<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Shiva Bhaskar on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Shiva Bhaskar on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@shivagbhaskar?source=rss-278afcac6ec5------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Mon, 16 Nov 2026 21:37:32 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@shivagbhaskar/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[How To Bring Men Together (& Get Them To Read Again)]]></title>
            <link>https://shivagbhaskar.medium.com/how-to-bring-men-together-get-them-to-read-again-fd3d2d01c953?source=rss-278afcac6ec5------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/fd3d2d01c953</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[men]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[masculinity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[fiction]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[community-building]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[loneliness]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Shiva Bhaskar]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 20 Sep 2026 16:58:55 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-09-20T16:58:55.257Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*W9c1jJtWX3-hIv6IVqhqqQ.png" /><figcaption>Created with Chat GPT</figcaption></figure><p>In today’s America, there is an intense national dialogue occurring around men. This discussion touches on a range of topics involving men.</p><p>Why are men falling behind women in <a href="https://nces.ed.gov/programs/coe/indicator/cha/college-enrollment-rates-by-gender">college</a> and graduate school attendance rates (including for <a href="https://www.americanbar.org/groups/legal_education/accreditation/statistics/">law school</a> and <a href="https://www.aamc.org/news/us-medical-schools-enroll-record-number-students-2025">medical school</a>)?</p><p>Why are men seemingly <a href="https://aibm.org/research/male-loneliness-and-isolation-what-the-data-shows/">lonelier</a> than ever (aka the “male loneliness epidemic”)?</p><p>Why are younger men <a href="https://aibm.org/commentary/gen-zs-romance-gap-why-nearly-half-of-young-men-arent-dating/">dating</a> and forming relationships less?</p><p>Here’s another one. Why are men <a href="https://www.arts.gov/stories/blog/2025/men-women-split-reading-real-and-persists-amid-historical-rate-declines">reading less</a> than women — particularly when it comes to <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2025/06/25/style/fiction-books-men-reading.html">fiction</a>?</p><p>These are complex questions, much of which goes well beyond the scope of what we’re going to discuss here. Instead, I want to tie together two of these topics — male loneliness and reading levels (of fiction specifically) — and craft a potential solution.</p><p>What I’m proposing requires relatively few resources. It’s something that any man who wants to engage with ideas and other men in a fun, growth-oriented setting could engage in. It can apply across class, geographic location, race / ethnicity, religion and personal interests.</p><p><strong>The Activity Component</strong></p><p>All discussions around gender differences are bound to gloss over some nuances and contain generalizations. With that out of the way, here’s a statement that has been born out by research: Men bond side by side, over activities, vs in face to face, emotionally expressive conversations (as women often do). In his seminal 1982 paper on this subject, researcher Paul Wright <a href="https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/BF00287670">found</a> that male bonding over activities is simply a different approach to relationship building, rather than an indication of an inferior friendship.</p><p>That same year, Mayta Caldwell and Letitia Anne Peplau of UCLA <a href="https://peplau.psych.ucla.edu/wp-content/uploads/sites/141/2017/07/Caldwell-Peplau-82.pdf">published</a> a paper titled “Sex differences In Same-Sex Friendship.” Here, Caldwell and Peplau conducted empirical research on male and female friendships.</p><p>They found that men preferred doing activities together, whether that be playing sports, working on projects, or attending events, as their primary method of friendship interaction. By contrast, women preferred talking, whether that be through sharing feelings or life updates. Caldwell and Peplau’s exploration offer additional support for Wright’s findings.</p><p>Are there plenty of men who connect with each other over deep face to face conversations? Absolutely. I’m one of them — though activities also work very well. Do a fair number women get closer over a round of golf or pickleball? Without a doubt. Yet, I’ve found the broad statements above to often hold true.</p><p>If we want to increase the chances that men spend meaningful time together, we’ll need to implement a group activity to bond over. That’s by far the most effective approach.</p><p><strong>Part 1: Why Read Fiction: The Power Of Novels</strong></p><p>This part is relatively obvious. You need to get a group of guys together to read. What should they read?</p><p>As I suggested earlier, the focus should be on fiction. Why?</p><p>It’s not that non-fiction doesn’t matter. To the contrary, reading about the world around us, whether through history, science, or biographies, expands our minds in the best way possible.</p><p>Yet, fiction is equally vital. Fiction pushes us to see the world with a completely new lens.</p><p>It stretches our imagination, transporting us to places and historical periods beyond ours. It cultivates understanding, or at least awareness, of those who are very different from us. We grow more comfortable with the shades of grey and ambiguities of human existence. The realities of good and evil both become starkly clear to us.</p><p>Let’s get specific. The American software developer in Austin sits down one evening to read, and meets a wealthy, eccentric older bachelor in Tokyo, or a large, boisterous family in Ireland. The Tokyo story is set in the late 1980’s, as Japan continued it’s remarkable postwar economic ascent. The Irish family is living through the tragic Potato Famine of the late 1840’s to early 1850’s.</p><p>The bachelor made his money from illicit trades but gives away most of his wealth to an orphanage. The Irish family is suffering immensely, which is aggravated by the father’s gambling habits. Yet, he is a deeply caring man, striving to support his loved ones under deeply challenging circumstances.</p><p>I should note that these are not storylines of actual books. Rather, I invented them, as works which I and many other men might find interesting.</p><p>Fiction also stretches our imaginations. How could one’s horizons <em>not</em> expand after reading some of Isaac Asimov’s incredible science fiction, or for that matter the incredible work JK Rowling did with Harry Potter? What about the best of George RR Martin, best known for the HBO hit series <em>Game of Thrones</em>?</p><p>Fiction can also appeal powerfully to traditional masculine ideals, which are still deeply meaningful to many men. Tom Wolfe’s <em>A Man In Full</em> powerfully delivers this. It’s portrayals of Charlie Croker, a lately-struggling commercial real estate magnate who escaped his hardscrabble background to rise to riches through sheer force of will, and Conrad Henske, a working-class aficionado of Stoicism, are simply excellent. These two characters deeply appeal to ideals of achievement, transformation, and how men handle the prospect of losing what they worked for, and adjust to the vagaries of life.</p><p>Ernest Hemingway’s <em>For Whom The Bell Tolls</em> is another powerful example. Robert Jordan’s courage under fire, mastery of craft and exposure to danger while working as part of a team, really encapsulates some of the themes and values that have appealed to men through the millennia.</p><p>These novels can stimulate fascinating conversations for men from backgrounds as varied as general contractors and police officers to physicians, tech entrepreneurs and athletes. The ideas they touch upon are deeply present in the lives of so many of us (including yours truly).</p><p>In short, fiction can help men understand people and places beyond themselves and understand themselves better in the process. It can serve as a window to the world, and a mirror into our own lives. That’s powerful.</p><p><strong>Part 2: Choosing A Book A Group Of Men Will Enjoy</strong></p><p>Reading fiction comes with a risk of failure: What if you don’t enjoy what you read? For some folks, this may not matter. Every moment they get to spend reading is a joy.</p><p>I’m not one of those people. While I enjoy fiction tremendously, I also need what I’m reading to genuinely resonate. I think if you’re going to bring together a decent sized group of guys, and hope to maximize participation, then you need to choose books that draw interest from a cross-section of the group.</p><p>First, the founder of the group should suggest a few broad themes or classes of books and gauge the level of interest. A WhatsApp group of members, with a poll, is the easiest way to do this.</p><p>Then, he should choose a few of the best books within this category. An LLM like Gemini or Claude can play a great role here (yes, I’m suggesting you use AI to choose a book to read). Simply prompt it for a few of the best books within that genre, for a male book club, and request a one paragraph summary of each book.</p><p>Forward the summary of each book to the group members via Whatsapp or a similar group chat. Again, have them vote on which book is of interest. Now it’s time for the reading to begin.</p><p><strong>Part 3: The Reading, Group Rules &amp; Group Discussions</strong></p><p>Now it’s time for reading. To make the efforts sustainable yet not overly ambitious, you should aim for the guys to read for 25 minutes per day.</p><p>That is enough time to make meaningful progress on the selected book, without placing overwhelming demands on a busy man’s time. It makes reading fun, rather than feeling like a chore.</p><p>The guys meet once a week. Ideally, the meetings should happen each week in person.</p><p>However, with geography plus schedules, this is probably not realistic, outside of book clubs where men live in close proximity to each other. A reasonable alternative is to meet online each week, and in person once per month.</p><p>As with any effective group, rules around attendance and participation are vital. Each member should be allowed to miss no more than one out of every 6 meetings.</p><p>It’s not enough to just show up. Each member must contribute — and be given space to contribute, in a warm, supportive environment.</p><p>How do we ensure this? The facilitator of the group should encourage each man to speak up at least per group session. Rather than pointing out that any man has not spoken, he could calmly call on the men who speak less often and encourage them to share their thoughts and insights. Or, he might speak individually with a man who talks less and figure out how to get him to participate more.</p><p>To drive group participation, specific themes should be chosen. For example, if the guys are reading <em>For Whom The Bell Tolls, </em>the facilitator might ask the men what they believe motivated Robert Jordan to take the risks he did, on behalf of people he did not know.</p><p>Could they think of examples of men sacrificing on behalf of others more broadly, and how did it shape their own perception of male duty? Effective facilitation starts with a topic to get the discussion going, monitors the interests and energy of the group, and adjusts accordingly.</p><p>The group need not be overly moderated. If the members treat each other with respect, and are engaging with the material and each other, that’s all that matters.</p><p><strong>Part 4: The Activities</strong></p><p>This is where it gets interesting. The guys move from talking to each other, to doing something fun.</p><p>Obviously, this can’t happen every single week. However, it should be at least once every 4 to 6 weeks. By doing so, the men in the group are putting the findings of Wright, Caldwell and Peplau into action, to maximize the fun for all the men involved.</p><p>What sorts of activities might the guys get into? In no order, I thought of a few.</p><p>Board games. Poker. Pickleball. Paddleboarding (one of my favorites). Snorkeling. Basketball — or a game of horse, to keep things slower paced.</p><p>Let’s keep going. How about a cookout / barbeque, where each guy makes something on the spot, and everyone shares in each other’s cooking? ATV riding. Top golf. Amateur car racing. A firing range. A wreck room.</p><p>What about serving others? I believe that an important component of being a full man is showing up for others. How about a beach or road cleanup? Volunteering to feed the less fortunate is another excellent option.</p><p>Each of these activities gives the guys a chance to come together, sometimes in friendly competition, while other times towards a common goal. There are opportunities to learn fun new skills, be terrible at them (they’re dilettantes at it after all), grow and have fun through a common undertaking. In short, the guys come together.</p><p>To get buy-in from the men in the group, the group leader should conduct a poll of which activities interest the group’s members the most. Some discussions in the group chat around the preferences of the members will also help.</p><p>To make the group as effective as possible, a series of ground rules need to be laid out. For example, while friendly competition is always welcome, each man is to exercise rules of good sportsmanship. Varying skill levels in an activity are welcome, and not to be ridiculed.</p><p>If someone has limited familiarity with the rules of a particular game or activity, they’re welcome to seek guidance from the other men in the group, with a designated expert (someone with at least some familiarity) with each activity. Ultimately, regardless of how good or bad someone is at any activity (and most of the guys will not be very good), the goal is to have fun, look silly, and come together.</p><p><strong>The Ripple Effect of Community: How These Groups Can Improve Lives &amp; Society</strong></p><p>Let’s think about how this group builds over the months. At first, the guys are sharing their thoughts on a book each week and getting to know each other better. There’s probably a bit of discomfort and hesitation. Is what I’m saying stupid? Is there a point to this group?</p><p>This might continue even after the first or second in-person activity. Some men will drop out of the group even before that activity occurs, while others will take their place.</p><p>As the months go by, assuming good leadership (which can be taught), a core group will continue to show up. As time goes by, that group of men it will get closer to each other, and share more about their lives. They might attend other activities together, outside of the group. New bonds will form, and circles will expand — for the guys who are willing to put in some effort.</p><p>In time, perhaps these guys can turn to each other when something in life comes up. A career setback. A romantic relationship running into setbacks. Challenges with the health of an aging parent. For that matter, one’s own health issues.</p><p>The presence of this community makes each man in the group stronger. It can help him show up in a better way for those in his life. He can feel more confident, knowing that there’s a team of other guys who have his back.</p><p>The benefits of friendship for men are well documented. One of the most comprehensive studies on aging was conducted by Harvard researchers. They began <a href="https://news.harvard.edu/gazette/story/2017/04/over-nearly-80-years-harvard-study-has-been-showing-how-to-live-a-healthy-and-happy-life/">tracking</a> men in the 1930’s, throughout their lives, and found that the single best predictor of health and longevity at age 80 was not any standard health metric we’d think of (like cholesterol). Nor was it income.</p><p>Rather, it was the quality of their close relationships at age 50. Friendship is an important part of that.</p><p>A 2021 study from the American Enterprise Institute <a href="https://www.americansurveycenter.org/commentary/american-men-suffer-a-friendship-recession/">found</a> that men are suffering from a “friendship recession” — and that men are better off with close friendships. One recommendation of the study was that men have more frequent contact with their friends and spend time together. The sort of group I’ve discussed makes that possible.</p><p><strong>A Note About Whom This Won’t Work For</strong></p><p>As with most solutions, there are limitations. There are guys for whom this group is simply not going to happen.</p><p>For one, men who not only don’t enjoy reading fiction, but aren’t willing to try, probably won’t get much benefit out of this group. The social aspects might help them — but the conversations which come from engage with the literature, and the growth it can facilitate, is a vital part of this endeavor.</p><p>Guys who aren’t willing to get at least a little uncomfortable, and engage with men they don’t know, both virtually and eventually in person, will also face challenges. Again, it’s not about not being comfortable. Rather, it’s about pushing through the discomfort, to get to a better place.</p><p>As the rapper Scarface said in his famous 1997 song “Smile” (featuring Tupac Shakur): “I often wish that I could save everyone, but I’m a dreamer.” As I get older, I relate powerfully to that sentiment. There are some guys who would benefit from this group, and will never have the privilege of finding that out. So it goes. In the meantime, plenty of other men will benefit.</p><p><strong>The Final Word</strong></p><p>For men, friendship is a critical aspect of a life well lived. Yet, forming and sustaining friendships can be challenging, particularly as we get older.</p><p>Fiction also has the potential to play an incredibly positive role in our lives, by helping us imagine, relate, and expand our thinking. When we bring fiction, friendship, and the male desire to do things together, we’ve got something special.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=fd3d2d01c953" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[We Don’t Need More Housing Construction. Here’s Why]]></title>
            <link>https://shivagbhaskar.medium.com/we-dont-need-more-housing-construction-here-s-why-d2252b9092f1?source=rss-278afcac6ec5------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d2252b9092f1</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[housing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[economics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[immigration]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Shiva Bhaskar]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 19 Jul 2026 23:39:12 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-08-17T16:30:26.141Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*bHiwrvMy_aIRnu52.jpg" /><figcaption>Photo Credit: Axios</figcaption></figure><p><strong>The Housing Shortage That Won’t Last</strong></p><p>Living in Los Angeles, you hear this everywhere. We are facing a housing shortage. We need to build more places for people to live.</p><p>Housing construction has not kept up with demand. Something must be done.</p><p>As per the Regional Housing Needs Assessment (RHNA) and the City of Los Angeles Housing Element, Los Angeles needs to <a href="https://planning.lacity.gov/odocument/6e79ba73-689a-4f6f-95e4-057dd85b5b57/What_to_Know_about__RHNA_Site_Selection_and_Rezoning.pdf">build</a> over 456K units from 2021 to 2029. Lest you think that the RHNA or Housing Element is a random study or organization, these are assessments required under local and state law, to make sure cities around California are meeting state-designated housing development goals.</p><p>Los Angeles isn’t the only place that’s purportedly facing a lack of homes. Nationally, we keep hearing about a <a href="https://www.realtor.com/research/us-housing-supply-gap-2026/">deficit</a> of at least 4 million housing units / homes.</p><p>Here’s the only problem with this narrative: It is not actually true. At least, in the long run, it won’t be.</p><p>Many housing observers argue that we need to not only build more apartments, but also develop vast numbers of single-family residences. Single-family home construction dipped dramatically after the 2008 recession and didn’t begin to pick up until many years later.</p><p>Before and during the COVID-19 pandemic, we saw a dramatic rise in rents, particularly in major metropolitan centers like <a href="https://www.dgimlaw.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/02/Commercial-Observer-2.28.22.pdf">Miami</a>, <a href="https://www.multihousingnews.com/2021-rent-growth/">Tampa</a>, <a href="https://azhousingforall.com/rate-of-rising-rent-prices-in-phoenix-could-suggest-consumer-changes/02/01/2022/">Phoenix</a> and <a href="https://liedcenter.unlv.edu/wp-content/uploads/2022/03/Apartment-Market-Report_2021Q4.pdf">Las Vegas</a>. As people migrated to these areas from large coastal markets, rents spiked — while capital flowed into Sunbelt apartment development projects.</p><p>Data from <a href="https://www.realpage.com/analytics/2023-by-the-numbers/">RealPage</a> and <a href="https://www.fanniemae.com/media/46851/display">Fannie Mae</a> found that Tampa, Phoenix, Austin and Charlotte all saw multifamily rental supply increase by double-digit percentages between 2019 to 2023. Austin especially stands out, with rental supply increasing by more than 20%.</p><p>This flood of new apartments caused rents to drop <a href="https://mediaroom.realtor.com/2026-03-17-Realtor-com-R-Rent-Report-U-S-Median-Rents-Hit-Four-Year-Low-as-Market-Records-30th-Consecutive-Month-of-Decline">precipitously</a> in many of the cities which experienced large construction booms. Rents in Austin fell by over 18% from the peak. Miami, Nashville, Phoenix and Las Vegas all saw double-digit percentage declines from 2022 to 2026. What once might have seemed like a magical idea for developers has instead turned (financially) tragic.</p><p>Back to Los Angeles. Despite claims of a housing shortage (both in the city of Los Angeles and the region as a whole), in April 2026, rents in LA County <a href="https://www.dailynews.com/2026/04/29/los-angeles-rents-fall-to-a-four-year-low-and-remain-unaffordable/">fell</a> to their lowest level in four years.</p><p>Santa Monica, which normally is seen as a sought-after coastal city, and thus insulated from downward pressure on rents, saw rents <a href="https://therealdeal.com/la/2026/04/13/apartment-rents-fall-8-1-in-santa-monica-most-in-los-angeles/">drop</a> by over 8%, as compared to one year earlier. Yet, Santa Monica has an influx of planned new rental supply, including a proposed <a href="https://layimby.com/2026/01/large-retail-residential-infill-planned-at-2716-ocean-park-boulevard-in-santa-monica.html">456-unit</a> mixed use project, and a <a href="https://layimby.com/2026/04/eight-story-mixed-use-development-proposed-at-1655-26th-street-in-santa-monica.html">planned</a> 401-unit residential development nearby.</p><p>The situation isn’t very different in most LA County neighborhoods. An influx of new apartment supply arrived in 2024, with more on the way in 2026 and 2027.</p><p>Where does all of this leave us — both in Los Angeles and nationally? We’re (supposedly) facing a housing shortage, at a time when rents are (definitely) dropping. This doesn’t mean that housing is per se affordable relative to incomes — though it is more so than just a few years ago.</p><p>Just as importantly, where are things headed in the future? After all, real estate isn’t acquired or constructed solely based on current trends. Rather, what will happen tomorrow is an important consideration for any real estate buyer.</p><p>Something that isn’t being widely discussed in the real estate demand picture: How do long-term birth rates, both in the United States and abroad, impact the demand for housing? Additionally, how will immigration from abroad color the demand for housing — especially when the nations where people are immigrating from are facing considerably reduced birth rates?</p><p>I believe these trends make for vastly reduced demand for housing. This means that further housing construction, on balance, is an economically unproductive activity.</p><p><strong>Fewer Babies Are Being Born In The United States, While Our Adult Population Is Aging Rapidly</strong></p><p>2008. What do you remember about that year, in terms of national and global events?</p><p>For many Americans who were adults at the time (or close to it), two things come to mind. One is the historic election of Barack Obama as the nation’s first Black president. Another is the 2008 financial crisis, which led to a crash in residential housing prices, as well as a painful global recession.</p><p>For a long time, I saw those as the two defining events of the year. I’d like to add a third, little-noticed (at the time) occurrence. When it comes to population growth in the United States, it was the year when everything changed — quite possibly forever.</p><p>In <a href="https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/nvsr/nvsr59/nvsr59_01.pdf">2008</a>, the number of births dropped slightly from <a href="https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/nvsr/nvsr58/nvsr58_24.pdf">2007</a>, as did the overall fertility rate. The shift wasn’t massive.</p><p>In 2007, just over 4.3 million babies were born in the United States. In 2008, that number fell to slightly under 4.25 million. The General Fertility Rate (we’ll call it GFR), which measures the number of births per 1,000 women aged between 15 to 44, fell from 69.3 to 68.1.</p><p>This wasn’t the first time the number of births, as well as birth rates, had come down. In the 1930’s, they <a href="https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11893318/">dipped</a> due to the Great Depression. In the early 1970’s, after the post-World War II baby boom, birth and birth rates once again <a href="https://stacks.cdc.gov/view/cdc/110389/cdc_110389_DS1.pdf">declined</a>.</p><p>Yet, from 1998 to 2007, birth rates, as well as the number of live births, steadily <a href="https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/nvsr/nvsr58/nvsr58_24.pdf">rose</a> (minus a brief drop in 2001 and 2002). At the time, the drop from 2007 to 2008 likely was a small blip on the population radar, with little attention paid to it.</p><p>Here’s the difference: Minus a small increase in <a href="https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/nvsr/nvsr64/nvsr64_12.pdf">2014</a> and again <a href="https://stacks.cdc.gov/view/cdc/122047/cdc_122047_DS1.pdf">2021</a>, the total number of live births, along with the birth rate for women aged 15 to 44, both consistently ticked downwards.</p><p>In <a href="https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/vsrr/vsrr043.pdf">2025</a>, there were 3.61 million live births, and a GFR or 53.1. That’s a 16.5% drop in the number of live births, along with a massive 23.4% drop in GFR.</p><p>Those small yearly declines compounded into something massive. The only reason the number of live births didn’t drop more is the large population of Millennial women. Despite the lower number of births per 1,000 women, the sheer size of this cohort meant that the total number of live births dropped — but by just over 16%, rather than north of 23%.</p><p>While fewer babies are being born, the portion of the population which has reached or passed retirement age (65 or over) is steadily rising. In 2007, <a href="https://www.census.gov/content/dam/Census/library/publications/2009/demo/p20-560.pdf">just under 13%</a> of the population fell into this category. By 2026, that portion <a href="https://www.census.gov/content/dam/Census/library/publications/2020/demo/p25-1144.pdf">spiked</a> by nearly 50%, to between 18% to 19% of the nation’s total headcount. The absolute number of senior citizens has also risen sharply, from just under 38 million people in 2007, to between 64 to 65 million as of 2026.</p><p>By <a href="https://www.cbo.gov/publication/61994#:~:text=Starting%20in%202030%2C%20declining%20fertility,slows%20to%20zero%20in%202056.">2030</a>, more than 1 in 5 Americans (around 73 million people) are projected to be over this age. That is the same year when deaths are expected to <a href="https://www.cbo.gov/publication/61994">surpass</a> births. This means, in the absence of immigration, the population will start decreasing.</p><p>By <a href="https://www.census.gov/newsroom/press-releases/2018/cb18-41-population-projections.html">2034</a>, the swelling ranks of the elderly will surpass that of individuals under the age of 18. That’s a first in American history.</p><p>This was first projected to happen in 2035. Yet, declining birth rates have raised questions about whether the timeline will once again be moved up.</p><p>This shift will create massive ripples, which will be felt in every part of our society. Any business which depends on younger consumers for growth will face battering headwinds.</p><p>For multifamily real estate, here is one simple, undeniable consequence: Setting aside potential immigration, the absolute number of people in prime renter-age demographics, outside of immigration, is steadily ticking downwards. Simply put, we’ll have future American-born renters in the future, then we do today.</p><p><strong>Immigration Into The United States Is Rapidly Declining</strong></p><p>Immigration is a fraught social and political conversation. At the outset, I should mention that I am not taking a political position on what an appropriate immigration rate is.</p><p>How many people should (or should not) immigrate to the United States, is a different discussion than the one we’re having. My goal is instead to share empirical evidence, to understand where immigration is headed, and how that impacts demand for rental units.</p><p>Over the past decade, Census data demonstrates that the vast majority of US population growth was <a href="https://www.census.gov/newsroom/press-releases/2026/population-growth-slows.html">driven</a> by immigration. Between 60% to 70% of the rise in the nation’s total population was attributable to people moving here from other nations.</p><p>Immigration wasn’t always such a large driver of population growth. If we look at the 30 years from 1996 to 2026, we <a href="https://www.cbo.gov/publication/61879">see</a> that immigration was crucial, but not decisive, in shaping population growth.</p><p>Data from the Congressional Budget Office (CBO) shows that while 40% to 45% of population growth was directly attributable to immigration, the majority was due to birth rates within the nation. Looking back to the past 50 years, we see that immigrants plus their children contributed to a <a href="https://www.pewresearch.org/wp-content/uploads/sites/5/2015/09/2015-09-28_modern-immigration-wave_REPORT.pdf">small majority</a> of total population growth.</p><p>The trend is increasingly clear. The United States’ population has been increasing in large part due to immigrants, and their American-born children. As in-country birth rates have entered a period of long-term decline, people coming from outside the nation have come to comprise a vastly larger share of any current or future population increase.</p><p>Where is migration headed today? I use the word migration because this term counts both authorized and unauthorized entrants to the United States. In 2024, <a href="https://www.census.gov/newsroom/blogs/random-samplings/2026/01/historic-decline-in-net-international-migration.html#:~:text=The%20new%20Vintage%202025%20estimates,trends%20continue%20(Figure%201).">2.7 million </a>people entered the nation. In 2025, that number fell to around 1.3 million.</p><p>For 2026, Census data suggests net migration of just 321,000. The Brookings Institution projects even lower numbers, with immigration of as <a href="https://www.brookings.edu/articles/macroeconomic-implications-of-immigration-flows-in-2025-and-2026-january-2026-update/#:~:text=Our%20results%20suggest%20that%20net,constrained%20because%20of%20the%20pandemic.">little</a> as 185,000 people, to a net decline of 925,000.</p><p>You read that correctly. Brookings thinks there could be a net <em>outflow</em> of immigrants. This hasn’t happened since the early 1930’s.</p><p>Much of the drop in immigration is due to more aggressive immigration enforcement, and a tightening on immigration inflows, since the Trump administration took office in 2025. The “catch and release” model has shifted to one of aggressive <a href="https://www.dhs.gov/news/2026/05/15/trump-administration-delivers-full-year-zero-releases-border">enforcement</a>, with apprehensions at the border down by 95% from a few years earlier. A $70 billion spending package for Immigration &amp; Customs Enforcement (ICE) and Customers &amp; Border Protection (CBP) has further bolstered enforcement efforts.</p><p>Legal immigration is also facing headwinds. The H1-B program, which brings technology workers to the United States, is being <a href="https://manifestlaw.com/blog/h1b-employers-guide-2026/">shifted</a> towards higher-paid jobs. This will reduce the number of entry level, lower-wage H1-B employees (which comprises a majority of those in the program). Enforcement around hiring and standards in the H1-B program has increased considerably. A <a href="https://roy.house.gov/sites/evo-subsites/roy-evo.house.gov/files/evo-media-document/rep-roy-s-american-white-collar-worker-jobs-act.pdf">bill</a> in the House, the American White-Collar Workers Jobs Act, would further restrict the program.</p><p>All of this has led to a freeze in people coming into the United States. Could that reverse in the future?</p><p>Perhaps. If there’s one thing we know about American politics, it’s that few things are permanent.</p><p>Realignments are a fact of the system. Policy shifts occur. Maybe the American public collectively decides we need more immigration, and the legislative and executive branches move accordingly.</p><p>However, there’s a big problem with this approach: Every one of the top 5 nations which people immigrate to the United States from is facing declining birthrates. More on that below.</p><p><strong>Fewer People Are Being Born in Nations Which Traditionally Drove Immigration To The United States</strong></p><p>Research from <a href="https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2024/07/22/how-the-origins-of-americas-immigrants-have-changed-since-1850/">Pew Research Center</a> and the <a href="https://www.migrationpolicy.org/article/frequently-requested-statistics-immigrants-and-immigration-united-states">Migration Policy Institute</a> found that from 1980 to 2020, the top 5 sources of immigration to the United States, in terms of the absolute number of people, were Mexico, India, China, the Philippines and El Salvador. Immigrants from these nations, and their children, now make up a substantial share of the nation’s population.</p><p>The chart below describes the birth rates for each of these 5 nations over time, as far as crude birth rates (live births per 1,000 people). The raw data can be found at the links for <a href="https://www.macrotrends.net/global-metrics/countries/mex/mexico/birth-rate">Mexico</a>, <a href="https://fred.stlouisfed.org/data/SPDYNCBRTININD">India</a>, <a href="https://www.macrotrends.net/global-metrics/countries/chn/china/birth-rate">China</a>, the <a href="https://www.macrotrends.net/global-metrics/countries/phl/philippines/birth-rate">Philippines</a> and <a href="https://www.macrotrends.net/global-metrics/countries/slv/el-salvador/birth-rate">El Salvador</a> as well as <a href="https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SP.DYN.CBRT.IN">here</a>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/522/1*9RT9h1Gg7ednBfyAznfktg.jpeg" /></figure><p>What do we notice? In each of these nations, birth rates cratered between 1980 to 2020, with every single country showing a drop in birth rates for each 10-year interval in between.</p><p>The chart below shows the percentage decrease in live births for each nation, between 1980 to 2020. As we see, the number of babies born has cratered everywhere, most dramatically in India.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/488/1*YHtKUzXl7IjE0hW7ekQTGg.jpeg" /></figure><p>Regardless of how open to immigration the United States is, there’s a more fundamental issue. A massive drop in the absolute number of babies born means there are fewer potential immigrants from each nation. Additionally, with weaker population growth, many of the nations above are likely to push even harder (and offer more incentives) for their citizens to stay at home. People don’t leave home unless their alternatives are meaningfully better.</p><p>It’s not just the top 5 sources of immigration which are starring down the barrel of crashing birth rates. Let’s review the 1980 to 2020 birth rate trends for the #6 to #10 nations sending immigrants to the United States, and the total drop:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/633/1*bV5nFChMNTjRnINxXHP9Jg.jpeg" /></figure><p>Birth rates are falling in most nations that send decent numbers of immigrants to the United States. Simply put, that means fewer immigrants in the future — and thus, less aggregate demand for housing.</p><p><strong>Emigration Of US Citizens Has Accelerated</strong></p><p>A lack of immigration isn’t the only issue. The number of Americans leaving the United States through emigration has hit multi-decade <a href="https://www.morningbrew.com/stories/2026/02/26/americans-are-ditching-america-in-droves">highs</a>. The American population of Portugal has grown more than fivefold since 2020, while immigration to Ireland more than doubled. Nations in the European Union, as well as Mexico, are seeing <a href="https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/us-politics/americans-leaving-citizenship-emigration-trump-b2975395.html">record levels</a> of arrivals from the United States.</p><p>Around 5.5 million Americans live <a href="https://www.relocatemagazine.com/new-research-tracks-the-largest-us-emigration-shift-in-decades-gcs-0526#:~:text=Based%20on%20analysis%20of%20Department,estimated%20180%2C000%20U.S.%20citizens%20emigrated.">abroad</a>, though a good portion of those are doing so temporarily. Of course, people who are not living in the United States for extended periods of time are not renting housing</p><p>The United States does not formally track how many Americans moved abroad, whether temporary and permanent, and where they relocated to. These statistics are an important unknown.</p><p>What’s driving these elevated levels of emigration? Differences in the <a href="https://relocatehandbook.com/tax-finance/true-cost-of-moving-us-portugal-spain-2026">cost of living</a>, as well as political division and attractive <a href="https://remoteworkeurope.eu/news/2026/dnv-index-2026-spain-tops-rankings/">visa options</a> abroad, have all increased the desire of some Americans to relocate to other nations. Around 40% of women aged 15 to 44 expressed a <a href="https://www.relocatemagazine.com/new-research-tracks-the-largest-us-emigration-shift-in-decades-gcs-0526#:~:text=Gallup&#39;s%20longitudinal%20tracking%20shows%20the,up%20from%2010%25%20in%202014.">.</a> to relocate abroad — as compared to just 10% in 2014.</p><p>To be clear, the outflow of Americans, as a share of total population of the nation, is relatively small. We’re not talking about a mass exodus. Nor will the vast majority of those who express interest in leaving follow through on their stated preference.</p><p>Yet, this trend of increased emigration is worth closely watching. It will have a long-term impact on the total size of the US population — and thus the demand for housing.</p><p><strong>A Full Picture of Where We Are</strong></p><p>Let’s recap where we are. For the past 18 years, setting aside a few yearly blips, birth rates in the United States have faced a long-term secular decline. At the same time, a small but fast-growing number of Americans are relocating abroad.</p><p>All of this is unfolding while immigration has been essentially frozen, going on two years in a row. There’s no indication that the flow of people to the United States will become more robust anytime soon.</p><p>The nations from which individuals and families traditionally immigrated to the United States are producing fewer people of the typical immigrant age, to send to our country. No policy reforms, regardless of how well-intentioned they are, can attract an immigrant who was never born.</p><p>Fewer people eventually lead to a glut of rental housing. This isn’t hard to figure out. Just because there’s a shortage of housing today, does not mean that continues. In fact, it decidedly will not.</p><p><strong>In The Long Run, Further Housing Construction Is Economically Unproductive</strong></p><p>Housing development is synonymous with a vigorous, youthful society — one which is growing at a strong good clip. Spoiler alert: That isn’t the United States anymore. Nor is it most other developed nations — or many developing ones.</p><p>The data we’ve reviewed above isn’t a snapshot of a brief period. Simply put, it’s our reality. Even if housing costs are astronomical in some major cities (New York City being the most obvious example), this isn’t a trend which will continue long-run across the nation. Adding to housing supply makes sense in some locations, for a short period of time. It is not a long-term trend.</p><p>I don’t believe in central planning. Within the bounds of the law, economic actors (such as real estate developers, and those who invest with them) should allocate their money as they see fit. If the collective thesis of housing developers and their investors is that more housing is needed, let them build it. Who am I to tell someone else not to waste their money and time?</p><p><strong>The False Housing Shortage &amp; Government Policy</strong></p><p>Where this dynamic becomes broadly objectionable is when public dollars are involved. That takes two forms.</p><p>One is offering tax credits to developers, for unnecessary residential development, whether earmarked as “affordable” or otherwise. Tax policy is one of the most powerful levers governments can pull to achieve it’s goals. We should avoid allocating such funds towards wasteful endeavors i.e. trying to solve a problem which in fact isn’t a long-term problem.</p><p>The second approach is public-private partnerships, and other ventures where public dollars are allocated towards residential housing construction. This is even more objectionable. Unlike tax credits, government is actively allocating money towards something patently unnecessary. That needs to end.</p><p><strong>Misallocation Of Talent</strong></p><p>One of the hallmarks of a socially and economically free society is that people can choose their occupations and pursue their livelihood in a manner that resonates with them. Telling people where they must work, and what they are required to do for work, is not the way.</p><p>With that caveat, people should be clear about the long-term economic potential of the work they’re taking on, as well as it’s social utility.</p><p>How do we make this clear? By talking about it publicly. Let’s discuss how different occupations fare in the marketplace, in terms of long-term supply and demand.</p><p>There’s nothing wrong with discussing the potential obsolescence of an occupation, or it’s shrinking value to society. Why would we want people to spend their time on something that might not lead to maximal fulfillment and contribution?</p><p><strong>The Final Word</strong></p><p>Is it a lie to say that at a national level, there’s a lack of affordable housing in the United States? I don’t think so. In many American cities, that is a reality (today).</p><p>At the same time, this won’t be the case for much longer. Therefore, pretending as if today’s housing shortage is a permanent reality is simply disingenuous. Allocating resources as if it is both wasteful and foolish.</p><p>Let’s address real problems. Spending on a housing shortage which population and immigration trends will organically solve is fundamentally unnecessary.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d2252b9092f1" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Selecting United States Attorneys: A Reimagination Of The Process]]></title>
            <link>https://shivagbhaskar.medium.com/selecting-united-states-attorneys-a-reimagination-of-the-process-6ac3fbb09e23?source=rss-278afcac6ec5------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6ac3fbb09e23</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[law]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[government]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Shiva Bhaskar]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 26 Apr 2026 00:29:50 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-04-26T00:33:52.722Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/720/1*O70kns0aHrtUSxVqVBXgTA.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>This is the second in a two-part series about the need to reform the selection process for top federal legal officials in the United States. In the </em><a href="https://medium.com/@shivagbhaskar/why-we-must-reform-the-way-we-select-the-attorney-general-4642735b8171"><em>first part</em></a><em>, I wrote about how we should reimagine the process of choosing the Attorney General. In this piece, I argue for reconsidering how we select United States Attorneys for the various federal districts across the nation. It should be noted that I served as an extern (law student semester internship) with the United States Attorneys Office for the Northern District of California, in San Francisco. None of the events or issues discussed here directly pertain to or were inspired by my time there.</em></p><p><strong>United States Attorneys: How They’re Chosen Today</strong></p><p>United States Attorneys, or USA’s as they’re known in many legal circles, are some of the most important individuals in the federal legal apparatus. While at first glance, each USA might simply appear to be a cog in the machine, they’re quite powerful and influential, both within their districts, and sometimes on the national stage.</p><p>There are <a href="https://www.uscourts.gov/about-federal-courts/court-role-and-structure/about-us-district-courts">94 federal judicial districts</a>, each of which is led by a USA. The USA is selected by the President and approved by the Senate. Traditionally, presidents have consulted with the 2 senators from the state where a given judicial district is located.</p><p>If both senators are from the same party as the president, then the nomination process is quite straightforward. The president will consult with both senators and choose a nominee.</p><p>In some instances, the president (really, leaders within the Department of Justice) might have someone in mind. They’ll ask the senators how they feel about this individual and go from there.</p><p>The Senate has a longstanding “<a href="https://www.congress.gov/crs-product/R44975">blue slip</a>” tradition, whereby each senator from a given state must approve of the nominee. If either senator is unwilling to approve the nominee, then it is back to the drawing board — unless the president chooses to appoint an acting US Attorney, who <a href="https://www.congress.gov/crs-product/LSB11345">serves</a> for just 120 days.</p><p>This has become more common in recent years, particularly during the Trump administration. However, in most instances, the president would rather have a nominee who will be in place for all four years, rather than having to repeatedly choose temporary heads of the office.</p><p>If one senator is from each party, or both senators are from a different party than the president, the process will be more delicate. At a minimum, the president will need to choose someone whose public persona is relatively apolitical, if not measured and moderate.</p><p>This person should be well respected by their colleagues. In short, they’re the sort of individual who commands the respect of a broad cross-section of the American public — and whom we might want as a USA.</p><p>Unlike with federal judges, the Senate Judiciary Committee does not hold independent hearings on each USA. Usually, USA’s are confirmed by <a href="https://www.congress.gov/crs-product/RS20594">unanimous consent</a>, voice votes, or other procedures which are designed for speed.</p><p>The full Senate votes on each USA placed before them, and he or she must win by majority vote. Typically, multiple USA’s are voted on around the same time — as a package.</p><p>US Attorneys serve at the pleasure of the president. This means that at any time, for any reason, they president may <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2020/06/20/us/politics/geoff-berman-who-can-fire.html">fire</a> a USA.</p><p><strong>What US Attorneys Do</strong></p><p>Each USA commands substantial power within their district. In some high-profile districts, like the Southern District of New York (which covers much of New York City plus the suburbs north of the city) or the Central District of California (which covers Los Angeles County and several surrounding counties) this results in national influence and attention.</p><p>Each USA oversees all <a href="https://da.lacounty.gov/media/news/five-ms-13-gang-members-los-angeles-found-guilty-series-murders-extortion-and-drug">federal criminal prosecutions</a> in their district. These include major drug cases, wire and mail fraud (which covers numerous financial crimes), civil rights violations, and terrorism matters. Some large street gang prosecutions find their way into USA offices, as do quite a few organized crime cases (especially if brought under RICO laws).</p><p>Of course, plenty of the work of each USA office is civil in nature. USA’s use the <a href="https://www.justice.gov/civil/false-claims-act">False Claims Act</a> to prosecute fraud involving Medicare and Medicaid, and illegal conduct involving government contracts. Civil rights violations have often been a major focus of USA offices.</p><p>The government doesn’t just bring cases against others. The federal government can also be sued for a range of reasons, ranging from major constitutional questions to immigration controversies, or the termination of federal employees.</p><p>In short, each USA, and the Assistant United States Attorneys (known as AUSAs) who serve under them, wield considerable power. It should now be clear just how crucial it is to choose honorable people to serve in these roles.</p><p><strong>When USAs are dismissed due to politics: The George W. Bush Administration Scandal</strong></p><p>As I discussed in <a href="https://medium.com/@shivagbhaskar/why-we-must-reform-the-way-we-select-the-attorney-general-4642735b8171">Part 1</a> of this series, USA’s have been dismissed for pursuing certain prosecutions, failing to prioritize other investigations, and more broadly for being out of step with the political winds blowing from the White House or higher up at the Department of Justice. Of course, when discontent towards a particular USA stems from the Department of Justice, the root of the issue often originates from the White House or members of Congress.</p><p>Perhaps the most egregious example of this was seen in the <a href="https://www.npr.org/2007/04/15/8901997/timeline-behind-the-firing-of-eight-u-s-attorneys">firing</a> of seven USAs by President George W. Bush’s administration in December 2006. The timing of the firings was quite unusual. Bush was reelected in November 2004. Normally, when an administration continues into a second term, they’ll retain most USAs from the first time, unless a particular USA chooses to depart voluntarily. Letting go of a few USAs in a second term, let alone seven, is highly unusual.</p><p>Why were these 7 dismissed? At least one of those let go, USA <a href="https://oig.justice.gov/sites/default/files/archive/special/s0809a/chapter10.htm">Carol Lam</a> of the Southern District of California (San Diego) appear to have been removed for investigating and prosecuting well-known local Republican members of Congress. In New Mexico, USA <a href="https://oig.justice.gov/sites/default/files/archive/special/s0809a/chapter6.htm">David Iglesias</a> was pushed aside for failing to prosecute alleged claims of voter fraud against local Democratic politicians. The most prominent of these complaints were lodged by high-ranking local Republican activists and elected officials.</p><p>Others, such as USA Kevin Ryan from the Northern District of California, were dismissed for what appears to have been valid been performance-related reasons. However, a distinct stench of political interference wafted from the entire process. Ultimately, the Inspector General of the Department of Justice found the process to have been highly flawed, with “<a href="https://oig.justice.gov/sites/default/files/archive/special/s0809a/chapter13.htm">significant evidence</a>” that partisan political considerations played a major role in at least some of the firings (especially that of Iglesias).</p><p><strong>USA’s &amp; Political Influence: Some Very Recent History</strong></p><p>This isn’t the only time USA’s and politics have collided. More recently, former acting USA <a href="https://www.npr.org/2025/11/25/nx-s1-5620636/lindsey-halligan-us-attorney-unlawful-comey-james">Lindsey Halligan</a> of the Eastern District of Virginia brought indictments against former FBI Director James Comey, as well as New York Attorney General Letitia James.</p><p>Both Comey and James were recipients of Trump’s ire. President Trump purportedly sought Comey’s “<a href="https://time.com/4809221/james-comey-testimony-donald-trump-loyalty/">loyalty</a>” early in his first term — a request that was rebuffed. Comey also <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2017/05/16/us/politics/james-comey-trump-flynn-russia-investigation.html">refused</a> Trump’s alleged request to pull back an investigation of General Michael Flynn, who was Trump’s National Security Advisor at the time. In James’ case, she initiated a wide-ranging civil lawsuit <a href="https://spectrumlocalnews.com/nys/central-ny/news/2025/10/10/a-history-of-president-trump-s-legal-battles-with-new-york-attorney-general-letitia-james">against</a> the Trump Organization, which resulted in a mixed bag of partial win for New York, and a victory on some grounds for Trump.</p><p>Many observers felt the charges against Comey and James were politically motivated and stood on shaky legal grounds. The charges were eventually dismissed, due to a finding by a federal judge that Halligan was improperly appointed.</p><p>Alina Habba, the former acting USA for New Jersey, found herself embroiled in controversy very soon after her March 2025 appointment. Early on, she <a href="https://www.politico.com/news/2025/08/21/alina-habba-new-jersey-us-attorney-ruling-00518559">announced</a> that she hoped her work as a USA would “turn New Jersey red.”</p><p>Habba initiated <a href="https://apnews.com/article/new-jersey-alina-habba-phil-murphy-matt-platkin-sanctuary-immigrant-dbf95a1dc06aa35270b6c6f591e0c31c">investigations</a> into two of the state’s top elected officials, Governor Phil Murphy and Attorney General Matt Platkin, over their lack of cooperation with federal immigration priorities. Habba announced her investigations into Murphy and Platkin on Sean Hannity’s show on Fox News — as partisan a show as one will find on network TV.</p><p>What do these incidents teach us? The deeper lesson isn’t’ about President Trump or his appointees.</p><p>In my view, while most USA’s act with integrity, there’s also clearly the potential for bias, not to mention abuse of power. While each USA chosen ought to be a person of integrity, we can’t rely on the good faith of a USA appointee — or the president who chose them. Thus, we must implement strong institutional safeguards.</p><p><strong>A Revised Selection Process For USA’s: The Attorney General’s Role</strong></p><p>In the previous piece, we explored a modified process, whereby the attorney general is chosen by the Senate through ranked-choice voting and approved by a panel of federal judges. This process helps insulate presidential interference in the work of the attorney general. Additionally, an attorney general chosen by ranked choice voting, and separately approved by judges, is more likely to be competent, and there’s a lower possibility that they’re a strong ideologue.</p><p>Prior to arriving at this approach, I considered (and rejected) the idea of having federal judges handle the process from end to end. Under that formulation, judges would choose a nominee and ultimately vote on him or her.</p><p>This approach appeared bereft of democratic consent — really, it was technocratic. Judges are selected by the president and confirmed by the Senate (both of which were voted on by the public).</p><p>Therefore, one might argue that people who were chosen by judicial officers, whom elected officials selected, was sufficiently democratic. However, this seems too attenuated, and places excess power in the hands of the judicial branch.</p><p>This approach also could fail to meet the real needs of the job. Who understands what they’re looking for in each USA better than an attorney general, and his or her close advisors? If we want the attorney general (who enjoys real insulation from political pressures) to succeed, then shouldn’t he or she need to have a say in the personnel they choose?</p><p><strong>The Nomination &amp; Confirmation Process</strong></p><p>The optimal solution has been hiding in plain sight the whole time: Allow the Attorney General to nominate each USA, and have them approved by the Senate, via majority vote. This allows the Attorney General to select USAs who can help him or her execute on their overall strategy, at a state and local level. An effective attorney general (his or her staff, more specifically) will have a good idea of who they want to work with.</p><p>That’s not all. As we discussed earlier, the selection of USAs can involve a fair amount of horse trading, between the president and senators from an opposing party who represent a state where the president wishes to appoint a USA. Even when a president and both senators of a given state hail from the same party, political considerations play a role.</p><p>All things equal, a USA who previously worked as a senior staffer for a senator, and supported their Senate campaign in some way, is somewhat more likely to earn a nod. The selection process, as with many high-stakes professional selection processes, is often not purely objective or merit-based.</p><p>While an attorney general might not behave in a purely objective fashion (few of us do) they’re likely less driven by pure political considerations. After all, they were chosen through a ranked-choice voting process, rather than through a presidential nomination. If an attorney general wishes to succeed (and we can assume that most do) then they’ll choose someone who can perform on the job.</p><p>Each USA must be approved by the Senate and can be placed before the Senate for a confirmation hearing. In practice, however, USAs are likely to be voted on in blocks, as is the case today.</p><p>So, here are the details: Once an attorney general nominates a USA, the nomination must be approved or declined by the Senate within 30 days. The Senate can devise it’s own schedule for a confirmation hearing (if it wishes to conduct hearings), but a vote must be held within 30 days.</p><p><strong>How Long A USA May Serve For — And How They May Be Removed</strong></p><p>As we detailed in the first part of this series, the attorney general ought to serve for 6 years. This insulates him or her from the political pressure that often comes with entering and exiting office with a president.</p><p>If the attorney general serves for 6 years, then the same should apply to each USA. They leave office when the USA who appointed them leaves, unless they’re removed from their seat first. Just as with the attorney general, each USA should serve for only one term.</p><p>This raises another important question: How and why might a particular USA be removed from office? We should restrict the removal of any USA strictly to ethical misconduct, whether financial, political or otherwise. Political considerations cannot enter the picture.</p><p>Within those parameters, we must create a few paths to remove the USA. Since each USA serves under an attorney general, the attorney general should be allowed to ask the Senate to remove the USA.</p><p>This request should trigger a meeting of the Senate Judiciary Committee, within 10 business days of the request for removal. The Senate Judiciary Committee will be allowed to hear from the USA (or their representative) as well as from a representative of the attorney general. The hearing should ideally last no more than one day, though the Judiciary Committee can take longer if needed.</p><p>The Judiciary Committee will then take a non-binding vote (meaning, the vote does not have any legal consequences) as to whether the USA should be removed. Then, the Senate will vote on a course of action, within 10 business days of the Judiciary Committee vote.</p><p>To remove any USA, 60 senators must vote in favor of removal. This allows for the removal of a USA who is genuinely in the wrong, while preventing political manipulation. Getting 60 senators to agree on anything isn’t easy — which in this content is a good thing. Removing someone from an appointed office of this stature is a serious matter.</p><p>You’ll notice that at no point have we provided any role for the president to remove a USA. It seems unlikely that a presidential administration is so carefully monitoring a USA that they’d catch some ethical misconduct which should lead to removal — while such conduct was missed by the attorney teneral and others.</p><p>Yet, what if an attorney general is so compromised that he or she overlooks ethical misconduct? In that case, we need another path to preserving the integrity of the USA as an office, especially for those who live in a particular federal district.</p><p>Given that the Constitution is an intricate set of checks and balances, this is exactly the sort of role the president is best suited for. Also, furnishing the president with the power to remove an attorney general allows those in a particular federal district, or the public at large, to petition the White House to move for impeachment. Without the president’s role, there would not be any elected official who could initiate the impeachment process.</p><p>The process with the president should proceed in a similar manner as when the attorney general moves to impeach a USA. This is designed for speed balanced with fairness — and a high bar for a successful impeachment.</p><p><strong>The Final Word</strong></p><p>USA’s are amongst the most pivotal actors in the federal judicial system. They play a vital role in enforcing federal laws, and preventing major harm to society. Thus, they must act with neither fear nor favor, with their North Star being the truth. The stakes are simply too high for anything else.</p><p>The process proposed above provides for this. By removing senators and the president from the direct selection of each USA yet continuing to offer them a role in the removal of a rogue one, we avoid political drama — while maintaining presidential input. This approach maintains oversight while avoiding interference. This is the right balance.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=6ac3fbb09e23" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Why We Must Reform The Way We Select The Attorney General]]></title>
            <link>https://shivagbhaskar.medium.com/why-we-must-reform-the-way-we-select-the-attorney-general-4642735b8171?source=rss-278afcac6ec5------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4642735b8171</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[law]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[society]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[democracy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[justice]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Shiva Bhaskar]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 15 Feb 2026 04:23:21 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-02-15T04:23:21.032Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Cs-B1vU-WvPKVuZS7vwWvg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Photo Credit: Democracy Docket</figcaption></figure><p><em>This is the first of a two-part series on how we select &amp; hold accountable key members of the Department of Justice — specifically, the Attorney General of the United States, as well as the 93 United States Attorneys. In Part 1, we dive into the Attorney General, who’s the chief law enforcement officer of the United States. Note 1: The author served as a law student intern in the United States Attorneys Office for the Northern District of California (San Francisco office). Note 2: Some of the examples, research and arguments here were formulated with the help of AI (Claude), though the core ideas and arguments are the author’s.</em></p><p><strong>Attorney Generals, Presidents, Prosecutions &amp; Controversies: Some Background</strong></p><p>In 1973, President Richard Nixon faced intense scrutiny. His involvement in the Watergate Hotel break-in conspiracy and subsequent cover-up, ultimately topped his presidency. Special prosecutor Archibald Cox (who was appointed by Attorney General Elliot Richardson) subpoenaed White House tapes, which he believed were vital to the investigation. President Nixon ordered Richardson to fire Cox. Richardson maintained his integrity and <a href="https://www.justice.gov/osg/bio/archibald-cox">refused</a>, instead resigning from his position.</p><p>Fast forward 33 years. In 2006, with George W. Bush as president, seven United States Attorneys were <a href="https://www.npr.org/2007/04/15/8901997/timeline-behind-the-firing-of-eight-u-s-attorneys">fired</a> by the Department of Justice. The firing of a US Attorney, outside of when a new president takes office, let alone the firing of 7 attorneys, was seen as quite unusual. A subsequent investigation focused on whether White House and Department of Justice officials <a href="https://www.npr.org/2007/04/15/8901997/timeline-behind-the-firing-of-eight-u-s-attorneys">dismissed</a> US Attorneys for political reasons.</p><p>Specifically, there were allegations that these US Attorneys were dismissed for prosecuting Republican politicians while failing to prosecute Democrats, and for not investigating claims of election fraud. The ensuing controversy led to the <a href="https://www.cnn.com/2010/POLITICS/07/21/us.attorneys/index.html">resignation</a> of former Attorney General Alberto Gonzales, as well as other officials in the Department of Justice. Eventually, a <a href="https://www.politico.com/blogs/politico-now/2008/06/ig-report-doj-under-bush-favored-gop-conservative-job-candidates-009900">report</a> by the Justice Department’s Inspector General found that the firings were at least somehwat politically motivated and improper.</p><p>During the second Trump presidency (I wrote this in late 2025 to early 2026) the role of the Attorney General has come into sharp focus. President Trump <a href="https://www.cnbc.com/2025/10/09/trump-letitia-james-halligan-mortgage.html">called for</a> the prosecution of New York’s Attorney General, Leticia James, as well as former FBI Director James Comey. Both were subsequently <a href="https://abcnews.go.com/US/judge-dismisses-criminal-cases-comey-james/story?id=127732668">indicted</a> by federal grand juries, in cases brought by the Department of Justice. The indictments were dismissed, with the dismissal being <a href="https://www.politico.com/news/2025/12/19/justice-department-halligan-james-comey-letitia-james-00701547">appealed</a> by the Department of Justice.</p><p>Federal Reserve Chairman Jerome Powell also <a href="https://www.federalreserve.gov/newsevents/speech/powell20260111a.htm">revealed</a> that the Federal Reserve was served with grand jury subpoenas, and the threat of a criminal indictment, in connection with the renovation of Federal Reserve buildings. Powell asserted that in his view, the underlying reasons for the Department of Justice’s actions were closely tied to disagreements between Powell and President Trump over the Fed’s decisions around interest rates. Such a clash involving a president, a Fed chair, and the Department of Justice is unprecedented.</p><p>I should note that in each of these instances, there are some questions about how involved Attorney General Pam Bondi was in these decisions, despite her leadership of the Department of Justice. Where does that leave us? Either Bondi has limited control over the actions of those who report to her, or she’s actively encouraging investigations with a strong political tinge. Neither is a positive development.</p><p>Finally, a highly contentious February 2026 <a href="https://thehill.com/homenews/house/5734303-pam-bondi-judiciary-committee-hearing-epstein/">House Judiciary Committee</a> hearing, with Bondi sparring with a number of Democrats on the committee, further shredded any remaining assertions that attorney generals are largely apolitical. The exchanges between Bondi and these representatives repeatedly veered into personal attacks, and full-on partisan combat.</p><p>These events raise serious questions about the independence of the Department of Justice, and the role of the attorney general, who is <a href="https://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/attorney_general#:~:text=The%20U.S.%20Attorney%20General%20is,may%20be%20nominated%20or%20elected.">nominated</a> by a president and confirmed by the Senate. If an attorney general can be so easily swayed by political considerations, what are the prospects for the impartial application of the law in our country?</p><p><strong>What The Attorney General Does</strong></p><p>The Attorney General is one of the most powerful people in our nation. Have doubts about that? Let’s take a close look at the powers he or she enjoys.</p><p>The Attorney General oversees the Department of Justice, which has <a href="https://ourpublicservice.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/01/DOJ-AgencySummaryProfile.pdf#:~:text=Each%20of%20the%20roughly%20112%2C000%20career%20federal,country%20safe%20and%20to%20protect%20civil%20rights.">around</a> 112,000 employees. Those employees provide administrative support, as well as staff and run the various divisions and US Attorney’s Offices. The cases brought by the Department of Justice not only impact many individual lives, but shape the overall direction of the law in our nation.</p><p>The Department of Justice isn’t just made up of attorneys and their support staff. The Department of Justice also <a href="https://www.justice.gov/agencies/chart/grid">houses</a> the FBI, DEA, ATF, the US Marshalls Service and the Federal Bureau of Prisons. All this falls under the purview of the Attorney General. Given the number of people incarcerated in federal prisons, as well as the wide-ranging nature of federal law enforcement, the work of these agencies impacts millions of lives.</p><p>The Attorney General through the <a href="https://www.justice.gov/olc">Office of Legal Counsel</a>, advises the President, as well as various executive agencies, on complex legal questions. Additionally, as head of the Department of Justice, the Attorney General is ultimately <a href="https://www.justice.gov/agencies/chart/grid">responsible</a> for defending the United States, when federal laws are challenged as being unconstitutional or otherwise improper.</p><p>Of course, the Attorney General <a href="https://www.justice.gov/usao">oversees</a> the 93 local / state US Attorneys offices, who handle criminal prosecutions, and oversee civil actions involving specific defendants around the nation. The head of each US Attorney’s office is nominated by the president and confirmed by the Senate.</p><p>The Department of Justice of course <a href="https://www.justice.gov/agencies/chart/grid">contains</a> 7 divisions, each of which oversee a myriad of legal issues, ranging from criminal prosecutions to civil rights, antitrust and tax matters. Some of the most serious matters of the day are handled by federal prosecutors, with far-reaching implications not just for the parties involved, but society itself.</p><p>The duties of the Attorney General aren’t just domestic. The Attorney General plays an integral role in matters involving national security, including investigations into terrorism, drug trafficking, cybercrimes and more.</p><p>As we can see, this is a highly weighty position. It is hard to overstate the relevance of the work done by the Department of Justice, and it’s impact on the public.</p><p>So, what are the key traits we should value in an attorney general? The job requires someone with an abiding sense of duty and integrity, strong leadership skills (particularly an eye for effective supervision and delegation) and a deep understanding of both the law as well as power dynamics. To say the least, it’s a tall order.</p><p><strong>How The Attorney General Is Chosen Today</strong></p><p>The process of choosing an attorney general, while it may have generally worked in the past, is rife with the potential for conflicts of interest and corruption. Today, the president <a href="https://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/attorney_general">nominates</a> the Attorney General. Usually, prior to being nominated, the future nominee <a href="https://abcnews.go.com/Politics/senate-confirmation-works/story?id=43643784">undergoes</a> criminal and other background checks, and fills out questionaries, including a personal financial disclosure, and details around ties to foreign governments.</p><p>After this, the nominee is forwarded to the Senate. The Senate Judiciary Committee will then hold <a href="https://ballotpedia.org/Confirmation_process_for_Merrick_Garland_for_U.S._attorney_general">hearings</a>, to ask the nominee questions, and decide whether they are ready to move forward on the nomination. At that point, if the committee votes to move the nomination forward, then the whole Senate will vote as to whether to approve or reject the nominee.</p><p>At first glance, this might appear to be a well-balanced process, with a comprehensive set of checks and balances. In the absence of historical evidence to the contrary, I’d agree.</p><p>However, when we dig a level deeper, we find a range of problems. What happens when both the president and majority of the Senate are from the same party?</p><p>Does this lead to rubberstamping of the president’s pick? How should we resolve a potential conflict between what the president wants, and fealty to the <a href="https://www.justice.gov/oip/foia-library/general_topics/ag_garland_appointment_affidavit_02_01_22/dl">oath</a> which the attorney general took?</p><p>How does an attorney general navigate such a situation? Based on current and prior history, this is hardly a fanciful hypothetical.</p><p>The Attorney General, as a position, is far too important of a position for there to be any risks of undue influence by any presidential administration. This is true whether the president (and those around him) are trying to avoid legal penalties, or if they choose to target someone for prosecution. It also holds true in a situation where they want to penalize a government employee (such as a prosecutor) for acting in a manner they find problematic.</p><p>How do we overcome this problem? I have a few ideas.</p><p><strong>A New Method for Choosing The Attorney General: The Nomination Process</strong></p><p>Here’s an idea: What if we change the selection process, to allow for proper political checks and balances, but without undue political influence (whether from Congress or the President)?</p><p>What would this change look like? First, let’s think about how we might select a nominee for attorney general.</p><p><strong>Having Federal Judges Nominate Candidates For Attorney General — And Why That’s Not A Good Idea</strong></p><p>My first thought was to have a nominee selected by federal judges, and then voted on by another group of federal judges. Perhaps judges could choose nominees through ranked choice voting?</p><p>Judges have a general sense of how various United States Attorney’s offices operate — in fact, many of them worked there before being appointed to the federal bench. They know who’s respected, and who’s not.</p><p>While I won’t indulge in the fiction judges are apolitical, they’re rarely partisan in the way elected officials are. Given that we want an attorney general who operates without fear or favor, might it not make sense to remove politicians from the process?</p><p>Here’s one issue: Judges know who’s a good lawyer — but does a good lawyer make for an effective attorney general? Succeeding in that role isn’t just about lawyering. In fact, it is virtually unheard of for a modern attorney general to personally appear in court.</p><p>Rather, an attorney general must possess the managerial and operational skills to oversee large, complex entities. He or she must be a person of impeccable judgment and discretion. They must possess a deep sense of independence.</p><p>We also should think carefully about the potential pool of attorney generals. Are the only people qualified to be an attorney general those who work in some federal capacity?</p><p>What about an effective state attorney general, or a former mayor or governor with a strong legal background? Or an attorney who formerly led a major federal agency — perhaps one which is part of the Department of Justice? How might a prominent local defense attorney or prosecutor, who effectively led a major district attorney or public defender’s office, fare in the job? While we’re at it, what if we consider someone who was once in government, but is now thriving in private practice?</p><p>How confident are we that federal judges would be familiar with a stellar candidate, who had little to no contact with federal courts? I am quite doubtful.</p><p>Let’s compare this with the Senate. It’s the job of each senator to represent their constituents.</p><p>In this context, they engage with members of the public, and various leaders in federal, state and local governments, as well as the private sector. While not every senator is equally active in this regard, as a group, they tend to engage with a range of people in the social, political and business arena. This gives them a better gauge on who a worthwhile nominee might be.</p><p>There’s another reason to avoid having federal judges select nominees — the concentration of power. If we have federal judges choosing nominees, and voting on them, then there’s effectively no political oversight of the process. Judges are in full control.</p><p>While the process is too political right now (with the president and senate deciding everything), we also don’t want to go in a direction where the political branches (Congress and the President) have no say. We must strike a balance.</p><p><strong>The Attorney General Nomination Process: The Senate Gets to Work</strong></p><p>Now that we’ve eliminated the judiciary from the nomination process, what should we do? We’ve already established problems with the president choosing the attorney general — an approach which is rife with conflicts of interest. So, instead of involving the President, we are going to run the entire nomination process through the Senate.</p><p>The President will enjoy other checks on the attorney general. We are not removing the executive branch from the process. More on that later.</p><p>How will this work? First, there will be an open 5-day period, during which each Senator will have an opportunity to nominate a potential Attorney General (no more than one nominee per Senator). 5 days is short enough to not let the process become too unwieldy, but long enough to allow senators to engage in a meaningful selection process.</p><p>The process should begin two months before the term of the current attorney general ends. In the event the process has not been completed in that time, the current attorney general will continue serving, until a new attorney general is chosen.</p><p><strong>Why Ranked-Choice Voting Is The Way To Go</strong></p><p>Once all nominees have been chosen, Senators will engage in ranked choice voting, with up to 5 choices.</p><p>You might have noticed another important departure from the current selection process: The Senate Judiciary Committee will not have a role to play. While they will continue to vote on federal judges and hold hearings on other matters involving the application of federal law, there’s no reason to have the Judiciary Committee involved in a ranked-choice voting process where the full Senate is voting.</p><p>This doesn’t mean that a nominee won’t have to go through screening, and answer questions in a public setting. However, that will be conducted in a different setting.</p><p>How does ranked-choice voting work? Well, let’s say that we have a total of 5 nominees, known as A, B, C, D and E.</p><p>In the first round, all first-choice votes are counted. If any candidate receives a majority (51 or more votes), they win immediately. If no candidate achieves a majority, the candidate with the fewest votes is eliminated.</p><p>In each following round, the eliminated candidate’s votes are redistributed to whichever remaining nominee each senator ranked next on their ballot. If that senator’s next-ranked choice has also been eliminated in a previous round, their vote continues down the ballot of that senator, to the next candidate still in the race.</p><p>After redistribution, votes are counted again. The process continues — eliminating the lowest vote-getter and redistributing votes — until one candidate receives a majority (51 or more votes). Essentially, it functions as a process of elimination.</p><p>Why is ranked-choice voting so vital here? There are a few reasons.</p><p>First, it reduces the risk of an extreme or polarizing candidate becoming the nominee, simply because they won the most votes in a crowded, contentious field. Let’s say there are a total of 5 nominees, with each senator allowed to vote on a single nominee. With just 21 votes, from a unified block of senators, a nominee who falls on either ideological spectrum (either the far left or far right) is the winner.</p><p>He or she is now the nominee. This nominee not only doesn’t truly reflect the preferences of many senators. He or she is also likely to be rejected in the (revised) confirmation process — more on that later.</p><p>Ranked-choice voting, when combined with an open nomination process, allows for a range of potential nominees. Yet it forces each senator to think strategically about which candidates they could ultimately live with as the nominee (however ideologically imperfect such a candidate might be), and which ones are anathema.</p><p>Ideally, ranked choice voting will optimize for ideological moderation, professional competence, and personal integrity. At a minimum, it will lead to the elimination of those who are severely lacking in one or more of those traits. This is positive for society, which benefits from thoughtful, highly qualified people in leading positions.</p><p>What sorts of candidates might ranked-choice voting promote? As an exercise, let’s consider four potential nominees:</p><p>1. A currently serving United States Attorney from a major district in a Republican-leaning state, she began her career as a large-firm attorney before moving to the Department of Justice. While a registered Republican and having a reputation for vigorously prosecuting violent crime, she is known to be scrupulously non-partisan. She is also well-regarded by defense attorneys in her district, and those who work under her, for her fair-minded approach to justice.</p><p>2. A state appellate court judge, who began his legal journey as a public defender, subsequently working as a private civil litigation attorney. He eventually rose to senior leadership in one of the largest law firms in his state. He left this position for a top role in the Civil Division of the Department of Justice. He oversaw appeals for the federal government. After serving for several years, he returned to private practice. After a few short years, he was appointed as a judge. He’s a registered Democrat from a large liberal city, and as a former public defender, might be seen as relatively left-leaning. Yet, he’s respected by a range of attorneys for his intellect, even-handedness, and thoughtful management style.</p><p>3. A recently retired state attorney general from a state with a consistent track record of voting for Republican presidents, this individual began his career as a local prosecutor. Much of his work was in bringing indictments against major local street gangs. He was also known for his reluctance to prosecute police officers accused of misconduct. This led to widespread criticism from local civil rights organizations. He eventually moved into private practice, where he defended, amongst others, major energy companies and gun manufacturers. He’s a leader in the Federalist Society. In his capacity as a state attorney general, he filed an amicus brief for the prevailing side in the <em>Dobbs </em>decision — the Supreme Court case which ultimately turned control of abortion rights back over to the states.</p><p>4. The head of the public defender’s office in a large, left-leaning coastal county, she started her career as a legal aid attorney, focused on tenant’s and immigrant rights. She then did a stint as a private plaintiff’s attorney, litigating cases against property owners for habitability issues, and against large corporations accused of wrongdoing. She is actively involved in a range of political causes, from climate change to activism for rent control expansion, and advocacy for stricter gun laws. She has been arrested for conducting sit-ins and lying in the road at demonstrations.</p><p>Many on the right will laud the third nominee. Much of the left will find the fourth nominee scintillating.</p><p>At the same time, the right will vigorously oppose the fourth nominee, as will the left with the third nominee. In both cases, it would be fair to strongly question whether the proposed nominee can act in a fair manner, as is vital for an attorney general. After all, they clearly have strong political preferences and have acted on them repeatedly.</p><p>What about Nominees 1 and 2? While neither would be the first choice for ideologues, both should be broadly palatable to most senators. They will win quite a few second or third choice votes.</p><p>After all, they’re each seemingly fair, competent people. Such individuals are more likely to win in a ranked-choice system.</p><p>Ranked choice voting is more likely to produce more nominees like 1 and 2, than 3 and 4. This is a good thing for American society itself. Unbiased competence is easily the most valuable trait we could hope for in an attorney general.</p><p>Below is an example of how this might work out. It is relevant to note that I simplified the scenario, in that we assume none of the candidates who were eliminated ranked anyone who was already eliminated, in a remaining round. In other words, there are no wasted votes.</p><p>Let’s say the top five vote earners had the last names of Jones, Fernandez, Williams, Chung &amp; Singh. Let’s say that the first round of voting shakes out as follows:</p><p><strong>Round 1: First-choice votes</strong></p><p>Jones: 31</p><p>Fernandez: 17</p><p>Williams: 15</p><p>Chung: 16</p><p>Singh: 21</p><p><strong>Total: 100</strong></p><p><strong>Williams eliminated (lowest: 15)</strong></p><p>In the second round, Williams has been eliminated. We now look at the 15 senators who ranked Williams first. Who were their second-round choices? We assign their second-round votes to the remaining nominees.</p><p>Round 2:</p><p>Jones: 2</p><p>Fernandez: 8</p><p>Chung: 3</p><p>Singh: 2</p><p><strong>Round 2 totals:</strong></p><p>Jones: <strong>33</strong> (31 + 2)</p><p>Fernandez: <strong>25</strong> (17 + 8)</p><p>Singh: <strong>23</strong> (21 + 2)</p><p>Chung: <strong>19</strong> (16 + 3)</p><p><strong>Total: 100</strong></p><p><strong>Chung eliminated (lowest: 19)</strong></p><p><strong>Round 3: Chung’s 19 voters redistributed</strong></p><ul><li>Jones: 3</li><li>Fernandez: 11</li><li>Singh: 5</li></ul><p><strong>Round 3 totals:</strong></p><ul><li>Jones: <strong>36</strong> (33 + 3)</li><li>Fernandez: <strong>36</strong> (25 + 11)</li><li>Singh: <strong>28</strong> (23 + 5)</li><li><strong>Total: 100</strong></li></ul><p><strong>Singh eliminated (lowest: 28)</strong></p><p><strong>Round 4: Singh’s 28 voters redistributed</strong></p><ul><li>Jones: 12</li><li>Fernandez: 16</li></ul><p><strong>Final totals:</strong></p><ul><li><strong>Fernandez: 52</strong> (36 + 16)</li><li>Jones: 48 (36 + 12)</li><li><strong>Total: 100</strong></li></ul><p><strong>Fernandez wins with 52 votes (majority)</strong></p><p>This is how ranked choice voting works. This process increases (though of course does not guarantee) the chances of a thoughtful, moderate nominee prevailing. Fernandez was the top vote-earner in the first round — but he ultimately prevailed.</p><p><strong>Selecting A Panel Of Federal Judges To Vote On The Nominee</strong></p><p>Earlier, I rejected the idea of having federal judges nominate an attorney general. Such an approach would concentrate excessive power in the hands of the judiciary. Instead, the nomination process should remain in the hands of elected officials.</p><p>At the same time, we want to select a highly qualified, fair-minded attorney general, free of political bias or influence. Involving someone other than elected officials (senators) in the approval process increases such an outcome.</p><p>How do we achieve these dual goals? I believe a panel of 5 randomly selected federal judges should ultimately vote on the nominee.</p><p>Why 5? As with any number when it comes to a judicial or political process, it’s a bit random.</p><p>3 judges are too few for something of such large national consequence. Yet 7 is too hard to coordinate. Too many people on a panel ultimately leads to inefficiency and gridlock. Thus, 5 is a reasonable number.</p><p><strong>Requirements for selecting the nominee voting panel</strong></p><p>Let’s get more specific. The 5 judges will be chosen randomly. There are 679 District Court judges &amp; 179 Court of Appeals judges. Since District Court judges hear trial cases, there are considerably more of them.</p><p>Judges from district courts and appeals courts have varied experiences. Both perspectives are valuable in deciding on a nominee.</p><p>District judges enjoy a front row seat to the daily functions of the federal judicial system. Those on appeals courts deal with broader procedural, legal and constitutional issues, sometimes with far-reaching effects on millions of people. To ensure proportional balance, 4 members of the panel should be randomly selected from the various district courts around the nation, and 1 judge will be chosen (again randomly) from appeals courts.</p><p>We also want to ensure that no judge serves on the selection panel more than once. This helps avoid the bias, however subtle, of a previous nomination influencing the current nomination process. It is fundamentally not fair to a nominee, or the country itself.</p><p><strong>What The Panel Does Once A Nominee Is Submitted</strong></p><p>Once a nominee is put before the committee, the real work begins. Just as in the <a href="https://law.justia.com/constitution/us/article-2/27-stages-of-appointment-process.html#:~:text=Nomination.,the%20appointee%2C%20by%20the%20President.">current</a> Senate confirmation process, the nominee will need to answer a series of written questions. Each judge should be allowed to submit up to 10 written questions. The nominee will need to answer these questions within 2 weeks of receipt. Answers to the questionnaire will be available to the public.</p><p>Next, a public hearing should be scheduled. Since Washington DC is the seat of the federal government, the hearing should be held in a federal courtroom there. This also has symbolic value. It serves as a reminder that while a group of federal judges from around the nation are voting on the nominee, they’re acting on behalf of the American people.</p><p>The public hearing will be televised. A limited number of observers will be admitted, just as with most high-profile court hearings. This will include a few dozen journalists, as well as around 20 members of the public. These journalists will be chosen at random from a lottery, as will ordinary citizens.</p><p>During the hearing, which will begin in the morning, each judge is allowed to ask the nominee up to 4 questions. This is designed to provide judges and the public with a reasonable opportunity to hear a nominee’s perspective.</p><p>At the same time, it’s not unduly burdensome to the nominee. It prevents a judge from taking over the process, with frivolous or harassing questions.</p><p><strong>Why 4 of the 5 Judges Must Vote Yes On A Nominee</strong></p><p>For a nominee to win approval, 4 of the 5 judges must vote in favor of the nominee. Why 4 of 5?</p><p>Let’s look at the alternatives. 3 out of 5 judges voting in favor of a nominee constitutes 60% of the panel, which is a solid majority. Why isn’t this enough?</p><p>While the selection of judges to the voting panel is random, there’s still a possibility that the panel ends up with more voting members who lean a particular way politically. Assuming the Senate leaned overwhelmingly in a similar direction, and we’ve had presidents from one party or the other in power for extended periods of time, then we might face courts which are more heavily saturated with judges from a particular party. In this situation, we might end up with an excessively partisan, ill-suited nominee obtaining approval.</p><p>For example, what if a Senate dominated by Democrats sends the nominee panel someone like the fourth nominee whom we discussed earlier — the political activist public defender? Let’s say we end up with a nominee panel made up of 3 judges appointed by Democratic presidents, with each judge being rather left-leaning. In this scenario, a questionable nominee is quite likely to be approved.</p><p>Of course, a similar situation could transpire with an equally unsuitable conservative nominee, who is put forward by a Republican-dominated Senate, and approved by 3 rightwing federal judges. Neither of these situations is ideal.</p><p>Requiring 4 judges to approve a nominee reduces this risk considerably. The chances that 4 of the 5 judges on the panel, all randomly chosen, each lean in a similar direction, is quite low. Simple laws of probability suggest this.</p><p>This requirement might also temper the Senate’s approach. If senators know a controversial nominee is less likely to obtain approval, they’d have less incentive to support such an individual. As a result, senators would send a more evenhanded, consensus pick to the voting panel.</p><p>Let’s take a concrete example. The fourth nominee (the activist public defender) is forwarded to the panel by the Senate, which is dominated by Democrats. On the panel, 3 of the judges are quite left-leaning. 1 is a registered Democrat but generally considered moderate. The 5th panelist is a conservative Republican.</p><p>On this panel, the Republican judge is almost certain to reject the nominee. The moderate Democrat is quite likely to as well. He or she probably values not only competence but political temperance, and this nominee is almost certainly lacking there. As a result, the nomination is likely to fail — which is the best outcome under the circumstances.</p><p>Why not require all 5 judges to vote yes on a nominee? I considered this approach and rejected it. While the Supreme Court has a <a href="https://www.scotusblog.com/2022/07/as-unanimity-declines-conservative-majoritys-power-runs-deeper-than-the-blockbuster-cases/">surprising number</a> of unanimous decisions, it’s hard to say how that will translate to this panel.</p><p>There’s also a good chance that at least one of the 5 judges will have issues even with a qualified nominee. This will lead to rejection of the nominee, and time wasted by everyone. Thus, requiring approval of 4 of the 5 nominees works best.</p><p><strong>What If A Panel Rejects A Nominee?</strong></p><p>What if the panel rejects a nominee? The Senate will now go through the ranked-choice voting process again, with the rejected nominee being ineligible. They’ll select a new nominee, through the ranked-choice voting process.</p><p>The nominee will be turned over to the panel and voted on. What if this nominee is also turned down? At that point, the Senate has one more chance to send a nominee. If this nominee is also rejected, then the panel is dissolved, and the existing attorney general will serve for 2 more years.</p><p>Let’s take stock of where we are at this point. 3 nominees were brought forward, and all 3 were rejected. Clearly, either the Senate, or the judicial panel, or both, are unable to reach an understanding. There’s no point in repeating what already hasn’t worked</p><p>Where are we now? The existing attorney general will serve for 2 more years. At that time, the Senate will vote on a new nominee. Quite likely, some Senators will have left the Senate at that point, being replaced by fresh blood. Maybe this will lead to a different outcome.</p><p>This places a check on everyone involved. If a panel of judges continues unreasonably rejecting candidates, then the panel is dissolved, and each member of the panel forever loses the privilege to vote on future nominees. They also will share in the ignominy of being seen as an unfair group, who blindly rejected qualified nominees, in a way unbecoming of a member of the judiciary.</p><p>At the same time, if the Senate repeatedly sends unsuitable nominees, then the current Senate loses the right to forward a nominee. For a senator who wishes to have an impact on the future of the nation, this creates an incentive to work closely with other senators, to select an attorney general.</p><p><strong>Changing The Attorney General’s Term to Six Years</strong></p><p>We’ve been exploring how to depoliticize the position of the attorney general. In my view, one approach, largely symbolic, is to extend the term of the attorney general. Right now, they serve a 4-year term, which coincides with that of the president. When the president leaves office, the attorney general almost always follows.</p><p>By arranging for the attorney general to serve a six-year term, we’re choreographing a decoupling the office of the attorney general from that of the president — making him or her independent of the ebbs and flows of a presidential term. The attorney general outlasts the term of any one president — or at least isn’t directly connected.</p><p>The practical impact of this, in terms of the actions of an attorney general, might be limited. Yet, if the goal is independence, it sends a powerful message.</p><p><strong>How An Attorney General Could Be Removed From Office</strong></p><p>If an attorney general engages in misconduct, they must face the possibility of removal. How would this work?</p><p>First, the grounds for potential removal must be clear. To avoid the process being politicized (which is inherently a tough task), only personal misconduct (whether financial or otherwise) or failing to carry out the duties of the office would be grounds for removal. Disagreements over policy are simply not a reason for removing someone from such an important office.</p><p>Secondly, both the president and the Senate must have a means to move impeachment forward. The president should be allowed to propose the impeachment of an attorney general, by providing a detailed written statement of the grounds for impeachment. The request will be sent to the Senate Judiciary Committee.</p><p>Within 15 days of receiving such a request, the Senate Judiciary Committee must hold a hearing on impeachment. The attorney general will be required to appear before the Judiciary Committee, for a hearing which will not last more than one day.</p><p>He or she will answer questions from the committee’s members. A representative of the president will also be required to appear before the committee, again for no more than one day, and answer questions as to the proposed impeachment.</p><p>The Judiciary Committee will not actually vote on impeachment. The purpose of the hearing is to provide each senator with more information as to the merits and downsides of impeachment.</p><p>Removing an attorney general is a serious step. Thus, a high bar must be met. 60 votes should be required. This helps ensure that even with a strong majority in the Senate (say 55 votes), no party can target an attorney general for removal, simply based on political disagreements. They’ll still require some support from those with different ideological inclinations.</p><p>What if the Senate wants to remove an attorney general, outside of the president suggesting removal? There is good reason to allow for this, especially in a situation where the president is somehow compromised.</p><p>For the Senate to remove the attorney general, the process will be quite similar to what we reviewed above — with one important exception: At least 4 senators must sign a petition supporting impeachment. At that point, the Judiciary Committee will commence hearings and begin the process. Instead of a representative chosen by the president answering questions, the senators who suggested impeachment will provide their own representative.</p><p>The president will not have any input during this process. The Senate will proceed on it’s own.</p><p><strong>The Final Word</strong></p><p>The process I’ve outlined above probably isn’t flawless. Likely, some areas for improvement will reveal themselves over time.</p><p>Yet, it is a vast improvement over the misaligned incentives and clear conflicts of interest which we have today. Removing the president from the selection process greatly increases the chances that an attorney general will be somehow beholden to an administration. Ranked-choice voting, combined with requiring the approval of four out of 5 federal judges on a panel, greatly reduces the chances of a highly biased, partisan person becoming attorney general.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4642735b8171" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Some Things I Find Absurd]]></title>
            <link>https://shivagbhaskar.medium.com/some-things-i-find-absurd-573521df527f?source=rss-278afcac6ec5------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/573521df527f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[life]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[absurd]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Shiva Bhaskar]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 05 Oct 2025 23:12:19 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-10-05T23:12:19.790Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/600/0*EhSx9U4t5Wlredgd.jpg" /><figcaption>Photo Credit: Shutterstock</figcaption></figure><p>I usually write about serious topics, such as technology, business, and law. Yet, life is filled with a range of absurdities. Here, I’m going to riff on some of those.</p><p><strong>Turmeric Suddenly Gaining Popularity</strong></p><p>I grew up in an Indian — American family. Turmeric was always a part of our cooking. <em>Haldi doodh </em>(turmeric with milk) was always known as something which could ease almost any illness (so was milk with brandy, but that’s another story).</p><p>Today, it seems turmeric is everywhere. Health and fitness influencers are raving about the benefits of turmeric for heart health and brain function, not to mention it’s anti-inflammatory properties.</p><p>They’re likely right. It’s also true that my great grandmothers knew about the health benefits of turmeric a long time ago — though admittedly, their ability to market it on Instagram and talk about it on Tiktok was somewhat limited.</p><p>They also were able to prepare meals and drinks containing turmeric, for a fraction of what some are hawking these products for today. Don’t get me wrong — I think anything which helps us live better lives is positive. Yet, I can’t help but notice that things which have existed for so long are coming back into vogue. Ashwagandha is yet another example.</p><p><strong>Being An Influencer Vs Doing the Work</strong></p><p>Cranky older millennial rant incoming. The rise of influencers is really something — whether that’s something good or bad, remains to be decided.</p><p>On the one hand, in many aspects of life, I don’t believe in gatekeeping. YouTube, not to mention TikTok, Instagram and other platforms, have spawned a whole lot of fascinating sub-genres of videos.</p><p>For any dish you can think of, you’ll find someone making it in a new and unique way — often while explaining in their native language. We’ve seen covers of just above every song out there, sometimes as good or better than the original (depending on your taste).</p><p>All of this is wonderful. At a minimum, it’s brought me plenty of entertainment.</p><p>At the same time, I can’t help but notice that there are lots of people talking about things that they don’t really do. Let’s take real estate.</p><p>There is an abundance of real estate coaching programs, often led by people who are not highly active real estate investors (maybe they own a property or two). Those who are actively buying and managing properties are often too busy making money to engage in coaching.</p><p>The same can be said for those who promote buying small businesses, cryptocurrency and more. Mercifully, those running cooking shows and demonstrating makeup techniques, don’t have much choice but to engage in their craft — who’s going to watch a purely descriptive cooking show?</p><p>In a sense, this bias towards talking rather than taking action is in fact rational. You’re able to build and monetize an audience, without having to do the work of your craft. In many ways, it is easier.</p><p>To me, it’s not the way to live — but I also don’t have a massive TikTok or Instagram following (yet). I go back to Nassim Taleb’s <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Skin-Game-Hidden-Asymmetries-Daily/dp/042528462X">thoughts</a> around the concept of “skin in the game” (also the title of his book). Living with integrity and being in the middle of things (as he is), seems to be the way to live.</p><p><strong>People Whose Emails Have Dramatically Improved Thanks To AI</strong></p><p>I’ll preface this by saying that I am in favor of anyone who wishes to, finding constructive ways to improve their life. More specifically, I think that when it comes to our careers, we should grab every lever which we ethically can, to increase our chances of success.</p><p>With that said, it’s always interesting when you have a “before and after” basis for people’s communication styles. I’ve seen some folks in my circles go from hesitant email senders to eloquent masters of the electronic medium.</p><p>As much as I’d like to believe that they suddenly became masters of written communication, the reality is that the first line of credit for these improvements should go to platforms like ChatGPT, Claude and Gemini. The transformation is remarkable.</p><p>Again, I am not against this in any way. However, I can’t unsee their original communication style, and the dramatic difference that we now find.</p><p><strong>The FIRE (Financial Independence Retire Early) Movement</strong></p><p>If you’re a Millennial and have been anywhere near Reddit, you’ve likely heard of the FIRE movement. FIRE is a financial and social movement, which advocates people being able to leave their full-time jobs (if they wish to) in their 30’s and 40’s, and retire early. To achieve their goals, FIRE proponents <a href="https://www.investopedia.com/terms/f/financial-independence-retire-early-fire.asp?utm_source=chatgpt.com">advocate for</a> a mix of aggressive savings and frugal living. They hope to replace their income through investment income (and reduced, often part-time work) to ultimately (voluntarily) exit the workforce.</p><p>On the one hand, I get why FIRE is attractive. Being in the workforce is, all too frequently, a thankless, draining experience. Wanting to leave is quite natural.</p><p>I also think it’s quite wise not to waste money. We need money to meet our basic needs.</p><p>At the same time, trying to live too frugally, at the expense of all fun, seems to be a recipe for long-term unhappiness. In theory, leaving one’s job early opens opportunities for philanthropic work, or finding a career which offers a greater sense of fulfillment opens up the door to a better life. In practice, it often simply leads to stagnation.</p><p>I suppose I’m not against the idea of FIRE, so much as I think it’s a suboptimal use of our lives. I just don’t see it as the best path forward. Rather, why not strive to work hard, contribute, and build a greater legacy?</p><p><strong>Los Angeles Traffic</strong></p><p>I know, I know. This topic has been beaten to death. But really, I have to ask: Why is the traffic in Los Angeles so bad?</p><p>For some context, I grew up in the LA suburbs. I’ve also lived in New York City and San Francisco. New York City has nearly 10 million people packed into a space much smaller than Los Angeles. It has real traffic issues — but somehow, Los Angeles manages to be even worse.</p><p>Why is this? Is it our lack of public transportation?</p><p>Almost certainly. The lack of mass transit forces people to drive, and there isn’t nearly enough space on our highways for the number of cars on the road.</p><p>How about the lack of lanes on our highways? That’s certainly an issue, given that most of our major highways were built in the 1950’s and 1960’s, for a much smaller population However, further expansion of our highways isn’t very realistic now.</p><p>So, is there no solution? Not quite. A major expansion of mass transit would certainly help, particularly a mix of trains (to go long distances) and buses to connect trains stops more locally. Yet, in the face of a lack of political will, and a population count that is more or less static in terms of numbers, who will this happen? I’m not sure.</p><p><strong>Some Final Thoughts</strong></p><p>Perhaps this article itself was absurd. I’m open to the possibility. If the article wasn’t absurd, then thank you for reading to this point. May your life be less absurd (unless absurdity is your thing).</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=573521df527f" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[We Need Age Limits For Congress. Here’s Why]]></title>
            <link>https://shivagbhaskar.medium.com/we-need-age-limits-for-congress-heres-why-8ffd136df6a4?source=rss-278afcac6ec5------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8ffd136df6a4</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[term-limits]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[congress]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[elections]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[government]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Shiva Bhaskar]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 25 Aug 2025 03:51:15 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-08-25T03:51:15.779Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/400/1*_yOlJ-rPy33wXp7ksoN79w.png" /><figcaption>Photo Credit: Roots Action</figcaption></figure><p>I can’t think of a time in my lifetime when the issue of age in politics has been such a hot topic of discussion. The most obvious example of this is with Joe Biden’s eventual withdrawal from the 2024 presidential race, as concerns about his age and cognitive decline mounted.</p><p>In the same year, we<a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2024/12/23/us/politics/kay-granger-congress-age.html"> learned</a> that Kay Granger, a House member from Texas (and formerly the top Republican member of the House Appropriations Committee), was living in a nursing home, and suffering from dementia. Mitch McConnell <a href="https://www.cnn.com/2024/02/28/politics/mitch-mcconnell-stepping-down-leadership-senate-gop">stepped down</a> from Senate leadership, in no small part due to concerns over his repeatedly <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2023/08/30/us/politics/mitch-mcconnell-freeze-kentucky.html">freezing up</a> during speeches.</p><p>Granger, McConnell and Biden were all over the age of 80, when they made the decision to step aside. While declining health was an important headline in each of their stories, age is an important subtext. Health issues can appear at any age — but they’re far likelier as we get up there in years. Age can be a concern in any job.</p><p>However, there are few positions with as much impact on the lives of Americans, as our elected officials. There has been quite extensive discussion of age limits for the presidency. However, we haven’t discussed this in as much detail for those we elect to Congress. In my view, members of Congress should not be over the age of 70, as of the date that their current term is scheduled to end. Here’s why.</p><p><strong>Age Limits for Other Jobs &amp; Undertakings</strong></p><p>For federal law enforcement officers, the <a href="https://www.afge.org/leaders-activists/steering-committees/law-enforcement-committee/6c-and-law-enforcement-officers-retirement-benefits-for-cbp-officers/#:~:text=LEOs%20Can%20Retire%20Earlier%20With%20No%20Penalties.&amp;text=However%20if%20someone%20in%20a%20covered%20position,of%20the%20month%20s/he%20finishes%2020%20years.">mandatory</a> retirement age (in most cases) is 57. Pilots have a <a href="https://www.shrm.org/topics-tools/employment-law-compliance/pilots--retirement-age-kept-at-65">mandatory</a> retirement age of 65. Air traffic controllers <a href="https://uscode.house.gov/view.xhtml?req=granuleid:USC-prelim-title5-section8335&amp;num=0&amp;edition=prelim#:~:text=%C2%A78335.,e)%2C%20whichever%20occurs%20later.">must</a> retire by the age of 61. In many cities and states, there are age limits for joining the police force or fire department.</p><p>In each of those jobs, we agree there are physical and mental requirements (including in terms of attention span) which typically deteriorate with age, thus posing challenges. We understand there are serious risks, both for the individuals working in these jobs as well as the public. If someone is unable to properly discharge their duties, it is best that they step aside.</p><p>None of us would contest that each of the jobs listed above are quite important, in terms of their impact on the public. For that reason, few would bat their eyes at age limits for these professions. Similarly, I assume we would agree that effective leadership at the Congressional level is incredibly consequential.</p><p>In that case, why don’t we implement appropriate age restrictions there? Any argument that such restrictions are ageist would seemingly require us to scrap all other age-based restrictions for other professions.</p><p><strong>The Odds of Cognitive Decline Increase with Age</strong></p><p>For many of us, cognitive decline is an unfortunate fact of life. Cognitive decline is also closely correlated with age. This of course isn’t to say that <em>all </em>older adults will face noticeable cognitive decline. However, age is one of the key factors closely associated with cognitive decline.</p><p>Research cited by UCSF suggests that our cognitive abilities <a href="https://memory.ucsf.edu/brain-health/healthy-aging">peak</a> around age 30, and begin to decline from there. Not all cognitive abilities <a href="https://www.health.harvard.edu/mind-and-mood/how-memory-and-thinking-ability-change-with-age">decline</a> with age. In fact, while it seems we might get worse at storing and processing new information, we also become more skilled when it comes to seeing the bigger picture.</p><p>There is an argument that some forms of wisdom continue to improve with age. Yet, our thinking is often overall not quite as sharp.</p><p>When does cognitive decline start to <a href="https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC2683339/#:~:text=most%20abilities%20tend%20to%20peak,%E2%80%9D%20(Schaie%2C%201989).">accelerate</a>? While science varies, it appears that cognitive decline tends to pick up as people enter their mid to late 70’s. Other research suggests that decline may <a href="https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC2683339/">start</a> substantially sooner, though it gets worse later.</p><p>Of course, our mental functioning is impacted by a range of factors, including <a href="https://www.heart.org/en/news/2024/09/27/food-for-thought-how-diet-affects-the-brain-over-a-lifetime#:~:text=During%20childhood%20and%20adolescence%2C%20poor,to%20brain%20structure%20and%20volume.">diet</a>, <a href="https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-022-26093-2">exercise</a>, <a href="https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11447500/">genetics</a> and more. As we learn about how the brain, body and environment interact (a process which might be accelerated by artificial intelligence), we will probably become even better at understanding what cognitive function looks like (and how it changes over time) for different people.</p><p>Yet, the reality is, we must also take broad factors into consideration, and age is one. As people get older, they’re more likely to face some loss of cognitive function.</p><p>Members of Congress can ill-afford to suffer from cognitive decline. The decisions they make are impactful, often with highly complex analysis often required.</p><p><strong>Physical Health Also Declines With Age</strong></p><p>I probably won’t shock you when I say that we usually become less healthy as we age. While the exact pattern of declining health varies with age, it is a reality that very few of us are as healthy at the age of 75 as we were when we were 25. For most of us, we don’t have as much energy, and we tend to move a step or two slower.</p><p>How does this matter for Congress? Well, members of Congress are often required to maintain a demanding schedule, with early and late meetings, trips to visit their constituents, and in some instances, international travel.</p><p>This doesn’t mean that they need to be marathon runners or professional weightlifters. However, the job requires a certain degree of stamina, which is less likely to be present after a certain age. If we want to optimize our national legislative bodies for effectiveness, we will need to increase the odds that those who serve are in at least decent physical health. Age limits are an effective means of implementing this.</p><p><strong>Older People, On Average, Have Less Cognitive Flexibility &amp; Neuroplasticity Than Younger People</strong></p><p>Here’s the reality: Age has no monopoly on mental vitality. There are incredibly sharp people of all ages — as well as plenty of people who are working with a lesser mental toolkit.</p><p>With that said, society is constantly changing. In the current moment, with the rise of artificial intelligence, this feels especially true. The domain of what could only be done by humans, vs. by machines, is quickly narrowing. Disciplines, areas of expertise, life itself, is starting to blur and fuse together, faster than ever.</p><p>At the same time, the specter of global conflict remains as visible as ever. Just in recent months, we’ve witnessed serious conflict between Israel and Iran, as well as bloody conflict between India and Pakistan, two nuclear powers. Russia and Ukraine continue to fight, and the conflict in Gaza remains active and bloody as ever. The world isn’t necessarily getting more peaceful with time.</p><p>In this time of chaos, the ability to synthesize new facts, change one’s mind, and adapt quickly are all vital. Once again, this is something that people from all age backgrounds can do.</p><p>However, for those who are younger, this is easier. Simply put, their minds are more flexible.</p><p>This is not mere speculation. <a href="https://www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.1700811114">Research</a> has found greater cognitive flexibility with certain tasks among children in pre-school, as compared to children of elementary school age. In turn, children of elementary school age perform better than adolescents and adults. In other words, the decline in cognitive flexibility may be a lifelong process.</p><p>While older adults have neuroplasticity, studies make it clear that they enjoy <a href="https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3622463/">less</a> of it than younger adults. More broadly, cognitive flexibility, in terms of switching between different tasks, declines with age.</p><p>We simply cannot afford this risk. The only way to prevent it is to implement age limits.</p><p><strong>Older Legislators Are Less Impacted By Some Future Issues of Great Concern</strong></p><p>What are the pressing issues of the next 20 years? I can think of several. The rise of artificial intelligence, and it’s growing impact on so many aspects of our lives. Our rapidly aging population, and the upcoming wealth transfer from the Baby Boomers to their children and grandchildren. The state of the healthcare system in the United States.</p><p>Now, to be sure, there are many older members of Congress who care deeply about these issues. They worry about the impact it will have on their descendants. At the same time, for how long will they experience these shifts? Will they really have to live with these changes? There’s a certain level of “skin in the game” which does not exist for those who will not be around to experience changing realities.</p><p>I believe we want politicians who are going to really live through what will eventually be history, and watch it unfold in front of them. They know that the lives of their children will also be directly impacted.</p><p><strong>There Are Other Ways To Serve The Public Outside Elected Office</strong></p><p>It’s not as if elected office is the only way someone can give back to their community. Older adults with a political bent engage in all sorts of public service — from being in think tanks to serving in board or other leadership roles in a range of non-profits and community organizations. There are so many needs in our world, and thus myriad ways to give back.</p><p>Despite the issues I’ve outlined above in terms of physical and mental changes, the experience and wisdom of older people, particularly those who held public office, is very valuable. We should not think of a life of political involvement narrowly, solely in terms of holding political office. If anything, those who are no longer in office might be freer to candidly express their views, thus improving the public’s understanding of our system. There’s no reason to think we’re discarding the collective wisdom of elected officials (don’t laugh — I’m serious), by imposing age limits.</p><p><strong>The Final Word</strong></p><p>Aging isn’t easy. Neither is governing. While I can certainly understand the desire of long-serving politicians to continue in office, the truth is that we have larger national interests to think about. With consequential decisions on the line, we need the most engaged, capable leadership we can find. Age restrictions are the way to achieve this.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8ffd136df6a4" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A Few Ways AI Will Change The Practice Of Law]]></title>
            <link>https://shivagbhaskar.medium.com/a-few-ways-ai-will-change-the-practice-of-law-e3e55a4f84e0?source=rss-278afcac6ec5------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e3e55a4f84e0</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[innovation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[legal-services]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[legal-innovation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[law]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ai]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Shiva Bhaskar]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 08 Jun 2025 15:38:18 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-06-08T15:38:18.492Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/550/1*QUohmRz4bhldqtscqJunmw.png" /><figcaption>Photo Credit: Clio</figcaption></figure><p>In the years to come, artificial intelligence will change just about every industry. 10 years ago, that might have been a bold assertion.</p><p>Today, in the era of ChatGPT, Perplexity and more, it’s not only becoming increasingly simpler to obtain information, but to complete a range of more complex tasks. Things are changing very quickly.</p><p>As an attorney, I am intrigued by how artificial intelligence will change the legal field. Below are some of the key areas where I believe AI will really make it’s mark. This has both positive implications, as well as the potential challenges it poses to society.</p><p><strong>Full Automation of Complaint Preparation</strong></p><p>When you sue someone, you file a complaint. The complaint is the paper which outlines how a plaintiff (the person suing) was harmed, and why this is a violation of the law. The complaint also outlines what the plaintiff is seeking, in terms of relief or compensation. A complaint is based both on the facts of a case, as well as how the laws treat that set of facts.</p><p>In many areas of law, complaints across cases are very similar. That is, the pattern of facts which result in a violation of the law tend to be similar. To a degree, this allows you to substitute in a set of facts, apply the law, and create a lawsuit.</p><p>Software like <a href="http://www.gavel.io/">Gavel</a> already allows attorneys to fill out a legal complaint, based on answering a series of questions, and filling in the appropriate facts. Soon, I imagine that Gavel, or perhaps another software, will simply use a voice transcription prepared by an attorney, or turn a client interview into a complaint. This will remove the time required to prepare lawsuits and allow lawyers to handle more cases in a shorter amount of time.</p><p>Of course, this has implications beyond just filing cases. Right now, junior attorneys and paralegals play a major role in preparing and filing these complaints. With the ascendancy of AI, the need for such staff may be reduced.</p><p>Additionally, it becomes easier for law firms to file cases. This means that we might see more frivolous cases filed. If the cost of doing something is reduced, producing more of it becomes considerably easier. That can lead to oversupply, i.e. the filing of too many cases.</p><p><strong>Case Filing</strong></p><p>Filling out a case complaint can be a complex matter. However, the actual filing of a case is much easier.</p><p>There is a specific set of repeatable steps that are typically followed to get a complaint properly submitted to a court and then served to a defendant. How a case should be filed depends on the venue where it is to be filed (state or federal court) as well as the specific type of case (there are many different sorts of civil cases). All that information can be gleaned from the complaint and other filing documents. Thus, using AI to extract the required information, and filing the case on it’s own, should be fairly simple.</p><p><strong>Making Discovery Responses Easier</strong></p><p>Any attorney who’s been involved in a lawsuit which made it beyond the very earliest stages knows that discovery is one of the most involved aspects of the case. In discovery, each side asks the opposing side for information. This means that they’re not only requesting information but also providing quite a bit of information.</p><p>What is requested in discovery will vary, depending on the type of case. Each attorney will be seeking information which helps prove their case. They might also have to provide information which ultimately weakens their arguments.</p><p>Preparing discovery requests can be complex — but not always. In more complex cases, it requires gathering information from the plaintiff or defendant.</p><p>However, quite often, it simply requires scanning documents from the existing case file, and publicly available data, to extract answers. In some instances, a party will object to answering a question, on grounds such as it being protected by attorney client privilege, or irrelevant, or unduly burdensome to answer.</p><p>Given a large enough data set, AI can easily accomplish all of this. AI can be trained by the work of several or more attorneys, each handling their own cases. As attorneys submit answers to discovery requests and provide the software with the sources they use to answer those questions, AI will continually improve at answering these requests. At the same time, AI will learn from their objections.</p><p>This isn’t a seamless process. After AI observes a particular attorney’s discovery process for a while and pulls in its knowledge of the techniques used by other attorneys, it will have a coherent idea of what needs to be done. Of course, the attorney will still need to provide feedback to the AI-generated responses. Yet, the power of AI lies in it’s ability to learn — and the discovery process is ripe for this.</p><p><strong>Jury Selection</strong></p><p>It’s no secret that in the biggest civil cases (let’s set aside criminal trials for a moment), a jury might ultimately decide the outcome. This means that the individuals who sit on this jury often have considerable power. For this reason, the stakes for choosing the right jurors are quite high. This isn’t to say that the merits of the case don’t matter (of course they do) — but telling a case</p><p>Right now, lawyers have a few options. One is to hire a jury consultant. While some are very effective, they’re often not cheap — and not always good. Another strategy is to rely on one’s hard-earned knowledge, through years of selecting jurors, and successfully trying cases. While some lawyers excel in this area, it is far from foolproof.</p><p>I don’t see jury consultants going anywhere. Jury consultants often play a key role in cases, even after a jury has been seated.</p><p>However, I suspect that both jury consultants, as well as attorneys working on their own, could benefit from the use of artificial intelligence. In the excellent 2003 film <em>The Runaway Jury, </em>the late Gene Hackman acts as a nefarious but skilled jury consultant, leading a team which is trying to sway the outcome in a high-profile gun liability lawsuit. Without giving away too much (it’s an excellent movie — watch it), Hackman assembles a hi-tech, largely illegal operation, to gather as much information as possible about jurors, and manipulate the outcome of the case.</p><p>Setting aside the legal ramifications of Hackman’s conduct, the practice of gathering information on jurors (especially in civil cases) to predict how they will vote, is time-tested. How might AI impact this?</p><p>Collecting social media and other information on potential jurors is already quite common. However, AI opens a whole new world of data — both individually, and at a more aggregate level. By knowing an individual’s name and a few other details, quite a bit of information can be gleaned.</p><p>For example, how do people who live in a certain zip code, drive a particular car, and work in a certain job, tend to perceive a particular issue? <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/ai-jury-selection-striking-right-balance-between-erik-hoogerhuis-4dmvc/">Mock trials</a> with similar types of jurors, in the same sorts of cases, can be used to generate better profiles of potential jurors, based on people like them. Tones of voice and facial expressions, which are already considered by jury consultants, might be further honed with AI, to better <a href="https://www.infotrack.com/blog/ai-jury-selection/">predict outcomes</a>.</p><p>To be sure, there are real risks to the use of AI in jury selection. <a href="https://www.uscourts.gov/educational-resources/educational-activities/participate-judicial-process-rule-law">Race and ethnicity</a>, as well as <a href="https://www.reuters.com/legal/us-supreme-court-declines-decide-legality-excluding-jurors-based-religion-2024-02-20/#:~:text=US%20Supreme%20Court%20declines%20to%20decide%20legality,excluding%20jurors%20based%20on%20religion%20%7C%20Reuters.&amp;text=State%20officials%20conceded%20that%20prospective%20jurors%20could,they%20adhere%2C%20caused%20them%20to%20be%20biased.">religion</a> (though perhaps not religious beliefs) and <a href="https://www.oyez.org/cases/1974/73-5744">gender</a> are forbidden as considerations when considering (or excluding) a juror. It is possible that AI will pull some of this information into it’s jury selection models. This is obviously not permissible. The ethical challenges around this approach will have to be figured out. However, it’s clear that AI’s ability to synthesize information and make decisions, could prove to be powerful for lawyers.</p><p><strong>Contract Preparation</strong></p><p>Thus far, I have focused quite a bit on civil litigation. However, within transactional law, and more specifically the field of contract preparation, there is certainly room for AI-driven innovation.</p><p>At this point in American history (let alone world history), humans have been preparing agreements for thousands of years. As a result, we’ve built quite a repository of legal agreements.</p><p>It’s true that each legal situation is slightly different. Yet, AI has a powerful (and growing) ability to make sense of vast troves of data and situations and improve over time.</p><p>Here’s the thing with legal agreements: The only way they’re really tested, is when a legal dispute happens, and thus an agreement goes bad. At that point, the strength (or lack of strength) of the agreement will be tested in court.</p><p>For this reason, any AI-based contract preparation system should make use of case law, to see where contracts have commonly gone wrong — and avoid those pitfalls. It is possible to gain a deep understanding of how particular contracts resulted in certain outcomes in cases.</p><p>There are companies which are doing very interesting work in this space.<a href="https://ironcladapp.com/"> Ironclad</a> comes to mind, but there are others.</p><p><strong>Hiring An Attorney</strong></p><p>Most of the applications we’ve reviewed thus far pertain to use cases within law firms. However, I see a few ways through which attorney hiring might be improved, using artificial intelligence.</p><p><a href="http://www.avvo.com/">Avvo</a> has played an interesting role in aggregating details about attorneys, and allowing lawyers to showcase themselves, and collect reviews. Of course, there is a bias to the data. After all, a lawyer might request reviews from clients, which does not truly showcase the quality of that attorney.</p><p>Here’s a rough idea of how AI might solve this problem. Let’s say a potential client is looking for a personal injury lawyer. An AI could pull in court filings, how long an attorney has been practicing, reviews from various sources, and more, to give that attorney a score. To further optimize the algorithm, the AI could solicit some information about a client’s specific case, to assess how it meshes with an attorney’s experience.</p><p>There is more required to hone this approach. With that said, there is enough information about attorneys out there, especially in litigation-related fields, to generate a better score of an attorney’s performance. This helps empower consumers.</p><p><strong>The Final Word</strong></p><p>AI is going to change so many things in our world. As a lawyer, it is natural to wonder how my field will be impacted.</p><p>While I can’t predict the full trajectory (likely, none of us can) I think the innovations detailed above will come into greater focus. How this impacts attorney hiring remains another open question. What we can be certain of is that dramatic change is coming.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e3e55a4f84e0" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Why We Need Small Landlords]]></title>
            <link>https://shivagbhaskar.medium.com/why-we-need-small-landlords-1edf6b4152f6?source=rss-278afcac6ec5------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/1edf6b4152f6</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[real-estate]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[multifamily]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[economics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[landlords]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Shiva Bhaskar]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 16 Mar 2025 22:51:56 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-03-16T22:51:56.356Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Why We Need Small Landlords</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/880/1*HM3Wm0TCs0-guHHpGD3Hag.jpeg" /><figcaption>Photo Credit: The Salinas Californian</figcaption></figure><p>Consolidation. It’s a specter in many industries. We visualize a few large players controlling the market, and raising prices, while reducing the quality of goods and services offered.</p><p>For residential rental properties, particularly single-family homes, there has been a lot of buzz around the idea of a few large landlords controlling the entire market. During recent years, both current vice president <a href="https://x.com/JDVance/status/1402608156254117894">JD Vance</a>, as well as previous vice president Kamala Harris, raised concerns about Wall Street firms buying homes, and pricing homebuyers (and perhaps even renters) out of the market.</p><p>There is some validity to these concerns. Yet, despite all the hype, institutional investors are not buying up the entire single-family home market. Most research <a href="https://www.foxbusiness.com/markets/wall-street-spent-billions-buying-homes-a-crackdown-is-looming">suggests that</a> large investors (those who own over 1,000 homes) control around 3% to 5% of all American rental homes. Of course, in some areas, <a href="https://nlihc.org/resource/gao-releases-report-institutional-investments-single-family-rental-housing#:~:text=GAO%20estimates%20that%20institutional%20investors,a%20lower%20cost%20than%20homeownership.">such as</a> Atlanta, Jacksonville, Charlotte and Tampa, ownership by large landlords is even more common.</p><p>Regardless of how common corporate ownership of homes is, the reality is that it is here and may become more common in the future. The same is true, of course, of smaller multifamily properties. All of this raises a question: Are small landlords important? Do they still have a role to play in the rental real estate ecosystem?</p><p>My answer is yes. Here’s why.</p><p><strong>Defining Small Landlords</strong></p><p>Whenever we discuss something, it is best if we first figure out and define what exactly we’re talking about. To me, small landlords are those who own 4 or fewer rental properties, and/or a total of no more than 20 rental units. Some may have a broader definition of what a small landlord is, but this seems fair to me.</p><p>Most of these landlords are not full-time real estate investors. They often (though not always) manage their properties in house, and answer their clients’ calls directly.</p><p><strong>Small Landlords Are More Likely To Live Near And Care About The Communities Where Their Properties Are Located</strong></p><p>If we take a look at the <a href="https://www.nmhc.org/research-insight/the-nmhc-50/top-50-lists/2023-top-owners-list/">largest landlords</a> in the United States (by unit count), we find that they are scattered in a wide variety of locations. Yet, many of them control properties across multiple states.</p><p>Are they invested in the wellbeing of the communities where they operate? Many, not all, might be. However, do they really know those communities? Have they ever attended a high school football game there, or gone shopping at a local market? Do they understand the needs and aspirations of this place?</p><p>All too often, the answer is no. Now, one might wonder, does this matter? To effectively operate and manage a property, do you need to live in a particular community?</p><p>Not necessarily. However, there is a level of skin in the game that comes from some shared sense of place — if not within the same neighborhood, then the same metropolitan region. At some level, you’re all in it together.</p><p>Smaller landlords, especially for single family rental homes, tend to be local owners. This creates a greater sense of alignment and investment.</p><p><strong>More Small Landlords Prevents Excessive Consolidation in The Rental Market</strong></p><p>One of the most important figures in American jurisprudence was Louis Brandeis. Brandeis was a lawyer who eventually ascended to the Supreme Court (where he served for over 20 years). One of the areas where Brandeis produced a great deal of original scholarship was around the topics of corporate consolidation, corporate power, and antitrust law. One of his most famous works was <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Curse-Bigness-Miscellaneous-Papers-Brandeis/dp/B000NLDC2Y">titled</a> “The Curse of Bigness.” In recent years, Brandeis’ work has made a comeback, in part thanks to former FTC chair <a href="https://prospect.org/justice/new-brandeis-movement-has-its-moment-justice-department-antitrust-jonathan-kanter/">Lina Khan</a> and others.</p><p>To be sure, I don’t agree with everything Brandeis says. However, I do think he was correct about some important points — most importantly, his wariness towards large entities. In real estate, there are real risks posed by large landlords, who buy up a large portion of the housing stock in any area. For one, they become the market in those areas. Their ability to set prices only grows stronger. This is especially true in areas where development is challenging, and the existing housing stock remains limited (I’m looking at you, California and New York).</p><p>That is not all. Larger landlords, especially those with many holdings concentrated in a given area, enjoy greater leverage over vendors. After all, if you’re a plumber, electrician or general contractor, you want to earn the business of these large players. Failure to do so could leave you merely competing for scraps.</p><p>This means they have greater ability to push your earnings per job down. Given that most operations in the building trade are small businesses, this consolidation means that, by definition, the earnings of these companies are constrained. While no one is entitled to high earnings and large profit margins, a diversity of thriving construction businesses creates more jobs, and is in general a major positive.</p><p>With smaller landlords, by definition, no one owner controls the entire market in any area. As a result, they’re not able to excessively sway vendor prices, or rents, to their advantage.</p><p>To be sure, there are advantages to larger landlords. Perhaps most prominently, they tend to be better capitalized, and thus more able to improve properties. At the same time, there’s a clear solution to that: Find ways to make capital more accessible to smaller property owners, to allow them to improve properties.</p><p><strong>Small Landlords Build Wealth &amp; Generate Additional Income, Which Reduces Income &amp; Wealth Inequality</strong></p><p>Income inequality is a hot topic of discussion across the United States. Income inequality has increased <a href="https://www.pewresearch.org/social-trends/2020/01/09/trends-in-income-and-wealth-inequality/">markedly</a> since 1980. Wealth inequality is even <a href="https://www.usatoday.com/story/money/2024/10/24/americas-richest-10-percent-controls-60-percent-of-wealth/75790850007/">starker</a>, with the top 1% of households holding 27% of all wealth, while the top 10% held 60% of all wealth in 2022. While we can debate the causes and ultimate impact of income inequality, the reality is that it exists.</p><p>Income inequality appears to have a range of negative consequences for society. It appears to <a href="https://www.epi.org/publication/secular-stagnation/">slow</a> economic growth, reduce <a href="https://www.epi.org/publication/inequalitys-drag-on-aggregate-demand/#:~:text=Most%20obviously%2C%20the%20rise%20in,%2C%20higher%2Dincome%20households).">consumer spending</a>,</p><p>How do small landlords tie into this? To be sure, it is quite tough (likely impossible) for a low-income individual to purchase rental property. However, for middle class people who can save (and perhaps supplement their income through additional work), it is possible to buy a single-family rental home. Another option is to pool funds with friends or relatives and buy properties together. For generations, this has been a means for immigrants to build a stronger financial base.</p><p>Over time, that property should generate cash flow. It also (probably) will appreciate over time. As the years go by, the owner of this property has built additional wealth.</p><p>This chips away at the wealth gap. That is especially true when an older landlord either sells a property (and passes money on to his or her heirs) or passes on the property (allowing the next generation to start with a leg up and partake in the benefits of real estate ownership).</p><p><strong>More Small Landlords Creates Greater Investment in The American System Of Private Property &amp; Capitalism</strong></p><p>I will make a shocking admission, coming from a landlord: I’m not a socialist. In fact, I am in favor of (regulated) capitalism. I think that capitalism has been one of the critical ingredients in the American miracle.</p><p>To be sure, capitalism is not perfect. Sometimes, it indeed falls short. Yet, in the aggregate, it works better than any of the available alternatives.</p><p>Given this belief, I probably will not surprise you when I say that a continued belief in the importance of capitalism (though with regulations) is, to my mind, a good thing. More widespread rental property ownership, and the resulting wealth that is built, helps facilitate a belief in our capitalist system. After all, profitable rental property ownership rarely happens under socialism.</p><p>Why is this so important? Well, a majority of younger Americans (those in Gen Z) hold a <a href="https://www.newsweek.com/majority-gen-z-americans-hold-negative-views-capitalism-poll-1604334">negative view</a> of capitalism. 54% of those in Gen Z hold a negative view of capitalism, while 42% view it favorably. At the same time, favorable views of socialism seem to have risen. While the portion of people who view socialism positively has had a modest decline in the past few years, <a href="https://www.pewresearch.org/politics/2022/09/19/modest-declines-in-positive-views-of-socialism-and-capitalism-in-u-s/">over 30%</a> of Americans view socialism somewhat or very positively. Of course, those numbers are likely higher amongst Gen Z.</p><p>Becoming a landlord means you have skin in the game. You pay property taxes. At a basic level, you want to see continuing economic growth and prosperity. You’ll support the preservation of property rights. You want to see a functioning system when it comes to the rule of law. You’re quite unlikely to have a nihilistic, “destroy the system” attitude.</p><p>When we have too many large landlords (and fewer smaller ones), fewer Americans have skin in the game of our economic system. This leads to (understandable) frustration with the system. As a result, socialism and similar proposals appear increasingly attractive.</p><p><strong>Small Landlords Support A Greater Range Of Local Businesses, Further Stimulating Economic Growth</strong></p><p>Earlier, I noted that the dominance of a few large landlords in an area, would afford them greater leeway in negotiations with vendors, such as plumbers, electricians and general contractors. This ultimately could put downwards pricing pressure on these businesses. It might ultimately thin the ranks of these independent companies.</p><p>Small landlords act as a bulwark against such consolidation. However, it’s not just the building trades which benefit from the presence of small landlords.</p><p>Every small landlord needs an insurance agent / broker to help secure their assets. Since most rental properties are acquired with a mortgage (vs solely with cash), landlords are typically working either with independent mortgage brokers, or loan officers at banks.</p><p>Small landlords might also hire property management companies. These businesses, at least the ones that serve small landlords, are overwhelmingly small operations.</p><p>Each person who works in these businesses provides for themselves, and quite possibly for a family as well. Their earnings go back into our economy in a myriad of ways. Consolidation threatens these earnings. Once again, small landlords have an important role to play.</p><p><strong>The Final Word</strong></p><p>Residential rental real estate, as a business, is controversial. As rents have risen considerably in recent years, and consolidation has spread throughout the industry, it’s quite likely that this won’t change.</p><p>Despite the stereotype of landlords as large corporations, the truth is that small landlords are a <a href="https://www.nar.realtor/blogs/economists-outlook/mom-and-pop-business-owners-day-landlords-of-small-rental-properties#:~:text=Among%2049.5%20million%20rental%20housing,mom%2Dand%2Dpop%20landlords.">large part</a> of the rental marketplace. They have a vital role to play. Hopefully, that continues into the future.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=1edf6b4152f6" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[8 Lessons Learned From Starting & Growing My Own Business]]></title>
            <link>https://shivagbhaskar.medium.com/8-lessons-learned-from-starting-growing-my-own-business-85c54352b674?source=rss-278afcac6ec5------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/85c54352b674</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[enterpreneurship]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[leadership]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[business]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Shiva Bhaskar]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 08 Feb 2025 16:10:29 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-02-08T16:10:29.469Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/940/1*bOcbCSBwbGu4frPJym99ag.png" /><figcaption>Photo Credit: Kathleen Lawson Consulting</figcaption></figure><p>Entrepreneurship. Business ownership. In the American lexicon, these words are hallowed. What comes to mind when we think of these words?</p><p>We might envision a person with boundless energy, a creative mind, strong leadership abilities, and an inextinguishable desire to win. Perhaps we think of someone ringing the bell of the New York Stock Exchange, eventually achieving a net worth in the tens of billions of dollars.</p><p>Of course, not every business owner or entrepreneur is a jet-setting billionaire. Many business owners run relatively small firms, generating tens or hundreds of thousands of dollars in revenue each year. This is often enough to live a good life — but we’d hardly consider such folks wealthy.</p><p>Whatever sort of business someone runs, they’ve learned some lessons along the way. There are peaks and troughs.</p><p>Sometimes, it feels like you’re growing at an unfathomable pace. No one can stop you. In other moments, it feels as if getting the cash register to ring is nigh impossible.</p><p>I run my own business. More specifically, I own and operate a law firm, along with a firm that assists consumers dealing with credit issues. These two businesses function hand in hand.</p><p>Over the past 7+ years, I’ve learned numerous lessons while running these businesses. Below, I’ve shared 8 of the most important ones.</p><p><strong>It Takes Longer Than You Think It Will</strong></p><p>I remember it like it was yesterday. I was sitting with my business partner at a coffee shop. We had just incorporated and launched our firm a few months earlier. We were sitting there and discussing what we’d pay ourselves in 12 months, as well as how many referral partners we would have, sending us cases.</p><p>It took us several years to hit both of those numbers. What’s more, this wasn’t the last time that things ran longer than expected. Now, was this because of our ineptitude?</p><p>To be sure, you don’t know what you don’t know. In retrospect, there were quite a few things we could have done better.</p><p>With that said, even properly executed plans take longer than predicted, to reach fruition. If you want something done in 4 months, assume it will take more like 6 months — maybe even 10 to 12 months.</p><p>Now, there are levels to this. A more experienced business owner might have hit these milestones sooner. Perhaps they were more effective at getting things done. Or maybe they simply knew where to direct their energy, and how to make certain things a priority.</p><p>Often, they might have had the right team around them. In the early days, the team was solely my business partner and I. If we wanted something done, we had to look to ourselves.</p><p>For these reasons, project the growth of your business conservatively, and give yourself lots of runway. You want to ensure you have enough money saved, and that you can survive, to thrive and grow another day.</p><p><strong>Reviews Are A Great Way To Build Trust</strong></p><p>Depending on the sort of business you’re in, it’s quite possible that you operate in a crowded marketplace. Some of your competitors may have a great reputation — and many may not.</p><p>Maybe you’re in a less crowded vertical. The service you offer is not widely known, or as well established.</p><p>In either situation, your reputation is key. In most marketplaces with extensive competition, there are some unsavory actors. Sometimes, their bad reputation is not entirely deserved. Often, the truth lies somewhere in between.</p><p>If people trust your business, that goes a long way towards powering your long-term growth. Perhaps the most powerful way that trust is built is when one of your happy customers tells their friends and family about what you offer, and how excellent your product or service is.</p><p>While growing your reputation this way is excellent, it also takes time. You also can’t count on all your clients telling their friends and family about you.</p><p>Reviews are a scalable way to further hone that reputation. When you do a great job for someone, you can get them to tell the world about it, online.</p><p>As people read the reviews from your customers, your reputation grows. While people are sometimes skeptical of reviews (and figure they might be fake), authentic reviews from real customers eventually shine through. When someone has worked with you, and experienced what you offer, there’s a certain vibe to what they say.</p><p>Other people feel and sense it. Can I empirically prove this? Probably not. However, I can tell you that it is real.</p><p>Any time someone had a positive interaction with us, we would ask them for a review. For some of these clients, it simply meant that we had reviewed their credit reports and offered basic advice. For others, they had gone all the way through our process. Either way, we had done something which made them happy.</p><p>If you respond to these reviews, you gain additional benefits. Not only does this push your online ranking up, but your prospects see how engaged you are with your customers. This builds further trust.</p><p>Where should you collect these reviews? We had the most success with Google Business reviews, although Trustpilot also seems to work quite well for national businesses, such as software companies. If your business operates locally or semi-locally, then Google Business offers the geographic benefit of building your reputation in your local area.</p><p><strong>Ask For Referrals From Your Existing Customers</strong></p><p>Along these lines, it is important that you ask your existing customers, whom you’ve effectively serviced, for referrals. These customers can vouch for the quality of what you offer firsthand. However, they may not know that you’re looking for clients and could actively use their help.</p><p>For this reason, you should come out and tell them. How might you do this? Simple: Ask for what you want. Pick up the phone and call your customer or send them an email.</p><p>Find out how they’re doing. Inform them that you are looking for more customers, whom you can serve just as you did for them. Tell them this is important for growing your business. Ask them if they know anyone who could benefit from your services.</p><p>Don’t hesitate to be vulnerable. Tell them that it would mean a lot, and that you could use it. That vulnerability makes people want to help.</p><p>I would come right out and tell our customers that we were a growing business. We had some wonderful customers — but not nearly enough. We could use their help in meeting more people whom we could work with.</p><p><strong>Write Useful Content (And Make Videos) About What You Offer</strong></p><p>People use the Internet to find out all sorts of useful (and not so useful) information. You should use this to your advantage. How?</p><p>First, start writing about the products and services you offer. Where? The best place to start is your website. Write about how to solve the sorts of problems which your customers often run into. For example, if you run an accounting firm which focuses on serving real estate investors, you might write an article about a specific tax deduction they can take advantage of.</p><p>Make your content extremely in-depth. How do you do this? Are you a physical therapist who knows specific exercises that someone could do at home to improve their posture? If so, you might consider including diagrams, with detailed descriptions of these exercises. You could also create a video of you doing the exercise with a client or model.</p><p>What if you’re a CPA, and you have a tip regarding tax deductions? Here, you might consider including screenshots of a tax return and other documents, along with a detailed how-to article. You could also use Zoom or another platform to record a video where you share a screen with the relevant documents and explain that to do.</p><p>The point is you need to engage your audience with clear examples, videos, and strong written content. People learn in different ways, and you need to meet them where they are.</p><p>How did we go about this? Early on, we shot videos on Facebook Live. Looking back, that is something which we should have continued, since it compounds over time. We would write about credit reporting issues on our website, which over time attracted more clients. We simply focused on making our content clearer, simpler, and more actionable. As that happened, the reception we received continued to improve.</p><p><strong>Early On, Don’t Worry Too Much About Accounting &amp; Corporate Structuring</strong></p><p>This might sound like sacrilege, coming from an attorney. However, hear me out.</p><p>When you first start a business, you have many different competing priorities. However, your most pressing task is to generate customers. With that, you have a viable business.</p><p>Without it, you merely have an aspiration. While admirable, it doesn’t generate revenue.</p><p>What does this have to do with accounting and the corporate setup of your company? Well, as a newer business owner, it is common to worry about how your business is set up (in terms of corporate structure) and spend time stressing over your corporate structure. You might also have concerns over taxes and earnings, and want to invest in hiring a CPA, bookkeeper and so on. After all, no one wants trouble with the IRS.</p><p>Here is the issue: That isn’t very important at such an early stage. You’re not making that much money. Your tax liability is not high. In fact, you might be losing money.</p><p>If you can maintain a strong focus on acquiring and serving customers, you’re going to grow. This will ensure that you’re eventually in a position where your corporate structure and taxes matter more. At that stage, you should invest in proper professional help.</p><p>Now, there are a few caveats I must add. First, please note that I said, “matters more.” I did not say “does not matter at all.”</p><p>You should invest in basic tracking of your expenses, even if it’s just an Excel spreadsheet. That is important to make sure that you’ve got your expenses and earnings in order.</p><p>Along those lines, using simple tax filing software, rather than a CPA, might make sense. This is what we did.</p><p>Was it messy? Sure. Did your CPA not like it later? Absolutely? However, the actual amount of earnings at that stage wasn’t much — and neither was the time we spent on it.</p><p><strong>Listen Carefully to Customer Feedback — But Not Too Much</strong></p><p>If you want your product to improve you need to listen carefully to the people who are paying for your product or service. However, here is something to keep in mind: You can’t listen to them too much.</p><p>Your product needs to deliver meaningful value to your customers. Without that, in the long run, you will not have business.</p><p>You can gather customer feedback in a few ways. One is by observing your customers, and by watching how they use your product or service. Observing customer behavior can take multiple forms.</p><p>If your product is software, you have built in mechanisms to check which features your customers are making use of, and how often. This helps guide you on which aspects of your product or service are most useful — and which are not.</p><p>Secondly, you can talk to your customers and break down each part of the customer experience. Find out how your customers found it to use your product or service, from start to finish.</p><p>For example, if you run a plumbing company, you might ask about each step of the process. How did booking an appointment with your team go? How did the customer feel about how long the job took, and how you (or your team) assessed the problem? Did they feel you were courteous? Did the explanations they were given make sense? How did they feel about pricing, relative to the value they received.</p><p>In this process, you want to ask lots of open-ended questions. Get your customers to talk in more detail. As they explain their experience, you’ll have a better understanding of whether the product or service you’re delivering is what the market needs. If you are falling short in some way, you now have a chance to improve.</p><p>Now, here is where it gets tricky. Let’s say that rather than asking open-ended questions, you ask your customers for suggestions. More specifically, you ask them what sorts of products or services they wish you offered. This is especially true for software products, where you might program additional features.</p><p>There’s a good chance that you’ll be provided with a laundry list worth of items. People will offer all sorts of things they would like to see.</p><p>The question is, will they use and pay for it? We used to regularly receive suggestions, for everything from offering mortgage and insurance services, to (not surprisingly) reducing our prices. If we had followed each of these ideas, we would have gone in 100 different directions — and perhaps succeeded at none of them.</p><p>The point is, you need to take in feedback, while staying focused on your core vision. Otherwise, you will find yourself spinning in too many different directions.</p><p><strong>Find The Others — &amp; Don’t View Them As Competition</strong></p><p>I can’t take even an iota of credit for the header above. Seth Godin’s podcast had an <a href="https://shows.acast.com/akimbo/episodes/find-the-others-e">episode</a> with the above title. From what I can tell, this quote <a href="https://www.goodreads.com/quotes/514216-admit-it-you-aren-t-like-them-you-re-not-even-close">originated</a> from Timothy Leary.</p><p>Either way, it’s a great quote. At it’s core, this is about finding those who are unique in the way that you are and perhaps see the world somewhat as you do. Even if they don’t, they think differently.</p><p>If you run a business, the road can sometimes feel lonely. You are your own company, and early on, you might not have colleagues. You’re not quite sure what you’re doing.</p><p>For this reason, it makes sense to connect with other folks who are in a similar situation. Perhaps these folks run a business like yours. Maybe they operate in a completely different vertical. Either way, at one level or another, you’re all on a journey together.</p><p>This is why you should get to know these others. You can support each other.</p><p>You’ll share triumphs and struggles. You can exchange ideas, strategies and contacts. In my case, joining a group of business owners through an organization called Preferred Networking is my group of others. We are each in different fields, yet we find an overlap in terms of needs and insights.</p><p>I also am in a few groups for folks who are in the credit restoration / credit law industry. Here, we share tactics and strategies which we think are relevant, as well as concerns around regulatory issues. I’ve gained invaluable insights from these conversations.</p><p>The reality is, for some business owners, this is uncomfortable. They feel as if they might be giving up valuable secrets or simply wasting their time.</p><p>I know this myself, because I’ve experienced those feelings of doubt and insecurity before. Yet, I have found that the rewards far outweigh the risks.</p><p>I think this is a counterproductive mindset. Ultimately, you miss out on good opportunities.</p><p><strong>Focus On Your Niche — But See Opportunities Just Beyond It</strong></p><p>Ricky Gervais once noted that if you’re for everyone, you’re for no one. In business, this is certainly a cogent argument.</p><p>There are law firms which assert that they have expertise in numerous practice areas. If you go on their website, they handle immigration, divorce, estate planning and more.</p><p>Now, if there are multiple attorneys at the firm, this could make sense. Each will have expertise in certain practice areas.</p><p>Yet, what if we just have one person doing all of this. How would that work?</p><p>It probably would not be optimal, from a perspective of specialization. There’s only so much that anyone can know (or do) on a particular topic.</p><p>For this reason, you should aim to pick one area of focus — and dive deep into it. Let the world know you’re good at this niche and keep growing.</p><p>This is what we’ve done, in the world of addressing credit reporting errors. We became good at one thing — and built a reputation around that.</p><p>Within our niche of consumer credit, there are closely related fields, which offer interesting opportunities. Debt collection lawsuit defense is one, as is bankruptcy, and a third is suing debt collection agencies which harass consumers.</p><p>We’ve kept a close eye on those fields. We have business partners whom we send these cases to, because that is their niche. We explore ways to tie the sort of work they do, together with what we offer. If that is not possible, we simply stay in our lane.</p><p>In short, we find opportunities beyond our core focus — without losing sight of our main mission. This is a tough balance to strike — but it is worth it.</p><p><strong>The Final Word</strong></p><p>Building your own business is, without a doubt, one of the ultimate growth experiences. At the same time, it is a challenging, at times trying experience.</p><p>The lessons I’ve detailed above came to us through hard-fought experience. I hope they help you in your journey.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=85c54352b674" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Non-Attorney Ownership Of Law Firms Should Be Allowed. Here’s Why]]></title>
            <link>https://shivagbhaskar.medium.com/non-attorney-ownership-of-law-firms-should-be-allowed-heres-why-f65de77f6148?source=rss-278afcac6ec5------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f65de77f6148</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[law]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[law-firm]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[innovation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[business]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[attorney]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Shiva Bhaskar]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 30 Dec 2024 00:05:23 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-12-30T00:05:23.418Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*jePYiuOZgAAuxPSd" /><figcaption>Photo Credit: Bill Tilley — LinkedIn</figcaption></figure><p><em>Note: The author is a practicing attorney with his own law firm</em></p><p><a href="https://www.clio.com/blog/can-non-lawyer-own-firm/#:~:text=Can%20a%20non%2Dlawyer%20own%20a%20law%20firm%20in%20the,Columbia%2C%20Arizona%2C%20and%20Utah.">In around</a> 90% of states (<a href="https://www.americanbar.org/groups/law_practice/resources/law-practice-magazine/2024/2024-january-february/extending-the-practice-of-nonlawyer-owned-law-firms/">except for</a> Utah, Arizona, and Washington DC), non-attorney ownership in law firms, or a non-attorney receiving legal fees (with a few small exceptions), is forbidden. There are reasons for this (mainly ethical concerns0 — and they’re not entirely invalid.</p><p>However, there are approaches to address those concerns, without taking an overly draconian approach to non-attorney ownership of law firms. The practice of law, perhaps deliberately, is an area where change is quite slow.</p><p>Ultimately, the delivery of legal services is ripe for change — and such change can ultimately benefit clients of law firms, and the public. Non-attorney ownership in law firms is an idea whose time has come.</p><p><strong>Arguments Against Non-Attorney Ownership Of Law Firms</strong></p><p><a href="https://www.americanbar.org/groups/professional_responsibility/publications/model_rules_of_professional_conduct/rule_5_4_professional_independence_of_a_lawyer/">Rule 5.4</a> of the American Bar Association’s (ABA) Model Rules of Professional Conduct states that non-attorneys and attorneys may not form a partnership, for the purposes of practicing law. There are exceptions to this, including compensation and retirement plans for non-attorney employees of a law firm.</p><p>Why do these rules exist? There are multiple reasons. Stephen Younger, former president of the New York State Bar Association, wrote an interesting <a href="https://www.yalelawjournal.org/forum/the-pitfalls-and-false-promises-of-nonlawyer-ownership-of-law-firms">piece</a> in the Yale Law Journal, opposing non-attorney ownership in law firms. Let’s examine some of the arguments Mr. Younger advances.</p><p>For this discussion, it’s helpful to understand the term Non-Lawyer Ownership (NLO), meaning allowing non-lawyers to own shares in law firms. Younger argues that</p><p><em>“…lawyers’ opposition to NLO stems principally from a steadfast commitment to professionalism and the ethical practice of law that leads many lawyers to draw the line at forbidding nonlawyers, who may have interests that are at odds with their clients, from owning or running legal practices</em>.”</p><p>Younger notes that attorneys cannot become members of the bar without passing the Multistate Professional Responsibility Exam (MPRE), an exam every attorney must pass, which focuses exclusively on attorney ethics. He also points out that attorneys can be suspended or disbarred from the practice of law, if they violate rules. Younger (correctly) notes that potential non-attorney partners in a law firm do not undergo such ethics training.</p><p>Younger also highlights important concerns around non-attorneys providing legal advice — and how clients understand such advice. He notes that sometimes it’s not even a person, but rather a chatbot or another technology, offering legal advice.</p><p>How consumers understand such advice, particular when it cannot take into account the nuances of each legal situation, is an important question which Younger raises. He brings up a hypothetical situation, where a potential client asks an online chatbot if it should get a divorce — and does not receive a nuanced answer, as the situation may require.</p><p>Younger also worries that non-attorneys enjoying ownership shares in law firms, creates the potential for various conflicts. Younger points out that a non-attorney partner might push for a settlement in a case, in a self-interested manner, rather than what is best for the client. Lastly, he raises serious concerns around how client confidentiality would be protected.</p><p><strong>Non-Attorney Ownership In Law Firms Carries Risks — Which Should Not Be Exaggerated, And Can be Mitigated</strong></p><p>Surprising as this might sound, coming from an advocate of non-attorney ownership in law firms, I believe Younger raises some valid concerns. It’s true that while many non-attorney partners may be ethical people, many may not. There are risks.</p><p>Of course, the same is true of attorneys<a href="https://www.abalegalprofile.com/discipline.html">, thousands of whom</a> are suspended and disbarred every year. We should note that those who are disciplined make up a small portion of all active attorneys — in a typical year, no more than 0.2% to 0.4% of all active attorneys.</p><p>Yet, attorney misconduct erodes public trust in the legal profession. In some cases, it also results in serious <a href="https://www.cbsnews.com/losangeles/news/attorney-tom-girardi-found-guilty-of-wire-fraud-embezzling-more-than-15-million-from-clients/">financial harm</a> for clients.</p><p>There are several measures we can take to help ensure that non-attorney ownership remains in the best interests of clients, and the public as a whole. I’ve shared more details below.</p><p><strong>Non-Attorney Partners Don’t Create Heightened Ethical or Legal Risks For Clients</strong></p><p>There is no indication that non-attorneys are any less ethical than lawyers — or that their participation in law firms is inherently riskier. How do we know this?</p><p>Arizona has <a href="https://www.bloomberglaw.com/external/document/XA9M2V18000000/corporate-compliance-professional-perspective-arizona-non-lawyer">allowed</a> non-attorney ownership in law firms, since early 2021. Such firms are known as Alternative Business Structures (ABS).</p><p>While non-attorneys can make business decisions and share in profits, only attorneys may provide legal services. Also, at least one attorney (known as a compliance attorney) must be a lawyer who is licensed in Arizona.</p><p>Additionally, each ABS must be<a href="https://www.azcourts.gov/accesstolegalservices/Questions-and-Answers/abs"> approved</a> by the Arizona Supreme Court. Such approval includes a full background check of all non-attorney partners. Attorney partners are still bound by all the rules which govern attorney ethics.</p><p>In the time that Arizona has allowed ABS firms, the rate of state bar complaints against ABS firms has been no higher than those against non-ABS firms. In fact, as of June 2022, there had been no complaints <a href="https://law.stanford.edu/wp-content/uploads/2022/09/SLS-CLP-Regulatory-Reform-REPORTExecSum-9.26.pdf">filed</a> against ABS firms.</p><p>While we are almost certain to see more complaints as time goes on (as is true of any business), the dire predictions of Younger and other observers have not come to fruition. One would think that if there were going to be a rash of problems with ABS firms, we’d have seen more evidence of that by now.</p><p>Of course, an ABS skeptic might counter that we need more time. It is still early, the argument would go. Eventually, more problems will surface.</p><p>To test this hypothesis, we should examine data from other nations. More specifically, in the United Kingdom, non-attorney ownership has been operational for about 12 years. Given that the UK is a Western nation with a similar legal system, the British experience is worth considering.</p><p>A <a href="https://law.stanford.edu/wp-content/uploads/2022/09/SLS-CLP-Regulatory-Reform-REPORTExecSum-9.26.pdf">report</a> from Stanford Law School, written by David Engstrom, Lucy Ricca, Graham Ambrose and Maddie Walsh found that opening up ownership structures has not led to a higher level of misconduct and bar complaints. The authors of the report interviewed Jason Chapman, a UK legal ombudsman, responsible for overseeing law firms.</p><p>Chapman found no difference in complaints filed against ABS firms, as compared to traditional law firms. The Stanford report also <a href="https://www.sra.org.uk/">cites</a> a 2018 report from the Solicitors Regulation Authority (SRA), which oversees attorney conduct in England and Wales.</p><p>The SRA found that 32% of all reported allegations against ABS firms fell within the highest level of severely — as compared to 39% of traditional law firms. Should we conclude that traditional law firms pose greater levels of risk to clients than ABS firms?</p><p>I’m not ready to reach that conclusion — but we can say that ABS firms are probably not more dangerous to clients than traditional law firms. In short, there is scant empirical evidence for the hypothesis that non-attorney law firm ownership will impair the ethical duties which attorneys and law firms owe clients.</p><p>The strongest (albeit false) argument advanced by opponents of ABS structures, is the risks to clients, posed by unethical conduct. If we’re taking an evidence-based approach (as any attorney should) that assertion can safely be disposed of.</p><p><strong>Attorney Ethical Obligations Offer A Strong Layer Of Protection Against Attorney Misconduct</strong></p><p>Let’s examine the ethical obligations which attorneys must honor — regardless of whether they have non-attorney partners. These rules offer substantial protection for clients.</p><p>Lawyers <a href="https://www.americanbar.org/groups/professional_responsibility/publications/model_rules_of_professional_conduct/rule_1_7_conflict_of_interest_current_clients/comment_on_rule_1_7/">must</a> determine whether conflicts of interest exist, prior to and during the representation of a client. Conflicts must be avoided, and if they come about, they must be disclosed to all involved clients and resolved appropriately.</p><p>Lawyers also have to keep their client’s information <a href="https://www.americanbar.org/groups/professional_responsibility/publications/model_rules_of_professional_conduct/rule_1_6_confidentiality_of_information/comment_on_rule_1_6/">confidential</a> (with certain very narrow exceptions). This is understandably important. How else can a client be properly represented, if they’re not confident they can share crucial information with their attorney?</p><p>There are numerous other professional rules which lawyers must follow. These rules are designed to protect against not only intentional misbehavior, but also incompetence.</p><p>Failure to follow these regulations can result in a range of negative consequences, including monetary sanctions, as well as the suspension or complete loss of an attorney’s bar license. Let’s not forget about the lasting damage to their reputation.</p><p>Again, no ethical obligation of an attorney is waived, upon forming a partnership with a non-attorney. Those lawyers who fail to uphold the rules might have done so, even if they were not working with someone who isn’t a lawyer.</p><p>This really isn’t an issue of non-attorney involvement. Rather, it’s an issue of ethical vs. unethical attorneys. That is an issue which has always been with us — and exists in every profession.</p><p><strong>Non-Attorney Ownership In Law Firms Allows Law Firms To Grow With Less Risk — Which Stimulates Investment, &amp; Creates Efficiency</strong></p><p>To better understand how non-attorney ownership in law firms can be beneficial, it is helpful to understand how law firms are currently funded. Most law firms are funded through equity provided by their attorney partners, as well as debt from lenders.</p><p>How does equity from partners work? Let’s say that a law firm has five partners, each with 20% ownership in the law firm.</p><p>These five partners might be interested in further expansion, through increasing their marketing efforts. To achieve this, they each agree to put $200K towards marketing efforts ($1 million total) and share in the profits according to their share in the partnership.</p><p>If the $200K does not yield results, that’s a loss the partners will have to face. If it takes several years to see a return from this investment, then the partners will have to wait until that time comes. On the other hand, if this marketing investment is massively successful, then the partners will enjoy considerable profits.</p><p>Let’s compare this to debt. If the five partners take on a $1 million loan, they must start making payments (at least on interest, if not the principal as well) within a few months. This affords them less time to watch their marketing initiatives pay off.</p><p>If the marketing efforts fail to pay off, then the firm, and perhaps even the partners individually (if they signed personal guarantees on the loan), will be liable. The firm might have to cut staff, or even close it’s doors.</p><p>All of this creates disincentives to investment. Or, if investments are made, they’re likely to be smaller and more conservative. In short, the law firm’s partners are forced to put the brakes on their own growth potential.</p><p>Spending on marketing isn’t the only thing a firm might do. Capital can also be used to invest in software and staff, allowing firms to better serve their existing clients.</p><p>Perhaps a firm brings on associates and partners with expertise in a new practice area, which current clients could use help with. This reduces the need for those clients to look for another law firm to serve them.</p><p>It creates greater efficiency. By stimulating hiring and spending, this model also helps power economic growth — not just for the law firm, but society as well.</p><p>Let’s return to our example of the 5 law firm partners. Let’s now imagine that the law firm has a 6th equity partner — an investment firm. This investment group agrees to put up $1 million out of it’s own capital, rather than through a loan.</p><p>In exchange, the investment group earns a sizable share of the profits generated. They take on the risk that this investment doesn’t work out, and $1 million is lost. The other five partners face no personal liability.</p><p>Of course, if it does turn out well, then the investment firm keeps a fair share of the profits — in exchange for the risk they’ve taken on. The other five partners will probably feel more comfortable making this investment, since they’re “risking” their time and effort — but not their capital. All of this drives positive growth and investment, which benefits society as a whole.</p><p><strong>Non-Attorney Ownership In Law Firms Will Allow For Greater Financial Stability</strong></p><p>Writing in the <a href="https://arizonalawreview.org/pdf/65-1/65arizlrev223.pdf">Arizona Law Review</a>, Robert Saavedra Teuton explains in detail how this works. As Teuton notes, a handful of prominent law firms failed in the 2008 financial crisis, in large part due to excessive levels of debt (combined with a drop in demand for services, especially around mergers and debt offerings).</p><p>Equity financing can take a long-term view of a law firm’s prospects. After all, equity financing typically means that an investor need not be paid every month. Rather, they earn a share of the profits generated.</p><p>As a result, if it takes many years for a firm’s growth efforts to pay off, the firm isn’t facing the financial instability associated with paying a loan. Of course, this preserves employment for those who work for law firms — including paralegals, legal assistants, and other non-attorney professionals.</p><p>Debt is not quite so patient. Debt payments (usually) need to be made every month. Otherwise, the creditor can take legal action.</p><p>If a law firm owes too much debt, then it must consider bankruptcy. If a marketing effort, or some other undertaking by a law firm, does not pay off in time, then the firm will find itself in hot water. Equity financing, through non-attorney ownership, creates a longer runway. This will facilitate financial security for law firms (and those who work for them).</p><p><strong>Non-Attorney Ownership Could Lead To Interesting Partnerships, Stimulating Technological Innovation Which Helps Serve Clients &amp; The Public</strong></p><p>We’ve thus far focused on how equity partnerships between attorneys and non-attorneys might lead to greater financial stability, as well as investments which benefit clients. However, there’s another angle (also raised by Teuton in his work) which is worth considering: How might non-attorney partners in law firms facilitate technological innovation?</p><p>Here, some very interesting approaches can take shape. As we know, artificial intelligence is moving forward at a rapid pace. These innovations are rife with opportunities to improve legal practice.</p><p>What might this look like? Imagine a small estate planning law firm partners (through equity and profit-sharing) with a savvy software developer. Together, they build a tool which allows those with simple estate planning matters, to prepare wills through software. For those with complex cases, the attorney can work with the clients directly.</p><p>For those who want greater attorney involvement, they can pay by the hour. Similar solutions can be applied for business transactional matters, such as contract preparation, corporate formation, and real estate matters.</p><p>Here’s a counter to this argument: Why do we need non-attorney ownership of law firms, to facilitate this change? Couldn’t law firms just hire software developers on salary, to help build these products?</p><p>Sure, they could. However, if developers are merely paid salary, and have no chance of realizing the (considerable) upside of such technology, they may not be quite as invested in building a highly creative product. Rather, they’d merely be executing the instructions of the developers. In a fiercely competitive technical employment landscape, this will hinder the efforts of innovative law firms.</p><p>That’s not the only issue. Lawyers’ expertise lies in figuring out legal issues. They are not (usually) experts in product development. By aligning the interests and expertise of attorneys and technology / product people, we can bring about a renaissance in legal innovation.</p><p><strong>Non-Attorney Ownership of Law Firms Might Have A Limited Impact On Legal Access For The Underserved — And That’s OK</strong></p><p>Access to legal services for lower- and middle-income Americans is seriously lacking. Of the <a href="https://law.stanford.edu/2024/06/13/justice-for-all-why-we-have-an-access-to-justice-gap-in-america-and-what-can-we-do-about-it/">20 million</a> civil cases which are filed each year, in ¾ of the cases, at least one side is without an attorney.</p><p>For low income Americans facing legal issues, <a href="https://justicegap.lsc.gov/resource/executive-summary/">92%</a> did not get any or enough legal help for their legal issues. Lower income households often don’t obtain proper help for their issues.</p><p>From debt collection lawsuits to evictions, the need is massive. Legal aid organizations, as well as pro bono efforts by private attorneys, can play a productive role. However, much more work is needed.</p><p>To be clear, I know that access to legal services is a serious issue. I’ve volunteered with legal aid organizations myself. I’m all too familiar with the disheartening reality that the doors of justice often open or close, based mainly on the size of one’s wallet.</p><p>On a more positive note, we should remember that technology is shaping positive outcomes— and will continue to in the future. <a href="http://www.solosuit.com/">Solosuit</a> helps consumers fight debt collection lawsuits, either for free or at a low cost. Legal aid organizations are <a href="https://www.context.news/ai/legal-aid-and-ai-help-poor-americans-close-justice-gap">already using</a> artificial intelligence tools to serve more members of the public, and streamline their caseloads.</p><p>Yet, the truth is that technology will not solve every problem. We need public interest lawyers, as well as pro bono efforts by lawyers at both small and large law firms.</p><p>However, one of the arguments advanced by Younger, is that there’s no evidence that non-lawyer involvement in law firms will meaningfully improve access to justice. Let’s assume, for the sake of argument, that Younger is correct.</p><p>Why should it matter? If non-lawyer ownership has other benefits, whether in economic terms, and in ensuring the effective representation of clients, isn’t that sufficient? Do we ask those firms where all partners are attorneys, to additionally justify how their practice benefits the underprivileged, outside of pro bono work?</p><p>Younger seems to think that such benefits to the less well off, is a requirement for non-attorney ownership in law firms to be justified. This framing is flawed.</p><p><strong>The Final Word</strong></p><p>Law, as a profession, isn’t one which changes quickly. In some respects, this is a good thing. Quite often, it’s best if the law is a haven of consistency and stability.</p><p>Yet, there are instances where the law must evolve, to better serve not only clients, but our society. I believe that non-attorney ownership in law firms will be a catalyst for growth, innovation, and better economic outcomes.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f65de77f6148" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>