<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Simon Van Teutem on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Simon Van Teutem on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@simonvanteutem?source=rss-e7bc9d1006bd------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 09:29:48 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@simonvanteutem/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Why I have lost faith in Ursula von der Leyen.]]></title>
            <link>https://simonvanteutem.medium.com/why-i-have-lost-faith-in-ursula-von-der-leyen-94947a669f1e?source=rss-e7bc9d1006bd------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/94947a669f1e</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[brussels]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[astrazeneca]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[vaccines]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[european-union]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[democratic-deficit]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Simon Van Teutem]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 12 Feb 2021 12:00:51 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-02-12T12:19:51.499Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>The European Commission President has let the EU down, but refuses to take responsibility.</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/612/0*-fWaPYELND36aSMU" /></figure><p>This week, Ursula von der Leyen finally addressed the fierce criticism that the European Commission has faced over the past two weeks. Her appearance was illustrative for a leader who fails to lead, who shuns democratic accountability, and who only wants to come out when the sun is shining.</p><p>Anyone with the aim to drive the European project in the right direction must realise that criticism is democracy’s fuel, reflection its gas pedal, and scrutiny its gears. Turning a blind eye to failure, on the other hand, is its greatest impediment, especially for the EU.</p><p><strong><em>A Promising Summer<br></em></strong>Last summer, the future was looking bright for the EU. Brussels took two leaps forward: not only had the member states reached an agreement on the European Recovery Fund, but the Union would also take charge of the vaccine rollout. Both results were unparalleled. The EU was going to issue common debt for the first time, and member states would join efforts to seize the most important remedy against the pandemic.</p><p>Yet, these far-reaching responsibilities went hand in hand with accountability, and that is precisely what the President of the European Commission is steering clear from now that her boat has capsized.</p><p><strong><em>A Month of Mistakes and Misfortune<br></em></strong>On the 22nd January, pharmaceutical company AstraZeneca announced it would deliver far less vaccines than initially promised. The supply to the United Kingdom, nonetheless, continued imperturbably, because our friends on the other side of the Channel had closed their deal months earlier than the EU did. As a result, the European Commission came under fire.</p><p>Yet, as things went south, the Commission President was nowhere to be found. When the first Europeans were vaccinated in December, Von der Leyen had still seized the opportunity to pat herself on the back for ‘Europe’s Moment’. Now that the tide had turned, however, she shunned scrutiny, and smoothly shifted responsibility to Stella Kyriakides, the European Commissioner for Health.</p><p><strong><em>A Preposterous Proposal and A Game of Hide-and-Seek<br></em></strong>Then, on Friday 29nd January, a policy proposal popped up: the EU was going to regulate the export of vaccines, to prevent ‘our’ shots from being shipped abroad. In addition, Ireland had to close its border with Northern Ireland to fill a potential loophole for the UK. The Irish government, however, had not been notified of this decision.</p><p>At breakneck speed, this creative solution turned into a political disaster. After a few ballistic calls from the other side of the Channel, President Von der Leyen made a U-turn and quickly withdrew its thoughtless provocation. Yet, the Commission’s recklessness on this highly sensitive subject had already harmed Irish and European interests, damaged our relations with key allies, and embarrassed the continent.</p><p>Who was responsible for this ruinous miscalculation?</p><p>On Monday 1st February, it turned out that President Von der Leyen had not sat still when she was shunning the camera; <em>she</em> had concocted this tactless response, top officials <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2021/02/01/world/europe/eu-vaccine-von-der-leyen.html">told</a> the New York Times. Moreover, the Commission President had, ‘per her habit’, only obtained information from a small group of confidants, excluding experts as well as some senior cabinet ministers from her deliberation.</p><p>In the same article, The New York Times called President Von der Leyen out for staying ‘away from the limelight’ and ‘letting subordinates take the blame’. When her chief spokesman, Eric Mamer, was confronted with the matter on the same day, a new victim was appointed: ‘What I can tell you is that there is one cabinet which was in the lead on this, that is Executive Vice President Valdis Dombrovskis because he is in charge of trade’.</p><p><strong><em>Facing Parliament and the King of Non-Apologies</em></strong><br>Only after her own party members (including Manfred Weber, the leader of the European People’s Party) had requested an apology, the Commission President faced the European Parliament Wednesday morning. Finally, she would take responsibility, face opposition, and get back to work with a clean slate.</p><p>Instead, her appearance was the straw that broke the camel’s back. Yes, she accepted a tiny bit of blame for the nickeling-and-diming of the Commission in the negotiations. But when it came to the diplomatic debacle for which she was personally responsible, she uttered no apology, and instead resorted to a phrase epitomic for her approach:</p><p>‘Mistakes were made and I deeply regret that. But in the end we got it right.’</p><p>Mistakes were made. It happened. Matters occurred. Affairs came about. Things took place. This phrase is the king of non-apologies. Did I harm anyone? No, harm <em>was done</em>. Did my dog urinate on your couch? Nah, a leak <em>was taken</em> on your couch. And I deeply regret that. But in the end, <em>we</em> got it right.</p><p><strong><em>Nothing New</em></strong><br>This empty gift, wrapped in apology-paper, is nothing new. In 1973, Nixon’s spokesman Ron Ziegler apologised to <em>The Washington Post’s </em>Bob Woodward and Carl Bernstein saying that ‘mistakes were made in terms of comments’. Fourteen years later, in his State of the Union address, President Reagan conceded that ‘mistakes were made’ as his administration had sold arms to Iran and lied about it. When President Clinton was asked about a fundraising scandal (not the other one) in 1997, he conceded that ‘mistakes were made here by people who did it either deliberately or inadvertently’.</p><p>This phrase is not an apology; it is what five-year olds say when they get caught stealing a candybar, or what seasoned politicians say when they seek to evade any direct admission of responsibility.</p><p><strong><em>And Then She Left</em></strong><br>Unfortunately, that is not the end of it. In the debate, Von der Leyen did not respond to <em>any</em> of the queries from Parliament, including an Irish MEP specifically asking ‘who made the decision, and why?’.</p><p>Instead, Von der Leyen left the debate soon after her statement.</p><p>As a result, Chris Macmanus, the first Irish MEP to speak in the debate, addressed an empty chair as ‘Madame President’. In his speech, he called the blunder ‘unacceptable’ and emphasised that ‘we must ensure that the fiasco isn’t repeated, and part of that is picking up the phone to Dublin and Belfast.’. But there was no Commission President to hear it.</p><p><strong><em>A Democratic Deficit</em></strong><br>Make no mistake: any national head of government in Von Der Leyen’s position would not have gotten away with this. They would have paid a high price. For these occasions, members of parliament take off their gloves, the national press puts you on the firing line, and broadcasters drag your name through the mud.</p><p>But the buzz disappointed; national media were occupied with regional matters. Brussels is not sexy enough. The Commission President, who, as a matter of fact, was never voted in as a Spitzenkandidat by the European public, knew this, which is why she thought she could get away with leaving the debate after a half-baked apology. Had she stayed, she would have heard MacManus address the ‘democratic deficit’ that she is rapidly deepening.</p><p>If this had happened in any national parliament, it would be front-page news. But it happened in Brussels, so, apart from a few political enthusiasts, no one noticed.</p><p><strong><em>A European Public Space</em></strong><br>That is why I am writing this piece. I deeply care about the EU, and I have realised that it will not evolve without scrutiny. If the democratic deficit is to be filled, we need a strong European public space. Our media should shift their attention away from the disproportionally covered Anglo-Saxon world, towards the continent with which our interests are intertwined. Anyone who cherishes the EU should not turn a blind eye to political representatives who refuse to take responsibility for their failures. Our leaders must be guiders, not duckers.</p><p>If you think that eurosceptic populists pose the biggest existential threat to the European project, think again. It is the EU’s pseudo-religious believers who pose the biggest danger to it. Those who believe that the EU will flourish when it is shielded from public debate, civil society, and critical scrutiny are its biggest threat.</p><p>If we truly value the EU, we <em>must</em> criticise its mistakes, dig deeper than the empty rhetoric presented to us, and hold our representatives accountable for the mistakes <em>they</em> made.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=94947a669f1e" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[After Disruption: Reflection and the Road Ahead.]]></title>
            <link>https://simonvanteutem.medium.com/after-disruption-reflection-and-the-road-ahead-47a39b00009?source=rss-e7bc9d1006bd------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/47a39b00009</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[arab-spring]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[fiscal-policy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[media-criticism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[2020]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[disruption]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Simon Van Teutem]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 11 Jan 2021 10:13:48 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-01-11T10:13:48.295Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/690/1*d1W6xWv1LIy5-NGhlc92KA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Illustration by Gary Waters</figcaption></figure><p>In 2020, the experience of political, economic and epistemic discontinuity that had been stirred up for years has reached a new climax. We feel more keenly than ever that the decline of the liberal world order, irreversible environmental damage, the distillation of a shared societal dialogue, and indeed COVID-19 are jolting a rethink of the certainties of the post-Cold War years. At the end of a troubled and turbulent twelvemonth, we reflect on <em>disruption</em>: what opportunities and pitfalls does it offer? How does progress occur? How do we deal with the dramatisation of disturbance, or conversely, with the backlash of broken promises?</p><p>Disruption is characterised by far-reaching disturbance or interruption of the status quo. It can occur and operate in separate domains, but when we speak of societal, public or financial upsets, it tends to rage through distinct interconnected dimensions. In this context, we will defend three core arguments. To begin with, disruption, as unsettling and disorienting as it can be, also offers a unique opportunity to imagine and implement a fresh set of ideas about society, or, more commonly, to throw away apples that are overripe or rotten. From this angle, we will see that disruption necessitates a <em>stress test</em> of the present order, swinging the door right open for a diagnosis of defective details or deeper chinks in the armour.</p><p>Yet, and secondly, the process of disruption is complex, elusive, and unpredictable. Even as it invites individuals and societies at large to contemplate alternatives to the <em>status quo</em>, it can be hard to steer clear of stumbling blocks and eventually stem the torrent. We shall see that democratic consensus and coherent actors are crucial in this process of consolidation. Thirdly, assessing the result is difficult in the eye of the storm. Change is opportunity, especially for media whose revenue models are fuelled by chaos or political actors always looking to see their prior world-views confirmed. Events can be bended in either direction towards elite interests, so we should be careful not to over or underestimate the desirability of the consequences.</p><p>As unsettling as we find disruption, it also has a positive effect: the unexpected pressure which crises exert on the <em>status quo</em> also serves as a stress test, allowing us to identify weak links which need repairing or replacing. Of course, it equally is crucial that these fresh ideas are well thought-through. As Boris Johnson, an expert on this very subject, once said, “There are no disasters, only opportunities. And indeed, opportunities for fresh disasters.”</p><p>What, then, has our present experience of disruption taught us about how to do things differently? The COVID-19 pandemic offers important examples. Governments in rich countries have been forced to spend enormous amounts on measures to support individuals and businesses, ranging from furlough schemes to tax breaks. According to IMF projections, government debt across advanced economies is set to increase by 20 percentage points in 2020. On the one hand, this surge in borrowing is raising alarm, especially among parties traditionally advocating fiscal prudence. On the other hand, economists point to record-low interest rates across the developed world, making debt unprecedentedly cheap. Indeed, hopes are being raised that, in rich countries beset by rising income inequality and governments hamstrung by fears of budget deficits, the pandemic might yet usher in a new social contract of a government-led, green, and equitable recovery made affordable by newly affordable debt and/or more progressive wealth and (corporate)-income taxes. To prevent this opportunity from turning into disaster, however, governments must avoid the trap of turning to austerity and ‘fiscal consolidation’ too soon. If they tread this line carefully, the damage wrought on the economy by coronavirus might lead to something altogether better.</p><p>In short, the process of turning new ideas into positive change is rarely certain and never neat. Even as ideas gain traction, important obstacles stand in the way of progress becoming entrenched. As we look ahead, this middle stage of the post-disruption trajectory is crucial.</p><p>The creation of the liberal world order offers important insights. After the Second World War, a sense that drastic change was necessary to prevent such a disaster from reoccurring was prevalent among elites and publics across the West. The foundation of the UN and related bodies, such as the WHO, as well as the Bretton Woods institutions and the European Coal and Steel Community, created the multilateral framework still governing the liberal world order today. The vision of a more peaceful, democratic, and prosperous world which this set of institutions sought to realise succeeded for several reasons. Firstly, there was a clear elite and popular consensus about the <em>need </em>for change, providing the project with legitimacy and a democratic mandate. Secondly, there were powerful and internally coherent actors able to articulate a consistent agenda who had the capacity to implement the desired changes. In the post-WWII context, the United States, then at the zenith of its relative power, was able to play that role. This combination of conditions turned a good idea into a consensus-driven and enduring new order.</p><p>Progress falters when one or more of these conditions is absent. Recent attempts at political transformation across the Middle East and the post-Soviet space have either fizzled out or turned into chaos. Even as the idea of revolution inspired millions, it failed to maintain its momentum as sectarian or ethnolinguistic divisions fractured a brittle consensus, or as opposition leaderships — or foreign powers — failed to set a clear agenda for the way forward. If history teaches us anything, it is that no universal recipe for progress exists. But a recurring theme is that ideas, however imaginative or pertinent, will not lead to progress if they lack democratic sanction and, more prosaically, the power to back them up. This observation is positive inasmuch as lasting, material progress can still happen anywhere; but it should also tell us that, counterintuitively, escaping a quagmire requires not a brash sprint into the unknown but consensus-building and agenda-setting.</p><p>Even as wanted or unwanted changes occur, awareness of the gaps and discrepancies between perception and reality is crucial. This misbelief works twofold: we overestimate the insights and progress that crises may or may not deliver, but we equally unduly dwell in doom rooted in exaggeration.</p><p>Let us proceed with a word of caution against excessive optimism. In our personal life and our societal dynamics, we tend to overestimate positive trends and extrapolate them into the far-away future. These are the animal spirits that gave rise to the dot-com bubble as well as naive expectations of democratisation and peace in the wake of the Arab Spring. Opportunistic elites can easily exploit this flaw. As Bas Heijne, a Dutch writer, noted in the surge of idealism following the pandemic, hardly anyone asks how they <em>themselves</em> can and should change; the prophets of progress instead focus on the direction in which the misty, blurry ball of <em>society </em>should roll as a result of recent revelations. It should not surprise anyone that usually their compass coincidentally and conventionally fits their <em>precedent</em> ideas or interests. The hodgepodge of excitement and hope of a new future, often accompanied by little critical scrutiny, inevitably results in disappointment, disenfranchisement and distrust when the world turns out to be far less linear and much less buoyant than the carpetbaggers’ greasy rhetoric had indicated. One merely needs to take a look at Tunisia’s Freedom House score to see that fluctuation is as common as continuity, and merely needs to stay one weekend in Sunderland, which overwhelmingly supported Brexit, to recognise that large groups of Britons yet have to taste the sweet fruits of globalisation.</p><p>Still, as we temper our initial optimism with these words of caution, we equally feel that anxieties are subject to careless extrapolation and are often overstated as a result. Over two centuries ago, Thomas Malthus famously warned for population growth to outpace agricultural production, causing large-scale famine and war. Instead, income per capita increased with a full order of magnitude and famine numbers in recent decades make up only a tiny snippet of that in preceding eras. Nowadays, fear or perception of disruption still leaves our worries vulnerable to exploitation. Disruption sells; the revenue models from media are powered by clicks and chaos. As a result, the lens through which we perceive wider societal developments is often manipulated by a gloomy filter. On any given day in the past century, it is possible to find a newspaper article telling us the end is near. Placing all of this ominosity into a broader perspective is a great challenge for the individual, but awareness of how the media win their bread is a good first step.</p><p>In the coming months, as the whirlwinds of 2020 disperse and we survey a moonscape littered with craters and with plenty of comets still cruising menacingly nearby, it will be tempting to seek security in a restoration of the <em>status quo ante</em>. That would be a mistake. Without being carried away by an abstract idealism or paralysing anxieties, we should continue to believe in real progress whose quality we measure not in terms of speed, or even sweep, but the soundness of the ideas that nourish it and the strength of the coalition that sanctions it. This is not a simple defense of moderation for its own sake; rather, we see an urgent need for change, and believe that this is the best way to overcome disruption and achieve it. The articles contained elsewhere in this edition exemplify a willingness to critically examine our present reality. That is a good start, and we are quietly confident that it will lead somewhere better.</p><p><em>Written by Maurits Westbroek and Simon van Teutem for Idee, the social-liberal journal from the Mr. Hans van Mierlo Stichting.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=47a39b00009" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Sterkere ruggengraat]]></title>
            <link>https://simonvanteutem.medium.com/sterkere-ruggengraat-91c673fb0522?source=rss-e7bc9d1006bd------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/91c673fb0522</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[tweede-kamer]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politiek]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[medium]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Simon Van Teutem]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 13 Jul 2020 06:45:22 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-07-13T06:56:51.955Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<blockquote><em>Het is niet raar om te denken dat we een afgebakende definitie van politiek nodig hebben om kritisch over politiek na te denken. Toch is het onzin. We moeten het streven naar een perfecte definitie van politiek loslaten om met een frisse blik te kunnen kijken. Dan zien we dat het ‘klikjeskapitalisme’ van de politiek en de media gevaren met zich meebrengt. Politici, journalisten en programmamakers kunnen en moeten zich daartegen wapenen.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>Door </em><strong><em>Simon van Teutem</em></strong></blockquote><h3>Sterkere ruggengraat</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/716/1*Hn3CtqxpvqJQe7TIfEzOMQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Bron: tweedekamer.nl</figcaption></figure><p><strong>Politiek is een ongrijpbaar begrip.</strong> Wie <em>House of Cards</em> heeft gezien, denkt bij het horen van het woord ‘politiek’ aan een individueel belangenconflict dat zich vermomt als een wedstrijd tussen principes. Wie onze minister-president het afgelopen decennium goed gevolgd heeft, denkt aan het in overeenstemming brengen van botsende belangen. Wie Carl Schmitt heeft gelezen, vindt de kern van de politiek in het onderscheid tussen vriend en vijand.</p><p>Zelfs de pioniers van het politiek denken, die met hun waarnemingen, stellingen en theorieën de basis legden voor het bestuur van vandaag, kwamen nooit tot een eenduidige definitie. Van Hobbes tot Habermas, Van Mill tot Miller, Van Nozick tot Nussbaum: er bestaat tot op de dag van vandaag geen perfect voorbeeld van hoe politiek eruit ziet, of nog belangrijker: hoe het eruit zou moeten zien.</p><p>Gelukkig is dat ook niet nodig. We behoeven namelijk geen toonbeeld van politiek om te reflecteren, kanttekeningen te plaatsen en positieve veranderingen teweeg te brengen. Op dezelfde manier als we de Mount Everest niet nodig hebben om te zien dat de Mont Blanc hoger is dan de Vaalserberg. Een vaag concept is nog steeds een concept, op dezelfde manier als een onduidelijke foto nog steeds een foto is.</p><p>Een kritische blik op bestuur, beleid, bewind, bemiddeling en botsende belangen levert meer op dan een zinloze zoektocht naar het archetype. De verschillen tussen plannen, politici en partijen verraden meestal zelf wel waar het goed gaat en waar het aan schort.</p><p><strong>Reflectie op de zichtbare contrasten</strong><br>Zo ook in de Nederlandse politiek van vandaag. Na de zoveelste liquidatie in een woonwijk ging Vincent Karremans, voorzitter van de VVD-fractie in Rotterdam, recent enorm tekeer over de gevolgen van recreatief drugsgebruik. Twee zaken vielen op. Ten eerste was hij zichtbaar emotioneel; zijn verhaal ontsluierde een onvervalst mengsel van woede, verdriet en frustratie. Nog opvallender was dat hij aanstipte wat veel mensen, inclusief zijn eigen achterban, liever niet willen horen: zolang het illegaal is, hebben gebruikers een onmiskenbaar aandeel in drugscriminaliteit, en dus ook in liquidaties.</p><p>Bij het bekijken van het filmpje lijkt het alsof Karremans uit z’n rol valt. Alsof hij, ondanks het gebrek aan een ideale definitie, geen politiek aan het bedrijven is. Alsof zijn optreden niet tot die categorie behoort. Dat is vreemd. Want waarom kijken we raar op als een politicus dingen zegt die zijn of haar achterban liever niet wil horen? Waarom geldt het tonen van emotie als afwijking van de norm? En wat zegt dat over de manier waarop ‘politiek’ bedreven wordt in Den Haag? Niet de vraag wat politiek definieert, of wat we precies van politici moeten verwachten, maar reflectie op de zichtbare contrasten tussen politici geeft zinnige aanwijzingen over wat er beter kan en moet. Die verschillen laten namelijk vaak zien wat politiek in elk geval <em>niet</em> zou moeten zijn.</p><p><strong>Politiek acteerwerk<br></strong>Zo legt het optreden van Karremans mijn inziens de meest zorgelijke trend in Den Haag bloot: de rol van de Nederlandse politicus wordt in toenemende gedefinieerd door persvoorlichterspraatjes bij talkshows, gespeelde verontwaardiging bij de interruptiemicrofoon en afgezaagde teksten op Facebook en Twitter, die niet alleen weerklank vinden bij het vaste groepje ja-knikkers, maar daar ook voor bedoeld zijn. Het is met grote regelmaat een toneelspel en Tweede Kamerleden noch bewindslieden verdienen een <em>Oscar</em>.</p><p>De reden voor dit acteerwerk schuilt in het feit dat partijen steeds beter <em>denken</em> te weten wat de achterban nou eigenlijk wil. Kliks en <em>likes</em> worden gemeten op Facebook, Twitter en zelfs Instagram. Kiezers worden opgesplitst in doelgroepen die men op de juiste momenten een bot toegooit. Standpunten zijn niet alleen afhankelijk van ideologische drijfveren, maar worden hevig onderworpen aan en afgebogen naar de onderbuik van de volgelingen. Dit leidt niet alleen tot toneelspel, maar logischerwijs ook tot het uitdragen van zo min mogelijk standpunten die in het verkeerde keelgat van de achterban kunnen schieten. Dat verklaart precies waarom Karremans voor het oog van de kijker uit zijn ‘rol’ als politicus viel. Partijen onderschatten echter structureel het gemak waarmee de kiezer deze marketingtrucs doorziet en de proefballonnen lek prikt. Precies dáárom is het optreden van Karremans een verademing.</p><p><strong>Medialisering<br></strong>De (sociale) medialisering van de politiek is niet alleen schadelijk voor de vorm, maar ook voor de inhoud van de politiek. Tweede Kamerlid Pieter Omtzigt — een uitzondering op de regel — vatte dat recent goed samen in een donderspeech: ‘Dit is een Tweede Kamer die twee derde van zijn tijd doorbrengt door, als je links bent, wat er op de voorpagina van <em>De Volkskrant </em>stond, of, als je rechts bent, wat er op de voorpagina van <em>De Telegraaf</em> stond.’ Hij eiste dat er meer tijd besteed zou worden aan wetgeving en minder aan spoeddebatten. Hij had groot gelijk.</p><p>Toch ligt niet alle schuld, en dus ook niet de gehele oplossing, bij politici zelf. In ‘het politieke’, het maatschappelijk debat en de informele democratie, is namelijk een soortgelijk mechanisme van kracht. Met name de media treffen blaam, want ook daar worden kijkers, luisteraars en lezers steeds nauwer gevolgd in plaats van geleid. Talkshows voeren kijkcijferoorlogen en op menig krantenredactie hangt een groot scherm waarop men <em>live</em> de meest ‘geklikte’ artikelen ziet staan. Het gevolg daarvan is een <em>bias</em> naar conflict, sensatie en polarisatie, en dat is nou precies wat politici perverse prikkels tot scoringsdrift geeft. Gedegen onderzoek naar een saai doch belangrijk beleidsstuk genereert minder aandacht dan een proefballon over zwaardere straffen in probleemwijken.</p><p>Politici die zich hier bewust van zijn, kunnen media als een instrument leren bespelen en daarmee zoveel mogelijk zuurstof van het publieke debat naar zich toetrekken. Dat kan met concreet beleid, zoals Trumps <em>great wall</em>, maar ook met onschuldige trucjes die evenzeer afleiden van de inhoud. Als Machiavelli vandaag de dag geleefd had, en met een kleine partij in de Tweede Kamer zat, zou hij net als Thierry Baudet een pikante foto op Instagram gooien. Aandacht is macht. Media laten zich op voorspellende wijze <em>gebruiken</em> door de politiek, terwijl hun rol juist is om deze te <em>controleren</em>. Een cruciaal element van ‘het politieke’ faalt.</p><p><strong>Minder volgen, meer leiden<br></strong>Hoe moet het dan wel? Een sterkere ruggengraat is een gezond startpunt, zowel bij politici als bij media. Om daadwerkelijk iets te betekenen voor mensen die je vertegenwoordigt of van informatie voorziet, moet je de verantwoordelijkheden van je vak serieus nemen en niet als een onzekere puber je eigenwaarde ontlenen aan wat er op de <em>socials</em> gezegd wordt. Er moet meer energie naar de knikkers en minder naar het spel. Omtzigts speurwerk bij de toeslagenaffaire is daar een uitstekend voorbeeld van. Politici moeten zich niet dagelijks bezigen met krantenkoppen, kliks en <em>likes</em>, maar moeten zich focussen op beleid en de achterban daarbij op sleeptouw durven nemen. Zij moeten minder volgen en meer leiden.</p><p>De crux is dat het geen perfecte definitie en ook geen toonbeeld van ‘politiek’ of ‘het politieke’ vergt om stappen vooruit te zetten. De nodeloze zoektocht daarnaar is dan ook zonde van onze energie, die we beter kunnen besteden aan een vergelijkende aanpak. Zo’n benadering laat zien dat het voor politici en media in onze tijd verleidelijk is om in de praatjes van communicatiebureaus te trappen, om kwaliteit af te meten aan kliks, en om bereik te laten verworden tot <em>doel</em> in plaats van <em>middel</em>. De inherente nepheid daarvan in de politiek en de speelbalverwording van media komt de democratie noch het vertrouwen van de burger ten goede. Er is in beide domeinen dan ook vooral behoefte aan een sterkere ruggengraat.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=91c673fb0522" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>