<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Ronald D. Rodriguez on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Ronald D. Rodriguez on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@ronman63?source=rss-14e38d873f99------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Fri, 20 Nov 2026 17:47:19 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@ronman63/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Gospel According to Mike Tyson]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/letters-to-a-young-cynic/the-gospel-according-to-mike-tyson-083f1f7ea793?source=rss-14e38d873f99------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/083f1f7ea793</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[special-education]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[hip-hop]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mike-tyson]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[love]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[boxing]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ronald D. Rodriguez]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 19 Nov 2024 03:04:21 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-11-19T03:04:21.737Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Time waits for no man.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*9SQsKKSpG0wz8cWxYVkOsQ.png" /></figure><p>It’s November 15, 2024. I just finished watching the “Battle of the Ages” between 58-year-old Mike Tyson and 27-year-old Jake Paul. And now I’m sitting up in bed, the remote still in my hand, thinking about my mortality and about the time I crossed paths with Mike Tyson in a club in West Hollywood on Martin Luther King Day in 1990.</p><p>I had a friend, we’ll call him Deshawn. At the time we were both working swing shifts in the dormitory of a residential school for severely multi-handicapped children. Microcephaly. Seizure disorders. Tourette’s Syndrome. Blindness. Hearing loss. Down’s Syndrome. Fetal Alcohol Syndrome. You name it, we probably had it. There was a staff of young people in the dormitory, mostly women, who took care of the children’s daily needs. Feeding, bathing, changing diapers, keeping logs for seizures and for bowel movements. Deshawn and I bonded mostly because we were the only two guys in the dormitory.</p><p>We were an odd pair. I came from a conservative white middle-class suburb in northwest Indiana. Deshawn was from a struggling south Los Angeles neighborhood. I had moved to California four years earlier. My bachelors in English did me no favors occupationally and I was struggling to find a purpose in life. My job with the kids was an effort to find something meaningful and would eventually lead to my becoming a special education teacher. Deshawn had no similar ambitions. He was just trying to make ends meet and, to him, this job wiping pre-teen butts was crazy, but it was better than working fast food.</p><p>Despite our differences, Deshawn and I had some important things in common. First, we had the same cynical worldview. Deshawn grew up in a gang infested, drug riddled inner city where there was persistent poverty and societal neglect and indifference. I grew up in a nice white suburb, but was routinely condescended to and bullied and denied the basic niceties simply because I was Mexican, or, more accurately, because I was not white. (See my story, “Heroism Denied: A Mexican American Boy in 1970s Indiana.”) This meant that we were both highly attuned to the bullshit around us and shared a very dark sense of humor. We also had the same taste in music, which at that time was mostly hip hop, although Deshawn often had to explain the inner-city references to me. For example, he had to explain to me why 911 was a joke. (See Public Enemy’s “911 is a Joke” from the album “Fear of a Black Planet.”)</p><p>Our shared appreciation of hip hop music naturally led to us hitting the dance clubs together. Deshawn would pick me up in his beat up Ford Fiesta and make his ritual pre-clubbing stop at the 7–11 to grab some “meat and cheeeeeese,” which is how he referred to Slim Jims and cheese sticks. Once he was sufficiently psyched up to “pick up some honeys,” we would head over to one of the many clubs throughout town, none of which I can remember the names of, although there was one ornate theater I remember that was called either the Aztec or the Mayan. Deshawn loved the way I danced. He would laugh and point and tell me how I looked “so stupid.” Which, oddly enough, was both an insult to my dancing, and a compliment to my confidence. And every time he saw a woman with a “banging” body, he would gesture to her butt or her chest and yell, “BAM! BAM! BAM!” But neither of us ever got lucky. I can’t imagine why.</p><p>Monday, January 15, 1990. The Martin Luther King holiday. Deshawn and I both had the night off so we headed on over to a club and it was, by far, the most happening place I had ever been to. There were wall to wall people. Somebody was spinning disks, but there didn’t seem to be any dancing going on. It was just a scene. And a cool one at that.</p><p>Sitting on a ledge against the wall to our left was the duo Milli Vanilli. Good looking guys. Wearing black leather. I was unaware at that time that there had been whispers about them not being the real singers on their albums, but the controversy would eventually explode 10 months later, in November of 1990, when their producer, Frank Farian, admitted that Rob Pilatus and Fab Morvan did not sing on their album “Girl You Know It’s True.” That same month the two were subsequently dropped from their label, Arista Records, and their Grammy for Best New Artist was rescinded.</p><p>It was not long after we had noticed Milli Vanilli that a commotion broke out and we felt ourselves being pushed to the side. Mike Tyson had entered the room, surrounded by four or maybe six body guards. They walked past us and towards the front of the hall.</p><p>Mike Tyson is three years younger than I am: I was born June 1963 and he was born June 1966. Tyson was, by all accounts, going through a rough patch in 1988 and 1989. In 1988 he fired both is manager and his trainer. He had suffered a very publicly tumultuous marriage to Robin Givens, which included accusations of physical abuse by Tyson and a reported miscarriage. They divorced in 1989. He had no kids at this point but there was one on the way from another woman. His daughter Mikey (Miki) Lorna Tyson would be born in July 1990. Finally, in November 1990, ten months after our Martin Luther King Day encounter, and the same month that Milli Vanilli would implode, Tyson would lose for the first time in his professional boxing career; surrendering his WBA, WBC, and IBF heavyweight titles to Buster Douglas in Tokyo, Japan on a technical knockout. (For many months afterwards I would chant “TKO in Tokyo, TKO in Tokyo,” while going about my day.)</p><p>But Tyson’s troubles were not evident on this night. Mike Tyson, surprisingly, is only 5”10”, which, judging by proportion, means that his bodyguards were probably 6’3” and taller. Even so, of the bunch, Mike Tyson was by far the most intimidating. This is largely because of his startling proportions. Tyson may have been short, relatively speaking, but he was also very thick, chest to back; and very wide, shoulder to shoulder. As they pushed by I leaned over to Deshawn and shouted, “He looks like a brick wall!” With that low center of gravity. one could easily picture how his punches could pack so much power. How the force would travel from the floor, up his leg, through his swiveling torso and down his thick muscular arm straight into someone’s face. (Or, to quote my shotokan sensei, “Punch from the floor.”) His reputation might have prompted my visceral reaction, but his physical presence was terrifying.</p><p>We did not see him again for the rest of the evening. At 2:00 A.M. the music stopped and the DJ said we all had to leave. In a huddled mass of humanity we squeezed our way outside where we were met by a phalanx of LA’s finest decked out in riot gear and lining the street across from the club. Above us was the fwup-fwup-fwup of a helicopter. A spotlight swept back and forth across the crowd and a loudspeaker shouted:</p><p>“Get into your cars, and go home! Get into your cars, and go home!”</p><p>This was very exciting, and nothing like anything I had ever experienced back in my small town in Indiana. I looked over at Deshawn and shouted, “So, what do you want to do?!”</p><p>Deshawn’s eyes grew wide and he looked at me like I had leprosy. “What do I want to doooo?! I want to get in my car and go home, that’s what I want to do! Do you think this is a joke?!”</p><p>So we got in his car and we went home.</p><blockquote><strong><em>The boiling frog</em></strong><em> is an apologue describing a frog being slowly boiled alive. The premise is that if a frog is put suddenly into boiling </em><strong><em>water</em></strong><em>, it will jump out, but if the frog is put in tepid </em><strong><em>water</em></strong><em> which is then brought to a boil slowly, it will not perceive the danger and will be cooked to death.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>Wikipedia</em></blockquote><p>Age sneaks up on you.</p><p>When you’re a man you never ever stop thinking that you can get the hot girl. Or that you can defend yourself against a group of thugs. Or that you can win at a competitive sporting event against someone half your age.</p><p>But age is real. Deterioration is real. Your body’s oxygen efficiency drops. You have fewer muscle fibers. Your neuromuscular system (the connection between your brain and your muscles) is not as effective or efficient. Your connective tissues are weaker. Your body’s healing process is delayed. In short: you are slower, you are weaker, you are less coordinated, and the damage you you endure may be permanent.</p><p>I am three years older than Mike Tyson, and I held out hope that Tyson would clobber Jake Paul; in the same way that I hold out hope that I can do all the things that I used to be able to do when I was younger. But watching Tyson biting on his glove, keeping his distance, and trudging to his corner as if he were heading to bed, made me reflect on my own limitations. I’m sure if I were to go dancing today I would still look “stupid,” but I don’t know that it would be a good stupid like it was in 1990. Rather than be admired for my confidence, I’d probably be pitied for trying to do what young people do.</p><p>In Hawaii, where I live, they recently passed a law that makes an assault against someone of my age, 60 years and older, an assault in the first degree. That is an enhanced penalty, from second degree to first degree assault, due to circumstances related to the age of the victim. The law recognizes me as fragile.</p><p>When did the water go from tepid to boiling?</p><p>Meanwhile, here’s the partial transcript of an <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yFrybVY2r7E">interview</a> with a 14-year-old reporter Jazlyn “Jazzy” Guerra:</p><blockquote><em>Jazzy: “What legacy does Mike Tyson want to leave behind?”</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>Tyson: “I don’t believe in the word ‘legacy.’ I think that’s another word for ego. Legacy doesn’t mean nothing. That’s just some word everybody grabbed on to. Someone said that word and everyone grabbed on to that word, now it’s used every five seconds. It means absolutely nothing to me. I’m just passing through. I’m gonna die and it’s gonna be over. Who cares about legacy after that?</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>“So I’m gonna die. I want people to think that I’m this, I’m great? No, we’re nothing. We’re just dead. We’re dust. We’re absolutely nothing. Our legacy is nothing.”</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>Jazzy: “Well thank you so much for sharing that. That is something that I have not heard before, someone saying that as an answer.”</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>Tyson: “Can you really imagine somebody saying, ‘I want my legacy to be this way?’ You’re dead! Who the f — — cares about me when I’m gone? My kids, maybe, or grandkids?”</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>Jazzy: “True. And, again, thank you so much for sharing that.”</em></blockquote><p>First, hats off to Jazzy. She handled it like a pro.</p><p>Rob Pilatus died of a drug overdose in 1998 on the eve of the release of Milli Vanilli’s comeback album. In any event, based on the gospel according to Mike Tyson, Milli Vanilli should probably not worry about their legacy.</p><p>Watching Mike Tyson, the man who I found so intimidating 34 years ago, shuffle around the boxing ring like <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z-QqmJimv_U">Tim Conway</a>, and waxing profanely about his legacy or lack thereof, reminded me that there comes a time in every man’s life when it’s just better to get into your car and go home.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=083f1f7ea793" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/letters-to-a-young-cynic/the-gospel-according-to-mike-tyson-083f1f7ea793">The Gospel According to Mike Tyson</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/letters-to-a-young-cynic">Letters to a Young Cynic</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Heroism Denied: A Mexican-American Boy in 1970s Indiana]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/letters-to-a-young-cynic/heroism-denied-a-mexican-american-boy-in-1970s-indiana-fafecb06718e?source=rss-14e38d873f99------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/fafecb06718e</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[classical-music]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[fight]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[midwest]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mexican]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[prejudice]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ronald D. Rodriguez]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 19 Nov 2024 02:22:26 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-11-19T02:22:26.506Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>The Chicano with a Thousand Faces</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*TRBUi3Ga14b_vbwbllxnBQ.jpeg" /></figure><h4>A memoir in the third person.</h4><p>Ron was too short to be playing basketball, but he enrolled in the summer basketball clinic at the local high school anyway. As he sat in the stadium lobby, surrounded by about 30 of his 11-year-old cohorts, waiting for the doors to the basketball court to open, he wondered how he ended up here. He didn’t remember ever asking to attend basketball clinic. And he didn’t recall being coerced into it either. More likely than not, somebody, probably his mom, suggested it and, absent any kind of alternative, the suggestion became reality.</p><p>Naturally it would be his mom who would suggest it because it was his mom who was stuck with him all summer. Actually, that’s not true. His mom wasn’t stuck with “Ronald.” She loved Ronald, and she enjoyed having him around. But it was summer and she wanted him to be out playing, like his older brother Jesse did. Ronald was nothing like Jesse. Jesse had his father’s wavy hair whereas Ron had his mother’s straight hair. Jesse had chiseled masculine features. Ron had a friendly, open, rounded face. Jesse was handsome and lean. Ron was cute. More importantly, Jesse had friends. And Jesse would go outside. With his friends. And engage in the sort of feverish competitive savagery considered normal for fourteen-year-old boys. The kind of mischief that some people consider necessary to find your manhood. Playing competitive sports, or chasing girls, or arguing over the rules of a game. Ron, on the other hand, was not particularly athletic and preferred to spend his time indoors. He scanned the newspaper every morning, reading pretty much anything that didn’t have to do with Watergate (whatever that was). He could spend hours crouched over construction paper with his 30-count set of colored markers. He liked watching Phil Donahue, and he loved classical music.</p><p>There was a TV commercial that aired frequently, usually in the middle of Gilligan’s Island reruns, featuring a high brow upper-crust elderly gentleman in a double-breasted suit standing next to a harp and a marble or plaster bust of somebody probably Beethoven. The commercial was for an album set of 120 Classical Masterpieces, and the names of classical works would scroll across the screen while music played in the background. Ron would write down some of the names then, every couple of weeks, ride to the local library on his purple bike to browse their modest but representative album collection. (Jesse wouldn’t have been caught dead on a purple bike.) Over time, Ron worked his way through Bach, Pachelbel, Beethoven, Tchaikovsky, Rachmaninoff, and Chopin, among others.</p><p>Record albums, for those who don’t know, were kept in cardboard slip covers and if you held the cover the wrong way the album could slide right out. This is what happened to Ron one day as he was leaving the library. He was holding the album covers with the slit side facing forward and, when he hit the breaks on his purple bike, the albums flew out of the covers like a pair of skeets and crashed onto the gravel pavement. Ron picked up the albums, very distressed, brushed them off, and slouched back to the circulation desk.</p><p>It’s important to note that this was 1974, in a predominantly white suburb in Indiana. There were no blacks, and only a handful of Mexican families, many of whom, like his father, were employed by the steel mills in Gary and East Chicago. And although many of the people in his small town were perfectly decent, he learned at an early age that a significant segment was not going to be receptive to him. Ever. And so he learned to keep his head down and go about his business. As a result, aside from saying “thank you” at check out, Ron had never spoken to the librarians, and they had never really spoken to him. Until now.</p><p>Ron was almost in tears as he approached the librarian, a blonde woman probably in her thirties. He assumed he would be in trouble and that the damage he caused would be very expensive. He described to her what happened. “I’m so sorry! I’m so sorry! I can pay for it, I promise. I just need to talk to my dad.”</p><p>Ron’s eyes were cast down as he said this so he did not notice when the one librarian magically multiplied into three. The two other women must have come from the back when they heard his squeaking apology.</p><p>“No, no, it’s okay!” They all sang in a cooing chorus of gentle overlapping urgency. “We can replace them. It’s okay. This happens all the time. Don’t worry. It’s okay. We’re not mad. You don’t have to tell anybody. It’s fine. Would you like to check something else out? Go ahead, choose another album. Please. It’s okay.”</p><p>Ron looked up and saw how all these women were trying so hard to be soothing. It went beyond tenderness. It was more like familiarity. Suddenly, it occurred him: these women knew him. They probably talked about him every time he came in. He was that cute little brown kid who checked out classical albums. We love you, we know you, we love you, we know you, we love you, we know you, please keep coming back.</p><p>Indiana could be like that sometimes. Polar extremes of tribalist hate and liberal love.</p><p>So, Jesse and Ron were not very much alike. And, it’s not like Ron didn’t have any friends, despite his Mom’s misgivings. He got along well enough with his classmates. It’s just that his friendships were, for the most part, situational. Not the sort of friendships that carried over from school into the “real world.” But Ron’s mother couldn’t see that. She saw his isolation as unhealthy. Like loneliness or depression. And she worried that maybe he wasn’t liked. She never actually said it, but you could see it in her eyes. “Where are your friends? How come they don’t come around?” He didn’t know. How do you know when you’re not invited to something unless someone tells you, “Oh, hey Ron, by the way, we decided to get together over the weekend and we didn’t invite. you.” Nobody says that. So, how would he know? Maybe his class was just a class of loners. Did she ever consider that?</p><p>What’s worse, Ron’s mother had recently gotten into the habit of telling Jesse to “take your brother” whenever Jesse wanted to meet up with friends. And Jesse’s friends would jostle Ron around and say things like, “Hey, are you tough like your brother?” Ron never knew how to respond to that, which sort of answered the question. No. “Take your brother” was a bad development for everyone involved. So, if Ron didn’t object to attending basketball clinic, that was probably why.</p><h4>The Instigator</h4><p>Every day Ron would ride his purple bike up 45th Avenue, approximately one mile to local high school where the clinic was being held. He didn’t know anybody in the clinic, but it was not a complete waste. Ron was amused by the rhythmic squeak of tennis shoes, the vibrating clank of the basketball rim, and the rare but occasional swoosh of the net. He marveled at the smell of the basketball’s rubber on his hands. He was getting the hang of dribbling, and the two-handed pass, and even the layup. And, most surprisingly, he was enjoying the feeling of exhilaration that comes from engaging in sweaty physical activity. But it was pretty obvious that he was never going to be Julius Erving.</p><p>“Hey! You!”</p><p>Ron was aware that somebody was yelling in the lobby, but he was preoccupied by his jog strap. It itched and he was trying to figure out how he could scratch it without digging his hand into his shorts.</p><p>“Hey!”</p><p>If Jesse’s groin itched, would he care if anybody saw him scratching it?</p><p>“Hey! I’m talking to you!”</p><p>Ron looked up. The crowd in the lobby appeared to have parted so as not to stand in the path of the voice. A puny kid with straight dishwater blonde hair cut in a bowl, and beady eyes that were set a sliver too close together, was pointing at him. Ron seemed to be the last person in the room to know he was being yelled at.</p><p>“Yeah, you!”</p><p>The puny kid’s voice was shrill, but his face was slack, like someone who is trying to look innocent. The sort of guy who would shoot a spit-wad at the teacher and then point at someone else. Ron had never met this guy before, but he knew his type. We’ll call him Shithead.</p><p>Shithead’s scratchy voice shot across the lobby like a crow.</p><p>“See this guy?!” Shithead pointed at a much bigger kid standing next to him. “You and him. Are going to fight. At the football field. After class tomorrow.”</p><p>Ron weighed only 69 pounds — easily the smallest boy in his class back at Wadsworth Elementary. And this bigger kid was… much larger. Ron let out a nervous laugh and lifted his upturned hands. “What are you talking about? I don’t even know him.” Ron looked at the bigger kid for support. And the bigger kid, we’ll call him the Dancing Bear, was smiling. He had braces. Ron looked around the room and noticed that everybody was staring at him. There wasn’t an adult in sight.</p><p>Oh, great, Ron thought. This is just great.</p><p>The doors to the basketball courts opened and they all filed into practice.</p><h4>Training</h4><p>Ron’s family lived in a tri-level house with pail green aluminum siding on the two-story portion, and red brick on the ranch level. Geraniums lined the brick wall leading to the front door. A visitor to the house would be greeted by an entryway lined in gold wallpaper overlapped by a fuzzy burgundy design. The carpeting was olive green. The couch and loveseat were covered in plastic. The victorian end tables had thick marble tops. There was a grandfather clog, with a gold pendulum, that had to wound with a key. A portrait of Jesus hung above the stairwell that led to the upstairs bedrooms. Beyond the living room was the adjacent dining room and the kitchen, smelling of chorizo and coffee and fresh tortillas, with a screen door leading to the back yard, and a stairway leading to the basement. The basement had cold tile floors, wood paneling, the hardest couch ever made, a black and white TV, and a desk where their father did the taxes.</p><p>Over the years the living room’s gaudy colors would fade into the interior decorating version of mayonnaise, but in 1974, you could still tell that Mexicans lived there.</p><p>The screen door slammed as Ron entered the kitchen. The smell of chicken with mole tickled the air. Whole pinto beans were boiling on the stove.</p><p>“How was practice?” His mom looked at him while her hands busied themselves at the stove. Ron tried to explain to her what had happened at the gym. His head was spinning so fast from panic that he didn’t hear exactly what his mom said, but it was something to the effect of, “They’re just trying to scare you.”</p><p>Jesse, who was also in the room, disagreed.</p><p>Since this was a good Mexican household, they were not unfamiliar with the sport of boxing, with fights playing on ABC’s Wide World of Sports when available. This included, most recently, the January fight between Muhammed Ali and Joe Frazier at Madison Square Garden, with the inimitable commentating of Howard Cosell. Ron had mentioned the Muhammed Ali fight to a classmate who immediately said how much he hated Ali. Ron accepted this as another cultural peculiarity of where they lived — like the fact that he watched Sesame Street while everybody else watched Captain Kangaroo — so he never mentioned Muhammed Ali in mixed company again.</p><p>Jesse led Ron to the cold dark basement where he tried to teach him how to fight. If this were a film, this is where the training montage would come in. The training montage was popularized by the Rocky movies. An otherwise boring collection of video clips, showing Sylvester Stallone running in the dim morning light, is overlapped by a punchy 70’s soundtrack to create a story within a story. A tale of overcoming obstacles and finding oneself through adversity and dedication, leading up to the big fight. Generations of people would turn to these montages for inspiration at times like this; imagining that their struggles were part of a greater story, punctuated by a crescendo of music. Unfortunately, Ron did not have this inspiration to draw from. The first Rocky movie wouldn’t be released until two years later. Instead, Ron had thoughts of Muhammed Ali taunting his opponents and fighting against Ken Norton with a broken jaw.</p><p>Jesse demonstrated how to stand feet shoulder’s width apart. How to keep on your toes. How to keep your hands up and in front of you to protect your face and body. “Never let your hands down. Your arms will get tired, but keep them up anyway.” He showed Ron how to jab: to keep your wrist straight and your punches quick and sharp. He punctuated his demonstration with sound effects, like a leather glove hitting a punching bag. <em>Tsch. Tsch-tsch. Tsch-tsch-tsch.</em> He also showed him the hook and the uppercut, and taught him to vary his punch selection so the other guy wouldn’t know what to expect. Jesse danced around the cold basement floor, and Ron followed. Sort of.</p><p>In the end, Ron was okay imitating his brother so long as he didn’t think about why they were doing this. So long as he didn’t think about what would happen when there was an actual person, a very large person, standing in front of him. Ron’s foot coordination left a lot to be desired, so there probably wouldn’t be any “floating like a butterfly,” but maybe he could still “sting like a bee.”</p><p>“One more thing,” Jesse said. “You need to set rules.”</p><p>“Rules?”</p><p>“Rules. No biting. No kicking. No scratching. No weapons. This is a fist fight. And once there’s blood, the fight is over.”</p><p>“Once there’s blood, the fight is over,” Ron repeated.</p><p>“Once there’s blood, the fight is over,” Jesse confirmed.</p><p>That night Ron stared at the ceiling of their second story bedroom, his heart beating like a hummingbird’s wings.</p><p>“Once there’s blood…” “Once there’s blood…”</p><p>He replayed, over and over in his head, that morning’s encounter in the gym lobby. Shithead’s beady eyes. Dancing Bear’s smile. The whole room staring at him. It’s funny how, the moment he saw Shithead’s beady eyes he completely forgot about his itchy crotch. Like the itching wasn’t real — it was just a distraction from, or more likely a symptom of, the hell-scape around him. He replayed the moment, trying to figure out if there was anything he could have done differently. Anything he could have said to avoid this.</p><h4>Fight Day</h4><p>The next day, it was difficult to focus on the two handed pass knowing what was coming. But as practice went on, and nobody said anything, Ron began to believe that maybe his mother was right. Maybe they were just trying to scare him. The thought of a reprieve filled him with exhilaration as he got in line for layups. As the final whistle blew, and class was dismissed, Ron let out a sigh of relief. But his smile quickly disappeared as Shithead and the Dancing Bear came up alongside him.</p><p>“Let’s go,” Shithead said. And they filed out the door.</p><p>Ron’s stomach felt queasy but he settled himself down as he tried to remember what his brother had taught him. As they walked across the parking lot to the football field, Ron recited the rules, ending with the final rule, “once there’s blood, the fight is over.” Shithead repeated each rule and agreed. The Dancing Bear didn’t seem to be listening.</p><p>Ron hung his glasses on the chain link fence. The sky in Griffith had a flat washed out appearance. This may have been due to the mist off Lake Michigan, or the haze that drifted over from the steel mills some 15 miles north. The gravel track that ran around the football field was dry and dusty. The white yard lines were faded. He could tell that the grass had become overgrown behind the bleachers because he could hear the wind hiss through its long blades. Surprisingly, there were no spectators. Everybody else seemed to have headed home.</p><p>At first, nobody did anything. Ron stood there with his arms raised, just as he had been taught, and the Dancing Bear stood there with his hands down and wearing a smirk on his face. Finally, somebody threw a punch. Ron couldn’t remember who threw the first punch. It may have been Dancing Bear, since all Ron wanted to do was go home. Or it may have been Ron himself, throwing a punch as a way of practicing what he had learned, or perhaps in an effort to get this thing over with. Important details like this, details that would shape the narrative and set in motion the legend one would create around himself, can be easily missed in the adrenaline rushed fury of the moment. And Ron was too honest and particular to simply manufacture a story for the sake of self aggrandizement. (Many years later, while working as an attorney, Ron would sympathize with those who had trouble recalling exactly how a tragic event unfolded.) One thing Ron did remember for certain was that his own first punch was a right jab that glanced off the Dancing Bear’s mouth. A little off target, but it connected.</p><p>The Dancing Bear appeared flustered, like he wasn’t expecting to get hit. Ron threw another jab. And another. The Dancing Bear’s mouth gaped open as he started to back up. The Dancing Bear must have thrown a couple of punches but Ron was too focused to notice. Quick jabs. Arms up. Quick jabs. Arms up. Ron didn’t know how many punches he had thrown, but at some point the Dancing Bear tripped and fell backwards.</p><p>Still focused, Ron sat on top of Dancing Bear and kept punching at his face.</p><p>At some point Ron heard Shithead’s voice. The same scratchy voice he had heard in the lobby the previous day. Shrill and distant.</p><p>“There’s blood! There’s blood! The fight’s over! The fight’s over!”</p><p>Suddenly, as if awakening from a dream, Ron looked down. The Dancing Bear was crying. Blood was running from his nose and his mouth. Ron’s knuckles were cut up, probably from the Dancing Bear’s braces. Shithead was jumping up and down but he kept his distance.</p><p>Ron jumped up, raised his palms in the air, and started chanting. “The fight’s over! The fights over! The fight’s over!”</p><p>A little boy, maybe three years old, charged up to Ron. The boy was crying. He yelled, “You beat up my brother!” and tried to kick Ron in the shin, but he was too scared to get that close. The little boy threw a frantic little foot at Ron then ran away.</p><p>Meanwhile, the Dancing Bear got up, lurched towards the chain link fence, and grabbed Ron’s glasses. At that instant, Ron burst into tears.</p><p>It’s important to note that Ron had gotten his first pair of glasses only a few months earlier. Without them he was blind. He didn’t know he was blind before he got his glasses, but once he had them he realized he couldn’t be without them. Second, Ron had never been in a fight before and he had not had time to process the emotions that it created: the building anxiety leading up to the fight; the utter terror of the fight itself; the unexpected exhilaration he felt as the bully kept backing up; the shocking realization that the Dancing Bear had brought his little brother to watch; and now the potential loss of Ron’s eyesight. But, beyond all of this, the thing that finally broke Ron was the injustice and the powerlessness one feels when trying to defend himself in a world that has no honor. People who seek revenge for actions that they themselves brought about. And living in a dominant culture that will not defend you. That will not take your side. How can you survive an ordeal and still lose?</p><p>Then, seemingly out of nowhere, Jesse stepped forward.</p><p>“Give me the glasses.”</p><p>The Dancing Bear froze. Jesse had one hand outstretched to receive the glasses. His other hand held a chocolate malt. Next to Ron’s brother, the Dancing Bear did not seem so big. Three years, at that age, is like a generation.</p><p>The Dancing Bear handed the glasses to Jesse and Jesse handed the glasses to Ron.</p><p>“Go home. I’ll take care of this,” Jesse said as he pulled some restaurant napkins out of his pocket.</p><p>Ron grabbed his purple bike and wheeled it across the parking lot while Jesse prepared to mop the blood off the Dancing Bear’s face.</p><p>A long-haired pothead-type teenager who happened to be hanging out in the parking lot called out to Ron.</p><p>“Who won?!”</p><p>The question caught Ron by surprise. He had been so busy trying to survive the ordeal that the question of winning and losing hadn’t even occurred to him. He perked up.</p><p>“I did!”</p><p>The pothead lifted a fist. “Hey, way to go, man!”</p><p>Ron rode out of the parking lot, replaying the incident over and over in his head, and practicing how he would retell the story. Fifteen minutes later he was still dizzy from the adrenaline when he coasted up the driveway and walked through the back screen door.</p><p>“I won!”</p><h4>Bats</h4><p>“That is the worst thing I ever heard.”</p><p>It was nighttime. Ron’s friend Mary was bobbing up and down in her swimming pool with a pool skimmer held high above her head. Bats would sometimes swoop down above the pool at night, probably trying to catch the insects that were attracted to the shimmery water, and Mary made a sport out of trying to swat them. Ron was bobbing at the other side of the pool. The sky was an uncharacteristically clear. The stars were unimpeded by smog or clouds.</p><p>There were plenty of above ground pools in town, big round steel drums edged by brown rust, but hers was the only pool he knew of that was in-ground. Not that he had been in very many back yards, but this underground pool with the little lights along the wall made him think that she was probably rich, though he had no real frame of reference from which to judge any of this.</p><p>“Seriously?” She continued. “Your parents told you that there are no winners in a fight?”</p><p>“Yeah.” Ron could taste something salty and discontent oozying in his mouth. He dipped his raw scratched up hands in and out of the water. The chlorine made the knuckles sting, and the sting reminded him that he had overcome something. “I don’t remember exactly what they said. There are no winners in a fight. Nothing good ever comes from violence. Violence only gets you more violence. Something like that.”</p><p>“That’s bullshit.”</p><p>Speaking in cartoon metaphors, if Ron was Charlie Brown, sort of mopey and unsure; Mary was Lucy Van Pelt — very certain, and always a little bit outraged about something. He envied her assuredness. How does someone even become like that?</p><p>“Do you really think you didn’t win that fight?” She asked.</p><p>“I don’t know. I mean, I didn’t get beat up, so that’s something.”</p><p>Mary lowered her skimmer and stared at Ron for a long time.</p><p>Residents of Griffith, Indiana were treated to summer evening concerts of chirping. Constant. Incessant. Chirping. Were they crickets? Grasshoppers? Katydids? Locusts? He had no idea. All he knew is that the sound was so loud and so ubiquitous that you didn’t even really notice it, until you did. Many years later the word “crickets” would come to mean silence in response to something ridiculous. This is what Ron was experiencing at that very moment, literally and figuratively, as Mary stared him down. Finally, she let out a sigh.</p><p>“How are your hands?”</p><p>“Okay.”</p><p>“Anything else?”</p><p>“My mouth a little.”</p><p>“You never been in a fight before?”</p><p>“No. Unless you count my brother.”</p><p>“That doesn’t count. Kind of surprising considering.”</p><p>The subtext being: considering everybody here is white and you’re not.</p><p>“Oh, and there was that kid who hit me in the head with a rock a couple of years ago, but that wasn’t really a fight. I just ran home. The next day I had a black eye.”</p><p>“And what did your parents do about that?”</p><p>“What could they do? It’s not like I knew the kid who hit me.”</p><p>Ron could feel Mary seething. He dunked his head and the sound of the crickets disappeared, replaced by the wallowing echo of his own head trapped in the water. He looked around at the pool lights. Mary was wearing a one piece. Ron wore a t-shirt because he was embarrassed about his dark nipples, so much darker than everybody else’s. The water was still cold despite being beaten by the sun all day. He waved his arms around to see how long he could stay under water. When he popped up, gasping for air, Mary was still staring. Still staring at the spot where he had been bobbing.</p><p>“You won that fight, Ron.”</p><p>Ron caught his breath. “Thank you.”</p><p>“I mean it. You won. You should be proud of that.”</p><h4>An Uncomfortable Realization</h4><p>Winning the fight, if you can call it winning, was completely anticlimactic for Ron, and did not provide any emotional payoff. No dancing around the ring with your hands raised in the air. No standing on the ropes to receive the adoration of cheering fans. Just a pothead asking who won and a parent waxing philosophical about violence.</p><p>There was a part of him that wished that he had gotten injured. Not badly, mind you. But enough so that people would feel sorry for him and take seriously the ordeal he had gone through. Enough so that people would notice him.</p><p>Ron had not processed, and barely even acknowledged that, at one point, he was sitting on top of Dancing Bear and repeatedly punching him in the face. SITTING ON TOP of a kid and PUNCHING him repeatedly IN THE FACE. How was that not a bigger deal?! Shouldn’t he have gone through some sort of existential crises? Why was this okay? On the other hand, if Dancing Bear had beaten Ron up, Dancing Bear would not be upset. Dancing Bear would not be questing the meaning of life. Dancing Bear would probably be bragging about it and retelling the story in a way that made him look heroic.</p><p>The problem with being liberal minded is that you see everything from the other person’s perspective, regardless of whether it’s the right perspective. It’s not a conscious thing so much as it is just the way you engage with the world. In this case, Dancing Bear was just a tool. As for Shithead: instead of feeling a sense of righteousness, Ron, and probably his parents, realized that Shithead was probably responding to his own tragic circumstances. Shithead may have been a victim of bullying or abuse himself, thus relieving himself of victimization by reversing roles, by assuming an aggressive posture. Or he may have lacked any kind of autonomy or control in his home life, and coercing strangers to fight may have given him a feeling of power. Or maybe Shithead had a compulsion to create drama around himself to drown out some kind of emptiness he felt inside, perhaps due to neglect. Any of these could have been his origin story.</p><p>You see. That’s the problem with being empathic. You’re so busy living in the skin of your adversary that you neglect to recognize your own victimization. You’re understanding of others cancels out your own lived experience.</p><p>What bothered Ron most about the whole incident was that Shithead chose to pit a big white kid against a small brown kid. Why would somebody do that? Were Shithead and Dancing Bear friends? Ron didn’t know. But this lopsided contest appeared to be designed for a predetermined outcome. The goal was not to see two people fight. The goal was to see the little brown kid get beat up.</p><p>It was not meant to be a contest. It was meant to be a lynching.</p><p>On some level 11-year-old Ron knew that. But it would be years before he could put it into words.</p><h4>The Post Fight Interview</h4><p>Ron would remagine that day in a million different ways. Usually to the soundtrack of the first movement of Beethoven’s Fifth Symphony, or Copeland’s Fanfare for the Common Man; his fists striking in unison with the timpani. He would dance around the cold basement floor, then pretend to have a post fight interview with Howard Cosell.</p><p>Howard Cosell: Ro-nald Ro-driguez. Good to see ya Champ!</p><p>Ron: How-ard Co-sell. The world’s greatest newscaster.</p><p>Howard Cosell: You’re very kind, Champ. So how did you feel out there?</p><p>Ron: I felt great, Howard. I felt great.</p><p>Howard Cosell: So did you worry…</p><p>Ron: Worry?</p><p>Howard Cosell: Did you worry that the Dancing Bear’s size would counteract your natural fighting ability?</p><p>Ron: Well, if the Dancing Bear dreamed it, he would have to apologize.</p><p>Howard Cosell: You are absolutely brilliant, Champ.</p><p>And his imagination would wander into blurred scenarios of camera flashes and lively banter and cheering fans. Lots of cheering.</p><h4>Bats and Crickets</h4><p>The following week Ron’s mother went to talk to the the basketball coach who, as it turns out, was an old classmate of hers from East Chicago. Two weeks later, at the end of the clinic, the coach awarded Ron a basketball for trying the hardest.</p><p>(Decades later, when asked what she remembered about the incident, Ron’s mom would express pride at Ron defending himself, seemingly forgetting any comments about nobody winning in a fight.)</p><p>As far as Ron knew, there were no other repercussions from the incident. They never heard from the Dancing Bear’s parents, and Ron never saw the Dancing Bear again. Ron and Shithead both finished out the clinic, but after that, Ron would not see those beady eyes again until years later when they crossed paths at the feeder schools: junior high school and then high school. But even then, they never spoke to each other about the incident, or about anything else. It was as if they had never met. It was as if it had never happened. But it had happened. And Ron never forgot.</p><p>The thing about crickets is that you can hear them, seemingly everywhere, but you can’t see them. They are simultaneously everywhere and nowhere. As for bats, you never see a bat coming. By the time you see a bat they are already out of sight. Thus is the nature of hatred. Thus is the invisible yet omnipresent sound of bigotry.</p><p>Your arms get tired from holding them up all the time, but sometimes you have no choice but to be vigilant. And if you try to see the world through the tear-filled eyes of another, don’t be surprised if what you see is your own face. Your own face staring down. Your vision interrupted by a cadence of little brown fists. The pale blue Indiana sky drifting in the background.</p><p><em>Note to readers: This story is written in the third person, but it is autobiographical. Aside from some artistic details, the story is true.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=fafecb06718e" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/letters-to-a-young-cynic/heroism-denied-a-mexican-american-boy-in-1970s-indiana-fafecb06718e">Heroism Denied: A Mexican-American Boy in 1970s Indiana</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/letters-to-a-young-cynic">Letters to a Young Cynic</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Love Is Blind: Adventures in Neurodivergence]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/letters-to-a-young-cynic/love-is-blind-adventures-in-neurodivergence-3784fefa41e6?source=rss-14e38d873f99------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/3784fefa41e6</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[love]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[neurodivergent]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[romance]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[domestic-violence]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[retail]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ronald D. Rodriguez]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 19 Nov 2024 02:15:37 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-11-19T02:15:37.308Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Where’s a glass slipper when you need one?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*7In-UcarmfDGvnkURP8HGA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Not a real person. But close.</figcaption></figure><h4>A memoir in the third person.</h4><p>There was a young Hispanic male in his twenties who worked as a bank teller on the ground floor of a shopping mall in West Los Angeles around 1987, 1988. He had all the hard skills. Neat. Efficient. Good with numbers. Good finger dexterity. If you gave him a stack of ones he could tell you, just by feel, if the stack was an even 25. He was also, by far, the quickest teller on the line. This was likely because, unbeknownst to anyone, he had, by sheer repetition, memorized the account numbers of all of the regular customers, allowing him to start the transaction as they were walking in the door. His name was Ron, and nobody understood how he could possibly work so quickly.</p><p>The regular checking and savings account windows, where Ron worked, were up front while the merchant windows were at the back of the bank. Since they were located in a shopping mall, this branch had more than its fair share of merchant accounts. Ron had no direct dealings with these vendors, but he would smile and wave as they walked by with their blue vinyl deposit bags, and they would smile and wave back.</p><p>Although Ron could recognize customers within the context of the bank, he was otherwise incapacitated when it came to remembering names and faces. Out of context, he would walk right past friends and coworkers without a clue. Likewise, he would mistake complete strangers for people he knew. Consequently, he was always on the alert; waiting for a tell-tale smile or a wave from anyone he passed. This made dating extremely difficult. For Ron, almost every date was a blind date.</p><p>Fortunately, those who are handicapped are often blessed with a compensatory skill. In Ron’s case, this saving grace came in the form of an empathic ability to feel people rather than see them. His ability to mirror people when they were happy, and deescalate when they were upset, combined with his hard skills, made Ron hugely popular. Customers would wait in line for him rather than go to the next open teller window.</p><p>This particular mall, the Westside Pavilion, located on the corner of Pico and Overland, had a whimsical, circus-like exterior, with brightly colored geometric shapes surrounding the entrance. This exterior contrasted with the refined minimalist interior. Three floors running in a straight line, with escalators and white pillars symmetrically spaced on either side. Silver railings. Beige tile flooring. And a glass dome roof that ran along the full length of the mall. The only interior element of the mall that echoed the circus-like exterior was the smell of movie theater popcorn that wafted from the cinemas on the third floor.</p><p>Despite it’s distinct characteristics, the Westside Pavilion was just like a thousand other shopping malls in the country. For the people who work in them, shopping malls are worlds unto themselves. Discrete neighborhoods where you see the same people, most of them in their teens and twenties, every day, day after day. Walking the tiled hallways and standing on the escalators. Sitting in the food court or on shopping mall benches. Folding shirts and shelving books and setting up window displays. Catering to people with money or credit to burn. Selling things that they couldn’t afford themselves. It was like an enclosed adolescent capitalist dystopia. The electric energy of youth trapped in a world of shiny surfaces, plastic trees, recirculated air, and homogenized music. And at the end of their shifts, as these young people push open the swinging glass doors leading to the outside world, the cool night air hits their faces and they realize that they’ve lost another day of their young lives, at minimum wage. Another day that they will never get back again.</p><p>The one thing Ron rarely did was go outside during his shift. When he did go outside it was never to walk out onto the street. The street was too untethered. Too lawless. Instead, he would take the escalators up to the third floor exit leading to the rooftop parking lot, take a deep smoggy Los Angeles breath, and peer through the water-spotted glass roof. From this angle the mall reminded him of a snow globe or a doll’s house, except without the joy. He would imagine himself walking from shop to shop, greeting the other mall workers. Pretending he recognized them.</p><h4>The Girlfriend.</h4><p>The teller job paid eight dollars an hour. An impossibly small sum to live on. But Ron was a frugal and meticulous bookkeeper. Every morning he printed out his bank statement and used a highlighter to color-code the entries. He didn’t own a credit card. He contributed $300 for rent in an apartment he shared with his brother and his brother’s wife. He took the Blue Bus to work so there were no car expenses. He rarely ate out. He splurged on a fancy Japanese hair stylist on the third floor of the mall. Otherwise, he had very few expenses and, really, no life outside of his job to speak of.</p><p>A year earlier, Ron had broken up with a young woman who worked in a gift shop on the second floor. The shop she worked in had delicate hand blown glass animals in the storefront window, fancy wooden music boxes, and snow globes. They met through a former coworker of his and Ron immediately took a liking to her, in large part because she was easily recognizable. The billow of her Aqua-Netted hair. The way she walked, like a penguin, side to side. Her dimples. One day they bumped into each other in the food court and talked over a soda. Later that same afternoon she appeared at the glass doors of the bank, waving. Ron went out to meet her and she sidled up to him as if they were dating. Which, as of that moment, they were.</p><p>The worst kind of breakup is a unilateral one. Ron saw that they were too different for this to last. He was unhappy, and he could tell she was unhappy. But when he tried to break up with her, she went hysterical. The voracity of it shocked him, and hearing her wail was the greatest pain he had ever experienced. Ever. He didn’t understand why she wanted this so bad. After agreeing to stay with her, he concluded that the only way he could break up with her was to make her hate him. And, in hating him, he thought, maybe she would choose herself. Maybe she could get over him and move on. So the second time he broke up with her he said terrible hurtful things. And she cried and cried and cried. But this time he stood his ground.</p><p>Unless you’re a sociopath, your self-esteem is affected by the opinions of others. How others see you influences how you see yourself, and how you see yourself influences how you think others perceive you. It’s like two mirrors facing each other. You think you’re worthless, which causes you to think others think you’re worthless, which causes you to think you’re even more worthless and so on. As much as we would like to believe it, our identities are not an objective reflection of who we are.</p><p>The road to hell is paved with good intentions. For months Ron was haunted by the thought of what he had done. In making her hate him, did he only succeed in making her hate herself? And what does that say about him?</p><p>He was terrified that he might randomly bump into the Gift Shop Girl and would be forced to see his reflection through her eyes. He was also taunted by the notion that everybody was judging him for what he had done. So for months he would walk straight from the bus stop to the bank and back, eyes cast down, avoiding at all costs the tiled hallways and the escalators and the food court. Occasionally he would imagine catching a glimpse of the Gift Shop Girl from the corner of his eye and it would send him running.</p><p>One day, an employee from a store a couple of doors down from the Gift Shop Girl’s, a former mutual friend, approached Ron’s teller window and, mercifully, told him that the Gift Shop Girl had quit her job. That she wasn’t in the mall anymore. “I thought you should know.” Ron caught a hint of judgment in her eyes and in her voice. He didn’t think he was imagining it. And he didn’t think she was wrong.</p><h4>Something Underneath Her Heartbeat</h4><p>Eventually, after weeks of hesitation, Ron started wandering the mall again. Up and down the tiled halls, and the escalators, and the rooftop parking.</p><p>One day, rather than eat lunch, Ron decided to walk up to the other end of the mall: Past the Waldenbooks employees shelving books; the Old Navy employees folding shirts; and the arcade where he could distinguish, through the noisy cacophony, the sounds of PacMan and Donkey Kong and Centipede. For better or worse this was his domain. His neighborhood. He knew where all the stores were. What they sold and how much they marked up the prices. He knew which ones were chains and which ones were privately owned. Which had happy workers and which ones had high employee turnover. His job at the bank was a job, not a career. Nothing to brag about. But the mall felt familiar and he had fallen into a comfortable routine.</p><p>Towards the other end of the mall he came across a wooden bench outside the Victoria’s Secret. And on that bench sat a conventionally beautiful young woman wearing a floral skirt and a long-sleeved blouse. He thought he recognized her as one of the vendors who would occasionally walk past his teller window, which meant she was either a supervisor or an assistant manager. He could picture her waving back at him as she breezed past. She looked up and her eyes said that she knew him.</p><p>“Hey,” he said.</p><p>“Hi!” she chirped.</p><p>“How’s it going?” Ron asked the question as a pleasantry. A midwestern custom. Not really expecting an answer. After all, it wasn’t like they knew each other.</p><p>“Okay,” she said.</p><p>Flash forward 20 years. Ron would have a stepdaughter named Alex. Alex was six years old when, during a routine checkup, her pediatrician heard in her stethoscope a “flutter underneath her heartbeat.” The pediatrician consequently sent Alex to cardiology who, in turn, admitted Alex for a three-week stay to manage a heart condition. Sometimes, all it takes is an attentive ear.</p><p>The Victoria’s Secret Supervisor said, “okay.” But something about the “okay” was not right. Her “Hi,” with its chipper tone, had been a habit. The sort of habit one develops when working in retail. Her “okay,” on the other hand, was introspective and unguarded. It betrayed a certain defeated exhaustion. More importantly, he could hear a barely perceptible nervous quiver fluttering beneath the surface of her exhaustion. He recognized the quiver as . . .</p><p>Fear.</p><p>Ron, who was still walking, albeit at a much slower pace, stopped and turned his full attention to the woman on the bench.</p><p>“Are you alright?”</p><p>“Huh?” Her eyebrows arched up. Her posture, knees together, hands clasped on her lap, shoulders slightly hunched, signaled worry. “Yeah, no. I’m fine.”</p><p>There was that quiver again. She was scared of something. Ron squared up.</p><p>“You seem deep in thought. What’s going on?”</p><p>“Nothing. Really.”</p><p>“No, come on. Talk to me.”</p><p>He didn’t really know her, aside from the occasional wave as she walked to the back of the bank. In fact, this was the first time they’d ever spoken to each other. Asking her to explain herself was presumptuous at best.</p><p>“I’m just,” she bit her lip. “I’m just trying to figure something out.”</p><p>“What’s that?”</p><p>Her eyes searched him hesitantly.</p><p>“I’m trying to move out of my apartment.”</p><p>He waited a beat. “Why are you trying to move?”</p><p>“Well. I’m living with this guy and.”</p><p>She stopped abruptly. The tension in the air told him that this was not a mutual breakup. The fear in her voice told him that she was trapped.</p><p>They stood there for what seemed like a minute. Finally, Ron whispered.</p><p>“It’s bad, huh?”</p><p>She did not respond. Her silence spoke for itself.</p><p>A muffled rush of blood coursed through Ron’s ears as the gravity of the situation settled in. Dust particles floated in a beam of sunlight that descended from the glass ceiling. The sights and sounds of the mall faded into a watery blur as Ron stood there in his tasseled loafers, staring at this slender young woman, her anxious fingers interlaced on her lap. It was as if a snow globe had formed around them.</p><p>“So,” he asked, “what is it that’s holding you back?”</p><p>She gathered herself. They both spoke in whispers now. “Well, I have the apartment picked out, and I’ve spoken with the landlord.” She glanced around. “And she says she’s holding it for me until the end of the month. But they require first and last month’s rent and I don’t have enough.” She paused, looked back down. “And the end of the month is Friday.”</p><p>“So that’s the day after tomorrow.” And if she missed this window, he thought, it would be another month, maybe more, before she could try again. Why was she alone in this? Did she not have family?</p><p>What could happen in thirty days?</p><p>“How much do you need?” He asked.</p><p>“Three hundred dollars.”</p><p>“So, if you had three hundred dollars the landlord would let you move in?”</p><p>“Yes.”</p><p>He looked at her slender arms. The blouse she wore had long sleeves. He wondered if there were bruises.</p><p>“So, if you had three hundred dollars. You would move.”</p><p>“Yes.”</p><p>“So, if I gave you three hundred dollars, right now, you would move.”</p><p>He said it more as a challenge than a question. It took her a second to process what he was saying. She made eye contact with him.</p><p>“What?”</p><p>“If I gave you three hundred dollars, right now, would you move?”</p><p>She squirmed. “No. I didn’t mean…”</p><p>Ron took a step closer. He was no longer whispering. His voice became earnest.</p><p>“If I gave you three hundred dollars. Right Now. WOULD? YOU? MOVE?”</p><p>He held her gaze. High above them there was a flapping sound. A bird had wandered into the mall and was fluttering along the glass ceiling three stories up.</p><p>Finally, in a voice barely audible, she said:</p><p>“Yes.”</p><p>Ron let out a deep relieved sigh.</p><p>“Okay. I’m going to walk back up to the bank. I’m going to withdraw three hundred dollars — cash. Then I’m going to walk back over here. Don’t <em>go</em> anywhere.”</p><p>She blushed. “Okay.”</p><p>As he backed away he could see her eyes turning inwards. Figuring out next steps.</p><p>Any vender on the second floor who happened to be glancing down would have seen Ron sprint up the mall in his tasseled loafers. Past the clothing stores and the arcade and the bookstore, all the way to the bank at the other end. A moment later, they would have seen him rushing back with cash in hand.</p><p>The Supervisor was still blushing. He couldn’t see it, but he could sense her goosebumps. A cool breeze wafted off of her as he approached. It smelled like citrus and lavender.</p><p>“Here,” he said, handing her the bills and bending over to catch his breath. “Don’t worry about paying me back now. Just do what you have to do. We can figure the rest out later”</p><p>They hugged. She thanked him.</p><p>“My name’s Ron, by the way.”</p><p>She said her name, but he wasn’t used to remembering names because he never remembered faces anyway. Suddenly embarrassed, he quickly turned and jogged back to work. He didn’t look back.</p><p>And he never saw her again.</p><h4>The Next Day.</h4><p>He mentioned what happened to his assistant manager, Pierre, at the bank. Pierre was a slightly balding French Canadian who loved blues music and kept a tin of pot underneath his couch back at his apartment. In a bank full of women, he was the only other guy.</p><p>“Oh man, you are an <em>idiot</em>!” Pierre shook his head laughing, then he grabbed Ron’s arm. “Are you serious?” Ron shrugged. “Oh man! You’re <em>never</em> going to see that money again! You know that, right?”</p><p>Ron shrugged again. Pierre moved in conspiratorially.</p><p>“Which one is she?”</p><p>Ron tried to describe her.</p><p>“Yeaaaaah.” Pierre nodded. “I know the one. Brunette, right?”</p><p>Ron nodded, although he wasn’t really sure.</p><p>“So… did you think she would let you bang her? Is that why you did it?”</p><p>“No, I just. You know. I don’t know.”</p><p>Pierre shook his head. “I don’t mean to say you got taken, but, youuuuu got taken.” Pierre laughed and walked away.</p><h4>The District Manager?</h4><p>An older woman with a titular bearing and carrying a leather portfolio marched up to Ron’s window. Ron recognized the portfolio as a Coach, but he did not recognize her. She stood in front of him for what seemed like an eternity. Silent. Making intense eye contact. Sizing him up before finally saying, “That was a really nice thing you did.”</p><p>She assumed she was speaking to the right person and that he would know what she was talking about. Ron speculated that she was a higher up at Victoria’s Secret. Perhaps a district manager. It didn’t seem like she was there for small talk.</p><p>“Is she okay?”</p><p>The woman nodded. “Just so you know, she did move. And the store immediately transferred her to our Century City location.” The mall in Century City was outdoors and more upscale, with high end shops, valet parking, and plenty of security. It was located three bus routes away from Ron’s apartment.</p><p>That simple phrase, “And the store immediately transferred her…” told Ron everything he needed to know. His instinct was correct. The woman on the bench did sneak away. And the company was helping to hide her. The fact that they transferred her “immediately” meant that the district management had been aware of her situation and was prepared to act. They were all in on the plan. All that was needed was a benefactor.</p><p>“Thank you for letting me know.”</p><p>“No. Thank you.”</p><p>And she quickly marched away, evidently satisfied to have checked this errand off her list.</p><p>The conversation, if you could call it a conversation, was cloaked in shadows. Addressing Ron’s altruism without identifying it. Referring to the Supervisor without speaking her name.</p><p>If “this guy” was as bad as all that, he would eventually track her down, he thought. But for now she was safe. And hopefully her successful escape would embolden her if anything went bad.</p><h4>The Envelopes.</h4><p>About a month passed. Ron got back into the rhythm of his day. Bus-bank-bus-home, bus-bank-bus-home. Hardly a day went by when he didn’t think about the woman on the bench, but he no longer obsessed about it and had pretty much forgotten about the money altogether.</p><p>One day, about a month after the day he gave her the money, a petite blonde young girl in a flouncy skirt, probably eighteen or nineteen years old, made a bouncy beeline to Ron’s teller window.</p><p>“Are you Ron?”</p><p>“Yes.”</p><p>She dropped an unmarked legal size envelope on Ron’s counter and skipped away, giggling. She smiled back at him as she exited the bank.</p><p>The envelope was sealed. Ron swiped a letter opener under the flap and pulled out a crisp new fifty dollar bill. There was no note.</p><p>Each month for five straight months a different young girl would show up at his teller window. (Or, at least, he thought they were different girls.) Each girl would drop a legal sized envelope on Ron’s counter and run away, giggling. Ron assumed they were all employees from the Century City location. Each envelope had a fifty dollar bill in it. After the third one, Ron mentioned it to Pierre.</p><p>“No way?” Pierre’s eyes went wide with surprise. Ron shrugged. “Man, that’s really… wow, that’s great.” He gave Ron a slap on the shoulder and leaned in. “So, maybe you do have a chance with her?”</p><p>Altogether, Ron received two hundred and fifty dollars, just shy of the three hundred he gave her. More likely than not, the last girl pocketed the fifty dollar bill rather than deliver it to him. Ron was fine with that.</p><p>There are those who might claim that Ron did this act of benevolence as a form of redemption for a bad breakup. And there are those, like Pierre, who assume that Ron did this as a way to get into this woman’s pants. There is no question that Ron felt guilty for what happened with the Gift Shop Girl. And there is no doubt that Ron dreamed of the woman on the bench and imagined becoming her soul mate as well as her savior. But, ultimately, Ron didn’t give her the money because of what he thought he could get out of it. He did it because he felt it was the right thing to do. And he never visited her at that other mall because he didn’t want her to think that she owed him. And so the whole incident got tucked into a metaphorical music box, closed, and forgotten. It would be another twenty-five years or more before Ron would ever open that box again. But the reflection he saw in the mirror hidden under the lid was no longer of a young man. The music, however, was just as sweet.</p><p>A couple of months after receiving her fifth payment, Ron looked up from his teller window and felt regret for having spent two whole years counting other people’s money for a living instead of doing something meaningful. That very same day Ron borrowed his manager’s typewriter and turned in his two-week notice. On the bus ride home, instead of staring out the window, Ron glanced around at the other passengers and thought about the Supervisor on the bench. He imagined her walking into her new apartment, setting her houseplant down on the kitchen counter, and wandering into her new bedroom which still smelled of fresh paint. He imagined her sliding open the bedroom window. The breeze through the screen. The carpeting beneath her toes. And all this empty apartment space waiting to be filled.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=3784fefa41e6" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/letters-to-a-young-cynic/love-is-blind-adventures-in-neurodivergence-3784fefa41e6">Love Is Blind: Adventures in Neurodivergence</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/letters-to-a-young-cynic">Letters to a Young Cynic</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Scenes from a Club — Mike Tyson, Milli Vanilli, and the LAPD]]></title>
            <link>https://ronman63.medium.com/scenes-from-a-club-mike-tyson-milli-vanilli-and-the-lapd-858fbc64ae4c?source=rss-14e38d873f99------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/858fbc64ae4c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[boxing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[los-angeles]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mike-tyson]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[aging]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[hip-hop]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ronald D. Rodriguez]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 17 Nov 2024 20:56:44 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-11-19T00:49:37.003Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>The Gospel According to Mike Tyson</h3><h3>Mike Tyson, Milli Vanilli, the LAPD. At the crossroads in 1990.</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*DVKvlo5F3faoOc_nkM2nKw.jpeg" /></figure><p>It’s November 15, 2024. I just finished watching the bout between 58-year-old Mike Tyson and 27-year-old Jake Paul. And now I’m sitting up in bed, the remote still in my hand, thinking about my mortality and about the time I crossed paths with Mike Tyson in a club in West Hollywood on Martin Luther King Day in 1990.</p><p>I had a friend, we’ll call him Deshawn. At the time we were both working swing shifts in the dormitory of a residential school for severely multi-handicapped children. Microcephaly. Seizure disorders. Tourette’s Syndrome. Blindness. Hearing loss. Down’s Syndrome. Fetal Alcohol Syndrome. You name it, we probably had it. There was a staff of young people in the dormitory, mostly women, who took care of the children’s daily needs. Feeding, bathing, changing diapers, keeping logs for seizures and for bowel movements. Deshawn and I bonded mostly because we were the only two guys in the dormitory.</p><p>We were an odd pair. I came from a conservative white middle-class suburb in northwest Indiana. Deshawn was from a struggling south Los Angeles neighborhood. I had moved to California four years earlier. My bachelors in English did me no favors occupationally and I was struggling to find a purpose in life. My job with the kids was an effort to find something meaningful and would eventually lead to my becoming a special education teacher. Deshawn had no similar ambitions. He was just trying to make ends meet and, to him, this job wiping pre-teen butts was crazy, but it was better than working fast food.</p><p>Despite our differences, Deshawn and I had some important things in common. First, we had the same cynical worldview. Deshawn grew up in a gang infested, drug riddled inner city where there was persistent poverty and societal neglect and indifference. I grew up in a nice white suburb, but was routinely condescended to and bullied and denied the basic niceties simply because I was Mexican, or, more accurately, because I was not white. (See my story: Heroism Denied: A Mexican-American Boy in 1970s Indiana). This meant that we were both highly attuned to the bullshit around us and shared a very dark sense of humor. We also had the same taste in music, which at that time was mostly hip hop, although Deshawn often had to explain the inner-city references to me. For example, he had to explain to me why 911 was a joke. (See Public Enemy’s “911 Is a Joke” from the album “Fear of a Black Planet”.)</p><p>Our shared appreciation of hip hop music naturally led to us hitting the dance clubs together. Deshawn would pick me up in his beat up Ford Fiesta and make his ritual pre-clubbing stop at the 7–11 to grab some “meat and cheeeeeese,” which is how he referred to Slim Jims and cheese sticks. Once he was sufficiently psyched up to “pick up some honeys,” we would head over to one of the many clubs throughout town, none of which I can remember the names of, although there was one ornate theater I remember that was called either the Aztec or the Mayan. Deshawn loved the way I danced. He would laugh and point and tell me how I looked “so stupid.” Which, oddly enough, was both an insult to my dancing, and a compliment to my confidence. And every time he saw a woman with a “banging” body, he would gesture to her butt or her chest and yell, “BAM! BAM! BAM!” But neither of us ever got lucky. I can’t imagine why.</p><p>Monday, January 15, 1990. The Martin Luther King holiday. Deshawn and I both had the night off so we headed on over to a club and it was, by far, the most happening place I had ever been to. There were wall to wall people. Somebody was spinning disks, but there didn’t seem to be any dancing going on. It was just a scene. And a cool one at that.</p><p>Sitting on a ledge against the wall to our left was the duo Milli Vanilli. Good looking guys. Wearing black leather. I was unaware at that time that there had been whispers about them not being the real singers on their albums, but the controversy would eventually explode 10 months later, in November of 1990, when their producer, Frank Farian, admitted that Rob Pilatus and Fab Morvan did not sing on their album “Girl You Know It’s True.” That same month the two were subsequently dropped from their label, Arista Records, and their Grammy for Best New Artist was rescinded.</p><p>It was not long after we had noticed Milli Vanilli that a commotion broke out and we felt ourselves being pushed to the side. Mike Tyson had entered the room, surrounded by four or maybe six body guards. They walked past us and towards the front of the hall.</p><p>Mike Tyson is three years younger than I am: I was born June 1963 and he was born June 1966. Tyson was, by all accounts, going through a rough patch in 1988 and 1989. In 1988 he fired both is manager and his trainer. He had suffered a very publicly tumultuous marriage to Robin Givens, which included accusations of physical abuse by Tyson and a reported miscarriage. They divorced in 1989. He had no kids at this point but there was one on the way from another woman. His daughter Mikey (Miki) Lorna Tyson would be born in July 1990. Finally, in November 1990, ten months after our Martin Luther King Day encounter, and the same month that Milli Vanilli would implode, Tyson would lose for the first time in his professional boxing career; surrendering his WBA, WBC, and IBF heavyweight titles to Buster Douglas in Tokyo, Japan on a technical knockout. (For many months afterwards I would chant “TKO in Tokyo, TKO in Tokyo,” while going about my day.)</p><p>But Tyson’s troubles were not evident on this night. Mike Tyson, surprisingly, is only 5”10”, which, judging by proportion, means that his bodyguards were probably 6’3” and taller. Even so, of the bunch, Mike Tyson was by far the most intimidating. This is largely because of his startling proportions. Tyson may have been short, relatively speaking, but he was also very thick, chest to back; and very wide, shoulder to shoulder. As they pushed by I leaned over to Deshawn and shouted, “He looks like a brick wall!” With that low center of gravity. one could easily picture how his punches could pack so much power. How the force would travel from the floor, up his leg, through his swiveling torso and down his thick muscular arm straight into someone’s face. (Or, to quote my shotokan sensei, “Punch from the floor.”) His reputation might have prompted my visceral reaction, but his physical presence was terrifying.</p><p>We did not see him again for the rest of the evening. At 2:00 A.M. the music stopped and the DJ said we all had to leave. In a huddled mass of humanity we squeezed our way outside where we were met by a phalanx of LA’s finest decked out in riot gear and lining the street across from the club. Above us was the fwup-fwup-fwup of a helicopter. A spotlight swept back and forth across the crowd and a loudspeaker shouted:</p><p>“Get into your cars, and go home! Get into your cars, and go home!”</p><p>This was very exciting, and nothing like anything I had ever experienced back in my small town in Indiana. I looked over at Deshawn and shouted, “So, what do you want to do?!”</p><p>Deshawn’s eyes grew wide and he looked at me like I had leprosy. “What do I want to doooo?! I want to get in my car and go home, that’s what I want to do! Do you think this is a joke?!”</p><p>So we got in his car and we went home.</p><blockquote><strong><em>The boiling frog</em></strong><em> is an apologue describing a frog being slowly boiled alive. The premise is that if a frog is put suddenly into boiling </em><strong><em>water</em></strong><em>, it will jump out, but if the frog is put in tepid </em><strong><em>water</em></strong><em> which is then brought to a boil slowly, it will not perceive the danger and will be cooked to death.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>Wikipedia</em></blockquote><p>Age sneaks up on you.</p><p>When you’re a man you never ever stop thinking that you can get the hot girl. Or that you can defend yourself against a group of thugs. Or that you can win at a competitive sporting event against someone half your age.</p><p>But age is real. Deterioration is real. Your body’s oxygen efficiency drops. You have fewer muscle fibers. Your neuromuscular system (the connection between your brain and your muscles) is not as effective or efficient. Your connective tissues are weaker. Your body’s healing process is delayed. In short: you are slower, you are weaker, you are less coordinated, and the damage you you endure may be permanent.</p><p>I am three years older than Mike Tyson, and I held out hope that Tyson would clobber Jake Paul; in the same way that I hold out hope that I can do all the things that I used to be able to do when I was younger. But watching Tyson biting on his glove, keeping his distance, and trudging to his corner as if he were heading to bed, made me reflect on my own limitations. I’m sure if I were to go dancing today I would still look “stupid,” but I don’t know that it would be a good stupid like it was in 1990. Rather than be admired for my confidence, I’d probably be pitied for trying to do what young people do.</p><p>In Hawaii, where I live, they recently passed a law that makes an assault against someone of my age, 60 years and older, an assault in the first degree. That is an enhanced penalty, from second degree to first degree assault, due to circumstances related to the age of the victim. The law recognizes me as fragile.</p><p>When did the water go from tepid to boiling?</p><p>Meanwhile, here’s the partial transcript of an <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yFrybVY2r7E">interview</a> with a 14-year-old reporter Jazlyn “Jazzy” Guerra:</p><blockquote><em>Jazzy: “What legacy does Mike Tyson want to leave behind?”</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>Tyson: “I don’t believe in the word ‘legacy.’ I think that’s another word for ego. Legacy doesn’t mean nothing. That’s just some word everybody grabbed on to. Someone said that word and everyone grabbed on to that word, now it’s used every five seconds. It means absolutely nothing to me. I’m just passing through. I’m gonna die and it’s gonna be over. Who cares about legacy after that?</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>“So I’m gonna die. I want people to think that I’m this, I’m great? No, we’re nothing. We’re just dead. We’re dust. We’re absolutely nothing. Our legacy is nothing.”</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>Jazzy: “Well thank you so much for sharing that. That is something that I have not heard before, someone saying that as an answer.”</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>Tyson: “Can you really imagine somebody saying, ‘I want my legacy to be this way?’ You’re dead! Who the f — — cares about me when I’m gone? My kids, maybe, or grandkids?”</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>Jazzy: “True. And, again, thank you so much for sharing that.”</em></blockquote><p>First, hats off to Jazzy. She handled it like a pro.</p><p>Rob Pilatus died of a drug overdose in 1998 on the eve of the release of Milli Vanilli’s comeback album. In any event, based on the gospel according to Mike Tyson, Milli Vanilli should probably not worry about their legacy.</p><p>Watching Mike Tyson, the man who I found so intimidating 34 years ago, shuffle around the boxing ring like <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z-QqmJimv_U">Tim Conway</a>, and waxing profanely about his legacy or lack thereof, reminded me that there comes a time in every man’s life when it’s just better to get into your car and go home.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=858fbc64ae4c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Love Is Blind: Adventures in Neurodivergence]]></title>
            <link>https://ronman63.medium.com/love-is-blind-adventures-in-neurodivergence-9aae42d883a0?source=rss-14e38d873f99------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9aae42d883a0</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[abuse]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[neurodivergent]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[rape]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ronald D. Rodriguez]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 06 Oct 2024 03:13:58 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-10-06T03:13:58.988Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Where’s a glass slipper when you need one?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*7In-UcarmfDGvnkURP8HGA.jpeg" /></figure><h4>A memoir in the third person.</h4><p>There was a young hispanic male in his twenties who worked as a bank teller on the ground floor of a shopping mall in West Los Angeles around 1987, 1988. He had all the hard skills. Neat. Efficient. Good with numbers. Good finger dexterity. If you gave him a stack of ones he could tell you, just by feel, if the stack was an even 25. He was also, by far, the quickest teller on the line. This was likely because, unbeknownst to anyone, he had by sheer repetition memorized the account numbers of all of the regular customers, allowing him to begin the transaction as they were walking in the door. His name was Ron, and nobody understood how he could possibly work so quickly.</p><p>Although Ron could recognize customers within the context of the bank, he was otherwise incapacitated when it came to remembering names and faces. Out of context, he would walk right past friends and coworkers without a clue. Likewise, he would mistake complete strangers for people he knew. Consequently, he was always on the alert; waiting for a confirmational smile or a wave from anyone he passed. This made dating extremely difficult, even in his dreams. One recurring dream involved a date with a beautiful woman at a crowded venue where he would arrive at the meeting place only to realize that he couldn’t pick her out in the crowd. For Ron, almost every date was a blind date. Many years later, after reading a book by the famous neurologist Oliver Sacks, he would identify this malady as a form of prosopagnosia — a neurological condition, the key attribute of which is face blindness.</p><p>Fortunately, those who are handicapped are often blessed with a compensatory skill. In Ron’s case, this saving grace came in the form of an empathic ability to intuit, or more accurately, embody what the other person was experiencing. He would feel people rather than see them. This allowed him to mirror people when they were happy, and deescalate when they were upset, regardless of outward appearances. This, combined with his hard skills, made Ron hugely popular. Customers would wait in line for him rather than go to the next open teller window.</p><p>The regular checking and savings account windows, where Ron worked, were up front while the merchant windows were at the back of the bank. Since they were located in a shopping mall, this branch had more than its fair share of merchant accounts. Ron had no direct dealings with these vendors, but he would smile and wave as they walked by with their blue vinyl deposit bags, and they would smile and wave back.</p><p>This particular mall, the Westside Pavilion, located on the corner of Pico and Overland, appeared to have been designed by two different architects. The exterior had a whimsical, circus-like motif, with brightly colored geometric shapes surrounding the entrance, while the interior had a more refined symmetrical design: three floors running in a straight line, escalators evenly spaced on either side, plain white columns, silver railings, beige tile flooring, and a glass dome roof that ran along the full length of the mall. The only interior element of the mall that echoed the circus-like exterior was the smell of movie theater popcorn that wafted from the cinemas on the third floor.</p><p>Despite it’s distinct characteristics, the Westside Pavilion was just like a thousand other shopping malls in the country. For the people who work in them, shopping malls are worlds unto themselves. Discrete neighborhoods where you see the same people, most of them in their teens and twenties, every day, day after day. Walking the tiled hallways and standing on the escalators. Sitting in the food court or on shopping mall benches. Folding shirts and shelving books and setting up window displays. Catering to people with money or credit to burn. Selling things that they couldn’t afford themselves. It was like an enclosed adolescent capitalist dystopia. The electric energy of youth trapped in a world of shiny surfaces, plastic trees, recirculated air, and homogenized music. And at the end of their shifts, as these young people push open the swinging glass doors leading to the outside world, the cool night air hits their faces and they realize that they’ve lost another day of their young lives, at minimum wage. Another day that they will never get back again.</p><p>The one thing Ron rarely did was go outside during his shift. When he did go outside it was never to walk out onto the street. The street was too untethered. Too lawless. Instead, he would take the escalators up to the third floor exit leading to the rooftop parking lot, take a deep smoggy Los Angeles breath, and peer through the mall’s water-spotted glass roof. From this angle the mall reminded him of a snow globe or a doll’s house, except without the joy and wonder. He would imagine himself walking from shop to shop, greeting the other mall workers. Pretending he recognized them.</p><h4>The Girlfriend.</h4><p>The teller job paid eight dollars an hour. An impossibly small sum to live on. But Ron was good with numbers, was diligent in his accounting, and was extremely frugal. Every morning he printed out his bank statement and used a highlighter to color-code the entries. He didn’t own a credit card. He contributed $300 per month to live in an apartment with his brother and his brother’s wife. He took the Blue Bus to work so there were no car expenses. He rarely ate out. Every six weeks he splurged on a fancy Japanese hair stylist on the third floor of the mall. Otherwise, he had very few expenses and, really, no life outside of his job to speak of.</p><p>A year earlier, Ron had broken up with a young woman who worked in a gift shop on the second floor. The shop she worked in had delicate hand blown glass animals in the storefront window, fancy wooden music boxes, and snow globes. They met through a former coworker of his and Ron immediately took a liking to her. The billow of her Aqua-Netted hair. The way she wobbled side to side when she walked, like a penguin. Her dimples. She was different enough that he could spot her anywhere. One day they bumped into each other in the foodcourt and she sidled up to him as if they were dating. Which, as of that moment, they were. Just like that.</p><p>To make a long story short: Boy and girl fall in love or something like love, girl is different in all the wrong ways, boy is unhappy and breaks up with girl, girl goes hysterical, boy apologizes and stays with girl, boy and girl are miserable, boy breaks up with girl again but this time for keeps.</p><p>“This time for keeps” is where it gets complicated. The worst kind of breakup is a unilateral one. The voracity of her desperation during the first attempt shocked him. He concluded, after agreeing to stay with her, that the only way he could break up with her was to make her hate him. And, in hating him, he thought, maybe she would choose herself. Maybe she could get over him and move on. So the second time he broke up with her he said terrible hurtful things. And she cried and cried and cried.</p><p>Unless you’re a sociopath, how others see you influences how you see yourself, and how you see yourself influences how you think others perceive you. It’s like two mirrors facing each other. You think you’re worthless, which causes you to think others think you’re worthless, which causes you to think you’re even more worthless and so on. As much as we would like to believe it, our identities are not an objective reflection of who we are.</p><p>Wanting her to hate him was the goal. But what if, instead of making her hate him, he only succeeding in making her hate herself?</p><p>The road to hell is paved with good intentions. For months Ron was haunted by the thought of what he had done. And he was terrified that he might randomly bump into the Gift Shop Girl and would be forced to see his reflection through her eyes. He was also taunted by the notion that everybody was judging him for what he had done. So for months he would walk straight from the bus stop to the bank and back, eyes cast down, avoiding at all costs the tiled hallways and the escalators and the food court. Occasionally he would imagine catching a glimpse of the Gift Shop Girl from the corner of his eye and it would send him running.</p><p>One day, an employee from a store a couple of doors down from the Gift Shop Girl’s, a former mutual friend, approached Ron’s teller window and, mercifully, told him that the Gift Shop Girl had quit her job. That she wasn’t in the mall anymore. “I thought you should know.” Ron caught a hint of judgment in her eyes and in her voice. He didn’t think he was imagining it. And he didn’t think she was wrong.</p><h4>Something Underneath Her Heartbeat</h4><p>Eventually, after weeks of hesitation, Ron started wandering the mall again. Up and down the tiled halls, and the escalators, and the rooftop parking.</p><p>One day, rather than eat lunch, Ron decided to walk up to the other end of the mall: Past the Waldenbooks employees shelving books; the Old Navy employees folding shirts; and the arcade where he could distinguish, through the noisy cacophony, the sounds of PacMan and Donkey Kong and Centipede.</p><p>Towards the other end of the mall he came across a wooden bench outside the Victoria’s Secret. And on that bench sat a conventionally beautiful young woman wearing a floral skirt and a long-sleeved blouse. He thought he recognized her as one of the vendors who would occasionally walk past his teller window, which meant she was either a supervisor or an assistant manager. He could picture her breezing past him. She looked up and her eyes said that she knew him.</p><p>“Hey,” he said.</p><p>“Hi!” she chirped.</p><p>“How’s it going?” Ron asked the question as a pleasantry. A midwestern custom. Not really expecting an answer. After all, it wasn’t like they knew each other.</p><p>“Okay,” she said.</p><p>Flash forward 20 years. Ron would have a stepdaughter named Alex. Alex was six years old when her pediatrician, during a routine checkup, heard something in her stethoscope. “I’m hearing something underneath her heartbeat.” The pediatrician would send Alex to cardiology who, in turn, would admit her for a three-week stay to manage a heart condition. Sometimes, all it takes is an attentive ear.</p><p>The Victoria’s Secret Supervisor said, “okay.” But something about the “okay” was not right. Her “Hi,” with its chipper tone, had been a habit. The sort of habit one develops when working in retail. Her “okay,” on the other hand, was unguarded. It betrayed a certain defeated exhaustion. More importantly, he could hear a barely perceptible nervous quiver vibrating beneath the surface of her exhaustion. Like an undercurrent in a seemingly calm shoreline or a flutter beneath a heartbeat. He recognized the quiver as . . .</p><p>Fear.</p><p>Ron stopped walking and turned his full attention to the woman on the bench.</p><p>“Are you alright?”</p><p>“Huh?” Her eyebrows arched up. Her posture, knees together, hands clasped on her lap, shoulders slightly hunched, signaled worry. “Yeah, no. I’m fine.”</p><p>There was that quiver again. She was scared of something. Ron squared up.</p><p>“You seem deep in thought. What’s going on?”</p><p>“Nothing. Really.”</p><p>“No, come on. Talk to me.”</p><p>He didn’t really know her, aside from the occasional wave as she walked to the back of the bank. In fact, this was the first time they’d ever spoken to each other. Asking her to explain herself was presumptuous at best.</p><p>“I’m just,” she bit her lip. “I’m just trying to figure something out.”</p><p>“What’s that?”</p><p>Her eyes searched him hesitantly.</p><p>“I’m trying to move out of my apartment.”</p><p>He waited a beat. “Why are you trying to move?”</p><p>“Well. I’m living with this guy and.”</p><p>She stopped abruptly. The tension in the air told him that this was not a mutual breakup. The fear in her voice told him that she was trapped.</p><p>They stood there for what seemed like a minute. Finally, Ron whispered.</p><p>“It’s bad, huh?”</p><p>She did not respond. A muffled rush of blood coursed through Ron’s ears as the gravity of the situation settled in. Dust particles floated in a beam of sunlight that descended from the glass ceiling. The sights and sounds of the mall faded into a watery blur as Ron stood there in his tasseled loafers, staring at this lovely woman, her anxious fingers interlaced on her lap. It was as if a snow globe had formed around them.</p><p>She let out a labored sigh.</p><p>“So,” he asked, “what is it that’s holding you back?”</p><p>She gathered herself. They both spoke in whispers now. “Well, I have the apartment picked out, and I’ve spoken with the landlord.” She glanced around. “And she says she’s holding it for me until the end of the month. But they require first and last month’s rent and I don’t have enough.” She paused, looked back down. “And the end of the month is Friday.”</p><p>“So that’s the day after tomorrow.” And if she missed this window, he thought, it would be another month, maybe more, before she could try again. Why was she alone in this? Did she not have family?</p><p>What could happen in thirty days? A lot.</p><p>“How much do you need?”</p><p>“Three hundred dollars.”</p><p>“So, if you had three hundred dollars the landlord would let you move in?”</p><p>“Yes.”</p><p>“So, if you had three hundred dollars. You would move.”</p><p>“Yes.”</p><p>He looked at her slender arms. The blouse she wore had long sleeves. He wondered if there were bruises.</p><p>“So, if I gave you three hundred dollars, right now, you would move.”</p><p>He said it more as a challenge than a question. It took her a second to process what he was saying. She made eye contact with him.</p><p>“What?”</p><p>“If I gave you three hundred dollars, right now, would you move?”</p><p>She squirmed. “No. I didn’t mean…”</p><p>Ron took a step closer. He was no longer whispering.</p><p>“If I gave you three hundred dollars. Right Now. WOULD? YOU? MOVE?”</p><p>He held her gaze. High above them there was a flapping sound. A bird had wandered into the mall and was fluttering along the glass ceiling three stories up.</p><p>Finally, in a voice barely audible, she said:</p><p>“Yes.”</p><p>Ron let out a deep relieved sigh.</p><p>“Okay. I’m going to walk back up to the bank. I’m going to withdraw three hundred dollars — cash. Then I’m going to walk back over here. Don’t <em>go</em> anywhere.”</p><p>She blushed. “Okay.”</p><p>He could see that her eyes were already turned inwards. Figuring out next steps.</p><p>Any vender on the second floor who happened to be glancing down would have seen Ron sprint up the mall in his tasseled loafers. Past the clothing stores and the arcade and the bookstore, all the way to the bank at the other end. A moment later, they would have seen him rushing back with cash in hand.</p><p>The Supervisor was still blushing. He couldn’t see it, but he could sense her goosebumps. A cool breeze wafted off of her as he approached.</p><p>“Here,” he said, handing her the bills and bending over to catch his breath. “Don’t worry about paying me back now. Just do what you have to do. We can figure the rest out later”</p><p>They hugged. She thanked him.</p><p>“My name’s Ron, by the way.”</p><p>She said her name, but he wasn’t used to remembering names because he never remembered faces anyway. But, god, she really was beautiful though.</p><p>Suddenly embarrassed, he quickly turned and jogged back to work. He didn’t look back.</p><p>And he never saw her again.</p><h4>The Next Day.</h4><p>He mentioned what happened to his assistant manager, Pierre, at the bank. Pierre was a slightly balding French Canadian who loved blues music and kept a tin of pot underneath his couch back at his apartment. In a bank full of women, he was the only other guy.</p><p>“Oh man, you are an <em>idiot</em>!” Pierre shook his head laughing, then he grabbed Ron’s arm. “Are you serious?” Ron shrugged. “Oh man! You’re <em>never</em> going to see that money again! You know that, right?”</p><p>Ron shrugged again. Pierre moved in conspiratorially.</p><p>“Which one is she?”</p><p>Ron tried to describe her.</p><p>“Yeaaaaah.” Pierre nodded. “I know the one. Brunette, right?”</p><p>Ron nodded, although he wasn’t really sure.</p><p>“So… did you think she would let you bang her? Is that why you did it?”</p><p>“No, I just. You know. I don’t know.”</p><p>Pierre shook his head. “I don’t mean to say you got taken, but, youuuuu got taken.” Pierre laughed and walked away.</p><h4>The Supervisor’s Manager?</h4><p>An older woman with a titular bearing and carrying a leather portfolio marched up to Ron’s window. Ron recognized the portfolio as a Coach, but he did not recognize her. She stood in front of him for what seemed like an eternity. Silent. Making intense eye contact. Sizing him up before finally saying, “That was a really nice thing you did.”</p><p>She assumed she was speaking to the right person and that he would know what she was talking about. Ron speculated that she was a higher up at Victoria’s Secret. Perhaps a district manager. It didn’t seem like she was there for small talk.</p><p>“Is she okay?”</p><p>The woman nodded. “Just so you know, she did move. And the store immediately transferred her to our Century City location.” The mall in Century City was outdoors and more upscale, with high end shops, valet parking, and plenty of security. It was located three bus routes away from Ron’s apartment.</p><p>That simple phrase, “And the store immediately transferred her…” told Ron everything he needed to know. His instinct was correct. The woman on the bench did sneak away. And the company was helping to hide her. The fact that they transferred her “immediately” meant that the district management had been aware of her situation and was prepared to act. They were all in on the plan. All that was needed was a benefactor.</p><p>“Thank you for letting me know.”</p><p>“No. Thank you.”</p><p>And she quickly marched away, evidently satisfied to have checked this errand off her list.</p><p>The conversation, if you could call it a conversation, was cloaked in shadows. Addressing Ron’s altruism without identifying it. Referring to the girl on the bench without speaking her name.</p><p>If “this guy” was as bad as all that, he would eventually track her down, he thought. But for now she was safe. And hopefully her successful escape would embolden her if anything went bad.</p><h4>The Envelopes.</h4><p>About a month passed. Ron got back into the rhythm of his day. Bus-bank-bus-home, bus-bank-bus-home. Hardly a day went by when he didn’t think about the the woman on the bench, but he no longer obsessed about it and had pretty much forgotten about the money altogether.</p><p>One day, about a month after the day he gave her the money, a petite blonde young girl in a flouncy skirt, probably eighteen or nineteen years old, made a bouncy beeline to Ron’s teller window.</p><p>“Are you Ron?”</p><p>“Yes.”</p><p>She dropped an unmarked legal size envelope on Ron’s counter and skipped away, giggling. She smiled back at him as she exited the bank.</p><p>The envelope was sealed. Ron swiped a letter opener under the flap and pulled out a crisp new fifty dollar bill. There was no note.</p><p>Each month for five straight months a different young girl would show up at his teller window. (Or, at least, he thought they were different girls.) Each girl would drop a legal sized envelope on Ron’s counter and run away, giggling. Ron assumed they were all employees from the Century City location. Each envelope had a fifty dollar bill in it. After the third one, Ron mentioned it to Pierre.</p><p>“No way?” Pierre’s eyes went wide with surprise. Ron shrugged. “Man, that’s really… wow, that’s great.” He gave Ron a slap on the shoulder and leaned in. “So, maybe you do have a chance with her?”</p><p>Altogether, Ron received two hundred and fifty dollars, just shy of the three hundred he gave her. More likely than not, the last girl pocketed the fifty dollar bill rather than deliver it to him. Ron was fine with that.</p><p>A couple of months after receiving her fifth payment, Ron looked up from his teller window and felt regret for having spent two whole years counting other people’s money for a living instead of doing something meaningful. That very same day Ron borrowed his manager’s typewriter and turned in his two-week notice. On the bus ride home, instead of staring out the window, Ron glanced around at the other passengers, and he was suddenly overcome with a sense of freedom.</p><p>This is how it must have felt, he thought. When she walked into her new apartment, set down her houseplant, and slid open the bedroom window, releasing the smell of fresh paint that still lingered from the newly covered eggshell colored walls. The breeze through the screen. The carpeting beneath her toes. And all this empty apartment space waiting to be filled.</p><p><em>Note to readers: This story is written in the third person, but it is autobiographical. Aside from some artistic details, the story is true.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9aae42d883a0" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Heroism Denied: A Mexican-American Boy in 1970’s Indiana]]></title>
            <link>https://ronman63.medium.com/heroism-denied-a-mexican-american-boy-in-1970s-indiana-90f1cc40c13c?source=rss-14e38d873f99------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/90f1cc40c13c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[mexican]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[justice]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[diversity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[midwest]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[bigotry]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ronald D. Rodriguez]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 23 Sep 2024 06:48:15 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-10-07T04:54:20.596Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>The Chicano with a Thousand Faces</h4><p>A memoir in the third person.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*UhBWY7vkMxjlqfY1HuGQgA.jpeg" /></figure><p>Ron was too short to be playing basketball, but he enrolled in the summer basketball clinic at the local high school anyway. As he sat in the stadium lobby, surrounded by about 30 of his 11-year-old cohorts, waiting for the doors to the basketball court to open, he wondered how he ended up here. He didn’t remember ever asking to attend basketball clinic. And he didn’t recall being coerced into it either. More likely than not, somebody, probably his mom, suggested it and, absent any kind of alternative, the suggestion became reality.</p><p>Naturally it would be his mom who would suggest it because it was his mom who was stuck with him all summer. Actually, that’s not true. His mom wasn’t stuck with “Ronald.” She loved Ronald, and she enjoyed having him around. But it was summer and she wanted him to be out playing, like his older brother Jesse did. Ronald was nothing like Jesse. Jesse had his father’s wavy hair whereas Ron had his mother’s straight hair. Jesse had chiseled masculine features. Ron had a friendly, open, rounded face. Jesse was handsome and lean. Ron was cute. More importantly, Jesse had friends. And Jesse would go outside. With his friends. And engage in the sort of feverish competitive savagery considered normal for fourteen-year-old boys. The kind of mischief that some people consider necessary to find your manhood. Playing competitive sports, or chasing girls, or arguing over the rules of a game. Ron, on the other hand, was not particularly athletic and preferred to spend his time indoors. He scanned the newspaper every morning, reading pretty much anything that didn’t have to do with Watergate (whatever that was). He could spend hours crouched over construction paper with his 30-count set of colored markers. He liked watching Phil Donahue, and he loved classical music.</p><p>There was a TV commercial that aired frequently, usually in the middle of Gilligan’s Island reruns, featuring a high brow upper-crust elderly gentleman in a double-breasted suit standing next to a harp and a marble or plaster bust of somebody probably Beethoven. The commercial was for an album set of 120 Classical Masterpieces, and the names of classical works would scroll across the screen while music played in the background. Ron would write down some of the names then, every couple of weeks, ride to the local library on his purple bike to browse their modest but representative album collection. (Jesse wouldn’t have been caught dead on a purple bike.) Over time, Ron worked his way through Bach, Pachelbel, Beethoven, Tchaikovsky, Rachmaninoff, and Chopin, among others.</p><p>Record albums, for those who don’t know, were kept in cardboard slip covers and if you held the cover the wrong way the album could slide right out. This is what happened to Ron one day as he was leaving the library. He was holding the album covers with the slit side facing forward and, when he hit the breaks on his purple bike, the albums flew out of the covers like a pair of skeets and crashed onto the gravel pavement. Ron picked up the albums, very distressed, brushed them off, and slouched back to the circulation desk.</p><p>It’s important to note that this was 1974, in a predominantly white suburb in Indiana. There were no blacks, and only a handful of Mexican families, many of whom were employed by the steel mills in Gary and East Chicago. Ron’s own family had moved to Griffith only seven years earlier from the town where his father’s employer, Inland Steel, was located. And although many of the people in his small town were perfectly decent, he learned at an early age that a sizable segment of the neighborhood was not going to be receptive to him. Ever. And so he learned to keep his head down and go about his business. As a result, aside from saying “thank you” at check out, Ron had never spoken to the librarians, and they had never really spoken to him. Until now.</p><p>Ron was almost in tears as he approached the librarian, a blonde woman probably in her thirties. He assumed he would be in trouble and that the damage he caused would be very expensive. He described to her what happened. “I’m so sorry! I’m so sorry! I can pay for it, I promise. I just need to talk to my dad.”</p><p>Ron’s eyes were cast down as he said this so he did not notice when the one librarian magically multiplied into three. The two other women must have come from the back when they heard his squeaking apology.</p><p>“No, no, it’s okay!” They all sang in a cooing chorus of gentle overlapping urgency. “We can replace them. It’s okay. This happens all the time. Don’t worry. It’s okay. We’re not mad. You don’t have to tell anybody. It’s fine. Would you like to check something else out? Go ahead, choose another album. Please. It’s okay.”</p><p>Ron looked up and saw how all these women were trying so hard to be soothing. It went beyond tenderness. It was more like familiarity. Suddenly, it occurred him: these women knew him. They probably talked about him every time he came in. He was that cute little brown kid who checked out classical albums. We love you, we know you, we love you, we know you, we love you, we know you, please keep coming back.</p><p>Indiana could be like that sometimes. Polar extremes of tribalist hate and liberal love.</p><p>So, Jesse and Ron were not very much alike. And, it’s not like Ron didn’t have any friends, despite his Mom’s misgivings. He got along well enough with his classmates. It’s just that his friendships were, for the most part, situational. Not the sort of friendships that carried over from school into the “real world.” But Ron’s mother couldn’t see that. She saw his isolation as unhealthy. Like loneliness or depression. And she worried that maybe he wasn’t liked. She never actually said it, but you could see it in her eyes. “Where are your friends? How come they don’t come around?” He didn’t know. How do you know when you’re not invited to something unless someone tells you, “Oh, hey Ron, by the way, we decided to get together over the weekend and we didn’t invite. you.” Nobody says that. So, how would he know? Maybe his class was just a class of loners. Did she ever consider that?</p><p>What’s worse, Ron’s mother had recently gotten into the habit of telling Jesse to “take your brother” whenever Jesse wanted to meet up with friends. And Jesse’s friends would jostle Ron around and say things like, “Hey, are you tough like your brother?” Ron never knew how to respond to that, which sort of answered the question. No. “Take your brother” was a bad development for everyone involved. So, if Ron didn’t object to attending basketball clinic, that was probably why.</p><h4>The Instigator</h4><p>Every day Ron would ride his purple bike up 45th Avenue, approximately one mile to local high school where the clinic was being held. He didn’t know anybody in the clinic, but it was not a complete waste. Ron was amused by the rhythmic squeak of tennis shoes, the vibrating clank of the basketball rim, and the rare but occasional swoosh of the net. He marveled at the smell of the basketball’s rubber on his hands. He was getting the hang of dribbling, and the two-handed pass, and even the layup. And, most surprisingly, he was enjoying the feeling of exhilaration that comes from engaging in sweaty physical activity. But it was pretty obvious that he was never going to be Julius Erving.</p><p>“Hey! You!”</p><p>Ron was aware that somebody was yelling in the lobby, but he was preoccupied by his jog strap. It itched and he was trying to figure out how he could scratch it without digging his hand into his shorts.</p><p>“Hey!”</p><p>If Jesse’s groin itched, would he care if anybody saw him scratching it?</p><p>“Hey! I’m talking to you!”</p><p>Ron looked up. The crowd in the lobby appeared to have parted so as not to stand in the path of the voice. A puny kid with bowl-cut dishwater blonde hair and beady eyes that were set a sliver too close together was pointing at him. Ron seemed to be the last person in the room to know he was being yelled at.</p><p>“Yeah, you!”</p><p>The puny kid’s voice was shrill, but his face was slack, like someone who is trying to look innocent. The sort of guy who would shoot a spit-wad at the teacher and then point at someone else. Ron had never met this guy before, but he knew his type. We’ll call him Shithead.</p><p>Shithead’s scratchy voice shot across the lobby like a crow.</p><p>“See this guy?!” Shithead pointed at a much bigger kid standing next to him. “You and him. Are going to fight. At the football field. After class tomorrow.”</p><p>Ron weighed only 69 pounds — easily the smallest boy in his class back at Wadsworth Elementary. And this bigger kid was… much larger. Ron let out a nervous laugh and lifted his upturned hands. “What are you talking about? I don’t even know him.” Ron looked at the bigger kid for support. And the bigger kid, we’ll call him the Dancing Bear, was smiling. He had braces. Ron looked around the room and noticed that everybody was staring at him. There wasn’t an adult in sight.</p><p>Oh, great, Ron thought. This is just great.</p><p>The doors to the basketball courts opened and they all filed into practice.</p><h4>Training</h4><p>Ron’s family lived in a tri-level house with pail green aluminum siding on the two-story portion, and red brick on the ranch level. Geraniums lined the brick wall leading to the front door. A visitor to the house would be greeted by an entryway lined in gold wallpaper overlapped by a fuzzy burgundy design. The carpeting was olive green. The couch and loveseat were covered in plastic. The victorian end tables had thick marble tops. There was a grandfather clog, with a gold pendulum, that had to wound with a key. A portrait of Jesus hung above the stairwell that led to the upstairs bedrooms. Beyond the living room was the adjacent dining room and the kitchen, smelling of chorizo and coffee and fresh tortillas, with a screen door leading to the back yard, and a stairway leading to the basement. The basement had cold tile floors, wood paneling, the hardest couch ever made, a black and white TV, and a desk where their father did the taxes.</p><p>Over the years the living room’s gaudy colors would fade into the interior decorating version of mayonnaise, but in 1974, you could still tell that Mexicans lived there.</p><p>“How was practice?” His mom looked at him while her hands busied themselves at the stove. Ron tried to explain to her what had happened at the gym. His head was spinning so fast from panic that he didn’t hear exactly what his mom said, but it was something to the effect of, “They’re just trying to scare you.”</p><p>Jesse, who was also in the room, disagreed.</p><p>Since this was a good Mexican household, they were not unfamiliar with the sport of boxing, with fights playing on ABC’s Wide World of Sports when available. This included, most recently, the January fight between Muhammed Ali and Joe Frazier at Madison Square Garden, with the inimitable commentating of Howard Cosell. Ron had mentioned the Muhammed Ali fight to a classmate who immediately said how much he hated Ali. Ron accepted this as another cultural peculiarity of where they lived — like the fact that he watched Sesame Street while everybody else watched Captain Kangaroo — so he never mentioned Muhammed Ali in mixed company again.</p><p>Jesse led Ron to the cold dark basement where he tried to teach him how to fight. If this were a film, this is where the training montage would come in. The training montage was popularized by the Rocky movies. An otherwise boring collection of video clips, showing Sylvester Stallone running in the dim morning light, is overlapped by a punchy 70’s soundtrack to create a story within a story. A tale of overcoming obstacles and finding oneself through adversity and dedication, leading up to the big fight. Generations of people would turn to these montages for inspiration at times like this; imagining that their struggles were part of a greater story, punctuated by a crescendo of music. Unfortunately, Ron did not have this inspiration to draw from. The first Rocky movie wouldn’t be released until two years later. Instead, Ron had thoughts of Muhammed Ali taunting his opponents and fighting against Ken Norton with a broken jaw.</p><p>Jesse demonstrated how to stand feet shoulder’s width apart. How to keep on your toes. How to keep your hands up and in front of you to protect your face and body. “Never let your hands down. Your arms will get tired, but keep them up anyway.” He showed Ron how to jab: to keep your wrist straight and your punches quick and sharp. He punctuated his demonstration with sound effects, like a leather glove hitting a punching bag. <em>Tsch. Tsch-tsch. Tsch-tsch-tsch.</em> He also showed him the hook and the uppercut, and taught him to vary his punch selection so the other guy wouldn’t know what to expect. Jesse danced around the cold basement floor, and Ron followed. Sort of.</p><p>In the end, Ron was okay imitating his brother so long as he didn’t think about why they were doing this. So long as he didn’t think about what would happen when there was an actual person, a very large person, standing in front of him. Ron’s foot coordination left a lot to be desired, so there probably wouldn’t be any “floating like a butterfly,” but maybe he could still “sting like a bee.”</p><p>“One more thing,” Jesse said. “You need to set rules.”</p><p>“Rules?”</p><p>“Rules. No biting. No kicking. No scratching. No weapons. This is a fist fight. And once there’s blood, the fight is over.”</p><p>“Once there’s blood, the fight is over,” Ron repeated.</p><p>“Once there’s blood, the fight is over,” Jesse confirmed.</p><p>That night Ron stared at the ceiling of their second story bedroom, his heart beating like a hummingbird’s wings.</p><p>“Once there’s blood…” “Once there’s blood…”</p><p>He replayed, over and over in his head, that morning’s encounter in the gym lobby. Shithead’s beady eyes. Dancing Bear’s smile. The whole room staring at him. It’s funny how, the moment he saw Shithead’s beady eyes he completely forgot about his itchy crotch. Like the itching wasn’t real — it was just a distraction from, or more likely a symptom of, the hell-scape around him. He replayed the moment, trying to figure out if there was anything he could have done differently. Anything he could have said to avoid this.</p><h4>Fight Day</h4><p>The next day, it was difficult to focus on the two handed pass knowing what was coming. But as practice went on, and nobody said anything, Ron began to believe that maybe his mother was right. Maybe they were just trying to scare him. The thought of a reprieve filled him with exhilaration as he got in line for layups. As the final whistle blew, and class was dismissed, Ron let out a sigh of relief. But his smile quickly disappeared as Shithead and the Dancing Bear came up alongside him.</p><p>“Let’s go,” Shithead said. And they filed out the door.</p><p>Ron’s stomach felt queasy but he settled himself down as he tried to remember what his brother had taught him. As they walked across the parking lot to the football field, Ron recited the rules, ending with the final rule, “once there’s blood, the fight is over.” Shithead repeated each rule and agreed. The Dancing Bear didn’t seem to be listening.</p><p>Ron hung his glasses on the chain link fence. The sky in Griffith had a flat washed out appearance. This may have been due to the mist off Lake Michigan, or the haze that drifted over from the steel mills some 15 miles north. The gravel track that ran around the football field was dry and dusty. The white yard lines were faded. He could tell that the grass had become overgrown behind the bleachers because he could hear the wind hiss through its long blades. Surprisingly, there were no spectators. Everybody else seemed to have headed home.</p><p>At first, nobody did anything. Ron stood there with his arms raised, just as he had been taught, and the Dancing Bear stood there with his hands down and wearing a smirk on his face. Finally, somebody threw a punch. Ron couldn’t remember who threw the first punch. It may have been Dancing Bear, since all Ron wanted to do was go home. Or it may have been Ron himself, throwing a punch as a way of practicing what he had learned, or perhaps in an effort to get this thing over with. Important details like this, details that would shape the narrative and set in motion the legend one would create around himself, can be easily missed in the adrenaline rushed fury of the moment. And Ron was too honest and particular to simply manufacture a story for the sake of self aggrandizement. (Many years later, while working as an attorney, Ron would sympathize with those who had trouble recalling exactly how a tragic event unfolded.) One thing Ron did remember for certain was that his own first punch was a right jab that glanced off the Dancing Bear’s mouth. A little off target, but it connected.</p><p>The Dancing Bear appeared flustered, like he wasn’t expecting to get hit. Ron threw another jab. And another. The Dancing Bear’s mouth gaped open as he started to back up. The Dancing Bear must have thrown a couple of punches but Ron was too focused to notice. Quick jabs. Arms up. Quick jabs. Arms up. Ron didn’t know how many punches he had thrown, but at some point the Dancing Bear tripped and fell backwards.</p><p>Still focused, Ron sat on top of Dancing Bear and kept punching at his face.</p><p>At some point Ron heard Shithead’s voice. The same scratchy voice he had heard in the lobby the previous day. Shrill and distant.</p><p>“There’s blood! There’s blood! The fight’s over! The fight’s over!”</p><p>Suddenly, as if awakening from a dream, Ron looked down. The Dancing Bear was crying. Blood was running from his nose and his mouth. Ron’s knuckles were also cut up, probably from the Dancing Bear’s braces. Shithead was jumping up and down but he kept his distance.</p><p>Ron jumped up, raised his palms in the air, and started chanting. “The fight’s over! The fights over! The fight’s over!”</p><p>A little boy, maybe three years old, charged up to Ron. The boy was crying. He yelled, “You beat up my brother!” and tried to kick Ron in the shin, but he was too scared to get that close. The little boy threw a frantic little foot at Ron then ran away.</p><p>Meanwhile, the Dancing Bear got up, lurched towards the chain link fence, and grabbed Ron’s glasses. At that instant, Ron burst into tears.</p><p>It’s important to note that Ron had gotten his first pair of glasses only a few months earlier. Without them he was blind. He didn’t know he was blind before he got his glasses, but once he had them he realized he couldn’t be without them. Second, Ron had never been in a fight before and he had not had time to process the emotions that it created: the building anxiety leading up to the fight; the utter terror of the fight itself; the unexpected exhilaration he felt as the bully kept backing up; the shocking realization that the Dancing Bear had brought his little brother to watch; and now the potential loss of Ron’s eyesight. But, beyond all of this, the thing that finally broke Ron was the injustice and the powerlessness one feels when trying to defend himself in a world that has no honor. People who seek revenge for actions that they themselves brought about. And living in a dominant culture that will not defend you. That will not take your side. How can you survive an ordeal and still lose?</p><p>Then, seemingly out of nowhere, Jesse stepped forward.</p><p>“Give me the glasses.”</p><p>The Dancing Bear froze. Jesse had one hand outstretched to receive the glasses. His other hand held a chocolate malt. Next to Ron’s brother, the Dancing Bear did not seem so big. Three years, at that age, is like a generation.</p><p>The Dancing Bear handed the glasses to Jesse and Jesse handed the glasses to Ron.</p><p>“Go home. I’ll take care of this,” Jesse said as he pulled some restaurant napkins out of his pocket.</p><p>Ron grabbed his purple bike and wheeled it across the parking lot while Jesse prepared to mop the blood off the Dancing Bear’s face.</p><p>A long-haired pothead-type teenager who happened to be hanging out in the parking lot called out to Ron.</p><p>“Who won?!”</p><p>The question caught Ron by surprise. He had been so busy trying to survive the ordeal that the question of winning and losing hadn’t even occurred to him. He perked up.</p><p>“I did!”</p><p>The pothead lifted a fist. “Hey, way to go, man!”</p><p>Ron rode out of the parking lot, replaying the incident over and over in his head, and practicing how he would retell the story. Fifteen minutes later he was still dizzy from the adrenaline when he coasted up the driveway and walked through the back screen door.</p><p>“I won!”</p><h4>Bats</h4><p>“That is the worst thing I ever heard.”</p><p>It was nighttime. Ron’s friend Mary was bobbing up and down in her swimming pool with a pool skimmer held high above her head. Bats would sometimes swoop down above the pool at night, probably trying to catch the insects that were attracted to the shimmery water, and Mary made a sport out of trying to swat them. Ron was bobbing at the other side of the pool. The sky was an uncharacteristically clear. The stars were unimpeded by smog or clouds.</p><p>There were plenty of above ground pools in town, big round steel drums edged by brown rust, but hers was the only pool he knew of that was in-ground. Not that he had been in very many back yards, but this underground pool with the little lights along the wall made him think that she was probably rich, though he had no real frame of reference from which to judge any of this.</p><p>“Seriously?” She continued. “Your parents told you that there are no winners in a fight?”</p><p>“Yeah.” Ron could taste something salty and discontent oozying in his mouth. He dipped his raw scratched up hands in and out of the water. The chlorine made the knuckles sting, and the sting reminded him that he had overcome something. “I don’t remember exactly what they said. There are no winners in a fight. Nothing good ever comes from violence. Violence only gets you more violence. Something like that.”</p><p>“That’s bullshit.”</p><p>Speaking in cartoon metaphors, if Ron was Charlie Brown, sort of mopey and unsure; Mary was Lucy Van Pelt — very certain, and always a little bit outraged about something. He envied her assuredness. How does someone even become like that?</p><p>“Do you really think you didn’t win that fight?” She asked.</p><p>“I don’t know. I mean, I didn’t get beat up, so that’s something.”</p><p>Mary lowered her skimmer and stared at Ron for a long time.</p><p>Residents of Griffith, Indiana were treated to summer evening concerts of chirping. Constant. Incessant. Chirping. Were they crickets? Grasshoppers? Katydids? Locusts? He had no idea. All he knew is that the sound was so loud and so ubiquitous that you didn’t even really notice it, until you did. Many years later the word “crickets” would come to mean silence in response to something ridiculous. This is what Ron was experiencing at that very moment, literally and figuratively, as Mary stared him down. Finally, she let out a sigh.</p><p>“How are your hands?”</p><p>“Okay.”</p><p>“Anything else?”</p><p>“My mouth a little.”</p><p>“You never been in a fight before?”</p><p>“No. Unless you count my brother.”</p><p>“That doesn’t count. Kind of surprising considering.”</p><p>The subtext being: considering everybody here is white and you’re not.</p><p>“Oh, and there was that kid who hit me in the head with a rock a couple of years ago, but that wasn’t really a fight. I just ran home. The next day I had a black eye.”</p><p>“And what did your parents do about that?”</p><p>“What could they do? It’s not like I knew the kid who hit me.”</p><p>Ron could feel Mary seething. He dunked his head and the sound of the crickets disappeared, replaced by the wallowing echo of his own head trapped in the water. He looked around at the pool lights. Mary was wearing a one piece. Ron wore a t-shirt because he was embarrassed about his dark nipples, so much darker than everybody else’s. The water was still cold despite being beaten by the sun all day. He waved his arms around to see how long he could stay under water. When he popped up, gasping for air, Mary was still staring. Still staring at the spot where he had been bobbing.</p><p>“You won that fight, Ron.”</p><p>Ron caught his breath. “Thank you.”</p><p>“I mean it. You won. You should be proud of that.”</p><h4>An Uncomfortable Realization</h4><p>Winning the fight, if you can call it winning, was completely anticlimactic for Ron, and did not provide any emotional payoff. No dancing around the ring with your hands raised in the air. No standing on the ropes to receive the adoration of cheering fans. Just a pothead asking who won and a parent waxing philosophical about violence.</p><p>There was a part of him that wished that he had gotten injured. Not badly, mind you. But enough so that people would feel sorry for him and take seriously the ordeal he had gone through. Enough so that people would notice him.</p><p>Ron had not processed, and barely even acknowledged that, at one point, he was sitting on top of Dancing Bear and repeatedly punching him in the face. SITTING ON TOP of a kid and PUNCHING him repeatedly IN THE FACE. How was that not a bigger deal?! Shouldn’t he have gone through some sort of existential crises? Why was this okay? On the other hand, if Dancing Bear had beaten Ron up, Dancing Bear would not be upset. Dancing Bear would not be questing the meaning of life. Dancing Bear would probably be bragging about it and retelling the story in a way that made him look heroic.</p><p>The problem with being liberal minded is that you see everything from the other person’s perspective, regardless of whether it’s the right perspective. It’s not a conscious thing so much as it is just the way you engage with the world. In this case, Dancing Bear was just a tool. As for Shithead: instead of feeling a sense of righteousness, Ron, and probably his parents, realized that Shithead was probably responding to his own tragic circumstances. Shithead may have been a victim of bullying or abuse himself, thus relieving himself of victimization by reversing roles, by assuming an aggressive posture. Or he may have lacked any kind of autonomy or control in his home life, and coercing strangers to fight may have given him a feeling of power. Or maybe Shithead had a compulsion to create drama around himself to drown out some kind of emptiness he felt inside, perhaps due to neglect. Any of these could have been his origin story.</p><p>You see. That’s the problem with being empathic. You’re so busy living in the skin of your adversary that you neglect to recognize your own victimization. You’re understanding of others cancels out your own lived experience.</p><p>What bothered Ron most about the whole incident was that Shithead chose to pit a big white kid against a small brown kid. Why would somebody do that? Were Shithead and Dancing Bear friends? Ron didn’t know. But this lopsided contest appeared to be designed for a predetermined outcome. The goal was not to see two people fight. The goal was to see the little brown kid get beat up.</p><p>It was not meant to be a contest. It was meant to be a lynching.</p><p>On some level 11-year-old Ron knew that. But it would be years before he could put it into words.</p><h4>The Post Fight Interview</h4><p>Ron would remagine that day in a million different ways. Usually to the soundtrack of the first movement of Beethoven’s Fifth Symphony, or Copeland’s Fanfare for the Common Man; his fists striking in unison with the timpani. He would dance around the cold basement floor, then pretend to have a post fight interview with Howard Cosell.</p><p>Howard Cosell: Ro-nald Ro-driguez. Good to see ya Champ!</p><p>Ron: How-ard Co-sell. The world’s greatest newscaster.</p><p>Howard Cosell: You’re very kind, Champ. So how did you feel out there?</p><p>Ron: I felt great, Howard. I felt great.</p><p>Howard Cosell: So did you worry…</p><p>Ron: Worry?</p><p>Howard Cosell: Did you worry that the Dancing Bear’s size would counteract your natural fighting ability?</p><p>Ron: Well, if the Dancing Bear dreamed it, he would have to apologize.</p><p>Howard Cosell: You are absolutely brilliant, Champ.</p><p>And his imagination would wander into blurred scenarios of camera flashes and lively banter and cheering fans. Lots of cheering.</p><h4>Bats and Crickets</h4><p>The following week Ron’s mother went to talk to the the basketball coach who, as it turns out, was an old classmate of hers from East Chicago. Two weeks later, at the end of the clinic, the coach awarded Ron a basketball for trying the hardest.</p><p>(Decades later, when asked what she remembered about the incident, Ron’s mom would express pride at Ron defending himself, seemingly forgetting any comments about nobody winning in a fight.)</p><p>As far as Ron knew, there were no other repercussions from the incident. They never heard from the Dancing Bear’s parents, and Ron never saw the Dancing Bear again. Ron and Shithead both finished out the clinic, but after that, Ron would not see those beady eyes again until years later when they crossed paths at the feeder schools: junior high school and then high school. But even then, they never spoke to each other about the incident, or about anything else. It was as if they had never met. It was as if it had never happened. But it had happened. And Ron never forgot.</p><p>The thing about crickets is that you can hear them, seemingly everywhere, but you can’t see them. They are simultaneously everywhere and nowhere. As for bats, you never see a bat coming. By the time you see a bat they are already out of sight. Thus is the nature of hatred. Thus is the invisible yet omnipresent sound of bigotry.</p><p>Your arms get tired from holding them up all the time, but sometimes you have no choice but to be vigilant. And if you try to see the world through the tear-filled eyes of another, don’t be surprised if what you see is your own face. Your own face staring down. Your vision interrupted by a cadence of little brown fists. The pale blue Indiana sky drifting in the background.</p><p><em>Note to readers: This story is written in the third person, but it is autobiographical. Aside from some artistic details, the story is true.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=90f1cc40c13c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Week of May 9, 2020: On This Day In SCOTUS History]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/scotus-watch/the-week-of-may-9-2020-on-this-day-in-scotus-history-776e1a9a06c5?source=rss-14e38d873f99------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/776e1a9a06c5</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[justice]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[law]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[supreme-court]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[scotus]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ronald D. Rodriguez]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 17 May 2021 03:02:58 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-06-03T07:57:39.685Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/456/1*Qun4iD_Sesac76NgY3DrOg.png" /><figcaption>Courtesy Suburban Nerd. Available on Redbubble <a href="https://rdbl.co/2RrjDFS">https://rdbl.co/2RrjDFS</a></figcaption></figure><h3>The Week of May 9, 2021: On This Day In SCOTUS History</h3><p>This week we will cover RBG’s first appearance in front of SCOTUS, marijuana distribution, trade secret vs patent laws, Congress changes a 4-factor injunction test, Benjamin Franklin’s “Join, or Die” cartoon, Standard Oil is dissolved, and discriminatory application of race neutral laws.</p><p>Cases are presented in chronological order. IRAC format used where possible.</p><p><em>Disclaimer: These cases have not been Shepardized. This article is not legal advice. Those seeking legal advice should consult an attorney. (I am an attorney, but I am not your attorney.)</em></p><h4><strong>1754, May 9</strong></h4><h3><strong>Benjamin Franklin Publishes “Join, or Die,” the First U.S. Newspaper Cartoon</strong></h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/640/1*8bAtq1STDWQVyvqR4BUPIA.jpeg" /><figcaption>1954</figcaption></figure><p>Benjamin Franklin was serving in the Pennsylvania Assembly in the early 1750s when the French and Indian War was heating up over control of the Ohio valley. Franklin saw the necessity for cooperation between the colonies, not only to resist the French but also to get Indian support in the resistance.</p><p>Unfortunately, the colonies were fiercely independent. The new world at that time was divided between Proprietary colonies, governed by private families that owned most of the unsettled land, and Royal colonies which were directly ruled by the king and his ministers. The proprietary colonies were resistant to taxation. To complicate matters, the Penn colony prioritized getting more Indian land, and the Quaker colonies were pacifists.</p><p>The Indians, meanwhile, were angry over white settlers’ unfair and dishonest trade practices (surprise!), and the settler practice of selling rum to their people. To complicate matters, the French were also courting them.</p><p>The inventive Franklin sketched out a structure for colonial cooperation, including a distribution of delegates proportional to the amount each colony paid to the general treasury, a royally appointed governor, and rotating meeting sites. Meanwhile, a young George Washington had failed in his attempt to get the French to vacate the Ohio valley.</p><p>When word of Washington’s defeat reached Philadelphia, Franklin wrote an editorial in &quot;The Pennsylvania Gazette,&quot; in which he blamed the French success on “the present disunited state of the British colonies.” Accompanying the article was a woodcut editorial cartoon of a snake cut into pieces with each piece labelled with the name of a colony. The caption was “Join, or Die.”</p><p>The cartoon would take on many forms and meanings over subsequent years, most of which Franklin did not endorse.</p><p>History provided by Walter Isaacson in <em>Benjamin Franklin: An American Life</em>.</p><h4><strong>1886, May 10</strong></h4><h3>Discriminatory Application of a Racially Neutral Statute Is Unconstitutional</h3><p><a href="https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/118/356/">Yick Wo v. Hopkins, 118 U.S. 356 (1886)</a></p><p><strong><em>Yick Wo v. Hopkins</em>,118 U.S. 356 (1886)</strong></p><p>The City and County of San Francisco enacted an ordinance requiring a permit from the board of supervisors to operate a laundry in a wooden structure. Of the 320 laundries located in the city, 310 were constructed of wood and 240 were owned by Chinese subjects. All of the 240 Chinese laundries were denied, while all but one of the remaining non-Chinese owned laundries were granted permits.</p><p>Yick Wo was a laundry facility owned by Lee Yick. He had been denied a permit despite having been approved and licensed by the board of fire wardens. He continued to operate his laundry. He was subsequently fined, and, when he refused to pay the fine, he was jailed.</p><h4><strong>Issue:</strong></h4><p>Whether the discriminatory application of a racially neutral law is unconstitutional.</p><p>An addition question was whether the protections granted in the 14th Amendment of the Constitution extend to all persons within the United States regardless of race, color, or nationality.</p><h4><strong>Rule:</strong></h4><p>14th Amendment: Guarantees due process and equal protection under the law.</p><h4><strong>Analysis/Opinion (Justice Matthews):</strong></h4><p>“[The ordinance] confers upon the municipal authorities arbitrary power, at their own will, and without regard to discretion in the legal sense of the term, to give or withhold consent as to persons or places, without regard to the competency of the persons applying, or the propriety of the place selected, for the carrying on of the business.”</p><p>The fact that permits could be granted for laundries in wooden structures, even if only among white business owners, shows that the practice itself is not necessarily dangerous.</p><p>The alleged fire hazard claimed for laundry purposes would be just as true for cooking, or for warming the house; yet, there are no similar ordinances in these situations.</p><p>The necessary tendency, if not the specific purpose, of this ordinance, and of enforcing it in the manner indicated in the record, is to drive out of business all the numerous small laundries, especially those owned by Chinese, and give a monopoly of the business to the large institutions established and carried on by means of large associated Caucasian capital.</p><p>California argued that the 14th Amendment didn’t apply to the Chinese since they were not American citizens. However, the 14th Amendment clearly declares that a State shall not “deprive any <strong><em>person</em></strong> of life, liberty, or property without due process of law; nor deny to any <strong><em>person</em></strong> within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws.&quot; The Constitution clearly does not make a distinction.</p><h4><strong>Conclusion/Holding (Unanimous):</strong></h4><p>Racially discriminatory application of a racially neutral statute violates the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment.</p><h4><strong>Personal Opinion &amp; Commentary On The Embedded Video:</strong></h4><p>The word “arbitrary” refers to decisions that are made without a legal basis. The common misconception, that “arbitrary” means “without reason” is not true. Reasons can be found in patterns of behavior. The Californians were obviously targeting the Chinese. Systemic racism always has its reasons.</p><p>The embedded video, narrated, in part, by Justice Kennedy, provides some valuable background and history to this case, but I take exception to Justice Kennedy’s much-to-forgiving characterizations. With all due respect . . .</p><p>He repeatedly couches the discrimination and brutality against the Chinese in gentle terms. The Chinese were “not too welcome” in California. Regarding the right to vote, “the Chinese didn’t have that advantage.” In defining the word “arbitrary,” he compares the U.S. favorably against Egypt and Brazil, without recognizing the difference between the bribes taken by individuals in their government, and the state-implemented systemic racism in the U.S.</p><p>He says that the principle of Yick Wo has never been questioned, yet this case was followed shortly by the concept of “separate but equal,” which runs contrary to the holding that racially discriminatory application of a racially neutral statute is unconstitutional.</p><p>Finally, he takes what strikes me as a paternalist attitude towards the Chinese. First, he repeatedly praises the Court for listening to the case of someone who <em>“wasn’t even a citizen!”</em> without acknowledging that the Naturalization Act of 1790 prohibited Chinese from becoming U.S. citizens to begin with. Then he wraps it all up by saying that “This is a gift that Yick Wo gave to us, and it’s a gift that we gave to him.” Acknowledging the rights of a Chinese immigrant was a gift that we gave to him? Allowing him access to the justice system was a gift that we gave to him? I am absolutely baffled by what he means here.</p><p>I don’t mean to pick on Justice Kennedy specifically. He is merely expressing the biases of a certain generation (born before WWII), and a certain demographic (White males) that has dominated the judiciary for half a century. Unfortunately, those biases have had a devastating impact on all variety of minority.</p><p>Having said that, the other speakers are excellent and the history is compelling.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FamRAdnJjhSo%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DamRAdnJjhSo&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FamRAdnJjhSo%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/9d410d2505200ce45809eabad81e5cb2/href">https://medium.com/media/9d410d2505200ce45809eabad81e5cb2/href</a></iframe><h4><strong>1911, May 15</strong></h4><h3><strong>Standard Oil Co. Is Dissolved For Violating the Sherman Act</strong></h3><p><strong><em>Standard Oil Co. of New Jersey v. United States</em>, 221 U.S. 1 (1911)</strong></p><p>This case involves Standard Oil Company of New Jersey and 33 other corporations as well as John D. Rockefeller, and six other individuals. “The record is inordinately voluminous, consisting of twenty-three volumes of printed matter, aggregating about twelve thousand pages, containing a vast amount of confusing and conflicting testimony relating to innumerable, complex and varied business transactions, extending over a period of nearly forty years.”</p><h4><strong>Issue:</strong></h4><p>Whether the appellant’s business practices constitute a violation of the Sherman Act and, if so, what the penalty should be.</p><h4><strong>Rule:</strong></h4><p>Sherman Antitrust Act (in pertinent part): “Every contract, combination in the form of trust or otherwise, or conspiracy, in <strong>restraint of trade</strong> or commerce, among the several States, or with foreign nations, is hereby declared to be illegal” and “Every person who shall monopolize, or <strong>attempt to monopolize</strong>, or combine or conspire with any other person or persons, to monopolize any part of the trade or commerce among the several States, or with foreign nations.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*F8E8GrWvtAGXI6MPZnPowQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Standard Oil Works, 1910. RIchmond, California.</figcaption></figure><h4><strong>Analysis/Opinion (Chief Justice White):</strong></h4><p>The Chief Justice complains and apologizes frequently throughout the opinion about how difficult and complicated the case is, using phrases such as “without going into detail,” and “it suffices to say” to indicate a severe truncating of the facts.</p><p>The first part of the grievance involved combining the stocks of various companies into a single trust. “The unification of power and control over a commodity such as petroleum and its products by combining in one corporation the stocks of many other corporations aggregating a vast capital gives rise, of itself, to the prima facie presumption of an intent and purpose to dominate the industry connected with, and gain perpetual control of the movement of, that commodity and its products in the channels of interstate commerce in violation of the Anti-Trust Act of 1890, and that presumption is made conclusive by proof of specific acts such as those in the record of this case.”</p><p>The second part of the grievance can be grouped as follows: “rebates, preferences and other discriminatory practices in favor of the combination by railroad companies; restraint and monopolization by control of pipelines, and unfair practices against competing pipelines; contracts with competitors in restraint of trade; unfair methods of competition, such as local price-cutting at the points where necessary to suppress competition; espionage of the business of competitors, the operation of bogus independent companies, and payment of rebates on oil, with the like intent; the division of the United States into districts and the limiting of the operations of the various subsidiary corporations as to such districts so that competition in the sale of petroleum products between such corporations had been entirely eliminated and destroyed, and, finally, reference was made to what was alleged to be the &quot;enormous and unreasonable profits&quot; earned by the Standard Oil Trust and the Standard Oil Company as a result of the alleged monopoly, which presumably was averred as a means of reflexly [sic] inferring the scope and power acquired by the alleged combination.”</p><p>The violations clearly fall within the interstate commerce reach of the Antitrust Act.</p><p>The remedy to be administered in case of a combination violating the Anti-Trust Act is two-fold: first, to forbid the continuance of the prohibited act, and second, to so dissolve the combination as to neutralize the force of the unlawful power.</p><p>“The constituents of an unlawful combination under the Anti-Trust Act should not be deprived of power to make normal and lawful contracts, but should be restrained from continuing or recreating the unlawful combination by any means whatever, and a dissolution of the offending combination should not deprive the constituents of the right to live under the law, but should compel them to obey it.”</p><h4><strong>Conclusion/Holding (8–1)</strong></h4><p>The Standard Oil Company conspired to restrain the trade and commerce in petroleum, and to monopolize the commerce in petroleum, in violation of the Sherman Act. The company was split and individual fines were assessed.</p><h4><strong>1973, May 14</strong></h4><h3>“All I ask of our brethren is that they take their feet off our necks.”</h3><p><a href="https://www.law.cornell.edu/supremecourt/text/411/677">Sharron A. FRONTIERO and Joseph Frontiero, Appellants, v. Elliot L. RICHARDSON, Secretary of Defense, et al.</a></p><p><strong><em>Frontiero v. Richardson</em>, 411 U.S. 677 (1973)</strong></p><p>A female lieutenant in the Air Force requested increased benefits or allowance for her husband as a dependent, in the same way that male servicemen receive dependent benefits for their wives. The Air Force required that she present proof that her husband was dependent for over one-half of their support, a requirement that did not exist for the male officers with wives. She was denied.</p><h4><strong>Issue:</strong></h4><p>Whether the difference in treatment between servicemembers based on gender constitutes an unconstitutional discrimination against servicewomen in violation of the Due Process Clause of the Fifth Amendment.</p><h4><strong>Rule:</strong></h4><p>5th Amendment, in pertinent part, says that no person shall be deprived of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law.</p><h4><strong>Analysis/Opinion (Justice Brennan):</strong></h4><p>Under &#39;traditional&#39; equal protection analysis, a legislative classification must be sustained unless it is &#39;patently arbitrary&#39; and bears no rational relationship to a legitimate governmental interest. However, classifications based on sex, race, alienage, and national origin are inherently suspect and must be subjected to close judicial scrutiny.</p><p>The discriminatory impact of the statutes is twofold: Procedurally, a female member is required to demonstrate her spouse&#39;s dependency; Substantively, a male member who does not provide more than one-half of his wife&#39;s support receives benefits, while a similarly situated female member is denied such benefits.</p><p>The government claims “administrative convenience” and a &quot;considerable saving of administrative expense and manpower&quot; as a rational basis for the policy. However, to satisfy the demands of strict judicial scrutiny, the Government would need to grant increased benefits only to those members whose wives actually met the dependency requirement, and subject those claims to a costly hearing process, rather than the simple affidavits currently required of male servicemembers. The Government&#39;s claims of costs savings, under these circumstances, is suspect.</p><h4><strong>Conclusion/Holding (8-1):</strong></h4><p>Any statutory scheme which draws a sharp line between the sexes solely for the purpose of achieving administrative convenience necessarily commands dissimilar treatment for men and women who are similarly situated and therefore involves the very kind of arbitrary legislative choice forbidden by the Constitution.</p><h4><strong>Note:</strong></h4><p>The appellant was ably represented by Joseph J. Levin, Jr., of the Southern Poverty Law Center; but this case is best known for the first ever appearance of the ACLU women’s rights advocate Ruth Bader Ginsberg in front of the Supreme Court. This embedded oral arguments includes Ginsberg’s appearance where she famously quotes the abolitionist and equal rights advocate Sarah Grimke. “She spoke, not elegantly but with unmistakable clarity. She said, ‘I ask no favor for my sex. All I ask of our brethren is that they take their feet off our necks.’”</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FBb9VG_YpOZE%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DBb9VG_YpOZE&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FBb9VG_YpOZE%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/1b739c59c2f4b7d7f33ba950e7cc7985/href">https://medium.com/media/1b739c59c2f4b7d7f33ba950e7cc7985/href</a></iframe><h4><strong>1974, May 13</strong></h4><h3><strong>State Trade Secret Laws Are Not Preempted By Federal Patent Law</strong></h3><p><a href="https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/416/470/">Kewanee Oil Co. v. Bicron Corp., 416 U.S. 470 (1974)</a></p><p><strong><em>Kewanee Oil Co. v. Bicron Corp.</em>, 416 U.S. 470 (1974)</strong></p><p>Petitioner, over a period of years, developed a process of growing and encapsulating synthetic crystals for industrial purposes. Former employees, who had signed nondisclosure agreements while at petitioner company, were hired by a competitor who, subsequently, was able to perform the same synthetic crystal process. Respondent was subsequently subject to a permanent injunction under the state’s trade secret law.</p><h4><strong>Issue:</strong></h4><p>Whether state trade secret law is preempted by federal patent law.</p><h4><strong>Rule:</strong></h4><p>The definition of trade secret under Ohio law is that “[a] trade secret may consist of any formula, pattern, device or compilation of information which is used in one&#39;s business, and which gives him an opportunity to obtain an advantage over competitors who do not know or use it. It may be a formula for a chemical compound, a process of manufacturing, treating or preserving materials, a pattern for a machine or other device, or a list of customers.&quot; This necessary element of secrecy is not lost, however, if the holder of the trade secret reveals the trade secret to another &quot;in confidence, and under an implied obligation not to use or disclose it.&quot; The law also protects disclosure by improper means. It does not, however, prohibit discovery by fair and honest means, or by reverse engineering.</p><p>A patent, on the other hand, under federal patent law, is limited to a &quot;process, machine, manufacture, or composition of matter, or . . . improvement thereof,&quot; which fulfills the three conditions of novelty, utility and non-obviousness. If an invention meets the rigorous statutory tests for the issuance of a patent, the patent is granted, for a period of 17 years, giving what has been described as the &quot;right of exclusion.&quot;</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*78iB41FTQxu3y3lHGmC5EQ.png" /><figcaption>Cue the James Bond music.</figcaption></figure><h4><strong>Analysis/Opinion (Chief Justice Burger):</strong></h4><p>Trade secret law protects items which would not be proper subjects for consideration for patent protection. States are free to provide protection for their own citizens so long as they do not conflict with federal laws.</p><p>Trade secret law is weaker than patent law and thus could not usurp it. Trade secret law does not forbid the discovery of the trade secret by fair and honest means, such as independent creation or even reverse engineering. Patent law, on the other hand, operates &quot;against the world,&quot; forbidding any use of the invention for whatever purpose for a significant length of time. Since novelty is not required, the passing on of trade secrets through theft or breach of confidence would be difficult to prove in discovery.</p><p>The policy that matter once in the public domain must remain in the public domain is not incompatible with the existence of trade secret protection. By definition, a trade secret has not been placed in the public domain.</p><p>Society itself faces no risk from trade secret law to the stated goal of encouraging invention, especially as it pertains to scientific or technological progress, since the ripeness-of-time concept of invention demonstrates that discoveries tend to happen when the time is right, and that multiple independent parties tend to make the same discovery at the same time.</p><h4><strong>Conclusion/Holding (6-2):</strong></h4><p>The federal patent policy of encouraging invention is not disturbed by the existence of another form of incentive to invent. Ohio’s trade secret law is not preempted by the federal patent laws.</p><h4>2001, May 14</h4><h3>There Is No Medical Necessity Exception for Marijuana.</h3><p><a href="https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/532/483/">United States v. Oakland Cannabis Buyers&#39; Cooperative, 532 U.S. 483 (2001)</a></p><p><strong><em>United States v. Oakland Cannabis Buyers&#39; Cooperative</em>, 532 U.S. 483 (2001)</strong></p><p>A cooperative was formed to distribute marijuana to qualified patients for medical purposes. They were charged with violating the Controlled Substance Act which prohibits distributing, manufacturing, and processing with the intent to distribute or manufacture a controlled substance.</p><p>The District Court enjoined the Cooperative’s activities and found them in contempt when they didn’t abide. The Ninth Circuit reversed on the grounds that medical necessity is a legally cognizable defense and that the District Court should have weighed the public interest and factors such as the serious harm in depriving patients.</p><h4><strong>Issue:</strong></h4><p>Whether there is a medical necessity exception for marijuana under the Controlled Substance Act.</p><h4><strong>Rule:</strong></h4><p>Marijuana is classified as a schedule I controlled substance. There is only one exception to the prohibition for schedule I substances: Government-approved research projects.</p><h4><strong>Analysis/Opinion (Justice Thomas):</strong></h4><p>A defense cannot succeed when the legislature itself has already written a contrary determination into law. Congress determined marijuana to be a schedule I drug without exceptions for medical necessity.</p><p>“This Court is unwilling to view that omission as an accident and is unable, in any event, to override a legislative determination manifest in the statute.”</p><p>Courts in equity cannot ignore Congress’ judgment expressed in legislation.</p><h4><strong>Conclusion/Holding (8-0):</strong></h4><p>There is no medical necessity defense to a charge under the Controlled Substances Act.</p><p>Note: This case dealt specifically with the rights of a medical coop, or other entity, to distribute, manufacture, and process a substance with the intent to distribute or manufacture as stated in the Act. It did not address whether there was a medical exception for individual use.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FH0y5qz9xk78%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DH0y5qz9xk78&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FH0y5qz9xk78%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/204d29fa07b1599084d2748aecdede79/href">https://medium.com/media/204d29fa07b1599084d2748aecdede79/href</a></iframe><h4><strong>2006, May 15</strong></h4><h3><strong>SCOTUS Scolds Appellate for Not Applying Traditional 4-Factor Test</strong></h3><p><a href="https://www.law.cornell.edu/supremecourt/text/05-130">547 U.S. 388</a></p><p><strong><em>eBay Inc. v. MercExchange, L. L. C.</em>, 547 U.S. 388 (2006) May 15</strong></p><h4><strong>Issue:</strong></h4><p>A subsidiary of Ebay, the web site for private sellers, used an electronic market platform that had already been patented by respondent. Respondent MercExchange, L. L. C., tried to license its patent to Ebay, but the agreement fell through. Respondent subsequently sued Ebay for patent infringement.</p><p>Jury found that respondent’s patent was valid and ordered petitioner Ebay to pay. Respondent then moved for permanent injunctive relief. The District Court granted the injunction but the Court of Appeals reversed, applying its “general rule that courts will issue permanent injunctions against patent infringement absent exceptional circumstances.”</p><h4><strong>Rule:</strong></h4><p>The four-factor test for permanent injunctive relief requires a plaintiff to demonstrate: (1) that it has suffered an irreparable injury; (2) that remedies available at law are inadequate to compensate for that injury; (3) that considering the balance of hardships between the plaintiff and defendant, a remedy in equity is warranted; and (4) that the public interest would not be disserved by a permanent injunction.</p><h4><strong>Analysis/Opinion (Justice Thomas):</strong></h4><p>Nothing in the Patent Act indicates that Congress intended a departure from the well-established four-factor test traditionally used for permanent injunction.</p><p>True, patent and copyright holders possess “the right to exclude others from using his property,” but the creation of a right is distinct from the provision of remedies for violations of that right. In fact, the Patent Act expressly provides that injunctions “may” issue “in accordance with the principles of equity.”</p><p>“Although the District Court recited the traditional four-factor test, it appeared to adopt certain expansive principles suggesting that injunctive relief could not issue in a broad swath of cases. Most notably, it concluded that a “plaintiff&#39;s willingness to license its patents” and “its lack of commercial activity in practicing the patents” would be sufficient to establish that the patent holder would not suffer irreparable harm if an injunction did not issue. But traditional equitable principles do not permit such broad classifications….”</p><p>In reversing the District Court, the Court of Appeals departed in the opposite direction from the four-factor test. The court articulated a “general rule,” unique to patent disputes, “that a permanent injunction will issue once infringement and validity have been adjudged.” The court further indicated that injunctions should be denied only in the “unusual” case, under “exceptional circumstances” and “in rare instances . . . to protect the public interest.”</p><h4><strong>Conclusion/Holding: (8-0):</strong></h4><p>The traditional four-factor test applied by courts of equity when considering whether to award permanent injunctive relief to a prevailing plaintiff applies to disputes arising under the Patent Act.</p><p>“Because we conclude that neither court below correctly applied the traditional four-factor framework that governs the award of injunctive relief, we vacate the judgment of the Court of Appeals, so that the District Court may apply that framework in the first instance. In doing so, we take no position on whether permanent injunctive relief should or should not issue in this particular case, or indeed in any number of other disputes arising under the Patent Act. We hold only that the decision whether to grant or deny injunctive relief rests within the equitable discretion of the district courts, and that such discretion must be exercised consistent with traditional principles of equity, in patent disputes no less than in other cases governed by such standards.”</p><h4>Update — The Trademark Modernization Act of 2020:</h4><p>On December 27, 2020, Congress passed the Trademark Modernization Act of 2020, to be implemented December 27, 2021. Among other things, the Act clarifies the analysis necessary when considering a permanent injunction for trademark infringement, and, in so doing, addresses the circuit split that gave rise to this case. Section 226 of the Act amends the 1946 Act by inserting the following: “A plaintiff seeking any such injunction shall be entitled to a rebuttable presumption of irreparable harm upon a finding of a violation identified in this subsection in the case of a motion for a permanent injunction or upon a finding of likelihood of success on the merits for a violation identified in this subsection in the case of a motion for a preliminary injunction or temporary restraining order.” (I have updated the Wikipedia page for this case accordingly.)</p><p><strong>MAHALO MUCHO!!!</strong></p><p><strong>If you enjoyed this article please follow and comment.</strong></p><p>You can also find me on most social media platforms under the handle <strong>ronman63</strong> and on LinkedIn at <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/ronalddrodriguez/"><strong>https://www.linkedin.com/in/ronalddrodriguez/</strong></a><strong> </strong>.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=776e1a9a06c5" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/scotus-watch/the-week-of-may-9-2020-on-this-day-in-scotus-history-776e1a9a06c5">The Week of May 9, 2020: On This Day In SCOTUS History</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/scotus-watch">SCOTUS Watch</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Week of May 1, 2021: On This Day In SCOTUS History]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/scotus-watch/the-week-of-may-1-2021-on-this-day-in-scotus-history-bdcd9458699a?source=rss-14e38d873f99------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/bdcd9458699a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[scotus]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[law]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[supreme-court]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[justice]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ronald D. Rodriguez]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 08 May 2021 09:05:20 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-09-15T06:59:27.125Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*gkGhHlshMRd2pzZpzM2Q3Q.jpeg" /><figcaption>Does anybody recognize this? Answer revealed in the article.</figcaption></figure><h3>The Week of May 2, 2021: On This Day In SCOTUS History</h3><p>This week we will cover nonconsensual eugenic sterilization, restrictive covenants against Blacks and Asians, ratification of the 13th Amendment (really?) and the 27th Amendment (great story!), and the disbarment of Spiro T. Agnew. There are lots of really good embedded videos in this one (especially that last one).</p><p>Cases are presented in chronological order. IRAC format used where possible.</p><p><em>Disclaimer: These cases have not been Shepardized. This article is not legal advice. Those seeking legal advice should consult an attorney. (I am an attorney, but I am not your attorney.)</em></p><h4>1865, May 5</h4><h3>The 13th Amendment Is Ratified, Abolishing Slavery, Sort of.</h3><p>The Emancipation Proclamation took effect in 1863, in the middle of the Civil War. The Proclamation added oil to the fire of the war, changing it from a fight to preserve the Union to a fight to end slavery (or to preserve slavery if you were a Confederate). One huge benefit of the Proclamation (a strategically sly benefit, perhaps), was that it led to the volunteer enlistment of thousands of Blacks to the war effort.</p><p>Still, a proclamation is not a law. It would take a constitutional amendment to abolish slavery permanently. It took a couple of tries before Congress finally passed the amendment for submission the the states. President Lincoln was assassinated on April 14, 1865, less than a month from its ratification.</p><h4>The Fourteenth Amendment:</h4><blockquote>Neither slavery nor involuntary servitude, except as a punishment for crime whereof the party shall have been duly convicted, shall exist within the United States, or any place subject to their jurisdiction.</blockquote><p>The “except as a punishment for crime” bit has gotten a lot of attention lately as proof that slavery has not died. The grossly disproportionate incarceration of African Americans is directly related to a business model that calls for the exploitation of these prisoners, at artificially deflated labor costs, to benefit the partnership of the for-profit prison industrial complex and American corporations. Coincidence?</p><p>I highly recommend the <strong>Netflix Documentary “13th Amendment.”</strong> If you do not have a Netflix account . . . I would tell you that somebody has posted it on YouTube, but I’m guessing she doesn’t have the rights, so you didn’t hear that from me.</p><h4>1915, May6</h4><h3>Babe Ruth Hits His First Major League Home Run</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/640/1*mp206wzO0YebqHve6_wXMg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Babe Ruth as a young buck in 1919.</figcaption></figure><p>Babe Ruth began his major league career in July, 1914, as a pitcher with the Boston Red Sox. He pitched 12 1/3 innings against the New York Yankees the day he hit his first home run — in the third inning, into the second tier of the right field grandstands. Home runs were still rare at the time, so the papers were effusive.</p><p>Ruth would go on to established many MLB batting records:</p><ul><li>career home runs (714)</li><li>runs batted in (RBIs) (2,213)</li><li>bases on balls (2,062)</li><li>slugging percentage (.690) (Still Stands)</li><li>and on-base plus slugging (OPS) (1.164) (Still Stands)</li></ul><p><strong>Offering this as a reminder that for every great achievement, there is always a first. You have to start somewhere. Trust the process, and keep grinding.</strong></p><h4>1927, May 2</h4><h3>The Court Legalizes Forced Sterilization for the Feeble-Minded</h3><p><a href="https://www.law.cornell.edu/supremecourt/text/274/200">BUCK v. BELL, Superintendent of State Colony Epileptics and Feeble Minded.</a></p><p><strong><em>Buck v. Bell</em>, 247 U.S. 200 (1927)</strong></p><p>Carrie Buck, 18 years old, and her mother Emma Buck, 52, lived at the Virginia State Colony for Epileptics and Feebleminded. The Colony superintendent ordered that Carrie should be sterilized because she was feeble-minded and promiscuous, like her mother.</p><h4>Issue:</h4><p>Whether forced sterilization (salpingectomy) violates the due process and equal protection of the laws through the Fifth and Fourteenth Amendments.</p><h4>Rule:</h4><p>Fourth Amendment (in pertinent part): “No person shall . . . be deprived of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law[.]”</p><p>Fourteenth Amendment (in pertinent part): “[N]or shall any state deprive any person of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law; or deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws.”</p><h4>Analysis (Opinion Justice Holmes):</h4><ul><li>“[H]eredity plays an important part in the transmission of insanity, imbecility, etc.”</li><li>The procedure is painless and carries no substantial danger to life.</li><li>The health of the patient and the welfare of society could be promoted.</li></ul><p>The Court opinion is short and there isn’t a lot to analyze, but it has it’s quotable moments.</p><blockquote>It is better for all the world, if instead of waiting to execute degenerate offspring for crime, or to let them starve for their imbecility, society can prevent those who are manifestly unfit from continuing their kind.</blockquote><h4>Conclusion/Holding</h4><p>Eugenics is a good thing, right? j/k By the way, this opinion WAS NEVER OVERTURNED! (It’s still law.).</p><p>Carrie Buck’s backstory is messed up to say the least. (For starters, she was not feeble-minded, but was put away to hide a rape by her foster mother’s nephew.) Fortunately, my favorite, dry-witted Supreme Court analyst, Mr. Beat, created a 7-minute video of these details. Definitely worth the watch.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2Fyx0jKEJIu-c%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3Dyx0jKEJIu-c&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2Fyx0jKEJIu-c%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/c271c8f911d74e0fda38e180bac51d0e/href">https://medium.com/media/c271c8f911d74e0fda38e180bac51d0e/href</a></iframe><p>Justice Holmes was not alone. I am including here a link to a video from PBS’s American Experience Series on The Eugenics Crusade, which briefly covers the Buck case while delving more deeply into the eugenics trend in the United States and worldwide.</p><p><a href="https://www.pbs.org/video/the-eugenics-crusade-jtaetc/">American Experience | The Eugenics Crusade | Season 30 | Episode 11</a></p><h4>1948, May 3</h4><h3>The Court Strikes Down Racially Restrictive Housing Covenants</h3><p><a href="https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/334/1/#tab-opinion-1939375">Shelley v. Kraemer, 334 U.S. 1 (1948)</a></p><p><strong><em>Shelley v. Kraemer</em>, 334 U.S. 1 (1948)</strong></p><p>An African-American family purchased a house in St. Louis. In this particular neighborhood, 30 out of 39 homeowners had signed a restrictive covenant (condition precedent) that the property should not be occupied, in whole or in part, <em>“by anybody not of the Caucasian race,”</em> and specifically called out for exclusion <em>“people of the Negro or Mongolian Race.”</em> This house was one of them.</p><h4>Issue:</h4><p>Whether the equal protection clause of the Fourteenth Amendment inhibits judicial enforcement by state courts of restrictive covenants based on race or color.</p><h4>Rule:</h4><p>Fourteenth Amendment (in pertinent part): <em>“[N]or shall any state deprive any person of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law; or deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws.”</em></p><p>The Civil Rights Act of 1866 provides: <em>“All citizens of the United States shall have the same right, in every State and Territory, as is enjoyed by white citizens thereof to inherit, purchase, lease, sell, hold, and convey real and personal property.”</em></p><p>Restrictive covenants are clauses that impose restraints on the use of land. (By contrast, an affirmative covenant would impose obligations or duties upon the landowner.) Such private agreements, standing alone, do not violate any rights guaranteed under the 14th Amendment.</p><h4>Analysis (Opinion Chief Justice Vinson):</h4><p><em>Private agreements</em> to exclude persons of designated race or color from the use or occupancy of real estate for residential purposes do not violate the Fourteenth Amendment, but a <em>state court’s enforcement</em> of those agreements would be a violation of the equal protection clause.</p><p>Respondents claimed that the judicial enforcement of the private agreement was so attenuated as not to amount to state action within the meaning of the 14th Amendment. But, it was determined in the Civil Rights Cases (1883) that <em>“State action of every kind”</em> including <em>“State authority in the shape of laws, customs, or judicial or executive proceedings”</em> which are inconsistent with the equal protection clause are void.</p><p>“The owners of the properties were willing sellers, and contracts of sale were accordingly consummated. It is clear that, but for the active intervention of the state courts, supported by the full panoply of state power, petitioners would have been free to occupy the properties in question without restraint.”</p><p>The State made available “the full coercive power of government to deny petitioners on the grounds of race or color[.]”</p><p>There is no merit in the argument that the racist property owners are denied equal protection of the laws if denied access to the courts to enforce the terms of these covenants. “The Constitution confers upon no individual the right to demand action by the State which results in the denial of equal protection of the laws to other individuals.” And the State must act within the boundaries of the 14th Amendment.</p><h4>Conclusion/Holding:</h4><p>Enforcement of the covenant is reversed.</p><p>Can you say “systemic racism”? I knew you could.</p><p>Please enjoy this delightful 2-minute video that includes a brief interview with the daughter of a black realter involved in the Shelley case. Also shows footage of St. Louis and of the Shelley’s house at that time.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FfvsEahWKgNo&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DfvsEahWKgNo&amp;image=http%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FfvsEahWKgNo%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/8ecf578de629f8892fdac30223dd575a/href">https://medium.com/media/8ecf578de629f8892fdac30223dd575a/href</a></iframe><h4>1974, May 2</h4><h3>Former VP Spiro Agnew Is Disbarred in the State of Maryland</h3><p>The Maryland Court of Appeals unanimously disbarred former Vice President Spiro T. Agnew for tax evasion while he was serving as Governor of Maryland. Attorneys are held to a higher standard which extends to private matters.</p><p>According to a <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/1974/05/04/archives/disbarment.html">New York Times article</a> at the time, Agnew pled no contest to the charge but asked for a suspension instead of debarment, claiming that his positions of high public trust be ignored. Yet, it was precisely because he was VP that he was able to escape more serious penalties. His successor as Baltimore County Executive, who was convicted of similar charges, was sentence to five years in prison. Agnew escaped with a $10,000 fine and three years of unsupervised probation.</p><h4>1992, May 7</h4><h3>The 27th Amendment Is Ratified After 203 Years</h3><p>The amendment that would eventually become the 27th Amendment was submitted to the 1st Congress by James Madison among the collection of amendments that, whittled down to ten, became the Bill of Rights.</p><p>The 27th Amendment Reads: <em>No law, varying the compensation for the services of the Senators and Representatives, shall take effect, until an election of Representatives shall have intervened.</em></p><p>In other words: <strong>When members of Congress want to give themselves a pay raise, they must wait until the next election has intervened before the pay raise takes effect.</strong></p><p>So, how did this 1789 amendment get ratified in 1992?</p><p>In 1982, a 19-year-old sophomore at the University of Texas at Austin, name Gregory Watson, wrote a paper for a government class in which he claimed that the amendment could still be ratified. The professor gave him a “C”.</p><p>So what did he do? He went <em>BEAST MODE!</em></p><p>He got it RATIFIED!</p><p>Check out this surprisingly popular 6-minute minute video, including an interview with Gregory Watson himself. <em>The Beast!</em></p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2Ff8IUbYsd3y0%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3Df8IUbYsd3y0&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2Ff8IUbYsd3y0%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/e19cf947877ce4cf242223789d0487cf/href">https://medium.com/media/e19cf947877ce4cf242223789d0487cf/href</a></iframe><h4>1995, May 1</h4><h3>Interstate Commerce Clarified for RICO Charges</h3><p><a href="https://www.law.cornell.edu/supremecourt/text/514/669">UNITED STATES, Petitioner v. Juan Paul ROBERTSON.</a></p><p><strong><em>United States v. Robertson</em>, 514 U.S. 669 (1995)</strong></p><p>The opinion in this case is four paragraphs long. Respondent invested in an Alaska gold mine using proceeds from his illegal narcotics activities.</p><h4>Issue:</h4><p>Whether the activities of the gold mine “affected” interstate commerce.</p><h4>Rule:</h4><p>Racketeering is the act of acquiring or controlling a business through certain crimes or income from those crimes. It’s often associated with extortion.</p><p>RICO (Racketeering Influenced and Corrupt Organizations Act) prohibits the use or investment of the proceeds of racketeering acts to acquire, establish or operate an enterprise which engages in or affects interstate commerce. It was ultimately designed to address the infiltration of legitimate enterprises by organized crime and other illegal ventures.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2Fo8_f3kJOX_8%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3Do8_f3kJOX_8&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2Fo8_f3kJOX_8%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="640" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/eff7343bcf98710f5e5233a77254f3c9/href">https://medium.com/media/eff7343bcf98710f5e5233a77254f3c9/href</a></iframe><h4>Analysis (Opinion Per Curiam):</h4><p>The Court of Appeals concluded that the Government had failed to introduce sufficient evidence that the gold mine (the RICO “enterprise”) was “engaged in or affect[ed] interstate commerce.”</p><p>Respondent’s activities included buying mining equipment in Los Angeles and shipping to Alaska, hiring and paying the expenses of out-of-state employees to travel to Alaska to work, and shipping gold out of the state.</p><p><em>“Whether or not these activities met … the requirement of substantially affecting interstate commerce, they assuredly brought the gold mine within [RICO’s] alternative criterion of “any enterprise . . . engaged in . . . interstate or foreign commerce,”</em> which includes being <em>“directly engaged in the production, distribution, or acquisition of goods and services in interstate commerce.”</em></p><h4>Held:</h4><p>Respondent’s gold mine comes within reach of the</p><p><strong>MAHALO MUCHO!!!</strong></p><p><strong>If you enjoyed this article please follow and comment.</strong></p><p>You can also find me on most social media platforms under the handle <strong>ronman63</strong> and on LinkedIn at <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/ronalddrodriguez/"><strong>https://www.linkedin.com/in/ronalddrodriguez/</strong></a><strong> </strong>.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=bdcd9458699a" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/scotus-watch/the-week-of-may-1-2021-on-this-day-in-scotus-history-bdcd9458699a">The Week of May 1, 2021: On This Day In SCOTUS History</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/scotus-watch">SCOTUS Watch</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Week of April 25, 2021: On This Day In SCOTUS History]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/scotus-watch/the-week-of-april-25-2021-on-this-day-in-scotus-history-2f161325628c?source=rss-14e38d873f99------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2f161325628c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[justice]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[scotus]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[law]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[supreme-court]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ronald D. Rodriguez]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 02 May 2021 07:43:12 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-06-09T08:14:55.249Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*K5CtAG7l5-eEnyvysqLNhA.png" /><figcaption>The weirdest picture of a Newfoundland I could find.</figcaption></figure><p>This week we will cover the Erie Doctrine, the first U.S. greenbacks, an entrapment case where the gov’t provided the illegal drugs, guns on campus and the commerce clause, eliminating jurors based on race, and the value of a dog.</p><p>Cases are presented in chronological order. IRAC format used where possible.</p><p><em>Disclaimer: These cases have not been Shepardized. This article is not legal advice. Those seeking legal advice should consult an attorney.</em></p><h4>1871, May 1</h4><h3>Legal Tender Cases — Necessary &amp; Proper Clause</h3><p><a href="https://www.law.cornell.edu/supremecourt/text/79/457">LEGAL TENDER CASES. KNOX v. LEE. PARKER v. DAVIS.</a></p><p><strong><em>Knox v. Lee</em></strong>, 79 U.S. 457 (1871)</p><h4>Facts:</h4><p>In 1862, the U.S. Congress passes the Legal Tender Act, authorizing the use of paper notes to pay the government’s bills — specifically, it’s costly Civil War debts. This was deemed necessary after its gold and silver reserves, used for specie or coin, were depleted.</p><p>In <em>Hepburn v. Griswold</em>, 75 U.S. 603 (1870), the Supreme Court ruled that the Legal Tender Act was unconstitutional. Only a year later, in <em>Knox v. Lee </em>(known as the Legal Tender Cases), the Court took up the issue again.</p><h4>Issue:</h4><p>Whether Congress has the power to authorized paper notes.</p><h4>Rule:</h4><p>The Constitution, Article I, Section 8, Clause 5: Congress has the power “to coin Money, regulate the Value thereof, and of foreign Coin, and fix the Standard of Weights and Measures.”</p><p>The Constitution, Article I, Section 8, Clause 18: Congress shall have the power “to make all Laws which shall be necessary and proper for carrying into Execution the foregoing Powers, and all other Powers vested by this Constitution in the Government of the United States, or in any Department or Officer thereof.” The authorized use of paper money was considered “necessary and proper</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*VGsW_qbw2kCpUlUlL1mZCQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>The first Greenback. $1, featuring U.S. Treasurer Salmon P. Chase, who helped finance the Civil War. Chase led design of the bill and chose his own portrait.</figcaption></figure><h4>Analysis (Justice Strong):</h4><p>The Constitution gives Congress the power to, specifically, coin money. It was determined that this power does not include issuing greenbacks, because a coin holds the intrinsic value of the metal it was minted from, while a greenback does not. A treasury note, or a promissory note, would not qualify under Clause 18.</p><p>However, over time the relation in value was lost such that the equivalent value of gold did not match the equivalent value of silver. As gold became scarce, it’s intrinsic value went up relative to silver, then when gold became plentiful during the gold rush, the intrinsic value of gold decreased relative to silver. Congress, thus, made efforts to bring the value of the coins in line with their intrinsic value.</p><p>As with other cultures where coins may become worn down to a lesser weight, or where coins may have holes in them, the <em>portability and convenience</em> of the legal tender made up for what they lacked in intrinsic value.</p><p>The opinion goes on to quote Chief Justice Marshall regarding the necessary and proper clause: “‘Let the end be legitimate; let it be within the scope of the Constitution, and all the means which are appropriate, which are plainly adapted to that end, and which are not prohibited, but consist with the letter and spirit of the Constitution, are constitutional.’”</p><p>The question then is whether it is necessary and proper “that treasury notes should be made a legal tender for antecedent debts. Is it appropriate and plainly adapted to the power to borrow money, to regulate commerce, to raise and support armies, to provide and maintain a navy, to suppress insurrections or repel invasions, or even to any of these powers united?”</p><p>The opinion then goes on an extended exploration, ad infinitum, of the words “necessary” and “proper” in turn, framed around the arguments in <em>Hepburn v. Griswold.</em></p><h4>Held:</h4><p><em>Hepburn v. Griswold</em> is reversed and the Legal Tender Act is Constitutional.</p><p>Note: The Supreme Court’s reversal, from one year to the next, was possible due to a radical shifting of the court. You will often see the story of that shift when researching this case. There was enough to focus on here without that.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Nd8rfYZRmziAJw6pQYdyqQ.png" /></figure><h4>1897, April 26</h4><h3>Dogs as Property</h3><p><a href="https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/166/698/">Sentell v. New Orleans &amp; Carrollton R. Co., 166 U.S. 698 (1897)</a></p><p><strong><em>Sentell v. New Orleans &amp; Carrollton R. Co.</em></strong>, 166 U.S. 698 (1897)</p><h4>Facts:</h4><p>A pregnant and “valuable Newfoundland bitch, registered in the American Kennel’s stud book” was killed by an oncoming electric train (trolley). The owner sued the railroad company for negligence, claiming the value of the dog. The railroad countered by claiming owner negligence, and that they owe him nothing in any case since he did not register the dog.</p><h4>Issue:</h4><p>Whether a law of the state of Louisiana requiring dogs to be placed upon the assessment rolls, and limiting any recovery by the owner to the value fixed by himself for the purpose of taxation is constitutional under 14th Amendment due process.</p><h4>Rule:</h4><p>Dogs owned by citizens of Louisiana a) are personal property, b) shall be entitled to protection of the law only if placed upon the assessment roles, and c) in civil action, the owner cannot recover beyond the amount of the value of the dog as the owner declared in the assessment.</p><h4>Analysis:</h4><p>Unlike horses, cattle, sheep, and other domesticated animals, dogs have no intrinsic value. They are not useful as beasts of burden, do not provide drink and are not converted to food. They are “kept for pleasure, curiosity, or caprice,” just as are cats and birds. They can be feral or domesticated. It’s nearly impossible to distinguish the value or worthlessness, for purposes of statute, from one breed of dog to another.</p><p>The Opinion goes on to cite laws upheld throughout the country that allows the licensing of dog and the killing of uncollared dogs. This falls under legitimate government powers to raise revenue (tax), and under police powers to protect the health, safety and welfare of the community.</p><h4>Held:</h4><p>There is nothing in this law that is not within the police power, or of which the plaintiff has the right to complain, and the judgment of the court of appeals is therefore affirmed. As such, since the plaintiff did not register his dog, he was not entitled to recovery.</p><h4>1938, April 25</h4><h3>The Erie Doctrin: Limits on the Federal Court’s Power in Diversity Jurisdiction</h3><p><a href="https://www.law.cornell.edu/supremecourt/text/304/64">ERIE R. CO. v. TOMPKINS.</a></p><p><strong><em>Erie Railroad Co. v. Tompkins</em>, 304 U.S. 64 (1938)</strong></p><p>This is a famous case that makes up the standard law school civil procedure curriculum (although, my law school chose to skip it — understandable given the amount of ground that needs to be covered in civ pro).</p><h4>Facts:</h4><p>(Another railroad accident!) Tompkins was struck by what seems to have been an open door from a passing freight train has he walked a well-worn path along the tracks. He sued the Erie Railroad Co. for negligence. Erie cited Pennsylvania law that said that people travelling long these paths are trespassers.</p><h4>Issue:</h4><p>When a federal court sits in diversity jurisdiction, what law does it apply: state or federal?</p><h4>Rule:</h4><p>Rules of Decision Act (in pertinent part): The laws of the several states, except where the Constitution on Acts of Congress otherwise require or provide, shall be regarded as rule of decisions in civil action, in the courts of the United States, in cases where they apply.</p><p><em>Swift v. Tyson</em>, 41 U.S. 1 (1841): Interpreted “the laws of the several states” in the Rules of Decision Act to mean legislative acts. As such, the federal courts exercising jurisdiction on the grounds of diversity of citizenship need not, in matters of general jurisprudence, apply the unwritten law of the State as declared by its highest court (i.e. case law).</p><h4>Analysis (Justice Brandeis):</h4><p><em>Swift v. Tyson</em> had failed in a number of ways. 1) The Rules of Decision Act was misinterpreted in Swift. 2) Contrary to the stated goal of providing equal protection through uniformity of law throughout the country, Swift actually prevented uniformity in administration of the law of the state. 3) Whether the law of the state shall be by statute or by court is not of federal concern — interference of either, except as permitted, is an invasion.</p><h4>Held:</h4><p>The Circuit Court of Appeals errored in ruling that the question of liability was one of general law and, as such, declined to enforce State common law. Reversed and remanded.</p><p>This holding reversed nearly one hundred years of precedent and would be known as the Erie Doctrine.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/736/1*fQgcYz2cybUzcgNxdPvN6Q.jpeg" /><figcaption>1938 Erie Locomotive. Courtesy Glen Rock Historical Society.</figcaption></figure><h4>1965, April 26</h4><h3>Refinement of Erie Doctrine’s Diversity Jurisdiction</h3><p><a href="https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/380/460/">Hanna v. Plumer, 380 U.S. 460 (1965)</a></p><p><strong><em>Hanna v. Plumer</em>, 380 U.S. 460 (1965)</strong></p><p>Twenty-seven years after Erie, the Court revisited the question of diversity jurisdiction.</p><h4>Facts:</h4><p>Mrs. Louise Plumer Osgood, a citizen of Massachusetts, injured a citizen of Ohio in a car accident in South Carolina. Mrs. Osgood was deceased at the time of filing (from the accident?) so the respondent in this case was the executor. Service was made to the executor’s wife at the executor’s home. The service to the executor’s wife was in compliance with federal law but not Massachusetts state law.</p><h4>Issue:</h4><p>Whether, in a civil action involving diversity of citizenship between parties, service of process shall be made in the manner prescribed by state law or that set forth in the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure.</p><h4>Rule:</h4><p>The Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, Rule 4(e)(2)(B), in pertinent part, allows for the the summons and complaint to be left with a competent adult at the residence of any defendant.</p><p>The Massachusetts General Laws (Ter.Ed.) Chapter 197, Section 9, in pertinent part, requires service to be hand delivered upon the executor or administrator and accepted by him.</p><p>According to the Enabling Act, 28 U.S.C. § 2072 (1958 ed.), “The Supreme Court shall have the power to prescribe, by general rules, the forms of process, writs, pleadings, and motions, and the practice and procedure of the district courts of the United States in civil actions.” “Such rules shall not abridge, enlarge or modify any substantive right, and shall preserve the right of trial by jury. . . .”</p><h4>Analysis (Chief Justice Warren):</h4><p>The Court drew a distinction between substantive laws and non-substantive or procedural rules as regards diversity jurisdiction.</p><p>Non-substantial rules are not likely to raise the sort of equal protection issues that troubled the Court in Erie. They are also not likely to influence the choice of forum.</p><p>“Erie and its offspring cast no doubt on the long-recognized power of Congress to prescribe housekeeping rules for federal courts even though some of those rules will inevitably differ from comparable state rules.”</p><h4>Held:</h4><p>Congress’s attempt to exercise the power outlined in the Enabling Act is valid, and thus applied to this case.</p><p>Note: Whereas Erie was a Constitutional issue, Hanna is one of statutory construction. What does the statute tell the federal courts to do? The Rules, it can be argued, are not themselves statutes but statute-like rules.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*EeCStcGEDvdvrxDGoLg8hQ.png" /><figcaption>NOOOO! Not HEROINE, HEROIN!!!</figcaption></figure><h4>1976, April 27</h4><h3>Entrapment Case Where the Government Supplied All the Drugs</h3><p><a href="https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/425/484/">Hampton v. United States, 425 U.S. 484 (1976)</a></p><p><strong><em>Hampton v. United States</em>, 425 U.S. 484 (1976)</strong></p><p>Some of you might remember from the “Week of April 18” edition of “On This Day” the case <em>United States v. Russell</em>, a 1973 entrapment case where the court made the distinction between entrapping an unwary innocent and an unwary criminal. <em>Hampton </em>takes place three years later.</p><h4>Facts:</h4><p>Petitioner sold heroin to an undercover DEA agent. According to petitioner, a) the drugs were provided by a DEA informant to sell to a DEA agent, b) he was told by the DEA informant that it was a nonnarcotic counterfeit drug, not the real thing.</p><p>The jury was instructed that in order to convict the Government needs to prove “that the defendant knowingly did an act which the law forbids, purposely intending to violate the law.” The jury found him guilty.</p><p>Petitioner argues that the jury should have been instructed that they must acquit him if it’s found that the government supplied the drugs.</p><h4>Issue:</h4><p>Whether a defendant may be convicted for the sale of a contraband which he procured from a government informer or agent.</p><h4>Rule:</h4><p>Under <em>Russell</em>, the statutory defense of entrapment is not available where the defendant had the established intent or predisposition to commit the crime, even where the government supplied a necessary ingredient in the manufacture of an illegal substance.</p><h4>Analysis (Justice Rehnquist):</h4><p>The difference between this case and <em>Russell </em>is one of degree not of kind.</p><p>“The limitations of the Due Process Clause of the Fifth Amendment come into play only when the Government activity in question violates some protected right of the defendant.”</p><p>Here, the police, the Government informant, and the defendant acted in concert with one another. “[T]he government did not implant in the mind of an innocent person the disposition to commit the alleged offence and induce its commission.”</p><p>“If the police engage in illegal activity in concert with a defendant beyond the scope of their duties the remedy lies not in freeing the equally culpable defendant, but in prosecuting the police under the applicable provisions of state or federal law.”</p><h4>Held:</h4><p>Defendant was not deprived of his rights.</p><h4>Dissent (Justice Brennan):</h4><p>This case is significantly distinguished from Russell in two ways: 1) The chemical supplied by the government in Russell was not contraband, whereas here the government supplied the illegal narcotic that was being sold. 2) Russell’s crime was participation in an ongoing operation, whereas here the sales petitioner was convicted for were instigated by Government agents and completed by the Government’s purchase (both the beginning and the end of the crime).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*2HgQh74VteoV9r0c6jv_xg.png" /></figure><h4>1986, April 30</h4><h3>Peremptory Challenges Cannot Be Based Solely On Race</h3><p><a href="https://www.law.cornell.edu/supremecourt/text/476/79">James Kirkland BATSON, Petitioner, v. KENTUCKY.</a></p><p><strong><em>Batson v. Kentucky</em>, 476 U.S. 79 (1986)</strong></p><h4>Facts:</h4><p>During the trial of a black man in Kentucky, peremptory challenges were used to dismiss the remaining four black jurists in a trial, leaving an all white jury. Defendant objected to this as a violation of the Sixth and Fourteenth Amendments. Judge denied this plea and the all white jury found the defendant guilty.</p><h4>Issue:</h4><p>Whether the defendant had met his burden of proving purposeful discrimination on the part of the State in violation of the Equal Protection Clause of the Constitution. (Or, put another way, what is the burden?)</p><h4>Rule:</h4><p><em>Swain v. Alabama,</em> 380 U.S. 202 (1965), held that a defendant alleging lack of a fair cross section in jury selection must demonstrate systematic exclusion of a group of jurors from the venire.</p><p>The State’s privilege to strike individual jurors through peremptory challenges, is subject to the commands of the Equal Protection Clause. The Equal Protection Clause forbids the prosecutor to challenge potential jurors solely on account of their race or on the assumption that black jurors as a group will be unable impartially to consider the State’s case against a black defendant.</p><p>The “invidious quality” of governmental action claimed to be racially discriminatory “must ultimately be traced to a racially discriminatory purpose.</p><p>Side note: The Constitution does not guarantee a right to peremptory challenges.</p><h4>Analysis (Justice Powell):</h4><p>As an equal protection case, the burden is on the defendant to prove the existence of purposeful discrimination. However, a black defendant may make out a <em>prima facie</em> case of purposeful discrimination by showing that the totality of the relevant facts gives rise to an inference of discriminatory purpose, at which point the burden shifts to the State to demonstrate that “permissible racially neutral selection criteria and procedures have produced the monochromatic result.”</p><p>In this case, petitioner made a timely objection to the prosecutor’s removal of all black persons on the venire. Because the trial court flatly rejected the objection without requiring the prosecutor to give an explanation for his action, we remand this case for further proceedings. If the trial court decides that the facts establish, prima facie, purposeful discrimination and the prosecutor does not come forward with a neutral explanation for his action, our precedents require that petitioner’s conviction be reversed.</p><h4>Held:</h4><p><em>Swain’s </em>holding requiring defendant to demonstrate systematic exclusion is overturned.</p><h4>1995, April 26</h4><h3>Limits of the Commerce Clause — In Defense of Federalism</h3><p><a href="https://www.law.cornell.edu/supct/html/93-1260.ZO.html">United States v. Lopez, 514 U.S. 549 (1995).</a></p><p><strong><em>United States v. Lopez</em>, 514 U.S. 549 (1995)</strong></p><h4>Facts:</h4><p>A 12th-grade student brought a concealed .38-calibert handgun and five bullets to school. Somebody informed on him and he was arrested and charged under Texas law with firearm possession on school premises. However, the next day the state charges were dismissed after federal agents charged him under the Gun-Free School Zones Act of 1990.</p><h4>Issue:</h4><p>Whether the Gun-Free School Zones Act of 1990 “substantially effects” interstate commerce.</p><h4><strong>Rule:</strong></h4><p>Gun-Free School Zones Act of 1990: It is a federal offense for any individual knowingly to possess a firearm at a place that the individual knows, or has reasonable cause to believe, is a school zone.</p><p>Under its commerce power Congress may regulate 1) the use of the channels of interstate commerce, 2) the instrumentalities of interstate commerce, or persons or things in interstate commerce, even though the threat may come only from intrastate commerce, 3) those activities that have a substantial relation to interstate commerce.</p><p>In order for a law to fall under Congress’s commerce powers, the activities it seeks to regulate must have a substantial relation to interstate commerce.</p><h4>Analysis (Chief Justice Rehnquist):</h4><p>Unless Congress explicitly conveys its purpose as a commerce clause purpose, it will not be deemed to have justified that purpose. In this case, neither the statute nor its legislative history implicates the effects upon interstate commerce of gun possession in a school zone.</p><p>The government argues, that firearms in schools may result in violent crime that could a) affect the national economy by raising insurance rates, b) reduce the willingness of individuals to travel to parts of the country perceived to be unsafe, and c) threaten the learning environment, resulting in a less productive citizenry which in turn would have an adverse effect on the Nation’s economic well-being.</p><p>The Court counters that, if we accept this argument, then there is no limit to the federal power. These arguments could be used to justify almost anything.</p><h4>Held:</h4><p>The possession of a gun in a local school zone is in no sense an economic activity that might, through repetition elsewhere, substantially affect any sort of interstate commerce.</p><h4>Dissent (Justice Breyer)</h4><p>Breyer applies three principles of Commerce Clause interpretation. 1) The power to “regulate Commerce . . . among the several States,” encompasses the power to regulate local activities insofar as they significantly affect interstate commerce. 2) In determining whether a local activity will likely have a significant effect upon interstate commerce, a court must consider, not the effect of an individual act (a single instance of gun possession), but rather the cumulative effect of all similar instances (<em>i.e.</em>, the effect of all guns possessed in or near schools). 3) The question should be not whether the “regulated activity sufficiently affected interstate commerce,” but, rather, whether Congress could have had “a rational basis” for so concluding.</p><h4>Note:</h4><p>This case had a number of long concurrences and dissents. More than we have time for here.</p><p>MAHALO MUCHO!!!</p><p>Your comments are welcome. You can also find me on LinkedIn.</p><p><a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/ronalddrodriguez/">https://www.linkedin.com/in/ronalddrodriguez/</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2f161325628c" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/scotus-watch/the-week-of-april-25-2021-on-this-day-in-scotus-history-2f161325628c">The Week of April 25, 2021: On This Day In SCOTUS History</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/scotus-watch">SCOTUS Watch</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Week of April 18, 2021: On This Day in SCOTUS History]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/scotus-watch/the-week-of-april-18-2021-on-this-day-in-scotus-history-9dbd417445a2?source=rss-14e38d873f99------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9dbd417445a2</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[law]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[scotus]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[justice]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[supreme-court]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ronald D. Rodriguez]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 26 Apr 2021 01:51:25 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-06-09T09:13:38.367Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*fVW-dYHSr_41cSrWX7H4Ew.png" /><figcaption>Warren McCleskey. McCleskey v. Kemp</figcaption></figure><p>This week we will cover probably the worst and most consequential death penalty decision in SCOTUS history, a case of fraud against a religion, an entrapment case with a powerful dissent, overturning racially motivated state laws that allowed non-unanimous guilty verdicts for serious crimes, a copyright case involving Dr. Oliver Wendell Holmes, and the requirements for sufficient notice.</p><p>Cases are presented in chronological order. IRAC format used where possible.</p><p><em>Disclaimer: These cases have not been Shepardized. This article is not legal advice. Those seeking legal advice should consult an attorney.</em></p><h4>1899, April 24</h4><h3>Copyright for a Serial and for a Collection of the Serial Is Indistinguishable.</h3><p><a href="https://www.law.cornell.edu/supremecourt/text/174/82">HOLMES v. HURST.</a></p><h4>Facts:</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/682/1*mQwsHbsxCO4AdQ7nt6pcrw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Dr. Oliver Wendell Holmes, Sr.</figcaption></figure><p>Dr. Oliver Wendell Holmes published a series of 12 installments, entitled “The Autocrat of the Breakfast Table,” between 1857 and 1858 in The Atlantic Monthly. The publisher of the magazine, Phillips, Sampson &amp; Co., of Boston, claimed no rights other than the right to publish the serial. In November 1858, after all 12 installments had been published, Dr. Holmes deposited the 12-part collection with the clerk’s office of his district court and with the Library of Congress.</p><p>Dr. Holmes died on October 7, 1894, 41 years after publication of the serial. On November 1, 1894, less than a month after Holmes died, the defendant, Phillips, Sampson &amp; Co., started selling the 12-part collection in book form. The estate, run by future Supreme Court Justice Oliver Wendell Holmes, Jr., sued.</p><h4>Issue:</h4><p>Whether the serial publication of a book in a monthly magazine, prior to any steps taken towards securing a copyright, impairs the copyright of the collection as a book, said copyright having been obtained subsequent to the magazine publications but prior to the publication of the book.</p><h4>Rule:</h4><p>The author is only entitled to a copyright of books not printed and published.</p><p>The author must deposit a printed copy of the title of the book before publication in order to be eligible for copyright.</p><h4>Analysis (Opinion by Justice Brown):</h4><p>Dr. Holmes’s estate argued that the Atlantic had the right to publish the separate chapters, but that did not give them copyright to publish them in book form.</p><p>Patent law dictates that a mere aggregation of familiar elements, producing no new result, is not a patentable combination. The copyright protects the intellectual production of the work and not the particular form It takes, such as a bound book.</p><h4>Held:</h4><p>The right to sell copies of the several parts versus the right to publish them in a single volume is indistinguishable.</p><h4>Footnote:</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/235/1*7mJGax94DMe2r8FsQq17xQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Oliver Wendell Holmes, Jr.</figcaption></figure><p>The executor of the Holmes estate was future Supreme Court Justice Oliver Wendell Holmes, Jr. Justice Holmes would be the only Justice in SCOTUS history to have appeared in front of the Court as a party to a case. (Courtesy of David L. Callies, et al., Concise Introduction to Property Law, First Edition (Matthew Bender &amp; Company, Inc., 2011).</p><h4>1944, April 24</h4><h3>A Religion Cannot be Sued for Fraud.</h3><p><a href="https://www.law.cornell.edu/supremecourt/text/322/78">UNITED STATES v. BALLARD et al.</a></p><h4>Facts:</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/765/1*CDQ55sx7Wa2lXgkU5J0PKA.jpeg" /></figure><p>Defendants created the I Am movement with claims that they, by reason of supernatural attainment, could and in fact had healed people from ailments, diseases, and injuries. They promoted their movement forming corporations, distributing and selling literature, soliciting funds, and selling memberships.</p><p>Defendants were accused of conspiring to use the U.S. mail to promote their movement “by means of false and fraudulent representations, pretenses and promises.”</p><h4>Issue:</h4><p>Whether a religious movement can be charged with fraud.</p><h4>Rule:</h4><p>The First Amendment a) “forestalls compulsion by law of the acceptance of any creed or practice of any form of worship,” and b) “safeguards the free exercise of the chosen form of religion.” In other words, the freedom to believe and the freedom to act.</p><h4>Analysis (Opinion Justice Douglas):</h4><p>The First Amendment “embraces the right to maintain theories of life and of death and of the hereafter which are rank heresy to followers of the orthodox faiths. Heresy trials are foreign to our Constitution.”</p><p>If the defendant’s religious doctrines are “subject to trail before a jury charged with finding their truth or falsity, then the same can be done with the religious beliefs of any sect.”</p><h4>Held:</h4><p>The District Court ruled properly when it withheld from the jury all questions concerning the truth or falsity of the religious beliefs or doctrines of respondents.</p><h4>Footnote:</h4><p>The I Am Movement is still alive today. You can find them online.</p><h4>1950, April 24</h4><h3>Notice by Publication Only Is Not Sufficient for Constitutional Due Process.</h3><p><a href="https://www.law.cornell.edu/supremecourt/text/339/306">MULLANE v. CENTRAL HANOVER BANK &amp; TRUST CO. et al.</a></p><h4>Facts:</h4><p>With regard to a common trust fund, notice was provided to beneficiaries by publication in a newspaper only. This notice complied with requirements under New York banking law.</p><h4>Issue:</h4><p>Whether notice by publication in a newspaper, to beneficiaries on a judicial settlement of accounts by the trustees of a common trust fund, is sufficient.</p><h4>Rule:</h4><p>14th Amendment, Section 1 (in relevant part): “nor shall any state deprive any person of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law…”</p><h4>Analysis (Opinion by Justice Jackson):</h4><p>“An elementary and fundamental requirement of due process in any proceeding which is to be accorded finality is notice reasonably calculated, under all the circumstances, to apprise interested parties of the pendency of the action and afford them an opportunity to present their objections. The notice must be of such nature as reasonably to convey the required information, and it must afford a reasonable time for those interested to make their appearance. But if with due regard for the practicalities and peculiarities of the case these conditions are reasonably met the constitutional requirements are satisfied…”</p><h4>Held:</h4><p>The New York Banking Law, as regards judicial settlement of accounts, is incompatible with the requirements of the Fourteenth Amendment as a basis for adjudication depriving known persons whose whereabouts are also know of substantial property rights.</p><h4>1973, April 24</h4><h3>Entrapment Is Allowable for an “Unwary Criminal” (but the Dissent is Strong).</h3><p><a href="https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/411/423/">United States v. Russell, 411 U.S. 423 (1973)</a></p><h4>Facts:</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/199/1*Jgx5MhcOlP88qhnyIH8Rzg.jpeg" /></figure><p>An undercover agent for the Federal Bureau of Narcotics and Dangerous Drugs, posing as an illegal methamphetamine distributor, approached defendants who he believed to be illicit meth manufacturers. He offered to provide them with phenyl-2-propanone, an essential ingredient for the manufacture of meth, in return for half of the drug produced and on the condition that he could see the lab where it was being produced. Defendants then provided agent with a sample, disclosed that they had been making the drug since 1969. The deal was made, meth delivered, and defendants arrested.</p><h4>Issue:</h4><p>Whether, by providing a scarce ingredient essential for the manufacture of the meth, the agent provided “an intolerable degree of governmental participation in the criminal enterprise,” thus constituting entrapment.</p><h4>Rule:</h4><p>Lower Court Decision: There is entrapment, regardless of predisposition, whenever the government supplies contraband to the defendants.</p><p>Ninth Circuit: Prosecution of a defendant was held to be repugnant to the American criminal justice system where the government investigator was so enmeshed in the criminal activity.</p><p>The entrapment defense prohibits law enforcement officers from instigating a criminal act by persons “otherwise innocent in order to lure them to its commission and to punish them.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*nvnyU_C57tDOPVt8P9vI6A.png" /><figcaption>Meth</figcaption></figure><h4>Analysis (Opinion by Justice Rehnquist):</h4><p>“To determine whether entrapment has been established, a line must be drawn between the trap for the unwary innocent and the trap for the unwary criminal.”</p><p>“[T]he gathering of evidence of past unlawful conduct frequently proves to be an all but impossible task. Thus in drug-related offenses law enforcement personnel have turned to . . . the infiltration of drug rings and a limited participation in their unlawful present practices. Such infiltration is a recognized and permissible means of investigation[.]” As would be the supplying of something of value in order to gain their confidence of those being infiltrated.</p><p>The agent’s contribution of propanone to the criminal enterprise already in process was not a violation. The chemical by itself is legal and harmless, and it was obtainable as evidenced by paraphernalia found at the lab.</p><p>“[T]he fact that officers or employees of the Government merely afford opportunities or facilities for the commission of the offense does not defeat the prosecution. Nor will the mere fact of deceit defeat a prosecution. . . . It’s only when the Government’s deception actually implants the criminal design in the mind of the defendant that the defense of entrapment comes into play.”</p><h4>Held:</h4><p>Defendant was an active participant in an illegal drug manufacturing enterprise which began before the Government agent appeared on the scene, and continued after the Government agent had left the scene. He was not an “unwary innocent” but an “unwary criminal.”</p><h4>Dissent:</h4><p>Justices Stewart, Brennan, and Marshall argue that the government cannot instigate, provoke, tempt, or create the commission of the crime in order prosecute someone for committing it.</p><p>“The purpose of the entrapment defense, then, cannot be to protect persons who are otherwise innocent. Rather, it must be to prohibit unlawful governmental activity in instigating crime. . . . [W]hether the particular defendant was predisposed or otherwise innocent is irrelevant; and the important question becomes whether the Governments conduct in inducing the crime was beyond judicial toleration.”</p><p>“It allows the prosecution [in offering hearsay suspicion, and rumor as proof of the defendant’s predisposition] to rely on the defendant’s bad reputation or past criminal activities, including even rumored activities of which the prosecution may have insufficient evidence to obtain an indictment[.]” This sort of evidence is not only unreliable, as the hearsay rule recognizes; but is also highly prejudicial, especially if the matter is presented to the jury, for, despite instructions to the contrary, the jury may well consider such evidence as probative … of his guilt of the offense[.]”</p><p>“More fundamentally, focusing on the defendant’s innocence or predisposition has the direct effect of making what is permissible or impermissible police conduct depend upon the past record and propensities of the particular defendant involved.” The Government is thus permitted to entrap a person with a bad reputation and them prosecute him for the manufactured crime, using his record or reputation as proof.</p><h4>1987, April 22</h4><h3>Probably the Worst and Most Consequential Death Penalty Decision in SCOTUS History</h3><p><a href="https://www.law.cornell.edu/supremecourt/text/481/279">Warren McCLESKEY, Petitioner v. Ralph KEMP, Superintendent, Georgia Diagnostic and Classification Center.</a></p><p>Justice Lewis Powell, when asked by his biographer if he wanted to change his vote in any case, replied, “Yes, McCleskey v. Kemp.” A Los Angeles Times survey among legal scholars name McCleskey one of the worst Supreme Court decisions since WWII. This case gave a solid foothold for race-based sentencing in the judicial system.</p><h4>Facts:</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*fVW-dYHSr_41cSrWX7H4Ew.png" /></figure><p>Petitioner, a black man who, during the robbery of a store, killed a white police officer, challenged his death penalty sentencing on Eighth and Fourteenth Amendment racial discrimination grounds. Petitioner sites a statistical study that indicates that black defendants who killed white victims, in Georgia, have the greatest likelihood of receiving the death penalty by a substantial margin.</p><h4>Issue:</h4><p>Whether a complex study that indicates a risk that racial considerations enter into capital sentencing determinations proves that petitioner McCleskey’s capital sentence is unconstitutional under the Eighth or Fourteenth Amendment.</p><h4>Rule:</h4><p>8th Amendment: “Excessive bail shall not be required, nor excessive fines imposed, nor cruel and unusual punishments inflicted.” (Note: the death penalty in itself has been determined not to be cruel and unusual, but the manner of execution may be.)</p><p>14th Amendment, Section 1 (in pertinent part): “nor shall any state deprive any person of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law; nor deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws.”</p><p>A defendant who alleges an equal protection violation has the burden of proving “the existence of purposeful discrimination.”</p><p>A criminal defendant must prove that the purposeful discrimination “had a discriminatory effect” on him.</p><h4>Analysis (Opinion by Justice Lewis Powell):</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/640/1*z6T_sgWWyr6QxRfK_fquZQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>Much of the argument centered around the findings of the Baldus Study. The Baldus study is actually two sophisticated statistical studies that examine over 2,000 murder cases that occurred in Georgia during the 1970’s. Baldus subjected his data to an extensive analysis, taking account of 230 variables that could have explained the disparities on nonracial grounds. The results include the following:</p><ul><li>Defendants charged with killing white persons received the death penalty in 11% of the cases, but defendants charged with killing blacks received the death penalty in only 1% of the cases.</li><li>4% of the black defendants received the death penalty, as opposed to 7% of the white defendants.</li><li>The death penalty was given in 22% of the cases involving black defendants and white victims; while the death penalty was given for only 8% of the cases involving white defendants and white victims; 1% of the cases involving black defendants and black victims; and 3% of the cases involving white defendants and black victims.</li><li>Prosecutors sought the death penalty in 70% of the cases involving black defendants and white victims; while only 32% of the cases involving white defendants and white victims; 15% of the cases involving black defendants and black victims; and 19% of the cases involving white defendants and black victims.</li><li>Defendants charged with killing white victims were 4.3 times as likely to receive a death sentence as defendants charged with killing blacks, even when corrected for nonracial variables.</li><li>Black defendants were 1.1 times as likely to receive a death sentence as other defendants, even when corrected for nonracial variables.</li></ul><p>The District Court determined that the Baldus study did not demonstrate a prima facie case of discrimination in this case and that the study itself “was flawed in several respects.” The Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit, on the other hand, assumed the validity of the study, but found that the statistics were “insufficient to demonstrate discriminatory intent or unconstitutional discrimination in the Fourteenth Amendment context or to show irrationality, arbitrariness, and capriciousness under Eight Amendment analysis.”</p><blockquote>Justice Lewis Powell, when asked by his biographer if he wanted to change his vote in any case, replied, “Yes, McCleskey v. Kemp.”</blockquote><p>The Supreme Court’s extended argument and rejection of the Baldus defense can be condensed to:</p><ul><li>The courts have discretion. The constitutional guarantees are met when the mode for determining guilt or punishment is done in an approved manner. In light of these safeguards, “we hold that the Baldus study does not demonstrate a constitutionally significant risk of racial bias affecting the Georgia capital sentencing process.”</li><li>Finding for McClesky in this case would “throw[] into serious question the principles that underlie our entire criminal justice system.” The reversal would result in similar claims for not just death penalty cases, but for other penalties as well; and not just for race, but also gender and even physical attractiveness.</li><li>This is a job for the Legislatures, not the court. The court’s duty is to determine case-by-case whether the laws are being applied consistently with the Constitution. The only question before the court is whether in this case the law of Georgia was applied properly.</li></ul><h4>Held:</h4><p>The judgment of the Court of Appeals and the Eleventh Circuit, and McCleskey’s death penalty sentence, is affirmed.</p><p>For a deeper dive into the case, consider this lecture by Professor Stephen B. Bright’s, available on YouTube courtesy of YaleCourses.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FjOKmtNRa8eI%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DjOKmtNRa8eI&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FjOKmtNRa8eI%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/c78f6840eb41180f2307d0e8bc5e0d46/href">https://medium.com/media/c78f6840eb41180f2307d0e8bc5e0d46/href</a></iframe><h4>2020, April 20</h4><h3>SCOTUS Affirms Unanimous Verdict Requirement for Serious Offenses.</h3><p><a href="https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/590/18-5924/">Ramos v. Louisiana, 590 U.S. ___ (2020)</a></p><h4>Facts:</h4><p>In 2016, petitioner was convicted of murder in a jury trial with a 10–2 vote. Petitioner appealed, claiming that for a serious crime a jury vote must be unanimous, and that the law making a non-unanimous conviction possible was the result of a Jim Crow law.</p><h4>Issue:</h4><p>Whether the Sixth Amendment right to a jury trial — as incorporated against the States by way of the Fourteenth Amendment — requires a unanimous verdict to convict a defendant of a serious offense.</p><h4>Rule:</h4><p>Sixth Amendment (emphasis added): <em>In all criminal prosecutions, the accused shall enjoy the right to a speedy and public trial, by an impartial jury of the state and district wherein the crime shall have been committed</em>, which district shall have been previously ascertained by law, and to be informed of the nature and cause of the accusation; to be confronted with the witnesses against him; to have compulsory process for obtaining witnesses in his favor, and to have the assistance of counsel for his defense.</p><p>Article III, Section 2 (in relevant part): The trial of all crimes, except in cases of impeachment, shall be by jury; and such trial shall be held in the state where the said crimes shall have been committed; but when not committed within any state, the trial shall be at such place or places as the Congress may by law have directed.</p><p>Apodaca v. Oregon, 406 U.S. 404 (1972): Held that, while federal law requires a unanimous verdict in criminal trials, state juries may convict a defendant by a less-than-unanimous verdict in a felony criminal case.</p><h4>Analysis (Opinion by Justice Gorsuch):</h4><p>Louisiana and Oregon were the only two states in the union that included laws that allowed for conviction on a less than unanimous vote. Both states have acknowledged the racial origins and motivations in adapting these laws. (Louisiana changed it’s law to require unanimous votes after the defendant was convicted and prior to this petition.)</p><p>The promise of a jury trial would have no meaning if a single person (or two, as was the case of Louisiana and Oregon law) could effect a guilty verdict. This is a tradition that emerged in 14th Century England and has been well-documented throughout American history.</p><p>Gorsuch, in his scorching condemnation of Apodaca, comments that “[r]eally, no one has found a way to make sense of it.”</p><h4>Alito’s Dissent, or, rather, Gorsuch’s Response to Alito’s Dissent</h4><p>Alito dissented based on reliance interests. Gorsuch provides a characteristically scorching response:</p><p>“[T]he only reliance interests that might be asserted here fall into two categories. The first concerns the fact Louisiana and Oregon may need to retry defendants convicted of felonies by non-unanimous verdicts whose cases are still pending on direct appeal. The dissent claims that this fact supplies the winning argument for retaining Apodaca because it has generated “enormous reliance interests” and overturning the case would provoke a “crushing” “tsunami” of follow-on litigation.”</p><p>“[T]he dissent suggests that the feeble reliance interests it identifies should get a boost because the right to a unanimous jury trial has “little practical importance going forward.” In the dissent’s telling, Louisiana has “abolished” non-unanimous verdicts and Oregon “seemed on the verge of doing the same until the Court intervened.” But, as the dissent itself concedes, a ruling for Louisiana would invite other States to relax their own unanimity requirements. In fact, 14 jurisdictions have already told us that they would value the right to “experiment” with non-unanimous juries. . . . No doubt, too, those who risk being subjected to non-unanimous juries in Louisiana and Oregon today, and elsewhere tomorrow, would dispute the dissent’s suggestion that their Sixth Amendment rights are of “little practical importance.””</p><p>“Every judge must learn to live with the fact he or she will make some mistakes; it comes with the territory. But it is something else entirely to perpetuate something we all know to be wrong only because we fear the consequences of being right.”</p><h4>Held:</h4><p>By a 6–3 majority opinion, the Court ruled in petitioner’s favor. In addition to the opinion there were three separate concurrences and one dissent.</p><p>Below is an article describing efforts, prior to this holding, to change the Louisiana State Constitution to require unanimous jury verdicts for serious crimes. According to the article, over the previous six years, 40 percent of 993 convictions came from split juries. The effort was ultimately successful, but the SCOTUS decision would have invalidated their non-unanimous law anyway.</p><p><a href="https://atlantablackstar.com/2018/04/16/louisiana-one-two-states-allows-non-unanimous-jury-convict-defendant-senator-wants-change/">Louisiana Is One of Only Two States That Allows a Non-Unanimous Jury to Convict a Defendant - This Senator Wants To Change That</a></p><p>MAHALO MUCHO!!!</p><p>You can comment on this article or contact the author directly through LinkedIn.</p><p><a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/ronalddrodriguez/">Ronald D. Rodriguez - Head of Contracts &amp; Procurement / Legal Counsel - Hawaii Tourism Authority | LinkedIn</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9dbd417445a2" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/scotus-watch/the-week-of-april-18-2021-on-this-day-in-scotus-history-9dbd417445a2">The Week of April 18, 2021: On This Day in SCOTUS History</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/scotus-watch">SCOTUS Watch</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>