<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by ronfriedmann on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by ronfriedmann on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@ronfriedmann?source=rss-d6a294d30768------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Wed, 18 Nov 2026 13:35:31 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@ronfriedmann/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Will COVID Change Lawyer Collaboration? — Prism Legal]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@ronfriedmann/will-covid-change-lawyer-collaboration-prism-legal-39d1d14e8f55?source=rss-d6a294d30768------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/39d1d14e8f55</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[collaboration]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[collaboration-tools]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[lawyers]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[ronfriedmann]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 14 Jun 2020 21:57:28 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-06-14T22:05:58.672Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Will COVID Change Lawyer Collaboration? — Prism Legal</h3><p>Collaboration improves problem-solving, productivity, and innovation. In normal times, lawyers and legal professionals collaborate in-person. With work from home (WFH) during the COVID epidemic, video conferences have replaced in-person meetings.</p><p>The WFH video experience prompts a collaboration question. Beyond in-person or video meetings, how effectively do legal professionals collaborate. How well do they work in groups? And can we do better?</p><p>To answer this question, let’s look at how others professionals work. Across industries, many use purpose-built software to coordinate within and across groups, to solve problems together, and to collaborate. Legal professionals, in contrast, use software mainly to pass-the-baton, not work in teams. Lawyers largely continue to rely on 1990s software designed to support <em>individual work</em>, with few features for <em>group</em> work or <em>real-time</em> collaboration.</p><p>I noted these distinctions in a 1997 a presentation. The first slide below sets up the distinction, the second categorizes the then-prevalent categories of software:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/765/0*qTFu1oAMWF4hJmBG.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/760/0*GgtJ--HXL99rH913.png" /></figure><p>My views have changed since then. Categorizing email as team software was and remains wrong: have fun trying to parse a long email thread with multiple participants and multiple subjects. And while document management software supports group work, it’s more about sharing documents and sequential collaboration and less about real-time and dynamic collaboration.</p><p>Lawyers today spend most of their time in MS Word, Outlook, and a browser. Contrast that with widely-used — outside of legal — 21st century software designed specifically to support groups:</p><ul><li>Multi-person chat (<em>e.g.</em>, AIM, Slack, MS Teams, or Google Hangouts)</li><li>Group screen share and video (<em>e.g.</em>, Zoom or Google Hangouts)</li><li>Shared task management (<em>e.g.</em>, ToDoist, DoneDone, BaseCamp, Trello, or Asana)</li><li>Joint authoring (<em>e.g.</em> Google Documents).</li></ul><p>And consider three recent surveys asking about a range of legal technology. None of the dozens of software products listed is designed specifically to collaborate:</p><ol><li><a href="http://iltanet.org/blogs/ilta-news1/2019/09/27/now-available-ilta-technology-survey-executive-sum?ssopc=1">ILTA’s 2019 Technology Survey</a> (executive summary) covers one dozen applications in one question.</li><li><a href="https://www.aderant.com/research/2019-business-of-law-legal-technology-survey/">The 2019 Aderant Business of Law and Legal Technology Survey</a> asks about 18 types of software.</li><li>The <a href="https://cloc.org/about-us/cloc-in-the-news/cloc-announces-the-results-of-2nd-annual-state-of-the-industry-survey/">CLOC 2019 State of the Industry</a> asks about two dozen types of software.</li></ol><p>Our abrupt move to WFH caused many legal professions to learn video conferencing and e-signing software. And those previously wed to paper now get by with way less. But beyond that, how much has the way lawyers work changed? Does the COVID crisis create a new mindset that allows a rethink, a path to using collaboration software? And if we do not rethink how we work, that implies we believe how we work today is just fine.</p><p>In my view, legal leaders should consider whether to support and encourage their organizations to adopt new ways of collaborating and working together in real time. We have an opportunity to move toward more, and more effective, collaboration with <em>purpose-built technology for groups</em> and <em>real-time collaboration</em>. Examples include products like MS Teams or Slack and the entire category of transaction management platforms.</p><p>Maybe such a move is too big a burden. Maybe it will face resistance. But now is the ideal time: minds may be more open now than in the past. And I believe the firms that take advantage of this crisis to improve the <em>how</em> of work will thrive post-crisis.</p><p>-</p><p>NOTES: A version of this post originally appeared at <a href="https://legaltechnology.com/will-covid-crisis-change-how-lawyers-collaborate/">Legal IT Insider</a> on 14 April 2020. I started thinking about new ways of working early in the lockdowns; see my March 2020 post, <a href="https://prismlegal.com/rethinking-how-lawyers-work-post-crisis-1/">Rethinking How Lawyers Work Post Crisis</a>.</p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://prismlegal.com/will-covid-change-lawyer-collaboration/"><em>https://prismlegal.com</em></a><em> on June 14, 2020.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=39d1d14e8f55" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Legal Tech in Love — Married Couple with Separate Start-Ups]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@ronfriedmann/legal-tech-in-love-married-couple-with-separate-start-ups-46b1dd772535?source=rss-d6a294d30768------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/46b1dd772535</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[ronfriedmann]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 02 Jun 2020 22:05:08 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-01-29T13:33:18.821Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*uI_EzMtO7-5cmYJn.jpg" /></figure><p>[Note: As of 27 October 2021, InCloudCounsel changed its name to <a href="https://www.ontra.ai/">Ontra</a>. This note added 29 Jan 2022.]</p><p>In networking for a new job, I recently met (remotely) <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/efficientdocuments/">Troy Pospisil</a>, the Founder and CEO of <a href="https://www.incloudcounsel.com/">InCloudCounsel</a>. Two surprises stood out in speaking with him. First, InCloudCounsel is an established Alternative Legal Service Provider (ALSP). I track the sector but had not previously come across it. And second, his wife, <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/documentautomation/">Dorna Moini</a>, also founded a legal tech company, <a href="https://www.documate.org/">Documate</a>, a cloud-based no-code document automation platform. I immediately thought that both surprises warranted a blog post. I subsequently interviewed Troy and Dorna.</p><p><strong>Question: I’ve been in legal tech a long time, including working with and for legal tech start-ups. You are the first married couple I’ve met where both are legal tech entrepreneurs in different businesses. Did you meet via legal tech?</strong></p><p>No. We met in college, at New York University, on the northeast corner of Washington Square Park in Greenwich Village. [RF: I can picture it well because my alma mater, NYU Law, sits on the Square.]</p><p>Troy: After graduating, I worked in management consulting at Monitor Deloitte and then moved to H.I.G. Capital, a private equity firm. Working at a large financial services firm, I saw an opportunity in the market: clients spending millions of dollars and countless hours on repetitive commercial contracts. Inspired by a combination of enterprise software tools and marketplace platforms, I had the idea to combine a cloud-based software platform with virtual attorneys to address high volumes of contracts.</p><p>Dorna: After I graduated law school, I was a litigator for many years, last at Sidley Austin. During that time, I had an active pro bono practice and found that the early stages of my immigration and domestic violence cases were form-heavy and rule-based. I wanted to automate that process for my clients so that I and other volunteer lawyers could spend time on their higher-value work. With my developer, we built a domestic violence platform for my firm and several legal aid organizations. I hadn’t planned to leave practice, but seeing the power of technology in delivering legal services led me to want to create a scalable platform for others to do the same — without any technical knowledge.</p><p><strong>Tell me a bit about each of your companies.</strong></p><p><a href="https://www.documate.org/">Documate</a> is a platform to build legal document automation and expert systems without using any code. We started as a “TurboTax” for domestic violence restraining orders, which we called HelpSelf. I wanted to offer a suite of similar tools for other pro or low bono domains but realized that would require at least one expert per jurisdiction and many developers — a heavy lift. So I focused instead on building a scalable platform for the experts, shifting from content to tool. Now, Documate is a no-code document automation tool that lawyers can use, either internally to accelerate and standardize their work, or externally to serve clients and generate new forms of revenue.</p><p>We started with small and medium sized law firms, and now have several AmLaw 100 firms on our platform. But our roots and mission will always be in legal aid, so we continue to support our non-profit legal aid organizations through free and discounted software, including through our “<a href="https://www.americanbar.org/news/abanews/aba-news-archives/2019/05/aba-center-for-innovation-and-lsc-launch-legal-tech-donation-eff/">Legal Tech for a Change</a>” partnership with LSC and the ABA.</p><p><a href="https://www.incloudcounsel.com/">InCloudCounsel</a> offers global, scalable solutions that modernizes companies’ high volume contracting processes by combining cloud based software and part-time virtual attorneys. Our goal is to completely free in-house legal teams from marking up, negotiating, and abstracting routine legal documents. In addition to freedom, we deliver faster turnaround times, lower legal costs, and better negotiation outcomes.</p><p>Our software platform combines workflow, automation, and document and data management tools designed to streamline the contracting process and minimize the lawyer and human time required. Our data management features provide reporting and benchmark across contracts to enable sophisticated obligation management and benchmarking. For the human component, we partner with attorneys who have, on average, 14 years of experience. InCloudCounsel accepts less than 4% of attorneys who apply to be in its network. Many of our customers process and manage thousands of contracts per year through our platform.</p><p><strong>Both of your businesses involve documents but they are fundamentally different. Do you find it helpful to compare notes at home, say over dinner?</strong></p><p>We do talk about work at the dinner table. Though our tech and customers differ, we find it helpful to compare notes on sales, marketing, branding, hiring, and managing teams.</p><p>Going beyond nitty-gritty business issues, we each find it good to have a spouse who understands the challenges of entrepreneurship. When you are building a business, the highs are incredibly high and lows can feel especially low. We each readily relate to that, and can help both celebrate and balance one another.</p><p><strong>Troy — given my long experience with alternative providers, I’m intrigued about how you see InCloudCounsel fitting in the legal ecosystem.</strong></p><p>Large law firms should focus on being the absolute best at helping their clients solve complex problems, such as M&amp;A transactions and litigation. They generally don’t make money or deliver an excellent customer experience with high volume work. Most law firms understand this and see solutions like InCloudCounsel as complementary to their business, as opposed to competitive. As for alternative legal service providers, the market is big with many solutions and providers. Each tends to excel at a particular niche. InCloudCounsel is typically brought in to take work off the plate of the internal legal team vs. displacing another ALSP.</p><p><strong>Troy — one more question for you. You sell into corporations, including some very large ones. How does that compare to selling to law firms?</strong></p><p>InCloudCounsel generally sells into law departments. I find that the bigger the company, the more stakeholders are involved in the evaluation and decision making process. This could include stakeholders from legal, compliance, IT, and procurement. We don’t sell into large law firms, but I suspect that this would also be a complex sales process.</p><p><strong>And Dorna, document assembly is one of the oldest and most-populated legal tech product categories, with programs available in the 1970s on mainframe computers. How do you differentiate Documate?</strong></p><p>Document automation has been around for years, and while that’s the core of our business, our clients are doing much more. On Documate, our clients <a href="https://www.documate.org/automation/how-to-build-legal-apps-legal-products-productizing-through-document-automation-and-legal-applications/">build legal products</a> and expert systems, collaborate with clients, and generate revenue through new legal service delivery models.</p><p>More importantly, we empower the lawyer to do it on their own. Documate has the power of complex code — loops, complex calculations, and nested logic to your heart’s desire — with the ease of use and delightful UX of a modern, no-code platform.</p><p><strong>Can you each tell me a bit about the tech at your companies.</strong></p><p>Dorna: Documate is built by lawyers and engineers to democratize the development process, allowing lawyers to build without learning a line of code. As a result, we are very thoughtful about product development. We’ve built a clean and easy interface that allows you to do everything an engineer would normally do with code. As we move forward, we’re also building data analytics tools to give our clients more insight into their own practices.</p><p>Troy: InCloudCounsel has a large product development team that includes dedicated teams focused on machine learning, front end engineering, back end engineering, product management, data, and design. About half of our overall company sits inside our product and engineering departments. Machine learning problems usually start with a workflow that’s being repetitively performed by a human and where our team sees an opportunity to either fully automate or make the task far more efficient. Starting with a task that is already being manually performed can really jump start the development of the machine learning tools, because we are usually starting with a tagged data set that we can use to begin testing models.</p><p><strong>No discussion today would be complete without asking how the COVID crisis is affecting you.</strong></p><p>Dorna: We’ve seen an uptick in lawyers and courts wanting to go online, quickly making this crisis a tipping point in technology for lawyers. The legal field recognizes that online collaboration is no longer a novelty, but a necessity. As our clients think about new ways to deliver legal services, we’ll be there to help them adapt and build scalable legal products.</p><p>Troy: I think COVID will accelerate the 20-year trend of corporations outsourcing non-core functions. Coming out of an economic downturn, most organizations will be even more hesitant to incur fixed costs. Companies like InCloudCounsel that variabilize a historically fixed cost will be attractive options for non-core, repetitive legal work.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=46b1dd772535" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Legal Tech in Love — Married Couple with Separate Start-Ups — Prism Legal]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@ronfriedmann/legal-tech-in-love-married-couple-with-separate-start-ups-prism-legal-1895428ff735?source=rss-d6a294d30768------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/1895428ff735</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[legaltech]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[document-assembly]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[contracts]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mariage]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[founders]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[ronfriedmann]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 02 Jun 2020 18:05:08 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-06-02T18:24:38.579Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Legal Tech in Love — Married Couple with Separate Start-Ups — Prism Legal</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*fBMS2QIzRTPrJip2.jpg" /></figure><p>In networking for a new job, I recently met (remotely) <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/efficientdocuments/">Troy Pospisil</a>, the Founder and CEO of <a href="https://www.incloudcounsel.com/">InCloudCounsel</a>. Two surprises stood out in speaking with him. First, InCloudCounsel is an established Alternative Legal Service Provider (ALSP). I track the sector but had not previously come across it. And second, his wife, <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/documentautomation/">Dorna Moini</a>, also founded a legal tech company, <a href="https://www.documate.org/">Documate</a>, a cloud-based no-code document automation platform. I immediately thought that both surprises warranted a blog post. I subsequently interviewed Troy and Dorna.</p><p><strong>Question: I’ve been in legal tech a long time, including working with and for legal tech start-ups. You are the first married couple I’ve met where both are legal tech entrepreneurs in different businesses. Did you meet via legal tech?</strong></p><p>No. We met in college, at New York University, on the northeast corner of Washington Square Park in Greenwich Village. [RF: I can picture it well because my alma mater, NYU Law, sits on the Square.]</p><p>Troy: After graduating, I worked in management consulting at Monitor Deloitte and then moved to H.I.G. Capital, a private equity firm. Working at a large financial services firm, I saw an opportunity in the market: clients spending millions of dollars and countless hours on repetitive commercial contracts. Inspired by a combination of enterprise software tools and marketplace platforms, I had the idea to combine a cloud-based software platform with virtual attorneys to address high volumes of contracts.</p><p>Dorna: After I graduated law school, I was a litigator for many years, last at Sidley Austin. During that time, I had an active pro bono practice and found that the early stages of my immigration and domestic violence cases were form-heavy and rule-based. I wanted to automate that process for my clients so that I and other volunteer lawyers could spend time on their higher-value work. With my developer, we built a domestic violence platform for my firm and several legal aid organizations. I hadn’t planned to leave practice, but seeing the power of technology in delivering legal services led me to want to create a scalable platform for others to do the same — without any technical knowledge.</p><p><strong>Tell me a bit about each of your companies.</strong></p><p><a href="https://www.documate.org/">Documate</a> is a platform to build legal document automation and expert systems without using any code. We started as a “TurboTax” for domestic violence restraining orders, which we called HelpSelf. I wanted to offer a suite of similar tools for other pro or low bono domains but realized that would require at least one expert per jurisdiction and many developers — a heavy lift. So I focused instead on building a scalable platform for the experts, shifting from content to tool. Now, Documate is a no-code document automation tool that lawyers can use, either internally to accelerate and standardize their work, or externally to serve clients and generate new forms of revenue.</p><p>We started with small and medium sized law firms, and now have several AmLaw 100 firms on our platform. But our roots and mission will always be in legal aid, so we continue to support our non-profit legal aid organizations through free and discounted software, including through our “ <a href="https://www.americanbar.org/news/abanews/aba-news-archives/2019/05/aba-center-for-innovation-and-lsc-launch-legal-tech-donation-eff/">Legal Tech for a Change</a> “ partnership with LSC and the ABA.</p><p><a href="https://www.incloudcounsel.com/">InCloudCounsel</a> offers global, scalable solutions that modernizes companies’ high volume contracting processes by combining cloud based software and part-time virtual attorneys. Our goal is to completely free in-house legal teams from marking up, negotiating, and abstracting routine legal documents. In addition to freedom, we deliver faster turnaround times, lower legal costs, and better negotiation outcomes.</p><p>Our software platform combines workflow, automation, and document and data management tools designed to streamline the contracting process and minimize the lawyer and human time required. Our data management features provide reporting and benchmark across contracts to enable sophisticated obligation management and benchmarking. For the human component, we partner with attorneys who have, on average, 14 years of experience. InCloudCounsel accepts less than 4% of attorneys who apply to be in its network. Many of our customers process and manage thousands of contracts per year through our platform.</p><p><strong>Both of your businesses involve documents but they are fundamentally different. Do you find it helpful to compare notes at home, say over dinner?</strong></p><p>We do talk about work at the dinner table. Though our tech and customers differ, we find it helpful to compare notes on sales, marketing, branding, hiring, and managing teams.</p><p>Going beyond nitty-gritty business issues, we each find it good to have a spouse who understands the challenges of entrepreneurship. When you are building a business, the highs are incredibly high and lows can feel especially low. We each readily relate to that, and can help both celebrate and balance one another.</p><p><strong>Troy — given my long experience with alternative providers, I’m intrigued about how you see InCloudCounsel fitting in the legal ecosystem.</strong></p><p>Large law firms should focus on being the absolute best at helping their clients solve complex problems, such as M&amp;A transactions and litigation. They generally don’t make money or deliver an excellent customer experience with high volume work. Most law firms understand this and see solutions like InCloudCounsel as complementary to their business, as opposed to competitive. As for alternative legal service providers, the market is big with many solutions and providers. Each tends to excel at a particular niche. InCloudCounsel is typically brought in to take work off the plate of the internal legal team vs. displacing another ALSP.</p><p><strong>Troy — one more question for you. You sell into corporations, including some very large ones. How does that compare to selling to law firms?</strong></p><p>InCloudCounsel generally sells into law departments. I find that the bigger the company, the more stakeholders are involved in the evaluation and decision making process. This could include stakeholders from legal, compliance, IT, and procurement. We don’t sell into large law firms, but I suspect that this would also be a complex sales process.</p><p><strong>And Dorna, document assembly is one of the oldest and most-populated legal tech product categories, with programs available in the 1970s on mainframe computers. How do you differentiate Documate?</strong></p><p>Document automation has been around for years, and while that’s the core of our business, our clients are doing much more. On Documate, our clients <a href="https://www.documate.org/automation/how-to-build-legal-apps-legal-products-productizing-through-document-automation-and-legal-applications/">build legal products</a> and expert systems, collaborate with clients, and generate revenue through new legal service delivery models.</p><p>More importantly, we empower the lawyer to do it on their own. Documate has the power of complex code — loops, complex calculations, and nested logic to your heart’s desire — with the ease of use and delightful UX of a modern, no-code platform.</p><p><strong>Can you each tell me a bit about the tech at your companies.</strong></p><p>Dorna: Documate is built by lawyers and engineers to democratize the development process, allowing lawyers to build without learning a line of code. As a result, we are very thoughtful about product development. We’ve built a clean and easy interface that allows you to do everything an engineer would normally do with code. As we move forward, we’re also building data analytics tools to give our clients more insight into their own practices.</p><p>Troy: InCloudCounsel has a large product development team that includes dedicated teams focused on machine learning, front end engineering, back end engineering, product management, data, and design. About half of our overall company sits inside our product and engineering departments. Machine learning problems usually start with a workflow that’s being repetitively performed by a human and where our team sees an opportunity to either fully automate or make the task far more efficient. Starting with a task that is already being manually performed can really jump start the development of the machine learning tools, because we are usually starting with a tagged data set that we can use to begin testing models.</p><p><strong>No discussion today would be complete without asking how the COVID crisis is affecting you.</strong></p><p>Dorna: We’ve seen an uptick in lawyers and courts wanting to go online, quickly making this crisis a tipping point in technology for lawyers. The legal field recognizes that online collaboration is no longer a novelty, but a necessity. As our clients think about new ways to deliver legal services, we’ll be there to help them adapt and build scalable legal products.</p><p>Troy: I think COVID will accelerate the 20-year trend of corporations outsourcing non-core functions. Coming out of an economic downturn, most organizations will be even more hesitant to incur fixed costs. Companies like InCloudCounsel that variabilize a historically fixed cost will be attractive options for non-core, repetitive legal work.</p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://prismlegal.com/legal-tech-in-love-married-couple-with-separate-start-ups/"><em>https://prismlegal.com</em></a><em> on June 2, 2020.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=1895428ff735" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Richard Susskind + Mark Cohen on Clients + ALSP — Prism Legal]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@ronfriedmann/richard-susskind-mark-cohen-on-clients-alsp-prism-legal-6464029f9511?source=rss-d6a294d30768------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6464029f9511</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[alsp]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[clients]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[biglaw]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[ronfriedmann]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 28 May 2020 15:32:27 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-06-02T18:26:53.575Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Richard Susskind + Mark Cohen on Clients + ALSP — Prism Legal</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*sNSnWEKj_peIk2BW.png" /></figure><p>This is a live blog post of a 75-minutes video discussion with <a href="http://www.susskind.com/">Richard Susskind</a> and <a href="https://www.legalmosaic.com/">Mark Cohen</a> about clients and ALSP (alternative legal service provider). It is hosted by Legal Geek and sponsored by Thomson Reuters, UnitedLex, and iManage.</p><p>Lisa Hart Shephard, Acritas founder and now part of TR, moderates questions in the first part.</p><p>This is the second of a four-part discussion, The Uncertain Decade, “Richard Susskind and Mark Cohen debate the future of the legal industry”. The topic today is “What clients want and need” and “Alternative legal suppliers — hope or hype?” (For my live post of session 1, click <a href="https://prismlegal.com/richard-susskind-mark-cohen-debate-the-future-of-the-legal-industry/">here</a>.)</p><p>This is a live blog post. I publish it as the session finishes. Please forgive typos and misunderstandings of meaning.</p><p><strong>Richard Susskind on What Clients Want and Need (10 minute opening)</strong></p><p>Mark and Richard <strong>polled some GCs</strong> in the UK, US, and Europe. They found worries about people, cash flow, and uncertainty. Other findings:</p><ul><li>Running team remotely well enough</li><li>Advising the business remotely well enough</li><li>Response of law firms was quite good</li><li>Response of ALSPs — not as good</li><li>Predicted change coming — significant / massive</li></ul><p>Richard thinks ALSP did not fare as well because the relationships are newer than with law firms and that ALSP work on lower value matters than law firms.</p><p>On the <strong>“more for less challenge”</strong>: GCs have long been under pressure to do more but spend less. The message today, and common sense says, the pressure will go up. There are only two ways to deal with this. Cut costs by becoming more efficient. The other way is “to share the cost” between law firms and clients.</p><p>That sharing is evidenced by the rise of legal operations professionals. Running a big legal department is more work than the GC can do. The running of the business has been passed to a COO (legal ops professional) of the law department. They think about management, technology, efficiency, collaboration, and managing the work. This is why CLOC has grown from a a handful to 1000s. Their influence has shifted the legal market from being a seller’s to a buyer’s market.</p><p>Richard points out that legal services are a credence good. The buyer cannot evaluate the quality of the service. This is similar to doctors / medicine.</p><p>Cautions about asking customers what they want, citing Henry Ford (“faster horses”) and Steve Jobs (“consumers don’t know what they want”). Customers are typically not the innovators. Richard counsels that clients should focus on outcomes, not the process or how. Clients don’t want innovation or AI per se. They want better outcomes or lower fees. (And innovation and AI may get there but are not the outcomes.)</p><p>Citing the railroads not understanding they were in the transportation business, in-house lawyers need to understand the outcomes. They want risk managed. The business wants a fence at the top of the cliff, not an ambulance at the bottom.</p><p><strong>Mark Cohen opening remarks</strong></p><p>Mark picks up on the theme of what business law firms and lawyers are in. For a long time it was legal expertise. But in the last 25 years, it’s not just legal expertise that matters. Today, business acumen and legal service delivery matter as much. Furthermore, lawyers today need to understand and use data. The ultimate client on the corporate side is more concerned about what the data say and tell, not the lawyer’s gut feel.</p><p>In the United States, the finding of survey was that GCs found the ALSP more helpful than their law firms. Mark notes this finding differs from the UK finding that Richard reported. And that relationships in the UK matter more than the US, where the question is “what have you done for me lately?”</p><p>Richard and I agree strongly that customers (clients) now drive the dynamic. Legal expertise is readily available. It must be paired with tech- and process-expertise, and take a multidisciplinary approach, which is driven by client demand.</p><p><strong>ALSP and Law Firms — The US — UK Difference</strong>: Richard: It’s hard to explain why GC views of ALSP in the crisis differ in the US versus UK. One hypothesis is that US ALSP have had to make themselves more distinctive than in the UK because in the US, they face tighter regulation. The regulatory constraints drove different behaviors by ALSP. Also, outside of the Big 4, the US has the bigger ALSP than the UK.</p><p><strong>Doing More for Less</strong>: Mark heard from one GC in the UK that “incrementalism is dead”. Just cutting costs no longer suffices. Mark asks if we can imagine the art of the possible, reconsider the traditional paradigm. Asks if we will see the legal provider deck shuffled. Richard discusses efficiency — using more tech or lower cost labor. We’e seen the labor cost arbitrage play out over the last decade. But we have not yet exhausted the benefits of tech. Richard looks at ALSP as focused on the efficiency strategy.</p><p><strong>Small and Medium Size Enterprises (SME) — audience poll picked topic:</strong> Richard asks if largest corporations do not like law firm service, how do the SME feel? Mark cites adage that there is too much law for those can it afford, and not enough for those who can’t. In the past, lawyers determined what is law and legal advice. Mark observes, however, that in SME contracts and other work is done by professionals without a law degree. Richard expects to see more online services to generate documents and comply with regulations, perhaps even using social media type tools to share resources and help each other. The size of SME could make it attractive for a large firm to deliver services to it via a digital service (thus serving what Richard calls the “latent legal market”). Mark observes that legal delivery for SME requires a variety of disciplines; both agree it takes designers, knowledge engineers, tech experts, and others.</p><p><strong>Lisa </strong>points outs that GC role has shifted from legal to business advisor. Thinking about how tech is often sold for efficiency and cost management… why is there not more focus on better service. Richard — in-house lawyers take a level of quality for granted. Law departments always face cost pressure, and in the pandemic, even more so. Richard says “good enough is good enough”, noting that clients believe that but law firms often do too much work, over-invest in the answer. Mark notes the C-suite increasingly drives expectations of law departments and all lawyers in the supply change. Because the GC is closer to the business, they feel the pressure soonest. For the C-Suite, legal is only one consideration. With these pressures, lawyers may not be the primary advisors, that role could fall, for example, to crisis managers.</p><p><strong>Audience: Will Law Firms See Legal Project Management as a Revenue Stream. </strong>Mark — no. Law is a service business. Firms must decide about build, buy, or rent. It’s a given that LPM is needed. The only question is who delivers it. Richard — is the best person a lawyer who learns PM or a PM who learns about law. There is not question LPM is needed. Who pays and how depends on overall charging models.</p><p><strong>Audience: Will Law Firms Start to Look More Like Big 4 with a Multidisciplinary Approach?</strong> Richard thinks law firms will emulate the Big Four with consulting and business services. And law firms will also adopt more technology. But otherwise, Big Law and Big 4 are very different and doubts the former will fully emulate latter. All need to re-think the business and operational model. Mark agrees that all providers should face the existential question of finding a place in the market. Law firms should think about practices, talent retention, training the next gen of talent, and with whom they should collaborate.</p><p><strong>Audience: Is CLOC supporting true change or just promoting tech?</strong> Mark — legal operations are critical and important but are a means to an end. Clients don’t care if ops is in department or firm — it merely needs to be embedded somewhere.</p><p><strong>Audience Poll Finds Law Firms Should Focus on Culture:</strong> Richard observes that technology and culture are interconnected. Crisis may accelerate use of tech, but can it accelerate cultural change asks Richard. He doubts it can.</p><p><strong>Mark on ALSP</strong></p><p>How did ALSP come about? There was an unmet market need to deliver legal services in a very different way. New competencies were needed, for example, design, tech, and process know-how. ALSP have different DNA than firms — closer to business than the legal profession.</p><p>ALSP have come a long way since the legal process outsourcing (LPO) days, which initially focused on lower cost labor (arbitrage). As LPO evolved, they adopted more and more technology. They were different from the start, with more corporate models than law firms.</p><p>In the last few years, ALSP have come of age. Those that operate at scale are tech enabled, use data, are customer centric. They are highly sophisticated, global, and employ 1000s. When they employe lawyers, it’s not to practice law; rather it is for data analytics, for LPM, and to design tech systems.</p><p>Alternative suggests Junior Varsity, a detour — and that’s the wrong view. Law is not just about legal expertise. It now requires, legal, tech, data analytics, and business expertise. Also, all providers must focus on customer satisfaction, citing Net Promoter Scores. Suggests ALSP does better on all these than the legal centric, hierarchical law firm partnership model. Furthermore, law firms, by distributing profits each year, encourage short term perspectives.</p><p>On culture… it’s about how groups self-identify. In law firms, the entrenched stakeholders, the partners, don’t want to change, even if change is good longer term.</p><p>Key take aways: the distinction among provider labels is less important than the operational model.</p><p><strong>Richard and Mark Discuss ALSP</strong></p><p>Richard: I am a big fan of ALSP. Has been involved in this evolution since 2004 in UK. But is disappointed. Only 1 or 2% of the trillion dollar legal market goes to ALSP. The potential remains but is largely untapped. Richard is puzzled that at why a few clients are super satisfied with ALSP but other clients are less satisfied or interested.</p><p>A premise of ALSP was unbundling / disaggregating legal work. This has been harder to do that we expected. Clients want one neck to choke. And it turns out a senior lawyer does need to supervise and integrate all the pieces. Increasingly, law firms are providing their own (captive) ALSP.</p><p>Another surprise: The UK re-regulated the legal market in 2011. That allowed more flexibility. Richard is disappointed that the US continues it monopolistic approach to legal regulation. Mark concurs with Richard on US approach to regulation but points out that the market has, nonetheless, responded, citing United Lex and Axiom, each of which has raised substantial investment capital. This is evidence that regulations are not holding back investment. Mark also notes that ALSP are doing very sophisticated work in the US. The boundaries are not that clear.</p><p>Richard notes that if we were to look a percent of legal work today that is done using alternative methods, it is very much higher than in the past because law firms have adopted the same approaches.</p><p><strong>Audience Poll Chooses a Focus on Legal Tech Companies and “New Look Law Firms”.</strong> Richard: we’ve gone in 500 to 1000s of legal tech start-ups in the last five years. Each is trying to do what Amazon has done, but just in a little corner. Most won’t survive. We talk about “legal tech industry” but most of the spend on it comes from law firms, not clients or consumers. Consequently, it is more a sustaining than disruptive force.</p><p>Mark advises legal tech start-ups to look a problems through the eyes of the customer. Don’t focus on what’s cool.</p><p><strong>The Law Company: </strong>This term is a nicer way of saying ALSP, though it may also engage in the practice of law. But we need to frame this with other models such as Axiom (2000-lawyer “non-law-firm”) and Fisher Broyles (virtual law firm, almost Am Law 200). Richard cites an interesting difference — culture. In law firms, innovators are often fighting battles but in other providers, they work with fellow travelers.</p><p><strong>Wendy Butler Curtis of Orrick Asks: What does it take for lawyers to thrive and What Will Law Firms Need More of and Less of?</strong> Mark: legal knowledge today is table stakes. UK has defined just six reserved categories. Lawyers have to acquire a range of skills. Richard: to answer more of, look at culture. It would good if lawyers were more open minded and less focused on perfection in evaluating new solutions. In short , we need more of a mindset shift.</p><p><strong>Mark Asks Wendy How Orrick Has Engineered Change?</strong> Clients drive the bulk of change.</p><p>[Last question not captured]</p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://prismlegal.com/richard-susskind-mark-cohen-on-clients-alsp/"><em>https://prismlegal.com</em></a><em> on May 28, 2020.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=6464029f9511" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Rise of Legal Operations and What Comes Next — Prism Legal]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@ronfriedmann/the-rise-of-legal-operations-and-what-comes-next-prism-legal-e0ea7712efd1?source=rss-d6a294d30768------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e0ea7712efd1</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[offshore]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[outsourcing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[legal-operations]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[contracts]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ai]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[ronfriedmann]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 19 May 2020 20:00:17 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-05-19T20:20:34.130Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>The Rise of Legal Operations and What Comes Next — Prism Legal</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/409/0*IEvS3bRTl3Y67Nzn.png" /></figure><p>Legal operations started as a handful of people two decades ago. Today, it has become a robust discipline with many practitioners. I was delighted to have the chance to interview one of the leading legal operations pioneers, <a href="http://uplevelops.com/about-us">Steph Corey</a> of <a href="https://uplevelops.com/">UpLevel Ops</a>.</p><p>I met Steph in 2018 doing work for my alternative legal service provider (ALSP) client <a href="https://www.cenza.co/">Cenza</a>. We discussed offshore teams to help with contract management. This year, law departments face new COVID-induced pressures. Contract review and management has only grown in importance, not just to understand Force Majeure provisions, but also as many companies retool their supply chains. Separately, huge cost pressures likely will cause many General Counsels to examine offshore options.</p><p>As Steph and I continued talking during the COVID crisis, I realized she has a wealth of knowledge and experience that others would value. In the interview, Steph shares how she got started in legal operations, talks about where it is today, and comments on AI tools, among other topics.</p><h3>How did you get into legal operations?</h3><p>I never thought I’d go into the legal market but here I am. After B-school, I interned at Merrill Lynch and got a job at a small investment firm in the Bay Area. I hated cold calling so did not stay long. In my next job in finance, I was still antsy to advance my career. I learned that HP was hiring for legal tech / legal ops. I had never heard of this, and really did not even know what a General Counsel did. But HP wanted a strong finance background to help manage outside counsel spend. I was 22 and didn’t know how the world worked: I emailed the GC. He called me and then I interviewed and got the job. That was 1999.</p><h3>You were a CLOC co-founder. How did that happen?</h3><p>My career at HP kept advancing — the company really believed in training and career progression. In my dozen years in the law department, we grew from 200 to 1,500 people. After I was promoted to Chief of Staff in 2008, I had to figure out what that meant so I started reaching out to folks in comparable roles in other law departments. That’s when I met <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/conniebrenton/">Connie Brenton</a> and we started <a href="https://cloc.org/">CLOC</a> [Corporate Legal Operations Consortium]. I hosted the first meeting at HP in 2010. We found that all law departments were struggling with the same issues — even though their companies were in different businesses. That’s still true. We saw then — and now — that one year it’s e-billing, then CLM, then intake. The cycles continue or repeat.</p><h3>You were on a roll. Why did you start UpLevel Ops?</h3><p>The <a href="https://uplevelops.com/">UpLevel Ops</a> story has one more background chapter. In 2011 I was ready for a new challenge outside of HP. I had a brief stint at VMWare, but it was not the right fit. Luckily, right at that time, Jon Hoak took the GC role at Flex. I had worked closely with him at HP. He recruited me to build a Flex legal operations team from scratch. I went from a team of 100 legal ops professionals at HP to one person at Flex.</p><p>Jon and I built a team; it was fun and successful. When you have a GC who understands legal ops and provides a mandate with budget, it shows what you can do. We went from a department that only managed outside counsel to a balanced team, bringing about half our total legal spend in-house. We put many systems and processes in place and saved over $7M in just 2 year’s time.</p><p>In 2016, two things happened. First, Jon announced he was retiring. I knew that would change things for me at Flex. And second, CLOC came into its own. What had been an informal Silicon Valley networking group morphed: I was amazed with the 500 attendees at the first formal CLOC conference. That signaled a strong demand for legal operations know-how. I saw one other strong signal. During my entire time at Flex, I regularly received calls from law departments around the country wanting to know how to build a legal ops team.</p><p>I persuaded Jon not to go into full-time retirement and, instead, join me in starting UpLevel Ops. He and I spent the summer of 2016 on business planning. And we have been going strong since then.</p><h3>What do your clients typically look like and what’s your work like?</h3><p>When we started UpLevel Ops, we thought we’d work with larger law departments, say 40 to 70 people. But a little over half of our law department clients have between 10 or 20 people. And sometimes a lone GC. Our model has been to grow with a flexible and agile team. Jon and I are the only two full-time employees. We have a network of many consultants and specialists with whom we regularly work, including Lucy Bassli, Ken Callander, Teju Deshpande and more. We work with a range of industries and law department challenges. For example, we’ve assisted many companies with assessments, legal ops strategies, contract management solutions, and e-billing tech and process.</p><h3>What’s your take on how AI works for billing and contracts?</h3><p>I’ve seen AI tools be a big help to analyze and manage contracts. But you still need humans. Very big organizations can invest heavily in tech and machine learning training. That can be great but you need a lot of data — and not just data, but cleaned-up, normalized, and often curated data.</p><p>Most of our clients don’t have the scale for that. And most companies don’t have that scale. They can get AI as part of a tool they license or via an ALSP, where the machine the provider has the data and takes care of the machine learning training. And by the way, we’ve found that it takes 10x more data than you initially think to train than you think at the outset. Also, no one, except for NDAs, wants to give up the human QC and exception handling. That’s one of the reasons I was interested to talk to you about Cenza, for access to an experienced team to handle machine learning training, exception processing, and QC.</p><h3>Where is legal operations as a discipline?</h3><p>Legal ops continues to advance and mature. We don’t know what long term effects of the COVID crisis will be but the smart money is that GCs will, once again, have to do more with less. That does not mean throwing more lawyers at problems. It just won’t work.</p><p>We need to build the right mix of people, process, and tech. On the people side, we need to delegate work to the lowest cost resource who can do it. For example, with crisis-induced pressure, I expect that we will see an increase in the number of paralegals versus lawyers in law departments. And with cuts likely in some law departments and hiring freezes in others, they will need to take advantage of these options and other alternative options.</p><p>You and I have talked about <a href="https://www.cenza.co/">Cenza</a> and its offshore teams. Outsourcing and offshoring is proven. And, by the way, outsourcing and offshore is not only about cost savings. For high volume work, say the likely surge in workouts, resolutions will require extracting a lot of data and provisions from agreements. An industrial-strength outsourcing company does that cheaper, better, and faster. And speed will be important to resolve the crisis.</p><h3>To close, any thoughts on the future of legal operations?</h3><p>GCs now see their departments can work remotely. Even when the crisis ends, we will see more remote work. And that will help companies because they will be able to tap a national talent pool without requiring relocation.</p><p>The common theme among our clients is that they want their lawyers focused on law practice, not on managing systems and processes. They want to delegate operations to the right professionals. Even before the crisis, we had requests for legal operations as a service. Now, that demand likely will increase because companies will not want to add headcount. And we are now able to provide that. With our experience and our networked team, we are well positioned. And I can see how we could call on an offshore team to support data and document intensive work. That might include e-billing review and supporting contract management, both with or without AI.</p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://prismlegal.com/the-rise-of-legal-operations-and-what-comes-next/"><em>https://prismlegal.com</em></a><em> on May 19, 2020.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e0ea7712efd1" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Doing Deals Better with Diagrams — Prism Legal]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@ronfriedmann/doing-deals-better-with-diagrams-prism-legal-c562782780b1?source=rss-d6a294d30768------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c562782780b1</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[diagrams]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[visuals]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[transactions]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[lawyers]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[ronfriedmann]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 04 May 2020 18:09:22 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-05-17T19:26:29.752Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Doing Deals Better with Diagrams — Prism Legal</h3><p>Lawyers may be the only professionals who routinely rely on dense text to understand complicated ideas. And that could change for transaction lawyers with the release of <a href="https://www.structureflow.co/">StructureFlow</a> to diagram and track complex deals. Before I report on this product, based on a conversation with Founder and CEO <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/tim-follett-1271b163/">Tim Follett</a>, some background.</p><p>[As with all my product-specific blog posts, this is neither a review nor a product comparison. I occasionally write about products that I think do something new or something differently enough to be interesting.]</p><p>In all my jobs, visual displays have played key roles and I regularly <a href="https://prismlegal.com/category/visual-intelligence">blog about visual intelligence</a>. As an economic and financial analyst after college, I regularly created time series, cross-sectional, and 2×2 portfolio displays. That was before PCs and required programming. After law school, I was a Bain &amp; Company consultant. Bain <em>never</em> wrote reports. It only presented to clients with slide decks. The company employed an army of graphic artists to hand produce multi-color overhead slides (which required Xacto-ing tiny colored acetate sections.)</p><p>These stories date me. And illustrate that professionals have long <em>invested</em> to create graphics to inform and advise. And some lawyers do so. My first published article was “Practicing Law with Pictures”. That was about 1992 in <em>Law Technology Product News</em>, today <em>Legal Tech News</em>. (I wish I had a paper or digital copy.)</p><p>In it, I showed several visual displays from my firm’s practice. I still remember two examples. One diagrammed regulating commercial banks versus bank holding companies. My firm visually illustrated an adversary’s interpretation of the law, which made clear the implications of its argument. The partner credited that diagram with winning the dispute. A second was a transaction diagram. The lawyer on the deal said “Until I diagramed the transaction, I did not really understand the deal.”</p><p>And here we are 25+ years later and transaction diagrams remain far from routine. Beyond any mindset issues, using PowerPoint or equivalent to create them is time-consuming and painful.</p><p>And that brings us to StructureFlow, which is purpose built to diagram — and document — deals. Here is an example of its visualization:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*xOWrG-2sRO-FCbON" /></figure><p>Looking at it, I understand quickly the deal elements. I cannot imagine how long that would take reading the deal documents or even a transaction summary.</p><p>Tim showed me how to create and document a diagram. The interface seems easy and elegant.</p><p>Adding, editing, and moving nodes is easy and StructureFlow maintains connection lines as you move around nodes. It is way easier than PowerPoint. Adding deal data is also easy using a sidebar with fields specific to either the node or the connector.</p><p>I see many benefits for deal diagrams. It helps lawyers and legal professionals understand what’s happening at the macro level, with the ability to drill down to the micro. The initial product release allows linking nodes and connectors to relevant documents in a document management system.</p><p>Because StructureFlow is cloud based, anyone viewing the deal diagram will see the current version. Tim emphasized that a single source of truth in the cloud avoids a problem he regularly experienced as a deal lawyer: out-of-date PowerPoint diagrams. Another nice feature is an audit trail of who changed what and how. (StructureFlow is hosted on Azure, is ISO 27001 compliant,and can be set-up in single tenancy without shared resources.)</p><p>StructureFlow will also integrate with transaction management platforms — it is not trying to compete with them but rather sees itself as part of the deal management ecosystem.</p><p>That StructureFlow can capture deal terms potentially simplifies creating records in deal databases and experience management systems. Some firms invest considerable non-billable resources to capture deal points (sometimes in excess of 100). I think that it’s an open question if lawyers using StructureFlow will diligently complete all the data fields. But even if they don’t, I suspect the deal diagram and links to documents would make finding the deal terms faster for a knowledge manager or other legal professional charged with extracting and recording deal points.</p><p>I would be remiss not to mention the #DoLessLaw benefits of StructureFlow. DoLessLaw refers to efficiency and effectiveness in law practice, for example, scoping, project management, delegation to lower cost resources, and technology for efficiency. I regularly <a href="https://prismlegal.com/category/do-less-law/">blog</a> and <a href="https://twitter.com/search?f=tweets&amp;vertical=default&amp;q=%23DoLessLaw">Tweet</a> about DoLessLaw.</p><p>Lawyers spend much time — perhaps too much — tracking and managing information. A clear and always-current transaction diagram, with links to key documents, can save time by reducing cognitive load and mechanical work. The deal structure stays clear and finding documents is faster. Diagrams also aid in training lawyers. Imagine the difference in explaining the transaction pictured above to a 1st year associate with and without the diagram.</p><p>A second DoLessLaw benefit centers around disputes. Diagrams may help <em>avoid </em>disputes. Lawyers may have no problem grasping complex deals but their business clients might like some support. They will welcome a diagram that explains the overall deal, and their part in it. Separately, should a completed deal become the subject of litigation, the diagram could help a mediator, arbitrator, or judge understand what happened and what went wrong. And this could help resolve a dispute more quickly and at less cost.</p><p>In closing, I need to mention that especially during the COVID crisis and lockdown, when lawyers cannot assemble to discuss deals, I can see that sharing the deal overview via a visual sitting on the cloud will be especially valuable. And adoption of this type of tool is an example of what I had in mind when I wrote <a href="https://legaltechnology.com/will-covid-crisis-change-how-lawyers-collaborate/">Will the COVID Crisis Change How Lawyers Collaborate?</a> ( <em>Legal IT Insider</em>, 14 April 2020) My point there was that the crisis could be a pivot point after which lawyers practice differently — and better. I certainly think using StructureFlow would improve deal practice.</p><p>[You can learn more about how StructureFlow helps with deals via a <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/posts/tim-follett-1271b163_legaltech-legaltechnology-lawtech-activity-6655376415225184256-Avgf">four-minute video</a> Tim created, accessible at his LinkedIn profile.]</p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://prismlegal.com/doing-deals-better-with-diagrams/"><em>https://prismlegal.com</em></a><em> on May 4, 2020.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c562782780b1" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Where Will the Legal Work Go? — Prism Legal]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@ronfriedmann/where-will-the-legal-work-go-prism-legal-7de7a0a172c3?source=rss-d6a294d30768------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/7de7a0a172c3</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[newlaw]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[competition]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[alsp]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[biglaw]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[ronfriedmann]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 01 May 2020 18:21:13 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-05-17T19:09:09.831Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Where Will the Legal Work Go? — Prism Legal</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*J2lR5jbbhSZ0SRbD.jpg" /></figure><p>This is a live blog post of the Baretz + Brunelle webinar, <a href="https://marketing.baretzbrunelle.com/where-will-the-work-go-futurecast?utm_campaign=NewLaw%20Futurecast&amp;utm_source=Brad%20Personal%20Invites&amp;utm_medium=Brad%20Personal%20Invites&amp;utm_term=Brad%20Personal%20Invites&amp;utm_content=Brad%20Personal%20Invite">Where will the Work Go? A NewLaw Futurecast</a>, presented by <a href="https://www.baretzbrunelle.com/brad-blickstein">Brad Blickstein</a>. I have appended below the webinar description</p><p>As with all my live blog posts, I publish as the session ends, so please forgive any typos or misunderstandings of meaning.</p><p>Corporations are changing the way clients are buying services, so law firms have to change how they deliver. Clients are struggling now and the pandemic is an opportunity to help them.</p><p>The standard law department playbook to cut costs, a February 2020 survey, shows that the top methods are negotiated rates and discoutns, e-billing enforcement of guidelines, and bringing work in-house. The latter takes advantage of the lower cost of hiring a lawyer.</p><p>The GC playbook here is 20 years old. The number of in-house counsel has grown at a rate almost 10x the growth of law firm lawyers. And 63% of law firm say they lose business to clients. But with crisis, law departments will not be able to bring work in-house. The growth in law departments dropped during the 2001 and 2008 economic challenges.</p><p>The likely cap on in-house hiring means law departments will have to turn elsewhere. Brad cites a 1991 article (in a recession) about Continental Bank axing its law department</p><p>Everyday legal work — employment, compliance, regulatory, routine contracts, IP management + enforecemtn, real estate, and entity management — must continue, even with budget cuts. In prior recessions, GCs would send this work to law firms. Then bring it back in.</p><p>Today, however, the GC have other options — specifically alternative legal service providers (ALSP). Moreover, there are now many legal operations and procurement professionals who buy legal services (up 20 percentage points in a dozen years).</p><p>Law firms no longer have a monopoly on legal talent. It is not just commodity work that will be in play among providers. Law firms, however, have an advantage: clients like their law firms and dealing with them. The GC prefers sending the work to law firms. But they must weigh risk and cost. They have to find firms that can do everyday-work cost effectivel.</p><p>CLOC surveyed its members in 2019. CLOC members want more alternative fees, better LPM, more use of tech, and digital services. These are the attributes that ALSP do better than law firms. That creates a tension.</p><p>Law firms can break this tension. Simply cutting rates does not do it. Firms must automate, project manage, and delegate.</p><p>Brad is on a weekly call clients. They want their firms to bring them new ideas. They cannot understand why their firms, in fact, are <strong>not</strong> doing this. “Clients are begging for new ideas to help them.” Firms can get this business if they can deliver at lower cost and more efficiently.</p><p>It is likely that the yo-yo of the past — work going to firm, then back to firms — will no longer happen. The non-core functions of corporations likely will be permanently moved to cost-effective outsourcing organizations. That is what has happened across corporate functions.</p><p>End of formal presentation, now to Qs:</p><p>Brad sees more firms building their own captives? That includes considering offshore or nearshore resources. But onshore can work if the work is done in lower cost domestic centers with lower cost professionals.</p><p>Should law firms be nervous about offering a low cost option now, when it could have in the past. Brad’s conversations with clients show that the GC will not hold this against firms. They will be receptive to any new ideas now.</p><p><strong>WEBINAR DESCRIPTION</strong></p><p>For anxious law firms, there’s good news: corporate clients still need help.</p><p>History shows that in times of economic crisis, in-house departments often lean harder on their outside partners.</p><p>But there’s a catch. For the first time, law firms are no longer the only outside partner in town.</p><p>This 30-minute B+B Futurecast will be presented by Brad Blickstein, co-head of Baretz+Brunelle’s NewLaw practice. Attendees will leave with an understanding of:</p><ul><li>Why law departments will be looking to send out work on an unprecedented level</li><li>What types of work are ripe for law firms to take over; and</li><li>How firms can compete with the Big Four, ALSPs and other new competitors to win</li></ul><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://prismlegal.com/where-will-the-legal-work-go/"><em>https://prismlegal.com</em></a><em> on May 1, 2020.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=7de7a0a172c3" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Richard Susskind + Mark Cohen debate the future of the legal industry — Prism Legal]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@ronfriedmann/richard-susskind-mark-cohen-debate-the-future-of-the-legal-industry-prism-legal-833d1f897c54?source=rss-d6a294d30768------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/833d1f897c54</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[disruption]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[business-models]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[lawyers]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cg]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[law-firm]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[ronfriedmann]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 30 Apr 2020 15:29:39 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-05-01T18:34:40.412Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Richard Susskind + Mark Cohen debate the future of the legal industry — Prism Legal</h3><p>This is a live blog post of a 75-minutes video discussion with <a href="http://www.susskind.com/">Richard Susskind</a> and <a href="https://www.legalmosaic.com/">Mark Cohen</a> hosted by Legal Geek and sponsored by Thomson Reuters, UnitedLex, and iManage.</p><p>The session title is The Uncertain Decade, “Richard Susskind and Mark Cohen debate the future of the legal industry”</p><p>This is a live blog post. I publish it as the session finishes. Please forgive typos and misunderstandings of meaning.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*MpPA7EBNKsAeAara.png" /></figure><p><strong>Mark Cohen opens with a 10 minute talk</strong>: What will legal market look like after the crisis ends, or ramps down. Lawyers like to look at precedent. What can we learn? From prior crisis, only the 2008 economic crash had a noticeable impact on the legal market. It accelerated disaggregation and the rise of legal operations and alternative legal providers. But other parts of the legal ecosystem did not change: law schools curriculum stayed the same and courts continued to function as they had.</p><p>Why will Covid be different asks Mark. The legal market, law firms and law departments included, quickly adapted to work from home. Similarly, law firms went to exclusive online learning. All had previously resisted WFH. From this, market players learned about “latent technologies” existed and worked. Moreover, the model of showing up at the office turns out not to be necessary. “This is a great surprise.” This casts a light on how we can do things differently.</p><p>What will happen as lockdowns ease? Is law’s present its future? Mark thinks much of the present will be the future, but with re-imagination of the present. To understand the future of law, look to the GCs, who are the belle-weathers of the legal profession. And GCs, beyond the crisis, have been moving to integrating law and business. They will drive more of a focus on digital transformation. Consumers (legal clients) will drive this too. Law will become more about platforms and less about pedigrees, more about competencies and metrics. The academy will recognize that education is lifelong and not just about ticking boxes; it will have to re-think the curriculum. The academy must improve marketability of graduates with multidisciplinary training. Legal providers will have to be data-driven and customer focused.</p><p>In sum, in 1959, President-Elect Kennedy said Chinese word for crisis combines danger and opportunity. Legal faces the danger of not seeing the underlying paradigmatic shift. The opportunity is for lawyers to recast themselves, that we will see more legal professionals, and to improve legal delivery.</p><p><strong>Richard Susskind:</strong> I am in violent agreement with much of what Mark said.</p><p>I see 5 phases of recovery:</p><ol><li>Mobilization (get to WFH)</li><li>Lockdown (where we are now)</li><li>Emergence (come out of lockdown, but that will be slow + uneven)</li><li>Surge (economy comes back to life)</li><li>New equilibrium (which is what Mark talked about)</li></ol><p>Richard sees a clear distinction now between leadership and managers. The latter focuses on getting through the month (short term), focused on lockdown survival. To get beyond the lockdown, we need leaders who ask the questions Mark posed — how will legal life be fundamentally different. It’s been revelatory that so many parts of the system have already adapted.</p><p>Tech to data has been about automation, not transformation. During lockdown, we see little discussion of AI.</p><p>Questions the sustainability of everyone doing WFH for more than lockdown. Not everyone likes it, but they are tolerating it now. Longer term, some / many may want to return to offices. We need to look at innovations now that came about by necessity to understand what we keep.</p><p>We are not seeing a new business model. We are just seeing some different ways of working. A business model change would be a shift from service to products based on tech.</p><p><strong>Discussion:</strong></p><p>Mark: if you are a managing partner, you are constrained by the model. If it’s not sustainable, how do you tell your partners. Customers will have to tell firms that the model is broken. Though law firm models have worked a long time, it will not be optimal going forward.</p><p>Richard: We need to look at how market leaders act. I have not observed any firms acting very differently. I am not seeing any change in service that law firms offer. This could hint that law firms think the legal market will not change very much.</p><p>Mark: I was a managing partner twice. Wearing that hat, I would go talk to clients, asking how my firm could help. Law firms should be of service, without the meter running.</p><p>-In audience poll, 57% ask to focus on law firms versus ALSP or in-house-</p><p>Mark: how does MP get to structural case, make that case. Richard thinks that’s a big challenge. Some MP are better in good times, some better in crisis. That’s a matter of luck. Richard cites a Harvard Prof on change. First step is creating a sense of urgency. That’s hard given that law firm platforms have done well. But the platform is in fact burning. Firms that respond emphatically will succeed.</p><p>Richard: law firms have very long and deep relationships with clients. They can use that to empathize and engage with clients. ALSP don’t have that a strongly. Firms should use that to gain the edge.</p><p>Mark raises the issue of culture. In law firm culture, profit and new business drive most decisions. How can a leader overcome that, inculcate a new set of metrics that changes the culture.</p><p>Richard observes that UK and US firm cultures may differ. US firms focused mainly on profits. In UK, more firms concerned with purpose as well. Big difference between those focused only on profit versus those focused on community. Latter less likely to lay off people now. Now is the time for organizations to be clear on this — and it’s hard to change values. The job of a leader is to focus on this</p><p>Mark points out that legal is almost at bottom of list of industries with “despair” — addiction and mental health issues. (Only coal miners are lower.) We also have an access to justice challenge.</p><p>Q&amp;A</p><p><strong>How will trainees / junior associates be supervised and mentored? Will this affect the revenue model? Richard Given (in-house counsel)</strong></p><p>Richard: if we simply graft old system of training onto Zoom, it’s a big mistake. We should think about simulators to train lawyers. If this can be done for astronauts, we should be able to do do.</p><p>Mark: We need to thin about delegation here. Not all tasks we ask young lawyers to do are the right ones. These tasks can / should shrink, with delegation to machines or other professionals. That will affect our view on training. In the past, lawyers exclusively decided what is a “legal activity”. That will change with more of a focus on legal delivery to solve client problems.</p><p><strong>Do you think digitizing of legal procedures will affect access to justice?</strong></p><p>Richard hopes this will help increase access. Hopes that tech will be the first port of call.</p><p>Mark cites a Joshua Browder. His DoNotPay. is helping unemployed Americans file for unemployment. It’s a great example of A2J with tech</p><p>Both: this reflects conversion of software to product</p><p><strong>If we all treat WFH as given, it’s just a matter of time to big cyber breach. Will that cause revert to office?</strong></p><p>Mark: It’s likely not an either-or situation. Risk is endemic to life and business. Risks in offices, risks in remote. I don’t see it as key driver of work force operation.</p><p>Richard agrees. Yes, there will be some horror stories. Crisis is a call to create robust / industrial strength remote work environments. Breach will cause</p><p>- Poll: about 2/3 of audience think there will be a “massive” or “significant” change in how lawyers work. [RF: I selected “modest”]</p><p><strong>Richard talks about future of courts</strong>: Most courts around the world are phsyically close. I have created <a href="https://remotecourts.org/">Remote Courts Worldwide</a> to share info.</p><p>The key question is whether court is a service or place? Do we really need people to gather IRL to resolve disputes. We have 3 alternatives: audio, video, and paper hearings.</p><p>Courts are <em>very</em> conservative. Until crisis, judges were skeptical of remote. Many have been surprised at how well the alternatives work. But now, there is a growing recognition that traditional in-person can change. We should view lockdown as a massive, unintentional pilot. We need to capture data so we know in the future, when remote works and when it does not. But we’ve seen a “flip in thinking.” In a few years, the default assumption likely will be remote and a request for in-person will need to be justified. In past, I was asked for evidence this would work; now we have the evidence.</p><p>We will see the rise of alternative — designed from the ground up as a digital approach — dispute resolution. There are already such systems and these will increasingly become a viable private digital approach to the public courts.</p><p>Richard also mentions ideas of using visuals to make arguments (in lieu of paper).</p><p>Mark mentions Richard’s book <a href="https://www.amazon.co.uk/Online-Courts-Justice-Richard-Susskind/dp/0198838360/ref=sr_1_1?crid=27CUIU9JT8JAQ&amp;keywords=susskind+richard&amp;qid=1573562963&amp;sprefix=SUSSK%2Caps%2C147&amp;sr=8-1">Online Courts and the Future of Justice</a> by Richard Susskind.</p><p>Mark: I see resistance in key stakeholders — the senior judges, who hold elevated status. To ask them to give up that pomp and circumstance (“Your Honor”) is a big ask. We have to ask why they are there. Judges interpret and apply the law. We’ve lost sight of that. For example, during impeachment proceedings, subpoena question was rendered moot because it would have taken too long. That is _not_ a functioning justice system. We have the same issue at the opposite end… access to justice. This is to say, we must focus on whom the judiciary serves. It’s not just the litigants, it’s all citizens, who need better access.</p><p>Mark asks Richard: Start with the premise that law is very territorial. In the US, each state has its own law. And there are sub-units. How do we overcome this provincialism / variation.</p><p>Richard: not sure I would take -on this challenge. Introducing common approach is too hard, it’s enough to just use digital techniques for better access and dispute resolution platforms.</p><p>- Poll: audience selects clients as next topic -</p><p>Richard: the purpose of law is not to keep lawyers working. Patients don’t want surgeons, they want health. We should not ask what the future of surgeons is. We should ask how we solve the problems they address. Framing the discussion around <em>clients</em> forces us to think about <em>outcomes</em> more than how we get there.</p><p>When Mark needed medical care, he focused on outcomes, based on data, with a range of options. Why should it be different for law and clients. They should have options, and data to help them decide. The crisis is causing us to doing things differently. This opens our eyes to doing things differently. That’s the central take away of the lockdown.</p><p>Richard agrees we need to focus more on outcome. We need lawyers to think less about the type of law and more about problems clients face. And what the real issue is and outcomes clients want (eg, sometimes apologies are better than lawsuits). Lawyers need to ask clients how they want to <em>feel</em> at end, eg, whole or vindication.</p><p><strong>Q: any examples of full digital transformation of a law firm?</strong></p><p>Richard: I’ve not seen a sizable firm where this is true. Even in firms known as innovative have only small pockets of actual innovation. From press releases, we seem massively innovative but if you look beyond the surface, that’s not true. Therein lies an opportunity for alternative providers, especially the Big 4.</p><p>Mark — there are some boutiques that are digital and some in-house departments, citing DXC law department, which works with sponsor UnitedLex. We need to keep an eye on what happens when law departments go digital, what impact will that have on clients.</p><p>Richard — if legal is like other markets, the real game changer will be a new player. We now have hundreds, not just a few, legal tech start-ups. One of them might emerge.</p><p><strong>Q: If we take as given that law schools must change, including use of tech.. what are your thoughts?</strong></p><p>Mark: until 20 years ago, lawyers only needed expertise. Today they need ‘augmented skills’. that includes, eg, legal project management know-how, basics skills in data management and analytics, the ability to read a balance sheet, and understand how to use technology.</p><p>Richard: what law schools teach has changed little in 40 years. If we think of likely outcomes, lawyers will need to move beyond just legal advice, to multidisciplinary training. Now, we have 20th C. legal training. We need to move to the 21st century.</p><p><strong>Last Q: What is the role of regulators in aiding recovery and legal profession?</strong></p><p>Richard: in England and Wales, we have re-regulated. Lawyers can take investment and share fees. That makes new ventures easier. It’s still early days (starting in 2011) but we now have new providers. The goal is to have multiple providers for law. Richard: lawyers in US should not survive because they have built a moat. Clients should have a choice.</p><p>Mark: I have ABS envy (alternative business structure, which is what Richard referred to indirectly). It is a blight on US legal industry that three efforts to re-regulate have been quashed by lawyers. But now, Utah is passing some interesting reforms. It comes down to the purpose of regulation. The purpose is to serve consumers, not lawyers.</p><p>-END-</p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://prismlegal.com/richard-susskind-mark-cohen-debate-the-future-of-the-legal-industry/"><em>https://prismlegal.com</em></a><em> on April 30, 2020.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=833d1f897c54" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Law Firms Going Virtual — Prism Legal]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@ronfriedmann/law-firms-going-virtual-prism-legal-f6911028dba0?source=rss-d6a294d30768------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f6911028dba0</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[office]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[collaboration]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[wfh]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[law-firm]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[ronfriedmann]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 22 Apr 2020 15:41:47 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-04-22T15:50:22.434Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Law Firms Going Virtual — Prism Legal</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/736/0*a13tLYGMsCqlHlHJ.png" /></figure><h3>Foreward</h3><p>I’ve long believed that lawyers and law firms could work on a more virtual basis, or what we now call work from home (WFH). The COVID-19 crisis and lockdown is an awful way to learn that is true.</p><p>As law firm management — and for that matter, law department management — consider the future of WFH, an article I wrote offers some potentially useful guidance for thinking through a more deliberate strategy. I reproduce it below.</p><p>I wrote the article over 16 years ago. It appeared in the January/February 2004 edition of <em>Law Practice </em>magazine, an ABA publication as <a href="https://prismlegal.com/the_future_law_office_going_virtual/">The Future Law Office: Going Virtual</a>.</p><p>While details and brands have changed and I might place different emphases today, much remains relevant. In it, I laid out the reasons WFH would work and the benefits both firms and lawyers would recognize, including:</p><ul><li>Better work life balance with shorter or no commutes</li><li>More deliberate collaboration, both in offices and remotely</li><li>Less spent on rent via smaller offices</li></ul><p>One idea I proposed — satellite offices in the suburbs of major metro areas — never took off. It may gain legs as a result of the lockdown.</p><h3>2004 Article Reproduced</h3><p>Lawyers usually think that all the trappings of traditional firm office space are essential to practicing law and serving clients. This certainly seemed true in the past, and maybe it is still true. But maybe not. Think of all the tools and resources for going virtual that are at our disposal today. We know how they enable us to do our work when we are on the road. What about when we are off the road?</p><p>Isn’t it time to question assumptions about the need for lawyers to work from the firm’s central offices? Moving toward more work from home offices and other alternative spaces could mean dollars in the pocket, increased efficiencies and more time to relax.</p><h3>The Three Cs that Explain the Value of Office Space</h3><p>Historically, traditional law firm office space has seemed essential because of the “three Cs”: core services, collaboration and control.</p><p><strong>Core services</strong> means the resources that individual lawyers need to deliver their services to clients. This includes individual office space with furnishings, someplace where the lawyer can read, write, analyze and store all the documents that every lawyer consumes and creates. Core services also include the range of equipment that lawyers need to “produce” their work: computers, copiers, fax machines, sophisticated phones and the like. Also, producing the work typically requires staff to help and they, too, need space in which to work. In addition, once a firm has more than a few lawyers, it may also provide other core services such as a library, mail room, photocopying center and high-speed Internet services.</p><p>The second C is <strong>collaboration</strong>. While lawyers may spend many hours working in solitude, ultimately, the practice of law involves people. Consequently, lawyers need nice office space so they can collaborate with colleagues, meet with clients and negotiate with opposing counsel. Even ignoring the human impulse to socialize over the proverbial water cooler, meetings with real business purposes occur regularly. And meetings require comfortable space in which groups of people can work together.</p><p>The third C, <strong>control</strong>, relates to interactions of another kind. In the traditional models of both blue-collar and white-collar work, managers and supervisors must be physically near workers to make sure that people do whatever it is they should be doing. At least some lawyers appear to take comfort in knowing that they can walk around their firm and observe their peers, juniors and staff busily at work.</p><h3>The Demise of the Three Cs</h3><p>A “before and after” portrait of the office of today compared to 20 years ago would be striking: PCs, sophisticated telephony systems, fax machines and the Internet have fully penetrated even the smallest of law offices. Combining the new technologies with other factors means that the three Cs are much less important today than even a few years ago.</p><p><strong>The question of core services.</strong> Access to core services no longer requires space in a traditional office building. For an increasing number of professionals including lawyers it may require no more than a spare room at home. An empty room alone, however, does not an office make. Not long ago, buying the furniture and equipment to convert an empty room into an office would have been beyond the means of all but a handful. Today, though, “big box” stores such as Staples, Office Depot, Best Buy and Costco make buying office equipment (such as a PC, printer, fax machine and copier) and furniture affordable. And a high-speed residential Internet connection will hardly break the bank, either. Between affordable equipment and an Internet connection, that extra room now has many of the capabilities of a traditional, downtown, high-rent office.</p><p>Granted, a few core services, like high-speed copying and binding, are still expensive to replicate at home. For these, companies such as Kinko’s provide an easy solution.</p><p><strong>Collaboration solutions.</strong> The second collaboration is a just a bit dicier. Although there is no true substitute for face-to-face meetings, collaboration is increasingly easy from a home office. For one thing, sharing computer files is easy. Solo practitioners and small law offices can use products such as GoToMyPC to access remote computers or Web-based services for sharing files. Larger firms can use products such as Citrix Metaframe and virtual private networks to access the central servers they typically use to store all work product. In addition, communication by voice or e-mail from home is no harder than from a traditional office. Most small and large office e-mail systems allow access from any PC with an Internet connection. For voice, an extra phone line at home typically suffices. An even better option is rapidly emerging: Voice over Internet Protocol (VoIP), which allows voice calls to be routed over the Internet. VoIP phones can easily be forwarded so that clients and colleagues have no idea where the call is actually being received. Moreover, a home PC can control VoIP phones and provide the more sophisticated features of central exchanges, such as, for example, conference calling and call forwarding.</p><p>For face-to-face communication, videoconferencing is a reasonable option. Although desktop computer video has its limitations, it is easy, relatively inexpensive and rapidly improving in quality. For jointly viewing or editing documents over a distance, there are many options. Webconferencing software, including WebEx, LiveMeeting and Lotus Sametime, allow sharing the desktop and applications. Other products, such as Viack’s VIA3, allow sharing documents and a video connection on the same screen. For those instances when sharing paper is essential, there is always that old standby, the fax machine or, better yet, scanning and sending images by e-mail (or via a shared file system).</p><p><strong>The control factor. </strong>The third control is a red herring. Lawyers are, by definition, professionals. Although they do need to be managed, they do not need to be supervised and controlled by physical observation. A lawyer who objects to a colleague working away from a central office because the colleague might not really be working should really worry about a more basic problem. Lawyers are obliged to bill their time accurately; an unethical lawyer can pad hours as easily in the office as at home. The answer to this concern is not control by observation. The answer is to find a new colleague.</p><h3>The Next Way: Mixing It Up for Firms of Every Size</h3><p>Without the constraints of the three Cs, we are free to think about new working arrangements. What might this “next way” look like? For various reasons (discussed in the next section), a true virtual office, meaning an organization without central facilities, where everyone works at home, is not realistic. The next way is more likely to involve a mixed arrangement.</p><p>Lawyers could work at home many days and, when they come to the firm’s offices, focus on those activities unique to central offices, such as attending in-person meetings or accessing core services or staff not available elsewhere. For larger firms, the next way might also include heavy use of low-overhead, limited-amenity suburban “satellite” offices that offer the three Cs at much lower cost than downtown space. For small firms and solos, it might mean heavier reliance on companies such as Regus that lease high-quality office space on a shared or as-needed basis or on clubs that rent nice conference rooms as needed.</p><p>The benefit of the next way for firms small and large is a significant reduction in the amount of expensive office space they need. This is not to say firms could eliminate central, downtown offices altogether. Rather, they could consider smaller lawyer offices, office shares and even hoteling (a system in which offices are not assigned to individuals but rather are used on an as-needed basis). Office shares could be implemented quickly. Creating smaller offices or switching to hoteling would require waiting until a move, a build out of new space or a big renovation.</p><p>The next way would also benefit lawyers by eliminating long commutes. Lawyers who avoid nonproductive commutes by working at home or in nearby suburban satellite offices would either have a higher quality of life or be able to bill more hours. Further, working at home some days would help lawyers with caregiving obligations to more easily juggle work and personal obligations.</p><p>Of course, some lawyers would resent any downsizing of their office, either for practical or for status reasons. Others might find it distracting to listen to office- or hotel-mates on the phone. (But let’s not forget that much of corporate America works in cubicles or open offices.) And many might miss day-to-day social interactions. A simple solution to these concerns is to make the next way an option rather than a requirement and allow individual lawyers to make the trade-offs required.</p><h3>Will the Next Way Work?</h3><p>Commentators have promoted the so-called virtual office for many years. The obvious question is: Would the next way work? It seems likely to for five reasons.</p><p><strong>First</strong>, many traditional offices, especially in larger law firms, create barriers to face-to-face collaboration. Even if all the floors of a large law office are on the same elevator bank, it can be very time-consuming to visit lawyers on other floors. If getting to some of those floors requires going to the lobby to switch elevator banks, the psychic barrier to visiting goes way up. Moreover, the value of spontaneous interactions is questionable in offices of hundreds of lawyers. Once an office has more than some critical number of lawyers, it’s hard to recognize, much less know, everyone else.</p><p>Most law firms with multiple offices face another barrier to in-person collaboration. If the multiple offices really act as a single firm, actively cross-selling services and staffing matters based on expertise and availability rather than geography, then the physical location of lawyers should not matter. Once a colleague is not in the same physical office, the technologies discussed earlier mean that it should make no difference whether that colleague works from home or a different office. As a marketing matter, multi-office firms that advertise their “one firm” culture will find it hard to argue that daily presence in a local office is essential.</p><p><strong>Second</strong>, many professional services organizations, particularly the Big Four accounting firms and some management consultancies, successfully use hoteling. Granted, in these businesses the professionals spend more time at clients’ offices than at their own firms’ offices. But this demonstrates that a firm can operate effectively even though its professionals are widely dispersed.</p><p><strong>Third</strong>, a few large law firms have already demonstrated that lawyers and staff need not work in the same location. Orrick Herrington has consolidated many technology, finance and other functions in a West Virginia office detached from all lawyers. Baker &amp; McKenzie has moved several technology functions, including the help desk, which deals directly with lawyers, from the United States to service centers in Asia. And Allen &amp; Overy has relocated a significant portion of its document production function from London to India.</p><p>It’s one thing to move staff off-site. It’s another to move lawyers. But many firms already have experience with an equivalent situation: lawyers who travel several days per week or are at a trial site for weeks or months. Further, some law firms do move lawyers off-site, to clients on secondment. For example, international law firm Herbert Smith currently has 70 lawyers working at client sites and expects the number to grow to 100. The experience of firms dealing with seconded and traveling lawyers is pretty good evidence that they can operate effectively without everyone being in the same office every day.</p><p><strong>Fourth</strong>, the next way will be facilitated by decreasing reliance on secretaries. Many solo practitioners and lawyers in small firms already have little or no secretarial support. And in large firms, the ratio of lawyers to secretaries has steadily increased. (Junior lawyers are commonly in three-on-one situations.) To the extent there is still lawyer reliance on secretaries within the firm, technology allows secretaries to serve lawyers at a distance. In some large law offices, lawyers are already on different floors than secretaries and do not see their secretaries very often.</p><p><strong>Fifth</strong>, many firms of all sizes already have experience substituting technology for proximity. One example is the increasing use of videoconferencing to connect multiple offices. Another is the use of application service providers (ASPs), such as CaseShare, CaseCentral and Lextranet, to “host” centrally stored litigation discovery documents. And, lastly, some law firms use products such as WebEx or LiveMeeting to present webinars to clients and e-learning software to present CLE programs to their own lawyers.</p><p>While no single factor alone supports the next way, taken together, these factors suggest that mind-sets have already shifted and that tools are available that facilitate lawyers working at a distance. The next way does not, however, mean doing away with law firm offices or working at home all the time. Lawyers will still need central offices for face-to-face meetings with colleagues and clients. But they do not have to be in the office every day.</p><h3>Next Steps: Avoiding Problems</h3><p>The skeptics will argue that daily face-to-face contact in traditional offices is critical. But it would be interesting to analyze how lawyers actually spend their time on a functional basis. Were one to obtain data about the percentage of time lawyers spend in meetings and the number of days per week meetings occur, we might well learn that it would be easy to schedule in-person meetings in such a way that lawyers only had to be in the office a limited number of days. The skeptics might also argue that such data would unduly discount the value of chance encounters, whether it is a lawyer walking into a colleague’s office or the proverbial watercooler chat. But let’s face it — many chance encounters are just distractions from work and a detriment to productivity. No one is likely to collect the empirical data, though and the skeptics probably have a point. But lawyers interested in making the next way work effectively can take steps to ameliorate some of the potential negatives.</p><p>One place to begin is to examine how law offices currently coordinate work. It may be that the emperor has no clothes, meaning that presence does not equal collaboration. With a move to the next way, firms could take institutional steps that would help avoid key problems. Here are some ideas.</p><ul><li>Schedule practice group meetings and require attendance absent compelling client reasons. Some firms may have to confront their own mythology here. It might turn out that some practice groups exist more in name than in fact. If the next way exposed such as situation, that would be a positive, not a negative.</li><li>Formalize mentoring programs so that junior lawyers have scheduled “face time” with their mentors. Daily presence in an office is no guarantee of mentoring young lawyers frequently complain they cannot find mentors.</li><li>Have more team meetings and other communications. The fact that all the lawyers working together on a matter are all present in one office does not automatically mean that they are coordinated. Between busy schedules and client billing policies, lawyers who run matters sometimes do too little to coordinate the team’s work. Explicit steps to meet more often or coordinate via Web-based tools could improve both productivity and morale.</li><li>Add social functions. There is clearly a benefit to knowing one’s colleagues and having connections beyond the purely business. Given how busy lawyers are and how little time they have at home, many tend to limit their participation in office social events. Perhaps those who spent more time working at home would more regularly attend firm events, both because the perceived value would increase and because they would feel less stressed about not being at home enough. And some lawyers would gladly give up chance office social interactions for structured events that include the people they really want to see.</li><li>In general, a systematic approach to dealing with the regular “absence” of lawyers from the office could end up enhancing collegiality and other benefits assumed to arise automatically from coming to the office daily.</li></ul><p>Technology can also help address the downsides, including the possible sense of isolation those working at home may feel. Leveraging e-mail and instant messaging can certainly enhance communications and the sense of interacting with colleagues located elsewhere. In addition, firms can establish collaborative Web spaces in which lawyers share client-, practice- and firm-related information regularly.</p><h3>There’s Little to Lose in Trying</h3><p>Where, then, is the peril in trying the next way? Lawyers and firms regularly make decisions that carry risk, though that risk is frequently not well perceived or appreciated. Consider the risks of nonpayment by a new client, the risks associated with hiring a new staff person or lawyer, or the risk of signing a lease. Because the next way can be tried on an incremental basis, it does not entail all that much risk.</p><p>The cost to experiment with suburban offices or work at home is relatively low. A firm that thinks it needs more downtown office space could, instead of expanding, try some of the tactics discussed here. For a firm with many locations, experimenting with alternative arrangements would seem especially useful, considering the possible savings. The worst-case scenario is that the expansion would happen after the test failed. But the upside could be a more efficient, effective, lower-cost operation with happier lawyers and more satisfied clients.</p><p>As firms large and small look to save money, increase effectiveness and improve the quality of each lawyer’s life, they need to take some chances. They need to look for existing models that already work and to experiment with new models. This may well be an area where the large firms can learn from the small ones. Many smaller firms, because they lack resources or because they have simply chosen to operate in a different manner, have had to be creative in their approach to running their businesses. Rather than resist on principle, firms should look wherever they can to learn how the next way could work for them.</p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://prismlegal.com/law-firms-going-virtual/"><em>https://prismlegal.com</em></a><em> on April 22, 2020.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f6911028dba0" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Taking Legal Analytics to the Next Level — Prism Legal]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@ronfriedmann/taking-legal-analytics-to-the-next-level-prism-legal-a0b373bc9d1f?source=rss-d6a294d30768------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a0b373bc9d1f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[law-firm]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[strategy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[litigation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[analytics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[clients]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[ronfriedmann]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 13 Apr 2020 21:20:46 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-04-13T21:32:17.062Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Taking Legal Analytics to the Next Level — Prism Legal</h3><h3>COVID-19 Prelude</h3><p>I started writing this blog post about LegalMation just as the COVID crisis was ramping up. By the time I finished it, the world had changed. As I noted in my <a href="https://prismlegal.com/fastcase-gains-share-in-big-law/">blog post last week about Fastcase</a>, this crisis will last a while. And what happens after it remains uncertain. Already, many large law firms have cut costs or withheld partner draws to conserve cash. We are now past the end of the beginning of the crisis. Consequently, law firm management should now plan for what comes next.</p><p>Many industries are already struggling and that almost certainly will continue. At least some practices therefore likely will face fee pressure. It may not be happening yet with “the house on fire”. But it almost certainly will come. And when it does, firms need to be ready to offer better value. That will drive the need to understand costs and manage matters more effectively.</p><p>LegalMation offers an interesting approach to cost and outcome analytics. As usual, when I blog about a provider, I do so because I find the product or service interesting and new or different. I am not comparing it to other approaches or reviewing it; rather explaining it.</p><p>— — — -</p><p>The legal analytics revolution continues. <a href="https://www.legalmation.com/">LegalMation</a> has developed a new approach to litigation data analytics. I learned about this from the <em>Artificial Lawyer</em> post <a href="https://www.artificiallawyer.com/2020/03/19/legalmation-expands-into-cost-analysis-lawyer-comparison/">LegalMation Expands Into Cost Analysis + Lawyer Comparison</a> (19 March 2020). Previously, the company <a href="https://abovethelaw.com/2018/04/law-firm-asks-ai-engine-to-draft-answers-upon-information-and-belief-error-404/">earned kudos in 2018</a> for its AI-driven approach automating draft answers to complaints.</p><p>I wanted to learn more about the new offering so I spoke with <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/james-lee-9468b64/">James Lee</a>, co-founder of LegalMation and report here.</p><h3>The Analytic Paradigm of Predicting Outcomes</h3><p><strong>Models and Analysis Can Improve Outcomes.</strong> Clients want to minimize litigation costs: the sum of legal fees, expenses, and the judgment or settlement. Smart law firms want to achieve better results for clients at lower cost. If lawyers understand how case strategy affects outcomes, then they can improve outcomes and/or reduce cost. For example, if investing more time early in a matter leads to better outcomes, then do that. Or if lawyers knew that using more senior lawyer time early in a matter, say during depositions, improved outcomes, then modify the staffing mix.</p><p><strong>How to Model + Analyze Case. </strong>To analyze the relationship between outcomes and cost and their drivers requires data and analysis. A word about analysis before turning to the data. Analysis can be bivariate: compare outcomes to just one input. Or it can be multivariate, comparing outcomes to multiple drivers. Either way, lawyers need a good theory of why one variable affects the other because correlation doesn’t equal causation.</p><p><strong>The Data Needed for Models and Analysis.</strong> A statistically reliable model requires good data and enough of it. While publicly available data provides some insights, 97% currently lies beneath the surface in the document and data repositories at the law firms and corporations. LegalMation’s approach offers a new approach to surface these data, an approach that may uncover insights previously not attainable. To get to those insights, its software:</p><ol><li>Characterizes what cases are about and classifies them.</li><li>Explains the work lawyers did on the case.</li><li>Measures the case outcome.</li></ol><p>In the next section, I discuss how LegalMation gets these.</p><h3>Generating the Data and Analyzing It</h3><p><strong>High Volume Data and Outcomes Data.</strong> LegalMation focused on two types of high volume cases: employment (such as age or disability discrimination claims) and personal injury claims (such as slip-and-fall cases). Most organizations with high volumes of litigation use enterprise legal management software (ELM) to track legal costs. Pulling cost data for analysis is easy.</p><p><strong>Characterizing Cases.</strong> LegalMation’s key insight was that they could use their underlying machine learning software to characterize both cases and the work lawyers do. Its software extracts information (“entities”) from documents. Examples include jurisdiction, parties, injuries alleged, and dollar claims. By extracting enough entities, the company systematically describes what cases are about. LegalMation captures and identifies up to 500 unique entity-relationships in areas of law: employment, personal injury, insurance defense, and financial services litigation.</p><p><strong>Characterizing Lawyer Work. </strong>The software also uses entity extraction to analyze lawyer time narratives. LegalMation determines both the <em>phase </em>of litigation and the <em>type</em> of work, for example research, writing, deposition preparation, taking a deposition, or appearing in court. (Assigning the phase depends on both machine learning on narratives and external task set definitions.)</p><p><strong>Phase and Work Type Classification.</strong> LegalMation’s first product in 2018 analyzed complaints and automatically drafted answers and discovery requests. To do this on par with a good junior associate, the company had to build and train its artificial intelligence to read passages from filings and comprehend their meaning. That, in turn, required developing a taxonomy and classification system to differentiate text at a granular level. The ability to analyze outcomes and work is an extension of these capabilities.</p><p>In analyzing matters by phase, existing standards for phase and work type were not helpful. The ABA phase and task codes are not very granular and, in any event, the lawyers who use them do not do so well. Moreover, LegalMation learned from law departments that most just wanted hours by phase; task-level detail proved distracting. The company extended its software to capture <em>events</em> in litigation from beginning to end of cases. Getting this right required deep and iterative work with lawyers in law departments and firms. Beyond automating a tedious task, using software to define phases yields more consistent data than human coding. This allows more reliable comparison of billing data across lawyers and firms.</p><p><strong>Visualize Relationships.</strong> To analyze these data, LegalMation provides visualization tools using capabilities from Tableau and IBM Cognos.</p><h3>Implications</h3><p>Legal analytics blossomed in the 2010s. Entrepreneurs realized that public information contained data to provide insight about litigation, data that incumbent providers had failed to tap. Early and successful legal analytic start-ups included Lex Machina, Casetext, Ravel Law, and Judicata. At the risk of oversimplifying, those companies initially focused on the law, judges, and citations.</p><p>Now, LegalMation is focusing on case facts and what we might think of as case metadata. James showed me several visuals that illustrate intriguing and actionable relationships. For example, plotting the age bracket of a plaintiff against case outcomes in the sample data set shows that the most costly outcomes are for plaintiffs age 50 to 55. That contradicts many labor lawyers’ instinct that older plaintiffs are more costly. It is also actionable: knowing this should affect the type of work lawyers do and their settlement negotiations.</p><p><strong>The figures below illustrate this type of analysis for disability harassment claims based on physical (top) vs. mental disability (bottom). The average settlement amounts are quite different. Today, most legal professionals lump all disability harassment claims in one bucket. The data, however, clearly show meaningful differences among sub-types. Knowing this allows lawyers and managers to make better decisions about handling each type. (These charts also illustrate the detailed analytics possible. The panes to left are facets / filters that allow an analyst quickly and easily to select different data slices.)</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*c3Z4ovfJLf2oQxsP.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*hpR_FQvT829bLU1n.png" /></figure><p>Another example compares the cost of lawyer time by phase with outcome. In the sample data, cases with more investment in early phases ( <em>e.g.</em> fact finding and depositions) achieve better outcomes than investing more later in the case. That should drive more lawyer work to early in the matter. (Spend by <em>phase</em> is an example of what I view as matter metadata.) <strong>The figure below illustrates the part of the analysis that looks at the difference in hours between partners and associates by phase. It is for a single firm. One can produce charts like this for multiple firms and compare outcomes.</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*wxiiMaRHRsfPAkzG.jpg" /></figure><p>James also showed me charts that compare outcomes to a set of specific plaintiff law firms. These clearly show some firms cost more to battle than others. <strong>The two figures below illustrate summarizing this type of analysis in a single metric — the dial here — to measure risk. The first shows a high risk score of 114.5 for one plaintiff’s attorney and the second a low-average score of 56.81. The first \s an attorney who takes cases to the end, seen in the bar chart to the left, with a high percent of time on trial and appeal. The second one tends to settle in the oral and written discovery phases — at typically lower amounts. James reports that the risk index compiles multiple measurements / statistics that relate to settlement amounts, hours incurred, and strength of counsel He said “the risk score is working really well in forecasting the level of risk.”</strong> <strong>The blurred orange / blue bars in the lower right of each figure show the sub-scores for each component of the risk index.</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*aqWOwjjwGhw1MQ3V.jpg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*VdWbDRFTYDwIBMKc.jpg" /></figure><p>A geek note: The real driver of the difference might not be firm but rather the judicial district (especially if plaintiff firms operate mainly in select districts). Where two explanatory variables correlate with one another, reliable modeling may require some more serious statistical chops.</p><p>James showed me multiple interesting visual comparisons of potential drivers and outcomes. In my former work as an econometrician, I’d call this exploratory data analysis, the practice of examining multiple relationships using visual displays. That stands in contrast to testing specific hypotheses. Good modeling requires both and, as important, having a sound hypothesis for any unexpected relationships that exploration yields.</p><h3>Conclusion</h3><p>LegalMation’s ability to characterize matters and lawyer work means that legal professionals can now model how decisions about case strategy affect outcomes. In-house counsel, legal operations professionals, and law firm partners who manage portfolios of related litigation should be all over this. Done properly, it will improve case strategy, and for in-house lawyers, selection of outside counsel. We could even develop best practices for legal strategies.</p><p>Even with fabulous findings to improve litigation outcomes or reduce costs, we will face a change management challenge. Empirical evidence alone rarely persuades lawyers to change what they do. To change what lawyers do, be prepared to offer carrots and sticks — and for some hard work.</p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://prismlegal.com/taking-legal-analytics-to-the-next-level/"><em>https://prismlegal.com</em></a><em> on April 13, 2020.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a0b373bc9d1f" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>