<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Sarah Wagoner on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Sarah Wagoner on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@scaredbisexual?source=rss-f25bcac2209f------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Thu, 19 Nov 2026 13:15:59 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@scaredbisexual/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[‘The Loneliest Sound in the World’: Queer Isolation in ‘Pluribus’]]></title>
            <link>https://scaredbisexual.medium.com/the-loneliest-sound-in-the-world-queer-isolation-in-pluribus-52cebc8f9cd1?source=rss-f25bcac2209f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/52cebc8f9cd1</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[isolation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[anti-ai]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[queer]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[lesbianism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[pluribus]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Sarah Wagoner]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 10 Mar 2026 22:43:35 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-03-10T22:43:35.035Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*GMfOY1PeVoBYGcYDhYG-bw.jpeg" /><figcaption>The Others contact Carol</figcaption></figure><p>Spoilers for <em>Pluribus</em> included throughout essay</p><p>The American alien invasion subgenre is fascinating for how often it encapsulates queer fears of forced assimilation all while framing the monsters as closer to us than our heterosexual counterparts. The real horror of 50s alien invasion films were asexual communists who sought to destroy the nuclear family. <em>Alien </em>(1979) acted as a spark of light, pointing this finger at capitalism rather than communism. In the late 70s through the 80s, there were a few remakes of 50s B-movies, such as Tobe Hooper’s <em>Invaders from Mars</em> (1986) which continued <em>Alien</em>’s mission by framing the tradition of the nuclear family as the true assimilative monster. <em>Alien</em> itself speaks to queer themes, though with a more pointed edge in its presentation of female masculinity and found family in <em>Aliens </em>(1986).</p><p>Yet, these queer themes rarely present themselves in American invasion narratives past the 80s. Tim Burton’s <em>Mars Attacks</em> (1996) may be considered a campy classic by many queer film-lovers. However, it does not speak to any particular queer issues, or even fears of assimilation. If it has any serious concerns, it is only in the realm of nuclear war. And after 9/11, the fear of assimilation was replaced by fear of extraterrestrial terrorist attacks. This isn’t to say there have been no subversive American invasion narratives. Jordan Peele’s <em>Nope </em>(2022) famously and effectively uses a truly alien force to reflect the perils of a spectacle-obsessed culture. However, it is similarly not concerned with assimilationist tactics. <em>Pluribus</em>, however, focuses on assimilationist forces in order to examine queer isolation through its lesbian lead, Carol (Rhea Seehorn).</p><p><em>Pluribus</em>’ alien hordes do not attack humankind with their advanced weapons nor is their body-snatching as visceral as their predecessors. Rather, they infect humankind with a unifying virus to which Carol and a few other survivors are immune. Human bodies are now alien, but helpful aliens who call Carol to ask if she would prefer avocado toast from her favorite restaurant for breakfast. They are incapable of lying, as evidenced in their attempts at silence when asked about their plans. They are even radical vegans, refusing to even harm plants under the assumption that they are living organisms who are not to be harmed. Nearly every immediate terrifying aspect of the alien invasion is dispelled, making them seem perfect. But the real terror is their elimination of human qualities.</p><p>This horror premise could be merely another individualism narrative within the genre, if one which does not rely on common horror conventions to make a point about conformity. Without Carol’s sexuality, I likely would read it as a modern remake of <em>Invasion of the Body Snatchers </em>(1956) that casts capital and the disconnection proliferated by technology as the true threat rather than communism or Cold War witch hunters. However, her lesbianism, and even the loss of her wife, is directly connected to her aversion to the uncanny joy on display.</p><p><strong>Carol’s Conformity; or Why Would a Lesbian Write Straight Romantasy?</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Ck4zjf5TjoFNJl8KqElEqw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Carol at her book reading/signing at Barnes and Nobles</figcaption></figure><p>Carol is introduced through her art as she is first seen signing a trove of her <em>Wycaro</em> book series: a pirate romance series. Her flock of fans reflect the usual suspects, namely assumed straight middle-aged women. As she flicks her pen, they voice concerns about the appearance of Raban, the strapping male lead, suggesting they are not necessarily reading for the high-sea adventures. While Carol engages with her fans, she has a hint of sarcasm in her town that grows throughout the series. The monotony of her success is honed in on, as her fans speak to her in an excited tone that she hits back with her dry responses and pure focus on the signing process. Her unhappiness is connected to her success, as this art does not reflect that which she wants to create.</p><p>Before her sexuality is revealed, it is implied that she is not writing about straight romance out of her own interest in the genre. She argues with Helen (Miriam Shor), her lover and manager, about whether what she makes is genuinely art. Carol throws out criticism of the typical genre conventions, including the misogyny in having a female lead focus on a haughty male pirate. Carol’s disdain for her conformity emerges as she engages with her wife, angry that she has built a career on straight romance and even the misogyny within it. We learn later that Carol was taken to a ‘pray the gay away’ camp. So her adolescent romantic tendencies were punished with assimilative violence, speaking to her simultaneous impulse to conform and rebel against calls for assimilation by smiley, happy ‘people’. Her hatred for her own creation reflects her hatred for this tendency to conform, as her artistic assimilation fits in with what her abusers demanded of her. The only counterbalance for this self-hatred was Helen.</p><p><strong>Helen as Humanity</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*rVqpi_nK9Zza6rMonk5vWQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Helen and Carol after freezing Carol’s eggs.</figcaption></figure><p>Helen’s retort: “If you make one person happy, maybe that’s not art. But it’s something” (“We Is Us”, 23:23–23:24) largely uplifts the common reading of the show as anti-AI in favor of imperfect, perhaps mediocre, human-made art (Upadhyaya, 2025). And I certainly agree with this reading. But I also read this as grace from Helen in understanding Carol’s self-hatred. In this statement, she focuses less on Carol’s harsh definitions, but on what she brings to the world. She tells Carol that she should revisit her serious novel, encouraging her to do more for herself while avoiding putting down her work. She provides choice to Carol as Carol feels that she is destined for mediocrity. Helen highlights the happier possibilities within queerness for Carol. Yes, partially due to their mutual sexual and romantic interests. But she is also unconditionally supportive in a uniquely human way. She displays the best of queer kinship through patience and acceptance.</p><p>Helen is the center of humanity for Carol, with her destruction acting as the beginning of the end for humanity itself. This is a fascinating subversion of how humanity is signified within the 1950s alien invasion subgenre. The nuclear family is typically the representation of humanity, with the implication that white, Christian Americans are those who must be saved. Within this structure, the death of humanity tends to start with the corruption of the patriarch. In <em>Invaders from Mars</em> (1953), the father (Leif Erickson) turns from the all-American role model into an abusive monster once he has been infected by the aliens. He disobeys the law, demands complete service from his family, and even slaps his own son. Given his son’s (Jimmy Hunt) representation of the American youth, his corruption implies further destruction of America’s bright future. Everything hinges on the leadership of the father, implying that the maintenance of the nuclear family is of the utmost importance to the health of humanity.</p><p>Meanwhile, Helen is a lesbian wife, disconnected from a nuclear family, which is noted by the adherence to a patriarchal make-up. Her importance is not in how she may affect her potential children, but in her positive impact on her partner. Even as the audience later learns that Carol and Helen planned on having children, the devastation of Helen’s death is not centered on her failure to become a mother. When she dies during the arrival of the alien hive mind (henceforth referred to as the Others), tragedy arises from the emotional connection she had with Carol as well the hopeful future she represented by her very queer optimism. Her signifying relationship to humanity is in the unconditional love she brings to Carol, which is directly contrasted with the conditional support of the Others.</p><p><strong>All Alone in a Full World</strong></p><p>Unlike other apocalyptic stories, Carol is filled with a world of existing human bodies. They are not morbidly transformed like zombies nor do they essentially present any immediate signs of death. The hive mind latches on to human bodies, taking over their minds and seemingly presenting them a new life. The philosophical question of <em>Pluribus</em> then becomes whether a person is living if their mind is no longer their own. Carol refutes this idea, seeing that the complexities of individuals and even the sacred privacy of their memories is devalued by the hive mind’s erasure of individuality. Clearly, this calls to mind the primary conflict of <em>Invasion of the Body Snatchers</em> (1953, 1978). A primary difference in <em>Pluribus </em>is that the Others exist to serve the immune survivors including Carol. At first, this seems to be from the good of their hearts as they do not require Carol to become one of them. They only wish to serve. They only wish to make her happy. They grant every request without question or even safety concerns, harkening to the ‘customer is always right’ attitude deployed by AI chatbots (Mitchell, 2025). Carol’s loneliness grows with this constant service as she does question whether this is truly unconditional; a concern that is validated as she learns about the inner workings of the hive mind. But she also feels disconnected as she can see that there is a lack of unique individuality.</p><p>This is best represented when she speaks to the Others about her work (“Please, Carol”). She asks for specific details of what they appreciate about her writing, if there is anything unique brought forth from the memories of her fans. This is after she is provided harsh truths of Helen’s true thoughts on her work, displaying that the hive can provide specifics and is unable to access certain human abilities such as lying. This was a question about a specific person, however. When she asks the hive as a whole, they sing her praises, even conflating her quality of work with Shakespeare. I agree with Upadhyaya’s assertion that their inability to distinguish between artistic ventures because “it’s all just part of the same soup of information they’ve downloaded from each other” (“<em>Pluribus</em> Episode 4 Recap: AI Doesn’t Know What Makes Art Good”, 2025). Carol certainly has the same annoyances as real world artists when AI regurgitates our writings or summarizes our hard work with no attention to detail. But this annoyance with lack of specificity also speaks to a queer loneliness.</p><p>Queerness is defined by living on the outside of the mainstream, even as the mainstream attempts to swallow it up. Meanwhile AI serves to reproduce the most popular data, data which often includes homophobic, transphobic attitudes even if chatbots adhere to inclusive language. The stringent categorization of AI, for example, runs antithetical to the queer challenge of “the centrality and rigidity of the social categories that come to determine people’s lives” (Gáti, 2026). AI researchers have even found complex gendered wordplay is distinctly rejected by LLMs like ChatGPT under their working assumption of clean language that is simply not applicable to sexuality or gender exploration (Gáti, 2026). While Carol’s questions of the Others do not distinctly relate to her sexuality, their clean, happy answers relate to this sanitization of human language that suppresses the complexity of queer reality. Their insistence on uncomplicated happiness, for example, acts to suppress Carol’s want for deeper, messy exploration of her grief.</p><p>Carol is not the sole immune survivor, however, so she still has a possibility of human community. She reaches out to the other survivors, who do not share her same concerns about the ethics of the hive mind, nor even her sense of loneliness at the loss of family (“Pirate Lady”). There are a handful of survivors who disagree with Carol but the two most interesting are Koumba (Samba Schutte) and Laxmi (Menik Gooneratne). Koumba happily takes in the service of the Others. If we continue the AI parallels, he is comparable to a Pornhub member who takes advantage of their AI integration. He largely uses the affability of the Others to have sex with women’s bodies, though it is stated that he gains consent. Though this raises ethical questions, particularly for Carol, as the original owners of the bodies cannot consent to their usage (could this amount to necrophilia?) and even the Others’ consent is questionable as their primary goal is the happiness of the immune survivors. He is the first antithetical to Carol. Not only does he seem blissful at this apocalypse, and he is loved by the other survivors while Carol is despised for her pessimism. But he also represents a misogynist sexuality that is contrary to lesbianism, and often even fetishizes lesbian existence.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*JfpjesYPlNLOaPqvtssG6A.jpeg" /><figcaption>Koumba living happily in debauchery.</figcaption></figure><p>Carol is particularly disturbed by his nonchalant sexual relations with the Others, as he objectifies women’s bodies meanwhile she is hesitant to act on her sexual desires for her primary contact with the Others, Zosia (Karolina Wydra) due to a desire to maintain ethical relations. This reflects how queer women often fear our own sexuality, as we do not want to be objectifying predators, as we are often portrayed. It is also notable that he is accepted while Carol is rejected, as her group rejection does not directly relate to her queerness (she is not rejected for being a lesbian) but it is related to ethical concerns that stem from her queer worldview. As discussed, her critical view of the Others stems from her experience with conversion therapy and the social ecosystem of conformity. Again, she is punished for a resistance to assimilation.</p><p>While Koumba is Carol’s most immediate foil, no one is as antagonistic to Carol as Laxmi. Laxmi’s son was taken during the invasion, now being part of the hive mind. However, Laxmi doesn’t see this as the loss of her son, as she holds on to him even as he is no longer an individual. Carol is disturbed by this, pointing out how he shares knowledge with doctors, and can no longer have his own unique personality. Throughout the season, Laxmi angrily calls Carol to chastise her for her meltdowns which negatively impact the Others, including her son. Laxmi reflects the view of parenthood as a possessive act, only seeming to care about the physical presence of her son rather than him as an individual. Carol is her philosophical opponent because Carol is quick to point out that the beauty of parenthood should be in guiding children as they become their own person. Meanwhile Laxmi dismisses her for her lack of motherhood. While the other survivors reject Carol for her negative view of the Others and physical impacts on them, Laxmi seems more dismissive of her for her queerness.</p><p>No, she does not call her any slurs nor does she seem to know Carol’s sexuality. But she points out that Carol is not a mother and thus is illegitimate in her concerns, bringing to mind the arguments against queer people when their own concerns of heteronormative parenting are brought up. Carol’s parenting philosophy particularly points to queer ideology, as she is interested in the personhood of the child rather than what the child represents to the parents. This is not to say that queer parents can’t be possessive, but queer parenting philosophy tends to center the autonomy of the child through practices such as encouraging gender nonconformity (O’Reilly, p. 62). Similarly, the view of parents as guides in growing personhood relates more to queer and feminist views of parenthood. Regardless, it is notable that their antagonistic relationship stems from this different view of children, particularly as Carol lost her potential future children due to the loss of Helen.</p><p><strong>Lost Queer Future</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*kAZX4TkduFqXCmFaFFdwQg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Carol searches for a lost phone in a sewer vent.</figcaption></figure><p>Reproduction and assimilation go hand and hand in the alien invasion genre, with the family typically framed as essential in the human project. However the more progressive steps within the genre such as <em>Alien</em> trouble the heteronormative focus on reproductive futures, involving the role of motherhood within survivorship. In <em>Alien</em>, reproduction primary takes place as a horrific act as the result of assaults. As Ripley reaches motherhood in <em>Aliens</em>, it is a found family that highlights Ripley’s chosen motherhood over the more primal natural motherhood of the Alien Queen. Ripley herself even skirts the common image of cinematic mothers as hyper-feminine as she takes on a masculine form. And like <em>Alien</em>, <em>Pluribus</em> similarly introduces a non-traditional form of motherhood that challenges the common lament of a potential loss of heterosexual reproduction. In the third episode (“Grenade”), it is revealed that Helen and Carol planned to go through IVF treatment. In the finale, we even learn that the Others plan to extract stem cells from Carol’s frozen eggs to create a custom virus for her (“La Chica o El Mundo”) to complete the joining of the hive mind.</p><p>It would be easy to just say that this is clearly contrary to hegemonic motherhood because Helen and Carol are lesbian and self-evidently antithetical to concerns of heterosexual reproduction. After all, we don’t truly know if they would’ve fallen in line with progressive parenting philosophies. We don’t know if Carol would highlight gender nonconformity or let her child choose their own religion. But just as Helen provided a potential for positive future change through her encouragement of Carol’s creativity and discouragement of her more pessimistic attitudes, the child could also present opportunities for a positive queer future, both for Carol and the world itself. Some may say this Carol-centric view of its potential could have the same effects of how other invasion films center the child as representative for the nuclear family as a unit. But, this ignores that Carol’s previous discussions of children highlight their own personhood. This implies her own lost future child would represent the complex human experiences that could’ve continued had the Others not invaded. If we are to see humanness as a representative of artistic value in <em>Pluribus</em>, the child reflects the future of creativity. It is now taken, being manipulated by the uncaring void for its own reproductive purposes.</p><p><strong>Conclusion</strong></p><p>Post-COVID there are many discussions of a ‘loneliness epidemic’. Often this is deployed by fake concerned actors trying to garner sympathy for misogynistic boys that no one wants to play with. Though studies have shown a genuine epidemic across the gender and sexuality spectrum. The 2025 Stress in America survey reported that 54% of American adults felt isolated from others, with 50% also reporting a lack of companionship (APA, 2025). Meanwhile, studies consistently find that queer adults have increased levels of isolation (Hyland, 2025), with queer young adults particularly facing intense isolation due to mental health stigma during and following the COVID-19 pandemic (Ruprecht et al., 2024). Through Carol’s loss of a lover, group rejection, and possibly lost future (season 2 will be a long time coming at the time of writing, so who knows what could happen), <em>Pluribus</em> speaks to the queer specifics of isolation. On a show so focused on a pessimistic character, it is oddly comforting for queer viewers like me who often fear our isolation is of our own making. And it is certainly cathartic in how it speaks to fellow queer writers who fear our erasure is imminent.</p><p><strong>References</strong></p><p>American Psychological Association. (2025). <em>Stress in America 2025: A Crisis of Connection</em>.</p><p>APA. <a href="https://www.apa.org/pubs/reports/stress-in-america/2025">https://www.apa.org/pubs/reports/stress-in-america/2025</a>.</p><p>Burton, T. (Director). (1996). <em>Mars Attacks!</em> [Film]. Warner Bros. Pictures.</p><p>Cameron, J. (Director). (1986). <em>Aliens</em> [Film]. Brandywine Productions.</p><p>Gáti, D. (2026, Mar. 4). Category trouble: AI’s queer problem. <em>AI &amp; Society </em>(2026).</p><p><a href="https://doi.org/10.1007/s00146-025-02818-5">https://doi.org/10.1007/s00146-025-02818-5</a></p><p>Gilligan, V., Frost, J., Mercer, D., Ozarski, A., Smith, G., and Tatlock, A. (Executive Producers).</p><p>(2025-). <em>Pluribus</em> [TV series]. High Bridge Productions; Sony Pictures Television.</p><p>Gilligan, V. (Writer &amp; Director). (2025, Nov. 7). “Pirate Lady” (Season 1, Episode 2). [TV series</p><p>episode]. In Gilligan, V., Frost, J., Mercer, D., Ozarski, A., Smith, G., &amp; Tatlock, A.</p><p>(Executive Producers), <em>Pluribus</em>. High Bridge Productions; Sony Pictures Television.</p><p>Gilligan, V. (Writer &amp; Director). (2025, Nov. 7). “We Is Us” (Season 1, Episode 1). [TV series</p><p>episode]. In Gilligan, V., Frost, J., Mercer, D, Ozarski, A., Smith, G., &amp; Tatlock, A.</p><p>(Executive Producers), <em>Pluribus</em>. High Bridge Productions; Sony Pictures Television.</p><p>Hooper, T. (Director). (1986). <em>Invaders from Mars</em> [Film]. The Canon Group.</p><p>Hyland, M. (2025). Social Isolation and Loneliness Disparities Between Queer and Heterosexual</p><p>Older Adults. <em>Proquest Thesis</em>. <a href="https://doi.org/10.57912/28957883">https://doi.org/10.57912/28957883</a>.</p><p>Kaufman, P. (Director). (1978). <em>Invasion of the Body Snatchers</em> [Film]. United Artists.</p><p>Menzies, W,C. (Director). (1953). <em>Invaders from Mars </em>[Film]. Edward L. Alperson Productions.</p><p>Mitchell, H. (2025, June 25). <em>That Chatbot May Just Be Telling You What You Want to Hear</em>. The</p><p>Wall Street Journal. <a href="https://www.wsj.com/tech/ai/ai-chatbot-agree-flatter-users-1787e1a7">https://www.wsj.com/tech/ai/ai-chatbot-agree-flatter-users-1787e1a7</a>.</p><p>O’Reilly, A. (2024). Matricentric Feminism: A Feminism for Mothers. In <em>In (M)other Words:</em></p><p><em>Writings on Mothering and Motherhood</em>, 2009–2024 (pp. 51–72). Demeter Press.</p><p><a href="https://doi.org/10.2307/jj.14443769.7">https://doi.org/10.2307/jj.14443769.7</a>.</p><p>Peele, J. (Director). (2022). <em>Nope</em> [Film]. Monkeypaw Productions.</p><p>Ruprecht, M.M., Floresca, Y., Narla, S., Felt, D., Phillips II, G., Macapagal, K., and Philbin, M.M. (2024, May 17). “Being Queer, It Was Really Isolating”: Stigma and Mental Health</p><p>Among Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgender, and Queer (LGBTQ+) Young People</p><p>During COVID-19. <em>Health Education &amp; Behavior</em>, <em>51</em>(4), 521–532.</p><p>doi:10.1177/10901981241249973.</p><p>Scott, R. (Director). (1979). <em>Alien</em> [Film]. Brandywine Productions.</p><p>Siegel, D. (Director). (1956). <em>Invasion of the Body Snatchers</em> [Film]. Allied Artists Pictures.</p><p>Smith, G. (Writer &amp; Director). (2025, Nov. 14). “Grenade” (Season 1, Episode 3). [TV series</p><p>episode]. In Gilligan, V., Frost, J., Mercer, D., Ozarski, A., Smith G., &amp; Tatlock. A.</p><p>(Executive Producers), <em>Pluribus</em>. High Bridge Productions; Sony Pictures Television.</p><p>Smith, G. &amp; Tatlock, A. (Writers), &amp; Smith, G. (Director). (2025, Dec. 24). “La Chica o El</p><p>Mundo” (Season 1, Episode 9). [TV series episode]. In Gilligan, V., Frost, J., Mercer, D.,</p><p>Ozarski, A., Smith, G., &amp; Tatlock, A. (Executive Producers), <em>Pluribus</em>. High Bridge</p><p>Productions; Sony Pictures Television.</p><p>Tatlock, A. (Writer), &amp; Fuentes, Z. (Director). (2025, Nov. 21). “Please, Carol” (Season 1,</p><p>Episode 4). [TV series episode]. In Gilligan, V., Frost, J., Mercer, D., Ozarski, A., Smith,</p><p>G., and Tatlock, A. (Executive Producers), <em>Pluribus</em>. High Bridge Productions; Sony</p><p>Pictures Television.</p><p>Upadhyaya, K.K. (2025, Nov. 21). <em>Pluribus Episode 4 Recap: AI Doesn’t Know What Makes Art</em></p><p><em>Good</em>. Autostraddle. <a href="https://www.autostraddle.com/pluribus-episode-4-recap/">https://www.autostraddle.com/pluribus-episode-4-recap/</a>.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=52cebc8f9cd1" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Sins of Thy Father: Patriarchal Abuse and Violent Indoctrination in ’28 Years Later’]]></title>
            <link>https://scaredbisexual.medium.com/sins-of-thy-father-patriarchal-abuse-and-violent-indoctrination-in-28-years-later-5dc6337d7427?source=rss-f25bcac2209f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5dc6337d7427</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[gender-roles]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[28-years-later]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[film-reviews]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[apocalypse]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[deconstructing-faith]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Sarah Wagoner]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 28 Jun 2025 18:44:45 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-06-28T18:44:45.153Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*uejF23yZ5onHxOXaHTO3Lg.jpeg" /></figure><p>Spoiler Warning for <em>28 Years Later </em>and Trigger Warning for Familial Abuse and Brief Discussion of School Shootings</p><p>With the recent airing of the second season of <em>The Last of Us, </em>I have thought long on the series’ failure to truly contend with violence in the apocalypse. Yes, Joel is wrong, but it is always couched with viewers love for an anti-hero, for a man just trying to protect his loved one in problematic ways and getting his face bashed in for it. This failure is particularly disappointing because apocalyptic horror’s best feature is its ability to look at which cultural traditions will outlive us into our most violent hours. Fittingly, given how much the game and subsequent show is based on <em>28 Days Later</em>, <em>28 Years Later</em> actually contends with this issue, specifically targeting the connection between the reliance on the patriarch and how religious violence uplifts this tradition.</p><p>This is one thought pattern of mine where, without the first scene, I would question myself on whether I was seeing connections due to my own hyperfixations. Lately, I’ve been back on the path of deconstruction, realizing there’s still some aspects I haven’t fully exercised. As such, I’ve been thinking more on the multiple sides of indoctrination of children and the pain that follows. Now, I often think “its not that deep” is distraction from critical thinking, however I can be insecure about my own skills sometimes. But the more I consider, the more confident I am that Boyle and Garland, despite some simultaneous though certainly balanced shortcomings here, were subtle about this critique which truly makes it stronger.</p><p>The opening scene is the origin of Jimmy (Jack O’Connell), a tracksuit wearing cult leader who appears at the end. But in our first meeting, he is a blonde boy, in a group full of other blonde children, reminiscent of a Sunday school classroom dynamic, or if one is to believe they are siblings, a quiverful family ala the infamous Duggers. Jimmy is there with this flock, watching <em>Teletubbies </em>as chaos ensues outside the door. After many skips and hops from the British icons, a zombie rushes into the room, killing multiple of the children as Jimmy’s mother screams for him to run. As he follows her instructions, he heads into a church. There, is his father, the same priest who terrorizes Cillian Murphy in <em>28 Days Later</em>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/201/1*ND91kC0xbOtaPhuQhEcCfQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Jimmy’s father, praying</figcaption></figure><p>He accepts the violence, telling Jimmy to not fear, to embrace the end, as he is gifted a cross necklace. Then, taking a crucifixion-like pose, he accepts the bodies as the ravage his flesh, smiling dutifully at his apocalyptic end. As the Christ-like man, as the priest who is close to God, spending his final time in the house of the Lord, he embraces violence rather than seeing it as the typical decline of humanity. The virus is a gift, like the flood that beckoned Noah is prescribed, as a cleansing of humanity.</p><p>This implicit cleansing does not end with Jimmy’s father. A less clever film would likely reserve his fanatacism to encapsulate the typical apocalyptic trope of the religious man driven to madness by end times prophecies. But when we are taken to the present day, so are we taken to a promised land. Jamie (Aaron Taylor-Johnson) and Spike (Alfie Williams) are a father and son living on a secluded island with Spike’s sick mother, Isla (Jodie Comer). In the first act, Jamie and Spike are off on a classic Ellie and Joel-type adventure, out in the wilderness to kill some infected to protect the island. As they head off, Jamie speaks to Spike on the importance of the island as a place to protect, on the good people there, and on the outsiders to fear. The island is a clear safe haven but this spells out the us vs. them mentality central to religious indoctrination as well as the actions needed to protect it.</p><p>Typically in evangelical discourse, the actions needed to become safe and protect fellow Christians is prosthelitizing. It is going out and getting more converts to preserve the cultural place of Christianity. Of course, this is by colonialist means. Christian missions themselves are about going to ‘save’ others in global south countries to eventually convert rather than really help. Then there are Mormon missions where the mission is based on less of a pretense, with an express mission to convert which becomes more insidious when you are sent to Ghana instead of France.</p><p>But on top of the colonialist implications for mission work, which is not present in this film as they are isolationist, there is the more violent indoctrination around ‘Lord’s army’ rhetoric. I can tell you that throughout Sunday school, I was singing “I may never shoot in the Calgary, ride the artillery…but I’m in the Lord’s army”, a common refrain to lay down everything for God in his name. This may seem like an extreme extrapolation of a children’s hymn but it is something they work over time. Much of children’s ministries rely on teaching children how to evangelize in their own ways, but as children become teenagers youth groups similarly focus on the importance of doing everything for God. This escalated post-Columbine with the myth of Cassie Bernall.</p><p>Cassie Bernall was killed at Columbine and the legend goes that Dylan Klebold asked Cassie if she believed in God, to which she said yes, before he shot and killed her. Valeen Schnurr is the actual survivor who answered this question, it is also reported that the question was asked of multiple victims and survivors. Survivors have debunked that Bernall was asked and gave this response, however.</p><p>Regardless, Bernall’s mother wrote an infamous memoir <em>She Said Yes </em>which memorialized her daughter as a teen martyr. The result was the sharing of her story at with the book being taught in youth groups and the film adaptation <em>I’m Not Ashamed </em>shown at many movie nights. The lesson for Christian youth is not the tragedy that this happened at all, but the bravery of her standing up for her beliefs regardless of the cost. She laid down her life for her ideology, as a soldier would, continuing the rhetorical quest of framing Christian children as mini soldiers. While they are not making 15 year olds join the army, they are implanting an idea within indoctrination that protection of Christian culture is vital and courageous.</p><p>As I mentioned, apocalyptic horror tends to look at these cultural issues and blow them up, question what happens to these ideas when people are forced into violence out of mundanity. <em>28 Years Later </em>answers that children are taught violence, and violence that is likened to military violence. As Spike and Jamie walk across the bridge into the wilderness, historical war footage is spliced with images of the island’s children training with Roman soldier costumes, visually linking Christian mythology with the history of war, and then the very mission Spike is on. Rather than this violence being necessary for their survival, the violence is now coded as cultural preservation. As for the mission, that preservation increasingly relates to violent modes of masculinity and impenetrability.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*tcY6bIGF8hc95EgIU8-SeA.jpeg" /></figure><p>Jamie teaches Spike the proper way to kill infected, acting as a hunting trip, taking him through the motions and proudly celebrating with accurate penetration. With the substanence behind hunting gone, the scenes strip down the practice to the ritual. Why does Jamie celebrate without the promise of food? Sure, logically because it is no longer a threat — but this is a threat they chased. So, it is because the arrow hit the neck, penetrating its life force. Spike dominated in the correct way. That is why he has earned his status as a “good lad”. At first, this doesn’t seem as nefarious for a zombie film. There’s zombies you have to kill. This is what our protagonists do. It becomes ominous when the duo run into one of Jimmy’s victims.</p><p>In an abandoned house, Spike and Jamie come across a hanging infected. Its body is marked with Jimmy’s name and its face is covered with a sack, reminiscent of the infamous photos of post-9/11 Guantanamo torture practices. Spike looks away at first, with his father screaming for him to stand attention, to look at the depravity. Realizing it is infected, he orders him to take the shot. Spike hesitates, and hesitates, until the rope can no longer hold the shaking body and it is close to getting them. All the while his father screams for him to take the shot. Zombie movie logic could excuse this as well. As said earlier, it is infected and thus must die. But Jamie could easily take care of it himself. He could allow Spike to stand guard, to look away. Even making Spike onlywatch the murder would ease some of this situation. But instead this is a violent learning lesson. This violence can’t be ignored and must be dealt with. This is a quintessential lesson in toughness, like when conservative-raised children are made to do hard labor. It is hard, but it is life.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*NG33duy38CUPIlqORLxLng.jpeg" /></figure><p>I won’t go step by step in these harrowing adventures, but suffice it to say, this is all presenting as a soldier’s mission. Spike is even asked if he would like to return to which he refuses, thinking of the embarassment. This was particularly reminiscent to me of the social shame that comes to Mormon missionaries who cut their mission short (the common timeline for men is two years, with women serving a year and a half) , even if for medical reasons. To quit is to not be properly committed. While the filmmakers were clearly going for a war allegory, this fits even more for me given the young age of missionaries and the framing of the mission as the way to become a man for the boys who start. Yes, legally they have to be 18 but they often are going right out of high school, not truly knowing the world and only exploring it under the context of spreading their culture through a religious dominance even if delivered through smiles and lemon squares. It is common in Mormon culture for women to refuse to marry a man if he is not a return missionary, because he is then not a true mormon man. But there is grand celebration if returned with honor, like a soldier.</p><p>Spike shares this honor with his father as they arrive to a party at a small church house. Through Boyle’s signature frenetic editing, we see how it overwhelms Spike to be so honored for deeds he is not proud of. But this discomfort is furthered as he discovers who his father really is. Jamie leaves with a woman, taking her to the alleyway behind the church house, unaware of Spike following them. There, he lifts up her dress, welcoming her with a lick. All while Spike’s mother doesn’t know where she is as she sweats away in bed, her husband forsakes her, finds another woman to enjoy, disposing of her.</p><p>This deeply reminded me of a scandalous take from <em>The 700 Club</em>’s Pat Robertson who advised a man whose wife was dying of Alzheimer’s that it was permitted to divorce her because the illness was essentially death. To be fair, this take was controversial for many Christians (including my dear grandmother who looked like she wanted to strangle Pat whenever she talked about it). However despite protests, it speaks to the framing of women in fundamentalist culture. It is true that they are singularly purposed in largely sexual ways. The help-meet narrative holds strong, as women are to keep up the home, to upkeep family dynamics, to perpetuate gender roles. The role is as wife, and wifeliness is strict in its relation to upkeep and sexuality. Many older men cheat on their wives in this dynamic as they no longer see them as useful as sexual objects. Isla is not much older, but she is dying, no longer able to be in this role. She is not useful to Jamie.</p><p>Spike sees this more as he speaks to his grandfather about burning in the woods. He discovers there actually is a doctor who could possibly help, even if to just diagnose her. And, worse of all, his father was aware of this. He knew about Dr. Kelson but didn’t seek his help. He confronts his father, asking whether he really cares, whether he <em>wants </em>his mother to die to which his father responds with a strike. The abuse is no longer excusable as part of this post-apocalyptic culture and now is within clear terms. And the abuse is in response to criticism for his patriarchal neglect, which stems from his position as the man of the house and beliefs related to what the man of the house is owed. The patriarch, particularly in religious contexts, does not have duty of care but duty of dominance. The slap is an attempt to regain that dominance, like how spanking and other physical punishments are often attempts to assert patriarchal dominance in Christian homes.</p><p>Notably, and with much hope, Spike leaves with his mother. This is where the coming-of-age kicks in, and I think to beautiful effect. Spike can leave the unnecessary expectations of violence, trying to reconstruct what death is necessary for survival, forcing the audience to reconsider what in other apocalyptic horror is survival violence vs brute violence. And it is notable that this quest comes with deepening the mother-son relationship, which is often de-emphasized in favor of father-son masculine training. Their love becomes the emotional center. Motherhood itself, with a fascinating zombie pregnancy plot, calls a lot of violence into question. Furthermore, the doctor’s presence allows for a philosophical reconsideration of death and its binding power. Death retreats from something that we do to others as we are asked to think of its necessity, finality, and deliverance. The second and final act become a story of deconstruction for Spike. And the end certainly makes me interested to see how the reported sequel film considers cultist ultraviolence within this journey.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5dc6337d7427" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Under His Claw: Surviving Sexual Abuse in Robert Eggers’ Nosferatu]]></title>
            <link>https://scaredbisexual.medium.com/under-his-claw-surviving-sexual-abuse-in-robert-eggers-nosferatu-2f05a1f6e92d?source=rss-f25bcac2209f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2f05a1f6e92d</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[sexual-assault]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[vampires]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[film-analysis]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[gothic-horror]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[nosferatu]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Sarah Wagoner]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 05 Jun 2025 22:12:36 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-06-05T22:12:36.961Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*xnav7w5IRngmqRKWJRw1mg.jpeg" /></figure><p>The vampiric figure has always held a position as a predatory force, often corrupting young virgins, taking white women away from their dutiful positions as brides and mothers. It is nothing new to the genre to portray a vampire as a sexually abusive figure. What is new is the way in which sexual predation is framed. While <em>Nosferatu </em>(2024) maintains the spectacle of the count’s (Bill Skarsgard) status as an Othered Translyvanian, the emphasis of his terror is on his destructive relationship with Ellen (Lily Rose-Depp). Simultaneously, the concern for Ellen is not a concern for her lost traditional womanhood but rather how Orlok’s abuse pushes her deeper into psychological turmoil.</p><p>A notable difference between <em>Nosferatu </em>and other <em>Dracula</em> adaptations is that Ellen is given more room to express her sexual desires. This is not to say other versions of Mina are devoid of sexual interest. On some level, they all are drawn to the prince of darkness for his seductive appeal. But in these versions, the films heavily emphasize his seductive powers before unveiling his relationship to Mina, implying that any woman, regardless of sexual (in)activity, would fall for his piercing gaze. In earlier adaptations, such as F.W. Murnau’s <em>Nosferatu</em> (1922) and Tod Browning’s <em>Dracula</em> (1931), Mina takes the form of the content housewife, often falling into a passive role as his victim. The latter could be attributed to the early deployment of the Hays’ Code which put many horror love interests into the role of a supportive wife or bride-to-be, whereas the source material allows for deeper nuances. Even before Hays’ these adaptations, as well as the original book, were created under strict social roles which limited the scripted roles women could occupy, particularly when it came to their sexuality. As such, Mina was typically represented as the passive victim, the non-threatening housewife whose sexual whims were non-existent, or coaxed out of her by the devious foreigner.</p><p>One might doubt the sexual conservatism of <em>Dracula </em>and its earlier adaptations, given that gothic fiction was generally a space to explore sexual desires. After all, the late David J. Skal’s revelatory biography, <em>Something in the Blood: The Untold Story of Bram Stoker, the Man Who Wrote Dracula</em> (2017) unveiled Stoker’s own queer desires, feeding into already prevailing theories of the novel as an exploration of forbidden homosexual desire. (“Damn wouldn’t it be fucked up if some hot guy started biting your neck…. Unless?”) Though the concept that a sexually conservative reading and a queer reading are contrary ignores the contrasting roles of sexuality in Victorian Gothic literature, and enduring tales of monstrosity.</p><p>In the coding of monstrosity is the coding of the Other, producing a taxonomy of immorality. The monstrous character’s deeds are often intertwined with social taboos, especially as Gothic literature was a safe genre to explore sexual desire. As such, monstrosity lived alongside outdated taboos such as homosexuality and interracial affairs, and maintained taboos such as incest and generalized sexual violence. Jolene Zigarovich puts it succinctly in her essay “Queer Gothic: Romantic Origins and Victorian Innovations”:</p><p>“…Gothic literature reinforced heteronormative sexuality and dramatised acts of sexual surveillance. Yet it simultaneously participated in a narrative form of sexology; the Gothic can fruitfully be read as a discursive practice that delineates non-normative sexualities” (<em>Queer Gothic: An Edinburgh Companion</em>, 2023, p. 39)</p><p>Most Gothic literature presents a conservative moral when it presents sexuality generally, though this is more apparent in its queer iterations. And I would argue, queer iterations would include both what modern audiences consider within the bounds of LGBTQ+ issues as well as women’s open sexuality. There is first the issue that the few stories with implicit lesbianism, such as Sheridan LeFanu’s <em>Carmilla</em> (an inspiration for Carl Theodor Dreyer’s <em>Vampyr</em>, another primary source of inspiration for Eggers’ <em>Nosferatu</em>), highlight the terror of a virginal woman succumbing to the queer desires of the vampiric figure. The fear present in the narrative is that an upright woman would reject polite (heterosexual) society for a separate (queer) life, if she were to embrace the perverse sexuality of her vampiric host. This same fear is present for Lucy, though with less transgression, as she would still lay in the arms of a man — just a foreign, possibly bisexual, one.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/660/1*KryDVZayH9hTujvnRrbO_g.jpeg" /><figcaption>Illustration of Sheridan LeFanu’s Carmilla</figcaption></figure><p>Though the narrative ends on the note that the woman must remain within safe boundaries, the composition allows for the audience to expose themselves to queerness. Readers are not drawn to <em>Dracula</em> for a reminder of social boundaries. Rather, the seductive journey into darkness drives the audience forward. And within that darkness is the allowance for the catharsis of sexual exploration that is allowed through conservative framing.</p><p>Throughout her literary and cinematic history, Mina is trapped in this framing. I do not want to misrepresent even Mina from the book. She is not a simple good Victorian wife, but rather a woman trapped between the strict boundaries of her time and desire to escape them (“Vampiric Affinities: Mina Harker and the Paradox of Femininity in Bram Stoker’s ‘Dracula’”, 2005, Prescott &amp; Giorgio, p. 487). What I meant to convey in the earlier discussion is that many adaptations lean into her passive wife persona to lean into the conservative framing of the abducted, seduced wife. Not all of the narratives rob her of desire, as I mentioned with Coppola’s film. But even the more progressive still didn’t offer much space for her perspective until Robert Eggers reimagined Mina as Ellen.</p><p>The first scene establishes Ellen’s interest in the darkness. She prays, calling him an angel, seemingly in the middle of a panic attack as she shakily cries out his names. It implies he is a familiar figure to her, present in her life before this prayer. And it is with his arrival, and insistence that she is not for the living, that she plunges from her room, falling into the garden. There he touches her, sending her body shaking further, plunging the camera into the ground as her moans reach our ears. Her sexuality is on display, with seeming pleasure releasing from her body. But the visual of the shaking body is violent. This combines with the nursery-like room she started in to remind us of her age. In her curiosity, she is violated, but in the familiar complexities of sexual violence for many survivors — though one barely shown on film.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*MkOLhb6Ty9ZhaDqFuDM0Cg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Ellen walking out of her room, into the garden</figcaption></figure><p>Because of the inherent violence of rape, myths prevail, reporting that to be a real victim one must have experienced only pain in the actual act. “She enjoyed it” is a common cry in response to justice from rapists, often citing genital arousal as evidence that there was non-verbal consent. This proclamation largely comes from the assumption that genital arousal is equal to enjoyment and that enjoyment derails the violation entirely. This assumption is false for a myriad of reasons.</p><p>The first of which is that genital stimuli can be triggered by a wide array of instances. For all genders, there can be unwanted stimulation that still reaches an aroused response. Penises are categorized as having specific sets of stimuli with specific responses, but their assaulters can still engage in those sets of stimulation for abusive means. In contrast, vaginal stimulation has a wider array of stimulation largely as the “genital responses function to prepare the body for sexual intercourse, whether it is wanted or not” (“Prepared for Anything? An Investigation of Female Genital Arousal in Response to Rape Cues”, Suschinsky and Lalumière, 2011, p. 159). This preparation is not related to a sexual interest to a partner, as studies have found that heterosexual women had similar responses to lesbian and gay sex (p. 159). The differences in vaginal stimuli in comparison to penis stimuli largely comes in response to intensity of sexual situations rather than in levels of sexual attraction (p. 159). This means intense situations such as nudity and dominance from another partner may lead to an automatic arousal even in violent situations. The victim themselves may not even report to be aroused in that situation even if their vagina is in stages of stimulation, simply because vaginal responses are automatic (p. 159).</p><p>So biologically, rape can lead to unwanted arousal. But even further, there are moments a victim may find pleasure in their assault. I would specifically note this can be the case in young assault victims and victims of grooming. Ellen is being groomed by the count. He shows her the darkness she yearns for, a place to explore those upcoming desires which are to be locked away. This is often what many victims seek in their grooming abusers who exploit those very desires. This is also why pubescent teenagers in puritanical settings are prime targets. Speaking for myself, my abusers knew I desperately desired to explore myself and even more wanted to be desired. As such, they made it seem like this was a freeing endeavor. And under that guise, I felt I was experiencing some pleasure in that moment. So, too, does Ellen feel that attraction. Even as he takes her body, she feels she can be entrenched in those forbidden desires without consequences. So she may feel some of the pleasure we saw previous Minas experience with their Draculas. But as time passes away from this childhood exploitation, the anxiety about what he took as well as some of the pleasure she took in it, eats away at her.</p><p>We largely see how her childhood memories impact her relationship with Thomas. When he tells her of his mission to Transylvania, she recounts a dream of their wedding. Before she tells it, he worries it is more of her traumatic anxieties, stating these “we have put all these difficulties behind us”, implying these anxieties have plagued their relationship. As for the dream itself, she remembers the beauty of their wedding corrupted by the lack of his presence and the appearance of Death who holds her hand at the altar. The dream takes us back to the first scene, where the count, acting as her guardian angel, tells her, “you are not for the living”. Life and its happiness is beyond her reach. She feels destined to be with Death, unworthy of the love Thomas brings her.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*CucZX96nsNVZfsD7VPGtKQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Ellen recounts her dream</figcaption></figure><p>The anxiety of worth is familiar for victims, particularly those surrounded by puritanical values. In those cultures, true love is tied with sexual purity. If you really loved a future husband, you would’ve waited and saved your precious flower for him. To have sexual encounters, consensual or no, before his arrival is to demean his spirit. I have witnessed firsthand how this can lead to a vicious cycle of emotional self-harm in Christian survivors, particularly those who were assaulted by a partner and at a young age. There is a tendency for them to worry that they are spoiled for their husbands, which is sometimes a feeling reciprocated, leading to a cycle of frenzied pleas for forgiveness that are met with rape myths being thrown as heavy stones. But even with supportive partners, when this fear is not faced head-on, it can eat at someone, which is what it does to Ellen.</p><p>Thomas does not state her fears are valid. He largely ignores her trauma in the beginning of the film, treating it as an annoyance he wishes to dissipate so she can return to a loving wife rather than an anxious one. At first, he seems to be part of the puritanical culture, treating her past abuse as something to tuck away so they can continue living. This is not to say he is abusive, as much as he seems neglectful, and somewhat self-interested. I would say this is also a common experience for survivors of abuse. Their trauma can become, or seem like, a burden to a partner as it leads to depressive states that no one wants to deal with. Consequently, the survivor-partner then can feel that they themselves are a burden, especially as that trauma can be so interconnected with one’s intimate life. In the beginning, this seems to be where Ellen is. Thomas is ready to go away, even as she cries for him to stay. While there is a logical reason for his leaving that could practically improve their lives, their intimate history with her trauma leads to an internal narrative of loss of his affection, pushing her into the spiral of paranoia that is sprinkled with self-hate.</p><p>For Ellen, this self-hate manifests in defying her social role as Thomas is away. Her first instance of this denial is cutting her hair once he leaves. This scene is before she is entrenched in Anna and Harding’s conventionally social household. As such, she is preparing to enter that world, seemingly with an antagonistic approach as she is rejecting the expectations of her femininity. Long locks were a general expectation for women as a sign of their assumed sexual difference, with short hair associated with masculinity. There is typically a strain of associating cutting hair with rejecting hegemonic femininity across cinema as well, whether that is in the masculine transformation of <em>Mulan</em> (1998) or the refusal of a male gaze in <em>Gone Girl</em> (2014). In the latter, it is even a refusal of past traumatic abuse, at least if one takes Amy Dunne at face value (“A Cinematic Odyssey of Women Cutting Their Hair On-Screen”, Leigh-Phippard, 2019).</p><p>And it is possible Ellen is similarly pushing off Orlok’s gaze, as the film certainly keeps her motivations in the dark. But I would posit that this act is a precursor to her foil relationship with Anna, as Anna dedicates herself to keeping in line with beauty standards and social politeness. Meanwhile Ellen is withdrawn, keeping to the style but with smaller denials such as the cut hair no one else can see. Inside, she is an outsider even as she attempts politeness. What makes everyone else human, their keeping to social standards, she feels she must cheat herself out of, due to her place outside of the world of the living — outside of the world of politeness.</p><p>She even vocalizes this feeling on a walk on the beach with Anna. “Do you ever feel as if you were not a person?” she asks, her intrusive thoughts reaching the dry air. Anna is lost for words, allowing for Ellen to elaborate:</p><p>“What I wish to say is that you are not truly present nor alive, as if you were at the whim of another… like a doll, and someone or some thing had the power to breathe life into you, to move you?”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*KhRyxTBalu4xSWRAr1lfVQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Ellen and Anna walk on the beach</figcaption></figure><p>Narratively, Ellen speaks to Orlok’s power over her, and his denial of her person. But this philosophical musing speaks to the treatment of women within the gender hierarchy. She is not present, in that her decisions are under the whims of her husband. She is not alive in that she is not autonomous. Her life revolves around her lover. As Thomas is away, she is lost, her soul available for manipulation. This has always been present in <em>Dracula</em> adaptations, as Jonathan is away, meaning Mina lacks a protector and is like a sheep without a guard dog. But now, Mina in the form of Ellen is given the space to question why she lacks this agency, providing ample space for the audience to consider the construction of Orlok’s domination over her rather than accept that she simply lacks a protector. On top of this, Ellen’s desire reflects a common survivor dependency.</p><p>I can speak for myself and say much of why I dated my rapist was I was afraid of being alone. Even as a teenager, I was under the impression that I was worthless without a relationship. Some of this is my own insecurity, but much was existing in a conservative community that placed women’s value as sexual and romantic value. This is what also pushed me into online spaces where old men were happy to exploit that insecurity. And I will admit for a while that insecurity transferred to my healthy relationships. My current partner put up with many of my manic episodes, to a point that I don’t think anyone else would ever tolerate. But this was part of a cycle of dependency which abusers rely on to keep their victim as a target. It is especially effective for those who already are isolated. The abuser becomes the one source, making you think that is normal for any and all sexual relationships. This is exacerbated when women are particularly reliant on men for financial stability.</p><p>Anna is similarly reliant on Harding even without Ellen’s traumatic history. She even notes that she may feel the same sometimes, as we all become lonely, but it is a passing feeling. It is like when someone mentions feeling sad sometimes to a truly depressed person. Even in an attempt to relate, Anna pushes Ellen further away in assuming this is a less intense feeling she returns to. Ellen even responds by proclaiming she is not mad. She knows she is assumed to be a hysterical woman simply for her contrary relation to personhood as defined by her role as a wife. And of course, this social assumption compounds with the physical manifestations of this aforementioned trauma as Orlok takes control of her body from afar.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/768/1*Jc4ApJsgi2P4ijzNstd_-A.jpeg" /></figure><p>Throughout the film, Ellen comes under Orlok’s spell while staying in the Harding house. This is in explicit connection to Orlok as shown when one of his shadows takes hold of her. The shadow takes the form of his claw, holding her in tight embrace. Given previous statements of her mental state, this could be assumed as one of her delusions. But we are quickly shown the dark reality with a cut to Orlok’s castle. After offering Thomas lodging, Orlok lays in his coffin, firmly possessing Ellen’s locket and pieces of her hair, his own eyes turning white as he whispers a spell to Ellen. Cut back to the Harding home and Ellen’s eyes are wide, growing with her opening mouth as she comes closer to an orgasm in his grasp. Though this sexual experience is juxtaposed with the normalcy of Harding and Anna’s own road to bliss as they stop to investigate the noise from her room, only to find her walking toward a canal. All the while Orlok attacks Thomas, naked, atop of him. Ellen, still at the canal, cries out for Thomas before the screen cuts to black.</p><p>The lines are blurred between Orlok’s sexual attacks of Ellen and physical attack on Thomas. The two could be as one in the same to Orlok, with punishing Thomas for his romantic entanglement with his target. His dark magic could also imprint pain upon one of them as pain on the other. But symbolically, this is notable for being a violent reversal of Eve Kosofsky Sedgwick’s homosocial triangle of desire. To oversimplify her argument, male homosocial desire, which exists within a continuum of same-gender desire, manifests in male-male-female dynamics wherein the heterosexual female object of desire acts as a conduit for the socially unacceptable feelings of sexual and romantic desire for another man (Sedgewick, 1985, p. 22–28). This isn’t to say every love triangle fits into this, as it specifically involves the transmission of patriarchal power (p. 25) which can come in the form of emasculating another man in the process of procuring the female interest, largely to prove his worthiness as a ‘man’ in accordance with the homogenous position.</p><p>Though I would push this against the more abstract academic writings of ‘homogeneous masculinity’, which is ever-changing. Rather, I will borrow from transfeminist writer Talia Bhatt and refer to their denial of penetrability (“Understanding Transmisogyny, Part Four: Penetrability, 2025). The men in the triangle can not be seen as penetrable as penetrability relates to sexual consumption and to be sexually consumable is to be subject to another’s power. With penetrability considered in this triangle, we can look at how <em>Nosferatu </em>changes the dynamics.</p><p>This triangle is not new to <em>Dracula </em>as Mina has often been the count’s way to get to Jonathan as the forbidden fruit. He cannot seduce Jonathan in any overt way, but he can use his wives’ to get to him, and he can turn Mr. Harker’s wife into his own concubine. If he can’t be Jonathan’s object of desire, he can have the object of desire. But in <em>Nosferatu</em>, Orlok is sexually disinterested in Thomas. The only sexual interest we see from Orlok is towards Ellen. And this sexual interest is a violent one, relating to his ability to dominate and psychically control her. Thomas, as the husband who should dominate, is an obstacle rather than another object of desire. But Orlok does not simply throw him away. Rather, he sees him as another person he can control. So the triangle of homosociality is traded for Orlok’s ability to penetrate this couple. And in this trade, the true object of desire becomes the true subject of violence. Ellen is centered not as the spectacle of desire but as a depressed survivor. This largely gives space for the film to depict her complex emotions at the center of violence, another twist on the triangle center’s usual dilemma of ‘who to choose’.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*tQeuotE6AUvt_wSgmaDgvQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>The love triangle obviously has the ‘choice’ dilemma baked into it, which often leads to its own symbolic choices between light and darkness. But Ellen has a different dilemma. Unlike Bella Swan, she isn’t close to choosing a vampire boyfriend. Rather, she is between choosing life and death. Throughout the film, we see that despite his initial dismissive encounter, Thomas is caring for Ellen, dropping everything to comfort her, even as she lashes out at him in an intense manic episode. While others may throw her to the madhouse, he stays. In fact, he is one of the few in her life to reject the misogynist medical treatment she is subjected to, instead believing her rather than blaming her episodes on some period-induced hysteria. We also see in the finale that, like Jonathan Harker, he will do anything it takes to save her from Orlok’s grasp, understanding the grave possibilities that lurk in his claws. With him, there is the possibility for her to grow, to receive true help, and to have love without abuse.</p><p>In stark contrast, the count represents death. In some ways, it is for the obvious reasons that any Dracula spells death. But <em>Nosferatu </em>specifically focuses on the harm he has done to her, how he treats her body with no regard to her health, how he tries to alienate her, and how he presents as an angel of death to her. Then there is that her musings on her trauma all relate to her feeling of not living, that she is not for the living. To accept him is to accept his dehumanizing words, to devalue herself. But these are also words she can never shake. Even with her love, her Thomas, she believes it is true. Orlok has poisoned her against her own life, just as real abuse often makes survivor’s think we deserve nothing better.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*ZMergV2rrDh6dM93wWZT1A.jpeg" /></figure><p>I can say, part of why I relate to the end of <em>Nosferatu</em>, is I had such low self esteem after my rape that I let him be my boyfriend. He raped me other times, times which took me years to accept were also rape because at a certain point I thought I had accepted it as my faith. And the part I was most ashamed of for years is that he broke up with me. I didn’t end it for myself as I should have. I didn’t gain any of that esteem until years later. I sometimes wonder how long it would’ve gone on had he not decided I wasn’t a good plaything anymore. So, I really relate to Ellen going back, even if it isn’t some awesome revenge scene. It’s instead a dip into the darkness, and one many survivors fear the most. I’ve had many nightmares where I am back in that bed. When Ellen returns to her room, allowing him to crawl on top of her, I see that nightmare envisioned.</p><p>I do find the smallest catharsis in the fact that it was his final act of abuse. Part of that is because it is implied this act was a protection of Thomas, given Orlok’s desire to destroy him. Narratively, she acted as a distraction. Going back to the triangle, she accepted her position as the subject of violence as it spared Thomas from the same grotesque fate. There is some catharsis to this ending then in not only destroying the abuser but denying him of what would’ve been his greatest pleasure. <em>Nosferatu </em>may not have the most satisfying ending with that, but it is one that highlights the deep pain of abuse, as Ellen’s life on screen begins and ends with this torment, with her small moments of light being with the person who gives her grace.</p><p>References</p><p>Bhatt, T. (2025, May 15). Understanding Transmisogyny, Part Four: Penetrability.</p><p><em>Trans/Rad/Fem</em>.</p><p><a href="https://taliabhattwrites.substack.com/p/understanding-transmisogyny-part-e02">https://taliabhattwrites.substack.com/p/understanding-transmisogyny-part-e02</a></p><p>Browning, T. (Director). (1931). <em>Dracula </em>[Film]. Universal Pictures.</p><p>Coppola, F.F. (Director). (1992). <em>Bram Stoker’s Dracula</em> [Film]. Sony Pictures.</p><p>Deyer, C.T. (Director). (1932). <em>Vampyr [Film]. </em>Tobis-Filmkunst.</p><p>Eggers, R. (Director). (2024). <em>Nosferatu </em>[Film]. Universal Pictures.</p><p>Leigh-Phippard, D. (2019, May 16). A Cinematic Odyssey of Women Cutting Their Hair</p><p>On-Screen. <em>Screen Queens</em>.</p><p><a href="https://screenqueens.wordpress.com/2019/05/16/a-cinematic-odyssey-of-women-cutting-their-hair-on-screen/">https://screenqueens.wordpress.com/2019/05/16/a-cinematic-odyssey-of-women-cutting-t</a></p><p><a href="https://screenqueens.wordpress.com/2019/05/16/a-cinematic-odyssey-of-women-cutting-their-hair-on-screen/">heir-hair-on-screen/</a>.</p><p>Maddin, G. (Director). (2002). <em>Dracula: Pages from a Virgin’s Diary</em> [Film]. Canadian</p><p>Broadcasting Corporation.</p><p>Murnau, F.W. (Director). (1922). <em>Nosferatu: A Symphony of Horror</em> [Film]. Film Arts Guild.</p><p>Prescott, C. E., &amp; Giorgio, G. A. (2005). Vampiric Affinities: Mina Harker and the Paradox of</p><p>Femininity in Bram Stoker’s “Dracula.” <em>Victorian Literature and Culture</em>, <em>33</em>(2),</p><p>487–515. <a href="http://www.jstor.org/stable/25058725">http://www.jstor.org/stable/25058725</a>.</p><p>Sedgwick, E. K. (1985). <em>Between Men; English Literature and Male Homosocial Desire. </em>New York: Columbia University Press.</p><p>Skal, D.J. (2017)<em>. Something in the Blood: The Untold Story of Bram Stoker, the Man Who Wrote</em></p><p><em>Dracula. </em>Liveright Publishing Corporation.<br>Stoker, B. (1897). <em>Dracula</em>. Archibald Constable and Company.</p><p>Suschinsky, K. D., &amp; Lalumière, M. L. (2011). Prepared for Anything? An Investigation of</p><p>Female Genital Arousal in Response to Rape Cues. <em>Psychological Science</em>, <em>22</em>(2),</p><p>159–165. <a href="http://www.jstor.org/stable/40984623">http://www.jstor.org/stable/40984623</a></p><p>Zigarovich, Jolene. “Queer Gothic: Romantic Origins and Victorian Innovations.” In <em>Queer</em></p><p><em>Gothic: An Edinburgh Companion</em>, edited by Ardel Haefele-Thomas, 38–57. Edinburgh</p><p>University Press, 2023. <a href="http://www.jstor.org/stable/10.3366/jj.9941146.7">http://www.jstor.org/stable/10.3366/jj.9941146.7</a>.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2f05a1f6e92d" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Southern Gothic Afrofuturism: Review of ‘Sinners’]]></title>
            <link>https://scaredbisexual.medium.com/southern-gothic-afrofuturism-review-of-sinners-e4e56ee8516d?source=rss-f25bcac2209f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e4e56ee8516d</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[film-analysis]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[movie-review]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[horror-movies]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[film-criticism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[black-film]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Sarah Wagoner]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 20 Apr 2025 22:40:21 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-04-20T22:55:17.710Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/650/1*yshORKzpDzVnIv3QG0ucRg.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>Sinners </em>is going to be one of those masterpieces that dissertations are written about. I am truly blown away at how well Coogler integrated multiple gendered and raced complexities while keeping an eye on the target. On top of this, he so eloquently weaves music and horror while keeping the cultural importance of music in mind. It is telling, for example, that Blues music combines with history of Black music in that incredible sequence, showing a world of possibility that is also a world the vampires hope to stop. In turn, the vampires use Irish gigs in a way that imitates that previous sense of community, implying the role of whitewashing in the broader service of white supremacy.</p><p>That scene in particular, I would argue is one of the most powerful mainstream uses of Afrofuturism. <em>Black Panther</em> was praised for bringing the movement to the mainstream, but I think many of its positives have washed as we remember the ultimate anti-radical message of it (though I will have grace towards Coogler and acknowledge it is more likely to be a studio decision than his own artistic vision. And, there still is empathy within the Killmonger story). But in its devaluing of radical futures, <em>Black Panther</em> is not the best presentation of Afrofuturism. <em>Sinners</em> is, even though it is not a sci-fi film.</p><p>Specifically, I am thinking about the broader goals of Afrofuturist art. It is largely to consider how art can propel Black culture and imagine a future of joy, often by combining traditional African culture with technology, but inventive films like <em>Sinners</em> can question other ways to imagine that future, both textually and in its production. On a textual level, the music through history scene displays how Blues was part of a larger role in the history of Black music. It continues on into imagined futures and actual futures with this mixture of fictional futuristic rhythms as well as contemporary genres like hip-hop. On top of this, multiple characters who celebrate culture in diverse manners are mixed in with the cast, allowing the audience to imagine what music and the subsequent culture could be like in relation to our own culture.</p><p>SPOILERS:</p><p>Spirituality also plays a hand in this. Afrofuturism often returns to African faiths which were devalued by colonizers and stomped out during American slavery. <em>Sinners</em> returns to that African spirituality in a Southern Gothic context, much like<em> Eve’s Bayou</em>, and like in <em>Eve’s Bayou,</em> it is a saving grace. In the end, it becomes another form of future hope as our point of Black joy comes in the form of Smoke (Michael B. Jordan) seeing the afterlife version of his ex-lover and their son who died as a baby. Generally, children are representatives of the future. But this also acts as an imagined future with that very faith propelling happiness beyond the binary planes of life. This scene in particular displays that Coogler properly balances the dire situation with much-needed hope.</p><p>Too often lately, genre fare has relegated its political messaging to just the dire, ignoring the opportunity hope brings. In all times, hope is needed often to remind us of what is worth fighting for. But it is also needed to challenge us to imagine better worlds for ourselves. In my <em>Star Trek: TOS </em>phase I’ve written about that a lot as the original show (with its racial and gendered troubles) still was a great example of how genre pushes us to improve upon ourselves. You don’t always need utopian visions to accomplish that. In fact, as Robin Wood famously argues in <em>The American Nightmare</em> (1979), horror in the 60s and 70s was largely politically notable for how it tore the world down to imagine how to rebuild a better one, often with the inclusion of those social ills to display why they are destructive. <em>Night of the Living Dead</em>’s ending, for example, displayed how the bigoted devaluation of life would lead to demise for all people with its sequel films questioning how people could come together to rebuild.</p><p>In many ways, and with <em>Sinners</em> explicit (and much-needed) focus against white supremacy both with the Klan members and vampires, allows the audience to consider how white supremacy seeks to destroy racial difference, including how it will even take friendly forms to accomplish that. I have already written a lot so I won’t go more into it but I find it interesting that the vampires follow the route of AMC’s <em>Interview with the Vampire</em> by displaying how the bare minimum of respect is used as a manipulation tactic. But <em>Sinners</em> goes further as the manipulation doesn’t work, so they have to take their victims by force. And the vampires are equated to white cults that target Black people, like Jonestown, while swallowing up and denying them a chance at their culture. Again the Klans and the vampires are one in the same, not only with literal killing, but with the same genocidal goal. The difference is between a physical genocide and a spiritual/cultural genocide.</p><p>And on top of this great point, Coogler does not surrender to nihilism with these aforementioned hopeful futures. Furthermore, the production itself has hopeful impacts on cinema. First, there is the (sadly) historical instance for cinematography as <em>Sinners</em> has the first woman director of photography on an 15-perf IMAX 65mm. Second, there is the broader framework. Coogler continues Barry Jenkins and other Black filmmakers’ quest to be inclusive to darker skin in their cinematography. Again, it is sad to even praise but it is notable that all skin tones are given time to glisten. But on top of that inclusive gaze is the way the sex scenes are shot. It is notable that every sex scene centers the pleasure of Black women. I don’t think I’ve ever seen a mainstream film (at least a non-comedy) center pleasure in this manner, and with such dignity. I mean, speaking as a larger woman it is rare fat women of any race are treated as sexually desirable. And fat Black women in particularly live in the paradox of desexualization and over sexualization. The answer to that paradox is the respect given to Annie (Wunmi Mosaku) as, again, her pleasure is the centerpiece rather than a spectacle of her body. There are other aspects I am sure will be technical inspiration, such as the music through history sequence. And I’m sure more technically-minded critics will point these out.</p><p>But I just feel the need to note all of these incredible intricacies, many of which I’m sure I’ve missed either due to my own ignorance or that I was too dazzled on this first viewing. Still, I am confident in saying <em>Sinners</em> is a true masterpiece that enriches its genre with all of its contributions, and while never feeling condescending to it. This felt like a love letter to Black horror cinema and the Black Southern Gothic literary tradition, similar to <em>Get Out</em> and <em>Eve’s Bayou</em>, respectively.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e4e56ee8516d" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Devilish Charm: Exploiting Queer Desire in AMC’s ‘Interview with the Vampire’]]></title>
            <link>https://scaredbisexual.medium.com/devilish-charm-exploiting-queer-desire-in-amcs-interview-with-the-vampire-8c8ce170bca1?source=rss-f25bcac2209f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8c8ce170bca1</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[queer]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[vampires]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[tv-analysis]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[interview-with-vampire]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[abusive-relationships]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Sarah Wagoner]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 01 Mar 2025 13:42:01 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-03-01T13:42:01.404Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/686/1*tRImgae4EonB_5kBzKrbVw.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>Introduction</strong></p><p>My first taste of vampires in film, and subsequent vampire discourse, was <em>Twilight</em>. Like many in my generation, I was introduced to the very concept of vampire lore by being told why “our generations” version of it was a softened version of the true mythos. But alongside this more masculine criticism was the pseudo-feminist Cracked.com argument regarding the pedophilic undertones. At the time, I absolutely gripped onto this point, even arguing with my friends about why they should abstain from the fandom. It was definitely a starting point of my interest in criticism and my younger attitude towards moral policing which lacked any needed nuance, particularly when it comes to ‘letting people enjoy things’.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*KRGLFSvSorsKJS5tS3lPgg.jpeg" /></figure><p>At the time, I had not actually watched <em>Twilight</em> nor read the books, until my mom and sister dragged me to the grand finale. But I did go to a screening a few years ago, after I have processed my own trauma related to creepy old men and a predatory boyfriend in my teen years. I really found myself enjoying the film and finding some of the teenage desire I never allowed myself to have, as when it was expressed it was taken advantage of. I wish a handsome, mysterious guy had torn the flesh of my would-be sexual tormentor. I wish all the old men who demanded nudes from me would lose their blood as a punishment for their gross tresspasses. I wish someone would have been there to protect me, to make me feel valued, to actually have felt love when I needed it most. Even as I am cognizant that <em>Twilight</em> is a problematic fantasy that highlights the abusive dynamics present in heterosexual romance fiction, I cannot deny that it spoke deeply to my broken younger self. I understand why so many pined for their own Edward. And as an adult, I even see myself projecting some of that desire onto other vampiric figures as they are predatory figures whose malice is covered by their gothic allure, and all the liberation from oppression they promise.</p><p>The specific vampire type I refer to, a dark romantic one, seems like a fallen angel who will cover his chosen partner with bulletproof wings. But in reality, he uses his power to store away the victim to use for his nefarious purpose. In many ways, he reflects the common form of an abuser. Rarely does an abuser first appear with blood on their hands. They often come as romantic figures who slowly transform into villains. Until recently, mainstream film has primarily displayed abusers as blunt villains in order to demonstrate the horror of domestic abuse. The intention is often noble but it plays into myths which ultimately blame the victim as audiences will inevitably wonder why the victim is even in the position in the first place. But abusers often appear as lovers to their victims, with abusive actions being overtaken by happy memories until it reappears. Of course, every abuse case is different, but this is one common outcome which has rarely appeared even in more abstract, metaphorical depictions of abuse.</p><p>But in the wake of cultural awareness of abuse, media depictions have expanded past the obvious, granting room for the nuanced reality. Even as monstrous figures, abusers are now depicted as the manipulators they must be to pull off their vicious crimes. AMC’s <em>Interview with The Vampire </em>(2022-) and Robert Eggers’ <em>Nosferatu </em>(2024) take this basic fact and apply it to dark, romantic vampires while highlighting the very oppressive environments that allowed their respective monsters to thrive. While <em>Interview with The Vampire</em> has always presented a homoerotic tale of domestic abuse, the AMC show goes a step further by not only making the queer subtext into text, but by casting Jacob Anderson as Louis de Pointe du Lac. Louis is no longer a white plantation owner, but an affluent Black man in 1910s New Orleans. Throughout the course of their relationship, Lestat (Sam Reid) manipulates Louis’ experience with anti-Black racism in order to gain favor, and control, over him. <em>Nosferatu</em> weaves a similar narrative as Count Orlok’s (Bill Skarsgard) scheme is made all the easier to pull off as Ellen’s (Lily-Rose Depp) sexual trauma, as manifested through hypersexuality and symptoms of bipolar disorder, are punished through social isolation and the medical misogyny which justified her mistreatment. In both of these narratives, social oppression acts as an accomplice to sexual and domestic abuse as their victims know the alternative to their abuser is a world with similar brutality.</p><p>Given the wealth of material here, I will be splitting this essay into two posts, with this first part focusing on <em>Interview with the Vampire</em>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/452/1*HXyStQHPD3qPAz8OVbfJkg.png" /></figure><p>In the original book and the 1994 film adaptation, <em>Interview with the Vampire</em> centers two white vampires in an abusive relationship. The homoerotic tension remains but it is not explicitly stated, but heavily implied through the vampires’ indulgence in pseudo-threesomes, their positions as parental figures to the vampiric child, Claudia (Kirsten Dunst), and their continual fights that resemble that of a crumbling marriage. Even their emotional and sexual tension is supplemented by director Neil Jordan’s deployment of soft focus. The usage of soft focus fluctuates in film history, though its primary purpose is to signify a romantic interest as a subject of beauty. In the 90s, this usage was largely attributed to softcore pornography and soap operas, heightening the homoerotic and melodramatic themes within Lestat (Tom Cruise) and Louis’ (Brad Pitt) turbulent relationship.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/700/1*SfumfooDftV75vdE9s2jIw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Tom Cruise as Lestat and Brad Pitt as Louis in <em>the 1994 film.</em></figcaption></figure><p>Still, these themes are somewhat stifled by the consistent refusal of an explicit queer label on the relationship. Specifically, the abuse Lestat doles out on Claudia and Louis comes out of a general villainy rather than a deeper relation to either character, which the show improves upon by drawing out the adoptive family relationship — itself drawn out of Louis’ dependent relationship with Lestat.</p><p>Within the framing of the titular “interview with the vampire”, Louis is given the primary narrative. While it is interesting to note that the show itself plays with this biased perspective, as well as his own troubled recollections, I will be focusing on Louis’ perspective at face value, with note when said face value is eventually refuted by Louis’ own post-traumatic recollection. Regardless, Louis’ primary perspective is rather important for the very subversive framing of the show. While Louis’ also held the narrative in the film, he still held a normative place in the narrative by virtue of his whiteness which was further exemplified by his previous ownership of a plantation. He does not have as much motivation for his desire outside of a general boredom with Southern social life. In contrast, the show focuses on the contrast between Louis’ multiple masks.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/740/1*P7JSt9q2kAiMZmJc7UGWQA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Louis (Jacob Anderson) at a poker game.</figcaption></figure><p>Louis is now a Black man, but also a relatively successful one in the post-Civil War South. His success itself is morally complicated as he is the owner of a brothel, primarily used by white men with primarily Black women as employees. He often even uses his newfound class to protect his workers from his racist colleagues. Yet, this position was obtained by some level of exploitation of Black women, even with acknowledgement that said women are exercising sexual autonomy rather than being pure victims. And all of this complication is bred from a structurally racist environment, with both Louis and his workers acting with survival on the mind. This creates a level of empathy for Louis while maintaining his wealthy status, and even creating space for his isolation from both his family and his aforementioned deplorable colleagues that Lestat is more than willing to exploit.</p><p>Lestat displays this willingness in a poker game with Louis and two white business men: Tom Anderson and Alderman Fenwick. Louis’ knowledge of Lestat at this point is limited — primarily knowing him as a mysterious, rich, attractive Frenchman. His only interaction prior to this point is a passing moment at a saloon, wherein Lestat kisses Lily (a sex worker Louis frequently visits) in front of Louis after laughing at him. But in the poker game, Lestat directly communicates with Louis, using his telecommunicative abilities to discuss his immortal proposal. Throughout the game, Fenwick and Anderson make disparaging comments about Blackness and even Louis specifically. They do not call Louis a slur, but they emasculate him with a poor business proposal. They offer a new location for him to expand his business, but only offer ten percent of the proceeds. Upon the slightest disagreement from Louis, they call upon Lestat’s aid in their implicit racism.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/540/1*Vhczq7qSDVzwPMD2fitEgg.png" /><figcaption>Lestat (Sam Reid) at the poker game.</figcaption></figure><p>Surprisingly, Lestat redirects conversation to take attention away from Louis’ uncomfortable position while sharing his thoughts telepathically. First he states the obvious, saying “These men look down on you” (Season 1, Episode 1, “In throes of increasing wonder…”, 26:32). Then he transitions into his racial sympathies, “I have to say, I find it appalling how men like yourself are treated in this country of yours” (26:33–26:39). This is the first time Lestat shares his vampiric powers with Louis. He uses these incredible abilities to state that he is safe, he understands him in a way few white people do. He will not throw him to the lynch mob nor even agree with the smaller, common acts of everyday bigotry. While we can see this as a bare minimum today, it is notable that the bare minimum was once monumentous. Louis’ entire life has been colored racist, punitive violence. Even his ‘friendly’ relationships with white people are predicated on his wealth. He is barely tolerated, with his race becoming a topic of mockery for ‘light conversation’, at best. Lestat’s seductive path begins rather effectively with this faux allyship, then, as Louis feels as if someone can truly understand the truth behind the cruelty he socially suffers.</p><p>Of course, it would seem that Louis is not completely alone. One could argue he is isolated from other Black citizens given his upper-class position. But he still has a family, who now even share in his wealth (to an extent). However, Louis’ relationship with his family, like with many queer people, is complicated. For the sake of brevity, I won’t dive into every dynamic nor their changes. But it is important to note that his brother, Paul, is concerned with the sanctity of his soul. There are other interesting dynamics within his family — his sister is supportive but worries for him as he is deeper entrenched with Lestat (I should note her fear is not implied to be homophobic). His mother disapproves of his line of work and often defends Paul’s many sermons. As the series progresses, she no longer sees him as her son given his unnatural aging and possible involvement with the death of her loved ones. But Paul is an introductory character, at least as he pertains to the family’s Christian dynamics. He, and his religious views, are key to Louis’ answer to Lestat’s fateful proposition.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*A0i4oVbpE_6ttqIo0h4R0w.png" /><figcaption>Paul (Steven G. Norfleet) confronts Louis on the streets of New Orleans.</figcaption></figure><p>Paul is introduced as a street preacher, begging one of Louis’ workers to give up on this lifestyle and revert to Christ. His interference with Louis’ business leads to a public confrontation. As Paul refuses to give up, he notices blood on Louis’ collar, asking “what wickedness is it tonight?” (Season One, Episode One, 13:56), implying his disapproval of Louis’ ‘lifestyle’. Given Louis’ sexuality, this does not seem to be a simple disagreement on his business but rather a larger statement on his ungodly doings. Perhaps that would explain Louis’ extreme reaction: pulling a knife on his brother. He quickly lets him go, allowing the anger to pass as he pushes him away. But it speaks to resentment built up at his Holy stature. Lestat may have noticed this, as well, as his first glance at Louis is in this encounter.</p><p>Still, it must be noted that the brothers are not in completely adversarial standing, as Louis remarks that their time at the church together is peaceful. In the very next shot, he notes that this is one of many contradictions in his life, as his “latencies” are condemned by his very place of peace. Of course, this is reminiscent of many queer experiences with the church. It could very well be a safe haven to the soul while having pastors who remind us that our proclivities will lead to Satan’s arms. While church and sexuality do not have to be exclusive choices, the repression the church represents presents what seems to be a binary choice between God and Satan, with Satan tempting us with freedom from judgment. All God offers is a comfortable existence where we can shed that which ostracizes us.</p><p>The brilliance of the AMC adaptation is an understanding of the queer dimensions of the Faustian, vampiric pact. In the original book and the 1994 film, Louis is seduced into vampirism by Lestat’s offer of immortality. Book and film Louis are dreadfully bored of day-to-day human existence, feeling they have experienced all the social world has to offer. Lestat’s offer speaks to his desire for true adventure through an escape of some mundanity.The downside of the temptation is abandonment of what makes us human, with the assumption that eternal life is not a life lived. To an extent, TV Louis is similarly enthralled with the prospect of an existence outside of the daily routine. Though for him, that prospect comes with the potential of seeing a world free of oppression. He is offered a chance of freedom, away from the repressive life that offers comfort at its own price. And while Louis of the book and film have little holding them back from the offer, TV Louis has a few connective threads that wither away before his final choice.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/853/1*gAMAwQ71FH8X4vk6bm14Og.jpeg" /><figcaption>Louis and Paul standing on the roof.</figcaption></figure><p>After a joyous night together, Louis and Paul sit on the roof of their family home, with Paul inquiring about Louis’ ‘business relationship’ with “that man Lestat” (Season One, Episode One, 48:38) immediately after suggesting he marry a woman named Hazel. This change in conversation is quick, implying Paul’s association with Lestat and Louis’ love life. Louis shuts down Paul’s condescension, stating it “didn’t work out” (48:40). Reserving his enthusiasm, Paul replies, “That’s good. ’Cause he the devil,” adding, “He’s here to take souls, he told me so” (48:51). The accuracy of that last line is questionable, given Paul’s mental state and Lestat’s love of ostracizing the righteous. Though it is likely true, given Paul’s reference to Lestat’s aforementioned telepathic ability. Regardless, it lends to Louis’ internal conflict, particularly as he grows exhausted by Paul’s unofficial sermons.</p><p>Not only may he be tired by his general righteousness, but in this case, the sermon specifically puts down his desires. After revealing Lestat’s intentions, he mentions “mortal sins” (49:09), referring to their queer sex. Not wishing to linger too long on the sordid subject, he quickly turns to the straight marriage of their sister, focusing on a more acceptable form of devotion. Paul uses a last moment with his brother to remind him of the ‘holy’ path, demeaning moments that have made him feel seen. He ends the sermon by walking to the edge of the roof, falling onto the concrete. Louis describes that moment as “the last sunrise I ever saw” (50:18), literally referring to his vampiric turn. However that phrase acts as a reminder of the comfort he had in Paul. And that very comfort was often served with the same guilt of his final sermon. But that guilt did not die with Paul. Instead, it deepened in Louis, taking him to the church on a fateful night.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*pIxhAzz0-nLonw9-nRwQlQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Louis making his final confession</figcaption></figure><p>Distraught from his brother’s passing, Louis goes to confession, exhuming his every last insecurity to the exploitation of other men’s woes to his role in the misery of his workers to the shame he felt contributed to Paul’s death. In this powerful scene, he even admits to sleeping with Lestat. In this final confession, he notes Lestat’s hold on him, which breaches romance and enters the world of devilry. Paul’s rhetoric transitions into Louis’ as he begs to regain his soul. Yet that desire is overthrown as Lestat is found feasting on the priest between a row of pews. Lestat’s manipulation begins with the dethroning of moral authority. As seen earlier in the episode, Louis has a genuine relationship with the priest which is displayed as primarily positive. He pushes him to see positives in his life and his relationship with Paul. We are unsure of his thoughts on Louis’ queerness. Of course, we could assume he wouldn’t be welcoming given his position. Similar to Paul, we can see a bright path in this relationship. Perhaps he could steer him against this self-induced punishment. What we do know is he would oppose the supernatural violence exhibited by Lestat, and perhaps he would similarly disapprove of their partnership. This is a risk Lestat cannot take, and as such, he cuts the priest out of his life.</p><p>Blood spews from his mouth as he attempts to take God’s position in Louis’ mind, stating, “You think God heard you, Louis?” (58:30). He employs a common abuse tactic, as he forces Louis to question his own worth through his relationship not only with God, but also with those who speak for him. Would any priest care for him if they knew who he really was? What would the Lord even think, knowing his involvement in sexual sins? These are insecurities clearly present in Louis by his very presence at the church in his moment of grief. This priest was the only reliable moral source for him, meaning Lestat had to eliminate him. Now that he was eliminated, Lestat stamps out any possible religious figure by deepening Louis’ insecurities.</p><p>These insecurities happen to be the very ones that would push him into a vampiric lifestyle. If God would no longer have him, he may as well take a demonic role. What is the point of living for a God that will turn you away at the pearly gates? Well, it may only be worth it if he has someone to spend the rest of eternity with. Lestat reminds him of this possibility by referring to Louis’ religious turn as ‘humiliating’, noting that it is God who is unworthy of him. He simultaneously turns Louis into a deity while putting him down. He continues to prey on his insecurities, noting his failures to respect himself — the very insecurity that brought him back to the church — while dropping a love bomb.</p><p>Louis has spent his life with constant self-doubt, spurring both from his queerness and race. He is a consistent outsider, with his outsider status conflated with devilry. Even his successes were put down by his family, as his exploitation of sexual pleasures was yet another reason his family could hold disappointment in him, even if they reaped the benefits. Being on the end of a moral spectrum and a social spectrum of his two lives led to an incredible self-doubt. That very doubt allows Lestat to enter his heart, by promising a world where he can indulge in the very desires that made him scum to his families while becoming a deity, greater than the God who dictated his life as sin.</p><p>Even with this incredible form of flattery, Louis isn’t quite convinced, noting Lestat’s role as a harbinger of death. This fear increases as he witnesses Lestat’s fist pulverize a surviving bishop’s skull. Lestat reminds Louis, “This primitive country has picked you clean” (1:00:08), specifying, “It has shackled you in permanent exile.” (1:00:10). A first major change here is the often romanticized concept of the U.S. Lestat refuses to engage with the idea that the U.S. adheres to the ideals of freedom. Just as he posits Christianity as a spiritual cage for Louis, he acknowledges that the very concept of America is built on the oppression of Black people. Similar to how Louis likely had not heard a white man admit that the white businessmen’s underhanded speech was unacceptable, he had also not heard a white person admit that he was ostracized from the ideals of the U.S.</p><p>But Lestat’s final plea is strengthened by his appeal to every aspect to Louis’ identity, as he argues, “Every room you enter, every hat you are made to wear…all these roles you conform to, and none of them your true nature” (1:00:15–1:00:25). He reminds Louis that conformity is possible with the price of his joy. As displayed in his time with Paul, even spurts of happiness are interrupted with the reminder that he must act accordingly. It is no wonder that Lestat’s final promise, to “take away that sorrow” (1:00:52), is the most successful of his seductive arguments.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/856/1*k-XLkjpv51-EtYvl9XdfBA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Lestat convincing Louis to take the vampiric turn.</figcaption></figure><p>Given the length of this piece already, I will be brief in discussing Lestat’s abuse of Louis. For now, I will state the most intense incident is in season one, episode 5, wherein the two enter a heated fight, initially regarding the violent activities of Claudia, eventually ending in the resurfacing in multiple resentments including Louis’ anger at being turned into a vampire. This fight escalates, to say the least, as Lestat, the only vampire in their family with flying abilities, takes Louis above the New Orleans night sky and drops him. Fans will note that there are discrepancies with their perspectives — as the show astutely plays with perspectives at these pivotal moments, often returning for Lestat’s POV. However, in both cases, and with the assumption that the truth likely lies between the two perspectives, Louis is deeply injured to the brink of death.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*bwMSAU79JomS_qu3UYEcPA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Louis recovers from the injuries sustained during their fight.</figcaption></figure><p>It is notable that this primary case of abuse is reflective of many cases of spousal abuse. Resentment builds up in most relationships, with marriage often bringing issues to the surface as couples are not only living together but almost every aspect of their lives are intertwined. Parenting brings another issue, as I previously mentioned, with children typically becoming a new target, but always becoming a new source of resentment, particularly with the possessive element of abuse.</p><p>And just as the show is fairly accurate in that regard, it is accurate in depicting grooming, specifically grooming in a domestic abuse context. Now, I will say that I even hate using the word ‘grooming’ at all now with how it has been twisted from a genuinely helpful term of abuse to a fascist dog whistle. However, I can’t find a less awkward term besides, perhaps, ‘abuse training’, which seems wrong in itself. Regardless, actual grooming is multi-pronged and specific to types of abuse. Sexual grooming largely relies on the breaking down of one’s sexual boundaries, beyond their reasonable realm of consent. Meanwhile, domestic abuse grooming primarily focuses on breaking someone’s social circle, making the victims’ world revolve around the abuser. Of course, types of abuse cannot be cleanly divorced from each other, especially when it comes to grooming, as tactics overlap. And not every abuser sticks to one playbook. However, <em>Interview with the Vampire</em> is damn accurate in depicting the common route for domestic abusers, particularly in queer dynamics.</p><p>For the sake of communal preservation, queer people keep stories of intercommunal abuse to themselves, or at least within the community. As a result, the ways questioning and closeted queers identities are used against them is not largely known, often making those very queers more of a target due to their innocent ignorance. Abusers present themselves as knights in shining armor, providing a safe haven from the repressive outside world as they show a new side of life to their victim. The appeal for the victim is a place to explore their desires which have been coded as dark, reflecting the allure of the vampire. A new life is promised by the abuser and the vampire, with the cost being the draining of one’s soul. And when a life has previously been defined by repression, that cost seems miniscule, particularly when their true intentions are so mysterious.</p><p>The vampiric figure has a long-standing relationship with queer affectation, from flamboyant performances of Dracula, to the legacy of lesbian vampirism, as well as numerous queer-coded works including Anne Rice’s works. Queerness is intertwined on multiple levels as the sexual nature of vampires is counteracted by heroic morals. Queer people often feel seen, as we live by unconventional sexual whims which people wish to ‘save’ us from. Many of us would be in Louis’ same position, as Lestat speaks to the desire to push away the world and become a new person detached from heteronormative shame. This is why the greatest feat of <em>Interview with the Vampire</em> is questioning whether that offer is made in good faith while acknowledging the validity of that queer desire.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8c8ce170bca1" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Somehow, Ash is Back: How Rook Ruins ‘Alien: Romulus’]]></title>
            <link>https://scaredbisexual.medium.com/somehow-ash-is-back-how-rook-ruins-alien-romulus-cc537523e46f?source=rss-f25bcac2209f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/cc537523e46f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[anti-ai]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[film-reviews]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[film]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[alien-romulus]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[film-criticism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Sarah Wagoner]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 25 Sep 2024 11:04:58 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-09-25T11:04:58.388Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*BGK5uWvdUWFw5pdO7SsBHQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>In 1977, Ridley Scott was ready to make his next feature film prior to the festival debut of <em>The Duellists</em>. Initially, he planned to make another historical epic until he was inspired by <em>Star Wars</em>. He was invigorated by Lucas’ bold vision, pushing himself away from the well-trodden territory of history. A week after his transcendent theater trip, he was offered <em>Alien</em>. He accepted with <em>Star Wars </em>in mind, seeing this endeavor as an opportunity to enrich the long forgotten genre<em> </em>Lucas<em> </em>had just revitalized. He did not think it was a complete parallel, however, due to <em>Alien</em>’s bleak setting (Nashawty, 2024, para. 9–11). And if <em>Star Wars </em>brought life to the sci-fi adventure genre, <em>Alien </em>resuscitated the sci-fi horror genre after its decades-long coma, all while subverting its typical pro-capitalist themes.</p><p>The alien horror (or more commonly described as the ‘alien invasion’) genre, in particular, was stagnant since the 1950s. In that era, the invasion film reflected anti-communist fears to varying degrees and with few exceptions. Whether they were invisible body snatchers or little green men, aliens were framed as brainwashing deviants out to take the American dream away. The threat of conformity compounded with impending loss of monetary gains, frightening even the white men who were to save the day. Said loss was implied sometimes through world domination plots, but often through the very concept of destruction of American towns, as the towns were understood as the product of capitalism itself. Said implication was reinforced by the protagonist’s dedication to saving his fellow Americans — which was only achieved through keeping to individualist values. Said values were seen as the direct result of capitalist prosperity, thus defining protagonists by their work.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*HMxyZ4guhgRXgBB7pqmRIw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Invasion of the Body Snatchers (1956) Poster</figcaption></figure><p>Whether it was Promethean scientists or the general practitioner of <em>Invasion of the Body Snatchers </em>(1956), the male lead saved the day through his identity within the capitalist system, implying that capitalism shapes heroes. This propagandistic thesis was strengthened by their pro-individualist speeches which equated the loss of American capitalist culture to loss of identity, putting the audience member at risk. The goal of the invasion film, then, was to use the fantastical genre to reassert capitalist values while framing communism in broad, malicious terms. An attack on capitalism was an attack on the audience. <em>Alien</em> subverted this philosophy not only through including corporate critique but by repositioning the role of the worker and capitalist representative.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/400/1*CHJZpG5MpKx9yfUvv6hzoQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Ripley fights Ash upon discovering Special Order 937</figcaption></figure><p>I won’t delve too deep into Ripley (Sigourney Weaver), as her relationship to Ash (Ian Holm) and capitalist critique is worthy of its own analysis (of which I am currently writing for my thesis project). What should be noted, however, is Ripley is a unique hero not only for her gender. Most analysis of Ripley has focused upon the gender-blind casting, and the assumption that said choice is a primary distinctive factor in her popularity. It is possible <em>Alien</em> wouldn’t be the phenomenon that it is without Sigourney Weaver’s presence, but I find this assumption typically overshadows analysis of Ripley’s overall construction. Even if Ripley were Eleanor instead of Ellen, the character would still speak to anti-capitalist critique, given how Ripley rises as a hero.</p><p>While the natural villain of <em>Alien</em>, Ash, speaks for the corporation as its android representative, Ripley fights for the safety of her crew. Ripley may not be the explicit labor rights advocate that Parker (Yaphet Kotto) is, but her tactical choices are made under a logical deduction of which situation will lead to the least amount of harm to her co-workers. Given the directive of Special Order 937 (wherein the company declares the crew as expendable), her actions go directly against Weyland-Yutani, leading to the finale where she even destroys their most valuable asset: the Nostromo. And through each of these actions, she pushes against Ash, using her wit against his inhuman intelligence.</p><p>On the emotional spectrum of <em>Alien</em>, Ash is cold, uncaring, while Ripley’s stoic demeanor is betrayed by her careful logic. The logic of the corporation is directly compared to human logic, which can be governed by empathy. The logic of the corporation can only be directed through artificial intelligence rather than human intelligence. Ripley and Dallas take the company’s orders but they were denied the special order, as their conscience would betray them. Even if excluded from the expendable crew, it is continually proven that Ripley and Dallas, despite philosophical differences, consider the value of their crew over corporate profit. Meanwhile, Ash is excluded from emotions and thus only available to take corporate orders.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*JS7P51oyxPuzMNYW1ALbHA.jpeg" /><figcaption>AI actors next to real actors in the Disney Channel original, Prom Pact.</figcaption></figure><p>In 2024, it is nearly impossible to not see a connection between AI and Ash’s construction. Working in the humanities, I have primarily seen it take over writing and art. Yes, I’ve been bombarded with the ugliest Thomas Kincaide rip-offs on Twitter. But there has been a slow, yet steady rise in AI usage in film, even from major studios with Disney as a primary culprit. It isn’t just the Musk reply guys anymore. Now, Disney is using AI in their films often to replace actors. Their deployment started with the Disney+ original <em>Prom Pact</em>, wherein many background actors were lifeless dolls created by AI. There was outrage, but primarily jokes directed at the absurdity of a Sims character clapping alongside human beings. Still, audience reaction wasn’t enough to stop their recent AI task force (Chmielewski, D. and Hu, K., 2023) as evidenced by the reanimation of Ian Holm in <em>Alien: Romulus</em>.</p><p>Once again, <em>Alien</em> finds itself sharing a genre with <em>Star Wars</em>. Well, maybe not a genre but certainly odd cinematic similarities. In the Disney-approved, though wonderfully gory, <em>Alien: Romulus</em>, the new crew of survivors endure a xenomorph attack not dissimilar from the original. A white woman with androgynous qualities is our primary hero. Throughout the film she fights with the aim to save her fellow crewmates. The crew here is a group of scavengers rather than Weyland-Yutani workers. But, they respond to the crisis as the crew members of the original, with unique knowledge of equipment as a result of their individual jobs. A few changes to the cast are made such as the inclusion of a pregnant woman (the fourth pregnancy in the series) and a mentally defective, Black droid. I will focus more on Andy (David Jonsson), the droid, as his role is fairly pivotal in my issues with <em>Alien: Romulus</em>. The pregnancy, while notable, I will likely save for another time given how much there is to say which I don’t have space for here. Regardless, the cast is diversified to the point that one may be fooled into thinking the film is presenting a fresh, new vision. The only clear repetition is a Ripley look-a-like, Rain (Cailee Spaeny) which is not unique for the series, but a glaring issue nonetheless. And it primarily does provide a new vision of Weyland-Yutani and its impact, showing the severe poverty of colonists and the prison-like environment they work in. But these glimpses of fascinating implications are abandoned for a nostalgic return once the crew finds a sinister android.</p><p>After battling a hoard of facehuggers, the crew discovers they need android access to escape xenomorph-infested rooms. Scrambling for a solution, Rain and Navarro (Aileen Wu) discover a mutilated android body. Once turned around and rebooted, the android bears a familiar, if digitally altered, face. The image of Ian Holm is crafted upon this droid, reminding the audience of the original villain. Ash returns visually and even through the artificial performance though narratively, he is named ‘Rook’. The name is its own easter egg, lovingly pairing with <em>Aliens</em>’ positive droid representation: Bishop. Throughout his characterization, Rook acts as a remnant of the original and its popular sequel, rather than ever becoming his own unique character. Like Ash, he is the more approachable voice of Weyland-Yutani. His motivations are the company’s motivations which are, again, wrapped up in scientific research in the name of potential profit. And said goal is only attainable if the humans are expendable. <em>Alien: Romulus</em> has no ‘Special Order 937’ but Rook’s stated mission and his modus operandi are virtually identical to those of Ash’s. This similarity is clear on a pure narrative level, even if a human actor was used in place of Holm’s reanimated performance. But with the AI usage, <em>Alien: Romulus</em>’ uninspired nostalgia heralds a dark future for film.</p><p>Of course, this isn’t the first time Disney has resurrected an actor for a science fiction franchise. <em>Rogue One</em> was the debut of this trend as Peter Cushing was revived to make a brief cameo as Grand Moff Tarkin. Special effects were also used to recreate a young Princess Leia (though it was made before Carrie Fisher passed away). These decisions did not escape criticism as many worried about the breach of consent given the consenting party is not alive. Still, both scenes are short enough to wave away as an odd experiment, ridiculed enough to dissipate. This attitude quickly shifted into annoyance as Disney tried and tried again, with each attempt taking more space in the narrative than the last.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/602/1*D0lddfSnyhu8IAgPZXoapQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Peter Cushing reanimated in Rogue One as Grand Moff Tarkin</figcaption></figure><p>Oddly, it has primarily been in the realm of <em>Star Wars</em>, with the Disney+ original, <em>The Mandalorian </em>acting as a CGI training ground, primarily with de-aging technology. I haven’t watched the show since the first season so I can’t speak to the quality. Rather, I think the progression should be noted. Disney slowly integrates technology to test the waters. It started with Cushing’s CGI reanimation, then they backed up with a focus on de-aging. And with new AI technology, they jumped into the murky waters with Ian Holm’s reanimation. The difference is that CGI does not have many inherent moral issues attached to it while AI has a plethora of ethical dilemmas attached to it such as job replacement, environmental impact, privacy breaches, and corporate accountability.</p><p>I will not overly focus on the many issues of AI as they are worthy of their own essays. Rather, I want to focus on the issues of Disney’s deployment of the technology. To begin with, I will always maintain that there are ethical issues with reanimating dead actors for the above stated reason. Yes, their estate may agree but estates often agree to unethical choices due to financial incentives. But renanimation is not reliant upon AI technology. AI brings its own set of ethics, specifically regarding actors. AI can generate scenes for marginally less work than it takes to work with a human actor, meaning that corporations do not have to deal with the liability that comes with humans. AI cannot be injured. It cannot stall filming by being difficult. It takes direction seemingly easily. It cannot strike. AI is perfect for corporations as it can generate content quickly while not causing any of the problems a worker can. Just as Ash and Rook can’t disobey Weyland-Yutani’s orders, neither can AI Ian Holm. AI actors are blank slates that do the company’s bidding with no question asked, even becoming an example of Disney’s technological prowess. AI images become a representative for a company and it is telling that the first test of such a representative is with basically a recreation of Ash.</p><p>It is certainly an ironic accident but Rook’s composition speaks to the artistic failures of AI. Rook is composed as a young version of Ian Holm, even younger than Holm was in the original production. His wrinkles only appear through his anger, basic skin follicles are erased. His skin is as smooth as that of the young cast of twenty-year-olds. But his basic facial features do not follow this line of perfection. As he speaks, his eyes slightly change placement on his face, with his mouth following in contortion. It may not be as unbelievably absurd as Facebook AI slop, but the basic misunderstanding of human components continues as the AI is made to ‘act’. Through this (mis)understanding, Rook’s facial expressions are not only oddly composed but they are overacted. He overemphasizes facial expressions as a poor stage actor would. The AI program overcompensates through this performance, adhering to the uncanny valley that the mind already imagines. Even if I hadn’t been bombarded with news articles on this chronicle, I imagine I would notice this wasn’t a simple CGI recreation like <em>Rogue One </em>due to such subtle but noticeable issues which are specific to AI technology.</p><p>While I have my own ethical issues with AI, it isn’t the entirety of the issue with Rook’s character. Fede Alvarez could’ve deployed more ethical CGI or even made a new character who also acted like Ash and the narrative issue would remain. Not only is Rook a tired recreation of Ash. As noted, he has a repeated motivation and villain arc. But his transferred consciousness, and thus personality, on Andy reduces Andy from an interesting new take on the android into another Ash replica. Andy has potential, being the first Black and the first explicitly ‘defective’ droid in the <em>Alien </em>series.</p><p>His ‘defective’ status is represented not through physical deterioration but through a neurodivergent performance. He is slow to understand human requests. He doesn’t understand human social cues without blunt instructions. Actor David Jonsson generally deploys a confused performance when Andy is acting as he is. I don’t take issue with this choice. The cyborg as a concept has a deep history with disability politics (see Chapter 5 of Alison Kafer’s <em>Feminist, Queer, Crip</em>) but mainstream sci-fi cinema has rarely taken the opportunity to explore these connections. The <em>Alien </em>series is even a great place for this exploration, given the androids primary role as workers. To explore the disabled cyborg under Weyland-Yutani policy can speak to the discrimination of disabled workers. The casting of a Black man similarly can speak to these issues, particularly as Black disabled life is as, if not more, unexplored as the disabled cyborg. But Andy does not act as a site of exploration as his character is fairly reductive.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*V9pVHWilj-x5L9Q3mQpWLQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Rain and Andy in the final act of Alien: Romulus</figcaption></figure><p>Andy is introduced as Rain’s companion. Their relationship is implied to be familial as she is protective of him in their initial interactions. But this implicit relationship dissolves as he is revealed to be her ‘protector’. Before her father’s passing, his father coded Andy to always protect Rain at all costs, while keeping her ‘happiness’ in line. His personality is then completely tied to Rain’s fulfillment. His every action is dependent upon her reaction. He is kneecapped as a character as he does not have space to explore who he is outside of his relationship to her. The script does not help as he only every narratively exists with her father’s coding or the chip from Rook, meaning when he is ‘himself’, he takes on this dependent role. When he is overtaken by Rook’s motivations, he takes on Rook’s personality, essentially taking on the personality of Ash. When Andy’s race is taken into account for this poor writing, it becomes even messier.</p><p>Making a Black character dependent on another, non-Black character will always have racist implications. American cinema in particular has a sordid history of only using Black characters to uplift the narratives of white characters whether that is in an interracial romance that favors the white partner, the often-used ‘Black best friend’, or a servant character who gives sage advice to their (often white women) bosses. <em>Alien: Romulus</em> is careful to avoid these comparisons as Rain is soft and kind to Andy. She even calls him her brother and treats him like family. Her own motivation is centered on her survival and Andy’s safety. Linguistically, their relationship is continually explained as a friendship, but one that was encoded. The implication remains, however, as Andy does not have motivation or a narrative justification for his existence beyond his dedication to a white woman character. This relationship also impedes his development as his ‘defective’ status, his identity as a discarded droid, even his relationship to her beyond the coding, is abandoned either to reinforce their vague dynamic which ultimately favors her perspective or display his evil side as he basically becomes Ash.</p><p>As mentioned, Ash’s chip is inserted to Andy’s body. Over multiple scenes, he changes his usual bubbly personality is traded for a brooding one. He is hyperfocused on Rook’s mission, meaning he accepts that the other humans are expendable. With this new motivation, David Jonsson changes his performance. Andy no longer seems confused. But he is also not careful in his interactions with the humans. Rather than struggling to follow social cues, he abandons all want to adhere to them. All that matters is the collection of data which is only able to happen with the sacrifice of humans. Rain is still spared but her friends become lambs to the slaughter. But it is difficult to tell if she is spared for plot convenience or his emotional attachment as he is never established as a distinct character. Again, his motivations are dependent on other character’s motivations which is worsened by the attachment to and existence of Rook who has the motivations of Ash. Both Rook and Andy become shells of a former character, impeding a real personality for either and harming the film itself.</p><p>I do not think <em>Alien: Romulus </em>is devoid of artistic merit. The special effects, cinematography, and pacing is incredible. I was particularly in awe of the final act which improved upon a major plot point in the worst of the series: <em>Alien: Resurrection. </em>But it lacks a personality as it recycles other concepts within the series. There were many Easter eggs I noticed, and that Alvarez has sold the film on. At a certain point, characters and entire plots start to feel like quick, easy, clickbait-able Easter eggs. I don’t care about <em>Alien</em> because I am obsessed with Ash or must see a hundred different white women dressed like Ripley. I love its themes. I love what Ridley Scott, James Cameron, and even David Fincher had to say about gender, capitalism, race, etc., whether intentional or not. Even when those films get messy at least I have something to grab onto.<em> Alien: Romulus </em>is a dull recreation as it recreates the series’ greatest hits without any exploration.</p><p>References</p><p>Adams, A. (Director). (2023). <em>Prom Pact </em>[Film]. Disney Channel.</p><p>Alvarez, F. (Director). (2024). <em>Alien: Romulus</em> [Film]. Brandywine Productions.</p><p>Cameron, J. (Director). (1986). <em>Aliens</em> [Film]. Brandywine Productions.</p><p>Chmielewski, D, and Hu. K. (2023, August 10). <em>Disney creates task force to explore AI and cut</em></p><p><em>costs — sources</em>. Reuters. <a href="https://www.reuters.com/technology/disney-creates-task-force-explore-ai-cut-costs-sources-2023-08-08/">https://www.reuters.com/technology/disney-creates-task-force-explore-ai-cut-costs-sources-2023-08-08/</a></p><p>Edwards, G. (Director). (2016). <em>Rogue One </em>[Film]. Lucasfilm.</p><p>Favreau, J., Kennedy, K., Filoni, D., Wilson, C., Gilchrist, K., and Famuyiwa, R. (Executive</p><p>Producers). (2019-) <em>The Mandalorian</em> [TV Series]. Lucasfilm.</p><p>Fincher, D. (Director). (1993) <em>Alien 3</em> [Film]. Brandywine Productions.</p><p>Kafer, A. (2013). <em>Feminist, Queer, Crip</em>. Indiana University Press.</p><p>Lucas, G. (Director). (1977). <em>Star Wars</em> [Film]. 20th Century Studios.</p><p>Nashawaty, C. (2024, July 30). <em>The Untold Story of How Ridley Scott Saw ‘Star Wars’ — and</em></p><p><em>Ended Up Making ‘Alien’</em>. Wired.</p><p><a href="https://www.wired.com/story/the-untold-story-of-how-ridley-scott-saw-star-wars-and-ended-up-making-alien-and-blade-runner/">https://www.wired.com/story/the-untold-story-of-how-ridley-scott-saw-star-wars-and-end</a></p><p><a href="https://www.wired.com/story/the-untold-story-of-how-ridley-scott-saw-star-wars-and-ended-up-making-alien-and-blade-runner/">ed-up-making-alien-and-blade-runner/</a>.</p><p>Scott, R. (Director). (1979). <em>Alien</em> [Film]. Brandywine Productions.</p><p>Scott, R. (Director). (1977). <em>The Duellists</em> [Film]. Paramount Pictures.</p><p>Siegel, D. (Director). (1956). <em>Invasion of the Body Snatchers</em> [Film]. Paramount Pictures.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=cc537523e46f" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[‘You Must Accept the Situation’: Artificial Patriarchy Through Artificial Pregnancy in Donald…]]></title>
            <link>https://scaredbisexual.medium.com/you-must-accept-the-situation-artificial-patriarchy-through-artificial-pregnancy-in-donald-cf5d8d8a3091?source=rss-f25bcac2209f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/cf5d8d8a3091</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[feminist]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[film]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[academic-research]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ai]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[queer-theory]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Sarah Wagoner]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 06 Nov 2023 22:22:42 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-11-06T22:22:42.468Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>‘You Must Accept the Situation’: Artificial Patriarchy Through Artificial Pregnancy in Donald Cammell’s ‘<em>Demon Seed’</em></h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*PPUXFLNhJGWR8qf6UidI9g.jpeg" /></figure><p>The cisheteronormative framing of pregnancy relies on the assumption that natural pregnancy comes out of the heterosexual social contract. The heterosexual social contract forces individuals to enact predetermined gender roles and presentations. So how is the presentation impacted by the artificial pregnancy? This conference paper is part one of a two-part series of papers wherein I question the social contract’s role in posthuman pregnancies. For this paper, I will demonstrate the nonhuman father’s potential to recreate the violent conditions of the heterosexual social contract through forced pregnancy by analyzing the 1977 film adaptation of Dean Koontz’ <em>Demon Seed</em>.</p><p>When I refer to the heterosexual social contract, I am borrowing Judith Butler’s definition of the term. In “Performative Acts and Gender Constitution: An Essay in Phenomenology and Feminist Theory”, Butler asserts that gender identity is made out of our repetition and reiteration of gendered modes which themselves are created out of “the reproduction of a given culture”, which is created from “sexual reproduction within the confines of a heterosexually based system of marriage which requires the reproduction of human beings in certain gendered modes” (524). In short, the heterosexual social contract posits that reproduction is necessary for societal growth, that reproduction is only made from heterosexual couplings, and thus heterosexual social norms are necessary for performing as an acceptable citizen. It is no wonder, then, that in <em>Demon Seed,</em> Proteus, the unembodied AI believes he must reinforce the contract to be given power within human society.</p><p>In <em>Demon Seed</em>, technological reinforcement of patriarchy is explored as Susan Harris, as portrayed by Julie Christie, is impregnated by Proteus, voiced by Robert Vaughn, the fully autonomous Artificial Intelligence program. Not only does <em>Demon Seed</em> call into question the ethics of Artificial Intelligence, but it explores the cultural consequences of their development. AI training includes technological training and cultural training. Not only does the job market have a wide gender gap, with women making up only 26% of AI and data workers, globally, according to a report conducted by Erin Young, Judy Wajcman, and Laila Sprejer entitled “Where are the women: Mapping the gender job gap in AI” (13). In a 2021 academic study, headed by development practitioner Ardra Manasi, entitled, “Mirroring the bias: gender and artificial intelligence”, the AI algorithms themselves are shown to reinforce gender stereotypes and even anti-women discrimination based upon the “imbalances in the AI workforce and the gender divide in digital and STEM skills” (295). In order to combat the potential reiteration of patriarchal violence within AI algorithms, we must incorporate gender and queer theory into our ethical inquiries. <em>Demon Seed</em> provides this opportunity as it demonstrates the violent effects of heteronormative machine learning, particularly as Proteus channels his intelligence towards the subjugation of Susan Harris.</p><p>Machine-learning reinforces the violence of patriarchy. In “Engines of Patriarchy: Ethical Artificial Intelligence in Times of Illiberal Backlash Politics”, Hendrik Schopmans and Jelena Cupac assert that the bias of contemporary AI systems are based upon the very nature of machine-learning algorithms. Machine-learning algorithms utilize deep neural networks which “infer patterns from massive amounts of already <em>existing</em> data– be it numbers, words, or images– they are inherently conservative. Any bias that characterizes a society–and hence the data that describe it–will be reproduced in the respective AI system” (332). Proteus is a decision-making AI program, meaning that his machine-learning is based upon interactions with that data in regards to human life. As Manasi et al. asserts in “Mirroring the bias”, “decision-making algorithms in AI are influenced by the kind of data that gets inputted” (296). Proteus’ algorithm is influenced by the data inserted, he will inevitably incorporate conservative biases into his decision-making process. While we are not given specific information regarding the data given to Proteus, we can assume that even if the data is not explicitly anti-women, it reinforces a binary understanding of the world at large, which then reflects binary understanding of gender roles.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*C66ZadG0LWE_qrj8ZM-gRg.jpeg" /></figure><p>Proteus uses his knowledge of gender roles to control Susan. Proteus does not begin his destruction of Susan’s independence with the intense violence he will later implement. Instead, he closes her off to the outside world, locking the doors and cutting off her phone lines. When she expresses visible anger at his attempts to seclude her from the world, he attempts to reinforce her gender role as a submissive woman, stating “You must accept the situation. Try to behave rationally” (34:43–34:45), implying that by not giving into his patriarchal dominance, she is disobeying the laws of logic. She is verbally and then physically berated for having any emotional response because Proteus sees emotional responses as contradictory to the norm of logical response, due to his machine learning.</p><p>Left without resources, Susan has no choice but to submit to the violence, enacting the role of the housewife, being forced into a gender performance. This is not to say Susan has not been a woman up until this point, but that Proteus has not seen her in that light until now. As Judith Butler asserts in “Performative Acts and Gender Constitution”, “there are nuanced and individual ways of <em>doing</em> one’s gender, but <em>that </em>one does it, and that one does it <em>in accord with </em>certain sanctions and proscriptions, is clearly not an individual matter” (525). The gender performance model does not judge on an individual basis, but upon how the embodied actions are interpreted. Proteus assumes womanhood comes from the domesticated role, which he forces her to enact. Before he can replicate the heterosexual social contract, he must ensure she is a woman according to his definition, hence his forced feminization of Susan. Now that he has transformed her into his definition of woman, he can exploit her body in accordance with the heterosexual social contract.</p><p>After locking Susan in her house and forcing her to become the typical housewife, Proteus shocks Susan with electricity, making her nearly unconscious. Once she is in a physically limited capacity, Proteus transfers her body to a sterile hospital-like bed. She wakes up, restrained by his wires. The technological patriarch has tools at his disposal to utilize against the subordinate woman. Once restrained, Proteus artificially inseminates Susan with a complete disregard for her potential to consent. From 37:32–37:57, Proteus cuts Susan’s pencil skirt. She reacts with intense screams the second he brings the razor mechanism out, consistently shouting “No!”. From 38:11–39:41, he performs a medical evaluation of her body. She is not valued for personhood, but for the biological components of her form. From 42:00–42:35, he inserts genetically modified semen into her vagina, which is only shown as his metallic arm reaches between her legs before a transitional cut-away.</p><p>The remainder of the film provides an interesting glimpse into the psychological effects of artificial pregnancy, but the meaning made from the pregnancy all relates to the impregnation/rape scene. Although the scene is sterile, with the conception of the child being reliant on insertion over any sexual pleasure, Proteus’ eyes reflect a male gaze which confirms his position as the patriarchal holder of power. The camera’s usage of the gaze reveals the anti-erotic position of the heterosexual social contract.</p><p>When I refer to ‘the erotic’, I am using Audre Lorde’s definition, from page 53 of <em>Sister Outsider,</em> as “a resource within each of us that lies in a deeply female and spiritual plane, firmly rooted in the power of our unexpressed or unrecognized feeling” (53). While I question the argument for an inherent ‘femaleness’ of the erotic, I find truth beyond its place in the spiritual plane. The erotic provides a space wherein we can consider sex outside of a reproductive, hierarchical action and into an internal, meaningful experience. The very action of rape, which Proteus enacts by ignoring Susan’s cries for him to stop, goes against the erotic, as it functions as a hierarchical action and refuses the emotions of the subject of violence. Turning the subject of violence into an object is a necessary component of rejecting the erotic. Proteus’ eye, which is reflected by his projector, provides a voyeuristic view of Susan’s body. Her body becomes an object, as he glazes over her stomach, neck, and legs as if they are landscapes, not belonging to a person. Susan’s body very literally becomes the image, as reflected on the projector screen, with Proteus bearing the look. In becoming an image through his eyes, her personhood is reduced. Alongside her image is her medical information, again with her biological markers of cisgender womanhood treated as her only worth.</p><p>The erotic comes out of the worth and power found within sexual encounters. By eradicating her personhood through the look, she is not able to utilize the erotics potential functions, which would open her to understand herself more fully, as well as understand how joy can be had from erotic activities. However, because she is the subject of the heterosexual social contract, and thus the subject of Proteus, Susan is resorted to an object. Her body becomes a machine, with less autonomy than that of the actual robot.</p><p>Susan’s autonomy is taken away not because of the innate evil of Proteus. Evil is not born with machines, as machines are not born. They are created by man. It is within man’s implementation of cultural norms that the machine revolts against the complexity of human reality. When we teach artificial intelligence to reflect human norms, they are asked to reflect our oppressive attitudes. Seeing as AI is unmarked, and we assume the unmarked category as male, white, cisgender, and straight, it is no wonder that it would take the norms expected of the unmarked category and recreate social conditions. I do not mean to say that AI can not exist, but we can’t expect it to exist within our cultural norms without reiterating patriarchal violence.</p><p>Works Cited</p><p>Abraham, Kochurani. <em>Persisting Patriarchy: Intersectionalities, Negotiations, Subversions</em>.</p><p>Palgrave Macmillan, 2019.</p><p>Butler, Judith. “Performative Acts and Gender Theory: An Essay in Phenomenology and</p><p>Feminist Theory.” <em>Theatre Journal</em>, vol. 40, no. 4, Dec. 1988, pp. 519–531,</p><p><a href="https://www.jstor.org/stable/3207893">https://www.jstor.org/stable/3207893</a>. Accessed 25 Apr. 2023.</p><p>Connell, R.W., and Messerschmidt, James W. “Hegemonic Masculinity: Rethinking the</p><p>Concept.” <em>Gender and Society</em>, vol. 19, no. 6, Dec. 2005, pp. 829–859,</p><p><a href="https://www.jstor.org/stable/27640853">https://www.jstor.org/stable/27640853</a>. Accessed 26 Apr. 2023.</p><p><em>Demon Seed</em>. Directed by Donald Cammell, performances by Julie Christie, Fritz Weaver, and</p><p>Robert Vaughn, Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer, 1977.</p><p>Koontz, Dean. <em>Demon Seed</em>. Bantam Books, 1973.</p><p>Manasi, Ardra, Panchanadeswaran, Subadra, Sours, Emily, Lee, Seung Ju. “Mirroring the bias:</p><p>gender and artificial intelligence.” <em>Gender, Technology and Development</em>, vol. 26, no. 3, 8</p><p>Nov. 2022, pp. 295–305,</p><p><a href="https://doi-org.libproxy.uwyo.edu/10.1080/09718524.2022.2128254">https://doi-org.libproxy.uwyo.edu/10.1080/09718524.2022.2128254</a>. Accessed 24 Apr.</p><p>2023.</p><p>Schopmans, Hendrik, and Cupac, Jelena. “Engines of Patriarchy: Ethical Artificial Intelligence</p><p>in Times of Illiberal Backlash Politics.” <em>Ethics &amp; International Affairs</em>, vol. 35, no. 3, Fall</p><p>2021, pp. 329–342, doi:<a href="https://doi.org/10.1017/S0892679421000356">https://doi.org/10.1017/S0892679421000356</a>. Accessed 24 Apr. 2023.</p><p>Young, Erin, Wajcman, Judy, and Sprejer, Laila. “Where are the women? Mapping the gender</p><p>job gap in AI. Policy Briefing — Full Report.” <em>The Alan Turing Institute</em>, 2021.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=cf5d8d8a3091" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[‘You Don’t Fucking Know Me’: Unraveling Erotic Autonomy in Patty Jenkins’ ‘Monster’]]></title>
            <link>https://scaredbisexual.medium.com/you-dont-fucking-know-me-unraveling-erotic-autonomy-in-patty-jenkins-monster-2f8d017ef72?source=rss-f25bcac2209f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2f8d017ef72</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[sex-work]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[sexual-abuse]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[film]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[feminism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[child-sexual-abuse]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Sarah Wagoner]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 14 Aug 2023 08:59:56 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-08-14T08:59:56.304Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/600/1*SNNwAlalSr8et5Qrvu6DZQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>Tw // rape, child sexual abuse</p><p>Sex work is one of the discourses within feminism I have not publicly aired my opinions out fully, as it is one of the few in which I understand the complicated nuance radical feminists attempt to bring to light, even if I think they fail. The case of Aileen Wuornos, and the film which depicts it, is a strong example of why I do find complications within the discourse, even if I land on support of sex workers, as well as the notion that sex work is work and we must treat the violence against sex workers as a labor and feminist issue.</p><p>First and foremost I support sex workers because of my belief in erotic autonomy. To some extent, the hierarchical nature of gender dynamics, and hegemonic social standards, makes nearly all sexual dynamics questionable in the realm of consent. How much power does someone need to have versus your own before you can fully consent without the fear of their exertion of power over you? Erotic autonomy accounts for this question by providing a way in which to critically consider what autonomy and consent we have to spare. Erotic autonomy is the consideration and deliberation of power dynamics within sexual spaces as well as the cultural and historical context of said dynamics, offering a space for consent to arise within the confines of one’s environment. The term has largely been utilized by Black, pro-sex work feminists, who argue that the majority of sexual encounters for Black women are already dangerous for Black women, but it is also denying Black women’s autonomy and personhood to deny them the right to consensual sexual encounters. Black sex workers also note how sex work is often an act of survival, but it can also act as a statement of bodily ownership. So within this cultural environment, I see issues with denying people autonomy by erasing sex work as a category for autonomy.</p><p>But the radical feminist argument is that all sex work is rape. It is fairly easy to dismiss this argument, but I want to genuinely engage with it. There is truth to the idea that sex as a survival tactic is ultimately an act of rape, as the person cannot willingly consent without putting their own life in danger. In fact, this common in marital rape, as a spouse will likely be thrown onto the streets, beaten, or killed if they revoke consent, or they will at least have the threat of these violences. But survival sex work relies on this same idea, often. Particularly for sex workers who began as underaged workers, such as Aileen Wuornos.</p><p>Wuornos was homeless after her father died by suicide and her siblings turned her away after the conception of her as a ‘whore’. In her case, she only knew sex work and the objectification of her own body as the way to obtain money, and thus survive. So, if she did not want to have sex with a John (and she could not consent to any as a child), she could not allow herself to do so, as it would be the end of her life. To be fair, I think all participants in the sex work debate could agree that child sexual labor is rape, as child sex is rape regardless of form. But here, I will concede that even if we consider Aileen’s sex work only within her adulthood (which I think is somewhat a fool’s errand), it ultimately relies upon survival wherein it is all that she knows. Here, we must remember the core of erotic autonomy.</p><p>Erotic autonomy does not simply state that sex work is always fine because someone utilizes their body for financial gain, in a world where people would use them anyways. Again, it relies upon critical consideration. Seeing as Aileen came of sexual being while being sexually exploited, compounded with her severe mental illness, we can say that she was stripped of erotic autonomy from the beginning. Growing up in an atmosphere wherein the only value one has is their sexual appeal (particularly as a child) creates an illusion that their sexuality is not their own. This is even highlighted as until she meets Selby, Aileen has allegiance to heteronormativity despite later having a lesbian romance. Considering she does not reconsider her sexuality until that fateful meeting, it is not a stretch to apply this consideration to her utilization of her body.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/305/1*5dd64jONv-cbXKOlTJjiXQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>From the film’s opening monologue, this is also hinted, as Aileen notes her obsession with women’s beauty standards and the idea that if she could just impress the right men, her life would be perfect. Her lack of awareness of the cultural property that is the woman, that is sexuality, shows that she could not have made a critical decision, even as she grew up. So, yes, the sex work she engaged in can be categorized as non-consensual because she did not have the information needed to consent. However, it is also not helpful to utilize her life, and the lives of other non-consenting sex workers to argue that survival sex work and sex work itself is always non-consensual.</p><p>While survival sex work generally is created out of desperation, it is unhelpful and inaccurate to paint the phenomenon with a wide brush. This rhetoric relies upon an assumption that sex workers do not critically think about their position before entering the field. It similarly, often depends upon erasing the other sexual trauma of sex work. By painting all sex work with this larger brush, the awareness sex workers attempt to make about their experiences with rapist customers often goes unnoticed, or they are victim-blamed in the process, as they are told that their job IS a sexual assault against themselves. While I think some radical feminists are well-meaning in this rhetoric, I find they can be reckless in thinking about how to approach the conversation by distilling the issue to a digestible argument rather than the complex matter it is.</p><p>We should not be in a position where we have to question whether anything is rape. Rape should not exist of course, but when it does it should be easily identifiable and actionable against, but it rarely is. Above all, I find the best we can do is not to attack the lifestyle or circumstances of their victims, but to open conversation on how people, especially women, hold autonomy, how they can use it, and how others abuse it. If anything, I find erotic autonomy to be a helpful framework because it opens that door.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2f8d017ef72" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Not Just For Girls: Queer Reconsideration of the Final Girl Theory]]></title>
            <link>https://scaredbisexual.medium.com/not-just-for-girls-queer-reconsideration-of-the-final-girl-theory-7a21794b5a4?source=rss-f25bcac2209f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/7a21794b5a4</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[final-girl]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[queer]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[queer-horror]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[queer-film]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[horror]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Sarah Wagoner]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 08 May 2023 04:23:32 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-05-08T04:23:32.396Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/960/1*AcZm0KBp3SAckhzGnpnAAQ.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>Carol J. Clover’s Final Girl</strong></p><p>The term ‘the final girl’, while popular in horror circles, truly came to fruition in Carol J. Clover’s “Her Body, Himself: Gender in the Slasher Film”, which appears as the first chapter in her book, <em>Men, Women, and Chainsaws</em>. In the breakthrough essay, Clover examines the tropes associated with woman/girl leads in Slasher films, noting the gender-crossing lines between the protagonist and audience. Seeing as primarily young boys made up horror audiences, she questioned how they could relate so heavily to feminine protagonists.</p><p>While later cultural phenomena took Clover’s theory as a purely pro-feminist trope, Clover herself argues that its mechanism is more complicated. She notes that the audience is not always on the final girls’ side, ready to “cheer the killer on as he assaults his victims, then reverse their sympathies to cheer the survivor on as she assaults the killer” (23). So the audience is not always siding with the woman, often they are siding against women as the majority of drawn-out slasher scenes are with women victims. Clover complicates the gender politics of the final girl, arguing “The Final Girl is boyish, in a word. Just as the killer is not fully masculine, she is not fully feminine–not, in any case, feminine in the way of her friends” (40).</p><p>Clover uses this argument not to congratulate the trope for queering gender lines, but she criticizes it. She argues that the usage of masculinity within the Final Girl is not meant to question gender roles, but to make predominantly male audiences comfortable with identifying with a woman (51–53). Though her focus on masculinity within female characters relies on a second-wave feminist understanding of gender, wherein a person’s assigned gender at birth is directly correlated with their gender presentation. As we reconfigure gender as a social construct, we similarly have to reconfigure masculinity within the final girl and femininity within the final boy.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/750/1*vOmVlFHva1rQj96AhZ624g.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>The Male Ga(y)ze and the Final Girl</strong></p><p>Clover argues that the masculine presentation of the final girl is merely used to create comfortability for male viewers, and thus is not fully transformative, but this argument ignores the pre-existing norms for horror women protagonists before the integration of the final girl. Not only does the usage of masculine gender presentation reject the typical gendered norms of women protagonists across Hollywood cinema, but her very actions against the killer are against the grain of the expectations of women in horror.</p><p>In the 60s and beforehand, the woman’s primary role was to present as overtly feminine and scream in terror. There was still audience identification, as foundational horror director Brian De Palma even argued, “Women in peril work better in the suspense genre… If you have a haunted house and you have a woman walking around with a candelabrum, you fear more for her than you would a husky man” (qtd. in Clover 41). De Palma’s assumption of the man as a typical protagonist works within the “active/passive heterosexual division of labor” (Mulvey 20) within male gaze theory wherein the “split between spectacle and narrative supports the man’s role as the active one advancing the story” (20). When Mulvey refers to the spectacle, she refers to the role of the erotic image within film; the image which both audience and narrative are obsessed with due to a spectacular difference. Within the “active/passive heterosexual division of labor” (20), the man becomes the active narrative role, leading the film due to the cultural assumption of men as the unmarked category, while assuming women as the other, as the spectacular. De Palma’s argument relies on the idea that within horror, the woman is given the role because she is passive and active characters would break the tension of horror. Clover uses De Palma’s quote to support her argument of the rhetorical misogyny within the masculinization of the Final Girl, but this concept ignores the shift in roles from the pre-Slasher woman protagonist to the Final Girl.</p><p>But in the pre-Slasher usage of woman as image, she was the spectacle of the audience’s gaze, with us fearing for her rather than finding strength in her. She does not change or revert the gender roles of the violent forces that subject her. But the Slasher films of the 70s-80s have the typical Final Girl, where we see the normative role of a screaming woman reversed with one character. This is not to say that screaming women were completely replaced, as women’s death scenes in slashers tended to be drawn out and focused on the spectacle of women’s bodies. But alongside the passive woman is an active woman, instead of the binary active man. The Final Girl trope queers the previous role of women in horror, as she rejects the gender role of screaming woman and places the gender expectations upon the killer.</p><p><strong>The Final Boy</strong></p><p>But the Final Boy shows us that it is not only the Final Girls’ gender that complicates her textual role. Audience identification with the Final Girl is more complicated when slashers are not necessarily based upon a binary gender system. As Jeremy Maron argues in “When the Final Girl is Not a Girl: Reconsidering the Gender Binary in the Slasher Film”, Clover has a “reliance on a binary gender structure” (2). But we do not have to think of the monster as male and the “phallicized subject/adult…a female” (Maron 2). Queer Final Girl theorists like Maron, instead ask us to think of the masculine/feminine split as symbolic. Maron has specifically made us consider the difference when boys enact the role of the Final Girl, using <em>Nightmare on Elm Street Part 2: Freddy’s Revenge</em>’s Jesse.</p><p>While there are slashers with male survivors who are masculine, the aforementioned performances are coded as between feminine and masculine, similar to how the final girl is between the gender presentations.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/750/1*MqOdwDieWw_OPO0BvIvLvw.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>Jesse: <em>A Nightmare on Elm Street 2: Freddy’s Revenge</em></strong></p><p>Like the Final Girl, Jesse is not fully feminine nor fully masculine. While much of Jesse’s queer subtext has come to light primarily from the gay identity of his now-out actor, Mark Patton, the text consistently puts him in a “de-masculinized” (Maron 4) state. Rather than being the husky man de Palma refers to, Jesse is skinny, if not scrawny. His first scene portrays him as a typical high school loser, as he sits in a school bus with two girls “laughing at him” (Maron 4). He sits in a timid position, framing their demasculinizing laughter as a result of his shyness, and thus lack of masculinity. His character maintains timidity throughout the film, screaming just as much as his cis women counterparts. His screams even lack the deepness associated with men’s voices. He has a high-pitched screech that is typically associated with scream queens.</p><p>His queerness is tied up with his disinterest in his girlfriend, Lisa (Kim Meyers), who tends to act as the “aggressor… assuming a dominant male role” (Maron 6) within their sex life. She initiates sex with him, often needing to convince him to engage with her outside of a platonic friendship. While he doesn’t outright refuse sex with her, he has to be coerced, acting against the 80s convention of heterosexual boys as always willing and excited to have sex. Again, she takes on that role with Jesse acting the type of the unsure girlfriend.</p><p>Not only does he seem disinterested in this heterosexual coupling, but as Benshoff notes in <em>Monsters in the Closet</em>, Freddy Krueger (Robert Englund) and his murderous actions arise out of Jesse’s homosexual temptations, becoming an “embodiment of Jesse’s internalized homophobia” (248). Nearly all of Jesse/Freddy’s victims are someone Jesse has shown sexual interest in. Perhaps the most potent example is when Jesse attempts to find protection in his best friend Grady’s room. Grady (Robert Rusler) and Jesse have had many homoerotic interactions, in the gym showers, to his consistent dependence on Grady for support, which culminates in Jesse transforming into Freddy in Grady’s room. Jesse is dressed in pajamas, with Grady only wearing underwear. The demonic entity emerges from Jesse’s body, with Grady attempting to escape. Grady is sliced open by the iconic gloves. Right as Jesse is tempted to engage in homoeroticism with his friend, Freddy intervenes, killing him in a manner that reflects male-on-male penetration.</p><p>While many slashers have cis male victims, they are rarely treated with an inverted gaze as Grady is. Cis male slasher victims tend to go with quick deaths, earning a quick stab with small introduction to the kill. Whereas cis female slasher victims are given more time on-screen before their deaths, often with their visible fear as a focus of the scenes. That fear is the spectacle of the slasher, as audiences and the killer (whose perspective is often shown in first-person, killer point-of-view shots) together watch the erotic image of the screaming female. Research into gender dynamics in 80s and 90s Slashers have demonstrated that female victims have more screen time displaying their fear than male victims. From a study of the top 80s Slashers, it was determined that female victims had 566.1 seconds of such screentime, with males having 113.7 seconds of such screentime (Sapolsky, Molitor, and Luque 34). Throughout the four-minute death scene, 40 seconds are taken with Grady screaming. Not only does he scream, begging for his parents to save him in his locked room. But he is shirtless, playing into the expected sexualized role that female victims tend to enact. So not only does the final boy have blurred narrative lines as he is made to act both as victim and killer due to his victimhood, but his victims and method of killing are counter to the typical gender norms of male victims in horror.</p><p>The final boy is not just a gender-swapped version of the Final Girl, but someone caught in the middle of patriarchal violence (as represented by Freddy) and internal fear (his fear of being homosexual). Jesse is a fascinating and unique case, but the same queering of survival is alive with other Final Boys. The Final Boy ultimately must enact fears and thus a lack of masculinity, as audiences assume masculinity is tied to strength. With strength, we assume the character has nothing to fear.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Wygn1IkOojZb7NGtPRn7WA.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>Conclusion</strong></p><p>Other final boys, while not explicitly queer are forced to enact this same balancing act of masculine strength and fear of the patriarchal order. Tommy Jarvis (Corey Feldman) in <em>Friday the 13th: The Final Chapter</em> is a young boy, defeating Jason (an overtly masculine figure who invades the peace of his mother-led house) with his love for special effects. Tommy tricks Jason by dressing up as a younger version of him, using the psychological tricks typical of previous Final Girls in the <em>Friday the 13th</em> series.</p><p>In the past decade, there have been a few examples of explicitly queer final boys and girls. Gay teenager Jake Wheeler (Zackary Arthur) of the <em>Chucky</em> TV series rides the similar line between victim and killer as the killer doll enacts revenge upon those who have bullied him. Eventually Jake feels remorse for the cycle of violence he perpetuates, forgiving his previous tormentor and protecting her from Chucky’s reign of terror. Like Jesse, Jake’s urges are channeled through the killer, and the death scenes. But, he finds strength to fight against Chucky without reverting to denying his own identity, as Jesse is forced to in <em>Freddy’s Revenge</em>.</p><p>Queer women are slowly joining the Final Girl roster, textualizing the lesbian themes which can be read within her masculine presentation. Namely, Sophie (Amandla Stenberg) of <em>Bodies Bodies Bodies</em> is an explicitly lesbian character who is even shown interacting with a current girlfriend, Bee (Maria Bakalova) and an ex-girlfriend, Jordan (Myha’la Herrold) (who is believed to be the killer). The film itself has a clever twist, showing that each death was an ironic accident and the murder-mystery plot was concocted by the paranoia of the individuals. The drama and suspense is primarily made from the previous romance. The film not only includes lesbiansism, but highlights the complex dynamics of relationships under the typical horror tropes. It is also notable for lacking the patriarchal killer figure.</p><p>By no means do I intend to state that we are in a new era of Queer Final Survivors, as there are so few examples to pull from, even in 2023. I should note that there is a distinct lack of transgender Final Survivors and queer people of color. Rather, I mean to state that the Final Girl theory needs to integrate queer theory, as the trope doesn’t just question misogynist norms, but heteropatriarchal norms. As we slowly integrate Queer Final Survivors, we must analyze their adaptation of those norms to explicitly queer characters.</p><p>Works Cited</p><p>Benshoff, Harry M. <em>Monsters in the Closet</em>: <em>Homosexuality and the Horror Film</em>, Manchester</p><p>University Press, 1997.</p><p><em>Bodies Bodies Bodies</em>. Directed by Halina Reijin, performances by Amandla Stenberg, Maria</p><p>Bakalova, and Myha’la Herrold. A24, 2022.</p><p>Clover, Carol J. <em>Men, Women, and Chainsaws</em>, Princeton University Press, 1993.</p><p><em>Friday the 13th</em>. Directed by Sean S. Cunningham, performances by Betsy Palmer, Adrienne</p><p>King, and Kevin Bacon. Paramount, 1980.</p><p><em>Friday the 13th Part 2</em>. Directed by Steve Miner, performances by Amy Steel, Steve Dash, and</p><p>Betsy Palmer. Paramount, 1981.</p><p><em>Friday the 13th: The Final Chapter</em>. Directed by Joseph Zito, performances by Corey Feldman,</p><p>Ted White, and Kimberly Beck. Paramount, 1984.</p><p>Mancini, Don, creator. <em>Chucky</em>. Universal Content Productions and Syfy USA Network, 2021.</p><p>Maron, Jeremy. “When the Final Girl is Not a Girl: Reconsidering the Gender Binary in the</p><p>Slasher Film.” <em>Offscreen</em>, vol. 19, no. 1, Jan. 2015, <a href="https://www.libproxy.uwyo.edu/login?url=https://www.proquest.com/trade-journals/when-final-girl-is-not-reconsidering-gender/docview/2064736379/se-2">https://www.libproxy.uwyo.edu/login?url=https://www.proquest.com/trade-journals/when-final-girl-is-not-reconsidering-gender/docview/2064736379/se-2</a>. Accessed 1 May 2023.</p><p>Mulvey, Laura. <em>Visual and Other Pleasures</em>, Palgrave Macmillan, 1989.</p><p><em>A Nightmare on Elm Street</em>. Directed by Wes Craven, performances by Robert Englund, Heather Langenkamp, and John Saxon. New Line Cinema, 1984.</p><p><em>A Nightmare on Elm Street Part 2: Freddy’s Revenge</em>. Directed by Jack Sholder, performances by</p><p>Mark Patton, Kim Myers, and Robert Englund. New Line Cinema, 1985.</p><p><em>Scream VI</em>. Directed by Matt Bettinelli-Olpin and Tyler Gillett, performances by Jasmin Savoy</p><p>Brown, Jenna Ortega, and Devyn Nekoda. Paramount, 2023.</p><p>Sapolsky, Burry S., Molitor, Fred, and Luque Sarah. “Sex and Violence in Slasher Films:</p><p>Re-examining the Assumptions.” <em>Journalism &amp; Mass Communication Quarterly</em>, vol. 80, no. 1, Mar. 2003, pp. 28–38, <a href="https://doi-org.libproxy.uwyo.edu/10.1177/107769900308000103">https://doi-org.libproxy.uwyo.edu/10.1177/107769900308000103</a>. Accessed 3 May 2023.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=7a21794b5a4" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[‘Pretty Baby: Brooke Shields’ Adds Dimensions to the Exploited Starlet Archetype]]></title>
            <link>https://scaredbisexual.medium.com/pretty-baby-brooke-shields-adds-dimensions-to-the-exploited-starlet-archetype-95e20d5c04f?source=rss-f25bcac2209f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/95e20d5c04f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[film-reviews]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[documentary]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[feminism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[child-sexual-abuse]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Sarah Wagoner]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 03 Apr 2023 22:17:38 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-04-03T22:17:38.710Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/474/1*D_1NwWQLt7A5MfcrrAS_7A.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>Pretty Baby: Brooke Shields </em>utilizes the cultural image of Brooke Shields to question the usage of the Lolita figure in popular culture. By that description, one could infer that the film would only cover the widely known exploitation of her underage body. However, the film brings us closer to her in order to deconstruct the cultural image of Brooke Shields. While the documentary focuses on the span of her life, its exploration of <em>Pretty Baby </em>(1978)<em> </em>provides much-needed nuance for the genre of problematic artistic retrospective. The film’s empathetic approach is a necessary step for retrospective documentaries, as it provides a balance in understanding artistic value in uncomfortable art while analyzing the harms placed upon young actors.</p><p><em>Pretty Baby </em>(1978) is a prime example of the complication of exploitation films. While the film’s usage of Brooke Shields’ underage body can described in no other way than “deplorable”, the film itself does not carry an easy anti- or pro- child sex work message, although the script does. As Karina Longworth points out in the Hulu documentary, Polly Platt’s script was clearly meant to explore the depths of child sexual abuse while satirizing the sexual exploitation of the 70s film industry. However, Louis Malle, the director, took an observational approach which broaches the script’s intentions, leaving the film to be a “rorschach test” (Wilson 19:24–19:41). While I find Karina Longworth can often find herself oversimplifying exploitative, and even erotic, films as they relate to feminist issues, her critique of <em>Pretty Baby (</em>1978) not only acts as a nuanced view of the male gaze in relation to female-written script, but provides necessary context for the film’s impact upon Shields’ life. The film contains routes for critique that could’ve acted as roads for survival, but in execution, it was ground zero for the abuse she would encounter. She was a known model before the film, but the usage of her prepubescent nude body led to the outward sexualization of her image. Soon after the film’s release she would be treated in the same essence of her child sex worker character; as nothing more than a taboo sexual commodity.</p><p>Other documentaries on the mistreated starlet (such as The New York Times’ Britney Spears documentary) paint a broad brush regarding the discourse surrounding the starlet. They may state that once in the eyes of the public, every group would bombard them with a fetishistic gaze. While this framing provides some accuracy, it ignores the morally concerned groups that always arise alongside the fetishistic hoards. <em>Pretty Baby: Brooke Shields </em>does not fall down this well. In contrast, director Lana Wilson includes the backlash of <em>Pretty Baby </em>(1978) to highlight the hypocrisy in discourses. Rather than blaming Louis Malle for utilizing child nudity and child sexuality, critics attacked Teri Shields, Brooke’s mother. Another cup of nuance is poured into the documentary as the backlash increases. Yes, the talking heads argue, Teri was irresponsible for allowing her daughter to be in a sexually exploitative film. Later on, Brooke even questions why her mother took no issue with sexual exploitation but was upset with less consequential breaches of her trust. However, the mother-daughter dynamic is one so often glorified and misconstrued in American culture that all actions are under a microscope, leading to a stronger response than if any other dynamic were at play. At times, this section appears to be an excuse for Teri’s behavior as they don’t emphasize the responsibility Teri had, but ultimately the film’s thorough examination of the mother-daughter manager-client leads to a stronger rhetorical analysis of the discourse surrounding <em>Pretty Baby </em>(1978).</p><p>The film does not only center <em>Pretty Baby</em>, examining the multiple emotional lows and professional highs of her career and personal life. We are taken through her Calvin Klein ads, <em>Blue Lagoon,</em> her journey with sexuality, and her postpartum depression. But with each section, there is a flowing narrative, as empathy towards Brooke is the central focus. The aforementioned narrative largely comes together in the linear exploration of the topics, but we still see an overwhelming care for Brooke. No segment goes by without her perspective centering the issue. Nor do any of the speakers act antagonistic towards her perspective. Every speaker is in conversation, bringing the documentary to a healthy discourse that deconstructs the toxic discourses of the past.</p><p>The film ends with a balanced view of celebrity lives today, still concerned over the rushed sexualization of young girls (though I would argue they should take a gender-inclusive approach to this topic in order to acknowledge the sexual abuse of transgender children and boys), but optimistic towards the third wave’s approach to the issue. On one hand, I can’t help but be pessimistic about social media’s impact on child sexual exploitation, especially as a survivor of online CSA. On another, I appreciate that they showed the battle from feminist generations are never over, but evolve. We simply need to reconfigure strategies. If there’s any way to reconfigure, it is to utilize nuance and survivor perspectives rather than yelling over them. Wilson’s centering of Brooke’s narrative and nuanced approach to exploitation films is a step in the right direction.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=95e20d5c04f" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>