<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Shana Dumont Garr on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Shana Dumont Garr on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@shanadumontgarr?source=rss-bd8a72c6747e------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Mon, 16 Nov 2026 00:48:39 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@shanadumontgarr/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Walden, Thoreau, and Sacrifice]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@shanadumontgarr/walden-thoreau-and-sacrifice-a903f3baf635?source=rss-bd8a72c6747e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a903f3baf635</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[nature]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[transcendentalism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[walden-pond]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[death]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[thoreau]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Shana Dumont Garr]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 24 May 2026 20:37:04 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-05-24T20:40:49.727Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>…the continuation.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*3c8vrmHk34w_3-vbJMhHvQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Concord Stop, Wachusett Line, MBTA Commuter Rail, View from the train, 2026.</figcaption></figure><p>The Wachusett line MBTA commuter rail train runs past Walden Pond, and I hear the same train when I’m at my house every day. This audible link takes me to the pond in my mind and has a calming effect. It is beautiful, it is amazingly deep,</p><p>As an aside, Henry David Thoreau’s survey in 1846 found the deepest point of Walden to be exactly 102 feet, a measurement that aligns with modern sonar readings.</p><p>There is a reason, beyond its beauty and location, that Walden Pond is such a famous place. <em>Walden</em> is also the title of a book by Thoreau, one of the Concord Transcendentalists, the son of pencil makers, a friend of Ralph Waldo Emerson, and a celebrated naturalist. So, what were these transcendentalists, such as Emerson and Thoreau, up to? They believed they could directly access truth/God/rightness, whatever words one might want to use to describe it. — They didn’t need to go through a priest, pastor, or book.</p><p>Thoreau was tough through his incredible directness. In <em>Walden</em>, he criticizes an Indigenous basket maker for not adapting more readily to capitalism, and sharply judges his fellow Concordians for being mediocre and conformist. He said, “I have lived some thirty years on this planet, and I have yet to hear the first syllable of valuable or even earnest advice from my seniors” (Thoreau 15). Soon, I’ll get to why I think he does this. But with his bold and memorable writing, I argue that Thoreau has become the closest thing we have to a local god.</p><p>Let’s consider the idea of transcending — that there is another place that is better than here. While alive, that perfection we can only imagine might guide our actions. That one day, when we die, we’ll go to a heavenly realm where we’re reunited with loved ones who passed before us.</p><p>There is a tension between the transcendental and the material, between what is imagined and what is accessible to our senses.</p><p>One evening, years ago, my family and I swam in Walden Pond. We realized something was off from the helicopter overhead. Then the boats came. Voices over a loudspeaker asked us to leave the water. We gradually left and then realized that a person had drowned. It was a young man in his late 20s, there with a group of his friends.</p><p>Another drowning occurred at Walden Pond the year before and the year after, all in July, the month Thoreau was born.</p><p>The United States is a young nation, and we look to ancient Greece and Rome for how to be reverent.</p><p>In ancient Greece, around 400 BCE, Plato, a student of Socrates, wrote about an ideal society. His writing often referred to perfect forms — that, if we can imagine it, we could reach toward perfection. He wrote about a heavenly realm four hundred years before the birth of Jesus, as though forecasting it.</p><p>Socrates: So, since gods are good, they are not — as the masses claim — the cause of everything. Instead, they are a cause of only a few things that happen to human beings, while of most they are not the cause (Plato 60).</p><p>Later: “Haven’t you realized that our souls are immortal and never destroyed?” (Plato 313).</p><p>Plato distrusted artists, including poets. He wrote, “Be aware that hymns to the gods and eulogies of good people are the only poetry we can admit into our city. For if you admit the honeyed muse, whether in lyric or in epic poetry, pleasure and pain will be kings in your city instead of law and the thing that has always been generally believed to be best — reason” (Plato 311).</p><p>In addition to founding continental Philosophy, ancient Greeks also lived by myths, including one about the Minotaur. The minotaur, or “Bull of Minos,” was the product of a love affair between Pasiphae, the wife of King Minos, and a bull that the King had failed to sacrifice.</p><p>The King and his family were ashamed of the Minotaur. He was hidden in a labyrinth built by an architect, Daedalus. The minotaur was ravenous and periodically demanded a tribute of seven healthy young men and women to be fed to him.</p><p>In this myth, Theseus emerges to save the day. King Mino’s daughter, Ariadne, working with the architect, Daedalus, gave Theseus a ball of red thread to find his way out of the labyrinth. Theseus was able to navigate the maze to its center, fight the minotaur to the death, and rescue the youths.</p><p>But the need for sacrifice persists. I thought of this that summer evening when that man in his late twenties, there with his friends, drowned in Walden Pond.</p><p>So, I wonder: when a person is revered beyond what one human can do or know, is that our way of understanding the mysteries we as humans can’t really solve? I was writing my own myth that evening to help comprehend the tragic loss of life.</p><p>I take the commuter rail to work, and I sit on the right side of the train so I can see the pond when we whiz by Concord. Someone spraypainted a stencil of Thoreau’s face onto a mural of Walden Pond at the Concord stop. This face seems to be asking me something.</p><p>After we die, where do we go next?</p><p>We can resolve the difference between what we imagine and what we can feel, see, and experience with all of our senses.</p><p>Jane Bennett is a contemporary philosopher who writes about the tension between thought and matter. She connects the ambiguity in nature, its innate lack of transparency, as an opportunity. Experiences observing nature are open to interpretation. In her book, <em>Thoreau’s Nature, </em>Bennet asks why Thoreau seeks out wildness. He saw those direct experiences as an antidote to convention, tradition, and normality. He trusted his direct experience, and, as Bennett has described it, transcendentalized the ordinary.</p><p>Thoreau, more than any of the other Transcendentalists, looked directly to nature. When he wrote Walden, he was most curious about understanding what of life is essential and timeless. He understood the urge for people to behave and prioritize reason as what limited them, what kept them from being their true selves.</p><p>I will read two passages where Thoreau delights in what he finds by Walden Pond. First, he describes the effects of the light:</p><blockquote>The whole bank, which is from 20 to 40 feet high, is sometimes overlaid with a mass of this kind of foliage, or sandy rupture, for a quarter of a mile on one or both sides, the produce of one spring day. What makes this sand foliage remarkable is its springing into existence thus suddenly. When I see on the one side the inert bank, — for the sun acts on one side first, — and on the other this luxuriant foliage, the creation of an hour, I am affected as if in a peculiar sense I stood in the laboratory of the Artist who made the world and me, — had come to where he was still at work, sporting on this bank, and with the excess of energy strewing his fresh designs about (<em>Thoreau</em> 293).</blockquote><blockquote><em>Next, a gorgeous passage about a Marlin:</em></blockquote><blockquote>On the 29th of April, as I was fishing form the bank of the river near the nine-acre-corner bridge, standing on the quaking grass and willow roots, where the muskrats lurk, I heard a singular rattling sound, somewhat like that of the sticks which boys play with their fingers, when, looking up, I observed a very slight and graceful hawk, like a night-hawk, alternately soaring like a ripple and tumbling a rod of two over and over, showing the underside of its wings, which gleamed like a satin ribbon in the sun, or like the pearly inside of a shell. This sight reminded me of falconry and what nobleness and poetry are associated with that sport. The merlin, it seemed to me, might be called, but I care not for its name. It was the most ethereal flight I had ever witnessed. It did not simply flutter like a butterfly, nor soar like the larger hawks, but it sported with proud reliance in the fields of air; mounting again and again with its strange chuckle, it repeated its free and beautiful fall, turning over and over like a kite, and then recovering from its lofty tumbling, as if it had never set its foot on <em>terra firma</em> <em>(Thoreau 303).</em></blockquote><p>Based on these passages, I think we could call Thoreau an earthist, rather than a Transcendentalist. We can’t know what is next. But when we use our senses to notice beyond what is expected, it enables us earthly beings to experience a kind of perfection in moments of presence. It cultivates trust in our senses and in the forms and beings we can perceive with them.</p><p><strong>Works Cited</strong></p><p>Bennett, Jane. <em>Thoreau’s Nature: Ethics, Politics, and the Wild. </em>Rowman &amp; Littlefield Publishers, Inc. 2002.</p><p>Plato, <em>The Republic. </em>Transl. C.D.C. Reeve. Hackett Publishing Company, Inc. 2004.</p><p>Thoreau, Henry David. <em>Walden. </em>Sirius Publishing, 2024.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a903f3baf635" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A Red Thread to Connect It All]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@shanadumontgarr/a-red-thread-to-connect-it-all-4e6318dca237?source=rss-bd8a72c6747e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4e6318dca237</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[dissertation-writing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[murder-mystery]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[greek-mythology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[columbo]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Shana Dumont Garr]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 01 Feb 2026 01:44:56 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-02-01T01:44:56.891Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Death, mystery, and gradually revealing</p><p>A few months into my PhD program, I was driving on the highway and had an epiphany: it’s all about death! I laughed merrily to myself as only those reading many philosophy books simultaneously might laugh.</p><p>The greatest mystery, the one I will never tire of wondering, is where we go next after we die.</p><p>Many of us who have lost a loved one wonder where in the heck they’ve gone. I understand my dad’s body is no longer animated, but where did his soul go? This can’t be so simple.</p><p>Does our consciousness persist?</p><p>Three years after my epiphany, death-related mysteries are indeed part of my dissertation, framed by the theme of bearing witness and the medium of video installation art.</p><p>My dissertation director asked me to revise my Chapter One by focusing on a throughline, “a red thread to connect it all.” The first thing I thought of was the obsessed detective’s board, assembling each suspect, clue, and location, even the subtlest of things that seem unrelated. The more winding the path, the more satisfying.</p><p>I appreciate how stories unfold in murder mysteries, especially “how-done-its” like Columbo. Between Columbo and Vera, these are the only television shows I rewatch. This might seem ironic, but to me the process of revealing is the best part, where deception and death intertwine.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*xwJkgskYeKCaRJC3wNID1Q.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>“The Minotaur in the Labyrinth,” Edith Hamilton, Mythology<em>, </em>Illustrated by Steele Savage, p. 158.</strong></figcaption></figure><p>Then, my Director said the detective’s board wasn’t what he meant — he meant the thread Ariadne provides Theseus so he can safely escape the Minotaur’s maze after killing him.</p><p>The Minotaur, who was born of love and imprisoned as a form of revenge, was considered a terrifying threat in Ancient Greece. Theseus intended to enter the maze and kill the Minotaur, who demanded the sacrifice of fourteen youths every cycle of tribute (seven to nine years). Ariadne swiftly and deeply fell in love with Theseus. In cooperation with Daedalus, the architect who designed the Minotaur’s maze, gave Theseus a red thread to help him find his way out. This Greek myth is about love, death, and sacrifice. It also associates clarity with care.</p><p>Edith Hamilton writes beautifully about it, in part because she retains empathy with the Minotaur. What follows is a quote from her book:</p><p>As an oak tree falls on the hillside</p><p>Crushing all that lies beneath,</p><p>So Theseus. He presses out the life,</p><p>The brute’s savage life, and now it lies dead.</p><p>Only the head sways slowly, but the horns are useless now.</p><p>When Theseus lifted himself up from that terrific struggle, the ball of thread lay where he had dropped it. With it in his hands, the way out was clear. The others followed and taking Ariadne with them they fled to the ship and over the sea toward Athens (Hamilton 158)</p><p>The Kate Winslet-driven <em>Mare of Easttown </em>features a strong female lead and could theoretically pass the Bechtel test, but like most other murder mysteries, it opened Season One with the body of a beautiful young woman, laid out in a stream like a sacrifice. To prevent further harm, the detective must find the murderer.</p><p>The idea that a body serves as a fact that drives the plot forward and hooks the viewer’s curiosity is part of the chapter I’m revising. The body&#39;s visibility makes it a priority to find those who trespass, robbing a person of their life (their body, their consciousness). As the process unfolds, the context behind the act ultimately leads to a satisfying conclusion, in which it is clear that the murderer will face the consequences of their actions.</p><p><em>To be continued.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4e6318dca237" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Universe is Collage]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@shanadumontgarr/the-universe-is-collage-d3adecc67dcd?source=rss-bd8a72c6747e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d3adecc67dcd</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[collage]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Shana Dumont Garr]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 04 Dec 2025 20:52:17 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-12-23T19:09:54.629Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*x9haYdjal7i36K-P1-nPpA.png" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 1. </strong>Todd Bartel,<strong> </strong><em>Anima Hominis (Bonum Electum)</em>, 2020 burnished, interlocking collage, xerographic prints on 20th-century end pages, pencil, watercolor, Yes glue, title page from “Everyday People,” by Charles Dana Gibson, Collier’s Weekly, New York 1904 (with missing artifact), “Bellman’s Map,” from Charles Dodgson aka Lewis Carroll’s 1874 “The Hunting of the Snark”, “Anima Hominis” pp. 54–54 of the “Orbis Pictus” 1658 (the first children’s book ever published in Europe), fortune cookie message “Willingness opens the doors to knowledge, direction, and achievement.” rudder diagrams of the Mayflower and a Boeing 767 (the plane flown into the twin towers), definitions of “tiller” and “rudder” (Merriam-Webster). Courtesy of the artist.</figcaption></figure><h3><strong>A Conversation with Todd Bartel</strong></h3><p>by Shana Dumont Garr</p><p>This interview is from the summer of 2022, right after I began my doctoral studies at <a href="https://www.idsva.edu/">IDSVA</a>. It is my honor to share this interview with <a href="https://toddbartel.com/">Todd Bartel</a>, a Boston-based interdisciplinary artist, educator, gallery director, and curator specializing in collage. Since the 1980s, his artistic practice has incorporated research into deepening the creative, spiritual, and historical understanding of the genre with a generous and wide-ranging curiosity that surpasses his own personal practice.</p><p>A few things come up in this interview that continue to be relevant to my research, which prompted me to share it now. One is the focus on arrangement as care. Todd’s definition of collage opens it to being part of a universal force. In his own practice, he creates the collages using the puzzle-piece method. This is far more sophisticated than the means we often associate with art collage, because the edges must dovetail on every edge, like a puzzle, and he accomplishes this by carefully cutting the paper to match.</p><p>Todd’s artwork series that we focus on in this interview, <em>Landscape Vernacular</em>, uses many found books from the nineteenth century, including illustrations and dictionary definitions. He combines the imagery and the meanings from multiple sources in a deeply intellectual way, and it was a lovely treat to have extended conversations with him in August 2022, including in-person and Zoom meetings. Our multidisciplinary discussion covers our interest in the genre of collage as a metaphor for how the universe exists, changes, and is experienced by humans.</p><p><strong>Shana:</strong> Todd, when we first met, I mentioned our mutual interest in collage, both as an artistic medium and as a way of understanding the world. It shifted us instantly from art world acquaintances to friends.</p><p><strong>Todd:</strong> Thank you, yes, I agree! Thank you for this wonderful invitation to capture some of our dialogue in printed form!</p><p><strong>Shana: </strong>You have said that collage is not only everywhere, but “the universe is collage–in the noun, verb &amp; adjective senses.” I’m hoping that in this conversation, we can parse out how this idea works both on specific works of art and in a philosophical sense.</p><p>If we were to begin with visual art, we could first define collage in its most recognizable form, and I credit the dictionary with the following: a technique of composing a work of art by pasting on a single surface various materials not normally associated with one another, as newspaper clippings, parts of photographs, etc. Your <em>Landscape Vernacular </em>series includes collages made with nineteenth-century ephemera. When did you begin that?</p><p><strong>Todd:</strong> In 2011, when I realized I had a collection of dictionaries spanning about 200 years, I wondered if I could find the moment in print when we separated ourselves from the definition of “nature” — a move of hubris on the part of humanity. That idea is what initiated my series and is how I eventually came to learn that René Descartes authored that concept, as my research eventually helped me connect his work to my inquiry. I’m not sure I will ever find a dictionary I can afford that was contemporary to Descartes, but I continue my search. [Todd from 2025 is happy to report he has since found two dictionary publicatoins that illustrate the separation, including <a href="https://theweirdshow.info/2024/03/17/reflections-on-nature-todd-bartels-artist-residency-at-weir-farm-part-1-2/">this one</a>.</p><p><strong>Shana: </strong>You describe progressive layers of collecting, then indexing and arranging in tandem.</p><p><strong>Todd: </strong>Yes, and I felt it helpful to consider things in as straightforward a manner as possible — such as with the definition of collage, I prefer a less limiting description, and the French, from my vantage, got it right. Certainly, collage in its most recognizable form is pasted paper, or as Modernist George Braque coined, “papier collé,” which is what comes to mind when anyone uses the term. Indeed, glued paper as the prevalent example is so ubiquitous that despite being a term only a century young, the original definition is nearly lost. The OED tells us that no mention of the word “paper” appears in the word’s etymology — “French, lit. ‘pasting, gluing’” — and that the first time the term appeared in English was 1919, in W. Lewis <em>Caliph’s Design</em> (52): “He gradually drifts into the habit (a sort of progressive collage) of bringing his lack of painter’s prowess and his nice feeling for art together.”</p><p><strong>Shana : </strong>Including paper in the definition would distract from the broader applications of collage?</p><p><strong>Todd:</strong> Exactly! I advocate for the emancipation of the word paper from the English definition of collage. When we understand that collage is glue, we have to ask ourselves what glue is and what glue can be, and that is where the term gets interesting. Glue is about connection. And the universe provides us with potent connective possibilities well beyond the confines of paper. Don’t get me wrong, I LOVE paper and use it more than any other material. However, I do not think the definition needs to reinforce the predominant material or any material for that matter. Emphasizing the meaning of collage by removing all references to materials would benefit our understanding of the word, the process, and the vast immateriality of the concept by exclusively centering on connective properties. And that encourages a deeper conversation about what collage does, intellectually, emotionally, and communicatively.</p><p><strong>Shana:</strong> I love a definition that centers relationships and what connects things. What subjects come to play in your artwork?</p><p><strong>Todd:</strong> In each series, I establish rules to govern how I find, mind, and bind — the three primary operations of collage. My <em>Landscape Vernacular</em> series uses book endpapers, and I research and try to piece together landscape history through the evolution of terminology associated with land, the history of land depiction, and the use and abuse of natural resources. Thus, I work with century-appropriate endpages because that unwieldy puzzle includes multiple histories: capitalism, industrialism, Cartesianism, and environmentalism, respectively. I collect a lot of material and use contemporary technology to reunite the images and texts I find on period paper whenever possible. I have a fair amount of materials from the 1700s or earlier, an extensive collection of books and engravings from the 1800s, and a plethora of materials from the 20th- 21st centuries. When I can only find scanned items of things from previous centuries, I look for affordable books from the same century and excavate those endpages, and then use xerography to return text/image to the papers from those centuries.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ab5oUY89k1Wyf06JxShw6w.png" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 2. </strong>Todd Bartel, Clearcut for Industry (Geomorphology), 2020, burnished interlocking collage, nineteenth- and twentieth-century end-pages, xerographic prints, pencil, Yes Glue, document repair tape, dictionary definitions. 22.625 x 24 inches. Courtesy of the artist.</figcaption></figure><p><strong>Shana</strong>: Continuing with visual art on a more macro level, I consider curating, another of your avocations, akin to the process of composing a collage. The gallery walls are like the paper or other grounds, the artworks, whether by one or many artists, the various materials, and the nails, screws, and other methods used to fix things in place are the glue. The space between the art creates a cadence that enables the contrasts and similarities in color, texture, shape, and content to inform each other and resonate in ways that create a more meaningful whole than the parts.</p><p><strong>Todd: </strong>Beauty, yes, but also care! When I curated the <em>Strange Glue</em> exhibition series in 2012, I wanted to claim the collection of three shows with art by 325 artists as my collage. I decided against a public declaration because I didn’t want to distract attention from the contributing artist’s expansive application of the idiom. However, I agree with you that curators are collage artists — anything collected and connected <em>is</em> curated! Hans Ulrich Obrist points out that the Latin root of curation is “curare, to take care of” (24–25). Curators, he writes, are public servants of “preservation,” “selection,” “contribution to history,” and “makers of exhibitions” (25), and they work, as you beautifully point out, Shana, to exhibit a “meaningful whole.”</p><p><strong>Shana: </strong>Both your artistic and curatorial practices demonstrate a prodigious knowledge of collage throughout time. Could you speak to the difference between ‘curated’/intentional/chosen collage and the ‘happy accident’ of nature- does your understanding of collage consider a deity-like higher power as the ‘artist?’</p><p><strong>Todd:</strong> Collage and intention, versus collage and accident? That is an exciting way to divide the possibilities. We can work with varying degrees of intentionality, and such options change the characteristics of the elements brought together in a collage. Nature throws many unexpected things together — sometimes at random and sometimes for discernible reasons. An accident of nature embedded the below-pictured wood fragment in the side of a tree — saved for posterity as a log by a photographer who collected it, captured the image, and with great purpose, glued the photograph of it to a card. The resulting collage demonstrates that nature and people have other ways of connecting things — wood/stick natural/selection.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/630/1*ij18-KhDL-_IR2qjPn5yig.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 3.</strong> 1800s cabinet card photo of a piece of wood lodged in a tree — result of a tornado.</figcaption></figure><p>A blank piece of paper is, of course, a collage of pulverized and liquified flora. I love thinking about tree material (paper pulp) presented in both the mounted photograph and the substrate board, the image of the tree itself, and the wood debris lodged in it; all paper, all flora, all collage. Chance operations and conceptual strategies open up marvelous possibilities for collage!</p><p><strong>Shana: </strong>Ooooh, what an image, thank you! It prompts the question of whether there is an author when beautiful things happen by chance.</p><p><strong>Todd: </strong>I don’t think I have the right words to express anything cogent about a “deity-like higher power,” but science has suggested something that works for me. In 2012, the discovery of the Higgs Boson (The God Particle) meant there was something in nothing, of which there is a lot in Outer space. Our limited human capacity to understand the relationships between everything leaves us with many unanswered questions and gaps in our knowledge, so there is a lot to put together. Collage is the perfect vehicle to point to things that yet need naming. As Gabriel Marquez wrote in <em>One Hundred Years of Solitude</em>, “<em>The world was so recent that many things lacked names, and in order to indicate them, it was necessary to point.</em>” Collage is a fantastic pointer! So I can only point toward what comes to mind in answer to your query.</p><p>For as long as I can remember, I have believed something connects me to the great ALL. I have felt, experienced, and intuited directedness and connectedness through countless moments of synchronicity. There are frequent moments in my life when I surrender to the universe with astonishment. At such times, I have always found myself to be an open vessel, allowing whatever I sought to be captured in a usable way. And since I am always seeking, I can typically recognize my query right in front of me. I can’t explain the countless things that have fallen into my lap, on my head, or magically appeared when I needed them most. But ask any of my closest friends, and they will all tell you this happens so frequently in my life it seems practically impossible.</p><p>Regarding the Great ALL and collage, I started consciously thinking about collage being the language of the universe in early 2001 when I took my 6-year-old son, Noah, to the Hayden Planetarium. There, I encountered a wonderful grouping of rocks and paper in a vitrine — elements from the periodic table and a quote from Walt Whitman that anticipated cosmic origins before science put forth a theory. In his <em>Song of Myself, 31 </em>(Leaves of Grass, 1855), Whitman suggested: “<em>a leaf of grass is no less than the journey-work of the stars</em>” — an idea that today expresses an accepted truth about the universe. While the concept of the Big Bang was not new to me in 2001, nor was Whitman’s poem, the juxtaposition of rocks and paper, in turn, validated something I could not find the words for until then: ‘<em>ever since the Big Bang, it’s ALL collage</em>.’ I’ve been saying that since 2002, but I first described it briefly in an interview on the <a href="https://theweirdshow.info/2020/03/23/discussing-about-collage-uncollage-and-everything-that-happened-after-the-big-bang-with-todd-bartel-part-1/">Weird Show</a>. I appreciate the opportunity to go a bit deeper here.</p><p><strong>Shana: </strong>Yes, when you first said it’s all collage since the Big Bang I didn’t necessarily disagree, but I certainly couldn’t have laid it out as you have in this conversation.</p><p><strong>Todd: </strong>I think it is interesting that art and intuition sometimes precede science. It wasn’t until Georges Lemaître deduced the universe’s expansion in 1927 and Fred Hoyle famously coined the phrase “big bang” in 1949 that we had a scientific name to attribute to Whitman’s poetic vision. And over a century later, the idea is expressed in cross-curricular terms. Neil DeGrasse Tyson (American Museum of Natural History) points out, for example, “<em>We are all connected; To each other, biologically. To the earth, chemically. To the rest of the universe atomically.</em>”</p><p>When I think of the broader ramifications of collage, I think of the relationships between astrophysics and particle physics — I wonder about all the different ways things can be combined. If the Big Bang theory is correct, everything, including us, can be considered atomic collages. There seems no other choice in this existence but for stuff to come together or be pulled apart again. Thus, the language of our universe is infinite recombination — collage. I like thinking about that. I can’t resist thinking about colliding galaxies breaking apart whole planets into bits of matter ready for another round of merging, or black holes’ inescapable pull, luring everything in its gravitational field, which I liken to hyper collectors — whole gluers! It follows that as parts of the universe, people are also accumulators, and collage is their common language. However, whereas the universe and collage have no bounds, people do.</p><p>If everything is made up of parts, and we are surrounded by stuff, then clearly, we must regularly figure out how to make what we find go together. In effect, we mind what we find as we bind that together. The challenging part of collage is the selection and the care to figure out how to make something useful, good, beautiful, or beneficial. While humans can’t control everything, we have certainly effected change in our biosphere with all the natural resources we have transformed and the fossil fuels we have synthesized, for example. Thus, considering collage as curatorial is more than just a helpful way to appreciate the definition of collage. Our natural world is staggeringly beautiful, but our world needs to be cared for right now. In the words of Joni Mitchell,</p><p><em>And we’ve got to get ourselves</em></p><p><em>Back to the garden.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*zuxztCNY8oRinFFTaNS8yA.png" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 6.</strong> Todd Bartel, <em>Ubercollage</em>, posted on Instagram 30 minutes after the world premiere image of the shadow of the supermassive black hole at the heart of the galaxy Messier 87. Credit: Event Horizon Telescope (CC by 4.0), April 10, 1919.</figcaption></figure><p>Indeed, Mitchell has a point. Beginning with René Descartes, we separated ourselves from the definition of nature, and ever since, we have been collectively sucking up the Earth’s material wealth with increasingly capitalistic detachment. Our Pale Blue Dot (Carl Sagan), arguably the only paradise in the solar system, is heating up with consumer culture’s friction — another kind of super collage.</p><p><strong>Shana:</strong> Your answer helpfully centers collecting in the consideration of collage, and I appreciate how you bring up the French source of the word, allowing for a more expansive understanding of it as glue. Collage allows for direct insertions of other disciplines and banal aspects of life into artwork: receipts, tickets, to name the most obvious. Their associations from outside of the art world become a part of the picture. They are of the actual world rather than mimetic, or depicted and recreated. Your example of the first use of collage in English by Wyndham Lewis refers to its practitioners as weaker artists, not as strong as those whose draftsmanship and painterly abilities more closely follow the Western Renaissance priority of illusionism and single-point perspective.</p><p>As a counterargument to the dated assumption that collage is an inferior medium to mimesis, I offer an example of how it supports alternative and experimental viewpoints and challenges the status quo. In 1920, Russian artists Varvara Stepanova and Alexander Rodchenko wrote a Constructivist manifesto, in which they dismissed art history in the context of Vladimir Lenin’s Communist ideology. In short, they were not a fan of how traditional art functioned as propaganda. The Constructivists considered material structures, formulated inventively, most capable of expressing communist ideals. For them, collage supported the articulation of their resistance. Their manifesto described the task as “the need to synthesize the ideological aspect with the formal.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/662/1*06_X09G1m79AouttcROR_g.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 4.</strong>Varvara Stepanova, Collage, ca. 1919, cut paper on cardboard. 7 3/8 x 4 ¼ inches. Private Collection.</figcaption></figure><p>A collage by Stepanova made in 1919 includes a photograph of a figure in a landscape, handwriting pulled perhaps from a letter, and other recognizable elements, but they have been cut, upended, and spliced together to form a new arrangement. It steps away from directly representing nature, yet abstraction is rooted in touchpoints to recognizable sources. Reshaped and overlapped, we see an example of what the Constructivists call “the real transference of laboratory work,” visualizing what they meant by being inventive and literally upending existing forms (Rodchenko, 341).</p><p>Rodchenko and Stepanova dismissed the weight of inherited history with their words and by collage. Created the same year as their manifesto, this playful portrait of Rodchenko by Stepanova exemplifies their Programme by innovatively utilizing design. The puffed, patterned pants look like a fractured globe, and superimposed letters prioritize the emblazoned text over defining the body. Humor comes forward as well as his face grimaces as though horrified by the thought of using old forms to express new ideas.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*htWTLOMN1on-9ns0jFj67A.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 8 </strong>Varvara Stepanova, Alexander Rodchenko (Rodtchenko), 1922, photo, paper, and gouache on paper, 23.5 x 18 cm, Private Collection.</figcaption></figure><p>How would you defend the medium of collage?</p><p><strong>Todd: </strong>In support of collage, I often point out that collage is the most fundamental and open-ended type of communication ever devised because it is the only form of communication that welcomes and can incorporate ALL other forms of communication or expression. Collage is the most democratic form of creation, and anything is possible. Of course, people are limited; we can’t glue two planets together, for example. Collage, as an essential principle of the universe, however, is boundless; forces in the universe can and do bring celestial bodies together.</p><p>The infinite potential of glue, thus, is not limited to physically sticky materials or hardware. When we consider alternatives to material gluing and pasting, we discover immaterial fusions within all couplings: feelings, associations, memories, ideas, et cetera. When we recognize material and immaterial bonds in unison, we activate collage’s full potential.</p><p>I coined the term “uncollage” in 1998 to offer credit where it is due in composite imagery. The “un” in uncollage is not an undoing — uncollage is not decollage, the archeological/historical subtraction of physical materials such as the work of <a href="https://www.smithsonianmag.com/smithsonian-institution/mark-bradfords-paintings-scratch-surface-conflicted-america-180967302/">Mark Bradford</a> and Mimo Rotella. Uncollage is cerebral coupling involving any number of human faculties, which infuse meaning beyond the physical/visual things combined. The “un” indicates “not glued materially.” Uncollage acknowledges intellectual bonds; immaterial gluing presents a universe of possibilities.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/728/1*QP-mVtaMCi4MOPiXQxGduw.png" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 10.</strong> Mimmo Rotella, <em>8 Sopra</em>, 1960, décollage on canvas, photo credit: yigruzeltil.</figcaption></figure><p>For example, the Stepanova and Rodchenko pieces you point out provide excellent examples of immaterial glue taxonomy: political glue. Works like theirs are potent because they immaterially connect with things not necessarily present in the actual works themselves but which, nevertheless, catalyze the appreciation of the specific materials they glued on cardboard and paper, respectively. Like Duchamp, who was against retinal art, Stepanova and Rodchenko created anti-art in the service of “intellectual” appreciation.</p><p>Stepanova’s and Rodchenko’s works exemplify the potential of collage to unify contrasting elements (ideas), edit and select precise parts of the world to contemplate, juggle varying points of view, incorporate contrasts, and balance differences even in a single piece. Harmony can commingle with disharmony in collage in so much as altogether the union establishes a sense of belonging despite anyone’s particular bias to the contrary. Such work unfolds over time and requires contemplation.</p><p>The problem with Lewis’ critique of collage is that even if there is a <em>“lack of painter’s prowess,” </em>his argument fails to value image juxtaposition as inventive and communicative. Lewis’s view may be dated, but it is still prevalent. What is problematic about such attitudes toward collage is that they belittle and ignore cutting and placing as acts of drawing and painting. Furthermore, they overvalue illusory semblance (naturalism and representation) in picture making and fail to recognize that to pull actual pieces of the physical world into a picture is to locate time and space as direct presentation.</p><p>Political glue is a powerful binder type, different from poetic, emotional, associative, or conceptual glues. It is a glue type that motivates not only a single viewer but also groups of individuals. In the above examples, political glue activates Stepanova’s and Rodchenko’s dissenting paper combinations as physical manifestations of their written ideology.</p><p><strong>Shana:</strong> This has the potential to scatter power. Those who don’t read their writings can get the idea from the collages. Ideas can be redistributed through their meanings and their actions.</p><p><strong>{The present Shana}: </strong>I’ve been connecting arrangement, a form of creativity that I’ve honed as a curator, with vibrant materialism. Associating these inspires me because those who arrange implicitly appreciate the immanence of each object or being with which they engage. Rather than fully transforming them, the components communicate their own characters. There’s some interesting potential when joining this line of thinking with Todd’s definition of collaging as glue. It could collapse the continuum of what is fabricated and what is found.</p><p><strong>Bibliography:</strong></p><p>Rodchenko, Alexander and Varvara Stepanova, “Programme of the First Working Group of Constructivists,” <em>Art in Theory 1900–2000: An Anthology of Changing Ideas</em>, edited by Charles Harrison and Paul Wood, 2nd ed., Blackwell Publishing, 2014, pp. 341–343.</p><p>Oxford English Dictionary, online, retrieved August 27, 2022.</p><p>Wyndham Lewis, <em>The Caliph’s Design, </em>1919, Black Sparrow Press, Santa Barbara, 1986, p. 52.</p><p>Hans Ulrich Obrist, <em>Ways of Curating</em>, Farrar, Straus and Giroux, New York, pp. 24–25.</p><p>Joni Mitchell, <em>Woodstock</em>, song lyrics, 1969, retrieved from <a href="https://jonimitchell.com/music/song.cfm?id=75">https://jonimitchell.com/music/song.cfm?id=75</a>, August 28, 2022.</p><p><strong>About Todd:</strong></p><p>Todd Bartel received a BFA in painting from RISD and an MFA in painting from Carnegie Mellon. He has taught at Brown, Carnegie Mellon, Manhattanville College and has been a guest critic at RISD, and the MFA programs of Vermont Collage, New Hampshire Art Institute, and Mass Art. He teaches drawing, painting, collage, and conceptual art at the Cambridge School of Weston (MA) and is the founder &amp; Gallery Director of the Thompson Gallery. Bartel has curated exhibitions at Knoxville Museum of Art, Art Complex Museum (Duxbury, MA) and he is currently working on a show at the Academy of Fine Arts in Kolkata, India, to open in January 2023. As a historian of collage, he is a contributing writer for Kolaj magazine. His collage-based studio practice examines the roles of landscape and nature in contemporary culture.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d3adecc67dcd" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[November Shadows and Light]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@shanadumontgarr/november-shadows-and-light-f330e26d9f6d?source=rss-bd8a72c6747e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f330e26d9f6d</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[historic-house-museums]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[contemporary-art]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[performance-art]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Shana Dumont Garr]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 11 Nov 2025 20:34:29 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-11-11T20:34:29.899Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/834/1*f5H2ooslrHEBmz9--Mg53g.jpeg" /></figure><p>This week, we prepare to do our final two performances of 2025 at the Gropius House, which is a great honor. We share special thanks to Wendy Hubbard, Site Manager and friend, who has done a lot of behind-the-scenes work to help us be there at the Codman Estate in May. In this photo, Deb and Sue spend time at the Gropius House as they prepare for how to share <a href="https://www.debtoddwheeler.org/studioprojects/no-sleeping">NO SLEEPING</a> at this beautiful site.</p><p>Since May, we have shared our work once a month at different historic homes in Greater Boston. At each place, I learned something new about subtlety. Like that feeling on your cheek of the air changing when moving from one room to another, and upon stepping outside, registering the shift in the air’s moisture, breeze, or scent. For me, the movement through these spaces, with a group of people who watched, felt, and sensed silently with me, reminded me that staying to meet grief is not always about words. The mystery can remain.</p><p>Now, we are in November, a month to survive. Daylight savings plunges us into early darkness in the afternoons. Work deadlines remain, while daydreams of holiday breaks to come seem still distant. For me, it’s also a month of serious personal loss. My grandfather, Ronaldo, died on November 10, 2005, of an unexpected heart attack. My father, Roger, died on November 15, 2001, of stage 4 colon cancer. As the cold and darkness increase, these anniversaries prompt me to enter the metaphorical rooms these memories inhabit: the dinner I was pulled away from when I received the call about my grandfather; watching my dad’s favorite TV show, a comedy, with my brother Andy when we knew, upstairs, his rattling breaths were numbered. I speak to them both more often at this time of year, and that raw confusion about where they went hovers especially closely in November.</p><p>The sharing of grief is a good way to transform it from a heavy weight on one’s chest into something else. As the curator of NO SLEEPING, I’ve given a lot of thought to how we remember in public and in private. Deb Todd Wheeler wrote a script that functions as the project’s horizon line: it grounds our creativity and helps us stretch forward as we continue creating the project. In this writing that has become a muse for all four of us, Deb mentions seeming stoic for not mourning before others. For saving the tears so they fall in private. Through her art, she shares the complexity of loss by foregrounding curiosity and stillness. Like the Stoics of the Western philosophical tradition, this mindset includes understanding the edges of one’s own influence and acting accordingly.</p><p>While we grieve as individuals, an important part of NO SLEEPING is becoming receptive to historic, domestic spaces. The losses, joys, and routines experienced in these houses might still hang in the air. Though we don’t hear those stories during a NO SLEEPING performance, we sense each other and the surroundings as Deb Todd Wheeler and Sue Murad guide us through darkening rooms at twilight. Inspired by the care involved in preserving historic homes and the grief borne of untimely death, the artists use light and a range of photographic and projection methods to facilitate an entrancing awareness of the domestic interior. Each sense is stimulated over the course of the evening, including taste, in the form of a non-alcoholic aperitif and small bites crafted by Megan Cronin, and before her, by Maureen Coffey.</p><p>Thank you to these spaces and the people who care for them for having us this year.</p><p>Meetinghouse, 1792, Harvard, MA</p><p>Codman Estate, 1740, Lincoln, MA</p><p>Loring Greenough House, 1760, Jamaica Plain, MA</p><p>Forbes House Museum, 1833, Milton, MA</p><p>Gibson House Museum, 1860, Boston, MA</p><p>Gropius House, 1938, Lincoln, MA</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f330e26d9f6d" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[“poets, those who force obscurity”]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@shanadumontgarr/poets-those-who-force-obscurity-3d2c3c1aaa7b?source=rss-bd8a72c6747e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/3d2c3c1aaa7b</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[art]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[performance]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[no-sleeping]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Shana Dumont Garr]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 09 Apr 2025 20:22:58 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-04-09T20:48:26.002Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/640/1*H3qMG_Ej2JWjrGLLHIM3uw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Deb Todd Wheeler, Gropius House, March 2025, pinhole photograph.</figcaption></figure><p>“poets, those who force obscurity”</p><p>-Édouard Glissant, <em>Poetics of Relation</em></p><h3>On Bearing Witness</h3><p><em>NO SLEEPING</em> is about bearing witness to spaces where loved ones once slept and to the care involved in keeping these spaces intact. By extension, it is a memorial to the loved ones who now eternally sleep. As the curator of this itinerant project, I have learned from Todd Wheeler and Murad how time and grief relate.</p><p>For months I have been asking myself what the next step is after bearing witness, which I define as an emotional experience with political origins and/or functions. No clear answers emerged.</p><p>What is the impact of bearing witness? This question also did not lead to interesting answers.</p><p>How do artists facilitate the process of bearing witness? Yes.</p><p>I propose that bearing witness is not a chronologically linear phenomenon. The “before” and “after” are beside the point. The time experienced while engaged with art like <em>NO SLEEPING </em>is eternal. Todd Wheeler and Murad facilitate a state of simultaneity by arranging objects, photographic images, words, affect, care, and presence (these last two words could be synonyms).</p><p>Making memory into form might be by and for those left behind to express gratitude for the part of the departed that we can still access with our memories. It might also be an effort or attempt to locate the part of them that is gone from our memory AND our senses. Deb chooses lo-fi photography to record the bedrooms intentionally, considering the camera obscura a way to “invite something that’s been dormant” (Todd Wheeler, artist statement). Her process finds form from the movement of light, which is a stand-in for time.</p><p>The concept of figuration elegantly bridges the disciplines of philosophy and photography because both practices are processes, ushering further into being what is thought and what is visible, respectively. The artist-philosophers John Cage and Édouard Glissant prioritize relationships — between people, places, times, art, etc. — over other denotations of meaning.</p><p>Writing about Robert Rauschenberg’s Combines, Cage explained how Rauschenberg unfocused attention with the objects he incorporated into his art. “This thing, he says, <em>duplication of images, </em>that is symmetry. All it means is that, looking closely, we see as it was everything is in chaos still” (Cage 100). This aesthetic fosters connections with intentionally open-ended outcomes.</p><p>The shift from house to house for source images and presentation spaces renders <em>NO SLEEPING </em>a nomadic enterprise. The many spatial changes — from town to town, structure to structure, room to room, object to object, witness to witness — encourage the repetition of stories, and from each telling, the impulse can spread in every direction (Glissant, 11). Glissant says, “this is very much the image of the rhizome, prompting the knowledge that identity is no longer completely in the root but also in Relation” (18). The convergence of form with light, and light with time, and so on, can be interpreted as assemblages that innovatively relate form, light, time, and space to each other.</p><p>Glissant considered the power of myth as he recalled Plato’s expulsion of poets in <em>The Republic</em>. Plato knew the unsettling power of “unforeseeable meanders of relation,” and he prioritized control over the incredible cracking-open artists can peacefully achieve (Glissant 21). Art can locate tension between transcendence and situatedness in one’s actual life.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*f_-KyKh0opozwNLoqZU2fw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Objects arranged by Sue Murad for an upcoming NO SLEEPING performance, April 2025. The light projector is part of the process of holding and photocopying held objects from the Shaker Meeting house (1791, Harvard MA).</figcaption></figure><p>The figuration of memory connects appearance to consciousness. Todd Wheeler describes her aim to see the unknown, time, and light as if it were the first time. Happenstance might tip into habit or ritual when it adds friction to the question of whether something is an object or a passage. She and Murad developed rituals for the audience to partake in during <em>NO SLEEPING.</em> When performing, Murad has an incredible knack for inviting those in her presence to notice in balletic, poetic ways. Anything in her line of gaze becomes revelatory. Time is suspended.</p><p>When writing about art, loss, and grief, the question of how ritual alters what one notices is relevant. Also, how much is ritual about changing how time seems? Ritual, including rituals composed by artists, can drop (or lift?) us into the eternal.</p><p>We might consider a similar relationship between consciousness and the motivation to make art, to make things that give form to the pain caused by the death of a loved one. People keep making memorials, remembrances, and tokens representing those we have lost, so they must work. Or maybe their persistence means we are all still searching.</p><p>I have learned that bearing witness is about the process, which involves being present. To bring form to memory ushers in change in a way that is less lonely.</p><p><strong>Works Cited</strong></p><p>Cage, John. “On Robert Rauschenberg, Artist, And His Work,” <em>Silence. </em>Middletown, CT: Wesleyan University Press, 1939, 2013. 106–109.</p><p>Glissant, Édouard<strong>. </strong><em>Poetics of Relation</em>. Ann Arbor: The University of Michigan Press, 1997.</p><p>Todd Wheeler, Deb. Artist Statement, NO SLEEPING, 2025, unpublished.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=3d2c3c1aaa7b" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Conversations with Trees]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@shanadumontgarr/conversations-with-trees-b957f6fe43a7?source=rss-bd8a72c6747e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b957f6fe43a7</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[trees]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[art]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[posthumanism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ancient-greece]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Shana Dumont Garr]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 14 Jun 2024 21:56:35 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-06-15T22:31:54.693Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>by Shana Dumont Garr</p><p>Art and philosophy are the lens through which this essay examines humans’ relationship with trees and how they cope with a fear of death. In the West, our attitude toward trees changed from ambivalence to admiration from prehistory to today. According to the scholar Robert Pogue Harrison, the eighteenth-century Italian theorist Giambattista Vico recounted a fable regarding “the logic of tragedy” wherein, just after the Last Glacial Period, “the forests became profane for a simple reason: they obstructed the communication of Jove — father of the world’s — intentions…in other words, their canopies concealed an open view of the sky” (Harrison 3, 6). When thunderstorms occurred, humans could not see the lightning or understand the source of the loud booms in the sky. They were curious, though, and wanted so much to know why, and to try to control the outcome of what from early interpretations were angry gods. Humans wanted to see the source of information. “Where divinity had been identified with the sky, or with the eternal geometry of the stars, or with cosmic infinity, or with heaven, the forests became monstrous, for they hide the prospect of God” (Harrison 6). Over time humans learned how to fall the trees and control the location of open spaces. A divide between humans and more-than-humans began to form, and the term ‘nature’ took hold.</p><p>It is effortless, after more than two thousand years of doing so, to see the world by how humans are different from more-than-human beings. For example, trees continue to stand after they die, their limbs still elegantly outstretched, their trunks robust. This characteristic demonstrates remarkable patience, is a good reminder about acceptance of the ephemerality of life, and life cycles made visible in the everyday. After death, trees continue to shelter their woodlands community such as squirrels, chipmunks, and many kinds of insects. Humans utilize the wood as tools and shelter. It is impossible to know whether trees truly accept this, but if embodiment is one of their ways of communicating, then they do.</p><p>In Athens, Greece, a huge hill topped by the Parthenon is the focal point of the city, dedicated to the goddess Athena during the fifth century BCE. Another hill, just as tall, stands beside it and does not come up nearly as often in cultural discussions. Called the Hill of the Muses, it is topped by Philopappos’ Monument and Mausoleum, dedicated to a prince who died in 116 CE. I was fortunate to climb it with a guide, Nina Papazoglou, who explained that in 1954, the prime minister Alexander Papagos followed his own individual impulse, rather than a democratic means for which Athens is famed, and hired the architect Dimitris Pikionis, whose designs were out of fashion at the time for integrating plants with his buildings rather than the Modernist style that was in vogue at the time. Pikionis redesigned the hill and restored the area. He prioritized growing foliage again for the first time since the first century — it was bare of trees for 2,000 years after they were clear cut to make boats for ancient wars.</p><p>From the peak of the Hill of the Muses I looked down — the metropolis of Athens, mostly white buildings and paved streets, stretched below me, bordered on one side by the beautiful azure ocean beyond. I admired the view, especially a deep green forest, the lone cluster of trees of the metropolis. It is Athens’ oldest and largest cemetery, the First Cemetery of Athens, founded in 1837. The necropolis, bordered on one side by an ancient road that ends at Hadrian’s Arch, includes more than 12,000 graves, with Christian, Protestant, and Jewish sections (Kostaki). The trees were left standing for people’s final resting spots, and their families who visit them. As the only place in the city with an expanse of woodlands, this convergence of a space for the observance of death and trees are left to grow caught my attention because I have been researching an installation by Maya Lin, <em>Ghost Grove,</em> created in Madison Square Park in 2021, and as a result the way trees help humans cope with their own mortality.</p><p>When interviewed by ARTFORUM in June 2021 about the project, she said, “each tree is a monument to climate change” (Yerebakan). Lin’s appropriation of the term “monument” to describe the trees so soon after 2020, the summer of unrest marked by the death of George Floyd, then toppled Confederate monuments and protests for racial equity throughout the United States, implies her contribution to and support of the ephemerality and redefinition of the term monument — distinct from but closely related to memorials — and calls back to her own origin story as an internationally recognized, divisive, and groundbreaking artist. The more ephemeral the monument, and the medium, the truer to the post-humanist world in which we now live, departing from humanism stemming from the Renaissance and Enlightenment attitudes, toward an attitude that humans are not the measure of all things. Lin’s <em>Ghost Forest</em>, in addition to the trees, features a soundscape of endangered wildlife, in collaboration with Cornell University. This focus on extinction connects with her website, WHATISMISSING.org, an interactive resource with a place to share individual memories, information about vulnerable species, and solutions, including restoration and land use reform.</p><p>At the conclusion of the <em>Ghost Forest </em>installation, Lin set aside parts of the trees for future projects, and much of the wood was built into boats by teens with a nonprofit organization, Rocking the Boat, and a South Bronx wood shop (Small). The teens also sail the boats after they finish building them. Transformation from one thing to another, and movement, or acceptance of change, provides solace. The Chinese artist Ai Wei Wei created the sculpture <em>Grapes</em> in 2015 with an artisan, assembling twenty-six Qing Dynasty wooden stools into a single sculpture reminiscent of a cluster of grapes and an example of matter in motion, the antique woodgrain arranged in a multiplicity of angles. The three-legged stools are typical forms in both Eastern and Western furniture. Wei Wei and Lin bridge cultural differences so the forms and the concepts connect viewers.</p><p>But, alongside ideas, we live with grief. How do we manage the passage of a friend of any species from living to deceased? The trees move from life to death in a distinctly different way than humans, standing strong but rather than feeling less, or other, in comparison to this aspect that we do not possess, we might consider the words of Vietnamese Buddhist monk and peace activist Thich Nhat Hanh for how it embraces cyclicality:</p><p>I am the cloud, the river, and the air at this very moment, so I know that in the past I have been a cloud, a river, and the air. And I was a rock. I was the minerals in the water. This is not a question of belief in reincarnation. This is the history of life on Earth (Hanh).</p><p>Hanh goes on to say the Buddha said he was a tree in one of his former lives to describe the continuity of life cycles and how the past, present, and future intermingle. Since I was a child, I’ve had conversations with trees: an energetic rather than a literal, verbose exchange, one with faith in things that cannot be seen directly. The main philosophical branch that Western culture inherited is from Socrates and his student Plato and their contemporary, Aristotle. Essentially, the Socratic philosophers put a premium on what can be proven with the five senses, and since then, that which can be seen and quantified has been more highly valued than the things that cannot. Art and poetics are mistrusted and secondary in this scheme of things.</p><p>To bring the unseen into balance, we would do well to also remember the first-century Latin philosopher and poet, Lucretius. Much of the message of the Greek philosophers was lost to Europeans in the Middle Ages, but monks working for the Vatican, and the Pope, kept looking for texts that were held safe at various monasteries throughout Europe. Their search was doubly challenging because at the time, books were written on parchment, rather than paper, which was rare. When more books and written surfaces were needed, they would take an older book, scrape off the older text, and write on that. Poggio Bracciolini, a book hunter and monk, found the last copy of Lucretius’ <em>On the Nature of Things</em>, written in 50 BCE, in a German monastery in 1417 (Greenblatt 181). Already the more vulnerable narrative, nearly lost to history, Lucretius’ ethos contrasts with the school of Socrates by poetically stating that all life is composed of atoms, and there is no afterlife or perfection. It leans into the concept of life cycles, anticipating twenty-first century molecular science and Thich Nhat Hanh’s message that we are all composed of the same materials then, now, and in the future.</p><p>In this segment of <em>On the Nature of Things</em>, Lucretius describes a charmingly straightforward renewal of flora and fauna:</p><p>But shining grainfields sprout, and twigs grow green</p><p>On trees; the trees grow, too, and bear their fruits;</p><p>Hence our kind and the animal kind are fed […]</p><p>Nature builds one from another, and lets no thing</p><p>be born unless another helps by dying (Lucretius, Copley 6)</p><p>Humanism has a positive connotation, but human-centric attitudes ushered in climate collapse and brought us to the threshold of extinction. In the model of metaphysics as set forth by philosophers including Socrates, Plato, and Aristotle, humans control outcomes by prioritizing that which can be measured and put less emphasis on the indeterminate poetics and arts. Humans become accustomed to controlling the outcomes of their fate, expressing less gratitude for what they receive, and along the way they feel an excessive sense of responsibility, closely related to hubris. What if we slow down and live more lightly? What if now is the time of gentleness and redemption? Post-humanists embrace the indeterminacy of matter and the concept of radical finitude as a means for reaching a redemptive state focused on connection, cultivation, and putting down roots, both metaphorically and literally (Staikou).</p><p>It is easier said than done to exist in the moment and let go of control. Even now when we hear a boom in the sky, it is scary, but we know it is thunder, rather than a message from Jove, father of the universe. Yet metaphorically, there are still booms from beyond, threats looming from the unknown that we cannot understand. Our non-human peers are also witness to these threats — humans are not the sole protagonist, though in our minds we are. When we realize we are in fear, we can consider that the entire world does not agree it is human-centered. There is increasing understanding of how our relationships with our non-human peers might shift from extractive to relational. When we spend time near trees in a relational, rather than a transactional way (such as, how many cords of wood could I get from that tree?) it enacts a vibrational exchange that tells us we are not alone, providing us with the opportunity to be receptive and listen.</p><p><strong>Works Cited</strong></p><p>Copley, Frank O, transl. <em>Lucretius:</em> <em>On the Nature of Things, </em>New York &amp; London: W. W. Norton &amp; Company, 1977.</p><p>Greenblatt, Stephen, <em>The Swerve: How the World Became Modern. </em>New York &amp; London: W. W. Norton &amp; Company, 2011.</p><p>Hanh, Thich Nhat. “The Heart Sutra: The Fullness of Emptiness,” Lion’s Roar: Buddhist Wisdom for our Time, <a href="https://www.lionsroar.com/the-fullness-of-emptiness/">https://www.lionsroar.com/the-fullness-of-emptiness/</a>, September 16, 2022.</p><p>Harrison, Robert Pogue. <em>Forests: The Shadow of Civilization</em>. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1992.</p><p>Kostaki, Maria. “Enchanting Necropolis: The First Cemetery of Athens,” This is Athens. <a href="https://www.thisisathens.org/arts-entertainment/sightseeing/first-cemetery-athens">https://www.thisisathens.org/arts-entertainment/sightseeing/first-cemetery-athens</a>. Accessed July 31, 2023.</p><p>Small, Zachary. “Maya Lin’s Dismantled ‘Ghost Forest’ to be Reborn as Boats,” New York Times, November 24, 2021.</p><p>Elina Staikou, lecture, Athens, Greece, June 2023.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*eFTv-b3VpkYW9DNN7y3N8Q.jpeg" /></figure><p>Yerekbakan, Osman Can. “Maya Lin on planting a ghost forest in Manhattan” <em>ARTFORUM</em>, June 22, 2021. <a href="https://www.artforum.com/interviews/maya-lin-on-planting-a-ghost-forest-in-manhattan-86134">https://www.artforum.com/interviews/maya-lin-on-planting-a-ghost-forest-in-manhattan-86134</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b957f6fe43a7" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>