<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Eli Sheets on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Eli Sheets on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@sheets?source=rss-81b3b357c625------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Mon, 16 Nov 2026 00:11:23 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@sheets/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Innovating Intellectual Property Reform]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@sheets/innovating-intellectual-property-reform-70d4132905b3?source=rss-81b3b357c625------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/70d4132905b3</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[patents]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[supreme-court]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[intellectual-property]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[patentable-subject-matter]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Eli Sheets]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 02 Feb 2020 06:03:02 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-01-01T03:16:31.206Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*WPpQwqQZt4aXQJhaZwvy5Q@2x.png" /></figure><h4>Or How to Stop Worrying About Congress and Love Blockchain</h4><p>If you weren’t looking closely, you might have missed it. A week ago, tucked unassumingly below articles about the congressional healthcare reform fiasco and big tech’s attempts at influencing foreign markets stood one of the most important Wall Street Journal opinion pieces on the American economy in recent memory. In an article entitled <a href="https://www.wsj.com/articles/americas-innovators-need-clear-patent-laws-11579824646"><em>America’s Innovators Need Clear Patent Laws</em></a>, the Honorable Judge Paul Michel, a retired judge of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit, laid bare the precarious state of U.S. patent law and its negative effect on innovation. But does the legislative solution for reform he suggests comport with reality for the innovators that drive the world’s largest and most dynamic economy?</p><h4>Abstract Law for Abstract Ideas</h4><p>In a shrewd analysis of the current gestalt of patent law in the United States, Michel rightly lays particularly sharp criticism toward the nation’s high court in its recent treatment of cases involving the issue of patent-eligible subject matter. This principle, which is codified in 35 U.S.C. § 101, attempts to block patent protection for the sort of broad principles that define the natural world, such as laws of physics (think <em>e=mc²</em>), naturally occurring material (<em>e.g.</em>, the water molecule), and the physically impossible (like a perpetual motion machine). As the article explains, the Supreme Court has substantially broadened the power of section 101 recently, holding that it precludes patent protection over “abstract ideas” and “natural phenomena.” The pragmatic problem, as Michel highlights, is that the justices “never define those terms and they appear nowhere in patent statutes.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*AxsI9gPr9cjFLMHy445ZrA.png" /><figcaption>Artist’s Rendering of the Supreme Court’s Test for Patentable Subject Matter</figcaption></figure><p>The results of the Court’s test for patentable subject matter have been disastrous for everyone left to make sense of it: judges, attorneys, examiners, and technology ventures seeking to protect the core ideas of their businesses. Michel goes as far as admitting that judges sitting on his former court, the Federal Circuit (the D.C.-based circuit court with exclusive federal jurisdiction over patent matters), have “felt trapped by Supreme Court precedent” in this area. How could you blame innovators for being uncertain about the safety of their most valued assets when an ex-judge from the nation’s premier patent court confidently states that the Supreme Court’s “abstract idea” test is “a judge-made test not found in the Patent Act” in the opinion page of Wall Street Journal? And a judicial solution does not appear imminent — the Supreme Court recently declined review of cases that would have allowed it to correct its dubious position on this important IP law doctrine. As a result, the tech industry is left to navigate a labyrinth of legal doctrine that varies nonlinearly with location, business sector, and time. Good luck.</p><h4>A Legislative Solution?</h4><p>One thing is clear, a fix is needed. So what does Michel offer to put this mess to bed? Congressional intervention.</p><blockquote>U.S. innovators compete in a hypercompetitive international marketplace.... Unfortunately, the current patent system is hamstrung by obtuse and obsolete concepts such as “natural phenomena” and “abstract ideas.” With the Supreme Court passing on the recent <em>Athena Diagnostics</em> case, the ball is in Congress’s court to act before U.S. innovation falls too far behind those nations that have IP systems equipped for the 21st century.</blockquote><p>For those with the luxury of having a low time preference on the issue, a legislative solution would appear ideal — and could be fairly characterized as accelerated <em>vis-à-vis</em> a likely more protracted judicial correction. In fact, as constitutional scholars, law school professors, and even some politicians (depending on their poll numbers) will tell us, a slow evolution of legal norms is a feature of the Constitution, not a bug. And they would be right and justified in saying so. For this reason, advocating for congressional intervention as a preferred systemic solution is not a logically flawed position in the abstract — in fact, in the long term, it may be ultimately serve as the best vehicle for achieving proper doctrinal homeostasis in this area. In other words, Michel’s proposal is theoretically sound.</p><p>But it is just not enough.</p><h4>The Problem with Congressional Intervention Alone</h4><p>Recently, a friend of mine decided to return to college after leaving school a decade ago to start a young family that has since graduated to larger diapers and bigger bills. He felt relieved when he was approved for enough student aid to make a comfortable return to academic life. But when registration day arrived, he received an email from his student loan vendor laying out the distribution schedule for his aid — the first disbursement coming weeks into the semester, well after the reasonable window for textbook and supply purchases. A week later, he would receive a less-than-gentle tuition reminder from the institution. Sure, ultimately the system provided a financial solution for my friend— but did so on its own schedule. In the meantime, he would simply have to dip into his personal funds to effectively front the bank. The solution would get there, but in the meantime, it did nothing but add to his anxiety — and seemingly without any good reason.</p><blockquote>Keep rocking those toddlers while you read old editions of your textbooks you were able to dig for online, sir — help is coming a few weeks after you need it, we promise.</blockquote><p>Most of us have been in a similar situation at some point in our lives — making genuine effort to improve our lot in life, only to suddenly find ourselves at the whim of some distant, powerful third-party who has little concern for the immediacy you feel. And it is particularly relatable for many innovators and tech entrepreneurs who simply want to ensure that they can protect their ideas. Yes, it would feel great to know that Congress is working on a way to clear the fog of patentable subject matter jurisprudence, but their startup needs stability <strong><em>today</em></strong>.</p><p>Time is of the essence in, as Michel himself puts it, the “hypercompetitive international marketplace” of technology innovation. A marketplace that is ruthless and that flies along at mach speed. The innovators of today simply do not have the time to wait on Congress to clear the fog based on some nebulous promise of stability sometime in the future. They need something practical, not theoretical. Personal, not systemic.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*MLDDSbG8JvmCcZps99aNSw.jpeg" /></figure><p>Making matters worse, this practicality problem is not isolated by any means — it is truly pervasive. For example, though much of Michel’s treatment focuses on case law in the biotech and pharma world, he is clear that many companies are “left wondering what, if any, computer-related inventions can be patented.” Given the low barrier-to-entry in the computer and software space, these businesses often see the fastest progression in innovation, resulting in almost universal uncertainty regarding the state of IP protection for their central assets. Oftentimes, venture funding (and frequently the livelihood of the entire business) hinges on the ability to show protection of these assets — a paradigm that simply cannot move in a “wait on Congress to act” framework. As a result, technological innovators large and small, from biotech disruptors to software giants to mousetrap tinkerers, are left in a state of limbo for a period that will likely surpass the lifetime of the business unless protection is obtained in some form. What is more, <a href="https://blueironip.com/what-do-patents-actually-cost/">as of 2017</a>, the average cost of obtaining a patent was in the neighborhood of $60,000US — not an insignificant sum for nearly anyone, particularly for innovators going it alone or for tech ventures still in their infancy.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/632/1*RLPomfY6vTpqBsEHivsFDA.png" /></figure><h4>The Most Recent Attempt at Legislative Reform</h4><p>Something Michel did not mention, but I would argue looms large in the background of any analysis here, is that congressional action was initiated in 2019. In April and May of last year, Senators Thom Tillis (R-NC) and Chris Coons (D-DE) issued a draft outline and a related draft bill for section 101 reform. Their effort, which <a href="https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2019/04/tillis-coons-patent-bill-will-be-disaster-innovation">came under fire</a> from the <a href="https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2019/05/terrible-patent-bill-way">Electronic Frontier Foundation</a> and <a href="https://spectator.org/the-orwellian-attack-on-section-101/">others</a> (for lacking proper clarity certain classes of inventions, among other reasons) proposes significant changes to the relevant law surrounding patentable subject matter. Specifically, the proposed legislation sought to “eliminate, within the eligibility requirement, that any invention or discovery be both ‘new and useful.’” In addition, it set out to “[d]efine, in a closed list, exclusive categories of statutory subject matter which alone should not be eligible for patent protection,” which may include (non-exclusively):</p><ul><li>Fundamental scientific principles;</li><li>Products that exist solely and exclusively in nature;</li><li>Pure mathematical formulas;</li><li>Economic or commercial principles; and/or</li><li>Mental activities.</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/774/1*X8KXOOP6wEl6QKJqF6FcVA.png" /><figcaption>Draft Language for Proposed Tillis-Coons Patent Bill on Section 101 Reform</figcaption></figure><p>However, as of last Friday, when Judge Michel’s piece appeared in the Wall Street Journal, this most recent effort at a congressional solution had seen no substantial movement outside of <a href="https://news.bloomberglaw.com/ip-law/tillis-coons-to-hold-new-huddles-on-patent-eligibility-proposal">some curiously secretive meetings</a> — which appeared more like a closed-door version of the APA rulemaking process than a serious bi-partisan effort at molding underlying curative patent legislation. For innovators without an invitation to these meetings, it was already shaping up to be another dose of D.C. reality: new legal standards crafted and promulgated by incumbent tech giants and lawmakers without their input. And making matters worse for the pragmatic among us was the pace at which the Tillis-Coons bill was developing. Despite the buzz that followed the Senators’ announcements in spring of 2019, as ten months passed without any firm updates regarding its progress, <a href="https://www.iam-media.com/frandseps/even-if-you-forget-about-101-reform-dont-forget-about-dc">some began to wonder</a> if it had any real legs — a feeling that I would be willing to bet played a significant role in the timing of Michel’s article.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*oNvvfOCtRxqUG2tN1Rgicg.png" /><figcaption>Senator Thom Tillis (R-NC), Sponsor of a 2019 Draft Section 101 Reform Bill</figcaption></figure><p>Earlier this week, a few short days after the publication of Judge Michel’s piece, we learned that this skepticism was indeed warranted when Senator Tillis broke his silence on the prognosis of the draft bill <a href="https://ipo.org/index.php/daily_news/daily-news-special-feature-qa-with-senator-thom-tillis/">in an interview with the Intellectual Property Owners Association</a>:</p><blockquote>“Given the reasonable concerns that have been expressed about the draft as well as the practical realities of the difficulty of passing legislation, absent stakeholder consensus <strong><em>I don’t see a path forward for producing a bill</em></strong> — much less steering it to passage — in this Congress.”</blockquote><p>So, despite Judge Michel’s efforts to revive any hope of stakeholder consensus around the latest congressional solution, it appears that another drawn-out attempt at legislative reform is dead, at least for the time being.</p><p>If, however, we were to set aside this week’s news and instead assume that a different reality had taken shape — a common-sense, forthright, and expeditious congressional solution — one has to wonder if the section 101 problem would necessarily be solved in any lasting manner. Changes to laws and their associated rules, though engineered to be the product of a slow and meandering process founded on compromise and antithetical to short-term trends in industry, nevertheless form a historical pendulum. In the context of the historical line of patentable subject matter jurisprudence, the pendulum has a tendency to swing between apexes of permissive and exclusionary. And with state of section 101 law today arguably being situated toward the exclusionary apex and moving back toward the permissive, one might assume that innovators should “anticipate the trend” and lean toward filing patent applications for inventions drawn to subject matter that would be considered unpatentable under section 101 today. But with the periodicity of this pendulum so very difficult to forecast, those same innovators have to wonder if any new judicially or congressionally mandated paradigm is here to stay — regardless of how concrete that paradigm may seem at the time it is instituted.</p><p>Accordingly, as not even a fully ratified congressional solution has the potential to change with the political winds, what may appear concrete temporary relative to the fast-paced technology life cycles at present, it begs the question: For which companies is the traditional patent game still worth the candle?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*t6FkiMyDW2QeI2nDetFD1w.png" /></figure><h4>How About Other Forms of IP Protection?</h4><p>From the day humans first lurched out of the cave, the innovators among us have had a limited set of options when deciding how exactly to protect their ideas from future copying or infringement by third parties. Patents, for example — but also trade secrets and copyrights (trademarks are a horse of a different color, so we will set those aside for purposes of this discussion) have been traditionally available to right-seekers. These traditional forms of IP are quite different, both in their attendant legal requirements and in their relative scope of protection.</p><p>With trade secrets, no right is explicitly granted from the U.S. government — instead, the trade secret holder must make reasonable efforts to keep the idea secret, and in the event that a third party steals, or “misappropriates,” the trade secret, the judiciary will protect your right to recover damages resulting from the third-party malfeasance. The scope of this protection is broad across business sectors, covering ideas used in commerce in basically any field of technology (or outside of what is traditionally considered “technology” — <em>see</em>, <em>e.g.</em>, the Krispy Kreme recipe), though the protection is limited to processes that were actually implemented in commerce.</p><p>Like trade secrets, copyrights do not require government examination to obtain — in fact, an author’s work is protected by copyright from the moment it is “fixed in a tangible medium of expression.” Of course, additional legal rights can be obtained by applying for copyright registration with the U.S. Copyright Office, including an explicit form of recognition from the federal government upon registration (which is closer than a trade secret to the issuance of a U.S. patent, though not quite the same). And like trade secrets, the scope of protection for copyrights is broad across subject matter categories, utilized from those in the fine arts to computer code — though the protection is limited relative to patents in what the right can protect, generally extending only to unapproved exact recreations of the work or its derivatives.</p><p>With these factors at play, the options are limited for utilizing other forms of traditional IP (trade secrets or copyrights, for instance) to protect the cross-section of ideas that would historically serve as strong candidates for patent protection. And given the presently dynamic nature of patent jurisprudence as described by Michel, the sky-high cost of obtaining a patent, and the disparity in time required for patent protection laid against the lightning-fast speed of the modern tech industry, the idea of diving headlong into a protracted and costly journey through the halls of the U.S. Patent Office may appear more risky than forgoing protection efforts entirely.</p><p>But before we throw our collective hands in the air in frustration — what if, rather than relying solely on a constantly changing legal landscape controlled by Washington, innovators could take an active role in protecting their own IP using technology?</p><h4>Toward a Technological Alternative to Governmental IP Reform</h4><p>Let’s first take a moment to zoom out to examine the traditional IP protection landscape. Regardless of the formal instrument of protection an idea takes on, if the inventor, author, or trade secret holder can prove undeniably that they were the first to have the idea, a vehicle exists in the traditional IP infrastructure for forming defensive protection.</p><p>But before we discuss these vehicles in any great detail, let’s define what is meant by “defensive protection” in this context and how it is different than “offensive protection.” The difference is best explained by first asking a fundamental question: What exactly is the advantage to obtaining IP protection? For some, the answer might be “to sell or license them to other companies,” or “to increase the book value of my tech business.” These are correct on a strategic level, of course, but let us dig a bit deeper.</p><p>If we examine the fundamental value of any form of traditional IP, is the ability for the right-holder to kick others out of the market with the backing of the United States judiciary. In the patent context, if a third party is (or would like to be) making or using an infringing product or process in your market, as a patent holder, you have the right to stop that third party from doing so (or to demand that they obtain a license from you before doing so). The same is true of copyright holders and, to some extent, trademark holders (though there are other factors at play in that context). Ultimately, these traditional forms of intellectual property provide “offensive protection” for the right-holder, bestowing the right to exclude others from a market for a period of time. In other words, the traditional form of IP serves as the sword to enforce this offensive protection in the holder’s market by knocking others out.</p><h4>Crafting a New Form of Defensive IP Protection</h4><p>But what if one of these third parties on the receiving end of market exclusion can undeniably prove that they had the idea before our sword-swinging right-holder? And not the “I dated my legal pad right here” or “my secretary date-stamped my lab notebook on the top margin there” kind of undeniable proof — but something much stronger, something unassailable. If we assume that generating that level of certainty is possible, then existing IP laws provide a shield for these third parties to defend themselves if they are truly first in time. For example, in the patent context, section 102 of the Patent Act mandates that to obtain patent protection, an idea claimed in a patent application must be novel, stating:</p><blockquote>A person shall be entitled to a patent unless … the claimed invention was patented, <strong>described in a printed publication</strong>, or in public use, on sale, <strong>or otherwise available to the public</strong> before the effective filing date of the claimed invention….</blockquote><p>Herein lies the shield. By leveraging the novelty requirement, if innovators possessed a tool that could timestamp and make public an idea at the instant it was conceived — and if that timestamp was unalterable, provable, and forever — the innovator could generate, at will, unassailable and unending defensive protection for the idea. And it would be even better if the inventor could do so anonymously and with complete control over the timing of the publication.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*SV_SfLMZgzDoLINWYUxu-w.png" /></figure><p>If such a tool were available, what would that mean for innovators? First of all, innovators would suddenly find themselves equipped with an affordable service for persistent IP defense that instantly boosts the speed of IP protection to meet the pace of idea creation the lighting-fast tech industry — negating the most acute practical problems with all of the government-centric IP reform options treated in Michel’s WSJ opinion piece: expense, uncertainty, and delay. And in terms of foundational IP rights, how would this newly acquired defensive protection compare to the offensive protection afforded to traditional IP right-holders? The answer — rather than providing the sword to exclude all others from using an idea for a limited period of time (only the government can hand out swords), the defensive protection tool would block all others from obtaining such an exclusionary sword (any IP creator has the power to create their own shields).</p><blockquote>Put simply, you cannot exclude others from the market, but no other will ever be able to exclude you.</blockquote><p>This may seem like a small change at first glance. But if you shift your conception of IP protection from a traditional and purely offensive perspective (requiring official governmental recognition in the form of a patent, copyright, etc. to obtain exclusionary market protection) to a new paradigm that is based on instant, irrefutable, and anonymous defensive protection, you begin to realize something powerful: if existing technology could be leveraged to build such a tool, it could return the power of IP reform from its typical custodians on Capitol Hill to where it rightfully belongs — the hands of every single IP creator.</p><p>But enough with the hypotheticals. The technology required for building this tool exists today in what is often referred to generally as “distributed ledger technology” (DLT) — or by its (slightly different but more famous) cousin, “blockchain.”</p><h4>Blockchain as Proof of Creation</h4><p>So what exactly is a blockchain and how in the world can it help innovators protect their stuff? Well, before we get to an answer, a quick aside. As several <a href="https://books.google.com/books?id=IHKhDwAAQBAJ&amp;pg=PT38&amp;lpg=PT38&amp;dq=blockchain+is+%22inherently+political%22&amp;source=bl&amp;ots=YJYME0bZFs&amp;sig=ACfU3U1HNARYJL7HH5xv1jzKXZmmCxNROg&amp;hl=en&amp;sa=X&amp;ved=2ahUKEwjv1L_Ay6XnAhXJV98KHd4BC-kQ6AEwB3oECAoQAQ#v=snippet&amp;q=%22inherently%20political%20dimension%20of%20blockchain%22&amp;f=false">brilliant</a> <a href="https://twitter.com/aantonop/status/1204826967951806469?s=20">commentators</a> (<a href="https://twitter.com/Sheets173/status/1202463821723516928?s=20">and others</a>) have argued, distributed ledger technology can be fairly described (especially in the Bitcoin context) as inherently political — and like every political topic receiving press coverage in the last five years, it has experienced its fair share of fact-based analysis, fake news, and seemingly everything between. As a result, there are almost as many definitions of blockchain as there are people who have heard of it.</p><p>Rest assured, we will stick with the factual stuff for this bit — and to avoid getting tangled in the low-level technological weeds involved in blockchain implementation, we will also keep the treatment of blockchain technology broad and brief. Though it is obviously in anyone’s best interest to develop a broad understanding of as many individual topics inside of the DLT universe as possible, I would strongly encourage those seeking to learn more about provable timestamping (especially with respect to IP protection) to focus on learning more about public, permissionless, proof-of-work implementations of DLT — and Bitcoin in particular. For those who would like to learn more about Bitcoin and related blockchain topics, generally, I would suggest the resources below.</p><ul><li><a href="https://cash.app/bitcoin">My First Bitcoin and the Legend of Satoshi Nakamoto </a>— A colorful introduction to the broad concepts underpinning blockchain — and Bitcoin in particular. <em>Beginner.</em></li><li><a href="https://www.lopp.net/bitcoin-information.html">Jamison Lopp Bitcoin Resource List</a> — Widely regarded as the best collection of Bitcoin-related materials on the web, from another (former) downtown Durham Trust denizen and Bitcoin savant <a href="https://medium.com/u/efbe66f7cec8">Jameson Lopp</a>. <em>Beginner to Expert</em>.</li><li><a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Lx9zgZCMqXE">How Bitcoin Works Under the Hood</a> — A video that provides a thorough explanation of the operation and infrastructure of Bitcoin, the most well-known implementation of blockchain. <em>Intermediate</em>.</li><li><a href="https://bitcoin.org/bitcoin.pdf">Bitcoin Whitepaper </a>— The paper that launched Bitcoin. <em>Expert</em>.</li></ul><p>Aside complete, let’s return to the question at hand: How in the world can this blockchain thing help innovators protect their stuff? For our purposes, we will assume the Bitcoin blockchain as our example blockchain implementation and will use a particularly functional formulation of that Bitcoin blockchain — specifically, as the world’s largest and most believable timestamper¹. Now that we know that Bitcoin can be used to verify time, how do we use that timestamping functionality to protect intellectual property using Bitcoin?</p><p>Well as a first example, let’s look back at the patent defense context we discussed above. If an inventor is able to incontrovertibly prove the time at which he or she conceived of an invention and that it was/is published and available publicly from that time on, any IP obtained by any third party drawn to the inventor’s previously timestamped and publicly available idea can be invalidated. We now see that blockchain can be leveraged to provide this incontrovertible proof of time².</p><p>But this power of applying blockchain to IP defense is not limited to the patent defense use-case. Let’s look at one more example: trade secret defense.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*gn860ZGQudop_3hI0r-8Ng.png" /></figure><h4>Solving the Trade Secret Paradox</h4><p>Trade secret holders sometimes find themselves in trouble when a third party independently and innocently (<em>i.e.</em>, without misappropriation of the trade secret from the existing holder) comes up with the same idea that embodies the trade secret, decides to patent the idea, and later enforces an issued patent on the idea against the original trade secret holder. Of course, trade secret law does not permit the kind of public disclosure defensive protection afforded in the patent law context — after all, that whole “secret” requirement inherently does not mix well with public disclosure.</p><p>So what is the original trade secret holder to do in this situation? On one hand, it does not seem fair to punish those who commit to keeping a proprietary idea as a trade secret, but on the other hand, the third party holds a valid and enforceable patent right to the idea. Luckily, U.S. patent law has created safe-haven for our trade secret holder in the event that these two parties clash over proper IP ownership rights over the idea. Referred to generally as prior use rights, this cutout gives trade secret holders protection from third-party patent infringement suits over the trade secret material — but to take advantage of prior-use rights, the trade secret holder must first produce clear and convincing evidence that the holder used the trade secret in commerce before the filing date of the eventual third-party patent.</p><p>Unfortunately, generating this sort of evidence has proven to be a practical impossibility for trade secret holders because third-party corroboration is almost always required to meet the clear and convincing evidence standard — and, by definition, a trade secret holder risks destroying the trade secret if he or she chooses to voluntarily disclose it to third parties for purposes of corroboration. Historically, this paradox has blocked many trade secret holders from employing a prior use defense when battling subsequent patent infringement allegations.</p><p>The good news for trade secret holders is that this is all about to change — and here’s why. In most blockchain-based software applications, the cryptographic operations that drive blockchain integration are performed by computers controlled by the software provider in the cloud. However, the mere act of uploading files that describe a trade secret to cloud-resident machines controlled by the software provider could risk forfeiture of the underlying trade secret. After all, the uploaded files contain the substance of the trade secret and the software provider is most often a third-party business. But what if, instead of uploading the actual contents of these files to a software provider’s cloud for processing, the trade secret holder utilizes their own computer to perform the required cryptographic operations, sending only the resulting encrypted (and thus, unreadable) unique representation to the trade secret (called a “hash”) to the software provider’s cloud for insertion into, for instance, the Bitcoin blockchain? This would allow the trade secret holder to generate the clear and convincing evidence required to avail themselves of the prior use safe-haven without destroying their trade secret in the process — a result that until now has been considered by many to be virtually impossible.</p><p>In the patent and trade-secret examples above, we have seen how blockchain technology allows IP holders to protect ideas against future legal challenges from two of the most popular forms of IP today. And in even better news, these examples are only the tip of the iceberg; in fact, for every form of traditional IP, there is a corresponding blockchain implementation for defense of the underlying asset. But rather than explaining the specifics of these additional blockchain-based IP defense tools here, I would encourage you to check them out for yourself — because, as you may have suspected, <a href="https://ideablock.io/">they are available for you to use today</a>. More on that below.</p><h4>Congress Tomorrow vs. Technology Today</h4><p>Ultimately, after taking in Judge Michel’s WSJ opinion piece and its related treatment above, it is clear that the Judge and I agree on one important point: something needs to be done about the current state of key aspects of U.S. patent law. It is in identifying the most viable strategy for this reform, however, that our opinions diverge. Michel would clearly like to see a resolution emerge exclusively from government channels, and the legislative branch in particular. Though I agree with Judge Michel that the most promising vehicle for meaningful reform (of the traditional set of government-based, or “systemic,” options) is likely some form of congressional action, I am simply not convinced that such a solution would bring lasting change or stability to an area of law that is absolutely critical to the long-term strength of our nation’s economy. Promises of congressional involvement tomorrow simply do not help innovators left to decode the patent law enigma of today. Additionally, even if a legislative overhaul is eventually enacted at some future point in time, any updates are themselves subject to change at any time, in any new Congress.</p><p>To solve the very real IP problems faced by technological innovators that drive a fast-paced modern economy, I believe these innovators would be smart to avoid pinning their hopes exclusively on Congress swooping in swiftly to the rescue, and instead to identify options that allow them to reclaim control over the future of their ideas and their businesses in the hypercompetitive modern tech marketplace.</p><h4>Ideablock: Empowering the Next Generation of Innovators</h4><p>Eighteen months ago, I stepped away from a decade-old career as an IP professional to build <a href="https://ideablock.com/">Ideablock</a>, a software company that is committed to bringing better IP protection tools to the people and companies who desperately need them. We at Ideablock have spent the last year working hard to bring our vision of a suite of robust, understandable, and affordable defensive IP protection tools to life.</p><p>We are excited to report that work has paid off. We are currently wrapping up development of Ideablock’s initial non-beta release, which we have scheduled for official release by March. We are extremely excited to share it with our existing clients and with our growing user base.</p><p>Of course, until the release of the new non-beta version in a few short weeks, we would love to invite you to begin using our suite of existing tools that can help you begin protecting your innovation today:</p><ul><li>Ideablock Beta, our first web-based application, launched in late 2019</li><li>Ideablock CLI, a command-line version of Ideablock Beta for all of the terminal-dwellers out there.</li><li>Ideablock Commit: a specialized tool for Git users.</li></ul><p>With these existing tools and many others to come, we look forward to empowering our users to take an active role in defending of their ideas after years of legal uncertainty — a quagmire created by the same federal bodies that some (even ex-Judges) trust exclusively with correcting. I won’t hold my breath.</p><p>¹<em>See </em><a href="https://blog.lopp.net/bitcoin-timestamp-security/">Bitcoin Timestamp Security</a> (Lopp, 2019) for a more low-level technical discussion regarding the timestamping functionality of Bitcoin.</p><p>²<a href="https://ideablock.io/proof.png">This screenshot</a> containing information from a Bitcoin blockchain information database (or “blockchain explorer”) <a href="https://blockchair.com/bitcoin/transaction/f703c5ceefbb64e34294a796315a222d7a2ba56fdfd94d6b602bc948a5a2e854">shows</a> how the upload time and contents an idea file (such as a zip file containing information describing <a href="https://beta.ideablock.io/idea/9J">an idea</a>) can be validated using idea file hashes embedded in the Bitcoin blockchain.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=70d4132905b3" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Challenging the Bitcoin Copyrights]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@sheets/challenging-the-bitcoin-copyrights-4c441883bbe5?source=rss-81b3b357c625------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4c441883bbe5</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[bitcoin]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[copyright]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[intellectual-property]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Eli Sheets]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 13 Jun 2019 16:12:59 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-06-13T16:12:59.557Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*d5dk_60gSCdjq4WCmzDalw.png" /></figure><h4>After representing that he is Satoshi Nakamoto, Craig Wright now holds two approved Bitcoin copyright registrations. Does a practical path to challenging their authorship even exist?</h4><p>It would be difficult to name a more divisive figure in any community at the moment than Craig Steven Wright. A denizen of the UK, avid Bitcoin SV supporter, and nChain chief scientist, Wright has claimed on be the individual, or a member of an alleged group of individuals, behind Satoshi Nakamoto — the pseudonym used by the creator of Bitcoin. Wright’s history in the Bitcoin community is rife with controversy — with battle lines being drawn between those who believe his claims and those who consider him anathema. Truly, the only point on which Bitcoin maximalists and BSV acolytes can agree is that there is simply no middle ground in this war.</p><p>For the past few years, in a personal capacity and via his role at nChain, Wright has filed for IP rights over a trove of technology in the Bitcoin and wider blockchain space. Though tallying IP application numbers is notoriously difficult to benchmark at any given time, the chairman of nChain’s strategic advisory board penned an <a href="https://coingeek.com/the-devil-is-in-the-patent-details/">editorial</a> in early March of 2019 claiming that the company had, at that time, over 665 pending patent applications worldwide. And if recent news is any indicator, he doesn’t appear to be slowing down any time soon.</p><p>Late last month, in the latest chapter of the Wright IP saga, the U.S. Copyright Office approved two Bitcoin-related copyright registration applications submitted by Wright:</p><h4>1. Bitcoin: A Peer-to-Peer Electronic Cash System (Text, Reg. No. TXu002136996)</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*weZsXoJDp7zR25UTyJS4bw.png" /><figcaption>Copyright 1: Wright Registration for Bitcoin Whitepaper</figcaption></figure><p>The first copyright covers the <a href="https://bitcoin.org/bitcoin.pdf">Bitcoin Whitepaper</a>, officially titled <em>Bitcoin: A Peer-to-Peer Electronic Cash System</em>. Notably, as with the second copyright below, we see Craig Steven Wright representing to the U.S. Government that he alone is Satoshi Nakamoto.</p><h4>2. Bitcoin (Computer File, Reg. No. TX0008708058)</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*QARoTmUN90Pu0vBvoNWC2A.png" /><figcaption>Copyright 2: Wright Registration for Bitcoin source code</figcaption></figure><p>This second copyright ostensibly covers the original Bitcoin code that was used to create the <a href="https://blockchair.com/bitcoin/block/0">genesis block</a> on January 3, 2009.</p><p>On the day the registrations hit the wire, we witnessed widespread disbelief, confusion, and anger on social media. Cryptotwitter memed. Normies didn’t notice, much less care. In other words, it was a typical weekday. But now, after a few weeks have passed, what does the Bitcoin copyright fiasco mean in the long run, and could the registrations eventually lead to a determination regarding the validity of Wright’s copyright registrations and the related authorship claims? This article will discuss the relevant law and Copyright Office procedures as they relate to Wright’s registrations and will attempt to determine whether the U.S. system of copyright registration and enforcement is even set up to determine whether a name listed as author of a pseudonymous work is the true author.</p><p>Before we get into the meat of the analysis and explore some hypotheticals, let me get a couple of things out of the way about my credentials to be speaking on this matter. First, I understand Bitcoin at a granular level. I am the founder of <a href="https://ideablock.io/">IdeaBlock</a>, a software startup in the legal tech space. Like some other software offerings in the wider blockchain world, we leverage the immutability of the Bitcoin blockchain to prove time. I personally wrote every line of code that defines how our software interfaces with Bitcoin and know the protocol down to the bare metal.</p><p>But I have not always been a developer or entrepreneur by trade. Before becoming a startup founder, I spent over a decade as an IP professional. First, as a patent examiner at the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office, then as a law student, the editor-in-chief of a widely distributed IP law journal, a judicial clerk at the federal trial court and appeals court levels, and lastly as a practicing IP attorney at a large K Street law firm, a large international law firm in the Midwest, and a couple of boutique patent firms. I know IP law much better than I know Bitcoin.</p><p>Also, any hypothetical discussed should be read and interpreted accordingly — as an academic exploration of the effects of a potential real-world scenario to existing law to test the veracity of a suggested idea or theory. By no means are such hypotheticals meant to explicitly or implicitly suggest that individuals take a course of action, such as, for example, filing a pseudonymous registration to materials published by Satoshi Nakamoto years ago to affect some official fact-finding as to the veracity of a previous copyright registration application. Nothing in the present article constitutes legal advice and should not be taken as such.</p><h3>Copyright Law and Bitcoin Authorship: Toward an Answer</h3><p>Let’s start with some basics. First, what <em>is</em> a copyright, exactly? The U.S. Copyright Office <a href="https://www.copyright.gov/help/faq/faq-general.html">defines</a> a copyright as “a form of protection grounded in the U.S. Constitution and granted by law for original works of authorship fixed in a tangible medium of expression.” It should be noted that there is a difference between the underlying copyright itself- which is created when a work is fixed into a tangible medium — and the <em>registration</em> of this underlying copyright — which is necessary to register a work with the U.S. Copyright Office, a prerequisite to bringing an infringement action. As explained by the court in <a href="http://nysbar.com/blogs/EASL/Pastime%20decision.pdf"><em>Pasttime LLC</em> v. <em>Schreiber</em> (2017)</a>:</p><blockquote>Although “copyright” and “registration” are sometimes treated as synonyms in common parlance, it is important to distinguish these two legal concepts. A copyright “exists automatically upon the creation and fixation of an original work of authorship in a tangible medium of expression.” . . . . A registration, in contrast, is granted by the Copyright Office, and the Copyright Act conditions certain statutory benefits — most notably, the right to sue for infringement — on registration. . . . In other words, copyrights exist by virtue of the author’s creation, while copyright registrations exist by grant of the Copyright Office.</blockquote><p>Our inquiry in the present case of the Bitcoin copyrights involves the underlying copyrights as a foundational layer involving proper authorship- but presents itself to us in the context of the U.S. Copyright Office procedures for registering the work. As it turns out, because the Bitcoin Whitepaper and original source code were authored under a pseudonym and (hypothetically) the person or persons behind the pseudonym have yet to be definitively identified (despite past attempts by some), we have a very interesting situation on our hands — and one that exposes a possible flaw in the U.S. copyright apparatus.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/proxy/1*BOhLxXkR93sZg2jVasoZYA.png" /></figure><h4>Copyright Office Procedure: Form Over Fact-Finding</h4><p>The rules and policies of the U.S. Copyright Office (“the Office”) are laid out in <a href="https://www.copyright.gov/comp3/docs/compendium.pdf">The Compendium of U.S. Copyright Practices</a> (“the Compendium”), which includes detailed information regarding almost all aspects of copyright registration procedure in the United States. Contrary to what many might believe regarding its responsibilities within the greater federal government apparatus, unlike the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office, the Copyright Office does not conduct fact-finding to determine the veracity of authorship claims contained in copyright registration applications:</p><blockquote>The author or co-authors listed in the application are presumed to be the sole authors or joint authors of the expression claimed therein. Although the U.S. Copyright Office does not investigate the truth of the claims asserted in the application, it does verify that the asserted authorship facts are consistent with the facts contained in the deposit copy(ies) or elsewhere in the registration materials. <em>Compendium</em> § 503.2 (3d ed., 2017).</blockquote><p>Many are puzzled by this rather noninvasive handling of applications for copyright registration- especially in view of the comparative full-cavity search given to patent applicants by the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office (“USPTO”). But unlike the USPTO, an executive branch agency tucked within the bureaucratic monolith officially known as the U.S. Department of Commerce, the U.S. Copyright Office is not an executive agency. Instead, it is a service unit of the Library of Congress, and as such, is a body of the <em>legislative</em> branch. In that role, it not only records claims to copyright ownership day-to-day, but is charged with high-level policy responsibilities — such as defining the role of United States in furthering democratic principles of property ownership on the international stage and advising Congress regarding the particulars of domestic copyright policy. As such, unlike the USPTO or the federal judiciary, its primary role is not rooted in enforcement or adjudication, but recordation and consultation.</p><p>Unfortunately, the head-scratching does not stop at the agency level. Exacerbating public confusion regarding its role, the Copyright Office not only accepts authorship details presented for <em>named</em> authors without factual inquiry, it also precludes any inquiry into truth of authorship for works by <em>pseudonymous</em> authors — those written by authors using a pen name. Said differently, where an author of a pseudonymous work does not register the work with the Office, anyone claiming to be the true author behind the pseudonym can submit a registration application to that work without any inquiry as to the veracity of the authorship claim.</p><p>If this whole thing seems “off” to you, don’t fret — you are not alone. In fact, this same confusion was so widespread in the wake of Wright’s registrations that the Office took the relatively rare step of issuing <a href="https://www.copyright.gov/press-media-info/press-updates.html">a pair of public responses on the matter</a> to clear the air, even tweeting about the issue from its official account:</p><h3>US Copyright Office on Twitter</h3><p>The Copyright Office has received lots of questions about certain Bitcoin registrations, see our response: https://t.co/C0dBuzec4X</p><p>In its responses, the Office explained some general points regarding official Copyright Office policy on the registration of pseudonymous works, stating:</p><blockquote>As a general rule, when the Copyright Office receives an application for registration, the claimant certifies as to the truth of the statements made in the submitted materials. The Copyright Office does not investigate the truth of any statement made….In a case in which a work is registered under a pseudonym, the Copyright Office does not investigate whether there is a provable connection between the claimant and the pseudonymous author.</blockquote><p>Despite this general policy, however, the Copyright Office apparently “went the extra mile” with respect to the Bitcoin-related registration applications, asking him to simply confirm that he was the author:</p><blockquote>In the case of the two registrations issued to Mr. Wright, during the examination process, the Office took note of the well-known pseudonym “Satoshi Nakamoto,” and asked the applicant to confirm that Craig Steven Wright was the author and claimant of the works being registered. Mr. Wright made that confirmation. This correspondence is part of the public registration record.</blockquote><p>Sarcasm aside, this added confirmation volley will surely fail to settle the matter for those who view Wright’s claims as dubious. Common sense tells us that if an applicant is willing to improperly claim authorship in the original application (hypothetically), would a subsequent request for confirmation of such an authorship claim reveal anything new? And would that answer change in the opposite case, where a proper claimant sought to obtain a copyright registration? Doubtful.</p><p>So taking stock of the situation at hand, we have two copyrights registered to an applicant who claims to have authored both the Bitcoin Whitepaper and the original Bitcoin source code. But at no time was the applicant pressed for any proof of authorship other than doubling down on his own word. But what if someone — say, hypothetically, a group of individuals who can prove that he is not the true author, or anyone at all for that matter — decided to sue Wright for a judicial declaration regarding the proper authorship or filed a competing application for registration of the same exact works? This is where things get interesting.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*8lsfe5gP4hQ0bXjlh0YfuA.png" /></figure><h3>Challenging Authorship of a Pseudonymous Work — Let’s Get Hypothetical</h3><p>Suppose we strain our imaginations here and hypothesize that Mr. Wright is not the true author of the Bitcoin Whitepaper or original source code. I’ll give you a minute to fight through the mental gymnastics required to imagine such a warped alternate reality — but please also imagine that you are the true author of these works ( <em>i.e.</em>, assume, again hypothetically, that Craig Wright lied on his application and fraudulently attested to his authorship of the works). Is our system equipped to establish true authorship absent an initial enforcement action by an improper author or claimant?</p><h4>A Hypothetical Judicial Path</h4><p>As a first academic exercise, we will examine the options afforded a true author when a copyright is registered to another claimant based on improper authorship. In addition to the hypothetical improper authorship claim by Craig Wright, let us further assume that the true group of authors have approached me (a hypothetical me, of course) to advise them regarding how they might leverage the federal courts to correct the improper rights granted to Wright via the improper registrations.</p><p>In such a hypothetical, I would first look for an affirmative civil cause of action that has been recognized by the courts that would allow them to bring such a corrective action. In most cases, absent a particularly strong set of facts, an equitable cause of action seeking declaratory relief (such as if Mr. Wright began widespread and aggressive enforcement campaign) is unlikely to prove fruitful for anyone but the lawyers. If, however, the true author is able to decisively prove authorship against all other existing claims ( <em>e.g</em>., by signing a message using one or more private keys known to belong to Satoshi), it is within the realm of possibility that a court could entertain the suit based on a strong set of facts in the complaint. In most other scenarios, such a cause of action have historically proven impractical (though such cases are rarely filed).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/proxy/1*i7hHwxbf1uEVGzpLBvuNhw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Kawhi Leonard Posterizes The Greek Freak</figcaption></figure><p>Recent caselaw, however, offers some optimism for those who might want to have the authorship question answered directly by the federal courts in a civil action¹. As a first option, there is recent precedent for federal courts entertaining requests for declaratory judgement of authorship. Specifically, <a href="https://www.dropbox.com/s/la96d7jz2uz0drg/ky.pdf?dl=0">one of the remedies requested</a> by the <a href="https://youtu.be/CROx4XvLJTk?t=42">plaintiff</a> in <em>Leonard v. Nike</em> (S.D. Cal. 2019) is a declaratory judgement of sole authorship, and one of the remedies granted in <em>Sprengel v. Mohr </em>(C.D. Cal. 2013) was a declaratory judgment of sole authorship². However, neither the <em>Leonard</em> complaint nor the <em>Mohr </em>opinion identify any authority — mandatory, persuasive, or otherwise — for requesting or granting such a declaration. Indeed, applicable case law is sparse.</p><p>In most other cases, the issue of authorship is examined in the context of an infringement action — namely, in the form of an affirmative defense raised by an accused infringer. In other words, returning to our purely hypothetical scenario, if Wright brought an infringement action against one or more Bitcoin users based on his Bitcoin-based copyright registrations, the allegedly infringing party (infringement defendant) could assert that the copyrights at issue are invalid due to knowingly improper authorship. The U.S. circuit courts, however, have set an increasingly high factual bar for defendants to meet with such an affirmative defense of copyright invalidity due to improper authorship. There is one scenario, however, that would again likely meet such a high bar: a different Satoshi Nakamoto comes forward to sign a message using at least one verifiable private key (assuming that, of course for merely academic reasons in this limited hypothetical scenario where Craig Wright is not in fact Satoshi Nakamoto).</p><p>It appears, therefore, that federal court litigation may offer a couple of options for adjudicating the truth regarding proper attribution for the Bitcoin Whitepaper and source code: (a) someone filing a federal suit requesting the court to issue a declaratory judgment regarding authorship or (b) Craig Wright suing someone for copyright infringement. Neither of these options are likely to see the light of day, let alone result in a definitive answer from a federal court on the matter. That said, the likelihood of success in either case would be significantly higher if you happen to be an individual that possesses one or more private keys known to be in the possession of Satoshi Nakamoto (or you happen to be an attorney that might have been approached by one or more of these individuals and these one or more individuals may be preparing to deploy this information in a judicial forum to set the authorship record straight once and for all — hypothetically).</p><h4>Adverse Claims: A Hypothetical Copyright Office Path</h4><p>Next, let us explore any procedural avenues that may be available via the Copyright Office for a (hypothetically) true author of a previously registered but improperly claimed work. As explained above, the Copyright Office does not as a matter of course delve into the veracity of authorship claims. But at over 1,150 pages in length, the Compendium must speak to the possibility of an applicant (hypothetically) improperly claiming authorship in a registration application, right? Well, yes. The Compendium contemplates such a hypothetical scenario and even outlines a procedure for a third party ( <em>e.g.</em>, the true author or authors) to challenge the validity: the adverse claim.</p><p>An adverse claim occurs in a situation where:</p><ol><li>The Office receives two or more consecutive or simultaneous applications by different applicants to register the exact same work, and each application contains conflicting statements regarding the authorship and/or ownership of the work; or</li><li>One party asserts that another party’s claim to copyright is unauthorized or invalid and submits an application for a new basic registration on behalf of the appropriate party.</li></ol><p>For instance, let us consider the hypothetical situation introduced briefly above, where an attorney is contacted by one or more individuals that are in possession of private keys known to be used by Satoshi, and these one or more individuals indicate that they would like to become clients and set the Bitcoin authorship record straight once and for all (or hypothetically, vis-a-vis Craig Wright). In this situation, the clients could file an adverse claim by filing an application to register the Bitcoin Whitepaper and/or the initial Bitcoin code as a copyright. In addition, per chapter 1800 of the Compendium, our hypothetical clients “should provide a brief statement in the Note to Copyright Office field or in a cover letter indicating that the exact same work has been registered by another party.” Ultimately, an adverse claim is presented in the form of a typical copyright registration application that includes a statement indicating the same work has already been registered by someone else.</p><p>Even if such an adverse claim was filed directly challenging the validity of one or both of Wright’s copyrights, chapter 1800 of the Compendium is clear that the adversarial nature of the claim will not change the role of the Copyright Office when it comes to registering a copyright to the work at issue. Specifically, § 1808 explains:</p><blockquote>In most cases, the Office will issue a separate registration to each party and will create a separate public record for each registration. The Office will not cancel the other registration or the registration number that has been assigned to that registration, it will not change the information set forth in the other registration or the public record for that registration, and it will not crossreference those records with the records for the new registration. <strong>Instead, each registration will coexist with each other in the public record.</strong></blockquote><p>Though the Office is clear that it will simply register multiple applications to the same work, the Compendium states that the Office will conduct a further function in the case of an adverse claim: inform the other party. So, back to our hypothetical, should another individual or group of individuals wish to file an adverse claim against one or both of the copyrights registered to Wright, he will be made aware. But it is clear that the official Office policy is again that it will not dig into the veracity of statements made by the applicant in an adverse claim.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*4A5OsNfFQv3eU3NVY5LviA.png" /></figure><h4>A Blind Spot in the System?</h4><p>Having examined the judicial and Copyright Office options for challenging the Wright registrations, we are left without a straightforward way for challengers to obtain a determination from a governmental entity regarding authorship. Specifically, any potential litigation path to such a determination is unlikely given that:</p><ol><li>Wright will likely not enforce the registered Bitcoin copyrights against another applicant (or anyone at all) because a suit could potentially open him up to authorship challenges, and</li><li>The question of whether a challenging party can even file a suit in federal court for a declaratory judgment to authorship is far from settled, and as a result, the option of initiating litigation against Wright as to authorship would likely be far too risky and expensive for anyone except the most wealthy and driven plaintiffs.</li></ol><p>And as to any path to such an authorship determination within the Copyright Office, as with other instances where fact-finding may be required, the Office punts in the context of receiving an adverse claim to an already-registered copyrights — leaving the competing applicants to duke it out in the appropriate court. But in view of the dead-end prospects of the litigation path outlined above, this path is likewise a non-starter.</p><blockquote>As a result, the present system offers no discernible direct path to recourse for a true pseudonymous author whose work has hypothetically been registered by a non-author.</blockquote><p>This constitutes a glaring systemic weakness that could easily result in situations that violate bedrock principles of American intellectual property law and private property ownership, and even the greater concepts of fairness and equity that undergird American society and tradition as a whole.</p><p>As the Wright case demonstrates, if the system is left unaltered, a non-author could simply claim to be the author of a pseudonymous work in any instance. And then they could simply wait — as long as they do not sue anyone to enforce the copyright, they can avoid a direct challenge to their authorship claim, at least one that has any teeth. They captain the boat in this situation, and if they simply keep it between the buoys, they can collect any residual benefits associated with copyright authorship — social distinction, leverage for product marketing and sales, increased employment potential, a meme shitcoin fork price — in perpetuity, without the threat of proving their authorship claim is genuine. This residual benefit comes at a real cost to the actual author and to the community that supports ideals furthered by such an actual author.</p><p>In the vast majority of copyright registrations, the author of the underlying work is known and goes unchallenged. But the application of a seemingly blanket rule against factual inquiry by the Copyright Office — even in instances where true authorship of a pseudonymous work is unknown and is the subject of clear public concern — looks a lot like the rigid and unapproachable brand of government that our country was founded to prevent. This could be quickly and easily fixed by Congress without requiring any additional public resources of consequence, but I won’t hold my breath.</p><h3>Hypothetical: What Bitcoin Users Can Do</h3><p>The controversy surrounding the Bitcoin copyrights shows the passion of the Bitcoin community and its commitment to the credo “don’t trust, verify” — even when it comes to Satoshi. But as the vast majority of these Bitcoin users are non-authors of Bitcoin source code and the Bitcoin Whitepaper, <a href="https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2019-04-18/self-described-bitcoin-creator-wright-sues-a-podcaster-for-libel">outside of tweeting and risking their financial security</a>, they feel powerless as it applies to the registered Bitcoin copyrights.</p><p>Now, hypothetically, there could be a way for Bitcoin users to highlight their point to the Copyright Office, which could hypothetically force action on their part — though this should not be taken as advice or any call to action whatsoever. Hypothetically, the community of users could each take up their pen and <a href="https://eco.copyright.gov/eService_enu/start.swe?SWECmd=Start&amp;SWEHo=eco.copyright.gov">fill out a copyright application</a> — say, to the Bitcoin Whitepaper, for example. As a copyright application can be <a href="https://www.copyright.gov/fls/fl101.pdf">filed by anyone in the case of a pseudonymous work by simply using the pen name on the underlying work as the applicant’s name</a>, these users could effectively flood the Office with adverse claims to the same Bitcoin material registered my Mr. Wright. Of course, these users would risk a maximum fine of $2,500.00 just like any non-author that attempts to claim they are the author of a work, so this would have to be hypothetically taken into account by any of these Bitcoin users, regardless of the likely minuscule likelihood that they would be prosecuted to collect the fine. In fact, a competing claim to the Bitcoin Whitepaper has already been filed and registered to a Wei Liu of China since its previous registration to Craig Wright:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/proxy/1*nbHYYMoVuG_WofOBVXJvjg.png" /></figure><p>It has been said by some Bitcoin users that “<a href="https://bitcoinfoundation.org/we-are-all-bitcoin/">We are all Bitcoin</a>.” For those users who share this sentiment, this credo could provide justification for such a hypothetical mass-filing. But of course, that is up to the community. Hypothetically.</p><p>[1] The Copyright Act creates a criminal right of action whereby “[a]ny person who knowingly makes a false representation of material fact in the application for copyright registration…or in any statement filed in connection with the application, shall be fined not more than $2,500,” and statements in the application regarding originality and authorship are considered material facts. This right of action, however, requires federal criminal prosecution — as section §506(e) explicitly states that there is no corollary private right of action for false representation or fraud on the Copyright Office during the application process. <em>See </em>17 U.S.C. § 506(e). Theoretically, however, this does not foreclose a slightly different private right of action requesting a declaratory judgment of authorship.</p><p>[2] Complaint at 8, <em>Leonard v. Nike</em> (S.D. Cal. 2019) (No. ’19CV1035BASBGS); <em>Sprengel v. Mohr</em>, 2013 WL 645532 (C.D. Cal. 2013).</p><p><em>Eli Sheets is the founder and CEO of </em><a href="https://ideablock.io/"><em>IdeaBlock</em></a><em> and an IP attorney — he can be reached on Twitter at </em><a href="https://twitter.com/sheets173"><em>@sheets173</em></a><em> or by email at </em><a href="/service/mailto:eli@ideablock.io"><em>eli@ideablock.io</em></a><em>.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4c441883bbe5" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>