<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Global Economics on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Global Economics on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@rodanogen?source=rss-12cc0087aebf------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sun, 22 Nov 2026 05:51:27 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@rodanogen/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[My correspondence with some Russians]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@rodanogen/my-correspondence-with-some-russians-ea0bd71312ee?source=rss-12cc0087aebf------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ea0bd71312ee</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[russia]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[war]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[putin]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[vladimir-zelenski]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ukraine]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Global Economics]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 06 Mar 2022 09:10:41 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-03-06T09:10:41.338Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>My correspondence with some Russians</p><p>----------------<br>Dima Voroblev<br>My life in the USSR was good.</p><p>By the time it all came crashing down, I was building a good career, with generous pay and cool colleagues. I’m ethnically Russian, and my father was a hero of WWII which gave me pride and the credentials I needed to further my career. I lived in Moscow, which a very strict Soviet system of resident permits (“propiska”) made an impossible dream for a large majority in the provinces. Unlike most of the Soviet population, I had an unhindered access to Western media and could interact socially with Western nationals. I traveled a lot, and interviewed many interesting people who I wouldn’t have met if I were not in the service of the Soviet state.</p><p>(And hey, I was young! It felt so heavenly to be young. Too bad I’m only now fully aware of that.)</p><p>But the rest of the nation decided that life in the USSR was not so good after all. So they sent my country to the landfill of history. I can’t blame them for that. Everyone looks for a better life</p><p>--------------------<br>My answer to Dima;</p><p>And what about destruction of Russian culture and spirit, by murdering most of the intellectuals, who couldn&#39;t accept, that 2+2=5? What about families of millions murdered just because they were in the wrong place in wrong time? What about people brain washed by Soviet propaganda, that were educated according to the “Soviet values”, pretending to prefer the needs of society upon their own individual needs, while in reality they cared only about themselves and their petty advantages upon others. Aren&#39;t you ashamed to admit, that you were part of the system and even enjoyed to have petty advantages, like right to travel and communicate with people out of USSR, while the others were inprisoned in the biggest prison in human history, the USSR? By the way, in the West everyone could communicate with everyone without the fear to be incriminated for that, what was not the case in USSR.</p><p>So you and your “privileged friend”, were nothing more than petty thieves in a huge criminal organisation called USSR.<br>--------------<br>I just served my country, Sir, as best I could.<br>---------------<br>Yes, many people under pretext of serving their country, have done it mainly to enjoy some petty advantages upon their fellow citizens. Like no need to stand hours in queues for basic food. Never asked the question, why those queues exist at all?</p><p>Could you explain me, way is your country so important to you, that you fell it right to serve it, even if it murdered and persecuted your friends, neighbours, family members, etc? Isn&#39;t more important certain level of human decency in interpersonal relations, than serving country, that enslaves it&#39;s own citizens? Wasnt it morally better, if you would demand from the country to serve you instead?<br>---------------<br>We believed at the time that our country showed the way to the rest of the world<br>------------<br>Thanks for your honest words. It is very interesting psychological issue. How could you believe in Sovietism? (I refuse to call it socialism). If i understand correctly you lived in Scandinavia. You could see and compare USSR with the most liberal, socially most advanced countries in the West. How come you still believed, the Communistic way is the right way? Maybe people like you suffered from Stockholm syndrome? https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stockholm_syndrome<br>---------<br>If you’re born into Real Socialism, it’s the only thing you know. Filial Imprinting is a much better term for what you’re trying to say<br>----------------<br>That&#39;s strange, i was born and grew up in Estern Europe, occupied by the Soviets. I remember most of my scholmates understood in what a shit we live in compared to the West. But maybe we didn&#39;t represent the majority of the population, just as today the Russian as in most of the democratic world, the intelectual elites don&#39;t represent the ignorant majority.</p><p>There are rare times in history, when the ignorant majority is ready to submit itself to the leading intelectual elites, and then the politics becomes positive, but in most of the history since WWI, the ignorant majority, or their “representatives “ ruled under flag of right or left ideology, and it was disaster. But Plato knew about this already 2400 years ago, nīl sub sōle novum.<br>--------------<br>Exactly ideological cohesion, was the thing that kept together this monstrous regime. Honestly, now that you are most probably retired, do you see ideological cohesion as a positive or negative thing?</p><p>Other thing, USSR never had allies in Eastern Europe, it had colonies of worse kind. The other colonial powers as GB or France gave something positive to colonised countries. Without British colonial rule, there would be no India today. The same with Morocco and Algiers. In India the people use English language and in Algeria and Morocco French. Noone speaks Russian in Eastern Europe, even if they speak Slavic languages, close to Russian.<br>------------------------<br>In humans it is well known, part of the capacity to think is innate. Of course the materialistic behaviouristic philosophy, you probably grew up in, refused this notion. But as in most of faith systems, be it religious or ideologically based, there is no refuteability or evidence that can oppose the ONE truth.<br>-----------------------<br>It seems Putin and his clan of supporters from KGB have problem seeing in their peripheral countries, the previous Soviet colonies in Central Europe and the Baltic states prospering, and having stable, democratic regimes. Ukraine tries to go the same way, and it seems to Russian bullies too much. They have no problem with despotic regimes in Bielorussia, Kazakhstan, Azerbaijan, etc. But to have a prosperous democratic Ukraine, as a show window to Russian people, seems to Putin too dangerous. It can give some dangerous thought to the Russians themselves.<br>You wrote, the regime in Ukraine is not stable, i would say in contrary. In Russia where the regime is based on one dictator, even if not despot as Stalin, is a very unstable regime. Try to check with what difficulties was transferred the power in USSR, with the death of the dictator. Competitors murdered or outposted from politics. Historical experience teaches us, the same head of any regime after more than 10 years is a very bad thing. The regime after 10 years necessarily becomes corrupt, more and more despotic, more and more resources are allocated for sustaining the regime itself, and too little is left for the people. At the end the collapse is inevitable. This is what happened to USSR. All the propaganda machinery, indoctrination, censorship, investment in indoctrinated education didn&#39;t help. At the end no-one, except of the bosses wanted to fight for this regime. Even the politburo members, when they surprised understood, no-one is behind them, they turned to the well know medicine, VODKA.<br>For how long is Putin in the reign? 20 years. For how long more he will stay? 20 more years. This is a stable regime for you? No!!! It is a stagnating regime, making mistakes on mistakes.<br>Russia had a chance to join EU and NATO 15 years ago. By now, it would be a leading nation in EU, economically and politically. It would mean to democratise Russia. To let political opposition grow and establish itself. But instead of that, Putin has chosen the road of confrontation, to ensure his regime will exist “forever”.<br>Pity, i feel pity for the Russians. Russia used to be culturally very influential in Europe. Not any more. It exports cultural people, but not culture.<br>Russia doesn&#39;t need war, its leadership needs paradigmatic change. It is it&#39;s only hope to save itself.<br>Do not forget, in the meantime the Eastern Dragon is watching, with its 10 times bigger population, already now more than 10 times bigger economy than Russia. Waiting until the fruit, all the territories East of Ural, will be ripe to pick it up. Eventually the great “patriot”, Putin will handover Siberia to the Chinese on golden plate. But it will be in the last year of his reign, in 20 years from now.<br>---------------------<br>Ukraine isn’t prosperous or democratic. Nobody in Russia envies it.</p><p>Russia, unstable? Russia’s okay. Better than some of our neighbors, that’s for sure. What inevitable collapse? Everything suggests against it.</p><p>Russia wanted all of that, but that was not in NATO or EU’s interest to let Russia join. Russia is too strong to control. Especially now that it has regained some strength.</p><p>Russia needs to be ready for war because NATO, US, Ukraine are readying for war.</p><p>China doesn’t need to be imperialist. They can buy anything they need.<br>---------------------</p><p>Dear Maxim, if you want to have a serious discussion on your article please do not put my comment out of context.<br>I never said Ukraine is a prosperous democratic country. Non of the Post USSR countries is. It takes dozens of years to correct the way people think about themselves and about their relationships with their associates, colleagues, friends, subordinates, bosses. Economically prosperous democratic country is all about these relationships. As contrary to Russia, Ukraine tried after few unsuccessful attempts, to make the very first steps toward correcting these relationships. It needed a revolution and several failed trials to kick out partly the corrupt leadership. But Putin didn&#39;t like to let the Ukraine people choose freely their representatives, for good or for bad. So he invaded Krym, then Other parts of Ukraine. No, it is not about Russian security, it is about the imperialistic policy of Putin.<br>-----------<br>No, Russia doesn&#39;t need to invest in its military. Noone dares even to think of attacking Russia, with or without its Atomic arsenal. No country, its political representatives must think about the prosperity of their population, which is not the case in Russia, want war. Only a president, who doesn&#39;t need to worry about the next election, as Putin, can think seriously about war.<br>Look what writes your citizens about life in Russia. Wouldn&#39;t it be more wise, if Putin would invest resources into everyday life, than in military and wars?<br>https://truthaboutrussia.quora.com/https-www-quora-com-How-do-Russians-perceive-<br>https://truthaboutrussia.quora.com/https-www-quora-com-How-do-Russians-perceive-their-government-and-place-on-the-world-stage-answer-Misha-Firer?ch=3&amp;oid=61668151&amp;share=c9a4f110&amp;srid=ulM1px&amp;target_type=post-government-and-place-on-the-world-stage-answer-Misha-Firer?ch=3&amp;oid=61668151&amp;share=c9a4f110&amp;srid=ulM1px&amp;target_type=post<br>One more thing. You and me, we probably have very different options about a stable regime. To me a regime building its legitimacy on repression is not stable in today&#39;s modern world, with the internet and other means of mass communication. The proof you can find in the Arab countries, and also in USSR, that collapsed not because of the US military, but because their own people became fed up with all the lies and mismanagement, such dictatorships suffer from.<br>--------------<br>At the end there is a soldier who has to aim and pull the trigger. What seems logical and obvious, the soldiers, not even the officers of the Russian army understand, what the goal of this war is. If it would be a walk, and Ukrainian beauties would wave to them on margines of the roads, this would be an another story. But no. Ukrainians already tasted what it means democracy, very chaotic democracy, but still better than being abused every day in every step in your life by some bully, who is part of some anonymous power structures, called KGB, NKVD, Soviets, central committees, you name it. Who the hell are the Soviets? Noone knew these people, only their vicious primitive footman, who if disconnected from some anonymous apparatus, are completely useless.</p><p>So yes Russia can destroy Ukraine, it can destroy the whole world, itself also. Do you believe they would do it? Are they as desperate? I would say in contrary. Russians, even under the regime of Putin, still live the best life they ever had in their history. Why would they destroy everything? It sounds too crazy to me to believe in it.</p><p>We all know, Russia can destroy Ukraine and the whole world, including Russia itself. The questions are:<br>A. If Putin is ready to destroy Ukraine or/and the world.<br>B. If there is a tool in Russian top decision process, that will stop him to do it.</p><p>---------------<br>You put it funny in a surreal way, but in real life it&#39;s sad to see so much loss of life and tragedy on both sides of the conflict for the sole sake of power games, geopolitical calculations and historical imperial dreams. Russia should have never attacked Ukraine. The two nations are distinct, but culturally and emotionally related.</p><p>A few days ago I found this quote from Erich Hartmann about the nature of war: War is a place where the young kill one another without knowing or hating each other, because of the decision of old people who know and hate each other, without killing each other.</p><p>Maybe, those old men on the corridors of power everywhere in the world should pause for a moment and think this through.<br>-----------------------------<br>Putin, is as unpredictable as any other dictator in late stage of his rule. <br> <br>I&#39;m not expert on Putin&#39;s regime. I don&#39;t know what Putin is capable. I don&#39;t know, if there is chance, someone in his inner circle, or in his commander structure will wake up and oppose him? I am reading the comments of Russians living in Russia on the web, and see most of them are totally blindfolded by Putin&#39;s propaganda. Every lie, even the most improbable, is accepted. They believe, Russia is fighting some imaginary enemy, they call him Nazi Bondar elements. If Putin would call it spagety dragon, it would work as well. Very few Russians, have the capacity to differentiate reality from lies.</p><p>Just like Donald Trump supporters. <br>I talked once to a republican supporting American friend of mine. He told me he doesn&#39;t believe in people from Academy. I asked him, if you don&#39;t believe in academics, whose thinking is based on critical thinking and scientific method, to whom do you believe? Donald Trump he said. Donald Trump? who can say in one line two opposite claims? Who, if says sometimes truth, it is only by accident, and most probably he is not even aware of him saying truth.</p><p>If China will use this opportunity to grab Taiwan, as some people suggests, the humanity is probably done. In mean time, what i see, China is rather watching from the side what&#39;s happening, with rather negativity towards Putin. When Lavrov, Russian minister of foreign affairs said, someone dragged us to this war, he meant most probably China.</p><p>Yes China is playing double game. China needs weak Russia, even better completely destroyed economically and militarily. So it can take over Siberia&#39;s resources. China&#39;s leader is much smarter than Putin. He understands that sovereignty has no value, if it doesn&#39;t feeds your countryman. Putin started this war for achieving political sovereignty upon Ukraine. Even if achieved, it will only cost Russia economically, with no reward. And Xe sees, how costly and unpredictable can be an unjust war against people used to freedom, be it freedom with corruption and incompetence. There are only costs, with no economic benefit. If China needs chips, it can buy it and doesn&#39;t need to make a very costly war against Taiwan.</p><p>So I trust more China than the US and the West to prevent WWIII.</p><p>And what Mr. Doom man suggests? To bomb by nukes Moscow? If his prediction is correct, then there is no use to be worried anymore about anything, everything is anyway out of our control and most probably we are all doomed. SORRY.</p><p>I start to miss the old communists upon Putin<br>----------------------<br>To my opinion a regime, who puts in its head a leader, (fuhrer in German), who stays there for more than 10 years and cannot be removed from his position, necessarily will create evil. Political power is based on loyal people. Dostojevsky wrote, that the strongest way to create loyalty is by joint criminal act. Political leadership, that have to make decisions on daily basis, makes mistakes, and those mistakes it never admits, rather it tries to correct them by more mistakes. That&#39;s how a kind of political leadership, that suffocate criticism by persecuting free flow of information, like Putin&#39;s regim acts.<br>The best historical examples are all those kings and dictators, who couldn&#39;t be removed, but by murdering them, or natural death. You have so many of them in Russian history.</p><p>Look at history of Communistic regime in Russia. How they accumulated mistake on mistake, and never made correction, in contrary, until the life in Russia and its colonies became unbearable, and it fall apart as a house of cards. Unfortunately it took whole 80 years to happened, and in mean time the Dostojevskys, Tolstoys and other potential great Russian intelectuals were murdered, or emigrated to US, to Israel, to the West. Who do you think Americans are? Many of them of Russian origin. In Russia they would be murdered or silenced, and in the western liberal countries they thrive. Even Dostojevsky was almost murdered by Russian regime, and if would be, he would never have the chance to write his books, that are the top of the top of human cultural creation. How many Dostojevskies were scielenced or murdered by Russian despotic regimes, of Tzars, Lenin, Stalin and his descendents? Noone knows. All we know, Russian regime is what it is, and noone wants to live under its reign voluntarily. Not the East European countries, not Baltic states, not Ukrainians, and not even Belarusians, who would happily overthrow their dictator, if this choice would be given into their hands. <br>Truth is i know very little about the war in Donetsk. Yet I read somewhere on the web a preference poll of Donetsk separatists themself, claiming that the public support of ethnic Russians in their land raised already to 20%. (Later they claimed that this publication was a mistake, but other sources verified this survey and a bit even corrected the data not in their favour. You can find it on the web). If it is truth, it doesn&#39;t sounds to me as they are an army of liberators. My conclusion, definitely not verified is, all this story about genocide in Donetsk, is just and another propoganda lie of Putins regime.</p><p>The fact is more than a million refugees, mostly woman and children left Ukrain in last week. And other millions are on their way. It doesn&#39;t look to me like Putin&#39;s army is on liberating operation in Ukraine. It more looks like it is doing genocide. <br>Of course no-one can stop Putin, unless people like you will face the ugly unpleasant fact, that you are part of a political system, that is aggressive and despotic, wherever it is, be it in Ukraine, Georgia, but also in Russia itself. Most of the economic resources, found in Russland, this regime sells to the west, to enrich themselves, and generate enough wealth used to stick to political power and disorient people of Russia as you, who belive in well structured lies and propaganda. (And please don&#39;t answer me, that US has also aggressive policy, because i agree and i wrote against it as well. Also please don&#39;t show me photos of Ukrainian neo Nazis. Of course they exist, as they exist everywhere, even in Russia).<br>These are the facts, you can deny, yet still 2+2 is 4, even if you don&#39;t like it.<br>------------<br>I wonder, what is it so attractive for Russia to annex other territories? Russia has difficulty managing its own territory.<br>If the aim is economy, war never pays off.<br>Sovereignty? What it is all about? Drawing new maps? It is just a headache.<br>Honestly i have no explanation, why would anyone in Russia, already far the largest state in the world, with declining population, stagnating economy totally dependent on exports of commodities, want to annex new territories?<br>Unless!!! Putin is like Vizard from Oz, that at the end all what is behind him is a loudspeaker.</p><p>You start with small piece of land, then you have to defend it. So you annex the neighbours. But then you have to defend the new territories, so you annex again the neighbours. But then you have to defend the new territories, so you annex again the neighbours. But then you have to defend the new territories, so you annex again the neighbours. But then you have to defend the new territories, so you annex again the neighbours,………</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ea0bd71312ee" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[If in previous assays i wrote about money and its connection to debt, here i would like to write…]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@rodanogen/if-in-previous-assays-i-wrote-about-money-and-its-connection-to-debt-here-i-would-like-to-write-27e558a203bb?source=rss-12cc0087aebf------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/27e558a203bb</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Global Economics]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 27 Jun 2021 20:17:52 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-06-27T20:17:52.695Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>If in previous assays i wrote about money and its connection to debt, here i would like to write about the more fundamental issue, that lays under the mechanism of exchange of goods and services, seemingly the substance of everything the economy stands on. This more fundamental issue i would call, the “social fabric”, of every element in the network, teemed together in the economic network, where each individual decision maker and provider, knows his task, his place and his authority in relation to his adjacent co-players and colleagues. The phenomenon of economic networking is based on relation between entrepreneurs, investors, producers, sellers, intermediators, employees and employers and final consumers. The exchange of goods and services needs an intermediary agent, that scales the relative value of the products, and gives it its price. This agent is money. Other emerging property of money is its function as value keeper on timeline, without propensity to lose it&#39;s value, and as such it brings with it unlimited demand for it. This also means money is an asset, held by people and institutions, in purpose either to generate income in form of interest, or as a value holding asset, that can be easily exchanged against any item or service, without a need to give up the money at discount price. <br>The major difference between money compared to other kinds of assets is its relative liquidity, and its value stability. The phenomenon of unlimited demand for money causes accumulation of it, and adds to the unequal distribution of wealth between people.</p><p>The above described function of money creates a whole monetary system, with agents, who are safekeepers of money deposits, intermediators between borrowers and lenders, trustful payment providers. This whole monetary system is securing smooth flow of exchange between purchaser and seller of goods and services, activities in the real economy.</p><p>The real economy is about production and distribution of goods and services. Production itself is about capital invested in production facilities, row material exploited from nature or processed, and labour invested into the production. <br>Distribution is about transportation, selling spots, brands, marketing services, etc. <br>Above all this stands money, the major tool enabling flow of products in the production process, until finally reaching the customer, who is willing to pay the product its price.</p><p>This simplified description of the economic system leaves one question, what kind of money distribution will secure to most people to get the most value, while limited resources is the axiomatic fact that underlies the whole economic system.</p><p>Assuming everyone&#39;s needs are the same, seemingly the solution, to pay to anyone the same amount, seems intuitively right. The problem is, such an approach proved to be very inefficient. The Soviet experiment proved to fail. Someone may claim, this experiment was not handled correctly. It was kidnapped by the most unscrupulous politicians, as Stalin, Khrushchev and Brezhnev. But even more successful experiments, under entirely different circumstances, like Kibutz in Israel, failed to survive beyond the first and second generation of founder fathers. The demand for individual expression and creativity, as fulfillment of desire for freedom, won over the ideology of cooperation and social harmony.</p><p>The economic efficiency of the market-capital economy, based on its capacity to recruit one of the most common human attributes: greed, envy, competitiveness, and infinite wish to stockpile possessions of value holding assets. These seemingly socially negative attributes succeeded to create harmonious social economic cooperation, out of rather chaotic competition between each individual and different parts of social structure. Whereas the alternative system, based on cooperation and mutual guarantee out of altruism and ungrudging acts of readiness to share, seemingly socially positive attributes, failed.</p><p>I thought what experience could be relevant to the expected economic breakdown that will emerge from the Covid-19 pandemic. The only comparable event that came up to my mind was the collapse of the centrally managed communistic economic block.</p><p>About 30 years ago, the communistic economic system collapsed. New leaders of more than half of the world population, introduced revolutionary change in the previous economic system, from bureaucratic, centrally managed-planned economy to capitalist-market oriented economy. The crises following the collapse of the previously centrally managed network was huge. Everything that seemed valuable in the past lost its value. Huge investments in production facilities, and economic infrastructure lost their relevance, and whole cities of industrial sites stood empty, without use. Public transportation, that used to bring workers to these factories became useless. Even worse, lots of the knowledge taught, learned, became irrelevant. The social network, that enabled functioning of the previous system disappeared overnight, and many major players needed to disconnect their ties with their previous colleagues, denying their identities.</p><p>Already before its collapse, significant parts of the leaders in the so called socialistic countries, understood the failure of the socalled &quot;socialist economic system&quot;. But only very few had the freedom to learn about the alternative market economy. The previous leaders, who participated in the leading positions in the communist regime, lost their possessions and position from one day to other. New leaders, relatively young, in their twenties and thirties, with capacity to learn and adopt new ways of action and thinking became relevant. They took the leadership positions, and erased whole level of nomenklatura, mostly opportunists and very few ideologically oriented leaders, were erased from the economic scenery.</p><p>The capitalistic-market economies were just happy to fulfill the economic void that had been opened in the post communist countries. They took over the leftovers of collapsed production and distribution facilities, replaced it, remodelled it, rebuilt it. New markets, with hundreds of millions of well educated, very adaptable people, hungry for knowledge, with entrepreneur spirit, opened for risk taking, since they had very little to lose, opened to the unscrupulous, well established, western economic entities. The capitalistic system based on competitiveness, used their advantage in knowledge and available capital, transformed the previously, &quot;socialistic&quot; economy to capital-market economy within less than 20 years. If the GDP per capita with the collapse of the &quot;socialistic system&quot; of the East European countries was about 15% of the major western European economies, at 2019 it was already about 70%.</p><p>But the winners of the bipolar cold war, due to their unscrupulous drive to victory, releasing all the forces of greed and envy, giving up the blush. They had neglected the fact, that there are two sides of the capitalistic-market economy, the financial monetary side and the real economy side.Their focusing mostly on the financial side of the economy, leaving the real economy side to the economies, emerging from the socialistic nightmare, mainly to China. Most of the industrial production moved to these countries, and most of the western economies focused on services, market developments, global corporate management, and above all financial services. This eventually brought the economic collapse of 2008, when USA needed to recycle debt, accumulated by growing foreign trade deficit, by selling financial assets to the exporting countries, among them, the main exporter to the US, China.</p><p>This policy meant, most developed countries were also the most indebted countries. On the other hand, the developing countries, mainly from the previous communistic block, to secure currency stability, needed to accumulate huge reserves of foreign currency, mainly US dollars, to secure their solvency in international transactions, mostly at times of financial crisis, became the borrowers.</p><p>Since 2008 financial crisis, the leading Western economies tried to reload their economies by nationalising the private debt, and continue to increase the volume of government deficit.</p><p>This process continued until 2020, when sudden outbreak of Covid-19 pandemic freezed the economic activity in most of the world, and caused in one hand decrease in the GDP, that means decrease in debt repayment capacity of economies deeply in depted, while in parallel to it, the governments increased substantially their deficit, that added additional increase in their debts. <br>How risky is this debt? The claim is, that Japan has much higher public debt, and it started to accumulate this debt many years before the 2008 financial crisis. But the US debt is very different from the Japanese or European debt, because large parts of it, (about one third), is external to foreign countries, mainly Japan and China, while the Japanese debt is internal debt. This means that the public debt, a financial monetary phenomenon by itself, has deep consequences as to the structure of the real economy. The default of many industries in US, the most famous, the bankruptcy of GM, few decades ago, the biggest company in the world just few dacades before, is direct result of monetary system of overvalued currency, that causes debt to foreigners.<br>----------------</p><p>Modern economy is based on social structure, where each individual, using money is an economically active human being. The very act of using money, is an economic act of participation in creating the fabric of economic network. This can be an entrepreneur, employee or employed, but also an unemployed or a pensioner, whose economic function is to be a consumer using savings, as participant in creating the aggregate demand.<br>The economy in local or global level includes, decision makers, each of them knows his unique function, his space to act, his institutive relationships to the other in cooperative network of division of labour. Everyone has his authority as to his adjacent co-players and colleagues, and who has the authority to manage and decide for him his tasks in the social-economic fabric. There are those, who&#39;s knowledge and understanding of realities is limited to their adjacent co-players, then are those with knowledge reaching far related co-players. The final level of decision makers are those, with global picture of the whole social-political-economic structure, and are in the position of global leadership.</p><p>If to try to predict the expected economic recovery from the post Covid-19 world, the closest comparable event will be the post world war, or post revolution world. <br>If we compare the post WWII economic recovering from destructed physical infrastructure by war, we find, that while West Germany and Japan miraculously recovered and within 10-15 years newly established a prosperous economy, the East block &quot;socialistic&quot; countries with the same, many cases even better starting point had failed. The major difference between these two competing economic systems was their very different economic networking structure. While in the West the networking was voluntarily based, self organised from the most local to the most corporate level, in the East it was planned and pre-decided by hierarchically organized bureaucratic structure, where networking was strictly imposed on each individual economic unit from the individual to corporate structure. When the so called &quot;socialistic economic system&quot; collapsed, very little useful economic networking remained in function, and all had to be newly build from scratch. <br>With the help of western investors and entrepreneurs, the introduction of market economy was relatively fast and successful. Yet, in Czechia as example, even 30 years later, many parts of the economy based on economic networking is in hands of foreign entities. The best example is the food retail distribution, that is all in hands of international food market chains, or small retail grocery shops on local level, entirely in hands of Vietnamese retailers, with their own supply chains, with their own capital investments, with labour force recruited among members of their own community.</p><p>Out of above, the question is, will the standstill of the economy, cause major disruption in the economic networking, or not. The answer to this question is partly in the preconditions that prevailed in global economy before the appearance of pandemics. <br>As explained above, the huge indebtedness of the most developed countries, mainly USA and Euro zone, are the basis of the reserve currency, that is fundamental for enabling international commerce and division of labour on global level. Disruptions in this monetary system can endanger the existing global economic networking. <br>The US economic policy, coordinated by president Trump, even before the outbreak of the pandemics, caused several disruptions to the system in the last years. Still the system continued to function without too big upheaval, until the outbreak of Corona virus. To secure the continuous functioning of the system needs international cooperation between the major economic powerhouses, as USA, China and Euro zone. The sustainability of monetary system, based on reserve currency depends on the trust in this monetary system. Trust is a subjective phenomenon and dependent on faith in actions of major political leaders, mainly USA. Major failure of political representatives, or any other disruption in the existing system, as withdraw from international agreements, sudden change of rules of the game, or even verbal expression of to make such a plans, can cause lose of trust among enough people, that panic will take over the system, and then the collapse will follow.</p><p>The major change in the economic thought as it appears in the news is sudden understanding of price paid to any decision. Until recently, most of the politicians, mainly in the US acted and spoke, as if resources were unlimited, and there is no lid on the exploitation of the resources. Suddenly, the talk is all about human life, as alternative price to be paid to the functioning economy.</p><p>-</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=27e558a203bb" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Umair Haque in his essay "The Beginning of the End of Western Civilization", said many right…]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@rodanogen/umair-haque-in-his-essay-the-beginning-of-the-end-of-western-civilization-said-many-right-d85a9dd11236?source=rss-12cc0087aebf------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d85a9dd11236</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[capitalism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[communism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[apocalypse]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[western-civilization]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[welfare]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Global Economics]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 26 Jun 2021 00:58:47 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-06-26T00:58:47.701Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Umair Haque in his essay &quot;The Beginning of the End of Western Civilization&quot;, said many right things, but made also many incorrect claims.</p><p><a href="https://link.medium.com/rUnAciB9mhb">https://link.medium.com/rUnAciB9mhb</a></p><p>Umair&#39;s claim is:<br> Descartes, Darwin and Nietzsche, are to be blamed for the necessary collapse, the Western civilization is heading too. Of course Western Civilization is much more than these three philosophers. But even if taking seriously the claim, that rationalism, individualistic competition and nihilism invented by these three philosophers, resulted the contemporary trend of self destruction of Western Civilization, still there is no other civilisation, who could take over the game.</p><p>What Umair is criticising is not the western civilisation created by Descartes, Darwin and Nietzsche, but capitalism driven by competition for the highest possible yield on investment, that is the foundation of economic system based on voluntary cooperation, through competition, and prices fixed on free markets. The capitalistic system stands in contrast to a system based on cooperation, either enforced by central power (communistic party leadership) or having decision processes implementing democratically decided decisions, enforced by democratically elected leadership ( cooperative production or service provider entities, or cooperative houses, or settlements) In practice the democratic cooperative system never existed at the level of national state. At the level of cooperative legal entities, many times it failed to sustain itself, due to corrupt leadership, elected, while politicaly manipulating the election in the cooperatives.</p><p>The important thing is, the Western civilization invented both economic political systems, that are the only game in the town. Chinese system, so called &quot;Communistic&quot;, follows Marxism, and if Indian civilisation is democratic competitive system, it follows western philosophy of Utilitarisme. All the known social, economic, political systems are Western civilisation systems, because nothing else exists. The only existing global alternative system to Western system is Islam, that was nowhere implemented as an economic system, but in some very wealthy Islamic countries, who could afford to have very inefficient economy, financed by income from selling oil. Other Islamic countries without such income, failed economically and politically, when trying to implement Islamic economic laws.</p><p>What Umair attacked is not the rationalism of Descartes, the competing for limited resources system of Darvin, or the Nietzschian nihilism, but the human egoism, its lust for power and for more and more possession of commercial stuff.</p><p>The competitiveness of human beings is part of the Human DNA. The communistic leadership understood this need for competitiveness. They didnt abolish it, but tried to upgrade it from level of individual egotism to the level of whole national egotism. This was the reason behind the huge investments of communistic countries in sports, space exploration, and arms race.</p><p>The communists failed, because their economic system, happened to be less efficient than the capitalistic system, and failed in effective allocation of resources. Their economic system was a tool to ensure political power, and not the opposite. The individual human egoism, its lust for power and desire for more and more possession, wellfare, and individual freedom of choice, became a major political factor, and caused loss of legitimacy, while traying to enforce cooperative economic system.</p><p>While the communistic system, negkected intentionaly the global environment, to achieve short term advantage upon countries with the capitalistic system, the legitimisation of individuals human lust for more and more, in the capitalistic countries, together with the unprecedent growth of human population mainly in the non western countries, since the end of WWII, necessarily drives the human civilisation towards collapse and annihilation. The first to feel it are the poor countries, with no functioning political system, like countries in Africa, most of the Muslim countries, but also some of the South and Latin American countries.</p><p>If after the collapse of civilisation, predicted by Umair, some civilisation will continue to exist, it will be definitely a Western Civilization, and not in contrary.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d85a9dd11236" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[1. Continued trade deficit degrades the US merchandise production capacity, and what's most…]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@rodanogen/1-continued-trade-deficit-degrades-the-us-merchandise-production-capacity-and-whats-most-f882765fa947?source=rss-12cc0087aebf------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f882765fa947</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[dollar]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[reserve-currency]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[currency]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[trade-deficit]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Global Economics]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 15 Apr 2021 06:04:00 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-04-15T06:04:00.702Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>1. Continued trade deficit degrades the US merchandise production capacity, and what&#39;s most important, its population will become instead of matterial merchandise product producers to service suppliers. Even if most of the employees in both, merchandise and service industries are rather low wage, low educated workers, the mentality difference between these two is immense. While the merchandise producers at the low level occupation are usually part of the production process, that needs cooperation, and are unionised, the service employee, usually acts individually, be it a shopper, banker or even post office clerk. While the merchandise producer&#39;s attention is concentrated on the product, the service provider on the final consumer. These differences are psychologically deep. Service provider has to be always positively oriented to clients, even if in bad mood, merchandise producer, doesn&#39;t. It makes a good service supplier a natural faker, while the merchandise producers can hold his integrity and pride of belonging to the producers community.</p><p>2. As to US trade deficit, it is result of US global position as world power, giving to the world after WWII, Pax Americana, with which came also the all mighty US dollar, leaning on US military dominance, and US democratic political system, unchanged since its independence, protecting free competitive market economy and unchallenged right for private property and wealth. But this caused trade deficit as explained in triffin dilemma.</p><p><a href="https://www.investopedia.com/financial-edge/1011/how-the-triffin-dilemma-affects-currencies.aspx">https://www.investopedia.com/financial-edge/1011/how-the-triffin-dilemma-affects-currencies.aspx</a></p><p>3. All mighty dollar is not result of US merchandise industries producers competitivness and contribution of merchandise products to foreign countries, but attractiveness of US as world power, with stable political system, protecting individual property rights.</p><p>After WWII, the West European countries, devastated by war, still threatened by despotic Soviet, millitarily aggressive regime, had very little choice, but accepting the US dictate for new post war economic order, based on free trade, (dismantling the mercantilism in colonies) and US dollar as reserve currency for International trade and anchor of currency exchange. These brought too strong dollar, that until early seventies was also supported by US merchandise production capacity, that had no competitors.</p><p>Since the seventies, Germany and Japan, recovered from WWII, took over the position of world industrial producers. From the late eighties China and other East Assian countries joined them and became the major merchandise producing economies, while the US provided for the system huge market to absorb all the overproduction capacity, and also an economic platform for reinvestment of US dollars accumulated in the merchandise exporting countries.</p><p>4. Also US, due to it&#39;s open emigration policy, attractive universities, and world dominance of English language, succeeded to become almost a sole leader country, introducing new technologies, new popular culture, and global service consumption chains and brands. It drew not only many skilled young people to US, but also capital investments. Yet, the leading US corporation, acting on the global scale, are incorporated mostly in tax shelter countries, and it reduces the tax basis for US government spending, that creates public deficit in US budget, causing US debt to Asian merchandise exporting countries.</p><p>5. The US global corporations, even if incorporated in tax shelter countries, they reinvest their profits mainly back in US. So eventually enable the whole global economic system to continue to exist. But these &quot;foreign &quot; investments of US based global companies causes also huge inequality in income, when concentrating on one hand the wealth in global corporation managers and owners, and on other hand causing degradation of the local merchandise production capacities.</p><p>6. Even if economically this system is sustainable, probably politically not, mainly if there is political opposition to foreign trade deficit and political need for millitarily adventurous US foreign policy. The result is elections, that brought to power politicians with short term populist agenda. Such a policy can&#39;t be sustainable on the long run. Even if the popular masses many times find short term solutions attractive, when the pay day comes, they tend to be revolutionised and are looking for the scapegoat to sacrifice it. We are still in the process of disastrous choices of the majority in the USA and in G.B. The masses still didn&#39;t get it, that the consequences of drastic change in economic policy to wrong direction, (that still didn&#39;t happen in acts, just in proclamations), will appear not less than in two years from the policy shift, unless the business community will panic and bring to collapse the whole system, that may happen in any moment. Such a collapse is unpredictable, and its cure is not always obvious, since it is in the fields of knowledge of psychology and sociology, and not economy, and these fields of science are even less equipped to bring solution than economics.</p><p>7. Still it is understandable that politically majority of the people in the US and GB want to bring back the merchandise production capacity, and with it this industry occupation. So how to do it? Definitely not by economic policy of segregation and anti global trade policy. This can only bring to reduction of global wealth, with all its consequences. The solution has to come in new world wide currency order, where the anchor currency will not be a national currency, not of US, not of EU or China, but some global currency solving the Triffen dilemma problem.</p><p>But any such solution needs an US President of very different skills and vision than the last Presidents of US. Last time US had president with such skills was R. Nixon, who had the courage to disconnect the US dollar from the gold standard and prevented by this act the world monetary system from potential collapse, that existed at the time.</p><p>Let me try one prediction in this blog, if the world economic powers, with strong reserve potential currency and China will not create such a currency, the cryptocurrency community will create it.</p><p>---------</p><p>Why necessarily reserve currency creates trade deficit?</p><p>Reserve currency means, that the currency is saved in other countries, than country of its origin. It can be done by private or public entities, or even private people, who prefer to hold the reserve currency, as media of savings, because of the trust in it, compared to the local currency. By doing so, they create demand for the money itself, as if it would be commodity or item of value by itself. And the truth is the reserve currency is an item of value, because of the trust people all over the world put in it. This trust is result of long history of reserve currency origin country’s military dominance, democratic political system, free competitive market economy and unchallenged right for private property and wealth. China, even with its size of economy, (bigger economy than that of US, in terms of potential production capacity) doesn’t have a reserve currency, because it couldn’t create the trust in its sincerity in most of the above mentioned issues. Europe succeeded only partly in making the Euro a reserve currency, because of its history of world wars it initiated, and their economic consequences on Europe. Even 70 years of peace was not enough to create enough trust in Europe, to make from its currency a reserve currency comparable to US dolla. Ythe history of Europe and its composition of competing semi-sovereign states, continuous to witch-hunt its image.<br>The need for reserve currency exists, to create trust in local currencies, based on these reserves. Just as in the past precious metal reserves, like gold or silver, made the currencies trustworthy, today holding of US dollars makes local currencies trustworthy.<br>But then if there is demand for reserve currency, not as media of exchange, but as value holding item, its price, or exchange value will be influenced by this demand, without the question if exists enough additional production capacity to satisfy the value of potential demand that reserve currency promises. Then the relative prices in the country of origin of reserve currency, have to be higher than in countries who accumulate the reserve currency, that has to create surplus in trade with reserve currency origin country, to be capable to accumulate these reserves. Such a surplus can be created only if the local currency value is undervalued compared to the reserve currency. Then the other side of this surplus has to be the deficit of the reserve currency origin country.<br>And here comes my warning, such a trust can be easily destroyed by irresponsible acts of politicians, who make big mistakes like, a. making wars destructive to economy, b. budget deficits creating debts, that are not invested into the increase of potential of production capacity, c. Not fulfilling the obligation given to the holder of the reserve currency, to supply against the reserve currency the promised value in form of products, whenever demand to its fulfilment will come, d. many more issues, known and unknown, that the reserve currency promise represents in the eyes of the reserve currency holder state.<br>Irresponsible president, who acts out of urge of the moment, without understanding or without caring of the possible consequences of his acts, and proving that after all, and if the legal -political system of reserve currency origin country has no instruments to stop such a policy of one man, it can be a very good reason to undermine the trust in the reserve currency.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f882765fa947" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Deficit, National debt, Money]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@rodanogen/deficit-national-debt-money-5b12dcd38b7e?source=rss-12cc0087aebf------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5b12dcd38b7e</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Global Economics]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 11 Feb 2021 03:55:39 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-02-11T03:55:39.110Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Deficit, National debt, Money</p><p>The stability of US economy due its size, (about 25% of the world economy), is critical to the economic stability of the world.</p><p>Due to the Covid-19 rescue package, and economic policy of previous administration, <br>the year 2020 ended with a deficit of above 3.1 trillion US Dollar, and national debt of about 27 trillion US dollars. To see the more comprehensive picture, the US GDP in 2020 was about 20 trillion dollars, making the 2020 deficit 15% of the GDP.</p><p>In 2021, the projected GDP grow will be about 5%, and the GDP above 21 trillion dollars. The 2021 deficit is projected to about 2 trillion US dollar. The US public debt will increase by about 7% and the national debt is expected to grow above 30 trillion US dollars, or close to 150% of the GDP. What does it means? Anyone remember the 100% strop of the debt installed by the congress, during the presidency of Obama?</p><p>To try to answer these question, i will try to analyse the US national debt:</p><p>6 trillion are intergovernmental debts, out if it 3 trillion intergovernmental holdings, mostly reserves for social security, civil and military servant retirement payments.</p><p>7 trillion held by Federal Reserve bank,</p><p>7 trillion by foreign entities - (in July 2020, Japan owned $1.29 trillion and China $1.07 trillion of U.S. debt, which is about a third of foreign US debt holdings)</p><p>The remaining 7 trillion are subdivided as follows:</p><p>Mutual funds: $2.5 trillion</p><p>State and local governments, including their pension funds: $1.14 trillion</p><p>Private pension funds: $819 billion</p><p>Insurance companies: $244 billion</p><p>U.S. savings bonds: $150 billion (June 2020)</p><p>Other holders such as individuals, government-sponsored enterprises, brokers and dealers, banks, bank personal trusts and estates, corporate and non-corporate businesses, and other investors: $1.79 trillion.</p><p>About 80% out of the 6 trillion intergovernmental debt are reserves for government employees retirement and social security payments, that are by definition long term savings. These reserves for retirement have low liquidity, and have no significant short term impact on the economy.</p><p>The remaining US debts are of three kinds.</p><p>Federal Reserve holding of US debt, result of Quantitative Easement policy, introduced by the Federal Reserve at 2009, to cope with the economic crisis of 2008 and 2020. As a result of this policy, the total assets in the federal reserve bank grew from 1 trillion at 2008 to 4 trillion until 2019. Since the outbreak of the pandemics it reached more than 7 trillion dollars, at the end of 2020.</p><p><a href="https://fred.stlouisfed.org/graph/?g=AOn6">https://fred.stlouisfed.org/graph/?g=AOn6</a></p><p>The treasury securities purchased by the Federal Reserve bank, or US government debts are assets in the balance sheet of the Federal Reserve, controlled by the government itself. This debt has no direct influence on the economy But the liability side of these assets in the Federal Reserve balance sheet is cash money printed to finance the asset purchases on the secondary market.</p><p><a href="https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/TREAST">Assets: Securities Held Outright: U.S. Treasury Securities: All: Wednesday Level</a></p><p>This newly printed money is accumulated in the private sector, and most of it was deposited in the commercial banks accounts and other depository institutions. The depository institutions, overwhelmed by the cash, partly redeposited the available cash into federal reserve bank as excess deposits,</p><p><a href="https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/EXCSRESNS">https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/EXCSRESNS</a></p><p>The excess reserves deposited in Federal reserve bank were at 2020 about 3 trillion dollars. These excess reserves are highly liquid, so the Federal Reserve started to pay minimum interest on them, to achieve certain level of control of it.</p><p>This money only partly went to sustain aggregate demand of the economy, that collapsed due to Covid-19 epidemy. Big parts of the cash money went to public corporations, they repurchased their own shares, and/or invested into value holding assets such as, real estate, crypto currencies, gold, shares, etc. their price inflated to unprecedented hights.</p><p>More than that, Quantitative easement policy had caused a major redistribution of wealth, while those possessing non-monetary assets (company shares, real estate, private business owners, etc.) entities became richer, due to zero interest rates, while those, holding monetary assets, as bank deposits, pension funds, and employees became relatively poorer.</p><p>C. Bretton Woods, post WWII international trade agreement, made the US dollar convertibility to gold at a fixed exchange rate of $35 an ounce. The United States had the responsibility of keeping the price of gold fixed and had to adjust the supply of dollars to maintain confidence in future gold convertibility. The othrr currencirs were peged to the dollar. The West European and Japan economies, that recovered from the WWII by the early sixties, needed more international reserve currency to secure monetary liquidity and stability.</p><p>The global gold stock could not meet the world’s demand for international reserves at fixed price for gold. Consequently, the United States provided dollar reserves by running a persistent balance of payments deficit and promised to redeem those dollars for gold at $35 per ounce. However, the amount of dollar claims outstanding US began to exceed the US government’s stock of gold and the Bretton Woods system could not preced, when the foreign-held dollars exceeded the US gold stock at a fixed price. As a result, at 1971 US stoped to exchange their dollars for gold; in effect, the international monetary system turned into a fiat money system.</p><p>Even if the dollar became a fiat money, due to trust in the US economy, that was dominant at the time, it became the reserve currency, to which all the other currencies were pegged. This caused relative appreciation of the US dollar against other currencies and consequently increase in trade deficite of US.</p><p><a href="https://www.stlouisfed.org/~/media/Publications/Regional-Economist/2018/Third_Quarter_2018/lead_fig1.jpg?la=en">https://www.stlouisfed.org/~/media/Publications/Regional-Economist/2018/Third_Quarter_2018/lead_fig1.jpg?la=en</a></p><p>The new policy of Donald Trump against China seemed have done very little to the trade deficit between China and US until 2019. The deficit is result of low saving rates in the US. Increased public deficit caused by reduced taxes implemented by Trump administration didn&#39;t help to increase yge saving rate, does to reduce the trade deficit.</p><p><a href="https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/PSAVERT#0">https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/PSAVERT#0</a></p><p><a href="https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/WSAVNS#0">https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/WSAVNS#0</a></p><p>The US saving rates are historically very low if compared to China, with saving rate of about 44%, and Japan’s saving rate of close to 30%. This high saving rates of Japan and China are transferred to the US, and enables to US citizens to live with very low saving rates and high standard of living. This resulted trade deficite.</p><p>Since the outbreak of the pandemic the saving rates in USA increased dramatically from 7% to more than 30% but then it dropped back to below 15%. Even if the saving rate went through correction, they are still at a higher level, than before the pandemic outbreak. Consequently it caused sharp fall of the US trade deficit.</p><p>Is it a long term trend? Or temporary phenomenon? It is hard to predict. If the US saving rates will remain high, it will have deflationary cosequences, and either in countries as China and Japan the saving rates will decrrase, or it will cause a worldwide economic deflation, due to lack of demand.</p><p>The foreign entities are holding about 7 trillion dollars of US debt. Among the major foreign holders are countries as China with 1 trillion and Japan 1.2 trillion dollar, but also Ireland 330b, Luxembourg 270b, Cayman islands 220b, typical tax haven countries. According to a report from the Institute on Taxation and Economic Policy, 366 of the country’s 500 largest companies maintain at least 9,755 tax haven subsidiaries, where they hold over $2.6 trillion in accumulated profits. As example, Apple is at the very top of the offshore cash pile, booking $246 billion all based in Ireland. It means that out of 7 trillion foreign debts in reality only 4.4 trillion at most are held by foreign countries as reserves, while at least 2.6 trillion dollars are held by US corporations, that are subjected to their investment policy.</p><p>On the other side, in 2019 among the biggest foreign investor were save haven countries, as Ireland and Luxembourg that together invested more than 500 milliard dollars in US.</p><p><a href="https://www.statista.com/statistics/456713/leading-fdi-countries-usa/">https://www.statista.com/statistics/456713/leading-fdi-countries-usa/</a></p><p>Even more interesting are the data about the Foreign Holdings of U.S. equities and Long-Term Securities. As to June 28, 2019, the Department of the Treasury<br>Federal Reserve Bank of New York published in April 2020 list of the biggest foreign US equities holding countries. The biggest out of US equity holding states are:</p><p>Cayman Islands, holding 1.084 trillion dollar market value equity, <br>followed by United Kingdom holding 1 trillion, Canada 956 milliard, <br>Luxembourg 663 milliard,<br>Ireland 456 milliard US dollars.</p><p>Obviously, from above, at least 2 trillion dollar valued equity holdings are in reality foreign entities, many of the from US.</p><p>The consequence of the overvalued US dollar, the USA had at 2020 an annual trade deficit of about 700 milliard dollars, while China and Japan together made about 350 milliard dollar trade surplus. These two countries are also holding about 2.2 trillion dollar of the US foreign 0debt, that is half of the 4.4 trillion US dollar foreign debt mentioned above. (US has with some countries trade surplus). To make their export oriented economy more competitive, China and Japans currency exchange rate policy is keeping their currency in relation to the US dollar weak. Is this trend sustainable? Sudden shift in currency policy of a major US debt holder can cause sudden change in the relative price of the US dollar and its devaluation.</p><p>Yet devaluation of the US Dollar would increase the competitiveness of the US economy, compared to the other countries, and also dilute the real value of foreign currency reserves and other assets connected to US dollar held by the US debtors. Consequently the living standard of the US citizens, relative to other countries, will have to decrease. Reduction of investments in US assets means for net exporting countries also allocation of these reserve dollars to domestic assets, that may cause price increase in their local economies.</p><p>Observing the latest developments in countries, their economies were damaged by US policy, they tried to base their international trade on bilateral agreements, detouring the need for useage of the dollar in international commerce. China since 2008 is gradually reducing its US treasury bonds holdings. In 2021 China plans to introduce E-Yuan, a new currency, based on blockchain technology. If accepted by the public as currency used for international transactions, it may compete with the US dollar. EU is also planning to introduce it&#39;s own blockchain technology based e-currency. All these are in a way endangering the hegemony of the US dollar, as a reserve currency in the world.</p><p>This shift from US dollar to alternative currency will have consequences on the US and the world economy as well.</p><p>Conclusion,</p><p>According to the above analysis, the US national debt, even if causing several long term structural problems is far for being unsustainable. The Chinese holding of the US debt are stagnating since 2010.</p><p><a href="https://files.stlouisfed.org/files/htdocs/publications/images/uploads/2018/ES1805Fig2_20180306104955.jpg">https://files.stlouisfed.org/files/htdocs/publications/images/uploads/2018/ES1805Fig2_20180306104955.jpg</a></p><p>While new emerging economies as Mexico and Vietnam are replacing the previouse surplus countries in their role.</p><p>The deficite in the US trade balance caused several deformations in the structure of US economy. The reduction of industrial production and employees structure is one of them. In addition to the public deficite, that is negative saving rate bybits definition, the US housholds have also relatively low saving rate. This is also caused by being the dollar overvalued. These structural realities cannot be changed overnight.</p><p>US for years was the vacuum cleaner of the world overproduction capacity, mainly of the East Asian countries, but also of Europe, the oil producing countries and lately Mexico. This enabled high standart of living in the US, but also adiction to trade deficite. If US dollar would lose its value relatively to other currencies, this would cause major disruption in the surpluse economies. Would be the process of devaluation of US dollar be gradual, US, as well as the surplus countries could adopt themself to the new situation. Yet the US public deficite at levels, of 5% and more, while the GDP growth rate is half and less, can cause mistrust among the debtor holders, and search for alternative reserve currency and monetary tool. This may bring a sudden collapse to US dollar, if the change of reserve currency from dollar to some other monetary tool will not happened in international cooperation.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5b12dcd38b7e" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[What's so wrong about Trump.]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@rodanogen/whats-so-wrong-about-trump-d3bdeb9f2e80?source=rss-12cc0087aebf------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d3bdeb9f2e80</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[global-warming]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[usa]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[trump]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Global Economics]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 19 Jan 2021 08:37:59 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-01-19T08:37:59.940Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>What&#39;s so wrong about Trump.</p><p>I’m judging leaders by their record and not by what others say about them. Donald Trump is and acted as a gambler, and didn’t have consistent policy. He started economic war with China, and it was a right step, but he lost this war, because he also bullied Canada and Mexico, to change few lines in signed NAFTA contract, and achieved nothing. He tried to bully Europe and especially Germany and Japan. But then dropped the subject, but made their relations rather reserved. The Chinese dictatorship is a real threat to the world, but US can’t win the economic war against China without the US traditional allies, Europe and Japan, so he lost the war before he even started it. <br>His most significant step in US economy was tax reduction, that gave money to corporations, financed by a huge deficit, that jumped to almost 1 trillion dollars even before the Covid epidemic. Doing it he tripled the deficit that left Obama, who made a huge deficit himself, to bring the US economy to safe shore, after the disastrous 2008 economic collapse. The corporations didn’t invest the money of tax reduction into the economy, but rather into Wall Street and purchase of real estate assets. The result is unrealistic stock and real estate prices, what Trump called amazing economic achievement, but in reality it caused just a bubble, and even a bigger gap in the income between the rich and the poor. At the end this trend will blow up in our face in the future, but then already no one will remember, that Donald Trump brought it all on America, and the world, and not his replacement be it Biden or someone else. He didn’t do anything out of promised investment in infrastructure. He didn’t taxed the global corporations, who are all incorporated in tax shelter countries and pay no taxes. <br>As to international politics, by nullification of agreement Obama made, he probably caused, Iran will be eventually a nation with atomic weapons. By the way also Nataniahu is to be blamed for this mistaken policy. He achieved nothing in North Korea, except making a great joke of himself. Afghanistan almost gave into the hands of Taliban, and Iraque pushed into the hands of Iran. In my opinion, in the Middle East, by creating anti Iranian coalition, he intensified the conflict there. And what to say, Iran is definitely one of new axis of evil countries in the world, crystallising slowly in front of us, all due to Trumps no policy, characterised with inconsistency and spontaneous acts. Trump made the world a very dangerous place. <br>I could continue with his huge mistakes in internal politics, causing huge division in the American society, or his anti environmentalist politics.</p><p>As to Biden, let&#39;s give him at least 100 days, before to judge him. His acts in the past were done from very different position and perspective.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d3bdeb9f2e80" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[E-money]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@rodanogen/e-money-56cf22905382?source=rss-12cc0087aebf------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/56cf22905382</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Global Economics]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 15 Jan 2021 03:21:41 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-01-15T03:21:41.035Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>E-money</p><p>A question. What is the difference between a dollar and e-yuan? China can increase the volume of e-yuan, any time it wants?<br>Bitcon, on the other hand has fixed number of bitcoins, not controlled by anyone, this is a special feature of bitcoin. The block chain is a nice feature, but which government will give up this control to know who sold to who to check if taxes were paid?<br>EugenR: The difference is what government you trust more, the Chinese government or the US government. Printing money is not an intention but a result of economic policy. If you have a government policy, where income is less than expense, or deficit, the result is either government sector taking over the private sector, by increased interest rate, and it also means shrinkage of the economic basis that pays taxes in the future, or printing money, what is by necessasity dilution of value of the currency against other items, be it consumption items or investment items as shares, real estate, other currencies, crypto urgency, etc. That’s what is happening now in the US. US luck is, that China has no internationally recognised and usable currency, and Europe has also deficit due to Covid-19. But at the moment, the covid will be over, and Euro zone will return to its normality, what is balanced trade balance, and/or China will have an internationally functioning currency, while US will continue its policy of deficit, because it is in the genetic of US economy. Otherwise it would mean increasing taxes, or reduction of government expenses, (less wars, what is imposible), the dollar will lose its relative value.<br>Unless, unless US global corporations will be forced to bring back to US their enormous profits accumulated in tax shelter countries, and now its called foreign investments, then it is all, &quot;As if&quot;.</p><p>https://www.marketwatch.com/story/how-did-ireland-become-the-us-governments-third-largest-creditor-2017-09-20</p><p>An other question:<br>About digital currency – if the question is trust – China or the US - why China creates e-yuan instead of regular yuan? Why e-yuan is more trustworthy than yuan?</p><p>EugenR: currency is not only about trust. International reserve currency needs behind it a trustworthy payment and deposits system. And if it is possible also an absolute commitment for securing secrecy of information. This third condition, due to the anti terrorist acts, in last decades, was weakened, and the governments started to force banks to supply them information also on tax issues.<br>Yuan doesn’t have non of these attributes, or at least noone believes it has. On the other hand, Bitcoin do has all the attributes, except the security of the deposits. If someone breaks into your account it can take all your deposits, and it is irreversible and non chargeable. Except of that, if the inflation and interest rate would grow, bitcoin has no instrument to compensate you for loss of value by paying you interest. Except of it, bitcoins value is very volatele and speculative.<br>Conclusion, it depends what will be the solutions of e-yuan to all these problems i mentioned above. I would rather trust e-Euro, that is ready to be introduced next year too. Euro zone economy is comparable in size to the US and Chinese economy. It will also force the Scandinavians and some other EU countries, as Czechia and Poland to join Euro zone.<br>Libra of facebook had solution for all these problems, and was based 50% on US dollar and nothing of Chinese Yuan, what would solve the debt problem of the Dollar, but the banks and Federal Reserve didn’t like it, and Trump probably didn’t understand how important this issue is, so just let it be. So US government has no answer for these new developments, or at least i am not aware of, that it has.<br>The Swiss were the first to understand all this very well, and prepared their own version of reserve e-currency, but there is no significant economy to collect taxes behind the Swiss Frank, and no military force behind Switzerland, so if foreign governments demand information, they are forced to expose it.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=56cf22905382" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[If in previous assays i wrote about money and its connection to debt, here i would like to write…]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@rodanogen/if-in-previous-assays-i-wrote-about-money-and-its-connection-to-debt-here-i-would-like-to-write-9dce4101142b?source=rss-12cc0087aebf------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9dce4101142b</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[economic-network]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[capitalism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[social-networking]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[money]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[communism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Global Economics]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 17 May 2020 01:28:41 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-05-17T01:28:41.785Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>If in previous assays i wrote about money and its connection to debt, here i would like to write about the more fundamental issue, that lays under the mechanism of exchange of goods and services, seemingly the substance of everything the economy stands on. This more fundamental issue i would call, the “social fabric”, of every element in the network, teemed together in the economic network, where each individual decision maker and provider, knows his task, his place and his authority in relation to his adjacent co-players and colleagues. The phenomenon of economic networking is based on relation between entrepreneurs, investors, producers, sellers, intermediators, employees and employers and final consumers. The exchange of goods and services needs an intermediary agent, that scales the relative value of the products, and gives it its price. This agent is money. Other emerging property of money is its function as value keeper on timeline, without propensity to lose it&#39;s value, and as such it brings with it unlimited demand for it. This also means money is an asset, held by people and institutions, in purpose either to generate income in form of interest, or as a value holding asset, that can be easily exchanged against any item or service, without a need to give up the money at discount price. <br>The major difference between money compared to other kinds of assets is its relative liquidity, and its value stability. The phenomenon of unlimited demand for money causes accumulation of it, and adds to the unequal distribution of wealth between people.</p><p>The above described function of money creates a whole monetary system, with agents, who are safekeepers of money deposits, intermediators between borrowers and lenders, trustful payment providers. This whole monetary system is securing smooth flow of exchange between purchaser and seller of goods and services, activities in the real economy.</p><p>The real economy is about production and distribution of goods and services. Production itself is about capital invested in production facilities, row material exploited from nature or processed, and labour invested into the production. <br>Distribution is about transportation, selling spots, brands, marketing services, etc. <br>Above all this stands money, the major tool enabling flow of products in the production process, until finally reaching the customer, who is willing to pay the product its price.</p><p>This simplified description of the economic system leaves one question, what kind of money distribution will secure to most people to get the most value, while limited resources is the axiomatic fact that underlies the whole economic system.</p><p>Assuming everyone&#39;s needs are the same, seemingly the solution, to pay to anyone the same amount, seems intuitively right. The problem is, such an approach proved to be very inefficient. The Soviet experiment proved to fail. Someone may claim, this experiment was not handled correctly. It was kidnapped by the most unscrupulous politicians, as Stalin, Khrushchev and Brezhnev. But even more successful experiments, under entirely different circumstances, like Kibutz in Israel, failed to survive beyond the first and second generation of founder fathers. The demand for individual expression and creativity, as fulfillment of desire for freedom, won over the ideology of cooperation and social harmony.</p><p>The economic efficiency of the market-capital economy, based on its capacity to recruit one of the most common human attributes: greed, envy, competitiveness, and infinite whish to stockpile possessions of value holding assets. These seemingly socially negative attributes succeeded to create harmonious social economic cooperation, out of rather chaotic competition between each individual and different parts of social structure. Whereas the alternative system, based on cooperation and mutual guarantee out of altruism and ungrudging acts of readiness to share, seemingly socially positive attributes, failed.</p><p>I thought what experience could be relevant to the expected economic breakdown that will emerge from the Covid-19 pandemic. The only comparable event that came up to my mind was the collapse of the centrally managed communistic economic block.</p><p>About 30 years ago, the communistic economic system collapsed. New leaders of more than half of the world population, introduced revolutionary change in the previous economic system, from bureaucratic, centrally managed-planned economy to capitalist-market oriented economy. The crises following the collapse of the previously centrally managed network was huge. Everything that seemed valuable in the past lost its value. Huge investments in production facilities, and economic infrastructure lost their relevance, and whole cities of industrial sites stood empty, without use. Public transportation, that used to bring workers to these factories became useless. Even worse, lots of the knowledge taught, learned, became irrelevant. The social network, that enabled functioning of the previous system disappeared overnight, and many major players needed to disconnect their ties with their previous colleagues, denying their identities.</p><p>Already before its collapse, significant parts of the leaders in the so called socialistic countries, understood the failure of the socalled &quot;socialist economic system&quot;. But only very few had the freedom to learn about the alternative market economy. The previous leaders, who participated in the leading positions in the communist regime, lost their possessions and position from one day to other. New leaders, relatively young, in their twenties and thirties, with capacity to learn and adopt new ways of action and thinking became relevant. They took the leadership positions, and erased whole level of nomenklatura, mostly opportunists and very few ideologically oriented leaders, were erased from the economic scenery.</p><p>The capitalistic-market economies were just happy to fulfill the economic void that had been opened in the post communist countries. They took over the leftovers of collapsed production and distribution facilities, replaced it, remodelled it, rebuilt it. New markets, with hundreds of millions of well educated, very adaptable people, hungry for knowledge, with entrepreneur spirit, opened for risk taking, since they had very little to lose, opened to the unscrupulous, well established, western economic entities. The capitalistic system based on competitiveness, used their advantage in knowledge and available capital, transformed the previously, &quot;socialistic&quot; economy to capital-market economy within less than 20 years. If the GDP per capita with the collapse of the &quot;socialistic system&quot; of the East European countries was about 15% of the major western European economies, at 2019 it was already about 70%.</p><p>But the winners of the bipolar cold war, due to their unscrupulous drive to victory, releasing all the forces of greed and envy, giving up the blush. The had neglected the fact, that there are two sides of the capitalistic-market economy, the financial monetary side and the real economy side.Theyir focusing mostly on the financial side of the economy, leaving the real economy side to the economies, emerging from the socialistic nightmare, mainly China. Most of the industrial production moved to these countries, and most of the western economies focused on services, market developments, global corporate management, and above all financial services. This eventually brought the economic collapse of 2008, when USA needed to recycle debt, accumulated by growing foreign trade deficit, by selling financial assets to the exporting countries, among them, the main exporter to the US, China.</p><p>This policy meant, most developed countries were also the most indebted countries. On the other hand, the developing countries, mainly from the previous communistic block, to secure currency stability, needed to accumulate huge reserves of foreign currency, mainly US dollars, to secure their solvency in international transactions, mostly at times of financial crisis, became the borrowers.</p><p>Since 2008 financial crisis, the leading Western economies tried to reload their economies by nationalising the private debt, and continue to increase the volume of government deficit.</p><p>This process continued until 2020, when sudden outbreak of Covid-19 pandemic freezed the economic activity in most of the world, and caused in one hand decrease in the GDP, that means decrease in debt repayment capacity of economies deeply in depted, while in parallel to it, the governments increased substantially their deficit, that added additional increase in their debts. <br>How risky is this debt? The claim is, that Japan has much higher public debt, and it started to accumulate this debt many years before the 2008 financial crisis. But the US debt is very different from the Japanese or European debt, because large parts of it, (about one third), is external to foreign countries, mainly Japan and China, while the Japanese debt is internal debt. This means that the public debt, a financial monetary phenomenon by itself, has deep consequences as to the structure of the real economy. The default of many industries in US, the most famous, the bankruptcy of GM, few decades ago, the biggest company in the world just few dacades before, is direct result of monetary system of overvalued currency, that causes debt to foreigners.<br>----------------</p><p>Modern economy is based on social structure, where each individual, using money is an economically active human being. The very act of using money, is an economic act of participation in creating the fabric of economic network. This can be an entrepreneur, employee or employed, but also an unemployed or a pensioner, whose economic function is to be a consumer using savings, as participant in creating the aggregate demand.<br>The economy in local or global level includes, decision makers, each of them knows his unique function, his space to act, his institutive relationships to the other in cooperative network of division of labour. Everyone has his authority as to his adjacent co-players and colleagues, and who has the authority to manage and decide for him his tasks in the social-economic fabric. There are those, who&#39;s knowledge and understanding of realities is limited to their adjacent co-players, then are those with knowledge reaching far related co-players. The final level of decision makers are those, with global picture of the whole social-political-economic structure, and are in the position of global leadership.</p><p>If to try to predict the expected economic recovery from the post Covid-19 world, the closest comparable event will be the post world war, or post revolution world. <br>If we compare the post WWII economic recovering from destructed physical infrastructure by war, we find, that while West Germany and Japan miraculously recovered and within 10-15 years newly established a prosperous economy, the East block &quot;socialistic&quot; countries with the same, many cases even better starting point had failed. The major difference between these two competing economic systems was their very different economic networking structure. While in the West the networking was voluntarily based, self organised from the most local to the most corporate level, in the East it was planned and pre-decided by hierarchically organized bureaucratic structure, where networking was strictly imposed on each individual economic unit from the individual to corporate structure. When the so called &quot;socialistic economic system&quot; collapsed, very little useful economic networking remained in function, and all had to be newly build from scratch. <br>With the help of western investors and entrepreneurs, the introduction of market economy was relatively fast and successful. Yet, in Czechia as example, even 30 years later, many parts of the economy based on economic networking is in hands of foreign entities. The best example is the food retail distribution, that is all in hands of international food market chains, or small retail grocery shops on local level, entirely in hands of Vietnamese retailers, with their own supply chains, with their own capital investments, with labour force recruited among members of their own community.</p><p>Out of above, the question is, will the standstill of the economy, cause major disruption in the economic networking, or not. The answer to this question is partly in the preconditions that prevailed in global economy before the appearance of pandemics. <br>As explained above, the huge indebtedness of the most developed countries, mainly USA and Euro zone, are the basis of the reserve currency, that is fundamental for enabling international commerce and division of labour on global level. Disruptions in this monetary system can endanger the existing global economic networking. <br>The US economic policy, coordinated by president Trump, even before the outbreak of the pandemics, caused several disruptions to the system in the last years. Still the system continued to function without too big upheaval, until the outbreak of Corona virus. To secure the continuous functioning of the system needs international cooperation between the major economic powerhouses, as USA, China and Euro zone. The sustainability of monetary system, based on reserve currency depends on the trust in this monetary system. Trust is a subjective phenomenon and dependent on faith in actions of major political leaders, mainly USA. Major failure of political representatives, or any other disruption in the existing system, as withdraw from international agreements, sudden change of rules of the game, or even verbal expression of to make such a plans, can cause lose of trust among enough people, that panic will take over the system, and then the collapse will follow.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9dce4101142b" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Is Capitalism going to survive?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@rodanogen/is-capitalism-going-to-survive-d1082308ed41?source=rss-12cc0087aebf------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d1082308ed41</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[survival]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[macroeconomics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[capitalism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[economics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Global Economics]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 17 May 2020 01:19:44 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-05-17T01:19:44.140Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Is Capitalism going to survive?</p><p>It’s not enough to predict the end of liberal-capitalistic political economic system, by the way, an opinion i fully agree with, but there is a need to point out a different outcome, that will be very different from anything we can learn from the past. So let me try one such a prediction.</p><p>If in most of twenties century, the world was divided to bipolar political entities. On one hand the liberal, democratic-capitalistic political-economic system based entities, on the other hand personal freedom repressive-socialist political-economic system based entities. This division was not based on differences of opinion as to the goals of any political entity, but to the way how to create more efficient economic system, to secure wealth and well being to most of the society. At the end of the century, the capitalist system won the battle, and the repressive-socialistic system became irrelevant.</p><p>The twenty first century, new division of political entities appeared. On one hand societies with demographically stagnant societies, with critical scientific conceptual institutions, against societies with population growth and institutionalised dogmatic thinking, mostly nourished by organised religion, enforced or voluntarily accepted by the majority of the population.</p><p>Accordingly, we can put political entities as EU and China and other East Asian countries, like Japan and South Korea to societies with scientific approach, while most of the Muslim countries and Africa to societies with dogmatic approach. As to the US and with it most of subordinated South American states, it does have leading institutions with scientific approach, but their political representatives, act as representatives of financial magnates, that are disconnected from critical-scientific approaches. Russia is in similar situation, even if with a very different political system, and very different reason.</p><p>But this bipolar division of political entities, doesn&#39;t apply only to division between countries, but also to social-economic layers of the societies within the political entity. Since the major force bringing change to the contemporary human society is science and technology, they are those who participate in developing this advance, and are those who don&#39;t. This leaves minority of people, necessary to advance modern scientific-technological societies, and majority of those who are useless for this process. Since the new scientific-technological approaches will create eventually enough resources, to satisfy the needs of all the world population, if as predicted, the world population will stop to grow, most probably the small minority of leading creative people in sciences, technology, arts, politics, entrepreneurship, etc. will create systems, to satisfy the needs of majority of &quot;useless people&quot;, while manipulating their needs, to virtual entertainments, that are causing relatively limited damage to the environment.</p><p>We can see already the signs of development to this kind of world. Many young people are already spending hours in computer games, simulating virtual reality, much more attractive than the real world. I can imagine the future, as the games and technology develops, hordes of people in zombie state, living in virtual reality. It demands a strong self aware individual, to be disconnected from these games.</p><p>So if to speak about the bipolar world of the future, i would predict divisions to the majority, living in virtual reality, and those who create and manipulate this world.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d1082308ed41" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Deficit!?! does it really matter?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@rodanogen/deficit-does-it-really-matter-603aeba5dd6d?source=rss-12cc0087aebf------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/603aeba5dd6d</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[economics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[deficit]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[macroeconomics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[money]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[debt]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Global Economics]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 17 May 2020 01:15:46 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-05-17T01:15:46.318Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Deficit!?! does it really matter?</p><p>The word deficit rises with negative connotation among many politicians, economists and even ordinary people. Year 2020 will be all about deficits. The deficits will become enormous even in comparison to the already huge deficits we could observe in countries as US, Japan, Italy, etc. before the outbreak of Coronavirus. So let&#39;s try to explain the essence of this term.</p><p>Investopedia defines deficit as; an amount by which a resource, especially money, falls short of what is required. A deficit occurs when expenses exceed revenues, imports exceed exports, or liabilities exceed assets. A deficit is synonymous with shortfall or loss and is the opposite of a surplus.<br>In a deficit, the outflow of money exceeds the inflow of funds. A deficit can occur when a government, company, or individual spends more than is received in a given period, usually a year.</p><p>Reading the definition above, we have to add and clarify few issues; Deficit has to be covered by loans given by someone who is ready to lend, so the result of persistent deficit is accumulation of debt, but also savings. The debt needs a borrower but also a lender who is in cooperation with him. Someone, who creates surpluses, and is ready to use it, to cover the debt of the deficit creator. The result is, the borrower accumulates debt, and the lender accumulates savings.</p><p>Money is the most common form of debt expression, but deficit can have other than monetary forms. Dificite happens, when some entity, a person, community, business, company, country, uses, usually on temporary basis, more value than it creates, or exploits more of the disposable resources than can be renewed by natural or man made processes. Accordingly, by definition the use of all natural resources are deficit creating processes, be it raw material mined out of earth, or accumulating ecological imbalances, as accumulation of greenhouse gasses in the atmosphere or acidification of oceans.</p><p>The deficit accumulation process has some very unique features. Many times deficit becomes an addiction, and then it has tendency to increase and even inflate. The entity may run on ever growing deficit and for an outside observer it may still appear as, &quot;business as usual&quot;. Then one day, one lender refuses to give new additional credit, or refuses to revolve the existing credit, and the borrower is exposed to insolvency. Then the collapse of the entity is inevitable.</p><p>Public debt, created by governments with sovereignty to print money, are very different from all the other debtors, (let&#39;s call them private entities).</p><p>Private entities can be businesses, companies, corporations, communities, non sovereign public entities, households, or even ordinary private people.</p><p>If a private entity makes debt, it has to generate in the future enough income, to repay the debt, while sustaining its economic activity and its daily necessities.<br>Loans of a private entity can have two purposes, either to finance investments or consumption. The difference between these two is not always obvious. For example; if someone borrows a loan to purchase an apartment, this apartment can be either for self use, or to be rented to others. The rented apartment obviously will create stable income, that will help to repay the loans, while the loan of apartment for self use, has to be paid from other source of income. <br>What&#39;s obvious, debts of private entities have to be repaid, and if the entity defaults on repayment, it may end in insolvency, or in other words, no capacity to fulfil its contractual obligations.</p><p>A very different story is the debt of a governments with sovereign authority to issue currency. Here we have to emphasize the difference between countries, with sovereign right to issue unlimited amount of currency, and countries without it, as are the Eurozone countries. The Eurozone countries live in kind of anomaly, that they do have authority to manage independently their own fiscal policies, (tax collection and budget expenses,) or in other words, they can create deficits and accumulate debt, but are dependent on the Eurozone monetary policy to cover this deficit. This discrepancy caused the Greek economic crisis, when Greece accumulated unsustainable budget deficits and debts, financed by private commercial banks loans. While USA is doing the same for decades, and still it can sustain its economic policy, based on deficit without consequences, in case of Greece, it had to default on loans. ⁰But we can observe other countries, like Argentina or Russia, with their own currency, and still had to default on their debts. This needs explanation.</p><p>The following chart shows the ratio of debt to GDP of world major economies. All the major economies clearly increased their ratio of debt to GDP already before the corona virus outbreak.</p><p>Even if this process is common to all the countries, there are different kinds of debts. As to 2019, four major economic regions, US, China, Euro Zone, and Japan have very different composition of their debt. The first three economic regions are with debt of about 250% of the GDP, while Japan&#39;s debt is about 380%. While 220% of GDP of the Japanese debt, is government debt, the US government dept is about 107%, Euro zone 85%, and the Chinese government debt is less than 50%. As to nonfinancial corporate and non corporate debts China is an exception with debt of 151% out of GDP, while USA about 75%, Euro zone about 108% and Japan 102%.</p><p>Government<br>Households<br>Corporations<br>Total<br>US<br>107<br>75<br>75<br>257<br>Euro Zone<br>82<br>58<br>108<br>258<br>China <br>50<br>54<br>151<br>255<br>Japan<br>220<br>59<br>102<br>380<br>Total world</p><p>239</p><p>These differences are significant and need interpretation. As to Japanese government debt, it is result of the stimulus that started in 1990, after the collapse of the property markets and following stagnation of the economy. The government tried to prevent economic crisis with high unemployment, that would follow collapse of the financial markets. The Chinese anomaly of high non financial corporations debt started after 2008 collapse, when China introduced loose credit policy. These two government policies had deep consequences. Japan did not emerge from stagnation since 1990, and in China the over investment reduced the efficiency of the investments. One of the consequences of the lose credit policy, are the ghost cities.</p><p>Government debt, or national debt: net accumulation of the federal government&#39;s annual budget deficits. This deficit is covered by issuing government securities, or other contractual liabilities of the government to the lender. The bonds are freely traded in bond exchange market. <br>The repayment of these securities in the future will be in local currency. It means, a sovereign state, with its own currency can always repurchase this debt by &quot;printing money&quot;. This is the stage, when public debt caused by government&#39;s deficit, changes to cash money or in monetary term liquid assets. <br>Printing too much money causes necessarily decrease of currency value, in form of inflation. Inflation can be comprehensive, or specific. If there is enough production capacity potential and opened freely competing markets, there will be no inflation of currently produced ongoing processes. On the other hand, the prices of accumulated value holding assets, (shares, real estate and sometime even cryptocurrencies), will go up.</p><p><a href="https://tradingeconomics.com/country-list/government-debt-to-gdp">https://tradingeconomics.com/country-list/government-debt-to-gdp</a></p><p>What government-public debt means in practice? Japanese public debt started in 1990, and since then for 30 years only grew? Does it have impact on the real economy? It didn&#39;t cause inflation, but prevented deep unemployment and decrease in economy. Public debt, big as it can be, not necessarily brings inflation in comprehensive way, but it does create anomalies, as high property prices, or boom and bust in share prices.</p><p>Debt of private households: debt of private households is mostly in form of mortgages, leasing, credit cards debts, and overdrafts. Private households have limited capacity to accumulate debt. The mine reason for the subprime crisis of 2007-2008 were the mortgage loans given to the households, that exceeded their reimbursement capacity.</p><p>The 2008 crisis started with unsustainable debt of private households in the US, that picked up at 2007 to level of above 100% of the GDP, and since then it dropped to level of 75% of the GDP. At 2019, the other major economies household debts were between 50-60% of the GDP. The US household debts had reducing trend, and seemed to be sustainable.</p><p><a href="https://tradingeconomics.com/country-list/households-debt-to-gdp">https://tradingeconomics.com/country-list/households-debt-to-gdp</a></p><p>Debt of the non financial corporate businesses: The non financial corporate and non corporate business sector differs from country to country. Chinese corporate debt grew since 2008 to unprecedented 150% of the GDP and has still upward tendency. Yet Chinese public debt is all by local banks, and relatively low government and household debts. At time if crisis caused by defaults on corporate business debts, the government will have the capacity to bail out the banks, and nationalise this debt, as it happened in the other big economies.</p><p>The following table represents <a href="https://www.oecd-ilibrary.org/economics/non-financial-corporations-debt-to-surplus-ratio/indicator/english_dc95ffa7-en">Non-Financial corporations debt to surplus ratio</a> of leading OECD countries. The non-financial corporations debt to surplus ratio provides an indication of the capacity of non-financial corporations to meet the cost of interest and debt repayments with the operational profits generated. Debt is calculated as the sum of the following liability categories: currency and deposits, debt securities, loans, insurance, pensions and standardised guarantee schemes, and other accounts payable. Gross operating surplus (GOS) is the value added and generated by production activities after deduction of compensation of employees. The sector non-financial corporations includes all private and public enterprises that produce goods and non-financial services to the markets.</p><p>LOCATION<br>Value<br>CAN<br>7.9 <br>USA<br>7.7 <br>FRA<br>6.6 <br>GBR<br>6.5 <br>JPN<br>6.1 <br>CHE<br>5.4 <br>KOR<br>5.1 <br>AUS<br>5.0 <br>ITA<br>4.8 <br>ESP<br>4.4 <br>ISR<br>3.2 <br>MEX<br>3.2 <br>DEU<br>3.0 <br>POL<br>2.6 <br>TUR<br>2.3 <br>CZE<br>2.0</p><p><a href="https://data.oecd.org/chart/5UVG">https://data.oecd.org/chart/5UVG</a></p><p><a href="https://www.zerohedge.com/sites/default/files/images/user5/imageroot/2017/06/29/iif%20total%20debt%201.png">https://www.zerohedge.com/sites/default/files/images/user5/imageroot/2017/06/29/iif%20total%20debt%201.png</a></p><p>External debt held by foreign countries: this debt is accumulation of trade deficit with foreign countries. The trade deficit has to be balanced by foreign investments in local assets, it can be investment into government or corporate securities, equities or direct investments. If the foreign investments don&#39;t cover the trade deficit, the difference has to be financed by reserves of foreign currency the country holds. But this solution is temporary. Usually, before the reserves of foreign currency dry out, the local currency has to be devalued in relation to other currencies, that enables to balance the deficit. But devaluation may cause in some occasion side effects, very different from solving the problem of trade deficit. The first is, price increase of the imported goods and services. This may cause increase of wages and allowances, that may cause hyperinflation, with annihilating effect on the local currency value. Other side effect may be capital runoff from the country. This may cause in extreme cases default of the country on its debts, that can have devastating long term negative effect on the credibility of the country.</p><p>Since the debt in foreign currency has to be repaid in that currency, and the local government has no authority to print it, maybe the most sensitive issue about the debt is, if it is local in local currency or external in foreign currency. Countries with sovereign currencies accumulate enough reserve currency in one of the leading currencies, US dollar, Euro, or the Japanese Yen, to be able to repay the debts in foreign currency. This policy forces all the other economies, that have no reserve currency, to export more goods and services, or needs to attract foreign investments, to have capacity to repay the debt to foreign countries. This gives a big economic advantage to USA, its currency, the US dollar is the main world reserve currency, also used as currency for international financial transactions.</p><p>Gross External Debt Position of major economies</p><p>Rank<br>Country<br>($ Mil.)<br><a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Per_capita">Per capita</a><br><a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Per_capita">US dollars</a><br><a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Debt-to-GDP_ratio">% of GDP</a><br>1<br>United States<br>20,263,768<br>58,200<br>94<br>2<br>Euro area<br>16,723,186<br>37,496<br>89<br>3<br>United Kingdom<br>8,491,386<br>127,000<br>313<br>4<br>France<br>6,470,490<br>87,200<br>213<br>5<br>Germany<br>5,800,945<br>65,600<br>141<br>7<br>Japan<br>4,243,568<br>28,200<br>74<br>10<br>Italy<br>2,471,611<br>42,300<br>124<br>11<br>Spain<br>2,390,372<br>48,700<br>167<br>13<br>China<br>1,971,657<br>1,326<br>15<br>17<br>Australia<br>1,484,182<br>60,800<br>126<br>20<br>Brazil<br>697,228<br>3,200<br>30<br>24<br>India<br>543,000<br>383<br>19<br>28<br>Russia<br>468,849<br>3,700<br>28<br>29<br>South Korea<br>462,062<br>7,500<br>27<br>30<br>Mexico<br>457,956<br>3,300<br>38<br>31<br>Turkey<br>446,860<br>2,983<br>34<br>34<br>Argentina<br>283,567<br>8,280<br>66<br>38<br>Czech Republic<br>194,146<br>13,000<br>70</p><p>Source: World Bank&#39;s Quarterly External Debt Statistics SDDS, 10/17/19 update.</p><p>United States External Debt<br></p><p><br>The deficit in their essence are result of excess spending and too low rate of savings. Government and private savings are complementary and integrated in this issue. There are countries like Japan where the private savings are high and public savings with huge deficit, as contrary to it China, that has huge private debt, but very low public debt. And then you have USA, that has relatively high private and public debts. All these economies, in spite of these anomalies, functioned relatively well before the Covid-19 crisis, (full employment, stable currency and low level of inflation).</p><p>On the other hand countries, as Turkey, Russia, Argentina, India function very poorly, in spite of their relatively low debt ratio. Why is it so?</p><p>How come, USA, with its huge external deficit to foreign countries, is the provider of the main reserve currency, while Russia, Turkey, Argentina, with low external and internal debt have difficulty to sustain the stability of their financial market? And above all, in spite of relatively high US debt, its currency is stable, and even with tendency of appreciation at times of crisis.</p><p>U.S. Dollar Index</p><p><br>published by the Federal Reserve</p><p>USA is historically highly credited, while Russia, Turkey, Argentina, are not. Is it all about credibility of the country, it&#39;s legal system, its institutions, its political culture, its tolerance to others, or it is some kind of magic that no one can explain?</p><p>--------------------===============================-</p><p><a href="https://www.merics.org/en/china-monitor/chinas-corporate-debt">https://www.merics.org/en/china-monitor/chinas-corporate-debt</a></p><p>In modern monetary system, when countries government generates public deficit, it finances it by taking loans in form of treasuries, or government bonds. But when in relation to the size of the local economy, there is too high level of government deficit, it means the government is forced to issue too much securities, and they become too abundant on the financial markets. The result is reduced price for these government securities (a general term for government bonds, treasuries, notes, etc.). The government securities have face value and usually, fixed annual interest rate. If the market price of security is below it&#39;s face value, the real interest rate the purchaser will get goes up, and vice versa. But higher interest rate means also decrease of the private sector economic activity. This system causes, that when government increases its activity, without increasing its income from taxes, it causes also a parallel shrinkage of private sector activity, and the previous equilibrium balance between fiscal economic activity and monetary activity is kept in place.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=603aeba5dd6d" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>