<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Roxanne Nelson on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Roxanne Nelson on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@roxannenelson?source=rss-546ab5a5605------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sat, 21 Nov 2026 07:52:41 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@roxannenelson/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Part 4 The Country Doctor]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@roxannenelson/part-4-the-country-doctor-4474bb1dbf27?source=rss-546ab5a5605------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4474bb1dbf27</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Roxanne Nelson]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 16 Apr 2023 21:20:21 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-04-16T21:20:21.858Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>In 1948 LIFE magazine published an inspiring photo essay called the “Country Doctor” which followed a general practitioner named Ernest Ceriani and his utter devotion to his patients. Dr. Ceriani was part of a breed that has long since vanished, as he served as the sole physician for a rural community of about 2,000 individuals, spread out over 400 square miles in the foothills of the Rocky Mountains.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*bKQLjxa7xOy_tGqnbILx_A.jpeg" /><figcaption>The country doctor (link below)</figcaption></figure><p>As the only physician in Kremmling, Colorado, and during a time without cell phones, telemedicine or even easy transport to better equipped facilities, Dr Ceriani operated a tiny hospital/clinic where he delivered babies, set broken bones, stitched up wounds, and made house calls to those who couldn’t come and see him. He was a jack of all trades — pediatrician, obstetrician, neonatologist, surgeon, radiologist, emergency specialist — whatever his patients needed, he did his best to provide for them. While their roles were not explicitly described in the photo essay, Dr. Ceriani had two or three nurses assisting him, and its safe to say that their job responsibilities also went way beyond what they may have been doing in a “regular” hospital located in an urban setting.</p><p>You can view the entire <a href="https://www.life.com/history/w-eugene-smiths-landmark-photo-essay-country-doctor/">photo-essay,</a> as it is available online. And kudos to photographer W. Eugene Smith who followed Dr. Ceriani for 23 days and recorded his story.</p><p>We’re Not in Kansas</p><p>However, the vast majority of modern medically based TV shows and movies do not take place in isolated rural communities, where limited supplies, personnel, and access would suggest more fluid movement between jobs and responsibilities. A nurse I worked some years ago had grown up in Montana and worked for a while in a rural facility located in a small mountain town. There were 10 beds and more often than not, she was the only person physically in attendance. Usually there were only two or three patients in house. She gave meds, drew blood and ran it in the lab, greeted the ambulance at the emergency entrance with trepidation, hoping it was something she could deal with. There was a physician on call, but it was still a phone call away, and she needed to stabilize the patient in the meantime. So yes, the Dr. Ceriani experience on a smaller scale and I think that would make a great TV show, I’m sure producers and talking heads would disagree. Hard to have a lot of drama, intrigue, sex, romance and other assorted shenanigans with a cast of a handful of people. I suppose it could focus on the wicked nurse who is sexually assaulting patients, or stealing narcotics, or setting up the hospital as a meth lab. Hmmm, maybe I should write the pilot for that!</p><p>Anyway, the academic urban medical center is the location of choice for virtually all shows. That goes for books as well. So why is it that these shows often to their best to emulate Dr. Ceriani?</p><p>The Chessboard</p><p>Like the players on a chessboard, hospital personnel need to be in the correct location. The chessboard itself doesn’t deviate. All the pieces have a specific role, and they can only move in certain directions and have different degrees of importance. Now this isn’t to say that hospital life and healthcare is static, or that someone is less important than another, but this is the basic outline. Everyone has a specific role, based on their education, job title, and salary. Hospitals vary depending on size, but they follow the same basic layout. The same goes for a patient. If you are admitted to the hospital for elective surgery, you are not going to be placed in a pediatric unit unless you are under the age of 18 years. If you’ve got pneumonia, you’re not getting a bed in post partum.</p><p>The ER doctor that you see when you come through the doors with chest pains is not going to be doing your cardiac surgery. She also isn’t going to be administering anesthesia for your procedure. A surgical resident is not going to be delivering a baby, or prescribing antibiotics for a 5 year old with sepsis — who hasn’t had surgery. The same goes for nurses. You are not likely to see the same nurse working round the clock, or to expect the nurse to babysit your kids (who are visiting) while you go to X-ray. The same nurse doesn’t scrub in the OR, and then go to work on a medical floor later in the day.</p><p>Before you can write accurate copy, it is therefore essential to start from the ground upFor example, in in order to do their jobAs many people know, hospitals are set up with different patients in different areas of the hospital. There are pediatric floors, adult medical floors, surgical floors, maternity floors, various intensive care units, etc. Knowing where your character/patient would be placed in the hospital depends a lot on the type of hospital you’ve chosen for your story.</p><p>The next two articles will provide some “building blocks,” for creating a credible story.</p><p><em>Authors, screen writers, journalists — it is possible to make your work accurate and entertaining, and keep the public’s interest, and without resorting to silly plot lines and unrealistic depictions of healthcare. Stay tuned to Medscript Owl — more to come to help you make your writing realistic, plausible, without sacrificing quality or putting your readers to sleep.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4474bb1dbf27" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Why All the Errors and Weirdness?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@roxannenelson/why-all-the-errors-and-weirdness-4910b75eecf1?source=rss-546ab5a5605------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4910b75eecf1</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Roxanne Nelson]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 09 Apr 2023 21:50:24 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-04-09T21:50:24.808Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>Why All the Errors and Weirdness?</strong></p><p><em>“Chris Mackelroy-I just found out I have a lump on my groin.<br> Dr.</em><a href="https://www.moviequotes.com/topic/grass/"><em>Herb</em></a><em> Melnick-</em><a href="https://www.moviequotes.com/topic/badness/"><em>Bad</em></a><em> place for a lump.<br> Charlie Harper-Tell me a good place.<br> Dr.</em><a href="https://www.moviequotes.com/topic/grass/"><em>Herb</em></a><em> Melnick-Someone else’s groin.”</em></p><p><em>From the TV series Two and a Half Men</em></p><p>With the Internet at our fingertips, where anything on earth (well maybe not the latest classified intelligence report) can be researched, why do television shows, movies, books, and mass media consistently and continually get it wrong?</p><p>For example, take this scene from an unidentified television program (I don’t recall the show since it was on as background noise at a colleague’s home):</p><p><em>A man was being discharged from the hospital, and a young female resident was going over his discharge teaching. I don’t recall the specifics of his diagnosis or what she wanted him to do, but it was something related to changing his behavior and doing/not doing something so that he could stay alive. The man joked about it, and then she stood up and proceeded to wheel him down to the front door. At the formidable glass doors they bade eachother farewell, the patient laughing and telling her he’d be fine. She watched sadly, a tear rolling down her cheek….</em></p><p>This scene might be plausible if the hospital in question was a 10 bed facility located in a very rural community. The physician would not likely be a resident, since rural community hospitals don’t tend to be teaching facilities, but we could say that she doing a family practice residency and a rotation on rural medicine. The hospital had only one nurse present at the moment, so the doctor discharged the patient. But in real life? And in a large urban facility where this was taking place? In your dreams!</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/0*dQjy7cijM8kh7o-X.jpg" /><figcaption>Yes there are nurses in hospitals who do most of the work that television shows depict physicians doing</figcaption></figure><p>Doctors do not do discharge teaching. That is the job of the nurse and sometimes the social worker, or patient navigators, etc. In other words, it falls on the so-called “supportive” staff, who do the actual patient care — whether it be physical or helping them navigate and maneuver their way through the system. The doctor passes by and signs the discharge papers, maybe pokes his head into the room and asks if the patient has any questions, but is gone in three minutes or less. He’s got a lot of other patients to see and never ending paperwork to complete, and it is not the job of the medical staff to prepare the patient for getting the hell out of Dodge. Nurses, meanwhile, go through the final discharge paperwork, give instructions to the patient, and then call for transport. There is never enough time to be as thorough as one would like, given the general shortage of nurses on any particular unit, and the limits on how much time they can spend with individual patients. Ideally, for a complicated patient, teaching began earlier, before the day of discharge.</p><p>I should add that nurses generally do not physically wheel the patient out the door. Most hospitals, unless they are desperately trying to unload as much as possible on nurses or aides, have transport teams whose job it is to well, transport patients to wherever they may need to go; ie, home, radiology, surgery, rehab, and so on.</p><p><strong>Getting it Soooo Wrong</strong></p><p>So why do medical shows often get it so wrong? When the simplest thing can’t be done correctly, and this goes not only for medical-themed TV shows, but also any television program that entwines a medical related incident into the plot — whether it be a gun shot, person waking up from a coma (a perennial favorite that is always wrong), surgery, someone diagnosed with cancer, and so on. Very little realism. Ditto for movies and books, and I will extend this to journalism in the mainstream media which is all too often frighteningly inaccurate.</p><p>For television and movies, I realize that writers are tasked with fitting complex medical jargon, hospital politics, and the pitfalls of the healthcare system into an hour of entertainment. Since illness and injury in and of themselves isn’t very entertaining (no one wants to watch a women in labor for an hour or a doctor remove an appendix) it must be peppered and spiced with dramatic, sometimes comic, and sometimes ridiculous, story lines about the personal lives doctors and to a lesser extent, nurses and patients. As expected, writers often don’t get it right, despite the fact that many shows claim to have medical advisers. Entertainment and ratings trump reality, and while we can say “well its just TV,” a lot of people are influenced by these shows. They think this is real, and for some, may even be a major source of healthcare information. While some shows are more realistic than others, nevertheless, they often give unrealistic expectations of the medical profession and patient recovery.</p><p>As an example, a 2017 <a href="https://tsaco.bmj.com/content/3/1/e000137">study </a>published in the BMJ, looked at how trauma patients are depicted on TV, and used Grey’s Anatomy as the main source of their research. Their findings:</p><p><em>Trauma patients as depicted on television usually need an urgent operation to address an injured body part, and then alternatively die or, in most cases, have a swift recovery with return to home after a relatively brief hospital stay. As anyone involved in the care of patients at a regional trauma center knows, real-life patients are often managed non-operatively or with operations (sometimes multiple) performed at an interval to the time of admission, and depending on the burden of injury, often require prolonged hospitalization and have disabilities requiring transfer to long-term inpatient facilities.</em></p><p>Not so in television-land.</p><p>Authors, screen writers, journalists — it is possible to make your work accurate and entertaining, and keep the public’s interest, and without resorting to silly plot lines and unrealistic depictions of healthcare. And for journalists, it is really important to maintain accuracy if you hope to have any credibility. So keep reading, more articles to come, as Medscript Owl will help you create great stories without sacrificing accuracy.</p><p>And getting back to the opening scene, that can be reworked very easily. Obviously, the resident was the main actor in this show, so the scene was written to put her into the spotlight. Keeping that in mind, this is one example of how it can be rewritten:</p><p><em>As the nurse finishes discharge teaching, Dr. Resident comes by to sign the papers. Says a few words to the patient, and then the nurse says she is calling for transport. Dr. Resident now perks up and says, “Oh why don’t I just take him downstairs since I’ve got a few minutes of downtime and am headed to the cafeteria.”</em></p><p><em>Nurse nods her head, sure, that’s fine, and Dr. Resident wheels him down. They can have a convo en route, she may then give him a few parting words as they reach the door,, and then patient disappears out the glass doors and the doctor watches. And no tears please — instead, maybe a sad look knowing that he is not going to be following instructions. Then she looks at her watch or phone and hurries off to the cafeteria.</em></p><p>Now that is a far more appropriate ending that includes the doctor but gives a realistic reason why she would be escorting a patient to the front door. And no teary farewells, please.</p><p><em>Authors, screen writers, journalists — it is possible to make your work accurate and entertaining, and keep the public’s interest, and without resorting to silly plot lines and unrealistic depictions of healthcare. Stay tuned to Medscript Owl — more to come to help you make your writing realistic, plausible, without sacrificing quality or putting your readers to sleep.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4910b75eecf1" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Dr X]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@roxannenelson/dr-x-2f983a16540c?source=rss-546ab5a5605------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2f983a16540c</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Roxanne Nelson]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 23 Mar 2023 18:09:59 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-04-09T21:33:22.151Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>Dr X</strong></p><p><em>“If I ever hear you describe a patient as “terminal” again, that’s how you’ll describe your career!”</em></p><p><em>Dr. Jack MacKee, from the movie “The Doctor”</em></p><p>My parents didn’t have an extensive library of books when I was growing up, as the apartment we lived in was rather small and cramped. But there was a big stack of old Readers Digest Condensed books, and being the voracious reader that I was, I devoured the entire pile. One book stands out clearly in my mind: <strong>Intern by Doctor X</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/350/1*oagNl2Z2bkW5d-wHNeyxyA.jpeg" /></figure><p>The title and author was written in bold black letters, making it look all the more ominous and forbidding. Who was Dr. X, I wondered, and why was his identity hidden? I was only about 11 or 12 at the time, so didn’t quite get the need for privacy or the intimate nature of this memoir. The book is a week-by-week diary of a young doctor during his year of hospital internship, and according to some reviews, it is the “first inside account of modern medical and hospital practice.” Nowadays, this is nothing novel. Memoirs of all stripes have been published by physicians and nurses and everyone in between, and the secret life of healthcare professionals laid bare for all to see. But this book was a fresh new concept back in the day, and somewhat shocking for its honesty and candid “no holds” look at the grueling life of an intern. Published in 1965, Dr X completed his internship year sometime in the early-mid 1950s.</p><p><em>And if there is a single dread that haunts doctors even after years of practice, it is the dread of misjudging a situation because of anger, irritation, laziness or selfishness….Dr X</em></p><p>While medicine has certainly changed since the 1950s, that one line continues to hold true. Misjudging a situation can mean a serious misdiagnosis or even a person’s life. Its quite a burden to carry around and can weigh heavy on your soul for the rest of your life.</p><p>Memoirs are more difficult when it comes to validating accuracy. TV shows, movies, novels — are all fiction, and even if liberties are taken and the information presented completely inaccurate, it’s still considered fiction. But the reason I’m mentioning memoirs now is to get them out of the way, so to speak. This genre of literature has become immensely popular, and the more scandalous, the better. Teachers, prison officers, midwives, soldiers, lawyers, doctors, nurses, terminally ill patients who were cured by unconventional means, people with abusive childhoods, royalty who have an axe to grind (think Prince Harry), and really, just about anyone under the sun who wants to share some segment of a life lived.</p><p>The problem with memoirs is that they can be very hard to authenticate, and many have fallen under scrutiny, been challenged and even debunked — in part at least. It can be especially telling when the memoirist refuses to release supporting information, such as in the case of undergoing a miraculous recovery. I can’t recall the name of this book or the author, but it was one of the early “return from the dead,” stories, which she wrote a detailed account of her time in heaven. Or wherever it was that her soul traveled to during her cardiac arrest. I would have liked to believe her, as some of the experiences described by people who have had near death experiences are eerily similar, and certainly, I am curious what happens to the soul when you’ve died and then been revived.</p><p>But in this case, the woman was featured on some television program, and one of the skeptics debunking her story said that she refused to allow her medical records to be released. That is a red flag for me right then and there. Why refuse if this really happened? It’s just fact checking. What also convinced me that perhaps this was a fantasy story was the description of her near death experience. According to the author, her soul rose out of her body and hovered above, and she was able to witness her alleged resuscitation — which didn’t sound particularly like your run of the mill code blue. She claimed that she started hemorrhaging post surgery, and that was the reason she died. Well, if a post op patient is gushing blood, the surgery would be buzzed stat, and she would be taken back to surgery asap. But she didn’t even mention a doctor being there — no CPR, nothing more than “the nurse gave me an injection.” No, no injections. An IV line would be stuck into her pronto, someone would be pounding her chest, and again, she would have been sent back to surgery. The clincher was that the next day her doctor asked her “what happened” and that he heard she had a hard time last night. Really? No, the doctor tells the patient what happened. Even the dumbest TV show doesn’t get it that wrong.</p><p>Another memoir that has gotten its fair share of challenges despite its popularity is <em>Educated, by Tara Westover.</em> Her family disputes her accounts of many of the incidents, and others question the authenticity of other parts of the book. While not a medical memoir, it seems that her family experienced a stream of never ending horrific accidents — each one worse than the other. By all accounts, at least some of the family — if not all — should be dead, disfigured, crippled, brain damaged, or all of the above. But for each horribly gruesome incident, which includes third degree burns where all skin melted off her father’s face, a hole in her brother’s head so deep you could see his brain, life threatening injuries from car crashes, a burn so deep that it exposed the bone — you get the idea. Yet they shun doctors and hospitals, all injuries and wounds heal with the magic oils her mother whips up (which turned into a multi-million dollar business), and everyone emerges unscathed. No infections, dehydration, lost limbs — -and since they didn’t seek hospital care, there are no medical records that could be checked. So in this case, its up to readers to decide if they want to take a leap of faith, or not.</p><p>As for memoirs penned by doctors and nurses, I would say that most are probably authentic, but you have to allow for how memory serves you. If a doctor writes about his internship that took place 50 years ago, it can be difficult to recall the exact incidents, or conversations, or if the situation really happened as he remembers. Its not lying per se if memories get bungled, but herein lies one of the problems with memoirs. How real are your memories? I often take issue with a memoir, for example, where the author recounts a conversation with grandma that occurred at age 3 — when the author is now 50 years old.</p><p>Plus in medicine, as with other memoirs, there is always the danger of lawsuits. People mentioned in your story may not take kindly to it, and so sue for defamation of character. This is another drawback and some authors have admitted to creating composites of people to hide identities, or fudging it in other ways — to conceal as much as possible so as not to violate another person’s privacy. But if you are writing about your own experiences, and unless you were living by yourself in a cave, other people are involved.</p><p>Which brings me back to Dr X. What is somewhat unique about his book is that it really is just an old-fashioned blog. He recorded his activities right after the fact, creating a verbal diary, and his wife transcribed it. So his memories were written in real time, and even though a decade passed between the experience and publication, the story did not rely on memory. Since it was published anonymously, without anyone knowing who he was or where he had done the internship, disguising identities was easier, and he made less of an attempt to sanitize some of the incidents, and worried less about hurting the feelings of colleagues, or exposing errors that were made.</p><p>Medical blogs can be seen as memoirs in the making, and if the writer is identified, far more open to scrutiny and authenticity checks. Many are not however, and are penned (or typed as the case may be) by people as anonymous as Dr X. Anonymity does allow for more freedom in telling your story, same as why people use screen names. This is particularly true if you are blogging about your current job and how badly it sucks, and how abusive it is and what poor care patients get…yes, people have gotten fired for that, although some have successfully sued in the aftermath.</p><p>The bottom line is that blogs and memoirs can offer a fascinating inside look at healthcare, seen through the eyes of one who is personally entwined with the system. They can be exhilarating, sad, frightening, joyful, hopeful, tedious or terrifying. I am not going to be focusing too much on memoirs or blogs in the articles to come, given their personal nature, and I don’t want to accuse someone of lying. That said, if something comes up that is so blatantly crazy or off the wall — like if a doctor posts today that he performed the first heart transplant — well yeah, he’s delusional or just trying to get clicks. But that said, I will offer tips along the way, as to how to keep your memoir authentic while maintaining the privacy of those you write about. Some memoirists have circumvented that problem by allowing the people presented to read the manuscript, and that nips any problems in the bud. Another way of keeping it real is to start a blog or a diary, if you think that a memoir is in your future. Recording events in real time is a lot easier than scouring your memory for facts and figures.</p><p>And as for Dr. X, he is no longer a mystery. Thanks to the internet, Dr. X has been outed as Dr. Alan Nourse, who did his internship at Virginia Mason Medical Center in Seattle. It is a bit of a coincidence, since I now live in the area and am very familiar with the hospital. Things come full circle. Dr. Nourse had a relatively short career in medicine and turned his skills to writing. He became a renowned juvenile sci-fi writer and longtime health columnist for Good Housekeeping. He passed away in 1992, at age 64.</p><p><em>Authors, screen writers, journalists — it is possible to make your work accurate and entertaining, and keep the public’s interest, and without resorting to silly plot lines and unrealistic depictions of healthcare. Stay tuned to Medscript Owl — more to come to help you make your writing realistic, plausible, without sacrificing quality or putting your readers to sleep.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2f983a16540c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Dr TV]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@roxannenelson/dr-tv-4d9d48c5437?source=rss-546ab5a5605------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4d9d48c5437</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Roxanne Nelson]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 20 Mar 2023 20:35:43 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-04-09T21:29:26.921Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/512/1*hxUTdAbxObt8E7zZv7oIlw.jpeg" /></figure><p>Several years ago, after my stepfather was admitted to the ICU with an aneurysm, I asked my mother how he was doing. She had just come home from visiting him at the hospital and I figured she could giv me a quick update. I couldn’t go visit myself, as I lived on the opposite end of the continent.</p><p>But in response to my question, she said that she didn’t know.</p><p><em>Me: Weren’t you just at the hospital?</em></p><p><em>Mom: Well yeah, and he seemed okay.</em></p><p><em>Me: Didn’t you talk to anyone?</em></p><p><em>Mom: No</em></p><p><em>Me: You didn’t? Why not?</em></p><p><em>Mom: There was no one there to talk to.</em></p><p><em>Me (now getting a little agitated): What do you mean, no one to talk to. It’s an ICU!</em></p><p><em>Mom: Well the doc-tah (with Brooklyn accent) wasn’t there.</em></p><p><em>Me: Weren’t there any nurses around? (I’m an RN)</em></p><p><em>Mom: Uh yeah. I guess.</em></p><p><em>Me: Well didn’t you think to ask one of them how he was doing?</em></p><p><em>Mom: (pause for several minutes). Would they know?</em></p><p>No, of course not. Nurses are just for show. They wander around the unit wearing cute little scrubs and spend the shift looking for a date with a hottie doc-tah, and maybe answer the telephone. Now, in all fairness, my mother was never the sharpest knife in the drawer and sometimes you did have to wonder if she was orbiting earth or somewhere beyond, but she had been in a hospital before. She did have some awareness of the different types of people who worked in healthcare, and certainly, she did talk to nurses during doctor’s appointments. But when it came to a source of information, the only word that sprang to her mind was DOCTOR.</p><p>She was truly stunned when I told her that his nurse could answer all of her questions, and tell her exactly what was going on. What surprised her, however, was the absence of a doctor in the unit. This was not a teaching hospital, so residents and medical students weren’t swarming around. But she somehow expected that there would be an MD hanging out 24/7, ready to answer any and all questions on the patient.</p><p>So where does this myth come from, that an MD is the only one who knows anything, and is always available, and everyone else is just there for menial work and window dressing? My mother knew I worked in the NICU, but I don’t think she really had a clue what that meant. No matter what I told her, she was always asking if she could call me at work since she knew I’d be there (she couldn’t stand it if I didn’t answer the phone when she called or voice mail picked up), and insinuated that I had plenty of time to sit and chitchat while I took endless coffee breaks and watched daytime soaps in the lounge (isn’t that what they do on TV?).</p><p>My mother regularly saw the PA — physician’s assistant — at her primary care physician’s office, so she was well aware that such “people” existed. He wasn’t a doctor and I never heard her complain about him, and she knew that he did doctor stuff including prescriptions and that she could ask him questions related to her health.</p><p>My mother aside, I blame the media for spinning the medical world into some bizarre fantasy realm, and often so far removed from reality that it may as well be classified as sci fi or magical realism. Let’s take a quick look at how physicians are often portrayed on TV and movies. For starters, they seem to possess powers beyond the scope of mere mortals. They are supernatural and put Superman and Batman to shame. In the course of a work day, Dr. TV will be in his office diagnosing a patient, then rush off to see a patient in the emergency room, and then admit her to the hospital. Then Dr. TV will be reading the CT scan images (which are ready within seconds) and then rushes her up to surgery. He then pulls on his sterile gloves, enters the operating room where she is already lying on the table prepped and ready to go, and prepares to cut. After that, Dr. TV will appear at the bedside of yet a different patient, changing the IV tubing and doing a urinary catheterization, and then is called to deliver a baby that is popping out back in the emergency room. And in between, Dr TV will somehow find the time to spend hours by the bedside of multiple patients, and have long, emotional conversations with them about death, life, their last breakup, and the high cost of potatoes. And why eating daily at MacDonald’s is not good for their waistline.</p><p>Well okay…</p><p>Despite the fact that they claim to have medical advisers, Hollywood doesn’t understand just how specialized the medical field is. And even that’s a stretch. The tasks mentioned above would be spread among a handful of specialists and other health care professionals. Nurses change IV lines and put in catheters, not doctors. A “jack of all trades” doctor is an imaginary superhero, one who can manage to run a practice, work in the ER, be trained as a radiologist, and also do surgery. The only physician who might come close would be working in a rural 5 bed hospital, and be the only MD for miles around. And even then, the patient would probably be airlifted to a larger facility if the needed surgery was more than stitching up a wound or removing a mole, and the scans sent by computer to a radiologist at a medical center to read and analyze.</p><p>In reality, hospital life, despite the fascinating and intriguing world that’s created in the media, is generally quite boring. It can be stressful, tedious, sad, fulfilling, and mundane. Following a real doctor around would put the audience to sleep, as most of their time is spent sitting in front of a computer getting the never ending paper work completed. Most of the tasks performed by TV doctors are done by other personnel, including nurses, lab and a sundry number of techs, pharmacists, chaplains, and housekeeping. Hollywood storylines are designed to be entertaining and suspenseful — laced with drama and romance — usually at the expense of reality.</p><p>Entertainment trumps realism, I get it, but this also extends to books. Authors have far more leeway to do research and make a story factual rather than relying on ignorance and stupidity to move a plot forward. I will point to examples in future articles, but case in point — in one popular novel, a girl has been involuntarily committed to a mental hospital, and the staff is trying to force her to swallow pills to sedate her. She spits them out and then trains herself to throw them up. Finally the staff gives up and medication is no longer required. Hmmm…..in the author’s dreams, perhaps. Apparently, the author has never heard of injections, and didn’t bother to do an iota of research. An agitated patient would never be given an oral medicine. Injection only until she became compliant. Since this scene also had little to do with the story, and in fact, could have been left out of the book entirely, there was no reason for this level of ignorance.</p><p>In a book, there aren’t any budget restraints on hiring actors, so you can populate your story with real healthcare folks. Like having the phlebotomist draw blood and not the jack of all trades doctor. You can also allow for time lapses, such as making a CPR sequence real (tried for an hour to revive a patient) as opposed to TV where the chest is smacked once and they give up. You can add in back stories, allow for nuances, and make the scenario as realistic as possible. Some story lines are built on silliness and the stupidity of characters, whether its medicine or another subject — I see it as laziness on the part of the author.</p><p>The same thing can be done with other media. TV shows can be just as entertaining but made more realistic. The stupidity factor can be removed or at least minimized. Someone can do research. It’s not that difficult.</p><p>So welcome to Medscript Owl. This is the first of many posts discussing this issue; giving examples of where the media got it wrong, and how to get it right. Whether you’re an author, a journalist, a screen writer, an editor, or a producer, keep reading and check back often. This blog is for you.</p><p><em>Authors, screen writers, journalists — it is possible to make your work accurate and entertaining, and keep the public’s interest, and without resorting to silly plot lines and unrealistic depictions of healthcare. Stay tuned to Medscript Owl. More is coming.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4d9d48c5437" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>