<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Sandeep Macwan on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Sandeep Macwan on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@sandeep.macwan19286?source=rss-f29cb6b72945------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sat, 21 Nov 2026 16:27:35 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@sandeep.macwan19286/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[She Spent Her Childhood Analysing Cartoon Colour Palettes. That Habit Built Her Design Career.]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@sandeep.macwan19286/she-spent-her-childhood-analysing-cartoon-colour-palettes-that-habit-built-her-design-career-7f9746c693dd?source=rss-f29cb6b72945------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/7f9746c693dd</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[design]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[digital-design]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ux]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[illustration]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[visual-communication]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Sandeep Macwan]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 24 Aug 2026 11:33:10 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-08-24T11:33:10.790Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>Parul Institute of Design, Parul University, Vadodara, Gujarat, India · ThroughBlack, Vadodara</em></p><p>Most people walk past a supermarket shelf and see products. Mudra Dave, growing up in Vadodara, saw packaging decisions. She saw colour palettes, hierarchy, and the quiet logic behind why one label caught her eye and the one next to it did not. She watched cartoons and noticed the character design, why a particular character used those specific proportions, that specific palette. She looked at building facades and saw typographic choices and spatial relationships. She did not have a name for what she was doing. She was just paying attention to things most people did not register.</p><p>That attention, sustained from childhood without any formal direction, was the beginning of a designer. It was also, four years later at Parul Institute of Design, the foundation of a career.</p><p>Mudra is now a graphic design and branding specialist with an internship at ThroughBlack, a Vadodara-based creative agency, where her work has been printed on diagnostic clinic walls, displayed on exhibition stands at national trade events, and applied to brand identities serving healthcare, manufacturing, tech, and corporate clients.</p><p>None of it was guaranteed by curiosity alone. What the curiosity gave her was a starting point. What Parul University gave her was the structure to develop it, and a faculty culture patient enough to let a self-described “walking bundle of anxiety” find her footing before demanding her best work.</p><h3>The Designer Who Almost Paralysed Herself</h3><p>Mudra is candid about her first year at the institute in a way that most student profiles are not.</p><p>She was anxious. She overthought every idea before presenting it, and by the time a jury approached she had often talked herself out of whatever she had built — convinced it was not good enough, not original enough, not ready. The presentation itself became the thing she dreaded rather than the work. She describes that version of herself as a walking bundle of anxiety and does not soften the description.</p><p>What shifted was not a single moment. It was the studio’s rhythm.</p><p>Design programmes at Parul Institute of Design run on a cycle of iteration: work produced, reviewed by faculty, revised, produced again, revised again, presented to a jury, critiqued, taken back into the studio, rebuilt. Repeat. The cycle is not designed to be comfortable. It is designed to make a student’s instincts more reliable by forcing them through enough passes that the judgment begins to develop from the inside rather than being borrowed from the outside.</p><p>By her final year, Mudra had internalised enough of that cycle that she could describe a different version of herself: confident, willing to take creative risks, genuinely interested in collaboration rather than threatened by it. She credits the faculty culture. Not any single teacher or any single piece of advice, the culture, the cumulative effect of an environment that took her seriously enough to push her repeatedly rather than letting her settle.</p><h3>What the Tabla Taught Her About Design</h3><p>There is a thread in Mudra’s story that most design profiles would leave out because it does not fit the expected narrative about portfolios and software fluency.</p><p>She plays the tabla.</p><p>Tabla practice is not casual. It is technically demanding, rhythmically precise, and built on years of patient repetition that builds something in the practitioner that cannot be accelerated by trying harder in a short stretch. The discipline you develop learning the tabla — the patience, the attention to balance, the willingness to repeat something slightly wrong until it is consistently right, is a real discipline. It transfers.</p><p><em>“Any composition, musical or visual, needs the same fundamentals. Music taught me patience, balance, and perseverance.”</em> — Mudra Dave</p><p>A visual composition rests on the same structural logic as a musical one. Rhythm, balance, proportion, space, the relationship between elements, the way everything holds together as a whole even when each part is considered individually. A student who has spent years developing the patience to build something layered and precise in music arrives at visual work with a sensibility that pure visual training alone does not always produce.</p><p>Her tabla practice was not a hobby she kept separate from her design life. It was training she brought into the studio without always realising she was doing it.</p><h3>A Portfolio Built Across the Full Range</h3><p>Mudra chose Parul Institute of Design partly because it did not require her to specialise immediately. The programme gave her room to move through branding, storytelling, graphic design, colour theory, packaging, photography, UX/UI foundations, visual merchandising, motion graphics, 3D modelling, advertising, and filmmaking across four years rather than narrowing her into one lane from the start.</p><p>She used that room. Four projects show how far she moved.</p><p><strong>Cristos</strong> was a branding and packaging project built from scratch for a consumer product. She studied the company in depth before touching any software, researched the target audience, built a visual identity from the ground up, designed the packaging, and shot photography of the final output — combining branding, graphic design, packaging, and photography as a single integrated experience rather than separate deliverables.</p><p><strong>PawPrints</strong> was a UX/UI project: a pet care management application built in a team, grounded in user research, wireframed instinctively, and designed around real daily problems that pet owners face. It was the project that showed her the difference between making something that looks good and making something that works for the person who has to use it.</p><p><strong>Nomi Cafe</strong> was brand identity work for a premium cafe brand drawn from boho culture — logo, packaging, social media content, brand tonality, and language, held together with enough consistency that the brand would read recognisably across every surface. The lesson she took from it was that visibility is a product of persistent consistency, not a product of one strong visual decision.</p><p>The <strong>3D camera modelling and animation project</strong> was the one she pushed herself hardest on. Form, lighting, materials, textures, movement, storytelling in three dimensions, it forced her to understand how motion elevates visual communication in ways that static design cannot reach, and it expanded what she considered possible within the field.</p><h3>When Two Traditions Became One Performance</h3><p>Not all of it happened inside the studio.</p><p>By the third semester, students at Parul Institute of Design receive a group project that is specifically not a typical design brief. The team Mudra worked with chose to build a cultural performance that fused Bhavai, Gujarat’s traditional theatre form, with Tholpavakoothu, the shadow-puppetry art of Kerala.</p><p>Two regional traditions, drawn from opposite ends of India, combined into a single performance by a group of students who had no precedent to follow because nobody had done it this particular way before. They built it themselves. They performed it. The audience responded.</p><p>Mudra learned something from that response that she has not stopped thinking about: design’s most significant power is not aesthetic, it is connective. A piece of work that bridges different cultural experiences does something that no single beautiful image can. She also displayed work at the Vadodara Film and Design Festival in two consecutive years, and found that standing beside her own work in public, answering questions, watching strangers engage with something she had made, built a different kind of confidence from anything the studio’s jury cycles produced.</p><h3>The Agency That Made It Real</h3><p>At the end of her degree, faculty member Rohit sir recommended ThroughBlack, a Vadodara creative agency, for her internship. She chose it deliberately, for the variety of its clients rather than any single industry. She had spent four years building range, and she wanted an environment that would use it.</p><p>From December 2025 to July 2026, she worked as a Design and Media Intern across healthcare, corporate, manufacturing, and tech clients. The variety was exactly what she had chosen it for, and the work was exactly as real as the agency world tends to be: actual deadlines, actual clients, actual production, actual constraints.</p><p>Two moments stood out.</p><p>The first was seeing the complete branding she had developed for the Advanced Bhopal Centre for Diagnostics, the logo, the brand elements, the marketing collateral, printed and installed in the physical spaces where patients and staff would actually see it. There is a specific feeling that comes from watching work move from a screen to a wall. It is not satisfaction exactly. It is realisation: this is what design does, and this is why it matters.</p><p>The second was the national exhibition. Her giant banners and corporate display graphics for Transformer and Rectifier (India) Ltd — one of the region’s most significant manufacturers, were installed and displayed at national-scale trade events. Her work was in a room with thousands of people who had no idea a recent graduate had made it. That anonymity was its own kind of confirmation.</p><p>She also contributed to an international India-South Africa (ISA) project due for release in late 2026.</p><p><em>“Designers’ work speaks louder in the real world than on a screen.”</em></p><p>She did not read that observation somewhere. She watched it happen with her own work.</p><h3>What Four Years Made of Her</h3><p>She came in anxious and unsure whether any of her ideas were worth presenting. She left having built brand identities that are in use, exhibition graphics that were displayed at national trade events, and a range of skills across branding, digital, packaging, motion, and 3D that she had deliberately accumulated rather than stumbled into.</p><p>She describes the four years in three words: transformative, inspiring, unforgettable.</p><p>The next step is higher studies, specifically to deepen the business side of design, because one thing the internship clarified is that the designers who build lasting careers are not only the ones who can produce strong visual work. They are the ones who understand the commercial context that visual work operates inside.</p><p>Her advice to students behind her is as specific as her own trajectory was.</p><p>Build the portfolio early, with fewer strong pieces rather than many mediocre ones. Treat rejection and critique as data, not as verdict. Develop confidence in the room, communication matters in client relationships as much as technical skill does. Stay genuinely curious about technologies that are changing the field, because the AI graphic-design tools she encountered at ThroughBlack were not threats to her craft; they were efficiencies she quickly learned to use alongside it.</p><p>And enjoy the four years. College is the rare environment where the risks are real enough to matter but not so catastrophic that a mistake ends anything. That combination, real stakes, survivable failure, is not available forever. Use it while it exists.</p><p>Versatility and a point of view are what set designers apart. Explore Visual Communication and design programmes at Parul Institute of Design.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=7f9746c693dd" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[She applied to six companies herself, and joined Livspace.]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@sandeep.macwan19286/she-applied-to-six-companies-herself-and-joined-livspace-666510ef88a8?source=rss-f29cb6b72945------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/666510ef88a8</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[modular-kitchen]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[design]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[interior-design]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[livspace]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[home]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Sandeep Macwan]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 24 Aug 2026 10:45:38 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-08-24T10:45:38.883Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Sahelpreet Kaur built her portfolio months early, researched the studios she admired, applied on her own, and negotiated her own joining terms. A case study in not waiting to be picked.</h4><p><em>Parul Institute of Design, Parul University, Vadodara.</em></p><p>Livspace selected Sahelpreet Kaur, and then she set the terms.</p><p>She told them, plainly, that she could only start after her final exams ended on 15 November. The company accepted it. Later, when they assigned her to Ahmedabad, she asked for Vadodara instead, and got that too.</p><p>None of this came from a campus placement. She found the job, applied for it, and negotiated it herself. That is the whole point of her story, and it is worth understanding how a design student ends up with that much say in the matter.</p><h3>From a commerce plan to a site visit</h3><p>Sahelpreet is from Bhawani Mandi, a small town near Kota in Rajasthan, and she grew up in a business family. Her father runs an electronics and furniture export business. The expectation was that she would join it.</p><p>So she took commerce in Class 11, pointed at exactly that future. Design arrived almost by accident, on a single site visit with a friend, where the actual work of shaping a space caught her attention and did not let go. She followed it up with a one-year foundational design course in Kota, learning the basics end to end.</p><p>Then came the hard part, which was choosing a college in the middle of COVID.</p><p>She applied widely and got into several design colleges. The problem was money, some were asking up to ten lakh rupees a year. Around then, Parul University had just finished a new building for its design institute, and friends from her hometown already studying there told her to look. She cleared the entrance exam, toured the campus with her family, the new design block, the hostels, and came away convinced. Reassured, too, by seniors from Kota who were already there. She enrolled at the Parul Institute of Design as a considered, value-conscious call, not a default one.</p><h3>What four years actually covered</h3><p>Her specialisation was interior and furniture design, built to move from broad ideas to hard technical skill across four years.</p><p>First year was a common foundation across fashion, visual arts and product design, a base before anyone specialised. Second year turned to the core of interiors: drafting, detailed floor plans, structural layouts, and ergonomics, designing furniture to match how a human body actually sits and moves. Third year went heavy on software and workshop. She learned AutoCAD, the industry standard, and built furniture miniatures at 1:16 scale.</p><p>Final year pulled it together at full 1:1 scale. In her last semester she picked up Rhino and used it to design a seating unit combined with a bicycle stand, a piece that came out well, got exhibited publicly, and drew real appreciation. Around all of it she built the working toolkit of the job: space planning, 3D modelling, electrical layout drafting, false-ceiling design.</p><h3>The people who kept her in it</h3><p>She arrived lost, like most first-years, and the teaching staff are the reason she settled.</p><p>Two permanent faculty carried her, Rutu Bhatt, her class mentor, and Hanna Ma’am. Rutu Bhatt was accessible enough that Sahelpreet could just call her to talk through a design problem over the phone, a line she kept open even after graduating. And a visiting faculty member, Mr Aman Raj, ran workshops that showed her what the professional world was actually like. That was the turning point. It is when she got serious about planning her career and, specifically, her portfolio.</p><p>Which set up everything that followed.</p><h3>The job search she ran herself</h3><p>As her final semester came into view, Sahelpreet refused to sit and wait for a placement.</p><p>Months ahead, she assembled her portfolio, built a proper LinkedIn profile, and rewrote her resume until it was right. She went looking on Instagram for studios and companies she admired, followed them on LinkedIn, and messaged people who worked there to ask what the culture was really like. She checked with her teachers on which studios were worth her time. Then she applied to six places on her own.</p><p>Livspace stood out because it was large and openly took freshers without rigid entry barriers. She applied, and was selected around September or October. Then came the part most freshers never attempt: she negotiated. She told them she could not join until her exams finished on 15 November, and they agreed.</p><p>The lesson underneath is not “apply to lots of places.” It is that a fresher with a ready portfolio and a clear head has more standing than she thinks. Enough to set her own start date and choose her own city.</p><h3>Inside Livspace, and the 3.0 model</h3><p>At Livspace, new hires go straight into live roles, not soft internships.</p><p>It opened with a strict seven-day training week on the company’s own software, its materials, and the whole concept of modular kitchens and furniture, which she had to research hard beforehand just to understand what “modular” meant next to a normal studio setup. Then three months of probation on live projects.</p><p>Here is where the earlier negotiation paid off again. Livspace first assigned her to Ahmedabad, and Rutu Bhatt actually advised her to take it, on the logic that the bigger market meant more opportunity. Sahelpreet made a different call, and a practical one. She had not received her degree yet, would need to visit the Parul campus repeatedly for certificates and paperwork, and was settled in Vadodara. So she requested the Vadodara branch, and secured the transfer before joining.</p><p>Her first three months were pure interior design work, floor plans and drafting, inside a structure split across pre-sales, design and installation teams, with design owning roughly 60 percent of a project’s scope. Then Livspace rolled out a new operating system, the 3.0 model, and the job widened. Designers now ran sales and design together: pitching services, showing 3D mock-ups, negotiating budgets and discounts, closing bookings.</p><h3>What the classroom could not teach</h3><p>Industry showed her the gap every design graduate eventually meets.</p><p>College projects assume clean, rectangular rooms. Real sites do not cooperate. Odd dimensions, non-standard layouts, structural columns dropped in inconvenient places. In college a beautiful design earns praise. On the job, clients reject ideas on pure personal preference and ask for endless changes to colour and layout.</p><p>Space planning, taught as a tidy mapping exercise, became a daily fight to cram an overwhelming list of features into tight client spaces. The software skills that felt fine for assignments were too slow for the pace and complexity of real work. And the comfortable belief that “the client likes what you like” fell apart fast. But learning to design around an awkward column and a stubborn brief is exactly what gave her a real, working grip on how the interior business actually runs.</p><h3>The long game</h3><p>Sahelpreet has a plan, and it loops back to where she started.</p><p>She is working at a local design studio now, gathering two or three years of experience before she returns to Bhawani Mandi. Her father’s business currently imports ready-made furniture from Delhi and Ahmedabad to sell locally. She intends to upgrade it, using her software and design skills to manufacture custom furniture built precisely to clients’ homes, and to open her own interior design studio in Bhawani Mandi, a market with almost no local competition.</p><p>The commerce student who was going to join the family business is, in the end, going to join the family business. Just on completely different terms, with a design degree, her own studio, and a plan to build furniture rather than import it.</p><p>Her parting advice carries the same self-directed streak that got her hired. Start your portfolio and resume early instead of stacking it all at the end. Network locally with professionals in your university’s city. Explore several options rather than grabbing the first offer. Look hard at real architecture, she points out that older buildings in Vadodara hold details modern designers struggle to even conceptualise. Do not wreck your health for the work. And honour the trust and money your parents put into your education.</p><p>For someone who was never placed, she made an unusual number of the decisions herself.</p><p><em>Explore Interior and Furniture Design at the Parul Institute of Design, where students build the technical skill and the initiative that industry actually rewards.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=666510ef88a8" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[She lost the school competition.]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@sandeep.macwan19286/she-lost-the-school-competition-eea27f6e45ad?source=rss-f29cb6b72945------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/eea27f6e45ad</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[startup]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[marketing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[paruluniversity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[chips]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[btech]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Sandeep Macwan]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 24 Jul 2026 10:11:36 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-07-24T10:11:36.469Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>She lost the school competition. Then a stranger’s child told her mother it was the best thing she had ever eaten.</h3><h3>Devanshi Bhatt and her co-founder built a chips company while carrying full-time B.Tech degrees at Parul University. The engineering behind it is more interesting than the story.</h3><p><em>Parul Innovation and Entrepreneurship Research Centre, Parul University, Vadodara.</em></p><p>The competition was on 25 December, at school, and Devanshi Bhatt did not win it.</p><p>She had made sun-dried chips with a flavour of her own. The judges were unmoved. Then a little girl who had tried them turned to her mother and said it was the best thing she had ever eaten.</p><p>That sentence, from someone with no stake in being kind, is the entire origin of Crunchy Wavez.</p><h3>The gap in the aisle</h3><p>By the time Devanshi enrolled in B.Tech Food Technology at Parul University, the idea had turned into a question worth researching, and the research produced a straightforward finding about the Indian snack aisle.</p><p>Cheap chips are unhealthy. The healthy alternatives, built on beetroot or millet, do not taste good enough for children to choose them. Parents buy the second category. Children eat the first.</p><p>Nobody was making chips that taste like the fried version and are genuinely not the fried version. That gap became the product specification.</p><h3>The stall test</h3><p>Their Head of Department gave them advice that skipped every step a business plan would have taken. Put up a stall in college. Find out whether anyone buys it.</p><p>They ran stalls at HORTUS and at Udyam, the management festival on campus. People bought the chips, and then came back. That was the evidence they needed before committing, and it cost them a table rather than a funding round.</p><p>Only after that did they enter the incubation programme at the Parul Innovation and Entrepreneurship Research Centre and build the company properly.</p><h3>Six months on a shelf, no preservatives</h3><p>This is the part where the food technology degree stops being a credential and starts being the product.</p><p>Food spoils because of two things: water and oil. Water lets microbes grow. Oil goes rancid.</p><p>Crunchy Wavez removes both. The potato slices are sun-dried, which takes the water out. Then they are roasted rather than deep-fried, which cuts the oil content by about 45 per cent. With almost no water and very little oil, there is not much left for spoilage to work with.</p><p>The result holds for six months without a single chemical preservative, which is not a marketing position. It is a consequence of the process.</p><p>The sun-drying is done by women employed locally for that stage, which puts wages into the same town the product comes from.</p><h3>A year of testing two variables</h3><p>The research and development ran for a full year, and the discipline in it is worth noting because most student projects do not have any.</p><p>They tested slice thickness and flavour powder particle size separately rather than together, which is the only way to know which change caused which result. Anyone who has run an experiment will recognise the method. Not many undergraduate founders apply it to a snack.</p><p>Their stopping rule was equally clear. If 85 per cent of tasters love it, stop worrying about the other 15 per cent. Chasing universal approval is how a product never launches.</p><h3>The arithmetic of Rs 10 to Rs 20</h3><p>The pricing decision shows the same kind of thinking, and it is the part most student ventures get wrong.</p><p>They set the price between Rs 10 and Rs 20, aimed at students aged 15 to 25, and they can explain both boundaries.</p><p>At Rs 5, the price itself signals cheap and therefore unhealthy, which destroys the entire proposition the product is built on. At Rs 60, it is a treat rather than a habit, and nobody buys it daily. Between Rs 10 and Rs 20 the price says quality without putting the product out of reach of the people meant to eat it regularly.</p><p>Marketing followed the same constraint-driven logic. College events for initial exposure, social media because it costs nothing, and no paid advertising at all. The money that would have gone to ads went into materials and production instead.</p><p>The team split reflects it too. The company grew from two people to sixteen. Parth handles money, supply chain and logistics. Devanshi handles product quality, marketing and public relations. Two founders, two domains, no overlap.</p><h3>What the year produced</h3><p>The company was registered on 7 March, which sits one day off International Women’s Day, and the founders chose the date deliberately.</p><p>Since then: incubation at the university’s innovation centre, meetings with IAS officers and with the Governor of Bihar, and a place in the finals of the Women Vadodara competition. The product launched at the Vadodara Startup Festival, and the CEO of Gopal Snacks, one of Gujarat’s largest snack manufacturers, inaugurated it.</p><p>Both founders are still full-time third-year students. They sleep four to five hours. The business work happens at night, after the academic day is finished. The teaching staff have been supportive of the arrangement, which matters more than it sounds, because the alternative is choosing between the degree and the company at twenty years old.</p><h3>What is actually transferable here</h3><p>The temptation with a story like this is to file it under inspiration and move on. The more useful reading is that almost every decision in it was made cheaply.</p><p>The market research was a stall at a college festival. The validation was whether strangers came back for a second packet. The product engineering came out of the degree the founder was already enrolled in. The pricing was reasoned from what the number signals rather than from a spreadsheet. The marketing budget was zero by choice, so the money could go into production.</p><p>None of that required capital. It required asking people things and then believing the answers.</p><p>The incubation centre they went through charges students nothing, takes ideas from any faculty, and runs the same route for everyone: idea submission, a verbal pitch, a formal presentation, fifteen days of pre-incubation spent on market research and talking to real customers, then mentorship and support with government grant applications.</p><p>Devanshi’s first customer feedback arrived from a child at a competition she lost. Everything after that was method.</p><p><em>Explore</em><a href="https://www.paruluniversity.ac.in/"><em> B.Tech Food Technology and other programmes at Parul University</em></a><em>, and the incubation route that took this product from a college stall to a launch.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=eea27f6e45ad" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Your first 149 rotis are prototypes. The 150th one is a product.]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@sandeep.macwan19286/your-first-149-rotis-are-prototypes-the-150th-one-is-a-product-b34114268682?source=rss-f29cb6b72945------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b34114268682</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[women-startups]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[parul-university-vadodara]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[innovation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[entrepreneurship]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[patience]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Sandeep Macwan]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 24 Jul 2026 10:06:05 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-07-24T10:06:05.510Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>The frameworks an incubator at Parul University uses to find out whether a student’s startup idea survives contact with an actual customer.</h3><p><em>Parul Innovation and Entrepreneurship Research Centre, Parul University, Vadodara.</em></p><p>Nobody’s first roti is round.</p><p>It takes about a month of making five a day before they come out properly, and the instructive part is what those failures are. Each one teaches something specific about the dough, the heat, the pressure of the rolling pin. The first 149 are not failures at all. They are prototypes.</p><p>The 150th is the minimum viable product.</p><p>That is how the Parul Innovation and Entrepreneurship Research Centre explains MVP to students who have never built anything before, and it is a better definition than most business schools manage. An MVP is not a finished product. It is the first version good enough to put in front of a real customer, which means it arrives long before the thing is any good.</p><p>For comparison, the team behind Helios built more than 300 prototypes across two years before finalising their design.</p><h3>The wallet exercise, which almost everybody fails</h3><p>Before any of the frameworks get taught, students do an activity that is designed to humble them.</p><p>They are put in pairs and given five minutes to design a wallet. One rule: no talking.</p><p>The results are consistently creative. Magnetic attachments for phones. Cross-body bags. Folding chain purses. Students enjoy it and produce genuinely inventive work.</p><p>Then comes the question that ruins the exercise for everyone. Which of these products would you spend your own money on?</p><p>Almost everybody picks their own.</p><p>The reason is that nobody asked the customer anything. Each student designed a wallet for themselves and assumed their partner would want the same thing. Five minutes of confident work, all of it built on an assumption nobody tested.</p><p>The activity then runs again with one change. Before designing, students interview their partner and write down what that person actually needs.</p><p>The second round produces different objects entirely. One person wants room for a comb, medicine and paper soap. Another hates bulk, so the designer switches to foam. Same students, same five minutes, dramatically better outcomes, and the only variable that changed was whether anyone asked.</p><p>The facilitator has a domestic analogy for it. When hostel food is bad on a Sunday, students discuss what to order before ordering. That conversation, conducted without anyone calling it anything, is design thinking.</p><h3>Five stages, and the one everyone skips</h3><p>The formal framework taught at the incubator runs in five stages.</p><p><strong>Empathise.</strong> Get close enough to the customer to feel what they deal with daily. A founder who does not know the problem cannot solve it.</p><p><strong>Define.</strong> State the problem in specific terms and set a concrete goal. Vague problem, vague solution.</p><p><strong>Ideate.</strong> Generate solutions, within real constraints. Tata sold the Indigo and the Nano for years before understanding that buyers wanted style, which produced the Harrier. Creativity still has to satisfy ISO and BIS standards.</p><p><strong>Prototype.</strong> Build the rough version. This is where the rotis live.</p><p><strong>Test.</strong> Put it in front of real users. When it fails, find out why, fix it, and go again.</p><p>The stage founders skip is the first one, which is why the wallet exercise exists.</p><h3>Eight questions, 100 marks</h3><p>The incubator scores student ideas against eight parameters before deciding what to do with them. The weighting tells you what the people running it actually believe.</p><p><strong>Problem clarity, out of 10.</strong> Can the founder describe the problem in two sentences a stranger would understand? A vague problem statement produces a vague product.</p><p><strong>Problem size, out of 10.</strong> How many people have this problem? The scoring is unusually blunt: affects two people scores zero, a whole class scores four or five, a city or state scores six or seven, and something affecting most of the population scores ten. A solution to a problem nobody has is not a business.</p><p><strong>Problem growth, out of 10.</strong> Is it getting worse? A shrinking problem scores zero. Skin conditions and children’s phone dependence are both measurably increasing, which makes them defensible starting points. Pick a problem that will be larger next year than it is now.</p><p><strong>Solution need, out of 10.</strong> Will anyone actually change their behaviour? This is the parameter founders underestimate. Someone with knee pain still wears formal shoes to the office because of what the office expects. And if butter were sold in a Fevicol tube, nobody would put it on bread, because the association is too strong to overcome. A real problem plus an unusable solution is still nothing.</p><p><strong>Problem frequency, out of 10.</strong> How often does it happen? A ceiling fan breaks once a year. An RO filter needs servicing once a year. Subscription models die on low-frequency problems, because nobody keeps an app they open annually. Twelve or more times a year makes recurring revenue viable.</p><p><strong>Founder’s passion, out of 10.</strong> Out of ten ideas a founder might genuinely care about two. Without that, the venture collapses the first time it gets difficult. But passion on its own scores badly if the customer demand is not there beside it.</p><p><strong>Solution feasibility, out of 20.</strong> Can this be built with technology, money and people that currently exist? Weighted double, because execution decides whether an idea becomes a product. An idea requiring technology nobody has scores low regardless of how good it sounds.</p><p><strong>Unique features, out of 20.</strong> What makes it different? If many companies already do it, rethink. If there are two competitors, there is room. Also weighted double, because differentiation determines survival.</p><p>Note where the marks sit. Sixty of the hundred go to understanding the problem. Forty go to whether the founder can build something different enough to survive. Almost none of it is about the idea being clever.</p><h3>The question that comes after the score</h3><p>Once students have scored their own ideas, they present them, and then get asked the thing nobody prepares for: why will your idea fail?</p><p>One student pitched Campus Connect, a tool for finding hackathon teammates, and was challenged on privacy risk. Another pitched a LinkedIn for athletes and was asked how he would verify that a profile belonged to a real athlete rather than a fabricated one. A third pitched an Ayurvedic skincare line and was advised to sell through dermatologists first, because consumers extend trust to a doctor’s recommendation that they will not extend to an unknown brand.</p><p>None of those responses killed the idea. All three sharpened it, which is what the scorecard is for. It is a diagnostic rather than a verdict.</p><h3>The canvas, and the thing people get wrong about Uber</h3><p>The last framework is the Business Model Canvas, nine blocks on one page: customer segments, value proposition, channels, customer relationships, revenue streams, key resources, key activities, key partnerships, and cost structure.</p><p>Two blocks generate most of the argument.</p><p>On <strong>customer segments</strong>, the standard mistake is answering “everyone.” Students are pushed to name one or two segments instead, and to answer two harder questions: who has the most pain, and who pays first? Those are frequently different people.</p><p>On <strong>value proposition</strong>, the rule is a length limit. If it does not fit in two sentences, the founder does not yet understand the customer. It is also about relieving a pain rather than listing features.</p><p>The teaching examples do useful work. Uber’s key resource is not cars, because Uber owns none. It is the platform and the driver network, which is precisely why it scales. Netflix runs on subscription revenue with a content library and technology as its key resources, and its entire model is built to stop subscribers leaving. McDonald’s earns from franchise fees and sales, and its standardisation is not a byproduct of the business but the value proposition itself. Amazon is a multi-sided platform serving buyers and sellers, earning from sales, Prime subscriptions and marketplace commissions at once.</p><p>Students then spend half an hour mapping their own ideas onto the canvas. One group got into a genuine argument about whether their customer was the individual user or the institution buying on that user’s behalf. The answer was that both can be true, but the value proposition has to be written differently for each.</p><p>The session ends on the most useful sentence in the whole framework: the canvas is not a plan, it is a hypothesis. Everything written on that page is an assumption until a customer proves otherwise.</p><h3>Why a university teaches this at all</h3><p>The frameworks above are taught free, in bootcamps, to students from any faculty, through an incubation centre that charges nothing and is government-backed.</p><p>The process behind them is structured. Ideas go in through the portal. Phase one is a verbal pitch. Phase two, for ideas that clear it, is a formal presentation. Then comes a fifteen-day pre-incubation window for market research, mentor matching, budget building and, critically, going out and talking to actual customers. Only after that does full incubation begin, with workspace, mentorship and support through government grant applications.</p><p>Which loops back to the wallet exercise. The entire pipeline is designed around the assumption that the founder’s biggest risk is not a lack of ideas. It is the confidence to build something nobody asked for.</p><p><em>Explore </em><a href="https://www.paruluniversity.ac.in/"><em>entrepreneurship, management and engineering programmes at Parul University</em></a><em>, and the incubation route open to students from every faculty.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b34114268682" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>