<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Rory Hoeschen on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Rory Hoeschen on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@roryhoeschen?source=rss-e38a8f15a9ac------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Mon, 16 Nov 2026 13:07:55 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@roryhoeschen/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Memories of a Greener Place: A Trip to Costa Rica]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@roryhoeschen/memories-of-a-greener-place-a-trip-to-costa-rica-89a45cfb54c7?source=rss-e38a8f15a9ac------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/89a45cfb54c7</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[travel]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[costa-rica]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Rory Hoeschen]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 28 Jul 2024 03:05:15 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-07-28T19:54:30.187Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*_pDxFy3inMmSqmZJfWbCUg.jpeg" /></figure><p>The first thing I say upon getting out of the van in Monteverde is “this is the best air I have ever breathed.”</p><p>I do not know if this is true. I do not particularly know what this means. All I know is that right now, high in the mountains, surrounded by more green than I have ever seen in my life, it seems like the right thing to say.</p><p>I take another breath.</p><p>The trees here are unbelievable. Everywhere I look, green upon green upon green, more shades than I knew existed. There is not a single blank space in the forest, every gap filled by another plant, another flower. I cannot see more than a few meters into it — it is dense and unknowable and beautiful beautiful beautiful. Everywhere I look is another unique leaf, petal, vine, root, things I have never seen before. My vision spirals, trying to find something to grab onto — I cannot stop my eyes from roaming roaming roaming. I cannot believe so much detail exists in the world.</p><p>I gently touch a bright orange flower, named after a bird. I wonder if there are really birds that look like this, if they exist outside of paintings. Surely the world cannot get more beautiful than this.</p><p>I wake up early — too early. The first rays of sunlight brush my eyelids and I cannot fall back asleep. I blink awake and move to the window, hoping to see the trees again, the beautiful trees, and instead I see a bird. Teal and green and jet-black, a long tail with fancy feathers, intelligent eyes that stare at me as it swallows a bright orange berry.</p><p>It moves to the next berry and I am frozen, held in place by a bird more beautiful than any I have ever seen. (I will later learn this is a Motmot. I will later see more of them, again and again. It will never get old.) I whisper-shout for my sister to come and see, see the unbelievable bird, and I barely even register her padding footsteps, her gasp of delight, our silence together as we watch the bird for what could be seconds or hours. Eventually, it flies away and the spell is broken.</p><p>I will not stop thinking about it for the rest of the week.</p><p>It seems that many things in Costa Rica are better than their American counterparts. The air. The trees. The birds. The fruit. Juicy pineapple, sweet watermelon, bright orange papaya (new to me, delicious). The mango juice here is like liquid gold, leaving sticky sweetness running down the back of my throat, conjuring the memory of scraping mango flesh off a rough pit even as I drink it through a straw. It is the most wonderful thing I have ever tasted. I drink it every day. Sometimes it comes with mint or orange slices, and I devour these as well. Everything tastes better in Costa Rica.</p><p>No one has ever given me a fried plantain before. I am unsure what to expect. No one told me that it would melt into sugar on my tongue, the crispy edges perfectly melding into the gooey center. It is better than candy, more delicious than cake. I eat fried plantains as much as I can, often paired with rice and beans for breakfast or pork at lunch. Halfway through each meal, my family asks why I haven’t eaten them yet. They do not know that I am saving them for last so their flavor will linger on my tongue the longest, bits of charred plantain stuck to the back of my teeth for the rest of the day, a reminder of the sweetness of this country.</p><p>I always forget to look up in the rainforest. We are hiking down the side of a mountain and I must watch for roots and rocks and snakes (theoretically — I have not seen any yet). Our guide points out interesting flowers and cool bugs, smiling at me when I spot a millipede thicker than my finger, pointing at the spots along its side. The ground is full of bugs and tripping hazards and potential snakes: it is so easy to forget to look up.</p><p>But every once in a while, when I stop to take a breath, to make sure I’m not leaning on a poisonous caterpillar, to take in the dappled sunlight for a second, I glance upward. Each time I am immediately rendered speechless.</p><p>Where the horizon should be are trees, barricades of bark and vines, stretching up and up and up into the sky. The cliffs here are made of vegetation instead of rock, layers upon layers of bushes and flowers, endlessly detailed. They seem to continue forever. We are surrounded by jungle, the clouds playing in the tips of the branches, the sun barely reaching us so far below. I cannot get over the sheer scale of this place.</p><p>My sister bumps into me, too focused on the roots and rocks to notice me there. Snapped out of my reverie, I hurry ahead to catch up with our guide before I miss some fascinating creature, holding the image of the green cliffs in my head, trying to remember where I am.</p><p>The birds here are something out of myth, of legend. Logically I knew that parrots and toucans lived in the wild, that birds this colorful existed outside of picture books. But I did not understand it.</p><p>I have seen toucans a million times in documentaries and shows, books and movies, pictures and paintings. The rainbow colors of its beak are etched into my mind as something fictional. They do not fit with my image of the world: a bird with a beak bigger than its skull, multicolored spirals against a jet-black body. I do not truly believe that they exist.</p><p>When the toucan lands on the tree next to us, I am speechless. Parts of the world I didn’t know existed are suddenly made real, made physical, by the bird in front of me. I feel my reality being expanded to include the toucan, horizons broadening as the light flashes off its beak. It is amazing. My world will never shrink again.</p><p>I am a bit too excited to swim in the waterfall.</p><p>We have been hiking for hours, the sweat beginning to stick to my body, the sun just a little too bright, the back of my throat raw from lack of water. When we emerge from the narrow shaded path into a clearing, it takes a second for my eyes to adjust, to recognize what I’m seeing.</p><p>A waterfall, enormous and spectacular, plunges down the side of a cliff into a pool below. The spray it sends up fills the air, creating rainbows and getting my glasses dirty. I cannot look directly at it; the sun is right at its top, making it feel even larger than it is.</p><p>I run down the slippery, moss-covered rocks to the pool’s edge, pulling off my shoes and socks as I go. I need to swim in this pool, to experience this part of the jungle firsthand, to swallow clear water and know that it has come from some place I will never see, can never imagine. I already know I will need to live in this moment forever.</p><p>I wade in, the water cold enough to make me catch my breath. The sun suddenly feels wonderfully warm, and I spread my arms to the sky to catch the last bit of its rays before I wade into the shadow of the cliff. As the shadow swallows me, the waterfall comes into focus, ten thousand beautiful twisting streams of water, some weaving against the cliff, some dissolving in mid-air. I dunk my head underwater, letting it stream between my teeth, weave its way into my stomach, cold pooling in my gut as I greedily gulp down more. When I finally surface the waterfall is even more unbelievable, shifting out of focus, the thousands of streams blending into one breathtaking mist, the sun blurring across my eyes.</p><p>I have lost my glasses.</p><p>I try not to panic, the gentle cool in my gut instantly turning to pure ice, the sun suddenly too hot, the stream so fast and so wide, the chasms between the rocks I am standing on yawning into nothingness, an abyss reaching out to swallow my glasses, leave me unable to see for the rest of the week, headache-riddled and nauseous, this beautiful country obscured behind a blur.</p><p>My hand reaches down, grasps, grasps again. Water. Rock. Water. Further down. I brush them, my glasses. A laugh bursts out of me in pure delight, echoing around the rocks, swallowed by the waterfall. Our guide reaches a hand out for my glasses, an angel come to save me from my own forgetfulness. How could I have believed for a second I would lose my glasses? Never in a place so blessed, so beautiful, on a day so nice.</p><p>My guide will have to return in a minute for my phone, tangled in my pocket, waterlogged and still, somehow, spectacularly, working. Nothing could go wrong in a place like this.</p><p>I am trying not to make a big deal out of the fact that it is my birthday. I am turning nineteen, a number that feels impossibly big and impossibly small at the same time. I am a kid and I am an adult. I can make my own decisions and I probably shouldn’t. I know what my future holds and yet I can never really understand: both terrify me. I wish I was a satisfied grown-up already and I wish I was a kindergartner again. I can never stop the thought spirals on my birthday.</p><p>I pocket a bottle cap for my collection. Five-year-old me smiles.</p><p>We are sitting at the head of a hiking trail, eating chicken and rice, watching the birds at the feeder. I am fascinated by the black-and-red birds with shiny silver-blue beaks. They look like paintings come to life, metallic paint mixed in some far-off land and applied to their beaks by a miniscule brush, one by one.</p><p>I am not expecting anything for my birthday. We are in Costa Rica, after all. The air and the sun is gift enough for me. I am trying to forget it is happening anyway. The less attention drawn to it, the better.</p><p>My guide gets up from the table, grabs something from behind the counter. The bird at the feeder cocks its head, indignant as a blue-gray bird steals its papaya. A series of chirps and wing flutters fill the air. A slice of cake is placed in front of me, the birds alight, drawing my gaze into the sun — -</p><p>Cake. A beautiful chocolate cake, with whipped cream and a cherry. It is rich and dark, the deepest brown I have ever seen. Our guide starts singing, the waiter joining in, “Feliz cumpleaños, feliz cumpleaños…” I laugh with delight, joining in to the familiar tune with unfamiliar words, stumbling over the accent I am not used to. My family is singing too, not in time, not in tune, but who cares? The cake is beautiful and the birds are singing and someone has thought of me today.</p><p>I hand out forks to my family and the guide, “gracias” falling from my lips again and again. I cannot believe my good fortune. The cake is every bit as delicious as it looks, washed down with mango juice and birdsong, the laughter of people I love around me. This is what I will remember from my birthday this year, the beauty of this exact moment. Nothing else seems to matter.</p><p>I dance with a Costa Rican boy who cannot be more than sixteen. He comes from a family of musicians. My guide tells me there is music in his blood.</p><p>His hands are sweaty and he is a clumsy dancer, but I am clumsier. We laugh together as I step on his toes again, him doing his very best to teach me the simplest steps possible. I cannot stop smiling. I look over his shoulder to see my mom dancing with his brother, who cannot be more than eight. He is already a wonderful musician, and he giggles as he tells my mom in about his family in stumbling English. I can hear my dad and my sister behind me, exclaiming as they are pulled onto the dance floor. Our guide has also been roped in, the clumsiest of us all, tripping over his own feet and grinning all the while. The music would be too loud in any other context but here, in someone’s grandma’s kitchen, surrounded by people I don’t know, the pitch black of the jungle pressing in on the edges of the porch, here it is perfect. I cannot stop smiling.</p><p>We dance and dance and dance, driving back the tiredness in our eyes to keep clapping, keep stomping, keep going. I stumble over my steps and do my best to follow what the musicians are doing, catching smiles from them whenever I mess up. The only song I know is the Macarena: I do my best to teach the grandma the steps. She does not speak a word of English, and I speak no Spanish, but we high five at the end of the song, laughing together. The little boy squeals with delight as we do a dance where we pretend to be bulls. His mother walks us through complicated steps, the music never stopping, never slowing, forcing me to do my best and just keep going, just keep laughing. When the music finally fades, we are all covered in sweat, the gentle breeze of the jungle doing nothing to cool us down. We smile as we down glass after glass of ice-cold guanabana juice, which, like everything in Costa Rica, I have just discovered and promptly fallen in love with. None of us have anything in particular to say, throwing around compliments and jokes and random stories just to fill the air, to keep basking the the glow of the dance for a few minutes more.</p><p>Soon I will head back to college, back to constant stress and no friends, cold weather and poorly-preserved fruit. But for now I am here, in Costa Rica, where the juice is cold and the air is warm, where I dance with people I barely know, where everything I see is beautiful beyond belief, where I cannot stop smiling. Tomorrow I will wake up early and spot new birds, lie on the ground with the sun in my face, nearly step on a lizard longer than my arm. He will stare at me with unblinking orange eyes, emerald scales bright against the path. He will be the most beautiful thing I have ever seen.</p><p>I close my eyes in pure delight, drink the last of my juice, smile as our guide tells another groan-worthy joke, the band starts another song, the breeze continues to play across my face. Right now I am here and there is nowhere I would rather be.</p><p><em>Pura vida.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=89a45cfb54c7" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Watching the Summer Pass: The Temporal Construction of Firewatch]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@roryhoeschen/watching-the-summer-pass-the-temporal-construction-of-firewatch-e89fb19d74c2?source=rss-e38a8f15a9ac------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e89fb19d74c2</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[game-analysis]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[firewatch]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Rory Hoeschen]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 14 Jun 2024 16:37:21 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-06-14T16:37:21.185Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="A screenshot of Firewatch. The sun sets over a pine forest, everything is tinged orange. From a first-person perspective, your character raises his hand to block the light from his eyes." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*wSNoGoIt8On9n_miSUYqIQ.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>This essay was written for a video game analysis class.</em></p><p><strong>Day 1<br></strong>A bird chirps in the distance. The wind rustles through the trees, the sunlight dappled by their leaves. A cloud rolls across the sky. A stick cracks under your foot.</p><p><em>Firewatch</em> is not a fast game.</p><p><em>Firewatch</em> is what’s known as a “walking simulator,” a game in which the main mechanic is simply walking from place to place. The game has no stamina or health bars to manage, no complex crafting trees, no hitstop or explosions. You simply walk. You wander the trails of Wyoming’s Shoshone National Park, through canyons and caves, forests and fields, accompanied by the radio chatter of a fellow fire lookout, Delilah. The story unfolds through a combination of dialogue and exploration, each triggering the other throughout the game.</p><p>This simple, relaxed gameplay makes <em>Firewatch</em> a target for mockery. “Calling a game a walking simulator is a way to mock and deride it, suggesting that the entire game can be reduced to little more than a simulation of what is imagined to be the most banal, uninteresting, and easiest of activities: walking” (Ruberg 201). <em>Firewatch</em>, in purposefully not containing many game mechanics we have come to expect from video games, seems to some people to not be a game at all. Rather, they see it as a boring recreation of walking, a game in which you press “w” to move forward and nothing else.</p><p>But reducing <em>Firewatch</em> to its mechanics does it a disservice, disregards the important parts of the game, the feeling of playing it, the very sensation of its walk. And <em>Firewatch</em>, by constructing a specific experience of walking, is also constructing a very specific experience of time.</p><p><strong>Day 2<br></strong>The languid buzz of cicadas, the gentle lap of waves upon the lakeshore. It is mid-afternoon, the blue of the sky dulled by the heat beating down upon you. Something rustles in the dry bushes, the sound slowly fading into the still afternoon.</p><p>Playing a game slowly — being forced to play a game slowly — is counter to mainstream ideas of fast-paced games, button-mashes and combo-inputs and lightning-quick reactions, but it is not inherently worse. It is simply <em>different</em>. “In contrast to supposedly ‘real’ games… walking simulators insist on the value of the slow stroll, and thus they facilitate a genre of queer play” (Ruberg 205). By making players experience the world at a slower speed than they are used to, walking simulators like <em>Firewatch</em> disrupt the expected experience of game time, creating a queer type of play. You are forced not to attack and react, but to watch and listen. The game’s environment encourages this, the peaceful forest lending itself well to sustained, thorough observation, new details always popping out at the player: “The player-characters… take pleasure in tarrying as they pass gradually from area to area, often stopping to observe, refusing to rush” (Ruberg 205). Rather than running from objective to objective, the walk between becomes the point, the world rewarding the player for lingering with tiny secrets, new conversations, and breathtaking vistas. The in-between space is recontextualized, changed from a path into a goal in itself. The player slows down.</p><p>Perhaps it’s fitting that <em>Firewatch</em> is a game about escaping modern life, leaving behind a job and a wife and the day’s busy schedule for the isolation of the forest: a forced deceleration mirrored by both the player and the character. It is a contrast both to the average video game and the bustle of the quotidian. In denying the player the running-jumping-sliding mechanics they expect, <em>Firewatch</em> questions the speed the rest of our life runs at. Rarely in our daily lives are we forced to slow down. When made to do this in the context of a game, many people’s first instinct is to think of it as a waste of time, hence the derisive tone of “walking simulator.” But to think of the world in <em>Firewatch’s</em> terms is not to see wastes of time, but rather to see something that is beautiful because of the time it demands. Its slow, deliberate pace is inseparable from the emotions it elicits. In being forced to experience the world slowly, you are forced to experience the world differently, to rethink the very speed we operate at. <em>Firewatch’s</em> construction of time is a challenge both to other games and to our daily lives, a challenge to slow down.</p><p><strong>Day 3<br></strong>The crackle of leaves under your feet, the stars bright above you. Somewhere to your right is a canyon, its dark abyss yawning at the corners of your thoughts. The crickets chirp, invisible in the grasses brushing against your legs.</p><p>While actively playing <em>Firewatch</em>, the game time passes in perfect 1:1 time with the real world. While many games allow you to skip ahead in one way or another or hold you back with loading screens, the experience of playing <em>Firewatch</em> is a seamless melding of real-time and game-time, or to use the words of Juul, “play time” and “event time” (Juul 2). Play time is the experience of time that the player has: the 15 minutes on the train that they play Candy Crush, the 4 hours straight they play Baldur’s Gate 3. It is experienced linearly at a constant rate, one moment moving to the next, moving to the next. Event time, on the other hand, is the time passing within the game world. This can mean any number of things, from years passing in minutes in games like The Sims or OpenTTD, to the event time matching play time in fast-paced action games like DOOM (Juul 3). The event time always maps onto play time somehow, but almost never perfectly. As mentioned before, skipping things through cutscenes or fast travel jumps the event time ahead, literally skipping a period of in-game time. On the other hand, loading screens or pause menus freeze the event time in place, dragging it behind play time. The simulated world cannot run exactly the way the real world does.</p><p>The world of <em>Firewatch</em>, however, gets close. While playing the game, there are no ways to skip ahead. The aforementioned slow and deliberate pace of the game necessitates actually walking everywhere, no fast travel allowed. The player feels, and waits through, every step the character takes. The speed of conversations also matches real-life: you’re forced to wait to respond until the voice line is finished, both you and Delilah taking turns talking. There is no button-mashing through this. Again, you are forced to wait with the character, to experience the world in something as close to real-time as possible.</p><p>Until the game purposefully breaks this illusion wide open.</p><p><strong>Day 9<br></strong>The sunrise looks different today, the clouds making it hazy and indistinct. The breeze is not yet hot. You shoulder your pack and set out on the trail, the pebbles crunching underfoot, the promise of another beautiful day ahead.</p><p><em>Firewatch</em> is divided into days. You’ll be walking around, and the conversation will peter out, leaving you in silence. The end of a scene. There are a few seconds to look at the trees, the sunset, the path in front of you, before the game abruptly cuts to a title card: yellow text on a black background, a day and a number. The jumps start off small, lulling the player into thinking this is a game played day by day: “Day 1,” “Day 2,” “Day 3.” The illusion of event time matching play time is broken, but not shattered. You are still experiencing the summer with this character, the everyday conversations and chores. The jumps between days are to be expected: you’re not going to wait eight hours while the character sleeps. You can explain it as nothing more than a convenient game mechanic, one of the few times the game concedes to speeding up. The player could be lulled into believing this is how the game is, the slow passage of a summer, experienced through a 15-minute chunk of each day.</p><p>Then, abruptly: “Day 9.” You have skipped over nearly a week, a week of exploration and conversation and little moments that you have irreversibly missed. The player is suddenly not living with the character, but restricted to specific scenes of this summer, locked out of everything else. Your character has been living without you; who knows what happened in the preceding week? Who knows what will happen between future jumps, as they get longer and longer? “Day 33,” “Day 64.” The relationship between play time and event time, so solid at the start of the game, feels gone. These vast jumps are difficult to bridge, impossible to rewind. The languid pace of the game is still present during gameplay, but always suddenly interrupted by the skipping of days, weeks. Play time and event time irreversibly separate, and along with them the player and character.</p><p><strong>Day 33<br></strong>The sun is high in the sky, the lake quiet before you as it bounces the light into your eyes. The shade under the tree is cool on your neck, the breeze rustling its branches. Each sound blends into the next as they roll across the lake in waves. You wonder if the fish hear the wind.</p><p>Before you know it, the summer in Shoshone — the long three months you’ve signed up for, the escape you’ve been promised — is slipping through your fingers. Weeks pass between gameplay scenes, time jumping ahead faster than you can adjust. The end of the summer is far away but suddenly feels so close, when each jump ahead in time could be your last. The threat of returning to your life — both for the character and the player — looms in the distance, every skip reminding you just how close it is.</p><p>Even as the gameplay remains slow and deliberate in the present, when skipping ahead it feels less like you’re living it and more like you’re remembering it, poorly. It’s as if the bits and pieces you recall of the summer have been scattered across time, everything in-between lost to the recesses of your mind. Three weeks pass in a heartbeat; did anything worth remembering even happen?</p><p>Where did the time go?</p><p><strong>Day 64<br> </strong>The flash of orange that signals sunset, the world in a state of flux. The stream runs over your shoes, getting your socks wet. The lingering heat of the day will dry them soon. Your dripping footprints on the rocks shrivel and disappear into nothing.</p><p>Even as the summer slips by, <em>Firewatch</em> still feels more present, more immediate, than most games I’ve played. <em>Firewatch’s</em> unique insistence on matching play time and event time, aside from the jumps ahead, creates a sense of immediacy that is undeniable.</p><p>Hanson posits that a feeling of “live-ness,” the feeling of a game world happening in real-time, is created by insisting, directly and repeatedly, on the player’s involvement (Hanson 24). This is most commonly achieved through the simple loop of asking a player to do something, then providing immediate feedback when they press buttons to accomplish it. However, this is only the most basic example. <em>Firewatch</em>, through its dialogue system, takes this feeling of live-ness to the next level by emphasizing both aspects of live-ness: copresence and immediacy.</p><p>“Copresence suggests that the event… shares the same spatial and temporal framework as the viewer or player” (Hanson 22). It convinces the player the people and events in the game are happening <em>now</em>. <em>Firewatch</em> is fully voiced, and as mentioned before, you have to wait for dialogue lines to finish. There’s no button to skip through a conversation, hearing the first word of each sentence cut off in a strange amalgamation of syllables as you speed through it. Neither is there much point to skipping through: the conversations happen as you walk around, and skipping them would just leave the rest of the walk in silence. They are tied to the time it takes to walk, timed out so they fill the space naturally, a background chatter as you navigate the trails.</p><p>The inability to skip through Delilah’s dialogue shifts her from an NPC to a person, making it feel like she’s coming up with things to say on the spot, that you can’t guess a predetermined outcome to the conversation. In this way, her fully voiced, unskippable dialogue creates a similar illusion as live theatre, the illusion that you are listening to someone naturally converse in real time. This copresence makes the audience feel as though they are sharing a space and time with the show or game, and connects the audience to these seemingly “live” events (Hanson 20).</p><p>However, <em>Firewatch’s</em> dialogue system also emphasizes immediacy by timing the player’s responses to questions. You hold down the “talk” button on the radio, and a small bar next to your dialogue options slowly empties. If it runs out, the conversation will end, your character not having picked something to say soon enough. There is no way to stop, to freeze the dialogue for several minutes while you choose what to say, run the responses again and again in your head or research online. Much like a real conversation, if you wait too long, it dies. You must choose with limited information, and sometimes while playing I found myself struggling for words the same way I do in real conversations, grasping at disconnected ideas of what I <em>could</em> say, with no idea of what I <em>should</em> say. More than many other dialogue systems, <em>Firewatch’s</em> forced me to have a conversation, with all the mistakes that come with it. Between the unskippable dialogue and the timer system, conversations in <em>Firewatch</em> are forced to happen in real time, a perfect match of play time and event time, copresence and immediacy. They are forced to happen live.</p><p><strong>Day 76<br></strong>Another bright summer day, the same as the last and the same as the next. The sun, the trees, the lake, the trails. They blend into one another in your memories, days blurring, weeks overlapping. But for now, they are here.</p><p><em>Firewatch’s</em> construction of time is both painfully languid and blazingly fast. During the moment-to-moment gameplay, the game has a perfect match of play time and event time. Walking, interacting with the environment, talking to other characters — everything takes just as long as it would in real life. This is emphasized by the dialogue system, which through voice acting and timers is forced to play out in real-time, making the world feel live, as if it’s happening <em>now</em>. This slow, deliberate pace is on purpose: <em>Firewatch</em> is designed to be a walking simulator, designed to force us to rethink our experience of time. The game is narratively and mechanically an escape from fast-moving modern life, a retreat to the forest where the only thing you are expected to do is wander. In a world of fast-paced games, <em>Firewatch’s</em> slow play is a breath of fresh air, a queer reimagining of time, forcing the player to slow down.</p><p>However, even as <em>Firewatch</em> slows to a crawl, the game’s insistence on numbering days and skipping through large portions of the summer constantly reminds the player that this will come to an end: that the character will have to return home and leave the forest behind. As will the player, who will have to turn of the game and return to school, work, their normal life. The slow pace cannot last forever. The world will speed up again.</p><p>But for now, it is slowed, and maybe that is enough.</p><p>Works Cited</p><p><em>Firewatch</em>. Campo Santo / Panic. 2016.</p><p>Hanson, Christopher. “More Than Live: Game <em>A-Liveness </em>and Immediacy.” <em>Game Time: Understanding Temporality in Video Games</em>, Indiana University Press, 2018.</p><p>Juul, Jesper. “Introduction to Game Time.” <em>First Person: New Meida as Story, Performance, and Game</em>, edited by Noah Wardrip-Fruin and Pat Harrigan, MIT Press, 2004.</p><p>Ruberg, Bonnie. “Speed Runs, Slow Strolls, and the Politics of Walking: Queer Movements Through Space and Time.” <em>Video Games Have Always Been Queer</em>, NYU Press, 2019.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e89fb19d74c2" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Inescapable Gravity of Resident Evil 4: Growing Up With A Game I’ll Never Play]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@roryhoeschen/the-inescapable-gravity-of-resident-evil-4-growing-up-with-a-game-ill-never-play-9157305eb539?source=rss-e38a8f15a9ac------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9157305eb539</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[growing-up]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[retrospectives]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[gaming]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[resident-evil-4]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Rory Hoeschen]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 28 May 2024 22:49:00 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-05-28T23:02:06.826Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>A version of this piece was published in Northwestern’s </em><a href="https://www.sceneandheardnu.com/content/resident-evil-4">Scene + Heard</a><em> magazine.</em></p><p>In the weeks leading up to my birth, a group of developers, proud as any mother, are putting the final touches on <em>Resident Evil 4.</em> The control inputs are being smoothed out, the slightly-pixelated textures implemented, Leon’s iconic catchphrases woven into the cutscenes. In a process as intricate as anything we know, lines of inscrutable code resolve into bleak villages, foreboding castles, chainsaw-wielding maniacs, tentacle-headed zombies. Guns blazing, Leon S. Kennedy swoops into a remote Spanish village and saves the president’s daughter from polygonal monsters, time and time and time again, each repetition becoming a little more polished, a little more <em>real</em>, until the final release date: January 11th, 2005.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*tzj2OSI7jCyjBuw5" /></figure><p>(“Final” release date.)</p><p>I am born a short time later. Struggling to achieve consciousness and personhood, I have no idea of the waves <em>Resident Evil 4</em> immediately creates in the gaming landscape, waves we can still feel nineteen years later. To oversimplify it; every game that uses a camera over the character’s shoulder (especially shooters) owes it to <em>Resident Evil 4</em>: <em>The Last of Us, Breath of the Wild, Elden Ring, Metal Gear Rising, Fortnite, Red Dead Redemption 2, Max Payne</em>… I could list them for hours. While earlier games in the <em>Resident Evil</em> franchise used fixed cameras, picking a specific corner of each room to view your character from, <em>Resident Evil 4</em> had the first true third-person over-the-shoulder perspective, the camera looking down the sights of Leon&#39;s pistol right along with him. It worked so well that it became the standard for the next two decades, unchallenged to this day. The camera in, <em>conservatively</em>, a third of the most popular games today was directly inspired by <em>Resident Evil 4, </em>and that’s without even mentioning all the <a href="https://venturebeat.com/games/10-years-later-resident-evil-4-is-still-influences-the-industry/">other</a> <a href="https://screenrant.com/resident-evil-4-best-video-games-inspired/">influences</a> <a href="https://www.gameinformer.com/b/features/archive/2017/01/22/12-years-later-and-resident-evil-4-remains-the-best-third-person-shooter-ever.aspx">it</a> <a href="https://www.gamespew.com/2023/03/how-resident-evil-4-changed-the-modern-gaming-landscape/">had</a>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*NoW1TEJhoCg6u6XP.jpg" /><figcaption>RE4&#39;s over-the-shoulder camera perspective.</figcaption></figure><p>Game reviewers in 2005 pick up on this right away, extolling the virtues of the unique camera system and reassuring players that this strange new system is still easy to control (<a href="https://www.gamespot.com/reviews/resident-evil-4-review/1900-6115968/">Gamespot</a>). Elsewhere, game developers take notes that will directly lead to <em>Uncharted, Dead Space, God of War</em>, and countless others (<a href="https://screenrant.com/resident-evil-4-best-video-games-inspired/">ScreenRant</a>). Somewhere in North Carolina, the video essayist who will eventually introduce me to the game begs his parents to buy it, arguing that now that he’s had his Bar Mitzvah, he should be allowed to play adult-rated games. The events that will lead to me playing <em>Resident Evil 4</em> are already being set in motion, the waves it made already on their way to hit me.</p><p>I can’t say I’m having as outsized of an impact on the world quite yet. Heck, mostly I’m just sleeping. Let’s jump ahead a bit.</p><p><a href="https://gamerant.com/resident-evil-4-remake-vr-hd-ports-re-releases-remasters/">October 2005</a>. <em>Resident Evil 4</em> is ported to the Playstation 2. It includes extra functionalities and downloadable expansions. According to the <a href="https://www.cdc.gov/ncbddd/actearly/milestones/milestones-2yr.html">CDC</a>, I can probably make sounds other than crying, which is an extra functionality of some sort.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*wIU2s_OPMJ1ABzfm.jpg" /><figcaption>The PS2 version of the game.</figcaption></figure><p>May 2007. <em>Resident Evil 4</em> is ported to the PC. My mother has been teaching me sign language and I now communicate frequently and insistently, not relenting until I get exactly what I want. Seventeen years later, I can barely remember any of it other than scattered signs for “cookie,” “more,” and “all done.” My mom and I still use it as an inside joke sometimes, but it doesn’t translate as well now that I’m in college, talking to her over the phone instead of face-to-face.</p><p>June 2007. <em>Resident Evil 4</em> is ported to the Wii, with added motion control aiming. Leon now whips his gun around as fast as you can throw your Wii remote at the TV. Keep your wrist strap on. I am currently learning to run.</p><p>July 2009. <em>Resident Evil 4</em> mobile edition releases on iOS. I have known how to read for about half a year now, which is terrible news for everyone who wanted me to be “normal” and “not a nerd.” One of my friends took a finger swipe out of the frosting on my last birthday cake and I will never forgive her.</p><p>September 2011. <em>Resident Evil 4 HD</em> launches on PS3 and Xbox 360, the first big graphical update to the game. Textures across the board are higher-resolution: the blood on the chainsaw is a bit more realistic, the stones in the castle have a bit more definition, the blasts from the gun are a little bit brighter. My little sister has been born for nearly half a year.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*VfAv4mMZ80-WBtLQ.jpg" /><figcaption>Resident Evil 4 HD.</figcaption></figure><p>April 2013. <em>Resident Evil 4</em> finally releases on Android. I am wrapping up 4th grade. My teacher gives me a spider plant to take home as a way to remember the year. I am sad to change classrooms, but mostly just excited for the summer.</p><p>February 2014. <em>Resident Evil 4 Ultimate HD Edition</em> releases on PC. A simple port of the HD version, nothing noteworthy. I’ve forgotten my spider plant outside over the winter, and the feet of snow we get smother it in ice.</p><p>February 2014. Someone named Cris makes a post on an obscure website titled “<a href="https://www.re4hd.com/?m=201402">Finally Gonna Do It</a>.” Unsatisfied with the current HD edition, Cris announces he’s going to make an HD mod for <em>Resident Evil 4</em>. He has little experience. The project will continue for the next nine years and accumulate over ten thousand hours of work, becoming one of the most detailed and time-consuming love letters to a game ever created. My mom finds my spider plant outside and nurses it back to health. Eleven years later, it sits in my college dorm, overflowing its pot as it reaches toward the sun.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*VP-2kbom_4gCtTE7.jpg" /><figcaption>Cris’ HD mod, in comparison to the original 2005 game.</figcaption></figure><p>August 2016. <em>Resident Evil 4</em> releases on Playstation 4 and Xbox One. Despite getting rid of the “HD” title, this is essentially the same game that released in 2011. A timeless classic. Cris (and now Albert) are continuing to work on their HD mod, updating room after room, texture after texture. I am about to start middle school and I’m scared of the change. I don’t feel like an “adolescent.” I’m pretty sure I’m still a kid.</p><p>May 2019. <em>Resident Evil 4</em> releases on the Nintendo Switch: a true mobile version is available for the first time. Theoretically I could buy this version on my shiny new Switch, but I have not yet tired of the cartoony Nintendo games it came with. Middle school is in the past now, high school looming in my future. This will be my first time at a new school, but at least my friends are coming with me. I’m sure we’ll stick together. Albert continues to update the HD mod. Cris has not posted for months.</p><p>October 2021. <em>Resident Evil 4 VR</em> releases on the Oculus Quest 2, a complete reimagining of the game in virtual reality. It abandons the iconic, game-changing, third-person perspective to put you into Leon’s head, the enemies’ bullets fired directly at your skull. I hope you know the steps to loading a shotgun. Covid has come (hitting a week before my birthday) and gone (the restrictions lifting just before my junior year of high school). Everything seems just a little bit off now. My english teacher introduces me to a video essayist named Jacob Geller. He made a <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7uJuTKyM4rQ">video</a> on the Resident Evil 4 HD Mod a year ago, and I will discover it soon, my first real introduction to this game I have unknowingly grown up alongside, told through the lens of art restoration. It is breathtaking.</p><p>March 2023. The <em>Resident Evil 4 Remake</em> releases for PC, PS5, and Xbox Series X only a couple of days before my birthday. It is nothing short of spectacular, a faithful recreation of the nineteen-year-old original, new graphics and updated controls drawing it into a new decade. Version 1.0 of the Resident Evil 4 HD Mod has been out for nearly a year now, beautiful in a different way than <em>Remake</em>, a labor of love seen to high-definition completion. Now in my senior year of high school, I have read and watched countless essays on <em>Resident Evil 4</em>. I’ve developed an interest in doing my own writing on games, and in a few short months I’ll start publishing my work. For now I watch other people do it, amazed by the stories they can weave with words, captivated by the beautiful rhythm of the games behind them. I recently got an Xbox to play <em>Microsoft Flight Simulator</em>, and it seems as if the gates have been sprung wide open, the world at my feet, any game at my fingertips. <em>Resident Evil 4</em> is at the top of my list.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*Dys-naVF744F1-ua.jpg" /><figcaption>The 2023 release of Resident Evil 4</figcaption></figure><p>May 2023. No <em>Resident Evil 4</em> release — I have no time for video games in the depths of IB exam hell. I am struggling through 4 hour tests while cherishing some of the last moments I’ll have with my friends. College looms around the corner, immense, unknowable, and terrifying. Saying goodbye to my english teacher is especially hard.</p><p>August 2023. A summer that is both long and short, filled with vacations and camps and desperate hang-outs with friends before they leave for college. My college starts later than everyone else’s, and I am left staring at the blank TV, the hectic Mariokart rounds and wild Smash Bros tournaments serving to simply point out the depressing absence of my friends. I glance at my Xbox, then convince my mom to take me with her on her next Target run. I know exactly what I am going to buy.</p><p>Running my hands over the <em>Resident Evil 4 Remake</em> case, it doesn’t feel quite real. This is a game steeped in history, a history I can barely comprehend. I think of the videos I’ve watched, the articles I’ve read, each trying to convey how amazing, breathtaking, mindblowing this game was in 2005. Today, it’s just another third-person shooter. It so definitively created the genre that it is still a shining example of it, a timeless classic, only the landscape around it changing to match. I have never been alive for a game that was not influenced by this one. In fact, I’ve never been alive for a world untouched by <em>Resident Evil 4</em>. It has simply been a fact of life for my entire existence, casting a long shadow whether I was aware of it or not. There is no way of truly knowing all the ways it affected my life, or the lives of the people who affected me, or the lives of the people who affected them. All I know is that it did.</p><p>I insert the disc carefully into my Xbox, adjusting the brightness lower (but not as low as they suggest) to make the darkened hallways all the scarier. The opening cutscene plays, one I’ve seen a thousand times before but never experienced (will never experience). I slowly start moving Leon through the forest, the setting familiar and new all at once. Playing this game feels inevitable, like something I’ve been meant to do for a long time.</p><p>When I make it to the village, I barricade myself in the house to hide from the bloody-masked chainsaw man. Trapped with no way out, I triumphantly spot the shotgun and turn around to blast the enemies to kingdom come, blood and guts splattering the screen. Overlaid on my own playthrough is the knowledge that Jacob Geller had this exact experience, has described this exact triumphant shotgun blast. I see a flash of every other player doing this, thousands upon thousands of them, fingers mashing the “fire” button since before I was born. I am playing this game through the hands of others, my own experiences never quite separate from the secondhand history I’ve built up in my head.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*W_dd-0t1ym9jCSLzWYxkGg.png" /><figcaption>A shotgun blast from 2005 and one from 2023.</figcaption></figure><p>I will never understand what <em>Resident Evil 4</em> was like to play in 2005, and in this way, I will never truly play the game. I can only play the game that <em>Resident Evil 4</em> has become, filtered through everyone and everything that has come before me, the context around it growing and changing while it stays essentially the same. A timeless classic so far removed from its origins that its original form is nothing more than a blurry memory, a time and place I can never inhabit.</p><p>I have changed immeasurably since the release of <em>Resident Evil 4</em>. Nineteen years of life have made me (definitely) taller and (debatably) wiser. A college transfer lies ahead of me now, somehow not as scary as the rest of my school changes. Maybe it&#39;s because I have some constants in my life now. <em>Resident Evil 4</em>, for all its releases, has changed very little. From 2005 all the way to 2023, it maintains the same rhythm, the same satisfying <em>shoot, kick, run</em> loop that works so beautifully. When I return to the game, as I often do now, I know exactly what to expect. It feels like an old friend I’ve known for forever, far longer than the year ago I started playing it. In a way, it has been with me this whole time. Guns blazing, Leon S. Kennedy swoops into a remote Spanish village and saves the president’s daughter from polygonal monsters, time and time and time again. I do not know where his journey started or where it will end, but I’m happy to join him for a while, me and all the other people still playing this masterpiece of a game.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*cLxim2xxDx5nHxOu.jpg" /><figcaption>The most recent release of Resident Evil 4.</figcaption></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9157305eb539" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Hypnotizing Simplicity of Hollow Knight’s Combat]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@roryhoeschen/the-hypnotizing-simplicity-of-hollow-knights-combat-a60f820fd433?source=rss-e38a8f15a9ac------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a60f820fd433</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[gaming]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[hollow-knight]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[boss-fight]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[game-analysis]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Rory Hoeschen]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 11 Apr 2024 00:02:00 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-11-08T13:22:45.382Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="The False Knight boss fight from Hollow Knight. The False Knight is a large armored bug, swinging a hammer at the player. Glowing rocks fall from above." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*MtLRck7UuzvvMuO4" /></figure><p><em>A version of this essay was published in Northwestern’s </em><a href="https://www.sceneandheardnu.com/content/2024/5/1/the-hypnotizing-simplicity-of-hollow-knight-mark-ii"><em>Scene+Heard</em></a><em> magazine.<br>This piece has been turned into a </em><a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XtR7LZ7QjTU"><em>video essay</em></a><em>.</em></p><p><em>This essay includes spoilers for Hollow Knight bosses.</em></p><p>Four hours into fighting a <em>Hollow Knight</em> boss, you may struggle to agree that this is a “simple” game in any sense of the word. <em>Hollow Knight</em> demands mastery of its systems; there is no button-mashing your way through the enemies, no moves you can spam over and over again to win, no bosses you can expect to beat on your first try. It’s a brutally hard game, and is not afraid to punish you for your mistakes.</p><p>How, then, could anything like this be “simple?”</p><p><em>Hollow Knight’s</em> combat feels infinitely complex, but the truth is that each battle can be broken down into a few simple interlocking systems centered around the moveset of your character, the Knight. The core of the Knight’s moveset relies on their melee attack: a sword called the “nail” that quickly slashes and does a decent bit of damage. You have the nail from the very beginning of the game, and will have it until the very end. There are no other weapons. No greatsword, no spear, no dual-wielded throwing knives: just you and the nail. It has upgrades, of course, but nothing special. You cannot forge it to shoot beams of light or set enemies ablaze. It simply does more damage. It never becomes more complex than this.</p><p>Described in this way, the nail seems boring, like a placeholder that never quite got fleshed out. But while playing the game, the nail’s simplicity allows it to become an extension of yourself — an action so natural you never have to think about it — while still holding some unique intricacies of its own. For example, the nail knocks back both enemies and yourself. It’s only logical, then, that slashing down upon an enemy would send the Knight into the air, allowing you to reach new places and avoid attacks while doing damage. It’s a beautiful continuation of the system that’s been established and a higher-level strategy necessary to truly master the game. However, where the nail really shines is how well it fits within the other systems of <em>Hollow Knight</em>. The nail provides the solid foundation that the rest of the game stands on, the point of reference everything else plays off of. To truly understand this interplay, we must talk about soul.</p><figure><img alt="The player in Hollow Knight uses the Howling Wraiths spell, creating a blast of white energy directly above them." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*lpHAm7d4-xrjy6nf" /><figcaption>The Howling Wraiths spell from Hollow Knight.</figcaption></figure><p>Like many games, there are two numbers you must watch while playing <em>Hollow Knight</em>: your health, and your soul. Soul is <em>Hollow Knight’s</em> version of “magic points“ or “mana,” letting you heal yourself and cast damaging spells. There are many ways games approach mana recovery. Some let it accumulate over time, forcing you to take a break to recover. Others treat mana as an object to be picked up, either dropped by enemies or found within the world. Still others, such as <em>Terraria</em>, combine these systems, creating complex mid-combat scenarios with multiple ways to gain mana. An additional complexity is that, in many games, different spells cost different amounts of mana; spells in <em>Skyrim</em> cost anywhere from 0 to 1426 “magicka”, making it nigh impossible to keep track of each spell and its cost. <em>Hollow Knight</em> streamlines all of this to the point where you could easily do the calculations in your head. Every time you hit an enemy with the nail, you gain exactly 11 soul. Casting spells or healing takes exactly 33, and you can hold exactly 99. That’s the whole system. That’s it.</p><p>The beauty of the soul system comes in how it plays off of the nail. The two systems are inseparable from each other, forcing you to blend multiple styles of fighting into one. Yes, you can cast a spell that will do massive amounts of damage, but that keeps you from healing. You can heal, but only if you have time to do it in between enemy attacks. And if you want to do either of those things, you have to go on the offensive first, hitting the enemies with your nail to gain soul. The game never devolves into purely nail or soul strategies because each inherently informs the other, creating a moveset where each move feels equally important.</p><p>By focusing on the nail and soul, <em>Hollow Knight</em> also keeps the player’s moveset simple. There are no attacks or specific button combos that the player will forget to use, nothing that doesn’t fit the parameters already laid out by the game. This lets you learn your entire moveset intimately, and the game trusts you to understand it; it constantly throws greater and greater challenges at you, always pushing you closer to the edge of your abilities. The challenge of <em>Hollow Knight</em> comes not from obscure combos or incomprehensible number crunching: the challenge comes from the game pushing your mastery of a simple system to the absolute breaking point.</p><p>The simplicity of the Knight’s moveset also makes it easy for the player to understand the consequences of each of their actions. You can see exactly when you’re 11 soul short of being able to heal, and you know it’s precisely because of the third hit you missed thirty seconds ago when you dashed the wrong way and were half a second late reacting to the boss. And you can have this entire train of thought in the middle of combat because the underlying systems are so understandable. By being comprehensible, the combat of <em>Hollow Knight</em> inherently lends itself to self-improvement: it’s easy to analyze your playstyle and understand where you can improve. This also requires that you trust the outcome of any fight is — nearly <em>always</em> — entirely skill based. If you’re relying on outside factors — such as XP, upgrades, etc — to get through a boss fight, you aren’t focused on your own performance and how you can improve. By simplifying the combat system to do away with these outside factors entirely, <em>Hollow Knight</em> puts all the focus on your skill. This is the whole system, and you already understand it. There’s nothing intermediary or extraneous between you and the boss. Now beat it.</p><figure><img alt="The Hollow Knight boss from Hollow Knight, suspended in chains over the player." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*9nqhjBo-R_tRHLri" /><figcaption>The Hollow Knight boss fight… from Hollow Knight.</figcaption></figure><p>This simplicity in the player’s combat system is in sharp contrast to a game often compared to <em>Hollow Knight</em>: <em>Ori and the Will of the Wisps</em>. <em>Ori</em> is, on its surface, similar to <em>Hollow Knight</em> in many ways. They’re both 2D “metroidvanias:” games that rely on complex maps and interesting character upgrades, including both platforming and combat elements. However, I knew something was different about <em>Ori</em> the moment the battles started. <em>Ori</em> also includes a quick sword attack, but this is not something fundamental the rest of the game is built around: it’s simply one in a long line of different attacks the player can use. On my save file, I currently have access to a flaming arrow, a thrown spear, an enormous hammer, a throwing star, a damaging aura, an explosion, a burst of flame, and a gust of wind. And I’m only halfway through the game! On one hand, this range of options can be really fun. Mixing and matching different abilities lets players find a playstyle that works for them, and leads to different encounters with every enemy. On the other hand, it creates a web of interlocking systems so complex that I cannot fully comprehend it. Nowhere is this overcomplexity more obvious than with <em>Ori’s</em> healing system. Just like <em>Hollow Knight</em>, <em>Ori</em> uses a magic system both for healing and for certain attacks. However, healing is not its own separate ability: it’s just thrown in with all the other attacks. Now, instead of a clear choice mid-battle on whether to heal or cast a spell, you’re choosing between healing and shooting an arrow and using a heavy attack and throwing a spear and causing an explosion. By adding so many options, <em>Ori</em> deemphasizes a core part of the game and makes that decision almost too complex to become interesting mid-combat. Left with a split-second to make a decision, you end up just using whatever’s easiest, not considering the rest of your moveset. This means fundamental actions, like the healing mechanic, get easily forgotten. This is both frustrating for the player, who doesn’t feel like they are fully utilizing their moveset, and for the game designer, who cannot trust that the player is using the mechanics at their disposal. Boss fights have to be that much simpler because the designers do not know how the player is approaching the battle, so they cannot precisely know and push the limits of the player’s skill.</p><p><em>Ori’s</em> complexity also makes it more difficult to improve. When looking back at a death in <em>Ori</em>, it’s hard to untangle which actions you should’ve taken because there were just so many options. With <em>Hollow Knight</em>, the systems are so understandable that the player can immediately tell what went wrong: the challenge lies in executing the change in the middle of combat. When I take damage in <em>Ori</em>, I don’t know if that was because of a genuine slip-up on my part, or if I fundamentally don’t understand something about my moveset. When trying a boss fight again and again, instead of more deeply understanding it with each fight, slowly learning the precise timings and movesets, I just throw a different weapon at it to see if it works. Without being able to truly understand the combat systems of <em>Ori</em>, there’s a disconnect between the choices you make and the outcomes you get, the exact process muddled by the complexity of the systems in between. I cannot trust that the fights are based on my skill. While <em>Hollow Knight</em> takes a few very simple systems and forces you to master their interplay, <em>Ori</em> instead throws everything at you at once and expects you to figure out what works. There are just too many variables. In this way, <em>Ori’s</em> more complex systems actually simplify the combat, deemphasizing mid-fight skill and strategy in favor of just trying different combinations to see what works. You never know if a failure is your fault or the game’s fault; you can’t truly improve.</p><figure><img alt="A giant black spider with green eyes towers over the player character, who is swiping a glowing sword at the boss." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*RlUsWfmlsDmpMiUb0YkUKw.png" /><figcaption>The Mora boss fight from Ori and the Will of the Wisps</figcaption></figure><p>This problem — where too much choice obscures the consequences of your actions — is only made larger by a game like <em>Elden Ring</em>. <em>Elden Ring</em> is an enormous open-world RPG that relies on character customization to drive your character’s growth. As you kill monsters, you gain XP to level up each of your skills, allowing you to choose which you want to excel at: Strength? Intelligence? Dexterity? The world of character customization is at your fingertips. While this system can be a fun way to make your character unique, it leads to many of the same problems as with <em>Ori,</em> but on an even larger scale: I cannot trust that the battles are skill-based. When fighting a boss, I never know whether I can beat it by carefully learning its attack patterns or whether I should just leave for a few hours and grind XP — and it’s often very unclear what the game wants you to do! An easy boss I can beat first try will sit right next to a boss I could never beat with my current loadout. The game often points the player towards bosses they cannot beat yet, expecting them to just realize the futility of their efforts. This means the best strategy when losing becomes to leave and go grind XP for several hours. You are incentivized to give up when you fail: the optimal choice is to go do something else. This doesn’t mean that skill isn’t involved with <em>Elden Ring</em> — far from it. However, the overly complex systems of <em>Elden Ring</em> make it difficult to tell exactly what comes down to skill and what comes down to stats, creating an incentive to control what you can: the exact numbers of your strength and health scores. This even swings the other way for me: I’m constantly worried I leveled up “too much” and turned what would have been a fun and engaging boss fight into a thirty-second slugfest. When I beat a boss in <em>Elden Ring</em>, it feels less impactful because I know I made it easier by leveling up that extra time. Rather than the bosses of <em>Elden Ring</em> feeling like a test of skill, they feel more like a test of stats.</p><p>People who have played <em>Hollow Knight</em> can, at this point, see the very obvious hole in my entire argument. <em>Hollow Knight</em> does have a complex customization system! Found scattered around the world, equipable charms will give you extra abilities: everything from another bit of health to summoning minions that follow you around. One could argue that these charms are functionally similar to <em>Ori’s</em> weapon system or even <em>Elden Ring’s</em> levels: they encourage swapping builds around or leaving the fight and coming back with a specific upgrade, rather than purely learning the boss. I counter with the fact that every effect of these charms is fully understandable. While complicating the combat, it is still simple to understand how exactly the charms impacted each fight. A charm might make your healing speed faster, or make the Knight sprout damaging thorns, or even just show your location on the map. Rather than how many other games handle equipable items, with seemingly arbitrary stat increases and random percentages (+2% attack speed, +4% knockback, +3% poison resistance), the effect of <em>Hollow Knight’s</em> charms on gameplay are immediately understandable. There is one charm that increases knockback. If you want increased knockback, you use that charm. No need to mix and match different equipment with different variables and effects and percentages to try to get the highest numbers. <em>Hollow Knight’s</em> charms also never change the core gameplay loop: they don’t give you a new weapon or a triple jump or anything like that. The charms only build upon the foundations that have already been established, and never break these norms. This means, no matter your loadout, you are still playing the game with the same fundamental rhythm. Out of these three games I’ve discussed, <em>Hollow Knight</em> is still, by a vast margin, the game with the least combat customizability. <em>Hollow Knight</em> has the purest sense of it being just you and the boss.</p><p>Outside of the player’s own skillset, <em>Elden Ring</em> and <em>Hollow Knight</em> also add complexity to their combat through these bosses. Good bosses can make or break a game, and my main problem with the bosses in <em>Elden Ring</em> is how unreadable they feel. “Reading” a video game boss means being able to recognize which attack they are about to perform by their attack cues. Things like drawing a bow, raising a knife, or jumping in the air can all communicate to the player which attack the boss is about to perform, giving them half a second to react. Readability is essential to a satisfying boss fight, and crucial to games like <em>Hollow Knight</em> and <em>Elden Ring,</em> which expect the player to fight bosses many times to truly master their moveset. While you may not be quick enough to recognize the boss’ attacks during the first fight, by the tenth you understand, and by the thirtieth you’ve turned the fight into more of a dance, immediately and instinctively reacting to what the boss is about to do. Of course, the challenge is not about simple recognition, but being able to react to the boss in time. This slow journey to mastery is part of what I love about <em>Hollow Knight</em>, as bosses slowly turn from incomprehensible killing machines into beautifully predictable blades.</p><figure><img alt="Margit, a tall humanoid with a long staff and tattered robes, circles the player character warily." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*syp-Gh37BgUMuNOl.jpg" /><figcaption>The Margit boss fight from Elden Ring.</figcaption></figure><p>I realized readability was my fundamental problem with <em>Elden Ring</em> after many hours of banging my head against the wall that <em>Elden Ring</em> refers to as “Margit, the Fell Omen.” Margit is one of the first important bosses in the game — perhaps <em>the</em> first important boss — and serves as a gateway to the rest of the world. I was excited for my first real <em>Elden Ring</em> boss: everyone compares <em>Hollow Knight</em> to the <em>Dark Souls</em> series, and any bosses even <em>similar</em> to <em>Hollow Knight’s</em> were sure to be right up my alley. Little did I realize at that point that <em>Elden Ring</em> takes away the simplicity and readability that made me fall in love with <em>Hollow Knight’s</em> combat in the first place. Margit has something like sixteen different attacks, most of which were very hard for me to tell apart. The attack cues frequently relied on subtle differences, such as him holding the sword at a slightly different angle, which were incredibly hard to notice in the heat of battle. The realism of <em>Elden Ring</em> worked against the boss design, constraining him to realistic and repetitive movements. The visual fidelity made the detailed textures blend into one another, and of course wrestling with the camera system made it even more difficult to recognize attacks with any sort of consistency. The same attack could be viewed from any angle, and would sometimes be obscured entirely, not to mention when the boss was simply not on screen. The sheer number of attacks also made it difficult for me to get a handle on them, and to make thing more complicated, Margit often chained together attacks in what felt like entirely unpredictable ways. I was frequently punished for correctly recognizing an opening and running in, only for him to suddenly pull out a dagger and cut me in half. His attacks would flow into each other with no cue between them, or he would switch up an attack halfway through, catching me entirely off guard. This unpredictability is clearly a feature of the game, but its a feature I didn’t expect to dislike so much. It made it impossible for me to find the rhythm with Margit, and made any hits I did get off feel more luck-based than skill-based. Without being able to read and predict the boss, I could never move past that first stage of learning the boss. It led to an unsatisfying fight where the struggle was not executing on the things I’d learned or honing my skill, but rather squinting at the screen and yelling at the controller in confusion whenever he performed an attack I wasn’t expecting in the slightest. I couldn’t properly react, and the fight wasn’t satisfying. I wasn’t having fun.</p><p>In contrast, the readability of <em>Hollow Knight’s</em> bosses is so fundamental to the combat that it is built into the very way the game looks. <em>Hollow Knight</em> is a beautiful game, with a cartoony 2D art style which manages to emphasize boss moves and keeps the focus on your reactions rather than your recognition, leading to a more satisfying fight. By being cartoonish, the bosses are inherently simplified, which already makes them easier to read in the thick of battle — strong lines divide each boss’ limb from every other, leaving no ambiguity as to which pose they’re taking. Additionally, because they’re cartoonish, the bosses aren’t limited to looking strictly realistic, allowing the artists to exaggerate their wind-ups, making the attacks even more clear. This means the bosses can have interesting cues that are still easy to read quickly. As an example, here are a few of the wind-up animations for the titular Hollow Knight’s attacks.</p><figure><img alt="Four photos: The boss crouches, ready to lunge forward. The boss spews orange infection from its front. The boss assumes a defensive stance. The boss winds up to take a large swing with its sword." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Nres9kcDMquz82EdthBcqg.png" /><figcaption>Stills from the Hollow Knight boss fight.</figcaption></figure><p>Even though these attacks are all some form of sword attack, each of them is distinct from the others and is easy to read at a glance. Even if you haven’t fought the Hollow Knight before, the attacks are so clear that you can tell where the moves are likely headed. By the time you learn the boss more, the game is testing you on quickly reacting to multiple attacks in a row while setting yourself up to capitalize on the next attack, rather than just recognition, leading to quick and satisfying gameplay. The camera is also fundamental to this: you never have to think about moving the camera to keep it focused on the boss, or waste time wrestling with a lock-on system. For the vast majority of bosses, there will never be a point where you can’t see them. By seeing the cues for each move from the same angle and distance every time, the player doesn’t have to waste time trying to figure out which move the boss is about to do, and can instead focus on just reacting. Other games also use their art style and camera to create difficult but satisfying bosses: we can observe a similar strategy in the game <em>Cuphead</em>. <em>Cuphead</em> is a 2D cartoon-inspired boss-rush game, known for being brutally difficult. Rather than relying on confusion from which attack is going to happen, <em>Cuphead’s</em> clear art style lets the game push the player’s skill to the limit. The over-exaggeration of moves cues and the incredibly simplified art style allow the game to have ridiculously complex bosses that are still clearly readable. <em>Hollow Knight</em> uses similar strategies to create exciting, clear, and fast-paced boss fights. The readability of <em>Hollow Knight’s</em> art style allows the player to spend less time in the recognition phase when learning a new boss, and allows them to more quickly begin learning the rhythm of the fight itself and how they need to react to each of its moves. Rather than trying to decipher confusing moves in the middle of battle, the player is instead tested on their skill and execution — not just looking at the boss, but actually <em>fighting</em> it.</p><figure><img alt="An enormous orange-and-yellow flower snakes bright green thorny vines across the stage, forcing the player to jump to avoid them." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*gI1pYBy8IfP3lGUz" /><figcaption>The Cagney Carnation boss fight from Cuphead.</figcaption></figure><p><em>Hollow Knight’s</em> bosses, beyond having clearly defined move cues, have very clearly defined moves. Each boss has a handful of moves they use interchangeably, each distinct and readable. Many of the game’s best bosses only have a few moves: the eponymous Hollow Knight only has nine, the Soul Master has six, the Traitor Lord only has four. The challenge from these boss fights either comes from the sheer speed and relentlessness of their attacks, or in how their attacks overlap with each other, creating unique scenarios you have to adjust to on the fly. Again, <em>Hollow Knight</em> takes a simple system and forces the player to truly master it. As an example, one of the best fights in the game, the Mantis Lords, have essentially only three different attacks: a horizontal one across the arena, a vertical one where they drop onto a specific spot, and one where they fire a projectile from the side of the arena. The first phase of the boss, which is one of the Mantis Lords, ensures you understand these separate attacks and exactly how they work. The second phase has two of them attack you at once. All of your knowledge from the first phase about how exactly their three distinct attacks work is put to the test, as you are now expected to react at nearly double the speed to many different combinations of these simple attacks. The only reason the Mantis Lords work is because their attacks are clearly defined. If they sometimes attacked an extra time, or fired two projectiles instead of one, the predictability of the fight would be entirely lost, making for a confusing scramble of a battle. As it is, the fight becomes akin to a dance as you learn it better, your fingers flying instinctively across the controller almost before you’ve recognized the attack. Like all bosses in <em>Hollow Knight</em>, the Mantis Lords are meant to push you to your limits, demanding lightning-fast reaction times and a deep understanding of both your moveset and the bosses’. This understanding must start with distinct and readable attacks.</p><p>One of the endgame bosses, Nightmare King Grimm, has exactly six attacks and I know each one like the back of my hand. The fight seems nearly impossible at first, with Grimm moving unbelievably fast and dealing double damage: my first attempt is lasted no more than a handful of seconds as I helplessly watched him obliterate me. But as I fought him again, and again, and again, and again, the fight started to make sense. I realized it was almost like a computer program, with defined inputs and outputs: he does X attack, I do Y. He does the fire bats attack, I jump, dash, then hit him exactly twice. He does the dive attack, I jump higher, dash the other way, and hit him once from above. This is a fight that pushes me to my absolute limits: the challenge lies not in any single move, but in executing the entire fight perfectly. There is no room for slip-ups, no margin of error. There is me and my skill and that is it.</p><figure><img alt="Nightmare King Grimm, bright red and covered in red flames, charges across the bottom of the screen. The player jumps over him." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*kQn2ZEG90OsgqmjT" /><figcaption>The Nightmare King Grimm boss fight from Hollow Knight.</figcaption></figure><p>This is the fight I return to when I’m at my most stressed, when the world feels the most out of control. I understand <em>Hollow Knight</em> on a fundamental level and fighting Nightmare King Grimm is nothing but a hypnotizing display of that knowledge. This is every system of the game pushed nearly to its breaking point in one last beautiful duel. There’s nothing I’m missing, no upgrades or levels to grind out. When I mess up, I understand exactly what I did wrong and how I can fix it. There is nothing between me and the boss. The Nightmare King Grimm fight is no longer a computer program to me: it’s a violent, deadly dance. I know my cues, I trust my skill. All that’s left is to perform.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a60f820fd433" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Art in the Machine: Five Short Essays on the History of Computers]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@roryhoeschen/the-art-in-the-machine-five-short-essays-on-the-history-of-computers-352807c2826d?source=rss-e38a8f15a9ac------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/352807c2826d</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[music]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[history]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[analog]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[computers]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Rory Hoeschen]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 29 Mar 2024 19:28:38 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-03-29T19:28:38.106Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>These essays were written as part of a computer history class. They are each about 500 words and focus on a specific object from the history of computing.</em></p><p>Essay 1: Adding Machine. An analog calculator for addition, used by moving rows of numbers with a stylus to turn the internal gears. (Unfortunately, I could not find the photo I took of the adding machine, but here is a similar one. The only difference is that mine could not subtract.)</p><figure><img alt="A picture of an adding machine. It has seven rows of numbers, which can be dragged with a stylus to add or subtract in each place value. It is small enough to hold in a hand and made of metal" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*_1P1vnTsBogTmwBI.jpg" /></figure><p>My laptop is designed to do, for all intents and purposes, <em>everything</em>.</p><p>I take notes on it, I write papers on it, I scroll social media and talk to my friends and research and watch videos and play games on it.</p><p>It is designed such that I can perform all these actions for hours upon end with the utmost ease. The keys are smooth and easy to press. The screen is large and readable. It barely makes a noise. This is a machine I could never get a callous from.</p><p>But “machine” doesn’t quite feel like the right word for it, does it? There seems to be nothing mechanical about it at all — smooth metal and rounded corners, easy to pick up, easy to put away, easy to use, easy, easy, easy —</p><p>The first thing that struck me about the adding machines was the noise.</p><p>As I jammed the stylus into the numbers, trying to figure out how this hunk of metal functioned, it was the noise that let me know I was doing something right. An incessant <em>click, click, click</em> — but not the tame, upbeat clicks of my laptop keyboard. These were louder, deeper, for lack of a better term they were <em>annoying</em>. I imagined an office with one of these machines on every desk, the cacophony that must have arisen from them, every clack and clank from each piece of metal slamming into the ones next to it.</p><p>I thought of my laptop keyboard, designed perfectly so as to have just the <em>right</em> amount of click so that it still felt like it was beneath my fingers, the slight noise saving itself from becoming the vague idea of machinery. I thought of how I could tell it was precisely engineered into its own mediocrity, meant to fade into the background. This adding machine has no <em>choice</em> but to be there. There is not a version of this adding machine without this noise. It takes up space and demands that it is <em>present</em> in a way my laptop never could.</p><p>The second thing I noticed about the adding machine was how it felt underneath my fingers.</p><p>When moving the rows of numbers, it took effort. It took technique to get the stylus at just the right angle and it took some force to move the rows. The stylus grated against my fingertips, to the point where I could feel them getting raw. As the rows moved, I could feel them going over each tooth of the gear, clicking up and down ever so slightly. When I released the row, the whole machine vibrated in my hand as the gear unspooled all at once. The number displayed on the readout felt insignificant next to the <em>feeling</em> of the readout changing, its unavoidable physicality.</p><p>When I use my laptop to add something, I click the same buttons I always click, and the pixels on the screen noiselessly flick to different colors. It wants to be as unintrusive as possible, to fade into the background so much I never spare it a second glance. When using the adding machine, it forces me to hear and feel every gear turn. Everything that makes it annoying, grating, frustrating, every hitch in the gear and every clack of the metal, is exactly what makes it feel real. The adding machine refuses to let me forget that it exists. It won’t let me forget that it is, first and foremost and always, a machine.</p><p>Essay 2: Computer-Generated Music. This album from the 1950s included both music generated by computers and played by people, and music written by people and played by computers.</p><figure><img alt="An album cover for “Computer Music from the University of Illinois.” It shows piles of different-colored computer punch cards." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*HVPSnSyd3dcmhSc2KH7xlw.jpeg" /></figure><p>The issue of computer composition is fundamentally an issue of translation.</p><p>In fact, you could argue all music composition is an issue of translation. The vast majority of sheet music today is written in western notation, which was built around the needs of classical composers. It’s decent at communicating pitches, harmonies, and simple rhythms, but quickly becomes difficult to parse with more complex rhythms, and there’s still no legitimate way to swing notes. Pitches outside of the chromatic scale, such as those used in many eastern cultures, are entirely left out. And, of course, its impossible to communicate the exact swells and feelings of a piece through sheet music. The process of transcribing the liveliness of music into static notes on a page inherently loses something.</p><p>Much of the ambiguity with written music is used to musicians’ advantage: if everything was perfectly communicated by sheet music, it would be impossible to have different interpretations of pieces. The same piece may sound completely different when played by different orchestras, even if the notes and rhythms are technically the same. The music is defined by the composition and the interpretation, driven by the imperfect translation of centuries-old ideas onto two-dimensional paper. Interpretation, and therefore translation, is fundamentally at the heart of all performances.</p><p>With computer music, there is inherently a translation barrier. Rather than working with a language both the composer and musician understand, they can barely communicate at all. While modern composition software can sidestep this translation barrier by letting composers use western notation, they had no way to do this in the 1960s. To get the computer to play a single note was a struggle, a series of seemingly-random holes punched in a card, with no way for the composer to know if this would sound anything like they wanted it to. They had to take the music in their head and transcribe it into something entirely illegible to them, something unrecognizable as music. Even once this composition was fed into the computer, it didn’t return anything familiar: a sequence of binary numbers, which must then be converted into an analog format, which only then could play the sounds that were so painstakingly hole punched into the cards hours or days or weeks ago. After layer upon layer upon layer of translation, the final product is more shaped by all these interpretations than by the composer’s original intent.</p><p>Perhaps these interpretations are even more obvious when going the other way, from computer-generated compositions to human-played music. The computer still created intelligible strings of binary, which still had to be converted into an analog format: in this case, western-notated sheet music. The musicians read this strange collection of notes the same way they would read any music: finding the phrases, the crescendos, the accents, deciding on the mood of the piece, the feelings it will invoke. They took this computer-generated music, inherently without emotion, and added their own. They created music defined by the composer and the musicians, the translation and the interpretation. This music would not be what it is without both contributions, without the inherent need to translate it.</p><p>All composition is shaped by its translations: across languages, across space, across time. The interpretations become as important as the music itself. Perhaps in this way, computer music, with its layers upon layers of translations, is not so different from human music. After all, it uses the same fundamentals: translation and interpretation, composer and musician, human and machine.</p><p>Essay 3: Spirit Photography. A common practice near the beginning of photography, photographers often overlaid faces of dead loved ones on otherwise normal photos by using tricks like double exposure.</p><figure><img alt="An old black-and-white photograph of a young girl. Two faces float behind her, looking like ghosts." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/360/1*ufBv5dWpykc84n8GO-eoAw.jpeg" /></figure><p>Truth is an impossibly complex concept, but most people accept a very simple definition. Whatever actually happened, <em>that</em> is the truth. The truth is that there is breed of dog called a beagle and the truth is that my family had two and the truth is that they died.</p><p>The truth is that I still hear them walking around the house.</p><p>It makes sense that the easiest way to remember them is through photographs. There’s no ambiguity there. The camera takes a picture of whatever actually happened, the camera shows the facts and therefore the camera shows the truth.</p><p>This is what practitioners of spirit photography believed. The camera was a new technology, a technology that could capture the world exactly as it was, show exactly what was there… and maybe something more. Spirit photography involved clever editing of the photographs to make it appear as if spirits, usually dead family members, were watching over the living subject. Some people knew it was fake, but some people believed the camera could show a deeper truth, show their loved ones still alive. Through these photos, the dead lived on.</p><p>The photos of my dogs are, from an outsider’s perspective, nothing. Blurry, over or underexposed shots, taken back when it was cool to take a photo on your phone. Pixelated puppies gnawing on toys and stumbling over their own paws, those same dogs getting older, running in the dog park, dragging me around on walks, snouts greying. My dogs are gone now, but they are captured in these photos forever, timeless and unchanging. These were the dogs and these are the dogs and these will be the dogs. In these photos, the dead live on.</p><p>But it’s not <em>life</em>, is it? The photos themselves are, from an insider’s perspective, nothing. Still, pixelated, grayish, lifeless. They show the facts, and they show them in every banal detail. They are nothing more and nothing less than exactly what happened. The moon is never as radiant when captured in a picture. The colors of a sunset get faded when filtered through a camera lens. When you take a photo of a dog, you miss the spark in their eye, the cock of their head, they way they look at you as you enter a room. These still photographs do not let my dogs live on, do not change the fact they are dead, do nothing but capture specific patterns of light which resemble my dogs only in the surface-level. But these photos still mean something to me. The facts the camera recorded are bland and meaningless, but the <em>truth</em> is something deeper. The photos are nothing but the memories attached are…</p><p>Well, they’re everything. I can picture my mom laughing as dad shows her how to take a photo with her phone, hear our dogs’ distinctive whines, the click of their nails, feel their fur under my fingers, the bite of a leash against my palm, see their delight when they spot a rabbit. The photos are nothing but vessels to remind me of the memories I have, the truth that I feel. In my memories, my dogs are alive. And that must be enough.</p><p>Photos are one way to “capture” truth, but I don’t think they show the truth at all. Truth is something so much deeper than facts, something that can’t be trapped in an inanimate photograph. It could be photos of my dogs taken on a digital camera in 2007, or spirit photos from the 1900s taken on cameras that captured light itself. Maybe the people in the spirit photographs believed in them, truly thought the camera showed another world where their loved ones were still alive. Maybe they knew it was all an elaborate fake. It doesn’t change the fact that photos aren’t the truth: they just remind us of it.</p><p>Essay 4: “Shoe-Field.” A piece by Sonya Rapoport, which was created by feeding data about people’s feelings on their shoes into a computer, which then used assigned values to generate electrical-field type patterns.</p><figure><img alt="The art piece “Shoe-Field.” It is very tall and narrow, and uses text to create what looks like different electrical fields interacting with each other (similar to ASCII text)." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*G-UTYGZMX1chix_Q1sNLmw.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>This essay has to be uploaded as a picture, as the formatting breaks in Medium. Please see </em><a href="https://docs.google.com/document/d/1Nz6ITYro57opXdGNbOaF7mvLJqhe8jrOe265qU9EHuo/edit"><em>this link</em></a><em> for an accessible version.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/768/1*Ks8WCfqRfP5-mfVBFN0YHQ.png" /></figure><p>Essay 5: Stereoscopes. Invented in the 1800s, these used sets of images taken at slightly different angles to provide the illusion of 3D pictures.</p><figure><img alt="A stereoscope, which looks like a pair of binoculars with a wooden box on the end." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/474/1*BgNwB8Y9r26Fg_6_Ga10MQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>In <em>Scott Pilgrim Takes Off</em>, an anime series based on the Edgar Wright film <em>Scott Pilgrim vs. The World</em>, the eponymous Scott Pilgrim travels years into the future to meet himself. The future is a fascinating blend of hundreds of disparate ideas of sci-fi: apocalyptic and perfectly normal, everyday and alien, technologically magical and a perfect reflection of our present day.</p><p>Scott Pilgrim, ever the nerd, shows off the technology of the future with a relic of the past. He promises a virtual reality experience, immersive in ways his past self can barely dream of, and the enormous vault door opens onto a Virtual Boy.</p><p>The Virtual Boy was Nintendo’s attempt at virtual reality — in the 90s. It was meant to create a stereoscopic effect through displaying two screens at slightly different angles to the player’s eyes. Unfortunately, what it really did was create headaches. It was a commercial failure, and Nintendo discontinued the console the following year,</p><p>The version of the Virtual Boy in Scott Pilgrim is called, to avoid copyright infringement, the Virtual Guuy. Like the original Virtual Boy, it displays things only in 32-bit red pixels, displaying the realities and lived experiences of Scott’s life filtered through shades of crimson squares. He relives the past through this fossil of a console, nothing quite accurate, nothing quite right, nothing quite <em>there</em>.</p><p>Stereoscopes of the 19th century, of course, had no pixels. By showing two photos of something — space, a statue, a geometric shape — from slightly different angles, the image seemed to gain depth, become three-dimensional, become <em>real</em> in front of the observer’s eyes. People loved these stereoscopes, using them to experience things and places they could never see in real life.</p><p>But these experiences weren’t any more <em>real</em> than cardboard printouts. The illusion is shattered as soon as you take the card out, look at the two images side-by-side, see beyond the illusion. There is nothing there but a static image. The sounds, smells, sensations of these places were entirely lost in the stagnant wooden box of the stereoscope, reduced to the smell of ink on paper, the sound of your own living room. The images themselves never move. You can never get a new perspective on them, see them from a different angle. They are captured exactly as they were, unchanging, unable to be interacted with.</p><p>The Virtual Boy came far before the advent of true virtual reality, inspired more by these wooden stereoscopes than anything digital. Like virtual reality technology today, It looked at the past to attempt move into the future. It was simply ahead of its time, the technology too complex for the knowledge of the 90s, forever limited by its red, pixelated output. Nothing in the Virtual Boy claimed to be real, but it tried to be. It tried to create a reality beyond itself, the illusion shattered by the slight mismatch of the images, the lag on the screen, the pixels in your eyes.</p><p><em>Scott Pilgrim</em> is a show about the past. It’s about being stuck in it, being unable to move on, reliving memories through red and black pixels. It’s a show about being obsessed with things that do not exist. Using stereoscopes and Virtual Boys and Virtual Guuys to transport ourselves to other realities only works as long as we maintain the illusion for ourselves. In the end, none of it is real. It is simply another way that we trick ourselves, another way for us to live and relive our lives in places we do not exist, realities we cannot influence, things we cannot touch.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=352807c2826d" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Circles of Safety: An Exploration of Dragon Quest’s Exploration]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@roryhoeschen/circles-of-safety-an-exploration-of-dragon-quests-exploration-d48463b07ad0?source=rss-e38a8f15a9ac------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d48463b07ad0</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[dragon-quest]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[videogames]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[video-game-analysis]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Rory Hoeschen]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 08 Dec 2023 18:45:32 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-12-08T18:45:32.204Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="A screenshot of the entire map of Dragon Quest. It is a green island, with mountains, deserts, hills, and trees. Many rivers cross it." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*esI8kxbQXl7EDqsAUQ8AQg.png" /><figcaption>The entire map of Dragon Quest</figcaption></figure><p><em>This essay was written for a JRPG analysis class.</em></p><p>While Dragon Quest seems like a simple game on its surface, it relies on a surprisingly nuanced system to drive its exploration and player choices, a system I will be referring to as the “circle of safety.” As I define it, the circle of safety is the area of the world that players know well and feel safe exploring. The boundaries of these circles are created by more difficult areas which are riskier for players to explore. The main goal of Dragon Quest is to expand this circle by getting stronger or finding safe zones past the boundary. Dragon Quest uses these circles of safety to drive exploration and create interesting choices for the player to navigate.</p><p>The entire map of Dragon Quest is centered around Tantegal Castle. This is where the player begins the game and where they will need to continually return to. Returning to the castle is not a choice or strategy: it is the only place to save the game, and so must happen at the end of each play session. This means the player is forced to return at periodic intervals, centering the exploration inextricably around the castle: this is where the player must always start from and end at. The castle, therefore, forms the center of every circle of safety in the game. It is the safe place from where every journey begins.</p><p>At the very beginning of the game, as the player starts to explore the world of Dragon Quest, they quickly meet enemies and obstacles. The lands immediately around the castle are populated by the lowest-level enemies in the game, easy enough that players can beat them with their starting equipment and start gathering experience points. However, if the player tries to venture too far south or north, they will quickly run into higher level enemies, such as ghosts and drakees. These enemies can kill early players extremely quickly, and this threat of death guides players back into the safer areas closer to the castle. This forms one of the boundaries of the initial circle of safety. The gameplay loop at this point in Dragon Quest consists of leaving the castle, fighting low-level enemies until the protagonist is nearly dead, then returning to the town next to the castle to heal. Through several repetitions, the player starts gaining levels, meaning the enemies become easier to defeat. The player is beginning to outgrow this circle of safety.</p><p>At this point in the game, risk-averse players may continue to stick close to the castle, fighting the low-level enemies they know they can safely beat. However, this is where the design of the world begins to come into play and begins to guide the player farther from the castle. For example, an NPC in the town next to the castle informs the player of another town to the north, providing a specific goal for the player to reach. More than that, however, the world itself is designed to provide incentives to explore, relying on the player’s natural curiosity. New and exciting enemy types are introduced throughout the first few hours, and as the player explores they discover more interesting areas, such as the first dungeon or the next town. This exciting exploration is in contrast to the combat itself, which is repetitive and uninteresting. While the optimal strategy to minimize the risk of death may be to stay entirely within the circle of safety, it quickly becomes boring, and the player will likely wish to experience new things. This phase of the game becomes a balancing act for the player between curiosity and safety: they must constantly choose whether the potential reward for exploration is worth the risk that comes with it. The game begins to encourage the player outside of their circle of safety through this careful balance, which creates interesting choices for the player.</p><p>If the player continues to stay in the circle of safety, Dragon Quest gradually increases the pressure to leave, introducing incentives that rely on the player’s desire for progression. Even for players who are entirely risk-averse, staying near the castle eventually becomes almost useless. As the protagonist grows stronger, they need more experience points to level up, and the enemies near the castle reward very few. At some point, they no longer reward enough to even be worth the time spent to fight them. At this point, even the most risk-averse players are pushed outside their circle of safety, as they realize no meaningful progress can be made by staying entirely within it.</p><p>When first venturing out of the circle of safety, players will be met immediately with much more challenging enemies. The enemies of Dragon Quest do not get gradually more difficult, allowing the player to gently push past the boundaries of their circle. Rather, a new type of enemy is introduced, significantly more difficult than the last. For example, a red slime, one of the earliest enemies, has 4 hit points. One of the next enemies the player will face as they explore farther is the ghost, which has up to 7 hit points as well as doing more damage than the red slime, dodging attacks more frequently, and being more difficult to run away from. Bridging this gap between enemy types is where much of the challenge of the game comes from. When first facing new enemies, a single unlucky hit can kill the protagonist, making every fight risky. Players may only be able to defeat one or two of these new enemies before having to run back to the town to heal. However, leveling up is faster when defeating these more difficult enemies, and so the player is incentivized to push the boundaries of their circle of safety and take on the extra risk that comes with that. If the enemies of Dragon Quest gradually got more difficult, the player would always be able to stay in an area that offered a perfect balance of safety and reward, right at the edge of their circle. As the game is designed, the player must take on significant risk to push the boundaries of their circle of safety. This creates more interesting scenarios for the player to navigate, and forces them to constantly choose how much of this risk they want to take on.</p><p>As players explore farther from the castle, slowly expanding their circle of safety, it becomes impossible to predict exactly where certain enemies roam. The most the player knows is that farther from the castle it becomes more likely that they encounter higher-level enemies. This means that high-level enemies can ambush players in areas that feel safe, or that low-level enemies can show up in difficult areas. While this is not extreme (you would never encounter a high-level enemy directly next to the castle, for example), it serves to blur the boundaries of the circle of safety. The player can never be certain where the boundaries lie and where exactly they become safe. Rather than knowing as soon as they reach a certain place they are safe from high-level enemies, the player must constantly weigh the risk that they could encounter difficult enemies where they do not expect. There are other parts to this randomness as well, namely whether enemies are even encountered or not. A lucky walk back to town may have a couple fights with low-level enemies, while the same walk the next time could have more fights with higher-level enemies, and be much more difficult simply due to random chance. This makes it impossible for the player to predict exactly what will occur, and creates more complex scenarios the player must evaluate. It means that there is no “correct” path, and the choice on whether to push forward or retreat back ultimately comes down to the player and how much risk they are willing to accept. The randomness of Dragon Quest makes it an unsolvable puzzle: there is no solution to how to progress through the game, on when exactly to continue forward and when to turn back. The vague boundaries of the circle of safety create uncertainty and make the individual choices of the player feel more meaningful, as there is not clearly a “right” choice.</p><p>As the player travels farther from the castle, the decisions they make, namely when they should turn around, become more difficult because there is more randomness with a longer journey and therefore more risks. In the first few hours of the game, the player will make their way through various types of enemies: first slimes, then red slimes, then ghosts, then drakees. The enemies are arranged with the more dangerous ones located farther from the castle, forcing the player to make their way through hordes of low-level enemies to reach the new ones each time they set out. While the low-level enemies pose little threat to the player at this point, as they are well within the circle of safety, they still do damage and drain resources before the player can reach the new threats. This also complicates when the player must turn around in order to make it back to the town safely. Because of the element of randomness and the unclear borders of the circle of safety, the player cannot predict exactly how many and what kind of low-level enemies they will face on their return trip, and each journey becomes a balance between fighting as many high-level enemies as possible for the most experience points and having enough health left to return to town safely. The choice of when to turn around becomes gradually more difficult as the circle of safety becomes larger, as more distance means more randomness must be considered, creating a more interesting decision for the player to make. This longer journey also means that the growth of the circle of safety becomes slower as the player ventures farther from their initial starting point and their resources are stretched thinner. Progress would eventually stop completely without the introduction of other towns.</p><p>The cycle of exploration out from the castle is broken up when the player encounters their first town. This town complicates the relatively simple gameplay loop. It immediately and dramatically expands the circle of safety by providing a safe healing point within a dangerous area. The player no longer has to fight through the low-level enemies to make it this far, and can instead start every journey from this town with all their resources. Although the player will eventually have to return to the castle to save, the town can serve as a temporary base from which, the player can once again quickly expand their circle of safety, free of the drain on their resources from the low-level enemies. This larger gameplay loop with the towns repeats several times: the player slowly expands the circle of safety farther from the new town until progress becomes incredibly slow, at which point another town is discovered to allow the process to begin again.</p><p>However, as soon as the player has been conditioned to believe this is how the game functions, Dragon Quest changes the formula. As the player pushes farther south, through gradually more difficult enemies, they start to believe a town must be up ahead soon. The circle of safety is becoming difficult to expand, and this is the exact point in the game that towns have been encoutered twice before. The problem is, to find the new town, the player must venture far beyond their circle of safety, too far to turn around and head back to the last town safely. Similar to the beginning of the game, this balances the player’s curiosity and drive to progress against their risk aversion and boredom. Trying to find the next town is an opportunity to make progress incredibly quickly and greatly expand the circle of safety, but with a lot of risk: if the town is not there, they will likely die. The safer option is to fight low-level enemies for a long time and slowly expand the circle of safety all the way to the new town, but the player is now exploring so far from the last town that this would take a prohibitive amount of time. This is a key choice for the player to make, and the careful balance of risk and reward ensures that either outcome will lead to an interesting scenario for the player to navigate. It is also a choice that will be made at a different point for each player: it will happen whenever they believe they have expanded their circle of safety far enough south that it is worth it to try to find the new town. When the player decides to try to find the new town, they are awarded with one exactly where they predicted it would be. However, upon entering, it is revealed that the town has been overrun with monsters. It is not a safe space and the player cannot heal here. Now, instead of the player managing to expand their circle of safety, they have pushed too far outside its boundaries and been punished for it. Making it all the way back to the last safe town alive will be a difficult endeavor, as the player has pushed very far outside of their circle and deep into a dangerous area. This is Dragon Quest reminding players how important the balance of risk and exploration is and that the gameplay loop is not as predictable as it may seem in its first few hours. The lead-up to the dead town provides a meaningful and interesting choice for the player to make, and the dead town itself serves as a reminder that the circle of safety is the only place the player is truly safe.</p><p>Dragon Quest has a relatively simple gameplay loop: explore outwards until the protagonist is badly hurt, then return to the nearest town to heal. Hidden within this system is the circle of safety that the game relies upon to drive exploration and create interesting choices for the player. The player is constantly encouraged to expand their circle of safety through a combination of progression and exploration incentives, providing interesting discoveries and faster progression when pushing the boundaries. Venturing outside of the circle of safety always feels risky because of the inherently random nature of the game’s enemies: this randomness makes the choices of the game more interesting because there is never a clear right or wrong choice, only the balancing of risk and reward based on where the player believes their circle of safety to lie. As the player gets farther from the center of their circle of safety, the game allows for continued progress by introducing towns, which greatly expand the circle and provide a new place to start each journey from. However, the game also uses the player’s knowledge of this formula to force them to make difficult choices and punish them for venturing too far outside of their circle. The circle of safety fundamentally drives the exploration in Dragon Quest and informs each choice the player makes. It allows this simple game to continually provide players with complex decisions and risk-reward balances, and makes the game fascinating to play.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d48463b07ad0" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Effect of LCCs & Market Share on the Delta/Northwest Merger]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@roryhoeschen/the-effect-of-lccs-market-share-on-the-delta-northwest-merger-af7c2e4f1b21?source=rss-e38a8f15a9ac------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/af7c2e4f1b21</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[aviation-merger]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[aviation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[aviation-industry]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[delta-airlines]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[northwest-airlines]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Rory Hoeschen]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 08 Dec 2023 18:45:17 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-12-08T18:45:17.641Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="A photo of two planes. In the foreground is a Northwest Airlines Airbus A319, with the Northwest Airlines silver livery. It has a silver fuselage, a red tail, and “nwa” in large letters on the side of the plane. In the background is a Delta Airlines 757, with the Delta Airlines “Colors In Motion” livery. It has a white fuselage and a tail painted to look like a red, blue, and light blue flag. The side of the plane says “Delta.”" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*LtUQ4sSQ0firG4YPERddsg.png" /></figure><p><em>This essay was written for a writing class.</em></p><p>With the passing of the Airline Deregulation Act in 1978, US aviation underwent major changes. Many new competitors began flying, notably low cost carriers airlines such as Southwest Airlines, who were organized much differently than the incumbent, “legacy” airlines. Over the next several decades, the airline industry saw many mergers and bankruptcies. In fact, all of the current major legacy airlines in the US have declared bankruptcy at some point in their past: United Airlines in 2002, Delta Airlines in 2005, and American Airlines in 2011. (Airlines for America) The reason these airlines are still around is due to a series of aggressive horizontal mergers: United Airlines merged with Continental Airlines in 2010 and American Airlines merged with US Airways in 2013. One of the most notable, however, was the 2008 merger between Delta Airlines and Northwest Airlines. The United States Department of Justice long debated this merger, as it would make the new airline the largest in the world (Airlines for America). Now, over fifteen years later, it’s important to look back and see what the long-term repercussions of this merger were. It undoubtedly shaped the airline industry for years to come and, in attempting to understand how it affected the industry and why, we can better understand the overall market effects of large mergers in the airline industry.</p><p>First, it is important to understand some of the underlying causes that influenced this merger’s outcome. When a merger happens, there are several market forces pushing in different directions. For example, a merger can lead to efficiency gains through economies of scale and streamlining processes across the new airline, which can drive down fares. In contrast, a merger can reduce competition on a route, which would allow the newly-merged airline to raise fares. I will be focusing on two influences in detail: the impact low cost carriers (LCCs) have on the industry, and the fact that Delta and Northwest were codeshare partners at the time of the merger, leading to overwhelming market share along certain routes. The LCCs affected the entire industry, and are not unique to the Delta/Northwest merger. The codesharing, on the other hand, is something singular to the Delta/Northwest merger, as not many other airlines have gone from codesharing to a merger, and therefore offers a unique opportunity to track how this affected the outcome of the merger. Through my research, I conclude that the downward pressure on fares from the LCCs was greater than the upward pressure on fares from the merger, leading to negligible increases in fares.</p><p>The passage of the Airline Deregulation Act allowed new airlines to enter the market, leading to the rise of the low cost carrier. An LCC is an airline that operates with lower fares than traditional airlines (legacy airlines) by reducing their operating costs (Asheville Regional Airport). They do this in many different ways, such as flying fuel-efficient aircraft, serving smaller airports that are less expensive to land at, and charging extra for in-flight amenities, such as checked bags or snacks, that are normally included with a legacy airline (Denby). They also traditionally fly short to medium-haul routes, though some LCCs have attempted long-haul routes, usually with little success (Asheville Regional Airport).</p><p>The main reason LCCs disrupted the industry so much when they entered is that they use a different organizational model for their flights. Legacy airlines such as United, Delta, and American operate using what is called the “hub-and-spoke” model. The hub-and-spoke model relies on several large airports, which the airlines connect passengers through. When trying to fly between two smaller cities on a hub-and-spoke airline, the route will go through this third connecting airport. Hub-and-spoke airlines benefit from economies of scale at their larger hub airports through having access to large maintenance facilities, employees, and passengers all in one place (The Geography of Transport Systems). They are also able to fly frequently to smaller airports due to the large numbers of connecting passengers routed through their hub: there may not be 200 people a day that want to fly from, for example, Milwaukee to Salt Lake City, but if an airline connects passengers through a larger airport like Denver, they can combine demand from many smaller cities such as Milwaukee, Omaha, and Minneapolis to fill a 200-seat plane from Denver to Salt Lake City. LCCs, on the other hand, rely on the “point-to-point” model. This model directly connects smaller cities with flights, eliminating the need for connections at a third airport (The Geography of Transport Systems). Because they do not have connections, LCCs often operate only a few flights a week between smaller airports, whereas with legacy airlines there are more frequent indirect options due to their connections. The point-to-point model is more complex and can be more difficult to manage, as the airline does not have a central airport where they have access to all their resources such as in-depth maintenance and extra crew members. However, this model can be highly profitable because passengers generally prefer direct flights, which avoid tight, stressful connections at large airports and take less time. As an example of hub-and-spoke versus point-to-point, let us look at a flight between two non-hub airports, such as Minneapolis, MN and Lexington, KY. A passenger could either book a flight with the LCC Sun Country Airlines and fly directly to Lexington in 2 hours and 50 minutes, or book a flight with the legacy airline United Airlines which requires a connection through their hub airport, Chicago, for a total time of over 4 hours (Flightradar 24; Google Flights). The direct option is more appealing to many passengers because it takes less time and effort: they only have to board one plane. Therefore by offering a direct flight between two smaller cities, LCCs can steal market share from a larger incumbent airline that only offers a connecting flight for that route.</p><p>LCCs have an outsized impact on legacy airlines, and their impact is only growing. The market share that LCCs hold increased from 7% of total domestic passengers in 1990 to 25% of total domestic passengers by 2002 (Ito and Lee). A 2003 paper found that LCCs’ strategy is to focus on entering markets with high passenger density, which allows them to fill seats and undercut legacy airlines (Ito and Lee). As an extreme example, when Southwest started flying nonstop from Sacramento to Portland, United went from having 90% of the market share on that route to having to cut nonstop flights altogether, unable compete with Southwest’s fares. The same paper states that “continued growth by LCCs is likely to be the primary driving force behind the future evolution of the deregulated U.S. airline industry” (Ito and Lee). It predicts that over half of legacy airlines’ revenue will be under threat from LCCs in the future (Ito and Lee). If we specifically look at Southwest Airlines, we can see just how drastic this impact is. Back in 2001, when Southwest was much less powerful than it is now, a paper was released analyzing the effect Southwest had on other airlines’ fares. It found that “when Southwest serves a route, fares are 46 per cent lower than on otherwise comparable routes that it does not serve” (Morrison). Southwest also influenced fares on routes it did not directly fly: when serving an adjacent route, fares on the original route were up to 26% lower. Even just the threat of Southwest serving a route lowered fares on that route by 33%. When adding all the savings up, Southwest saved passengers up to $12.9 billion dollars in 1998 alone. Only $3.4 billion of that was directly Southwest — the rest was the result of other airlines being forced to lower their fares to stay competitive. (Morrison) Southwest and other LCCs have a very strong effect on airline fares by forcing legacy carriers to lower their fares to stay competitive.</p><p>Opposite from LCCs and their downward force on fares is the fact that Delta and Northwest were codeshare partners prior to merger. Codesharing is a practice in which one airline sells tickets for another airline’s flights (Rizzo). For example, a passenger booking a ticket through American Airlines’ website may have access to a flight American itself does not fly. That ticket would technically be booked through American, but the flight itself would be operated by a different company, such as Alaska Airlines. Codesharing can be more convenient for passengers by allowing them to stick with one company and earn frequent flyer miles and other benefits with that company, even on routes they do not directly fly. However, codesharing can also be confusing for passengers, and there are sometimes problems with checked luggage and rebooking flights (Rizzo).</p><p>Codesharing can be economically beneficial for passengers as well, but only in certain cases. A 1997 study titled “The Effects of Airline Alliances on Markets and Economic Welfare” found that codesharing and other alliances between airlines were only helpful to them if the airlines were “complementary:” “For the complementary alliance, air fares decrease… and thus consumers in these markets are better off due to the alliance” (Park, Jong-Hun). Complementary airlines have route networks that rarely — if ever — overlap. An example of a complementary alliance would be the alliance between Northwest Airlines, based in the Midwest United States, and KLM, based in the Netherlands. KLM could use this codeshare alliance to book tickets to US cities they do not directly serve, flying the transatlantic flight themselves and booking a second leg with Northwest Airlines. A booking like this would be referred to as an “interline” fare, as the passenger will fly on multiple airlines. A more recent study from 2014 found that codesharing like this “has the most significant impact on interline fares, decreasing them by up to 22.5%” (Hüschelrath and Müller). In contrast, a “parallel” alliance would be an alliance between two airlines where they are already competitors along many routes. An alliance like this gives the allied airlines overwhelming market share, and allows them to drive fares up because of decreased competition along the route (Park, Jong-Hun).</p><p>The general consensus is that Delta and Northwest operated with route networks that overlapped to a significant extent. While the Hüschelrath and Müller paper argue that Delta and Northwest had complementary networks due to the airlines not sharing any hub airports, most papers come to the conclusion Delta and Northwest competed on many routes. An analysis of the merger from 2009 titled “Analyzing the Effects of a Merger between Airline Codeshare Partners” found that “Delta and Northwest products are substitutable (competing) in a significant number of markets in which they offer products” (Brown and Gayle). This paper analyzed routes across the Delta and Northwest network to predict the effects the merger would have on the industry. They concluded that Delta is a competitor on over half of Northwest’s routes, and Northwest is a competitor on nearly half of Delta’s. When accounting for the fact that Delta and Northwest were already codesharing, this would suggest that Delta and Northwest were already able to exercise overwhelming market share along certain routes and drive up fares, a problem that would only get worse by them merging (Brown and Gayle).</p><p>When looking back at the Delta/Northwest merger, LCCs and market share are two of the strongest forces influencing it. LCC competition worked to drive fares down across the industry, while the shared networks of the merger could have allowed the newly-merged airline to capture an overwhelming market share and drive fares up. Through my research, most analyses of the merger conclude that overall, passenger fares decreased. That is, the force of the LCCs was stronger than the force of the merger.</p><p>Observation of the merger concludes that fares increased briefly, but were quickly brought back down to pre-merger levels by the effects of LCCs. In an analysis from 2014, the authors concluded that on routes where Delta and Northwest held overlapping routes, there were short-term fare increases of about 11% (Hüschelrath and Müller). However, in the long-term, the analysis shows this fare increase to stabilize around 3%. They suggest that “competition in the U.S. airline industry is sufficiently strong to mitigate the market power effects of even larger consolidations” (Hüschelrath and Müller). The short-term fare increase due to the newly-merged airlines’ overwhelming market share on these routes was eventually undermined by LCCs’ entry into these routes. As stated before, LCCs specifically look for entry into high-traffic, overpriced routes, on which they can undercut legacy carriers. When LCCs enter into these markets, they have drastic effects on lowering the fares of every airline, which is what caused the fare increase to eventually stabilize around 3% (Hüschelrath and Müller). It’s important to note here that this study concluded the merger still resulted in higher fares, although this may have been affected by other outside forces in the industry, namely large waves of unemployment and the aftereffects of the 2008 recession.</p><p>This is further supported by the fact that despite large market share gains, this did not create higher fares for passengers. A paper from 2014 specifically analyzed how the merger affected market share across the industry. They found that overall, while Delta/Northwest and other legacy airlines increased their market share, their fares fell, suggesting heightened competition between these airlines and LCCs (Park, Sora). The newly-merged airline gained the most market share on routes Northwest and Delta had already been competing on, in line with the codesharing predictions from earlier. However, the newly-merged airline also had the largest fare reductions among legacy carriers, while LCCs did not change their fares. When looking at specific airports, the airline’s presence increased post-merger at their hub in Atlanta, but decreased at traditional Northwest hubs such as Detroit and Minneapolis “from approximately 61% to 49% and 66% to 53% respectively” (Park, Sora). This analysis suggests that while Delta/Northwest gained market share along many routes, this market share did not translate to higher fares for passengers. Additionally, they did not gain market share equally across their network, and some areas ended up with lower market shares post-merger (Park, Sora). This all suggests that other airlines were able to still compete with Delta/Northwest post-merger. Specifically LCCs, who were able to undercut legacy airlines across the industry without changing their fares at all, forced all legacy airlines to decrease their fares.</p><p>Finally, there were few large fare increases across the Delta/Northwest network, especially in markets where LCCs were competitors. A 2013 paper took a holistic look at the airline industry, and holds up many of the conclusions drawn by other analyses. They found, in line with the LCCs analyses from earlier, that the presence of a nonstop Southwest flight lowers fares along the route by 25%, and even connecting Southwest services lower fares by 7% (Luo). They found that “legacy carriers have a weak effect on fares, whereas LCCs have greater fare impacts, whether they are incumbents or potential entrants” (Luo). In regard to the Delta/Northwest merger, they found that the effect of LCCs was greater than the market power effect of the merger. Post-merger, there were small fare increases, but nothing drastic. They found “the fares for airport-pairs where Delta and Northwest competed with each other prior to the merger do not increase by much” (Luo). This is important to note because this is where fares were expected to increase the most, as Delta/Northwest gained overwhelming market share. In the connecting market, there was no significant change in fares except where they had been codeshare partners prior to the merger, where fares rose by 3.9% (Luo). One possible reason other than market share that the paper posits as an explanation for this is that Delta and Northwest could use price discrimination on these routes pre-merger, resulting in lower average fares. Post-merger, they could not use this strategy anymore (Luo). Price discrimination on codeshare routes is frequently used to charge interline passengers lower fares, while keeping fares high for non-interline passengers. This encourages use of the codesharing network (Czerny). Finally, Luo’s paper found that fares increased the most in markets LCCs abandoned post-merger (Luo). This supports the conclusion that LCCs were the main force keeping fares low.</p><p>The merger between Delta and Northwest made the new airline the largest in the world and there were many worries that it would lead to decreased competition across the aviation industry as this new mega-airline was able to attain overwhelming market share and drive out competitors. However, although Delta and Northwest gained market share from this merger, especially on routes where they were already competing or cooperating through codeshare agreements, passenger fares did not substantially increase due to LCCs. LCCs have an enormous effect on the airline industry, as they are able to undercut legacy airlines’ fares and therefore force all airlines to lower their fares to compete. Several different analyses of the merger conclude that this downward force on fares from the LCCs was stronger than the upward force of the merger. While fares increased slightly, it was not by much, and competition continued to happen as LCCs were able to undercut any routes that were being overcharged. The landscape of the aviation industry is being shaped by LCCs, and it is important to consider their impact on any legacy mergers that have happened in the past and may happen in the future.</p><p>Works Cited</p><p>Airlines for America. “U.S. Bankruptcies and Services Cessations.” <em>Airlines for America</em>, Airlines for America, 28 May 2016, <a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20160528074046/http://airlines.org/data/u-s-bankruptcies-and-services-cessations/">https://web.archive.org/web/20160528074046/http://airlines.org/data/u-s-bankruptcies-and-services-cessations/.</a></p><p>Asheville Regional Airport. “From Legacy to Low Cost: How Different Types of Airlines Work.” <em>Asheville Regional Airport</em>, Asheville Regional Airport, 27 Jan. 2016, <a href="https://flyavl.com/article/legacy-low-cost-how-different-types-airlines-work.">https://flyavl.com/article/legacy-low-cost-how-different-types-airlines-work.</a></p><p>Brown, David and Philip Gayle. “Analyzing the Effects of a Merger between Airline Codeshare Partners.” <em>Unpublished Manuscript, Kansas State University</em> (2009).</p><p>Czerny, Achim. “Code-Sharing, Price Discrimination, and Welfare Losses.” <em>Journal of Transport Economics and Policy</em>, May 2009, vol. 35, no. 2, pp. 193–212 (2009). University of Bath, Bath, England. <a href="https://www.jstor.org/stable/pdf/20466777.pdf.">https://www.jstor.org/stable/pdf/20466777.pdf.</a></p><p>Denby, Sam . “How Budget Airlines Work.” <em>YouTube</em>, uploaded by Wendover Productions, May 31 2016. <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=069y1MpOkQY.">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=069y1MpOkQY.</a></p><p>Airline route details. <em>Flightradar24</em>, accessed 5 December 2023. <a href="https://www.flightradar24.com./">https://www.flightradar24.com.</a></p><p>Airline route details. <em>Google Flights</em>, accessed 5 December 2023. <a href="https://flights.google.com./">https://flights.google.com.</a></p><p>Hüschelrath, Kai and Kathrin Müller. “Market Power, Efficiencies, and Entry: Evidence from an Airline Merger.” <em>Managerial and Decision Economics</em>, vol. 36, no. 4, pp 239–255 (March 2014).</p><p>Ito, Harumi and Darin Lee. “Low cost carrier growth in the US airline industry: Past, present, and future.” Working Paper, no. 2003–12, Brown University, Department of Economics (2003), Providence, RI.</p><p>Luo, Dan. “The Price Effects of the Delta/Northwest Airline Merger.” <em>Review of Industrial Organization</em>, vol. 44, pp. 27–48 (2013).</p><p>Morrison, Steven. “Actual, Adjacent, and Potential Competition: Estimating the Full Effect of Southwest Airlines.” <em>Journal of Transport Economics and Policy</em>, May 2001, vol. 35, no. 2, pp 239–256 (2001). University of Bath, Bath, England.</p><p>Park, Jong-Hun. “The Effects of Airline Alliances on Markets and Economic Welfare.” <em>Transportation Research Part E: Logistics and Transportation Review</em>, vol. 33, no. 3, pp. 181–1975 (1997). Elsevier Science Ltd, Great Britain.</p><p>Park, Sora. “A merger effect on different airline groups: empirical study on the Delta-Northwest merger in 2008.” <em>Journal of Transport Literature</em>, vol. 8, no. 2, pp. 73–99 (2014).</p><p>Rizzo, Cailey. “What Is Codesharing and How Can It Affect My Flight?” Travel + Leisure, Travel + Leisure, 3 May 2018, <a href="https://www.travelandleisure.com/travel-news/what-is-codesharing.">https://www.travelandleisure.com/travel-news/what-is-codesharing.</a></p><p>The Geography of Transport Systems. “Point-to-Point versus Hub-and-Spoke Networks.” <em>The Geography of Transport Systems | The Spatial Organization of Transportation and Mobility</em>, The Geography of Transport Systems, 30 Oct. 2017, <a href="https://transportgeography.org/contents/chapter2/geography-of-transportation-networks/point-to-point-versus-hub-and-spoke-network.">https://transportgeography.org/contents/chapter2/geography-of-transportation-networks/point-to-point-versus-hub-and-spoke-network.</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=af7c2e4f1b21" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Perspectives on Violence: The Duality of Everything Everywhere All At Once]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@roryhoeschen/perspectives-on-violence-the-duality-of-everything-everywhere-all-at-once-d70c7720740e?source=rss-e38a8f15a9ac------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d70c7720740e</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[film-analysis]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[film]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[movies]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Rory Hoeschen]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 08 Dec 2023 18:45:04 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-12-08T18:45:04.428Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="A screenshot from Everything Everywhere All At Once. Alpha-Waymond, a middle-aged asian man, stands over a security guard who is violenty faceplanting on the ground." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*gBVabFAbcBczIn21ECR34A.png" /></figure><p><em>This essay was written for a film analysis class.</em></p><p>From the lighthearted fights of a Marvel movie to revolting horror movie scenes, violence takes on many different forms in cinema. However, few movies show as broad a range of these perspectives as <em>Everything Everywhere All At Once</em>. The movie manages to be an action film that takes a distinctly anti-violence stance by portraying violence throughout the movie in several distinct ways, all depending on the perspective of the main character, Evelyn. Evelyn is a middle-aged Chinese American who unwittingly gets pulled into a multidimensional war when her husband, Waymond, is replaced by a different universe’s version of himself, Alpha-Waymond. Together, they use “verse-jumping” to gain skills from other versions of themself and, hopefully, save the multiverse. As Evelyn learns to fight, violence is portrayed at alternate times as something both triumphant and exciting, as well as something disgusting and awful, depending on her position and power in the fight. These perspectives are in conflict throughout the movie, demonstrating that whether someone views violence as “good” or “bad” depends more on their perspective than the violence itself.</p><p>The first true action scene in the movie serves as both a moment of levity and a transition point into the rest of the movie, which will be much less grounded in reality from this point forward. After Evelyn mistakenly punches an IRS worker, Alpha-Waymond gets into a fight with the security guards. The defining feature of this fight is how the camera is constantly used to emphasize certain moves and individual power struggles. For example, the characters spin and jump in ways that completely defy gravity, flying over walls from a single hit. The camera frequently stops moving to focus on the guards’ surprise at this, which emphasizes how Alpha-Waymond is not from this reality and does not fit in with the setting. The only true threat to Alpha-Waymond, the gun, is immediately communicated to the audience by moving the camera around it, showing how the outcome of the fight will revolve around who gets it. Other moves bring the camera along with them to show the momentum of the move, like when Alpha-Waymond spins the fanny pack around to grab a guard’s ankle. The fight also heavily relies on humor, with the music pausing to let the guards swear at their predicament, or the camera cutting from Alpha-Waymond’s masterful wielding of the fanny pack to a guard fumbling his baton in surprise. The guards are completely outclassed by Alpha-Waymond, and the movie makes it fun to watch their incompetence. There is also little blood in the fight, and the guards’ reactions to getting hit are funny groans, not screaming, crying, or other reactions that would communicate deep pain. Between the energetic camera movements and the humor of the fight, it is enjoyable to watch, and does not expect the audience to worry about the damage or fallout from the violence. Evelyn is never threatened, so there is no reason for the fight to be scary to the audience. The movie does not ask the audience to consider the guards’ perspective or pain: they are just the “bad guys” in the way of the “good guys.” This is a funny, entertaining violence, which the movie does not try to complicate morally.</p><p>In the very next scene, Alpha-Waymond and Evelyn have been cornered by a powerful version of the IRS worker, Deirdre, who is trying to kill them. This is a far cry from the lighthearted action scene before it: Evelyn and Alpha-Waymond are not in control of the situation, so they perceive it as terrifying, and the movie reinforces this terror. Rather than the bright lighting and eye-level shots of the previous scene, it is shot more like a horror movie, with the characters stalked through long hallways lit only by flickering lights as Deirdre looms in the background. The sound design is also much scarier: Deirdre makes inhuman screams as she smashes walls apart to try and find them. Within this sequence, there is a grotesque scene where Alpha-Waymond must give himself paper cuts, an action other characters within the movie visibly cringe at witnessing. The sound design emphasizes the sound of skin splitting and Alpha-Waymond’s pained breathing in a way that is meant to make the audience uncomfortable. This violence is disgusting and unsettling to watch, not something to be laughed at. The reason this violence is portrayed this way is because of Evelyn’s perspective: she is now in danger and holds no power, so she perceives the violence as awful and scary. Even though many of the actions are similar to the fight scene with the guards, we are now forced to see the other side of that fight: people fruitlessly fighting someone much more powerful than them, unable to land a single hit. The level of violence is similar but the lighting, camera, and sound design make this fight disturbing instead of fun. This is the first time that the movie contrasts different perspectives on the same kind of violence, and it is deeply unsettling. Whether the violence is something fun and lighthearted or something terrifying is simply due to the perspective of the person watching, not the level of violence itself.</p><p>As Deirdre continues to stalk Evelyn, she tries over and over to verse-jump, but to no avail. Eventually it is just her and this universe’s version of Waymond, who has no fighting skills, against Deirdre. Finally, Evelyn manages to verse-jump and gain martial arts skills from an alternate-universe version of herself. The mood is immediately different from the horror-movie shots used earlier in the sequence. While <em>Claire de Lune</em> plays, Evelyn easily takes care of Deirdre with her new powers. The fight is shot entirely in slow motion, showing how easy Evelyn finds this; she is so powerful literally perceiving Deirdre in slow motion with ample time to react to her attacks. The calm music of <em>Claire de Lune</em> emphasizes this relaxation, Evelyn fully in control. When described like this, this scene feels triumphant and exciting, with Evelyn coming into her own powers and saving herself and Waymond. Evelyn views it this way, enjoying her new powers, and tempted by the alternate life she saw for herself, where she studied martial arts and became rich and famous. The violence is therefore portrayed positively, almost as a beautiful dance. However, the camera also shows Waymond throughout this scene, horrified by what he is witnessing. His first question to Evelyn is not “how,” but “why.” He does not understand why Evelyn would attack Deirdre, even after seeing Deirdre chasing them. The violence here drives a rift between Evelyn and Waymond. While Evelyn perceived it as beautiful and triumphant, Waymond was deeply unsettled, seeing the violence as nothing but awful despite his wife being in control.</p><p>Throughout the movie, Evelyn gains greater and greater power over her skills, verse-jumping with ease. She learns that each problem she faces can be solved with more violence, the action scenes only becoming more over-the-top throughout the movie. Just as the movie is reaching a rhythm with these fight scenes, always making them more impressive, more triumphant, more entertaining, this momentum comes to a screeching halt. The antagonist, Jobu Tupaki, forces Evelyn to see the futility of everything, and she breaks down. She takes the violence that she has learned to use and turns it on everyone around her: stabbing her husband, smashing windows, screaming. The movie draws parallels between this physical violence and other kinds of violence, intercutting the stabbing scene with Evelyn in another universe handing Waymond divorce papers. This is where the movie forces both Evelyn and the audience to shift their perspective from viewing the violence as something entertaining to something repulsive. The movie shows the fallout of the violence Evelyn is inflicting, no longer underscored with upbeat battle music but instead tragic strings. We directly see the pain of the people she is hurting. The violence is no longer beautifully choreographed but disgustingly realistic. Not a single over-the-top martial arts move is used: just baseball bats and shards of glass and people screaming. These simple scenes are bloodier than any before them: blood drips down Evelyn’s knuckles and smears across her face. This scene shows the violence from Evelyn’s perspective, but now she knows it is something awful and is purposefully hurting people. By forcing the audience to see this violence as something tragic and awful, they are made deeply uncomfortable with the same actions that made them laugh an hour ago.</p><p>This disgust provides the springboard for the climax of the movie, as Waymond monologues about how he sees the violence as something awful, no matter who is committing it. This monologue would fall flat without the previous scene, as Evelyn and the audience would still consider the violence in the movie as something fun rather than something disgusting. As it is, Waymond convinces Evelyn to stop fighting, instead using her powers to resolve the battle peacefully. This is what the juxtaposition of violence has been building up to throughout the movie. While some characters, like Evelyn and Alpha-Waymond, have seen the violence as a positive thing in most situations, Waymond has always viewed it as negative. By letting the climax finally show Waymond’s perspective, it recontextualizes the violence that has occurred throughout the movie, and it would be disturbing if Evelyn continued to use violence. As Evelyn is the main character, the audience sees events the way she views them, and so experiences the same perspective shift as her at the climax. It forces the audience to face the disgusting violence they have found entertaining for most of the film, and demonstrates the power perspective has. The same violence Evelyn now condemns is what was portrayed so triumphantly earlier in the film: just her perspective on it has changed. By forcing the audience to reckon with this, the film demonstrates how every violent act in this film has hurt someone, something that only Waymond has seen. There was no “good” violence, nothing that was “justified,” funny, or triumphant. It was all the same disgusting, awful violence.</p><p><em>Everything Everywhere All At Once</em> demonstrates how people’s judgment of violence is often based on their own perspective, rather than the violence itself. Evelyn frequently views fights in which she is the most powerful as exciting and fun, while when she’s in danger the violence is terrifying. At the climax, the film forces the audience to realize all the violence in the movie has been terrifying to someone: there is no “good” violence. Despite Evelyn’s fights seeming justified or exciting to her, someone is always hurt. Violence always has a victim.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d70c7720740e" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Wikis We’ve Made Along the Way]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@roryhoeschen/the-wikis-we-make-along-the-way-ec51c268e528?source=rss-e38a8f15a9ac------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ec51c268e528</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[video-game-history]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[terraria]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[minecraft]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[video-game-analysis]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[videogames]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Rory Hoeschen]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 30 Nov 2023 21:25:49 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-10-06T15:04:23.413Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="A bunch of chaotically overlapping screenshots from the Terraria wiki, the Minecraft wiki, Xevious, and Dragon Quest 3. Overlayed in large text are the words “WIKI GAMES.”" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*UPF4z8r5QdclJcbluAT9UA.png" /></figure><p><em>A version of this piece was published in Northwestern’s </em><a href="https://www.sceneandheardnu.com/content/2023/11/30/the-video-game-wikis-weve-made-along-the-way"><em>Scene + Heard magazine</em></a><em>.<br>This piece has been turned into a </em><a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y5gyJYaPGUw&amp;t=8s"><em>video essay</em></a><em>.</em></p><p>It’s something I hear about often, but have never truly experienced: stuck on a video game level, your only option is to run to your friend’s house and ask how to complete it. They grab your gameboy and show you how it’s done, likely feeding you some classic video game rumor about secret characters in statues or legendary Pokémon hiding under trucks while they’re at it. These urban legends were spread and fed by kids’ imaginations and the imperfect information available on early video games: you simply couldn’t know everything about a game yourself. If you had a question that wasn’t answered by the game manual, your only option was to ask your friends. To truly understand a game, you had to go to the playground.</p><p>This sort of communal playground strategizing and rumor-swapping fell with the rise of the internet and had almost completely faded by the time I started playing games. It’s been replaced, of course, with other ways of sharing information: forum threads, video playthroughs, wikis, and the ever-growing industry of game guides. These new methods create truly all-encompassing collections of information while allowing people to access them more easily than ever before. But these communities are fractured and disparate, the vast swathes of information used only to find a single answer before being tossed aside, a far cry from the collaborative excitement of a playground. Many games these days try to minimize your contact with anything other than the game, creating playthroughs entirely isolated from any outside community. This individualized gaming loses part of what made games so special in the first place. Video game culture began with close-knit groups of friends and neighbors, and this is a part of its worth saving.</p><p>Perhaps it’s no surprise playground-like situations are where some of the very first video game communities sprung up. Long before the days of <em>Pokémon</em> or <em>Sonic</em>, a little arcade game called <em>Xevious</em> was becoming massively popular in Japan. It was a scrolling shooter, with the player controlling a spaceship shooting down wave after wave of enemies. It was, gameplay-wise, not all that different from other scrolling shooters of the time. But the community it created was entirely unique. In his essay “<a href="https://www.kinephanos.ca/2015/game-freaks-who-play-with-bugs/">The Game Freaks Who Play With Bugs</a>,” Nakazawa Shin’ichi sets out to uncover what made “Xevious” so incredibly popular. He begins, interestingly enough, with pinball games.</p><p>“The pleasure of pinball machines comes from the enjoyment of a type of competition,” Nakazawa writes. The pinball machine, also very popular in 1980s Japan, was mainly a solo endeavor. Sure, people could gather around and watch someone play, but they were focused on making their own score go up. Getting the high score automatically meant someone else lost it. The ultimate goal is a solo victory, to have <em>the</em> high score, to be unquestionably the best. There is no inherent collaboration in a pinball machine.</p><p><em>Xevious</em> was also a game with a high score counter. <em>Xevious</em> was also a game with a ladder to climb and other players to best. A surface-level look at <em>Xevious</em> would take it as a well-polished spaceship shooter with fun strategy and interesting enemies: easy to play, satisfying to master.</p><figure><img alt="The game shows a top-down view of a river and a forest with strange alien ships flying over it." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*qXdcBFq_MfKWjjfJ" /><figcaption>A promotional image for Xevious</figcaption></figure><p>But <em>Xevious</em> was also a game full of secrets.</p><p>The first hint of this was deliberately placed: your spaceship in <em>Xevious</em> was equipped with two weapons, an air attack and a ground attack. Hitting certain spots on the ground, something that was sure to happen with enough playing, uncovered hidden bonuses — a secret tower, a concealed flag. As simple as it was, this was the beginning of something much bigger, the first step into <em>Xevious</em>’ cavernous depths. As intrigued players began to dig deeper, more and more secrets were unearthed.</p><p>Nakazawa notes some of the phenomena that were discovered: “Warp back to area 7 immediately after being hit.” “A number of ‘mysterious forest phenomena’ may appear.” “After the destruction of Ando Genesis’ Argos… the background turns to black and it looks as if the player is entering a tunnel until, eventually, a background previously unseen appears.” These were not features anymore: these were <em>bugs</em>, unintended consequences of programming that led to strange anomalies. This is what the community formed around. Children swapped rumors of “hidden characters” and secrets, discussing the game into the early hours of the morning. So-called “game freaks” created walkthroughs of the game together, with the express purpose of discovering more of these secrets and sharing them with their friends. It got to the point where a guide book was published, recording the many bugs the community had discovered over the years in one place. Collectively, these players moved toward a more complete understanding of <em>Xevious</em>.</p><p>Without the bugs, <em>Xevious</em> was an interesting game, sure, but one a single person could comprehend. With the bugs, that was impossible. “By ingeniously leaving bugs behind, <em>Xevious</em> ended up holding countless mysteries,” writes Nakazawa. People were forced to swap information and tips, each one of them contributing a small amount to the overall understanding, each part of a greater community. What set <em>Xevious</em> apart from pinball was no aspect of the gameplay, but simply the collaboration surrounding it. Playing <em>Xevious</em> was not a solo endeavor, and the community is what propelled the game to such heights.</p><p>Collaborative games today take on many forms, but one of the strongest connections to communities like <em>Xevious</em> would be the modern trend of “wiki games” — games where players frequently consult community-created reference sites, referred to as wikis. Perhaps the first game that comes to mind when thinking of wiki games is <em>Terraria</em>.</p><figure><img alt="The game is 2D and made of blocks. A player character stands in the middle of the photo, a large eyeball attacking him. Another character stands in the caves near the bottom of the image. A house with several NPCs is to the left, and a rocky overhang is to the right." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*V5PK6bAh7eZ6l3ZN" /><figcaption>A promotional image for Terraria</figcaption></figure><p>As a kid, I played countless hours of <em>Terraria </em>with my friends, but my strongest memories are not the bosses or the exploration, or even any part of actually playing the game. Rather, they’re of crouching on the floor with my friends, scrolling through pages upon pages of the Terraria Wiki on our parents’ iPads, trying to understand an impossibly large and complex catalog of information. Playing <em>Terraria</em> without the wiki is a near-impossible endeavor. The systems of the game are so complex that there is no conceivable way you could figure them out through simple trial-and-error. Entire bosses, crafting trees, end-game items — heck, <em>most of the game</em> is locked behind one specific boss, who spawns in one specific area after one specific action, which can be easily missed if you don’t know what to look for.</p><p>And so my friends and I researched and researched and researched. We would sit in the back of the classroom sketching boss arena designs on stolen graph paper, writing out complex guides to character builds we wanted to try. We’d strategize about new items on the way home and, when we finally got there, would immediately do <em>more</em> research. When we at last pulled up the game, we’d inevitably find we’d forgotten a tip or percentage or statistic and would have to pause everything to look it up again.</p><figure><img alt="A complex web of materials and swords, starting at the top of the image with raw materials and coming together into one sword at the bottom of the image. There are at 10 different swords that must be crafted together to make the powerful sword at the bottom of the image" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*GrAxF8NtAbPt9Jre" /><figcaption>A crafting tree from Terraria, as shown on the Terraria wiki</figcaption></figure><p>This is not a normal approach to a game today. In fact, many people swear off wikis and guides, preferring to play games “themselves.” Many games embrace this individual play, trying to minimize the number of times you have to pause the game to search for an IGN walkthrough. Yet with a game like <em>Terraria</em>, this level of research is all but required, and it creates a unique community adjacent to the game. Being twelve years old, I wasn’t really involved in the online <em>Terraria</em> forums, but rather found this community among my friends. Through all of our research and planning, <em>Terraria</em> took up much more of our time than just the hours we spent playing it. There was always a new goal somewhere off in the distance that we could work toward together. In fact, the only reason we eventually stopped playing the game is that we quite simply completed everything. When there was nothing left to complete, no more research to do, no more strategies to construct, we moved on.</p><p>This community is fundamentally different from the community that formed around <em>Xevious</em> back in the 80s. They were attempting to piece together a complete picture of the game from imperfect information, constantly adding to their knowledge by discovering new things. Essentially, they were writing the <em>Xevious</em> wiki. My friend group was working from an already-complete body of information — the wiki — trying to synthesize and understand it in a way that was helpful to us. Despite that, the interactions within these communities were incredibly similar: groups of people comparing knowledge, working toward a greater understanding, updating their consensus as new information pours in. We were all engaged in the game <em>beyond</em> the game, immersed in meta-knowledge, constantly putting together and pulling apart the facts in different ways. Sitting around the lunch table discussing <em>Terraria</em> strategies recalls the playground discussions around <em>Xevious</em> from the 80s: a close-knit local community, working together to truly master a game.</p><p>The necessity of the wiki also forced my friend group to engage with <em>Terraria</em> beyond the surface level. Long before my school research projects got beyond simple lists of facts about elephants or lions, I was connecting disparate pieces of information across <em>Terraria</em> wiki pages, synthesizing statistics into strategies. My friends and I were constructing long-term plans together, constantly researching and updating our ideas. Look, I’m not going to argue that <em>Terraria</em> somehow honed my research skills or made me a responsible adult or got me into college. I’ll just say that I played a lot of games as a kid, and <em>Terraria</em> is still the one I know the best. I can still list the differences between the Corruption and the Crimson (and argue, with examples, why the Crimson is better), tell you how to build a boss arena for everything from the Eye of Cthulhu to Plantera and beyond, explain how hardmode ore generation works, and even tell you how to get the incredibly rare Skeletron pet. I don’t play <em>Terraria</em> anymore. This information is useless. But it’s there. We spent so much time thinking about this game, so much time struggling with its complexities, that I still remember its nuances. I don’t think this would be true if it was a simpler game, if I had been able to figure everything out on my own. There is something special in needing to <em>work</em> to know a game intimately, forging your own connections with it, forcing yourself to learn something so complicated inside and out.</p><p><em>Dragon Quest 3</em> is not a difficult game. Released in a time before wikis, it’s not a game that would have ever needed one. <em>Dragon Quest 3</em> was meant to be approachable, with the focus less on gameplay and more on an interesting story that anyone could enjoy. It was exactly this that made it so incredibly successful, praised as one of the best games of all time when it was released. Takahashi Gen’ichirō acknowledges as much in his essay “<a href="https://drive.google.com/file/d/1gSryO2WSTcXwe0XXJ28dM0g20okl98o7/view?usp=sharing">Has ‘Story’ Emerged Victorious?</a>” saying that “Dragon Quest 3” “may be in some sense a perfect game.” He argues, however, that this very perfection is the game’s downfall. <em>Dragon Quest 3</em> is a perfectly tuned masterpiece, with an exciting story and accessible gameplay, a game with every sharp edge and point of friction sanded off.</p><p>And yet, is something so frictionless worth your time?</p><figure><img alt="A pixelated, top-down view of a town. Four player characters walk along a brick path. A small pond and several buildings are visible." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/386/1*eTDs5AEL2WIVsDHqZhny3w.jpeg" /><figcaption>A screenshot from Dragon Quest 3</figcaption></figure><p><em>Dragon Quest 2</em>, the preceding game in the series, was notorious for its difficulty. Endless enemies to grind, countless deaths, night after night spent screaming at the screen. Despite all that, Takahashi writes, “still there undeniably exists within <em>DQ2</em>… a certain intransigence, so that even when you’ve exhausted your last reserves and cry out in despair… you rise again like a phoenix to grip the controller.” It is exactly that tooth-grinding difficulty that makes <em>Dragon Quest 2</em> an interesting game. It is a game that demands mastery. The difficulty made the bosses seem undefeatable until you bested them, the challenges insurmountable until you completed them. Each death deepened your emotional investment until the nearly unbelievable win, the highest of highs, a place you fought tooth and nail every step of the way to reach. The difficulty created true stakes, true failures, and therefore true successes.</p><p>The final boss of <em>Dragon Quest 3</em> felt boring in comparison. The carefully constructed narrative could not overcome how easy the gameplay was: you followed the instructions to the end of the game. There was no personal journey, no struggle, and no reason to engage deeper than surface-level. Takahashi describes it as “a game that never loses our interest. But, from another angle, this is no different than saying it lacks the power to push us to our limits.” Everything grating, disgusting, and frustrating about <em>Dragon Quest 2</em>, everything that gave it its power, was sanded away. It was replaced with a frictionless experience, something Takahashi referred to as “leisure reading.” An experience that demands nothing from us gives nothing in return. There is no reason for it to matter.</p><p>Which is why I was so mad when <em>Minecraft’s</em> 1.12 update added a recipe book.</p><p>Logically, I can understand why this is a good approach for the game. It makes it more accessible and was eventually going to be a necessity with all the new items being added. But again, something was lost. An important part of <em>Minecraft</em> for me was always trying to craft a cake and grabbing two sugars and one egg instead of one sugar and two eggs. Or was it the other way around? I had stacks of unlicensed <em>Minecraft</em> books in the corner of my room that I’d drag to sleepovers with me to keep track of the different recipes. There would constantly be someone asking how to craft this or that, and we would always be putting our heads together to puzzle out where each item went on the little 3x3 grid. There were even things to learn in the act of crafting itself — I remember one friend having their mind blown when I shift-clicked and dragged my cursor across the crafting table, and every time someone clicked wrong and made an entire inventory’s worth of diamond hoes, it was funny for days.</p><figure><img alt="Two menus side by side: one shows the player’s inventory, full of random items; and the crafting table, a 3x3 grid. Another menu to the left shows a list of items the player can craft." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*BotcpRGB4hPOboF9fuLWSQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>The updated Minecraft crafting table: the menu on the left is the recipe book</figcaption></figure><p>Today, it’s just a single button press and everything is done for you. I liked <em>thinking</em> about the <em>Minecraft</em> recipes as a kid: finding the logic behind how this layout of wood created stairs, while this one created trapdoors. Making up little stories to remember how it all fit together. You had to engage with the crafting system on a deeper level beyond a simple button press, work to dredge something up from the depths of your memory, laugh with your friends when you got it wrong again. Not so today. The more streamlined, frictionless crafting of today’s <em>Minecraft</em> completely erases that feeling of figuring out the game. Everything being laid out for you is easier, yes, but it also means it’s easier to ignore the game’s complexities. Like <em>Dragon Quest 3</em>, you never actually learn anything, never forge your own connections and unique memories. You just follow the directions laid out in front of you you.</p><p>I’m not trying to argue that easier or more accessible games are somehow inherently worse than games that force you to struggle. But when everything is made completely frictionless, there’s nothing left to engage with. When games stop demanding investment from their players, they stop being able to pay out. The work that used to be necessary to understand games is entirely avoidable today. My little sister will never laugh about messing up the <em>Minecraft</em> cake recipe, never teach her friends the difference between crafting a dispenser and a dropper, never work to understand and appreciate this intricate system. It’s all been sanded away.</p><p>The playground circles of early video games have all but disappeared, rendered obsolete or relegated to obscure corners of the internet. I was endlessly lucky to be able to find a similar community with my friends. I will forget the experience of playing <em>Terraria</em> and <em>Minecraft</em> long before I forget the lunch-table discussions, the pages upon pages of the wiki, the books we thumbed through in the early hours of the morning while desperately trying not to wake my parents. These experiences of group discovery are unique to games, and it’s worth creating spaces for them to occur, places where these memories can be made. From the early days of <em>Xevious</em> and <em>Dragon Quest</em> to the wiki games of today, these communities have been a significant part of video game culture. They are worth saving.</p><p>Luckily, the video game industry seems to agree. The rise of brutally punishing, purposefully confusing games like Fromsoft’s <em>Dark Souls</em> series illustrates this perfectly. The latest installment, <em>Elden Ring</em>, was wildly successful and has an enormous collection of guides, maps, and wikis surrounding it. The <em>Terraria</em> wiki is still alive and very much necessary, though some steps toward including more information in the game have been taken. Other wiki games continue to be incredibly popular; <em>Stardew Valley</em> and <em>The Binding of Isaac</em> come to mind. <em>Minecraft</em> continues to become more complex, now closer to the wishful mods of my childhood than the game I’m familiar with. The rise of MMORPGs provides a perfect space for this kind of collaborative knowledge-building among friends.</p><p>Not all players want frictionless experiences. Some players are willing to put in the work, willing to dive in deep, willing to participate in the enormous, fascinating communities that surround wiki games. These games are here for the people who want to be challenged to truly understand a game. Wiki games are not inherently better or worse: they simply provide a unique experience, one that we shouldn’t erase. The age of swapping tips on the playground may be long over, but I rediscovered it through these games. I wouldn’t trade it for anything.</p><p>I went back on the <em>Terraria</em> wiki while writing this essay, back in time through old pages and edits and long-forgotten history. In the depths, I found an edit I had made. A single tip, left in a list of other tips, for an esoteric boss. If I close my eyes, I can distinctly picture the low lighting in my bedroom as I typed it out on my mom’s iPad all those years ago, the glowing screen lighting my friends’ excited faces. It was an important moment for us. We were contributing to this community that had given us so much, this beautiful collection of information that we couldn’t have played without. We could only hope our knowledge would help some new playground visitor on their own journey.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ec51c268e528" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Communities Controlled by Space: Architecture in Atlantics]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@roryhoeschen/communities-controlled-by-space-architecture-in-atlantics-a59b8a3944f7?source=rss-e38a8f15a9ac------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a59b8a3944f7</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[movies]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[movie-analysis]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[architecture]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[atlantic]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Rory Hoeschen]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 23 Nov 2023 02:01:03 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-11-23T02:01:03.689Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*7h96E2r-VYPWeZGTGct74Q.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>This essay was written for a film analysis class.</em></p><p>A community is inextricably shaped by the spaces that it inhabits. It’s fitting then, that a movie so focused on community uses its spaces to tell the story. The plot of <em>Atlantics</em> follows Ada, a teenager living in Dakar with an arranged marriage to a rich man named Omar, whom she does not love. Ada’s boyfriend, Souleiman, has not been paid for three months, and so he decides to try and emigrate to Spain. He and the other men he travels with are never seen again, and the women are left to pick up the pieces. The movie constantly emphasizes the feelings of community found within different groups of people: mainly the women left behind, but also the men emigrating at the beginning. Their strength is in numbers, but the upper class of Dakar controls many of the spaces they inhabit. Through the architecture and spatial design of <em>Atlantics</em>, the ways spaces and communities influence each other are emphasized. Spaces controlled by the few separate people and widen divides, while spaces controlled by the many become comfortable gathering spaces, rallying points for the community.</p><p>The opening shot of <em>Atlantics</em> is an extreme long shot, the mise-en-scène framing two buildings with a vast expanse of sky between them (<em>Atlantics </em>0:1:32). On the left are brown brick buildings, currently under construction. They are clearly visible and in focus and people move between them. On the right is a behemoth of a structure, a tower of glass and metal, its edges blurred by the dust in the air. No one goes near it. The take stretches for fifteen full seconds. We see the construction workers, always shot against the overwhelmingly brown buildings they build. However, even as the camera centers these buildings, the tower lurks in the background of the frames, dominating them with sheer scale. The scene zooms in, finally breaking the pattern of long shots to show the audience close shots of the workers, arguing for their pay. As the workers drive away, defeated, Souleiman looks back up at the tower. We get an extreme long shot POV from his perspective, showing how the tower dominates the skyline. It is by far the largest thing for miles.</p><p>The tower functions as a symbol of the upper class. Its luxury is entirely out of place among the other buildings of Dakar, out of place among the people that live there. Despite all the workers and all the other buildings, the tower is something that is unable to be ignored. Its size dominates entire shots that it is barely even a part of. The fog that it fades into makes it look ethereal, untouchable. When Souleiman looks up at it as they drive away, the tower is the only thing worth looking at — bigger and more modern than anything else. It is a symbol of the power of the few. None of the buildings around the tower, as many as there are, as high as they reach, ever get close to the sheer unbelievable scale of the tower. The workers, for all their communal bargaining and their power as a group, are powerless against the upper class. They do not get paid, no matter how much they fight. No matter how powerful the community, the tower and the upper class are unassailable. The tower demonstrates a space entirely controlled by the upper class, a space that inherently keeps the lower class out. There is no space for Souleiman’s community to survive here; they must leave.</p><p>After Souleiman has left, Ada protests against the arranged marriage. However, her family continues with it and when Ada visits Omar’s house there is a long parade of people congratulating her (<em>Atlantics </em>0:32:07). The long establishing shot shows the dirty street they arrive on. High angle shots emphasize the crowd’s size before POV shots from Ada show how chaotic it is. More than just chaotic, the crowd is excited, decked out in colorful clothing that pops against the dark street. The sound of their joyful singing immediately cuts off when Ada enters the house. The first shot of the interior shows the blank white ceiling, lit only by harsh LED lights. It is a quiet scene, without any of the raucous joy that was found just outside. A scene further in the sequence shows Ada’s future room, first shown with a shot from Ada’s POV: pure, blank white, from the ceiling to the bed. Her friends’ colorful clothing looks out of place in the room, and they are always framed against the luxurious furniture they are admiring. Ada is never in these shots with them, never shown with the rest of the room.</p><p>Omar’s house is a luxury, and functions as an anti-community space. The other girls, Ada’s friends, covet the house and its amenities, expressing delight that they even get to be here. They take photos happily, trying to preserve the moment, but Ada sees the truth: when they leave, this house will separate her from the life she knows. Her friends are not welcome here. Everyone who congratulated her on the way in was abandoned at the door, their singing silenced by the thick walls of the house. Even the dirt from the street outside has no place here. When Ada is left here, it will completely isolate her from the community she grew up in. With this knowledge, the pristine house feels cold and distant, and Ada is acutely aware of this fact. She stands apart from the fancy furniture and the things her friends covet, knowing they will be what separates her from them. In this way, Omar’s house is used to emphasize the vast class divide that Ada will soon be on the other side of, isolated from her friends and family. The house is another space controlled by the upper class, but this time it keeps people in as well as out, fracturing the community.</p><p>In a movie full of hostile spaces, the bar is a welcome reprieve (<em>Atlantics </em>0:18:41). Immediately upon the start of this scene, the sound mix is full of women laughing and upbeat pop music. The bar stands open to the beach on one side, and every shot of Ada has the sea out-of-focus in the background. Several quick cuts in a row show different women talking and laughing with their friends. A longer tracking shot of the bar’s owner shows us the rest of the bar: small and worn down, with peeling paint and stacks of cardboard boxes. The sea is constantly in the background of the shots and the sound mix as the women realize their boyfriends have left. They stand at the edge of the bar, watching the sea, as they discuss what to do. Even as the scene turns from joyful to depressed, the women are all there for each other, figuring out what to do together.</p><p>The bar functions as the communal space in a movie defined by its community. This bar is where the women go to meet up and enjoy themselves. It is by no means a luxury space — the shots show us the paint is peeling, it’s cramped, and there’s clutter everywhere. However, the bar is run by a member of their own community. That is what makes it so approachable: it is familiar to the community it serves. As dirty as it is, the people are comfortable here because this is what they know, and it is a space controlled by them. The bar is also open to the sea, which sneaks its way into every shot and sound mix: no one can be kept out of the bar or trapped inside it. The quick shots emphasize the chaos found in the bar, but also the laughter. We see this bar used throughout the movie as a communal gathering space for the women affected by the men’s emigration. They are all welcome here, and they are all here for each other. The bar’s immersion in the community is inextricable, as it is built into the very landscape to be open to all. There are no walls here. This is a space run by the community, for the community.</p><p>The spaces in <em>Atlantics</em> are constantly used to divide or join communities, and it is always contingent on who controls the space. When spaces are controlled by the upper class, they force people out or in, fracturing communities and diminishing their power. When spaces are controlled by the community, they are open and allow for a safe gathering space. <em>Atlantics</em> demonstrates the power spaces have over people, and the ways this can be used or abused. In real life, spatial design is often used by the upper class to control people, from projects as small as individual buildings up to city planning. Safe communal spaces are necessary for a strong community, and it is vital that we recognize that importance and strive to create spaces run by the communities they serve.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a59b8a3944f7" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>