<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Ryan Lindauer on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Ryan Lindauer on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@ryanlindauer?source=rss-bba799de9783------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sun, 22 Nov 2026 00:43:35 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@ryanlindauer/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Gaslight Year: A Season Four Retrospective]]></title>
            <link>https://ryanlindauer.medium.com/the-gaslight-year-a-season-four-retrospective-b7516005eb98?source=rss-bba799de9783------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b7516005eb98</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[television]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[community]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ryan Lindauer]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 22 Feb 2021 22:38:36 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-02-23T06:01:55.514Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/600/1*BUZDSnJ_afVexGR6ZrnHEw.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>Community </em>is one of the best television shows ever made, and since it’s availability on Netflix, its fanbase has been in an almost consistent state of expansion. With the perfect blend of self-awareness, cynicism, and sentimentality, it serves as a breath of fresh air for anyone fed-up with the tedium and predictability of network sitcoms. Why, then is an honest assessment of it’s entirety so hard to come by? Why do it’s most vocal fans seem to hate it (or at least parts of it) as much as they love it? Ask one of these vocal fans, and the same culprit will be named every single time: season four. Some will say the show died when Dan Harmon was fired at the conclusion of season three, and others will claim that his rehiring before season five brought it back to life — but the common ground of the sheepish <em>Community </em>fan will always be trashing season four (“The gas leak year,” as Harmon retroactively scripted it).</p><p>Oddly, just about every critique of season four ignores both the core reason for Dan Harmon’s firing and the actual origins of the ever-popular criticism of season four. While blasting the network for firing Harmon, none of these critics are willing to acknowledge that he was fired, at least in large part, for what he did to Megan Ganz. Throughout the writing of seasons two and three, Harmon sexually harassed Megan Ganz to the extend that, by her own admission, it took her years to believe in her own writing or trust that praise from her male co-workers/employers was rooted in sincerity rather than toxic impulses. Five years after the fact, however, Harmon delivered what even Ganz described as a master-class apology, and his predatory past has been all but forgotten — save the influence it retains over fans’ collective perceptions of when and why the quality of <em>Community</em> dropped off. That is to say, Harmon’s desire to paint his dismissal as unjustified led to a relentless effort on his part to retcon the episodes written in his absence by his victim and those who stood by her and the show (rather than him) as unwatchable, and a slew of fans have aped his baseless critiques with very little regard for consistency of logic or decency of motivation.</p><p>After being fired and watching his creation carry on without him and with the survivor or his abuse remaining a key component of the <em>Community </em>writing staff, Harmon described his feelings toward the experience by stringing together a series of words that could only be seen as trivializing rape. This might have been held against him, but he apologized yet again, so he was forgiven yet again — despite his apology being laden with sarcasm. To be clear, the former apology appears to have been heartfelt and may well have catalyzed something of an evolution within Harmon’s views toward women, but his apology covered only his conduct toward Ganz when they were working together — not his retroactive gaslighting after being rehired before the start of season five (at which time Ganz left to join the <em>Modern Family</em> team). While devoting an entire episode of his podcast to the subject several years after the harassment and temporary firing occurred, he failed to address his repeated attempts to denigrate the work of his victim and her supporters while he was in #timesup time-out. Never did he come anywhere close to acknowledging the high quality of the writing Ganz was able produce in his absence — simply continuing to refer to her solo time as “the gas leak year” in a transparent attempt to convince fans that firing him was worse than the things he did to force NBC into firing him. Just about every time he has spoken about the show publicly since his rehiring, he has used the opportunity to negatively reshape the public perception of season four. This could be seen as pure hubris, had season four not been written by the primary victim of the behavior for which he was fired, and had he not used arguments against season four which actually apply much more correctly — if at all — to the seasons for which he was responsible. He owned up to the first portion of his mistreatment of Ganz five years after the fact, but he consistently doubles down on the second phase of abuse which began the moment he was fired and shows no signs of commencing without his impetus.</p><p>Few modern television fanbases can hold a candle to the level of toxicity displayed by those of <em>Rick &amp; Morty</em>, and perhaps the purest display of this was said fanbase’s reaction to the show hiring its first female writers before the beginning of season three. No one saw it as problematic that there were no female writers involved in a show with no compelling female characters and an alarming number of rape jokes, but the hiring of a few female writers prompted a literally criminal level of outrage among <em>Rick &amp; Morty</em>’s online fanbase. Every possible form of hate speech was levied against the new writers, and most of these angry fans insisted that the show would never be the same; that season three was noticeably worse than the first two — many of them posing their comments before the episodes aired. Harmon himself has clarified his position on these fans, declaring that he resents being the conduit of the furtherment of the “creepy agenda” being pushed by angry white men online — but only after several of the newly-hired female writers were doxed by rabid <em>Rick &amp; Morty </em>fans, and apparently only in reference to these fans’ toxicity in this specific instance. When the creepy agenda came for <em>Community’s </em>season four, after all, he never shied away from leading the parade — even scripting the penultimate joke of the series to be a fart joke when season four is referenced.</p><p>A cursory glance at the <em>Community </em>and <em>Rick &amp; Morty </em>fanbases reveals a significant degree of overlap, and with such a large portion of <em>Rick &amp; Morty</em> fans showing a clear willingness to misrepresent the quality of an entire season of their self-professed favorite show for the purpose of maintaining their preexisting chauvinistic worldview, it’s not hard to see why an honest assessment of <em>Community</em>’s season four (which, again, saw Harmon absent and the victim of his sexual predation retained on the writing staff) is so hard to come by. Still, it’s possible for legitimate argument against season four to exist independent of Harmon’s toxic fanboys, and each purported reason why season four doesn’t live up to the rest is worthy of analysis:</p><p><strong>All the good <em>Community </em>writers left with Harmon after season three</strong></p><p>Dan Harmon is an excellent comedy writer, but unless he’s won an Academy Award for his screenwriting skills or gone on to write key episodes for <em>Modern Family</em> and <em>It’s Always Sunny in Philadelphia</em>, believing that he is the best comedy writer to ever grace <em>Community</em>’s pages is quite a stretch; professing that there were no good writers on staff for season four is downright nonsensical. Season four sees Jim Rash (Dean Pelton, and Oscar-winning writer of <em>The Descendants</em>) finally being given the greenlight to write an episode, the end result of which being as much emotional maturity and character growth than anything featured in any twenty-three minute span of the first three seasons — not to mention the most honestly homoerotic moment in Troy and Abed’s time together. “The Gas Leak Year” also features arguably the most accomplished comedy TV writer of the past decade — Megan Ganz — finally being able to create free from the burden of constant sexual harassment from her employer. The fruit of Ganz’ labor ultimately results in utter hilarity, <em>Community</em>-style creative leaps, and legitimate growth for all seven study group members. Unfortunately, Harmon’s attempt to direct his followers’ angst toward Rash and Ganz’ work has been successful enough to make an honest, unbiased analysis of their contributions seem like a contrarian take.</p><p><strong>Even <em>Community </em>seasons five and six mock the fourth season’s quality</strong></p><p>It would probably be easier to ethically and logically make the case against season four were this argument never made possible. Seasons five and six saw Harmon back at the helm, and his non-stop efforts to use his private platforms as well as the characters on the show to mock the quality of season four led every fan with a “creepy agenda” of their own to follow-suit. Hating on season four became the flavor of the week through which toxic Reddit and Twitter users could filter their disdain for “cancel culture” and the “P.C. police,” and it has neither stopped nor gained any legitimacy as a merit-based argument since. It was, of course, the same fans Harmon professed to hate who forwarded his season four propaganda —to believe that the doxing of female <em>Rick &amp; Morty</em> writers and the persistent trolling of season four at Harmon’s behest were perpetuated by completely separate subgroups of <em>Community </em>is to effectively purchase oceanfront property in Nebraska. When the doxing happened — coupled with countless comments invoking sexual assault — Harmon spoke out forcefully against it. When season four was released, however, it was Harmon himself who stated that watching it felt like “being held down and watching your family get raped on a beach.” He would, of course, later apologize and at times even acknowledge the high quality of season four’s concepts and comedy, but fanboys have never being willing to acknowledge and abide by their deities’ apologies. Furthermore, his return to the show and consistent bashing of season four shows a fairly distinct reversal of said apology, and a return to the petty, self-obsessed mindset that led him to invoke sexual assault in his own defense. Toxic men helping a powerful man remain in power both practically and narratively after he forfeits his right to it through criminal sexual behavior appears to be something Harmon can indeed get behind, but only if the subject of said assistance is Dan Harmon.</p><p><strong>Bill Murray, not James Brolin, should have played William Winger</strong></p><p>Should one be seeking to catch Community Stans red-handed in their pursuit of blindly defending a one-time sexual predator, they need look no further than said Stans’ consistently-professed belief that Bill Murray was the only person who should have played Jeff Winger’s long-estranged father. This collective outrage is rooted exclusively in Dan Harmon’s professed desire for Murray to have played the role, and the propensity of this belief quite clearly exemplifies the nature of most season four criticisms: rooted in the cult of personality (and a rebuke of women’s empowerment), rather than any sort of logic or pursuit of evidentiary criticism. James Brolin played the role to near-perfection, and it’s hard to imagine Murray matching the levels of chemistry and believability Brolin achieved with on-screen son Joel McHale. After watching Jeff Winger repeatedly tease addressing his Daddy issues for three seasons, season four delivers the payoff and closure the character deserved in an honest, heartfelt fashion with a pair of episodes that were quite well reviewed by fans and critics alike at the time — before Dan Harmon was rehired and made it his mission to convince the world that he was absolutely essential to the creation of quality <em>Community</em> episodes, and that anything created in his absence is barely worthy of being considered canon.</p><p><strong>The Britta/Troy romance doesn’t work</strong></p><p>It’s not supposed to. And perhaps more importantly, the Britta/Troy romance is methodically and tediously hinted at throughout the first three seasons — much like Jeff’s Daddy issues — until finally being addressed head on in season four, and given proper closure so the characters can finally move on and show real growth. Teasing this romance in the first place was a mistake, one made by Harmon, not the season four writers; not delivering progress and closure at any point in the first three seasons was an even bigger mistake, but also can’t be laid at the feet of season four. The only reason to decry season four writers for a perceived mismanagement of the Britta/Troy romance is if one’s desire was to either see them stay together or continue to repeatedly tease a potential romance that never arrives — as it was the season four writers who allowed the relationship to play out, and it was the season four writers who ended it. Anyone who dislikes Britta and Troy dating should be thanking the season four writers, and wondering why Harmon insisted on pushing this awkward plot, while simultaneously doing nothing with it, for the show’s first three seasons.</p><p><strong>The Annie/Jeff plot gets downright weird</strong></p><p>This frequently-peddled explanation is roughly the equivalent of watching the first three quarters of a football game played with helmets on, and the fourth quarter without — then waiting until the two-minute warning to observe that football is a violent game. The Annie/Jeff plot was downright weird from the moment it emerged in season one; that season four finally lets it be seen for what it is should be commended, not derided. Especially when one considers Dan Harmon’s potential motivation for consistently pushing Annie and Jeff’s odd sexual tension— almost always initiated by Annie, the brilliant young student taken under Jeff’s wing. Harmon has made no secret that Jeff Winger is largely written from a biographical lens, and it’s difficult to ignore the parallels in timing between Megan Ganz being brought on as a Community writer and Annie’s character devolving into what appears quite clearly to have been Harmon’s personally-objectified fantasy-version of Ganz. Before Ganz joined the staff, Annie floated between crushing on Troy and their troubadour-classmate Vaughn; once season two hits, Annie is either fixated on Jeff or completely deromanticized. Jeff rarely behaves inappropriately towards Annie, typically rebuffing her flirtations. Both Ganz and Harmon have confirmed that in real life, Harmon was fixated on Ganz, and she consistently denied his advances but was met with more inappropriate behavior. Were this a veiled fantasy on Harmon’s part, it was very well-crafted; in any case, it lingers for two seasons until season four allows it to spiral to a level of absurdity that should have allowed the season five writers to move on entirely — but once Harmon was back, so was Annie’s innocent infatuation. In seasons one through three, Annie operates as a creepy guy’s fantasy; a pretty, young, sexually-inexperienced go-getter who — despite consistently seeking to better herself — for some inexplicable reason can’t shake her giggly infatuation for the older, dumber Jeff Winger, who makes no secret of his belief that the women in his life are mere objects whose exclusive purposes are to serve his needs. Season four finally allows viewers to see this plotline for what it is: lazy at best, and creepy wish-fulfillment at worst. It is a thing of beauty, the outright clarification that the Annie/Jeff plotline was creepy to begin with, but it predictably felt out of step with viewers who didn’t enjoy being forced to that conclusion. Much the way a helmetless fourth quarter of football would seem surprisingly violent to anyone capable of convincing themselves that the first three helmeted quarters were somehow completely nonviolent.</p><p><strong>Season four just doesn’t feel the same as the rest of the seasons</strong></p><p>This point is a bit more difficult to deconstruct, since the show in question began its run by featuring a Halloween and Christmas episode every season until this trend was indeed abruptly halted. Likewise, the cast remained constant through the opening seasons until suffering a series of losses — culminating in only four of the original seven study-group members remaining. And then there’s the study group no longer taking a class together, thus ceasing to be an actual study group. These changes certainly make the assertion of a change in feel seem understandable, and such critiques would indeed be on point — if they were levied against season five, when each aforementioned change occurs. Season four features a great Halloween episode, a solid Christmas episode, and the series’ only Thanksgiving episode — season five breaks entirely with the <em>Community </em>holiday tradition. Season four saw the entire cast in tact, while Harmon’s return for season five was swiftly followed by the departures of Chevy Chase and Donald Glover; followed soon thereafter by Yvette Nicole Brown. Season four sees the study group taking History 101 together in perfect synchrony with the pattern of <em>Community</em>, while season five sees the group all but disbanded as they pursue hilarity in more independent ventures than featured in previous seasons, as well as seeing each of them magically undo their own personal growth. The only aspect of season four that felt noticeably different at the time — according to critic and fan reviews written then — was the pacing, as the show had only been renewed for 13 episodes after opening with seasons of 24, 25, and 22.</p><p><strong>Season four writers clearly didn’t understand the <em>Community </em>characters</strong></p><p>It would be odd to assert that the study group “clearly didn’t understand” Greendale when they saved it during season five, or that the group only prevented Fat Neil from committing suicide because they “clearly didn’t understand” him. Yet as it pertains to season four, toxic fans are insistent that saving something from destroying itself is a sign that the savior simply didn’t understand the essence of the thing it saved. On the surface, this notion is absurd — but considerably more generous than what would be handed down by an honest analysis of the characters’ season four arcs.</p><p>The first three seasons see Pierce seem to function largely as Dan Harmon’s id, which results in a steady devolution in character marked by increasingly racist, sexist, and homophobic words and actions. This spiral is punctuated by periodic moments of decency, but rarely does he even remotely approach altruism. Community’s inability to flesh Pierce into a complete character was perhaps a result of Dan Harmon’s well-publicized feud with Chevy Chase; the bulk of logic behind this assumption comes from season four, which sees Pierce retain his offensive bitterness while growing into a character who is allowed (by the writers) to show that he actually cares about the others in his study group. In short, he graduates from being the recurring villain to an actual member of the show — being written with the same level of care and respect as the others. In the season four episode “Herstory of Dance,” Chase delivers one of Pierce’s all-time funniest bits when trying to check his e-mail before the post office closes, and closes the episode by imploring Jeff — and the audience — to start viewing and speaking about Britta as if she is a human being with feelings that matter. For whatever reason, the <em>Community </em>writers never thought to make Pierce progress to anything more than a one-dimensional xenophobe until season four, despite the first three seasons consistently hinting at progress being made on this front. Each time the show needed some low-hanging fruit during the opening seasons, it was time for some Chevy. By all accounts, this lazy writing (combined with Chase and Harmon’s incompatible egos )led to a strained relationship that fringed on violent hatred at times. Chase may have had a point about his character being underutilized, but what he didn’t have was any control over what went on in the writers’ room — not the pattern of sexual harassment or the writers’ failure to use his character as anything but a villain or the butt of others’ jokes.</p><p>Much the way Pierce was unable to grow beyond the borders of Dan Harmon’s id until the fourth season, Jeff Wingers stands in as Harmon’s ego throughout the first three seasons, and the character’s season four progression into a more honest, caring friend falls perfectly in line with the season three finale — in which Jeff proclaims “Helping other people is good, and helping only ourselves is bad.” Failing to allow Jeff to show any sort of growth after years of arrogance, apathy, and outright chauvinism led him to this altruistic epiphany would have been in service to the creator, not the character. He is supposed to have learned the value of humility and empathy several times over, but doesn’t show this knowledge in earnest until the fourth season. Jeff admitting to his father that he is crippled by insecurity to the extend that he constantly pretends to be texting to avoid giving his closest friends the satisfaction of his full attention — followed by his admission that, as a child, he faked an appendectomy scar so he could see that people care about him — is the most honest moment viewers receive from the character up until that point, and allowed Jeff to graduate from being another man’s ego to a fully-fleshed man of his own. That it took Harmon five years of contemplation to conclude that it was wrong of him to sexually objectify Megan Ganz does not necessitate the same for Jeff; season four writers should be praised for retaining the trademark Winger cynicism while expanding his emotional maturity to the extent that he is actually able to self-reflect and see the pain cause to others by his actions. Another result of Harmon and his ardent followers leaving the writing room was Jeff becoming considerably less sex-crazed, and he seems to replace his alternating pursuits of Annie and Britta with an earnest — albeit conflicted— desire to become a better person. Through it all, his primary motivation for everything is still graduating as soon as possible, which allows the character to remain himself as he enters his delayed version of adulthood.</p><p>If one were informed only by what the sheepish fans regurgitate about season four, they would likely assume that Troy getting a pet monkey and naming it “Annie’s Boobs,” and dramatically leaving the group to join the Air Conditioner Repair School only to rejoin the group less than a full episode later all must have happened in the fourth season. They are cheap, dumb gags that can’t possibly have come from the genius mind of Dan Harmon…right? And surely Troy nervously rambling about there being “no heat,” confessing that he was about to “eat garbage dip,” and (as Evil Troy) admitting he was out of bullets “to sound intimidating” must <em>not </em>have come from season four. They are enduring moments of hilarity that can only have come from the genius mind of Dan Harmon…right? It should go without saying that none of the dumb gags from the former group are from season four, where the the entire latter group can be found. It should also go without saying that the argument presented by the sheepish fans has no legs left to stand on, and it only loses stability from here.</p><p>Britta and Shirley do feel oddly out-of-step with themselves in season four, but this is only because of the severe regression each of them endures after actually being fleshed out into more complete versions of themselves during the fourth season. After season four implores fans to look at Britta as an actual human being with good intentions, season five reduces her back to a punch-line that viewers don’t need to care about. Describing Britta as “the worst” is thoroughly retired by season four, only to be lazily (and perhaps deliberately) resurrected by Harmon upon his return — a dehumanization toxic twitter found quite refreshing.</p><p>Throughout season four, Shirley not only succeeds a businesswoman after years of scripted incompetence, but she also usurps Annie’s role as “the smart one” by outperforming her academically — all the while maintaining her duties as a wife and mother (save one hiccup at the grocery store). With Troy serving as the consistent bottom of the study group’s intelligence barrel, Shirley’s naivete and religious fervor allow her to be painted as the show’s second-dumbest main character up until season four. When the group enrolls in biology class, though, Shirley — like many religious people exposed to science for the first time — grows. She shows an ability to balance religious faith and practical intelligence which results in her earning valedictorian over Annie (and Leonard); no longer does she serve as a stereotypical dumb religious black woman. Additionally, she balances her personal and professional life with the aplomb displayed every day by real-life do-it-all women of color, leading her sandwich shop to thrive while her family finally remains in tact — no more dead-beat dad stereotypes being regurgitated. Season five undoes literally all of Shirley’s progress with off-screen between-season failures which serve no purpose other than to reduce her to the previously-outgrown stereotypes which defined her throughout the first three seasons. Women of color being portrayed in this manner is a big problem in the industry, and season four’s temporary course correction would surely be celebrated — or at least noticed — by Harmon and the rest of season four’s most vocal critics if it was seen by them as big of a problem as toxic men facing consequences for toxic behavior.</p><p>None of this is to suggest that seasons one, two, three, five, or six are anything short of sublime — simply to remind fans that no logic-based argument exists placing season four below the rest. “Community just isn’t Community without Dan Harmon at the helm” as a serious statement boils down to little more than “There is no Today Show without Matt Lauer” or “Taylor Swift isn’t Taylor Swift without Scooter Braun in control of her music” — both patently absurd notions only made to feel at home among the “creepy agenda” of toxic social media users. “The gas leak year” propaganda campaign was and is a gaslight attempt, plain and simple; one which, if ultimately unsuccessful, can be appreciated as another piece of meta-humor in perhaps the richest comedy television has ever produced. But this appreciation cannot happen as long as Dan Harmon and the general population of <em>Community </em>fans refuse to stand up to the toxic element within the fandom — and dispel the equally toxic myths perpetuated about season four’s quality once and for all.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b7516005eb98" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Does Representation Actually Matter? To/For Whom?]]></title>
            <link>https://ryanlindauer.medium.com/does-representation-actually-matter-to-for-whom-12251ad0d9b4?source=rss-bba799de9783------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/12251ad0d9b4</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[golden-globes]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ia]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[awards]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[movies]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[representation]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ryan Lindauer]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 04 Feb 2021 03:50:21 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-02-04T03:53:18.051Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*PZFTZ2iB6FHMVy59we8J8Q.jpeg" /></figure><p>Amidst what appears to be a perennial state of outrage on Twitter over perceived microaggressions regarding a lack of adequate representation in media, one glaring question presents itself: what are the rules?</p><p>When Sia’s debut film, <em>Music</em>, received a pair of Golden Globe nominations, many on Twitter appeared to have something of a meltdown over the film’s perceived disrespectful treatment of individuals with autism; an especially strange reaction, given that none of them have seen the film. The only people who have seen it — critics who received screeners ahead of it’s February 12 release — collectively decided it was one of the five best comedy/musical films in contention. Yet the Twitter crowd are confident they are in a better position to judge the quality of a film they have not seen than the people who have actually seen it, and they appear to believe that neurotypical Maddie Ziegler’s casting as an autistic teenager is the most offensive silver-screen occurrence since Mickey Rooney in <em>Breakfast at Tiffany’s</em>. So, for the benefit of these self-described empaths, it seems appropriate to comb through the entire list of nominees to make sure there aren’t any other offensive lapses in representation — and to make sure that this is actually about representation, rather than the opportunity to bully an artist in the hopes of silencing her.</p><p>In <em>Sound of Metal</em>, Riz Ahmed plays a character who slowly loses his hearing, yet Ahmed admittedly is not even a little bit deaf. Sure, he immersed himself with “deaf culture,” but so did Sia and Ziegler with autism, and Twitter made it clear that this was not adequate. There are plenty of deaf actors, yet they were all passed over for the lead in <em>Sound of Metal</em>. If representation matters, we can expect to see Ahmed’s nomination to be resoundingly criticized.</p><p><em>The Father </em>sees Anthony Hopkins depict a man named Anthony who is suffering from creeping dementia. While the producers did at least have the decency to cast an actor with the correct name, Hopkins has repeatedly asserted that his mind is still sharp at 83 with no signs of dementia. There are plenty of aging actors who actually do have dementia, and every single one of them were tossed aside so this role could be given to Hopkins. The film shows great respect for the issue being addressed, but by all accounts so does Sia’s film, and <em>The Father</em>’s casting conundrum is virtually a carbon-copy of hers. If representation matters, the Woke Mafia will work their fingers until they turn Hopkins’ nomination into the greatest controversy of his illustrious career.</p><p>French-Algerian Tahar Rahim’s nomination for <em>The Mauritanian </em>speaks for itself. There are plenty of Mauritanian actors who could have played Mohamedou Ould Salahi, yet the Mauritanian people were deemed unworthy of legitimate on-screen representation. If they mean what they say and aren’t just out there bullying women for the sake of it, anyone who levied even the slightest criticism of Sia’s creative choices will be making it know that they are not okay with a French-Algerian pretending to be a Mauritanian.</p><p>Likewise, <em>Borat Subsequent Moviefilm </em>sees British Sacha Baron Cohen and Bulgarian Maria Bakalova play a Kazakhstani father and daughter. Again, the offensive nature of this casting is relatively obvious — there are quite a few Kazakhstani actors and actresses, and even more Kazakhstani children who might benefit from seeing themselves represented in a more accurate manner.</p><p><em>Hillbilly Elegy </em>is a movie about poor people from Appalachia. Glenn Close is a fantastic actress, but she is also from Greenwich, Connecticut, and has never spent a day of her life in poverty. The producers could have pursued representation by choosing an actress from Appalachia, or an actress who had personally experienced poverty, but they did neither. It would be difficult to imagine a world in which Twitter mobs see her nomination as acceptable.</p><p>Jodie Comer and Nicolas Hoult are British; Elle Fanning is American. Peter III<em> </em>and Catherine the Great — as well as Villanelle from <em>Killing Eve — </em>are all distinctly Russian. That Russians are predominantly white does not preclude the fact that Russian characters in film and television are portrayed by non-Russian actors at an alarming rate, nor does it diminish its problematic nature. This trend is perhaps best exemplified by <em>The Great</em>’s predictable participation in the trend of completely “west-washing” in their effort to dramatize a very important period in Russian history. If one truly cares about representation in film and television, these nomination surely doesn’t sit well.</p><p>In <em>Ma Rainey’s Black Bottom</em>, Viola Davis plays an obese blues singer — and while her performance shines, it is worth noting that she wore a fat-suit and did not actually sing in the film. She did gain a nominal amount of weight, but there are plenty of full-figured actresses who could have played Ma Rainey without the indignity of wearing a fat-suit. Obese actresses of color are among the most marginalized and underrepresented in Hollywood, and Viola Davis is not one of them. There are quite a few heavy-set black actresses who surely would have done Ma Rainey justice had they been given the chance, and if representation actually matters, Viola Davis’ nomination will not be met with any semblance of open arms as far as the Woke Mafia is concerned.</p><p>James Corden’s “gay for pay” turn in <em>The Prom</em> has garnered significant Twitter criticism from those who believe gay characters should be played exclusively by gay actors. If these self-professed representation-advocates believe deaf people, victims of dementia, Mauritanians, Kazakhstanis, Appalachians, poor people, Russians, or heavy-set women of color are deserving of the same respect will be dictated by their outrage — or absence thereof — regarding the aforementioned Globe-nominated performances.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=12251ad0d9b4" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Oscar Thoughts…1.10.21]]></title>
            <link>https://ryanlindauer.medium.com/oscar-thoughts-1-10-21-9bf63324975a?source=rss-bba799de9783------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9bf63324975a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[movies]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[academy-awards]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[oscars]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ryan Lindauer]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 10 Jan 2021 18:51:50 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-01-11T05:33:33.833Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/736/1*mzYMIVd_VLWwiWJIl-spEg.jpeg" /></figure><p>First and foremost, a quick rewind…</p><p>With 1980’s <em>Raging Bull</em> and 1990’s <em>Goodfellas</em>, Martin Scorsese firmly bookended the 1980s in film — after spending the preceding decade establishing himself as perhaps the hottest hand in a town blossoming with sharpshooters. The Academy’s refusal to honor him with Best Picture or Best Director for either film is among their most striking retrospective failures, even taking into account the innumerable oversights resulting from voters’ historical biases regarding race, gender, orientation, and nationality.</p><p>Fast-forward to 2020 and history has repeated itself to an almost absurd degree, with the preceding decade’s most astonishing Academy error in the categories of Picture and Director coming in its very first year when voters took the bait that was <em>The King’s Speech </em>— seemingly unaware that in ten years time popular opinion would hold <em>The Social Network</em> as a firm “Best of the Decade” contender among cinephiles and casual moviegoers alike, with <em>The King’s Speech</em> relegated to the ever-growing list of movies whose most noteworthy attribute is being an undeserving Best Picture winner. The real shame here is that <em>The King’s Speech</em> is a perfectly fine movie that should be regarded without the forcible distraction of it being placed on a mantle where it doesn’t belong. <em>Driving Miss Daisy</em>, <em>Dances with Wolves</em>, <em>Shakespeare in Love</em>, <em>Chicago</em>, <em>The Artist</em>, <em>Spotlight</em>, and <em>Green Book</em> are all well-crafted movies that should be appreciated and enjoyed as such — but instead they have had each of their legacies diminished by receiving the Academy’s highest honor despite it being plainly obvious that honor was undeserved. Simply put, <em>Nomadland</em>, <em>The Trial of the Chicago Seven</em>, and <em>Ma Rainey’s Black Bottom</em> all deserve better than such a relegation, but it seems increasingly likely that one of their names will wind up on that unfortunate list which begs thoughtful viewers to wonder “Why?” instead of enjoying each of these fine films for what they are.</p><p>A clear Best Picture favorite has yet to emerge, but consider some algebra:</p><p>x = <em>Parasite</em> was the best film released in 2019<br> y = <em>Parasite</em> won both Best Picture and Best Director<br> z = The Academy rarely, if ever, makes back-to-back shots</p><p>Clear as it may be that <em>Mank</em> is the best film of 2020 (with the possible exception being Charlie Kaufman’s <em>I’m Thinking of Ending Things</em>, itself even further beyond the scope of voters’ collective creative threshold), clearer perhaps still is the sum of x, y, and z: the best film of 2020 will not win Best Picture. The aforementioned <em>Chicago Seven</em> and <em>Ma Rainey</em> are sure-thing nominees, as is <em>One Night in Miami</em> — unless it is considerably less impressive than advanced reviews indicate. Those would be the nominees in a five-picture year, but with the field expanded to include as many as ten, <em>The Father</em>, <em>Minari</em>, <em>News of the World</em>, <em>Da 5 Bloods</em>, <em>Soul</em>, and <em>Promising Young Woman</em> will all have their eyes on one of the final five spots — each hoping that <em>Judas and the Black Messiah</em> and <em>The United States vs. Billie Holiday</em> don’t upset the apple-cart upon their eventual release dates. Either of these final two knocking off one of the five favorites — or even taking the top spot — is highly unlikely, but both still have very real potential — something that can’t honestly be said about any of the other six.</p><p>Chloe Zhao’s directorial achievement regarding <em>Nomadland</em> is certainly outstanding enough to merit an Oscar win, just not against David Fincher’s <br><em>Mank</em>. Zhao captured the unconventional beauty of nature with the vision and patience of the very best documentarians and nature photographers, all the while helping to guide one of the world’s finest actresses to perhaps her greatest individual performance — not to mention directing non-professional actors with the just the right balance of delicacy and force to allow their lack of expertise to go entirely unnoticed and their emotional honesty to speak with the clearest voice possible. In nearly every sense of the word, she deserves to win Best Director, and in a perfect world, the Academy would be willing to declare multiple winners with regularity — but until that day comes, the Oscars effectively operate under Highlander rules: there can be only one, and she objectively does not deserve to win this award in the same year that David Fincher delivered his fifth masterpiece. There are many years in which she would have deserved it, but not this one. That having been said, there’s a very strong chance she does indeed walk away with the award, much the way Tom Hooper did for <em>The King’s Speech</em> (over Fincher for <em>The Social Network</em>), Kevin Costner did for <em>Dances with Wolves</em> (over Martin Scorsese for <em>Goodfellas</em>), and Robert Redford did for <em>Ordinary People</em> (over Scorsese for <em>Raging Bull</em>). Considering the Academy’s track record with all-time great directors, it would actually make a lot more sense if she won than lost.</p><p>If one were to read the names Alfred Hitchock, Stanley Kurbick, Akira Kurosawa, Federico Fellini, Sidney Lumet, Charlie Chaplin, and Orson Welles in the same breath, it would be reasonable to assume they were looking at a list of the greatest film directors of all time. They would be mistaken, but the reason such a mistake is understandable is because a Venn-diagram of “greatest directors of all time” and “Oscar-winning directors” would pretty much look like two entirely separate circles. It should then come as no surprise that David Fincher, Paul Thomas Anderson, Spike Lee, and Quentin Tarantino have never won the award, despite — or, perhaps, as a result of already having earned their positions in the former circle. This trend (and the fact that winning Best Director is effectively trading in the company of Hitchcock, Kubrick, and Kurosawa for that of Costner, Gibson, and Polanski) should be kept in mind by fans of Wes Anderson, Sofia Coppola, Ryan Coogler, Barry Jenkins, Denis Villeneuve, and any other director whose work seems to have been overlooked by the Academy to a near-criminal degree.</p><p>With all this in mind, smart money is on Chloe Zhao to win Best Director, but a bet against David Fincher always feels hard to make, established as the Academy’s bias against him — and other all-time great directors — is. Aaron Sorkin (<em>The Trial of the Chicago Seven</em>) and Regina King (<em>One Night in Miami</em>) are also locks to be nominated — which leaves one spot to be filled by either <em>Da 5 Bloods</em>’ Spike Lee, <em>News of the World</em>’s Paul Greengrass, <em>Minari</em>’s Lee Isaac Chung. The only real potential for a last-minute surprise comes from Shaka King and Lee Daniels, with their films (<em>Judas and the Black Messiah</em> and <em>The United States vs. Billie Holiday</em>, respectively) still unreleased. As an long overdue aside, Zhao and King’s eventual nominations will mark the first time two female directors are honored by the Academy in the same year. This historic pairing will make it even more likely that voters will gravitate toward Zhao, rather than using their respective secret platforms to honor yet another white man.</p><p>Unlike any award in recent memory, this year’s Best Actor race isn’t much of a race at all. The best performance of the year aligns perfectly with the most compelling real-life narrative of the year, and there is no chance that Chadwick Boseman isn’t given this posthumous award for his riveting work on <em>Ma Rainey’s Black Bottom</em>. A few months ago, it was Delroy Lindo’s to lose, then he appeared to have lost it to Anthony Hopkins, and finally <em>Ma Rainey </em>was released and the conversation over ended within thirty-five minutes. If Boseman hadn’t tragically passed away this past year, there’s a very strong possibility that Hopkins would have taken it — but not because it would have changed anything about their performances. Voters would simply have skewed toward Hopkins because many of them would fear this being the last chance they have to cast a vote in his favor, as a result of his age. Now, Hopkins’ age is all but irrelevant, with this year being the definitive last chance any Academy voter ever has to honor Chadwick Boseman — a talent most of them likely projected to win multiple Oscars over the following decades. Along with Hopkins for <em>The Father, </em>Lindo is sure to receive a nomination for his work on <em>Da Five Bloods </em>— both worthy winners in a softer year. They will likely be joined by <em>Mank</em>’s Gary Oldman, and either Riz Ahmed for the <em>Sound of Metal</em>, Steven Yuen for <em>Minari</em>, or Kingsley Ben-Adir, whose turn as Malcolm X is receiving high prause from just about everyone who has seen <em>One Night in Miami</em>. But this award belongs to Chadwick Boseman.</p><p>On the other side of the gender-aisle exists something of a tight race, with a veteran frontrunner in Frances McDormand, two worthy young challengers in Carey Mulligan and Vanessa Kirby, a dark horse in Andra Day (whose turn as Billie Holiday has still yet to be seen), and Viola Davis — who appeared in just 26 minutes (or 28 percent) as the titular Ma Rainey. That’s the very same Viola Davis who won Best Supporting Actress for a <em>Fences</em> performance featured at over twice the rate. These aren’t the official nominees, of course, but unless Andra Day underwhelms and allows Kate Winslet (<em>Ammonite) </em>or Sophia Loren (<em>The Life Ahead</em>) to sneak in — it’s pretty much codified. A win for McDormand (her third in this category) would elevate her to rarified air currently occupied exclusively by Katharine Hepburn and Daniel Day-Lewis. A win for Mulligan would signify overdue recognition of perhaps the most accomplished acting talent of her generation, as well as voters’ willingness to broaden their scope of acceptable Oscar-worthy performances beyond biopics and cookie-cut heroines. A win for either Kirby or Day would be shocking, if only due to the lack of traction their films are receiving and the trajectories of their careers up to this point. A win for Davis would be problematic, but far from unprecedented — the aforementioned Anthony Hopkins took home Best Lead Actor for his 16 minute turn as Hannibal Lecter in <em>The Silence of the Lambs</em>. It’s also an understandable — and somewhat admirable — move from her perspective, as her decision to campaign as a supporting actress for <em>Fences</em> was — and is — widely regarded as a cheap way to guarantee a win. Taking home her second Oscar in the exact reverse fashion, after effectively stacking the deck against herself, would be the most decisive way to silence the doubters. Some will cite the raw power of her performance (similar to that of Heath Ledger’s supporting turn as the Joker), its scene stealing intangible quality (not unlike Laura Dern in <em>Marriage Story </em>or Regina King in <em>If Beale Street Could Talk</em> — the two previous Best Supporting Actress winners), or the fact that she must be the lead because she plays the titular role (like Vanessa Redgrave did in <em>Julia</em>, for which she won 1977’s Oscar for Best Supporting Actress). No matter how it’s sliced, Viola Davis doesn’t belong in this category for this specific performance — which means she’ll probably win.</p><p>Best Supporting Actor is a bit more of an open field, with even the two frontrunners — <em>One Night in Miami</em>’s Leslie Odom Jr. and <em>Judas and the Black Messiah</em>’s Daniel Kaluuya — appearing in films that have yet to be seen by the general public. Beyond them, Sacha Baron Cohen is the strongest contender as the clear standout of a brilliant ensemble — but if there was ever a movie built for multiple nominees in this category, it’s <em>The Trial of the Chicago Seven</em>, which would likely result in a nomination for Mark Rylance, with a slight possibility that Yahya Abdul-Mateen II takes it instead (or as well). Again, the rest of the field is left to compete for (at most) one spot, and while Bill Murray seemed like an early lock for <em>On the Rocks</em>, <em>The Sound of Metal</em>’s Paul Raci has been gaining traction, David Strathairn seems likely to get some love if <em>Nomadland</em> winds up this year’s Oscar darling, and a Chadwick Boseman double nomination (this one for <em>Da 5 Bloods</em>) can’t be ruled out. Despite both of their films still being largely under wraps, the best bets here are Odom and Kaluuya as real-life civil rights icons Sam Cooke and Fred Hampton, respectively. Should both performances somehow end up being anything less than stellar (which would effectively render both films’ trailers masterworks of deception), Cohen have a clear path to becoming the logical choice.</p><p>Early on, Best Supporting Actress looked like it was going to belong to Glenn Close for her work on<em> Hillbilly Elegy</em>, which keen Oscar followers (and anyone with score-keeping capabilities) knew was absurd regardless of how exceptional her performance may have been. Then it looked like<em> Ammonite</em>’s Saoirse Ronan would finally get her due, but many were quick to point out that she seems well on her way to being the Oscars’ new Glenn Close (both have gone from being out-and-out frontrunners to empty-handed on far too many occasions for their fans’ comfort). Then <em>Borat</em>’s Maria Bakalova, <em>Minari</em>’s Yuh-Jung Youn, and <em>Pieces of a Woman</em>’s Ellen Burstyn were brought into the conversation. Now, it’s Amanda Seyfried’s turn in the spotlight, and she could very well be pushed over the top by carrying the entire weight of <em>Mank</em>’s realistic Oscar chances on her shoulders. But through all of this, Olivia Colman (<em>The Father</em>) has been resting comfortably in the number-two spot — exactly where she for the majority of the awards run-up when she won her first Oscar, for which Glenn Close was the early frontrunner. Colman can never be counted out, but at this stage in the game, she still has a bit of ground to make up against Seyfried — especially if voters treat <em>Mank</em> with the same trepidation as they have Fincher’s previous best-of-the-year films.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9bf63324975a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[LeBron James Has a Consistency Problem]]></title>
            <link>https://ryanlindauer.medium.com/lebron-james-has-a-consistency-problem-d89d902979e3?source=rss-bba799de9783------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d89d902979e3</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[lebron-james]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[hong-kong]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[china]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[nba]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ryan Lindauer]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 17 Oct 2019 14:54:06 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-10-17T14:54:06.370Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>LeBron James doesn’t want to be told to “shut up and dribble.” Nor should he.</p><p>When Laura Ingraham insisted that every public figure should devote their time and energy exclusively to the initial reason they were hired for their current job, it rang false on every level imaginable — especially coming from a <a href="https://www.vox.com/2016/8/15/12416662/roger-ailes-fox-sexual-harassment-women-list?__c=1">female FoxNews employee hired by Roger Ailes</a>. The continued pattern of social and political outspokenness from James that followed was widely viewed as heroic almost exclusively because of his clear prioritization of speaking truth to power over the bottom line. He refused to be silenced by threats of financial repercussions and made it clear that using his platform to speak out for those less fortunate than himself was what mattered most. Unarmed black men and women were (and are) being killed by the police at an alarmingly disproportionate rate with little or no justice ever being served, and LeBron James has refused to tiptoe around the issue, even if it means sacrificing millions of sponsorship dollars for himself and the league he represents; even if it means making ex-fans out of millions of Americans who believe in a strict separation of athletics and politics; even if it means sacrificing everything, he stands for something…sometimes.</p><p>It is, at this point, worth acknowledging that despite her callousness and hypocrisy on this matter and others, Laura Ingraham is an avid supporter of — and regular donor to — the Wounded Warrior Project, The Fisher House, St. Jude’s Hospital, and the Covenant House, and that she routinely espouses views that many view as controversial without fear of losing advertisers. However, when faced with the obligation to apply consistency of logic when her previously asserted views are turned against her vested interests (one cannot be “pro-life” and support capital punishment, nor can one decry violations to the sanctity of marriage and condone divorce), she routinely backpedals and offers her viewers a heaping pile of self-serving bullshit.</p><p>Whether it’s ever explicitly admitted or not, the primary reason why Black Lives Matter rallies are largely comprised of black activists is because white Americans know that the problems the movement is addressing will never impact them directly. If you were to ask LeBron James if that’s a good excuse, he would almost certainly reply in the negative. Yet, now that he and the league he represents have been presented with a humanitarian crisis that will never impact them directly, he and they seem to have lost their will to speak out. Worse yet, he seems to have taken on the Laura Ingraham role — publicly lambasting Daryl Morey for tweeting “Fight for Freedom. Stand With Hong Kong.” Hypocrisy notwithstanding, the precedent being set by James in this instance is horrifying at best, and leads to the logical conclusion that the NFL owners were absolutely justified in their black-balling of Colin Kaepernick — an assertion James would undoubtedly take issue with. It is possible that Kaepernick was black-balled because the NFL owners are white supremacists, and it’s possible that LeBron James is standing with China because he’s a Communist — more likely, though, is that both are simply chasing the bottom line with utter disregard for the ethical and practical ramifications.</p><p>If doing charitable acts and speaking your mind without fear of consequences is enough to make you a hero, then all hail Laura Ingraham. But if LeBron James wants to be taken more seriously(or at least to be <em>able </em>to be taken more seriously) than the woman who told him to “shut up and dribble,” he needs to abandon the self-serving bullshit and show the world that he’s willing to stand up for an oppressed group of people even if they don’t look like him.</p><p>Bottom line: you can believe that the NFL owners were objectively wrong for black-balling Colin Kaepernick (either because they are white supremacists or because they were afraid of losing money), or you can believe LeBron James is objectively right for standing with the Chinese government as they violently squash peaceful protests in Hong Kong (either because he is a Communist who hates the people of Hong Kong or because he is afraid of losing money) but you cannot believe both. You can believe Laura Ingraham was objectively wrong for telling LeBron James to “shut up and dribble,” and you can believe that LeBron James is objectively right for shouting down Daryl Morey’s call for self-determination in Hong Kong, but you cannot believe both.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d89d902979e3" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Why the Neymar Double-Standard?]]></title>
            <link>https://ryanlindauer.medium.com/why-the-neymar-double-standard-c6f515784076?source=rss-bba799de9783------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c6f515784076</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[brazil]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[soccer]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[brasil]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[neymar]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[world-cup]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ryan Lindauer]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 04 Jul 2018 21:48:19 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-07-04T21:59:19.389Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>The most skilled player on the planet may also be the smartest —and he’s the only top-tier superstar who hasn’t given his home nation reason to doubt his World Cup commitment— so why is hatred for the history of contact sport and the nature of human officiating being redirected at Neymar?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/650/1*Q8KvU3DIaGGGy0sKoDLNFQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Criticisms of Neymar tend to be rooted in the idea that he ought not be judged on the same scale as other world-class players — amongst whom flopping has been common practice for decades.</figcaption></figure><p>Following Brazil’s routing of Mexico in the round-of-sixteen, disgruntled American fans circulated GIFs, memes, tweets — and a troubling USA Today op-ed by Yahoo! Sports contributor Martin Rogers (who put his bias on full display by squeezing the rant in between “England Ends PK Curse…” and “Weight of the World Finally Off England’s Shoulders”) — all with the same central theme: Neymar is a whiny little bitch who’s ruining soccer because of the way he rolled around after Miguel Layun stomped his ankle.</p><p>When Martin Rogers saw Neymar get stepped on by Layun’s metal-spiked cleat after the whistle had blown, he sat down at his computer and devoted 730 words to tying himself in psychoanalytic knots to excuse Layun’s violent outburst, and trying shamelessly to convince his readers that Neymar has never actually been injured, that every opponent he’s ever faced has played perfectly clean defense, and that he is the only superstar player who has ever flopped. Rogers capped off his unhinged tirade by mocking Neymar for actually caring whether or not his team advanced. A grown man worth hundreds of millions of dollars doesn’t break down in tears after the end of a grueling match unless he is heavily invested in his team’s (and nation’s) success. While Neymar is ridiculed for having national pride and allowing it to be seen on live television (nearly the exact criteria by which legendary Italian keeper Gigi Buffon receives his highest praise), Cristiano Ronaldo and Lionel Messi are given free passes for stoically half-assing their way through yet another World Cup in pursuit of their next paycheck. Literally laughing all the way to the bank while Portuguese and Argentinian fans agonize. Again. Brazil made it further than Portugal and Argentina in the World Cup because they are the only one of those three countries whose best player played like he actually gave a shit about the country he came from. Again. All three countries needed last minute heroics to keep their World Cup dreams alive, and Neymar showed up while Messi and Cristiano disappeared. Again.</p><p>When Martin Rogers saw that an English fan had vandalized a statue of Fyodor Cherenkov, he could only muster 173 words, and uses none of them to denounce the fan in any way, shape, or form. He had just chosen to use his editorial voice to denounce flopping, but couldn’t quite decide how he felt about the vandalism — or the Nazi salutes. That’s right, when Martin Rogers saw video of English fans doing Nazi salutes during the England/Tunisia fixture, he said nothing for two weeks — after which time he offered this:</p><p>“There have been relatively few incidents, although social media videos did emerge earlier in the event of an England fan doing a Nazi salute.”</p><p>And when presented with the opportunity to expand on the antics of the English fans — the way he did for 730 words when Neymar rolled around on the ground for a few seconds — he chose instead to change the subject:</p><p>“After beating Colombia, England will now face Sweden in Saturday’s quarterfinal in Samara. A significant influx of fans is expect to enter the country, with even more to follow if the team reaches next week’s semifinal in Moscow.”</p><p>It would be easy to write-off Rogers as an English fanboy, were he not the sole arbiter of World Cup information for USA Today readers — and had his rant about Neymar not been used as an excuse for a slew of other fanboys to simultaneously excuse acts of violent aggression on the pitch (if they happen to Neymar) and denounce intelligent play (if Neymar does it), all the while overlooking Nazi salutes and acts of vandalism against the Russian hosts.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*25h7wAzuZlgieVJO6CyMbw.jpeg" /><figcaption>U.S. Soccer fans — a demographic largely devoid of soccer knowledge and historically incapable of staying focused for long enough to learn much about it — have been the driving force behind recent Neymar criticisms.</figcaption></figure><p>Okay, so the criticisms are off-base and Martin Rogers is nuts — but what about that claim that Neymar might be the smartest player?</p><p>Any trial lawyer worth their salt is keenly aware of the fact that nothing is ever truly stricken from the record — so long as juries are made up of human beings. Likewise, any footballer deemed worthy of representing their country at the World Cup is severely ill-prepared if they aren’t aware that football fixtures are basically jury trials with three angry men deciding the outcome. A trial lawyer who robotically makes their case without any attempt to manipulate the emotion-fueled jurors is failing to maximize their chances of emerging victorious. Likewise, a footballer who goes through the motions of dribbling, passing, and shooting without attempting to manipulate the emotions which fuel the referees — who have all but complete control over the fixture’s outcome — is failing in the exact same manner.</p><p>In American football, coaches routinely use timeouts as a de facto way of having the previous play reviewed and hopefully reversed; often times, it works. There are no timeouts in association football (soccer) — no matter how bad the call, soccer managers are completely helpless — leaving it up to the players on the pitch to delay the game and give the referees a chance to second-guess themselves. This is especially important in the event of a possible direct red card infraction, as VAR review is mandated under such circumstances. With all this in mind, the smart thing for a player to do after being intentionally stepped on by an opposing player after the whistle is milk the injury until the referee shows red to the opposing player. If Neymar doesn’t roll around for as long as he does, he isn’t maximizing Brazil’s chances of winning the World Cup — and if Layun doesn’t step on him after the whistle, there is nothing for Neymar to react to. So why are people more worried about Neymar’s reaction to Layun stomping his ankle than they are about Layun stomping Neymar’s ankle in the first place? How is it Neymar, not Layun (and those who commit similar offenses), who is ruining soccer?</p><p>Those who hate flopping altogether have yet to offer any real solutions — preferring instead to complain, but only about certain players — perhaps because they all know, on some subconscious level, that the real solution is a very uncomfortable one. But if they actually hate flopping, they should be eager to embrace VAR — and looking to take further similar steps with the ultimate goal of eliminate the human referees altogether. Microchips, hi-def cameras, and advanced algorithms are capable of delivering a perfectly honest game — including identifying and punishing actual acts of simulation (flopping). They are capable of ending virtually every debate in sport, and it is probably for this reason that so many are resistant to the coming change.</p><p>In short: if you hate players flopping, what you actually hate is contact sport being officiated by emotion-fueled beings; if you hate Neymar’s flopping more than other players’ flopping, you’ve got some self-reflecting to do; if you hate Neymar’s flopping more than Layun’s stomping, English fans vandalizing a Moscow statue, or English fans doing Nazi salutes — you’re lost.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FvvgNHK6bvbY%3Fstart%3D132%26feature%3Doembed%26start%3D132&amp;url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DvvgNHK6bvbY&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FvvgNHK6bvbY%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/f43deb23ad65620dcc8b313a257dc461/href">https://medium.com/media/f43deb23ad65620dcc8b313a257dc461/href</a></iframe><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c6f515784076" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[FIVE REASONS MOONLIGHT SHOULDN’T WIN BEST PICTURE…AND ONE REASON IT SHOULD]]></title>
            <link>https://ryanlindauer.medium.com/5-reasons-moonlight-shouldnt-win-best-picture-and-one-reason-it-should-11394f37cba2?source=rss-bba799de9783------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/11394f37cba2</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[oscars]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[movies]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ryan Lindauer]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 27 Feb 2017 16:14:51 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-02-27T20:00:26.646Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>If you were expecting another La La Land puff piece, my apologies.</p><p>Moonlight shouldn’t win Best Picture because it’s the best “black” film of the year — it should win because it was the best motion picture released in 2016.</p><p>Moonlight shouldn’t win Best Picture because it’s the best “LGBT” film of the year — it should win because it was the best motion picture released in 2016.</p><p>Moonlight shouldn’t win Best Picture because Hollywood has a responsibility as a beacon of American liberalism to counteract the continued xenophobic narrative presented by the current presidential administration and should thus utilize the Oscars as an opportunity to highlight the American diversity that truly makes this country great— it should win because it was the best motion picture released in 2016.</p><p>Moonlight shouldn’t win Best Picture because it’s only competition, La La Land, was so racially insensitive that it borders on being outright offensive — — it should win because it was the best motion picture released in 2016.</p><p>Moonlight shouldn’t win Best Picture because black lives matter — it should win because it was the best motion picture released in 2016.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=11394f37cba2" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[CAM NEWTON IS HERE TO SAVE THE NFL]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/laces-out/cam-newton-is-here-to-save-the-nfl-8e854f439779?source=rss-bba799de9783------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8e854f439779</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[sports]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cam-newton]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[nfl]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ryan Lindauer]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 27 Jan 2016 15:39:36 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-01-27T15:39:36.759Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>At a time when the two loudest narratives coming out of the NFL are the (not necessarily unrelated) ongoing <a href="http://www.ranker.com/list/nfl-players-domestic-violence/ranker-nfl?page=4&amp;utm_expid=16418821-174.5vlqpgn-RoaJUIiApA53hg.0&amp;utm_referrer=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.ranker.com%2Flist%2Fnfl-players-domestic-violence%2Franker-nfl">domestic abuse</a> and <a href="http://nymag.com/daily/intelligencer/2016/01/advanced-cte-found-in-former-giant-tyler-sash.html">concussion</a> crises, ardent fans of the game may remain undeterred — but potential newcomers find themselves with an increasingly short list of players who make them want to watch without giving them any logical reasons <em>not </em>to watch. Sure, everybody (save hipsters) loves Peyton Manning, but he’s on his way out the pads, and hasn’t truly been enjoyable to watch since last November. Yes, Russell Wilson is an exciting young talent, but he’s also a <a href="http://thefinersports.sportsblog.com/posts/2794778/russell-wilson-deserves-our-judgment---for-being-a-d-bag.html">fundamentalist Christian</a> who believes <a href="http://jimrome.com/2015/08/27/russell-wilsons-magic-water/">mineral water can prevent concussions</a>. Of course watching Adrian Peterson run the ball is a sheer thing of beauty, but thinking about the marks he left on his child last summer is decidedly not. And of course, Belichick and Brady are an absurdly productive tandem, if the countless cheating allegations aren’t enough to turn you off, there’s the fact that neither seems to have any fun on game day. Which leads us to the matter at hand…</p><p>Cam Newton is here to save the NFL. This might seem like an absurd statement while the NFL is still raking in billions and encompassing the entirety of TV programming’s Mount Olympus — admittedly, the salvation in question is unlikely to be required for at least a few decades. But for every <a href="http://www.wdsu.com/news/local-news/new-orleans/drew-brees-appears-on-ellen-with-inspiring-gift-to-two-bffs-and-he-says-hell-play-sunday/35598836">Drew Brees</a> and <a href="http://www.kirotv.com/news/news/22000-turn-out-richard-shermans-charity-softball-g/ngjq3/">Richard Sherman</a> winning over potential new fans with their on and (especially) off the field conduct, there is a <a href="http://www.newsmax.com/TheWire/johnny-manziel-hit-girlfriend/2015/10/21/id/697320/">Johnny Manziel</a> or <a href="http://www.nationalfootballpost.com/Greg-Hardys-accuser-details-alleged-attack/">Greg Hardy</a> doing exactly the opposite; for every squeaky-clean <a href="http://jacksonville.com/breaking-news/2014-12-13/story/oregons-marcus-mariota-favorite-scandal-free-heisman-ceremony-focused">Marcus Mariota</a>, there is a scandal-plagued <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/fsu-settlement-jameis-winston_us_56a6a377e4b0172c6593fce9">Jameis Winston</a>. Then there’s <a href="http://www.usatoday.com/story/sports/nfl/49ers/2015/03/16/chris-borland-retire-san-francisco-49ers-head-injuries-concussion/24882901/">Chris Boreland</a>, <a href="http://www.nydailynews.com/sports/football/steelers-wr-antwaan-randle-el-regrets-football-career-article-1.2503227">Antwaan Randle El</a>, and a <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_NFL_players_with_chronic_traumatic_encephalopathy">long list of deceased former players</a> that science suggests would still be alive if they never played football.</p><p>New helmets, stricter personal conduct policies, and half-hearted PSAs won’t be enough to win over the hearts and minds of new viewers. In order for the NFL to transcend the endless onslaught of negative attention it will continue to receive, people need to remember why they love football. They need a new breed of superstar; one who brings a novel excitement to the game, who stays out of trouble off the field, and who wears his in-game emotions like badges of honor. They need an uncompromising master of his craft who cares as much about entertaining his fans as he does renegotiating his contract; a disciplinarian who knows exactly when to slip into role as ringleader. Quite simply, they need an alien — an unpredictable outsider who routinely does things that would be impossible for a human being. They need a beacon of hope with supernatural strength, x-ray vision, and the ability to fly. Fortunately for them, Cam Newton is here — and he’s not going back to Krypton anytime soon.</p><p>When Columbia Pictures released <em>Concussion</em> — a captivating film that lays out the science behind the concussion crisis and details the lengths the NFL has gone to suppress said science — football pundits everywhere were forced into an uncomfortable pause; unwilling or unable to do their jobs at a moment when fans are genuinely curious what they have to say. Then Cam Newton delivered highlight reel after highlight reel (and taught the world how to dab in the process). Now anytime anyone brings up any of the legitimate reasons why football might be doing more harm than good to the American psyche, you can show them a clip of Cam front-flipping into the end-zone, landing on his feet, and laughing as the subsequent hits roll in.</p><p>But what values is he teaching our children? Well, besides the courage it takes to front-flip over a wall of giants, the focus it takes to maintain greatness while receiving objectively unwarranted scrutiny from the sports media , and the leadership it takes to spearhead an all-but-receiverless team to a 15–1 season and a trip to the Superbowl — how about hard work and discipline? Yes, Cam Newton is blessed with a whole lot of natural talent, but that’s not how he got where he is. Every player in the NFL possesses natural talent, but there’s only one with an “S” on his chest. Supercam’s speed and strength (both entirely unmatched among top-tier quarterbacks) are the direct products of a continuous pattern of hard work and discipline; so is the consistent progression of his accuracy as a passer, patience as a runner, and composure as a leader. Sure, there are a lot of NFL players one could feasibly look to as a model of these two core values, but if they were as hard-working and disciplined as Cam Newton, he probably wouldn’t be the 2015 season’s runaway MVP.</p><p>Perhaps most importantly, though, is the blatantly divergent (and visibly infectious) attitude he unabashedly brings to the game. Unlike the other laser-focused, perennially-scowling, win-at-any-cost franchise players, Newton doesn’t smack himself in the head or mimic the aggressive behavior of a wild animal after a big play — nor does he follow up touchdowns with displays of anger, or celebrate in a way that suggests he didn’t think he was capable of scoring. He hands the ball to the first child he sees in Panther gear, thanks God, and dances with an ear-to-ear smile on his face. Oh, and he occasionally reminds fans that he is, in fact, Superman.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8e854f439779" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/laces-out/cam-newton-is-here-to-save-the-nfl-8e854f439779">CAM NEWTON IS HERE TO SAVE THE NFL</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/laces-out">Laces Out</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Why You Shouldn’t Be Afraid to Call Caitlyn Jenner a “Media Whore”]]></title>
            <link>https://ryanlindauer.medium.com/why-you-shouldn-t-be-afraid-to-call-caitlyn-jenner-a-media-whore-c5550b797ac2?source=rss-bba799de9783------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c5550b797ac2</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[lgbtq]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[caitlyn-jenner]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[transgender]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ryan Lindauer]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 05 Aug 2015 21:49:07 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2015-08-06T21:02:31.464Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/670/1*a6Lp-HoooMNzb5Qw1zyFZA.png" /></figure><p>“She’s just a media whore.”</p><p>When someone utters these words about someone like Caitlyn Jenner, it’s the second word that is most troubling — not the fourth and fifth.</p><p>Caitlyn Jenner has helped broaden the spectrum of the light already being shone on trans individuals, and the vitality of this enhanced illumination mustn’t be understated. Because of Jenner and her highly-publicized transition, a great many individuals will have the otherwise-absent fortitude to forego the pains of suppression; instead choosing to accept and embrace the people they truly are. Inevitably, a great many men living in women’s bodies (and vice versa) didn’t need Jenner’s help in coming to terms with their gender identity. And to be sure, there are many more who will need a moment of public affirmation a bit more significant than several media cycles spent on the transition of an absurdly wealthy television personality who gives great speeches, but doesn’t use the platform she’s given (or her voting power) to advance the political agenda of the LGBT community.</p><p>But she isn’t a politician; she’s a reality star. Caitlyn Jenner is a hero primarily by virtue of her fame; the type of hero that is easy to write-off, despite its tremendous importance. She hasn’t championed the cause of trans individuals by doing anything more than seeking out a television camera at every possible moment of her transition. It might not seem like much, but when the bigotry at hand is rooted in ignorance and denial, what matters more than forcing as many people as possible to see what they have previously been blind to? What better way to foster acceptance?</p><p>Yes, Jenner is — for lack of a better term — a media whore. With a television filmography that includes <em>I’m a Celebrity…Get Me Out of Here!</em>, <em>The Apprentice, Skating with Celebrities, Pet Star, </em>and <em>Keeping Up with the Kardashians, </em>there is no logical defense from such a label — but why should the situation require any defense at all? Why the knee-jerk defense from self-professed allies of the LGBT community when the notion is breached? Why do we assume Jenner (and others like her) are incapable of seeing the words “media whore” and “publicity stunt” for the badges of honor they are — and have been throughout every struggle for human rights in recent memory.</p><p>Rosa Parks wasn’t the first black woman to protest segregation in the public sphere; she wasn’t even the first black woman to sit in the white section of a segregated bus and get arrested for doing so. And Mamie Till was hardly the first black woman to demand that others not turn a blind eye after her child was abducted and lynched by a mob of white racists. But what Parks and Till were the first to do is take their respective actions with the explicit intention of making it onto the evening news, and because Rosa Parks and Mamie Till <em>did</em> make it onto the evening news, Martin Luther King was able to mobilize a nation of otherwise-disinterested citizens and make his dream of desegregation something of a reality. Harvey Milk wasn’t the first homosexual to come out of the closet; but putting himself and his message in front of the television cameras as frequently as possible allowed him to have an incalculably positive (and in many cases life-saving) impact on the lives of people who otherwise wouldn’t have known that there was anything but homophobia waiting for them in the world. Media whores tend to be blamed for their supposed contributions to the supposedly-detrimental celebrity culture, but rarely receive credit for their work as pioneering catalysts of widespread awareness to their respective causes. When they do, their true nature is denied in favor of a more traditional-heroic narrative.</p><p>So yes, Caitlyn Jenner is a media whore. But so was Rosa Parks. And so was Harvey Milk. And Mamie Till. And maybe it’s not such a bad thing to be.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c5550b797ac2" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Trending in America…July 29, 2015]]></title>
            <link>https://ryanlindauer.medium.com/trending-in-america-july-29-2015-392b8d337dc6?source=rss-bba799de9783------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/392b8d337dc6</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ryan Lindauer]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 29 Jul 2015 23:09:00 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2015-07-29T23:39:13.429Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/463/1*RO-AwHq-nJV8NOcEPDUNZA.jpeg" /></figure><p>Kit Harrington was spotted on the Game of Thrones set, promting even those who know nothing to realize that Jon Snow will be just fine.</p><p>Meek Mill exposed Drake’s use of ghostwriters. Drake responds by releasing two diss tracks, both of which are pretty clearly ghost-written.</p><p>Cecil the Lion was killed by American dentist Walter Palmer after Palmer paid upwards of fifty-thousand dollars to be taken on an illegal hunting expedition by a group of Zimbabweans who are now facing charges for assisting in the crime, which is expected to catalyze an immediate decrease in Zimbabwe’s tourism dollars — and will almost certainly lead Cecil’s twenty-four cubs to be killed by other lions. No word from President Obama on extraditing Palmer, though it seems safe to assume the United States would demand extradition if a Zimbabwean citizen committed a wanton act of aggression on American soil — especially if the violent act carried with it such devastating economic consequences.</p><p>Jonathan Pollard, who was convicted of spying on the United States and revealing top secret information, is being released. Every other spy ever apprehended by the United States (who will never see the light of day) scratches their heads, failing to see the legal distinction between “Spying on the United States” and “Spying on the United States for Israel.” That he also gave information to apartheid-South Africa and Pakistan (as well as stealing classified information for no reason other than his wife’s financial gain) doesn’t matter, because Adam Sandler and Sean Hannity said so.</p><p>An eight-year-old boy in Baltimore receives the first-ever double hand transplant. An unquestionably uplifting story, unless he one day happens to raise those hands while any police officers are around.</p><p>New York (where my family lives) is currently experiencing an outbreak of Legionnaires’ Disease, and Louisiana (where I live) has a brain-eating amoeba in the water. Neither situation is currently contained — nor the source uncovered — so I will definitely not be drinking the water.</p><p>A giraffe calf died at the Dallas zoo after hitting the wall and breaking its neck. Dallas zookeepers are understandably heartbroken and stunned to learn that concrete walls are not part of the giraffe’s natural habitat.</p><p>Linda Tripp seems to think that for some reason, she has a right to speak about Hillary Clinton’s readiness to be President of the United States and be taken seriously by anyone outside of her immediate family. Amidst all this seriousness, a little humor is appreciated. Thanks, Linda.</p><p>A piece of metal was found in the Indian ocean. CNN is on it.</p><p>Congressman Marc Meadows (R-NC) filed a resolution seeking to remove John Boehner as speaker of the house. Boehner cries like a baby.</p><p>Former rapper David Faustino is reportedly working on a television show with Christina Applegate, Ed O’Neil, and Katey Sagal. And they said Peter Dinklage would be the only “little person” getting work anytime soon.</p><p>NFL Commissioner Roger Goodell upholds Tom Brady’s four-game suspension. Brady refuses to admit any wrongdoing even in the face of overwhelming evidence. Peyton Manning parties with Brett Favre, Steve Young, John Elway, Dan Marino, Bart Starr, and Warren Moon, and Joe Montana — who pretend not to be home when Tom Brady comes knocking.</p><p>Hillary Clinton still can’t figure out how to answer an incredibly basic question about the Keystone Pipeline.</p><p>Microsoft releases Windows 10. Apple is shaking in its boots.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=392b8d337dc6" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[FAT SHAMING IS JUST THE BEGINNING]]></title>
            <link>https://ryanlindauer.medium.com/fat-shaming-is-just-the-beginning-627e155d5ec2?source=rss-bba799de9783------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/627e155d5ec2</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ryan Lindauer]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 24 Jan 2015 14:51:50 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2015-01-24T19:32:26.752Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>And it won’t stop till we’ve all conformed—nine other pervasive social media trends, and how they hold us back as a society.</p><p>Hollywood, fashion houses, and “health”-crazed mothers like Abby Pell and Maria Kang have made no secret of the fact that they don’t want us to feel good about ourselves—perhaps best exemplified by their continued condescension with regard to matters of the body.</p><p>No matter how you weigh in, “fat shaming” is one of the most dangerous behaviors trending in today’s society. But it’s hardly alone…</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*hHLtw556Cwr_wiC6yNrqzA.jpeg" /></figure><p>Most recently, it was fitness enthusiast Abby Pell posting a series of incredibly insensitive pictures on Instagram and refusing to apologize after being bombarded with complaints. Before that, it was Maria Kang irresponsibly championing the “fit mom” movement with complete disregard for how her patronizing words impacted the millions of people who read them. Before that, it was Fashion Week, diet crazes, the Academy Awards, television shows, and the commercials that punctuate them. It’s been an uphill battle from the beginning for those born out-of-touch with society’s superficial expectations, and spitting in someone’s face rarely makes them climb faster.</p><p>Pell’s most controversial picture depicted her daughter pointing at her mother’s exposed six-pack abs with widened eyes—accompanied by the caption:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/444/1*7AVC4azwIJOzOhEvrUfsUw.png" /></figure><p>“I have a kid, a six pack, and no excuse.”</p><p>The surface value insensitivity was enough to make a decent person’s head explode—but even worse, the comment was a blatant allusion to an even more offensive post by Maria Kang showing off her own six-pack while her three sons smile at the camera. Kang’s accompanying caption:</p><p>“What’s your excuse?”</p><p>As if the world’s increasing number of overweight individuals have done nothing but make excuses; as if they actually chose this. As if, like cigarette smokers, they have it so easy that they can just “quit” and solve the problem once and for all. As if anyone would actually choose to be obese. The disrespect conveyed by Pell’s Instagram posts and Kang’s Facebook rants is so great that it makes one wonder what it will take for such offenses to be rightly labelled as hate crimes.</p><p>As established by the outrage (from both the media and American public), it would take an absolute monster not to be offended by Pell or Kang’s actions—even if neither of them intended to hurt anyone. But is our society overlooking other ways in which our seemingly-harmless actions are causing a great deal of pain to people who already feel like second-class citizens?</p><p>Just as the deliberate display of a low BMI and high muscle content serve to alienate and disenfranchise people whose nature-nurture combination led them to obesity, these nine common social media occurrences just might be digging someone else’s ditch a little bit deeper:</p><p>“Fertility Shaming”<br>While you’re gleefully celebrating pregnancy by posting pictures of your baby-bump and eventual baby on Facebook, how do you think it makes the woman who can’t have children feel?</p><p>“Accomplishment Shaming”<br>Tweeting about your scholastic and professional accomplishments might seem harmless—until you bother to think about all the people who’ve failed to achieve their goals, and how your wanton bragging is making them feel.</p><p>“Family Shaming”<br>The next time you post a selfie with Grandma or brag about the fun day you had with Mom, maybe you’ll stop for a second and think about all the people who don’t have any living grandparents, or whose parents have passed away. Every day, people lose family members, and shoving your good familial fortune in their faces isn’t helping anyone.</p><p>“Rehabilitation Shaming”<br>When you boast on social media about how many days you’ve been sober, you’re probably making all the people still fighting to reach step one feel pretty bad about themselves.</p><p>“Pet Shaming”<br>Pictures and videos of pets are fun and heart-warming to most, but to many they stand as tragic reminders that their dearly departed furry friends are no longer with them. It hardly seems considerate to stomp on a broken heart.</p><p>“Death Shaming”<br>On a related note, “In Memoriam” posts about friends and family members (furry or otherwise) who have passed away might help you cope with your personal losses—but perhaps you might consider the millions of optimists living in peaceful denial of the fact that death exists. Anyone who’s ever had a truly euphoric dream knows how cruel it is to be woken up, so why go out of your way to pinch their arms?</p><p>“Job Shaming”<br>Every Facebook newsfeed that has ever existed is riddled with complaints, critiques, and general observations about people’s jobs—most likely because they are composing their update from their work phone or computer. But what too few of us take into account is how such posts make America’s tens of million of unemployed individuals feel.</p><p>“Bald Shaming”<br>Can we just admit that Larry David was right about this one thing? Bald people are among the most severe victims of covert oppression in today’s society, and all these pictures of your beautiful flowing locks are downright offensive.</p><p>“Beard Shaming”<br>The Instagram pictures of your creative facial hair might play like gangbusters with the ladies, but the insensitivity of your actions can hardly be ignored. Different men grow facial hair at different rates and in different quantities—the only responsible party is genetics, and you just made all the peach-fuzz riddled men out there feel pretty worthless.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/461/1*dWuZ60WzIWlq-gVDO3BvUg.jpeg" /></figure><p>Seems like we could all stand to be a little more sensitive.</p><p>In the words of the incomparable Audrey Hepburn:</p><p>“I have no illusions about my looks. I think my face is funny”</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=627e155d5ec2" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>