<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Savannah Marciezyk on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Savannah Marciezyk on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@savannahmarciezyk?source=rss-b8313f8d5ecf------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Fri, 20 Nov 2026 12:52:34 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@savannahmarciezyk/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Deconstructing a Deconstruction]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@savannahmarciezyk/deconstructing-a-deconstruction-1bdbaeee4fde?source=rss-b8313f8d5ecf------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/1bdbaeee4fde</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Savannah Marciezyk]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 18 Sep 2014 03:18:41 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2014-09-18T03:18:41.495Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>This post is in response to “I Am Not All About That Bass: Deconstructing The Summer’s Feel-Good, Body-Positive Hit,” which can be found in its original form by following this link. <a href="http://jennytrout.com/?p=7857">http://jennytrout.com/?p=7857</a></p><p>This statement will seem obvious to most of you, but I’ll put it out there for the sake of this argument. I am a feminist — a raging, angry, passionate feminist who cares deeply about the inequalities in our world that exist between men and women. I attend one of the world’s oldest and most prestigious women’s colleges, where it’s considered a rite of passage to take a course in Gender Studies, and my friends and I discuss popular feminist theories over lunch. That being said, I also understand that not everybody is a feminist (though they probably should be), or more accurately, that not everybody is as well versed or educated in the terms, theories and concepts surrounding feminism. I know Meghan Trainor personally. We attended the same high school, graduated together and occasionally were in the same class. I don’t know her as well as some — I wouldn’t exactly refer to us as friends — but I spent enough time with her in high school to know that she is a bright, talented and kind person who is passionate about music and is completely deserving of her new fame.</p><p>So, let’s begin where Ms. Trout does, shall we?</p><p>She first criticizes that though the opening lyrics say the speaker is “all about that bass,” she’s actually singing in a treble voice. She then moves on to criticize Ms. Trainor’s vocal abilities. Now, there are two things very wrong with these beginning critiques: First, of course the song is not going to be sung solely from the range of a bass. Yes, that would be boring, but in case you missed every English class ever, Ms. Trout, Trainor is using what we like to call a metaphor, which helps bring the abstract into a more understandable state. The song is not <em>literally </em>all about bass, the song is <em>figuratively </em>about bass. Second, I have heard Meghan Trainor sing live numerous times, and happen to know that not only is she a highly talented singer and song writer with a wide range, she also knows music theory better than anyone else I know, with the possible exception of our high school band director. Telling her that a song with only bass is boring is like telling a poet that they use words to write their stuff: it’s obvious and insulting.</p><p>The next point made by Trout is that Trainor has no right to complain about her body type because she isn’t subject to the kind of prejudice or shame that women who actually fall into a plus-size category are.</p><p>Let’s take a minute to define “plus-size.” Depending on who you ask, this category can range anywhere from size 12 to above a size 18. If you ask me, that’s a pretty broad range of sizes to lump into the same category. And additionally, let’s take into account Trainor’s age, which is about 20, and think about the types of clothing that have been marketed to her up to this point. Abercrombie and Fitch, a hugely popular brand for girls in the area that Meghan and I grew up, creates no size over a size 12. Take into account that their ratio of inches to size is pretty skewed compared to other women’s companies, such as Anne Taylor or LL Bean, and this size 12 pretty quickly becomes closer to an eight. Forever21, which for most was the next big retailer, similarly defines their plus-size line, which they JUST started this past year, at size 12.</p><p>During our adolescent and teen years, women’s bodies go through a diverse set of changes. Some develop wider hips, larger thighs or bigger breasts. Some don’t. All are equally beautiful, but all are also equally subjected to the same kind of scrutiny by our peers, a scrutiny that is highly influenced by the media’s photoshopped and detrimental view of women and the way their bodies should look. From what I know of why Trainor wrote this song, she felt a lot like I did when I was in middle and high school. My body was doing things I didn’t understand, while the bodies of the girls around me were doing completely different things. They were smaller, I was not. So imagine you’re shopping with your friends, and while they fit into size fours and sixes, you barely manage to squeeze your hips into a size 12, and all of a sudden, you’re deemed “plus-size.” Now, I personally disagree with the fact that a size 12 is a plus-size, but I didn’t think that way as a 15- or 17- or even 20-year-old. I thought that if my body didn’t fit into the same sizes as my friends that I was fat, and I felt extremely insecure about the way I looked.</p><p>What angers me most about this part of Trout’s article, though, is the fact that she has the audacity to invalidate the feelings expressed in this song because she deems Trainor to be too skinny to feel insecure. In all honesty, how fucking dare you negate someone’s personal experience. That is something you should have learned in any sort of critical social thought 101 class — that everybody’s story of oppression, insecurity or shame is valid, accepted and takes courage to share. “All About That Bass” creates dialogue about what the standard of beauty is in our culture, and I think that anyone who openly criticizes the way our society views and dissects the way that women look should be championed, regardless of the way they themselves look.</p><p>Next, Trout makes a point that I somewhat begrudgingly agree with. The song is body positive, but encourages women to seek validation through the way men view them (“boys like a little more booty to hold at night”). While this is a problematic and heternormative way to define one’s self-worth — I wouldn’t expect Trainor to know that. She, as far I as I know, has not spent a single day of her life devoted to studying heteronormativity or the way society forces women to determine their worth. This is not to say that Trainor is unintelligent or uneducated, far from it actually. I mean to point out that Trainor has not taken any formal courses on these subjects at institutions of higher learning. After high school, Trainor moved to Nashville to pursue her dreams instead of attending college. Not a bad trade off if you ask me.</p><p>Trout also criticizes how “All About That Bass” has a line including the phrase “skinny bitches,” and complains about how this under mines the overall ‘body positive’ message of the song. To think that Trainor is intentionally working to make others feel bad about their body is counterintuitive to the song’s entire existence, and further more, Trainor herself is making fun of the trope commonly used in pop. Take for example the recent hit “Anaconda” by Nicki Menaj. This is a song that is seriously and unapologetically about bringing down “skinny bitches in the club.” The phrases in “All About That Base” don’t strive to make women with slimmer body types feel badly about themselves, but rather express that all women, regardless of their body type, will feel insecure about themselves at some point in their lives, because that is the nature of the society in which we live. Further, Trout criticizes Trainor for refusing to be a stick figure, which shouldn’t be problematic — it should be applauded. For girls and women globally who’s body types don’t fit their society’s idea of “beauty,” overcoming the extreme pressure to change one’s body in a way that is unhealthy is outrageously difficult. In the United States, 20 million girls and women and 10 million boys and men suffer from eating disorders like Anorexia Nervosa and Bulimia according to nationaleatingdisorders.org. If Trainor wants to stick a middle finger to all those people who have and will pressure her to become a “stick figure Barbie Doll,” then I say let her.</p><p>The final issue Trout has is with Trainor’s video is that she see’s black women used as props to uphold white standards of beauty. On this, I will say three things. First, that I think the video is actually quite diverse in dancers, and that to take three screenshots from a three minute video is an inaccurate sample. Second, the problem of possession of black bodies in our culture (not just women, mind you) is a real problem, a problem that I will allow those who have experienced it to speak about in their own terms. I claim no knowledge of this struggle, and do not wish to silence others about their experience surrounding race and privilege. Finally, these judgements about the video beg the question about how much artistic control an artist has over who is cast in their videos, its choreography and overall tone. I would think this control would be even less for a first-time star like Trainor.</p><p>I will end this with two final thoughts, of which I think perhaps the second is more important than the first. There’s this fancy thing that we who study literary criticism like to call “Reader Response Theory” (sorry if I lose you here, Trout, I know English isn’t your best subject). According to Reader Response Theory, the intent of the artist does not matter once their work has been set out into the world. How the reader (or listener, in this case) responds to the work is the only thing that matters. I, however, am inclined to disagree with this theory, generally, but specifically in reference to “All About That Bass,” I’m even more inclined to disagree. I think that Trainor’s intent here is extremely important. Meghan Trainor has said numerous times in numerous interviews that her intent was not the write the “body-positive anthem of the summer.” She simply set out to write a song that was empowering, had a good beat and spoke to an issue she cared about. To claim that as an “anthem” this song must be flawless in its consciousness of every feminist and racial issue in our world is to ignore the artist’s intent, which was not to create an anthem at all. Additionally, I would encourage Trout to try and come up with a song that has spoken to so many people, and very positively, that doesn’t offend someone, somewhere.</p><p>My final thought is one more simple. Deconstruction is a type of analysis that looks at systems, and how the parts within systems function to make meaning. If you find that a part within a system is flawed, rather than criticizing that specific part, perhaps you should instead look at the system as a whole to find where flaws truly lie.</p><p>Oh, P.S.: When you grow up where Meghan and I grew up, you quickly learn that we have a sense of community so strong it’s hard to verbalize. To anyone looking to criticize her personally — rather than just her art — beware. I know I speak for a lot of people when I say that we will always have her back, regardless of how far away from our oceanside home we all are.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=1bdbaeee4fde" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>