<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Shawn Foust on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Shawn Foust on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@shawnfoust?source=rss-7f36b18f8cf2------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Mon, 16 Nov 2026 18:17:11 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@shawnfoust/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Games, The Lingua Franca]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/fortisgames/games-the-lingua-franca-f6b1a6083cd3?source=rss-7f36b18f8cf2------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f6b1a6083cd3</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[startup]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[gaming]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[community]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[videogames]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Shawn Foust]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 12 Jun 2023 19:47:37 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-06-12T19:47:37.792Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*1E8f4rT415y54bZT.png" /></figure><p>(After a multi-month sojourn, we rejoin the <a href="https://medium.com/fortisgames/hello-world-1f73be677303">main thread</a> on Fortis. For the up to date and fully Fortified, thank you for your patience. For those of you just joining the melee, it’s worthwhile to circle back and read the previous entries at some point.)</p><p>Hello friends, I’ve missed you. They say bloggin’ is a young man’s game, and these keys don’t clack like they used to. There’s a Rocky training montage to be had in the lead up to all of this, but it’d mostly be clips of me beginning a blog, hating it, and starting over for months. Not particularly inspiring.</p><p>Anyways.</p><p>I spend a lot of time on Zoom calls. About a third of them are interviews, which are a largely choreographed affair that I suspect no one loves. Same questions, same answers. Same conversation, different day. There’s some variances to be had, but generally things stay on a track that isn’t satisfying for anyone involved. Just two people sitting there, trying to figure out whether the other person is insane and will make their life a living hell. Too superficial to meaningful. Skating along the surface, looking for holes in the ice hiding RED FLAGS.</p><p>I imagine it’s a bit like dating apps. Something I don’t know much about beyond their reputation. Or, closer to my wheelhouse, assessing people for a Dungeons and Dragons group. Every once in a while someone insane appears trying to run a Chaotic Neutral Bard who plays violin like a guitar, but that’s the outlier. Mostly it’s just normal people saying normal things so they can get to the next step in the process.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*ZreZz3Dcdhv5rXIy.png" /><figcaption>Countryside in flames. Rest of the party dead. There he is jamming on his guitar violin. This is why you interview.</figcaption></figure><p>There just isn’t enough time to spend the time explaining the things that people really care about.</p><p>These blogs, in all of their meandering glory, are an attempt to fill in the gaps on the topics that we think are important and sit at the center of the company. One topic we haven’t covered much is the “why” behind Fortis. It’s a long and convoluted narrative, but it simplifies down to this: We believe games are the Lingua Franca of Humanity and Fortis is built to pursue the opportunity that creates.</p><p>I’ll explain. Not briefly.</p><h3>The Common Tongue</h3><p>In works of fantasy there’s often a “common tongue,” a language which all characters speak — a Lingua Franca. A common tongue is valuable as a literary device because it gives the author a simple way of ensuring all characters can communicate with one another efficiently. In the absence of a common tongue, most character communications end up being some form of Charades meets Pictionary.</p><p>Something like this:</p><blockquote><em>Point to myself.</em></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>“Shawn.”</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><em>Walk my fingers across my hand and then make a stabbing motion at the two figures I’ve drawn in the dirt.</em></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>“Shawn is going to go down the path and slaughter two orcs.”</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><em>Hands up in front of me, pointing to you now.</em></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>“Stay here while I murder those orcs.”</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><em>Thumbs up!</em></blockquote><p>You may not get the words being said, but we’re still communicating.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*V_I714falcyWJPN_wMk6aA.png" /><figcaption>See? Couldn’t be more clear.</figcaption></figure><p>That’s because both of us are trying to solve the same problem: road obstructing orcs. We are in the same space trying to do the same thing. This shared context provides important roadsigns that enables the possibility of communication. The fact that we me speak different languages and come from different backgrounds doesn’t prevent us from overcoming our mutual obstacle. Who needs words when there are gestures and MAJESTIC drawings in the dirt to provide the bridge between us?</p><p>Shared context, powerful stuff.</p><p>And that’s the bit of it that sticks in my brain. This idea that communication across language barriers and cultural differences is possible if the right context is introduced. That, regardless of where we might come from or what our personal history might be, we can <em>belong</em> in the same group when we are in the same place and have the same goals. Like, for example, a game.</p><p>Everyone can belong if we’re playing the same game.</p><p>And, for long time, we weren’t. For much of Human history, the distance between people was too great. We were all in our own little geographies, concerned with our own local affairs. The context wasn’t shared. The objectives weren’t collective.</p><p>The internet changed that, or at least made a change possible. It reduced the space between us in strange and powerful ways. We are present in a single space. Each time we log in, we sit at a nexus of infinite connections, where the distance between us is measured in clicks rather than miles.</p><p>And, within the endless sea of potential connection known as “Online” there are games. Games that can now reach billions of people simultaneously, because they are free and they are attached to an affordable, powerful computing platform quaintly still called a phone. In the last decade (and really the last five years), for the first time, Humanity is playing the same game.</p><p>Global belonging is possible.</p><h3>All the World’s a Game</h3><p>I really can’t overstate how profound this shift is. How suddenly it came upon us. Games that sit at the intersection of online, phone, and free have a TAM (total addressable market) amounting to the majority of Humanity. It’s wild.</p><p>The odds that any one game fully occupies the globe seems low, but the possibility that any one successful game might reach a meaningful percentage of online Humanity is quite high. And the implications of that feel profound, particularly when the service model is considered.</p><p>A game, played by connected billions, for decades. A persistent, global shared context. It’s a uniquely potent tool for building communication between people. A way to draw figures in the dirt that everyone sees and everyone understands. A way to build a common tongue. A lingua franca.</p><p>There’s already interesting examples of this, evolving in real time — the League of Legends ping framework comes to mind.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FgWkXtiveAi8%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DgWkXtiveAi8&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FgWkXtiveAi8%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/718b3b20bc288fc42d92e9b1b2626649/href">https://medium.com/media/718b3b20bc288fc42d92e9b1b2626649/href</a></iframe><p>These pings are a form of universal communication, given meaning by the shared context of the game they reside in. This is the beginning of a tidy little chain reaction. <strong><em>Communication builds understanding, understanding builds empathy, and empathy builds trust. With trust comes belonging.</em></strong></p><p>Global peace is within our grasp! It’s just a ping away.</p><p>Theoretically, at least.</p><p>As an industry, we’re in the early stages of figuring this all out. We don’t fully understand what we have or how to make use of it. We’re largely focused on the basic functions right now. Squarely in the monkey with a bone banging on a rock and screaming stage. We have yet to figure out how to put the community in communication. We have yet to grasp the centrality of building belonging in the heart of our design. The tools we build to allow players to close the gap between them are misused almost as often as they are used.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2F4_IwX21ODcw%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3D4_IwX21ODcw&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2F4_IwX21ODcw%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/b4223141f4d6098c2d3de7a6aec96c79/href">https://medium.com/media/b4223141f4d6098c2d3de7a6aec96c79/href</a></iframe><p>If you build a chat, the odds it occasionally descends into a toxic waste dump is 100%. Particularly when the game is structured in a way that drives that outcome (such as high stakes competitive PvP) and fails to effectively penalize bad behavior when it occurs. That simmering toxicity undermines the development of belonging. It breaks the chain reaction. It leaves scars and builds resentment. It takes the shared context of the game and weaponizes it.</p><p>But the possibility is there. Things are evolving. The preconditions for a global game that encourages belonging are increasingly being met. It’s that possibility that Fortis is meant to pursue, but it’s going to take some work. As an industry, we’ve painted ourselves into a corner.</p><h3>Infinite Whack-a-Mole and its Discontents</h3><p>The path to belonging requires trust. It’s a crucial link in the chain. It’s also a tough nut to crack.</p><p>In order for trust to develop, each person in a communication group needs to believe that all parties are there for the same reason and will act in the best interests of the group. I need to believe it’s us against the orcs and you’re not some sort of orc sympathizer or something. That trust is difficult to assemble in online, anonymous spaces where the incentives of the game aren’t necessarily enough to overcome the personal preferences of the people playing it. Sure, most players are there to win, but some may also want to watch the world burn and run it down mid because you misused your pings.</p><p>People are complex. Motivations are varied. All of this is brought into the game and it plays out as one might expect. It only takes one person to destroy the trust.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FusYvefDzOqQ%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DusYvefDzOqQ&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FusYvefDzOqQ%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="640" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/87b8ea8047c398de51c952684e6ea7b1/href">https://medium.com/media/87b8ea8047c398de51c952684e6ea7b1/href</a></iframe><p>The incentives within the game can only do so much to shape the behavior of the participants. A single, anonymous match is not strong enough context to trigger the chain. It’s mostly just triggering. No, there needs to be more. Some persistent, connective tissue that people are invested in beyond the match.</p><p>But there rarely is.</p><p>That’s because developers are largely focused on getting players into a match rather than thinking about how to make them better citizens in an online society. The weakness of the context is managed by the developer serving as a referee rather than a government. As a result, the player/developer relationship is a relatively superficial one largely focused on policing poor behavior within the game or on the sidelines. It’s all about negative incentives.</p><p>Don’t feed the enemy team or you’ll be banned.</p><p>Don’t use bots or you’ll be banned.</p><p>Don’t be a toxic or you’ll be banned.</p><p>This is a reaction to a stimulus, not a proactive solution. It creates this game of infinite whack-a-mole where the developer asserts itself only in response to toxicity, which typically results in players being exposed to quite a lot of shitty behavior. This, combined with <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Negativity_bias">negativity bias</a>, ensures that on any given day of cycling through matches, people are going to have at least one bad interaction and that interaction will be among the more memorable things that happened to them during the session. It destroys empathy. It prevents trust. It stops belonging.</p><p>It isn’t great.</p><p>The issue is that infinite whack-a-mole is generally viewed as the logical end state of a successful game for most developers. The belief is that players are something to be managed (hence the term “community management,” which feels strangely analogous to pest management), and positive incentives aren’t worth the time or effort to create. Aspiring to more isn’t worthwhile. It’s low ROI. I get the logic, and the industry is rife with failed attempts to do things differently.</p><p>But…</p><p>I’d argue a lot has changed over the last five years. The cost of not evolving is much higher in this era. Unlike before, where bad behavior was isolated to minor skirmishes on forums, the modern player exists within a rich broth of connected Humanity, all stewing on social networks. In this setup, the reach of bad actions is much broader. More concerning, the bad behavior is algorithmically favored. It’s given a megaphone.</p><p>Network effects aren’t always a positive thing.</p><p>Look at many top influencers in game spaces. The majority of them aren’t modeling…model behavior. Thirteen year olds love a bad boy and algorithms love to recommend bad boys. The drama aggro-influencers generate creates attention, which can be converted into online clout, which is a highly monetizable thing. The clout is significantly more valuable than the cost of an occasional account ban. Who cares if you got banned for being toxic if the video generated a million views (and you have six other accounts)? The incentives are all screwed up, and whack-a-mole doesn’t shift them. The algorithm is too powerful.</p><p>And, as developers lose the algorithm, they lose their community. It grows more aggressive and toxic. Negative feedback loops predominate, both inside the game and on social networks. Attempts to rectify it via targeted bans of prominent bad actors results in massive blowback. The mole whacks back. Eventually, the developer pulls back from community engagement, believing itself incapable of salvaging the situation. If every attempt at fixing the problem snowballs into a revolt, why bother? Who needs all of the death threats?</p><p>The fandom becomes toxic. The players are team orc. The developers retreat behind their walls. Belonging does not flourish in this environment.</p><p>It’s a shame.</p><p>And it’s outdated. The whack-a-mole mentality is a vestigial appendage from a bygone era. It’s based on a time when the developer controlled all of the channels and the cost of bad behavior was total exile (and $60 dollars). It’s also a time where the BAN HAMMER was the most sophisticated tool available to the developer.</p><p>But now there’s so much more to work with.</p><p>The time has come. Player whack-a-mole needs to die.</p><h3>Players to Citizens</h3><p>A new approach is possible.</p><p>Not players. Citizens.</p><p>Game communities can become societies.</p><p>Negative incentives are still a component to this, but they’re not the first line of defense. The first line of defense is making a person care about their status in the society. The benefits of being good must outweigh the catharsis and clout harvesting of being bad. There must be value to citizenship.</p><p>Thankfully, the service model introduced a crucial durability to the relationship between player and developer that is fertile ground for positive incentives. It is possible to build a society when there are hundreds of millions of people actively engaged with each other and the developer for decades. Why? Because repeated, persistent interaction is how one escapes the <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prisoner%27s_dilemma">Prisoner’s Dilemma</a>. The expectation of future encounters enhances the benefits of cooperation. When it’s just a single game, to hell with everyone. But, if we’re all going to be trapped together in this online fandom for years, we might as well work together.</p><p>And that’s where the developer needs to put the effort in. It starts by making sure their online society prizes good citizenship. The rewards of working together need to be a step function more powerful than what whack-a-mole has experimented with (which has generally been limited to minor cosmetic bonuses). Developers must leverage the passion of the fandom, their control over the game, and their resources to fashion a system of governance that re-weights the incentives distinctly toward good. The developer must overcome the algorithm. These perks need to be catered, observable, and meaningful.</p><p>Tangible benefits. Status.</p><p>If you’re a good citizen, it’s more likely you’ll get access. It’s more likely your stream will take off. It’s more likely that you’ll get a discount on that next cool item. It’s more likely you’ll get to play with other good citizens. It’s more likely you’ll get the things you want most out of the fandom.</p><p>In success, the shared context of the game becomes a powerful tool for belonging again. A citizenship framework allows for a set of meaningful, positive incentives to help that chain reaction occur — it’s a powerful macro context that supports the game play. Every match is an opportunity for a player to become a better citizen, a goal they can expect others to share because of the benefits it brings (and the fact matchmaking considers it). As more positive interactions occur, more are more likely to occur. People like paying things forward.</p><p>We want to create citizens.</p><p>I expect it’ll take Fortis a while to reach the aspiration here. There’s a number of practical things we’ll need to solve along the way (like making a game people even want to play in the first place). There’s also a number of other sticky incentive conflicts that exist between players and developers that I expect we’ll need to work out. The journey will be long and fraught, but the goal of creating a game with global belonging is a North Star for us. Something to reach for and invest in. A society worth building.</p><p>It seems like a shame to do anything else with something so powerful. Games are a persistent, global shared context. A place where everyone can speak the common tongue, regardless of their background.</p><p>Somewhere where everyone can belong.</p><p>The Lingua Franca of Humanity.</p><p><a href="https://medium.com/fortisgames/hello-world-1f73be677303"><strong>First Part</strong></a><strong> | </strong><a href="https://medium.com/fortisgames/look-at-all-the-people-7f7b04722be7"><strong>Previous Part</strong></a><strong> | Next Part (Coming Eventually)</strong></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f6b1a6083cd3" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/fortisgames/games-the-lingua-franca-f6b1a6083cd3">Games, The Lingua Franca</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/fortisgames">Fortis Games</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[You, Me, and the Machine]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@shawnfoust/you-me-and-the-machine-1aba477e68ab?source=rss-7f36b18f8cf2------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/1aba477e68ab</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[generative-art]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[videogames]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ai]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Shawn Foust]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 17 Jan 2023 18:08:06 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-01-17T18:08:06.855Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>(This is an aside from the <a href="https://medium.com/fortisgames/hello-world-1f73be677303">main thread</a> on Fortis. On occasion, I meander into foreign pastures.)</p><p>Let’s talk Generative AI.</p><p>When I pictured the rise of our robot overlords, I generally imagined more deathbots and fewer chatbots. Of course, eradicating Humanity is probably easier if we stop interacting with one another entirely, and ever more sophisticated chatbots seems like a reasonable start down that path. I’m having vivid visions of millions of bots talking to each other on Tinder and no one ever going on dates until Humanity dwindles into nonexistence.</p><p>Skynet has gotten real weird.</p><p>Wild times.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*IU7ppJ09b94TEHJTwiA-5g.png" /><figcaption>Prompt: Chatbot Wars. Stable diffusion is making me unstable. Where do the images come from? What do they mean? Time to get some red string and connect the dots.</figcaption></figure><p>I’ll leave off the existential questions for another time and focus on the relationship between AI and the video game industry.</p><p>The games industry is an odd bird. It’s this awkward marriage of technology, creativity, and community. Technology tends to be the dominant partner in that trinity, with innovations in distribution, storage, rendering, etc. having an outsize impact on the nature of creativity and community in games. Figuring out a better/cheaper/faster/clever way of doing things can lead to massive opportunities. Add in the fact that games folk tend to be early adopters and you’ve got a recipe for constant shifts in how things are done.</p><p>It’s part of the reason games tends to spin out so many valuable companies so consistently. In games, the way things have been done is a weak indicator of how they will be done on any timeline greater than a few years. Particularly recently, where the pace of disruption has increased at an exponential rate. Scale incumbency is an advantage, but it’s not an unassailable one.</p><p>And things are just gonna get more wild from here.</p><h3>The Era of Compounding Tech</h3><p>Why?</p><p>We’re in the Era of Compounding tech. At this point, the rate of advancement is increasingly unbounded. Technology is more interconnected, with advancements in one having a broad, rippling effect across the ecosystem. That ripple runs into ripples of other advancements and creates all sorts of unpredictable outcomes. It’s B-A-N-A-N-A-N-A-N-A-N-A-S.</p><p>Think about it this way: For the vast majority of Human history, a parent’s experience with technology wasn’t all that different than their children’s. Perhaps some trader rolled into town and had a better set of awls for leather-working or something, and people were all: “Sweet, this is a better way to punch holes through leather. +3.5% to village leatherworking productivity. Maybe I’ll make an extra belt this week.” Exciting, but it wasn’t like the Human condition was constantly and fundamentally changing.</p><p>Compare that to today.</p><p>I have to spend ten hours a week just trying to understand WTF is going on. My childhood was defined by the shift from OFFLINE to ONLINE, which was massive. My ten year old is being raised in a different world. One defined by technological accessibility. Tech sits in the middle of all interactions with all things. She is immersed in a technosoup that permeates the reality of her being. For her, everything in the world is easy and immediate (on a relative basis to me).</p><p>Desires have instant gratification.</p><p>Want to know something? No problem. You can get an education on any topic within minutes — along with some helpful suggestions of ten related rabbitholes organized in an ever-growing, ever-streaming playlist. Much like the spice, the information flows. Some poor wizened scholar got cast out of society as a heretic back in the 16th century for whispering about a heliocentric solar system while my daughter is lecturing me about how Pluto isn’t a planet (it is, and I refuse to engage with planet-denialism).</p><p>Want to buy something? No problem. If it’s online, it’ll be here instantly. If it’s physical, it will be here in a day courtesy of our Amazon Prime driver (who should be paying rent for the amount of time he spends here). The idea that something might take more than a day is STRANGE and CONCERNING.</p><p>Want to play something? No problem. My kid can download and then GORGE upon a GREAT FEAST of free games (assuming she’s willing to be absolutely obliterated by ads, which she totally is). Back in my day, I had to beg my mom for a month to take me to Toy ‘R Us so I could buy a game I spent four months saving for and then wait another two months for Nintendo Power to explain to me how to beat it. And yes, the car ride was uphill both ways.</p><p>Everything is fast. Everything is now. Everything and everyone is a click away. And at any given moment, whatever the current thing is will likely be replaced by the next, better thing.</p><p>As a parent, I’m expected to know and understand this situation and manage it. I’ve got an edge over most given the nature of my work, but the cognitive load of staying on top of things is extreme. My TikTok is NOT taking off. I’m poorly equipped for this. The problem is that I merely adopted technosoup existence while my daughter is being raised in it. Her life is different. Radically so.</p><p>She also has the MVR (minimum viable rhythm) for TikTok.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*_nVEGTkS0K87vm3Kcu-ErQ.png" /><figcaption>Rough paraphrasing of conversations with my kid. I really don’t know where she gets it from.</figcaption></figure><p>She’s a denizen of the Era of Compounding Tech. Everything is churning and roiling and evolving. Faster and faster. Broader and broader.</p><p>Increasingly, I’m worried that the rate of technological gain is outpacing the rate of Humanity’s ability to adapt to it. But that isn’t going to stop it. In a fully interconnected world, technological optimization will occur, spread, and render anyone who doesn’t adopt it inefficient. The magic of integrated globalization.</p><p>This is a polite way of saying the moral and ethical debates about technology tend to fade in the backgrounds to the reality of inevitable progression.</p><p>Which brings us back to AI and its consequences.</p><p>ChatGPT. Stable Diffusion. Midjourney. The four hundred other companies VCs are going to put capital into. It’s all coming.</p><h3>The Value of Human Work</h3><p>I think a lot about the value of an hour of Human work. On an absolute, subjective, and relative basis. The relationship between type of work, location of work, and supply of work produces all sorts of strange equilibriums, which technology has a habit of upsetting with some regularity.</p><p>Some tech advancements might have little to no impact on an existing equilibriums (the better leather awls example), while others provoke a wholesale reshaping of society — Agriculture, Industrialization, and Internet, I’m looking at you. When a tech-shock to the system occurs, there’s typically some delay as the market fiddles with capital allocation and deployment until a new system can settle in. Longer periods of reordering tend to allow for a calmer procession, as people shift skills and locations to adjust.</p><p>As far as I can tell, those periods are growing shorter. Early efforts at industrialization took far longer than the more recent entrants. The internet managed to spread globally in a few decades. Mobile reached global penetration in about a decade. All of this has had impacts. All of it has had displacements. The oft discussed Gig Economy is a good, recent example.</p><p>Certain fields have been largely protected from these shifts. Creative fields are front and center here. The cultural aspects to being professionally creative are a barrier to entry that extends beyond standard capital cost considerations. While a widget may be turned in many locations, a piece of artwork that resonates with a person tends to be a more geocentric ordeal. Sure, there’s been some shifts, tax incentives in Georgia or Canada means LA might a less attractive to place to film something, but by and large, the value of an hour of work in creative fields has been somewhat protected.</p><p>It takes a long time to train your hand to move in a certain way to produce a certain visual outcome that will be appreciated by the certain group of people that are culturally aligned to appreciate that thing. These things are distinctive and difficult to duplicate. They require training, dedication, and nuanced understanding. Producing a work of quality is an endeavour.</p><p>Enter Generative AI.</p><p>Oof.</p><p>It turns the system on its head. The millions of hours of work that have been produced by generations of talented artists (singers, and writers) is now weaponized against the artists of today and those to come. All of that talent, skill, and sweat is distilled into a training set for a voracious, never-tiring cybernetic art wizard. It consumes. Compiles. Evolves. Every interaction gives it more knowledge, more understanding.</p><p>This was good.</p><p>That was bad.</p><p>ArtWizard V1 understands.</p><p>ArtWizard V2 will do better.</p><p>An artist might devote a lifetime to developing a style and craft. An AI can consume that output and begin duplicating it with reasonable effectiveness instantly (and getting better all the time). The bounding agents of experience, cultural knowledge, and talent that have historically been the gatekeepers of creative professionals tend to fall apart in this context. The accumulated history of all available works are sufficient to train an AI to compete.</p><p>And (soon) compete well.</p><p>I suppose this was inevitable, considering the direction of things. Muscle memory has long been a depreciating asset in the modern era. Knowledge may be joining that group — why learn a thing when you can google or ChatGPT it? AI has the potential to usher in a post-skill, post-knowledge…nirvana?</p><p>That feels like the wrong word. Particularly given the impacts upon people that are currently skilled and currently knowledgeable. And Human expression generally.</p><p>So, assuming we’re heading down this path and we can’t move off of it, what changes? Probably a lot, over some timeline that’s measured in a low number of years. As Generative AI continues to evolve, it will continuously reduce skill and craft knowledge as contributors to outcomes relative to judgment, capital availability, and risk friendliness. This re-weighting magnifies the existing trend that was already moving in that direction.</p><p>Good time to be an entrepreneur with a dream.</p><p>Bad time to be a highly invested incumbent.</p><h3>Generative AI &amp; the Games Industry</h3><p>A lot of people are making the argument that Generative AI is just going to become some sort of production tool pocket companion rather than a wholesale replacement for Human crafters. That’s probably true, but even at that level it’s likely to radically shift the cost-per-work on a given art team. That could mean that the size of art teams is about to get considerably smaller …</p><p>…OR…</p><p>…what is possible within a game for a given cost structure is about to get considerably higher. It will take some time to adapt, but the modern game industry’s standard designs are all predicated on velocity of content consumption being a primary constraint on how games are developed and operated. Level design, meta design, and economy design are all keyed to the idea that content is limited and costly to come by.</p><p>We may be entering a world where the same art team (or a team with the same number of people with compatible skillsets) are capable of producing an order of magnitude more content.</p><p>If true, the entire foundation of modern system design begins to show cracks. Design will need to adapt to a content-rich environment.</p><p>Branching content.</p><p>Responsive content.</p><p>Endless content.</p><p>The implications are profound. The possibilities are exciting. For those of us preoccupied with the <a href="https://medium.com/fortisgames/the-design-lane-b648d7116737">Design Lane</a>, it’s a moment infused with potential.</p><p>Potential for progress, but at a cost. Displacement. Rearrangement. A wholesale refactoring of the creative pipeline. All possible, all increasingly probable. How that will impact each of us is unclear, but we should remember that the industry has rarely favored the unresponsive. Teams will be a first mover in adopting these practices and tools, and, should they prove to be the future, the rewards will follow.</p><p>Thoughtful leaders should be considering not just the potential of these tools, but how best to build a stable bridge to the sort of team that could make use of them. This isn’t a simple affair. The march of technology can be brutal, but the Human element of making games is its best element. Regardless of the tools involved, creative potential is magnified when different people of different skills are brought into collaboration with one another. Protecting that is a worthwhile endeavor.</p><p>And I don’t just say that as an aspiring BLOG THOUGHT-VISIONARY nervously eyeing ChatGPT.</p><p>Stay safe, friends.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=1aba477e68ab" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[World War Web3]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@shawnfoust/world-war-web3-2df9920e57bc?source=rss-7f36b18f8cf2------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2df9920e57bc</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[gaming]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[web3]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[videogames]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[startup]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[bitcoin]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Shawn Foust]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 06 Dec 2022 18:07:48 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-12-06T21:09:05.166Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>(This is an aside from the <a href="https://medium.com/fortisgames/hello-world-1f73be677303">main thread</a> on Fortis. On occasion, I meander into foreign pastures.)</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/768/1*SPSHCFNaz9eAbKo9ETFxDQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Thanks Stable Diffusion. Can’t wait to ChatGPT my next blog.</figcaption></figure><p>Narratives are a powerful tool.</p><p>When they’re well crafted, they take a messy, chaotic dough of inedible context and bake it into the sweet bread of a consumable story. A good narrative is understandable, relatable, and transferable. The listener comprehends, believes, and wants to tell others.</p><p>The world (and particularly Silicon Valley) seems to be increasingly driven by narratives. The simpler and the grander the better. Big, bold, and beautiful. Death to nuance. Shades of grey are an insidious blight that threaten the orderly partitioning of the world between believers and those poor lost souls that just don’t get it. You’re either about to change the world with us or you’re an archaic luddite that hates progress.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FrGfaJZAdfNE%3Fstart%3D98%26feature%3Doembed%26start%3D98&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DrGfaJZAdfNE&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FrGfaJZAdfNE%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/3db1b04a4a91739bf0347091897a7c13/href">https://medium.com/media/3db1b04a4a91739bf0347091897a7c13/href</a></iframe><p>As far as I can tell, the ideal narrative for the modern age is one that:</p><ul><li>Proposes a radical re-ordering of society</li><li>Forces a clean division between the initiated and the scorned</li><li>Can be expressed in 280 characters (<a href="https://www.businessinsider.com/elon-musk-twitter-expand-character-limit-tweet-to-do-list-2022-11">though 1000 may soon be acceptable</a>)</li></ul><p>This structure is desirable because it enables the storyteller to gain the greatest amount of traction among the broadest group of people and turn them into zealots quickly. Conversion. Radical narratives stand out from the crowd. Particularly when they appeal to commonly held grievance. The breadth of the vision and the forcefulness of its delivery is directly correlated with the tightness of the community that can develop around it. There’s a reason there’s not a lot of scale influencers with moderate positions.</p><p>The downside of this structure is that the narrative it produces tends to be brittle. It lacks the nuance to withstand scrutiny. Thankfully, that’s not much of a problem since one side is rarely considering the points of the other side. The world is so polarized by believers and non-believers that the pragmatic middle ground is a nuclear wasteland between the entrenched positions. The wise moderate bunkers up. Poking your head out is liable to get you nuked from both sides.</p><p>Narrative wars are a zero sum game. There can be no neutral parties. Can be no thoughtful interlocutors. No mediation. No peace.</p><p>There are many narrative wars being waged at any given time, but this post is just about one: World War Web3.</p><h3><strong>The Narrative</strong></h3><p>Web3 is a tidy piece of narrative.</p><p>It simultaneously suggests progression and inevitability. It focuses on the technology that people are more intimately involved with on a day-to-day basis and leverages a natural assumption that it will continue to evolve, with one version giving away to the next. It touches on a natural fear that our technology might ultimately move past us and that missing this shift will prove to be a regret.</p><p>Tomorrow is coming. It’s inevitable. Smart people are ready for it today or get left behind.</p><p>You’re <em>Web2</em>? Wow. That’s sad. I bet you find TikTok confusing.</p><p>I’m <em>Web3</em>.</p><p>That’s a lot of narrative weight in just four characters.</p><p>And that’s just the branding. The full narrative (but still under 280 characters) manages to cover a much broader set of real estate. It provides the broad strokes of what this new Future of the 3rd Web will look like, and just how transformative it will be. It tells of a future where society is fully reshaped and nothing will every truly be same again. It also provides a set of defining pillars that allow a community to form, organize, and proselytize.</p><p>I’ve written this one up and, while others may use other phrasing, I think it’s a fairly reasonable representation of the constant stream of content pushed my way on this topic:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/838/1*K3YqXv_Mw0p9wLwbXC-Jag.png" /><figcaption>Thankfully, there’s still 50 characters left to work with should it be needed.</figcaption></figure><p>There’s a lot to unpack here, but I’ll start by saying this: it’s a really fascinating topic to think about. As a rather ardent pragmatist cursed with a deep love of pursuing impractical possibilities, Web3 is the sort of thing that gives me the warm fuzzies. There are aspects of this future that I want to be true, or at least that I would want to experience on some level to decide whether I want it to be true.</p><p>But that’s beside the point.</p><p>What’s important here is the narrative and its structure. At its root, it’s designed to force an ideological split. This is a debate between people that accept the next phase of Human society will be dominated by a transition to a decentralized digital existence, represented by the metaverse, and those who do not. To adherents, those who do not accept this inevitability of this evolution are unfortunate misguided souls.</p><p>The centrality of the metaverse to the narrative is mystifying to some, but it makes logical sense in the context of the other pieces of puzzle. The metaverse is a necessary next step because Web2 is already a lost cause. There is no way to undo the ruin of our current digital landscape. It has been dominated by rent-seeking corporations that utilize their centralized monopoly power to make it extremely difficult for any individual to reap their just rewards for their contributions to society. Individuals cannot be owners in Web2. There is no future in this barren landscape.</p><p>To have a chance at success, we must start anew. Or, better yet, we must evolve. Web1 was about letting a user read. Web2 was about participating via social networks. Web3 is about owning.</p><p>Owning is the key component to Web3. To my eye, it’s the cornerstone upon which the entire edifice is built. A belief in the value of ownership is what makes decentralizing important. It’s what drives the view that a metaverse is essential. Confused? Not surprised. Me too. This is a convoluted puzzle once you start digging in, which is why the simple narrative package has been so crucial.</p><p>I’m going to try and break this down into as basic a logic chain as possible. I’m speed running the logic chain a bit — there’s a lot more depth to be mined in all of this — but it’s good enough until I get my Ted talk going:</p><ol><li>The web will continue to evolve as technology does in response to user demand</li><li>Users will demand greater empowerment in the digital sphere</li><li>In this case, empowerment comes in the form of individual ownership over their digital property (data, virtual goods, crypto, etc.)</li><li>To provide this ownership, centralized authorities must be removed and replaced with a decentralized system (this is where blockchain comes in)</li><li>The demand for decentralized systems will be high because people will demand/opt for greater control over their digital property, which cannot exist in centralized ecosystems (because centralized monopolies always try to dis-intermediate ownership — that’s why you need to pay a subscription for seat warmers in your new car)</li><li>Users will make this demand because digital property will have increasingly greater value in a person’s life and losing that value to a centralized authority’s unilateral decision will be unacceptable</li><li>Digital property will have increasingly greater value because society will continue placing greater emphasis on the digital representations</li><li>These digital representations will be of importance because Humanity will spend a significant percentage of its time in the metaverse</li><li>The metaverse will come into existence because Humanity’s demand for diversions from the real world will continue to increase</li><li>The form of the metaverse is likely to be an immersive reality because the technology is within reach and because people will want an alternative to the hellscape of their actual existences</li></ol><p>Man. Shit got grim.</p><p>I could be overstating things, but that’s the general thrust of the matter as I understand it. And it’s a powerful thrust. It sets up a classic conflict between the status quo and the upcoming generations that desire to break free from the unfair tyranny of it. The Web2 game is rigged, and the smart people will opt out and find a way to create their own game. Frankly, pursuing the next game is even the moral thing to do. People should own what’s theirs.</p><p>But beware: The status quo dies hard. The powers that be will spread FUD (Fear, Uncertainty, &amp; Doubt).</p><p>Don’t succumb to fear. Sometimes, you will be holding a bag, but, so long as you believe, WAGMI (We’re All Gonna Make It). It’s inevitable.</p><p>It’s a powerful narrative.</p><p>It’s just a brittle one.</p><h3>The Believers</h3><p>The narrative is structured in the broadest possible terms. As articulated, this isn’t about a disruption to a platform or a business model, it’s a wholesale shift in the nature of society and how it transacts. The next version of the web will put all prior versions to shame. Humanity will be fundamentally altered by this change. It’s more than a revolution, it’s an evolution.</p><p>I get the framing. When it comes to building a movement, subtlety isn’t an asset. In a situation like this, your lowest common denominator of communication needs to incite a horde to zealotry.</p><p>We’re looking for pithy and powerful.</p><p>But why is it structured this way? Why does it need to be this broad, this bold? I mean, movements need adherents, but why does this need to be a movement at all? Can’t it just be a business that evolves in response to demand?</p><p>Probably. It’s just a lot less exciting for everyone involved, particularly the sources of capital.</p><p>In fairness, it all began honestly enough.</p><p>At the root of Web3 there’s a group of people with anarcho-libertarian preferences who are largely DONE with the centralized status quo and want to change things. We’ll call them the Maxies. Their sensibilities drove them to conceive of a de-centralized alternative to this status quo, and their weapon of choice is the blockchain. Remove central authority. Trustless. Permissionless. Someday maybe resulting in Stateless (State meaning Nation here).</p><p>If the trustless, permissionless world was slower, less reliable, and prone to criminality, then so be it. It was a price worth paying to remove the government and corporations from your nooks and crannies. Power to the people was more important than transaction times measured in nanoseconds.</p><p>A lot of the Maxies were debating white papers and building mining rigs before it was cool or there was much economic incentive for it. They were doing it for the love of the game. For the genuine belief that decentralization was required to move Humanity forward. I admire them. I’m not one of them, but I can appreciate a principled purist.</p><p>The Maxies are a small group, but their grievances with the current order, when properly packaged, can resonate with a broader group. Getting that broader group on board with their particular solution is where things get a bit screwy. That broader group doesn’t care about decentralization — not in the way the purists do— but they do really hate how the current financial system doesn’t seem to be working for them very well. They were promised a life better than their parents, and it doesn’t seem like that outcome is coming to pass, what with all of these Great Recessions, pandemics, and student loans. Mostly Millennials who can’t buy houses and Zillennials who can’t afford rent. We’ll call them the Opportunists.</p><p>The Opportunists don’t really care about the nature of the solution, they just want an alternative to the status quo that provides a path to financial independence. They want the possibility of getting rich, ideally quickly and with relatively low work. If that happens while sticking a thumb in the eye of traditional institutions, then that’s sw33t so long as it doesn’t jeopardize their gains. This is about money, not piety.</p><p>The problem is that it’s fairly difficult to deliver that outcome to the Opportunists without a proper vehicle. One that’s accessible, thinly regulated (or at least thinly enforced), and capable of margin fueled trips to the moon.</p><p>Accessibility proved to be the stumbling block. No one understands WTF a distributed ledger means. White papers are not accessible. Anarcho-libertarian screeds are charming, but they just don’t pack much punch to those that aren’t already initiated. The value proposition needed to be simplified. Cleaned up. Made understandable.</p><p>How about a chart?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*grsJ0NLsiWXLY_o04RBriw.png" /></figure><p>Ah. Much better.</p><p>Chart go up. Money go up. There may be some bumps along the way, but it’s always heading in the right direction. Who doesn’t love a sure thing?</p><p>There are a few points on this chart that have made for some extremely compelling story telling. Where the buzz reached a broader and broader group of people. The massive run-up toward the end of 2017 was particular notable. People were getting rich. Lots of people. Probably one or two that you knew or at least sorta knew or had maybe heard your cousin talking about during Thanksgiving dinner.</p><p>That graph was the opportunity to bridge the gap between Maxies and Opportunists. It made an abstract concept with complicated goals simple, tangible, and relevant: Get rich.</p><p>And so a great compromise of narrative occurred. A deal with the devil as it were: the soul of decentralization was traded for critical mass. The blockchain became an economic enterprise rather than a political one. A great swarm of people began to search for “how to get crypto, go to moon” and almost none of them were reading Satoshi’s white paper. They were vaguely aware of the anti-centralization roots, but they wanted the fruit of the tree more. They wanted crypto. Ideally as easily as possible (which generally meant centralization).</p><p>Everything proceeds from there. Once a sufficiently large audience indicates a desire to mine for gold, the ecosystem responds. Some sell picks and shovels. Some sell maps to mother loads. Some sell fool’s gold. Some sell places to exchange gold nuggets for silver bars. Some just invest to help all the other somes do something. These are our friends the Middlemen (investors, entrepreneurs, con artists, etc.).</p><p>As more people become co-opted into the narrative, they become emotionally invested in it. They adopt, push, and amplify the narrative that seduced with great fervor. Why? Because the alternative is horrifying. Accepting that the narrative was overstated means that they’ve pledged fealty to a false god and in so doing placed themselves in an even worse position than if they had just gone along with the BS system that they felt they couldn’t succeed within. Sunk costs are annoying to accept.</p><p>Arguments about a lack of use cases aren’t persuasive, because use cases were never the point. The point was to get rich. The use cases were just fig leafs to justify the speculation. They’re disposable.</p><p>Crypto crashes are just winters, because believing that their escape pod out of the status quo is doomed is nihilistic.</p><p>This isn’t about reason. It’s about hope. Hope for a better tomorrow.</p><p>Hope that we’re all going to make it.</p><p>And so they push. And push. And push.</p><h3>The Unbelievers</h3><p>The Unbelievers, are, well, skeptical about all of this.</p><p>They come in many different flavors, but if I were to lump it all into one neat explanation, I’d say they’re the equal and opposite reaction. When blockchain and crypto were curios inhabiting the fringe of society, there were still Unbelievers, but it wasn’t a very glamorous pass time. The Maxies just aren’t very fun to poke fun at because they tend to be fairly open about the tradeoffs they’ll embrace in order to affect a fundamental shift in societal norms. Their viewpoints are political in nature, backed by a fairly well formed and durable ideology.</p><p>Maxies are the sort that will say: Yes, that would be worse in that way, but who cares, it’ll be so much better in the way that matters.</p><p>Idealists are annoying to argue with.</p><p>When the Opportunists entered the picture the game changed. Opportunists are not political actors, they’re economic ones. Their actions stem from a desire to accrue capital, rather than ideology. They will adopt Maxi viewpoints, but it’s typically a superficial thing in service of justifying buying another $500 of Doge coin. They’ll also accept narratives from the Middlemen as well, and Middlemen can be quite crafty at dressing their narratives up with a lot of the words and concepts used by the Maxies to make everything seem copacetic. Opportunists will also accept narratives from each other because the best way to go to the moon is with friends.</p><p>And the Opportunists and Middlemen, both being highly motivated by financial outcomes, will spend an inordinate amount of time trying to increase the value of whichever rocket they’re trying to launch. This comes in the form of a constant onslaught from all angles on the inevitability of the outcome they’re betting on. Media plays along because who doesn’t love a spicy narrative with some big names and some eye-popping wash-traded numbers attached? Social networks amplify the most inflammatory aspects, as social networks tend to do.</p><p>Unbelievers get annoyed by all of this. Not just the overreach, but also the inconsistency and incoherence of the narrative as expressed by Opportunists and Middlemen. At times this annoyance rises to the level of moral outrage. It sort of depends on who you are talking to and how grandiose of a counter-narrative they want to run. Are they just poking fun or are they clutching pearls and worrying about the children?</p><p>They see the crypto-narratives as flimsy and fake things. They point out all of the failures. All of the inconsistencies. All of the places where the Maxies have said one thing but the Opportunists and Middlemen are doing another.</p><p>They gleefully point out the Middlemen and Opportunists are centralizing everything.</p><p>They highlight every crypto crash.</p><p>They sadly shake their heads when another fraud is exposed.</p><p>They right click and save jpegs.</p><p>They assemble their own community of people that are opposed, for one reason or another, to the great swarm of Believers that so persistently proselytize their beliefs. They are Unbelievers. They just want everyone to get off their damned lawn and out of their Twitter feed (but also not entirely because they have YouTube channels to maintain).</p><p>Schadenfreude harvesting is a dirty work, but someone has to do it.</p><p>And so World War Web3 rages throughout the realm. The Believers versus the Unbelievers, with a swath of bewildered and occasionally annoyed Indifferent betwixt the two sides. And all of our sweet, innocent Twitter and LinkedIn feeds must pay the price.</p><h3>The Collateral Damage</h3><p>So. Why am I writing about this?</p><p>First, because I too desire to taste the sweet nectar of internet points. Second, because World War Web3 has had a rather toxic impact on the industry I’m most personally invested in: video games.</p><p>If ownership is the cornerstone of the Web3 future, then video games were always going to get drawn into this affair. There are few ways you can provide value for an object that exists purely online that is more powerful than a virtual world. Virtual worlds establish meaningful context for objects, which creates community value, utility value, and a scarcity framework that can support a fairly robust total value proposition to players (free-to-play and MMOs are built around this). That’s a desirable setup if you’re trying to make people care about jpegs.</p><p>That’s great. I’m all for the expansion of virtual worlds and how they interact with players. Ownership can be just one more tool for making a game resonate.</p><p>My issue comes with how the Web3 narrative interacts with the industry.</p><p>It all starts with the money and the incentives it creates.</p><p><strong><em>The Money</em></strong></p><p>After the performance of A16z’s first crypto fund (which could be conservatively categorized as absolutely bonkers prior to the recent crash and still bonkers after it), there was something of a stampede by LPs (pension fund managers, school endowments, family offices, etc.) interested in gaining their own crypto exposure. If A16z was going to the moon, they wanted to as well — their capital allocation model demanded it. It gets a bit complicated here, but capital allocation under the Yale model embraces a certain amount of speculation in a balanced, diversified portfolio. As a result, a few percent of hundreds of billions of dollars suddenly was looking for a home in crypto, and quickly.</p><p>It was a truly breathtaking expansion in available capital — I’ve never seen anything like it.</p><p>The offer from Pensions Funds to VC Firms was simple: Embrace the Web3 narrative and you can raise an egregious amount of capital at a ridiculous pace for your next fund. The scrutiny on your partners, investment strategy (to the extent there is one), and proposed deploy rate will be light.</p><p>The offer from VCs to Entrepreneurs was simple: Embrace the Web3 narrative and you can raise an egregious amount of capital at a ridiculous valuation for your next round. The scrutiny on your team, product roadmap (to the extent there is one), and proposed burn rate will be light.</p><p>As a developer, failing to embrace the narrative shuts off the spigot of funding tied to it. The teachers’ pension fund wants NFTs, and you better give it them. Blockchain is the future and your next video game was just a way of easing the transition to this inevitable outcome. Play ball and get paid. Or don’t and don’t.</p><p>An idea that was entirely non-fundable as a free-to-play game (which has a proven market value greater than any other segment of games by a wide margin and considerably easier design problems to solve) was instantly fundable as a Web3 pitch. It was a great frenzied mania as VCs raised funds as fast as the university endowment manager could sign the checks. The only thing that slowed the process was the pace of fund deployment, which could be solved by increasing valuations and lowering standards. Which happened at an equally breathtaking space. Because, ultimately, if the future truly was Web3, the worst thing you could do was not invest in the winner. So better to just invest everywhere.</p><p>And, well, here we are.</p><p>Billions have been invested into a segment of games that is incredibly difficult to design for, has no demonstrated scale audience, and no proven, sustainable business model. That isn’t to say it won’t eventually generate solutions to these gaps, but it is to say that the scale of investment happened well in advance of even a theoretical market framework that could deliver reasonable returns on that capital. This issue was largely ignored due to the availability of ICOs, token sales and other ways of bringing liquidity forward, but all that does is transfer the bag to the players. That’s all well and good until the enforcement actions begin or the players stop playing ball.</p><p>It was too much, too fast, and it hurts our industry.</p><p><strong><em>The Damage</em></strong></p><p>I believe there’s a role for ownership in games — largely because there always has been a role. I have a closet full of Magic cards to back it up. I also have a Microsoft GamePass subscription. It seems to me that both are capable of co-existing in some level of harmony. Sometimes it’s fun to own, often I’m indifferent. To my eye, ownership is a reasonable option, not an inevitable evolution.</p><p>But the nature of the narrative doesn’t allow that. It forces polarization. It removes the room for thoughtful discussion on how ownership will continue to evolve as a concept within virtual worlds and replaces it with a borderline religious howling match between Believers and Unbelievers.</p><ul><li><strong>Believers</strong>: The metaverse is the future. Where players will finally own their goods, which will travel through interoperable virtual spaces via the blockchain. Web2 is a predatory license-based horror house operated by monopolistic tyrants. It will die.</li><li><strong>Unbelievers</strong>: The future is great content, and Web3 produces bad, auto-generated content or no content at all. No one cares about ownership, they just want to be entertained and not have to deal with people shilling their NFTs. Web3 is a predatory ponzi scheme. Everyone involved is going to jail or should be.</li></ul><p>Trying to straddle the middle has few benefits because this polarization has extended to our audience — they’re Believers or Unbelievers too. The audience picks sides, with some percentage absolutely refusing to consider content produced on a model outside of their preferences. This stunts the growth of emerging opportunities and often requires a wholesale shift in demographics for the industry to evolve (as we’ve been seeing with mobile/free-to-play that last 4–5 years). People are always going to have preferences, but when those preferences escalate into flame wars, review bombing, and general toxicity, no one wins.</p><p>As a company, if you say you’re considering Web3, then you’re casting your lot with the Believers and your company is <a href="https://kotaku.com/we-live-in-hell-and-this-ubisoft-nft-that-requires-you-1848202326">suspect</a> amongst Unbelievers forever more (for the record, Fortis isn’t considering Web3). You cannot be pragmatic about this debate, you must be dogmatic.</p><p>And the problem with all of this is that it fragments the industry. The talent must pick a side of the divide — do they want to be known as a…Web3 Designer? The ramifications are real, as those who lived through the early dawn of free-to-play saw. The AAA/Free-to-Play divide was similarly fierce to Web3. The end result for our industry was a schism in the talent pool that resulted in us learning at a much slower pace and our games evolving at a much slower pace. Things have shifted in the last five years as more of AAA moves into service design (in order to scrabble together a reasonable hope of profit margin), but there was a lot of time lost. Talent pools that didn’t have this same level of schism out performed (China in particular).</p><p>Creative industries thrive on a certain fluidity in ideas and mediums, and polarization has the tendency to force outcomes that calcify into stagnation. AAA has suffered enormously from this. Given the exciting pace of evolution in games at this moment in time, it’s a terrible place for us to be in.</p><p><strong><em>Personally</em></strong></p><p>The monolithic nature of the Web3 narrative combined with the forcefulness of the presentation just weakens it in my eyes. I find the chain of logic on the Web3 side fairly unpersuasive in its totality but fairly interesting on any number of individual points. I’m open to the possibility of continued evolution of value propositions for players in games (my career has been spent thinking about this), but I’m fairly skeptical it has to come in precisely this packaging.</p><p>I’ve spent a long time studying ownership in games, largely because it ties into a motivation I’m deeply interested in: collection. Every time a version of ownership has popped up in the industry in a product (Eve Online, Entropia, Second Life, Ultima Online, Diablo III, etc.), I’ve watched it, even when it’s not “true” ownership by Web3 standards. My general conclusion is that most people feel like owners of their accounts’ possessions even when the accounts are subject to a license. Moving toward “true” (which I take to mean you can transfer, buy/sell and cash out at will) is an incredibly costly and risky proposition for both developer and player. There’s value to it, but it’s narrower than you’d think.</p><p>It doesn’t mean it’s a non-starter. It does mean that your game got a few orders of magnitude more difficult to design and run than your standard free-to-play economy (which is already wildly difficult to run well). Here’s a few of the incredibly interesting issues as I see them:</p><ul><li><strong>The number of people that tolerate having their virtual goods priced is low.</strong> The Diablo III auction house was an example of this. When a game relies on the toasty feeling of getting a sweet loot drop, few things are more disappointing than realizing that thing you farmed 9 hours for is worth $.03. For most, their entertainment is about escapism, and nothing ruins that feeling more than reducing it to numbers, particularly low ones.</li><li><strong>In order for ownership to matter, people will probably need to feel like they’re making an investment</strong>. You need reasonably high resell price floors. Price floors are incredibly difficult to reinforce at scale. Generally, you need to maintain scarcity (for example the reserve list on MTG) but it comes at a cost of ever increasing entry price for later players. This caps the accessibility of your game versus a free-to-play model, which allows you to price against individual demand rather than market price.</li><li><strong>An investment model in a game economy is incredibly difficult to design.</strong> You generally lose access to linear power creeping as a natural progression model because players who bought in early don’t like seeing their investment devalued. Horizontal expansion space is hard to do indefinitely due to the limited scope of core play mechanics. There’s only so many axes of progression available before you’re just adding entirely new games in — we see people already doing this by moving from character collection and into land sales in their Web3 games. The massive expansion in Magic: The Gathering card text is another example.</li><li><strong>Games are global, but the value of people’s time is local. </strong>This came up in Axie Infinity with the value of Smooth Love Potion and gold in World of Warcraft. The value of farmable goods in your game will always normalize at the value of the cheapest local wage rate with access to the game. This means massive inflation in your farmable economy, with few good solutions for combating it (I think I could write a book about this, it’s a super super interesting design problem in Web3).</li><li>Logistic issues like AML, tax compliance, etc.</li></ul><p>There’s another couple of dozen, but this blog is already outlandishly long. I think I’ll just leave it by saying: I really wish I could have these debates with people without it degenerating into a Believer/Unbeliever battle. Most of my attempts have been met with prickly responses as people tend to suspect that I’m not an honest broker and I’m actually some nefarious agent from the other side of the divide. There’s endemic fear that acknowledging the strengths of the other side and the weaknesses of your own will be weaponized against you. It’s been a bit depressing to see a bunch of my friends drink the kool-aid one way or another and stop engaging in the discourse.</p><p>There has never been a more exciting time to be in games. The possibilities are nigh on endless if we can just get some of these dogmatic narratives and shitty incentives flushed out of the creative pipes. The alternative is stagnation leading to calcification on a creative and professional level. Getting the discourse going between the sides would be a healthy start.</p><p>In the end, together, we can all make it.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2df9920e57bc" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Look at All the People]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/fortisgames/look-at-all-the-people-7f7b04722be7?source=rss-7f36b18f8cf2------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/7f7b04722be7</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Shawn Foust]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 03 Nov 2022 16:29:32 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-06-12T21:00:38.896Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*XO2uwF_3dQGFyrNmnThwpA.png" /></figure><p>We’re going to talk about people in this one. It’s a beast of a topic, so I’ll probably split it into a few separate posts, with this one really trying to talk about the relationship between the pandemic, culture, and the <a href="https://medium.com/fortisgames/the-design-lane-b648d7116737">Design Lane</a>.</p><p>But, before all of that, permit me a brief personal detour.</p><h3><strong>A Detour (of a most personal nature)</strong></h3><p>It may shock many of the readership to learn that I am a nerd. Such an admission hardly bears notice in the modern world, but I came to age in the 80’s and 90s, an era that bore some hostility to the sort of person inclined toward dungeons, dragons, and daydreaming.</p><p>Things are different now, with nerds gaining certain status within society:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*4Mc4IuXwWMkYpJA7olk4ag.png" /><figcaption>This seems healthy.</figcaption></figure><p>But back then, in the long ago, in the before times, being a nerd was hardly a ticket to social success. My aberrant interests (I was really into playing bards in AD&amp;D and building artifact decks in Magic: The Gathering) combined with volatility in my home life to create a pretty severe feeling of social isolation. I managed to figure out how to LARP normalcy around high school, but, even then, there’s a certain emotional cost to maintaining a façade.</p><p>Thankfully, the internet decided to manifest in all of its AOLian glory around that time. CDs with FREE MINUTES were plentiful, and I gorged upon a great feast of online access until I was forced to become a paying member and become more judicious in my usage.</p><p>But even under MINUTE AUSTERITY, the internet quickly became my home. It was the place I felt most myself, and most at ease. Why? Because it was there that I found my community.</p><p>All of a sudden, there were people.</p><p>People like me.</p><p>Lots of them.</p><p>All over.</p><p>I really can’t describe what an incredible boon that was, how fundamentally it changed my self perception and my life. I went from feeling on the outside to feeling very much on the inside.</p><p>These people were <em>gamers</em>. Unabashedly and thoroughly.</p><p>They were cool, and I was cool in their company.</p><p>It was all very cool.</p><p>I befriended some, and mostly just enjoyed being around the others. Early on, our haunt of choice was a text-based multi-user dungeon known as Gemstone III, where we resided in a small, wintry town known as Icemule Trace.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*AjdBY1AZeIOoFFRk.gif" /><figcaption>Behold! Icemule in all of its glory. This is from Gemstone IV, but Google refuses to cooperate and show me the original map.</figcaption></figure><p>We were salty, decent folk, unlike those pampered twits down in rival town Wehnimer’s Landing. And, even though traveled we came from all over, we were community. We knew each other. We looked out for each other.</p><p>It was a formative experience.</p><p>As the internet has blossomed outward and reduced human interaction to its most superficial lowest common denominators via algorithms, I think a lot about those early years and what that deep community felt like. It’s something I’d like to recreate. Both in the company I work at and in the games I help create. I want be a part of a group of people who are all very different but feel familiar all the same. I want the whole world in a community, working together for some collective goal.</p><p>And, for a long time, this didn’t feel possible. Not in the construct of a company at least. Previously successful patterns of work had calcified into hardened views on how companies <em>must</em> work. These views insisted on a certain style of organization with a certain style of culture and style of working. Within that system, a diverse, global workforce was far less valuable than a local, culturally homogenous one. Alternatives were not to be considered, not if you were serious about attracting funding.</p><p>Until the pandemic.</p><p>Suddenly, endemic assumptions about work were called into question. No one was quite sure what work would even look like any more. Perhaps it would be the same, but perhaps it would be entirely different. Responsiveness to a dynamic and shifting environment might be more important to success than having a really amazing work campus with soft serve in Silicon Valley. Things were different. Could be different.</p><p>Enter Fortis.</p><p>Global. Remote First.</p><p>Games where you belong made by people who want to belong.</p><p>That’s the dream.</p><p>Detour over. Let’s rejoin the main road.</p><h3><strong>The People Puzzle</strong></h3><p>Talent is a precious commodity. Finding the right people and convincing them to join you is often the greatest obstacle a company faces in the early going. You start with an idea, but you need a team to make it a reality. That’s the People Puzzle. There’s many versions of it, but it’s always the same: how to find the right people at the right time.</p><p>Fortis was founded during the pandemic. At that moment in time, it wasn’t clear what the future might hold. We were in an unprecedented moment. Society had never had the technological capability to engage in work remotely (at least not at this scale) and it rarely had a force of suitable power to disrupt standard practice. It was a surreal experience to consider whether companies were just going to be different moving forward. That past might be an unreliable predictor of future.</p><p>In the murk, we made a judgment call: Fortis would be remote first. We would commit to it up front and attempt to design the entire company with that in mind. We believed that leaning into the societal shifts then under way would be a competitive advantage compared to companies that were on the fence about it (or that had been built with a different set of assumptions in mind).</p><p>The bargain we made was simple: We would trade the closeness live offers for the ability to hire the world.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*OSXhth5_6M20GR9TRduiOQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>I feel like I’m playing Pokémon, just trying to hire ’em all.</figcaption></figure><p>I think we came out ahead in that trade. We employ amazing people in twelve countries and we receive ~2000 applications a week. It’s an incredible inflow of people wildly beyond anything I’ve ever experienced before. I believe we have access to the right people and I believe we can hire them at the right time.</p><p>But I don’t want to pretend it didn’t come without costs.</p><p>Even under “traditional” circumstances, it’s hard to establish a strong culture with trust (I think the “in” phrase for this is psychological safety) in professional settings, doubly so in creative enterprises where debates tend to center on ambiguous, complicated, and subjective topics like: Is this the best design for this audience? Quadly so when you’re building in the <a href="https://medium.com/fortisgames/the-design-lane-b648d7116737">Design Lane</a>, which has considerably more ambiguity to manage.</p><p>Fortis is a <strong>global</strong>, <strong>remote</strong>, <strong>Design Lane</strong> <strong>game developer</strong>. Each of these qualifiers makes it more difficult to establish a strong cultural identity.</p><ul><li>By being <strong>global</strong>, we have far more local work cultures to reconcile into a stable company culture.</li><li>By being <strong>remote</strong>, we have far fewer social reinforcements to our culture. Team building via Starbucks runs is gone.</li><li>By being in the <strong>Design Lane</strong>, we have considerably more ambiguity in our processes, which creates tension.</li><li>By being a <strong>game developer</strong>, we have to deal with the passion and emotional scarring that comes along with working in games. People arrive with dreams and baggage.</li></ul><p>All of these are entropic forces in Fortis’ culture, constantly trying to drag it toward chaos. It’s more than the typical startup needs to deal with. It adds considerable complexity to management, even if our approach is relatively straight forward:</p><ul><li>Define the culture clearly — mission, vision, values &amp; processes.</li><li>Hire against our values and try to live them.</li><li>Be transparent that this is an evolving process.</li><li>Double down on empathy.</li></ul><p>Four points. Simple!</p><p>Those bullets are easy to write and hard to put into practice.</p><p>You see all of these articles about managers wanting to force workers back into the office. Often its framed as out-of-touch managers with God complexes trying to destroy the lives of their subordinates so they can live out their narcissistic fantasies via face time. I’m pretty content to have that narrative out there since it works in our favor, but I get where the managers are coming from.</p><p>It’s really hard to be effective as a manager in a remote setting, particularly if your company isn’t set up for it and didn’t hire against it.</p><ul><li><strong>Communication</strong>: The value of communication is far higher in a remote setting, but its effectiveness is far lower. Lol @ charisma in remote settings — you just become an insane person emoting frantically in your basement at a webcam.</li><li><strong>Emotions</strong>: Negative moments — such as constructive feedback — are felt far more keenly than positive ones when people are sitting in a room by themselves.</li><li><strong>Politics</strong>: Social cues are less noticeable, causing misunderstandings that proliferate and entrench into problematic narratives that stampede through the Zoomiverse.</li><li><strong>Interpersonal</strong>: It’s harder to build connections because most interactions are transactional (Zoom meeting for a particular purpose or a Slack message to ask for something).</li></ul><p>Tough situation.</p><p>In a remote company, it feels like culture needs to operate as its own stand alone product, rather than a natural extension of modeled leadership behavior. Remote companies make it far harder for that behavior to be modeled and understood. The four point plan of attack I outlined above is our approach to things, and it’s worth going into with more detail. We don’t have time to cover everything so, we’ll just start with the first point: a clear definition of our vision, mission, and values.</p><p>It’s hard to build a culture if people don’t know who we are and what we aim to do.</p><p>So who are we?</p><h3>A Fitting Culture for Cultural Misfits</h3><p>We’re Fortis.</p><p>We build games where you belong… (<em>← Vision statement.</em>)</p><p>…made by people who want to belong.</p><p>Our culture is built upon a desire to find ways to bridge the gap between people, because that’s what our games are meant to do.</p><p>You can probably see the through line from the personal detour we opened with to the vision statement. Like most startups, Fortis is shaped by the things that motivated the founders to come together and all three of us were strongly attached to “belonging” as a guidepost for the company (I’ll leave it to Steve &amp; Calvin to offer their own personal connections to this). We viewed Fortis as an opportunity to create a community that embraces a broader group of people from a wider set of backgrounds than might be found elsewhere.</p><p>In our experience, a certain set of personality types tended to dominate leadership roles in our industry. The ability to project a viewpoint in a charismatic way in a live setting was an essential criteria to leadership. Intuitive, on-the-spot reasoning and debate ability were also highly prized. The creative process was best driven by people who could maintain a veneer of mastery over it at all times. Owning the room, as it were.</p><p>Quiet types. Deliberative types. Careful types.</p><p>All disfavored. <em>Misfits</em>.</p><p>Historically, that’s played to my benefit (Multi-classing from a lawyer base gave me +5 to verbal combat). I’m less certain it always plays to the company’s benefit. Particularly when confronting the complexity of the Design Lane. Within the Design Lane, many issues don’t reach resolution through charismatic driving (which the standard leader archetype excels at), they require sitting with the problem, considering the complexities, and then searching for solution by gathering data through experimentation.</p><p>That approach sits on the far end of the spectrum from the auteur/visionary model.</p><p>As we considered the implications of our lane, it became clear that our culture would need to find ways to draw in people outside of the typical leadership archetypes and support them. These people would need to feel like they <em>belonged</em> in the company.</p><p>This has required a massive retooling of standard industry processes, some of which I referenced last time when talking about how we handle green lights. There’s a de-weighting of high stakes meetings and pageantry. Discussion takes place asynchronously through written documents with comments rather than in the ZOOM DEBATE THUNDERDOME. If a debate breaks out live, everyone is told that the topic is not closed and they should feel free to add their thoughts in writing afterwards if they want to consider the issue further. People are also encouraged to put messages in the chat if they would rather not participate via speaking. The goal is to encourage thoughtful deliberation of topics and to open the avenues to discuss them to a broad array of communication styles.</p><p>That’s had all sorts of interesting effects. Since things are written, there’s now a textual history in the company, which makes ramping future people into context easier. It also creates greater accountability for decisions because we can go back and know exactly what we were thinking at the time we were making them (rather than allowing ego-preserving selective memories to fill in those gaps).</p><p>It also makes it far easier for people from different work cultures and time zones to participate. Following a fast-moving debate on an abstract topic like game design in your second or third language is a challenge. Participating in that debate when you have a local work culture that discourages confrontation is intimidating — asking probing questions on a document presents a lower barrier to participation. If you can’t make a Zoom meeting, the relevant context will be written (or the meeting itself will be recorded for future viewing) so you can still respond.</p><p>There’s a lot more to it. The last few years has highlighted some of the difficulties people face in the industry when they don’t fit the standard mould, and building Fortis has been enlightening on just how narrow that mould is. Very few processes have been left untouched, and all of them are being evolved as we learn more about how to build belonging in the company. It’s invigorating stuff, but it’s a beast to really untangle.</p><p>In the end, I think the prize will be worth the pain. The pandemic has already forced us to work in a new way, and it seems like an ideal time to really consider and update the processes the industry has used to function. These blog articles (beyond being a shocking exercise in self-aggrandizement) have been a helpful tool in trying to document and lay out the thought process behind this effort. It’s a good window into the Fortis way.</p><p>To those of you who have enjoyed reading them, shoot us an application at <a href="https://fortisgames.com/">fortisgames.com</a>. If you think it’s a pile of BS, drop a comment — that’s the Fortis way too.</p><p><a href="https://medium.com/fortisgames/hello-world-1f73be677303"><strong>First Part</strong></a><strong> | </strong><a href="https://medium.com/fortisgames/the-design-lane-b648d7116737"><strong>Previous Part</strong></a><strong> | </strong><a href="https://medium.com/fortisgames/games-the-lingua-franca-f6b1a6083cd3"><strong>Next Part</strong></a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=7f7b04722be7" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/fortisgames/look-at-all-the-people-7f7b04722be7">Look at All the People</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/fortisgames">Fortis Games</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Design Lane]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/fortisgames/the-design-lane-b648d7116737?source=rss-7f36b18f8cf2------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b648d7116737</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[videogames]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[game-design]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[games]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[venture-capital]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Shawn Foust]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 04 Oct 2022 16:01:43 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-11-03T19:07:54.933Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/700/0*nL9DJ6PbR7JigNnO.png" /></figure><p>Welcome back to the Fortis Games (<a href="http://www.fortisgames.com/">www.fortisgames.com</a>) metablog, where we offer non-fungible knowledge as a token of our appreciation.</p><p>We’ve been building toward this one. <a href="https://medium.com/fortisgames/hello-world-1f73be677303">Part 1</a> was all about the aspirations. <a href="https://medium.com/fortisgames/the-game-investment-game-38df35f2add8">Part 2</a> was why those aspirations are difficult to fund (I blame society). Part 3 shall delve into the dark depths of assembling a Design Lane company.</p><p>How it’s different.</p><p>How it’s the same.</p><p>How if this doesn’t work out my mother is going to be right that I should have never left law and that my entire life is a fraud. Not her exact words, but we all know what she was thinking last Mother’s Day.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*5AShlncNw4f4enVISCRQOw.png" /><figcaption>A visual representation of why mom thinks I should go back to law. I’ve told her the hair isn’t going to regrow, but she thinks it’s worth a shot.</figcaption></figure><p>Anyways, on to the main event.</p><p><strong>The Design Lane</strong></p><p>We should define the Design Lane. That seems important. As much as I like making up mysterious terms and lording them over people, it’s not particularly conducive to blog retention.</p><p>The “Design” in Design Lane is relatively straightforward. It refers to game design.</p><p>A “Lane” refers to a company’s competitive strategy. It guides the company’s choices, it determines the type of talent it wants to attract, and it drives the sort of products it’s going to make. Here are some examples of major lanes in the industry:</p><ul><li>The traditional <strong>Publishing Lane</strong> focuses on building a competitive advantage around gaining access to users, typically leveraging their scale to outbid/out-market the competition. In the boxed good era, this looked like the AAA publishers with their privileged access to brick and mortar retail. Now it looks like scale spenders on ad networks.</li><li>The <strong>Financial Engineering Lane</strong> looks for market pricing inefficiencies that can be exploited via acquisition arbitrage. Folks buying up companies at a lower multiple than they can obtain on elsewhere market fit in here (often private/public or geo/geo).</li><li>The <strong>Platform Lane</strong> typically seeks to aggregate a number of content creators in a single place by offering some efficiency (either a technology like an engine or a distribution platform) and then levy a tax. It’s the publishing lane without the middleman.</li><li>The <strong>Disruption Lane</strong> focuses on being a first-mover in an emerging macro market shift. It’s speculative by nature, but amazing when it works out. Mobile was a good example there. Web3 folks are betting on this now.</li></ul><p>This isn’t total coverage of the lanes, and there’s some interesting variants within and between each that are worth talking about at some point, but let’s stay focused. All of the lanes described above are commercially viable. They’re also investable to varying degrees, depending on market conditions.</p><p>None of these lanes have game design at their core. They’re all dependent on design, but they’re not driven by it. They benefit from advancements in design, but these lanes do not focus on generating them. They are design opportunists, not innovators. This does not make them evil, but it does make them unlikely to produce much by way of novelty in design.</p><p>And that’s where the Design Lane comes in as a competitive strategy. It’s a bet on game design. More specifically, it’s a bet that commercial opportunities within our industry can arise with abundance out of design innovations in addition to the more traditional bets on model shifts and arbitrages. That there is an explosive economic potential lying within so many audiences, if only they were presented with something sufficiently new and interesting to jolt them from their dreary doldrums.</p><p>In a Design Lane company, the organization must put design itself in the center of its competitive effort. It must believe that the commercial goal comes out of advancing design and be wholly organized to pursue it. A Design Lane company is open to arbitrages, business model disruptions, and other opportunities, but they’re always placed in the context of a single question: Is there a design gap (and are we positioned to close it)?</p><blockquote><em>A design gap occurs when there is a mismatch between assumptions driving existing design principles/norms and the actual circumstances related to a given audience.</em></blockquote><p><strong>Some examples of historic design gaps:</strong></p><p><strong>Shooters.</strong> I discussed this briefly in the last part, but shooters were largely calcified, with Call of Duty and Battlefield dominating the field and typically competing within the same framework (team deathmatch + RPG progression + fidelity advancements) with periodic premium releases. Competing with these two games, particularly during the holiday season, was largely seen as a fool’s errand. This viewpoint was anchored in the assumption that the traditional publisher model was unassailable, particularly on console. Eventually, a novel design, service-based Battle Royales, that leaned into the shifts in the market (the rise of alternative distribution models, increased bandwidth, mobile, etc.) upended the space.</p><p><strong>Roguelites.</strong> This one is in progress, with the design model beginning to move from the indie space to broader adoption. The roguelite model substantially increases the value of and durability of content by networking it together via a repeatable decision tree rather than placing it on a purely linear power progression. Indies utilized this framework because it made a body of content significantly more replayable (which made it easier to justify a price point on Steam)— the same theory is valuable in the context of a service (but significantly more difficult to design and balance). The linear model is outdated, based on a time and place in services that no longer exists. Expect more here in the years to come.</p><p><strong>Mobile.</strong> When mobile first arose, many assumed it would be similar to the traditional premium model. It took some time to recognize these assumptions were incorrect, that the immersion framework didn’t work well on a phone. That a design focused on intermittent, session-based play throughout the day was the opportunity. Even now, there are fairly regular “AAA for Mobile” pitches, which tend to conflate largely incompatible design frameworks.</p><p><em>Aside: Interestingly, a more immersive model (but not typical AAA immersion) might be viable now due to recent shifts in demographics, community, and technology. Genshin Impact, I’m looking at you.</em></p><p><strong>Some existing unsolved gaps that generate a lot of noise (we aren’t pursuing these):</strong></p><p><strong>Web3 — NFT/Play-to-Earn.</strong> Within web3, there was an initial assumption that standard free-to-play designs could be leveraged despite the fact that they are simply not built for open economies. A “Play-to-Earn” or “Play &amp; Earn” model is not viable within prevailing designs in free-to-play. They’re mutually exclusive. This is beginning to be understood as the speculative mania dies down and people begin to talk about “utility,” but that’s an oversimplification. There’s a complicated interplay between utility, scarcity, transaction costs, and time/value balancing that needs to be worked out. Needless to say, there’s an opportunity for Design Lane companies here (just not us for the moment).</p><p><strong>Metaverse</strong>. The aspirational metaverse, one that operates as essentially a duplicate existence in a virtual space, is going to require a completely different design model. I wrote at some length <a href="https://venturebeat.com/games/metaverse-is-an-identity-not-a-place/">over here</a> about what that design model might need to be based upon (I argue you start with virtual identity as the foundation rather than any particular platform or piece of content), but I’ll freely admit that I have no certainty as to what design framework might be required to generate a viable digital life. Solving for meaning in digital life seems like a good use of time for a Design Lane game company though.</p><p>Those are a few design gaps. There’s a zillion others. Some big, some small. Many of them with wildly commercial opportunities attached to their resolution. Identifying gaps takes some craft, determining which to prioritize takes a strong sense of where your design strengths lie (and hoping there’s an overlap with the identified gaps), and closing the gaps takes a heavy investment into building an innovation-oriented creative process capable of producing solves.</p><p>Innovation-oriented creative process.</p><p>So many words.</p><p>Why not just say greenlight process?</p><p>Because a greenlight process, as it’s currently understood, doesn’t produce innovation. They’re largely there to reduce the scope of a project to something quantifiable and checkable via milestones (which has the side effect of eliminating innovation discovery). In fact, many of the processes for developing games aren’t designed for innovation. That’s the legacy of an industry dominated by lanes other than the Design Lane. Since other competitive lanes tend to co-opt design solves rather than generate them themselves, the processes they’ve developed tend to skip over the angst and misery associated with innovation.</p><p>I don’t blame them. Angst and misery are decidedly not fun.</p><p>Sadly, you can’t skip over that part. In fact, you can’t build a Design Lane company using standard processes. They’re incompatible (except the Disruption Lane, there’s some overlap there).</p><p>That’s a problem. A big problem. A big process problem.</p><p>It’s problematic.</p><p>I’m still processing it.</p><p><strong>Processing Design Lane Greenlight Processes (a process in progress)</strong></p><p>The heart of the matter comes down to this: in the other lanes, you can assume the outcome. You don’t need to question whether something is possible, you already know it is. If you don’t know it’s possible, you can’t price your arbitrage/upside value, which means it’s not worth pursuing. It’s a perfectly reasonable principle to apply when you’re a scale business that needs to build additional scale businesses and isn’t rewarded for volatility (most public companies fall into this category, and most VC backed companies just want the hockey-stick).</p><p>This shouldn’t come as a surprise, the nature of industry risk aversion was the theme of <a href="https://medium.com/fortisgames/the-game-investment-game-38df35f2add8">Part 2</a>.</p><p>With question of innovation removed from the equation, the decision process in the other lanes proceeds in a fairly orderly matter. You’re basically just getting to an ROI calculation on the known, identifiable thing:</p><ul><li>What is the thing we want to arbitrage?</li><li>How long do we think it will take to acquire/duplicate?</li><li>How much money will it cost?</li><li>How much execution risk is there along the way?</li><li>Can this level of risk be sustained by the arbitrage margin?</li><li>Is what margin remains attractive?</li></ul><p>This reasoning tends to dominate the Publishing, Platform, and Financial Engineering lanes. The Greenlight process reflects these key questions and seeks to control the investment of resources. Gates are established to ensure the expected return is being protected before additional resources are released and everything works out fine so long as the margin on the arbitrage is big enough to sustain some execution risk along the way.</p><p>That is the Greenlight process as it exists in the traditional sense.</p><p>Within the Design Lane, there’s a slew of additional questions that complicate matters considerably:</p><ul><li>What audiences do we believe are currently underserved?</li><li>What are they currently doing with their time?</li><li>Can we identify an alternative that they would consider doing?</li><li>What would motivate them to consider switching to that alternative?</li><li>How easy is it to communicate that alternative?</li><li>Can that alternative be distilled into a set of designs?</li><li>Can we determine the best design of the possible options?</li><li>Will those designs be defensible from fast-followers?</li><li>How long do we think it would take to gain confidence in this path?</li><li>What is the opportunity cost of pursuing this path versus alternatives?</li></ul><p>The majority of these questions cannot be answered via speculation alone. They require experimentation. They require slamming our collective heads against the wall and bitter tears of defeat as you search through the <strong>design labyrinth</strong>, trying to find the right path. The target is often moving, and in constant competition with the other options the company might pursue. Data is sparse (particularly if you adhere to standard practices) during the early going as well. Getting lost in the maze is very possible.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*ErRD3xwvge4YWaFX" /><figcaption>Of course, if a concept gets lost in the Design <a href="https://youtu.be/O2yd4em1I6M?t=54">Labyrinth</a>, it’ll be imprisoned by David Bowie until you navigate the maze with Jennifer Connelly. Happens all the time. Poor captured baby concept. :(</figcaption></figure><p>Process needed to change to accommodate this search. To guide it. To make progress possible amidst the ambiguity of endless possibility.</p><p>The end result is a massive overhaul of the traditional greenlight framework at Fortis. Concepts are neither vague ideas nor X for Y statements — they’re thesis arguments. They’re a statement of position on an identified design gap and a request for resources to prove the thesis one way or another. They’re an acknowledgement of the core unknowns that sit at the heart of the concept and an offering on how best to proceed with understanding whether they can be solved. They are brutal to assemble. Intellectual self-flagellation.</p><p>We greenlight when we feel like we’ve honestly identified why the design gap is there, and how difficult it will be to find a solution. Then we gather a team.</p><p>Once a team is assembled, their progress through the labyrinth is measured by increases in confidence rather than a checkmark next to a deliverable. Constant communication about ideas becomes the heart of the process, and every playtest is treated as an opportunity to learn more about the problem space we’re searching through. Knowledge flows from the data gathered via experimentation, so speed of iteration is paramount. The success of the process lives and dies on the back of collaborative back and forths between stakeholders (which are a smaller set of people than in a traditional process), with a lot more effort at honesty about where things stand.</p><p>It can be frustrating, because things often feel uncertain. Where a project stands is often in doubt, because the path through the labyrinth is hard to judge (and it may be an illusion).</p><p>It takes a lot of trust. A lot of belief in the skills and the intentions of the people in the process.</p><p>Which gets us to people. The industry processes surrounding people are also a problem.</p><p>People process problems.</p><p>Problems processing people.</p><p>Processing people problems.</p><p>Words are fun.</p><p>Next time, we’ll talk about the traditional model of hiring, training, and managing and how that maps to the Design Lane.</p><p>Here’s a teaser: Not well.</p><p><a href="https://medium.com/fortisgames/hello-world-1f73be677303"><strong>First Part</strong></a><strong> | </strong><a href="https://medium.com/fortisgames/the-game-investment-game-38df35f2add8"><strong>Previous Part</strong></a><strong> | </strong><a href="https://medium.com/fortisgames/look-at-all-the-people-7f7b04722be7"><strong>Next Part</strong></a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b648d7116737" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/fortisgames/the-design-lane-b648d7116737">The Design Lane</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/fortisgames">Fortis Games</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Game Investment Game]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/fortisgames/the-game-investment-game-38df35f2add8?source=rss-7f36b18f8cf2------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/38df35f2add8</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[videogames]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[technology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[video-games-industry]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[tech]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[venture-capital]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Shawn Foust]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 15 Sep 2022 15:58:34 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-10-18T06:33:42.921Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/875/1*GTWkzGmGt4dxERi1EiFo6g.png" /></figure><p>Hello, friends.</p><p>Time for part two. Might make a trilogy. Or an interconnected blog metaverse. They’re hot right now.</p><p>In the <a href="https://medium.com/fortisgames/hello-world-1f73be677303">first part</a>, I went through why we wanted to found a game company that focused on advancing game design versus some of the alternatives. The goal was clear, but the path had some twists.</p><p>The pitching process was a grisly Zoom gauntlet. In a decent chunk of those meetings, we were pushed to align our narrative with a more investable one — to de-emphasize the role of design in what we are doing in favor of things like business model shifts or platform shifts. In the end, it all worked out, but it’s worth talking a bit about what we learned along the way.</p><p>More to the point, I want to get into why design innovation is disfavored as an investment path. Then I want to connect that to what types of projects do end up attracting funding and the toxic effect that’s had on creativity writ large within our industry.</p><p>This one is going to get into the weeds.</p><p>Grab a coffee.</p><p>Settle in.</p><p>Ready?</p><p>Great. We proceed.</p><p><strong>Capital Allocators &amp; The Power of Patterns</strong></p><p>Let’s start by talking about allocators of capital. Allocators of capital have been entrusted with the holy and solemn responsibility of determining which teams get funding and what games get made. Allocators might be a venture capitalist or a senior executive at a large publisher. Generally (but not always), they come from disciplines outside of the core game-making crafts. They deal in more arcane and mysterious arts like strategy, finance, and marketing. Even if they have made games directly, that experience tends to rapidly atrophy as they move away from the day-to-day hustle and bustle of development.</p><p>This experience gap creates a knowledge gap. Their background gives them an understanding of how to evaluate patterns, but they’re not particularly prepared to speculate on what can conceivably done. They theorize about extensions from the current state, applying previously learned lessons about market shifts or business model shifts.</p><p>There’s consequences to that knowledge gap.</p><p>The primary consequence is in what is viewed as investable. Allocators of capital tend to favor investing in patterns they recognize and understand or, absent that, just following the herd and doing what everyone else is doing (the <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fear_of_missing_out">FOMO</a> theory of investment). There’s safety in numbers. It’s not an insane approach to things, but it does limit the field of investment-grade pitches to a pretty narrow set of trends.</p><p>A developer seeking funding is therefore given a choice: mimicry with funding or novelty without it.</p><p>Fit within a pattern or forego funding.</p><p>Unfortunately, advancements in game design do not fall into the recognizable pattern/FOMO herd category because they are, by definition, an attempt to break an existing pattern by introducing a novelty.</p><p>We see this play out in very real, tangible ways in a pitch meeting or greenlight. It comes in the form of the blaring signals that the thing you’re pitching needs to be CATEGORIZED and SORTED into something that’s a part of something that everyone agrees is something. A pattern must be identified.</p><blockquote>“What are the comps?”</blockquote><blockquote>“What genre is this?”</blockquote><p>What pattern does this fall into so I, the capital allocator, can rest assured that the thing you are pitching to me is an acceptable thing? How do I quickly explain to the people who trust me to dole out money that I made a good decision? Ideally it’s something everyone else is doing, but with an even pithier catchphrase attached to it than whatever my competitors invested in.</p><blockquote>“Oh…so it’s like Minecraft (acceptably large audience) but for the metaverse (acceptable place to park Limited Partner money)?”</blockquote><p>NO. PITHIER.</p><blockquote>“NFT Voxels. Blocks on the blockchain. The blockaverse.”</blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/684/0*pp38oKeH5jqu13yx" /></figure><p>What trends might be most appealing depends largely on who is sitting on the other side of the table and what they want to hear. In AAA, a good pitch tends to involve a reference to some other game that has been very successful somewhere else associated with some marketable theme/IP — It’s like Breath of the Wild but with Ninjas (because we own the Ninja franchise and they’re very cool). In startups, it’s often some reference to a scale game but with a platform arbitrage — It’s like League of Legends but on mobile. Or Magic: The Gathering, but with NFTs.</p><p>In each case, you’re pitching an opportunity that focuses on understood arbitrages, not an advancement in design. In the above pitches, the design has been proven elsewhere, and that helps make the idea “safe” enough to invest in because the risk comes in a better understood and more marketable space. The investor need not worry about the messiness of creativity, because it has largely been eliminated from the equation.</p><p>Safe.</p><p>Safe is a dangerous word when it comes to creative industries.</p><p>Safety is the mind killer.</p><p>I don’t blame the capital allocators. The desire for safety is a reflection of their incentives. Pattern breakers are hard to gain alignment on and hard to justify when they fail. If you reach the point where you are given the chance to allocate capital, you very much want people to understand why you made a bet and not blame you if it happens to fail.</p><p>“Breath of the Wild with Ninjas” is easier to explain than describing a new genre. Imagine pitching Fortnite if the concept of battle royales didn’t exist. Let’s explore why with a bit of role play (and excuse me while I absolutely annihilate proper formatting to make it more readable):</p><p><strong>Gamey McGameDev</strong>:</p><blockquote><em>“This entire team versus team shooter market is stale! Sure, it’s making billions of dollars, but it’s ripe for disruption, and me and my ragtag team of four are going to make it happen with our sw33t design.”</em></blockquote><p><strong>Sir Allocator d’Capital the Third, Seed Funder of a Decacorn, LinkedIn Top Voice of 2017, Retweeted by Elon, First of His Name</strong>:</p><p>Leans forward, adjusts Patagonia sweater vest.</p><blockquote><em>“We already have a shooter.”</em></blockquote><p>Pauses. Squints, a shrewd glint in the eye.</p><blockquote>“<em>Does it have superheroes? They’re doing very well in testing right now.”</em></blockquote><p><strong>Gamey McGameDev</strong>:</p><blockquote><em>“What? No. Wait. Maybe. Not at first. But maybe later.”</em></blockquote><p>Begins to gesticulate wildly.</p><blockquote><em>“I wanna put a hundred people in a giant map with poison gas that slowly moves inward until there is only one person left.”</em></blockquote><p>Stares offscreen, eyes glazing over, as if peering into a majestic future. A single tear slowly travels down their cheek.</p><blockquote><em>“And they jump out of a plane and do weird dances and it’ll eventually be a metaverse with concerts in it.”</em></blockquote><p><strong>Sir Allocator:</strong></p><p>Metaverse?</p><p>That sounds made up.</p><p>Better to place it in a category.</p><blockquote><em>“So it’s some kind of shooting MMO?”</em></blockquote><p><strong>GameyMcGameDev</strong>:</p><blockquote><em>“Kind of. It’s a new kind–”</em></blockquote><p><strong>Sir Allocator:</strong></p><blockquote>“MMOs are too expensive, and they all fail.”</blockquote><p><strong>=Zoom Call Ended=</strong></p><p>Sad.</p><p>Of course, the value of hundred person poison-filled skydiving concert metaverses is well understood now, but in this fictional world where there were no prior examples, who would be a funder? Fortnite was pre-dated by all some early indicators — a successful Arma mod, the erstwhile streamer favorite H1Z1, and Fortnite’s immediate predecessor PUBG — but the Battle Royale frenzy only took hold (and attracted serious capital) once scale was achieved and arbitrages became attractive. Then came the Everything Royale era.</p><p>Why only AFTER Fortnite was successful?</p><p>Because those early indicators weren’t <em>relevant comps</em> to funders — they weren’t strong enough evidence of opportunity. Without scale, Battle Royales weren’t worth paying attention to. Not worthy of attempting to duplicate and exploit. Who cares about a mod that didn’t make any money? Or a AA game with a few excited streamers? Those games were just something that the intern <a href="https://youtu.be/mLyOj_QD4a4?t=81">Leeroy Jenkins</a> was playing, and that kid would charge headlong into anything. It’s not the sort of thing respectable people put capital behind.</p><p>Why?</p><p>Capital allocators sit at a table of people similar to themselves (though perhaps even more removed from game development). It’s a very expensive and pretty table and maybe even has marble accents. I’ve provided a visual aid so you can understand just how great these tables are:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/612/0*7G7XjpK37K0-FsM7" /><figcaption>Not Pictured: Sweet Lobby Water Feature &amp; Modern Art Collection</figcaption></figure><p>Your top goal when you sitting at that table is to stay sitting at that table. Unless catered lunch arrives, then you risk moving from your seat to grab a Fiji water from the cart.</p><p>The best way to stay sitting at that table is by entering into a mutual assured destruction contract known as “alignment.” You want everyone else at the table to agree that the thing you want to do is something they want to do as well. This requires explaining things in terms they can buy into. This reinforces the incentive to travel down known paths. Mutual understanding is so much easier to achieve when there’s a lowest common denominator involved.</p><p>These alignment conversations can be depressing.</p><blockquote>What are our competitors doing?</blockquote><blockquote>If they’re doing it, we should be too, shouldn’t we? If they’re successful and we’re not doing it, we’ll look bad.</blockquote><blockquote>If they’re not doing it, we shouldn’t be doing it. If we fail then we’ll look like idiots compared to them.</blockquote><blockquote>Let’s just do [trend of the week], everyone is talking about that. No one is going to question that.</blockquote><p>Again, the logic makes sense, given the incentives at play. But what’s an intrepid game designer to do?</p><p><strong>The Pattern Pitch</strong></p><p>If they want to maximize their chances of getting funded, they should become very strong at pitching a well-traveled, design-neutered narrative. Or they can bootstrap and hope to raise after they’ve shown some momentum. There aren’t a lot of contrarian investors out there.</p><p>In AAA, the ideal pitch focuses on the ever more immersive world (that can potentially be turned into a content service). Immersion is the guiding light. If a customer is to part with $60-$70 up front, they must be convinced they are purchasing a ticket to a world worth visiting. This world must be fully realized and in high fidelity.</p><p>Pitch wonder. Pitch story and characters and fantasy. And quests — main, side, sub, and, if you’re feeling particularly daring, branching.</p><p>This pitch will be well received so long as it’s credible. Credible means you’ve done it before or at least have a way to imply that you have — like working at a place that’s done it before. The prize for an immersive AAA game with a solid Metacritic score is considerable. To a capital allocator, it is worth sailing into the AAA open-world red ocean so long as the people leading the journey are viewed as bankable talent.</p><p>And, should those creative captains crash upon the rocky shoals, the investors in this misadventure can sadly shrug and explain: we backed the best people and we had to do it — everyone else was doing an open world game. Besides, how could Breath of the Wild with Ninjas miss? It polled great in the focus group! We all booked a loss on this one, shut down the studio and promote the guy in marketing.</p><p>A regrettable tragedy.</p><p>Free-to-play does not fare much better. It’s avoided the treacherous AAA Path of Ever Increasing Immersion, as it takes much too long and does not work well on mobile devices. Instead, we have constructed a great altar to the God of Data, because the High Priests of Capital Allocation demand it. Thankfully, we have identified the perfect prayer, the one that stands the best chance of bringing precious funding: The Overlooked Optimization.</p><p>The narrative is simple. We need not mess about with expensive art books and world building. Instead, we explain that we have seen the TRUTH of the data. Others have mined to unearth gold, yes, but they have missed the mother lode. Invest in us. Let us make [<em>Other Game+1</em>]. We see the optimization they do not, and we have the data to prove it, improve it, and get clicks on Facebook to move it.</p><p>Design innovation, particularly ones that push the game outside of identified genres, muddies the waters and kills the pitch. Such innovations should be left to the barbarous modder and the uncouth indie. Those odd creatures create for sport rather than commerciality, and they aren’t to be trusted. And who can understand them anyways?</p><p>And that’s where design innovation resides, for the most part. Out there in the gap between investable narratives, experimenting and then throwing it into Roblox or Steam to see what sticks. Every so often, something bubbles up and then explodes outward, radically reshaping the industry on a much grander scale. The disruption is taken in stride by the giants among us, because the idea of a Hundred Person Poison Circle Skydiving Shooting Festival may be co-opted, re-branded and aggressively marketed to success. There is no need to innovate, just iterate.</p><p>It’s a very comforting idea to those who would rather not deal with design.</p><p>But they’re locked into the wrong pattern. Assuming the old systems of distribution and marketing developed in the premium era will hold true in the service era. That brand equity and franchise strength will endure in perpetuity.</p><p>Perhaps.</p><p>Perhaps not.</p><p>First movers in service innovation that reach scale find themselves in a much more defensible position than within the premium model. Innovative services can reach their audience rapidly and sustain their relationship with that audience for far longer. Those who attempted to compete with World of Warcraft or Clash of Clans will know this well. With free-to-play, mobile and community tools increasing accessibility worldwide, novel mechanics from innovative developers can find an audience and reach scale before larger publishers — who were built on limited distribution models — can react.</p><p>Known narratives run the risk of pitching for a piece of pie that may not be attainable and is far less attractive than baking the pie and carving out the hefty first slice.</p><p>Battle royales upended the entire shooter market overnight. Think about that. The largest, most invested in genre was completely re-oriented. All due to a set of system design innovations that were well mapped to the modern era rather than tied to the past.</p><p>That’s the power of the Design Lane. It’s the beginning of the disruption, not the end of it. More systems will come and redefine how people interact with known genres. We’re in the infancy of understanding the relationship between community, game design and services. This is not a mature field.</p><p>It’s wide open.</p><p>If only someone were willing to fund it.</p><p>We were fortunate there. In the next part, I’ll go over what we’re up to at Fortis (<a href="http://www.fortisgames.com/">www.fortisgames.com</a>) and the challenges of building a Design Lane company. It’ll be filled with joy and terrors.</p><p>And pith.</p><p>Can’t do anything without that.</p><p><a href="https://medium.com/fortisgames/hello-world-1f73be677303"><strong>First Part</strong></a><strong> | </strong><a href="https://medium.com/fortisgames/the-design-lane-b648d7116737"><strong>Next Part</strong></a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=38df35f2add8" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/fortisgames/the-game-investment-game-38df35f2add8">The Game Investment Game</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/fortisgames">Fortis Games</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Hello World]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/fortisgames/hello-world-1f73be677303?source=rss-7f36b18f8cf2------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/1f73be677303</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Shawn Foust]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 02 Mar 2022 03:51:13 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-10-18T06:32:46.572Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*XO2uwF_3dQGFyrNmnThwpA.png" /></figure><p>Hello Friends,</p><p>It’s been some time since I last attempted to put something out into the wilds of the internet, but a strange thing happened en route to founding another startup and I wanted to share.</p><p>Today, we announced Fortis Games. She’s an odd bird, born of unique circumstances. I’m very proud to play a part.</p><p>We founded Fortis on a simple idea: that game design can be a competitive advantage. It seems obvious, but the market has underinvested in this category relative to the opportunity. Capital tends to flow toward opportunities its allocators understand, and said allocators rarely come from a design background. As a result, investment focuses on shifts in platform, changes in business model and inefficiency arbitrages. It’s unsurprising. The patterns are easier to identify and investments into those categories, particularly when made early in a cycle, have often been successful.</p><p>Already, we see the market looking for the next shift. The NEXT thing is far more important than the evolution of the current thing. Phones MUST give way to headsets or microchips or AI overlords. A window to virtual reality must give way to a fully immersive experience. Because if there is a NEXT thing, then incumbency advantages disappear, and incumbents in the current thing are annoyingly hard to displace. We understand the reasoning, but we believe the ecosystem has misjudged the stage this cycle is in.</p><p>Game services are in their infancy, not their maturity. Incumbency advantages in services are vastly overestimated. Or, to carry on my contorted narrative from before: the current thing is the NEXT thing.</p><p>Some context. When smartphones came out they ushered in the era of game services, but the platform began in a very bounded state.</p><p>Compute power.</p><p>Storage.</p><p>Data.</p><p>Updates.</p><p>Audience.</p><p>Access.</p><p>Distribution.</p><p>Marketing.</p><p>Games catered to these boundaries. Design patterns were set and then ingrained. Data reinforced these patterns. Experimentation became increasingly less common because it was so risky. Costs went up as everyone began to compete on the same axis — the traditional arms race generally associated with market “maturity.”</p><p>But this industry is fast. It changes quickly. These limits have changed. But the designs, by and large, haven’t kept pace. We want to focus on updating them. That’s the biggest opportunity. Not walking away from the current market in search of a new model or a new reality (though I’m personally excited to see what comes of all of that).</p><p>As Steve, Calvin and I embarked upon our Zoom Odyssey in search of the right partner we repeated the same mantra over and over: compete on design. So few others are doing it. Make the whole company about it. Build a company from the ground up with that thought process in the center. Go back to first principles and question all of these other patterns the industry has fallen into.</p><p>Why do teams silo and compete with each other rather than collaborate?</p><p>Let’s change it.</p><p>Why do green lights have to be high stakes pageants rather than fluid conversations?</p><p>Let’s change it.</p><p>Why do interviews need to be superficial exercises in awkward small talk rather than opportunities to share thought processes?</p><p>Let’s change it.</p><p>Off we went in search of a fellow contrarian. A partner willing to support building a different way of doing things.</p><p>In the end, we found that partner. It came from an unexpected place, but perhaps that’s fitting. What mattered was what we shared. Core beliefs: team is what matters, building for the long run is better than focusing on the next quarterly result, and zigging while the market zagged could often pay dividends.</p><p>And so Fortis is here. A global studio (150+ people in 9+ countries) dedicated to advancing the design of game services. To building games where you belong. Places where you can express yourself in meaningful ways and build ties around the interesting differences these choices create. To assembling digital societies that add to our lives.</p><p>The design patterns for this future are out there, waiting for us. Some discovered and in their infancy with many others yet to be unsurfaced. Our job is to find these patterns and cultivate them into games worth playing for years. Our KPIs look to friendships formed, experience differentiation, and community development in addition to the ordinary grist of running a business. Ideas are brought to light within the creative core of the company and then debated openly. The ideological battlefields are fierce and exciting. There’s just so much to think about. So many possibilities to consider. So many societies to build.</p><p>I’m leaving a lot left unsaid. This is just a preamble. A prologue to the dialogue we hope never hits an epilogue.</p><p>I hope it succeeds.</p><p>I guess that’s it.</p><p>…</p><p>Wait. No. Come back.</p><p>One last thing.</p><p>If you’re interested in why people do the things they do, if you study it and think about it, we want to talk to you — regardless of your experience or background. Not in games? Not a problem. Apply. We don’t care where you live. We’re a global, remote first studio.</p><p>At the very least, the interview will be interesting. Go over and apply at <a href="http://www.fortisgames.com./">www.fortisgames.com.</a></p><p><a href="https://medium.com/fortisgames/the-game-investment-game-38df35f2add8"><strong>Next Part</strong></a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=1f73be677303" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/fortisgames/hello-world-1f73be677303">Hello World</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/fortisgames">Fortis Games</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>