<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Scribulatora on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Scribulatora on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@scribulatora?source=rss-ea18e777cb8e------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 20:59:47 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@scribulatora/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Fiscal Conservative Social Liberal is a M̶y̶t̶h̶i̶c̶a̶l̶ Rare Creature.]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@scribulatora/the-fiscal-conservative-social-liberal-is-a-m%CC%B6y%CC%B6t%CC%B6h%CC%B6i%CC%B6c%CC%B6a%CC%B6l%CC%B6-rare-creature-e0e23771c93d?source=rss-ea18e777cb8e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e0e23771c93d</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[canadian-politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Scribulatora]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 12 Sep 2020 23:50:43 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-02-18T20:11:46.046Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*CtUXCe0weFhuGmiS-AOZFA.jpeg" /></figure><p>When <a href="https://financialpost.com/opinion/william-watson-if-youre-socially-liberal-and-fiscally-conservative-you-may-be-endangered">William Watson of the Financial Post wrote this description </a>of the compound phrase “fiscal conservative, social liberal”, I found myself face to face with one of my conquered vices.</p><blockquote>It’s social liberalism combined with fiscal conservatism: the idea that government should let people run their own personal lives but should also be modest about intervening in the economic aspects of their lives and so should not overly regulate, spend, tax or borrow. It used to be a common view.</blockquote><p>Having spent most of my life as a conservative, deeply rooted in my working class Nova Scotian background, I wanted to accept that familiar message as simple, concise truth.</p><p>But what Mr. Watson actually provided is a pretty accurate description of the views of a “classical liberal” which we now know as a “conservative”. It’s the <strong><em>great conceit</em></strong> of conservatism, one that I used to share, to use the phrase “social liberal, fiscal conservative&quot; as if it’s not a dichotomy, but a two sided Janus coin. It’s a seductive fallacy and the original sin of political virtue signaling.</p><p>Like all complex discussions, we can’t proceed without understanding the terms.</p><h3>Fiscal conservatism is a real thing with a definition.</h3><p>The phrase “fiscal conservatism&quot; has been around since the 1930s when Roosevelt’s New Deal created a schism in the broad “liberal” camp.</p><p>The policies initiated by FDR’s social liberals were seen by the classical liberals to be the mechanism by which America became a “welfare state” with increased regulations, enforced worker protections, market controls, higher taxes, increased government debt and deficit spending. All this was anathema to the classical liberals who favoured the most minimal possible government intervention in the workings of both society and the economy.</p><p>In fact, it became such an issue for them that they created a new phrase to distinguish themselves. That phrase was “fiscal conservative”.</p><blockquote>Those classical liberals began to call themselves fiscal conservatives so as not to be associated with FDR’s coalition of social liberals. And then finally just “conservatives”.</blockquote><p>It started what became one of the greatest realignments in American political history. So, in a way, this compound phrase is the fulcrum of a decade long political struggle that shifted the world’s greatest democracy on its axis.</p><p>Deregulation, free trade, open markets, privatization and low personal and business taxes are the defining qualities of classical liberalism turned fiscal conservatism. To use “fiscally conservative” as an adjective to describe your beliefs, or to call yourself a “fiscal conservative” is to believe in these things.</p><p>As Mr. Watson said in his definition:</p><blockquote>government should … be modest about intervening in the economic aspects of their lives and so should not overly regulate, spend, tax or borrow.</blockquote><h3>Social liberalism is also a real thing with a definition.</h3><p>Mr Watson’s definition of being socially liberal is simple and straightforward and is the only manner in which the “fiscal conservative” component can be true.</p><blockquote>Government should let people run their own personal lives.</blockquote><p>And it’s also fully opposite to the actual definition. <strong>That is a conservative’s idea of what “social liberal” <em>should</em> mean, not a definition of what it <em>does</em> mean.</strong></p><p>His wording is perfectly representative of the mental trick so-called principled conservatives play upon themselves. By taking the very passive position of non interference he is displaying no animosity or prejudice, no ill will or sense of superiority, no desire for people to suffer, merely a dispassionate notion of non interference. It is a fundamental belief of conservatism that we must not interfere in the natural course of a person’s life or do so as little as possible. For good or ill, that government should “let people run their own lives”.</p><p>To <em>actually</em> be a “social liberal” or a believer in social liberalism is to essentially be a FDR New Deal style liberal. The opposite of Mr. Watson’s definition. Social liberalism’s core principle is that it’s not enough to be passive, to just leave people to live their lives. It’s founded on the belief that not only <strong><em>should</em></strong> government concern itself with people’s lives, but that it has a <strong>duty </strong>to do so.</p><p>A social liberal, or someone who is “socially liberal” believes that government should directly and indirectly address economic and social issues such as equality, racism, workplace protections, poverty, health care, education and so on by way of regulations, laws, policies, increased taxes, and, as necessary, borrowing and deficit spending.</p><p>Social liberalism is the political recognition that left unchecked — when people are left to “live their own lives”— without sufficient controls on their worst impulses, society begins to erode. Socio-economic classes split and harden, wealth and income disparity explodes, poverty increases and with it violence, disease, and addiction. Serious crime, racial and religious intolerance, domestic violence and minor crimes specific to poverty overwhelm underfunded institutions.</p><p>Social liberalism formed organically in 1930’s America as a response to all those things <em>which had already happened to their society</em> leading up to and during the great depression. It wasn’t a bunch of lefty do-gooders doing good, it was the heroic effort to save a country from permanent damage, maybe even ruin, to change its direction and to allow it to flourish.</p><p>One cannot argue with the results. It ushered in an age of progress and prosperity the likes of which the world has rarely, if ever, seen.</p><p>And still, America’s conservatives have been engaged in a persistent and sometimes incomprehensibly craven attempt to undo the New Deal for almost a hundred years.</p><h3>The rest of the necessary nomenclature</h3><p>Let’s clarify the Canadian specific definitions used in this particular argument.</p><p>If your hard belief is “fiscal conservative” (low taxes/debt and minimal social intervention), you are <strong>right wing </strong>and a <strong>conservative</strong>. You usually vote for Conservative Party of Canada (CPC).</p><p>If your hard belief is “social liberal” (moderate social intervention, moderate taxes, and the cautious use of debt as a fiscal tool) you are <strong>left wing </strong>and a <strong>liberal. </strong>You usually vote for Liberal Party of Canada (LPC).</p><p>If your hard belief is an extension of the left wing/liberal ideology (extensive social intervention, higher taxes and the more free use of debt as a fiscal tool) you are <strong>left wing</strong> and a <strong>social democrat. </strong>You usually vote for the New Democratic Party of Canada (NDP).</p><p>If you’re a moderate “conservative” who believes that a little debt and social spending is okay as long as it doesn’t overly threaten personal freedoms, restrict open markets or increase taxes, you’re <strong>centre-right</strong> . Your natural vote will be for either the CPC or the LPC, depending upon the economy, the party representatives and the party platform.</p><p>If you’re a moderate “liberal” who believes we should have robust social programs, but not so many that we become a “nanny state”, or unable to fund those programs without a debilitating level of taxation, or they interfere too much with the free market, you’re <strong>centre-left</strong> worldview. Your natural vote is for the LPC or the NDP, depending upon the economy, the party representatives and the party platform.</p><p>For the purpose of this article, let’s create a foundation thesis.</p><blockquote>Canada is a socially liberal country and our two primary parties are engaged in an endless tug of war between moderate fiscal conservatism and moderate social liberalism.</blockquote><p>Canada itself hasn’t been (if it ever was) properly fiscally conservative since universal healthcare was introduced in 1966, more than thirty years after FDR’s New Deal. That was the Rubicon which the “social liberals” pulled us across and from which the “fiscal conservatives” have been relentlessly and fruitlessly trying to “rescue” us ever since.</p><p>Being planted, firmly we think, on the left bank of the Rubicon creates the illusion that the stakes in the tug of war are nominal — a matter of how much we spend on social liberalism, not whether we have it.</p><p>Fair enough. On the basis of this belief, let’s say that while you cannot be both a “social liberal” <strong>and</strong> a “fiscal conservative” based on their clinical meanings, you <strong>can </strong>be either center-left or center-right and that these positions could be described accurately, if not clinically, as being “socially liberal <strong>and </strong>fiscally conservative” to one degree or another.</p><p>I’m writing this to clarify a public statement I made that one could not be both socially liberal and fiscally conservative. As I’ve just proved myself wrong, I owe a public apology.</p><p>[insert appropriate <em>mea culpa</em> here]</p><h3>I concede my mistake. Now let’s talk about yours.</h3><p>Yours has its roots in the nomenclature section, where I talk about which party/parties is/are your natural go to, depending upon your type of centrism.</p><p>By the definitions I just established, the people who use the “fiscal conservative, social liberal” phrase to describe themselves are moderates from both sides. Centrists. They lean left and right, but stay fairly close the center. They tend to believe that the way to bring Canada back to that desired “centrist” balance is to simply vote for the other side for a term. If you feel the side in power has veered too far into either “social liberalism” or “fiscal conservatism” you might believe that a vote for the opposition merely has a braking effect.</p><p>You might believe, for instance, that voting for a CPC government simply causes either less spending/debt or voting for an LPC government simply means a greater attention to social programs designed to equalize social and economic opportunity.</p><p>You might even plan to vote for the other side again the next time, and believe it’s like tapping “resume” on Canada’s political cruise control.</p><p>This is the mistake I want to convince you to concede.</p><p>The value of the <strong><em>great conceit</em></strong> so succinctly laid out by Mr. Watson is that it allows you to believe it’s just a matter of book keeping and reduction of some of social spending that you personally find offensive or excessive. It allows you to believe that all you’re doing when you vote the “other side” is hitting pause while we make some fiscal bank or regain some social ground.</p><p>But that’s not even a little true. It would only be true if the real, actual meaning of “socially liberal” is simply to be passive and “let people run their own personal lives”. Which it’s not.</p><p>Those of you who currently (while we have a liberal government in power) use the phrase this way “I’m a social liberal, fiscal conservative and I really care about people and want them to be good, but I’m getting mighty nervous about the amount of spending going on to enact that liberal program. I’m thinking of voting conservative next time, just to get things under control.”</p><p>Here’s what that vote you think is a harmless braking action is actually doing: it’s eroding the foundations of social liberalism itself. It’s making us a little less firmly planted on the left bank of the Rubicon. It’s making us easier to pull back across.</p><p>It’s reducing taxes, deregulating, taking away benefits and protections and trying to re-invigorate the “ruling class” (wealthy white people referred to as “job creators” by conservatives) by opening markets and privatizing services. It’s selling public land and rights to our resources. It’s <em>dismantling</em> the liberal democracy we just paid for — are <em>still </em>paying for. And when you elect the Liberals again next time, we’ll pay for it <strong><em>again … </em></strong>plus the cost of the rebuild<strong><em>.</em></strong></p><p>Conservative governments tend to all cut costs in the same basic way: they cut revenue by cutting taxes and then to balance the books, they have to cut social programs. There is no other way. I refer you to Alberta which is governed by a right wing party which has a philosophy closest to genuine “fiscal conservatism”. Ontario is a less compelling but still valid example of the shifts between a liberal and a conservative government. It’s not just fiscal restraint, it is a philosophy of passive government whose “enemy” is active social liberalism. It is not social-liberalism lite, it is a whole other beast.</p><p>Honestly, it’s like buying something on credit and then setting it on fire before it’s paid for because you suddenly feel you overpaid.</p><p>If the intention was to gently brake while still in “Drive” , you should know that by voting for the “other side” you’ve actually thrown us into a hard, gear grinding “Reverse”.</p><h4>The correct thing to say if you are a social liberal and want Canada to stay a socially liberal country, but you are concerned about our economy or fiscal state, is “I’m a social liberal and I want the social liberal government to stop spending so much money or explain it to me so I can stop worrying.”</h4><p>Social liberalism — like anything else — can’t exist in stasis. If society/government does not move along and become progressively more adept at being “socially liberal” (not necessarily more socially liberal, just better at it), it will begin to disintegrate under its own weight.</p><p>If portions of it are undone every four years, it will always be a crumbling building that requires constant repair. And real fiscal conservatives undo the pillars, you must understand, not the roofs. They aren’t going to try and cut off a toe, they’re going to try to stab it in the heart.</p><p>So, if you’re a person who wants the government to actively participate in engineering a more equal society — to do more than be passive road builders — placing that conservative vote is a funny way of showing it.</p><p>Here’s a truth: because we ARE a socially liberal democracy, when the conservatives come to power it can seem an awful lot like they’re supportive of all those social programs and of social liberalism itself. It’s not like they come in on the first day and send a guy around to start kicking seniors out of public housing and herding them down to the local church basement.</p><p>They are insulated against a public outcry about their intentions because we’re sure the things we’re warned about could never <em>actually </em>happen. Canada won’t, you tell yourself, ever get rid of public healthcare or downgrade its public education or have a state media. Canada will never deregulate the markets or remove workplace protections or let people go without necessities.</p><p>In a province things can happen much more quickly and the results are much more visible and obvious, so if you’re sure we won’t actually go backwards and your conservative vote will simply be a check, I invite you to go talk to some social liberals in Alberta or Ontario.</p><p>There’s another side, of course.</p><p>If your concern is that the fiscal state is a result of <em>veering too far left ideologically</em>, that we’ve started building a government so large that it has become vulnerable to unchecked excess, that we’ve become hostage to special interest group grievances and “feelings” , that by trying to be all things, it has become a jack of all trades and a master of none, then that’s a different thing.</p><p>Perhaps you’re concerned that we’re slicing off the sharp edge of personal responsibility and shaving too close to the bone of personal freedom and in the grand scheme to equalize things, your own chances at success are slowly disappearing. Or that we’re sidling too close to the moral hazard of a government trying to remake human nature itself or subsidizing its weaknesses to an enabling degree. Perhaps you’re not sure that it’s the government’s job, and thus not yours, to feed the poor or house the vulnerable or contain the markets or make people stop saying mean things.</p><p>Perhaps you feel that the Necromonger was right and that a person should get to “keep what they kill”. Or at least more of it.</p><p>If any of these things are true — or all of them — to this or that degree your choice is different. You can believe all (or any) of these things, they’re perfectly valid views that have a place in the discussion, but it’s best if you understand them in their entirety. If any of these things resonate, your vote for a conservative government as a check is a perfectly reasonable one to make.</p><p>But just be clear why you’re choosing to do that and what the consequences will be. You’re checking ideological drift, not fiscal excess. They’re different but equally valid things.</p><p>This whole exercise started as an explanatory/mea culpa Twitter thread that became a victim of my “writing how to books” brain. Which is to say that twitter threads that contain nomenclature tables are bad Twitter threads.</p><p>Because I will be amazed if anyone makes it this far, I might as well add this personal and extraneous post script:</p><p>The original Twitter thread combined with a bunch of real life and online conversations with conservative and liberal friends, has sent me into a terrible political identity tailspin.</p><p>I think I’m likely a “Mulroney conservative” which is nothing at all like a “Harper conservative” and even less like an “O’Toole conservative”. My closest political home is the Liberal Party and their drive to maintain ascendancy requires a movement leftwards that I find increasingly uncomfortable in some very complicated “big government” ways which are not at all fiscal.</p><p>My personal stopping point is that I honestly believe that wealth/income inequity is our single largest global problem, bigger even than climate concerns— which I think are the second most pressing issue we face as a race of people.</p><p>I do not like this new variety of Canadian conservative — not one little bit. I dislike the Harper-ness of their ideas, their willingness to accept and even embrace what we tend to call “Right Wing Nut Jobs”, religious social conservatives and, frankly, low rent candidates with neither the intellectual capacity nor the character to run a country like Canada.</p><p>Mr. O’Toole has come right out and told us he would implement a “Canada First” set of economic policies that are, in his own words, “exactly the same” as Trump’s “America First” economic policies. I’m not sure why anyone with a functional brain would vote for that or advocate that any other Canadian do so, frankly. To be clear, that is a set of policies aimed at getting to real “fiscal conservatism” very quickly and, as already discussed, actual fiscal conservatism is the political opposite of “social liberalism” and shouldn’t be a place anyone wants to go after 2020.</p><p>In the late 1970s, Prime Minister P.E. Trudeau claimed that his Liberal Party of Canada adhered to the “radical center”. I think, all things considered, in a country like Canada, we should stick as close to that center and that philosophy as possible and only one party has stated policies that are even within reaching distance of that center.</p><p>I’m going to remain a “Mulroney conservative” and vote for the closest thing we have to that, which is the Liberal Party.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e0e23771c93d" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Battle Slogan of the Republic]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@scribulatora/the-battle-slogan-of-the-republic-4712ecdb1eba?source=rss-ea18e777cb8e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4712ecdb1eba</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[canadian-politics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Scribulatora]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 06 Sep 2020 17:23:42 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-09-06T19:18:26.881Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*7teBQUbHWHvRlugI1e78jw.jpeg" /></figure><p>In America, the center-left Democratic Party, aided by a growing array of grassroots organizations and individuals with the phrase “take back” sprinkled liberally in their rhetoric, are dedicated to beating Donald Trump’s hard right Republican Party in this year’s Presidential Election.</p><p>As I type from my comfy Canadian couch, surrounded by sleeping dogs, a host on one of the cable shows is saying “sixty five days until the election” enunciating each word like she’s announcing the pending arrival of a civilization ending asteroid.</p><p>The message, to hit you in the face with the obvious hammer, is that only electing Joe Biden, the Democratic Candidate, will stop the asteroid. “Taking back” America is a moral imperative, not merely a political ambition.</p><p>To most people in Canada and other liberal democracies there is a general agreement that America is on the brink of cliff so steep that her existence as a free democracy is in legitimate jeopardy. In some part of our conscious minds we understand that if American democracy “falls”, the cascade effect will be catastrophic for many countries, including our own. Maybe even especially our own. New world order stuff.</p><p>Because we understand the stakes, we have not only accepted “take back”, we have imbued it with the mystic power of a warrior’s mantra. The “oorah” of the proletariat. We even find it exciting, exhilarating in the moment. It’s a rally cry and we’re all there for it, cheering for the good guys in America as they try to take it back from the bad guys. It’s pretty basic psychology 101.</p><p>It’s not even close to the first time the phrase itself has been employed in an American political campaign. Chris Good, writing for The Atlantic in 2011, in an article titled <a href="https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2011/06/take-back-america-two-decades-in-the-life-of-a-political-cliche/240755/">‘Take Back America’: Two Decades in the Life of a Political Cliche</a> points out both the frequency of the phrase and its allure to those on all sides of the political spectrum.</p><blockquote>It happens almost every campaign year: Candidates urge us, like repo men, to “take back America.” The phrase and its natural variants are everywhere in American politics — and have been for some time, making them among the hardiest cliches of American political discourse. And yet with each fresh cycle, the command to “take back America” or “take America back” reappears, uttered with fresh vigor by politicians undeterred by the history the phrases have had in campaigns run by those with diametrically opposed views.</blockquote><p>The thing that makes the current American iteration of the “take back” theme extraordinary and unique, the SOS of a polity in extremis and not merely a garden variety political slogan turned cliché, is that while it <strong>is </strong>political, it is <strong>not</strong> <em>partisan</em>.</p><p>The further left one travels on the political spectrum, the more vociferous and worldview tainted are the cries, often railing against the underlying conservative ideology, but in the end, the “take back” coalition is a broad one that is united against Trump and the Republican party itself. In addition to Democrats, Independents and soft Republicans, it encompasses the Never Trumpers, a group of influential formerly Republican but still conservative journalists, operatives, former government officials and what is sometimes described as the “intellectual class” of American conservatism: Max Boot, Bill Kristol, David Frum, Tom Nichols, Charlie Sykes.</p><p>Day after day, as we approach November, we are told about this retired General or that retired Senator or the other former Judge who has publicly come out against Trump in particular and the current version of Republicanism (not conservatism) in general. “Take Back America” is like a train picking up speed as it approaches the chasm spanning bridge, its smoke plume the combined exhales of the two hundred million Americans loaded into it.</p><p>The liberal democratic world at large understands why the moderate and left faction of America is trying to take itself back now. We witness the observables daily: escalating social discord, a leader deteriorating cognitively and physically, an enabling Senate, and a corrupt Justice Department led by a man about which former Republican communications director Tara Setmayer said, “I think he has all of Trump’s bad intentions but with little of Trump’s incompetence.” Forming part of a story by David Smith for the UK’s Guardian titled ”<a href="https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2020/aug/02/william-barr-attorney-general-trump-washington">Is Trump’s top cop, attorney general William Barr, a danger to democracy?</a>” which echoes similar sentiments in all of America’s own flagship publications, the writer outlines why it’s neither partisan nor hyperbolic to say that America’s future as a free democracy is not at all assured.</p><p>In short, it would be good for the world if the Democrats were, in fact, able to take back America.</p><p>Will it work? It’s hard to know. The most recent precedent for this particular rhetorical device being successful in convincing an entire nation to agree on a massive change of direction and purpose is the “Take Back Control” slogan employed by the people lobbying for Britain to leave the European Union. Brexit, as we all know, was successful — barely so, but still so — and more than one pundit has opined that had the “other side” found a similarly catchy slogan, it might have actually changed that outcome.</p><p>As <a href="https://www.birmingham.ac.uk/staff/profiles/gov/haughton-tim.aspx">Tim Haughton</a> of the University of Birmingham wrote in a piece titled <a href="https://www.birmingham.ac.uk/research/perspective/eu-ref-haughton.aspx"><em>“It’s the Slogan, Stupid”</em></a><strong><em> </em></strong>:</p><blockquote>The reason why the United Kingdom voted to leave the European Union can be expressed in three words: ‘Take Back Control’. The Leave side used the alluring slogan repeatedly and relentlessly whereas the Remain side never coined a simple and affective slogan. Leave’s slogan was vague and often masked an inaccurate description of decision-making in the EU. But in political campaigns what matters is not what is accurate, but what works.</blockquote><blockquote>‘Take back control’ effectively combined not just a sense of a positive future albeit never defined or elaborated, but also suggested a sense of rightful ownership.</blockquote><p>Words are powerful and of all the ways we combine words into meaningful messages, the simple, memorable slogan that calls for action is an especially powerful device.</p><p>In its most banal form, “take back” is nearly a perfect slogan for political strategies in general, made benign as the missing words in the very pedestrian sentence, “The mission of a political party not currently in power is to ____ ____ power.” However, when separated out and deployed as a slogan against a slide into authoritarianism “take back” now holds the inherent promise of re-empowerment and inflames a sense of lost but <em>rightful</em> if not ‘ownership’, then control of a thing.</p><p>If location, location, location is the super power of real estate, then context, context, context is the super power of words.</p><p>To arrive at the Canadian angle, an <a href="https://toronto.citynews.ca/2020/06/16/trump-us-racism-poll/">Abacus Data/CityTV poll conducted in June, 2020</a> indicated that <strong>84%</strong> of Canadians viewed Trump as racist which is the exact same percentage of people who disapprove of Trump’s handling of the pandemic as reported by an <a href="https://globalnews.ca/news/6793101/coronavirus-canadians-trump-approval-poll/">April 2020 Global/Ipsos poll</a>. In a <a href="https://abacusdata.ca/canadians-would-vote-trump-out/">July 2020 Abacus poll titled “Canadians would vote trump out</a>, between 77% and 80% of Canadians would vote against Trump in the November election. We are acutely aware of the gravity of America’s situation.</p><blockquote>The very important caveat to this Abacus conclusion, which you should keep in your head because it’s important later, is that “between 41% and 46% of Conservative Party [of Canada] supporters would vote for Trump”.</blockquote><p>As a direct corollary, of the 67% of Canadians (<a href="https://www.statista.com/statistics/282846/regular-social-networking-usage-penetration-worldwide-by-country/">Statista</a>)who are active on social media where the phrase is embedded in the dialogue like a virus, 80% — more than 50% of all Canadians — are already conditioned to view the slogan “take back America” as a positive call to action upon which people who love democracy and freedom are united in supporting.</p><p>Canada <em>gets</em> it, America. “Take back” is the chorus of your battle song and you’re at war for your Republic.</p><p>Oorah.</p><p>All of that to ask this, “What in the world is newly elected Conservative Party leader Erin O’Toole doing trying to sing America’s battle song to Canadians?”</p><p>By all accounts, using traditional Canadian metrics or those generally agreed to in the broader world, Canada is not just a healthy democracy, but a thriving one. We consistently lead world rankings in a variety of indices from Quality of Life to Freedom, have a G7 leading economic outlook, fair and free elections, relatively low levels of crime, poverty and social discord and do not suffer from the deep cultural and religious divisions that have infected American politics.</p><p>The only brink Canada is on, one might argue, is greatness. If we managed to address our embarrassingly ongoing inability to make a lasting accord with the First Nations people, took better care of our elderly and disabled and were more progressive in our approach to income inequity, climate change and fossil fuel issues, we’d be very close to greatness indeed.</p><p>Inside this objective reality, the message “Take Back Canada” is outright ridiculous — <strong>especially</strong> since Mr. O’Toole’s platform addresses <strong>none</strong> of those lingering issues that keep us on the brink.</p><p>Mr. O’Toole has chosen a cliche and well-used strategy, that five or ten years ago might not have inspired any particular reaction at all. That was before we were all so “woke” and hyper-vigilant about slogans and words. Before MAGA. Before Take Back Control. Before Black Lives Matter. But we’ve seen these slogans, amplified by social media, literally change the face of our world.</p><p>The ambiguous nature of the phrase itself is like an omnidirectional, multi-pitch dog whistle. Across social media people are asking the non rhetorical question, “From whom are you taking back Canada?” From people of color? From immigrants? From those in the centre and on the left who want even more change? From climate science believers?</p><p>Is this an appeal to the “ordered” type moderates who typically make up the left flank of conservative base but who have fled in the past 5–10 years to the more socially moderate Liberal party? If so, he’ll amplify every single act of obstructive protest and activism that ends in violence or property destruction in an appeal to these people — and there will be a lot of them — who fear social chaos and uncertainty more than most things.</p><p>Marie-Danielle Smith, <a href="https://www.macleans.ca/politics/ottawa/who-really-is-erin-otoole/">writing in MacLeans</a>, summed up the public response:</p><blockquote>For his hard line on that issue [blocking transportation infrastructure with protests], paired with his “Take Canada Back” slogan, he has been accused of engaging in dog-whistle politics. His campaign dismisses that as pure politics.</blockquote><p>Conservative columnist Andrew Coyne, <a href="https://www.theglobeandmail.com/opinion/article-theres-more-to-being-a-tory-than-winning-or-at-any-rate-there-better/">in a Globe and Mail piece</a>, prior to Mr. O’Toole’s win, defined it rather haphazardly, one assumes from reading through Mr. O’Toole’s social media feeds where all of the noted phrasing was evident.</p><blockquote>Because he is the underdog, the affable Mr. O’Toole is suddenly posing as a “fighter” who will “take Canada back” from “cancel culture and the radical left.”</blockquote><p>Mr. O’Toole himself defines it in a more specific way.</p><h3></h3><p>&quot;It&#39;s about taking back Canada...They hate it when I say that, but Trudeau has taken us in a way that has made us more divided, less prosperous and less respected around the world.&quot;https://t.co/ChDkkje9Za</p><p>By choosing this slogan, Mr. O’Toole and the Conservative Party of Canada are deliberately broadcasting the incorrect and inflammatory sub-message that Canada has been similarly invaded by a hostile political force intent on destroying its democracy. In effect, that the progressive, Liberal-led, left leaning majority coalition is a danger to Canada in the same way Trump is to America. Existential threat stuff.</p><p>This is where the knowledge that between 41% and 46% of Conservative Party of Canada supporters would vote for Trump is a vital piece of information. Mr. O’Toole is betting that the slogan will appeal, in a counter-insurgency sort of way, to Canada’s conservatives. Not only a rejection of “Take America Back” by America’s left, but a counter-strategy that effectively says, “No, they don’t need to take <strong>America </strong>back, America is in the right place, we need to take <strong>Canada </strong>back.”</p><p>It’s so nonsensical on every level that one can understand the press, in general, taking the position that it must be a racist thing. On the ground, around social media, it was greeted with outrage of a different sort.</p><p>It is seen as an actual attack on democracy itself.</p><p>“Take it back from whom?” is the question most asked. Often obligingly accompanied by the answer, “From the people who voted for this.”</p><p>Melanie Woods, in an article in the Huffington Post titled “Erin O’Toole’s ‘<a href="https://www.huffingtonpost.ca/entry/erin-otoole-take-back-canada_ca_5ee2af10c5b67f9eb84b61c9">Take Back Canada’ Slogan Prompts Plenty Of Questions</a>” added a uniquely Canadian note to the argument.</p><blockquote>Taking Canada back suggests something’s been stolen. And one does not simply say “take Canada back” in a country built on colonization and forcibly seizing land from Indigenous people without raising a few eyebrows.</blockquote><p>If it’s true that Canada exists on “stolen land”, then the same is true for America with the notable difference that we still grapple with this question and the obligations it presses upon us as a society while America does not.</p><p>Is Mr O’Toole telling us that our national quest for reconciliation is not only unimportant to his party but that he has no intention whatsoever of giving anything, including the dignity of equality, back? Just more taking? Does he not understand the stake to the heart of First Nations people it must be to hear that any inroads, however marginal, they might have made under this current government, are to be “taken back”? Again.</p><blockquote>67% of Canadians voted for this center-left moderate-progressive government. To say you want to take it back, is to say you want to steal it.</blockquote><p>As Canadian-American conservative, Republican and Never Trumper David Frum told <a href="https://www.vox.com/2018/1/18/16880524/donald-trump-democracy-republicans-trumpocracy">Vox’s Sean Illing in 2018</a> , “The Republican Party has a platform that can’t prevail in democratic competition.”</p><p>He might as well as have been speaking about the Conservative Party of Canada.</p><p>As Frum said in that same interview, “When highly committed parties believe strongly in things that they cannot achieve democratically, they don’t give up their beliefs, they give up on democracy.”</p><p>If that aphorism is true, Mr. O’Toole’s “Take Canada Back” strategy is a compelling object lesson.</p><p>No, Mr. O’Toole, you can’t take Canada back. It doesn’t want to go.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4712ecdb1eba" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>