<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Sarah Brennan on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Sarah Brennan on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@sh-brennan?source=rss-55e3fdb3b1cf------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Mon, 16 Nov 2026 09:27:07 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@sh-brennan/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[On Tornado Cash. A Bang.]]></title>
            <link>https://sh-brennan.medium.com/on-tornado-cash-a-bang-61f281b11f92?source=rss-55e3fdb3b1cf------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/61f281b11f92</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Sarah Brennan]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 12 Aug 2022 18:03:06 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-08-12T23:52:37.851Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3><strong>On Tornado Cash.</strong></h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*v23gAwMmX1jia75csCXajQ.png" /></figure><p>As I am wont to do, I have been discussing the Tornado Cash fallout in various internet chat groups and someone described the arrest of a developer as “some 1984 shit”. This made me pause. Haven’t we already solidly arrived there? Haven’t the collective governments of the world been marching steadily toward surveillance states for decades?</p><p>We see this steady encroachment everywhere. In the U.S., these aren’t just 9/11 fallout measures holding over without de-escalation. From the <a href="https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2020/10/27/2020-23756/threshold-for-the-requirement-to-collect-retain-and-transmit-information-on-funds-transfers-and">2020 FinCEN proposal</a> that attempted to lower the dollar thresholds for bank mandated snitching on customer transactions from $3k to $250[1] against a background of inflation to the endless layering of additional reporting and surveilling obligations, including the Corporate Transparency Act (CTA) and Anti-Money Laundering Act of 2020 (AMLA), we see privacy rights repeatedly trumped by *talking points* around terrorism and crime. And all it takes is talking points because no govt official will be stopped from using them by the facts on the ground —which are that there is a lack of correlation between these ever increasing measures and results/efficacy. Meaning, that as we continually ratchet up the compliance burden, it has come with little to no reduction in money laundering and/or terrorism while creating tremendous costs (amirite banker frens). Not to mention the diminishing returns from financial institutions arriving at surveilling and reporting my $5 Arby’s purchase (I am clearly unwell, plz let me be ashamed in private). But over and again we see these measures being introduced and largely passed with privacy concerns being pushed aside “blah blah blah only criminals would oppose this $5 reporting threshold and what if they put that $5 in a terrorist crowdfund” and you likely win the day.</p><p>So with all of this building,what keeps playing in my head is “<strong>This is the way the world ends. Not with a bang but a whimper</strong>.” The incremental erosion of personal liberty and criminalization of privacy marches ever forward. Yet this encroachment has been ongoing without much to stop it.Why does this keep happening without significant pushback, you might ask? Inertia or maybe that the world is terrible and overwhelming and it takes so much effort, and it has to be organized effort, to fight the tide. And I will pause to say hi to Edward Snowden, who tried his best at yelling into the void only to be featured on a John Oliver’s dick pic segment highlighting that Americans only care about surveillance when the government is passing around their noods. [2] Further to the average American only caring about their dick pics getting in the wrong hands, we dont have the benefit most deregulatory efforts do — where you can rely on the TradFi business community to fight pesky and costly compliance initiatives. Last time I checked, it wasn’t a great look for TradFi to fight financial crime regs and none of them have felt like getting dragged on this.</p><p>With that doom and gloomy state of affairs, enter crypto, an inherently Libertarian and privacy-centric movement (at least in its purest form as public ledgers could easily be harnessed for “1984 shit” on steroids). Crypto was always destined for a clash with the surveillance state. It has felt inevitable that there would be a stand-off, that the government would try to kill permissionless tech and label privacy preservation efforts as fundamentally criminal. Aaaaand I am pretty sure that we are here and we were always going to get here. With Tornado Cash, we see the sanctioning of a protocol itself, blacklisting of addresses, deplatforming (and arrests) of TC developers and ongoing fallout — and it is all sudden, unprecedented and (I hope) a step too far that spurs multiple constitutional challenges that will serve to draw a line in the sand broadly for individual liberty (queue inspirational music plz).</p><p>Constitutional challenges are hard; they can take a long time to play out. And everything is on hold until they do. This is why they are a challenge of last resort. It is the law equivalent of “I want to speak to your manager’s manager’s manager”. In private practice, I always told clients that even if you have a constitutional argument, you never want to be in court having to make it. It is bad for business, expensive and you end up spending years financing the defense of key liberties if you fight. You are undertaking a public good often at your direct expense. It is very noble and altruistic. So we can’t rely on business interest lobbying alone (even ones that are indirectly impacted) and likely need to fight this battle on constitutional grounds with advocacy organizations as our allies.</p><p>But here, <strong>I believe we have a “bang”; </strong>something that jolts people to attention. There are severe consequences at play — strict liability financial crimes are no joke and neither is having your CEX account(s) frozen indefinitely or your centralized stablecoins for that matter. You can see the high stakes in all these rippling overreactions — shutting accounts down that interacted with TC before the sanctions, aggressive compliance flagging due to inadequate precision in screening tools and erring on the side of caution. Individuals and market actors do not want that type of smoke with the government and will react to myopically protect their immediate needs. But here we have an overreach that needs to be addressed (once standing issues are figured out) and the absurdity is being proved out through the dusting and contagion of wallets — you do not need intent to receive the funds to have issues here (I dont have to be sitting around asking for that 0.1 ETH to be sent to my IamabsolutelyKateHudson.ETH address). If there ever was a reason for crypto advocacy efforts to unite around a common principle, it is here. Code is speech. Speech is protected. Take this for the monumental and explosive development that it is. We should not give up this ground, it is, as always, a slippery slope. We should wake up now lest we continue sleeping through the further criminalization of privacy until there is nothing left.</p><p>[1] More nuanced than this, applies to certain transactions but making a point here</p><p>[2] I am sure you have seen this but worth a revist as it is endlessly demoralizing and makes you really question whether humanity deserves a good future — like all good comedy <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XEVlyP4_11M">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XEVlyP4_11M</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=61f281b11f92" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Decentralized Organizations — Another Round of Definitional Questions & Existential Crises]]></title>
            <link>https://sh-brennan.medium.com/decentralized-organizations-another-round-of-definitional-questions-existential-crises-2ee6a93f82b5?source=rss-55e3fdb3b1cf------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2ee6a93f82b5</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[regulation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[dao]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[policy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[defi]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Sarah Brennan]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 16 Aug 2021 16:02:32 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-08-16T16:02:32.630Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3><strong>Decentralized Organizations </strong>— <strong>Another Round of Definitional Questions &amp; Existential Crises</strong></h3><p>Recent events, namely the infrastructure bill saga and many thoughtful conversations that have followed, have me rethinking my stance on definitional issues that have existed in crypto from inception. A couple of years ago, I used to think that crypto had a definitions problem due to a lack of precision in terminology used by the space— both in the sense that no one used the same terms to refer to the same thing or people used the same terms to refer to different things (see token taxonomy issues). Compounding these definitional issues, crypto otherwise uses legacy terminology that has legal or regulatory ramifications, the impact of the optics of such uses being, at times, underappreciated in the space or just ignored because — and just to scapegoat, hubris and libertarianism are a heady combo (please direct all hate mail to @haxxor_birdman, which is 1000% not my alt). This has still led to some suboptimal situations, like the use of the term “swaps” as discussed by my LeXpunK compatriot here:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/481/1*dn2knI1R64eGUbHxX11Z6w.jpeg" /></figure><p>And the need to create firmness around definitions continues today (see <a href="https://twitter.com/lex_node/status/1425994691103842304?s=20">@lex_node’s Digital Asset draft definition</a> too):</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/485/1*EmuAw7GuWCSjnjevcYlDiQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>Now, with the help of Congress and various state laws, we see what happens when the task of crafting definitions is outsourced. All these definitional disasters now under our belts, we can better appreciate the delicacies involved. It is hard to formulate definitions because by the nature of the exercise, structures that fall outside of the four corners of the definition do not meet that purity test. I loathe purity tests and think they have bad outcomes because they create incentives to become overly rigid or formulaic and may punish ingenuity that results in criteria not being met for a safe harbor. This is a quickly evolving space, it changes, morphs, and renders obsolete understandings of the characteristics of concepts or models that exist at a static point and time. On balance, there is clear danger in crafting overly broad, all-encompassing definitions that would allow for discretionary regulatory overreach in interpreting scope and applicability.</p><p>Why am I yammering on you ask to the extent you made it here? I may not be entirely happy with definitions that the crypto community has manifested but it is clear to me at this point that if we do not create structure, definitions and narratives, others will do so for us. This can be seen in the infrastructure bill debates and recent SEC regulatory action against Blockchain Credit Partners and the SEC actively touting a fraud case as the agency’s first DeFi enforcement action, a disingenuous characterization for a DINO (DeFi in name only) project. Definitions are hard to get right but failing to shape well-crafted definitions leaves the space vulnerable from a policy perspective, including the inability to push back on false narratives and poor outcomes.</p><p><strong>One conversation currently at the forefront is how do we define a decentralized (autonomous) organization?<em> That is, what are their defining characteristics?</em></strong></p><p>Are these rhetorical questions? And by that I mean, questions that are not capable of a definitive answer — ones that can only spark a dialogue? I have felt at times that it is too difficult or too early to draw definitive lines here. However, as we try to actively shape law and policy, I see value in setting flexible baseline definitions that do not address every intricacy or facet, but provide a base to build upon. <strong>The answer must lie somewhere between Wyoming’s overly formulistic approach and the classic “I know porn when I see it”.</strong></p><p>With all that said, I will give an attempt at a baseline definition, will put it up on GitHub, and welcome any feedback, improvement etc. but<strong> <em>would suggest that this definition can be built upon by a non-exhaustive list of indicative features and characteristics (see Appendix for a start)</em>:</strong></p><blockquote><strong>Decentralized organizations are cloud cooperatives with an enumerated mission, purpose or mandate, and have fluid affiliation or membership through participation.</strong></blockquote><p>Why arrive at this baseline definition?</p><ol><li>Decentralized organizations are in their infancy, this definition hopefully allows for diversity in purpose, mission, and members — factors that will inevitably require structural and organizational tailoring based on the use case and goals of the organization.</li><li>A key component of the definition, from a policy perspective, is to focus on <strong>fluid membership by participation</strong>. Participation, by its nature gives a universal nexus for membership based on agency and affirmative acts (again, this is membership with fluid entries and exits) but must not, *in and of itself*, give rise to liability for the individual contributors. Imputed liability for the acts of a loose cooperative amounts to a non-sensical outcome when the individual contributor can and will otherwise be held liable for their specific acts and omissions (deployer liability). I will leave it to regulators to inevitably formulate additional theories of liability but those would not be based on imputed liability for acts of the collective but instead around the ability to “control” policy and decision-making, akin to c-suite liability or control stakes in deciding the outcome of a vote.</li></ol><p>If the above sounds familiar, my goal is a definition that counters the narrative around the applicability of de facto general partnership principles to decentralized organizations and their contributors. General partnership by estoppel is a model that is better applied in the closely held context where a small static group of actors engages enterprise in a single jurisdiction. There is utility in moving beyond the boogeyman of unlimited liability for looking too hard at a DAO and pushing back at the appropriateness of applying partnership law as foregone conclusion given the lack of certain shared fundamental characteristics.</p><p>I throw this piece out in furtherance of the above goals and because there is an opportunity now if we are active. There are so many areas where legal friction can be reduced. Having sensible and workable definitions and daring to live in world where you, your mom and your cousins aren’t all broker-dealers, is low hanging fruit. There is power in creating our own narratives (one of them being that we never have to hear “wild west” again) and communally working to create and refine informed and tailored definitions feels like an increasingly essential building block for workable policies that address decentralized enterprises instead of ones that make the space illegal per se.</p><p>While I do not speak for LeXpunK, my goal is to contribute what I can to the conversation, hoping these efforts will spark broader debate and improvement on these ideas. LeXpunK is focused on DeFi advocacy through a number of avenues, each pursued in parallel. We can pursue formulating and advocating for the development of laws and policies that make sense but because that may be a long time horizon, efforts should be directed to formulating workable solutions out of existing law and structures and developing crypto native solutions (self-help and self-regulatory practices, opt in arbitration mechanisms, formulating industry “customs” and best practices). It is incumbent upon us all to be active in shaping narratives and advocating for smart policy outcomes.</p><p><strong>Appendix </strong>— Thank you to all in LeXpunK who reviewed and provided comments and thoughtful feedback. What is evident from responses is both that the definition is very personal to those involved in the space and there is also such a broad diversity of views. I thought it would be helpful to include some of the additional thoughts received as our starting building blocks to expand the definition further:</p><p><strong>Characteristics that embody the ethos of DAOs:</strong></p><ul><li>People can participate at whatever level they like and no one needs to define their work agreement (ie you can be part of a DAO with an hour a week and generally the DAO will try to reward contributions proportionally).</li><li>You can be members of multiple DAOs at once, often even competing ones, and mostly people don’t care as long as you create value.</li><li>DAOs don’t care where value comes from. From an anon, another protocol, or the market, DAOs are generally open to all value contributed.</li></ul><p><strong>Things that are often true of DAOs:</strong></p><p>An association of people, who:</p><ul><li>Do not have a single person or team that carries (some ratio of?) executive power</li><li>Have interactions mediated by one or more associated smart contracts</li><li>Have an articulated purpose, vision, or ideology</li><li>Have fluid membership</li><li>Membership based on participation, whether through contributions or active participation in governance and decision making(forums, use of governance tokens)</li></ul><p><strong>Relevant things that can be true of DAOs:</strong></p><ul><li>Be formed for a number of purposes, including without limitation: to build protocols for deployment on the blockchain; collect funds for investment purposes; provide services for customers (such as DeFi services, mediation, etc.); conduct advocacy consistent with the purpose, vision, or ideology</li><li>Be non-profit or for-profit</li><li>May involve specialized membership or diverse membership</li><li>May involve legal entities at one or more levels in the organization</li><li>Involve governance tokens that are transferable or not, and involve different rights</li><li>Have charter documents</li><li>Be permissioned or permissionless</li><li>Involve smart contracts in governance functions, though the degree may vary</li><li>Have investment from VCs or other institutional investors or funded by broad community</li></ul><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2ee6a93f82b5" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[On GME, Regulatory Paternalism and Decentralized Market Phenomena]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/crypto-law-policy-musings/on-gme-regulatory-paternalism-and-decentralized-market-phenomena-693393612733?source=rss-55e3fdb3b1cf------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/693393612733</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[defi]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[regulation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[gem]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Sarah Brennan]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 03 Mar 2021 00:34:39 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-03-03T00:34:39.216Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Though seemingly coming from nowhere for many, the themes behind the Reddit-fueled r/wallstreetbets pump of GameStop feel familiar. Watching it unfold, I tried to figure out just why it had captured my interest to such a degree — and, to me it was a spillover into the traditional markets of some pervasive themes driving crypto. Despite some competition in the narrative,<a href="#_edn1">[i]</a> I view the motivating force<a href="#_edn2">[ii]</a> behind the GME pump as analogous with what, at one point, was an impetus behind Bitcoin, and is a driver for (depending on your level of cynicism) the crypto markets more broadly and the DeFi, or decentralized finance, movement — a desire for the “democratization of finance”, the view that finance and financial products should be open sourced, accessible to all, as opposed to hinging on whether you are an accredited (read: high net worth) or an institutional player.<a href="#_edn3">[iii]</a> There was a folkloric element to the narrative, a David and Goliath tale of sorts, where the everyday man was able to pull off a coup in inspiring a sizable crowdfunded movement in the market. Yet, while it evoked some degree of euphoria, the episode also brings to the forefront some of the simmering underlying tensions in U.S. society, including a strong sense of paternalism toward the poor, in this case the retail investor, and mounting generational tensions.</p><p>In the U.S., as a somewhat toxic offshoot of self-determination, there is the underlying bias or presupposition that those who are wealthy became so because of their personal attributes and, likewise, those who are poor will remain poor as a result of some personal failing on their part. Outside the academic setting, policy toward retail hasn’t reflected much exploration into the social and economic factors that allow people to accumulate wealth and the feeling that “the game is rigged” through increasing barriers to achieving upward mobility in the U.S. This manifests itself in regulatory paternalism, the government imposing limitations on who they deem able to afford to make investments or have access to certain financial products. Most visibly, this has left those who are non-accredited<a href="#_edn4">[iv]</a> without access to early stage investments, but at the same time allows access to casinos and lottery tickets, payday loans and other predatory financial instruments such as reverse mortgages. presumably where a competing interest such as state-budgetary shortfalls or effective lobbying on the part of industry won out.<a href="#_edn5">[v]</a></p><p>What you end up with is a system that seems engineered to reinforce class-based barriers — where the wealthy get to shape law and dictate the narrative as well. This is most starkly evidenced by the Melvin Capital sympathetic content that ran on CNBC,<a href="#_edn6">[vi]</a> portraying the hedge funds as the protagonists, leveraging the dogmatic network-wide belief system that, somehow Melvin’s actions were good for society and universally just. This was juxtaposed against a characterization of the Redditors as huddled unwashed masses who, somehow, through chaos and destruction, embarked like lemmings on a path toward personal financial ruin and created a situation where there was some sort of systemic risk created by touting a random low volume stock. Not to put too fine a point on it but while rich people lost some money here, among others,<a href="#_edn7">[vii]</a> it is not exactly the financial apocalypse it was portrayed to be.</p><p>To me, putting aside the unending joy of having mainstream finance publications quote Reddit netizens like DadBod39 and prompting untold memes around Robinhood changing their name to Prince John’s Trading or RobingtheHood, this episode in the stock market captured my attention by highlighting the above described tension as well as a generational shift to social-media based messaging, where the internet can be leveraged widely to produce decentralized market forces. Fueled by (semi)-anonymous decentralized actors, this episode brings forward one of my core fascinations with crypto — the prospect of a paradigm shift that challenges existing regulations. Much like the regulatory challenges applicable to DeFi, how do you address a movement of the masses when law presupposes there is a central figure, with more culpability than Keith “Roaring Kitty” (but not a cat) Gill, to which you can attach liability. Addressing this poses a conundrum as regulators are increasingly faced with cutting heads off hydras with the prospect of more growing back.</p><p>Most recently, the House Committee on Financial Services had a post-mortem hearing on Gamestop and the surrounding market volatility<a href="#_edn8">[viii]</a> and while I always go into these with the lowest of expectations, I come out each time with a sense of renewed nihilism and hopelessness. While the recent House hearing on Feb 18, 2021 provided an opportunity for a rehashing of the r/wallstreetbets pump from those with a first-row view of the events that transpired and gave legislators the opportunity to sabre rattle and virtue signal to their respective constituents, there were no clear signs of a path forward. There was a cursory discussion of the merits of reducing settlement time (and yes, blockchain), the downsides of relying on high growth FinTech startups to provide market infrastructure type services, and the balancing act, as Rep. Casten put it, of trying to democratize finance while not “being a conduit to feed fish to sharks.”<a href="#_edn9">[ix]</a></p><p>It was also an opportunity for legislators to play who can be the most tone deaf to the underlying market incentives that fuel today’s AdTech and surveillance driven economy, questioning whether this was indeed a free service for consumers, in this case retail investors (breaking news, it isn’t), while remaining a for-profit institution. One House member asked if Robinhood would stop the practice of earning revenue by allowing Citadel to “pay for order flow”<a href="#_edn10">[x]</a> and allowing for the institutional players to front run retail.<a href="#_edn11">[xi]</a> The answer was clearly and universally no, or, as Rep. Casten put it, “there is a tension in [Robinhood’s] business model.”<a href="#_edn12">[xii]</a> This is the same legislature that has stalled in any attempt to stem consumer data from being bought and sold as a business model<a href="#_edn13">[xiii]</a>. Thereby achieving peak level hypocrisy in the triple threat of (i) allowing the monetization of violations of privacy, and somehow both (ii) blaming free market actors for making money off acts that are legal, and (iii) also suggesting at times that regulation was the cause of the harm that was done. In a particularly depressing segment of the hearing, Robinhood was all at once villainized for not providing the committee with disclosure forms that are publicly available, for not foreseeing a tenfold spike<a href="#_edn14">[xiv]</a> in the capital they would need and for taking emergency steps to meet capital requirements, which involved some degree of discretion in how to address but not as much as House members insinuated.<a href="#_edn15">[xv]</a> Others suggested that Robinhood should be responsible for the relative gains in their users’ portfolios and still others decried that there were capital requirements for Robinhood in the first place, suggesting that regulations were the root cause of the capital crunch. Altogether the hearing left no discernable path forward except that we should expect more hearings.</p><p>In all, as the fallout continues,<a href="#_edn16">[xvi]</a> the GME moment in the markets was a fascinating early case study that seems indicative of a broader power struggle going on between CeFi/ TradFi and these new movements of younger, digitally adept, social media fueled movements. I view this as likely a beginning rather than a one-off, where we can look forward to additional skirmishes breaking out with increasing frequency as well as corresponding pressure on regulators to address them. And by address them, I do not mean playing whack-a-mole through enforcement efforts –aside from evaluating the need for more movement in the accredited investor definition in the short term, maybe it is an opportunity for market regulators to reexamine underlying regulatory bias more broadly as this has shown a spotlight on the need, and the market demand, for new opportunities for younger generations to build wealth. Technology can, and is being leveraged by younger generations to help broaden access to opportunities to build wealth and capital. It is also not a zero-sum proposition for regulators. The SEC can and must embrace technology that facilitates capital formation to effectively fulfill their mandate, while still keeping sight of their other regulatory objectives around investor protection and maintaining market integrity. At a philosophical level, there is a balance to be struck by regulators in investor protection efforts. As Hester Peirce characterized it, that is “to remind people of some basic truths about participating in the markets” and the risks attendant, while — and this is key, still “respecting people’s right and capacity to make their own decisions.”<a href="#_edn17">[xvii]</a></p><p><a href="#_ednref1">[i]</a> To be sure, as Hester Peirce observed in a February 22 speech, the GME saga captured the “the top of the non-financial news feed” with reporting covering the events from all angles, including “the market volatility, trading volumes, regular Joe-to-riches stories, hedge fund losses, short squeezes, gamma squeezes, glee at sticking it to the “suits,” anger at trading limitations, [the] jumble of emotions as stock prices fell from their highs, and debates about the intricacies of market structure.” See Commissioner Hester M. Peirce, Atomic Trading, February 22, 2021, available at <a href="https://www.sec.gov/news/speech/peirce-atomic-trading-2021-02-22.">https://www.sec.gov/news/speech/peirce-atomic-trading-2021-02-22.</a></p><p><a href="#_ednref2">[ii]</a> By motivating force, I mean the social media fueled spread of the message that drew enough widespread interest to have an impact in the market. I do not mean Keith Gill, who touted a stock like many others have before him. For those in need of a central figurehead for the phenomenon, he did manage to come out of the House hearing looking like some modern-day folk hero though.</p><p><a href="#_ednref3">[iii]</a> Accredited investor rules, long the subject of critique, were recently expanded in 2020. Far short of a revolution, the amendment allowed additional classes of investors with certain financial credentials like a Series 7 and knowledgeable employees of PE funds to meet the definition, among other changes that did not amount to meaningful changes. See the press release describing the recent amendments to the definition, available at <a href="https://www.sec.gov/news/press-release/2020-191">https://www.sec.gov/news/press-release/2020-191</a>.</p><p><a href="#_ednref4">[iv]</a> Many have argued that the wealth test systematically disenfranchises any and all investors capable of understanding risk despite their income level, see e.g. <a href="https://www.marketwatch.com/story/lets-not-backtrack-on-loosening-accredited-investor-rules-11611936391">https://www.marketwatch.com/story/lets-not-backtrack-on-loosening-accredited-investor-rules-11611936391</a> (making an argument that I agree with, that “being wealthy is no proxy for financial sophistication”).</p><p><a href="#_ednref5">[v]</a> See various articles around lotteries as a source of state funding, e.g. <a href="https://www.ncsl.org/research/fiscal-policy/keeping-state-lottery-revenue-alive.aspx">https://www.ncsl.org/research/fiscal-policy/keeping-state-lottery-revenue-alive.aspx</a> and <a href="https://www.cbsnews.com/news/mega-millions-jackpot-1-6-billion-drawing-tonight-but-where-do-lottery-profits-really-go/">https://www.cbsnews.com/news/mega-millions-jackpot-1-6-billion-drawing-tonight-but-where-do-lottery-profits-really-go/</a>; see also Payday Rules Relax on Trump’s Watch After Lobbying by Lenders, The New York Times, <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2018/02/02/us/politics/payday-lenders-lobbying-regulations.html">https://www.nytimes.com/2018/02/02/us/politics/payday-lenders-lobbying-regulations.html</a></p><p><a href="#_ednref6">[vi]</a> See, e.g. <a href="https://www.cnbc.com/2021/02/19/citadel-billionaire-ken-griffin-defends-melvin-stake-against-what-he-calls-an-insane-conspiracy-theory.html">https://www.cnbc.com/2021/02/19/citadel-billionaire-ken-griffin-defends-melvin-stake-against-what-he-calls-an-insane-conspiracy-theory.html</a>; see also <a href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/2021/01/29/leon-cooperman-gamestop/">https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/2021/01/29/leon-cooperman-gamestop/</a>; <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gXxpdhsvaRA">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gXxpdhsvaRA</a> (Douglas C. Lane’s Sarat Sethi calling the GME short squeeze scary and that regulators need to step in).</p><p><a href="#_ednref7">[vii]</a> To be clear, there are retail investors that have lost money as well, my husband being one of them.</p><p><a href="#_ednref8">[viii]</a> The webcast as well as written statements for the hearing, entitled “Game Stopped? Who Wins and Loses When Short Sellers, Social Media, and Retail Investors Collide, is available here <a href="https://financialservices.house.gov/calendar/eventsingle.aspx?EventID=407107">https://financialservices.house.gov/calendar/eventsingle.aspx?EventID=407107</a>.</p><p><a href="#_ednref9">[ix]</a> See Lawmaker calls Robinhood helpline to make point about customer service, The Hill, February 19, 2021, <a href="https://thehill.com/homenews/house/539576-illinois-lawmaker-calls-robinhood-helpline-during-hearing-gets-voicemail">https://thehill.com/homenews/house/539576-illinois-lawmaker-calls-robinhood-helpline-during-hearing-gets-voicemail</a></p><p><a href="#_ednref10">[x]</a> <a href="https://www.cnbc.com/2021/02/19/aoc-wants-robinhood-to-return-payment-for-order-flow-profits.html">https://www.cnbc.com/2021/02/19/aoc-wants-robinhood-to-return-payment-for-order-flow-profits.html</a></p><p><a href="#_ednref11">[xi]</a> See <a href="https://www.institutionalinvestor.com/article/b1m2p1cv68bx56/Twitter-Freaked-Out-Over-Robinhood-Selling-Its-Trade-Flow-But-the-App-and-Others-Have-Been-Doing-It-for-Years">https://www.institutionalinvestor.com/article/b1m2p1cv68bx56/Twitter-Freaked-Out-Over-Robinhood-Selling-Its-Trade-Flow-But-the-App-and-Others-Have-Been-Doing-It-for-Years</a> (pointing out that the practices that Robinhood engages in are legal, with disclosure, and certainly not unique, and are used by Fidelity, eTrade, Charles Schwab and TD Ameritrade, among others according to SEC Rule 606 disclosures).</p><p><a href="#_ednref12">[xii]</a> See supra note 8.</p><p><a href="#_ednref13">[xiii]</a> <a href="https://www.rollcall.com/2020/02/19/as-congress-stalls-on-data-privacy-big-tech-tangles-with-states/">https://www.rollcall.com/2020/02/19/as-congress-stalls-on-data-privacy-big-tech-tangles-with-states/</a></p><p><a href="#_ednref14">[xiv]</a> Robinhood says restrictions on GameStop due to tenfold increase in clearinghouse deposit requirements, CNBC, January 30, 2021, <a href="https://www.cnbc.com/2021/01/30/robinhood-says-restrictions-on-gamestop-due-to-tenfold-increase-in-deposit-requirements.html">https://www.cnbc.com/2021/01/30/robinhood-says-restrictions-on-gamestop-due-to-tenfold-increase-in-deposit-requirements.html</a></p><p><a href="#_ednref15">[xv]</a> Id.</p><p><a href="#_ednref16">[xvi]</a> As Hester Peirce noted, “The Securities and Exchange Commission, along with other regulators and market watchers, is still sorting through the many layers of those events, so [they] cannot give you a definitive assessment of what took place, let alone whether any significant regulatory changes or enforcement actions will result.” Supra note 1. For a couple of indications that there is certainly more to come, Maxine Waters has stated that regulators will be present to testify at additional hearings of the House Financial Services Committee and class actions have been filed naming Keith Gill. See <a href="https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2021-02-17/-roaring-kitty-sued-for-securities-fraud-over-gamestop-rise">https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2021-02-17/-roaring-kitty-sued-for-securities-fraud-over-gamestop-rise</a></p><p><a href="#_ednref17">[xvii]</a> Supra note 1.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=693393612733" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/crypto-law-policy-musings/on-gme-regulatory-paternalism-and-decentralized-market-phenomena-693393612733">On GME, Regulatory Paternalism and Decentralized Market Phenomena</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/crypto-law-policy-musings">Crypto — Law &amp; Policy Musings</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Breaking the Long Silence: The SEC Provides Guidance on Tokens (Part I)]]></title>
            <link>https://sh-brennan.medium.com/breaking-the-long-silence-the-sec-provides-guidance-on-tokens-part-i-9d13deff4809?source=rss-55e3fdb3b1cf------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9d13deff4809</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[cryptocurrency]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[token-sale]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[blockchain]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[regulation]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Sarah Brennan]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 08 Apr 2019 17:46:00 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-04-08T17:46:00.556Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>After what was, frankly, a painfully long period of silence, the SEC issued crypto guidance in the form of a <a href="https://www.sec.gov/divisions/corpfin/cf-noaction/2019/turnkey-jet-040219-2a1.htm">no action letter</a> and non-binding guidance through a <a href="https://www.sec.gov/files/dlt-framework.pdf">digital asset framework</a> on April 3, 2019.</p><p>Taking the no-action letter first, the SEC is responding to <a href="https://www.sec.gov/divisions/corpfin/cf-noaction/2019/turnkey-jet-040219-2a1-incoming.pdf">a request from TurnKey Jet, Inc. (TKJ)</a> which sought SEC assurances that it would not recommend an enforcement action with respect to TKJ’s planned token issuances. The SEC no-action letter lays out a number of factors that it considered in reaching the position that the token in question was not subject to securities laws. These factors are as follows:</p><ul><li>(1) The Company would not use any funds from Token sales to develop the Platform, Network, or App, and each of these will be fully developed and operational at the time any Tokens are sold;</li><li>(2) The Tokens would be immediately usable for their intended functionality (purchasing air charter services) at the time they are sold;</li><li>(3) The Company would restrict transfers of Tokens to Company Wallets only, and not to wallets external to the Platform;</li><li>(4) The Company would sell Tokens at a fixed price (of $1USD in this case) per Token throughout the life of the Program, and each Token represents a Company obligation to supply services at a fixed value ($1USD) per Token;</li><li>(5) If the Company offers to repurchase Tokens, it will only do so at a discount to the face value of the Tokens ($1USD per Token) that the holder seeks to resell to the Company, unless a court within the United States orders the Company to liquidate the Tokens; and</li><li>(6) The Token is marketed in a manner that emphasizes the functionality of the Token, and not the potential for the increase in the market value of the Token.</li></ul><p>What struck me first in reading the above factors is that the features are startlingly similar to (read: exactly the same) those shopped to us by the SEC over a year ago when we spoke to them to get their impressions about a client’s proposed token model. While many of the factors are unpalatable from a business perspective, factor (3) above, which restricts transfers of the token to the platform (to give the SEC assurances that there will not be a secondary (speculative) market in the token) was a non-starter. That factor, combined with the fixed pricing element also made the token model, in that instance, dead on arrival from a business perspective.</p><p>Well, it looks like the SEC found a project willing to move forward with them. What we end up with amounts to a consumptive (utility) token model mimicking a gift card to the company, albeit with more restrictions on their use than are typically attendant to gift cards. After all, you and I are free to resell (or regift) our gift cards to Olive Garden and REI if Aunt Becky got it wrong on our last birthday. In fact, there are market places dedicated to facilitating this resale market (see <a href="https://www.cardpool.com/">CardPool</a>, for example).</p><p>However, for 99% of projects looking to pursue a token issuance, this model would provide no upside and would entail added costs and it would make more sense to go with a traditional gift card product.</p><p>That said, the no-action letter is important because it provides a line in the sand for the crypto industry to use as a baseline — now comes the interesting part, which is testing the line for an enforcement action as we toggle the factors above to see, on balance, which of the factors need to be in place for the SEC to determine whether a securities offering has occurred. For instance, is the transfer restriction a necessity given the fixed pricing element (on sale and redemption) —or, does the fixed pricing element (and lack of a scarcity element in the token model) provide enough pressure on the pricing of the token to quell speculation in any resale market such that the token may be freely transferable.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9d13deff4809" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Regulatory Dark Ages of Crypto]]></title>
            <link>https://sh-brennan.medium.com/the-regulatory-dark-ages-of-crypto-3d8bbe6ee673?source=rss-55e3fdb3b1cf------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/3d8bbe6ee673</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[policy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[bitcoin]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cryptocurrency]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[regulation]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Sarah Brennan]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 20 Aug 2018 13:00:43 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-08-20T13:01:31.664Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>The Regulatory Dark Ages of Crypto</strong></p><p>I got through the July 16, 2018 hearings in the House. I intended to listen in the night of the hearings but had a head’s up that they would be dramatically disappointing so I took some time to gather myself before slogging through them.</p><p>My overall impression listening to the hearings is an overwhelming feeling of déjà vu — it feels very much like we are stuck in a time loop. As it turns out, from a legislative perspective, we have been running in place since the March hearings. Politicians dusted off their diatribes from March (Sherman strikes again) and generally used the opportunity to display little to no growth in their understanding of the space. Nor do they display a willingness to learn. Now I know I am being overly dramatic — there are pro-tech members of Congress, and I have a lot of respect for the members of the Congressional Blockchain Caucus — particularly for Tom Emmer and David Schweikert for attempting to educate their fellow Congressmen — because that must be emotionally exhausting; a black hole of their time and energy. Making it through these hearings alone felt deflating — the whole time, I kept thinking whatever happened to the ideal of “American Ingenuity”? We are letting it stagnate while our elected officials scramble to use every opportunity for self-serving political grandstanding.</p><p>First up, the more painful of the two hearings, the House Committee on Agriculture’s hearing on crypto held June 16, 2018 which, per its description, came about from the Committee’s “deep interest in promoting strong markets for commodities of all types, including those emerging through new technology” and through the hearing, the Committee promised to “shed light on the promise of digital assets and the regulatory challenges facing this new asset class.” As is the norm in congressional panels, the panelists were incredibly well qualified to be speaking and, unlike some other panels to date, they seemed to generally be aligned in their views of the promise of the technology:</p><p>· <a href="https://agriculture.house.gov/UploadedFiles/07.18.18_Fairfield_Testimony.pdf">Mr. Joshua Fairfield</a>, William Donald Bain Family Professor of Law, Washington and Lee University School of Law, Staunton, VA</p><p>· <a href="https://agriculture.house.gov/UploadedFiles/07.18.18_Baldet_Testimony.pdf">Ms. Amber Baldet</a>, Co-Founder and CEO, Clovyr, New York, NY</p><p>· <a href="https://agriculture.house.gov/UploadedFiles/07.18.18_Kupor_Testimony.pdf">Mr. Scott Kupor</a>, Managing Partner, Andreessen Horowitz, Menlo Park, CA</p><p>· <a href="https://agriculture.house.gov/UploadedFiles/07.18.18_Gorfine_Testimony.pdf">Mr. Daniel Gorfine</a>, Director, LabCFTC and Chief Innovation Officer, CFTC, Washington, DC</p><p>· <a href="https://agriculture.house.gov/UploadedFiles/07.18.18_Gensler_Testimony_.pdf">The Honorable Gary Gensler</a>, Senior Lecturer, MIT Sloan School of Management, Brooklandville, MD</p><p>· <a href="https://agriculture.house.gov/UploadedFiles/07.18.18_Ness_Testimony.pdf">Mr. Lowell Ness</a>, Managing Partner, Perkins Coie LLP, Palo Alto, CA.</p><p>The opening statement seemed promising, describing the technology as providing a tool that, for “the first time… enables individuals to reliably exchange value in the digital realm, without an intermediary. We can have assets that exist — and can be created, exchanged and consumed — in digital form. The promise of being able to secure property rights in a digital space may fundamentally change how people interact with one another. This technology holds the potential to bring enormous benefits to each of us, <em>if we are willing to give it the space to grow</em>” (emphasis added). The goal of the Committee being to provide “a strong, clear legal and regulatory framework for digital assets” and to discuss “how laws should govern the issuance, trade and utilization of digital assets” in furtherance of that goal.</p><p>However, though the Committee espoused a “deep interest” my overall impression was that there almost seems to be a competition amongst the Committee members on who is least equipped to be legislating in this area:</p><p>· We are a long way from peanut fields in Sycamore, Georgia</p><p>· I am a guy that distrusts the Federal Reserve</p><p>· I’m a flip phone guy</p><p>· This is something that is really confusing to me… my wife and I watched a documentary on Bitcoins and came out more confused</p><p>At the same time, listening to the panelists explain in very basic reductivist plain-English terms the potential of the technology, the present and future use cases, and the need for well-tailored regulation, the feedback from the Committee seemed to range from brick wall: *blink* “I am still skeptical” to an almost militant antagonism. As a self-appointed spokesperson for the second camp, Mr. Soto seemed incredibly uninterested in absorbing any responses to his questions, let alone learning anything. He was generally rude and dismissive of the set of very qualified panelists, but was most aggressively disrespectful to Amber Baldet, engaging in a range of mansplaining to outright cutting her off mid-responses.</p><p>Given the Committee’s internal competition on who is most hopeless and unqualified to legislate in this area, it would, at a minimum behoove the Committee to do more listening than speaking. By showing a degree of deference to experts in the area, they might be in danger of displaying some investment in their jobs. Especially, given the espoused goal of preventing the offshoring of this entire space, a threat which the Committee (unlike the SEC in the past) acknowledges as real.</p><p><strong>Financial Services Committee</strong></p><p>Next up, the Subcommittee on Monetary Policy and Trade held a hearing entitled “The Future of Money: Digital Currency” at 2:00 p.m. on Tuesday, July 18, 2018, which promised to “examine the extent to which the United States government should consider cryptocurrencies as money and the potential domestic and global uses for cryptocurrencies. The Subcommittee will evaluate the merits of any uses by central banks of cryptocurrencies, and discuss the future of both cryptocurrencies and physical cash.”</p><p>The hearing had a similarly distinguished panel with the following witnesses, but this time with the inclusion of crypto-skeptics/crumudgens (whats up Dr. Prasad), as is only traditional in the crypo space:</p><ul><li><a href="https://financialservices.house.gov/UploadedFiles/HHRG-115-BA19-WState-RGarratt-20180718.pdf">Dr. Rodney J. Garratt</a>, Maxwell C. and Mary Pellish Chair, Professor of Economics, University of California Santa Barbara</li><li><a href="https://financialservices.house.gov/UploadedFiles/HHRG-115-BA19-WState-NMichel-20180718.pdf">Dr. Norbert J. Michel</a>, Director, Center for Data Analysis, The Heritage Foundation</li><li><a href="https://financialservices.house.gov/UploadedFiles/HHRG-115-BA19-WState-EPrasad-20180718.pdf">Dr. Eswar S. Prasad</a>, Nandlal P. Tolani Senior Professor of Trade Policy, Cornell University</li><li><a href="https://financialservices.house.gov/UploadedFiles/HHRG-115-BA19-WState-APollock-20180718.pdf">Mr. Alex J. Pollock</a>, Distinguished Senior Fellow, R Street Institute</li></ul><p>I was more interested in this panel to see if there was legislative movement on issues such as tax treatment, given that Germany recognized Bitcoin as legal tender and the IRS ruling turned in part on Bitcoin not being recognized as legal tender in any jurisdiction. Dr. Michel in particular advocates for removing barriers on digital currency being used as money, including the tax treatment. TL;DR is nope.</p><p>The Committee was also more informed and engaged than the Agriculture Committee, though this is a low hurdle.</p><p>Sherman gave his (predictable at this point) diatribe, calling for the wholesale banning of cryptocurrency and the mining thereof. The most interesting part of his speech is that, much like reheated leftovers in the microwave, it was dry and unappealing, lacking the vigor and emotion of his first dramatic reading. He gave the impression that he is almost certainly reading off a speech that was scripted in whole by aides, without an ounce of emotional investment in the issue.</p><p>Others focus on the use of crypto by different actors for crime, as if it invalidates the space in whole. This similarly rings hollow — you can make countless analogies that render this point absurd. Just because a plunger was once used by a fed up house-wife to beat her husband within an inch of his household-chore- shirking life does not invalidate its noble primary use case. This focus on the fact that crime is facilitated by something that operates as a store of value and we should thereby ban it, is strange to say the least. All stores of value can be used to finance things. It is an intrinsic feature, whether it be a cash, cash equivalent or commodities or whatever else people deem to have value (pogs, magic cards, beanie babies). They can be used to pay for your wedding, they can be used to buy tampons, and they can be used to illegally purchase horse tranquilizers.</p><p>Less dramatically, it brings to mind a book in read a long time ago but think of frequently, “The Ambivalence of the Sacred” which examines the dichotomy of “religion’s ability to inspire violence” and how that “is intimately related to its equally impressive power as a force for peace”. Religion is a rallying point, a unifier, and often as a vehicle to accomplish the aims of an individual actor or group of actors (whether that manifests itself into a religious mission to build a well or a school in a remote area to “Jesus wants me to get a private jet”). No is advocating a banning of religion (and in the context of certain religions and today’s political climate, let me qualify that with a *yet*) because it is used by bad actors as a rallying point.</p><p>To bring this around, and apologies for the juxtaposition of plungers and religion, my response is “don’t blame the plunger”. Dr. Garrat touched on this point that we don’t make things illegal just because they can be used for illegal purposes. Moreover, we regularly overlook the ambivalence of facilitating instruments, the means to an end, when it is convenient or we are aligned with the end. On one side of the policy spectrum, “guns don’t kill people, people do” has been a decades’ long rallying cry without any deep analysis into the role of guns as a facilitator of violence and death.</p><p>Issues around digital currency as a threat to the U.S. dollar’s status as a global reserve currency are real issues to be examined. Sitting through law makers bringing up point after point on cryptocurrency and all the inherent issues with what it has been used to buy, the John McAfee inspired “but — people will buy drugs and prostitutes” argument, and having the panels point out repeatedly that these issues are all inherent in the current monetary scheme, while satisfying in one respect to listen to the rebukes, this should be self-evident.</p><p>At this point, there have been numerous reports about how Bitcoin, as a medium of exchange, has actually improved the chances of law enforcement (over cash) to trace transactions by bad actors. Listening to these hearings where we parade these very qualified panelists out to debate topics for which they end up re-debating points that should now be established shows the inherent bias of the law makers raising these same points ad nauseam. Our legislature may have varied notions and positions but appear are preconceived. No one is learning from these hearings or changing their positions — what a waste of everyone’s time.</p><p>In the wake of these hearings, there have been a number of articles citing the need for further education but you can lead these guys to water but I am increasingly unconvinced that you can make them drink.</p><p>Can we please get out of this partisan nightmare on issues that don’t need to be polarized? How are we ever going to get to coherent policy in the U.S. without any inclination on the part of lawmakers to be engaged enough to understand the issues. The unwillingness (which prevents us from even getting to whether they are capable or able) to understand the mechanics or the potential of the technology, gives little to no hope of a legislative solution.</p><p>The space is composed of a multitude of actors, of crypto assets, with diverse goals and use cases. If we are actually concerned about crypto being used in furtherance of crime, we need to acknowledge certain basic facts around the varying properties of crypto assets (ie. cryptocurrency as a crypto asset class and operating from the basic premise that Bitcoin is distinct from privacy coins). And if we are actually worried about forming a coherent legislative scheme, and frankly I don’t think there is a credible argument that our law makers are interested in legislating after sitting through these hearings, we need to tailor coherent regulations around the actual and potential risks in the space. We are a long ways away.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=3d8bbe6ee673" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Contortions for Compliance: Life Under New York’s BitLicense (Originally Published in CoinDesk, Jan…]]></title>
            <link>https://sh-brennan.medium.com/contortions-for-compliance-life-under-new-yorks-bitlicense-originally-published-in-coindesk-jan-ea9ea1496728?source=rss-55e3fdb3b1cf------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ea9ea1496728</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[regulation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[blockchain]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[from-the-archives]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Sarah Brennan]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 26 Jul 2018 15:04:47 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-07-26T15:04:47.587Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Contortions for Compliance: Life Under New York’s BitLicense (Originally Published in CoinDesk, Jan 21, 2018)</h3><p><em>Sarah H. Brennan, a corporate and securities attorney, leads the blockchain technology, cryptocurrency and digital assets practice team at Lippes Mathias Wexler Friedman LLP.</em></p><p>In June 2015, in a race to be a first mover in the space, the New York Department of Financial Services (DFS) enacted the BitLicense regulatory framework, a licensing regime that covers substantially all “virtual currency business activity” to the extent it touches New York or its residents.</p><p>Namely, any business engaging in virtual currency business activity involving New York State or persons that reside, are located, have a place of business, or are conducting business in New York must apply for the BitLicense, with no grace periods or de minimis exceptions.</p><p>To the extent a business makes it through the licensing <a href="http://www.dfs.ny.gov/legal/regulations/vc_license_application.pdf">process</a> and receives a BitLicense, as a whopping four businesses have to date (in addition to two companies who undertook the application process and received <a href="https://www.coindesk.com/in-itbit-we-trust/">trust charters</a>), the BitLicense imposes significant operational burdens, requiring robust compliance policies and processes with respect to anti-fraud, anti-money-laundering, cybersecurity, privacy and information security, among other requirements.</p><p>As such, the BitLicense has prompted flight from New York by larger players such as <a href="https://bravenewcoin.com/news/mass-exodus-of-bitcoin-exchanges-from-new-york-state-triggered-by-bitlicense-deadline/">Bitfinex</a> and <a href="http://pleaseprotectconsumers.org/">Shapeshift</a> and has had a chilling effect on others acting in an abundance of caution.</p><p>For those of us who remain in New York because we happen to live here, there is a widespread sense of confusion as to the scope of activities which fall under the purview of the regulations given: their vague wording, requirements that seem <a href="https://www.americanbanker.com/news/nys-lawsky-considering-strict-cybersecurity-regime-for-banks">positioned toward financial institutions</a> and the lack of formal guidance in the wake of the enactment of the regulations.</p><p>In all, uncertainty as to the reach of the licensing requirement has left many companies with three options: avoid doing business in New York entirely, attempt to structure a business around the law, or engage in potential or outright non-compliance with the law.</p><p>Based on the fact that DFS has received <a href="https://www.reuters.com/article/us-bitcoin-regulations-dfs/new-yorks-bitcoin-hub-dreams-fade-with-licensing-backlog-idUSKBN12V0CM">so few applicants</a> to date, and has only<a href="http://www.dfs.ny.gov/about/press/pr1703221.htm)"> five rejected applications</a> on file, one could infer that many are electing non-compliance.</p><h3>Case studies</h3><p>Drone Energy and Travel by Token are two Empire State-based clients of mine running very different businesses, but with the common concern of operating in line with best practices.</p><p>These businesses, in addition to complying with applicable foreign, federal and state regulatory regimes (existing and as they develop), are expending a significant amount of time and energy to structure around the BitLicense.</p><p>For example, Drone Energy has a patented solution and an innovative business model designed around mining cryptocurrency. While it would be helpful for this exemption to have been explicit in the text of the BitLicense regulations, <a href="https://www.coindesk.com/lawsky-bitcoin-developers-miners-exempt-bitlicense/">DFS has indicated in public comments</a> that mining activities are categorically outside the scope of the law.</p><p>However, the business will at some point look to exit to U.S. dollars without tripping into the definition of “virtual currency business activities.” This has been limiting as we have discussed various potential business models but something our client is able and willing to work around.</p><p>The other client, Travel by Token (<a href="https://www.travelbytoken.com/">TBT</a>), is an early-stage start-up that uses an AirBnB/timeshare hybrid model for vacation stays, providing token holders access to vacation properties purchased and held by the company for the exclusive use of token holders at below-market prices.</p><p>As the token is in the development stage, we are in the clear to develop the underlying software in New York State under the BitLicense regulations. But the company will need to leave the state before commencing a token offering and hazarding being deemed to be “controlling, administering, [and/]or issuing a Virtual Currency” under <a href="http://www.dfs.ny.gov/legal/regulations/adoptions/dfsp200t.pdf">Section 200.2(q)(5)</a> of the BitLicense regulations.</p><p>While providing a viable path forward, structuring business plans and transactions to avoid the BitLicense is not a small or inexpensive undertaking.</p><p>For an example of how regulations interact, given the developments in securities laws over the course of December alone, in order to conduct a utility token offering (whether for Travel by Token or for another New York State-based client) we are considering the following as a potential workaround to the BitLicense as it interacts with applicable securities laws:</p><ul><li>Structuring an initial offering as a <a href="https://www.sec.gov/fast-answers/answers-rule506htm.html">506(c)</a>-compliant Simple Agreement for Future Tokens (<a href="https://saftproject.com/">SAFT</a>) offering, using a <a href="https://www.coindesk.com/whered-get-token-7-platforms-managing-icos/">third-party service provider </a>to verify accredited investors and for AML/KYC compliance, to the extent we do initial raises in New York because the SAFT, while squarely an investment contract subject to securities laws, should not trip the BitLicense as no tokens are issued;</li><li>Use funds raised in SAFT offering to continue to develop the token and move the business out-of-state and/or build out the organizational structure and form an affiliate to conduct the offering in a friendlier jurisdiction;</li><li>Subsequent to reorganizing the business, in the next iteration of funding, through a token offering:</li><li>At the time of the token offering, we would evaluate the state of securities laws with respect to whether utility tokens that are immediately usable in exchange for a service or product constitute securities in the eyes of the Securities and Exchange Commission and/or state regulators. This would inform us as to whether there is a need to comply with securities laws in the larger offering. However, even if we take the position that a token is not a security based on the <a href="https://corpgov.law.harvard.edu/2017/10/30/sec-enforcement-against-initial-coin-offering/">Howey test</a>, we would likely expend the effort to produce offering materials with robust securities law type disclosures;</li><li>We would, absent DFS guidance, plan to block New York State residents (and any others in jurisdictions that give rise to compliance concerns) from participating because, taking a conservative approach, all issuers will likely need a BitLicense to conduct any sort of token offering if based in the state or offering to state residents.</li></ul><p>The above process only relates to fundraising and is based on the current state of the law as we understand it (literally) today.</p><p>New York passed the BitLicense regulations in a regulatory vacuum and now state and federal laws are catching up to it, oftentimes with less-than-stellar coordination between regulators, causing a compliance nightmare.</p><h3>Next steps</h3><p>Absent a <a href="https://www.coindesk.com/judge-dismisses-long-shot-bid-overturn-new-york-bitcoin-law/">successful</a> challenge to the BitLicense regulations in court, and short of the DFS (or the state legislature) reworking the rules in line with the Uniform Law Commission <a href="http://www.uniformlaws.org/Committee.aspx?title=Regulation%20of%20Virtual%20Currency%20Businesses%20Act">framework</a>, it would be helpful for the DFS to issue more expansive guidance than the bare-bones <a href="http://www.dfs.ny.gov/legal/regulations/bitlicense_reg_framework_faq.htm">FAQs</a> posted on its website.</p><p>We will also learn the limits of the law the hard way — through enforcement actions, though there have been none to date.</p><p>However, further clarification (in whatever form it takes) should provide comfort in the space and limit further exits as well as complex structuring exercises.</p><p><a href="https://www.shutterstock.com/image-photo/man-performing-backbend-pose-on-mat-686791597"><em>Contortion</em></a><em> image via Shutterstock</em></p><p><em>The leader in blockchain news, CoinDesk is a media outlet that strives for the highest journalistic standards and abides by a </em><a href="https://www.coindesk.com/editorial-policy/"><em>strict set of editorial policies</em></a><em>. CoinDesk is an independent operating subsidiary of Digital Currency Group, which invests in cryptocurrencies and blockchain startups.</em></p><p><em>This article is intended as a news item to inform our readers of various events and developments that affect, or that might in the future affect, the value of the cryptocurrency described above. The information contained herein is not intended to provide, and it does not provide, sufficient information to form the basis for an investment decision, and you should not rely on this information for that purpose. The information presented herein is accurate only as of its date, and it was not prepared by a research analyst or other investment professional. You should seek additional information regarding the merits and risks of investing in any cryptocurrency before deciding to purchase or sell any such instruments.</em></p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://www.coindesk.com/contortions-compliance-life-new-yorks-bitlicense/"><em>www.coindesk.com</em></a><em>.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ea9ea1496728" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[BitLicense Challenge Dead in the Water (Originally Published Jan 11, 2018)]]></title>
            <link>https://sh-brennan.medium.com/bitlicense-challenge-dead-in-the-water-originally-published-jan-11-2018-c77ece25f692?source=rss-55e3fdb3b1cf------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c77ece25f692</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[regulation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cryptocurrency]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[bitcoin]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[from-the-archives]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Sarah Brennan]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 26 Jul 2018 15:02:47 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-07-26T15:02:47.095Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>By Sarah H. Brennan and Sean P. Balkin</p><p>On December 21, 2017, well in advance of the anticipated January 11th, 2018 court date, the New York Supreme Court handed down a ruling in <a href="https://law.justia.com/cases/new-york/other-courts/2017/2017-ny-slip-op-51908-u.html">Chino v New York Dept. of Fin. Servs</a>., dismissing the Theo Chino’s lawsuit against the New York State Department of Financial Services (DFS) due to a lack of standing, effectively ending the multi-year litigation. Chino’s lawsuit alleged that DFS had acted illegally and arbitrarily in enacting the State’s <a href="http://www.dfs.ny.gov/legal/regulations/adoptions/dfsp200t.pdf">Virtual Currency Business Activity</a> regulatory framework and accompanying licensure requirement (commonly known as the “BitLicense”) in an effort to regulate the rapidly expanding cryptocurrency space.</p><p>While the dismissal of Chino’s case may facially appear to be a strike against the cryptocurrency community, it is important to note that the case was dismissed without the Court analyzing the substance and merits of the claim. Specifically, the case was dismissed because the Court found that Chino lacked standing to bring the Article 78 action because Chino abandoned his BitLicense application midway through the process (without receiving an official rejection from the state), and, as such, had not exhausted all of his potential administrative remedies prior to brining suit in court. As DFS had not reached a final decision with respect to his application, there was “nothing for [the] Court to review”. With respect to Chino’s challenge to the constitutionality of the BitLicense, the Court similarly ruled that Chino lacked standing because he failed to show injury as “personal disagreement and speculative financial loss are insufficient to confer standing.” Specifically, the Court found that as Chino’s company never turned a profit, he could not show harm.</p><p>While it appears that Chino plans on appealing the Court’s decision, it would seem that any appeal is a long shot as, based on our reading of the decision, the Court did not find Chino’s fact pattern to be particularly compelling. However, in handing down its decision, the Court did indicate that the decision was not dispositive or a bar for any and all challenges to the BitLicense regulations — as it specifically noted certain fact patterns strong enough to survive a motion to dismiss would be heard on their merits. In attempting to determine which parties could advance a valid challenge to the BitLicense regulations, the first place to look may be parties who have already applied for, and been denied, a BitLicense. As of March of 2017, NYDFS references<a href="http://www.dfs.ny.gov/about/press/pr1703221.htm"> five (5) rejected applications</a> from Disruptor Labs, LLC, ChangeCoin Inc., Ovo Cosmico Inc., Snapcard Inc. and OKLink PTE. LTD. One or more of those applicants could advance a challenge to the regulations based on having an active revenue positive business in New York, applying for the BitLicense, being denied and subsequently ordered to cease operations in New York State.</p><p><strong>Disclaimer</strong>: The information in this post is provided for general informational purposes only, and may not reflect the current law in your jurisdiction. No information contained in this post should be construed as legal advice from our firm or the individual author, nor is it intended to be a substitute for legal counsel on any subject matter. No reader of this post should act or refrain from acting on the basis of any information included in, or accessible through, this post without seeking the appropriate legal or other professional advice on the particular facts and circumstances at issue from a lawyer licensed in the recipient’s state, country or other appropriate licensing jurisdiction.</p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://www.lippes.com/information/blog/corporate-law-blog/article:01-11-2018-12-00am-bitlicense-challenge-dead-in-the-water/"><em>www.lippes.com</em></a><em>.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c77ece25f692" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[SEC Settles Charges in Bitcoin-Denominated Offering (Originally Published Wednesday, June 11, 2014)]]></title>
            <link>https://sh-brennan.medium.com/sec-settles-charges-in-bitcoin-denominated-offering-originally-published-wednesday-june-11-2014-a1a0af10887c?source=rss-55e3fdb3b1cf------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a1a0af10887c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[from-the-archives]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[bitcoin]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Sarah Brennan]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 26 Jul 2018 14:56:57 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-07-26T14:56:57.272Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>On June 3, 2014, the Securities and Exchange Commission (the “SEC”) announced that it had settled with Erik T. Voorhees, a well-known founder of Bitcoin start-up companies, in connection with allegations that Voorhees conducted unregistered Bitcoin-denominated offerings over the internet in 2012 and 2013.</p><p>The SEC alleges that Voorhees distributed prospectuses and actively solicited investors to buy shares in FeedZeBirds and SatoshiDICE, two ventures co-owned by Voorhees. However, despite making general solicitations, Voorhees failed to file registration statements in connection with the offerings and no exemptions from registration were applicable to these offerings.</p><p>Voorhees agreed to settle with the SEC by paying more than $15,000 in disgorgement of profits plus a $35,000 penalty.</p><p>Bitcoin is a digital currency created (or “mined”) with no central repository and no single administrator, which is traded electronically. Bitcoins can be bought, sold and traded for traditional currencies using online exchanges and used to purchase goods online at an increasing number of mainstream merchants, such as Overstock.com.</p><p>The enforcement action signals the SEC’s continued focus on Bitcoin and other digital currencies. Andrew J. Ceresney, director of the SEC’s Division of Enforcement, said of the enforcement action that the SEC “will continue to focus on enforcing our rules and regulations as they apply to digital currencies” and that “[a]ll issuers selling securities to the public must comply with the registration provisions of the securities laws, including issuers who seek to raise funds using Bitcoin.”</p><p>Earlier this year, Cersney was quoted as saying that the SEC is “very focused” on evaluating the legality of Bitcoin-denominated stock exchanges given that securities trading platforms are required to be licensed in the U.S.</p><p>In May, the SEC issued an Investor Alert on Bitcoin and Other Virtual Currency-Related Investments, citing the potential risks of investments involving digital currency, including the potential for fraud.</p><p>Given the heightened scrutiny, we expect to see future SEC investigations and enforcement efforts regarding Bitcoin in the succeeding months.</p><p><a href="https://www.lippes.com/talent/profile:sarah-h-brennan/"><em>Sarah Brennan</em></a><em> at </em><a href="/service/mailto:sbrennan@lippes.com"><em>sbrennan@lippes.com.</em></a></p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://www.lippes.com/information/news/in-the-news/article:06-11-2014-12-00am-sec-settles-charges-in-bitcoin-denominated-offering/"><em>www.lippes.com</em></a><em>.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a1a0af10887c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[NY OAG Tries Its Hand at Crypto Regulation: Expert Take (Originally Published on CoinTelegraph on…]]></title>
            <link>https://sh-brennan.medium.com/ny-oag-tries-its-hand-at-crypto-regulation-expert-take-originally-published-on-cointelegraph-on-3a52c718c262?source=rss-55e3fdb3b1cf------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/3a52c718c262</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[from-the-archives]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cryptocurrency]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[bitcoin]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[regulation]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Sarah Brennan]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 27 May 2018 23:58:00 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-07-26T15:07:25.911Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>NY OAG Tries Its Hand at Crypto Regulation: Expert Take (Originally Published on CoinTelegraph on May 28, 2018)</h3><p><em>In our Expert Takes, opinion leaders from inside and outside the crypto industry express their views, share their experience and give professional advice. Expert Takes cover everything from Blockchain technology and ICO funding to taxation, regulation, and cryptocurrency adoption by different sectors of the economy.</em></p><p><em>If you would like to contribute an Expert Take, please email your ideas and CV to </em><a href="/service/mailto:george@cointelegraph.com"><em>george@cointelegraph.com.</em></a></p><p>On April 17, 2018, the New York Attorney General’s Office (the “OAG”) joined <a href="https://cointelegraph.com/news/sec-cftc-irs-and-others-a-guide-to-us-regulating-bodies">the throng of U.S. regulators</a> vying to exercise oversight over various aspects of the cryptocurrency capital markets space. As announced in its <a href="https://ag.ny.gov/press-release/ag-schneiderman-launches-inquiry-cryptocurrency-exchanges">press release</a>, the OAG sent information requests (“Inquiries”) to thirteen cryptocurrency trading platforms, including some with (theoretically) no nexus to New York, as exchanges such as Kraken and Bitfinex <a href="https://bitconnect.co/bitcoin-news/826/ip-addresses-from-new-york-and-washington-are-banned-on-several-bitcoin-exchanges">purport to block New York users</a>. The information requests were characterized as “[a]s part of a broader effort to protect cryptocurrency investors and consumers[,]” marking the “launch” of OAG’s broader Virtual Markets Integrity Initiative.</p><p>The exchanges that received letters (the “Exchanges”), namely (1) Coinbase, Inc. (GDAX); (2) Gemini Trust Company; (3) bitFlyer USA, Inc.; (4) iFinex Inc. (Bitfinex); (5) Bitstamp USA Inc.; (6) Payward, Inc. (Kraken); (7) Bittrex, Inc.; (8) Circle Internet Financial Limited (Poloniex LLC); (9) Binance Limited; (10) Elite Way Developments LLP (Tidex.com); (11) Gate Technology Incorporated (Gate.io); (12) itBit Trust Company; and (13) Huobi Global Limited (Huobi.Pro), include entities that operate in New York and have successfully completed the BitLicense application process as well as those that have <a href="https://www.inverse.com/article/40144-binance-bitlicense-bitcoin-cryptocurrency-exchange-new-york-city">carved out</a> any New York presence and block New York consumers from their platforms.</p><p>Specifically, the Inquiries seek information on a number of topics of concern, including: ownership and control of the Exchange, operations and fee structure, trading policies and policies on suspensions of trading, internal controls and compliance with respect to privacy and AML and seek corresponding disclosures around the approach of each Exchange with respect to combating suspicious trading and market manipulation; their policies on the operation of bots; their limitations on the use of and access to non-public trading information; and the safeguards they have in place to protect customer funds from theft, fraud, and other risks.</p><p>The OAG press release cites that the OAG, as New York’s chief law enforcement agency, has an interest in the requested information as it is “the Attorney General’s duty to protect [New York] consumers and ensure the fairness and integrity of [New York’s] financial markets.” The press release cites undisclosed “published reports” which indicate the “sector” has “attracted fraudsters, market manipulators, and thieves” which, in their view, brings the whole “sector” into the purview of the OAG as it “is responsible for protecting consumers and investors from these bad actors and ensuring the fairness and integrity of New York’s financial markets.”</p><p>In response, it appears all of the Exchanges have indicated a willingness to work with the OAG with the exception of Kraken, which, through a number of <a href="https://twitter.com/jespow/status/986700932778934273/photo/1?tfw_creator=btc_manager&amp;tfw_site=btc_manager&amp;ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw&amp;ref_url=https%3A%2F%2Fbtcmanager.com%2Faudacity-crypto-exchange-kraken-ceo-tells-new-york-attorney-general-to-mind-his-business%2F">social media</a> posts, has been vocal in its unwillingness to engage with the OAG in this exercise. In fact, it’s CEO has explicitly outlined many of its issues with the Inquiry as well as some suggested policy prescriptions <a href="https://blog.kraken.com/post/1561/krakens-position-on-regulation/">here</a>. Kraken also ponders about the true intent of the Inquiry, indicating it may be a publicity stunt.</p><h3>Purpose of the Inquiry</h3><p>Given New York State’s history of interactions in the crypto space, which include the BitLicense but also more recently the <a href="https://www.coindesk.com/new-york-power-providers-cleared-to-hike-rates-for-crypto-miners/">announcements of electricity tariffs</a> that hit crypto mining companies, many are speculating as to the purpose of the Inquiry as well as the intent behind the broader Initiative.</p><p>The stated purpose of the Inquiry is to conduct “a fact-finding inquiry into the policies and practices of platforms used by consumers to trade virtual or “crypto” currencies … requesting key information on their operations, internal controls, and safeguards to protect customer assets” with a relatively benign end goal of analyzing “the responses, compar[ing] them across platforms, and at the conclusion of this process, present[ing] what [was] learned to the public.” While the results may be of interest to regulators and the public, the Inquiry is an aggressive move coming from the OAG from a number of perspectives:</p><ol><li>these types of inquiries into entities that operate on a national and international scale are more appropriately conducted by one or more federal regulators. The CFTC and SEC in particular have expressed concern over the lack of direct federal oversight of market practices with respect to these exchanges, including questioning whether the current state-by-state regime is appropriate.</li><li>more than half of the Exchanges that received requests have chosen not to interact with New York, many in reaction to the BitLicense regulatory regime. This gives New York less of a vested interest in regulating the behaviors of those Exchanges than many other U.S. states where these Exchanges would have an unfettered (subject to compliance with applicable law) ability to interact with the residents of those states.</li><li>(as Kraken has pointed out) New York should already have comfort on a number of the subjects in the information requests for the Exchanges that went through the BitLicense application process and received the Bitlicense or a trust charter, as this is a regulatory regime suited for banks and financial institutions that includes requirements around compliance, internal controls, and cybersecurity. Further, New York State’s Department of Financial Services (“DFS”) recently issued <a href="https://www.dfs.ny.gov/about/press/pr1802071.htm">guidance</a> to the BitLicensed Exchanges, reminding them to implement measures to detect, prevent and respond to fraud while being vigilant against market manipulation.</li><li>The OAG, seemingly somewhat self-aware enough to acknowledge that they are potentially stepping into the existing realm of jurisdiction of New York State’s Department of Financial Services (“DFS”), again as far as it relates to the Exchanges with an actual nexus to New York, notes that their role in this sector is “is separate from, but complementary to,” that of DFS, which, in their words “established a first-in-the-nation licensing protocol that requires virtual currency trading platforms and other firms engaged in virtual currency business activities to receive approval to operate and follow certain regulatory requirements.”</li></ol><h3>On Jurisdiction</h3><p>While it is also notable that the language in the request itself contains less bravado than the press release and is more conciliatory, the OAG will be able to change its tune to the extent New York residents have wrangled their way onto Exchanges despite efforts to block them. The request describes the recipients as being targeted due to their status as “major virtual currency trading platforms” rather than alleging that all have a substantiated nexus to New York and words the Inquiry as a “request [of] the participation of [the Exchange] in OAG’s Virtual Markets Integrity Initiative, which seeks to protect the interests of New York residents who trade virtual currency and related investment products.”</p><p>The OAG acknowledges the potentially tenuous nature of any assertion of jurisdiction over other Exchanges in the sample through the footnote stating that the OAG is “aware that certain trading platforms have formal rules barring access in New York and may not have a license to engage in virtual currency business activity in New York.” Among other topics, we are asking platforms to describe their measures for restricting trading from prohibited jurisdictions.” This line of questioning is the most dangerous for those that purport to have no nexus to New York as many implement the ban of New York users by (at a minimum) blocking <a href="https://bitconnect.co/bitcoin-news/826/ip-addresses-from-new-york-and-washington-are-banned-on-several-bitcoin-exchanges">New York based IP addresses</a>, which is known to be less than foolproof. See, e.g. this <a href="https://bravenewcoin.com/news/cryptocurrency-and-vpns-protecting-privacy-and-bypassing-geo-blocking/">article on getting around geo-blocking</a>. The OAG is well aware of this, when prompted on Kraken’s refusal to engage them, subsequently citing that they have <a href="https://www.marketwatch.com/story/crypto-exchange-kraken-may-have-to-comply-with-new-york-ag-push-for-transparency-2018-04-19">enforcement jurisdiction</a> over foreign and out of state companies that operate in New York (ie. interact with New York consumers).</p><h3>Next Steps in the Space</h3><p>In all, to the extent the Inquiry is not publicity stunt or a fishing expedition for data to underpin a fact finding that the BitLicense regulatory regime has resulted in heightened compliance standards, internal controls and the professionalization of those Exchanges that are subject to it, the goals and broader path forward for the OAG’s Virtual Markets Integrity Initiative remains a mystery — a mystery further clouded by the <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2018/05/08/nyregion/eric-schneiderman-succession.html">very recent departure</a> of attorney general Schneiderman. However, to the extent pursued actively by Mr. Scheiderman’s successors, it may well be the state’s first step into regulating the crypto markets under New York’s Martin Act, which gives the OAG broad authority to investigate violations of the same.</p><p>Despite the long term direction of the Virtual Markets Integrity Initiative, this seems to be another shaky step forward by New York in its attempts to produce cutting edge regulatory oversight in the crypto space and one that does not seem well coordinated with New York’s existing regulations under DFS or federal regulators. It is also a step taken at a time where there have been increasingly vocal calls to rethink the existing state patchwork of laws in the crypto space — replacing the current regulatory regime with coordinated and coherent regulation at a national and international level. It seems that New York, in continuing to aggressively seek a role as watchdog and regulator of the crypto markets, may be throwing accelerant on the fire under federal regulators to solidify a federal scheme that would serve to preempt the states in this space.</p><p><strong>Sarah H. Brennan</strong>, a corporate and securities attorney, leads the blockchain technology, cryptocurrency and digital assets practice team at Lippes Mathias Wexler Friedman LLP.</p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://cointelegraph.com/news/ny-oag-tries-its-hand-at-crypto-regulation-expert-take"><em>cointelegraph.com</em></a><em> on May 27, 2018.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=3a52c718c262" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[On Infant Industries and Regulation]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/crypto-law-policy-musings/on-infant-industries-and-regulation-f0ed073530fc?source=rss-55e3fdb3b1cf------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f0ed073530fc</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[ico]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[sec]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[regulation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cryptocurrency]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[blockchain]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Sarah Brennan]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 11 May 2018 11:45:40 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-05-11T11:45:40.420Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>For a regulatory framework to be effective, it needs to be tailored with precision to serve the dual goals of (x) mitigating risk and tamping down acts of fraud and malfeasance while (y) still enabling innovation and growth.</p><p>Especially in the context of an infant industry, it is incumbent upon regulators to nurture and support the space. While some governments have historically protected these economic ecosystems through trade protectionism, at a minimum, regulators should be flexible and an encourage innovation in their oversight and guidance of the space. As a function of oversight, they are able to set appropriate guidelines for behaviors in furtherance of public policy goals such as consumer protection. However, these guidelines must be in a form that is carefully crafted as not to erect unnecessary barriers to entry or unduly burden operations in order to support (rather than stifle) the growth, stability and long-term prospects of the market and the participants in the nascent economic ecosystem. The need for permissive regulation has been especially true for the crypto space — where the technology is still being developed and incubated; where many projects are not yet live and the use cases not yet implemented; and where it is hard to predict where the space will move next.</p><p>While some have criticized the SEC for making sweeping pronouncements that apply to the space (myself included at many times) —namely, that all ICOs they have seen to date are securities offerings, in retrospect they have shown great restraint in the space. This is apparent in conversations with the staff but also overtly apparent when compared against, say, New York, China and a number of other jurisdictions that have regulated the space at various times both proactively and reactively, with less than ideal outcomes.</p><p>The SEC, overseeing a market in which the overwhelming majority of token issuers have been out and about pre-selling tickets with a surprising degree of success to roller coasters that are not only not yet built but may ultimately be a tilt-a-whirl or, less ideally, a private yacht for the ticket salesman, has reacted in a measured manner. Watching over the space from a high level, they have carefully stepped in to set guidelines when warranted (or, from their perspective, reinforce existing law and actively tamped down fraud. By framing their pronouncements around what they have historically seen, they leave the door open for future projects to begin a dialogue with them to help guide token projects for which a securities law framework is inappropriate.</p><p>This measured approach is not without its drawbacks. There has been a yawning gap in the last several months in terms of public guidance or other regulatory movement that would help dictate to the market how to satisfactorily comply with securities laws in the token offering space, to the extent a project is attempting that path forward. Many securities token projects are attempting to navigate a potential catch-22 of structuring tokens and offerings to avoid 12(g) and TEFRA issues while running into uncertainties caused by the lack of accounting guidance in the space — this may serve to hinder attempts at successful registered token offerings in the space for those compelled to register (noting there is no platform to list on, as the ATS platforms are still in development and not yet live). Many are coming up with workarounds, but absent explicit regulatory buy in, the appetite of some for embracing these workarounds has chilled in the wake of the SAFT.</p><p>At the same time, token projects that attempt consumer facing tokens and currency-like instruments (ie. privacy coins, and stablecoins) have a similarly murky path forward. The SEC, by using this facts and circumstances test, while flexible and capable of shifting to cover the technology as it evolves, is taking on an incredible administrative burden for an agency with finite resources and a broad mandate. To the extent you tell this market that a“facts and circumstances” test applies / that there are no bright line rules/ that prescriptive guidance would be a “waste of time” while inviting projects to begin a dialogue to help get clarity — all parties involved in that resultant dialogue should expect that it will not be an efficient process as it is a significant time commitment (on a project-by-project basis and a more macro level) and amounts to a side gig for an agency that has its plate more than full overseeing Wall Street.</p><p>Though the SEC’s approach is time consuming for all parties involved, it is appropriate for this market. It has had the (likely intended) effect of chilling new market entrants as well as some of the less than ideal practices in the space. It has made the market aware that existing laws and regulations apply; of the need for best practices (see the <a href="https://docs.google.com/document/d/1DkAN3p7t0qefUOnvIkKS3PxgU6tCYEmCYxv2wBAeLng/edit#">Brooklyn Project’s framework for consumer tokens</a>) and self-regulatory organizations in the space; as well as the need to provide disclosures to protect the token purchasers (whether characterized as investors or actual consumers; see the FTC’s <a href="https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/blogs/techftc/2018/03/its-time-ftc-blockchain-working-group">past involvement</a> in the space and upcoming <a href="https://themerkle.com/ftc-will-host-a-free-cryptocurrency-workshop-in-june/?utm_medium=push&amp;utm_source=onesignal&amp;utm_campaign=traffic%20boost&amp;utm_content=extended%20%traffic%boost">workshop</a>) and end-users of their product offerings, once live. In this SEC imposed cooling off period, market participants can reflect on the goings on of the crypto capital markets to date and evaluate the tensions of fitting into existing securities law frameworks through the lens of co-authoring a path forward. It is through increased dialogue that pain points will continue to be identified, as well as corresponding solutions. As SEC Commissioner Hester Peirce recently offered up in a balanced and thoughtful speech touching on the role of regulators before the <a href="https://www.sec.gov/news/speech/speech-peirce-050218">Medici Conference on May 2nd</a>:</p><blockquote>I hope more people come to talk to me. I still have questions. For example, I understand that some issuers are conducting ICOs as private placements under Reg D. Does that approach work? Is there anything about our regulation of private placements that just doesn’t work with tokens? Should Reg D be revised in any way? Are other exemptions being used? How are those working? Where are the pain points? What can we do differently? How can we think through when a token that starts out as a security turns into something else? How should our thoughts on that question affect trading platforms? How should governance structures affect how we look at ICOs? What are some potential applications of distributed ledger technology in the securities space?</blockquote><p>Again, while imperfect, the SEC’s approach is a reasonable and light touch way to approach the space. As we have seen from the New York’s proactive attempt to regulate the space through the BitLicense regulations (though some would argue reactive as it was passed in the wake of Mt. Gox),broad and rigid regulatory frameworks age particularly badly in this space. Equally unproductive are the reactive knee jerk legislative and regulatory responses to reported ills in the space, such as the <a href="https://www.cnbc.com/2018/03/16/bitcoin-mining-firms-getting-pushback-from-new-york-state.html">crypto mining bans, moratoriums and tariffs</a> as well as <a href="https://www.newsbtc.com/2018/05/09/in-china-crypto-is-a-no-no-but-blockchain-thrives-according-to-md-of-the-floor-hk/">China’s ICO ban</a> and giving in to the temptation to <a href="https://www.cnbc.com/2018/03/14/congressional-hearing-devolves-into-bitcoin-bash-fest.html">label things you are unable or unwilling to attempt to understand </a>as fraud and only used to further terrorism and crime. Regulators have the responsibility to protect main street consumers and of the various approaches taken in so doing, the current lack of certainty around a securities law compliant path forward is decidedly more palatable than having no path forward.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f0ed073530fc" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/crypto-law-policy-musings/on-infant-industries-and-regulation-f0ed073530fc">On Infant Industries and Regulation</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/crypto-law-policy-musings">Crypto — Law &amp; Policy Musings</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>