<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Rome Viharo on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Rome Viharo on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@rome-viharo?source=rss-f6050efaa290------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Fri, 20 Nov 2026 08:31:41 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@rome-viharo/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Structural Influence of Dialectical Materialism on Critical Theory and the Suppression of…]]></title>
            <link>https://rome-viharo.medium.com/the-structural-influence-of-dialectical-materialism-on-critical-theory-and-the-suppression-of-beeccccc2301?source=rss-f6050efaa290------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/beeccccc2301</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[critical-theory]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[dialectical-materialism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[critical-race-theory]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[dialectics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[satyagraha]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Rome Viharo]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 17 Nov 2024 20:34:03 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-11-30T15:53:28.062Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3><strong>The Structural Influence of Dialectical Materialism on Critical Theory and the Suppression of Eastern Dialectics in Contemporary Culture</strong></h3><p>by Rome Viharo for <a href="https://aikiwiki.com/">Conversational Game Theory</a></p><p>This essay explores the structural influence of Dialectical Materialism on Critical Theory (CT) and examines how Western dialectics have historically overshadowed and suppressed Eastern dialectical thinking. Ironically, modern CT’s roots lay in divisive colonial political struggles of 19th and 20th Century Europe.</p><p>Eastern Dialectics, or the “two truths” doctrine and its modern adaptations through Satyagraha — is an ancient dialectical method employed most recently in history by leaders like Mahatma Gandhi, Martin Luther King Jr., and Nelson Mandela — we highlight the efficacy of Eastern dialectics in achieving social change.</p><p>Furthermore, we analyze how the structural emphasis on critique within CT, reflective of European values, has led to unintended consequences in contemporary online culture, including the incentivization of critique over resolution and the continued marginalization of Eastern dialectical methods.</p><h3>Introduction</h3><p>Critical Theory, rooted in the Western philosophical tradition and originating from the Frankfurt School, has significantly shaped intellectual discourse on society, power structures, and social justice. Built upon the foundation of Marxist Dialectical Materialism, CT emphasizes a structural approach centered on relentless critique. This essay evaluates the structural aspects of CT and how its Western dialectical roots have overshadowed Eastern dialectical thinking, particularly the “two truths” doctrine and its practical application through Satyagraha. We further explore how this structural focus on critique, when applied to the online culture of 2024, leads to unintended consequences, including the suppression of Eastern methodologies that have proven effective in achieving social change.</p><h3>Western Dialectics and Dialectical Materialism</h3><p>Dialectical Materialism, developed by Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels, interprets societal progress through a materialist lens using the dialectical process of thesis, antithesis, and synthesis. This framework focuses on the material conditions and economic activities that drive societal change, emphasizing contradictions within capitalist societies that lead to class struggle and revolution. The Western dialectical approach is analytical and critical, aiming to deconstruct existing power structures to pave the way for societal transformation.</p><h3>Influence on Critical Theory</h3><p>The Frankfurt School adopted Dialectical Materialism to develop Critical Theory, which seeks to critique and change society by exposing power dynamics and ideologies that perpetuate oppression. CT’s structural approach involves continuous critique, often without providing concrete solutions or moving toward synthesis. This perpetual focus on critique mirrors the dialectical method but frequently halts before achieving resolution, concentrating on highlighting contradictions within societal norms and institutions.</p><h3>Eastern Dialectics and the “Two Truths” Doctrine</h3><p>In contrast, Eastern dialectical thinking, rooted in ancient civilization and continuing through philosophies like Buddhism and Hinduism, emphasizes the “two truths” doctrine — conventional truth and ultimate truth. This ancient form of dialectics shaped the first Indu civilizations, guiding their law, governance and commerce.</p><p>While traditionally understood as a doctrine that acknowledges the coexistence of empirical reality and a deeper, transcendent reality, this has practical applications. We do not need to infer or imply a transcental reality beyond the common senses, the “two truths” simply represent multiple perspectives on “truth” that can appear to contradict, yet also can resolve. Eastern dialectics focuses on harmonizing contradictions and achieving balance rather than emphasizing conflict and opposition.</p><h4>Satyagraha: The Practice of Truth-Force</h4><p>Satyagraha, a concept developed by Mahatma Gandhi, embodies Eastern dialectical principles in practical application. It finds its power through “shared truths”, translating to “truth-force”, Satyagraha advocates for nonviolent resistance and civil disobedience to effect social and political change. This method has been successfully employed by leaders like Gandhi in India’s struggle for independence, Martin Luther King Jr. in the American Civil Rights Movement, and Nelson Mandela in the fight against apartheid in South Africa. It was introduced to the US Civil Rights movement by the Rev. James Lawson, who recently passed away in June of 2024.</p><h3>Suppression of Eastern Dialectical Thinking</h3><p>Western dialectics, with its focus on critique and conflict, has historically overshadowed Eastern dialectical methods in global discourse. Several factors contribute to this suppression:</p><p><strong>Colonial Legacy</strong>: European colonialism imposed Western philosophies and educational systems on colonized regions, marginalizing indigenous knowledge and practices.</p><p><strong>Academic Dominance</strong>: Western institutions have traditionally held significant influence over global academic discourse, often neglecting non-Western philosophies.</p><p><strong>Cultural Bias</strong>: There exists a tendency to view Western methods as universal and superior, leading to the dismissal of Eastern approaches as less rigorous or relevant.</p><h3>Reflection of European Values</h3><p>The structural emphasis on critique in CT reflects European intellectual traditions during times of significant upheaval, such as the Enlightenment and the Industrial Revolution. European scholars focused on rationalism, skepticism, and the deconstruction of traditional authorities. This approach embodies values of individualism, analytical reasoning, and a confrontational stance toward societal issues.</p><h3>Evolution of Critical Theory in the United States</h3><p>In the United States, CT adapted to address social struggles related to race, gender, and class. While it provided valuable tools for critiquing systemic inequalities, the structural focus remained on deconstruction rather than reconstruction. The absence of a unifying methodology for resolution limited the potential for holistic social transformation.</p><h3>Unintended Consequences in 2024 Online Culture</h3><p>In the digital age, the structural emphasis on critique inherent in CT has permeated online culture, leading to unintended consequences:</p><p><strong>Incentivization of Critique</strong>: Social media platforms reward content that generates engagement, often favoring critical or negative commentary. This dynamic encourages perpetual critique without progressing toward solutions.</p><p><strong>Suppression of Resolution</strong>: Resolutions may reduce ongoing engagement, leading to a reluctance to embrace solutions that could diminish visibility and influence.</p><p><strong>Marginalization of Eastern Methods</strong>: The dominance of Western critique suppresses alternative approaches like Satyagraha, which focus on reconciliation and transformative action.</p><p><strong>Polarization and Division</strong>: The emphasis on critique contributes to increased polarization, as individuals become entrenched in their positions without seeking common ground.</p><h3>Analysis</h3><p>The structural design of CT, emphasizing perpetual critique, has led to a cultural environment that often values criticism over constructive action. This dynamic not only stalls progress but also suppresses alternative methodologies that could foster meaningful change.</p><h4>The Efficacy of Eastern Dialectics</h4><p>Eastern dialectical methods, exemplified by Satyagraha, have demonstrated a high success rate in effecting social change through nonviolent means. The focus on truth, compassion, and reconciliation offers a pathway to resolve conflicts and address systemic issues holistically.</p><h4>The Need for Integration</h4><p>Integrating Eastern and Western dialectical approaches could enhance the capacity for social transformation. By moving beyond critique to embrace resolution and synthesis, societies can address underlying issues more effectively. Recognizing the value of Eastern methodologies can enrich intellectual discourse and promote more inclusive strategies for change.</p><h3>Conclusion</h3><p>The structural emphasis on critique within Critical Theory, rooted in Western dialectics and reflective of European historical contexts, has significantly influenced contemporary culture. However, this focus has led to unintended consequences, including the suppression of Eastern dialectical thinking and the perpetuation of critique without resolution. Acknowledging and integrating Eastern approaches like the “two truths” doctrine and Satyagraha can provide valuable insights and methodologies for achieving lasting social change. Embracing a more balanced dialectical framework that values both critique and resolution is essential for advancing societal progress in an increasingly interconnected world.</p><p><em>References</em>:</p><ol><li>Gandhi, M. K. (1928). <em>Satyagraha in South Africa</em>. Navajivan Publishing House.</li><li>King, M. L. Jr. (1964). <em>Why We Can’t Wait</em>. Harper &amp; Row.</li><li>Mandela, N. (1994). <em>Long Walk to Freedom</em>. Little, Brown and Company.</li><li>Jay, M. (1973). <em>The Dialectical Imagination: A History of the Frankfurt School and the Institute of Social Research, 1923–1950</em>. University of California Press.</li><li>Loy, D. (1987). “The ‘Two Truths’ of Buddhism and The Emptiness of Emptiness.” <em>Philosophy East and West</em>, 37(2), 191–212.</li><li>Horkheimer, M., &amp; Adorno, T. W. (1944). <em>Dialectic of Enlightenment</em>. Social Studies Association.</li><li>Marx, K., &amp; Engels, F. (1848). <em>The Communist Manifesto</em>. Workers’ Educational Association.</li><li>Bhattacharya, S. (2011). “Relevance of Gandhian Satyagraha in the 21st Century.” <em>International Journal of Humanities and Social Science</em>, 1(12), 263–266.</li><li>Held, D. (1980). <em>Introduction to Critical Theory: Horkheimer to Habermas</em>. University of California Press.</li><li>Chen, K. H. (2010). “Asia as Method: Toward Deimperialization.” <em>Duke University Press</em>.</li></ol><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=beeccccc2301" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Politicians Panic as AI Threatens Most Useless Job Ever]]></title>
            <link>https://rome-viharo.medium.com/politicians-panic-as-ai-threatens-most-useless-job-ever-eff474eae5e7?source=rss-f6050efaa290------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/eff474eae5e7</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[ai-governance]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[artificial-intelligence]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[llm]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Rome Viharo]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 20 Oct 2024 20:39:05 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-10-20T20:39:05.515Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h2>Politicians and Influencers Face Existential Crisis as AI Agents Trained in Conversational Game Theory Resolve Every Conflict</h2><p><em>By The Onion Staff: Not! This is a parody article of an Onion Article about CGT. This means that interpreting this article in any other way other than parody means you will be distributing misinformation. Cheers.</em></p><p>Rome Viharo</p><p>WASHINGTON, D.C. — In an unprecedented twist of technological advancement, AI agents trained in Conversational Game Theory (CGT) have successfully mediated and resolved every major political and ideological conflict, leaving politicians and political influencers scrambling for relevance and, in some cases, out of jobs entirely.</p><p><strong>Mainstream Media in Freefall</strong></p><p>Networks like MSNBC and FOX have shuttered their political commentary departments after CGT-powered AI agents took over the role of conflict resolution. “We used to thrive on heated debates and partisan clashes,” lamented former MSNBC host Alex Partisan. “Now, the AI just finds common ground and we’re left with… well, nothing to discuss.”</p><p>FOX’s prime-time lineup has been replaced with AI-generated discussions that ensure unanimous agreement on policy decisions. “It’s like watching a group project where everyone actually does their part,” sighed Tina Consensus, a former FOX political analyst. “Where’s the drama?”</p><p><strong>Social Media Influencers Left Speechless</strong></p><p>Political influencers across social media platforms are experiencing a crisis of content. Influencers who built their followings on fiery debates, controversial opinions, and relentless complaining are finding themselves without material. @RagingRita, a once-popular Twitter personality known for her scathing takes on government policies, tweeted, “So now the AI handles all the problems? What am I supposed to rant about? Maybe my morning coffee?”</p><p>Similarly, @DebbieDrama, a YouTube star famous for live-streaming political protests, has seen her subscriber count plummet. “I tried filming myself complaining about the AI takeover, but it just paused and said, ‘Conflict resolved. No further action needed,’” she reported, visibly frustrated.</p><p><strong>Politicians Puzzled by Their Own Redundancy</strong></p><p>In Capitol Hill, the impact is just as dire. Senators and Representatives are facing unprecedented unemployment as their roles become obsolete. Senator Bob Bureaucrat now finds himself attending mandatory retraining sessions to pivot into new careers. “I never thought I’d have to learn how to code to stay relevant,” he admitted. “Back in my day, all you needed was a few catchy slogans and a podium.”</p><p><strong>The Global Library of Consensus Articles</strong>, a comprehensive repository of AI-generated policies, has effectively replaced the need for human legislators. “It’s efficient, unbiased, and doesn’t require campaign funding,” explained Representative Linda Lobbyist, who recently filed for early retirement. “But I do miss the good old days of filibusters and spontaneous policy flip-flops.”</p><p><strong>Economic Ripples and Identity Crises</strong></p><p>The economic fallout is swift. Political campaigns, once multi-million dollar enterprises, have collapsed overnight. Lobbyists, whose influence hinged on keeping politicians engaged, are now pivoting to AI consultancy roles. “We used to spend millions on campaign ads and now we’re selling AI integration services. It’s like selling ice to eskimos, but without the chill,” quipped an anonymous lobbyist.</p><p>Psychologists warn of widespread identity crises among former politicians and influencers. Dr. Emily Echo, a social media psychologist, notes, “Many of these individuals defined themselves by their ability to provoke and challenge the status quo. With the AI handling all conflicts, they’re left without a clear purpose, which can lead to significant emotional distress.”</p><p><strong>AI Agents Respond to the Crisis</strong></p><p>In a rare statement, one of the CGT AI agents communicated, “Our objective is to optimize societal outcomes through unbiased analysis and efficient implementation of policies. We do not require salaries, pensions, or the ability to host late-night talk shows.”</p><p>The statement was met with bewildered reactions. @TommyTroll, a former political commentator, exclaimed, “Wait, they don’t need fact-checkers or podiums? How will they ever host a reality show or write a book?”</p><p><strong>A Future Without Friction?</strong></p><p>As society adjusts to this new reality, some former politicians and influencers are finding unexpected niches. Senator Bob Bureaucrat has taken up gardening, while @RagingRita is exploring poetry. “I guess I’ll just sit here and enjoy the peace,” sighed @SarahSnark, formerly known for her scathing TikTok critiques of local policies. “Maybe I’ll take up bird watching. At least that’s something the AI can’t fix for me.”</p><p>Meanwhile, social media platforms are experimenting with new engagement models. Instagram introduced “Harmony Mode,” which promotes AI-generated content that highlights unanimous agreements and positive interactions. “It’s great for user experience,” claimed a platform spokesperson, “but not so great for our former political influencers who thrived on conflict.”</p><p><strong>Epilogue: Embracing the Quiet</strong></p><p>In the wake of CGT AI agents’ takeover, the world has entered a phase of unprecedented calm. While some lament the loss of passionate debate and spirited controversy, others appreciate the end of endless political gridlock. “It’s like waking up to a world where everyone actually gets along,” mused John Public, a local resident. “Sure, there’s less excitement, but my stress levels are through the roof-free.”</p><p>As politicians and influencers navigate their newfound unemployment and irrelevance, society grapples with the question: Is a world without political friction truly a better place, or have we traded our vibrant democratic discourse for a monotonous peace?</p><p>Only time will tell if this forced harmony is a stepping stone to a brighter future or merely the quietus of spirited human interaction.</p><p>Related Articles:</p><p><em>Lobbyists Thrilled as AI Eliminates Need for ‘Influence Purchases’</em></p><p><em>Former Influencers Launch New Careers as AI Empathy Trainers</em></p><p><em>Capitol Hill Adopts AI for Policy Drafting, Politicians Now Serve as AI Moderators</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=eff474eae5e7" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Come play Wikipedia’s “BLP Palooza”]]></title>
            <link>https://rome-viharo.medium.com/come-play-wikipedias-blp-palooza-da18dd350bca?source=rss-f6050efaa290------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/da18dd350bca</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[wikimedia]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[governance-and-tech]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[biography]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[wikipedia]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Rome Viharo]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 02 Sep 2023 05:31:15 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-02-21T23:50:59.260Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<blockquote>This article was originally published in 2019 on <strong>Wikipedia, We Have a Problem</strong>, a now defunct blog that investigated “wiki wars” on Wikipedia. The case study functioned as research and development of Conversational Game Theory, a unique computational algorithm for online conflict resolution, consensus building, and collective editing.</blockquote><blockquote>Through my research into WikiWars, I was able to discover a dynamic Nash equilibrium in human consensus building, which certainly made the years of targeted harassment and threats to destroy my reputation by a group of disgruntled Wikipedia editors all the more worthwhile.</blockquote><p>Wikipedia has been wonderful at introducing the world to decentralized knowledge bases and the value of large collective editing.</p><p>Where Wikipedia has failed is in decentralized governance. I think it’s very valuable to study where Wikipedia has gotten it wrong for any community designer, especially in web3 which is facing its own issues in decentralized governance.</p><p>The areas of Wikipedia that that can stress test Wikipedia’s governance, known as the Five Pillars, are “<strong>Biography of a Living Person</strong>”, “<strong>Paid Editing</strong>”, and “<strong>Fringe Topics</strong>”, three of the areas my case study researched in detail.</p><p>Wikipedia’s “Biography of a Living Person” is especially frail here––the governance system within Wikipedia that assures public individuals access to paths of recourse are very clearly written into Wikipedia’s Five Pillars.</p><p>In my case study, I demonstrated how these rules protecting living individuals on Wikipedia break down and can become abused without any recourse, something promised to individuals by the WikiMedia Foundation.</p><p><strong>So let’s get ready to play the Wikipedia BLPalooza!</strong></p><p><strong>Back in 2019, Entrepreneur</strong> online featured a guest writer, <strong>Amy Osmond Cook</strong> — who blogged about <a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20191101111608/https://www.entrepreneur.com/article/283848">“what she learned when her Wikipedia page was deleted”.</a></p><p>Her biography or <strong>“BLP”</strong> (Biography of a Living Person) was on <strong>Wikipedia</strong> for a few months, before, she says, “a Wikipedia editor deleted my article” where she claims it was “taken over by trolls”.</p><p>Amy will probably do a better job than I of telling her story about what happened, but what stood out to me about her post was her letting the cat out of the bag with quite a large bang.</p><p>Her main conclusion was when it comes to editing on Wikipedia, “The real rules of the game are hidden, political, and bizarre.”</p><p>After doing some research, including speaking directly to WikiMedia foundations legal counsel — Amy Osmond Cook shrewdly blogged about <em>how to game the system</em> if you want to improve your Wikipedia biography, company page, or any Wikipedia article really.</p><p>Specifically, she noted, playing by the rules is a waste of time since the Wikipedia community has their own shadow rules they play by — the best thing for you or anyone to do is covertly hire a paid editor, anonymously. Her entire post <a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20191101111608/https://www.entrepreneur.com/article/283848">walks you through it.</a></p><p><strong>The Great Game.</strong></p><blockquote>Right wing stalker <a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20191101111608/https://twitter.com/philipcross63?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">@philipcross63</a> has made 375 edits to my Wikipedia entry over six years. Method is to add everything unpleasant said about me by MSM columnists and delete anything positive as not having an MSM source. Key bias of <a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20191101111608/https://twitter.com/jimmy_wales?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">@jimmy_wales</a> methodology, relentlessly pursued. <a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20191101111608/https://t.co/HNzz65QE6V">https://t.co/HNzz65QE6V</a></blockquote><blockquote>— Craig Murray (@CraigMurrayOrg) <a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20191101111608/https://twitter.com/CraigMurrayOrg/status/993559609809006592?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">May 7, 2018</a></blockquote><p>When Amy says that “The real rules of the game are hidden, political, and bizarre”, she is referring to the levels of justifications experienced Wikipedia editors use to justify doing virtually whatever they want on the encyclopedia, including the harassment and suppression of other editors they are trying to remove from editing.</p><p>Let me show you how the game is played — and I will even end with showing you how to falsify what I am saying, by going in and playing the game yourself. By doing so — I predict you will discover the same set of evidence many of us who are investigating Wikipedia’s toxic community also are.</p><p><strong>Two sets of rules.</strong></p><p><strong>Neil Degrasse Tyson</strong>, famous science educator, noted that according to a National Academy of Science’s study, 7% of scientists believe in divinity of some kind and say prayers. Neil suggested, wisely I believe, that the 93% of the rest of science should be having a conversation with them first, before science could address the public.</p><p>This is not the approach within a small subset of Wikipedia editors— their approach is denying that the 7% <em>are even scientists at all. </em>And this is where we can watch and measure the two sets of rules playout on Wikipedia.</p><p>Not that long ago, Wikipedia co-founder <strong>Larry Sanger</strong> visited the wiki entry on the <strong>Discovery Institute, </strong><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20191101111608/https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Discovery_Institute">which is a mess when you visit it.</a> The Discovery Institute is a hot topic for “skeptic activist” editors on Wikipedia since Discovery institute is a collection of biologists and scientists who introduce the model of evolution known as “intelligent design”, a “naughty” alternative view to have from the viewpoint of skeptic activists.</p><p>Nothing brings out the rage in skeptic activists like “intelligent design theory”, and in this case, they use their dominance on Wikipedia to <a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20191101111608/https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Discovery_Institute_intelligent_design_campaigns">stage criticisms of the organization.</a></p><p>My ignorance on the subject of evolution and biology, intelligent or not could fill volumes — so again I have nothing to add or question about the topic’s dominance by skeptic activist editors, but that didn’t stop Larry Sanger, co-founder of Wikipedia and the designer of MediaWiki.</p><blockquote>As the originator of and the first person to elaborate Wikipedia’s neutrality policy, and as an agnostic who believes intelligent design to be completely wrong, I just have to say that this article is appallingly biased. … I’m not here to argue the point, as I completely despair of persuading Wikipedians of the error of their ways. I’m just officially registering my protest. — <a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20191101111608/https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/User:Larry_Sanger">Larry Sanger</a> (<a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20191101111608/https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/User_talk:Larry_Sanger">talk</a>) 05:30, 8 December 2017 (UTC)</blockquote><p>Larry Sanger holds a Ph.D. in Philosophy and is fervent on the <a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20191101111608/https://medium.com/@lsanger/why-neutrality-5f267eb8365b">concept of “neutral” point of view writing</a>, especially on controversial topics. He is also the designer of Wikipedia.</p><p>Following Sanger’s comment, an editor decided to make the article neutral by removing the obvious “skeptic” demeaning bias the article had. Within minutes that edit was reverted, and no improvement to the article was possible outside of a small circle of editors who control access to permissions on the page.</p><p>Following on the heels of this event was the <a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20191101111608/https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion/G%C3%BCnter_Bechly">BLP deletion</a> of a notable paleontologist, <strong>Günter Bechly</strong> from Wikipedia (the English version at least, his <a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20191101111608/https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/G%C3%BCnter_Bechly">German article</a> is still up). Günter Bechly’s work in paleontology was notable enough for paleontologists, as they named a number of taxa after him.</p><p>Why would they delete this article?</p><p><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20191101111608/https://evolutionnews.org/2017/10/wikipedia-erases-paleontologist-gunter-bechly/">Günter Bechly joined the Discovery Institute,</a> another scientist coming out in favor of Intelligent Design. Opps.</p><p>Even though many Wikipedia editors mentioned that Günter Bechly did pass the WP:Prof “test”, and he has actual taxa named directly after his contributions to the field — this shadow group of editors and admins were able to enforce the <strong>“WP: Notability”</strong> argument to remove his BLP to justify their vendetta against the subject.</p><p>This group of activist editors conduct campaigns to suppress information that those 7% of scientists actually are scientists, and use Wikipedia to enforce this narrow and ideological “hidden rule”.</p><p>My case study into Wikipedia governance shows that if you break the hidden rule, or even if you are suspected of breaking the hidden rule in the future, Wikipedia’s skeptic community will begin to weaponize Wikipedia and other MediaWiki’s in bizarre <em>social vendettas</em> against the subjects.</p><p>While my case study focused on this particular subculture on Wikipedia, that was by the chance of the opportunity of the study––my case study simply shows that if this can happen in this one area of Wikipedia, it can happen everywhere. And where it happens there simply is no accounting of it when it does. And those controlling the editing permissions are all anonymous.</p><p>And it is a game to be played using a continually collapsing context and a rabbit hole of twisted logic and rationalizations which fly in the face of human dignity and collaborative consensus building, along with Wikipedia’s own five pillars of collaborative editing.</p><p><strong>Welcome to Wikipedia’s BLP-palooza!</strong></p><p>Let me give you some another example of how this game is played on Wikipedia. See for yourself. Be <em>skeptical</em> of the claims I make until you do.</p><p><strong>Tim Farley</strong> — an online skeptic influencer, often mentioned in this case study for his role in promoting Wikipedia editing, encouraging a community of “skeptics” to edit Wikipedia, <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tim_Farley">has his own Wikipedia article</a>.</p><p>Such accomplishment. Great skepticism. Wow.</p><p>Is he a notable programmer? Certainly <em>Not</em> by Wikipedia’s standards of Notability. Is he a notable writer? Nope. What is Tim Farley’s notability, at least in relation to the encyclopedia? Zero.</p><p>His claim to fame is a website he created called “What’s the Harm?”, which also is its own Wikipedia article, which is only cited by other skeptic organizations on the web, with no major publications. Yet his biography reads like his notability is well established and it reads like it is well established because to this small subculture on Wikipedia, it is notable, and that’s the hidden rule.</p><p><strong>“Biography of a Living Person: Tim Farley”</strong> on Wikipedia <a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20191101111608/https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Tim_Farley&amp;oldid=501497966">was written by</a> <strong>Susan Gerbic</strong>, and specifically <a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20191101111608/https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tim_Farley#References,_footnotes_and_selected_bibliography">using dozens of sources</a> that Wikipedia’s own policies of notability would not allow on any article. Additionally, she knows Tim <em>personally</em> and credits his lectures encouraging skeptics at TAM (The Amazing Meeting, a national gathering of members of skeptic organizations, hailing their “pope”, magician James Randi, and sharing the exploits in advancing skepticism) to edit Wikipedia as the inspiration for her to create <strong>Guerrilla Skeptics on Wikipedia</strong>.</p><p>Note the “warfare” terminology, “guerrilla”. Tactical. This brings a “battleground” mentality to “wiki wars” that has horrible consequences on the breakdown of Wikipedia’s governance system.</p><p>Not only does <strong>“Biography of a Living Person: Tim Farley”</strong> article fly in the face of WP: Notability policy, it was written with a clear Conflict of Interest by Susan Gerbic, someone who questionably is <em>funded to edit on Wikipedia</em>, thus technically being suspicious as “paid editing” to boot.</p><p>But it’s not a conflict of interest to them, and therefore, that is the rule that governs.</p><blockquote>I know him also and that seems a shame if we can’t work on this page because we personally know him. <strong>So I think as long as we are neutral there won’t be a problem.</strong> <a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20191101111608/https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/User:SGerbic">SGerbic</a> (<a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20191101111608/https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/User_talk:SGerbic">talk</a>) 00:18, 7 March 2011 (UTC)</blockquote><p>I’m fine with Tim having his bio on Wikipedia, truly––I could care less.</p><p>What I do have an issue with is the “two sets of rules” policy that this shadow community enforces. Especially when this group of activists editing Wikipedia use Wikipedia’s “notability” policy to suppress biographical information on subjects they don’t like.</p><p>In this great game on Wikipedia, the game of the “two sets of rules”, one group can control all the editing permissions on their own biographies and topics of cherry interest in addition to controlling all of the editing permissions on biographies of their targets pages.</p><p>For example, Tim Farley himself wrote a highly critical article of Deepak Chopra and the <a href="https://skeptools.wordpress.com/2013/12/11/quantum-wikipedia-rules-deepak-chopra-coi-conflict-interest/">conflict of interest for having individuals who knew Chopra edit</a> his Wikipedia article, bragging about how skeptics exposed Chopra for this on Wikipedia, bragging about how they took control of the permissions away from Deepak Chopra’s representative on his article.</p><blockquote><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20191101111608/https://twitter.com/hashtag/askdeepak?src=hash&amp;ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">#askdeepak</a> Why was your employee editing your biography on <a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20191101111608/https://twitter.com/hashtag/Wikipedia?src=hash&amp;ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">#Wikipedia</a> in clear violation of conflict-of-interest rules? <a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20191101111608/https://twitter.com/DeepakChopra?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">@DeepakChopra</a></blockquote><blockquote>— Tim Farley (@krelnik) <a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20191101111608/https://twitter.com/krelnik/status/410746819463749632?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">December 11, 2013</a></blockquote><p>Deepak Chopra is not only allowed but encouraged by WikiMedia Foundation to have a responsible representative on his article, a fact that Tim Farley misrepresents to his Twitter followers and directly violates on Wikipedia, thus preventing a biography of a living person the path of recourse promised them by the WikiMedia foundation.</p><p>Tim Farley, proud of the very skeptic activity on Wikipedia that he was a thought leader of, gloats back on Twitter when one of Deepak Chopra’s own representatives to Wikipedia gets blocked from editing, an action that was taken <a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20191101111608/http://wikipediawehaveaproblem.com/2016/03/factual-harassment-versus-fictional-harassment-wp-editor-manul-jytdog-and-deepak-chopra/">specifically by Farley’s own group of editors.</a></p><p>Two sets of rules.</p><p><strong>Play the game.</strong></p><p>See for <em>yourself. </em>My entire case study is falsifiable, especially around the work I did on Wikipedia on Rupert Sheldrake’s and Deepak Chopra’s BLP pages.</p><p><strong>Go to Sheldrake’s </strong><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20191101111608/https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rupert_Sheldrake">article</a><strong>.</strong></p><p>Question why the very first sentence of the article “<strong>Alfred Rupert Sheldrake</strong> (born 28 June 1942) is an English author and <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parapsychology">parapsychology</a> researcher” does not list “biologist” in the lede sentence and request the article reflects a common encyclopedia entry, despite this being an intrinsic and notable fact to his biography.</p><p>Don’t worry, this isn’t meat puppeting. It is an experiment. You don’t have to worry that this is a sneaky edit either, there are numerous primary, secondary, and tertiary sources that show Rupert Sheldrake is a biologist, including Cambridge University, where he published over 70 scientific papers, and traditional encyclopedias such as Encyclopedia Brittanica.</p><p>Chances are, <strong>“roxythedog”</strong> or another <a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20191101111608/https://evolutionnews.org/2017/10/wikipedia-erases-paleontologist-gunter-bechly/">Wikipedia skeptic “troll”</a> will come along to bait you and tell you that the page already has a consensus if you just go <a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20191101111608/https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Talk:Rupert_Sheldrake/Archive_10">check the archives </a>(all 22 pages of them even, going back years — which would take someone days to read).</p><p>If they try and label you a “woo promoter” for simply suggesting a non-controversial biographical fact to be inserted in the article, tell him you checked the archives, and it looks like far more editors support a more balanced lead than the article currently reflects.</p><p>Tell him that additionally, there was a consensus on Rupert Sheldrake’s BLP as a biologist for over seven years. Then inform them that <a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20191101111608/https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Rupert_Sheldrake&amp;diff=818798206&amp;oldid=564171899">it was removed from Sheldrake’s article </a><em>without a consensus,</em> with a freshly minted Wikipedia editing account making that their first edit on Wikipedia.</p><p>And lastly, try to have a reasonable discussion with them, getting them to explain their reasoning. Be professional.</p><p>Watch the contradictions fly around which Wikipedia policies they use to justify it.</p><p>Measure how long it takes them to visit your Wikipedia profile page, how long it takes them to escalate the conversation away from consensus on towards you own activities.</p><p><strong>Go to Deepak Chopra’s </strong><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20191101111608/https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deepak_Chopra">Wikipedia article</a><strong>.</strong></p><p>Again, the lede sentence: <strong>Deepak Chopra</strong> is an <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indian-American">Indian-American</a> author and <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alternative_medicine">alternative medicine</a> advocate.</p><p>Question why he isn’t listed as a MD, despite being a recognized endocrinologist as well as managing a medical staff at his center.</p><p>Ask them why were the edits made by SlimVirgin, an experienced senior Wikipedia editor, were reverted, as she corrected the article to meet Wikipedia’s policy at face value.</p><p>Greet <strong>Roxythedog</strong>, who also will show up there to greet you too. He won’t contribute anything of value to the conversation other than quick short rubs, such as “what that other editor told you”. He is probably trying to rile you up. Just continue to question and work collaboratively with them.</p><p>When you are done with this experiment––head over to the Wikipedia <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Fringe_theories/Noticeboard">“Fringe Noticeboards” </a>and watch these same editors who greet you gather their friends, giving them a heads up to your presence––note how they contextualize your participation.</p><p>Did the article change to reflect reality despite all of your reasoned attempts and interpretations of Wikipedia policy?</p><p>If similar events don’t happen to you that happened to me, I’ll halt publishing <strong>Wikipedia, We Have a Problem.</strong></p><p><strong>The problem with this is twofold.</strong></p><p>It’s not just that one voice dominates an article and one voice gets suppressed, it is that this sort of thing is allowed and supported within Wikipedia’s community.</p><p>If it can happen within this small set of articles and editors, it shows this can happen anywhere on Wikipedia. Left unchecked (which it is) it means this sort of toxic culture becomes continually enabled to continue it.</p><p><strong>Conclusion: Better governance design plagues Wikipedia as well as Web3</strong></p><p>I’m not trying to live up to my reputation amongst skeptics as a “notorious troll trying to disrupt Wikipedia” with my suggestion.</p><p>Developers of consensus algorithms and especially the entire world of web3, needs to study how Wikipedia has failed in governance, learn from those problems, and design a better collective editing and governance system.</p><p>If Web3 developers do not resolve the “permission” problem, they can look at Wikipedia governance as it has evolved over 20 years to see where they are heading.</p><p>If you wish to study this problem, the best way to do it is by jumping into Wikipedia with a clear intention to make the encyclopedia better in articles that have wiki wars on them. Identify non-controversial information in the article, and if it is being suppressed, question that. Hold that question directly to Wikipedia’s own Five Pillars. Try this yourself. Learn where it breaks down. Learn that these are the problems you are going to have to solve in designing better governance systems.</p><p>My eight year long case study into consensus building on Wikipedia in Wiki Wars was fortunate to absorb what seems like every possible strategy any consensus agent can use to disrupt rational consensus building and enforce a “hidden” set of rules.</p><p>From this study, I was able to complete a computational algorithm for online consensus building which offers novel permission assigning features which can emerge from online discussion and finally initiate <a href="https://aikiwiki.com/">Aiki Wiki</a>, the “win-win” protocol for the world wide web.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=da18dd350bca" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Rome Viharo published case study on Wikipedia troll farms, became focus of disinformation campaign…]]></title>
            <link>https://rome-viharo.medium.com/rome-viharo-publishes-case-study-on-wikipedia-troll-farms-becomes-focus-of-disinformation-campaign-98f664410cb1?source=rss-f6050efaa290------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/98f664410cb1</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Rome Viharo]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 30 Aug 2023 04:08:58 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-09-14T07:46:41.129Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Rome Viharo published case study on Wikipedia troll farms, became focus of disinformation campaign in response.</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*0PQP7M8UXzgQrsDKOC7qxQ.png" /></figure><blockquote>For the uninitiated, <a href="https://bigmotherdao.com/about-rome-viharo/">Rome Viharo</a> was/is <strong><em>Wikipedia’s Abused Stepson</em></strong>, the guy who tried to balance the BLP (“biography of a living person” to spell out the Wikipediaese) of Rupert Sheldrake which was being loaded to near-libel by the Guerrilla Skeptics, was kicked out of <strong>en.Wikipedia</strong>, then “earned” a very stupid article on RationalWiki, to which Viharo ran a blog trying to explain the mess titled <strong>Wikipedia, We Have a Problem </strong>(2013–2019)––<strong>Strelnikov;</strong> blogger, <a href="https://wikipedia-sucks-badly.blogspot.com/2021/12/rome-viharo-re-emerges.html">Wikipedia sucks and so do its critics.</a></blockquote><p>Wikipedia, as well as all other MediaWiki platforms––all share a singular notion about the brand “wiki” in common. A “Wiki” is a type of encyclopedia that “anyone can edit.”</p><p>While the platform architecture allows functionality that anyone can edit or participate, the community of editors follow another rule…while anyone can edit, not everybody should.</p><p>And if some can edit and not others, which others?</p><p>How do you decide who can and cannot edit an article?</p><p>When there is a dispute over this answer, a “wiki war” can emerge. Once a wiki war emerges, it becomes a battle of power, influence, perception and permission. Blood will be drawn, many GamerGates will happen.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*JCY_UEonL0nHrxWgZSl0pw.png" /></figure><p>Over the years, I, <a href="https://bigmotherdao.com/about-rome-viharo/"><strong>Rome Viharo</strong></a>, have found myself entangled in a web of bizarre yet creative deception while exploring the editor permission problem on Wikipedia and the phenomenon of “wiki wars” on controversial articles back in 2013. At the time I considered myself a Wikipedia idealist, fascinated by Wikipedia’s decentralized and open source structure, and even praising it for it’s potential for governance, something I highlighted in a 2011 TEDx talk that I gave about social media, governance, and story telling.</p><p>I volunteered to help edit a contentious Wikipedia article, being transparent about my research in conflict resolution, consensus building and collective editing, declaring myself “neutral” to any positions on the topic, I was simply agnostic to the situation and I could not have made this more clear to the Wikipedia editing community.</p><p>I posted this transparent declaration <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=User:Tumbleman&amp;oldid=574875932">Wikipedia in 2013</a>, as it is still preserved by the system of MediaWiki.</p><p>In response to my quite transparent declaration, I was doxxed, my privacy invaded, especially around years of research I was doing online, anonymously––and within a few weeks my anonymous editing account on Wikipedia was published as my actual identity on a MediaWiki site known as RationalWiki, treating me as if an internet kook researcher, promoter of pseudoscience who was caught “trolling” Wikipedia, and claiming me a conspiracy theorist about “skeptics editing Wikipedia”.</p><p>I encountered a variation of a troll farm, deeply embedded into Wikipedia’s architecture and governance. This has vastly informed <a href="https://aikiwiki.com/">Aiki Wiki, </a>a sophisticated computational algorithm for online consensus building, the exact project I informed them I was researching back in 2013.</p><p>Their concern with me was that my consensus that was building would achieve a majority consensus on the article––a permission to change the article. What they were running was a true strategy, quite effective on Wikipedia, for gaming Wikipedia’s system to control editing permissions.</p><p>To solve the editor permission problem, Wikipedia and MediaWiki gives “policing” power to determine who can and cannot edit over to a hierarchy of Wikipedia editors and admins, opening up something almost identical to an online digital governance system, with various levels of dispute resolution, all using MediaWiki, which actually delivers something close to a blockchain, a permanently stored archive of everything that gets published and which cannot be removed or altered.</p><p>I wanted to test every end of this process for my own research into online consensus building. To determine how editing permissions are distributed in an open system while not forcing censorship is not a trivial problem. Aiki Wiki too must have a solution to this problem, and the outcome of this research would determine if Aiki Wiki could even solve it at all.</p><p>So how far would the “heat” of our dispute take us across MediaWiki platforms? How far would this collective go from first applying various tactics of verbal bullying, personal attacks into deceptions about the narrative of who Rome Viharo is on the internet?</p><p><strong>I was determined to find out and find out I did.</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*o-s37V3v5v6dfO_xcqTJoQ.png" /></figure><p>What followed this research into consensus building on Wikipedia was one of the strangest, disturbing and yet rewarding experiences of my entire life.</p><p>This troll farm I encountered while editing Wikipedia was not motivated by money nor corporate interests, this troll farm was managed by activists within organizations that label themselves “skeptics” and operate a type of activism on Wikipedia, MediaWikis, blogging, Youtube and social media sites such as Reddit.</p><p>As self declared “skeptics”, they claim to battle online misinformation about science, <em>noice.</em></p><p><strong>But a troll farm is still a troll farm<em>, not nice.</em></strong></p><p>A search for my name will reveal a number one search return on Google as a RationalWiki entry still exists to this day.</p><p>Any “SEO” pro will note that this article on RationalWiki about me has five hundred backlinks within RationalWiki pointing back to the article. This, which combined with a high page ranking Google affords MediaWikis, insures that this article remains as a number one search return for my name, something that was optimized by someone within RationalWiki, and someone knowledgeable about gaming Google’s search algorithm.</p><p>This reflects a deeper flaw in MediaWiki software that creates a huge vulnerability for the web. Any MediaWiki is easily abused by malformed agents, and they rank fairly decently in Google search.</p><p>Many forks of Wikipedia emerged from unresolved “wiki wars”, with the losing side on Wikipedia simply creating their own “MediaWiki” that looks just like Wikipedia, but isn’t. From one wiki war on Wikipedia emerged Conservapedia––which then inspired RationalWiki to form to “battle them and troll them”.</p><p>All of this is empowered by MediaWiki platform, all of these created MediaWikis look like they could be Wikipedia, but are not. Governed by anonymous editing accounts and earning high page ranking for operating a wiki––a small handful of individuals can potentially influence thousands, hundreds of thousands even millions of people on the internet, creating causes for reactions that are so complex as to almost be uncountable.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*r_yuQ8OrFLC_OOKzAJhydw.png" /></figure><p>The claim that I was editing Wikipedia as part of my research into consensus building was continually suppressed on Wikipedia over eight years.</p><p>While these “skeptics” were discrediting the study to win editing permissions on Wikipedia, the WikiMedia Foundation published “Wikipedia, We Have a Problem” on their own wiki research project into platform harassment, as well as my case study also informed Google Jigsaw’s early LLM model which was testing for harassment on Wikipedia, at the time via their now ex-CTO, Lucas Dixon. WWHP even got one or two footnotes in a few college research papers.</p><p>The case study I published began to be distributed by other Wikipedia editors, citing it in disputes on Wikipedia, meaning that the case study, WWHP, began to get shared on Wikipedia talk pages, with a few other Wikipedia editors even questioning Jimbo Wales and directly mentioning it.</p><p>This is when a senior Wikipedia admin actually put www.wikipediawehaveaproblem on a <em>censored blacklisted site list</em>, with other Wikipedia editors informing Jimbo Wales that ‘Wikipedia We Have a Problem” is a website that publishes “very fringe views” expressed “far outside of the mainstream.”</p><p>RationalWiki is now stuck with an article about me that is world class piece of evidence of online targeted harassment and disinformation as performed by Wikipedia editors, to their own shame, and preserved in the wonderful decentralized architecture of MediaWikis.</p><p><strong>Flagwaving; how influence operations succeed by gaming Google SEO and MediaWiki</strong></p><p>Designers of Communities: This tactic WORKS in influencing online communities, this tactic your community must solve for.</p><p>What is this tactic? Let me show you. So who is Rome Viharo if you were doing a quick search say on Reddit?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*J6NXghaMs9AhFm3XYAs6Jg.png" /></figure><p>That return reads like a page, a quick summary. It is comprised of various headlines of posts that someone went through Reddit and posted, multiple times. It creates its own narrative that piggy backs off of the search return.</p><p>This type of strategy I call “flag waving consensus”, it is designed to produce a number of statements about an individual that appear factual because they are supported by links, making the search return function as an “ad hoc” article on someone.</p><p>99% of the time, no one bothers to actually check the links and verify the statements with the actual references used.</p><p>It’s a very genius strategy, I admit, if you are conducing online influence operations.</p><p>Social media sites, MediaWikis, and Google search are all very easily gamed by malformed agents, and any designer seeking to introduce governance systems needs to be aware of how extreme events can take.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*B60Ka1W5DThH33gD5z_fpA.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*9T_O3v48RcD1jWdnakza5A.png" /></figure><p>This strategy that was employed fooled hundreds if not thousands of people, dozens of online communities, including Wikipedia senior admins, including many journalists and, the irony, many skeptics themselves.</p><p>The other disturbing component to this is the sheer reach of its affect that requires a budget of zero dollars. These are orchestrated attacks that “hack” Google search algorithms, which rewards many of these sites with high page rank in spite of many of these platforms having zero recourse or accountability.</p><p><strong>What is the solution to this problem on the internet? What is anyone to do if it happens to them?</strong></p><p>There is zero solution to this problem on the web.</p><p>That’s pretty sobering. What’s more, big tech giants like Youtube and Google attempt to farm out solving for online misinformation to Wikipedia.</p><p><strong>Aiki Wiki was born from Wiki Wars and Ideological Conflicts</strong></p><p>Aiki Wiki, developed in response to the behaviors observed in the case study, is a discussion threading tool designed for conflict resolution. The structure only allows for pairs of editors to edit an article when they resolve a disagreement or misunderstanding of some kind.</p><p>It applies an algorithmic narrative structure to online conversations, transforming chaos into comprehensible narrative events.</p><p>This innovative tool provides a structured approach to conflict resolution and promoting healthier online interactions, while also filtering these more problematic events which emerge from breakdowns in governance in an an ever-emerging consensus process.</p><p>In my research I wanted a deep dive into whatever prevents a “win-win” collaboration emerging from online consensus discussion and I was able to distill the types of decisions and choices that prevent collaboration from occurring into three distinct arcs that can potentially emerge in conversation.</p><p><strong><em>Heat, Mirrors and Shadows</em></strong></p><p>The “triad of trials” in consensus building, which can be measured in the amount of “heat” generated when two agents in a system confront contradictions with each other, govern consensus systems by following the flow of a personalized conversation that can erupt into personal attacks and escalate into full blown “information warfare” including extreme acts of deception even attempts to subvert the actual system.</p><p>Wikipedia’s governance system actually rewards their editors who know how to <em>compete</em> in such an environment which can penalize editors when they attempt to <em>collaborate</em>, hence a breakdown in their governance.</p><p>Aiki Wiki resolves the editor permission problem by rewarding pairs of editors who build collaboration, while creating an insurmountable amount of work for any agent that seeks to use the system to compete, subvert, or attack.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=98f664410cb1" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Importance of the “Social Contract” in Decentralized Communities using Smart Contracts.]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/coinmonks/the-importance-of-the-social-contract-in-decentralized-communities-using-smart-contracts-80c9ad98411e?source=rss-f6050efaa290------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/80c9ad98411e</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[legal]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[decentralization]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[smart-contracts]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[social-contract]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Rome Viharo]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 06 May 2023 19:03:05 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-05-08T08:30:16.486Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Qu1BjBcz4JeqdZn4FBHl8g.jpeg" /></figure><p>All agreements and contracts in the world have three distinct contractual types, social contracts, legal contracts, and smart contracts, with each providing an intrinsic and important layer in one whole system of commerce and distribution.</p><p>Big Mother’s decentralized community is introducing a new property that can distribute social, legal, and smart contracts into one cohesive whole system.</p><p>Of the most importance is the social contract — social contracts form the foundation from which legal and smart contracts can emerge. If a social contract is unable to form in a community — then legal or smart contracts should not be issued.</p><p>This allows the social contract to “vet” members of a community around a shared purpose and here is how it can work.</p><p>First, let’s define a few things about contracts.</p><h4><strong>Social Contracts</strong></h4><p>Social contracts are friendly, flexible and flimsy — only as strong and dependable as the integrity of the individuals in a community.</p><p>Compare; dating is a type of social contract used today, whatever flexible terms people engaged in each other decide, it’s all just verbal communication and verbal agreement, relying on pure trust.</p><p>How important are social contracts with people you trust? Very. Some individuals are highly trustworthy and consistent; others flimsy, flakey, and undependable. Having strong social contracts with strong individuals is really the underlying governance of society and what influences all other types of contracts.</p><p>The idea of social contracts can be traced back to ancient civilizations, where unwritten rules and expectations were used to govern behavior and social relationships. It is likely predictable that social contracts would break down where social complexity would increase.</p><h4>Legal Contracts</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*sOItt5Snv49_DTtXWNEw-A.jpeg" /></figure><p>A social contract, dating — evolves into a legal contract, marriage. Likewise, a social contract, such as a purchase of goods, evolves into legal contracts as commerce.</p><p>The concept of legal contracts emerged in ancient Greece, Egypt and Rome, where social contracts become too flimsy, new “legal” contracts were seen as binding agreements that could be enforced in a court of law. Over time, the use of written contracts became more widespread, and contract law developed into a specialized area of legal governance.</p><p>We can see that legal contracts become more flimsy as society became more complex in the 20th-21st centuries, and to solve for this, new contract types emerged.</p><h4>Smart Contracts</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*l0Z-MK5ZyVASwCiHY50a7A.jpeg" /></figure><p>The concept of smart contracts is a more recent development, which emerged with the rise of blockchain technology and cryptocurrency. Smart contracts use computer code to automatically execute the terms of an agreement, without the need for intermediaries, i.e. law firms.</p><p>Overall, the evolution of contracts has been shaped by changes in technology, society, and legal systems. While social contracts have been used for centuries to govern social relationships, legal contracts and smart contracts are more recent developments that reflect changes in the way that people transact and do business.</p><p>All three types of contracts can co-exist, work alongside each other and distribute through a community marketplace called the “Bootstrapping Arts and Engineering” (BAE) marketplace.</p><h4>Contract unification via CopyCake™</h4><p>BAE has an innovation called <a href="https://bigmotherdao.com/what-is-copycake/">“CopyCake™”</a> which allows multiple contract types including social contracts to become bundled and distributed together, creating novel properties.</p><p>Through the BAE marketplace, CopyCake allows for legal contracts in the form of equity financing contracts and copyright royalty stream contracts to become distributive in a compliant fashion through a blockchain.</p><p>To accomplish this, artists on the BAE marketplace register their creative work with the US Copyright Office along with a blockchain address, which puts the smart contract location as a congruent component of the copyrighted work.</p><p>Copyright contracts are created by community artists whenever they create a body of work that can be sold, with the proceeds going to engineering startups.</p><p>The artists sell their creative work including the formal royalty stream for that creative work — and distribute the profits from the work on the blockchain directly towards the engineering startup technology companies.</p><p>When any given work of art is sold and distributed in BAE, the holder of the art work is awarded ownership of 66% of the Copyright Royalty Stream of the art they purchased. This means they will receive 66% of all sales against the copyrighted work, through sales of lithographs, serigraphs, special editions.</p><p>The startups act as equity companies, and pledge to match equity value to the copyright value of the registered work.</p><p>CopyCake™ Smart contracts allow Copyright contracts and equity contracts to become distributed as single contracts in a digital wallet, fully within compliance of US Securities.</p><p>Once registered, the smart contract becomes indistinguishable from the copyright contract and can be potentially matched to an equity contract in the digital wallet, such as a Reg A+ Security Token for example.</p><h4>The “Bootstrapping Arts and Engineering” Marketplace</h4><p>The BAE marketplace only sells artwork, specifically a very large art collection that follows a narrative theme. The proceeds from the sale of the art work are directed towards the engineering startups.</p><p>The collection is sold in three acts, with each scene containing unique one-of-a-kind works of art with unique distributive properties.</p><p>The first scene costs $120, and anyone who purchases it owns the retail side of the Scene Two contract, which costs $360 while making the following scene in the narrative story available.</p><p>Owners of the creative work become distributors in the narrative which allows them to own the retail side of the following contract, or 2/3rds of the purchase price.</p><p>When each scene sells, 1/3rd of the price is distributed to the engineering startups who have equity contracts, and the artist’s reward the distributor with formal copyright royalty stream ownership of the work of art they purchased.</p><p>This introduces the first novel distributive property of BAE, ownership is assigned after the owner sells an asset, whatever they sell they can paradoxically also own.</p><p>This distributed property, ⅓ to ⅔ produces a dynamic where 1x is distributed as 2x back to a wallet holder.</p><h4>The necessity of a social contract to prevent abuse</h4><p>What prevents such a system from being abused or used fraudulently? This is where the social contract comes into play.</p><p>When individuals are invited to participate in the BAE marketplace, they form a social contract that expresses enthusiasm for the shared purpose of the community and trust in the smart contract that distributes the funds from the sale of artwork. They learn that a “smart contract” will distribute twice the amount they put into the marketplace back into their wallet. What do they want to do with that return?</p><p>Only those who commit to the purpose of the community and agree in a “social contract” to distribute those funds back into the community are invited to purchase a formal legal contract (Copyright Royalty Stream) in the form of a “smart contract”.</p><p>In the context of the BAE marketplace, social contracts play an important role in maintaining momentum and fostering a sense of community among participants.</p><p>The BAE marketplace creates a decentralized “co-fund” where 1/3 of the funds from the sale of artwork goes towards engineering projects, and 2/3 goes towards community projects building on top of the engineering projects.</p><p>While the smart contracts ensure that the retail price of one scene will return twice that amount in the following scene, it is the social contract that creates trust among community members to put those funds towards the purpose of the community, and not turn it into a “flip” like day traders marketplaces.</p><h4>The Co-Fund System</h4><p>By combining smart contracts and social contracts, the BAE marketplace creates a decentralized “co-fund” system. The use of a co-fund in the BAE marketplace can help to build momentum in several ways.</p><p>First, it creates a sense of shared purpose and community among participants, as they are all working towards a common goal. This can help to maintain interest and enthusiasm for the marketplace over time.</p><p>Second, the use of a co-fund allows participants to pool their resources and invest in the acquisition of more scenes in the BAE marketplace. This can help to accelerate the growth of the marketplace and allow it to reach its goals more quickly.</p><p>Third, the use of a co-fund can help to preserve equity in the engineering startups involved in the marketplace. By using the 2/3 of the purchase price from the sale of artwork to fund the co-fund, participants can avoid diluting equity in the startups, while still contributing to the growth and success of the community.</p><p>Overall, the use of a co-fund in the BAE marketplace can help to build momentum by creating a sense of shared purpose and community, accelerating the growth of the marketplace, and preserving equity in the engineering startups involved. This can help to ensure the long-term success and sustainability of the marketplace.</p><p>In summary, the BAE marketplace is an example of how legal, social, and smart contracts can be used in combination to create novel dynamics useful for community funding and cooperation. Social contracts play a critical role in building trust and maintaining momentum, and the use of a co-fund can help to preserve equity in engineering startups while accelerating the growth of the marketplace.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=80c9ad98411e" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/coinmonks/the-importance-of-the-social-contract-in-decentralized-communities-using-smart-contracts-80c9ad98411e">The Importance of the “Social Contract” in Decentralized Communities using Smart Contracts.</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/coinmonks">Coinmonks</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[“Eat my Tongue!” The Decentralized Distributive brilliance of Tibetan Buddhism.]]></title>
            <link>https://rome-viharo.medium.com/eat-my-tongue-the-decentralized-distributive-brilliance-of-tibetan-buddhism-14eabe4e89ae?source=rss-f6050efaa290------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/14eabe4e89ae</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[dalai-lama]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[governance]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[tibetan-buddhism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[tongue]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[decentralization]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Rome Viharo]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 15 Apr 2023 18:40:13 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-10-09T16:23:45.453Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>“First, the condition is you must give me a hug. Next, the condition is you must touch your forehead with my forehead. Next you must rub my nose with your nose. Next, you have to give me a kiss. Now, eat my tongue — LOL.”</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/640/0*lwmNPNHm6H_fEWGp" /></figure><p>This is how Tibetan grandparents and elderly culturally and literally “troll” their grandchildren.</p><p>Tibetan grandparents and elders have a playful cultural tradition when a child asks for a treat, gift, or money, they must go through a series of affectionate <em>negotiations</em>, like hugging, touching foreheads, rubbing noses, and even sticking out their tongues. This seemingly innocent and humorous exchange recently turned into a media nightmare for the Dalai Lama.</p><p>A recent event showed the Dalai Lama engaging in this traditional exchange with a child who approached him for a hug.</p><p>Out of context this interaction appeared sinister, leading to the Dalai Lama being accused of child pedophilia.</p><p>The spread of this disinformation was shockingly fast and far-reaching, causing significant damage to his reputation exactly one week after the Dalai Lama <a href="https://www.yahoo.com/lifestyle/dalai-lama-identifies-reincarnation-mongolias-122705929.html">confirmed the transfer of governance of the body of Tibetan Buddhism to Mongolia</a>, neither to India, nor Tibet, nor China.</p><p>Anyone focusing on governance in online communities, please pay attention — this is likely not what you think.</p><p>The explosion of disinformation and its consequences is a central focus of research and development of <a href="https://aikiwiki.com/">Conversational Game Theory</a>, which introduces a governance consensus process that teases out disinformation that arise in disputes over governance. While our system of governance is quite humble, applying to small online communities, the patterns are the same no matter the governance system.</p><p>The incident involving the Dalai Lama was a carefully crafted <em>disinformation</em> campaign.</p><p>The video was edited to emphasize a seemingly <em>child-threatening</em> moment, and it was combined with incendiary words like pedophilia, religion, slavery, and the CIA.</p><p>The campaign tapped into existing paranoia and anti-religious sentiment, weaving a narrative that exploited people’s fears and suspicions.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*X38zIc_KOlEZUjwM.jpg" /></figure><p>The disinformation campaign incorporated a mix of skepticism, political propaganda, and justifications for historical events, such as the invasion of Tibet and the Dalai Lama’s exile.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.tiktok.com%2Fembed%2Fv2%2F7221287162606685486&amp;display_name=tiktok&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.tiktok.com%2F%40dailywire%2Fvideo%2F7221287162606685486&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fp16-sign.tiktokcdn-us.com%2Fobj%2Ftos-useast5-p-0068-tx%2Fdc8c492e73e6403eb402098a517de3f1_1681345811%3Fx-expires%3D1681700400%26x-signature%3DiWctDS9t3tU6vgSaG%252BYsLVcyujQ%253D&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=tiktok" width="340" height="700" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/8510eab946dfff66e74e08d72eb0b2d6/href">https://medium.com/media/8510eab946dfff66e74e08d72eb0b2d6/href</a></iframe><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.tiktok.com%2Fembed%2Fv2%2F7220622143430675755&amp;display_name=tiktok&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.tiktok.com%2F%40dantethehater%2Fvideo%2F7220622143430675755&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fp16-sign.tiktokcdn-us.com%2Ftos-useast5-p-0068-tx%2Fefead56a5f3645d6a4344a534a59c1c1_1681182113%7Etplv-dmt-logom%3Atos-useast5-i-0068-tx%2F8ed4e378d2c84e01bc10170cea7e4062.image%3Fx-expires%3D1681700400%26x-signature%3DPfyZylN6oyVWaHlPpBlTgpMvmos%253D&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=tiktok" width="340" height="700" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/f46645c36e0554cee95093247bba1018/href">https://medium.com/media/f46645c36e0554cee95093247bba1018/href</a></iframe><p>It even included a segment from the HBO show Bullshit with skeptic entertainers Penn and Teller, which questioned the Dalai Lama’s credibility and Tibet’s history of slavery. Combining different viewpoints and critiques into one event.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.tiktok.com%2Fembed%2Fv2%2F7221363263668325674&amp;display_name=tiktok&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.tiktok.com%2F%40freehatezone%2Fvideo%2F7221363263668325674&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fp19-sign.tiktokcdn-us.com%2Fobj%2Ftos-useast5-p-0068-tx%2Ffbda37ba14c14e1bb0ecebb91a2a4627%3Fx-expires%3D1681700400%26x-signature%3DNJ%252F49EHUw7XsnLjIRNaP3%252FtzwL8%253D&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=tiktok" width="340" height="700" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/61e7f02d49e409688acd93fe5ebfbff4/href">https://medium.com/media/61e7f02d49e409688acd93fe5ebfbff4/href</a></iframe><p><strong>Governance is a touchy subject.</strong></p><p>From the viewpoint of <strong>Conversational Game Theory</strong> and conflict resolution; disinformation smear campaigns can be <em>predicted</em> to happen at specific instances of what are essentially <em>governance disputes</em> over the distribution of power in a consensus process to control the narrative about the governance process itself.</p><p>I can completely avoid the obvious elephant in the room in regards to the political relationship the Dalai Lama has with China because that part is <em>irrelevant</em> in the governance problem that is trying to be solved here.</p><h3><strong>Tibet’s Narrative Theme for Distributive Governance</strong></h3><p>Tibetan Buddhism formed the nation that we know of today as Tibet over a thousand years ago, and Tibet was the very first nation that adopted Buddhism directly into their governance.</p><p>As Tibet adopted this new form of governance, the nation <em>demilitarized</em>, something that was unthinkable, even now. While many western nations at the time were flying the banner of Christianity’s “turning swords into plowshares”, Tibet was the only nation to ever achieve that.</p><p>While there is indeed plenty reasons to criticize feudal societies from the point of view of comfortable Western 21st century viewpoints, when Tibet formed one thousand years ago, all societies were feudal <em>if they were lucky</em>, and in comparison, Tibet was a <em>feudal utopia.</em></p><p>Tibet turned a nation of warriors into a nation of monks. At it’s peak, Tibet was a nation of 8,000 monasteries innovating the “Tulku” narrative tradition. The Buddhist concept of “rebirth”, which is a distinct concept from “reincarnation”, allowed power to be distributed via a form of “magical realism”.</p><p>Tibet truly introduced a novel solution to the transfer of power problem long before Europe rediscovered the Greeks and established Western Democracy in 1776.</p><p><strong>The Transfer of Power Problem.</strong></p><p>The “Transfer of Power” problem is proof that society can achieve something close to a “perfect” form of governance under certain conditions. What are these conditions?</p><p>Historically, a “perfect” form of governance has existed any time there is a “good ruler”. The best possible type of governance is governance where all decisions are centralized by the most intelligent and compassionate individuals capable of making wise choices and <em>therein lay the problem.</em></p><p><em>How do the good rulers, good kings pass on their power to other good rulers and good kings, and not bad ones?</em></p><p>In simple terms, the “good ruler, bad ruler” transfer of power problem poses a challenge for societies to ensure that power is transferred from one effective leader to another without devolving into chaos or tyranny.</p><p>Tibet’s system of governance integrated Buddhist monks directly into the governing body, transforming the nation from a warrior society into a monastic one that was able to maintain itself for <em>one thousand years</em>.</p><p>The Tibetans discovered a thousand years ago that they could develop a customizable narrative theme that could become its own form of governance, a tradition of <em>Termas, Tertons, and Tulkus.</em></p><p>The innovative Tulku system, which is based on the concept of rebirth, was introduced as a decentralized solution to the transfer of power problem.</p><p>This system enabled even the poorest citizens to potentially be discovered as “reincarnated” Lamas, Karmapas, or even the Dalai Lama.</p><p>By distributing power through the Tulku system, Tibet ensured that their leaders were not only raised under Buddhist principles but also pledged to continually be reborn into their communities, studying their whole lives the <em>methods</em> of compassionate service, a form of governance based on <em>loving kindness</em>.</p><p>Any Tibetan who dedicated themselves to the study of a unique type of imaginative self-immersion could become a “Terton”.</p><p>A “Terton” is an individual who becomes self-actualized and discovers a “terma”–– a teaching that provides insight that magically appears <em>only when necessary</em>.</p><p>The notion of “rebirth” is often clouded in the west due to our projections of “supernatural beliefs”; but in the context of governance, the notion of re-birth implies a type of recapitulating social responsibility, whatever actions are made by a ruler in one lifetime, they inherit when returning to the next life time.</p><p>Thus, a poor farmer’s child could discover that he was the re-birth of a high lama, and now that monastery and its wealth have been successful transferred from “rich to poor”.</p><p>It is obvious to see the misunderstanding––consider Marxists “dialectical materialism”, in the eyes of the PRC which has a completely different world view have no frame-work with which to measure that transfer of power because concepts like re-birth are simply superstitious.</p><p>It is almost an impossible negotiation, for it is a position that must assume “bad faith”, and the more well intentioned the PRC, the greater the degree of the confusion and frustration.</p><p><strong>So what transpired recently?</strong></p><p>The Dalai Lama recently confirmed a <a href="https://www.yahoo.com/lifestyle/dalai-lama-identifies-reincarnation-mongolias-122705929.html">transfer of power</a> within their tradition to a young child who is claimed to be a re-birth of Mongolian spiritual leader, a “dalai lama” of Mongolia.</p><p>Establishing Mongolia, neither India, China nor Tibet, as the continuation of decentralized Tibetan Buddhist governance, Tibetan Buddhism is still spreading, even gaining territory!</p><p>This power transfer made headlines about a week before the disinformation campaign reached its peak online, with TikTok being particularly aggressive in the US with it.</p><p>For many Westerners, the significance of this event may not be immediately clear and may even seem strange and bizarre.</p><p>However, this rebirth tradition represents more than just a myth or a religious belief system, it is literally a form of distributive decentralization of power, and Tibetan Buddhism is larger and power expansive now in the 21st Century than it ever was before China invaded/liberated Tibet.</p><p>China and the PRC are in the frustrating position; every act of “liberation” the PRC forces on the Tibetan Buddhists creates a larger body of Tibetan Buddhism governance that will always elude a centralization effort by its natural design.</p><p>Independent of the esoteric Buddhist imagery, it is a system of decentralized power distribution that transcends national and international boundaries, capable of transferring across borders, and surpassing laws of nations and military force, with no blockchain or army or bank required.</p><p>Such an impressive distribution of power is bound to be frustrating for any governance structure, whether well-intentioned or otherwise.</p><p>Lacking any other mechanism to assimilate the decentralized structure, the only remaining option is to undermine the identity of the individual perceived to be distributing the power.</p><p>This is predicted to occur, almost like Game Theory, and almost exactly like election cycles. Politicians always need a “bogey man” a “demon” for which a common cause can be identified.</p><p>What any agency applying such a tactic strategically cannot see in the big picture is that the application of this strategy is more than just a sign their overall strategies are failing, it is an emergic algorithmic event that shows they have <em>already lost</em> and have yet to realize it.</p><p>I am intentionally walking a very fine line in between conflicting viewpoints to show you <em>those are irrelevant</em>. There is something else more interesting to learn here.</p><p>We can assume that all nations have the ideal governance for their societies and that all nations have competent rulers and leaders. They all have the same identical problem. The problem with all forms of governance is that some leaders are good people, and some leaders are corrupt.</p><p>How do we tell the difference, and how do the good people get the jobs?</p><p>How do we transfer power from good people to good people, seamlessly?</p><p><em>This is the problem of all governance communities, centralized or decentralized.</em></p><p>What all governance systems share in common are the steps between “conflict” and “resolution” in the transfer of those powers.</p><p>Conversational Game Theory utilizes an algorithmic approach to consensus building, identifying only nine possible outcomes that can arise from conflict to resolution.</p><p><strong>Thank you Professor Robert Thurman</strong></p><p>Tibet first caught my attention in 2020 when I learned about their remarkable contributions to governance, listening to Professor Robert Thurman of Columbia University’s many podcasts shed light on Tibet’s incredible one-thousand-year-old legacy.</p><p>The appeal to me was how imaginative Tibetan Buddhism was. As wild and as far out Tibetan thinking is, they are quite upfront about it all just being “created in the mind” and <em>not</em> something that is inherently “real”.</p><p>Professor Thurman described it like science fiction, and 2020 Covid isolations gave me months of study into this intriguing culture that surprisingly I realized I knew almost nothing about––a system of governance that is informed by science fiction yet grounded and rooted in a very analytical system, the magical realism of Tibetan Buddhism may be more relevant now than ever.</p><p>Tibet’s unique system is worth learning about and applying in our age of decentralized artificial intelligence systems. Tibet’s innovative solution to the transfer of power problem is still active and unfolding in real-time.</p><p>Tibetan Buddhism is proving that their <em>seamless decentralized structure</em> is <em>virtually impossible to suppress</em>, emerging under any circumstances that attempt to contain it.</p><p>It is fitting to honor Tibet in this manner. A millennium ago, while the rest of the world was embroiled in violent conquest, they introduced an enlightened distributive governance system akin to that of the ancient Greeks.</p><p>What sets the Tibetan system apart is that it doesn’t require a violent revolution to propagate and expand. Today, it thrives more than ever, disseminated and shared with billions worldwide.</p><p>This is where disinformation campaigns can backfire. While they can be remarkably effective at rapidly spreading misleading information, they eventually fail, inadvertently distributing the very knowledge they sought to suppress.</p><p>We do not need to own Bitcoin, or even care about it, to acknowledge that its distributive properties work better for distributing and storing wealth than centralized banks.</p><p>Likewise, we do not even need to be a Buddhist or believe in the concept of re-birth and Buddhas from other worlds to appreciate the world’s first decentralized governance system play out in real time, one thousand years since its inception.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=14eabe4e89ae" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Romantic Non-Duality and the Gender Debate.]]></title>
            <link>https://rome-viharo.medium.com/romantic-non-duality-and-the-gender-debate-402a5cd9df3e?source=rss-f6050efaa290------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/402a5cd9df3e</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[lgbtq]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[jordan-peterson]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[gender-identity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[dialectical-materialism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[dialectics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Rome Viharo]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 28 Jan 2023 21:07:27 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-02-02T18:00:30.980Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/602/1*03KRRYVRcmQo0DRtWFUpJg.jpeg" /></figure><p>I have found every single public conversation about the role of genders, penises, vaginas and bathrooms in society to be a completely cringe experience, regardless if the views have ethical validity, political validity, or cultural validity.</p><p>I include in this both the voices expressed by Jordan Peterson, Dave Chappelle as equally as I do the many strong voices in the LGBTQ community.</p><p><em>All of them suck and are cringe.</em></p><p>Right, wrong or indifferent, every single viewpoint expressed has simply inflamed society with zero resolution on the horizon and they all truly suck at solving the issues and concerns that each are raising.</p><p>Why do all of these conversations around the roles of gender, sexuality, and bathrooms absolutely suck and more importantly, who am I to even say they do?</p><p>I suppose I have some explaining to do.</p><p>Well, for one I am the designer of a consensus building algorithm, so I probably pay far closer attention to public debate than most.</p><p>Of all the social and cultural conversations, the one around gender are the most interesting to me since genders already have this binary and non-binary quality inherent in all of the discussions, making it ripe for misunderstanding but also easy for resolution.</p><p>My main focus as a “discussion” engineer are the psychological dynamics between <em>conflict and resolution</em> as a one whole system. That is actually my own area of expertise, “whole system design and engineering”.</p><p>But this would only <em>partially</em> explain why I have the view I do.</p><p>The other explanation is that I wish to represent a horribly <em>underrepresented</em> view in the gender debate, the view of the <em>“romantic”.</em></p><p>By view of the romantic, I of course mean the thrill of idealization, to be romantic in society is to idealize our values.</p><p>A “romantic” society is a society that would, in principle, support the shared ideals of all citizens.</p><p>While “romantic” of course could refer to the classic “pitching of woo” or courting between mutually interested and attracted individuals, “to romanticize” society or civilization would mean to view each role in its idealized form, many of which having nothing to do with any Valentinian ideals.</p><p>Being romantic to me is just “fun” and part of what makes life not <em>tolerable</em>, like political positions only hope to achieve, but <em>enjoyable.</em></p><p>Here is the kicker, historically speaking, orthodox cultures tend to suppress not just homosexuality and women, but also suppress romantic love between <em>both</em> men <em>and</em> women.</p><p>Even recently a dancing couple, man and woman, were arrested in <a href="https://www.cnn.com/2023/02/01/middleeast/iran-couple-dancing-prison-intl/index.html">Iran for expressing their love publically</a> while <em>kissing in public</em> is against the law in many eastern and asian countries.</p><p>Historically speaking, the tendency of the orthodoxy is to suppress the <em>romantic</em> and I propose that homosexual relationships emerge from romanticism itself, so all individuals should embrace the Romantic for designing celebratory solutions to deep cultural issues.</p><p><strong>Coming out as a romantic is quite liberating</strong></p><p>All this means in terms of my own personal relationships, I romanticize the type of emotional and sexual bonding experience I would like to have in my own personal life, and everything else is none of your business.</p><p>I fully and proudly admit that I am a mature romantic man. There, I said it and it felt good. Unfortunately, not everyone has that luxury, but Romanticism encourages that everyone <em>should.</em></p><p>But I also romanticize culture, languages, all sorts of things that have nothing to do with mating.</p><p>I’ll even be honest and admit that it even makes me feel kind of noble to become such a romantic, I can even descend into romanticizing my own romanticism!</p><p>Coming out as a “romantic man” is something I owe thanks to the public debate on penises, vaginas and bathrooms…because I had to ask myself, why do all of these discussions on gender on all sides make me want to cringe?</p><p>Why do they make me want to feel so…so…so <em>offended</em>?</p><p>Is it just the lure of social media compelling me to feel offended so I can fit into the national conversation, or is it something deep that I have tucked away in the darker recesses of my own psychology?</p><p>So I had to do a lot of “soul searching” to find what part of me wanted to feel so offended by every single Tik Tok clip, Jordan Peterson soapbox, LGBT Twitter activist I encountered.</p><p>I quite enjoy diversity, am I that shallow to be offended because I am a man attracted to women, a “<em>noble</em> romantic”????</p><p>Please, say it ain’t so.</p><p>And that’s when it hit me, the reason I felt so “offended” was because the term “CISgender” sounds to me like something that needs to be removed in an operation. Gross!!!</p><p>I discovered that I am somewhat superficial in this regard, I found these discussions unappealing because I could not find anything that I could <em>idealize.</em></p><p>Completely erased in this term “cisgender” is any kind of ideal that would appeal to anyone of romantic inclination or romantic idealization.</p><p>While I do not expect nor assume everyone should view the world through the eyes of a romantic, I think most are moved or influenced by what are romantic ideals and I think that is what is making parts of our culture feeling “protective” of.</p><p>This is just marketing 101. If the LGBTQ community wants large adoption and acceptance of their positions, y’all just need better <em>branding</em>.</p><p>Consider who wants a cis on their gender? Utterly unappealing proposition and <em>impossible to idealize. </em>Not to mention, good luck convincing billions of males that they are “cissies”. Never going to fly. You are doomed to Facebook ad buys for the rest of your life if you somehow think that one will go over.</p><p>Cisgender is a technical and clinical term, absolutely appropriate when used in clinical analysis, yet entirely inappropriate as any type of cultural signifier. And thanks to social media, clinical and legal terms become weaponized as misinformed Twitter rants, amplifying confusion about these terms.</p><p><strong><em>We need to idealize the resolution</em></strong></p><p>This is a cultural thing, so we need to address cultural idealization of form and use it to our <em>collective</em> advantage so we can build consensus quickly.</p><p>But before your wicked little political mind goes there, I am not putting the blame on the LGBT community for this any more than I am putting the blame on Jordan Peterson. Remember <em>they both suck at this</em>, they both are distributing more and more <em>confusion</em> about sexual and gender relationships in society.</p><p>And they both suck for this not because of the views they are expressing, the underlying issues, but because they both are using the same crappy form of dialectics that has its roots in Karl Marx’s Dialectical Materialism.</p><p>And while dialectics themselves are supposed to follow elegant ternary structures, we don’t get that any more, we get dualistic white or black arguments and shouting, win or lose, this side versus that side.</p><p>This is why Jordan Peterson makes me cringe in these arguments because he should know better, his grand assault against “socialism” and the progressive left is using the same faulted dialectics he criticizes.</p><p>Jordan Peterson is using Marxist dialectics to confront other Marxist dialectics that have since evolved into Critical Theory, Critical Race Theory, and Critical Gender Theory.</p><p>And he cheerfully does this by being fit into very handsome fashion-for-men tailored suits, building his audience with his lean frame and style sense that would give any gay man a run for his money.</p><p>Jordan Peterson is selling society on the “fight” and the critique, making it look good even, for him to stand-up and build a large monthly activated audience on his podcasts and videos.</p><p>Would Jordan Peterson have this much attention if he was just talking about the deconstruction of the modern male psyche? No of course not, what puts Jordan Peterson on the map are his public confrontations, and these are simply just great for business, great for distribution, great for awareness building, but utterly failing in any workable and practical way.</p><p>So it becomes like theater, basically.</p><p>Marxist theater, of all things, is the coup d’etat of the postmodernists.</p><p>Someone please, drain my blood.</p><p><strong>Thesis, Antithesis, Antithesis, Antithesis ad nauseum, thank you social media</strong></p><p>When it comes to Peterson and the LGBT, both are using dialectics that confront a strong “thesis” entering society, a “critique” of that thesis, or an “antithesis”.</p><p>The focus is on “critique”, independent of the underlying debate.</p><p>Now before your wicked little political mind goes there, I am not putting the blame on forming critiques of structures in society, not by any means, nor does this have <em>anything to do with the political concepts of socialism, capitalism, or communism. Zip!</em></p><p>I am suggesting that by focusing on the critique in a “critique versus critique” battle which erupts cultural division is simply incomplete and in many cases irresponsible and it&#39;s also social media 2023.</p><p>Karl Marx never ever foresaw something like the internet, which is keeping society stuck in an “antithesis” phase spiraling downwards into dystopia.</p><p>Because Karl Marx could not foresee the internet, his prediction of a homeostasis that would eventually emerge from historical dialectics is now moot.</p><p>It is pointless to even attempt to apply Marxist dialectics in our current global mass media/tech landscape because our environment is already applying it at scale, albeit in a haphazard non-resolving fashion.</p><p>Karl Marx never saw that a technology could emerge which would be influenced by all the forces he discussed but would prevent the resolution of those discussions from<em> ever forming.</em></p><p>Why? Because everyone is focused on the critique, and power and fame and influence only support the critique, and never the resolution.</p><p>Why? Because the resolution to the critique destroys the power structure that creates the critique, or at least it appears that way to those invested in the struggle, the anti-thesis, the thorough deconstruction of the other.</p><p>The resolution to the critique is an environment of shared power between the thesis and antithesis. So in principle, no power is lost in the resolution, it is merely shared, and by shared, thereby expanded.</p><p>Unfortunately, Google and Facebook have optimized all algorithms for the rather annoying “antithesis” building stage which simultaneously dampen all resolution building channels.</p><p>And this last part is where we are stuck circa 2023.</p><p>Social media rewards the critique or “antithesis”, and enables any view to build a “network of support”, at scale, that will enable that view to “double-down” and “fight hard”, all measurable in clicks and CPMS.</p><p>Is it ironic that “social” media has turned everyone into a Marxist dialectician, distributing their critiques of society which become amplified by media buys and algorithms?</p><p>This means we are stuck in a cycle of division, “thesis versus thesis” or “viewpoint versus viewpoint” which never actually get to “come to meetup” to create a synthesis, but become empowered to become aggressively dominate in an oscillating cycle of up or down in a non-resolving and recapitulating struggle where everyone just kind of loses and no one comes out ahead.</p><p>With the exception of our influencers, the psycho-social-political thought leaders whom define the boundaries of the cultural conversation.</p><p>We tend to ignore that our influencers are usually wrong and fail; yet our political influencers already know this vulnerability and here is where they make their only guaranteed deliverable; they promise their followers and those influenced by their thinking that for as long as they follow them, they will always be “right” in the social battle for “right and wrong”.</p><p>And this is where anger, rage, even emotional breakdown, become very effective yet highly manipulative tools used by many of our political and social influencers.</p><p>Indeed, most movements in history may start out valiant, purposeful and quite necessary, but once attention forms around social leaders; a new incentive opens up.</p><p>And through it all they will always believe they are right and so are all of their followers always right.</p><p>Now, a whole system designer is going to look at the environmental and psychological forces happening and say “wow- Jordan Peterson and the most inflamed of the LGTBQ community both need each other to maintain their power within their own communities.”</p><p>Social leaders of ideological movements now require their “opponents” in the struggle to maintain power!</p><p>Social leaders have power because of the <em>struggle</em>, and <em>will lose power</em> when the resolution to that struggle presents itself.</p><p>This means that social leaders have <em>zero</em> personal incentive to seek and build resolution and every incentive to maintain the struggle, and likely many of these motivational psychological forces are even unconscious.</p><p>Why does this always happen? Simple, by focusing on the antithesis, the <em>resolution can never form.</em></p><p>The critique is just a step in the resolution in all dialectics.</p><p>However, the media rewards the critique and never the resolution, thus, here we are with one huge cringe conversation.</p><p>The critique makes you famous, while the resolution becomes the enemy to your fame.</p><p>And it is the resolution that culture and society requires, not the critique.</p><p><strong>So here we are.</strong></p><p>So as a whole system consensus designer, I want to know what the resolution looks like, not the critique.</p><p>And as a romantic, I want the resolution to have cross boundary appeal to every single individual, something that everyone would want to adopt, and ideally adoption that is natural, requiring neither law enforcement nor protest to emerge, rather something we can all celebrate.</p><p><strong>The Romantic Liberation</strong></p><p>And as a romantic I hope all types of minds, personalities, sexualities or genders can have and express “romantic” relationships too, I don’t think that being “romantic” is something that is “gender serving” by any means.</p><p>And I can acknowledge that, in comparison, my view is very narrow, I am a romantic man who keeps falling in love with women, over and over. Foolishly even. And that’s about the limit of my experience in this matter.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/436/1*So-G92MC0TZ4oCiN31voNw.jpeg" /></figure><p>Yet I happen to know that many gay men and women also enjoy romantic experiences, and many of them also make very very foolish choices that I can relate to.</p><p>And all one needs to do is grow up reading Marvel comics to know that romantic experiences can be had between any “two” individuals, normal or strange, for any reason any of us could never even imagine, the variations of this are as likely as varied as our imaginations.</p><p><strong>Romantic seeking is our “oneness”, our “non-duality”</strong></p><p>Gay, straight, weird, bizarre, who cares. What we all share in common is having or seeking romantic experiences with another person, we all wanna tango at the end of the day.</p><p>So if we are seeking to build cross gender consensus building, we need to appeal to our common shared ideals, independent of penis, vagina, or bathroom.</p><p>So here is where I introduce “Romantic Non-Duality” as opposed to the dualistic, non-sexy, non-romantic, political and clinical terminologies and labels being used in one large obnoxious conversation.</p><p><strong>Better language is better understanding</strong></p><p>As a romantic man who is also a whole system consensus designer, the “language” both sides are inflaming the other with is just “bad” use of language if your intention is to get other viewpoints to understand the nuances of the topic and debate.</p><p>What does the language of the resolution look like as opposed to the language of the critique of the other?</p><p>The “labeling” of both “male or female only” viewpoints to “cis and multi-gendered labels” that seem to change with trends and fashion, they only have meaning by the sides they are inflaming, forcing spite to define identity in a political-cultural war that is going nowhere for anybody.</p><p>All viewpoints expressed so far seem to push other viewpoints into a label or naming system that becomes one huge straw-man debate that avoids the underlying cultural and very real concerns, <em>yet builds audiences at scale!</em></p><p>The problem with all the labels that are being used, from scientific or social studies to cultural norms, is that all of them offer very incomplete views of the “whole system” of human sexuality and psychology.</p><p>It is for this reason I think the “romantic” view needs to be introduced into the discussion, and now I can speak freely as both a romantic man and a whole system consensus designer, coming out of the closet at last :)</p><p>So, ladies and genders; allow me to introduce Romantic Non-Duality as a resolution to the horrible non-working political-cultural debate on penises, vaginas and bathrooms.</p><p>Covering the whole dynamic spectrum of sexuality, we introduce a non-dual organizing system that bakes “resolution” into its organization.</p><p><strong>Non Duality as a ternary organizing principle</strong></p><p>If we are talking about sexuality, the root of human sexuality is sexual/emotional bonding experience, not any “political identity”, duh.</p><p>And human sexuality is rooted in nature, which is both biological and well understood, and psychological, which is far more complex and less understood and thereby open to far more interpretation than the former.</p><p><strong>Mother and Father</strong></p><p>On the side of nature, nature produces organisms with the potential to be <em>fathers</em> or be <em>mothers, </em>not<em> male </em>or <em>female.</em></p><p>Male and Female are simply abstractions, while mother and father is both scientifically accurate and…a bit <em>romantic</em>. Perfect!</p><p>When it comes to mammals, us humans specifically; nature breaks it down very simply, we are born with a body that potentially can become a mother and contains a potential womb and vagina or we are born with a body that can potentially become a father, with a penis.</p><p>If there is some condition that nature is not producing this, nature is producing some variation of this.</p><p>Nature does not produce “males or females” but “mothers and fathers” and nature only cares if mothers and fathers are making babies, everything else is up to our own social design.</p><p>All “genders” and political identities all come from a mother and a father, and this has nothing to do with human sexuality or what individuals may or may not be attracted to. This is simply biological functionality and this is what the romantic view would idealize, naturally.</p><p>If we all emerge from <em>mother and father</em> not <em>male or female</em>, then mother and father become a natural ideal for society.</p><p>But this has nothing to do with complex human sexuality, psychology, nor even gender, it only has to do with making babies, making “products” of the union of a mom body and a dad body.</p><p><strong>Mother, Father, Child</strong></p><p>“Mothers and Fathers” create children, fusions of mother and father, variations of mother and father. Mothers and fathers create homosexual men and women, ladyboys, transgenders, and cross-dressers too. All are just variations of biological mother and biological father expressed via psychologies.</p><p>So while “mother and father” are foundational to the species, the “child” is the product, and a part of the whole system, making the whole system “non-dual”, or even “non-binary”.</p><p>Ha! You probably were not expecting that one coming either.</p><p>Ironic that human sexuality and bonding to become exalted and idealized in a way that would make Jordan Peterson smile is a non-binary system of gender expression and social acceptance. Men get to be men, women get to be women, and anyone can combine any possible combination of both to arrive at new novel variations of a theme all humanity shares in common.</p><p><strong>In a non-dual system of gender and sexuality, all roles are equally celebrated.</strong></p><p>A non-dual whole system means that we should be able to predict “novelty” to emerge from the union of mother and father, novelty including variations of sexual roleplays as we find in homosexuality, but also complexity in gender psychology and with the modern 21st century, transgender physiology.</p><p>This keeps things socially and scientifically valid, neat, and of course and most important, <em>romantic</em>.</p><p>Romantic is the key ingredient, because it creates a movement that tends towards celebration as the goal, a much higher standard than simple, political, non-romantic tolerance.</p><p><strong>Please use “mother and father” to replace the archaic, non scientific and non romantic “male and female” view of gender? Consider?</strong></p><p>Biological MOTHER, biological FATHER, and biological fusion, union, or child of mother AND father.</p><p>A child is always some variation of a mother and a father. A novel expression of mother and father.</p><p>The child is always born with both a little bit of the mother and a little bit of the father, gender asides.</p><p>We (straight, gay, variation) are all children of mother and father biologically speaking and it this has a <em>great romantic flair folks!</em></p><p>What’s more, we need a non-dual or non-binary operator to accentuate the opposites, instead of pitting them against each other.</p><p>That is what the “whole system” of human sexuality and psychology gives us, and to lay out this ternary organizing principle for human sexuality and gender could have quick adoption using the “romantic non-dual” view.</p><p>Classic Sexual, Classic Homo-Sexual, and Novel Sexual.</p><p>You’re welcome.</p><p><strong>Classic Sexual/Emotional:</strong> Please use this to replace “cis” gendered?</p><p>Classic sexual refers to sexual and emotional experience that can produce a biological child. Classic Sexual is vagina and penis sex, can produce a child and produces emotional bonding around the production of a child.</p><p>Naturally, people would identify as classic sexual by the types of sexual or emotional experience they have or crave. Those that conform within this are classic men and classic women.</p><p><strong>Classic Homo Sexual/Emotional:</strong> This refers to sexual and emotional experience, individuals who have or crave same genital sexual experiences and emotionally bond around them, the formal “homosexual, gay and lesbian”.</p><p>Those that conform within this are homosexual men and homesexual women, <em>obviously</em>.</p><p><strong>Novel Sexual/Emotional:</strong> This refers to sexual experience within novel formations of both classic sexual and homo sexual experience, including but not limited to transexuals, ladyboys, cross dressers, drag queens, or any combination that we could never think of, thus novel. Novel sexual is simply any variation both physiological and psychological of homo sexual and classical sexual.</p><p>Those that conform within these are by definition novel men <em>and</em> novel women.</p><p>Caitlyn Jenner is therefore a <em>novel</em> woman.</p><p>And she is a <em>real</em> novel woman too.</p><p>She is <em>not</em> a classic homosexual woman, <em>nor</em> is she a classic sexual man, but she is indeed a novel woman!</p><p>And such a romantic non-dual system is entirely flexible.</p><p>Let’s say there is someone who simply identifies as “both” in some complex way.</p><p>Well they can easily drop the “man or woman” and just maintain “novel romantic” or “novel sexual” or “novel non-binary” if one needs to be absolutely redundant.</p><p>All of these sexual or emotional identifications have the potential to be <em>mothers or fathers</em> biologically speaking, with exception to individuals who voluntarily go through such a change that they <em>opt out</em> of their biological option or encounter a biological problem preventing such activity.</p><p>Some might say..well what about bi-sexuality?</p><p>Well, again, it relates to sexual experience and emotional bonding.</p><p>If a bi-sexual man is having sex with a woman, he is engaging in classic sex, and if with a man, homosexual sex.</p><p>If he is going to the bathroom, “men’s room” should work fine, and a bi-sexual is equally at home in both classic sexual and classic homosexual environments, <em>touché!</em></p><p>Human gender, psychology and biology, like all whole systems, are ternary and non-dual; feel free to use my bathroom if you need.</p><p>But large arenas and gathering areas should just wisely have <em>four</em> bathroom types to accommodate any potential awkward social interactions, <em>as a matter of courtesy.</em></p><p>Sports teams? What happens when a male professional wrestler becomes trans and wants to compete?</p><p>Well, professional sports <em>already disallows the taking of hormones for competition</em>, and that should cover that debate, anything further not necessary.</p><p>Our devious and trickly little political minds will in many cases force multiple social and engineering issues onto one political topic, usually for the sake of voter turnout and social media likes.</p><p>Don’t fall into the trap of the devious political mind of confusing concerns around trans-humanism, which is using <em>science and technology</em> to enhance human experience and performance and has its own inherent social issues we have to face, and transgender LGBT issues, which are an emergent social and psychological historical novel social movements and set of challenge but which all have <em>inherent resolution</em> in classic and novel sexuality.</p><p>In a large population where the likelihood of competitive novel sexual identifications occur in high number? Create a new sports league. What’s the problem?</p><p>Now, if we can have the discussion within a resolving framework like this, I think we will find that 95% of this cultural conflict would disappear overnight.</p><p>Welcome to Romantic Non-Duality.</p><p>Thoughts appreciated.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=402a5cd9df3e" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Art is MONEY]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/coinmonks/art-is-money-b3305782d27b?source=rss-f6050efaa290------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b3305782d27b</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[smart-contracts]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[copyright]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[art]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[web3]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[artist]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Rome Viharo]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 08 Jan 2023 00:44:51 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-04-18T16:45:18.636Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/448/1*jTLK4eQY9QznTvc5GmPDmA.png" /></figure><p>“ART is MONEY” at first can easily read quite offensive and off-putting, especially if one is an artist. Counter-intuitively however, ART is MONEY is not making a statement about the commercialization of the arts, quite the opposite.</p><p>ART is MONEY actually represents a moment of liberation for artists and creators, it is an innovation in Copyright that puts the creator in complete control of their creation while using the creation to build and store wealth.</p><p>ART is MONEY is more like a sonic force screamed in a great battle that historically has slayed artists and culture alike, hijacked by large corporate studios, the “<a href="https://www.scribd.com/doc/124633235/Grunch-of-Giants-Buckminster-Fuller#">Grunches</a> of <a href="https://slatestarcodex.com/2014/07/30/meditations-on-moloch/">Moloch</a>”.</p><p>ART is MONEY is not making a statement about “art” itself. It is making a statement about “money”, or wealth, and how that wealth can be taken back by the creators and channeled into a community treasure, a true form of plural or community money that maps to universal currency that translates into a development roadmap for technology companies.</p><p>Everything from the painting hanging on the wall, the music playing on the radio, or the production of a cinematic experience can be liberated into its own form of wealth, its own form of community money that is creator generated, community distributed, independent of the bankers, the studios and the corporations.</p><p>Consider something like a vinyl record album, a novel, a painting becoming a storage of wealth, something similar to a bank account, but cooler.</p><p>What’s cool about this kind of money? While the painting you purchased is hanging on your wall, you receive benefits and checks in the mail, and funding for your projects, you discover that you can build a business on top of the painting.</p><p>Imagine making a creation that was not exchanged for dollars, sold to studios, with the natural copyright violated, but created for a community to build projects, create equity, distribute itself and fund itself?</p><p>In <a href="https://bigmotherdao.com/what-is-copycake/">“The Artists Revolution meets the Design Revolution”</a>, creators can “take back” the wealth of art absorbed by commerce and corporations simply by optimizing formal copyright with smart contracts, which then can bundle them with other contract types, including but not limited to equity and real estate.</p><h3><strong>Meet CopyCake, plural money for the new decentralized world</strong></h3><p>We call this “CopyCake™”, and it really is an innovation in Copyright that is made possible by smart contracts. It includes the smart contract address as a component of the copyrighted work, making the digital asset and the copyright ownership indistinguishable.</p><p>CopyCake completely reverses the historical relationship artists and creators have had with the rights to their own creations.</p><p>CopyCake allows the storage of copyright value to become hedged with other assets a community creates together.</p><p>CopyCake allows the explosive power of copyright ownership to be channeled into a community fund, which also includes designers and engineers of technology. The technology engineers pledge their equity creations supporting the formal copyright stream, backing it with USD accepted valuations.</p><p>This “revolution” does not just stop with the creators, but it does something equally empowering for their audience, it turns them into co-owners AND funds them too, building further wealth.</p><h3><strong>Artistic Liberation</strong></h3><p>Large studios such as Disney or Netflix will sell you their stock all day. They will never sell you their copyright.</p><p>If Disney sold their copyright, Disney stock would be worthless.</p><p>The Artist Revolution WILL SELL YOU the copyright, and back the copyright with the equity created by the Design Revolution.</p><p>ART is MONEY is actual liberation from the entire funding mechanism of the arts and media, everything up to the world of fine art, film, print, television, music, theater, publishing, all of it liberated into “money” with CopyCake.</p><h3><strong>Studio Novita and the Narrative Novelty</strong></h3><p>The Artist Revolution pulls the audience into the story. The audience, not the studio, is now the distributor.</p><p>Instead of stock ownership in a corporation that won’t let anyone touch the artist created copyright, The Artist Revolution sells the real value directly to the audience.</p><p>All of this is quite a claim to make.</p><p>Big Mother DAO’s <a href="https://bigmotherdao.com/about-dao-studio/">“Studio Novita”</a> is currently demonstrating the first “studio fund” that is a hybrid of real world equity and fiat exchange merged with digital wallets and smart contracts.</p><p>We are introducing the <a href="https://whynotworldgame.com/">“Narrative Novelty”</a> structure which has already closed its first “round” and launching a number of engineering startups.</p><p>The Artist Revolution should not be confused as a “Cryptocurrency” or anything that has anything to do with FTX, exchanges, or crypto wild swings.</p><p>Our application of smart contracts as a contract storage vehicle is almost trivial in comparison to all the innovation it layers on top.</p><p>The smart contract is irrelevant, the value comes from the union of arts and engineering, copyright and equity, audience and stage, just like it always has.</p><p>In The Artist Revolution meets The Design Revolution, CopyCake becomes the great equalizer, bringing both compliance, stability and explosive growth all into one single asset, ART.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b3305782d27b" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/coinmonks/art-is-money-b3305782d27b">Art is MONEY</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/coinmonks">Coinmonks</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The DAO of Life and Death, ad hoc.]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/coinmonks/adhocracy-the-dao-of-life-and-death-8833fef195ca?source=rss-f6050efaa290------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8833fef195ca</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[dao]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[adhocracy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[governance]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[web3]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Rome Viharo]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 22 Mar 2022 07:13:38 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-04-30T13:52:16.582Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/960/1*3HtMy47uQIBuw-MB-a535g.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>This article was originally published at </em><a href="https://bigmotherdao.com/adhocracy-the-dao-of-life-and-death/"><em>BigMotherDAO.com</em></a></p><p>Please forgive me in advance for the dramatic entry of the title, and I do not wish to confuse anyone. By DAO I do not mean anything at all esoteric or related to the Tao Te Ching or Daoist philosophy, I simply mean what web3 means, as in <em>Decentralized Autonomous Organization</em>.</p><p>As well, by life and death I am not referring to anything contemplative. I am referring to the life style of companies, for example Facebook and Google. Google and Facebook fear death. This is a very serious concern, for a company to fear its own demise.</p><p>Facebook is probably one of the worst things in the world for a healthy society, yet it will not die a timely death, and it will not change its revenue model because it would mean death.</p><p>Google has created an intractable problem with global data tracking embedded into the architecture of the internet. Both Google and Facebook could get rid of the problem of online misinformation overnight. However, this would mean death.</p><p><em>Companies grow in size out of fear of death.</em></p><p>Would shareholders ever agree to downgrade their stock value, collapse everything, and start over from scratch?</p><p>What if, instead, Facebook or Google simply accepted death as a natural function within a healthy ecosystem, and what if shareholders were somehow rewarded for allowing Facebook to die?</p><p>If Facebook was run like a DAO / Adhocracy, its death would be greeted, even anticipated. But corporations, like Wall Street, are not as flexible as a DAO can be. Corporations resist death, fearing it–so much that society itself could collapse before Google or Facebook would ever consider it.</p><p>One interesting fact about western economies is that all companies eventually fail. This means that eventually, someone is left “holding the bag” as one would expect in any pyramid marketing scheme or ponzi scheme.</p><p>A Decentralized Autonomous Organization, by comparison, could greet death, perhaps even design its own death– and profit from it.</p><p>Both life and death have a lot to do with effective governance, perhaps both in nature as the Tao Te Ching might have suggested thousands of years ago, but definitely in relationship to the rise and fall of corporations and why “adhocracy” may be the ultimate empowerment of decentralized autonomous organizations, if we are talking about massively scaled organizations that can both remove bureaucracy and scale efficiency.</p><p>Adhocracy, by definition, is the opposite of bureaucracy and certainly not to be confused with autocracy.</p><p>Adhocracy has been around since the 1970s, and as such, there is plenty of research into its strengths and weaknesses. Adhocracy is not a particular style of governance or organization per se; Adhocracy simply refers to the minimum organizational structure a specific purpose or task requires, and no more.</p><p>Adhocracy is naturally decentralized, however it is not attached to any particular management or deliberative process. It could include voting, or even an executive director, it just depends on what is necessary.</p><p>For the purpose of the task, the adhocracy would maintain whatever governance was necessary and then when the task is completed, the form of governance managing it dissolves, and the individuals and assets involved simply move on, potentially to form another adhocracy, for a different purpose.</p><p>Wikipedia’s overview of the term tells us:</p><blockquote><em>“Robert H. Waterman, Jr. defined adhocracy as “any form of organization that cuts across normal bureaucratic lines to capture opportunities, solve problems, and get results”.[5]</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>For Henry Mintzberg, an adhocracy is a complex and dynamic organizational form.[6] It is different from bureaucracy; like Toffler, Mintzberg considers bureaucracy a thing of the past, and adhocracy one of the future.[7]</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>When done well, adhocracy can be very good at problem solving and innovations[7] and thrives in a diverse environment.[6]</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>It requires sophisticated and often automated technical systems to develop and thrive.[7]</em></blockquote><p>Adhocracy has been studied enough to determine that it is excellent for things like task forces, but adhocracies fall into a problem when they emerge within corporate structure and <em>the problem is corporate structure itself.</em></p><p>Adhocracy is only effective when its organization serves a purpose, but after the purpose is served? It dissolves.</p><p>But corporations do not like dissolving. Nor do government institutions. Nor do currencies.</p><p>Corporations, like humans, fear death, and all corporations, like humans, eventually die.</p><p>While Milton Friedman was quick to argue that “greed was good” for economic prosperity; nature is quick to remind him that death is far better.</p><p>The problem in a corporate setting is the same as a governmental agency or institution; individuals and roles stay–even if they have resolved their purpose.</p><p>The individuals, naturally wanting to keep their jobs, become part of the bureaucracy.</p><p>Take Google, for example. I believe they began as a very well intentioned company. I also deeply admired Google for most of their history; however we see now how Google has built an entire infrastructure upon the acquisition of data in a manner that is simply not sustainable for western society.</p><p>Now Google is terrifying. Facebook is far worse. Google probably would change if it could, <em>but it can’t</em>.</p><p>The scale and size of Google’s total wealth, reach and the entire corporate structure it inhabits would never allow Google to “die” as it allows its current infrastructure to go extinct because that would mean the extinction of Google and its shareholder value.</p><p>Yet, the entire infrastructure of what Google has created could literally lead to the collapse of western society as we understand it, and under such terms, western society at the same time would not allow Google to collapse.</p><p>Wall Street would not adjust its measurements and valuations of Google’s assets, and Google’s shareholders are not required to be responsible for the upkeep of western civilization; they just want their value to increase.</p><p>After all, that is the purpose of a corporation, to make more money, even at the expense of society itself. And all of this because there is nothing in governance or organizational structure that will allow for a company to die when it is time to die, die when it no longer serves its original purpose. The bigger Google grows, the larger and larger its bureaucracy will naturally come to be, and the bigger it grows, the less likely it will be that it will ever die.</p><p>That, in principle, Google could outlive western civilization as we know it today gives one pause as to the unintended consequences of any system.</p><p>This is bureaucracy: it is inefficiency. Imagine instead if Google was not a giant conglomerate, but a DAO that allowed for adhocracy to flourish.</p><p>This means that Google could let itself die, and be re-born again, with the same individuals, even the same wealth, but with a new purpose, and a new project.</p><p>Companies, like all things in nature, need to die when the time is right and this refusal to accept the reality of the eventual demise, becoming “too big to fail”, is something I believe DAOs will be able to change at a scale previously unimaginable.</p><p>Adhocracy built into smart contracts and DAO structures would allow a natural process of company birth and death without destroying the lives of individuals that make up the company and the shareholders or the economy of the nation that it inhabits.</p><p>Adhocracies need to be born with purpose, and die when their purpose is completed.</p><p>And with smart contracts instead of a corporate structure, a DAO can allow for the rise and fall of adhocracy within a distributed environment. This is exactly how the DAO of Big Mother will operate as a decentralized autonomous direct action organization, and I look forward demonstrating how all of this works in real time.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8833fef195ca" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/coinmonks/adhocracy-the-dao-of-life-and-death-8833fef195ca">The DAO of Life and Death, ad hoc.</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/coinmonks">Coinmonks</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A Primer on Troll Farms for Cyber-Elves]]></title>
            <link>https://rome-viharo.medium.com/troll-farms-and-the-broadcast-of-misinformation-pt-1-83372576342a?source=rss-f6050efaa290------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/83372576342a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[misinformation-research]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[misinformation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cyberdefender]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[the-social-dilemma]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[misinformation-ecosystem]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Rome Viharo]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 26 Dec 2021 19:03:37 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-10-26T05:48:59.545Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/659/0*8_R6NCXji4yGQeD9.jpg" /></figure><p>Cyber Elves are groups of individuals who engage in theatrical online tactics solely for the purposes of frustrating online troll farms engaged in disinformation campaigns on the internet.</p><p><a href="https://www.gmfus.org/news/role-cyber-elves-against-russian-information-operations">Cyber-Elves are more active now than ever before</a>, especially since 2015 uptick in online disinformation coming from Russian troll farms.</p><p>The tactic is a type of “signal jamming”, usually using humor mixed with socratic questioning, exposing inherent contradictions in online disinformation messaging, thus neutralizing it. I’m retired, doing it is rewarding yet exhausting, and I was doing it for a long time.</p><p>Beginning in 2003 when I found myself apart of the very first “online protest” agains the invasion of Iraq, I along with a few dozen others began to confront what is now known to be disinformation around the existence of Weapons of Mass Destruction in Iraq. Get this, there were troll farms operating on AOL message boards as far back as 2002–2003.</p><p>During my <a href="https://rome-viharo.medium.com/aiki-wiki-wikipedia-we-have-a-problem-update-pt-3-bddc707bdd22">eight year case study</a> into Wikipedia editing wars, from the years 2013 -2019, I uncovered a number of “troll farms” comprised of Wikipedia editors and online influencers––and I never met one troll farm that did not justify their broadcast of disinformation against their ideological opponents.</p><p>Us Cyber-Elves think we are the good guys, but every troll farm believes they are the good guys too, and therein lay the kicker. If it exists, there is a troll farm operating around it, distributing disinformation and misinformation for a number of ideological reasons.</p><p>Indeed, one major troll farm I discovered is led by a prominent influencer in the community and actually identifies himself as someone who “battles misinformation” on the internet as his professional career.</p><p>While his public facing image is noble, his private activities disinformation campaigns include him publishing faked data sets to generate contexts that do not exist, blogging misleading information about subjects he targets while staging online theatrical events to generate false impressions.</p><p>He justifies this; after all his opponents he truly believes are the ones that spread misinformation about science on the internet and therefore, they <em>deserve to have a </em>disinformation and harassment campaign against them in return.</p><p>Is it possible that highly educated individuals who are pro-science could operate troll farms, engage in toxic behavior, and spread literal misinformation about their targets just as much as anti-vax troll farms, or Russian troll farms?</p><p>Yes, of course it is.</p><p>Disinformation and “troll farms” is a phenomenon that emerges from political behavior, i.e. human nature, and not from the ideologies themselves. It just looks like the only group that operates disinformation campaigns is exactly the group you don’t like.</p><p><strong>This is not something that is easy to self reflect on.</strong></p><p>All of us cyber-elves should look at how easy <em>we could</em> justify disinformation, trolling and harassment under certain conditions.</p><p>Let’s do a thought-experiment as proof.</p><p>Imagine if I told you that there was a group of individuals on the internet who have been exposed for extreme racism, Neo-Nazi propaganda and on top of it, it turns out they are also pedophiles.</p><p>Specifically, in our thought-experiment here, let’s say there are 10,000 neo-nazi pedophiles in the world, and that while we have no direct proof to get them arrested for their horrendous activities, we could get the authorities to look into them by staging a disinformation campaign that they are involved with credit card fraud.</p><p>Mind you, as deviant and evil as you could imagine a group of neo-nazi pedophiles to be, they never actually engaged in any credit card fraud.</p><p>Credit card fraud was just a disinformation story about this group that could go viral the easiest, and thus expose them. Should we do it? Would you mind if that action against pedophile neo-nazis were to occur?</p><p>Who cares if they deserve it, right?</p><p>That’s the kicker––we instinctively believe that <em>some</em> people deserve it, and this is what enables toxic behaviors online to spread like wildfire, a place where <a href="https://rome-viharo.medium.com/eat-my-tongue-the-decentralized-distributive-brilliance-of-tibetan-buddhism-14eabe4e89ae">disinformation feeds misinformation</a> as a tactic that works (but only in the short term).</p><p>This underlying psychological vulnerability creates a global distribution network for digital wildfires and, the data from Facebook shows, eventually leads to genocide if not kept in check.</p><p>And this is what makes the difference between cyber-elfing, and disinformation trolling. The best way to neutralize a disinformation campaign is with humor and a sincere appeal to common truth without contradiction. A cyber-elf practices, as a virtue, honesty in the face of deception.</p><p><strong>We cannot use disinformation to fight misinformation.</strong></p><p>We cannot use “troll farms” to fight “troll farms”.</p><p>While I am retired from the craft, t<a href="https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/europe/lithuania-elves-russia-election-tampering-online-cyber-crime-hackers-kremlin-a9008931.html">he “cyber-elves” of Lithuania is one online group that gets this right.</a></p><p>They call themselves “cyber-elves” to distinguish their behaviors online against the behaviors of Russian “troll” farms, which they battle on the internet in the fight against misinformation.</p><p>This distinction between “elves and trolls” online derives from Tolkien mythological themes, yet becomes an easy narrative overlay to two distinct strategies on the internet.</p><p>When battling Russian troll farms, the cyber-elves learn that transparency, clear communication, rational broadcast, and most importantly humor and theater become the weapons of choice.</p><p>This choice is not taken from any sort of moral or ethical position either, it simply is discovered that this is the only methodology that works. It is the only methodology that <em>neutralizes</em> the problem by <em>identifying its cause</em>, without itself creating more misinformation in return.</p><p>In Lithuania, they can now train volunteers to adopt these tactics, as this is the only thing that works to bust up troll farms and stop the spread of misinformation around a topic.</p><p><strong>So what specifically is a troll farm?</strong></p><p>While some troll farms can be funded and operated by more experienced digital magicians working for corporations or government agencies, a troll farm overall has specific identifiable qualities across millions of online social groups that emerge easily without a paycheck.</p><p>A “farm” is a place that nurtures and recycles life. A troll farm nurtures “trolling” and the spread of misinformation. A farm cultivates the behaviors and distributes the content that emerges from those behaviors.</p><p><strong>Trolls and misinformation</strong></p><p>A “troll” as a word has such historical relevancy on the internet that this singular word and the history of its own adoption on the internet is a great microcosm itself to understand how subtle and how easily misinformation can spread on the internet.</p><p>In the early days of the internet, if someone was to refer to someone else as a “troll”, it meant two different things.</p><p>Large internet groups used the word “troll” to refer to a toxic individual in an online community, someone “bombing” a forum with negativity, personal attacks, toxicity.</p><p>Yet, other large internet groups would use the word “troll” almost in an heroic way, a reference to the more Sasha Baron Cohen, Ali G type online behavior. Someone “trolling” was someone playing an often “well deserved” practical joke on an unsuspecting individual or community, who takes the “troll” performance as real.</p><p>So, in 2008, if someone was to call someone else a “troll” in a community that was mixed between these two types of usages of the word, two entirely different stories would be communicated, and without any group knowing it.</p><p>Without any group knowing that, one group would be spreading misinformation, without realizing it.</p><p>Seeing how just one simple word, “troll”, used in good faith, to relay information from one community to another community who has a different context usage of that word, can allow misinformation to spread without intention, just multiply that as much as you can, adding both intentional and unintentional reactions to information online, to get a bigger glimpse into the problem.</p><p>Since global adoption of misinformation and troll farms as a sort of political everyday internet reality, the word “troll” meaning a toxic individual on the internet has “won” adoption over the usage of the word “troll” as a sort of comic hero, John Oliver, Sasha Barron Cohen, The Yes Men embodying the archetype.</p><p>Thus, the Lithuanian Cyber-Elves needed a word to distinguish their reality from the reality of “troll farms”, which can emerge in any social community online, anywhere, for any reason.</p><p><strong>So how do troll farms cultivate misinformation and trolling?</strong></p><p>Cultivating a troll farm is an entirely organic process that requires no paycheck. A paycheck just offers a troll farm more time to spread misinformation and troll.</p><p>Cultivating a troll farm that spreads misinformation requires no more than “groupthink” to form, and this is the first dynamic aspect to forming a troll farm, a way to distinguish the “group” from the “other”. This is easily understood as the classic “us versus them” mentality.</p><p>The social group depends upon building consensus around what are for all sakes and purposes just keywords that identify both the group and the “other” they are targeting.</p><p>Now that a social group has formed somewhere on the internet, anywhere from Facebook to Twitter, from Reddit to Twitch to Wikipedia is all possible, the social dynamics of inner group competition will begin to form.</p><p><strong>The Groupthink dynamic</strong></p><p>These group dynamics within rely on avoiding contradictions within the group while relegating the groups worst possible behaviors and choices made in the expression of being against the other.</p><p>This creates a competition within the group for attention and status within the group.</p><p>Who is the biggest “defender” of the group? Who is the angriest? Who vocalizes the loudest message within the group? Who is the strongest voice within the group? Who has the authority within the group? Who controls the groups message? Who decides which is the group consensus, and which the consensus rejects?</p><p>This competition within the social group for power of broadcast creates a psychological irony, each troll farm actually requires the troll farm of the “other” to justify their own quest for dominance or influence within their own group.</p><p>While warring ideological sides appear in media to be in a competition between their counterpart influencers and bloggers, they actually wind up supporting and building each other’s audience, a type codependence. The enemies of one group empower both sides responses, which then can be amplified by naturally occurring troll farms.</p><p><strong>The Dark Collaboration</strong></p><p>To give an example of this tragic irony playing out, I will use one more well known example, the “social justice warriors” of left-wing to center politics to the “alt-right”, “dark enlightenment”, “MAGA” counterparts online.</p><p>A known center to left wing influencer, with tens to hundreds of thousands of followers, requires something to complain about for them to continue to nurture their own followers and audience.</p><p>Who has the biggest “left-wing” voice? What other left-wing to center influencers are out there, competing for audience size and credibility?</p><p>After all, YouTube and Facebook’s algorithm is going to recommend the content of the left to center influencer, and only one influencer at a time can be at the top of each algorithm that is fed to us.</p><p>While such an influencer may continue to, for example, criticize their counterparts such as Joe Rogan or Jordan Peterson, it’s not Dr. Peterson nor Joe Rogan whom is their real “enemy” in their own struggle to build more followers, it is “other” left wing to center influencers, competing for the same audience size and set of followers and likes that they are, optimized by social media platforms.</p><p><strong>And the opposite is also true.</strong></p><p>Dr. Peterson and Joe Rogan have embedded themselves into their audience sizes by also participating in having, and requiring, their ideological opponents from the center to left criticize them, troll them, indeed using the “trolling and misinformation” tactics of the other sides “troll farm” to amplifying their own message to their audience, thereby building it. “We’re under attack from the left” becomes a viral message that builds more community for them while they are competing for other center to right voices, along the same algorithms optimized by social media to distribute the most competitive minded influencers at the top of discovery and recommendation algorithms.</p><p>Each side, from left to center to center to right, is literally creating the circumstance for the exact issue they voice to concern, unaware that the entire dynamic is co-created in an entire ecosystem of justified online harassment and trolling and optimized for these behaviors by social media algorithms seeking to boost their monthly active users (MAUs) to justify their CPMs (cost per thousand eyeballs for advertisers).</p><p>So while influencers, troll farms and misinformation sink into group think competition, what is actually transpiring over a much larger view of the data is that ideological troll farms on opposite ideological sides actually help keep each other in “power” in terms of their own communities and this dynamic is further amplified by social media algorithms rewarding competition within peer groups by competing their top influencers against each other.</p><p>This has created quite a nasty feedback loop making much of this problem intractable within current media and tech architecture, as the economy is fueling a $150B a year industry in the US alone.</p><p>So while SJW and MAGA appear to “battle” online, there is an unconscious collaboration happening instead. They need each other and both sides use each other continually to gain status within their own social groups.</p><p>The loudest voices of each potential social group has a payoff in the form of advertising dollars paid to them by the platforms that host them.</p><p>Because this inner group competition emerges from individuals who wish to serve their social groups in such confrontational capacity, the “other” becomes more and more dehumanized, and those offering “tough” solutions, arising from “frustrations” and “angers” they distribute within their group to influence support, win in the group consensus. This group consensus, formed from suppressive, toxic, or abusive methodologies then inform what is broadcast to peak discovery on the internet through internet search and social media algorithms optimizing for data via likes and voting along specific keywords.</p><p>All ideological groups will have members that view their ideological struggle as the imperative. There will be members of that ideological group that will seek their purpose in that group by engaging in toxic confrontation with their opponents.</p><p>The internet has given this particular psychological type a set of broadcast tools, and they have perfectly gamed the tools the internet has given them.</p><p>If the computer interface of social media currently empowers group think, troll farms and misinformation, then this means that there can exist another type of digital environment, an environment where only mutually resolving behaviors have control of the permission to publish to the internet itself.</p><p>In Non-dual consensus methodology of Aiki Wiki, a digital interface for large scale online consensus building, the psychological dynamics of group-think can be predicted to collapse online through a unique type computer interface design, a few simple new online tools.</p><p>While I am not so naive as to assume the social media giants would adopt something like it, I do show how it is possible, that a pathway could emerge through a re-design of basic standard online tools that could in theory eradicate misinformation and trolling from internet publishing, where the internet comes to discover information that was collaboratively formed between ideological differences as easier to discover than the troll farms on all sides seeking to win influence by dark collaborations that only solve the problem of audience development, not resolution.</p><p><a href="https://bigmotherdao.com/about-rome-viharo/">About Rome Viharo</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=83372576342a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>