This policy paper analyses Afghanistan’s political transformation since the Taliban’s return to power in August 2021. It highlights the regime’s systematic dismantling of democratic institutions, reversal of human rights progress, and maintenance of exclusionary policies based on ethnic and religious lines.

The severe restrictions on women’s rights and suppression of political dissent present significant challenges to the European Union’s commitment to liberal democratic values in its external relations. These developments carry profound implications for European interests, including security concerns, migration management, and the EU’s support for human rights and democracy.

While no EU member state has formally recognised the Taliban regime, European institutions maintain a limited diplomatic presence in Afghanistan primarily to facilitate humanitarian operations. The EU remains a significant humanitarian donor, assisting UN agencies and international NGOs.

The paper recommends an EU strategic engagement with Afghanist an centered on five key pillars:

1. Foster Inclusive Governance through EU Diplomatic Leverage — Establish clear benchmarks for Taliban engagement with non- Pashtun ethnic groups, women, and civil society as preconditions for increased European diplomatic interaction.
2. Condition EU Engagement on Human Rights Benchmarks — Maintain non-recognition until specific human rights improvements are demonstrated while developing a graduated framework of incentives tied to measurable progress.
3. Support Economic Stability through European Development Frameworks — Continue humanitarian assistance while developing innovative financial mechanisms that allow for basic service provision without Taliban control of funds.
4. Empower Afghanistan’s Civil Society with European Support Mechanisms — Create dedicated funding streams and visa pathways for at-risk human rights defenders, journalists, Hazara activists and women’s rights activists.
5. Utilise EU Legal and Accountability Instruments — Support legal initiatives at international courts while documenting human rights abuses for potential future prosecutions. Implementation requires coordinated action across EU institutions. The European Council, Commission, Parliament, and External Action Service should each have clearly defined roles. This collaborative approach balances the EU’s commitment to human rights and democracy with pragmatic engagement on security and humanitarian issues in Afghanistan.

• Download Chapter

Abstract

This paper examines China’s involvement in Afghanistan’s peace process from 2014 to 2021, a period marked by significant regional transformations. As the United States withdrew, China’s engagement intensified, driven by strategic interests in maintaining stability, fostering its economic interests, and addressing security concerns posed by groups such as the East Turkestan Islamic Movement (ETIM). While initial optimism prevailed, China’s mediation efforts ultimately proved unsuccessful. A content analysis of Chinese Embassy communications from 2011 to 2021 sheds light on China’s approach to peace in Afghanistan. The findings reveal China’s persistent reliance on facilitating talks between the Taliban and the Afghan government and on reducing tensions between the Afghan and Pakistani governments. Hindered by its reliance on Pakistan and the Taliban’s evasion of negotiations, China lacked the leverage needed to mediate effectively, highlighting the complexities of its role in the region. This paper contributes to our understanding of the limits of China’s diplomacy and the challenges faced by external actors in volatile regions such as Afghanistan.