<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Sean Edwards on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Sean Edwards on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@seaneauthor?source=rss-78b049551229------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 17:33:39 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@seaneauthor/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Why Taxes Are A Good Thing — Except When They Aren’t]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/christian-intellectual/why-taxes-are-a-good-thing-except-when-they-arent-5bfce80cbd73?source=rss-78b049551229------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5bfce80cbd73</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[liberty]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[taxes]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[principles]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Sean Edwards]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 20 Feb 2017 18:06:31 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-07-19T14:33:33.274Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*oMrXt9mnqV2QeKXT." /></figure><p>1716, Christopher Bullock said: “Tis impossible to be sure of any thing but Death and Taxes.”</p><p>Taxation, and what should and shouldn’t be taxed, can be a hot subject for many.</p><p>People will get very heated about the role taxes play in our lives. Some believe it is your civic duty to pay taxes, while others view taxes as a legal form of theft.</p><p>And with something so ubiquitous as taxation, it can become easy to become numb to taxes in our modern lives. They just are. They always have been. And they always will be.</p><p>However, no matter where you stand on government issues, the situation is the same: <strong>you must pay taxes, or you will go to jail.</strong></p><p>That’s it. We can have philosophical discussions about duty and “the public good,” but at the end of the day, taxes are a serious issue. We are talking about the forced acquisition of people’s money.</p><p><em>We can have philosophical discussions about duty and “the public good,” but at the end of the day, taxes are a serious issue. We are talking about the forced acquisition of people’s money.</em></p><p>As we’ve seen in a previous article (<a href="http://www.seanedwards.com/zero-sum-fallacy/">Why Money Doesn’t Exist</a>), money represents the time and energy you spend working–time and energy you will never get back.</p><p>Because of this, in many ways your money represents a portion of your life (that portion you spent working). And if something is going to take a piece of your life by force, then you need to be sure you understand why.</p><p>Whether you think the tax rates are too high or too low, we need to give this subject the gravity it deserves. And most do not.</p><p>This article will explore the broad concepts behind taxes. And we will see why, when held to certain principles, taxes are a good thing.</p><h3>Why Taxes Are A Good Thing — Except When They Aren’t</h3><p>In its simplest form, taxes fund the government.</p><p>If the government needs to fight a war, it will levy a tax to fund that war.</p><p>If the government needs to build roads, it will levy a tax to construct those roads.</p><p>You get the idea.</p><p><strong>Therefore, the question of taxes is really a question of government.</strong></p><p>If you believe the government should be the instrument of social change, then “good” taxes will fund things like healthcare, education, and welfare assistance.</p><p>If you believe government should insure national security and justice, then “good” taxes will fund the armed forces and justice system.</p><p>This means your view of tax ethics depends on your view of government.</p><h3>Government and Taxes, Like Two Peas In A Pod</h3><p>Government is a human invention. Government did not predate humanity. And modern governments are based on laws, which are written by humans.</p><p>If government is a human invention, then it derives its power (or, more aptly, its moral authority) from humanity.</p><p>This means that the government must follow the same rules as people. In other words, governments can’t do things individuals couldn’t.</p><p>Governments can practically accomplish things individuals can accomplish. But it can’t morally do things humans cannot.</p><p>If government is a human invention, then it can’t have authority that humans don’t.</p><p>The government must be restrained by the same moral code that restrains humans.</p><p>Think of the government as humanity’s child. When two people have a child, it doesn’t have human DNA along side alligator DNA. It is 100% human, and can’t be anything but human.</p><p>The government is a human creation. Meaning its power, authority, and jurisdiction come from the same morals that limit individuals.</p><p><em>The government is a human creation. Meaning its power, authority, and jurisdiction come from the same morals that limit individuals.</em></p><p>If the government had the right to do things individuals don’t, where did that DNA come from? Where did that moral authority originate?</p><p>In the past, this “DNA” (or moral authority) came from the “Divine Right of Kings.” It was believed that royal families were God-breathed, which gave them the moral authority to rule over people.</p><p>But we don’t believe that today. That is why our government is “of the people, by the people, for the people.”</p><p>Our government gets its authority (to exist) from the people. So, I ask again, how can the government, a human invention, have power and authority that humans do not?</p><h3>Hubris Comes Before The Fall</h3><p>Some might say, “The will of the people give it that power.” Meaning, society as a whole empowers the government to do things individuals could not.</p><p>If the people want socialized medicine, then the government should provide socialized medicine.</p><p>However, I would ask, “How many more people did Hitler need to agree with him before the Final Solution became morally okay?”</p><p>If we define our government by “the will of the people,” then we are saying that the majority determines what is right and wrong.</p><p>Meaning that if enough people agree, then it must be right (or “true” or “good”). However, this ideology just replaces a dictator with mob rule.</p><p>If the mob wants to round up all the Japanese and put them in interment camps, <strong>they can.</strong></p><p>If they mob wants to create a muslim registry, <strong>they can.</strong></p><p>If they mob wants to enslave Africans, <strong>they can.</strong></p><p>If they mob wants to kill all the jews, <strong>they can.</strong></p><p>A group of individuals cannot override the rights of a single individual. This philosophy is known as <em>vox populi vox dei</em> (the voice of god is the voice of the people).</p><p>It may produce some good fruit initially, but eventually you end up in Nazi Germany or Stalinist Russia.</p><p>The government is supposed to reflect the will of the people, but only to an extent.</p><p>There are laws in place to keep the people from committing the same atrocities as dictators.</p><h3>Vox Populi Vox Dei: The Road to Death</h3><p>If we agree that the majority can’t determine right and wrong, then it implies we also believe there is another, more objective definition of right and wrong that can override the majority.</p><p>If the government doesn’t have any other “DNA” in it, then it must be 100% man-made. Meaning it must operate by the same moral standards as humans.</p><p>Groups of individuals do not have rights. And “group rights” (if such a thing could ever exist) certainly can’t override individual rights.</p><p>Practically, this means the government cannot violate the rights of individuals.</p><p>What does this mean? It means that any action the government takes to violates the rights of individuals is unethical.</p><p>If a person can’t do it, neither can the government. Plain and simple. If you can find a way around this, then please explain it in the comments, because I cannot.</p><p>If this is true, then taxes collected to fund programs that violate the rights of individuals are by nature unethical.</p><p>This is our yardstick to measure the morality of a tax: Does it fund a program or department that violates individual rights? Even if its doing so for the “public good”?</p><h3>Good Tax, Bad Tax</h3><p>We need to take an honest look at our government (and our personal political positions) to see if we as individuals could perform those actions.</p><p>If we could, then the government is in the clear, and the tax is ethical.</p><p>If we cannot, then ethics demands we stop our government from doing it. If its a social program we like, we must find a different way to accomplish the same end.</p><p>Lets take Universal Healthcare for example. Do I have the right to go to my neighbor and force him to pay for a homeless man’s healthcare?</p><p>Could you grab a gun, go next door, and force them to comply?</p><p>No. They would call the cops, and then you’d go to jail. Why? Because that’s called armed robbery.</p><p>It doesn’t matter what you intend to do with the money, you don’t have the right to your neighbor’s money.</p><p>Let me make this point again: <strong>Your intentions do not negate your actions.</strong> It doesn’t matter if you’re trying to help people, stealing is wrong.</p><p><em>Your intentions do not negate your actions. It doesn’t matter if you’re trying to help people, stealing is wrong.</em></p><p>So… why can the government do it? If you believe the government has the right to tax people for universal healthcare, then you must believe that the government has a type of authority people do not.</p><p>If that’s what you believe, then you need to defend your position. Because I don’t see how that’s true.</p><p>You can’t say, “It’s the right thing to do.” Or, “Society has a duty to take care of the least amongst us.”</p><p>Though they reveal noble intentions, neither of these sentiments answers the question, “How can the government ethically do things that individuals cannot?”</p><p>We want to take care of the poor. <strong>But just because we want something doesn’t make the way we’re doing it right.</strong></p><p>Furthermore, if we believe the government has this kind of “divine” power to override people’s rights… is that what we really want?</p><p>What happens when someone you don’t like gets into office (like President Trump, for instance)?</p><p>If you’ve endorsed policies that gave the government power individuals don’t have, then you’ve left a loaded gun in the White House for someone to use against you.</p><p>And it says that in some capacity, you believe vox populi vox dei.</p><p>It means that morality can be determined by the masses, and that Hitler only needed a few more people to agree with him to make his actions ethical.</p><p>Do you believe that?</p><h3>The Nefarious Nature of Implicit Beliefs</h3><p>Many of these beliefs are implicit, meaning they were subconsciously adopted. You didn’t consciously decide you believed them. Which gives you a certain innocent naivety.</p><p>But now that you know, you only have 2 options: A) You must defend your position with logic and reason, and explain how the government has the authority to do things individuals cannot, or B) You must openly declare that you desire a tyrannical government, so long as you agree with those in power.</p><p>Those are your 2 options. There are no others. Either you believe the government has a divine spark, or you believe you and your political party have the right to violate the rights of individuals (as long as you all agree about it).</p><p>If you see a third option, please describe it in the comments.</p><p>So, which is it? If you believe the government can do things individuals cannot, can you defend your position with logic? Or are you making way for the next Hitler?</p><h3>How To Define A “Good” Tax</h3><p>In an abstract, philosophical sense, we have individual rights. And those are generally defined as the right to life, freedom, and the fruit of your labor.</p><p>However, in the real world, you don’t really have any rights. If someone comes along who’s stronger than you, and they want your property (or your spouse), they’ll get it.</p><p>In a practical sense, your rights don’t exist.</p><p>This is why government exists, to ensure your rights as an individual. Otherwise, you would live at the mercy of those around you.</p><p>Since without government I’d be at the mercy of the strongest thug with a baseball bat wrapped in barbed wire, taxes that protect my rights are good.</p><p>In this context, taxes are my rent for living in a free country, free from the aggression of other people.</p><p>However, I would never pay a thug with a baseball bat wrapped in barbed wire to be my slave master.</p><p><em>I would never pay a thug with a baseball bat wrapped in barbed wire to be my slave master.</em></p><p>No rational person would voluntarily give up their freedom to a government that can rob or enslave them whenever the voting majority decided to do so.</p><p>The only tax that can be considered good is the tax that protects your rights as an individual.</p><p>When you pay taxes, you’re paying for protection from aggressors. <strong><em>But an individual would never pay someone to be their aggressor.</em></strong></p><p>And that’s the line. Once we cross from protecting individual rights into fixing social problems, we’ve made our government immoral.</p><p>We have empowered a thug to rule over us, and whenever the masses decide they want my property, or my life, there is nothing to stop them.</p><p>Taxes are a good thing because they empower an impartial entity to protect our rights as individuals, and administer justice. Without the government, your rights as an individual wouldn’t practically exist in the world.</p><p>Taxes become theft when they go beyond these borders, and force people to pay into programs with which they may or may not agree.</p><p>These are the 2 simple questions you can use to determine if a tax is good or not:</p><ol><li><strong>“Could an individual do what this tax is doing?”</strong></li><li><strong>“Does this tax actively defend my rights as an individual?”</strong></li></ol><p>If an individual couldn’t do it, then it is a bad tax.</p><p>But if it goes to protect your rights as an individual, it’s a good tax.</p><p>That is how taxes are a good thing… except when they aren’t.</p><p>Thank you for reading.</p><figure><a href="https://codylibolt.typeform.com/to/KpfJSh"><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1018/1*xK8wc7XFOAmEchKJ124GkQ.png" /></a></figure><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="http://www.seanedwards.com/taxes/"><em>www.seanedwards.com</em></a><em> on February 20, 2017.<br></em><a href="https://christianintellectual.com/subscribe/">Click here to subscribe to <em>For the New Christian Intellectual.</em></a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5bfce80cbd73" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/christian-intellectual/why-taxes-are-a-good-thing-except-when-they-arent-5bfce80cbd73">Why Taxes Are A Good Thing — Except When They Aren’t</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/christian-intellectual">For the New Christian Intellectual</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[3 Questions That Will Change Your Life]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/christian-intellectual/3-questions-that-will-change-your-life-457bf9de302e?source=rss-78b049551229------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/457bf9de302e</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[ethics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[worldview]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[definition]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Sean Edwards]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 03 Feb 2017 18:55:43 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-07-19T14:32:43.360Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*II2sqRLBia6yeUvZ." /></figure><p>In the previous post, we asked the question, <a href="http://www.seanedwards.com/right-and-wrong/">“How do you know if your definitions of ‘right’ and ‘wrong’ are correct?”</a></p><p>If you didn’t read that post, I highly recommend that you go back and <a href="http://www.seanedwards.com/right-and-wrong/">read it now</a>. We are going to build off it, so getting the most out of this post depends on you reading the previous one.</p><p>For those that read it, here’s a quick re-cap:</p><ul><li>The ancient world operated out of a very different, and very flawed moral code.</li><li>Their civilizations were often built on slave labor, prejudice, and exploitation.</li><li>However, their morals were justified by their understanding of the world.</li><li>Furthermore, if we went back in time to teach them our moral code, they would have balked at it, claiming it was too “abstract, impractical, and idealistic” to work in the real world.</li><li>How do we know we aren’t any different? Are we blind to our moral failings as well?</li><li>How do we know we haven’t written laws and built portions of our society on a faulty moral code?</li><li>Where do our definitions of “right” and “wrong” come from?</li><li>And ultimately, how do we know that our definitions of “right” and “wrong” are correct (or complete)?</li></ul><p>People often ask, “What is the right thing to do in this situation.” But very few ask, “How do I know this is the right thing do in this situation?”</p><p>Your definitions of “right” and “wrong” dictate your every action. They dictate everything from what kinds of clothes you where, to your career, to who you marry (or don’t marry).</p><p>Yet, for something that affects so much of our lives, very few people stop to ask if their understanding of “right” and “wrong” is accurate.</p><p>It would be like using a map to navigate through a dangerous territory, but never asking where the map came from, or who made it, and if it can be trusted.</p><p>We treat our morality like it’s a given. As if it where a compass that could never lie. But where did that compass come from? Who built it? By what standards? And where is it pointing?</p><p>However, before we can explore this question, we need to address the first part of the question: “How do I know my definitions…”</p><p>Most people never think to ask this question, but it is vital.</p><p>Were you born with your moral code?</p><p>Did your parents teach it to you? Or your school? Or church? A sacred text?</p><p>Where did they get it? And how do you know they are right?</p><p>Or do we simply “know” right from wrong based on how we feel? Is it something inherent to our “intuition”? Do we make decisions because something feels right (or wrong)?</p><h3>Where Did You Get Your Definitions Of “Right” And “Wrong”?</h3><p>Everything in nature has a survival mechanism. There is something inside every living thing that equips it to survive.</p><p>Tigers are born knowing how to survive. They have sharp teeth, powerful claws, and keen hunting skills.</p><p>Birds instinctually know how to fly (even if they have to be pushed out of a nest).</p><p>But, humans are unique in that we are not born with innate, instinctual survival skills and assets.</p><p>We don’t have keen hunting skills. We aren’t born with great strength and sharp claws. We aren’t magically endowed with agricultural knowledge.</p><p>We are born completely vulnerable to the world, wholly unequipped to survive, except for one thing: <strong>Our minds.</strong></p><p><em>We are born completely vulnerable to the world, wholly unequipped to survive, except for one thing: Our minds.</em></p><p>Our minds equip us to not only survive, but thrive. How? By learning, and then applying what we learn to better our lives.</p><p>We observe seeds falling to the ground, and then notice plants growing in the same spot.</p><p>We learn how to craft tools and weapons that allow us to hunt.</p><p>And we learn how animals behave to effectively track them.</p><p>Our minds take the information our senses give us, and synthesizes it into useable knowledge.</p><p>In the philosophical world, this is called <em>reason</em>.</p><p>Reason, or the act of synthesizing data from your senses into useable knowledge, is the foundation of all human survival and advancement.</p><p>But it goes further than that. Reason is our only means of gaining knowledge of anything.</p><p>Without our senses, would we be able to do anything? No. We would be lost in a dark, silent, empty void. We would have no way of knowing if we were moving our limbs, making noises, or anything.</p><p>Conversely, if we had our senses, but lacked the ability to synthesize that information, we wouldn’t be able to survive as well.</p><p>We would be like those unfortunate souls left in a vegetative state. Their senses are sending information to the brain, but their minds aren’t using that data for any purpose, much less for their betterment.</p><p>If this is true, then our definitions of “right” and “wrong” come from the same place: reason.</p><h3>The Headwaters Of Truth, Knowledge, and Morality</h3><p>We’ve established that reason is our only means of knowing anything. Which means we must learn our definitions of “right” and “wrong.”</p><p>We observe the world, we see certain actions, and deem them “good” or “bad.”</p><p>However, some will argue that “right” and “wrong” can be felt. And that we are born with it, or it is innate to our soul.</p><p>For example, beating children “feels” wrong. Helping the poor “feels” right.</p><p>But a feeling is not knowledge. Your feelings can’t give you any new information other than what you already know. Your feelings can only inform you of what you already believe.</p><p>Let me say that again: Feelings can only reveal what you already believe. They do not bring you any new information about the outside world.</p><p><em>Feelings only reveal what you already believe. They cannot teach you how to survive or better your life.</em></p><p>Feelings cannot give you the knowledge necessary to survive and thrive. They can drive you to discover that knowledge (hunger is a powerful feeling), but merely wanting food does not give you the ability to gain food.</p><p>If we are cold and wet, we cannot simply wish for shelter. We must learn how to build it, and then we must build it.</p><p>If we are hungry, we cannot simply wish for food. We must learn how to grow it, and then we must grow it.</p><p>If we are lonely, we cannot simply wish for companionship. We must learn how to obtain it, and then we must obtain it.</p><p>How does this affect our definitions of “right” and “wrong”?</p><p>We cannot use our feelings to define morality. Our feelings merely tell us what we already believe about morality.</p><p>If something “feels” wrong, it doesn’t mean your emotions know something you don’t. It doesn’t mean your emotions are imparting new knowledge to you.</p><p>Therefore, “it just feels right” cannot be a valid argument.</p><h3>Getting To The Core of Morality</h3><p>Our advancement in life depends on our observations of reality, and learning how to use those observations to our advantage.</p><p>This tells us two important facts about life: First, everything that betters human life is a product of someone’s mind.</p><p>Secondly, it teaches us that everything that betters human life requires action.</p><p>Someone must observe reality, learn how it works, and utilize that knowledge to grow food, produce water, build cars, manufacture airplanes, and invent the Internet. Learning does not produce these things by itself. <em>You must also do things.</em></p><p>Francis Bacon once said, “Nature, to be commanded, must first be obeyed.”</p><p>A famous philosopher expounded on this statement by saying, “Reality, to be successfully lived in, must be acknowledged.”</p><p>This means we must base our observations of the world on what the world actually is, not what we want it to be.</p><p>Many of the problems in the world are caused by a simple logical error. People have placed an “I want” before an “it is.”</p><p>Meaning, they want to command nature without understanding it. And they want to live in reality without acknowledging it. Both of which will produce bad fruit.</p><p>What does any of this have to do with anything?</p><p>Many of us have developed moral codes based on what we want to be true, and not what is true.</p><p><em>Many of us have developed moral codes based on what we want to be true, and not what is true.</em></p><p>Let’s take the concept of healthcare as a basic human right as an example.</p><p>Many people feel healthcare should be a basic human right. This is a noble goal. It feels wrong that money should determine if someone gets treatment or not.</p><p>However, by classifying healthcare as a basic human right, we are saying that people are born with a right to healthcare, and that the government must protect this right (i.e., guarantee access to healthcare).</p><p>But, healthcare, like all human values, requires thought and action to produce.</p><p>We want free healthcare because we don’t like the idea of other people suffering. But healthcare isn’t free. It may seem free to you, but it can’t be free. Its impossible for it to be free.</p><p>Someone, somewhere thought up the procedure or medicine. Our medicine was produced by observing reality, learning how to manipulate it to our benefit, and then doing the actions necessary to make the medicine.</p><p>Healthcare literally can’t be free. It cost someone time and energy.</p><p>However, if we want to enforce “healthcare as a human right,” then we must guarantee every individual access to healthcare.</p><p>This means we must either force doctors and researchers to work for free, or we must forcibly take money from others to pay doctors and researchers.</p><p>“Alright,” some of you might say, “I’m okay with that.”</p><p>But what happens if those doctors refuse to work? Even if you pay them? What happens when the pharmaceutical companies refuse to participate, and close their doors? Who will provide medicine then?</p><p>If healthcare is a right, then the government can’t let this happen. Since the government must guarantee access to healthcare, if people refuse to perform the actions necessary to produce healthcare, the government must force them to do so.</p><p>By declaring healthcare a human right, we are ignoring reality and refusing to acknowledge how these services come into existence.</p><p>Eventually, this system will fail. It will only survive as long as people are willing to be part of the system. If they decide not to participate, you must either force them to work (at gunpoint), or healthcare disappears.</p><p>Once the doctor says, “You have no right to my mind, and the products of my thought” you no longer have a doctor.</p><p>There is no way around this. The universal healthcare model blatantly ignores how human values are created. It puts an “I want” before an “it is.”</p><p><em>The universal healthcare model blatantly ignores how human values are created. It puts an “I want” before an “it is.”</em></p><p>And it only functions as long as the producers consent to supporting people who believe reality can be bent to their feelings.</p><p>This may seem harsh, but I challenge you to discover any way that healthcare is not the product of another human’s mind and actions.</p><p>And then I challenge you to find a way to actualize your belief in a way that doesn’t depend on the exploitation of another human being.</p><p>You can’t, because everything that advances human life is the product of our minds and actions. Healthcare doesn’t grow on trees independent of human action. Literacy isn’t download into people’s brains. Food doesn’t fall into our laps (unless we’re Isaac sitting beneath an apple tree).</p><p>Everything that advances our lives, from surviving to thriving, depends on our ability to think and act.</p><h3>Clipping The Wings Of Humanity</h3><p>Since reality is real, and we cannot change it simply by wanting it to change…</p><p>And since people must use their minds to survive and thrive…</p><p>We can define “good” as those things that advance life, and “bad” has those things that destroy life.</p><p>This means that every “good” action is one that advances life. And every “bad” action is one that takes life.</p><p>We cannot will “good” things into existence. We must create them.</p><p>By the same logic, we cannot stop a person from pursuing their own survival and well-being.</p><p>It is like clipping the wings of a bird, and then expecting it to survive. Or de-clawing a tiger and releasing it back into the wild.</p><p>This means that people have a “right” to utilize their minds to advance their lives, free from external coercion. Any attempt to limit a person’s ability to advance their life is the same thing has clipping a birds wings, or declawing a tiger, and releasing them back into the wild: We are sentencing them to death.</p><p>Since “good” things advance human life, and bad things hinders human life, any attempt to limit a person’s ability to pursue their own survival and wellbeing is “bad.”</p><p>In my previous post, I said we’d discuss some tools to help us determine if our definitions of “right” and “wrong” are accurate.</p><p>We’ve been using them in this post. They are 3 questions every person must answer to develop an accurate moral code:</p><ol><li>What kind of world do we live in?</li><li>How do I know the answer to the above question?</li><li>What do the answers to questions 1 and 2 tell me about how I should live (i.e., what is right and wrong)?</li></ol><p><strong>What Kind of World Do We Live In?</strong></p><p>Here we ask the basic question of reality. Does reality exist independent of human thought? Or does it change when we want it to?</p><p>Does the rain stop because we want it to?</p><p>Does food offer itself to us when we’re hungry?</p><p>Does fire appear when we are cold?</p><p>No. Reality is real, and our wants and desires don’t change it. This means we are prisoners of reality and the laws of nature.</p><p><strong>How Do I Know What Kind of World We Live In?</strong></p><p>As we have seen, all human knowledge comes from our minds. We observe reality and learn how the laws of nature work. Then we use that knowledge to pursue things that will better our lives.</p><p>We aren’t born with agricultural knowledge. We do not have instinctual hunting skills. If we want to survive, and thrive, we must use our minds to learn how.</p><p><strong>How Should I Live My Life?</strong></p><p>If we can agree that human life is valuable, then we must conclude that “good” is anything that advances human life, and “bad” is anything that hinders human life. And that it is “bad” to inhibit another person from advancing their life.</p><h3>Taking It Home</h3><p>In my previous post, I said we’d discuss some tools to sift through our ideas. These 3 questions are those tools.</p><p>Take your definition of “right” and “wrong” and run it through these questions.</p><p>If you think free healthcare is “good” or “right,” what does that say about your belief of the world?</p><p>Is your belief consistent with the nature of reality? (Does healthcare grow on trees? Are people born with the knowledge to perform brain surgery?)</p><p>Is your belief consistent with how we achieve “good” things? (Does it accept that all “good” things in life are the product of someone(s)’s mind and actions? Or do “good” things just magically appear because we want them to?)</p><p>Does your belief hinder a person’s ability to pursue their own survival and well-being? (Do laws force people to act a certain way or bar them from activities that would advance their lives, assuming those actions don’t harm others?)</p><p>Finally, does your belief require the extortion of other people to execute?</p><p>Healthcare (the poor unfortunate punching bag of this blog series) cannot be a human right.</p><p><strong>Socialized healthcare requires the extortion</strong> of other people to execute. Plain and simple. There is no way around this.</p><p>It ignores how healthcare services are produced. And it ignores reality by assuming that healthcare can be achieved apart from human effort.</p><p>Or, even more nefarious, it assumes that we have the right to forcibly use other people’s minds and actions for our own betterment.</p><p>Winston Churchill once said, “The problem with socialism is that at some point you run out of other people’s money.”</p><p>Even though he’s right (from a practical stand point), I would go a step further and say, “The problem with socialism is that it requires the exploitation of some individuals for the betterment of others… and eventually your run out of other people’s money.”</p><p>Any system that requires other people’s money to operate (and not the money of the person seeking the service) necessarily requires people who are willing to be extorted.</p><p>Socialism only works if people are willing to be slaves. Once they’ve had enough, and they stop producing the good thing you want, that good thing vanishes, and the socialist state collapses.</p><p>No amount of legislation and protesting will change that. No amount of screaming for “change we can believe in” will create healthcare when doctors refuse to work.</p><p>Everything we value depends on human thought and effort. And any attempt to survive ignoring this fact requires a willful rejection of reality and the exploitation of others.</p><p>We may not like the conclusions reality forces us to make. But not liking those conclusions doesn’t change them. The only things that changes our living conditions are thoughts paired with actions.</p><p>This means we have to abandon our idea of universal healthcare (as enforced by the government). It means we have to accept that even though a universal healthcare system is more convenient and “better” for some people, it requires that we use other people’s minds and actions for own betterment.</p><p>If we are to build a better world, we must accept reality for what it is. We cannot wish universal healthcare into reality. Like everything else, we must observe reality and learn how to use what we learn to achieve what we want.</p><p>And universal healthcare fails the reality test. It only works as long as some are willing to be extorted.</p><p>As soon as the wealthy decide they don’t want to pay for your healthcare, they’ll move out of the country.</p><p>Then it will only work as long as doctors are willing to work for free. Once other people’s money and other people’s labor dries up, universal healthcare ceases to exist.</p><p>Therefore, we can conclude that universal healthcare is wrong and evil because it requires the willful restriction and extortion of other people’s minds and labor.</p><p>This does not mean humans can’t be charitable. People can still help the poor. But it has to be completely voluntary. If it isn’t, charity just becomes a nicer word for extortion.</p><h3>This Is How You Know If Your Definitions Are Correct…</h3><p>How do you know if your definitions of right and wrong are correct?</p><ol><li>Do they align with reality? Or do they depend on our wishes altering reality?</li><li>Do they recognize that everything necessary for man’s advancement are a product of our minds and labor? Or do they presume that knowledge (the ability to survive) are innate in man’s consciousness, or that good things magically appear without thought and labor?</li><li>Do they protect everyone’s ability to pursue their own survival and well-being? Or do they intentionally restrict it by presuming that some have the right to benefit from other people’s labor?</li></ol><p>This way of thinking may be foreign to many. That’s alright. And if you think I’m wrong, then I have to ask, how do you know you’re not reacting like the ancients would’ve reacted to our current moral standards?</p><p>What if we’re blind to our immoralities because our current moral code is incomplete?</p><p>Are we certain that conveniences aren’t overwriting our logic? If we’re used to universal healthcare, are we certain our desire to keep our health coverage (in its current form) isn’t blinding us to the immorality of where it comes from?</p><p>Will people 1,000 years from now look at our system, see that it depends on the extortion of other humans, and judge us no different than we judge slave owners?</p><h3>Is Your Worldview Really Your Own?</h3><p>Here’s another thing to notice, everyone has answers to these questions. But not everyone has thought about their answers.</p><p>We must believe something about the nature of reality… but is it something you’ve thought through? Or something you’ve picked up from your parents or peer group?</p><p>If you don’t take the time to think through these questions yourself, you are letting other people’s answers influence your morals.</p><p>Think about that. If you don’t formulate your own opinions on the nature of reality, how we know the nature of reality, and what that means for our lives, you can’t call yourself a “free thinker.”</p><p>Why? Because you’re letting someone else think for you. If your understanding of the world is implicit, then you’re letting other people determine your worldview.</p><p>Lets take this a step further. If we acknowledge that all human survival and advancement comes from our actions… And if our actions are determined by what we believe… Then we are letting other people tell us how to live our lives.</p><p>Every decision we make… every job we choose… the person we marry… the place we live… the friends we have… everything… could be controlled by other people.</p><p>If you are not thinking about these questions, your thoughts are not your own. Your actions are not your own. Your life choices are not your own. They are someone else’s.</p><p>Is that what you want?</p><p>That is why philosophy is so important. It isn’t an esoteric discussion of how many angels can balance on the head of a pin.</p><p>It asks the most important questions humans could ask: What makes life “good,” and how should I live it?</p><p>There was a lot to digest in this post, but I hope you found it helpful.</p><p>At this point, I challenge you to run different ideas and policy positions through these 3 questions. You might find it… illuminating.</p><p>Thank you for reading.</p><figure><a href="https://codylibolt.typeform.com/to/KpfJSh"><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1018/1*xK8wc7XFOAmEchKJ124GkQ.png" /></a></figure><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="http://www.seanedwards.com/3-questions/"><em>www.seanedwards.com</em></a><em> on February 3, 2017.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=457bf9de302e" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/christian-intellectual/3-questions-that-will-change-your-life-457bf9de302e">3 Questions That Will Change Your Life</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/christian-intellectual">For the New Christian Intellectual</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[What If Your Definitions of “Right” and “Wrong” Are Wrong?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/christian-intellectual/what-if-your-definitions-of-right-and-wrong-are-wrong-c2d770ab5d61?source=rss-78b049551229------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c2d770ab5d61</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[ethics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[morality]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Sean Edwards]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 16 Jan 2017 17:31:40 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-07-19T14:42:10.818Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*x7qr2Z_rIMv7gdum53HOTg.png" /></figure><p>In the year 146 B.C., Rome destroyed the city of Carthage. Rome and Carthage had been at odds for a long time over supremacy of the Mediterranean.</p><p>When Roman troops breached the walls of Carthage for the final time, they acted as any ancient army would: They killed the men, raped the women, sold the women and children into slavery, burn the city to the ground, and they may have even sown salt into the soil “so nothing would grow again.”</p><p><strong>By today’s standards, this is beyond brutal.</strong> If a modern army engaged in this kind of activity, the rest of the modern world would intervene (hopefully).</p><p>However, in the ancient world, this was standard practice. It was how you dealt with threats to your empire. And Rome wasn’t the worst. That title may go to the Assyrians.</p><p>In the year 698 B.C., Sennacherib, the King of Assyria attacked Babylon, the capital of the Babylonian Empire. After taking the city, Assyria did everything the Romans would do to Carthage, and more.</p><p>In a final act of repudiation, they diverted the Euphrates River to flood the canals in Babylon, essentially washing the city from the face of the earth.</p><h3>Those Doing Evil Often Believe They Are Doing The Right Thing</h3><p>These examples merely scratch the surface of ancient brutality. It is hard for us to imagine a time when rape, slavery, and genocide were standard war practices. Not only that, but it was considered virtuous to brutalize your enemy.</p><p>Victory in combat meant that your people were superior to their foe. Or that your gods were stronger than their gods. Or, if you worshiped the same gods, it meant the gods favored you over the people you conquered. This gave you a “divine right” to rule over and extort the conquered.</p><p>There’s an old adage that says, “If you don’t study the past, you’re doomed to repeat it.”</p><p>There’s a powerful principle buried deep inside these examples of ancient brutality. And once we discover it, we realize we may be sitting on a time bomb.</p><p>Why did our ancestors do these things? How could they be proud of these actions? What is it about humanity that lets us behave with such evil?</p><p>If we don’t understand how our ancestors came to justify such actions, <strong>we could end up doing the same things.</strong></p><p>It is easy to think we’ve evolved past our ancestors. But genetically, the ancients were virtually identical to humans today.</p><p>This means they had the same ability to determine right from wrong as we. But they got it horribly wrong. They also had the same capacity for compassion and love, but they felt no need to employ it.</p><h3>We’ve Come A Long Way From Those Dark Days, But…</h3><p>We like to think we’ve moved past that brutality. But, at the end of the day, we’re just as capable of evil as our ancestors.</p><p>How, then, did our ancestors justify their actions? Why did they feel it was right and even virtuous to brutalize other humans? And, maybe more importantly, why did we decide these actions were wrong?</p><p>The clues to our answer lie in the question itself: How did they <em>justify </em>their actions? What standards of <em>justice</em> did they use to defend their actions? <strong>What <em>ideas</em> about the <em>world</em> and <em>humanity</em> led them to believe brutality was virtuous?</strong></p><p>Here’s the point: The only thing keeping us from acting like our ancestors are our definitions of right and wrong. That’s it. They classified very different actions as “good” and “virtuous.”</p><p>Fortunately, our morality has evolved. But, this exposes a critical fact about humanity: Our definitions of right and wrong dictate our actions, either for good, or for evil. And a flawed moral code can turn entire populations evil.</p><p>Furthermore, the people of the ancient world did not know their moral code was flawed. To them, it made perfect sense.</p><p>Their racism and prejudices were supported by what they saw in the world around them. Here are a few examples:</p><ul><li><strong>Outsiders sounded weird</strong> and spoke a different language, which made them seem less intelligent.</li><li><strong>Outsiders had strange, and sometimes bizarre customs</strong>, making them appear “backwards” and inferior.</li><li><strong>They had strange gods that demanded worship</strong>, threatening your peace with your gods (ancient gods were very finicky about who worshipped whom…).</li></ul><p>All of this to say, the ancient people had a “rational” defense for their morality. It made sense. And it helped explain human behavior.</p><p>Going even further, if you could go back in time and explain how their morality was flawed, they would have a very hard time accepting your position.</p><p>Their everyday experiences reinforced their understanding of the world. Our explanation of “right and wrong” would have contradicted this understanding.</p><p>Additionally, our definitions would have seemed abstract, arbitrary, and too idealistic for the real world.</p><p><em>To the ancients, our definitions of “right and wrong” would have seemed abstract, arbitrary, and too idealistic for the real world.</em></p><p><strong>This is has startling ramifications for us today.</strong></p><p>Suppose humans from 1,000 years in our future visited us today. What would they say about our moral code? Would they approve? Or would they be horrified by what we consider “virtuous”?</p><p>It would be arrogant to assume that we’ve perfected our definitions of right and wrong. Have we improved them? Certainly. But are they perfect? Probably not.</p><p>Have we rationalized any prejudices based on a flawed “common sense” understanding of the world?</p><p>Are we committing injustices because our understanding of humanity is incomplete?</p><h3>When The Truth Makes You Poor, It’s Easier To Believe A Lie</h3><p>In the ancient world, while mainstream culture exalted brutality, some philosophers and theologians had begun to identify moral codes similar to those we have today. But most of the ancient world rejected them.</p><p>Why? Either because they didn’t fit with how they perceived the world (as we’ve already illustrated), or because their way of life depended on their flawed moral code.</p><p>Slaves built their buildings and worked their fields. The rich and powerful stole their wealth from other people groups. And their land holdings were nothing more than nation-sized theft.</p><p>In order to accept a more advanced moral code, many people would’ve had to give up their wealth.</p><p>It is very hard to get people to see truth when their way of life depends on them continuing to believe believing a lie (remember this point…).</p><p><em>It is very hard to get people to see truth when their way of life depends on them continuing to believe believing a lie.</em></p><p>Returning to today, let’s assume that we’re the same as our ancestors (cognitively), and that we are susceptible to the same character failings as they.</p><p>If we are to learn anything from history, it is this:</p><ol><li><strong>We are often blind to our own moral deficiencies.</strong> We probably don’t have a complete understanding of ethics and morality. It would be arrogant to assume otherwise. We have reasons for why we believe what we believe. Our understanding of the world seems to support our moral code. But our observations and conclusions are most likely incomplete, meaning our moral code is also incomplete.</li><li><strong>If our ancestors are any indication of our behavior, then we’d probably reject</strong> a more advanced moral code presented by humans from the future. Their understanding of humanity, our their psychology, biology, and sociology, would presumably be more complete than ours. Meaning their understanding of right and wrong would be more advanced, and would necessarily expose injustices in our society. Furthermore, these injustices (to which we are currently blind) are probably enshrined in law, and are things we may even consider “good” and “virtuous.”</li><li><strong>The “seeds” to that more advanced morality are probably present today,</strong> but most people either don’t know about them, or believe they are foolish because they appear to contradict what we know about the world and humanity.</li></ol><p>This should concern us. Anyone who pursues truth should be asking themselves, “Am I like this? Do I have moral blind spots?”</p><p>And if we think we don’t… how do we know? The ancients didn’t know they were wrong. They felt completely justified in their positions.</p><h3>The Deceptively Simple Question No One Asks…</h3><p>And this brings us to the deceptively simple question no one asks: <em>What if my definitions of “right” and “wrong” are wrong?</em></p><p>How do we know that we haven’t we made the same mistake as our forefathers and mothers, just in different ways? Have we accepted incomplete definitions of right and wrong without realizing it? And has our culture blinded us to these failures in our moral code?</p><p>Do we support laws and policies that in fact violate human rights in a way we don’t currently understand?</p><p>Are there people who know better definitions, but we’ve ignored them because they seem too “abstract, arbitrary, and idealistic to work in the real world”?</p><p>In any given situation, many people ask, “What is the right thing to do?”</p><p>But very few ask, “How do I know this is the right thing to do? By what standard am I measuring my virtues? Where did my moral code originate? And why should I accept it?”</p><p>These are the questions a true student of social justice needs to ask. Otherwise, we may be no different than our ancestors.</p><p>If we want to make the world a better place, we need to make sure we’re not actively inhibiting our process with an incomplete moral code.</p><p><strong>The ancients saw themselves as justified in their exploitation of their fellow man.</strong> Their concept of justice validated their brutality. And their economy depended on their extortion.</p><p>If they had immediately accepted our morality, their economies would have collapsed. Food production would have halted. Construction of aqueducts, roads, and other infrastructure would have stopped. Their armies would have dissolved.</p><p>If we had asked them to abandon their human rights violations, they would have balked, saying such a transition would cause huge socio-economic upheaval, and leave many in dire conditions. Our ideas would have seemed too impractical, idealistic, and, ultimately, destructive.</p><p>Have we built structures and systems on immoral grounds as well? Their infrastructure, food production, and military defense were built on faulty moral codes. Are ours?</p><p>Does our way of life depend on human rights violations to which we are currently blind?</p><h3>Are We Advancing? Or Holding Ourselves Back?</h3><p>More importantly, are we willing to accept a more advanced moral code if it means we have to give up our current lifestyle and beliefs?</p><p>To really drive the point home, If we find that our healthcare is paid for immorally, will we adjust? Or will we irrationally defend our policies because we don’t want to transition to a more ethical, but less convenient system?</p><p>(I am not saying that our healthcare is paid for immorally. I’m just drawing a hypothetical situation to illustrate a point.)</p><p>To the ancients, using slave labor to grow their food and build their roads was far more convenient than paying their laborers. But that “convenience” depended on the extortion of other human beings.</p><p>At the end of the day, will we be like the rulers of old who refused to accept truth because it meant they’d have to give up their lifestyles? Or are we going to be better than our ancestors, and choose what <em>is</em> true over what we <em>want</em> to be true?</p><p>If we do not ask ourselves these questions, and more importantly answer them, how do we know if our definitions are correct? <strong>How do we know if our society is progressing, and not reverting?</strong></p><p>What if our own cultural programming has blinded us to our own failures?</p><p>And what if our laws, the very ones we believe are virtuous, are in fact empowering evil and increasing suffering in the world?</p><p>Fortunately, there are tools we can use to sift through our ideas. We don’t have to stay blind. We can learn to see through our cultural programming and separate truth from folly. We’ll discuss how in the next post.</p><h3>If Our Future Depends On What We Believe Today… Where Is Our Compass Taking Us?</h3><p>For now, I want to leave you with the following questions to ponder.</p><p>I have to warn you, critically answering these questions can be unsettling. It is never easy to have your worldview challenged.</p><p>This is only meant for the brave truth-seekers out there. If you want to know why you believe what you believe, you must answer them.</p><p>The only way we can advance as a species is by honestly evaluating our values. And we have to be willing to let go of our cherished beliefs if we find they they’re built on a faulty moral code.</p><ul><li>What modern laws might humans 1,000 years from now challenge? Why?</li><li>How do you define “good” and “bad,” “right” and “wrong”?</li><li>If you can’t define them clearly, at least describe activities you think are “good” and “bad,” then describe why those activities are good or bad. This will help you understand your own beliefs about morality.</li><li>How do know your definitions are correct? Where did you get them? Did you think through them yourself and arrive at your own conclusions? Or were they adopted in a cultural setting (like a church body, university campus, etc…)?</li><li>What makes something a “virtue”? By what standard does something become a virtue?</li></ul><p>Until next time, happy truth hunting.</p><figure><a href="https://codylibolt.typeform.com/to/KpfJSh"><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1018/1*xK8wc7XFOAmEchKJ124GkQ.png" /></a></figure><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="http://www.seanedwards.com/right-and-wrong/"><em>www.seanedwards.com</em></a><em> on January 16, 2017.<br></em><a href="https://christianintellectual.com/subscribe/">Click here to subscribe to <em>For the New Christian Intellectual.</em></a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c2d770ab5d61" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/christian-intellectual/what-if-your-definitions-of-right-and-wrong-are-wrong-c2d770ab5d61">What If Your Definitions of “Right” and “Wrong” Are Wrong?</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/christian-intellectual">For the New Christian Intellectual</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[What Is The Alt-Right, And What Does It Say About American Politics?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/christian-intellectual/what-is-the-alt-right-and-what-does-it-say-about-american-politics-ff1201d1e8a4?source=rss-78b049551229------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ff1201d1e8a4</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[racism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[alt-right]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Sean Edwards]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 20 Dec 2016 00:17:21 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-07-19T14:41:22.854Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*tWcEsHorCuOM2cmC." /></figure><blockquote>“The rise of the Alt-Right forces us to ask some poignant questions, if for no other reason than self-discovery.”</blockquote><p>Several years ago, I was flying home on a long flight with some friends, when I fired up the second Twilight movie to pass the time.</p><p>About halfway through, I took my headphones off, and with a “dead-in-the-eyes” look, I stared at my friend sitting next me.</p><p>He asked, “What?”</p><p>“This movie is terrible,” I replied.</p><p>He saw what I was watching, and while chuckling asked, “What did you expect?”</p><p>Opening my hands to speak, I said, “I have to believe there is something worth redeeming about this movie.”</p><p>He laughed and replied, “Sean, that’s why I love you. You have hope even when there is no hope.”</p><p>I’m sorry if you liked the Twilight movies. You’re allowed to. But I did not.</p><p>The movie had several issues (for me), but I couldn’t stand the female lead. Something about her bugged me.</p><p>When I got home, I watched a humorous YouTube critique of the movie.</p><p>The video described the female lead as a character who lacked any distinct personality. The critic argued this was done on purpose so the predominantly female audience could overlay their own personalities onto Bella. In this way, they could more easily insert themselves into the story.</p><p>And the critic was right! That was one of the things I did not like about the movie. It lacked character depth. The main characters didn’t have definitive personalities.</p><p>This phenomenon happens in other areas as well. It is easy for us to overlay our own ideas onto undefined concepts.</p><p>Take the Alt-Right for example.</p><h3>What Twilight and the Alt-Right Have In Common</h3><p>When the term “Alt-right” first started popping up, I didn’t know what it was. And I think very few people did.</p><p><strong>But some started throwing it around like a dirty word</strong> equating it with racism and bigotry.</p><p>In many ways, the term has become the “Bella” of the political world.</p><p>Since most didn’t know what the “Alt-Right” was, it was easy to overlay our own ideas (and dare I say prejudices?) onto the term.</p><p>Many people started calling the “Alt-Right” white-nationalists, and since we didn’t have anything to reference their claims against, it was easy to believe.</p><p>Then, when Trump announced that Bannon would be his Chief Strategist, the term exploded, and people really freaked out.</p><p>Based on the news coverage, I was very concerned as well.</p><p>However, I’ve learned over the years to take the media with a grain of salt.</p><p>Not because they’re malicious, but because reporters aren’t experts on every subject, and it is easy for them to get things wrong.</p><p>So, I decided to investigate the “Alt-Right,” and see for myself who this Bannon guy was.</p><p>Just a heads up, I am not an investigative journalist. I don’t know the trade.</p><p>So, my amateur study is probably incomplete. But, I believe it is thorough enough to start defining the “Alt-Right.”</p><h3>What Is The “Alt-Right”?</h3><p>The “Alt-Right” stands for Alternative Right.</p><p>Apparently, these are conservatives who feel like the conservatives in Washington D.C. have left them behind.</p><p>It’s hard to pin the Alt-Right down. They are a widely disparate group. It’s a big tent that holds a lot of people with a lot different ideas.</p><p>Some of them are white-nationalists, but not most of them.</p><p>According to Colin Grunwold, a self-proclaimed member of the Alt-Right, the movement is mostly defined by what they’re against, rather than what they are for.</p><p>So let’s start there, and put the big rocks in first.</p><p><strong>1. Those in the “Alt-Right” reject virtually every form of Marxism, socialism, or welfarism.</strong></p><p>A hallmark of leftist, progressive politics is an optimistic view of humanity and the world.</p><p>I personally love this about the left.</p><p>However, their optimistic outlook usually involves some form of socialism. In fact, socialism requires the belief that people are basically good and self-less (otherwise the philosophy cannot work).</p><p>The Alt-Right does not hold this view.</p><p>To quote Grunwold:</p><blockquote><em>“[Those considered “Alt-Right”] have an understanding that life is brutal, tribal, chaotic and difficult. It is not just a “fun ride”… We’ve all been taught that life is basically good and humans are all part of this egalitarian experiment called ‘The West’ which has ‘diversity’ as its greatest core value.”</em></blockquote><p>He goes on to say: “The base state of human behavior is essentially animalism not ‘peace and love.’ In the absence of capitalism and growth, sectarian and racial violence are the norm, not the aberration.”</p><p>They believe the nature of the world rejects some basic tenets of the left: mainly that everyday people are good and can be trusted.</p><p>To the Alt-Right, capitalism and limited government are the only ways to ensure peace among people.</p><p>They reject the idea that government can build a utopia, and don’t want other people’s values forced on them.</p><p>As a side note, I did not get the impression that the Alt-Right thinks the world is bad and that life is going to be hard no matter what.</p><p>They believe life can be amazing, they just don’t trust the government to make it happen.</p><p><strong>2. The Alt-Right is extremely anti-establishment.</strong></p><p>Most of those in the Alt-Right believe politicians are crooks, and that Congress has been purchased by big business and left-leaning media outlets.</p><p>They feel rejected by establishment republicans. They feel the GOP has accepted too many tenets of the left and no longer represent their interests.</p><p>To them, the GOP has given up too much ground on issues, and has thrown the Alt-Right under the bus to save face with the mainstream public.</p><p>Therefore, they resonated with Trump’s message to “drain the swamp.”</p><p><strong>3. They resist all forms of the Politically Correct culture.</strong></p><p>This is the big one.</p><p>According to many who identify as Alt-Right, they feel shutdown by the left. Instead of engaging with the Alt-Right about issues, they feel like the left has shamed and slandered them by calling them bigots.</p><p>Instead of being allowed a seat at the table, the Alt-Right feel like both the right and the left refuse to talk to them.</p><p>Instead, they’re written off as xenophobic racists. Their opinions don’t matter. Their voices don’t count.</p><p>Most people in the Alt-Right do not believe they are racist. And some of them are minorities themselves.</p><p>So, the accusation of racism not only makes them angry, it tells them the establishment has become disconnected from the people.</p><p>This is huge. People in the Alt-Right feel as though they’re being judged, convicted, and exiled before they’re allowed to speak.</p><p>They feel like they can’t ask certain questions without being ostracized by both the right and left.</p><p>For instance, the left holds diversity and cultural equality in high regard. If you question that, those in the Alt-Right feel that you’re often labeled a bigot.</p><p>People in the Alt-Right want to ask, “Why should we value cultural diversity so much? By what criteria have you determined that we should embrace and celebrate other cultures as highly — if not higher — than our own?” And they feel like they don’t get an answer, but an insult.</p><blockquote><em>People in the Alt-Right want to ask, “Why should we value cultural diversity so much? By what criteria have you determined that we should embrace and celebrate other cultures as highly — if not higher — than our own?” And they feel like they don’t get an answer, but an insult.</em></blockquote><p>However, it’s a valid question. If we value something, we should be able to say why.</p><p>Some people in the Alt-Right see their position as very similar the left. The only difference is whose culture we value.</p><p>According to some of those in the Alt-Right, the left appears to value other cultures by default, and without question.</p><p>This brings up 2 issues I’ve observed.</p><p>First, according to some in the Alt-Right, we are being forced to accept (and celebrate) other cultures without any proof that those cultures deserve acceptance or celebration.</p><p>They want to ask, “Why should I value this other culture? What about it makes it worth celebrating or adopting?”</p><p>But, the PC culture doesn’t allow those kinds of questions. If you question a culture’s value (and even more so if you reject it), you’re deemed a close-minded bigot.</p><p>Secondly, according to those in the Alt-Right, not only are we supposed to accept other cultures without question, but it appears to that the left wants us to value other cultures over American culture.</p><p>The Alt-Right perceives that the left feels embarrassed by American culture, and elevates other cultures as “better,” or more virtuous.</p><p>By contrast Alt-righters value American culture without shame. They love America, and they want to protect American culture, just as the left wants to protect other cultures.</p><p>Someone in the Alt-Right might think, “Okay, so you’re allowed to celebrate other cultures, but we can’t celebrate ours?”</p><p>Even though I don’t consider myself Alt-Right, I can appreciate these questions.</p><h3>5 Types of Alt-Right, As Described By An Alt-Righter</h3><p>Again, the Alt-Right doesn’t have official policy positions. They don’t have official values. And they don’t all agree. This is a grassroots movement.</p><p>However, the 3 elements above seem to run through most Alt-Right positions. But, there’s more to it than that.</p><p>Grunwold broke the Alt-Right into 5 groups. Obviously, you don’t have to fit into these categories to be Alt-Right.</p><p>1) Anarcho-Capitalists 2) Nationalists 3) Conspiracy theorists 4) Religious conservatives</p><p>5) “Race Realists” — The racists</p><p><strong>Anarcho-Capitalists:</strong> These individuals believe in unbridled capitalism and extremely decentralized government.</p><p>They aren’t necessarily anti-government (what most people assume “anarchy” means–it doesn’t). They tend to support highly localized, and sometimes overlapping and even competing municipalities.</p><p>It is an interesting political philosophy, but it isn’t racist. In fact, anarcho-capitalism assumes society operates based on peoples’ abilities, not their ethnicity. So you could argue that anarcho-capitalism is incompatible with systematic racism.</p><p><strong>Nationalists:</strong> Nationalists want to put their country–and their people–first. Period.</p><p>These individuals are not racists. When people hear “nationalist,” fascist images come to mind. But nationalism doesn’t have to be defined by ethnicity. Nationalism simply means prioritizing the interests your nation over the interests of others.</p><p>Bannon described himself as an “economic nationalist”:</p><blockquote><em>“I’m an economic nationalist. I am an America first guy,” Bannon said. “And I have admired nationalist movements throughout the world, and have said repeatedly strong nations make great neighbors. I’ve also said repeatedly that the ethno-nationalist movement, prominent in Europe, will change over time. I’ve never been a supporter of ethno-nationalism.”</em></blockquote><p>Ethno-nationalism is nationalism based on race, i.e., true, systematic racism.</p><p>Economic nationalists love America more than other countries. And they want to preserve American culture. They don’t care what color your skin is or what religion you are.</p><p>Even though nationalism and racism can be bed partners, nationalism in and of itself isn’t racist.</p><p>You may not be a nationalist, and you may not like nationalist policies, but you can’t call nationalists racists for being nationalistic.</p><p><strong>Conspiracy Theorists:</strong> I was surprised that Grunwold put this on the list.</p><p>I know many conspiracy theorist who are not Alt-Right. But these themes that can be present; they don’t have to be.</p><p>I think this is self-explanatory. They believe there is a conspiracy to keep the little guy down. But, there are people in every political party that believe that.</p><p><strong>Religious Conservatives:</strong> Grunwold didn’t give a detailed definition of this term, but I assume he refers to people who want to “restore Christian values.”</p><p>That’s a lot of people. Most of whom I would not consider Alt-Right.</p><p>However, if you’re a religious conservative who holds the above tenets, then you’d probably be very comfortable around those in the Alt-Right.</p><p><strong>Race Realists:</strong> According to Grunwold, this was the group Hillary and other pundits identified as the Alt-Right. These are the racists.</p><p>They believe that one race (usually white people) are genetically superior to other races. Meaning, people who are not white are incapable of accomplishing the things white people can.</p><p>They are less intelligent and morally inferior. Meaning they value “lesser” and sometimes evil things compared to the virtuous desires of white people (or whomever).</p><p>This is bad stuff.</p><p>Furthermore, my friend Cody Libolt (<a href="http://ifwewilllive.com/">IfWeWillLive.com</a>) pointed out the ugliness of the term “Race Realists.” It implies that that they are being realists concerning race, i.e., racism is real.</p><p>It also implies that the rest of us aren’t being “real” and are living in a daydream, where all the races can peacefully coexist.</p><p>This is tribal brutality at its worst. But according to Grunwold, the “race realists” are a tiny fraction of the Alt-Right.</p><p>Here’s a summary of the Alt-Right so far:</p><ul><li><strong>They strongly oppose</strong> any form of socialism or Marxism.</li><li><strong>They are strong nationalists.</strong> They believe America is the best, and don’t want other cultures forced upon them. They don’t care what color your skin is, and they don’t care if you bring your culture here, they just don’t want it forced on them.</li><li><strong>They oppose the PC culture</strong> of the left, and the “pandering” to the left by the right. They feel shutdown by politicians who’ve discredited them in the media through name calling.</li><li><strong>They feel abandoned</strong> by establishment republicans for not representing their interests (and sometimes throwing them under the bus to save political face).</li><li><strong>Some of them</strong> are white-nationalists (racists).</li></ul><h3>How Does Breitbart Fit Into All Of This?</h3><p>From what I can determine, Breitbart highly values the freedom of expression. If you post a racist comment, that represents you, not Breitbart. And they aren’t going to moderate it.</p><p>It is easy to see how people who felt censored through name-calling would flock to a site that didn’t censor them. Especially one that leans pretty far to the right.</p><p>You don’t have to spend very much time on Breitbart to tell it is very conservative. But after spending 30 minutes or so on the site, I can’t say its racist.</p><p>They had several favorable front page articles about minorities and women. One in particular examined solutions to the wage gap between minorities and white people.</p><p>I had to ask, “Would a racist news outlet have articles like that?” Maybe if they were trying to pull the wool over our eyes. But that seems unlikely.</p><p>Like I said, it is clearly conservative; I’m not saying it is a bastion of objectivity.</p><p>Breitbart made headlines when one of their executives called it “the platform of the Alt-Right.”</p><p>For people who believe the Alt-Right are white nationalists, Breitbart just become enemy #1.</p><p>Bannon, who used to be a part of Breitbart, has said many times he doesn’t support racism, and thinks it is terrible … but he believes in freedom of expression.</p><p>In this context, you could see why Breitbart become the platform for the Alt-Right. All the other news outlets rejected them.</p><p>And you can see why Alt-righters would camp around a site that didn’t ostracize them.</p><h3>Who are the Alt-Right according to Breitbart?</h3><p>When I was on Breitbart, I found an article called, <a href="http://www.breitbart.com/tech/2016/03/29/an-establishment-conservatives-guide-to-the-alt-right/">“An Establishment Conservative’s Guide to the Alt-Right,”</a> and I found it quite interesting.</p><p>Allum Bokhari &amp; Milo Yiannopoulos (the article’s authors) broke the Alt-Right into 4 groups.</p><p>These classifications are a little different than Grunwold’s, but they help fill in some of the gaps.</p><p><strong>The Intellectuals:</strong> These are thinkers who argue heady philosophical and sociological subjects.</p><p>They aren’t afraid to question some of our most cherished values. Many of them are more than willing to put modern democracy under a critical microscope.</p><p>They are encouraged to “strip away self-censorship” and explore ideas divorced from the divisive rhetoric of mainstream media.</p><p>Obviously, this is going to produce some ideas that don’t fit the norm of society.</p><p>And it is easy to vilify something we don’t understand.</p><p><strong>The Natural Conservatives:</strong> Many people consider these people racists. But, that’s not fair, and it depends on your definition of racism.</p><p>These people want to protect American culture.</p><p>Some of them want to limit how many other cultures can enter the country (by tightening immigration), but most simply don’t want other cultures forced upon them (and then being called a bigot for resisting).</p><p>Think of small town America. I am not calling small town America “Alt-Right,” but a small town can help us visualize the motivation behind natural conservatives.</p><p>If you grew up in a small town, you may resist a large influx of people who wanted to dramatically change the culture of your home.</p><p>You may even resist such movements.</p><p>But it wouldn’t have to be about race.</p><p>It could merely be about preserving your sense of “home.” You wouldn’t care if new people came, but you wouldn’t want your traditions and customs destroyed.</p><p>Many in the Alt-Right believe the left worships at the altar of tolerance, acceptance, and diversity.</p><p>The Alt-Right is mostly ambivalent toward the love of diversity. But they feel like those on the left are forcing their love of diversity on everyone.</p><p>To them, they’re being asked to sacrifice their traditions, culture, and values out of some sense of altruistic and unearned love for other cultures.</p><p>They feel like they’re being asked to love other cultures precisely because they are not our culture. As if the definition of a good culture is one that isn’t ours.</p><p>Then, they feel like you must agree with the left, otherwise you’re labeled a bigot. They feel like there isn’t any middle ground.</p><p>Natural conservatives are like the small town inhabitants who don’t want their town’s identity taken from them.</p><p>They don’t care if people from other cultures want to live here… or even import their culture into their own home. They just don’t want their culture destroyed in the process.</p><p>I personally like diversity, so I wouldn’t want to be in a homogeneous community like that. But I can understand why they value it.</p><p>So, the left values others’ cultures, and the natural conservatives value their own culture.</p><p>But it isn’t on ethnic grounds. It’s cultural. Are you American? Or are you trying to force your values on others under the guise of “tolerance”?</p><p>Natural conservatives say, “You’re more than welcome to come to our country, just please respect the values of our country.”</p><p>I should point out that some natural conservatives do border on racism, and some would call them racists.</p><p>These people want to specifically protect white culture. They don’t think less of other races and ethnicities (they don’t make value judgments based on skin color), they just want to be surrounded by white people because they’re more comfortable with that.</p><p>Again, you could call this racist, depending on your definition of racism.</p><p>But according to the New Oxford American Dictionary, racism is “prejudice, discrimination, or antagonism directed against someone of a different race based on the belief that one’s own race is superior.”</p><p>To call these people racist, you’d have to get at the root of why they want to live in predominately white areas. If they do so because they think the white race is superior, then they’d be racist.</p><p>But, if you grew up in a predominantly white area, a deluge of other languages and cultures might stress you out. You wouldn’t feel “at home.” Not because the people themselves are bad (you aren’t making a moral judgment about them), but because the environment is very foreign.</p><p>You can call these people many things (if you want…), but I’m not ready to call them racists.</p><p><strong>The Memers:</strong> These are predominantly young people who post extraordinarily insulting comments and memes on the internet.</p><p>Allum Bokhari &amp; Milo Yiannopoulos describe the memers as young people who mock the abuses of PC culture by intentionally using racist, sexist, and bigoted comments. They aren’t actually racist; they just hate the political atmosphere around racial issues.</p><p>The authors found individuals hurling derogatory terms at each other in one comment thread, and the same people showing genuine care for each other in other comment threads.</p><p>They say this: “Whenever such pressure arises in a society [self-censoring because of the PC culture], there will always be a young, rebellious contingent who feel a mischievous urge to blaspheme, break all the rules, and say the unsayable. Why? Because it’s funny!”</p><p>Later they say, “It’s hard to know for certain, but we suspect that unlike the core of the alt-right, these young renegades aren’t necessarily instinctive conservatives. Indeed, their irreverence, lack of respect of social norms, and willingness to stomp on other people’s feelings suggest they may actually be instinctive libertarians… [But] are they bigots? No more than death metal devotees in the 80s were actually Satanists.”</p><p><strong>And the “1488ers”:</strong> These are the “race realists” Grunwold described. These are the racists. But their numbers are quite small.</p><blockquote><em>“Anything associated as closely with racism and bigotry as the alternative right will inevitably attract real racists and bigots. Calmer members of the alternative right refer darkly to these people as the ‘1488ers.’ And for all their talk of there being ‘no enemies to the right,’ it’s clear from the many conversations we’ve had with alt-righters that many would rather the 1488ers didn’t exist.”</em></blockquote><p>Why are they called the 1488ers? It comes from the first 14 words of neo-nazi slogans: “We Must Secure The Existence Of Our People And A Future For White Children.”</p><p>Then, 88 comes from the 8th letter of the alphabet ‘H’, so 88 signifies HH or “Heil Hitler.”</p><p>Allum Bokhari &amp; Milo Yiannopoulos go on: “Not very edifying stuff. But if you want to use the 1488ers to tarnish the entire alt-right, you need to do the same with Islamist killers and Islam… Which you might well be fine with — but let’s be consistent.”</p><h3>What can we take away from all of this?</h3><p>The Alt-Right is a very complicated and diverse group of people.</p><p>They are loosely connected by their reaction to the left. They have strong nationalistic tendencies (albeit, not necessarily racist tendencies). They reject the GOP, deeming them fake conservatives. And they are generally anti-establishment.</p><p>The only members of this group who are racists are the “Race Realists” and/or the “1488rs.” And a bulk of the Alt-Right wishes they didn’t exist.</p><p>I am not Alt-Right, but after doing some reading, I can understand some of their positions.</p><p>I would challenge us to look at our own values. The rise of the Alt-Right forces us to ask some poignant questions, if for no other reason than self-discovery.</p><p>From my earliest memories, my public education taught me the virtues of diversity and tolerance (they also defined those terms for me, but that’s a different subject…).</p><p>Because of this education, I never questioned the value of diversity.</p><p>But if we’re going to be mature humans, we must ask ourselves why we believe what we believe.</p><p>During this study, I came up against a question I wasn’t comfortable asking: “Why should I value other cultures over my own?”</p><p>Something about it felt wrong.</p><p><em>During this study, I came up against a question I wasn’t comfortable asking: “Why should I value other cultures over my own?”</em></p><p>If I’m not alone in this feeling, then it says something about our culture.</p><p>Why don’t we feel comfortable asking questions like that?</p><p>What values have we accepted; what definitions of “right” and “wrong” have we established that makes us feel like asking these questions is wrong?</p><p>It also spawns other questions, like:</p><p>“What about other cultures makes them ‘better’ than ours (almost by default)?”</p><p>“Why can’t I be proud of American culture, and love it more than other cultures?”</p><p>And those in the Alt-Right might say, “Why can’t I ask these questions without being called a xenophobe?”</p><p>Researching this topic opened my eyes to a lot of perspectives I had not considered. And I hope you were able to benefit from them.</p><p>This study made me think about why I value what I value, and what I think of other people’s values.</p><p>And that is never a bad thing.</p><p>Now that we have an idea of what defines the Alt-Right, I think we can safely reject the notion that they are racist, and we don’t have to fear them either.</p><p>And now that we have this broad understanding, we can reference it against what we hear in the media.</p><p>No longer can the Alt-Right be the Bella of the political world (again, sorry Twilight fans…).</p><p>Thank you for reading.</p><p>— —</p><p>Here are the major resources I used for this article:</p><p><a href="http://www.breitbart.com/tech/2016/03/29/an-establishment-conservatives-guide-to-the-alt-right/">An Establishment Conservatives Guide to the Alt-Right</a>, Breitbart.com</p><p><a href="https://lfb.org/alt-right-rises-lefts-frankenstein-claps-back/">The Alt-Right Rises, Left’s Frankenstein Claps Back</a>, Laissez-Faire (lfb.org)</p><p><a href="http://www.usatoday.com/story/news/politics/onpolitics/2016/11/22/alt-right-trump-white-nationalist-clinton-breitbart-spencer/94273282/">9 Things You Need To Know About The Alt-Right Movement</a> , USAToday.com</p><figure><a href="https://codylibolt.typeform.com/to/KpfJSh"><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1018/1*xK8wc7XFOAmEchKJ124GkQ.png" /></a></figure><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="http://www.seanedwards.com/alt-right/"><em>www.seanedwards.com</em></a><em> on December 20, 2016.<br></em><a href="https://christianintellectual.com/subscribe/">Click here to subscribe to <em>For the New Christian Intellectual.</em></a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ff1201d1e8a4" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/christian-intellectual/what-is-the-alt-right-and-what-does-it-say-about-american-politics-ff1201d1e8a4">What Is The Alt-Right, And What Does It Say About American Politics?</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/christian-intellectual">For the New Christian Intellectual</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[What Getting Shellacked About Racism Taught Me About Politics]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/christian-intellectual/what-getting-shellacked-about-racism-taught-me-about-politics-c66ad9ef03a4?source=rss-78b049551229------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c66ad9ef03a4</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[communication]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[racism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[communication-skills]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[life-lessons]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Sean Edwards]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 07 Dec 2016 17:26:37 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-07-19T14:43:13.981Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*ibpBpAWIMnyoCiQB." /></figure><p>The day after the election, I wrote a small post about the results. It was simple. I didn’t think too much of it.</p><p>The next morning my blog had crashed because it couldn’t handle the traffic.</p><p>As of today, it has nearly 450 comments.</p><p>If you haven’t seen that article, I encourage you to check it out, apparently people like it: <a href="http://www.seanedwards.com/election-response/">“Why Your Reaction To The Election May Say More About You Than The Election Itself”</a></p><p>You could probably guess that racism came up a lot in the comments. And I quickly learned that my estimation of the situation was far too simple.</p><p>I stand by the basic points of my article, but I realized the issue is far more complex and nuanced than I originally thought.</p><p>Racism came up a lot, and I quickly learned that my estimation of the issues was far too simple. I stand by my the basic points of my article, but I realized the issue was far more complex and nuanced that I had thought.</p><p>I don’t believe I’m racist, but my perspective on racism has changed.</p><p>I began to see that I didn’t understand what it was like to be a minority in America.</p><p>I would hear people talk about racism, and I would think they were overblowing the issue, trying to politicize to advance their political agenda.</p><p>I don’t personally know a real racist. There might be racist pockets around the country, but for the most part, I thought we had moved beyond that issue.</p><p>But my perspective was about to change.</p><h3>You Don’t Have A Solution For A Problem<br> They Don’t Have</h3><p>There’s an old hotel in Spokane (where I live), and throughout there are pictures of the hotel in the 1910’s and 20’s. I’ve always enjoyed looking at those photos, because it was a connection to my past.</p><p>Recently, I noticed that there wasn’t a single person of color in any of those pictures. Now, to be fair, Spokane probably didn’t have too many people of color in 1910, but still…</p><p>I began to wonder… Were these people all racists? Maybe. Probably. That made me sad, and I felt like I couldn’t relate to them as much anymore.</p><p>And then I put myself in a black person’s shoes… would I find these photos as interesting? Probably not.</p><p>If none of the photos contained a single white person, I wouldn’t be able to connect as much. It wouldn’t feel like my history.</p><p>That made me more aware of how African Americans might feel today. Would they look at these pictures and see a bunch of people who looked down them? Would they wonder, “How many of you owned my ancestors?”</p><p>It was a wake-up call, but not just about racism, about a lot of things. What else was I blind to? What other issues had I drawn too simply? And what do I do about it?</p><p>Author and speaker Danny Silk has a saying, <strong>“You don’t have a solution for problem they don’t have.”</strong></p><p>Meaning, if someone (like me) doesn’t think racism is a real issue, then your proposed solutions will mean nothing to me.</p><p>If someone doesn’t think racism is a real issue, then your proposed solutions will mean nothing to them.</p><p>So, how do we change this? Again, I turn to my own experience. Lower your defenses, and listen to people with different opinions.</p><h3>Opening Someone’s Eyes Takes Patience, Respect, and Emotional Maturity</h3><p>It is easy to get upset when someone starts talking about hot button issues.</p><p>As soon as someone brings up border control, instead of listening to see if they have anything new to say, we can immediately put a bunch of ideas, concepts, and positions onto that person.</p><p>And then we feel like we need to fight this imaginary person we’ve constructed, because they’re what’s wrong with the country.</p><p>Why do we do this?</p><p>I believe it’s because we subconsciously wrap our identity into our ideas.</p><p>When someone says that X is a bad idea, that implies that anyone who believes X is, at best, a stupid person who likes bad ideas, and at worst, a bad person who likes bad ideas.</p><p>Humans are fickle creatures. We have a deep need to protect our sense of self. And it is easy to tie your political beliefs to your sense of self-worth.</p><p>Your ideas what you believe represent who you are and what you value. They are integrally linked to your sense of self.</p><p>How many times have you gotten into a heated argument with a friend or loved one over something <em>really</em> stupid?</p><p>Not just politics, but anything. For instance, which is better, Ford or GMC? Apple or Android?</p><p>We can feel this need to be right, so we fight for our position, sometimes abandoning logic to do so. Why? Because we feel like our value as a person is under attack.</p><h3>The Link Between Football and Racism</h3><p>This happens with football teams all the time. Why do fans get depressed when their team loses? <em>We</em> had <em>nothing</em> to do with their performance, but we still feel like <em>we </em>lost.</p><p>When I asked myself this question, I realized it was because I had tied my ability to pick a good team to my sense of value. And when they lost, my self-esteem took a hit.</p><p>It felt like a failure because I picked the wrong team. My ability to choose the right team reflected poorly on my judgment, which affected my sense of self-worth.</p><p>Mind you, this was all subconscious until I started asking these questions. I didn’t walk around saying, “I’m a failure because I picked the wrong team.”</p><p>I felt slightly depressed, not as excited about the day, and people might annoy me more than usual. But deep down, something else was happening.</p><p>And until we’re willing to step back and analyze ourselves, we’ll stay stuck on these subconscious loops.</p><h3>Keys To Changing The World This Holiday Season</h3><p>This has 2 practical applications:</p><p><strong>1) When discussing politics</strong> with your family this holiday season, stand-down from DEFCON 1.</p><p>You won’t do any good if you allow yourself to get angry. You must divorce your ability to choose a good political position from your sense of self-worth. Then you must listen.</p><p>You have to say to yourself, “If I’m wrong about these ideas, it doesn’t reflect poorly my ability to think, nor does it affect my value as person. In fact, my inability to listen to new ideas (and thus allow my emotions to blind me) is what reflects poorly on my person.”</p><p>When your Trump-supporting father-in-law starts talking about immigration… listen.</p><p>Divorce his statements from any preconceived notions you have about Trump supporters, and see if he has anything of value to say.</p><p>Is he right about anything? Is there some truth in what he is saying? Analyze those ideas on their own (apart from any other political issue), and then see how they affect yours.</p><p>Not only might you learn something… and not only will you be happier (emotionally)… but once your Trump-supporting family members feel heard (and not condemned for their ideas), they will be more willing to hear other ideas as well.</p><p><strong>2) When sharing your ideas,</strong> only share your ideas… don’t launch cruise missiles.</p><p>This is simple: Criticize ideas, not people.</p><p>People won’t listen to you if you’re firing cruise-missiles at them.</p><p>When your super liberal sister starts talking about the electoral college, things will go VERY poorly if your language implies that she’s stupid for holding that position.</p><p><strong>Example A:</strong></p><p>Liberal Sister: “The electoral college is outdated, has racist roots, and violates the will of the people.”</p><p>Cruise-Missile You: “That’s ridiculous, then California, Texas, Florida, and a handful of other states would decide the president. Is that what you want? That isn’t democracy. Stop crying about the election results. We had to handle 8 years of Obama. You can handle Trump.”</p><p>Nuclear war occurs while your mother prepares dinner.</p><p>There are no survivors.</p><p>You may have had some good points (and you may feel better), but they won’t listen because you did more than just attack their ideas; you called them stupid, anti-democratic, and a cry-baby.</p><p>Now, would you listen to <em>anything</em> someone had to say if they made those claims about you?</p><p>By belittling your position, would you think they have anything constructive to add to your ideas?</p><p>Probably not. So, maybe don’t do that?</p><p><strong>Example B:</strong></p><p>Liberal Sister: “The electoral college is outdated, racist, and violates the will of the people.”</p><p>Mature-You: “I have some thoughts on the electoral college, but I’m going to be honest, I don’t know much about its history. Can you explain more about that?”</p><p>You must be sincere. You must want to learn (see Step 1). People can detect insincerity from a mile away.</p><p>This also doesn’t mean you’re giving up your position. It just means you’re listening for the time being. The example continues….</p><p>[Liberal Sister explains her position]</p><p>Mature-You: “I didn’t know that. Well, maybe we do need to take a second look at the Electoral College. But if we did away with it, how would you address the concerns of the less populated states? How could we make sure they didn’t feel disenfranchised, as if their vote wouldn’t matter?”</p><p>And, a nice discussion will occur. Some heated emotions may still rise, but if you maintain this demeanor, things will go well for you.</p><p>Neither of you may change your position. But you averted nuclear war, and at the very least, you learned something (most likely).</p><p>You’ve also demonstrated to your sister that not everyone on the other side is crazy.</p><h3>Where To Go From Here</h3><p>Racism is real a problem in this country, but it won’t go anywhere until more people accept that reality.</p><p><strong>My perspective on this issue did not change</strong> from name calling and insults.</p><p>It did not come from people yelling at me.</p><p>It did not come from people calling me a racist.</p><p>It did not come from incendiary twitter comments.</p><p>It did not come from grand generalizations about white people and white privilege.</p><p><strong>It came from people who</strong> <em>challenged my thinking in a respectful way.</em></p><p>We cannot legislate away racism. Racism must be dealt with on the cultural and personal levels.</p><p>The only way to do that is by talking to each other.</p><p>This is how we change our nation. This is how we grow as people.</p><figure><a href="https://codylibolt.typeform.com/to/KpfJSh"><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1018/1*xK8wc7XFOAmEchKJ124GkQ.png" /></a></figure><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="http://www.seanedwards.com/shellacked-politics/"><em>www.seanedwards.com</em></a><em> on December 7, 2016.<br></em><a href="https://christianintellectual.com/subscribe/">Click here to subscribe to <em>For the New Christian Intellectual.</em></a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c66ad9ef03a4" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/christian-intellectual/what-getting-shellacked-about-racism-taught-me-about-politics-c66ad9ef03a4">What Getting Shellacked About Racism Taught Me About Politics</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/christian-intellectual">For the New Christian Intellectual</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Road to Healing: How to Recover from One Hell of an Election]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/christian-intellectual/the-road-to-healing-how-to-recover-from-one-hell-of-an-election-e809ca66f281?source=rss-78b049551229------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e809ca66f281</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[bernie-sanders]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[elections]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Sean Edwards]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 29 Nov 2016 19:12:21 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-07-19T14:43:58.983Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>It’s been a few weeks since Election 2016, but most people are still reeling from the results.</p><p>For many, it still isn’t any easier to accept them. It still hurts. It still feels like half the country hates them. And people feel deeply betrayed.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*hVxD1lIcfVVKhHY6." /></figure><p>How can we ever recover from this? Is it even possible?</p><p>Yes, and we can do it by believing in each other again.</p><h3>Words Have Power, Be Careful How You Use Them</h3><p>First we need to look at the roles of the DNC, RNC, and their media conglomerate allies.</p><p>Every election sees its share of slander. But this election takes the gold. I have never seen so many video clips and sound bites taken out of context at one time.</p><p>I haven’t seen CNN and Fox be so obvious with their biases.</p><p>And I haven’t seen people as upset as they are now.</p><p>What happened? Every election someone loses, and their supporters feel a sense of loss. That is normal.</p><p>But this election was different. It was far more intense.</p><p>Basically, the respective campaign machines, and their media allies, convinced us that the “other side” was the enemy.</p><ul><li><strong>They are bad people…</strong></li><li>They want to take away your rights…</li><li><strong>They want to take away your guns…</strong></li><li>They want to deport you…</li><li><strong>They are everything that is wrong with this country…</strong></li></ul><p><strong>At the root of it all:</strong> <em>You can’t trust your fellow Americans</em>. Your neighbors hate you. The only people you can trust are the people who vote like you. Otherwise, you’ve partnered with racism, bigotry, tyranny, and pure evil.</p><p>Both sides drove messages of fear down our throats about what might happen if the other person won.</p><p>They convinced us that the other side’s candidate, and their supporters, represented everything wrong with this country… a<em>nd we believed them.</em></p><blockquote><em>They convinced us that the other side’s candidate, and their supporters, represented everything wrong with this country… </em>and we believed them.</blockquote><p>We allowed our political parties to label half the country as “bad people”… and we accepted it.</p><h3>If We Don’t Change This, Elections Are Going To Get Worse</h3><p>What did we think was going to happen when both sides effectively convinced their followers that the other candidate, and their followers, were evil?</p><p>If I truly believed that Hillary was a murdering elitist, bent on nothing but her own gain, then it would be my DUTY to fight back.</p><p>If I swallow the party line–hook, line, and sinker–then I must come to one conclusion: <em>The other side wants me in chains and to plunder my bank account.</em></p><p>It doesn’t matter which side I’m on, both sides are telling me this.</p><p>If I truly believed the stuff being said about the “other candidate,” then I would have to fight back. And I couldn’t be civil with their supporters.</p><p>Don’t be surprised when people feel betrayed after the democratic party spent 6 months screaming about how terrible Trump was, but now says we need to “calm down” and “give him a chance.”</p><p><em>People feel betrayed after the democratic party spent 6 months screaming about how terrible Trump was, but now says we need to “calm down” and “give him a chance.”</em></p><p>What?? Weren’t you just saying how TERRIBLE he’d be for the country? And weren’t you trying to convince me that our human rights could be violated if he won? Then how can you tell me to “calm down” and “give him a chance”???</p><p>Were you telling the truth? Or were you just saying whatever you thought would get your candidate elected?</p><h3>The Post-Election Protests Reveal The True Integrity of Americans</h3><p><strong>If I were a Hillary supporter</strong>, my morals would require me to fight Trump and his followers… maybe even to violence.</p><p>Why? Because I believe his presidency may usher in the fourth reich… because that’s what my party told me.</p><p><strong>If I were a Trump supporter</strong>, my principles would require me to fight Hillary and her followers… maybe even to violence.</p><p>Why? Because I believe she wants to establish a socialist police state straight out of 1984… because that’s why my party told me.</p><p>If I buy the party-lines, I MUST protest. If I don’t, I’m a hypocrite.</p><p>Integrity doesn’t mean you do good things. Integrity means that you are consistent with yourself. If you believe A, then you’ll perform actions that support A. If you believe A, but you do B, then you are a hypocrite and lack integrity.</p><p>All the violence and chaos during (and after) the election show us two things: 1) Many Americans swallowed their party’s kool aide, and 2) Most Americans have high levels of integrity.</p><p>If I were a Hillary supporter who believed my party, and I didn’t protest Trump’s election, I would be a hypocrite. Why? Because I would believe A (that Trump could be the next Hitler), but I do B (nothing).</p><p><strong>The protests and anger after the election show us that Americans have spine and integrity (go America!).</strong></p><p>The real problem comes down to 2 things: 1) People lied, and 2) we believed them.</p><h3>What Do Your Actions Say About Your Values?</h3><p>However, none of this would have happened if we all had done one thing: Given each other the benefit of the doubt.</p><p>I know this is crazy, but what if we believed in people again? Instead of assuming the worst in people, how about we assume the best in people (until they prove us wrong)?</p><p>If we all respected each other, and recognized that we all want what’s best for the country (we just disagree on how to do it), how different would this election have looked?</p><p><strong>Instead of trying to beat the other side down</strong> with slander, half-truths, and out-right lies, we’d try to talk with them. We’d try to have real conversations about issues.</p><p><strong>Instead of hurling insults, we’d ask questions</strong>… because we wouldn’t understand how a smart, good human being could hold a contrary view point.</p><p>We’d have to say things like, “That idea seems absurd, but these people seem to like it. Why are these smart people, who want good things for all Americans, supporting this idea? There must be something I don’t understand about their position. Or there must be something they don’t understand about mine. Or a little of both. But I should talk to them none-the-less.”<br> Can you imagine how different our political culture would be if we adopted this mindset?</p><p>In my life, I have adopted a core value that says, “All people (including their motives) are innocent until proven guilty.” I have chosen to believe that people are good until I have proof they are not. That’s what core values are. They are values that you’ve established in your life, either intentionally or unintentionally, that make decisions for you.</p><p>This core value makes decisions for me (especially when I need to be reminded of it). If I don’t have proof that Hillary is a liar (and I just think she is), then I must make decisions assuming she tells the truth (despite how I feel).</p><p>This isn’t easy at first. You have to stop yourself mid-thought and correct your thinking. But, once you do it for a while, it begins to be second nature, and you begin to think the best of people by default.</p><p>Instead of getting mad at someone for something they said or did, you start thinking of ways you might have misinterpreted them. And you become a happier person, because suddenly the world looks a lot different.</p><p>That’s how we heal. That’s how we rebuild. And that’s how we make American great again.</p><figure><a href="https://codylibolt.typeform.com/to/KpfJSh"><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1018/1*xK8wc7XFOAmEchKJ124GkQ.png" /></a></figure><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="http://www.seanedwards.com/election-recovery/"><em>www.seanedwards.com</em></a><em> on November 29, 2016.<br></em><a href="https://christianintellectual.com/subscribe/">Click here to subscribe to <em>For the New Christian Intellectual.</em></a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e809ca66f281" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/christian-intellectual/the-road-to-healing-how-to-recover-from-one-hell-of-an-election-e809ca66f281">The Road to Healing: How to Recover from One Hell of an Election</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/christian-intellectual">For the New Christian Intellectual</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[How Access To More Information Is Making Us Less Tolerant]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/christian-intellectual/how-access-to-more-information-is-making-us-less-tolerant-74f664bdd123?source=rss-78b049551229------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/74f664bdd123</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ideas]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[internet]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[tolerance]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Sean Edwards]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 21 Nov 2016 17:54:10 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-07-19T14:44:32.413Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*0ObVaSOgn-drRIqvj0EWDQ.png" /></figure><p><strong>The internet is making us more tolerant right?</strong></p><p>For the first time in history we have access to news from all over the world.</p><p>In days gone by, we were limited to our local news outlet. And sometimes, those didn’t even exist.</p><p>But today, we have access to anything and everything. We should be getting smarter, more complete pictures of world events, right?</p><p><strong>In some ways, yes. But in others</strong>, we’re really only building our own “echo chambers.”</p><p>Now we can cherry pick which news outlets we listen to. We can choose which blogs we read. And we choose who’s comments we see in a Facebook News Feed.</p><p>This distorts how we see the world. Our worldview can seem dominate, while other opinions appear to be less widespread.</p><p>Individuals who disagree with us appear to be on the fringe of society… but our view of society has been distorted.</p><p><em>Those individuals are merely on the fringe of our perception of reality.</em></p><p>This isn’t malicious. People are not doing this on purpose. But it is REALLY easy to do.</p><h3>How We Create Our Own Reality Distortion Fields</h3><p>Let’s say you’re a conservative Christian. You probably don’t watch a lot of CNN or MSNBC because those news agencies fare fairly biased to the left. That doesn’t jive with your worldview, so you probably gravitate towards Fox or the Wall Street Journal.</p><p>And then, most of your friends will probably share your values. They are probably a similar demographic and are part of a similar socio-economic circle. And they will post things that re-affirm your values.</p><p>So, what you see very day is a bunch of people who agree with you, and you listen to news that leans in your direction.</p><p>Do you see how little, innocuous choices we make every day can lead us to surround ourselves with our own opinions without us realizing it?</p><p><em>Little, innocuous choices we make every day can lead us to surround ourselves with our own opinions without realizing it.</em></p><p>The same thing happens on the left, except in reverse.</p><p>You probably avoid Fox News and watch MSNBC. You read the New York Times over the Wall Street Journal. And a lot of your friends probably share your same opinions.</p><p>This is dangerous, however. <strong>Because it is easy to jump from your own echo chamber to prejudice.</strong></p><p>If you are surrounded by people who believe the same thing as you, you will subconsciously assume that your opinion is in the majority (or is at least a large group). But your perspective could be WAY off (without you realizing it).</p><p>So, you think your worldview is “normal,” and when you hear a different worldview they are automatically “not normal.”</p><p>If all I’m hearing is that Bernie Sanders wants to destroy corruption, and Trump hates minorities, then I’m going to start believing this as “normal.” And when I encounter a Trump supporter, I’m going to put them into the “not normal” camp. And I’m going to assume they also hate minorities.</p><p>To you, there is no other option. All the facts prove it (that you’ve seen).</p><p>But you’ve merely created your own echo chamber and you aren’t seeing reality.</p><p>This can cause us to judge people unfairly.</p><h3>How To Break The Echo Chamber In Your Life</h3><p>To move forward, we need to realize that smart people can disagree with us. And we need to recognize that our view of reality may not be accurate.</p><p>Most people, or at least most smart people may not think like us, nor may they share our opinions. And assuming otherwise it dangerous.</p><p>If someone holds a different opinion (one we think is a minority position), we need to take a step back and see if we’re reacting to reality, or our own perception of reality.</p><p>Reality distortion fields are real. They are easy to make. And they make it easy to judge other people who hold a different opinion.</p><p>If we want our republic to last, we need to learn to see beyond our own perspective.</p><p>I challenge you to do this: The next time you get mad a comment someone makes about politics, set aside your offense for a moment, and temporarily adopt that person’s worldview and values. You don’t have to keep them. You can always pick yours back up at any moment.</p><p>Look at the issue through their eyes. Try to understand why they believe what they believe. Think the issue from that perspective. And, please, assume people are good until you know for a fact that they aren’t.</p><p>If someone holds a different opinion from you, assume they have good intentions until you can prove they don’t. It is never helpful to enter a conversation assuming someone is a liar, malicious, or ignorant.</p><p>There’s an Emerson quote I love, and often need reminding of: “In my walks, every man [or woman] I meet is my superior in some way, and in that I learn from him [or her].”</p><blockquote><em>“In my walks, every man [or woman] I meet is my superior in some way, and in that I learn from him [or her].”</em></blockquote><p>This is how we make America great again.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1018/1*xK8wc7XFOAmEchKJ124GkQ.png" /></figure><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="http://www.seanedwards.com/reality-distortion-field/"><em>www.seanedwards.com</em></a><em> on November 21, 2016.<br></em><a href="https://christianintellectual.com/subscribe/">Click here to subscribe to <em>For the New Christian Intellectual.</em></a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=74f664bdd123" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/christian-intellectual/how-access-to-more-information-is-making-us-less-tolerant-74f664bdd123">How Access To More Information Is Making Us Less Tolerant</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/christian-intellectual">For the New Christian Intellectual</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Healthy And Productive Way To Deal With Post-Election Anxiety]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/christian-intellectual/the-healthy-and-productive-way-to-deal-with-post-election-anxiety-ea567d4cf054?source=rss-78b049551229------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ea567d4cf054</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[government]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[elections]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Sean Edwards]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 16 Nov 2016 19:24:56 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-07-19T14:45:01.151Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*FckbAj662mEU3E5w." /></figure><p><em>The response to my last post was off the hook! Thank you for commenting a contributing. I learned a lot, and really enjoyed engaging with everyone.</em></p><p>After chatting with a bunch of people, I wanted to post a follow-up article about how to deal with post-election anxiety.</p><p><strong>Because a lot of people are having post-election anxiety.</strong></p><p>I touched on this in <a href="http://www.seanedwards.com/election-response/">“Why Your Reaction To The Election May Say More About You Than The Election Itself,”</a> but I really want to hit the nail on the head.</p><p>If you are having fear or anxiety about the election, I would invite you to take a second look at <em>why you’re anxious.</em></p><p>All feelings and emotions are rooted in some thought or idea. Emotions do not float around, disconnected from your mind. You thought about something, made a conclusion about, and now those conclusions are pressing the “panic” button.</p><p>You may not be conscious of these thoughts, but you still have them.</p><p>I want to suggest that your anxiety over the election may not be about the election itself, <em>but what you believe the election represented.</em></p><p>And once we look at that belief, I think you’ll find it illuminating, freeing, and empowering.</p><h3>You’re Anxious About Something, But Its Not What You Think</h3><p>I would like to invite us all (no matter who you voted for) to reflect on this quote:</p><blockquote><em>Is there a greater tragedy imaginable than that, in our endeavor to consciously shape our future in accordance with high ideals, we should in fact have unwittingly produced the very opposite of what we have been striving for?</em></blockquote><p>– Friedrich Hayek, <em>The Road to Serfdom.</em></p><p>Is it possible that our desire to change the world for the better actually put us in the position to FEAR an election out-come?</p><p>Love him, or hate him, Trump is our next president. And that has some people really scared. Genuinely scared.</p><p>Therefore, I feel compelled to ask a very pointed question: <strong>What kind of government do we want? Or, what kind of world do we want?</strong></p><p>Over the last 100 years, we have worked hard to improve the living conditions for all Americans.</p><p>The introduction of programs like Social Security, Medicare, and other programs like them have all attempted to build a better tomorrow.</p><p>However, by tasking the government with these jobs, have we created the very thing we now fear?</p><h3>How Did We Get Here???</h3><p>Let me illustrate, and let’s use socialized healthcare as an example.</p><p>When we task the government to give healthcare to all individuals, we run into some inherent logistic problems. Mainly, congress can’t agree on every detail.</p><p>Even if everyone in the House of Representatives wanted to create a universal healthcare system, you have 435 individuals with different ideas on how this universal healthcare system should work.</p><p>Socialized healthcare is VERY complicated. Suddenly the government has to write THOUSANDS of new regulations and design the entire system. Yeah right!</p><p>Inevitably, a group as big as the House will come to a grid-lock because they can’t arrive at a consensus.</p><p>So, we establish a committee to do all the hard work, and then submit the results to Congress for approval.</p><p>(We do this all the time. Remember the sequester budget cuts a few years back? That’s an example of it NOT working…)</p><p>What is a government to do? The people have said, “We want socialized healthcare,” but the government can’t come to an agreement on how to do it.</p><p>Instead of trying to pass every piece of the system at once, they pass a law that sets up government agency to design the system and hammer out the details. Think of the EPA, FCC, or the Federal Reserve.</p><p>But congress can’t stop there. Because what if this new “socialized healthcare” agency spends 2 years making their plans, then submits it to a new congress, just to have it shot it down?</p><p>Or worse yet, what if a new congress decides to hold people’s healthcare access hostage to get what they want on another issue?</p><p>No, “we need to keep politics out of healthcare.”</p><p>To “keep politics out of healthcare,” congress decides that this new agency doesn’t need to get to congressional approval in the future, as long as they follow some very broad rules (because that’s all they could agree on).</p><p>Congress preemptively authorize their actions. But, this agency’s actions won’t be called laws; they’ll be called regulations (sounding familiar?).</p><p>This is the way complicated items get through the congress.</p><p>Here’s what we’ve done. We’ve aggregated more and more power into the hands of fewer and fewer people. And we’ve gotten to the point that these people no longer require congressional approval to enact their policies.</p><p>Think this goes too far and over simplifies things?</p><ul><li><strong>The Federal Reserve</strong> doesn’t require congressional approval to print more money.</li><li><strong>The EPA doesn’t need</strong> congressional approval for its “regulations.”</li><li><strong>The FCC can</strong> just make decisions about the Internet without any voter oversight.</li></ul><p>And those are just the cases I can think of off the top of my head.</p><p>Sometimes, the President has to approve or block their activity, but that’s not democratic. That’s quasi-dictatorial.</p><p>And many times, the President gets to appoint the leaders of these agencies.</p><p>This is the point: Our desire to make the world a better place (through the government) has created a more powerful government, and put a greater amount of power into the hands of fewer people. And in some cases, solely into the hands of the President.</p><p>Elections then become a choice between the liberal quasi-dictator or the conservative quasi-dictator. This is where we are now.</p><p>But, if we continue with this trend… a real dictator will rise.</p><h3>If We Do Nothing, It Will Only Get Worse</h3><p>If we continue to task the government with things it can’t (or shouldn’t) handle, and it keeps aggregating power into the hands of fewer and fewer people, we will get a dictator.</p><p>We’re not there yet, but we’re getting closer.</p><p>Let’s put ourselves into those shoes.</p><p>We’ve voted and said, “We want free healthcare for all. We want free education for all. And we want equal opportunity for all.”</p><p>But the government continually fails to deliver on its promises (sound familiar?), and the people become disillusioned (also sound familiar?).</p><p>We (the people) lose trust in our government because it can’t seem to do what it’s supposed to. We begin to think the government is broken (even though we were the ones that broke it).</p><p>New candidates arise promising to “drain the swamp,” or “fix Washington.”</p><p>What are they trying to fix? A grid-locked government… that we grid-locked.</p><p><em>New candidates promise to “fix Washington.” What are they fixing? The gridlock… that we, the people, created.</em></p><p>Then, lets say an economic downturn happens. Not only has the government failed to its job, but now we are losing our jobs.</p><p>We get afraid and angry, thinking, “The president/congress/whomever said they would fix this. And they haven’t. In fact, things are worse. We need to empty congress and get people who will bring real change. <strong>Enough of the status-quo</strong>.”</p><p>But at this point, the only person who can break the gridlock is the very person you don’t want to be president.</p><p>Instead of realizing how our votes created the problem, we demand leaders who can actually “get things done.”</p><p>We eventually arrive at a scenario where the people are irate, the government is at a stand-still (because no one is willing to make the hard calls),<strong><em> and a voice of hope emerges…</em></strong></p><p>This voice promises they can fix the problem. They promise they can make the hard calls. They promise they can get the government back on track.</p><p>And they can.</p><p>Why? Because they’re morally questionable enough to do things others are unwilling to do.</p><p>They use the public unrest to pull more and more power into their hands. They are willing to jump over obstacles and remove legal hurdles to accomplish the mission.</p><p>They push against the limits of their power… because they don’t respect that power. And the people, in essence, have asked them to override it.</p><p>It goes like this:</p><p><strong>The People:</strong> “Fix the problem!”</p><p><strong>The President:</strong> “I can’t without breaking the law.”</p><p><strong>The People</strong>: “Fix the problem!”</p><p><strong>The President:</strong> “If you say so…”</p><p>Okay, maybe it doesn’t go quite like that, but you get the point.</p><p>If we voted for a socialized healthcare system, and the government couldn’t produce one, how would we respond if the president just wrote an executive order that outlined how it would work?</p><p>Legally, he can’t do that. But given the right economic situation, even the people of the United States could be okay with this.</p><p>And then, before you know it, the Jews end up in concentration camps.</p><p>Why? Because the very person who had the skill set to accomplish the job is the very person you don’t want in the oval office.</p><p>They a populist, and a populist generally has no qualms breaking the law to make the people happy… and centralize more power into their hands (but that’s just a side benefit…).</p><p>How did we get here? How did this happen?</p><p>Well… we got what we wanted: <em>A government powerful enough to do what we’ve asked it to do.</em></p><h3>The Road to Good Intentions Is Paved With Hell</h3><p>Hillary supporters are crushed and terrified that Trump has become president.</p><p>Why? Because they fear his power. Because the Office of the Presidency is more powerful than ever, the president has real power to cause real change… Or real tragedies.</p><p>So, Trump opponents are terrified of what Trump will do with that power. And it makes them anxious.</p><p>But would we be okay with Hillary having that kind of power?</p><p>If we want the government to be powerful enough to solve social ills (or “protect” conservative values…), then we have to accept one truth: <strong>We want a quasi-dictator, as long as we agree with them.</strong></p><p>That is not a judgment. I am not trying to condemn anyone. I am merely revealing a fatal flaw in our thinking.</p><p>If you fear a Trump presidency, I ask you to think about why.</p><p>Do you want a government powerful enough that you <em>have to truly fear the other candidate winning?</em></p><blockquote><em>Do you want a government powerful enough that you have to truly fear the other candidate winning?</em></blockquote><p>If you feared a Hillary presidency, I ask you the same question. Are you okay with one person having that much power?</p><p>Republicans and Democrats are both guilty of this. I’ve railed on socialized healthcare in this post because it’s an easy example.</p><p>But republicans have done the same thing, and I’m 99% sure we’ll see them do it again early next year.</p><p>And you can bet I’ll point it out 🙂</p><h3>How To Restore Hope and Trust In Our Government</h3><p>The solution to this problem as an obvious answer: Limit the power of the president so they don’t have as much power.</p><p>Unfortunately, our Constitution already does this, and our Congress and Supreme Court have pretty much allowed the president to become a quasi-dictator.</p><p>So, the real answer is that we need to re-learn what it means to American. Most people don’t understand how our government is supposed to work, and therefore, they don’t realize how it has gone off track.</p><p><strong>But, some of these ideas may leave you skeptical…</strong></p><p>Or you may think my arguments too simplistic.</p><p>That’s fair. I can’t formulate a complete treatise on the purpose of government in a single post.</p><p>I would, however, invite you to better understand my position. You don’t have to adopt it, but you can certainly examine it.</p><p>You can do that by reading my short book on American politics, called <em>American Resurrection: The Failure of the U.S. Constitution and the Rebirth of a Nation</em>.</p><p>Its short and easy to read. You can get it on <a href="https://www.amazon.com/American-Resurrection-Failure-Constitution-Rebirth/dp/0985771542/">Amazon.com</a>, or you can download a <a href="http://www.seanedwards.com/monster/#">free PDF version of it here</a>.</p><p>But even if you don’t check it out, I still want to hear your thoughts.</p><p>Should the president be as powerful as they are today? Would that even solve “Trump anxiety”?</p><p>I’ve really enjoy engaging with your ideas and perspectives in the comments. So comment away.</p><figure><a href="https://codylibolt.typeform.com/to/KpfJSh"><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1018/1*xK8wc7XFOAmEchKJ124GkQ.png" /></a></figure><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="http://www.seanedwards.com/monster/"><em>www.seanedwards.com</em></a><em> on November 16, 2016.<br></em><a href="https://christianintellectual.com/subscribe/">Click here to subscribe to <em>For the New Christian Intellectual.</em></a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ea567d4cf054" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/christian-intellectual/the-healthy-and-productive-way-to-deal-with-post-election-anxiety-ea567d4cf054">The Healthy And Productive Way To Deal With Post-Election Anxiety</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/christian-intellectual">For the New Christian Intellectual</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Why Our Reaction To The Election Says More About Us Than The Election]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/christian-intellectual/why-our-reaction-to-the-election-says-more-about-us-than-the-election-57c94eba35e4?source=rss-78b049551229------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/57c94eba35e4</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[hope]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[life-lessons]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[2016-election]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Sean Edwards]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 09 Nov 2016 20:53:50 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-07-19T14:45:37.488Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*2bRmcY3WMUm5K_pR." /></figure><p>This election night was a roller coaster ride for many. I think we can all agree with that.</p><p>I spent the evening in a hotel lobby with some good friends while on a business trip watching the results come in.</p><p>And as the night went on, and it became more and more apparent that Trump was going to win, we saw more and more people crying around us.</p><p>There was an educators conference going on at the hotel as well, and they obviously, as a block, wanted Clinton to win.</p><p><strong>I heard people sobbing about the results. And it broke my heart.</strong></p><p>The problem isn’t with the system. Even though the system has many problems. The problem isn’t with Trump. Even though Trump has many problems. The problem isn’t why Hillary lost. Even though there are many reasons she did.</p><p>The problem is the faith, the trust, and the hope we place in one individual we think can change the course of our lives.</p><p><em>The problem is the faith, the trust, and the hope we place in one individual we think can change the course of our lives.</em></p><p>There’s a growing concept out there that some are referring to as the “cult of the presidency.”</p><p>You see, the president was never meant to be very powerful. He, or she, was merely supposed to execute the laws that Congress enacted (and foreign relations).</p><p>Don’t get me wrong, that still gave the president a lot of power. But the president cannot legislate. The president cannot make laws. The president cannot do most of the things that we want the government to do. And the president can’t do 90% of the things they promise they’ll do. They just don’t have the power to do it.</p><p>And that is why the founding fathers set up our government this way.</p><p>Therefore, when someone like Trump wins the presidency, we have confidence that his influence can only go so far. Congress can keep him in check. As well as the Supreme Court. And if you think Trump has Congress in his pocket, then you haven’t been watching the news over the last six months.</p><p>The problem is not Trump.<em> The problem is that we as individuals </em><strong><em>have placed our hope</em></strong><em>, and even a piece of our identity (how we view ourselves and our self-worth) </em><strong><em>in the candidate of our choosing</em></strong><em>.</em></p><p>And when that candidate loses, we feel like a piece of our own identity lost.<strong> We feel like the country rejected our values, and therefore rejected us.</strong></p><p>We feel marginalized and invisible. We feel insignificant and under the boot of our opponent. We even want to say, “Not my president.”</p><p>But that says more about us than it does the election.</p><p>A wise person once said, “Insecurity is a wrong security exposed.” Meaning, when we feel marginalized or insecure, we have placed our sense of self (or security) in the wrong place.</p><p>Why on earth do we allow our sense of self-worth and validation to depend on who gets elected?</p><p>If you were devastated by the results of election night, I ask you to take a moment and look within.</p><ul><li><strong>Did you misplace your confidence?</strong></li><li>Did you buy the lie that you’re a victim if the opponent wins?</li><li><strong>Did you swallow the idea that one person can fix our problems?</strong></li><li>Did you drink the partisan Kool-Aid that said, “if the other person wins we’re all doomed?”.</li></ul><p>If so, then you may have unwittingly joined the cult of the presidency. And I invite you now to breathe a sigh of relief.</p><p>The world is not going to end.</p><p>Our hope, as people and a civilization, has to be in something other than one person who is in office for 4 to 8 years… and whose job description explicitly keeps them from writing laws or enacting edicts.</p><p>And if you are still worried about what Trump might do, then I also invite you to take a second look at how you want your government structured.</p><p><em>Do you want a government so powerful that a person like Trump can have that kind of power?</em></p><p>Is that the kind of government you want? If it isn’t, then we need to restore the values of the republic.</p><p>This was a truly emotional day. And many people are still processing through the results of the election.</p><p>But if you take nothing else from this post, please take hope.</p><p>Let’s reinvest in our system, reinforce the values of the separation of powers, and enforce the strict limitations the constitution places on the presidency.</p><p>Then, we can all go back to living the lives we want to live.</p><p>Let freedom reign.</p><figure><a href="https://codylibolt.typeform.com/to/KpfJSh"><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1018/1*xK8wc7XFOAmEchKJ124GkQ.png" /></a></figure><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="http://www.seanedwards.com/election-response/"><em>www.seanedwards.com</em></a><em> on November 9, 2016.<br></em><a href="https://christianintellectual.com/subscribe/">Click here to subscribe to <em>For the New Christian Intellectual.</em></a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=57c94eba35e4" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/christian-intellectual/why-our-reaction-to-the-election-says-more-about-us-than-the-election-57c94eba35e4">Why Our Reaction To The Election Says More About Us Than The Election</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/christian-intellectual">For the New Christian Intellectual</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Root of America’s Inequality Problem]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/christian-intellectual/the-root-of-americas-inequality-problem-sean-edwards-b8ed978f1f2f?source=rss-78b049551229------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b8ed978f1f2f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[law]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[liberty]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[democracy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[minorities]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Sean Edwards]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 01 Nov 2016 18:12:36 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-06-07T12:46:59.710Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*DgnFoxt-nUNu_C-x." /></figure><p>America has a serious inequality problem.</p><p>For a country that was founded on the idea of absolute equality, its reprehensible.</p><p>It goes deeper than #BlackLivesMatter and other movements like it.</p><p>The government’s main jobs is to protect minorities from the aggression of majorities. Otherwise, we’d have some sort of authoritarian regime.</p><p>However, even though our country was built on equality, both parties are failing our minorities.</p><p>And there’s one minority that has taken the most abuse recently.</p><p><strong>In fact, both parties claim to be defenders of this group.</strong></p><p>And both parties continually put these people under greater and greater oppression.</p><p>This group has been beaten, silenced, ridiculed, labeled as crazy, and completely dismissed by our government today.</p><p><em>This group has been beaten, silenced, ridiculed, labeled as crazy, and completely dismissed by our government today.</em></p><p>And our government deliberately and systematically keeps these people oppressed.</p><p>A lot of people say that we have systematic racism in this country.</p><p>That’s not true. Systematic racism means that racism is written into law.</p><p>There is a difference between the Jim Crow laws and individual law enforcement offers abusing their power.</p><p>But this minority is oppressed by the system.</p><p>Laws are written specifically to oppress these people.</p><p>And nobody notices.</p><p>Who are these people? And how–in this day and age–do we still have laws on the books targeting them?</p><p>That’s a good question.</p><p>The only minority specifically targeted by our laws are: Individuals.</p><p>If you balk at that, please stay with me.</p><p>We don’t usually talk about individuals as a minority, but aren’t they?</p><p>Merrimack-Webster defines a minority as:</p><ul><li><strong>A number or amount</strong> that is less than half of the total</li><li><strong>The group that is</strong> the smaller part of a larger group</li><li><strong>A group of people that are different</strong> from the larger group in a country, are, etc., in some way</li></ul><p>Individuals are certainly less than half the population.</p><p>Individuals are smaller than the whole.</p><p>And individuals are different from the whole… because they are individuals. A person cannot be multiple people (unless they have mental health issues).</p><p>The individual is the smallest, most oppressable minority on the earth (I know oppressable isn’t a word, but I like it, so I’m using it)</p><p><em>The individual is the smallest, most oppressable minority on the earth</em></p><p>It is easier to make a person submit than a group of people.</p><p>And our government oppresses them every day. Don’t believe me?</p><h3>The Rise of Feudalism in America</h3><p>Let’s look an example:</p><p>Property Taxes.</p><p>You may not think of property taxes as a form of oppression, but lets take a closer look at them.</p><p>In a nutshell, you don’t own your house, the state does.</p><p>Think you own your property?</p><p>Try not paying your property taxes.</p><p>If we don’t pay the government a portion of what our land is worth, the government evicts us and gives it to someone who will pay.</p><p>Does that sound familiar?</p><p>It should. It’s called serfdom. And it defined a dark and oppressive form of government during a very oppressive time in history.</p><p>I understand that the government needs money to operate. I’m not saying that all taxes are oppression.</p><p>But let me ask you this… If the government can kick us off our land, do we really own it?</p><p>There need to be consequences for failing to pay taxes. But taking someone’s property is an affront to the the basic tenets of individual rights.</p><h3>Individuals Are The Smallest Minority On Earth</h3><p>All of our racial problems in this country stem from this problem: We give equality lip service, but hate its application.</p><p>Why do we hate its application? Because if we truly believe that all people are equal, then it means we have to give up things we cherish.</p><p>Things like socialized healthcare, legislating who can marry whom, or criminalizing drug use.</p><p>When we accept that ALL people are equal, then we realize we can’t force ANY other individual do ANYTHING.</p><p>I cannot tell you how to live your life. I cannot enslave you. And I cannot take your money from you. I don’t have that right.</p><p>Since the government is made by people, and it is just a collection of people, it must be held to the same moral standards as people.</p><p>I.e., the government can’t perform actions that individuals couldn’t (morally).</p><p>For instance, I cannot tell another person how to live their life, or force them to work for me.</p><p>If I don’t have that right… and you don’t either… do we gain that right when we do it together?</p><p>What if we get a group of 10 together? Or 100? Or 1,000?</p><p>What size does our group have to be so we can ethically take people’s money by force?</p><p>What’s the magic number that makes the majority the arbiters of truth?</p><p>What philosophical argument allows the majority to dictate who can marry whom? Or what you can or cannot put into your body? Or dictate how you spend your money?</p><p>What makes the government different? Why does the government get to do these things, but individuals cannot?</p><p><em>Why can the government morally do this individuals cannot?</em></p><p>If we understand equality, then government can only exist for one purpose: Protect the individual from the oppression of the majority.</p><p>If it tries to go beyond those boundaries, it will become oppressive in nature.</p><h3>Why Protecting Individual Rights Protects Minorities and Destroys Racism</h3><p>Once the government oppresses the individual, ie., once we task our leaders to force other people to live by our values, we give it the power to easily oppress racial minorities.</p><p>Or ideological minorities. Or economic minorities.</p><p>But, if we mandate that the government can ONLY protect the rights of the individual, then it wouldn’t have the ability to oppress racial, ideological, or economic minorities.</p><p>All our racial struggles come to this problem: Our government no longer protects the individual.</p><p><strong>If we protect the individual, we protect minorities.</strong></p><p>It doesn’t matter what skin color you have, who you want to marry, what bathroom you want to use, or what you want to put into your body.</p><p>It doesn’t matter how much money you make.</p><p>It doesn’t matter where you live.</p><p>It doesn’t matter what language you speak.</p><p>Or what country you come from.</p><p><strong>We are all people. And we are all equal.</strong></p><p>The government became the problem when we decided it should be the instrument of social change.</p><p>We said, “Government, this social problem needs fixing. You’re big and powerful, and you have the strength to accomplish this. You fix it.”</p><p>So, we attack poverty by levying a tax to subsidize healthcare for those in need.</p><p>However, that money has to come from somewhere. Which means that one person is being forced to pay for someone else’s healthcare.</p><p>And even though its a noble cause, its still theft.</p><p>There is no such thing as forced charity.</p><p>If you take money from someone without their consent, its theft. There are no ifs, ands, or buts about it.</p><p>If it is their money–and not yours (nor society’s)–and you take it from them without their permission, it is theft.</p><p>Money can only change hands in one of two ways: By trade, or by force.</p><p>We can either choose to exchange wealth voluntarily, either through trading, or by charity.</p><p>Or one must steal it from the other.</p><p>Which means we can’t forcibly take money from some in order to help others.</p><p>“Forced charity” is a contradiction of terms. Charity has to be completely voluntary, otherwise it is just a nice word for slavery.</p><p><em>“Forced charity” is a contradiction of terms. Charity has to be completely voluntary, otherwise it is just a nice word for slavery.</em></p><p>People OFTEN object to this line of reasoning by saying, “It isn’t theft, its a tax” (like the property tax mentioned earlier).</p><p>It is easy to think they are different.</p><p>“Theft” conjures an image of a thief, masked and lurking for their next victim.</p><p>And a tax is just something that comes out of our paycheck.</p><p>No one is holding a gun to your head. No one is lurking in the shadows to steal from. Everyone does it. Its just how things work, right?</p><p>So it seems like an inapt comparison to call it theft.</p><p>However, taxes don’t justify any expense. You can’t just label something a tax and call it good.</p><p>If something’s a tax, it only means that enough people in congress said “yay” to a vote.</p><h3>Taxes Aren’t Theft (Except When They Are)</h3><p>Taxes fund the government.</p><p>If we task the government with a new job, it needs money to accomplish it.</p><p>And as long as the government uses those dollars to protect the individual, that’s okay.</p><p>But, if the government is doing something immoral, that means those tax dollars are being used for something immoral. Which makes the tax immoral.</p><p>What if we taxed black people more heavily because they place the largest burden our prison system? Would that be moral? Could we still say, “Its not racism, its a tax.”</p><p>No. That would be preposterous and evil.</p><p>Thus, when someone says we can tax one person to pay for another’s health care (or education, or paid maternity leave, or whatever), they are saying that theft is okay as long we call it a tax… and that the majority agrees its okay.</p><p>Theft is wrong. Even if you intend to use that money for good purposes.</p><p>Therefore you cannot hide behind the term “tax”.</p><p>Taxes can only be used to fund the government to protect individual rights.*</p><p>Otherwise the tax itself becomes immoral (and thus, theft), and and our government becomes the aggressor.</p><p>If we truly want to eliminate the inequality in our country… then we need end inequality in our country.</p><p>We need a philosophical revolution to occur. And we need to re-task our government to only protect individual rights.</p><p>Not just the parts we like.</p><p>We cannot say, “I stand up for individual rights, but believe marriage should be between a man and a woman.” That is a contradiction.</p><p>We are picking which parts of equality and freedom we like, and which we don’t.</p><p>This says, “I like freedom as long people behave how I want. If they don’t, I making a law that forces them to.”</p><p>We cannot say, “I am a proponent of social justice and human rights,” and also believe that the government should tax the wealthy to fund social welfare programs. This too is a contradiction.</p><p><strong>We are picking which parts of freedom we like, and which we don’t.</strong></p><p>This says, “People should be free, so long as they behave how I want. If they don’t, I’m going to force them to do so.”</p><p>The democratic and republican parties are 2 sides to same coin.</p><p>If we say we believe in human rights, we have to accept them all, not just the ones we like.</p><p><em>If we say we believe in human rights, we have to accept them all, not just the ones we like.</em></p><p>We can’t cherry pick which rights we like and which we don’t.</p><p>This means everyone will have to let go of their golden calves. We must limit the government to only protecting individual equality.</p><p>Otherwise equality itself is undone.</p><p><strong>Your motives or intentions don’t matter. <em>Your actions do.</em></strong></p><p>So if you support a law that forces your neighbor to live by your values (and forces them fund a program with which they do not agree), then you don’t actually stand for equality.</p><p>You don’t want freedom. You just say you do.</p><p>If you want to force some to pay for other people’s healthcare or education, you don’t really believe in justice.</p><p>If you want to dictate who people can and cannot marry, you don’t really believe in freedom.</p><p>If you want to tell people what they can and cannot put into their bodies, you don’t stand for equality.</p><p>If you want any of these things, you don’t want freedom. You want to control people. Its plain and simple.</p><p>And you have no place in government.</p><p>Government cannot be run by people who want to control people.</p><p>Enlightened government, and people, don’t seek to control people. They seek to expand freedom and justice.</p><p>True freedom respects people with basic human dignity.</p><p>It says, “No right of mine constitutes an obligation on any living person.” (Ayn Rand)</p><p>It respects that I have no right to tell you how to live your life.</p><p>An enlightened people realize that if I can’t control you, the government can’t either.</p><p>There are other ways to change the world for the better. Forcing our values on those around us is not the answer.</p><p>We must learn to love freedom in all of its applications. Not just the parts our party prefers.</p><p><em>We must learn to love freedom in all of its applications. Not just the parts our party prefers.</em></p><p>We must learn to love freedom and hate oppression.</p><p>This is what our country was built on. This is our purpose and our destiny.</p><p>Love freedom. Love your neighbor. Don’t try to love people by forcing them to live by your values.</p><p>Let go of your favorite political ideas and just love people… even if they do things you don’t agree with.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*J7fQKcFBAAxW0DRcIPlV3g.png" /></figure><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="http://www.seanedwards.com/american-inequality/"><em>www.seanedwards.com</em></a><em> on November 1, 2016.<br></em><a href="https://christianintellectual.com/subscribe/">Click here to subscribe to <em>For the New Christian Intellectual.</em></a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b8ed978f1f2f" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/christian-intellectual/the-root-of-americas-inequality-problem-sean-edwards-b8ed978f1f2f">The Root of America’s Inequality Problem</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/christian-intellectual">For the New Christian Intellectual</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>