<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by John Seitz on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by John Seitz on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@seitzfarm?source=rss-89cbb5b40750------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sun, 22 Nov 2026 07:13:20 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@seitzfarm/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Not Reading J.D. Vance in Almaty, Kazakhstan]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@seitzfarm/not-reading-j-d-vance-in-almaty-kazakhstan-6c3d3a9fee2d?source=rss-89cbb5b40750------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6c3d3a9fee2d</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[appalachia]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[John Seitz]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 04 Jun 2017 15:01:57 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-06-05T02:13:35.899Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>I was at a party of other graduate students from the US living in Kazakhstan doing dissertation research like myself. He seemed a nice person, thoughtful, and intelligent. However, the party and our interaction went awry early on when he brought up J.D. Vance’s <em>Hillbilly Elegy</em> asking if anyone had read it. No one had, and I began to discourage them from taking it up, ready to suggest that their time would be better spent reading Paul Salstrom’s <em>Appalachia’s Path to Dependency</em>, Ron Eller’s <em>Uneven Ground</em>, or even better C.V. Moore’s essays “<a href="http://www.oxfordamerican.org/magazine/item/351-o-beulah-land">Oh Beluah Land</a>” and “The Book of the Dead” since access to English language books is somewhat limited in Almaty. But I never got the chance. It wasn’t the first time something like this had happened, but it is the first time I decided to write about it.</p><p>Earlier we’d gone through the formalities of discussing where everyone was from, so I was surprised when, as the only Appalachian in the room, I found myself cut off and immediately challenged with the question, “Well, have you read Vance?” This kind of question is rather normal in a setting of academics, where the published written word holds a prestige greater than any lived experience by an actual human being. I paused for a minute, suspecting that if I told the truth and said that I had not read Vance, whatever I had to say would be promptly ignored. Perhaps it was the cheap beer on an empty stomach after a frustrating day in the archives that caused me to answer the question honestly, and try begin to explain why I had not read the book. However, I never got the chance. Instead, I was once again cut off mid-sentence, while my Ivy League “peer” held forth on the book and its importance. He also went on to explain to us how back when he read the book, “no one had heard of it” (I didn’t get the chance to tell him those of us in West Virginia knew long before Trump’s election that there was another politicized, monetized expose written by someone not who doesn’t live in the region). He also explained to us how “liberals” are up in arms about the book because of “some few political conclusions he makes at the end.” He concluded by explaining to us that we should really just read the book, because it is “just a great memoir.”</p><p>I wanted to try and explain that it was perhaps “just a memoir” to him, but that it is much more than that to me. I wanted to say that it does real damage to real people when authors continue to write exposés on Appalachia that imply or outright state that it is individual personal failings not structural realities that that make stories like Vance’s family common. Additionally, I wanted to say that my colleague’s own education at Harvard was funded in part by money made from exploiting my home. I wanted to say that the region doesn’t suffer from a lack of spirit or good ideas, but that he really should read the books I suggested above to understand that the story doesn’t begin or end with Vance’s family. Or even better yet, spend several years teaching in the WV school system like both of my parents did and see the poverty, potential, frustration, beauty, and regional inferiority complex that is just as much a part of the fabric of where I’m from as banjos, poisoned creeks, and dropping in on neighbors unannounced. But I didn’t because as the only native son of Appalachia I was not given the credentials to speak about “hillbillies.”</p><p>I wanted to tell him that in addition to being destructive, I did not feel the need to read it. I’ve read this stuff before. This is just the most recent in a long line of works that seek to explain “the problem” of Appalachia, (I was tempted to ask him if he’d read Kephart’s <em>Our Southern Highlanders</em>, but wasn’t given the chance). I don’t believe there is a problem of Appalachia, the problem is not the region or the people in it, it is the system of power that enables its exploitation and poverty. What is more, I find it morally objectionable to monetize the suffering and problems of my home for personal economic gain and fame by someone who refuses to live in the region, so I refuse to buy the book.</p><p>But more than these rational arguments, I really wanted to make an argument that was much less about Vance, and more about my colleague’s use of the written word and his privileged status as a non-Appalachian, well-spoken, Ivy Leaguer to silence me. In short, I wanted to tell him this:</p><p>“No, I didn’t’ read it, because I’ve been too busy working to make my home a better place not run by out of state interests that make your state, your university, and your life better while leaving my home a wreck, with poisoned water, corrupt politics, and drug addiction rampant, all of which daily affect me and my neighbors and friends. I can see it every day, I don’t need to read about it. I spent two summers teaching kids that had much the same life experiences as JD Vance, and I spent a couple of years teaching them about farming in the middle of coalfields. I don’t need to read about it because even before teaching them, I sat beside them in class, helped them cheat on their tests, and saw them come in with bruises from abusive parents, or sneak into the classroom in the morning so no one knew they got free breakfast. I don’t need to read about because they are my neighbors and we share stories and fears over beer and cigarettes, my stories about what Russia and Kazakhstan are like, my broken hearts, my adventures when town flooded, or about my latest hike up a mountain. And they share their stories about getting hurt in coal mine, how smart their granddaughter is, how much it hurts to have a family member on pills, and how there’ll never be a frost after the blackberries blossom.</p><p>I didn’t read it because I don’t want to read another story about how screwed up my home is, because sometimes it really destroys my soul to think about how the place that I love more than any other might be doomed. For you it may just be an interesting story, an intellectual excursion like your academic work here in Kazakhstan, but for me it is about my home, my friends, and my neighbors. I didn’t read it, because I don’t want to be told again that it is our fault that things are bad in Appalachia. I couldn’t take another exposé written about how the fact that I couldn’t play in the orange creeks as a kid was our own fault, not the fault of some long dead coal baron who left his fortune to Harvard rather than to Fairmont State. I didn’t want to hear that it was our fault that the rocky soccer fields we played on had no topsoil. (It wasn’t our fault, it was because they were on old strip mines that the company sold for well above market value allowing them to be deemed “good corporate citizen” while company profits from the coal went to Richmond or New York). I didn’t want to read about how it was our fault that my high school was the best in the state, but still not good enough to ensure any of its top graduates a spot at an Ivy League, something that is a forgone conclusion elsewhere. I didn’t read it because I didn’t need to be told again that these shortcomings of my childhood were our fault, while the real crooks get off guiltless, and the beneficiaries of this system tell me whether or not I am qualified to speak about my home.</p><p>Perhaps I didn’t have time to read it because I am still distracted thinking about how when we played sports against teams from Pittsburgh parents from the other team called us “hicks” and “just a bunch of coal miners kids.” Maybe I didn’t have time to read it because I was too busy remembering to say that I grew up South of Pittsburgh rather than saying I grew up in West Virginia, for fear that people would know I was from a state that my great-great grandfather fought and almost died to ensure existed. I was also busy taking time to remember never to say “ain’t” for fear of facing my mother’s wrath, and for always trying to ensure that we weren’t “trashy” so I could never wear camo and rarely was allowed to shoot guns. Or maybe I didn’t have time to read the book because I am trying every day to convince the most beautiful person I’ve ever known or even heard of, that I am not a worthless, stupid, and ugly hillbilly. That I could be deserving of her love.</p><p>Maybe I didn’t read it because I am tired. I am tired of being told in the academy that my friends and neighbors back home aren’t “normal people… like you know what I mean.” I am tired of being told that I should try and escape them, “do better for yourself” and that I am “not like those people” when those people are exactly who I am, and who I want to be: kind, generous, funny, and beautiful, faults and all. I am tired of doubting myself, my home, and my neighbors because people like you read one book or take one trip through town on the interstate, and think that you are now an expert.</p><p>I did not read it. I’ve been too busy, been too sad, and been too tired. I don’t want to read and I shouldn’t have to, but that shouldn’t let you keep me from commenting on any book with the word “hillbilly” in the title. The fault is not with me for not having read another worthless book. I shouldn’t be silenced by your erudition and leisure time, I should be able to speak about my home, whether I went to Harvard and wrote a book or not. But that is precisely what happened, you silenced me just like you all always do with your power of books, rationality, and fancy degrees that come through the wealth created by the exploitation of my home and its people.</p><p>It might have been a “good memoir” but what good is a memoir if it takes my power away and gives it to you, an outsider and lets you silence me? If that is what makes a “good memoir” what is a memoir good for? You are clearly a smart and decent person, if however, this is what books do to you, then maybe you’ve read enough, and should start listening.”</p><p>The whole interaction left me baffled, angry, and with those age-old feelings of inadequacy that come with being from Appalachia. I was also rather surprised that someone with a fancy education who studies a part of the world he is not native to would be so unaware of the problem of outsiders and experts explaining the region to its own inhabitants. Here I was, a real life “local informant” in the process of being dismissed and ignored for my lack of proper training. I suppose I shouldn’t have been surprised, I am writing a dissertation on this very topic. But also, I’ve personally experienced it time and again in the university, jokes about where I am from, exasperation at “those idiots voting against their own interests” as though the Democrats have offered my region anything since Lyndon Johnson. I’ve grown used to it, but it never ceases to amaze me how frequent it is for academics trained to spot nefarious ideologies in those people or groups under study to be unable to cast their inquisitive gaze inward.</p><p>As demoralizing and infuriating as the interaction was, it was in some ways useful. Despite dragging up these bad feelings, it also reinforced some very valuable lessons that I have learned from friends with marginalized identities, most especially women and people of color. My own story mirrored many of the experiences they’ve described to me. For example, the boundary of what is and isn’t acceptable experience or evidence, weighted heavily against the emotions of those most affected and in favor of the privileged “rational” side. The classic male tactic of cutting me off mid-sentence was something that I have heard about and observed happening to women more times than I can count. But perhaps, the most significant and frustrating aspect of the interaction was something that a co-instructor who is a woman of color lived out in front of me weekly in class. Like she had been, in Almaty, I was engaged in an argument in a very emotional state because my identity was being ignored and dismissed in favor of an “objective” expert’s opinion. Even if he had let me finish a sentence, and “allowed” me to use my lived experience as evidence to make a point I was never really allowed to introduce (that Vance’s book is garbage and harmful), I would have had to do it under the influence of the intense feelings that I mentioned above, a problematic debating position.</p><p>On my angry walk home, I spent some time thinking about the interaction and how much it reflected everything described to me by my friends with marginalized identities. In my rage on the streets of Almaty, I once again became incredibly grateful to the amazing people in my life who have not only shared their time, energy, and wisdom to teach me how their oppressions work against them, but who have thereby helped me see even more clearly how my own (much less suffocating) oppressions work against me. It renewed my belief that we have a lot to learn from one another, and that diversity of identity and experience is a must in any education setting. It also reminded me that our shared wisdom is a potent intellectual map of how oppression works and is interconnected, but, even more importantly, it reminded me that our shared compassion for one another’s’ suffering should be a powerful weapon for organizing and action.</p><p>There is certainly a danger in saying that we are all oppressed, this can mean that no one oppression need take center stage at a given moment, or that others should “just get over it” because I have. There is also a danger that I might pretend to know what another person with different identities goes through. These are real dangers, and by no means exhaustive, and we should be aware of them when thinking about different types of identities and privileges, and struggling for social justice. However, there is also a great potential to get a lot more people on board with the idea that oppression exists if even relatively privileged people can see it in their own lives. I did not suffer from the extreme poverty that is endemic to my home, and don’t want to compare my disadvantages with anyone, but the emotional cost of being from a place that is disparaged and dismissed is real, and I have internalized a lot of the criticism about my home by those from the outside, and those emotional burdens are real, just like the emotional burdens people from other marginalized communities face, and hearing about their much greater challenges actually helped validate my own. But it can also work the other way, by helping marginalized groups see their oppression as systemic, it is then easier to help the see that other people’s oppression is real as well.</p><p>In short, if the stories of an amazingly strong Appalachian woman with an abusive misogynistic boss, a kick ass first generation immigrant and twice college graduate, an incredibly supportive and loyal homosexual Muslim, a wonderfully kind and creative brother with Asperger’s, and countless other marginalized folks fighting for social justice can teach this middle-class, white, heterosexual Appalachian about his own oppression however much it pales in comparison to theirs, then there is I think hope in America, however dark it is now just “before the dawn.” I left the party angry and hurt, but I also left it even more in awe of my friends fighting the good fight, and with a renewed willingness to join them in their struggles as an ally and a friend.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=6c3d3a9fee2d" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>