<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by John Erik Roh on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by John Erik Roh on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@saltygentlemen?source=rss-8bdea7783d20------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sun, 22 Nov 2026 15:58:24 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@saltygentlemen/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The New Nativism:]]></title>
            <link>https://saltygentlemen.medium.com/the-new-nativism-7e3c7aa2b6ba?source=rss-8bdea7783d20------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/7e3c7aa2b6ba</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[immigration]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[history]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[racism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[pseudoscience]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[John Erik Roh]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 07 Jan 2022 05:09:25 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-01-07T05:09:25.643Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Racism &amp; Immigration in the Jazz Age</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*Jna96uBknzoKxWTI" /></figure><p>Ask most anyone to sum up the 1920’s in American history, and you’ll get a wide variety of answers. Talkies, Jazz, Prohibition, Al Capone and organized crime, flapper dresses, Art Deco architecture, F. Scott Fitzgerald, bootleg moonshine in a speakeasy. What you probably won’t get, is a nationwide surge of racism masquerading as immigration reform.</p><p><strong>New</strong> <strong>Nativism</strong> became the predominant ideology of the 1920’s and renewed many nationalist sentiments about the declining American ethos in the wake of windfall immigration in the wake of The Great War. Both the immigration act of 1917 and the Immigration act of 1924 served to set the precedent for white ethnocentricity, and racial discrimination against immigrants for decades to come.</p><p>The sentiments expressed in these acts are largely echoed today, as the election of the current administration’s president was built on many of the racist rhetorical notions that served as foundational evidence for the passage of those immigration policies.</p><p>From a campaign trail interview in 2016, then presidential hopeful Donald Trump was quoted as saying</p><blockquote>They’re sending people that have a lot of problems, and they’re bringing those problems with us. They’re bringing drugs. They’re bringing crime. They’re rapists. And some, I assume, are good people[1]</blockquote><p>Which sounds an awful lot like a modernized version of the opening of John Box’s <em>Immigration Restriction</em> of 1928, wherein he writes:</p><blockquote>Every reason which calls for the exclusion of the most wretched, ignorant, dirty, diseased, and degraded people of Europe or Asia demands that the illiterate, unclean, peonized masses moving this way from Mexico be stopped at the border….[2]</blockquote><p>Seeing the past repeated so clearly is a reason why understanding the past in its entirety, not just through the rose gold glow of nostalgia, is important now more than ever; so as not to repeat the egregious mistakes of our ancestors.</p><p>It is clear that the Immigration Acts of 1920’s were based on racial stereotypes rooted in anthropological pseudoscience and with their passage, disproportionately affected Chinese, Japanese, and Mexican immigrants, even as European immigrants were the intended targets for these new reforms; igniting a new hotbed of racial hostility that would continue for decades after.</p><p>Before we understand the passage of the Immigration acts, we must understand the rising anti-immigrant attitudes that the public expressed, long before policies ever came to a vote.</p><p>Franz Boas, widely regarded as the father of Anthropology in America, began a series of studies in 1908, determined to “confirm scientifically the existence of physical and mental deficiencies of recent immigrants”[3]. These studies and subsequent others by highly regarded professors and institutions like Columbia University, used the pseudoscience of phrenology (under the umbrella of anthropology)to explain the <em>perceived</em> <strong>detrimental</strong> effects immigrants and the poor have on the economics, values and morals of society at large. For a man who would pioneer the theory of cultural relativism, who would publish his ethnography <em>Race, Language and Culture</em> some thirty two years later, and stress in that publication:</p><blockquote>“the idea that there is no necessary correlation between race, language, and culture that one’s physical appearance does not determine ones culture or ability to learn any language”[4]</blockquote><p>It is saddening to see that he was not so wise in his youth. Going so far as to proclaiming that “Southern and eastern Europeans experienced a decline in mental abilities due to diminished head size”[5]. These kinds of broad spectrum racial declarations “based in science” gave a platform for white, protestant Americans to cavalcade their support of Federal policy to limit the “American racial stock from further degradation or change through mongrelization”.[6] That quote from John Box in the Immigrant Restriction policy of 1924 highlights the pro-white, anti-immigrant feelings of many Americans in the 1920’s.</p><p>Feelings that raged at an all-time high with the trial of Sacco and Vanzetti. Nicola Sacco and Bartolomeo Vanzetti were Italian Immigrants wrongly convicted and executed in conjunction with a robbery and murder in Braintree Massachusetts[7]. While there was no direct evidence that linked the two to the actual crime, the court of public opinion had sentenced them to death for their anarchist sympathies and pro-violent, overthrow-of-capitalist attitudes[8].</p><p>Negative attitudes around European immigrants in postwar America had gained huge momentum, and while Sacco and Vanzetti may have been the spark that lit the blaze, it would be immigrants of color that would pay the harshest penalties of the immigration reforms to come</p><p>The hallmark of immigration reform throughout the history of the United States, has always centered on the division and “theft” of labor. From the earliest British colonies work being undercut by indentured servants, to the antebellum plantation south expanding their networks of slavery through westward expansion and robbing the common man of a job; the outcry has seemingly been that some underpaid workforce has always stolen the opportunities for labor of the hardworking common man. Yet these underpaid workforces have always been the backbone of our society, despite repeated efforts to figuratively (and in many cases literally) demonize them as quintessentially un-American. Without indentured servants, our fledgling colonies would have failed much like the mysterious Roanoke. Without enslaved African peoples, our nation would not have built an agricultural empire and had the capital to pay off its earliest war debts to remain an independent nation. Without Mexican immigrants and Free Blacks, we would not have won the Civil war and stayed united. Without Chinese and Japanese immigrants, our entire system of mining and railroads would never have been built, halting the progress of the American Industrial Revolution.</p><p>Yet “To keep out… this blend of low-grade Spaniard, peonized Indian, and Negro slave mixes with Negroes, mulattoes, and other mongrels… is another essential part of the Nation’s immigration policy”[9], becomes our sentiment whenever we look for a scapegoat to our nation’s problems. Ernesto Galarza, a Mexican scholar responding to the immigration policies of 1924 says:</p><blockquote>“I would ask for recognition of the Mexican’s contribution to the agricultural and industrial expansion of western United States…. From Denver to Los Angeles and from the Imperial Valley to Portland, it is said, an empire has been created largely by the brawn of the humble Mexican, who laid the rails and topped the beets and poured the cubic miles of cement”[10]</blockquote><p>The first broad spectrum official anti-immigration act passed in the United States was the Chinese Exclusion Act[11]. Passed in May of 1882, the Chinese became the first illegal immigrants in the United States. Afterwards the country began passing other acts, such as: The Immigration Act of 1882[12], The Anarchist Exclusion Act of 1903[13], The Immigration Act of 1907, The Gentlemen’s Agreement of 1907 (which banned the Japanese)[14], The Literacy Act of 1917, The Dillingham-Hardwicke Act of 1918, The Emergency Immigration Act of 1921[15], and The National Origins Act of 1924[16].</p><p>These acts, one by one focused on different racialized sectors of the populace, each in turn seen as some lower form of humanoid in comparison to the White, Protestant, American working male. These groups, each in their own way, are responsible for the foundations of the American empire, yet are exploited by the Capitalist ruling classes greed and their workarounds to paying higher wages for domestic labor, and vilified by the propaganda of that class to divert the anger and rage of the domestic working class off of them, and onto the poorest immigrants. While President Coolidge declared “American must be kept American”[17] upon signing the National Origins Act, his vilification of Eastern Europeans merely reduced their ability to come to America. Whereas for Mexicans, it forcefully repatriated many of them, unable to obtain visas necessary to stay, when they had originally crossed without needing them[18].</p><p>This act would govern American immigration policy until it was replaced by the Immigration and Nationality Act of 1952. Decades of anti-color sentiment would inform policy decisions and cultural attitudes, creating a racially hostile environment for non white persons in America till beyond the second World War.</p><p>Phrenology would serve as the basis for the justification of the racism of Euro-colonial attitudes in an America none too eager to join in a war it had no part in, and its scientific platitudes, alongside the increasing fields of anthropology, would inform broad schools of thought about the nature of savages, slaves and the perceived inferiority of immigrant cultures.</p><p>Disproportionately this took a toll on Chinese, Japanese, and Mexican immigrants, even as racism against Blacks and Jews was perpetuated by the populist revival of the Klu Klux Klan, and Eastern Europeans populaces were directly targeted by the language of federal immigration acts.</p><p>It seems that no matter how many strides we take in society, we seem to be running in place, experiencing the same problems that have plagued us since the beginning.</p><p>As Freud once spoke about the narcissism of small differences, racism has always had roots in American culture, and it’s likely that it always might have some part to play in our culture. Even as we find “scientific” reasoning to justify our prejudices, and pass laws attempting to disguise our hatred of the other as functions for the best of society, we still cause disproportionate harm to the most marginalized peoples among us.</p><p>The New Nativism and immigration restrictions of the 1920’s that contributed to the rise of racism in America directly influenced the immigration acts of the 1920’s. As they were based on racial stereotypes rooted in anthropological pseudoscience that disproportionately affected Chinese, Japanese, and Mexican immigrants, even as European immigrants became the targets for these new reforms.</p><p>It is not enough to be “not racist”, we must be actively anti-racist. Challenging our preconceived notions about racial stereotypes, groups and cultures. And actively standing in opposition of rhetoric and propaganda that falsely isolates intersections of American people as somehow being “un-American” for their skin color, religious beliefs, or ancestral culture.</p><p><strong>In Text Citations</strong></p><ol><li>Mark, Michelle., April 5, 2018</li><li>Box, John., 1928</li><li>Lund, John M., December 1994.</li><li>Brown, Nina., 2020.</li><li>Lund, December 1994</li><li>Box, John., 1928</li><li>Corbett, P. Scott, 2017</li><li>Corbett, P. Scott, 2017</li><li>Box, John., 1928</li><li>Galarza, Ernesto, 1929.</li><li>The American Yawp, 2019The American Yawp, 2019</li><li>The American Yawp, 2019</li><li>The American Yawp, 2019</li><li>Corbett, P. Scott, 2017</li><li>Corbett, P. Scott, 2017</li><li>Corbett, P. Scott ,2017</li><li>Box, John., 1928.</li></ol><p><strong>Supporting Materials</strong></p><ul><li>Locke, Joseph, and Ben Wright. The American Yawp, 2019. <a href="http://www.americanyawp.com/">http://www.americanyawp.com/.</a></li><li>Corbett, P. Scott, Volker Janssen, John M. Lund, Todd J. Pfannestiel, and Paul S. Vickery. <em>U.S. History</em>. Houston, TX: OpenStax, Rice University, 2017.</li><li>Mark, Michelle. “Trump Just Referred to One of His Most Infamous Campaign Comments: Calling Mexicans ‘Rapists’,” April 5, 2018. <a href="https://www.businessinsider.com/trump-mexicans-rapists-remark-reference-2018-4?op=1.">https://www.businessinsider.com/trump-mexicans-rapists-remark-reference-2018-4?op=1.</a></li><li>Box, John. “Immigration Restriction.” Digital History, 1928. <a href="https://www.digitalhistory.uh.edu/disp_textbook.cfm?smtID=3.">https://www.digitalhistory.uh.edu/disp_textbook.cfm?smtID=3.</a></li><li>Lund, John M. “Boundaries of Restriction: The Dillingham Commission.” UVM History Review vol. 6 Dec. 1994: Lund, December 1994. <a href="https://www.uvm.edu/~hag/histreview/vol6/lund.html.">https://www.uvm.edu/~hag/histreview/vol6/lund.html.</a></li><li>Brown, Nina, Thomas McIlwraith, and Laura Tubelle de Gonzalez. <em>Perspectives: An Open Introduction to Cultural Anthropology</em>. 2nd ed. Arlington, VA: American Anthropological Association, 2020.</li><li>Galarza, Ernesto. “Immigration Restriction.” Digital History, 1929. <a href="https://www.digitalhistory.uh.edu/disp_textbook.cfm?smtID=3.">https://www.digitalhistory.uh.edu/disp_textbook.cfm?smtID=3.</a></li><li>“Immigration Restriction Act of 1924.” Digital History, 1924. <a href="https://www.digitalhistory.uh.edu/disp_textbook.cfm?smtID=3.">https://www.digitalhistory.uh.edu/disp_textbook.cfm?smtID=3.</a></li></ul><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=7e3c7aa2b6ba" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Aristotle, the Poetics and The Modern Era; A Critical Inquiry into Understanding the Implications…]]></title>
            <link>https://saltygentlemen.medium.com/aristotle-the-poetics-and-the-modern-era-a-critical-inquiry-into-understanding-the-implications-d53c0f1f5e36?source=rss-8bdea7783d20------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d53c0f1f5e36</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[critique]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[theatre]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[aristotle]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[broadway]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[John Erik Roh]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 14 Dec 2021 09:14:54 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-12-14T09:14:54.537Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Aristotle, the <em>Poetics </em>and The Modern Era; A Critical Inquiry into Understanding the Implications of the Aristotelian Philosophy on Theatre</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*v-pVgfxfD9QBqR4p" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@javiertenenbaum?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Javier Quiroga</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p>History attributes Aristotle’s birth to 384 BCE, and for 62ish years, he lived a modest life, first as a student to Plato, then later as a teacher and philosopher to men of Athens, not the least of which was Alexander the Great, son to Philip II, King of Macedon. His legacy survives, owing to a great many moments of luck. Aristotle himself was not a massively prolific public writer, and many of his treatises were written esoterically for his students at the Lyceum. When he fled to the isle of Euboea after a wave of anti-Macedonian sentiment rose up in the wake of Alexander’s death, he passed his life works to his Lyceum successor, Theophrastus, who passed them onto his nephew, Neleus, who hid them in a cave, where they lay dormant for several hundred years until they were discovered by another philosopher Andronicus of Rhodes.</p><p>Translated, edited and published, Aristotle’s work would find new life in the Renaissance era and has remained an influential work of thought that has transcended the context in which it was written to inform authors, playwrights, philosophers, scientists and creators in societies around the globe. In the 2,500 years since its inception, one of Aristotle’s most influential works the <em>Poetics</em>, the first ever extant treatise on dramatic &amp; literary theory has gone on to live an extraordinary life as a monumental cornerstone of critique and abstract theorem, all while inspiring deeply controversial principles that are hotly contested even to this day. In learning about Aristotle and pondering on the <em>Poetics’</em> potency that lies beyond Aristotle’s somewhat cryptic esotericism and its effects on the theatre of the modern world, some interesting conjectures bubble up from the deep void that we will herein discuss.</p><p>Distilling the abundance of questions that one may conjure while reading Aristotle, three principal ideas about the intentions &amp; subsequent effects of the <em>Poetics</em> formulate. The first: Aristotle, while lacking the linguistic objects to elucidate his meaning, is describing multiple processes at work when he is describing “poetry”. In one such way, the psychological implications of “imitation as learning” is his way of relating to us the anthropological concept of enculturation (and later acculturation) as they coincide with conceptualizations of the performative aspects of culture and identity. Aristotle uses “poetry” as an intersection of conscious and unconscious imitation as performance of culture, and “poetry” that preserves &amp; ennobles performance of culture. This is the concept of “<strong>Theatrx</strong>” (pronounced as theatre) that I introduce later in this paper to explain these separate but overlapping theoretical principles alluded to, but for lack of linguistic objects (and our missing contextualization) within the text, Aristotle is unable to fully articulate for us. The second: In writing the <em>Poetics</em>, Aristotle is offering a “higher” explanation of the descriptively universal principles (a tautological concept I will explain in detail further on) of “poetry” herein theatre &amp; theatrx, and specifically its culminating form, the pureness of tragedy as it extends from the imitation of the natural process of “civilized” (read: social) human interaction. This “higher” (read: enlightened or Divine) explanation is not an absolute claim for the due process by which all theatre should be conducted were Aristotle a theatre critic, but a proposed model for maximising the potential effects of the dramatization of human interactivity-identity-culture (re: Theatrx). And finally the third: Aristotle’s proposed model is then by necessity of its construction a subjective commentary on the effectiveness of Theatre as it exists, how it best should connect humans to the human condition through the dramatization of Theatrx (cultural performance &amp; identity politics) which posits the man himself as a critic of Theatre and simultaneously postulates a framework by which a critic may then serve Theatre for its betterment or detriment in official regard as a “critic”.</p><p>I posit that these principle ideas of the <em>Poetics</em> are the roots to the crucial misgivings modern era armchair philosophers and ersatz theatre critics attribute to the work of Aristotle. And as a result, have formulated incongruous maladaptive doctrines of the <em>Poetics</em> that continue to shape guiding thought around what is and is not, theatre. These maladaptive doctrines are best described by noted English theatre director Peter Brook, a man once given the title “our greatest living theatre director”. In his seminal literary work on modern theatre, Brook describes four domains of theatre: Holy, Rough, Immediate and Deadly. For our purposes we concern ourselves with Deadly theatre (and Holy, but later on) in this way, and use Brook’s definition to expound on our principal ideas, and ones direct from Aristotle the layman forgets exist within the <em>Poetics</em>.</p><p>As all four of Brook’s domains exist within a metaphysical state, what he calls the theatre of the invisible, he does not give a full-on, Merriam-Webster definition for Deadly theatre (or any other of his terms). What Brook attempts to do is glean a sense of working order that constitutes Deadly Theatre, out of the metaphysical realm into the physical realm. Much like any description of The Way in the Tao Te Ching, no physical description of metaphysical Deadly theatre could ever fully encompass the entirety of Deadly theatre. Much like a 2D drawing of an object can only represent, not embody, a 3D object, our understanding is limited and incomplete by virtue of our perception and cognition. Brook explains that Deadly theatre is one that “[conforms] to these canons… that makes [them] pass as living truth” and that “meaning never belongs in the past…so each new generation finds the grand manner more and more hollow, more and more meaningless” (Brook, 1968/1996).</p><p>He further explains that as “theatre is relativity…the deadly trap is to divide the eternal truths from the superficial variations; this is a subtle form of snobbery and is fatal” (Brook, 1968/1996). And its fatality is inherent because Brook presupposes “the vehicle of drama is flesh and blood… the vehicle and the message cannot be separated”. To rephrase in an attempt to clarify: the “empirical truth” of theatre cannot be disengaged from the modality by which it is expressed, human performance, and in its inseparability lies its flaws; flaws that Deadly Theatre directors, actors, playwrights and critics, in supplanting their own perceptions of the <em>Poetics</em>, attempt to buff out to shape themselves ever closer to the Grand Manner which is held supreme above all others. A Grand Manner believed to be laid out by Aristotle’s <em>Poetics</em> but no more resembles the pure truth than any other Deadly misinterpretation. The armchair philosopher and ersatz critic reads the Cliff Notes of the <em>Poetics</em> and sees the Grand Design of six elements of tragedy as blueprints to greatness, and not the tangible injections into reality of the metaphysical connection to the human condition they more accurately represent</p><p>You have undoubtedly witnessed Deadly Theatre. It is spectacle for the sake of spectacle. It is the hemming and hawing over which way to better pronounce Shakespeare’s dialectical prosodies to be more “authentic”. It is the “nightmare of vast feuds over tiny details; of surrealist anecdotes that all turn round the same assertion” (Brook, 1968/1996). As Brook warns us: “there is a deadly element everywhere; in the cultural set-up, in our inherited artistic values, in the economic framework, in the actor’s life, in the critic’s function” (Brook, 1968/1996). It is billion dollar movie franchises, community productions of the same retinue of shows year after year. In a way I believe it is Aristotle’s distaste for the double issue. The dual outcome undermines the emotional impact of pure Tragedy — Grief metered by the convenient happy ending; a weakness he equates “symptomatic of an ethical failure” (Heath, 2009). The “just desserts” ending where the villain is punished, the good guy saves the day, and all is right in the world; this too, is Deadly Theatre, as once it may have been an original idea, that now is ancient canon in the modern world. One that has passed “from the lively to the moribund” (Brook, 1968/1996). Deadly Theatre bellows out its siren song in single review tweets, and one-star Amazon reviews. It is the riptide in conversations about what’s binge-worthy or not.</p><p>Aristotle, in his treatise on poetry that would become to be known as the <em>Poetics</em>, created the cornerstone on which all western theatre traditions are built, and his influence is still widely felt today; even as this work is largely incomplete and become a focal point of stagnation because of the tropes by which modern theatre still deeply relies on, the underpinnings of the Poetics and ultimately Aristotle’s archetypal structuring of many prominent theatre traditions are profoundly insightful, and deserve continued study for insight and relevance in the modern era. It is now that we turn to dissect the hypothetical principles laid out before in turn and judge their meaning.</p><p>Foremost, we look directly to Aristotle’s words and work so that we may be clear of the foundations on which we must stand to then see clearly the enervated state it subsists within modern theatre culture today. Aristotle builds his argument for tragedy through a series of points. With each, he presupposes acceptance of the former, in order to grasp the entirety of the concept he attempts to describe. This concept-staggering follows a path that we will explore at length in this first principle. Imitation is the first concept Aristotle brings to us in the <em>Poetics</em> — more specifically “mimêsis”. Dr. Eugnene Garver, whose formal notes on the <em>Poetics</em> have stood as the formal baseline for decoding Aristotle for nearly 20 years, explains that mimêsis is not only in reference to the making, but to the product, and most importantly “mimêsis does not have the connotation of copying” (Aristotle &amp; Garver, 2005). Therefore we must attribute more substance to the meaning of the narrowly translated “imitation” that Aristotle actually attempts to convey. Imitation in this way is more complex and dynamic, akin to spiritual inhabitation, the way one “becomes” another, or singularly the metaphysical way one adopts an identity. This is the first divergence I make note of. As Aristotle did not have the field of psychology or anthropology to empirically validate his hypothesis with actual data, he had to invent the concepts he was creating. To this end, when Aristotle writes:</p><blockquote>First the instinct of imitation is implanted in man from childhood, one difference between him and other animals being that he is the most imitative of living creatures, and through imitation learns his earliest lessons; and no less universal is the pleasure felt in things imitated. (Aristotle &amp; Garver, 2005)</blockquote><p>He is explaining a dual-fold process, one that he does not have the linguistic objects to do so effectively to his purpose. Firstly, in anthropological terms, what he is explaining is the process of enculturation: “we learn to become members of our group both directly, through instruction from our parents and peers, and indirectly by observing and imitating those around us” (Brown et al., 2020). The imitation of others is the primary modality we experience the world, find our places within it and “become” human, with identities, perceptions, beliefs and socio-cognitive tools to perform the culture that has shaped and become us, back to the world. Aristotle then gives simple purpose to this explanation:</p><blockquote>The cause of this again is, that to learn gives the liveliest pleasure…thus the reason why men enjoy seeing a likeness is, that in contemplating it they find themselves learning or inferring, and saying perhaps, ‘Ah that is he’. (Aristotle &amp; Garver, 2005)</blockquote><p>In psychology we recognize this principle as the firing of mirror neurons in the prefrontal cortex throughout the motor system, including the ventral and dorsal premotor cortices and primary motor cortex, as well as being present in different regions of the parietal cortex. Mirror neurons are the function by which we perceive a behavior in the world and then re-enact it within our mind and body. Mirror neurons map behavior, and emotion onto the somatosensory and visceromotor sections of the brain, and in doing so, create within our biology the realness of perception, morphing witnessed action into original conception. Mirror neurons are the reason smiles and yawns are said to be contagious, to witness (or even hear about) an action, mirror neurons recreate it within our mind and body. According to many psychologists, this may be the reason why we are so affected by film and television (and theatre!) because our mirror neurons do not distinguish between “fantasy” and “reality”. We map actions witnessed or heard onto our mind as if we were enacting them ourselves and we then react to the consequences of the perception that what we are witnessing is happening to us through biological processes of the amygdala, HPA axis and hundreds of other biological and psychological contributions to sensory perception and management. Aristotle’s use of mimêsis makes more sense here when related to anthropological and psychological concepts he had no way of explaining or communicating with the limits of his language 2,500 years ago.</p><p>Aristotle’s consideration then in this way is that imitation is a function of our natural biological functions; our curiosity and empathy inherent to our humanness. The intention of integrating the intentionality of then purposeful-imitation into natural-imitation (as it simultaneously extends from it) serves then as a “higher” purpose of exploring the morality and conditions <em>as</em> <em>humanity</em>. Daniel Balderston explores this with the Muslim philospher Averroes’ thoughts on Aristotle: “the liminal is the space of poetics” (Balderston, 1996). Which we might explore to mean in the context of purposeful imitation &amp; natural imitation, the intermediary space between self-awareness &amp; will is where imitation lies. And this purposeful + natural imitation, identity, enculturation is the concept of <strong>Theatrx</strong> I seek to introduce. It is the first that we engage with. Performing culture, the awareness of identity and the personal agency of choice through will; when American musical theorist and philosopher John Cage says:</p><blockquote>“Theatre takes place all the time — wherever one is — and art simply facilitates persuading one this is the case.”</blockquote><p>This is what I propound as <strong>Theatrx</strong>. A third definition for the psychosocial underpinnings of <strong>Theatre</strong> that takes place in a <strong>Theater</strong>. Allan Gilbert, in his critique of Aristotle’s four species of tragedy, reminds us “a topic developed at length is man’s advance from primitive to civilized life” (Gilbert, 1947). A topic Aristotle is acutely focused on throughout the Poetics and even more so in Rhetoric.</p><p>This then more fully explains Aristotle’s focus on Tragedy as the supreme form of poetry, because “Tragedy is an imitation, not of men, but of an action and of life, and life consists in action, and its end is a mode of action, not a quality” (Aristotle &amp; Garver, 2005). In the end, we are not “happy” by mark of quality, it is through our actions that we can be said to derive happiness from them. From the natural imitation (theatrx) to the purposeful imitation (theatre) Tragedy attains its lofty positions in Aristotelian ascription because it preserves &amp; ennobles theatrx. Margaret Finkelberg in her work on <em>Aristotle and Episodic Tragedy </em>says of tragedy:</p><blockquote>If the action represented in poetry is of the right ‘philosophical kind’, the emotions of fear and pity aroused in an audience who are fully absorbed in the action would purge the soul and thus allow an ordinary man, by sharing for a while the defying experience of characters, one arrives at the kind of pleasure which comes as close as possible to the pure cognitive pleasure experienced by the philosopher (Finkelberg, 2006)</blockquote><p>Of course Aristotle would then relate the “highness” of pleasure of Tragedy to the heights of logic a philosopher attains. In witnessing Oedipus, Aristotle may have connected his catharsis for the protagonist unto himself in the same bone fide way “learning” creates endorphins in the brain. The oneness of experiencing characters as ourselves and the “learning” that accompanies that experience is what it means to be human to Aristotle. Finkelberg posits: “if literature does not supply us with plots, we find them in American made-for-television films, or by default on the front page stories from Kuwait” (Finkelberg, 2006) and we must ask ourselves of that thought: Did Aristotle touch upon a descriptively universal affectation of human nature when he connected learning-natural imitation-purposeful imitation-tragedy? That we biologically &amp; psychologically construct “narrative” formulations of the world, non-episodic stories, of which tragedy is the “highest” order because it most purely preserves and ennobles the frailty of the human condition and the method by which we experience that condition?</p><p>Malcolm Heath in his work<em> Should there have been a Polis in Aristotle’s Poetics</em>? has much to say on these questions. To ascertain Aristotle’s decisions for the order of “highness” and “lowness”, in relation to his three forms of poetry (theatre) Tragedy, epic poetry, comedy, we draw forth a conclusion that if imitation is humanness, then “highness” is then “closeness” to metaphysical humanness; civility, rationality, logic. Whereas “lowness” then is its antithesis and is closer to the chaos of being uncivilized or closer to animal-ness. Heath asserts, “comedy, defined as an imitation of inferior actions, also demands ethical judgment in poet and audience” and reminds us “Politics for Aristotle, is the ‘architectonic discipline…[and] conceives that there could not be a human activity that is not answerable to politics’’ (Heath, 2009). Which then if we extend to its maxim, theatrx and theatre are inherently political (and by extension ethical) as they are human activities. To which he conveys “if poetry is ethical, it is social; society is implicated in any human activity with ethical dimension” (Heath, 2009) and further elaborates with, “of course if poetry is a universal human practice, no particular social context is implied. The society involved in any actual poetic practice is necessarily some particular society, for the simple reason that all actual societies are particular societies ‘’ (Heath, 2009).</p><p>Here again, Aristotle’s preconceptions about human mimetic tendencies and “how poetry is rooted in anthropological universals: the natural human inclination towards imitating and taking pleasure in imitations” (Heath, 2009) lead us ultimately toward Tragedy because as Aristotle offers us “experience-based recognition that certain ways of composing tragedies are effective into a rational understanding of why they are effective”(Heath, 2009). Heath leads us now onto the second principle of this works with two distinct and important concepts (mentioned briefly earlier) we will explore as the foundation for Aristotle’s focus on tragedy; <strong>descriptively universal</strong>: “you will find it in every human society” (Heath, 2009); and <strong>normatively universal</strong>: “it is something that every [society] would have to acquire if it is to have achieved it optimal development”(Heath, 2009).</p><p>Heath alleges “since poetry is rooted in natural human instincts common to all, we would expect its most primitive forms to arise spontaneously in every human society” (Heath, 2009) which we understand is in part what Aristotle communicates when he talks about the naturalism of imitation &amp; learning in all humans. Heath adds this crucial piece which marks an important dialectical shift, “the behavior of humans is far more open to modification by habit, and also by reason, than that of any other animal” (Heath, 2009). The modification by reason marks the interpersonal shift from natural imitation to purposeful imitation, and societal shift from theatrx to theatre. Megumi Sata, in her comparative work of Aristotle’s <em>Poetics</em> and culturally renowned Japanese Noh playwright Zeami’s <em>Teachings on Style and the Flower,</em> brings us evidence of the impact of many Aristotelian principles in Japanese culture, in relation to imitation. Observing that”both societies (Japanese and Ancient Greek) being polytheistic and both theatre forms having ritualistic origins” (Sata, 1989) both philosopher-poets have similar ideas of what imitation consists of. Aristotle saying, “they while reproducing the distinctive form of the original make a likeness which is true to life, and yet more beautiful” (Sata, 1989) and Zeami saying,</p><blockquote>He must imitate down to the smallest detail the various things done by persons of high profession, especially those elements related to high artistic pursuits. On the other hand, when it comes to imitating laborers and rustics, their common-place actions should not be copied too realistically” (Sata, 1989)</blockquote><p>Zeami echoes Aristotle’s thoughts about high and low imitation, in regards to Tragedy and Comedy and with an added dimension of high and low imitation within a Tragedy or Comedy. Sata presents us with the Zeami versions of a well constructed plot and gifts us another concept that affirms this process of learning in what the Japanese playwright calls “fulfillment”. Through equal endowment of <em>jo, ha, kyū </em>(the japanese equivalents of beginning, middle and end, in a plot) in the construction of a tragedy “one’s own consciousness of one’s art will follow the proper process to genuine fulfillment” (Sata, 1989). Aristotle cites Oedipus as the supreme tragedy, the one by which all other tragedies must strive to achieve equality. As he says “pity is aroused by unmerited misfortune, fear by misfortune of a man like ourselves” (Sata, 1989), we understand deeper that Aristotle in having witnessed Oedipus himself may have had his own mirror neurons activate, and the catharsis he felt was a deeper (or higher) understanding, however brief, of Odepius’ humanity through empathy with his own.</p><p>That brief enlightenment, connection to something esoteric, what Brook calls Holy Theatre, changes us. This I believe is the “pleasure of learning” Aristotle speaks so often of, and it is why Tragedy is given supremacy over Comedy because in preserving yet ennobling the human condition it is isolated and focused for a moment. To borrow from the Tao, we briefly connect to The Way, and take back knowledge that has changed us, even if we cannot entirely elucidate what that change is. Zeami, too, hammers this point home when he affirms “when the audience can express its astonishment as one with a gasp, the moment of Fulfillment has come” (Sata, 1989). Imagine oneself in the seats, at the theatron of Delphi and watching Oedipus Rex for the first time. The hubris of a king among men learning that his arrogance and folly was repaid in kind by the fulfillment of the prophecy at his birth. The revelation he did indeed murder his father and bore children with his mother. The gasp must have been audible throughout the crowd of thousands, and the power of that moment probably rippled out like an electrified tidal wave. And being a man of thought, who sought to contemplate the meaning of existence and the purpose of life as the purpose of his life, he ought to have been familiar with the eureka feeling that begets a moment of enlightenment and uncovering of a potential truth of the universe. Catharsis is powerfully felt, it is no casual thing. But where Tragedy is the penultimate expression of catharsis, Zeami breaks from the ancient master and does not speak of ideal dramatic form. His advice is to decide all matters in reference to the audience’s taste, nature and psychological condition:</p><blockquote>When the location or the occasion demands, and the level of the audience is low, the actor should strive to bring happiness to them by performing in a style which they truly can appreciate. When one thinks over the real purpose of our art, a player who truly can bring happiness to his audience is one who can without censure bring his art to all” (Sata, 1989).</blockquote><p>To take into account the always separate nature of Tragedy and Comedy in the time of ancient Greece, Aristotle’s offering of a “higher” explanation for the process of tragedy (rooted in imitation, constructed of the six aspects) as it extends from the natural process of human theatre, might then be seen as not an absolute claim for the descriptively universal truth of all Theatre, but a normatively universal truth for the culture/society of Theatre in his day and a simulacrum for the maximizing of the potential for the dramatization of human condition-culture-identity or what I now refer to as Theatrx. Put in another way, Aristotle claims Tragedy is the highest form of Theatre because it brings us connection to humanity through catharsis/Fulfillment, in a way that Comedy of his day could not. But Zeami gives clarity and grounding to the actuality of Aristotle’s claim by reminding us that adapting our theatre imitation to the audience who will bear witness to it, in forms of imitation they have experienced and are geared to receiving, is the true ideal method to achieve catharsis/Fulfillment, regardless of it being comedy or tragedy; imitation of Kings or Peasants.</p><p>Aristotle is first and foremost a philosopher, and we often forget that is the lens by which he wrote the <em>Poetics</em>. Because taken as a critic’s analysis of Theatre, the Poetics is dreadfully narrow-minded. Of the three most well known playwrights Aeschylus, Sophocles and Euripedes (and the dozen other Tragic writers and perhaps fifty or more Comedy writers) we have written knowledge of, Aristotle cites only a handful? Surely we must take into account personal taste, and as brilliant as Aristotle is, he was still a man with distinct preferences and foibles. Looking to Brook, we are provided a clear definition of a “good” critic (we will shortly define a Deadly one). He says:</p><p>…the more the critic becomes an insider the better. I see nothing but good in a critic plunging into our lives, meeting actors, talking, discussing, watching, intervening…the vital critic is the critics who has clearly formulated for himself what the theatre could be — and who is bold enough to throw this formula into jeopardy each time he participates in a theatrical event” (Brook, 1968/1996).</p><p>Does Aristotle fit this definition? Only some of the way. The <em>Poetics</em> is without a shadow of a doubt Aristotle’s formula for theatre, but is it what theatre could be or is it more what it ought to be? It is Aristotle’s philosophical leanings that are his undoing, and while we may never know if there were in-fact updated revisions to the <em>Poetics</em> where the man amended his position, challenging old assumptions and fighting the rotten status quo; to take the <em>Poetics</em> as it stands, as a theatre critic’s review, is to bind it to the Deadly for all time, for “the critic who no longer enjoys theatre is obviously a deadly critic, [and] the critic who loves the theatre but is not critically clear what this means, is also a deadly critic” (Brook, 1968/1996). Aristotle explains “the poet being an imitator, like a painter or any other artists must of necessity imitate one of three objects, — things as they were or are, things as they are said or thought to be , or things as they ought to be”(Aristotle &amp; Garver, 2005).</p><p>But to truly sit with the gravity of that thought one comes to recognize the nature of perception confounds each of those objects and we then realize objects are: 1.) what they are outside of our ability to perceive them, 2.) what they are according to our ability to perceive them, and 3.) what they could be according to our ability to imagine them. These then do not exist as separate Venn diagrams; they are all simultaneously true at once. To then read further is to realize Aristotle himself meets the guidelines of his own (adapted from Glaucon) deadly critic; ”Critics jump at certain groundless conclusions; they pass adverse judgement and then proceed to reason on it; and assuming that the poet has said whatever they happen to think, find fault if a thing is inconsistent with their own fancy” (Aristotle &amp; Garver, 2005). Allan Gilbert, in paraphrasing Aristotle in his article <em>Aristotle’s Four Species of Tragedy</em>, remands critics when he writes: “just because there have been poets before him strong in several species of tragedy, the critics now expect one man to surpass that which was the strong point of each one of his predecessors” (Gilbert, 1947). And while Aristotle makes clear the point that he does not hold the playwrights of his day to that standard, he still sets the bar as the definition of all “good” tragedy: the six characteristics by which one should follow to achieve catharsis and <em>highness</em>. In one breath he lifts the yoke of burden off the shoulder of current playwrights when he says:</p><blockquote>“the critics misrepresent the poets, for it is true that there have been poets good at using in a play one, and only one, of these four parts, but critics now expect any poet to do as well, in a single play, with all four parts as an earlier poet has done with the one part he was most skillful in” (Gilbert, 1947).</blockquote><p>And then sets it down on the shoulders of future playwrights when he pronounces:</p><blockquote>“A perfect tragedy should, as we have seen, be arranged not on the simple but on the complex plan…while reproducing the distinctive form of the original, make a likeness which is true to life and yet more beautiful. So too the poet…should preserve the type and yet ennoble it…these then are the rules the poet should observe”(Aristotle &amp; Garver, 2005).</blockquote><p>We look to Aristotle’s teacher Plato now and see clearly the roots from which the <em>Poetics</em> grew. Margalit Finkelberg in her work <em>Aristotle and Episodic Tragedy</em> speaks of Plato’s influence in shaping Aristotle’s reactionary position in <em>Politics</em>, <em>Rhetoric</em> and Poetry. She writes:</p><blockquote>Plato was the first who consciously employed such devices as a remedy against reader’s emotional identification with the characters…it is Plato who should be considered the first representative of the anti-Aristotelian theory of poetry, even if he expressed these ideas several decades before the <em>Poetics</em> was written. (Finkelberg, 2006</blockquote><p>Plato’s theories about theatre regard mimesis “as the art of producing phantoms of reality” (Finkelberg, 2006), a concept Brook reworks as Rough/Immediate Theatre in his formative text. Aristotle deviated explicitly from his former master in his paragon placement of mimesis, as an ”art that enables the representation of the universal, purified of the accidental aspects of empirical reality” (Finkelberg, 2006). Studying Plato gives us great insight into Aristotle’s thought process because it is evident how much “Aristotle puts highest what Plato puts lowest”(Finkelberg, 2006).</p><p>How much of what Aristotle wrote is informed by his emotions surrounding the teachings of his former mentor? Aristotle’s “right” kind of tragedy allows a fully engrossed audience to walk the path to catharsis, and experience pure philosophical cognitive pleasure, whereas Plato “interpreted this very experience as contamination of the soul by emotions” (Finkelberg, 2006). Plato purports the misogyny of Logic as Superior to Emotion in his teachings which then helps form the basis of Aristotle’s “opposite” to his mentor where Logic can integrate/absorb Emotion and catharsis is pure philosophical learning pleasure <em>through </em>emotional connectivity to the humanness of characters in Tragedy. Finkelberg asserts:</p><blockquote>The Aristotelian way is to exploit the tendencies that, as Plato also recognized, are inherent in our response to the mimetic art, and to cultivate the latter as a form of art that is both intellectually satisfying and aesthetically enjoyable (Finkelberg, 2006).</blockquote><p>Lacking linguistic objects to assert this himself, we ask of Aristotle in the <em>Poetics,</em> is that the descriptively universal affect he alludes to? That because we biologically &amp; psychologically construct “narrative” formulations of the world, non-episodic stories by which we experience the world, therefore self-contained plot driven stories of tragedy are placed upon the “highest” pedestal as the elysium all theatre should strive to realize? Forest Hansen in his work <em>A Broadway View of Aristotle’s Poetics</em> reminds us of an important point, one that we must question of the <em>Poetics</em>, and query deeper into the space of “did he ask this of himself” and that is: “but like many great works, it can easily become part of an unexamined way of thinking. Its shortcomings should also be appreciated” (Hansen, 1969). Daniel Balderston in his article <em>The Poetics of Poetics</em>, citing esteemed Muslim philosopher Averroes’ argument:</p><blockquote>The theory of the philosophers that universal exist only in the mind, not in the external world, only means that the universals exist actually only in the mind, and not in the external world, for the meaning is that they exist potentially, not actually in the external world; indeed if they did not exist at all in the outside world they would be false.(Balderston, 1996)</blockquote><p>Take this into contextualization of Aristotle philosophical informing of theatrical criticisms, Balderston quotes Jorge Luis Borges: “divinidad sólo conoce las leyes generales del universo” meaning;</p><blockquote>“Divinity only knows laws of the general universe and species, not the individual” (Balderston, 1996).</blockquote><p>Ultimately acknowledging Aristotle’s comments on Poetry as <em>not</em> divine (read: absolute descriptively universal truth), and belonging to the realm of the individual, Balsderston argues, through Averroes and Borges, that Aristotle, in writing the <em>Poetics</em> did not set out to lay down the rules for all poetry forever, but merely comment on his individual belief of the importance of what connects us from unconscious performance of culture to willful performance; from theatrx to theatre. Just as well because Hansen gives us pause to look holistically at whether or not Aristotle was cognizant enough to critique his own work and check for fallacies, inconsistencies and biases. Brook says this another way, and one that tarries on considering the implications the <em>Poetics </em>has rendered on the entire pantheon of Western theatre, in that meaning both is lost to the past by the machinations of time, and “meaning never belongs to the past” (Brook, 1968/1996). Contrary to Aristotle’s attempt to lay down what he believed to be a pathway to cathartic truth, Balderston notes that “knowing and not knowing; in this paradox resides one of Averroes fundamental insights…revelation itself is somewhat suspect as faith requires closure” ​​(Balderston, 1996).</p><p><em>“In proving foresight may be vain: The best laid schemes o’ mice an’ men, gang aft agley, an’ lea’e us nought but grief an’ pain,</em>” — Robert Burns wrote in his poem <em>To A Mouse</em> in 1785. We cannot know why Aristotle wrote what he did, nor could he fathom his Lyceum lectures being translated into hundreds of different languages and being debated, studied, pored over thousands of years later. To this end we discuss now Aristotle’s six elements model proposed in the <em>Poetics, </em>by necessity of its continued relevance, is in fact a a subjective commentary on the effectiveness of Theatre as it currently existed (in his time) and how it best should connect humans to the human condition through the dramatization of Theatrx (cultural performance &amp; identity politics). Which simultaneously posits the man himself as a critic of Theatre and postulates a framework by which a critic may then serve Theatre for its betterment or detriment in official regard as a “critic”.</p><p>Speaking earlier of a humans discovering tragedy through course of social &amp; civil evolution, Aristotle’s assertion that humans will naturally optimize it over time begins our line of query, where we must first ask what is the purpose of optimization in relation to something as fluid and dynamic as tragedy, or more cogently humanness, for that matter? Accepting Aristotle’s earlier notions that constructs the pedestal on which philosophical catharsis is the ultimate aim of the higher form of uncompelled <em>and</em> willful performance (theatrx &amp; theatre), we see that optimization is the paving-of-the-pathway to catharsis, yet theatrx &amp; theatre existed communally well before cities and civilizations. And as we can speculate that the storytelling of shamans, healers and elders around campfires and in caves undoubtedly gave its listeners a measure of (what Zeami would say as) <em>fulfillment</em>; why then optimize what can be reached through equifinality? Heath quotes Aristotle saying:</p><blockquote>Once self sufficiency has been secured, it becomes possible for humans to pursue goals that go beyond mere survival. The city comes into existence for the sake of living, but it continues in existence for the sake of living well” (Heath, 2009)</blockquote><p>But Aristotle in <em>Poetics </em>catches the fallacy of this; “for assuming that if one thing is or becomes, a second is or becomes, men imagine that, if the second is, the first likewise is or becomes. But this is a false inference” (Aristotle &amp; Garver, 2005). Talking here of the fallacy of affirming the consequent, Aristotle commits his own fallacy in the assumption that optimization is the natural course <em>because</em> humans move beyond survival. The premises of optimization are themselves fallible, and from this we deconstruct the wholeness of the <em>Poetics </em>in the broad assumption that the six characteristics is the method by which pure Tragedy, higher than Epic Poetry and Comedy achieves the highest philosophical plateau of catharsis. In actuality (normatively universally), theatrx &amp; theatre will never be “optimized” (read: perfected). Zeami knew this in the 13th century:</p><blockquote>“Successful performances depend on the changing tastes of each generation…success can only be assured when various elements are properly matched — the level of play, the skill of the performer, the discernment of the audience, the performing area, and the occasion itself” (Sata, 1989)</blockquote><p>What is “best’’ is known to the individual because it is arbitrary. Catharsis was Aristotle’s “best” and we must do well to remember this and to take it, and him, off from the pedestal lorded over theatre for the last 2,500 years. Sata does exactly this, and incidentally conceptualizes the Brookian concept of Holy Theatre when she supposes:</p><blockquote>The tradition of Western dramatic theory that Aristotle established has long viewed drama as a unidirectional process wherein the artistic achievements of the playwright are presented to an audience through the medium of language with the help of acting (gesture). Although the audience is the object of the tragic aim of catharsis, the catharsis does not depend on the nature of the audience. (Sata, 1989)</blockquote><p>Looking beyond optimized (read: perfected) forms of theatre, aims of catharsis, and the rigid structure of the six elements, can loosen and become tools by which theatre can be willfully developed, not walled in by adherence to tradition. Brook’s Holy Theatre, or the Theatre of the Invisible-Made-Visible, is truly the higher form Aristotle is attempting to actualize with his leaning-on catharsis. Again lacking the linguistic objects, Brook attempts to describe the indescribable, a fourth dimension we only become aware of once we are in it, describing “audiences all over the world will answer positively from their own experience that they have seen the face of the invisible though an experience on the stage that transcended their experience in life” (Brook, 1968/1996). <em>Fulfillment, Catharsis, Holy Theatre</em>, these are all the same concepts, realized centuries apart by philosophical thinkers touched by Divinity (for lack of a better word) and given a glimpse of The Way.</p><p>But any description of The Way, is not The Way and thus we see each of these philosophical ways coincide, and differ in their conceptualization. Aristotle’s folly is his insistence of “logicalizing” qualitative judgements of theatre aesthetics; “his principles, which with his characteristic logic he has pushed to a radical conclusion, have led him into a <em>cul-de-sac</em>” (Finkelberg, 2006). If the audience can be moved to catharsis by the mere reading of Tragedy through the medium of imitation (plot &amp; character), what then serves the purpose of qualifying the manner of imitation (diction), and the objects of imitation (thought, spectacle, song)? If “beauty depends on magnitude and order” (Aristotle &amp; Garver, 2005), it does so as it relates to our ability to perceive the wholeness of that magnitude and order. This thought process is Deadly Theatre;</p><blockquote>“It is, after all a defect of our own imagination and a legacy of later drama which leads us to think that everything needs to be presented visibly in order to make an impact on the audience: deaths unseen but told are just as much a part of the plot of a Greek Tragedy as those which are seen, and they are every bit as real to the audience. (Rees, 1972)</blockquote><p>Brook details an exercise he conducted to a group of actors at a University that perfectly illustrates this affectation. Asking a volunteer to read a list of names typed from a monologue in Peter Weiss’ play about Auschwitz, <em>The Investigation</em>, they were “too struck and too appalled” to be caught up in the performative acts of reading for an audience, and the crowd in reacting to the realness of the non-performance-performance fell silent. “The very first words were loaded with their own ghastly sense and the reader’s response to them. Immediately the audience understood” (Brook, 1968/1996). And yet calling upon a second volunteer to read a list of names from <em>Henry V </em>“all the faults of the amateur actor appeared. One look at the volume of Shakespeare had already set off a series of conditioned reflexes to do with speaking verse” (Brook, 1968/1996). Brook’s dialogue with the group after about the difference is deeply important:</p><blockquote>When he had finished, I asked the audience why they could not take the list of dead at Agincourt as seriously as the description of death at Auschwitz. This provoked a lively exchange.</blockquote><blockquote>‘Agincourt’s in the past.’ ‘<em>But Auschwitz is in the past’ </em>‘Only fifteen years.’ <em>‘So how long’s it got to take? When’s a corpse a historical corpse? How many years make killing romantic? </em>(Brook, 1968/1996).</blockquote><p>What has become of the <em>Poetics</em> and the six elements, is that they have lived long enough to see themselves to become the villain. They are tools of Deadly Theatre, rigid walls that enforce one man’s arbitrary system and are so institutionalized we hardly see them for the prison they have become. We are sparrows in a cage. Born into it, we have no conscious knowledge we can fly beyond its boundaries because we maintain the borders out of adherence to tradition. But not even then are the six elements <em>always </em>normatively universal tools of Deadly Theatre. A playwright, or creator can utilize them in part, in whole or discard them for something else. Aristotle discussing “good” tragedy implies the existence of “bad” tragedy, yet their arbitrariness as aesthetic interpretations leads to a spectrum of good, bad and combinations of the two.</p><p>Only if it is a true, well done tragedy can one get the “full impact” from simply hearing it read, yet “bad” theatre in this way can still be seen as “good”. As a prime example, the Rocky Horror Picture Show is ostensibly “bad” by Aristotelian standards. Absolute swiss cheese of a plot, utter nonsense characters, basic diction, little thought, wild irreverent song, and unabashed spectacle. Yet it’s widely regarded as “so bad it’s good” by audiences around the globe. What might Aristotle say to the phenomena of its impact on social &amp; pop culture, despite being a debauchery of tragedy? Is there merit to descriptively universal qualifications when a “bad” tragedy can, in performance, be “good? Hansen asks &amp; answers “What are the best musicals?” in examining our question of merit and his response further clarifies our stance on the Deadliness of the six elements in the modern era:</p><blockquote>One answer is, ‘Inspect them and you’ll see’. To anyone who attends to the performance of <em>Pajama Game</em> and <em>Brigadoon</em>, say, it should be obvious that <em>Brigadoon</em> is the better musical… not because the critics have said so (if any have) or because <em>Brigadoon</em> had a longer run (if it did) or because it sold more records (if that is the case. One simply perceives that it is better, if not in the same way that we perceive that someone is taller than someone else(Hansen, 1969)</blockquote><p>Excellent evidence for Zeami’s critique that the immediacy of the audience (and by extension the culture of the era) is important &amp; relevant to any discussion of “best” <em>and </em>any discussion of the qualities that define “better” are only relevant to the immediacy of context as the immutability of change inherently calls into question the efficacy of any absolute truth of “better” or “best”. If one is to take the six elements and the relevancy of the <em>Poetics</em> as immutable law for the modern day, one exhibits the qualities of a Deadly Theatre playwright, actor, critic, or participant. But taking the six element and <em>Poetics</em> not as absolute universal law as is presupposed of Aristotle’s intentions in writing them and “by contradicting himself from one text to another, by thinking through paradox… a critic attentive to the particulars of the text he comments…can be used productively at almost every turn of contemporary theoretical work” (Balderston, 1996).</p><p>Or in other words, one can see the flaws and contradictions of the <em>Poetics</em> and six elements and use them, <em>for their flaws</em>, to attain catharsis/fulfillment/Holy Theatre in real time for their audience, not in merely a philosophical suppositional way. If we found the six elements “these particular complications in all or most [plays], we could call them principles or rules of the [play]” (Hansen, 1969). This is inductive logic, and ultimately fallacious thinking because it presupposes what came is indicative of what <em>should always come</em>, and while Aristotle “acknowledges that no play has all [six elements], nor is it vital that a good play even have most of them, but the best plays <em>generally</em> exhibit <em>most</em> of these characteristics” (Hansen, 1969) it is the Deadly Critic expecting the play must exhibit all of them, the Deadly Playwright unable to imagine a play without exhibiting them, and the Deadly Audience that cannot expand their enjoyment to anything outside of them. Hansen asks the question that we come to now in assessing the effectiveness of the elements and the <em>Poetics</em> on theatre as it exists today; <em>Did Aristotle go wrong?</em></p><p>No. He merely pre-supposed there was only one way to achieve his catharsis, Zeami’s Fulfillment, Brook’s Holy Theatre, through the modality of tragedy and then perpetuated unfounded thinking as the highest form and aim Theatre can attain, and any author aiming anywhere else is aiming Empirically lower. It is centuries of modern theatre interpretations who have gone wrong; perpetuating clearly flawed logic as absolute truth, stymieing the potential for creative work outside of the Aristotelian curriculum.</p><p>All things considered, the<em> Poetics</em> is a monumental triumph, a profound philosophical elucidation of literary concepts that has influenced generations writers, creators, both in the Theatre world and outside of it. Millions, and millions of people have been touched with the power of this work through first, second and third hands. Like the “six degrees of separation” game of a certain actor, Aristotle’s connections to works of nearly every era after him associate him with nearly every arena of creative literary work and subsequent adaptation. Firstly, Aristotle’s work is limited however by the lack of linguistic objects we have today, ones that we can use to expand upon and possibly clarify many of the esotericisms lost in the context of the time in which it was written, and give rise to a new definition, <strong>Theatrx</strong>, that helps us materialize tautological concepts Aristotle does not in the <em>Poetics.</em> Secondly, the misgivings of presupposing the six elements as descriptively universal processes obfuscates the reality of the faulty logic behind the proportions, and breaking the cycle of its absolute importance allows for the reshaping of the elements functions and purposes within Modern theatre spheres. And thirdly, seeing the elements, the <em>Poetics</em> and Aristotle himself as not “objective truisms” allows for actualized, relevant critique of Theatrical works to function in an immediate and authentic way, instead of echoing ad nauseum a failing of standard adherence to the elements in their critical order as the highest duty a theatrical work ought to serve.</p><p>This critical look at the <em>Poetics</em> and Aristotle intends to pull him down from the pedestal of Philosopher-Legend and remember that he was too, a man. His works may yet survive, but we must not uncritically adore them, their worth and meaning swelling to insurmountable proportions, and the words becoming unto dogmatic doctrine. Meaning never belongs in the past, and with every age and generation, we must again reconvene our traditions to assess their meaning, worth, purpose and fundamentally their impact. What stories lie beyond the canon of plot-character-diction-thought-spectacle-song? What might we conceptualize if we expand our horizon beyond a border we believed to be absolute? Without Aristotle’s willingness to declare faith in his beliefs, his fervency behind the search for objective, Divine truth, our world may have taken an entirely different course, and be unrecognizable if we could perceive that alternate reality. For good, or bad, the <em>Poetics</em> exists, and informs writers, playwrights, directors, actors and many more in theatre (and film &amp; television) to this very moment. Shakespeare once articulated “all the world’s a stage”; knowing that Aristotle alluded to this a thousand years before he did seems to make its relevance all the more important now.</p><h4>References</h4><ul><li>Aristotle, &amp; Garver, E. (2005). Poetics and Rhetoric. Barnes &amp; Noble Classics.</li><li>Balderston, D. (1996). Borges, Averroes, Aristotle: The Poetics of Poetics. Hispania, 79(2), 201–207. <a href="https://doi.org/10.2307/344881">https://doi.org/10.2307/344881</a></li><li>Brook, P. (1996). The empty space. Touchstone. (Original work published 1968)</li><li>Finkelberg, M. (2006). Aristotle and Episodic Tragedy. Greece &amp; Rome, 53(1), 60–72. <a href="http://www.jstor.org/stable/4122460">http://www.jstor.org/stable/4122460</a></li><li>Gilbert, A. H. (1947). Aristotle’s Four Species of Tragedy (Poetics 18) and Their Importance for Dramatic Criticism. The American Journal of Philology, 68(4), 363–381. <a href="https://doi.org/10.2307/291527">https://doi.org/10.2307/291527</a></li><li>Hansen, F. (1969). A Broadway View of Aristotle’s “Poetics.” Journal of Aesthetic Education, 3(1), 85–91. <a href="https://doi.org/10.2307/3331465">https://doi.org/10.2307/3331465</a></li><li>Heath, M. (2009). Should There Have Been a Polis in Aristotle’s “Poetics”? The Classical Quarterly, 59(2), 468–485. <a href="http://www.jstor.org/stable/20616699">http://www.jstor.org/stable/20616699</a></li><li>Rees, B. R. (1972). “Pathos” in the “Poetics” of Aristotle. Greece &amp; Rome, 19(1), 1–11. <a href="http://www.jstor.org/stable/642517">http://www.jstor.org/stable/642517</a></li><li>Sata, M. (1989). Aristotle’s Poetics and Zeami’s Teachings on Style and the Flower. Asian Theatre Journal, 6(1), 47–56. <a href="https://doi.org/10.2307/1124289">https://doi.org/10.2307/1124289</a></li></ul><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d53c0f1f5e36" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Problem with Precious Metals as our Moral Compasses]]></title>
            <link>https://saltygentlemen.medium.com/the-problem-with-precious-metals-as-our-moral-compasses-81ea74c891b2?source=rss-8bdea7783d20------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/81ea74c891b2</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[masculinity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[morality]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ethics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[John Erik Roh]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 05 Oct 2020 14:40:59 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-10-05T14:40:59.921Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>The Golden Rule, now The Platinum Rule, whats next?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*ApV938MQP3UHNd2Q" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@munz0?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Aaron Munoz</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p>Many of us learned the Golden Rule as kids. Whether it was in kindergarten, preschool, at home or through religious services the notion that one should, <em>Do unto others as you have them do unto you,</em> became a very important cornerstone of our future developing values surrounding morality. <strong>The Golden Rule </strong>is complex and with no singular origin; it is chiefly a theoretical hypothesis of philosophical origin. Many, many philosophers have sought to provide grounding evidence for this maxim because it creates a universal foundation in which all humans could potentially agree too and thereby move forward from. If every living adult and child accepted this notion as the foundational truth to gauge all interactions in their existence, we might not have nearly the problems we do in society. Yet it is incomplete, simply undone by the differences in ourselves — what if what I want done to me, somehow violates your personhood? Upsets you? Hurts you? Marginalizes you? Erases you? What then good does the Golden Rule do for us?</p><p>Milton Bennet, acclaimed communication scholar, developed the <strong>Platinum Rule</strong><em> </em>in response to the ethical dichotomy of the Golden Rule. The <em>Platinum Rule </em>seeks to supersede the Golden Rule by reworking the notion of mere reciprocation into one of <em>empathetic equity</em>.</p><p><strong>Do to others as they themselves would like to be treated</strong>[1] gives a more contextual framework that applies to the true nuances of communication as it exists, not just a vague guideline to follow. The parallels between The Golden Rule and The Platinum Rule mirror the parallels between social de-centering/ethnocentrism and empathy/projection.</p><p>As we understand social de-centering to be a cognitive process that “actively takes into account another person’s thoughts, feelings, values, background and perspective”[2], we can look at it’s opposite, ethnocentrism, and apply it in this context to mean the active <em>disregard</em> of another person’s thoughts, feelings, values, background and perspective. For what do all those things inform? <strong>One’s culture</strong>. And to believe in the inherent superiority of one culture over another is to socially center oneself above all others. As we understand empathy to be the “feeling of what another person is feeling”[3] we can also understand its opposite in <em>projection</em>. Projection is “is the process of displacing one’s feelings onto a different person”[4].</p><p>If applied to the Golden &amp; Platinum Rules, we can see that the Golden Rule individually presupposes that how you want to be treated is superior to the way others wish to be treated and that it is the most ethical to project how you wish to feel onto others. In the extreme, it promotes a socially centralized (ethnocentric) idea that how you feel is superior to the way others feel and it is in the best interest of all parties involved to project that feeling onto them. Whereas the Platinum Rule presupposes that we must imagine how others want to be treated and attempt to do that; “interact with them the way you think they’d like to be treated”[5].</p><p>The Golden Rule was something I lived by in my early teenage relationships. I grew up in a household where acts of service was <em>the</em> love language. Where fixing the problem for the person was how you showed you cared. This did not go well for me when I got married because it set me up for a toxic script I wasn’t even aware of. The problem with acts of service, is that often those acts <strong>are unasked for by one party</strong>. I always set out to fix my partner’s problems, attempting to streamline their life and remove obstacles, pains, etc.. in the hopes that clearing their path would leave only room for joy…<em>CoughToxicMasculinityCough…</em> But that doesn’t work.</p><p>And I would venture to guess many of us know this firsthand when someone chooses to give us advice on how to “fix” our problems, instead of listening and validating the struggle we are going through. My partner and I struggled for years in a miscommunication rut, because I could not identify my “fixit” attitude behavior as the root problem and they could not see their missing boundary as the open door that invited it in. It wasn’t until a traumatic awakening, separation &amp; therapy did I come to see my own issues with “fixing” them as obsessing with a phantom perfect relationship. And while I never learned about the platinum rule until recently, I did deepen my understanding of my moral core to expand on the narrow definition I once held to.</p><p>The Platinum Rule, despite its inclusivity over the Golden Rule, is still incomplete. “If we think someone isn’t being nice to us, then we are unlikely to be nice to them”[6] . The Platinum Rule, like the Golden Rule, is based on <strong>transactionality</strong>. In both instances, we are interacting with another either to a.) get what we want or b.) give others what they want. In both instances, we or the other, is a means to an end. An object in a transaction to some destination. No matter the path we use, empathy or projection, social centering or de-centering, the other party becomes a tool we manipulate to achieve a goal. Transactionality in this way defeats whatever noble purpose the Platinum Rule would give rise to.</p><p>How do we know how another person wants to be treated? Merely imagining it, or engaging with their culture, family, life circumstances is still some form of projection because we are only able to see through our understanding. The Platinum Rule must be utilized with curiosity and communication. We must seek to understand from the source, not our interpretation of the source. We must have the willingness and curiosity to ask and be ready to wholeheartedly seek to understand the answer. But if that curiosity and understanding is colored by motive to an end with another person, how then is it not <strong>manipulation</strong>?</p><p>The Platinum Rule is good, and we can still even do better. We must look deeper and see the transactional nature of our communications, and work to shift them from a give-to-get paradigm, to one of give-for-the-sake-of-giving. “Good” must be for the sake of good and nothing else, or it becomes a vehicle for something, an object. We are not objects, and as imperfectly as we communicate we can, for the sake of doing so, better our communication from one that sees others as means to an end, to one that sees others as ends unto themselves.</p><h4>Footnotes</h4><ol><li>(Beebe, Beebe, &amp; Redmond, 2017 pg. 112)</li><li>(Beebe, 2017 pg. 108)</li><li>(Beebe, 2017 pg. 108)</li><li>(<em>Projection</em> 2020)</li><li>(Beebe, pg. 112)</li><li>(Beebe, 2017 pg. 79)</li></ol><h4>Works Cited</h4><p>Beebe, S. A., Beebe, S. J., &amp; Redmond, M. V. (2017). <em>Interpersonal communication: Relating to others</em>. Boston, MA: Pearson.</p><p>Projection. (n.d.). Retrieved September 27, 2020, from <a href="https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/basics/projection">https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/basics/projection</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=81ea74c891b2" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[How To Become a Goblin]]></title>
            <link>https://saltygentlemen.medium.com/how-to-become-a-goblin-c0dfdcb265ed?source=rss-8bdea7783d20------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c0dfdcb265ed</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[fatherhood]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[wilderness]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[masculinity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[utah]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[John Erik Roh]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 23 Sep 2020 20:38:19 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-09-23T20:38:19.775Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>A cautionary desert tale</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*HMyd-3tpCYVqK5aC1g9Xpg.jpeg" /></figure><p>It’s 57 degrees outside, and the sun has just begun its ascent into the already cloudless, blue sky. She greets me first with a friendly wave, and an extra loud hello from beneath her floral cloth face mask. I introduce myself and we bump elbows, as she pulls me inside the quaint, and well-kept Goblin Valley visitors center. <em>Ranger Brooke,</em> she says, <em>I’ve never done an interview before, but I’m sure happy to help answer any questions you have about the park. Folks don’t seem interested much beyond a few pictures and pretending they’re in Galaxy Quest”.</em></p><p>She’s about five-foot-five, sandy blond waist length hair, and the bridge of her nose and forehead are covered in tell-tale Irish heritage freckles. She’s awfully young to be a ranger, but then again I only have experience with Smokey the Bear, and the one that Yogi and Boo Boo would terrorize in my childhood cartoons, so maybe she isn’t so young after all.</p><p><em>It’s nice to feel like my generation is showing up for the environment</em> she offers alongside a small glass of cool water she’s poured for me. “Why is that?” I ask, my curiosity levels rising as I reach into my bag for my pad and pen. <em>So many young people are raised here their whole lives, and never step beyond their familiar routines. Oh sure, they’ve been up Little Cottonwood, or maybe to Timpanogos, but this state has some of the most beautiful and rich natural history, it’s a shame more don’t experience it</em>. She follows with a long sigh and I sit while she quietly ruminates, lost in thought of what, I could only imagine.</p><p>“Tell me about how you came to be here”, I say, trying to warm her to better memories. She recalls growing up in California, and moving to Utah when she was six. Her parents instilled a love of the outdoors, and camping every weekend until she was almost out of high school. “Seems like being a ranger was destiny for you” I chime in, as she is laughing telling me about the time she played hide and seek in the woods and scared her parents so bad they nearly called in a search and rescue team. <em>You’d think that, but I originally planned to go culinary school</em>. She tells me the story that she enrolled for a semester and convinced some new friends to go camping a few times together. She loved the conversation, and the fun of making things together over a campfire, but she found herself policing the group. Keeping the campsites tidy, teaching them all about fire safety, how to start a fire (without matches and lighter fluid), how to build makeshift shelters and even basic foraging. <em>Ranger Brooke became a nickname started by those friends, but by the start of my second semester, I knew I wanted something different.</em></p><p>Living in West Valley growing up, she saw many places where natural lands were disrupted and destroyed by careless citizens.<em> A whole section of road was closed, because of people dumping trash into undeveloped land. Turns out it was a wetland habitat that was nearly destroyed</em>. “So you wanted to save the environment?” I ask her. <em>Not just save, but help people learn to appreciate and love the nature they live in</em>.</p><p>After high school, she studied at the University of Utah, applied for an internship working for Wild Utah in her second year. It was there she made connections, and within six months of graduating, had submitted her application to work with the National Parks.</p><p>“Did you start out here in Goblin Valley?” I ask her. She laughs a little and reaches into her wallet, pulling out a crinkly, well-loved, printed photo and hands it to me. <em>See the wild eyed excited kid?</em>, she asks me in earnest, <em>and the giant mountain behind her? That’s Bears Ears, and that’s me on my first day</em>. Apparently Bears Ears is known among the Diné tribes (and many others) as a place of feminine healing, and her boss, the “female Ron Swanson” sent Brooke there first because she thought they “needed one another”. “That must have been incredible” I say, still holding the worn out polaroid. <em>It was until they </em><strong>[redacted]</strong><em> ruined it.</em></p><p>Brooke visibly shifts her weight forward now, her elbows on the small steel table and head in her hands. She tells me about the love of the land, and the rangers who worked there. The tribes she interacted with. The (mostly) wonderful public, who meant well, but occasionally had to discipline for trying to get onto reservation land to forage for fossils and artifacts. She’d never taken back more than a few arrowheads from patrons, but the black market sale of Native American artifacts is something the Parks service has had to deal with in the past.</p><p>It’s here that the whole tone of our conversation shifts. While she is here at Goblin Valley, a mostly clean and quiet state park, her heart goes out to local parks, and national Utah lands that have suffered at the hands of the public and at the national government. <em>That video, the one where those people took explosives and destroyed a natural arch and hoodoo? It’s things like that that make my heart sick. It might have been faked, but the destruction of Utah land’s is all too real</em>. “I take it you’re not a fan of the current administration’s decision to” <em>— </em>she cuts me off before I can finish; <em>To literally cut Bear’s Ears down to nothing so they can mine it into oblivion, for capitalism? Yeah I’m not too happy about that.”</em></p><p>The hard part, she expresses, is that while many Utahns love the outdoors, many have never experienced them. Choosing to stay indoors and ignorant of the changing landscapes around them. <em>Folks don’t think about their single use plastics, their garbage from their camping trips, taking ‘souvenirs’ from their hikes, swimming in reservoirs when nobody is watching.. Little things add up over time, and our home is suffering because of it</em>.</p><p>She motions to me, and we get up from the little table we’re sitting at. She says for me to grab my gear, and I pack up my bag and my son and we start walking into the valley. The “goblins” are everywhere. Rock formations shaped by wind, rain, and eons of erosion, they look like rock gnomes. Some are small, like the size of a playskool buggy, some are massive, like the Three Sisters, as big as houses. We walk for twenty or so minutes, in the complete silence of the desert. No wind, no cars, no cell phones. Just the soft thump of our feet on the dried mud ground. She stops after some time, and after a quick drink of cool water, and letting my little guy down, she walks us the rest of the way to the Goblin Cave, an incredible rock formation she explains that formed over a hundred million years. Recently there was some vandalism to the cave; a little goblin was pushed over by some teenagers a week or so ago. <em>It’s one of my most favorite spots in the whole world, and yet it wasn’t safe from the cruelty of someone’s greed</em>, she quietly, somberly tells me. She hopes that by educating people in the parks, and online, that she can impart a curiosity to explore the land around us so that we may come to love it, appreciate it and protect it.</p><p>She grabs a little dust off the biggest goblin in the cave, mutters some words quietly and sprinkles a little bit on me and my son. <em>You’re now officially a goblin too; you must protect this cave and these lands at all cost. And even if you stray, you must always return and pay your respects to the goblin family to which you know belong</em>. My son yells excitedly, and tries to say the word Goblin, but his command of language isn’t entirely up to par at eighteen months. The crackle of radio static comes through on Brooke’s radio, and she nods, heading back out of the cave and back to the station. We stay a little longer and dance like wild things amongst our new family.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c0dfdcb265ed" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[In the Digital Garden of Good and Evil]]></title>
            <link>https://saltygentlemen.medium.com/in-the-digital-garden-of-good-and-evil-953f013a8300?source=rss-8bdea7783d20------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/953f013a8300</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[technology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[masculinity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[John Erik Roh]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 17 Sep 2020 19:41:47 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-09-17T19:41:47.512Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>Is the internet inherently good, evil, or neutral?</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*BPlU-wTYAg2MVHm5" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@tvick?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Taylor Vick</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p>If only such question could have an easy answer. As if somehow the internet could be the bad guy in a Saturday morning cartoon. Visible weaknesses, simple tropes and something dealt with swiftly and kept in check by the good guys every week. Or some miracle source of good that only benefited the world, incorruptible and accessible to everyone, only making things better.</p><p>I would love to have an answer to that question; but before we can ever debate the goodness, neutrality, or evilness of anything we first have to establish the parameters of what is good, neutral or evil?</p><p>You cannot simply throw out an accusation of something being “<strong>evil</strong>” or “<strong>good</strong>”, either inherently or by action, when you have not established a <em>baseline or minimum standard.</em></p><p>So, before we answer our questions, we must look into what we might mean by our qualifications. Chimamanda Adichie in her TED talk [1] reminds us of this important fact when she asks us to challenge our beliefs beyond what we have only experienced. It is not enough to have a one sided view of good/neutral/evil — which in this work, I refer to as the spectrum of morality (SoM).</p><p>To challenge our perspective we must not only challenge what we know by learning what others know, we must go a layer deeper by challenging the knowledge that our teachers know. We <em>must learn, and unlearn</em> according to the problems and experiences we face. It cannot be enough to gain new information, it must override factually incorrect, slanted, or misrepresented information that we have come to perpetuate as “truth”. Which in this context, truth refers to: <strong>a belief held by one to be of factual, demonstrable, undeniable, and objective evidence that can be reaffirmed to its maxim by any and all who encounter it.</strong></p><p>How then do we go about deriving the foundations of the SoM that represent all (or at least in some measurable way a vast majority) humans capacity for evil? We must rule out religious notions because they are too extreme and could in no way represent a majority of humans. Secular definitions may come close but we must be careful to not lean too heavy into any one cultures view points for the same reason we would not use religious ones. And for the sake of brevity in this argument, instead of dealing with infinite variations as I could begin to name them, let us narrow down to one by a much more learned and practiced individual in this area.</p><p>Immanuel Kant, a German philosopher developed what he believed to be an ethical and moral baseline code for generating any system’s basis of morality. In his <strong>Categorical Imperative</strong>, he identified and denotes an absolute, unconditional rule that must be obeyed in all circumstances and justifies as an end in itself. It is best known in its first formulation:</p><blockquote>Act only according to that maxim whereby you can, at the same time, will that it should become a universal law.</blockquote><p>Kant is advocating for filtering all personal moral choices and actions taken through this notion. Which put plain would be: If I chose to do this action, would it be ethical for then every other human on earth do so? The idea being that actions expanded out to their <em>maxim</em> help us weed out actons that use other individuals as <strong>means to and end</strong> rather than <strong>ends unto themselves</strong>.</p><p>Hypothetically, if I throw a piece of garbage out of my window while I am driving on the highway, it is only one piece, hardly amounting to anything and most likely without little consequence. But say every human threw a piece of garbage out of their window while they were driving; we would create billions of tons of garbage and an incredibly immense problem. It is therefore my ethical duty to not take the easy path by disposing of garbage wherever, using another to clean up after me and achieve my end of laziness, but do my duty to humanity to throw out the piece of garbage in the appropriate place we all have socially-contracted upon to do so.</p><p><strong>So, by this maxim then, where do our internet corporations fare?</strong></p><p>Miserably, by any stretch of the imagination. Every single one of the big corporations at hand (Facebook, Google, Apple, Microsoft) violates the Categorical Imperative, as we are used endlessly for our information and purchasing power. But we must look deeper at that thought. Are they truly evil because of what they do? Or are they merely complicated tools in a system designed by those who themselves are evil? Capitalism as an economic playbook functions on the exploitation of others. The many work for the few, and the few brutalize, exploit and use the many for their infinite ends. The many are numbers, data points, exploited machinations in a machine built for the sole purpose of using others as a means to an end.</p><p>Take Facebook’s humble origins at Harvard — it was a system created by Mark Zuckerberg to <strong>exploit</strong> his female classmates, rating their hotness, relationship availability, sexual promiscuity for his personal enjoyment, and the enjoyment of his male peers. It has now ballooned to a system that <strong>exploits</strong> countries and entire populations to learn their habits, likes and dislikes to connect other mercantile endeavors together so they can use both parties to enrich themselves. But just as a gun did not create itself and cannot fire itself, the <em>systems of social media are created for exploitation and enacted upon us.</em></p><p>There is no inherent morality in a tool. A gun is not good, and a media networking site is not evil. An object cannot inherently ascertain moral qualities. <strong>It is the people who create these tools</strong> to perpetuate and often enhance their evil desires that these “tools” share the blame. Never forget that we <strong>create</strong> and use weaponry to use as tools for the exploitation and manipulation of other humans. We use guns to perpetuate violence, war, systemic racism; We use social media to scrawl, mine, deceive and conflagrate the reality of the world we live in. Geopolitcal power drives much of the grand technological advancements we explore in this world; yet they are driven by the narcissim of small differences. Fears of the other, and the ego of ethnocentrism wedges us further and further apart.</p><p>The great Alexandre Dumas knew this, even as he wrote his fantastical stories of <em>The Three Musketeers; </em>“D’Artagnan was amazed to note by what fragile an unknown threads and destinies the nations and lives of men are suspended” [2]. The Duke of Buckingham went to war with France simply to adore Anne of Austria. Christopher Columbus committed the Caribbean Holocaust because he loved gold. Adolf Hitler became chancellor of Nazi Germany because he didn’t make it into art school. Ray Kroc founded McDonalds and grew it into the biggest fast food empire on earth because he liked to compete with his childhood friend Walt Disney.</p><p>By its own design Google cannot “be evil”. Maybe it should amend its motto to something else: “Never do evil”, and then maybe it might actually have a standard to uphold itself to and reject those who perpetuate evil.</p><h4>Footnotes</h4><p>1. Chimamanda Ngozi, “The Danger of a Single Story,” TED, July 2009, <a href="https://www.ted.com/talks/chimamanda_ngozi_adichie_the_danger_of_a_single_story.">https://www.ted.com/talks/chimamanda_ngozi_adichie_the_danger_of_a_single_story.</a></p><p>2. Alexandre Dumas and Barbara T. Cooper, <em>The Three Musketeers</em> (New York, NY: Barnes &amp; Noble Classics, 2004).</p><h4>Works Cited:</h4><p>Dumas, Alexandre, and Barbara T. Cooper. <em>The Three Musketeers</em>. New York, NY: Barnes &amp; Noble Classics, 2004.</p><p>Ngozi, Chimamanda. “The Danger of a Single Story.” TED, July 2009. <a href="https://www.ted.com/talks/chimamanda_ngozi_adichie_the_danger_of_a_single_story.">https://www.ted.com/talks/chimamanda_ngozi_adichie_the_danger_of_a_single_story.</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=953f013a8300" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Help! I fixed myself but I’m still unsuccessful!]]></title>
            <link>https://saltygentlemen.medium.com/help-i-fixed-myself-but-im-still-unsuccessful-2982afe8c459?source=rss-8bdea7783d20------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2982afe8c459</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[John Erik Roh]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 11 Sep 2020 23:27:56 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-09-11T23:27:56.601Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Self Improvement and success often occur together, that doesn’t mean they’re the same thing — Mark Manson</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*Vpbu-UVXCbQ0xyZT" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@clarktibbs?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Clark Tibbs</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p>Success is often coded deep within Toxic Masculinity to mean many things. It’s not just the completion of a task, or a win instead of a failure.</p><p>Success means many things in the western patriarchy, and in especially in America.</p><p>Think about what <em>success</em> means to you, for a moment. Is it a big house and luxury car? Attractive, sexy wife or girlfriend? Is it a six pack, boulder shoulders, ripped arms and tanned skin? What about financial freedom? The ability to travel and stay in luxury hotels? A thriving business with you as Owner/CEO and employees underneath you?</p><p>Or take it down a notch, and it means a job you don’t <strong>hate</strong>, an apartment you can <strong>afford</strong>, to not panic check your bank account before you have the thought about<strong> going out</strong> with friends?</p><p>All these “things” are that; often objects we must collect or milestones we must cross to prove we are men. And who tells us these things?</p><p>Other men we have learned from. Media we consume. And ultimately, the person we see in the mirror who holds tight to that rhetoric.</p><p>The lie is: <em>If you improve yourself, you’ll automatically be more successful. </em>And while self improvement and success have an overlap, it’s important to note they are not the same thing. Sure you may put an end to self-sabotaging behaviors, but the work of internal self-care and improvement does not magically equate to the loaded definitions of “success”. Having a positive self-image isn’t magically going to put money into your account, add more reps to your workout routine, or instantly make you attractive to women.</p><p>Self- Improvement cannot happen while you cling to toxic ideas. When you discover the lie that self-improvement does NOT suddenly make you healthy, wealthy and sexy, it can be incredibly easy to turn around on self-improvement and believe its bullshit. <strong>Hokey, new-age crap designed to “make you feel good”.</strong></p><p>But can we sidebar for a second and dissect that toxic statement? Why is “feeling good”, bad? Why is a healthy attitude and love for yourself, your body, your struggles, your life, somehow “unmanly”? What about suffering and pain is more valid than “feeling good”? If you have warped ideas that you aren’t allowed to feel good, love yourself for all your emotions <strong>and</strong> logic, then wouldn’t it follow that you don’t believe you’re allowed to have success?</p><p><em>Doesn’t it track then, that the real message you’re given and internalizing is that you’re only as good as how much your grind, exhaust yourself and feel miserable?</em></p><p>If you’re deeply holding onto this idea that being masculine is constantly struggling, then what you’re really chasing isn’t success and arriving at a place where you can enjoy the fruits of your labor. You already have what you want; misery. You are a man because you aren’t happy and you work nonstop.</p><p>Doesn’t that kind of suck though? I mean truly; isn’t that <strong>absolutely fucking miserable?</strong></p><p>Maybe challenging notions of what masculinity and patriarchy tell us about success, we can actually do the work to heal from deep traumas we inflict on ourselves and others. Maybe we can break cycles of broken rhetoric we tell ourselves about what we should feel and should be to qualify as a “man”.</p><p>Maybe if we heal that part of ourselves, we can actually put our hearts behind efforts to be successful, in a way that feels true and genuine to us, not to a vague, constantly moving goalpost designed to always be out of reach.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2982afe8c459" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Origins of Nutrition]]></title>
            <link>https://saltygentlemen.medium.com/the-origins-of-nutrition-b49b0779e9da?source=rss-8bdea7783d20------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b49b0779e9da</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[fast-food]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[food]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[capitalism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[history]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[nutrition]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[John Erik Roh]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 09 Aug 2020 01:18:58 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-08-09T01:18:58.787Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>It’s less about your health than you think</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*pFH02yimYNJ1gH8V" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@fishmac?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Vitalii Pavlyshynets</a></figcaption></figure><p>In the midst of a union labor crisis in 1941, Walt Disney once said to his workers:</p><blockquote>Don’t forget this, it’s the law of the universe that the strong shall survive and the weak must fall by the way, and I don’t give a damn what idealistic plan is cooked up, nothing can change that[1]</blockquote><p>Ray Kroc, founder of McDonald’s, once told a reporter in 1972:</p><blockquote>“Look, it’s ridiculous to call this an industry, this is not. This is rat eat rat, dog eat dog. I’ll kill ’em, and I’m going to kill ’em before they kill me. You’re talking about the American way of survival of the fittest”[2]</blockquote><p>Andrew Carnegie is attributed to have famously said:</p><blockquote>“If a man would eat, he must work. A life of elegant leisure is the life of an unworthy citizen. The republic does not owe him a living; it is he who owes the republic a life of usefulness”[3]</blockquote><p>These are the ideologies of industry titans that have shaped the American ethos since the turn of the century. It is these dogmatic, and perpetually grind-focused mentalities that have brought us to the climate in which we live in the modern day. One that has nearly autonomous control over the narratives of American food, diet and health.</p><p>Nutrition in American dialectic is an extremely complicated and rapidly shifting field of study as a well as profitable business sector. Having studied the current scientific findings and proposed theories about bodily nutrition, it was eye-opening (to say the least) to learn about the financially driven side of Nutrition, one that roots in a post World War II burgeoning corporate America. <strong>Fast Food Nation: The Dark Side of the All-American Meal</strong> by journalist Eric Schlosser is the spiritual successor to<em> </em>another journalistic tome that uncovered the insidious practices of a corporate conglomerate and forever changed the way Americans would consume their food. Upton Sinclair’s <em>The Jungle</em>, first published in 1906, shocked the American psyche to the horrors and atrocities of the meat packing industry; revealing that “human beings…had been made into ‘cogs in the great packing machine’, easily replaceable and entirely disposable”[4]. Schlosser’s work, first published in 2001, sinks deeper into the sludge first shown to us by Sinclair; revealing the <strong>deepest, darkest</strong> inner workings of a global billion dollar industry built on greed.</p><p>This damning exposé explores every corrupt facet of the Fast Food industrial complex and how it has shaped attitudes about consumption, nutrition, health, advertising, beauty, production, automation, and much more in the wake of the Second Wave of the Industrial Revolution of America. Diet trends, technological advancements, attitudes about weight control, food requirements, federal legislation have all been shaped by the insatiable desire of the Fast Food industrial complex, to the point that our subconscious psyche is <em>riddled </em>with marketing messages about food and generations of children have been raised with ideologies about food first drawn up in meeting rooms and offices of corporations looking to increase their profits.</p><p>These outdated ideologies have formed the bedrock current nutrition science is based on, and because of that, it is of the <strong>utmost importance </strong>to critically look at the food one eats, the narratives surrounding health, diet, and the cultures created by the intersection of all those points. Learning about nutrition today is a complex interweaving of history, capitalism, science &amp; pseudoscience and hegemony.</p><p>Today it’s called <em>MyPlate</em>, but growing up for many Americans, it wasn’t always so simple. Originally introduced thirty two years after the founding of the United States Department of Agriculture, the first <strong>nutritional guidelines</strong> would be introduced by Wilbur Olin Atwater, a chemist for Wesleyan University, as a farmer’s bulletin[5]. He would go on to publish <em>Principles of Nutrition and Nutritive Value of Food, </em>in 1904, which predated the discovery of vitamins, and focused on variety, proportionality, and moderation based on calorie counts[6]. His work would go on to inform <em>modern Olympic nutrition.</em> Which is important to note because from the very beginning, the <strong>roots of nutrition aren’t reflective of the general population’s actual health, but an idealized version.</strong></p><p>The first formal food guide would be published in 1916 by Caroline Hunt entitled: <em>Food for Young Children[7]</em> that focused food into <strong>groups</strong>, instead of merely calories, and emphasized heavily on the consumption of milk. This would stand until the publication of <em>How to Select Food</em> in 1917[8] that focused on adults until 1933 when it was replaced by the USDA introduction of <strong>food plans[9] </strong>that focused on prices of food in the Great Depression. That would be replaced with the introduction of <strong>7 food groups</strong> in accordance with war time rationing[10], but would be whittled down to <strong>four</strong> in post war 1956. The USDA would not make changes again to food education until 1992, with the introduction of the <strong>food pyramid</strong>. This pyramid was based on serving sizes and emphasized grains as the most important, and demonized “fat” above all else. This would be replaced in 2005 with the <em>MyPyramid,</em> that added in exercise as crucial to diet, and finally would be replaced with our current <em>MyPlate </em>diagram, on June 2nd, 2011. Each of these have in turned been informed by the climate of influencers and lobbyists who have contributed to the USDA throughout its history, and we will attempt to uncover much of the mystery surrounding the complexity of nutrition and how, in many ways, Fast Food has contributed to the way we Americans perceive their own health from inside the house.</p><p>It is this insider access that Fast Food has had in the earliest times of the USDA that has helped <em>shaped the way</em> Americans eat their food, where they get it, what it consists of, and what we understand to be healthy. The Fast Food industry is the nexus creation of the intersecting Agricultural and Business sectors in the Second Wave of the Industrial Revolution post World War II. Today it has a hand in nearly every industry and sector in America and single-handedly paved the way for the resurgence of turn-of-the-century monopolistic capitalism, the automation and decentralization of the American workforce, and has <strong>fundamentally altered</strong> the way Americans consume food and shaped our base perceptions about diet and health.</p><p>The efforts of these monumental conglomerates, cannot be understated. Schlosser writes:</p><blockquote>“On any given day in the United States about one-quarter of the adult population visits a fast food restaurant”.[11]</blockquote><p>And:</p><blockquote>“the typical American now consumes approximately three hamburgers and four orders of french fries every week”. [12]</blockquote><h4><strong>We are in the midst of an epidemic; one we have been buying into since before we were even born.</strong></h4><p>Eric Schlosser is best known for his investigative journalism. Having started in <em>The Atlantic Monthly</em> in Boston, his career took off with the publication of <em>Reefer Madness</em> and would gain national attention with a two part article that would premiere in Rolling Stone magazine. That article would form the foundation of the book <em>Fast Food Nation: The Dark Side of the All-American Meal</em> that he would publish to critical acclaim in 2001. Having no background in nutrition, his eye for investigative journalism details the corruption, greed, and shady business practices of one of the most influential industries in America today. <em>Fast Food Nation</em> focuses on the history of fast food, its origins, leaders, and early businesses that paved the way for the runaway success that the industry giants experience today. While he does not specifically focus on nutrition in his book, it is informed everywhere in his writing.</p><p>Exploring the nature of early propaganda that fast food industry pioneers used, in conjunction with the post-war economic boons from the federal government, mass advertising in the age of television and radio, the focus on shifting that advertising to children, vertical integration &amp; synergy that allowed for consolidation of businesses, monopolization of markets, and ultimately huge sums of wealth to bust up unions, buy legislation and create new propaganda; Schlosser reveals how the <em>origin of nutrition guidelines </em>were shaped by a rapidly growing fast food giant. Nineteen years later, his words have never held truer, as corporate fast food power has only waxed in the near two decades since its publication.</p><p>In the early 1920’s, a few years after the USDA released its guidelines for Young Children, <strong>General Motors</strong> began buying up trolley systems around the country[13]. Not content with just government subsidized road &amp; highway production (thank you Eisenhower, Hitler &amp; the Autobahn), GM wanted no competition with its new automobile industry, and convinced other companies that benefited from the government road building to help share the burden of the buying out the trolley and rail cars[14]. Eventually purchasing <em>over 100</em> companies in more than twelve states from New York to Los Angeles[15], GM would then <strong>demolish them</strong>. Every last one, sold for parts and scrap. The plot of <em>Who Framed Roger Rabbit</em> is actually based on GM’s destruction of state owned public trolley car transit. When the light of this racketeering crime came to light and was presented before a Grand Jury, GM and the other companies were fined a pittance of $5,000.</p><h4>T<strong>he Executives responsible were fined $1, each</strong>. [16]</h4><p>And with that slap on the wrist, two things changed in America. Big Business would never more be held accountable for such blatant criminal cooperation against the public and the nation forever more would be beholden to the automobile. This cooperation of business giants set the precedent for the Fast Food industry, who would stand on the shoulders of giants like US Steel, Disney, Iowa Beef Packers (IBP), and reach new heights previously <strong>unimaginable</strong>.</p><p>Post World War II America saw the greatest economic boon the world has ever seen. Eisenhower, fresh off winning the War, brought back more than heroism, he brought back spoils of war from the Nazi war chest. The Autobahn, Volkswagen, visionaries like Albert Einstein, Werner Von Braun, and over 1,600 scientists, engineers, opticians, geophysicists, chemists, physicists were brought back to America as <strong>intellectual reparations</strong> “owed” to the US for participation in the war as part of Operation Paperclip. The US prospered, gaining over $10 billion in valuated profits from patents and industrial processes it now held. Eisenhower enlisted a young Walt Disney, to create propaganda touting American exceptionalism and greatness in this post war boom[17]. von Braun had made appearances on episode <strong>Tomorowland</strong>, Disney’s futurism propaganda television show designed to warm Americans to the ideas of automation, business and most importantly nuclear power.[18]</p><p>One of his crowning films was during the war specifically, a film called <strong>Food Will Win the War; </strong>it<strong> </strong>was adopted by the USDA in publishing its guidelines for nutrition, and based around war time needs of food for soldiers overseas. The mass publication and propaganda of <em>Food Will Win </em>came not from nutritional scientists working for the good of the public, but from scientists designing MREs (Meals, Ready-to-Eat) for soldiers that could maintain their integrity and avoid spoilage. Keeping the soldiers healthy, and saving the war effort millions in disease, out-of-commission soldiers due to foodborne illness, and extended conflicts or battlefield defeats due to potential malnourished forces was priority. The health of post war America was determined less by what we actually needed, than what was <em>most fiscally economical</em> for the advancement of Democracy and the defeat of Facism.</p><p>The four food groups, or “Square Meals”, published by the USDA in 1956, was informed by four major industries at the turn of the century. The <strong>Dairy, Meat Packing, Sugar</strong> and <strong>Fruit</strong> Industry. Each of these conglomerates spent billions to win “defense contracts” with the federal government in order to feed the military. These companies would then develop the food necessary for the MREs of the armed forces, causing profits to surge during wartime and in the post war boom. The sugar industry saw the most potential to the lobby and in the 1960’s published <em>pseudoscientific research</em> in a recognized medical journal[19]. An industry group called the <strong>Sugar Research Foundation was behind </strong>a study commissioned by Harvard scientists that refuted claims of “sugar’s possible role in heart disease”[20]. This “research”, published in the widely respected and academic <em>New England Journal of Medicine</em> in 1967, shaped the conversation about food and fats for <strong>decades</strong> to come. It is this falsification of research that would then form the basis for a pro-grain, anti-fat culture beginning to develop in America circa the 1970’s.</p><p>Between 1920 and 1940, the population of California nearly <strong>tripled</strong>, as more than two million Americans made their way out west[21]. The Federal Government, training troops and military out in California would spend nearly $20 billion dollars in and around Los Angeles[22], building airplane factories, steel mills, military bases and more. This huge influx of people and spending saw the rise of restaurants, specifically roadside “carhops” that pioneered a new way of eating alongside the new highway system, one where the food came to you, and fast. It is in Southern California where the original fast food giants were born. Carl Karchner opened the original Carl’s Drive-In Barbeque (Carl’s Jr) on January 16th, 1945[23], Richard and Mac McDonald opened the first Speedee system McDonalds in 1948[24], Harland Sanders opened Kentucky Fried Chicken in 1952[25] and countless others would open and close their doors in the years that followed the war.</p><p>These large chains would find immediate footholds, quickly securing <strong>household recognition</strong> in children and adults. The automation of the food industry quickly, and skillfully, gutted the technical process to cooking; paving the way for huge strides in growing, harvesting, cooking, packing, shipping, storing, and serving food to the American public. Nutrition information published by the USDA formulated perfectly in the form of three square meals a day (MRE’s were initially in square containers), providing government backing to the notion of fast food’s goodness for American health and country. Alongside symbols of patriotism like the victory garden, or recycling metal, the <strong>hamburger and french fry</strong> became powerful symbols of American Nationalism. Nutrition focused not on vitamins, essential amino acids, a balanced diet of whole grains, varied and colorful fresh vegetables and fruits, dairy, unsaturated fats, phytochemicals, fiber, minerals… no, it became focused on beef, dairy, grains, all of which could be found in the American hamburger.</p><p>Throughput, or “scientific management”, were not terms the McDonald’s brothers were familiar with when they created their Speedee System of food service back in 1948, but its founding principles of assembly line production, largely borrowed from industrial factories of US Steel, Ford Motor Co, GM, put them in play. When Ray Kroc purchased the rights to begin franchising McDonald’s across America, the traveling salesman sought to <em>increase production and maximize profits</em>, not make the best, most delicious or healthiest hamburgers the world had ever seen. Kroc continued to develop and refine the speedee system, turning the kitchen into a factory, and cooking into assembly[26]. The ethos of speed and efficiency has driven fast food chains to <em>monopolize</em> every single aspect of food production, <strong>vertically integrating </strong>wherever they can to maximize profits, and minimize expense. One such instance is the french fry.</p><p>Initially brought to America by Thomas Jefferson in 1802[27], French fries wouldn’t gained universal popularity until WWI vets would bring them home, and in the 1930’s and 40’s with the popularity of drive in restaurants their popularity soared. With the advent of home refrigeration &amp; freezer technology, people like J.R. Simplot could sell frozen french fries to the masses; but their ultimate success wouldn’t manifest in the housewife’s kitchen. In 1966, Simplot and his budding french fry empire met with Ray Kroc and began selling his frozen, pre-made french fries in 725 McDonald’s across America. <strong>In ten years</strong>, the popularity and ubiquitous nature of the french fry catapulted sales and McDonald’s had more than 3,000 locations[28]. Schlosser details our obsession with french fries with:</p><blockquote>In 1960, the typical American ate eighty -one pounds of fresh potatoes and about four pounds of frozen french fries. Today the typical American eats about forty-nine pounds of fresh potatoes every year — and more than thirty pounds of frozen french fries. Ninety percent of those french fries are purchased at fast food restaurants[29]</blockquote><p>Simplot, whose price reducing frozen french fry contract with McDonald’s has shaped American eating habits, owns a “bloc of North American land that’s bigger than the state of Delaware”[30]. The J.R. Simplot Company, along with LambWest and McCain, the three largest frozen french fry companies control about 80% of the US market[31]. This conglomeration has only been possible by the massive strides in manufacturing and processing technology the french fry plants utilize at every single step of the process.</p><p>Of the thirty pounds of french fries that Americans consume, McDonalds original recipe called for them to be fried in a 7% cottonseed and 93% beef tallow mixture. This beef tallow gave McDonald’s french fries their signature taste, but there is one drawback. Tallow, or Lard is a saturated fat. Saturated fat, that already high in LDL cholesterol, when heated to high degree causes produces large amounts of free radicals. Renegade particles that wreak havoc on the body’s systems. In the early 90’s when the nutrition climate became largely influenced by a <em>shift away</em> from fast food culture and into <strong>fad-diet</strong> culture, cholesterol became the enemy. Schlosser reminds us that:</p><blockquote>“Farm Activist Jim Hightower warned of ‘the McDonaldization of America’. He viewed the emerging fast food industry as a threat to independent businesses, as a step toward a food economy dominated by giant corporations, and as a homogenizing influence on American life”</blockquote><p>McDonalds, in a maneuver to be relevant and “health conscious”, switched from beef tallow to pure vegetable oil in 1990. The problem became how to impart their signature beef flavoring when their french fries were no longer fried in beef fat? The answer lay in another industry who would become essential of the Fast Food Industrial Complex, one that services the entire world from a small plot of acreage on the New Jersey Turnpike.</p><p>As far back as the tenth millennium BCE, humans have been trading spice. The first documented spice route trades were from the Austronesian people who traded from the southern tip of India, to Sri Lanka. The early Roman Republic was “fed by its citizen farmers; the Roman Empire by its slaves”[32]. The rise of the Silk Road of antiquity would be the largest sharing of spices across continents until the Age of Discovery when the Ottoman Empire would control trade routes after the fall of Constantinople. Portugal’s circumnavigation of Africa to find a new route to the West Indies would reshape the way the world thought about the spice trade.</p><p>One can imagine that early hominids, like <em>Australopithecus Africanus</em> and <em>Homo Habilis</em>, who first played with fire to cook their food, sought ways to shape and change the flavor. These spices, like cinnamon, cassia, cardamom, ginger, pepper, turmeric that have been used to enhance the flavor of our food, drove <strong>thousands of years</strong> of human progress and innovation. It is no different today that we are driven by our need to eat, to create, and innovate using modern technology, the foods we consume. Schlosser reminds us that:</p><blockquote>“A nation’s diet can be more revealing than its art or literature”. [33]</blockquote><p>The spice trade didn’t “decline” as much as it became supplemented by the early colonial trade of sugar, molasses, wheat, and tobacco. The rise of the industrial ages in Europe and America would see the consolidation of many industries, and interestingly enough, it would be an industry adjacent to food, that would have the single greatest impact on the rise of fast food, and the commercialization of food, in the 20th century.</p><p>Biologically inextricable from one another, smell and taste inform many important processes in the body. Smell is widely scientifically accepted as the most important sense tied to memory. Early humans used their sense of smell in conjunction with taste to identify rotten or soured foods, identify poisonous plants, and help make decisions about what to eat in order to stay alive. Early human cultures adorned their food, homes and bodies with spices, oils and florals for their scent. Perfumery existed in India alongside the early spice transport, and would be introduced as an industry by the Hungarians in 1370, and flourished in Renaissance Italy during the age of Discovery, with France becoming the ultimate seat of perfumery with the coronation of Louis the XV. By the time of the colonization of the Americas, the French would bring perfumery into the new world with the creation of “Florida Water”. The establishment of perfume houses in New Jersey would see a boon with early American colonial boycotts of European goods.</p><p>These perfume houses sought new markets with the growing industrial revolution, and <strong>would find it in food</strong>. The International Flavors &amp; Fragrances company was founded in 1891 in New Jersey[34] and by the 1930’s would become the largest perfumery and flavor company in the world. Today, its manufacturing facility is located in an industrial corridor off the New Jersey Turnpike with several other flavor and perfumeries including Givaudan, Haarman &amp; Reimer (the largest German flavor company)[35], Takasago (the largest Japanese flavor company)[36], Flavor Dynamics, Frutarom, and Elan Chemical. “Two thirds of the flavor additives sold in the United States”[37] are sold in an area less than 55 square miles. IFF is the world’s largest flavor company[38] because it understands one fundamental piece of human biology:</p><h4>“The aroma of food can be responsible for as much as 90 percent of its flavor”. [39]</h4><p>Scientists have long understood that human taste is comprised of a narrow palette of available flavors: “sweet, sour, bitter, salty, astringent and umami”[40]. These pale in comparison to the olfactory senses which are infinitely more complex: “The nose can smell thousands of different chemical aromas. Indeed ‘flavor’ is primarily the smell of gases being released by the chemicals you’ve just put in your mouth”[41].</p><p>This discovery of aroma-as-food has shaped the conditions in which food has been harvested and in the modern century “created”. In a post-WWII society when processed food sales began to soar (as a result of the work done by agriculture companies to develop MREs), the flavor industry expanded from baked goods, candies and sodas[42] to nearly every sector of the spectrum of food in America. Brian Granger, the senior “flavorist” at IFF, in an interview with Schlosser, reveals that “he enjoys walking down supermarket aisles, looking at the many products that contain his flavors”[43]. The issue has become that as the science of flavor has grown, the food we consume has become artificially altered, drastically altering our eating habits, and subsequently the nutrition of the American diet.</p><p>On the surface, the sugar industry of the 1960’s sought to influence the public narrative about the consumption of fats. Camila Domonoske in her article for NPR explains:</p><blockquote>If Americans could be persuaded to eat a lower-fat diet — for the sake of their health — they would need to replace that fat with something else. America’s per capita sugar consumption could go up by a third.[44]</blockquote><p>This fundamental shift of public ideas about the dangers of fat (and cholesterol) would have long reaching effects, as the makers of pre-packaged and frozen foods would make the shift from fats, to sugar, to flavor their foods. This exchange was unequal, and the flavoring industry rose to answer the problem of added sugar. Schlosser acknowledges:</p><blockquote>Recognizing the need for flavor additives, the early food processors turned to perfume companies that had years of experience working with essential oils and volatile aromas…the great perfume houses of England, France and the Netherlands produced many of the first flavor compounds[45]</blockquote><p>The invention of the gas chronometer, mass spectrometers increased the amount of synthesized flavors in the heyday of the 1960’s[46]. Early “food” products like Pop-Tarts, Bac-O’s, Tab, Tang, Filet-O-Fish sandwiches (and thousands of others) rapidly shifted the American diet from almost entirely agricultural sources of food, to integrating large amounts of pre-packaged, sugar laden, artificially flavored foods.</p><p>This is the fundamental lesson to learn about American health and nutrition. It has been attributed to Plato that the gut is the cauldron of health, and for <strong>nearly 200,000 years</strong>, humans have by and large eaten food that they have naturally grown and cultivated. Chemical additives weren’t even a thought until the latter half of the twentieth century as a response of needing to feed troops in the trenches of WWI, and since that time, the processing of food has only grown <em>exponentially.</em> That nearly 90 percent of the more than thirty pounds of frozen french fries Americans consume every year, comes from fast food restaurants[47], showcases the <strong>power</strong> and permeability that processed food has made into the psyche of American food consumption and nutrition. This is a new era of human dietary understanding, as we have dramatically shifted, in a scant hundred years, away from eons of human eating habits.</p><p>As the production of food has shifted, and science has revolutionized both the production and our understanding of food, we now come to understand the larger link between how our food is grown, produced, shipped, consumed and disposed of in our local environments and globally. Beyond the scope of this essay, modern medicine has come to broaden our understanding of heart disease, cancer, food allergies, long-term inflammation, and has begun to push-back against the industrial food production complex. Divorcing from scientific findings <em>published by corporate interests </em>has led to more equitable widespread nutrition education for children and adults vis-a-vis the current MyPlate standards, as well as the booming private industry of nutrition and the emergence of “diet culture” in America. Fad diets further shape the American diet, as processed food companies latch onto the buzzwords of the time, altering their foods to meet dietary criteria: low-fat, low-sodium, gluten-free, non-GMO, Atkins-friendly, Paleo… <strong>the list goes on.</strong></p><p>In the shift from an agrarian society to an industrial urban society over the course of America’s history, the public has become more and more distanced from the food they consume, and thus have become less in charge of what is put into their bodies. Upton Sinclair’s scathing indictment of the meatpacking industry in the <em>The Jungle </em>brought to light this reality, examining an instance where a worker was killed after falling into a lard making machine, only to be packaged and sold to unsuspecting customers[48. Schlosser notes:</p><blockquote>Approximately ten thousand new processed food products are introduced every year in the United States… the rise and fall of corporate empires — of soft drink companies, snack food companies, and fast food chains — is frequently determined by how their products taste”[49]</blockquote><p>This in turn unwittingly shapes our nutrition, and ultimately our collective weight issues, as we have little control over what is put into our food products, with and without our knowledge. Dietary patterns are like unions to a corporate monopoly;<em> largely a nuisance</em>, <strong>often ineffective</strong>, and infiltrated in order to be weakened. Weight control is now more difficult than ever as the greed of a handful of corporations enact systemic oppression of the masses through secrecy, manipulation, legislation and propaganda.</p><h3>“Being healthy” is fundamentally at odds with giant corporations, a cost to their bottom lines they are looking to reduce.</h3><p>It would be reductionist to say nutrition is easy. Even here, we only touch on the complexity of how the nutrition of our food is informed largely by forces outside of our control. How our food is grown, the declining nutritional content of our vegetables, fruits, beef, poultry, dairy in the grocery store and fast food restaurants, quietly informs our nutrition before we even consciously make decisions for ourselves. Fast food has made incontrovertible changes to the way our food is grown, harvested and distributed to the public, and has shaped our ideas about nutrition as long as we have been concerned with it. Sophie Terbush in her USA Today article reminds us that:</p><blockquote>Calorie labeling in fast-food restaurants has no effect on the food purchases of parents or teens in low-income neighborhoods, according to a new study published in the International Journal of Obesity.[50]</blockquote><p>From the outset of the USDA, the fast food industry has shaped the dialogue of nutrition. Decentralizing the American workforce, automating the agricultural processes as well as the food preparation processes, and the mass propaganda of fast food has irrevocably shaped our nutrition ideals. From twelve food groups, to four, to a pyramid, to a plate; our understanding of what food gives our bodies is <strong>often at odds</strong> with a capitalist structure whose sole desire is to sell us the <em>most scientifically delicious food, in the most financially exploitative way.</em></p><p>It is this insider access that Fast Food has had in the earliest times of the USDA that has helped shape the way Americans eat their food, where they get it, what it consists of, and what we understand to be healthy. The Fast Food industry is the nexus creation of the intersecting Agricultural and Business sectors in the Second Wave of the Industrial Revolution post World War II. Today it has a hand in nearly every industry and sector in America and single-handedly paved the way for the resurgence of turn-of-the-century monopolistic capitalism, the automation and decentralization of the American workforce, and has fundamentally altered the way Americans consume food and shaped our base perceptions about diet and health.</p><p>Take a second a look at how much food you eat comes from fast food, and pre-packaged food. Do you know where it’s made? How it’s grown? Where the ingredients are sourced from? Do you look at nutrition labels critically, identifying the ways that it’s informed by colorism, ableism and defaultism about race standards? Nutrition is linked to many different systems; food production, wages, entry level jobs, agriculture, food science, packaging, shipping, real estate, advertising, and so much more. As you explore your own nutrition journey, see the ways every choice you make, for the good or bad of your health, impacts the world around you.</p><p>This quote from Gary Ruskin’s article in Mothering Magazine is important to note:</p><blockquote>“The number-one health problem in the United States is not SARS,” said Dr. Julie Gerberding, director of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC). “It is not emerging infectious diseases. It is the epidemic of obesity that we are watching unfold before our very eyes.”[51]</blockquote><p>An epidemic by and large laid at the feet of the fast food industries. We who consume must examine the lengths to which our consumption consequences have shifted the dynamics of our world at large. Next time you order from the dollar menu, go on another diet, or even check the nutrition facts on a label at the grocery store, hopefully you will see, more grandly, the interwoven structures that make up your choices for nutrition.</p><h3>Footnotes</h3><ol><li>Schlosser, Eric. <em>Fast Food Nation: The Dark Side of the All-American Meal</em>. Boston, MA: Mariner Books, 2012., pg.37</li><li>Schlosser, Eric. <em>Fast Food Nation: The Dark Side of the All-American Meal</em> 2012., pg.37</li><li>Schlosser, Eric. <em>Fast Food Nation</em> 2012., pg.37</li><li>Schlosser, Eric. 2012., pg.153</li><li>Combs, G.F. (1994), “Celebration of the past: nutrition at USDA.”, The Journal of Nutrition (published Sep 1994), 124 (9 Suppl), pp. 1728S–1732S, <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Doi_(identifier)">doi</a>:<a href="https://doi.org/10.1093%2Fjn%2F124.suppl_9.1728S">10.1093/jn/124.suppl_9.1728S</a>, <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PMID_(identifier)">PMID</a> <a href="https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/8089740">8089740</a></li><li>Combs, G.F. (1994), “Celebration of the past: nutrition at USDA.”, The Journal of Nutrition</li><li>“1916.” 1916 — Dietary Timeline. Social Issues Research Centre. Accessed July 21, 2020. <a href="http://www.sirc.org/timeline/1916.shtml">http://www.sirc.org/timeline/1916.shtml</a>.</li><li>“1916.” 1916 — Dietary Timeline. July 21, 2020.</li><li>“1916.” 1916 — Dietary Timeline. 2020.</li><li>“1916.” 2020</li><li>Schlosser, 2012., pg:18</li><li>Schlosser, 2012., pg:18</li><li>Schlosser, 2012., pg:16</li><li>Schlosser, 2012., pg:16</li><li>Ibid 2012., pg:16</li><li>Ibid 2012., pg:16</li><li>Ibid 2012., pg:38</li><li>Ibid 2012., pg:39</li><li>Domonoske, Camila. “50 Years Ago, Sugar Industry Quietly Paid Scientists To Point Blame At Fat.” NPR. NPR, September 13, 2016. <a href="https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2016/09/13/493739074/50-years-ago-sugar-industry-quietly-paid-scientists-to-point-blame-at-fat">https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2016/09/13/493739074/50-years-ago-sugar-industry-quietly-paid-scientists-to-point-blame-at-fat</a>.</li><li>Domonoske, Camila. “50 Years Ago, Sugar Industry Quietly Paid Scientists To Point Blame At Fat.” NPR. NPR, September 13, 2016.</li><li>Ibid 2012., pg:18</li><li>Ibid 2012., pg:18</li><li>Ibid 2012., pg:18</li><li>Ibid 2012., pg:18</li><li>Ibid 2012., pg:18</li><li>Ibid 2012., pg:69</li><li>Ibid 2012., pg:114</li><li>Ibid 2012., pg:115</li><li>Ibid 2012., pg:115</li><li>Ibid 2012., pg:116</li><li>Ibid 2012., pg:116</li><li>Ibid 2012., pg:3</li><li>Ibid 2012., pg:3</li><li>“Home.” International Flavors &amp; Fragrances. Accessed July 29, 2020. <a href="https://www.iff.com/en.">https://www.iff.com/en.</a></li><li>Ibid 2012., pg:121</li><li>Ibid 2012., pg:121</li><li>Ibid 2012., pg:121</li><li>Ibid 2012., pg:122</li><li>Ibid 2012., pg:122</li><li>Ibid 2012., pg:123</li><li>Ibid 2012., pg:123</li><li>Ibid 2012., pg:124</li><li>Ibid 2012., pg:129</li><li>Domonoske, Camila. NPR. NPR, September 13, 2016.</li><li>Ibid 2012., pg:124</li><li>Ibid 2012., pg:124</li><li>Ibid 2012., pg:115</li><li>Ibid 2012., pg:152</li><li>Ibid 2012., pg:124</li><li>Terbush, Sophie. “Calorie Labeling Doesn’t Change Fast-Food Orders.” USA Today. Gannett Satellite Information Network, March 7, 2011. <a href="https://usatoday30.usatoday.com/yourlife/food/diet-nutrition/2011-03-07-Calorielabeling07_ST_N.htm.">https://usatoday30.usatoday.com/yourlife/food/diet-nutrition/2011-03-07-Calorielabeling07_ST_N.htm.</a></li><li>Mothering on April 10, 2009. “The Fast Food Trap: How Commercialism Creates Overweight Children.” Mothering, September 21, 2015. <a href="http://www.mothering.com/articles/the-fast-food-trap-how-commercialism-creates-overweight-children/">http://www.mothering.com/articles/the-fast-food-trap-how-commercialism-creates-overweight-children/.</a></li></ol><h3>Supporting Materials (Citations)</h3><ol><li>“1916.” 1916 — Dietary Timeline. Social Issues Research Centre. Accessed July 21, 2020. <a href="http://www.sirc.org/timeline/1916.shtml">http://www.sirc.org/timeline/1916.shtml</a>.</li><li>“A Brief History of USDA Food Guides.” ChooseMyPlate, 2019. <a href="https://www.choosemyplate.gov/eathealthy/brief-history-usda-food-guides">https://www.choosemyplate.gov/eathealthy/brief-history-usda-food-guides</a>.</li><li>Chandler, Adam. “Fast Food.” Washington Post, Jun 16, 2019. ,<a href="https://explore-proquest-com.libprox1.slcc.edu/sirsissuesresearcher/document/2297102156?accountid=28671">https://explore-proquest-com.libprox1.slcc.edu/sirsissuesresearcher/document/2297102156?accountid=28671</a>.</li><li>Combs, G.F. (1994), “Celebration of the past: nutrition at USDA.”, The Journal of Nutrition (published Sep 1994), 124 (9 Suppl), pp. 1728S–1732S, <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Doi_(identifier)">doi</a>:<a href="https://doi.org/10.1093%2Fjn%2F124.suppl_9.1728S">10.1093/jn/124.suppl_9.1728S</a>, <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PMID_(identifier)">PMID</a> <a href="https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/8089740">8089740</a></li><li>Domonoske, Camila. “50 Years Ago, Sugar Industry Quietly Paid Scientists To Point Blame At Fat.” NPR. NPR, September 13, 2016. <a href="https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2016/09/13/493739074/50-years-ago-sugar-industry-quietly-paid-scientists-to-point-blame-at-fat">https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2016/09/13/493739074/50-years-ago-sugar-industry-quietly-paid-scientists-to-point-blame-at-fat</a>.</li><li>Karlamangla, Soumya. “Fast-Food Ban Gets Grilled.” <em>Los Angeles Times</em>, Mar 19, 2015. ,<a href="https://explore-proquest-com.libprox1.slcc.edu/sirsissuesresearcher/document/2262554989?accountid=28671"> https://explore-proquest-com.libprox1.slcc.edu/sirsissuesresearcher/document/2262554989?accountid=28671</a>.</li><li>Rep. <em>Restaurant and Food Service Industry in the U.S.</em> New York, NY: Statista, Inc., 2019.</li><li>Ruskin, Gary. “The Fast Food Trap.” <em>Mothering</em>, Nov, 2003. ,<a href="https://explore-proquest-com.libprox1.slcc.edu/sirsissuesresearcher/document/2266177976?accountid=28671"> https://explore-proquest-com.libprox1.slcc.edu/sirsissuesresearcher/document/2266177976?accountid=28671</a>.</li><li>Schlosser, Eric. <em>Fast Food Nation: The Dark Side of the All-American Meal</em>. Boston, MA: Mariner Books, 2012.</li><li>Schlosser, Eric. “Special Report: Slow Food — Fast Food Nation.” <em>Ecologist</em>, 04, 2004. ,<a href="https://explore-proquest-com.libprox1.slcc.edu/sirsissuesresearcher/document/2264185384?accountid=28671"> https://explore-proquest-com.libprox1.slcc.edu/sirsissuesresearcher/document/2264185384?accountid=28671</a>.</li><li>Terbush, Sophie. “Calorie Labeling Doesn’t Change Fast-Food Orders.” <em>USA TODAY</em>, Mar 07, 2011. ,<a href="https://explore-proquest-com.libprox1.slcc.edu/sirsissuesresearcher/document/2265695914?accountid=28671">https://explore-proquest-com.libprox1.slcc.edu/sirsissuesresearcher/document/2265695914?accountid=28671</a>.</li><li>Wilson, Charles. “The Birth of Fast Food.” <em>New York Times Upfront</em>, Feb 02, 2015. ,<a href="https://explore-proquest-com.libprox1.slcc.edu/sirsissuesresearcher/document/2265988325?accountid=28671"> https://explore-proquest-com.libprox1.slcc.edu/sirsissuesresearcher/document/2265988325?accountid=28671</a>.</li></ol><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b49b0779e9da" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Racism is the Sisyphean burden of Black America]]></title>
            <link>https://saltygentlemen.medium.com/racism-is-the-sisyphean-burden-of-black-america-70dcefd0aead?source=rss-8bdea7783d20------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/70dcefd0aead</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[white-supremacy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[racism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[masculinity]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[John Erik Roh]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 02 Aug 2020 19:40:04 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-08-19T17:35:25.776Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Because Whites have always kicked the boulder back down the hill</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*cjxdjbIt_I02laZC" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@historyhd?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">History in HD</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p>Issues of race have remained prevalent in this country because the cultural foundations of life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness that are built into the founding constitution, were only made possible by the exploitation, oppression, violent abuse and enslavement of Blacks in the diaspora.</p><p>In the annals of our history together there have been consistent measures to establish equality, eradicate racism, and lift the yoke of oppression that <strong>Blacks </strong>have borne since the inception of colonies on this continent. But over and over again, <strong>Whites</strong> have pushed back against change that threatens the status quo of their divine superiority &amp; manifest destiny.</p><p>Slave rebellions, the Underground railroad, works from Frederick Douglass, Harriet Beecher Stowe, the Abolitionist movement were the originators of the movements for the equality of <strong>Black</strong> Americans, (though many names lost to history paved the way before them) and when the Thirteenth Amendment was passed, it looked like America could finally move forward in a post-racial society. Where the <em>all men</em> in “All men are created equal” would actually <strong>include</strong> Black people.</p><p>But passing a law doesn’t make the change, the enforcement of that law does. And at every turn “everyday violence between individuals disproportionately targeted African Americans during Reconstruction”[1] . <strong>Whites</strong> overwhelmingly responded with violence against <strong>Blacks</strong>, yet little retribution came to them for violating laws, and committing heinous acts of violence;</p><blockquote>“White men beat or shot black men with relative impunity, and did so over minor squabbles, labor disputes, long-standing grudges, and crimes of passion”[2].</blockquote><p><strong>Whites</strong>, now suddenly bereft of their entire labor force, and source of unlimited profit, responded to the Thirteenth Amendment by forming white nationalist ethnocentric mobs:</p><blockquote>“While it is difficult to differentiate Klan actions from those of similar groups, such as the White Line, the Knights of the White Camelia, and the White Brotherhood, the distinctions hardly matter. All such groups were part of a web of terror that spread throughout the South during Reconstruction”[3].</blockquote><p>The Fourteenth Amendment passed despite a Veto from Johnson, yet its language only went so far, prohibiting state level racial discrimination, not individual, or business level racial discrimination, and <strong>Whites</strong> pushed back, channeling their anger through a policy reversal decision in the Freedman’s Bureau. This decision crushed hopes of freed <strong>Blacks</strong> telling them:</p><blockquote>“the promise of land was not going to be honored and that instead they should plan to go back to work for their former owners as wage laborers”[4].</blockquote><p>The Fifteenth Amendment prohibited states from denying any citizen the right to vote, yet <strong>Whites</strong> pushed back again, creating systems of disenfranchisement.</p><p><strong>Blacks</strong> hoping to vote in Mississippi would have to jump through a series of hurdles designed with the explicit purpose of excluding them from political power. The state first established a poll tax, which required voters to pay for the privilege of voting. Second, it stripped suffrage from those convicted of petty crimes most common among the state’s African Americans. Next, the state required voters to pass a literacy test. Local voting officials, who were themselves part of the local party machine, were responsible for judging whether voters were able to read and understand a section of the Constitution[5].</p><p>The Progressive Era advances would continued to be hindered by <strong>Whites</strong> at every opportunity, with racial inequalities disproportionately affecting <strong>Blacks</strong> in:</p><ul><li>WWI with the 369th Harlem Hellfighters coming home to death and racial violence of the “Red Summer” where white supremacy race riots erupted in more than three dozen cities and resulted in the murder of over 300 <strong>Black</strong> Americans</li><li>The Roaring 20’s where Black Wall Street was bombed by private aircraft resulting in the deaths of more than 300 Black Americans, and the Great Depression where groups like the Black Shirts advocated for firings of <strong>Blacks</strong> to make room for <strong>Whites</strong> (and often the killing of them when they would not vacate).</li><li>In a post-WWII economic boon America, the Eisenhower Administration (modeling the Nazi Regime’s building of the Autobahn) would create the National Highway system, and <strong>White</strong> communities in major cities lobbied (read: paid/bribed) commissions on the development of the plans for the highways to be built through <strong>Black</strong> communities, forcing them to relocate without compensation.</li></ul><p>The Era of Civil Rights that many of us are accustomed with and for many Americans, was the first time that violence against <strong>Black</strong> Americans became widely publicized and televised. This era is most often reduced to a handful of prominent figures, but consistently two men, whose immeasurable contributions to the freedom of <strong>Black</strong> Americans mirrored one another while simultaneously appearing to be at odds with one another.</p><p>Martin Luther King Jr, and Malcolm X rapidly advanced <strong>Black</strong> Civil Rights more in a short 15 year movement, than what had been accomplished in nearly 400 years before it. The words and actions of both these incredible men would echo on, informing the actions, choices, movements and protests nearly fifty years later.</p><p>On August 9, 2014, Michael Brown Jr., an 18-year-old black man, was fatally shot by 28-year-old white Ferguson police officer Darren Wilson in the city of Ferguson, Missouri, a suburb of St. Louis. The murder sparked national outrage and televised protests in Ferguson that rocked the nation. To the mainstream news media it looked like a violent protest by looting mobs, but any closer look at the “riots’’, one could see the truth. The protests of systemic injustice and disproportionate violence enacted on the <strong>Black</strong> community were broken up into distinct groups.</p><p>Again, <strong>Whites</strong> responded to <strong>Blacks</strong> demanding change, with a disproportionate response: the appearance of “Oathkeepers”. These Oathkeepers were <strong>Whites</strong> in paramilitary dress and automatic assault rifles. Who showed up in Ferguson, not protesting the unjust murder of Michael Brown, police violence, systemic racism; but to protect “Infowars”. A website known for its high-level conspiracy theory propaganda.</p><p>This group, with automatic and semi automatic weapons were naively lumped together with the peaceful protests by news media corporations and as such the state reacted to the threat of violence disproportionately. Steve Stenger, St. Louis Executive County Member, justified the increased national guard presence and state of emergency saying the community “worked too hard to be set back”[5]. But <strong>Whites</strong> focus on corralling <strong>Black</strong> protestors through tear gas and cops in riot gear because of their supposed threat of violence, not the actual men bringing guns to protect a website. They “handle” the protest, but overlook the root cause of the protest, which begs the question:</p><h4>Who is really doing the work in the community?</h4><p>These nonviolent protests are the teachings of Martin Luther King Jr. who sought to educate <strong>Black</strong> Americans to use a peaceful path of nonviolence to enact change. King believed nonviolent direct action created tension, which dramatized the issue in the Socratic method of “tension of the mind”, that would force open the door to negotiation[6]. Specifically in the case of a strong economic withdrawal program. King knew that <strong>Whites</strong> would not listen to morality claims for the advancement of <strong>Blacks</strong>, but would absolutely pay attention when their economics were threatened. This was the point of segregation; <strong>Black</strong> separation while still under White control. Slavery 2.0. Whites would still control rent, businesses and all financial outlets of Black communities while still keeping them separate enough</p><p>King’s nonviolent movements pushed to end segregation culminated with the Supreme court decision in <em>Brown vs Board of Education</em>. Disproportionately <strong>Whites</strong> responded with violent attacks on <strong>Blacks</strong>, KKK lynchings of students who dared to attend white schools, and some parents fully pulling their children from segregated schools and enrolling them in “private academies”, makeshift schools in the homes and basement of their neighbors[7].</p><p>This “white flight” can be seen even today, as language of laws making segregation illegal by the court systems overlooks private individual and business and their racism. In April of 2014, Wilcox County High School in Georgia held its first non-segregated prom since being de-segregated in the 1970&#39;s[8]. Though the school had laws to mandate the integration of Blacks and Whites, the administration had chosen to suspend all school proms, favoring private proms held by parents in the community. These private proms allowed active racial discrimination against <strong>Black</strong> students by the <strong>White</strong> members of the school district. This first integrated prom was still held <em>by the students</em>, not the school administration, and is evidence that despite many claims that Civil Rights “ended racism”, we do not, in fact, live in a post racial society. These passive “not racist” actions like the school refusing to hold any proms, allow for active racism to flourish, like parents holding segregated proms.</p><p>“Not-racist” has become the code for the hidden racism that spreads rampant in private individuals, businesses, and industries that aren’t under the jurisdiction of laws promoting equality of <strong>Blacks</strong> and <strong>Whites</strong>. The simple act of buying a home is riddled with this hidden racism. From her New York Times article, Shaila Dewan enlightens us to the plight <strong>Black</strong>, <strong>Latinx</strong>, and <strong>Asian</strong> peoples experience when buying a home as compared to <strong>Whites</strong>. Minorities experience: more questions about their financial viability, overt refusal to be shown homes, are shown less homes than <strong>White</strong> customers, experienced higher rents, were steered to homes unlikely to increase in value (leading to decrease in wealth) and more[9].</p><p>This pernicious hidden racism isn’t addressed in large scale regulation by federal government reform. Little penalties or punishments come to these individuals or businesses that engage in these predatory and discriminatory practices. Even if businesses purport equality and diversity, the microaggressions of <strong>White</strong> individuals against <strong>Black</strong> individuals have a longstanding financial cost. A cost that <strong>Blacks</strong> and other persons of color must pay heavily.</p><p>This is where King’s teaching of nonviolence and direct action falls short, as the rules for equality can change on paper, yet <strong>Whites</strong> find subtler and subtler ways to push back against increasing pro-<strong>Black</strong> reform. “Action on all fronts, when necessary”[9] is one of the core tenets of Malcom X’s philosophy. This is the crucial difference between King and Malcolm. They were not on opposing sides like one might believe, but Malcolm’s threshold for tolerance was lower than King’s. Malcolm only “advocated” for violence when met with violence. otherwise he held the same standard of nonviolence.</p><p>Malcolm, in his “Ballot or Bullet’’ speech, details the next step that Black Americans must take. The steps that exceed the capacity nonviolence is capable of. Openly disavowing notions of “anti-white”, Malcolm pushes King’s agenda of <strong>Black</strong> equality further when he says “I’m not going to sit at your table &amp; watch you eat, with nothing on my plate and call myself a diner”[10]. Malcolm wasn’t simply content to appealing to <strong>Whites</strong> sense of decorum and addressing social tension, he knew “they get all the negro vote…[and the] negro gets nothin in return[11].</p><p>Not content to be Democrat or Republican, he sought to wake up his fellow <strong>Black</strong> Americans to the notion that the corruption, lies, and manipulation were common to both parties, and that despite the supreme court outlawing segregation, and segregationist actions now criminalized; the hidden racism existed in both parties and appealing to morality of the <strong>White</strong> man was a fool’s errand. As the saying goes: <em>the master’s tools will never dismantle the master’s house</em>.</p><p>Malcolm wanted to push the movement out of the hands of Uncle Sam’s courts, rules, shifting fully from civil rights to human rights. Pivoting to human rights, the <strong>Black</strong>, <strong>Latinx</strong>, <strong>Asian</strong> diaspora could appeal to the courts of the UN, the world government to force the hand of the United States to make the changes necessary to equity and justice for them. King’s focus was on economic stress, Malcolm sought to focus on politics:</p><blockquote>“A ballot is like a bullet, you don’t throw your ballots until you see a target, and if that target is not within your reach, keep your ballot in your pocket”[12].</blockquote><p>Electing black officials, politicians, senators, governors was the message of Malcolm X. His view of segregation was: “when you’re under someone else’s control, you’re segregated”[13]. Only by Black communities being governed by Black representatives was the way forward.</p><p>Both of these men informed one another’s ideas and ideals, and the power of each has informed generations of <strong>Black</strong> Americans, empowering them to seize their own liberation. This power would be their demise as the disproportionate action of <strong>Whites</strong> would call for the assassination of both of these great leaders. King’s strategies of nonviolence and economic manipulation and Malcolm’s strategies of human rights and voting in <strong>Black</strong> officials have shaped the protests of the last fifty years. But they should not be taken separate. Together, each tenet can push the narrative forward and more closely secure the freedom, equity and justice that <strong>Black</strong> Americans have long been overdue.</p><p>Works Cited</p><p>1. Locke, Joseph, and Ben Wright. The American Yawp V1, 2019.<a href="http://www.americanyawp.com/"> http://www.americanyawp.com/</a>. pg: 420</p><p>2. Locke, Joseph, and Ben Wright. The American Yawp V1, 2019 pg: 420</p><p>3. Locke, The American Yawp, 2019 V1 pg: 420</p><p>4. Locke, The American Yawp, 2019 V2 pg: 129</p><p>5. CBS News. “Tensions after Confrontations Overnight in Ferguson.” CBS News. CBS Interactive, August 17, 2015.<a href="https://www.cbsnews.com/video/tensions-after-confrontations-overnight-in-ferguson/"> https://www.cbsnews.com/video/tensions-after-confrontations-overnight-in-ferguson/</a>.</p><p>6. King, Matin Luther. “Letter from a Birmingham Jail.” Letter from a Birmingham Jail [King, Jr.], April 15, 1963. <a href="https://www.africa.upenn.edu/Articles_Gen/Letter_Birmingham.html.">https://www.africa.upenn.edu/Articles_Gen/Letter_Birmingham.html.</a></p><p>7. Corbett, P. Scott, Volker Janssen, John M. Lund, Todd J. Pfannestiel, and Paul S. Vickery. <em>U.S. History</em>. Houston, TX: OpenStax, Rice University, 2017. pg 215</p><p>8. Klein, Rebecca. “School District Holds Its First Official Integrated Prom.” HuffPost. HuffPost, April 3, 2014.<a href="https://www.huffpost.com/entry/wilcox-integrated-prom-2014_n_5072414"> https://www.huffpost.com/entry/wilcox-integrated-prom-2014_n_5072414</a>.</p><p>9. X, Malcolm. “The Ballot or the Bullet.” Malcolm X: The Ballot or the Bullet, April 3, 1964.<a href="http://www.edchange.org/multicultural/speeches/malcolm_x_ballot.html"> http://www.edchange.org/multicultural/speeches/malcolm_x_ballot.html</a>.</p><p>10. X, Malcolm. “The Ballot or the Bullet.” Malcolm X: The Ballot or the Bullet, April 3, 1964</p><p>11. X, Malcolm. “The Ballot or the Bullet.” April 3, 1964.</p><p>12. X, Malcolm. April 3, 1964.</p><p>13. Ibid., April 3, 1964.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=70dcefd0aead" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Toxic Masculinity; Now What?]]></title>
            <link>https://saltygentlemen.medium.com/toxic-masculinity-now-what-2dd75cdabf0b?source=rss-8bdea7783d20------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2dd75cdabf0b</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[youth-sports]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[social-emotional-learning]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[therapy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[metoo]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[masculinity]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[John Erik Roh]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 02 May 2020 19:20:35 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-05-02T19:20:35.877Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>We’re still talking about the problem, when will we start talking about the solution?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*HMrXc0oaQ8lM4pef" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@matheusferrero?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Matheus Ferrero</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><blockquote><em>I am tired of men hurting women, each other, and themselves — Carlos Andrés Gomez.</em></blockquote><p><strong>Hegemonic Masculinity</strong>, and the more widely talked about <strong>Toxic Masculinity</strong>, represent one of the largest, most destructive, systemic issues of the modern era Western Culture faces. Its sinister influence is felt across our country, affecting politics, consumable media (film, television, advertisements etc..), national sports, corporations, the economy, the internet and much more.</p><p>It is an oppressive issue, we as a nation and people, are called to deal with. How we will deal with it as a nation is our biggest challenge. From the simple family unit, to the large scale repetition of toxic masculine diatribes in our television news media, there has yet to arise a single solution. A solution to engage with all the permutations of Hegemonic, and its inclusory: Toxic, Masculinity. In this discussion we will attempt to cover the three most prompted views on the most feasible solution to the problem at hand.</p><p>Hegemonic &amp; Toxic masculinity affects everyone you know. It is a poison that has filtered down generation after generation, bearing down on men and women alike, sapping our integrity, intuitiveness, individuality to feed itself in a deepening cycle.</p><p>Hegemonic Masculinity refers to the oppressive characteristic of masculinity boys and men must assume and perform to be considered a “real man”. Examples of culturally appropriate characteristics include</p><ol><li>Dominance over women and other men</li><li>Drive to provide</li><li>Being heterosexual, even to the point of homophobia</li><li>Demonstrations of caring through action</li><li>Performing aggression</li><li>Self-reliance</li><li>Exerting control and toughness</li><li>Courage</li><li>Being emotionally restrictive</li><li>Risk-taking</li><li>Displaying misogyny.</li></ol><p>Toxic Masculinity is the labeled reserved for the characteristics of Hegemonic Masculinity that are deemed detrimental to the person and society at large, but psychologists and scholars disagree on the necessity of the subset as the oppressive nature of Hegemonic Masculinity, as a whole, is a toxic manifestation of the gender construct. <em>[V. M. Marasco (2018): Addressing Hegemonic Masculinity With Adolescent Boys Within the Counseling Relationship, Journal of Child and Adolescent Counseling]</em></p><p>Globally, a man dies every minute by suicide. About twenty (20) per minute are physically abused by an intimate partner in the United States alone. <strong>One-in-three-women</strong> and <strong>one-in-for-men</strong> in will experience some form of sexual assault or violence in their lifetime. These are facts from the National Coalition Against Domestic Violence (NCADV), and a reality for the more than 325 million Americans living today. Toxic Masculine attitudes, and beliefs can be traced to the roots of many of these horrifying and tragic incidents. And with the number of occurrences so relatively high, you or someone you know is likely to experience the first hand cruelty Hegemonic &amp; Toxic Masculinity is capable of.</p><p>This discussion is not about the credibility or merit-worthiness of Hegemonic &amp; Toxic Masculinity, no, this is an attempt to break down in simplest terms the <em>solutions proposed so far</em> to engage with and dismantle those systems. As members of society, it’s our social responsibility to make cultural changes as a whole, and within ourselves, to provide a better future for generations to come. That means addressing detrimental systemic issues; including Hegemonic &amp; Toxic masculinity (HM &amp; TM). Do we make the change with our <strong>dollars</strong> behind large scale corporations that have the power to change culture with long term market shifts away from the incumbent attitudes to more progressive ones? Should we double down on <strong>counseling</strong> for men and boys on a personal level by intersecting with their spots and hobbies? Or do we push our elementary, middle and high schools to the front line of this debate by implementing <strong>Social Emotional Learning</strong> (SEL) curriculum nationwide? A complicated issue with no quick solution, to say the least, we need to explore every possible avenue in order to right this continued wrong.</p><p>Where do we begin with such a complex, monumental task? Let’s start with the first large-scale cultural shift away from HM &amp; TM in the 21st century. 2017 saw the rise of both the trending topic and subsequent feminist organization of the movement <strong>#metoo</strong>. What started as a simple hashtag by sexual assault survivor <em>Tarana Burke</em>, blossomed when female celebrity activist Alyssa Milano called for women everywhere to share their #metoo stories. It quickly gained international media coverage as millions upon millions of women and men<strong> began sharing their stories.</strong></p><p>It is in this vein where our first solution lies. As the sparking movement found its voice through a large-scale corporate social media conglomerate, Twitter, I present the first method we’ll be talking about.</p><h3>The Economics of Masculinity</h3><p>Do we make the change with our dollars behind large scale corporations that have the power to<em> change culture</em> with long term market shifts away from the incumbent attitudes to more progressive ones?</p><p>In the wake of the #metoo movement’s rise in awareness, companies by and large were not immune from being exposed by members abound of their workforces and communities. This radical awakening led many companies move to immediately pull an about-face in the functionings of their day-to-day operations and rise to the call-to-action of the #metoo movement.</p><p>One such example is the case of <strong>Gillette</strong>. On February 3rd 2019, Gillette premiered an ad during the 53rd Super Bowl. Titled <em>We Believe: The Best Men Can Be</em>, the minute long ad took an <strong>aggressive</strong> stance, calling out toxic masculinity and defying generations of <em>their own advertising</em> positions on men, authority, bullying and more. Pankaj Bhalla, Gillette brand director for North America, explains: “This is an important conversation happening, and as a company that encourages men to be their best, we feel compelled to both address it and take action of our own,”[1]. While it received backlash from men, feminists, publications and other media outlets, the company saw a <strong>10% rise in product sales</strong>, the highest rise in quarterly sales in 5 years. In her article about Gillette’s take on TM, Senior Reporter for the Wall St Journal’s digital media publication The Hub, Alexandra Bruell writes: “P&amp;G is among the companies that in recent years have used advertising as a platform to promote their stance on topics such as gender equality, immigration and gun control”[1].</p><p>Super Bowl LIII had a recorded 98.2 million televised live viewers. That 1:42 minute Gillette ad was shown to just about 30% of the entire United States population. <strong>Just like that</strong>, 3 in 10 Americans were suddenly thrust into a conversation we all needed to be having. And with the subsequent media blitz for the week after the shortened ad premiered on national television (outside of the super bowl), that number skyrocketed. Its aggressive stance sparked widespread debate on social media forums and dinner tables around the country. That kind of power to spark social discourse of that magnitude is not easily attainable. And thus we enter into the territory of the first solution. Imagine for a moment, that the NFL decided to take on the same anti-TM stance as Gillette? And then Tesla, Pepsi, Google, Tiffany’s, GOOP, Heckler &amp; Koch? Corporations big and small have a<strong> huge impact</strong> on our daily lives in America. Advertising and marketing messages are <em>impossible to escape</em>. And a trillion dollar shift in these huge conglomerates all talking about the same issue, the pressure would be incredible! But is it ethical for a for-profit company to push for such a social solution when it’s goal is <em>ultimately to make money?</em> What about the social ramifications to that kind of pressure? Is it healthy to replace one oppressive system for another even if the goal of one is far more holistic and healthy than the other? As the original ad seemingly backfired and alienated the buyers of Gillette, would anti-TM messaging from corporations ultimately <strong>cause more controversy </strong>than it would solve?</p><p>Let us now turn to another proposed solution while we ponder on those questions. In the opposite direction of mass media, and big corporate bucks, there is a large consensus of therapists, psychologists, and counselors that believe our collective healing from TM comes not from buying into it, but conversing about it <em>one-to-one</em>.</p><h3>Masculinity, Sports, and the Therapist’s Couch</h3><p>Psychologists, like R.W. Connell have been talking about Masculinity and its impact since the late 80’s and the conversation hasn’t slowed down since the revelations of <strong>#metoo</strong> and its subsequent follow up movement <strong>#timesup</strong>. The proposition is simple: engage in one-on-one conversations with men and boys and court TM on a personal impression level to overcome it. The new trick for this old dog is where these conversations are happening. <em>Moving away</em> from the therapist’s couch and sterile office, mental health advocates are pushing to open these conversations up on the football field, baseball dugout, and in many other sport and hobby arenas of men and boys.</p><p>Little league (and other youth sports) is a staple of HM for boys and young men growing up in America. Be it the cliché of tossing a ball with their fathers, learning a sport through extracurriculars at school, summer camps, community leagues or even just engaging with the televised collegiate &amp; professional leagues; <strong>sports play a big role in the lives of budding young men. </strong>Elissa Strauss, culture essayist for CNN has a lot to say about the unorthodox “curriculum of masculinity” boys are being taught. “Often a crash course in machismo, [sports] teaches boys to suppress vulnerability, and harness aggression and dominance. Winning is everything”[2]. With this quality of sportsmanship beginning at such a young age, it is no wonder, large scale organizations like the NFL are riddled with claims of TM in players, coaches, and management of all levels. The video of Ray Rice assaulting his fiancé in an elevator, Tom Brady deflating footballs, and Roger Goodell manipulating facts and information surrounding Chronic Traumatic Encephalopathy are only a <em>handful of examples </em>of the detrimental system at play. Yet with such prominence in the lives of our children, it’s potential power cannot be underestimated. Strauss interviewed Dan Blitstein, a volunteer youth soccer coach and coach advisor in Wyncote Philadelphia who’s own approach to youth sports is changing the conversation. “[He] tries to make sure the boys he coaches have a decent emotional vocabulary to avoid the jumble of rage and confusion he felt as a child”[2]. Strauss also got a statement from Ruben Nieves, the National Director of Training at the Positive Coaching Alliance that says “Such an attitude is increasingly common among youth coaches, but not yet the norm…one of PCA’s key messages is that coaches should value player growth over winning, and a big part of helping children grow as athletes — and people — is by listening to them”[2].</p><p>Vincent Marasco, PhD, LPC, NCC, and Assistant Professor of Clinical Mental Health Counseling at Purdue Northwest School of Education and Counseling <strong>warns caution</strong> in exploring therapy spaces within sports. “Organized sports [are] another example of a school sanctioned activity that promotes hegemonic masculinity… organized sports present adolescent boys in a literal arena in which to perform toxic aspects of HM in a socially acceptable and celebrated manner”[3]. He also advises specifically “Counselors working with adolescent boys need to take into consideration these social influences, their impact on the counseling relationship, and the unique ways adolescent boys perform masculinity”[3].</p><p>While the one-on-one approach might take the greatest effect, it is also the realm of the educated. It is admirable to take on the responsibility of wanting to help the young men and boys on a team you coach, or a league you oversee, as in the case of Dan Blitstein, but it is <strong>fraught with difficulty</strong>. As HM can inform, and alter the environment in which one counsels against HM, it needs a special awareness to make sure one <em>isn’t participating in HM while counseling against it</em>, as Marasco warns.</p><p>With the ethics of business tackling masculinity presenting its own issue, and the overwhelming nature of one-on-one counseling being a difficult venture to engage in without specialized education, where are we to turn to now? Our third potential solution may have the answer we are seeking.</p><h3>Masculinity and the Public School System</h3><p>Social Emotional Learning, or SEL, is “the process through which children and adults understand and manage emotions, set and achieve positive goals, feel and show empathy for others, establish and maintain positive relationships, and make responsible decisions”[4].</p><p>It’s <strong>school-programming curriculum</strong> that elementary, middle and high schools take as full classes to learn emotional and social skills. These skills focus on 5 core competencies (in no particular order):</p><ul><li><strong>Self awareness</strong>: the ability to accurately recognize one’s emotions and thoughts and their influence on behavior</li><li><strong>Self-management</strong>: the ability to regulate one’s emotions, thought, and behaviors effectively in different situations</li><li><strong>Social Awareness</strong>: the ability to take the perspective of and empathize with others from diverse backgrounds and cultures, to understand social and ethical norms for behavior, and to recognize family, school, and community resources and supports</li><li><strong>Relationship Skills</strong>: the ability to establish and maintain healthy and rewarding relationships with diverse individuals and groups</li><li><strong>Responsible Decision-Making</strong>: the ability to make constructive and respectful choices about personal behavior and social interactions based on consideration of ethical standards, safety concerns, social norms, the realistic evaluation of consequences of various actions, and the well-being of self and others.[4]</li></ul><p>These core competencies inform the curriculum CASEL gives to the more than 20% of schools in America that voluntarily engage with SEL classes. Study after study shows <strong>decreased dropout rates</strong>, school and classroom behavior issues, drug use, teen pregnancy, mental health problems and criminal behavior [4]. Sara Miller Llana, Bureau Chief of Latin America for the Christian Science Monitor since 2006, reports on how schools around the world are trying to <em>prevent the root </em>of sexism taking hold by teaching children as young as 2 years old. “‘These kids are growing up with an awareness that there is an imbalance of power in our society, and they’re being challenged to unpack that and break it down,’ says Joshua Forehand, principal at Nestor Munro Community School, an elementary school in Wisconsin that has introduced discussion on gender and identity into the school plan”[4]. Wisconsin, and many other states join a large coalition of nations around the world like Iceland and Israel, where social emotional learning is being impressed upon children from pre-k to high school ages in order to help <strong>directly address</strong> sexism, traditionalist mindset views about gender &amp; gender roles, bullying and more.</p><p>Educators also must consider, as the culture changes to recognize equality and equity among genders, the influence of TM in past educational works and materials. <strong>As question to consider:</strong> is it ethical to continue to teach, read, and otherwise explore works written by men who have been implicated by the #metoo movement? Emma Goldberg, Researcher and Journalist for the New York Times explores the worries that educators have about the complex nature of changing curriculum and censorship. She says “some argue that tossing out works by men accused of abuse creates an opportunity to break up the ‘old white guys club’ that for too long defined school reading lists”[5]. This question is part of a larger question raised by the #metoo movement and its subsidiary movements, most namely the enactment of <em>“Cancel Culture”</em>. Goldberg asks “Should [the works] be <strong>canceled</strong> — banished from public engagement like some of their creators? Or should they continue to be <strong>studied</strong>, only with frank discussions about abuse and harassment?</p><h3>Two Steps Forward, One Step Back</h3><p>Hegemonic &amp; Toxic Masculinity are pervasive, invasive, and expansive subjects that have no clear answers on the immediate horizon.</p><p>Despite that fact, it is still our social responsibility to continue to discuss the implications of both and strive to find ways to overcome and eradicate this systematic oppression.</p><p>Do we make the change with our dollars behind large scale corporations that have the power to change culture with long term market shifts away from the incumbent attitudes to more progressive ones? Should we double down on counseling for men and boys on a personal level by intersecting with their spots and hobbies? Or do we push our elementary, middle and high schools to the front line of this debate by implementing Social Emotional Learning (SEL) curriculum nationwide?</p><p>I personally believe the answer lies in the power of Social Emotional Learning. <strong>But not just in classrooms</strong>. While tackling this issue for the next generation is important to stem the tide of it spreading further and further, there is much we can do about it here and now. Large corporations are creating their own movements to incite personal discussion, like the men behind Australia’s Men’s Health and Awareness movement <em>Movember</em> and Dr. Robert Glover with his book <em>No More Mr. Nice Guy </em>and the thousands of seminars he has taught to men around the world. Social Emotional Learning is something we can all experience and engage with, from the elderly to the youth. <strong>Encouraging corporations</strong>, with our buying power, to enact social emotional learning programs into their corporate culture; E<strong>lecting political candidates</strong> that endorse Social Emotional Learning programs in public schools and advocate for more accessible mental health programs for all; <strong>Requiring youth athletic coaches</strong> in private and public programs to take courses in SEL coaching as well as yearly continuing education; <strong>New parents</strong> can be offered SEL classes alongside birthing and newborn classes to help them navigate their child’s first few years.</p><p>There are <em>endless ways</em> to incorporate social emotional learning into our everyday life, not one among us wouldn’t benefit from learning how to navigate our own emotions better and learning tools to enhance the quality of our relationships and strengthen our own personal boundaries. <strong>Communication reduces anxiety</strong>, and learning how to more effectively communicate our internal narrative can only help us in overcoming long standing systemic oppression in HM &amp; TM, patriarchy, misogyny and heteronormative colonialism.</p><p>Empowering us as a society to recognize the flaw is what ultimately matters. Over punishing perpetrators, and even protecting victims. If we can overtly see the failure in HM &amp; TM <strong>we can do better.</strong> Then perpetrators can be educated and helped instead of shamed and isolated, victims can be given justice and respect instead of being re-triggered or mocked.</p><h4>Supporting Materials</h4><ol><li><strong>Bruell, A.</strong> (2019, Jan 15). Gillette urges men to shave ‘toxic masculinity’ in new ad. Wall Street Journal Retrieved from <a href="https://explore-proquest-com.libprox1.slcc.edu/sirsissuesresearcher/document/2266068070?accountid=28671">https://explore-proquest-com.libprox1.slcc.edu/sirsissuesresearcher/document/2266068070?accountid=28671</a></li><li><strong>Strauss, E.</strong> (2020, Feb 11). Why sports can be so toxic to boys and how we unravel that culture. CNN Wire Service Retrieved from <a href="https://explore-proquest-com.libprox1.slcc.edu/sirsissuesresearcher/document/2384321825?accountid=28671">https://explore-proquest-com.libprox1.slcc.edu/sirsissuesresearcher/document/2384321825?accountid=28671</a></li><li><strong>CASEL</strong> (2020, Jan 1) What is SEL? Retrieved from <a href="https://casel.org/what-is-SEL/">https://CASEL.org/what-is-SEL/</a></li><li><strong>Llana, S. M.</strong> (2018, Feb 28). Can schools help rid the world of sexual harassers and abusers? Christian Science Monitor Retrieved from <a href="https://explore-proquest-com.libprox1.slcc.edu/sirsissuesresearcher/document/2262647603?accountid=28671">https://explore-proquest-com.libprox1.slcc.edu/sirsissuesresearcher/document/2262647603?accountid=28671</a></li><li><strong>Goldberg, E</strong>. (2019, Oct 07). Do works by men implicated by #MeToo belong in the classroom? New York Times (Online) Retrieved from <a href="https://explore-proquest-com.libprox1.slcc.edu/sirsissuesresearcher/document/2307704384?accountid=28671#undefined">https://explore-proquest-com.libprox1.slcc.edu/sirsissuesresearcher/document/2307704384?accountid=28671#undefined</a></li></ol><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2dd75cdabf0b" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Dear, Dear Evan Hansen, Thank You]]></title>
            <link>https://saltygentlemen.medium.com/dear-dear-evan-hansen-thank-you-b5c8bfa8b23c?source=rss-8bdea7783d20------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b5c8bfa8b23c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[broadway]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[theatre]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[masculinity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[musicals]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[theatre-review]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[John Erik Roh]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 30 Apr 2020 00:31:32 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-04-30T00:31:32.353Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>A critical look into, and review of, the Broadway phenomenon</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/600/1*WlFiCIqwadd2VHQrNm2vzw@2x.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>Dear Evan Hansen</em> is the story of Evan Hansen’s little white lie. An emotionally fragile young man, son of a single working mother, Evan writes letters-to-himself at the behest of his therapist. At the computer lab at his high school a printout of one of his letters is found by another troubled student, Connor Murphy, and in a moment of confrontation, misunderstanding and rash action, Evan’s note is found with Connor’s backpack after his suicide.</p><p>In a desperate attempt to comfort a deeply grieving Cynthia (Mrs.) Murphy, Evan <strong>lies</strong> about the origins of the letter, claiming it as one of a long string of correspondence between the two boys. The suicide rocks the school and while Connor is mostly unknown among the student body, suddenly Evan’s connection to him vaults him into forefront of the tragedy as his lie <strong>spirals</strong> out of control with the Connor Murphy Project, and his made-up relationship that goes viral alongside itand <em>inspires millions of people worldwide</em>.</p><p>The production accomplished this feat in a three-fold manner.</p><ol><li>Cleanliness of presence</li><li>Exacting of message, and</li><li>Awareness of itself.</li></ol><p>Cleanliness of presence; in this context it means that from top to bottom, the script, music, set, actors and meta-production presented themselves (and were presented) in a clean manner. Not to mean “the opposite of dirty or covered in filth” <strong>but to mean “used to emphasize completeness”</strong>. <em>No one thing in the play had more emphasis over another</em>. The actors’ dialogue, their movements were equally important as the chosen set pieces, instruments used in the composition of the music, and colors in the lighting.</p><p>Each element of the play was as important as the other and clean in their own way. The set had large “screens” that visually explored the digital world in which <em>Dear Evan Hansen</em> exists, alongside the real world of couches, bedrooms, living rooms and kitchen tables it also inhabits.</p><p>Visually, the balance between them served as a tangible dichotomy of the <strong>struggle</strong> Evan has between a manufactured lie in digital space and the truth of his life in the real world, the <strong>struggle</strong> his mother has between being present for her son and being a provider for her son, the <strong>struggle</strong> the Murphys have between processing their grief and the shame and failure triggered by Connor’s suicide.</p><p>The costumes were uncomplicated, but <em>thoughtfully</em> chosen; Evan’s wardrobe mimics his character arc, wearing brighter colors and more traditionally masculine button-ups the more he needs to present in front of others (and the further away he moves from who he really is to what he believes others want to see), and back to his starting wardrobe by the end of the play.</p><p>Even the lighting choices functioned to invisibly enhance the play. Certain characters were given color schemes and the intensity of the light was increased or decreased with the intensity of the character’s presence onstage yet it was so well accomplished that the effect was nearly <strong>imperceptible</strong>.</p><p>“Cleanliness” is often used as a qualitative metric in visual design, and it applies in that sense to the production. The production was complete. Each of its internal mechanisms serve to sustain a single unbroken line, and from that, the audience can grasp the whole and all its details at once.</p><p><em>Dear Evan Hansen</em> also succeeds in its exacting of message. In this case, that is to be understood as the production<strong> never loses sight of its message</strong>. It never gets muddled, even as the character’s questionable decisions, moral dilemmas, and perilous dramas create a muddy environment to wade through. #youwillbefound is that message. <em>Evan is lost</em>. Emotionally he is awash in the trauma of his father’s abandonment, and his mother’s unintentional neglect. He is lost in the turbulence of adolescence, the storm that is high school. <em>Connor is lost in that same sea</em>, and lost in his own mind with pressing mental health issues that overtake his sanity.<em> Adults are lost</em> in their grief and the perilous journey of parenthood. And most tellingly, <em>we as a society are lost</em> in a great digital sea, that swallows us up, even as it is intangible to us.</p><blockquote>The violent need to project meaning and receive validation calls into sudden existence wild and unpredictable forms</blockquote><p>Adjacent to that message, <em>Dear Evan Hansen</em> explores <strong>issues</strong> of the damaging nature of toxic &amp; hegemonic masculinity in adolescents, in men, and in fatherhood; <strong>issues</strong> of bullying in schools and the role social media plays in counterbalancing or exacerbating it; <strong>issues</strong> of western ideologies about identity politics, the demonization of individual needs, the scapegoat of validity, shaming of therapy seekers, and the uniquely pervasive American dogma of “bootstrap pulling”.</p><p>But these issues are for the audience to interact with as they unfold, and overlap on each other in succession. Even as <em>Dear Evan Hansen</em> shines light on these issues, it does not focus on them. It does not deviate from its keystone, as #youwillbefound informs all the decisions of the characters, and the message of the lyrics of nearly every song. Everyone is <em>seeking visibility in their own way</em>, each wanting to be seen and doing their best with the limited language they have to do so. The violent need to project meaning and receive validation calls into sudden existence wild and unpredictable forms. Evan manufactures both the <strong>mechanism to maintain</strong> a non-existent friendship with a dead classmate and a <strong>non-existent friendship</strong> with a dead classmate in a mere instant as he desperately runs towards the tiniest ray of light that might shine on him with real acceptance. Larry Murphy emotionally <strong>adopts</strong> Evan in the wake of his sons suicide to prove to himself that he isn’t a failure as a father and his <em>hegemonic masculine methods of stoicism and distance parenting</em> that form the basis of his identity are actually successful, and Connor is somehow a fluke and not his responsibility. Zoe Murphy begins <strong>dating</strong> Evan as a bridge to connect the estranged brother she so desperately wanted attention from. Even the unseen individuals who <strong>donate</strong> to the Connor Murphy Project, do so because <em>the message it spreads gives them hope that they are not alone</em>, and being seen as contributing, is just that, <strong>them being seen.</strong></p><p><em>Dear Evan Hansen</em> maintains its cleanliness, and exacting message because it succeeds in <strong>never forgetting</strong> its own awareness of itself. Not in the <em>comedic breaking-of-the-fourth-wall-with-a-sly-joke-and-look-at-the-camera,</em> but in only ever telling the story of a young man’s honest-but-misguided attempt at <strong>finding his place</strong> in the worlds he belongs to. The myriad of issues it shines light on only ever belong to the audience to sort, judge and keep track of. <em>Dear Evan Hansen</em> doesn’t masquerade a plot and songs as bait into accepting the playwrights social agenda.</p><p>It doesn’t dive into <em>surrealist fantasy</em> about the goodness of human nature of by tying all the loose ends of character choices into perfect ethical resolutions. The production doesn’t <strong>engorge</strong> itself on spectacle at the expense of the rest of itself. It is as close to Peter Brook’s exemplary <em>Holy Theatre</em> as I can surmise. The ground it touches verbally and visually, is hallowed, and in doing so gives off a reflection of the invisible-made-visible so we can experience it. <em>Dear Evan Hansen</em> is a reproach of the reigning monarchs of Broadway but by accident; it’s too focused to be accused of trying to upstage or revolt against the institution to which it belongs.</p><p>There is no dupe of nostalgia the audience falls for; the child inside us that remembers that fear and longing of being sits beside the adult that is also us and for a moment <strong>we hold our own hands</strong> as we see the invisible hands of behavior and thought, feed the hunger of form, function, shape, and rhythm that silently dictate our deepest and fullest human lives.</p><p>It deserves higher praise than I can give it, far beyond clichéd platitudes critics assign the barest of deference from the marginal norms Broadway allows on its stages. If you have the opportunity to see it, I encourage you to do so before it succumbs to Deadly Theatre’s poisonous tendrils.</p><blockquote>All I see is sky forever</blockquote><blockquote>(A moment.</blockquote><blockquote>A suspension.</blockquote><blockquote>Black.)</blockquote><p><strong>END</strong></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b5c8bfa8b23c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>