p><p>The panel comprised the core Mattereum team: <a href="http://twitter.com/mcimpoesu">Mihai Cimpoesu</a> (Chief Engineer), <a href="http://twitter.com/harshcopywriter">Christopher Wray</a> (Chief Legal Officer), <a href="http://twitter/leashless">Vinay Gupta</a> (CEO) and myself, COO of Mattereum.</p><p>We touched upon interesting topics like standardisation of contracts, governance of forks, digitising contractual rights, the potential use of the blockchain as a digital evidence log, reasons why a lot of contracts are unenforceable, cultural differences in dispute resolution, and more.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2Fh2RwXdU6hNw%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3Dh2RwXdU6hNw&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2Fh2RwXdU6hNw%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/1be16b710a9f387d3cdc5cd7f2d90a80/href">https://medium.com/media/1be16b710a9f387d3cdc5cd7f2d90a80/href</a></iframe><p><strong>Transcript.</strong></p><p><strong>Rob:</strong> I’m just going to do a brief introduction, to give you a conceptual background to what Mattereum is and what we’re doing. I’d first like to start by explaining what kind of problem we’re solving. Different people ask me this, and the answer tends to be pretty different, depending on the context that the people have when they ask that question. If you begin with knowledge of blockchain, you start thinking about why do we need these legal contracts on a blockchain? If you begin with knowledge of the law, you think, “What do we need a blockchain for? Why does that come in?” So I’m going to try and do a brief history lesson of the time before blockchains existed and how people thought about how to put contracts on the Internet, and why they thought it was necessary to do so.</p><p>I’m going to go back to the late 1990s, which some of you will remember. In the late 1990s people were thinking about how to set up systems of digital cash, how to set up a system pretty similar to Bitcoin, where you could on the Internet send money to other people with reasonably low transaction costs reasonably quickly all around the world. It was pretty obvious at that time that you couldn’t this with dollars, you couldn’t do it with pounds, you couldn’t do it with yen; the system simply hadn’t been built. If we think that bank IT is pretty bad now, it was even worse then. It would take days and days and days for payments even within the same country, and the idea of sending payments internationally with low fees and rapid transaction times was a complete pipe dream.</p><p>So, a bunch of people thought about how they would do this, and they came to the conclusion that you could do it if you had an asset of reasonably stable value, such as gold, that you placed in a bank vault, and then you issued essentially entries in a database to people that pretty much represented their share of the gold. At that point you can move those entries around in the database, and that is essentially like paying someone else with money: the entries in the database have this cash-like property, where if I update the database to say that 10 units has gone from me to you, you now have money that you didn’t have before. The problem with this system was how did we know that the entries in the database actually related to real gold in a bank vault somewhere? This was solved using a system which is now known as the Ricardian contract, and there’s a whole history behind that name which you can read on the Wikipedia page.</p><p>The Ricardian contract essentially is an ordinary legal contract that closely identifies a particular technical system and the state of that technical system at the beginning, and says, “Anything that happens inside this system when the ledger is updated, when the database changes, those changes have a certain meaning in the real world.” So the numbers in the database refer to units of gold, and everybody who participates in that system signs the contract, which means that we now have an agreement between all the participants as to what the database actually means. That was the only way that the database could have legal force in the real world; you make an update in the database, and it affects the ownership of physical stuff in the real world.</p><p>That line of thinking was actually largely forgotten, or largely ignored in fact, once Bitcoin came along. Because with Bitcoin there is no real asset, there is no physical bar of gold somewhere, there is nothing off-chain that Bitcoin refers to. If you have a digital key and a certain quantity of Bitcoin that is controllable by your digital key, there’s no external asset to even worry about. There’s the phrase “Possession is nine-tenths of the law,” and with Bitcoin, if you possess the digital key, that’s it, you have ownership and control, simply by virtue of holding the key. With a system that needs to refer to real assets in the physical world, you might be able to update the ledger, but unless you are sure that updating the ledger actually changes the ownership of the asset in the real world, then you’re just pushing numbers around in a computer system and there’s a risk that it doesn’t actually mean anything.</p><p>That Ricardian contract thinking is the building block for what we are doing at Mattereum. We’ve taken those sets of ideas and looked at how do we create a system where on a blockchain we can represent physical assets and move them around with the convenience of a modern computer system, but where you can refer to physical assets, where in fact you can refer to non-physical assets, things like intellectual property or things like future streams of value that might be that might be earned from an investment. It’s this thinking that gives us this notion of the Internet of Agreements, it gives us this idea that we can have, representing on a blockchain, contractual rights that we can move around extremely easily, that we can trade with each other, and that we can structure increasingly complex and increasingly powerful assets, agreements, financial instruments of various different kinds, using a combination of a legal contract and a technical system whose behaviour is in conformance to the terms set out in a legal contract.</p><p>That I think is the key background to what Mattereum does. We’ve got that set of thinking about Ricardian contracts, but it’s kind of clunky, it’s kind of difficult. I mean, who really wants to be signing a paper contract? How do you even… It doesn’t sound Internet native, it doesn’t really sound like the way that we do things in 2018, having people printing things out and signing with ink and so on and so forth; it might have been acceptable in the 90s, but it’s not acceptable now. So we look at other innovations that have occurred over the last 20 years, and we’ve moved very much from a society that ran on cash to a society that now is largely cashless. You can buy pretty much anything you want now using a credit card or for that matter Apple Pay, Google Pay, any of the various contactless systems — I can pay for things using my watch, which is pretty cool — and that transition, that move from physical bits of paper to essentially digital systems for payment has made the life of consumers much more convenient.</p><p>But if you look at the technologies that back something like a credit card, there’s in fact a whole bundle of different things in there, there’s a whole bunch of things going on that are way more powerful and way more interesting than what you would get with cash. If you buy something, you pay for something online with a credit card and that thing doesn’t turn up, you have a system where you can dispute the payment, you can say, “I paid for something and I didn’t get what I paid for,” so you can actually get a chargeback in the case of a credit card payment, which is something that you wouldn’t be able to get with cash. You get, in some cases, extra warranty or extra insurance on the goods; again, you don’t get that with cash. You also get a form of identity. If I go to an ecommerce site and type in my name and my address, that can be checked by the merchant against the information that’s held by the credit card issuer.</p><p>What if we could take those kinds of innovations and bring them to contracts, so we have a situation where when you sign a contract with somebody, you can verify your identity, verify the identity of both parties to the contract, where you can begin to bring in insurance against the possibility that the contract isn’t performed, and where you can start to bring in dispute resolution — which is already commonplace for legal contracts as it is, where you could bring in a form of dispute resolution that is globally accessible all around the world — could we begin to see the same kind of innovation in personal finance, in business-to-business deals, in global trading arrangements that we’ve seen in the consumer world over the last 30 years, beginning with the credit card and going through payment systems such as PayPal and Stripe, that have given rise to the ecommerce era, with Amazon, Netflix, eBay, Uber, Airbnb and so on and so forth? Is there a similar level of innovation, a similar level of change that you could achieve around contracts, so it becomes as easy and as frictionless to sign a mortgage agreement or a rental agreement, or to structure a long-term deal for shipment of goods, or for hedging of risks, or for investment in new businesses? Could we make that as easy to do as buying something with your credit card?</p><p>That is ultimately the end state that we want to get to, that’s ultimately what Mattereum is here to do, is to make it easy to facilitate all of those things. When we talk about blockchains and world trade, we really are talking about trying to facilitate trade around the world, where you’re making it possible for people to feel as safe and as comfortable and as convenient, when they’re going anywhere in the world to conduct business with anybody else in the world, as they would if they were doing an ordinary consumer purchase using a credit card. That is I think, as a vision, something that we think about a lot, but as a set of practical steps, it’s something that we’re just starting out on, and we want to talk a little bit more about what we’ve achieved so far and where we’re going with that vision. So I’m going to move over, take my seat, and we’ll begin a panel discussion. Thank you. [applause]</p><p><strong>Mihai</strong>: My name is Mihai Cimpoesu, Chief Engineer at Mattereum.</p><p><strong>Chris</strong>: Christopher Wray, Chief Legal Officer.</p><p><strong>Vinay</strong>: Vinay Gupta, Co-Founder.</p><p><strong>David</strong>: David Salgado, Head of Operations.</p><p><strong>Rob</strong>: Rob Knight, Co-Founder.</p><p><strong>Vinay</strong>: I guess it would be worth talking a little bit about how we got here. How we got here is a long and winding path, because, as Rob alluded to, there’s literally been this 20-year process of attempting to get computers properly integrated into trade, and to get the ability to do legal transfer of property using the Internet. There’s been generations and generations of technology deployed on this, but we still don’t have a situation in which you can reliably generate something that looks like a net 90 invoice and pay it using some kind of electronic currency, so it’s still a primitive process.</p><p>We’ve come to this from a range of different backgrounds, all attempting to converge on the different things that you need to get right to enable that process to run end to end: you need technology, you need law, you need the actual business processes, you need your concept of operations, and you need all these pieces to slot together. This is basically interdisciplinary research; it’s the hard questions about the boundaries between fields, and the demarcations between fields, that give the company the shape that it has, that’s why we are the shape that we are. Do you want to talk a little bit about the legal side of this, Chris?</p><p><strong>Chris</strong>: Sure. On this interdisciplinary angle, we touched on it in the panel session. It feels like there’s scope here for lawyers to do more and to start to take on, as I said, not coding, but really starting to think about the architecture of the social system that is being created by a contract, as much as the hard constraints, if someone needs to enforce it with the big stick of nation state violence, ultimately. So I would say already in some of the early work it’s not just law plus code, but there’s some systems engineering, systems design in there, scenario planning… It’s doing what could have been done earlier I think, and maybe should have been, in law, but there are certain misalignments of incentives.</p><p>It would be far preferable for all of the legal work to be done upfront, to produce… If you’re going to automate the performance of something, and if you’re going to have a big chunk of software there that helps you carry out your promises, then that chunk of software isn’t going to want to change radically deal to deal, so that’s going to become fairly standardised, which is going to push contracts towards being more standardised, so that’s a constraint on freedom of contract. You can map out the parameters, and there’s still scope for negotiating, depending on the parties’ negotiating positions and all the usual factors, but that standardisation actually now allows, in fact requires, upfront a thought to the system that comprises these parties, and whatever the rights and the various assets are that will be involved in their interaction, and it’s designing that, ideally, to reduce over time the number of disputes that ever arise.</p><p>Of course you want robust dispute resolution in place, but if you start to have a virtuous feedback loop, where you continually try and evolve your contracts and your code which are carrying parties through the carrying out of their promises to one another, then this becomes an opportunity, if you do it right, to anticipate the kind of things that can go wrong and to start to plan for them, put it into the code. Of course there will always be exceptions. I don’t take seriously the fact that we will, in general, move beyond having written legal contracts that accompany pieces of code. I think there will be whole classes of smart contracts which become so ubiquitous and so reliable that I would no more have a written contract to use it than I would have a written contract with a vending machine.</p><p>So, I do think there’s a new discipline here of the sort of legal systems thinker, where we map out… Just as good commercial lawyers always say, “We help shape the commercial deals,” it’s not just some sort of irritating formality to be added on, there’s input to the structure of relations that depends on the parties’ long-term goals and values and the kind of relationships they want to construct, but I think we’re going to see more of that. I think this whole space is a really exciting opportunity to do a lot more of that, as lawyers; it’s just it’s going to be something that’s done hand in hand with software engineers.</p><p><strong>Vinay</strong>: Mihai, do you want to talk a little bit about the technical side of this? We literally this week did a very large design charrette, which was really the very detailed collaboration between the legal team and the programming team, literally line-by-line analysis of a contract pair. Do you want to talk a little about that process and about how it’s different from the sort of regular coding environment?</p><p><strong>Mihai</strong>: Yeah. I’m coming from the programming side, from the guys who write the code, and it’s been a significant mind shift for me, from taking requirements from a clients which are sometimes vague and turning them into code, to then going through this legal process and collaboration with the legal team, it’s a significant mind shift. Because the coders are very eager to finish the work, and I guess we’re seeing a lot of projects like that in the crypto space, but they don’t do the proper diligence to make sure that what they are doing actually makes sense in the real world.</p><p>Also, just a view on how Mattereum is constructed as a company. I think a parallel on how Elon Musk is designing his companies is very aligned, in the sense that we are trying to build, as much as possible, in-house, as a collaboration between people coming from different backgrounds, and then the entire process of delivering a client project is much faster and much more efficient, and if we can make it so that at the end we weed out 99% of the bugs instead of 67%, that would be amazing.</p><p><strong>Question</strong>: Would you mind please explaining a bit how lawyers — who are late adopters of technology, not early adopters — are going to be affected by this new technology, whether they want to or not, and how might they need to be able to respond.</p><p><strong>Question</strong>: Mihai, you mentioned the requirements governing process is different to conventional software development. Please, could you talk a little bit to the process of teasing out your requirements in the Mattereum context?</p><p><strong>Question</strong>: Chris, you were talking about some of the new or possibly adjusted roles that lawyers might take on. In this country at least, there’s a deep cultural background that lawyers have which doesn’t come from their clients; if anything, what they get from their training is much more rooted in centuries of practice and the culture of the country. What new elements will they require for their new roles? Because obviously if that’s not something one thinks about, then you’ll get defaults that you probably didn’t want.</p><p><strong>Chris</strong>: Maybe I’ll try and do the first and third questions. When you’re dealing with multiple jurisdictions, which of course you are in world trade, and yes, we have the luxury of deciding on our governing law, if disputes are going to be submitted to arbitration instead of going to a national court, but still you’ve got to engage with all the local regulation. So there’s inevitably, I think forever, are going to be that requirement for specialist legal knowledge within particular jurisdictions, and on interactions between jurisdictions, that will always require that entirely conventional legal knowledge. Yes, I think it’s essential that with this kind of interdisciplinary thing we do both law and software engineering in-house, that’s the only way you tease out some of the interesting overlaps and new areas, but it’s never going to be all-encompassed within house. It would be bizarre to try and become a master of every single jurisdiction, so there’s going to be plenty of work for lawyers, with specialist expertise in specialist jurisdictions, to provide the kind of input that is required in producing these kind of contracts. Of course there’s going to be conventional legal work there, and this is only in one aspect of law, the kind of commercial side, for now.</p><p>But yeah, if you’re an early adopter, if you’re a lawyer interested in seeing where there is new space to move to, I think there’s some quite exciting new skills that you could move into. As I said initially, good commercial lawyers will have been doing this anyway. Of course they’ll have had a kind of implicit model of the space that their clients are operating in, the different kind of relationships, the different way those relationships can evolve, and they try and shape those or support the client’s choice of direction, they try and support that as well as possible and build enough around it, to provide the clarity and to manage the risks as best they can.</p><p>But I think there will be scope now for a formalisation of this. I think what we’re already developing is more of a methodology that is systemically aware. It’s no longer the case that the contract is fully performed or not, it’s just no longer the case that… And yes, there’s always been a scope for liquidated damaged or for ways of trying to anticipate something that might go wrong and specify a remedy for it in advance, to save the uncertainty and expense of having to determine it later, but now there’s vastly greater scope for this kind of anticipation of different possible future evolutions of a given commercial relationship and to try and start mapping those out.</p><p><strong>Vinay</strong>: I think it would be worth putting this is a kind of practical context. We have a set of clients, about 10, most of whom are developing some kind of Ethereum-based smart contract application which handles some kind of legal property. You get into a position where at some point there is a transfer of ownership or transfer of status of the legal property, and the intention is that that transfer of legal ownership or legal status will be triggered by an event on the blockchain; typically a payment arrives, or a certain amount of time elapses. You would think that in principle this is a relatively simple process, where the contract says, “In this condition, then when that ownership changes from one key to another key, the legal ownership change,” everybody signs their paper contracts and off you go to the races. But in practice, if you think about the gnarly technical complexity that even a relatively simple smart contract has, there’s an enormous need to have very, very specific domain understanding of what’s happening for the smart contract to be created in a way it represents the actual underlying reality.</p><p>Similarly, for those who are on the legal side of the house, if you think about how complex even relatively simple contracts are, because they directly interface with the full complexity of the world — and anything that happens in the real world, there must be some way of managing it inside of the paper contract, or you wind up with a kind of hard crash where the entire thing turns into litigation — what we have is an interdisciplinary space in which all of that complexity is put into a single techno-social system which emits a contract pair. The paper contract and the smart contract basically divide reality between them in a way that hopefully gives you a comprehensive coverage of the set of things which can occur. We talk about this as contract enforceability engineering, but really it’s a new discipline for thinking about the interface between the complex nature of the real world and two different kinds of simplifying abstractions, one of which is law and the second of which is code. It’s been quite a process of really beginning to frame what that discipline looks like, because it asks a lot of very hard questions about the nature of complex systems, and the sort of philosophical underpinnings of how we do things like make decisions.</p><p><strong>Mihai</strong>: The question about how do we deal with the specs coming from clients: with the clients that we have dealt so far, it was often the case that they come up with a half-page sketch of what they were doing, and they said, “Yes, we want this blockchain thing,” and then I would go in and produce a five-page technical requirements and technical specs out of that, go back to them and they’re like “Whoa… This is what I asked for?!”</p><p><strong>Chris</strong>: Which became a 10-page legal spec…</p><p><strong>Mihai</strong>: Yes, and then that become a 10-page legal spec, and this is what we’ve all signed up for in the end. But that whole process of coming from a sketch of an idea to an actual deliverable product that is even enforceable in the real world and is actually legal, this was the bulk of the work for those clients. Then we’ve written the code, and with one of these projects we are now at the end, where we’ve basically spent days together in a meeting room, just going line by line, having the code on the left and the written contract on the right, going line by line between the two of them to see if they match — it was a pretty exhilarating experience.</p><p><strong>Dominic</strong>: My name is Dominic Cameron, I’ve been building digital businesses in London, not very large scale, for about 30 years. Two related questions, speak to engineering and to operations, about maturity and readiness I guess of the underlying frameworks, the underlying platforms, partly about Ethereum and so on. At lunch Liang Tzu and I were talking, and he reminded me that we’re in sort of the 1990s phase of the evolution of blockchain… We know it’s going to be faster than that perhaps compared to the Internet, but still early phase. The first question is f we think about companies like DHL or Maersk or Costco, when would you imagine, how many years away would you imagine that at that scale, tens of thousands, perhaps hundreds of thousands of trades per day are impacted by the sort of things we’re talking about today? Are we 3–5 years away, are we 10–15 years away, and why?</p><p>Related to that, without getting into the kind of flame wars about ETC and Cardano and all that sort of stuff, given that you guys are I think focused on Ethereum primarily as an underlying platform, what are the things which companies like Tezos, EOS, Cardano are trying to resolve, whether it’s about interoperability, around scalability, around governance, around whatever other themes… What are the themes that you believe Ethereum have to solve to get on that path of delivering tens of thousands per day?</p><p><strong>Chris</strong>: Can I just say one line on Ricardian contracts first? Because I do think it’s important to realise that with the Ricardian contracts concept, this separation of legal terms and the software that implements it, it doesn’t lock you into a single software platform. I mean, I’m not sure why you would choose to do this, unless there was some compelling underlying reason, but conceivably a Ricardian contract could comprise some written legal terms and more than one software system on the other side. Again, that would potentially seem perverse is some cases, but I can imagine very complex situations where you would need to do that. I think that’s an inherent flexibility about the Ricardian contract approach, and an argument against a drive towards complete convertibility between code and written language. Not only are they on different levels systemically in terms of what they’re trying to describe, but potentially sometimes the world needs to be dealt with with different systems in different places.</p><p><strong>Vinay</strong>: At least theoretically, you could rebase a contract so the legal agreement doesn’t change, you just peel out one implementation layer and replace it with a different chunk of software. This would be tricky to do on the fly in large, complex systems, but if the legal agreements haven’t changed, switching the technology can be drafted into the legal contract as one of the things that you could do.</p><p><strong>Rob</strong>: On the question of maturity, I think there’s two levels that we need to think about maturity for, one is the scalability of the underlying blockchain system. You mentioned the idea of large companies and thousands of trades per day. Right now that’s not possible on public blockchains, the scalability characteristics are just not appropriate for that. So there’s a good amount of engineering work that needs to be done there, if we’re going to do this on public chains. You could do it now on private chains, and IBM will tell you a very good story about Maersk and Hyperledger, and that is very good work that’s being done and we’re not in any sense opposed to that. I think people have their views about public versus private ledgers; our view is you pick the right tool for the right job.</p><p>I think the second part of the maturity question is really the engineering culture. Do we actually have enough people out there, do we actually have the capability to deliver these systems? Because if you look at what web development did, web development pulled a large number of people into the software industry, a massive expansion of the number of people writing code. One of my favourite possessions is a book, I think written in 1999, called <em>After the Gold Rush</em>, and it was on the premise that the great gold rush era of software began in the 1980s and it roughly finished sometime in the mid-1990s, and that we should now settle down and professionalise software development because we weren’t going to need to pull in a huge number of new people. This turned out not to be the case.</p><p>But, what we’ve never really done is develop a professional code of software engineering. The general attitude that summed up a company like Facebook was move fast and break things. Move fast and break things is great when you’re deploying something to a Web server: you break it in the morning, you look at your logs, you see that errors are being reported, and you push out a fix that afternoon. What you’re really measuring in that instance is not how many bugs did we have, but how long did it take us to fix all the bugs we have, after we’ve found out about them? And this kind of works. You get updates on your phone every single day, you get websites that get updated several times day, it works for those kinds of systems. That approach does not work at all for a smart contract. If you imagine getting a letter from your bank, saying, “We’ve updated the terms of your mortgage contract,” and receiving several letters a day as new updates are being are being… It just doesn’t make any sense at all.</p><p><strong>Vinay</strong>: “Trust us.” [laughter]</p><p><strong>Rob</strong>: So, I think what we actually need is a very different engineering culture for these kinds of hybrid legal and technical systems, which is a culture of zero defects, of making sure the thing actually works correctly, and where there absolutely do need to be these kind of exception handling systems where something goes wrong, because the one rule is something always goes wrong, some unexpected aspect of reality occurs.</p><p>We’re at an interesting situation now, where for smart contracts… As someone who has worked as a software developer for many years, when I write some code for instance that appears on a website, that’s run on millions of computers around the world that are running different hardware, different versions of operating systems, different web browsers… If it goes wrong, it’s kind of a little bit unfair to hold me personally responsible for the fact that on some particularly weird configuration of system my code turns out not to work entirely as expected. But with smart contracts, they run again on millions of computers all around the world, but those computers compare their results and make sure that they all agreed on what the result of the smart contract was. If it does something, it does it because I programmed it to do it that way, and not because there are kind of weird errors being introduced by different hardware and operating system configurations.</p><p>We’ve had cases now of deployed smart contracts on Ethereum that have caused financial losses, where we can directly measure the financial loss. You can then go to GitHub and look at the code, and you can go right down to the individual line and you can look at the commit history, and there’s a lovely command in Git called “git blame” [laughter] which tells you who wrote that line. So you can actually find out directly…</p><p><strong>Comment</strong>: “It was just a white space change…”</p><p><strong>Rob</strong>: Exactly. So there is a level of accountability in smart contract engineering which is just not present in web development or mobile app development, and I think the software industry has not yet, at all, begun to internalise the cultural change that you get from that. I think that is going to be a very big driver of a new kinds of maturity for software engineering.</p><p><strong>Question</strong>: Is that on the way on Ethereum, the cultural change?</p><p><strong>Vinay</strong>: Well, at this point Ethereum smart contract goofs have cost many hundreds of millions of dollars. I would say that the engineering culture is beginning to get a little warier.</p><p><strong>Mihai</strong>: We’re kind of obligated now, that’s not down to preference anymore — these guys enforce it!</p><p><strong>Vinay</strong>: All of this gets into the much more general domain of how you do reliability engineering for big systems, and that is still very much a craft. I think that it would be unsurprising if in five years you saw an enormous influx of expertise from aerospace and satellite into these areas, simply because you wind up with so much value at risk that those kind of engineering practices become a much more sensible way to approach it. I don’t know for sure that’s the way it will go, but it would be an unsurprising future hybridisation.</p><p>The governance and fork thing… That’s such a hard question. The fiddly thing with all of this is that the blockchain is extremely poorly defined. I often say to people that cryptocurrency is today’s equivalent of the term “horseless carriage”. These things are no more currencies than early motor cars were horse carriages. But we don’t really know what they are yet, because we are in this awkward transitional period, as we used to be with the Internet, where defining these things is a profession. There was a period in the late 90s where just telling people what the Internet was was a job, and then after a while that job goes way. This was true with social media. There was a period when knowing what social media was was a job, there was a profession called social media consultant; not so much of that anymore.</p><p>Similarly, we’re in this thing where we’re in a position where language formation lags behind the technological reality. When we talk about governance on blockchains, we’ve got an established body of practices for governance, and we’ve got this kind of wibbly-wobbly- squeezy thing called the blockchain which constantly changes, because the blockchain isn’t an object; it’s a process. It’s a cultural initiative, it’s a thing, a bit like… If we think of something like sport, sport contains a myriad of things, and blockchain is about as general a term as sport; it’s a not a clearly defined entity. So when we talk about the governance question of blockchain, for some people what they hear is “How do we revert a bad transaction?” and what other people hear is “How do we modify the software systems to choose for example a scaling algorithm we’re going to try?” and then in the middle there’s a whole bunch of questions about identity, and some people want to build these things into blockchains, and other people think that those are applications.</p><p>So, right now in terms of getting large-scale systems to run, I think what you’re going to get is the most conservative systems win. The systems which are least like the new and most like the old will be things which look a bit like online transaction processing, they might even come from the old vendors like SAP, and those things will likely be the first systems that begin to carry the first couple of 20–50–100 billion dollars’ worth of real trade transactions. The question then is the equilibrium between the legacy people who add a thin layer of blockchain, and the blockchain people that learn their way back into legacy, and that struggle happened right the way through the Web business for decades. That tension between legacy players requiring Web features and Web features requiring legacy skill, that demarcation has… I mean, half of the advertising money spent for business-to-business Web stuff was probably spent by people fighting down that line, and I think that will be exactly the same way with blockchain. Notably, Facebook, Amazon, Google, Microsoft, they’ve all been very reticent to announce their blockchain strategies; SAP and Oracle, practically nothing heard.</p><p>So I really think that the majority of the heavy trade stuff will initially happen when for example Oracle launches a blockchain-shaped thing, and it will be about 15–20% blockchain, it will be a thin layer on top of Oracle, but it’s much more credible to me that you’ll see large value transactions over those kind of systems than a whole-scale flight onto even a very fast version of Ethereum. Because it turns out that the enterprise has a whole bunch of needs which have nothing to do with the technology working. Do you want to say a bit more about that, Rob? I think specifically in terms of the stuff that you did for the BBC, just how you get Web-style technologies into these big institutions.</p><p><strong>Rob</strong>: A lot of my early thinking about smart contracts in particular came because I was working at the time with the BBC on a large-scale project, to digitise a lot of their rights management for commercial purposes, and this involved going through the BBC archives and basically taking all of these old pieces of footage. The video had been digitised for years, but the contractual rights have never been digitised, and so the challenge there was going through all the filing cabinets and pulling out pieces of paper from the 1970s, and working out what the implications were of this contract that had been drafted and signed with no knowledge of the concepts of streaming and download for streaming and downloading things. What does this actually mean? Who do we need to pay? How much do we need to pay them? How long can we put this thing online for? Those challenges are actually… in many respects, they’re more serious than the straightforward engineering challenges. Building the front end on the thing was not very hard, building a system that could take clean data and serve it up to end customers was not very hard; getting the clean data into the system in the right format and figuring out how to structure that, that was hard.</p><p>A lot of my early thinking on smart contracts, when I first came across Ethereum, was wouldn’t this be a great system for doing all of these things that we’ve been doing? Think about splits between actors and directors and production companies and all of these kinds of things. It’s the sort of thing that smart contracts are theoretically very well suited to. And then you realise how many transactions you can do per second on a public blockchain, and you realise that that kind of thing is completely unfeasible right now. But that is a thing that shifts year by year by year, and very, very suddenly you’ll find it becomes possible, and it will become possible almost overnight. The difficulty I think is that you’ve got to start now. Vinay mentions the likes of Oracle and so on. If you’re a large media organisation for instance, then probably is a blockchain, smart contract future for your organisation, at some point you’re going to face that.</p><p>The thing is, do you start now, or do you wait for the technologies to be ready? History kind of shows us that waiting until the technology is ready typically is waiting until it’s too late, you get disrupted by someone who comes up underneath you. So there is this kind of interesting period now where of people are kind of circling around these questions, there’s a lot of PoCs, there’s a lot of pilot projects… I think it’s easy to look at that and think, “They’re not putting that much real value over it,” but this really is the forerunner of the thing that’s going to come next. Companies that have survived the Internet, the original disruption of the Web, have done so because they learnt to adapt pretty quickly; those organisations are going to see blockchain coming and are going to adapt in pretty much the same kind of way.</p><p>I think their suppliers, their vendors, the big technology companies are themselves going to have to get into that game, because it’s the only way they’re going to be able to keep their own clients in business, once that disruption comes along. If you’re selling the old tools to companies who are being disrupted by the new tools, that’s a doubly bad situation for you to be in.</p><p><strong>Vinay</strong>: David, do you want to talk a little bit about government adoption and those processes? Because I think that’s also very sharp point here in terms of what those adaptation pairs look like.</p><p><strong>David</strong>: Sure. The reason I’m talking about this is that before joining Mattereum I was working at the Ministry of Justice as a technical architect, and certainly our government, and lots of other governments with different degrees of enthusiasm, are very keen that they’re not seen to be on the back foot with these technologies, that blockchain is clearly a very interesting technology, and what nobody wants is in five years’ time for some politician to go, “Why haven’t you been thinking about this?”</p><p>On the other hand, the fundamental attributes of distributed ledger technologies that make them useful is distribution of trust. We talked a lot about trustlessness this morning. Blockchain technologies are immensely useful where we have multiple actors who don’t necessarily trust each other terribly much. In the case of nation state governments, the government is the central trusted authority. There isn’t really a lot of point having blockchain tech for many of the things that government does, because the government is trusted. That’s partly why I think there’s potentially less interest in blockchain tech in government than one might expect. On the other hand, for those cases where there is distribution of trust, there’s certainly interest in looking at these technologies. But at the same time, the government moves very, very slowly, as we all know, and I think we will see developments in the private sector much more quickly than we will in government, and then those will sort of backfill into government, as it happens with lots of other technological shifts.</p><p>One area that… Let me be very clear that I’m not saying anything that is in any way government policy or that people are planning to roll this out as a live application, but there is a lot of interest, certainly in the MoJ and across other departments in government, about a potential use of blockchain technology as essentially a digital evidence log, such that if you have… A particular case in point at the moment is communication service provider data, where in a criminal case the police might have gone to Vodafone and said, “We’ve arrested this guy, we need to know where he’s been and who he’s been calling,” and the service provider can provide a log of these calls. There is a lot of interest in the idea of using a blockchain to store the hash of that artefact — whatever it is, whether it’s a communications log or a digital image or a piece of digital video — to write the hash to a blockchain, such that you can then go and point at it and say, “In six months’ time when you present the evidence in court, here is this thing, you can compare it against this hash on the blockchain, and it cannot possible have been tampered with.”</p><p>And this is actually, oddly enough, not a new idea. There used to be vaguely similar cases, where the proof that the thing was as you said it was is because they’d published certain hash numbers in the times, and you can actually go back to the times and verify it; details of exactly what the artefacts were isn’t that relevant. But it turns out that this concept is quite interesting for government, there’s is some work in exploring how that could be used. It also transpires that exactly the same concept can actually be very useful in contract negotiations, particularly in arbitration, where if the two parties who have a dispute go to a mediator or a qualified arbitrator and both of them have a thick pile of documents to say, “Look, this is exactly what happened,” that that can massively streamline and simplify the whole dispute resolution process, which… Chris is nodding, so I think… I’m sure he’ll correct me in a minute.</p><p>So yeah, certainly in government I think the applications of blockchain technology are not perhaps quite as widespread as we might have thought, but there is a lot of interest in particular niches where distribution of trust is an issue.</p><p><strong>Chris</strong>: Yeah, and this is a wonderful idea to borrow for civil proceedings. I think one of the things that we touched on the legal panel earlier but didn’t say too much about was this gap, where at present you have contracts which are effectively unenforceable, because the cost of effort to enforce it is too great, relative to what you would gain from doing so, and even if some recoverability of your cost is built in, it’s never complete. So there’s this sort of window where you’re well above small claims, retail level kind of disputes, but you’re well below the multimillion-dollar disputes, where of course it makes sense for both parties to have a full-blown arbitration, with all the trimmings.</p><p>Now, this is where I think this kind of technological application can be useful in trying to really trim cost and time. I think you will still end up… If you’re at a full arbitration, of course there will still be the traditional witness statements, people swearing an oath, that such and such evidence was indeed the document that they sent at that particular time, that’s still going to happen when you have full hearings. But for lower-value disputes and at earlier stages, this prospect of having a clear chronology of events as they unfolded through the contract and pieces of evidence that were thrown up at the time — it may be a bill of lading, it may be a notice by email from one party to the other, but certain things are hashed and that hash is put on a chain — the idea that you could very quickly have a third-party neutral come in and look at a set of documents which they know are the documents that were recorded at those times… That’s a boring but really meaningful efficiency saving.</p><p><strong>Vinay</strong>: I think it’s important to put this in the context of risk. Anytime something goes wrong in a piece of trade there are associated costs of recoverability that get spread across all of the transactions that you’re doing. All of the risk increases friction, the friction reduces the number of trades you can make which are profitable, and it all shrinks the size of global GDP Just getting the barriers to international trade down using mechanisms which don’t rely on international treaties is potentially a much larger counterbalance to the ongoing slowdown that we’re seeing in global trade than almost any other single thing we could do. If you think about how effectively access to information has been transformed by the Internet in the last 20 years, it’s not impractical to imagine that you could see something similar happening for access to goods, and that process is already well underway with for example Amazon. Amazon is what the game begins to look like when you see this kind of fluidisation of trade; imagine if that was true for everything else at the same time. Peter, you had a question.</p><p><strong>Peter</strong>: Yeah, I had an observation. I was very pleased to hear Rob bring up the subject of culture, particularly the collision of culture between the legal and technical and entrepreneurial. I had a situation in Italy years ago, where an entrepreneur wanted to use a gigantic Italian company to move shitloads of his product, and we had an informal memorandum of understanding… We negotiated on an A4 scrap of paper, we agreed this, that and the other. Then he brought his lawyer in, and the lawyer had set him up at a Delaware-based corporation, so his focus and mindset was protecting the IP at all costs, and within five minutes he completely destroyed the trust in the deal, because that was the only language that he could see.</p><p>Let alone the fact that the legal system there is somewhat Napoleonic law-based, which is different than our system, certainly different from America. Let alone the cultural aspect that the Italians don’t fight black against white. Their language, when they express such things, it uses a special tense where there’s a bit of wiggle room built in for the other side. Because as a macho society, Spain is the same I think, you can’t be seen to fail as a male in that sort of combative environment. So I think culture, Rob, is a fantastic element to look at on the longer term, and to think about what are we going to do with all these other legal jurisdictions and how do they fit in on international trade, which is where we came in.</p><p><strong>Vinay</strong>: This is the unresolved business that has been all the way through the Internet-based round of globalisation. The formation of a single global Internet culture around things like Wikipedia is very, very far advanced, but in things like international trade, those cultures are going to remain extremely particular and national for a long time. We don’t really know what it means to have a global trade backbone, which technically works more or less the same way everywhere but regionally will be used in completely different ways. I think you could look at what’s happened with Internet messaging, where you see the iconographic cultures give rise to emojis, which eventually get backported into the West. It would be fascinating to see whether trade norms from other cultures came back across these channels, once these channels were opened.</p><p><strong>Chris</strong>: What I hope we might also be able to do is overcome a cultural failing with human beings generally, which is that we just don’t like to think about what will happen when it goes wrong. Law has been the technology, contract law, that we’ve developed to deal with that failing, you have this class of human beings who are trained to try and constrain those risks, but there are… I think the kind of systems thinking design approaches that I keep referring to are much better ways. Scenario planning, trying to map out how this dynamic system might evolve in various different directions, and then anticipate and allow for what you’d like to see in those different outcomes. That is something that human beings just don’t do, but it would be tremendously good if they did, and I think this space allows us to start imposing that discipline on the planet.</p><p><strong>Question</strong>: Your idea of lateralisation of evidence so that you keep track of the chain of events and when it happens and so on, why is that a public blockchain and not a GitHub repository or something like that? Why do you need the overhead?</p><p><strong>Chris</strong>: Rarely is that, I would say, going to be a public blockchain. Even just the hashes carry valuable metadata that you wouldn’t necessarily want to reveal to a competitor. Just somebody watching the timing of these hashes pop up could give them valuable intelligence. So I think we’re not going to see that kind of thing on a public blockchain.</p><p><strong>Vinay</strong>: That’s all, folks — thank you very much! [applause]</p><p>________________________</p><p>Learn more about Mattereum: <a href="https://www.mattereum.com/">https://www.mattereum.com/</a></p><p>Join the conversation in Telegram: <a href="https://www.mattereum.com/">https://www.mattereum.com/</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f732dc873b93" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/humanizing-the-singularity/mattereum-panel-at-the-internet-of-agreements-conference-f732dc873b93">Mattereum panel at the Internet of Agreements conference.</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/humanizing-the-singularity">Mattereum - Humanizing the Singularity</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Global governance in the era of blockchain.]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/humanizing-the-singularity/global-governance-in-the-era-of-blockchain-815cfbd06eca?source=rss-69bb99cf537a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/815cfbd06eca</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[smart-contracts]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[blockchain]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mattereum]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Rob Knight]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 21 Mar 2018 15:29:20 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-03-21T16:03:12.314Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>On February 24th Vinay Gupta and I held a talk at the conference</em><a href="http://www.blockchaincambridge.com/"><em> “Blockchain: Rewiring Governance”</em></a><em> in Cambridge. Below you can find the video and the transcript of this talk.</em></p><p>We were talking about problems and possibilities for global governance in the era of blockchain, raising questions like:</p><ul><li>How will blockchain affect the way we globally do business?</li><li>How do we apply rules and regulations to this space, when it was built without any of the affordances you need to put the existing national rules and regulations in place?</li><li>How is the technology changing the way we understand and deal with our individual rights?</li><li>And how do we rethink and use individual rights to shape the legislative agendas that will regulate how new technologies are managed?</li></ul><p>Video:</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FI_wT3P9f0NA%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DI_wT3P9f0NA&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FI_wT3P9f0NA%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/c5da0fc225927834cebd22663a12cb7f/href">https://medium.com/media/c5da0fc225927834cebd22663a12cb7f/href</a></iframe><p>Transcript:</p><h4><strong>Rob</strong>:</h4><p>I want to try and look a little bit at blockchain governance from a historical perspective. I’m trying to introduce some long-range, 40–45 year thinking here, where we can look back on the blockchain in the context of the development of the Internet.</p><p>We’ve had something that resembles an Internet for about 45 years at this point. The first iteration of the Internet, if you want to call it that, probably begins in about 1973, and it begins with a group of universities in the US linking their computer networks up to each other. The primary drivers for this thing are for the sharing of information amongst scientists, academics and researchers, and for the defence establishment to have a secure and robust communications infrastructure that is decentralised and resistant to, for instance, nuclear attack on a communications HQ.</p><p>The defence people are mostly interested in having the infrastructure there, but they don’t actually have that much day-to-day use for it most of the time, so by default the system belongs to the scientists, it belongs to the academics, it belongs to the researchers. They do the kind of things that those people want to do, which is they want to share research information with each other, they want to keep in touch, they want something to replace having to send letters to each other, or having to send paper reports, or having to publish all of their results quarterly in journals. With email they can share those results immediately, and with FTP or other file transfer systems they can send large datasets to each other pretty much as quickly as the communications lines will carry them.</p><p>We have this first era of the Internet that runs for about 15–20 years and is primarily an <strong>Internet of ideas</strong>; it’s non-commercial, and it’s really just there to help people communicate with each other, and pretty much the last act of that kind of first age of the Internet was the creation of the Worldwide Web. This was a product of the scientific establishment, it was invented by Tim Berners-Lee at the CERN research institute, and his original thinking was “This is going to be a great way for me to share my findings and my research with other scientists, and maybe they will want to share their findings and research in the same way too.” This isn’t how it’s done now. The Worldwide Web was the first thing that was actually easy enough for ordinary people to use, and even inside CERN people were using it for all kinds of stuff that was completely unrelated to their day job. I think one of the first examples of this was that a group of female scientists at CERN had formed their own music group, and they created a webpage to talk about their songs and to share that with other people. So pretty quickly the Web began this process of bringing more personal information, bringing more personal discussion and bringing the sharing of media onto the Internet.</p><p>Go forward another couple of years, and people realise that this might be really useful for commercial purposes. The same things you can do on the Web kind of look a lot like catalogue shopping: you can browse around and you look at things, you’ve got pictures of stuff… If there was only some way that you could actually place the order, then you could complete the entire purchase process using the Internet. Unfortunately, there’s no secure way of sending payments over the Internet at this point so we can’t do it. Enter some cryptography researchers, you have a good way of encrypting information over the Internet, this gets formalised as the Secure Sockets Layer standard, or HTTPS, and this gives us the ability to send payment information. We can take our credit card numbers and send them securely across the Internet to other people.</p><p>We then get the second great age of the Internet, which is variously you might call it the <strong>Internet of payments</strong> or an Internet of commerce or an Internet of shopping, which is all about taking the things that we can do with our credit cards and putting them on the Internet. Amazon is basically just a giant supermarket, and Netflix is basically just a giant video rental store, and Uber is basically just a giant taxi service, but we’ve taken those things from the physical world and moved them into the digital world, all on the back of being able to send our credit card information securely over the Internet. I really want to emphasise how simple that innovation is; just being able to send credit card information securely over the Internet gives us Amazon, Uber, Airbnb, eBay, Netflix, and it also in a way gives us Google and Facebook, because the business models of Uber and Facebook are dependent on advertising to people who have credit cards and can put their credit card numbers in and then buy something from somebody.</p><p>This gives you several of the world’s largest companies by market cap at this moment in time. <strong>The entire e-commerce revolution, the entire last 20 years of Web and mobile app development is all based off this ability to send credit card information.</strong> And it works because the technology has the same kind of basic form as the shopping experience: you go into a store, you kind of browse around, you see something you like, you pick it up, you put it in a shopping basket, you take it to the checkout, you’re then processed through the checkout, and, congratulations, you now own a pair of jeans that you didn’t own before, and you’ve paid for it using cash or credit card. The Web is very, very good at modelling that kind of experience: you click through various different pages, you see a product you like, you add it to your shopping cart, you click “checkout”, you enter your payment information, and, congratulations, you’ve now bought something.</p><p>That fit between the technology and the experience created the explosive growth of ecommerce, that was why it was so easy to do it, that is why it rolled out so quickly and why it was so effective. But it also leaves a bunch of stuff that hasn’t been done: we don’t yet really have a good digital representation of something like an insurance contract. Because you sign an insurance contract, and many months or years later you then come back to make a claim on the insurance, and the Web isn’t such a good fit for that, because things that get put on the Web tend not to stay there. If you go back 10 years and write down the top most popular webpages in the world from 10–20 years ago, a good number of them aren’t there anymore. A contract that disappears is not very useful; a product that disappears from the supermarket shelves, that’s kind of expected, you kind of know that the products that are there now… This year’s spring and summer collection is not going to be there next year, but this year’s insurance contracts damn well better be there next year when you want to make a claim on it.</p><p>So we have this space of personal finance, business finance, things that run on for instance 90-day invoices, that need to last quite a long time and that need to have clear identities of the participants, so they are multiparty participant-based. They might be conditional, they might have logic built in — the insurance pay-out will only happen if these conditions have been met, the invoice will only be paid if these conditions have been met — and they need to last for a really long time.</p><blockquote>In a way that the Web is a good fit for the shopping experience, do we have a technology now that’s a good fit for these other experiences? Our position is that the blockchain is a good fit for those kinds of experiences. You can sign something with your digital signature and your counterparty signs it with their digital signature, you can specify the logic of conditionality in a smart contract, and once you put it on the blockchain it stays there. So it’s a super useful way of doing all kinds of contractual agreements, where you have a proper, full digital representation of that contract, in the same way that an ecommerce store gives you a proper, full digital representation of basically the catalogue shopping experience.</blockquote><p>Our thinking in all of this is that there’s a long sweep of technical innovation going on, where problems get solved once the technology becomes available to solve them. The Web unlocked a bunch of stuff that just wasn’t possible before the Web was invented, and the blockchain has unlocked a bunch of stuff that wasn’t possible before the blockchain was invented. <strong>So the reason why people are getting really excited about the blockchain, the reason why so much money and so much hype and so much buzz is going on is because it has opened up a new space, and that new space may well be bigger than e-commerce was, so bigger than the thing that gave us Amazon, Netflix, Google, Uber, Airbnb, etc. </strong>It might actually be the thing that in 20 years’ time you look back on, we see the world’s five most valuable companies were companies that were born out of the blockchain revolution, in the same way that several of the world’s most valuable companies right now were born out of the e-commerce revolution.</p><p>The interesting thing that’s changed, and I think where this gives us a governance challenge, is that the blockchain is also kind of world’s first major post-Internet digital technology. What I mean by that is that you need to think about the ages and the psychology of the people involved in creating a lot of this technology. There is a famous quote by Douglas Adams which I don’t trust myself to remember, so I’m going to read it out from my phone.</p><p>Douglas Adams said:</p><blockquote>“I’ve come up with a set of rules that describe our reactions to technologies: Anything that is in the world when you’re born is normal and ordinary and is just a natural part of the way the world works. Anything that is invented between when you’re 15 and 35 is new and exciting and revolutionary and you can probably get a career in it. Anything that is invented after you’re 35 is against the natural order of things.”</blockquote><p>[laughter]</p><p>This worked pretty well: I’m 36 now, so basically anything that comes after this point is just wrong, but that kind of matches my experience pretty well. Google was invented in 1998, when I was 17, and to me that was a very, very clear signal that this is where I’m going to build my career, and I built my early career as a software engineer building Web systems, because it was obviously the way the world was going. One of the things that happens though as you get older is you realise that the people in their early 20s are getting further and further away from you. If I look at Vitalik Buterin for instance, who created Ethereum, he’s 24, he was born in 1994, he was four years old when Google was founded. So for him, the Internet and global, very, very low cost, always-on communications is just a natural part of how the world works, it’s always been there. For people pretty much under the age of 30, the Internet has always been there: Facebook has always been there, Google has always been there, Amazon has always been there; it’s kind of like the post office or the phone company or something, they’ve always existed. And they’ve always been global: they made friends with people they’re playing videogames with on the other side of the world, they’re used to being able to communicate through social media with anybody and everybody, and national borders really don’t figure in that.</p><p>So when we were starting to roll out the Internet in the late ’80s and early ’90s and we wanted to figure out how we were going to identify all of these computers on the Internet — we couldn’t just use the IP addresses, they’re very, very hard to remember — we need to give them names, and we need to have a hierarchical system of naming servers on the Internet, and we created the Domain Name System. The Domain Name System has a whole bunch of top level domains — .com, .edu and so on and so forth — but the majority of these names are country codes — .co.uk, .fr, .de and so on and so forth — which identifies a website as having a scope that’s, broadly speaking, limited to a particular country. The blockchain doesn’t have any of that, because the people who built the blockchain grew up in a world in which global communication was normal rather than the exception. Global communication is not some exciting, new, whizzy thing that’s never been seen before; global communication is how the world works. So when they set out to build a system of money, it doesn’t occur to them to think, “We’re going to have a British system of money for this area, a separate French system and a separate German system, a separate system for China… We’re going to have one system, and it’s going to work in pretty much exactly the same anywhere in the world.”</p><p>So when Bitcoin comes along, it’s just global by default. Nobody thinks, it doesn’t even occur to anybody that you should limit it on a country by country basis, that idea is just not something that anybody would ever think. That’s what gives us this really interesting governance problem when people start to build really interesting things on top of blockchains, decentralised, autonomous organisations. What jurisdiction is that organisation in? I don’t know. Does anybody really have a good answer to that? Probably not. What jurisdiction is a record on the blockchain held in? Which data protection regulations apply to the information on the blockchain? If people are doing initial coin offerings or token sales, whatever you want to call them, which countries’ financial investment and securities regulations apply to those token sales?</p><p>There isn’t an obvious answer, because the assumptions of the people who built the underlying system were so at odds with the existing national regulatory frameworks that the things just don’t play very nicely together. So any response of legal governance is going to have to be one that takes into account the fact that in an Internet native world, national governance and global communications are kind of an odd fit. We need some way of maybe… Either we balkanise the Internet and have separate national Internets with national governance, or we figure out some way of doing international governance that people are happy with, and international governance right now is pretty hard to do. The great wave of Post-World War II international institution building has kind of stopped. Brexit would be a good example, but there are other examples now, of it becoming harder and harder to get international cooperation on certain kinds of issues.</p><h4>So we’re faced with this real, genuine conundrum: how do we apply rules and regulations to a space that was built without any of the affordances you need to put the existing national rules and regulations in place?</h4><p>Our view is that honestly we don’t know how that is going to end.</p><p>As Mattereum, as a company, we believe in contracts and self-regulation, the idea that people make agreements amongst themselves, and use existing enforcement mechanisms to tie those into the national, existing legal systems. But when it comes to the really big questions of what’s allowed on the blockchain, what would be considered a criminal offence on a blockchain, even that is kind of above our paygrade. And those are the kind of sets of questions that I don’t think I’ve heard anybody give a really good answer to, so I’m kind of posing this more as a question that needs an answer than something that I’ve got a good answer to.</p><p>I’ve done a bunch of talks to different kinds of audiences, some very heavily student oriented, some more business oriented, and you get different generations of people. Some people will come up to me after the talk and say, “You know, this reminds me very much of a situation we had in 1987, with a new financial product that came along and we needed to figure out how to govern that.” Other people come along, who are younger, with a different perspective, which is that they don’t see why some of these things should be a problem. They’re more coming in with the perspective that this is just how the Internet works, surely it’s the responsibility of the governments to get with the programme and understand how the Internet works. I think that culture clash, that set of problems to be resolved, that set of thinking that needs to be done is really just starting to happen now. I think people are only just starting to wake up to the fact that there’s a question that needs to be answered.</p><p>Looking around this room, we’ve got a good mix of people of various different ages, but I think for the younger people in the audience, grappling with these kinds of questions is probably going to be a big thing that you’re going to see as a political question, as a business question, as an academic question over the next 20 years. So in many respects, I think it’s kind of up to you guys to figure out what the answer is, because I certainly don’t know. But I think if we can… Does this generally makes sense to everyone as a framing of the question? If we take that forward, we now need to think very much more about how do we do global governance of major global public infrastructure. The blockchain doesn’t belong the Western Europe, it doesn’t belong to North America, it doesn’t belong to China, it doesn’t belong to India; it kind of belongs to the world, and we need to figure out how we’re going to do global governance of these kinds of systems.</p><p>That’s basically my piece, the framing thing, and I’ll hand it over to Vinay now, but I think that’s a question that I’d really like to hear everybody’s thoughts on. Maybe not immediately, but if you have thoughts on this over time, if you write about it, think about it, talk about it publicly, please do let me know what you think, I’d really love to hear what everybody makes of that.</p><h4><strong>Vinay</strong>:</h4><p>Because we’re not going to solve this stuff today. The long-haul questions about how we do this kind of global governance, these questions are going to be with us for a while.</p><p>I’m going to take a slightly different tack. I’m going to talk about <em>individual rights</em>. The blockchain is a system which, at least in theory, is constituted by individual actors from their <strong>right to free speech</strong>. The blockchain records a series of utterances, these are statements, and those statements carry with them a digital signature, the statement with a digital signature is taken as being an indicator of somebody’s free action, their free will, and as a result it’s very hard to argue that the blockchain should be illegal. A series of statements are made by individuals, those statements are interpreted by other individuals to authorise the transfer of value, and the value only exists because individuals have chosen to recognise it as having value. It’s very hard to imagine a regime in which you can stop something like that, without fundamentally limiting speech. <strong>“You can have all the speech you like, but if your speech is interpreted by other people as being a transfer of value, I’m very sorry, you’re going to have to pay taxes on that.”</strong></p><p>This is very typical of what happens when archaic framings of rights are carried into an age with new technology. You see this in America, where we have an enormous amount of drama around gun control right now, because at the point where the equilibrium is set between individuals and the state and the guns are handed out, the guns are not particularly effective at killing people. They fire roughly once every 45 seconds, they don’t have any kind of large magazine, there’s no repeating function, you have to take the thing to pieces before you could get another shot off, so they are dangerous, but they’re not that dangerous; one individual with a gun is not a global menace. 200 years later you have large calibre, large magazine assault rifles, and the balance of power that was envisaged by the American Founding Fathers has now shifted dramatically towards the individual. However, again if you look at free speech, the balance of power in free speech matters has shifted dramatically towards the state because of the enormous automated surveillance platforms that we’ve seen revealed by people like Edward Snowden.</p><p><strong>So the machinery which is used to actually carry out your rights changes over time. </strong>The right may be the same, the individual is largely unchanged, human beings have not changed very much a really long time, but the machinery that’s used to practically implement the right changes over time, and as a result, for the foreseeable future, we’re going to be in a position where there is a constant struggle over the interpretation and reinterpretation of basic human rights, as technology either strips those rights or reinforces those rights. And because electronic communications are a fantastic mechanism for speech, speech rights are the most heavily affected initial rights in these kinds of systems.</p><p><strong>The second class of rights that I think are going to come up in a big way are <em>rights to property</em>.</strong> The objects around us are casually thought of as being property. We look at this stuff, and we don’t really think very much about the system of machines that turns the physical stuff around us into somebody’s property, but actually property is a really sophisticated, complicated legal process. Does everybody know the word “fiat”? Only a few people. Fiat basically means “This is so because we have willed that it is so,” and this is typically a will which is done by a sovereign, it’s something that is done by the crown. So fiat money is money which is willed into existence by the government, and that’s all of the common forms of currency, with the exception of cryptocurrencies.</p><p>Fiat property is not a term that’s used very heavily, but it refers to property which exists by government fiat. A good example of fiat property is patent. There is no immediately obvious natural right to patent, there’s no immediately obvious natural right to copyright, patent and copyright are new forms of property, they only go back a few hundred years. The ancient world doesn’t have anything that resembles copyright or patent. A trademark is another kind of fiat property, and the current system of land rights that you see in Europe is balkanised: the Germans have one model, the Dutch have a different model, the Brits have a different model, and if you go to America there are different models. All of these land rights are relatively arbitrary. Exactly how you implement the individual right of a human being to own land varies from place to place, and a lot of the conflicts that you saw between Native Americans and European colonists were because the Europeans brought with them this idea that land was divided up into partials and owned, but the Native Americans in many regions had a system of harvest, where the buffalo would come through, you take whatever you thought you were entitled to, but the land itself was not understood as having value. Because the land was not actually something that produced a lot of value, it was very hard to do any kind of farming, this was not suitable for agriculture without technology, so all you could really do was harvest what nature gave you as it went by on the hoof.</p><p>We’re in an age now where the global interconnectedness of speech is more or less total. You can say something and it’s heard around the world immediately, we’re going to record this little video here, that thing could well be on YouTube 15 minutes after we finish the talk. We have an environment where global speech and global free speech is achieved, at the cost of pervasive global monitoring of that speech, and you can argue that this has become something of a balance. The individual is more empowered by the global network, so is the state, and these things may or may not be seen as being in some kind of equitable balance. You could then tip that very radically if you saw mass adoption of surveillance-resistant privacy technologies, you could imagine a very sudden shift of the free speech equilibrium towards the individual. The state may be concerned, the state may also decide it just doesn’t matter that much; you’d have to see what the social impacts were.</p><p>The next round of negotiation that we see is a negotiation over the globalised nature of fiat property. Right now, if I take an object from the UK to Germany, the ruling law that governs that object goes from being British law to German law, and an object which may be perfectly legal for me to own here, in Germany suddenly becomes illegal. You see this very strongly with drug policy. People are increasingly getting caught flying out of California with a marihuana cigarette in their pocket, because where they come from it’s just a cigarette, and they arrive someplace like Dubai and now they have a real problem. The object has been mysteriously transubstantiated from being kind of inoffensive to being horrendous, lethal and life-destroying, because the property has been taken from one jurisdiction to another.</p><p><strong>Now, for individuals this is occasionally a little dangerous and kind of aggravating, but for businesses this stuff is hugely problematic. </strong>If you’re something like a supplier of industrial chemicals, you have no idea whether the stuff that you’re going to ship will be legal in the jurisdiction it’s going to arrive in. You can do your legal research and you can make some phone calls and you could check what the government calls it, but the fact is that these systems are extremely complicated. Everybody gives the chemicals different names, the law may be updated infrequently, and you’re not going to get a notice telling you the law has changed, so you wind up in a position where people just repeat the same behaviour that they always have done before, and it was always okay so it should be okay now, or they deal largely with local suppliers, because the local suppliers are likely to be in the same jurisdiction they’re in, so you don’t have all these cross-border issues.</p><p><strong>The old approach that we took to enabling global trade in spite of these fiat property guidelines was that we basically produced continental-level integrated trade blocks. </strong>The first big one of these is probably the Soviet Union, you have a single law from one end to the other, you could argue that America was actually the first continental block, although the states were dramatically different from each other until really the end of World War I, but one way or another, the European Union continues the trend, modern China continues the trend, one law per continent has basically been the thing that we attempt to approximate, and this is quite useful, because a continent is a sensible size of political trade. You kind of have a railroad network, and there’s coextensive region where the law and the railroad network kind of have the same domain, everywhere that’s connected by rail you kind of have the same law, and that has held us in pretty good shape right up until about now.</p><p><strong>But now we’re in a domain where the international will towards this kind of uniform global order is rolling backwards. </strong>The Trans-Pacific Partnership failed, the European Union is in trouble, I think it would be unsurprising if you saw America break up into some fairly large units in the next 5–10 years… You’d just about see a vector where the South of America refuses to accept election results that indicate a Far Left Democrat is elected, and you could see some kind of secessionist or partitioning movement. The same thing in the South of Europe: Spain, Italy, Greece all having problems keeping their countries together… We’re in a position where these continental blocks are kind of breaking down, because it turns out that a lot of what comes along for the ride with this trade integration is a whole bunch of craziness about social policy, and everybody hates social policy. It doesn’t really matter what the social policy is, at least one thing that your government institutes as social policy will get right up your nose; almost nobody agrees with everything their government recommends.</p><p>So, what we really need is to think sensibly about the global level. We’ve got global warming, we’ve got things like slavery baked into goods, we’ve got a whole bunch of toxic waste which is being dumped in by the developed nations on poor countries, or being dumped by poor countries on even poorer regions of poor countries, and all of this stuff is global trade network problems. But we don’t have a global government, and the people that have nuclear weapons are unlikely to accept the formation of a global government. If we did have a global democracy, you would discover that the vast majority of people would vote against most of what you consider to be your fundamental human rights, because those rights are relatively recently created and enforced, and so we would see some very, very serious breakdowns, but this doesn’t mean that we couldn’t potentially build an architecture that supported global regulation of trade on a more or less case-by-case basis.</p><p><strong>Imagine a future in which an object uniquely identifies itself</strong>, and I don’t mean the object identifies itself as “This is a bottle of water,” what I mean is “This is this specific bottle of water: it was pulled out of this well, it was bottled at this time, the bottle is made of these components, it’s got this ownership history, it has this environmental profile,” we know everything about that bottle of water, the entire context is carried there, including the legal structures that currently govern this bottle, and if I take that bottle across a border, the legal structure associated with that bottle changes. You could just about imagine this. You kind of have some way of figuring out what an object is, and the object is bound to all of the relevant law, and when the object crosses from one jurisdiction to another the relevant law changes. At that point, we can imagine a world where your software could automatically inspect everything that you happen to be carrying, and make sure that when you cross a border you’re not accidentally taking something somewhere where you shouldn’t take it. You walk into an airport, and your phone starts beeping and says, “You’re carrying nail clippers in your pocket. Could you put those back in the car or throw them away? You can’t bring them in here. — Right, okay.”</p><p>That notion is no stranger in the future than Google Maps is now.<strong> The idea that you can navigate around the physical landscape using a computer to make all the hard decisions seems totally natural</strong>. You get out of an airplane in Bangkok or in Dubai or somewhere, and you just pull your phone out, it tells you where to go and it’s generally pretty accurate. The same thing could be done for the law. And the best thing about this is in the same way that you could go and visit places you’ve never been on Google Maps, you could go and run experiments on the law in places that you’ve never been and in places that you might want to go. I’m an industrial shipper of goods, I want to see whether I could take this particular container of yoghurt and send it to Germany. I take my virtual yoghurt, I register it with all the systems, I ship it to Germany inside of the computer, the computer comes back and says, “Your product labelling is all wrong, you can’t do that,” I correct the product labelling, I try in the simulator again, and this time it goes through.</p><blockquote>What I think we’re heading into is a world in which there is very substantial automated access to regulation, so that we can very, very quickly use computers to figure out what particular set of rules the government wants us to play by locally, and then the computers could just figure out all of the hard stuff, and it should set us free from the vast majority of the regulatory burden, in the same way that digital mapping set us free from the vast majority of the navigational burden of going to unfamiliar places — automated compliance assistance.</blockquote><p>Now, here’s the hard question at the bottom of this and why this is very relevant to the blockchain. Systems like this will make the automation of law extremely cheap, it’ll make it very, very easy to tell people what to do, because the software in their phone will beep and tell them that they’re going to do something wrong when they do something wrong. “Hey, you can’t do that here! — Oh, right,” and on one hand you never get a parking ticket unexpectedly, and on the other hand maybe you’ve got Big Brother in your pocket in a whole new way.</p><p><strong>What we’re going to need as we move into an age when these kinds of technologies are inevitable is a much clearer understanding of what constitutes liberty.</strong> We need to think very clearly about what are the universal standards that we think all nation states should comply with, because at the end of the day the governments of the world work for us, they’re constituted on behalf of the people to do what they are told, and that’s why we have systems like democracy. Even in cultures which are not constituted in a democratic way, you still have the fundamental idea that the state is there to serve the people; that idea is universal, it’s almost never breached.</p><p>So in this kind of modern context, because the governments are slow, because they’re kind of inept, because they fumble with the future in almost all cases… There are a few examples, like Dubai has a different attitude, Singapore, but for the vast majority of governments the future is a threat. And for us, as people that are leaning hard into the future, we have to figure out what are the fundamental rules that we expect governments to play by as they interface with us in this kind of co-creation of the future. <strong>How do we create a situation in which individual rights are used to shape the legislative agendas that will regulate how technologies are managed? How do we use the technologies themselves to document those decisions in such a way that we can transparently navigate around the high-tech environment we’re going into?</strong> Because if we don’t get these things right, what we’re going to get is automated legal enforcement which is completely incoherent as you go from jurisdiction to jurisdiction to jurisdiction, and if you yourself are not the person that owns the device that gives you this legal navigation, you’re going to be in the kind of Internet of Things hell, where every time you go outside something starts automatically sending you bills. You’ll be sent fines for things that you never even knew you did, which is the current situation that people have as drivers, but that will go from drivers to being with individuals within 5–10 years.</p><p>I think the blockchain is basically a posterchild for individual, self-organised free speech being used to constitute these higher-level political structures, which it’s extremely difficult to find a civil rights case for tearing it down. <strong>You can’t really explain why free speech is not something people are allowed to do, and if somebody is clever enough to figure out how to use free speech to create currency, it’s very hard to imagine you would stop that. </strong>But it’s a test case, and you know the kind of future that we’re heading into, you know how complicated the technology will get. We have to catch up our rhetoric and our dialogue around fundamental human rights, and global fundamental human rights, very quickly, or we’re going to be left in a very uncomfortable place indeed. Thank you very much.</p><p>[applause]</p><p><strong>Question</strong>: I wanted to ask about the intersection of what you guys talked about. Because you started out talking about global systems, and then you were talking about property. But there’s things that are global systems that are things, like the oceans. So where’s the intersection between what you guys are talking about, as far as global governance of things that are global systems.</p><p><strong>Vinay</strong>: Part of the reason that we have such a problem protecting the oceans is because we have no effective global governance of the oceans, there’s no constituted body that treats the oceans as its sovereign territory. If we had a kind of single country that was all of the deep ocean, everything’s that’s outside of… All the international waters, if that was treated as if it was a nation state and had a bunch of people who are elected to represent it, you could easily imagine that that would then be able to enforce law in its sovereign territory, and you’d very quickly be able to figure out a lot of the environmental issues regarding the oceans. But because we’ve treated it as basically no mans’ land, it turns out that nobody is really taking care of it; the same thing for the atmosphere. We only really know how to regulate land.</p><p><strong>Matthew</strong>: My name is Matthew Schutte, I’m with a project called Holochain. One of the ways in which we kind of subsidise our project is by building a little app that bridges between our peer-to-peer apps and the central Web servers, we’ve got this bridging thing. I bring that up, because the question that Rob had posed early on about how will these distributed autonomous organisations interact with this world that is dependent on geography, etc., and I don’t think we’re the only ones who are going to grapple with this, to find some solution to it.</p><p>But the fundamental tension there is that these distributed autonomous organisations — blockchain-based solutions, Holochain-based solutions, etc. — are really dealing with enforcement and influence of behaviour through discretion, through people choosing whether to interact with somebody else based on their history, and that’s a different model: it’s a discretion-based enforcement mechanism, and it’s different from what legal systems are based upon, which is a violence-based enforcement mechanism and is dependent on the presence of a body.</p><p>So one of the things that we’re dealing with, and I’m sure others will as well, is you actually need, if you want to operate in a particular jurisdiction and make use of the enforcement mechanisms and the guarantees and the banking system, etc. that operates there, you have to show up according to those rules, you have to have some bodies that you put at risk. Then you start to get into how do we set up the relationships between those bodies and this distributed organisation, and it’s very different scenario mechanisms. There’s a whole bunch of design decisions that get in between those, but it really boils down to this tension between two different mechanisms of enforcement.</p><p><strong>Vinay</strong>: Yeah, yeah. I mean, it’s all jurisdictional arbitrage, isn’t it? You have a single business process that has an element that runs on the blockchain world, an element that runs in the physical world, and different parts of the process are done in different jurisdictions.</p><p><strong>Matthew</strong>: And at some level this stuff isn’t new, right? Multinational corporations have been doing this “We’ll put a body here, we’ll put a body there…” This game is not a new game, but it’s being played with a different set of decision making processes on the other stuff.</p><p><strong>Vinay</strong>: Yeah, yeah. You have a saying, the thing about nerds and securities law…</p><p><strong>Rob</strong>: Oh, yes. I remember seeing this comment somewhere on Twitter or social media somewhere, saying the real purpose of the blockchain and cryptocurrencies and ICOs is to teach nerds how securities law works. And I think this was intended, that these nerds are going to get a rude awakening one day and they’re going to learn how the law really works, it’s going to show them who’s boss. But I kind of think there’s an unintended consequence, which is the outcome of this is a bunch of nerds who know how securities law works, and that sounds pretty dangerous. [laughter]</p><p><strong>Question</strong>: Just a general question of how blockchain might affect the role of governments and nation states, and maybe the geopolitical consequences of blockchain.</p><p><strong>Vinay</strong>: Oh, let’s just do it. How many nation states do you think there are?</p><p><strong>Question</strong>: 60?</p><p><strong>Vinay</strong>: 15. <em>If you don’t have a nuclear bomb, you’re not a nation state. </em>[laughter] It’s very simple: these things are provinces, they’re not countries. By the way, Germany and Japan and a few other places are considered to have what they refer to screwdriver-ready nuclear weapons: you don’t have any nukes, 15 seconds after the Russians being to make serious noise, they’re like “Look what we’ve found in this factory!” Once you understand that there are only really 15 countries in the world and the rest is provinces, most of international relations becomes very, very easy to understand. You just look at the nuclear arsenal, and you look at the position of the nuclear arsenal relative to the other nuclear arsenal, and the global political game becomes extremely simple. The Americans do design and finance, the Chinese do manufacturing, the Russians do energy, the Europeans just kind of screw around with agriculture and stuff… [laughter] You could tell what each nuclear block does, and then you’ve got the areas that have nuclear actor, like South America and Africa, and these places are generally terrible, because nobody is in charge.</p><p>Once you get an accurate model of how this stuff works, you then note that the nuclear state actors are completely outside of the democratic framework. You don’t get to vote on who actually makes the decisions about that stuff, are you crazy? The US National Security Council maintained the policy of containment for 40 years regardless of who was in power, without taking any regard of the democratic institutions at all — the national security guys have figured out how to solve the problem.</p><p>Against that background, I think there’s enormous hope for individual liberty, because the real powers inside of government don’t care about social policy; they’re super busy watching the other peers in the big power game, they don’t care about social policy at all. I think if we got real about that, that the real powers in government don’t care about social policy, we could get much clearer about where the demarcation line is between the individual and the state. The state is the thing that maintains the nuclear weapons stockpile, and everything else is just a series of interlocking mayors: they’re responsible for cleaning the streets, they’re responsible for making sure that there are schools open, but other than that they don’t really care what people do. It’s this slipping away of realism in the way that we relate to the state since the invention of the nuclear bomb that I think leads to this enormously futile political thrashing which is the vast majority of our political activity. The real state doesn’t really care, and we should take advantage of that and renegotiate, and stop paying so much attention to the fake state apparatus which is the machinery of democracy. That’s not where the power is, don’t be ridiculous. Does that make sense? We can largely renegotiate, because those guys are completely hollowed out compared to where they used to be. That’s my analysis. Do you have anything to add to that?</p><p><strong>Rob</strong>: No. [laughter]</p><p><strong>Question</strong>: As you were saying, all of the issues that have come up recently are just a by-product of the way that our political system has been set up. By establishing something that’s as controversial as social policy being managed by blockchains, how do you envision that governments will change in the future?</p><p><strong>Rob</strong>: There’s a few different ways that people have tried to approach this. I’ve seen a bunch of different projects that have gone on in the past to create digital democracy, digital engagement with democracy. The UK actually has a particularly good voluntary community, organisations like mySociety, which basically saw that the government wasn’t doing anything to build digital tools to help citizenry engage with the government, and just went out and built them themselves. That kind of work is really good as far as it goes, that’s definitely led to greater accountability for Members of Parliament… But has it really changed the political culture. I don’t think it has. What we’ve seen in the recent US elections is claims that in fact the Internet has in some ways at least shifted where the power is coming from, because we now have these systems of mass influence through digital channels that enable non-state actors or external state actors to influence people’s opinions and to control public opinion in that way.</p><p>So I think the first thing we need to figure out is do the people, does the democratic polity have the right tools at its disposal to express what it really wants to our political class? Right now I’d say it’s not clear that we do. We have a system based on voting, which is very much a quantitative system. We measure political success by things like opinion polls, by things like general election results. We were hearing earlier today about systems like Futaki or other proposed alternative government systems that focus much more on whether or not a particular policy is effective, so we separate the question out of what do we want from what’s the most effective way of getting it. That might be a way of re-slicing things so that we get a more realistic set of levers that we can pull on to get what we want. But I think one of the things that we haven’t really done yet, and the blockchain and more open systems for moving around money and moving around value might give us this, is much more fine-grained measurements of how people’s lives are actually going.</p><p>Over the last 10 years average wages in the UK have not risen, the average person is poorer than they were 10 years ago. That should be the top item on the political agenda, and nobody ever talks about it, the average person’s life is not getting any better. The government: you had one job, which is make people’s lives better, and you have not managed to do it for 10 years. Where are the alarm bells going off in central government about this fact? They don’t appear to be there.</p><p>So I think what we might see out of new tools for coordination is essentially the ability for the people to issue these kind of conditional ultimatums to government, to say, “You need to reduce these things according to these measures, or we will withdraw our support from you and we will move our support over here.” We might get much more fine-grained decision making tools than we currently have, which is every few years we do this voting thing, and then you get these talking head political experts turn up on the news to try and explain what it was that people actually voted for. The classic line is the people have spoken, but nobody knows what it was that they said. The last UK general election produced no overall majority for any particular political party, it’s really not obvious what the British public was trying to say, other than “We’re not happy and we don’t know what to do about it.”</p><p>So it might be possible that we get, by better modelling conditionality, by better modelling what it is that people really want, and the difference between values that people would like to see implemented and beliefs about the correct form of policy… If we can separate those things out and represent them in a much more fine-grained way, we might get better democratic tools. That’s a reasonably optimistic take on the possibility for innovation, but I’m going to at least try and be optimistic and suggest that there’s a way forward.</p><p><strong>Vinay</strong>: I think this is a context thing. We should have updated the machinery of democracy every time we had an opportunity. It should have been updated a little bit with railway, it should have been updated a little bit with telegraph, it should have been updated a little bit with radio, it should have been updated a little bit with television… There was a possibility of just little updates in the democratic machinery, but now we’ve got some multi-hundred-year backlog of technological change just in the democratic machinery. If you don’t change the democratic intention at all and you just update the machinery, I think we would get vastly better societies. But how do you take the risk, how do you do the experiment? Maybe we should foist it on Scotland.</p><p><strong>Question</strong>: Moving away from voting and back to justice, as you guys started, is there another danger with the Internet generation and as people are interacting at distances well beyond their local communities in ways that previously they would have interacted only with peers in their local communities, that a lot of stuff that used to be enforced in a more social way now needs to be enforced in another way, and our legal institutions are not designed to deal with that? The most obvious crimes nowadays are trolling and piracy, but I think the institutions may not be cheap enough to deal with the scale of those breaches in the social contract. So I think that goes beyond the model that you’re talking about, of automating something which is then enforced by courts; if it’s too expensive to enforce a minor infraction to the courts, but actually the sum total of those minor infractions is major social evil. What do you do with that?</p><p><strong>Rob</strong>: I’ve got one thought on this. I think we are starting to see that certainly social media is a major force for exerting social pressure on individuals. If you say the wrong thing to the wrong person, it’s not just one person who is going to be annoyed at you; it’s going to be the entire world who can witness that conversation and then pile in, and that could be a good thing or a bad thing, depending on which side of the argument you’re on. Obviously you can see sometimes it’s somebody that you think has said something very inappropriate or obnoxious, and they’re getting their rightful condemnation; other times you might see this is a hate mob being set after an individual who has made a perfectly reasonable statement and is being prevented from speaking out and speaking the truth.</p><p><strong>Vinay</strong>: Often both at the same time.</p><p><strong>Rob</strong>: It really does depend on your perspective. Everyone is a liberal when they think their speech is under threat, and everyone is an authoritarian when they think they can crush the other side. It took me a long time to figure that out, but it is unfortunately true.</p><p>So, I’d be vary of making enforcement mechanisms that can be triggered too easily, simply because the first… It’s often justified on the basis that we need to protect the weak from the strong, so we’re going to have an authority and that authority is going to have an enforcement mechanism, but it often tends to be the case that the strong then have better access to the enforcement mechanism than the weak do. Twitter has had this whole problem with trying to create a mechanism whereby they can punish people for making threats or for making inappropriate statements, but the power of that system basically goes to whoever can organise the most people to report someone else’s content that isn’t appropriate. So an organised trolling group can very easily go around and report a bunch of other people’s content, and it often ends up being the case that the people that I think in a rational world would be seen as more sinned against than sinners tend to be the ones who are getting shut down, and you can often have to me very inappropriate things that go completely unpunished.</p><p>So I would say… My answer to that is kind of terrible, which is wait and see. I don’t think we’ve had long enough to internalise the cultural impact of this stuff. There’s a sort of old thing which I just don’t quite remember, but the age of newsgroups and stuff like this in the late 80s, early 90s, there was this idea of acculturation. People would come in, they’d kind of be assholes to each other, and then they kind of get taught that you don’t do that kind of thing around here, it’s not right. Then in basically September, 1993 the Internet underwent this phase shift as AOL subscriptions became a main thing, and instead of it being every year a new bunch of students get access to the Internet at university and they go through this kind of acculturation process, and by the time the next batch of students come in the first batch have kind of been taught how to behave properly, with AOL began this rolling wave of huge numbers of new users coming onto the Internet, and civil discourse on online discussion forums completely broke down and has never been recovered. It’s referred to as the Eternal September: we’re basically in this period of so many people and so little cultural authority that we can’t use social pressure to teach people how to behave properly, and this is why people are now trying to get Facebook to do it or Twitter to do it as a kind of big stick authoritarian power.</p><p><strong>Vinay</strong>: Yeah.</p><p><strong>Rob</strong>: Hopefully, over time the Internet will become a normal part of everyday life, that we develop the social mechanisms that teach people that actually saying that kind of thing is deeply inappropriate and wrong and you shouldn’t do it. But we just haven’t found the right balance between authoritarian power and social pressure that makes that work correctly.</p><p><strong>Vinay</strong>: There are lots of experiments. The Chinese Sesame Credit system begins to look like real social consequences for bad behaviour online; it just happens to be a little closer to the authoritarian end of that landscape. When the Americans get around to doing it, they’ll do it with AI. You’ll have some really effective Nazi detection algorithm, and then you’ll just basically censor people with AIs, but then the question is always once you’ve got an incredibly cheap robot watchman, the tendency will be to extend the reach more and more and more. Very, very tricky territory, very, very tricky. Automated law enforcement is going to be the big danger in the 21st century.</p><p><strong>Question</strong>: Thank you so much for your really interesting and clear discussion of the tension between new technologies and existing governance structures, particularly framed by geography. I would like to hear your thoughts on the tension between the upcoming EU GDPR framework, and the public blockchain.</p><p><strong>Vinay</strong>: Yeah, it’s going to be a car crash. I mean, it’s just what do you do? It’s just two completely different paradigms of understanding of what computers are or how they work. The blockchain does have this property that if you post somebody’s personal information there it’s there for keeps, and GDPR does make that very, very illegal.</p><p><strong>Rob</strong>: We’ve had that kind of problem before, specifically in relation to newspapers. If a newspaper publishes a story about you that turns out to be incorrect, in certain jurisdictions you have the ability to sue them, but the normal, first option is to ask for a correction to appear in a newspaper. Generally speaking, you pick up any newspaper on any given day, and there will be some small section somewhere marked “corrections” and it will say that in this story, published on this date, where we said that these things happened, they in fact did not happen.</p><p><strong>Vinay</strong>: “We did not mean to imply that this person ate their own dog.”</p><p><strong>Rob</strong>: Yes. That’s not a perfect solution, but the idea that you publish something that’s incorrect and then publish a correction after the fact is one way of looking at things, and this is kind of similar to how for instance your bank works, if your bank charges you for something because they say you went overdrawn and in fact you didn’t… They charge you a £10 fee, you call up the bank, they admit the mistake and they credit you with £10 back again to make it okay. They never go back in time and remove the wrong transaction; they make a compensating transaction after the fact to make things okay again. The newspaper correction is a similar thing: they do something wrong, and then they make a compensating action to correct the thing that they did wrong.</p><p>So I think there’s a kind of sliding scale of things, where, in my view, an incorrect financial transaction, as long as it’s corrected after the fact, expunged from my credit record or whatever it might be is basically fine. If my name gets published on the sex offenders register, someone publishing another record later saying, “Oh no, it was a different guy with a similar name,” I would be less inclined to believe that that’s an acceptable fix for that problem, because someone is always going to be able to find that, and there’s always going to be that question of “He was on there, then he got removed and we’re not really sure why.”</p><p>GDPR is at one end of the spectrum on this. I personally find it really hard to imagine how we’re going to enforce this, and I think it’s going to be really, really interesting to see how it works. It’s possible that we get somewhere with different kinds of encryption technology that enable us to expunge records from blockchains once they’ve been put on there… As a sort of purist software architect, that kind of horrifies me, the idea of going back and rewriting history, it breaks the integrity of the system, but making those kinds of compromises might be necessary. I don’t buy the argument which says it simply can’t be done. It is an engineering job and someone will figure out how to do it. It is a classic example of if you really wanted to rigorously enforce that, rigorously enforce it, you would need to be inspecting data as it leaves the EU to see if it contains anybody’s personal information, you’d need to have a digital border and you’d need to be able to inspect all the traffic that’s going over. That’s clearly incompatible with the way that we actually do things, it’s probably incompatible with privacy…</p><p><strong>Vinay</strong>: And this is going to keep happening, this kind of head-on crash between perfectly sensible-looking law and a new technology is going to be more and more and more how government works. Over and over again you’re going to see new technologies, they won’t work properly with the old law, you’ll make new law to regulate them, and the law will be incoherent… We’re going through a very, very hard time for lawmakers, because they’re just constantly trying to manage a situation that’s changing faster than they can adapt.</p><p><strong>Host</strong>: On that note, I think we’re all very grateful to have Vinay and Rob close the day today with such a thought-provoking speech, so if we could just thank them again. [applause]</p><p>_______________________________</p><p>Learn more about our project Mattereum<strong> </strong><a href="https://mattereum.com/"><strong>https://mattereum.com/</strong></a></p><p>Join the conversation in our<strong> </strong><a href="https://t.me/joinchat/GQBQcAulO-RZRl-3SMDKyQ"><strong>telegram chat</strong></a><strong>.</strong></p><p>______</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=815cfbd06eca" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/humanizing-the-singularity/global-governance-in-the-era-of-blockchain-815cfbd06eca">Global governance in the era of blockchain.</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/humanizing-the-singularity">Mattereum - Humanizing the Singularity</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Mattereum partners with Sweetbridge to deploy smart contracts for global supply chains]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/humanizing-the-singularity/mattereum-partners-with-sweetbridge-to-deploy-smart-contracts-for-global-supply-chains-9f8659efa862?source=rss-69bb99cf537a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9f8659efa862</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[blockchain]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cryptocurrency]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mattereum]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ethereum]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[supply-chain]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Rob Knight]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 26 Jan 2018 15:26:20 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-05-11T17:19:52.675Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*-KOFXmqOUAc1NfawSB7pGg.jpeg" /></figure><p><a href="https://sweetbridge.com/"><strong>Sweetbridge</strong></a><strong> </strong>is<strong> </strong>the global blockchain alliance developing protocols to enable frictionless commerce and interest-free financing for individuals, businesses, and enterprises. Mattereum’s lawyers and developers will work with Sweetbridge Alliance members to create smart contracts for specific applications and use cases, ranging from global trade in real-world goods to token sales on the Sweetbridge <a href="https://sweetbridge.com/crowdsale">crowdsale platform</a>.</p><p><a href="https://mattereum.com/"><strong>Mattereum</strong></a> will create and manage the legal and technical systems required to implement the control and transfer of rights in material and intellectual property, as well as digital assets. Non-performance issues will either automatically be resolved by smart contracts or adjudicated by an international commercial arbitration court. Mattereum will also undertake the legal and technical development work to ensure that legal texts and their corresponding digital equivalents represented in Sweetbridge ecosystems are compliant with regulations in relevant jurisdictions.</p><p>Mattereum’s panel of technically competent, independent arbitrators are able to make legally binding rulings that are enforceable in more than 150 countries.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*qmCj4q88nfyUXcEkMrp_og.jpeg" /></figure><blockquote><strong>Mattereum CEO Vinay Gupta: </strong>“For the blockchain to achieve global adoption in the industrial and commercial world, it is really important that standards for blockchain smart contract enforcement are as high or higher than that for ordinary contracts. That does not just mean that the technical part, the blockchain part, works perfectly. We also need the unpredictability of the real world, the world of ships and trains, to be managed flawlessly. By helping Sweetbridge achieve its aims of creating a more efficient, decentralized form of commerce supported by a widely compliant legal infrastructure, we will also be realizing our own ambitions to decentralize commercial law by automating legal contract execution.”</blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*xQBqEciGymwKvpHw_MUDfA.jpeg" /></figure><blockquote><strong>Sweetbridge CEO and Chairman Scott Nelson:</strong> “Sweetbridge is proud to partner with Mattereum to ensure that the framework behind its innovative platform is legally enforceable in multiple jurisdictions. Mattereum’s innovative solution for ensuring regulatory compliance will prove critical as we support global companies conducting token crowdsales on our platform. We are delighted to join forces with Mattereum to further the development of our crowdsale platform and ensure its long-term sustainability and success.”</blockquote><p>You can learn more about the subject in the talk of Mattereum’s team with Sweetbridge’s CEO Scott Nelson and Coinfund’s Aleksandr Bulkin <em>on</em> <em>the future of contracts, law &amp; commerce</em>:</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FcmWcWLKIHpY%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DcmWcWLKIHpY&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FcmWcWLKIHpY%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/baf7f593357cf58dc192f83514f68e68/href">https://medium.com/media/baf7f593357cf58dc192f83514f68e68/href</a></iframe><p>Learn more about <strong>Mattereum</strong>: <a href="https://mattereum.com/">on the website</a> / in on our first briefing <a href="https://medium.com/humanizing-the-singularity/the-first-mattereum-briefing-11a67c75d840">article</a> / join our <a href="https://t.me/joinchat/GQBQcAulO-RZRl-3SMDKyQ">Telegram chat</a>.</p><p>Lear more about <strong>Sweetbridge</strong>: <a href="https://sweetbridge.com/">https://sweetbridge.com/</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9f8659efa862" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/humanizing-the-singularity/mattereum-partners-with-sweetbridge-to-deploy-smart-contracts-for-global-supply-chains-9f8659efa862">Mattereum partners with Sweetbridge to deploy smart contracts for global supply chains</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/humanizing-the-singularity">Mattereum - Humanizing the Singularity</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Mattereum and business on the blockchain — talk at “Beyond the Blockchain”]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/humanizing-the-singularity/mattereum-and-business-on-the-blockchain-talk-at-beyond-the-blockchain-cb1780ce1694?source=rss-69bb99cf537a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/cb1780ce1694</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[blockchain]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[bitcoin]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ethereum]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mattereum]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[internet-of-agreements]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Rob Knight]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 04 Jan 2018 19:36:35 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-01-04T19:36:35.302Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*m7BvU2uka0RkKJ37Oqy8jw.jpeg" /></figure><p>At the <a href="http://brightondigitalfestival.co.uk/">Brighton Digital Festival</a> in 2017, I gave a talk on the future of the blockchain. I talked about:</p><ul><li>Using blockchains to manage contractual rights</li><li>Tokenisation of assets</li><li>Legal enforceability of smart contracts</li><li>Resolving disputes that arise from smart contracts</li></ul><p>On a similar theme to <a href="https://medium.com/humanizing-the-singularity/2018-year-in-preview-the-future-of-cryptocurrency-b99110480ff0">Vinay’s recent post</a>, I asked what it would take for the blockchain to become the backbone for our mortgages, our loans and our insurance, how we would be able to buy a house on the blockchain, how we would crowdfund creative works and reward the backers. These are the questions we’ve spent our time at <a href="https://www.mattereum.com/">Mattereum</a> trying to solve, and this talk explains some of that thinking.</p><p>Below is the video, transcript, and slides from the talk.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FfoIo7wbiWsA%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DfoIo7wbiWsA&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FfoIo7wbiWsA%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/3d51e8932db4363bd1023d515031b7f2/href">https://medium.com/media/3d51e8932db4363bd1023d515031b7f2/href</a></iframe><p><strong>Transcript</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/960/1*t1HERUHfl4PJ3hoKDjZ0gw.png" /></figure><p>One of the things that I want to talk about is what blockchains are for. Because we kind of have a good idea now of technologies like the Web, we kind of know what you can do with the Web, what’s it good for, what’s it not so good for — we can do social networking, we can do shopping sites, we can do marketplaces — we can do a whole bunch of things on the Web that we kind of had to figure out were the best uses of that technology. And for blockchains right now we’ve got Bitcoin and Bitcoin works, and everybody is happy that on a technical level Bitcoin works and from an adoption point of view plenty of people are using it, Ethereum is gaining adoption as well, but the kind of big picture sense of ”What is this thing actually really for?” is the thing that I want to talk about.</p><p>The phrase that we use for this is the Internet of Agreements, and this is a shameless rip-off of the Internet of Things, but it’s basically intended to convey the idea that what a blockchain gives you is the ability to reach agreement with other people around the world, you come to a consensus about a set of facts, and that’s what’s unique and interesting about the blockchain, as distinct from say the Web.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/960/1*YZ3D3b2lTQmuK-FEze43Sw.png" /></figure><p>A quick summary, and I’m not going to get into technical detail on any of this: for people who are wanting to learn about the blockchain and maybe haven’t encountered it before, a blockchain is a globally-distributed database, which means that there are many different copies of the blockchain — this applies to Bitcoin, it applies to Ethereum, it applies to all of the other blockchains — that has immutable history, which means that once something happens, once a record goes onto the blockchain, it stays there. We don’t change the blockchain by taking something out and replacing it with something else, like we do in some traditional databases; we change the blockchain by adding something new, to say, “This thing that used to be five is now 12, this thing that used to be my old address is now my new address,” and the history of the fact that my address used to be whatever it used to be, or that the number that is now 12 used to be five, stays there. So we’ve got auditability, we can see the complete history of everything that has happened since the blockchain began.</p><p>It has digital signatures built in, and this is the key thing that enables Bitcoin to work for instance, that if I want to transfer my Bitcoin to you, I need to sign that using my digital signature that only I have. This is by no means a full identity system, but it gives you a basic sense that when we add things to the blockchain, when we create transactions, we’re doing that as some body, we’re doing that as a thing that has a signature. So every record, every update that goes onto the blockchain goes on with a signature there, to identify that we can tell that five different updates were made by the same person, or at least made by someone with access to the same key.</p><p>The blockchain gives us a fair solution to consensus problems. If we want to get a bunch of people around the world to agree on what order something happened in, who was first to do something… When all of those computers are distributed around the world and there’s no single computer that’s in control of the network, that’s actually kind of hard to do. I don’t know how many of you are familiar with high-frequency trading: this is the situation where close to the stock exchanges in New York and in London people will buy up buildings and buy up office space right next to where the exchange is so that they can run a cable directly to the exchange so that they can get their information in quickest. This is because this is a centralised system, there is a physical centre, you can point to it and say, “This is where the stock exchange is,” and people who can get their computers closest to the stock exchange can get their data in and out faster than everybody else can, and this gives them an advantage.</p><p>The blockchain solves this problem by not having a centre at all, there is no centre. Generally speaking, the way that blockchains decide the order that things happened in or who gets to know what happened first is that for every given block of transactions — and Bitcoin and Ethereum do blocks over different times; Bitcoin does one block every 10 minutes, Ethereum does one every few seconds — for every given block, a different computer on the network will be randomly selected to be the one that decides the order of the transactions in that block. If you’ve heard of mining, this is basically the process of doing a whole bunch of computations to see who generates the magic number first; whoever generates the magic number first, they get to decide the order of the things in the block, and as a result there’s no advantage to being geographically located in any particular place. So it gives that global network the property of being fair in terms of coming to a consensus about what the facts are.</p><p>It also has some notion of programmability. Bitcoin has fairly limited programmability, Ethereum takes this further with smart contracts, and there are other platforms that come along with further smart contract technology. What that means is not only can we write new data to the blockchain but we can also upload our own small programs to the blockchain, which then, when they receive some data, they will do some computation that we told them to do, and then they will produce a result which will write some new data to the blockchain.</p><p>This package of things that are bundled together give you a bunch of things that you can’t do with the Web, you can’t do with traditional databases and you can’t do really any other way. You’ve got full history for auditability, digital signatures so that we can tell that the updates are being made by the same people, we’ve got a consensus solution, which means that the whole system can operate without needing to have a physical centre, and then we have the ability for people to create their own programs that then live on the blockchain and respond to other people’s transactions.</p><p>You could operate the whole system yourself by having people email transactions to you that are digitally signed. The digital signature just says, “I am authorised to make a transaction with respect to this Bitcoin account or this Ethereum account,” so it’s just there to say, “On a previous transaction, your account was created when someone sent you some Bitcoin, and that account is linked to your digital signature,” so that the network then knows when another transaction from that digital signature is received that wants to transfer that Bitcoin to someone else, that it definitely came from the right person.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/960/1*UHdqtjZy60Yx1g-xhkMTpg.png" /></figure><p>To try and put this in a little bit of context, I’d like to talk about the three great ages of the Internet. You start sort of 1973–74, with the first thing that could reasonably be called an Internet, which is basically a bunch of universities in the US connecting their computers up to each other, and I think it starts out with five or six universities. This was the Internet of Ideas and this runs for about 20 years, and it’s really just about information sharing: it’s scientists, it’s academics, it’s researchers, it’s some military people, and they’re keen to be able to share information with each other. But they don’t want to do business, they don’t want to trade, they don’t want to advertise anything, there’s no commercial usage; it’s just purely a scientific and academic process. They build the things that people with those kinds of needs will want: so they build email and they build FTP so they can send files around, they build newsgroups so that people can talk to each other, and pretty much the last thing they do, the final act of scientists for the Internet, is they give us the World Wide Web. In 1991, at the CERN Research Institute, Tim Berners-Lee invents HTTP, and we get the Web.</p><p>Pretty quickly the Web becomes so popular that a whole bunch of other people decide that the Internet is pretty cool and they’d like to start using it, and at this point the scientists lose control of the Internet. And when the normal people show up, normal people are doing normal people things, like shopping. So the next stage of technology transformation on the Web, which runs from the mid-90s up until basically now, is all about figuring out how we can do shopping on the Internet: we do Secure Sockets Layer, HTTPS, the PCI standards for credit card security, and it’s really all about how can we let people type in their credit card number into a webpage so that they can buy something.</p><p>We figured that out by the mid-90s, and then we proceed to basically take everything that we used to do by going into physical stores or by using catalogues and phoning people up, and we put that all on the Internet. So you get Amazon, where l pay you and you send me something, we get eBay, where I pay you and then you pay someone else and then they send me something, or Netflix, where I pay you every month and you continue to give me access to something, or you get Google and Facebook, which is really just advertising to people who want to do the first three things. That’s pretty much all business anybody has done on the Internet in the last 20 years, and this gives us three of the world’s five largest companies, by market cap it’s absolutely huge, but it’s basically the credit cards.</p><p>This works because it is a good fit for the Web. The Web is a request-response protocol, HTTP is a request-response protocol: I send a request, I type in a URL, I send in a request to a server, and it gives me back a page, and maybe I send some data along with the request as well, like if I’m doing a Google search. This is a really good fit for payment, because payment is I send you some payment details and you send me a receipt back to say that you’ve received my payment, so it all works really, really neatly. The thing that we get from blockchains is the ability to do a whole bunch of different kind of economic activity that the Web isn’t very good at. One of my old possessions is a book about the Web from 2001 or so, and it tells you about all of these amazing websites that there are and all of this kind of stuff, and you go through and you type in the URLs and none of them work. And that wasn’t that long ago; I remember that pretty well, and for a bunch of other people 15 years is not that long of a time.</p><p>With blockchains, they kind of don’t have that property: once something has been put on a blockchain, it stays there; we talked before about the immutable history of the blockchain. Let’s say you were doing something like a loan, where you expect that loan to be paid back over five years. You wouldn’t want to think that the URL for your loan has disappeared and then you don’t know where to send your payments anymore, or if you’ve lent the money to someone else and they don’t need to pay you anymore because the URL is not working. With the blockchain, we can put a record on there saying, “I have borrowed £10,000 from you and I promised to repay you in this number of instalments over this period of time, and we have a smart contract where I send the money every month, and if I fail to send the money, the smart contract will add penalties on,” and all of this kind of stuff. This is a really neat fit for how blockchains work, and it’s a terrible fit for how the Web works.</p><p>What we can do with the blockchain that we couldn’t do before is model and structure long-running agreements that run for potentially an unbounded length of time, because nothing ever goes missing from the blockchain once it’s there, or multiparty agreements. Everyone has got their digital signatures, so we can deal quite neatly with the idea that there are multiple people who are all signing things and getting involved in those smart contracts. And they can also be conditional, because the smart contracts contain code, so they can have if statements, they can have data, they can have all kinds of things that they might depend upon when they’re deciding whether or not to add a penalty onto my failure to make a loan repayment for instance.</p><p>The kind of possibilities that we get now is first-class digital representations of agreements between multiple parties, and this is where you get the idea of decentralised autonomous organisations coming from, where you get people building new financial instruments on blockchains, and ultimately where we might get people structuring work contracts, music contracts, energy contracts, supply chains, all of these different things, because we now have a technology that is shaped… In the same way that the Web is shaped the same way that a payment is shaped, the blockchain is kind of shaped the same way a contractual agreement is shaped.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/960/1*6aYjleMnr-VRxMaBXX-FHQ.png" /></figure><p>We’ve got a few trade-offs when we introduce this kind of new capability to the blockchain. Bitcoin for instance works really, really well because it keeps everything very simple. Bitcoin, at its heart, is just a ledger of how many Bitcoins there are and who owns them, and then it has some really, really simple rules for moving those bitcoins around so that I can’t send the same Bitcoin to two different people, and that’s pretty much it. And by keeping it really, really simple, Bitcoin has been extremely reliable, no one has ever hacked Bitcoin. People have hacked Bitcoin exchanges, people have hacked Bitcoin wallets, but no one has ever actually hacked the core Bitcoin protocol, because it’s fundamentally well-engineered and does one pretty simple job. But if you think of what it represents, if you just imagine this giant ledger that sits on the Internet, it really only has one kind of thing in it, which is Bitcoins.</p><p>What Ethereum allows us to do is put other kinds of data on the blockchain, so we can invent new kinds of things that will be stored on the blockchain and we can write new kinds of rules about how we move them around. So rather than relying on the Bitcoin core protocol, we can write our own rules in smart contracts, which says that I can invent a new kind of digital currency and I can invent a new kind of token, but I can’t send it to anybody if they already have more money than I do, or I can only send things on a Tuesday… Arbitrary rules; we can write any kind of rules that we want.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/960/1*4e8JmRsAt-4W7HK82mrEjA.png" /></figure><p>But with great power comes great responsibility, and it turns out that smart contracts are pretty hard to write; as we get this new sort of flexibility, we get the ability to screw up in some pretty big ways, and plenty of people have done that. When you hear about people being hacked on Ethereum, it generally is because somebody wrote a smart contract that had a bug, a bunch of other people sent a bunch of money to that smart contract, it’s sitting there with X million dollars held in a vault under the management of the smart contract, and then someone else comes along, sends the smart contract a transaction that triggers a bug, and pretty quickly the money goes missing. So the kind of engineering that you need to do for smart contracts is closer to programming a nuclear power plant than it is to programming a website: it’s dangerous, and if you get it wrong you will lose money. Because, fundamentally, smart contracts are hard.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/960/1*i3ELePFgFkfBZ-ktc8pCiA.png" /></figure><p>Most software has bugs; websites have bugs, mobile phone apps have bugs. If you look on any given day at the App Store or the Google Play Store or whatever it is you have, you’ll see 25 updates, and if you look into the description of what the updates are for, they say “bugfixes”; often they don’t say what the bugs are, they’ll just say “bugfixes”. What that means is not really so much that someone screwed up… I’ve worked in software all my career, and there have been plenty of times where my software doesn’t work, but normally, it doesn’t work because someone runs it on a computer that I couldn’t have anticipated them running it on: they’ll run it on some version of a web browser that I didn’t test, or they’ll be on some version of an operating system that I didn’t test, with a screen resolution and a graphics card and a network driver… maybe they’ll be on a really bad network connection, maybe they’ll be running some kind of weird ad blocker… There is all kinds of different things that could cause that to go wrong that are fundamentally beyond my control as a developer.</p><p>So as a result, nobody cares. We say move fast and break things, which is Facebook’s famous phrase. What you’re really measuring is not how many bugs did we have but how long did it take us to fix the bug after we found out about it, and then we just push out hundreds of new features, hundreds of new bugs and hundreds of new bugfixes every week, and this is normal, everybody thinks that this is completely okay.</p><p>But if you did that with smart contracts, you’d be totally screwed. Because if you introduce that quantity of bugs into smart contracts, people will be stealing money right off the fact that you’ve got those bugs there; a single piece of code, a single function could be responsible for managing tens of millions of pounds’ worth of actual value held in cryptocurrencies. Fortunately, if we go back to our earlier consideration of what a blockchain is — it’s a globally-distributed database running across thousands of computers — when we execute a smart contract, we don’t just execute it once on a randomly-selected computer; we execute it on all of the computers that are taking part in the mining, and this means that we don’t get caught out by the fact that some random person somewhere is running some completely weird hardware.</p><p>If they get a result that doesn’t agree with the general consensus across the network, their version is thrown away. So we get an agreement across the network that this computation had these inputs and it produced this output, and everybody agrees that that is the canonical output for that function, and it can only look at the previous state of the blockchain and the stuff that is currently coming in in this transaction in order to determine what to do. It can’t go off over the network and read new information, it can’t get input from the keyboard, it can’t load files from the disc, it can’t generate random numbers, it can’t do any of these things; it has to be deterministic, it has to be based just on the previous state of the blockchain and the current transaction.</p><p>That means if a smart contract fails, we know that there’s definitely a bug in the smart contract, and I kind of have a suspicion that once the culture catches up with this, once the engineering culture catches up with this, we’re going to start to see a very different attitude towards smart contract programming to what we see with web development. We might actually start to see professional liability for programmers for instance, you might be sued if your smart contract goes wrong and loses people’s money, because we know it was definitely your bug and we know exactly how much money was lost as a result. So perhaps professional indemnity insurance for programmers, all kinds of really weird and bizarre things could actually come back into fashion that we thought we’d kind of avoided doing 50 years ago; actually, on blockchains that kind of stuff does actually makes sense.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/960/1*dYuSntvj6FHb-1rH2Oag1w.png" /></figure><p>I want to look at one, slightly more futuristic application of blockchain. If we think ahead a few years as to how blockchains might start to invade the real world, right now we’ve got a bunch of stuff going on out there in the virtual space — lots of people making money, losing money, hacking people and so on and so forth for Bitcoin and Ether and tokens — but if you switched it all off, would anybody really notice outside of the blockchain community? Probably not. It hasn’t become fundamental global infrastructure, there are a few people who depend on it, but most of the people in this room, aside from the fact that we might lose some money, wouldn’t really care; whereas if you switched the Web off, people would notice pretty damn quickly.</p><p>So if blockchains are going to become important, then they are going to have to become the backbone for our mortgages, our loans and our insurance. You’re going to have to be able to buy a house on the blockchain, you’re going to have to be able to buy a pair of shoes on the blockchain, you’re going to have to be able to make an agreement that the proceeds of sale of your new album are going to be paid out to these following people who backed you on a crowdfunding platform, you’re going to need to be able to credibly commit to doing all kinds of stuff in the real world, so that instead of having a big ledger of all the Bitcoins or a big ledger of all of the weird Ethereum tokens, we have a big ledger of all the physical stuff: the buildings, the cars, the intellectual property products, all of these kinds of things. So what we need is to think in terms of contracts, we think in terms of what we’re putting on the blockchain is actually statements, commitments between multiple parties to do things with each other at some point in the future. The smart contract can handle a whole bunch of the shuffling the money around, it can handle shuffling the data around, and this, as we’ve discussed, requires a very high standard of engineering.</p><p>The final piece of the picture, and the final piece that is going to be the hardest to put into place, is actually getting this stuff accepted in a court of law. If I send you some Bitcoin and you told me you were going to send me a pair of shoes, and you don’t send me the pair of shoes, what do I do? If I turn up in court and say, “This guy said he was going to send me some shoes and I sent him some Bitcoin,” the judge is probably going to be like, “Bit-what?” and I’m going to have to call an expert witness who is going to have to get up and do a version of the talk that I’ve just done, and that person is going to charge £3,000/hour and it’s going to be terrible — no one is going to want to do that kind of thing. And it gets even worse if the person who promised they were going to send me some shoes lives in another country on the other side of the world.</p><p>We think that we have found a solution for this, and by “we” I mean <a href="https://www.mattereum.com/">Mattereum</a>, which is the company that I’m a co-founder of, and our solution to this is to use the existing legal system’s mechanisms for dispute resolution in the form of arbitration. What we’d do is we take smart contracts and legal contracts and combine them together, so the performance details, the kind of “Did you send the payment? Did you send the payment when you were supposed to? What are the charges that have been paid?” all of that kind of stuff gets fully modelled inside the smart contract, but the kind of legally enforceable promise that you’re actually going to do something in the real world gets modelled in a legal contract. We sign an agreement with each other about what it is that we’re going to do, and if I don’t do my part of the deal, you can take me to court, or, rather, you can take me to arbitration.</p><p>And it turns out that arbitration is this totally bizarre thing that a whole bunch of commercial law runs on that actually very few people have heard of. Under the terms of the 1958 New York Convention on Foreign Arbitral Awards, if two people sign a contract and they say, “In the event of a dispute regarding this contract, this dispute will be handled by arbitration at the following arbitration association,” then they can’t go to court to handle this; they have to go to arbitration, and they have to accept the decision of the arbitrator, and this applies in 150–160 jurisdictions around the world. So you can freely enter into agreements with people from Brazil or America or France or Vietnam, and in the event that either of you disagree, you can have an arbitrator who actually understands the technology, who understands how the whole thing works, who has access to the blockchain, who has access to the smart contracts, who could see everything, and this person can make the decision for you, as long as you agreed in the contract that this is what is going to happen.</p><p>This turns out to be how we handle maritime disputes already. You’re shipping rice from Vietnam to Brazil, the ship sinks off the coast of Somalia, but the insurance was in Switzerland, the ship was registered in Greece, but the ship was actually owned in England, and the parties are actually based in Russia and Argentina… Rather than trying to cash that out in the national court systems of all of those countries involved, they all agree to use binding arbitration, typically in London, because London just has a history of doing all of this kind of stuff for maritime, and that’s a way of getting a consistent result that everybody understands ahead of time is going to be the result. Everybody understands English law, they understand how the London arbitration system works, and this smooths out a whole bunch of problems that would occur in maritime disputes.</p><p>So in the same sense that things being shipped over the sea kind of have that property, deals being done over the Internet have the same property, that people making the deals could be based in all kinds of different places, if it’s a multiparty agreement, there could be all kinds of different jurisdictions involved… So what we have built is a system to allow people to make those agreements that have binding arbitration built in, we have a group of arbitrators based in London who are familiar with the technology and who are able to hear the cases, and we actually have legally enforceable blockchain contracts running now on Ethereum. This is our contribution, this is what we think is going to be necessary to enable people to build real-world systems that run on the blockchain, we think that this is the right way to handle it and a way of sidestepping a whole bunch of legal issues, and kind of jump 10 years forward in terms of how long it would take for the courts to figure out how the blockchain should be handled. We’ve started to see a whole bunch of other companies come forward now who want to build supply chain contracts, energy contracts, music contracts, all kinds of different things, where they can roll out much faster, because they know that they have got this consistent, legal kind of framework that they can build on top of.</p><p>To explain the British angle on this, it just so happens that this is running on English law and the arbitration is based in the UK. But there’s an interesting facet of the Internet of Agreements on blockchains that we think is different from the last 20 years of the Web and mobile, where the Web and mobile has been kind of dominated by companies from the US, because the US is a 300 million people single jurisdiction with a single legal system. People build things in California, and if it works in California, they can roll it out to those other 300 million people pretty much immediately, they don’t have any jurisdictional issues or anything like that.</p><p>But in this country, we have a bunch of expertise about how to do legal agreements, we have a bunch of expertise about how to do finance, we have a bunch of expertise about how to do trade, and if we said that the single legal system that this new Internet is going to run on is one that we’re super familiar with, and if you can build a business that works in Brighton or in London or in Manchester or in Newcastle or in Edinburgh or in Cardiff or wherever, and it will run on the same legal principles that the rest of the world is able to run on, then you can roll out business much faster than you used to. That I think is the potential for British companies, for UK companies, to be able to make something work at home and then immediately have it work around the rest of the world, in a way that the American companies have been getting an advantage from for the last 20 years, because their home jurisdiction is very, very large. By creating a kind of virtual jurisdiction of the Internet, we give that advantage to basically everyone in the world. In the same way that the blockchain decentralises business and says, “There is no one central place where you need to be in that central place to get the best access,” this system says, “There is no central place, you’re not any better off being in Silicon Valley than you would be anywhere else,” it’s an open playing field and anyone can play.</p><p>That basically is my vision of what the blockchain is, what it’s for, where it’s going to go, some of the engineering that we need to do to get there, a lot of it is actually more legal engineering than it is technical, and I would be more than happy to talk to anybody who would like to know more about those kinds of things.</p><p>______</p><p><strong>You can learn more about Mattereum </strong><a href="https://medium.com/humanizing-the-singularity/the-first-mattereum-briefing-11a67c75d840"><strong>in this post</strong></a><strong> and on </strong><a href="https://mattereum.com/"><strong>https://mattereum.com/</strong></a></p><p><strong>Join the conversation in our </strong><a href="https://t.me/joinchat/GQBQcAulO-RZRl-3SMDKyQ"><strong>telegram chat</strong></a><strong>.</strong></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=cb1780ce1694" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/humanizing-the-singularity/mattereum-and-business-on-the-blockchain-talk-at-beyond-the-blockchain-cb1780ce1694">Mattereum and business on the blockchain — talk at “Beyond the Blockchain”</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/humanizing-the-singularity">Mattereum - Humanizing the Singularity</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Why the biggest winners of the blockchain might be economists]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/humanizing-the-singularity/why-the-biggest-winners-of-the-blockchain-might-be-economists-60b9c67f47b4?source=rss-69bb99cf537a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/60b9c67f47b4</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[blockchain]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ethereum]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mattereum]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[bitcoin]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[economics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Rob Knight]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 02 Jan 2018 16:04:22 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-01-02T16:04:22.933Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Why economists might be the biggest winners of the blockchain revolution</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*YsMAYA0sBwKVT1Hnlk8E4w.png" /></figure><p><strong><em>Bubbles, regulatory shocks, incomplete contracts, game theory and mechanism design — in many ways the blockchain is better understood as an economic system than a software system.</em></strong></p><p>I’ve been in the software industry for most of two decades now, but it wasn’t always clear that this is where I would end up. Back when I was a student, my other interest was economics. I found the subject fascinating, and still spend a good portion of my time reading about it, aided by the fact that economists <a href="http://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2016/07/how-giles-wilkes-learned-to-love-the-economics-blogosphere.html">embraced blogs and online communication</a>, making it easy for laypeople to keep in touch with the debates of the day. I went into software and never looked back, but the interest in economics has remained.</p><p>Over time, I became more interested in it as a human discipline rather than a collection of problem-solving techniques or mathematical models. Economics is a high-stakes game — human livelihoods are greatly affected by it — and is also extremely contentious, politically sensitive, and divided between many competing schools of thought. Working out who these people are, why they think the way they do, and what the implications of their agendas are, became more interesting to me than how to model the effects of interest rates or optimal taxation. There would be occasional overlaps between this interest and my own work, but for the most part it remained an intellectual pursuit for its own sake.</p><p>The blockchain, and crypto-currency, finally allows me to indulge my two main interests at the same time. In many cases, what people mean by “the blockchain” is just “economics, on computers” (seriously, try it — any time someone says that the blockchain will solve a problem, substitute in “economics, on computers” for “the blockchain” and the statement generally makes way more sense). As someone with a combined interest in economics and computer science, this looks like fun.</p><p>If I had taken the other path, and been an economist instead of a software engineer, would I still find the blockchain to be relevant? I suspect that I would; in fact, I suspect that the blockchain might be one of the biggest things to hit economics in decades.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*iKut3zXHfEk3VcdCWQRW7g.jpeg" /><figcaption>Frank Gehry’s Guggenheim Museum in Bilbao</figcaption></figure><p>When people think of digitisation of a particular field or industry, they tend to think of automation — “<a href="http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-us-canada-42170100">robots taking the jobs</a>”. But this is somewhat ahistorical. Digitisation of architecture in the form of Computer-Aided Design has not led to the robotisation of architecture, but to the creation of <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parametricism">new concepts</a> and <a href="https://www.technologyreview.com/s/517596/new-forms-that-function-better/">better tools</a> that enable new kinds of buildings. The architect is set free to consider new problems by the elimination of old ones. The same is true for graphic design, accountancy, aeronautics, biology and many other fields.</p><p>Digitisation gives us better information, and more of it, for a lower cost. It automates processes that would otherwise have been laborious and slow. One might think that this would reduce society’s expenditure on the activity in question — we can get the same amount of stuff for less money! — but in practice this tends not to be so. Make graphic design cheaper and we make graphic design more affordable to more consumers, with the result that many more instances of elaborate graphic design are created than before. Of course, none of this is news to economists — it’s known as the <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jevons_paradox">Jevons Paradox</a>.</p><p>So does the blockchain do something like this for economics? There are a few ways in which this might be the case.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*6KtWAuVzzwULcra-Nx_bYA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Vlad Zamfir speaking at Devcon One</figcaption></figure><p>Firstly, the blockchain has helped to establish a new discipline known as “crypto-economics”. Although the terminology is not entirely settled, I regard crypto-economics as being the use of economic incentives and models in the service of building secure distributed systems (my definition is basically taken from <a href="https://softwareengineeringdaily.com/2017/10/28/cryptoeconomics-with-vlad-zamfir/">Vlad Zamfir’s</a>). Bitcoin is the paradigmatic example: it’s the payment of freshly-mined Bitcoin that incentivises the miners to participate and secure the network during its early growth phase. Proof-of-stake designs also employs economics in the same way — as an essential building block of the system.</p><p>Economists have plenty of tools for designing such systems — mechanism design, game theory, theories of asymmetric information, and models for economic constructs like auctions. The central insight of crypto-economics is that the design of a distributed computer system, with no central source of truth, is similar to the design of an economy with no central planner. As such, many of the tools of economics can now be applied to structuring collaborative distributed computer systems, not just people and firms. Thus, crypto-economics is about using economics to build and scale computer systems.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*EyAVdZZObt36pZl2dUxe4g.png" /><figcaption>Cryptokitties!</figcaption></figure><p>Secondly, there’s the “economics, on computers” (EOC, for brevity) work, which I would distinguish from crypto-economics on the basis that this activity occurs <em>on top of</em> the blockchain rather than as part of its foundational structure. For instance, there are economies running on top of Bitcoin, Ethereum, and other blockchains, that don’t have anything much to do with crypto-economics per se — the critical distinction is that they’d work pretty much the same way on top of a centralised system. We can apply economic reasoning to, say, <a href="https://cryptocurrencyhub.io/the-cryptokitties-economy-83c18ca07cd8">Cryptokitties</a>, without needing to apply crypto-economics just because we’re using a blockchain.</p><p>EOC is the study and design of economic interactions that occur entirely over computer systems. What this gives us is a real-time, high-fidelity set of accounts for entire digital economies. A complete transaction history of the Bitcoin blockchain exists, as does one for Ethereum and each of the other blockchains. As a tool for modelling and analysis, there has never been anything quite like it. And, as the blockchain slowly integrates with the real world, it becomes ever more useful as a tool for validating economic theories.</p><p>Phenomena that are hard to study in the offline world — regulatory shocks, supply/demand shifts, bubbles, responses to technological change and innovation — become much easier to measure in the blockchain economy. As tokens proliferate, we can measure their relative performance, their patterns of acquisition and use, how their structure and key economic drivers play out in the long-term. There has never been a better data set for many of these things.</p><p>Finally there is the political economy of the blockchain. Bitcoin is partly an ideological construct, encoding a set of beliefs about what money and value <em>are</em>, how they should be constructed, and how such beliefs can be sustained (or not) over time. The institutional structure of blockchains, of blockchain-native organisations, of DAOs and new forms of corporate entity, these are all fertile terrain for the deployment of institutional economics and political economy. You can’t fully understand Bitcoin with understanding its politics, and many of the alternatives differ more in their politics and economics than they do in their technology.</p><p>So the blockchain is great for academic economists, because it is a kind of living economic laboratory. Does it end there? No, because the blockchain does not evolve randomly but by attempts at designing new, and better, models for money, ownership, control, trade, lending, licensing, and investment. In other words, many of the key innovations of the blockchain are <em>economic</em> innovations, and that means we need economists to help design them.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/1*jqnqb2JqnMsX72KA3tQ8Kw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Yanis Varoufakis, former Valve economist</figcaption></figure><p>There is precedent here in the field of video games. These days, Yanis Varoufakis is better known as the former Greek Finance Minister, whose battles with the Eurogroup were a pivotal part of the crisis of the Euro and the Greek economy. My first awareness of him came when he was appointed Economist-in-Residence at Valve, makers of Half-Life and Portal, amongst other video games, three years before returning to politics. There, he analysed the virtual economy that had grown up around the Steam platform, as well as Valve’s internal corporate structure.</p><p>Eyjólfur Guðmundsson has <a href="https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/virtual-world-economists-on-real-economies/">studied the economy of EVE Online</a>, an economy worth millions of dollars in virtual spaceships. What he found was that the tools of economics were just as applicable to virtual economies as to physical-world ones, perhaps even more so. Moreover, those insights can be fed back into the decisions of the game’s designers, telling them how to price and structure new additions to the game world, or to tweak older ones.</p><p>If the blockchain is primarily an engine of economic innovation, this makes the skills, knowledge, and expertise of economists more valuable, because it is these skills that will be needed to create viable <a href="https://tokeneconomy.co/token-summit-san-francisco-2017-a-snapshot-of-where-we-stand-in-the-process-of-tokenizing-the-b6a55330ba23">blockchain economies</a>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/859/1*B4bhA6p5Px1fbzJIDj_-yw.png" /></figure><p>Is this already starting to happen? I’m an advisor at <a href="https://sweetbridge.com/">Sweetbridge</a>, and one of the most impressive things about Sweetbridge’s design is the depth of economic thought behind it. From the micro-economics of interactions between actors in a supply chain to the macro-economics of stable currencies, innovation ecosystems, and new labour markets for rare talent, <a href="https://sweetbridge.com/whitepaper">the Sweetbridge model</a> is both deep and broad. Sweetbridge, of course, is advised by several experienced economists and employs economic modelling techniques throughout their product design.</p><p>For us at <a href="https://mattereum.com/">Mattereum</a>, understanding our activities in relation to economic theory is crucial. The theory of incomplete contracts (for which Oliver D. Hart and Bengt Holmström received the <a href="https://www.nobelprize.org/nobel_prizes/economic-sciences/laureates/2016/press.html">2016 economics Nobel prize</a>) informs our thinking on smart contracts and how they relate to ownership structures; management of volatile assets is a major challenge in blockchain contract design; systems of price discovery that could previously only exist as thought experiments become possible with a globally shared ledger.</p><p>Of course, it’s all well and good to say that economists are important, but how about my revealed preferences? After all, Mattereum doesn’t have an economist on staff. This is true, and if you’re an economist who would like to get involved in shaping the future of the blockchain, <a href="https://hbr.org/2017/03/we-dont-need-political-solutions-for-global-trade-we-need-practical-ones">global trade</a>, and the new institutions of the 21st century, we’d certainly like to <a href="/service/mailto:info@mattereum.com">hear from you</a>.</p><p><strong>Learn more about Mattereum </strong><a href="https://medium.com/humanizing-the-singularity/the-first-mattereum-briefing-11a67c75d840"><strong>in this post</strong></a><strong> and at </strong><a href="https://mattereum.com/"><strong>https://mattereum.com/</strong></a></p><p><strong>Join the conversation in our </strong><a href="https://t.me/joinchat/GQBQcAulO-RZRl-3SMDKyQ"><strong>Telegram chat</strong></a><strong>.</strong></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=60b9c67f47b4" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/humanizing-the-singularity/why-the-biggest-winners-of-the-blockchain-might-be-economists-60b9c67f47b4">Why the biggest winners of the blockchain might be economists</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/humanizing-the-singularity">Mattereum - Humanizing the Singularity</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Tokens for ecosystem investing]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/humanizing-the-singularity/tokens-for-ecosystem-investing-7cdd4a0f8dbe?source=rss-69bb99cf537a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/7cdd4a0f8dbe</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[blockchain]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[internet-of-agreements]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ethereum]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cryptocurrency]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[token-sale]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Rob Knight]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 05 Jul 2017 10:04:01 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-07-05T10:04:01.336Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*LVvg4KkL8HlSTAFZphKAtg.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>In this post, I’m going to examine how </em><a href="https://blog.coinbase.com/a-beginners-guide-to-ethereum-tokens-fbd5611fe30b"><em>tokens</em></a><em> can differ from traditional financial instruments, in particular how they might allow for new kinds of “ecosystem” investments.</em></p><p>When someone founds a business, they generally expect the business to make money. Typically this involves buying goods or services from suppliers, hiring and paying staff, and selling goods or services to customers, turning a profit in the process.</p><p>As an investor, I can buy shares in a business that I think is going to be successful. Over time, these shares may rise in value as the business succeeds, or fall in value if it fails (there are various other reasons why prices might rise and fall, but the health of the business is the fundamental driver).</p><p>This works pretty well for businesses that operate in established markets. There’s no doubt that the market exists, so investors just have to decide if they think that the new business can out-compete the incumbents. Even most technology startups fall into this category: any time someone calls something a “disruptive” innovation, they’re acknowledging the existence of an existing market order that will be disrupted.</p><h3>Platforms and predation</h3><p>As described above, when I think that a company will be successful, I can buy shares in that company and be rewarded when those shares appreciate in value. But what if I don’t want to buy into a single company, but something more like an ecosystem?</p><p>Say we have a new software platform, perhaps a fantastic new system for creating worlds in VR, let’s call it SuperDuperWorldBuilder, or SDWB for short. SDWB provides tools for creating worlds, a scripting language, a library of objects and interactions. Let’s imagine for a moment that SDWB’s creators have <em>nailed it</em>: it’s the best VR experience anyone has ever seen. All that the platform needs is content, and here the problems begin.</p><p>As a business, SDWB needs content creators to build virtual worlds on its platform. Content creators need to be paid. But SDWB’s revenues are thin, at least in the early days. Even if SDWB grows, there is a constant conflict between SDWB and the content creators — SDWB wants to capture the largest share that it can, consistent with providing the content creators enough revenue to survive.</p><p>This pattern is familiar — Google and Facebook have this relationship to most of the web, particularly news publications. Google wants to capture as much advertising revenue as possible, and wants to pay publishers as little as possible for the content that the advertising sits on top of. Facebook likewise needs content for its users to share with each other, but has little interest in funnelling revenue towards those publishers if it could capture the revenue stream itself.</p><p>For both Google and Facebook, this conflict was not fatal. Publishers continued to publish, even when their digital divisions made losses, because they understood the importance of building digital audiences and had enough existing revenue and money in the bank to finance this. In the case of an entirely new ecosystem, the predatory relationship between the platform and the content creators has a good chance of killing the platform before it begins.</p><h3>Enter the token</h3><p>Tokens are (maybe?) a new form of financial instrument, issued on blockchains. I should point out that there are multiple definitions of “token”, and even more suggestions as to their correct — or incorrect — use. I’m going to consider one use-case that I think is both interesting and useful.</p><p>In the SDWB example above, investors are clearly incentivised to invest in the platform, and then to encourage the platform to squeeze the content creators as much as possible in order to maximise revenues. If SDWB, the content creators, and the end users together constitute an ecosystem, SDWB’s incentive is to be the apex predator in that ecosystem. Tokens can provide an alternative to this, by allowing investment in <em>ecosystems</em> rather than specific businesses.</p><p>How it works is fairly simple: tokens are used by SDWB’s customers — the end users — to purchase subscriptions, and/or to purchase access to specific virtual worlds, or items in those worlds. The rewards are split between SDWB and the content creators (and there are many ways to do this). The tokens trade on an open market, and content creators compete to create the best virtual worlds in order to gain the most tokens, which they can then trade for other things (including fiat currency in their countries of operation). Whereas a purchase of shares in SDWB is a bet on the success of SDWB, a purchase of tokens is a bet on the success of the entire SDWB ecosystem. An increase in the value of the tokens rewards SDWB <em>and</em> the content creators equally. For token investors, funding an ecosystem makes sense because even if SDWB never makes huge profits, the ecosystem as a whole might do so. Betting on the whole ecosystem might be a good way to spread risk.</p><h3>Funding ecosystem development</h3><p>If buying equity in a business is a good way of funding a predatory model, is buying tokens a good way to fund an ecosystem-nurturing model? Well, it depends.</p><p>Some token sales look like thinly-veiled equity issuances. The language used — shares, market caps, dividends — is the language of equity. Many equity-like tokens are simply inferior to straight-up equity — they come with no voting rights, and often have broad disclaimers which guarantee token-holders no rights in the business that issued the tokens. A bet on a single firm is also very risky, because the single business is also a single point of failure — and startup failure rates are somewhere over 90%.</p><p>In contrast, ecosystem tokens are designed to be <em>used</em>. They circulate between the participants in the ecosystem, with the tokens rising in value as the demand for tokens increases. As individual tokens become more valuable, a single token should buy more services from the ecosystem, with the participants making higher revenues from the increased volume of transactions. As such, early token-holders could expect to gain from the appreciation of the value of their tokens without rising token prices killing the ecosystem.</p><p>There are also all manner of <em>other</em> token schemes, which I can’t cover here. But, contrasted with equity-like tokens, ecosystem tokens seem to me like a genuinely useful financial innovation, and one which should become part of regular finance in the future.</p><p>So, how do token issuers create ecosystems? My suggestion is that token sales should not just fund a single business, but should fund the ecosystem of other businesses around them too. In the case of SDWB, that means funding content creators as well as the core platform, and possibly several other ancillary services too. The token issuer has to play a dual role — they’re probably the one setting up the core platform, but they also have to play a role as an ecosystem catalyst.</p><p>What this looks like in practice may vary. In some cases, it may end up looking quite like <a href="https://slack.com/developers/fund">Slack’s venture fund</a>. In other cases, it may look like <a href="https://www.bountysource.com/">Bountysource</a>. There’s no best practice right now, but if <a href="https://insights.dcg.co/will-blockchains-disrupt-venture-capital-9436f158f2f2">ICOs disrupt traditional VCs</a>, a new role as ecosystem curators may beckon.</p><h3>Conclusion</h3><p>All of this is fairly speculative, and is much more optimstic in outlook than my normal take on things. Put simply, I think we have enough critiques of the ICO market right now, and I’m more interested in trying to rescue the good and useful ideas that have bubbled (pun intended) to the surface. For these things to become practical at scale, much more regulatory compliance work will be needed, and maybe even regulatory changes. Many more people will end up getting it wrong than those who get it right, but the ones that get it right deserve our support and encouragement.</p><p><em>It should go without saying that none of the above constitutes investment advice, or a recommendation of any particular token, ICO or investment scheme.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=7cdd4a0f8dbe" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/humanizing-the-singularity/tokens-for-ecosystem-investing-7cdd4a0f8dbe">Tokens for ecosystem investing</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/humanizing-the-singularity">Mattereum - Humanizing the Singularity</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[We Don’t Need Political Solutions for Global Trade — We Need Practical Ones]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/humanizing-the-singularity/we-dont-need-political-solutions-for-global-trade-we-need-practical-ones-8b51d4e2b91e?source=rss-69bb99cf537a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8b51d4e2b91e</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[internet-of-agreements]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ethereum]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[blockchain]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[trade]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[supply-chain]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Rob Knight]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 03 Jul 2017 13:02:24 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-07-03T13:58:57.032Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>We Don’t Need Political Solutions for Global Trade — We Need Practical Ones</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*UwG0qjMLG1GKM-iJrXwC1w.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>This story originally appeared in </em><a href="https://hbr.org/2017/03/we-dont-need-political-solutions-for-global-trade-we-need-practical-ones"><em>Harvard Business Review</em></a><em> on March 9th 2017.</em></p><p>What if we could track every component in a supply chain, automatically verifying their compliance with regulations and laws as they cross borders and are processed and combined with others to create a final product for sale? What if we could verify the pay and conditions of the factory workers each step of the way? What if we could account fully for the carbon emissions produced in manufacturing, shipping, and handling of the goods? In a <a href="http://internetofagreements.com/files/WorldGovernmentSummit-Dubai2017.pdf">recent paper</a>, my colleagues at Hexayurt.Capital and I described a future in which blockchains, AI, and automated logistics explain how organizations and governments will soon be able to do all of these things and more.</p><p>These capabilities might seem like nice things to have, the metrics useful to measure. But as global supply chains become more complex, and the drive to harmonize global trade rules slows down or goes into reverse, the ability to answer these questions could become crucial for any business that hopes to grow in international markets.</p><p>For the last four decades, global trade rules have been harmonized by international treaties and trade organizations. In 2016 the trend began to reverse. One of President Trump’s first actions was to withdraw from the Trans-Pacific Partnership, a free trade deal among 11 countries. Britain not only voted to leave the European Union but also seems set to exit the single market free-trade zone.</p><p>All of this was foreshadowed in 2007, by <a href="https://www.hks.harvard.edu/about/faculty-staff-directory/dani-rodrik">Harvard economist Dani Rodrik</a>, whose <a href="http://rodrik.typepad.com/dani_rodriks_weblog/2007/06/the-inescapable.html">“trilemma of the world economy”</a> predicted that it would be impossible to pursue globalization while maintaining nation states and democratic government. He pointed out that international rules would be hard to maintain and extend in the face of democratic demands for locally set laws and regulations.</p><p>This is a challenge for businesses that have come to depend on the harmonized rules of the international trading system in order to do business. In principle, there’s no problem with combining democracy, nation states, and reasonably open global trade. It’s the practicalities that make it difficult. In practice, every country making its own regulations and bilateral deals is a recipe for chaos and confusion. No human could possibly keep up with the required paperwork, with the regulatory and compliance burden imposed by such a system. But computers can, which leads us to the <a href="http://internetofagreements.com/">Internet of Agreements</a>.</p><p>An agreement can be as simple as a handshake between two people who trust each other. But such trust doesn’t spread very far. Modern trade networks need hundreds of people to cooperate — not just the parties to the trade and their customers and suppliers, but also customs agents, tax collectors, and agents of the legal system. Because we can’t trust everyone, we need law and regulation, in the form of paperwork. If the paperwork is correct and matches what actually happened to get a product shipped across international borders, we know that everything has been done correctly. Discrepancies indicate malfeasance, corruption, or error.</p><p>Business runs on agreements — that shipments will be sent and received, salaries and invoices paid, goods transported, contracts fulfilled, debts honored, and the law complied with. Today this is often done on paper — payslips, bills of lading, safety certificates, professional credentials, with signatures and countersignatures to verify approval — but the near future will see the entire collection of documents digitized. Blockchain technology, with encryption keys verifying the authenticity of the data and decentralized storage ensuring that data cannot be lost, replaced, or tampered with, provides a perfect means for managing digital documents for trade.</p><p>This isn’t just a savings on paperwork; it’s a fundamental change in the nature of contracts and agreements. For much the same reason that computers have enabled us to handle much greater complexity in other areas, computers could handle checking 476 sets of regulations as easily as checking one. Armed with data about what has been agreed upon by the parties to a contract and what is required for regulatory compliance, computers can begin managing compliance for us. Machine-readable laws and machine-readable contracts enable machine-managed supply chains.</p><p>Consider the example of tracking food from the farm to a supermarket. London-based startup <a href="https://www.provenance.org/whitepaper">Provenance</a> is already testing blockchain technology for tracking the origin of food; its ambition is to provide complete transparency over the entire supply chain. With access to such data, working out whether a given shipment is compliant with local regulations becomes a much more tractable problem, one that can be solved automatically. As economies of scale reduce costs, the idea of having a fully legible global supply chain begins to look feasible. Just as shipping containers boosted trade by standardizing shipping, the Internet of Agreements could standardize the ways we exchange and process the metadata of trade, and it’s this metadata that is important for compliance.</p><p>Other factors of production could be tracked and managed similarly. Imagine being able to inspect the labor contracts used by suppliers, so that you could ensure minimum standards of pay, safety, or education are being met. As factory workers clock in and out, and are paid for their work, a permanent record created on a blockchain could allow the factory owner to prove compliance with labor standards regulations in the markets they are selling to, at a trivial cost.</p><p>It’s this ability to automate paperwork, the system that allows us to trust each other across vast distances and cultural differences, that will allow us to extend globalization past the limits set by Rodrik’s trilemma. As we wrote in the <a href="http://internetofagreements.com/files/WorldGovernmentSummit-Dubai2017.pdf">Internet of Agreements paper</a>, “The first globalization was an industrial model of globalization, where everything has to be made with the same standards before people can work together. In Globalization 2.0, computers take the strain of handling local differences in standards, regulation, and consumer preference, and advanced manufacturing meets these requirements because it can run small batches tailored to local needs efficiently.” This new environment does not require that everyone’s laws be the same, merely that everyone’s laws be connected and agreed upon in some way. The <a href="http://internetofagreements.com/">Internet of Agreements</a> has the potential to facilitate this, allowing trade to flow where it’s both legal and satisfies market needs.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8b51d4e2b91e" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/humanizing-the-singularity/we-dont-need-political-solutions-for-global-trade-we-need-practical-ones-8b51d4e2b91e">We Don’t Need Political Solutions for Global Trade — We Need Practical Ones</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/humanizing-the-singularity">Mattereum - Humanizing the Singularity</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>