<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Ronald W. McNutt on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Ronald W. McNutt on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@ronmcnutt?source=rss-368797e78488------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 06:43:20 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@ronmcnutt/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Clinical, therapeutic, and religious uses of psychedelics, some updates for 2026, a review by Ron…]]></title>
            <link>https://ronmcnutt.medium.com/clinical-therapeutic-and-religious-uses-of-psychedelics-some-updates-for-2026-a-review-by-ron-967076b107bc?source=rss-368797e78488------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/967076b107bc</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[psychedelics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ronald W. McNutt]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 25 Sep 2026 23:03:39 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-09-25T23:03:39.933Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Clinical, therapeutic, and religious uses of psychedelics, some updates for 2026, a review by Ron McNutt, September 2026</p><p>Natural psilocybin programs for therapies under state laws:</p><p>Psilocybin mushrooms in their natural state are part of healing program initiatives in Utah and New Mexico, and are at the center of the supported adult use programs in Colorado and Oregon. Psychedelic chemical compounds have been the traditional medicinal resources in clinical applications and therapies, such as synthetic varieties of psilocybin, LSD, and MDMA. Pharmaceutical industries, including Usona, Institute, a nonprofit organization, are developing modified derivatives and innovated formulas, often with administration protocols to seek patent protection in new drug applications for mental health treatment. States are now showing openness to organic psilocybin in regulated mental health therapeutic programs. Psilocybin mushrooms in their natural state are part of healing program initiatives in Utah and New Mexico, and are part of the supported adult use programs in Colorado and Oregon.</p><p>Social impressions are more favorable toward clinical use of psychedelics for psychotherapy, but still are unfavorable toward celebratory or personal experience with psychedelics. A Rand survey of adults in the United States shows that a majority of voters remain receptive to having psychedelics for use in psychotherapy but not for celebratory or recreational use.</p><p>In April, 2025, New Mexico adopted the Medical Psilocybin Act, which was signed by the governor after the legislation passed with significant majorities. The law creates a framework and ordered supporting regulations for licensed healthcare providers to prescribe natural psilocybin to patients with posttraumatic stress disorder, major treatment-resistant depression, and end-of-life care, as well as other conditions that may be approved as part of forming a regulatory framework. The Act removes organic psilocybin mushrooms from the Controlled Substances Act when they are used as part of a clinical therapeutic program.</p><p>The rulemaking process is underway, for regulating growing and distribution of psilocybin-containing mushrooms for healthcare. The program is to be in place by the end of 2027. New Mexico will begin issuing licenses for mushroom growers for this program for treatment of PTSD, substance abuse disorder, and for end-of-life distress. Licenses and registrations will be for in-state use.</p><p>Utah’s Section 58–37–3.5 codifies enactment of Senate Bill 266, which created a three-year a pilot program allowing medical providers at two large healthcare systems, the University of Utah and Intermountain Health, to prescribe psilocybin and MDMA as behavioral health treatments. Effective May 1, 2024, subject to rulemaking, the medical providers at these two healthcare systems will be allowed to prescribe naturally-occurring psilocybin mushrooms and MDMA as behavioral health treatments to adults in a medical facility setting, subject to the rules of their institutions to create standards of care, as an exception to the Utah Controlled Substances Act.</p><p>Resilient Pharmaceuticals, the successor to MAPS, renews the new drug application for MDMA assisted therapy:</p><p>MDMA, with therapy support, is being resubmitted for FDA approval of the new drug application to reschedule it from Schedule 1. The organization that is the successor to MAPS, Resilient, is hoping it will be approved in a new climate that it hopes is less prohibitionist. In August, 2026, the organization Resilient Pharmaceuticals, which succeeded Lykos Therapeutics, filed a renewed submission to the FDA for its MDMA-assisted therapy. The new drug application, for its trademark version <em>Rysanso</em>, came after the FDA issued a new guidance, nonbinding recommendations, called Psychedelic Drugs: Considerations for Clinical Investigations Guidance for Industry.</p><p>The July 2026 Guidance offered investigative new drug recommendations for psychedelics, including production standards and clinical trial design, and discussed some review considerations. The Guidance provided that in showing that the investigative new drug is reasonably safe, the applicant can rely on safety data for human use. The Guidance suggested attention to a potential concern for heart valve function being affected by traditional serotonergic psychedelics as well as abuse potential from states of euphoria and alteration of consciousness, and allowed consideration by reference to existing research. The Guidance had protocols and safety considerations, part of the Risk Evaluation and Mitigation Strategy (REMS) for supervisory administration sessions, part of risk reduction to limit adverse events. The Guidance recommends having two persons, called monitors, attend dosing sessions: a lead monitor who would be a licensed psychotherapist and a second person, the assistant monitor, who would have a college or nursing degree and a year of mental health experience at a licensed facility. The Guidance also calls for physician backup support to be available within fifteen minutes.</p><p>The Resilient Pharmaceuticals application takes advantage of the opportunity to rely on data from previous studies to address a concern raised in the 2024 Complete Response Letter of the FDA. In that letter, the agency said that Lykos would need to conduct another Phase three clinical trial to eliminate perceived risk of biased results, screening deficiencies, participants with prior MDMA experience, and insufficient proof of long-term effectiveness. Resilient Pharmaceuticals has addressed one concern about tracking positive side effects. It relied on external research including one Veterans Affairs study to support the application and anticipated a more favorable application with a more receptive agency.</p><p>FDA expedited vouchers, psilocybin rescheduling, and pharmaceutical investment:</p><p>Psilocybin is at the center of litigation seeking access for end-of-life distress by a physician practicing palliative care, Dr. Sunil Aggarwal. He and his practice are parties to several cases styled <em>Advanced Integrative Medical Science Institute, PLLC v. United States Drug Enforcement Agency</em>. This case has involved several appeals and remands seeking to provide access to psilocybin for patients in palliative and end-of-life care under Right to Try laws. These cased have led to a psilocybin rescheduling petition which is currently before the Department of Health and Human Services.</p><p>The Food and Drug Administration (FDA) granted breakthrough therapy status for psilocybin to treat major depressive disorder in 2019 to both Usona Institute and Compass Pathways. The FDA in April 2026 issued national priority vouchers to three companies studying: 1) Psilocybin for treatment-resistant depression; 2) Psilocybin for major depressive disorder; and 3) Methylone for post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD). The FDA announced that it was awarding expedited review status under a type of voucher: “to appropriate psychedelic drugs that have received a Breakthrough Therapy designation and are in accordance with the criteria of the [program].” The FDA announcement’s reference to Right to Try Laws for end of life indicate a role for psilocybin, which was referred to the DEA to consider rescheduling as part of the AIMS litigation supporting prescribing under Right to Try laws.</p><p>Through philanthropy and private funding, Usona Institute, a nonprofit organization, conducts research and supports medical research provides training for the psychedelic guides of the future for their research studies. The Usona Institute has been in a phase three study of psilocybin for major depressive disorder. Usona Institute provided a relatively simple chemical formula for synthesizing psilocybin to enter the public domain. The vouchers issued in April 2026 for Usona and Compass Pathways for treatment-resistant depression and major depressive disorder, along with psilocybin’s breakthrough therapy designation indicates expedited review will favor psilocybin’s potential by streamlining the time for reviewing new drug applications. The outcome is not guaranteed, but the studies are favorable and risks have been reduced by assigning trained sitters or facilitators who can provide assurance. Following the dosing sessions, participants will presumably follow up with their regular therapists for further treatment.</p><p>LSD, which has also received breakthrough therapy status from the FDA, has had a successful Phase 3 study. Sandoz allowed the original formulae for synthesizing LSD and psilocybin, developed by Albert Hofmann, to enter the public domain without renewing their patents. On June, 22, 2026, Definium Therapeutics announced positive topline results from its Phase 3 study of LSD (DT120) for major depressive disorder. It is a strong result, the first Phase 3 result for an LSD derivative. The company’s Chief Medical Officer, Dan Karlin, said it has a $5.5 billion market capitalization. The interest in psychedelic-assisted therapies recognizes that LSD and other psychedelics were irrationally prohibited and the failure to allow research, combined with the inadequacy of drug treatments for depression, is adding to the enthusiasm for these medicines.</p><p><a href="https://www.biopharmadive.com/news/psychedelics-definium-biotech-research-field-results-validate/823510/">https://www.biopharmadive.com/news/psychedelics-definium-biotech-research-field-results-validate/823510/</a></p><p>A landmark study came out in early September 2026 from University of California and Berkeley, showing a single dose of psilocybin prior to chemotherapy prevents onset of peripheral neuropathy in mice. The study indicates a potential benefit for cancer patients. This is the first time a study showed preventive salutary benefits from psilocybin, which are easy to appreciate because of the harm that peripheral neuropathy brings to come chemotherapy recipients. Recently, a small South American study showed potential benefits with psilocybin to inhibit dementia.</p><p>Eli Lilly and Company, perhaps the largest pharmaceutical company, has purchased AtaiBeckley, which was developing therapies with derivatives of MDMA, DMT, and 5-MeO-DMT. The cost of acquisition was $ 2.8 billion. Lilly has shown interest in acquiring companies in late-stage development of novel pharmaceuticals.</p><p>In July, 2020, the Lundquist Institute for Biomedical Innovation announced a multi-site clinical trial to study the effects of psilocybin to ease existential distress for patients with serious illness. The multi-site project will study the effectiveness and safety of psilocybin to treat terminally ill people with psychological distress. It will be funded by a $ 1.75 million donation by an anonymous donor. In July, 2020, the Lundquist Institute for Biomedical Innovation announced a multi-site clinical trial to be led by Dr. Charles Grob and Dr. Anthony Bossis to study the effects of psilocybin to ease existential distress for patients with serious illness. The multi-site project will study the effectiveness and safety of psilocybin to treat terminally ill people with psychological distress. It will be funded by a $ 1.75 million donation by an anonymous donor. There have been multiple sites involved in clinical trials by the Lundquist Institute for Biomedical Innovation to study the effectiveness and safety of psilocybin to treat terminally ill people with psychological distress. Charles Grob, M.D., and Brian Anderson, M.D., have been leading the trials in California and Maryland. Results have not yet been announced, but the multi-site clinical trials were announced in July 2020. The studies were funded with a $ 1.75 million anonymous donation.</p><p>Veterans’ programs and administration’s emphasis on ibogaine:</p><p>The Department of Veterans Affairs is pursuing expanded clinical psilocybin-assisted therapies. The department has twenty active clinical trials underway. An Ohio State study was published recently with a small sample of twelve veterans. It showed that they reported success with favorable rates of resolution of symptoms of posttraumatic stress syndrome good. There was a In August 2026, Secretary Doug Collins announced a new clinical trial program at VA hospitals for psilocybin-assisted therapies for treatment-resistant depression. He described the expanded clinical trials with psilocybin as a step in the direction of the administration’s goal to “evaluate new treatments and offer meaningful relief “for veterans. According to the department’s August 6th, 2026 release:</p><p>The randomized, controlled trial will enroll Veterans diagnosed with treatment-resistant major depressive disorder, with or without concurrent PTSD, and will compare outcomes between two psilocybin dosage levels. The study will also assess participants’ levels of depression before and after treatment, tolerability of side effects, and overall patient-reported depression.</p><p>The trial will be conducted in five locations: Birmingham VA Health Care System and Tuscaloosa VA Medical Center in Alabama; VA Portland Health Care System in Oregon; Corporal Michael J. Crescenz VA Medical Center in Philadelphia; and VA Puget Sound Health Care System in Seattle, Washington.</p><p>The emphasis on increasing patenting of pharmaceutical derivatives and expanding psychedelic and empathogenic treatments is engaging with political influence and opposition. Some legislative initiatives have been introduced but have not advanced, apparently facing opposition in the Senate Veterans Affairs Committee. Bipartisan legislation was introduced in January, H.R. 7091, a bill called Expanding Veterans’ Access to Emerging Treatments Act of 2026. It appears to be a response to pressure to address untreated depression, trauma, and concussive disease, and reported successes with elite special forces at The Mission Within. It would authorize the Department of Veterans Affairs to conduct extensive clinical trials using innovative treatments and emerging therapies, including psilocybin, MDMA, ibogaine, 5-MeO-DMT, and ketamine. The Freedom to Heal Act was introduced around November 2025, and would provide for psychedelic therapies to be available for people who have exhausted other medical options and for Right to Try applications for end-of-life care when the therapy has passed Phase 1 clinical trials.</p><p>In the FDA announcement, the agency is authorizing an early phase clinical study of noribogaine hydrochloride to move forward following an Investigational New Drug (IND) submission. FDA Commissioner Marty Makary announced investigational new drug clearance of ibogaine, meaning that clinical trials of the drug can begin in the U.S. There will be another $ 50 million for ibogaine research to augment Texas’s program, which has a state appropriation of the same amount. Louisiana also has announced that it will be designating opioid settlement proceeds for a psychedelic project funded under the state’s department of health to investigate using psilocybin, MDMA, and ibogaine to treat metal health conditions and opioid abuse under FDA standards. The program anticipates involving academic institutions in these studies.</p><p>According to an article by Jack Gorsline in Double Blind in February 2026, an advocate and Navy veteran, Tina Williams, has requested scrutiny of the nexus between the Psychedelic Science Funders Cooperative, led by Genevieve Jurvetson, New Approach, and SpaceX directors Antonio Gracias, the principal at Resilient Pharmaceuticals, and Steve Jurvetson. Some bad news for federal ibogaine legislative initiatives came when one of its principal proponents, Matthew Ammel, was involved in scandals including alleged misconduct involving former senator Kirsten Sinema and improper expenditures and personal conduct. His apparent corruption and emotional instability have impeded the notable forward progress of legislation for access to psychedelic-assisted therapies for veterans and people in the armed services. <a href="https://doubleblindmag.com/veterans-caught-between-policy-paralysis-and-controversy-in-dc/">https://doubleblindmag.com/veterans-caught-between-policy-paralysis-and-controversy-in-dc/</a></p><p>Results from the Oregon Psilocybin Services program:</p><p>There are reports of favorable results from Oregon’s psilocybin supported adult use program. Oregon Psilocybin Services began awarding licenses in early 2023 and there are now three years of data. It originated as a fee-based licensure model and the costs of regulation have been formidable. Approximately 22,000 customers have participated in regulated psilocybin services under the state program.</p><p>The Oregon program is a supported adult use program that is not directed at treatment of depression, PTSD, or other mental health conditions. Adults can receive the services outside of a medical model. The Oregon psilocybin program services are not directed by a psychotherapist, but facilitators must complete a state certification program. Many facilitators received training and are finding that the costs are increasing. License fees for psilocybin service centers are increasing to $20,000 per year. The Oregon Health Authority issued program data showing favorable safety data, with a low severe adverse event rate of 0.15%, which it emphasizes is below the approximately 0.9% rate in clinical studies. Effectiveness data show that 53% of clients assessed for depression reached remission after a single session.</p><p>Sam Chapman of the Center for Psychedelic Policy stated that average costs for participation are between $ 1500 to $ 3000, including preparation and administration supervision. He stated that a third of Oregon’s centers have closed. He contends that the costs of psilocybin therapy are about $5,660 per remission achieved, compared to $22,408 for transcranial magnetic stimulation, or TMS costs, which are covered under the Oregon Medicaid benefits.</p><p>Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration (SAMHSA) memorandum:</p><p>A federal report from the Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration (SAMHSA) encouraged states to prepare for FDA approval of psychedelics. The report is not currently posted, but it encouraged states to prepare for possible approval of psychedelic therapies by the Food and Drug Administration. It encourages state regulatory authorities to prepare regulations for risk reduction. The report reviews the positive results of psychedelics like MDMA and psilocybin for treatment of depression and substance abuse and it stresses the importance of expanding treatment to marginalized populations due to income or challenges with trauma and mental illness. The report encourages the states to consider “fiscal, legal, and operational implications of potential FDA-approved psychedelic therapies, including any Medicaid coverage obligations.”</p><p>According to the SAMHSA report, coverage could require state expenditures of millions of dollars if the FDA approves such treatments citing the example of esketamine, which can cost as much as $45,000 per year. It suggests that states could be required to pay up to $20 million per year for psychedelic-assisted therapy for treatment-resistant depression. The report states, “These decisions are likely to come whether or not states are ready for them, and it will be easier to develop informed positions in advance than to react under pressure,” the report reads.</p><p>Recent litigation is expanding protection for religious use of ayahuasca through success in court proceedings and settlements favoring ceremonial plant medicine psychedelic churches:</p><p>Spiritual settings for psychedelics have been seeing substantial court success in recent years. Well-funded litigation with teams of conscientious lawyers have succeeded in reaching favorable results in protecting religious liberty for ayahuasca churches. There is an expansive view of religious protection that appears to be diminishing the level of federal persecution of psychedelic religions while several courts seem to be more favorably disposed toward recognizing legal protection. This has led to important decisions and settlements in the Church of the Eagle and Condor, Church of the Celestial Heart, and the Church of Gaia cases.</p><p>Psychedelic experience had been part of religious liberty before the Supreme Court, in <em>Employment Division, Department of Human Resources of Oregon v. Smith</em>, 494 U.S. 872 (1990), held that the Free Exercise Clause of the U.S. Constitution could not be applied to invalidate laws that are considered neutral and generally applicable. The Court declined protection for religious practices with peyote by members of the Native American Church of North America. This position provided no constitutional protection for religious use of psychedelics until the Religious Freedom Restoration Act.</p><p>Previously, constitutional protection for sincere religious experience with psychedelics was extended, at least to members of that conscientious and sincere peyote sacramental practice. In <em>People v. Woody</em>, 61 Cal. 2d 716, (1964), the California Supreme Court reversed the convictions under state law of members of the Native American Church for possession of peyote. The court found that enforcement laws placed an undue burden upon their freedom to exercise their religion. It upheld findings that the adherents were sincere and that the peyote was central to the religion. Peyote was the “sine qua non” of their faith and the “sole means by which the defendants are able to experience their religion.” <em>Id</em>., 61 Cal.2d at 725, 394 P.2d. at 820, 40 Cal. Rptr. at 76. The California Supreme Court noted that the use of peyote for the members “incorporates the essence of the religious experience,” and that the liberty interest weighed heavily in favor of protection, while there was only a slight danger to law enforcement interests. <em>Id.</em>, 394 P.2d. at 821.</p><p>The Religious Freedom Restoration Act (RFRA) overturned the absence of religious protection after <em>Smith</em>, restoring by legislation the previous higher level of scrutiny to laws that burden religious exercise. The Religious Freedom Restoration Act, 42 U.S.C. § 2000bb-1 calls for review of religious exemption claims in a “judicial proceeding” and it challenged the agency’s authority to adjudicate religious freedom claims. (<em>Id</em>., slip op. at 23).</p><p>A branch of the Brazilian <em>União do Vegetal </em>church won a favorable result from the Supreme Court in 2006. The U.S. Supreme Court rendered a unanimous (8–0) decision in <em>Gonzales v. O Centro Espirita Beneficente União do Vegetal, </em>546 U.S. 418, (2006), which upheld the right of practitioners in the branch of the <em>União do Vegetal</em> church in New Mexico to use ayahuasca as a sacrament under the free exercise of religion clause of the first amendment.</p><p>Two ayahuasca churches, American branches of successors of the Santo Daime religion, the oldest of the Brazilian ayahuasca religions, prevailed in obtaining protection after its leader was arrested in 1999 and the church’s Daime tea (ayahuasca) was seized. The district court entered a permanent injunction to allow the two Santo Daime branches to import and use ayahuasca, after the churches filed an injunctive and declaratory action in 2008. They offered evidence including expert testimony that showed overall social and health benefits from the use of ayahuasca, including providing benefits that helped members with problems such as addiction and had a low incidence of causing mental health problems, like transient psychosis. <em>Church of the Holy Light of Queen v. Mukasey</em>, 615 F.Supp.2d 1210 (D. Or. 2009). The court credited the founder, Mr. Goldman’s, testimony that taking the ayahuasca tea is “an arduous path that is not suitable for most people. Careful screening to ensure serious participants through a sponsorship system, an orientation program, and regular participation requirements were practices the court recognized as signs of sincerity and careful preparation. <em>Id</em>. at 1216–17. The court found the plaintiffs sustained their burden of persuasion, that they were sincere in their religion, and that the ceremonial use of the Daime tea is essential to their religion. <em>Id.</em> at 1219.</p><p>After the decision in <em>Gonzales v. O Centro Espirita Beneficiente União do Vegetal</em>, 546 U.S. 418 (2006), the Drug Enforcement Administration developed a separate religious exemption process. (Opinion at 12). Then it offered an on-line guidance first issued in 2009, and which was updated in 2020. It is titled, the Drug Enforcement Administration Diversion Control Division, Guidance Regarding Petitions for Religious Exemption from the Controlled Substances Act Pursuant to the Religious Freedom Restoration Act. In the <em>Soul Quest Church of Mother Earth</em> and <em>Iowaska Church of Healing</em> cases, the act of pursuing an administrative exemption with the Drug Enforcement Administration led reviewing courts to regard the agency as having the authority to make freedom of religion decisions, and that its findings are subject to limited review. Cases that were litigated with better facts and strategies avoided the pitfall of seeking the approval and invoking the factfinding of the Drug Enforcement Administration.</p><p>In <em>Church of the Celestial Heart v. Garland</em>, a U.S. magistrate judge in California denied a federal government motion to dismiss a complaint by an ayahuasca church called Church of the Celestial Heart. The Church of the Celestial Heart and its pastor sued the attorney general and other federal officials after the seizure of a shipment of its ayahuasca by the Department of Homeland Security, followed by local authorities arresting and filing charges against the church pastor’s wife. They asserted the right to freely exercise their religion using an ayahuasca sacrament, claiming that ayahuasca is essential to their church as a sacrament and that threats of civil and criminal penalties were an impermissible burden on their freedom of religion.</p><p>The federal government asserted that the plaintiffs, an ayahuasca church and its leaders, did not have standing because the seizure was done by parties not named in the lawsuit and the prosecution, which had not been further pursued, was undertaken by local county officials. The magistrate judge held that the plaintiffs showed that there was a genuine threat of imminent prosecution, and that the prosecution and enforcement activities could be traced to the named federal officials.</p><p>The court rejected the Drug Enforcement Administration’s effort to force the parties to invoke its administrative process to assess freedom of religion claims using the balancing-of-interests analysis intended for the courts under the Religious Freedom Restoration Act. The court held that the Drug Enforcement Administration should not be allowed to stay proceedings to require the plaintiffs to seek a religious exemption in administrative proceedings before that agency, noting its lack of authority. The government argued that the agency should have the prerogative, in the first instance, to examine the religious freedom claims, perform the appropriate balancing of interests to decide whether public safety interests outweigh the burden on religious practices, prepare a record, and maintain an independent administrative system for churches seeking redress. The magistrate judge held that if an administrative agency like the Drug Enforcement Administration were to regulate religions without authorization by congressional action, chaos would follow. On April 2, 2025, Attorneys Jack Silver and Sean McAllister achieved a settlement gaining recognition and religious protection for the Church of the Celestial Heart based in California. The Church of the Celestial Heart was founded by Kai Karrel, and employs ayahuasca as its sacrament.</p><p>The <em>Church of the Eagle and Condor v. Garland </em>(D. Ariz. April 22, 2024) reached a settlement that protected the privacy of its membership lists. In March 2023, the plaintiffs prevailed on a motion to dismiss filed by the government. The court held the Religious Freedom Restoration Act claims could proceed to trial and that the plaintiffs had standing. The court declined to order a stay or require the plaintiffs to pursue a certificate of registration from the DEA. The settlement recognized “activities of a religious entity” in setting forth the rights and responsibilities of the Church of the Eagle and Condor.</p><p>The settlement agreement allows the Church of the Eagle and Condor plaintiffs to import, receive, manufacture, distribute, transport, securely store, and dispose of ayahuasca solely for the church’s religious purposes. The church is authorized to receive ayahuasca “in concentrated paste or in liquid form” and, when needed, to “combine the ayahuasca paste with water to manufacture ayahuasca tea for sacramental uses” at a designated church facility in Phoenix. The settlement allows the DEA to take spot samples of the imports “for the purpose of confirming that the consignment is in fact ayahuasca which contains no controlled substance other than DMT.”</p><p>The Drug Enforcement Administration has minimized its role in law enforcement with respect to ayahuasca churches in cases such as <em>Church of the Celestial Heart </em>and cases discussed in that opinion. Despite a substantial number of border seizures of plant medicine materials, there were very few prosecutions following seizures and interception of plant medicine materials. The agency would provide information about the intended recipients and content to state prosecutors, who have tended to be disinterested in pursuing charges. Federal and state authorities have not appeared eager to bring many enforcement actions against churches with natural psychedelic sacraments.</p><p>On May 2025, the Church of Gaia in Washington<strong> </strong>received the first religious exemption for a plant medicine religion under the Religious Freedom Restoration Act without bringing a lawsuit to force a decision. Through the DEA’s petition process, the Church of Gaia, reached a settlement that allowed the community to practice ceremonial experience with ayahuasca.</p><p>A psilocybin church in Utah, the Church of Singularism, won a motion to dismiss in a federal district court in Utah. The court held that the protection for free exercise religion extended to psilocybin mushrooms, which the church obtained from authorized providers (manufacturers) in Oregon. The court held that the federal Religious Freedom Restoration Act, RFRA, which intended to restore the constitutional free exercise of religion, offers protection for the sacrament of the Singularism community. Holding that Singularism showed likelihood of success at a preliminary stage in pleadings, U.S. District Judge Jill Parrish granted church officials’ request for a preliminary injunction against city and county officials on February 20th, 2025. The court converted its prior temporary restraining order into a preliminary injunction to protect Singularism’s religious free exercise. The court ordered the government to return the mushrooms and not to interfere with the group’s “sincere religious use of psilocybin” while the case is pending. The case is on appeal and has been argued before the Tenth Circuit Court of Appeals.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=967076b107bc" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Narratives of Freedom and Resilience From Veterans on 2-North in Nashville]]></title>
            <link>https://ronmcnutt.medium.com/narratives-of-freedom-and-resilience-from-veterans-on-2-north-in-nashville-91cfe4e8a1b5?source=rss-368797e78488------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/91cfe4e8a1b5</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[anomalous-experiences]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ronald W. McNutt]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 25 Sep 2026 22:50:38 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-09-25T22:50:38.875Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Narratives of Freedom and Resilience From Veterans on 2-North in Nashville</p><p>Patient Accounts of Sources of Inspiration for Faith, Healing, and Transformation: Forms of Experience that Bring Meaning and Purpose to Motivate Positive Changes in Lifestyle and Orientation.</p><p>Ronald W. McNutt, chaplain fellow, U.S. Veterans Affairs Tennessee Valley Healthcare System, V.A. Healthcare Center in Nashville. This research project, presented on September 1, 2026, is for a 2025 to 2026 clinical fellowship with a specialty in spiritual care with medical-surgical patients.</p><p>Purpose and Overview of this Study</p><p>This is a fellowship project that accumulates narratives that were identified as significant events by spiritual care recipients during chaplain visits during the past fellowship year from October 2025 to September 2026. This study records some descriptions of spontaneous or dramatic events, realizations, and anomalous experiences that some patents cited as sources of meaning and purpose or which inspired them to change their lifestyles and orient themselves with new priorities. This project presents and explores the narrative accounts that have surfaced as significant and precise in the descriptions patients offer from their own experience during spiritual care encounters. The assembled narrative accounts have surfaced in natural conversations that explore sources of motivation or inspiration and describe the types of past inspiring experiences, events, and important decisions that care recipients have identified as providing them with meaning and purpose and with hope and confidence.</p><p>The patients in this study are on a medical and surgical care floor at the Nashville Veterans Affairs Hospital with the Tennessee Valley Healthcare System. They come primarily from the Middle Tennessee and Kentucky area. Some patients come from other areas of the country for traveling veteran care, or for organ transplant services including follow-up care. A separate document with identifying information and subject to HIPAA is available to my educator and director for purposes of authenticity and documentation in case it may become useful for further study. The patient visits are primarily initial encounters, with frequent return visits and follow-up visits as patients continue treatment and find improvement or further advancement of their healthcare concerns. As we discuss their progress and outlook, these accounts surface as sources of inspiration in their lives and their outlook of faith.</p><p>This project presents diverse examples of experiences that what patients describe as important to them. Hopefully, it can bring greater understanding of the varieties of experiences that become sources of resilience. It is important for chaplains to document the spiritual orientation of patients and how it impacts their emotions and sense of purpose as they confront their challenges. I try to learn whether the patients have a strong sense of what to live for. Like other providers, I encourage the veterans to identify their sense of meaning regardless of their expected outcomes. My approach involves an appreciation that death is a natural result of embodied life. Approaching patients with openness and positive regard can encourage them to share what is important to them and to shed light on their spiritual and emotional needs when they face critical healthcare decisions.</p><p>The literature suggests what my experience seems to confirm, that a sense of meaning and purpose is important for relations, belonging, and self-esteem and can help make medical treatment more effective and possibly improve outcomes for care recipients. Patients can benefit from their past spiritual experiences when they receive treatment, augmenting the medical services and care of doctors, nurses and healthcare technicians. When patients identify experiences of transformation, they often describe purposeful choices motivated by a desire to take a different approach to life or pursue new priorities and embrace new core values.</p><p>These accounts may resemble repentance in Christian theology. Some accounts are dramatic, with visions, sounds, or realizations. These experiences provide meaning in health crises, even into end-of-life care, and especially for the majority of patients who are receiving short-term treatment for illnesses and exacerbations of chronic medical conditions. Patients can improve spontaneously or with the support of the medical team but the experience can be disorienting and frightening. Spiritual care providers can help patients gain support by relying on their inner resources of inspiration, which can bring a sense of gratitude and blessing in a challenging time.</p><p>Chaplains may become aware of how a care recipient’s spiritual orientation affects recovery from medical conditions and life challenges. Providing insight into the patients’ sense of meaning might help foster patient care and inform other members of the medical team. A patient may be more willing to receive additional treatment or undergo difficult medical procedures if he or she has something to live for. A patient who is at peace about a transition may choose a path with quality of life as a priority even if it hastens death. I hope to build greater appreciation of how the patient is a “living human document” with unique experiences and intentions that complement the healing modalities of the medical team. I hope to build awareness of how such experiences and decisions provide resilience and openness to patients that help them face new serious challenges to their agency, capacity, and autonomy.</p><p>Patient Sources and Process of Gathering Narratives</p><p>The patients in the source material that follows were seen by me on an acute care floor when they were receiving inpatient treatment for medical conditions at a Veterans Affairs hospital. Every week this past year, I have seen patients who are in the hospital receiving care, including surgery or diagnostic procedures for chronic conditions or acute injuries, diseases, or conditions. The veterans are typically men in their seventies and eighties. It is not uncommon to speak to men with combat experience from the Vietnam War era healing from trauma from combat or injuries received in military service.</p><p>The selection of the following narratives is subjective and based on the emphasis of importance the spiritual care recipients placed on their experiences. The prominence, clarity, and importance that these events have in marking turning points in patients’ lives is not typical, but their significance is representative of care recipients’ need to find meaning and inspiration for weathering difficult adversity. I routinely ask what inspires patients, and patients mention a wide variety of activities and relations, such as motorcycle rides, fishing, family, pets, and hobbies that do not have the salience of these narratives. These exchanges have stood out as significant at the time I gleaned them. They are not necessarily correlated to unusually beneficial outcomes, but are related to improved quality of life from the patients’ point of view, at least for a brief period of time, but usually much longer.</p><p>This research indicates that perception of anomalous experience, while not typical, occurs more often than many people might expect. Such experiences are very important and meaningful to patients, who often keep these experiences close to their hearts. Originally, I planned to limit accumulation of these experiences to ten months, but I found it hard not to include a few that appeared after July. Metric data collection shows I have made just over 1600 total patient visits in this period, and I collected 60 narratives of resilience and transformation, many of which are accounts of spiritual experiences that are unexplainable from a secular humanist materialist perspective. I often visit patients two or more times when they have prolonged hospital stays.</p><p>Typically, I see seven to ten patients per day, usually five days per week. Roughly one-third of patient visits will be follow-up or repeat patient visits. Sometimes I will interact briefly with one or two patients who show little interest in engagement. A typical individual patient visit will not involve identified spontaneous transformation, healing, or dramatic life-transforming events. Presumably, many patients will not feel motivation to share important spiritual, existential, or religious experiences because they are physically uncomfortable or do not feel a strong affinity with me or are not motivated to confide in a spiritual care provider in a healthcare setting. Most patient accounts of experiences that help provide meaning and purpose to their lives are significant but not as transformative as the ones that I am accumulating and recording here.</p><p>Accounts with unredacted information that will allow for identification to prove authenticity will be stored separately and sent in encrypted form at the conclusion of this project. The accounts in this project are edited for greater clarity and to remove identifying information to protect patient privacy. This is a qualitative review and not an empirical clinical study. My intention is to accumulate information within my role as a spiritual care provider. By collecting and synthesizing the patients’ accounts of experiences that have transformed their lives and helped to provide meaning and purpose to their lives, I hope to identify some recurring themes.</p><p>Chaplains are equipped to help patients find meaning within their suffering to encourage faith to pursue their recovery. Spiritual experience often gives patients new perspective to face often dire circumstances, even their end-of-life existential concerns, with equanimity. As a chaplain and a participant in the healing arts, I believe that this project can provide information about the emotional needs of veterans and generate appreciation for how varied the spiritual and spontaneous experiences care recipients have which provide them with well-being and healing.</p><p>Forms of experience that bring meaning and purpose to motivate changes in lifestyle and orientation</p><p>Religious traditions seek to align one’s body, mind, and spirit in tune with the creative and sustaining forces. Whether called God, Natural Law, or another form of spiritual, existential, religious, or theological term, part of human experience seeks to create order by actions and intentions that are consistent with an order that is restorative and provides energy and seems to be supportive of widespread or universal goodwill and harmony. In times of personal tragedy and when people feel lost, cynical, or betrayed, they often make decisions that do not serve their best interests. Jesus spoke of lost sheep, the prodigal son, the lost coin, and repentance as a way back into the good graces of the higher power.</p><p>Often in times of distress and despair, people’s identities are threatened. Their lives’ purpose and meaning are compromised when they lose capacity to engage in the activities that brought engagement and a sense of belonging, or when they experience grief from the loss of loved ones. It is critical for healing to have a sense of meaning to counter existential despair and feelings of shame and failure that come from having dramatic changes to one’s world view. Prior life experience that led to faith, acceptance, and gratitude help build resilience. It is beyond the scope of this project to chronicle these benefits, but it is important to consider the ways that meaning and purpose can appear in one’s life, become part of one’s narrative, and come into awareness at times of pain, loss, and feelings of emptiness from grave diagnoses.</p><p>Often, veterans will draw inspiration from their sources of meaning and purpose when they survive health crises and reflect on how they found resilience and thrived in their lives. They also describe times when they decide to turn their lives around because they do not want to have a downfall and have experiences like family members or friends who provide negative examples. People who have made positive changes, supported others, and taken risks to help others, cite such experiences as resources for their own healing. For example, a man who had come into the hospital with problem with low pulse was elated with gratitude after fearing that he would not survive. He was expecting to be restored to his life activities. He reflected on how, as a youth minister in his forties, he helped support and encourage many young people for many years. He shared how he had invested love and goodwill toward others and felt that his life had been blessed by God’s spirit and the presence of angels. He was not afraid of the afterlife and he was giving God the glory for his experiences of life and feelings of goodwill.</p><p>Veterans in medical care can have better outcomes with favorable and affirming spiritual care. Religion and spirituality have been associated with positive health outcomes. Researchers have shown that patients who find meaning in spiritual, religious, existential, and theological perspectives find these attitudes protective when facing mild to moderate depression and anxiety. Spiritual and religious orientation can help insulate people from having posttraumatic stress disorder when they have experience with trauma and violence. <em>See</em>, Balboni, T. <em>et al</em>. editors, “Spirituality in serious illness and health,” Journal of the American Medical Association. (2022) 328(2):184–197 10.1001/jama.2022.11086 <a href="https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/35819420/">https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/35819420/</a>; Fitchett, G. and Nolan, S., editors, Spiritual Care in Practice: Case Studies in Healthcare Chaplaincy (February 2015); Fitchett, G., Rybarczyk, B. D., DeMarco, G. A., &amp; Nicholas, J. J. (1999). “The role of religion in medical rehabilitation outcomes: A longitudinal study,” <em>Rehabilitation Psychology, 44</em>(4), 333–353. <a href="https://psycnet.apa.org/doi/10.1037/0090-5550.44.4.333">https://doi.org/10.1037/0090-5550.44.4.333</a>; VandeCreek, L., Lucas, A., editors, “The Discipline for Pastoral Care Giving: Foundations for Outcome Oriented Chaplaincy,” Journal of Health Care Chaplaincy, Volume 10, Number 2 2001 and Volume 11, Number 1 2001.</p><p>During my chaplaincy, I became more comfortable addressing mortality and the veterans’ thoughts and beliefs about the afterlife. I noticed a wide variety of outlooks and noticed a sense of relief when veterans realized that they could discuss death with openness and in a peaceful way. Our culture avoids death discussions, but people must confront its reality in the hospital or spend considerable effort to avoid doing so. Some research shows that this confrontation with death can help people find improved quality of life. In psychology, the term “mortality salience” describes engagement with death consciously through therapy or contemplation. Some research indicates it can increase resources such as increased gratitude and improved relations with others, and increased appreciation of one’s place in creation. <em>See</em>, Cozzolino, P. J., “Death contemplation, growth, and defense: Converging evidence of dual-existential systems?” <em>Psychological Inquiry</em>, 17, 278–287(2006); Hicks, J. and Routledge, C. The experience of meaning in life: Classical perspectives, emerging themes, and controversies (2013).</p><p>Vail et al., <em>Personality and Social Psychology Review</em>, 16(4) 303–329 (2012) have described how acceptance of the reality of death brings about improved satisfaction in life and greater freedom to prioritize what brings people greater satisfaction and relationships with others. <a href="https://existentialpsych.sites.tamu.edu/wp-content/uploads/sites/152/2020/02/Vail-III-K.-E.-Juhl-J.-Arndt-J.-Vess-M.-Routledge-C.-Rutjens-B.-T.-2012.-When-death-is-good-for-life.pdf">https://existentialpsych.sites.tamu.edu/wp-content/uploads/sites/152/2020/02/Vail-III-K.-E.-Juhl-J.-Arndt-J.-Vess-M.-Routledge-C.-Rutjens-B.-T.-2012.-When-death-is-good-for-life.pdf</a></p><p>Community organizer and activist Saul Alinsky describes how accepting mortality helped him focus on his priorities:</p><p>I have learned one lesson, I learned it in my belly, the astonishing lesson that I wasn’t going to live forever…After the full realization, on a gut basis, that I was going to die, my whole life changed. I was confronted with the question, ‘What is the meaning of my life, since I’m here just so long a period of time?’ I’ve never been able to answer that question. I don’t ever expect to answer it. But I know that once you reach the point of accepting your own death, you no longer care much whether you’re important or not important.</p><p>I have spoken to several veterans who have visions during surgery or other interventions that help give them inspiration. Some recent research has identified positive benefits from dream states when patients come out from anesthesia. Dr. Lauren Hack, Dr. Harrison Chow, and Dr. Pillerin Sikka authored a research article, “Reduction in trauma-related symptoms after anesthetic-induced intra-operative dreaming,” in the American Journal of Psychiatry, 2024 Jun 1;181(6):563–564. <a href="https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/38476046/">https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/38476046/</a> . Boris Heifets, M.D., Ph.D., an anesthesiology professor at Stanford University, discussed these findings at Emory University’s 2026 Science on Spiritual Health Conference. The research revealed that two-thirds of patients with dreams in gentle awakening from anesthesia had very positive outcomes, and another 20 % had somewhat positive outcomes. Some patients reported resolution of post-traumatic stress disorder. Dr. Heifets stated that this research urges allowing patients to continue under anesthesia quietly and gently, rather than reviving them before they awaken in the natural course, in order to obtain possible benefits to help ease trauma. He suggests further exploring intentional dream induced anesthesia involving slowly emerging from anesthesia and integrating their visions.</p><p>Patient Accounts of Sources of Inspiration for Faith, Healing, and Transformation</p><p>September 2025</p><p>1). A near-death experience inspires a man to quit smoking cigarettes.</p><p>A veteran who is 66 and unhoused had a vision that helped him recover from heart surgery. He shared a triumphant narrative about visions he received when he had heart surgery in 2008. He was transformed when he had a vision of Jesus and angels and visions of consequences that led him to quit smoking cigarettes. His guardian angel appeared and he bowed and was trembling, feeling guilty about causing his illness by smoking. He heard the angel say, “arise, my son,” and assured him that he was not in trouble. He was told, “someone wants to see you.” It was Jesus Christ, and he had a hug that helped him heal and feel total peace. He let him see his mother, who had died, and even a pet cat who had died. He felt comforted and wanted to stay, but he was told to go back and let people know about his experiences. His guardian angel was a woman. Another angel, Uriel, led him to visit hell, which had three levels, one with sinners and he saw people being forced to smoke there. He also saw heaven, and noticed that there were rooms with no bathrooms or kitchens around, since people did not have the same needs as on earth or were provided for, but he said that people do not get bored there.</p><p>2). A deliberate choice to become a new person to overcome post-traumatic stress disorder:</p><p>A 77-year-old veteran had a challenging childhood, with a mother who had bipolar mood disorder and a father who was alcoholic and a sexual predator who later became active in church. The veteran moved frequently, lived in solitude at times and with his grandmother, before he enlisted in the Marines and had some traumatic experiences in Vietnam. He shared his way to heal from PTSD that had led him to be angry, have poor control of his emotions, and he often woke up sweating. He said that he made a deliberate choice to “leave himself behind” and form a new identity. He expressed self-consciousness about this but he emphasized that it was a positive choice and that it was something he had decided to do to address a problem that seemed out of control. He is not involved in a church community because of the many differences between faith traditions, and he grew to trust more in his own experience.</p><p>October 2025</p><p>3). A message from the afterlife and a near-death experience inspire less fear of death and greater compassion.</p><p>A patient in his seventies had terrible back pain from an accident and was on long-term pain management treatment requiring opioid medication to function and was considering a revision surgery to implant a second pain pump. He became involved with church after a transformative experience when he was in a coma for 3 or 4 days after the motor vehicle accident. He observed his body from above and saw a nurse reading a magazine when a large tree limb crashed through the window and he had come to consciousness. About 15 years before his hospital admission, he had lost relatives including a beloved son-in-law who left a young daughter. A few months later, he did some automatic writing without focus, went to bed and found the following morning that he had written had been messages from his late son-in-law to impart confidence that his daughter would be a good and responsible person and assured them that there is life after death. This insight gave him relief from fear, motivated him to be a caring and responsible person, and to tolerate his pain. He became more focused on priorities involving kindness and had distanced himself from a friend who had adopted cruel behavior after serving in the Vietnam War.</p><p>4). A patient’s life turned around when he gave his cares over to God.</p><p>A 70-year-old man described his trauma as a child from having a father who was very stern, unkind, and distant. He and his siblings had a lot of chores and would not be fed unless they did them each day. He discontinued contact with his family after his mother died and struggled as he was intent on being different from his father. In his early forties, he felt his struggle overwhelming him and he decided to give everything up and he told God he would leave it all in His hands. When he gave over his cares and asked God to lead him, things started to fall into place and his burden was removed. He shared his narrative of resilience, how he showed great loyalty to his sons, built a life that seemed full of joy, including a business. He had supported his family with love and concern, including his ex-wife, who had been recovering from addiction for many years while he had custody of their children.</p><p>5). A patient feels the blessing of the Holy Spirit helped him live through combat in Vietnam.</p><p>A man in health distress related a narrative about a spiritual experience when he was a young man of 17 and had enlisted in the Marines. Just before he entered the service, a young pastor appeared at his home and met him, his mother, and his brothers, invited them to go to a church service. The patient went and when he was receiving a prayer from the pastor, he felt very strong flow of energy when the man placed his hands on him. He felt a force unlike anything he ever felt, before or since, that he could not describe or explain, which he associated with his survival when he served as a platoon sergeant in Vietnam and was responsible for 30 men. The veteran said that he felt the strength to withstand the combat safely. I asked if it could have been the Holy Spirit, and he said that he did not know what it was, but it had given him the confidence that he would be all right. He felt that this helped him withstand the combat dangers for two years, during which time he would step over mines and would have snipers fire at him and hit other soldiers. One time, the veteran heard a Vietcong intruder and woke up to save people while bullets were flying around him and took the lives of others around him.</p><p>6). A patient made lifestyle changes with retirement.</p><p>A man in his mid-seventies had had a series of medical treatments in the hospital in recent years. He said that he had retired after a career in public service and involvement with youth development after he had a back injury. He developed medical problems with pre-diabetes, arthritis and cardiovascular problems. He decided to improve his health, and he began to lose weight and exercise, walking and riding a stationary bicycle. He had declined nerve medication, choosing to use turmeric and change his diet. He had lost 100 pounds, and despite bone-on-bone hip arthritis, he found he could exercise on a stationary bicycle without hip pain. He is motivated by his interests and his grandchildren and great-grandchildren and making to best use of his remaining time in life.</p><p>7). A grandchild inspires a woman’s recovery from addiction.</p><p>I met a woman patient who had been afflicted by personal tragedies and betrayals as well as very uplifting relations. She had had an unstable childhood with an abusive stepfather and had been raised by her grandparents. When she had three young children, her ex-husband</p><p>divorced her and left her for another woman. She had been disrespected and fired by her employer when she was a single mother when she was blamed after an employee stole some money from the cash register. She later gave up a child for adoption when she was raped. She had been self-sacrificial, trying to save her marriage, and was scrupulous in finding adoptive parents for the child and forming a relationship with him. She shared all this in the presence of one of her granddaughters and it seemed very important for her to share. I responded with a statement about how her trauma sounded so overwhelming and intense that it would have caused so much pain and despair that many people would become suicidal or addicted to drugs to deal with such suffering. She confided that she had in fact become addicted to crack cocaine, but had stopped and returned to her home community to heal when she had her first grandchild. She had found her son and daughters to be a blessing in her life, and her narrative described many actions of resilience, strength, and courage to heal from her disappointments, including deepening relations with her children and the son she gave up for adoption. Her redemption experience inspired her to channel adversity to deepen her values and relations and she learned to value herself and stand up for her family.</p><p>8). A man adopts lifestyle changes due to a medical diagnosis.</p><p>One of the patients I met was a man who had been in the hospital for a week and he accepted my follow-up visit. His niece was present for part of the time. He said that he had not had to go to the hospital before he was 59. He said he had received a diagnosis of stage 4 cirrhosis and he had a cough and tremors that affected his mobility, making it too difficult to walk even short distances. He said that when he quit drinking, he had developed severe tremors and it became painful to move. He was animated, after days when he was not very engaged, explaining that he saw as opportunity to maximize his remaining time. He had asked his neighbor remove all the alcohol from his house and give it away or throw it away, and he was researching how to eat a healthy liver diet with high protein and low sodium. He wanted to be more active and avoid atrophy from lying in bed. He was not religious and the roster listed his religion as “unknown/no preference.” He was eager to return home and his niece expressed that she was dedicated to making the same changes to help support him.</p><p>9). A patient had a conversion experience in jail</p><p>One of my patients, a man in his late eighties, shared his account of a conversion experience he had had as a young man. At the time, he was an alcoholic and was confined in jail, and a young minister reached out to him and prayed for him. He said that he had been inspired, he stopped drinking, and he had avoided alcohol ever since. Later, he served in the Marine Corps for several years and after his service, he had begun a prison ministry first with another man, and then by himself. He did this independently and not as an affiliate of a particular religion. He was a nondenominational Christian and he had attended church initially, and later had developed a solitary devotional practice. He suggested that he had not been fully saved until later in his life. He seemed to recognize how the choices he had made over time are part of a process. He implied that redemption was a process. He was inspired by his long-term marriage that had lasted many years. He said that he reads the Bible every day.</p><p>November:</p><p>10). A near-death experience in a dream led to identifying an important relationship that gives meaning and purpose.</p><p>One patient I visited was a single man under forty with hypertension and who was getting established in dialysis treatment. He was having fluid accumulate and was improving after over 30 pounds of fluid was being drawn off his body. He has recently lost his father and he was helping his divorced sister with the care needs of her children. He described himself as an introvert who had been reluctant to share his feelings. He grew up as a Christian but felt that many religious traditions “cherry pick” aspects of teachings and life experience and would not deal with the full picture of reality. He confided that he had been unhappy and isolated with little joy or sense of purpose, and had even considered giving up on life before his niece and nephew entered his life. He was having dire distress with medical issues when a near-death experience allowed him to identify his love and loyalty for his niece as providing meaning that has inspired his healing. One night he dreamed that he was hovering over his body in an out-of-the-body experience. In his dream, his young niece was trying to wake him up. When he woke, he realized he had the strong motivation to be present for his niece, and he told me about his appreciation for her expressiveness and how she shared her emotions. He felt his affection for her had given his life meaning and he felt the courage to provide a beautiful presence for her. He said he was grateful for his opportunity to be more active and not to feel terribly ill as he was before being established for dialysis. He was looking forward to the coming time when he would return home and feel well again.</p><p>11). Feeling absence of suffering in proximity to death brings a veteran a sense of peace.</p><p>A man who was a heart transplant recipient was admitted for complications that required extensive hospital follow up. He had a lot of fatigue and he had been in the hospital for five days at the time of this chaplain visit. His blood count was concerning and he hoped it would improve. He was active in his church community and in civic life in a small town in another state. He had humbly informed his pastor not to make a big deal when he returned to his church after his heart transplant. He shared that he was accepting of what would come his way as being part of God’s will. He had had a coronary bypass several years before the heart transplant, which had taken place almost a year before this visit. At one point in his treatment, he had “coded” and he was revived, but the process did not really phase him. His immediate concern was for his wife who had had to witness distressing measures to bring him back. He felt that God has mysterious ways, citing how he had called his mother on Mother’s Day, and she died that evening after telling him that she was “ready to go.” She had had her possessions packed up when they went to her place. He had been inspired to de-clutter his own home and he no longer felt anxious or fearful about the next life. He planned to devote his coming time with openness for discernment and engagement that would be revealed in time. He emphasized his feeling that God has a plan for him.</p><p>12). Near death experience yields hope with a sense of purpose.</p><p>A return patient had been on our unit for five days when we met, and we had met several months before. He said that after his son had died in their home a few years earlier that he almost drank himself to death from despair. He also had trauma from wartime violence. He was from a religious family and was close to his widowed mother and his living son. He shared great news that he was cleared for a liver transplant and was not far down on the waiting list. He was elated and confident that he would pass the drug screens and receive this gift after a year and a half of problems with liver function. He was inspired by an incident when his son had helped him recover from an alcohol-related near-death experience. The veteran stated that he had basically “died,” and that he had seen his deceased son who had died of a grand mal seizure and told him to go and “be there” for his living son. He spoke with good humor about a traumatic divorce many years earlier and the ways he related so well with her current husband. He was carrying grief and loss but he was enthusiastic about devoting himself to conditioning his body and was hoping to improve his health.</p><p>13). A series of dreams gives a man a sense of purpose and a mission that motivates him.</p><p>A man who was admitted for chest pain and had come to the hospital by bus, was coping with housing insecurity. Nevertheless, he expressed a strong sense of faith and calling. He had requested a large print King James version of the Bible, which I brought to him, and he asked me to walk with him in the hallways. As we walked, he described having a visit from an angel who had told him to fast for three days, stating that he would have dreams each night and receive information to know that God had sent him. His dreams revealed imagery of the inside of an art deco style building that had a cross and other indicia that it was a church. When he was visited by the angel again, he did not say what the vision was revealing, but that he would be receiving another person’s visitation.</p><p>The patient said that he spoke to a chaplain before being released from prison, who told him to go to a certain area of town, where he found the church he had seen in his dreams. He met a man there who had been waiting for him, and this contact led to him entering a long program to train people in a spirituality program and develop the capacity to help others. Over the years, he said that he had developed powers for healing others, and by singing and helping people out of difficult situations. He had to let go of pride. He said that he was devoted to Jesus of Nazareth, stressing the importance of identifying him specifically. His moods would shift from elation to tearfulness, as he spoke, and I suspected that his inspiration may be partly magical thinking. He showed some grandiose thoughts, stating that he was placed in the hospital to help other patients and that there is nothing wrong with his health, although he was using a walker, he had chest pain, and his records indicated substance issues.</p><p>14). A heart attack sparks a change in a traumatized Vietnam veteran.</p><p>A male veteran in his early eighties said that he had been heavily self-medicating himself after experiencing combat trauma. He was admitted for a short stay after some falls and several bouts of pneumonia. He had been healing and coping from deep trauma after combat duty in Vietnam but he realized that healing would never be complete. He said that having to sort and return effects after his comrades died was very hard. He lived in the same rural area near his birthplace and had a strong sense of place. He had met his wife by chance in the mid-1980s and he had a heart attack a few weeks after they married. He gave up heavy drinking and smoking tobacco and cannabis and he challenged himself by placing a pack of cigarettes on a shelf and staring it down. He went on to invest himself in his community and started a successful business that he ran for almost 40 years. He enjoyed a strong marriage. He and his wife had a close relationship with their son and his family with three grandchildren. He gladly accepted my offer to pray but he said that he does not participate in church activities because he objects to the financial emphasis of churches. He was excited to be able to share his enthusiasm for spirituality and asked for contact information.</p><p>December 2025</p><p>15). A near-death experience gives a man confidence in this life and the afterlife.</p><p>A Jewish veteran in his mid-sixties had had many health challenges that he had surmounted, bringing himself to an active life after a period of immobility. When he had very serious health challenges, he was unconscious for eight minutes. He saw visions of multiple geometric patterns, and he directed his intention to finding a deeper meaning. He said he heard a voice that told him when it was his time, God would take his breath from him. He said this is what happened to his father. This an event led him to have faith in God’s presence and gave him some peace about the afterlife. This brought him confidence that it was not his time. We discussed some parts of religious texts. He mentioned how God took breath away at death, and with Moses, he took him up to heaven.</p><p>16). A mother quit smoking to set a good example for her daughter after her own mother had set an example of inability to quit.</p><p>A woman who appeared confident and secure and who valued her strength and independence was sharing her narrative during a chaplain visit. We discussed raising children and she shared that her mother was a cigarette smoker who got lung cancer but did not quit smoking. The patient said that she had quit smoking due to an experience when she was a young mother. She was smoking as she was a sitting next to her young daughter. When her daughter said that she would smoke like her when she grew up, this led her to quit right away.</p><p>17). A church service led to a man having a born-again repentance experience and becoming active in the Assemblies of God.</p><p>A man in his mid-eighties shared his experience of being reborn during a hospital stay for fluid accumulation. He said that about ten years after his military experience, he was smoking three packs of cigarettes per day and he was drinking alcohol. Although he was married, he said that he was preoccupied with “chasing women.” He was in his early thirties when he turned his life over to Jesus Christ on a date he remembered specifically. He went to a church service and he said that Jesus asked him in and he has been changed ever since. He was active with a mission outreach program that was helping people with addiction and alcoholism through spirituality. He met his current wife after his experience of being reborn. He had gone to a Bible college in his mid-thirties and he became involved in rehabilitation ministries and serving as a pastor. He was interested in details about the accounts in the Bible. He was teaching at a rehabilitation facility in another state and learned about a new branch opening in Tennessee and came here in the mid-1980s. He has been living in a small town, helping drug addicts and alcoholics ever since.</p><p>18). A born-again experience leads to home-schooling of children.</p><p>A man in his early sixties met with me when he was receiving treatment for diabetes-related health problems. He had swelling and pain in his foot and substantial challenges with mobility. His parents were divorced and his father would build churches overseas, although he lived with his mother and stepfather growing up. He recalled the date when he became born again at a church service, which led to his lifelong identification as a Pentecostal Christian. The experience led to him making changes in his priorities and building his reputation. He had a 50-year marriage to a Native American woman who maintained close relations with her relatives and community. He and his wife chose to home-school their children with a Christian curriculum and he said that he did not trust the government to be involved in education, apparently because of secular influences. His brother was a pastor at a different church from the worship community he attended. He said that he considered himself to be very family-oriented and stressed that his spirituality is a priority for him.</p><p>January 2026</p><p>19). A spontaneous spiritual “download” leads to confidence and assurance and ushers in a more thriving life.</p><p>A white Catholic male Marine veteran in his late fifties was being treated for foot pain from osteomyelitis and an infected foot joint. He described a vision of premonition he received on a specific day about ten years earlier when he could foresee future events involving his children. He was very excited and shared rich details about his life interests and experience. His transformation took place after a series of experiences of chance encounters that were synchronistic with his visions. He recognized that he was flawed and yet he still considered himself to be an instrument of God at a time when he was having a period of disability and distress with his vocation and family. His young daughter had had paranormal experiences with moving objects and being lifted. He was drawing associations from passages from Jeremiah and Ezekiel that were brought to his attention. He heard a Catholic priest tell him, “if you don’t regard evil, it will go away.”</p><p>As he stayed up one night reading the Bible, a voice he heard as he read from Genesis asked if he wanted to know “how this all worked.” He was directed him to look at himself in the mirror, receiving a message that he was created beautifully, and that what had happened he had done to himself. He was told he was known before he was born and would be known again, but not if he was “like that,” meaning changes were needed. He received other messages about dedication to spiritual values and not being overly focused on money. God offered to use his hands, and warned he would be tested, like Job, and feel abandoned before his life would be restored. Circumstances then ensued that affirmed his sense of calling. A woman offered him work, saying that she had been led to give him a Catholic medal to encourage him, knowing he was having a time of identification with Job. After his visionary and synchronistic experiences, his family had thought he was psychotic, but his marriage improved, he developed a successful business, he got a side job and lost weight, which led to a sense of greater confidence and faith.</p><p>20). A passage of scripture and reflection leads to grace.</p><p>An African-American patient in his early seventies was receiving treatment for atrial fibrillation and weakness. He was a widower and a retired pastor, who had fallen at his home and he had been having weakness. He had some very tragic losses, grief, and trauma. He described a traumatic childhood with an emotionally abusive mother whose friend had molested him for three years when he was young. He reflected on his lengthy service as a pastor, his theological education, and how he had ordained many ministers while serving as a pastor, and his sadness about how the church had diminished in size to few members. He had retired after Covid and a loss of membership. He identified as a source of strength and resilience an experience over thirty years earlier. He said that he had surrendered to God when he released his resentment and hatred spontaneously while studying a passage from scripture, Romans 4:17, that inspired him to live into a better world. He conceptualized it as advice to “speak those things as though they were.” He had previously identified himself as an alcoholic or addict, the way people in Twelve Step programs will, but in that moment, he freed himself to adopt a better identity. He had maintained sobriety and been “clean” ever since. He was coping with trauma and grief by reflecting on his inspiration and seeing every moment as a choice. I encouraged him to recognize that he is beloved by God and to care for himself with loving kindness.</p><p>21). A near-death experience and lessons from spiritualism inspire a patient with courage and optimism despite news of recurring lung cancer.</p><p>A male patient in his late seventies shared his insights from spiritualism that gave him courage to face a recurrence of lung cancer. After having survived a prior case and having a lobe of his lung removed, he received news that indicated its recurrence in another lobe. Nevertheless, he responded with optimism that he gleaned from insights that he wanted to discuss as he was getting ready to be discharged. He was not devastated or crushed by the sobering news. He had had near-death experiences that reaffirmed his belief that people never die, they just shed their bodies and reform with spirit renewed and take on flesh. He described experiences in his childhood of communication with spirit entities named Michael and David, whom he identified as the archangel Michael and King David,. He learned arcane details about creation from them and said that he would travel to many places, in reality and in his imagination. He had enlisted in the Army because he wanted to be in combat during the Vietnam War, but he later saw through this motive of domination through his studies. He had become inspired by a scientist, Bruce Lipton, who studied epigenetics, and spiritualists Edgar Cayce, Hugh Lynn, and Walter Russell. He had come to realize that love is the fundamental principle of the universe. He believed that fear is the source of illnesses, and that ancient humans were much larger and lived much longer.</p><p>22). Protective parental instincts inspire healing from alcohol poisoning.</p><p>A young white male veteran in his thirties had been having abdominal pain for a week and was about to be discharged. He lived in a rural area with open space in the countryside. He had a solitary personality style with principles of devotion. He said that he had been drinking daily and smoking cigarettes for years and he quit about a month earlier. He was divorced and had a devoted girlfriend. He was recovering from trauma and growing in strength, but had suffered some liver damage and hoped to gain improved function. He had a son who was seven years old and he said that his protective instincts and his love for his son inspired his recent choice to quit his years-long daily pattern of drinking and smoking.</p><p>23). An idiosyncratic angelic presence and synchronous events inspire faith in a woman.</p><p>One female patient in her mid-sixties grew up in a Southern Baptist tradition. She had chemical-induced epilepsy that had ended her military career, and she had come for neurological care and physical therapy after having a severe seizure. She had family support but had grief from an unhappy marriage and had lost a couple of her siblings. She showed a sense of humor that she said was part of her openness to spirituality. She described ironic events that thwarted a baptism when she was young, first having stepped on a rusty nail and then slipping and falling during the approach to the baptismal font. She later found another church and was baptized there. She went to a revival service long ago, and one of the preachers appeared to her to be glowing. The brilliance and sense of inspiration she noticed was inspiring, but others did not notice it, and the man left right after speaking. It led her to believe there are transcendent experiences of the Spirit.</p><p>Her most inspiring experience, however, was about 35 years earlier, when she was trapped in an unhappy, verbally abusive marriage. After her husband berated her, she felt overwhelmed with despair and like her burden was more than she could tolerate. She fell asleep, entertaining self-destructive thoughts. She drifted to a reverie seeing a long alleyway and saw herself walking, when an exuberant and joyful being, like a stick figure on a wet floor sign, was going in and out of her and uplifting her and making her feel joy. This continued, inspiring her with love and a sense that she should live and enjoy life. She woke up feeling rejuvenated. This experience has helped uplift and sustain her over the years, even when she felt downcast with residual PTSD and her seizure and arthritic problems.</p><p>24). A near-death experience provided comfort and faith for this life and the afterlife.</p><p>I met a combat veteran in his early seventies who was in the hospital for a couple of weeks receiving treatment after he had had a life-threatening neck injury from a fall. During the middle of his stay, he confided that he had been feeling challenged in his faith, wondering how God could let this happen to him when he had been so devoted to helping others. He wanted to have the use of his arms and legs and have mobility. He had developed a priority for spirituality after he had held comrades dying of combat wounds in two wars, and he had only begun to appreciate that he had not known what was going on in their heads. He had been a minister and was involved in Christian volunteer work, continued to be devout, and had helped bring people to the gospel of Jesus Christ.</p><p>He shared an experience when he had clinically died after a heart attack. He recalled a feeling while he had been unconscious of having been wrapped in what felt like blankets. He said that it was like being a baby surrounded by love and warmth. He said that all fear and negativity left him and that he felt great love and comfort. His cares eased away and he was then awakened by a surgeon who slapped him and he was told he had threatened to retaliate. His experience had resolved his fear of death. He said that he would like to be fully healed or ease into the next life, stating that he is not afraid to die, and he said that he would not want to live with his current limitations. His persistence led his to neurosurgical treatment that helped improve his function and strengthened his relationships with his neighbors and family.</p><p>25). A close call with death brings gratitude for life and a sense of purpose.</p><p>A man who had been admitted for very disorienting symptoms and shortness of breath said that he had been in and out of hospitals for a couple of months. He had some medication changes, and he had noticed positive developments with a weight loss regimen and reduction in his dose of antidepressants. He confided that he had been suicidal when he was growing up due to low self-esteem, and he developed addictive patterns that had affected him. He had turned his life around after a felony conviction and serving over ten years in prison. He had made positive changes that led to reduction of a longer sentence, and he had been a good citizen in the two decades since he was released. He said that he had been a workaholic, extending himself for others and being a provider, but still had felt some emptiness inside until an incident about eight years earlier. He had been involved in a very serious motor vehicle accident. He broke his arm and was upside down when he was cut out of the car by EMT personnel. He had felt like there was no reason for him to live, but in that moment, he decided that God had a purpose for him. He celebrated his joys of a happy family with children, saying that he enjoyed being a grandfather for his three grandchildren.</p><p>26). Spontaneous writing announces spiritual engagement with Catholicism during a health crisis.</p><p>A male patient in his late sixties with a professional career was raised in the Roman Catholic Church, but when he enlisted in the Navy at a young age, he lost all engagement with religion apart from attending weddings and funerals. He was unfamiliar with the Bible. After years of being an endurance athlete and helping with volunteer events to raise funds for The Leukemia and Lymphoma Society for several years, he had been diagnosed with an unusual form of leukemia. He was dismayed; he felt devastated and had a sense of betrayal from his diagnosis. He was anticipating being scheduled for a bone marrow transplant in a few weeks. He was very excited to describe a significant automatic writing experience occurring on a specific date in 2024, when he had written absent mindedly, on a Post-It note, “It starts today.” He bought a Bible not long afterward and had noticed a Catholic church near his home. He was very excited about his engagement there, his newly-revived membership and engagement with his tradition from childhood, and how his wife was interested in the changes in his outlook. He expressed humility and great humor to avoid taking himself too seriously, and not arguing with his wife anymore. He described acts of kindness and excitement about his new faith. He was reading the Bible daily, and was particularly inspired by the Book of Job.</p><p>February 2026</p><p>27). Spontaneous remission of addiction.</p><p>A patient who was in his early seventies had come to the hospital for abdominal and gastric pain when we met following his colonoscopy. He shared a triumphant narrative about being freed from a severe alcohol and drug problem over thirty years earlier. He was living in a city where he grew up and he had gotten into a habit of drinking heavy amounts of strong alcohol daily and using illegal drugs. He said that God removed the desire to engage in this behavior, which had become a very disabling addiction. He had entered a halfway house but he said that the problem simply dissipated. His wife had died a few years earlier and he was having feelings of grief. Overall, he said that his outlook was inspired by the uplifting experience of having had the burden lifted and seeing the light. He would encourage others and do motivational speaking as a way to express gratitude and a sense of purpose.</p><p>28). Spontaneous grace easing deep grief and trauma.</p><p>A male Vietnam veteran in his mid-seventies who had had heart problems and prostate cancer was admitted for dizziness and light-headedness. He explained that he had survived severe trauma in combat in Vietnam and he believed that Agent Orange exposure was the source of his prostate cancer. He was happily married and he reflected a peaceful and thoughtful outlook. He shared his faith, designated as “unknown, no preference,” which gave him assurance about the afterlife. He saw the afterlife as not being much different from this life. He was influenced by foundational classical philosophy and literature. He does not view this faith as courage but more like knowledge. He has an orientation that perceives the presence of the Divine as part of the physical world, a nondual or unitary presence that is not separate from the phenomenal world. After one of their sons died about seventeen years earlier, he endured three years of terrible grief that made it hard to cope. One morning about three years later, he was driving to work and spontaneously felt a great peace and lifting of the burden of grief. It reminded me of John Wesley’s experience in 1738, when he described “feeling my heart strangely warmed,” and the mystical coming to terms of Julian of Norwich. This experience had helped him feel peaceful amidst health and social challenges.</p><p>29). Spontaneous transformation and recovery one day at a manufacturing plant.</p><p>A male patient in his late seventies shared an experience that led him to a spontaneous shift of priorities and a lifestyle transformation. He was working at an industrial plant in a large southern city in the mid-seventies. He had become dissatisfied with his lifestyle, which involved sharing pornography with a co-worker. He described how he had mysteriously become motivated to surrender himself and live for God. He went to the factory rooftop and gave himself to God and overcame the ways of life that did not honor the Spirit. He did not understand the transformation fully, but he had noticed a difference when he went downstairs and one of his co-workers asked him how things were going, and he replied that he was “just saved.” He felt like he proclaimed something. Afterwards, he developed a jail ministry community in that city that he continues to participate in every other week. He also had grown a jail ministry in the rural county where he had moved after retiring. He felt that his ministry was ordained directly and he does not seek to conform to a particular denomination. He studies scripture and is Christian but he is happy to keep the ministry unreduced and feels that it is perfect. He feels confidence in this life and to face the next one.</p><p>30). A near-death, out of the body experience imparts confidence in the afterlife, as well as forgiveness and understanding.</p><p>An Army veteran in his mid-seventies was very welcoming of a chaplain visit. He shared his sources of inspiration that gave him faith in the afterlife. He had been receiving care for possible liver cancer and an accumulation of fluid that made it uncomfortable to breathe. Despite the fear of his condition and his grief from the past, he felt gratitude and healing from forgiveness. He said that he had an inspiring near death experience that gives him confidence and courage as well as the desire to improve and fulfill his purpose in his remaining time. He had been at this hospital years ago for a surgery when he found himself rising above his body in a spiritual body. He observed his physical body with tubes and surrounded by medical staff. He became aware that he was in the presence of spiritual higher power and received a message that invited him to remain in that realm. He was told, “I’ll take you with me if you’re ready.” He realized that he wanted to remain there and he had the desire to improve his way of life. He had already left behind personal habits involving alcohol, drugs, and sex that did not give him feelings of self-respect, but he still had “a few pieces of paper to pick up” in his life to place things in proper order. His experience led him to feel hopeful about the next life.</p><p>He was raised by his grandparents who were raised in slavery and emancipated. He had lived with many relatives, with no water, no electricity, and no indoor plumbing. He grew up with spiritual influence, but he said he had been in and out of jail for years. He had been mistreated by his grandfather and step grandfather, and overcame his resentment before they died, helping cook and support his step grandfather when he was ill. His grandfather had lost his savings when he was exploited by a lawyer who represented his brothers, who were being prosecuted for crimes they did not commit. When he found this out, he learned to forgive him for years of abusive behavior. He was a member of a church and had completed a twenty-year period of sobriety and has accumulated wisdom and patience. He said that he had a period of resentment after he worked hard to be a deacon and he was told that he was not qualified. His experiences had helped him honor himself and not get caught up in resentment.</p><p>31). A father’s poor example and a teacher’s dismissal of his potential led a veteran to determination and persistence.</p><p>A veteran in his early eighties was being treated for about a week to monitor his heart function when we met a couple of times. Although he had lost the manual dexterity he needed to engage in his pastime of woodworking that he had enjoyed up until a couple of years previously, he said that he had never been happier. He attributed his happiness to a restored relationship with his daughter and his financial freedom after divorces and mistreatment by others. He had endured severe trauma and had worked very hard to be a careful and caring father and a responsible citizen. He grew up in a log cabin that did not have running water. His father was a tenant farmer and an alcoholic who would have different farming jobs every year and would squander what little money he had and not support his family. He saw his father passed out and drunk in a barn and resolved never to be like him. He had also been humiliated by his fourth grade teacher, who dismissed his goal of being a pilot one day, saying that he never would amount to much and would always do menial work. He had not finished school.</p><p>The veteran had lost contact with his only daughter when his first wife had lied to her and claimed he had been killed in Vietnam. She had later found him and they developed a close relationship. She and her husband lived nearby him and he enjoyed a good relationship with his only granddaughter, who lived in another state. Although he had been disenchanted with a conservative religion he participated in through his grandparents, and had had severe trauma after serving in Vietnam and struggled with alcoholism, he became religious after an experience he shared with me. He said he was driving a truck in another state one day, and he decided to find a church which he attended on that road trip and had positive interactions with the pastor. He later encouraged his older sister to find a church with him. He supported a charity to help address hunger in rural counties. He farmed for many years and he has been industrious and a stable influence. He would drink occasionally, but not to excess. He attended Protestant churches with one of his sisters, became an elder, and moved around between mainline Protestant churches and a Mennonite community.</p><p>32). A tragedy and an encounter with an empathic stranger give inspiration for a spiritual transformation.</p><p>I met with a veteran in his late seventies who had been treated for heart problems for a few days and who was about to be discharged with a medication regimen. He was animated and expressed gratitude about outliving his doctors’ expectation after a major heart attack 25 years earlier. He was happy to share a narrative of resilience and he identified a specific date when he became a Christian in the mid-1970s. He was inspired by the synchronicity of events. He was on a payphone at a laundromat, speaking with his mother. His mother told him that three of his friends had killed another of his friends, a young man who was somewhat slow mentally, in the small town where he grew up. The veteran became furious and incredulous as he tried to process the information. A man who had heard his conversation approached the veteran afterward and asked him if he knew what it meant to be a Christian. During the discussion, he encouraged the veteran and asked if he would be willing to make the choice of discipleship. When he said he was reluctant at the time to do so, the man gave the veteran his phone number and offered to explore the subject further. The following day, something came over him and he called the man and suggested going to a film, Time to Run, produced in association with Billy Graham’s ministries. Events coalesced that were surprising. The man changed plans for that evening with his own wedding rehearsal, when his fiancé gave her blessings for him to attend the film with the veteran. The veteran went, and the film’s depiction of a young man’s poor choices about priorities seemed biographical for his own life. He said that his heart was changed. He persisted in his faith.</p><p>March 2026</p><p>33). Adversity, including near-death experience, motivates a man to overcome obstacles and live fully.</p><p>A Vietnam veteran in his mid-seventies was receiving treatment for myasthenia gravis and had survived a series of strokes, childhood poverty, and trauma in combat, yet he lived an open and engaged life and had proven resilient in regaining his abilities. He had a happy marriage lasting over fifty years. He had scaled down his life by parting with his beloved horses and other animals to live well and function within his capacity after he had collapsed and struggled to survive a few months earlier. He recounted harsh experiences, having to eat out of garbage cans because of poverty as a child in a large family with meager resources, suffering through bloody combat during the Tet Offensive, and serious health challenges. He had had to relearn to walk and function after one of his strokes fifteen years earlier, and he survived a surgery when he had heard a doctor say he would not make it during a stay at a local hospital. Although he suffered trauma, he had transformed the experience by making it a part of a narrative that was beautiful as a whole, which led to his flourishing and deeper development of his faith.</p><p>Having outlived expectations and overcome limitations and trauma, he appeared radiant as he shared from his experience and outlook. Rather than becoming bitter or feeling defeated and persecuted, the veteran had chosen to adopt a very engaged, authentic, and full life. He was determined to live out his days fully alive. He had formed a business, and he had become an accomplished horseman. He was active in his local Catholic church. He enjoyed engaging in flying when he was younger. He and his wife had raised many foster children. He encouraged the children to participate in their own faith traditions. He would bring horses to support veterans and disabled children. As he approached the final stage of his life, he remained enthusiastic and determined to make the most of it. He said that he had no regrets and that every step had been blessed. He also spoke of leaving thumbprints wherever he went to improve the wellbeing of others. He enjoyed sharing information to inspire and edify others, especially foster children.</p><p>34). Adversity and deprivation, followed by a religious experience during baptism, and unexpected good fortune and abundance, led a man to an outlook that gives his life’s glory to God.</p><p>A male veteran in his late seventies who identified with the Pentecostal tradition was glad to have chaplain visits during his stay. He was a widower who lived independently, and he seemed relaxed about having foot surgery for recurring diabetic problems. He enthusiastically affirmed his faith. He had grown up at a state facility in a state residential school for children in need. He said that he would escape and left for good at the age of sixteen. He was led to be baptized in the Pentecostal tradition and as he was emerging from the water, he was speaking in tongues. Years later, he continued in his faith, an optimistic outlook that finds God’s presence in several positive outcomes and traits in his life. He said a couple of times that “it’s all God!” He pointed to the word Bible as an acronym for “basic instructions before leaving Earth,” and said that he would use a copy he purchased with highlights and would skip around and read different passages.</p><p>He said that the Holy Spirit led him to acquire two houses, one he fixed up and one that was a gift from his mother, whom he met after over thirty years with no contact, and he had developed skills for fixing up buildings. When I followed up with him after a surgery to remove one or two toes from his right foot, he again reflected positivity and was eager to affirm his faith and express his reliance on God’s help. He professed that God is good, and he shared affirmations like his “busy person’s prayer,” and emphasized his outlook of gratitude and feeling held by God, which he contrasted to the neglect of his mother. He was effusive about praising God, and how God can get your attention when we are not mindful of God. He stressed how important it is to treat others well. He was looking forward to returning to the home he restored with God’s help.</p><p>35). A man has a near-death experience that gives him faith in having a purpose. He encounters synchronistic events and clairvoyant people.</p><p>A man in his early seventies who was a Vietnam veteran, cited a near-death experience as a source of his abiding faith. He also discussed encounters where people seemed to know him already, and he had social challenges. He maintained an optimistic outlook with a lot of suspicion about people being Satan worshippers. He had been in the hospital for four days for treatment of swelling in his legs, and he had atrial fibrillation. He had housing insecurity and did not know if he could return to a group housing facility. He said that he had had a close call in Vietnam in combat, and that afterward, in the U.S., he was in a motor vehicle accident when the driver fell asleep, and he was thrown out and was in a coma for several hours, had a period of paralysis, and while unconscious, entered a dark space and noticed a circle spinning and humming. In the coma, he kept giving thanks to God and Jesus Christ for his survival with gratitude, as he had prayed when he was a child. The more he prayed, the louder the sound became. He remained unconscious while his father, who was in the room, tested his arm and told him to hold it up. It would flop down until the third time, when he was enlivened and his system was awakened. Over the following months, he became able to see and walk again.</p><p>He later was told by someone he did not know that God had saved him to serve a purpose and that his life could be lost at any time he no longer is needed. He noticed animals like birds being drawn to him. He recounted several incidents when he met people who could foresee the future. He had a premonition about a pending disaster in the U.S. and Europe with loss of life, and felt he needed to convey this urgent message about. Some of his thought process sounds like magical thinking but he articulated a benign and compassionate approach, with love for animals and children and faith in God. He sees unity in the different branches and traditions. He feels that he has had scrutiny and testing by Satan.</p><p>36). After feeling like he had succumbed to a life of temptation and taken the wrong road, a man found that he could devote himself to God and feel delivered from temptation.</p><p>A veteran in his late seventies was getting treatment for infection and heart disease. He expressed a strong sense of faith and wished to give credit for his outlook to God. He was married and had grown children and was very happy about their presence in his life. He shared from his experience that has led to him overcoming distress from a dissolute lifestyle after the loss of his first wife in a motor vehicle accident many years ago. His grief led to a downward spiral, and he became uncomfortable with himself after he had fallen into lustful behavior and spent money on partying. He lost his prosperity and had become distressed. He is inspired by the parable of the prodigal son, and he feels that he has had help to recover from being “down and out.” He had built a business and had been doing well at the time and he felt like he lost his bearings, became self-satisfied, and led a Bohemian lifestyle. He recognized that he had needed to change and he prayed intently. He felt that he was blessed by relief from temptation. He had feelings and experiences that made him feel lost and then he prioritized his relationship with God. He was praying in gratitude to God and for direction. He felt that he was heard and within his awareness he received the message, “just tell everyone about it.” He said that he gives the glory to God for all his blessings and is aware that the devil seeks to distract him from his faith. He prays regularly, principally in gratitude for the blessings in his life. He is glad to share his affirmation of faith and believes that we all need to inspire one another, like people in a sinking boat who must work together as a team.</p><p>38). An experience of surrender led to resilience in life and engagement in the charismatic traditions and healing ministries.</p><p>A veteran in his mid-eighties, who had served in the Army intelligence service, had been here for a week with breathing difficulties and coughing that were slowly improving with treatment. He began to speak about his interesting and varied work experience, which involved teaching in high school, working in an industrial job, and studying history in his late forties, and Greek to understand the Bible better. He was happily married and he and his wife of ten years would attend each other’s churches which were fairly traditional or Pentecostal. He had made sincere efforts to make two earlier marriages succeed and he described instances when he forgave people who wronged him, such as his second wife. He had strong views and described having times of friction in some of his jobs because of ethical differences, and he said he had been uninvited from a couple of worship communities.</p><p>He had times of inspiration, especially a religious experience in the early 1970s when he was in his early thirties. He had been overly confident, and he said he was brought low and had an opening to faith. He was led to charismatic practices and attended gatherings that drew people of different faith traditions. He spoke about receiving gifts of the Spirit and being drawn to mentors. He described having people brought to him so he could help cast out dark spirits from them. He prays to understand God more, and to deepen his trust in God and Jesus Christ. He sees God as benevolent and loving. He looks forward to improvement and continuing to help other people.</p><p>39). A veteran finds comfort in a quiet inward encounter with God on a Navy ship.</p><p>A man in his mid-sixties from the Lutheran tradition had been receiving treatment of fluid in his legs with open wounds related to heart and kidney disease for five days when we met. He had moved to a rural area of west Tennessee with his wife from the Pacific northwest about two years earlier. They had been living separately and were working out their relations. He described having had received some poor medical advice and friction with his wife and neighbors. He had a priority of personal autonomy. He had happy childhood experiences in youth groups and as an altar boy. He described an experience in the Navy when he was lonely, and he asked God to be in his life. It changed his life and he felt that his luck changed and a burden was lifted. He had a congenital issue that had been an affliction, but he had reframed his issue as a way in which God marked him as his own.</p><p>April</p><p>40). A woman who had a series of near-death experiences from episodes of having insufficient heartbeat found it to be very upsetting, but she did not feel a fear of death.</p><p>A woman in her early fifties, who is married with two young adult children, had been in the hospital for six days. She had been in great distress when she first came in but she had begun to feel more hope and peace. She would have days of sleeplessness followed by long periods of sleep. She was being considered for a heart transplant and said that she had been having a series of episodes of complete loss of consciousness and had been transported by life flight. She had had to receive shock treatments to revive her. She cited her children as sources of inspiration and purpose, and she was receiving support from her husband and extended family during this difficult time. She described the deep distress, worry, and concern about her unsustainable affliction, but she did not have a fear of death. She said that she would become completely unconscious and would not recall anything until she felt the relief of regaining consciousness. She said it felt like coming back to life after it “could go either way.”</p><p>41). A man receiving news of a grave diagnosis relied on the blessing of a child who came into his life after a prediction foreseen by a clergyman.</p><p>A veteran who was a return patient in his late sixties was newly admitted and had contact precautions as he was getting treatment for pneumonia. He was quite thin and having difficulty eating. He became tearful and reflective as he was absorbing news of a possible diagnosis of metastatic bone cancer from the day before. He said he was always a kind person who intended to be positive. He mentioned a special blessing that he and his wife had received four or five years earlier at their church. The pastor and two visiting pastors were present, he said, and he felt that the Holy Spirit was present and people were experiencing holiness. After he and his wife had gone up to the altar, testified to their faith, and returned to their pews, one of the visiting pastors came from a far corner and told his wife, “God has told me to let you know that a manchild is coming to your life and care.” He added that it was not going to be easy.</p><p>The veteran and his wife had not doubted the prediction. A few months later, a male infant came into their care when close relative of his wife’s were not able to care for their male child. He felt that they had been set forth to do what God had asked. The news felt like the way that God commands angels to do God’s works. He accepted this responsibility, despite financial limitations and health challenges. He wanted to profess that he has been a good steward of the boy who was now five years old. He was concerned about his salvation, and I assured him that God loves him and appreciates his intentions, that his concerns were consistent with faith, and that his condition was not a sign of spiritual failing. He could appreciate his experience as consistent with faith and find beauty even in this difficult time.</p><p>42). A man surrenders and finds his burdens lifted and enjoys engagement in a Baptist church and his musical ministry.</p><p>A male veteran who was almost 80 years old met with me after a few days in the hospital. He had had a heart procedure and consultations and was being considered for surgery for a gastric outlet obstruction. He was worn out and had had a nasal tube for feeding as he shared his experience passing a massive bowel movement the previous evening. He noticed immediate relief after enormous pain and felt some alarm, and his wife was there at the time. The ordeal has been quite exhausting, but he was animated and felt it had relieved his problem. He described a pleasant life in a rural county, a fruitful but demanding career in the insurance business, and an early retirement after he had expended energy and endurance to finish it well. Since his retirement, he had been very busy as a musical director in a Baptist church in his home county.</p><p>The veteran described a religious experience about 35 years earlier when he was in his early forties. He said that he was saved at a time when he was busy with work, but he felt that his drinking was interfering with his life and his smoking was an impediment to his health. He surrendered and he began to feel a great burden lifted from him. It impacted him in positive ways, and he felt like discontinuing these habits was the best choice he could have made. He became active in his church. He told his friends that he would continue being their friends, but at the time, they drifted away from him. Later, two or three made similar decisions and became engaged in the church community. The experience had helped him through this recent ordeal and medical trauma that appeared to have ended well.</p><p>43). A man’s pathway to ministry is inspired by a vision in his thirties, which was confirmed by his marriage.</p><p>An African American veteran in his mid-seventies was admitted for fluid accumulation, apparent from insufficiency of his heart function, and he was responding well with Lasix. His wife was present and she excused herself, apparently to give him privacy and he discussed his life and the importance of meeting her. He had grown up in the Midwest Region of the country in a devout family. When he was 37, he had an inspiring vision during a low point in his life that led to him relocating to another city to pursue a pastoral education and become a minister. Meeting his wife was a significant sign that he was on a pathway provided by the Spirit. He had pastored some mainline Protestant churches in Tennessee for many years before retiring.</p><p>The veteran said that he had been active in church and that he was very knowledgeable about the Bible, but that he had felt disconnected and unfulfilled. He said that he had been “doing things his own way.” He became despondent when his marriage ended, and he began relying on alcohol and drugs to numb his pain. He had had a mentor in the Midwestern city, whom he had known previously, and at the low point in his life, he ran into this mentor. This inspired him to deepen his connection with God. Later, while he was awake, he had a vision of the mentor on a riverbank with some steppingstones to approach, and he took this as a sign. His inspiring experience led to him to pursue ministry, to take the gospel to heart, and to feel his inspiration from Jesus Christ deep within himself. He developed patience and released resentment as he pursued his studies and ministry, and importantly, he met his wife. He flourished at the college and was inspired by notable civil rights figures he met in the nonviolent social change gospel tradition. He had retired when he was 60, and felt constrained by the church hierarchy, but he felt that there is more of his pathway yet to be revealed. He is interested in building bridges or lines of communication between Christianity and other faith traditions, and in increasing awareness within the fraternal organization that he was actively participating in.</p><p>May</p><p>44). A woman feeling frustration and isolation hears a voice that spurs inspiration to relocate close to family.</p><p>A woman in her early eighties had been on the unit for a couple of days and was being discharged after medication modifications for swelling and diabetic kidney disease. She was recovering from cancer and numerous orthopedic injuries. She and her husband had recently moved to the area from a distant state where her son, daughter, and grandson had moved. She has a loving relationship with her husband, whom she married during her military service, and he and their son were coming to pick her up. They have different orientations and outlooks, and he was not as freely able to surrender her cares to God. She was frustrated with limitations and setbacks, walking with assistance, and being somewhat isolated from her children at a time when she heard an inner voice say to “get busy.” She clearly felt that she was urged to visit the Tennessee area and see her son and daughter and a grandchild who had moved here. Her son and daughter had both relocated here. The veteran said that even with many medical and life challenges, she has an appreciation of being very blessed. She often affirms, “what will be will be.” Their children have been very devoted and helpful to their aging parents, their families were enjoying more frequent contact, and her son has been becoming more spiritual. She is humbled by her life trajectory and how “it all fell into place.”</p><p>45). A prayer in the air leads to identifying and reviving lost love.</p><p>A veteran in his late seventies was admitted for care of his heart and was in a room with his wife, who was resting an upholstered recliner. He sat up and said that he was spiritually focused and wanted to support our chaplain ministries. He was glad to share a narrative from his experience, which was inspiring to his faith, and had just enough time before the cardiologist arrived. He was a professional from Tennessee. When he was young and serving in the Navy, he met his wife in a distant state. She was a model and studying dance and she was impressed because he had asked her if she was a “believer” and she said she was. Her family liked him. They were engaged, and he bought her a ring, but they had not proceeded to marriage when they were separated. He said the long-distance calls were expensive. She said that she did not want to move from her state because of its cultural richness. Years later, about fifteen years before his hospitalization, he had been lonely. As he was driving to work one day, he prayed or affirmed a wish for someone he could talk to. They were thinking independently about reconnecting around that time. When he found out that a woman was looking into his profile on a dating website, he went to great lengths to find the person, believing it was his lost love, and it was. Since they rekindled their loving relationship after so many years, they have been very loving and devoted to one another and feel completed. He identifies as a Christian from the Baptist tradition, and he states that he and his wife have priorities focused on spirituality.</p><p>46). God’s voice and a national disaster led a veteran to develop new faith.</p><p>A male veteran in his early eighties was in the hospital receiving treatment for fluid accumulation that was easing the pressure and pain symptoms that led him here. He was feeling great relief after a time of serious concerns and distress. He said that it felt like a miraculous recovery. He grew up in church life, and he was baptized but he fell away from communal worship. He said that he was relying on his own resources but that after 9/11/01, he had a change of priorities, and he began focusing on spirituality. He quit smoking cigarettes and he quit drinking alcohol. He began listening to a gospel radio station and began visiting a Salvation Army Church near his home. He felt that God’s voice was directing him there. He felt some shame about his lifestyle and was self-conscious when he arrived for worship. He was greeted by a woman in a uniform and a bonnet. He was amused by her skepticism. She informed him that their pastor was ministering to victims of the Twin Towers explosions and their families and community. He felt humbled and heard an inner voice telling him to plant his backside in a seat there, inspired by the mission of service. He began volunteering to play music, guitar, and keyboards in their services. He became close with the ministry leaders and congregants, and their mission inspired him to work in the adult rehabilitation facility that houses and employs people who are in recovery or are impoverished for other reasons.</p><p>47). A veteran has a prayer and frees himself from the presence of an entity he accidentally invited into his being.</p><p>A man in his early forties had been admitted for medication issues related to multiple sclerosis and for an old ankle injury that affected his mobility. He was glad to affirm his faith. He had been working as a truck driver before his ankle injury took him off work around twenty years earlier and he and his wife had moved to a small town in a rural area. We discussed ideas about benevolent spirits and angels and being open to divine presence when the veteran explained that his curiosity led him to become interested in ghost hunting. He was interested in technology and found a device that helped identify the presence of ghosts.</p><p>One day, he said, he was getting information near a shopping area when a signal came to show a demon, which initiated contact. The veteran asked it about itself, and it gave him a name, Mark, which the veteran said was an assumed name to build confidence. The veteran asked it what he could do for it, and he felt something enter his side. It persisted as a presence. The veteran would notice a problem with a food mixer in his home coming off a table, and he realized that he had opened himself up to a dark entity that was taking space in his life. He was not fearful or deeply distressed, he said, but he was aware that it was not serving him. He had found a great resource four years earlier, called the Deliverance Prayer. He showed it to me on the internet, and he said it helped rid him of the pesky entity. Since then, the veteran’s life has been peaceful, and his wife has developed a deep spirituality. They pray and read Bible passages together. He feels at peace and has gratitude for overcoming a preoccupation that had begun rather innocently. He gladly accepted my offer to pray for him.</p><p>48). A vision portending the afterlife during a health crisis, and his father’s peaceful transition, inspires a veteran to “put things in perspective,” feel greater peace in his life, and have more confidence in the afterlife.</p><p>A male veteran in his early seventies had been getting medical care for heart failure and fluid overload, and I visited him twice during his stay. The veteran was a pleasant and stoic man who approached his condition in a frank and matter-of-fact manner. He regarded his condition as terminal, and he relied on supplemental oxygen. He expressed gratitude, saying that he had not expected to live past the age of sixty. The veteran spoke of having had a hard life. He discovered that his mother and grandmother had practiced in the dark arts when he was the executor of his mother’s estate. The veteran had done risky work repossessing cars in a dangerous area, and he said that he had ridden with outlaw motorcycle clubs. His life had since improved. He remarried and had a happy marriage after a bitter divorce. He had re-established relations with his daughters after they were alienated from him by his ex-wife, and his daughters had done well in their careers.</p><p>The veteran had an engineering background and had been working as a power plant operator, but he sought work with a benevolent healthcare organization that provided public health services and helped children avoid polio. An injury had taken him out of work about 35 years earlier, and he had progressive worsening of his heart disease. He had some visionary experiences during treatment several years ago. He had required diuretics and he became dehydrated after eliminating 30 pounds of fluid. He was in and out of awareness and clearly saw a series of visions of a woman dressed in black all over, including a black hat and stockings, which he felt was a harbinger of death. He could hear his deceased relatives when he saw the apparition. He survived this fearful experience and developed a sense of confidence about death. He also was inspired by his father’s peaceful transition when he had been near death. His father told the veteran that he was seeing apparitions, and said, “they’re here for me.” He encouraged the veteran to go watch television, and almost immediately passed away peacefully. The veteran had non-traditional religious beliefs, and he preferred to keep them private, but he described them as his “own beliefs.” He felt motivated to be honest and to do what is right.</p><p>June</p><p>49). An anomalous event saves lives and enhances a veteran’s faith.</p><p>A veteran in his late seventies who was receiving treatment for longstanding heart disease shared an account of a miraculous life-saving intervention after hearing me express interest in the presence of the Spirit and belief in angels. During a prior visit, while he had been in the hospital for four days for treatment of heart failure, he said he had survived many heart attacks and stent placements related to Agent Orange exposure in Vietnam. He is in good spirits and alert and he looks well. We discussed his wife’s dementia and their membership in a Pentecostal Church where he led Bible study class. He was waiting for his lunch and he took a phone call, but he took the opportunity to share his faith.</p><p>He told me about an experience around 25 years earlier, when he lived in another state. He and a friend of his, and two women, were driving to visit the friend’s son in prison on a rainy Saturday. A few miles from the prison, the road went from a four-lane road to a two-lane road. The veteran’s friend was driving and he went into the approaching lane to pass a pickup truck, apparently thinking there were four lanes. Two vehicles were quickly approaching, and the veteran was alarmed, expecting an immediate head-on collision. He exclaimed, “Oh, Jesus!” and immediately the car’s electrical system went blank and everything stopped as the car was smoothly and gently lifted and placed on the grass on the side in a safe place. Cars whizzed by and they felt overwhelmed with the relief. They completed the visit to the prisoner and the veteran shared this experience with his pastor the following day at church, and he was glad that the pastor had believed him. He said that this enhanced and deepened his faith and inspired him to go through his medical challenges. He appreciated my expression of belief and appreciation of his faith and he took a phone call and felt complete with our visit.</p><p>50). A series of near-death experiences relieves a veteran’s fear of death and increases his faith.</p><p>A veteran in his mid-seventies returned and we remembered each other from a patient visit a year earlier. He was in good spirits although he had shortness of breath from limited lung function. He was receiving follow-up care from a cardiac catheterization, he had stage IV cancer, and he did not expect to have much more than one year left to his life. We spoke after I had met and prayed with his roommate in the adjacent hospital bed, and I learned that both of them had had three near-death experiences that had enhanced their faith and lessened their fear of death. The veteran was glad to see me and he shared his faith from his youth. He was inspired by his mother, who was very devout and encouraged church attendance and Bible study. He said that he had had two prior experiences when he was not expected to survive his medical challenges. One time it occurred, his mother and sister were with him as his life support for breathing was withdrawn and they were told they could have time with him before he died. He said that they prayed and sang for him and he came back to life. His mother told him that she knew that he would come back because “it was not his time.” He said that his mother was very attuned to spiritual matters and he never doubted her confidence.</p><p>Around the time of a heart attack the previous year, he said that he was hovering over his own body as he was laughing and felt a lightness about the circumstances. He said that he came back because it simply was not his time. This was his third near-death experience, and it helped increase his faith and relieve his fear. He had strong faith and he said that he had not been worried about the afterlife. When we had met previously, he described how he had a life in the Lord and that he had had prayers answered. He would read from the Bible and he said that he enjoyed being helpful to others.</p><p>51). A second patient in the same room independently reported that he had had a series of near-death experiences that gave him belief in the afterlife and relieved his fear of death.</p><p>A man in his mid-seventies returned to the hospital and he was interacting with humor while receiving nursing care when I arrived. He warned me not to mention the words “hospice” or “palliative” to him (the “H” word or the “P” word) and I agreed to honor his request. He had heart failure, cirrhosis, and a pulmonary embolism. As we spoke, he shared from his experience that he had had three occasions when his heartbeat flatlined. The veteran said that he had looked down onto his body and had come back to life one time after being in a coma for six months. Another time, he had had to relearn to walk and it took him three months, much less time than had been expected. He had survived being shot three times about thirty years earlier. He had less fear of death, he said. By coincidence, he was in the same room as a man roughly his age who had had three near-death events and had also experienced an increase of his faith. Their near-death experiences had helped both of them increase their faith and relieve their fear.</p><p>I was amazed that both of them had said that they had three near-death experiences and had been told “it is not your time,” and I confirmed this with them. The veterans said that people often do not believe them, but they know they were real and that the experiences were vivid, real, and important, no matter what other people think. I emphasized that I believe them and that I appreciated the inspiration of the experiences they shared. They were both receptive to receiving prayer as part of chaplain services.</p><p>52). Religious experiences inspire a veteran to give back by supporting a youth camp near their home.</p><p>I met with a combat-wounded veteran retired from military service over twenty-five years in his mid-seventies who was receiving treatment for shortness of breath and fluid overload. He said that he was feeling better after treatment and he was looking forward to returning to his home. He was inspired to give back from the abundance that he had been blessed with. He also described friends and others who influenced him favorably over the years, especially his wife. They have been generous in supporting the youth camp. He has devoted his energy to providing his labor and practical skills, and they have provided generous financial support to buy large items that enhance the experience of the youths who participate in the camp.</p><p>The veteran said that he has been inspired by experiences of the Spirit, first when he was “saved” as a young man in a small Baptist church. He was also inspired by a local youth camp he and his wife supported over many years. He described one time when he was alone on a hill near the youth camp when he felt the presence of God. He did not describe it in detail, but it sounded like a gentle feeling of God’s presence abiding with him. He felt gratitude for the financial resources they had from years of work and sacrifice. He and his wife had gardens and were growing tomatoes, green beans, and okra, and his wife has many plants and flowers on their patio. He said that nature, the plants and the flowers, their animals, and the wildlife around them was restorative and inspiring. They would feed deer and see many animals, including skunks, racoons, and a woodchuck.</p><p>53). An anomalous appearance of an unlikely “angel” deepens a couple’s faith.</p><p>A Vietnam veteran in his early eighties was hospitalized with shortness of breath complicated by diabetes. His records suggested that he had dehydration leading to weakness and fatigue. His wife was present at his bedside and she said that she had been inspired the previous day when someone stopped her and offered to pray for her as she was bringing her husband to the emergency department. He was hoping that his studies would not show a grave problem and he said he hoped to be discharged soon. He had home healthcare assistance and he had support from his wife of 40 years and her children. He was retired from work in public service.</p><p>They spoke about how they felt spiritually supported, how they were devoted to one another, and had a life of faith. He was a Vietnam veteran who had traumatic memories, including combat and helicopters, viewing a friend’s body, and coping with large numbers of casualties. He had felt wrung out when he arrived home. When we spoke about faith, they shared an anomalous experience that led them to deeper appreciation of God’s presence and support. A few years ago, they were driving their camper and truck and it stopped and they were in a remote area with the hood up. A burly man with tattoos came there and they were apprehensive about his motives because of his appearance. They were grateful when he fastened a hose. He gave them his cellphone number, saying to call back if it happened again. Ten miles later, the problem recurred, and they called him and he came and fixed the problem again. He said, as he finished the repair, that he thought it would work that time, and added, “Don’t run faster than your angel can fly.” As they headed down the highway, they called the number again, intending to express their gratitude again, but there was a message that there was no such number. They would tell this story often to express their sense of the presence of the Spirit.</p><p>July</p><p>54). An intercession by a despondent veteran’s granddaughters persuaded him to persevere and reclaim his life despite significant health and mobility challenges.</p><p>A Vietnam veteran in his mid-seventies met with me a few times and we developed a rapport and he revealed that before coming to the hospital the prior week, he had lost his purpose and reason to live. He had been a medevac helicopter medic. He had lost a friend and had contacted his sister and visited her, and even named his son after his friend. He spoke about finding “tricks” as a combat medic to keep people alive with meager resources to keep people’s blood pressure stable by squeezing bags of plasma using various means. He had been a paramedic in a local emergency medical service for over thirty years and he had not realized how hard it was at the time. His medical condition from Agent Orange, diabetes, heart failure and stomach problems were very uncomfortable and he was dependent on a wheelchair. He had “been through hell” and that he had gotten to a point where he could not sleep or drive and had stopped eating.</p><p>He said he had decided not to accept care, refusing entreaties by his wife, and he did not want to live. He was planning to overdose stored up pills to take his own life. He had stopped eating and had spent weeks in bed. When his grandchildren prevailed upon him, he had changed his mind and decided to live. He became open to persevering, something shifted, and he came for treatment. He concluded that he was not finished with life. He affirmed his Catholic faith and he agreed that God loves him. He said that while he had felt abandoned by God, he now felt supported by God. Despite his traumatic experiences in war, he said he would do his combat service all over again if he had the choice. He had a close group of Vietnam Veterans and he was going to receive psychiatric care.</p><p>55). A prior near-death experience and vision inspired a veteran to have faith when facing a serious health condition.</p><p>A veteran in his late sixties had been on our unit for four days after having been in intensive care for two days. We had two visits. He had mobility concerns and had lost strength that had not returned, possibly due to heart problems. He said that two weeks before the incident happened, God’s presence let him know he was going to enter into a valley. His wife was present with him and they were quite worried after the episode. He and his wife had an active church life in a rural county. He was hoping for a resolution, and as he shared his faith, he and his wife spoke about a stroke he had over twenty years earlier that had been very disabling and that the doctors had said he would not ever recover the ability to walk.</p><p>He said he was in a coma and was in intensive care for two weeks, and spent eight weeks in the hospital. His wife was tearful as she shared that the staff at the outside hospital where he had stayed had essentially given up on him The veteran said that while he was in a coma, he had had a vision of an angel that identified himself as God’s messenger Gabriel, who had brought assurance and told him that it was not his time. He said that Angel Gabriel assured him he would walk again and even though the doctors concluded he would not, over a period of months he had regained his walking ability with his wife’s help. He did not return to work, but he has been engaged in his life and family. He said that he felt that God has been watching over him and that God has been good to him. He and his wife showed great love to each other as they shared this narrative which inspired hope for recovery from his current health challenges. He said that the experience eased his fear of death and helped him feel inspired to recover. We spoke about their family and interests and I shared appreciation of his faith and courage and told them that I had heard testimonies from other patients who had had similar experiences.</p><p>56). An appearance of benevolent physicians appeared miraculous in preserving and healing a young boy’s leg, deepening his faith and establishing gratitude to persevere through later health challenges.</p><p>A man in his mid-sixties with combined health problems had been recovering from a heart procedure after he had had a very challenging month of a confluence of challenges involving three organs. He was reserved at first and said that he felt better and had relief but was</p><p>still having pain around a fresh incision. I asked the veteran about what helped him come through these trials and he instantly replied, “God.” He said that he has had faith from his early life and spoke about how he brings his faith into his relations and how it is his priority in his relations. He gave his affirmation of faith, expressing his awareness of how God is good and gave His son for us to find freedom from sin. He believes that people who do not make God their priority will face judgment and that God will remove favor from them, and he said he believed that Jesus is coming soon.</p><p>The veteran was raised in a rural area of Kentucky in a large Black family that faced financial hardship and discrimination. He was emotional as he spoke about and how he was inspired by his mother and his parents’ sacrifices for them. He shared an inspiring account of how he was a young boy and had a badly broken leg. His family lacked resources and he was vulnerable, and fearing he would lose his leg and ability to walk. However, at a hospital he was approached by three doctors, an Indian, a Jew, and a Mexican, who directed his family to go to a hospital in Louisville and ask for them. They repaired his leg and he walked soon afterward. There was no bill to pay, and when the family followed up, they discovered there was no record of their existence. He realized they were angelic. He expressed deep gratitude for his life and healing path, his wife and his dog, and stated that he participated in a Baptist church in Guthrie. He was open to receiving prayer.</p><p>After I was accumulating narratives of inspiration and resilience, I had two more visits that called out to me for their salience for illustrating the permeable membrane between life and death. One veteran, when I asked him about whether he had confidence in the afterlife, told me that he had had an anomalous experience as a young man. He was fifteen years old and it was a week after his grandfather had died. He was alone in his parents’ house, and he answered a phone call and heard his grandfather’s voice. He was asking how everyone was, and the veteran said everyone was fine. His grandfather even used a mispronunciation of one of his relative’s names which he had always done because of ill-fitting dentures. My patient asked him how he was doing and his grandfather said he was fine. He said that he had to go and after the brief call, the veteran waited many years before telling his sisters. He had not shared this account with others, and he held it close to his heart, and it inspired him to accept health and social challenges.</p><p>57). Messages from a benevolent customer and a vision of Christ inspire a veteran.</p><p>Another encounter with a Marine veteran in his late sixties involved a clearly detailed near-death experience in which he felt the deep love he had for others that was not directed to specific people, but he felt bathed in it and reassured about the afterlife. He was receiving heart care and had had an echocardiogram after having some dizziness and fainting episodes. He grew up in poverty and had had frequent times of neglect and hunger. His parents exploited him, making him do shoplifting when he was a young boy, and he had spent a couple of years in state care while his parents were incarcerated. He had Parkinson’s disease which he attributed to contaminated water at Camp Lejeune, but he cited his Marine Corps experience as highly valuable in his development of self-esteem and confidence. After his service of eight years, he worked in carpentry and one of his customers, aware that he worked for someone with less ability and character, urged him to build his own business, saying, “If you want the better fruit, you have to get on a limb” referring to the financial risks of having his own business.</p><p>He had met his wife after vowing to God that if she would marry her, he would be honorable and faithful to her, and they had been married almost forty years, with children and grandchildren. He had succeeded in his business and had a spiritual emphasis including generosity and gratitude. He had had some altar boy experience with the Catholic Church. He became focused on self-discipline, and he has had a prayer life. He felt spiritually supported in finding his wife. Four years before his current hospital stay, he had a heart attack and open-heart surgery and had to be deeply sedated because he was uneasy and agitated. He had a lovely vision being in the presence of Christ surrounded by brilliant light. He saw the silhouette of Jesus and was told he had more work to do. He felt himself be gently pushed back into his body and woke up as a nurse was speaking to him. He felt a shift in priorities and has become focused on sharing his talents and supporting his family and being a blessing to others.</p><p>58). A voice and determination to lead a better life led to greater aliveness, which was inspired by a vision of heaven during a health crisis.</p><p>A male veteran who was almost 80 had been on 2-North for 11 days and he celebrated his blessings, the presence of his great grandchildren, his wife, and his daughter’s family, while grieving a son who died in a motor vehicle accident, and a daughter who died after two days. He had problems walking due to low blood pressure, but he felt peace and was aware of God’s presence. He was raised attending church and after he drifted away, he cultivated his spirituality. He would feel some regret about partying, feeling that he could have lost his life to carelessness. One early morning around 3:15 a.m., he heard God’s voice say, “tonight’s the night.” He knew what this meant, that a void or hole he had felt in his life would to be filled with love. This void became filled and he has felt restored since then. He said, “What a mighty God is with us,” and he focused on God’s gift of Jesus and salvation. He still felt grief about losing two of his children, but he had , had a supportive dream about seven months earlier while in the hospital. He dreamed he was in heaven. His impressions were vivid of Jesus and he kissed his feet and expressed gratitude to him. God was present on a throne and advised him not to look because he might not be able to stand the sight. He saw a crowd of people who could not be close, and also his deceased family, his mother, brother, two sisters, and son and daughter, and Jesus said ,”We’ll walk together in the cool of evening,” and they were walking and there were beautiful roses that reminded him of his faith. He still felt exhilarated from his blessings, and he was coping with grief with the love he draws from these experiences. He had stopped attending church due to Covid dangers, but he felt God’s spirit leading him, giving him hope, and inspiring his progress.</p><p>59). A conversion by the influence of people who opened the way for an inmate.</p><p>A man in his mid-sixties who was a recent kidney transplant recipient told me that he had had a conversion experience while in prison. He and his wife were present in his room, and he requested a large print King James version of the Bible which I brought, and I returned to his room after he had a medical consultation about his body’s response to his recent kidney transplant. He grew up in Alabama in an African American family and had spiritual examples in his mother and grandmother. After surviving for dialysis for two years, he felt uplifted and optimistic, supported by the Spirit, with his new kidney.</p><p>He shared a conversion experience while he was serving time in prison in another state. He said he had been a sophisticated con man who became inspired by a peer leader in prison who sang and had intuited or foreseen his thoughts and prayers and helped him learn how to study the Bible. He attended the chapel for a while and developed a prison ministry, and he had a conversion experience in which he felt God’s presence and blessing. The veteran was familiar with the Bible, and he discussed how what God desires from people is at odds with what the world encourages. He felt led to surrender to God and become God’s instrument. He worked to improve himself and devoted himself to healing ministries with a mentor and advisor He had become successful in business before deciding to pursue ministries to help with food security and spiritual support for marginalized people full time before his health issues arose. He continued to study the Bible and engage in evangelism, and his wife was committed to their shared priorities.</p><p>60). A man with grief hears a voice that God hears him, and after he prays for a cross as a sign of devotion, one appears the following day.</p><p>An African American man in his early seventies spoke with love about his influences as a child in an urban area growing up under modest circumstances but with care, direction, and love. His mother was widowed and his grandmother was very supportive of him and his family. He grew up with faith, and his life experience enhanced his sense of closeness to God. He felt that God watched over him in Vietnam and he survived close calls. He has carried a small Bible for the past twenty-plus years that was worn and showed a lot of use. He was wearing a steel cross that he found under mysterious circumstances on his couch. His wife died in 2008, and he was grieving her loss while also praising God for all his blessings. He would pray regularly. One day, he heard a voice call his name when he was watching a television evangelist, a voice called his name and said, “God hears you. God sees you.” He was very inspired by an event ten years prior to his hospital stay. He was praying to God, and he asked for a cross to show his devotion, and the next day, about ten years ago, he found it. He verified with his cleaning lady that it was not hers. He felt chills both times and he would give God all the credit and glory for his blessings. Even though a tragedy happened to one of his children, he felt God has a purpose for everything. He was very moved by our conversation and prayer and had tears as he affirmed his faith.</p><p>61). A man has a vision of Jesus Christ at a holy place at a bad time in his life.</p><p>I made a return visit to a patient in his mid-eighties who was relieved by some findings from a diagnostic study. As we spoke more about his condition, he shared more about his outlook. Despite some difficulties from unhappy divorces and incidents when he was exploited and cheated by people who took advantage of him, he had an outlook of gratitude and equanimity that felt inspiring. The veteran is a devout Catholic who was an altar boy. His father was unsupportive and he found some comfort in the church, but he drifted away and returned later. He is active at a nearby Catholic church, and he said that he attends mass daily. Despite some recent incidents of being cheated and losing large amounts of his savings, he resisted being consumed by anger and resentment. He shared about having had great successes in business and having accomplished a great deal in his work. He was under stress from being unfairly rejected in his two marriages and having to cope with sudden unfairness and infidelity. The veteran had had a difficulty with alcohol at that time. When he was disappointed in an experience with a love interest he had tried to drown his sorrows with alcohol, and he woke up in a very despondent state in San Antonio feeling very low and disconsolate. He went to the Lourdes Grotto of the Southwest &amp; Tepeyac of Guadalupe and prayed deeply, and he saw angels and the Spirit of Jesus Christ who told him, “Your sins are forgiven.” He felt a burden lifted and he has stopped drinking, lived as a single man, and directed himself toward working God’s will. He gave me some medals of our Lady of Lourdes/ Lady of Guadelupe and St. Bernadette to share with others, stressing that they had been blessed.</p><p>Analysis and Conclusions</p><p>The Value of a Model of Wholeness, Promotion of Self-Acceptance, and Soul Connection for Spiritual Care Providers</p><p>These accumulated narratives reveal how patients may form a strong level of clarity about what guides them during health crises and other challenges, and how spiritual care providers can support them by helping them recall and share these sources of resilience. These accounts are examples of what people rely on for guidance and as resources for claiming wellbeing, quality of life, and to prevent them from falling into despair.</p><p>A series of dreams inspired one man to a greater sense of purpose and he developed a mission of ministry. A man whose near-death experience gave him faith and purpose found validation in encounters with synchronistic events and clairvoyant people. A message from the afterlife and a near-death experience inspired one man to have less fear of death and greater compassion. An idiosyncratic angelic presence and synchronous events inspired faith in a woman. Spontaneous writing led a man to be inspired to begin spiritual engagement with his Catholic tradition during a health crisis.</p><p>Protective parental instincts inspired one man’s healing from alcohol poisoning. A grandchild inspired a woman’s recovery from addiction. Another woman quit smoking to set a good example for her daughter after her own mother had set an example of inability to quit. A father’s poor example and a teacher’s dismissal of his potential led a veteran to determination and persistence. A veteran with end-stage liver disease found hope and a feeling of wellbeing after turning his life around by focusing on devotion to serving others.</p><p>Several patients cited spontaneous experiences of life-changing transformation of outlook and priority. Patients have described spontaneous remission of addiction, spontaneous grace easing deep grief and trauma, and spontaneous transformation and recovery one day at a manufacturing plant. A veteran found comfort in a quiet inward encounter with God on a Navy ship. A spontaneous spiritual “download” led one man to new confidence and assurance that brought him a more thriving life. A man said he made a deliberate choice to become a new person to overcome post-traumatic stress disorder. One patient had a conversion experience in jail. Feeling the absence of suffering in proximity to death brought one veteran a sense of peace. A church service led to a man having a born-again repentance experience. A passage of scripture and reflection led one man to grace. A patient’s life turned around when he gave his cares over to God. An experience of surrender led to resilience and engagement in life and the charismatic traditions and healing ministries.</p><p>Narratives of patients show that when they have had to confront death, forms of existential despair, feelings of shame, and a sense of failure that come from trauma, there are opportunities to build and maintain an identity that can withstand times of pain, loss, and feelings of emptiness from grave diagnoses. Care recipients see various types of experiences that can challenge them to adopt outlooks with give perspectives that provide them with meaning, purpose, hope, and confidence, which motivate their healing. Patients who are open to share the inner resources that are implicit in their narratives can become inspired by their sources of strength and resilience.</p><p>This research is intended to help foster understanding about the forms of experience that bring patients meaning and purpose. The narratives help reveal that avoiding responsibility to confront hard truths in order to escape trauma and grief does not shield people from despair or bestow these resources. Like Gautama Buddha’s experience after his parents tried to help shield him from pain, decay, and death, he realized avoidance did not ease pain. The greater truth he discovered was that easing suffering entails confrontation with difficult truths and disenchantment from fantasy to cultivate equanimity, empathy, and compassion. Confrontation with the parts of life that create fear and tempt us to resist and try to escape from them, seem to help these patients ease despair become resilient. Such encounters of reckoning reveal sources of inspiration for faith, healing, and transformation, helping care recipients find their core values and principles of faith.</p><p>Retirement, major life changes, and a grave diagnosis, a heart attack for example, spur patients to adopt positive lifestyle changes. Adversity, including near-death experience, motivated a man to overcome obstacles and live fully. Adversity and deprivation, followed by a religious experience during baptism and unexpected good fortune and abundance, led a man to an outlook that gives his life’s glory to God. A tragedy and an encounter with an empathic stranger gave one man inspiration for a spiritual transformation. After feeling like he had succumbed to a life of temptation and taken the wrong road, a man found that he could devote himself to God and feel delivered from temptation.</p><p>Veterans who rely upon our services often come here in severe distress and are preoccupied or overwhelmed with a sense of loss, grief, or re-triggered responses to trauma. For veterans who feel lost and empty, rudderless, and adrift from familiar sources of reference and belonging, spiritual care providers can help restore their reference points of connectedness with reminders of what endures: their sources of inspiration and resilience, which may be more pronounced when they are admitted and receiving treatment. It is often an organic process, unfolding from within, as a base of their soul connection, their deepest core values, cultivated with prior encounters with the harsh realities of living in a materialistic, violent, and competitive society. Helping them identify their antidotes to estrangement and loss can promote healing and transformation for a renewed opportunity to engage.</p><p>Some Reflections on Trauma-Informed Care</p><p>Spiritual care providers can represent the antidote to the tendency to be overwhelmed by voices imposing a sense of dread and negativity. Stepping back for perspective and allowing an aggrieved or wounded person to see their resources and the friendly voices that are difficult to hear is part of the “big picture” with the good and the bad, that can be beautiful with a perspective of wholeness. The following poem by Jan Richardson describes how grief provides a liminal space with potential to reform and reframe sorrow and bring renewal, a process that spiritual care providers can cultivate in their care recipients:</p><p><strong>Blessing for the Place Between</strong></p><p>When you come<br> to the place between.</p><p>When you have left<br> what you held<br> most dear.</p><p>When you are traveling<br> toward the life<br> you know not.</p><p>When you arrive<br> at the hardest ground.</p><p>May it become<br> for you<br> a place to rest.</p><p>May it become<br> for you<br> a place to dream.</p><p>May the pain<br> that has pressed itself<br> into you<br> give way<br> to vision,<br> to knowing.</p><p>May the morning<br> make of it<br> an altar,<br> a path,<br> a place to begin<br> again.</p><p>— Jan Richardson<br> from The Cure for Sorrow: A Book of Blessings for Times of Grief.</p><p>Dr. Judith Herman is an American psychiatrist, researcher, teacher, and author who has focused on the understanding and treatment of incest and traumatic stress. Dr. Herman is a professor of Psychiatry at Harvard Medical School, and director of training at the Victims of Violence Program in the Department of Psychiatry at the Cambridge Health Alliance in Cambridge, Massachusetts. She is best known for the 1992 book, Trauma and Recovery: The Aftermath of Violence — From Domestic Abuse to Political Terror. The book has been republished with an afterword and an epilogue. (Basic Book 2022). Dr. Herman was the first professional to propose the diagnosis of complex posttraumatic stress disorder, or PTSD.</p><p>Her landmark book traces the forgotten history of the effects of reactions to severe trauma and repetitive trauma on consciousness and behavior, and discusses possible treatment options. In the late 1800s, trauma was identified as a source of emotional and behavioral instability and dissociative states. Because its treatment led to conclusions that large numbers of girls in polite society of Vienna and Paris were abused by family members and other adults, social pressure led to discrediting the diagnosis, termed hysteria, as originating in unfounded fantasy. Sigmund Freud actively participated in characterizing the condition as originating in fantasy because of the pressure to avoid stigmatizing well-respected men with social standing.</p><p>Dr. Freud found, through psychoanalysis, that there was an epidemic of trauma from widespread sexual abuse of girls in France and Austria in the late 1800s, but later discredited his own publications out of ambition and political pressure. Judith Herman wrote about one of the victims, Bertha Pappenheim, who became the last person of influence speaking about the etiology or basis of trauma, termed hysteria, as being the result of actual abuse.</p><p>Later, the condition of posttraumatic stress disorder would be recognized officially in 1980 in the aftermath of the Vietnam War. Recent pioneers like Bessel van der Kolk, M.D., and Gabor Mate, M.D., and many others recognized sources of the condition as arising from exposure to very upsetting events and situations such as physical, emotional, or sexual abuse or neglect in childhood, and violence in military conflict and criminal acts. One type of trauma results from moral injury when one is forced into actions that are contrary to one’s core values, or acts of betrayal by trusted people.</p><p>During World War II, psychiatrists J.W. Appel and G.W. Beebe conducted treatment and research for the U.S. military, and found that spending from 200 to 240 days in combat would cause virtually any soldier to suffer lasting harm from trauma. Sometimes, traumatic experience results in the body surviving by entering a dissociative state with a repressed memory.</p><p>The soldiers serving in such conditions would form powerful attachments to one another for their survival and they would suffer if their treatment led to prolonged separation. (Herman, J. p. 35). Psychiatrists, such as Dr. Abram Kerdiner, Dr. Roy Grinker, and Dr. Herbert Spiegel, explored methods to help treat “shell shock,” as wartime trauma was called. “They found that artificially induced altered states [of consciousness] could be used to gain access to traumatic memories.” (<em>Id</em>. at 36). To help the men return to the battlefield by processing their terror, fatigue, and stress, Dr. Kardiner and Dr. Spiegel used hypnosis. Dr. Grinker and Dr. Spiegel employed sodium amytal to induce an altered state of consciousness that would allow them to “unburden” their traumatic memories in therapy. (<em>Id</em>. at 36–37). Some of the soldiers were returned to the battlefield, while others would follow up with therapists to help them integrate the memories into awareness.</p><p>Dr. Herman writes that the study of lasting effects of trauma was not resumed until after the Vietnam War, at the insistence of returning veterans. The soldiers returning from Vietnam formed rap groups of peer support. They faced an unwelcoming public that was opposed to the war and suspicious of behaviors during warfare, while many were burdened with unprocessed grief, overwhelming trauma, and repressed memories. In 1980, the American Psychiatric Association recognized posttraumatic stress disorder, encompassing the symptoms of traumatic neurosis previously described by Dr. Kardiner forty years earlier. (<em>Id</em>. at 39–40).</p><p>In the 2022 epilogue in Dr. Herman’s most recent edition, she discussed more recent research by Dr. van der Kolk and others. A neurofeedback technique pioneered by Sebern Fisher, a psychotherapist studying attachment and development of personality in childhood, and author of Neurofeedback in the Treatment of Development Trauma: Calming the Fear-Driven Brain, was very successful. Ms. Fisher found that when she was addressing a child who had not bonded with a parent, she would be “talking to the amygdala,” the portion of the brain that engages in fight-or-flight and shuts down awareness. (<em>Id</em>. at 394–95). This technique was successful in studies led by the Trauma Research Foundation and Dr van der Kolk, published in 2016.</p><p>Dr. Herman’s 2022 epilogue also discussed successful clinical studies with MDMA in research funded by the Multidisciplinary Association for Psychedelic Studies (MAPS), led by Michael Mithoefer and other clinicians. (<em>Id</em>. at 397). One study concluded in 2018 had helped 90 men and women with complex posttraumatic stress disorder. The subjects had had multiple childhood and later traumatic experiences and had developed symptoms of depression, dissociation, and/or substance abuse and posttraumatic stress disorder. (<em>Id</em>. at 396–97). Results showed that MDMA, when combined with therapy, showed major improvements in their symptoms. (<em>Id</em>. at 397) (citing M. Mithoefer, “The Evolving Science of the Use of Psychedelic Substances in the Treatment of PTSD” from a 2021 workshop at a conference of the Trauma Research Foundation). Therapists are present during the psychedelic (or empathogenic) experience for reassurance and encouragement, and for preparation and integration sessions to facilitate processing. (<em>Id</em>.) (citing J.M. Mitchell, M. Bogenschutz, A. Lilienstein, <em>et al</em>, “MDMA-Assisted Psychotherapy for Severe PTSD: A Randomized, Double-Blind, Placebo-Controlled Phase 3 Study, in Nature Magazine 27 (2021) at 1025–33). It is an “inner-directed” therapy that encourages the subjects to “go inside” with a “beginner’s mind,” and is especially beneficial with repressed memories.</p><p>Spiritual Orientation Informing Theological Model of Care</p><p>The beauty of Christianity for spiritual care providers is its emphasis on healing. We hold our wounds, our sin, our failings and disappointments to Jesus Christ, who kisses them and while they do not disappear, they diminish. I had studied Christianity at the Catholic Institute in Paris under Pere Grelot, a priest who taught Introduction to the New Testament in French. I was a religion major at Tufts University and was fascinated by mysticism and I became a Christian in 1995 when I joined my church, Second Presbyterian Church in Nashville. Meeting Jesus Again for the First Time, the 1995 book by Marcus Borg and The Authentic Gospel of Jesus, a 2009 book by Geza Vermes were very valuable sources of my model of care.</p><p>William James, the psychologist of religion influential in the early 1900s, in his published lectures, The Varieties of Religious Experience, emphasized the great diversity of ways in which people have spiritual experiences that guide their outlooks. The accounts of these patients seem to reinforce the importance of spiritual care providers having an approach that does not impose judgment or rigid expectations to spirituality. By witnessing the ways people encounter spiritual values with appreciation, we can serve our patients in an authentic way that does not intrude on the appropriate freedom from condemnation. (See John 3:18).</p><p>Brother David Steindl-Rast, a 100-year-old Benedictine Monk and co-author of Belonging to the Universe, speaks of the importance of belonging, saying that it is the basis of spirituality. He writes that when people use the term “God,” that God is the one they feel they belong to. He adds that with this sense of belonging, there is also a sense of longing and that this is a tension in our spiritual journey of life. He writes that “we long for that to which we most deeply belong.” Our sense of belonging, he suggests, calls us to respect the earth and other creatures, and to act in accordance with these beliefs, including by religious ritual and worship. He states that with gratitude, we become less fearful and cultivate happiness and a sense of abundance with respect for others.</p><p>In The Myth of Normal: Trauma, Illness, and Healing in a Toxic Culture, Gabor Maté, M.D., and his son Daniel chronicle numerous medical sources that show various forms of systemic disease can be traced to societal influences that breed competition, captious fault-finding, and forms of cultural alienation and materialism. The authors emphasize how harmful self-concepts and mental rumination, like the shame I identified in my tentative approaches to spiritual care, can make people sick from stress that sometimes becomes physical symptomatology as the body seeks greater regulation.</p><p>Dr. Maté is an author and retired psychiatrist who specializes in addiction recovery and trauma-informed care. He learned about how people like ourselves adopt a mistaken identity by over-relying on what begins as “healthy remorse.” On page 432, they write that healthy remorse is like the voice of the Spirit, “Nature’s way of bringing us back to our interconnected nature.” The authors write that these inner voices that come to keep our motives in check first come along to save us and heal us through a realignment, but that what matters is that we, rather than they, “are not in the lead.” (<em>Id</em>. at 432).</p><p>As I completed reading The Myth of Normal, I was left with an interest in invoking the Spirit and bringing forth the sacred by helping ease narratives of condemnation. I gravitated toward concepts from Internal Family Systems Therapies, advanced by Richard Schwartz, Ph.D., and the insights of Bessel van der Kolk, M.D. As a man with experience with family members and job experience working with people with mental illness, and coping with my own experience with panic reactions and fainting episodes, I found Internal Family Systems Therapies to be very helpful resources. These references helped me understand how posttraumatic stress disorder arises from exposure to upsetting events like physical, emotional, or sexual, childhood abuse or neglect, and violence in military conflict and criminal acts, and anxiety and stress from fear of social dominance, are unhealthy and part of a spiritual distress that will benefit from healing.</p><p>Self-compassion is the principal advice in The Myth of Normal, and the authors urge freeing oneself from automatic programming. (See, pp. 393–94, 431–32). They suggest helping ease the voices of self-criticism that start out as helpful guides, finding antidotes to them, or reframing them with gratitude and perspective. They urge a shift from wondering, “How do I get rid of this?” to “What is this for? Why is this here?. They continue, “In other words, we endeavor to get to know these irksome aspects of ourselves and then, as best we can, to turn them from foes to friends.” (<em>Id</em>. at 431). Before unhealthy patterns of negativity and shame manifest in mental or physical illness, paying careful attention can help people realign their priorities and proceed toward wholeness. Dr. Maté provides an illustration, whiting, “Somewhat playfully, I call these apparent foes ‘stupid friends’ …these parts cannot learn new tricks. They refuse to get the memo that the circumstances under which they first came along no longer exist, and we are no longer children in peril.” (<em>Id</em>. at 431–32).</p><p>My work during my residency and as a chaplain led me to embrace Universalism. Rev. Hosea Ballou was the first president of Tufts College, where I majored in religion. In his work, An Examination of the Doctrine of Future Retribution, On the Principles of Morals, Analogy and the Scriptures, (Boston Trumpet Office. p. 36. (1834)) described one of its tenets:</p><p>It is well known, and will be acknowledged by every candid person, that the human heart is capable of becoming soft, or hard; kind, or unkind; merciful or unmerciful, by education and habit. On this principle we contend, that the infernal torments, which false religion has placed in the future world, and which ministers have, with an overflowing zeal, so constantly held up to the people, and urged with all their learning and eloquence, have tended so to harden the hearts of the professors of this religion, that they have exercised, toward their fellow creatures, a spirit of enmity, which but too well corresponds with the relentless cruelty of their doctrine, and the wrath which they have imagined to exist in our heavenly Father. By having such an example constantly before their eyes, they have become so transformed into its image, that, whenever they have had the power, they have actually executed a vengeance on men and women, which evinced that the cruelty of their doctrine had overcome the native kindness and compassion of the human heart.</p><p>The acceptance of mystery is a strong indicator of faith. This makes openness a valuable attribute for chaplains in healthcare settings. Michael Pollan’s 2026 book, A World Appears, discusses scientific disagreement about life and “the hard problem of consciousness,” which is the absence of an explanation for life and awareness. After numerous interviews and research on the subject, he concludes that there is great value in “not-knowing,” openness to the spiritual nature of all life, and appreciation that life is a mystery. Part of the discussion in his book includes phenomenology, the study of authentic life experience, which recognizes subjective experience as part of nature, and a discussion of Edmund Husserl and the significance of one’s life world or <em>lebenswelt</em>. (<em>Id</em>. at large print edition, p. 172). He describes considerable frustration and disillusionment among materialist scientists and philosophers attempting to come up with an explanation for the mystery and identifies the tendency to find stagnation and futility in closed systems that impose stiff or wooden explanations in reductionist terms.</p><p>Mr. Pollan notes that being in an “explore mode” can help evoke the numinous nature of childhood by “softening the sense of self.” His reflections on the encounters with the creative and imaginative sources in his book helped him learn to appreciate the capacity of spontaneous, nondirective thought to help reveal greater meaning to life and appreciation of lived experience. (<em>Id</em>. at 217).</p><p>One of the sources Mr. Pollan discussed in his book, Dr. Allison Gopnik, a neuroscientist at Berkeley and author of the 2009 book, The Philosophical Baby, describes how children and infants look at the world with “lantern vision” viewing a field as a whole with many attributes, as opposed to “spotlight vision,” with a utilitarian or goal-directed focus, which is more common in adults. Dr. Gopnik studied how childhood emphasizes the relational and exploratory phenomenal state which makes people more open and plastic in the sense of adaptability to change. (<em>Id</em>. at 257). One theory Mr. Pollan advances is that serotonin, a neurotransmitter, or hormone associated with openness, may offer adaptability. I suspect that in moments of distress, this openness can offer our patients “critical periods” of learning and meaning making, which these narratives reveal: an openness to inspiration and anomalous experience that brings a sense of meaning, purpose, and love. Perhaps this is why Jesus urged the faithful to look at the world as a child would, with wonder, curiosity, and awe.</p><p>In the poem The Guest House, Jalāl al-Dīn Rūmī, the thirteenth century Persian Sufi mystic writes, in the interpretation of Coleman Barks:</p><p>This being human is a guest house. Every morning a new arrival. A joy, a depression, a meanness, some momentary awareness comes as an unexpected visitor. Welcome and entertain them all! Even if they’re a crowd of sorrows, who violently sweep your house empty of its furniture, still, treat each guest honorably. He may be clearing you out for some new delight. The dark thought, the shame, the malice, meet them at the door laughing, and invite them in. Be grateful for whoever comes, because each has been sent as a guide from beyond.</p><p>Prior to my fellowship, I had read the books Life After Life: The Investigation of a Phenomenon — Survival of Bodily Death by Raymond Moody, (Harper &amp; Row 1975), not long after it was published, the 1971 book Journeys Out of the Body by Robert Monroe, and The Ultimate Journey, Consciousness and the Mystery of Death, by Dr. Stanislav Grof, published in 2006 by the Multidisciplinary Association for Psychedelic Studies. These discussions about transpersonal psychology and soul awareness correspond with Paul’s description of the spiritual body or <em>soma pneumatikon</em>, in 1 Corinthians 15:44 and the principle that consciousness can exist apart from the brain. Survivors of near death experiences often have lucid recollections of events when their bodies show no signs of awareness, or rapid sequences of visions of their life as they fall or face death from a sudden crisis. Survivors often report portals to another realm and contact with benevolent souls or spiritual and angelic presences. These experiences have helped survivors of such experiences feel new love for life and appreciation of the soul’s prospect for an afterlife.</p><p>Veterans attribute near-death experience with the inspiration to provide them comfort and faith for this life and the afterlife. Patients identify near-death or out-of-body experiences as resources to impart confidence in the afterlife, the present life, and appreciating each breath and moment. Confidence in this life and the next brings meaning and inspires people to greater gratitude, forgiveness, and peaceful understanding. A near-death experience inspired one man to quit smoking cigarettes and another man to have hope and a new sense of purpose. A close call with death brought one patient gratitude for his life and a sense of purpose. A near-death experience and lessons from spiritualism inspired a patient with the courage and optimism to accept more easily the news of recurring lung cancer. A near-death experience in a dream led one man to identify an important relationship that gives meaning and purpose.</p><p>Reflections on Appropriate Pastoral Models of Care</p><p>Experiences that these patients identify as critical periods that afford life changes in their outlooks and spiritual orientations are very personal to them and form a core of insight and inspiration. For many patients who have such transformative experiences, they become treasures that lead to new commitments and become part of their identities. Developing familiarity with patients through openness, appreciation, and curiosity in care encounters tends to promote trust, which can help people feel seen and stay involved with life. By engaging with the patients in a respectful, positive, and affirming way, these patients felt confident enough to share their narratives of resilience, meaning, and purpose, entrusting me with something personal and valuable at a time of vulnerability in a hospital. An authentic appreciation of the life of the Spirit is consistent with the Veterans Affairs chaplaincy approach of offering respect for the orienting systems of individual patients and approaching patients with cultural humility.</p><p>During my residency, I had had to confront a dynamic in which I had made a patient feel like an object and this helped me learn to be more relational and engaging. I have worked to recall and record details about the patients I meet to help bring familiarity and build relations in later visits. I strive to be a companion in difficult times and a loving presence. This has helped me focus on compassion-centered, trauma-informed care and my appreciation on authenticity and companionship. The patient narratives listed above are the gifts, the fruit borne from this approach, this practice of being an empathic presence present to affirm their narratives of healing in relationship with God and community.</p><p>This project results from my appreciation of how veterans can draw inspiration out of adversity and reframe their experiences. Some of the narratives may appear odd and unconventional and not consistent with conventional theologies. The variety of experience that patients find to be faith-building and transformative of outlook and identity reinforces the value of spiritual care providers who can address diverse populations. As chaplains serving a diverse population from many backgrounds, we need to respect unique experiences and traditions. We must also be able to provide care to the majority Christian population who wish to express their faith. As time passes and demographics continue to change, our population is likely to increase in its proportion of nontraditional spirituality, and it will be important to address spiritual care needs in a flexible and adaptable way.</p><p>Veterans in medical care can have better outcomes with favorable and affirming spiritual care, which can help them appreciate the gifts and capabilities they have cultivated. Fear of pain, disease, grief, and existential despair can cause people to develop entrenched patterns of resistance. These patterns can be effective survival strategies to resist trauma, terror, and despair, but avoidance and resistance can be inhibitory of wholeness and flourishing. An authentic sense of deep meaning seems to require confronting pain and suffering. It is a hard task to face the reckoning that is accomplish this type of outlook. Sometimes, it appears spontaneously by grace.</p><p>In his book, The Empathic God, Dr. Frank Woggon writes that salvation appears in the compassionate engagement with harmed and shamed persons and communities. Applying a wholeness model of redemption, he writes that cultivating a state of belonging, offering community in life-affirming ways, and being present with patients in their uncomfortable and vulnerable places is important for healing. Dr. Woggon states that relational wholeness in individuals and communities is the essence of salvation. (2–3). He portrays the calling of spiritual care workers to be building “relational wholeness.” (251). By becoming a trusted companion, and providing a sense of belonging and self-acceptance, the spiritual care worker can help another person overcome alienation. He states that faith can offer flourishing in important ways and he finds the capacity for salvation in healing and community.</p><p>Citing Rita N. Brock, Dr. Woggon views sin as the experience and consequence of being damaged, a brokenness to be healed. (67). Dr. Woggon writes that shame is integral to our culture and that it can be eliminated only by integrating into wholeness with the benefit of empathic connections and understanding. He suggests a process to recognize shame and face it and understand it empathically. (199). Empathy has potential to overcome the alienating effect of shame, he observes, and stimulate positive regard and self-exploration. (212). He advocates for a type of spiritual care that listens to the brokenhearted and offers restorative love and empathy to welcome and restore through relationships that provide grace. Compassionate spiritual care providers represent God’s solidarity amid suffering.</p><p>Dr. Woggon sees acts of solidarity and support as opportunities to liberate people from traumatic memories that can instill shame. (105). “Attempts to mitigate the effects of trauma by developing a persona to mask the shame only intensify the alienation between self and others.” (87). He urges spiritual care providers to provide resources that support flourishing through empathic engagement. Dr. Woggon draws from patient narratives and other stories showing conflict and alienation, and their resolution, with illustrations of the conflict between one’s will to be known in one’s full humanity and the fear of rejection. One practical act of solidarity and support he suggests is using curiosity to welcome and encourage a liberating confrontation with one’s trauma so a care recipient can reframe and transform one’s outlook from shame to reconciliation and liberation. (105).</p><p>Dr. Woggon writes, “Jesus’s work for liberation from shame, his healing work, and his activism to establish just relationships must be considered central aspects of his atoning life. (235). He argues that what Jesus brought to the world is an empathic response to intrinsic shame and estrangement. Jesus was concerned with overcoming divisions in relations and providing a sense of belonging and self-acceptance. This is borne out in the role Jesus plays as a mediator to God who uplifts the ordinary people and village life as models for the reign of God in his parables. (235). In Luke 6:36, Jesus directs the faithful everywhere to show compassion to others, saying “Be merciful, just as your Father is merciful.” Luke’s parable about the return of the prodigal son, (Luke 15:11–32) also emphasizes the compassion of God.</p><p>Spiritual care, he states, offers an opportunity to be drawn into the details that bring relationship. (262). Like an artist, the chaplain is invited to bring attention to the care recipients’ stories, remembering their myths, rituals, activities, problems, and experiences. He discusses a broad definition of spirituality that was developed by an interdisciplinary group of palliative care providers, in a 2014 article in The Journal of Palliative Medicine. Spirituality is “the aspect of humanity that refers to the way individuals seek and express meaning and purpose and the way they experience their connectedness to the moment, to self, to others, to nature, and to the significant or sacred.” (247). He identifies meaning-making as a principal tool for spiritual care; to bring connection that facilitates an awareness of one’s imperfection, “a hopeful response to life as it is.” (248).</p><p>Having served as a chaplain for the Department of Veterans Affairs for almost two years, I have noticed that relational and restorative love are healing. I seek to remind people of what endures in their lives after loss and the activities and relations that are their sources of inspiration. Many patient encounters lead to important discussions about faith and the ways in which God is appreciated as non-dominant and non-controlling. These narratives serve to illustrate the benefit of spiritual care providers who strive to be engaged companions who appreciate, respect, and affirm the care recipient’s spiritual and social resources.</p><p>The theological model that Dr. Woggon emphasizes is very useful for the experience of being a companion that does not reinforce narratives of alienation, restriction, and condemnation that isolate people and create alienation. I believe that sin is hurting other people from malice, greed, or ill will, and that it creates alienation and impairs the healing we seek to promote. Faith brings the courage and strength to intend goodness for others, to feel gratitude and forgiveness, and to share from an appreciation of abundance.</p><p>The patients describe a type of surrender, a giving over to God, respecting and appreciating the benevolence of a caring power. It seems to resemble the loving kindness that holds everything together, reminiscent of Julian of Norwich. She came to terms with the presence of sin in the world by relying on principles of love and gratitude. She was known for her writing, “All shall be well and all shall be well and all manner of thing shall be well. For there is a force of love moving through the universe that holds us fast and will never let us go.”</p><p>Faith and the Acceptance of Mystery</p><p>My work has led to appreciation of openness and curiosity, including making room for nontraditional spirituality. Experiences that these patients identify are very personal and become treasures that lead to new commitments. It seems important for chaplains to join patients and celebrate the ways their inner spirits come alive. The Apostle Paul emphasized that there are varieties of gifts and varieties of service. He also wrote that the Lord is the Spirit, and where the spirit of the Lord is, there is freedom. This illustrates how there is a living God active in the ways patients have found healing, ways like repentance, surrender, or resolution.</p><p>The theological foundations that I identified from the encounters and the ways I feel most authentic for spiritual care are to bring an empathic presence as a companion in a challenging time. I hope to remind the patients that their sources of comfort and transformation endure after loss and trauma, so that they will find their own resources to cope with loss, adapt to change, and even find ways to flourish by confronting and accepting their uncomfortable feelings. Being present in the moment in times of difficulty, and resisting the impulse to avoid and escape reveals difficult feelings, reveals authentic hope. I remind people that God loves them, to be a present witness of all of their feelings, and be a reminder that people are not alone by honoring their unique experiences and resisting the impulse to provide my own answers. I can acknowledge and celebrate each patient’s strengths, their curiosity to approach their lives as an adventure.</p><p>The good news I want to share is the gospel of freedom from condemnation which reveals that we all are beloved children of God and that we do not have to earn the worthiness to experience God’s love. When people understand that afflictions, struggles, suffering, and health crises are part of human experience and inherent to embodied existence along with the presence of loving awareness, they can find meaning and ease the burden of grief and shame that lead to estrangement and alienation. The gospel of the good news is a burden and a blessing, being anointed with power and authority, and being propelled to the depths. With love, we can accept our vulnerability and our sensitive uncomfortable emotions, including our grief and other unlived parts of our experience, as part of a big picture of color, light and shadow, making up the entire “human document.” By bringing wholeness to understanding, spiritual care providers can help spiritual care recipients preserve their quality of life and accept their humanity, suffering, and vulnerability as part of something wondrous and difficult, but beautiful.</p><p>Ralph Waldo Emerson wrote that God enters by a private door to every individual. As a chaplain in a diverse environment, respect for a care recipient’s orienting system is our mission. The first amendment assures patients that our service will not take steps to establish a particular religion and that we will respect the patients’ freedom of religion. As part of this responsibility, spiritual care providers approach individuals with cultural humility and resist the temptation to direct patients spiritually. Implicit in this mission is the recognition that the patient is a living document, as Anton Boison observed, and that the patient has the resources from life experience and inner wisdom to develop toward wholeness and healing. These principles free the chaplain to appreciate and encourage the care recipient’s inner power to adapt to changes in a way that enhances the care recipient’s quality of life despite setbacks in health and social circumstances, even near the conclusion of one’s lifetime.</p><p>Conclusion</p><p>The narratives that result from this research project suggest that out-of-the-ordinary, or anomalous experiences that impart meaning are very important. Our patients often have thought of themselves as very capable and influential, and able to effect changes and be protective of themselves and others. Life can present these types of experiences, and break through humanity’s resistance to confronting our unlived aspects of self, our entrenched patterns of evasiveness, to confront hard truths about life to inspire greater aliveness. Sometimes these layers of resistance ease away fairly easily after inner work. Other times the reckoning can be more painful. Pain, disease, grief, and other traumatic experiences lead people to create strategies for survival to prevent terror and despair. Sometimes, it is natural to move toward avoidance and denial, but these narratives reveal how a reckoning with hard truths can build resilience. Patients will describe how confronting and recognizing their sources of fear and accepting a hard truth can inspire and reinforce love and aliveness. When care recipients feel loss they often express gratitude for the experiences that brought “aliveness,” flourishing, and thriving after confrontation with difficult truths, while lamenting their loss of the ability to participate more in life. I offered encouragement and appreciation, as well as understanding, and help them affirm faith and reframe their struggles into a whole picture, with both light and shadow, to find beauty in the unique details of their experiences.</p><p>Experience can be a “brutal teacher,” as one of my patients said, but part of the gift of life is a blessing that many sources of joy are provided by the Creator to overcome the temptation to withdraw and live lives of insulated resignation. Acceptance of the full range of experience and the challenges of life is a responsibility, but it is also a gift to oneself, and allows people who bear witness to all of life to claim a deeper soul connection. It also helps people find the ways in which Spirit is alive.</p><p>These narratives reveal to me an organic process from our Source that leads the human spirit to triumph in brokenness and recognize its potential. This has felt familiar, like Hans Christian Anderson’s story of the ugly duckling who recognizes its intrinsic beauty after a time of trial and humiliation. These accounts show what Rabindranath Tagore named when he said, in Gitanjali 69 “my pride is from the life-throb of ages dancing in my blood this moment.” I hear the baritone voice of Peter Tosh when he sang, “and I try, I really try, try, but I’ve got to pick myself up and dust myself off and start all over again,” an inner voice like Bob Dylan’s find Chimes of Freedom “Tolling for the aching ones whose wounds cannot be nursed” and tolling for “each an’ ev’ry underdog soldier in the night An’ we gazed upon the chimes of freedom flashing.” I also hear Bob Marley’s urging, “Won’t you help to sing these songs of freedom, cause all I ever have [are] redemption songs.”</p><p>Providing greater understanding about the subjective experiences that accompany dramatic healing experiences and personal transformation can inform awareness of the critical role of care recipients’ engagement in their own healing. Learning how people break through entrenched patterns of resistance hopefully can inform care providers, as well as medical, surgical, holistic health, and specialty medical care teams provide considered and informed spiritual interventions that promote patient autonomy. Increasing awareness of meaning-making and purpose can help stimulate discussions about the goals of treatment and healing.</p><p>Lessons from my own experience and my residency and fellowship in clinical pastoral education have reinforced my interest in serving a narrative of wholeness and soul connection. My focus on ministry involves alleviating self-condemnation and helping our patients experience wholeness with light and shadow in perspective. Without bypassing the reality of death, hard experience, and disillusionment, the veterans whose accounts are recorded here have found support in their own experience and were kind to share their stories of resilience. Spiritual care providers can benefit people in distress by helping them with their naturally-occurring narratives from their own experience from the teachings of life that have allowed the veterans to reframe their experiences from disillusionment to promote healing and faith that builds hope. Hopefully, these narratives will contribute to understanding about how people find resilience and healing as they build faith and hope to lead them toward wholeness.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=91cfe4e8a1b5" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Narratives of Freedom and Resilience from Veterans on 2-North in Nashville]]></title>
            <link>https://ronmcnutt.medium.com/narratives-of-freedom-and-resilience-from-veterans-on-2-north-in-nashville-fc3dcdf46714?source=rss-368797e78488------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/fc3dcdf46714</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[spiritual-care]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[veterans-affairs]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ronald W. McNutt]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 29 Jul 2026 20:45:04 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-07-29T20:48:20.236Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Narratives of Freedom and Resilience from Veterans on 2-North in Nashville</p><p>Patient Accounts of Sources of Inspiration for Faith, Healing, and Transformation: Forms of Experience that Bring Meaning and Purpose to Motivate Positive Changes in Lifestyle and Orientation. A research project, 2025 to 2026 second-year fellowship clinical specialty with medical-surgical patients.</p><p>Ronald W. McNutt, chaplain fellow, U.S. Veterans Affairs Tennessee Valley Healthcare System, V.A. Healthcare Center in Nashville.</p><p>Purpose and Overview of this Study</p><p>This is a fellowship project that accumulates narratives that were identified as significant events by spiritual care recipients during chaplain visits during the past fellowship year from October 2025 to September 2026. This study records some descriptions of spontaneous or dramatic events, realizations, and anomalous experiences that some told me had brought them meaning and purpose or otherwise inspired them to change their lifestyles and orient themselves with new priorities. This research project presents and explores the narrative accounts that have surfaced as significant and precise in the descriptions patients offer from their own experience during spiritual care encounters. The assembled narrative accounts have surfaced in natural conversations that explore sources of motivation or inspiration and describe the types of past inspiring experiences, events, and important decisions that care recipients have identified as providing them with meaning and purpose and with hope and confidence.</p><p>The patients in this study are on a medical and surgical care floor at the Nashville Veterans Affairs Hospital with the Tennessee Valley Healthcare System. They come primarily from the Middle Tennessee and Kentucky area. Some patients come from other areas of the country for traveling veteran care, or organ transplant services including follow-up care. A separate document with identifying information and subject to HIPAA is available to my educator and director for purposes of authenticity and documentation in case it may become useful for further study. The patient visits are primarily initial encounters, with frequent return visits and follow-up visits as patients continue treatment and find improvement or further advancement of their healthcare concerns. As we discuss their progress and outlook, these accounts surface as sources of inspiration in their lives and their outlook of faith.</p><p>This project presents diverse examples of what patients describe as important to them and to bring greater understanding about the varieties of experiences that become sources of resilience. It is important for chaplains to document the spiritual orientation of patients and how it impacts their emotions and sense of purpose as they confront their challenges. I try to learn whether the patients have a strong sense of what to live for. Like other providers, I encourage the veterans to identify their sense of meaning regardless of whether they are nearing the end of life. This includes an appreciation that death is a natural result of embodied life. Approaching patients with openness and positive regard can encourage the patients to share what is important to them and to shed light on their spiritual and emotional needs when they face critical healthcare decisions.</p><p>The literature suggests what my experience seems to confirm, that a sense of meaning and purpose is important for relations, belonging, and self-esteem and can help make medical treatment more effective and can help improve outcomes for care recipients. Patients can benefit from their past spiritual experiences when they receive treatment, augmenting the medical services and care of doctors, nurses and healthcare technicians. When patients identify experiences of transformation, they often describe purposeful choices motivated by a desire to take a different approach to life and to or pursue new priorities and embrace new core values.</p><p>These accounts may resemble repentance in Christian theology. Some accounts are dramatic, with visions, sounds, or realizations. These experiences provide meaning in health crises, even into end-of-life care, and especially for the majority of patients who are receiving short-term treatment for illnesses and exacerbations of chronic medical conditions. Patients can improve spontaneously or with the support of the medical team but the experience can disorienting and frightening. Spiritual care providers can help them gain support by relying on their inner resources of inspiration, which can bring a sense of gratitude and blessing in a challenging time.</p><p>Chaplains can become aware of how a care recipient’s spiritual orientation affects recovery from the medical conditions and life challenges that impact them. Providing insight into their sense of meaning could help foster patient care and inform other members of the medical team. A patient may be more willing to receive additional treatment or undergo difficult medical procedures if he or she has something to live for. A patient who is at peace about a transition may choose a path with quality of life as a priority even if it hastens death. I hope to build greater appreciation of how the patient is a “living human document” with unique experiences and intentions that complement the healing modalities of the medical team. I hope to build awareness of how such experiences and decisions provide resilience and openness to patients that help them face new serious challenges to their agency, capacity, and autonomy.</p><p>Patient Sources and Process of Gathering Narratives</p><p>The patients in the source material that follows were seen by me on an acute care floor in hospital beds receiving inpatient treatment at a Veterans Affairs hospital for medical conditions. Every week this past year, I have seen patients who are in the hospital receiving care, including surgery or diagnostic procedures for chronic conditions or acute injuries, diseases, or conditions. Most patients are in their sixties or older and are male. The veterans are typically men in their seventies and eighties. It is not uncommon to speak to men with combat experience from the Vietnam War era healing from trauma from combat or injuries received in military service.</p><p>The selection of the following narratives is subjective and based on the emphasis of importance the spiritual care recipients placed on their experiences. The prominence, clarity, and importance that these events have, in marking turning points in patients’ lives is not typical but their significance is representative of care recipients’ need to find meaning and inspiration for weathering difficult adversity. I routinely ask what inspires patients, and patients mention a wide variety of activities and relations, motorcycle rides, fishing, family, pets, and hobbies, which I respect, avoiding impressions that something more is expected. These exchanges have stood out as significant, at least at the time I gleaned them. They are not necessarily correlated to unusually beneficial outcomes, but are related to improved quality of life, from the patients’ point of view, at least for a brief period of time, but usually much longer.</p><p>I typically see seven to ten patients per day, usually five days per week, with occasional repeat patients. Sometimes I will interact briefly with one or two patients who show little interest in engagement. For context I will assume over fifty weeks, I will see roughly 35 patients per week during most weeks approximately 1,200 individuals, accounting for repeat visits, holidays and vacations, and days with administrative activities. This estimate clearly shows that a typical individual patient visit will not involve identified spontaneous transformation, healing, or dramatic life-transforming events. Most patient accounts of experiences that help provide meaning and purpose to their lives are significant but not as transformative as the ones that I am accumulating and recording here.</p><p>Accounts with unredacted information that will allow for identification to prove authenticity will be stored separately and sent in encrypted form at the conclusion of this project. The accounts in this project are edited for greater clarity and to remove identifying information to protect patient privacy. This is a qualitative review and not an empirical clinical study. My intention is to accumulate information within my role as a spiritual care provider. By collecting and synthesizing the patients’ accounts of experiences that have transformed their lives and helped to provide meaning and purpose to their lives, I hope to identify some recurring themes.</p><p>Chaplains are equipped to help patients find meaning for their suffering to encourage their recovery. Spiritual experience often gives patients perspective to face often dire circumstances, even their end-of-life existential concerns, with equanimity. As a chaplain and a participant in the healing arts, I believe that this project can help provide information to help consider the emotional needs of veterans and identify, and generate appreciation for spiritual and spontaneous experiences as sources of well-being and healing.</p><p>Forms of experience that bring meaning and purpose to motivate changes in lifestyle and orientation</p><p>Religious traditions seek to align one’s body, mind, and spirit in tune with the creative and sustaining forces. Whether called God, Natural Law, or another form of spiritual, existential, religious, or theological term, part of human experience seeks to create order by actions and intentions that are consistent with an order that is restorative and provides energy and seems to be supportive of widespread or universal goodwill and harmony. In times of personal tragedy and when people feel lost, cynical, or betrayed, they often make decisions that do not serve their best interests. Jesus spoke of lost sheep, the prodigal son, the lost coin, and repentance as a way back into the good graces of the higher power.</p><p>Often in times of distress and despair, people’s identities are threatened. Their lives’ purpose and meaning are compromised when they lose capacity to engage in the activities that brought engagement and a sense of belonging or experience grief from the loss of loved ones. It is critical for healing to have a sense of meaning to counter existential despair and feelings of shame and failure that come from having dramatic changes to one’s world view. Prior life experience that led to faith, acceptance, and gratitude help build resilience. It is beyond the scope of this project to chronicle these benefits, but it is important to consider the ways that meaning and purpose can appear in one’s life, become part of one’s narrative, and come into awareness at times of pain, loss, and feelings of emptiness from grave diagnoses.</p><p>Often, veterans will draw inspiration from their sources of meaning and purpose when they survive health crises and reflect on ways they found resilience and thrived in their lives. They also describe times when they decide to turn their lives around because they do not want to have a downfall and have experiences like family members or friends who provide negative examples. People who have made positive changes, supported others, and taken risks to help others, cite such experiences as resources for their own healing. For example, a man who had come into the hospital with problem with low pulse was elated with gratitude after fearing that he would not survive. He was expecting to be restored to his life activities. He reflected on how, as a youth minister in his forties, he helped support and encourage many young people for many years. He shared how he had invested love and goodwill toward others and felt that his life has been blessed by God’s spirit and the presence of angels. He was not afraid of the afterlife and he was giving God the glory for it all.</p><p>Veterans in medical care can have better outcomes with favorable and affirming spiritual care. Religion and spirituality have been associated with positive health outcomes. Researchers have shown that patients who find meaning in spiritual, religious, existential, and theological perspectives find these attitudes protective when facing mild to moderate depression and anxiety. Spiritual and religious orientation can help insulate people from having posttraumatic stress disorder when they have experience with trauma and violence. <em>See</em>, Balboni, T. <em>et al</em>. editors, “Spirituality in serious illness and health,” Journal of the American Medical Association. (2022) 328(2):184–197 10.1001/jama.2022.11086 <a href="https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/35819420/">https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/35819420/</a>; Fitchett, G. and Nolan, S., editors, Spiritual Care in Practice: Case Studies in Healthcare Chaplaincy (February 2015); Fitchett, G., Rybarczyk, B. D., DeMarco, G. A., &amp; Nicholas, J. J. (1999). “The role of religion in medical rehabilitation outcomes: A longitudinal study,” <em>Rehabilitation Psychology, 44</em>(4), 333–353. <a href="https://psycnet.apa.org/doi/10.1037/0090-5550.44.4.333">https://doi.org/10.1037/0090-5550.44.4.333</a>; VandeCreek, L., Lucas, A. Editors The Discipline for Pastoral Care Giving: Foundations for Outcome Oriented Chaplaincy Journal of Health Care Chaplaincy, Volume 10, Number 2 2001 and Volume 11, Number 1 2001.</p><p>During my chaplaincy, I became more comfortable addressing mortality and the veterans’ thoughts and beliefs about the afterlife. I noticed a wide variety of outlooks and a sense of relief that they could have someone who would discuss death with openness and in a peaceful way. Our culture avoids death but people must confront its reality in the hospital, or spend considerable effort to avoid doing so. Some research shows that this confrontation with death can help people find improved quality of life. In psychology, the term “mortality salience” to describe engagement with death consciously through therapy or contemplation. Some research indicates it can increase resources such as increased gratitude and improved relations with others, and increased appreciation of one’s place in creation. <em>See</em>, Cozzolino, P. J., “Death contemplation, growth, and defense: Converging evidence of dual-existential systems?” <em>Psychological Inquiry</em>, 17, 278–287(2006); Hicks, J. and Routledge, C. The experience of meaning in life: Classical perspectives, emerging themes, and controversies (2013).</p><p>Vail et al., <em>Personality and Social Psychology </em>Review, 16(4) 303–329 (2012) have described how acceptance of the reality of death brings about improved satisfaction in life and greater freedom to prioritize what brings people greater satisfaction and relationships with others. <a href="https://existentialpsych.sites.tamu.edu/wp-content/uploads/sites/152/2020/02/Vail-III-K.-E.-Juhl-J.-Arndt-J.-Vess-M.-Routledge-C.-Rutjens-B.-T.-2012.-When-death-is-good-for-life.pdf">https://existentialpsych.sites.tamu.edu/wp-content/uploads/sites/152/2020/02/Vail-III-K.-E.-Juhl-J.-Arndt-J.-Vess-M.-Routledge-C.-Rutjens-B.-T.-2012.-When-death-is-good-for-life.pdf</a></p><p>Community organizer and activist Saul Alinsky describes how accepting mortality helped him focus on his priorities:</p><p>I have learned one lesson, I learned it in my belly, the astonishing lesson that I wasn’t going to live forever…After the full realization, on a gut basis, that I was going to die, my whole life changed. I was confronted with the question, ‘What is the meaning of my life, since I’m here just so long a period of time?’ I’ve never been able to answer that question. I don’t ever expect to answer it. But I know that once you reach the point of accepting your own death, you no longer care much whether you’re important or not important.</p><p>Some recent research has identified positive benefits from dream states when patients come out from anesthesia. Dr. Lauren Hack, Dr. Harrison Chow, and Dr. Pillerin Sikka authored a research article, “Reduction in trauma-related symptoms after anesthetic-induced intra-operative dreaming,” in the American Journal of Psychiatry, 2024 Jun 1;181(6):563–564. <a href="https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/38476046/">https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/38476046/</a> which Boris Heifets, M.D., Ph.D., an anesthesiology professor at Stanford University, discussed at Emory University’s 2026 Science on Spiritual Health Conference. I have spoken to several veterans who have visions during surgery or other interventions that help give them inspiration. The research revealed that two-thirds of patients with dreams in gentle awakening from anesthesia had very positive outcomes, and another 20 % had somewhat positive outcomes. Some patients reported resolution of post-traumatic stress disorder. Dr. Heifets stated that this research urges allowing patients to continue under anesthesia quietly and gently, rather than reviving them before they awaken in the natural course, in order to obtain possible benefits to help ease trauma. He suggests further exploring intentional dream induced anesthesia involving slowly emerging from anesthesia and integrating their visions.</p><p>Patient Accounts of Sources of Inspiration for Faith, Healing, and Transformation</p><p>September 2025</p><p>1). A near-death experience inspires a man to quit smoking cigarettes.</p><p>A veteran who is 66 and unhoused had a vision that helped him recover from heart surgery. He shared a triumphant narrative about visions he received when he had heart surgery in 2008. He was transformed when he had a vision of Jesus and angels and visions of consequences that led him to quit smoking cigarettes. His guardian angel appeared and he bowed and was trembling, feeling guilty about causing his illness by smoking. He heard the angel say, “arise, my son,” and assured him that he was not in trouble. He was told, “someone wants to see you.” It was Jesus Christ, and he had a hug that helped him heal and feel total peace. He let him see his mother, who had died, and even a pet cat who had died. He felt comforted and wanted to stay, but he was told to go back and let people know about his experiences. His guardian angel was a woman. Another angel, Uriel, led him to visit hell, which had three levels, one with sinners and he saw people being forced to smoke there. He also saw heaven, and noticed that there were rooms with no bathrooms or kitchens around, since people did not have the same needs as on earth or were provided for, but he said that people do not get bored there.</p><p>2). A deliberate choice to become a new person to overcome post-traumatic stress disorder:</p><p>A 77-year-old veteran had a challenging childhood, with a mother who had bipolar mood disorder and a father who was alcoholic and a sexual predator who later became active in church. The veteran moved frequently, lived in solitude at times and with his grandmother, before he enlisted in the Marines and had some traumatic experiences in Vietnam. He shared his way to heal from PTSD that had led him to be angry, have poor control of his emotions, and he often woke up sweating. He said that he made a deliberate choice to “leave himself behind” and form a new identity. He expressed self-consciousness about this but he emphasized that it was a positive choice and that it was something he had decided to do to address a problem that seemed out of control. He is not involved in a church community because of the many differences between faith traditions, and he grew to trust more in his own experience.</p><p>October 2025</p><p>3). A message from the afterlife and a near-death experience inspire less fear of death and greater compassion.</p><p>A patient in his seventies had terrible back pain from an accident and was on long-term pain management treatment requiring opioid medication to function and was considering a revision surgery to implant a second pain pump. He became involved with church after a transformative experience when he was in a coma for 3 or 4 days after the motor vehicle accident. He observed his body from above and saw a nurse reading a magazine when a large tree limb crashed through the window and he had come to consciousness. About 15 years before his hospital admission, he had lost relatives including a beloved son-in-law who left a young daughter. A few months later, he did some automatic writing without focus, went to bed and found the following morning that he had written had been messages from his late son-in-law to impart confidence that his daughter would be a good and responsible person and assured them that there is life after death. This insight gave him relief from fear, motivated him to be a caring and responsible person, and to tolerate his pain. He became more focused on priorities involving kindness and had distanced himself from a friend who had adopted cruel behavior after serving in the Vietnam War.</p><p>4). A patient’s life turned around when he gave his cares over to God.</p><p>A 70-year-old man described his trauma as a child from having a father who was very stern, unkind, and distant. He and his siblings had a lot of chores and would not be fed unless they did them each day. He discontinued contact with his family after his mother died and struggled as he was intent on being different from his father. In his early forties, he felt his struggle overwhelming him and he decided to give everything up and he told God he would leave it all in His hands. When he gave over his cares and asked God to lead him, things started to fall into place and his burden was removed. He shared his narrative of resilience, how he showed great loyalty to his sons, built a life that seemed full of joy, including a business. He had supported his family with love and concern, including his ex-wife, who had been recovering from addiction for many years while he had custody of their children.</p><p>5). A patient feels the blessing of the Holy Spirit helped him live through combat in Vietnam.</p><p>A man in health distress related a narrative about a spiritual experience when he was a young man of 17 and had enlisted in the Marines. Just before he entered the service, a young pastor appeared at his home and met him, his mother, and his brothers, invited them to go to a church service. The patient went and when he was receiving a prayer from the pastor, he felt very strong flow of energy when the man placed his hands on him. He felt a force unlike anything he ever felt, before or since, that he could not describe or explain, which he associated with his survival when he served as a platoon sergeant in Vietnam and was responsible for 30 men. The veteran said that he felt the strength to withstand the combat safely. I asked if it could have been the Holy Spirit, and he said that he did not know what it was, but it had given him the confidence that he would be all right. He felt that this helped him withstand the combat dangers for two years, during which time he would step over mines and would have snipers fire at him and hit other soldiers. One time, the veteran heard a Vietcong intruder and woke up to save people while bullets were flying around him and took the lives of others around him.</p><p>6). A patient made lifestyle changes with retirement.</p><p>A man in his mid-seventies had had a series of medical treatments in the hospital in recent years. He said that he had retired after a career in public service and involvement with youth development after he had a back injury. He developed medical problems with pre-diabetes, arthritis and cardiovascular problems. He decided to improve his health, and he began to lose weight and exercise, walking and riding a stationary bicycle. He had declined nerve medication, choosing to use turmeric and change his diet. He had lost 100 pounds, and despite bone-on-bone hip arthritis, he found he could exercise on a stationary bicycle without hip pain. He is motivated by his interests and his grandchildren and great-grandchildren and making to best use of his remaining time in life.</p><p>7). A grandchild inspires a woman’s recovery from addiction.</p><p>I met a woman patient who had been afflicted by personal tragedies and betrayals as well as very uplifting relations. She had had an unstable childhood with an abusive stepfather and had been raised by her grandparents. When she had three young children, her ex-husband</p><p>divorced her and left her for another woman. She had been disrespected and fired by her employer when she was a single mother when she was blamed after an employee stole some money from the cash register. She later gave up a child for adoption when she was raped. She had been self-sacrificial, trying to save her marriage, and was scrupulous in finding adoptive parents for the child and forming a relationship with him. She shared all this in the presence of one of her granddaughters and it seemed very important for her to share. I responded with a statement about how her trauma sounded so overwhelming and intense that it would have caused so much pain and despair that many people would become suicidal or addicted to drugs to deal with such suffering. She confided that she had in fact become addicted to crack cocaine, but had stopped and returned to her home community to heal when she had her first grandchild. She had found her son and daughters to be a blessing in her life, and her narrative described many actions of resilience, strength, and courage to heal from her disappointments, including deepening relations with her children and the son she gave up for adoption. Her redemption experience inspired her to channel adversity to deepen her values and relations and she learned to value herself and stand up for her family.</p><p>8). A man adopts lifestyle changes due to a medical diagnosis.</p><p>One of the patients I met was a man who had been in the hospital for a week and he accepted my follow-up visit. His niece was present for part of the time. He said that he had not had to go to the hospital before he was 59. He said he had received a diagnosis of stage 4 cirrhosis and he had a cough and tremors that affected his mobility, making it too difficult to walk even short distances. He said that when he quit drinking, he had developed severe tremors and it became painful to move. He was animated, after days when he was not very engaged, explaining that he saw as opportunity to maximize his remaining time. He had asked his neighbor remove all the alcohol from his house and give it away or throw it away, and he was researching how to eat a healthy liver diet with high protein and low sodium. He wanted to be more active and avoid atrophy from lying in bed. He was not religious and the roster listed his religion as “unknown/no preference.” He was eager to return home and his niece expressed that she was dedicated to making the same changes to help support him.</p><p>9). A patient had a conversion experience in jail</p><p>One of my patients, a man in his late eighties, was interested in sharing in our patient encounter about conversion experience he had had as a young man. At the time, he was an alcoholic and was confined in jail, and a young minister reached out to him and prayed for him. He said that he had been inspired, he stopped drinking, and he had avoided alcohol ever since. Later, he served in the Marine Corps for several years and after his service, he had begun a prison ministry first with another man, and then by himself. He did this independently and not as an affiliate of a particular religion. He was a nondenominational Christian and he had attended church initially, and later had developed a solitary devotional practice. He suggested that he had not been fully saved until later in his life, and that choices made over time are part of the process of redemption, but he did not use that word. He was inspired by his long-term marriage that had lasted many years. He said that he reads the Bible every day.</p><p>November:</p><p>10). A near-death experience in a dream led to identifying an important relationship that gives meaning and purpose.</p><p>One patient I visited was a single man with hypertension and who was getting established in dialysis treatment, who was under forty. He was having fluid accumulate and was improving after over 30 pounds of fluid was being drawn off his body. He has recently lost his father and he was helping his divorced sister with the care needs of her children. He described himself as an introvert who had been reluctant to share his feelings. He grew up as a Christian but felt that many religious traditions “cherry pick” aspects of teachings and life experience and would not deal with the full picture of reality. He confided that he had been unhappy and isolated with little joy or sense of purpose, and had even considered giving up on life before his niece and nephew entered his life. He was having dire distress with medical issues when a near-death experience allowed him to identify his love and loyalty for his niece as providing meaning that has inspired his healing. One night he dreamed that he was hovering over his body in an out-of-the-body experience. In his dream, his young niece was trying to wake him up. When he woke, he realized he had the strong motivation to be present for his niece, and he told me about his appreciation for her expressiveness and how she shared her emotions. He felt his affection for her had given his life meaning and he felt the courage to provide a beautiful presence for her. He said he was grateful for his opportunity to be more active and not to feel terribly ill as he was before being established for dialysis. He was looking forward to the coming time when he would return home and feel well again.</p><p>11). Feeling absence of suffering in proximity to death brings a veteran a sense of peace.</p><p>A man who was a heart transplant recipient was admitted for complications that required extensive hospital follow up. He had a lot of fatigue and he had been in the hospital for five days at the time of this chaplain visit. His blood count was concerning and he hoped it would improve. He was active in his church community and in civic life in a small town in another state. He had humbly informed his pastor not to make a big deal when he returned to his church after his heart transplant. He shared that he was accepting of what would come his way as being part of God’s will. He had had a coronary bypass several years before the heart transplant, which had taken place almost a year before this visit. At one point in his treatment, he had “coded” and he was revived, but the process did not really phase him. His immediate concern was for his wife who had had to witness distressing measures to bring him back. He felt that God has mysterious ways, citing how he had called his mother on Mother’s Day, and she died that evening after telling him that she was “ready to go.” She had had her possessions packed up when they went to her place. He had been inspired to de-clutter his own home and he no longer felt anxious or fearful about the next life. He planned to devote his coming time with openness for discernment and engagement that would be revealed in time. He emphasized his feeling that God has a plan for him.</p><p>12). Near death experience yields hope with a sense of purpose.</p><p>A return patient had been on our unit for five days when we met, and we had met several months before. He said that after his son had died in their home a few years earlier that he almost drank himself to death from despair. He also had trauma from wartime violence. He was from a religious family and was close to his widowed mother and his living son. He shared great news that he was cleared for a liver transplant and was not far down on the waiting list. He was elated and confident that he would pass the drug screens and receive this gift after a year and a half of problems with liver function. He was inspired by an incident when his son had helped him recover from an alcohol-related near-death experience. The veteran stated that he had basically “died,” and that he had seen his deceased son who had died of a grand mal seizure and told him to go and “be there” for his living son. He spoke with good humor about a traumatic divorce many years earlier and the ways he related so well with her current husband. He was carrying grief and loss but he was enthusiastic about devoting himself to conditioning his body and was hoping to improve his health.</p><p>13). A series of dreams gives a man a sense of purpose and a mission that motivates him.</p><p>A man who was admitted for chest pain and had come to the hospital by bus, was coping with housing insecurity. Nevertheless, he expresses a strong sense of faith and calling. He had requested a large print King James version of the Bible, which I brought to him, and he asked me to walk with him in the hallways. As we walked, he described having a visit from an angel who had told him to fast for three days, stating that he would have dreams each night and receive information to know that God had sent him. His dreams revealed imagery of the inside of an art deco style building that had a cross and other indicia that it was a church. When he was visited by the angel again, he did not say what the vision was revealing, but that he would be receiving another person’s visitation.</p><p>The patient said that he spoke to a chaplain before being released from prison, who told him to go to a certain area of town, where he found the church he had seen in his dreams. He met a man there who had been waiting for him, and this contact led to him entering a long program to train people in spirituality program and develop the capacity to help others. Over the years, he said that he had developed powers for healing others, and singing and helping people out of difficult situations. He had to let go of pride. He said that he was devoted to Jesus of Nazareth, stressing the importance of identifying him specifically. His moods would shift from elation to tearfulness, as he spoke, and I suspected that his inspiration may be partly magical thinking. He showed some grandiose thoughts, stating that he was placed in the hospital to help other patients and that there is nothing wrong with his health, although he was using a walker, he had chest pain, and his records indicated substance issues.</p><p>14). A heart attack sparks a change in a traumatized Vietnam veteran.</p><p>A male veteran in his early eighties said that he had been heavily self-medicating himself after experiencing combat trauma. He was admitted for a short stay after some falls and several bouts of pneumonia. He had been healing and coping from deep trauma after combat duty in Vietnam but he realized that healing would never be complete. He said that having to sort and return effects after his comrades died was very hard. He lived in the same rural area near his birthplace and had a strong sense of place. He had met his wife by chance in the mid-1980s and he had a heart attack a few weeks after they married. He gave up heavy drinking and smoking tobacco and cannabis and he challenged himself by placing a pack of cigarettes on a shelf and staring it down. He went on to invest himself in his community and started a successful business that he ran for almost 40 years. He enjoyed a strong marriage. He and his wife had a close relationship with their son and his family with three grandchildren. He gladly accepted my offer to pray but he said that he does not participate in church activities because he objects to the financial emphasis of churches. He was excited to be able to share his enthusiasm for spirituality and asked for contact information.</p><p>December 2025</p><p>15). A near-death experience gives a man confidence in this life and the afterlife.</p><p>A Jewish veteran in his mid-sixties had had many health challenges that he had surmounted, bringing himself to an active life after a period of immobility. When he had very serious health challenges, he was out of consciousness for eight minutes. He saw visions of multiple geometric patterns, and he directed his intention to finding a deeper meaning. He said he heard a voice that told him when it was his time, God would take his breath from him. He said this is what happened to his father. This an event led him to have faith in God’s presence and gave him some peace about the afterlife. This brought him confidence that it was not his time. We discussed some parts of religious texts. He mentioned how God took breath away at death, and with Moses, he took him up to heaven.</p><p>16). A mother quit smoking to set a good example for her daughter after her own mother had set an example of inability to quit.</p><p>A woman who appeared confident and secure and who valued her strength and independence was sharing her narrative during a chaplain visit. We discussed raising children and she shared that her mother was a cigarette smoker who got lung cancer but did not quit smoking. The patient said that she had quit smoking due to an experience when she was a young mother. She was smoking as she was a sitting next to her young daughter. When her daughter said that she would smoke like her when she grew up, this led her to quit right away.</p><p>17). A church service led to a man having a born-again repentance experience and becoming active in the Assemblies of God.</p><p>A man in his mid-eighties shared his experience of being reborn during a hospital stay for fluid accumulation. He said that about ten years after his military experience, he was smoking three packs of cigarettes per day and he was drinking alcohol. Although he was married, he said that he was preoccupied with “chasing women.” He was in his early thirties when he turned his life over to Jesus Christ on a date he remembered specifically. He went to a church service and he said that Jesus asked him in and he has been changed ever since. He was active with a mission outreach program that was helping people with addiction and alcoholism through spirituality. He met his current wife after his experience of being reborn. He had gone to a Bible college in his mid-thirties and he became involved in rehabilitation ministries and serving as a pastor. He was interested in details about the accounts in the Bible. He was teaching at a rehabilitation facility in another state and learned about a new branch opening in Tennessee and had come here in the mid-1980s and he has been living in a small town, helping drug addicts and alcoholics ever since.</p><p>18). A born-again experience leads to home-schooling of children.</p><p>A man in his early sixties met with me when he was receiving treatment for diabetes-related health problems. He had swelling and pain in his foot and substantial challenges with mobility. His parents were divorced and his father would build churches overseas, although he lived with his mother and stepfather growing up. He recalled the date when he became born again at a church service, which led to his lifelong identification as a Pentecostal Christian. The experience led to him making changes in his priorities and building his reputation. He had a 50-year marriage to a Native American woman who maintained close relations with her relatives and community. He and his wife chose to home-school their children with a Christian curriculum and he said that he did not trust the government to be involved in education, apparently because of secular influences. His brother was a pastor at a different church from the worship community he attended. He said that he considered himself to be very family-oriented and stressed that his spirituality is a priority for him.</p><p>January 2026</p><p>19). A spontaneous spiritual “download” leads to confidence and assurance and ushers in a more thriving life.</p><p>A white Catholic male Marine veteran in his late fifties was being treated for foot pain from osteomyelitis and an infected foot joint. He described a vision of premonition he received on a specific day about ten years earlier when he could foresee future events involving his children. He was very excited and shared rich details about his life interests and experience. His transformation took place after a series of experiences of chance encounters that were synchronistic with his visions. He recognized that he was flawed and yet he still considered himself to be an instrument of God at a time when he was having a period of disability and distress with his vocation and family. His young daughter had had paranormal experiences with moving objects and being lifted. He was drawing associations from passages from Jeremiah and Ezekiel that were brought to his attention. He heard a Catholic priest tell him, “if you don’t regard evil, it will go away.”</p><p>As he stayed up one night reading the Bible, a voice he heard as he read from Genesis asked if he wanted to know “how this all worked.” He was directed him to look at himself in the mirror, receiving a message that he was created beautifully, and that what had happened he had done to himself. He was told he was known before he was born and would be known again, but not if he was “like that,” meaning changes were needed. He received other messages about dedication to spiritual values and not being overly focused on money. God offered to use his hands, and warned he would be tested, like Job, and feel abandoned before his life would be restored. Circumstances then ensued that affirmed his sense of calling. A woman offered him work, saying that she had been led to give him a Catholic medal to encourage him, knowing he was having a time of identification with Job. After his visionary and synchronistic experiences, his family had thought he was psychotic, but his marriage improved, he developed a successful business, he got a side job and lost weight, which led to a sense of greater confidence and faith.</p><p>20). A passage of scripture and reflection leads to grace.</p><p>A patient in his early seventies was receiving treatment for atrial fibrillation and weakness. He was a widower and a retired African-American pastor who had fallen at his home and he had been having weakness. He had some very tragic losses, grief, and trauma. He described a traumatic childhood with an emotionally abusive mother whose friend had molested him for three years when he was young. He reflected on his lengthy service as a pastor, his theological education, and how he had ordained many ministers while serving as a pastor, and his sadness about how the church had diminished in size to few members. He had retired after Covid and a loss of membership. He identified as a source of strength and resilience an experience over thirty years earlier. He said that he had surrendered to God when he released his resentment and hatred spontaneously while studying a passage from scripture, Romans 4:17, that inspired him to live into a better world. He conceptualized it as advice to “speak those things as though they were.” He had previously identified himself as an alcoholic or addict, the way people in Twelve Step programs will, but in that moment, he freed himself to adopt a better identity. He had maintained sobriety and been “clean” ever since. He was coping with trauma and grief by reflecting on his inspiration and seeing every moment as a choice. I encouraged him to recognize that he is beloved by God and to care for himself with loving kindness.</p><p>21). A near-death experience and lessons from spiritualism inspire a patient with courage and optimism despite news of recurring lung cancer.</p><p>A male patient in his late seventies shared his insights from spiritualism that gave him courage to face a recurrence of lung cancer. After having survived a prior case and having a lobe of his lung removed, he received news that indicated its recurrence in another lobe. Nevertheless, he responded with optimism that he gleaned from insights that he wanted to discuss as he was getting ready to be discharged. He was not devastated or crushed by the sobering news. He had had near-death experiences that reaffirmed his belief that people never die, they just shed their bodies and reform with spirit renewed and take on flesh. He described experiences in his childhood of communication with spirit entities named Michael and David, whom he identified as the archangel Michael and King David,. He learned arcane details about creation from them and said that he would travel to many places, in reality and in his imagination. He had enlisted in the Army because he wanted to be in combat during the Vietnam War, but he later saw through this motive of domination through his studies. He had become inspired by a scientist, Bruce Lipton, who studied epigenetics, and spiritualists Edgar Cayce, Hugh Lynn, and Walter Russell. He had come to realize that love is the fundamental principle of the universe. He believed that fear is the source of illnesses, and that ancient humans were much larger and lived much longer.</p><p>22). Protective parental instincts inspire healing from alcohol poisoning.</p><p>A young white male veteran in his thirties had been having abdominal pain for a week and was about to be discharged. He lived in a rural area with open space in the countryside. He had a solitary personality style with principles of devotion. He said that he had been drinking daily and smoking cigarettes for years and he quit about a month earlier. He was divorced and had a devoted girlfriend. He was recovering from trauma and growing in strength, but had suffered some liver damage and hoped to gain improved function. He had a son who was seven years old and he said that his protective instincts and his love for his son inspired his recent choice to quit his years-long daily pattern of drinking and smoking.</p><p>23). An idiosyncratic angelic presence and synchronous events inspire faith in a woman.</p><p>One female patient in her mid-sixties grew up in a Southern Baptist tradition. She had chemical-induced epilepsy that had ended her military career, and she had come for neurological care and physical therapy after having a severe seizure. She had family support but had grief from an unhappy marriage and had lost a couple of her siblings. She showed a sense of humor that she said was part of her openness to spirituality. She described ironic events that thwarted a baptism when she was young, first having stepped on a rusty nail and then slipping and falling during the approach to the baptismal font. She later found another church and was baptized there. She went to a revival service long ago, and one of the preachers appeared to her to be glowing. The brilliance and sense of inspiration she noticed was inspiring, but others did not notice it, and the man left right after speaking. It led her to believe there are transcendent experiences of the Spirit.</p><p>Her most inspiring experience, however, was about 35 years earlier, when she was trapped in an unhappy, verbally abusive marriage. After her husband berated her, she felt overwhelmed with despair and like her burden was more than she could tolerate. She fell asleep, entertaining self-destructive thoughts. She drifted to a reverie seeing a long alleyway and saw herself walking, when an exuberant and joyful being, like a stick figure on a wet floor sign, was going in and out of her and uplifting her and making her feel joy. This continued, inspiring her with love and a sense that she should live and enjoy life. She woke up feeling rejuvenated. This experience has helped uplift and sustain her over the years, even when she felt downcast with residual PTSD and her seizure and arthritic problems.</p><p>24). A near-death experience provided comfort and faith for this life and the afterlife.</p><p>I met a combat veteran in his early seventies who was in the hospital for a couple of weeks receiving treatment after he had had a life-threatening neck injury from a fall. During the middle of his stay, he confided that he had been feeling challenged in his faith, wondering how God could let this happen to him when he had been so devoted to helping others. He wanted to have the use of his arms and legs and have mobility. He had developed a priority for spirituality after he had held comrades dying of combat wounds in two wars, and he had only begun to appreciate that he had not known what was going on in their heads. He had been a minister and was involved in Christian volunteer work, continued to be devout, and had helped bring people to the gospel of Jesus Christ.</p><p>He shared an experience when he had clinically died after a heart attack. He recalled a feeling while he had been unconscious of having been wrapped in what felt like blankets. He said that it was like being a baby surrounded by love and warmth. He said that all fear and negativity left him and that he felt great love and comfort. His cares eased away and he was then awakened by a surgeon who slapped him and he was told he had threatened to retaliate. His experience had resolved his fear of death. He said that he would like to be fully healed or ease into the next life, stating that he is not afraid to die, and he said that he would not want to live with his current limitations. His persistence led his to neurosurgical treatment that helped improve his function and strengthened his relationships with his neighbors and family.</p><p>25). A close call with death brings gratitude for life and a sense of purpose.</p><p>A man who had been admitted for very disorienting symptoms and shortness of breath said that he had been in and out of hospitals for a couple of months. He had some medication changes, and he had noticed positive developments with a weight loss regimen and reduction in his dose of antidepressants. He confided that he had been suicidal when he was growing up due to low self-esteem, and he developed addictive patterns that had affected him. He had turned his life around after a felony conviction and serving over ten years in prison. He had made positive changes that led to reduction of a longer sentence, and he had been a good citizen in the two decades since he was released. He said that he had been a workaholic, extending himself for others and being a provider, but still had felt some emptiness inside until an incident about eight years earlier. He had been involved in a very serious motor vehicle accident. He broke his arm and was upside down when he was cut out of the car by EMT personnel. He had felt like there was no reason for him to live, but in that moment, he decided that God had a purpose for him. He celebrated his joys of a happy family with children, saying that he enjoyed being a grandfather for his three grandchildren.</p><p>26). Spontaneous writing announces spiritual engagement with Catholicism during a health crisis.</p><p>A male patient in his late sixties with a professional career was raised in the Roman Catholic Church, but when he enlisted in the Navy at a young age, he lost all engagement with religion apart from attending weddings and funerals. He was unfamiliar with the Bible. After years of being an endurance athlete and helping with volunteer events to raise funds for The Leukemia and Lymphoma Society for several years, he had been diagnosed with an unusual form of leukemia. He was dismayed; he felt devastated and had a sense of betrayal from his diagnosis. He was anticipating being scheduled for a bone marrow transplant in a few weeks. He was very excited to describe a significant automatic writing experience occurring on a specific date in 2024, when he had written absent mindedly, on a Post-It note, “It starts today.” He bought a Bible not long afterward and had noticed a Catholic church near his home. He was very excited about his engagement there, his newly-revived membership and engagement with his tradition from childhood, and how his wife was interested in the changes in his outlook. He expressed humility and great humor to avoid taking himself too seriously, and not arguing with his wife anymore. He described acts of kindness and excitement about his new faith. He was reading the Bible daily, and was particularly inspired by the Book of Job.</p><p>February 2026</p><p>27). Spontaneous remission of addiction.</p><p>A patient who was in his early seventies had come to the hospital for abdominal and gastric pain when we met following a colonoscopy. He shared a triumphant narrative about being freed from a severe alcohol and drug problem over thirty years earlier. He was living in a city where he grew up and he had gotten into a habit of drinking heavy amounts of strong alcohol daily and using illegal drugs. He said that God removed the desire to engage in this behavior, which had become a very disabling addiction. He had entered a halfway house but he said that the problem simply dissipated. His wife had died a few years earlier and he was having feelings of grief. Overall, he said that his outlook was inspired by the uplifting experience of having had the burden lifted and seeing the light. He would encourage others and do motivational speaking as a way to express gratitude and a sense of purpose.</p><p>28). Spontaneous grace easing deep grief and trauma.</p><p>A male Vietnam veteran in his mid-seventies who had had heart problems and prostate cancer was admitted for dizziness and light-headedness. He explained that he had survived severe trauma in combat in Vietnam and he believed that Agent Orange exposure was the source of his prostate cancer. He was happily married and he reflected a peaceful and thoughtful outlook. He shared his faith, designated as “unknown, no preference,” which gave him assurance about the afterlife. He saw the afterlife as not being much different from this life. He was influenced by foundational classical philosophy and literature. He does not view this faith as courage but more like knowledge. He has an orientation that perceives the presence of the Divine as part of the physical world, a nondual or unitary presence that is not separate from the phenomenal world. After one of their sons died about seventeen years earlier, he endured three years of terrible grief that made it hard to cope. One morning about three years later, he was driving to work and spontaneously felt a great peace and lifting of the burden of grief. It reminded me of John Wesley’s experience in 1738, when he described “feeling my heart strangely warmed,” and the mystical coming to terms of Julian of Norwich. This experience had helped him feel peaceful amidst health and social challenges.</p><p>29). Spontaneous transformation and recovery one day at a manufacturing plant.</p><p>A male patient in his late seventies shared an experience that led him to a spontaneous shift of priorities and a lifestyle transformation. He was working at an industrial plant in a large southern city in the mid-seventies. He had become dissatisfied with his lifestyle, which involved sharing pornography with a co-worker. He described how he had mysteriously become motivated to surrender himself and live for God. He went to the factory rooftop and gave himself to God and overcame the ways of life that did not honor the Spirit. He did not understand the transformation fully, but he had noticed a difference when he went downstairs and one of his co-workers asked him how things were going, and he replied that he was “just saved.” He felt like he proclaimed something. Afterwards, he developed a jail ministry community in that city that he continues to participate in every other week. He also had grown a jail ministry in the rural county where he had moved after retiring. He felt that his ministry was ordained directly and he does not seek to conform to a particular denomination. He studies scripture and is Christian but he is happy to keep the ministry unreduced and feels that it is perfect. He feels confidence in this life and to face the next one.</p><p>30). A near-death, out of the body experience imparts confidence in the afterlife, as well as forgiveness and understanding.</p><p>An Army veteran in his mid-seventies was very welcoming of a chaplain visit. He shared his sources of inspiration that gave him faith in the afterlife. He had been receiving care for possible liver cancer and an accumulation of fluid that made it uncomfortable to breathe. Despite the fear of his condition and his grief from the past, he felt gratitude and healing from forgiveness. He said that he had an inspiring near death experience that gives him confidence and courage as well as the desire to improve and fulfill his purpose in his remaining time. He had been at this hospital years ago for a surgery when he found himself rising above his body in a spiritual body. He observed his physical body with tubes and surrounded by medical staff. He became aware that he was in the presence of spiritual higher power and received a message that invited him to remain in that realm. He was told, “I’ll take you with me if you’re ready.” He realized that he wanted to remain there and he had the desire to improve his way of life. He had already left behind personal habits involving alcohol, drugs, and sex that did not give him feelings of self-respect, but he still had “a few pieces of paper to pick up” in his life to place things in proper order. His experience led him to feel hopeful about the next life.</p><p>He was raised by his grandparents who were raised in slavery and emancipated. He had lived with many relatives, with no water, no electricity, and no indoor plumbing. He grew up with spiritual influence, but he said he had been in and out of jail for years. He had been mistreated by his grandfather and step grandfather, and overcame his resentment before they died, helping cook and support his step grandfather when he was ill. His grandfather had lost his savings when he was exploited by a lawyer who represented his brothers, who were being prosecuted for crimes they did not commit. When he found this out, he learned to forgive him for years of abusive behavior. He was a member of a church and had completed a twenty-year period of sobriety and has accumulated wisdom and patience. He said that he had a period of resentment after he worked hard to be a deacon and he was told that he was not qualified. His experiences had helped him honor himself and not get caught up in resentment.</p><p>31). A father’s poor example and a teacher’s dismissal of his potential led a veteran to determination and persistence.</p><p>A veteran in his early eighties was being treated for about a week to monitor his heart function when we met a couple of times. Although he had lost the manual dexterity he needed to engage in his pastime of woodworking that he had enjoyed up until a couple of years previously, he said that he had never been happier. He attributed his happiness to a restored relationship with his daughter and his financial freedom after divorces and mistreatment by others. He had endured severe trauma and had worked very hard to be a careful and caring father and a responsible citizen. He grew up in a log cabin that did not have running water. His father was a tenant farmer and an alcoholic who would have different farming jobs every year and would squander what little money he had and not support his family. He saw his father passed out and drunk in a barn and resolved never to be like him. He had also been humiliated by his fourth grade teacher, who dismissed his goal of being a pilot one day, saying that he never would amount to much and would always do menial work. He had not finished school.</p><p>The veteran had lost contact with his only daughter when his first wife had lied to her and claimed he had been killed in Vietnam. She had later found him and they developed a close relationship. She and her husband lived nearby him and he enjoyed a good relationship with his only granddaughter, who lived in another state. Although he had been disenchanted with a conservative religion he participated in through his grandparents, and had had severe trauma after serving in Vietnam and struggled with alcoholism, he became religious after an experience he shared with me. He said he was driving a truck in another state one day, and he decided to find a church which he attended on that road trip and had positive interactions with the pastor. He later encouraged his older sister to find a church with him. He supported a charity to help address hunger in rural counties. He farmed for many years and he has been industrious and a stable influence. He would drink occasionally, but not to excess. He attended Protestant churches with one of his sisters, became an elder, and moved around between mainline Protestant churches and a Mennonite community.</p><p>32). A tragedy and an encounter with an empathic stranger give inspiration for a spiritual transformation.</p><p>I met with a veteran in his late seventies who had been treated for heart problems for a few days and who was about to be discharged with a medication regimen. He was animated and expressed gratitude about outliving his doctors’ expectation after a major heart attack 25 years earlier. He was happy to share a narrative of resilience and he identified a specific date when he became a Christian in the mid-1970s. He was inspired by the synchronicity of events. He was on a payphone at a laundromat, speaking with his mother. His mother told him that three of his friends had killed another of his friends, a young man who was somewhat slow mentally, in the small town where he grew up. The veteran became furious and incredulous as he tried to process the information. A man who had heard his conversation approached the veteran afterward and asked him if he knew what it meant to be a Christian. During the discussion, he encouraged the veteran and asked if he would be willing to make the choice of discipleship. When he said he was reluctant at the time to do so, the man gave the veteran his phone number and offered to explore the subject further. The following day, something came over him and he called the man and suggested going to a film, Time to Run, produced in association with Billy Graham’s ministries. Events coalesced that were surprising. The man changed plans for that evening with his own wedding rehearsal, when his fiancé gave her blessings for him to attend the film with the veteran. The veteran went, and the film’s depiction of a young man’s poor choices about priorities seemed biographical for his own life. He said that his heart was changed. He persisted in his faith.</p><p>March 2026</p><p>33). Adversity, including near-death experience, motivates a man to overcome obstacles and live fully.</p><p>A Vietnam veteran in his mid-seventies was receiving treatment for myasthenia gravis and had survived a series of strokes, childhood poverty, and trauma in combat, yet he lived an open and engaged life and had proven resilient in regaining his abilities. He had a happy marriage lasting over fifty years. He had scaled down his life by parting with his beloved horses and other animals to live well and function within his capacity after he had collapsed and struggled to survive a few months earlier. He recounted harsh experiences, having to eat out of garbage cans because of poverty as a child in a large family with meager resources, suffering through bloody combat during the Tet Offensive, and serious health challenges. He had had to relearn to walk and function after one of his strokes fifteen years earlier, and he survived a surgery when he had heard a doctor say he would not make it during a stay at a local hospital. Although he suffered trauma, he had transformed the experience by making it a part of a narrative that was beautiful as a whole, which led to his flourishing and deeper development of his faith.</p><p>Having outlived expectations and overcome limitations and trauma, he appeared radiant as he shared from his experience and outlook. Rather than becoming bitter or feeling defeated and persecuted, the veteran had chosen to adopt a very engaged, authentic, and full life. He was determined to live out his days fully alive. He had formed a business, and he had become an accomplished horseman. He was active in his local Catholic church. He enjoyed engaging in flying when he was younger. He and his wife had raised many foster children. He encouraged the children to participate in their own faith traditions. He would bring horses to support veterans and disabled children. As he approached the final stage of his life, he remained enthusiastic and determined to make the most of it. He said that he had no regrets and that every step had been blessed. He also spoke of leaving thumbprints wherever he went to improve the wellbeing of others. He enjoyed sharing information to inspire and edify others, especially foster children.</p><p>34). Adversity and deprivation, followed by a religious experience during baptism, and unexpected good fortune and abundance, led a man to an outlook that gives his life’s glory to God.</p><p>A male veteran in his late seventies who identified with the Pentecostal tradition was glad to have chaplain visits during his stay. He was a widower who lived independently, and he seemed relaxed about having foot surgery for recurring diabetic problems. He enthusiastically affirmed his faith. He had grown up at a state facility in a state residential school for children in need. He said that he would escape and left for good at the age of sixteen. He was led to be baptized in the Pentecostal tradition and as he was emerging from the water, he was speaking in tongues. Years later, he continued in his faith, an optimistic outlook that finds God’s presence in several positive outcomes and traits in his life. He said a couple of times that “it’s all God!” He pointed to the word Bible as an acronym for “basic instructions before leaving Earth,” and said that he would use a copy he purchased with highlights and would skip around and read different passages.</p><p>He said that the Holy Spirit led him to acquire two houses, one he fixed up and one that was a gift from his mother, whom he met after over thirty years with no contact, and he had developed skills for fixing up buildings. When I followed up with him after a surgery to remove one or two toes from his right foot, he again reflected positivity and was eager to affirm his faith and express his reliance on God’s help. He professed that God is good, and he shared affirmations like his “busy person’s prayer,” and emphasized his outlook of gratitude and feeling held by God, which he contrasted to the neglect of his mother. He was effusive about praising God, and how God can get your attention when we are not mindful of God. He stressed how important it is to treat others well. He was looking forward to returning to the home he restored with God’s help.</p><p>35). A man has a near-death experience that gives him faith in having a purpose. He encounters synchronistic events and clairvoyant people.</p><p>A man in his early seventies who was a Vietnam veteran, cited a near-death experience as a source of his abiding faith. He also discussed encounters where people seemed to know him already, and he had social challenges. He maintained an optimistic outlook with a lot of suspicion about people being Satan worshippers. He had been in the hospital for four days for treatment of swelling in his legs, and he had atrial fibrillation. He had housing insecurity and did not know if he could return to a group housing facility. He said that he had had a close call in Vietnam in combat, and that afterward, in the U.S., he was in a motor vehicle accident when the driver fell asleep, and he was thrown out and was in a coma for several hours, had a period of paralysis, and while unconscious, entered a dark space and noticed a circle spinning and humming. In the coma, he kept giving thanks to God and Jesus Christ for his survival with gratitude, as he had prayed when he was a child. The more he prayed, the louder the sound became. He remained unconscious while his father, who was in the room, tested his arm and told him to hold it up. It would flop down until the third time, when he was enlivened and his system was awakened. Over the following months, he became able to see and walk again.</p><p>He later was told by someone he did not know that God had saved him to serve a purpose and that his life could be lost at any time he no longer is needed. He noticed animals like birds being drawn to him. He recounted several incidents when he met people who could foresee the future. He had a premonition about a pending disaster in the U.S. and Europe with loss of life, and felt he needed to convey this urgent message about. Some of his thought process sounds like magical thinking but he articulates a benign and compassionate approach, with love for animals and children and faith in God. He sees unity in the different branches and traditions. He feels that he has had scrutiny and testing by Satan.</p><p>36). After feeling like he had succumbed to a life of temptation and taken the wrong road, a man found that he could devote himself to God and feel delivered from temptation.</p><p>A veteran in his late seventies was getting treatment for infection and heart disease. He expressed a strong sense of faith and wished to give credit for his outlook to God. Was married and had grown children and was very happy about their presence in his life. He shared from his experience that has led to him overcoming distress from a dissolute lifestyle after the loss of his first wife in a motor vehicle accident many years ago. His grief led to a downward spiral, and he became uncomfortable with himself after he had fallen into lustful behavior and spent money on partying. He lost his prosperity and had become distressed. He is inspired by the parable of the prodigal son, and he feels that he has had help to recover from being “down and out.” He had built a business and had been doing well at the time and he felt like he lost his bearings, became self-satisfied, and led a Bohemian lifestyle. He recognized that he had needed to change and he prayed intently. He felt that he was blessed by relief from temptation. He had feelings and experiences that made him feel lost and then he prioritized his relationship with God. He was praying in gratitude to God and for direction. He felt that he was heard and within his awareness he received the message, “just tell everyone about it.” He said that he gives the glory to God for all his blessings and is aware that the devil seeks to distract him from his faith. He prays regularly, principally in gratitude for the blessings in his life. He is glad to share his affirmation of faith and believes that we all need to inspire one another, like people in a sinking boat who must work together as a team.</p><p>38). An experience of surrender led to engagement and resilience in life and the charismatic traditions and healing ministries.</p><p>A veteran in his mid-eighties, who had served in the Army intelligence service, had been here for a week with breathing difficulties and coughing that were slowly improving with treatment. He began to speak about his interesting and varied work experience, which involved teaching in high school, working in an industrial job, and studying history in his late forties and Greek to understand the Bible better. He was happily married and he and his wife of ten years would attend each other’s churches which were fairly traditional or Pentecostal. He had made sincere efforts to make two earlier marriages succeed and he described instances when he forgave people who wronged him, such as his second wife. He had times of inspiration, especially a religious experience in the early 1970s when he was in his early thirties. He had been overly confident, and he said he was brought low and had an opening to faith. He was led to charismatic practices and attended gatherings that drew people of different faith traditions. He spoke about receiving gifts of the Spirit and being drawn to mentors and having people brought to him. and he helped cast out dark spirits from them. He prays to understand God more, and to deepen his trust in God and Jesus Christ. He sees God as benevolent and loving. He looks forward to improvement and continuing to help other people. He had strong views and described having times of friction in some of his jobs because of ethical differences, and he said he had been uninvited from a couple of worship communities.</p><p>39). A veteran finds comfort in a quiet inward encounter with God on a Navy ship.</p><p>A man in his mid-sixties from the Lutheran tradition had been receiving treatment of fluid in his legs with open wounds related to heart and kidney disease for five days when we met. He had moved to a rural area of west Tennessee with his wife from the Pacific northwest about two years earlier. They had been living separately and were working out their relations. He described having had received some poor medical advice, friction with his wife and neighbors. He had a priority of personal autonomy. He had happy childhood experiences in youth groups and as an altar boy. He had an experience in the Navy when he was lonely, and he asked God to be in his life. It changed his life and he felt that his luck changed and a burden was lifted. He had a congenital issue that had been an affliction, but he had reframed his issue as a way in which God marked him as his own.</p><p>April</p><p>40). A woman who had a series of near-death experiences from episodes of having insufficient heartbeat found it to be very upsetting, but she did not feel a fear of death.</p><p>A woman in her early fifties, who is married with two young adult children, had been in the hospital for six days. She had been in great distress when she first came in but she had begun to feel more hope and peace. She would have days of sleeplessness followed by long periods of sleep. She was being considered for a heart transplant and said that she had been having a series of episodes of complete loss of consciousness and had been transported by life flight. She had had to receive shock treatments to revive her. She cited her children as sources of inspiration and purpose, and she was receiving support from her husband and extended family during this difficult time. She described the deep distress, worry, and concern about her unsustainable affliction, but she did not have a fear of death. She said that she would become completely unconscious and would not recall anything until she felt the relief when she would regain consciousness. She said it felt like coming back to life after it “could go either way.”</p><p>41). A man receiving news of a grave diagnosis relied on the blessing he had received, of a child brought to their care after a promise foreseen by a clergyman.</p><p>A veteran who was return patient in his late sixties was newly admitted and had contact precautions as he was getting treatment for pneumonia. He was quite thin and having difficulty eating. He became tearful and reflective as he was absorbing news of a possible diagnosis of metastatic bone cancer from the day before. He said he was always a kind person who intended to be positive. He mentioned a special blessing that he and his wife had received four or five years earlier at their church. The pastor and two visiting pastors were present, he said, and he felt that the Holy Spirit was present and people were experiencing holiness. After he and his wife had gone up to the altar and testified to their faith and returned to their pews, one of the visiting pastors came from a far corner and told his wife, “God has told me to let you know that a manchild is coming to your life and care.” He added that it was not going to be easy.</p><p>The veteran said that they did not doubt the news and that a few months later, a male infant came into their care who was a close relative of his wife’s whose parents were not able to care for him. He felt that they had been set forth to do what God had asked and that the news felt like the way that God commands angels to do God’s works. He accepted this responsibility, despite financial limitations and health challenges. He wanted to profess that he has been a good steward of the boy who was now five years old. He was concerned about his salvation, and I assured him that God loves him and appreciates his intentions, that his concerns were consistent with faith, and that his condition was not a sign of spiritual failing. He could appreciate his experience as consistent with faith and find beauty even in this difficult time.</p><p>42). A man surrenders and finds his burdens lifted and enjoys engagement in a Baptist church and his musical ministry.</p><p>A male veteran who was almost 80 years old met with me after a few days in the hospital. He had survived a major ordeal with passing impacted waste after he had been in distress for weeks with abdominal and cardiovascular problems and had not known what was causing his problems. He had had a heart procedure and consultations and was being considered for surgery for a gastric outlet obstruction. He was worn out and had had a nasal tube for feeding as he shared his experience passing a massive bowel movement the previous evening. He noticed immediate relief after enormous pain and felt some alarm, and his wife was there at the time. The ordeal has been quite exhausting, but he was animated and felt it had relieved his problem. He described a pleasant life in a rural county, a fruitful but demanding career in the insurance business, and an early retirement when he had expended energy and endurance to finish it well. Since his retirement, he had been very busy as a musical director in a Baptist church in his home county.</p><p>The veteran described a religious experience about 35 years earlier when he was in his early forties. He said that he was saved at a time when he was busy with work, but he felt that his drinking was interfering with his life and his smoking was an impediment to his health. He surrendered and he began to feel a great burden lifted from him. It impacted him in positive ways, and he felt like it was the best choice he could have made. He became active in his church. He told his friends that he would continue being their friends, but at the time, they drifted away from him. Later, two or three made similar decisions and became engaged in the church community. The experience had helped him through this recent ordeal and medical trauma that appeared to have ended well.</p><p>43). A man’s pathway to ministry is inspired by a vision in his thirties, which was confirmed by his marriage.</p><p>An African American veteran in his mid-seventies was admitted for fluid accumulation, apparent from insufficiency of his heart function, and he was responding well with Lasix. His wife was present and she excused herself, apparently to give him privacy and he discussed his life and the importance of meeting her. He had grown up in the Midwest Region of the country in a devout family. When he was 37, he had an inspiring vision when he was having a low point in his life that led to him relocating to another city to pursue a pastoral education and becoming a minister. Meeting his wife was a significant sign that he was on a pathway provided by the Spirit. He had pastored some mainline Protestant churches in Tennessee for meany years before retiring.</p><p>The veteran was active in church, and he was very knowledgeable about the Bible, but he felt disconnected and he felt unfulfilled. He said that he was doing things his own way, that he was despondent when his marriage ended, and he was relying on alcohol and drugs. He had had a mentor in the Midwestern city, whom he had known from earlier in his life, and at the low point in his life, he ran into his mentor which was inspiring him to deepen his connection with God. Later, while he was awake, he had a vision of the mentor on a riverbank with some steppingstones to approach, and he took this as a sign. His inspiring experience led to him to pursue ministry, to take the gospel to heart, and to feel his inspiration from Jesus Christ deep within himself. He developed patience and released resentment as he pursued his studies and ministry, and importantly, he met his wife, which had been his hope along with finding deeper meaning. He flourished at the college and was inspired by notable civil rights figures from the nonviolent social change gospel tradition, whom he met. He had retired when he was 60, and felt constrained by the church hierarchy, but he felt that there is more of his pathway yet to be revealed. He is interested in building bridges or lines of communication between Christianity and other faith traditions, and in increasing awareness within the fraternal organization that he was actively participating in.</p><p>May</p><p>44). A woman feeling frustration and isolation hears a voice that spurs inspiration to relocate to be with family.</p><p>A woman in her early eighties had been on the unit for a couple of days and was being discharged after medication modifications for swelling and diabetic kidney disease. She was recovering from cancer and numerous orthopedic injuries. She and her husband had recently moved to the area from a distant state where her son, daughter, and grandson had moved. She has a loving relationship with her husband, whom she married during her military service, and he and their son were coming to pick her up. They have different orientations and outlooks, and he was not as freely able to surrender her cares to God. She was frustrated with limitations and setbacks, walking with assistance, and being somewhat isolated from her children at a time when she heard an inner voice say to “get busy.” She clearly felt that she was urged to visit the Tennessee area and see her son and daughter and a grandchild who had moved here. Her son and daughter had both relocated here. After she visited a few months earlier, they decided to move here, and it has been a good move. The veteran said that even with many medical and life challenges she has an appreciation of being very blessed. She often affirms, “what will be will be.” Their children have been very devoted and helpful to their aging parents, their families were enjoying more frequent contact, and her son has been becoming more spiritual. She is humbled by her life trajectory and how “it all fell into place.”</p><p>45). A prayer in the air leads to identifying and reviving lost love.</p><p>A veteran in his late seventies had been admitted for care of his heart was in a room with his wife, who was resting an upholstered recliner. He sat up and said that he was spiritually focused and wanted to support our chaplain ministries. He was glad to share a narrative from his experience, which was inspiring to his faith, and had just enough time before the cardiologist arrived. He was a professional from Tennessee. When he was young and serving in the Navy, he met his wife in a distant state. She was a model and studying dance and she was impressed because he had asked her if she was a “believer” and she said she was. Her family liked him. They were engaged, and he bought her a ring, but they never proceeded to marriage when they were separated. He said the long-distance calls were expensive. She said that she did not want to move from her state because of its cultural richness. Years later, about fifteen years before his hospitalization, he had been lonely. As he was driving to work one day, he prayed or affirmed a wish for someone he could talk to. They were thinking independently about reconnecting around that time. When he found out that a woman was looking into his profile on a dating website, he went to great lengths to find the person, believing it was his lost love, but had not followed through. Since they rekindled their loving relationship after so many years, they have been very loving and devoted to one another and feel completed. He identifies as a Christian from the Baptist tradition, and he states that he and his wife have priorities focused on spirituality.</p><p>46). God’s voice and a national disaster led a veteran to develop new faith.</p><p>A male veteran in his early eighties was in the hospital receiving treatment for fluid accumulation that was easing the pressure and pain symptoms that led him here. He was feeling great relief after a time of serious concerns and distress. He said that it felt like a miraculous recovery. He grew up in church life, and he was baptized but he fell away from communal worship. He said that he was relying on his own resources but that after 9/11/01, he had a change of priorities, and he began focusing on spirituality. He quit smoking cigarettes and he quit drinking alcohol. He began listening to a gospel radio station and began visiting a Salvation Army Church near his home. He felt that God’s voice was directing him there. He felt some shame about his lifestyle and was self-conscious when he arrived for worship. He was greeted by a woman in a uniform and a bonnet and amused by her skepticism. She informed him that their pastor was ministering to victims of the Twin Towers explosions and their families and community. He felt humbled and heard an inner voice telling him to plant his backside in a seat there, inspired by the mission of service. He began volunteering to play music, guitar, and keyboards, in their services. He became close with the ministry leaders and congregants, and their mission inspired him to work in the adult rehabilitation facility that houses and employs people who are in recovery or impoverished for other reasons.</p><p>47). A veteran has a prayer and frees himself from the presence of an entity he accidentally invited into his being.</p><p>A man in his early forties had been admitted for medication issues related to multiple sclerosis, and an old ankle injury that affected his mobility. He was glad to affirm his faith. He had been working as a truck driver before his ankle injury took him off work around twenty years earlier and he and his wife had moved to a small town in a rural area. We discussed ideas about benevolent spirits and angels and being open to divine presence when the veteran explained that his curiosity led him to become interested in ghost hunting. He was interested in technology and found a device that helped identify the presence of ghosts.</p><p>One day, he said, he was getting information near a shopping area when a signal came to show a demon, which initiated contact. The veteran asked it about itself, and it gave him a name, Mark, which the veteran said was an assumed name to build confidence. The veteran asked it what he could do for it, and he felt something enter his side. It persisted as a presence. The veteran would notice a problem with a food mixer in his home coming off a table, and he realized that he had opened himself up to a dark entity that was taking space in his life. He was not fearful or deeply distressed, he said, but he was aware that it was not serving him. He found a great resource four years earlier, called the Deliverance Prayer. He showed it to me on the internet, and he said it helped rid him of the pesky entity. Since then, the veteran’s life has been peaceful, and his wife has developed a deep spirituality. They pray and read Bible passages together. He feels at peace and the gratitude from overcoming a preoccupation that had begun rather innocently. He feels at peace and he gladly accepted my offer to pray for him.</p><p>48). A vision portending the afterlife during a health crisis, and his father’s peaceful transition, inspires a veteran to “put things in perspective,” feel greater peace in his life, and have more confidence in the afterlife.</p><p>A large male veteran in his early seventies had been getting medical care for heart failure and fluid overload, and we visited twice during his stay. The veteran was a pleasant and stoic man who approached his condition in a frank and matter-of-fact manner. He regarded his condition as terminal, and he relied on supplemental oxygen. He expressed gratitude, saying that he had not expected to live past the age of sixty. The veteran spoke of having had a hard life. He discovered that his mother and grandmother had practiced in the dark arts when he was the executor of his mother’s estate. The veteran had done risky work repossessing cars in a dangerous area, and he said that he had ridden with outlaw motorcycle clubs. His life had improved. He remarried and had a happy marriage after a bitter divorce. He had re-established relations with his daughters after they were alienated from him by his ex-wife, and his daughters had done well in their careers.</p><p>The veteran had an engineering background and had been working as a power plant operator, but he sought work to serve a benevolent healthcare organization that served public health and helped children avoid polio. An injury had taken him out of work about 35 years earlier, and he had progressive worsening of his heart disease. He had some visionary experiences during treatment several years ago. He had required diuretics and he became dehydrated after eliminating 30 pounds of fluid and he was in and out of awareness and clearly saw a series of visions of a woman dressed in black all over, including a black hat and stockings, which he felt was a harbinger of death. He could hear his deceased relatives when he saw the apparition. He survived this fearful experience and developed a sense of confidence about death. He also was inspired by his father’s peaceful transition. He had been near death and told the veteran that he was seeing apparitions, and said, “they’re here for me.” He encouraged the veteran to go watch television, and almost immediately passed away peacefully. The veteran had non-traditional religious beliefs, and he preferred to keep them private, but he described them as his “own beliefs.” He felt motivated to be honest and to do what is right.</p><p>June</p><p>49). An anomalous event saves lives and enhances a veteran’s faith.</p><p>A veteran in his late seventies who was receiving treatment for longstanding heart disease shared an account of a miraculous life-saving intervention when I expressed interest in the presence of the Spirit and belief in angels. During a short visit while he had been in the hospital for four days for treatment of heart failure, he said he had survived many heart attacks and stent placements related to Agent Orange exposure in Vietnam. He is in good spirits and alert and he looks well. We discussed his wife’s dementia and their membership in a Pentecostal Church where he led Bible study class. He was waiting for his lunch and he took a phone call, but he took the opportunity to share his faith, perhaps because it was such a significant event and I appreciated how the Spirit is alive and asked him about angels.</p><p>He told me about his experience around 25 years earlier, when he lived in another state. He and a friend of his and two women driving to visit the friend’s son in prison on a rainy Saturday. A few miles from the prison, the road went from a four-lane road to a two-lane road. The veteran’s friend was driving and he went into the approaching lane to pass a pickup truck, apparently thinking there were four lanes. Two vehicles were quickly approaching, and the veteran was alarmed, expecting an immediate head-on collision. He exclaimed, Oh, Jesus!” and immediately the car’s electrical system went blank and everything stopped as the car was smoothly and gently lifted and placed on the grass on the side in a safe place. Cars whizzed by and they felt overwhelmed with the relief. They completed the visit to the prisoner and the veteran shared this experience with his pastor the following day at church, and he was glad that the pastor had believed him. He said that this enhanced his faith and inspired him to go through his medical challenges and deepened his faith. He appreciated my expression of belief and appreciation of his faith and he took a phone call and felt complete with our visit.</p><p>50). A series of near-death experiences relieves a veteran’s fear of death and increases his faith.</p><p>A veteran in his mid-seventies returned and we remembered each other from a patient visit a year earlier. He is in good spirits although he had shortness of breath from limited lung function. He was receiving follow-up care from a cardiac catheterization, he had stage IV cancer, and he did not expect to have much more than one year left to his life. We spoke after I had met and prayed with his roommate in the adjacent hospital bed, and I learned that both of them had had three near-death experiences that had enhanced their faith and lessened their fear of death. The veteran was glad to see me and he shared his faith from his youth. He was inspired by his mother, who was very devout and encouraged church attendance and Bible study. He said that he had had two prior experiences when he was not expected to survive his medical challenges. One time it occurred, his mother and sister were with him as his life support for breathing was withdrawn and they were told they could have time with him before he died. He said that they prayed and sang for him and he came back to life. His mother told him that she knew that he would come back because “it was not his time.” He said that his mother was very attuned to spiritual matters and he never doubted her confidence.</p><p>Around the time of a heart attack the previous year, he said that he was hovering over his own body as he was laughing and felt a lightness about the circumstances. He said that he came back because it simply was not his time. This was his third near-death experience, and it helped increase his faith and relieve his fear. He had strong faith and he said that he had not been worried about the afterlife. When we had met previously, he described how he had a life in the Lord and that he had had prayers answered. He would read from the Bible and he said that he enjoyed being helpful to others.</p><p>51). A second patient in the same room independently reported that he had had a series of near-death experiences that relieved his fear of death with his belief in the afterlife.</p><p>A man in his mid-seventies returned to the hospital and he was interacting with humor as he receiving nursing care when I arrived, warning me not to mention the words “hospice” or “palliative” to him (the “H” word or the “P” word) and I agreed to honor his request. He had heart failure, cirrhosis, and a pulmonary embolism. As we spoke, he shared from his experience that he had had three occasions when his heartbeat flatlined. The veteran said that he had looked down onto his body and had come back to life one time after being in a coma for six months. Another time, he had had to learn to walk and it took him three months, much less time than had been expected. He had survived being shot three times about thirty years earlier. He had less fear of death, he said. By coincidence, he was in the same room as a man roughly his age who had had three near-death events and had also experienced an increase of his faith. Their near-death experiences had helped both of them increase their faith and relieve their fear.</p><p>I was amazed that both of them had said that they had three experiences with near death and had been told “it is not your time,” and I confirmed this with them. The veterans said that people often do not believe them, and they know they were real; that the experiences were vivid, real, and important, no matter what other people think. I emphasized that I believe them and that I appreciated the inspiration of the experiences they shared. They were both receptive to receiving prayer as part of chaplain services.</p><p>52). Religious experiences inspire a veteran to give back by supporting a youth camp near their home.</p><p>I met with a combat-wounded veteran retired from military service over twenty-five years in his mid-seventies who was receiving treatment for shortness of breath and fluid overload. He said that he was feeling better after treatment and he was looking forward to returning to his home. He was inspired to give back from the abundance that he had been blessed with. He also described friends and people who influenced him favorably over the years, especially his wife. They have been generous in supporting the youth camp. He has devoted his energy to providing his labor and practical skills, and they have provided generous financial support to buy large items that enhance the experience of the youths who participate in the camp.</p><p>The veteran said that he has been inspired by experiences of the Spirit, first when he was “saved” as a young man in a small Baptist church. He was also inspired by a local youth camp he and his wife supported over many years. He described one time when he was alone on a hill near the youth camp when he felt the presence of God. He did not describe it in detail, but it sounded like a gentle feeling of God’s presence abiding with him. He felt gratitude for the financial resources they had from years of work and sacrifice. He and his wife had gardens and were growing tomatoes, green beans, and okra, and his wife has many plants and flowers on their patio. He said that nature, the plants and the flowers, their animals, and the wildlife around them was restorative and inspiring. They would feed deer and see many animals, including skunks, racoons, and a woodchuck.</p><p>53). An anomalous appearance of an unlikely “angel” deepens a couple’s faith.</p><p>A Vietnam veteran in his early eighties was hospitalized with shortness of breath complicated by diabetes. His records suggested that he had dehydration leading to weakness and fatigue that had led his wife to bring him to the emergency department the prior day. He was hoping that his studies would not show a grave problem and he said he hoped to be discharged soon. He had home healthcare assistance and he had support from his wife of 40 years and her children. He was retired from work in the public sector that was in the public interest.</p><p>His wife was present at his bedside and she said she was gratified when someone stopped her and offered to pray for her yesterday when she brought her husband to the emergency department. They spoke about how they felt spiritually supported, how they were devoted to one another, and had a life of faith. He was a Vietnam veteran who had traumatic memories, including combat and helicopters, viewing a friend’s body, and coping with large numbers of casualties. He had felt wrung out when he arrived home. When we spoke about faith, they shared an anomalous experience that led them to deeper appreciation of God’s presence and support. A few years ago, they were driving their camper and truck and it stopped and they were in a remote area with the hood up. A burly man with tattoos came there and they were apprehensive about his motives because of his appearance. They were grateful when he fastened a hose and he gave them his cellphone number, saying to call back if it happened again. Ten miles later, the problem recurred, and they called him and he came and fixed the problem again. He said, as he finished the repair, that he thought it would work that time, and added, “Don’t run faster than your angel can fly.” As they headed down the highway, they called the number again, intending to express their gratitude again, but there was a message that there was no such number. They would tell this story often to express their sense of the presence of the Spirit.</p><p>July</p><p>54). An intercession by a despondent veteran’s granddaughters persuaded him to persevere and reclaim his life despite significant health and mobility challenges.</p><p>A Vietnam veteran in his mid-seventies met with me a few times and we developed a rapport and he revealed that before coming to the hospital the prior week, he had lost his purpose and reason to live. He had been a medevac helicopter medic. He had lost a friend and had contacted his sister and visited her, and even named his son after him. He spoke about finding “tricks” as a combat medic to keep people alive with meager resources to keep people’s blood pressure stable by squeezing bags of plasma using various means. He had been a paramedic in a local emergency medical service for over thirty years and he had not realized how hard it was at the time. His medical condition from Agent Orange, diabetes, heart failure and stomach problems were very uncomfortable and he was dependent on a wheelchair. He had “been through hell” and that he had gotten to a point where he could not sleep or drive and had stopped eating.</p><p>He said he had decided not to accept care, refusing entreaties by his wife, and he did not want to live. He was planning to overdose stored up pills to take his own life. He had stopped eating and had spent weeks in bed. He had changed his mind and decided to live when his grandchildren prevailed upon him. It was a meeting with young children that led him to be open to persevering and something shifted and he came for treatment. He concluded that he was not finished with life. He affirmed his Catholic faith and he agreed that God loves him, and said that while he had felt abandoned by God but now felt supported by God. Despite his traumatic experiences in war, he said he would do his combat service all over again if he had the choice. He had a close group of Vietnam Veterans and he was going to receive psychiatric care.</p><p>55). A prior near-death experience and vision inspired a veteran to have faith when facing a serious health condition.</p><p>A veteran in his late sixties had been on our unit for four days after having been in intensive care for two days. We had two visits and he had mobility concerns and had lost strength that had not returned, possibly from heart problems. He said that two weeks before the incident happened, God’s presence let him know he was going to enter into a valley. His wife was present with him and they were quite worried after the episode. He and his wife had an active church life in a rural county. He was hoping for a resolution, and as he shared his faith, he and his wife spoke about a stroke he had over twenty years earlier that had very disabling and that the doctors said he would not ever recover the ability to walk.</p><p>He said he was in a coma and was in intensive care for two weeks, and spent eight weeks in the hospital. His wife was tearful as she shared that the staff at the outside hospital where he had stayed had essentially given up on him. The veteran said that while he was in a coma, he had had a vision of an angel that identified himself as God’s messenger Gabriel, who had brought assurance and told him that it was not his time. He said that Angel Gabriel assured him he would walk again and even though the doctors concluded he would not, over a period of months he had regained his walking ability with his wife’s help. He did not return to work, but he has been engaged in his life and family. He said that he felt that God has been watching over him and that God has been good to him. He and his wife showed great love to each other as they shared this narrative which inspired hope for recovery from his current health challenges. He said that the experience eased his fear of death and helped him feel inspired to recover. We spoke about their family and interests and I shared appreciation of his faith and courage and told them that I had heard testimonies from other patients who had had similar experiences.</p><p>Analysis and Conclusions</p><p>The Value of a Model of Wholeness, Promotion of Self-Acceptance, and Soul Connection for Spiritual Care Providers</p><p>These accumulated narratives reveal how patients may form a strong level of clarity about what guides them during health crises and other challenges, and how spiritual care providers can benefit them by helping them recall and share these sources of resilience. These accounts are examples of what people rely on for guidance and as resources for claiming wellbeing, quality of life, and to prevent them from falling into despair.</p><p>A series of dreams inspired one man to a greater sense of purpose and he developed a mission of ministry. A man whose near-death experience gave him faith and purpose found validation in encounters with synchronistic events and clairvoyant people. A message from the afterlife and a near-death experience inspired one man to have less fear of death and greater compassion. An idiosyncratic angelic presence and synchronous events inspired faith in a woman. Spontaneous writing led a man to be inspired to begin spiritual engagement with his Catholic tradition during a health crisis.</p><p>Protective parental instincts inspired one man’s healing from alcohol poisoning. A grandchild inspired a woman’s recovery from addiction. Another woman quit smoking to set a good example for her daughter after her own mother had set an example of inability to quit. A father’s poor example and a teacher’s dismissal of his potential led a veteran to determination and persistence. A veteran with end-stage liver disease found hope after turning his life around by focusing on devotion to serving others and feeling of wellbeing.</p><p>Several patients cited spontaneous experiences for life changing transformations of outlook and priorities. Patients have described spontaneous remission of addiction, spontaneous grace easing deep grief and trauma, and spontaneous transformation and recovery one day at a manufacturing plant. A veteran found comfort in a quiet inward encounter with God on a Navy ship. A spontaneous spiritual “download” led one man to new confidence and assurance that brought him a more thriving life. A man said he made a deliberate choice to become a new person to overcome post-traumatic stress disorder. One patient had a conversion experience in jail. Feeling the absence of suffering in proximity to death brought one veteran a sense of peace. A church service led to a man having a born-again repentance experience. A passage of scripture and reflection led one man to grace. A patient’s life turned around when he gave his cares over to God. An experience of surrender led to engagement and resilience in life and the charismatic traditions and healing ministries.</p><p>Narratives of patients show that when they have had to confront death, forms of existential despair, feelings of shame, and a sense of failure that come from trauma, there are opportunities to build and maintain an identity that can withstand times of pain, loss, and feelings of emptiness from grave diagnoses. Care recipients see various types of experiences that can challenge them to adopt outlooks that give perspectives that provide them with meaning, purpose, hope, and confidence, to motivate their healing. Patients who are open to share the inner resources that are implicit in their narratives can become inspired by their sources of strength and resilience.</p><p>This research is intended to help foster understand more about the forms of experience that bring patients meaning and purpose. The narratives help reveal that avoiding responsibility to confront hard truths in order to escape trauma and grief does not shield people from despair or bestow these resources. Like Gautama Buddha’s experience from being shielded from pain, decay, and death, when his parents tried to help him, the greater truth he discovered was that easing suffering entails confrontation, disenchantment, and cultivating empathy and compassion. Confrontation with the parts of life that create fear and tempt us to resist and try to escape from them, seem to help these patients ease despair and promote positive traits of flourishing and resilience. Such encounters of reckoning reveal sources of inspiration for faith, healing, and transformation, helping care recipients find their core values and principles of faith.</p><p>Retirement, major life changes, and a grave diagnosis, a heart attack for example, spur patients to adopt lifestyle changes that indicate flourishing. Adversity, including near-death experience, motivated a man to overcome obstacles and live fully. Adversity and deprivation, followed by a religious experience during baptism and unexpected good fortune and abundance, led a man to an outlook that gives his life’s glory to God. A tragedy and an encounter with an empathic stranger gave one man inspiration for a spiritual transformation. After feeling like he had succumbed to a life of temptation and taken the wrong road, a man found that he could devote himself to God and feel delivered from temptation.</p><p>Veterans who rely upon our services often come here in severe distress and are preoccupied or overwhelmed with a sense of loss, grief, or re-triggered responses to trauma. For veterans who feel lost and empty, rudderless, and adrift from familiar sources of reference and belonging, spiritual care providers can help restore their reference points of connectedness with reminders of what endures: their sources of inspiration and resilience, which may be more pronounced when they are admitted and receiving treatment. It is often an organic process, unfolding from within, as a base of their soul connection, their deepest core values, cultivated with prior encounters with the harsh realities of living in a materialistic, violent, and competitive society. Helping them identify their antidotes to estrangement and loss can promote healing and transformation for a renewed opportunity for engagement.</p><p>Some Reflections on Trauma-Informed Care</p><p>Spiritual care providers can represent the antidote to the tendency to be overwhelmed by the voices imposing narratives of what is wrong, a sense of dread and negativity. Stepping back for perspective and allowing an aggrieved or wounded person to see their resources and the friendly voices that are difficult to hear is part of the “big picture” with the good and the bad, that can be beautiful with a perspective of wholeness. The following poem by Jan Richardson describes how grief provides a liminal space with potential to reform and reframe sorrow and bring renewal, a process that spiritual care providers can cultivate in their care recipients:</p><p><strong>Blessing for the Place Between</strong></p><p>When you come<br> to the place between.</p><p>When you have left<br> what you held<br> most dear.</p><p>When you are traveling<br> toward the life<br> you know not.</p><p>When you arrive<br> at the hardest ground.</p><p>May it become<br> for you<br> a place to rest.</p><p>May it become<br> for you<br> a place to dream.</p><p>May the pain<br> that has pressed itself<br> into you<br> give way<br> to vision,<br> to knowing.</p><p>May the morning<br> make of it<br> an altar,<br> a path,<br> a place to begin<br> again.</p><p>— Jan Richardson<br> from The Cure for Sorrow: A Book of Blessings for Times of Grief.</p><p>Dr. Judith Herman is an American psychiatrist, researcher, teacher, and author who has focused on the understanding and treatment of incest and traumatic stress. Dr. Herman is a professor of Psychiatry at Harvard Medical School, and director of training at the Victims of Violence Program in the Department of Psychiatry at the Cambridge Health Alliance in Cambridge, Massachusetts. She is best known for the 1992 book, Trauma and Recovery: The Aftermath of Violence — From Domestic Abuse to Political Terror. The book has been republished with an afterword and an epilogue. (Basic Book 2022). Dr. Herman was the first professional to propose the diagnosis of complex posttraumatic stress disorder, or PTSD.</p><p>Her landmark book traces the forgotten history of the effects of reactions to severe trauma and repetitive trauma on consciousness and behavior, and discusses possible treatment options. In the late 1800s, trauma was identified as a source of emotional and behavioral instability and dissociative states. Because its treatment led to conclusions that large numbers of girls in polite society of Vienna and Paris were abused by family members and other adults, social pressure led to discrediting the diagnosis, termed hysteria, as originating in unfounded fantasy. Sigmund Freud actively participated in characterizing the condition as originating in fantasy because of the pressure to avoid stigmatizing well-respected men with social standing.</p><p>Dr. Freud found, through psychoanalysis, that there was an epidemic of trauma from widespread sexual abuse of girls in France and Austria in the late 1800s, but later discredited his own publications out of ambition and political pressure. Judith Herman wrote about one of the victims, Bertha Pappenheim, who became the last person of influence speaking about the etiology or basis of trauma, termed hysteria, as being the result of actual abuse.</p><p>Later, the condition of posttraumatic stress disorder would be recognized officially in 1980 in the aftermath of the Vietnam War. Recent pioneers like Bessel van der Kolk, M.D., and Gabor Mate, M.D., and many others recognized sources of the condition as arising from exposure to very upsetting events and situations such as physical, emotional, or sexual, childhood abuse or neglect, and violence in military conflict and criminal acts. One type of trauma results from moral injury when one is forced into actions that are contrary to one’s core values, or acts of betrayal by trusted people.</p><p>During World War II, psychiatrists J.W. Appel and G.W. Beebe conducted treatment and research for the U.S. military, and found that spending from 200 to 240 days in combat would cause virtually any soldier to suffer lasting harm from trauma. Sometimes, traumatic experience results in the body surviving by entering a dissociative state with a repressed memory.</p><p>The soldiers serving in such conditions would form powerful attachments to one another for their survival and they would suffer if their treatment would lead to prolonged separation. (Herman, J. p. 35). Psychiatrists, such as Dr. Abram Kerdiner, Dr. Roy Grinker, and Dr. Herbert Spiegel, explored methods to help treat “shell shock,” as wartime trauma was called. “They found that artificially induced altered states [of consciousness] could be used to gain access to traumatic memories.” (<em>Id</em>. at 36). To help the men return to the battlefield by processing their terror, fatigue, and stress, Dr. Kardiner and Dr. Spiegel used hypnosis. Dr. Grinker and Dr. Spiegel employed sodium amytal to induce an altered state of consciousness that would allow them to “unburden” their traumatic memories in therapy. (<em>Id</em>. at 36–37). Some of the soldiers were returned to the battlefield, while others would follow up with therapists to help them integrate the memories into awareness.</p><p>Dr. Herman writes that the study of lasting effects of trauma was not resumed until after the Vietnam War, at the insistence of returning veterans. The soldiers returning from Vietnam formed rap groups of peer support. They faced an unwelcoming public that was opposed to the war and suspicious of behaviors during warfare, while many were burdened with unprocessed grief, overwhelming trauma, and repressed memories. In 1980, the American Psychiatric Association recognized posttraumatic stress disorder, encompassing the symptoms of traumatic neurosis previously described by Dr. Kardiner forty years earlier. (<em>Id</em>. at 39–40).</p><p>In the 2022 epilogue in Dr. Herman’s most recent edition, she discussed more recent research by Dr. van der Kolk and others. A neurofeedback technique pioneered by Sebern Fisher, a psychotherapist studying attachment and development of personality in childhood, and author of Neurofeedback in the Treatment of Development Trauma: Calming the Fear-Driven Brain, was very successful. Ms. Fisher found that when she was addressing a child who had not bonded with a parent, she would be “talking to the amygdala,” the portion of the brain that engages in fight-or-flight and shuts down awareness. (<em>Id</em>. at 394–95). This technique was successful in studies led by the Trauma Research Foundation and Dr van der Kolk, published in 2016.</p><p>Dr. Herman’s 2022 epilogue also discussed successful clinical studies with MDMA in research funded by the Multidisciplinary Association for Psychedelic Studies (MAPS), led by Michael Mithoefer and other clinicians. (<em>Id</em>. at 397). One study concluded in 2018 had helped 90 men and women with complex posttraumatic stress disorder. The subjects had had multiple childhood and later traumatic experiences and had developed symptoms of depression, dissociation, and/or substance abuse and posttraumatic stress disorder. (<em>Id</em>. at 396–97). Results showed that MDMA, when combined with therapy, showed major improvements in their symptoms. (<em>Id</em>. at 397) (citing M. Mithoefer, “The Evolving Science of the Use of Psychedelic Substances in the Treatment of PTSD” from a 2021 workshop at a conference of the Trauma Research Foundation). Therapists are present during the psychedelic (or empathogenic) experience for reassurance and encouragement, and for preparation and integration sessions to facilitate processing. (<em>Id</em>.) (citing J.M. Mitchell, M. Bogenschutz, A. Lilienstein, <em>et al</em>, “MDMA-Assisted Psychotherapy for Severe PTSD: A Randomized, Double-Blind, Placebo-Controlled Phase 3 Study, in Nature Magazine 27 (2021) at 1025–33). It is an “inner-directed” therapy that encourages the subjects to “go inside” with a “beginner’s mind,” and is especially beneficial with repressed memories.</p><p>Spiritual Orientation Informing Theological Model of Care</p><p>The beauty of Christianity for spiritual care providers is its emphasis on healing. We hold our wounds, our sin, or failings and disappointments to Jesus Christ, who kisses them and while they do not disappear, they diminish. I had studied Christianity at the Catholic Institute in Paris under Pere Grelot, a priest who taught Introduction to the New Testament in French. I was a religion major at Tufts University and was fascinated by mysticism and I became a Christian in 1995 when I joined my church, Second Presbyterian Church in Nashville. Meeting Jesus Again for the First Time, the 1995 book by Marcus Borg and The Authentic Gospel of Jesus, a 2009 book by Geza Vermes were very valuable sources of my model of care.</p><p>William James, the psychologist of religion influential in the early 1900s, in his published lectures, The Varieties of Religious Experience, emphasized the great diversity of ways in which people have spiritual experiences that guide their outlooks. The accounts of these patients seem to reinforce the importance of an approach that does not impose judgment or rigid expectations in the approach of spiritual care providers to spirituality. By witnessing of the ways people encounter spiritual values with appreciation, we can serve our patients in an authentic way that does not intrude on the appropriate freedom from condemnation. (See John 3:18).</p><p>Brother David Steindl-Rast, a 100-year-old Benedictine Monk and co-author of Belonging to the Universe, speaks of the importance of belonging, saying that it is the basis of spirituality. He writes that when people use the term “God,” that God is the one they feel they belong to. He adds that with this sense of belonging, there is also a sense of longing and that this is a tension in our spiritual journey of life. He writes that “we long for that to which we most deeply belong.” Our sense of belonging, he suggests, calls us to respect the earth and other creatures, and to act in accordance with these beliefs, including by religious ritual and worship. He states that with gratitude, we become less fearful and cultivate happiness and a sense of abundance with respect for others.</p><p>In The Myth of Normal: Trauma, Illness, and Healing in a Toxic Culture, Gabor Maté, M.D., and his son Daniel chronicle numerous medical sources that show various forms of systemic disease can be traced to societal influences that breed competition, captious fault-finding, and forms of cultural alienation and materialism. The authors emphasize how harmful self-concepts and mental rumination, like the shame I identified in my tentative approaches to spiritual care, can make people sick from stress that sometimes becomes physical symptomatology as the body seeks greater regulation.</p><p>Dr. Maté is an author and retired psychiatrist who specializes in addiction recovery and trauma-informed care. He learned about how people like ourselves adopt a mistaken identity by over-relying on what begins as “healthy remorse.” On page 432, they write that healthy remorse is like the voice of the Spirit, “Nature’s way of bringing us back to our interconnected nature.” The authors write that these inner voices that come to keep our motives in check first come along to save us and heal us through a realignment, but that what matters is that we, rather than they, “are not in the lead.” (<em>Id</em>. at 432).</p><p>As I completed reading The Myth of Normal, I was left with an interest in invoking the Spirit and bringing forth the sacred by helping ease narratives of condemnation. I gravitated toward concepts from Internal Family Systems Therapies, advanced by Richard Schwartz, Ph.D., and the insights of Bessel van der Kolk, M.D. As a man with experience with family members and job experience working with people with mental illness, and coping with my own experience with panic reactions and fainting episodes, I found Internal Family Systems Therapies to be very helpful resources. These references helped me understand how posttraumatic stress disorder arises from exposure to upsetting events like physical, emotional, or sexual, childhood abuse or neglect, and violence in military conflict and criminal acts, and anxiety and stress from fear of social dominance, are unhealthy and part of a spiritual distress that will benefit from healing.</p><p>Self-compassion is the principal advice in The Myth of Normal, and the authors urge freeing oneself from automatic programming. (See, pp. 393–94, 431–32). They suggest helping ease the voices of self-criticism that start out as helpful guides, finding antidotes to them, or reframing them with gratitude and perspective. They urge a shift from wondering, “How do I get rid of this?” to “What is this for? Why is this here? They continue, “In other words, we endeavor to get to know these irksome aspects of ourselves and then, as best we can, to turn them from foes to friends.” (<em>Id</em>. at 431). Before unhealthy patterns of negativity and shame manifest in mental or physical illness, paying careful attention can help people realign their priorities and proceed toward wholeness. Dr. Maté provides an illustration, whiting, “Somewhat playfully, I call these apparent foes ‘stupid friends’ …these parts cannot learn new tricks. They refuse to get the memo that the circumstances under which they first came along no longer exist, and we are no longer children in peril.” (<em>Id</em>. at 431–32).</p><p>My work during my residency and as a chaplain led me to embrace Universalism. Rev. Hosea Ballou was the first president of Tufts College, where I majored in religion. In his work, An Examination of the Doctrine of Future Retribution, On the Principles of Morals, Analogy and the Scriptures, (Boston Trumpet Office. p. 36. (1834)) described one of its tenets:</p><p>It is well known, and will be acknowledged by every candid person, that the human heart is capable of becoming soft, or hard; kind, or unkind; merciful or unmerciful, by education and habit. On this principle we contend, that the infernal torments, which false religion has placed in the future world, and which ministers have, with an overflowing zeal, so constantly held up to the people, and urged with all their learning and eloquence, have tended so to harden the hearts of the professors of this religion, that they have exercised, toward their fellow creatures, a spirit of enmity, which but too well corresponds with the relentless cruelty of their doctrine, and the wrath which they have imagined to exist in our heavenly Father. By having such an example constantly before their eyes, they have become so transformed into its image, that, whenever they have had the power, they have actually executed a vengeance on men and women, which evinced that the cruelty of their doctrine had overcome the native kindness and compassion of the human heart.</p><p>The acceptance of mystery is a strong indicator of faith. This makes openness a valuable attribute for chaplains in healthcare settings. Michael Pollan’s 2026 book, A World Appears, discusses scientific disagreement about life and “the hard problem of consciousness,” which is the absence of an explanation for life and awareness. After numerous interviews and research on the subject, he concludes that there is great value in “not-knowing,” openness to the spiritual nature of all life, and appreciation that life is a mystery. Part of the discussion in his book includes phenomenology, the study of authentic life experience, which recognizes subjective experience as part of nature, and a discussion of Edmund Husserl and the significance of one’s life world or <em>lebenswelt</em>. (<em>Id</em>. at large print edition, p. 172). He describes considerable frustration and disillusionment among materialist scientists and philosophers attempting to come up with an explanation for the mystery and identifies the tendency to find stagnation and futility in closed systems that impose stiff or wooden explanations in reductionist terms.</p><p>Mr. Pollan notes that being in an “explore mode” can help evoke the numinous nature of childhood by “softening the sense of self.” His reflections on the encounters with the creative and imaginative sources in his book helped him learn to appreciate the capacity of spontaneous, nondirective thought to help reveal greater meaning to life and appreciation of lived experience. (<em>Id</em>. at 217).</p><p>One of the sources Mr. Pollan discussed in his book, Dr. Allison Gopnik, a neuroscientist at Berkeley and author of the 2009 book, The Philosophical Baby, describes how children and infants look at the world with “lantern vision” viewing a field as a whole with many attributes, as opposed to “spotlight vision,” with a utilitarian or goal-directed focus, which is more common in adults. Dr. Gopnik studied how childhood emphasizes the relational and exploratory phenomenal state which makes people more open and plastic in the sense of adaptability to change. (<em>Id</em>. at 257). One theory Mr. Pollan advances is that serotonin, a neurotransmitter, or hormone associated with openness, may offer adaptability. I suspect that in moments of distress, this openness can offer our patients “critical periods” of learning and meaning making, which these narratives reveal: an openness to inspiration and anomalous experience that brings a sense of meaning, purpose, and love. Perhaps this is why Jesus urged the faithful to look at the world as a child would, with wonder, curiosity, and awe.</p><p>In the poem The Guest House, Jalāl al-Dīn Rūmī, the thirteenth century Persian Sufi mystic writes, in the interpretation of Coleman Barks:</p><p>This being human is a guest house. Every morning a new arrival. A joy, a depression, a meanness, some momentary awareness comes as an unexpected visitor. Welcome and entertain them all! Even if they’re a crowd of sorrows, who violently sweep your house empty of its furniture, still, treat each guest honorably. He may be clearing you out for some new delight. The dark thought, the shame, the malice, meet them at the door laughing, and invite them in. Be grateful for whoever comes, because each has been sent as a guide from beyond.</p><p>Prior to my fellowship, I had read the books Life After Life: The Investigation of a Phenomenon — Survival of Bodily Death by Raymond Moody, (Harper &amp; Row 1975), not long after it was published, the 1971 book Journeys Out of the Body by Robert Monroe, and The Ultimate Journey, Consciousness and the Mystery of Death, by Dr. Stanislav Grof, published in 2006 by the Multidisciplinary Association for Psychedelic Studies. These discussions about transpersonal psychology and soul awareness correspond with Paul’s description of the spiritual body or <em>soma pneumatikon</em>, in 1 Corinthians 15:44 and the principle that consciousness can exist apart from the brain. Survivors of near death experiences often have lucid recollections of events when their bodies show no signs of awareness, or rapid sequences of visions of their life as they fall or face death from a sudden crisis. Survivors often report portals to another realm and contact with benevolent souls or spiritual and angelic presences. These experiences have helped survivors of such experiences feel new love for life and appreciation of the soul’s prospect for an afterlife.</p><p>Veterans attribute near-death experience with the inspiration to provide them comfort and faith for this life and the afterlife. Patients identify near-death or out-of-body experiences as resources to impart confidence in the afterlife, the present life, and appreciating each breath and moment. Confidence in this life and the next brings meaning and inspires people to greater gratitude, forgiveness, and peaceful understanding. A near-death experience inspired one man to quit smoking cigarettes and another man to have hope and a new sense of purpose. A close call with death brought one patient gratitude for his life and a sense of purpose. A near-death experience and lessons from spiritualism inspired a patient with the courage and optimism to accept more easily the news of recurring lung cancer. A near-death experience in a dream led one man to identify an important relationship that gives meaning and purpose.</p><p>Reflections on Appropriate Pastoral Models of Care</p><p>Experiences that these patients identify as critical periods that afford life changes in their outlooks and spiritual orientations are very personal to them and form a core of insight and inspiration. For many patients who have such transformative experiences, they become treasures that lead to new commitments and become part of their identities. Developing familiarity with patients through openness, appreciation, and curiosity in care encounters tends to promote trust, which can help people feel seen and stay involved with life. By engaging with the patients in a respectful, positive, and affirming way, these patients felt confident enough to share their narratives of resilience, meaning, and purpose, entrusting me with something personal and valuable at a time of vulnerability in a hospital. An authentic appreciation of the life of the Spirit is consistent with the Veterans Affairs chaplaincy approach of offering respect for the orienting systems of individual patients and approaching patients with cultural humility.</p><p>During my residency, I had had to confront a dynamic in which I had made a patient feel like an object and this helped me learn to be more relational and engaging. I have worked to recall and record details about the patients I meet to help bring familiarity and build relations in later visits. I strive to be a companion in difficult times and a loving presence. This has helped me focus on compassion-centered, trauma-informed care and my appreciation on authenticity and companionship. The patient narratives listed above are the gifts, the fruit borne from this approach, this practice of being an empathic presence present to affirm their narratives of healing in relationship with God and community.</p><p>This project results from my appreciation of how veterans can draw inspiration out of adversity and reframe their experiences. Some of the narratives may appear odd and unconventional and not consistent with conventional theologies. The variety of experience that patients find to be faith-building and transformative of outlook and identity reinforces the value of spiritual care providers who can address diverse populations. As chaplains serving a diverse population from many backgrounds, we need to respect unique experiences and traditions. We must also be able to provide care to the majority Christian population who wish to express their faith. As time passes and demographics continue to change, our population is likely to increase in its proportion of nontraditional spirituality, and it will be important to address spiritual care needs in a flexible and adaptable way.</p><p>Veterans in medical care can have better outcomes with favorable and affirming spiritual care, which can help them appreciate the gifts and capabilities they have cultivated. Fear of pain, disease, grief, and existential despair can cause people to develop entrenched patterns of resistance. These patterns can be effective survival strategies to resist trauma, terror, and despair, but avoidance and resistance can be inhibitory of wholeness and flourishing. An authentic sense of deep meaning seems to require confronting pain and suffering. It is a hard task to face the reckoning that is accomplish this type of outlook. Sometimes, it appears spontaneously by grace.</p><p>In his book, The Empathic God, Dr. Frank Woggon writes that salvation appears in the compassionate engagement with harmed and shamed persons and communities. Applying a wholeness model of redemption, he writes that cultivating a state of belonging, offering community in life-affirming ways, and being present with patients in their uncomfortable and vulnerable places is important for healing. Dr. Woggon states that relational wholeness in individuals and communities is the essence of salvation. (2–3). He portrays the calling of spiritual care workers to be building “relational wholeness.” (251). By becoming a trusted companion, and providing a sense of belonging and self-acceptance, the spiritual care worker can help another person overcome alienation. He states that faith can offer flourishing in important ways and he finds the capacity for salvation in healing and community.</p><p>Citing Rita N. Brock, Dr. Woggon views sin as the experience and consequence of being damaged, a brokenness to be healed. (67). Dr. Woggon writes that shame is integral to our culture and that it can be eliminated only by integrating into wholeness with the benefit of empathic connections and understanding. He suggests a process to recognize shame and face it and understand it empathically. (199). Empathy has potential to overcome the alienating effect of shame, he observes, and stimulate positive regard and self-exploration. (212). He advocates for a type of spiritual care that listens to the brokenhearted and offers restorative love and empathy to welcome and restore through relationships that provide grace. Compassionate spiritual care providers represent God’s solidarity amid suffering.</p><p>Dr. Woggon sees acts of solidarity and support as opportunities to liberate people from traumatic memories that can instill shame. (105). “Attempts to mitigate the effects of trauma by developing a persona to mask the shame only intensify the alienation between self and others.” (87). He urges spiritual care providers to provide resources that support flourishing through empathic engagement. Dr. Woggon draws from patient narratives and other stories showing conflict and alienation, and their resolution, with illustrations of the conflict between one’s will to be known in one’s full humanity and the fear of rejection. One practical act of solidarity and support he suggests is using curiosity to welcome and encourage a liberating confrontation with one’s trauma so a care recipient can reframe and transform one’s outlook from shame to reconciliation and liberation. (105).</p><p>Dr. Woggon writes, “Jesus’s work for liberation from shame, his healing work, and his activism to establish just relationships must be considered central aspects of his atoning life. (235). He argues that what Jesus brought to the world is an empathic response to intrinsic shame and estrangement. Jesus was concerned with overcoming divisions in relations and providing a sense of belonging and self-acceptance. This is borne out in the role Jesus plays as a mediator to God who uplifts the ordinary people and village life as models for the reign of God in his parables. (235). In Luke 6:36, Jesus directs the faithful everywhere to show compassion to others, saying “Be merciful, just as your Father is merciful.” Luke’s parable about the return of the prodigal son, (Luke 15:11–32) also emphasizes the compassion of God.</p><p>Spiritual care, he states, offers an opportunity to be drawn into the details that bring relationship. (262). Like an artist, the chaplain is invited to bring attention to the care recipients’ stories, remembering their myths, rituals, activities, problems, and experiences. He discusses a broad definition of spirituality that was developed by an interdisciplinary group of palliative care providers, in a 2014 article in The Journal of Palliative Medicine. Spirituality is “the aspect of humanity that refers to the way individuals seek and express meaning and purpose and the way they experience their connectedness to the moment, to self, to others, to nature, and to the significant or sacred.” (247). He identifies meaning-making as a principal tool for spiritual care; to bring connection that facilitates an awareness of one’s imperfection, “a hopeful response to life as it is.” (248).</p><p>Having served as a chaplain for the Department of Veterans Affairs for almost two years, I have noticed that relational and restorative love are healing. I seek to remind people of what endures in their lives after loss and the activities and relations that are their sources of inspiration. Many patient encounters lead to important discussions about faith and the ways in which God is appreciated as non-dominant and non-controlling. These narratives serve to illustrate the benefit of spiritual care providers who strive to be engaged companions who appreciate, respect, and affirm the care recipient’s spiritual and social resources.</p><p>The theological model that Dr. Woggon emphasizes is very useful for the experience of being a companion that does not reinforce narratives of alienation, restriction, and condemnation that isolate people and create alienation. I believe that sin is hurting other people from malice, greed, or ill will, and that it creates alienation and impairs the healing we seek to promote. Faith brings the courage and strength to intend goodness for others, to feel gratitude and forgiveness, and to share from an appreciation of abundance.</p><p>The patients describe a type of surrender, a giving over to God, respecting and appreciating the benevolence of a caring power. It seems to resemble the loving kindness that holds everything together, reminiscent of Julian of Norwich. She came to terms with the presence of sin in the world by relying on principles of love and gratitude. She was known for her writing, “All shall be well and all shall be well and all manner of thing shall be well. For there is a force of love moving through the universe that holds us fast and will never let us go.”</p><p>My work has led to appreciation of openness and curiosity, including making room for nontraditional spirituality. Experiences that these patients identify are very personal and become treasures that lead to new commitments. It seems important for chaplains to join patients and celebrate the ways their inner spirits come alive. The Apostle Paul emphasized that there are varieties of gifts and varieties of service. He also wrote that the Lord is the Spirit, and where the spirit of the Lord is, there is freedom. This illustrates how there is a living God active in the ways patients have found healing, ways like repentance, surrender, or resolution.</p><p>The theological foundations that I identified from the encounters and the ways I feel most authentic for spiritual care are to bring an empathic presence as a companion in a challenging time. I hope to remind the patients what they have relied on for comfort and transformation endures after loss and trauma so they will find their own resources to cope with loss, adapt to change, and even find ways to flourish by confronting and accepting their uncomfortable feelings. Being present in the moment in times of difficulty, and resisting the impulse to avoid and escape reveals difficult feelings, reveals authentic hope. I remind people that God loves them, to be a present witness of all of their feelings, and be a reminder that people are not alone by honoring their unique experiences and resisting the impulse to provide my own answers. I can acknowledge and celebrate each patient’s strengths, their curiosity to approach their lives as an adventure.</p><p>The good news I want to share is the gospel of freedom from condemnation, which reveals that we all are beloved children of God, and that we do not have to earn the worthiness to experience God’s love. When people can understand afflictions and health crises as part of human experience, along with the presence of loving awareness, and that struggle and suffering are inherent to embodied existence, they can avoid feeling the burden of feeling judged that leads to estrangement and alienation. The gospel of the good news is a burden and a blessing, being anointed with power and authority, and being propelled to the depths. With love, we can accept our vulnerability and our sensitive uncomfortable emotions, including our grief and other unlived parts of our experience, as part of a big picture of color, light and shadow, making up the entire “human document.” Accepting our humanity, suffering, and vulnerability as part of something wondrous and difficult but beautiful can save quality of life by bringing wholeness.</p><p>Ralph Waldo Emerson wrote that God enters by a private door to every individual. As a chaplain in a diverse environment, respect for a care recipient’s orienting system is our mission. The first amendment assures patients that our service will not take steps to establish a particular religion and that we will respect the patients’ freedom of religion. As part of this responsibility, spiritual care providers approach individuals with cultural humility and resist the temptation to direct patients spiritually. Implicit in this mission is the recognition that the patient is a living document, as Anton Boison observed, and that the patient has the resources from life experience and inner wisdom to develop toward wholeness and healing. These principles free the chaplain to appreciate and encourage the care recipient’s inner power to adapt to changes in a way that enhances the care recipient’s quality of life despite setbacks in health and social circumstances, even near the conclusion of one’s lifetime.</p><p>Conclusion</p><p>The narratives that result from this research project suggest that out-of-the-ordinary, or anomalous experiences that impart meaning are very important. Our patients often have thought of themselves as very capable and influential, and able to effect changes and be protective of themselves and others. Life can present these types of experiences, and break through humanity’s resistance to confronting our unlived aspects of self, our entrenched patterns of evasiveness, to confront hard truths about life to inspire greater aliveness. Sometimes these layers of resistance ease away fairly easily after inner work. Other times the reckoning can be more painful. Pain, disease, grief, and other traumatic experiences lead people to create strategies for survival to prevent terror and despair. Sometimes, it is natural to move toward avoidance and denial, but these narratives reveal how a reckoning with hard truths can build resilience. Patients will describe how confronting and recognizing their sources of fear and accepting a hard truth can inspire and reinforce love and aliveness. When care recipients feel loss they often express gratitude for the experiences that brought “aliveness,” flourishing, and thriving after confrontation with difficult truths, while lamenting their loss of the ability to participate more in life. I offered encouragement and appreciation, as well as understanding, and help them affirm faith and reframe their struggles into a whole picture, with both light and shadow, to find beauty in the unique details of their experiences.</p><p>Experience can be a “brutal teacher,” as one of my patients said, but part of the gift of life is a blessing that many sources of joy are provided by the Creator to overcome the temptation to withdraw and live lives of insulated resignation. Acceptance of the full range of experience and the challenges of life is a responsibility, but it is also a gift to oneself, and allows people who bear witness to all of life to claim a deeper soul connection. It also helps people find the ways in which Spirit is alive.</p><p>These narratives reveal to me an organic process from our Source that leads the human spirit to triumph in brokenness and recognize its potential. This has felt familiar, like Hans Christian Anderson’s story of the ugly duckling who recognizes its intrinsic beauty after a time of trial and humiliation. These accounts show what Rabindranath Tagore named when he said, in Gitanjali 69 “my pride is from the life-throb of ages dancing in my blood this moment.” I hear the baritone voice of Peter Tosh when he sang, “and I try, I really try, try, but I’ve got to pick myself up and dust myself off and start all over again,” an inner voice like Bob Dylan’s find Chimes of Freedom “Tolling for the aching ones whose wounds cannot be nursed” and tolling for “each an’ ev’ry underdog soldier in the night An’ we gazed upon the chimes of freedom flashing.” I also hear Bob Marley’s urging, “Won’t you help to sing these songs of freedom, cause all I ever have [are] redemption songs.”</p><p>Providing greater understanding about the subjective experiences that accompany dramatic healing experiences and personal transformation can inform awareness of the critical role of care recipients’ engagement in their own healing. Learning how people break through entrenched patterns of resistance hopefully can inform care providers, as well as medical, surgical, holistic health, and specialty medical care teams provide considered and informed spiritual interventions that promote patient autonomy. Increasing awareness of meaning-making and purpose can help stimulate discussions about the goals of treatment and healing.</p><p>Lessons from my own experience and my residency and fellowship in clinical pastoral education have reinforced my interest in serving a narrative of wholeness and soul connection. My focus on ministry involves alleviating self-condemnation and helping our patients experience wholeness with light and shadow in perspective. Without bypassing the reality of death, hard experience, and disillusionment, the veterans whose accounts are recorded here have found support in their own experience and were kind to share their stories of resilience. Spiritual care providers can benefit people in distress by helping them with their naturally-occurring narratives from their own experience from the teachings of life that have allowed the veterans to reframe their experiences from disillusionment to promote healing and faith that builds hope. Hopefully, these narratives will contribute to understanding about how people find resilience and healing as they build faith and hope to lead them toward wholeness.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=fc3dcdf46714" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Basic Research About the Sacred Mushroom Traditions of Mexico and Religious and Spiritual…]]></title>
            <link>https://ronmcnutt.medium.com/basic-research-about-the-sacred-mushroom-traditions-of-mexico-and-religious-and-spiritual-8b5a45f448ea?source=rss-368797e78488------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8b5a45f448ea</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ronald W. McNutt]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 16 Sep 2025 14:21:45 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-09-16T14:21:45.272Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Basic Research About the Sacred Mushroom Traditions of Mexico and Religious and Spiritual Experience with Fungi</h3><p>by Ronald W. McNutt, September 19, 2025</p><p>The pathway that psilocybin-containing mushrooms have taken in the last century is as mysterious as their effects on consciousness. The Indigenous practices were preserved by the Mazatec people of Mexico, a remnant of what was a widespread practice that suffered terribly from colonialism and persecution. This paper will explore the interesting people who were part of the sharing of information that spread into Western culture and areas like medicine and religion.</p><p>A tradition of using psilocybin-containing mushrooms was established before the Spanish conquest. It had existed for centuries, possibly 3000 years. Buried mushroom stone sculptures from a culture of the highland Maya of Guatemala, southern Mexico, and El Salvador, dating from one thousand years B.C.E. to about 500 A.D. show that mushrooms had sacred associations for the ancestors of that area. The mushrooms are often paired with animals and human figures associated with shamanism, revealing sacred associations. Ceramic figures with mushroom-like headdresses have been dated from 160 A.D. A ceramic figure from that time in Mexico shows a shaman using a mushroom as a drum.</p><p>Ceremonial use of psilocybin mushrooms is apparently depicted on a stone sculpture of the Aztec Prince of flowers. It is a seated divine male figure, carved in stone during the 1500s, with stylized mushrooms on its body, along with tobacco, ololiuqui, the hallucinogenic morning glory, and Heimia salicifolia, a plant which appears to have had complementary visionary effects. When Hernándo Cortés conquered the Aztec Empire in the early 1500s, his followers noticed the Aztecs eating mushrooms in a religious setting.</p><p>Ceremonial practices use and divination rituals with psilocybin mushrooms were important to the Aztecs. They called one or more of the types of psychedelic mushrooms God’s flesh or <em>teonanácatl</em> in the Aztec language of Náhuatl. This was recorded in the 1500s by Bernardino de Sahagún, a Franciscan friar, and a Dominican friar, Diego Durán. They were able to speak the language and were interested in the practices and culture of the inhabitants. A stone sculpture of Xochipilli, the Aztec Prince of Flowers, from the early 1500s, appears to depict a mediary to the heavens who was associated with music and song. The sculpture is decorated with stylized Psilocybe aztecorum mushrooms, a sacred morning glory, and tobacco and other sacred plants. It is on display at the National Museum of Anthropology in Mexico City.</p><p>In 1656, a Spanish court physician, Francisco Hernández de Toledo, in a guide intended for missionaries, recorded his description of the practices with consuming <em>teonanácatl</em> mushrooms, stating that they caused a kind of “madness” bringing “before the eyes all kinds of things, such as wars and the likeness of demons.”</p><p>Many plant hallucinogens were used in the New World, including cohoba, a hallucinogenic snuff, in Hispaniola. The Spanish also encountered peyotl and ololiuqui in Central and South America. They were held in the highest esteem by the native peoples, used for healing, divination, and cultural incorporation in rites of passage. Colonial authorities believed that these practices were evil and deemed them to be witchcraft and a threat to the goals of spreading Christian faith. In their minds, they were justified in committing the most extreme measures to obliterate them. They called for repression and death for those who claimed to experience revelations by indigenous practices using such elements from nature.</p><p>The description of experience with psilocybin mushrooms as God’s flesh or <em>teonanácatl</em> offended the Spanish authorities, as did their practices of human sacrifice. The Inquisition was established in Mexico in 1570. According to an article by Guerra in 1967, the Holy Inquisition of Mexico issued a proclamation in 1616 ordering the persecution and excommunication of those who, would employ “herbs and roots with which they lose and confound their senses, and the illusions and fantastic representations they have, judge and proclaim afterwards as revelation, or true notice of things to come…”</p><p>In 1629 a collection of observations from Nahuatl, a region in Mexico and Central America, described a pattern of chanting by Indians that persisted into the time when Western explorers located the practices in the 1950s in the Western Sierra Madre: professions of humility, claiming an ability to be able to talk to supernatural beings, and referencing a book of knowledge that was gifted from long before.</p><p>The Inquisition of Europe persecuted and repressed practices using traditional plant medicines, the Solanaceae herbs henbane, mandrake, and belladonna as witchcraft. The Inquisition which caused the execution of tens of thousands of people, mostly women, for witchcraft for centuries, especially during the 1500s and 1600s. These severe policies of persecution and repression were imported to the Americas, where disease and warfare were killing millions of Indigenous people.</p><p>The knowledge of the mushroom of the Aztecs, <em>teonanacatl</em>, and the earlier highland Maya became secret to evade persecution. This knowledge was thoroughly hidden by the guardians of the ceremony, which allowed the traditional healers in Oaxaca to employ these sacred medicines with respect and in secret for centuries and into the present time.</p><p>Dr. Schultes identifies sacred mushrooms</p><p>A prominent botanist, William Safferd, had concluded in a 1915 article that <em>teonanacatl</em>, was not a mushroom, but peyote. In 1938, specimens of psychoactive Panaeolus and Psilocybe mushrooms were identified to western science by Richard Evans Schultes. He was an adventurous ethnobotanist and doctoral student at Harvard University whose undergraduate research at Harvard included participating in many peyote ceremonies of the Kiowa in Oklahoma. Dr. Schultes knew that Safferd’s conclusion was contrary to the observations of Spanish chroniclers who observed such practices with their own eyes, as well as the evidence from imagery from the 1500s and 1600s, and earlier times.</p><p>Dr. Schultes had found a letter from an Austrian physician living in Mexico, Dr. Blas Pablo Reko, to the director of the United States Herbarium about a mushroom growing from cattle dung heaps. Dr. Schultes then had received samples of divine mushrooms from an anthropologist, Robert Weitlaner, which led him to contact the Austrian physician and travel to the Oaxaca region in 1936 to meet him. They collected three botanically identifiable specimens in the village of Huautla de Jiménez, in mountainous terrain. José Dorantes led Dr. Schultes to a Mazatec man who helped him obtain sacred mushrooms on July 27, 1938. (Wade Davis One River pp. 110–11). He acquired a dozen fresh mushrooms that later would be identified as Psilocybe cubensis and Panaeolus campanulatus.</p><p>Dr. Schultes’s 1939 paper about these field explorations concluded that the sacred medicine of the Aztecs, <em>teonanacatl</em>, or flesh of the gods, was a variety of psilocybin-containing mushroom. He had the impression, later borne out, that the hallucinogenic <em>teonanacatl </em>of the Aztecs was more than one species. This proof that sacred mushrooms were still being used in the hills of southern Mexico supported his doctoral dissertation. The information did not achieve much attention at first and remained in an obscure leaflet of the Harvard Botanical Museum.</p><p>In 1938, a British-American party with Bernard Bevan, Jean Bassett Johnson and Irmgard Weitlaner had attended a <em>velada</em> led by and old <em>curandero</em>. Their account was published in a Swedish anthropology journal. It also did not receive very much attention.</p><p>In 1939, Dr. Schultes returned to Huautla de Jiménez and explored the area with a guide. At that time, they located another Aztec teacher plant, ololiuqui, or vine of the serpent, the sacred morning glory. He collected botanical samples to identify this plant, Turbina corymbosa, at a curandero’s home in San Juan Lalana. He earned his Ph.D. in botany in 1941 describing these entheogens and their history of sacramental use. Dr. Schultes then shifted his attention to field work in the Colombian Amazon region where he continued his study of plants like rubber, ayahuasca, and medicinal plants and their use by humanity. He later returned to Harvard University as a teacher and researcher and inspired a new generation of ethnobotanists and contemporaries.</p><p>Gordon Wasson and others find the mushroom ceremony continued in Mazatec Indian traditions</p><p>R. Gordon Wasson was an ethnomycologist and a mycophile, a lover of fungi, who helped people learn about the natural psychedelic medicines that he preferred to call entheogens, plants and fungi that bring about the divine within. Gordon and Valentina Wasson introduced the American public to the revelation of the sacred mushroom ceremony when, along with their photographer Allan Richardson, they revealed a June 1955 <em>velada </em>or sacred mushroom ceremony led by Maria Sabina in a Life magazine article in 1957.</p><p>The Wassons had been conduction field explorations and careful research for several years. Mr. Wasson was an investment banker in Danbury, Connecticut, but his physician wife, from Russia, shared her love of mushrooms with him, an intriguing discovery on their honeymoon. Mr. Wasson combined his fascination and diligence with an ability to connect with Indigenous people. Their thirty-years of research led to the scientific discovery of the forgotten tradition of using psychedelic mushrooms for spiritual healing among the Mazatec Indians of the western Sierra Madre mountains of Mexico.</p><p>They had researched mushrooms and were investigating the traditional use of psychedelic mushrooms in Mexico. Robert Graves and Hans Mardersteig had found out about use of sacred mushrooms among indigenous people in Meso-American cultures. In 1952, Robert Graves wrote to Mr. Wasson and Dr. Tina Wasson about the sacred mushrooms and he included the article by Dr. Richard Evans Schultes. Mr. Wasson contacted Dr. Schultes at the Harvard Botanical Museum, who discussed his field explorations with Dr. Reko for his 1939 paper revealing that the sacred medicine of the Highland Maya and the Aztecs was continuing in the religious practices of their indigenous descendants using psilocybin-containing mushrooms. Dr. Schultes referred Mr. Wasson to Dr. Reko, who died shortly before they could meet.</p><p>Gastón Guzmán was a Mexican mycologist who also studied psilocybe and other psychedelic mushrooms in Huautla de Jiménez beginning in the 1956, and continued his studies throughout his career throughout the world. He found that in the 1950s and 1960s, many different Indigenous groups in Mexico were familiar with varieties of the sacred mushrooms. Through his friendship with a Mazatec Indian, Don Isauro Nava, he participated in and consumed six pairs of Psilocybe cubensis mushrooms on July 12, 1958, in a ceremony led by his 80-year-old mother. (Guzmán in The Sacred Mushroom Seeker, p. 92–93). He concluded that there are about 140 psychedelic species, mainly psilocybe, around the world, in temperate, tropical, and tropical habitats. He identified 300 mushroom species in all, throughout the world and wrote about 20 books and 400 articles about mushrooms.</p><p>Gordon and Valentina Wasson continued to travel to Mexico, and they participated in some well-organized expeditions. Gordon Wasson met Maria Sabina through a municipal leader at Huautla de Jimenez. The Wassons and photographer Allan Richardson participated in a June 1955 <em>velada</em> or sacred mushroom ceremony led by Maria Sabina, which was reported in a Life magazine article in 1957. Dr. Valentina Wasson wrote an article of her own which appeared in Look magazine.</p><p>Mr. Wasson was inspired by the fantastic effects and concluded that humans exploring foods in ancient times would have encountered the mushrooms and that the impact “could only have been profound, a detonator to new ideas.” Although his host, Maria Sabina, asked him not to share photographs except to his most trusted friends, he felt compelled to disclose the images while concealing her name. Their disclosure led to increased appreciation within the dominant culture about how humanity in other societies has been using entheogens since ancient times. At the same time, it created difficulties for the people of that region due to an influx of curious and often thoughtless tourists and hippies.</p><p>The 1953 Velada of Don Aurelio Carreras</p><p>In Persephone’s Quest, Mr. Wasson wrote that he attended a ceremony led by Don Aurelio Carreras before he was allowed to consume the mushrooms himself. On August 15, 1953, while traveling with Roberto Weitlaner, the Wassons had a <em>velada</em>, or sacred mushroom ceremony session, with a Mazatec Indian, Don Aurelio Carreras, in Huautla de Jiménez. Mr. Wasson wrote that don Aurelio was a <em>curandero</em> and<em> </em>one of their best informants in Persephone’s Quest shortly before his death.</p><p>A 1990 series of essays about Gordon Wasson, edited by Thomas Riedlinger, includes a chapter by Masha Wasson Britten in which she writes that she attended her father’s first mushroom rite, one conducted by Don Aurelio in 1953. Her father, she wrote, was very excited, “though we were not allowed to take the mushrooms.” They were accompanied by Robert Weitlaner, a distinguished Austrian engineer, ethnologist, and linguist, who had moved to Mexico in 1922 and who had extensive experience among the people of that region. Don Aurelio had provided them with samples of two varieties of sacred mushrooms and had allowed them to join the Mazatec Indians in a reverent search for the mushrooms.</p><p>Don Aurelio was a butcher who had lost one eye in an accident involving a bull. When other curanderos had not appeared, they learned that he was “one who knows,” and that his visions always had been accurate. The Wassons and Mr. Weitlaner were planning to depart the following day. Don Aurelio agreed to preside over a ceremony, and received the blessings of his relatives to do so. He was reluctant to proceed because his late wife’s mother was gravely ill, but because they had come so far, he decided to proceed. Don Aurelio would provide amazingly accurate telepathic information to Mr. Wasson from his sacred mushroom journey.</p><p>Don Aurelio instructed them to come to his compound that evening at 9:00 p.m. He told them his son, Demetrio, would serve as an interpreter, from Mazatec to Spanish, because the mushrooms only spoke to him in Mazatec at nighttime. The <em>curandero</em> (or healer) ordinarily would take 26 good-sized landslide varieties, which were the strongest of many varieties in the region. He had needed to substitute three Psilocybe mexicana (the species from which Dr. Hofmann later would isolate the active alkaloids psilocybin and psilocin) for the one landslide that he had been unable to obtain.</p><p>He consumed the 13 pairs of mushrooms and quietly smoked a cigar. Mr. Wasson wrote that he did not chant or recite prepared words, but would speak in conversation when the mushrooms would speak to him. He sat on a stool or shifted to his chair, smoking while wearing a sarape (shawl), with embers glowing on the floor. Don Aurelio asked what problem was troubling them and Mr. Wasson mentioned his concern about their teenage son, Peter, who had not been in contact, saying he was near Boston, where he had a summer job. Don Aurelio had to focus a while and then located him. He said that he was alive, but that people were reaching out for him to send him to war and it was hard to say if they would get him. Don Aurelio mentioned that he might have military service in Germany. He also told them that he was in New York and he was thinking of them and was to the point of being in tears, and was having difficulty coping with inner turmoil. He then invited them to smoke cigars. Later, he told them that one of Mr. Wasson’s relatives would fall seriously ill within a year.</p><p>Although Mr. Wasson did not believe the predictions or, more accurately, divinations, of Don Aurelio during the ceremony, he wrote that they proved to be correct. Mr. Wasson found out that his son Peter had had a party at their home in New York that weekend. Peter was in the National Guard, but due to an emotional ordeal with his girlfriend, he enlisted in the Army shortly afterward, and ended up doing service in Germany for two years followed by tours of duty in Vietnam. The following January, one of Mr. Wasson’s cousins, who had been in his forties and apparently healthy, died of heart failure.</p><p>Mr. Wasson did not reveal how he had received the psychic transmissions from Don Aurelio about their son’s whereabouts, his future involvement with the military, and the approaching death of a relative until much later. Mr. Wasson wrote that he had not actively emphasized this amazing account, and how his visions of the future came true, because he had not wanted to sensationalize the experience.</p><p>Maria Sabina and her initiation</p><p>Maria Sabina was born Maria Sabina Magdalena Garcia around 1894. She became a wise woman or <em>curandera</em> when she was about forty. Maria Sabina and the Mazatec people believed that a youthful man that later became identified as Christ brought the sacred mushrooms, or saint children, as a gift, and that they sprang up from where his blood would drop. She had a hard life in a beautiful mountain area of Oaxaca, in the Sierra Mazateca of Mexico. She and her sister worked hard on a small farm with a few goats, doing chores such as tending chickens in the woods. There was no school available. Their father died when she was a few years old. She was always hungry and cold when she was young.</p><p>When she was about six years old, a wise man came and cured her uncle using the sacred mushrooms in a traditional healing ceremony. Her people always spoke quietly and would use terms of respect to describe the sacred mushrooms, such as the little ones that leap forth or the saint children. Her father’s father and his father also had been wise ones, who could cure with mushrooms. She recognized the mushrooms from the woods and she and her sister ate them many times. Maria Sabina heard beautiful voices from another world giving beautiful advice and leading her to sing beautifully. One time, she had a vision of her father, who said to her, “Maria Sabina, get on your knees and pray.” She then spoke to God and became closer to God.</p><p>The Mazatecs reported to Mr. Wasson that the mushrooms would reveal to them secrets such as the location of a young wife who had vanished, where money that had been taken was located and who was keeping it, what had happened to a missing burro, and news of the activities of a missing son and where he was staying.</p><p>Before she became a wise woman, one who knows, she had suffered in two unhappy marriages. She shared from her life story in Alvara Estrada’s excellent book, Maria Sabina, Her Life and Chants. Maria Sabina had an arranged marriage and three children with her first husband but he left her and she was widowed after a six-year marriage. A few years later, she was required to intercede for her only sister who was having a health crisis with stomach pains and she could not get out of bed. Maria Sabina ate 30 pairs of the most potent variety of saint children, the name she would use for the mushrooms. She observed the ancient Mazatec vigil practices using candles of pure beeswax, flowers with scent and color, copal incense to bless the sacrament, and tobacco to put on the skin. Then, proceeding in pure darkness, the spirit of the mushrooms guided her hands and her words, which caused her sister’s body to expel a large amount of blood, and she stopped groaning and slept.</p><p>Then their mother attended her recovering sister while Maria Sabina went off and had a vision. It was an anointing and a revelation. Six or eight spiritual beings were before her at a table. The voice of the saint children told her that these were the Principal Ones she had learned about from her ancestors. One of them told her, “Maria Sabina, this is the Book of Wisdom. It is the Book of Language. Everything that is written in it is for you. The Book is yours, take it so that you can work.” She gladly accepted this wonderful gift and they left her to contemplate it. She began to speak and realized that she was reading its contents, and that this gift had been bestowed upon her because she was pure. She had attained the wisdom beyond being an apprentice and had become a Wise One.</p><p>Later that night, Maria Sabina also received a visit from the Lord of the Mountains, Chicon Nindo. In her wise language she had called him. He rode up on a horse and she went outside to witness his presence. She then received a third revelation when a luminous vegetal being, like a bush with flowers of colors and a halo shining with radiance, fresh and alive. Then, it quickly faded into a splendid red background. She cried, whistled, clapped, and danced, realizing that she was now the “Lord Clown Woman,” as she described her qualifications.</p><p>Maria Sabina continued working with wool and cotton, planted corn and beans, and harvested coffee. She sold bread, candles, and pots, and she raised silkworms. She remarried after twelve years. Both times while she was married, she would not eat mushrooms because their tradition required four-day periods of celibacy before and after mushroom ceremonies, or veladas. After she was widowed for the second time, she dedicated herself to curing with the saint children. She would access the Book of Wisdom in her visions until she could access it from memory, using the language to heal as an intermediary between this world and the heavenly realm, finding cures for soul illnesses, curses, and various diseases. She would accept gifts but would not charge for the medicine.</p><p>Maria Sabina said that the saint children speak and she would have the power to translate. She was aware of the dark places where illnesses of the soul would lurk, but she would go upward to commune with the Principal Ones. She would see the saints appear in the ceremonies when she sang their names. In her chanting, she proclaimed, “I am the woman of the winds, of the water, of the paths, because I am known in heaven, because I am a doctor woman.” She would clap, whistle and chant with a beautiful sing-song cadence, proclaiming her purity of heart for the service of Christ and the saints, and becoming the voice of the divine mushrooms. She stated, “I know that God is formed by the saints. Just as we, together, form humanity, God is formed by all the saints.”</p><p>Maria Sabina said, “Nothing that the mushrooms show should be feared.” After effecting a cure with the language of the children, she would say something like, “the one who has healed your son is God who is raising all of us.” She was active in a church group, Sisters of the Sacred Heart of Jesus, and she was great friends with the local priest. She said she had respect for everything that has to do with God. Maria Sabina practiced Catholicism. She said that she would commune with God by ceremonial experience with sacred mushrooms, and learn how to treat and address the problems of her clients. The local bishop, Father Antonio Reyes Hernandez, was supportive of her participation in the church, according to Estrada. Her oral autobiography was released in 1977.</p><p>Mazatec Mushroom Velada with Gordon Wasson</p><p>On June 29–30, 1955, Mr. Wasson and photographer Allan Richardson were the first outsiders to participate in the sacred mushroom ceremony, under the direction of the <em>curandera</em> Maria Sabina. They had traveled to the Mazatec Indian community of Huautla de Jiménez, 5500 feet high in the mountains of Oaxaca, a journey that included a harrowing flight and several miles on horseback. Mr. Wasson had approached an official at the town hall, a municipal sindico or magistrate, for whom Maria Sabina had provided counsel for his decisions for three years. He approached him respectfully and used the correct pronunciation for the word to describe the mushrooms. This gave the man the confidence to show Mr. Wasson a place where the mushrooms were growing so he could gather many of them. A term they would use for them was “the little ones who spring forth.” Then, the sindico introduced him to Maria Sabina, who led the ceremony with her daughter at night, with many members of the community. Gordon and Valentina Wasson participated, along with Allan Richardson, the photographer, in her velada.</p><p>In the influential article in <em>Life </em>magazine on May 13, 1957, Gordon Wasson described how the ritual Maria Sabina led was full of reverence, and “hedged about with restrictions of many kinds.” The mushrooms were gathered at a new moon before dawn by a virgin, consecrated on an altar at a Catholic church, and are eaten fresh in pairs. Before the ceremony, the mushrooms were held over copal incense. Their society believed the Christ spirit would come to them through the mushrooms, and the <em>curandera </em>prevailed upon it to come down in her singsong prayers. “They carry you there where God is,” the Mazatec would say.</p><p>The <em>curandera </em>Maria Sabina ate 13 pairs and Wasson said he was served six pairs. He wrote that he emerged awestruck and described visions more wonderful and real than ordinary life, of magnificent journeys and overwhelming beauty. As he wrote the<em> Life </em>magazine article, he was making his fifth trip there. Before the article came out, he had repeated the experience three days later and saw visions of people in another world, and felt his consciousness as not having a body. Six weeks later, he had some dried mushrooms, which he stated had kept their potency. The world was amazed by the news of the tradition that she and her people had preserved and Maria Sabina had many people come to see her from around the world.</p><p>Mr. Wasson had Maria Sabina’s words translated from a 1957 ceremony he participated in, when he was allowed to record her chanting. The recordings of her chanting were released on Folkways Records the following year, with translations from the Mazatec language, as Maria Sabina and her Mazatec Mushroom Velada. This was his proudest accomplishment, among his many discoveries.</p><p>French mycologist Roger Heim identifies new varieties of psychoactive mushrooms</p><p>In 1956, Mr. Wasson was accompanied to Huautla de Jiménez by a leading mycologist, his friend Roger Heim, the director of the French National Museum of Natural History, to help collect and identify the mushrooms. Dr. Heim found 24 kinds of psychoactive mushrooms in use by the Mazatec <em>curanderos</em> including some that were new to science. Dr. Heim illustrated in watercolors the seven different varieties of divine mushrooms he had seen them use, four of which had never been seen before. Mr. Wasson collaborated with Dr. Heim, writing books about the discovery of new mushrooms. They authored a book in France in 1958 about the hallucinogenic mushrooms of Mexico. The Life Magazine article published Dr. Heim’s watercolor paintings of varieties of sacred mushrooms.</p><p>In 1956, Dr. Heim contacted Albert Hofmann, the plant chemist who had synthesized LSD, to do a chemical investigation of psilocybin mushrooms that his assistant had grown after Dr. Heim discovered them in Mexico with Gordon Wasson. Dr. Hofmann decided to experiment with the mushrooms, eating 32 of them. He had visions of Mexican landscape and of a scientific colleague appearing as an Aztec priest, then a whirlpool of abstract motifs. (W. Davis at 120). Dr. Heim’s supply was sufficient for Dr. Hofmann to synthesize psilocybin and psilocin in 1958.</p><p>On April 19, 1943, Dr. Hofmann conducted an earlier scientific self-experiment with a different fungus with psychedelic properties. Dr. Hofmann ingested 250 micrograms of LSD-25, which he had synthesized from ergot of rye, Claviceps purpurea, a fungus. He described this chemical as “my fateful molecule,” in his lab in Basel, Switzerland. Dr. Hofmann rode his bicycle home together with his lab assistant. In the 1930s, he studied the chemistry of ergot to help blood circulation and stimulate breathing. In 1938, one derivative, lysergic acid diethylamide, seemed to have no obvious benefit, and so he shelved it until he had a “strange presentiment” and made a new batch in April 1943, which led to the discovery of its psychedelic effects. Dr. Hofmann isolated two new indole alkaloids the active psychedelics. Dr. Hofmann synthesized them, naming them psilocybin and psilocin, and he published his research in 1958. (Dr. Hofmann also derived compounds from psilocybin mushrooms that became beta blocker cardiac drugs).</p><p>When Mr. Wasson returned in 1958, Don Aurelio officiated the <em>velada</em> with Maria Sabina. He wrote that she treated Don Aurelio with marked deference, and called him a respectful term in Mazatec meaning “one who knows.” After Tina Wasson’s death in 1958, Dr. Heim returned with Gordon Wasson in 1959 and 1961.</p><p>In 1962, Albert Hofmann and his wife Anita traveled with Mr. Wasson to Oaxaca in 1962. Don Aurelio was also in attendance at the ceremony. Dr. Hofmann wrote that he had a strong presence. Dr. Hofmann participated in the mushroom ceremony, and shared his psilocybin pills with Maria Sabina and don Aurelio. At dawn she told him the pills “had the same spirit as the mushrooms.” Before they departed, Dr. Hofmann gave her a gift of the psilocybin pills, which she accepted with gratitude. Maria Sabina told him that she would be able to use them during dry seasons when the mushrooms would not grow.</p><p>Maria Sabina had a movie made about her. The Mexican government hosted her stay in Mexico City when she was honored and went to the film’s opening. In 1979, Maria Sabina went to Mexico City, where the documentary “Maria Sabina: Mujer Espiritu,” by Nicholas Echevarria, was shown under government sponsorship. She was honored for her work, and remained in Mexico City for over a month.</p><p>A friend of mine has let me know of her experience: “I met Maria Sabina twice in her mountain village. Her village is well known for the beautiful embroidery the women make; beautiful bright flowers and birds. The people of her village loved her and resented the big researchers who came to visit, made lots of money from their publishing and she didn’t get a cent. The last time I was there someone had shown up with a film crew and all the men in the village surrounded her house and would not let them see her. It was powerful to feel their protection of her. She was poor as far as money goes. She gave me several beautiful huipils (embroidered tops she had made that I still wear!) and her house was very simple, earthy literally. She was a visionary and a dedicated healer, deeply committed to her inner life, a woman of integrity, also very practical. I assisted in a session she gave to a woman who visited her hoping for cure of cancer. Maria Sabina ate fresh picked mushrooms on a plate that was a tobacco leaf. In this case so did the woman. Then she sang and prayed all night. In the morning she treated the woman according to her visions. In the session I was at she was assisted by her sister. I certainly received a big download from her but it was mostly energetic — an experiential blessing!”</p><p>The virtuous circle</p><p>Another discovery that Dr. Hofmann made completed what he called “the magic circle.” His friend Gordon Wasson obtained <em>ololiuqui</em>, Morning Glory seeds, from Zapotec Indians and provided them to him for analysis. He discovered lysergic acid amides in them, like in his original discoveries with ergot. He wrote about this with Dr. Richard Evans Schultes in 1973, The Botany and Chemistry of Hallucinogens, which also revealed the mysterious interplay in ayahuasca of DMT and the harmine and harmaline mono amine oxidase inhibitors, manifesting a profound psychedelic effect. Recently, a young chemistry student at West Virginia University, Corinne Hazel, found ergot alkaloids with lysergic acid amides in in fuzzy material on the seed coats of Ipomoea tricolor, the Mexican species used for visionary experience among the Mazatec and other indigenous groups of Mexico. She published the findings with her adviser, Daniel Panaccione, <a href="https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/00275514.2025.2483634">https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/00275514.2025.2483634</a> in the journal <a href="https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/00275514.2025.2483634">Mycologia</a>. The seed coats contain a <em>Periglandula</em> species, a type of fungus that creates lysergic acid, and the scientists have named is Periglandula clandestina because it was secretive and avoided detection by scientists as notable as Dr. Hofmann for all these years.</p><p>Dr. Hofmann collaborated for two years with Gordon Wasson and Carl Ruck to investigate what the ancient Greek rites, the Eleusinian Mysteries, had used in their tradition, which offered a visionary experience. For almost two thousand years in ancient Greece, and into the era of Christianity, the Eleusinian Mysteries employed a libation, known as the <em>kykeon</em>, that created profound visions and was associated with Persephone’s return from Hades, the cycle of seasons, and the continuity of life. The Eleusinian Mysteries incorporated a vision that reinforced an appreciation of eternity. The ritual pilgrimages of the ancient Greeks in Eleusis took place from 1600 B.C. to 392 C.E. They were part of an annual festival led by hierophants or priests that celebrated the myth of Demeter and Persephone.</p><p>The Eleusinian Mysteries were ended when Christian institutions became powerful and entrenched. The <em>Kykeon</em> ingredients were guarded in secrecy. The rituals were restricted to the once in a lifetime ceremony available as part of a pilgrimage restricted to individuals who had not committed a murder. The culmination of the Mystery was “an overwhelming vision of spiritual presences demonstrating the relationship of the living and the dead.”</p><p>The formula for the kykeon of Eleusis has remained a mystery with some hints to bring a sense of wonder and intrigue. There was an absolute prohibition on revealing or profaning the sacrament. The authors’ research indicated that they likely employed a psychedelic, quite possibly a substance containing lysergic acid amides derived from ergot, to produce the mysterious visions in the Eleusinian Mysteries over the centuries. The Road to Eleusis, published in 1978, speculated that a variety of ergot that grew on a common grass, Claviceps paspali, could have been used. It had no toxins, but contained the hallucinogenic lysergic acid alkaloids. Alternatively, they thought that common ergot varieties that grew on wheat and barley had water-soluble extracts which were very similar to <em>ololiuqui</em> and LSD.</p><p>The Good Friday Experiment in 1962</p><p>Walter Pahnke was a Ph.D. student in psychology at Harvard University when he was responsible for the most significant study of the Harvard Psilocybin Project, the Good Friday experiment on April 20, 1962. For years, it was the leading experiment showing that psilocybin can facilitate experiences of mysticism in people disposed toward spirituality when used in a conducive setting. The project was carefully designed to provide supportive conditions to induce a profound experience which could be measured by psychometric assessments. It was the basis for the Ph.D. thesis for his program in religion and society. He previously had earned M.D. and M. Div. degrees.</p><p>By the time it was conducted, the subcommittee that became responsible for supplying the psilocybin for experiments refused to provide it for this experiment. Walter Pahnke was studying under Dr. Timothy Leary and Dr. Richard Alpert, however, had been withheld supplies from the university authorities, stressing that it was the very type of research for which the psychedelics were intended.</p><p>The volunteers for the experiment were twenty divinity school students from Andover-Newton Theological Seminary, and ten leaders who were professors or graduate students with psychedelic experience. Dr. Leary had insisted that half of the leaders also receive the psilocybin. No one knew who would receive the psilocybin, which was a 30 mg. dose for participants and a 15 mg. dose for the leaders, and who received an identically-appearing control of nicotinic acid.</p><p>The event was held in a downstairs chapel, below Marsh Chapel at Boston University, on Good Friday. They listened to a 2 ½ hour service with music, prayers, and a sermon by Rev. Howard Thurman. The experiment employed a questionnaire which Dr. Pahnke prepared to measure the experience, adopting categories identified by the work of William James and W.T. Stace as representing the characteristics of fundamental, universal mystical experiences.</p><p>His 1966 article about the Good Friday experiment was published in 1970 in the Aaronson and Osmond publication <em>Psychedelics</em>. He stated that psychedelics help facilitate experiences of mysticism, and that researchers identified similarities in descriptive language of the experimental subjects to the descriptions found in the descriptions of people having spontaneous mystical experiences. The responses showed the active participants responded that they experienced: (1) sense of unity or oneness; (2) transcendence of space and time; (3) deeply felt positive mood, blessedness, peace; (4) sense of sacredness; (5) objectivity, reality, and intuitive knowledge; (6) paradoxicality; and (7) alleged ineffability, which refers to the difficulty of grasping the experience by language and logical thinking; (8) transiency; and (9) persisting positive changes in attitude and behavior.</p><p>Social and scientific involvement with psilocybin as a source of renewal</p><p>The 1960s were a time when there was wide access to psilocybin and LSD for use in research and in therapy. There had been over one thousand publications presenting encouraging results with about 40,000 participants in LSD therapy, in well-funded studies with very capable staff. It was the subject of six international conferences. Western culture had a challenging reaction to the way the hallucinogens came to assume a central role in a movement that began to question many of the basic values and precepts of mainstream Euro-American culture.</p><p>The early experiments with psychedelics explored whether they could be a trigger for psychosis and help explain mental illness. Scientists expected LSD and psilocybin to reveal the way to understand the origins of psychosis or to present a means to control thought. The discovery of serotonin, a neurotransmitter, and its similarity to serotonergic psychedelics like LSD, psilocybin and dimethyltryptamine, ignited interest in experiments. MK-ULTRA, a prolonged and cruel CIA mind control program dominate or control people’s minds, failed to demonstrate a clear means for manipulating others. Instead, psychedelics appeared to be respectable and potentially viable agents for transformation.</p><p>Timothy Leary was introduced to psychedelics after he had received a position as a lecturer in clinical psychology at The Center for Personality Research at Harvard University in 1959. In the summer of 1960, a psychology professor he knew from Berkeley, Frank Barron, inspired him to experience psychedelic mushrooms in Mexico. He described it as “the deepest religious experience of my life.” He saw that his reality appeared to be a fabrication, and came to believe that psychedelics were one of the most important events of the 1900s. Dr. Leary organized research on the effects of psilocybin and LSD, and oversaw the Harvard Psilocybin Project.</p><p>In Be Here Now, published in 1971, Ram Dass, formerly Richard Alpert, revealed that his first turning point in transformation began with his trip on synthesized psilocybin on March 6, 1961 at Timothy Leary’s house in Newton, Massachusetts. He began having monthly psychedelic sessions and with Tim Leary, Ralph Metzner, and others, and they formed the Harvard Psilocybin Project. They invited about 200 graduate students, creative people, academics, theologians, and others to write about their experiences with psilocybin. In an account published in Psychedelics<em> </em>(1970), Dr. Stanley Krippner wrote about his first psilocybin experience in 1962 supervised by the Harvard University Psilocybin Research Project. He described a richly symbolic experience of heightened sensation with pronounced tastes, feelings, smells, sights, and sounds, and felt “overwhelmingly tuned in to ‘the true nature of things.”</p><p>Religious scholar Huston Smith joined the Harvard Psychedelic Project after his mescaline trip in Dr. Leary’s home on New Year’s Day in 1961. He came to disapprove of Dr. Leary’s departure from the therapist and researcher roles and becoming a public figure leading people to leave education and careers behind, and he did not view this counterculture movement as having staying power. He preferred the cautious and studied approach of his friends Aldous Huxley, Gerald Heard, Gordon Wasson and Albert Hofmann. He thought the tenets of the world religions all counseled in favor of positive activity to promote universal compassion. He cherished his heritage and others that recognize that we “are in caring hands and that in gratitude for that fact we should try to bear one another’s burdens.”</p><p>William A. Richards, Ph.D., is a clinical psychologist who was at the forefront of the original entheogen studies in the mid-1960s and is again one of the leading psychotherapists during the psychedelic renaissance. In his 2016 book, Sacred Knowledge, Psychedelics and Religious Experiences, Dr. Richards wrote about his religious experience during his first session with synthetic psilocybin in 1963 in Germany. Amazing undulating designs, a field of flowing energy filled with multidimensional symbolism, gave way to a full mystical experience outside of time, flooding him with awe, glory, and gratitude.</p><p>In 1977, after the federal Controlled Substances Act of 1970, and the response of the funding agencies, Dr. Richards had the distinction to be the clinician to deliver the final administration of psilocybin at a research project with cancer patients at Maryland Psychiatric Center, on the grounds of Spring Grove Hospital. A veil of silence descended over the role of hallucinogen research in psychiatry, and there was little discussion about the merits of this research for 25 years, except for some brave souls willing to be marginalized in their careers.</p><p>Terence McKenna became interested in shamanism in college and traveled to the Colombian Amazon La Chorrera, in the jungles of Colombia, culminated on March 4, 1971, along with his brother Dennis, now a plant pharmacologist and a leading expert on psychedelics and consciousness, and others. The epic trip is described in his 1989 book True Hallucinations and in Dennis McKenna’s book, Brotherhood of the Screaming Abyss. The brothers intended to find an orally acting psychedelic, virola, that would resonate with sound and open a portal into an alternative reality. A research paper by the ethnobotanist Dr. Richard Evans Schultes released in 1969, stated that components of virola sap, a psychedelic used by the Witoto people called oo-koo-hé, contained DMT and 5MeO-DMT, and that it was believed to be orally active like ayahuasca.</p><p>The experiment at La Chorrhera intended to create a trans-dimensional reality using their voices to resonate sound in a vibration with their DNA and enter a portal to another dimension. They did not find virola but they found large amounts of psilocybin in fields and used them with ayahuasca vine, and received a major download of information that led to them developing a technique for cultivating psilocybin mushrooms over the next couple of years. In 1975, they had a small book or pamphlet called, “Psilocybin — Magic Mushroom Grower’s Guide” published in Berkeley under pseudonyms. Dr. McKenna states that it provided a reliable method for cultivating psilocybin mushrooms at home and brought psilocybin to many people and paved the way for the Psychedelic Renaissance. The first psychedelic era had left seeds of inspiration that reignited with the insight they shared: a technology to propagate Psilocybe cubensis mushrooms which Dennis developed. The guide taught people how to grow mycelium in rye grain, which brought greater familiarity with the benefits of this fungal medicine.</p><p>Terence McKenna suggested taking psilocybin mushrooms in silent darkness, and with eyes closed. He believed that when taken this way one could expect a profound visionary experience. He believed that mushrooms were a spiritual force from another world that helped contribute to evolution. He believed that by dissolving boundaries and ego clinging, psychedelics can help ordinary people connect emotionally, build community, and feel spiritually at one with nature and help bring about a healthier society.</p><p>In 1999, Bill Richards and Roland Griffiths spearheaded a study at Johns Hopkins, using a double-blind experiment with psilocybin or Ritalin, in which two-thirds of the active subjects said it was among the five most important events of their lives and many volunteers experienced enduring positive effects.</p><p>In 2005, neuroimaging studies at Imperial College London identified the “default mode network” that is involved in depression, rumination, rigid thinking, and post-traumatic stress disorder. It had reduced involvement in the psychedelic state with psilocybin while previously-suppressed neural networks and regions “light up” and become more active under the influence of psilocybin. The results suggest that psilocybin seems to reduce repressive control and promote other pathways increasing communication.</p><p>An article in July of 2006 by Dr. Griffiths and researchers, William A. Richards, U. McCann, and Robert Jesse, titled “Psilocybin Can Occasion Mystical-Type Experiences Having Substantial and Sustained Personal Meaning and Spiritual Significance,” was published in the journal <em>Psychopharmacology</em>. The study reported that psilocybin-assisted psychotherapy with healthy volunteers who regularly participated in religious or spiritual activities and who had no experience with psychedelics experienced “sustained personal meaning and spiritual significance.” It was a scientific study, authorized with FDA protocols, and was recognized for good clinical experimental design consisting of two to three sessions with psilocybin at two-month intervals. The results showed that after two months, 2/3 of volunteers said it was the most or one of the five most spiritually significant experiences of their lives. At 14 months afterward, 58 % stated that it was among the most meaningful, and 67 % said it was among the most spiritually significant experiences. 58 % had had a complete mystical experience.</p><p>Dr. Griffiths served as the founding Director of the Johns Hopkins Center for Psychedelic and Consciousness Research, established in 2020 with private philanthropy. He was the author of over 400 journal articles and book chapters and led several groundbreaking studies with synthetic psilocybin before his death in 2023.</p><p>Dr. Richards served as the Clinical Director of the States of Consciousness Research in the Department of Psychiatry at Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine at the Bayview Medical Center. He found that the volunteers often had mystical experiences that they treasured, and that these experiences were remarkably similar. Dr. Richards also found that the volunteers would have healing realizations about the importance of resolving conflicts in their lives and reconciling with people, and strengthening friendships. The wisdom within the mind could bring awareness of unexpected realizations and lead people to balance life interests well. People would often experience not what they wanted or expected, but what they seemed to need.</p><p>In his book, Sacred Knowledge, Dr. Richards writes that the experience with psychedelics involves increase of serotonin and reduced activity in the amygdala, and prompt access to the mystery of the collective unconscious. People experience a presence and power beyond oneself as the ego humbly and unconditionally will choose to trust, receive, and participate with all that is emerging from within the depths of the mind. He said that “the ego is best transcended through acceptance, forgiveness when appropriate, and unconditional love.”</p><p>Psychedelics act as a reset for expansion of one’s mind. They permit consciousness to go beyond the default mode network, including the dysfunctional patterns we develop, to be transformed through the journey to go to a more natural resting state, a healthier mindset. Psychedelics are classified as tryptamines, including psilocybin, psilocin, and DMT; ergolines, such as LSD; and phenethylamines, like mescaline and its derivatives. Phenethylamines, such as mescaline, which is in plants like peyote and San Pedro, bind to the 5-HT2A receptor at a lower binding affinity than tryptamines and ergolines. LSD contains both the tryptamine and the phenylethylamine chemical structures and will occupy four serotonin receptors, while the tryptamines will occupy three. MDMA, ketamine, and iboga act in different ways from serotonergic psychedelics, which act as agonists, replacing the serotonin.</p><p>Dr. David Nichols has had an active career as a chemist and advocate for psychedelic research and clinical applications. He was a professor at Purdue University, where he helped to establish the Betty Gordon Library devoted to psychedelics and research, and is an adjunct professor at the University of North Carolina. He explains that psychedelics are classified as tryptamines, including psilocybin, psilocin, and DMT, ergolines, such as LSD, and phenylethylamines, like mescaline and its derivatives. Phenylethylamines, such as mescaline-containing plants like peyote and San Pedro, bind to the 5-HT2A receptor at a lower binding affinity. He published an article in 2016 that concluded that LSD contains both the tryptamine and the phenylethylamine chemical structures. One of his graduate students discovered a simpler and more effective way to synthesize psilocybin, and he placed the formula in the public domain for greater access and affordability.</p><p>Dr. Nichols believes that psilocybin helps address experiences that cause stress. He states that they are activating and opening rather than suppressing and flattening of emotions, and that the difficult experience is what does the healing. Psychedelics, he believes, address overly rigid emotional and cognitive patterns, and that the profound shake-up experience is what can bring about long-term change. Recent work shows excellent results in addressing obsessive compulsive disorder and alcoholism, at N.Y.U. and at the University of New Mexico.</p><p>In 1993, Dr. Nichols founded of the Heffter Research Institute, which has been the major organizer and funder of clinical research with psilocybin at research institutions in the United States and Europe. Psychedelic research has not been funded by the government and until recently, it has not represented a profit-making venture for the pharmaceutical industry, so the Heffter Research Institute relies on private funding to promote scientific studies. Usona Institute was founded in 2015 by Bill Linton, and the clinical director, Dr. Charles Raison. In 2023–24, Usona Institute had a psilocybin-assisted study for major depression in 11 different sites in the United States. It is near phase 3 stage now. patients showed great improvement.</p><p>In July, 2020, the Lundquist Institute for Biomedical Innovation announced a multi-site clinical trial to be led by Dr. Charles Grob, a psychiatrist and researcher at U.C.L.A., and Dr. Anthony Bossis of New York University to study the effects of psilocybin to ease existential distress for patients with serious illness. From 2004 to 2008, Dr. Grob conducted an important study that showed the beneficial use of psilocybin in terminal cancer patients, helping people come to terms with death and easing the emotional burden they were facing. In his research, he showed that the mystical experience is a potent indicator of positive outcomes with favorable and lasting changes, when used in settings with careful preparation, administration, and integration. His results were influential in encouraging more research, and were published in a 2011 article in Archives of General Psychiatry, and in a 2013 chapter with Roland Griffiths and Tony Bossis.</p><p>The Beckley Foundation supported research with psilocybin-assisted therapy at Imperial College London, the Beckley-Imperial Research Programme, which began in 2009 and concluded in 2016. The research showed outstanding success in treatment of patients with severe depression who had shown little to no improvement from traditional treatment. The trial that all the subjects reported scores below the level of moderate depression afterward, and a significant reduction that lasted until the five-week follow-up evaluation. Even six months later there were significant benefits from that one psychedelic therapy session, averaging slightly above the threshold for moderate depression. In January 2019, the study entered phase 2 with a larger group of subjects.</p><p>Dr. Nichols and the Heffter Research Institute have directed their energy to help fund and promote scientific research with psilocybin, a tryptamine alkaloid that binds with serotonin 2A receptors. They have been responsible for producing scientific studies that clearly show the benefits of psychedelic-induced mystical experiences and meaningful, spiritually significant experiences with enduring effects on ordinary people. The experiences can improve interpersonal closeness, decrease resistance, increase gratitude, life meaning or purpose, and forgiveness, and relieve anxiety about death and social expectations, and enhance religious faith and coping ability.</p><p>Dr. Griffiths explains that the major psychedelics are unspecific amplifiers of unconscious processes, and through enhanced insight, the subjects can observe what drives their own objectionable behaviors. His research indicates that psychedelics increase neuroplasticity in brain function, which can help people transform through experiencing and integrating deep inner experiences. People have experiences that reset them into a new world view with opportunities for positive changes and choices.</p><p>In 1998, Amanda Feilding, a British psychedelic activist, founded what is now the Beckley Foundation, an important source of scientific research and publications, as well as consulting and advocacy for making psychedelics available in safe settings for therapeutic use and for spiritual transformation. Albert Hofmann was the president of the Beckley foundation until his death in 2008 at the age of 102. She states, “The best way to overcome the taboo, and re-integrate psychedelics into the fabric of society, is by undertaking the very best scientific research.” Ms. Fielding has participated in about 40 scientific publications, one of which was the first imaging study of LSD’s impact on brain connectivity. The Beckley Foundation has pursued over twenty psychedelic research projects, including studies in Australia using psilocybin with terminally ill cancer patients to promote acceptance.</p><p>The Beckley-Imperial Research Programme began conducting psilocybin research at Imperial College in 2009 that shows outstanding success in treatment of patients with severe depression who had shown little to no improvement from traditional treatment. The trial concluded in 2016 and showed that all of the subjects reported scores below the level of moderate depression afterward, and a significant reduction that lasted until the five-week follow-up evaluation. Even six months later there were significant benefits from that one psychedelic therapy session, averaging slightly above the threshold for moderate depression. In January 2019, the study entered phase 2 with a larger group of subjects. Dr. Robin Carhart-Harris published an article in Wired on January 1, 2021, about studies with psilocybin. He wrote: “In a study we carried out at Imperial College London’s Centre for Psychedelic Research, which I head, 100 per cent of participants ranked a 25 mg. psilocybin experience as the single most intense state of consciousness of their lives.”</p><p>The studies at The Johns Hopkins School of Medicine show the benefits of psilocybin to alleviate depression in terminally ill patients. Eighty percent of the participants had significant decreases in depressed mood. From 2007 to 2014, Dr. Griffiths led a large study into the effects of psilocybin, using high-and low-dose experiences, with anxiety in cases of life-threatening cancer illness. The study had 51 participants whose symptomatology met the definition of a mood or anxiety disorder. After having the high dose, 76 % had substantial relief five weeks later for anxiety and 92 % showed significant antidepressant response. After six months, there was a 78 % response rate for anxiety and 83 % success rate for depression. The experience provided sustained death acceptance, life meaning, optimism, and quality of life. The best measures were from those reporting mystical-type experiences. Seventy percent stated it was the most or among the five most significant spiritual experiences of their lives and 67 % reported that it was the most or among the five most personally meaningful experiences of their lives.</p><p>These results show that perhaps the greatest potential for entheogen assisted psychotherapy would be in palliative care units in the hospitals. Bill Richards wrote that the best time to institute the series of about three sessions of high dose psilocybin, would be about six months prior to transition. He believes that this will provide the greatest benefits, providing less anxiety around death, and opportunities for deepened family relationships in time for that growth. He encourages a spirit of honest curiosity toward death and entrusting one’s life to a sacred dimension greater than one’s everyday personality.</p><p>In February 2021, Charles Grob, M.D., and Jim Grigsby, Ph.D., released a textbook they edited, titled Handbook of Medical Hallucinogens. From 2004 to 2008, Dr. Grob conducted an important study that showed the beneficial use of psilocybin in terminal cancer patients, helping people come to terms with death and easing the emotional burden they were facing. In his research, he showed that the mystical experience is a potent indicator of positive outcomes with favorable and lasting changes, when used in settings with careful preparation, administration, and integration. His results were influential in encouraging more research, and were published in a 2011 article in Archives of General Psychiatry, and in a 2013 chapter with Roland Griffiths and Tony Bossis.</p><p>Recently, the Usona Institute announced a research project with psilocybin in phase 2 clinical trials at several locations in the United States is underway for studying treatment of major depressive disorder. In July, 2020, the Lundquist Institute for Biomedical Innovation announced a multi-site clinical trial to be led by Dr. Grob and Dr. Anthony Bossis of New York University to study the effects of psilocybin to ease existential distress for patients with serious illness. Dr. Griffiths and Dr. Stephen Ross, of N.Y.U. School of Medicine, are leading ongoing studies with psilocybin for religious professionals, to understand mystical experience and its enduring effects on attitude, behavior, and vocation.</p><p>A Congressional hearing about psychedelic assisted therapies research and treatment for veterans took place on November 14, 2023, before the House Veterans’ Affairs Subcommittee on Health. Two panels including Veterans Administration officials spoke in favor of Congress enacting the Breakthrough Therapies Act, which would streamline the implementation of psilocybin- and MDMA-assisted therapies for veterans to address posttraumatic stress disorder and help prevent veteran suicide. The hearing was titled, “Emerging Therapies: Breakthroughs in the Battle Against Suicide?” It took place after a previous Veterans Administration conference September 2023 State of the Art Conference to consider system-wide clinical implementation for psychedelic compounds for potential future use. The conference presented very encouraging results from outside studies and those conducted through the Veterans Administration.</p><p>Frederick Barrett, the new director of the Johns Hopkins Center for Psychedelic and Consciousness Research discussed results of studies showing that psychedelic therapies have proven effective in a wide range of psychiatric indications. He has been involved with studies over the past ten years with over 400 individuals and over 1000 doses. He testified that psilocybin is relatively safe, that risks can be managed in controlled settings. Studies have shown it to be effective with mood disorders, depression, eating disorders, substance abuse disorders, and obsessive-compulsive disorder.</p><p>Laws and decriminalization initiatives</p><p>Dr. Dennis McKenna wrote a chapter in the textbook, The Handbook of Medical Hallucinogens, p. 41 (C. Grob, J. Grigsby, ed., 2021), titled “Plants for the People.” He reviewed the history of the original psychedelic era and the incongruous laws that resulted in criminalizing these substances. He proposed making natural substances legal internationally for religious use. “Codify into law the principle that plants (and fungi and other biologically active organisms) are not ‘drugs’ in their natural form, and thus should not be regulated. When psychoactive substances are extracted from their natural sources, purified, and concentrated, they are then ‘drugs’ and should be appropriately regulated as such.”</p><p>Provisions adopted in various states and cities that are sometimes described as decriminalization measures are “deprioritizing” measures. In 2019 Denver decriminalized the use of psilocybin mushrooms by citizen referendum. Oakland California’s city council passed an ordinance to direct law enforcement to stop investigating and prosecuting individuals for using or possessing drugs sourced from plants, cacti, and mushrooms that contain the mescaline or <a href="https://www.usatoday.com/story/opinion/2019/05/13/denver-magic-mushrooms-promising-medicine-reckless-recreation-column/1182543001/">psilocybin</a>. A 2020 resolution by Santa Cruz made investigation and arrest for “the adult possession, use or cultivation of psychoactive plants and fungi” a low-priority infraction by law enforcement.</p><p>In the District of Columbia, a 2020 measure made enforcement of laws prohibiting psilocybin, ayahuasca, and mescaline-containing plants the lowest law enforcement priority. Ann Arbor, Michigan deprioritized enforcement of local laws punishing use and possession of entheogenic plants and compounds in 2020. In 2021, Detroit’s Proposal E made enforcement of laws prohibiting all entheogenic plants the lowest priority of law enforcement. Somerville, Northampton, and Cambridge, Massachusetts adopted similar measures in 2021, following a grow, gather, and gift model, stating that deprioritizing enforcement of laws regarding possession and use of psychedelic mushrooms and entheogenic plants should be the lowest law enforcement priority, and discouraging use of city funds to punish such non-commercial use of these substances. In 2023, Portland, Maine deprioritized law enforcement of laws regulating psychedelic plants and fungi such as psilocybin, San Pedro, and plants containing DMT.</p><p>Oregon’s supported adult use psilocybin mushroom program is a nonmedical program with supervision by trained facilitators and regulatory supervision for testing, qualifications, and standards of behavior. The Oregon program provides “psilocybin services” regulated by the Oregon Psilocybin Services, a subdivision of the Oregon Health Authority Public Health Division’s Center for Health Protection. Oregon Psilocybin Services began awarding licenses in early 2023. The Oregon psilocybin program does not require a license as a psychotherapist or other professional health credential to be a facilitator. Compliance with regulations can create substantial operating expenses that make participation costly for centers and consumers. Regulation helps ensure safe material for consumption and a setting with an experienced and trained facilitator.</p><p>The Colorado Natural Medicine Health Act was enacted into law after a successful voter referendum in 2022. The Colorado Natural Medicine Health Act has a combined set of provisions including supported adult use, the Regulated Natural Medicine Access Program, and a decriminalization program. The Colorado Natural Medicine Health Act also has personal use and cultivation provisions that do not depend on the regulated program’s requirements for facilitators and locations. The Natural Medicine Health Act permits adults aged 21 and over to use, possess, process, share, and grow natural medicines like psilocybin mushrooms, components of ayahuasca, or San Pedro cactus or huachuma. Personal use provisions of the Natural Medicine Health Act were effective as of July 2023. The law establishes a twelve-by-twelve-foot area allotted for individuals to be able to grow protected plants or fungi. The propagation must take place in compact areas not accessible to minors. There are provisions that prevent counties from prohibiting the personal use provisions or restrict the amount of growing space. Earlier provisions in the Natural Medicine Health Act to include plant material with ibogaine were removed by later amendments to the law.</p><p>Religious protection</p><p>The major psychedelics became illegal nationwide by October 1968. In 1970, the Federal Controlled Substances Act was enacted, which gave authority to the Food and Drug Administration to create schedules for criminal sanctions for the use and possession of psychoactive drugs and substances. <em>See</em> 21 U.S.C. §§ 841(a)(1), 811–821. After the Controlled Substances Act was enacted, and under its authority, LSD, mescaline, peyote, ayahuasca, and psilocybin mushrooms were placed in the highly restricted Schedule I as having no medical potential and being subject to abuse and presenting grave dangers. The substances listed in Schedule I of the Controlled Substances Act are subject to an outright ban on all importation and use except for strictly regulated research projects. <em>See</em>, 21 U.S.C. §§ 823, 960(a)(1).</p><p>The Supreme Court refused to afford First Amendment protection for use of peyote as a sacrament in <em>Employment Division, Department of Human Resources of Oregon v. Smith</em>, 494 U.S. 872 (1990). This represented a departure from the traditional protection of a fundamental right, the right to freedom of worship and religious observance. This removal of constitutional protection received bipartisan criticism and Congress was motivated to pass legislation to undo this unpopular approach. The Congress in 1993 responded by legislatively overturning the diminished constitutional protection.</p><p>The Religious Freedom Restoration Act was enacted to provide a private cause of action for persons whose religious exercise has been substantially burdened, allowing them to “assert that violation as a claim or defense in a judicial proceeding and obtain appropriate relief against a government.” 42 U.S.C. § 2000bb-1 provides, in section (a), “Government shall not substantially burden a person’s exercise of religion even if the burden results from a rule of general applicability, except as provided in subsection (b).” Section (b) states, “Government may substantially burden a person’s exercise of religion only if it demonstrates that application of the burden to the person- (1) is in furtherance of a compelling governmental interest; and (2) is the least restrictive means of furthering that compelling governmental interest.”</p><p>A unanimous Supreme Court decision upheld the right of a church to use ayahuasca in <em>Gonzales v. O Centro Espirita Beneficente União do Vegetal, </em>546 U.S. 418 (2006). The Court held that a <em>prima facie</em> showing that federal enforcement of the Controlled Substances Act places a substantial burden on a sincere exercise of religion, shifts the burden of persuasion to the federal government to establish that its burdensome actions furthered a compelling interest in the least restrictive manner. <em>Gonzales v. O Centro Espirita Beneficente União do Vegetal, </em>546 U.S. 418, 437–38(2006).</p><p>The DEA has developed, or imposed, an administrative process to consider applications for religious exemptions from the Controlled Substances Act for use of psilocybin for religious, Indigenous, or spiritual practices under the Religious Freedom Restoration Act. Its process was strongly criticized in a May 2024 Government Accountability Office report. It has also been deemed overly burdensome in subsequent cases. The report informed Congress about severe deficiencies in the religious exemptions petition process for psilocybin mushrooms and other controlled substances and offered recommendations for better procedures in the religious exemption process.</p><p>The Government Accountability Office also reviewed the use of psilocybin, data on enforcement, and barriers to the legal access and use of psilocybin for religious practices under the Religious Freedom Restoration Act of 1993. The report noted that numerous clinical studies are underway to investigate the benefits of synthetic psilocybin for depression, headaches, fibromyalgia, pain, substance use and eating disorders, obsessive-compulsive disorder, and post-traumatic stress disorder. The report suggested appropriate legislation to facilitate research. It noted that Expanded Access legislation is limited by requirements of review by the Food and Drug Administration and institutional review bords, and that Right to Try laws are not providing access to psilocybin, notwithstanding the breakthrough therapy designation granted to the Usona Institute’s clinical trials and those of Compass Pathways.</p><p>The report states that the Government Accountability Office intends to measure progress toward meeting its four recommendations including timeframes for determining religious exemption claims, communicating what types of information are considered, disclosing the standards and factors for decision, and implementing a process for providing updates on the review process. Each of the four recommendations is attached to a status tracker. “When we confirm what actions the agency has taken in response to this recommendation,” the Government Accountability Office says, “we will provide updated information.”</p><p>On April 22, 2024, the plaintiffs in <em>Church of the Eagle and the Condor v. Garland</em>, 2:22-cv-01004, (D. Ariz.), announced a settlement with federal defendants that recognizes their right to religious liberty that encompasses sacramental experience with ayahuasca, which contains dimethyltryptamine (DMT), a controlled substance. In <em>Church of the Holy Light of Queen v. Mukasey</em>, two ayahuasca churches that are American branches of successors of the <em>Santo Daime</em> religion, the oldest of the Brazilian ayahuasca religions, were granted a permanent injunction by the district court that allowed them to import and use ayahuasca. <em>Church of the Holy Light of the Queen v. Mukasey</em>, 615 F. Supp. 2d 1210, 1219 (D. Or. 2009), <em>vacated sub nom. Church of Holy Light of Queen v. Holder</em>, 443 F. App’x 302 (9th Cir. 2011) (to limit scope of injunction). The district court observed, “In Brazil, thousands of people consume hoasca or Daime tea several times each month. The government of Brazil would not allow the UDV and Santo Daime churches to operate if there was evidence that Daime tea or hoasca was killing church members.” <em>Id.</em> at 1218. The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals upheld the injunction insofar as it enjoined the government from prohibiting the importation, storage, and use of their sacrament.</p><p>In <em>Church of the Celestial Heart v. Garland</em>, 1:23-cv-00545, (E.D. Cal. January 9, 2024), the plaintiffs succeeded in convincing the court that Religious Freedom Restoration Act claims against federal government defendants do not require DEA administrative factfinding and adjudicatory functions, or create an implied exhaustion of administrative remedies for court review. That claim ultimately settled and provided protection to the participants of the church.</p><p>Going forward</p><p>Three varieties of recently identified psilocybin-containing mushrooms,<em> Psilocybe cyanescens</em>, <em>Psilocybe allenii,</em> and <em>Psilocybe ovoideocystidiata,</em> are proliferating and spreading from areas of the Pacific Northwest or the Ohio River Valley. The author of an April 2022 National Geographic article, Daniel Merino, writes that the three varieties are “in lockstep with human expansion,” offering companionship for life’s journey. The spores “colonize” in areas that have not been occupied by other fungi, carried by the wind and showing up in urban environments from human activity, growing, mainly in areas with large mulch beds and broken-down wood chips and open spaces. The earliest variety was found at the royal Kew Gardens in England in 1946, and has spread into Europe, South Africa, Australia, and New Zealand. One is described as a “synanthrope,” a living organism that thrives in places built by and for humans.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/781/1*PneVHviAu7edlB-E8pZpSQ.png" /></figure><p>Mushroom stones of the Highland Maya, from U.S. Forest Service website,<strong> </strong>photo by Richard Rose.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8b5a45f448ea" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Dr. Joe Tafur, A Physician’s Insight into Ayahuasca Healing and Traditional Amazon Plant Medicine]]></title>
            <link>https://ronmcnutt.medium.com/dr-joe-tafur-a-physicians-insight-into-ayahuasca-healing-and-traditional-amazon-plant-medicine-24a678d8d1b9?source=rss-368797e78488------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/24a678d8d1b9</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ronald W. McNutt]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 03 Jun 2025 01:35:51 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-06-04T00:11:18.933Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Dr. Joe Tafur, A Physician’s Insight into Ayahuasca Healing and Traditional Amazon Plant Medicine</p><p>Ronald W. McNutt June 2, 2025</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/956/1*_3hyyYLEwyI6ZDbk626mTQ.png" /></figure><p>Dr. Joe Tafur is a physician in family medicine licensed in California and Arizona. He is also a curandero or a spiritual healthcare provider of the traditional Amazonian plant medicine tradition of the Shipibo people. He is the author of the 2017 book, The Fellowship of the River, in which he describes how his medical career developed and was inspired by his experience with ayahuasca and traditional Amazonian plant medicine practices. Dr. Tafur studied plant medicine traditions deeply beginning in 2007 after his graduation from medical school.</p><p>Dr. Tafur and Ricardo Amaringo helped found Nihue Rao Centro Espiritual, near Iquitos in the jungle of the upper Amazon. The healing center is named for sacred trees whose name means medicine of the air or breath. Dr. Tafur spoke at the Science on Spiritual Health Symposium in April, 2025, at the Emory Center for Psychedelics and Spirituality, and in May for a book group I attend with the Sacred Garden Community. He shared many insights into spiritually-integrated healing with the spiritual, soul-healing benefits of ayahuasca. The way Dr. Tafur explains the intersection between traditional Amazonian plant medicine and Western medicine is very helpful and illuminating.</p><p>The fellowship experience he had in the Amazon showed how ayahuasca helps facilitate a mysterious healing process that is cathartic and part of emotional healing or soul healing. Dr. Tafur states, “Love is the acceptance of all things as they are, without reservation.” He says that ayahuasca brings about energy healing that can untangle energy blockages that are traumatic responses to childhood events and extreme or repetitive trauma. The medicine opens people to benevolent influences of a spiritual nature and heals with compassion and forgiveness. There is often the experience of a flood of forgiveness, self-compassion, gratitude, and an opportunity for meaning making and death transcendence. These experiences convey spiritual wellbeing and an outlook of renewal that can help regulate feelings, improve physiological processes, and provide good coping skills.</p><p>In <em>Church of the Eagle and Condor v. Garland</em>, 2:22-cv-01004<em> </em>(D. Ariz. April 22, 2024), a ceremonial circle Dr. Tafur co-founded, that practices worship with sacramental experience with ayahuasca, reached a settlement with the federal government. The Church of the Eagle and Condor formed in 2018 in Phoenix, Arizona, with leadership including Indigenous persons. The Church of the Eagle and Condor achieved religious freedom protection for their ceremonial practices with ayahuasca, which contains dimethyltryptamine (DMT), a controlled substance. In its proof and pleadings, the church argued that the beneficial medical effects of ayahuasca are spiritually oriented. Their April 22, 2024, settlement with federal defendants resulted from its lawsuit filed in 2021 after the government seized its sacramental ayahuasca.</p><p>Dr. Tafur describes in an understandable way how the healing of the emotional body within the Shipibo tradition is a way toward living in a sacred connection that experiences the beauty of one’s life. By enhancing spiritual wellbeing, the traditional Amazonian plant medicine can help bring emotional health which in turn improves physical health and resilience. He emphasized that these Indigenous traditions view health and spirituality as inseparable, and that the inner healing process involves restoring right relations with oneself, one’s intimate loved ones, and one’s community, society, ecosystem, the world, and nature. He states that each ceremony with ayahuasca is unique and benefits from the support of a healthy container to release healing energy and untangle blockages to the emotional body.</p><p>In his book, he quotes Ricardo Amaringo who advised that people should approach the experience with ayahuasca medicine with love and respect to gain more from it. The experience and its healing effects resist definition. Dr. Tafur explains that it provides an opening to a consciousness that is bigger than we had imagined, a relationship with a spiritual being that is transcendent. He recommends ayahuasca as an ongoing process, with multiple sessions that reveal more as part of awareness of insights for healing. Dr. Tafur said that the tradition wishes to remain as a spiritual experience and that Indigenous medicine guardians oppose the medicalization of ayahuasca.</p><p>Dr. Tafur finds a parallel between the emotional body that is the subject of healing in the ceremonial setting and the psychological, neurological, endocrine, and immunological network, related to the limbic system which regulates the autonomic nervous system that controls breathing, digestion, the vagus nerve, airways, and inflammation. He writes that the hypothalamic, pituitary, adrenal axis is a central component of emotional body, and that too much stress creates somatic responses and dysregulation. The emotional body can be affected by spiritual wounds and result in conditions like migraine headaches, asthma, allergic rhinitis, chronic cough, psoriasis, alcohol and drug addiction, and fibromyalgia. Emotionally derived energetic disturbances can be addressed in ayahuasca ceremonies by experiences of catharsis with the assistance of skilled facilitators.</p><p>Our cultural influences, the experiences of life, can benefit an individual, or lead to an allostatic load that affects one’s emotional and physical states. He explains that the allostatic load is the burden of accumulated stress in the body. Stress can lead to cortisol and adrenaline production and accumulations the body does to mediate stress and return to normal. Dr. Tafur writes that repetitive stress with cumulative stressors and extremely stressful events can generate physiological responses that do not subside and are spiritual wounds. Maladaptive stress is our body’s chronic response to harmful influences that compromise our sense of self-worth, such as violence, stressful relationships and social expectations, and things like experiencing rejection, inadequacy, and lack of engagement and failure to thrive.</p><p>The maladaptive programming can be relieved and there can be a healing of the emotional body. There are ways in addition to ayahuasca to relieve these blockages and heal. Such supportive techniques include meditation and yoga. He quotes Ricardo as saying that spiritual energy helps clear out accumulated pathological energies that accumulate as we age and harbor traumatic stress. He said that Ricardo could notice problem energies in people while under the influence of ayahuasca. Love can heal these energies.</p><p>Dr. Tafur acknowledges that ayahuasca is not for everyone, but that it can provide an ongoing process of spiritually-oriented healing. Ayahuasca can heal systemic disease, and he gives examples of people healing from chronic fatigue syndrome, psoriasis, addiction, Crohn’s disease, post-traumatic stress disorder, and related difficulties that appear in relationships. It can help provide meaning making which reframes negative experience and promotes healing with forgiveness, self-love, compassion, and gratitude. He has observed and helped facilitate individual emotional breakthroughs with ayahuasca medicine, which provide a sense of relief and can bring spiritual wellbeing, increase connections, and stimulate an inner healing intelligence.</p><p>Dr. Tafur’s family origin is from Colombia, and his grandfather was friends with Hernando Garcia, a botanist who studied traditional plant medicines in the Sibundoy Valley. From 2011 to 2017, he apprenticed within the Shipibo ayahuasca medicine tradition of Peru under Ricardo Amaringo, who joined the board of the church. This tradition employs ayahuasca ceremony as an essential sacrament to draw together heart and wisdom traditions and provide emotional healing and the universal element of spirituality. Dr. Rodney Garcia, an anesthesiologist with the Veterans Administration in New Mexico, is a co-founder of the church and serves on the board of directors with Belinda Eriacho, Dr. Tafur, and Kewal Wright. Dr. Tafur said that Ricardo Amaringo also serves on the board of the Church of the Eagle and Condor.</p><p>The Church of the Eagle and Condor accepts a lineage of teachers and maintains a broad set of ethics that promote the wellbeing of participants. The church presented appropriate factors for religious protection, respecting practices for health and safety to reduce risks and prevent diversion for inappropriate purposes, and by exhibiting sincerity. It has a communal tradition with recognition of an ancestral prayer of the Americas, a call of the Spirit, to bring about a beneficial re-encounter bridging countervailing influences. Its members adhere to a code of ethics. It promotes understanding of the purpose of worship among its members and encourages careful practices that are consistent with their shared beliefs.</p><p>Dr. Tafur said that the Shipibo cultural heritage has gained stature due to the American and European influence where people have been seeking out this tradition for healing and inspiration to live more fully engaged lives. He takes groups to the Nihue Rao center to participate in plant dietas and ayahuasca experience, and he actively participates in the church and its legally-authorized ayahuasca medicine experience in Arizona as well.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=24a678d8d1b9" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Christianity and Psychedelics, research and reflections by Ron McNutt, April 2025]]></title>
            <link>https://ronmcnutt.medium.com/christianity-and-psychedelics-research-and-reflections-by-ron-mcnutt-april-2025-3083f72fc5b2?source=rss-368797e78488------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/3083f72fc5b2</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ronald W. McNutt]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 29 Apr 2025 23:49:57 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-04-29T23:49:57.465Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*sr5teOMchBdcfWOMmVowOQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>Christianity and Psychedelics, research and reflections by Ron McNutt, April 2025</p><p>I put some research, thoughts, and memories together for a paper on psychedelics and Christianity. I thought it would be a good background for someone interested in the subject. Institutional Christianity was a source of persecution toward Indigenous cultures, but there are some interesting ways in which psychedelic healers incorporated aspects of the Spirit that the Christian institutions seem to have violated. I am hopeful that eventually, religious freedom protection will extend to the retreat settings that may include a wide range of outlooks and orienting systems, including Christians.</p><p>When psychedelics are part of a sincere and intentional practice, such as spiritual, ceremonial, or celebratory settings, in a manner that employs risk reduction practices, they can provide great benefits. They can help reduce ruminative, negative thinking, and help people shed layers of resistance and antipathy, and help people deepen soul connection by encounters with grief that enrich the soul and help restore full aliveness.</p><p>Jesus instructs people to hunger and thirst for righteousness and be blessed. By mutual goodwill and encouragement, people can join and be aligned with the primary teachings of Jesus, which are to forgive, to love one another and ourselves, to be generous, compassionate, honest, and humble, and to act from gratitude. Jesus spoke about the Holy Spirit being like the wind. We cannot see it but we may observe its influence. The word for breath, wind, and spirit is the same in Hebrew, <em>ruach</em>, and people of different cultures speak of life in the spirit, and finding a common understanding in relation to the spirit. In the Christian gospels, works of the Spirit play out among people who have gifts of the Spirit to bring them to being and action. Jesus spoke about bringing peace, showing love, and bearing fruits in the world. Our intentions matter very much for our souls.</p><p>Jesus instructs that as you sow, so shall you reap and we can change. He showed that forgiving others, releasing our holding onto one another’s faults, frees us with a sense of our own forgiveness. Forgiveness brings grace and forgiveness to ourselves. We can realize how beloved we all are in the unity of the Holy Spirit, and can disentangle ourselves from judgment and grievance. He taught that before offering prayers and sacrifices at the altar of the Temple we should first go and resolve our grievances and make peace with our siblings. He taught that God is compassionate, so we also should be compassionate.</p><p>People have had spontaneous mystical states of unity for centuries. These experiences of the sacred form the basis of religions, forms of practice that attempt to reach high and pull beauty down for their neighbors to share. These attempts are performed out of love. Ralph Waldo Emerson, a Transcendentalist writer and Universalist minister, wrote that, “God enters by a private door into every individual.” The door to God can be a way that is particular to its user, whose actions bear fruits that are translation of the sacred into forms. Some may follow a tradition of belief and ritual, others a system of traditions or images of the Beloved, and still others seek an original relation to the universe without formula, or find their own formula. If two people look at one thing they never have heard described before, they probably will perceive and report it differently. Yet religious images come through widely divergent cultures in similar patterns.</p><p>One way in which psychedelics can reveal a mystical awareness is the perception of how all reality is interwoven consciousness. The ancient Greek rites, the Eleusinian Mysteries, incorporated a vision that reinforced an appreciation of eternity. The contents were kept secret for over 1200 years and remain a mystery. The ritual pilgrimages of the ancient Greeks in Eleusis took place from 1600 B.C. to 392 C.E. They were part of an annual festival led by or hierophants or priests that celebrated the myth of Demeter and Persephone. The culmination of the Mystery was “an overwhelming vision of spiritual presences demonstrating the relationship of the living and the dead.”</p><p>The Eleusinian Mysteries employed a libation, known as the <em>kykeon</em>, that created profound visions and was associated with Persephone’s return from Hades, the cycle of seasons, and the continuity of life. The <em>Kykeon</em>, was guarded in secrecy, and the rituals were restricted to the once in a lifetime ceremony available as part of a pilgrimage restricted to individuals who had not committed a murder. There was absolute prohibition on revealing or profaning the sacrament, which research by Albert Hofmann, Carl Ruck, and R. Gordon Wasson have determined were quite possibly a substance containing lysergic acid amides derived from ergot.</p><p>Participants included Plato, Sophocles, Cicero, Pindar, and Marcus Aurelius. It was outlawed by Emperor Theodosius, a Roman institutional Christian. In The Road to Eleusis, Ruck, Hofmann, and Wasson showed how the <em>kykeon </em>may have been a water-soluble ergot of barley or Claviceps paspali, to produce a psychedelic effect without the poisonous alkaloids with blood clotting properties. Brian Muraresku has done some outstanding research, building on that of Carl Ruck and others. Part of the problem with proving the contents is that the vessels found at Eleusis were sealed in a solvent, so analysis is not feasible.</p><p>Unfortunately, the Christian teachings became part of a state religion that accepted violence and domination. Practices like the rites of Eleusis were supplanted with a hierarchical system of severe persecution by authorities who were suspicious of witchcraft beliefs and practices that were often spiritually-oriented ceremonies that would provide direct access to soul awareness.</p><p>Western and European society has had a traumatic relationship with psychedelic substances. The Inquisition stamped out the herbalist use of henbane, mandrake, and belladonna, in Europe, and by the 1600s, it was directing its energies to the Indigenous practices of New World inhabitants, who employed psychedelic plants and fungi to have experiences that they said showed them higher worlds, deepened their soul connections, and improved their health and vitality. European religions set about to eradicate long standing indigenous traditions using naturally-occurring plants and fungi as part of the traditions for acculturation, socialization, and initiation into the beliefs and priorities of their societies.</p><p>The Inquisition Disrupts Traditions Employing Plant Medicines and Psychedelic Mushrooms</p><p>Before the Europeans arrived, in many places throughout Central America, South America, and the Caribbean Islands, the major natural psychedelics, known as teonanacatl or psilocybin mushrooms, peyote or peyotl, ayahuasca, San Pedro or huachuma, ololiuqui, and yopo, were held in the highest esteem by the native peoples. Communities would engage with such psychedelic substances in ceremonial experiences that would be at the center of community life, and reinforce and strengthen their view of relations with nature and all life. Their experiences would reveal a spiritual presence and a sense of sacredness and understanding that spirit that animates all life. Indigenous were, who would approach them with reverence and sincerity and part of a disciplined practice.</p><p>The colonial powers persecuted the use of natural psychedelics in the Americas. When the Spanish early Spanish explorers encountered traditions and cultures that used psychedelic plants and fungi, they were bewildered, and associated them with biblical proscriptions against witchcraft. The severe repression of the Inquisition, motivated by self-righteous clerics and rigid institutions of government, resulted in the traditions being eliminated, retreating to remote areas, becoming obscured in secrecy to outsiders, or transforming in response to social pressure of influences including exploitations and opposition.</p><p>The earliest writings about the origins of the ceremonial use of ayahuasca are historical records of the Spanish Catholic Church, which were produced from a perspective that was hostile to practices of employing plant hallucinogens by a force of persecution and domination. Early explorers in South America found many Indian villages along the Amazon and other areas. In the 1600s and 1700s, Jesuits observed natives using ayahuasca in the Marañón River area. The Marañón runs northwest from a glacier high up in the Andes mountains through Peru along the eastern edge of the Andes. The Marañón turns east and flows into plains and meets the Ucayali River and together they form the Amazon River.</p><p>According to an article by Guerra in 1967, the Holy Inquisition of Mexico issued a proclamation in 1616 ordering the persecution and excommunication of those who, under the influence of, “herbs and roots with which they lose and confound their senses, and the illusions and fantastic representations they have, judge and proclaim afterwards as revelation, or true notice of things to come…” Having called for repression and death for those who claimed to experience revelations by using roots and herbs, the traditions practicing use of ayahuasca suffered and diminished because of contact with the European culture, and the persecution would be exacerbated further by colonialism and the forced labor of Indians by the British for rubber production. However, there was some interaction and contact generated by the Rubber Boom that did lead to spreading information about ayahuasca and its practice.</p><p>Teonanacatl</p><p>A tradition of using psilocybin mushrooms was established before the Spanish conquest. Mushroom stone sculptures in Guatemala, southern Mexico, and El Salvador date from around the year one thousand. They are often paired with animals associated with shamanism, revealing sacred associations. Ceramic figures with mushroom-like headdresses have been dated from 160 A.D. Ceremonial use and divination rituals with psilocybin mushrooms by Aztecs who called them God’s flesh or <em>teonanacatl</em>, was recorded in the 1500s by a court physician Francisco Hernandez, Bernardino Sahagun, a Franciscan friar, and another friar, Diego Duran. In 1629 a collection from Nahuatl, a region in Mexico and Central America, described a pattern of chanting by Indians that reappeared in the 1950s, in the Western Sierra Madre: professions of humility, claiming an ability to be able to talk to supernatural beings, and referencing a book of knowledge that was gifted from long before.</p><p>Cohoba</p><p>The New World had widespread use of an inhaled entheogen called cohoba powder, more recently called yopo, or Anadenanthera peregrina. Cohoba was a psychedelic snuff preparation used by indigenous cultures of Hispaniola, described in records after Columbus’s arrival from Spain. It is described by missionaries and explorers in 1560 and 1599 as being widely used among Central American people. The West Indian indigenous societies did not survive contact with the Spanish. The Western explorers of the New World regarded the hallucinogenic snuff as an instrument of the devil. The practice had largely retreated to remote areas.</p><p>In 1801, Alexander von Humboldt reported that cohoba powder was a part of ceremonial experience in the Orinoco River basin area of Colombia and Venezuela border was regarded as the center of its use, along with the area of northern Brazil. The eminent ethnobotanist Richard Spruce documented its use and collected samples of it along with snuffing tubes in 1851 that were recently identified. In the Orinoco region of western Brazil, and other areas, yopo use has continued among various indigenous groups to the present day.</p><p>Peyote</p><p>Peyote has been in use ceremonially for 5000 years. Articles in 2002 and 2005 describe how a team of scientists from Sweden and the Netherlands proved that Native Americans used peyote as long ago as 5700 years earlier. The scientists did a chemical analysis of two dried peyote buttons in the collection of the Witte Museum in San Antonio, which were thought to be from the Shumla Cave number five on the Rio Grande. Using radiocarbon dating and alkaloid analysis, their age was identified as being between 3780 to 3660 B.C. The analysis found alkaloids of mescaline. Some samples from an archeological site in Coahuila, Mexico showed peyote with radiocarbon testing dated to 810 to 1070 C.E., about 1000 years old.</p><p>For centuries the <em>Wixárika </em>people, who have been called the Huichol in Spanish, have lived harmoniously with the forces of nature in a sustainable way in the Sierra Madre Occidental, in northwestern Mexico. The Huichols practice the oldest current tradition of religious usage of peyote. Their practices include going from their various mountain villages on annual pilgrimages in groups to harvest peyote and visit their sacred ancestral land in semi-desert areas. Their harvest rituals include ceremonially hunting the peyote, calling it the little deer, and they offer prayers to it and thanks for its body and its spiritual essence.</p><p>Dr. Harvey Cox, a professor at the Harvard Divinity School, participated in the peyote ritual of the Huichol Indians around 1974. He said that the ritual involved purification, preparation, and prayer. For part of his journey, the leaders encouraged him to participate alone and to have his own visions. Because he had his own traditions, the leader did not feel capable of guiding him at that point. He felt that the fire was communing with him, and he felt a message from the morning star that it was mediating the energy of the universe to him. Dr. Cox reflected that he had become more receptive to other forms of religious experiences as a result, and that the range of possible experiences of the sacred had grown for him.</p><p>Huachuma or San Pedro</p><p>An ancient stone glyph, or stone relief, excavated at a temple in the northern highlands of Peru, from the Chavin culture, shows a spirt entity holding a stalk of the San Pedro cactus. It has serpentine hair and a serpent belt, fangs, and harpy eagle claws. It is the earliest depiction of a relationship with this mescaline-containing plant, and shows that San Pedro cactus was revered by South American cultures as early as 1300 B.C. It is a tall cactus that grows from sea level to altitudes of 3000 meters. Ceramics from later cultures of the area from 1000 B.C. to 700 B.C. and textiles hundreds of years old also show images of the cactus. Its use was widespread in the regions of the Andes mountains and it was in cultivation but encountered severe persecution after the Spanish conquest, beginning with a campaign to extirpate “idolatry” in the 1600s.</p><p>Ayahuasca</p><p>Ayahuasca is a classic hallucinogen from the Amazon, a mixture of Banisteriopsis caapi, a woody vine or liana also known as ayahuasca, and one of the most common admixtures, known as chacruna, or Psychotria viridis, Psychotria alba, called amaruca or samaruca, and chagropanga, or Diplopterys cabrerana, and Mimosa hostilis, and Mimosa tenuflora roots, as well as Arundo donax, Nile reed grass. The leaves of these shrubs and roots contain DMT. Sometimes, other admixtures are included, depending on the traditions. The brew is orally active because of the presence of a monoamine oxidase inhibitor, ayahuasca vines in the Americas. Syrian rue, Peganum harmala, was used in the Middle East area. It also prevents metabolizing the DMT, and this activates the tryptamines, which have a similar effect to psilocybin. It also limits the metabolism of serotonin. There is often a great degree of nausea from the harmine alkaloids. The accompanying visions can be very intense. Although it can be dangerous because of the reaction to other drugs, it is constitutionally protected as a religious practice under a 2006 Supreme Court case. There are many ayahuasca churches, especially in Brazil, and many indigenous or neo-shamanic retreats in Peru, Colombia, Ecuador, and elsewhere. There are retreat centers and underground medicine circles throughout the U.S.A.</p><p>Scientists have found the chemical components of ayahuasca in a cave in the Bolivian Andes 13,000 feet high, and recently showed they were in use around 1000 years ago. In an article published in <em>Science </em>magazine in May 2019, a team of scientists revealed the results of a chemical analysis from this archeological find from 2008. They were part of a group of medicine plants that were dated in a study by the tools for powdering and insufflating them. Dust and debris with harmine, dimethyltryptamine, along with cocaine and bufotenine. These are the essential ingredients of ayahuasca, ordinarily made with the plants, chacruna (Psychotria viridis) and ayahuasca (Banisteriopsis caapi) which would grow in the areas of the upper Amazon but the presence of bufotenine indicates that the powder included yopo seeds. These ingredients must have been highly valued because they had been carried far from where they would grow to a burial site location high up in the Andes.</p><p>One of the earliest sources documenting ayahuasca use is from Father José Chantre y Herrera, compiled from historical documents of the Jesuit missionaries in the Marañón River area of Peru from the time between 1637 and 1767. He included a clear description of an ayahuasca ritual using a liana, or woody vine, with other plants. He described how there would be a night-long divination ceremony held in a house suited to hold many people, with benches placed for the men on one side, and open space for the women on the other. The leader would be in the middle seated on a hammock with a platform beside him, and, Herrera stated, places beside it “an infernal beverage that they call ayahuasca, which is singularly efficient in depriving one of one’s senses.” He continued, “They make the concoction of lianas or bitter herbs, which, after a great deal of boiling, becomes very thick. Since it is so strong as to derange a person even in small quantities, the dose is minimal, and fits into two small receptacles. The sorcerer, each time he drinks, consumes very small amounts, and knows very well how many times he can drink the potion without losing his sanity in order to carry out the ceremony with due solemnity and direct the chorus, since everyone responds to his invocation of the devil.”</p><p>In the 1700s, Jesuit writers wrote about a vine called ayahuasca in a pejorative fashion. Pablo Maroni, a Jesuit missionary present in the Marañón River area in 1738 to 1740, wrote that some of the indigenous people used the juice of a Brugmansia, while others would use a liana, or woody vine, called ayahuasca, for divination. He said that these drinks were “very effective to deprive one of the senses, and even of life” when used in “overloaded” doses. He added, “This they also sometimes use to cure themselves of habitual diseases, mainly of headaches. Drink, then, because he who wishes to divine conducts certain ceremonies, and being deprived of his senses lays face down, to avoid being suffocated by the power of the herb, he is thus many hours and sometimes even two and three days, until the inebriation takes its course. After this, he reflects on what the imagination represented, who alone and at times must remain in a delirious state, and this he takes as fact and prophesies as an oracle.”</p><p>In 1768 Franz Xaver Veigl described ayahuasca use as a bitter vine used for “mystification and bewitchment” and that it caused the users to lose their minds. The location of the rituals was not specified. Some ethnobotanists believe that ayahuasca usage spread from the Tukano tribal region near the Colombian Amazon and spread along the Vaupés River, a tributary of the Rio Negro, which flows into the Amazon. Usage of ayahuasca apparently spread with the trade routes where Quechua language was used during the first rubber boom from 1879 to 1912, a time of mass movement, especially in the area of Brazil. Quechua is an ancient language that was used by the Incan empire, throughout the Andes. The word ayahuasca is Quechua language for “vine of the soul”, “vine of the dead”, or “vine of the ancestors.”</p><p>Richard Evans Schultes was an Episcopalian and an influential ethnobotanist who conducted extensive botanical exploration field work in the Colombian Amazon. wrote that yagé, another name ayahuasca, often with a different admixture, arose before history into the well of the world, to help people learn of the soul and bring back transformative information for use in this world and make things beautiful. With Albert Hofmann, Dr. Schultes helped discover how ayahuasca creates a potent effect by combining dimethyltryptamine with a mono amine oxidase inhibitor. They collaborated on books including Plants of the Gods (1979), which states in its introduction: “A few plants had inexplicable effects that transported the human mind to realms of ethereal wonder — in communication with the spirit world. It is little wonder that they have long played an important role in religious rites of early civilizations and are still venerated by people who remain part of ancient traditions.”</p><p>Traditions and adaptation</p><p>In many ways, the Indigenous traditions in the Americas can provide an appropriate context and example of the psychedelic experience for people descended from other traditions. A faith may evolve from experience with psychedelics that is the most inclusive and true to the visionary experience of the individual. Ideas from core shamanism, the paths of righteous conduct from Buddhism, Christianity, Islam, Hinduism, and Indigenous traditions are likely to evolve toward a more open and universal set of principles and guidelines. Environmental stewardship and trauma-informed understandings from psychotherapy and self-help traditions can be incorporated into orientation and integration sessions in group settings providing safe containers for celebratory and exploratory uses.</p><p>The late author, psychologist, and advocate for access to psychedelic plants, fungi, and compounds, Dr. Ralph Metzner, encouraged explorations and practice applying an explorer path of shamanism that respects harmony with nature. He states that major entheogens such as ayahuasca reveal to sincere and respectful seekers the interwovenness of beings and the sacred nature of life. Indigenous societies informed by ayahuasca often have an outlook of animism, an understanding that assumes the aliveness of living spirits occupying a symbolic universe. It is a reality in which the earth and the forces and beings all are alive in spiritual energy like a quantum field, all beings are sacred, and everything is related.</p><p>Some Indigenous Traditions of the New World and Their Influences</p><p>Plant medicine traditions stem from wisdom sources in the medicine traditions of the indigenous, such as traditions from the upper Amazon region going back at least 1000 years. Ayahuasca churches in Brazil have sources that include inspiration from Christian traditions, adapting in an organic way many other sources of influence and inspiration.</p><p>The founders of the two largest Brazilian ayahuasca religions had learned of ayahuasca when they had contact with indigenous people when they were rubber work. In the Brazilian Amazon, ayahuasca churches formed in the 1930s and 1940s. Raimundo Irineu Serra originated an ayahuasca religion with Christian influences called Santo Daime. Daniel Pereira de Matos formed the Barquinha ayahuasca religion which also has Christian orientation. Jose Gabriel de Costa formed the União do Vegetal religion in Brazil in the 1960s, which is a more independent ayahuasca religion and has branches in many countries, as does the Santo Daime ayahuasca church.</p><p>The <em>União do Vegetal </em>Ayahuasca church and Santo Daime and Barqhinho churches achieved legal protections in Brazil. In 1987, Brazil declared ayahuasca a legal substance when used within the context of religious practice, becoming the first country to allow psychedelic use by non-indigenous persons.</p><p>Healthy respect for ayahuasca, psilocybin, San Pedro and the other major psychedelic plant teachers hopefully will avoid the error of fundamentalism, which tends to limit the symbolic life of the superconscious into a rigid dogma. Instead, we embrace what Walt Whitman celebrated as the “chant of dilation” and a spirit of inclusivity. It is the widening of the embrace of spirit, which Jesus emphasized is God’s own way. It does not exclude repentant people but restores others and builds community through a redemptive merciful outlook like that of the loving father in the parable of the prodigal son. Loving kindness was a central emphasis in the teachings of the Buddha and appears at the basis of the major religions.</p><p>Quanah Parker, John Wilson, and the Origins of the Native American Church</p><p>Peyote is a spiritual medicine that brought healing and salvation to American Indians beginning in the late 1800s and is at the center of The Native American Church of North America. The ceremonies are specially called, usually on a Saturday from sunset to sunrise in a tepee or hogan. The ceremony can be called by a sponsor for an important occasion like a birth or an anniversary, or for holidays, but usually for healing. Ceremonies vary between tribes, but there is drumming with a water drum, a fire chief who brings water at midnight, and people offer songs and prayers of devotion and supplication seeking blessings from God. After taking peyote those assembled are led to the peyote road where visions pass between God and the participants. and having sustaining visions and love that draws the community together. People in the circle take turns offering four songs under the guidance of the roadman, a guide to encourage their minds to see the spirit and lead to sustaining visions and love that draws the community together.</p><p>Quanah Parker was the last chief of the Comanche, and he was a principal founder of the Native American Church. He had a dual heritage; his mother was white and became a member of the tribe when she was taken in as a young girl. Both his mother and his sister later were taken by soldiers, leading him to oppose settlers and he was a fierce warrior. In 1875, he led his tribe to Fort Sill after deciding further warfare would be futile. He took his mother’s last name and became a leader and a prosperous rancher and served as judge and sheriff on a reservation. He was opposed to peyote but in 1884, he was healed of a serious blood infection after being gored by a bull in Texas. He became deathly ill, and his aunt took him to a Mexican <em>curandera</em>, probably a Tarahumara, and he was healed with peyote tea. He became a road chief for peyote, bringing it to many tribes in the 1880s and later. He regarded peyote as a sacrament to be taken with water. He composed songs for singing in the ceremonies. During the informal period afterward, when people discuss their visions, he would counsel others and encourage them in the right path and strengthen their purpose. The goal is to study and learn something, perhaps to have a visit by the peyote bird or an eagle. Reverence in purpose is essential.</p><p>The Kiowa-Comanche ceremony is the prototype for peyote ceremonies of the plains Indians. The important elements of the ceremony include half-moon earth altar, songs of praise and devotion, the staff, the kettle water drum, the gourd rattle, the eagle wing bone whistle, and the prayers with tobacco. There are variations among the tribes. There is an emphasis on devotion. All talking stops when the ceremonial Father Peyote or Chief Peyote is put in place at the center of the crescent-shaped altar and the road man offers the first prayer. People sit upright and peyote is passed four times, in dried form or as powder, taken with water or peyote tea. Music becomes more spirited after midnight, when the fire chief brings water and after prayer everyone drinks; and the roadman goes outside and whistles to the four directions with the eagle wing whistle.</p><p>Peyote is regarded as a divine messenger and respected for its “medicine power.” In addition to its spiritual properties, peyote is an antibiotic and antiseptic. Ceremonies may center on native doctoring and purification, using sacred elements such as water, tobacco, sage, feathers and bird imagery, and fire. A typical first song in a ceremony will be this prayer, “May the gods bless me, help me, and give me power and understanding.”</p><p>State laws were enacted in many states in opposition to peyote rituals, many such laws were passed in the 1920s. In 1908, Quanah Parker testified before the Oklahoma legislature, a year after two Indians were prosecuted under an 1899 law against peyote, and the law was repealed. Chief Parker did not adopt Christianity and he was respected as a leader. He is quoted as saying, “We do not go into ceremony to talk about God. We go into ceremony to talk with God.”</p><p>The peyote religion among the American Indians was influenced by the mescal bean tradition and the Ghost Dance movement at a time when there was a cultural loss. It suffered persecution but it endured through the resolute purpose of its members in different tribes. Peyote use was observed by missionaries in Texas in 1760, who viewed use of peyote by the Indigenous as a problem, and it was common among Mexican tribes who viewed peyote as a divine being. After the Civil War, there was more contact between tribes between Mexico and the United States. Peyote use spread from the north of Mexico to Texas and the plains by the Kiowa and Comanche tribes after they visited Mexican tribes, the Carrizo, Tonkawa, Lipan, and Mescalero. They became the primary leaders of the spread of peyote through the plains along with the Caddo.</p><p>The Apaches of the Mescalero Indian Reservation used peyote in a shamanistic way in the time from just before their reservation was established in 1873 until about 1910. They spread the use of peyote, but their own society abandoned it, apparently because of an emphasis on individual spiritual powers and an adversarial approach to the practices, leading to rivalries and bloodshed.</p><p>When the Native American Church began forming in 1885, intertribal warfare was ending and there was more intermarriage, but the buffalo were eliminated by the white people, and it was after the Wounded Knee massacre when Indians being confined to reservations and experiencing a loss of their culture. The peyote religion helped develop inter-tribal cooperation and create a positive expression of identity, and it spread to the Cheyenne, Arapaho, Ute, Shoshone, Delaware, Sioux, and many other tribes. It is used as a religious sacrament by about forty tribes. Participants would sing songs and try to maintain beauty, hope, and goodness in their hearts.</p><p>In 1922, there were about 13,300 ceremonial peyote users. Members will seek to eat as many as 25 to 30 of so, maybe 20 buttons if they are green, although some members state they have eaten 50 or more peyote buttons in a ceremony. The medicine was inexpensive and $ 2.50 could buy 1000 peyote buttons in Laredo and Nuevo Laredo, Mexico at that time.</p><p>An anthropologist from the Smithsonian, James Mooney, who traveled to Indian Territory, present day Oklahoma, in 1891, was impressed with the tradition. He wrote favorably about the tradition and participated in its ceremonies. In 1918, he encouraged the leaders, called road men or road chiefs, to assemble and incorporate and write a charter. They told legends about peyote discovery by a woman who was in labor, lost in the desert, and hungry, and a voice told her to eat it, and she was relieved and gave birth.</p><p>John Wilson was initiated into the peyote religion in the 1880s and he became a roadman. He was part Caddo, part Delaware, and partly of Scottish descent. Before he turned forty, he had been a moderate drinker who participated in gambling and social dance. He had a background in the Ghost Dance movement in the Caddo Tribe. His Caddo name was <em>Nishkuntu</em> (Moon Head). He attended an Arapaho and Cheyenne Ghost Dance in 1890 that Sitting Bull presided over, where he had visions that led him to become a healer of diseases by revelations, drawing people from other tribes. He was introduced to peyote by a Comanche man at a ceremonial dance and he became converted. He was in seclusion with his wife outdoors for two or three weeks, staying by a stream, and taking about 15 peyote buttons at various times. Peyote took pity on him for his sincerity and humility, and he stayed attentive to its lessons. He received a revelation and was transported to the sky realm. He was shown celestial landmarks and scenes familiar to the Delaware Tribe, observed events in the life of Christ. He saw the empty grave of Christ and was shown the Road from the grave to the Moon in the Sky. Peyote directed him to walk this pathway and advance in greater knowledge through the use of peyote and faithfulness to its teachings, until at his death he would be present with peyote and Christ. He was shown how to conduct worship in peyote meetings, how to cure diseases and heal injuries, how to purge the body of the effects of sin, and how to lead Indians to the regions above heaven and to reach the presence of the creator and peyote. He learned about 200 songs.</p><p>Peyote also gave him instructions about construction of a new form of the moon altar in the peyote tent in the form of Christ’s grave. He taught worshipers to seek knowledge by direct communion. He taught that Indians could receive direct revelations from God through the peyote spirt. His ceremonies would include filing out of the tipi in the morning to meet the sun with raised arms and prayer. He traveled extensively and led ceremonies, particularly among the Osage and the Quapaw. He advocated clean living, honesty, restraint in sexual matters and fidelity in matrimony, as well as peaceful coexistence with the white people. He gave the following instructions to his nephew, George Anderson, on how to find the peyote way: “Keep your mind on peyote and don’t think anything about the people around you or anything outside. Look at peyote and the fire all the time and think of it. Sit quiet and do not move around or be uneasy. Then you will not get sick or see visions. Visions and nausea are signs of bad self-adjustment to the proper religious attitude.”</p><p>He was criticized when he received generous gifts from some of the wealthy tribes. In 1901, he died in an accident at a railway intersection at the age of 61, with many horses received as gifts and in the presence a Quapaw woman who was not his wife. Most tribes retained the traditional small moon altar of the Kiowa Comanche tradition. In 1993, when a leader of the Native American Church, Reuben Snake, died, there were an estimated 250,000 members. He had led a coalition of Indian groups that succeeded in advocating for national protection of the religion. Presently, peyote has become scarce, and groups such as the Native American Conservation Initiative are organized to establish habitat and protect the sacrament’s availability.</p><p>Maria Sabina and her Mazatec Mushroom Velada</p><p>Maria Sabina was born Maria Sabina Magdalena Garcia around 1894. She became a shaman or curandera when she was about forty. She had a hard life in a beautiful mountain area of Oaxaca, in the Sierra Mazateca of Mexico. She and her sister worked hard on a small farm with a few goats, doing chores such as tending chickens in the woods. There was no school available. Their father died when she was a few years old. She was always hungry and cold. When she was about six years old, a wise man came and cured her uncle using the sacred mushrooms in a traditional healing ceremony. Her people always spoke quietly and would use terms of respect to describe the sacred mushrooms, such as the little ones that leap forth or the saint children. Her father’s father and his father also had been wise ones, who could cure with mushrooms. She recognized the mushrooms from the woods and she and her sister ate them many times. Maria Sabina heard beautiful voices from another world giving beautiful advice and leading her to sing beautifully. One time, she had a vision of her father, who said to her, “Maria Sabina, get on your knees and pray.” She then spoke to God and became closer to God.</p><p>Before she became a wise woman, one who knows, she had suffered in two unhappy marriages. Maria Sabina had an arranged marriage and three children with her first husband but he left her and she was widowed after a six-year marriage. A few years later, she was required to intercede for her only sister who was having a health crisis with stomach pains and she could not get out of bed. She ate 30 pairs of the most potent variety of saint children and observed the ancient Mazatec vigil practices using candles of pure beeswax, flowers with scent and color, copal incense to bless the sacrament, and tobacco to put on the skin, and then proceeding in pure darkness. The spirit of the mushrooms guided her hands and her words, causing a large amount of blood to be expelled from her sister, and she stopped groaning and slept.</p><p>Their mother attended her sister, while Maria Sabina went off and she received a revelation vision of the Principal Ones she had learned about from her ancestors. Six or eight of the spiritual beings were before her at a table. The voice of the saint children told her these were the Principal Ones. One of them told her, “Maria Sabina, this is the Book of Wisdom. It is the Book of Language. Everything that is written in it is for you. The Book is yours, take it so that you can work.” She gladly accepted it and they left her. She contemplated it and she began to speak, realizing she was reading its contents. She realized that the gift had been bestowed upon her because she was pure, and that she had attained the wisdom beyond being an apprentice and had become a Wise One. She also received a visit from the Lord of the Mountains, Chicon Nindo, later that night because in her wise language she had called him. He rode up on a horse and she went outside. She then received a third revelation when a luminous vegetal being like a bush with flowers of colors with a halo and radiance, fresh and alive, appeared before fading into a splendid red background. She cried, whistled, clapped, and danced, realizing that she was now the Lord Clown Woman.</p><p>Maria Sabina continued working with wool and cotton, planted corn, beans and harvested coffee. She sold bread, candles, and pots, and she raised silkworms. She remarried after twelve years. Both times while she was married, she would not eat mushrooms because their tradition required four-day periods of celibacy before and after mushroom ceremonies, or veladas. After she was widowed for the second time, she dedicated herself to curing with the saint children. She would access the Book of Wisdom in her visions until she could access it from memory, using the language to heal, as a shaman mediating a world of heaven to this world, finding soul illnesses and curses and cures for various diseases. She would accept gifts but not charge for the medicine.</p><p>A 1957 Life Magazine article ran a momentous article that Gordon Wasson wrote after he and Allan Richardson, the photographer, participated in her veladas. A municipal sindico or magistrate, for whom Maria Sabina had provided counsel for his decisions for three years, had been approached by Mr. Wasson and had directed him to her. The world was amazed by the news of the tradition that she and her people had preserved and Maria Sabina had many people come to see her from around the world. Recordings of her chanting from 1957 were released on Folkways Records the following year.</p><p>Maria Sabina said that the saint children speak and she would have the power to translate. She was aware of the dark places where illnesses of the soul would lurk, but she would go upward to commune with the Principal Ones. She would see the saints appear in the ceremonies when she sang their names. In her chanting, she proclaimed, “I am the woman of the winds, of the water, of the paths, because I am known in heaven, because I am a doctor woman.” She would clap, whistle and chant with a beautiful sing-song cadence, proclaiming her purity of heart for the service of Christ and the saints, and becoming the voice of the divine mushrooms. She stated, “I know that God is formed by the saints. Just as we, together, form humanity, God is formed by all the saints.”</p><p>Maria Sabina said, “Nothing that the mushrooms show should be feared.” After effecting a cure with the language of the children, she would say something like, “the one who has healed your son is God who is raising all of us.” She shared from her life story in Alvara Estrada’s wonderful book, Maria Sabina, Her Life and Chants. This oral autobiography was translated and published in 1977. According to Estrada, she said she had respect for everything that has to do with God. Maria Sabina practiced Catholicism. She was active in a church group, Sisters of the Sacred Heart of Jesus, and she was good friends with the local priest. The local bishop, Father Antonio Reyes Hernandez, was supportive of her participation in the church. She said that she would commune with God by ceremonial experience with sacred mushrooms, and learn how to treat and address the problems of her clients.</p><p>A friend of mine has let me know of her experience: “I met Maria Sabina twice in her mountain village. Her village is well known for the beautiful embroidery the women make; beautiful bright flowers and birds. The people of her village loved her and resented the big researchers who came to visit, made lots of money from their publishing and she didn’t get a cent. The last time I was there someone had shown up with a film crew and all the men in the village surrounded her house and would not let them see her. It was powerful to feel their protection of her. She was poor as far as money goes. She gave me several beautiful huipils (embroidered tops she had made that I still wear!) and her house was very simple, earthy literally. She was a visionary and a dedicated healer, deeply committed to her inner life, a woman of integrity, also very practical. I assisted in a session she gave to a woman who visited her hoping for cure of cancer. Maria Sabina ate fresh picked mushrooms on a plate that was a tobacco leaf. In this case so did the woman. Then she sang and prayed all night. In the morning, she treated the woman according to her visions. In the session I was at she was assisted by her sister. I certainly received a big download from her but it was mostly energetic — an experiential blessing!”</p><p>Maria Sabina was happy to share the ceremony with the strangers in the 1950s and 1960s, but she regretted the way the notoriety affected her village and the careless use of the mushrooms by some of the hippies.</p><p>Maria Sabina had a movie made about her “Maria Sabina: Mujer Espiritu,” by Nicholas Echevarria. In 1979, Maria Sabina was sponsored by the Mexican government to attend the opening of the film in Mexico City, where the documentary opened, and the Mexican government hosted her stay in Mexico City. She was honored and went to the film’s opening, enjoying some recognition after her modest life and having faced criticism from some of her people for sharing the information and experience with sacred mushrooms. She was honored for her work and remained in Mexico City for over a month. The film emphasized that although she was almost 80 years old and had become very well known, she had not altered her way of life in the least.</p><p>Eugenia Pineda Casimiro, one of the grandmother healers of the Mazateco tradition, stated that her people have a reverence for the sacred nature of the divine mushrooms, and approach the experience with psychedelic mushrooms with devotion and awe. She said that everyone has a belief system that forms one’s identity. The experience helps people find the essence of spirituality, which is experienced sometimes as a metaphor. She attends church and said it is in Mazateco and has chants and nature elements that are harmonious in many ways. She said that by accepting their experience, which includes the Indigenous as well as Catholic traditions, they honor themselves as well as their ancestors. Their experiences help them learn not to be so judgmental of other peoples’ experience.</p><p>Mestre Irineu:</p><p>Raimundo Irineu Serra, Mestre Irineu, was born in 1892 and grew to be seven feet tall. He founded Santo Daime, an ayahuasca religion, in 1930 in Rio Branco. He had gone to the western part of Brazil from a poor area in northern Brazil in 1912 to work in rubber tapping, but that industry began to collapse. He was initiated into the mysteries of ayahuasca by indigenous shamans in the upper Amazon near the border with Bolivia. He had a series of visions and revelations that included a vision of the Divine Mother who identified herself as “the queen of the forest.” According to the Daime tradition, on a clear and beautiful night, Irineu took ayahuasca and, as he looked up at the moon, he saw a beautiful and wondrous lady. She asked him, “Who do you think I am?” Irineu was amazed as he looked at her and he replied: “My lady, you must be a Universal Goddess!”</p><p>The goddess gave him guidance and told him to observe practices, which he undertook and she gave him the blessings of healing power and instruction on making ayahuasca with chacruna and the vine. The queen of the forest also taught him how to sing and asked for beautiful songs of devotion to be sung to her and he identified her as the Virgin Mary. She revealed to him that ayahuasca was the sacred blood of Jesus Christ giving light, love and strength, and he called it <em>daime</em>, a variation of “give me” in Portuguese, with the sense of asking for love and light.</p><p>Mestre Irineu was inspired to form the religion Santo Daime, which combined the medicine practice with African, Christian, and folk traditions with teachings about reincarnation and karma and Christian theology. He was not able to read and write, and he was a Black man from a slave tradition. His healing ability and popularity allowed him to build a church and an agricultural community. His first adherents were migrants from the jungle who were displaced rubber tappers. When he first started holding ayahuasca ceremonies, he met opposition from authorities who misunderstood his practices, and thought it was witchcraft. Irineu served time in prison in the early 1940s. He moved around and settled his church in Rio Branco in Acre State near Peru. The church began to draw well-placed citizens and it exhibited self-discipline and devotion. Their goal was to model unconditional love of neighbor, show devotion to Jesus and the saints, and carefully protect the formula for the sacrament <em>daime</em>. The church has been very particular about preparing ayahuasca the traditional way, and psychotria viridis is referred to as Queen of the Forest.</p><p>The services offer hymns that came to Mestre Irineu — and his followers wrote them down. They open and close with Christian prayers there is an emphasis on preparation beforehand for appropriate dedication. There are 132 hymns to portray strength, harmony and love, which revealed the course of his spiritual path. The ceremonies are called <em>trabalhos</em> or “works” and are organized rituals of different kinds, some contemplative, called concentrations, sitting upright quietly. The “hymnals” or dance ceremonies, have worshippers sing and dance for up to twelve hours, as the hymns guide the journeys. Services are dedicated to healing and promote personal responsibility, a wholesome lifestyle, love of nature, humility, fraternity and purity of heart.</p><p>There is a leader or godfather and controllers, an altar or table with the cross and symbols, and all the practitioners wear white. The symbols in the altar include a six-point star, a double cross to symbolize the second coming of the Spirit. The church motto is harmony, love, truth and justice.</p><p>Mestre Ieineu referred to the work of the church, from the beginning with his vision, as “Juramidam,” or God and God’s soldiers. After Mestre Irineu died in 1971, different branches and communities formed. The original community continues to function in the same place, led by Irineu Serra’s widow, Madrinha Peregrina Gomes Serra: the Luz Universal Christian Light Center — Alto Santo. Around 1980, Sebastiao Mota de Melo (Padrinho Sebastiao) formed a church and community, the Raimundo Irineu Serra Eclectic Center of Fluid Universal Light and a community centered on Santo Daime, in Ceu do Mapio, Amazonas State. This is the branch of Santo Daime that has the most practitioners, up to 10,000, and helped to spread this type of ayahuasca church to many places around the world.</p><p>Mestre Gabriel:</p><p>Known as Mestre Gabriel, Jose Gabriel da Costa was the founder of Centro Espirita Beneficente União do Vegetal, the largest, most organized, and most recent of the three main ayahuasca churches in Brazil. <em>União do Vegetal</em> means “union of the plants” in Portuguese, and is a reference to the two plants they know as <em>mariri</em>, the vine, and <em>chacrona</em>, the leaf, which combine to give the medicine its powerful effect which. Mestre Gabriel first had ayahuasca on April 1, 1959 at the Guarapari rubber camp, on the border between Brazil and Boliva. He had gone from Bahia in northeastern Brazil to the area of the Amazon in 1943 for wartime efforts to produce rubber. He had traveled between Porto Velho and rural rubber camps in the 1950s, and discovered the mestizo Peruvian ayahuasquero tradition that incorporated an exchange between Indian vegetalista healers and influences from other cultures.</p><p>In the 2012 biography The Messenger of God, Ruy Fabiano writes that Mestre Gabriel was looking for a way to help humanity and take evil away from human hearts. When he first drank ayahuasca, it was served without ritual and he recognized the need for one to recognize its spirit. He got up from his hammock and said, “Look, Chico, this is something from God, something serious. You don’t know how to work, you mx a lot. Whoever gives this tea is responsible for the people.” He found that it produces a state of consciousness that can amplify one’s perception and help people recognize their essentially spiritual nature and promote their moral and intellectual capacities.</p><p>Mestre Gabriel’s experience evoked the ancient origins of Hoasca and renewed the ritual with spiritual revelations. He became dedicated to working exclusively with Vegetal. Drawing upon the spiritual foundations of his day, and his personal experience, he led a structured group in Porto Velho with ayahuasca worship. He incorporated names from Quecha language and aspects of healing with plants, including nine other healing plants that he used initially. He had been steeped in his mother’s lay leadership in Catholicism and the Umbanda tradition, of southeastern Brazil, an African-Brazilian religion that he had actively practiced before. He developed devotional songs and practices. His vision drew on deeper mysteries that he felt had been lost and rediscovered. He taught that it had been a known sacrament from the time of King Solomon and reappeared during the Incan civilization, and that he had been involved with the medicine in previous incarnations. <em>União do Vegetal </em>also drew on a Kardecist spritism tradition that held that spirits of the dead, and psychic and magnetic forces, would intervene in the events on earth, and had teachings about reincarnation. He was guided by an Indian sprit, Sultan of the Forest, with knowledge of the medicines and secrets of the jungle.</p><p>Sandra Goulart, who conducted fieldwork and studied<em> União do Vegetal </em>wrote that one tradition that it holds is that twelve masters of curiosity, who preserved the tradition of ayahuasca, recognized him as having authority and complete knowledge to complete the elements of this lost tradition, blessing his efforts to reestablish it.</p><p>He founded the church on July 22, 1961, near Rondonia in the Amazonian state of Acre, Brazil, and moved it to Porto Velho in 1965, and is now centered at the capitol of Brasilia, with centers throughout the world. His purpose was “to heighten spiritual understanding and perception and bring practitioners closer to God.” He served without compensation, and earned income at various times working as a rubber worker, a bricklayer, and as a nurse.</p><p>The church celebrates with the sacrament of Hoasca Tea or Vegetal, with a goal to promote reverence for the medicine and its messages, and transparency among its members. Its practices involve simple dress, with green, a five-pointed star, seated ceremonies when everyone drinks at the same time, and last about four hours. Members will ordinarily drink medicine one or two times per month. Services and teachings are in Portuguese, and there is a is a council of mesters.</p><p>Mestre Gabriel sought to include the poor, the simple folk, and excluded people in the church. The church’s story is set forth in The History of Hoasca, which states that the Mariri vine and the Chacrona leaf encompass elements of the life of Christ. Mestre Gabriel is identified as the reincarnation of the first person ever to drink Vegetal on earth, and was a vassal of King Solomon, and remembered his mission, and was among the people who had been transformed to plants. He serves as a model of virtues such as generosity and devotion. The tea is regarded as providing spiritual healing, as opposed to physical healing. The church has a medical scientific department with health professionals. Its teachings do not accept the curandeirismo or folk healing traditions, and they believe those traditions had forgotten the original spiritual knowledge and proper context for taking Vegetal. Members will wear common clothing often with green and will typically drink Hoasca tea two times per month, and they all take it together at the signal of the mestre of their center. The church has many charitable activities such as literacy projects, clothing and book drives, sustainable agriculture projects, and a large preserve of 20,000 acres in Amazonas.</p><p>Some Influences from Psychedelic Experience and Christianity</p><p>Western proponents of psychedelics within the Christian tradition:</p><p>Huston Smith:</p><p>Huston Smith was a foremost scholar of mysticism and world religions and a leading figure in the psychedelic era. His writings about entheogens were collected from over the decades and published with funding by the Council on Spiritual Practices in a book titled <em>Cleansing the Doors of Perception — The Religious Significance of Entheogenic Plants and Chemicals</em>. He wrote that entheogens “have light to throw on the history of religion…and the religious life itself.”</p><p>He is best known for the 1958 book, which he expanded in 1991 and titled <em>The World’s Religions</em>.<em> </em>He was in a five-part television series with Bill Moyers in 1996. He taught the many religions reach toward the indescribable Absolute and help people bear fruit in the world and try to “turn our flashes of insight into abiding light.” He wrote that, “If we take the world’s enduring religions at their best, we discover the distilled wisdom of the human race.” He advocated for greater mutual appreciation, stating that, “If, then, we are to be true to our own faith, we must attend to others when they speak, as deeply and as alertly as we hope they will attend to us.”</p><p>He grew up in rural China where his parents were Protestant missionaries, and he saw poverty, illness, and death, as well as many diverse religions in practice around him. He had decided to teach about religion, and his focus turned toward mysticism, and away from scientific rationalism, as he was completing his Ph. D. when he read a book by Gerald Heard, <em>Pain, Sex and Time</em>. He met Mr. Heard, who encouraged him to meet Aldous Huxley in 1947. His meeting with Aldous Huxley led Dr. Smith to become active in The Vedanta Society of St. Louis, when he was teaching at Washington University and serving as an associate minister in a Methodist church. He began a lifelong practice of meditation.</p><p>Years later, after he had joined the faculty at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Dr. Smith and others invited Aldous Huxley to be a visiting lecturer there and conduct a lecture series in the fall of 1960 that was enormously popular. Mr. Huxley had written about visionary and mystical experiences with mescaline in <em>The Doors of Perception</em> and <em>Heaven and Hell</em>, titles drawn from the mystical poet William Blake. Prof. Smith confided to him that he had not had a genuine mystical experience, and this led Mr. Huxley to give him the telephone number of Timothy Leary, who was beginning a three-year appointment at Harvard University as a research professor for the study of personality. Dr. Leary had experienced a profound mystical experience in Mexico with psilocybin before arriving at The Center for Personality Research at Harvard, and he had decided to focus his research on psychedelics. He would lead The Harvard Psilocybin Project and begin conducting scientific studies to measure the benefits of entheogen-assisted psychotherapy with prison recidivism, alcoholism, and with personality disorders.</p><p>When they met, they arranged for Prof. Smith to have a professionally supervised session with mescaline on New Year’s Day in 1961 in Dr. Leary’s living room in Newton, Massachusetts. In a 1964 <em>Journal of Philosophy</em> essay, he wrote that he had a full range of impressions with beatific visions as well as fearful aspects to his experience. He found bands of consciousness, each one real, in layers with unclear boundaries, emanating both the eternal and momentary. A group met every month or so for three years for group psychedelic sessions with meetings using incense, candles, with readings from poetry or spiritual writings, or spontaneous observations. They also would meet socially for discussions and sharing experiences.</p><p>He was a designated guide for the research as well, participating in the Good Friday experiment in 1962, led by Walter Pahnke, with twenty divinity school students and ten supervising volunteers, in groups with four students and two guides, and half would be given psilocybin while the others got a control of nicotinic acid. He was one who had an experience with psilocybin and he said it was his first ever direct personal encounter with God when he was transported by a woman singing a hymn. He felt God’s love in a personal way and said he became a more considerate and positive person for many months. The study found a high incidence of mystical experiences among the active group. They all assembled listening below, in a basement chapel, to the two-and one-half hour Good Friday service. Years later in 1996, Prof. Smith revealed that one of the students who had had psilocybin thought he had to go out and proclaim a new messianic era, and he was able to escape, and Prof. Smith quickly sprang to follow him and got other helpers to follow him into the Boston area, and he was returned, and was the only person in his research who had to be administered Thorazine as an antidote to the effects.</p><p>His friends from the project and he began publication of <em>The Psychedelic Review</em>,<em> </em>which was in publication for ten years. Prof. Smith came to agree with Aldous Huxley that psychedelic experiences closely corresponded with spontaneous mystical experiences in the world religions, like near-death or sudden feelings of belonging. He cited studies showing one-quarter to one-third of ordinary population and three-quarters of people with a religious inclination would have mystical experiences with psychedelic-assisted therapy. When he shared the view that research showed that psychedelics were effective in bringing about an authentic religious experience, he had to consider and respond to the criticism of religious skeptics and traditionalists.</p><p>Huston Smith thought the best factors for measuring the validity of the entheogenic mystical experiences was how they affected the people. He argued that experiences should be joined with actions, such as better relations, more patience and equanimity, positive experiences, and morality, or altruistic responsibility. He disapproved of Dr. Leary’s departure from the therapist and researcher roles and becoming a public figure leading people to leave education and careers behind, and he did not view this counterculture movement as having staying power. He preferred the cautious and studied approach of his friends Aldous Huxley, Gerald Heard, Gordon Wasson and Albert Hofmann. He thought the tenets of the world religions all counseled in favor of positive activity to promote universal compassion. He cherished his heritage and others that recognize that we “are in caring hands and that in gratitude for that fact we should try to bear one another’s burdens.”</p><p>In his later career, he firmly decided not to take any more entheogens, but he carried forward their lessons of gratitude for this great gift of love in his thoughts and actions. He was dedicated to the Civil Rights Movement, he helped introduce the Dalai Lama to Americans, and he worked to promote understanding of Islam when people who purported to be Muslims engaged in destruction on 9/11. His career was long and full, and he shared the unifying vision of an omnipotent, caring, healing God through his work.</p><p>Stanislav Grof:</p><p>Stanislav Grof, M.D., is a psychiatrist and perhaps is the world’s most experienced authority on psychedelic-assisted psychotherapy. His career included supervising over 3000 sessions with patients using psychedelics. The vast amount of research on higher states of consciousness that the did during more than fifty years in Prague, Czech Republic, and in the United States, led him to become one of the principal developers the field of transpersonal psychology, the understanding that consciousness is not contained exclusively within the body.</p><p>Dr. Grof found that in the early stages of psychedelic-assisted therapy that everyone would have personal experiences of sensing and memory. In the later stages, however, something universal about the human experience confronting death would be revealed. Virtually all the subjects in the intense form of psychedelic therapy experienced death and rebirth in some form. He found that the psychedelic experience moves one toward wholeness and provides opportunities to experience and transcend death. People would see beyond this lifetime to an understanding about the soul journey that would be liberating and healing. Becoming convinced that death is followed by rebirth, and having other experiences in the transpersonal realm, brought an enormous potential to heal human anxiety, spur inner transformation, relieve people of a sense of isolation, and connect them with the collective psyche of humanity.</p><p>Dr. Grof founded the International Transpersonal Association and he is a proponent of the benefits of inner transformation that come from the human encounter with death.</p><p>Dr. Grof found that people’s initial experiences with psychedelic-assisted therapy were extremely unpredictable, with personal experiences on a sensory, emotional level and processing memories.</p><p>Aldous Huxley, Humphry Osmond, and Al Hubbard:</p><p>Aldous Huxley was a philosopher, a writer, a jazz pianist, and a mystic. His writings included science fiction, screen plays, social commentary, children’s books, and some of the seminal writings of the Psychedelic Movement. He was intrigued by the research of Dr. Humphry Osmond and Dr. John Smythies who were conducting clinical experiments using mescaline and LSD in Saskatchewan to learn more about the mind and mental illness. He sent them a copy of one of his books and an invitation to visit him, expressing his interest in the phenomena of hallucinations and mental illness, and stating an interest in taking mescaline.</p><p>In 1953, Dr. Humphry Osmond conducted successful research with psychedelics, first with mescaline and then with LSD, treating people with alcoholism in Saskatchewan. He invented the word psychedelic and helped edit one of the major books about psychedelics. In 1955, the American Psychiatric Association had a symposium on psychedelics. Aldous Huxley addressed that conference, and a book edited by Louis Cholden, LSD and Mescaline in Experimental Psychiatry, was released based upon papers presented at the conference. By the mid-1960s, there had been over one thousand publications presenting encouraging results of well-funded studies with able staff, with about 40,000 participants in LSD therapy. It was the subject of six international conferences. In the late 1950s and early 1960s, researchers like Al Hubbard, psychiatrists Sidney Cohen, Oscar Janigar, A. Wesley Mitford, and Arthur Chandler, who formed the Beverly Hills Psychiatric Institute with radiologist Mortimer Hartman (who was the LSD therapist of actor Cary Grant and many others), were active in the field of psychedelic research or therapy.</p><p>Dr. Osmond went to Los Angeles for a psychiatric convention and on May 4, 1953, he supervised Mr. Huxley’s experience with mescaline and had him write about his impressions. In his 1954 book about this experience, The Doors of Perception, he wrote that after one and one-half hours he felt as though he had passed through a screen and saw “what Adam had seen on the morning of creation.” Everything was shining with its own inner light, charged with significance, like pure Being, the source of existence. It was “the miracle, moment by moment, of naked existence.” Mr. Huxley wrote that he witnessed “eternity in a flower, infinity in four chair legs, and the Absolute in the folds of a pair of flannel trousers.” He wrote, “The Mind at Large seeps past the no longer watertight valve,” opening up a field of thoughts and impressions. He repeatedly said, “This is how everyone ought to see.”</p><p>Aldous Huxley had been fascinated by inner experience and the realities that lie beyond the senses. At age 16, after his mother’s death, an illness left him almost completely blind for a year and a half. This prevented him from being in World War I and left him with diminished vision. He would use a small telescope and magnifying glass throughout his life. Mr. Huxley had written the successful novel Brave New World in 1932, expressing concern about how authoritarian government could manipulate people with technology and automation, or use subliminal messages to appeal to emotions to overtake their humanity. He moved with his wife Maria to Los Angeles, near Hollywood, in 1937. He wrote successful screenplays for the movies “Madam Curie,” and “Pride and Prejudice.”</p><p>He and his British friend Gerald Heard, an author and teacher of science, religion, and philosophy, pursued a common interest in access to the unconscious and the evolution of consciousness, and universalism, the belief that one common truth underlies the differences in religion. He studied Vedanta, the unitary vision in Hinduism. Mr. Huxley wrote about mysticism in religious traditions in his 1945 work, The Perennial Philosophy. He made friends with Jiddu Krishnamurti. He and Maria would have Tuesday evening study groups to discuss meditation, hypnosis, extrasensory perception, and similar topics.</p><p>In 1954, he lectured on “The Far Continents of the Mind,” at the International Conferences of Parapsychological Studies and a couple of years later, he was invited to lecture at the American Psychoanalytic Association convention. In 1955, he helped Maria navigate her transition from life using insight from the Tibetan Book of the Dead. His second essay about a mescaline trip, Heaven and Hell, was released in 1956. He argued that the experiences were not “mere chemical religion,” but like the physiological effects of prolonged fasting like people in medieval times would experience, or self-flagellation or prolonged chanting or meditation. His work brought him to the forefront of a spiritual and scientific movement fascinated by consciousness. The word “psychedelic,” meaning manifesting the mind, was created by his friend, Dr. Osmond, in correspondence with him as they explored new terms for hallucinogen or psychotomimetic in March 1957.</p><p>“Captain” Al Hubbard, known as the Johnny Appleseed of LSD, was a fervent Catholic. He apparently had friends in government. At a time when scientists in lab coats were providing psychedelics in sterile environments and creating the expectation of psychosis, his contribution was the specially-designed psychedelic therapy session room called the Hubbard room. It provided stereo music, spiritual images, a small altar, and burning candles, usually with himself as a guide. He developed and promoted a method to induce transcendental experience in a large percentage of participants, and shared his knowledge throughout the world. He taught the importance of set and setting, about subtleties such as which music is best to use, and how facilitators should behave to lead people to the Beatific Vision.</p><p>Al Hubbard embodied the spirit of curiosity that characterized the early psychedelic research and he is one of the most inscrutable personalities of that era. He was known as the Johnny Appleseed of LSD. By 1959, he stated that he had led 1700 LSD sessions and he had contributed to an LSD therapy manual that came into use that year. In 1957, Vancouver’s Cathedral of the Holy Rosary released an announcement stating that it would approach the study of psychedelics and their influence on the mind, with an approach anxious to discover whatever attributes they possess, respectfully evaluating their place in the Divine Economy and calling for their use to know and understand creation and benefit humanity.</p><p>The late 1950s and early 1960s were a time when people like friend Al Hubbard, and psychiatrists Sidney Cohen, Oscar Janigar, A. Wesley Mitford, and Arthur Chandler, who formed the Beverly Hills Psychiatric Institute with radiologist Mortimer Hartman (who was the LSD therapist of actor Cary Grant and many others), were active in the field of psychedelic research or therapy. He had a full mystical experience on LSD with psychedelic assisted therapy in 1960, and he distinguished visionary experiences from full unitary mystical awakening. His friend Huston Smith, a scholar of comparative religion who was teaching comparative religion at MIT, invited Mr. Huxley to lecture at MIT. In the fall of 1960, he gave a series of lectures that fall, “What a Piece of Work is Man,” which were enormously popular. He met Dr. Timothy Leary, who attended his lecture on November 8, 1960, and later he had psilocybin at his house. He appreciated Dr. Leary’s enthusiasm and his connections and his theoretical orientation, and shared his goal to enlist luminaries from philosophy, literature, art and science to have mystical experiences with psychedelics, but he became concerned that he created trouble and scorned accepted scientific models in his research.</p><p>In 1961, he rescued his manuscript for his final novel, Island, from a fire that destroyed the home he and his second wife, Laura, had near Hollywood. It depicted a society that balanced body and mind and employed a mystical sacrament, moksha medicine, from the Sanskrit word for liberation. It revealed truth and beatific glimpses of enlightening and liberating grace and another world, and helped sustain a utopian society. It would be taken for initiation into society and every year or so to help people realize their potential. People were told, “You will know what it’s like to be what in fact you always have been. It remains for you to decide whether you’ll cooperate with grace and take those opportunities.”</p><p>He died on November 22, 1963, the day that John Kennedy was assassinated, after receiving requesting administrations of LSD to help with his transition. The third issue of Psychedelic Review in 1964 was a memorial about him. One of his interviews was published in November 1963 interview, in Playboy Magazine, called “The Pros and Cons: History and Future Possibilities of Vision-Inducing Psychochemicals, A Philosopher’s Visionary Prediction.”</p><p>In her book <em>This Timeless Moment: A Personal View of Aldous Huxley</em>, Laura Huxley described how the author, at the end of his life, requested an administration of LSD for this soul journey. She had him tell her whom he wanted to join him in taking that medicine, and then she imparted to him the advice we all would be well to heed. She felt the relief that he had accepted his death and she repeated to him, “light and free. Light and free you let go, darling; forward and up. You are going forward and up; you are going toward the light. Willingly and consciously you are going, willingly and consciously, and you are doing this beautifully — you are going toward the light — you are going toward a greater love — you are going forward and up. You are going toward Maria’s love with my love. You are going toward a greater love than you have ever known. You are going toward the best, the greatest love, and it is easy, it is so easy, and you are doing it beautifully.”</p><p>They waited in silence for hours. She had administered a second 100 microgram dosage when the first had not had much effect. When it came near the time, Laura Huxley continued: “It is easy, and you are doing this beautifully and consciously, in full awareness, in full awareness, darling and you are going toward the light.” She repeated this the last three or four hours. Then she said, “Easy, easy, and you are doing this willingly and consciously and beautifully — going forward and up, light and free, forward and up toward the light, into the light, into complete light.” He gently slipped away afterward, embracing the light we all hope to share when we take off the tight shoe of this life, and go toward a greater love than we have ever known.</p><p>Alan Watts:</p><p>In 1968, Alan Watts, a philosopher of religion, wrote an article, “Psychedelics and Religious Experience,” for the California Law Review, stating that psychedelics can facilitate genuine religious experience and should not be prohibited by law. He was a gifted speaker, teacher and writer who embraced a unitary vision of the universe. He wrote about twenty books, including his 1962 book The Joyous Cosmology: Adventures in the Chemistry of Consciousness, revealing his experiences with three consciousness-expanding psychedelics: LSD, mescaline, and psilocybin. He praised their ability to bring about religious experience and insights that facilitate personal transformation “when accompanied with sustained philosophical reflection by a person who is in search, not of kicks, but of understanding.”</p><p>At a young age, Alan Watts embraced Buddhist teachings when his father began taking him to the Buddhist Lodge in London. He came to America in 1938 at the age of 23 and continued studying Zen Buddhism, which teaches a path to enlightenment by work to eliminate selfish craving and practice mindfulness and inward contemplation. Then, he studied Christianity, becoming an Episcopal priest from 1944 to 1950, and served as chaplain at Northwestern University. He wrote Behold the Spirit in 1947, describing a mystical approach to Christianity that revealed the “gold within the sectarian dross of every great religion.” He urged a mystical understanding of the statements of Jesus as being unified with God, and Paul’s statement of being alive in the Holy Spirit. Instead of a cosmology regarding God as a king, he advocated an awareness of a unified field with awareness everywhere and encouraged spiritual practices seeking self-realized awakening of compassion.</p><p>In 1959, he had LSD at U.C.L.A. Medical School, and later that year at a clinic in San Francisco, an experience he described as a profound experience deeper than any of his previous naturally-occurring experiences. He described psychedelics as “instruments, like microscopes, and telephones,” and urged people to apply the lessons and work with what they had seen. An influential research book from 1966, The Varieties of Psychedelic Experience, by Masters and Houston, identified four levels of experience in their research with peyote and LSD: sensory, recollective-analytic, symbolic and integral. They included a record from Alan Watts about a psychedelic mystical experience at the highest level. After various impressions his mind opens and he describes a great release: “I feel, with a peace so deep that it sings to be shared with all the world, that at last I belong, that I have returned to the home beyond home…The sure foundation upon which I had sought to stand has turned out to be the center from which I seek.”</p><p>Mr. Watts gave lectures on Zen and eastern religion in San Francisco, including a notable one at the Avalon Ballroom in 1967. His book titled The Book: On the Taboo Against Knowing Who You Are came out in 1966, as did an influential article in The Oracle. His popular radio show and writings inspired individual and societal liberation with accessible discussions of Buddhist and ecological ideas. He was friends with beat poet Gary Snyder, and inspired Jack Kerouac, an author of the Beat generation, who included him as a character in two of his novels. He offered a view of non-dualistic spirituality that awakened the imagination of the Beat generation and, later, the counter-culture of the 1960s.</p><p>Alan Watts became fascinated by parallels between mystical experience and insights from physics about energy and matter. He served as the president of the Society of Comparative Philosophy. He spoke at Esalen Institute and at colleges and in seminars and entertained friends on his ferryboat, many of whom were artists in the Druid Heights artist community. He moved to a cabin around Mount Tamalpais in the late 1960s and wrote mountain journals and continued to tour until he died in 1973 at the age of 58.</p><p>Mr. Watts argued that psychedelics should be legal because they reveal hidden truths and can lead to transformation of consciousness with greater compassion and interest in ecology and sustainability. They deepen the significance of the present moment in life, reveal how differences become parts of each other in a unified field of an eternal energy, and reveal a sense of connectivity in which all forms of life are a variation on the same theme. He recognized that the experiences can bring about anxiety, when people are lost in the corridors of the mind or experience shifting conceptions of reality, and can lead to conflict with a society not ready for challenges to authority and a patriarchal image of God. He stated: “Lack of awareness of the basic unity of organism and environment is a serious and dangerous hallucination” that leads to alienation from nature and hostility to others.</p><p>Alan Watts had a mystical experience on psychedelics in 1962. He described his impressions of a church chorus, how a priest chanting a mass with a chorus of nuns seemed to represent the depth of the history of the church, then seeming to be artificial, but this gave way to ancestral struggle in which the nuns seem to overpower the priest. The ancestral symbolism of survival then becomes a deeper experience.</p><p>Walter Pahnke, Bill Richards, and the Good Friday Experiment:</p><p>William A. Richards, Ph.D., is a clinical psychologist who was at the forefront of the original entheogen studies in the mid-1960s and is again one of the leading psychotherapists during the psychedelic renaissance. Dr. Richards earned two degrees from divinity schools and a Ph.D. in education and counseling. In his 2016 book, Sacred Knowledge, Psychedelics and Religious Experiences, Dr. Richards, wrote about his religious experience during his first session with synthetic psilocybin. It was on December 4, 1963, part of a program intended to shed light on schizophrenia, headed by the psychiatrist Hanscarl Leuner, in Germany. Amazing undulating designs, a field of flowing energy filled with multidimensional symbolism, gave way to a full mystical experience outside of time, flooding him with awe, glory, and gratitude. He realized that he was incapable of describing what had happened to him, after the summation of his revelation, “Reality is. It is perhaps not important what one thinks about it!” did not convey its power. He found, however, that the memory remained vividly accessible and it was a “pivotal fulcrum that provided clarity and direction” as his path unfolded.</p><p>Walter Pahnke was a Ph.D. student at Harvard University when he conducted the Good Friday experiment on April 20, 1962. It was the most significant study of the Harvard Psilocybin Project. For years was the leading experiment showing that psilocybin can facilitate experiences of mysticism in people disposed toward spirituality when used in a conducive setting. The project was carefully designed to provide supportive conditions to induce a profound experience which could be measured by psychometric assessments. It was the basis for the Ph.D. thesis for his program in religion and society.</p><p>The volunteers for the experiment were twenty divinity school students from Andover-Newton Theological Seminary, and ten leaders who were professors or graduate students with psychedelic experience. Dr. Leary had insisted that half of the leaders also receive the psilocybin. No one knew who would receive the psilocybin, which was a 30 mg. dose for participants and a 15 mg. dose for the leaders, and who received an identically appearing control of nicotinic acid.</p><p>To prepare, the participants had a physical examination and filled out a questionnaire that gathered information about their personalities and prior religious experiences to match them in five groups of four participants and two leaders. They were matched to promote friendship and trust. They listened below Marsh Chapel at Boston University to a two-and-one-half hour service with music, prayers, and a sermon by Rev. Howard Thurman. The experiment found a very high correlation for the participants who took psilocybin and profound healing mystical experiences. The experiment employed a questionnaire which Dr. Pahnke prepared to measure the experience, adopting categories identified by the work of W.T. Stace as representing the characteristics of fundamental, universal mystical experiences., with responses showing the active participants responded that they experienced: (1) sense of unity or oneness; (2) transcendence of space and time; (3) deeply felt positive mood, blessedness, peace; (4) sense of sacredness; (5) objectivity, reality, and intuitive knowledge; (6) paradoxicality; and (7) alleged ineffability, which both refer to the difficulty of grasping the experience by language and logical thinking; (8) transiency; and (9) persisting positive changes in attitude and behavior.</p><p>Dr. Pahnke’s 1966 article about the Good Friday experiment was published in 1970 in the Aaronson and Osmond publication <em>Psychedelics</em>. He stated that psychedelics help facilitate experiences of mysticism, and that researchers identified similarities in descriptive language of the experimental subjects to the descriptions found in the descriptions of people having spontaneous mystical experiences.</p><p>Dr. Pahnke worked together with Dr. Bill Richards in psychedelic-assisted therapy, beginning with a psilocybin assisted therapy research project in Boston in 1966, and later at Spring Grove, which became the Maryland Psychiatric Research Center. Dr. Pahnke was the director of clinical sciences there, practicing “Psychedelic Peak Therapy” using music in therapeutic experiences supervising about 600 sessions as part of teams with male and female therapists with sessions of 200 to 400 micrograms of LSD. The process included screening, ten to twenty hours of intensive psychotherapy before the sessions and as many hours as needed for integrations afterwards. Results were measured with psychological tests. A music therapist would meet in advance to learn about the patient’s musical history and preferences, and to try out selections, to ensure that the playlist would complement the therapeutic objectives of promoting intense, positive cosmic and transcendental experiences.</p><p>Dr. Pahnke was sensitive to the concern about adverse reactions as well as the potential for benefits from mystical experiences. In the early research he conducted, he found how important preparation, support during therapy, administration in a comfortable setting, and integration of the experience are to decreasing adverse psychological reactions and promoting beneficial results. Preparatory sessions would foster trust and rapport with guides and minimize fear and anxiety.</p><p>Dr. Pahnke co-authored with Bill Richards an article, <em>Implications of LSD and Experimental Mysticism</em>., published in 1969. They showed how LSD, used in in controlled studies and clinical trials, frequently produced psychedelic peak or mystical experiences. These experiences brought about positive clinical outcomes with patients suffering from advanced terminal conditions. The psychedelics could improve the quality of life for terminally ill cancer patients even with a single session. It would provide a sense of security that transcends even death. The patients had decreased anxiety and worry, diminished need for pain medicine, and more serenity, peace, and calmness. By helping reduce one’s fear of death, one becomes more able to live more meaningfully in the present and attend to things that are most significant in the here and now. Dr. Pahnke said: “If the use of psychedelic psychotherapy for the dying patient ever should become widespread in our society, there would probably be a change in our whole approach toward death. There might be less fear and more acceptance of this part of the life process.”</p><p>According to Lester Grinspoon and James Bakalar, in the 1979 book Psychedelic Drugs Reconsidered, there were over 500 papers on LSD in print in 1960. At the time they published their book, investigations had revealed a longstanding effort by American intelligence and military agencies had abused psychedelics in human experimentation, often with casual acceptance among academic professionals. They noted on page 61 that the academic interest in LSD and its adoption by the wider culture “had their own intellectual and social roots independent of and sometimes opposed to government interests.” Research showed that ordinary people would have religious experiences in psychedelic-assisted psychotherapy, about one-third, and about three-fourths would if they had religious proclivities, up to 90 % in religious settings with that purpose.</p><p>Building on the often forgotten, previous research, a new generation of scientists is proving the benefit of psychedelics in helping with resistant depression and promotion of spiritual experience, to ease the fear of death, and limit the effects of posttraumatic stress disorder.</p><p>The psychiatrist Charles Grob, who is a professor at the University of California at Los Angeles, initially studied with MDMA and ayahuasca before focusing on the benefits of psilocybin for alleviating pain and depression for end-stage cancer patients. Dr. Grob and colleagues published results of successful studies with psilocybin in 2011, in the Archives of General Psychiatry, that showed the ability of this psychedelic to ease anxiety about death in subjects with advanced-stage cancer. Dr. Grob has stressed that when psychedelics are used in socially-sanctioned settings, consistently with community standards and as part of culturally cohesive practices, the potential of entheogens can be observed, and the substantial risks of adverse reactions can be minimized.</p><p>Roland Griffiths, Ph.D., was a Professor in the Departments of Psychiatry and Neurosciences at the Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine, and founding Director of the Johns Hopkins Center on Psychedelic and Consciousness Research. In 1999, Bill Richards and Roland Griffiths spearheaded a study at Johns Hopkins School of Medicine, using a double-blind experiment with psilocybin or Ritalin, in which two-thirds of the active subjects said it was among the five most important events of their lives and many volunteers experienced enduring positive effects.</p><p>An article in July of 2006 by Dr. Griffiths and researchers, William A. Richards, U. McCann, and Robert Jesse, was published in the journal <em>Psychopharmacology</em>. This was a major breakthrough in showing the benefits of psychedelic therapy. The article was titled “Psilocybin Can Occasion Mystical-Type Experiences Having Substantial and Sustained Personal Meaning and Spiritual Significance.” The results showed that 58 % had had a complete mystical experience. After two months, two-thirds of volunteers said that the psilocybin session was the most, or one of the five most spiritually significant experiences of their lives. At 14 months afterward, 58 % stated that it was among the most meaningful, and 67 % said it was among the most spiritually significant experiences of their lives.</p><p>Dr. Griffiths published similar research in 2008 showing long-term benefits from psilocybin in people who participated regularly in religiously-oriented activities. Thirty participants reported improved positive attitudes about life and self, mood, altruism, and behavior. Two-thirds rated the experience as the most or one of the five most meaningful experiences of their lives, while a similar number, 64 %, reported having greater life satisfaction and well-being due to the experience.</p><p>Ken Kesey:</p><p>Ken Kesey described himself as an “acid head Christian” and he taught Sunday school. In April 1992, Mr. Kesey spoke to a group of people before a reading he did, in costume, at a small college in the hills of Tennessee. I heard him describe his orientation toward Christianity. He had had a series of visions that had led him to accept Christ’s teachings. “I wish that some of these people who claim to be Christian would practice what they preach,” he said, and we need to call them on their actions that depart from the message of love. His purpose was to make this a better place to live. He suggested one good way would be to help old people, to value their presence and keep them company. He was very happy to be outdoors, saying, “The spirits really communicate outside.” He spoke fondly of the 1970s, when people were in tune, and opening their minds. He spoke of the picture of the young man placing flowers in the rifle barrels of guardsmen pointing their weapons at war protesters.</p><p>Mr. Kesey urged people to claim their own traditions, but to stand up for their core principles and not follow blindly. He said that there is something worse than greed, worse than evil, about the willingness to pollute rivers. He explained that we must avoid selling the inheritance of the sacred Earth, that we need to resist the people who want to sell out something precious for profit like that. He urged us to notice hope, to see the one guard at the jail who tries to be fair, the police officer who does not give in to corruption, and that we cannot give up. He said that we need to be willing to take the wheel when there is a crazy person driving. Our country’s culture is young, and if we cannot do it here, we are not going to be able to do it anywhere.</p><p>Mr. Kesey said that there is always pressure to get sucked into the corruption of greed and money and personal comfort, but resistance is necessary to defend what is valuable. He said that it is necessary periodically to clean your compass point so it will point in the right direction. One way to do this is to have a personal tragedy, to engage in prayer, and one way is to have an LSD trip, an experience that strips you to the basics of life. He said that the people who were taking psychedelics and hyperventilating fifteen times and passing out are the most free-spirited and adventurous; they are the ones we need to lead the way.</p><p>Walter Houston Clark and Salvador Roquet</p><p>Walter Houston Clark was a professor at Andover-Newton Theological Seminary who was a participant in the Good Friday experiment. He authored the book, Chemical Ecstacy, about religious use of psychedelics and spoke in favor of the benefits of psychedelics to provide direct experience of the sacred. He described a distinction between what he termed “churchianity,” a dry formalism of rituals devoid of metaphysic, and Christianity, which was based on the experience of transcendence, which he argued could be available through carefully administered experience with psychedelics.</p><p>Dr. Clark was an advocate of the practices of Dr. Salvador Roquet, M.D., a Mexican psychiatrist who actively led group psychedelic-assisted psychotherapy in Mexico City from 1967 until 1974. Dr. Roquet was a Roman Catholic. He opened the Institute of Psychosynthesis in Mexico City in October 1967 using techniques he learned from Maria Sabina and Huichol healers. He used a variety of entheogens: LSD, mescaline, psilocybin, <em>Rivea corymbosa, </em>ketamine, MDA, Datura species, and <em>Salvia divinorum</em> administered in a series of monthly administrations. Dr. Roquet’s multi- media convivial sessions would create a sense of chaos and help people confront their basic nature and then help synthesize their feelings through mutual support. The group therapy sessions would include 15 to 30 participants and last about 20 hours. They would begin with taking the Hartman test which could identify issues with fantasy, anguish, and distortion for the work to be done. They entered a large prepared room for the disintegrative phase. There were stereos, strobe lights, film projectors for slides and movies projecting beautiful, happy, funny, cruel, and disturbing images. He and his assistants would create a sense of chaos or sensory overload. They would show themes of birth, death, childhood, love, violence, sexuality, spiritual themes, and representations of evil.</p><p>Dr. Roquet was arrested in 1974 and imprisoned for five months in Mexico. He was released in April 1975 after political pressure and testimonials from psychotherapists who cited benefits to his former patients. The process helped people grow and process through rigid emotional barriers. Dr. Roquet asserted that he had been able to help about 85 % of his patients, and that the other participants would be of great comfort to one another and show great empathy. The process helped promote a sense of healing and vitality. He believed that there is a close connection between madness and the mystical experience, and that it is practically a prerequisite.</p><p>The Church of the Awakening</p><p>The Church of the Awakening was founded in 1963 by two osteopathic physicians, John and Louise Aiken, who were Presbyterians living in New Mexico. They founded the church as a fellowship for spiritual evolution and growth when they began inner explorations after their two adult sons both had died in tragic accidents. They sought a deeper understanding of the true nature of existence than physical existence, a universal, omnipresent, and omnipotent reality. They explored paranormal activity, deep meditation, and prayer, to promote enhancement of growth in love and understanding, and the concurrent diminution of egotism and selfishness. Psychedelics, edited by Aaronson and Osmond at 178 (1970). They learned about psychedelics and were able to obtain peyote from the Rio Grande Valley, and later they also employed mescaline as one of their sacraments. They found that these substances, when used with reverence and careful preparation not more frequently than every three months, were very helpful in achieving spiritual growth and maturity.</p><p>One aspect of their practices was to observe proper and respectful sacramental use of peyote, which they regarded as an agent that aided their search for the spiritual meaning of life. They did not have a specific body of doctrine, and were focused more on experience than on beliefs. The psychedelic sacraments were administered to prepared and qualified individuals by trained monitors and ministers. Dr. Aiken wrote that their intention was to begin an entry to deeper purpose, opening to a pathway of personal growth employing various means, with an emphasis on individual efforts to meet challenges and develop inner life. They maintained that the bona fide ceremonial use of peyote and mescaline should be equally available to individuals not of American Indian origin. In 1972, a federal court denied the Church of the Awakening’s appeal of a denial of an exemption from anti-peyote laws by the Bureau of Narcotics and Dangerous Drugs.</p><p>Reflections</p><p>The courts considering religious protection for psychedelics appear to be more attracted to the familiar types of ceremonies. Although the Christian traditions have been a source of hostility in years past to the potential spiritual benefits of psychedelics, and there is most recently a great deal of ambivalence by organized religion toward traditional uses and modern applications of psychedelics. The court decisions emphasize that it is the sincerity of the adherents that is a principal area of focus, along with a showing of low risk of harm. Greater protection for sincere religious practices using psychedelics is likely through court decisions, state and federal legislation, and local ordinances as scientific research and legal psychedelic assisted psychotherapy yield results showing spiritual transformation and other benefits, particularly with psilocybin, which is very safe from a physiological standpoint.</p><p>Americans are supporting greater access to natural medicines for healing of trauma and for spiritual exploration. There has been pressure to limit their use to a medical context, which appears to be financially prohibitive for most people and restricts access to people presenting themselves as having a mental health pathology. Legal protections are likely to expand and incorporate celebratory and exploratory adult use of psychedelic medicines, as well as a broader category of spiritual exploration that would not depend on insincere presentation or cultural appropriation of another society’s traditions.</p><p>North American and European experience faces the problem of an absence of accepted psychedelic spiritual traditions. Authoritarian structures eliminated psychedelic practices in ancient Greece and Europe, and throughout the colonial empires in the Americas and Africa. North American religious institutions have been at the forefront of efforts to suppress and eliminate the longstanding traditions in Central and South America. Traditions in other countries that go back many centuries have survived by withstanding and evading extreme persecution by religious and governmental authorities.</p><p>Opposition by mainstream religions and legal authorities, and the social stigma associated with drug culture and psychedelics, have resulted in ordinary people having no legal access to psychedelics. These forces have also inhibited or prevented formation of social groups and organizations that would have developed naturally to provide practices and social reinforcement for safer practices and risk reduction. The United States judicial system is inhibited by initial experience of its society with psychedelics because of missteps, abuses, and inappropriate uses that led to adverse consequences, and because of the insights that led to challenges to mainstream society’s expectations of social conformity.</p><p>Many people in the West are moving away from traditional organized religion or becoming more entrenched in religious institutions that are firmly opposed to ceremonial use of entheogens. There is a crosscurrent of influences that could inform a more universal spiritual message consistent with the experience of an unfolding psychedelic journey. Disenchantment with mainstream religious institutions can help reveal beneficial and more holistic theologies from other traditional frameworks, and open worldviews to incorporate new ideas and realizations drawn from individual and community experience. Some of the challenges to having a more universal, experience-based religion that incorporates psychedelic substances include improper or corrupt motivations by leaders, inadequate preparation or exploitation of vulnerable participants in a hyper-suggestible mental and emotional state, incompetency in administration of the sacraments or in addressing uncomfortable or hazardous reactions, factionalism, divisiveness, envy, and misunderstanding between leaders, an absence of reverence for the medicines, and disrespect of the viewpoints and experience of other participants.</p><p>Careful, deliberate, and confident preparation and oversight can help mitigate risks and provide a safe container for an inward healing process that can afford people with a deepened sense of connection with nature, community, the ground of being, and contact with the numinous. The psychedelic experience can provide a sense of greater aliveness and motivation through restorative insights that bring about gratitude, love, forgiveness, and compassion. It creates the potential to bring about a clarity of awareness about one’s own experience and motivations, and exposing one to truths about one’s past actions and experiences that can enhance insight and motivation for transformation. It can motivate the inner work to transform in more engaging and positive ways.</p><p>While programs for adult use in non-clinical settings evolve, Colorado’s program will be a fine example of the guidelines most beneficial to employ in providing a safe container. People will have an opportunity to shed layers of resistance and deepen understanding and compassion for oneself and for others, and other opportunities for personal transformation due to a mysterious neuroplasticity process that can reveal unfamiliar types of awareness. Risk mitigation practices with informed consent for voluntary participation with disclosures of risks, and accountability for best practices, will contribute to reaching the greatest potential for psychedelics.</p><p>Psychedelic group and individual settings for healthy adults are likely to evolve and develop with myriad influences, reaching in differing directions and coalescing sometimes when their ways find common ground. A group could meet in a retreat setting with careful leadership that should be able to include multiple spiritual frameworks with such moral precepts and self-discipline, but without a rigid or fundamentalist viewpoint particular to an insular religion.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=3083f72fc5b2" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Christianity and Psychedelics, research and reflections by Ron McNutt, April 2025]]></title>
            <link>https://ronmcnutt.medium.com/christianity-and-psychedelics-research-and-reflections-by-ron-mcnutt-april-2025-6c154c2b9454?source=rss-368797e78488------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6c154c2b9454</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[religion]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[psychedelics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ronald W. McNutt]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 26 Apr 2025 13:57:30 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-04-26T19:55:39.692Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Christianity and Psychedelics, research and reflections by Ron McNutt, April 2025</p><p>This is some research that explores my interest in psychedelics and Christianity. When psychedelics are part of a sincere and intentional practice, such as spiritual, ceremonial, or celebratory settings, in a manner that employs risk reduction practices, they can provide great benefits. They can help reduce ruminative, negative thinking, and help people shed layers of resistance and antipathy, and help people deepen soul connection by encounters with grief that enrich the soul and help restore full aliveness.</p><p>Jesus instructs people to hunger and thirst for righteousness and be blessed. By mutual goodwill and encouragement, people can join and be aligned with the primary teachings of Jesus, which are to forgive, to love one another and ourselves, to be generous, compassionate, honest, and humble, and to act from gratitude. Jesus spoke about the Holy Spirit being like the wind. We cannot see it but we may observe its influence. The word for breath, wind, and spirit is the same in Hebrew, <em>ruach</em>, and people of different cultures speak of life in the spirit, and finding a common understanding in relation to the spirit. In the Christian gospels, works of the Spirit play out among people who have gifts of the Spirit to bring them to being and action. Jesus spoke about bringing peace, showing love, and bearing fruits in the world. Our intentions matter very much for our souls.</p><p>Jesus instructs that as you sow, so shall you reap and we can change. He showed that forgiving others, releasing our holding onto one another’s faults, frees us with a sense of our own forgiveness. Forgiveness brings grace and forgiveness to ourselves. We can realize how beloved we all are in the unity of the Holy Spirit, and can disentangle ourselves from judgment and grievance. He taught that before offering prayers and sacrifices at the altar of the Temple we should first go and resolve our grievances and make peace with our siblings. He taught that God is compassionate, so we also should be compassionate.</p><p>People have had spontaneous mystical states of unity for centuries. These experiences of the sacred form the basis of religions, forms of practice that attempt to reach high and pull beauty down for their neighbors to share. These attempts are performed out of love. Ralph Waldo Emerson, a Transcendentalist writer and Universalist minister, wrote that, “God enters by a private door into every individual.” The door to God can be a way that is particular to its user, whose actions bear fruits that are translation of the sacred into forms. Some may follow a tradition of belief and ritual, others a system of traditions or images of the Beloved, and still others seek an original relation to the universe without formula, or find their own formula. If two people look at one thing they never have heard described before, they probably will perceive and report it differently. Yet religious images come through widely divergent cultures in similar patterns.</p><p>One way in which psychedelics can reveal a mystical awareness is the perception of how all reality is interwoven consciousness. The ancient Greek rites, the Eleusinian Mysteries, incorporated a vision that reinforced an appreciation of eternity. The contents were kept secret for over 1200 years and remain a mystery. The ritual pilgrimages of the ancient Greeks in Eleusis took place from 1600 B.C. to 392 C.E. They were part of an annual festival led by or hierophants or priests that celebrated the myth of Demeter and Persephone. The culmination of the Mystery was “an overwhelming vision of spiritual presences demonstrating the relationship of the living and the dead.”</p><p>The Eleusinian Mysteries employed a libation, known as the <em>kykeon</em>, that created profound visions and was associated with Persephone’s return from Hades, the cycle of seasons, and the continuity of life. The <em>Kykeon</em>, was guarded in secrecy, and the rituals were restricted to the once in a lifetime ceremony available as part of a pilgrimage restricted to individuals who had not committed a murder. There was absolute prohibition on revealing or profaning the sacrament, which research by Albert Hofmann, Carl Ruck, and R. Gordon Wasson have determined were quite possibly a substance containing lysergic acid amides derived from ergot.</p><p>Participants included Plato, Sophocles, Cicero, Pindar, and Marcus Aurelius. It was outlawed by Emperor Theodosius, a Roman institutional Christian. In The Road to Eleusis, Ruck, Hofmann, and Wasson showed how the <em>kykeon </em>may have been a water-soluble ergot of barley or Claviceps paspali, to produce a psychedelic effect without the poisonous alkaloids with blood clotting properties. Brian Muraresku has done some outstanding research, building on that of Carl Ruck and others. Part of the problem with proving the contents is that the vessels found at Eleusis were sealed in a solvent, so analysis is not feasible.</p><p>Unfortunately, the Christian teachings became part of a state religion that accepted violence and domination. Practices like the rites of Eleusis were supplanted with a hierarchical system of severe persecution by authorities who were suspicious of witchcraft beliefs and practices that were often spiritually-oriented ceremonies that would provide direct access to soul awareness.</p><p>Western and European society has had a traumatic relationship with psychedelic substances. The Inquisition stamped out the herbalist use of henbane, mandrake, and belladonna, in Europe, and by the 1600s, it was directing its energies to the Indigenous practices of New World inhabitants, who employed psychedelic plants and fungi to have experiences that they said showed them higher worlds, deepened their soul connections, and improved their health and vitality. European religions set about to eradicate long standing indigenous traditions using naturally-occurring plants and fungi as part of the traditions for acculturation, socialization, and initiation into the beliefs and priorities of their societies.</p><p>The Inquisition Disrupts Traditions Employing Plant Medicines and Psychedelic Mushrooms</p><p>Before the Europeans arrived, in many places throughout Central America, South America, and the Caribbean Islands, the major natural psychedelics, known as teonanacatl or psilocybin mushrooms, peyote or peyotl, ayahuasca, San Pedro or huachuma, ololiuqui, and yopo, were held in the highest esteem by the native peoples. Communities would engage with such psychedelic substances in ceremonial experiences that would be at the center of community life, and reinforce and strengthen their view of relations with nature and all life. Their experiences would reveal a spiritual presence and a sense of sacredness and understanding that spirit that animates all life. Indigenous were, who would approach them with reverence and sincerity and part of a disciplined practice.</p><p>The colonial powers persecuted the use of natural psychedelics in the Americas. When the Spanish early Spanish explorers encountered traditions and cultures that used psychedelic plants and fungi, they were bewildered, and associated them with biblical proscriptions against witchcraft. The severe repression of the Inquisition, motivated by self-righteous clerics and rigid institutions of government, resulted in the traditions being eliminated, retreating to remote areas, becoming obscured in secrecy to outsiders, or transforming in response to social pressure of influences including exploitations and opposition.</p><p>The earliest writings about the origins of the ceremonial use of ayahuasca are historical records of the Spanish Catholic Church, which were produced from a perspective that was hostile to practices of employing plant hallucinogens by a force of persecution and domination. Early explorers in South America found many Indian villages along the Amazon and other areas. In the 1600s and 1700s, Jesuits observed natives using ayahuasca in the Marañón River area. The Marañón runs northwest from a glacier high up in the Andes mountains through Peru along the eastern edge of the Andes. The Marañón turns east and flows into plains and meets the Ucayali River and together they form the Amazon River.</p><p>According to an article by Guerra in 1967, the Holy Inquisition of Mexico issued a proclamation in 1616 ordering the persecution and excommunication of those who, under the influence of, “herbs and roots with which they lose and confound their senses, and the illusions and fantastic representations they have, judge and proclaim afterwards as revelation, or true notice of things to come…” Having called for repression and death for those who claimed to experience revelations by using roots and herbs, the traditions practicing use of ayahuasca suffered and diminished because of contact with the European culture, and the persecution would be exacerbated further by colonialism and the forced labor of Indians by the British for rubber production. However, there was some interaction and contact generated by the Rubber Boom that did lead to spreading information about ayahuasca and its practice.</p><p>Teonanacatl</p><p>A tradition of using psilocybin mushrooms was established before the Spanish conquest. Mushroom stone sculptures in Guatemala, southern Mexico, and El Salvador date from around the year one thousand. They are often paired with animals associated with shamanism, revealing sacred associations. Ceramic figures with mushroom-like headdresses have been dated from 160 A.D. Ceremonial use and divination rituals with psilocybin mushrooms by Aztecs who called them God’s flesh or <em>teonanacatl</em>, was recorded in the 1500s by a court physician Francisco Hernandez, Bernardino Sahagun, a Franciscan friar, and another friar, Diego Duran. In 1629 a collection from Nahuatl, a region in Mexico and Central America, described a pattern of chanting by Indians that reappeared in the 1950s, in the Western Sierra Madre: professions of humility, claiming an ability to be able to talk to supernatural beings, and referencing a book of knowledge that was gifted from long before.</p><p>Cohoba</p><p>The New World had widespread use of an inhaled entheogen called cohoba powder, more recently called yopo, or Anadenanthera peregrina. Cohoba was a psychedelic snuff preparation used by indigenous cultures of Hispaniola, described in records after Columbus’s arrival from Spain. It is described by missionaries and explorers in 1560 and 1599 as being widely used among Central American people. The West Indian indigenous societies did not survive contact with the Spanish. The Western explorers of the New World regarded the hallucinogenic snuff as an instrument of the devil. The practice had largely retreated to remote areas.</p><p>In 1801, Alexander von Humboldt reported that cohoba powder was a part of ceremonial experience in the Orinoco River basin area of Colombia and Venezuela border was regarded as the center of its use, along with the area of northern Brazil. The eminent ethnobotanist Richard Spruce documented its use and collected samples of it along with snuffing tubes in 1851 that were recently identified. In the Orinoco region of western Brazil, and other areas, yopo use has continued among various indigenous groups to the present day.</p><p>Peyote</p><p>Peyote has been in use ceremonially for 5000 years. Articles in 2002 and 2005 describe how a team of scientists from Sweden and the Netherlands proved that Native Americans used peyote as long ago as 5700 years earlier. The scientists did a chemical analysis of two dried peyote buttons in the collection of the Witte Museum in San Antonio, which were thought to be from the Shumla Cave number five on the Rio Grande. Using radiocarbon dating and alkaloid analysis, their age was identified as being between 3780 to 3660 B.C. The analysis found alkaloids of mescaline. Some samples from an archeological site in Coahuila, Mexico showed peyote with radiocarbon testing dated to 810 to 1070 C.E., about 1000 years old.</p><p>For centuries the <em>Wixárika </em>people, who have been called the Huichol in Spanish, have lived harmoniously with the forces of nature in a sustainable way in the Sierra Madre Occidental, in northwestern Mexico. The Huichols practice the oldest current tradition of religious usage of peyote. Their practices include going from their various mountain villages on annual pilgrimages in groups to harvest peyote and visit their sacred ancestral land in semi-desert areas. Their harvest rituals include ceremonially hunting the peyote, calling it the little deer, and they offer prayers to it and thanks for its body and its spiritual essence.</p><p>Dr. Harvey Cox, a professor at the Harvard Divinity School, participated in the peyote ritual of the Huichol Indians around 1974. He said that the ritual involved purification, preparation, and prayer. For part of his journey, the leaders encouraged him to participate alone and to have his own visions. Because he had his own traditions, the leader did not feel capable of guiding him at that point. He felt that the fire was communing with him, and he felt a message from the morning star that it was mediating the energy of the universe to him. Dr. Cox reflected that he had become more receptive to other forms of religious experiences as a result, and that the range of possible experiences of the sacred had grown for him.</p><p>Huachuma or San Pedro</p><p>An ancient stone glyph, or stone relief, excavated at a temple in the northern highlands of Peru, from the Chavin culture, shows a spirt entity holding a stalk of the San Pedro cactus. It has serpentine hair and a serpent belt, fangs, and harpy eagle claws. It is the earliest depiction of a relationship with this mescaline-containing plant, and shows that San Pedro cactus was revered by South American cultures as early as 1300 B.C. It is a tall cactus that grows from sea level to altitudes of 3000 meters. Ceramics from later cultures of the area from 1000 B.C. to 700 B.C. and textiles hundreds of years old also show images of the cactus. Its use was widespread in the regions of the Andes mountains and it was in cultivation but encountered severe persecution after the Spanish conquest, beginning with a campaign to extirpate “idolatry” in the 1600s.</p><p>Ayahuasca</p><p>Ayahuasca is a classic hallucinogen from the Amazon, a mixture of Banisteriopsis caapi, a woody vine or liana also known as ayahuasca, and one of the most common admixtures, known as chacruna, or Psychotria viridis, Psychotria alba, called amaruca or samaruca, and chagropanga, or Diplopterys cabrerana, and Mimosa hostilis, and Mimosa tenuflora roots, as well as Arundo donax, Nile reed grass. The leaves of these shrubs and roots contain DMT. Sometimes, other admixtures are included, depending on the traditions. The brew is orally active because of the presence of a monoamine oxidase inhibitor, ayahuasca vines in the Americas. Syrian rue, Peganum harmala, was used in the Middle East area. It also prevents metabolizing the DMT, and this activates the tryptamines, which have a similar effect to psilocybin. It also limits the metabolism of serotonin. There is often a great degree of nausea from the harmine alkaloids. The accompanying visions can be very intense. Although it can be dangerous because of the reaction to other drugs, it is constitutionally protected as a religious practice under a 2006 Supreme Court case. There are many ayahuasca churches, especially in Brazil, and many indigenous or neo-shamanic retreats in Peru, Colombia, Ecuador, and elsewhere. There are retreat centers and underground medicine circles throughout the U.S.A.</p><p>Scientists have found the chemical components of ayahuasca in a cave in the Bolivian Andes 13,000 feet high, and recently showed they were in use around 1000 years ago. In an article published in <em>Science </em>magazine in May 2019, a team of scientists revealed the results of a chemical analysis from this archeological find from 2008. They were part of a group of medicine plants that were dated in a study by the tools for powdering and insufflating them. Dust and debris with harmine, dimethyltryptamine, along with cocaine and bufotenine. These are the essential ingredients of ayahuasca, ordinarily made with the plants, chacruna (Psychotria viridis) and ayahuasca (Banisteriopsis caapi) which would grow in the areas of the upper Amazon but the presence of bufotenine indicates that the powder included yopo seeds. These ingredients must have been highly valued because they had been carried far from where they would grow to a burial site location high up in the Andes.</p><p>One of the earliest sources documenting ayahuasca use is from Father José Chantre y Herrera, compiled from historical documents of the Jesuit missionaries in the Marañón River area of Peru from the time between 1637 and 1767. He included a clear description of an ayahuasca ritual using a liana, or woody vine, with other plants. He described how there would be a night-long divination ceremony held in a house suited to hold many people, with benches placed for the men on one side, and open space for the women on the other. The leader would be in the middle seated on a hammock with a platform beside him, and, Herrera stated, places beside it “an infernal beverage that they call ayahuasca, which is singularly efficient in depriving one of one’s senses.” He continued, “They make the concoction of lianas or bitter herbs, which, after a great deal of boiling, becomes very thick. Since it is so strong as to derange a person even in small quantities, the dose is minimal, and fits into two small receptacles. The sorcerer, each time he drinks, consumes very small amounts, and knows very well how many times he can drink the potion without losing his sanity in order to carry out the ceremony with due solemnity and direct the chorus, since everyone responds to his invocation of the devil.”</p><p>In the 1700s, Jesuit writers wrote about a vine called ayahuasca in a pejorative fashion. Pablo Maroni, a Jesuit missionary present in the Marañón River area in 1738 to 1740, wrote that some of the indigenous people used the juice of a Brugmansia, while others would use a liana, or woody vine, called ayahuasca, for divination. He said that these drinks were “very effective to deprive one of the senses, and even of life” when used in “overloaded” doses. He added, “This they also sometimes use to cure themselves of habitual diseases, mainly of headaches. Drink, then, because he who wishes to divine conducts certain ceremonies, and being deprived of his senses lays face down, to avoid being suffocated by the power of the herb, he is thus many hours and sometimes even two and three days, until the inebriation takes its course. After this, he reflects on what the imagination represented, who alone and at times must remain in a delirious state, and this he takes as fact and prophesies as an oracle.”</p><p>In 1768 Franz Xaver Veigl described ayahuasca use as a bitter vine used for “mystification and bewitchment” and that it caused the users to lose their minds. The location of the rituals was not specified. Some ethnobotanists believe that ayahuasca usage spread from the Tukano tribal region near the Colombian Amazon and spread along the Vaupés River, a tributary of the Rio Negro, which flows into the Amazon. Usage of ayahuasca apparently spread with the trade routes where Quechua language was used during the first rubber boom from 1879 to 1912, a time of mass movement, especially in the area of Brazil. Quechua is an ancient language that was used by the Incan empire, throughout the Andes. The word ayahuasca is Quechua language for “vine of the soul”, “vine of the dead”, or “vine of the ancestors.”</p><p>Richard Evans Schultes was an Episcopalian and an influential ethnobotanist who conducted extensive botanical exploration field work in the Colombian Amazon. wrote that yagé, another name ayahuasca, often with a different admixture, arose before history into the well of the world, to help people learn of the soul and bring back transformative information for use in this world and make things beautiful. With Albert Hofmann, Dr. Schultes helped discover how ayahuasca creates a potent effect by combining dimethyltryptamine with a mono amine oxidase inhibitor. They collaborated on books including Plants of the Gods (1979), which states in its introduction: “A few plants had inexplicable effects that transported the human mind to realms of ethereal wonder — in communication with the spirit world. It is little wonder that they have long played an important role in religious rites of early civilizations and are still venerated by people who remain part of ancient traditions.”</p><p>Traditions and adaptation</p><p>In many ways, the Indigenous traditions in the Americas can provide an appropriate context and example of the psychedelic experience for people descended from other traditions. A faith may evolve from experience with psychedelics that is the most inclusive and true to the visionary experience of the individual. Ideas from core shamanism, the paths of righteous conduct from Buddhism, Christianity, Islam, Hinduism, and Indigenous traditions are likely to evolve toward a more open and universal set of principles and guidelines. Environmental stewardship and trauma-informed understandings from psychotherapy and self-help traditions can be incorporated into orientation and integration sessions in group settings providing safe containers for celebratory and exploratory uses.</p><p>The late author, psychologist, and advocate for access to psychedelic plants, fungi, and compounds, Dr. Ralph Metzner, encouraged explorations and practice applying an explorer path of shamanism that respects harmony with nature. He states that major entheogens such as ayahuasca reveal to sincere and respectful seekers the interwovenness of beings and the sacred nature of life. Indigenous societies informed by ayahuasca often have an outlook of animism, an understanding that assumes the aliveness of living spirits occupying a symbolic universe. It is a reality in which the earth and the forces and beings all are alive in spiritual energy like a quantum field, all beings are sacred, and everything is related.</p><p>Some Indigenous Traditions of the New World and Their Influences</p><p>Plant medicine traditions stem from wisdom sources in the medicine traditions of the indigenous, such as traditions from the upper Amazon region going back at least 1000 years. Ayahuasca churches in Brazil have sources that include inspiration from Christian traditions, adapting in an organic way many other sources of influence and inspiration.</p><p>The founders of the two largest Brazilian ayahuasca religions had learned of ayahuasca when they had contact with indigenous people when they were rubber work. In the Brazilian Amazon, ayahuasca churches formed in the 1930s and 1940s. Raimundo Irineu Serra originated an ayahuasca religion with Christian influences called Santo Daime. Daniel Pereira de Matos formed the Barquinha ayahuasca religion which also has Christian orientation. Jose Gabriel de Costa formed the União do Vegetal religion in Brazil in the 1960s, which is a more independent ayahuasca religion and has branches in many countries, as does the Santo Daime ayahuasca church.</p><p>The <em>União do Vegetal </em>Ayahuasca church and Santo Daime and Barqhinho churches achieved legal protections in Brazil. In 1987, Brazil declared ayahuasca a legal substance when used within the context of religious practice, becoming the first country to allow psychedelic use by non-indigenous persons.</p><p>Healthy respect for ayahuasca, psilocybin, San Pedro and the other major psychedelic plant teachers hopefully will avoid the error of fundamentalism, which tends to limit the symbolic life of the superconscious into a rigid dogma. Instead, we embrace what Walt Whitman celebrated as the “chant of dilation” and a spirit of inclusivity. It is the widening of the embrace of spirit, which Jesus emphasized is God’s own way. It does not exclude repentant people but restores others and builds community through a redemptive merciful outlook like that of the loving father in the parable of the prodigal son. Loving kindness was a central emphasis in the teachings of the Buddha and appears at the basis of the major religions.</p><p>Quanah Parker, John Wilson, and the Origins of the Native American Church</p><p>Peyote is a spiritual medicine that brought healing and salvation to American Indians beginning in the late 1800s and is at the center of The Native American Church of North America. The ceremonies are specially called, usually on a Saturday from sunset to sunrise in a tepee or hogan. The ceremony can be called by a sponsor for an important occasion like a birth or an anniversary, or for holidays, but usually for healing. Ceremonies vary between tribes, but there is drumming with a water drum, a fire chief who brings water at midnight, and people offer songs and prayers of devotion and supplication seeking blessings from God. After taking peyote those assembled are led to the peyote road where visions pass between God and the participants. and having sustaining visions and love that draws the community together. People in the circle take turns offering four songs under the guidance of the roadman, a guide to encourage their minds to see the spirit and lead to sustaining visions and love that draws the community together.</p><p>Quanah Parker was the last chief of the Comanche, and he was a principal founder of the Native American Church. He had a dual heritage; his mother was white and became a member of the tribe when she was taken in as a young girl. Both his mother and his sister later were taken by soldiers, leading him to oppose settlers and he was a fierce warrior. In 1875, he led his tribe to Fort Sill after deciding further warfare would be futile. He took his mother’s last name and became a leader and a prosperous rancher and served as judge and sheriff on a reservation. He was opposed to peyote but in 1884, he was healed of a serious blood infection after being gored by a bull in Texas. He became deathly ill, and his aunt took him to a Mexican <em>curandera</em>, probably a Tarahumara, and he was healed with peyote tea. He became a road chief for peyote, bringing it to many tribes in the 1880s and later. He regarded peyote as a sacrament to be taken with water. He composed songs for singing in the ceremonies. During the informal period afterward, when people discuss their visions, he would counsel others and encourage them in the right path and strengthen their purpose. The goal is to study and learn something, perhaps to have a visit by the peyote bird or an eagle. Reverence in purpose is essential.</p><p>The Kiowa-Comanche ceremony is the prototype for peyote ceremonies of the plains Indians. The important elements of the ceremony include half-moon earth altar, songs of praise and devotion, the staff, the kettle water drum, the gourd rattle, the eagle wing bone whistle, and the prayers with tobacco. There are variations among the tribes. There is an emphasis on devotion. All talking stops when the ceremonial Father Peyote or Chief Peyote is put in place at the center of the crescent-shaped altar and the road man offers the first prayer. People sit upright and peyote is passed four times, in dried form or as powder, taken with water or peyote tea. Music becomes more spirited after midnight, when the fire chief brings water and after prayer everyone drinks; and the roadman goes outside and whistles to the four directions with the eagle wing whistle.</p><p>Peyote is regarded as a divine messenger and respected for its “medicine power.” In addition to its spiritual properties, peyote is an antibiotic and antiseptic. Ceremonies may center on native doctoring and purification, using sacred elements such as water, tobacco, sage, feathers and bird imagery, and fire. A typical first song in a ceremony will be this prayer, “May the gods bless me, help me, and give me power and understanding.”</p><p>State laws were enacted in many states in opposition to peyote rituals, many such laws were passed in the 1920s. In 1908, Quanah Parker testified before the Oklahoma legislature, a year after two Indians were prosecuted under an 1899 law against peyote, and the law was repealed. Chief Parker did not adopt Christianity and he was respected as a leader. He is quoted as saying, “We do not go into ceremony to talk about God. We go into ceremony to talk with God.”</p><p>The peyote religion among the American Indians was influenced by the mescal bean tradition and the Ghost Dance movement at a time when there was a cultural loss. It suffered persecution but it endured through the resolute purpose of its members in different tribes. Peyote use was observed by missionaries in Texas in 1760, who viewed use of peyote by the Indigenous as a problem, and it was common among Mexican tribes who viewed peyote as a divine being. After the Civil War, there was more contact between tribes between Mexico and the United States. Peyote use spread from the north of Mexico to Texas and the plains by the Kiowa and Comanche tribes after they visited Mexican tribes, the Carrizo, Tonkawa, Lipan, and Mescalero. They became the primary leaders of the spread of peyote through the plains along with the Caddo.</p><p>The Apaches of the Mescalero Indian Reservation used peyote in a shamanistic way in the time from just before their reservation was established in 1873 until about 1910. They spread the use of peyote, but their own society abandoned it, apparently because of an emphasis on individual spiritual powers and an adversarial approach to the practices, leading to rivalries and bloodshed.</p><p>When the Native American Church began forming in 1885, intertribal warfare was ending and there was more intermarriage, but the buffalo were eliminated by the white people, and it was after the Wounded Knee massacre when Indians being confined to reservations and experiencing a loss of their culture. The peyote religion helped develop inter-tribal cooperation and create a positive expression of identity, and it spread to the Cheyenne, Arapaho, Ute, Shoshone, Delaware, Sioux, and many other tribes. It is used as a religious sacrament by about forty tribes. Participants would sing songs and try to maintain beauty, hope, and goodness in their hearts.</p><p>In 1922, there were about 13,300 ceremonial peyote users. Members will seek to eat as many as 25 to 30 of so, maybe 20 buttons if they are green, although some members state they have eaten 50 or more peyote buttons in a ceremony. The medicine was inexpensive and $ 2.50 could buy 1000 peyote buttons in Laredo and Nuevo Laredo, Mexico at that time.</p><p>An anthropologist from the Smithsonian, James Mooney, who traveled to Indian Territory, present day Oklahoma, in 1891, was impressed with the tradition. He wrote favorably about the tradition and participated in its ceremonies. In 1918, he encouraged the leaders, called road men or road chiefs, to assemble and incorporate and write a charter. They told legends about peyote discovery by a woman who was in labor, lost in the desert, and hungry, and a voice told her to eat it, and she was relieved and gave birth.</p><p>John Wilson was initiated into the peyote religion in the 1880s and he became a roadman. He was part Caddo, part Delaware, and partly of Scottish descent. Before he turned forty, he had been a moderate drinker who participated in gambling and social dance. He had a background in the Ghost Dance movement in the Caddo Tribe. His Caddo name was <em>Nishkuntu</em> (Moon Head). He attended an Arapaho and Cheyenne Ghost Dance in 1890 that Sitting Bull presided over, where he had visions that led him to become a healer of diseases by revelations, drawing people from other tribes. He was introduced to peyote by a Comanche man at a ceremonial dance and he became converted. He was in seclusion with his wife outdoors for two or three weeks, staying by a stream, and taking about 15 peyote buttons at various times. Peyote took pity on him for his sincerity and humility, and he stayed attentive to its lessons. He received a revelation and was transported to the sky realm. He was shown celestial landmarks and scenes familiar to the Delaware Tribe, observed events in the life of Christ. He saw the empty grave of Christ and was shown the Road from the grave to the Moon in the Sky. Peyote directed him to walk this pathway and advance in greater knowledge through the use of peyote and faithfulness to its teachings, until at his death he would be present with peyote and Christ. He was shown how to conduct worship in peyote meetings, how to cure diseases and heal injuries, how to purge the body of the effects of sin, and how to lead Indians to the regions above heaven and to reach the presence of the creator and peyote. He learned about 200 songs.</p><p>Peyote also gave him instructions about construction of a new form of the moon altar in the peyote tent in the form of Christ’s grave. He taught worshipers to seek knowledge by direct communion. He taught that Indians could receive direct revelations from God through the peyote spirt. His ceremonies would include filing out of the tipi in the morning to meet the sun with raised arms and prayer. He traveled extensively and led ceremonies, particularly among the Osage and the Quapaw. He advocated clean living, honesty, restraint in sexual matters and fidelity in matrimony, as well as peaceful coexistence with the white people. He gave the following instructions to his nephew, George Anderson, on how to find the peyote way: “Keep your mind on peyote and don’t think anything about the people around you or anything outside. Look at peyote and the fire all the time and think of it. Sit quiet and do not move around or be uneasy. Then you will not get sick or see visions. Visions and nausea are signs of bad self-adjustment to the proper religious attitude.”</p><p>He was criticized when he received generous gifts from some of the wealthy tribes. In 1901, he died in an accident at a railway intersection at the age of 61, with many horses received as gifts and in the presence a Quapaw woman who was not his wife. Most tribes retained the traditional small moon altar of the Kiowa Comanche tradition. In 1993, when a leader of the Native American Church, Reuben Snake, died, there were an estimated 250,000 members. He had led a coalition of Indian groups that succeeded in advocating for national protection of the religion. Presently, peyote has become scarce, and groups such as the Native American Conservation Initiative are organized to establish habitat and protect the sacrament’s availability.</p><p>Maria Sabina and her Mazatec Mushroom Velada</p><p>Maria Sabina was born Maria Sabina Magdalena Garcia around 1894. She became a shaman or curandera when she was about forty. She had a hard life in a beautiful mountain area of Oaxaca, in the Sierra Mazateca of Mexico. She and her sister worked hard on a small farm with a few goats, doing chores such as tending chickens in the woods. There was no school available. Their father died when she was a few years old. She was always hungry and cold. When she was about six years old, a wise man came and cured her uncle using the sacred mushrooms in a traditional healing ceremony. Her people always spoke quietly and would use terms of respect to describe the sacred mushrooms, such as the little ones that leap forth or the saint children. Her father’s father and his father also had been wise ones, who could cure with mushrooms. She recognized the mushrooms from the woods and she and her sister ate them many times. Maria Sabina heard beautiful voices from another world giving beautiful advice and leading her to sing beautifully. One time, she had a vision of her father, who said to her, “Maria Sabina, get on your knees and pray.” She then spoke to God and became closer to God.</p><p>Maria Sabina had an arranged marriage and three children with her first husband but he left her and she was widowed after a six-year marriage. A few years later, she was required to intercede for her only sister who was having a health crisis with stomach pains and she could not get out of bed. She ate 30 pairs of the most potent variety of saint children and observed the ancient Mazatec vigil practices using candles of pure beeswax, flowers with scent and color, copal incense to bless the sacrament, and tobacco to put on the skin, and then proceeding in pure darkness. The spirit of the mushrooms guided her hands and her words, causing a large amount of blood to be expelled from her sister, and she stopped groaning and slept.</p><p>Their mother attended her sister, while Maria Sabina went off and she received a revelation vision of the Principal Ones she had learned about from her ancestors. Six or eight of the spiritual beings were before her at a table. The voice of the saint children told her these were the Principal Ones. One of them told her, “Maria Sabina, this is the Book of Wisdom. It is the Book of Language. Everything that is written in it is for you. The Book is yours, take it so that you can work.” She gladly accepted it and they left her. She contemplated it and she began to speak, realizing she was reading its contents. She realized that the gift had been bestowed upon her because she was pure, and that she had attained the wisdom beyond being an apprentice and had become a Wise One. She also received a visit from the Lord of the Mountains, Chicon Nindo, later that night because in her wise language she had called him. He rode up on a horse and she went outside. She then received a third revelation when a luminous vegetal being like a bush with flowers of colors with a halo and radiance, fresh and alive, appeared before fading into a splendid red background. She cried, whistled, clapped, and danced, realizing that she was now the Lord Clown Woman.</p><p>Maria Sabina continued working with wool and cotton, planted corn, beans and harvested coffee. She sold bread, candles, and pots, and she raised silkworms. She remarried after twelve years. Both times while she was married, she would not eat mushrooms because their tradition required four-day periods of celibacy before and after mushroom ceremonies, or veladas. After she was widowed for the second time, she dedicated herself to curing with the saint children. She would access the Book of Wisdom in her visions until she could access it from memory, using the language to heal, as a shaman mediating a world of heaven to this world, finding soul illnesses and curses and cures for various diseases. She would accept gifts but not charge for the medicine.</p><p>A 1957 Life Magazine article ran a momentous article that Gordon Wasson wrote after he and Allan Richardson, the photographer, participated in her veladas. A municipal sindico or magistrate, for whom Maria Sabina had provided counsel for his decisions for three years, had been approached by Mr. Wasson and had directed him to her. The world was amazed by the news of the tradition that she and her people had preserved and Maria Sabina had many people come to see her from around the world. Recordings of her chanting from 1957 were released on Folkways Records the following year.</p><p>Maria Sabina said that the saint children speak and she would have the power to translate. She was aware of the dark places where illnesses of the soul would lurk, but she would go upward to commune with the Principal Ones. She would see the saints appear in the ceremonies when she sang their names. In her chanting, she proclaimed, “I am the woman of the winds, of the water, of the paths, because I am known in heaven, because I am a doctor woman.” She would clap, whistle and chant with a beautiful sing-song cadence, proclaiming her purity of heart for the service of Christ and the saints, and becoming the voice of the divine mushrooms. She stated, “I know that God is formed by the saints. Just as we, together, form humanity, God is formed by all the saints.”</p><p>Maria Sabina said, “Nothing that the mushrooms show should be feared.” After effecting a cure with the language of the children, she would say something like, “the one who has healed your son is God who is raising all of us.” She was active in a church group, Sisters of the Sacred Heart of Jesus, and she was great friends with the local priest. She said she had respect for everything that has to do with God. She was happy to share the ceremony with these strangers, but she regretted the way the notoriety affected her village and the careless use of the mushrooms by some of the hippies. She came to be honored by Mexico and many people.</p><p>A friend of mine has let me know of her experience: “I met Maria Sabina twice in her mountain village. Her village is well known for the beautiful embroidery the women make; beautiful bright flowers and birds. The people of her village loved her and resented the big researchers who came to visit, made lots of money from their publishing and she didn’t get a cent. The last time I was there someone had shown up with a film crew and all the men in the village surrounded her house and would not let them see her. It was powerful to feel their protection of her. She was poor as far as money goes. She gave me several beautiful huipils (embroidered tops she had made that I still wear!) and her house was very simple, earthy literally. She was a visionary and a dedicated healer, deeply committed to her inner life, a woman of integrity, also very practical. I assisted in a session she gave to a woman who visited her hoping for cure of cancer. Maria Sabina ate fresh picked mushrooms on a plate that was a tobacco leaf. In this case so did the woman. Then she sang and prayed all night. In the morning she treated the woman according to her visions. In the session I was at she was assisted by her sister. I certainly received a big download from her but it was mostly energetic — an experiential blessing!”</p><p>Eugenia Pineda Casimiro, one of the grandmother healers of the Mazateco tradition, stated that her people have a reverence for the sacred nature of the divine mushrooms, and approach the experience with psychedelic mushrooms with devotion and awe. She said that everyone has a belief system that forms one’s identity. The experience helps people find the essence of spirituality, which is experienced sometimes as a metaphor. She attends church and said it is in Mazateco and has chants and nature elements that are harmonious in many ways. She said that by accepting their experience, which includes the Indigenous as well as Catholic traditions, they honor themselves as well as their ancestors. Their experiences help them learn not to be so judgmental of other peoples’ experience.</p><p>Mestre Irineu:</p><p>Raimundo Irineu Serra, Mestre Irineu, was born in 1892 and grew to be seven feet tall. He founded Santo Daime, an ayahuasca religion, in 1930 in Rio Branco. He had gone to the western part of Brazil from a poor area in northern Brazil in 1912 to work in rubber tapping, but that industry began to collapse. He was initiated into the mysteries of ayahuasca by indigenous shamans in the upper Amazon near the border with Bolivia. He had a series of visions and revelations that included a vision of the Divine Mother who identified herself as “the queen of the forest.” According to the Daime tradition, on a clear and beautiful night, Irineu took ayahuasca and, as he looked up at the moon, he saw a beautiful and wondrous lady. She asked him, “Who do you think I am?” Irineu was amazed as he looked at her and he replied: “My lady, you must be a Universal Goddess!”</p><p>The goddess gave him guidance and told him to observe practices, which he undertook and she gave him the blessings of healing power and instruction on making ayahuasca with chacruna and the vine. The queen of the forest also taught him how to sing and asked for beautiful songs of devotion to be sung to her and he identified her as the Virgin Mary. She revealed to him that ayahuasca was the sacred blood of Jesus Christ giving light, love and strength, and he called it <em>daime</em>, a variation of “give me” in Portuguese, with the sense of asking for love and light.</p><p>Mestre Irineu was inspired to form the religion Santo Daime, which combined the medicine practice with African, Christian, and folk traditions with teachings about reincarnation and karma and Christian theology. He was not able to read and write, and he was a Black man from a slave tradition. His healing ability and popularity allowed him to build a church and an agricultural community. His first adherents were migrants from the jungle who were displaced rubber tappers. When he first started holding ayahuasca ceremonies, he met opposition from authorities who misunderstood his practices, and thought it was witchcraft. Irineu served time in prison in the early 1940s. He moved around and settled his church in Rio Branco in Acre State near Peru. The church began to draw well-placed citizens and it exhibited self-discipline and devotion. Their goal was to model unconditional love of neighbor, show devotion to Jesus and the saints, and carefully protect the formula for the sacrament <em>daime</em>. The church has been very particular about preparing ayahuasca the traditional way, and psychotria viridis is referred to as Queen of the Forest.</p><p>The services offer hymns that came to Mestre Irineu — and his followers wrote them down. They open and close with Christian prayers there is an emphasis on preparation beforehand for appropriate dedication. There are 132 hymns to portray strength, harmony and love, which revealed the course of his spiritual path. The ceremonies are called <em>trabalhos</em> or “works” and are organized rituals of different kinds, some contemplative, called concentrations, sitting upright quietly. The “hymnals” or dance ceremonies, have worshippers sing and dance for up to twelve hours, as the hymns guide the journeys. Services are dedicated to healing and promote personal responsibility, a wholesome lifestyle, love of nature, humility, fraternity and purity of heart.</p><p>There is a leader or godfather and controllers, an altar or table with the cross and symbols, and all the practitioners wear white. The symbols in the altar include a six-point star, a double cross to symbolize the second coming of the Spirit. The church motto is harmony, love, truth and justice.</p><p>Mestre Ieineu referred to the work of the church, from the beginning with his vision, as “Juramidam,” or God and God’s soldiers. After Mestre Irineu died in 1971, different branches and communities formed. The original community continues to function in the same place, led by Irineu Serra’s widow, Madrinha Peregrina Gomes Serra: the Luz Universal Christian Light Center — Alto Santo. Around 1980, Sebastiao Mota de Melo (Padrinho Sebastiao) formed a church and community, the Raimundo Irineu Serra Eclectic Center of Fluid Universal Light and a community centered on Santo Daime, in Ceu do Mapio, Amazonas State. This is the branch of Santo Daime that has the most practitioners, up to 10,000, and helped to spread this type of ayahuasca church to many places around the world.</p><p>Mestre Gabriel:</p><p>Known as Mestre Gabriel, Jose Gabriel da Costa was the founder of Centro Espirita Beneficente União do Vegetal, the largest, most organized, and most recent of the three main ayahuasca churches in Brazil. <em>União do Vegetal</em> means “union of the plants” in Portuguese, and is a reference to the two plants they know as <em>mariri</em>, the vine, and <em>chacrona</em>, the leaf, which combine to give the medicine its powerful effect which. Mestre Gabriel first had ayahuasca on April 1, 1959 at the Guarapari rubber camp, on the border between Brazil and Boliva. He had gone from Bahia in northeastern Brazil to the area of the Amazon in 1943 for wartime efforts to produce rubber. He had traveled between Porto Velho and rural rubber camps in the 1950s, and discovered the mestizo Peruvian ayahuasquero tradition that incorporated an exchange between Indian vegetalista healers and influences from other cultures.</p><p>In the 2012 biography The Messenger of God, Ruy Fabiano writes that Mestre Gabriel was looking for a way to help humanity and take evil away from human hearts. When he first drank ayahuasca, it was served without ritual and he recognized the need for one to recognize its spirit. He got up from his hammock and said, “Look, Chico, this is something from God, something serious. You don’t know how to work, you mx a lot. Whoever gives this tea is responsible for the people.” He found that it produces a state of consciousness that can amplify one’s perception and help people recognize their essentially spiritual nature and promote their moral and intellectual capacities.</p><p>Mestre Gabriel’s experience evoked the ancient origins of Hoasca and renewed the ritual with spiritual revelations. He became dedicated to working exclusively with Vegetal. Drawing upon the spiritual foundations of his day, and his personal experience, he led a structured group in Porto Velho with ayahuasca worship. He incorporated names from Quecha language and aspects of healing with plants, including nine other healing plants that he used initially. He had been steeped in his mother’s lay leadership in Catholicism and the Umbanda tradition, of southeastern Brazil, an African-Brazilian religion that he had actively practiced before. He developed devotional songs and practices. His vision drew on deeper mysteries that he felt had been lost and rediscovered. He taught that it had been a known sacrament from the time of King Solomon and reappeared during the Incan civilization, and that he had been involved with the medicine in previous incarnations. <em>União do Vegetal </em>also drew on a Kardecist spritism tradition that held that spirits of the dead, and psychic and magnetic forces, would intervene in the events on earth, and had teachings about reincarnation. He was guided by an Indian sprit, Sultan of the Forest, with knowledge of the medicines and secrets of the jungle.</p><p>Sandra Goulart, who conducted fieldwork and studied<em> União do Vegetal </em>wrote that one tradition that it holds is that twelve masters of curiosity, who preserved the tradition of ayahuasca, recognized him as having authority and complete knowledge to complete the elements of this lost tradition, blessing his efforts to reestablish it.</p><p>He founded the church on July 22, 1961, near Rondonia in the Amazonian state of Acre, Brazil, and moved it to Porto Velho in 1965, and is now centered at the capitol of Brasilia, with centers throughout the world. His purpose was “to heighten spiritual understanding and perception and bring practitioners closer to God.” He served without compensation, and earned income at various times working as a rubber worker, a bricklayer, and as a nurse.</p><p>The church celebrates with the sacrament of Hoasca Tea or Vegetal, with a goal to promote reverence for the medicine and its messages, and transparency among its members. Its practices involve simple dress, with green, a five-pointed star, seated ceremonies when everyone drinks at the same time, and last about four hours. Members will ordinarily drink medicine one or two times per month. Services and teachings are in Portuguese, and there is a is a council of mesters.</p><p>Mestre Gabriel sought to include the poor, the simple folk, and excluded people in the church. The church’s story is set forth in The History of Hoasca, which states that the Mariri vine and the Chacrona leaf encompass elements of the life of Christ. Mestre Gabriel is identified as the reincarnation of the first person ever to drink Vegetal on earth, and was a vassal of King Solomon, and remembered his mission, and was among the people who had been transformed to plants. He serves as a model of virtues such as generosity and devotion. The tea is regarded as providing spiritual healing, as opposed to physical healing. The church has a medical scientific department with health professionals. Its teachings do not accept the curandeirismo or folk healing traditions, and they believe those traditions had forgotten the original spiritual knowledge and proper context for taking Vegetal. Members will wear common clothing often with green and will typically drink Hoasca tea two times per month, and they all take it together at the signal of the mestre of their center. The church has many charitable activities such as literacy projects, clothing and book drives, sustainable agriculture projects, and a large preserve of 20,000 acres in Amazonas.</p><p>Some Influences from Psychedelic Experience and Christianity</p><p>Western proponents of psychedelics within the Christian tradition:</p><p>Huston Smith:</p><p>Huston Smith was a foremost scholar of mysticism and world religions and a leading figure in the psychedelic era. His writings about entheogens were collected from over the decades and published with funding by the Council on Spiritual Practices in a book titled <em>Cleansing the Doors of Perception — The Religious Significance of Entheogenic Plants and Chemicals</em>. He wrote that entheogens “have light to throw on the history of religion…and the religious life itself.”</p><p>He is best known for the 1958 book, which he expanded in 1991 and titled <em>The World’s Religions</em>.<em> </em>He was in a five-part television series with Bill Moyers in 1996. He taught the many religions reach toward the indescribable Absolute and help people bear fruit in the world and try to “turn our flashes of insight into abiding light.” He wrote that, “If we take the world’s enduring religions at their best, we discover the distilled wisdom of the human race.” He advocated for greater mutual appreciation, stating that, “If, then, we are to be true to our own faith, we must attend to others when they speak, as deeply and as alertly as we hope they will attend to us.”</p><p>He grew up in rural China where his parents were Protestant missionaries, and he saw poverty, illness, and death, as well as many diverse religions in practice around him. He had decided to teach about religion, and his focus turned toward mysticism, and away from scientific rationalism, as he was completing his Ph. D. when he read a book by Gerald Heard, <em>Pain, Sex and Time</em>. He met Mr. Heard, who encouraged him to meet Aldous Huxley in 1947. His meeting with Aldous Huxley led Dr. Smith to become active in The Vedanta Society of St. Louis, when he was teaching at Washington University and serving as an associate minister in a Methodist church. He began a lifelong practice of meditation.</p><p>Years later, after he had joined the faculty at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Dr. Smith and others invited Aldous Huxley to be a visiting lecturer there and conduct a lecture series in the fall of 1960 that was enormously popular. Mr. Huxley had written about visionary and mystical experiences with mescaline in <em>The Doors of Perception</em> and <em>Heaven and Hell</em>, titles drawn from the mystical poet William Blake. Prof. Smith confided to him that he had not had a genuine mystical experience, and this led Mr. Huxley to give him the telephone number of Timothy Leary, who was beginning a three-year appointment at Harvard University as a research professor for the study of personality. Dr. Leary had experienced a profound mystical experience in Mexico with psilocybin before arriving at The Center for Personality Research at Harvard, and he had decided to focus his research on psychedelics. He would lead The Harvard Psilocybin Project and begin conducting scientific studies to measure the benefits of entheogen-assisted psychotherapy with prison recidivism, alcoholism, and with personality disorders.</p><p>When they met, they arranged for Prof. Smith to have a professionally supervised session with mescaline on New Year’s Day in 1961 in Dr. Leary’s living room in Newton, Massachusetts. In a 1964 <em>Journal of Philosophy</em> essay, he wrote that he had a full range of impressions with beatific visions as well as fearful aspects to his experience. He found bands of consciousness, each one real, in layers with unclear boundaries, emanating both the eternal and momentary. A group met every month or so for three years for group psychedelic sessions with meetings using incense, candles, with readings from poetry or spiritual writings, or spontaneous observations. They also would meet socially for discussions and sharing experiences.</p><p>He was a designated guide for the research as well, participating in the Good Friday experiment in 1962, led by Walter Pahnke, with twenty divinity school students and ten supervising volunteers, in groups with four students and two guides, and half would be given psilocybin while the others got a control of nicotinic acid. He was one who had an experience with psilocybin and he said it was his first ever direct personal encounter with God when he was transported by a woman singing a hymn. He felt God’s love in a personal way and said he became a more considerate and positive person for many months. The study found a high incidence of mystical experiences among the active group. They all assembled listening below, in a basement chapel, to the two-and one-half hour Good Friday service. Years later in 1996, Prof. Smith revealed that one of the students who had had psilocybin thought he had to go out and proclaim a new messianic era, and he was able to escape, and Prof. Smith quickly sprang to follow him and got other helpers to follow him into the Boston area, and he was returned, and was the only person in his research who had to be administered Thorazine as an antidote to the effects.</p><p>His friends from the project and he began publication of <em>The Psychedelic Review</em>,<em> </em>which was in publication for ten years. Prof. Smith came to agree with Aldous Huxley that psychedelic experiences closely corresponded with spontaneous mystical experiences in the world religions, like near-death or sudden feelings of belonging. He cited studies showing one-quarter to one-third of ordinary population and three-quarters of people with a religious inclination would have mystical experiences with psychedelic-assisted therapy. When he shared the view that research showed that psychedelics were effective in bringing about an authentic religious experience, he had to consider and respond to the criticism of religious skeptics and traditionalists.</p><p>Huston Smith thought the best factors for measuring the validity of the entheogenic mystical experiences was how they affected the people. He argued that experiences should be joined with actions, such as better relations, more patience and equanimity, positive experiences, and morality, or altruistic responsibility. He disapproved of Dr. Leary’s departure from the therapist and researcher roles and becoming a public figure leading people to leave education and careers behind, and he did not view this counterculture movement as having staying power. He preferred the cautious and studied approach of his friends Aldous Huxley, Gerald Heard, Gordon Wasson and Albert Hofmann. He thought the tenets of the world religions all counseled in favor of positive activity to promote universal compassion. He cherished his heritage and others that recognize that we “are in caring hands and that in gratitude for that fact we should try to bear one another’s burdens.”</p><p>In his later career, he firmly decided not to take any more entheogens, but he carried forward their lessons of gratitude for this great gift of love in his thoughts and actions. He was dedicated to the Civil Rights Movement, he helped introduce the Dalai Lama to Americans, and he worked to promote understanding of Islam when people who purported to be Muslims engaged in destruction on 9/11. His career was long and full, and he shared the unifying vision of an omnipotent, caring, healing God through his work.</p><p>Stanislav Grof:</p><p>Stanislav Grof, M.D., is a psychiatrist and perhaps is the world’s most experienced authority on psychedelic-assisted psychotherapy. His career included supervising over 3000 sessions with patients using psychedelics. The vast amount of research on higher states of consciousness that the did during more than fifty years in Prague, Czech Republic, and in the United States, led him to become one of the principal developers the field of transpersonal psychology, the understanding that consciousness is not contained exclusively within the body.</p><p>Dr. Grof found that in the early stages of psychedelic-assisted therapy that everyone would have personal experiences of sensing and memory. In the later stages, however, something universal about the human experience confronting death would be revealed. Virtually all the subjects in the intense form of psychedelic therapy experienced death and rebirth in some form. He found that the psychedelic experience moves one toward wholeness and provides opportunities to experience and transcend death. People would see beyond this lifetime to an understanding about the soul journey that would be liberating and healing. Becoming convinced that death is followed by rebirth, and having other experiences in the transpersonal realm, brought an enormous potential to heal human anxiety, spur inner transformation, relieve people of a sense of isolation, and connect them with the collective psyche of humanity.</p><p>Dr. Grof founded the International Transpersonal Association and he is a proponent of the benefits of inner transformation that come from the human encounter with death.</p><p>Dr. Grof found that people’s initial experiences with psychedelic-assisted therapy were extremely unpredictable, with personal experiences on a sensory, emotional level and processing memories.</p><p>Aldous Huxley, Humphry Osmond, and Al Hubbard:</p><p>Aldous Huxley was a philosopher, a writer, a jazz pianist, and a mystic. His writings included science fiction, screen plays, social commentary, children’s books, and some of the seminal writings of the Psychedelic Movement. He was intrigued by the research of Dr. Humphry Osmond and Dr. John Smythies who were conducting clinical experiments using mescaline and LSD in Saskatchewan to learn more about the mind and mental illness. He sent them a copy of one of his books and an invitation to visit him, expressing his interest in the phenomena of hallucinations and mental illness, and stating an interest in taking mescaline.</p><p>In 1953, Dr. Humphry Osmond conducted successful research with psychedelics, first with mescaline and then with LSD, treating people with alcoholism in Saskatchewan. He invented the word psychedelic and helped edit one of the major books about psychedelics. In 1955, the American Psychiatric Association had a symposium on psychedelics. Aldous Huxley addressed that conference, and a book edited by Louis Cholden, LSD and Mescaline in Experimental Psychiatry, was released based upon papers presented at the conference. By the mid-1960s, there had been over one thousand publications presenting encouraging results of well-funded studies with able staff, with about 40,000 participants in LSD therapy. It was the subject of six international conferences. In the late 1950s and early 1960s, researchers like Al Hubbard, psychiatrists Sidney Cohen, Oscar Janigar, A. Wesley Mitford, and Arthur Chandler, who formed the Beverly Hills Psychiatric Institute with radiologist Mortimer Hartman (who was the LSD therapist of actor Cary Grant and many others), were active in the field of psychedelic research or therapy.</p><p>Dr. Osmond went to Los Angeles for a psychiatric convention and on May 4, 1953, he supervised Mr. Huxley’s experience with mescaline and had him write about his impressions. In his 1954 book about this experience, The Doors of Perception, he wrote that after one and one-half hours he felt as though he had passed through a screen and saw “what Adam had seen on the morning of creation.” Everything was shining with its own inner light, charged with significance, like pure Being, the source of existence. It was “the miracle, moment by moment, of naked existence.” Mr. Huxley wrote that he witnessed “eternity in a flower, infinity in four chair legs, and the Absolute in the folds of a pair of flannel trousers.” He wrote, “The Mind at Large seeps past the no longer watertight valve,” opening up a field of thoughts and impressions. He repeatedly said, “This is how everyone ought to see.”</p><p>Aldous Huxley had been fascinated by inner experience and the realities that lie beyond the senses. At age 16, after his mother’s death, an illness left him almost completely blind for a year and a half. This prevented him from being in World War I and left him with diminished vision. He would use a small telescope and magnifying glass throughout his life. Mr. Huxley had written the successful novel Brave New World in 1932, expressing concern about how authoritarian government could manipulate people with technology and automation, or use subliminal messages to appeal to emotions to overtake their humanity. He moved with his wife Maria to Los Angeles, near Hollywood, in 1937. He wrote successful screenplays for the movies “Madam Curie,” and “Pride and Prejudice.”</p><p>He and his British friend Gerald Heard, an author and teacher of science, religion, and philosophy, pursued a common interest in access to the unconscious and the evolution of consciousness, and universalism, the belief that one common truth underlies the differences in religion. He studied Vedanta, the unitary vision in Hinduism. Mr. Huxley wrote about mysticism in religious traditions in his 1945 work, The Perennial Philosophy. He made friends with Jiddu Krishnamurti. He and Maria would have Tuesday evening study groups to discuss meditation, hypnosis, extrasensory perception, and similar topics.</p><p>In 1954, he lectured on “The Far Continents of the Mind,” at the International Conferences of Parapsychological Studies and a couple of years later, he was invited to lecture at the American Psychoanalytic Association convention. In 1955, he helped Maria navigate her transition from life using insight from the Tibetan Book of the Dead. His second essay about a mescaline trip, Heaven and Hell, was released in 1956. He argued that the experiences were not “mere chemical religion,” but like the physiological effects of prolonged fasting like people in medieval times would experience, or self-flagellation or prolonged chanting or meditation. His work brought him to the forefront of a spiritual and scientific movement fascinated by consciousness. The word “psychedelic,” meaning manifesting the mind, was created by his friend, Dr. Osmond, in correspondence with him as they explored new terms for hallucinogen or psychotomimetic in March 1957.</p><p>“Captain” Al Hubbard, known as the Johnny Appleseed of LSD, was a fervent Catholic. He apparently had friends in government. At a time when scientists in lab coats were providing psychedelics in sterile environments and creating the expectation of psychosis, his contribution was the specially-designed psychedelic therapy session room called the Hubbard room. It provided stereo music, spiritual images, a small altar, and burning candles, usually with himself as a guide. He developed and promoted a method to induce transcendental experience in a large percentage of participants, and shared his knowledge throughout the world. He taught the importance of set and setting, about subtleties such as which music is best to use, and how facilitators should behave to lead people to the Beatific Vision.</p><p>Al Hubbard embodied the spirit of curiosity that characterized the early psychedelic research and he is one of the most inscrutable personalities of that era. He was known as the Johnny Appleseed of LSD. By 1959, he stated that he had led 1700 LSD sessions and he had contributed to an LSD therapy manual that came into use that year. In 1957, Vancouver’s Cathedral of the Holy Rosary released an announcement stating that it would approach the study of psychedelics and their influence on the mind, with an approach anxious to discover whatever attributes they possess, respectfully evaluating their place in the Divine Economy and calling for their use to know and understand creation and benefit humanity.</p><p>The late 1950s and early 1960s were a time when people like friend Al Hubbard, and psychiatrists Sidney Cohen, Oscar Janigar, A. Wesley Mitford, and Arthur Chandler, who formed the Beverly Hills Psychiatric Institute with radiologist Mortimer Hartman (who was the LSD therapist of actor Cary Grant and many others), were active in the field of psychedelic research or therapy. He had a full mystical experience on LSD with psychedelic assisted therapy in 1960, and he distinguished visionary experiences from full unitary mystical awakening. His friend Huston Smith, a scholar of comparative religion who was teaching comparative religion at MIT, invited Mr. Huxley to lecture at MIT. In the fall of 1960, he gave a series of lectures that fall, “What a Piece of Work is Man,” which were enormously popular. He met Dr. Timothy Leary, who attended his lecture on November 8, 1960, and later he had psilocybin at his house. He appreciated Dr. Leary’s enthusiasm and his connections and his theoretical orientation, and shared his goal to enlist luminaries from philosophy, literature, art and science to have mystical experiences with psychedelics, but he became concerned that he created trouble and scorned accepted scientific models in his research.</p><p>In 1961, he rescued his manuscript for his final novel, Island, from a fire that destroyed the home he and his second wife, Laura, had near Hollywood. It depicted a society that balanced body and mind and employed a mystical sacrament, moksha medicine, from the Sanskrit word for liberation. It revealed truth and beatific glimpses of enlightening and liberating grace and another world, and helped sustain a utopian society. It would be taken for initiation into society and every year or so to help people realize their potential. People were told, “You will know what it’s like to be what in fact you always have been. It remains for you to decide whether you’ll cooperate with grace and take those opportunities.”</p><p>He died on November 22, 1963, the day that John Kennedy was assassinated, after receiving requesting administrations of LSD to help with his transition. The third issue of Psychedelic Review in 1964 was a memorial about him. One of his interviews was published in November 1963 interview, in Playboy Magazine, called “The Pros and Cons: History and Future Possibilities of Vision-Inducing Psychochemicals, A Philosopher’s Visionary Prediction.”</p><p>In her book <em>This Timeless Moment: A Personal View of Aldous Huxley</em>, Laura Huxley described how the author, at the end of his life, requested an administration of LSD for this soul journey. She had him tell her whom he wanted to join him in taking that medicine, and then she imparted to him the advice we all would be well to heed. She felt the relief that he had accepted his death and she repeated to him, “light and free. Light and free you let go, darling; forward and up. You are going forward and up; you are going toward the light. Willingly and consciously you are going, willingly and consciously, and you are doing this beautifully — you are going toward the light — you are going toward a greater love — you are going forward and up. You are going toward Maria’s love with my love. You are going toward a greater love than you have ever known. You are going toward the best, the greatest love, and it is easy, it is so easy, and you are doing it beautifully.”</p><p>They waited in silence for hours. She had administered a second 100 microgram dosage when the first had not had much effect. When it came near the time, Laura Huxley continued: “It is easy, and you are doing this beautifully and consciously, in full awareness, in full awareness, darling and you are going toward the light.” She repeated this the last three or four hours. Then she said, “Easy, easy, and you are doing this willingly and consciously and beautifully — going forward and up, light and free, forward and up toward the light, into the light, into complete light.” He gently slipped away afterward, embracing the light we all hope to share when we take off the tight shoe of this life, and go toward a greater love than we have ever known.</p><p>Alan Watts:</p><p>In 1968, Alan Watts, a philosopher of religion, wrote an article, “Psychedelics and Religious Experience,” for the California Law Review, stating that psychedelics can facilitate genuine religious experience and should not be prohibited by law. He was a gifted speaker, teacher and writer who embraced a unitary vision of the universe. He wrote about twenty books, including his 1962 book The Joyous Cosmology: Adventures in the Chemistry of Consciousness, revealing his experiences with three consciousness-expanding psychedelics: LSD, mescaline, and psilocybin. He praised their ability to bring about religious experience and insights that facilitate personal transformation “when accompanied with sustained philosophical reflection by a person who is in search, not of kicks, but of understanding.”</p><p>At a young age, Alan Watts embraced Buddhist teachings when his father began taking him to the Buddhist Lodge in London. He came to America in 1938 at the age of 23 and continued studying Zen Buddhism, which teaches a path to enlightenment by work to eliminate selfish craving and practice mindfulness and inward contemplation. Then, he studied Christianity, becoming an Episcopal priest from 1944 to 1950, and served as chaplain at Northwestern University. He wrote Behold the Spirit in 1947, describing a mystical approach to Christianity that revealed the “gold within the sectarian dross of every great religion.” He urged a mystical understanding of the statements of Jesus as being unified with God, and Paul’s statement of being alive in the Holy Spirit. Instead of a cosmology regarding God as a king, he advocated an awareness of a unified field with awareness everywhere and encouraged spiritual practices seeking self-realized awakening of compassion.</p><p>In 1959, he had LSD at U.C.L.A. Medical School, and later that year at a clinic in San Francisco, an experience he described as a profound experience deeper than any of his previous naturally-occurring experiences. He described psychedelics as “instruments, like microscopes, and telephones,” and urged people to apply the lessons and work with what they had seen. An influential research book from 1966, The Varieties of Psychedelic Experience, by Masters and Houston, identified four levels of experience in their research with peyote and LSD: sensory, recollective-analytic, symbolic and integral. They included a record from Alan Watts about a psychedelic mystical experience at the highest level. After various impressions his mind opens and he describes a great release: “I feel, with a peace so deep that it sings to be shared with all the world, that at last I belong, that I have returned to the home beyond home…The sure foundation upon which I had sought to stand has turned out to be the center from which I seek.”</p><p>Mr. Watts gave lectures on Zen and eastern religion in San Francisco, including a notable one at the Avalon Ballroom in 1967. His book titled The Book: On the Taboo Against Knowing Who You Are came out in 1966, as did an influential article in The Oracle. His popular radio show and writings inspired individual and societal liberation with accessible discussions of Buddhist and ecological ideas. He was friends with beat poet Gary Snyder, and inspired Jack Kerouac, an author of the Beat generation, who included him as a character in two of his novels. He offered a view of non-dualistic spirituality that awakened the imagination of the Beat generation and, later, the counter-culture of the 1960s.</p><p>Alan Watts became fascinated by parallels between mystical experience and insights from physics about energy and matter. He served as the president of the Society of Comparative Philosophy. He spoke at Esalen Institute and at colleges and in seminars and entertained friends on his ferryboat, many of whom were artists in the Druid Heights artist community. He moved to a cabin around Mount Tamalpais in the late 1960s and wrote mountain journals and continued to tour until he died in 1973 at the age of 58.</p><p>Mr. Watts argued that psychedelics should be legal because they reveal hidden truths and can lead to transformation of consciousness with greater compassion and interest in ecology and sustainability. They deepen the significance of the present moment in life, reveal how differences become parts of each other in a unified field of an eternal energy, and reveal a sense of connectivity in which all forms of life are a variation on the same theme. He recognized that the experiences can bring about anxiety, when people are lost in the corridors of the mind or experience shifting conceptions of reality, and can lead to conflict with a society not ready for challenges to authority and a patriarchal image of God. He stated: “Lack of awareness of the basic unity of organism and environment is a serious and dangerous hallucination” that leads to alienation from nature and hostility to others.</p><p>Alan Watts had a mystical experience on psychedelics in 1962. He described his impressions of a church chorus, how a priest chanting a mass with a chorus of nuns seemed to represent the depth of the history of the church, then seeming to be artificial, but this gave way to ancestral struggle in which the nuns seem to overpower the priest. The ancestral symbolism of survival then becomes a deeper experience.</p><p>Walter Pahnke, Bill Richards, and the Good Friday Experiment:</p><p>William A. Richards, Ph.D., is a clinical psychologist who was at the forefront of the original entheogen studies in the mid-1960s and is again one of the leading psychotherapists during the psychedelic renaissance. Dr. Richards earned two degrees from divinity schools and a Ph.D. in education and counseling. In his 2016 book, Sacred Knowledge, Psychedelics and Religious Experiences, Dr. Richards, wrote about his religious experience during his first session with synthetic psilocybin. It was on December 4, 1963, part of a program intended to shed light on schizophrenia, headed by the psychiatrist Hanscarl Leuner, in Germany. Amazing undulating designs, a field of flowing energy filled with multidimensional symbolism, gave way to a full mystical experience outside of time, flooding him with awe, glory, and gratitude. He realized that he was incapable of describing what had happened to him, after the summation of his revelation, “Reality is. It is perhaps not important what one thinks about it!” did not convey its power. He found, however, that the memory remained vividly accessible and it was a “pivotal fulcrum that provided clarity and direction” as his path unfolded.</p><p>Walter Pahnke was a Ph.D. student at Harvard University when he conducted the Good Friday experiment on April 20, 1962. It was the most significant study of the Harvard Psilocybin Project. For years was the leading experiment showing that psilocybin can facilitate experiences of mysticism in people disposed toward spirituality when used in a conducive setting. The project was carefully designed to provide supportive conditions to induce a profound experience which could be measured by psychometric assessments. It was the basis for the Ph.D. thesis for his program in religion and society.</p><p>The volunteers for the experiment were twenty divinity school students from Andover-Newton Theological Seminary, and ten leaders who were professors or graduate students with psychedelic experience. Dr. Leary had insisted that half of the leaders also receive the psilocybin. No one knew who would receive the psilocybin, which was a 30 mg. dose for participants and a 15 mg. dose for the leaders, and who received an identically appearing control of nicotinic acid.</p><p>To prepare, the participants had a physical examination and filled out a questionnaire that gathered information about their personalities and prior religious experiences to match them in five groups of four participants and two leaders. They were matched to promote friendship and trust. They listened below Marsh Chapel at Boston University to a two-and-one-half hour service with music, prayers, and a sermon by Rev. Howard Thurman. The experiment found a very high correlation for the participants who took psilocybin and profound healing mystical experiences. The experiment employed a questionnaire which Dr. Pahnke prepared to measure the experience, adopting categories identified by the work of W.T. Stace as representing the characteristics of fundamental, universal mystical experiences., with responses showing the active participants responded that they experienced: (1) sense of unity or oneness; (2) transcendence of space and time; (3) deeply felt positive mood, blessedness, peace; (4) sense of sacredness; (5) objectivity, reality, and intuitive knowledge; (6) paradoxicality; and (7) alleged ineffability, which both refer to the difficulty of grasping the experience by language and logical thinking; (8) transiency; and (9) persisting positive changes in attitude and behavior.</p><p>Dr. Pahnke’s 1966 article about the Good Friday experiment was published in 1970 in the Aaronson and Osmond publication <em>Psychedelics</em>. He stated that psychedelics help facilitate experiences of mysticism, and that researchers identified similarities in descriptive language of the experimental subjects to the descriptions found in the descriptions of people having spontaneous mystical experiences.</p><p>Dr. Pahnke worked together with Dr. Bill Richards in psychedelic-assisted therapy, beginning with a psilocybin assisted therapy research project in Boston in 1966, and later at Spring Grove, which became the Maryland Psychiatric Research Center. Dr. Pahnke was the director of clinical sciences there, practicing “Psychedelic Peak Therapy” using music in therapeutic experiences supervising about 600 sessions as part of teams with male and female therapists with sessions of 200 to 400 micrograms of LSD. The process included screening, ten to twenty hours of intensive psychotherapy before the sessions and as many hours as needed for integrations afterwards. Results were measured with psychological tests. A music therapist would meet in advance to learn about the patient’s musical history and preferences, and to try out selections, to ensure that the playlist would complement the therapeutic objectives of promoting intense, positive cosmic and transcendental experiences.</p><p>Dr. Pahnke was sensitive to the concern about adverse reactions as well as the potential for benefits from mystical experiences. In the early research he conducted, he found how important preparation, support during therapy, administration in a comfortable setting, and integration of the experience are to decreasing adverse psychological reactions and promoting beneficial results. Preparatory sessions would foster trust and rapport with guides and minimize fear and anxiety.</p><p>Dr. Pahnke co-authored with Bill Richards an article, <em>Implications of LSD and Experimental Mysticism</em>., published in 1969. They showed how LSD, used in in controlled studies and clinical trials, frequently produced psychedelic peak or mystical experiences. These experiences brought about positive clinical outcomes with patients suffering from advanced terminal conditions. The psychedelics could improve the quality of life for terminally ill cancer patients even with a single session. It would provide a sense of security that transcends even death. The patients had decreased anxiety and worry, diminished need for pain medicine, and more serenity, peace, and calmness. By helping reduce one’s fear of death, one becomes more able to live more meaningfully in the present and attend to things that are most significant in the here and now. Dr. Pahnke said: “If the use of psychedelic psychotherapy for the dying patient ever should become widespread in our society, there would probably be a change in our whole approach toward death. There might be less fear and more acceptance of this part of the life process.”</p><p>According to Lester Grinspoon and James Bakalar, in the 1979 book Psychedelic Drugs Reconsidered, there were over 500 papers on LSD in print in 1960. At the time they published their book, investigations had revealed a longstanding effort by American intelligence and military agencies had abused psychedelics in human experimentation, often with casual acceptance among academic professionals. They noted on page 61 that the academic interest in LSD and its adoption by the wider culture “had their own intellectual and social roots independent of and sometimes opposed to government interests.” Research showed that ordinary people would have religious experiences in psychedelic-assisted psychotherapy, about one-third, and about three-fourths would if they had religious proclivities, up to 90 % in religious settings with that purpose.</p><p>Building on the often forgotten, previous research, a new generation of scientists is proving the benefit of psychedelics in helping with resistant depression and promotion of spiritual experience, to ease the fear of death, and limit the effects of posttraumatic stress disorder.</p><p>The psychiatrist Charles Grob, who is a professor at the University of California at Los Angeles, initially studied with MDMA and ayahuasca before focusing on the benefits of psilocybin for alleviating pain and depression for end-stage cancer patients. Dr. Grob and colleagues published results of successful studies with psilocybin in 2011, in the Archives of General Psychiatry, that showed the ability of this psychedelic to ease anxiety about death in subjects with advanced-stage cancer. Dr. Grob has stressed that when psychedelics are used in socially-sanctioned settings, consistently with community standards and as part of culturally cohesive practices, the potential of entheogens can be observed, and the substantial risks of adverse reactions can be minimized.</p><p>Roland Griffiths, Ph.D., was a Professor in the Departments of Psychiatry and Neurosciences at the Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine, and founding Director of the Johns Hopkins Center on Psychedelic and Consciousness Research. In 1999, Bill Richards and Roland Griffiths spearheaded a study at Johns Hopkins School of Medicine, using a double-blind experiment with psilocybin or Ritalin, in which two-thirds of the active subjects said it was among the five most important events of their lives and many volunteers experienced enduring positive effects.</p><p>An article in July of 2006 by Dr. Griffiths and researchers, William A. Richards, U. McCann, and Robert Jesse, was published in the journal <em>Psychopharmacology</em>. This was a major breakthrough in showing the benefits of psychedelic therapy. The article was titled “Psilocybin Can Occasion Mystical-Type Experiences Having Substantial and Sustained Personal Meaning and Spiritual Significance.” The results showed that 58 % had had a complete mystical experience. After two months, two-thirds of volunteers said that the psilocybin session was the most, or one of the five most spiritually significant experiences of their lives. At 14 months afterward, 58 % stated that it was among the most meaningful, and 67 % said it was among the most spiritually significant experiences of their lives.</p><p>Dr. Griffiths published similar research in 2008 showing long-term benefits from psilocybin in people who participated regularly in religiously-oriented activities. Thirty participants reported improved positive attitudes about life and self, mood, altruism, and behavior. Two-thirds rated the experience as the most or one of the five most meaningful experiences of their lives, while a similar number, 64 %, reported having greater life satisfaction and well-being due to the experience.</p><p>Ken Kesey:</p><p>Ken Kesey described himself as an “acid head Christian” and he taught Sunday school. In April 1992, Mr. Kesey spoke to a group of people before a reading he did, in costume, at a small college in the hills of Tennessee. I heard him describe his orientation toward Christianity. He had had a series of visions that had led him to accept Christ’s teachings. “I wish that some of these people who claim to be Christian would practice what they preach,” he said, and we need to call them on their actions that depart from the message of love. His purpose was to make this a better place to live. He suggested one good way would be to help old people, to value their presence and keep them company. He was very happy to be outdoors, saying, “The spirits really communicate outside.” He spoke fondly of the 1970s, when people were in tune, and opening their minds. He spoke of the picture of the young man placing flowers in the rifle barrels of guardsmen pointing their weapons at war protesters.</p><p>Mr. Kesey urged people to claim their own traditions, but to stand up for their core principles and not follow blindly. He said that there is something worse than greed, worse than evil, about the willingness to pollute rivers. He explained that we must avoid selling the inheritance of the sacred Earth, that we need to resist the people who want to sell out something precious for profit like that. He urged us to notice hope, to see the one guard at the jail who tries to be fair, the police officer who does not give in to corruption, and that we cannot give up. He said that we need to be willing to take the wheel when there is a crazy person driving. Our country’s culture is young, and if we cannot do it here, we are not going to be able to do it anywhere.</p><p>Mr. Kesey said that there is always pressure to get sucked into the corruption of greed and money and personal comfort, but resistance is necessary to defend what is valuable. He said that it is necessary periodically to clean your compass point so it will point in the right direction. One way to do this is to have a personal tragedy, to engage in prayer, and one way is to have an LSD trip, an experience that strips you to the basics of life. He said that the people who were taking psychedelics and hyperventilating fifteen times and passing out are the most free-spirited and adventurous; they are the ones we need to lead the way.</p><p>Walter Houston Clark and Salvador Roquet</p><p>Walter Houston Clark was a professor at Andover-Newton Theological Seminary who was a participant in the Good Friday experiment. He authored the book, Chemical Ecstacy, about religious use of psychedelics and spoke in favor of the benefits of psychedelics to provide direct experience of the sacred. He described a distinction between what he termed “churchianity,” a dry formalism of rituals devoid of metaphysic, and Christianity, which was based on the experience of transcendence, which he argued could be available through carefully administered experience with psychedelics.</p><p>Dr. Clark was an advocate of the practices of Dr. Salvador Roquet, M.D., a Mexican psychiatrist who actively led group psychedelic-assisted psychotherapy in Mexico City from 1967 until 1974. Dr. Roquet was a Roman Catholic. He opened the Institute of Psychosynthesis in Mexico City in October 1967 using techniques he learned from Maria Sabina and Huichol healers. He used a variety of entheogens: LSD, mescaline, psilocybin, <em>Rivea corymbosa, </em>ketamine, MDA, Datura species, and <em>Salvia divinorum</em> administered in a series of monthly administrations. Dr. Roquet’s multi- media convivial sessions would create a sense of chaos and help people confront their basic nature and then help synthesize their feelings through mutual support. The group therapy sessions would include 15 to 30 participants and last about 20 hours. They would begin with taking the Hartman test which could identify issues with fantasy, anguish, and distortion for the work to be done. They entered a large prepared room for the disintegrative phase. There were stereos, strobe lights, film projectors for slides and movies projecting beautiful, happy, funny, cruel, and disturbing images. He and his assistants would create a sense of chaos or sensory overload. They would show themes of birth, death, childhood, love, violence, sexuality, spiritual themes, and representations of evil.</p><p>Dr. Roquet was arrested in 1974 and imprisoned for five months in Mexico. He was released in April 1975 after political pressure and testimonials from psychotherapists who cited benefits to his former patients. The process helped people grow and process through rigid emotional barriers. Dr. Roquet asserted that he had been able to help about 85 % of his patients, and that the other participants would be of great comfort to one another and show great empathy. The process helped promote a sense of healing and vitality. He believed that there is a close connection between madness and the mystical experience, and that it is practically a prerequisite.</p><p>The Church of the Awakening</p><p>The Church of the Awakening was founded in 1963 by two osteopathic physicians, John and Louise Aiken, who were Presbyterians living in New Mexico. They founded the church as a fellowship for spiritual evolution and growth when they began inner explorations after their two adult sons both had died in tragic accidents. They sought a deeper understanding of the true nature of existence than physical existence, a universal, omnipresent, and omnipotent reality. They explored paranormal activity, deep meditation, and prayer, to promote enhancement of growth in love and understanding, and the concurrent diminution of egotism and selfishness. Psychedelics, edited by Aaronson and Osmond at 178 (1970). They learned about psychedelics and were able to obtain peyote from the Rio Grande Valley, and later they also employed mescaline as one of their sacraments. They found that these substances, when used with reverence and careful preparation not more frequently than every three months, were very helpful in achieving spiritual growth and maturity.</p><p>One aspect of their practices was to observe proper and respectful sacramental use of peyote, which they regarded as an agent that aided their search for the spiritual meaning of life. They did not have a specific body of doctrine, and were focused more on experience than on beliefs. The psychedelic sacraments were administered to prepared and qualified individuals by trained monitors and ministers. Dr. Aiken wrote that their intention was to begin an entry to deeper purpose, opening to a pathway of personal growth employing various means, with an emphasis on individual efforts to meet challenges and develop inner life. They maintained that the bona fide ceremonial use of peyote and mescaline should be equally available to individuals not of American Indian origin. In 1972, a federal court denied the Church of the Awakening’s appeal of a denial of an exemption from anti-peyote laws by the Bureau of Narcotics and Dangerous Drugs.</p><p>Reflections</p><p>The courts considering religious protection for psychedelics appear to be more attracted to the familiar types of ceremonies. Although the Christian traditions have been a source of hostility in years past to the potential spiritual benefits of psychedelics, and there is most recently a great deal of ambivalence by organized religion toward traditional uses and modern applications of psychedelics. The court decisions emphasize that it is the sincerity of the adherents that is a principal area of focus, along with a showing of low risk of harm. Greater protection for sincere religious practices using psychedelics is likely through court decisions, state and federal legislation, and local ordinances as scientific research and legal psychedelic assisted psychotherapy yield results showing spiritual transformation and other benefits, particularly with psilocybin, which is very safe from a physiological standpoint.</p><p>Americans are supporting greater access to natural medicines for healing of trauma and for spiritual exploration. There has been pressure to limit their use to a medical context, which appears to be financially prohibitive for most people and restricts access to people presenting themselves as having a mental health pathology. Legal protections are likely to expand and incorporate celebratory and exploratory adult use of psychedelic medicines, as well as a broader category of spiritual exploration that would not depend on insincere presentation or cultural appropriation of another society’s traditions.</p><p>North American and European experience faces the problem of an absence of accepted psychedelic spiritual traditions. Authoritarian structures eliminated psychedelic practices in ancient Greece and Europe, and throughout the colonial empires in the Americas and Africa. North American religious institutions have been at the forefront of efforts to suppress and eliminate the longstanding traditions in Central and South America. Traditions in other countries that go back many centuries have survived by withstanding and evading extreme persecution by religious and governmental authorities.</p><p>Opposition by mainstream religions and legal authorities, and the social stigma associated with drug culture and psychedelics, have resulted in ordinary people having no legal access to psychedelics. These forces have also inhibited or prevented formation of social groups and organizations that would have developed naturally to provide practices and social reinforcement for safer practices and risk reduction. The United States judicial system is inhibited by initial experience of its society with psychedelics because of missteps, abuses, and inappropriate uses that led to adverse consequences, and because of the insights that led to challenges to mainstream society’s expectations of social conformity.</p><p>Many people in the West are moving away from traditional organized religion or becoming more entrenched in religious institutions that are firmly opposed to ceremonial use of entheogens. There is a crosscurrent of influences that could inform a more universal spiritual message consistent with the experience of an unfolding psychedelic journey. Disenchantment with mainstream religious institutions can help reveal beneficial and more holistic theologies from other traditional frameworks, and open worldviews to incorporate new ideas and realizations drawn from individual and community experience. Some of the challenges to having a more universal, experience-based religion that incorporates psychedelic substances include improper or corrupt motivations by leaders, inadequate preparation or exploitation of vulnerable participants in a hyper-suggestible mental and emotional state, incompetency in administration of the sacraments or in addressing uncomfortable or hazardous reactions, factionalism, divisiveness, envy, and misunderstanding between leaders, an absence of reverence for the medicines, and disrespect of the viewpoints and experience of other participants.</p><p>Careful, deliberate, and confident preparation and oversight can help mitigate risks and provide a safe container for an inward healing process that can afford people with a deepened sense of connection with nature, community, the ground of being, and contact with the numinous. The psychedelic experience can provide a sense of greater aliveness and motivation through restorative insights that bring about gratitude, love, forgiveness, and compassion. It creates the potential to bring about a clarity of awareness about one’s own experience and motivations, and exposing one to truths about one’s past actions and experiences that can enhance insight and motivation for transformation. It can motivate the inner work to transform in more engaging and positive ways.</p><p>While programs for adult use in non-clinical settings evolve, Colorado’s program will be a fine example of the guidelines most beneficial to employ in providing a safe container. People will have an opportunity to shed layers of resistance and deepen understanding and compassion for oneself and for others, and other opportunities for personal transformation due to a mysterious neuroplasticity process that can reveal unfamiliar types of awareness. Risk mitigation practices with informed consent for voluntary participation with disclosures of risks, and accountability for best practices, will contribute to reaching the greatest potential for psychedelics.</p><p>Psychedelic group and individual settings for healthy adults are likely to evolve and develop with myriad influences, reaching in differing directions and coalescing sometimes when their ways find common ground. A group could meet in a retreat setting with careful leadership that should be able to include multiple spiritual frameworks with such moral precepts and self-discipline, but without a rigid or fundamentalist viewpoint particular to an insular religion.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=6c154c2b9454" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[This is a story about a student organization that I started in 1976, after being inspired by my…]]></title>
            <link>https://ronmcnutt.medium.com/this-is-a-story-about-a-student-organization-that-i-started-in-1976-after-being-inspired-by-my-5f24b8d719e9?source=rss-368797e78488------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5f24b8d719e9</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ronald W. McNutt]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 09 Jan 2025 20:48:26 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-01-09T20:48:50.319Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*91kHFN2TkPXw0Z2JGQMX6A.jpeg" /></figure><p>This is a story about a student organization that I started in 1976, after being inspired by my Altered States of Consciousness class, the professor who offered the course, and experience with psychedelics. It was published in the Tufts student Newspaper, The Tufts Daily as a letter to the editor on October 16, 2019. Thanks to the editors of that publication.</p><p>Former Tufts professor Sam McLaughlin celebrated his 95th birthday on Oct. 6, 2019. During the spring in 1976, my sophomore year, he taught the most exciting class I ever took: Psychology 10, “Altered States of Consciousness.” It was Sam’s last year teaching before he retired to move with his wife to his farmhouse in Limerick, Maine. Sam was an inspiring and energetic speaker himself, and he offered a wide variety of amazing and accomplished speakers to the students who would assemble three afternoons per week in Goddard Chapel. The course inspired me to form and lead a student organization named the Tufts Altered States of Consciousness Organization, and we became lifelong friends.</p><p>In preparation for this tribute, I called Sam and asked him about his experience and impressions. He told me that he had taught the course for several years, once per year. Sam was inspired to offer the course based upon his own experience with psychedelics. He would always invite guest speakers, and in 1976, he had so many speakers he hardly had the opportunity to give lectures himself. The course had grown to the point that he had enrollment limited to 300 students, and he had to hold it in Goddard Chapel because of its size. He wanted his final year to be a course that no one would forget.</p><p>Sam and his guests discussed the science and spiritual aspects of states of consciousness, such as in dream states, meditation, kundalini yoga, and those brought about when using psychedelics, like LSD, psilocybin, ayahuasca, peyote and marijuana. We learned how different parts of the brain are active in different states of awareness and that it is beneficial for people to navigate through different moods and states of awareness. We studied the many levels of consciousness and perception, how perception plays a role in creativity and the curious role of the unconscious mind. Scientists explored near-death experience, spontaneous healing and how the mind can cause psychogenic diseases but also promote the innate and miraculous healing potential, not unlike spiritual awakening. We learned about the benefits of mystical experience, characterized by the perception of unity, a sense that it is more real than waking consciousness and the feeling of transcending space and time.</p><p>Our textbooks and lectures revealed not only the traditional uses of plant hallucinogens, or entheogens, in history and contemporary indigenous cultures, but also how they and LSD recently had been used successfully in psychotherapy and in experimental research.</p><p>Dr. Norman Zinberg, a psychiatrist who had experimented with the effects of marijuana on humans, stressed that social reinforcement has a major role in helping to minimize the great dangers of addiction, and that when a substance is illegal there is not as much information coming from older generations. Walter Clark, a professor at Andover-Newton Theological Seminary and author of a book about religious use of psychedelics, spoke about his experience with group psychedelic therapy sessions led by Dr. Salvador Roquet. Dr. Roquet had been able to help about 85% of his patients in sessions that would begin with creating a sense of chaos and leading people to synthesize their feelings and achieve a sense of vitality.</p><p>Dr. Harvey Cox, a professor at the Harvard Divinity School, spoke about his participation in the peyote ritual of the Huichol tribe of north- and central-Mexico. This had a deep spiritual impact on him and provided lasting benefits including becoming more receptive to other religious experiences.</p><p>We learned the importance of the “inner life” and the long-term benefits of deep relaxation states. Tufts professor Seymour Simches, founder of the Tufts European Center, shared teachings of Carl Jung who viewed dreams as a source of inner wisdom to expand our limited sense of identity. A psychotherapist invited students to a new way of life simply by being committed to honesty with our feelings. Various speakers shared information about meditation, yoga and religion. They invited us to use meditation to help direct thoughts away from selfishness and occupy space more graciously so that we could be more centered, and dark aspects of life would loosen their hold on our emotions.</p><p>Ram Dass (A’52), a Harvard University psychology professor who helped pioneer research into the potential of psychedelics, shared wisdom he learned under the guidance of yogi Neem Karoli Baba. In a calm and peaceful way, punctuated with humor and love, he spoke about identifying with our souls and not being attached to desires and expectations. He taught that devotion to something higher than ourselves allows us to love the perfection around us and in one another.</p><p>When the class was nearing its conclusion in the spring, Sam invited interested students to discuss forming a student organization to continue learning about consciousness after he retired. The following year, I attended three meetings with the Committee on Student Life and faced strong opposition to the proposal from some of the professors. The Altered States of Consciousness Organization became a recognized organization, however, thanks to the University Chaplain Robert Miller, who spoke up in favor of preserving free speech principles and encouraging thought and inquiry.</p><p>The organization presented various speakers on topics ranging from temporal lobe epilepsy and transcendental meditation to a series on marijuana including author Bill Novak, Dr. Norman Zinberg and entrepreneur Laurence McKinney. Sam returned to speak a couple of times, and Clark spoke again about religious use of psychedelics. Dr. Carl Ruck, a classics professor at Boston University, discussed his research into the possible use of a psychedelic in ancient Greece with Albert Hofmann, the chemist who discovered LSD and synthesized psilocybin, and R. Gordon Wasson, the writer who discovered ceremonial use of psilocybin in Mexico.</p><p>The mid-1970s marked the end of a promising period of funded research into the potential for therapeutic usage of entheogens. Pioneers like Ralph Metzner, Bill Richards, James Fadiman and Stanislav Grof preserved an interest in their potential to evoke spiritual transformation. As Michael Pollan’s recent book “How To Change Your Mind” (2018) describes, some of the work continued underground. And in 2006, the Supreme Court issued a unanimous decision in Gonzales v. O Centro Espírita Beneficente União do Vegetal, upholding the right of practitioners of a religious group in New Mexico to use ayahuasca, which has been used for centuries as a sacrament.</p><p>Recently, New York University’s Psilocybin Cancer Anxiety Study has produced careful research on using psilocybin to help people with serious cancer diagnoses facing the anxiety of death, and this past September, Johns Hopkins University announced its Center for Psychedelic and Consciousness Research.</p><p>When psychedelics or entheogens are used in socially-sanctioned settings, consistently with community standards and as part of culturally cohesive practices, their potential can be realized, and the substantial risks of adverse reactions can be minimized. Sam’s courage and honest clarity have been part of our culture’s opportunity to awaken to the potential offered in these mysterious plants from our Creator that may help people find purpose, develop humility, gratitude, empathy, affection and intuitive capabilities and to be more fully alive.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5f24b8d719e9" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Discussion About Recent Developments in the Law of Psychedelics and Natural Medicines in the United…]]></title>
            <link>https://ronmcnutt.medium.com/discussion-about-recent-developments-in-the-law-of-psychedelics-and-natural-medicines-in-the-united-645fe1ca7bd3?source=rss-368797e78488------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/645fe1ca7bd3</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[law]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[religion]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[psychedelics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ronald W. McNutt]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 02 Sep 2024 22:25:22 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-09-03T22:10:18.799Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*xYbsnKOEkJHwA9IuMrUscw.jpeg" /></figure><p>Discussion About Recent Developments in the Law of Psychedelics and Natural Medicines in the United States</p><p>By Ron McNutt, attorney, September 2, 2024</p><p>This is a very active time for the law affecting psychedelic substances and many forms of easing restrictions and enthusiasm for wider access to psychedelics have appeared recently. It is a good time to reflect on what we can offer to contribute in this space. As we progress from a prohibitionist past into a more flexible future, we attorneys are in a good position to help promote accountability and redress for misconduct involving the administration of psychedelics in nonmedical ceremonial contexts and in clinical and therapeutic settings. Attorneys have a duty to be informed and to educate the public about important legal issues.</p><p>Despite setbacks in the clinical field with MDMA-assisted therapy, with Lykos Therapeutics losing its MDMA application for new drug approval, Usona Institute and Compass Pathways are at Phase 3 with breakthrough therapy status for treatment of depression with psilocybin.</p><p>There has been a mixed set of results in the ceremonial settings with the recent failure and closure of the <em>Soul Quest</em> ayahuasca retreat center due to limited protection under the Religious Freedom Restoration Act and repercussions from a large liability verdict against Soul Quest and its owner and the repercussions for ketamine clinics with Matthew Perry’s death after becoming addicted to ketamine. There was also an adverse and restrictive decision in the <em>Iowaska Church of Healing</em> appellate decision. At the same time, some positive results have developed on other religious freedom cases, with a favorable settlement approved with the Church of the Eagle and Condor and a successful court decision upholding the right to redress for the Church of the Celestial Heart. and an Office of General Counsel gave directions to the Drug Enforcement Administration to be more receptive to psilocybin-based ceremonial experience and therapeutic initiatives. The AIMS Right to Try cases and its rescheduling of psilocybin efforts are providing pressure for beneficial changes, and federal authorities are receiving some congressional encouragement to ease restrictions on access to psilocybin.</p><p>The momentum has been expanding for adult use and decriminalization programs in Oregon, Colorado, and other states. The Colorado Natural Medicine Health Act rulemaking progress is nearing completion. Important issues will arise in the new regulation programs that may affect prospective and active clients who engage in the adult use programs in Oregon, Colorado, Massachusetts, and elsewhere.</p><p>The Colorado and Oregon adult use programs, and the Massachusetts and Washington initiatives and decriminalization efforts provide important opportunities for ordinary people to have access to experience with entheogens, which now appear to be of greater significance because of the hesitant and skittish reception of psychedelics in the medical community, which is unfortunate for the veterans and other people suffering from trauma and anxiety. The present time is an opportunity to channel the momentum in the Psychedelic Re-emergence into the adult use context and re-examine the forgotten culture and subculture in the U.S. that remains after the Controlled Substances Act and culture wars of the 1970s and 1980s.</p><p>The chemist and scholar William Leonard Pickard has degrees in public policy and chemistry. He wrote the 2015 paperback book, The Rose of Paracelsus — On Secrets &amp; Sacraments, his tribute to the chemists who manufactured large quantities of LSD. He was incarcerated three times for manufacturing LSD. His most recent term of confinement was for about twenty years in federal prison for manufacturing LSD, beginning in 2000 until his compassionate release in 2020. Dr. Pickard said that he was accused of producing 90 % of the world’s LSD at one of his trials. In addition to his experience living as a monk in a Zen Buddhist monastery in San Francisco, he is a former research associate in neurobiology at Harvard Medical School, Harvard fellow in drug policy at the Harvard Kennedy School of Government with the Interfaculty Initiative on Drugs and Addiction, and Deputy Director of the Drug Policy Analysis Program at UCLA.</p><p>In an April 2023 talk at the Harvard Center for the Study of World Religions, Mr. Pickard said that we are in the honeymoon phase of psychedelic experience. He could see possible outcomes with medicalization and permissive religious use being options for increased access to psychedelic experience. He could foresee outcomes like: 1) all is well and things go smoothly, and many new medicines arrive; 2) an untoward event and incidents of behavioral acting out create a pretext for blowback or renewed prohibition; 3) an increase in regulation and backward movement occurs, instead of softening regulation; and 4) formation of new religious groups, creating more opportunity for access to sacramental psychedelic experience.</p><p>He sees the future in positive terms, and has a current interest in artificial intelligence and its potential to create new psychedelic compounds. He was working with the pharmaceutical companies Cybin and Gilgamesh. He said that 300 to 500 firms had appeared, with interest in novel applications of psychedelics. He was optimistic about the large-scale interest in the potential of psychedelic compounds. He predicted that tens of thousands of analogues of every conceivable variety could be created.</p><p>Clinical and therapeutic topics:</p><p>The U.S. Food and Drug Association (FDA) rejected the new drug application from the Lykos/MAPS-led MDMA clinical work for PTSD. The rejection stated that Lykos can submit an FDA-approved phase three trial with data, but this would take years to complete. The rejection has been a major setback for therapists and clinicians who anticipated a major expansion of MDMA-assisted therapy, and for veterans and advocates who are concerned about problems with veteran suicide, anxiety, depression, and posttraumatic stress disorder afflicting people who serve in the military.</p><p>Some FDA reviewers expressed opinions that the trials had been low quality or failed to meet standards. Some of the criticism of the Lykos studies concerned the method of combining therapy as part of the treatment protocol. The FDA appears to be concerned with cardiac risks associated with MDMA, a risk of depression, and a risk of misconduct by therapists. There was some concern about the lack of an active control, such as Adderall, for comparison were part of the reason for objections by scientists and the FDA. There was an instance of sexual misconduct during one of the trials. Researcher Jennifer Mitchell at UCSF, who was involved in some of the clinical trials said, “we thought we met the criteria that the FDA requested, and I absolutely stand by our data.”</p><p>This setback serves as a rejection of the effort to bring MDMA-assisted psychotherapy into mainstream healthcare within the next few years. This will delay the positive impacts from the MDMA treatments which were expected to help clear other obstacles to more openness on regulating psychedelics. Lykos has laid off 75 % of its workforce, about 100 people, and 14 employees of MAPS, about one-third of its workforce, as a result. It hired a new clinical director, Dr. David Hough, who had helped get Spravato, the nasal esketamine formulary, gain FDA approval. Rick Doblin resigned from Lykos and plans to focus on advocacy for MAPS. After the rejection, it appeared that Lykos had arranged to pursue unannounced patent proceedings for its therapeutic protocol and MDMA formula.</p><p>According to the Beckley foundation, 13 million people in the U.S. have symptoms of PTSD, and it calls for programs to address this public health need. Hopefully, there will be some good developments coming after this Lykos rejection. There are several other clinical trials underway, at various stages, that are more promising. The federal government is doing clinical studies with psilocybin and MDMA for active-duty military personnel to help with depression and posttraumatic stress disorder. Another federal agency, the National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health, has created a website to discuss the benefits of psilocybin for therapeutic treatment of depression, anxiety, and existential distress, and is investigating a potential benefit to help ease chronic pain.</p><p>State clinical programs have begun in Utah and Arizona, for example. Arizona has passed legislation to fund clinical programs for research with organic psilocybin mushrooms to help treat pain and trauma for people with life-threatening illnesses. Dr. Sue Sisley will serve as the director of this research at Scottsdale Research Institute. Utah enacted legislation that has expanded clinical programs for psilocybin-assisted psychotherapy and MDMA-assisted psychotherapy. In March 2024, it passed a three-year pilot clinical program to take place at the University of Utah and Intermountain Health, a network of providers, to prescribe synthetic psilocybin and MDMA as behavioral health treatments for depression, anxiety, and posttraumatic stress disorder.</p><p>House of Representatives Hearing about Veterans Programs with Psilocybin and MDMA Therapies</p><p>A Congressional hearing about psychedelic assisted therapies research and treatment for veterans took place on November 14, 2023, before the House Veterans’ Affairs Subcommittee on Health. Two panels including Veterans Administration officials spoke in favor of Congress enacting the Breakthrough Therapies Act, which would streamline the implementation of psilocybin- and MDMA-assisted therapies for veterans to address posttraumatic stress disorder and help prevent veteran suicide. The hearing was titled, “Emerging Therapies: Breakthroughs in the Battle Against Suicide?” It took place after a previous Veterans Administration conference September 2023 State of the Art Conference to consider system-wide clinical implementation for psychedelic compounds for potential future use. The conference presented very encouraging results from outside studies and those conducted through the Veterans Administration.</p><p>The first panel consisted of Veterans Administration officials, Carolyn Clancy, M.D., a clinical research specialist with the Department of Veterans’ Affairs, joined by Dr. Ilsa Wiechers and Dr. Rachel Yehuda, who addressed proposals for expanding treatment options to prevent suicide, treatment-resistant depression and posttraumatic stress disorder with therapy using MDMA and psilocybin. Dr. Clancy testified that there have been five Veterans’ Administration clinical studies using psychedelics, including a phase 2 MDMA-assisted therapy program for the military taking place in Loma Linda, California. Dr. Clancy stated that there will be many more studies to be sponsored by the Veterans’ Administration, although there are many steps needed to obtain grants. She expected a large expansion of MDMA-assisted therapy and approval of the Lykos protocol by the Food and Drug Administration as part of rescheduling, which did not occur.</p><p>The members of the committee pressed the Veterans’ Administration representatives to be more active in getting studies underway and helping veterans access these programs. Congressional representative Morgan Luttrell, who had undergone psychedelic-assisted therapy to recover from combat trauma, said that he is a strong advocate to expand psychedelic modalities for treatment. He is a Navy veteran who survived a traumatic brain injury from a helicopter crash, and he is part of the Veteran Mental Health Leadership Coalition, a group of over thirty organizations working to persuade lawmakers that psychedelics can bring beneficial therapeutic outcomes. He testified that he had lost hope and that he had tried to take his own life five times before he was healed in a MAPS clinical trial in North Carolina which included therapy. He said that he was able to talk about his demons, resolve his posttraumatic stress disorder and become fully functional, such that he was able to withstand a time consulting in Ukraine and sleep after missile explosions.</p><p>Representative Luttrell wanted to know if there were any friction points that could be removed to promote engagement with treatments using psychedelics. He advocated for the Veterans Administration officials to help expanded access to psychedelic therapies, and spoke in favor of Congress enacting the Breakthrough Therapies Act, which would streamline the implementation of psilocybin- and MDMA-assisted therapies for veterans to address posttraumatic stress disorder and help prevent veteran suicide.</p><p>Dr. Yehuda stated that MDMA-assisted therapy involves not a pleasant escape, but a means to gain insight and confront traumatic material, explore difficult material that affects behavior, and deal with it in a way to help address the root cause of suffering. The duration of benefit is uncertain, and this will be explored, along with developing safety data and identifying any adverse effects. She stated that the studies will provide data and they will see where it leads.</p><p>The second panel included research clinicians and veterans, including retired Army sergeant Jonathan Lubecky and Juliana Mercer, the director of advocacy at Healing Breakthroughs. Ms. Mercer, a 16-year Marine veteran, testified that she had had to go overseas to access healing of posttraumatic stress disorder. She stated that MDMA-assisted therapy has shown an 86 % rate of clinically significant improvement, and a 71 % rate of complete improvement. Brett Waters, an attorney and, with retired Marine Lt. General Martin R. Steele, co-founded Reason for Hope, and the Veteran Mental Health Leadership Coalition, argued that the government should take a leading role in expanding access to psychedelic assisted therapies. He argued for the therapeutic access to be expanded under Right to Try laws, enactment of the Breakthrough Therapies Act, increasing peer support programs, and rescheduling of therapeutic psychedelics to Schedule 2.</p><p>Frederick Barrett, the new director of the Johns Hopkins Center for Psychedelic and Consciousness Research discussed results of studies showing that psychedelic therapies have proven effective in a wide range of psychiatric indications. He has been involved with studies over the past ten years with over 400 individuals and over 1000 doses. He testified that psilocybin is relatively safe, that risks can be managed in controlled settings. Studies have shown it to be effective with mood disorders, depression, eating disorders, substance abuse disorders, and obsessive-compulsive disorder.</p><p>Dr. Rajeev Ramchaud, a psychologist with Rand Corporation, also spoke about the psychotherapeutic benefits of psychedelics like psilocybin. He described cumbersome and expensive requirements posed by schedule 1 status that create demands and barriers that inhibit research, and urged Congress to remove these by reclassifying them. He testified that all veterans who need the therapy should have access to the benefits of psychedelic therapies through community care network access with a capacity to monitor the quality of care.</p><p>State decriminalization and supported adult use programs:</p><p>Initiatives to increase opportunities to have experiences with psychedelics face different procedural requirements in different states. The successful results in states and localities are often grassroots efforts, like the results in Oregon and Colorado, primary examples of a movement based on the principle of freedom to have access to a natural substance that grows from the earth.</p><p>Dr. Dennis McKenna, a plant pharmacologist and author, and a leading expert on psychedelics and consciousness, wrote a chapter in the textbook, The Handbook of Medical Hallucinogens, p. 41 (C. Grob, J. Grigsby, ed., 2021), titled “Plants for the People.” He reviewed the history of the original psychedelic era and the incongruous laws that resulted in criminalizing these substances. He proposed making natural substances legal internationally for religious use. “Codify into law the principle that plants (and fungi and other biologically active organisms) are not ‘drugs’ in their natural form, and thus should not be regulated. When psychoactive substances are extracted from their natural sources, purified, and concentrated, they are then ‘drugs’ and should be appropriately regulated as such.” He also advised that biomedicine would benefit society by integrating psychedelic healing and restructure therapeutic support protocols using shamanic learning.</p><p>This experience, provided in medical or other social contexts, could open a door to more compassionate state of mind and help people experience realizations, adopt healthy attitudes, and begin practices that develop resilience and stimulate feelings of greater gratitude and enthusiasm and willingness to accept greater personal responsibility to promote sustainable and benevolent communities. Thus, state and local initiatives are supported under a due process of law inquiry as having a rational basis. However, there is a potential conflict with federal authority under the supremacy clause with respect to regulation of health and controlled substances.</p><p>Provisions adopted in various states and cities that are sometimes described as decriminalization measures are “deprioritizing” measures. These direct law enforcement to stop investigating and prosecuting individuals for using or possessing plants, cacti, and mushrooms that contain DMT, mescaline (not from peyote to respect Indigenous traditions), or <a href="https://www.usatoday.com/story/opinion/2019/05/13/denver-magic-mushrooms-promising-medicine-reckless-recreation-column/1182543001/">psilocybin</a>. Beginning in 2019 Denver decriminalized the use of psilocybin mushrooms by citizen referendum, and one month later, Oakland California’s city council passed a broader plant medicine ordinance to remove law enforcement priority for all natural psychoactive medicines.</p><p>In the District of Columbia, a 2020 measure made enforcement of laws prohibiting psilocybin, ayahuasca, and mescaline-containing plants the lowest law enforcement priority. Ann Arbor, Michigan deprioritized enforcement of local laws punishing use and possession of entheogenic plants and compounds in 2020. In 2021, Detroit’s Proposal E made enforcement of laws prohibiting all entheogenic plants the lowest priority of law enforcement. Similar measures passed in 2020 in Santa Cruz, California, and Ann Arbor, Michigan, and in 2021, Somerville, Northampton, and Cambridge, Massachusetts, followed in 2023, by Portland, Maine, and several other municipalities. Most of these measures protect use of psilocybin mushrooms and San Pedro Cactus and ayahuasca and do not include synthetic compounds like LSD, MDMA, 2-CB, synthetic forms of 5-MeO-DMT, and Moxy or 5-MeO-MiPT.</p><p>The traditional right to freedom of worship and religious observance involving peyote has been reserved for Indigenous populations such as members of the Native American Church, but the cultivation and use of mescaline-containing San Pedro for personal and ceremonial use by individuals who are not American Indians has typically received protection.</p><p>Ayahuasca is a classic hallucinogen from the Amazon, a mixture of Banisteriopsis caapi, a woody vine or liana, also called ayahuasca or by other names, and one of the two common admixtures, known as Chacruna, or Psychotria viridis, and chagropanga, or Diplopterys cabrerana. The leaves of these shrubs contain DMT. Sometimes, other admixtures are included, depending on the traditions. The brew is orally active because of the monoamine oxidase inhibitor in the vine, which prevents metabolizing the DMT. This activation of the tryptamines has a somewhat similar effect to psilocybin which also has tryptamines. It also limits the metabolism of serotonin. There is often a great degree of nausea from the harmine alkaloids. The accompanying visions can be very intense.</p><p>Oregon’s supported adult use psilocybin mushroom program is a nonmedical program with supervision by trained facilitators and regulatory supervision for testing, qualifications, and standards of behavior. The Oregon program provides “psilocybin services” regulated by the Oregon Psilocybin Services, a subdivision of the Oregon Health Authority Public Health Division’s Center for Health Protection. Oregon Psilocybin Services began awarding licenses in early 2023. The Oregon psilocybin program does not require a license as a psychotherapist or other professional health credential to be a facilitator. Compliance with regulations can create substantial operating expenses that make participation costly for centers and consumers. Regulation helps ensure safe material for consumption and a setting with an experienced and trained facilitator.</p><p>Participants in Oregon’s supported adult use program receive preparation and supervision from trained facilitators who must pass a background check and have a high school diploma. They must also complete a licensed certification program which is approved by the state and meets coursework and practicum hour requirements. Several private training programs for facilitators have been established and many people have received training to be facilitators. There are about 25 healing centers. The first psychedelic treatment centers opened in Oregon in 2023. Over 5000 subjects have been treated, apparently successfully. The state legislature is considering allowing people with disabilities and facing terminal conditions so they can receive psilocybin mushrooms with support in their homes. Licensed service centers have been the exclusive location for consumption, which drew an ADA lawsuit by three trained facilitators and a physician to permit access. The Oregon Health Authority had asserted, in defending against the claims, that legislation would be required to make the changes sought.</p><p>Colorado Natural Medicine Health Act:</p><p>The Colorado Natural Medicine Health Act was enacted into law after a successful voter referendum in 2022. The Colorado Natural Medicine Health Act has a combined set of provisions including supported adult use, the Regulated Natural Medicine Access Program, and a decriminalization program. The Colorado Natural Medicine Health Act also has personal use and cultivation provisions that do not depend on the regulated program’s requirements for facilitators and locations.</p><p>After many meetings of the Natural Medicine Advisory Board and public hearings as part of the rulemaking process, the regulations have been proposed for Colorado’s supported adult use program for consuming psilocybin mushrooms in licensed healing centers and other authorized locations. The regulations will affect access and cost as well as the extent of oversight, accountability, and aspects of medicalization and opportunity for ceremonial uses. The board has set proposed fees for various licensures for operations for the authorized program. The first licenses are expected to be awarded in mid-2025.</p><p>The supported adult use program with psilocybin mushrooms will be regulated by a set of regulations under two state agencies. The Division of Natural Medicine, under the Department of Revenue, will oversee healing centers and natural medicine businesses. There are regulations that set standards and address comprehensively aspects of product cultivation, inventory, security, storage, transportation, and product inspection, and set standards for healing centers, testing facilities, manufacturing facilities, and training providers. Small scale ownership is encouraged through limitations on the number of five licenses that can be owned by a single owner. There is flexibility that allows facilitators to receive from a facility and store, and keep in their custody up to 750 milligrams of active psilocybin and be subject to a less demanding standard for storage and documentation. There are provisions that promote community investment and planning for Indigenous benefit sharing.</p><p>The Department of Regulatory Agencies or DORA will oversee facilitator licenses and conduct. The regulations set competency as well as ethical standards of practice. The training requirements are a minimum of 150 hours of training, with 40 hours of supervised practice under a trained facilitator. The regulate address matters of documentation, confidentiality, informed consent, permission for touch, prohibition of romantic relations between participants and facilitators and other providers. Training centers for facilitators have been licensed and are training authorized facilitators.</p><p>Centers will contract with facilitators, and there are measures to include clinical facilitators who are interested in infrequent participation. There are provisions to allow for multipurpose use of space for practitioners who will facilitate infrequently or on a part-time basis and use space with coexisting purposes. There are fees with dual license arrangements for both roles as facilitators and owners of healing centers. There is a $ 10,000 license fee for training programs during the first year, and a $ 200 to $500 level for facilitators, a $ 7500 fee for licenses for extraction and manufacturing with the organic psilocybin, and $ 300 to $ 6000 for an annual healing center license. Prohibitions on advertising do not appear to prevent sharing information. The regulations that provide for cultivation of psilocybin-containing mushrooms also allow for their processing into “manufactured” products like teabags, capsules, chocolates, tinctures, and soft confections.</p><p>The regulations accommodate dual license arrangements for facilitator-owners of healing centers. They provide flexibility that allows facilitators to receive from a facility and store, and keep in their custody up to 750 milligrams of active psilocybin and be subject to a less demanding standard for storage and documentation. Small scale ownership of cultivation facilities, manufacturing facilities, healing centers, and other is encouraged through limitations on the number of five licenses that can be owned by a single owner. There are provisions that promote community investment and planning for Indigenous benefit sharing.</p><p>Colorado’s regulations for supported adult use of psilocybin are unique in providing for tiers of facilitators and clinical facilitators. Clinical facilitators are facilitators who are professionals with a secondary license who can offer services to individuals with pre-existing conditions that would not be permitted to participate. Participants undergo a preliminary safety screen before administration sessions, and this is when risk factors are identified. To participate in natural medicine services, people with certain conditions are screened to prevent participation if they have cardiac problems, very high blood pressure, certain mental health challenges, or taking certain medications like antidepressants, would have to gain clearance permission from a therapist or physician, depending on the condition. The clinical facilitators also have the authority as facilitator and the added authority for the clinical screening decisions reserved for qualified medical and behavioral health specialists.</p><p>During stakeholder meetings for the supported adult use of psilocybin program, officials stated that the regulators have good working relationships with federal regulatory programs. They expect the federal government to honor state permission for the clinical practitioners and the regulations safe harbor protection for the clinical facilitator licensures.</p><p>There is a provision for regulation of group administration sessions. Under § 12–170–205(1)(a)(I)(F), of the Natural Medicine Health Act, the director of the Division of Professions and Occupations has authority to make provisions to regulate group administration of plant medicines and set requirements for the number of facilitators and the number of participants in these group sessions.</p><p>Provisions in the law anticipate future discussions to consider adding additional psychedelic medicines and how to implement adult use provisions if other plant-based psychedelic substances are added to the program. The Act anticipates future authorization for supported adult use with other natural psychedelic medicines, including mescaline-containing cactus plants like San Pedro (not including peyote) and DMT-containing tea like ayahuasca upon recommendations by department officials on or after June 1, 2026.</p><p>The regulations for the supported adult use psilocybin program will affect access and cost as well as the extent of oversight, accountability, and aspects of medicalization and opportunity for ceremonial uses. The board will decide about which other plant-based psychedelic substances will be added to the program.</p><p>Personal use provisions in the Colorado Natural Medicine Health Act:</p><p>Personal use, cultivation, and sharing of psilocybin, mescaline-containing cacti other than peyote, and ayahuasca and organic DMT preparations are permitted under the personal use provisions of the Natural Medicine Health Act, which were effective as of July 2023. The law establishes a twelve-by-twelve-foot area allotted for individuals to be able to grow protected plants or fungi. The propagation must take place in compact areas not accessible to minors. There are provisions that prevent counties from prohibiting the personal use provisions or restrict the amount of growing space. Earlier provisions in the Natural Medicine Health Act to include plant material with ibogaine were removed by later amendments to the law.</p><p>The Natural Medicine Health Act permits adults aged 21 and over to use, possess, process, and grow natural medicines like psilocybin mushrooms, components of ayahuasca, or San Pedro cactus or huachuma. It allows individuals to cultivate and share natural medicines. It does not allow sale or cultivation or manufacture for sale or commercial purposes. Colorado Revised Statutes § 18–18–434(12)(b)(III)(d). The Act allows consumption, possession, cultivation, and sharing “within the context of counseling, spiritual guidance, beneficial community-based use and healing, supported use, or related services.” Colorado Revised Statutes § 18–18–434.</p><p>The provisions for legal sharing do not permit payment for the natural medicines, but they appear to allow for remuneration for support services that may be offered with such sharing. A Apparently, it has become an accepted practice for individuals to receive compensation for harm reduction services or coaching while simultaneously gifting mushrooms. While advertising is prohibited, compensation for services to provide information and education for associated preparation and integration work will apparently be compensable under the Natural Medicine Health Act.</p><p>Under Colorado Revised Statutes § 12–170–108(4), practitioners can perform bona fide religious ceremonies if they are not claiming to be licensed, and so long as they are not associated with a for-profit activity. Spiritual use is not prohibited or regulated under the Act so long as facilitators make it clear that they are not certified practitioners under the Natural Medicine Health Act.</p><p>The Natural Medicine Health Act, and the ongoing regulatory activity with respect to natural entheogens, appear to be developing into a useful prototype for the decriminalization and supported adult use initiatives that are appearing in California, Massachusetts, and New Jersey. Colorado has adopted a very progressive framework overall, and is attracting attention as an effective model for other states.</p><p>The Massachusetts Natural Psychedelic Substances Act:</p><p>Massachusetts is considering a decriminalization program that permits Adults 21 and older to legally possess, grow, and share natural psychedelic substances with psilocybin, psilocin, dimethyltryptamine, ibogaine and mescaline (San Pedro, not peyote). Local organizers Massachusetts for Mental Health Options gathered the signatures to secure ballot placement for November. The referendum is expected to succeed in the election.</p><p>The measure would create a Natural Psychedelic Substances Commission of five persons, as well as a 20-member advisory board, to regulate the production and use of plant-based psychedelic substances like psilocybin mushrooms for people at least 21 years old to legally consume psychedelics at licensed therapeutic centers. A Natural Psychedelic Substances Advisory Board would “study and make recommendations” to the commission about issues such as public health, regulations, training for facilitators, affordable and equitable access, traditional use of psychedelics and future rules, including possible additions to the list of legal substances.</p><p>The measure also would eliminate criminal penalties associated with possessing, consuming, and sharing, without compensation, limited amounts of natural psychedelics and to allow individuals to legally cultivate psychedelics at home. Adults 21 and older could legally possess, grow, and share up to the following amounts of the organic material containing the following weight limits of the active compounds of these specific psychedelics: DMT (one gram), non-peyote mescaline (18 grams), ibogaine (30 grams), psilocybin (one gram) and psilocin (one gram).</p><p>Adults could propagate natural psychedelics in a space no larger than a 12 by 12 ft. space. The penalty for possession of amounts of up to double the limit would be a $100 civil fine, with greater penalties for greater amounts.</p><p>The effective date of the law would be December 15, 2024. The commission and advisory board would need to be created by March 1, 2025.</p><p>The program would be funded with revenues from a 15 percent excise tax on psychedelic substances purchased at licensed facilities. Localities would have the option of imposing an additional two percent tax if they permit the centers to operate in their area. Revenue would be used to fund regulation of the program. Local governments could enact regulations on the time, location, and manner of service centers, but they could not outright ban the centers from operating in their area. There would be civil legal protections related to professional licensure, child custody and public benefits for people who participate in a legalized psychedelic activity.</p><p>Massachusetts for Mental Health Options was the leading advocate to support the efforts to secure ballot placement in Massachusetts for November. The referendum has been tarnished by revelations that discredited the principal director of that grassroots organization for impersonating another activist who represented veterans in favor of the measure and fraudulently acting on his behalf. However, it is a very progressive program that permits cultivations of natural psychedelics and has been expected to succeed in the election.</p><p>Washington:</p><p>The Natural Psychedelics and Supportive Services Act has been approved for a proposed voter referendum in the state of Washington for decriminalization of natural medicines. The ballot title, Initiative Measure №2076, and a summary were issued by the Washington Secretary of State. The proposed voter initiative developed after two bills had failed in the state legislature and after a task force was assembled that merely proposed additional research.</p><p>The proposed initiative was prepared by a group of advocates called REACH-WA, for Responsible Entheogen Access and Community Healing. It proposes to fully decriminalize under state law access to certain plants and fungi containing classic serotonergic psychedelics, namely psilocybin, psilocin, mescaline, dimethyltryptamine or DMT, and 5MeO-DMT. The initiative excludes peyote and its derivatives from its protection to respect the prerogative of Indigenous populations and communities. It includes as protected “natural psychedelics” preparations such as “teas, extracts, and mixtures, such as ayahuasca tea and psilocybin chocolates.” It excludes all “versions of any controlled substances that are created by means of chemical synthesis or obtained from animal sources.”</p><p>The proposal would allow consumption individually and in community settings. It prohibits the sale of the substances, but allows for the free transfer of natural psychedelics to a person twenty-one years or older for consumption during the provision of bona fide supportive services, which can be provided in exchange for remuneration. Supportive service providers are not licensed under state law. They may receive compensation for bona fide services offered in conjunction with providing natural medicines. Supportive service providers must observe ethical guidelines set forth in the proposal to promote health and safety. Informed consent and advance authorization for supportive touch are required, with disclosure of risks.</p><p>The proposal has provisions for Supportive service providers to advertising only for eligible persons who request contact about the supported services for natural psychedelics. Communications must not be misleading of offer clinical or therapeutic services that require licensure, unless the licensing board authorizes such services. Organizations that are organized as nonprofit organizations may offer support services, as can certain cooperative organizations.</p><p>The proposal provides for formation of a diverse group of professionals and public servants called the Natural Psychedelics Community Resource Advisory Council. The council will identify and provide best practices and guidelines for services and consider provisions for addressing instances of misconduct. Private experience or personal use provisions provide few restrictions beyond restrictions on public consumption and advertising. The proposal seeks to promote inclusivity to be respectful to other traditions and access to natural psychedelics, from organic sources in spiritual and religious settings.</p><p>California:</p><p>Following the December 2022 veto of California’s proposal to decriminalize natural psychedelics and establish supported adult use of psilocybin mushrooms, SB 58, by Governor Newsom, there have been other efforts at legislation and a proposed voter initiative. Governor Newsom stated his preference for a clinical and therapeutic program. A voter initiative in California, The Psychedelic Wellness and Healing Initiative of 2026, a proposed regulated adult use program, was drafted following a senate committee amendment that would require that facilitators to have an existing professional health license like those for psychiatrists, social workers, drug and alcohol counselors and nurse practitioners, to administer psychedelics. The initiative will need to have over 500,000 signatures to be certified by the attorney general of California, which would approve its title and summary to the California Secretary of State for placement on the ballot.</p><p>Free exercise of religion and protection of ceremonial experience with psychedelics:</p><p>The current time is presenting an opportunity for activists, attorneys, and public officials to protect legitimate spiritual experience with natural medicines. Americans are supporting greater access to natural medicines for healing of trauma and for spiritual exploration. There has been pressure to limit their use to a medical context, which appears to be financially prohibitive for most people and restricts access to people presenting themselves as having a mental health pathology. Legal protections are likely to expand and incorporate celebratory and exploratory adult use of psychedelic medicines, as well as a broader category of spiritual exploration that would not depend on insincere presentation or cultural appropriation of another society’s traditions.</p><p>North American and European experience faces the problem of an absence of accepted psychedelic spiritual traditions. Authoritarian structures eliminated psychedelic practices in ancient Greece and Europe, and throughout the colonial empires in the Americas and Africa. North American religious institutions have been at the forefront of efforts to suppress and eliminate the longstanding traditions in Central and South America. Traditions in other countries that go back many centuries have survived by withstanding and evading extreme persecution by religious and governmental authorities.</p><p>Opposition by mainstream religions and legal authorities, and the social stigma associated with drug culture and psychedelics, have resulted in ordinary people having no legal access to psychedelics. These forces have also inhibited or prevented formation of social groups and organizations that would have developed naturally to provide practices and social reinforcement for safer practices and risk reduction. The United States judicial system is inhibited by initial experience of its society with psychedelics because of missteps, abuses, and inappropriate uses that led to adverse consequences, and because of the insights that led to challenges to mainstream society’s expectations of social conformity.</p><p>Some of the challenges to having a more universal, experience-based religion that incorporates psychedelic substances include improper or corrupt motivations by leaders, inadequate preparation or exploitation of vulnerable participants in a hyper-suggestible mental and emotional state, incompetency in administration of the sacraments or in addressing uncomfortable or hazardous reactions, factionalism, divisiveness, envy, and misunderstanding between leaders, an absence of reverence for the medicines, and disrespect of the viewpoints and experience of other participants.</p><p>As Americans are moving away from organized religion or becoming more entrenched in religious institutions that are firmly opposed to ceremonial use of entheogens, there is a crosscurrent of influences that could inform a more universal spiritual message consistent with the experience of an unfolding psychedelic journey. Disenchantment with mainstream religious institutions can help reveal beneficial and more holistic theologies from other traditional frameworks, and open worldviews to incorporate new ideas and realizations drawn from individual and community experience.</p><p>Careful, deliberate, and confident preparation and oversight can help mitigate risks and provide a safe container for an inward healing process that can afford people with a deepened sense of connection with nature, community, the ground of being, and contact with the numinous. The psychedelic experience can provide a sense of greater aliveness and motivation through restorative insights that bring about gratitude, love, forgiveness, and compassion. It creates the potential to bring about a clarity of awareness about one’s own experience and motivations, and exposing one to truths about one’s past actions and experiences that can enhance insight and motivation for transformation. It can motivate the inner work to transform in more engaging and positive ways.</p><p>While programs for adult use in non-clinical settings evolve, Colorado’s program will be a fine example of the guidelines most beneficial to employ in providing a safe container. People will have an opportunity to shed layers of resistance and deepen understanding and compassion for oneself and for others, and other opportunities for personal transformation due to a mysterious neuroplasticity process that can reveal unfamiliar types of awareness. Risk mitigation practices with informed consent for voluntary participation with disclosures of risks, and accountability for best practices, will contribute to reaching the greatest potential for psychedelics.</p><p>Recent cases involving the free exercise of religion and psychedelics</p><p>The major psychedelics became illegal nationwide by October 1968. In 1970, the Federal Controlled Substances Act, was enacted, and it gave authority to the Food and Drug Administration to create schedules for criminal sanctions for the use and possession of psychoactive drugs and substances. <em>See</em> 21 U.S.C. §§ 841(a)(1), 811–821. After the Controlled Substances Act was enacted, and under its authority, LSD, mescaline, peyote, ayahuasca, and psilocybin mushrooms were placed in the highly restricted Schedule I as having no medical potential and being subject to abuse and presenting grave dangers. The substances listed in Schedule I of the Controlled Substances Act are subject to an outright ban on all importation and use except for strictly regulated research projects. <em>See</em>, 21 U.S.C. §§ 823, 960(a)(1).</p><p>Although ayahuasca can be dangerous because of the reaction to other drugs, it is constitutionally protected as a religious practice under a 2006 Supreme Court case. There are many ayahuasca churches, especially in Brazil, and many indigenous or neo-shamanic retreats in Peru, Colombia, Ecuador, and elsewhere. There are retreat centers and underground medicine circles throughout the U.S.A.</p><p>The Supreme Court refused to afford First Amendment protection for use of peyote as a sacrament in <em>Employment Division, Department of Human Resources of Oregon v. Smith</em>, 494 U.S. 872 (1990). This represented a departure from the traditional protection of a fundamental right, the right to freedom of worship and religious observance. This removal of constitutional protection received bipartisan criticism and Congress was motivated to pass legislation to undo this unpopular approach. The Congress in 1993 responded by legislatively overturning the diminished constitutional scrutiny adopted in <em>Employment Division v. Smith </em>decision by enacting of the Religious Freedom Restoration Act (RFRA).</p><p>The Religious Freedom Restoration Act was enacted to provide a private cause of action for persons whose religious exercise has been substantially burdened, allowing them to “assert that violation as a claim or defense in a judicial proceeding and obtain appropriate relief against a government.” 42 U.S.C. § 2000bb-1 provides, in section (a), “Government shall not substantially burden a person’s exercise of religion even if the burden results from a rule of general applicability, except as provided in subsection (b).” Section (b) states, “Government may substantially burden a person’s exercise of religion only if it demonstrates that application of the burden to the person- (1) is in furtherance of a compelling governmental interest; and (2) is the least restrictive means of furthering that compelling governmental interest.”</p><p>42 U.S.C. § 2000bb-1(c) of the Religious Freedom Restoration Act provides a federal cause of action with judicial relief for infringement of religious freedom and religious practices. It has been construed, however, to apply exclusively to federal enforcement activity. Subsection © states as follows:</p><p>A person whose religious exercise has been burdened in violation of this section may assert that violation as a claim or defense in a judicial proceeding and obtain appropriate relief against a government. Standing to assert a claim or defense under this section shall be governed by the general rules of standing under article III of the Constitution.</p><p>42 U.S.C. § 2000bb–3(a) states that the Religious Freedom Restoration Act “applies to all Federal law, and the implementation of that law, whether statutory or otherwise, and whether adopted before or after November 16, 1993.”</p><p>The law provides that a <em>prima facie</em> showing that the federal government activity, applying the Controlled Substances Act to place a substantial burden on a sincere exercise of religion, shifts the burden of persuasion to the federal government to establish that its burdensome actions furthered a compelling interest in the least restrictive manner. <em>Gonzales v. O Centro Espirita Beneficente União do Vegetal, </em>546 U.S. 418, 437–38(2006).</p><p>Many states followed the Religious Freedom Restoration Act, which applies only to federal enforcement, with state laws of similar effect. These laws reinstate the constitutional standards for the protection of religious activity, including the ceremonial use of psychedelics. The standards in effect prior to <em>Employment Division v. Smith </em>were stated in <em>Sherbert v. Verner</em>, 374 U.S. 398 (1963), and <em>Wisconsin v. Yoder</em>, 406 U.S. 205 (1972). These decisions of the Supreme Court applied a balancing test for constitutional protection, weighing a compelling state interest against the extent of the burden it placed on religious activity. The Court in <em>Sherbert v. Verner</em> stressed that cases that sustained statutes despite a burden placed on religion have involved activities that “invariably posed some substantial threat to public safety, peace, or order.” <em>Id</em>., 374 U.S. at 403 (citations omitted). The state has an obligation to present evidence of a compelling interest in regulation and upon such a demonstration, a court will decide whether the state could achieve its goals by less restrictive alternative means. The Court held that if it had found the state had a compelling state interest, it would have required the state to show that “no alternative forms of regulation would combat the abuse without infringing First Amendment Rights.” <em>Id</em>., 374 U.S. at 407.</p><p>The Drug Enforcement Administration Diversion Control Division issued a “Guidance Regarding Petitions for Religious Exemption from the Controlled Substances Act,” which invites applicants to invoke its administrative process. The Drug Enforcement Administration (DEA) has only agreed to recognize bona fide ceremonial psychedelic practices (in each case ayahuasca) after court intervention. The Government Accountability Office has admonished the DEA for its pattern of delay and refusal to recognize protection for psilocybin churches. The Government Accountability Office urged the DEA adopt a more hospitable approach to ceremonial experience with psilocybin mushrooms and process several deficiencies in administering religious exemptions from the controlled Substances Act.</p><p>Some courts have shifted responsibility for factfinding and legal conclusions entailing the balancing fundamental rights and deferring to the DEA. One example is the adverse D.C. Circuit decision in the <em>Iowaska Church of Healing</em> case. In <em>Soul Quest Church of Mother Earth, et. al. v. Attorney General, United States of America, et. al</em>., the request for a DEA exemption led to findings that led to a very limited opportunity for review, with deference to the agency findings. There was a finding of lack of sincerity or religious purpose. The district court’s deference to agency findings did not allow for this balancing of interests because there was no review of the finding of lack of sincerity. In the Eleventh Circuit, Soul Quest raised a challenge to the DEA process with factfinding authority without adopting rules. Because this was not raised in the district court, it was deemed to be waived.</p><p>In <em>Soul Quest</em>, there was an agency determination of a lack of sincerity. The Eleventh Circuit decision interpreted the DEA review as a final administrative decision and found there was an untimely appeal. This interpretation would give the DEA’s determinations a deferential standard of review under an arbitrary and capricious standard. More concerning still is the court’s implicit prerequisite of DEA administrative review prerequisite in future cases. The government separately supported its denial of an exemption by concluding that restrictions on ayahuasca did not place an impermissible burden on religion because ayahuasca posed risks to safety justifying legal restrictions. Facts in<em> Soul Quest</em> that were viewed unfavorably by the agency included its resemblance to a retreat center model, a lack of universal tenets or beliefs, for-profit aspects of its structure, and the existence of a pending wrongful death case.</p><p>These precedents could represent a pattern of courts delegating fact finding, including the constitutional balancing of interests under the Free Exercise Clause, to the Drug Enforcement Administration. It is important in litigation to protect the province of the judiciary to make the findings and conclusions to protect rights under the Religious Freedom Restoration Act. It may be appropriate in some states and in the federal government to try to address, through legislation the need to protect the decision-making authority of the courts and safeguard the higher scrutiny, requiring compelling state interests to justify activity that burdens religious liberty.</p><p>There has been a great expansion of ayahuasca and psilocybin mushroom spiritual practices in the time since the <em>O Centro Espirita Beneficente União do Vegetal</em> decision. The opposition to legal protection by government authorities, the expense and stress of litigation, and the skepticism of the courts, has led many spiritual communities that employ plant medicines to avoid seeking recognition through judicial proceedings.</p><p><em>Church of the Eagle and the Condor v. Garland</em>:</p><p>On April 22, 2024, the plaintiffs in <em>Church of the Eagle and the Condor v. Garland</em>, 2:22-cv-01004, (D. Ariz.), announced a settlement with federal defendants that recognizes their right to religious liberty that encompasses sacramental experience with ayahuasca, which contains dimethyltryptamine (DMT), a controlled substance. The Church of the Eagle and Condor is a church based in Phoenix, Arizona with leadership including Indigenous persons that practices worship with sacramental experience with ayahuasca. The plaintiffs included leaders and board members of the church, Joseph Tafur, M.D., Belinda Eriacho, Kewal Wright, Benjaman Sullivan, and Joseph Bellus. The Church of the Eagle and Condor has been incorporated as a not-for-profit organization and it has bylaws, a code of ethics, and ceremonial guidelines in place to help guide its ceremonies.</p><p>Although the Church of the Eagle and Condor has been granted legal authority for its ceremonies, it had to accomplish this result with exemplary facts and several outstanding and conscientious attorneys. It was not required to apply under the application process, the “Guidance Regarding Petitions for Religious Exemption from the Controlled Substances Act Pursuant to the Religious Freedom Restoration Act,” the Drug Enforcement Administration’s internal process for assessment of the validity of religious claims. The settlement recognized “activities of a religious entity” in setting forth the rights and responsibilities of the Church of the Eagle and Condor. As a prevailing party, the Church of the Eagle and Condor is entitled to petition for attorney fees as prevailing plaintiff under the Religious Freedom Restoration Act and 42 U.S.C. § 1988. If the issue is not resolved, it could petition the district court for determination about an award of fees.</p><p>The Church of the Eagle and Condor alleged that it accepts a lineage of teachers and maintains a broad set of ethics that promote the wellbeing of participants. The church presented appropriate factors for religious protection. The allegations of the complaint with respect to the sincerity of the church and its membership in their sacramental practices were accepted. No adverse evidence was produced to discredit their sincerity.</p><p>The church exhibited sincerity, promoted an understanding of the purpose of worship among its members, and encouraged careful practices that prevent diversion for health and safety. The church would observe measures to prevent diversion for unauthorized purposes that were inconsistent with the shared beliefs. Its leaders were inspired by the Shipibo ayahuasca medicine tradition of Peru that holds ayahuasca ceremony as an essential sacrament to draw together heart and wisdom traditions. Its members adhered to a code of ethics. It has maintained a communal tradition with tenets based upon an ancestral prayer and call of the Spirit of the Americas to bring about a beneficial re-encounter bridging countervailing influences.</p><p>The federal defendants, who were officials sued in their official capacities, were Attorney General Merrick Garland as head of the Department of Justice, Secretary Alejandro Mayorkas for the Department of Homeland Security, Administrator Anne Milgram for the Drug Enforcement Agency, and Acting Commissioner Troy Miller representing the U.S. Customs and Border Protection.</p><p>The church had continued to participate in its practices under the guidance of a trained ayahuasquero. The settlement agreement allows the Church of the Eagle and Condor plaintiffs to import, receive, manufacture, distribute, transport, securely store, and dispose of ayahuasca solely for the church’s religious purposes. The church is authorized to receive ayahuasca “in concentrated paste or in liquid form” and, when needed, to “combine the ayahuasca paste with water to manufacture ayahuasca tea for sacramental uses” at a designated church facility in Phoenix. The settlement agreement states that it would be receiving kilograms of paste and liquid ayahuasca from Ricardo Amaringo, a Shipibo elder who has helped train Dr. Tafur. Shipments will be subject to sampling and inspection by the DEA or Customs and Border Protection. Ports of entry are Los Angeles, Miami, Houston, and Atlanta.</p><p>The settlement allows the DEA to take spot samples of the imports “for the purpose of confirming that the consignment is in fact ayahuasca which contains no controlled substance other than DMT.” The settlement provides for the church to be issued certificates of registration during periods of compliance. The church will receive annual permits for shipments, registering the importer. Applications for shipment are not required to designate quantities of material. The church would be issued a bulk manufacturer registration. It also will register as an importer.</p><p>The DEA will not seek to limit the quantity of ayahuasca necessary for the plaintiffs’ religious use. It will not be required to register as a distributor. The persons designated to have responsibility for receiving, handling, preparing, manufacturing, storing, and transporting the ayahuasca are the ayahuasqueros, Joseph Tafur and Benjamin Sullivan.</p><p>According to the terms of the settlement, the Church of the Eagle and Condor anticipated holding regular meetings at members’ residences and specified locations. The church will provide the local DEA field office with general information about the locations and dates of their ceremonies. It will not be required to report the names or addresses of individual members or non-member ceremonial participants. The church asserted the privacy interests of its adherents, and their rights to freedom of association, to shield its membership lists from disclosure as part of discovery. The ayahuasca will be delivered and served by designated dispensers at ceremonial locations. The government agreed not to make public the addresses of locations.</p><p>The health screening process and first aid processes in place by the church were adopted in the settlement as safety protocols that will continue. The settlement provides for participants to be asked to disclose their medications and health conditions in order to identify contraindications for participation. A person with basic life support training will be present during ceremonies in case of medical or psychological events. The designated person must be present during church ceremonies and may partake of the medicine in keeping with traditions for attendees to participate in consuming ayahuasca.</p><p>The church agreed to recordkeeping for the importation, receipt, manufacture, distribution, transportation, storage, and disposition of ayahuasca. The batches and containers will be identified. The ayahuasca will be stored in a secure location locked with a deadbolt with an alarm system, and in a locked refrigerator. The ayahuasqueros are responsible for handling the containers. During an authorized inspection of manufacturing location, church representatives would be present with DEA inspectors and the inspection will not entail physical handling of the containers by agency personnel. The ayahuasqueros are responsible transporting ayahuasca to ceremonial locations.</p><p>The church issued a press release that stated that it is “the first non-Christian church to receive protection for its spiritual practices regarding ayahuasca.” The church expressed its hope that the settlement “has positive implications and paves the way for other ancestral and syncretic religions.”</p><p>Other cases:</p><p>In <em>Church of the Holy Light of Queen v. Mukasey</em>, two ayahuasca churches that are American branches of successors of the <em>Santo Daime</em> religion, the oldest of the Brazilian ayahuasca religions, were granted a permanent injunction by the district court that allowed them to import and use ayahuasca, called Daime by the churches. <em>Church of the Holy Light of the Queen v. Mukasey</em>, 615 F. Supp. 2d 1210, 1219 (D. Or. 2009), <em>vacated sub nom. Church of Holy Light of Queen v. Holder</em>, 443 F. App’x 302 (9th Cir. 2011) (to limit scope of injunction). The district court found that consuming ayahuasca tea is “an arduous path that is not suitable for most people,” and that the participants were screened to “select only those who are serious about the Santo Daime religion, and to turn away would-be recreational users or thrill-seekers.” <em>Id</em>. at 1216. The court also observed, “In Brazil, thousands of people consume hoasca or Daime tea several times each month. The government of Brazil would not allow the UDV and Santo Daime churches to operate if there was evidence that Daime tea or hoasca was killing church members.” <em>Id.</em> at 1218. The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals upheld the injunction insofar as it enjoined the government from prohibiting the importation, storage, and use of their sacrament.</p><p>In <em>Church of the Celestial Heart v. Garland</em>, 1:23-cv-00545, (E.D. Cal. January 9, 2024), the plaintiffs succeeded in convincing the court that Religious Freedom Restoration Act claims against federal government defendants do not require DEA administrative factfinding and adjudicatory functions, or create an implied exhaustion of administrative remedies for court review. The court in the <em>Church of the Celestial Heart </em>case upheld a cause of action to protect an ayahuasca church to seek redress for federal enforcement activity and in so doing, did not give much reason for confidence in the DEA exemption process.</p><p>In <em>Church of the Celestial Heart v. Garland</em>, a U.S. magistrate judge in California denied a federal government motion to dismiss a complaint by an ayahuasca church. The decision contains information that the federal authorities have not been frequently initiating or pursuing prosecutions involving ceremonial experiences with ayahuasca. The Drug Enforcement Administration submitted pleadings that minimized its role in law enforcement with respect to ayahuasca churches in that case and other cases discussed in that opinion.</p><p>Although it had found sufficient allegations to find standing based on actual enforcement action, it proceeded to examine the criteria for standing in the pre-enforcement context. Despite a substantial number of border seizures of plant medicine materials, there were very few prosecutions following seizures and interception of plant medicine materials. The agency would provide information about the intended recipients and content to state prosecutors, who have tended to be disinterested in pursuing charges.</p><p>The court held that the plaintiffs could not be required to pursue an application for an exemption from the Controlled Substances Act in the Drug Enforcement Administration’s administrative process as the government was urging. (Opinion at 47). The court held that by pursuing, the Drug Enforcement Administration exemption process the church would lose options to obtain preliminary relief available in court under the Religious Freedom Restoration Act. (Opinion at 46–47). Moreover, the church would be restricted in holding its ceremonies because parties seeking religious exemptions were precluded by law from using prohibited substances like ayahuasca until they obtain an exemption and proceed with registration. <em>Id</em>. (citing DEA Guidance at 2: “Activity Prohibited Until Final Determination. No petitioner may engage in any activity prohibited under the Controlled Substances Act or its regulations unless the petition has been granted and the petitioner has applied for and received a DEA Certificate of Registration.”). The court also observed that the guidance allows the agency to suspend or revoke protection, “without detailed separate guidelines or specific protections except for aversion to general principles.” (Opinion at 47).</p><p>The trial court denied a motion to dismiss, holding that there was a valid cause of action under Religious Freedom Restoration Act, 42 U.S.C. §§ 2000bb-1(a). This is a favorable decision for religious freedom, bringing important fundamental rights before the courts as anticipated under the Religious Freedom Restoration Act. It also revealed that federal and state authorities have not appeared eager to bring many enforcement actions against churches with natural psychedelic sacraments. <em>See, also</em>, <em>Arizona Yage Assembly v. Attorney General</em>, 595 F. Supp. 3d 869 (D. Ariz. 2022).</p><p>The Religious Freedom Restoration Act states that courts have the authority to perform the delicate balancing of interests with formal proof standards. The courts are more likely to apply strict scrutiny constitutional review in a way that is more promising and less complex than the administrative process used by the DEA, as the courts had been applying First Amendment protection before <em>Employment Division, Department of Human Resources of Oregon v. Smith</em>, 494 U.S. 872 (1990). Arguments for court adjudication can be supported by the May 2024 Governmental Accountability Office report which criticized the DEA for not having regulations or an effective and timely processes for making these decisions.</p><p>To avoid prosecution, or succeed in establishing the right to worship with entheogenic plants, best practices to be observed include having a structure with appropriate leadership and education, adherence to guiding principles, an understanding of the worldview, teachings, or tenets of the community, practices that inspire reverence and respect for the medicine, its traditions, and other members, and upholding spiritual traditions. It is especially important to reduce risks and promote beneficial experience with preparation, careful administration, and integration of the experience with community support. It is beneficial to have organizational documents and protocols for abuses of power or other misconduct, to promote diversity, screening and support for health and mental health concerns.</p><p>The Sacred Plant Alliance advises communities with psychedelic plant and fungi medicine sacraments in ceremony to have a congregation in place and a leader with seven or more years of experience with entheogenic sacraments. The Sacred Plant Alliance was formed in 2020 and it is a 501(c)(3) not for profit corporation of 12 to 15 member churches. It has member communities with psychedelic knowledge and offers mutual support and guidance toward risk mitigation practices and guidance about vision and inclusive practices, and helping organizations withstand scrutiny as sincere and entitled to protection for the free exercise of religion. Sacred Plant Alliance has committees like health and safety, outreach and reciprocity, membership, and ethics. The Sacred Plant Alliance recommends that spiritual communities have a not-for-profit structure, that and have models of authenticity with opportunities to learn. Member churches are encouraged to adopt ways of regulating themselves with authenticity and accountability through peer review and recourse to conflict resolution with the Sacred Plant Alliance.</p><p>The legacy of past prohibitionist approaches has created a substantial issue with a lack of experience for leadership, and the need for developing leadership among racial and ethnic minorities in North America. Psychedelic group and individual settings for healthy adults are likely to evolve and develop with myriad influences, reaching in differing directions and coalescing sometimes when their ways find common ground. A group could meet in a retreat setting with careful leadership that should be able to include multiple spiritual frameworks with such moral precepts and self-discipline, but without a rigid or fundamentalist viewpoint particular to an insular religion. With experience and the examples of churches like Church of the Celestial Heart, Church of the Holy Light of the Queen, and Church of the Eagle and Condor, and insight from the Sacred Plant Alliance, organizations have viable resources for meeting standards for constitutional protection, such as information about shared leadership and how to maintain best practices for risk reduction.</p><p>In many ways, the Indigenous traditions in the Americas can provide an appropriate context and example of the psychedelic experience for people descended from other traditions, including Black Americans. A faith may evolve from experience with psychedelics that is the most inclusive and true to the visionary experience of the individual. Ideas from core shamanism, the paths of righteous conduct from Buddhism, Christianity, Islam, Hinduism, and Indigenous traditions are likely to evolve toward a more open and universal set of principles and guidelines. Environmental stewardship and trauma-informed understandings from psychotherapy and self-help traditions can be incorporated into orientation and integration sessions in group settings providing safe containers for celebratory and exploratory uses.</p><p>The AIMS Right to Try and rescheduling of psilocybin issues:</p><p>The AIMS cases involve persistent efforts to access psilocybin for end-of-life distress treatment. <em>Advanced Integrative Medical Science Institute, PLLC v. United States Drug Enforcement Agency</em>, (9th Cir. no. 22–1568) (AIMS II), involves an effort to prescribe psilocybin for palliative care in end-of-life existential distress. Dr. Sunil Aggarwal, a physical medicine physician working at an outpatient clinic who focuses his practice on oncology, psychiatry, neurology, and pain management treatment, is seeking to invoke the Right to Try Act, 21 USC § 360bbb, which has parallel state laws in many jurisdictions. These laws were enacted to help patients with end-of-life distress. An appeal involving the Drug Enforcement Administration’s authority under the Federal Right to Try Act to deny the efforts by Dr. Aggarwal to prescribe psilocybin was argued before the Ninth Circuit on the 19th of August. He filed the suit after being unable to acquire synthetic psilocybin from pharmaceutical companies and being denied permission or authorization from the Drug Enforcement Administration (DEA).</p><p>Dr. Aggarwal has been seeking to treat patients with terminal conditions with psilocybin under the 2018 Federal Right to Try Act since 2020, offering several proposals to the DEA. The AIMS plaintiffs have an associated case on appeal in the Ninth Circuit, no. 22–1718 (AIMS III), which involves a petition filed by AIMS in 2022 to reschedule psilocybin from Schedule I to Schedule II of the Controlled Substances Act. There are numerous organizations and professionals supporting rescheduling in amicus briefs. The Food and Drug Administration granted “breakthrough therapy” status for psilocybin to treat major depressive disorder in 2019, for Usona Institute and Compass Pathways.</p><p>Shane Pennington argued the appeal in this case, which involves the issue whether the federal government must allow patients access to psilocybin, notwithstanding its Schedule I status, to help with anxiety, depression, and distress in end-of-life palliative care. Seven states and the District of Columbia filed an amicus brief in support of the clinic’s arguments favoring access to psilocybin for patients with terminal conditions.</p><p>The DEA attorney, Thomas Pulham, advanced the position that the Right to Try Act does not provide any exemptions from the Controlled Substances Act or its implementing regulations. He conceded that the agency’s follow-up response to an inquiry represented a final agency order subject to appeal. In response to questioning during argument, he also conceded that the government could have granted some kind of waiver by rule. The government relied on psilocybin’s Schedule I status to support its position is that there is no pathway for access to psilocybin apart from research protocols, as well as the absence of references in the Right to Try Act to the Controlled Substances Act. The argument included discussion of section 822(d) the Controlled Substances Act, which provides for waiver of federal law: “The Attorney General may, by regulation, waive the requirement for registration of certain manufacturers, distributors, or dispensers if he finds it consistent with the public health and safety.” Counsel for Dr. Aggarwal argued that this to prescribe psilocybin was argued before the Ninth Circuit on the 19th of August. The Food and Drug Administration has granted “breakthrough therapy” status for psilocybin to treat major depressive disorder in 2019.</p><p>The agency conceded that it could accommodate the request for access, but that it was not required to do so because the examples of exceptions are limited to clinical experimentation. The court was averse to finding a silent exception or an implied repeal in the absence of a specific exemption for Right to Try laws, and seemed disposed to require an explicit exception in the Right to Try Act to use controlled substances. The court appeared uncomfortable with the minimal record available for review, however, and to be looking for a way to remand the case and avoid ruling on the issue. In response to one question, the attorney for the DEA said that the agency is considering the rescheduling petition very carefully, and that the agency was told by the office of legal counsel that its criteria for exemption were too narrow.</p><p>Soul Quest Liability Issues:</p><p>In the Begley v. Soul Quest Church of Mother Earth, Inc., case, the Orlando jury rendered a large liability verdict against Soul Quest and its founder. On May 15, 2024, the trial jury returned a $15,048,526.25 verdict against Soul Quest Church of Mother Earth, Inc., and Christopher Young (principal owner of Soul Quest) finding liability for failure to exercise ordinary care in causing Brandon Begley’s death. The jury found that Mr. Young’s instructions to Brandon caused the hyponatremia, and his refusal to call medical attention as he had seizures had precluded an opportunity for paramedics to save his life.</p><p>The jury concluded that Soul Quest was 40% liable and that Mr. Young was 60% liable for the verdict. The jury rejected the defense’s contention that Brandon was negligent in causing his death. The verdict was to be shared by each of the decedent’s parents. The jury rejected Mr. Young’s claim that the decedent had misrepresented a prior medical history,</p><p>The court had excluded exculpatory documents under unique circumstances, and a significant litigation about the ruling that two exculpatory documents were inadmissible. Mr. William Chapman, who represented the plaintiff estate, said that the releases were poorly written. A waiver document that the decedent had signed did not identify Soul Quest as the party to be released. It had been borrowed from another organization involved with soil conservation, so the wrong party was released. The trial court held that a second exculpatory document did not have enough specificity to be enforceable.</p><p>Mr. Chapman said that the trial judge tried to keep the case a negligence and products liability cause of action. Mr. Chapman said that there was a concept of <em>in pari delicto</em> that came up in the discussion of the waiver, and consideration of what the decedent had known, to bear on his own responsibility and assumption of risk. With respect to the products liability claim, the contributory negligence defense does not apply.</p><p>Mr. Chapman said that he thought that if Soul Quest had followed through on safety protocols it had represented to be in place, there would not have been any need for a waiver in the case. He said he is not opposed to having a safe place with protocols. He said that a specific and detailed release would be more likely to be enforceable. He stated that the practice of members signing releases makes it look more like a business than a purported religion.</p><p>Soul Quest closed in August 2024 to pursue bankruptcy protection. After the March 2018 incident with Mr. Begley that resulted in the wrongful death that would close its doors, Soul Quest developed appropriate safety measures and trained facilitators, practitioners, and integration coaches who provided services for regular ceremonies. The structure of leadership did not maintain the continuity of leadership and community that would be the best examples of sustainability.</p><p>The challenges to safe consumption of psychedelic plant medicines include inexperience, concern about law enforcement and exposure, insufficient care to the need for support structures, appropriate screening, unrealistic expectations, and insufficient integration. To anticipate and mitigate these risks and dangers, it is important for entheogenic churches to receive guidance about the appropriate and conscientious efforts to present safe containers for religious experiences and transformation toward community healing with the benefit of psychedelic medicines.</p><p>The Government Accountability Office May 2024 Report Urging Improvement of the Religious Exemption Program of the Drug Enforcement Administration:</p><p>The DEA administrative process concerning the consideration of religious exemption from the Controlled Substances Act for use of psilocybin for religious, Indigenous, or spiritual practices under the Religious Freedom Restoration Act was strongly criticized in a May 2024 Government Accountability Office report. In a 46-page report with appendices, the Government Accountability Office discusses the impact of Controlled Substances Act enforcement in jurisdictions that allow psilocybin use and possession, and barriers to accessing the psychedelic for medical use, research purposes and for religious purposes pursuant to the free exercise of religion. The report informed Congress about severe deficiencies in the religious exemptions petition process for psilocybin mushrooms and other controlled substances, and its recommendations for better procedures in the religious exemption process.</p><p>The Government Accountability Office report was based on an investigation requested by the U.S. Congress in a statement accompanying the 2023 appropriations act. The investigation responded to concerns raised by numerous stakeholders regarding the timeliness of determinations, the clarity of the considerations for exemption, and the lack of direction provided to applicants about the information their petitions should include. The 2022 spending act report directed the investigation to determine the following:</p><p>Psilocybin Report. The Committee directs GAO to report to Congress within one year of the date of enactment of this Act on the barriers to State, local, and Tribal programs that incorporate psilocybin products, including for therapeutic use and religious, Indigenous, or spiritual practices. The report shall: (1) review the impact of Controlled Substances Act enforcement on psilocybin use legally sanctioned by States, local governments, and Tribes; (2) identify barriers to accessing therapeutic use of psilocybin in States that have made such use legal under State law; (3) recommend ways to improve the processes used to obtain Federal authorization to conduct research with psilocybin-related substances; and (4) identify barriers to legal access to and use of psilocybin for religious, Indigenous, or spiritual practices under the Religious Freedom Restoration Act.</p><p>The Government Accountability Office reviewed the use of psilocybin, data on enforcement, and barriers to the legal access and use of psilocybin for religious practices under the Religious Freedom Restoration Act of 1993.</p><p>The report detailed the DEA registration process for individuals and entities interested in working with Schedule I substances, like psilocybin, for study, which have inhibited research, including inspection, record keeping, inventory, storage, and disposal requirements for all manufacturers, distributors, researchers, practitioners, and pharmacists. It noted that numerous clinical studies are underway to investigate the benefits of synthetic psilocybin for depression, headaches, fibromyalgia, pain, substance use and eating disorders, obsessive-compulsive disorder, and post-traumatic stress disorder. The report suggested appropriate legislation to facilitate research. It noted that Expanded Access legislation is limited by requirements of review by the Food and Drug Administration and institutional review bords, and that Right to Try laws are not providing access to psilocybin, notwithstanding the breakthrough therapy designation granted to the Usona Institute’s clinical trials and those of Compass Pathways. It described several impediments to research including FDA, institutional, and state government approval requirements, and DEA authorization and oversight requirements.</p><p>The report noted that the DEA investigations of crimes involving psilocybin made up very few of the agency’s investigations, about three percent, or 24 out of 13,865 over a six-year period, and amounted to under two percent of the seizures of material.</p><p>The report concluded that it could not find evidence of any tribal nation in the United States with historical involvement with using psilocybin for sacramental practices. The Department of the Interior and the Bureau of Indian Affairs told investigators that to their knowledge, no federally-recognized tribes have legalized psilocybin for religious or spiritual purposes at this time. The report states that Government Accountability Office representatives reached out to eleven tribes about the issue and that one responded. (Report at 5–7).</p><p>The Religious Exemption Process of the DEA and Findings of Deficiency</p><p>The investigation relied for input on four organizations, officials from the Food and Drug Administration and the Drug Enforcement Administration, and nine individuals from law firms and advocacy organizations. The attorneys and advocates pointed out problems with timeframes, lack of clear guidance, burdensome information requirements, a perception of unreliability and communication problems affecting the DEA administrative exemption process. (Report at 36–37). Five of the nine did not believe that the DEA would be likely to grant exemptions for the religious use of psilocybin and expressed the view that the agency was skeptical of non-western religious beliefs. (Report at 42).</p><p>The report discussed the pathway for spiritual or religious use of controlled substances, and the Religious Freedom Restoration Act provisions which provide claims and defenses to protect against any federal government activity that places a substantial burden on a sincere religious belief. Upon such a showing, the burden of proof shifts to the government to demonstrate that its burdensome actions further a compelling governmental interest by the least restrictive means. (Government Accountability Office report<em> </em>at 29) (citing<em> Gonzales v. O Centro Espirita Beneficente União do Vegetal, </em>546 U.S. 418 (2006), which upheld the right of practitioners in the branch of the <em>União do Vegetal</em> church in New Mexico to use ayahuasca as a sacrament under the free exercise of religion clause of the first amendment as revived by the Religious Freedom Restoration Act).</p><p>The report found that aspects of the DEA’s exemption review process, which purport to apply the Religious Freedom Restoration Act provisions, are unclear to petitioners. (Report at 35). The report found that the exemption process is overly burdensome and is missing explanations about what information is needed and standards for review.</p><p>The report discussed a 2009 DEA guidance document, which was updated in November 2020, for applications for religious exemptions from the Controlled Substances Act. The report found that the guidance does not define the considerations, standards or set time frames for making responses, and that there is no mechanism for status updates or final rulemaking procedures. (Report at 43). The report found that it is not clear what would be considered “sincerity,” especially where psilocybin has been used for a long time but there is not any documentation to show it was used. (Report at 37). “DEA’s guidance does not provide the standard the agency will use to assess ‘religious sincerity’ or other aspects of the application.” (Report at 37). The report gave an example of an investigative file showed confusion by the field agent because of this lack of clarity of what is a sufficient showing of belief system, structure, and practice to support a finding of sincerity. (Report at 37).</p><p>The report noted that from 2016 to January 2024, 24 petitions for religious exemption from the Controlled Substances Act had been filed under the Drug Enforcement Administration’s process, six for psilocybin, and as of January, the agency had not granted any religious exemptions. The Drug Enforcement Administration (DEA) had not acted on some exemption applications that had been pending for three to seven years.</p><p>There is a requirement of a case-by-case analysis for exemptions, and the agency may not simply rely on the Schedule I classification to support denial of exemptions. In the exemption procedure, the report noted, a sworn petition, preferably with supporting documents, is needed, and demonstrate that the application of the would be a substantial burden on the sincere exercise of religion (Report at 35). The petition for exemption is directed to the Diversion Control Division of the DEA. It may be submitted by email and may contain attached documents, a written statement and supporting information to show the burden on sincere exercise of religion. (Report at 35). The application must describe the nature of the religion, each practice associated with any use, possession, and manufacture, importation, exportation, dispensing, use, or possession of a controlled substance, its nature, and the amounts, conditions, and locations of each such transaction or interaction. (Report at 31–32).</p><p>The report stated that a certificate of registration is required before entering onto any activity with psychedelics like psilocybin, unless it is waived by the DEA. <em>Id</em>. at 32 (citing 21 C.F.R. § 1307.03). The attorney general may waive the registration requirement. (Report at 36). The petitioner “is required to abide by the Act and its regulations for the duration of the evaluation according to DEA guidance. (Report at 35). This means to comply with requirements that require not using controlled substances, or abstaining from consuming the church’s sacrament, during the application process. (Report at 36).</p><p>The report found that the agency had an indeterminate process with exemption requests, with examples of 24 requests over eight years from 2016 to 2024, with no exemptions granted. Three of the six exemption applications for psilocybin were withdrawn, one after waiting four years. (Report at 39). There were requests pending during the investigation for up to three years, and past unsuccessful applicants had waited almost five years and almost eight years. (Report at 38–39). The investigation received information that the DEA did not answer questions while the petition is pending, give updates or anticipated dates to anticipate its decisions, or identify local office contact personnel. (Report at 38).</p><p>The Diversion Control Division will return the application if it is incomplete, and applications will be considered withdrawn if the responses are not received withing 60 days. (Report at 36). The assistant administrator of the Diversion Control Division will give a response in writing, which the agency deems to be a final determination, for administrative law purposes, under 21 U.S.C. § 877, which would be reviewable in a federal court of appeals of the principal location of the petitioner within 30 days. (Report at 36).</p><p>One of the report’s observations about the DEA exemption process for religious organizations was that it was not guided by rulemaking and the agency never followed through on creating formal rules for the process. The agency’s Diversion Control Division had drafted a notice of proposed rulemaking in 2019 for RFRA exemption petitions and that in fall 2013 there was a unified agenda of regulatory actions that listed as a DEA priority to accommodate religious entities and to amend the application and hearing procedures, but that “DEA has no estimated for issuing the notice.” (Report at 33). There had been no activity since the draft notice in 2019, apparently, since the proposed rulemaking notice was reviewed by the Office of the Administrator. (Report at 44).</p><p>The DEA asserted that it followed consistent procedures for investigations, with on-site visits and interviews. When a petitioner invokes the exemption process, the report states that there will be an investigation that includes the background of the petitioner, and headquarters decides when the investigation is complete. (Report at 34–35). A field report will issue to the Diversion Control Division, which weighs the public interest and religious sincerity. The DEA examines the nature of the religion, its practices involving psychedelics as sacraments, its history, beliefs, structure, practices, membership, rituals, holidays, leadership, organizations, and other factors its investigators use to consider whether it is a sincere religion. (Report at 35–36). The division may order further investigation before issuing a decision whether to grant the petition. (Report at 33–34).</p><p>The DEA told the Government Accountability Office that it has “put in place processes aimed at reducing processing times” and that it was planning to streamline its process further and ensure consistency in approaching regulations. (Report at 42). Performance Audit concludes that the agency, “should more clearly communicate the types of information that the Religious Freedom Restoration Act petitioners should provide to allow DEA to evaluate petitions for religious sincerity.” It also states that the agency should “more clearly communicate the standards and relevant factors” when making its determinations, and “establish timeframes for DEA to make determinations on completed religious exemption petitions.” The report also urges the DEA to provide “information for petitioners to be able to receive updates on the agency’s process related to exemption reviews.”</p><p>The report states that the Government Accountability Office intends to measure progress toward meeting its four recommendations including timeframes for determining religious exemption claims, communicating what types of information are considered, disclosing the standards and factors for decision, and implementing a process for providing updates on the review process. Each of the four recommendations is attached to a status tracker. “When we confirm what actions the agency has taken in response to this recommendation,” the Government Accountability Office says, “we will provide updated information.”</p><p>It is very refreshing to see that the views of advocates have been taken into consideration as the recommendations were considered. The social change from the decriminalization and adult use programs with organic psilocybin have created some political pressure to have viable programs in place that are not purely prohibitionist.</p><p>Reflecting on the flaws in the process that led to the recommendations, an absence of rules, findings that reveal the need for a status tracker, and a pattern of rejections, it does not seem advisable to engage in the DEA administrative procedure for exemption from the Controlled Substances Act for religious and spiritual experience with psychedelics. Invoking the procedure would probably be a disadvantage for a meritorious applicant for religious exemption from the Controlled Substances Act for religious purposes. Moreover, the process is demanding, it requires discontinuing using the psychedelic sacrament and opens the organization to intrusive and burdensome record keeping for the DEA, far more than would be expected of mainstream religions. A party would be more likely to prevail by insisting on redress in federal court as a defense to enforcement and assert rights under the Religious Freedom Restoration Act with its right to judicial findings of fact and conclusion of law. Invoking the administrative process creates the implicit legal admission that it is a valid process, and gives the findings of the agency undue deference on appeal.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=645fe1ca7bd3" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Soul Quest and Lightning in a Bottle: Liability Verdicts For Wrongful Deaths Involving Psychedelics]]></title>
            <link>https://ronmcnutt.medium.com/soul-quest-and-lightning-in-a-bottle-liability-verdicts-for-wrongful-deaths-involving-psychedelics-e778063b4f6c?source=rss-368797e78488------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e778063b4f6c</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ronald W. McNutt]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 15 Jun 2024 17:58:04 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-06-15T18:11:40.181Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Soul Quest and Lightning in a Bottle: Liability Verdicts For Wrongful Deaths Involving Psychedelics</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*-0m6PSGBZowvn6J0N7bKGg.jpeg" /></figure><p>Ron McNutt, June 15, 2024</p><p>Ron studied religious use of psychedelics at Tufts, where he was a religion major. He has been a litigation attorney for most of his 41-year legal career. Ron is the steward of the Litigation and Advocacy Committee of the Psychedelic Bar Association. In October 2024, he will serve a one-year chaplain residency with the Veterans Administration hospitals in Nashville and Murfreesboro, Tennessee.</p><p>Some thoughts about my time with Soul Quest</p><p>Soul Quest Church of Mother Earth, Inc. was founded in 2015 in Orlando, Florida by Chris Young and Verena Young. It is formed as a neo-shamanic church with a hybrid retreat center model, like many plant medicine ceremonial centers in Peru and Latin America. Dr. Scott Irwin was a corporate director as well, but he resigned and left for Ecuador in July 2021. He is living with the Sacha Wasi, an indigenous village with medicine ceremonies.</p><p>My introduction to ayahuasca was at Soul Quest on March 9–10, 2018. I went back for ceremonies the weekends of August 14–15, 2020, December 4–5, 2020, March 26–27, 2021, August 26–27, 2021, January 28–29, 2022, and October 14–15, 2022. I have had 20 ayahuasca ceremonial weekends, 7 at Soul Quest, and I have never tried Kambo. Ayahuasca can cause blood sugar to drop, or blood pressure to increase, so it is necessary to stop eating after 3:00, to have a clear diet beforehand, and to avoid contraindicated medications. I did not eat enough the first time I went, although eating beforehand was recommended. Adequate nutrition is very important with ayahuasca consumption.</p><p>I was feeling very well when I left that Sunday from my first ceremony. Chris was encouraging people to have Kambo ceremonies. Two weeks later was the ceremony weekend that led to the death of Brandon Begley. He died of hyponatremia, low sodium levels, which can be caused by overhydration. There was evidence that the decedent consumed copious amounts of water after having Kambo that Sunday morning, despite directions to the contrary. Chris Young has emergency medical tech training, although his EMT license expired in 2006.</p><p>The jury found that Chris he was responsible for the delay in obtaining medical treatment. Brandon was showing signs of distress around 2:00, shortly after the administration of Kambo. He was not responsive at 5:00, and around 8:00, was given cane sugar water, and shortly afterward, he had a seizure. Chris called 911 at 8:09, and Brandon was unresponsive and unconscious when emergency medical assistance arrived.</p><p>I kept the preparation materials and the schedule from Soul Quest from March 2018, a couple of weeks before he died. They were having Kambo on Sundays at 11:00 after the Friday and Saturday night ayahuasca ceremonies, and the Saturday daytime ceremony. Kambo is not a psychedelic but frog venom that causes severe shock and disruption of the autonomic nervous system. The materials have instructions that encouraged people to drink a lot of water the morning of a Kambo ceremony. Brandon had attended Soul Quest the weekend of February 23–25, 2018, and did not have Kambo.</p><p>The tragic events and the verdict are a cause for carefully considering precautions, but I believe the verdict itself is a precedent with numerous factors and deficiencies: it is not only the ayahuasca, or only the combination with Kambo, that were deemed to be the cause of death. The tragedy took place after Kambo, combined with several hours of lack of response when emergency treatment was needed, and honey water. The verdict considered a variety of compounding problems from these various factors, not just the ayahuasca and Kambo together that make an unsafe product. Chris Young’s decision to mix the two at Soul Quest and not take urgent action may be a fatal flaw for Soul Quest, but the result should not be interpreted to discredit this powerful spiritual medicine.</p><p>I hope that people will not view that weekend as representative of the level of care that Soul Quest has provided to this time. I think Soul Quest improved itself with strong leadership by the women and men it developed as facilitators and guardians. From September 2020 until January 2022, I was volunteering with the Sunday service production team with Scott and four core people. At its peak, there were about 26 online integration groups, a medical director, paramedics, with layers of accountability: facilitators, guardians, and volunteers. They trained many volunteers, and provided screening, orientation, preparation calls, advice and directions on diet, supervision, programs like yoga for grounding, and integration. The period from mid-2020 to late 2022, when I was participating and volunteering, I felt there were excellent staff and a great volunteer program. I noticed in early 2023 that Soul Quest lost almost every one of the exemplary leaders I had known; they did not retain the facilitators and guardians I knew, and they have moved onward.</p><p>The facilitators were responsible for securing the premises and making decisions about treatment challenges, supported by guardians. There was an onsite medical team led by Tiffany Riley, an emergency medicine and natural medicine practitioner. There were therapists and life coaches who would lead groups, with significant experience, and they would take a five-month training course called Being True to You. There was a very diverse group of participants and leaders. It was a healing space with people of different races, ages, and backgrounds. There was a purification ceremony, and a prayer before we would drink dosages of varying amounts deemed appropriate for one’s experience and condition. The volunteers would wear white clothing and escort people who had to go to the bathroom. Spiritually evocative music from different traditions would be played.</p><p>Many people would come to help heal trauma and addiction, and problems such as dependency. Soul Quest provided insight from Dr. Gabor Mate and the therapists and life coaches. The leaders encouraged intentions of reverence, openness, and respect, to cooperate with the ayahuasca experience, which was understood to reveal the universal source and presence that are part of the inner essence that is joined with creation. The experience revealed layers of resistance that can be released and help one connect more deeply with one’s soul, to be more alive, open to positive changes in relations and wellbeing, and gratitude, forgiveness, and love.</p><p>The online groups included lessons from A Course in Miracles and other sources. There were groups for paramedics and there was a lot of effort to serve veterans and military personnel. Sometimes indigenous facilitators would preside, including the Kuntanawa and Yawanawá. Factors such as the retreat format, irregular attendance, the absence of a central set of theological beliefs, the presence of for-profit health care aspect, the Natural Healing Center, and the wrongful death case, led to the conclusion by the DEA that it was not a sincere religious organization.</p><p>John P. Begley, personal representative for Brandon K. Begley v. Soul Quest Church of Mother Earth, Inc. <em>et al.</em>, Orange County Circuit 2020-CA-003387-O (May 15, 2024):</p><p>On May 15, 2024, an Orlando, Florida jury returned a $15,048,526.25 wrongful death verdict against Soul Quest Church of Mother Earth, Inc., and Christopher Young, the CEO, president, and co-owner of Soul Quest, after a seven-day trial with several witnesses including medical doctors in nephrology, forensic pathology, and toxicology, and an expert psychiatrist, Charles Grob, M.D. The exhibits included medical and emergency records, the autopsy report, corporate records, and documents related to Soul Quest’s safety guidelines and practices. The jury found Chris Young liable for failure to exercise ordinary care in causing Brandon Begley’s death, and that Soul Quest served a dangerous product, apparently the Kambo combined with ayahuasca, leading to a wrongful death that occurred in March 2018. The verdict apportioned 40% liability to Soul Quest, $6,019,410.50, and 60% liability to Chris Young, $9,029,115.75.</p><p>The jury concluded that the decedent died after severe, acute hyponatremia resulting from the decedent’s experience with Kambo following his ayahuasca ceremonies. It is a condition of low sodium, which can result from overhydration or excessive vomiting. The jury rejected the defense’s contention that Brandon Begley was negligent in causing his death. Chris Young was called as a witness for both sides and he apparently acknowledged at trial that he got it “wrong” and that he did not know what severe, acute hyponatremia was. According to the verdict, the jury concluded that the decedent had not misrepresented a prior medical history or contributed to causing the hyponatremia, and that Chris Young’s delay in calling for medical attention after a medical emergency, with Mr. Begley having seizures, precluded an opportunity for medical attention to save his life. Saline solution used between 2:00 and 8:00 likely would have saved Brandon Begley’s life.</p><p>Soul Quest had wonderful leadership by women, particularly Tiffany Riley, the on-site medical director, several facilitators and guardians, Laurie Maddox, Norelle Adams, Lori Drell, Lenoria Kroos, Lora Parsons Wilson, Colleen Mix. Grace Charles was an active volunteer and originally from a Haitian family. Ben Heimann, Carlos Guzman, Scott Irwin, Brandon Pickard, and many other men also provided strong leadership at important times. I would like to praise the facilitators, guardians, and the volunteers who improved Soul Quest and to thank everyone committed to risk reduction who can apply lessons learned. We should encourage careful preparation with appropriate nutrition and healthy ways to approach this profound experience.</p><p>Soul Quest had screening and preparation practices and informed consent and waiver of liability forms, as well as medical screening measures. The exculpatory documents were not admitted as defense exhibits. The signed forms did not identify the proper parties, and they were objectionable as violative of public policy because of the illegal status of the sacrament and the adverse opinion in the Eleventh Circuit, as well as the presence of a claim for strict liability for serving a defective product (which involved the multifaceted issues) that was unreasonably dangerous.</p><p>The proof revealed a very bad case characterized by a combination of ceremonies with ayahuasca followed by a later session with Kambo, compounded with an unreasonable delay in calling emergency medical services. The case should not be interpreted to support a general principle that ayahuasca is an unsafe medicine. Serving the two substances in series was deemed to be an unsafe product. The jury was informed that ayahuasca is a “Schedule 1 controlled substance,” and there was evidence that Kambo created a physiological hazard. The combination of events and evidence at trial provide a way to distinguish the result, and Soul Quest’s improved supervision and risk reduction practices resulted in more favorable results since 2018.</p><p>The verdict is a warning to other facilities not to hesitate to call 911 in emergencies, to be able to recognize health emergencies, not to overdo the dieta requirements, and not to compound risks by offering Kambo in conjunction with ayahuasca. It also will increase skepticism by institutions like the DEA and academicians, and inhibit domestic practices with ayahuasca in large retreat settings, and steer people toward small ceremonial circles using best practices. The case about Soul Quest’s religious protection was decided against it on appeal, and I do not think the petition for rehearing is going to change it, so it is almost final. Maybe it could reform as a different entity, and try to be a better model that will gain protection as a religious entity. The corporation and owner could get some relief in bankruptcy.</p><p>Coincidentally, on May 24, 2024, an article in The Guardian discussed a coroner’s investigation of the death of a 46-year-old Australian man, Jarrad Antonovich, on October 16, 2021, at a Dreaming Arts Festival in New South Wales. The investigation revealed that a ceremony combined ayahuasca and Kambo. The decedent was becoming was becoming increasingly ill but he was opposed to going to a hospital and he later died of a perforated esophagus. A witness said he had not disclosed to the facilitators that he had asthma. Leaders at the ceremony apparently were opposed to seeking medical help and one of the facilitators said he was being looked after appropriately. The facts indicated that the facilitator and decedent were inhibited by the illegality of the medicine and the desire to protect themselves, and there was evidence that one of the facilitators made efforts to discourage a witness from revealing facts. After an investigation, the case was referred by the coroner to the Director of Public Prosecutions as a criminal matter.</p><p>ICEERS report on worldwide ayahuasca deaths:</p><p>There was a June 2023 overview by International Center for Ethnobotanical Education, Research and Service (ICEERS) of the global reported deaths in the media associated with ayahuasca retreats. It concludes that the acute effects of ayahuasca intoxication using the traditional formulas for ayahuasca without other admixtures probably did not cause of any acute deaths. Extrapolating from various sources, it estimated about 4.24 million people had consumed ayahuasca with about 824,000 individuals doing so in 2019. About 1.3 million people from the U.S. have had ayahuasca, with about 200,000 having it in 2019. Most people who had the experience, 62 %, had a bachelor’s degree or more education, and a similar proportion were professionals. 94 % would have it in a ritual context under the leadership of a specialist. Most of the retreat centers were in Peru, 173, with 20 in Costa Rica, 14 in Colombia, 13 in Ecuador, 7 in Brazil, and 5 in Bolivia. The settings typically are one-week retreats with 3 to 4 ceremonies. About 567,000 Brazilians had experience with ayahuasca, in religious settings like União do Vegetal, Santo Daime, Barquinha, or neo-shamanic traditions.</p><p>From 1994 to 2022, there were 16 cases of death after consumption of ayahuasca, involving possible adverse reactions to ayahuasca, but the study concluded that these reactions could have been instances of contraindicated drug use or an admixture such as Brugmansia. There was a bone fracture and a case of hyponatremia or heart attack. Although there were 58 reports of deaths associated with ayahuasca, some apparently had not involved consumption. There were 8 homicides, 14 suicides, 3 drownings, and 4 tobacco infusions in the context of the ceremonies. The study concluded:</p><p>The deaths that the media reported were indirectly from ayahuasca could have been avoided by incorporating safety standards when admitting participants, supervising the experience, and integrating it afterward, or offering psychological follow-up if necessary. Based on our preliminary analysis, the ratio between the deaths directly or indirectly attributed to ayahuasca and the number of people taking it worldwide seems to be very low.</p><p>Lightning In a Bottle case</p><p><em>Gatlin et al. v. Do Lab, Inc., and MAPS, the Multidisciplinary Association for Psychedelic Studies, Inc.</em>, California Civil Court, Case №20CV002753 (Nov. 30, 2022).</p><p>On May 28, 2017, a 20-year-old woman, Baylee Gatlin, died from multiple organ failure from heat stroke after she had been cared for at the Zendo sanctuary harm reduction tent at the Lightning in a Bottle festival. She had been sent by the medical tent personnel to the harm reduction tent without indicating that she was in great distress. The peer support staff did not know what substance she had taken, or appreciate the extent of her heat stroke. Her vital signs were checked at the Zendo tent, and after her condition deteriorated, she was moved to the medical tent and later died after being transported from the festival by emergency medical service providers.</p><p>A wrongful death suit was filed by her parents in Los Angeles. The jury found a breach of the duty to exercise ordinary care with respect to training of volunteers to identify medical emergencies and call for medical or emergency services. The jury found that this led to postponing calling for emergency services. The finding of breach of the duty of care involved representations that created the reasonable expectation that there would be safety at Zendo’s support tent. The festival was not close to outside medical facilities, and the volunteers at the sanctuary tent had received admission to the festival for their services without receiving extensive training.</p><p>Although the Zendo project limited its role to support services, the liability determination shows that peer support providers are working within an unpredictable environment supporting others. Volunteers need to be able to identify a medical emergency and call for emergency services.</p><p>MAPS indemnified its volunteers and staff under <em>respondeat superior</em> principles. It was found to be 25 % liable under comparative fault principles for Ms. Gatlin’s death. MAPS paid the portion of a $ 4 million verdict, $ 1.33 million, of its subsidiary, Zendo, to her parents. While the medical provider was held to be 50 % liable, there had been a settlement the previous year between the personal representatives and the event producer, Do Lab Inc., and the medical providers, Richard Gottlieb, individually and doing business as RGX Medical, for $ 4 million. The medical providers were insured to provide medical services at the festival, while MAPS was self-insured.</p><p>Zendo is a nonprofit corporation that was founded in 2012, and it has provided harm reduction for over fifty events. Originally, it was part of MAPS, which began offering peer support in the early 2000s. Zendo has been independent since May 2023, and it has secured liability insurance. The director of Zendo, Chelsea Rose Pires, stated that since the 2017 tragedy, Zendo has developed protocols to require eight hours of training per event, increased communication with medical providers, enhanced digital record keeping with documentation of medical involvement, and involvement of medical personnel in each shift. Zendo has adopted an interdisciplinary healthcare Pulse Team to provide additional support. A medical triage volunteer will monitor for signs of dehydration, heat exposure, and physical distress. When peer support providers have questions about the health of a guest, they will need to contact medical staff immediately and document the information.</p><p>For volunteers who support people having challenging psychedelic experiences, it is important to build relationships with providers of security, law enforcement, medical services, and festival producers. Sara Gael, who has been involved in the leadership of Zendo, was present in 2017. She noted that people do not ordinarily test their drugs and that they did not know what Ms. Gatlin had taken. She seemed like hundreds of other distressed guests that they had served over the years. Adulterated and novel substances often have lethal doses, and drug testing could be an important safeguard going forward.</p><p>Psychedelic peer support services are offered to reduce the risk of adverse consequences from experiences with psychedelics, which can provide important experiences that are also difficult and frightening. Intense emotions and altered emotions arise from confronting unfamiliar and deeper parts of the psyche, which can result in existential distress. This is amplified in cases of inadequate preparation, unfamiliarity with the experience, large doses of substances, difficult circumstances, and uncomfortable settings.</p><p>Compassionate care services like Zendo, which involve volunteer support, can help prevent serious adverse consequences. Peer support traditions include the Hog Farm at Woodstock, and similar services were offered at earlier festivals, as discussed in Dr. Larry Brilliant’s book, and in Grateful Dead parking lots, at Rainbow Gatherings, and at the Boom Festival.</p><p>Sitters can provide support in grounding guests who are medically safe by offering empathy and assurance in a gentle and ethical manner and a peaceful space, alongside medical treatment options and mental health services for individuals requiring services outside the parameters of peer support. They can help people gradually become grounded and transition through difficulties to synthesize and learn that “strength, resilience, surrender, and deep wisdom are often forged in the fires lit in our darkest times.”</p><p>Raymond Allen, the general counsel for MAPS, stated in October 2023 that organizations need to have clear contracts and exercise due diligence before partnering with individuals and organizations. He advised that there should be clear lines of authority, clear roles and job descriptions, training and management standards, and terms providing for medical responsibility and legal liability. He stated that a harm reduction organization should have its own liability insurance coverage.</p><p>Attorney Allison Hoots discussed the case in May 2023, and discussed the liability risks facing volunteers and providers of support. Public perception and society’s prohibitionist policies can create pressures that inhibit efforts to make consumption safer. Safety measures are subject to consequences under the 2003 “Rave Act,” The Illicit Drug Antiproliferation Act of 2003. This legislation enhanced penalties under a prior law, the “Crack House” law, that punish activities that knowingly allow drug use. The Rave Act was directed at organizers of electronic dance parties, creating liability for promoters and club owners. It provides fines up to $ 250,000 and civil penalties for knowingly leasing, using, or profiting from a space where illegal drugs are being stored, manufactured, distributed, or used. The law inhibits measures like providing medical or educational services for people who are taking drugs. It can confuse harm reduction and safety measures, like medical support and traditional mental health crisis responses, with encouragement and persuasion to use illegal substances.</p><p>Ms. Hoots advised that people should be encouraged to consult in advance with their personal physicians. She emphasized that a Third Circuit decision in 2021 held that the “Crack House” law applied to the activities of a nonprofit safe house, punishing efforts to reduce risks.</p><p>Dance Safe and Test Your Poison sell testing kits online for detecting contaminants in substances. Contamination and heat exposure are serious dangers in this area.</p><p>For people sitting for people having psychedelic experiences, even well-worded waiver forms and informed consent forms, asserting that the user knowingly and voluntarily agrees to accept the risks of medical contraindications and mental health risks, are by no means a guarantee of protection. Insurance companies do not cover illegal activities, and even making referrals or recommendations for centers operating outside of the county can create liabilities for problems people face at their destinations.</p><p>The Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Agency, SAMHSA, a division of the federal Department of Health and Human Services, leads public efforts to advance behavioral health and improve outcomes for people impacted by substance use disorders. In the summer of 2023, Zendo was invited to discuss integrating psychedelic harm reduction into federal initiatives. In addition to counseling through the Fireside Project, Dance Safe offers drug testing kits, to help prevent overdoses or other harm from adulterants or contamination.</p><p>It makes good sense to have legal protection for ceremonial practice with psilocybin, as well as San Pedro cactus, which do not present the same danger from contraindicated medications. In May 2024, there was a performance audit report by the U.S. Government Accountability Office to congressional committees, which was highly critical of the DEA religious exemption process with respect to psilocybin-based spiritual practices. It revealed that the agency was creating barriers to protecting ceremonial practices with psilocybin through artificially restrictive and unclear reporting demands, failing to follow through with the review process, and rejecting applications. The agency was admonished and placed on an improvement plan to improve its process for recognition of Religious Freedom Restoration Act claims.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e778063b4f6c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>