<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Ricardo Zapata Lopera on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Ricardo Zapata Lopera on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@rzapatal?source=rss-603c21b946c0------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Wed, 18 Nov 2026 16:55:14 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@rzapatal/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Artificial Intelligence in the Latin American Public Sector]]></title>
            <link>https://rzapatal.medium.com/artificial-intelligence-in-the-latin-american-public-sector-3941f212cc69?source=rss-603c21b946c0------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/3941f212cc69</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[latin-america]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[artificial-intelligence]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[oecd]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[public-sector]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ricardo Zapata Lopera]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 28 Apr 2022 20:49:14 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-04-28T20:49:14.765Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*ZhBEbjkjTchFJN80.jpg" /><figcaption>Photo by Robynne Hu via Unsplash</figcaption></figure><blockquote>Across the world, governments are incorporating artificial intelligence (AI) into their arsenal of tools to improve efficiency, make better policy decisions, and increase engagement with the public. This trend holds true for many nations in Latin American and the Caribbean (LAC). A new report by the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD), an international policy analysis think tank, explores how LAC governments are incorporating AI into their processes for a more responsive public sector. We (<a href="https://edgelands.institute/">Edgelands Institute</a>) spoke with <strong>Ricardo Zapata</strong>, an analyst at the OECD and one of the co-authors of the report, “ The Strategic and Responsible Use of Artificial Intelligence in the Public Sector of Latin America and the Caribbean “ to learn more about how LAC governments are using AI and what this means for the future of responsible governance, public security, and digital rights in the region.</blockquote><p><strong>What are some of the most common ways that a government may use AI?</strong></p><p>Governments will generally approach AI to improve efficiency. Concretely, this will mean automating simple tasks or upgrading the speed and quality of public services. Most of the visible use cases belong to this category. In some other cases, governments will also look to improving the policy design process by getting in-depth knowledge out of large quantities of data (and most governments are already good at producing a lot of data) and making more informed decisions. This is an area where AI can deliver good results, but that also calls for stronger ethical approaches in the whole cycle, from the collection of data to its processing. Finally, AI is being used also to enhance communication and engagement with the public, generally through chatbots, matching tools (producing better recommendations according to citizens’ needs or characteristics), or improving the abilities to better understand opinions and perspectives of citizens at scales that were previously unfeasible. Good to note that similar uses happen the other way around when citizens use AI to better understand what their governments are doing.</p><p><strong>The report states that Colombia has emerged as a leader in the LAC region for its use of AI. Why is that?</strong></p><p>Colombia is building strong AI policy and producing very interesting use cases. On the policy side, we documented various instruments and levers that secure strong governance of AI in the public sector. In the first place, its AI strategy is the only one in the region to have the whole set of enablers that can help drive implementation. With enablers we mean having objectives and specific actions, measurable goals, responsible actors, time frames, funding mechanisms, and a monitoring instrument. Although they do not guarantee successful implementation, having them in place can improve its performance, especially when we consider Colombia is a large country and the strategy has been made to endure across administrations.</p><p>Second, we analysed 15 policy levers that can improve the implementation of AI projects in the public sector and, in most of them, Colombia stood out as a regional leader. For example, when looking at the efforts to develop a responsible, trustworthy and human-centric AI, Colombia’s ethical framework was well aligned with our reference instrument, the <a href="https://oecd.ai/en/ai-principles">OECD AI Principles</a>. When looking at funding, Colombia’s national strategy was unique in the region in having an explicit funding mechanism. When looking at data governance or spaces for experimentation, it was also among those countries with the most complete instruments and practices.</p><p>This whole evaluation exercise did not intend to create a ranking, but to identify strengths among countries to enable others to learn from their practices and lessons. Our study does not say who the best is and neither who has the greatest impact. At this stage, we can compare what countries are doing with the policy frameworks we are developing and, being AI such a recent trend, it is possible that these frameworks evolve in the coming years. So, being a regional leader, in this case, means that countries should take a special look to what Colombia is doing.</p><p><strong>Could you give an example of how Colombia uses AI in the public sector?</strong></p><p>Aside from all the policy developments I described, Colombia is also making some interesting implementations in the public sector. I think <a href="https://www.corteconstitucional.gov.co/noticia.php?PRETORIA,-un-ejemplo-de-incorporaci%C3%B3n-de-tecnolog%C3%ADas-de-punta-en-el-sector-justicia-8970">PretorIA</a>’s case stands among the most interesting we documented. This is a project developed by the Constitutional Court to help in the selection of key <em>tutelas</em> (i.e. Constitutional Action for the protection of fundamental rights) to set legal precedents on the provision of fundamental rights. The Court receives more than 2000 <em>tutelas</em> each day, so a solution to make this process more efficient can add a lot of value. PretorIA automatically reads and analyses all plaints, detects and predicts the presence of predefined criteria, and intuitively presents reports and statistics. It serves as a tool for judges, so it ensures there is a human in charge of the decision-making process.</p><p>What I found the most interesting about this case is how it was developed. Initially, it was an adaptation of <a href="https://medium.com/astec/prometea-artificial-intelligence-in-the-judicial-system-of-argentina-4dfbde079c40">Prometea</a>, an AI system developed in Argentina to help justice providers. It acted as a virtual assistant that predicted case solutions (based on previous cases and solutions) and helped provide information required to assemble case files. When the Constitutional Court first announced the project in 2019, it sparked citizen participation and dialogues with many stakeholders due to concerns about the opacity and black-box effect of this system, especially when dealing with a process made to guarantee fundamental rights. Citizen participation then led the Court to transform the whole project into what we now know today as PretorIA, a system that uses topic modelling technology instead of neural networks, making it more explainable, interpretable and traceable. The institutional reaction to external voices is a nice example of responsible actors being held accountable, making the necessary changes to assure the trustworthiness of the AI system.</p><p><strong>What is a “trustworthy, human-centered” approach to AI and how does it differ from traditional uses? How does Colombia rank in its use of human-centered AI?</strong></p><p>Our reference framework to assess trustworthy and human-centered approaches are the<a href="https://oecd.ai/en/ai-principles"> OECD AI Principles</a>, which intend to promote the development of innovative AI that respects human rights and democratic values. Coming from an institution like the OECD dedicated to sharing best practices, establishing international standards, and improving public policies in democratic and market-oriented economies, the report seeks then to interrogate how public sector AI systems are integrating these values. I think it is hard to say what a traditional approach is. What I would stress is that technology is not value-neutral, so every development embeds a vision of how the world should look like. Many systems we know today have put their focus in efficiency, profit, or control. As citizens and institutions, we should therefore permanently ask how we want technology to be and what values do we want it to reflect.</p><p>In this regard, Colombia has done a great effort issuing the AI Ethical Framework, aligning with the OECD AI Principles. Our report goes more in depth and looks at particular aspects of the responsible, trustworthy and human-centric approach, so we look at fairness and bias mitigation, transparency and explainability, safety and security, and accountability. In all of those, Colombia’s AI Ethical Framework gives the country good capacities to promote this type of approach. Where we see room for improvement is in setting guidance and methods for understanding user needs and for building diverse AI teams. Of course, all this concerns the existence of policy frameworks, which is in itself a great progress, so their application and impact will be a matter of future research.</p><p><strong>How could human-centered AI help people coexist better in cities? Could you give an example of how this technology could be used in a city planning or public security intervention?</strong></p><p>Cities are a context where digital government projects can have a more tangible and visible impact for citizens. Implementing a trustworthy and human-centric AI in domains like security, where we are dealing with the privacy and integrity of persons, could allow society to be confident on the right applications of the technology and held responsible actors accountable for its results. It could also help us decide where we do not want to apply it, which is a completely valid choice. We talk a lot about the benefits of AI, but sometimes a risk-based approach can say: these domains should remain tech-free. For instance, facial recognition, which has been banned in some places and remains a debated topic. It could also help us discover that AI is not the best solution, as it happened with Predpol in Montevideo.</p><p>At the urban level, many authorities in Latin America are using AI systems to analyse the enormous amounts of real-time and historical mobility data to improve traffic management, detect risks, or model future scenarios. Some are also using surveillance cameras and devices together with AI algorithms to track criminal activity, identify persons, and analyse historical data. Our report highlights that there are still two main challenges in this last area: establishing the necessary safeguards when processing sensitive personal data (e.g. biometric data), and defining clear frameworks for the use of these technologies to prevent possible abuses such as the profiling and persecution of political opponents or protesters.</p><p>We certainly need more active discussion to shape urban surveillance technologies. There is still a lot of progress to be made. In the end, that is one of the points of incorporating democratic values in the development of AI, that we can collectively shape these technologies and their applications.</p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://edgelands.institute/Artificial-Intelligence-in-the-Latin-American-Public-Sector"><em>https://edgelands.institute</em></a><em>.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=3941f212cc69" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Acuerdo de Escazú: democracia ambiental y datos abiertos en Colombia]]></title>
            <link>https://rzapatal.medium.com/acuerdo-de-escaz%C3%BA-democracia-ambiental-y-datos-abiertos-en-colombia-6ab406ccf1b?source=rss-603c21b946c0------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6ab406ccf1b</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[datos-abiertos]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[medio-ambiente]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[open-data]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[acuerdo-de-escazú]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[gobierno-digital]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ricardo Zapata Lopera]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 24 Aug 2021 09:01:00 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-09-06T08:19:15.494Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Acuerdo de Escazú: democracia ambiental y datos abiertos</h3><p><em>Una oportunidad para una nueva forma de cogestión de nuestro ambiente</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/696/0*jE87w21KnCdGioUQ.jpg" /></figure><blockquote><strong><em>El sector ambiental tiene tres grandes retos: la dispersión de la información, la desigualdad de capacidades tecnológicas entre instituciones y la desconexión de las pocas iniciativas valiosas que están usando tecnología.</em></strong></blockquote><p>Colombia aún no ratifica el Acuerdo de Escazú. Pasó un año en el que, entre discusiones y dilaciones, no se surtió el trámite necesario y la ratificación terminó archivada. En la actual legislatura, el Gobierno puede volver a radicar el Acuerdo, tal como se lo están <a href="https://www.ambienteysociedad.org.co/la-ratificacion-del-acuerdo-de-escazu-necesita-voluntad/">pidiendo</a> varias organizaciones ambientales. Con o sin radicación, la discusión sobre una política unificada de democracia ambiental sigue abierta y más sectores sociales deben conocer cómo ésta puede traer beneficios para la gestión ambiental del país.</p><p>Uno de los argumentos que utilizan los opositores del Acuerdo de Escazú es que no es necesario porque, dicen ellos, Colombia ya cuenta con las normas e instrumentos que garantizan los derechos de acceso, que incluyen el acceso a la información, la participación y la justicia ambiental. Si bien esto es parcialmente cierto, el problema que tiene el país está en la desarticulación y la falta de cohesión de lo que existe. Es decir, Colombia no tiene una política estructurada sobre democracia ambiental, sino una colección de normas e iniciativas que no operan de la misma forma en todo el territorio ni con un mismo objetivo.</p><p>Una de las áreas en las que más se evidencia esto es en la apertura de datos ambientales y en la incorporación de tecnologías digitales para mejorar la participación en la gestión ambiental. El sector ambiental tiene tres grandes retos en esta materia: la dispersión de la información, la desigualdad de capacidades tecnológicas entre instituciones y la desconexión de las pocas iniciativas valiosas que están usando tecnología. Veamos punto por punto.</p><h4>La dispersión de la información</h4><p>El Sistema Nacional Ambiental (SINA) tiene alrededor de 40 portales que publican información en diferentes temporalidades, formatos e interfaces de usuario. Esta dispersión hace que para el ciudadano sea difícil encontrar lo que necesita. Por ejemplo, quien esté interesado en flora y fauna podrá empezar a buscar en el Sistema Nacional de Información Forestal ( <a href="http://snif.ideam.gov.co/ideam-snif-web/">SNIF</a>), el Sistema de Información sobre Biodiversidad de Colombia ( <a href="http://datos.biodiversidad.co/">SIB Colombia</a>), el Registro Único Nacional de Áreas Protegidas ( <a href="https://runap.parquesnacionales.gov.co/">RUNAP</a>) o el Sistema de Información Ambiental Territorial del Pacífico Colombiano ( <a href="https://siatpc.co/">SIAT-PC</a>). Cada uno tiene categorías, formatos e interfases diferentes.</p><p>Si se quiere información sobre los mares y las costas, el Sistema de Información Ambiental Marina ( <a href="http://siam.invemar.org.co/">SIAM</a>) afortunadamente centraliza gran parte de esta. Quien busque sobre calidad del aire puede empezar por el Subsistema de Información Sobre Calidad de Aire ( <a href="http://sisaire.ideam.gov.co/ideam-sisaire-web/consultas.xhtml">SISAIRE</a>) y, para datos más detallados y actualizados, tendrá que buscar en portales locales como el <a href="http://www.siata.gov.co/">SIATA</a> para el Valle de Aburrá o en los <a href="http://www.ambientebogota.gov.co/calidad-del-aire">tres visores</a> que tiene Bogotá. Además de esta variedad de portales temáticos, varias Corporaciones Autónomas Regionales (CAR) tienen sus propios portales y sistemas de información.</p><p>Algunos portales como el Sistema de Información Ambiental de Colombia ( <a href="http://www.siac.gov.co/">SIAC</a>) deberían ser espacios donde converjan los datos que publican otros portales especializados, pero, como no hay interoperabilidad, se vuelve muy costoso mantenerlos actualizados. Por eso, si uno entra a buscar los datos de calidad del aire que ofrece este portal, se topa con que, por ejemplo, los últimos registros de PM 2.5 son de 2014.</p><h4><strong>La desigualdad de capacidades tecnológicas</strong></h4><p>Una política nacional de democracia ambiental garantizaría el derecho pleno de acceso a la información orientando todos los sistemas con los que cuenta el país hacia la “[generación, recopilación, disposición al público y difusión de la información ambiental relevante (…) de manera sistemática, proactiva, oportuna, regular, accesible y comprensible, y actualizada] periódicamente”, tal como lo propone el Artículo 6 del Acuerdo de Escazú. En este escenario, el Ministerio de Ambiente podría jugar un rol más activo para orientar al ciudadano hacia las diferentes fuentes, por ejemplo, mediante un portal como el SIAC donde converjan los datos más populares y se haga pedagogía sobre los usos y potenciales de la información que existe en el país.</p><p>Dentro del SINA, algunas instituciones han adelantado procesos avanzados de sistematización y estructuración de información para ser presentada al público, bien sea como datos abiertos o mediante portales de visualización, mientras que otras no tienen ningún dato abierto ni portales de visualización. En la mitad de ambos polos, hay una gran cantidad de datos que algunas entidades del sector han producido, pero que se encuentra desactualizada, desordenada o desestructurada.</p><p>El más <a href="https://diariolalibertad.com/sitio/2021/01/13/conozca-el-ranking-de-las-mejores-y-peores-car-de-colombia/">reciente</a> Índice de Evaluación de Desempeño Institucional (IEDI) que publica el Ministerio de Ambiente (del que, por cierto, no puede encontrarse información en los canales oficiales) ya muestra una gran diferencia de capacidades entre las CAR. Si bien la evaluación en el IEDI no se correlaciona con la calidad de la información que cada CAR publica, sí siguen existiendo grandes diferencias entre ellas. Por ejemplo, el <a href="http://crc-siac.opendata.arcgis.com/datasets">portal</a> de datos abiertos de la Corporación Autónoma Regional del Cauca (CRC) cumple con los requisitos técnicos principales de una buena política de datos abiertos: permite el acceso a datos geográficos, no exige usuario para descargar la información, está habilitado para interoperar con otros sistemas de información y permite descargar los datos gratuitamente. Otro <a href="http://sigae.cda.gov.co/">portal</a>, el de la Corporación para el Desarrollo Sostenible del Norte y el Oriente Amazónico (CDA), exige usuario para poder ingresar. ¿Cómo obtener el usuario? No es claro, por lo que ni siquiera se puede saber qué está disponible. Otras CAR ni siquiera tienen sistemas de información abiertos al público.</p><p>El complejo entramado de instituciones que componen el sector ambiente es tanto un reto como una oportunidad para la liberación de datos ambientales. El reto está en la compleja coordinación de casi 50 entidades dispersas en todo el territorio nacional y con diferentes capacidades técnicas para avanzar en la liberación simultánea de datos. La oportunidad está en el relacionamiento más directo que cada entidad puede tener con su territorio y nicho poblacional, pues tiene un conocimiento más profundo de su público objetivo. El acceso a la información y, en particular, la publicación de datos abiertos, no debe ser una acción pasiva, sino que debe trabajarse activamente con los públicos que pueden estar interesados en reutilizar esos datos. Por ejemplo, una junta de acción comunal puede estar interesada en monitorear las licencias ambientales que se están otorgando en su zona de influencia, un grupo de investigación puede estar buscando estadísticas actualizadas de calidad del agua o una fábrica puede querer conectar sus sistemas informáticos con los datos de gestión de riesgos y desastres que publica la CAR local.</p><p>Acceder a estos datos no debería implicar derechos de petición y esperas largas, sino que deberían estar listos para ser reutilizados y procesados sin restricciones para su reproducción, tal como propone el Acuerdo de Escazú. Una propuesta complementaria del Acuerdo, la promoción del acceso a la información ambiental que está en manos de entidades privadas, podría incluso ampliar la riqueza de datos a los que accedería la ciudadanía. Entender estas necesidades, mejorar el relacionamiento con grupos de interés y publicar datos abiertos de calidad permitiría avanzar en la solución de retos públicos y la creación de valor social y económico.</p><h4>Iniciativas aisladas</h4><p>Un último reto que enfrenta Colombia para el desarrollo de una política coherente de democracia ambiental es la conexión y la ampliación de iniciativas valiosas que están utilizando las tecnologías digitales para ampliar el acceso a la información y la participación de la ciudadanía en los procesos de gestión ambiental. Un caso relevante está en los diferentes enfoques sobre la gestión de la calidad del aire de los tres centros urbanos más grandes del país. El Área Metropolitana del Valle de Aburrá es probablemente la autoridad ambiental más avanzada en esta materia pues no solamente tiene activo el portal del <a href="http://www.siata.gov.co/">SIATA</a> con información en tiempo real de más de 20 estaciones oficiales, sino que ha desarrollado desde 2011 un programa de ciencia ciudadana llamado <a href="https://www.metropol.gov.co/ambiental/siata/Paginas/ciudadanos-cientificos.aspx">Ciudadanos Científicos</a> que hace pedagogía con e involucra a cientos de personas en la producción de datos usando sensores de bajo costo.</p><p>En el caso de Bogotá, la ciudad cuenta con una <a href="http://www.ambientebogota.gov.co/calidad-del-aire">red de monitoreo</a> de la calidad del aire abierta al público, pero el número de estaciones es similar al del Valle de Aburrá para una población casi dos veces superior; entre los indicadores estándar, la ciudad ofrece el IBOCA (Índice Bogotano de Calidad del Aire), un indicador que no es homologable a los demás que existen en el país y, hasta hace poco, los códigos de color que representaban los diferentes niveles de contaminación no eran los mismos que pide la norma nacional. A raíz de esto, la actual administración se encuentra trabajando en la actualización de la estrategia de comunicación y relacionamiento público de su línea de calidad del aire.</p><p>En el caso de Bogotá, la ciudad también cuenta con una <a href="http://www.ambientebogota.gov.co/calidad-del-aire">red de monitoreo</a> abierta al público, con datos en tiempo real y acceso a varios contaminantes. Recientemente, la autoridad ambiental ha comenzado a incorporar elementos de participación ciudadana y relacionamiento público, con un enfoque de gobernanza del aire. Si bien estos procesos aún son incipientes, son un gran avance frente a unos últimos años marcados por prácticas que generaban confusión y poca confianza en el público, como el uso de códigos de color para los niveles de contaminación con paletas diferentes al estándar nacional, o la reiterada inoperancia de estaciones en horas y temporadas críticas.</p><p>El caso de Cali es el más dramático pues la información es prácticamente inaccesible. A través del Sistema de Vigilancia de Calidad del Aire de Cali ( <a href="https://www.cali.gov.co/dagma/publicaciones/38365/sistema_de_vigilancia_de_calidad_del_aire_de_cali_svcac/">SVCAC</a>), la autoridad pública boletines periódicos sobre el estado de la calidad del aire en formato PDF. Es decir, no pueden ni reutilizarse ni visualizarse. Además, su publicación es poco constante y está desactualizada. Por ejemplo, los últimos boletines publicados son de diciembre de 2020.</p><p>Estas diferencias entre las tres ciudades más grandes del país muestran cómo la apropiación de tecnologías digitales por parte de las autoridades ambientales para garantizar el máximo acceso a la información y mejorar la participación ciudadana no es una constante. Ante este panorama, la ciudadanía está respondiendo proactivamente desarrollando sus propios sistemas de monitoreo de calidad del aire con tecnologías de bajo costo. Por ejemplo, entre la <a href="https://derechoanoobedecer.com/convocatoria-acciones-por-el-aire/">Red Nacional Ciudadana por la Calidad del Aire</a>, en la que participan más de 20 organizaciones sociales, universidades, colectivos y ciudadanos de todo el país, y <a href="https://canair.io/">CanAir.IO</a>, un proyecto ciudadano y abierto de sensores de bajo costo, se está creando una red nacional ciudadana de monitoreo que operará principalmente en ciudades intermedias.</p><p>Ampliar las capacidades de gestión ambiental no sólo requiere fortalecer las instituciones formales, sino desarrollar los mecanismos que permitan acceder a la inteligencia que pueden desarrollar las comunidades trabajando en colectivo. En otras palabras, el ambiente no puede gobernarse desde un escritorio ni con burocracia; exige mecanismos efectivos de participación. En otros sectores, como el de la <a href="https://www.economist.com/briefing/2021/08/07/open-source-intelligence-challenges-state-monopolies-on-information">inteligencia militar</a>, esta forma colectiva de producción de servicios públicos ya está retando el monopolio estatal de la información. Por ello, en un contexto digital donde compartir datos y vincular sistemas de información es relativamente fácil, este tipo de iniciativas ofrece una oportunidad de colaboración y cogestión ambiental con las comunidades locales. Una política clara sobre democracia ambiental basada en el Acuerdo de Escazú permitiría hacerlo sistemáticamente.</p><p>El Acuerdo de Escazú es la oportunidad que tiene Colombia para formalizar una política de democracia ambiental que, hoy en día, se encuentra desarticulada y avanza a partir de intenciones esporádicas y no bajo un marco que encauce y nivele su desarrollo en todo el país. La democracia ambiental tiene como objetivo no sólo ofrecer garantías a más sectores de la población en la toma de decisiones, sino también mejorar la eficiencia en la gestión ambiental al incluir canales para acceder a la inteligencia de una colectividad con más conocimiento de y cercanía al territorio. Es decir, ofrece la posibilidad de superar el dilema entre democracia y eficiencia que erróneamente se ha popularizado entre algunos enfoques de la gestión pública. Ratificar este Acuerdo nos permitirá concebir de forma distinta la gestión ambiental, usando las tecnologías digitales para mejorar la participación y garantizar un real acceso a la información. Los datos abiertos se vuelven pues un elemento central con el potencial de detonar nuevos procesos de colaboración entre ciudadanía y gobierno.</p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://lalineadelmedio.com/acuerdo-de-escazu-democracia-ambiental-y-datos-abiertos/"><em>https://lalineadelmedio.com</em></a><em> on August 24, 2021.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=6ab406ccf1b" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[COVID is not an excuse to threaten freedom on the Internet]]></title>
            <link>https://rzapatal.medium.com/covid-is-not-an-excuse-to-threaten-freedom-on-the-internet-a51c96d80e8b?source=rss-603c21b946c0------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a51c96d80e8b</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[digital-rights]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[human-rights]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[covid19]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[technology]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ricardo Zapata Lopera]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 19 Jun 2020 14:39:02 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-06-19T14:58:09.058Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>8 proposals to reconfigure the digital after the pandemic</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*atsYFJasSrcpic4l.png" /></figure><p>Latin America is going through a period of uncertainty marked by deep social discontent and an accelerated and opaque rush of social and political changes driven by the COVID-19 health emergency. In 2019, countries such as Chile, Colombia or Mexico were experiencing various social protests demanding improvements and expansion of rights. Shared injustices threw people onto the streets to advocate for a transformation of the social order and solutions to structural problems such as corruption and violence.</p><p>But in 2020 the citizen action to which we were accustomed simply stopped being possible. Although we have seen that protests against racism and police abuse have not ceased the concentration of people in Mexico, Brazil or outside the region, the health emergency has shortened citizens’ rights and increased the powers of the rulers to monitor, control and, in many cases, legislate by decree. National and local governments are adopting new technologies and data management systems to cope with the public health emergency and general economic trauma, increasing reliance on data-based systems to track disease and profile the population. COVID-19 expansion rhythms not only delimited collective action and the gathering of people on the streets, but also confined citizenship to the digital space, a largely private, surveilled and opaque domain.</p><p>These changes are not <a href="https://www.technologyreview.com/2020/03/17/905264/coronavirus-pandemic-social-distancing-18-months/">temporary</a> nor <a href="https://www.nesta.org.uk/blog/there-will-be-no-back-normal/">inconsequential</a>. They radically change the way we understand the effective exercise of human and political rights. Perhaps it is our daily life that is already beginning to experience this new normality. We have resorted to virtuality for work, school, activism, and daily relationships. But with the increasing digitization of social interactions, civil society is questioning the false dilemma many governments are leading us to: that of health or privacy.</p><p>This occurs due to the undemocratic way in which social relations have been configured in the digital sphere. Therefore, controlling and facing the health crisis through technology has accentuated inequalities and has presented us with urgent challenges to reconfigure a digital space that truly serves democracy. One of them is recognizing the Internet as a public space that we inhabit and that allows us to exercise rights and freedoms: such as the freedoms of expression, assembly, and privacy. Questioning whether the Internet is currently a democratic space and identifying what conditions endanger our democratic life in digital spaces are other not minor challenges.</p><p>If we aim for a new normality, what structural changes do we need to extend to the digital environment? What discourses, ideas and conceptions about technology hinder or threaten an <strong>Internet of rights and freedoms that allows collective action and citizen participation?</strong></p><p>There is no more urgent time to <strong>reconfigure the prevailing narratives or discourses on the digital and democracy</strong> and propose alternatives that point in another direction. However, the participation of civil society in the debates on digital rights is still limited to a few organizations, so it is vital to add diverse voices, from environmentalism, gender struggles, the defense of human rights, and many others.</p><p>These are some of the narratives that we see are being reproduced with the current health crisis, and to which we bring forward democratic, alternative visions.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2F6MP6pAKv5-M&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3D6MP6pAKv5-M&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/f343183dbfd551e3f6642e9e98adae05/href">https://medium.com/media/f343183dbfd551e3f6642e9e98adae05/href</a></iframe><blockquote>1. Today the Internet is seen as “a non-real world” (e.g. the real world and the digital world).</blockquote><p><strong>We propose to recognize the internet as a public space that we share and inhabit. The network is also a real space, with tangible impacts on our lives.</strong></p><blockquote>2. The main use of the Internet and digital technologies has gone to businesses and political propaganda. This has opened the door to increased government surveillance and censorship of dissident voices. Currently, digital tracking facilitated by widely adopted systems is used by authoritarian governments to exercise control and repression.</blockquote><p><strong>Let us defend the Internet as a common good, as a space to affirm and defend rights and collective action. Let us defend digital technologies as tools that support processes of social change, organization, meeting and participation. Let’s defend an Internet that strengthens democracy!</strong></p><blockquote>3. A few major players have a monopoly on how the networks and systems we use work, how we interact, what we see, and what content is privileged.</blockquote><p><strong>But we all create content and socio-digital relationships, identities and new ways of thinking-doing through these systems. We are not just users, a good part of our democratic life happens right there. It is therefore necessary to make the management of these systems more democratic and open.</strong></p><blockquote>4. Digital technologies are seen as a solution to all kinds of problems.</blockquote><p><strong>However, it is key to submit the implementation of new technologies to democratic deliberation. What elements do they involve? How do they work? What are the related risks? Who gets benefited and who gets hurt? How do they become more beneficial? Are they truly necessary?</strong></p><blockquote>5. Surveillance seems to be justified on the grounds that “I have nothing to hide.”</blockquote><p><strong>We believe that democracy and privacy are closely related. A healthy democracy depends on the interaction of autonomous individuals. Individual autonomy depends on having privacy. Defending the Internet as a space where privacy matters benefits the entire society.</strong></p><blockquote>6. Currently there is a discourse of “savagery of the Internet” where violence is normalized and its impact is minimized.</blockquote><p><strong>It is important not to normalize digital violence as part of Internet interactions, recognizing that it has real impacts on people’s lives. Digital violence is an extension of “analogous” violence, which is evident and is carried out through technology.</strong></p><blockquote>7. Digital is seen as an unlimited world in which everything goes viral and reproduces infinitely.</blockquote><p><strong>We must be aware that digital has a physical and social impact. Visits, likes, reproductions, and interactions imply more energy consumption, hardware waste generation and a greater deployment of infrastructures such as marine cables and data centers. For example, it has been </strong><a href="https://theshiftproject.org/article/climat-insoutenable-usage-video/"><strong>estimated</strong></a><strong> that, in 2020, only streaming video would emit as much CO2 as Spain.</strong></p><blockquote>8. In a health emergency context, technology has <a href="https://www.accessnow.org/tecnologias-de-vigilancia-para-controlar-el-covid-19-en-america-latina/">posed</a> a dichotomy between health and privacy.</blockquote><p><strong>Technology can support pandemic expansion control while respecting rights and freedoms. All initiatives based on technology and management of personal and health databases must be transparent, respectful of rights and comply with measures that protect our information. The COVID-19 emergency situation we face is not an excuse to collect unnecessary data, or to not improve the protection practices and ethical development of technology for the public interest. Short-term efficiency should not undermine human rights.</strong></p><p><strong>Written by</strong></p><p><em>Ricardo Zapata — El Derecho a No Obedecer (Colombia)</em></p><p><em>Beatriz Quesadas — SocialTIC (México)</em></p><p><em>Haydeé Quijano — SocialTIC (México)</em></p><p><em>Daniela Jordán — Frena la Curva (Chile)</em></p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://ciudadaniai.org/en/actualidad/2020/03/21/el-covid-no-es-pretexto-democracia-digital.html"><em>https://ciudadaniai.org</em></a><em>.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a51c96d80e8b" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[El COVID no es pretexto para amenazar la libertad en Internet]]></title>
            <link>https://rzapatal.medium.com/el-covid-no-es-pretexto-para-amenazar-la-libertad-en-internet-592be9d34866?source=rss-603c21b946c0------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/592be9d34866</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[derechos-humanos]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[tech]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[covid19]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[human-rights]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[tecnología]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ricardo Zapata Lopera]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 18 Jun 2020 07:39:47 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-06-19T14:33:18.061Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>8 propuestas para reconfigurar Internet post-pandemia</em></p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FIBuZxZy4IxY%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DIBuZxZy4IxY&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FIBuZxZy4IxY%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/f0cf9413152662140aa1f170f0398afa/href">https://medium.com/media/f0cf9413152662140aa1f170f0398afa/href</a></iframe><p>América Latina atraviesa un periodo de incertidumbre marcado por un profundo descontento social y una acelerada y opaca marea de cambios sociales y políticos producto de la emergencia sanitaria. En el 2019, países como Chile, Colombia o México vivían momentos convulsos donde, a través de la protesta social, se exigían mejoras y expansión de derechos. Miles de personas unían su hartazgo intentando transformar el orden social y reclamando soluciones a problemas estructurales como la corrupción y la violencia.</p><p>Pero llegó 2020 y el accionar ciudadano al que estábamos acostumbrados simplemente dejó de ser posible. Si bien hemos visto que las protestas contra el racismo y el abuso policial no han impedido la concentración de personas en México, Brasil o fuera de la región, la emergencia sanitaria ha recortado los derechos ciudadanos e incrementado los poderes de los gobernantes para vigilar, controlar y, en muchos casos, legislar por decreto. Los gobiernos nacionales y locales están adoptando nuevas tecnologías y sistemas de gestión de datos para hacer frente a la emergencia de salud pública y el trauma económico general, aumentando la dependencia de los sistemas basados en datos para rastrear enfermedades y perfilar a la población. Los ritmos de expansión del COVID-19 delimitaron no solo la reunión de personas en las calles y la acción colectiva, sino que también confinaron la ciudadanía al espacio digital, un dominio mayoritariamente privado, vigilado y opaco.</p><p>Estos cambios no son <a href="https://www.technologyreview.com/2020/03/17/905264/coronavirus-pandemic-social-distancing-18-months/">temporales</a> ni <a href="https://www.nesta.org.uk/blog/there-will-be-no-back-normal/">intrascendentes</a>, sino que cambian radicalmente la forma en que entendemos el ejercicio efectivo de los derechos humanos y políticos. Es tal vez nuestra cotidianidad la que ya empieza a vivir esta nueva normalidad. Hemos recurrido a la virtualidad para el trabajo, la escuela, los activismos y las relaciones cotidianas. Pero la digitalización de las interacciones sociales genera cuestionamientos por parte de la sociedad civil por el falso dilema al que nos enfrentan las acciones de muchos gobiernos: el de la salud o la privacidad.</p><p>Esto ocurre por la forma poco democrática en la que se han configurado las relaciones sociales en el ámbito digital. Por ello, controlar y enfrentar la crisis sanitaria a través de la tecnología ha acentuado las desigualdades y nos ha propuesto retos urgentes para reconfigurar un espacio digital que le sirva a la democracia.</p><p>Uno de ellos es reconocer Internet como espacio público que habitamos y que nos permite ejercer derechos y libertades: como libertad de expresión, reunión, privacidad. También cuestionar si Internet es actualmente un espacio democrático e identificar qué condiciones pone en peligro nuestra vida democrática en espacios digitales.</p><p>Si apuntamos a una nueva normalidad ¿qué cambios estructurales necesitamos extrapolar al ámbito digital? ¿qué discursos, ideas y concepciones sobre la tecnología obstaculizan o amenazan una <strong>Internet de derechos y libertades que permita la acción colectiva y la participación ciudadana?</strong></p><p>No hay momento más urgente para <strong>reconfigurar las narrativas o discursos predominantes sobre Internet y democracia</strong> y proponer alternativas que apunten hacia otra dirección. Sin embargo, la participación de la sociedad civil en los debates sobre los derechos digitales sigue siendo limitada a pocas organizaciones, por lo que es vital sumar voces diversas, desde el ambientalismo, las luchas de género, la defensa de los derechos humanos, y muchas otras.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*UAHVhjhDEiEV2JtB.png" /></figure><p>Estas son algunos de los discursos que vemos reproducirse con la actual crisis sanitaria y ante los cuales proponemos otros caminos para un bien común.</p><blockquote>1. Hoy Internet es vista como “un mundo no real” (ejemplo: el mundo real y el mundo digital).</blockquote><p><strong>Proponemos reconocer internet como un espacio público que compartimos y habitamos. La red también es un espacio real, con impactos tangibles en nuestras vidas.</strong></p><blockquote>2. El uso mayoritario de la Internet y las tecnologías digitales se ha volcado a los negocios y la propaganda. Ello ha abierto la puerta al incremento de la vigilancia gubernamental y la censura a voces disidentes. Actualmente Internet y el rastreo que permite la actividad digital son usadas por gobiernos autoritarios para ejercer control y represión.</blockquote><p><strong>Defendamos Internet como bien común, como espacio para afirmar y defender derechos y la acción colectiva. Defendamos las tecnologías digitales como herramientas que apoyan procesos de cambio social, de organización, reunión y participación. ¡Defendamos una Internet que fortalezca la democracia!</strong></p><blockquote>3. Unos pocos grandes actores tienen el monopolio para definir cómo funcionan las redes y sistemas que utilizamos, cómo interactuamos, qué vemos, qué contenidos se privilegian.</blockquote><p><strong>Pero todxs creamos contenido y relaciones socio digitales, identidades y nuevas formas de pensar-hacer a través de estos sistemas. No somos simples usuarios, una buena parte de nuestra vida democrática ocurre allí mismo. Es necesario entonces hacer más democrática y abierta la gestión de estos sistemas.</strong></p><blockquote>4. Las tecnologías digitales son vistas como una solución a todo tipo de problemas.</blockquote><p><strong>Sin embargo, es clave someter a deliberación democrática la implantación de nuevas tecnologías. ¿Qué implican? ¿Cómo funcionan? ¿Cuáles son los riesgos relacionados? ¿A quiénes benefician y a quiénes perjudican? ¿Cómo se hacen más beneficiosas? ¿En realidad son necesarias?</strong></p><blockquote>5. La vigilancia pareciera estar justificada bajo el argumento de que “no tengo nada qué esconder”.</blockquote><p><strong>Creemos que la democracia y la privacidad están íntimamente relacionadas. Una sana democracia depende de la interacción de individuos autónomos. La autonomía individual depende de contar con privacidad. Defender Internet como un espacio donde nos importa la privacidad beneficia a toda la sociedad.</strong></p><blockquote>6. Actualmente impera un discurso del “salvajismo de internet” donde las violencias son normalizadas y se minimiza su impacto.</blockquote><p><strong>Es importante no normalizar la violencia digital como parte de las interacciones de Internet, reconociendo que tiene impactos reales en la vida de las personas. La violencia digital es una extensión de la violencia “análoga”, que se hace evidente y es realizada a través de la tecnología.</strong></p><blockquote>7. Lo digital es visto como un mundo ilimitado en el que todo se viraliza y reproduce al infinito.</blockquote><p><strong>Debemos ser conscientes de que lo digital tiene un impacto físico y social. Las visitas, los likes, las reproducciones, las interacciones implican más consumo de energía, generación de basura digital y un mayor despliegue de infraestructuras como cables marinos y centros de datos. Por ejemplo, se ha </strong><a href="https://theshiftproject.org/article/climat-insoutenable-usage-video/"><strong>estimado</strong></a><strong> que en 2020 sólo el streaming de video emitiría tanto CO2 como España.</strong></p><blockquote>8. La tecnología en contexto emergencia sanitaria ha <a href="https://www.accessnow.org/tecnologias-de-vigilancia-para-controlar-el-covid-19-en-america-latina/">planteado</a> una dicotomía entre salud y privacidad.</blockquote><p><strong>La tecnología puede apoyar al control de expansión de la pandemia respetando derechos y libertades. Todas las iniciativas basadas en tecnología y manejo de bases de datos personales y de salud, deben ser transparentes, respetuosas con los derechos y cumplir con medidas que protejan nuestra información. La situación de alerta que enfrentamos frente al COVID-19 no es pretexto para recopilar datos innecesarios, no mejorar las prácticas de protección y desarrollo ético de tecnología para interés público.</strong></p><h4><strong>Autores</strong></h4><p><em>Ricardo Zapata — El Derecho a No Obedecer (Colombia)</em></p><p><em>Beatriz Quesadas — SocialTIC (México)</em></p><p><em>Haydeé Quijano — SocialTIC (México)</em></p><p><em>Daniela Jordán — Frena la Curva (Chile)</em></p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://ciudadaniai.org/actualidad/2020/03/21/el-covid-no-es-pretexto-democracia-digital.html"><em>https://ciudadaniai.org</em></a><em>.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=592be9d34866" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Technology won’t save the planet]]></title>
            <link>https://rzapatal.medium.com/technology-wont-save-the-planet-7fe61448a91e?source=rss-603c21b946c0------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/7fe61448a91e</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[technology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[climate-change]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[low-tech]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[degrowth]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[environment]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ricardo Zapata Lopera]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 27 Feb 2020 09:53:29 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-02-27T09:55:54.803Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>A critical review of ‘The Age of Low Tech: towards a technically sustainable civilization’ by Philippe Bihouix</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*8t_GcZe4h59O4OTE" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@rafaeltran?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">TUAN ANH TRAN</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><blockquote>Bihouix, P. (2014). <em>L’âge des low tech: Vers une civilisation techniquement soutenable</em>. Paris: Éd. du Seuil.</blockquote><p>During the last four decades, we have been constantly surpassing the Earth Overshoot Day<a href="#_ftn1">[1]</a>, the moment of the year when all regenerative resources for a year are depleted and we start consuming what belongs to the next years. Even so, each day we face a rush of advertising encouraging vain consumption, analysts concerned about the slow growth prospects, and journalists covering, with no critical eye, how technology is solving every single flaw of our system. I decided to read Philippe Bihouix’s The Age of Low Tech (<em>L’Âge des Low Tech</em>) because the systematic exploration of alternatives to that blind faith in technology to solve environmental problems has not been a widely debated topic. If there is a wide production of low tech literature, most of it is less scientific and more pamphlet-like. Additionally, try searching for “low tech” and “high tech” in Google Scholar, just to see the enormous differences in citations among the top articles. True, high tech literature does not treat the same topics as low tech literature. The former includes a mix of every subject that uses cutting edge technology, while the latter mostly deals with the promotion of the concept and its applications. But that is ultimately the point: no one has to convince others about the benefits of high tech, it is embedded in social and economic practices. Even more, as a technology and public policy student, I have come to learn how misled we have been by tech discourse<a href="#_ftn2">[2]</a>, so the idea of building a simpler, slower, humbler, and sustainable future is appealing.</p><p>From that stance, <em>The Age of Low Tech</em> is mostly deceiving. I would broadly describe it as an introduction to slow tech, a book for a general audience who is just confronting other possible alternatives, who just discovered the reality hidden by mainstream discourse. Bihouix takes his position as a technical expert in scarce resources to clear up the view: facts do not support our present system and, with some imagination and a switch of some values based on sobriety, we could build a new, still comfortable, reality.</p><h4><strong>The analytical perspective</strong></h4><p>Nevertheless, I must admit that the expectations for this type of ‘resistance’ literature are quite high. Not to be called naive, an idealist, or a smoke seller, he who dares to propose an alternative system should cover all technical, political, economic, social, and cultural factors, including a plan for the transition. Even more, our current neoliberal rationality is severe in judging alternatives when they don’t manage to fit the <em>homo economicus</em>. Bounded rationality is the standard for judgment.</p><p>But being critical of rational choice theory and its reluctance to proposals containing other rationalities does not distance me from the tools it offers to make a realistic assessment of low tech. As I will discuss in the following paragraphs, my reading of <em>The Age of Low Tech </em>has been crossed by rational choice <em>institutionalism </em>as a heuristic device to critically evaluate its arguments.</p><h4><strong>General book overview</strong></h4><p>Philippe Bihouix takes the opposite position to the <em>cornucopian </em>school, which believes in the continuous progress of humanity through technological advancement. Bihouix defends de-growth, but he is not a collapsologist. He argues that the current system is unsustainable and that its essence must be challenged, building an alternative system based on the opposite values of high-tech. “Since the high-tech system goes into the wall (or towards the cliff, don’t quibble) why not try something else, take the opposite way and turn to the low tech?”<a href="#_ftn3">[3]</a>. In the first part of the book, Bihouix makes well-grounded documentation of the contradictions and limitations of today’s economic system. He refutes the key argument of cornucopians which goes on to say that capitalism and technology have always found a way to solve constraints through innovation. The problem with this position is that, even if we manage to solve the next crisis, the cost of extracting new non-renewable resources does not stop increasing and it will arrive a moment when it will not be any more profitable to do it.</p><p>Even more, putting faith in technology has problematic socio-technical consequences. Namely, the rebound and park effects. The first refers to the interrelation between the decrease in the cost of technologies and the increased efficiency they allow for resource use<a href="#_ftn4">[4]</a>. The author presents several examples of how technological improvements have led to a permanent increase in resource consumption, and not the contrary. This is the case of the ‘Jevons Paradox’. On the other side, the park effect refers to the replacement rate of old pollutant technologies and the quick deployment of new, clean ones. For Bihouix, the observed replacement rates make impossible to rely on technological updates, if we want to reduce resource consumption. All these elements have led to a triple dead end: of unsustainable exploitation of resources, increased pollution (including CO2 emissions), and depletion of natural spaces for artificial materials, particularly hard surfaces.</p><p>As growth and high-tech are not viable options, the question then is about forced or chosen de-growth. Collapse is a possibility, so Bihouix suggests we should anticipate it. Orienting towards the low tech is assuming an ethical stance to not let the world fall into collapse. This is particularly explored in the second part of the book that describes an ethical framework of low technologies. One valuable thing we learn is that opting for low tech is not a rational and technical consequence of the established political and economic logic. We need to alter the main decision rationale for it to work. That is, making sobriety a permanent criteria for choice. Almost the rest comes as a consequence of it and the book follows this logic, seeking to prove that it is possible to live with sobriety, without returning to the Middle Age. This extends to say that there is not properly a state of low tech, but a process of <em>lower</em>-tech, where the principle of sobriety is continually extended into new areas.</p><p>Up to this point, the book is rather illustrative and provocative. A well-conceived first part nevertheless contrasts with the second, which delves more in philosophy than in science. The growing enthusiasm for reaching the promised age of low tech is, however, not well compensated with what happens in the last two parts. The third part of the book makes a shallow review of applied low tech in different fields such as agriculture, transportation, finance, technologies, among others. The fourth part talks about the transition and how four main constraints (employment, change in a globalized world, culture, and morals) may be tackled to make change possible.</p><h4><strong>The supply-demand debate</strong></h4><p>These two parts are the source of the main problem I find in The Age of Low Tech. The book shows that the technical side of the problem could be covered, but we are rather facing a political and economic problem. We are in a crossroads of inaction. The world is saturated with technical alternatives but lacks political imagination. I would agree that reading this book in 2019, five years after its publication, is an issue. We have gone through various COPs, new IPPC reports, increasing global temperatures, and, with mass protests and motionless political leaders, an adverse political scenario for environmental protection. Specialized audiences could say they have had enough illustration. But even if we were not specialists, even if we are just discovering low techs, this question about scale and collective, coordinated action remains.</p><p>This is problematic in two ways. In the first place, the economic mechanisms to push for action are not clear. The book is full of “it should be…” and “it is necessary…” language. Even if mail marketing, cars, or programmed obsolescence are products and practices that should be replaced by others, making that change in a market democracy is the real challenge. Much of the proposals are good wills that can only be implemented in a dictatorial system.</p><p>Bihouix is nevertheless cautious about this, he recognizes much of these proposals, if simply mandated, would become liberticidal, so he adopts an ethical and moral stance, talking to individuals, pushing for changes first at the personal level. Someone should renounce to using the car by self-constraint, than by an external obligation. But this is the source of a second problem, an ambiguous consideration of supply and demand approaches for implementation. The author is explicitly against a certain type of supply-side ecologists that push for green-growth solutions (e.g. replacing classic electric plants for renewable ones), and instead is in favor of demand-side ecologists that would push for de-growth solutions (e.g. unplugging televisions). This perspective heads in the right perspective, but, by focusing on this particular demand-side solutions, misses the discussion about collective and coordinated action.</p><p>Collective action is an absent topic in <em>The Age of Low Tech</em>. How are we going to coordinate the change in the demand side that the book is pushing for? In a moment of crisis and urgent action, a leadership discussion is much needed. This will certainly not come through conscious persons who have read this kind of literature and, one by one will start making a change in the world. The individualistic perspective has, at least in 2019, proven short. Collective action will either need to come through social organization and direct action or through supply-side mechanisms. Indeed, by rejecting the supply-side ecologists, Bihouix misses the most relevant position to push for systemic, overarching changes. It is not only possible but necessary to be a de-growth advocate on the supply side. For example, when mentioning the Jevons Paradox, Bihouix position is fatalistic. Nevertheless, States can find mechanisms to discourage additional consumption when resource use gains are achieved through innovation. This might legitimate technological innovation, but low tech literature needs to explore how the modesty and sobriety perspectives might also be applied to high tech developments. Another example has to do with the banking and financial systems, their dependence on permanent and growing credit, and the effect this has on economic growth. Bihouix does not consider, for instance, increasing the cash reserve ratio, as a measure to reduce secondary emission. This type of simple (although polemic) measures are in line with low tech principles, but as they belong to the State and public policy, they do not enter into the book’s reflections.</p><p>This is symptomatic of the lack of consideration given to the design of new institutions. <em>The Age of Low Tech,</em> as happens with mainstream low tech literature, speaks to the individual, but presents a set of proposals that cannot be attained by individuals. This is what happens, for example, in its Epilogue where the book calls for resistance. “<em>Resistons</em>”, it says. Yes, a new type of resistance, but resistance after all. It is the same script social movements have been following for decades. One may resist injustice, but building a better future requires organization.</p><p>Finally, on this issue also comes about the globalization discussion proposed by Bihouix. He does bring some interesting points, admitting the difficulties a low tech agenda will face in a globalized world. On the one side, there is a prisoner dilemma because a wide, early adoption of slow techs will probably make an economy more vulnerable to others. The first mover could lose, except if he manages to create a standard that others will need to adopt, as it happened with the United Kingdom after the abolition of slavery in the mid-XIX century. Here the key factor was the UK, the most powerful country at the time. Today, any type of slow tech adoption will necessarily pass by the United States, and this question is not even touched by the book. This will certainly require complex political processes, and to do it, more collective action.</p><p>But the other side of the globalization debate left unfinished by Bihouix is the type of international, multi-stakeholder coordination that should happen to push for these types of changes. This is inexistent in the book. Without more solid and tangible institutional mechanisms (even at the advocacy level), it will be difficult to even envision a minor adoption of low tech. As a philosophy and an ethical stance towards life, it could remain a niche phenomenon, but the planetary crisis calls for scale.</p><h4><strong>The digital question</strong></h4><p>For its publication year, <em>The Age of Low Tech</em> brings some remarkable insights into the understanding of the environmental impact of digital technologies. As a high tech, digital technologies are questioned in various parts of the book, both for their environmental direct impact as for their indirect contribution to the acceleration of the traditional economy.</p><p>Facts do not support the idea of zero marginal cost expressed by Jeremy Rifkin or Albert Wenger. “Once a piece of information is on the Internet, it can be accessed from anywhere on the network for no additional cost”<a href="#_ftn5">[5]</a>, says Wenger. “That additional YouTube video view? Marginal cost of zero. Additional access to Wikipedia? Marginal cost of zero. Additional traffic report delivered by Waze? Marginal cost of zero.”<a href="#_ftn6">[6]</a></p><p>Nonetheless, the French think-tank The Shift Project estimates that, by 2020, digital technologies would emit 4% of greenhouse gases or twice the emissions of air transportation<a href="#_ftn7">[7]</a>. This is represented in the energy required to keep data flowing, cooled data centers, and technological equipment production. Additionally, there is the question of the increasing material complexity hardware requires, depending each time more on rare materials, and using such small quantities per unit that it is almost impossible to recycle the materials.</p><p>So the direct environmental impact of digital technologies is a non-negligible reality. The biggest problem might come through their indirect impacts, although they are more difficult to measure. To Bihouix, the potential to build a smarter and more efficient economy through digital technologies is surpassed by the acceleration of the present, traditional economy through digital tech. A sample of this is that our pollution and resources consumption levels are higher today than they were before the massification of digital technologies.</p><p>Bihouix’s critical diagnostic goes beyond the environmental. He takes a holistic approach and explores different other related consequences of high tech. Reflecting on the nature of work in a mechanized and automated context, he points out that “because it always takes a human being to carry out maintenance and supply spare parts, it is even more so since the system is complex because there is also the one who ensures the maintenance of the tool of the maintainer, and so on”<a href="#_ftn8">[8]</a>. This is at the same time matched by the de-localizable jobs a digitally connected world facilitates. The matter is then not about job loss through technology, but about its transformation. This reflection matches the recent work published by Antonio Casilli, <em>En Attendant les Robots</em>, where, using novel qualitative data, he uncovers the recent myth of the great replacement of jobs by Artificial Intelligence. What is truly happening is the digitization and precarization of labor. The digital context as we know it then is problematic both for the acceleration of environmental impacts and the precarization of human labor.</p><p>Ultimately, this section exemplifies a recurring problem in <em>The Age of Low Tech:</em> good diagnostics do not match the roadmap for implementing solutions. In this case, Bihouix only proposal is adopting a sense of digital austerity. I would argue that a deeper exploration of institutional mechanisms (including complex digital ones like special software, sensing, and smart contracts) would provide a richer contribution to this debate.</p><h4><strong>The book’s legacy</strong></h4><p>I have been arguing that <em>The Age of Low Tech </em>paints a clear picture of ‘low tech’, but leaves ‘The Age’ promise midway through. Nevertheless, although not expressed by the author, I understand this book’s main contribution as a <em>recognition </em>of the problems and alternative principles at hand, based on Axel Honneth’s notion of recognition as the central element of social conflicts. The individual application of its teachings is possible and desirable. The collective scenarios it depicts are nothing more than a utopia.</p><p>One other way to describe this piece is as ‘draft ecology’: written experimentations of a desirable situation, this time strengthening a new ecological approach based on sobriety, the recognition of material limits of technology, and that solutions should be socio-technical, not technologic. But it is not enough yet to build a new paradigm. Probably it will be up to Bihouix’s most recent book, <em>Le Bonheur était pour demain, </em>where his message could begin to take a political content. But on what concerns <em>The Age of Low Tech</em>, I read on its pages the desperate cry of an engineer that sees the madness we live in, presenting a hard and critical diagnosis, but lacking concrete operationalizable solutions for a complex political and economic context.</p><h4><strong>Footnotes</strong></h4><p><a href="#_ftnref1">[1]</a> <a href="https://www.overshootday.org/">https://www.overshootday.org/</a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref2">[2]</a> Zapata, Ricardo (2019). “A new social contract or a mere blank check?”, <a href="https://medium.com/@RZapataL/a-blank-check-or-a-new-social-contract-28077b0828f0">https://medium.com/@RZapataL/a-blank-check-or-a-new-social-contract-28077b0828f0</a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref3">[3]</a> P. 113</p><p><a href="#_ftnref4">[4]</a> Note that this concept is neutral about the ultimate variability in resource consumption.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref5">[5]</a> Wenger, A (2018). <a href="https://continuations.com/post/170801220375/world-after-capital-digital-technology-zero">World After Capital: Digital Technology (Zero Marginal Cost)</a>. <a href="https://continuations.com/post/170801220375/world-after-capital-digital-technology-zero">https://continuations.com/post/170801220375/world-after-capital-digital-technology-zero</a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref6">[6]</a> Ibid.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref7">[7]</a> The Shift Project (2019). « Climat : l’insoutenable usage de la vidéo en ligne » : le nouveau rapport du Shift sur l’impact environnemental du numérique <a href="https://theshiftproject.org/article/climat-insoutenable-usage-video/">https://theshiftproject.org/article/climat-insoutenable-usage-video/</a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref8">[8]</a> P. 162.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=7fe61448a91e" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Sobre la condición humana en la era digital]]></title>
            <link>https://rzapatal.medium.com/trinos-del-pasado-la-condici%C3%B3n-humana-y-el-mundo-digital-78eab9356c68?source=rss-603c21b946c0------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/78eab9356c68</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[digital-rights]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[human-parts]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[privacy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[digital-world]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[sociology]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ricardo Zapata Lopera]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 15 Feb 2020 12:00:16 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-04-26T11:49:18.891Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*AryEUFFgGBuREbfD" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@markusspiske?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Markus Spiske</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p><strong><em>La vida cotidiana, llena de ambigüedades, de incoherencias, de cambios de opinión, se estrella contra la racionalidad propia del mundo digital.</em></strong></p><p>El mundo digital es implacable: todo lo registra, todo lo recuerda. Sin pensar en sus efectos, hemos cambiado la naturaleza misma de nuestras interacciones sociales a medida que las hemos trasladado a canales digitales. Si antes una conversación con familia o amigos era un momento que se quedaba sólo en los recuerdos, hoy su registro es casi permanente y se nos devuelve cuando el contexto, las opiniones, los conocimientos y la vida misma han cambiado. Lo que pueden ser frases fugaces, pensamientos repentinos, actos del subconsciente captados por cualquier canal digital, sólo por el hecho de quedar sistemáticamente registrados tienen el potencial de redefinirnos ante los demás y ante nosotros mismos. Esta cuestión se amplifica cuando somos nosotros quienes cedemos a esta nueva lógica y de forma voluntaria, muchas veces entusiasta, exponemos nuestra vida y pensamientos a cambio de un poco de valoración social. Detrás de esto se impone un nuevo principio, el de la transparencia, que apasionadamente promovemos como si se tratara de un nuevo peldaño en la evolución de la ética.</p><p>Es así como los escándalos recurrentes en las redes sociales se convierten en una especie de portal para entender mejor la condición de nuestra era digital. No es una mera eventualidad el descubrimiento de unos trinos del pasado que dejan mal parada a una figura pública. Es una situación estructural, relacionada con el diseño de las tecnologías y la forma en que las usamos. Pero en realidad solo descubrimos lo evidente: que los famosos también mienten, que los políticos tienen sexo, o que alguien puede ser o haber sido racista, xenófobo o idiota. Sin embargo, nos fascina descubrir la humanidad de los demás y el mundo digital, con su transparencia casi absoluta, nos lo facilita.</p><p>A esto se suma que en Colombia el discurso de la tecnología suele estar más asociado con la innovación y el progreso. Poco nos detenemos a pensar qué es lo que realmente estamos adoptando. Buscamos digitalizar más y que la transformación digital llegue a todo rincón, creando aplicaciones para cada problema y automatizando cuanto proceso sea posible. Pero tanto espejismo, ¿acaso no tiene consecuencias?</p><p>Las tecnologías no son neutrales, o como <a href="https://twitter.com/evgenymorozov/status/1227496657756901377">sugería</a> Evgeny Morozov, “las tecnologías que tenemos son una función de las relaciones de poder, y también lo son sus efectos”. Justamente, las redes sociales están hechas para capitalizar la atención y, por eso los escándalos explotan con tanta facilidad. Nos incitan a producir contenidos constantemente, siempre a costa de desnudarnos cada vez un poco más. Sin embargo, no se trata únicamente de las redes sociales, sino de una lógica más amplia de la digitalización reciente: el registro permanente de todo acontecimiento para ser rentabilizado mediante distintas formas de procesamiento de datos. Y acá regresan las redes sociales: digitalizar no es automático, requiere que personas comunes y corrientes estén constantemente produciendo contenidos. La mayoría lo hace a cambio de ‘likes’, del placer de jugar a ser famosos. Otros porque ganan dinero o porque aspiran a ganarlo. A este fenómeno se le conoce como <em>digital labor</em> y ha sido <a href="https://www.casilli.fr/2019/02/11/los-trabajadores-del-clic-viento-sur-spain-11-feb-2019/">documentado</a>, entre muchos otros, por Antonio Casilli en <em>Los Trabajadores del Clic</em>.</p><p>¿Nos enfrentamos a una suerte de conspiración económica para rentabilizar nuestros comportamientos? Creo que hay es un cambio social más profundo pues, a pesar de las constantes <a href="https://es.wikipedia.org/wiki/Revelaciones_sobre_la_red_de_vigilancia_mundial_(2013-2015)">advertencias</a> que hemos tenido, seguimos exponiendo ampliamente nuestra persona tanto para ser deseada como para ser vigilada.</p><p>En <a href="https://www.academia.edu/38571558/Book_Review_Exposed_desire_and_disobedience_in_the_digital_age_by_Bernard_Harcourt"><em>Expuestos: deseo y desobediencia en la era digital</em></a>, el teórico crítico Bernard Harcourt hace un recuento de diferentes metáforas que se han utilizado para sintetizar la condición social actual. Una metáfora como el “Gran Hermano” es comúnmente evocada, pero para Harcourt no es útil pues no considera el rol fundamental que juega el deseo. La metáfora de “El Estado de la vigilancia” ( <em>Surveillance State</em>, en inglés) se ha vuelto popular a partir de las revelaciones de Wikileaks y Snowden, pero pareciera más bien que, de acuerdo con el sociólogo David Lyon, vivimos en una cultura de vigilancia donde entidades no públicas y los individuos juegan un rol igual de relevante. Como hemos visto, no se necesita una agencia de inteligencia para revelar comprometedores mensajes del pasado.</p><p>Otra popular metáfora es el “panóptico”, que evoca una noción de disciplina o la erradicación de todo trastorno, mientras que Harcourt encuentra, recordando a Foucault, que nuestra realidad tiene más relación con la idea de <em>securité,</em> que tolera perturbaciones menores, pero se enfoca en optimizar objetivos. Esto lleva a Harcourt a concluir que vivimos en una “sociedad de la exposición”, ilustrada por el pabellón de vidrio espejado ( <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2014/04/30/arts/design/hedge-two-way-mirror-walkabout-at-the-met-museum.html">mirrored glass pavilion</a>, en inglés). Esta sociedad está caracterizada por la transparencia, la seducción, la autenticidad virtual y por narrativas y confesiones digitales, conviviendo contradictoriamente con una opacidad fenomenal por parte de los proveedores tecnológicos. Es decir, publicamos sin límites basados en la transparencia como valor fundamental, mientras la privacidad se convierte en una mercancía costosa y la infraestructura tecnológica es inescrutable.</p><p>Pareciera un fenómeno inatajable que escapar de las tecnologías que nos rastrean es inviable, que limitarse a una vida social <em>análoga </em>es imposible, que nuestro futuro profesional y personal depende de qué tan bien nos vendemos en línea. Desconectarse es tanto un lujo como una tragedia. Hoy se popularizan las escuelas sin pantallas para los trabajadores pudientes de Silicon Valley. Las personas ‘importantes’ no tienen que ser esclavos de un celular inteligente para gestionar su vida digital; alguien más lo hace por ellos. Al mismo tiempo, en países como Colombia un <a href="https://www.mintic.gov.co/portal/inicio/Sala-de-Prensa/Columnas-Ministra-TIC/82174:Sentido-de-urgencia-Cerrar-la-brecha-digital">segmento</a> de la población permanece desconectado y <a href="https://www.fedesarrollo.org.co/sites/default/files/8.iml-agosto_2018-web.pdf">otro tanto</a> no tiene las capacidades para competir en un mercado laboral que da por sentado las habilidades de un nativo digital. Incluso los movimientos sociales, para quienes las nuevas tecnologías traían promesas de emancipación y extensión de la democracia, se han dado cuenta que la lógica misma de las herramientas digitales empodera más a grupos conservadores establecidos, como <a href="https://lareviewofbooks.org/article/the-revolution-wont-be-live-tweeted-on-jen-schradies-the-revolution-that-wasnt-how-digital-activism-favors-conservatives/">documentó</a> Jen Schradie en <em>La revolución que no fue</em>.</p><p>No creo que negar la sociedad de la exposición sea el camino. No se trata de volver a un pasado idealizado, sino de construir un presente más justo. La pregunta no sólo está en qué tanto debemos resistir a los abusos que se cometen en esta era digital, sino en qué tanto debemos resistir a la mano totalizadora de la digitalización. La inversión del valor de la transparencia absoluta por la defensa de la privacidad, la austeridad y la higiene digital es un punto de partida personal. Podemos desobedecer a la lógica de la exposición de muchas formas y ser críticos sobre cómo nos envuelve. Un mismo celular que registra los abusos de la autoridad en una protesta puede acabar con la reputación de una persona que tuvo un mal día en el transporte público. Es clave guardar límites y rechazar la cultura de la vigilancia que, con tantas herramientas al alcance de la mano, fácilmente nos seduce. Si bien el Internet ha acortado las distancias sociales y pareciera que de la urbe anónima del siglo XX regresamos a la aldea donde todos se reconocen, es clave defender la privacidad como un derecho humano fundamental. Hemos aprendido en las últimas décadas que lo privado es político, pero no necesariamente de escrutinio público.</p><p>Todo esto puede ir vinculado a muchas otras acciones como la extensión del movimiento de datos abiertos; una mayor protección y garantías para los informantes de abusos estatales (conocidos como <em>whistleblowers</em>, en inglés); el desarrollo de <a href="https://medium.com/iipp-blog/the-unlikely-tech-giant-empowering-citizens-through-data-7ffa7282a7ba">tecnologías</a> que devuelvan el control de la información personal a sus usuarios; la regulación del manejo de datos sensibles como los biométricos (hoy un tema necesario de cara a los <a href="https://lasillavacia.com/silla-llena/red-de-la-innovacion/cuatro-cosas-podrian-salir-mal-la-cedula-digital-71982">riesgos</a> que traería la nueva cédula digital); o el desarrollo de <a href="https://luminategroup.com/posts/news/its-time-for-a-bill-of-data-rights">nuevos derechos digitales</a>. Por ejemplo, la legislación de protección de datos <a href="https://es.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reglamento_General_de_Protecci%C3%B3n_de_Datos">europea</a> cuenta con derechos que no existen o no están regulados en Colombia, como <a href="https://www.eltiempo.com/tecnosfera/novedades-tecnologia/derecho-al-olvido-en-colombia-la-regulacion-sigue-pendiente-419468">el derecho al olvido</a>, la portabilidad de datos y las restricciones en la toma de decisiones a partir del procesamiento automatizado de datos. Las nuevas tecnologías digitales dependen de la captura sistemática de datos y, con ello, encuentran las maneras, a veces impensables, para registrar nuestros movimientos, nuestras emociones, nuestros comportamientos, buscando hacernos más predecibles y manipulables, tal como lo <a href="https://www.project-syndicate.org/onpoint/surveillance-capitalism-exploiting-behavioral-data-by-shoshana-zuboff-2020-01/spanish?barrier=accesspaylog">relata</a> Shoshana Zuboff en <em>Capitalismo de Vigilancia</em>.</p><p>No obstante, la defensa de la privacidad puede llevar a caminos resbalosos. Existe una <a href="https://www.generationlibre.eu/en/personnal-data-ownership-1/">mirada</a> liberal que busca profundizar el mercado para el control de la privacidad. Dice que, si pudiéramos poseer nuestros propios datos y ser remunerados por su uso, estaríamos recuperando el valor que algunos extraen al procesarlos. Esta mirada pasa de largo que, por un lado, un dato no tiene valor intrínseco; lo adquiere cuando está en relación con otros; y, por otro lado, que la privacidad no es solamente un derecho personal, sino un bien común. Al respecto, Martin Tisné <a href="https://luminategroup.com/posts/blog/data-isnt-the-new-oil-its-the-new-co2">sugiere</a> que los datos no son el nuevo petróleo, sino el nuevo CO2. En casos como el escándalo de Cambridge Analytica, aunque miles de datos personales fueron extraídos sin autorización, el mayor daño lo sufrió el proceso democrático. La defensa de la privacidad es la defensa de la autonomía individual, un pilar básico de la democracia.</p><p>No parece que la montaña rusa de escándalos tuiteros vaya a parar pronto, ni que los videos indiscretos o las noticias falsas dejen de circular por los grupos de Whatsapp. La vida cotidiana, llena de ambigüedades, de incoherencias, de cambios de opinión, se estrella contra la racionalidad propia del mundo digital. Podemos dejar que este camino siga su curso, sin control social, sólo con la dirección que imponen las pocas personas con las capacidades técnicas para crear y sostener las infraestructuras digitales que habitamos. Pero también podemos intentar otro camino, uno que involucre desde al cambio de comportamientos individuales y desarrollo de una ética digital comprensiva, hasta el establecimiento de nuevos derechos y la promoción de otras formas de desarrollo tecnológico.</p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://lalineadelmedio.com/sofiagomezuribe-condicionhumana-mundodigital/"><em>https://lalineadelmedio.com</em></a><em> on February 15, 2020.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=78eab9356c68" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[El paro nacional: cuatro futuros posibles]]></title>
            <link>https://rzapatal.medium.com/el-paro-nacional-cuatro-futuros-posibles-69dcfc4e7808?source=rss-603c21b946c0------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/69dcfc4e7808</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[protesta]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[paro-nacional]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[game-theory]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[colombia]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ricardo Zapata Lopera]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 09 Dec 2019 17:53:28 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-12-09T20:23:32.519Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>¿Qué sentido hacen propuestas como las asambleas ciudadanas, la conversación nacional o la mesa de negociación? Un análisis del juego de posibles estrategias entre Gobierno y el paro.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/proxy/0*O03hLiy6sR4NJ-H-.jpg" /><figcaption>(Foto: <a href="https://aztecaamerica.com/2019/12/03/colombia-se-prepara-para-mas-marchas-y-otro-paro-nacional-en-contra-de-gobierno-de-duque/">Aztecamerica</a>)</figcaption></figure><p>No podemos decir que el paro nacional que inició el pasado 21 de noviembre siga siendo un paro. En realidad, las últimas semanas han estado caracterizadas por una movilización ciudadana sin precedentes, simbolizada por cacerolas, <em>performances </em>artísticos, marchas, plantones, debates públicos y un permanente activismo digital. El hecho de parar se ha convertido en una expresión más. Me referiré como paro nacional a todo este sancocho de ciudadanía activa.</p><p>Este paro es el fenómeno político ciudadano más relevante de los últimos tiempos en Colombia porque, más allá de su impacto, ha surgido de la acción colectiva espontánea y ha sido capaz de hacer escuchar su voz. Lo que empezó como una acción más de los grupos de presión organizados en el Comité Nacional del Paro fue rebasado por la participación mayoritaria de una ciudadanía no organizada, caracterizada por la multiplicidad de causas y miradas, una suerte de representación de <em>la multitud </em>de Negri y Hardt.</p><p>Por la misma emoción que suscita, el futuro del paro no es claro. La acción colectiva suele romantizarse, derivando en muchas expectativas de cambio. El problema surge cuando ésta se enfrenta a actores ‘gerenciales’ como el Gobierno, que imponen una dinámica más vertical y demandan representantes para dialogar. El paro, en su diversidad y bajo la presión del tiempo, se debate internamente sobre lo que representa y quiénes lo representan.</p><p>Hay varias formas de entender lo que puede seguir en este contexto. En su mayoría, dependen de cómo los dos principales actores, el Gobierno y el paro, resuelvan sus principales dilemas. Para entenderlo mejor, el siguiente modelo simplifica los escenarios futuros.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/876/0*2uvnwIc2zmbfT1M9.png" /></figure><h4><strong>¿Qué alternativas tiene cada actor?</strong></h4><p>Por un lado, el paro puede actuar de forma unificada o dispersa. Los debates sobre la legitimidad del Comité Nacional del Paro para negociar con el Gobierno son justamente muestra de este proceso. Actuar bajo un liderazgo unificado, como fue convocado, implica poner la representación en unos líderes con capacidad y legitimidad para hablar en nombre del paro. Puede que las demás voces del paro ‘callen y otorguen’ el liderazgo al Comité actual, pero también podrían pedir ser escuchadas y reclamar representación, resultando en una reconfiguración del Comité. El grado de unificación dependerá de la presión para negociar y la disposición de las élites internas de compartir el poder entre ellas.</p><p>Actuar de forma dispersa se parecería más a lo que vimos en días posteriores al 21N. Muchos grupos se manifiestan, la reivindicación no es única, los líderes no tienen legitimidad para hablar en nombre del paro y los opositores usan esta debilidad para ‘dividir y vencer’.</p><p>El Gobierno, por otro lado, tiene dos opciones relativamente simples. O actúa como lo ha venido haciendo o reconoce el descontento y concilia una salida.</p><p>Vale aclarar que las posibilidades que ofrece este modelo están basadas en lo que los actores hacen en la práctica. Es decir, no dependen de apelativos. Por ejemplo, si alguien dice querer negociar, pero en la práctica sabotea el diálogo, en realidad no está adoptando una actitud conciliadora. También supone que el paro no podrá ser infinito y que su vocación es buscar la conciliación.</p><h4><strong>¿Qué puede pasar?</strong></h4><p>Lo que podrá ocurrir dependerá del juego entre las posturas que adopte cada actor.</p><p>En primer lugar, si <strong>el Gobierno es inflexible y el paro se unifica verticalmente</strong>, veríamos un escenario de paro continuado. Esto podría estar ocurriendo actualmente y explicaría por qué se han prolongado los llamados a nuevas jornadas de paro. Sin embargo, es un escenario de tensión en el que cada actor mide las fuerzas del otro y necesariamente buscará un equilibrio, que puede llegar por un cambio de postura del Gobierno, la división o mutación de los liderazgos al interior del paro o la disolución completa del paro.</p><p>Una segunda posibilidad es que <strong>el Gobierno siga inflexible y el liderazgo al interior del paro se disperse</strong>. Como el paro se mantendría, la salida más conveniente la tendría que dar el Gobierno: una consulta pública para recibir sugerencias de mejora a las políticas actuales. La característica principal de cualquier consulta pública está en que alguien hace el filtro, guardando el poder de decisión. Este escenario es el de la conversación nacional que ha propuesto el Gobierno, algo muy parecido al <em>Grand Débat </em>que organizó el Gobierno Francés luego de las protestas de los chalecos amarillos. Los resultados de este debate (por ejemplo, en <a href="https://granddebat.fr/media/default/0001/01/a95c01efe99bf13294aa6b574bf445a0925fb40b.pdf">impuestos y gasto público</a> o en cantidad de datos para hacer <a href="https://t.co/o0MGpYbzvc?amp=1">análisis y visualizaciones</a>) no dejan de parecerse a una encuesta masiva a profundidad: mucha información y poca decisión. No obstante, es una estrategia suave de disolución del paro y poco disruptiva para el establecimiento.</p><p>En tercer lugar, si <strong>el paro mantiene un liderazgo unificado y el Gobierno se torna conciliador</strong>, nos arrojaría a un escenario de negociación. Este escenario es complejo porque la práctica suele diferir del discurso, siendo difícil saber si los actores realmente adoptan las posiciones que requiere una negociación. Por ejemplo, mientras el Gobierno mantiene abierta la mesa de negociación y su discurso es conciliador, podría estar empujando por debajo de la mesa estrategias dilatorias y divisorias.</p><p>El cuarto escenario sería la situación menos próxima en el contexto actual, pues dependería de <strong>una actitud conciliadora del gobierno y una permanencia del paro, a pesar de la dispersión de sus liderazgos</strong>. En esta situación el Gobierno daría legitimidad al descontento generalizado y, como nadie puede atribuirse la vocería del paro, la única forma de resolver la diversidad de demandas ciudadanas sería utilizando mecanismos genuinos de democracia deliberativa. Éstos se caracterizan por la toma de decisiones colectivas e informadas. Es decir, sí hay un resultado final, que puede variar desde una recomendación hasta un mandato. Las asambleas ciudadanas son el mecanismo deliberativo más utilizado en la actualidad, tal cual lo está <a href="https://carnegieeurope.eu/2019/11/26/new-wave-of-deliberative-democracy-pub-80422">documentando</a> el equipo de gobierno abierto de la OCDE y lo ha <a href="https://twitter.com/rey_salamanca/status/1199727438361776128">propuesto</a> el profesor Felipe Rey.</p><h4><strong>Entonces, ¿hacia dónde nos llevará el paro?</strong></h4><p>Si bien es imposible predecir el futuro, un modelo simplificado como el que se ha presentado puede ayudar a entender cómo se entretejen las estrategias de ambos actores a la luz de sus dilemas internos.</p><p>Una primera conclusión evidente es que el Gobierno juega un rol privilegiado (al menos en apariencia), pues tiene claridad sobre su unidad de mando, capacidades para actuar rápidamente, superioridad de información y puede escoger si concilia o mantiene su postura. Sin embargo, juega en su contra el costo político de la inacción, que ya se ha visto reflejado en las recientes <a href="https://www.elespectador.com/noticias/politica/desaprobacion-de-la-gestion-del-presidente-duque-llego-al-70-articulo-894297">encuestas de aprobación</a>.</p><p>El paro nacional, al ser por naturaleza una disrupción temporal, en el mediano plazo tiene que conciliar o disolverse. No obstante, en el corto plazo debe resolver su dilema de liderazgo. ¿Qué es el paro? ¿A quién representa? ¿Qué intereses y qué agenda política defiende? Si bien el Comité ha intentado posicionar <a href="https://lasillavacia.com/estas-son-las-peticiones-del-comite-del-paro-duque-74692">13 peticiones</a>, no todos los manifestantes las conocen, las comparten o han participado en su definición. Esta tensión interna sobre cómo unificar la propuesta del paro tiene mucho que ver con la idea de <a href="https://lasillavacia.com/silla-llena/blogoeconomia/la-batalla-de-las-elites-71802">dos élites</a> enfrentadas que describía Marc Hofstetter — una mirada realista que pasa por alto la relevancia que toman otras voces al interior del paro — .</p><p>Una segunda conclusión es que para el establecimiento es muy conveniente el argumento de que el paro es de todos. Legitima la conversación nacional y le otorga al Gobierno el rol de canalizador de esa indignación. No podemos negar que conversar es necesario en Colombia, más aún cuando no somos capaces de <a href="https://www.bbc.com/mundo/noticias-america-latina-50577978">acordar cuáles son nuestros problemas</a> o ponernos de acuerdo sobre la historia reciente. La conversación nacional es, ante todo, una deuda histórica que debería ocurrir como una herencia más del paro, no como su única salida.</p><p>La situación actual es políticamente compleja porque los escenarios más beneficiosos para la sociedad y la democracia son los menos probables o más difíciles de sostener. Esos son la democracia deliberativa y la negociación. Dada la popularidad de la que goza el paro y la poca voluntad que muestra el Gobierno para ceder a las peticiones del Comité del Paro, el equilibrio del sistema tiende hacia la conversación nacional. El problema es que esa historia ya la hemos visto y su impacto no estaría a la altura de las expectativas que ha generado el paro. Será la voluntad de cambio y capacidad para innovar políticamente la que permitirá un resultado mucho más provechoso para la sociedad en su conjunto.</p><p>*Estudiante de Política Pública y Nuevas Tecnologías, Sciences Po Paris. @rzapatal</p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://lalineadelmedio.com/el-paro-nacional-cuatro-futuros-posibles/"><em>https://lalineadelmedio.com</em></a><em> on December 9, 2019.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=69dcfc4e7808" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The algorithm that decided the destiny of thousands of families]]></title>
            <link>https://rzapatal.medium.com/the-algorithm-that-decided-the-destiny-of-many-families-7b374fa2574b?source=rss-603c21b946c0------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/7b374fa2574b</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[transparency]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[algorithms]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[digital-government]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[automation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[failure]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ricardo Zapata Lopera]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 06 Dec 2019 23:37:37 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-01-16T15:56:25.434Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>Or how inscrutable code can amplify human mistakes. A case study of La Buona Scuola teachers’ mobility algorithm in Italy.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/769/0*pYrmmzeT9i1-yu8B.jpg" /><figcaption>Teachers protest against the Buona Scuola educational reform (Source: <a href="http://contropiano.org/news/politica-news/2017/06/11/docenti-deportati-legge-107-de-profundis-la-scuola-pubblica-092789">Contropiano</a>)</figcaption></figure><p>What can happen when you poorly implement a simple but inscrutable allocation algorithm in the midst of a hectic political context? As part of a teachers’ mobility program in 2016, an algorithm was supposed to assign vacant positions across Italy to existent and new teachers. After its implementation, thousands of teachers found to be wrongly placed. News coverage began to unveil the personal drama of separated families and the insuficient explanations on the side of the Ministry of Education. The case was taken to courts, teachers were reassigned to new posts, and just until early-2019 Italy’s State Council ruled creating valuable jurisprudence in favor of better algorithmic accountability. <strong>This case brings automated public decisions to the center of debates around digital human rights when writing ‘rules as code’.</strong></p><h4>An education reform is born</h4><p><em>La Buona Scuola</em> (the Good School, in English) was an educational reform promoted in 2015 by the reformist, center-left Government of Matteo Renzi in Italy. This reform aimed to transform the school system introducing a series of actions in three main pillars.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*bA1J4bcSMEYg6Psgr9P8eg.png" /><figcaption><em>Table 1 — Buona Scuola reform summary (Source: self-construction, based on Universo Scuola</em><a href="#_ftn1"><strong><em>[1]</em></strong></a><em>)</em></figcaption></figure><p>The reform was finally approved as Law 107 of 2015, containing a set of dispositions that were to be developed in the next two years. Since its discussion, it sparked protests all around the country, being highly criticized by teachers’ unions and students’ groups<a href="#_ftn2">[2]</a>, claiming the introduction of neoliberal principles in the school system.</p><p>It is worth to say that Matteo Renzi’s reforms went through extensive debates around the country. The climax came when he lost the Referendum that was to approve a wide Constitutional Reform.<a href="#_ftn3">[3]</a> This led to his resignation in December 2016. Even though the Democratic Party continued in Government with Paolo Gentiloni until mid-2018, the implementation of the Buona Scuola was still mid-way. In April 2017 the Minister of Education issued the eight implementation decrees that Law 107 required.</p><p>In the midst of this process, a new scandal came to light. Product of the 100,000 recruitment plan (see Table 1) and a teachers’ mobility program, during the 2016–2017 school year, teachers were to be located in vacant positions around the country, based on their merits and location preferences. Around 210,000 transfers were demanded<a href="#_ftn4">[4]</a>. Of those, at least 10,000 teachers demanded explanations over why the program had placed them differently than they expected. After a two-year social and legal struggle to scrutinize the used algorithm, society was once again reminded that automating public decisions without the proper operational and ethical frameworks has the potential to amplify negative implications.</p><h4>The technological promise</h4><p>In a 117 million EUR contract, Italy’s Ministry of Education hired Hewlett-Packard (HP) Italia and Finmeccanica to manage various IT processes. Inside that contract, as it was discovered by various investigative journalists, the contractors were tasked with the creation of a software to manage the teachers’ mobility program. The cost of that item totaled 444,000 EUR<a href="#_ftn5">[5]</a>.</p><p>As explained in the following diagram, HP Italia and Finmeccanica where supposed to create an algorithm that assigned teachers to different vacant positions around the country. To do so, it had to consider the availability of the seats, together with teachers’ scores in merit-based tests and their location preferences.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/502/1*ZkEKaienWi7aDJ1tou3ZZg.png" /><figcaption>Logical sequence of teachers’ mobility algorithm (Source: La Sapienza and Tor Vergata universities<a href="#_ftn6"><strong>[6]</strong></a>)</figcaption></figure><p>Nevertheless, as teachers began complaining over the inconsistent results of the program, the ‘<em>Gilda degli Insegnanti</em>’ (Teachers’ Union) began a legal complaint with the Ministry of Education, after the latter denied supplying the information that would explain how the algorithm worked. Also asked about it, the contractors denied supplying information, arguing privacy of commercial contracts. “We do not comment on private commercial contracts. I think that the best opportunity will be to get in contact with the Ministry and see if they are willing to provide additional answers”<a href="#_ftn7">[7]</a>, they answered.</p><p>It was Lazio’s Regional Administrative Court who required the Ministry of Education to provide all technical material to allow an audit from the affected parties. The provided documentation didn’t allow to entirely replicate the algorithm’s operation, but after a preliminary evaluation of its source code, the auditors established “that the most basic programming criteria that are known to apply have not been observed. In fact — analysts write in the report — even in light of the simplicity of the requested operation, it is not clear what are the reasons that led the programmer to create a bombastic, redundant and non-maintenance-oriented system”<a href="#_ftn8">[8]</a>. Particularly, the use of COBOL programming language led the auditors to speculate that the algorithm was badly adapted from an older program. This language was used in the 60’s and 70’s, and only old systems keep using it due to the high costs of migration to other languages. For a new system like the teachers’ mobility software, it was an inexplicable choice.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*FUZW0riUNle_TVDDWssqBQ.png" /><figcaption><em>Involved actors (Source: self-construction)</em></figcaption></figure><p>The technical audit was ultimately not able to determine how the algorithm worked, thus, it couldn’t determine how it was exactly delivering a place assignment considering merit and preferences.</p><blockquote>“given the lack of [input data (rankings, teacher data, etc.)], it is not possible to understand whether these data were transferred to the company that developed the algorithm and processed by it or whether, once the algorithm was set up, it was transferred to the Ministry of Education which managed the operation (data input and output) until the appointment of the teachers. It is evident that the lack of such details, as well as the lack of the files referred to in the code, the database, the files that the software uses to read and write data (not so much in content as in form), as well as technical specifications, configures a conduct that is not very transparent, despite the order to show the data and documents by the TAR (Tribunali Amministrativi Regionali), against the ministry.”<a href="#_ftn9">[9]</a></blockquote><h4>The legacy of La Buona Scuola’s allocation algorithm</h4><p>The ‘Buona Scuola’ algorithm case brings two important lessons for algorithmic decision making. First, it illustrates the social and ethical implications of automation and digitisation, reminding of a simple but striking risk: the amplification of mistakes through technological solutions. Once a system is programmed, any wrong instruction will replicate undesired outcomes as data is crunched. This is particularly problematic when public decisions are at stake.</p><p>Nevertheless, one must remember that, as technology is ultimately created by humans, mistakes may happen. Coping with this may not require more than adjusting to the mechanisms already defined by contemporary, analogous administrative law. After determining the lack of impartiality, transparency and publicity in teachers’ allocation mechanism, the State Council’s final rule in April 2019<a href="#_ftn10">[10]</a> called to comply with the principles of reasonableness, proportionality, publicity and transparency<a href="#_ftn11">[11]</a>. As governments digitise and public decisions become more driven by data and automated procedures, they should be subject to <em>ex ante</em> and <em>ex post</em> control and scrutiny.</p><p>A second lesson this case brings about is that technification and digitisation do not necessarily correlate with neutrality. In other words, discretion is still present. Even more, due to the increased complexity, detecting the embedded principles and criteria for decision-making could be harder. This is important to bear in mind as public sector digitisation is happening amidst profound ongoing debates. For instance, in the Buona Scuola’s case there was resistance and scepticism to automation due to a general context of market-oriented management of education.</p><p>These two lessons suggest that public-interest algorithms should be knowable in all aspects, “<em>from its authors to the procedure used for its elaboration, to the decision mechanism, including the priorities assigned in the evaluation and decision-making procedure and the data selected as relevant” (</em>Consiglio di Stato, sentenza n. 2270, 8 aprile 2019<em>). </em>A radical and comprehensive stance for algorithmic transparency is a first but necessary step for the delivery of real public value by automated systems.</p><p>References:</p><p><a href="#_ftnref1">[1]</a> <a href="https://www.universoscuola.it/buona-scuola-cosa-prevede-normativa.htm#superpreside">https://www.universoscuola.it/buona-scuola-cosa-prevede-normativa.htm#superpreside</a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref2">[2]</a> <a href="https://www.huffingtonpost.it/2016/10/07/scuola-proteste_n_12384006.html">https://www.huffingtonpost.it/2016/10/07/scuola-proteste_n_12384006.html</a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref3">[3]</a> <a href="https://www.ft.com/content/bd39453e-baec-11e6-8b45-b8b81dd5d080">https://www.ft.com/content/bd39453e-baec-11e6-8b45-b8b81dd5d080</a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref4">[4]</a> <a href="https://www.repubblica.it/cronaca/2019/09/17/news/scuola_trasferimenti_di_10mila_docenti_lontano_da_casa_il_tar_l_algoritmo_impazzito_fu_contro_la_costituzione_-236215790/?refresh_ce">https://www.repubblica.it/cronaca/2019/09/17/news/scuola_trasferimenti_di_10mila_docenti_lontano_da_casa_il_tar_l_algoritmo_impazzito_fu_contro_la_costituzione_-236215790/?refresh_ce</a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref5">[5]</a> <a href="https://www.agi.it/cronaca/algoritmo_miur_assegnazioni_insegnanti-1896615/news/2017-06-20/">https://www.agi.it/cronaca/algoritmo_miur_assegnazioni_insegnanti-1896615/news/2017-06-20/</a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref6">[6]</a> <a href="http://www.gildains.it/news/dettaglio.asp?id=6398">http://www.gildains.it/news/dettaglio.asp?id=6398</a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref7">[7]</a> <a href="https://www.orizzontescuola.it/presadiretta-caos-scuola-mobilita-2016-lalgoritmo-resta-segreto-spesi-400mila-euro-il-video/">https://www.orizzontescuola.it/presadiretta-caos-scuola-mobilita-2016-lalgoritmo-resta-segreto-spesi-400mila-euro-il-video/</a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref8">[8]</a> <a href="https://www.orizzontescuola.it/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/Perizia-tecnica-preliminare-pdf.pdf">https://www.orizzontescuola.it/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/Perizia-tecnica-preliminare-pdf.pdf</a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref9">[9]</a> Ibid.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref10">[10]</a> Consiglio di Stato Sez. VI, sentenza n. 2270, 8 aprile 2019</p><p><a href="#_ftnref11">[11]</a> <a href="https://www.4clegal.com/settore-pubblico/lintelligenza-artificiale-tinge-diritto-0">https://www.4clegal.com/settore-pubblico/lintelligenza-artificiale-tinge-diritto-0</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=7b374fa2574b" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Ups and Downs of Human Resources Management Algorithms]]></title>
            <link>https://rzapatal.medium.com/ups-and-downs-of-human-resources-management-algorithms-1b3eb363f603?source=rss-603c21b946c0------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/1b3eb363f603</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[human-resources]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[human-resource-management]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[human-rights]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[algorithms]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[transparency]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ricardo Zapata Lopera]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 06 Dec 2019 22:45:04 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-12-06T23:55:27.689Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>Introduction to three use cases of HRM algorithms in public and private sectors</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*QvsYroNl0ujH6J7h" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@clemono2?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Clem Onojeghuo</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p><em>Written by </em><a href="https://medium.com/@aurore.guglielmi"><em>Aurore Guglielmi</em></a><em>, </em><a href="https://medium.com/@etheltanhy"><em>Ethel Tan</em></a><em>, </em><a href="https://medium.com/@yuxiwang"><em>Yuxi Wang</em></a><em> and </em><a href="https://medium.com/@rzapatal"><em>Ricardo Zapata</em></a></p><p>The digital transformation of certain sectors have been more rapid than others. Human resources management as a business function concerning the allocation of talent and labour touches on all sectors and has received significant attention of late.</p><p>According to IBM’s Global C-suite Study in 2018, 65% of CEOs surveyed across 112 countries expect skills management to have a significant impact on their businesses and require the creation of new strategies. The awareness is present. However, only 28% expect real action to be taken by their companies. This gap between expectations and reaction can be attributed to a host of factors — ranging from the changes and size of needs, the level and adoption of technology, the agility and inertia of actors, and the various legal, sociopolitical and economic consequences.</p><p>This work studies three cases of deploying artificial intelligence (AI) and algorithms in human resources management across the public and private sectors: Buona Scuola in Italy, Amazon in the US, and Precire in Germany. We will understand the forces pushing for and pushing against the incorporation of new technologies in human resources management.</p><p>To put this into context, we need to keep in mind that the stage and speed of adoption is still nascent but fast. IBM’s Global C-suite Study in 2018 found that most companies are struggling to build analytics capabilities in human resources. 41% of CEOs are not prepared to use data analytic tools and only 4% of CEOs are prepared to a large extent. Furthermore, a survey by LinkedIn in 2018 saw that less than one-quarter companies in North America have already adopted analytics inhuman resources. However, the need is strong, due to (1) competition for a limited talent pool; (2) complexities in human resources management (e.g. diversity, geolocation, hiring, benchmarking, branding); (3) quick development of human resources management innovation and technology. The nascent stage but fast speed of adoption creates a tension. There is considerable uncertainty and controversy involved — which will be illustrated in the case studies.</p><p>Nonetheless, a quick analysis of opportunities and challenges shows that there is still great potential to be tapped on to improve the processes and outcomes of human resources management. The capability of AI to conduct high-speed computation, stable and predictive analytics, and accuracy with quality data, is able to manage the heavy paperwork, repetitive administrative work, inherent psychology and bias involved in human resources management. We can end up with reduced decision-making bias, reduced administrative time, have access to better insights, improved strategic hiring and training and a personalised employee experience. However, many issues have yet to be properly addressed at a technology-, corporate policy-, and public policy-level — such as privacy and security, fairness, small data sets, integration and maintenance of the technology, accountability, liability, resistance to adoption. By looking at the following three case studies, we aim to address the challenges where applicable and identify best practices.</p><h4><strong>CASE I: BUONA SCUOLA | Italy</strong></h4><p><em>“The algorithm that decided the destiny of many families”</em></p><p>The Buona Scuola case deals with the poor implementation of simple allocation algorithm in the midst of a hectic political context. As part of a teachers’ mobility program in 2016, an algorithm was supposed to assign vacant positions across the country to existent and new teachers. After its implementation, thousands of teachers found to be wrongly placed. News coverage began to unveil the personal drama of separated families and the missing explanations on the side of the Ministry of Education. The case was taken to courts, teachers were reassigned to new posts, and just until early-2019 Italy’s State Council ruled creating valuable jurisprudence in favour of higher algorithmic accountability. This case is relevant as it brings transparent and explainable automated public decisions into the centre of debates around digital human rights.</p><p>Check <a href="https://medium.com/p/7b374fa2574b/">here</a> the complete story.</p><h4><strong>CASE II: AMAZON | United States</strong></h4><p><em>Discriminatory AI hiring system</em></p><p>Amazon’s experimental hiring tool used artificial intelligence to give job candidates scores ranging from one to five stars — much like shoppers rate products on Amazon.” Amazon’s team has been building machine learning program to review job applications since 2014. However, the system did not rate candidates for software developer jobs and other technical positions in a gender-neutral way. The data being fed into the system come from successful applicants to Amazon over a 10-year period. Unfortunately, the data set is biased against female applicants because there is an overwhelming majority of male dominance across the tech industry especially for technical jobs.</p><p><strong>CASE III: PRECIRE | Germany</strong></p><p>Precire is a new speech analysis software particularly dedicated to Human Resources. It helps recruiters assess stress levels and psychological stability of candidates. The software analyses your voice digitally, looking at your voice variation, vocabulary and syntax. It will therefore be able to determine your personality, your strengths and weakness. Based on its finding, it will provide recruiters with diagrams and charts summarizing those traits. The form is therefore more important than the content. In the case of Precire, the software runs without any human intervention. It is supposed to be able to determine ‘artificial emotional intelligence’ more accurately than any human. For instance, use of words such as partly or slightly will make the candidate stand out as insecure.</p><p><strong>LESSONS LEARNED &amp; CONCLUSION</strong></p><p>AI in human resources management can have a strong potential to raise employee engagement and productivity.<strong> </strong>It is essential to combine (1) people, (2) process and (3) technology to deliver transformational value at an optimised cost. Employees are most affected so it is crucial to focus on their needs and outcomes.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/602/1*vDwXSnBxmLhebDIuTkMYOg.png" /></figure><p><em>This post was written for the “</em><a href="http://formation.sciences-po.fr/enseignement/2019/k2sp/3015"><em>Data &amp; Algorithms for Public Policy</em></a><em>” class instructed by </em><a href="https://medium.com/u/c26a8fae0914?source=post_page-----a480775a336a----------------------"><em>Simon Chignard</em></a><em>, </em><a href="https://medium.com/u/c78ea8876723?source=post_page-----a480775a336a----------------------"><em>Timothée GIDOIN</em></a><em> and </em><a href="https://medium.com/u/13168ffc025d?source=post_page-----a480775a336a----------------------"><em>Jean-marie JOHN MATHEWS</em></a><em> at the</em><a href="http://www.sciencespo.fr/public/en"><em> Sciences Po Paris School of Public Affairs</em></a><em> as part of the “</em><a href="https://www.sciencespo.fr/public/en/content/digital-new-technology-and-public-policy.html"><em>Digital, New Technology &amp; Public Policy</em></a><em>” master policy stream courses.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=1b3eb363f603" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A new social contract or a mere blank check?]]></title>
            <link>https://rzapatal.medium.com/a-blank-check-or-a-new-social-contract-28077b0828f0?source=rss-603c21b946c0------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/28077b0828f0</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[surveillance]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[austerity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[gig-economy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[environment]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[digital-transformation]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ricardo Zapata Lopera]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 17 Oct 2019 21:54:45 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-06-13T22:56:54.708Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>Four things to know before thinking about a new ‘social contract’ for the digital age</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*9JGz9Ls91C5imUCD" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@joeldevriend?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Joël de Vriend</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p>Let’s easily put this: there are many things we don’t know are happening behind or as a product of digital technologies. Not nice things, worrying things. But our society is obnubilated by tech discourse and we can only think about all the solutions it can bring to our troubled world. The narrative goes on to say that we are in the midst of a revolution (the <a href="https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2016/01/the-fourth-industrial-revolution-what-it-means-and-how-to-respond/">4th</a> for some, the <a href="https://medium.com/iipp-blog/second-machine-age-or-fifth-technological-revolution-part-2-db42863a8df8">5th</a> for others) and it’s time to forge <strong>a new social contract</strong> to make the unleashed forces of such disruptive technologies work for society.</p><p>And I would agree. We are indeed in the midst of a moment of tensions and the power inequalities brought by digital technologies should be re-balanced. Work, democracy, the public sector, and life in itself will not continue the same. But <strong>before running on to sign a new contract, we should know what’s the deal about</strong>. We’ve been told it was about solutions but I certainly don’t see that we as a society even manage to grasp what’s really at stake. A new social contract today is just a mere blank check to big tech capital, the digital economy is not what we have heard of and slowly we discover the truth behind it.</p><p>In the next paragraphs I will argue that, <strong>at least in four ways, digital technologies are not fulfilling their promise</strong>. Quite the contrary. To solve it, and as a condition to bet for a new social contract, I suggest we should work on building consensus over stronger accountability from big digital players and improving the democratic control we have over value creation.</p><h4><strong>First: self-determination and democracy are at risk</strong></h4><p>Shoshana Zuboff’s idea of <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Surveillance_capitalism">Surveillance Capitalism</a> describes the mechanisms that operate in the digital economy to extract what she calls “behavioral surplus”, a situation when more data are rendered than required for service improvements. The surplus data is used to feed machine intelligence that fabricates predictions of user behavior and sells them in behavioral futures markets for profit maximization. This logic drives the need for more data extraction for the sake of making predictions, comparable to guaranteed outcomes in real-life behavior. This extraction began online, but today has gone for getting data from the physical world, our daily life, and our bodies and selves, ultimately betting on modifying our behavior.</p><p>Zuboff, as a psychologist, develops a well-grounded reflection on how digital technologies are, ultimately, getting their power from an unequal division of learning, in which their owners get to know more of ourselves than we do, having in their hands the “means of behavioral modification”. For Zuboff, what is at stake is ultimately the individual’s self-determination. This is not just a human right, but the basic component of what we understand as democracy.</p><p>The problem is not a private one. It is not just the individual’s privacy and autonomy that are at risk. The problem is shared, and, as such, any solution or alternative must also be grounded in collective action.</p><h4><strong>Second: automation is a chimera, digital technologies are labor-intensive</strong></h4><p>The digital transformation is intensifying the precariousness of human work. In “<a href="http://www.seuil.com/ouvrage/en-attendant-les-robots-antonio-a-casilli/9782021401882">The Workers of the Click</a>”, Antonio Casilli documents a phenomenon that we are just discovering: the digital economy and artificial intelligence are neither disappearing nor automating human labor, but digitizing it. With this, they convert the human productive gesture into sub-paid or unpaid micro-operations, because it considers them too small, not very obvious, too playful, or of little added value. Digital labor on-demand (Uber or Taskrabbit), micro-working (Amazon Mechanical Turk or UHRS) and networked social work (Facebook or Snapchat) are the three major modalities that Casilli distinguishes.</p><p>For example, Yann LeCun, VP and Chief AI Scientist at Facebook, <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RgUcQceqC_Y&amp;feature=youtu.be">explains </a>that the advances in AI are not due so much to the improvement of scientific methods during the last years, but due to the increasing availability of hundreds of millions of images, texts, and sounds examples distributed in millions of categories. Casilli argues that platform value has not come through the “user-generated content”, but through the “user-generated content classification”.</p><p>What we are understanding today is that digital platforms and ‘artificial intelligence’ really depend on a high dose of human work, either to train algorithms, nurture databases or, in many cases, to pretend that something is automatic (thanks to micro-tasking). Nevertheless, the labor required to accomplish it is outsourced, fragmented and, sometimes, hired under precarious conditions.</p><p>For Casilli, this is not a temporary phenomenon, as might be thought. He argues that as long as AI seeks to reach the level of human intelligence, the latter will also move so that the distance that separates them will never be erased. Human intelligence transforms and adapts to new practices, and AI will require perpetual updates that, as today, only the humans will be able to operate.</p><h4><strong>Third: who’s controlling public decisions?</strong></h4><p>The most recent <a href="https://www.ohchr.org/en/NewsEvents/Pages/DisplayNews.aspx?NewsID=25156&amp;LangID=E">report </a>by Philip Alston, UN’s Special Rapporteur on extreme poverty and human rights, “produced a devastating account of how new digital technologies are revolutionizing the interaction between governments and the most vulnerable in society. In what he calls the rise of the “digital welfare state”, billions of dollars of public money is now being invested in automated systems that are radically changing the nature of social protection”, as reported by <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2019/oct/16/digital-welfare-state-big-tech-allowed-to-target-and-surveil-the-poor-un-warns">The Guardian</a>.</p><p>Alston argues that “the digitization of welfare systems has very often been used to promote deep reductions in the overall welfare budget, a narrowing of the beneficiary pool, the elimination of some services, the introduction of demanding and intrusive forms of conditionality, the pursuit of behavioral modification goals, the imposition of stronger sanctions regimes, and a complete reversal of the traditional notion that the state should be accountable to the individual.”</p><p>Hand in hand with the development of artificial intelligence and smart contracts, changes are emerging in the way we regulate and control the processes that affect us as a society. These technologies involve decision making through algorithms where the code becomes the law and accessing it becomes a matter of technical expertise. Its opacity, little transparency, and virtually no accountability are the biggest problems. Additionally, regulation and control by public authorities is still a challenge, although it is possible to think of ways to influence the governance of these systems. Particularly in blockchain-based applications, their distributed and transnational nature allows them to be resilient to the intervention of external actors. With this, a democratic tension is generated: where is the responsibility? Under what criteria are decisions made? Can the public regulator intervene in case of violation of rights? Does it have the technical capabilities to do it?</p><h4><strong>Fourth: zero marginal cost? Digital technologies have a material limit</strong></h4><p>We have been told that digital technologies are fully scalable. A criterion of infinity is part of the digital mindset. Albert Wenger best described this in his book “World After Capital”, where he <a href="https://continuations.com/post/170801220375/world-after-capital-digital-technology-zero">suggests </a>that “Once a piece of information is on the Internet, it can be accessed from anywhere on the network for no additional cost”. This is the idea of zero marginal cost.</p><blockquote>That additional YouTube video view? Marginal cost of zero. Additional access to Wikipedia? Marginal cost of zero. Additional traffic report delivered by Waze? Marginal cost of zero.</blockquote><p>But the material side of the digital is out of this perspective. Think about it in three ways. The direct impacts of the production and use of ICTs (information and communication technologies) on the environment are the most obvious ones. But there are also indirect impacts related to the effect of ICTs on production processes, products, and distribution systems. Finally, there’s also the structural/behavioral impacts related to the stimulation of structural change and growth in the economy by ICTs, and the impacts on lifestyles and value systems. These last two might be positive and negative. This is the framework developed by <a href="https://www.researchgate.net/publication/240173973_De-materialising_and_re-materialising_Digital_technologies_and_the_environment">Berkhout and Hertin</a> back in 2004.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/567/0*YlqFjW0UhbRfUFk7" /><figcaption>Source: Berkhout, F., &amp; Hertin, J. (2004). De-materialising and re-materialising: digital technologies and the environment. Futures, 36(8), 903–920.</figcaption></figure><p>It is striking to look at some direct impacts. The French think-tank <a href="https://theshiftproject.org/article/climat-insoutenable-usage-video/">The Shift Project</a> estimates that digital technologies would emit 4% of greenhouse gas emissions in 2020 (2,1 GT). That’s half of the emissions of the light vehicles sector (8%) and twice the emissions of air transportation (2%). For example, just video streaming would emit as much CO2 as Spain (300 Mt per year). The troubling aspect is that the global energy consumption of digital media grows by 9 percent per year.</p><p>Take the case of revolutionary technologies like blockchain. O’Dwyer and Malone <a href="http://karlodwyer.com/publications/pdf/bitcoin_KJOD_2014.pdf">estimated </a>the energy requirements of the Bitcoin Network in 2014. They suggested that the total power used for Bitcoin mining was around 0.1–10GW. As a reference, the average Irish electrical energy demand and production is estimated at around 3GW.</p><p>Yet, the problem is not just energy consumption. Waste production from tech hardware is becoming a significant problem. Just in the European Union around 350,000 tons of electronic waste are exported to emerging countries, according to the NGO Basel Action Network. And the number of smartphone devices has skyrocketed. While in 2013 its numbers amounted to 1,7 billion, it is <a href="https://theshiftproject.org/article/climat-insoutenable-usage-video/">estimated </a>that by 2020 they could increase up to 5,8 billion units. These devices <a href="https://www.techradar.com/news/phone-and-communications/mobile-phones/our-smartphone-addiction-is-costing-the-earth-1299378">need</a> scarce materials and, yes, the production of one gram of a smartphone still needs 80 times more energy than producing one gram of a car.</p><p>Some people will throw out that, with time, we’ll find <a href="https://www.forbes.com/sites/annapowers/2019/03/04/researchers-may-have-found-a-greener-way-to-extract-the-rare-earth-metals-your-smartphone-needs/#7edb946d30c3">more efficient</a> ways of production and the direct impacts could be mitigated. But what remains through all discussions about the environmental impacts of digital technologies is a permanent tension between the potential to build a smarter and more efficient economy through digital tech, and the acceleration of the present, traditional economy facilitated by digital technologies. The “Jevons Paradox” better explains this phenomenon.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/300/0*SfUHOJaqb_U6ATy-" /></figure><p>It tells us that, as unitary costs decrease due to technical advances, consumption also tends to increase, driving total costs to similar levels as before. For example, “on average, when comparing generic online and traditional behaviors, online shopping tends to be more efficient than traditional shopping. However, when taking into account the variability of multiple consumer behaviors, this is no longer the case.” As shown in the following graph, Weideli and Cheikhrouhou <a href="http://docplayer.net/36291617-Environmental-analysis-of-us-online-shopping.html">estimated </a>that online shopping could even be more polluting than traditional shopping, if shoppers were more impatient and ordered fast shipping.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/554/0*a9yq6yoxatqq1hsU" /><figcaption>Source: Weideli, D., &amp; Cheikhrouhou, N. (2013). Environmental analysis of US online shopping. Ecole Polytechnique Fédérale de Lausanne — EPFL: Lausanne, Switzerland.</figcaption></figure><p>We could think of managing these types of behaviors by encouraging cleaner modes of shopping. Nevertheless, at the end of the day, can we stop the simplicity digital tech offers to buy with just a click? Andrew McAfee <a href="https://marker.medium.com/capitalism-is-helping-us-use-less-stuff-no-really-45cfa27b12b8?source=search_post---------0">argues</a> our present capitalist system is helping us to be more efficient, but <a href="https://ourworldindata.org/co2-and-other-greenhouse-gas-emissions">data</a> shows that the increase of human CO2 emissions continues.</p><p>Is there no room for austerity in this discussion?</p><h4><strong>What to do?</strong></h4><p>Describing problems might appear easy, especially in a world that places a great deal of value on solutions. But centuries of scientific discovery have taught us that making the right questions is the first step to solve a problem.</p><p>Nonetheless, we do have an issue today with the disruption brought by digital technologies and it is important to think about solutions. Some advocate for pursuing a path of networked individuals, increasing returns to scale, zero marginal cost and new productive alliances between customers and companies. This is the path defended, for example, by Nicolas Colin in<a href="https://hedgethebook.com/"> Hedge</a>, where he suggests it is the time to develop a new safety net for the digital age.</p><p>But this approach suggests we sign a blank check. What is the deal about? We have been hearing about automation, but today we discover the great amount of labor force required to get the digital wheel moving. We were promised a smarter State, but what we see today is the depoliticization of public action through the surrender of public accountable processes to opaque, private actors. We thought the digital was a synonym to infinite possibilities, but today we discover that our bytes even have a carbon footprint. We thought the digital was about improving our lives, but today we discover we are just the raw material of someone else’s profit.</p><p>There are, however, a couple of things we can do beyond complaining. Casilli’s approach is worth considering. He suggests the first step lies in recognizing digital labor, based on<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Axel_Honneth"> Axel Honneth</a>’s notion of recognition as the central element of social conflicts. Second, he reviews the ‘common sense’ solutions to unrecognized labor many talk about. At first, it could be argued that it is necessary to bring the social conquests of formal wage labor to digital labor. But digital labor’s ability to move across the planet will mean the geographic displacement of the problem, after installing social protection in one country. A marginal, old-fashioned approach to face that will be platform certification, but scaling remains a barrier. Some other market-oriented solutions that have been proposed are the installment of a micro-royalties system and of a <a href="https://www.generationlibre.eu/en/personnal-data-ownership-2/">personal data market</a>, but, according to Casilli, they will only deepen the ‘remuneration per piece’ system that already exists, doing nothing to solve the problem of fair remuneration.</p><p>Casilli finally proposes a new type of platform. In fact, he suggests a return to the original 19th-century idea of platform, where dependent labor was abolished, private property repealed, and governance of the commons was instituted. But for the author, the idea of ‘platform cooperativism’ risks remaining a phenomenon of a niche that can easily be co-opted.</p><p>For him, a more integral solution orients towards creating an informational common domain with common governance over data. He leans towards the creation of a social digital revenue (to be distributed to each individual, but also to the platform community as a whole), although leaves plenty of unconcluded proposals for implementing it. Ultimately, he argues, the main characteristics of new platforms should consider remunerating the digital labor, financing the commons, and renouncing to present logic of proprietary closeness and technological opacity.</p><p>This proposal resonates with <a href="https://newleftreview.org/issues/II116/articles/evgeny-morozov-digital-socialism">Evgeny Morozov</a>’s proposed agenda to reclaim the “feedback infrastructures”. For him, “the ownership and operation of the means of producing ‘feedback data’ are at least as important as the question of who owns the data itself”. It also aligns with Sébastien Soriano’s <a href="https://medium.com/@sorianotech/big-tech-regulation-d12430d7fc1b">proposals </a>of data as a common good (“Crowdsourced data should belong to the many!”) and inter-operable platforms.</p><blockquote>In the end, the logic is straightforward: in a collectively built environment, value should be accessible to the many.</blockquote><p>But also in the heart of these ideas lies the need to match collective value production and governance of such infrastructures. What should be recognized is that <strong>most of the digital economic value is socially produced, and as such, should be socially governed</strong>. This means changing the way how we conceive the digital. One interesting vision is that of Omri Ben-Shahar, who introduced the idea of <a href="https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3191231">data pollution</a>. He argues that we should look at digital environments with an environmental law mindset, as a way to sort out public differences, defend public values, and reduce market failures. But, as it has been <a href="https://impakter.com/defending-the-planet-in-the-era-of-humans/">argued</a>, environmental law has proven its limits and that is why today the idea of <strong>environmental democracy</strong> is understood as a step forward.</p><p>Environmental democracy is the dynamic development of the three access rights: access to information, to public participation, and to justice in environmental matters. In the digital, <strong>greater transparency from platforms, more participation from the stakeholders in their governance, and better conflict resolution mechanisms</strong> will provide a solid institutional framework to eventually reach consensus over the new social contract for this age.</p><p>Finally, getting the right information might remind us about the material limits of digital technologies. Present discussions about regulating the digital economy assume <em>ad infinitum</em> possibilities, a mistaken departure point. A sense of digital austerity could be necessary after all. If tech is that problematic, let’s try to use it less. Not a joke.</p><p><strong><em>This post was written as an assignment for the ‘</em></strong><a href="http://formation.sciences-po.fr/enseignement/2019/K2SP/3215"><strong><em>Regulation and Digital Economy</em></strong></a><strong><em>’ course at Sciences Po Paris, taught by Bertrand Pailhes and Sébastien Soriano.</em></strong></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=28077b0828f0" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>