<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Shatha Sbeta on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Shatha Sbeta on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@shathasbeta?source=rss-ce32b337ce43------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Thu, 19 Nov 2026 07:15:17 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@shathasbeta/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[10 years after the Libyan Uprising: A Personal Reflection]]></title>
            <link>https://shathasbeta.medium.com/10-years-after-the-libyan-uprising-a-personal-reflection-57963dec7e4d?source=rss-ce32b337ce43------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/57963dec7e4d</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[reflections]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[libyan]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[uprising]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[libya]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Shatha Sbeta]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 18 Feb 2021 03:03:16 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-02-18T03:03:16.350Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*RPB_gw8Pl9mim-6WueM_3A.jpeg" /></figure><p>On February 2011, I was 17 years old, studying the International Baccalaureate in Canada. It was the first time that I live on my own and away from home and family. I experienced the Tunisian and Egyptian uprisings with my schoolmates at school; but I did not imagine what an uprising would look like in Libya.</p><p>On the 17th, I woke up to the news in Benghazi. I was terrified but also excited. I was born into a family of opposition. I grew up with stories of assassinations and oppression- some of whom were of family. I, therefore, learnt the art of silence. But all of my silence was shaken that morning.</p><p>I spent my days and nights watching the news, excited that silence has finally broken, but I was also fearful of how the Gaddafi regime would respond. I recalled all the stories of killing and torturing that my grandfather told me. “Will I witness similar violence take place? Will my loved ones be safe? What can I do from afar?”</p><p>The only power I had was my voice. I used that. I spoke about Gaddafi’s tyrannical regime on multiple platforms including one of Canada’s national radio stations, and hosted weekly events to update the faculty and student body about the uprising. Soon, however, I came to realize that my family could be in danger as a result of my activism. Fear overtook me and I was no longer able to eat, attend classes, study or sleep. I watched the war take place, while I was far, feeling helpless, anxious and frightened. Soon enough, the government blocked the internet and other forms of telecommunications. I was 17, alone, in a country, culture and language that was foreign to me, and with this, I became unable to even communicate with my family or know if they were alive or dead. Insomnia, depression, anxiety became my reality. I was afraid I will end up living a life, along, with no family. So, they put me on antidepressant medications.</p><p>The day they captured Gaddafi and killed him was an especially strange day. I was awakened by my school mates, who were running around in joy and relief screaming at me “Shatha, he is dead. It is over.” But I did not believe them. I read the news, I still did not believe it. “What does this mean? What now? What’s next? what should I do?”. I was overwhelmed with complex feelings and I could not fathom why I was unable to feel joy and relief. I was thinking of those who died and those who were raped and the many others who were injured, the damages and the losses, the trauma. How can we heal and move forward from this?</p><p>I thought I celebrated the end of violence!</p><p>Today marks the 10th anniversary of the Libyan uprising. It should be the 10th anniversary of the end of tyranny. But have we ended tyranny or violence? Have the systems of oppression, intersectionally speaking, ended?</p><p>It is not surprising that we remember the Feb. 17 uprising with conflicting thoughts and feelings. The new Libya we all dreamt of is not taking shape as we imagined it to do so. But this, as well, is also expected. How could a state stabilizes after 42 years of political oppression, bloodshed, economic downturn, deteriorating social wellbeing and alienation? How can Libya democratize with ineffective and oftentimes non-existing government institutions, corrupted bureaucratic structure, and a political culture based on distrust and fear?</p><p>Uprisings, like coups are messy and destabilizing. It was naive of me to think that post uprising Libya will look better. Instead, post uprising Libya requires building effective democratic institutions, expanding political competition and participation and cultivating economic liberalization.</p><p>These may be good recipes for a successful democratic transition. But what about the sociological and psychological impacts?</p><p>Many of us probably feel disappointed at the current state of affairs in Libya. Public trust in government institutions is below 10% due to high inflation, coupled with low salaries, unemployment and lack of cash fluidity. Public service is extremely poor and weak. The middle class is shrinking, with more households falling in the poverty trap. Security and safety in the midst of militias, armed and terrorist groups, tyrannical military general as well as military foreign interventions.</p><p>So why celebrate Feb. 17?</p><p>I acknowledge that I am writing this reflection from the comfort of my life outside of Libya. Do I have a right to this uprising? Can I claim it mine, even though I was far? I am perplexed.</p><p>Watching Libya from afar, I feel heavy, bitter and powerless. I am saddened at the level of alienation we arrived at, as people. I see greed and selfishness, not only exercised by politicians, but by average people; like you and me. While the majority is no longer able to afford basic needs, others are showcasing their latest luxurious collectibles. The human value and relationships became materialistic often associated with a price tag.</p><p>However, I also see a phenomenal energy and thirst for change, innovation and progress. There is a refreshing bulge of young men and women who work tirelessly despite all the political, economic and social obstacles, to create positive change. I see public awareness, activism and action taking place to address a multitude of issues including but not limited to mental health, climate change, entrepreneurship, women empowerment and refugees and migrants.</p><p>Today, as I reflect on the 10th anniversary of the Libyan uprising, I am reminded of the sacrifices made during the uprising and the many more that continue to be made today.</p><p>To those who lost their lives in 2011, we would never forget…</p><p>Today, I feel sorrowful but hopeful.</p><p>May harmony and peace find their way to Libya, and may all of us heal.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=57963dec7e4d" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[My 2020 in Books: Religion, Feminism & Lots of Novels]]></title>
            <link>https://shathasbeta.medium.com/my-2020-in-books-religion-feminism-lots-of-novels-3d3b34e30d25?source=rss-ce32b337ce43------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/3d3b34e30d25</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[reading]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[books]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[book-review]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Shatha Sbeta]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 31 Dec 2020 00:05:08 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-12-31T00:05:08.773Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>My 2020 in books included lots of readings in religion, feminism, personal development, and novels. Each book signifies an important chapter of my learning development during one of the most difficult years I have lived thus far. To wrap this amazingly challenging year, I wrote this blog about my year in books. For each book, I provide a short overview. I also include an occasional anecdote about my experience reading that particular book.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*6qLndUi0P8wmVD5taXgf4g.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>Beyond the Veil: Male-Female Dynamics in Modern Muslim Society, by Fatima Mernissi</strong></p><p>In this fantastic study based on qualitative data in Morocco, Mernissi explores the connections and intersectionalities between gender dynamics, sexuality, religion, and state policies. She begins by providing a historical context of gender and sexual dynamics in pre-Islamic Arabia, then during the message of Islam, and the ramifications of these events on the current male-female dynamics in modern-day Muslim societies. With modernization, Muslim societies experience disorientation as socioeconomic and sociopolitical realities around them change. This, therefore, presents them with new social expectations that require movements outside the allowed realm, especially for women. The Muslim social order is based on the maintenance of gendered spaces, where public spaces are occupied by males while private spaces are the female territory. This is established through segregation, male authority, and conjugal units. Today, this order is threatened by desegregation processes, the increase of women working due to a rising need for female economic contribution, rural and urban dynamics. These changes along with pressures from the prevailing traditional patterns such as parental authority, states gendered family laws, and confusing sexual relationships caught in between attraction and repulsion present disorienting effects on members of modem Muslim societies which lead to contradictory identity formation.</p><p>This book was the last book I read in 2020. Reading this book has been especially fatiguing. As I read the chapters of this book, I found it difficult to disassociate myself and my communities from the realities discussed in the book. Although it used Morocco as a case study, the patterns discussed and analyzed were applicable to the Libyan society I was born into and grew up with. It, therefore, put me on a difficult yet rewarding journey of self-discovery questioning how I formulated the identities I claim today. It allowed me to see how I personally navigate gendered spaces in Libya and here in the United States. It put me face to face with the contradictions I internally struggle with as a liberal Libyan Arab Muslim woman.</p><p><strong>The Seven Necessary Sins for Women and Girls, by Mona Eltahawy</strong></p><p>Capitalizing on the #metoo movement that spread around the world in such a phenomenal way, Eltahawy wrote this book as a guide for women and girls to unlearn being soft-spoken, weak, and well behaved. Instead, she advocates for a curriculum that teaches girls and women to be loud and muscular to harness their power and refuse to be on the margins. The seven sins are therefore anger, attention, profanity, ambition, power, violence, and lust. All of which are attributes societies never describe “good” women to attain. Eltahawy emphasizes how patriarchy is universal and hence, feminism should also be universal.</p><p>Due to her approach, Monal Eltahawy has galvanized extensive animosity in the Arab world. Regardless of what I think of her individual approach to feminism, this book provides important reminders of how powerful societies are in engineering and programming our minds with socially constructed ideals and corrupted value systems. I am often called “angry”, “difficult” and “complicated” as ways to undermine my power and make question my assertiveness; because a woman is neither taught to be assertive nor powerful. Instead, women are taught to be submissive, stick to their private spaces, and obey authority. I used to respond to such comments with frustration; however, today, I take these comments as insight for my power to shake a misogynist status quo. I agree with Altahawi that we must teach girls to be loud, assertive, and powerful.</p><p><strong>Kafka on the Shore, by Haruki Marukami</strong></p><p>This mind-blowing Japanese novel comprises two separate yet interrelated plots of a teenage boy named Kafka Tamura, who runs away from his father’s house and finds refuge in a library where adventures overtake him; and Nakata, who is an old man with supernatural abilities who also undergoes a ray of adventures.</p><p>Murakami is known for his usage of elements of magical realism that were evidently present in Kafka on the Shore as well. The events of the story take us on a metaphysical journey of complex human emotions from love to hate and joy to anger vis-a-vis the world and nature around us. The elements highlighted in this novel are loneliness, self-sufficiency, fate, dreams and reality, and the relationship between consciousness and the subconscious.</p><p>I have always been a great fan of Haruki Murakami. His novels, plots, and characters reflect the influences of the Japanese culture. Reading Kafka on the Shore took me to a course I took in my first year of college titled “Persons and Systems” where I read many books on Japanese sociological structures and systems. Concepts of social relativism and moral orientation were evident throughout the novel. The characters omit the Japanese concepts of omote-ura, which are perspectives that describe the ways of looking at things in Japan; and tatemae-honne, which describe the outward appearance versus the inner reality. In Murakami&#39;s work, we see omote-ura and tatemae-honne in the ways Kafka and Nakata navigate their movements within their societies.</p><p><strong>In the Country of Men, by Hisham Matar</strong></p><p>This intensely emotional novel follows the journey of a nine-year-old boy named Suleiman in Tripoli, Libya during the oppressive regime of Gaddafi. His father, a member of the opposition, leads anti-Gaddafi activities which leave the family in a vulnerable fragile state. The book takes you on a journey of fear, anxiety, and anger associated with life under Gaffadi’s terror rule and the narratives of the lives of people who sought survival in the midst of political oppression. The book also takes on social issues such as gender and sexual tyranny experienced through Suleiman’s mother.</p><p>As a millennial born in Libya during the 1990s, there were some parts of the story that resonated with me. I am fortunate enough not to have lived the terror of Gaddafi’s public assassinations. However, as a child who comes from a family that opposed Gaddafi’s regime, I grew up learning about these stories. There was a scene in the book that vividly described the assassination of Suleiman’s neighbor and father’s friend on public television. Regardless of whether you have a similar story in your family, this scene is particularly traumatizing. In my case, however, my mother’s uncle was viciously murdered by Gaddafi’s regime due to his political activities. This book was a revisit to my family’s history and the struggles they had to undergo in order to survive Gaddafi’s heinous oppressive regime.</p><p><strong>Animal Farm, by George Orwell</strong></p><p>George Orwell’s Animal Farm is one of those books that you must read at least once in your lifetime. The allegorical novel is a classic satire of the 1917 Russian revolution that uses farm animals who rebel against their human farmer in order to create a free equal society where animals claim their autonomy, agency, and liberty. The rebellion created a new concept “animalism” as a system that governs the farm based on seven commandments: ‘whatever goes upon two legs is an enemy; whatever goes upon four legs, or has wings, is a friend; no animal shall wear clothes; no animal shall sleep in a bed; no animal shall drink alcohol; no animal shall kill any other animal; all animals are equal’. However, the animals soon discovered that greed and desire were present and the last commandment was amended into ‘all animals are equal, but some animals are more equal than others’. The utopian state the animals had hoped to achieve soon transformed into a state of dictatorship under a pig named Napoleon.</p><p>In his exile, Karl Marx wrote the communist manifesto as a utopian state society can arrive at if they follow the process of a socialist revolution. Marx highlighted the issues of capitalism as it creates inequalities and alienation between the bourgeoisie and the proletariats. As the gap between the two classes increases, a revolution is inevitable to take place. That is where socialism would be achieved as a preconditional state before communism where equality or production and consumption is achieved. Following these steps, Vladimir Lenin led the Russian revolution against the rule of the Tsar monarchy. However, the communist idealism soon disappeared and turned into terror and famine under Joseph Stalin. Animal Farm is a fantastic satirical novella that describes the events of the Russian Revolution and the Stalinist regime in astonishingly relating ways.</p><p><strong>The Alchemist, by Paulo Coelho</strong></p><p>Originally written in Portuguese, the Alchemist is an interesting novel following a shepherd boy named Santiago who travels to Egypt and indulges in supernatural events that teach him vital lessons about life and self-discovery. Two famous quotes received global hype from the book: ‘when you want something the whole universe will conspire together to help you get it’ and ‘to realize one’s destiny is a person’s only obligation’. The journey of Santiago from his homeland in Spain to Egypt reflects the inner makings and complexities of our human nature and powers.</p><p>For a young reader, this book is inspiring and transforming. It emphasizes the importance of dreams and dedication as we listen to our hearts. It is a fantastic novel with some magical realism elements that create a desire for discovery, love, and adventure. However, for an older reader whose life experiences have taught her/him essential lessons in self-love, growth, and development, this book will come out very gullible.</p><p><strong>Who Moved my Cheese? By Spencer Johnson</strong></p><p>This motivational allegorical business fable is an excellent short story about change, agility, rigidity, and adaptation. It describes changes in our lives through the journey of two mice and two little people as they hunt for cheese. As the characters realize there was no more cheese to be found, they needed to figure out different plans to hunt for cheese. Each character responded to this change differently which evidently reflects their adaptability and willingness to react to change.</p><p>The cheese kept on moving and will always keep on moving, therefore change happens and we should always expect it to happen. As we anticipate change, we need to monitor, adapt quickly, move along the changes, and embrace the experience of it. For cheese in this fable represents our goals and desires in life, whether at work, school, or personal relationships.</p><p>I was introduced to this book during an interesting business opportunity. The recruiter asked me to read this book to determine my mindset vis-a-vis change. She asked me whether I thought of myself as a goal-oriented individual or someone who cares about the process. I am a person who extremely dislikes dichotomies and this book along with these questions presented a dichotomous reality that pushes us to think that we have a single mindset we use when a change in our lives occurs. Depending on the cheese and depending on the type of change that occurs to the cheese, we adapt. For example, I react to changes in my professional career differently than how I react to changes in my personal relationships. I soon discovered that this business opportunity wanted to see an individual who is always quick to adapt to change. And that is why corporations give this book to their employees. By shaping their employees to adapt quickly to change, they push them away from thinking and reflecting whether that change is worthy for them to continue their journey in pursuit of the new cheese. It is another way of corporate employee alienation and machine-making slavery disguised in goal-oriented pieces of training.</p><p><strong>7 Habits of Highly Effective People, by Stephen Covey</strong></p><p>This self-help book provides 7 habits for one to become effective. Covey defines effectiveness as the balance of obtaining desirable outcomes with caring for that which produces those outcomes. According to Covey, in order to become effective, it is essential to undergo a paradigm shift that brings together independence, interdependence, and continual improvement. The habits for independent effectiveness is to be proactive instead of reactive, begin with the end in mind, and to prioritize. As for interdependence, effective habits require thinking win-win, seek first to understand then be understood, and to synergize. Finally, being effective requires continuous work of development.</p><p>This book enjoyed a particularly excessive global public praise, despite the fact that many other self-help books provide similar insights. Covey’s definition of effectiveness is extremely limited and narrow. It is informed by a business mentality and although it could be argued to have helped many outside of the realm of business, its simplistic outlook of how humans operate is especially uncomfortable.</p><p><strong>Home Body, by Rupi Kaur</strong></p><p>This collection of short simple poems take us on a journey of self-love as we embrace the connections between our hearts, minds, and bodies. What makes Kaur’s work phenomenal lies in her ability to share raw and honest emotions that we all relate to in a way to remind us of the importance of self-love, self-acceptance, community, and family and the process of embracing change.</p><p>I read this book in one sitting, on a Friday evening and I traveled through the past and present and revisited the times I felt insecure about my own body and the times I felt empowered and powerful. Bodies are sites of movement. They tell stories and carry joy, sorrow, and resilience. Our bodies represent our experiences and fears. That is why this collection of poetry is vital for every girl and woman to read. Around the world, women are constantly told contradicting things; be confident but not too confident you will scare the men away. Show some skin and don’t be too uptight, but not too much skin as you will be viewed as cheap. In order to look beautiful, you have to be skinny, but not too skinny that curves disappear hence attraction vanishes. As women, we are in a constant struggle to accept, love, and embrace our bodies as the world around us tells us otherwise.</p><p><strong>The Middle East in the Global Era, by Sallama Shaker &amp; Steven Childs</strong></p><p>This text is a significant insight into the political, economic, and social dynamics in the Middle East. It explores the importance of physical and political landscapes including geopolitical significance &amp; the impact of Sykes-Picot, regional rivalry, the region’s political economy including rentier states and the 2011 uprisings, demography, education, and political pluralism and displacement. The book also includes prospects for peace by highlighting the Red Sea-Dead Sea deal among other pathways to peace. The book comprises 17 chapters, each of which is written by different scholars.</p><p>This book is particularly special to me not only because of my genuine interest in the region; but also because it is my first book publication. I wrote the first chapter of this book titled “why the Middle East matters” in which I discuss the religious significance of the Middle East being the birthplace of all Abrahamic religions. I also discuss the geopolitical and strategic location of the region, therefore, controlling water pathways connecting Asia, Africa, and Europe. This further plays a vital role in the transportation of oil as 17m barrels of oil pass through the straits of Hormuz in addition to 3.8m barrels transported through Bab el-Mandeb and 2.9m through the Suez Canal. In this chapter, I also evaluate the human migration and security concerts as well as regional rivalries.</p><p><strong>Migration, Diasporas, and Transnationalism, by Steven Vertovec, and Robin Cohen</strong></p><p>This phenomenal collection of essays present three main theoretical frameworks and concepts: contemporary migration, diaspora, and transnationalism. The changes in contemporary migration manifest incontestable connections to diaspora and transnationalism due to an increased need for legal labor migration, the market for illegal and undocumented migration, refugee migration, and independent female migration. Vertovic defines diaspora as a term that practically describes any population which is considered deterriotirzed or transnational. Diaspora is therefore understood as a social form, a type of consciousness, and a mode of cultural production. Transnationalism is a diaspora consciousness marked by dual or multiple identifications. The theoretical framework of transnationalism divided into four parts: transnationalism as the reconstruction of place or locality, transnationalism as the movement of capital, transnationalism as a mode of cultural reproduction, and finally transnationalism as a site for political engagement. Transnationalism as the reconstruction of place or locality concerns the process that migrants and transnationalism undergo in deconstructing and reconstructing space and identity outside nationalist boundaries.</p><p>As a Libyan who lived all my childhood in Tripoli, and in multiple places including Canada, France, Indiana, and now California, the concepts of diaspora and transnationalism echo my story. I am conscious of my diasporic connection to Libya, in my deterritorialization and mode of cultural production. I am also transnational as I subconsciously created and claimed a hybrid identity that reconstructs my sense of locality outside the Libyan borders that carry my national identity.</p><p><strong>Religion Across Borders, by Helen Braugh and Janet Chafetz</strong></p><p>In this text, Braugh and Chafetz study the relationship between religion and transnationalism as it is an often neglected factor in the research. Their framework is based on networks defined as organizing systems of people to describe the pathways, content, and impacts of religious exchanges among actors in home and host countries. Transnationalism is therefore people whose feet are in two societies, as their identities are connected simultaneously to communities in two or more nation-states. The authors use network analysis to understand the relationship between these transnational religious institutions in two levels: micro focusing on participants in the religious relevant networks; a meso level focusing on local-level religious organizations and finally marco level focusing on religious institutions. To further analyze this, the authors use case studies to evaluate the interrelations between religion and transnational networks. The case studies include Santa Cena of the Luz Del Mundo church, a nontrinitarian Christian denomination whose headquarters are in Guadalajara in Mexico but has transnational ties in multiple American cities. There is also evidence found in Catholic churches that exist in transnational realms between Mexico and the Catholic Immigrant Church in Houston, Texas. The Vietnamese Catholic church in the US, as well as the Chinese Church in Houston, are other cases used. What they found in common was that immigrants bring religious beliefs and practices that then become transplanted and adapted in the US context. Additionally, transnational religious networks include resource monetary flows that migrants send to their families as well as their home congregations to help build religious facilities in the home country.</p><p><strong>Rethinking Scripture: Essays from a Comparative Perspective, by Miriam Levering</strong></p><p>In this outstanding collection of scholarly essays, scripture is understood in a different light. The anthology of essays in this book covers the orality of Scripture and canon formation. Levering defines scripture as a relational phenomenon, a matter of the communal reception of texts. Levering further highlights the generalizations made by Western scholars in their studying of sacred texts whose approach is protestant in nature. In scholarship, what constituted sacred was the divinity in its origin, normative authoritativeness, closeness, rigidity, and completion. The problem with this categorization of scripture is that it excludes communities such as the Hindus and the Buddhists whose sacred words are neither fixed nor bounded. The Veda, for example, does not have normative authority in terms of legal conduct, yet it plays a scriptural role. Hence, Levering argues that the intimate connections that people have with texts symbolize the power and truth that comes through the texts for these communities.</p><p><strong>What Is Scripture? A Comparative Approach, by Wilfred Smith</strong></p><p>Smith is not a religious scholar, instead, he is a historian by training. Therefore, his understanding of scripture stems from a historical perspective. In his book, Smith poses questions ‘what is it for something to be scripture? What is it for human communities to scripturalize and produce scripture?’. Smith argues that the emergence of scripture as both a form and a concept is a direct consequence of historical processes. They result from the relationship between communities and their views of the universe. It is, therefore, a social phenomenon and must be thought of only in relation to the communities that make it meaningful. In this case, Smith does not condition scriptures to a divine origin but instead coins their existence to human activity. For that purpose, Smith argues that scriptures hold no ontological power and thus have no way of being understood apart from the humans making it scripture.</p><p><strong>The Voice, the Word, the Books: the Sacred Scripture of the Jews, Christians, and Muslims, by Francis E. Peters</strong></p><p>In this analysis of sacred scripture, Peters defines scriptures as words of God and is concerned with how they came to be. He identifies scriptures as books that are too complex in their content as well as in their history; because God’s words were written by human believers. This relationship between the divine origin and human contribution makes the study of scripture further difficult. He compares and examines three written scriptures: the Quran, the Torah, and the Christian bible. He argues that the Torah is an institutional book, published and recited, and that gives it scriptural power to the Jews. Similarly, the Quran for Muslims. The recitation and remembrance of Quranic verses is a way to integrate God’s words into the minds and hearts of believers. Finally, the new testament, for Christians enjoys assertive and argumentative authority that makes it scripture.</p><p><strong>Beyond the Written Word: Oral Aspects of Scripture in the History of Religion, by William Graham</strong></p><p>Many scholars who study scripture focus on written sacred texts. Graham looks beyond that and contends that scriptures can be oral and argues against the functional and relational understanding of scripture. He adds that scripture must be understood as both ‘writ’ and ‘word’ because it is not an absolute term. The simple argument stands that if it lives in the faith and piety of people, then it is scripture. Scripture as ‘writ’ means a sacred book or whatever formulation that expresses the essentially written character of holy text as a tangible document. Written scripture provides visibility as it connects the past and present in a physical format. The most important aspect of written scripture is that written fixation replaced the oral transition of sacred texts which is shared amongst many traditions. This replacement was necessary for the sustainability of the religion. On the other hand, the orality of scripture is substantial in oral cultures in particular. In these cultures, the transmission of sacred lore and ritual life is dependent upon the sacred spoken word.</p><p><strong>The Holy Book in Comparative Perspective, by Frederick Denny</strong></p><p>This is another book of scholarly essay collections that study different scriptures. Denny argues that all scripture has in common a special language through which basic concepts and insights are generated. This language must be understood by people and this knowledge requires technical literacy before any scripture can emerge into canonical status. The study of comparative scripture is therefore completed within a framework of origin, forms, and functions. Scriptures have a sacred language, canon literature, and authority which could be closed (like the case of the Quran) or open (such as Confucianism). Scriptures also have a standardizing influence and accessibility. Scriptures have two functions in their living context: an informative and performative function particularly in nonliteral communities.</p><p><strong>Crossing and Dwelling: a Theory of Religion, by Thomas Tweed</strong></p><p>Tweed’s theory of religion is a brilliant abstract exercise for the brain. He uses a deductive-nomological theory of religion that highlights movement and relation and emphasizes tropes of dwelling and crossing. He defines religion to be confluences of organic cultural flows that intensify joy and confront suffering by drawing on human and superhuman forces to make homes and cross boundaries. He argues that there is no such thing as a singular religion because we can never encounter religion in general. The confluences refer to movement and relation as aquatic metaphors which signal that religions are not refined substances but complex processes. Each religion is a flowing together of currents traversing multiple fields and cross, thereby creating new spiritual streams. These conferences are organic and cultural as they flow in spatial and temporal ways experienced through ritual performances and passed by generations. Therefore, religions involve finding place and moving through space to make homes and cross boundaries. They situate the devout in the body, the home, and the homeland and hence prescribe social locations and construct collective identities.</p><p>I read this book during the first few months of 2020 and I particularly enjoyed the theoretical framework that explained and described each segment of the definition of religion. It helped position my own biases in relation to the confluences of religious and cultural flows I learned growing up Muslim. I imagined Tweed’s theory of religion as a non-binding tube with fluid flowing but it is difficult to determine where the fluid began and where it is going. To me, that was religion as a confluence of organic cultural flow. In doing that, I discovered my collective identity as a Muslim as it situated my existence within the boundaries of the body (in terms of what I can do and not do with my own body as informed by religion), the homeland (my sense of belonging to Libya is very much connected to the collective identity I have as both Libyan and Muslim), and the cosmo (as I imagine my belonging to a global community of Muslims although I do not know them nor do they know me).</p><p><strong>Passionately Human, No Less Divine — Religion and Culture in Black Chicago, by Wallace Best</strong></p><p>In his book, Best attempts to fill the gap between historiography and migration in Chicago by addressing the role of religion in the shaping and formation of the city. Best defines religion to be mutually reinforcing modalities that find expression as the cultural production of their adherents. In his book, he discusses various issues in a historical manner starting with a discussion and an analysis of Lacy Kirk Williams’ vision of Chicago’s religious and cultural transformation, the churches changing identities, and the 1919 riot. In other chapters, he analyses the new sacred order and the reaction of mainstream churches as well as women’s role in the religious scene. Throughout the book, Best provides claims and arguments for the intersectionality between religion and culture in Chicago. Although many scholars are in agreement, Best neither believes that the second exodus of migration took two waves, nor does he think migration stopped during the great depression. Instead, he argues it slowed down. In fact, the continuous movement of Southerners was due to the Jim Crow laws. And failure to acknowledge this migration was to risk one’s church becoming extinct. Hence, he contends migration to have had a profound effect on the religious landscape of Chicago, church growth and structural development, and relations between cultural and religious symbols. The success of southern migrants was due to the changing of religious and congressional practices primarily and the emergence of female prominent religious figures. With these changes taking place, given Black folk culture and storefront churches among others, the sacred order of Chicago was reordered due to the adaptation of the Protestant church to migrant needs.</p><p><strong>Sacred Assemblies and Civic Engagement: How Religion Matters for America’s Newest Immigrants, by Fred Lamar Kniss, and Paul David Numrich</strong></p><p>In their book, Kniss and Numrich study religion and migration by assessing deeper categories of differentiation. Their study examines three religious variables: sectarianism (tension within a society), moral authority (shared text or religious history), and moral projects (community building such as social justice and structural issues) on civic engagement. In the first interaction between sectarianism and civic engagement, they found that when sectarianism is organized around religious purity, people are likely to protest against others in their religion. On the other hand, if sectarianism was organized around cultural purity, people are likely to protest against others outside their religion. Second, the effect of moral authority on civic engagement depends on individuality or collective tradition, maximization of individual or collective utility, and whether authority is individual or collective from above. Finally, the effect of moral project on civil engagement was found to depend on whether the institution has individualistic moral projects like Hinduism and Buddhism — putting the individual as the locus of attention-, collectivistic like Islam and Judaism or mixed moral projects. From this framework, the authors examine the impact of these findings on immigrants’ work and occupation, education, marriage, and engagement in society.</p><p><strong>God Needs No Passport: Immigrants and the Changing American Religious Landscape, by Peggy Levitt</strong></p><p>Levitt’s book discusses debates on religion and immigration arguing that the current image does not reflect the American national reality. She argues that the reality is not a dichotomy between home and host country or a choice between assimilation or multiculturalism, it is the employment of simultaneously all of these things. Levitt calls for toleration and religious pluralism in American society. She defines tolerance to mean acceptance and pluralism to mean active engagement. Her research model is based on 10 years of research based on interviews and surveys of Pakistanis, Gujaratis, Irish and Brazilian immigrants. She contends that religion transcends political, cultural, and ethnic boundaries and that is why it has the power to change the religious demography in America. In her analysis, she uses the transnational lens to understand migration and identities. In America she hopes to see, she hopes to see, she divides the religious architecture into categories such as the transnational religious corporation and the catholic variety and the transnational corporate model and the protestant experience. Levitt argues that incorporating immigrants in the American society will not shift civil society as many believe, it will enhance it instead.</p><p><strong>Bells Introduction to the Quran, by Montgomery Watt and Richard H. Bell.</strong></p><p>In this volume, Watt and Bell speak about the Quran from various perspectives highlighting its history, form, and chronology. They also dig deep in the relationships that occidental scholars have with Quranic studies as well as that of Muslims in a form of “dialogue”. Both authors have different views and opinions regarding the Quran as a form of revelation. While Bell is keener to falsifying the revelation aspect of the Quran, Watt is careful with the Muslim dogma. In fact, he argues that scholars must make the Quran the first object of study. This is particularly due to their arguments regarding revelation and origin. Watt argues that the complete Quran was not circulating in a written form among the prophet’s followers for them to study. He adds that a verse once delivered might easily have been forgotten in the course of the years. If the verse does not smoothly fit into the text, that is probably because it was substituted for the one which follows. It fits admirably into the historical situation. However, he assures that there is no reason to question the authenticity of a verse so suited to the circumstances.</p><p><strong>The Qurâns Self-Image Writing and Authority in Islams Scripture, by Daniel Madigan.</strong></p><p>In his book, Madigan analyses the Quran using semantic analysis of the concept of book or ‘kitab’ to represent the Quran. The holy book is seen by Muslims and scholars as a scriptural book that came to humanity through a process of revelation. Hence, Madigan analyses the concept of kitab within the Quran by analyzing the verses to answer what is the Quran when it is often referred to as a book. He argues that, as scripture, the Quran is self-aware. It is not a kitab that points to dogma or laws. It is an open-ended process of divine engagement with people. The process of revelation and reception is self-observed and that is how it asserts its authority. The premise is, therefore, the Quran does not regard itself as a complete volume (book). Instead, it is an ongoing process of divine-humanity engagement.</p><p><strong>The Qurān in Its Historical Context, by Gabriel Reynolds.</strong></p><p>This book, edited by Reynolds provides a contextual perspective to the study of the Quran. The book is a series of articles and studies by different scholars. In the first chapter by Fred Donner, he attempts to answer 5 important questions in the recent scholarship of the Quran. The first question regards the origin of the Quran, whether we can trace the current copy to an original version. In answering this question, scholarly debate sparks clashing information as to whether the Quran is the exact manuscript of God’s word or if it is the product of centuries of a crystallization process. Second, Donner asks about the nature of Ur-Quran. Here, we see consensus on the books being religious and moral guides, but disagreements on their original message and other religious influences on the Quran. He argues that the Quran falls between Christian and Jewish influence. Third, the scholarly debate has recently been attempting to research the original language of this pre-text and its effect on the Quran. Donner argues that language is paradoxical. The fourth question regards the transmission of the Ur-Quran; highlighting the issue that remains in the oral versus written transmission process. Finally, Donner attempts to answer the controversial question that has long sparked academic debate regarding the codification and canonization of the Quran. He contends that what we currently have is sets of contradictory information between support for early codification and late codification of the Quran.</p><p>Despite the fact that this book was an interesting read, the evidence used to complement these scholarly discussions was very weak. Furthermore, the language and tone of writing by these scholars echo orientalist sentiments and a Western imperialistic and superior view of Islamic scripture.</p><p><strong>The Making of Sikh Scripture, by Gurinder Mann Singh</strong></p><p>Mann Singh explores the Adi Granth, the scripture for the Sikh community in India by tracing the history of the Sikh community. Like many other religious scriptures, the Adi Granth occupies the highest authority within the community. It is believed to be the repository of the divine revelation in the Sikh belief system and therefore plays a central role in the devotional and ritual life of the community. Mann argues that the canon formation of the Adi Granth in Sikhism was closely related to other developments in the community, as it served to be the principal source defining Sikh theology and the creation of the ethical code.</p><p><strong>Migrating Faith: Pentecostalism in the United States and Mexico in the Twentieth Century, by Daniel Ramirez</strong></p><p>In this book, Ramirez assesses the connection and relationship between religion and culture through a close study of Mexican migrants of the Apostle Pentecostalism faith in Los Angeles. He outlines the history of the faith, the establishment of the group in the US, their identities, and surrounding homelands. By exploring life narratives and stories, he demonstrates how Pentecostals built their religious identities and argues that given the distance between the migrants and their group in Mexico, the group found fertile ground for religious innovation. This innovation included change in traditions and practices expanded by working-class Pentecostals in the US using hymes, music, and cultural resurgence. He further argues that the intertwined nature of the Chicago and Mexican Pentecostal movements created an overarching religious identity for the new faith which in turn allowed the group to gain and maintain transborder alliances that facilitated the growth of Pentecostalism. In this context, transnationalism, particularly consciousness about transnationalism, provided symbolic and material support to the migrants fostering a unique transnational unity among the Mexican Pentecostals that transcended racial lines.</p><p><strong>Globalizing the Sacred: Religion Across the Americas, by Manuel Vásquez and Marie Marquardt</strong></p><p>This book on religion across the Americas examines the evolving roles of religion in the context of globalization, migration, technology, and modernity. The authors challenge the current paradigm that argues for secularization and rational choice. Using case studies from the US and Latin America, the authors develop a new theoretical approach to study the role of religion using mixed methodologies from sociology, anthropology, history, philosophy, and political science. This multidisciplinary approach is based on ethnographic research in local congregations and textual analysis. The study takes transnational churches as its object to examine how the evolving role of religion affects various congregations such as Presbyterian congregation, the Catholic Parish, the Baha’i center as well as youth gangs. This study has significant theoretical implications that highlight an interplay of hybrid identities (transnational migrants) within globalization and historical context. The authors argue that the role of religion in the context of globalization is both concrete and extensive. In that, globalization causes a restructuring of high and low boundaries where religion operates as an alternative to navigating these spaces, particularly for transnational migrants. If we use religion as a map, as the authors suggest, we realize how it shapes social and intimate spaces. This happens as a result of a process of deterritorialization and reterritorialization through transnational religious networks, glocalization, hybridity, and non-exclusionary identity formation.</p><p><strong>Latinos and the New Immigrant Church, by David Badillo</strong></p><p>In this volume, Badillo explores the links between migration, urbanization, and Catholicism between the US and Latin America. Given the large number of Latin American immigrants, Badillo studies the fast-emerging growth of the Catholic church in San Antonio, Chicago, New York, and Miami. His analysis utilizes a historical briefing on the Catholic religious traditions in Spain and Latin America, the Mexican revolution, and how it traveled to San Antonio, and colonialism with Puerto Rico as a case example. Badillo argues that Catholicism, as a religious movement, goes beyond the institutional hierarchy of clergy and laity. Rather, it is incorporated into everyday life and entails the urban experiences of societies. His analysis examines the Catholic church in Cuban Miami and the concept of exile Catholicism, in Chicago and the development of suburbanization and mobility, and similarly in New York City and Texas. As the Catholic movement helped immigrants build and realize individual and cultural identities, Badillo argues that a deeper understanding of parishes, cities, and ethnicities enables a fuller comprehension of how Latin American immigrants influenced and continue to influence Catholicism and urban development in the US.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=3d3b34e30d25" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>