<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Samah Abdelrahim on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Samah Abdelrahim on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@samahrahim?source=rss-9176c890179e------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Fri, 20 Nov 2026 02:15:19 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@samahrahim/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Abraham, fire, and Bayesian inference]]></title>
            <link>https://samahrahim.medium.com/abraham-fire-and-bayesian-inference-7ac4a09e653f?source=rss-9176c890179e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/7ac4a09e653f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[occasionalism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[abrahamic-religions]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[islamic-theology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[causality]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[bayes-theorem]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Samah Abdelrahim]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 09 Sep 2026 02:26:48 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-09-12T04:16:24.704Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>In the books, and by books I mean arguably divine books like the Quran and post-biblical interpretations, a story about the great-grandfather Abraham is told, with minor deviations here and there. The main point is that Abraham was thrown into a massive fire pit because he refused to worship some idols of that time and/or smashed his father’s idol shop. “In the Quran (primarily in Surah Al-Anbiya 21:51–70), young Abraham (Ibrahim) openly challenges his people and his father for worshipping carved idols. He destroys their gods, leaving only the largest one. When confronted, Abraham tells them to ask the big idol what happened. Unable to answer, the community resolves to punish him to protect their god”. But what does this have to do with Bayesian inference?</p><blockquote>Occasionalism: the claim that God is the only real cause of anything, and that fire burning, water running, or a knife cutting are only the occasion on which He acts, never the doer.</blockquote><p>This story is where the debate over occasionalism among Islamic theologians in the 9th-10th centuries CE always ended up. So after Ibrahim is thrown into the massive fire, Allah commands: “O fire, be coolness and safety for Abraham.”The fire miraculously obeys, burning only his bonds while leaving Abraham completely unharmed and at peace. So whatever usually “causes” the fire to burn was somehow deactivated in that moment, and this is where the debate circles around. To illustrate, what makes this story a story about a miracle is that fire naturally possesses the power to burn; human flesh and other materials like cotton are naturally flammable. But for a theologian to believe this story, they need to resolve this problem: how come it naturally burns, but it doesn’t burn Abraham this time? Where does the “cause of the burn” lie? Is it intrinsic to the fire itself, in which case the fire should just keep burning whenever it comes into contact with anything flammable? It is a law of nature. But if at any point this causal link can be disconnected, and the fire stops burning, then causality must lie somewhere else, and not intrinsic to the fire.</p><p>Ash’arite theologians, one of the main schools of Sunni theology, pioneered by Abu al-Hasan al-Ash’ari (d. 936 CE), argue that Fire has no power to burn. When fire touches cotton, God creates the fire, creates the cotton, and creates the burning at that exact moment. The world here is not a machine that keeps running on its own once it has been started: it is made again, moment by moment. This pattern is usually repeated, creating what humans perceive as “laws of nature,” but in fact they are merely “Sunnat Allah, Ada = consistent divine habits and customs”. Now, I am not writing this about whether Abraham is burned or not, whether he was actually thrown into fire, or whether he even actually existed, and if you are thinking about this right now, this post is probably not for you.</p><figure><img alt="In the ordinary story, cause sits inside the fire, and the fire burns because of what fire is. All three take it out of the object and put it somewhere else: God’s will, human habit, a distribution over beliefs." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*SHav_0-kns19uK38wzqeKg.png" /></figure><h3>Just a language metaphor</h3><p>The fire and cotton thought experiment was first introduced, as far as my knowledge goes, by the early Ash’arite master Al-Bagillani (d. 1013 CE), who argued that a real causal agent must possess intent, will, and knowledge of what it is doing. Therefore, calling fire an “agent” is an error. He concluded that humans use language metaphorically for convenience (e.g., “the fire burned the cotton”), but it doesn’t tell anything about the “cause” of burning. Then, Al-Ghazali (d. 1111 CE) advanced this argument and talked about “cause, effect, necessity, observation, and causation,” summarizing it into what we now simply refer to as “correlation doesn’t imply causation,” i.e., <em>two things happening together, again and again, does not tell you that one of them is making the other happen.</em> If God wills it, the continuous recreation of the universe can simply omit the property of burning, or the body catching fire, which explains how Abraham survived the furnace. But to prevent panic, Alghazali made it clear that God governs His own actions with perfect consistency and reason. He reliably creates the burning whenever cotton touches fire so that the universe remains predictable and orderly for human life, giving the <em>illusion</em> of natural laws.</p><p>Similarly in lab, when a prediction fails, or a null couldn’t be rejected, it could either be that the theory was wrong, the theory is right, but the causality link was superseded somehow, or something confounded/intervened, and I didn’t measure it.</p><blockquote>The null is the boring baseline: the assumption that there is no real effect (using a screen or not doesn’t make a difference for children); not being able to reject it means the data weren&#39;t strong enough to rule that baseline out.</blockquote><blockquote>Confounded means something else was going on that I did not measure, and it produced the result instead.</blockquote><p>Al-Ghazali’s ideas entered Europe later through his opponents’ books, like (Ibn Rushd, who somehow became Averroes, and Ibn Sina, who somehow became Avicenna), more than his actual writings. Centuries later in Europe, the Western philosopher David Hume advanced a nearly identical skeptical argument about cause and effect, where he argued that all we ever see is one thing followed by another, again and again, and we never see the connection itself. The sense that fire must burn comes from habit in us, not from anything we observe in the fire. He called it custom, which is exactly what the Arabic word ‘ada` means in Al-Ghazali&#39;s writings.</p><blockquote><strong>You still didn’t answer the question: how is this related to Bayesian inference?</strong></blockquote><h3>What about Bayesian inference?</h3><blockquote>Bayes’ rule is a way of updating what we believe about the world. You start with what you already believe based on your current experience. You see something new, and you end with a revised version of what you previously thought. The starting belief is called the prior. The revised one is called the posterior.</blockquote><p>Bayes’ rule, as I understand it, relies heavily on this idea of priors; the idea of a prior is exactly why we say the fire will burn. We haven’t tested every fire that ever exists, but we still avoid fire every time we see it, simply because we have strong priors based on what we have seen before: it will burn us if we come into contact with it. That is exactly the position of occasionalism as stated by the Islamic theologians like Al-Ghazali. A “prior” is our observation of the “Ada=custom” and its consistency updates our beliefs every time, to the extent that the posterior becomes so strong to be weakened, and there is no reason for it to, otherwise, life will be intolerable. Priors of both 0 and 1 force the posterior to stay the same no matter what the evidence is.</p><blockquote>A prior of 0 means: this is impossible. A prior of 1 means: I am certain about this. Both are dead ends, because the rule works by multiplying what you already believe by what the new evidence says. Start at zero, and you stay at zero forever, no matter what you see next. Statisticians call this “Cromwell’s rule.”</blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ZgY_B4TY7BGcEqW1mdtgTg.png" /></figure><p>At first I thought the connection between statistical Bayesian thinking and those old ideas from the Asharite school of thought until Hume was only conceptual and structural. But then I did some searching and found that Richard Price, a friend of Thomas Bayes, published Bayes&#39;s work after he died in 1761. Price’s publication of Bayes’s writing was directed at Hume to oppose his skeptical stance on induction and religious miracles (<em>induction is using what has happened so far to think about what will happen next</em>). Hume thought that (when a single witness tells you they saw a miracle, it is always mathematically more rational to believe the witness is wrong than to believe the laws of physics were broken). However, Price and Bayes argue this breaks down with multiple independent witnesses, especially when strong priors exist about the witness’s reliability. Later critics of the assumption of conditional independence pointed to a flaw in their ideas.</p><blockquote>Conditional independence means the witnesses’ mistakes are unrelated: one witness being wrong tells us nothing about whether the next one is also wrong. But if they talked to each other, or if they all walked in expecting to see a miracle, their agreement counts for much less than the math assumes.</blockquote><h3>From Baghdad, to Edinburgh, to my stats class</h3><p>Across at least three eras, three locations, three people, and three vocabularies, they said similar things: refuse to put the cause inside the object, and each relocates it elsewhere. However, they take different interpretive routes: Al-Ash’ari, Al-Bagillani (77 years later), and Al-Ghazali (98 years later) move it into God’s will and direct divine intervention; Hume (600 years later) moves it into the human mind and takes an entirely secular conclusion; and Bayes (at the same time as Hume) moves it into a probability distribution. Denying necessity, direct causality, and avoiding priors of 0–1 are all ways to keep the door open. You might want to keep it open to keep learning, or to prove that God exists and that we know it because miracles exist.</p><blockquote>A Probability distribution is a spread of belief across different possibilities, instead of a single yes or no. Instead of the event either happening or not, it could happen with a 10%, 50%, or 90% probability.</blockquote><p>Maybe those three schools of thought are themselves victims of the (Adat, custom, prior), as they are using the same chain of thought to claim different things, things they cannot observe. Whenever we measure any effect, the effect of burning on cotton, we observe the contact, the burning, the ashes, but never the cause itself, and no instrument or more data can fix this. Which is a lesson for us as scientists and teachers: the science we do right now is an accumulation of human tradition that happened across different times, locations, languages, cultures, and, most importantly, for different reasons. The motivation of each one of these scholars could possibly contradict the motivation of another, but somehow they all contributed very crucial and rigorous knowledge and methodologies that are shaping our lives and the way we do science until today.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*z2FxgMDE-gdlJ7ZT9he0SA.png" /></figure><ul><li><a href="https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/occasionalism/#HistOcca">https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/occasionalism/#HistOcca</a></li><li><a href="https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/al-ghazali/">https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/al-ghazali/</a></li><li><a href="https://ideas.repec.org/a/taf/eujhet/v20y2013i1p29-57.html">https://ideas.repec.org/a/taf/eujhet/v20y2013i1p29-57.html</a></li><li><a href="https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/arabic-islamic-causation/">https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/arabic-islamic-causation/</a></li><li><a href="https://www.muslimphilosophy.com/ei2/baqillani.htm">https://www.muslimphilosophy.com/ei2/baqillani.htm</a></li><li>Quran 21:69 (Surah Al-Anbiya)</li></ul><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=7ac4a09e653f" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A Handful of “Ful”: One Day in Omdurman]]></title>
            <link>https://samahrahim.medium.com/a-handful-of-ful-one-day-in-omdurman-c62357ba6b0e?source=rss-9176c890179e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c62357ba6b0e</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[war]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[sudan-crisis]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[resilience]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[sudan]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[khartoum]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Samah Abdelrahim]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 08 Aug 2026 18:50:15 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-08-09T00:43:32.542Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>This is not my story. It belongs to Mohamed Hamed Jumaa Nawwar, a Sudanese writer who stayed in Abbasiya, Omdurman, while it was under RSF occupation during the war that started in April 2023. He posted it on Facebook, in Sudanese Arabic, remembering just one day: August 8, 2023. I translated it here with his permission and the help of Claude. The writing is his; I only carried it into English so that more people can read it. Sudanese Arabic does not map comfortably to English, so I kept some words as they are, with a short explanation the first time they appear. Whatever is lost in translation is my fault, not his.</em></p><p><em>That day, in 22023, he had posted this:</em></p><blockquote><em>Oh people, give us a half-time. Let us go find some ful and sort out our lentils. Man, this is officially a hard day!</em></blockquote><figure><img alt="People, give us a half-time. Let us go find some “ful” [fava beans] and sort out our lentils. Man, this is officially a hard day!" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*9T50E2Hh0-EA9blq" /></figure><p><em>Ful is stewed fava beans, one of the most everyday Sudanese foods. This is what he was out looking for. Here is the story of that day, as he wrote it.</em></p><p>Then, today, August 25, 2026, he posted his memories of that day:</p><p>I remember this day well. I was in Abbasiya, “a neighborhood in Omdurman”. I went out early, heading for “Hay al-Dubbat – al-Dubbat neighborhood”, to fetch water. I said goodbye to the wall of the X’s family’s house and glanced down the street at some of the Y’s family houses. South of me was the home of the Z family. That one was like a citadel, in how it was built and how it was sealed all around. I remember that when I reached Khor Abu Anja “Abu Anja’s water Creek”, I noticed the place was unusually quiet, which in the protocols of those days meant a battle was coming. So I turned back, and no sooner had I taken the first steps of the road south than bullets crackled and the sky spilled over with gunfire from every direction. I pressed myself against a wall of <em>jalous “</em>mud brick”. Some of the bullets passed, I think, by the edges of my cheek. Or so it seemed to me. I panicked for a moment, then remembered another protocol: the bullet that kills you is the one you never hear. Since I could hear them, they had already passed me by.</p><p>TThe gunfire grew heavier. I think the army was advancing from around Banat and the al-Daw Hajjuj post, northward toward Abbasiya. In situations like this, the militia is usually like a rabid dog. The expectation was that they would slip through the streets inside the neighborhood, and your miserable luck would place you between the two brackets of killing and capture if they came across you in the street. I was certain I was a dead man, because I could hear the din of their voices. At that moment, a man came out. An older man, wearing nothing but trousers and an undershirt. I think his house stretched across the space between two streets, joining one side to the other. He shouted at me in alarm: get in, quick! Then he pointed with his finger to say the militia soldiers were at the far end of the street. I dragged my feet, crawling from the side facing him, pulling along my empty water <em>bagha “ a bottle, or a </em>plastic jerrycan”, until I reached him. He scolded me: are you insane? Is this a day to go out in? Then, in a hurry, he told me his name and the names of everyone in the house, and invented a family relation for me to claim if those tyrants stormed in. He did not know me, and I did not know him before. He sat me in the salon with some of his sons, and before that he called out to the women of the house: water and tea! And would you believe that carrying these from the women’s courtyard to the <em>diwan “</em>the sitting room”, required crouching and dodging?</p><p>TThe diwan had a beloved old-time flavor. The old color television. Enlarged photographs and sashes arranged on the walls. Suitcases lined up on top of the wardrobe. A wide bookshelf, dominated by covers pairing the Mahdi with Karl Marx, and a thick Quranic commentary. I kept my silence. Then a conversation began that shut out everything that was happening around us. That puzzling makeup of Sudanese people, how quickly they pour out the chemistry of connection into the room. Its opening was a large photograph, or an oil painting, of a young man with a beautiful forehead and beautiful eyes. My host said this was his late brother, a <em>zol</em> of football and song “zol = person”, one of the great supporters of al-Nasir football club of Omdurman. My elderly host kept handing me cups of tea and swearing I should ask for food if I wanted any. He joked: of course, all we have is lentils, but your auntie who made this tea makes world-class lentils. We talked, silenced only by that whistle that comes before a <em>dana “</em>an artillery shell” explodes. What baffled me was that the man spoke like an artillery expert. He would say: this one was fired from Hay al-Umara “Hay = neighborhood” and will land in Khor Abu Anja, and that one is from Maydan al-Rabi and most likely fell near the Aisha al-Abbasiya folks or Hawwa al-Taqtaqa! “a famous female Sudanese singer.” Then he would take a sip of his tea and call out the boys’ names: what is all this trembling tonight? It’s only tea, isn’t it! Then he would laugh, looking up at the ancient ceiling of the house, and say: you know, if one of those lands on us… <em>sajam</em> on all your mothers. Sajam is the ash of mourning; this is how a Sudanese jokes about his own death.</p><p>After about two hours, I left, carrying strict warnings from my host, who saw me off after filling my bagha for me: watch yourself, keep to the dead streets until you reach the houses of the Arabi folks. And I did exactly that, but I fell into a militia group ambush that ended with my water seized and dumped out in front of me. I was beaten, after bullets’ grazes under my feet touched my toes and left a wound that took months to recover. Again, while I was slipping through, I came upon militia men breaking into a building they thought was a shop, because of a Pepsi sign on its walls. Their leader shouted: can’t you see we’re working! And I said, under my breath: my apologies, doctor! I think their leader somehow sensed that I must have muttered something to myself that was not flattering. He came to me and tore my shirt, feeling my collarbone like an orthopedist. Before letting me go, his followers gathered around me as if they were reading a patient’s X-ray. Inside me, mockery was flowing so fast I nearly laughed. Every second I wanted to shout: I swear, doctors, all of you are doctors! It is the irony of tragedy: when I came back, all I had hoped for was one safe window to get a <em>kamsha</em> of ful “a handful of fava beans”.</p><p><em>Under his post, one of his friends, “Obaid Sideig</em>” <em>wrote this reflection. I translated it too, because it says what I would have wanted to say:</em></p><p>Sometimes I wonder about the secret of this strange Sudanese spirit: how can a people carry this much loss, fear, uprooting, and waiting, and still keep, despite everything, the desire to smile, to laugh, to sit with others and drink tea and go on with their lives?</p><p>I do not know if it is spontaneity taken very far, or recklessness, or a particular way of surviving. But it seems that the Sudanese, from the sheer weight of what they have seen and endured, have learned something that cannot be taught: how to live with pain without letting it cancel life.</p><p>We do not live because we have not suffered, and we do not smile because things are fine. We smile, sometimes, because we have understood that grief, however great, cannot be all that is left to us.</p><p>Maybe this is why some Sudanese stories sound unbelievable to others. You read about a man in the middle of gunfire, hiding in a stranger’s house, offered tea and food, talk and laughter passing back and forth while shells fall outside. Then he walks out, survives or gets hurt, and after all of that he is still looking for a bite, a handful of ful!</p><p>This is not lightness in the face of tragedy, and it is not disregard for pain. It may be one of the deepest forms of human adaptation: to carry your pain with you without handing it the reins of your life.</p><p>A Sudanese may be uprooted from his home, lose someone dear, survive death, start his life over from zero… and then, at some moment, laugh from the heart.</p><p>That capacity is exactly what astonishes me. To hurt without becoming pain. To fear without stopping to live. To lose so much, and still keep something small inside that says: <em>lissa fi bukra</em>. There is still a tomorrow. Maybe this is the strangest and most beautiful trait of the Sudanese spirit: that after everything it has been through, it still wants to live.</p><p><em>Originals: </em><a href="https://www.facebook.com/mhmd.hamd.jm.t.nwar/posts/pfbid0uPGzZSE5jf9mZVRg5AzvrewhDWSyWYBTbFCjwEdTZed149XqdDeEScZA673UHWsBl"><em>Mohamed Hamed Jumaa Nawwar’s post</em></a><em> and </em><a href="https://www.facebook.com/Bettyie?__cft__[0]=AZZvpjWswmN39UOshjAWgd1wcqi3WN7cyr9CtWLa_PHCSIj2qaiesznAP2y_C2gaTkyo6Ym5aiy7UmXUTSze-vI1irf4awoPAiPQwwr8B1-gEWoPoquWfthlTrUNJpj0-m7TZGnoSfjZXl-14bvqbs7J89CSPLX1nngHZohxo89nQwX7ct7BQJ-5PjUXjXQXL88&amp;__tn__=-UC%2CP-R">Obaid Sideig</a>’s reflections<em>, both on Facebook.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c62357ba6b0e" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A leap of faith, and evidence?]]></title>
            <link>https://samahrahim.medium.com/a-leap-of-faith-and-evidence-7b87cf933562?source=rss-9176c890179e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/7b87cf933562</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[science]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[scientific-method]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[faith]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[islamic-sufism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[religion]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Samah Abdelrahim]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 24 May 2026 23:00:35 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-05-25T17:40:24.508Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>A believing scientist</p><p>I was born in a believing environment. A belief here refers to the religious belief, believing in “Allah/God”, who is above and beyond our mental capacity, but sent us a religion that shows us the right path. For millions of people I know, this is not news. This is their daily life, not even worth mentioning. Now, though, it is the exact opposite for me; I even sometimes feel scared to say that I am a believer, since I know many people may find it “funny” to believe in such a thing.</p><p>To me, being a scientist and a believer are not two identities in conflict. They are two rooms in the same house, the lab and the prayer mat, the dataset and the du’a, and I walk between them every day without changing who I am. They are two disciplines of <em>seeking</em>: both demand humility, honesty about limits, patience with ambiguity, and a willingness to be transformed by what is true. Both change you, if you let them. Science trains my relationship to evidence; to the seen, faith trains my relationship to what cannot be fully measured; to meaning, to the unseen. And both, at their best, train my relationship to myself.</p><blockquote>In Islamic literature, a common story goes that Fakhr al-Din al-Razi, a 12th-century scholar and philosopher, was once walking through town with a large group of his students. An old lady, curious about the scene, asked a student who the man was. The student replied, “How could you not know him? That’s Fakhr al-Din al-Razi. He has 70 proofs for the existence of God.” The old lady smiled and responded, “He wouldn’t need 70 proofs if he didn’t have 70 doubts.”</blockquote><p>I think about this story often, in two directions at once.</p><h3>A question with seventy answers</h3><p>In science, one question can have seventy answers , because doubt is not a weakness but the engine of progress. Science progresses because it permits revision. Evidence is not a trophy; it is a constraint. The scientific mindset is: “I might be wrong; show me.” In the business I am in, questioning is the core. It is the power that drives it , falsifiability. Everything needs evidence; types of evidence change with time and updates in the state of our knowledge. You either don’t know where to go and just follow where the evidence takes you, or you use what you previously know to form an idea, a speculation, on where to go, then check what the evidence displays against that speculation. Both approaches exist in the realm of science, necessary for progression, regulated and corrected by the scientific methodology itself. One question could have seventy answers, answers changing with time, state of knowledge, progress, measures, technology, and tools.</p><h3>An answer to seventy questions</h3><p>In faith, the starting commitment is different. It is “here is the reality, I will orient my life toward this ultimate reality.” The questions do not disappear; they change direction, they dive deeper, into intention, ego, sincerity, fear, love, reliance, humility. Certainty (<em>yaqeen</em>), in many Islamic traditions, is depicted as the fruit of a path, not a cheap starting point. Fakhr Al-din Al-razi had a hypothesis, one that he strongly believed in, he was certain about it. But yet he spent his life collecting 70 (in other sources 1000) proofs that support it. An intelligent mind, and a faithful one, that left behind knowledge about logic, reasoning, hypothesis testing, philosophizing, and debating. All of these endeavors were human mental inventories that served to arrive at something non-human, non-mental, non-materialistic. Something that existed before existence, and will remain after. For the faithful, the construct is well defined from the start; you develop its measures later. Those measures get clearer as you walk the way. Seventy questions, one answer.</p><h3>The streetlight story</h3><p><em>In the Islamic Sufism literature, a common story goes: A policeman sees a drunk man searching for something under a streetlight. “What did you lose?” the policeman asks. “I lost my keys”, says the man, and they both look under the streetlight together. After a few minutes, the policeman asks if he is sure he lost them here, and the man replies, ”No, I lost them in the park”. The policeman asks why he is searching here, and the drunk replies, “Light is much better here.” The story can be used to imply that rational, intellectual approaches to religion (which can seem light and clear) are insufficient for finding deep spiritual truths. Or that we often search for God, peace, or spiritual enlightenment in established, easy rituals or external actions (under the streetlight), because it is comfortable. However, spiritual truth often requires looking in the “darkness” of the self, dealing with difficult emotions, and performing inner work.</em></p><p>You probably heard this story under the name “the streetlight effect” in a scientific methodology class about bias. Does science borrow from religious literature ⁉ I think it might. I call it bias when I am a scientist, and I call it a ceiling, a cover (hijab: not only the veil, but what veils the heart/mind from seeing clearly) when I am a believer. I am often both simultaneously.</p><p>The drunk man searches where the light is good, not where the keys were lost. I think of al-Razi under his own streetlight; seventy proofs, seventy doubts; and then I think of the old lady, who did not need a single proof as she didn’t have a single doubt. For her, the light was not out there. It was in the eyes of the searcher. What is lost in the dark is not to be found in the light. You might find a key, in fact, many keys, but not the one you lost.</p><blockquote>Science warns us: we search where measurement is easiest. Spirituality warns us: we seek God where the ego is comfortable. And sometimes, the light is not out there at all, it is in the seeker.</blockquote><h3>The unseen</h3><p>I said earlier that faith trains my relationship to the unseen. But I have learned that science, properly understood, does too.</p><p>I realized that sometimes our “premature” understanding of science can lead to completely disregarding the “unseen”. There is no “unseen”, or if there is, it isn’t worth thinking about. However, this prejudiced, “opposite of humble?” behaviour is exactly what delayed acceptance of a round earth, what put Galileo under house arrest, what made Einstein’s ideas seem absurd before they could be tested. Ibn al-Haytham, the writer of the revolutionary <em>Book of Optics</em> and famous for the dark room experiment, and Ibn Sina were forced into isolation. A gravity wave was unseen. Curved space was unseen. Creating an optical image of a scene was unseen, until Ibn al-Haytham’s dark room, and centuries of wrong conclusions, made it visible.</p><p>Everything is unseen before we can measure it. The lack of tools and measurements has always led to premature conclusions and incorrect theories, and has sometimes led science itself astray. The problem of measurements is the problem of the unseen. This is why we should be humble and recognize our limitations. This problem of psychometrics could never have been clear to us as it is today, if not for this long history and accumulation of wrong conclusions and inaccuracies. The practice of making mistakes is in itself our door to whatever we cannot see now , that which is in the dark corridor, not under the streetlight. Which leads me to my next section: Practice and knowledge, between science and religion.</p><h3>Practice before knowledge</h3><blockquote><em>Knowledge (ilm) “spiritual” isn’t just intellectual facts but a transformative, experiential journey toward direct divine knowing (Ma’rifa), essential for spiritual purification and closeness to Allah</em></blockquote><p><strong>وَاتَّقُوا اللَّهَ وَيُعَلِّمُكُمُ اللَّهُ</strong><br><em>“Be mindful of Allah, and Allah will teach you.”</em> (Surah Al-Baqarah, 2:282)</p><p>I grew up thinking religion was a transaction: you witness, you obey, you get rewarded, in this life or the next. Knowledge had no place in that picture. It took me years to see that practice is not a transaction. It is a method of becoming capable of knowledge , the same way training in a lab changes not just what you know, but what you are able to perceive.</p><p>Sufism is a purely epistemic Islamic tradition in which knowledge plays a central role. Knowledge does not necessarily equal faith, although they are closely intertwined in the Sufi tradition. There is belief, having faith in a creator, which serves as an essential and central idea through which you understand life, and then there is knowledge: actual knowing of this creator rather than a mere strong idea of Him. The former does not necessarily lead to the latter, but it is essential for it.</p><p>When I was a kid, which applies to many people, I thought religion was all about the first point: you start by acknowledging the witnessing of your creator, no questioning, it should just come naturally to you. Then you practice and follow the rules, to be rewarded, in life and death. To get support, help, paradise, whatever you want as a reward for your obedience. That is it. Knowledge had no place here.</p><p>Now, this is interesting, to me at least: when you are a young child, or when you first accept Islam and faith, no aspect of this faith is valid without affirming the existence and oneness of God as the very first step. In fact, not just affirming, but “witnessing.” The word used is literally “I bear witness to God.” But how do I bear witness to something I have never seen before?</p><p>Then i understood one thing: Knowledge of Allah, the Lord, is the ultimate goal of every practice you engage in. It is where the religion starts and ends. Oddly, you start with something, and then end with it.</p><p>Then there is the other way around: you learn the rules, guidance, books; you read, you ask, and you practice, and then you get rewarded with the knowledge itself, the learning. You don’t start with the knowledge; you end with it. But to get there, you need a place to start from. The knowledge you start with is merely the signs that pave the way, the streetlights, a map, that might be enough to get you there, but it is not the end knowledge that you will be awarded with.</p><p>In the Quran, there is much mention of following and then being taught. Granting you wisdom and knowledge comes as a reward, as an outcome.</p><h3>Knowing Allah or arguing for Allah?</h3><p>I learned that the goal has never been the commonly known rewards. Whatever you do, follow, pray, remembrance, doing good deeds, connecting with your family, caring for people, fasting, going to school, every single deed you do is to actually getting close to “knowing” the Creator. You might find some rewards here and there while walking towards that goal. But the ultimate goal has always been that knowledge.</p><p>In Sudan, the religious figures and scholars we revere most are often called <em>Faqeer= </em>the poor, poor before God, or <em>Aarif</em> =the knower, one who has come to know rather than merely believe. Those who have achieved the highest level of <em>yaqeen</em> and <em>taqwa</em> have two characteristics: being poor to their Creator, and possessing the knowledge of Him.</p><p>Knowledge has always been the center, the pillar of faith and religion. Knowledge itself has many layers; the very last one is the knowledge of God. But you can only arrive there by achieving the prerequisites of knowledge, central to which is the knowledge of self. You can never know the Creator if you don’t know the self. The self is the key to opening these doors to <em>ma’rifa, </em>knowledge of God or “Maarif=knowedges in plural”. Purification of the soul, and all of this, is to pave the way to knowing. As if you are a psychometrician who is working hard to define the construct and contrast it with other constructs, making sure what you are measuring is, in fact, the desired construct, not adjacent ones.</p><blockquote><strong>(إِنَّمَا يَخْشَى اللَّهَ مِنْ عِبَادِهِ الْعُلَمَاءُ)</strong><br><em>“It is truly those who are gifted with knowledge who are conscious of Allah the most, for Allah is Great and Forgiving.”</em> (Surah Fatir, 35:28)</blockquote><p>Now, I use the word knowledge when I am talking about both scientific knowledge and spiritual knowledge. The first is public, shareable, testable, and built to be checked by others; it changes the others, and their relationship to the seen reality. While the spiritual knowledge (ma‘rifa) is lived, transformative, inwardly verified, and built to change the knower. These are not the same kind of knowing, but they share virtues of knowing (discipline, humility, honesty, consistency, attention).</p><h3>The importance of stupidity in science</h3><p>I want to understand all there is I can, limited by resources and mental capacity, to the maximum of it. Then, I want to know what is beyond that, through faith. I do both to know; I am using different means to the same end. The difference, however, is that in science, we only arrive at conclusions and apply the results after finishing the work. In faith, we start backwards: you apply and practice first, and you get to know last. Puzzling, mind-blowing, and interesting.</p><p>For a construct well defined, all measures converge and integrate, if they are the correct measures. Seventy questions, one answer. For a construct ill-defined, no measure is correct, to begin with. Here, you have seventy answers to one question. This is exactly what we do in science as well, especially in the social sciences, where, as one biologist put it, “stupidity is crucial.” You get in the mud and then learn how to swim. You develop the measures and revise them along the way. As measures change, theories change, constructs get redefined, terms’ meaning is revisited, measures are re-evaluated, redefined, and this is how our sciences seem to be working. A theory about a construct is correct, as long as it survives this process of revising, redefining, and measuring.</p><p>In science, I start with uncertainty in the conclusion and earn certianty, slowly, through disciplined methods and ways that i already know. In faith, you operate under “certainty in the conclusion” and then you discover the way, slowly, through disciplined practice. Both require me to admit what I don’t know. Both punish self-deception. And both, at their best, make me more honest: with data, and with myself.</p><p>The difference is where certainty lives. In science, I am uncertain about the answer but confident in the method. In faith, I am oriented toward the answer, but the path still demands the same ruthless honesty. Am I seeking God, or seeking comfort? Am I measuring the right construct, or an adjacent one that flatters my ego? In that sense, faith has its own falsifiability, turned inward.</p><p>Again, It is strange and amazing as the same time that in one domain, you only get to know better through your uncertainty, and in another, you know better under certainty. In science, you don’t have the correct answer, but you know the way to get there; the methodology. The idea of hypothesis, pre-registration, theory-driven testing, is somehow our way to pretend as if we have some answers, to constrain our way and limit our options, so it is easy to falsify. Although there could be infinite ways to do it, that is all we have ; the empirical way; so we need to limit it as much as possible.</p><p>In faith, the orientation is given; you know what you are seeking, even when you cannot yet see it. The paths are many, and you do not need to constrain them the way science constrains hypotheses, because the destination is not a proposition to be falsified. It is a presence to be approached. All roads lead to it, but only if you walk them honestly.</p><blockquote>Science taught me <em>how</em> to doubt well; faith taught me <em>how</em> to live well with what I cannot fully prove.</blockquote><h3>What each gave the other</h3><p>I used to think these two parts of my life were separate compartments, science over here, faith over there. They are not. Here is what each has given the other.</p><p>Science gave my faith intellectual humility: the daily reminder that I can be wrong. It gave me tools against self-deception: bias, confounds, motivated reasoning, that I now apply when I catch myself performing sincerity rather than living it. And it gave me patience with not-knowing, which turns out to be a spiritual virtue too.</p><p>Faith gave my science something harder to name but no less real: meaning, and a reason why truth matters even when no one is watching. It gave me discipline, the habit of showing up, doing the work, refining the intention. And it gave me reverence toward reality: the world is not only objects to measure, but signs (<em>ayat</em>) to read.</p><h3>The sacred work of mentorship</h3><p>I have been writing about constructs and measures, about practice and knowledge, about the unseen. But none of this happens alone. In both science and faith, what transforms you is rarely a paper, a proof, or even a verse. It is a person, someone who walks beside you long enough to see whether you are measuring the right thing, or fooling yourself.</p><p>In science, a mentor teaches you how to ask, how to fail, how not to fake certainty, and how to respect the method even when the method humiliates you. My PhD advisor for example, have always pointed me away from my streetlight. When i hurrying up my gaze towards the beta coefficients and the p-values that confirm my “idea”, he always looks at the boring numbers “why does it say 1000 data points while we know we have only 400?” and then it is a data wrangling mistake that i made while rushing things to get to the conclusions. “The data don’t care about my story.” This is not cruel. It is the most honest thing that i can tell myself. It doesn’t teach me to abandon faith in the process; but to abandon faith in my own preferences. That is a spiritual lesson wearing a lab coat “figuratively”.</p><p>In faith, a teacher, a sheikh, a guide, sometimes just an old lady in the street, helps you diagnose the self, refine intention, and avoid spiritual shortcuts. I think of someone I knew in Khartoum. I was much younger than I am now, but more confident in my own ignorance. He pushed the limits of my mind by merely asking me questions about my religios beliefs, and afterwards, I couldn’t help but define myself as an agnostic, to say the least. Another mentor I met years later, also in Khartoum, asked me questions about religion too. Every answer I gave was wrong. Afterwards, I ended up a very strong believer and Muslim because of him. Like the old lady with al-Razi, he did not need seventy answers. He needed me to stop searching under the streetlight.</p><p>I want to end with an honest caveat. Everything I have written about complementarity assumes both are practiced as seeking. But both can be used incorrectly, and I have seen both fail in parallel. Bias is only the beginning. There is also dogma: the closed question. Gatekeeping: who is allowed to ask. Authority without accountability. Resistance to change dressed up as rigor in science, or as piety in faith. Generational inheritance without generational examination. New insight is resisted not because the evidence is weak, but because the ego is invested. I have seen it and felt the pull of it myself, rushing toward the p-values that confirm my idea while ignoring the boring numbers and facts checking. In science, the ego hides behind methodology. In faith, it hides behind sincerity. In both, the tell is the same: discomfort with being wrong, allergic to the question why, allergic to the mentor who points you away from your streetlight. a refusal to be checked, by data, by conscience, by a mentor, by God, by the parts of yourself you would rather not examine.</p><p>I do not think this means science and faith are equally false, or equally true. I think it means both are human, and both require the same virtues to stay honest.</p><blockquote>I was born in a believing environment, and I became a scientist in a skeptical one. For a long time I thought I had to choose , or hide one from the other. I don’t anymore. When I am in the lab, I call it bias. When I am in prayer, I call it <em>hijab</em>. I am often both simultaneously. And I think that is not a contradiction. It is the only honest way I know to seek. <em>And perhaps the only way to keep either from becoming an excuse to stop seeking.</em></blockquote><p>links and further readings</p><ul><li><a href="https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/al-razi/">Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy: Fakhr al-Din al-Razi</a></li><li><a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fakhr_al-Din_al-Razi">https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fakhr_al-Din_al-Razi</a></li><li>Schwartz, M. A. (2008). <a href="https://journals.biologists.com/jcs/article/121/11/1771/30459/The-importance-of-stupidity-in-scientific-research">The importance of stupidity in scientific research</a>. <em>Journal of Cell Science</em>.</li><li>Al-Ghazālī. <em>Deliverance from Error</em> (<em>Al-Munqidh min al-Dalal</em>).</li><li>Shah, I. (1964). <em>The Sufis</em> (Nasrudin stories).</li><li>Mulla Nasrudin stories: <a href="https://en.wikibooks.org/wiki/Sufism/Nasrudin">Sufism/Nasrudin Wikibooks</a></li><li><a href="https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/alhazen/">Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy: Ibn al-Haytham</a></li><li>Qur’an 35:28 (Fatir), Qur’an 2:282 (Surah Al-Baqarah)</li></ul><p><a href="https://en.wikibooks.org/wiki/Sufism/Nasrudin">Sufism/Nasrudin - Wikibooks, open books for an open world</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=7b87cf933562" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Allah/God: Why is he a “he”?]]></title>
            <link>https://samahrahim.medium.com/allah-god-why-is-he-a-he-7f37d7f6d021?source=rss-9176c890179e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/7f37d7f6d021</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[gender]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[religion]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[arabic]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Samah Abdelrahim]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 08 Apr 2026 19:04:30 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-04-10T14:15:18.796Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>“All praise to him,” I was talking to a friend who was confused about what to feel about non-muslims using the word “Allah” to refer to God. I was personally surprised by why they would feel confused. If you really believe in “the idea” of god, then God is god to anyone, not exclusively those who explicitly believe in him in a specific way. Literally any creature, anywhere in the universe, has the right to call him using whatever word they want, whenever they want. This also taught me that some people don’t experience “Allah” as just a translation of “God”, but as a word loaded with history, identity, and sometimes even politics.</p><p>God is not a person who belongs to a specific racial group; he is not an object possessed by a specific group, and definitely not an “idea” to those who believe. I used the word “idea” above, but to the believers, he is not an idea; he is just god, beyond ideas, time, or space. Yes, this makes it unfalsifiable, and i know that language can’t fully capture this anyway, which is kind of the whole point of what I’m about to say. But then, why do I keep calling him a “he”? I counted the number of times I used “he” and “him” in this passage alone until this point, and it is 10 times. Does this mean “he” at the end belongs to a group, that is, the group of “males”?</p><p>Then I started thinking hard about this, in my native language, “Arabic”, we also refer to Allah as “he=هو”. In the Quran, it is all “هو”. The Arabic language is heavily gendered in its syntax and morphology. All nouns, pronouns, adjectives, and verbs are marked for gender, masculine or feminine, requiring strict agreement across a sentence. But then I realized something, we also call the door a “he”, does it really elicit a feeling of “masculinity” in our minds?</p><blockquote>Now, let me ask you something, for native English speakers: when you think about the moon and the sun, which one makes you think of “feminine” and which is more “masculine”? Take a moment to think about this before you proceed.</blockquote><p>In a lot of popular symbolism and mythological traditions (at least the ones I keep running into), the moon is widely considered more feminine, largely due to its association with intuition, emotions, and the 28-day menstrual cycle, mirroring its own phases. In some cultures, the moon represents the “divine feminine” (reflective, calming, receptive), while the sun is seen as the “masculine” principle (active, projective, intense).</p><p>Now, for those who aren’t familiar, let me tell you something. In Arabic, the moon is linguistically “masculine”. When we speak about the moon, we “strictly” use a masculine linguistic marking; otherwise, your language is not correct, it will be a different language. On the other side, the sun is feminine. A chair is linguistically masculine, while the table is feminine. Here, it is very important to note the word “linguistically”, because it seems like there is no clear mapping between how the Arabic language marks something as “F/M” and whether we perceive it as such. In fact, sometimes it might conflict with common notions, like the example of the moon and the sun.</p><p>When I was just reflecting on this, I realized that it might be completely arbitrary. But if it is arbitrary, then using “he” linguistically doesn’t automatically mean “male” conceptually, and using the Arabic linguistic equivalence of a “she” would also be arbitrary. If any strong association between the concept of “feminine” as a distinct biological and/or cultural construct and the feminine linguistic markings exists, then maybe it emerged later (or at least, it can be learned later by speakers, culturally, even if the grammar itself is older than our current associations). Which in turn means that we might be retrospectively using an association between the language and the “F/M” distinctive concepts to explain how the language works, even when that association is not actually doing the grammatical work.</p><p>Then, to go back to “Allah”, if my premise is correct, that is, the language use of F/M markings does not cleanly map to our conception of these constructs, and doesn’t give us enough information to make a judgment about it, then we could never assign a conceptual “M/F” distinction to “Allah” for the mere use of M linguistic markings when referring to “him”. Now that is all building on how Arabic works, not sure if the same reasoning can be used in other languages like “English”, especially since it doesn’t mark non-human/inanimate/intangible beings using the same language as humans. For example, there is an “it” to refer to non-humans/abstract/inanimate beings. And also, in English, “He” can feel less like pure grammar and more like an image of maleness, which might be why the question feels sharper in English than it does in Arabic.</p><p>Someone can, of course, ask why this God-masculine language happens to be very common across different languages and cultures. This assumes a few claims that I am not sure how warranted they are. First, is it indeed that common? Were these cultures and languages indeed isolated from each other that they could never influence each other? Maybe the timing and history of these languages/cultures that share this property could help. I don’t possess the knowledge to speak about any of this, but it is something that I will try to educate myself on. Especially that, for some people, this isn’t only a linguistic question, nor a purely conceptual one, but it’s a question about power, patriarchy, and who gets to represent the divine, which is a real conversation too. These are random thoughts I had this morning, and I felt like writing them. Maybe someone who has more knowledge on this would read it and help me learn more, or even correct any misconceptions I have now.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=7f37d7f6d021" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The scientist and the human]]></title>
            <link>https://samahrahim.medium.com/the-scientist-and-the-human-3f83dfeea0f1?source=rss-9176c890179e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/3f83dfeea0f1</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[neutrality]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[social-context]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[phd-life]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[science-communication]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[unscientific]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Samah Abdelrahim]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 24 Feb 2025 19:32:55 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-02-26T01:43:32.388Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>How science, emotion, and social Context shape one another</em></p><p>This quarter, Winter 2025, I am a student in the Affective Core graduate course led by Prof. Ian Gotlib. I’ve had conflicting feelings about this class. On one hand, I’ve learned an incredible amount and now know far more than I did before. On the other hand, those feelings dim a little when I remember that I have to complete two readings and write two reaction papers every week, on top of everything else that comes with being a PhD student in Stanford’s psychology department. My colleagues will understand the weight of these responsibilities, but this isn’t a space for complaints. 😛</p><p>So why am I bringing all of this up? Because despite my complaints, I’ve genuinely appreciated all the speakers and assigned readings in this course. Before this class, I didn’t even know what <em>affect</em> meant or what an <em>emotion</em> truly was. I had never considered that an entire body of rich literature and theoretical debate existed just to better understand emotions.</p><p>One reading, in particular, has stayed with me: Laura Carstensen’s paper, <em>Socioemotional Selectivity Theory: The Role of Perceived Endings in Human Motivation</em> (Carstensen, 2021).</p><p>In my reaction to this paper, i first wrote:</p><blockquote>“That was such an interesting read, thank you for assigning it. I really appreciated the connection made in the introduction between life and science. The way time shifts our life priorities, as well as our scientific endeavors, is such a clever and valuable perspective, one that is useful to recognize as early as possible. What I also appreciated was the historical background of your ideas and how they evolved into Socioemotional Selectivity Theory. Too often, we don’t see researchers discussing the context that motivated them to develop a research project or scientific theory. There seems to be an implicit assumption that context doesn’t matter, that only results and methodology do. However, as you highlighted in the introduction, scientists, as human beings, enter the research world with a whole set of assumptions, motivations, and perspectives shaped by their experiences. So, I appreciate your willingness to make it less uncommon to discuss the context in which a scientific theory, especially one about human nature, takes shape.”</blockquote><p><strong>How neutral is science? And how neutral is the word neutral?</strong></p><p>In the midst of discussions about scientific findings, hypothesis rebuttals, replication failures, and the inherently cyclical nature of scientific progress, confirming, disconfirming, and revising, we often see/hear/read heated debates. Scientists interpret the same data in different ways, sometimes even using identical findings to support opposing theories. Intellectual conflicts flare up. We hear comments like: <em>“This paper was rejected because it contradicts the reviewer’s previous work” and </em>whispers of bias intertwined into the peer review process. These everyday conversations with colleagues and collaborators reveal a simple truth: behind the suits, the jargon-laden papers, and the lab coats, science is deeply human. Part of our training as researchers involves learning <em>how</em> to disagree; how to respectfully say, <em>“I think this is just wrong” </em>and, more importantly, how to navigate the delicate balance between critiquing a hypothesis and maintaining professional relationships. Conducting research often means exposing gaps, missing links, and insufficient evidence in existing theories, yet we must also remain good colleagues to those working in the same domain.</p><p>These challenges, learning to manage conflict, handle rejection, and engage in discourse, are as much a part of the scientific process as collecting data, running statistical tests, or writing papers. What many of us don’t realize coming into this work is that science isn’t some divine force that purifies the soul under the assumption of neutrality. It doesn’t elevate us above human biases. Science, however, can push personal boundaries, it can be as clarifying or as cloudy as you allow it to be. This is where Laura Carstensen’s Socioemotional Selectivity Theory (SST) comes in. According to SST, as scientists grow older, they may become more willing to accept when their work is refuted, revised, or fails to replicate. They begin to value the process over the pursuit of <em>being right</em>. With time, they see the deeper assumptions and motivations at play, both in their own work and in the field more broadly. This shift makes them more accepting, less defensive, and, ultimately, less “<em>grumpy”</em>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*TANktbb-MsKnYxeH2GDxOA.jpeg" /></figure><p>In this way, doing science is just a more structured way of doing “<em>life”</em>.</p><p>And so, I find myself asking: <strong>How neutral is the word “neutral”? And neutral to what?</strong></p><p><strong>Friendships and collaborations</strong></p><p>In the second part of my reaction to Laura’s paper, I wrote:</p><blockquote>Continuing my very unscientific reaction to your paper, I’m sure most of my classmates had many smart questions about the science and substance of the theory. But since you dedicated time and effort to reflecting not just on the theory itself but also on life, your scientific career, and lessons learned from your father, I wanted to meet that with a similar effort. I wanted to learn from that reflection as well. After all, I’m sure I’ll have other opportunities to discuss the scientific details of your work with you.</blockquote><blockquote>“ In appreciation of Laura’s style of communicating science “</blockquote><p>On page 4, Laura writes, “Of course, I benefitted tremendously from hallway conversations with my Stanford colleagues, who offered critical commentary in the way that only good friends do.”</p><p>The boundary between <em>colleague</em> and <em>friend</em> is not always easy to navigate in professional settings. Given all the challenges mentioned earlier, along with others that readers may know even better than I do, this often feels like a road to avoid rather than one to cross. This is why so many of us seek friendships <em>outside</em> of our academic or professional circles, where we share nothing in common, it feels safer, healthier. But I wonder: has Laura, and perhaps others, found a way to navigate these blurred lines, something we have yet to learn? Or maybe I’m reading more into this than I should, placing a heavier burden on it than it was ever meant to carry? Is this one of those untransferable lessons that only comes with time? Just another thing we selectively learn to prioritize as we grow older, in line with Socioemotional Selectivity Theory?</p><p>In all our conversations about well-being, support systems, and the mental health challenges of PhD life, about maximizing productivity, mindfulness, and meditation, perhaps we should also talk more about the values we bring into our workplaces. About how we do science. And, most importantly, about how we communicate and write about it.</p><p>I find the lessons embedded in how Laura chose to write this paper deeply meaningful, worth pondering, worth discussing. And I thought they were worth sharing, in the hope that others might find meaning in them too.</p><h4>The social context</h4><p>Finally, as Laura writes in her paper: <em>“But it would be misleading to ignore the social influences on my thinking.”</em> Similarly, I find it misleading to ignore the social influences on my own interest in her style of communicating science and writing about it, especially when I compare it to the academic writing I more often encounter from other scientists. I strongly believe this preference is shaped by my upbringing in Sudan, a society where social boundaries in relationships are fluid, if not nonexistent. In Sudan, your friends are often your coworkers, possibly your neighbors, and even family members. It’s not uncommon for your grandparents to have once worked alongside the relatives of your colleagues. This deeply interconnected societal model comes with both strengths and flaws, and many Sudanese people believe it needs to change. In fact, it is changing. As the old family- and tribe-based structure shifts away from an economy built on self-sufficiency and social support, Sudanese society is transforming into a more capitalist model, one where individuals seek not just stability but economic growth, crossing community borders into a broader market of opportunities, productivity, and wealth accumulation. There will always be debates about what societies should prioritize, whether it should be peace of mind, social cohesion, and strong relationships, or productivity, economic expansion, and success in competitive fields like science. But no matter where one stands in this debate, there are valuable lessons to be learned from both ends of the spectrum.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=3f83dfeea0f1" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A flesh in Palo Alto, a soul in Khartoum]]></title>
            <link>https://samahrahim.medium.com/a-flesh-in-palo-alto-a-soul-in-khartoum-c643c95aee32?source=rss-9176c890179e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c643c95aee32</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[sudan]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[nile-river]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[khartoum]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[history]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[memories]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Samah Abdelrahim]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 09 Feb 2024 07:48:29 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-05-24T22:06:12.501Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>A Flesh in Palo Alto, a Soul in Khartoum</h3><h3>Khartoum: the story of harmonious convergence</h3><p>Khartoum, the city where the renowned River Nile takes its initial form, tells a tale of two rivers. The Blue Nile, originating from Lake Tana to the East of Sudan, converges with the White Nile, which begins its journey from Lake Victoria to the south of Sudan. Conventionally, when two rivers meet, one tends to dominate the other. However, Khartoum tells a unique story as the Blue Nile and the White Nile meet at their confluence on equal footing, both in stature and nomenclature.</p><p>In this meeting of waters, the Blue Nile and the White Nile maintain their individual significance, yet in harmony. At this point, their names undergo a transformation, and for thousands of kilometers to come, as they pass north through Egypt, they merge into the singular entity known as the Nile, or in Arabic, “Bahr El-nil = the Nile Sea” or “Nahr El-nil”. In Sudan and Egypt, the term (El-nil) refers to this river that traverses both of them, being a crucial source of life, and a long-standing symbol of history.</p><p>Khartoum, situated at this geographical point, becomes a symbolic representation of unity and parity. While the Blue Nile is known to the Sudanese for its turbulence, the White Nile is characterized by its calm and steady flow. Having these contrasting temperaments, they go on a shared journey as partners in creating the Ancient Nile toward the Mediterranean. The joining of the Blue Nile and the White Nile in Khartoum stands not only as a geographical phenomenon but also as a testament to the coexistence of diverse forces, creating a singular force that will continue to shape the land and narrative of the Nile for ages to come.</p><h3><strong>Suaad: Beyond Grandmother, a Collage of Memories</strong></h3><p>Suaad, a name echoing across many regions of Sudan, takes on a distinctive significance in the narrative I tell here. She is not just any Suaad; she is my grandmother, the matriarch with whom my brother and I shared our formative years.</p><p>In her yard, furnished with metallic beds similar to those found in numerous Sudanese households, Suaad cultivated a space of familial warmth. Every afternoon, she came out from her room, a room steeped in time, and into the yard, awaiting our company as we came back from school or work. The room itself, a collection of memories, has a roof and walls crafted from the same wood that goes back to the days of her father, an era predating the departure of British colonizers from what would later be recognized as Sudan.</p><p>This room, where I spent my childhood and beyond, holds a table that has witnessed over seven decades of shared meals, a testament to the strong ties that bind generations. Suaad’s legacy transcends familial roles; she embodies a living archive of personal history, rooted in a time before geopolitical shifts and colonial legacies left their mark on the land.</p><p>Born and raised in a small island in the heart of Khartoum, Suaad’s roots intertwine with the exact location where the Blue and White Niles converge to give birth to the River Nile. This island, Tuti, is embraced by the joining of the rivers, bordered by the “Three Towns”: Khartoum, Omdurman, and Khartoum Bahri (my hometown). Despite its proximity to urban hubs, Tuti stands as an exemplification of simplicity and traditional life, with its grasslands and traditional houses defining the island’s landscape.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/277/0*ddWSYRclH3pCzwAM" /><figcaption>Tuti Island</figcaption></figure><p>Notably, Tuti has earned recognition as one of eight communities worldwide honored as Champions of Disaster Risk Reduction by the UN Office for Disaster Risk Reduction (UNDRR). The island faces the annual onslaught of floods unleashed by the surrounding Nile. Yet, Tuti’s resilience is shown through traditional flood warning systems and collective efforts to control the water flow, ensuring minimal loss of life during major flood events for hundreds of years. In the face of adversity, Suaad’s connection to Tuti brings a meaningful illustration of the island’s ability to navigate the challenges posed by its geographical context.</p><p>Suaad of Tuti, beyond being a grandmother, embodies a living link to a community marked by fortitude, community bonds, and an enduring connection to the ebb and flow of the Nile. The island, with its humble village, stands as a sign of resilience in the face of nature’s challenges, a story mirrored in Suaad’s life as she personifies the spirit of Tuti and Sudan.</p><h3><strong>The morning of April 15th</strong></h3><p>On April 15th, 2023, while I, the granddaughter of Suaad, studying in the Bay Area west of the US, on the beautiful campus of Stanford, my family awoke to the unsettling sounds of conflict through their city. In a world over ten hours ahead, I grappled with the ongoing crisis, spending hours scrolling through social media for updates.</p><p>As the Rapid Support Forces militia (RSF) clashed with the Sudanese army, what seemed like hours turned into days, then months. Panic set in as reports surfaced of RSF soldiers forcefully occupying civilian homes. My family, deeply rooted in our ancestral town of Bahri, resisted leaving their home, a tangible link to their identity.</p><p>Despite my attempts to focus on my studies, the haunting images of my family facing violence and forced eviction persisted. Panic attacks, declining health, and sleepless nights became my companions as the uncertainty about their fate became visible.</p><p>The tipping point arrived when RSF soldiers invaded our relatives’ and neighbors’ homes, forcing them out at gunpoint. The stark reality that staying was untenable dawned on my family; they had to abandon their home and country to survive. [ <a href="https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2023/5/7/sudan-residents-describe-looting-evictions-by-rsf">1</a>, <a href="https://www.teachingwhilemuslim.org/sudan-speaks/2024/1/10/when-this-war-ends-what-will-i-be-coming-home-to-by-saja">2</a>, <a href="https://www.voanews.com/a/sudanese-who-fled-war-return-to-find-homes-occupied-by-fighters/7091668.html">3</a>]</p><p>Now scattered across different locations, my family struggles to rebuild. Meanwhile, international entities issue carefully worded statements about human rights and democratic transitions in Sudan, conveniently overlooking the deliberate displacement and suffering inflicted upon my family by a well-supported militia. Reports detailing some regional military support to the RSF facilitated through neighboring countries further highlight the complexities of the situation. Despite this, there is a resounding silence in Khartoum, where people endure eight months without access to clean water, a story yet to be told by the media.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/305/1*Q4CltqjWniBEUTZ39eg1YA.jpeg" /><figcaption>In 2019, thousands of young people took to the streets, “many of them were women”, calling for freedom, justice, and peace. They had high hopes for their future, but all were shattered soon after the 2019 transition.</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/640/1*78NFP6JBGdAU32NyBxaOMQ.jpeg" /></figure><h3><strong>In the Wake of Darkness: Unraveling Humanitarian Crisis in Sudan</strong></h3><p>As the RSF militia extends its reign of terror beyond Khartoum, recently targeting Wad Medini, Sudan’s second-largest city with a population exceeding 6 million, the already dire situation intensifies. Displaced individuals from Khartoum sought refuge in Wad Medini, believing it to be a safe refuge devoid of military and government targets. Unfortunately, their hopes were shattered as the militia seized control, unleashing threats, looting homes, and confiscating money and vehicles. Forced to flee once more, those seeking safety face a grim reality; nowhere seems secure, as the militia’s reach expands relentlessly.</p><p>An emerging humanitarian crisis and food insecurity cast a dark shadow over Sudan, exacerbated by the RSF militia’s assault on El-Gezira state, known as the “breadbasket of Sudan.” This region, integral to the country’s sustenance for the past 70 years, now grapples with the destructive aftermath of attacks and displacement. The agricultural sector, already strained by labor shortages due to widespread displacement, faces further challenges with rising fuel costs. Shortcomings in Sudan’s harvest season threaten to escalate food prices, compounding the dilemma of a population already struggling to meet basic needs.</p><p>Public infrastructure, including the fragile health system, bears the brunt of the crisis. Medical facilities and hospitals suffer repeated attacks, looting, and occupation, leaving them deprived of staff, funding, and essential supplies. The consequences ripple through communities as healthcare accessibility deteriorates.</p><p>Education, a cornerstone of societal development, lies in a state of chaos as all schools, colleges, and universities remain closed nationwide. Children, the future of Sudan, find themselves without the means to pursue knowledge, trapped in a cycle of uncertainty.</p><p>In the face of this level of adversity, Sudan grapples not only with the immediate impact of violence but also with the long-term consequences that threaten to reshape the fabric of its society.</p><h3><strong>To Suaad: A guide amidst uncertainty</strong></h3><p>As we, the descendants of Suaad, find ourselves navigating through these challenging times, she emerges not merely as my grandmother but as a symbol of history and identity, transcending the boundaries of familial ties and becoming a guiding light. In the face of darkness, doubt, and the specter of enduring poverty and uprootedness, I am left to ponder: Is Suaad watching over us?</p><p>Is she, in her timeless realm, offering prayers for our well-being? Are tears shed for the trials we face, or is there a quiet anger at the perceived loss of our ancestral home? Does she perceive us as victims of circumstance, or does she, with a discerning gaze, question our roles in this destruction? These questions linger, suspended in that space between past and present, as we grapple with the complexities of the situation.</p><p>In these moments of reflection, I wonder if the narrative of our present, interwoven with the threads of the past she represents, prompts contemplation about our shared responsibilities and the impact of our collective choices on the legacy she left behind.</p><p>To Suaad, not only a grandmother but an continuous presence, your spirit resonates through these challenging times, urging us to navigate them with resilience, introspection, and a steady connection to our heritage.</p><p>Note: AI helped me translate some sections of this article as they were originally written in my native language (Arabic)</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c643c95aee32" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>