<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Barbara van Schewick on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Barbara van Schewick on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@schewick?source=rss-548c5492e42f------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sun, 22 Nov 2026 00:19:43 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@schewick/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Setting the Record Straight: Carriers Can Help Veterans and Comply with California’s Net Neutrality]]></title>
            <link>https://schewick.medium.com/setting-the-record-straight-carriers-can-help-veterans-and-comply-with-californias-net-neutrality-b25fdd2fa1ff?source=rss-548c5492e42f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b25fdd2fa1ff</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[net-neutrality]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Barbara van Schewick]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 25 Mar 2021 06:21:04 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-03-25T06:52:42.768Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Setting the Record Straight: Carriers Can Help Veterans and Comply with California’s Net Neutrality Law</h3><p>On Wednesday, Politico reported on a leaked email from the Department of Veterans Affairs, expressing concern that California’s net neutrality law could force some wireless providers to end a program that exempted the V.A.’s telehealth app from their customers’ data caps.</p><p>Veterans across the country and in California shouldn’t have to worry they’ll go over their data caps by talking to their doctor or mental health provider online. In fact, no American or Californian should.</p><p>But California’s net neutrality law is not the problem here.</p><p>While a press leak does drive fear-mongering coverage, there are easy solutions that broadband providers could embrace that are far more effective at helping veterans and all Californians, while also complying with California’s net neutrality protections.</p><p>As the pandemic has shown, it’s vital that all Americans are able to use their internet connection to work, go to school and see a doctor.</p><p>To help, carriers could exempt all conversational video apps like Skype, Zoom and the V.A.’s telehealth app from people’s data caps. That way veterans, teachers, police officers, suicidal teens, retirees, people with low incomes and members of traditionally marginalized communities can all work, learn and get critical healthcare virtually. That kind of category-based zero-rating is allowed under California’s net neutrality law.</p><p>This would also be better for veterans: Veterans could use the doctor or mental health provider of their choice, using whatever app they like or whatever app their health care provider uses.</p><p>That’s important. V.A. mental health providers currently use whatever online tool a veteran is comfortable with — Skype, Zoom, Google Meet, WebEx, etc., but under the carriers’ current system, only the V.A.’s telehealth app is exempt from veterans’ data caps, hurting those who use other apps or get their medical care outside of the V.A..</p><p>Alternatively, carriers could offer more affordable unlimited plans just for veterans. That’s technically simpler than zero-rating and removes the need for it entirely. (At $55/month for one line, T-Mobile’s <a href="https://www.t-mobile.com/cell-phone-plans/military-discount-plans">current discount plan for veterans</a> is far more expensive than the $40/month <a href="https://www.t-mobile.com/cell-phone-plans/unlimited-55-senior-discount-plans">plan for people over the age of 55</a>). Under the current system, veterans on capped plans can use the V.A. telehealth app without worrying about their cap, but have to ration their data for everything else. With truly affordable unlimited plans, veterans can apply for jobs, take classes, join online support groups, and connect with family, friends and those they served with <em>and</em> see their doctor — all without fear they are going over their cap.</p><p>Carriers can also lower the cost of unlimited plans for everyone so people can use the internet in the way that’s best for them. That’s the real solution, not allowing ISPs to pick and choose what apps and what segment of the population gets relief from low data caps.</p><p>Congress understands that, which is why it recently passed the Emergency Broadband Benefit that provides $50 a month to households with low incomes so they can do <em>all </em>the things they need to do online.</p><p>Finally, the carriers told the V.A. they will be forced to shut down this program for all veterans nationwide. That’s not true; the law only applies to California customers.</p><p>While not a solution to the real problem, carriers could turn off the program for California customers and just bump up California veterans’ data caps, while keeping the program the same in all the other states.</p><p>But carriers do not seem to be interested in finding ways to comply with California’s net neutrality law, which is not surprising given they spent millions in 2018 to stop it.</p><p>The ISPs then started this program with the V.A. in 2019 after the law took effect.</p><p>The carriers had two years to work with the California AG’s Office to come up with a solution, but they did not. Instead they waited those two years, scared the V.A. with phantoms of lost benefits, and then the V.A.’s communication got leaked to the press.</p><p>That looks more like an industry using veterans as political pawns than one committed to ensuring Americans can get the life-saving online health services they need.</p><p>Americans and veterans deserve better.</p><p><em>Professor Barbara van Schewick is a professor of law at Stanford University and the director of Stanford Law School’s Center for Internet and Society.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b25fdd2fa1ff" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The FCC is about to repeal net neutrality. Here’s why Congress should stop them.]]></title>
            <link>https://schewick.medium.com/the-fcc-is-about-to-repeal-net-neutrality-heres-why-congress-should-stop-them-8072a27eff95?source=rss-548c5492e42f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8072a27eff95</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[net-neutrality]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[tech]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Barbara van Schewick]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 27 Nov 2017 00:28:08 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-11-27T05:34:24.843Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*4RhTSi8QcjrOUbTU0Rf87A.jpeg" /></figure><p>On Wednesday November 22, FCC Chairman Ajit Pai published his <a href="https://apps.fcc.gov/edocs_public/attachmatch/DOC-347927A1.pdf">draft order</a> outlining his plan to undo the net neutrality protections that have been in place in the U.S. since the beginning of the Internet. His proposal would leave both the FCC and the states powerless to protect consumers and businesses against net neutrality violations by Internet Service Providers (ISPs) like Comcast, AT&amp;T, and Verizon that connect us to the Internet.</p><p>His plan discards <a href="http://fortune.com/2017/11/22/net-neutrality-fcc-ajit-pai-verizon-comcast-att/">decades of careful work</a> by FCC chairs of both political parties, who recognized and acted against the danger ISPs posed to the free markets that rose out of and depend on the Internet. If his plan takes effect, ISPs would be free to disrupt how the Internet has worked for 30 years.</p><p>His plan repeals the existing net neutrality protections without a replacement. Contrary to Chairman Pai’s assertions, the Federal Trade Commission won’t be capable of protecting the open Internet. ISPs say they support net neutrality and bipartisan legislation to settle the issue. But ISPs only support draft bills that are net neutrality in name only, and whatever the merits of a legislative solution, Congress isn’t ready to pass a net neutrality law.</p><p>The proposal is <a href="https://www.fcc.gov/news-events/events/2017/12/december-2017-open-commission-meeting">scheduled for a vote at the FCC</a> on December 14.</p><p>In the rush to eliminate net neutrality protections, Chairman Pai failed to hold a single public hearing, and has ignored the chorus of entrepreneurs, investors, businesses and citizens asking him to stop.</p><p>Citizens across the political spectrum are now looking to their elected representatives to speak out on their behalf and call on Chairman Pai to cancel the vote.</p><p><strong>Chairman Pai proposes to dismantle the existing net neutrality protections.</strong></p><p>Chairman Pai’s plan has three components.</p><p><em>1. He proposes to eliminate all of the current net neutrality rules with the exception of a modified transparency rule.</em></p><p>That means ISPs would be free to block, speed up or slow down websites, applications, and services; charge online companies for access to an ISP’s customers and block those that don’t pay; and to enter into deals with online companies to put them in a fast lane to the ISP’s customers. All of these are prohibited by the current rules.</p><p>The only remaining constraint under Chairman Pai’s plan: ISPs have to tell their customers that they are engaging in these practices.</p><p>ISPs will also be free to favor some applications over others by exempting them from their customers’ data caps, a practice called “zero-rating” that the 2015 net neutrality protections left for the FCC to evaluate case-by-case.</p><p>Finally, the FCC would lose the authority to oversee the points where ISPs like AT&amp;T and Verizon connect to the Internet at large, which ISPs have used to slow down and extract fees from online services in the past.</p><p><em>2. He proposes to move ISPs to a different part of the Communications Act called Title I.</em></p><p>ISPs are currently classified as common carriers under Title II of the Communications Act. That provides the legal foundation for the current net neutrality protections.</p><p>Reclassifying broadband Internet service under Title I of the Communications Act would make it impossible for the FCC to adopt or enforce any kind of meaningful net neutrality protections going forward. That’s because the Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit <a href="https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20140912/06281128502/courts-own-words-life-without-title-ii-has-online-discrimination-paid-prioritization-exclusive-deals-maybe-blocking.shtml">ruled</a> in the 2014 Verizon case that net neutrality protections can only be imposed on entities that have been classified as common carriers under Title II of the Communications Act.</p><p><em>3. He proposes to ban states from adopting any net neutrality rules of their own.</em></p><p>That would make it impossible for states to react to the lack of protections at the federal level with net neutrality or broadband privacy protections of their own.</p><p><strong>Chairman Pai’s plan is a radical break from FCC history and a fundamental departure from how the Internet has operated for the past 30 years.</strong></p><p>This proposal is a radical break from the FCC’s history of protecting and enforcing net neutrality, including by Republican chairs Powell and Martin.</p><p>Net neutrality protections did not suddenly appear in 2015. Although the FCC formally adopted network neutrality rules for the first time in 2010, we have always had a de facto network neutrality regime in the U.S. — first, through the architecture of the Internet, and later, through a mix of formal and informal FCC regulation and action. This de facto regime prevented or at least deterred blocking and discrimination.</p><p>Since its inception, Internet access in the U.S. has been guided by one basic principle: ISPs that provide the on-ramps to the Internet should not control what happens on the Internet.</p><p>Originally, this principle was built into the architecture of the Internet. In the mid-1990s, however, technology emerged that allowed ISPs to interfere with the applications, content, and services on their networks.</p><p>In the face of this threat, the FCC has strongly supported Open Internet principles since 2004, has expressed its expectation that Internet service providers would live by these principles, and taken enforcement actions that stopped discriminatory conduct. Until 2005, DSL providers were directly banned from blocking and unreasonable discrimination under Title II of the Communications Act. In addition, the FCC imposed binding net neutrality merger conditions, attached net neutrality requirements to stimulus grants for broadband services and to certain parts of the wireless spectrum, and, in 2010 and 2015, promulgated enforceable net neutrality rules.</p><p>(I explain this history and prior Republican Chairmen’s actions in more depth in a<a href="http://fortune.com/2017/11/22/net-neutrality-fcc-ajit-pai-verizon-comcast-att/"> piece</a> that was published in Fortune on November 22.)</p><p>The FCC’s decades-long commitment to and enforcement of this basic principle — that ISPs don’t get to pick winners and losers on the Internet — means Internet users in the U.S. haven’t had to worry about whether ISPs might block or discriminate against certain kinds of content or applications. Entrepreneurs who have an idea for a new application have not needed permission from ISPs in order to innovate and have been able to realize their ideas at a low cost.</p><p>This is a well-oiled free market at work.</p><p>By contrast, from 2009 to 2015, European law allowed blocking and discrimination, as long as it was disclosed. ISPs engaged in widespread blocking and discrimination, such as prohibiting Skype to protect their traditional voice revenue.</p><p>That’s the regime Chairman Pai envisions for the United States.</p><p>His plan would also allow ISPs to charge websites for access to the ISPs’ customers, block those that don’t pay, and build pay-to play fast lanes. This would be a radical departure from how the Internet has operated over the past 30 years and would allow ISPs to increase costs for businesses across the entire economy.</p><p>In the U.S., companies that use the Internet to reach their customers have always simply paid for their own access to the Internet. They have never had to pay any additional fees to their customers’ ISPs.</p><p>ISPs have wanted to change that since 2006, and Chairman Pai’s plan would finally allow them to do so.</p><p>Verizon told a federal court in 2013 that it should have the right to charge any website any fee Verizon liked — and if, for instance, the Wall Street Journal didn’t pay up, Verizon should be allowed to block its site.</p><p>ISPs also want to be able to offer fast lanes that would give better service to companies that pay ISPs when their data travels to the ISPs’ customers over the ISPs’ networks. Websites that don’t pay would receive a slower speed.</p><p>But the FCC, lawmakers and the public have long pushed back against access fees and fast lanes, and in 2010, the FCC formally prohibited them for cable and DSL providers and expanded those prohibitions to mobile in 2015.</p><p>Allowing these fast lanes and fees for access to ISP customers would hurt every single sector of the economy.</p><p>Today, almost every company relies on the Internet one way or the other. Large corporations that pay these fees will have higher costs, so their customers will be forced to pay higher prices for products and services. Small businesses and startups that can’t afford a fast lane will find it harder to compete; those that can’t afford the access fees won’t be able to compete at all.</p><p>Thus, Chairman Pai’s plan would allow ISPs to distort the well-greased free markets that rely on the Internet and tax businesses in every single sector of the economy.</p><p><strong>Now all eyes turn to Congress.</strong></p><p>As I explain below, allowing Chairman Pai to move forward with his plan repeals all existing net neutrality protections without a replacement, leaving consumers and businesses without protections against ISP interference for the first time in U.S. history.</p><p>Chairman Pai’s plans are deeply unpopular with people across the political spectrum. According to a<a href="https://www.scribd.com/document/353285485/Freedman-Consulting-Net-Neutrality-Poll"> poll</a> released in July 2017, 77% of Americans support keeping the FCC’s existing net neutrality protections in place. This issue is not about party: 73 percent of Republicans, 80 percent of Democrats, and 76 percent of independents want to keep the current protections.</p><p>Unfortunately, the FCC is not accountable to the public, and<a href="https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2017/07/ajit-pai-not-concerned-about-number-of-pro-net-neutrality-comments/"> Chairman Pai</a> and<a href="https://www.engadget.com/2017/04/27/the-fcc-doesn-t-care-what-you-think-about-net-neutrality/"> his Republican colleagues</a> have made clear that they do not give much weight to public opinion or to the number of comments.</p><p>However, members of Congress care about an open Internet and what their constituents think, and since they oversee the FCC, they have the power to stop him. Already, three members of Maine’s four-member congressional delegation, including Sens. Susan Collins (R) and Angus King (I), have spoken out in opposition to Chairman Pai’s proposal.</p><p>Congressional pressure has stopped the FCC before. In the past, the FCC has responded to pressure from Congress by choosing not to vote on previously circulated draft orders. Just last year, for example, the FCC <a href="https://motherboard.vice.com/en_us/article/vv7pmd/fcc-postpones-vote-on-set-top-box-proposal">tabled a proposed change</a> to cable set top box rules after the draft order had been circulated.</p><p>Voters understand Congress can stop Chairman Pai from eliminating net neutrality. In the first 24 hours after Chairman Pai announced the plan, Americans made more than 200,000 calls to Congress through BattleForTheNet.com alone, urging their representatives to do just that.</p><p><strong>Is there really no other option?</strong></p><p>Chairman Pai defends the immediate removal of the existing net neutrality protections, arguing that the FTC can effectively police ISPs. ISPs have said that they support net neutrality and would support Congress passing bipartisan legislation that settles the issue.</p><p>But the FTC doesn’t have the power and tools to adequately protect consumers and businesses against net neutrality violations, and ISPs don’t really want Congress to adopt meaningful net neutrality rules. And whatever the merits of a legislative solution, Congress is not ready to pass a net neutrality bill.</p><p><strong>The Federal Trade Commission will not be capable of protecting net neutrality.</strong></p><p>Chairman Pai claims that the FTC can protect the open Internet once the FCC has eliminated the existing protections and classified ISPs as an information service under Title I of the Communications Act.</p><p>But even when the FCC and FTC shared oversight of ISPs before 2015, the FTC never enforced any net neutrality protections. That’s always been done by the FCC. For example, the FCC <a href="https://www.cnet.com/news/telco-agrees-to-stop-blocking-voip-calls/">stopped</a> DSL provider Madison River from blocking the Internet telephony service Vonage in 2005; <a href="https://apps.fcc.gov/edocs_public/attachmatch/FCC-08-183A1.pdf">prohibited</a> Comcast from blocking peer-to-peer file-sharing applications in 2008; and <a href="https://www.cnet.com/news/what-verizons-fcc-tethering-settlement-means-to-you-faq/">forced</a> Verizon Wireless to stop interfering with customers’ ability to use their mobile phones as wireless hotspots.</p><p>By contrast, the FTC focused on ISPs deviating from their published privacy policies and deceptively advertising “unlimited” Internet plans that were not actually unlimited.</p><p>That is not surprising.</p><p>The FTC <a href="https://cyberlaw.stanford.edu/downloads/ProfessorLetterToFTC-20150129.pdf">lacks the power and tools</a> to police net neutrality violations. The FTC can intervene if a company violates its stated policies. But if a company discloses that it has paid fast lanes, charges online companies for access to users, and blocks those that don’t pay, there is nothing the FTC can do.</p><p>Beyond that, the FTC’s role is limited to protecting consumers against practices that “harm competition,” a term of art in antitrust law, after the fact. As a result, the FTC cannot adopt rules proactively.</p><p>Nor can it adequately protect against threats to innovation and free speech. For instance, current net neutrality protections ban broadband providers from creating fast lanes to their customers for websites that pay the ISPs a fee. These fast lanes tilt the market in favor of deep-pocketed companies and speakers, making it harder for startups, small businesses, and low-cost speakers to compete and be heard. While clearly harmful to innovation and free speech, that’s not an antitrust violation.</p><p>The FTC does not oversee ISPs today because it does not have authority over common carriers, and ISPs are currently classified as common carriers. But it’s not clear whether the FTC gains authority to oversee ISPs if the FCC moves ISPs into Title I. According to a recent Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals decision, the FTC does not have authority over any company that offers one common carrier service such as landline or cellular telephony. If that interpretation prevails, the FTC would be powerless to police the Internet services offered by companies like AT&amp;T and Verizon since they are also telephone companies.</p><p><strong>ISPs do not want to secure net neutrality by law.</strong></p><p>ISPs are trying to create the impression that Chairman Pai’s plans are not a big deal. In advertising and public statements, they say they support an open Internet and support Congressional action to end the debate.</p><p>But behind closed doors, the ISPs are pushing for bills that would eliminate key components of an effective net neutrality regime. Their vision of net neutrality is limited to some principles against blocking and slowing down sites. They want the law to allow them to charge websites for access to the ISPs’ customers and block sites that don’t pay. They want to be able to charge websites fees to reach people faster. And they oppose FCC oversight over interconnection practices and zero-rating.</p><p>This is not net neutrality.</p><p>Thus, ISPs don’t want to secure net neutrality in law, they want to get rid of net neutrality by law.</p><p>This is not surprising. As this <a href="http://fortune.com/2017/11/22/net-neutrality-fcc-ajit-pai-verizon-comcast-att/">article</a> explains, ISPs have been fighting attempts to enact or enforce net neutrality protections in Congress, at the FCC, and in the courts for years. When blocking was found unacceptable, ISPs declared they intended to charge websites for access to ISP customers. When that led to a public outcry and draft bills in Congress, they came up with the idea of charging websites for a fast lane to ISP customers.</p><p>And when the FCC’s 2010 rules foreclosed charging websites for data traveling inside an ISP’s network, they found a way to charge websites at the point of interconnection where data entered the ISPs’ networks. To do that the six largest ISPs refused to widen the pipes into their networks in 2013–14, slowing millions of Americans’ access to huge swaths of the Internet.</p><p><strong>Congress is not ready to protect net neutrality by law.</strong></p><p>Some argue this issue is too important to be decided by an independent agency and that Congress should settle the issue with legislation. But whatever the merits of a legislative solution, Congress is not ready to adopt a net neutrality bill.</p><p>Congressional Republicans are divided on net neutrality. Some Republicans do not see a need for net neutrality rules; others support a legislative solution. However, powerful Republicans in the latter camp are <a href="https://www.politico.com/tipsheets/morning-tech/2017/03/trump-light-on-tech-in-congressional-address-218985">split</a> on key net neutrality protections like the ban on online fast lanes. For example, Sen. John Thune, who chairs the Commerce Committee and would spearhead legislation in the Senate, wants to ban fast lanes. Rep. Marsha Blackburn, who heads the relevant subcommittee in the House Energy and Commerce Committee, wants to allow them.</p><p>Net neutrality is a complicated topic, and many members are just starting to think about how to best protect the open Internet. As Chairman Pai rushes to abolish the current net neutrality protections, Congress is focused on passing tax reform, negotiating a spending bill and a potential increase in the debt limit, finding a solution for the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) program, and avoiding a government shutdown.</p><p>All of this makes it all but impossible for Congress to have the time to replace the FCC’s existing rules with equally strong, carefully written net neutrality protections in the near future.</p><p><strong>Now members of Congress have to make a choice</strong>.</p><p>The question right now is not whether Congress should ultimately resolve the issue through net neutrality legislation. The question is whether the FCC should rush to unilaterally dismantle the existing protections and revoke the FCC’s ability to react to net neutrality violations in the future, before Congress has had a chance to deliberate.</p><p>Despite the wide range of voices urging him to slow down, Chairman Pai is determined to move forward quickly with his plan to eliminate all existing net neutrality protections, undoing decades of effort by FCC chairmen and commissioners from both parties.</p><p>The process has been inadequate, given the gravity of the issue and the number of people and industries affected. The Commission had to process more than 22 million comments in just three months. Contrary to net neutrality proceedings in 2008, 2010 and 2014, the FCC held no hearings with experts or the public.</p><p>Over the last 30 years, Americans have experienced unparalleled freedom and opportunity online. The low barriers to entry have let millions of entrepreneurs and small business owners live the Internet version of the American dream. Free markets have flourished across the Internet, leaving no industry untouched.</p><p>Chairman Pai’s plan would change that.</p><p>For the first time in history, ISPs will be allowed to interfere with these free markets, limiting choice, distorting competition and raising the price of doing business for everyone, including entrepreneurs and small businesses.</p><p>And for the first time in history, the FCC will be powerless to stop them.</p><p>Only Congress can prevent this from happening.</p><p><a href="http://cyberlaw.stanford.edu/about/people/barbara-van-schewick"><em>Barbara van Schewick</em></a><em> is an expert on net neutrality, a professor at Stanford Law School, and the director of the Stanford Law School Center for Internet and Society. She is the author of</em><a href="http://netarchitecture.org/"><em> Internet Architecture and Innovation</em></a><em> (MIT Press 2010). Parts of this text draw on her earlier writing on net neutrality. </em><a href="https://twitter.com/vanschewick"><em>Follow her</em></a><em> on Twitter. CC-licensed image by </em><a href="https://www.flickr.com/photos/janpersiel/27706588173"><em>Jan Persiel</em></a><em>.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8072a27eff95" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Europe Is About to Adopt Bad Net Neutrality Rules. Here’s How to Fix Them]]></title>
            <link>https://schewick.medium.com/europe-is-about-to-adopt-bad-net-neutrality-rules-here-s-how-to-fix-them-bbfa4d5df0c8?source=rss-548c5492e42f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/bbfa4d5df0c8</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[net-neutrality]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[europe]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[tech]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Barbara van Schewick]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 22 Oct 2015 04:13:48 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2015-10-23T07:50:52.603Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>On Tuesday, October 27, the European Parliament will vote on rules intended to protect network neutrality in the European Union (EU). However, the proposal about to be adopted fails to deliver network neutrality to the EU and is much weaker than current net neutrality rules in the United States. Fortunately, it’s not too late to change course. Members of Parliament can still secure meaningful network neutrality for Europe — if they adopt key amendments on Tuesday.</p><p><strong>Unless it adopts amendments, the European Parliament’s net neutrality vote next Tuesday threatens the open Internet in Europe.</strong></p><p>The European Parliament understands that the future of economic growth, innovation, and free speech in Europe depends on net neutrality — the principle that has kept the Internet an open and free space since its inception. However, a compromise proposal up for vote next Tuesday contains major problems that threaten the open Internet in Europe. Contrary to some claims, the proposal is weaker than network neutrality rules in the US. European citizens deserve the same free and open Internet that Americans can enjoy.<br>The good news is that members of the European Parliament will introduce amendments that would fix these problems. For the amendments to be adopted, the majority of the members (376 of the 751 members) need to vote for the amendments.</p><p><strong>The current proposal has major problems.</strong></p><p>The proposal bans Internet service providers (ISPs) from blocking or slowing down websites, or charging sites extra fees to reach people faster, i.e. creating “fast lanes” online. This is good — companies that provide gateways to the Internet shouldn’t interfere with our ability to access what we want online.<br>But the current proposal contains four significant problems that still allow ISPs to engage in bad behavior that would harm Internet users, businesses, and speakers in Europe.</p><p>• Problem #1: The proposal allows ISPs to create fast lanes for companies that pay through the specialized services exception.</p><p>• Problem #2: The proposal generally allows zero-rating and gives regulators very limited ability to police it, leaving users and companies without protection against all but the most egregious cases of favoritism.</p><p>• Problem #3: The proposal allows class-based discrimination, i.e. ISPs can define classes and speed up or slow down traffic in those classes even if there is no congestion.</p><p>• Problem #4: The proposal allows ISPs to prevent “impending” congestion. That makes it easier for them to slow down traffic anytime, not just during times of actual congestion.</p><p><strong>We should ask the Parliament to adopt amendments to ensure an open Internet in Europe.</strong></p><p>To save the open Internet in Europe, members of the European Parliament need to adopt the amendments. This won’t happen automatically. Here’s what you can do to help:</p><p><strong><em>Take action</em></strong>: Ask your representatives in the Parliament to adopt the necessary amendments. You can find all the necessary information and tools at <a href="http://savetheinternet.eu/">SavetheInternet.eu</a>.</p><p><strong><em>Spread the word</em></strong>: Share this post and others on Facebook, Twitter, or anywhere else. Talk with your friends, colleagues, and family and ask them to take action. If you are a blogger or journalist, write about what is going on.</p><h4><strong>HOW THE AMENDMENTS WILL FIX THE PROPOSAL</strong></h4><p>Let’s look more closely at the major problems with the compromise proposal and how to fix them.</p><h4><strong>PROBLEM #1:</strong></h4><p><strong>The proposal allows ISPs to create fast lanes for companies that pay through the specialized services exception.</strong></p><p><strong><em>“Fast Lanes” on the Internet harm innovation, free expression, and democratic discourse in Europe.</em></strong></p><p>ISPs want the power to charge websites extra fees to reach people faster. If some websites can pay ISPs to be in the “fast lane,” anyone who can’t afford the extra fees will be left behind in the slow lane. That means that it will be harder for Europeans to access websites that can’t afford to pay extra fees. European start-ups, small businesses, non-profits, educators, artists, musicians, writers, activists, faith groups, and NGOs would be at a disadvantage. Europe’s Internet would no longer be an open space where everyone has an equal chance of reaching people.</p><p><strong><em>The proposal allows ISPs to create harmful fast lanes online.</em></strong></p><p>The current proposal generally bans ISPs from creating fast lanes. But it contains an exception for “specialized services.” That is important, because it allows applications to emerge that would not be able to function on the open Internet because they need special treatment that the open Internet cannot provide.</p><p>However, the exception for specialized services is too broad: In many cases, it still allows ISPs to offer fast lanes by calling them a specialized service.</p><p><strong><em>Fast lanes would crush start-up innovation in Europe and make it harder for European start-ups to challenge dominant American companies.</em></strong></p><p>Slow lanes spell disaster for innovation. On the Internet, the costs of innovation are incredibly low. Entrepreneurs don’t need permission to innovate or a lot of upfront funding. This benefits European start-ups that often don’t have access to outside funding.</p><p>Allowing ISPs to offer fast lanes would change that. If established companies can pay so that their content loads faster or does not count against users’ monthly bandwidth caps, then those who can’t pay don’t have a chance to compete. Many of today’s most popular applications — Google, Facebook, Yahoo, eBay — were developed by innovators with little or no outside funding. In a world where such innovations are stuck in the slow lane, they would never have seen the light of day. Today, these companies can pay for a fast lane, but the next generation of innovators that will challenge them should be assured the same level playing field.</p><p><strong><em>Fast lanes would harm all sectors of the economy.</em></strong></p><p>Today, most companies rely on the Internet to reach their customers. As a result, fast lanes would harm all sectors of the economy. Large corporations that pay to be in the fast lane will have higher costs, so we the customers will be forced to pay higher prices for their products and services. Small businesses that are unable to pay will be shut out of the market. Many small businesses in Europe are just starting to take advantages of the opportunities that the Internet has to offer. They should have the same opportunity to benefit from an Open Internet as their counterparts in the United States.</p><p><strong>SOLUTION: The Parliament should adopt amendments that refine the definition of specialized services to close the specialized services loophole and keep the Internet an open platform and level playing field.</strong></p><h4><strong>PROBLEM #2:</strong></h4><p><strong>The proposal generally allows zero-rating and gives regulators very limited ability to police it, leaving users and companies without protection against all but the most egregious cases.</strong></p><p><strong><em>Zero-rating is harmful discrimination.</em></strong></p><p>Zero-rating is the practice of not counting certain applications against users’ monthly bandwidth caps. Like fast lanes or other technical discrimination, zero-rating allows ISPs to discriminate against content that users want to see. Zero-rated applications are more attractive to users than applications that are not. That means zero-rating some content over others has the same discriminatory effect as speeding up certain applications over others. Like fast lanes, zero-rating threatens the future of competition, innovation, and free speech in Europe and around the world.</p><p><strong><em>The proposal does not clearly ban zero-rating.</em></strong></p><p>The European Commission and the European Parliament disagree whether the proposal applies to zero-rating. The Commission has stated that zero-rating is subject to the rules and that the rules allow it. If zero-rating is subject to the rules, regulators’ ability to regulate zero-rating is limited: regulators could only reach the most egregious cases, while everything else would be permitted. Member states would not be able to adopt additional rules to regulate zero-rating — their hands would be tied.</p><p>However, members of the Parliament said that they agreed with the Council during the compromise negotiations that zero-rating would be outside the scope of the rules.</p><p><strong><em>Zero-rating results in discrimination.</em></strong></p><p>Research shows that zero-rated applications are far more attractive to users than those that are not. In a study commissioned by the CTIA, 74% of users said that they would be more likely to watch videos offered by a new provider if the content did not count against their monthly bandwidth caps. When the online magazine Slate experimented with zero-rating, it told some users that the podcast did not count against their cap. People who were offered the zero-rated podcast were 61% more likely to click on the link. Thus, zero-rating has the same impact as technical discrimination: it gives ISPs power to make certain applications more attractive than others and pick winners and losers on the Internet.</p><p><strong><em>Zero-rating distorts competition.</em></strong></p><p>In the European Union, many ISPs zero-rate their own video applications. Users on these plans can watch unlimited zero-rated videos, but their bandwidth caps prevent them from watching more than 2–5 hours of video content unaffiliated with the ISPs. Similarly, many ISPs in Europe zero-rate their own cloud-storage applications. Their users can upload 10 gigabytes of traffic to the ISP’s cloud storage for free. But it costs between $50 and $70 to upload the same amount of data to other cloud storage sites like Dropbox or Google Drive. These plans make it effectively impossible for unaffiliated providers to compete with the ISP’s zero-rated application.</p><p><strong><em>Zero-rating harms users.</em></strong></p><p>When European ISPs start zero-rating certain applications or content, they often reduce overall bandwidth caps or increase the price of unrestricted bandwidth, as the European research firm Rewheel has shown. This is not surprising: the lower the bandwidth caps, the more attractive zero-rated applications become, so lower bandwidth caps motivate rich providers to pay for zero-rating. Thus, zero-rating harms users (and the providers of applications that are not zero-rated) by reducing the amount or increasing the costs of bandwidth that users can use however they like. By contrast, when a Dutch regulator banned zero-rating, the provider KPN doubled its monthly bandwidth cap for mobile Internet access from 5 to 10 GB at no additional cost.</p><p><strong><em>Zero-rating harms innovation and free speech.</em></strong></p><p>Start-ups, small businesses, and low-cost speakers in Europe and elsewhere don’t have money to pay for fast lanes; they don’t have money to pay for zero-rating, either. But if some companies can pay to be zero-rated, those who can’t pay will find it hard to compete. Thus, allowing ISPs to zero-rate websites or services against a fee creates the same problems for innovation and free speech as allowing ISPs to charge for fast lanes.</p><p><strong>SOLUTION: Europeans deserve clarity on this important issue. The parliament should adopt amendments that make it clear that member states are free to adopt additional rules to regulate zero-rating. This would bring the proposal in line with the negotiators’ stated intent and empower individual member states to address this harmful practice in the future.</strong></p><h4><strong>PROBLEM #3:</strong></h4><p><strong>The proposal allows ISPs to define classes and speed up or slow down traffic in those classes, even if there is no congestion. This allows ISPs to distort competition, stifles innovation, harms users, and hurts providers who encrypt traffic by putting all encrypted traffic in the slow lane.</strong></p><p><strong><em>The proposal allows ISPs to engage in class-based discrimination.</em></strong></p><p>The proposal allows class-based discrimination: ISPs can make distinctions between different kinds of traffic and treat them differently to optimize overall transmission quality at any time, not just during times of congestion. The discrimination must be based on the technical requirements of the applications in question. Thus, ISPs could treat different kinds of applications differently if they have different technical requirements. For example, Internet telephony is sensitive to delay, but e-mail is not, so an ISP could give low delay to Internet telephony, but not to e-mail.</p><p>Whenever an ISP has the power to speed up certain applications or slow down others, it might use this power to give certain applications an advantage over others. The proposal tries to mitigate this danger by forcing ISPs to consider an application’s technical requirements when making distinctions among traffic.</p><p>However, this kind of class-based discriminatory network management still allows ISPs to give some applications an advantage over others, whether intentionally or inadvertently. It distorts competition, slows all encrypted traffic, harms individual users, stifles innovation, and creates high costs of regulation.</p><p><strong><em>Allowing ISPs to treat classes differently gives them power to deliberately distort competition.</em></strong></p><p>When ISPs are free to define classes, they have a lot of discretion to discriminate against certain applications. ISPs could use this power to deliberately distort competition. For example, an ISP could offer low delay to online gaming to make it more attractive, but it could decide not to offer low delay to online telephony because that would allow Internet telephony to better compete with the ISP’s own telephony offerings. Although both services are sensitive to delay, ISPs could argue that there are other, technical differences that justify distinguishing between them.</p><p><strong><em>Class-based traffic management can inadvertently harm applications.</em></strong></p><p>Traffic management that distinguishes among different kinds of applications often results in inadvertent discrimination that hurts users, distorts competition, and makes it harder for providers of affected applications to innovate. Traffic management technologies that distinguish among classes of applications often end up harming certain applications, even if that effect is not intended, because the ISPs or their technology misclassify certain applications.</p><p>For example, many ISPs in the UK limit the bandwidth available to peer-to-peer file sharing applications during times of congestion, arguing that these applications are not sensitive to delay. This creates huge problems for online gaming. ISPs use deep packet inspection technology to identify these applications, but the technology doesn’t work very well: it has a hard time distinguishing between online gaming and peer-to-peer file sharing, so online games stop working or don’t work as well as they could. In the end, UK ISPs and gaming providers established standing committees where ISPs, technology vendors, and gaming providers worked together to make sure the games would work on ISPs’ networks in spite of the discriminatory network management.</p><p>In the UK, this class-based traffic management not only creates problems for online gamers and gaming providers, whose applications perform worse than other kinds of applications, but it also creates problems for innovation. If an online gaming provider wants to introduce a new feature for its game in the UK, it needs to work with the ISPs and their technology vendors to make sure that the feature won’t be caught up in the traffic management measures directed at peer-to-peer file sharing. This is the opposite of innovation without permission.</p><p>Similarly, until 2010, many ISPs in Canada used deep packet inspection technology to single out all peer-to-peer file sharing applications and limit the amount of bandwidth available to them from 5pm to midnight. Again, ISPs assumed that it was alright to target peer-to-peer file sharing, because it’s not sensitive to delay. But this assumption turned out to be wrong: there was an application called Vuze that used peer-to-peer file sharing protocols to stream video in real time. Real-time video is highly sensitive to delay, so the performance of Vuze suffered in the evening, when everybody wants to use the Internet.</p><p>Thus, the class-based traffic management might result in harmful discrimination by even the best-intentioned ISPs.</p><p><strong><em>Class-based traffic management discriminates against encrypted traffic.</em></strong></p><p>If traffic is encrypted, then the ISP cannot identify what kind of application — e-mail, telephony, web browsing — that a user is using, so it doesn’t know what kind of treatment it needs. In the past, ISPs have addressed the problem by simply putting all encrypted traffic in the slow lane. That means that any time someone sends encrypted data, it will take longer to transmit. People encrypt their data for a variety of valid reasons, for example, to protect privacy, secure sensitive financial transactions, protect trade secrets, and guard against surveillance. If all encrypted data is automatically slowed down, it would discourage people from using encryption at all.</p><p><strong><em>Class-based traffic management harms individual users.</em></strong></p><p>Class-based traffic management takes the power to choose the right kind of service out of the hands of users and puts it into the hands of ISPs. However, people have different needs for speed on the Internet, and the same person has different needs at different times. As a result, a user’s needs may differ from an application’s technical requirements, so ISPs don’t necessarily know what kind of service a user needs. For example, Internet telephony applications like Skype benefit from low delay, so ISPs may opt to give them low-delay service. That’s great if you are doing a job interview, where you want the best quality possible. But if you are talking with a friend, you don’t need crystal clear quality over Skype, so low-delay service might not be necessary. File uploads are generally considered not to be sensitive to delay. If you are uploading your hard disk to the cloud to do a backup, you will not mind that ISPs give file uploads lower priority. But if you are a student uploading homework right before it’s due, or a lawyer filing a brief before the deadline, or an architect submitting a bid, then the speed of this upload is your highest priority. As long as ISPs, and not users, have the power to decide which classes of application get what kinds of service, users will never get exactly what they need. That’s why class-based discrimination often harms users.</p><p><strong><em>Class-based traffic management stifles innovation.</em></strong></p><p>Imagine you develop a new application that would benefit from a specific kind of service. Entrepreneurs and start-ups typically do not have the resources or capacity to reach out to ISPs around the European Union to alert them that their particular application needs a certain kind of service. Even if a start-up manages to contact ISPs, they may not be interested in changing their systems for particular applications, which is a lot of work, especially when new apps don’t have any users yet. Entrepreneurs should be able to get the kind of Internet service their application needs without having to seek ISPs’ permission.</p><p><strong><em>Class-based traffic management leads to high costs of regulation.</em></strong></p><p>If ISPs get to define classes of applications, the only way to challenge these definitions is to complain to regulatory agencies. The agency would need to determine whether kinds of traffic are similar enough to be treated in the same way, a messy and costly process that would involve lots of lawyers and expert witnesses. This not only creates high costs of regulation, but also tilts the playing field against anybody — users, start-ups, small businesses, low-cost speakers — who doesn’t have the money to engage in long and costly proceedings before a regulator.</p><p><strong>SOLUTION: The Parliament should adopt amendments that prohibit ISPs from differentiating among classes of applications unless it’s necessary to manage congestion or maintain the security or integrity of the network. The proposal already contains an exception that allows ISPs to differentiate among classes of applications if that’s the only way to manage congestion. Thus, removing the language that allows class-based traffic management at all times protects users, competition, and innovation, while still giving ISPs the tools they need to manage their networks.</strong></p><h4><strong>PROBLEM #4:</strong></h4><p><strong>The proposal allows ISPs to start managing congestion in the case of impending congestion. That means that they can slow down traffic anytime, not just during times of actual congestion.</strong></p><p>The proposal gives ISPs a carefully calibrated set of tools to manage congestion. In particular, it allows them to differentiate among classes of traffic if doing so is necessary to deal with temporary or exceptional congestion. The relevant provisions have been designed carefully to ensure that discriminatory traffic management remains the exception rather than the rule.</p><p>However, the proposal allows ISPs to use the same tools to prevent “impending” congestion. Since the meaning of “impending” is not clearly defined, this provision opens the floodgates for managing traffic at all times. It makes it easier for ISPs to discriminate among classes of applications even if there is no congestion, using the justification that congestion was just about to materialize.</p><p><strong>SOLUTION: The Parliament should adopt amendments that limit ISPs’ ability to discriminate against traffic to prevent impending congestion.</strong></p><h4><strong>HOW WE GOT HERE — AND WHAT WE SHOULD DO NEXT</strong></h4><p>In April 2014, the European Parliament voted for strong network neutrality rules for the European Union. But under European law, network neutrality rules need to be adopted jointly by the Parliament and the Council, which consists of the representatives of the governments of each member state. Over the past year, the Council has consistently supported proposals that were significantly weaker than the Parliament’s text. In late June, representatives of the Parliament and the Council unexpectedly reached a compromise in informal negotiations. This compromise proposal was formally adopted by the Council in September.</p><p>If a majority of the members who vote approves this flawed compromise next Tuesday, the rules are adopted and become law. Europe will have far weaker network neutrality rules than the US, and the European Internet would become less free and less open. By contrast, if a majority of the members approves amendments, the text goes back to the Council. The Council can then accept the amendments, and they become law. If the Council rejects the amendments, a joint committee consisting of representatives of the Parliament and the Council has six weeks to come up with a compromise. Any compromise would then have to be adopted by the Parliament and the Council.</p><p>The future of the Internet in Europe is on the line. It’s up to all of us to save it.</p><p><a href="http://cyberlaw.stanford.edu/about/people/barbara-van-schewick"><strong><em>Barbara van Schewick</em></strong></a><em> is a leading net neutrality expert, a Professor at Stanford Law School, the Director of the Stanford Center for Internet and Society, and the author of Internet Architecture and Innovation (MIT Press 2010, Paperback 2012). Her writings on network neutrality have influenced regulatory debates in the United States, Canada, Europe, Latin America and India. The FCC’s Open Internet Orders in 2010 and 2015 relied heavily on her work. Parts of this text draw on her earlier writing on net neutrality.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=bbfa4d5df0c8" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>