<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Avaneesh Satyang on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Avaneesh Satyang on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@satyangavaneesh?source=rss-2a5af0491dad------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Fri, 20 Nov 2026 21:12:45 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@satyangavaneesh/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Strength to Bend, Somewhere to Return]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@satyangavaneesh/the-strength-to-bend-somewhere-to-return-2d1a95cde077?source=rss-2a5af0491dad------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2d1a95cde077</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[personal-essay]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[manga]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[grief]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[pop-culture]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Avaneesh Satyang]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 14 Sep 2026 17:43:18 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-09-14T19:03:48.418Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Reading Takehiko Inoue’s Vagabond through grief and the fantasy of the lone man.</p><p><strong>Spoiler note:</strong> This essay discusses <em>Vagabond</em> through chapter 327, including major encounters, losses, and the farming arc. If you are still reading, you may wish to return when you reach its unfinished stopping point.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/636/1*ZDN6JnEWWygihLHys1uGAA.png" /><figcaption>Takehiko Inoue, portrait of Miyamoto Musashi, <em>WATER: Vagabond Art Book</em>, p. 157. © I.T. Planning. <a href="https://itplanning.co.jp/works/vb-jpn-water/">Official artbook catalogue</a>.</figcaption></figure><h3>Literally me — a disambiguation</h3><p>The man in the picture has very few friends, considerable difficulty expressing affection, and a capacity for violence that is so finely developed that it almost counts as an alternative means of communication. Beneath him are the words “he’s literally me.” The distance between this extravagant competence and ordinary life is part of the meme. So is the word <em>literally </em>permits a confession to be made already wearing the expression it will use in case someone laughs.</p><p>Ryan Gosling’s unnamed Driver in <em>Drive</em> is particularly good at this work. Alone, silent, apparently sufficient by himself, he makes loneliness look like a stoic decision. You can spend quite a while looking at a face like that before having to consider the difference between being unreachable and having nobody to reach. In one fan edit, posted by u/dakisaurus, Musashi from Takehiko Inoue’s <em>Vagabond</em> acquires the Driver’s car. A manga speech balloon is crossed out until the surviving words announce that Musashi is the “man who drives.” The comment section performs the expected recognition, “Musashi is literally me”. The swordsman fits, but the real joke is that he fits so easily.<a href="#note_1">1</a></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/406/1*QKt_1FFClTRRTJYoKR_Rvw.png" /><figcaption>The solitary swordsman becomes the Driver. <strong>Source:</strong> Fan composite posted by u/dakisaurus, “I did a funny,” r/vagabondmanga, May 5, 2024. Incorporating Takehiko Inoue’s Vagabond and imagery from Drive (dir. Nicolas Winding Refn, 2011). <a href="https://www.reddit.com/r/vagabondmanga/comments/1cl3jeh/i_did_a_funny/">https://www.reddit.com/r/vagabondmanga/comments/1cl3jeh/i_did_a_funny/</a>.</figcaption></figure><p>Some of the first Musashis I encountered online were already combinations: a face from here, words from there, the interval between them removed. They were beautiful. In an isolated panel, injury and composure could sit together without the awkward business of the recovering that happens in between them; a man could carry the evidence that life had hurt him and still seem prepared for whatever it might do next. I wanted something in that composure. The attraction had room for several wishes: to become good at something difficult, to keep going when life changes, and to possess a steadiness that other people could not take away.</p><p>I began reading <em>Vagabond</em> after turning thirty, in the months that followed after losing Baba, my grandfather. Around the same time, close friendships also ended because of choices that made reconciliation impossible. One person was dead, and others were living a life that would no longer include mine in the way it once had. Together, the losses changed the shape of the sky I thought I knew. Baba had been part of its shelter — despite death’s inevitability — imagining life without him had been almost impossible. Now this present and the coming future required me to be a person I had not yet learned to be. From a distance, Thirty looks more solid. It suggests an age at which the adult would finally be installed, and the anxious provisional person could stop covering for him. Instead, I felt freshly uncovered, remarkably vulnerable. The appeal of a man whose suffering had become strength was therefore fairly immediate, even if my nightly reading did not involve formulating it this way. Reading, thus became a ritual.</p><p>I knew the pages would be extraordinary because I already trusted Inoue. <em>Slam Dunk</em>, in its animated form, was a huge part of my childhood. The scene I remember most insistently is Mitsui on his knees before Coach Anzai, bloodied and crying. He has made an elaborate, destructive facade of not caring. He presents himself as a delinquent, picking fights with Shohoku’s players and trying to sabotage the basketball team which has taken the shape of a bloody battle the gymnasium in the anime has not seen yet. Then the person before whom the facade cannot survive enters the gym, and what comes out of Mitsui is the wish it was organized to conceal: he wants to play basketball.<a href="#note_2">2</a></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/620/1*tMyCVCXyTSN-URx6MXuh1w.png" /><figcaption>Mitsui before Coach Anzai: The desire to play survives the performance of not caring about it. <strong>Source:</strong> Slam Dunk, episode 27, Toei Animation, based on Takehiko Inoue’s manga. Still from Toei Animation’s official episode page. © Toei Animation. <a href="https://lineup.toei-anim.co.jp/ja/tv/movie_slumdunk/episode/27/">https://lineup.toei-anim.co.jp/ja/tv/movie_slumdunk/episode/27/</a>.</figcaption></figure><p>As a teenager, that scene had always given me a reason to look past masculine bravado without ceasing to see what it did. So, apart from it being hailed as one of Seinen’s “Big Three” Manga series; I also brought this reason to <em>Vagabond</em>, although I did bring some my appetite for the bravado as well. Inoue’s swordsman could appear so composed in an isolated panel that it was possible to overlook how often the story found him frightened, dependent, or simply wrong. His great ambition, “invincible under the sun,” sounded like a solution to more problems than a sword could reasonably be expected to solve. I knew this, of course. But knowing it did not dispose of its appeal.</p><p>With the benefit of hindsight, David Foster Wallace’s “E Unibus Pluram” helps me understand why knowing this is not the end of the matter. His account of television follows an irony so accomplished that recognizing the manipulation can become another sort of pleasure the screen provides. The knowing viewer remains in front of it. For Wallace, by the essay’s end, sincerity has become a risk worth considering: a work might have to endure looking soft, obvious, or embarrassingly moved by ordinary human troubles.<a href="#note_3">3</a> I recognize the protection offered by the joke beneath the solitary man. I also remember Mitsui still kneeling after the nonchalance has failed. Inoue lets the desire remain in the room long enough for our cleverness about it to become less interesting than whether somebody will answer a sincere call for help. That patience is part of what I trusted.</p><p>I have been trying to think about men like this through manga characters like Guts, Thorfinn, and Buntarō Mori as well. Musashi is the wandering philosopher among them, pursuing a skill until the pursuit begins asking more of him than skill can answer. I could follow a man who was often wrong without having to stand outside his life until he redeems himself. His perseverance carried me through parts of the story in which I could not admire his choices, and when his understanding changed, it somehow changed the meaning of pages I had already read as well. A posture that once looked like self-sufficiency could become chronic loneliness. A pause before a fight could become the space in which someone might choose to leave. The greatest achievement of <em>Vagabond</em> is that it made that identification last long enough to become a question about the life I wanted, and about how much room that life would leave for other people.</p><p>Finally, there’s a distinction between identifying with a character and simply liking or imitating one. This distance fluctuates as I read; close enough to want the spear to miss him, far enough away to see the person wielding it. While the meme compresses this shifting relationship into an identity; the manga allows it to sway and move.<a href="#note_4">4</a> The question that kept me reading was what would happen to his determination when it encountered something that sheer determination could not settle. I wanted him to keep going, and I increasingly wanted to know what and whom he would carry with him along the way.</p><h3>Invincible under the sun, I’m going to become</h3><p>Before he is Musashi, he is Shinmen Takezō, a boy whose father’s reputation for strength leaves very little space in the house for a child to remain a child. Munisai (his father) reads the threat in his son’s eyes. Inoue’s depiction of Takezō’s childhood fragments show contempt, rejection, and the terrible confusion of being treated as an adversary by someone on whom he should’ve depended on. The child learns to be always prepared. Later, it is this perpetual readiness that other men will admire.</p><p>The childhood wish gives the phrase “invincible under the sun” an intimate urgency. Inoue brings the solitary boy and the magnificent public title close enough for me to hear, inside the ambition, a promise that not needing anyone will never again expose him like this. It is a persuasive promise to give a child. The title also contains a difficulty that will grow with its audience; someone else must recognize him as invincible. Every challenger can reopen a question he is trying to settle for good, and the promise of a final answer keeps him moving from one duel to the next.<a href="#note_5">5</a></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*9MT_FiDWK6FGAd3e5W6mjQ.png" /><figcaption>A child’s wish is given a title. The desire to never depend on anyone expands into public ambition. <strong>Source:</strong> Takehiko Inoue, Vagabond, vol. 2, chap. 17, VIZ English edition. © I.T. Planning.</figcaption></figure><p>That admittedly is an effective and but rather well-known premise. I recognized the title’s shape before I needed to understand its setting. It had the brightness of a childhood anime goal. Become Hokage; acquire the name that makes people look at you differently. The work towards it has an attraction of its own. A movement can be repeated, corrected, and attempted again; something that the body could scarcely manage begins to become possible. The childhood fragments help me understand the urgency with which he pursues strength, while the pursuit will continually give him new things to want. The protagonist’s curiosity about mastery starts taking room beside his hunger for recognition. This is part of why relinquishing ambition becomes so difficult. And he really does improve. His efforts produce capacities that other people recognize and that he can feel in use, so the larger promise continues to receive apparently convincing evidence. Another victory looks capable of completing what the previous victory began. Everyone admires the willingness to return to difficult work. but what becomes increasingly doubtful is the expectation that enough accomplishment will leave one with nothing left to fear.</p><p>In this sense, Musashi was a particularly severe version of a man I had often met in other forms and media. The samurai swordsman and Western gunman both share a capacity to make distance look authoritative. Lee Clark Mitchell’s study of how Westerns make masculinity and Martin Holtz’s account of the genre’s cultural mobility help place this resemblance stopping short of turning it into a universal male archetype. The movement from Kurosawa’s <em>Yojimbo</em> to Leone’s <em>A Fistful of Dollars</em> is an actual history of this adaptation.<a href="#note_6">6</a> Ryan Gosling’s Driver in <em>Drive</em> and Officer K in <em>Blade Runner 2049</em> belong to different stories, yet their reticence gives the viewer room to imagine a life behind an economical surface. K’s uncertainty about his significance makes his wish to be exceptional particularly vulnerable. Even the superhero’s division between ordinary and extraordinary selves can give a familiar shape to the wish that somebody should recognize what is hidden. I had learned something from these arrangements before I could explain their histories. The man who stands apart gets the room to be impressive; and the people who keep him fed tend to occupy less space in the picture.</p><h3>There is no light for those who do not know darkness</h3><p>But<em> Vagabond</em> begins by making the impressive man difficult to separate from the person holding him up. Takezō and his friend Matahachi come to the battlefield at Sekigahara to make their names but wake among dead bodies. They are defeated boys, sick and trying to get away. In the first pages of their grand careers, getting away alive requires each boy to accommodate the weight of the other.<a href="#note_7">7</a></p><p>The date, 1600, places them at a historical turn. The battle of Sekigahara helped establish Tokugawa supremacy; Ieyasu became shōgun in 1603, although the final defeat of the Toyotomi at Osaka came in 1615. The relative peace associated with the Edo period indeed had a violent making.<a href="#note_8">8</a> The manga’s boys enter that transition from the ground level, where a change in the political order is first encountered as mutilated bodies, abandoned weapons, and the visceral danger of being found, as all that moves probably wants you dead. Inoue’s fictional scenes give the grand ambition this immediate environment.</p><p>At the house where they take refuge, the women who shelter them have to survive in this world too. Okō and her daughter Akemi live by recovering armour and weapons from the dead. War offers the boys an entrance into glory; the women have to find something saleable in its remains. Soon, Tenma and his gang threaten their livelihood and their lives. Takezō intervenes to answer a real danger. But after driving Tenma away from the house, he continues to go after him. He demands the fleeing man to behave like a leader and continues beating him past the point at which the violent confrontation could plausibly be called protection. Takezō and Matahachi laugh together under the moon. They tally the men they have killed. Their friendship has found an activity in which fear can be turned outward, inflicted, and returned to them as evidence of who they are. Okō looks at them and thinks of children “playing a game of blood.” Her face changes the scene. Something momentous has occurred in the boys’ version. From where she stands, the grandeur looks horribly young.<a href="#note_9">9</a></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/544/1*ASxdP8cuKSHsQ17UedPbGQ.png" /><figcaption>The boys have an audience. Okō’s thoughts follow their laughter and unsettle the account of what the killing has made them. <strong>Source:</strong> Takehiko Inoue, Vagabond, vol. 1, chap. 5, VIZ English edition. © I.T. Planning.</figcaption></figure><p>The difference between the perspectives reveal more than just who the real Takezō is. Both perspectives belong to the same event. The boys can feel grown up and empowered by an action that makes it appear juvenile to someone else. The young men are in dire need of validation, and they must achieve it collectively; they are mutual witnesses to attest that the recent event demonstrated strength. Connell and Messerschmidt’s account of masculinity as a social practice provides a useful lens at this scale. Two boys establish the terms on which they will recognize each other, while somebody outside the agreement sees its cost.<a href="#note_10">10</a> For that moment, each knows how to be the kind of man the other will acknowledge.</p><p>Takezō learned in his childhood to watch for hostility in a world where hostility has often been close at hand; aggression gets him into trouble, but it has also helped him survive trouble that he did not invent. Reading his alertness as a response to danger leaves room for the terrible usefulness of it. He cannot simply discard the part of himself that has kept him alive. Nor does its usefulness establish that everyone he meets is a threat. A defensive habit can outlast the encounter that required it, until even the approach of affection is received in the body by preparing to withstand something. This pattern I consistently recognize in Inoue’s character. The manga makes it visible in how he meets people, how quickly distance becomes confrontation, and how much effort an apparently simple kindness can require him to accept.</p><p>Matahachi will eventually try a cheaper route. He poaches a swordsmanship certificate from a dead traveller, though initially intending to return it to the man’s family. Later, adopts the name on it, Sasaki Kojirō, as his own. He has found a portable part of accomplishment and hopes to dispense with the rest. For a while other people respond to the certificate as he wants them to, and there is relief in being received as a great swordsman, until the performance requires things he cannot do and a swindler discovers that he will have to pay for cheap access to such a position.<a href="#note_11">11</a></p><p>It is not easy to enjoy Matahachi’s fraud beside Musashi’s authentic achievement. The more awkward likeness is that both men want a name to perform an internal repair. Musashi will do an almost inconceivable amount of work for his. Matahachi lies. This is a serious difference, and the hoped-for moment of arrival has a familiar resemblance: <em>after they know what to call me, I can stop feeling like this</em>.</p><p>For Takezō, the trouble starts before any title can protect him. Matahachi flees with Okō, and leaving Takezō wandering among the bodies calling his friend’s name. The capacity to kill the men who come at him has done nothing to keep the person he expected to stay. The village too blamed Takezō for leading Matahachi away to war; and when he returned alone, he was hunted as a dangerous fugitive. Later, the monk Takuan calls his distance from everybody a proof of fear, and calls the supposedly strongest boy the weakest person in Miyamoto. Takezō remembers the insult when he is bound and hung alive from the village’s great cedar. Takuan helped bring this about.<a href="#note_12">12</a></p><p>Otsū tries to feed him. She raises a rice ball on a bamboo pole, an awkward contrivance that Takezō must stretch towards while tied above the ground. A long piece of wood, normally useful for keeping a body away, has become a means of getting food to one. She could not accomplish the entire movement. He has to lean.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/546/1*I701KIo3Kyusl1ZCIt-jzQ.png" /><figcaption>Otsū raises the rice. Bound above the ground, Takezō must help complete the movement by leaning towards her. <strong>Source:</strong> Takehiko Inoue, Vagabond, vol. 2, chap. 18, VIZ English edition. © I.T. Planning.</figcaption></figure><p>Takuan, the Buddhist monk who becomes a recurring presence in his life, sees a boy where the village sees a menace. He neither dismisses Takezō’s violence nor accepts it as the whole truth of him. His resolve lies in continuing to address someone who has learned to meet concern as another threat, without demanding that the boy become gentle before he is worth helping. He can be harsh himself; being understood by Takuan is not always comfortable or safe. Yet he keeps open a possibility that Takezō cannot sustain alone: that his strength might find a purpose beyond killing.. Later, after cutting Takezō’s ropes, Takuan tells him, “There is no light… …for those who do not know darkness…” The promise begins to acquire a voice and direction before it acquires any certainty. Takezō has somewhere to look.<a href="#note_13">13</a></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/544/1*T8R-8jpH2rGjLizqwG7unQ.png" /><figcaption>Takuan urges Takezō to keep living, then briefly admires his own phrasing. Otsu’s voice comes from beyond the panel. <strong>Source:</strong> Takehiko Inoue, Vagabond, vol. 2, chap. 21; VIZ English edition. © I.T. Planning.</figcaption></figure><p>The boy who vowed never to depend on anyone, just received rice from someone who wanted him to survive. Takuan declares Takezō dead and names him Miyamoto Musashi, he gives a fugitive a way forward and a place to carry in his name. To go on as Miyamoto Musashi is therefore to carry the place he is leaving, a peculiar arrangement for someone hoping to be sufficient to himself, and one that becomes more peculiar as the new name begins to travel ahead of him. People hear it and expect a swordsman, but they do not know how much of Takezō is coming with him.</p><h3>See everything in its entirety… effortlessly</h3><p>On the road with Takuan, Musashi admits that he thinks about Otsū all the time and asks how monks shake such distractions off. Takuan answers first with a stick: he mentions her name, Musashi freezes, and the rotten wood breaks across his head. Later, when Musashi declares his devotion to the way of the sword, Takuan identifies the effort of looking away as part of what holds his attention captive.</p><p>The page opens over the forest. Absorption in a leaf can hide the tree, and absorption in a tree can hide the forest. The two men become tiny figures in the foliage. “See everything in its entirety… effortlessly…” The page gives me more to look at than the man who has struggled to see correctly. Otsū’s face then returns, large against the landscape of the Yagyū estate, where Takuan says she now is. There is something quietly generous in that recognition. I read the lesson as permission for affection to belong among the things Musashi has to attend to, without every thought of her becoming a failure of discipline. His steadfastness can include the fact that he misses her.</p><p>We soon find him in Kyoto, Musashi has words for his ambition and is willing to kill to establish that he means them. But before Seijūrō, head of the Yoshioka school, his body begins saying something else. Seeing his opponent’s mere movement, he imagines the lethality which leaves him shaking. Seijūrō’s younger brother, Denshichirō, later notices the tremor at the tip of his wooden sword. We learn Musashi can boldly announce himself; but he cannot quite yet control the information travelling down his arms.<a href="#note_14">14</a></p><p>Jōtarō is introduced before Musashi’s strength acquires a reputation. After the first Yoshioka challenge, the boy calls the wounded stranger his master and asks to follow him. Jōtarō offers an early recognition of someone who wants to become like him. He admires the roughness that sets Musashi apart from the other pretentious samurai. Musashi refuses him, telling the crying child that samurai do not cry. It is ironic here, that this prospective disciple had already carried him to a shelter but Musashi could not make room for his tears. Nevertheless, Jōtarō tails Musashi.</p><p>On the road, Jōtarō explains that he has no parents and nowhere to go; becoming strong seems his only chance of surviving without anyone’s help. One can hear Takezō in that ambition, although the boy’s need is immediate enough for survival. He needs somebody to let him stay. Musashi’s answer makes this one of the earliest relationships in which we see him beginning to let another person in: he speaks about Otsū, places a hand on Jōtarō’s head, and proposes that they become stronger together. Perhaps he can offer company here because the demand to survive alone sounds so familiar. He takes the boy towards Hōzōin and another challenge.<a href="#note_15">15</a></p><p>Combat in <em>Vagabond</em> unveils a unique form of intimacy. In the duel, two men must keep their distance, yet become acutely aware of the secrets the other wishes to hide. Before Hōzōin Inshun’s spear, Musashi sweats into his grip and reaches for sand to dry his hands. His stomach churns. A fraction of a movement has consequences that thought cannot afford to keep up. The young spear master, meanwhile, welcomes the intensity of danger that his immense talent has largely kept from him. The same encounter gives one man an experience he has been seeking and exposes the other to an experience he can scarcely bear.<a href="#note_16">16</a></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/936/1*8lCW0KpjLOtq2QK_DB6rkg.png" /><figcaption>Musashi faces Inshun. <strong>Source:</strong> Takehiko Inoue, Vagabond, vol. 5, chap. 43, “Inshun’s Spear.” © I.T. Planning.</figcaption></figure><p>Inoue follows a damp palm, an eye, the angle of a weapon, and the diminishing space through which it must pass. We are watching two accomplished bodies, and suddenly the contest depends on something as ordinary as keeping hold of a piece of wood. The spear has not striked yet. There is still time to look, although looking more closely makes the remaining distance feel ominous.</p><p>When reading at night on a screen, I could prolong that interval further. My thumb decided when I left the posture for the consequence, but the eye could keep moving what the image retained: back towards the hand, along the weapon, into the space between the men. A held image could become more urgent as its arrangement became clearer. Then I would move on. I could return afterwards, but Musashi could not. That difference contributed to the intimacy of reading him. His body exposed details I could spend time with, and the time made the movement difficult to dismiss as merely an impressive thing a swordsman did, especially because I had been allowed to attend to its preparation.</p><p><em>Vagabond</em> is extraordinarily fluid, and I’d argue some of that fluidity comes from the ease with which Inoue changes the scale of his attention. A face can become the landscape of tension, and a body that dominated one panel becomes a small disturbance within the next. His lines have weight and suppleness. It makes movement feel continuous even when the sequence breaks it into distinct views because a turn of the shoulder or the direction of a gaze carries force beyond the frame in which it is drawn. His drawing solicits a bodily understanding, the sense that something is about to give, that the balance has shifted, and that standing still has begun to require effort.</p><p>This is why speed seems too narrow a word for the action in <em>Vagabond</em>. The manga can make a moment dilate until its details become almost invisible, then compress several movements into an encounter I have to go back and reconstruct. The time involved in reading is elastic and responsive to the pressure of the drawing and to the attention I can bring it. Research by Linda Berube and her colleagues on digital comics treats touch, device, and pace as part of that experience.<a href="#note_17">17</a> Their exploratory study gives useful terms for something the screen made available to me: advancing the story was an action, and waiting before advancing became one too. The silence had activity within it.</p><p>Fear, in the first Inshun encounter, takes up more and more room. Beside the sweat at Musashi’s neck, there come black panels holding two pale eyes, scarcely enough to make a face but just enough to make the darkness seem occupied. They appear to have been waiting before he notices. The sensation is intimate and alien at once: the spear is in front of him, but something within his own body has begun answering it before he can decide what to do. Inoue’s narration speaks of humans and of us, giving the dread a reach beyond this boy’s history.<a href="#note_18">18</a> It feels older than the encounter, as if the danger is universal to the human experience.</p><figure><img alt="Pale eyes occupy the black fields beside Musashi’s sweating neck and watchful face." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/552/1*Asxjz_apRGBJdZeuZrPejA.png" /><figcaption>Fear looks back. <strong>Source:</strong> Takehiko Inoue, Vagabond, vol. 5, chap. 46, VIZ English edition. © I.T. Planning.</figcaption></figure><p>The fighters clash, in a battle of this skill level, it’ll only take one decisive strike to defeat a combatant, but Musashi continues to persist even when the contest has been called over. The perseverance I had come prepared to admire becomes difficult to distinguish from his inability to stop putting himself where terror can find him. He wants to defeat fear but keeps presenting it with the same conditions almost always running towards it. The eyes offer no opponent he can reach. I find them more unsettling for having so little expression: there is almost nothing to read in them, while Musashi’s body beside them is painfully legible.</p><p>He wakes under the care of In’ei, the old Hōzōin master, who bandages and feeds him. In’ei had already told him that he was making enemies of the people around him, projecting his fear and bloodlust onto them. The monk now takes him into the river. There, Musashi says, “I am scared. I’m scared of Inshun. How can I beat him?” I like the way the last question prevents the confession from becoming an exemplary breakthrough. He has told the truth about his fear and also that he wants to use it to win.<a href="#note_19">19</a></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/544/1*cyxcCAzXiLxBJaL5Lo5_Fw.png" /><figcaption>In’ei directs Musashi back to the mountains. <strong>Source:</strong> Takehiko Inoue, Vagabond, vol. 6, chap. 52, VIZ English edition. © I.T. Planning.</figcaption></figure><p>At the rematch, a spider crosses Musashi’s face, and its thread opens towards the stars. Such a small thing to admit into the middle of a duel. His face is still exposed to the spear and he still has to react in time. Yet the encounter now has room for the spider, for leaves and breath, for the night continuing around the two men. The danger still lurks, but there is pleasure in watching this enlargement happen, in discovering that fear has not permanently fixed the limits of what Musashi can notice. His readiness makes him more responsive. He can attend to something fragile without surrendering the precision that keeps him alive, and the fight changes because his body has learned to inhabit more than just the mechanics of a weapon.</p><p>The encounter has an intimacy for which the word <em>opponent</em> is insufficient. Each man discovers something about his own limits reading the other’s body. Musashi cannot achieve this alone in the mountains, however exacting the practice, because Inshun’s body will answer with an initiative of its own. Inshun, whose massive talent has made genuine danger rare, is also looking for that answer. They are exposed to each other in a way that speech has scarcely prepared them for, and for a time the manga lets this exposure feel immense, as if a duel could reveal a world that ordinary living had left hidden.</p><p>Musashi then strikes Inshun down and continues beating him after he becomes unconscious, insisting that he has won. In’ei will record no victor.<a href="#note_20">20</a></p><p>I was ready to recognize the widening of attention as progress, and it is progress in the sense that he can perceive and do things he could not before. But watching what he does with it makes admiration harder to sustain. The spider and the stars belong to the same development as the blows after Inshun has fallen, however much I might prefer to just keep the beautiful part of the world.</p><h3>Do you see how infinite you are?</h3><p>The Yagyū arc makes this problem stranger. The change following Hōzōin first appears through Musashi’s relationship with Jōtarō. The boy saw his master lose and flee from Inshun but trusted that he would return; as they approach Yagyū, Musashi carries him on his back. This is a modest form of dependence, easily overlooked beside the new swords at Musashi’s waist.</p><p>He follows evidence of an old master’s skill in a severed peony whose vitality seems to have survived its cutting. When he tries to recreate it, his own attempts leave the flowers damaged. His own blade can sever a stem, but the flowers he cuts appear to lose their vitality; the old man’s peony remains vividly alive. He crouches to inspect the stem and fibre, watching the consequences of movement rather than merely imagining the force of the swing.<a href="#note_21">21</a> Skill is no longer measured only by what the sword can overcome, but by what remains living after it has been swung.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/576/1*7TzJXJt32h2z-MY2hUjV9A.png" /><figcaption>Musashi sees the peony as a living consequence of the cut, yet continues to interpret its vitality through swordsmanship. <strong>Source: </strong>Takehiko Inoue, <em>Vagabond</em>, vol. 9, chap. 84, official VIZ English edition; adaptation by Yuji Oniki; lettering by Steve Dutro. © I.T. Planning.</figcaption></figure><p>Musashi reads the estate’s ancient trees and long freedom from invasion as proof of Sekishūsai’s greatness, then declares that he will challenge the supposedly invincible master. He has become more receptive to the world around him, but still converts what he sees into another hierarchy he must climb. When four senior Yagyū disciples invite Musashi to discuss swordsmanship beneath an <em>ensō</em>, he cannot accept just conversation as a meaningful encounter. He misnames and provokes them until a fight becomes possible. The crisis outside gives his aggression a more defensible purpose; after Jōtarō kills a dog in self-defense and is beaten by the retainers, Musashi publicly accepts responsibility for his disciple. It is a significant relational act, but he immediately turns protection into another assault and announces that he will defeat the entire estate.</p><p>Growth and regression occupy the same gesture. Inoue intercuts the battle with Otsū caring for the feverish Sekishūsai, who tells her that there is nothing wrong with crying. Otsū’s flute interrupts the men’s fighting, the music travels out. The flute draws Musashi towards Sekishūsai’s cottage, where he and Otsū confront one another with swords drawn. Musashi tells her that she has become beautiful, then orders her aside and threatens to cut her down when she cannot move. After her legs fail, he carries her inside. Otsū gives him dry clothes and conceals him from the returning disciples. Their reunion holds longing, fear, and care together. Musashi uses that care to continue towards the confrontation she tried to prevent.</p><p>Sekishūsai appears to present the easiest victory of Musashi’s life: an old, feverish man asleep beneath his bedding. Yet this apparent defencelessness makes the title of “invincible” increasingly incoherent. When Musashi moves his sword, the old man’s wooden back-scratcher catches its path.<a href="#note_22">22</a> Sekishūsai answers the intrusion with a wooden back-scratcher of all things and a composure that makes a conventional duel seem beside the point. Musashi tries again, only to imagine a dark version of himself seizing him by the throat. Images of Musashi’s father return within his struggle to understand what has happened. Munisai’s fear begins to show through the image of invincible strength; the word that was meant to end the child’s difficulties starts to look like something the father was trapped inside too. Musashi squints for the answer. The harder he tries to make the world yield it, the less he sees. The opponent preventing Musashi from reaching Sekishūsai is no longer another swordsman. It is the identity he has carried into the room.</p><p>There is the spread I have carried the longest. Musashi stands as a small dark figure inside an enormous white field, his swords still at his waist, his feet without a drawn ground beneath them. “Do you see how infinite you are?” The question occupies some of the space his body leaves open. There is very little here to inspect, and still the eye has somewhere to go; away from the familiar figure, into a whiteness that makes his outline incapable of containing everything he can be. His possible life grows larger as the picture of him becomes smaller.<a href="#note_23">23</a></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/936/1*JOtjJ5g4WKADC038feSczA.png" /><figcaption>Musashi becomes smaller within a larger possibility. The white field opens his perception without deciding his next action. <strong>Source:</strong> Takehiko Inoue, Vagabond, vol. 11, chap. 102, VIZ English edition. © I.T. Planning.</figcaption></figure><p>Beside this opening, the spread has dense bamboo, an enlarged eye, and the lettered breaths of exertion. but its white expanse remains the part that comes back most vividly. In isolation, it can resemble an ufinished answer. Its beauty gives me a reason to stay with a possibility whose consequences have yet to unfold. Musashi identifies himself by recounting the years and opponents that brought him there, and what has that led to? He just threatened Otsū, invaded a sickroom, and considered killing an unguarded man. He then admits that beside Sekishūsai he feels like nothing. The old man recognizes Musashi’s ability and his danger before declaring; invincible is merely a word. The title he has been chasing imagines all of life organized around comparison. The white field makes that arrangement difficult to see. There is no crowd from which he can distinguish himself, no defeated rival against whom to measure his size. There is his figure, the question, and a space that seems to exceed the question’s need for an answer. To me, what the page offers is a perceptual possibility; strength need not mean making the self large enough to dominate the world. Sekishūsai’s question invites Musashi to stop squinting after a single answer and discover an infinity in which he is small, permeable, and connected. I can think of it as a loosening of the self, the ego.</p><p>I want to tell him he can stand there for a little longer. We have seen the swords. They can stay at his waist while the eye wanders somewhere else, and he will still be there when it returns. That is the permission I want to borrow. I have spent much of this essay following the appeal of a man who knows what he is for; here, I can try leaving a little of myself unaccounted for. I do not know what belongs in that space, and I would like to resist furnishing it immediately with another impressive version of the same man.</p><p>Look at him again. I can imagine taking that space into an ordinary argument, stopping the constant defence of our positions long enough to hear the real person answering it. I might remain unconvinced and still let the conversation go somewhere I had not prepared for, with no need to make every word I had already spoken come out right.</p><h3>The strong are always kind</h3><p>The seventy-man battle at Ichijōji becomes the defining public exploit of Musashi’s journey. It begins with some unfinished business; almost a year after his first challenge, he has to return to Kyoto for a rematch with Denshichirō, the younger Yoshioka sibling. All this while, he has admitted his terror to In’ei, learned to see beyond Inshun’s spear, and encountered a strength at Yagyū that his old idea of winning cannot explain. And this time, Musashi’s reputation precedes him. Worried that Musashi might easily kill his younger Denshichirō; Seijūrō, the older brother comes to kill him in the dark before the appointed duel, Musashi welcomes the encounter. He still wants to measure himself against Seijūrō. However, this time, Seijūrō finds a different body before him. The challenger who once seemed flat and stiff now has depth and an unsettling lightness. He thinks of cotton which is a wonderfully strange way to register danger; Musashi has become harder to defeat by becoming less rigid in his swordplay.</p><p>Seijūrō can now imagine Musashi cutting him down. He acknowledges the possibility conversationally; his ease has not vanished, but the outcome no longer seems certain. Fear has more than just his own body to attach itself to. Earlier, he had imagined his brother losing an arm to Musashi and states that he would feel the pain as his own. At the decisive instant, the faces of the disciples of the Yoshioka school fill the spread beside his eye and raised sword. The man who seemed able to stand so lightly carries the weight of an entire school. Its weight briefly diverts his attention, and Musashi’s cut lands. I find the reversal unsettling because this time the fear shows up with attachments which I would otherwise want Musashi to acquire someday, family and social relations. Musashi, meanwhile, has found in combat a place where his anxieties fall away and he can give everything to the movement. For this encounter, this freedom helps him kill the man who cannot keep everyone else out of it.<a href="#note_24">24</a></p><p>During the recovery, with the duel against Denshichirō still ahead, Musashi encounters Sasaki Kojirō, the deaf swordsman whose name Matahachi had borrowed, beside a snowman in a courtyard. They exchange no names. Kojirō moves a twig; Musashi watches, tries its weight, and follows the movement with his own body. For a few pages, learning from another man does not require either of them to stake up deathly consequences. The light branch keeps becoming a sword in the imagination, and their play can flash into imagined blood.<a href="#note_25">25</a></p><p>The following morning, Kojirō reaches towards Musashi’s face and pulls up one cheek off the corner of his mouth. The gesture is funny before it is anything I can make a claim about. Musashi’s face has always been made to carry an extraordinary burden of determination, and here someone took a little of it between his fingers and changed the expression. Musashi looks startled. A hand crossed his guarded distance without making an attack, and he let it happen.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/414/1*kLm797I54TnSg9ph_05tZg.png" /><figcaption>A hand crosses the guarded distance. <strong>Source:</strong> Takehiko Inoue, Vagabond, vol. 24, chap. 212, VIZ English edition. © I.T. Planning.</figcaption></figure><p>Beyond the courtyard, spectators were gathering for the duel with Denshichirō. They wanted a different use of the famous man’s face; to see what it looks like when he dies at the hands of their representative. In the duel, Musashi kills Denshichirō. Now the Yoshioka have lost both brothers, and the school, driven by vengeance, is prepared to overwhelm him with seventy men.</p><p>Even at this point, there is an opportunity to leave. Before Ichijōji, over food and sake, Musashi tells Takuan he will go from Kyoto and asks the monk to take care of himself. Takuan notices the concern; Musashi has become kinder, which means he has become stronger. “The strong are always kind,” he says. The monk can recognise him as strong without requiring the next fight as proof, and for a while Musashi accepts the possibility too.<a href="#note_26">26</a></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/522/1*aa1x_JLOEtL5Ot0LVHT9vA.png" /><figcaption>Over a meal before their parting, Takuan recognizes kindness in Musashi and calls it a strength. <strong>Source:</strong> Takehiko Inoue, Vagabond, vol. 25, chap. 224; VIZ Signature Edition. © I.T. Planning.</figcaption></figure><p>He bows and takes the road away. Then, the anticipated battle gathers in the darkness behind him, fills his imagination, and turns him around anyway. Musashi’s pursuit of an individual reputation has entered into other people’s obligations and grief.</p><h3>In order to hide itself, fear calls out to hatred.</h3><p>Violence promises to end the insecurity but that only keeps producing more violence. Musashi wanted to establish his strength beyond question, but every victory gave him a reputation to defend, another possible rival, and something more to lose. Strength became dependent on other people’s recognition. The supposedly self-sufficient warrior must thus, keep returning to an audience, his achievements are real; but their capacity to answer his deeper question starts turning doubtful.</p><p>“One against seventy” is usually a finished story before anybody draws a weapon; arguably it is greatness measurable as a ratio. But Inoue spends time giving the quantity their own lives. A disciple has food to take to his pregnant wife. Other men remember teachers, raising the school’s crest, consider fleeing, and decide that they cannot leave. The institution has its own frightened dependence on a name. If it cannot preserve the Yoshioka, the deaths already incurred become harder to justify. In order to hide itself, fear calls out to hatred, this time Musashi is the object of that hatred.<a href="#note_27">27</a></p><p>The battle is exhilarating. Musashi finds an opening inside the swarm, changes weapons, and moves before the group can become the crushing total it is on paper. A black internal field opens; the number falls away into successive instants. I follow the problems he has to solve, and each successful movement makes the next one possible. The pleasure lies partly in this intelligibility. The years of practice are paying divident in the movement. He orders himself to remain calm, make the ego fade, and disregard number, victory, and loss.</p><p>I want him to survive; the men surrounding him want to survive too. The fight makes it much easier to follow one necessity rather than seventy. But Inoue has already interrupted the arithmetic with a pregnant wife, remembered teachers, and the possibility of life at cost of flight from battle. Those lives do not stop being lives, but they become difficult to keep equally present while I am watching for Musashi’s next opening. The attention that had admitted the spider and the stars now allows him to cut through bodies more efficiently. His absorption has a practical effect, and its direction is supplied by the task he has entered into. Nothing in the experience of concentration itself determines whether a task should be undertaken. Inoue does not expose Musashi’s insight as false. He shows that insight has no moral direction of its own. This is a problem more difficult than hypocrisy. Since the widening of his perception is real, the manga allows me to feel its beauty. Musashi escapes the noise of self-reflection while remaining in battle. A widened field of attention can receive a flower, hear a flute, or keep a lone fighter alive while he cuts through a group.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/526/1*7eWQqRVKmT5xv1iIeolXXQ.png" /><figcaption>Leaving the battlefield. A hand braces against the ground, and Musashi’s labored breaths punctuate the landscape through which he tries to walk. <strong>Source:</strong> Takehiko Inoue, Vagabond, vol. 27, chap. 242, VIZ English edition, adaptation by Yuji Oniki, lettering by Steve Dutro. © I.T. Planning.</figcaption></figure><p>The aftermath lingers longer than the battle. Men groan, plead, and call for sons; they sometimes try to strike once more. Musashi laughs and retches. He and the dying Ueda rest their heads together, imagining a rivalry that might have been amicable, a possibility that has become available to them only when it can no longer be lived. The ground is wet with the consequences of Musashi’s achievement. He tries to leave it but his leg fails.<a href="#note_28">28</a></p><p>His injured body will reach shelter through Matahachi’s efforts. This is the same friend whose inadequacy has been easy to recognize beside Musashi’s purpose. He finds a motionless figure in snow, checks for breath, and recognizes Takezō.<a href="#note_29">29</a> Otsū brings something resembling porridge. People tend his leg. Takuan asks Musashi to face the path behind him. Musashi’s attempts to remain upright fail. Later protection and nursing take place inside custody at Nijō Castle, where his fame has become an asset officials seek to recruit. Around the injured swordsman, people have different reasons for keeping him alive. Otsū’s presence carries a history that just the bowl of porridge cannot contain. At Yagyū, she had been caring for Sekishūsai; her music reached Musashi from a life already in progress, and his arrival brought danger into it. Now she is here again, with food he needs and desires of her own. There are two lives in the encounter, even when the story makes one of them occupy most of the page.<a href="#note_30">30</a></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*siOU2ud-XIovBUQEKzedAw.png" /><figcaption>Otsū’s care takes practical forms: <strong>A</strong>, raising rice towards the bound Takezō; <strong>B</strong>, pulling Musashi away from Sekishūsai’s door; <strong>C</strong>, offering dry clothes; and <strong>D</strong>, bringing potato porridge after the Yoshioka battle. <strong>Sources:</strong> Takehiko Inoue, <em>Vagabond</em>: A, vol. 2, ch. 18; B–C, vol. 10, ch. 97; D, vol. 28, ch. 250 © I.T. Planning.</figcaption></figure><p>Her strength has a different visibility from his. The bowl of porridge cannot be made spectacular in the way a successful katana strike can, although it can matter just as urgently to the body receiving it. To remain capable of affection towards this difficult man, and to act on that affection, takes resolve. It also leaves a question for him that being nursed cannot answer; what kind of life is he willing to share? Otsū’s wish for closeness is already there, but it is a claim on the future. Musashi still seems to be unable to meet her there, despite him being grateful.</p><p>Takuan’s care has institutional consequence. When another monk wants the killer of so many men out of the temple, Takuan argues that Buddhist shelter must include wrongdoers. Indeed, who needs it more? Below his untroubled face, the page returns to Musashi carving a piece of wood, injured and impatient.<a href="#note_31">31</a> The man for whom Takuan is speaking has not become agreeable, let alone innocent. I find something formidable in the monk’s willingness to keep this man within reach. His resolve has none of the forward rush of a challenge; rather it feels like the effort it takes to prevent a door from closing.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/544/1*MmAZY13cSiewV2O_INNsmw.png" /><figcaption>Takuan argues that the temple must shelter wrongdoers. Below the monks’ exchange, the wounded Musashi continues carving. <strong>Source:</strong> Takehiko Inoue, Vagabond, vol. 28, chap. 250, “An End to Fighting.” © I.T. Planning.</figcaption></figure><p>It would be too convenient to make Takuan the spokesman for a simple pacifism that the manga’s warriors have failed to understand. He urges Musashi away from killing, yet continues to deal with swordsmen and authorities within a world organized around their prestige. He is no stranger to severity. Musashi’s asylum that he defends does not erase anything, he knows this leaves the dead dead and their families bereaved; he has no forgiveness to distribute on their behalf. What he refuses is the further certainty that a man who has done terrible things can now be treated as if nothing else were possible for him. There is a Buddhist gravity here that is more important to me than an aura of serenity around the monk. The Mahāyāna aspiration to awaken for the benefit of other beings, including those that one might prefer to exclude from compassion, makes oneself answerable to suffering beyond one’s own.<a href="#note_32">32</a> I prefere to read Takuan’s intervention in that light. The demanding part happens at the temple door, where compassion has to decide whether this particular violent man can stay.</p><p>In confinement, the spiral of killing and death gather into a grotesque figure above Musashi, and he asks whether it is him. The question reaches towards responsibility. I want to be careful about what the darkness allows me to forgive. This immense, accusing presence cannot simply be attributed as the fear-demon’s job, as though the frightened boy’s suffering explains what the man has done. His dread was real; but so were the lives on which he acted.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/546/1*fv_rZXLMax8a19ADTznUWg.png" /><figcaption>A monstrous face looms above Musashi after the killings. <strong>Source:</strong> Takehiko Inoue, Vagabond, vol. 29, chap. 255. © I.T. Planning.</figcaption></figure><p>The only possibility I want to follow beyond the duels is that a life can grow around fear without requiring its utter disappearance first. It is important to remember that later, an orphaned child will be hungry and a field will need water. Those needs will have a claim on Musashi even when his old desires return.</p><p>Later on the road, Musashi meets Ittōsai, an older swordsman delighted by the prospect of testing the man who killed seventy men. The sword has not ceased to promise discovery; Musashi is still drawn to a fight that might demand everything he has. Yet when Ittōsai presses him, he calls invincibility a mirage, a word. What Sekishūsai once said to the bewildered young challenger now comes from Musashi himself. He no longer takes being stronger than everyone else as a sufficient account of what he is seeking. Inoue gives this declaration an almost ordinary posture; Musashi stands with his arms at his sides, his swords at his waist, while the old man appears below. Although badly hurt, the body has survived the ambition.</p><p>Ittōsai calls him a liar. Musashi says he has no reason to fight, but the older man attacks anyway. Their exchange causes Musashi’s sword to fall from his hand and wounds Ittōsai. We can’t let the clash cancel what Musashi has just understood, as if the threat-response of a trained body must always be more truthful than the words he has managed to find. The appetite is still there in him, hoping that another encounter will disclose something the previous ones could not. But wanting to enter that intensity is becoming separable from wanting a title to settle his worth. Ittōsai refuses to let the distinction stand untested; his attack also makes it harder to see what Musashi would choose without the demand.</p><p>Afterwards, Musashi traces the spiral that has kept him killing. The need to be known as the strongest feeds the fear of losing everything, and fear conceals itself in hatred. The chapter returns to Ittōsai standing over him after their clash, awarding points and declaring Kojirō stronger. Musashi lies with his eyes closed. The older man is still keeping score; Musashi has begun to question why must he.<a href="#note_33">33</a></p><p>There is a particular comfort in the idea that understanding a habit is the decisive event in changing it. Musashi has the formulation but still has to get through this encounter. His body, for the moment, makes the old way of proceeding impossible.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*kw-odi6R2Zt8575ZoWnZQg.png" /><figcaption>Ittōsai measures their encounter in points while Musashi lies beneath him, eyes closed. The older swordsman’s language of rank persists beside the body that has begun to question its value. <strong>Source:</strong> Takehiko Inoue, <em>Vagabond</em>, vol. 32, ch. 281 © I.T. Planning.</figcaption></figure><p>Matahachi’s road gives gives us another body to carry, one that may have been the first to detest Takezō’s ambition. Matahachi’s mother Osugi is dying. The woman who raised him has defended the Hon’iden name and sustained her hatred of Takezō with a stubbornness that makes the world easier to narrate; her son had been led astray, and the fault can keep a familiar face, Takezō’s. Matahachi has let her believe it. Her account protects him from one of humiliation while keeping him dependent on her mistake. Yet the manga also remembers the woman taking a child into her arms and devoting her life to him; the family name is tied to that chosen care, and pride has become entangled with the person she most wants to protect. As he carries her, he cannot separate the mother he loves from the judgments he knows are wrong.</p><p>When he says they have reached Miyamoto, Inoue lets us see the homecoming; the people, the welcome, Osugi’s relieved face. Then the forest returns. She is dead, and they had never arrived. Matahachi’s last lie has given her somewhere to return. Beside her afterwards, he admits the cost of the earlier lies, the truth about Takezō he never told her, the hatred he allowed her to carry. Even her dying tenderness has not quite released Takezō from that story. She can imagine Matahachi becoming the kindest person in the world while continuing to exclude Takezō from the same possibility. The scene leaves love and error so close that I cannot distinguish a clean boundary between them, and the tears do not provide one.<a href="#note_34">34</a></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/848/1*ko_C3r35RP3lobtVsZ7Vyg.png" /><figcaption>An imagined homecoming gives way to the forest. Matahachi has told Osugi they have reached Miyamoto; the following spread reveals that she has died before they could arrive. <strong>Source:</strong> Takehiko Inoue, Vagabond, vol. 31, chap. 274, “Mother.” © I.T. Planning.</figcaption></figure><p>Years pass to the growth of the tree at her grave. An older Matahachi interrupts his account because it still makes him cry. His listeners want Musashi and Kojirō; but he has brought them to his mother. He has become a teller with a crowd to please, money to collect, and a promise of more tomorrow. I am glad Inoue allows him that inconvenient duration. Musashi’s life has not swallowed his; the man who once borrowed another swordsman’s name now tells stories in which his own shame and affection take up time. It makes me reconsider how easily I would’ve rebuked his character. From where he is sitting, this is his life.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/544/1*Vzvm2_hxRSmB5Z2WYPtN0A.png" /><figcaption>Matahachi pauses, recounting his mother’s death still brings him to tears in front of his listeners. <strong>Source:</strong> Takehiko Inoue, Vagabond, vol. 31, chap. 275, “Liar.” © I.T. Planning.</figcaption></figure><h3>Water only obeys itself</h3><p>Above the field, there was the night sky. Musashi’s leg had given away; the sword’s outward movement seemed to turn back towards the body wielding it. Rain crossed his face. He fell beneath the stars, and the drawing allowed my eye to move away from him without making his bewilderment disappear. The night stars still kept the same distance. Everything by which he has measured his life can come apart while the sky continues at its own scale.<a href="#note_35">35</a></p><p>I recognized something in that disproportion. After Baba died, time kept passing into a future I had scarcely been able to imagine. A person could be gone from the world and remain necessary to the way I understood it. Looking with Musashi towards the stars, I could spend time with an arrangement in which an overwhelming feeling and vast indifference existed together, and neither perspective cancelled the other. My attention could travel outwards and return to him. Hurt would still be there. I think part of the page’s beauty lay in allowing that movement: there was somewhere for the eye to go while the difficult thought remained unfinished.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/534/1*-MFaqeudDBNmEZi26FE6dQ.png" /><figcaption>A face beside stars. The marked close-up and long field of night remain separate, held together by the page. <strong>Source:</strong> Takehiko Inoue, Vagabond, vol. 34, chap. 301. © I.T. Planning.</figcaption></figure><p>It happening to me as I turned thirty was mildly significant. That figure of age brings an expectation of becoming settled; but grief had opened a life that felt unfamiliar. Psychologists Clare Mehta and her colleagues call the years from thirty to forty-five “established adulthood,” describing the intersecting demands of work, partnership, and care in developed-country settings.<a href="#note_36">36</a> The phrase nevertheless captures the promise I had attached to the age, and the demands they describe to complicate that promise. Establishment can involve having more people to answer to, more that requires one’s attention, more that can be lost. The ordinary adult life is already permeable to other lives. Musashi’s difficulty is partly recognizable because he keeps trying to turn competence into an exemption from that exposure.</p><p>To call this reading phenomenological is, for me, to begin with the experience of spending time in the pages; the changing sense of distance, bodily excitement, and moments when an image seemes to leave room for a feeling I could not yet put into words. I went through its scenes, and some of them gave me ways to think that became useful later. The farming chapters are precious to me especially because their duration lets an understanding remain incomplete while life continues to ask something of the person who has to carry on living.</p><p>He thinks of Otsū, rises with a staff, and tries to attend to the leg. Soon on the road, he comes upon Iori, a child sharpening a sword beside his father’s corpse. The boy is considering cutting it into pieces he can carry beacuse he cannot move the body. Musashi stops him and bears the father to a grave. Only after the work is done, does the boy’s grief become visible to him.<a href="#note_37">37</a> The order is exact and difficult. Someone has to do the thing that cannot wait. Iori, in turn, feeds and shelters the exhausted man.</p><p>The child’s inheritance is a field in which very little grows. Musashi begins working it with a swordsman’s confidence in what repeated effort can accomplish. However, a storm ruins the work. Water disregards the channels he has made, although it also leaves fish to eat, a mixed response to his labor for which the dichotomous vocabulary of victory and defeat is not particularly useful. Later, he decides to leave but Iori asks him to stay. Musashi walks away anyway, stops at a tree, and returns. He evades the promise the child wants, but they walk towards the hut together and the direction acquires a name; home.<a href="#note_38">38</a> I find the return moving because he could have kept going; there was still a road on which the child and the field would become people and places he had once encountered. Instead, they are ahead of him again. But the interval might mean something different for Iori, who is already at home and has been asking whether this adult will remain there. Musashi gets to experience someone returning for the first time; but it is not for him, it is for Iori.</p><p>Before cultivating the field, Musashi had already been making things with his hands that did not required adversarial combat. He carves Buddha figures. On the night before the Inshun rematch, his fear troubles the face emerging from the wood. Inoue places his eyes above the fierce face, so that the question of what he has made also becomes a question of how he looks.<a href="#note_39">39</a> Whatever absorption brought the figure out, its expression will remain after his hands have done carving it.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/550/1*Gh9P_woC8VmtXi7Ug1hOwA.png" /><figcaption>The maker and the made face. Musashi’s intense eyes appear above the fierce expression of his own carving. <strong>Source:</strong> Takehiko Inoue, Vagabond, vol. 21, chap. 181, “Carving Demons,” VIZ English edition. © I.T. Planning.</figcaption></figure><p>On the road he encoutners gentler faces belonging to another sculptor. Musashi notices their softness and the life that seems to have entered the wood. I find myself imagining what it would mean to approach one while frightened, to bring the feeling close to a face that did not answer by becoming frightened too. Would its composure remain available when I could not imitate it? This is a different relation to an image from wanting to become the man in it. Someone has spent part of a life preparing an expression before which strangers might pause, ask, or pray. The sculptor speaks of wife, children, and carving, a life gathering around the desire that once expected to occupy the whole of it. A birth interrupts Musashi’s sword practice. The man’s account circles back to a centre instead of describing an ascending line.<a href="#note_40">40</a> Here I am drawn to the Buddhist possibility of an attention that loosens possession; the work may be exacting and deeply one’s own without existing chiefly to establish the maker’s exceptional self. That is the possibility I bring to this encounter. The softness Musashi recognises here differs from the fierce expressions we have seen him carve. The rice fields will ask what he can do with that recognition.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/538/1*V15hIxvXfXMndIaLCLRyjw.png" /><figcaption>Musashi among the carved faces. The composed expression above and the fierce one below give the wood more than one way of addressing its viewer. <strong>Source:</strong> Takehiko Inoue, Vagabond, vol. 33, chap. 293. © I.T. Planning.</figcaption></figure><p>The animals and small movements scattered through the manga prevent the swardsman’s life from becoming the only scale available. An ant appears beside a bloodied human face early in the manga. At Hōzōin, Agon swats a moth and In’ei objects to the unnecessary cruelty. Later it is Denshichirō imagining the eagle’s height and remembers that the ants still exist below, whether or not they remain visible from above.<a href="#note_41">41</a> These are not successive awards for Musashi’s improved consciousness. Other people look; other creatures go on living, and sometimes a human hand interrupts them. The manga’s attention keeps leaving its central man without treating his absence as empty space.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/546/1*2BqFTFwEEAthYw4WdEuMnw.png" /><figcaption>An eagle above, ants below. Denshichirō’s reflection moves between scales of life that cannot all remain visible from one position. <strong>Source:</strong> Takehiko Inoue, Vagabond, vol. 21, chap. 184, “Eagle and Ant,” VIZ English edition. © I.T. Planning.</figcaption></figure><p>I felt the vastness of <em>Vagabond</em> most strongly in these small departures. The natural world can remain indifferent, nourishing, or lethal; the crop will have insects as well as water. Still, there is a difference between searching every movement for what it might do to me and finding that something has held my attention without demanding defence. Musashi moves unevenly between those ways of seeing. Well, so does the reader who came looking for an invincible man.</p><p>Musashi works the field with the same intensity he has brought to everything, and when the work fails there he is always giving it more of himself. He already knows how to watch the natural world; terrain, darkness, weather and the movement of animals helped keep him alive long before any teacher would call him a pupil. The problem is that he keeps bringing this knowledge back to a contest. What he has learned to watch closely in order to survive may have to be watched differently if he is going to grow something in it.</p><p>At the waterfall, the pictures gives Musashi something to do with his whole body. In the page reproduced here, he is suspended beside the falling water, knees bent, feet clear of the pool, and his dark hair set against the white descent. Above him, a near circular image gathers curved plant forms into its small outline; below, water occupies a vertical expanse through which his body can pass. The change of scale gives the page a sudden appetite for movement.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/532/1*J7HeFQpqjCNP7YUEIbzgSw.png" /><figcaption>Water changes scale. A small suspended droplet is followed by a waterfall, with Musashi’s body airborne beside its descent. <strong>Source:</strong> Takehiko Inoue, Vagabond, vol. 35, chap. 305. © I.T. Planning.</figcaption></figure><p>Water falls, breaks into foam, and spreads across the pool. Its fluidity has pressure and direction. Musashi can cup it or enter it, but neither action settles its shape for very long, and Inoue allows this instability to become something the reader can follow through the drawing. What attracts me is the coexistence of force and a form that keeps changing. Musashi has spent much of his life trying to make his body answer danger with greater certainty. Here is something powerful whose outline is continually being revised. Later in the chapter, he can still return to the wish to defeat water. For these images, though, he is in motion with it.<a href="#note_42">42</a></p><p>I associate these pages with the Taoist images of living suppleness and water overcoming hardness. In the <em>Tao Te Ching</em>, the softness of living things is beside their capacity to endure; water can overcome what resists it.<a href="#note_43">43</a> What is important is the possibility of being changed without thinkinf of change as the destruction of self. Water had no investment in the previous outline. But I had an investment in mine, and some of it was love.</p><p>The image of grass bending through a storm is the one through which I remember this thought most readily. Its yielding has something active in it, a way of remaining alive through a pressure it cannot prevent. Musashi’s own formulation in the farming chapters places an unwavering spirit within movement and change. Earlier on the road, his practice makes the apparent contradiction physical; breath, the weight of the sword, bones and fingers, a falling dry leaf. He catches himself trying to do the movement well. Each repetition is to be encountered as if it were the first.<a href="#note_44">44</a></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/546/1*uJpcs0qqJB2pg2rphxvjow.png" /><figcaption>Every repetition asks for fresh attention. Musashi interrupts the demand to perform well while continuing the work of practice. <strong>Source:</strong> Takehiko Inoue, Vagabond, vol. 33, chap. 289. © I.T. Planning.</figcaption></figure><p>I have already talked about discipline as repeating something until the hand can do what it could not do before. These pages make me linger over what happens to the hand during the repetitions. The thousandth movement may become some record if one is seeking to make a case about oneself, or it can still require attention to this weight, this breath, the pressure of these fingers. Musashi imagines an empty infant’s hand; soon his own hand is sore, and he hears waves in his chest. Effort has not gone away. For a while, though, the person doing it doesn’t need to count every movement deciding what it proves.</p><p>Fear and desire may have kept drawing him towards an imagined outcome; but attention brings him back into contact with what his body is doing. He has to notice again, with a tired hand this time. A mind capable of staying with change will have to admit sensations that a rigid idea of composure might treat as interruptions. I find more to learn from this repeated, imperfect availability than from imagining calm as something one acquires and keeps perpetually.</p><p>There is, however, a danger in making bending an agreeable philosophy of living. Must rigid people now become impressively flexible? Accept loss beautifully, with a minimum of inconvenience to everybody else; soon you will be able to explain what it taught you. I can hear how close this is to the earlier promise. Master the response, and perhaps whatever happens can still be brought under control.</p><p>Baba’s death did not offer any such agreement. I had to move through the seasons without making the loss useful enough to justify it. His absence was not necessary for a wiser version of me to emerge. I could find a form of words broad enough to hold all losses. There were facts here that my capacity to describe them could not change. Water did not tell me what they were, but it did give me a way to imagine continuing despite those facts.</p><p>The manga brought the thought back to the field, where water’s behavior had a more immediate consequence. Musashi’s irrigation scheme drains away. The villagers who had joined the effort were hungry and exhausted. But Iori noticed a puddle that remained. Shūsaku, an old farmer, can explain the soil beneath the surface. Between a child looking at a small amount of water and a man who knows what keeps it there, the heroic undertaking is revised.<a href="#note_45">45</a> The puddle is almost offensively modest compared to Musashi’s effort. Having supplied persistence at a scale few people could ever match, he has to attend to a small amount of water near his feet and accept what Iori and Shūsaku tell him about it. Their observation is going to mean doing much of the work again, so there is no consolation in exemption from effort.</p><p>Meanwhile, the village cannot eat this potential understanding. To preserve the future, they have to consume part of what was supposed to produce it. Hunger occupies the pages through faces, bowls, steam, and the work of cooking and serving. Earlier, before this latest failure of irrigation, rice kept for planting has already become food. A future crop is spent on people who might not live to harvest it. This meal has none of the simplicity that pictures of people gathered around a table can lend to togetherness.<a href="#note_46">46</a> The work of preparing and serving food continues despite the difficulties faced by the men who draw much of our attention. For Musashi, learning to care here is the same as an urgent capacity to learn; those bowls required somebody to fill them regardless of effort. The villagers have crops to lose and children to feed whether he discovers anything or not.</p><p>Karla Elliott’s account of caring masculinities gives this labor an ethical weight that admiration alone cannot supply. Her framework joins care and interdependence to a rejection of domination; it asks more than whether a man has acquired warmer feelings.<a href="#note_47">47</a> Applied cautiously to these fictional lives, the question becomes practical. Can Musashi let someone else’s knowledge change the work? Can he persist without treating exhaustion as a failure of character? Can the people whose lives he wishes to improve tell him that his plan is wrong? The field gives those questions consequences. A sincere wish to help and an unusable channel can co-exist. The villagers need from him the capacity to be corrected. Inoue wrote, after finishing chapter 310, about the gratitude he had put into it and about wanting a manga that did not depend on shocks delivered in quick succession. He also refused to make that chapter an enclosure for everything that the work could still become.<a href="#note_48">48</a></p><p>Shūsaku contributes soil as well as knowledge. People bend together in the mud, and eventually, the water holds. Across the spread, the workers stand along the far bank, small between the sky and its reflection. Clouds extend into the foreground. The people have reflections too, their upright figures meeting inverted ones at the edge of a surface that previously would not form without water.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/936/1*cXU5_2efRqGN019YdW9SQQ.png" /><figcaption>Water held by a field. The landscape not only contains the workers but also the results of their shared efforts. <strong>Source:</strong> Takehiko Inoue, Vagabond, vol. 36, chap. 314. © I.T. Planning.</figcaption></figure><p>This spaciousness feels different from the white infinity at Yagyū. There, the figure stood amid an absence of drawn surroundings; here, the water reflects the world around it, holding clouds, trees, and the people who have worked to keep it there. I can linger over both images, but the field lets the pleasure of looking gather around a practical accomplishment. Something has finally worked. A child noticed the puddle; an older farmer understood the soil; the others returned to the labor. Their success deserves this expanse of page, even while it remains one necessary achievement in the longer work of growing food.<a href="#note_49">49</a></p><p>Winter makes the need more desperate and Iori has become feverish. Musashi carries him, warms him, and tries to gather what can be eaten. The carrying and the journeys test his endurance, as combat did, and for all the effort he can make, they still have too little food. He has no choice now but to ask for help.</p><p>The bow is the scene that changed the manga for me. Musashi has carried Iori, worked the ground, watched, failed, learned, and worked again. His endurance has mattered at every stage. Now he has to bring the village’s need before someone else’s pleasure. The body that has made so many other bodies yield lowers itself and begs. I find that gesture deeply moving. He has reached the limit of what he can provide and remains responsible to the people on the other side of his limits. Asking exposes the insufficiency of his efforts without making them worthless. Unlike a sword strike, he has to remain there long enough for the request to be heard, without the immediate certainty a successful movement once supplied.<a href="#note_50">50</a></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/936/1*trO-a2Jz5b_W2oJ7LXwsmg.png" /><figcaption>Musashi asks Nagaoka for food. Bows before a decision that his strength cannot make for other people. <strong>Source:</strong> Takehiko Inoue, Vagabond, vol. 37, chap. 316. © I.T. Planning.</figcaption></figure><p>Nagaoka’s aid has terms, binding Musashi towards a future service in Kokura. His name still gives him access to resources the villagers lack. The reputation he once wanted to complete himself with enters an arrangement that commits him beyond the moment of asking. Rank determines who has the resources to grant and who must petition for them. The aid allows them to continue towards a harvest. In the planting that follows, seeds are placed one at a time, and Musashi’s armed presence becomes an impediment, his swords are a distraction, and he is told to move away.<a href="#note_51">51</a></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/514/1*tA6luQPFTyT8sBo-TMz7vA.png" /><figcaption>Musashi plants rice alongside the villagers under Shūsaku’s exacting instructions. The accomplished swordsman becomes a beginner again. <strong>Source:</strong> Takehiko Inoue, <em>Vagabond</em>, vol. 37, chap. 318, “Rice Sprouts.” © I.T. Planning.</figcaption></figure><p>A third of the harvest is lost to disease and insects. After the work, the failed channels, the hunger, and the appeal for food, there is still no perfect crop with which to close the account. Shūsaku accepts what remains. He needs Musashi’s arm to stand, and the harvest gives them something to share. For a moment, the old farmer’s knowledge and the swordsman’s strength belong to the same small movement; one man helping another rise to look at what has grown. Shūsaku has been angry, insulting, and difficult to please but there is room for gratitude by and for the man we have spent these chapters getting to know.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/548/1*DwaFtcrw66bbHxDYbYKVxA.png" /><figcaption>Shūsaku at the harvest. Rice heads meet his profile; below, a dragonfly receives its own panel. <strong>Source:</strong> Takehiko Inoue, Vagabond, vol. 37, chap. 322. © I.T. Planning.</figcaption></figure><p>His death follows. There is a funeral, followed by a birth, and the seed is protected for another planting. Officials return, and the road to Kokura remains open.<a href="#note_52">52</a> The field we have watched them make will need work again. Shūsaku’s knowledge has helped other people learn what to do there.</p><p>This is where the farming chapters come closest to what has been significant to me while mourning Baba. A season can contain something worth sharing and the loss of someone with whom a life has been shared. Reading across the repetitions gives them both room; work gathers affection around it, irritation survives affection, and soon even a familiar task can become unfamiliar because somebody is missing. I can imagine continuing through that changed familiarity without having to decide what death has taught me. The seed preserved for another planting makes a modest demand on the future. There will always be work to return to and people who need it done.</p><h3>Beyond the open gate: One who is favoured by all swords</h3><p>The sword then returns to the road. In the chapters after the harvest, four armed men close in on Musashi, and he recognizes something of his former self in them. He lets them live with a blade at the neck of one man. His restraint still draws on his power to kill. Iori and their travelling companion Toyozaemon worry about provisions and the practicalities of travel, while Musashi has room to be unhurried. What has changed is only partial, distributed unevenly among the people walking with him.<a href="#note_53">53</a></p><p>Speaking of unhurriedness, Kojirō’s ease in company has a history, and that history includes an old swordsman who scarcely knew what to do with him. Kanemaki Jisai, who takes him in as an infant, must find someone who can feed the crying child. Other people around them nurse, advise, and help the retired swordsman; the boy’s survival needs exceeds the resources of his adoptive father. Jisai until now has thought little about caring for anyone, even his disciples. He tries throwing his sword into the sea and but immediately finds himself diving after it. When he returns for the child, he is armed and shouting. Then the baby touches him. A hand that has just reached for the sword’s hilt closes on his beard, and the stern, desperate face is caught in an exchange for which it has no practiced expressions. Kojirō smiles. Jisai stares back. He carries the child towards the shore while a woman calls after him to bring the boy whenever he needs milk. He promises never to look away from Kojirō again, with the sword still beside them.<a href="#note_54">54</a> There is an older man here being looked at in a way he has never been looked at before, and a small hand making contact with his face.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/542/1*dtN0zPd-wcd47Hw4-f6DTg.png" /><figcaption>The infant Kojirō touches Jisai’s beard. A swordsman’s alarm gives way to an exchange he has not rehearsed. <strong>Source:</strong> Takehiko Inoue, Vagabond, vol. 14, chap. 130, “Glimmering Waves,” VIZ English edition. © I.T. Planning.</figcaption></figure><p>These lives give the manga a breadth that its duels cannot measure. Osugi’s son carries her at the end; Jisai carries a child into a future he cannot know. Neither relationship is made safe by the strength of the feeling, and neither older person becomes free of pride or fear because care has found something for them to do. Yet the gestures remain. I can feel why a story might need to leave Musashi for so long: something is happening elsewhere that will lose its particular weight if it appeared only as a lesson waiting for him on the road.</p><p>Kojirō, meanwhile, has entered the Hosokawa household. Affection and administration keeps arriving almost simultaneously. Tadaoki, the lord of the household, embraces him; retainers consider his value and the also the difficulty of fitting him into a role. His movement attracts children, women and somebody could see a political use for their delight. When a writing lesson asks for controlled signs, his arm takes possession of a much larger surface beyond the designated paper.<a href="#note_55">55</a> I once wanted to call Kojirō innocent. He was loved; his pleasure in movement seemed less defensive; the twig and the snowman appeared to offer Musashi something his childhood couldn’t. But it is true that Kojirō kills too. At Sekigahara, the two young men had recognized one another in the middle of killing other people.<a href="#note_56">56</a></p><p>Chapter 327, the last chapter in the series, brings its narrative to a meal and a threshold. Kojirō sets bowls and dishes moving around the table. Tadaoki joins the play, and the retainers remain alarmed. Then, a bridge, a garden, and Yūsai appears receiving Musashi at Sanjō. On my screen, a swipe carries me from the crowded activity of the room into the quiet of an empty screen. There is somewhere to arrive, someone to meet him, but no next passage to enter.<a href="#note_57">57</a></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/936/1*xlytH3t1zzmdPdu8izm5lQ.png" /><figcaption><strong>Source:</strong> Takehiko Inoue, Vagabond, ch. 327. Montage of selected excerpts. © I.T. Planning.</figcaption></figure><p>I have no single feeling to place at the gate. Earlier Musashis gather there, along with all those departures and returns, Otsū’s food, Matahachi’s carrying, Jōtarō following him and Iori asking him to stay. Neither the historical Musashi nor the accounts of his famous duel can supplant Inoue’s absent pages. Here, at the edge of the available story, Musashi receives a warm welcome. I can remain with the small and simple generosity of the arrangement; after so much walking, someone will be there.</p><h3>A way of the sword without the sword</h3><p>I still find Musashi while scrolling through Pinterest; beneath the sky, in the water, and standing in a field. The panels retain their beauty and encourage me to keep going. Whenever he appears again, I remember the effort involved in getting from one part of that history to another. The encouragement comes partly from his determination and partly from me having stayed with him while the meaning of what strength means changed.</p><p>That discipline is important to me. There is pleasure in doing something difficult well, in returning until the hand can make a movement it previously could only attempt, and in discovering, through that effort, how much remains to be learned. I certainly want to preserve that appetite. Musashi brings it to the field, where he has to let a child and an old farmer change his understanding of the work. A way of the sword without the sword would carry something of that exactness into an ordinary life; the willingness to practice, to notice a mistake, and to remain interested after the first assurance of talent has worn away.</p><p>I think here of Yagyū Sekishūsai in his sickroom, lifting one hand as he says that his sword is “one with heaven and earth.” Inoue places Musashi’s dark, bent figure above the reclining man. Words might create an immense distance, but the drawings keep them within reach. Musashi feels crushed by the old man’s presence, wants to flee, and also wants to stay next to him. Whatever this mastery is, it has made him want company.<a href="#note_58">58</a></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/534/1*DcKaJUQYJ8CVX-oJPn3-FQ.png" /><figcaption>Sekishūsai raised his hand beneath Musashi’s looming silhouette. <strong>Source:</strong> Takehiko Inoue, Vagabond, vol. 11, chap. 101, “Blue Sky.” VIZ English edition, first printing May 2004; English adaptation by Yuji Oniki, touch-up and lettering by Steve Dutro. © I.T. Planning.</figcaption></figure><p>I hear something in that sentence that the promise of being unrivalled could never offer me. A skill might deepen my involvement in the world instead of becoming the place from which I fend it off. I want to be absorbed in work, to give it the patience it deserves, and still be able to return when somebody calls. Heaven and earth are large words to bring into an ordinary day; I can begin with the part of it deep concentration sometimes excludes. Being good at something should leave me more available to the life around it, with enough attention left to notice when that life needs something else from me.</p><p>Yet, it is a crowded manga to remember through one man’s silhouette. I want Otsū’s wish for a shared life to have a future. Matahachi survives to tell his story, still interrupted by his mother’s death; Takuan and In’ei remain difficult presences, capable of care and severity; Shūsaku is a particular old man whose absence the next planting will contain. Jisai’s astonishment before the infant belongs to his life as well as Kojirō’s, and Kojirō has his own pleasure in movement, which briefly meets Musashi’s in the snow. I have come to care about these people beyond what they can teach him. Their lives give the story places to go that his ambition alone could never have found.</p><p>That company reached this reader, too. During the nightly readings after Baba’s death, there was somewhere to bring an attention that the grief had altered. I could spend time with a field, with water, with two men playing, without having to explain what each scene was doing for me. Looking back, I can see the connections. The pages were beautiful, and I wanted to return. Their place in those nights still belongs to the life I continue to live.</p><p>I want Musashi’s perseverance to remain available to me when I have to go on alone. There may be work whose first uncertain attempts are mine to make, or stretches of a life through which nobody can accompany me in quite the way I would have wanted to. But his movement gives me courage. And I want room for company when it comes, for the interruption of somebody else’s interests, the pleasure of finding that the day has become shared. Closeness will ask me things that a picture of composure cannot rehearse. I am interested in the lives those demands might make possible.</p><p>For all the thoughts these pages have prompted, I want Musashi to be happy with the people who love him, and smile more. This wish survives the unfinished manga. Beyond the gate, I have no further scene to read; I have the life in which I first encountered him, and the part of it still ahead. The vagabond seems less like an exceptional kind of person from this perspective. I want to become good at things, to be kind, to remain capable of affection, and to keep walking when I cannot yet see how these wishes will fit together. I can carry that much away from the pages. I would welcome company along the way.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/568/1*vl9oQwrbhRvZrTwCANIcwg.png" /></figure><h3>Notes</h3><p><a href="#ref_1">1.</a> u/dakisaurus, “I did a funny,” r/vagabondmanga, May 5, 2024, <a href="https://www.reddit.com/r/vagabondmanga/comments/1cl3jeh/i_did_a_funny/">https://www.reddit.com/r/vagabondmanga/comments/1cl3jeh/i_did_a_funny/</a>. The post is a fan composite incorporating <em>Vagabond</em> and <em>Drive</em> (Nicolas Winding Refn, 2011).</p><p><a href="#ref_2">2.</a> <em>Slam Dunk</em>, episode 27, “I Want to Play Basketball,” Toei Animation, based on the manga by Takehiko Inoue. Official episode page: <a href="https://lineup.toei-anim.co.jp/ja/tv/movie_slumdunk/episode/27/">https://lineup.toei-anim.co.jp/ja/tv/movie_slumdunk/episode/27/</a>.</p><p><a href="#ref_3">3.</a> David Foster Wallace, “E Unibus Pluram: Television and U.S. Fiction,” in <em>The David Foster Wallace Reader</em> (Little, Brown, 2014), supplied electronic excerpt, PDF pp. 26–87, especially the closing discussion on PDF pp. 82–87. These are file-page locators, not pagination of the printed Reader. Wallace supplies a comparison concerning irony, spectatorship, and sincerity, not evidence of influence on Inoue.</p><p><a href="#ref_4">4.</a> Jonathan Cohen, “Defining Identification: A Theoretical Look at the Identification of Audiences with Media Characters,” <em>Mass Communication and Society</em> 4, no. 3 (2001): 245⁠-⁠64, <a href="https://doi.org/10.1207/S15327825MCS0403_01">https://doi.org/10.1207/S15327825MCS0403_01</a>.</p><p><a href="#ref_5">5.</a> Takehiko Inoue, <em>Vagabond</em>, vol. 2, chaps. 17 and 19. Childhood recollections also occur in vol. 1, chap. 3. The child’s wish and title occur in chapter 17; Munisai’s lethal test is in chapter 19.</p><p><a href="#ref_6">6.</a> Martin Holtz, “The Western as a Genre of Cultural Mobility,” <em>Humanities</em> 13, no. 1 (2024): article 7, <a href="https://doi.org/10.3390/h13010007">https://doi.org/10.3390/h13010007</a>; Lee Clark Mitchell, <em>Westerns: Making the Man in Fiction and Film</em> (University of Chicago Press, 1996).</p><p><a href="#ref_7">7.</a> Inoue, <em>Vagabond</em>, vol. 1, chaps. 1⁠-4.</p><p><a href="#ref_8">8.</a> Princeton University Art Museum, “Japan Timeline,” entries for the Momoyama and Tokugawa periods, <a href="https://static.artmuseum.princeton.edu/asian-art/japan/timeline">https://static.artmuseum.princeton.edu/asian-art/japan/timeline</a>.</p><p><a href="#ref_9">9.</a> Inoue, <em>Vagabond</em>, chap. 5. Okō’s thought follows the boys’ laughter and kill-counting. She observes them from outside their shared account of what the violence means.</p><p><a href="#ref_10">10.</a> R. W. Connell and James W. Messerschmidt, “Hegemonic Masculinity: Rethinking the Concept,” <em>Gender &amp; Society</em> 19, no. 6 (2005): 829⁠–⁠59, especially 832⁠–⁠38, <a href="https://doi.org/10.1177/0891243205278639">https://doi.org/10.1177/0891243205278639</a>.</p><p><a href="#ref_11">11.</a> Inoue, <em>Vagabond</em>, vol. 6, chaps. 55⁠–⁠57.</p><p><a href="#ref_12">12.</a> Inoue, <em>Vagabond</em>, vol. 1, chap. 7; vol. 2, chaps. 12 and 17⁠–⁠21; vol. 3, chap. 22. Takuan’s “weakest” rebuke precedes Takezō’s capture and returns in memory during the tree sequence. Otsū’s feeding attempt is in chapter 18.</p><p><a href="#ref_13">13.</a> Inoue, <em>Vagabond</em>, vol. 2, chap. 21, VIZ English edition.</p><p><a href="#ref_14">14.</a> Inoue, <em>Vagabond</em>, vol. 3, chaps. 22, 24, 26, and 29.</p><p><a href="#ref_15">15.</a> Inoue, <em>Vagabond</em>, vol. 4, chaps. 34⁠–⁠35 (San Francisco: Viz Comics, 2002), archive image leaves 065⁠–⁠068, 071⁠–⁠074, and 083⁠–⁠088. For Jōtarō’s early recognition, carrying Musashi to shelter, and the rebuffed apprenticeship, see chap. 32. Takuan calls responsibility for a child a form of training in chap. 34. Jōtarō’s circumstances, Musashi’s disclosure, and their shared resolve appear in chap. 36.</p><p><a href="#ref_16">16.</a> Inoue, <em>Vagabond</em>, vol. 5, chaps. 42⁠–⁠49. Musashi’s fear, bodily detail, and Inshun’s appetite for mortal danger appear across the encounter.</p><p><a href="#ref_17">17.</a> Linda Berube et al., “‘Moving with the Story’: The Haptics of Reader Experience and Response to Digital Comics,” <em>New Review of Hypermedia and Multimedia</em> 30, nos. 1⁠–⁠2 (2024): 94⁠–⁠113, <a href="https://doi.org/10.1080/13614568.2024.2374291">https://doi.org/10.1080/13614568.2024.2374291</a>.</p><p><a href="#ref_18">18.</a> Inoue, <em>Vagabond</em>, vol. 5, chap. 46. The narration’s references to humans and to us permit a shared-human reading of fear.</p><p><a href="#ref_19">19.</a> Inoue, <em>Vagabond</em>, vol. 6, chaps. 50⁠–⁠52; the quoted confession is in chapter 52.</p><p><a href="#ref_20">20.</a> Inoue, <em>Vagabond</em>, vol. 7, chaps. 63⁠–⁠65; vol. 8, chaps. 70⁠–⁠76.</p><p><a href="#ref_21">21.</a> Inoue, <em>Vagabond</em>, vol. 9, chaps. 81⁠–⁠84.</p><p><a href="#ref_22">22.</a> Inoue, <em>Vagabond</em>, vol. 10, chaps. 89⁠-97, especially 94⁠–⁠97.</p><p><a href="#ref_23">23.</a> Inoue, <em>Vagabond</em>, vol. 11, chaps. 98⁠-⁠102; vol. 12, chap. 109. The quoted question is in chapter 102, in a sequence associated with Sekishūsai’s remembered teaching and Musashi’s changing perception.</p><p><a href="#ref_24">24.</a> Inoue, <em>Vagabond</em>, vol. 21, chaps. 180, 182, and 185–188; vol. 22, chap. 189. Volume 21 depicts Musashi’s altered bearing, Seijūrō considering his possible death and imagining his brother’s pain, and Musashi describing combat’s relief from anxiety. Volume 22 depicts the Yoshioka faces and the fatal diversion of Seijūrō’s attention. Fear as attachment is an interpretation of this sequence.</p><p><a href="#ref_25">25.</a> Inoue, <em>Vagabond</em>, vol. 24, chaps. 208⁠–⁠212, especially the twig exchange in chapters 208⁠–⁠209 and the cheek-tug in chapter 212.</p><p><a href="#ref_26">26.</a> Inoue, <em>Vagabond</em>, vol. 25, chap. 224, and vol. 26, chap. 225. The meal and kindness remark occur in chapter 224; the following chapter confirms Musashi’s return.</p><p><a href="#ref_27">27.</a> Inoue, <em>Vagabond</em>, vols. 25⁠–⁠26, Yoshioka battle sequence; especially chap. 227.</p><p><a href="#ref_28">28.</a> Inoue, <em>Vagabond</em>, vol. 27, chaps. 239⁠–⁠242, especially chapter 242.</p><p><a href="#ref_29">29.</a> Inoue, <em>Vagabond</em>, vol. 28, chap. 244. The rescue is shown retrospectively.</p><p><a href="#ref_30">30.</a> Inoue, <em>Vagabond</em>, vols. 28⁠–⁠29, post-battle convalescence, especially chaps. 250⁠–⁠252. On care as requiring more than the receipt of warmth or an isolated caring act, see Steven Roberts and Riikka Prattes, “Caring Masculinities in Theory and Practice: Reiterating the Relevance and Clarifying the Capaciousness of the Concept,” <em>Sociological Research Online</em> 29, no. 3 (2024): 767⁠–⁠77, <a href="https://doi.org/10.1177/13607804231205978">https://doi.org/10.1177/13607804231205978</a>.</p><p><a href="#ref_31">31.</a> Inoue, <em>Vagabond</em>, vol. 28, chap. 250, “An End to Fighting,” Takuan argues for sheltering wrongdoers at the temple.</p><p><a href="#ref_32">32.</a> Dalai Lama, “Section Three: August 21st AM,” in “Commentary on Chapter 8 of Shantideva’s Bodhicaryavatara,” teachings in Bloomington, Indiana, August 21, 1999, Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive, <a href="https://www.lamayeshe.com/article/chapter/section-three-august-21st-am.">https://www.lamayeshe.com/article/chapter/section-three-august-21st-am.</a> The teaching describes bodhicitta as aspiration to awakening for all beings and discusses extending compassion beyond friends to perceived enemies. The Tao Te Ching comparison later in the essay remains a distinct philosophical resemblance.</p><p><a href="#ref_33">33.</a> Inoue, <em>Vagabond</em>, vols. 29–32, especially chaps. 255, 276, 279–281, and 284. Musashi’s rejection of invincibility and comparative rank appears in chap. 279; his refusal to fight and Ittōsai’s attack follow in chap. 280.</p><p><a href="#ref_34">34.</a> Inoue, <em>Vagabond</em>, vol. 31, chaps. 272–275. Ch. 273 depicts Osugi taking in and raising Matahachi; she is his mother through adoption. Ch. 274 moves from her counsel and imagined homecoming to death in the forest. Ch. 275 contains his confession; passing years through tree growth, and the older storyteller.</p><p><a href="#ref_35">35.</a> Inoue, <em>Vagabond</em>, vol. 34, chap. 301.</p><p><a href="#ref_36">36.</a> Clare M. Mehta, Jeffrey Jensen Arnett, Carlie G. Palmer, and Larry J. Nelson, “Established Adulthood: A New Conception of Ages 30 to 45,” <em>American Psychologist</em> 75, no. 4 (2020): 431⁠–⁠44, <a href="https://doi.org/10.1037/amp0000600">https://doi.org/10.1037/amp0000600</a>. The limited description here draws on the published abstract, <a href="https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32378940/">https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32378940/</a>.</p><p><a href="#ref_37">37.</a> Inoue, <em>Vagabond</em>, vol. 34, chap. 302.</p><p><a href="#ref_38">38.</a> Inoue, <em>Vagabond</em>, vol. 34, chap. 303.</p><p><a href="#ref_39">39.</a> Inoue, <em>Vagabond</em>, vol. 7, chap. 61; vol. 21, chap. 181, “Carving Demons,” ; vol. 33, chap. 293.</p><p><a href="#ref_40">40.</a> Inoue, <em>Vagabond</em>, vol. 33, chaps. 291 and 293.</p><p><a href="#ref_41">41.</a> Inoue, <em>Vagabond</em>, vol. 2, chap. 14, ; vol. 7, chap. 64; vol. 21, chap. 184, ; vol. 33, chap. 289.</p><p><a href="#ref_42">42.</a> Inoue, <em>Vagabond</em>, vol. 35, chap. 305. Musashi returns to the language of defeating water later in the same chapter.</p><p><a href="#ref_43">43.</a> Laozi, <em>Tao Te Ching</em>, trans. James Legge, chaps. 76 and 78, Chinese Text Project, <a href="https://ctext.org/dao-de-jing/zhs">https://ctext.org/dao-de-jing/zhs</a>. The comparison concerns suppleness and water overcoming hardness.</p><p><a href="#ref_44">44.</a> Inoue, <em>Vagabond</em>, vol. 33, chap. 289; vol. 36, chap. 311.</p><p><a href="#ref_45">45.</a> Inoue, <em>Vagabond</em>, vol. 36, chap. 312.</p><p><a href="#ref_46">46.</a> Inoue, <em>Vagabond</em>, vol. 36, chap. 310. The later discussion of the failed irrigation returns to chapter 312; this paragraph looks back to the meal as an example of the village’s continuing need.</p><p><a href="#ref_47">47.</a> Karla Elliott, “Caring Masculinities: Theorizing an Emerging Concept,” <em>Men and Masculinities</em> 19, no. 3 (2016): 240⁠–⁠59, <a href="https://doi.org/10.1177/1097184X15576203">https://doi.org/10.1177/1097184X15576203</a>. The discussion uses the framework’s broad commitments to care, interdependence, and rejection of domination.</p><p><a href="#ref_48">48.</a> Takehiko Inoue, “Vagabond 2K13,” January 17, 2013, <a href="https://itplanning.co.jp/en/inoue/i130117-2/">https://itplanning.co.jp/en/inoue/i130117-2/</a>.</p><p><a href="#ref_49">49.</a> Inoue, <em>Vagabond</em>, vol. 36, chap. 314. The water-holding paddy and dawn precede the winter need and petition in chapters 315⁠–⁠316.</p><p><a href="#ref_50">50.</a> Inoue, <em>Vagabond</em>, vol. 36, chap. 315, and vol. 37, chap. 316.</p><p><a href="#ref_51">51.</a> Inoue, <em>Vagabond</em>, vol. 37, chap. 317.</p><p><a href="#ref_52">52.</a> Inoue, <em>Vagabond</em>, vol. 37, chap. 322.</p><p><a href="#ref_53">53.</a> Inoue, <em>Vagabond</em>, chap. 323.</p><p><a href="#ref_54">54.</a> Inoue, <em>Vagabond</em>, vol. 14, chap. 130, “Glimmering Waves,” VIZ English. Jisai’s recognition of care, his armed demand for the child, the child’s touch, and the community’s continued offer of milk all belong to the same sequence.</p><p><a href="#ref_55">55.</a> Inoue, <em>Vagabond</em>, chaps. 324⁠–⁠326.</p><p><a href="#ref_56">56.</a> Inoue, <em>Vagabond</em>, vol. 18, chap. 162; vol. 24, chaps. 208⁠–⁠212. The larger Kojirō sequence in vols. 14⁠–⁠20 complicates the innocence projected onto him by other characters.</p><p><a href="#ref_57">57.</a> Inoue, <em>Vagabond</em>, chap. 327. Chapter 327 is the endpoint of the reading discussed here. The <em>LAST Manga Exhibition</em> is a separate work and is not used to supply a conclusion to the serial.</p><p><a href="#ref_58">58.</a> Inoue, <em>Vagabond</em>, vol. 11, chap. 101, “Blue Sky,” VIZ English edition, first printing May 2004, English adaptation by Yuji Oniki, touch-up and lettering by Steve Dutro.</p><h3>Bibliography</h3><p>Berube, Linda, Ernesto Priego, Stella Wisdom, Ian Cooke, and Stephann Makri. “‘Moving with the Story’: The Haptics of Reader Experience and Response to Digital Comics.” <em>New Review of Hypermedia and Multimedia</em> 30, nos. 1⁠–⁠2 (2024): 94⁠–⁠113. <a href="https://doi.org/10.1080/13614568.2024.2374291">https://doi.org/10.1080/13614568.2024.2374291</a>.</p><p>Cohen, Jonathan. “Defining Identification: A Theoretical Look at the Identification of Audiences with Media Characters.” <em>Mass Communication and Society</em> 4, no. 3 (2001): 245⁠–⁠64. <a href="https://doi.org/10.1207/S15327825MCS0403_01">https://doi.org/10.1207/S15327825MCS0403_01</a>.</p><p>Connell, R. W., and James W. Messerschmidt. “Hegemonic Masculinity: Rethinking the Concept.” <em>Gender &amp; Society</em> 19, no. 6 (2005): 829⁠–⁠59. <a href="https://doi.org/10.1177/0891243205278639">https://doi.org/10.1177/0891243205278639</a>.</p><p>Dalai Lama. “Section Three: August 21st AM.” In “Commentary on Chapter 8 of Shantideva’s Bodhicaryavatara.” Bloomington, Indiana, August 21, 1999. Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive. <a href="https://www.lamayeshe.com/article/chapter/section-three-august-21st-am.">https://www.lamayeshe.com/article/chapter/section-three-august-21st-am.</a></p><p>Elliott, Karla. “Caring Masculinities: Theorizing an Emerging Concept.” <em>Men and Masculinities</em> 19, no. 3 (2016): 240⁠–⁠59. <a href="https://doi.org/10.1177/1097184X15576203">https://doi.org/10.1177/1097184X15576203</a>.</p><p>Holtz, Martin. “The Western as a Genre of Cultural Mobility.” <em>Humanities</em> 13, no. 1 (2024): article 7. <a href="https://doi.org/10.3390/h13010007">https://doi.org/10.3390/h13010007</a>.</p><p>Inoue, Takehiko. <em>Vagabond</em>. Vols. 1⁠–⁠27. VIZ English editions, adaptation by Yuji Oniki; lettering credits vary by volume. Cited by volume and chapter.</p><p>Inoue, Takehiko. <em>Vagabond</em>. Vols. 28⁠–⁠37 and uncollected chaps. 323⁠–⁠327. English scanlations.</p><p>Inoue, Takehiko. “Vagabond 2K13.” January 17, 2013. <a href="https://itplanning.co.jp/en/inoue/i130117-2/">https://itplanning.co.jp/en/inoue/i130117-2/</a>.</p><p>Kurosawa, Akira, director. <em>Yojimbo</em>. Toho, 1961. Film.</p><p>Laozi. <em>Tao Te Ching</em>. Translated by James Legge. Chapters 76 and 78. Chinese Text Project. <a href="https://ctext.org/dao-de-jing/zhs">https://ctext.org/dao-de-jing/zhs</a>.</p><p>Leone, Sergio, director. <em>A Fistful of Dollars</em>. 1964. Film.</p><p>Mehta, Clare M., Jeffrey Jensen Arnett, Carlie G. Palmer, and Larry J. Nelson. “Established Adulthood: A New Conception of Ages 30 to 45.” <em>American Psychologist</em> 75, no. 4 (2020): 431⁠–⁠44. <a href="https://doi.org/10.1037/amp0000600">https://doi.org/10.1037/amp0000600</a>.</p><p>Mitchell, Lee Clark. <em>Westerns: Making the Man in Fiction and Film</em>. University of Chicago Press, 1996.</p><p>Princeton University Art Museum. “Japan Timeline.” <a href="https://static.artmuseum.princeton.edu/asian-art/japan/timeline">https://static.artmuseum.princeton.edu/asian-art/japan/timeline</a>.</p><p>Refn, Nicolas Winding, director. <em>Drive</em>. FilmDistrict, 2011. Film.</p><p>Roberts, Steven, and Riikka Prattes. “Caring Masculinities in Theory and Practice: Reiterating the Relevance and Clarifying the Capaciousness of the Concept.” <em>Sociological Research Online</em> 29, no. 3 (2024): 767⁠–⁠77. <a href="https://doi.org/10.1177/13607804231205978">https://doi.org/10.1177/13607804231205978</a>.</p><p>Toei Animation. <em>Slam Dunk</em>. Episode 27, “I Want to Play Basketball.” Based on the manga by Takehiko Inoue. Official episode page. <a href="https://lineup.toei-anim.co.jp/ja/tv/movie_slumdunk/episode/27/">https://lineup.toei-anim.co.jp/ja/tv/movie_slumdunk/episode/27/</a>.</p><p>u/dakisaurus. “I did a funny.” Reddit, r/vagabondmanga, May 5, 2024. Fan composite. <a href="https://www.reddit.com/r/vagabondmanga/comments/1cl3jeh/i_did_a_funny/">https://www.reddit.com/r/vagabondmanga/comments/1cl3jeh/i_did_a_funny/</a>.</p><p>Villeneuve, Denis, director. <em>Blade Runner 2049</em>. Warner Bros. Pictures and Sony Pictures, 2017. Film.​</p><p>Wallace, David Foster. “E Unibus Pluram: Television and U.S. Fiction.” In <em>The David Foster Wallace Reader</em>. Little, Brown, 2014. pp. 26–87.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2d1a95cde077" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Great Responsibility of Spider-Man at the Movies]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@satyangavaneesh/the-great-responsibility-of-spider-man-at-the-movies-afdc036f2209?source=rss-2a5af0491dad------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/afdc036f2209</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[personal-essay]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[metamodernism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[pop-culture]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[spider-man]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Avaneesh Satyang]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 03 Aug 2026 19:17:32 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-08-03T19:18:16.016Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>On repetition, franchise machinery, and the possibility of sincerity after irony.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*d9yVJjs1H0J-t1t97BFIxA.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>Spoiler warning:</strong> This essay discusses major plot developments across the <em>Spider-Man</em> films, including <em>Brand New Day</em>.</p><p>I once assumed that learning how stories were made would make them seem smaller. A hero seen first in childhood could later be separated into genre convention, ideology, studio ownership, market segmentation, canon, nostalgia, and intellectual property; after that, belief would presumably become impossible. The trick named is the trick disarmed. Or so I thought. Surely, an adult who can see the wires and harness should no longer be astonished by the web slinging.</p><p>What remains of my first encounter with Spider-Man is difficult to separate from the kind of exhilaration only childhood permits. I remember Peter stitching together his own suit in a cramped bedroom with the seriousness of someone building himself anew. I remember the first awkward discoveries of a body that no longer obeyed ordinary rules; the accidental adhesion to walls, the impossible leaps across rooftops, the delighted confusion of becoming something other than what you were yesterday. For a boy who was clever and kind but unnoticed and awkward, occupied that familiar social space between invisibility and ridicule, the transformation felt almost miraculous. Spider-Man seemed to promise that somewhere beneath every ordinary life waited another one, if only chance would find you first.</p><p>Yet memory has a curious way of sanding away spectacle while preserving just the feeling. Long after the web-swinging, the Green Goblin and the soaring New York skyline had blurred together, one sensation remained unexpectedly clear: Peter Parker was always tired. Beneath the mask was a young man perpetually running out of time, money and himself. Growing up middle class in a small town in India, New York seemed to me as an arrangement of impossible surfaces of glass towers, fire escapes, yellow taxis, and sirens; but Peter’s exhaustion crossed that distance more easily than the impressive New York skyline ever did. Money could become an atmosphere inside a home. Adults could turn grocery bills, school fees, transport and an unexpected repair into silent arithmetic. A young man could love his family completely and still disappoint them, because love could never manufacture another hour in the day. The revelation of Sam Raimi’s Spider-Man was therefore that climbing walls did not exempt him from rent. The extraordinary gift of superpowers enlarges the radius of duty while leaving the length of the day unchanged. The mask multiplies the number of people who can make a claim upon him, both behind the screen and in front of it.</p><p>Years later, I learned to see the superhero as modern myth, the film as industrial product, the shared universe as risk management, and nostalgia as an asset activated on opening weekend. Casting announcements at Comic Con Hall H acquire the suspense once reserved for plots. We know why an old face has returned before the character has said a word. But astonishingly, this knowledge has never made Spider-Man smaller. What does it mean to believe in a hero after we have learned to see the machinery that manufactures him?</p><p>I went into <em>Spider-Man: Brand New Day</em> with that machinery very much in view. I came out immensely hopeful. Not because the Disney MCU machinery has disappeared, but because the film understood that sincerity after disenchantment cannot mean becoming innocent again. It must mean risking feeling and being emotionally sincere with one’s disillusion intact.</p><p>Cinema will always need Spider-Man despite his story being repeated one too many times to pretend originality. An IP asset too commercially valuable to pretend purity, and an idea too entangled in our private histories to be dismissed as only a product. But beneath all that accumulation remains a moral problem whose answer cannot be copyrighted: what does an ordinary person owe to others once he possesses an unusual power to help them? Every era must translate that problem into its own cultural language. A new sincerity begins when a film can acknowledge the previous versions, the market calculation and the possibility of failure, and still ask the question as though our answer matters.</p><p><strong>The Rent Is Due</strong></p><p>Raimi’s trilogy is often remembered as an artefact of a more earnest blockbuster age, but that description conflates sincerity with innocence. The Raimi films are full of gargoyles, wet funerals, swelling music and villains who seem to have wandered out of tragic opera by way of a horror comic. Their feelings are enormous, and the films are not embarrassed by the enormity. Surely a bit camp, but they do not stand outside their emotions and smirk.</p><p>Cross for being underpaid after beating Macho Man Randy Savage as the Bone Crusher (thanks Raimi for not breaking the kayfabe then), Peter’s refusal to stop the thief is selfish, but Uncle Ben’s subsequent death is not a tidy equation in which one omitted action mechanically produces one deserved punishment. Philip Tallon, writing in <a href="https://www.wiley.com/en-us/Spider-Man%2Band%2BPhilosophy%3A%2BThe%2BWeb%2Bof%2BInquiry-p-x000516005"><em>Spider-Man and Philosophy</em></a>, distinguishes culpability from what Bernard Williams called agent-regret: the first-person responsibility we may feel for damage in whose causal history we participated, even when we neither intended nor fully caused it. Peter is guilty of letting the thief pass but he is not guilty of murder. What binds him to Ben’s death is the knowledge that he could have acted differently, and that the world after his inaction cannot be repaired.</p><p>“With great power comes great responsibility” has been polished by repetition into something perilously close to branding. But in Raimi’s first film, it is still a wound. Peter cannot resurrect Ben, so he gives the loss a future by refusing to repeat the choice. His heroism is the form his regret takes when resolution of grief is impossible. The trilogy then crushingly refuses to let that awakening float above material life. Peter delivers pizzas, sells photographs of his own alter ego, misses classes, disappoints Mary Jane, worries about Aunt May, loses jobs and hears Mr Ditkovich ask for the rent with the regularity of a curse. <em>Spider-Man 2</em> understands that obligations do not become compatible merely because each is righteous. A stranger in danger, an aunt facing foreclosure, a professor expecting work and a city asking to be saved may all have legitimate claims; together they can make a life unliveable. Another chapter in <em>Spider-Man and Philosophy</em> describes Peter’s responsibility as a nearly unlimited responsiveness to whoever calls, which is precisely why he is always late.</p><p>Then comes the Doc Ock fight that spills onto the train. Peter stops it with his body. The webs stretch until they tear; suit ripped; the mask comes off; his face loses every trace of heroic composure as he succeeds in saving the train and collapses. The passengers catch him, lift him above their heads and carry him through the carriage. A child returns his mask. Having seen the secret, they agree to protect it, “he is just a kid”. When Doctor Octopus comes for him, ordinary people place themselves between the unconscious hero and a machine they cannot defeat. The scene interrupts the fantasy of the exceptional individual with reciprocity. Spider-Man saves the train and then the train carries Peter Parker. The city seizes to be a passive mass, for one brief passage, it becomes capable of care. “Friendly neighbourhood” ceases to be a scale of operation and becomes a relationship.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*xChRkcFz43tCzB0aw-6oxQ.jpeg" /></figure><p><a href="https://books.google.com/books/about/Super_Heroes.html?id=Rrx-5cn1F8oC">Richard Reynolds’s account of superheroes as modern mythology</a> identifies the contrast between extraordinary power and mundane surroundings as one of the genre’s basic structures. Raimi presses on it until it hurts: the body that can stop a train still has to hurry to class. <a href="https://www.jstor.org/stable/464920">Umberto Eco’s account of the serial superhero</a> supplies another tension. The mythic hero must remain recognisable, while the hero of a continuing narrative must act, accumulate a past and move toward exhaustion. Every action “consumes” him. Raimi lets us feel that consumption in Peter’s face.</p><p>None of this makes the trilogy politically pure. Its New York is sentimental, sacrifice can become a masculine compulsion toward self-erasure, and women are too often made witnesses to male moral development. Still, the films allow Peter to cry, fail and plead without sending in a joke to protect us from discomfort.</p><p><strong>The Wound the Franchise Left Open</strong></p><p>Andrew Garfield’s films belong to the interval in which emotional protection was becoming customary. His Peter is wounded, and he has learned to wear the wound well: the skateboard, the hair, the lowered voice, the studied casualness of a body that knows how it looks while leaning against a wall. Alienation in the 2010s had become a performance, and Garfield performs it beautifully. The awkward boy has become legible as cool before he has become legible as heroic. He still stands outside the social order, though now with enough charisma to make exclusion resemble a style.</p><p>There is a noted change to the fantasy of transformation. While Tobey Maguire’s Peter seems almost astonished to inhabit his own body after the bite; Garfield’s Peter appears to discover a body that was waiting to become expressive. His Spider-Man moves with a dancer’s pleasure, folding, twisting, taunting, finding in the mask a fluency Peter lacks in ordinary life. The quips arise from that fluency. They are sometimes cruel, sometimes defensive, often exhilarating. Humour becomes a way of controlling the encounter before the encounter can expose him. The mask gives him confidence, though it also gives his anger somewhere to go.</p><p>The films are at their most emotionally convincing when Gwen interrupts that performance. Garfield and Emma Stone’s chemistry make intimacy feel improvised rather than announced. Their silences, unfinished sentences, touches and retreats have the nervous rhythm of two people trying to remain truthful while already anticipating impending loss. Peter’s promise to Captain Stacy becomes especially important here. He breaks it because love feels more immediate than fear, then discovers that responsibility cannot be confined to a single decision made in grief. Gwen’s death is devastating partly because Garfield allows Peter’s physical confidence to vanish at once. The body that had seemed endlessly agile reaches her too late.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/735/1*OTht7KgRbfu_wmXcl5sChA.jpeg" /></figure><p>Gwen Stacy’s valedictorian speech is the emotional anchor of <em>The Amazing Spider-Man 2</em>. It foreshadows her death and gives Peter the strength to overcome his subsequent depression. Peter spends five months listening to this recorded speech while mourning. Aunt May gives a beautiful, poetic perspective on grief and moving forward while packing away Uncle Ben’s clothes. When Peter catches her packing, he initially thinks she is erasing his memory, but she explains the paradox of processing loss. Healing involves transitioning your love for the person you lost from a source of active trauma to a permanent, cherished place in your heart.</p><p>That grief follows him into <em>No Way Home</em>, where the franchise finally gives his Peter the emotional aftermath his own series had left suspended. He still carries immense survivor’s guilt. When meeting the other Spider-Men, he describes himself as “Peter #3” and displays low self-worth, masking his deep-seated depression with anxious, self-deprecating humor. The emotional catharsis for Garfield’s character occurs when Tom Holland’s MJ falls from a scaffolding. Peter #3 dives after her, catching her using the exact same web-drop technique that failed to save Gwen. This time, he holds her close to his chest to absorb the impact, ensuring her head and spine are safe. When he catches MJ, the scene works through recognition, though Garfield’s face prevents recognition from exhausting it. He saves another Peter from inheriting his worst memory, and for a moment the old failure changes without being erased. The scene is openly engineered around audience knowledge. Garfield plays the rescue as an involuntary return of grief rather than a triumphant correction.</p><p>The instability of the films around him also belongs to the story. Villains arrive carrying future instalments; mysteries are planted for continuities that never mature; emotional scenes must share space with the visible anxiety of franchise construction. Peter Parker’s attempt to come to terms with Aunt May’s advice and overcome the immediate pain of Gwen’s passing reflects the tumultuous situation occurring off-screen. The sequel’s emotional core was initially disrupted by the burden of constructing an overly complex cinematic universe. This structural instability culminated in the <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2014_Sony_Pictures_hack">2014 Sony Pictures Hack</a>, a massive corporate cyberattack that leaked private emails, exposed immense behind-the-scenes politics, and fundamentally shook the studio’s confidence. Executives decided to completely abandon the franchise due to industrial panic and financial disappointment, instead of allowing Peter’s narrative wounds to heal naturally with a planned third film. Garfield’s Peter therefore becomes strangely representative of the films themselves: searching for intimacy inside a machinery already looking beyond the present moment. His performance keeps reaching for a human centre while the franchise keeps dispersing its attention.</p><p>This Peter’s sincerity is apparent once style, irony and self-consciousness have become part of the emotional vocabulary. His feelings remain direct, though they rarely arrive undefended. He carries pain with a knowing smile.</p><p><strong>The Neighbourhood Joins the Universe</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*hOoHL_4iKKnqRDgB1rb3cQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>Tom Holland’s Peter enters cinema through another hero’s conflict not through his own origin story. Tony Stark recruits him into their <em>Civil War</em>; Peter records the experience on his phone, narrating his astonishment at being admitted behind the curtain. This Spider-Man’s first desire is not simply to help his neighbourhood. It is to be noticed by the people already authorised to save the world.</p><p>In<em> Homecoming</em>, Tony gives Peter a suit filled with modes, surveillance systems and an artificial intelligence. Raimi’s Peter sells images of himself to survive while Holland’s Peter is handed a weapons platform by a billionaire. Queens remains a modest backdrop, Adrian Toomes is a contractor displaced when Damage Control absorbs the work of cleaning up superhero destruction, but the structure of aspiration has changed. Peter too looks upward toward institutional membership in the grand scale of things Marvel’s cinematic universe.</p><p>The film permits him to refuse the Avengers. In the rubble scene, where Tony is absent, the expensive suit is confiscated, and Peter must lift himself out while his frightened face is reflected beneath the mask. Without alluding that technology produces heroism,<em> Homecoming</em> allows Peter to discover that he was already morally answerable before he was institutionally recognised. Yet Tony’s shadow remains the trilogy’s horizon. Even after his death, <em>Far From Home</em> gives Peter E.D.I.T.H., a planetary surveillance and drone system as Stark’s inheritance. The neighbourhood hero has now been incorporated into a global heroic order. His anxiety is no longer limited to the person in front of him, the stakes dictate that he may be unworthy of the system that selected him.</p><p><a href="https://nyupress.org/9780814742815/convergence-culture/">Henry Jenkins’s <em>Convergence Culture</em></a> helps explain what happened around Peter as much as what happened to him. The MCU trained viewers to derive pleasure from relations among narratives: recognising an object, predicting an arrival, remembering an earlier line, staying through the credits, and assembling fragments into a personal map. Jenkins is careful, in his later <a href="https://henryjenkins.org/blog/2011/08/defining_transmedia_further_re.html">clarification of transmedia storytelling</a>, not to confuse every franchise with transmedia. A story extended by another medium differs from a brand reproduced across platforms. Much of the MCU’s power lies instead in seriality, radical intertextuality and additive comprehension, essentially a promise that each connection changes the whole.</p><p>I learned willingly that this altered spectatorship is not false pleasure. For someone whose early access to Hollywood came from a small Indian town, the shared universe felt like entry into a vast conversation: in equal parts a narrative, a puzzle, and a global ritual. Knowing became a form of belonging. Fans are not empty vessels into which corporate meaning is poured; they compare, argue, refuse, remix and care in excess of what any studio can fully administer.</p><p>But pleasure is not an alibi for the importance of structure. In <a href="https://www.collectiveinkbooks.com/zer0-books/our-books/super-heroes"><em>Capitalist Superheroes</em></a>, Dan Hassler-Forest situates the superhero boom within post-9/11 neoliberal Hollywood, where globally recognisable intellectual property travels efficiently across markets, platforms and products. The superhero is at once story, logo and an infrastructural promise. Ideological criticism does not prove that every feeling inside the system is counterfeit; it prevents affection from becoming innocence. <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/film/2019/oct/04/martin-scorsese-says-marvel-movies-are-not-cinema">Martin Scorsese’s comparison of Marvel films to theme parks</a> caught something real about controlled risk and pre-sold recognition, but he missed what spectators do with these films afterward. A corporation may design the track and the ride but it cannot entirely determine which memory a passenger carries home.</p><p>The MCU’s Spider-Man thus contains the contradiction in unusually visible form. He is the child dazzled by access and the local moral agent who must learn to act without permission; a working-class fantasy equipped by a billionaire. He is a neighbourhood emblem inside a planetary brand. The films are most alive when those scales grate against one another, and least alive when “friendly neighbourhood” becomes only a charming label attached to the next global deployment and press tour.</p><p><strong>Canon Is a Strange Kind of Law</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/735/1*M-9PWk8X4NHLYPEP_I0hoQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>Perhaps because I work with law, I find the language of canon both familiar and faintly comic. Fans discuss fictional continuity as though it were a constitutional order. The elements are definitely there, there is precedent, hierarchy, jurisdictional conflict, implied overruling and, whenever a disliked adaptation arrives, there is an ironic search for the character’s basic structure. Which universe has competence? Was the earlier rule repealed, distinguished, retconned or simply ignored?</p><p>Canon reassures us that an authorised source can settle meaning. It converts editorial choices, commercial pressures, accidents and breakthroughs into an apparently objective sequence. Call it the positivistic temptation of fandom: a proposition is true because the recognised authority has enacted it. Yet myth does not live by authority alone. Canon is logos attempting to administer mythos; the classificatory appetite trying to govern a figure whose vitality comes from retelling. This is, however, where the analogy reaches its limit. A court must eventually decide the dispute before it, but a myth can survive incompatible answers.</p><p>Will Brooker writes about Batman, not Spider-Man, but the analogy is useful. In <a href="https://www.bloomsbury.com/us/hunting-the-dark-knight-9781848852808/"><em>Hunting the Dark Knight</em></a>, he shows how a character with decades of contradictory incarnations is nevertheless policed through claims of fidelity, realism and truth. An “authentic” Batman, rather than a pure source; is produced by selecting some elements from the archive and pushing others aside. Brooker later describes canon less as stone tablets than as an editable database, capable of revision while the supposedly erased versions continue to haunt cultural memory. Spider-Man is the same. Raimi’s tearful labourer, Garfield’s wounded romantic, Holland’s eager recruit and Miles Morales do not line up behind an uncontested original, but alter what the name Spider Man can mean.</p><p>Jenkins’s distinction between continuity and multiplicity is especially valuable here. Continuity asks the pieces to cohere under authorised control; multiplicity permits divergent versions to illuminate one another. Fans participate in both. They can police canon, and they can preserve meanings official continuity has discarded.</p><p><em>No Way Home</em> is unprecedented as the moment when continuity itself becomes the emotional object. Tobey Maguire and Andrew Garfield return simultaneously as characters, intellectual property and repositories of spectators’ personal time. We recognise them before Holland’s Peter does. Their faces carry other theatres, other ages, other versions of ourselves. The film knows this as their entrances are staged around the pause required for recognition. It would be easy, and partly correct, to call this nostalgia management as prima facie, the past has been organised and sold back to us. Yet the three Peters do more than stand together for the photograph. On the rooftop they speak about grief as men whose different performances of masculinity have each failed to protect someone. Maguire’s Peter prevents Holland’s from killing the Green Goblin by placing his body against another repetition of rage. Garfield’s Peter catches MJ and breaks down because, for one impossible second, he answers the fall he could not stop in his own film. The moment is calculated but the tears are still real. It here when one notes that nostalgia may be commercially summoned without being emotionally counterfeit.</p><p>This however, does not defend every resurrection or acquit the system. It simply means awareness of orchestration does not place us outside emotion. The premise of No Way Home gives the returning histories an ethical task; Peter’s insistence that his villains can be cured, reconciled or rehabilitated. Memory must become responsibility or else it remains as just merchandising.</p><p>Eco’s paradox returns, the serial hero must be changed by action without becoming unavailable for further use. <em>No Way Home</em> consumes Holland’s Peter almost completely; May dies, his friends forget him, and he enters a bare apartment with a homemade suit. It is both a devastating consequence and a commercially useful reset. Both descriptions are true, it would be a mistake to believe that one cancels the other.</p><p><strong>One More Time</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/736/1*X4h0MUuRDVH_IV_t7PFQzg.jpeg" /></figure><p>David Foster Wallace understood that irony ceases to be rebellion once the entertainment industry learns to speak it fluently. In <a href="https://longform.org/archive/publications/the-review-of-contemporary-fiction">“E Unibus Pluram”</a>, his problem was not humour or self-awareness but the way television could flatter viewers for seeing through conventions while turning that superiority into another mode of consumption. The alternative was risky because it invited accusations of sentimentality and naïveté. Adam Kelly’s <a href="https://pure.york.ac.uk/portal/en/publications/david-foster-wallace-and-the-new-sincerity-in-american-fiction">account of Wallace and the new sincerity</a> adds an important refinement: sincerity after postmodernism cannot recover transparent inner truth. It becomes relational, anticipating suspicion and proceeding without guaranteed trust. Jesse Thorn later compressed the problem with greater cheer in <a href="https://maximumfun.org/news/manifesto-for-new-sincerity/">his manifesto</a>: irony and sincerity combined “like Voltron.” “New sincerity” does not name a clean period arriving after postmodernism packed its bags. Irony did not die, nor should it have. Suspicion remains necessary because power remains interested in appearing natural. The phrase describes a gesture: the decision to commit after critique, to speak feeling without pretending performance has disappeared, to act as if meaning remains possible when certainty does not.</p><p>No Spider-Man film understands that gesture better than <em>Into the Spider-Verse</em>. It begins with a promise: “All right, let’s do this one more time.” We know the bite, dead relative, mask, lesson, fall and swing. The film repeats the origin across Spider-people until repetition becomes the joke. But “one more time” is also how ritual works. A story is not necessarily emptied because it has been told before, sometimes repetition is the condition under which a new person can enter it.</p><p>Miles does not inherit the suit as a sacred object kept free of alteration. In the “What’s Up, Danger” sequence, he takes the dead Peter’s costume and paints over it in black and red. His fingers leave material traces on inherited form. Then he climbs, hesitates and jumps before he can know he is ready. The camera reverses the fall so that he appears to rise; shards of glass remain at his fingertips because the leap costs something. Readiness is produced by the act that seems to require it. Jen Cardenas’s <a href="https://whatismetamodern.com/film/spider-man-spider-verse-metamodernism/">metamodern reading of the film</a> calls this reconstruction rather than substitution. Miles was not copied into an unchanged template. The visual language of old comics — Ben-Day dots, hard lines, misregistered colour — is rebuilt around an Afro-Latino teenager whose family, graffiti and hip-hop soundscape change the form that receives him. The past is neither rejected nor restored. It becomes material. <a href="https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.3402/jac.v2i0.5677">Timotheus Vermeulen and Robin van den Akker’s “Notes on Metamodernism”</a> offers a vocabulary for this movement: oscillation between enthusiasm and irony, hope and melancholy, naïveté and knowingness. According to them “informed naivety” is not stupidity recovered. It is the pragmatic decision to move toward an impossible possibility while knowing it may remain impossible. The leap of faith is almost embarrassingly literal. The film knows the phrase is a cliché, but Miles still has to jump.</p><p><em>Across the Spider-Verse</em> turns this argument into a conflict over canon. Miguel O’Hara has studied the recurring losses in Spider-Man stories and built an institution around them. Police captains die. Mentors die. A loved one dies after the mask is assumed. These repetitions appear as nodes in a visual network until history acquires the authority of physics. The Spider-Society after observing that all Spider-Man stories have involved suffering, concludes that suffering must be preserved.</p><p>A canon event is what happens when description crystallizes into prescription. The error is familiar. A pattern is mistaken for law and inheritance becomes destiny; what repeatedly happened acquires the force of what ought to happen. Miguel’s grief gives the doctrine its power. He witnessed a universe collapse after inhabiting another version of his life, and bureaucracy is the architecture he builds around terror. If every tragedy is necessary, his loss has an explanation. If canon is law, he need never again endure the uncertainty of choosing. Miles refuses this interpretation when told that his father must die to keep the story intact, he does not reject responsibility for a private happiness. He assumes the more frightening responsibility of trying to save both his father and the worlds Miguel says depend upon the sacrifice. His wager that he can do both may be impossible, even naïve. But the moral failure would be to let a theory of narrative necessity decide that for him.</p><p>Myth repeats in order to reopen meaning. Bureaucracy repeats in order to foreclose choice.</p><p>Miles preserves Spider-Man’s moral tradition by disobeying its administrators. He accepts that power addresses him but refuses the proposition that responsibility requires predetermined suffering. The mask can be transferable without becoming meaningless because a symbolic transfer does not make anyone automatically heroic. It makes you potentially answerable. Each wearer must discover what inherited power asks in a world the previous wearer did not inhabit.</p><p>The Spider-Verse films proved that multiplicity need not dissolve character and that Spider-Man’s deepest continuity is not biographical. It is the recurring confrontation between capacity and obligation. The details must change because obligation is always encountered somewhere: in another body, another family, another city, another distribution of power. Fidelity to the myth means keeping the question alive not preserving every event in it.</p><p><strong>A Brand New Day</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/736/1*m-Oq-Loq8QP68727CcK2NQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>The title <em>Brand New Day</em> carries an old wound for comic readers. The comics era bearing that name followed “One More Day,” the notorious story in which Peter and Mary Jane’s marriage was erased from continuity. Freshness was purchased by deleting an accumulated life. It allowed Peter to be permanently available by undoing the consequences that changed him. That history made the new film’s title sound almost like a threat as did the ending of <em>No Way Home</em>. Peter returns to a recognisable starting position: poor, anonymous, alone, sewing his own suit in a small room. Was this consequence, or had consequence become the mechanism of reset? Would adulthood alter him, or would the serial corporate machine restore the product?</p><p>The film does not escape that machine. It contains Damage Control, Jean Grey, Bruce Banner, the Punisher, an artificial intelligence and a post-credits promise pointing Spider-Man toward space. Even sympathetic reviews observed that its intimate story must fight through the busy mechanics expected of Marvel product. Four years after the spell, the world remembers Spider-Man but has no place for Peter Parker: a social nonexistence rather than secret identity. Even his body refuses a clean reset. Repressed grief and anger emerge as what the film jokingly calls “Spider-Puberty”: organic webbing, sharpened senses and aggression. But the body horror is palpable, history has been erased from other minds, but remains lodged in him.</p><p>The moral centre of the film arrives when Peter shields Jean Grey from the Punisher’s bullet, perhaps as a call-back to Tobey Maguire’s Peter Parker blocking a lethal glider attack from the Green Goblin to protect Tom Holland’s Peter Parker during the climax of <em>No Way Home</em>. Jean is dangerous and capable of violating minds; she is also a grieving sister persecuted by institutions that treated her family as material. Peter responds to the vulnerable person before him. Spider-Man as responsibility-as-responsiveness returns in cinematic form: power creates no perfect calculus, only the possibility of answering or turning away.</p><p>What left me hopeful, though, was the film’s refusal to restore Peter and MJ through nostalgia’s easiest miracle. A telepathically controlled kiss briefly stages the fantasy that love might break Doctor Strange’s spell but Jean punctures it at once. Later, MJ reads the letter Peter never delivered, understands that another version of herself loved him, and tells him something more honest than the franchise usually permits: “I don’t love you.” She cannot inherit a feeling merely because the audience remembers it for her. Yet she trusts him. She invites Spider-Man upstairs to meet Ned. Peter and Ned fall into play over Lego. MJ draws them, but draws Peter without the mask. After the final battle, the sketch appears beside his hospital bed, evidence that she came to see him. The film closes not with recovered memory but with the broken black-dahlia necklace in her hand and the possibility that attention may begin where recognition failed. Their relationship is not restored but is offered the dignity of being built.</p><p>This difference; reconstruction rather than restoration, is the source of my hope. <em>Brand New Day</em> allows continuity to matter without treating it as sanctionable command. Peter’s past has consequences, but does not entitle him to MJ’s love. The audience’s attachment does not overrule her autonomy. He must become knowable again. The film takes franchise cinema’s reliable pleasure of an old relation returning and acknowledges possibility rather than possession. The cosmic icon in the post-credits scene lingers as the next instalment of the machinery is already warming. But the New Sincerity does not require us to pretend otherwise. It requires an emotional wager inside the machinery that self-awareness does not dissolve in advance. <em>Brand New Day</em> nevertheless remains compromised, crowded and commercially continuous, but it is also tender enough to let a woman say that the past cannot be hers simply because it is ours.</p><p><strong>The Multiplex after Irony: A New Sincerity Is Afoot</strong></p><p>Something in contemporary cinema has grown tired of mistaking recognition for wisdom, as though naming the trope before it materializes, identifying the manipulation before it succeeds, or locating the market calculation beneath the image are sufficient acts of understanding. We have become very good at seeing through things. Plot structures, brand strategies, prestige gestures, nostalgic cues: each can be exposed with an ease that can make disillusion feel like liberation. But a culture cannot live indefinitely on the privilege of seeing through everything. It eventually leaves us nowhere to stand; finding a window which sees through the smoke and mirrors remains at the end, just a window.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/736/1*P48wExvx0I04m23oNN1qbg.jpeg" /></figure><p>Perhaps this is why <em>Everything Everywhere All at Once</em> could place a nihilistic bagel, hot-dog fingers, googly eyes, tax paperwork and two silent rocks inside the same film, then make its final wager not on cleverness but kindness. The absurdity never takes a back seat, these are the conditions under which an earnest feeling can arrive without pretending that our existence has become less absurd. Waymond’s gentleness hits hard despite the film knowing exactly how easily gentleness can sound foolish, how quickly a declaration of kindness can be converted into a meme, printed on a T-shirt, circulated until its emotional life is flattened into recognisable content. But the film says it anyway. Its sincerity emerges through the exhaustion of irony’s claim to be the final intelligence.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/735/1*d0R-T8dYifipakC8Yo7MLA.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>Project Hail Mary</em> performs a similar manoeuvre but with science. Its equations, improvisations and comic explanations might seem to belong to an older era of sci-fi fantasy that reason shall make the universe manageable. Yet the film’s real act of faith is stranger and more intimate: a human being and an alien, each radically alone, learning enough of one another’s language to become responsible for each other. Science here supplies the method but it is friendship that supplies them with the reason to continue. The humour does not always know when to leave the room (perhaps no large contemporary film entirely trusts silence anymore) but beneath it is the almost embarrassingly earnest conviction that intelligence reaches its highest form not in conquest but cooperation. The challenge of survival transforms into a moral quandary. What value lies in possessing the wit to save oneself if one turns a blind eye to the duty owed to another life? It’s the timeless trolley dilemma reimagined, with Grace’s innate social instincts guiding his choice amidst overwhelming odds. Here, Kant’s Deontology triumphs over Bentham’s Utility.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/735/1*xqT3F_Mlj3GVzOPlzlDbNQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>Then there is <em>The Odyssey</em>, a tale nearly three millennia old, yet once more capturing the summer spotlight like a timeless blockbuster. This vividly highlights that the practice of repetition existed long before intellectual property laws were established. Ancient myths were continuously retold, altered, and discussed, shaped to reflect the anxieties and aspirations of their audiences. Nolan’s film has ignited a discussion about adaptation: praised as an exceptional cultural event, criticized by Emily Wilson for removing the poem’s emotional, political, and psychological depth, and supported by others as a legitimate cinematic transformation. The discussion itself is more captivating than any assessment of its faithfulness. What does it truly mean to remain faithful to a story that has endured precisely because each generation dared to alter it? Nor should the argument remain confined to the respectable quarrel between filmmaker and classicist. Around it gathered the internet’s less dignified tribunal of the ‘bros’, particularly outraged by Lupita Nyong’o’s portrayal of Helen, as if fidelity to Homer required obedience to a racial image. Helen has always been less a fixed person than a surface upon which cultures project their standards of beauty, desire and blame. Renaissance artists, Victorian illustrators, and Hollywood filmmakers all reimagined her, only to confuse their own creations with ancient history. This discussion is therefore revealing and fascinating; a mythical woman, whose charm once led to battles, still ignites controversy over what constitutes acceptable beauty. Yet beneath the casting wars and <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/film/2026/jul/27/odyssey-translator-emily-wilson-attacks-nolan-blockbuster">Emily Wilson’s formidable criticism</a>, there is something disarmingly sincere in Nolan’s approach. His characters may lack the thespian vocabulary and interior fluency of the poem; Matt Damon’s Odysseus is rendered more simply, as a battle-hardened man whose intelligence has become inseparable from survival. However, Nolan does not ridicule the ancient deities nor does he shy away from celebrating heroic magnificence. His version invites evaluation not as a mere reproduction of Homer, but as a reimagined myth.</p><p>That sincerity shines brightest in the film’s exploration of <em>xenia</em>, the sacred duty between host and stranger, safeguarded by Zeus himself. Hospitality emerges not as mere etiquette but as a delicate mechanism of civilization: in a world devoid of institutions to ensure safe passage, mutual welcome allows strangers to meet without instantly becoming foes. Nolan’s Bronze Age hinges on this restraint, unravelling when the Greeks at Troy find it easier to breach than to uphold. The enigmatic Sea Peoples cannot be neatly equated with Homeric Greeks, yet the film’s parallel is morally evocative: heroes in one tale may be seen in another as displaced warriors and coastal marauders. The victors return from Troy already bearing the seeds of the chaos they seek to mend. Beneath the IMAX spectacle, the scholarly debates, and the revived interest in classical learning, The Odyssey holds a sincere core: the conviction that civilization is built on restraints upheld even when breaking them is tempting, that war teaches exceptions which refuse to remain rare, and that returning home means discovering if the moral world left behind can endure the person one became to return. This historically speculative yet thematically pivotal interpretation of xenia, warfare, and Bronze Age collapse has also been observed in contemporary archaeological and critical responses to the film.. (<a href="https://www.indiewire.com/features/general/who-are-the-sea-peoples-christopher-nolan-the-odyssey-1235201014/">IndieWire on the Sea Peoples and <em>xenia</em></a>; <a href="https://classicalstudies.org/scs-blog/rlesser/blog-nolan%E2%80%99s-odyssey-big-suffering-and-grotesque-short-cunning-and-women">the Society for Classical Studies’ assessment</a>).</p><p>Call this the age-old tussle between logos and mythos, though neither can be fully captured by the other. Logos categorizes, differentiates, sets things in order, and questions which version holds authority. Mythos, on the other hand, thrives through lived experience. One explains how the pieces interlock; the other ponders why their arrangement holds significance for human existence. Cinema craves both. Devoid of logos, myth ossifies into mere superstition. Stripped of mythos, logos becomes a sterile archive: exhaustive, meticulously cross-referenced, yet devoid of spirit.</p><p>These films do not adhere to a singular aesthetic vision. <em>Everything Everywhere</em> transforms maximalism into a heartfelt appeal for tenderness. <em>Project Hail Mary</em> morphs problem-solving into the bonds of friendship. <em>The Odyssey </em>revisits an ancient myth with disarming sincerity, treating its inherited ideals not as relics to be mocked, but as fragile truths still worth testing against the violence of the present. There is no definitive historical rule here, no precise moment when postmodernism concluded and a new era began as if on cue. Vermeulen and van den Akker’s exposition remains pertinent because it captures a dance of contrasts rather than a linear progression: enthusiasm tempered by irony, irony lifted from apathy by desire; and the choice to seek meaning without pretending that skepticism has been vanquished. There is no dichotomy of choice between a wise past and a naive future. It is between irony that halts commitment and irony that accompanies it.</p><p><strong>Why Cinema Still Needs Spider-Man</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*kUMY8p4Mku174f_GEr5sdw.jpeg" /></figure><p>New sincerity is not a genre, a colour palette, or a collection of respectable emotions. Not warm light, swelling music, or tearful confessions. Those things can be manufactured efficiently. I beg to plea that nor does sincerity require us to stop noticing the manufacture. It begins precisely after the wires and harness become visible; after we have learned how nostalgia is activated, canon administered, and even grief fitted to a release calendar. An emotion can be marketed without being entirely defined by the terms of its transaction.</p><p><em>Everything Everywhere All at Once</em> built a new machine around its absurdism; <em>Project Hail Mary</em> introduced a new friendship; <em>The Odyssey</em> has outlived ownership. Spider-Man however, must speak while being a valuable and sought after intellectual property. His mask belongs to corporations and his past is divided among studios. The dead guardian, the leap, the returning theme, the older actor stepping through a portal; each carries both memory and market value. Without Spider-Man, new sincerity risks becoming a boutique sensibility, protected by prestige from popular culture’s compromises. He drags it into the multiplex, the toy aisle and the post-credit scene. If sincerity survives there, it cannot be dismissed as innocence preserved by distance from power.</p><p>Across his cinematic lives, Spider-Man’s continuity has never truly depended on biography. Raimi’s Peter is a tired labourer whose remorse becomes attention; he saves the train, and then the people on the train carry him. Garfield’s Peter turns alienation into style until grief strips it away; catching another Peter’s MJ lets failure become protection. Holland’s Peter seeks admission into a heroic institution and discovers that responsibility precedes authorisation. Miles paints over an inherited costume, accepting the symbol without becoming a copy. These versions disagree about temperament, romance, technology and even the events that supposedly make Spider-Man Spider-Man. What they preserve is the moment in which private power becomes an answer owed to another person.</p><p>Miguel O’Hara converts accumulated tragedy from description into prescription: because loved ones have died before, someone must die again. Suffering authenticates the hero, resets the product and reassures the audience that the pattern remains intact. Miles does not demand a world without cost; he refuses to let repetition decide in advance whose death must count as necessary. Myth repeats to reopen a question; bureaucracy repeats to prevent one. Spider-Man remains alive because each retelling treats precedent as an argument rather than a sentence. The question is disarmingly simple: what does an ordinary person owe to other people once he has an unusual capacity to help? No version can answer it finally, because the person asking and the world making the claim keep changing. Fidelity cannot mean arranging every uncle, lover and police captain for the prescribed death. It means keeping the question alive when responsibility takes a new material form: rent, grief, institutional power, inherited trauma, or the demand to refuse an apparently necessary sacrifice.</p><p>The quietest image in <em>Brand New Day</em> therefore carries more weight for me than its cosmic promises. MJ learns that another version of herself loved him, but that past cannot conscript her present. Peter’s memory gives him grief, not title. When she tells him she does not love him, the film refuses nostalgia’s easiest jurisdiction. Yet she trusts him, watches him, and draws him and Ned without the mask, a subtle yet remarkable act of witnessing Peter whose isolation has burdened him for four years. Their relation is not restored through magic; it is tentatively reconstructed through attention. That drawing gathers all the scattered threads mentioned here in this essay. Being recognised as exceptional is no hallmark of Peter’s heroism. In recognising him as another person before an institution, theory or story has told us what they are worth, that makes Peter a hero. MJ, deprived of recognition, pays attention anyway. Peter is not restored by destiny. He is being seen in the present.</p><p>I do not need the film to be pure, free of studio interference, or the emotion unconstructed. I need the choice to remain open after those qualifications have been admitted. Critique remains necessary. But disenchantment is not freedom if it leaves us capable only of withdrawal. To expose the apparatus and refuse every feeling it mediates would grant it a complete victory: not merely ownership of the image, but jurisdiction over our capacity to answer it. When critique relinquishes that jurisdiction without relinquishing its knowledge, that is what I mean by sincerity. Not innocence recovered, but the refusal to make invulnerability our only proof of intelligence.</p><p>When the lights came up after <em>Brand New Day</em>, the machinery returned at once. There was a post-credit image to interpret, a future appearance to predict, another instalment in the continuity waiting to absorb the film. Phones came out. Story became information again. But beside Peter’s hospital bed remained a drawing of his unmasked face: no recovered memory or guaranteed destiny, only evidence that someone had looked closely enough at the man Peter was.</p><p><em>What does an ordinary person owe to other people once he has an unusual capacity to help?</em></p><p>This question remains beyond canon or copyright. For a few seconds after the lights came up, the red and blue remained. Perhaps that is all sincerity can promise now: not innocence restored, but a responsibility felt, one more time.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/736/1*lvA9yqcuAeE8wRhvz6sq5g.jpeg" /></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=afdc036f2209" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Au Pays de Cocagne: On Geese’s Getting Killed and the strange abundance of rock after its death]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@satyangavaneesh/au-pays-de-cocagne-on-geeses-getting-killed-and-the-strange-abundance-of-rock-after-its-death-c0117c651c19?source=rss-2a5af0491dad------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c0117c651c19</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[music]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[music-review]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Avaneesh Satyang]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 02 Apr 2026 17:59:10 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-09-07T10:48:37.002Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Geese’s <em>Getting Killed</em> did not just give me songs to admire. It altered the feeling of the present. It made time thicker, stranger, and more crowded with return.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*hYyUEyUamSBCjpA380jXzQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>Most people who have written about <em>Getting Killed</em> seem to agree on one thing: “Trinidad” is a strange opener. It is. It is also exactly right. “There’s a bomb in my car” has already taken on the life of a meme, but the song itself is harsher than a meme can hold. Its images of daughters dead, husbands burning lead, bodies force-fed or baked into bread are so brutal that they almost feel like the album clearing its throat with a scream. And yet it does not scream cleanly. It loops. It circles. It drives. It sounds to me like the beginning of a haunted return to the self, or to whatever remains of the self after panic has already arrived. Which is why “Cobra” makes such sense after it. If “Trinidad” is the blast radius, “Cobra” is the first strange sway inside it.</p><p>That is where I first really feel the strut. Not at the album’s start, but as it opens itself out of dread and into movement. “Baby, let me dance away forever,” Winter sings, and the line is tender and vaguely sick at once, like devotion passing through shame. By then the album is no longer only alarming me; it is beginning to get into my bloodstream. The songs stalk, lurch, grind, and sway. They know that rock music, before it becomes history or canon or scholarship, begins in posture. It begins in the body.</p><p>I should probably say here that I did not come to any of this through a proper grooming in the canon. I met the Rolling Stones through the movie <em>Scott Pilgrim vs The World </em>, “Under My Thumb” drifting softly in the background, more atmosphere than revelation at first. I came to Bruce Springsteen embarrassingly late; in my final year of law school and the first year after, when work was beginning to harden the body and the abstract concept of the American Dream still felt, from far away, both rich and gritty and poetic enough to be believed in for a few minutes at a time. I heard <em>In Rainbows</em> in late 2020, in the depths of despair, and it has never quite left me. So when I hear traces of those older worlds in <em>Getting Killed</em>, I do not hear them as a trained archivist would. I hear them as someone whose life has been periodically decorated by sound, often at odd hours, and who has found that songs do not enter in order.</p><p>Maybe that is why Cameron Winter’s voice hits me the way it does. There is something in it that feels drawn up from the belly. Something Springsteen-like there, for me. Then there are the inflections, little bends, feints, and verbal smirks, and that is where Jagger comes in. But those comparisons only get you so far. The phrasing is what unsettles me. He enters lines at odd angles. He hangs back where I expect him to rush. He rushes where I expect him to hold. The timings are off-kilter enough that the singing begins to feel less like delivery than possession. It scratches at the brain.</p><p>And still, what keeps me here is not only the frontman but the feeling of a band behaving like a band. The rhythm section keeps repetition from sealing shut. Even when the songs circle, they breathe. At moments I am reminded of the drumming on “Weird Fishes,” the way repetition there becomes a living current rather than a loop. Emily Green’s guitar work does something I can only call wizardry or post-op witchcraft in her case (the transition having nothing to do with her guitar chops). “Edgy” is too thin a word for it. The lines are sometimes almost conventional, but they arrive with such odd tone and pressure that they feel briefly dislodged from their own history. That, to me, is one of the album’s quiet miracles. At moments I am reminded of Johnny Greenwood, though that comparison may reveal as much about the listener’s desire for lineage as it does about the playing itself. There is always a temptation, when confronted with work this vivid, to slot it into a pantheon, to search for heirs and saviours and continuities.</p><p>I keep circling back, too, to the thought that music is not chronological. Or not only chronological. Simon Frith writes about how our judgments about popular music are tied up with bodily response, with how we move and react and decide what feels “for real.”<a href="#_ftn1">[1]</a> Bergson, elsewhere, writes of duration as the prolongation of the past into the present.<a href="#_ftn2">[2]</a> I do not mean to force <em>Getting Killed</em> under theory. I only mean that listening to it has made those thoughts feel intimate to me. Sound happens only in the present. But when it happens, the present becomes porous. It lets in remembered time, inherited time, imagined time, feared time. Old songs and new songs decorate the same life.</p><p>If there is a song that contains the emotional grammar of the album for me, it is “Au Pays du Cocaine.” I learned it on guitar as a simple I-IV-V progression, and that matters because it gives the song the feeling of one of rock music’s oldest motions: departure, tension, and return. But Geese do not use that old movement to sound antique or comforting. They use it to make a plea. “You can be free and still come home” is one of the most moving lines on the record for me, because it refuses the idea that freedom must mean severance. Then the repetitions start: “you can change,” “I’m alright,” “it’s alright.” They do not sound like certainty. They sound like someone trying to sing home into existence before it vanishes. And with the video in mind, I cannot hear the song only as a love song. At times it feels like a parent speaking to a child. At times like the self calling back to itself. At times, stranger still, like a ghost addressing the living as “baby,” from some other life entirely. That is only my reading. But I cannot unhear it. That feeling spreads into “Half Real” and “Islands of Men,” where the album starts to sound less like a group of songs than a meditation on unstable reality. “Our love was only half real,” and then: that is only half true. “What is real and what is fake.” These are not neat oppositions. They feel like the language of someone moving through a world whose bindings have loosened. I have even found myself thinking of the moment after death described in some Hindu and Buddhist traditions: the intermediate passage, the nearness to departure, the sense that consciousness is not yet fully gone from one plane and not yet settled in another.<a href="#_ftn3">[3]</a> I do not mean that the album “is” that. Only that some of these songs seem to operate in a similarly suspended register, as though they were being sung from the threshold between staying and leaving, between resisting the pull back and surrendering to whatever comes next.</p><p>The album’s dreamlike quality would mean less if it were not also so alert to injury. That is where “Getting Killed” and “100 Horses” become crucial. “I’m getting killed by a pretty good life” is such a brutal line because it refuses melodrama. This is not ruin in the grand tragic sense. It is suffocation by the ordinary, by the city, by a life that is livable and still somehow annihilating. “I have been fucking destroyed by this city tonight” makes the feeling even starker. And yet the album does not remain private for long. In “100 Horses,” the pressure opens outward into a public atmosphere where “all people must smile / in times of war,” where “all people must go dancing,” where “there is only dance music in times of war.” Dancing here is not simple joy, nor even simple escape. It is ritual. Command. Consolation. Compulsion.</p><p>That is why I have started calling the album, for myself, a cradle-dirge. Not as a theory. Not even as a proper concept. Only because no other phrase has come close enough to the feeling of it. It is an oxymoron, yes, but some truths only arrive in broken compounds like that. A cradle-song welcomes life. It soothes, rocks, repeats, makes room for breath, teaches the body how to rest inside time. A dirge does almost the opposite: it accompanies the fact of ending, or the foreknowledge of ending, or the long ache that lingers after something has already slipped beyond recall. Some of these songs feel as though they are sung from that strange threshold where departure and return are no longer cleanly opposed. I keep thinking of those religious images of the moment just after death, when the soul, not fully gone and not fully here, is said to hover near the life it has just left: able, perhaps, to look back, perhaps even to mistake its leaving for a different kind of staying. I do not mean that the album represents that state. Only that it sometimes sounds as though it has found a comparable register; a music of lingering, of near-departure, of consciousness passing through itself. That is why its repetitions matter so much. They do not merely insist; they hover. They circle the way grief circles, the way prayer circles, the way a parent might rock a child through fever, or the way one might speak softly beside a hospital bed when the body does not yet know whether to hold on or let go.</p><p>Which is why the end of the album matters so much. In “Long Island City Here I Come,” when Winter sings, “You were there the day the music died, and / I’ll be there the day it dies again,” the line does more than nod toward an old rock-and-roll obituary. It enters the long habit of announcing music’s death and then keeps walking anyway. “Here I come,” he says over and over, until the phrase no longer sounds like swagger. It sounds like fate. Or duty. Or someone advancing through fog because stopping would be the real disappearance. Then comes the line that breaks me open: “until I get home, I am not anyone.” Home, here, is no longer just a place. It is a condition of being gathered back into oneself. Maybe that is what this album has been doing all along. Not saving rock. Not reviving it. Not redeeming anything so cleanly. Just carrying something old and hurt and still breathing through the noise of the present toward return.</p><p>A cradle-dirge, then, is not just a contradiction. It is a song for what is being born in the same instant that something else is passing away. It is a welcome note written in the margins of an elegy. It is the sound of a form being mourned without being abandoned. Rock, perhaps more than any other genre, has been made to live under the sign of its own death. It is forever being declared exhausted, revived, betrayed, redeemed, buried, resurrected. But this album does not sound to me like a resurrection story. Resurrection is too clean a word, too triumphant, too certain of what has returned. <em>Getting Killed</em> feels stranger than that. It feels like sitting up with something through the night, hearing it breathe unevenly, not knowing whether one is witnessing its end or its transformation. It feels like the old body of rock music being held close enough that, in the act of grieving it, one can still feel a pulse.</p><p>That is what moves me most about the record. It understands that music can welcome and mourn in the same breath. That it can gather the old world into its arms without pretending the old world is unbroken. A lullaby is supposed to ease us into sleep; a dirge is supposed to accompany us toward the grave. But what if a song inhabits the hour between those two, when sleep already resembles disappearance, and disappearance is still full of voice? What if it sings not to the living or the dead alone, but to whatever in us keeps passing back and forth between them? That is the space this album sometimes enters for me. Not life, not death, not revival, not ruin, but a trembling interval in which something wounded is still being carried, still being named, still being moved enough to move again.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref1">[1]</a> Simon Frith, <em>Performing Rites: On the Value of Popular Music</em></p><p><a href="#_ftnref2">[2]</a> Henri Bergson — the Stanford Encyclopedia summarizes his notion of duration as the “prolongation of the past into the present.”</p><p><a href="#_ftnref3">[3]</a> In Tibetan Buddhism, the <em>Bardo Thödol</em> is a funerary text meant to guide consciousness through an intermediate state between death and rebirth. In some Hindu traditions the soul is understood to remain near the abode of the deceased for a period after death, before passing onward; related funeral rites are understood as helping the soul on to its next state.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c0117c651c19" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Where the Light Found Me: Seeing John Mayer, Finally]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@satyangavaneesh/where-the-light-found-me-seeing-john-mayer-finally-d6cb3d99cb79?source=rss-2a5af0491dad------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d6cb3d99cb79</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[music]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[personal-essay]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[memoir]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[this-happened-to-me]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[life-lessons]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Avaneesh Satyang]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 13 Feb 2026 18:33:20 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-02-13T19:00:17.097Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*WeqLyXJFN_iNblpNzmZkYg.jpeg" /></figure><p>There are artists you admire, and then there are artists you grow up inside.</p><p>John Mayer was the second kind for me.</p><p>By the time I first found him, he was already many people in public imagination — virtuoso, heartbreaker, punchline, prodigy. I met John Mayer on television before I met him in music. VH1 used to run those month-long spotlights, the kind that crowned one artist as the centre of the cultural weather, and that month it was him, his 2009 album <em>Battle Studies</em> was approaching, “Who Says” was the first single off of it, everything polished and camera-ready. In the video for “Heartbreak Warfare”, he looked like a pop star in the most literal sense: immaculate hair, easy charm, the practiced composure of someone built for close-ups. It unsettled my early mythology of guitar greatness, which had come from elsewhere, mostly <em>Guitar Hero 3</em>, played ironically on a keyboard and mouse, where guitar heroes seemed wild, abrasive, excessive, or weathered by blues and ruin. They weren’t supposed to look this elegant. But then I listened. First the songs from his first album, <em>Room for Squares</em>, then especially the acoustic versions of “My Stupid Mouth,” “Your Body Is a Wonderland,” “Neon” and the contradiction disappeared. Beneath the sheen was an obsession; a musician with pop instinct and a guitarist’s rigor, writing songs that could flirt, confess, and fracture in the same breath.</p><p>By fourteen, his music had already entered my private emotional grammar. <em>Heavier Things</em> felt like a revelation in hooks and ache. Songs like “Clarity,” “Bigger than my Body,” “Something’s Missing” were larger than my age but exactly my size. Around then, while stumbling through first crushes and first online intimacies, a girl from school asked me on Facebook who my favourite artist was. I froze, not only because I didn’t know, but because I was the kind of child who feared wrong answers, who lived more vividly in imagination than in conversation. I asked my younger sister, who heard everything I heard; she answered immediately: “John Mayer.” Her certainty gave me my own. From then on, admiration became archive. With one close friend who shared the same nerd-level devotion, I traded songs compulsively and kept digging; Atlanta-era recordings after dropping out of Berklee, his cover of “Message in a Bottle,” a rendition of Stevie Ray Vaughan’s “Lenny” into his own “Man on the Side”, unreleased tracks, stray EP cuts, “Five Long Years”, “Love Soon”, “Victoria”, “Sucker,” the private catalog beneath the public one. It was never enough to praise Continuum in public; in private, I wanted the whole map.</p><p>With the odds of seeing him play live next to nil, I saw him in pixels, 480p on YouTube, if fortune allowed, usually 240p on my internet, buffering every few seconds like revelation arriving in fragments. I torrented <em>Where the Light Is</em>, one of the first movies I ever pirated myself, and watched it with near-religious attention. At that age, two versions of me were developing in parallel: one drawn to the angsty, dismal, existential undertow of Kurt Cobain and Nirvana Unplugged in New York; the other pulled toward Mayer’s disciplined elasticity. That concert film became a three-part education: the acoustic set, intimate and lucid, with “Free Fallin’” and “In Your Atmosphere,” John flanked by David Ryan Harris and Robbie McIntosh; the Trio ignition with Steve Jordan and Pino Palladino on “Who Did You Think I Was” and “Good Love is on the Way”; and then the full-band ascent, horns included, where even his popular bops felt expansive.</p><p>Not long after discovering him in 2009, I still approached <em>Battle Studies</em> sideways: “Who Says” opened the door, but I initially ran backward into the earlier records, as if I trusted their emotional grammar more, while songs like “Heartbreak Warfare” felt almost too sleek, too pop, for where I was then. But heartbreak has a way of changing your ear. Around my first breakup, during a family trip to a relative’s wedding, our extended family spread across one or two train coaches, everyone noisy and social while I sat withdrawn with my iPod Nano, “Half of My Heart” came on and found me at exactly the right fracture point. I remember the turn in the lyric, that ache of divided willingness, and then the refrain “I can’t keep loving you” landing not as defeat but release, like a small private verdict that let me imagine a future beyond that one person. Over time, the album I had once kept at arm’s length became structurally important to me: “Edge of Desire” revealed itself as a guitar-and-longing masterclass, “War of My Life” became a companion through college, and even his cover of “Crossroads” sharpened my sense that beneath the pop architecture there was always a working guitarist’s mind; restless, exacting, and emotionally unsparing.</p><p>Then there was the era of fallout: interviews, careless words, backlash, cancellation, retreat. The feeling that one ugly phase could eclipse the whole person. He receded. Around the same time, there were whispers about his throat, the granuloma, the silence that followed. A singer unable to sing. A voice interrupted by its own instrument.</p><p>And then, almost quietly, <em>Born and Raised</em> arrived, not like a comeback parade, but like a man stepping back into sunlight with his head bowed, hat low, songs first. I was a lonely kid then. The kind of lonely that doesn’t always look like sadness from outside; sometimes it looks like functioning, good grades, polite conversation, and a private world too large for one body. Songs like “Speak for Me” felt less like listening and more like being recognized. “Walt Grace” would ruin me every time, this tender mythology of disappearance, invention, escape. It taught me that yearning can be engineered into motion. That a life can be both improbable and true. By college, I had consumed not only the albums but their internet afterlives, live cuts, alternate renditions, obscure uploads, fragments of tours.</p><p>By <em>Paradise Valley</em>, he seemed like someone who had chosen weather over noise. The aesthetic by these two last albums had changed; cowboy edges, canyon air, a little Neil Young ghosting the frame, but it felt earned, not performed. “Dear Marie” felt like a postcard written from adulthood to every forked road behind it. I remember listening to “Who You Love” (with Katy Perry) and being happy for him in that strangely intimate way fans can be: not because we know the artist, but because we know what their survival sounds like.</p><p>In college, whenever people joked that I looked like him whenever I put on a leather jacket reminiscent of the Battle Studies cover, I took it as an absurd badge of honor. Identity, at that age, is often collage; borrowed gestures, borrowed jackets, borrowed confidence. We become ourselves partly by trying on other people’s silhouettes. In psychology, this is identity construction through available cultural scripts, the stories and symbols we use to compose a coherent “me.”</p><p>More importantly, in my most volatile phases, his songs gave me emotional scaffolding: <em>Born and Raised</em> and <em>Paradise Valley</em> became survival records, with “I Will Be Found (Lost at Sea)” and “If I Ever Get Around to Living” shaping not just what I felt, but what I wanted a life to feel like. Then in 2017, <em>The Search for Everything</em> arrived as a subtle return to pop without abandoning his complexity; country traces, blues muscle, and that fragile singer-songwriter centre still intact, and even while I was in a relationship, I could hear the honest residue of grief in songs like “Still Feel Like Your Man,” “Never on the Day You Leave,” and “Rosie.” There was barely any merch accessible in India unless one imported it, so I made my own custom John Mayer T-shirts designed online, now lost, but at the time they felt like beautiful, handmade proof of devotion.</p><p>Years passed. New music, new people, new griefs, new routines. But desire has a long memory. The dream remained embarrassingly sincere: one day I’ll see him live. I used to tell my friends in college, half joking and half praying, “Once I see him, I can die happy.”</p><p>Then in September 2025, the news came, John Mayer was coming to India.</p><p>It came, ironically, through an ex-colleague who remembered how much I loved him. I was excited, but not in that teenage, over-the-top stan way. Life had become heavier. I had lost my grandfather in early 2025. I had moved to a new place, begun a new master’s program, explored different jobs, tried to build new routines in the aftermath of grief. I called my sister. We booked two tickets.</p><p>Due to the passing of Bob Weir, John’s friend and bandmate from Dead &amp; Company, we endured a postponement that made my sister miss his concert and briefly made me think I should skip it, maybe this was one of those dreams that works better at a distance.</p><p>But as the new date approached, I started opening old folders: photos, guitar voice memos, tiny video fragments of myself trying to play his songs. One night at 3 a.m., in that half-lit state where memory and impulse shake hands, I booked a flight to Mumbai. The word in my head was one my grandfather loved: <em>serendipity</em>.</p><p>What followed felt improbable in gentle ways: a surprisingly affordable upgrade on the flight, cozy accommodation through old friends, my sister unable to make it but a close friend stepping in gladly, another lucky ticket upgrade at the venue. The opening acts — Naga Singer-Songwriter Abdon Mech and the proficient Tejas — set a grounded, intimate tone. The crowd thickened. The sky darkened. Then he walked out, and the first riff of “Slow Dancing in a Burning Room” cut through the noise like a blade through cloth.</p><p>By the time I stood in that ground, I wasn’t arriving as one person. I was arriving as an accumulation.</p><p>The child who needed songs more than conversation.</p><p>The teenager who learned longing through headphones.</p><p>The college kid who mistook archiving for understanding.</p><p>The adult learning that devotion is also a way of measuring time.</p><p>I did what I knew I would do: sang, shouted, and when I wasn’t doing either, I cried. Not cinematic tears — but the kind that arrive when a present moment opens a trapdoor beneath itself and all your previous selves climb out at once. At thirty-one, I was also twenty-three. Also seventeen. Also fourteen.</p><p>Psychology has terms for parts of this; parasocial attachment, autobiographical memory, temporal self-continuity, but the language of it, in real time, felt simpler: the screen had become a stage; the archive had become breath. I wasn’t just watching an artist. I was watching the life his songs had lived inside me. I felt my scattered former selves were still, somehow, me. Not dead versions. Not obsolete drafts. But co-authors.</p><p>And there was another recognition; time had done what time does. His presence felt softer, calmer, more deliberate. Mature in a way that can only be purchased with loss and consequence. For a moment I grieved the imagined version of him I had carried for years. Then I understood the grief was gratitude. I hadn’t come to meet an old video. I had come to meet a human being who had survived himself.</p><p>What lingers most is not even one of the twenty-two songs, but two pauses between them: the old promo clips; one from <em>Room for Squares</em>, another from the <em>Continuum</em> era, where a younger John is still trying to understand who he is making music for — half self-doubting, half defiant, even calling himself a “former pop sensation.” Each time those videos played, I couldn’t fully see his face from where I stood, so I kept imagining the same frame: his back to us, his face to the screen, watching the younger version of himself ask questions the older one was now answering in real time. I can’t know what he felt in that moment; but from where I stood, it looked like recognition.</p><p>In that pause, the concert stopped being performance and became a mirror — his across years, and mine across selves.</p><p>Around us, thousands of strangers sang the same lines for entirely different reasons, and somehow it became one feeling anyway. Strangers completing each other’s lines, an effervescent fusion where individual emotion becomes a shared ritual. A concert is one of the last secular temples where this still happens without irony; you enter as a private person and leave as part of a temporary “we.”</p><p>That night I realized music had always been bigger than the musician for me. Bigger than biography. Bigger than scandal. Bigger than virtuosity, even. His lyrics were written out of his life; I translated them into mine. So did everyone else in that crowd. Meaning moved from author to audience, multiplied there, and returned as something nobody owned alone.</p><p>Maybe that is art’s most humane trick. I watched him react to us in astonishment — people from a place he may never have imagined when <em>Room for Squares</em> first came out, singing his songs back to him with full throat and frightening tenderness. You could see a flicker of surprise in him, and maybe reverence too, as if he knew, in real time, that songs outgrow their makers and become common property of feeling.</p><p>What happened was simpler and harder to explain:</p><p>I went there to see John Mayer.</p><p>I met my own timeline.</p><p>I came back with everyone I had been.</p><p>And in that strange, crowded holiness, I felt an old sentence rewrite itself.</p><p>Not: “<em>Once I see him, I can die happy.</em>”</p><p>Something quieter. Truer.</p><p>I saw him.</p><p>I cried.</p><p>I understood.</p><p>I don’t need to die happy.</p><p>I need to keep living in tune, listening to the voices that once carried me, and staying faithful to the voice I owe myself now.</p><p><em>Disclosure</em>: This essay was written by a human with selective AI support (mostly for compression and polish). The feelings are mine; the commas are negotiated. Ethical sentencing is respectfully deferred.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d6cb3d99cb79" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Miura Kentarō’s Guts: Perspectives on Trauma and Masculinity’s Battle with Fate]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@satyangavaneesh/miura-kenatar%C5%8Ds-guts-perspectives-on-trauma-and-masculinity-s-battle-with-fate-d59d7c425869?source=rss-2a5af0491dad------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d59d7c425869</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[manga]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[masculinity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[berserk]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[psychology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Avaneesh Satyang]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 19 Nov 2025 19:23:52 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-11-20T03:46:55.443Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>“<em>Even if you force back what was lost, it still won’t be the way it was.” — Guts</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/728/1*XTgMdBhlYsTRmYP-51CNXw.jpeg" /></figure><p>Guts, the central figure in Kentarō Miura’s <em>Berserk</em>, embodies one of the most intricate and paradoxical warrior archetypes in modern literature. His character is situated at the crossroads of trauma studies, existential philosophy and mythological archetypes. As Casey Evans (2020) observes, Guts serves as a “character study on perseverance”, surviving conditions that should have annihilated him (Evans, 2020). However, endurance is not his only defining trait. His life is equally marked by unrelenting grief, survivor’s guilt, confrontation with the Absurd, and unexpectedly, by moments of compassion and tenderness. As Sophie Thomas (2022) argues, vulnerability reshapes what power means in cultural and gendered contexts (Thomas, 2022). Guts embodies this paradox: a warrior scarred by trauma who eventually learns that the truest form of strength lies not in destruction but in connection.</p><p>Beyond philosophical readings, scholars have also stressed the psychological and cultural dimensions of Guts. The case study on Guts highlights how attachment theory explains his inability to form trust early in life, while neurobiological language (heightened cortisol responses, trauma-driven vigilance) anchors Miura’s character in scientific frames. Axel Martínez Shepherd’s <em>Beyond the Guts and Viscera: The Nuanced Masculinity of Kentaro Miura’s Berserk</em> (2023) argues that Miura destabilizes hegemonic masculinity by presenting a protagonist whose strength is inseparable from tenderness, responsibility, and care. Shepherd situates <em>Berserk</em> at the crossroads of Eastern and Western storytelling, drawing on samurai ideals, European tragedy, and post-war Japanese cultural anxieties to show how Guts becomes a transnational figure of nuanced masculinity. Miura’s fusion of these narrative traditions produces a distinctly transnational portrait of trauma — one that resonates across cultural boundaries because it frames suffering as both universal and culturally mediated. The Japanese post-war ethos of endurance (<em>gaman</em>), European tragic fatalism, and global discourses on childhood trauma converge in Guts’ arc. This synthesis allows readers from diverse backgrounds to recognize their own cultural scripts of pain, survival, and resilience within his story. Trauma becomes at once a shared human experience and a phenomenon refracted through specific cultural lenses, enabling <em>Berserk</em> to speak across borders without losing the texture and specificity of its Japanese setting.</p><p>Miura’s <em>Berserk</em> is not merely a fantasy tale of swords and sorcery but a visual and thematic masterpiece. Miura’s artistic techniques — his stark use of shadow, the immense weight conveyed in panel composition, and his ability to render silence as eloquently as battle — draw readers directly into Guts’ inner world. Scholars, critics, and video essays alike note how his body language — slumped posture in exhaustion, brief smiles in reprieve, or the cold ferocity of his stare — functions as narrative shorthand for his psychological state. This attention to visual detail ensures that the manga is not only read but also felt.</p><p><em>Berserk</em> is a profound meditation on trauma, survival, and moral endurance. Guts’ story resonates with Camus’ conception of the Absurd and Sartre’s reflections on facticity. Shepherd (2023) extends this analysis, suggesting that Miura’s redefinition of strength is itself a cultural text about masculinity in late modernity where violence and stoicism give way, slowly and painfully, to responsibility and tenderness. His arc from wound to tenderness invites readers to reflect on what it means to endure and what forms of strength can emerge from even the deepest suffering. Importantly, the manga itself functions as an existential and ethical case study: a narrative about surviving in a world saturated with violence and corruption, while still finding ways to affirm life, build bonds, and create meaning.</p><h3>Origins and Early Trauma</h3><p>The extremity of Guts’ birth and childhood sets the foundation for his lifelong solitude and resilience. He was born beneath the hanged corpse of his mother, discovered amid blood and decay, and adopted by mercenaries. Raised by Gambino, a father figure who alternated between reluctant caretaker and violent oppressor, Guts endured neglect, betrayal, and exploitation. Trained to wield oversized weapons from an early age, he became a child soldier hardened by necessity. Physical abuse and sexual assault compounded his alienation, instilling hypervigilance, rage, and dissociation, classic symptoms of PTSD as described by Herman (1992, Trauma and Recovery).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/720/1*FaC5yTvdZcMPJkQ0F8ktwQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>Chronic trauma fundamentally alters neuroendocrine functioning. Studies of trauma-exposed children demonstrate dysregulation of the hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal axis, resulting in both elevated and blunted cortisol responses (Daud et al., 2008). This physiological imbalance mirrors Guts’ perpetual vigilance — his body, like those of real survivors, remains locked in a state of hyper-readiness long after danger has passed.</p><p>Neuroimaging research confirms that prolonged trauma reshapes neural pathways regulating fear and memory. Nijenhuis et al. (2010) demonstrate that trauma survivors exhibit heightened amygdala activity and reduced prefrontal modulation, producing chronic hypervigilance and fragmented memory. Guts’ near-reflexive combat stance and dissociative calm in battle evoke precisely this altered neural equilibrium.</p><p>Empirical studies of adult survivors reveal enduring personality configurations shaped by early adversity. Allen and Lauterbach (2007) identify elevated conscientiousness and introversion as adaptive ways of maintaining order against chaos. Guts embodies this pattern: his relentless discipline and guarded solitude function as protective structures against a world he expects to betray him.</p><p>Pitman et al. (2012) synthesize neurobiological and behavioral data, showing how chronic stress hormones reinforce aggressive readiness and emotional numbing. Guts’ repeated immersion in violence — his inability to stop fighting despite exhaustion — reflects this cyclical biology of trauma, where the body itself becomes addicted to vigilance.</p><p>From a psychological standpoint, this period can also be understood through attachment theory. Guts exemplifies disorganized attachment (Beeney et al. 2017): longing for care yet expecting betrayal. His hypervigilance and readiness for violence mirror trauma-related neurobiological patterns; heightened cortisol responses and overactivation of survival systems. In this way, Miura renders his protagonist believable not only as myth but as a psychological case study of childhood trauma. Miura draws on both samurai tropes — stoic endurance, loyalty, and honor — and European tragic archetypes, such as Oedipus or Hamlet, to position Guts as a hybrid figure whose suffering fuses East and West. This hybridity ensures that his pain is legible across cultural traditions, amplifying his universality.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/711/1*eH5yN7j8ciRHNUaYBeNEVg.jpeg" /></figure><p>Steel rather than love became his comfort. His sword, absurdly large for his young frame, symbolized both weapon and surrogate parent: a means of survival in place of nurture. His adolescence as a mercenary, wandering battlefields reflects a logic of trauma; better to keep moving, sever ties, and trust no one than risk betrayal again. The world of <em>Berserk</em> intensifies this orientation. Miura depicts a feudal landscape suffused with corruption, cruelty, and demonic presence, a world that is practically evil incarnate. In such a universe, Guts’ suspicion and hardness are adaptive strategies, not idiosyncrasies.</p><h3>Will and Perseverance: The Struggler</h3><p>If trauma isolates him, willpower defines him. Guts is revered and feared as “the Struggler,” one who refuses to submit to annihilation. Evans (2020) emphasizes perseverance as his essence. His article carefully charts Guts’ refusal to surrender, framing him as a paragon of sheer human will. Evans concludes that Miura portrays willpower not as an abstract concept but as lived resistance, often at the cost of alienation. This reading highlights how Guts’ strength is double-edged: a source of awe but also of isolation. In this sense, Evans’ analysis underscores that perseverance in <em>Berserk</em> is both heroic and tragic, situating Guts firmly within the existential motif of the endless struggle. Moreover, Evans situates Guts as a cultural symbol of resilience for readers themselves, whose fascination with the character derives from his embodiment of perseverance against overwhelming odds.</p><p>Psychological analysis offers additional depth in this context. The case study portrays Guts’ determination as similar to a combination of high conscientiousness and introversion, traits that account for his unwavering focus and distrust of others. This psychological perspective enhances the existential one: he serves as both a philosophical symbol and a psychological archetype, with his resilience stemming from both his temperament and his circumstances.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/693/1*8v2iz1NCTpmuiw-M9cg3mw.jpeg" /></figure><p>After the Golden Age, his prowess attains mythic dimensions. The weight of his suffering is mirrored in his weapon: the Dragonslayer, less a sword than an iron slab meant to crush apostles. It is poetic in its enormity, a monument of rage and grief as much as a weapon. Wielded as an extension of himself, it is revenge made steel. Each swing against demons is both combat and existential defiance. This physical excess is a metaphor of embodied masculinity: strength that is simultaneously burden and wound.</p><h3>The Brand and the Weight of Guilt</h3><p>The Brand of Sacrifice originates in one of the most harrowing moments in the entire manga — the Eclipse — where Griffith, in a moment of absolute despair and ambition, chooses to sacrifice the very comrades who built his dream alongside him. The brand is seared onto the flesh of Guts and Casca during the ritual invocation of the God Hand, marking them as offerings to demons and forever binding them to the nightmarish consequences of Griffith’s ascension. Miura renders this scene with gut-wrenching visual intensity: bodies contorted in terror, apostles descending in grotesque waves, and the helplessness of the branded as they are hunted like prey. The brand is not just a mark, it is a wound born from betrayal and cosmic cruelty, symbolizing the deepest imaginable violation of trust, loyalty, and love.</p><p>For Guts, the Brand becomes a permanent reminder of the trauma he failed to prevent: the slaughter of the Band of the Falcon, the brutal loss of comrades he considered family, and the violence inflicted upon Casca before his eyes. For Casca, the Brand is an even more intimate horror; it signifies the moment her agency and humanity were shattered. Their marks bleed in unison, drawing demons toward them, but they also bind the two survivors together in a shared fate neither chose. The Brand becomes the cruel knot between them, born of the same catastrophe, yet interpreted through different wounds.</p><p>This shared marking creates a tragic paradox: they are united by the very trauma that nearly destroyed them. Their relationship is thereafter shaped by the brand’s dual significance; Guts’ drive for vengeance and Casca’s need for safety. While Guts fights against fate with relentless fury, Casca retreats inward, embodying the quiet endurance of someone trying to survive overwhelming pain. Their divergence mirrors the contrast between Guts and Griffith. Guts, branded against his will, resists his imposed destiny; Griffith, unbranded and ascended as Femto, embraces fate by sacrificing others to achieve his dream.</p><p>In this contrast, Miura poses a profound question: what defines a person’s relationship to fate? Griffith chooses power at the cost of humanity; Guts chooses humanity at the cost of peace. The Brand thus becomes a narrative fulcrum — one that reveals the moral chasm between the two men. Where Griffith sees destiny as a ladder to climb regardless of who must fall, Guts sees destiny as a chain to shatter, even if it tears his hands to pieces.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/600/1*zpuI7pn-n2-JvGJD3EMtGA.jpeg" /></figure><p>The Brand of Sacrifice, etched into the flesh as a small, jagged, cross-like sigil that seeps blood whenever evil draws near, is both curse and moral compass. MidnightMoth (2021) interprets it not merely as a supernatural beacon for monsters but as emblematic of survivor’s guilt. Their essay delves into how the Brand externalizes inner torment, framing it as a constant reminder of responsibility and loss. MidnightMoth argues that Miura uses the Brand to embody guilt in physical form, ensuring that trauma is never repressed but forcibly confronted. The conclusion drawn is that Guts’ survival is not simply biological but ethical: he must continually choose whether guilt becomes corrosive or transformative. This reading enriches our understanding of the Brand as not only curse but as philosophical device, grounding Miura’s work in reflections on trauma, penance, and moral direction. Each night’s torment externalizes his trauma. His existence in the “interstice” between worlds mirrors his psychological liminality — never at peace, never fully human nor fully damned.</p><p>Yet the Brand becomes a tether. Over time, Guts transforms guilt into responsibility. Protecting Casca and accepting companions shifts the mark’s meaning from damnation to reminder. His fellowship grows: Farnese, a zealot turned devotee of Casca; Serpico, her loyal attendant whose cunning complements Guts’ brute force; Puck, the mischievous elf who relieves despair with levity; Isidro, a fiery youth who apprentices under him; Schierke, the prodigious witch whose magic anchors his mind when the Berserker Armor overwhelms him; and the cryptic Skull Knight, who guides him at turning points. Even Godot, the reclusive ironsmith, shelters Casca and reforges Guts’ weapon, embodying the quiet support he once scorned. These figures, together, create a surrogate family that tempers his rage and makes survival bearable.</p><h3>Masculinity, the Beast of Darkness and Allostatic Overload</h3><p>Miura probes cultural constructions of masculinity through the Beast of Darkness. Thomas (2022) notes that hegemonic masculinity equates strength with stoicism and violence. In her essay, she expands on how cultural expectations demand men repress vulnerability, equating care with weakness. Applied to Guts, Thomas’ analysis reveals that his early embodiment of this destructive script isolates him further, while his gradual embrace of tenderness offers a counter-model. Her conclusion is that Miura’s narrative critiques these norms by showing that true strength lies in the ability to accept interdependence and vulnerability. Thus, Thomas situates Guts not only as a tragic hero but as a vehicle for questioning and revising what masculinity should mean in contemporary culture.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/736/1*zbfAylwXBtVdtL2l4x0Nzg.jpeg" /></figure><p>The Beast dramatizes this model: an inner predator urging Guts to collapse into rage. Amplified by the Berserker Armor, it grants terrifying strength at devastating cost. The Beast is both psychological metaphor and cultural critique. To yield is to go berserk — indiscriminately dangerous to his loved ones, isolated, consumed by violence. To resist is to model an alternative strength grounded in restraint and care.</p><p>Schierke proves decisive here. During the battle with Grunbeld, when the Berserker Armor nearly consumes him, she projects her mind into his, directly confronting the Beast. Anchored by memories of Casca and his comrades, Guts pulls back from the brink. This moment allegorizes impending psychosis: overwhelming emotion and trauma threaten his humanity, yet relational support rescues him. Miura thus frames survival not only as will but as interdependence.</p><p>In understanding this moment through the lens of psychosomatic medicine, Miura’s depiction aligns strikingly with contemporary research on how overwhelming stress, trauma, and emotional overload can distort perception, compromise executive functioning, and precipitate dissociative or near-psychotic states. Psychosomatic scholarship emphasizes that chronic exposure to extreme stressors produces what McEwen terms “allostatic overload,” wherein the brain’s adaptive mechanisms begin to malfunction under cumulative strain, impairing judgment, emotional regulation, and bodily awareness (Fava et al., 2017). Guts’ Berserker Armor battle with Grunbeld can be read as an embodied dramatization of this overload: his sensory field narrows, pain signals are muted, and rage becomes his primary organizing principle — mirroring how trauma-induced alterations to the HPA axis and limbic system can eclipse higher cognitive control.</p><p>Moreover, psychosomatic studies show that relational support — what Fava calls the buffering effect of interpersonal connection — is often the decisive factor in interrupting escalating dysregulation. Schierke’s intervention functions as precisely such a psychosomatic corrective. By entering his psyche and reasserting relational meaning through Casca’s face and the loyalty of his companions, she restores emotional grounding and interrupts the neuropsychological cascade toward dehumanization. This parallels findings that social support moderates stress responses, reduces cortisol secretion, and helps reintegrate fragmented affective states during crisis (Fava et al., 2017). In this sense, Miura’s narrative mirrors clinical insights: healing is not simply the cessation of pain but the restoration of connection.</p><p>The moment also reflects the principles identified in psychosomatic treatment research regarding the integration of mind and body. Trauma does not exist merely as memory but becomes embedded in musculature, pain pathways, and autonomic arousal — manifesting as what is described as somatic symptoms secondary to psychological distress. The Berserker Armor literalizes this: it fuses psychological torment with somatic amplification, blurring the line between body and mind. Guts’ near-collapse into transformative monstrosity mirrors how chronic trauma can produce dissociative embodiment, where individuals feel overtaken by impulses alien to their conscious selves.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/736/1*yLfHF0l__T1J74jy__gQog.jpeg" /></figure><p>Finally, Schierke’s psychic intervention functions analogously to what psychosomatic clinicians describe as macroanalytic therapeutic interruption; locating the specific moment where symptoms escalate and reestablishing narrative coherence. Her guidance offers Guts a “psychological anchor,” a restorative image that recalibrates the stress response and arrests the spiraling autonomic collapse. In this way, Miura’s depiction resonates with psychosomatic medicine’s central claim: that healing emerges not from suppressing symptoms but from reweaving psychological, relational, and bodily threads into a coherent whole.</p><p>Here, the collapse into monstrosity is thus reframed not only as a narrative turning point but as a psychosomatic crisis: an embodied expression of accumulated allostatic load and trauma-driven dysregulation. This collapse is not an aberration but the logical endpoint of a cultural script equating strength with domination. The Berserker Armor makes this collapse literal: the more Guts channels rage, the more he becomes physically monstrous. Yet Miura refuses to end the story there. By tethering Guts back through Schierke and his companions, the narrative demonstrates that tenderness and vulnerability are not supplements to masculinity but necessary correctives. This radicalizes Berserk as a cultural text: it insists that true heroism lies not in rejecting weakness but in reconstituting strength through connection and care.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/720/1*6purNBz_jLnPULkRadvgow.jpeg" /></figure><h3>Post-Traumatic Growth and Relational Healing</h3><p>Guts’ journey, while deeply wounding, also exhibits trajectories of post-traumatic growth as forms of strength that emerge not from isolation but from connection. His transformation from a solitary, distrustful wanderer into a figure capable of mentoring, protecting, and emotionally attuning to others exemplifies this shift. Rather than reinforcing the trope of the lone warrior, Miura reframes Guts’ healing as relational: his growth is inseparable from the bonds he chooses to nurture.</p><p>Each of Guts’ key relationships functions as a case study in trauma-informed healing. <strong>Casca</strong>, once his equal and later rendered vulnerable by the Eclipse, becomes the center of his protective impulse, her presence grounds his rage and redirects his purpose toward care. <strong>Farnese</strong>, initially a zealot driven by fear and repression, transforms under Guts’ example; witnessing his endurance teaches her emotional regulation and courage. <strong>Schierke</strong> provides the spiritual and psychological scaffolding Guts lacks, acting as both healer and moral compass, counterbalancing his self-destructive impulses. <strong>Isidro</strong>, the reckless but eager youth, reflects the possibility of generative mentorship: through guiding him, Guts rehearses healthier expressions of responsibility and nurturance.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/736/1*JAGYXx7AJhzdrcA80_absQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>Together, these relationships illustrate that Guts’ strength is no longer defined solely by resistance, rage, or physical endurance. It expands into the realm of emotional responsibility and mutual growth. Miura thus depicts a nuanced model of post-traumatic resilience — one in which healing is not a solitary ascent, but a shared reconstruction of trust, community, and meaning.</p><p>The most radical evolution in Guts’ arc is his turn to tenderness. The man who once abandoned Casca to pursue vengeance ultimately prioritizes her safety over Griffith’s pursuit. His acceptance of companions — Puck’s irreverence, Isidro’s admiration, Farnese’s devotion, Schierke’s guidance — rebuilds trust piece by piece. Having established safety and engaged remembrance, Guts now enters reconnection. His mentorship of Isidro, his reliance on Schierke’s wisdom, and his trust in Farnese dramatize post-traumatic growth. The new “Band” is not bound by Griffith’s ambition but by mutual care. Tenderness, fragile yet deliberate, is his most subversive act in a brutal world. To protect rather than to dominate, to love rather than to destroy, becomes the deepest expression of strength.</p><p>Guts’ interactions with children and vulnerable figures, such as Isidro or the traumatized Casca, reveal a reluctant paternalism that directly counters the destructive scripts of hegemonic masculinity. These moments are radical in their context: within a seinen manga famed for violence and brutality, Miura dares to present nurturing as heroic. The caretaking Guts models becomes a cultural counterpoint, suggesting that resilience and protection are inseparable from vulnerability and empathy.</p><h3>Philosophical Positioning</h3><p>Guts’ saga resonates profoundly on philosophical grounds. <em>The Artifice</em> (2019) frames him as Sisyphean: condemned to ceaseless struggle (The Artifice, 2019). Unlike Sisyphus, however, Guts finds intermittent meaning in companionship and responsibility. His refusal to lay down his sword echoes Nietzsche’s eternal recurrence — the demand to live as though one would choose the same life again. He affirms existence, not through triumph but by persisting in the face of futility. Camus’ Absurd, the clash between human longing for meaning and an indifferent universe, resonates in his nightly battles with demons; yet he asserts dignity through defiance. Sartre’s notion of facticity i.e. the unalterable weight of one’s circumstances, is dramatized in his and Casca’s branded bodies, testifying to trauma that cannot be erased, only carried.</p><p>Philosophically, then, Guts’ journey suggests that absurdity and facticity need not paralyze; they can become conditions for authentic action when one chooses solidarity over isolation. Miura’s artistry reinforces this insight through quiet panels of respite between battles: fleeting images of Guts’ face softened by contentment, gratitude, or fragile peace. These interludes: campfires with companions, a gentle glance at Casca, a moment of laughter, mirror Camus’ interpretation of Sisyphus on his descent, after the rock has rolled back down. Just as Sisyphus finds dignity not only in the ascent but in the return to the valley, Guts finds fleeting humanity in these pauses, affirming that strength is not only in struggle but also in the brief, luminous reprieves from it.</p><h3>Survivor, Not Victim</h3><p>Even as Guts turns away from vengeance and directs his strength toward his own healing and the fragile restoration of Casca, he enters every battle prepared to die. This readiness is not recklessness but a deliberate stance: he knows the world will always batter him with cruelty, yet he insists that the choice of how to face it remains his. To fight until the end is his assertion of agency in a hostile universe.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/736/1*T1--WCRlZlpK5rMAoW1MQQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>Seen in full, Guts emerges as a figure of layered contradictions. He is an abuse survivor carrying scars of distance and distrust, a young man burdened with responsibilities beyond measure, and a reluctant guardian who refuses to lose those he loves again. <em>Berserk</em> is therefore not simply a chronicle of suffering in a merciless world; it is a testament to endurance. Above all, Guts is not defined as a victim. He is marked instead as a survivor¸ tragic, yes, but also enduring. In following the path of this so‑called unstoppable force, readers are invited to reflect on the quiet but radical power of persistence. However heightened the violence, however supernatural the setting, the heart of his story teaches a deeply human lesson: that survival itself, chosen again and again, can be the most profound act of defiance.</p><h3>Conclusion</h3><p>Guts complicates this archetype of the solitary warrior. His life testifies to trauma’s devastation, will’s resilience, guilt’s corrosiveness, and the dangers of traditional hegemonic strength, where dominance and suppression are mistaken for resilience. Yet it also demonstrates transformation: wounds becoming responsibility, solitude yielding to solidarity, rage flowering into tenderness. He is both Struggler and redeemer, proof that true strength is relational. His greatest feats are not counted in the demons he has slain or the apostles he has felled, but in the lives he has shaped for the better: Farnese, who abandons fanaticism under his influence to become a devoted protector; Serpico, whose loyalty deepens through witnessing Guts’ integrity; Isidro, who grows from reckless thief into earnest disciple under his reluctant mentorship; Schierke, who finds courage and identity in supporting him; and even Casca, whose fragile survival depends on his constant care. Through them, Guts demonstrates that his true legacy is not only survival but transformation — the capacity to redeem and reorient those around him toward resilience and compassion.</p><p>His legacy lies not in final triumph but in refusal to be broken. The series itself remains unfinished, and his confrontation with Griffith unresolved, yet the impact is already clear. He redefines the meaning of strength for readers, not as domination or victory, but as the capacity to endure, to protect, and to love. In a cultural moment enthralled by power, <em>Berserk</em> insists, through Guts, that the ultimate act of power is to nurture and connect. <em>Berserk</em> redefines what it means to be strong in late modernity: not conquest, but care. Guts’ story endures as a meditation on survival, struggle, and the radical possibility of tenderness, leaving us with a vision of strength that is ethical, soft, relational, and deeply human.</p><figure><img alt="Author’s recreation of a popular fan art of Guts — a resilient smile" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/597/1*XscKpa9WEcaeMb7x6Es3aQ.jpeg" /></figure><h3>References</h3><p>· <strong>Allen, B., &amp; Lauterbach, D.</strong> (2007). <em>Personality characteristics of adult survivors of childhood abuse.</em> Journal of Traumatic Stress, 20(4), 587–595. <a href="https://doi.org/10.1002/jts.20195">https://doi.org/10.1002/jts.20195</a></p><p>· <strong>Beeney, J. E., et al.</strong> (2017). <em>Disorganized Attachment and Personality Functioning in Adults: A Latent Class Analysis.</em> Personality Disorders: Theory, Research, and Treatment, 8, 206–216.</p><p>· <strong>Berserk Wiki.</strong> (Accessed 2025). <em>Guts.</em> Available at: <a href="https://berserk.fandom.com/wiki/Guts?utm_source=chatgpt.com">https://berserk.fandom.com/wiki/Guts</a></p><p>· <strong>Daud, A., Skoglund, E., &amp; Rydelius, P.-A.</strong> (2008). <em>Children in families of torture victims: Transgenerational transmission of stress and mental health.</em> Scandinavian Journal of Public Health, 36(5), 475–483.</p><p>· <strong>Evans, Casey.</strong> (2020). <em>Guts and Berserk: A Character Study on Human Will and Perseverance.</em> Medium.<br> Available at: <a href="https://medium.com/@CaseyEvans_/guts-and-berserk-a-character-study-on-human-will-and-perseverance-cae30198a8f4">https://medium.com/@CaseyEvans_/guts-and-berserk-a-character-study-on-human-will-and-perseverance-cae30198a8f4</a></p><p>· <strong>Fava, G. A., Cosci, F., Guidi, J., &amp; Tomba, E.</strong> (2017). <em>Allostatic overload in psychopathology: Toward a transdiagnostic understanding.</em> Psychotherapy and Psychosomatics, 86(2), 69–85.</p><p>· <strong>Martínez Shepherd, Axel.</strong> (2023). <em>Beyond the Guts and Viscera: The Nuanced Masculinity of Kentaro Miura’s Berserk.</em><br> Available at: https://www.academia.edu/106447177/Beyond_the_Guts_and_Viscera_The_Nuanced_Masculinity_of_Kentaro_Miuras_Berserk</p><p>· <strong>MidnightMoth.</strong> (2021). <em>The Weight of the Brand: Guts and the Philosophy of Guilt in Berserk.</em> Medium.<br> Available at: <a href="https://medium.com/@midnightmoth303/the-weight-of-the-brand-guts-and-the-philosophy-of-guilt-in-berserk-4d9071cc230f">https://medium.com/@midnightmoth303/the-weight-of-the-brand-guts-and-the-philosophy-of-guilt-in-berserk-4d9071cc230f</a></p><p>· <strong>Miura, Kentarō.</strong> (1989–2021). <em>Berserk.</em> Hakusensha.</p><p>· <strong>Nijenhuis, E. R. S., van der Hart, O., &amp; Steele, K.</strong> (2010). <em>Trauma-related structural dissociation of the personality and the biopsychosocial model of PTSD.</em> European Journal of Psychotraumatology, 1(1).</p><p>· <strong>Pitman, R. K., Rasmusson, A. M., Koenen, K. C., et al.</strong> (2012). <em>Biological studies of post-traumatic stress disorder.</em> Nature Reviews Neuroscience, 13, 769–787.</p><p>· <strong>The Artifice.</strong> (2019). <em>Berserk and the Myth of Sisyphus.</em><br> Available at: <a href="https://the-artifice.com/berserk-sisyphus/?utm_source=chatgpt.com">https://the-artifice.com/berserk-sisyphus/</a></p><p>· <strong>Thomas, Sophie.</strong> (2022). <em>We Need to Talk About Masculinity.</em> Substack.<br> Available at: <a href="https://sophiethomasfitlosophy.substack.com/p/we-need-to-talk-about-masculinity">https://sophiethomasfitlosophy.substack.com/p/we-need-to-talk-about-masculinity</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d59d7c425869" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>