<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Roman Ormandy on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Roman Ormandy on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@romanor?source=rss-ba469f91a8c7------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Mon, 16 Nov 2026 20:37:18 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@romanor/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Embodied Personal Assistants]]></title>
            <link>https://romanor.medium.com/embodied-personal-assistants-d2f8d0442480?source=rss-ba469f91a8c7------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d2f8d0442480</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[ai]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[neuroscience]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mobile]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[wearables]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[personal-assistant]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Roman Ormandy]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 10 Sep 2020 21:04:18 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-09-10T21:05:19.555Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/994/1*x6fq8X2ZN1ZIuVHxwo9lZg.png" /></figure><p>Mobile personal assistants (PA) should guard the customer data with their life; they should not be designed to share customer data with advertisers as they do today. Also, the vast majority of today’s PA’s such as Siri, use AI-based IP metaphor to approximate the meaning of the user actions. After 20+ years of brain and PA research, four of those with Walter Freeman, the seminal neural scientist at Berkeley, I have come to believe this metaphor does not work.</p><p>Metaphors matter; once one realizes that brains did not evolve to process information but to support intentional human behavior in novel environments, the static neural networks become less important. Instead, dynamic e-fields created by resonant populations of neurons embedded and embodied within the moving body come into focus.</p><p>Without understanding the user’s context and his intentional motor behavior, “personal assistant” with all its “symbolic models” will inevitably fail. Once, when Napoleon Bonaparte was asked for advice on how to win a battle, he answered: “You jump in and see.” He was right; the user’s intentional action within his present context is the essence of embodied thinking. Disembodied thinking, such as Tony Fauci’s Covid-19 symbolic models, can not produce real understanding.</p><p>My company, Embody Corp believes three critical ingredients are missing from the existing personal assistants, preventing them from understanding the user:</p><ol><li>AI neural networks comprised of synapses linked by slow axons are augmented in the human brain by tiny neuron oscillators forming large, resonant, and lighting fast e-fields in theta, beta, and gamma range, supporting all meaningful actions. We recently discovered an emergent hardware technology that can deliver these fields inexpensively on top of existing CMOS neurons.</li><li>To truly grasp the meaning, a personal assistant must be grounded in the embodied motor action in addition to symbols. It turns out that all wearable sensors are motor sensors, including vision and hearing sensors. AI engineers do not understand this, as can be seen from current AR/VR static displays, which perform poorly because they ignore the motor aspect of human perception, such as eye saccades. 50% of proprioceptors in the human body are in the neck and ocular muscles.</li><li>Any personal assistant must protect the privacy of valuable user memories. The best way to do that is with the internet of values, i.e., blockchain.</li></ol><p>The recent discoveries of field phenomena, such as hippocampal phase precession and sharp-wave ripples present during long term memory formation projected from the hippocampus to the frontal lobe, already play an important role in Google’s Deep Mind work. Embody Corp assistants take this approach to a whole new level. When embodied thinking is finally coupled with the emerging e-fields hardware, personal assistants capable of meaningful user understanding will become possible. They will become our trusted advisers; indeed they will become our alter egos.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d2f8d0442480" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Neural Science and AR/VR limitations]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/swlh/neural-science-and-ar-vr-limitations-23023f241887?source=rss-ba469f91a8c7------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/23023f241887</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[neuroscience]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[artificial-intelligence]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[apple]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ar]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[vr]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Roman Ormandy]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 23 Apr 2020 21:47:55 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-04-23T21:47:55.302Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/646/1*ZXL87DfoTQYECC1gG0w3-g.png" /></figure><p>Two years ago, after reading the glowing media reviews of upcoming VR headsets in virtually all tech publication, I chose to attend the GDC conference in San Francisco to check VR headsets myself. Sure enough, trade show aisles were peppered with booths sporting Microsoft HoloLense, Oculus Rift, HTC Vive, Sony Playstation VR and more.</p><p>I expected to be swept off my feet by life-like immersive experience. I was not. The dirty little secret of first-generation VR headsets is that the user experience is overhyped by the VR companies as well as by the press. I predict, that they will not be embraced by the mainstream consumers. After the initial sell-in to early adopters, VR companies will have a hard time convincing the majority of customers who expect experience exceeding that of a modern movie theater or console-style video games. No matter what anyone else tells you, resolution of Oculus Rift and pretty much all new VR headsets is inadequate. Recent Magic Leap fiasco just confirms the sad state of AR/VR product quality. I doubt Apple will do much better.</p><p>How could the engineers at Facebook and HTC as well as technical editors at respected technical publications conclude that the current experience is acceptable is beyond me. The only explanation I can come up with is that being engineers, they focused too much on the technical aspects of their problem and they paid little attention to perceptual limits of human vision.</p><p>I decided to perform a quick, back of the envelope analysis and this is what I came up with comparing a 4K TV with a VR experience: Typically, TV manufacturers recommend a 20-degree field of view (FOV) for the best viewing experience. Modern 4K TV sets offer 8M pixel resolution, which translates to about 20,000 pixels per 1 degree of FOV using both X and Y dimensions. Oculus Rift and HTC Vive have almost identical specs, both providing 2.5 M pixels for 110-degree FOV, which translates to just over 200 pixels per 1 degree i.e. 100 times less than 4K TV. Human eyes are very sensitive, most of us (with a notable exception of CNET TV editors) can easily tell the difference between HDTV and 4K TV picture on a 65-inch screen at 8 feet viewing distance, which for 4K TV’s, is not too close. VR displays are much closer still, in near proximity of our eyes, rather than in our pockets, where hapless phone displays live most of the time. But how much res VR display needs to have to deliver a satisfying experience?</p><p>To match visual acuity of the human eye VR display would need about 100,000 pixels per 1 degree FOV. So while 4K HDTV in typical viewing situation is off by a factor of 5, VR displays are off by a factor of 500. This is why the images on VR headsets seem so blurry, not even approaching the “uncanny valley” for the suspension of disbelief. This becomes even more of a problem for AR displays which by definition must blend the natural and CG images. Mike Abrash, the software architect for Oculus Rift spent a considerable amount of time during the last Facebook F8 conference to emphasize visual perception research his team is doing. Judging by their first two commercial products, I am not sure they are on the right track.</p><p>Could Oculus do better? I think they could. Palmer Luckey used to complain that no Apple computer is fast enough to recalculate pixels for Rift 3D display and only a small minority of PCs today have enough graphics horsepower to drive Rift. In my view, the solution is not to increase the static display resolution (and the needed computer power) by 100 times. Rather, we need to replace the static frame buffer with a small, dynamic foveal display. Why do I think this? Basic neural science tells us that the highest density of cones in the human retina which allows us to see the sharp details and color are within 1.5 square mm area of the retina known as the fovea, which translates to around 1 degree FOV. The rest is the peripheral vision for motion detection. When our peripheral vision detects something interesting for us to see, our finely tuned ocular muscles rotate both eyes in such a way that light rays from the object of interest fall precisely on the fovea. The motion which accomplishes this task is called a saccade and each second of our waking life (and some of our sleeping time) we make between 3–5 saccades, so our eyes get quite a workout. Just like our other senses, our eyes can not be separated from our bodies. We say that they are embodied, to emphasize the disembodied nature of computing solutions produced by engineers today.</p><p>Technology elements for the creation of such dynamic foveal displays exist today and I can imagine a number of design options. While this task is certainly challenging, it is a far more worthy approach than the present insistence of VR computer engineers on the mindless increase of resolution of static displays. This reminds me of Intel’s unsuccessful efforts some years ago to increase the clock speed of its single CPU’s beyond 4Ghz, rather than adopting parallel architectures which work so well today in Nvidia and AMD GPU’s powering VR displays. I believe that the first generation VR headset companies will ultimately pay the price for their ignorance of human visual perception.</p><p>But there is hope on the horizon. The recent emergence of foveated rendering is a small step in the right direction which alas, still keeps the expensive static display in place. The real solution is to build a moving foveal (not just foveated) display with much lower resolution, which follows our gaze and dynamically projects all its pixels solely on our retina after each saccadic motion. We could also add a second, low resolution black and white display for the peripheral vision, primarily detecting the motion of objects appearing in our field of vision as we move around our environment. Such a system would match human visual acuity using a small fraction of transistors and the energy needed for a static display. To my knowledge, not a single AR/VR headset manufacturer thought of it. Why? The answer again may lie in the engineering mentality of Silicon Valley companies focused solely on disembodied, symbolic techniques.</p><p>The foveal display is an almost trivial application of basic neural science, applied to a low-level brain structure, i.e. retina. Real bonanza lies in the application of neural science at the level of higher brain structures, such as the Superior Colliculus for sensor fusion, the hippocampus for navigation and memory, and the entorhinal cortex which accomplishes multimodal integration and motor action planning. Importantly, motor actions include the use of our muscles for the positioning of our bodily sensors in the environment in active anticipation of expected stimuli. It turns out that a large portion of the human neocortex is devoted to real time multimodal sensor/motor correlation, which is, in fact, one of the most important functions of the brain.</p><p>In summary, the golden age of AR/VR is in front of us but in order to get there, we will have to include brain science and its practitioners in our arsenal of tools, technologies, and human resources.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=23023f241887" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/swlh/neural-science-and-ar-vr-limitations-23023f241887">Neural Science and AR/VR limitations</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/swlh">The Startup</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Do Brains Actually Perform Information Processing?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/swlh/do-brains-actually-perform-information-processing-d9fce1ca7c1?source=rss-ba469f91a8c7------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d9fce1ca7c1</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[metaphor]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ai]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[neuroscience]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[brain]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Roman Ormandy]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 12 Apr 2020 00:46:09 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-04-20T03:38:12.294Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/740/1*7K7ckcrMto0uFPuxlyucVg.png" /><figcaption>“Brain as CPU” is not much better than “Brain as set of Cogwheels”</figcaption></figure><p>The vast majority of AI and neural science researchers adopted the information processing metaphor as the model for the workings of the human brain. The reason for this is not an epistemic analysis but the automatic acceptance of 400 years old Cartesian Dualism, which separates the mind from the body and places abstract symbols within the realm of the disembodied mind. The analysis of the evolution of the brain in vertebrate shows that all major structures of the mammalian brain emerged in support of the motor control of the organism, and none of them perform or are even capable of computer-style “information processing.”</p><p>Metaphors matter. Once one realizes that brains did not evolve to process information but to support motor behavior afforded by the morphology of the body, the role of static brain circuits becomes less critical and the role of dynamic e-fields created by resonant neuron populations comes into focus. The binding problem vanishes, together with the need to build representations i.e., symbolic models of the “real” world, which are presumed to exist independently of the organism’s survival needs.</p><p>I show on the example of ephapsis that the dualist paradigm is not only wrong but that it is actively impeding the progress in the understanding of the human brain. Today AI is focusing on the synaptic transmission of “symbolic messages” through a static “neural network.” Alas, the speed of synaptic links turns out to be too slow to explain observed human perception. The answer to the understanding of the human action and perception lies in a better understanding of the plethora of powerful dynamic e-fields in the brain in the alpha, beta, theta, and gamma bands, produced by the populations of billions of cortical and hippocampal neurons. The early discoveries of field phenomena, such as hippocampal phase precession or sharp-wave ripples, already play an important role in Google’s Deep Mind ML work.</p><p><strong>Problem with Dualism</strong></p><p>Dualism is replete with dichotomies such as structure vs. function, waves vs. particles, perception vs. cognition, learning vs. development, mind vs. body, etc. Scientists themselves usually object vehemently when they are labeled as dualists. Surprisingly, however, even the pioneers of embodied cognition such as the Nobel prize winner Gerald Edelman, George Lakoff, Gyorgy Buzsaki, or Walter Freeman, retain symbols and the information processing metaphor in some aspects of their work. Most AI workers just take the information processing symbolic stance for granted. A few quotes from 2008 book of Lakoff’s co-worker Jerry Feldman:</p><p><em>“Information processing is often useful because we have a rich knowledge of computing</em>….<em>Appropriate information processing perspective allows us to understand the neural basis of language and thought….The information processing stance is extremely common in cognitive science, so much so that it rarely needs to be mentioned. It is simply implicit in much of the research done….The general idea that mental connections are active neural connections is universally accepted.”</em></p><p>The number of scientists who truly abandoned the idea of representations in the brain is low. Among them is the psychologist Esther Thelen and the philosopher Merleau-Ponty. Their work is a testament that in science, like in other human endeavors, the majority is not always right.</p><p>Most cognitive scientists see cognitive development as flowing in only one direction — from percepts to concepts to language in a classical reductionist approach. Thelen sees the continuous interactions in both directions — from perception to language and from language to perception. It makes no sense to ask whether one determines the other, the entrainment is mutual. The development is the outcome of the self-organizing processes of active living systems, without the need for programming and rules. Self-organization is not magic; it occurs because of inherent non-linearities in nearly all of our physical and biological universe. In dynamic terminology then, behavioral development may be envisioned as sequences of system attractors of varying stability, evolving and dissolving over time. Pattern emerges through the cooperativity of the components alone. New forms appear during development as a series of <em>phase shifts </em>engendered by the loss of stability of current forms.</p><p>Thelen proposes that symbolic thought, like walking up and down slopes, like interpreting novel words, is emergent in activities and the products of those activities in the physical world and on us. As we act and explore our world, our actions will produce concrete physical changes in that world that we may perceive. By perceiving the products of activity and the reentrant mapping of that perceiving onto the ongoing activity from which it emerged, we create<em> external </em>symbols and discover their value. Inside our brains, there are no symbols, only the <em>meanings</em> we perceive.</p><p><em>“An example is the early emergence of spatial classification. People commonly display their knowledge of object categories by grouping objects in space, for example, putting all the balls together in one pile and all the boxes together in another pile. Thus classifying uses space symbolically (metaphorically); nearness stands for similarity, and farness stands for dissimilarity. Note that in this account, the only symbols are external: space on the table is a symbol for similarity. Perceiving, thinking, classifying, wanting, however, are not symbols; they are behaviors made manifest in the activity of a complex dynamic system.”</em></p><p>Perhaps the clearest expression of the active role of body and brain in our imaginative construction of reality comes from Merleau-Ponty. In his magnum opus, <em>Phenomenology of Perception</em>, Merleau-Ponty starts with the proclamation: “<em>We must not wonder whether we really perceive the world, we must instead say: the world is what we perceive. To seek the essence of perception is to declare that perception is, not presumed true, but defined as access to truth. All my knowledge of the world, even my scientific knowledge, is gained from my own particular point of view. The whole universe of science is built upon the world as directly experienced.” </em>It is unfortunate that modern science would like to forget this. Merleau-Ponty concludes:</p><p><em>“Perception is not based on representation. Perception is not a science of the world…. Analytical reflection knows nothing of the problem of other minds, or that of the world because it insists that with the first glimmer of consciousness, there appears in me theoretically the power of reaching some universal truth…..As long as I keep before me the idea of an absolute observer or knowledge in the absence of any viewpoint, I can never understand my situation in the world. Once I acknowledge my viewpoint, my contact with the social in the finitude of my situation is revealed to me as the starting point of all truth, including that of science”.</em></p><p><strong>Motor Grounding of Cognition</strong></p><p>The longer one studies the evolution of neural systems, the more it becomes apparent that all innovations of neural systems were tightly coupled to innovations in organism<em> motor control</em>. Lampreys, the most primitive of vertebrates, are the only fish species without a cerebellum. The reason is simple; lampreys do not have jaws, nor real vertebrae. With jaws and better muscles, modern fish not only acquired the cerebellum, but they also developed a larger cortex. The transition from an aquatic environment to terrestrial habitats afforded organisms new means of locomotion, as illustrated by an elaboration of basal ganglia during the evolutionary transition from amphibians to reptiles. Reptiles also gained better vision. The emergence of mammals was accompanied by an explosion in special senses, as well as with the arrival of the neocortex as the primary target of the basal ganglia circuitry, <em>devoted</em> to executing and inhibiting the basal ganglia-mediated control of movement. Eventually, the liberation of front limbs in primates for object manipulation resulted in the use of these limbs for meaningful, signifying social gestures in one species of primates and thus the emergence of speech. It is quite illuminating to observe the growth and interplay of sensory and motor parts of the brain in the process of vertebrate evolution:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*hSjB8HHKF9y3vzH4QF9MZg.jpeg" /></figure><p>The picture above, taken from Glenn Northcutt’s 2002 paper, shows the evolution of the brain in vertebrates. Crosshatched (<em>ch)</em> area is cortex, stippled (<em>cb) </em>area is motor cerebellum, and black (<em>ot)</em> area shows sensor optic tectum. Lowest vertebrate, lamprey, has virtually no cerebellum due to the lack of structured skeleton which cerebellum could control, but it does have a sizable optic tectum which, fed by visual stimuli from large eyes, takes over the control of lampreys lower motor actions. Optical tectum continues to form a large portion of the brain in higher vertebrates such as amphibians, bony fish, birds, which all show enlarged cerebellum due to increasingly elaborate skeletons and muscles. This is true also for mammals, where optical tectum equivalent, under the name of<em> the superior colliculus</em>, is well developed, albeit overshadowed by a large cortex and prominent basal ganglia with profuse projections in and out of the cortex. The moral of the story is that the cerebellum evolved to coordinate feedback from proprioceptors, while cortex evolved to coordinate feedback from exteroceptors.</p><p>This progression seems natural and continuous. On the other hand, it would be hard to pinpoint a time or a location of the emergence of specific brain structures devoted to “representations” in the above picture.</p><p>What about the sensor cells themselves? Yakov Vinnikov in 1982 book, <em>Evolution of Receptor Cells</em>, concluded that all sensors evolved from motor structures of 9x2+2 tubules of flagellate or ciliate cells. This includes <em>chemoreceptors </em>(taste, olfactory), <em>photoreceptors</em> (cones and rods), and <em>mechanoreceptors</em> (the lateral organ in fish, gravity, and hearing). He formulates a molecular theory of reception which combines <em>“evolution of receptive proteins transforming certain types of energy into biopotentials for the brain, with their localization in the plasma membranes forming a “maximum grip,” positioning these membranes with the greatest adequacy to the direction of the stimulus.</em>”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Qfyi-O-gvG9eWVkYgpKWJQ.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>Evolution of receptor types from the original flagellate cell</em></p><p><em>Chemoreceptors</em> are closest to their initial model of a flagellate and ciliate cell, and mobility of microvilli and flagella is of particular importance. But phylogenetic links to flagella and cilia are equally clear for <em>photoreceptors</em>. For example, in some protists, such as <em>Euglena,</em> there is a small cluster of a red pigment called <em>ocellus</em> with a paraflagelate body adjacent to it with 9x2+2 tubules. Even in vertebrates, motor activity of kinocilia can be preserved in retinomotoric phenomena in rods and cones.</p><p><strong>The Brain as a Mutual Entrainment of Multi-scale Dynamic Fields</strong></p><p>Do neurons always send messages to each other via axodendritic synaptic transmissions? There is increasing evidence that it is not the case. Jose L. Perez Velazquez et al. in his 2010 paper found that:</p><p><em>“The individual brain’s activity (MEG recordings) started to differentiate free versus forced choices in the sensory cortex about 50–60 ms after stimulus presentation, which instructed the subject to either make a free choice or to push the button indicated. It was puzzling because the time was too short for, say, information going backward from frontal or prefrontal areas to the visual cortex, which according to the literature, should take about 100 ms or more. Hence, it looks like the whole brain, or at least visual cortex in this case, already “knew” about the meaning of the symbol the subject saw, apparently without the need for PF or other areas involvement.”</em></p><p>In their 2006 paper, Freeman and Vitiello started with observation based on Freeman’s experiments in which he recorded cortical EEG waves:</p><p><em>“The dominant mechanism for neural interactions by axodendritic synaptic transmission should impose distance-dependent delays on the EEG oscillations owing to finite propagation velocities and sequential synaptic delays. It does not. Neural populations have low-velocity information and energy transfers and high velocity of spread of phase transitions.”</em></p><p>The answer to this puzzle may be provided by <em>Collective Electrodynamics </em>(which Freeman was not aware of at the time), or <em>quantum field theory</em> (QFT), both of which differ drastically from <em>quantum mechanics</em>. Freeman speculates that his observed <em>wave packets </em>act as a bridge from quantum dynamics at the atomic level through the microscopic pulse trains of neurons to macroscopic properties of large populations of neurons. <em>A wave packet </em>is a collective mode that sustains a field of neural activity. The authors propose to model wave packets with <em>Nambu-Goldstone boson wave</em> (or mode) in <em>Bose-Einstein condensates,</em> using the dissipative many-body QFT model. The field theory of many-body systems allows for phase transition by spontaneous break of symmetry (SBS) or event-related potential (ERP). SBS is always accompanied by the dynamical formation of collective waves (Nambu-Goldstone modes), that span the whole system. These ordering waves (bosons) condense in the system ground state and ordering is a result of this boson condensation. Examples of macroscopically observed patterns are phonons (elastic waves) in crystals and the magnons (spin waves) in magnets.</p><p>Freeman and Vitiello propose that the physical nature of SBS carrier wave is a dipole wave in which the 3D-rotational (electric) axis is spontaneously broken. They believe that cortical boson condensate or its wave packet may explain the rapid course of perception: how neocortex can respond to the impact of photons from a face in a crowd on a handful of retinal neurons mixed among many impulses elicited by light from the crowd. Phase transition of order from disorder emerges suddenly: the neural vapor as it were, condenses into neural droplets, the first step in recognition within a few tens of milliseconds, which is insufficient for classical models.</p><p>Boson condensate enables an orderly description of the phase transition that includes all levels of macroscopic, mesoscopic, and microscopic organization of the cerebral patterns that mediate the integration of animal with its environment. Dendritic trees may interact by ephapsis of the ionic currents from their neighbors densely packed in the neuropil. No one knows how ephaptic transmission works, but the candidate mechanism may include coupling through water dipoles, because both the intracellular and extracellular compartments are weak ionic solutions, comprised of more than 80% water, with high electrical conductivity on either side of the lipid layers. This is in good agreement with Carver Mead’s observation in Collective Electrodynamics that electric dipoles coupling is a million times stronger than the coupling of magnetic dipoles. NG theorem predicts that the quanta have zero mass, and thus they can span the whole system volume without inertia.</p><p>In his 2014 paper, <em>The Origins of the Brain Endogenous Electromagnetic Field…</em>, Colin Hales describes a potential mechanism of brain EM field as: <em>“</em>t<em>he spatial and temporal coherent action of transmembrane ion channel currents which simultaneously produce electric and magnetic fields that dominate all other field sources.</em>” Hales decided to simulate the EM field of a real, well documented hippocampal CA1 neuron, identified as D151, with the realistic dynamics of current propagation. Hales approximated the collective scalar potential with a randomly positioned set of 20,000 copper filaments, simulating ion channels. In the image below, showing part of a 25 ms simulation, one can see the time progression, with straight arrows depicting growth/shrinkage of stationary field patterns and curved arrows indicating rotating field pattern. The image shows that every time an AP is triggered, D151 bathes itself in a <em>large, rotating electric field.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/318/1*fQxzANPdhZNmyQgyug-2-Q.png" /></figure><p>Hales estimates that in the volume depicted, there are 40,000–50,000 neurons, all mutually interacting with each other in a line-of-sight manner. This result is consistent with the expectation that filamentary formalism may be responsible for EM coupling effects. It also means that fixed filament locations on a neuron can express <em>radically different field systems dependent on the relative positioning of larger compartments</em>. Field structure is thus dependent on cell morphology, i.e., context.</p><p>In real neurons, individual ion channels, by virtue of their large numbers, spread spatially over the cell surface. Through their <em>collective</em> action and production of small, highly localized and time-sequenced pulsing/reversing dipoles, they can deliver a large spatial and unified dynamic electric field and magnetic field system. Such a field system extends spatially over vast distances compared to their hosting neuron and is many orders of magnitude larger than filaments/ions themselves. This is highly suggestive of <em>membrane-spanning filamentary dipoles as the originator of the dynamic part of the endogenous EM field</em> system of neurons.</p><h4><strong>Conclusion:</strong></h4><p>Once we replace the information processing metaphor with the motor theory metaphor, the reason to form representations in the brain evaporates. In 1999 paper,<em> Binding Through Fovea</em>, Cisek, and Turgeon describe why building an internal model of the external world is not the goal of perceptual systems. “<em>Vision did not evolve to enable animals to see the world; it evolved to provide distal control of their movement in it.</em>” They describe how ventral and dorsal visual pathways cooperate in “binding” the visual percept to action. The motor system grasps whatever is fixated without a need to create a representation at all.</p><p>A.M. Liberman’s motor theory of speech claims, unlike the traditional theory, that the elements of speech, the true primitives that underlie linguistic communications are not phonemes i.e., sounds but rather, the <em>articulatory gestures </em>that generate those sounds. Rizzolatti and Arbib provide evidence for Liberman’s views. They find it in mirror neurons located in Broca’s area, which facilitate learning via imitation. Half of the proprioceptors in our body is located in the neck and the head, supporting the accurate location for vision and hearing targets.</p><p>Neuroscientist Walter Freeman described the brain as a dynamic, far from equilibrium, open system in which ephapsis augments synaptic information processing: “<em>All that brains can know has been synthesized within themselves… Every neuron participates in every experience and behavior… Perception and action result in a global amplitude-modulated pattern, as the cooperation carries the entire hemisphere from one global chaotic attractor to the next</em>”.</p><p>We can further conclude with Freeman that the biology of meaning includes the entire brain and body, with the history built by experience into bones, muscles, endocrine glands, and neural connections. <em>“Meaningful states consist of pulses and waves in the brain, the contraction of the muscles, the joint angles of the skeletal system, and the secretion of cells in the autonomic and neuroendocrine systems. The skills of athletes, dancers, and musicians, live not only in their synapses but also in their limbs, fingers, and torsos. Cognitive scientists who study the molecular basis of learning in synapses tend to overlook the fact that enlarged muscles and honed immune systems have also learned to do their jobs. The strengths of connections between the neurons and the properties of the body are continually shaped by learning and exercise throughout a lifetime.” </em>Disembodied AI systems are open to the same criticism.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d9fce1ca7c1" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/swlh/do-brains-actually-perform-information-processing-d9fce1ca7c1">Do Brains Actually Perform Information Processing?</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/swlh">The Startup</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A.I. Circuits vs. Life Fields.]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/brainchronicles/a-i-circuits-vs-life-fields-2fb530f1691?source=rss-ba469f91a8c7------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2fb530f1691</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[economics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[crypto]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ai]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[neuroscience]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Roman Ormandy]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 17 Mar 2019 23:18:14 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-04-25T10:24:51.577Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*PpS9x4qFXpvXd8eF5TUGsQ.png" /><figcaption><em>PC Neural Network ____________________A.I. View of Brain_________________Neural Science View of Brain</em></figcaption></figure><p>This article is an excerpt from my upcoming book <em>Dynamics of Life</em>. It is a bit longer and not an easy read, but perhaps worth reading to obtain an alternative view to the prevalent A.I. doctrine. On the plus side, it is easier read than my previous article on Medium, <a href="https://medium.com/datadriveninvestor/merleau-ponty-and-the-a-i-d8f1ffcfe1ba"><em>Merleau-Ponty and the A.I.</em></a><em> </em>though it is not nearly as easy read as<em> </em><a href="https://medium.com/datadriveninvestor/ai-hoax-of-the-century-8f2cb7b853a3"><em>AI, the Hoax of the Century</em></a><em> </em>:)</p><p><em>Dynamics of Life</em> goes beyond just the A.I. and the Neural science. The central idea of this book is that there are similarities between the dynamics of a population of electrons, the dynamics of a population of neurons and the dynamics of market participants. <em>They all resonate and form wave-fields,</em> rather than static hierarchical or network structures A.I. researchers love so much. New phenomena are not created by Fregean compositionality, i.e., syntax, but by the phase shift resulting from the criticality which systems enter when fields on neighboring scales mutually entrain each other.</p><p>In his critique of Cartesian dualism, Prigogine quipped that “triumph” of modern science was the elimination of time. Elimination of time also eliminated evolutionary thinking from scientific arguments. Reductionistic method, the dominant scientific principle today, reduces macro structures to micro-level elements and structure, or syntax, of their timeless composition. This introduces linear causality, which Western science is so fond of, and one-way constraints where macro level syntax completely constrains lower level micro elements. In <em>Selfish Gene</em>, Richard Dawkins proclaimed that phenotype (our bodies) exists for the benefit of genotype (our DNA) and not the other way around. This view is rather similar to the view of Keynesian economics, which sees the individual passively responding to a demand curve and macro level government monetary policies. They are both wrong. In both cases, interacting individuals constrain macro-level structure just as much as it constrains them. In the words of Austrian economist Von Mises: “<em>Common man …is like a sheep in the herd…yet the common man does choose”</em>. What Mises says is that entrainment between neighboring spatial and temporal scales is mutual. This concept is difficult to grasp for a Western mind, used to the explanation of the world in terms of linear causality such as input/output computer metaphor, often applied to human perception in the form of stimulus/reaction model. A good example is a difficulty modern linguists have with grasping the Whorfian idea of language influencing perception and much greater difficulty still of modern biologists to understand Esther Thelen’s generalization that language and perception simultaneously influence each other.</p><p>It turns out that the consequences of this mutual entrainment are far-reaching. In a Cartesian and Keynesian world, all systems strive for equilibrium. In Prigogine’s mutually entrained world, on the other hand, populations at all scales operate in a “far from the equilibrium” mode, resonate and form waves, i.e., fields, demonstrating that static structures such as AI type neural networks are insufficient for generation of intentional behavior. Frege’s compositionality principle, stating that the meaning of a complex expression is a function of the meanings of its constituents and the way in which they are combined ceases to apply to large populations at any scale. When it comes to an understanding of the brain and other complex systems, tried and proven reductionism just does not work. It did not work for Walter Freeman when he was researching neuron populations, Esther Thelen’s research of synergies in the development of human reach and walk, David McNeill’s study of the evolution of speech/gesture or for Ludwig Von Mises analysis of markets.</p><p>Once we dispense with Cartesian dualism and with its corollary concept of representations, a new paradigm emerges. It is the paradigm of the population dynamics operating on many scales of the universe, from electrons to neurons, to brains, to financial markets on a spatial scale, and from real-time behaviors to developmental and evolutionary time on a temporal scale. These boundaries are always human-made, according to our needs, i.e., they are not hard “objectively existing” boundaries. Rather, we humans select spatial and temporal scales from a continuum of <em>oscillating waves, i.e., fields</em>. For example, person-family, family-nation and nation-world form four distinct scales of social reality with three adjacent boundaries. I further argue that these interacting populations <em>mutually entrain e</em>ach other between the adjacent scales. Novel phenomena appear via phase shifts, which are fast but continuous changes, not discontinuous “digital” jumps. Thelen states that while evolution appears structured, there are no fixed structures, just dynamic assemblies, i.e., <em>wave-fields.</em></p><p>I postulate that there are clear analogies between the dynamics of a population of electrons, the dynamics of a population of neurons and the dynamics of social interaction as in financial market transactions. They all resonate and form waves-fields, rather than static hierarchical or network structures. This does not mean of course that there are no differences between electron fields and neuron fields, but it does mean that we can apply the same organizational principles to all spatial and temporal scales.</p><p>A corollary idea is that adjacent fields interact, on both spatial and temporary scales and thus they entrain each other. Reductionists see only one-way causality, from micro-to-macro direction. Physicist Brian Green in <em>The Elegant Universe</em> concludes it is only a matter of time till we have enough computing power to explain properties of tornados in terms of the interaction of electrons and quarks. However, as we add top-down leg of constraints to reductionistic bottom-up leg, we will see that it makes no sense to ask how molecule interaction or butterfly moving its wings can cause a tornado because <em>there is no linear causality between events on the scale of individual air molecules and the scale of tornados</em>. This is what Carver Mead meant when he stated that “<em>Properties of each electron depend on the state of the entire ensemble.</em>”</p><p>The fascinating question, however, is when and how does the continuous interaction of a large population of elements change its behavior and form a new, qualitatively different, macro entity, a new phenomenon. If all matter is composed of electron fields, how come that chair (or diamond lattice) seems solid to our eyes? On most places on earth water molecules usually assume their liquid form, but when they reach a certain temperature, liquid water can turn to ice or steam. How many water molecules must change their behavior before liquid turns into ice? Is this process discrete or continuous? How do electrons “jump” between orbitals? How many atoms does it take to form a molecule? How many neurons are needed to form a cortex? Is helium atom a molecule? Is lungfish still a fish? The answer, just like the question about Jerusalem, depends on whom does one ask. Scientists have difficulties seeing their role in the definition of boundaries between spatial and temporal scales. The majority of scientists do not doubt that, at least in a spatial dimension, nature <em>really is </em>divided into a myriad of scales and that they are merely discovering these objectively existing boundaries.</p><p>What are the emergent phenomena? In the last few decades, widely diverse researchers described the role of genes, CAM’s and neuromodulators in the organism development, the role of motor system in the language, and even investor decisions in the free market, not in terms of causal agents, rules or programs, as the majority of scientists still believe today, but in terms of modulators i.e. d<em>istributed control parameters</em> which are inducive to the emergence of population identity. Is it not remarkable, that all these independent writers in widely disparate fields all found the same bi-directional interaction between adjacent space-time fields? This bi-directional interaction between the scales has been described by several different names which I believe refer to the same phenomenon. ”<em>Reentrant feedback,” circular causality,” “dialectics,</em>” and “<em>autocatalysis</em>” refer to in many, albeit not all contexts, to the phenomenon I will call “<em>mutual entrainment</em>.” We will encounter this concept in many parts of this book.</p><p>Wikipedia defines entrainment as <em>1. flow of air bubbles during pouring of concrete; 2. brain waves.</em> Bubble concrete example is an interesting metaphor as air bubbles have little to say where they move since they are stuck inside liquid concrete being poured on the sidewalk. Swarming insects are also “stuck” inside the swarm and are following the overall direction of the swarm, but unlike the concrete’s air bubbles, insects have a degree of freedom which bubbles do not. Individual insects constrain swarm just as much as they constrain each other. Insects are the swarm, and at the same time, the swarm is the insects. Seemingly, a single entity forms two different phenomena at two different spatial scales. To describe it, we say that two phenomena mutually entrain each other.</p><p>Neural scientist Gyorgy Buzsaki defines the mutual entrainment as <em>“a measure of the stability of two or more oscillators that they would not have on their own. Mutual feedback is the key to entrainment of oscillators of various frequencies and stabilities. When multiple single-cell oscillators with different intrinsic frequencies are connected, they may produce a common intermediate global frequency. This frequency is not simply a linear sum of the frequencies because each neuron fires phase-locked to the global rhythm….The emergent population rhythm enslaves the behavior of individual units”</em>. This formulation is identical to that of the phenomenon described by Haken for the laser.</p><p>In effect, Buzsaki states without perhaps realizing it, that mutual entrainment of micro and macro levels forms a field. He was not alone. With an open mind and open eyes, we can see mutual entrainment on all spatial scales. Here is a short selection of quotes from researchers in different fields, all documenting the mutual entrainment between neighboring spatial scales:</p><p><strong>Electrons and Atoms </strong>— On the sub-atomic scale, Carver Mead concludes that “<em>Properties of each electron depend on the state of the entire ensemble</em>,” adding, “<em>the mechanism for initiating an atomic transition is not present in an isolated atom; it is the direct result of coupling with the rest of the universe”</em>.</p><p><strong>Bacteria and Cells</strong> — Evolutionary biologist Lynn Margulis describes how the populations of interacting bacteria deposited their separate DNA into a common nucleus and through a phase shift formed higher life form, the eukaryotic cell.</p><p><strong>Cells and Organisms.</strong> Biologist John Tyler Bonner describes phase shift from cells to organisms through primitive chemical signaling within a population of unicellular organisms such as slime mold. The “Control system” for slime mold is literally outside of bodies of the individual amoebas. Multicellular organisms exhibit mutual entrainment too. Gerald Edelman writes: “<em>As cells bind into specific collectives during ontogeny, the binding itself changes the form of the cell, by signaling back to the genome (phylogeny). The interactive cycle is established where the alteration of CAM binding alters morphology, and where changes in morphology alter CAM expressions.</em>”</p><p><strong>Neurons and Brain</strong>. Neural scientist Walter Freeman discovered the mutual entrainment in neuron populations in the brain. Instead of static structures such as those assumed in the prevailing cognitivist view of Hebbian assemblies, he sees “<em>Sensory stimulation, neuromodulators, and growth causing neurons to come together and form a mesoscopic pattern of activity. This pattern simultaneously constrains the activities of the neurons that support it.</em>”</p><p><strong>Organisms and Swarms</strong>. I have described the mutual entrainment in the movement of a swarm of insects, a school of fish and a flock of birds.<em> </em>Psychologist Kurt Lewin: <em>“The person and his environment have to be considered as one constellation of interdependent factors. Life space is a field of forces — attractors and repellers with varying strength</em>”. <em>On the temporal scale, </em>J.J. Gibson sees the mutual entrainment in the perception and action:<em> “We must perceive in order to move, but we must move in order to perceive.”</em></p><p><strong>Language and Consciousness.</strong> For a philosopher George Mead and psychologist Julian Jaynes, language emerged before the human consciousness and made the emergence of consciousness possible. For social communication, David McNeill, inspired by Vygotsky, observed: “<em>Gesture output abruptly increases between three and four years, and speech and gestures become inseparable. This is a reentrant process. First, the abundance of gesture makes dialectic more accessible. Second, dialectic itself can cause the upsurge</em>”. Psychologist Esther Thelen claims convincingly that <em>“Perception modulates language and language modulates perception. It makes no sense to ask whether one determines the other.</em>”</p><p><strong>Individuals and Societies</strong>. Even the structure of society itself is not fixed by some external factors; rather it is a dynamic process on two scales. Sociologists Berger and Luckman in Social Construction of Reality write: “<em>By playing roles, the individual participates in a social world. By internalizing these roles, the same world becomes subjectively real to him. Society is a human product, and at the same time man is a social product</em>”. Edward Bernays writes in Propaganda: “<em>The interests of the railroad and the communities through which it passes mutually interact and feed one another.</em>” John F Kennedy also weighed on this issue: “<em>Ask not what your country can do for you, ask what you can do for your country.”</em></p><p><strong>Transactions and Economies.</strong> Austrian economist Ludwig Von Mises was critical of Keynesian economists focusing solely on a macro level of government and overplaying the role of central regulators. He argues instead that: “<em>Common man …is like a sheep in the herd…yet the common man does choose. Society is not merely an interaction. It always involves men acting in cooperation with other men in order to let all participants attain their own ends.</em>” Not only would Burke agree, so do smart investors and economists. George Soros does: <em>“Not only do market participants operate with a bias, but their bias can also influence the course of events.</em>” Alan Greenspan concurs: <em>“Stock prices are not merely a leading indicator of business activity but a major contributor in that activity</em>.”</p><p>Each of the examples above describes results of a lifelong search of some of the world’s most profound thinkers for the fundamental principles of sciences, particularly the sciences of life. Taken together, they form a compelling formulation of a new research paradigm. It turns out that “fundamentals” of life are found in relations between the “elements” of life, rather than in the elements themselves.</p><h4><strong>Limits of Modularity</strong></h4><p>Although we typically interact with the nature on the scale of centimeters and meters, we have no problem extending the spatial range with a microscope to millimeters and micrometers and with a telescope to miles and light-years. While Lakoff’s “base level interaction” of folk categorization agrees rather well with scientific categories, as we move up and down the spatial scales, science increasingly takes over and creates a plethora of specialized domains which are not readily accessible to common man; physics, chemistry, biology, sociology, or astronomy.</p><p>In those domains, we listen to expert scientists accredited by specialized social institutions to be the trust bearers for the rest of us. Their words are the science itself in our eyes, and we gladly submit to their judgment. Over the centuries, these learned men divided nature into many slices, starting with subatomic particles, atoms, and molecules, to cells, organs, organisms, societies. While it is true that the neighboring science disciplines sometimes overlap, as in the discovery of DNA, it is also true that the chemistry and physics use different languages, organize different conferences and form different cultures, sometimes fiercely clashing with each other.</p><p>__________________</p><p>It is equally true that much of science is based on the reductionistic principle. Cells are comprised of molecules in specific structural configurations; molecules are comprised of specific structures of atoms; sentences are comprised of words adhering to a particular syntax, and so on. Each time someone reduces a complex phenomenon into simpler components connected with a particular structure, he/she gets awarded a prize, and we chalk up the achievement on the altar of never-ending scientific progress. But how do we decide where to make the boundaries between different levels of nature?</p><p>Humans love containers. They are everywhere we look, starting from the envelopes, mailboxes, trashcans and shipping containers which revolutionized oversea transport, to biological cells, encapsulated software modules of object-oriented programming and language container metaphors such as “He is in love,” which are fundamental to everyday speech according to George Lakoff.</p><p>Containers are also called modules, and they simplify our everyday life. They are only accessible through public, standardized interfaces, so for example mailman can deliver your mail without invading your privacy. Large software projects involving hundreds of developers would not be feasible if everyone had to track changes in everyone else’s code, instead of just a few interfaces of modules directly relevant to their work. Cognitive scientists love modularity as it allows them, just like it allows software designers, to break a complex problem into a bunch of simpler ones and link them together into an encapsulated structure using Fregean compositionality principle. Next, the scientist or the designer writes a bunch of rules to put inside of each box, and if external interfaces connecting the boxes are chosen well, the whole system works.</p><p>Fodor developed a modularity thesis into the architecture of cognition. He concluded that cognitive mechanisms that mediate visual size perception must be informationally encapsulated. His theory was widely accepted, and much empirical work has been directed to researching the modularity of human perceptual subsystems in the mature language and mature vision. Unlike Fodor, Thelen was primarily interested in the dynamics of development of cognitive functions. She admitted that “informationally encapsulated” units may emerge with learning, but she pointed out that in a live system there must be deep correspondences between modules. For example, the long necks of giraffes, which are adapted for eating, require special cardiovascular support. It is not enough that each piece does its job well; they must fit together. Nature of one piece constrains the others, and because of that, there will be developmental interactions between the modules. While the modules may seem stable at a particular time, over the developmental time the internal structure of modules, even their existence, may change as a product of interactions in the whole organism. For example, larvae may be very different from an adult organism. There can be no complete encapsulation in a developing dynamic system because there is no cognitive theorist or designer in the brain to draw a new box or write a new rule.</p><p>In social life, modularity is hard to enforce by a new law, as can be seen from the politics of immigration everywhere in today’s world. Walls Street bankers, on the other hand, striving for global order, are very keen on dissolving containers on many spatial scales, from the scale of family and tribe to the scale of nations. There are always dependencies between the modules such as the above case of giraffes neck and heart. In the case of manufactured artifacts, some years ago Consumer Report found out during annual testing of cars that an 8-year-old $20,000 Toyota was more reliable than a brand new $50,000 Mercedes, even though Mercedes components were individually more reliable than corresponding Toyota components. Japanese engineers take a more holistic, “mutually entrained” view to the design process, including living on the factory floor and frequent visits to customers.</p><p>In Thelen’s view, during the development, anything can influence anything else. In dynamic systems, order, discontinuities, and new forms emerge precisely from the complex interactions of many heterogeneous forces. Thus, the power source of human cognitive development is not located in the separate modules, but their mutual interaction.</p><p>In summary, on a macro level looking from above, we see fixed structures, particles, solids, modules, grammar, symbols, and rules. However, looking from below, they are all dynamic fields of micro-level elements. They are not hardwired; they are just temporary assemblies and swarms of interactive populations, whether they are molecules, cells, organisms or societies. Actual separation of levels is entirely the product of human imagination, a sort of useful illusion. As Anaxagoras said 2500 years ago, modules and their boundaries are all products of the human mind.</p><h4><strong>The emergence of New Phenomena</strong></h4><p>Surprisingly, most scientists think they are just discovering the objective structures “out there” in the world, rather than considering the possibility that they are actively creating these boundaries themselves, according to their own beliefs and adherence to beliefs of their colleagues via imitation. Some scientists indeed reject reductionism between these levels and argue instead that individual scales can be studied in isolation. Fodor, in particular, contends that there is nothing to gain by reducing a macro phenomenon to a micro level. He is right, but then he proceeds to argue for the autonomy of individual scales, in his case the linguistic scale. Chomsky adopted this approach and concluded that neural science could not possibly contribute to linguistics. David Marr uses the same reasoning to conclude that high-level computer vision does not need to be “reduced” to neuron level operations in the brain. The problem with this view is that it replaces reductionist boundaries with phenomena wholly isolated from each other. In my view, neither reductionism of Chomsky nor parallel modular theory of Fodor and Marr explain the emergence of new structures in nature. To come up with a better explanation, we need a more drastic change in our outlook.</p><p>It takes courage to question the accepted wisdom. Esther Thelen was brave to argue that the “<em>power of the explanation is in the dynamics of micro and macro processes, in the view from below examined from above.”</em> Thelen believes that perception and language simultaneously influence each other. Her position brings her close to Whorf but with a significant difference. In her view, language does not directly “determine” perception, but rather language and perception influence each other through continuous interaction. Using the terms of mutual entrainment, we see the language and biology as two neighboring spatial scales, where language emerged at some point out of biology via phase shift when biology reached criticality during the evolution of human brain and formed Wernicke’s and Broca’s areas in the left brain hemisphere. Similarly, in the economy, Von Mises, while still working within the dualist framework dared to reject top-down reductionism of Keynesian economic theory. Friedrich Hayek, working at the philosophy department of Chicago University, abandoned dualism and completed Mises work. Curiously, even after he earned Nobel prize for his work, School of Economics at Chicago University did not allow Hayek to teach their students within their hallowed classrooms.</p><p>Cartesian dualists explain the creation of new phenomena as a Fregean composition. They effectively reduce the macro level object to its components and rules of assembly (syntax) which encapsulate this assembly into a module. If the Fregean composition explains how we create the new machines and the new computer programs, presumably the same Fregean composition can explain how the new molecules, new cells, new organisms, new songs, new stories or new currencies are created in the same manner. But do they? Let us turn our attention to the emergence of novel organisms.</p><p>If one thinks that the brain’s internal “representations” “mirror” already existing and timeless structures in the “objective” world, one is more likely to focus on the static structures inside the brain. It is this dualism that impels the AI researchers to see the static symbols being sent as “messages” through the conduit of the static axonal network. Walter Freeman, on the other hand, focuses instead on brain function, which forms a dynamic e-field, possibly “ignited” by the static neural network, but which forms a new phenomenon, just as “real” as the neural network producing it. In Freeman’s view, live, working mammalian brain forms and maintains an ephaptic e-field, not so different from a large flock of starlings circling overhead. It is this field, rather than the underlying neural networks, which is essential to understanding the working brain. We thus arrive at a very different concept of novel phenomena, which are the product of subjective human imagination, rather than mere mirrors of “objective world structures.</p><p><strong>Swarms, Flocks, and Schools</strong></p><p>One afternoon, sitting in the garden, I noticed a large swarm of tiny flying insects. The swarm was quite visible against the background in the crisp, late afternoon light. Its motion was very intriguing, it formed a dynamic, always morphing shape, moving seemingly at random but with strange fluidity and rather beautiful grace of abstract dance. This “abstract dance” and “organic shape” was, of course, the active construction of my perception, no different the image of the rainbow I see after the rain or the reflection of a ship in the water. In each case, these “images” were actively constructed by my perception and may not exist for other people in different locations with different viewpoints. Merleau-Ponty would answer the proverbial question about whether a falling tree in the forest makes a sound when no one is there to hear it, with a categorical no.</p><p>For a few minutes the swarm was hovering there in the middle of my backyard, and then it disappeared. Now, I know that the swarm shape was composed of moving and interacting individual insects; there was no leader coordinating this undulating motion. The swarm shape was built bottom-up from a myriad of small movements of individual insects, all moving for a short time in the same direction, perhaps for mating or forming a feeding “wolfpack” or just being moved by a gust of wind. At the same time, it was clear that just as the shape of moving swarm was a result of all these interactions, so too the micro movement of individual insects was constrained by the overall macro shape of the swarm, like dancers in a crowd on a dance floor. One could say that micro and macro phenomena were <em>mutually entrained</em>, without any single central process “regulating” the behavior of swarm.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*hVx7f8cpSdSx7-oveOGAOA.jpeg" /><figcaption><em>Swarm of starlings (photograph by Neels Castillon)</em></figcaption></figure><p>This kind of behavior is not unusual for a group of animals: <em>ant swarms</em>, with individual ants communicating chemically via their antennas, <em>school of fish</em>, using sensitive lateral organ, or a <em>flock of birds</em> using vision, behave similarly. My claim is that electron fields, neuropil, organisms, and market behaviors are not that different. We do not usually think about the ephemeral temporal swarms as “real” objects, let alone “organisms.” After all, they are not tangible, they do not have a purpose, and they dissolve just as readily as they assembled into brief macro existence, much like cloud formations in a storm. It would be hard to believe that during its existence, a swarm is an animal, say like a dog. However, what if there is more to swarms than meets the eye?</p><p><strong>Slime Mold</strong></p><p>Then there is <em>slime mold </em>comprised of individual amoebas, which spend part of their life cycle in a multicellular form, bound by a sheath. When the food is abundant, individual amoebas exists as a single-celled organism and feed individually. When the food is depleted, however, some of the amoebas will emit pulsating puffs of a simple cAMP molecule to form gradient signaling to the other amoebas — the message being “come to this place.” The other amoebas move towards it and at the same time release a puff of cAMP of their own. Eventually, the population of amoebas congregates towards the center and starts moving as a single body, a multi-cellular slime mold slug. In this form, the population of amoebas is sensitive to airborne chemicals and can better detect food sources. It can readily change the shape and function of its parts and form stalks that produce fruiting bodies eventually releasing spores that become single-celled amoebas, thus completing a reproduction cycle.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*zdJ-fh3iBIWPKzhB37L73w.jpeg" /><figcaption><em>The movement of individual cells in a 2D slime mold showing the anterior cells are more active and swirl about, while the posterior cells move straight forward. The slug contains 225 amoebae (Bonner 1998)</em></figcaption></figure><p>Bonner points out that if the amoeba moves near the apical hot spot, they are stimulated to secret more cAMP creating a self-feeding, autocatalytic process. Remarkably, the gradient is maintained in the surroundings of the cells and not within the cells themselves. Thus, the motor control of the slug, its “neural system,” is literally outside of the bodies of individual amoebas. The resulting fruiting body is a sort of a “frozen swarm,” without a sharp boundary, with external gradient shaping the movement of individual amoebas.</p><p>In Donner’s view, cAMP in slime mold and chemicals surrounding ant swarms can be considered autocatalytic. The difference between slime molds and ants seems to be that the amoebae are always bound by a sheath, while the ants roam free. That is precisely why we classify slime mold as a single animal. What if this difference is, however, more one of a degree rather than one of a kind?</p><p><strong>Sea Pens</strong></p><p>Next, there are Sea pens. Sea pens live at the ocean bottom and look like beautiful underwater flowers.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/708/1*-sHiLJy0GmoV2RhK5CuwTA.jpeg" /></figure><p>Sea Pens are <em>colonies of polyps</em>. Each “individual” Sea pen is comprised of about 2000 polyps who spent about 15 years together and in the process are rather specialized to provide several important functions for the colony, like a feeding polyp, the primary polyp, and siphonozooid polyps on the stalk. Wikipedia classifies them as “colonial marine <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cnidaria">cnidarians</a> belonging to the order Pennatulacea. It seems Wikipedia has no problem in considering Sea pens regular, ordinary animals, even though they “really” are consortia of polyps.</p><p><strong>Placozoa</strong></p><p><em>Trichoplax adhaerens</em> is the best-known member of the phylum <em>Placozoa</em>, one of the earliest-diverging metazoan, i.e. multicellular phyla. Trichoplax is a small, disk-shaped animal with 1mm diameter that glides on surfaces in warm oceans to feed on algae. Like the single-celled <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amoeboid">amoebae</a>, which it superficially resembles, it continually changes its external shape. Trichoplax lacks tissues and organs; there is also no manifest body symmetry, so it is not possible to distinguish anterior from posterior or left from right. It is made up of a few thousand cells of six types in three distinct layers: dorsal epithelia cells and ventral epithelia cells, each with a single cilium, ventral gland cells, syncytial like fiber cells, lipophils, and crystal cells. Lacking sensory and muscle cells, Trichoplax moves using <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cilium">cilia</a> on its external surface.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*CD0GQQCuXmBnaG_dYURjzg.jpeg" /></figure><p>Between the two layers of cells is a liquid-filled interior space, which, except for the immediate zones of contact with the ventral and dorsal sides, is pervaded by a star-shaped fiber syncytium: a fibrous network that consists essentially of a single cell but contains numerous nuclei. The individual fibers can relax or contract and thus help determine the animals’ shape. In this way, the fiber syncytium may assume the functions of nerve and muscle tissues.</p><p>There are no neurons present but in the absence of a nervous system the animal use short chains of amino acids known as <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peptide">peptides</a> for cell communication, in a way that resembles how animals with neurons use <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neuropeptide">neuropeptides</a> for the same purpose. Individual cells contain and secrete a variety of small peptides, made up of between four and 20 amino acids, which are detected by neighboring cells. Each peptide can be used individually to send a signal to other cells, but also sequentially or together in different combinations, creating a vast number of different types of signals. This allows for relatively complex behavior such as crinkling, turning, flattening, and internal churning.</p><p><strong>Roundworms</strong></p><p>As we step up the evolutionary ladder, we progress to roundworms. <em>C. Elegans </em>are very well studied; indeed they became a sort of test bed for evolutionary biologists. C. Elegans look like “real” animals with “real” organs. Remarkably, every worm grows in essentially the same way — from a single cell, the fertilized egg, to an adult containing precisely 959 somatic cells. Out of these cells, 302 are neurons forming 8,000 synapses, but all cells form a well-defined structure of differentiated organs.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*KvwpPc9wacPEvPrwtvmwyw.jpeg" /></figure><p>The motor behavior of the worm is particularly interesting, given the animal’s fully mapped nervous system. However, the worm’s locomotion dynamics derive, not only from the neuromuscular and chemical control systems, but from mutual entrainment of internal control and the physical properties of the body, and the environment (water, dry surface) in which it moves. More on that in Chapter 7 focused on the evolution of the brain.</p><p>I presented several intermediate steps between temporary swarms and fully multicellular persistent animals. But where is the boundary between an “ephemeral” swarm and a solid, “durable” animal like a worm or a dog? Lynn Margulis is convinced that all organisms are temporary “consortia” of smaller life forms. Who decides the “proper” time scale for the form duration? On a closer look, there is a continuity where before, it seemed, were clear boundaries.</p><p>However, there is an even bigger issue here. What is the “structure” of a swarm? It certainly can not be a Fregean structure defined by the reduction of a macro-level object to its components and rules of assembly. Language sentences analyzed with Chomskian grammars or Hebbian neural networks in cognitive science are pressed into such a static network structure. But generative grammars and cognitive science approaches did not produce good working systems. In these networks, the symbolic “information” flows only in one direction, between the micro level “elements” which essentially entrain the macro level. In reality, these “swarms of life” forms are entrained in both directions, from the bottom up and from the top down, all at the same time. Freeman calls this phenomenon “circular causality.” I call it the<strong> </strong><em>“mutual entrainment.”</em></p><p><strong>Field Continuity and Boundaries</strong></p><p>Continuity of fields does not mean there are no abrupt transitions. Water, ordinarily liquid, “suddenly” changes its state into ice below the freezing point and gas above the boiling point. Electrons “suddenly” jump to a new orbital. Neural scientist Walter Freeman and physicist Carver Mead claim that these transitions, while very fast, are nevertheless continuous and can be better described as <em>phase shifts</em> of large resonating assemblies. Carver Mead does not think that electron transition is discontinuous; it only seems so to us due to self-reinforcing, non-linear nature of two small dipole resonators. Quantum jump may be fast, but it is continuous. Mead views nature as being continuous both in time and space; in his view electron is just a wave, never a particle. Quantum mechanics, universally accepted at universities today, postulates, on the other hand, that electron is simultaneously a solid particle and an electromagnetic wave. This duality is ultimately grounded in the Cartesian dualism of body and mind. Einstein never accepted this duality, and for that, he was criticized by the Copenhagen clan. Younger Schroedinger fared worse as the entire generations of young physicists were subjected to the harsh bullying tactics of Niels Bohr, Werner Heisenberg, and John Von Neumann. Not until the last year of the 20th century did Carver Mead muster the courage to notice that the emperor had no clothes:</p><p><em>“One must solemnly affirm one’s allegiance to the Quantum God before one may be admitted to the physics clan. It is my firm belief that the last seven decades of the twentieth century will be characterized in history as the dark ages of theoretical physics.”</em></p><p>Similarly to Mead, Freeman describes gamma wave packets generated in the cortex as a gas to liquid transitions of a large interacting population of resonating neurons. In their 2006 paper, Freeman and Vitiello started with observation based on Freeman’s experiments in which he recorded EEG waves:</p><p>“<em>The dominant mechanism for neural interactions by axodendritic synaptic transmission should impose distance-dependent delays on the EEG oscillations owing to finite propagation velocities and sequential synaptic delays. It does not.</em>” In plain English, this means that unlike a computer, which consists of billions of discrete, digital circuits sending bits of information to each other, human brain functions on a very different principle. It’s 200 billion neurons in neocortex considered by traditional cognitive science to be transistor-like switches, could not possibly account for the incredibly fast spread of EEG oscillations in neocortex if they were “sending” information to each other via rather slow axons in the form of an action potential.</p><p>The answer to this puzzle may be provided by quantum field theory, which is rather similar to Carver Mead’s <em>Collective Electrodynamics</em>, both of which differ drastically from the quantum mechanics. Freeman speculates that his observed wave packets act as a bridge from quantum dynamics at the atomic level through the microscopic pulse trains of neurons to macroscopic properties of large populations of neurons. The wave packet is a collective mode that sustains a field of neural activity in the form of a boson wave, i.e. Bose-Einstein condensate. This approach is radically different from the traditional view of the brain as a “digital, information processing” system. Physicist Vitiello shows that in addition to neuron fields, other examples of macroscopically observed patterns are phonons (elastic waves) in crystals and the magnons (spin waves) in magnets. Freeman and Vitiello believe that cortical boson condensate, or its wave packet, ignited with collective e-fields emanating from neuron ion channels acting like electric dipoles, may explain the rapid course of perception. Their theory explains the fact that neocortex can respond to the impact of photons from a face in a crowd on a handful of retinal neurons mixed among many impulses elicited by light reflected from the crowd. The phase transition from a disorder to an order emerges suddenly: the neural vapor as it were, condenses into neural droplets, the first step in recognition, within a few tens of milliseconds, which is insufficient for classical models. It also conforms to the decades-old dictum of Wolfgang Kohler: <em>“A theory of perception must be a field theory</em>.”</p><p>Boson condensate forms a field which enables an orderly description of phase transition that includes all levels of macroscopic, mesoscopic, and microscopic organization of the cerebral patterns that mediate the integration of animal with its environment. Microscopic levels go down to electric dipoles of a myriad of proteins, amino acid transmitters, ions and water molecules that comprise the quantum system. This hierarchical but non-modular system, extending from atoms to the whole brain and outwardly into the engagement with the environment in an action-perception cycle is the essential basis for the emergence and maintenance of meaning during the development through successful continuous interaction within the environment. For this process to work, it is crucial that neighboring micro-meso and meso-macro levels of the brain influence each other <em>bidirectionally</em> and <em>concurrently.</em></p><p>To sum up: Fregean compositionally does not work outside of Dualist theories. We already defined the mutual entrainment as a bi-directional dependency between the micro and macro levels of the same phenomenon. It is also implied by the recognition of live organisms as open systems. All animals exchange thermodynamic energy with their niche, which is called context in the case of human behavior. All phenomena are relative to the activity and interest of the observer and, like Wittgenstein’s language games, they have no hard boundaries.</p><p><strong>Criticality and Phase Shift Form New Phenomena.</strong></p><p>For a phase shift to occur, a system must reach criticality. Criticality can be seen everywhere in daily life, at all scales. We can see it in microscopic electron transitions between orbitals, and we can observe it on a macro level as water suddenly freezes at zero degrees Celsius. While temperature drop approaching zero is continuous, the behavior of water is dramatically discontinuous. Esther Thelen describes these nonlinearities, or phase changes, as highly characteristic of non-equilibrium systems. In her 1994 book, <em>A Dynamic System Approach to the Development of Cognition and Action</em>, she quotes Farmer and Packard: “<em>Adaptive behavior is an emergent property which spontaneously arises through the interaction of simple components. Whether these components are neurons, amino acids, ants, or bit strings, adaptation can only occur if the collective behavior of the whole is qualitatively different from that of the sum of the individual parts. This is precisely the definition of nonlinear</em>”.</p><p>As Prigogine noted, most theoretical systems studying change have a teleological core. This approach presumes the end state before the developmental process even began and thus negates the “arrow of time.” Both he and Thelen wanted to study systems that “<em>change over time, where novelty “emerges,” and the end state is not coded anywhere and where behavior at the macro level can, in principle be reconciled with behavior at the micro level.</em>” Their approach is different from the reductionist approaches grounded in Cartesian dualism, which seek to find the essence of a system in a unique and privileged component of that system, such as Federal Reserve in the US economy. Examples of such complex emergent systems are weather, laser beams, liquid flow patterns, slime molds, nerve impulse patterns, heart rhythms, perceptual systems or economic patterns. All these systems are “open systems,” existing in a “far from equilibrium,” yet stable states. Far from equilibrium conditions can be maintained only by the continuous flow of free energy into and out of the system. These emergent organizations are different from the elements that constitute them. Details of one such a system are described by Herman Haken, an inventor of laser: “<em>In an ordinary lamp, electrons of individual atoms make their optical transitions independently of each other, but in the laser, the electrons make their optical transitions cooperatively. Such cooperative activity can be brought about by external orders, but in the laser, there is nobody to give orders. Thus the natural cooperative behavior of the laser is an act of self-organization”</em>. Incidentally, two high priests of quantum mechanics, the physicist Niels Bohr and the computer scientist Von Neumann, argued against the possibility of the laser until the very day Townes showed them one in operation. Haken’s genius was to understand how certain collective actions of individual elements increase until they appear to dominate and govern the behavior of the whole system. Haken called these parameters “<em>order parameters</em>” as they allow to describe the system with a few collective variables, rather than by many individual elements. New patterns fall out strictly as a result of the interactions among the elements that compose the system, the constraints on the system and the energy flux. No separate “central controller” or “master plan” is needed.</p><p>As a psychologist, Esther Thelen studied learning of motor activities, i.e. how children learn to walk or grasp objects. Her discoveries dismantled the old concept of development based on pre-existing “central pattern generators” which were presumably encoded in DNA and replaced it with a novel, more dynamic approach. In her study of children’s acquisition of reaching proficiency, Thelen demonstrated that each infant acquired reaching proficiency by solving a different set of problems. She illustrated how infants limbs exhibit remarkable self-organizing patterns that emerge from the physical characteristics of bones, joints, and muscles and the energetic and metabolic characteristics of an excited baby. Thelen quotes from Kurt Lewin, an important system theorist whom we will encounter again in Chapter 7: “<em>the person and his environment have to be considered as one constellation of interdependent factors</em>,” i.e., an open system. Any physical setting acquires meaning to the individual only as a function of the state of the individual in that setting. Lewin characterizes the life space as a <em>field of forces — attractors and repellors forming a landscape </em>which our life journey both forms and traverses at the same time.</p><p>Thelen was very impressed with Haken’s concept of order parameters. <em>“What is remarkable that parameter change (temperature in this case) is entirely nonspecific to the actual behavior of the system. While attractor causing the behavior was assembled through slaving of its order parameter, there are no codes, prescriptions, schemata or programs orchestrating the nature of the attractor. In biological systems, any number of external variables can act as control parameters; for example in photosensitive animals light intensity determines locomotor vectors. The energy level is another common control parameter, as can be seen readily from the gait of horses. As horse continuously increases the speed, its gait shifts discontinuously from walk to trot, to a gallop”</em>. Oxygen gradient or gravity gradient are additional examples.</p><p>Thelen generalized her research from motor activities to all cognitive activities and, much like Merleau-Ponty proposed that symbolic thought itself is emergent in an activity and the products of those activities in the physical world and on us. In that, symbolic thought is no different from interpreting novel words or walking up and down slopes. Thelen: “<em>As we act and explore our world, our actions will produce concrete physical changes in that world that we may perceive. By perceiving the products of activity and the reentrant mapping of that perceiving onto the ongoing activity from which it emerged, we create external symbols and discover their value. Development does not unfold according to some pre-specified plan. There is no plan. Developmental change is caused by the interacting influences of heterogeneous components, which are not encapsulated modules; indeed development happens because everything affects everything else</em>”. But time-locked patterns of activity across heterogeneous components are not building “<em>representations of the world</em>” by connecting temporary contingent ideas. “<em>Indeed, we are not building representations at all</em>.”</p><p>Contrary to Thelen’s view, the overwhelming majority of cognitive scientists and AI scientists love representations, and without the slightest hesitation, they concluded that brain “must be” a larger and more complex version of digital computers invented in the second half of 20th century. This conclusion, made without any prior epistemic analysis, is simply taken for granted, as chapter xx quotes from a well known AI researcher, Jerry Feldman show rather clearly. My own experience of this happened in 2015 when I talked in person to Ilya Sutskever, a Google Brain scientist and a student of neural network guru Geoffrey Hinton. I approached Ilya at one of Stanford University VLAB meetings, attracted by his T-shirt with a large picture of “brain as a computer circuit.” This image, quite popular on the web and also shown in the middle of the picture below, was proudly displayed on Ilya’s chest, so I asked: “<em>Are you sure that brain looks like that?” — “Completely sure</em>” was Ilya’s quick answer. I did not give up: “<em>If you looked at any neural science 101 college course, you might learn that it may not be the case</em>”, receiving a quick retort again: “<em>Why would I do that? There is nothing I could learn from neural science</em>”. He then added: “<em>Let us just agree to disagree”</em> and walked away.</p><p>This reaction I knew only too well, the vast majority of computer scientists today simply assume that brain “must be” a glorified computer, much like 400 years ago Rene Descartes contemporaries assumed that brain was a clock-like mechanism, replete with spinning cogwheels found in mechanical marionettes of the day. The same mechanical metaphor can be found in the early attempts of Charles Babbage and Countess Ada Lovelace at building a “difference engine” and Alan Turing’s early effort at ENIAC, a mechanical precursor of modern digital computers. The reason this assumption comes to computer scientists so naturally is not just theoretical, even though CS curriculum at Western universities today is based on a hardcore set of Cartesian beliefs. More importantly, young computer scientists today grow up in a Heideggerian world they are “thrown” into, without having much choice in the matter. Today, this world is inhabited by the population of millions of Von Neumann’s computers, most of them built by Intel. By programming these machines daily from their childhood, computer scientists constructed, in Berger and Luckman sense, an “external” world into which they later externalized themselves. In the final step, they merged their humanly constructed world with the world of nature, reifying it into “objective reality,” forgetting that they and their fathers created it in the first place.</p><p>Is there an alternative? If the computer scientists metaphor is misleading, what is a better metaphor for our brain?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*PpS9x4qFXpvXd8eF5TUGsQ.png" /><figcaption><em>PC Neural Network ____________________A.I. View of Brain_________________Neural Science View of Brain</em></figcaption></figure><p>In the image above there is a modern neural network on the left and its crude expansion into AI view of the brain, depicted on Ilya Sutskever’s T-shirt, so irresistible to Silicon Valley culture, in the center. On the right, there are two graphs. On top, there is the <em>time graph</em> of values of the harmonic oscillator and below the same for chaotic oscillator based on Leon Chua’s nonlinear Double Scroll attractor. Both right side images illustrate not the static circuits, but the temporal, dynamic fields. I argue in this book that these fields are not only far better models for the understanding of the human brain; they are also far better models for the understanding of the modern physics, chemistry, biology, linguistics, and even the economy and culture.</p><p>In the realm of intentional human behavior, neuroscientist Walter Freeman described the brain as a dynamic, far from equilibrium, open system. “<em>All that brains can know has been synthesized within themselves… Every neuron participates in every experience and behavior… Perception and action result in global amplitude modulated pattern, as the cooperation carries the entire hemisphere from one global chaotic attractor to the next</em>”. Freeman concluded that consciousness is not an organ, i.e., some part of the brain, rather it is a higher level of self-organization. Social self-organization is an extension of the micro-meso interactions we saw between neurons and populations, and between meso-macro populations and global AM patterns. At each level, the individual retains autonomy but accepts constraint with respect to the embedding surround. <em>“In human societies, we experience empathy; we confirm our solidarity by shared gestures and words of joy, threats, and invitations to cooperate. We respond by making ourselves similar to each other using mirror neurons in the process of assimilation”</em>. George Mead would expand this assimilation into the emergence of language and its companion, self-awareness, resulting in the emergence of “I,” “me” and the world of culture. In the world of economics, Von Mises and Hayek understood this dynamics of life very well, unlike Keynesian economists, whose static systems are striving for equilibrium. Federal Reserve misguided attempts to eradicate “income inequality” will result in the inevitable crash, an equivalent of death in living systems. 21st-century economics may yet vindicate Austrian economic theory as well as Freeman’s concept of the brain as a field of forces produced by mass action of a vast population of neurons in neocortex, cerebellum and limbic system. Evolution on all scales is an ever-expanding spatial and temporal progression of dynamic fields, resonating with each other at the same micro-level scale, mutually entrained between neighboring scales and forming, via phase shift, novel, macro-level phenomena.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2fb530f1691" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/brainchronicles/a-i-circuits-vs-life-fields-2fb530f1691">A.I. Circuits vs. Life Fields.</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/brainchronicles">BrainChronicles</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[How to Build a Better Siri]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.datadriveninvestor.com/how-to-build-a-better-siri-b48aa9284882?source=rss-ba469f91a8c7------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b48aa9284882</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[business-intelligence]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[linguistics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[artificial-intelligence]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[wearables]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Roman Ormandy]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 21 Jan 2019 01:10:16 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-01-21T03:18:09.677Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><a href="http://www.track.datadriveninvestor.com/1B9E"><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/700/0*TxWqfNzcLKj4yVuB" /></a></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*9f5RZHLFi1iPaCAiFwtQtA.png" /><figcaption>Is the disembodied, logical AI really the future as we are so often told?</figcaption></figure><p>Let me start with two true stories. A few years ago I asked my phone’s assistant in Seattle: “Where is the Swedish hospital?” The answer was: “I do not know any Scandinavian restaurants around here.” Last year during a big fire near Los Gatos I asked Siri: Tell me the news about the fire near Los Gatos.” The answer: “I do not know about any movies about a fire near Los Gatos.” I am sure many readers had similar experiences. In both cases, the so-called smart assistant had no idea about the <em>intent </em>of my question and the <em>context </em>in which I asked it.</p><p>Why are these personal assistants still quite dumb after the “amazing progress” of AI in the last few years? The answer is that the AI experts and cognitive scientists are all computer scientists, with virtually no knowledge of the working human brain. Like all Cartesian dualists, they simply assume that brain is much like a computer which “accepts” the “input”, “processes symbols”, “sends messages”, “builds symbolic representations”, does some more “processing” to finally issue an “output” motor command for the body muscles to execute. For the last 50 years, these “gurus” proclaim that AI will supersede human intelligence any day now. Elon Musk exhorts “responsible scientists” to prevent the human genocide by such killer AI and warns that AI may “wipe out the mankind like a virus,” presumably about five years from now. For some reason, it is always five years they quote.</p><p>However, what if the human brain does not “process digital symbols” and what if it does not create “representations” of the “real world” at all? What if instead, the human intentional motor action preceded and enabled the perception, unlike the simple Input-Output model the AI uses? What if the language emerged not as a symbol processing technology but as the mutual entrainment of human motor and sensor systems? The human brain is inseparably linked with the body action through about 1million proprioceptors residing in muscles (most of them in the eye and neck muscles). Could it be a good idea to use a plethora of wearable sensors emerging in the marketplace and build personal assistants based not on symbol crunching CPU’s, but grounded in the human intentional motor behavior tracked and augmented by such sensors reporting in minute details and multiple modalities user intentional motor behavior in its current context?</p><p>The critical insight in creating a usable personal assistant is the realization that human cognition is embodied. Unlike Siri, Alexa, Cortana, and Google Assistant, all of which are disembodied algorithms running on supercomputers locked up somewhere in a closet, human intelligence is inseparable from our locomoting bodies, other motor behaviors and the rapidly changing environment (context). Merleau-Ponty expressed this 75 years ago: “A conventional algorithm will never express anything but nature without a man.”</p><p>Here is then the recipe for building such an assistant: Instead of starting with symbolic AI gurus such as Marvin Minsky, Ray Kurzweil, Nick Bostrom, Gary Markus, Geoffrey Hinton, Andrew Ng etc, all of whom are preaching deep learning and static neural networks, we will start with the phenomenology, linguistics, biology and the real neural science which made great strides in last few decades. When I say “real neural science”, I mean Gerald Edelman’s Nobel prize-winning work and Walter Freeman’s mass action theory grounded in population activity of 100 billion neocortex neurons and 100 trillion e-coupled ion channels, creating resonant ephaptic fields interacting at a speed of light rather than static synaptic circuits sending and receiving “symbolic messages” at a snail-like speed through axons. It turns out we only need four good researchers covering the fields above.</p><p><strong>Phenomenology: </strong>Let us start with phenomenology which is kind of like the epistemology (which AI workers skip anyway). How can we know that what we perceive is “real”? <strong>Merleau-Ponty</strong>, in <em>Phenomenology of Perception, </em>wrote: “<em>We must not wonder whether we really perceive the world, we must instead say: the world is what we perceive. To seek the essence of perception is to declare that perception is not presumed true but defined as access to truth. As long as I keep before me the idea of an absolute observer or knowledge in the absence of any viewpoint, I can never understand my situation in the world. Once I acknowledge my viewpoint, my contact with the social in the finitude of my situation is revealed to me as the starting point of all truth, including that of science</em>.<em> The whole universe of science is built upon the world as directly experienced.” </em>It is unfortunate that modern science, and in particular mathematics, would like to forget this.</p><p>Perception is not based on representation. “<em>Perception is not a science of the world. Truth does not inhabit the inner man, or more accurately, there is no inner man, man is in the world and only in the world does he know himself. When I return to myself from an excursion into the realm of dogmatic common sense of science, I find, not a source of intrinsic truth, but a subject destined to the world. Analytical reflection knows nothing of the problem of other minds, or that of the world because it insists that with the first glimmer of consciousness there appears in me theoretically the power of reaching some universal truth.” </em>To a dualist, the notion of sensation is immediate and obvious; it is an impression of the world. Merleau-Ponty disputes this and claims that traditional analyses missed the phenomenon of perception.<em> Elementary perception is already charged with meaning, even a perception of a pure white patch on a dark background.”</em></p><p>Our <em>perception of an object has already been conceived before the sensory input</em>, by the <em>action taken to obtain the input</em>.<strong> </strong>The structuring is done by repeated cycles of action and perception that Merleau-Ponty calls the <em>intentional arc,</em> which constitutes the effort to achieve maximum grip of our sensors. The self adapts to an object and learns about it by shaping the body, (for example by forming hand gesture to grip a cup for drinking), and also by reshaping or repositioning the object. This leads directly to the A.M. Liberman’s <em>Motor Theory of Language</em>.</p><p><strong>Motor Theory of Language.</strong> The traditional theory of speech identifies sounds (phonemes) as the primitives that are exchanged when linguistic communication occurs. <strong>A.M. Liberman</strong> motor theory of speech claims on the other hand that the phonetic elements of speech, the true primitives that underlie linguistic communications are not sounds but rather, the <em>articulatory gestures</em> that generate those sounds.</p><p>The traditional theory of speech cannot explain how production and perception developed together in evolution. George H. Mead’s requirement for <em>parity</em> means that language communication can succeed only if two parties have a common understanding of what counts — what counts for the speaker, must count for the listener. From the motor theory point of view, the speaker produces gestures that are managed by machinery that evolved in connection with a specifically communicative (linguistic) function, from which it follows that gestures are phonetic by their very nature. There is no need to appeal to cognitive connections between an initial auditory representation and some more abstract phonetic unit to which it is somehow linked (by the process of binding) because the initial representation is already phonetic.</p><p>In two-way communication, where speaker and listener exchange roles, motor theory stipulates that parties conduct their business in the common currency of phonetic gestures; the gesture that is the unit of production for the speaker is the unit of perception for the listener. In contrast, the traditional theory needs to explain how representations of the speaker (motor) and representations of the listener (auditory) which are not alike, marched through evolutionary development in perfect step. The motor theory holds that the primary representations of speaker and listener are precisely the same; accordingly, a change in one is inevitably mirrored by the same changes in the other. Evolution came up with a distinct phonetic module, not in the higher reaches of cognitive machinery, but down among the “nuts and bolts” of action and perception, i.e., motor structures.</p><p><strong>Neural Science and Motor Action.</strong> <strong>Rizzolatti</strong> and <strong>Arbib </strong>in <em>Language within our Grasp</em> provide the empirical evidence for the motor theory. They find it in mirror neurons located in Broca’s area. These neurons, they claim, represent the link between sender and receiver that Liberman postulated in his theory. Broca’s area is most commonly thought of as an area for speech. PET data indicate that Broca’s area might also become active during the execution of hand or arm movement, during mental imagery of hand grasping movement and during tasks involving hand mental rotations. They find further evidence indicating, that individuals recognize actions made by others because the neural pattern elicited in their pre-motor areas during action observation is similar to that which is internally generated to produce that action.</p><p>In the case of action observation, there is a robust spinal cord inhibition that selectively blocks motoneurons involved in the observed action execution. Sometimes, however, for example, when the observed action is of particular interest, the premotor system will allow a brief prefix of the movement to be exhibited. This prefix will be recognized by the other individual. This fact will affect both the actor and the observer. The actor will recognize an intention in the observer, and the observer will notice that its involuntary response affects the behavior of the actor. When this occurs, a primitive dialogue between observer and actor is established. This dialogue forms the core of the language.</p><p>Rizzolatti and Arbib argue that (1) the mimetic capability inherent to the area F5 and Broca’s area had the potential to produce various types of closed systems related to the different kinds of motor fields present in that area (hand, mouth, and larynx); (2) the first open system to evolve en route to human speech was a manual gestural system that exploited the observation and execution matching system described earlier; and (3) that this paved the way for the evolution of the open vocalization system we know as speech. Congruent with this view is the observation by Donald that mimetic capacity, a natural extension of action recognition, is central to human culture such as dances, games and tribal rituals and that the evolution of this capacity was a necessary precursor to the development of language. It has been shown that a newborn can mimic her mother’s facial expression as early as an hour after birth.</p><p>Rizzolatti and Arbib speculate that at a particular stage, a brachio-manual communication system evolved, complementing the oro-facial one. They argue further that their findings contradict Noam Chomsky’s idea of universal grammar and that human language evolved from a primary mechanism that was not originally related to communication; the <em>capacity to recognize actions</em>.</p><p><strong>Psychology and Motor Action. David McNeill</strong> in <em>Gesture and Thought, </em>argues an even stronger case: that language, regardless of how advanced, is never separable from the gesture. Gesture, language, and thought are seen as different sides of a single mental/brain/action process. Speech and gesture are two modalities, performing their own function, but supporting one another.</p><p>The gesture is not a behavioral fossil but an indispensable part of our current ongoing system of language. Mirror neurons closed Mead’s loop and enabled humans to respond to one’s own gestures as if they belonged to someone else. This produces social framing of gestures even if they are invisible, as in case of a blind person gesturing when talking on the phone. This reconfiguration of brain provided thought-language-hand circuitry and a way for language to co-opt the machinery of Broca’s area. Evolution selected the ability to combine speech and gesture under a meaning, and speech and gesture emerged in evolution together. Just as speech could not have evolved without gesture, the gesture could not have evolved without speech.</p><p>A gesture is not an external accompaniment of speech. It is not a “representation” of meaning. Instead, meaning “inhabits” it. The actual motion of the gesture itself is a dimension of meaning. The Heideggerian echo in this statement is not accidental; the gesture is not representational, it is a form of cognitive being itself. To the speaker, gestures and speech are not “messages” or communications, but a way of cognitively existing at the moment of speaking. To have your thoughts come to exist in the form of a sign is to cause them to exist in a context of shared practical activities (including shared breathing). A sign signifies only for those who “dwell” in the context. Heidegger spoke of language as “house of being,” Merleau-Ponty spoke of “inhabiting” language and Wittgenstein’s spoke of “meaning as “use”; they all echo the same idea.</p><p>McNeill concludes that language has a double character of motor action and vocal speech, joined into a single process because evolution selected the ability to combine speech and gesture. This mutually entrained<em> joint action of speech and gesture</em> was the critical adaptation and was selected as the core of the language. What evolved was a new way of acting. Going further still, psychologist Esther Thelen claims that there is in principle no difference between the process engendering walking, reaching, and looking for hidden objects and those resulting in mathematics and poetry. But that is another story.</p><p>Our story is about how to make personal assistants which work. The recipe is rather simple and focuses on the embodied motor action captured by wearable sensors, rather than disembodied symbol processing. Do I worry that some bright guys at Google, Apple or in some Silicon Valley startup can take this concept and run with it? The answer is I do, but only a little. AI researchers are deeply indoctrinated with Cartesian Dualism and, much like the US citizens chanting “Russians, Russians,” under the influence of the mass media, they are trapped in the world of abstract computations and symbols their education thoroughly immersed them in. Both groups are thinking within the box, a straitjacket imposed on them by the prevalent culture.</p><p>One more point. All present personal assistants gather vast amounts of confidential user info and resell it to the outside parties without the user permission or even knowledge. Worse, they provide it to political parties and the government to be used in unconstitutional mass surveillance. The government may protect Google and Apple monopoly in exchange, but this protection created a conflict of interest and already slowed down the pace of innovation at Google and Apple. It will not last. In my opinion, the private personal data is a property of the user, and true personal assistant should guard user memories against any prying eyes at all cost. As it happens, the technology to protect user privacy emerged just in time in the form of the blockchain, bitcoin, and related crypto technologies. The future of true personal assistants is bright.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fupscri.be%2Fb2a0d6%3Fas_embed%3Dtrue&amp;dntp=1&amp;display_name=Upscribe&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fupscri.be%2Fb2a0d6%2F&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=upscri" width="800" height="400" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/0707f5c806284d01a4a13c7b13a91ce3/href">https://medium.com/media/0707f5c806284d01a4a13c7b13a91ce3/href</a></iframe><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b48aa9284882" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.datadriveninvestor.com/how-to-build-a-better-siri-b48aa9284882">How to Build a Better Siri</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.datadriveninvestor.com/">DataDrivenInvestor</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Merleau-Ponty and the A.I.]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.datadriveninvestor.com/merleau-ponty-and-the-a-i-d8f1ffcfe1ba?source=rss-ba469f91a8c7------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d8f1ffcfe1ba</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[biology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ai]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[wearables]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Roman Ormandy]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 07 Jan 2019 00:17:14 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-01-08T12:55:27.472Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><a href="http://www.track.datadriveninvestor.com/1B9E"><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/700/0*Gizxt9erAwMNir4b" /></a></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*LyO7szt97Zist5vmkunRoA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Merleau-Ponty: “A conventional algorithm will never express anything but nature without man”.</figcaption></figure><p>For some time now, I believe that virtually all A.I. researchers and cognitive scientists, being Cartesian Dualists, fundamentally misunderstand the workings of the human brain. In 2017 I wrote a well-received Medium article called <a href="https://medium.com/@Romanor/ai-hoax-of-the-century-8f2cb7b853a3"><em>AI, the Hoax of the Century</em></a>. I am presently working on a book called <em>The Dynamics of Life,</em> which is heavily influenced by Merleau-Ponty’s <em>Phenomenology of Perception</em>. It turns out that his 75-year-old work has plenty to say about the modern A.I. ambitions and limits. Warning, what follows is not an easy read:</p><p>Martin Heidegger’s follower, Merleau-Ponty, investigated the biological foundation of a social experience by using clinical data about syndromes of brain damage in patients during the WWI, compiled by German neurologists Goldstein and Gelb. This data provided him with a window into the healthy unity of human skills from how that unity breaks down in patients with injured brains. Repeatedly, the data showed that localized brain damage in a variety of brain regions caused patients to exhibit generalized impairment across a wide variety of behaviors. An example was the loss by a patient of the ability to point to an object, which is a social action, intended to inform someone else while retaining the ability to grasp it, which is the utilitarian assimilation by the body to some part of the world.</p><p>From this evidence, Merleau-Ponty hypothesized that <em>perception is a focus in the structure of learned behavior, which becomes explicit as an organized multi-sensory perception when the organism applies its skills by acting into the world</em>. He concluded that human mental activities shape themselves by adapting bodily movements towards biological goals in everyday tasks. When asked once to sum up his views he said:<em> “To perceive is to render oneself present to something through the body.” </em>He makes the distinction between the horizon of the world outside and the horizon of perception within. This conforms to Aquinas and Maturana’s approach. His emphasis on the motor grounding of all aspects of cognition including the language brings him very close to A.M. Liberman’s motor theory of language.</p><p>In his magnum opus, <em>Phenomenology of Perception,</em> Merleau-Ponty starts with the proclamation:<em> We must not wonder whether we really perceive the world, we must instead say: the world is what we perceive. To seek the essence of perception is to declare that perception is, not presumed true, but defined as access to truth.</em></p><p><em>All my knowledge of the world, even my scientific knowledge, is gained from my own particular point of view. The whole universe of science is built upon the world as directly experienced.</em> It is unfortunate that modern science, and in particular mathematics, would like to forget this. <em>Scientific points of view, according to which my existence is a moment of the world’s, are always both naive and at the same time dishonest, because they take for granted, without explicitly mentioning it, the other point of view, namely that of consciousness, through which from the outset a world forms itself around me and begins to exist for me. To return to things themselves is to return to that world which precedes knowledge, of which knowledge always speaks, and in relation to which every scientific schematization is an abstract and derivative sign language, as is geography in relation to the country-side in which we have to learn beforehand what a forest, a prairie or a river is.</em></p><p><em>This move is distinct from the idealist return to consciousness, and the demand for a pure description excludes equally the procedure of analytical reflection on the one hand, and that of scientific explanation on the other. Descartes and particularly Kant detached the subject, or consciousness, by showing that I could not possibly apprehend anything as existing unless I first of all experienced myself as existing in the act of apprehending it. They presented consciousness, the absolute certainty of my existence for myself, as the condition of there being anything at all.</em></p><p>Perception is not based on representation. <em>Perception is not a science of the world. Truth does not inhabit the inner man, or more accurately, there is no inner man, man is in the world and only in the world does he know himself. When I return to myself from an excursion into the realm of dogmatic common sense of science, I find, not a source of intrinsic truth, but a subject destined to the world.</em></p><p><em>Analytical reflection knows nothing of the problem of other minds, or that of the world because it insists that with the first glimmer of consciousness there appears in me theoretically the power of reaching some universal truth.</em> This is close to Esther Thelen’s claim that both information processing and connectionism make a mistake in focusing on the end state of a mature organism, as they both seem to know where the development is inevitably going. They presuppose what it is that they try to explain.</p><p>To a dualist, the notion of sensation is immediate and obvious; it is an impression of the world. Merleau-Ponty disputes this and claims that traditional analyses missed the phenomenon of perception. Elementary perception is already charged with meaning, even a perception of a pure white patch on a dark background. The perceptual “something” is always in the middle of something else; it always forms part of a “field.” A homogeneous area offering nothing cannot be given to perception, an isolated datum of perception is inconceivable.</p><p>Merleau-Ponty gives up any attempt to define sensation as the pure impression. Color can be said to be there only if it occupies an area of certain size, and analysis discovers in each quality meanings which reside in it. If perception was an impression of the world, we would perceive a segment of the world precisely delimited, surrounded by the zone of blackness. We experience nothing of the sort. We shall never, using the world as our starting point understand what a field of vision is.</p><p>The two straight lines in Muller-Lyer’s optical illusion are neither of equal or unequal length; it is only in the objective world that this question arises.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/424/1*EuG0UhvjgfUpid0SSb4euw.png" /></figure><p>The visual field is that strange zone in which contradictory notions jostle each other because the objects — the straight lines in of Muller-Lyer, are not in that field, assigned to realm of being, in which a comparison would be possible, but each is taken in its private context as if it did not belong to the same universe as the other.</p><p>Sensory apparatus is not fitted for the role of “transmitter.” Non-cortical lesions of the apparatus of touch no doubt lessen the concentration of points sensitive to heat and cold, or pressure but, if to the injured system, a sufficiently large stimulus be applied, the specific sensation reappear. The raising of the thresholds is compensated by a more vigorous movement of the hand. Even at this initial stage of sensibility, working together on the part of partial stimuli and collaboration of the sensory with the motor system which keeps sensation constant and rules out any definition of the nervous process as <em>a simple transmission of a given message.</em></p><p>Perception must be understood as a process of integration in which the text of the external world is not so much copied as composed. So if we try to seize “sensation” within the perspective of the bodily phenomena which pave the way to it, we find not a psychic individual but a formation already bound up with a larger whole, already endowed with meaning. A.M. Liberman’s phonetic gestures are a prime example.</p><p>When I say that I have before me a red patch, the meaning of the word patch is provided by previous experiences which have taught me the use of the word. “Good form” is not brought about because it would be good in itself in some metaphysical heaven; it is good form because it comes into being in our experience.</p><p>Cartesian Dualists take the objective world as the object of their analysis. They keep their distance in relation to perception. This can be seen from the “constancy” hypothesis or the priority of the objective world. The constancy hypothesis forces us to admit that “normal sensations” are already there. A function which reveals them, like a searchlight showing objects pre-existing in the darkness, is called attention. Attention then creates nothing; it strikes up like sparks just those perceptions or ideas capable of providing an answer to the questions which I was asking. But in a consciousness which constitutes everything, attention remains abstract because it has no work to perform.</p><p>In Merleau-Ponty’s view, expressed in section 3 of the Introduction called “<em>Attention” and “Judgement</em>,” attention, first of all, presupposes a transformation of the mental field, a new way for consciousness to be present to its objects. An example is locating a point of my body which is being touched. Certain disorders, having their origin in the central nervous system make that identification impossible and reveal the profound workings of consciousness. The primary condition of the disorder is a disintegration of the sensory field which no longer remains stable while the subject perceives, but moves in response to the exploratory movements and shrinks while it is being probed. A vaguely located spot reveals a pre-objective space where there is no univocal position because no spatial framework persists from one perception to another. The first operation of attention is, then, to create for itself a field which can be surveyed and in which movements of the exploratory organ or elaboration of thought are possible.</p><p>It has long been known that a nine-month-old infant can distinguish only globally the “colored” and “colorless” areas of vision. Thereafter, “colored” areas are distinguished as “warm” and “cold” shades, and finally, the specific colors are arrived at. However, psychologists are convinced that nine-month-old child must be able to “see” the green color, it only fails to pay attention and apprehend its own phenomena. Merleau-Ponty on the other hand, sees with Koehler the first perception of color as a change of the structure of consciousness, the establishment of a new dimension of experience.</p><p>To pay attention then is not merely to elucidate further pre-existing “hidden” data, it is to bring about a new articulation of it by taking it, as Koffka did, as <em>figures.</em> Performed as <em>horizons</em>, they constitute in reality new regions in the whole world. Attention is not an association of images, but the active constitution of a new object. The passage from the indeterminate to determinate, this recasting at the very moment of its own history in the unity of the new meaning, is the thought itself. The work of mind exists only in the act.</p><p>If the moon on the horizon when I look at it through a telescope or a cardboard tube looks no bigger than at the zenith, the conclusion can not be drawn that in free vision its appearance is equally invariable, as dualism would have it. Dualists believe this because they are not concerned with what we see, but what we ought to see according to the retinal image. However, when we look naturally, the various parts of the field interact and <em>motivate</em> this large moon on the horizon.</p><p><em>Judgment</em> (reason) is often introduced as <em>what sensation lacks to make perception possible</em>. Dualist see reason as delineating the structure of perception by joining up the points of sensations. They can eliminate all sensible properties of an object and still keep the object as physical “matter,” while for perception there is nothing left. Once dualists define the vision as the possession of quality impressed upon the body by the stimulus, they conclude that perception is judgment. It becomes simply a logical activity of drawing a conclusion. The words “see,” “hear,” “feel” lose all their meanings. The reason is everywhere.</p><p>Merleau-Ponty believes that to perceive is not to reason (judge) but to apprehend an immanent sense in the sensible before reasoning begins. True perception offers, therefore, a meaning inherent in the signs. Dualism simply reduces the phenomenon to a mistake.</p><p>When I see diagonal lines in Zollner’s illusion as not parallel, a dualist would argue that I mistake the task given and compare the two wholes, instead of comparing the principal elements. But why do the long main lines refuse to be separated from the short auxiliary lines?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/560/1*pKsl080zYUVH_M_4b7Jsdw.png" /></figure><p>The answer is that by acquiring the auxiliary lines, the main lines have ceased to be parallel, that they lost their meaning and acquired another. The auxiliary lines introduced into the figure a new meaning which henceforth clings to it and can not be shifted. There is here, preceding physical relationships, a perceptual syntax constructed according to its own rules.</p><p>Mind introspection cannot “run over isolated impressions” and gradually discover the meaning of the whole. Perception is an act which creates at a stroke, not only the cluster of data but also the meaning which unites it. It does not “discover” the meaning which it has, it “sees to it” that it has a meaning. Sensations are not experienced, and consciousness is always consciousness of an object. The pure sensation is an illusion but a necessary one and necessarily misleading the way in which mind sees its own history.</p><p>Perception cannot be a process of reasoning since there are no sensations to provide it with premises or an interpretation because there is nothing prior to it to interpret. Along the idea of sensation, we discard the idea of purely logical activity. Perception is thus thought about perceiving. Analytical reflection becomes a purely regressive doctrine according to which every perception is a muddled form of intellection. No analysis of perception can afford not to conceive perception as a totally originating phenomenon. Dualism started from a world in itself which acted upon our eyes as to cause us to see it and it is still defined by the absolute mutual exteriority of its parts. It accepts as completely valid the idea of truth and gives the assurances of apprehending a “real” beyond appearance, the “true” beyond illusion.</p><p>Dualism sets itself up as a doctrine of science and not of perception, purporting to base its analysis on the test of mathematical truth and not on the naive acceptance of the self-evidence of the world. However, in reality, I would not know that I possess a true idea if my memory did not enable me to relate what is now evident with what was evident a moment ago, and through the medium of words, correlate my evidence with that of others. My thought always uses thoughts already formulated by myself or others and relies on my memory or else on the memory of the community of thinkers. To take for granted that we have a true idea is to believe in uncritical perception. Dualism retained an absolute belief in the world as the totality of spatiotemporal events and treated consciousness as a province of this world. Reflection furnishes an essence of consciousness.</p><p>Merleau-Ponty abandons dualism. In his view, when gestalt psychology started to criticize “constancy hypothesis,” it rejected reason and judgment as an explanatory factor in the theory of perception. It concluded that perception is not an act of understanding. The real sin of dualism is that it took as given the determinate universe of science and placed perceptual consciousness in the midst of the ready-made world.</p><p>Gestalt theory has clearly shown that alleged signs of distance — the apparent size of the object, the number of objects interposed between it and us, the disparity of retinal images, the degree of convergence, are only known in an analysis after the perception but we do not go through these stages in knowing the distances. Unfortunately, Gestalt psychology retains dualism and claims that these signs can be <em>causes</em> of this perception. Merleau-Ponty makes the next decisive step beyond the Gestalt theory.</p><p>A subject whose oculomotor muscles are paralyzed sees objects moving to his left whenever he believes that he is turning his eyes towards the left. This classical psychology maintains, because perception reasons: the eye is supposed to swing to the left, and since nevertheless the retinal images have not moved, the view must have slipped leftwards to keep them, in place in the eye. Gestalt theory informs us that the perception of the position of objects does not pass through the detour of an express body-consciousness, at no moment do I know that the images remain stationary on the retina, I see the landscape move to the left directly. For the illusion to be produced, the subject must have intended to look to the left and must have thought he moved his eye. The movements of his body are naturally invested with a certain perceptual significance. Perception “takes account” of the movement of the organs of perception finding in them not “the express explanation” but the <em>motive</em> for the changes.</p><p>In a healthy person, the intent to move the eye to the left creates oscillation of the visual field. The object remains in place after a short fluctuation. This is the immanent meaning of “shift of gaze.” For the afflicted person the gaze and the landscape remain as if they were glued together, no quiver dissociates them, and the gaze carries with it the landscape. Thus the immobility of images on the retina and the paralysis of the oculomotor muscles are not actual causes of the illusion; they are motives in the same way the objects interposed between me and the thing upon which I fix my eye. There is no reason, but they are motives.</p><p>This leads Merleau-Ponty to question objective thinking of classical logic, to lay aside the categories of the world, to place in doubt the alleged self-evidence of realism and undertake a true phenomenological reduction. The phenomenological notion of motivation is a fluid concept in which one phenomenon releases another, not by means of some objective, efficient cause, but by the <em>meaning</em> which it holds out and guides the flow of phenomena. Thus the intention to look to the left and the fact that the landscape remains stubbornly fixed in one’s gaze bring about the illusion of movement in the object. Instead of the one merely succeeding the other, the motivated phenomenon makes the motivating phenomenon explicit and comprehensible and thus seems to have <em>preexisted its own motive</em>. Similarly, the object at a distance and its physical projection on the retinas explain the disparity of the images, and through a retrospective illusion, we speak about a natural geometry of perception.</p><p>We place beforehand within perception a science constructed upon it and we lose sight of the original relationship of motivation, in which distance springs into existence ahead of any science, not from a judgement of “the two images” for these are not numerically distinct but from the phenomenon of the “shift” from the forces which reside in this rough outline, which are trying to come to rest and which lead it to the most determinate form possible. To a Cartesian doctrine, these descriptions will be treated as allusions to unreflective states of mind, which by their nature can never become articulate and which, like any form of psychology, are without truth in the eyes of the understanding. In order to admit them, it is necessary to show that in no case can consciousness entirely cease to be what it is in perception and that it can not take full possession of its operations. For recognition of phenomena, then implies a theory of reflection and a new <em>cogito</em>.</p><p>Dualism treats perception as a process constituting more or less truthfully, objective things. By extension, the scientific concept becomes a means of objectifying phenomena. This helped science to find reason immanent in the world, geometrical space indifferent to its contents and pure movement which does not affect the properties of the object. Dualism thus provided phenomena with a setting of inert existence in which each event could be related to physical conditions responsible for the changes occurring, and therefore contributed to this freezing of being which appeared to be the task of physics. In the end, it converts the living body into an interior-less thing. Impelling intentions of the living creature are converted into bodily movements, the execution of which is controlled entirely by the nervous mechanism. Sense experience is thus detached from effective and motor functions. So the living body becomes just another object, a machine.</p><p>Merleau-Ponty no longer holds that perception is incipient science, but that dualist science is a form of perception which loses sights of its origin and believes itself complete. He wants to return philosophy to the world of actual experience which is prior to the objective world, he wants to restore to things their concrete physiognomy, to organisms their individual ways of dealing with the world, and to subjectivity its inherence in history.</p><p>He makes clear that the phenomenal field is not an “inner world,” the “phenomenon” is not a “state of consciousness” or a “mental fact,” and the experience of phenomena is not an act of introspection. The return to the phenomenal avoids all of the problems of dualism, once the prejudice of sensation has been banished, a face ceases to be a mere “visual data” and mental life of others becomes an immediate object. Gestalt psychologist leads to break with dualism and the meaning, connection and “truth” of the percept no longer arise from the fortuitous coming together of our sensations as they are given to us by our psychological nature, but determine the spatial and qualitative values of these sensations, and are their irreducible configuration.</p><p>We must regard perception as a creative operation which itself participates in the facticity of that experience. That is why phenomenology, alone of all philosophies, talks about a transcendental field. It is a study of the advent of being to consciousness, instead of presuming its possibility as given in advance. Other philosophies judge what is by what ought to be, by what the idea of knowledge requires. But reflection can never make me stop seeing the sun two hundred yards away on a misty day, or seeing it “rise” and “set.” The core of philosophy its no longer an autonomous transcendental subjectivity to be found everywhere and nowhere: it lies in the perpetual beginning of reflection at the point where an individual life begins to reflect on itself. Philosophy should recognize as its fundamental problem presumption of absolute consciousness on the part of the reason.</p><p>Merleau-Ponty concludes that the overwhelming emphasis on consciousness is overrated. <em>Consciousness holds itself responsible for everything and takes everything upon itself, but it has nothing of its own and makes its life in the world.</em></p><p><strong>Sources:</strong><br><a href="http://alfa-omnia.com/resources/Phenomenology+of+Perception.pdf">http://alfa-omnia.com/resources/Phenomenology+of+Perception.pdf</a></p><p><a href="https://epdf.tips/phenomenology-of-perception.html">https://epdf.tips/phenomenology-of-perception.html</a></p><p><a href="https://drive.google.com/viewerng/viewer?url=http://timothyquigley.net/cont/merleau-ponty-pp_preface.pdf">https://drive.google.com/viewerng/viewer?url=http://timothyquigley.net/cont/merleau-ponty-pp_preface.pdf</a></p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fupscri.be%2Fb2a0d6%3Fas_embed%3Dtrue&amp;dntp=1&amp;display_name=Upscribe&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fupscri.be%2Fb2a0d6%2F&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=upscri" width="800" height="400" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/0707f5c806284d01a4a13c7b13a91ce3/href">https://medium.com/media/0707f5c806284d01a4a13c7b13a91ce3/href</a></iframe><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d8f1ffcfe1ba" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.datadriveninvestor.com/merleau-ponty-and-the-a-i-d8f1ffcfe1ba">Merleau-Ponty and the A.I.</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.datadriveninvestor.com/">DataDrivenInvestor</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Midterm Elections and the Blockchain]]></title>
            <link>https://romanor.medium.com/midterm-elections-and-the-blockchain-a948a3ed26f6?source=rss-ba469f91a8c7------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a948a3ed26f6</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[usa]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[elections]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cryptocurrency]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[blockchain]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Roman Ormandy]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 21 Nov 2018 23:57:55 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-11-28T21:45:47.313Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*dsnl0BlTtJyqEPwfCtAoMg.png" /><figcaption>Brenda Snipes, the Broward County election supervisor</figcaption></figure><p>I never thought that voting, being a centuries-old legacy process, would be an essential application for the blockchain. After all, the USA is an advanced democracy, with plenty of computers to add up the votes of the individual US citizens. How hard could it be?</p><p>Enter the 2018 midterm elections, the Broward County and the Broward’s county election supervisor, Brenda Snipes. In the Broward County election this year just about everything went wrong, from the destruction of the legal ballots to the creation of possibly fraudulent ones on a massive scale. By law, the county officials have to submit the votes for counting within 30 min of the polls closing. In the Broward County in November 2018, 30 minutes became 4 days. During that time 83,000 new ballots have been “found,” and GOP senator lead shrank from 60,000+ votes at the time of the polls closing to just above 10,000 votes. One could infer that if the ballot finding process took just one day longer, Florida Senate seat would have been flipped for the Democratic candidate.</p><p>How could this happen in the world’s most advanced democracy? The answer is the corruption of course, but the election process is supposed to be protected from the political manipulation. Instead, we have seen the Broward County election officials filling in the empty ballots and trucks arriving and leaving the election center in the middle of the night without any supervision. We have seen observer oversight of the election blocked, even after the judge ruled that oversight officials must have access to the process documents by the end of the 3rd day. While the other Florida counties, even those suffering from the hurricane damage, submitted the ballots on time, there were counties in several other states in which the late count favored the Democratic party. Many commentators concluded that 2018 midterm elections were stolen.</p><p>When I entered the polling center in California where I live and was handing my ID to a lovely lady behind the desk, she just waved the hand and said no ID was necessary. In other words, I could have voted as many times as I wanted. I guess California in its effort to make sure that “every vote count” also believes that the more, the merrier and that you can not have too many votes, even if they are fraudulent.</p><p>How does this relate to the blockchain? SEC likes to emphasize that decentralized crypto cannot be trusted until it is “properly regulated” by a central, wise human regulator. If there is one thing that 2018 midterm elections proved is that human regulators cannot be trusted. From now on we just can not trust the humanly controlled election process. It can be too easily biased toward a specific candidate and towards one particular party. Sanctity of the election process is the very bedrock of democracy, and it has been tainted. How can the US voters go to a polling booth in 2020, knowing that their vote may be stolen by the unscrupulous election officers?</p><p>Something must change, or the very future of the US democracy is in peril. Fortunately, there is a simple solution. Blockchain can eliminate fraudulent votes, provided we will muster the political will to demand the free elections. Satoshi Nakamoto solved the “double spend” problem in his famous 2008 bitcoin paper a long time ago, what we need now is to avoid “double voting” and the other forms of election fraud.</p><p>Either we switch to the blockchain based election system or the USA may turn into a totalitarian regime controlled by the Wall Street bankers. Bankers are eager to take the final step. In his 1971 book <em>Between Two Ages</em>, Zbigniew Brzezinski, the architect of several US administrations and the longtime personal assistant of David Rockefeller concluded: <em>“Nation state as a fundamental unit of man’s organized life has ceased to be the principal creative force: International banks and multinational corporations are acting and planning in terms that are far in advance of the political concept of the nation-state. The fiction of sovereignty is clearly no longer compatible with reality”</em>.</p><p>It may be the ultimate irony that at the very moment that central banks are reaching the point of the absolute control, the internet and the blockchain technology may erode their very reason for existence. Provided of course, that US voters will stand up and exercise their choice.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a948a3ed26f6" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Crisis in the Valley]]></title>
            <link>https://romanor.medium.com/the-crisis-in-the-valley-71b93b94ec67?source=rss-ba469f91a8c7------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/71b93b94ec67</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[culture]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[silicon-valley]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[tech]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cryptocurrency]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[internet]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Roman Ormandy]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 01 May 2018 22:54:51 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-05-02T21:26:43.991Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*AEUMmBUWZZVZdmnBv7zyZA.jpeg" /><figcaption>The Old Money: Eric Schmidt, Mark Zuckerberg, Elon Musk, Tim Cook</figcaption></figure><p>Someone said that the first sign of company decline is the erection of imposing new headquarters. By this standard, Apple, Google, and Facebook could be in peril indeed. Back in 1992, I moved my 3D graphics company to Silicon Valley, after first defecting from communistic Czechoslovakia and then spending ten years in New York City. Despite the economic crisis, Silicon Valley was an exciting place to live and work. My company did well, and to this day I am grateful for the opportunity Bay area provided for me. Today, however despite seeming prosperity of internet giants, my excitement is gone, and I wonder whether there is much future for Silicon Valley as a nurturing cradle of big ideas.</p><p>The signs of decline are everywhere. Let us start with Apple. It is mind-boggling that since the death of Steve Jobs in 2011, Apple failed to introduce a single new major product innovation. Tim Cook put his efforts in ill-conceived Apple watch, introduced as a luxury accessory, complete with $17,000 Gold edition. After years of milking iPhone innovation, iPhone X sales are abysmal and just today rumors are circulating about the “AR headset with two 8K displays”. An idea of two 8K rendering engines crammed into a lightweight headset is wrong on so many many levels. It reminds me of Intel’s Paul Otellini proudly introducing a single core 4Ghz CPU in 2005. In 2006, Intel chips started to melt, and Intel laid off 10,000 people. Apple may soon follow.</p><p>The moral of the story? The problem is cultural, not technical, as engineers are always trying to extend the old paradigm with more transistors, faster clock, more memory, more pixels, etc., instead of inventing a new paradigm, better suited to changing market demands. In the CPU case the new paradigm was the multi-core architecture, for the AR headsets it will be a better understanding of human eye which concentrates most of its sensors in the fovea and moves the fovea 3–5 times per second to interesting scene objects via saccades. I estimate that static frame display wastes 99.9% of its GPU cycles compared to the dynamic operation of the mammalian eye and brain. Sure, the dynamic display is harder to make, but staying with static frame display will simply not work. It takes a visionary to see that, but today, vision is in short supply in Silicon Valley.</p><p>Prolonged ignorance of human physiology had even more dire consequences for wearable sensor technologies. It explains the abysmal lack of progress in fitness and health assistants and personal assistants in general. Typically, the sensor companies start with some hardware sensors onto which they add a low level, low-quality UI, forcing the user to interpret meaningless data such as the number of steps per day. What is needed instead is understanding of the meaning of multimodal streams of data by correlating in real time all modalities with current intentions of users. As it turns out engineers do not understand how people form intentions in the context of their daily activities. Whence we expect a wearable computing equivalent of Steven Jobs iPhone? I would not hold my breath.</p><p>Finally, AI and computer scientists convinced themselves that human brain is simply a PC-like CPU. If they bothered actually to study the brain, they would find out that nothing could be farther from the truth. Neural science could provide the answers, but Silicon Valley AI “experts” and cognitive scientists awash with VC money are not interested in anything contradicting their “vision.” Sand Hill road VC’s after watching too many Hollywood movies about “killer AI’s wiping the mankind like a virus,” pour money into countless AI startups with little to show for it. Elon Musks basks in visionary glory while Tesla is forced to remove AI robots from Model 3 production factory floor of as AI’s can not keep up with human workers. Similarly, Google’s Sergey Brin in an annual letter to all Google employees claims that “the new spring of AI is the most significant development in my lifetime” and “I fear that AI robots can manipulate us.” The simple truth is that AI technology never worked and never will. Elon Musk is a frequent Pentagon visitor and another AI proponent, Google’s Eric Schmidt is the chairman of Pentagon’s influential Defense Science Board. The real benefactor of “AI revolution” is the Pentagon budget as US citizens, scared by “killer AI’s,” look to the government for protection from this “menace.” The real truth is that threat of Hollywood AI’s is great for increased military funding; only Hollywood aliens can compete with that.</p><p>As bad as this is, there is an even bigger problem on the horizon. As <em>the existing internet of information</em> is being replaced with the new <em>internet of value</em>, there are no Silicon Valley companies leading or even following the ongoing crypto revolution. Worse, Google, Facebook, and Twitter are actively censoring news about cryptocurrencies. Why? The ugly truth is that it is not just the lack of vision and creativity slowing down Silicon Valley progress but the active involvement of the government which is protecting US banking industry rather than banks customers.</p><p>How close is the Silicon Valley to Washington? The answer is very close indeed. On November 7th, 2012, Google’s CEO Eric Schmidt, was working hard inside one of the presidential candidate’s election headquarters, directing the power of Google’s mighty technology to sway the results his way. Two months later, the government, in turn, dropped the Google anti-monopoly lawsuit and from 2013 to 2015 Google executives attended several hundreds of meetings inside the White House. The frequency of the meetings increased every year, from 32 in 2009 to 97 in 2014. Altogether, during this period 55 individuals moved from positions at Google into the federal government, and 197 people moved from the government positions to jobs at Google, including Darpa director, Regina Dugan, who became a VP of Google. The latest addition to Google’s board of directors is the former board member of the US Federal Reserve, Roger Fergusson. As of today, for all practical purposes, there is no difference between Google and the government.</p><p>Did Google have to succumb to the government lawsuit so readily? Certainly, the threat of a company break-up is scary, but Google and later others did not even put up a fight, seeking the government protection eagerly at a high cost of freedom of all US citizens. A few years earlier Microsoft did not give up in a similar situation. Why did Google betray their customers so readily? As Ron Paul remarked during his farewell speech to Congress, the answer may lie in the lack of virtues of new American leaders.</p><p>It is no coincidence that Google Assistant, Amazon’s Alexa, Microsoft’s Cortana, etc. with a possible exception of Siri are spying on its customers and that Google, Facebook or Amazon forward their customer’s private information to the government in bulk. “You can now talk to your house” is the punch line of a popular TV ad, but in reality, it is not your house but Eric Schmidt and Jeff Bezos who listen to you 24/7. Soon, US customers will wake up to that.</p><p>Netflix too is no longer serving their customers, but manipulating them in an explicit, broadcast fashion. In 2015, Netflix eliminated excellent peer to peer user recommendation of “viewers like you,” and replaced them with Netflix produced ratings, not surprisingly pushing their shows, Time-Warner style. The collateral damage of this decision was that Netflix made virtually inaccessible 15 years of my ratings. From my point of view, Netflix deliberately destroyed 15 years of my memories. I resent that.</p><p>Finally, In a massive blow to the first amendment right to a free speech, Twitter, Facebook, and Google recently joined the old style mass media and implemented both visible and invisible censorship. Through shadow banning and algorithmic filters, the big three resorted once more to the tired AI moniker and “science” to justify the blatant violation of our rights.</p><p>But there is a price to pay. When the government itself becomes the real focus of Silicon Valley companies, the service to existing customers becomes less important. Worse, free innovation at protected companies is restricted or outright suppressed. Over time, in a free market, the government protected companies become uncompetitive as new technologies gain market share and eventually replace them.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*qfvyeVARShJMAWnnujWqZg.jpeg" /><figcaption>The New Money: Charlie Lee, Vitalik Buterin, Dan Larimer, Roger Ver</figcaption></figure><p>Do we still have a free market in the US or are the government monopolies perhaps becoming all-powerful Orwellian Big Brothers forcing us to live in Huxleyan Brave New World of leisure paid for by our submission to mind control by mass media and web giants? The time will tell, but the emergent crypto revolution may offer a different alternative. With the internet of value delivering the next generation of social networks, news and financial services both superior to Google and Facebook and at the same time ferociously protecting the privacy of their users, the future of Silicon Valley web monopolies if not secure. Far from it, there is a strong possibility that new decentralized internet of value will replace them.</p><p>SEC is trying to stop innovative companies from getting funded directly from their customers and public investors through ICO’s rather than banks here in the US, but with the emergence of distributed exchanges, a physical location of the company will be irrelevant. As we see on a daily basis, crypto pioneers such as Binance, EOS or Telegram can relocate easily around the world to countries like Switzerland, Malta or Slovenia, whose governments are eager to attract the emerging new industry. Internet will continue to evolve, as Jurassic Park says: “Life will find a way.” When that happens, the real estate prices in Bay area will not be the only assets whose prices may finally come down to earth.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=71b93b94ec67" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[American Idols]]></title>
            <link>https://romanor.medium.com/american-idols-4529c8d8fe0b?source=rss-ba469f91a8c7------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4529c8d8fe0b</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[religion]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[media-criticism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[social-media]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[internet]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Roman Ormandy]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 08 Apr 2018 19:46:46 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-04-09T02:05:59.250Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*S1kHoAyvmWFkpQ0dxJ8tPQ.jpeg" /><figcaption><em>The real god of Scientism is Cartesian Dualism. Elon Musk and Beyonce are its idols.</em></figcaption></figure><p>My new book, <a href="https://www.amazon.com/dp/194763741X/ref=sxts_sxwds-puwylo_rv_1?pf_rd_m=ATVPDKIKX0DER&amp;pf_rd_p=3534076942&amp;pd_rd_wg=R00Ub&amp;pf_rd_r=W4P8EJWZTHZ0WKW2AZ1B&amp;pf_rd_s=desktop-sx-top-slot&amp;pf_rd_t=301&amp;pd_rd_i=194763741X&amp;pd_rd_w=fq4SB&amp;pf_rd_i=the+god+of+scientism&amp;pd_rd_r=9ed46c18-56fd-4eb4-bb25-7dcb0abcf9c7&amp;ie=UTF8&amp;qid=1523216388&amp;sr=1"><em>The God of Scientism</em></a>, argues that modern scientism, attempting to replace religious beliefs with the “objective scientific truths” ended up instead just replacing one set of beliefs with another, a more pernicious one. As a side effect, it also replaced the religion and the monotheist god with a gaggle of Hollywood idols. This article is about these idols and their role in manufacturing the US public opinion.</p><p>Contemporary Western culture prides itself on its rational approach, unassailable reason and ice-cold logic, all of which presumably will make the traditional religion obsolete. As we stop reading books, we happily line up in front of TV or movie screens controlled by Hollywood broadcasters or a mobile phone screens controlled by Silicon Valley Google, Facebook, and Twitter. On all of these screens, we obediently worship the glorious pantheon of our new secular idols, from Hollywood movie and TV actors to mass media news anchors, moderators, and talk show hosts, to social networking idols, even politicians. Sometimes it is not easy to tell who is who.</p><p>Work of media idols parallels the work of bureaucrats operating from the shadows of the deep state and both groups answer to their Wall Street owners. The job of an idol is not to entertain or inform, but to manufacture the opinions of huddled masses. Hollywood idols were doing their job extraordinarily well until recently, they are attractive, intelligent and they are talented and sensitive artists. Above all, however, they must be charismatic. Our educational system and our mass media provide them with exclusive access to the US audiences so they can form a desired public opinion, such as the current belief that 2016 US elections were manipulated by Putin, rather than by FBI or CIA.</p><p>There are privileges to being an idol, but there is a price to pay as well, often in the form of opioid addiction, as we have seen from examples of actors like Charlie Sheen, Alec Baldwin, Lindsey Lohan, Amanda Bynes or Britney Spears, and pop singers like Michael Jackson, Prince, Mariah Carey, Whitney Houston, Sinead O’Connor, Christine Aguilera, Courtney Love, Chris Brown, Justin Bieber and others.</p><p>For idols to be properly worshipped, however, mass media must first silence the religion, Christian religion to be specific. A good example was last week’s Easter Sunday, when Facebook censor banned the Franciscan University ad, depicting Jesus on a cross for “shocking content,” “excessive violence” and “sensationalism.” At the same time, Hollywood’s actor and an amateur painter Jim Carrey’s recent tweet and depiction of the imaginary gruesome death of both sons of Donald Trump is apparently “fantastic”.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*T62m4ILEtZB5vaZLq_SDcw.jpeg" /><figcaption><em>“excessive violence” …………………………………………………“fantastic art”</em></figcaption></figure><p>But even in the age of Reason, humans do not abandon religious faith lightly. A good example is the desert festival <em>Burning Man,</em> which exhibits attempts of modern men to return to religion, albeit in a concealed, techno-pagan form. According to Tesla founder Elon Musk: “<em>Burning Man is Silicon Valley”</em>, but in addition to hordes of computer executives and Hollywood stars reveling in freely available sex and drugs, there is also a temple where the participants post messages to their dead relatives, get “baptized” during various ceremonies and where Susan Sarandon was spreading the ashes of Timothy Leary. Even the final ceremony of torching a 100 feet tall statue of Burning Man reminds me of the pagan festivities I witnessed as a boy where peasants in remote Slovak villages welcomed the arrival of Spring with a procession and burning of a wooden effigy of goddess Morena.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1020/1*2dtQ9ZAP4fKAlwi8nj8O1g.jpeg" /><figcaption>19th century Morena burning………………………..…..21st century Burning Man</figcaption></figure><p>How important is the role of charismatic, or as Zbigniew Brzezinski put it “magnetic,” personalities for the mass media propaganda? The short answer: very important. Author of <em>Propaganda,</em> Edward Bernays pioneered the use of movie screen magnetic personalities during the tobacco industry successful PR campaign converting masses of young American women to this deadly habit in the early part of the 20th century. Working for the <em>American Tobacco Company</em>, he created the “<em>torches of freedom”</em> campaign which raised women purchases of cigarets in the US from 5% to 33% percent and which was eagerly embraced by the feminist leaders. Here are some “glamor” photographs of famous Hollywood actresses, all ready to pick up and carry the “torches of freedom.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/980/1*opCDPnuKq0RnO8qQDpu4qw.jpeg" /></figure><p>Almost a hundred years later, the technology changed but the demand for charismatic idols stays the same. Priyanka Chopra (ABC TV show <em>Quantico)</em> and Claire Danes (Showtime TV show <em>Homeland) </em>exceptional IQ, good looks, and charisma are critical for their job as FBI and CIA recruiters.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*BOzGj1XYyz1c7h8gP30tnQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Priyanka Chopra…………………………………………………..Claire Danes</figcaption></figure><p>Male idols play an important role too. In 1998, <em>Saving Private Ryan, </em>Matt Damon’s character traded his biological brothers for the government issued “band of brothers<em>.” </em>In 2015,<em> </em>Matt teamed up with NASA and Elon Musk to recruit Mars colonists for a one way trip to Mars in the movie <em>Martian</em>. Amazingly, thousands of real people signed up for the trip after the movie came out.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*O4dCenhGTdsCQ-iMUiWSBw.jpeg" /><figcaption><em>Go West young man, plant some potatoes on Mars!</em></figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1016/1*uScq8aLteBJECOuXR0OUHQ.png" /><figcaption><em>Lech Lecha, Matt: Get out of your country, to a land that I will show you.</em></figcaption></figure><p>Music idols are equally if not more important and they too rely on enormous supporting infrastructure. Beyonce easily transitioned from her 2013 Super Bowl halftime show Black Panther persona dressed in bullet lined outfit to a 2017 Grammy awards look of a <em>Pagan Fertility Goddess</em> in chain string bikini.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/796/1*xBuMkTtpWd8phSdpplPRQQ.jpeg" /><figcaption><em>From a Black Panther to a Fertility Goddess</em></figcaption></figure><p>In a major change from the relatively independent musicians of the 60’s and 70’s, 80’s saw the rise of a new kind of Pop music idols who brought the mass manipulation of teenagers to a whole new level. Some of these pop stars were not even trained musicians, and some actually did come from the movie industry. Many of contemporary music idols started as child actors in Disney empire, such as Miley Cyrus, who morphed from Disney’s Hannah Montana to a twerking sex idol, but Selena Gomez, Vanessa Hudgens, and others came from Disney.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*KsrYOoFa9ea8qS2XH9alUw.jpeg" /><figcaption><em>Miley Cyrus ……………………..…….Katy Perry ……………………………….Justin Bieber</em></figcaption></figure><p>“TV personalities” and political pundits job is to whip their audiences into an emotional frenzy, dividing them into two violently opposed, “left-wing right-wing” factions with false metaphors of “diversity”, “Inclusivity” and “equality”, while they themselves enjoy the rather exclusive status and multimillion-dollar salary packages. Even kindly Oprah, who earned $290M in 2011 according to Daily Mail, is not about the fray and played a crucial role in 2008 presidential elections.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Is1ZM8s576HJ3hEZvxfjLQ.jpeg" /><figcaption><em>Sean Hannity …………………………..………Oprah ………………………………..Rachel Meadows</em></figcaption></figure><p>And who did she help to get elected? A young but charismatic freshman senator Barack Obama, who was picked from virtual obscurity in 2008 to become the president of the US. Mass Media glossed over his radical history and some questionable friends and portrayed him as the true champion not only of black community but every “progressive” cause. In my view, Barack Obama, more than his predecessors, showed no signs of independent will, dutifully preaching to US citizens the gospel of globalism via the teleprompter, while pilling additional $10 trillion to our national debt. Yet, when I speak to my progressive friends, I am struck how many of them consider Barack Obama to be the best American president. Bernays was right; propaganda works through endless repetition even when we know we are being manipulated.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*jzPGGnzPirMYwZ9Rn9QK1A.png" /><figcaption><em>All you need is love</em></figcaption></figure><p>Finally, a whole new type of well-funded idols is emerging in the fight to kill the Second Amendment in an unlikely person of David Hogg. Isn’t it rather remarkable that a lowly “engaged high school student” can gain unlimited access to mass media, topple politicians, “right wing” journalists, change the laws of the country, even eliminate the 2nd Amendment?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*DoPH9y-DFf829xwB3q-0jA.jpeg" /><figcaption><em>Passing the torch from one media puppet to other: Dan Rather coaches David Hogg.</em></figcaption></figure><p>For now, thanks to the mass media, propaganda still works. Many of us were hopeful that Internet would put an end to the era of idols. It did not happen, at least not yet. Is there any force which could compel the establishment to relinquish the power over the masses of US citizens? Perhaps there is. After the internet of information dies, a new type of internet will arise from its ashes, an internet of values. Cryptocurrencies, in the form of the first generation Bitcoin, second-generation Ether, third generation EOS and other modern distributed cryptocurrencies are evolving at speeds which bankers like Nouriel Roubini or Joseph Stiglitz cannot fathom. But that is another story.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4529c8d8fe0b" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>