<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Sisonke Msimang on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Sisonke Msimang on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@sisonkemsimang?source=rss-f63865ca787c------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Fri, 20 Nov 2026 22:45:32 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@sisonkemsimang/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Statues, Flags, Bridges and the mainstream press: reflections on Rhodes, Lee & Trump]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@sisonkemsimang/statues-flags-bridges-and-the-mainstream-press-reflections-on-rhodes-lee-trump-4a62d2aa1fca?source=rss-f63865ca787c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4a62d2aa1fca</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[rhodesmustfall]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[racism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[medium]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Sisonke Msimang]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 29 Nov 2017 04:34:19 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-11-29T04:34:19.569Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*fO645AzumE0ISfci1Lkxsw.jpeg" /><figcaption>NewsXChange 2017; Amsterdam. Sisonke Msimang, intrviewed by Guido Baumhauer of <br>Deutsche Welle</figcaption></figure><p><em>* This is the text of a talk I gave in Amsterdam at the </em><a href="http://www.newsxchange.org/home.html"><em>NewsXchange</em></a><em> conference (November 14–16). NewsXchange is a two-day, annual conference bringing together around 600 media executives and journalists from the broadcast world.</em></p><p>So I’m a writer. I have opinions but I’m not a journalist. I have great respect for journalists — for people who invest the time and energy in getting to know and understand the events that shape our world. I got my start writing a column for a spunky start up online paper in South Africa called the Daily Maverick — an outlet that embodies the best of what journalism is. Feisty, independent and full of analysis. These days I work at a place called the Centre for Stories and part of what we try to do there is to really think and reflect on what is going on underneath the big stories of the day- so again a strong focus on analysis.</p><p>As someone involved in the story business I am well aware that ‘storytelling’ has become a bit of a buzzword. But I think it’s important to think about stories in a grand sense — to think about meta-stories that help us puzzle and think things through.</p><p>So that’s what I’m going to try to do today. I’m going to try to help us to think about the media and how its responded in the last year to the challenge thrown up by the on-going culture wars. Because that is exactly what lies underneath the Trump presidency, underneath Brexit and Black Lives Matters and the strong anti-Islam sentiment we see across Europe and America today.</p><p>The culture wars are a contest about who gets to interpret the world and according to what values. We find ourselves in the midst of a war of ideas. The role of the media is not simply to report on the chaos but to help make sense of it — to connect the dots. At their best story-tellers and story shapers (which is what all of you are) provide not just human interest stories or what might be referred to as micro-stories. At their best, media institutions provide deeper analysis and they help us to see the grand themes that are shaping our lives.</p><p>So, I’ve called this talk Statues, flags and bridges because all of these are of course symbols — stand ins for the things our societies value — for history and memory and what and who matters most. And at the heart of these tussles I think is a bigger question about identity and what many of you have come to describe as “identity politics.” Indeed, the very idea that when black people talk about race they are referring to ‘identity politics.’</p><p>John Cecil Rhodes has been a particular focus in both South Africa and in the UK when it comes to statues. Rhodes played an instrumental role in the colonization of Southern Africa. The fact that both Zambia and Zimbabwe once carried his name — Northern and Southern Rhodesia respectively — speaks volumes.</p><p>In the United States of America, violent protests by white supremacists in Charlottesville, Virginia over this past summer and in other parts of the country over the last few years have involved the confederate flag and statues of General Robert Lee — a Southerner who fought to preserve slavery in that country’s civil war. Lee is America’s version of Rhodes: he is as reviled and revered as Rhodes.</p><p>In this spirit then — of old dead white men with deeply problematic legacies — I want to start by telling the story of a statue and a plucky newspaper called the Daily Vox in my country South Africa.</p><p>On a sunny day in April 2015, a young man named Chumani Maxwele (at the end of this talk there will be a quiz and you will all have to say Maxwele) threw human excrement at a statue of John Cecil Rhodes that has stood on the campus of the University of Cape Town for decades.</p><p>Maxwele had carried the poo from a township in Cape Town where toilets are still communal, and often overflowing with excrement. His act was powerful because it connected many painful facts about the failure of post-apartheid South Africa to address even the most basic aspects of human dignity for the majority of its black citizens.</p><p>Maxwele’s shit hit the fan, and in so doing, it sparked a movement that had been on a slow boil for some time. Within weeks the student protests had spread across the country. The protests were largely about racism on campus — which was why Rhodes’ statue was such a useful target. Although they werent only about that. They were about the fact that many black students go to bed hungry. Or that there are only a handful of black professors on the faculties of the country’s universities.</p><p>The protests culminated in the largest march in the history of our young democracy. In October 2015 200 000 students took to the streets. A government commission is now recommending free higher education on the basis of their demands.</p><p>The Daily Vox was initially the only news organisation that bothered to cover the protests with any seriousness. Established only a year before the protests began, with a budget of $1500, the online news outlet was focused on youth. Its original mission had been to cover the 2014 elections with a focus on young voters. The project was such a success that the founders — two young journalists — Khadija Patel and Azad Essa — decided to keep it open.</p><p>The Daily Vox knew the ins and outs of campus politics and had full access to student leaders which was not as easy a task given the high levels of mistrust students had for mainstream media.</p><p>As Khadija has said, the Daily Vox turned usual reporting on its head. She says, “The approach to news in South Africa is broken. If you have big story like the student protests, often what the bigger news organisations are looking for is the voice of authority.”</p><p>So instead of focusing on press releases from the offices of Vice Chancellors who were under fire, they interviewed the students — not just the leaders but also the seemingly apolitical ones. The ones who were just tired and hungry and wanted to learn.</p><p>Soon, largely on the basis of the Daily Vox reporting and its influence on social media — the mainstream press caught up and started dedicating resources to cover the students.</p><p>Just as the Black Lives Matter activism forced police brutality onto the front pages, The Daily Vox made the protests a story. They helped to shape the issue in a way that simply would not have been possible if it had been left to the big news organisations alone.</p><p>One of the reasons the Daily Vox has been such a success is the fact that it is a niche publication. In today’s world being niche means understanding the specifics of who your people are — knowing your tribe.</p><p>We live in a era in which religious, ethnic and racial minority groups are articulating claims for citizenship in the Global North: in countries like Australia (where I live), here in Holland and across Europe and North America. This is an era in which women are in the throes of yet another push for justice and dignity — a push it seems that is never-ending.</p><p>These claims for dignity by women, by people of colour, are often being met with unbridled resistance by people who claim to speak on behalf of ethnic, racial and religious <strong><em>majority </em></strong>groups.</p><p>It is against this backdrop of claims of full humanity on the one hand, and resistance and a renewed agenda of conservatism and racism on the other that I want to talk about the role of media organisations such as the ones gathered in this room today.</p><p>Media institutions can choose to be statues — incapable of moving forward, frozen in time. They can be flags — blowing in the wind, pretty to look at and symbolic of the audiences they think they represent. Or — and I will make a strong push for this — they can become bridges.</p><p>The world is a jumble, and institutions that are able to make sense of this jumble have a special role in enabling democracies to function. Across the world the organisations you work for are not simply companies responsible to their directors — they are critical interlocutors. Your institutions — when they are at their best — represent a crucial public good.</p><p>At their best, media organisations help people to engage; they tear down walls and make space — they serve as bridges between people and views that might otherwise never encounter one another.</p><p>Unhealthy and undemocratic societies take root when people embrace polarization; when people don’t know what their fellow citizens think and why, and when they don’t have a chance to encounter one another.</p><p>***</p><p>So lets talk about the landscape for media, and how it is shifting and how it might work better if it were able to bring ideas together rather than serve as a platform for people to tear one another apart.</p><p>It goes without saying that in the last few decades the way the media operates has changed. There is a sense amongst many media practitioners that the reporting process is more complex today than it has ever been.</p><p>This is in part because by the time mainstream reporting begins, an event that already has garnered some public response and speculation. If it is an unfolding mass shooting for example, there is already an analysis of what the media will say and how it will say it before crews arrive. Why did you not call him a terrorist? (it is invariably a man) Why did you call him a terrorist? This never happened. This is a conspiracy.</p><p><strong>Trust</strong></p><p>This clearly makes your jobs much harder than they used to be. The questions and the cynicism are partly a function of technology but also they speak to the fact that trust for the media is at an all-time low amongst the general public.</p><p>No one has capitalized on the mistrust of the media, of ‘experts’ and intellectuals more than Donald Trump. This is what populists do. Those of us who have lived in more fragile democracies than those in the West are familiar with this sort of rhetoric. Trump’s deliberate and dangerous attacks on the media through his railing against #FakeNews are — frankly — — ingenious even as many of us recognize them as completely disingenuous and self-serving.</p><p>Trump may be a liar but he has recognized a fundamental truth about how the media is perceived. He’s a stuntman. But stunts only work if people want to believe in them and when there is something real within them. I’m going to say something I never thought I would say. Trump is kind of right about Fake News, especially if you don’t take him too literally.</p><p>When Trump screams #FakeNews, he is able to do so because many people recognize that the facts media houses report on may be <em>true</em> but the narrative threads — the stories media organisations tell people to explain the world — aren’t always representative of their truths. People often don’t recognize themselves in the world media institutions describe.</p><p>Trump may not care about biased reporting but he is onto something real when he taps into the deep sense of distrust many people feel about media descriptions of their lives and their circumstances.</p><p>In my own country, the media certainly represents the elite viewpoints of people who are university educated, urban and still disproportionately white.</p><p>So yes — some of the news they report — to people in rural areas — may as well be Fake. At the very least it is often irrelevant. That distinction between a media that is disseminating lies and a media that is speaking to only one segment of the population — this is the line Trump is walking. His ability to name that tendency — even if he is stirring and exaggerating — is one of the reasons he is still popular. This has to be addressed if the media is going to regain trust.</p><p>So what should the media do? How do media organisations strive for relevance and accuracy in a crowded arena where people are less interested in facts and more interested in affirming their identities?</p><p>Well this is where bridges come in.</p><p><strong>Fighting Cynicism</strong></p><p>Fighting the cynicism and providing good news content may seem like a tall order in this environment. Yet for practitioners like you, there isn’t much of a choice. While I believe you matter more than you ever have, you also at the same moment, have never been less relevant.</p><p>This seeming contradiction ought to give you pause.</p><p>As the media learned last year, if you believe in yourselves and your predictions and your expertise without having real connections to real life people not simply to abstract polls and numbers, you will become less and less important; less and less relevant.</p><p>Especially for outlets with a mass audiences, getting the balance right is hard. Sadly, I think in the last year we have seen in both Europe and America the main media takeaways from Brexit and Trump seem to have been that the white working class has been ignored and neglected and that a largely liberal media has been too left-leaning, too soft on migrants and minorities.</p><p>Suddenly we have an explosion of stories about white people’s pain. For example there have been a slew of articules about life in small town USA, and about the heroin and epidemics in the mid Western US. Some of this reporting has been phenomenal. More empathy for everyone in reporting is a good thing.</p><p>But as many others have pointed out, the complex forces of globalization that have left poor whites in America behind and have hollowed out opportunities for working class white Europeans are the very same forces that made migrants leave their countries searching for better lives and that have made minority communities even more vulnerable in Western countries the last decade. Life isn’t getting better for a whole lot of people in diverse countries — except the rich.</p><p>Rather than respond to the present moment of finger pointing and identity politicking by producing deeper reporting on structural issues — covering long-term economic trends and focusing on the root causes of discontent — many media outlets have bought into a milder version of the narrative of fear that drove Britain out of Europe and has Trump talking about Muslim bans and putting up walls. Others simply continue to report on politicians — on personalities rather than on policies.</p><p>Better coverage should have come out of the serious mistakes media organisations made last year. In some cases this has happened. But in other ways I see far too many reactive stories — coverage that tries to tell the stories of those <em>who say </em>they are left behind, rather than of factors that have left all but a few on the other side of a growing inequality gap.</p><p><strong>What can be done?</strong></p><p>The solution of course is to tell more truthful stories. The only way to do this is to listen to the voices on the absolute edges — not simply to the voices of the disgruntled majority. Not the most hateful voices but the voices of resistance and opposition; the most hopeful voices.</p><p>We are facing some very scary problems: climate change and environmental degradation, racism and sexism and religious intolerance driven by widening inequality. The media’s job is to help connect the dots — to tell grand and important stories not just the small stories that make people weep or smile. These matter but I am talking about meta stories. Grand arcs.</p><p>We need media that tell true stories that explain the world in ways that aren’t elitist or exclusionary. We need media that are able to find the source of the pain, not simply report on the casualties and count the dead. We also need media organisations that know how to use data and evidence and serious investigative work to drive these big picture stories.</p><p>Those of you who see your institutions as bridges — as platforms people are able to access, to use, to tread on to get from one place to another — you are the ones who will survive. More than that, if you get it right you are the ones people of all identities — will come to see as indispensable not because they agree with you, but because they respect you.</p><p>Good luck — your mission matters.</p><p><strong><em>Sisonke Msimang is a writer and speaker from South Africa. Her work focuses on money, power and sex.</em></strong></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4a62d2aa1fca" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>